Letter 69
The letter of the holy Mar Severus, patriarch of Antioch, to Anastasia the deaconess.
THE LETTER OF THE HOLY MAR SEVERUS, PATRIARCH OF ANTIOCH, TO ANASTASIA THE DEACONESS.
While walking in the way of righteousness—I mean the path of asceticism and the monastic life—you meditate on the sublime thoughts of the God-inspired Scriptures and gather benefit from them. You shun ignorance and the poverty that comes from it as something foreign to the commandments of religion, and for this attitude you deserve praise. The book of Proverbs also says somewhere, "The lips of the righteous know high things, but fools die in scarcity." For this reason it has decreed for you a blessing from above and a life that is without sorrow and blessed, for it adds, "The blessing of the Lord upon the head of the righteous, this makes rich, and sorrow in heart shall not be added to it." It is clear that you also bring me freedom from sorrow through your God-loving questions, since you cause me to enjoy the pleasure of spiritual thoughts. Therefore I will readily try to give an explanation of the rest of your questions as well.
You are pleased to ask me what our Lord Jesus Christ wishes to make known to us by that parable which Luke the Evangelist recorded as follows: "Who among you shall have a friend, and he shall go to him at midnight and say to him, 'My friend, lend me three loaves, for a friend has come to me from a journey, and I have nothing to set before him,' and he from within shall answer and say, 'Do not trouble me. The door is already shut, and my children with me are in bed. I cannot get up and give to you'? I say to you that, if he will not get up and give to him because he is his friend, because of his persistence he will get up and give him as much as he needs." To try to find the reason for this parable from outside is foolish and senseless, since our Savior himself plainly added by his own words and declared that he brought this forward to convince us that we ought to pray and make requests without ceasing and at all times, readily and without ever growing slack or weak from the constant habit. For he added, "I also say to you, Ask, and it shall be given to you. Seek, and you shall find. Knock, and it shall be opened to you. For everyone who asks receives, and he who seeks finds, and to him who knocks it shall be opened." Earlier he delivered to the disciples the form of that divine prayer which begins, "Our Father which art in heaven," and so he added to it the parable given above, so that the purpose is clear from all sides.
But since you have thought to yourself that there is some spiritual, sublime, lofty allegory contained in the words of the parable, and ask what those three loaves are, we ourselves also find it quite impossible not to be uplifted with your instruction-loving and inquiring mind, and to state the partial result which we have reached. We must certainly not force the parables into an allegory in every point. These three loaves I consider to be faith in the Father and in the Son and the Holy Spirit, to which it is reasonable to suppose that our Lord, the "one of the Trinity," is urging all people through these words, because indeed, as the apostle said, he "wishes all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth." Since some have wasted all their life in negligence and taken no account of the faith, and at last toward the end of life come to a perception of their sins and rush to the faith, the merciful one says this: "Even people of this kind, who come and knock at my door at an untimely hour of night, I will hear, not for the sake of justice, but because of their persistence, and I will hand to them the loaves of faith, which is the confession of the Holy Trinity."
The friend, the master of the house, is therefore the God and Savior Jesus, who loves every person, even those who have not yet believed in him, and thirsts for their salvation. But he who asks for the three loaves in the middle of the night is he who comes to the faith late. But the friend who came from a journey and was received by him we should rightly understand as the angel or angels who come at the end of life to take us and conduct us on the last journey. They themselves also love us and make our salvation a subject of rejoicing, according to the testimony of our Lord which says, "Joy arises before the angels of God over a sinner who repents." But the children who are resting in the bed are those who have been brought up as children and have believed the gospel with a simple heart and have been judged worthy to rest with our Lord. The lying on the bed is also a sign of rest, as our Lord himself again says in the Gospel of Matthew: "Many shall come from the east and from the west and shall recline with Abraham and Isaac and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven."
While walking in the way of righteousness (I mean that of asceticism), and the monastic life, you meditate on the sublime thoughts of the God-inspired Scriptures, and gather benefit from them, and shun lack of knowledge and the poverty arising therefrom as something alien to the commandments of religion, and for this disposition therefore you are an object of praise. For the book of Proverbs also somewhere said, «The lips of the righteous know high things, but fools die in scarcity». For this reason it has decreed for you a blessing from above, and a life that is without sorrow and blessed: for it adds, 'The blessing of the Lord upon the head of the righteous, this maketh rich, and sorrow in heart shall not be added unto it». It is therefore known beforehand that to me too you bring freedom from sorrow through your God-loving questions, inasmuch as you cause me to enjoy the pleasure of spiritual thoughts. Accordingly I will readily try to give an elucidation of the rest of your questions also. You are pleased to ask me what our Lord Jesus Christ wishes to make known to us by that parable which Luke the Evangelist recorded as follows: «Who among you shall have a friend, and he shall go unto him at midnight and say to him, 'My friend, lend me three loaves, for a friend hath come to me from a journey, and I have not wherewith to set before him', and he from within shall answer and say, 'Trouble me not. Lo! the door is shut, and my children with myself are in bed. I cannot rise and give to thee'? I say unto you that, if he will not rise and give to him because he is his friend, because of his importunity he will rise and give him as much as he needeth». For, us to find the reason of this parable from outside is foolish and senseless, since our Saviour himself plainly added by his own words and declared that he brought this forward to convince us that we ought to pray and make requests without ceasing and at all times, readily and without ever growing slack or weak from the constant habit: for he added, «I also say unto you, Ask, and it shall be given unto you. Seek, and ye shall find, knock, and it shall be opened unto you. For everyone that asketh receiveth; and he that seeketh findeth; and to him that knocketh it shall be opened unto him». In what precedes he delivered to the disciples the form of that divine prayer which begins, «Our Father which art in heaven»; and so he added to it the parable given above, so that on all sides the object'is clear. But, since you have thought to yourself that there is some spiritual, sublime, lofty allegory contained in the words of the parable, and ask what those three loaves are, we ourselves also find it quite impossible not to be uplifted with your instruction-loving and inquiring mind, and to state the partial result which we have reached; for assuredly we must not force the parables into an allegory in every point. These three loaves I consider to be faith in the Father and in the Son and the Holy Spirit; to which it is reasonable to suppose that our Lord, the ' one of the Trinity ' is urging all men through these words; because indeed, as the apostle said, he ' wisheth all men to be saved, and to come to the knowledge of the truth'. Since therefore some have wasted all their life in negligence, and taken no account of the faith, and at last towards the end of life come to a perception of their sins, and rush to the faith, the merciful one says this: «Even men of this kind, who come and knock at my door at an untimely hour of night, I will hear, not for the sake of justice, but because of their importunity, and I will hand to them the loaves of faith, which is the confession of the Holy Trinity». The friend therefore, the master of the house, is the God and Saviour Jesus, who loves every man, even those who have not yet believed on him, and thirsts for their salvation. But he who asks for the three loaves in the middle of the night is he who comes to the faith late. But the friend who came from a journey and was received by him we should afterwards rightly understand as the angel or angels who come at the end of life to take us and conduct us on the last journey; for they themselves also love us, and make our salvation a subject of rejoicing, according to the testimony of our Lord which says, «Joy ariseth before the angels of God over a sinner who repenteth». But the children who are resting in the bed are those who have been brought up as children, and have believed the gospel with a simple heart, and have been judged worthy to rest with our Lord. For the lying on the bed also is a sign of rest, as our Lord himself again says in the Gospel of Matthew: «Many shall come from the east and from the west, and shall recline with Abraham and Isaac and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven».
The words spoken by our Savior to the Jews—"In order that upon you may come all the blood of righteous men that has been shed upon the earth, from the blood of Abel the righteous to the blood of Zacharias whom you slew between the temple and the altar"—have been understood in various ways by interpreters, because the God-inspired Scripture says nothing plainly about this matter. But since our Savior's purpose requires that he should unite and include in this saying all the blood of righteous men that was unjustly shed from Abel down to the day when he himself said these things to the Jews, and lay responsibility for this upon them and their ancestors, it seems right and reasonable to me to understand that he referred to Zacharias the priest, who fathered for us the holy John the Forerunner and Baptist. A tradition not contained in Scripture relates that the Jews killed him between the temple and the altar because he plainly prophesied—or rather showed—that the God-bearer was a virgin, and that the one born of her was the great God and Savior Jesus Christ, like some King and chief and Lord over their people. He did not remove the holy Virgin herself after her incomprehensible conception by the Holy Spirit from the virgins' place in the temple, between the temple and the altar, as if she were married, but knew her to be still a virgin and allowed her to stand in the same customary place as usual. For this reason, they say, those who heard of it fell into a rage and took up weapons against him, fearing the king who was expected from his prophecy, who was to rule over them and lay the yoke of bondage upon them. These things Gregory the wise in divine matters, the brother of Basil the great and bishop of Nyssa, states in his sermon on the Nativity of our Savior as follows: "But if we are not straying too far from the subject, it would perhaps not be inappropriate to bring in Zacharias also, who was slain between the temple and the altar, to testify to the undefiled mother. This Zacharias was a priest, but not only a priest—he also possessed the gift of prophecy, and the power of prophecy is proclaimed in the book of the gospel as inevitable, in that the divine grace makes a way for people beforehand so they may not think the birth from a virgin incredible. Training the assent of those who did not believe beforehand by small miracles, a child is born to a woman who is barren and past childbearing age. This is the beginning of the miracle that is performed in the Virgin. For just as Elizabeth does not become a mother by the power of nature, since she had grown old in the world without bearing children, but the boy's birth is attributed to the divine will, so also the unbelievable nature of the virgin birth gains credibility by reference to the deity. Since therefore the son born of the barren woman—who at the voice of her who had conceived the Lord, before he came forth to the light, leaped in his mother's womb—preceded the son born of the virgin, immediately when the forerunner of the Word came forth to birth, the silence of Zacharias was broken by the prophetic indwelling, and everything that Zacharias uttered was a prophecy of the future. This man therefore, who was being led by the spirit of prophecy to knowledge of hidden things, having understood the mystery of virginity in the undefiled birth, did not exclude the unmarried mother in the temple from the place which according to the law was assigned to the virgins. He was teaching the Jews that the Maker of all that exists and King of all creation has human nature under his rule along with all things, and by his own will leads it to whatever pleases him, and is not himself controlled by this nature, so that it is in his power to make a new form of birth which will not cause her who has become a mother to cease being a virgin. Therefore he did not exclude her in the temple from the ranks of the virgins; and this place was a space between the temple and the altar. Since therefore they heard that the King of creation was coming forth by dispensation to human birth, in fear of being under a king's rule they killed the man who testified these things concerning the birth, sacrificing the priest at the very altar." But we cannot reasonably understand the passage quoted to refer to Zacharias who was one of the twelve prophets, since it is not related that he was killed, but he departed from life by the ordinary end of human life. For this reason also, in the times of the pious king Theodosius the grandson of the elder Theodosius, his holy body was found by revelation in the territory of Eleutheropolis, when it had not been corrupted at all but was found as if it had been buried yesterday, at a place where an oratory can now be seen, and a temple which was consecrated to God in his name; and it is known and honored by all who pass by that way. This is related by a certain Sozomen who wrote ecclesiastical histories. Some have supposed that in the above-quoted passage our Savior referred to Zacharias the son of Jehoiada who was put to death by Joash, king of the Jews. But this explanation is futile and is refuted by the facts themselves. For it is not the case that the foul murder of prophets and priests—the murder which it is the intention of the evangelic saying of our Savior to set forth—was perpetrated down to his time and then ended. For after Joash, other kings of the Jews also reigned who turned aside to idolatry and, as is natural, were ill-disposed toward those who pleased God; among whom Manasseh is said to have put Isaiah the great among prophets to death with a saw. But besides these things we should also know this: the man who was put to death by Joash was called Azarias and not Zacharias, though in certain copies some men have changed the name, and by a slight change have written 'Azarias' as 'Zacharias'. Accordingly, for all these reasons it seems to be a just conclusion that we must consequently understand our Savior's saying to refer to the father of John the Baptist, as the holy Gregory said.
The words spoken by our Saviour to the Jews, «In order that upon you may come all the blood, of righteous men that has been shed upon the earth, from the blood of Abel the righteous to the blood of Zacharias whom ye slew between the temple and the altar», have been variously understood by those who have interpreted, because concerning this matter nothing is plainly stated by the God-inspired Scripture. But, since our Saviour's purpose requires that he should unite and comprise in the saying all the blood of righteous men that was unjustly shed, from Abel down to the day on which he himself said these things to the Jews, and lay the responsibility for this upon them and upon their ancestors, it is a right and reasonable thing, as it seems to me, to understand that he referred to Zacharias the priest, who begot for us the holy John the Forerunner and Baptist, whom a tradition not contained in Scripture relates that the Jews slew between the temple and the altar, because he plainly prophesied or rather showed the God-bearer to be a virgin, and him that is born of her, the great God and Saviour Jesus Christ, like some King and chief and Lord over their people, and did not remove the holy Virgin herself after the incomprehensible conception by the Holy Spirit from the virgins' place in the temple, between the temple and the altar, as one that was married, but knew her to be still a virgin, and allowed her to stand in the same accustomed place as usual. For this reason (they say) those who heard of it fell into a rage and took weapons in their hands against him, fearing the king who was expected from his prophecy, who was to exercise sway over them and lay the yoke of bondage upon them. And these things Gregory the wise in divine things, the brother of Basil the great, and bishop of Nyssa, in the sermon on the Nativity of our Saviour, states thus: «But, if we are not straying a long way from the subject, it would perhaps not be inopportune to adduce Zacharias also who was slain between the temple and the altar to testify to the undefiled mother. This Zacharias was a priest, but not a priest only, but possessing also the gift of prophecy, and the power of prophecy is proclaimed in the book of the gospel as inevitable, in that the divine grace makes a way for men beforehand, that they may not think the birth from a virgin incredible, and, training the assent of those who did not believe beforehand by small miracles, a child is born to her that is barren and past age. This is the beginning of the miracle that is performed in the Virgin. For, as Elizabeth does not become a mother by the power of nature, inasmuch as she had grown old in the world without bearing, but the boy's birth is referred to the divine will, so also the incredibility of the virgin birth-throes obtains belief by reference to the deity. Since therefore the son born of the barren woman, who at the voice of her that had conceived the Lord, before he came forth to the light, leaped in his mother's womb, preceded the son born of the virgin, immediately on the forerunner of the Word coming forth to birth, then the silence of Zacharias is dissolved, by the prophetic indwelling, and all things that Zacharias utters were a prophecy of the future. This man therefore who was being led by the spirit of prophecy to the knowledge of hidden things, having understood the mystery of virginity in the undefiled birth, did not exclude the unmarried mother in the temple from the place which according to the law was assigned to the virgins, teaching the Jews that the Maker of the things that are and Ring of all creation has human nature under his rule with all things, and by his own will leads it to that which pleases him, and is not himself controlled by this nature, so that it is in his power to make a new form of birth which will not cause her who has become a mother to cease from being a virgin. Therefore he did not exclude her in the temple from the ranks of the virgins; and this place was a space between the temple and the altar. Since therefore they heard that the King of creation was coming forth by dispensation to human birth, in fear of being under a king's rule they slew the man who testified these things concerning the birth, sacrificing the priest at the very altar». But of the Zacharias who was one of the twelve prophets we cannot reasonably understand the passage quoted, since it is not related that he was killed, but he departed from life by the ordinary end of human life. Wherefore also in the times of the pious king Theodosius the grandson of the elder Theodosius his holy body was found by revelation in the territory of Eleutheropolis, when it had not been in the least corrupted but was found as if it had been buried yesterday, at a place at which an oratory is now to be seen, and a temple which was consecrated to God in his name; and it is known and honoured by all who pass by that way. This is related by a certain Sozomen who wrote ecclesiastical histories. Some have supposed that in the above-quoted passage our Saviour referred to Zacharias the son of Jehoiada who was put to death by Joash, king of the Jews. But this explanation is futile, and is refuted by the facts themselves. For it is not the case that the foul murder of prophets and priests, the murder which it is the intention of the evangelic saying of our Saviour to set forth, was perpetrated down to his time and then ended: for after Joash other kings of the Jews also reigned who turned aside to idolatry, and, as is natural, were ill-disposed towards those who pleased God; among whom Manasseh is said to have put Isaiah the great among prophets to death with a saw. But besides these things we should know this also, that the man who was put do death by Joash was called Azarias and not Zacharias, though in certain copies some men have changed the name, and by a slight change have written 'Azarias' as 'Zacharias'. Accordingly for all these reasons it seems to be a just conclusion that we must consequently understand our Saviour's saying of the father of John the Baptist, as the holy Gregory said.
Here is the explanation of the passage written by wise Paul in the first letter to the Corinthians: "He who speaks in tongues edifies himself, but he who prophesies edifies the church." In the time when the apostles were spreading the saving preaching of the gospel throughout the world, many believers performed signs and wonders in order to bring unbelievers to accept the truth. This is why miracles are numerous among unbelievers and not among those who have already believed, according to Paul's own words. For this very reason, the gifts of the Spirit were given more generously and more openly to those who were being brought to the faith. Those who were baptized often spoke in tongues immediately. Some were considered worthy to receive prophetic inspiration, while others even received both gifts, as is written in the book of Acts about some men who were baptized by Paul at Ephesus: "But when they had heard it, they were baptized in the name of the Lord Jesus. And when Paul had laid his hand upon them, the Holy Spirit came upon them, and they spoke with tongues and prophesied." This grace also flourished among the Corinthians at that time. Some spoke in tongues, while others were considered worthy to prophesy. The form of prophecy was such that it made things known not only by foretelling the future but also by mixing in words of instruction that corrected morals, just as the God-clothed teachers such as Athanasius the Great and Basil, and such as Gregory and John, and all who were like them, gained renown at various times in the churches. Since certain men at Corinth were puffed up and thought much of themselves because they spoke in tongues, while others prophesied and taught useful and beneficial things, Paul, wishing to humble their pride, says this: "He who speaks in the tongues of the nations edifies himself—that is, he establishes his own reputation and is merely admired, but does not benefit the souls of the hearers by reforming their morals. But he who prophesies and weaves together moral teaching, and exposes secret things of the heart, and purifies the souls of the hearers from shameful passions, edifies the church and uses the gift of prophecy or of teaching for others rather than for himself."
Of the passage written by the wise Paul in the first epistle to the Corinthians, «He that speaketh with tongues edifieth himself, but he that prophesieth edifieth the church », this is the elucidation. In the times in which the apostles were "propagating the saving preaching of the gospel in the world, many of those who believed worked signs and prodigies, in order to bring unbelievers to accept the truth. For it is for this cause that miracles are numerous among unbelievers, and not among those who have already believed, according to the saying of the same Paul. For this very same reason the gifts of the Spirit were given with greater liberality, and more openly, to these who were being brought to the faith. And those who were baptized often spoke with tongues immediately, and some were thought worthy to receive prophetic inspiration, while certain others even enjoyed the possession of both, as is written in the book of the Acts about some men who were baptized by Paul at Ephesus, as follows: «But, when they had heard it, they were baptized in the name of the Lord Jesus. And, when Paul had laid his hand upon them, the Holy Spirit came upon them, and they spake with tongues and prophesied». This grace therefore flourished among the Corinthians also at that time, and some used to speak with tongues, while others were thought worthy to prophesy. And the form of prophecy was such that it was made known not only by foretelling the future but also by the commingling of words of instruction which corrected morals, as the God-clad doctors such as Athanasius the great and Basil, and such as Gregory and John, and all who were like these, gained renown at one time and another in the churches. Since therefore certain men at Corinth were puffed up and thought much of themselves because they spoke with tongues, while others prophesied and taught things useful and beneficial, Paul, wishing to bring down their high looks, says this: «He who speaks with the tongues of the nations edifies himself, that is, establishes his own reputation, and is admired only, but does not benefit the soul of the hearers by reforming morals: but he who prophesies and weaves a web of moral teaching, and reproves secret things of the heart, and purifies the souls of the hearers from shameful passions, edifies the church, and acquires the gift of prophesy or of teaching for others rather than for himself».
The meaning of Job's saying, "May the blessing of him that hath perished come upon me" is clear to those who read it thoughtfully and carefully, based on what comes before it and what follows after. This is what he says: "I have often seen a man suffering extreme tortures and just on the point of perishing—perhaps when enemies or violent men were attacking him—and I rescued him from distress and saved him. Such a person has blessed me, because against all hope he was delivered from the destruction that was hanging over him. May that blessing therefore come upon me, and may God bring it to pass." That this is the correct interpretation is proven by the words that follow, as I said before. What does he actually say? "For I delivered the poor from the hand of the powerful, and I helped the orphan who had no helper. May the blessing of him that hath perished come upon me; and the mouth of the widow hath blessed me." But one can also understand this at a higher level as a parable. For our Lord also says in the gospels about those who put their soul to death as far as the world is concerned, and give up their body to martyrdom or to the labors of asceticism, and are therefore thought to be destroying and killing their soul because they are deprived of worldly pleasure: "He that destroyeth his soul for my sake shall find it." The prayer and blessing of a person who has perished in this way according to our Savior's saying and finds his soul is therefore a great thing. Any right-minded person will pray that this may come upon him, and will wisely say the words, "May the blessing of him that hath perished come upon me."
The meaning of Job's saying, «May the blessing of him that hath perished come upon me» is plain to those who read with intelligence and not carelessly from the fact that it follows the words which precede, and from the words which next follow. This is what he says: «Often have I seen a man suffering extreme tortures, and just on the point of perishing, as perhaps when enemies were upon him, or violent men, and have rescued him from distress and saved him; and such a one has blessed me, because against all hope he had been delivered from the destruction that was impending over him. May that blessing therefore come upon me, and may God bring it to effect». That this is so the words which follow will prove as I said before. What in fact does he say? «For I delivered the poor from the hand of the powerful, and I helped the orphan who had no helper. May the blessing of him that hath perished come upon me; and the mouth of the widow hath blessed me». But one may also understand this in a higher sense as a parable. For our Lord also says in the gospels about those who mortify their soul to the world, and give up their body to the arena of martyrdom, or to labours of asceticism, and are thereby thought to be destroying and slaying their soul, because they are deprived of worldly pleasure: «He that destroyeth his soul for my sake shall find it». The prayer and blessing therefore of a man who has thus perished according to our Saviour's saying and finds his soul is a great thing: and any right-minded man will pray that this may come upon him, and will wisely say the words, «May the blessing of him that hath perished come upon me».
Regarding what is written at the end of the book of Job, that he took an Arabian wife, we don't need to investigate too much who this is—whether this is another wife by whom he had other children after the disaster, or his former wife, who under the weight of the afflictions that came upon him gave way and stumbled, and urged him to speak some blasphemous words and escape from his sufferings. However, it is reasonable for us to understand that the wife by whom the children after the disaster were born was someone different from her. For the writer uses the words "Having taken an Arabian wife he begets a son" as if adding something new. For it would have been far from just for her to share in the good things when she shrank back in the time of struggle and tried to bring the combatant down from the highest summit of endurance.
As to what is written at the end of the book of Job, that he took an Arabian wife, it is unnecessary for us to inquire much who this is, whether this is another wife by whom he had other children after the calamity, or the former one, who under the magnitude of the afflictions that came upon him gave way and stumbled, and advised him to utter some blasphemous speech and depart from his pains. However it is reasonable for us to understand that the wife by whom the children after the calamity were born was some other one different from her. For it is as if adding something new that the writer uses the words: «Having taken an Arabian wife he begets a son». For it would have been far from just that she should share in the good things, who shrank in the time of the struggle, and tried to bring the combatant down from the highest summit of endurance.
The words written by the author in the book, and also about Job, of whom it is written that he "shall again rise with those whom the Lord raises," we must understand to have been composed with this meaning. Because of such a great trial, he had in a sense gone down to Sheol and final destruction, so that even his name would be extinguished from that point on, as he himself said when he was being tormented by the pains. Then suddenly he arose as from the dead, and put off the ugliness of the sores, and he was beautiful in body, as in the bloom of youth, and everything ended for him in a change to the best fortune. Therefore, so that no one would think that the prize of virtue ends with these things, and so that we who read would not imagine that we shall receive the rewards for the labors of virtue in this world, for this reason the writer recorded the words that are written, "He shall again rise with those whom the Lord raises." That is, so that no one would think that his rewards are completed and ended with present things, for these were given as a down payment for the things that are future and are expected by us all. For he shall rise with those whom the Lord raises, that is, those who have conducted themselves according to the same pattern, of whom Paul also in writing to the Hebrews says that all those who have borne testimony through faith "did not receive the promises, God having provided some better thing for us, that they might not be made perfect without us." By the words which he used (and it is written, "He shall again rise with those whom the Lord raises") the writer is thought to be explaining this also, that he endured such pains, not because he looked to the things that were given him in this world, but to the hope of the great and wonderful resurrection. Concerning this resurrection he also said, "I will endure for you until I shall again be," and again, "For I know that he who lives forever shall release me upon the earth. He shall raise my skin which endures these things." The words which are before us for the purpose of interpretation were used by the author with reference to the general resurrection which is expected by everyone (and the words are "He shall again rise with those whom the Lord raises"), and not, as your religiousness has supposed, to that by which some of the saints rose when our Lord took the saving Cross upon him for our sakes, and the Good Shepherd laid down his soul for the sheep. For this the holy Matthew the Evangelist recorded in these words: "But Jesus, when he had cried with a loud voice, gave up the ghost. And behold! the veil of the temple was torn in two, from the top to the bottom, and the earth quaked, and the rocks were split, and the graves were opened, and many bodies of the saints who slept arose, and came out from the graves, and after his resurrection went into the holy city, and appeared to many." Since the Evangelist stated indefinitely that many bodies of the saints who had fallen asleep rose, it is unnecessary for us to inquire who these were, and if Job was among them. For the reason why he said "many," and not "all the bodies of the saints" is because the resurrection which is expected by everyone is not that one, but the one at the second coming of our Savior Christ. For then, I mean at the time of the revered Cross, it was only in order to demonstrate the power of our same Savior, who in that the soul separated from the body went down to Sheol, that certain men rose by a divine manifestation, showing that in the places beneath the earth there was perception of the God-befitting illumination. And these were prophets and some of those who lived in the same manner as they, who were well-known from the Holy Scriptures among the inhabitants of Jerusalem. This is stated also by the God-clad Ignatius, who adorned the throne of the Antiochenes, immediately after the apostolic administration and the first see of the chief of the apostles Peter, and was perfected with a crown of martyrdom. In writing to those at Magnesia he wrote as follows about our Savior Christ: "How shall we be able to live without him, whom the prophets also, being his disciples in the spirit, expected as a teacher? And for this reason he whom they rightly awaited when he came raised them from the dead." But that we should think that those who rose then, at the time of the saving Cross, remained to this day the words of the gospel do not permit. For they cry plainly, "They went into the holy city and appeared to many." The word "appeared" plainly denotes a temporary appearance, for the purpose of confirming, as we said, the power of our Savior, who broke the gates of bronze and the bars of iron from which there is no escape, of the places beneath the earth. After therefore those who rose had shown themselves at that time, they again laid their bodies aside and departed to their places, awaiting the general resurrection which is expected by everyone. That this is so, the holy John bishop of Constantinople also testifies in the fourteenth note of the second part of the commentary on the first epistle to the Corinthians, where he wrote thus: "But if anyone is in doubt why, when speaking about the resurrection, he did not here introduce the bodies which rose in our Lord's time, we will say this, that this is not speaking about the resurrection. For to show that those who rose die again was foreign to the purpose of one who is showing that death is finally destroyed. For it is for this reason also that he said that it is the last thing to be destroyed, in order that you may no longer fear that it will rise. For, when evil is done away, much more shall death be annihilated." And in the fifteenth note which follows, when speaking about saving baptism, and explaining why a man who is about to be baptized, when he repeats the baptismal confession, is baptized into the remission of sins and the resurrection of the dead and eternal life, he says this: "For, since sin brought in death, the root being dried up, we must no longer dispute in any way about the destruction of the fruit. Therefore after first saying 'the remission of sin,' he then confesses also the resurrection of the dead, being led from this to that also. And afterwards, since the name 'resurrection' does not suffice to set forth everything (for many after they had risen departed again, as those in the Old Testament, as Lazarus, as those at the time of the Cross) you are commanded to say, 'and in eternal life,' so that no one may any longer fear death after that resurrection."
The words that were written by the writer in the book, and these also about Job, of whom it is written that he also 'shall again rise with those whom the Lord raiseth', we must suppose to have been composed with this meaning. In consequence of so great a trial he had in a sense gone down to Sheol and final destruction, so that even his name should thenceforth be extinguished, as he himself said when he was being tormented by the pains, and suddenly he arose as from the dead, and put off the unsightliness of the sores, and he was comely in body, as in the bloom of youth, and everything ended for him in a change to the best fortune. Therefore, lest any think that the prize of virtue ends with these things, and lest we who read imagine that we shall receive the rewards for the labours of virtue in this world, for this reason the writer recorded the words that are written, «He shall again rise with those whom the Lord raiseth»; that is, lest any think that his rewards are completed and ended with present things: for these were given as an earnest for the things that are future and are expected by us all. For he shall rise with those whom the Lord raiseth, viz. those who have conducted themselves after the same pattern, of whom Paul also in writing to the Hebrews says that all those who have borne testimony through faith 'did not receive the promises, God having provided some better thing for us, that they might not be made perfect without us'. By the words which he used (and it is written, «He shall again rise with those whom the Lord raiseth») the writer is thought to be explaining this also, that he endured such pains, not because he looked to the things that were given him in this.world, but to the hope of the great and wonderful resurrection, concerning which also he said, «I will endure for thee until I shall again be»; and again, «For I know that he ever floweth who shall release me upon the earth. He shall raise my skin which endureth these things». The words which are before us for the purpose of interpretation were used by the author with reference to the general resurrection which is expected by everyone (and the words are «He shall again rise with those whom the Lord raiseth»), and not, as your religiousness has supposed, to that by which some of the saints rose, when our Lord took the saving Cross upon him for our sakes, and the Good Shepherd laid down his soul for the sheep. For this the holy Matthew the Evangelist recorded in these words: «But Jesus, when he had cried with a loud voice, gave up the ghost. And lo! the veil of the temple was rent in two, from the top to the bottom, and the earth quaked, and the rocks were rent, and the graves were opened, and many bodies of the saints who slept arose, and came out from the graves, and after his resurrection went into the holy city, and appeared to many». Since then the Evangelist stated indefinitely that many bodies of the saints who had fallen asleep rose, it is unnecessary for us to inquire who these were, and if Job was among them. For the reason why he said 'many', and not 'all the bodies of the saints' is because the resurrection which is expected by everyone is not that one, but the one at the second coming of our Saviour Christ. For then, I mean at the time of the revered Gross, it was only in order to demonstrate the power of our same Saviour, who in that the soul separated from the body went down to Sheol, that certain men rose by a divine manifestation, showing that in the places beneath the earth there was perception of the God-befitting illumination. And these were prophets and some of those who lived after the same manner as they, who were well-known from the Holy Scriptures among the inhabitants of Jerusalem. This is stated also by the God-clad Ignatius, who adorned the throne of the Antiochenes, immediately after the apostolic administration, and the first see of the chief of the apostles Peter, and was perfected with a crown of martyrdom. In writing-to those at Magnesia he wrote as follows about our Saviour Christ: «How shall we be able to live without him? whom the prophets also, being his disciples in the spirit, expected as a teacher; and for this reason he whom they rightly awaited when he came raised them from the dead». But that we should think that those who rose then, at the time of the saving Cross, remained to this day the words of the gospel do not permit; for they cry plainly, «They went into the holy city and appeared to many». The word 'appeared' plainly denotes a temporary appearance, for the purpose of confirming, as we said, the power of our Saviour, who broke the gates of bronze, and the bars of iron from which there is no escape, of the places beneath the earth. After therefore those who rose had shown themselves at that time, they again laid their bodies aside and departed to their places, awaiting the general resurrection which is expected by everyone. That this is so, the holy John bishop of Constantinople also testifies in the fourteenth note of the second part of the commentary on the first epistle to the Corinthians, where he wrote thus: «But if any be in doubt why, when speaking about the resurrection, he did not here introduce the bodies which rose in our Lord's time, we will say this, that this is not speaking about the resurrection. For to show that those who rose die again was alien to the purpose of one who is showing that death is finally destroyed. For it is for this reason also that he said that it is the last thing to be destroyed, in order that you may no longer fear that it will rise. For, when evil is done away, much more shall death be annihilated». And in the fifteenth note which follows, when speaking about saving baptism, and explaining why a man who is about to be baptized, when he repeats the baptismal confession, is baptized into the remission of sins and the resurrection of the dead, and eternal life, he says this: «For, since sin brought in death, the root being dried up, we must no longer dispute in any way about the: destruction of the fruit. Therefore after first saying 'the remission of sin', he then confesses also the resurrection of the dead, being led from this to that also. And afterwards, since the name 'resurrection' does not suffice to set forth everything (for many after they had risen departed again,' as those in the Old Testament, as Lazarus, as those at the time of the Cross) you are bidden to say, 'and in eternal life', that none may any longer fear death after that resurrection».
We have now answered, as you can see, all the God-loving questions you asked in your esteemed letter, according to our weakness and according to the small measure of knowledge that has come to us. We pray that you may receive the glorious part of Mary, who never tired of turning her instruction-loving ear to the saving teaching of Jesus, and about whom that testimony was given which said, "For Mary has chosen for herself the good part, which shall not be taken from her."
But in your previous letter to us you explained how your religious brother Innocent and the sisters stand in the faith. After writing this about them, you added—as if you had done something contrary to the profession of philosophy—that you take no thought for them. Know clearly that it is not unworthy of your perfection to take thought for those who are related to you regarding the faith and in fitting spiritual matters, and to do all that is in your power, and to give assistance with counsels and prayers. For our duty consists in these things. The apostolic saying also extends to this: "If any man takes no thought for his own and especially those of the house, he denies the faith, and is worse than an unbeliever." To take thought for their worldly wealth, or for anything else that is pleasant, is the part of those who are not philosophers. I therefore made this distinction as well, and asked the love of God that is in you to write to me about them. You have done well in telling everything both wisely and in accordance with truth. It is proper that this distinction should not escape you either.
You have asked me questions about another matter of this kind. I have heard that Isaiah the unlawful, like Dathan and Abiram, has risen against the laws of the priesthood and has trampled upon everything like a hog, with foul, disorderly, uncanonical feet. I have heard that, having gone to Pamphylia, he has thought fit to whisper lies about me and to say that in what I wrote about the incorruptibility of the body of God and our Savior Jesus Christ, I proclaimed the faith and said that the body was corrupted and dissolved during the three days' burial, and certain similar blasphemies which are not plausible, which wound the ears and disturb the souls of those who listen without intelligence. It is therefore in my mind to send a man there carrying all that has been written by me, in order to establish the truth. If you also have heard of any similar report that has been whispered there, since some persons have perhaps written and told you, tell me.
I read with great pleasure the statement on which you have expanded in the letter, about how you have loved and still love my humility with peculiar warmth, and I rejoiced with spiritual joy on learning the fervor of the love that is in you—the God-befitting and pure love with which rational souls are smitten towards one another, even among those with whom you associate in the blood of Christ. But I believe of you that, even if you write at very great length in every letter, you will not be able to express even a small portion of the love and confidence that you have towards me, who am unworthy and fall far short of this. But I pray that for this perfect love you may receive rewards both in this world and in the future and endless life.
We have now discharged, as you see, all the God-loving debt of your, esteemed questions, according to our feebleness, and according to the small measure of knowledge which has come to us; and we pray that there may fall to you the glorious part of Mary, who never tired of bending her instruction-loving ear to the saving teaching of Jesus, and upon whom that testimony was given which said, «For Mary hath chosen for herself the good part, which shall not be taken from her». But, whereas in the previous letter to us you stated how your religious brother Innocent and the sisters stand in the faith, and after writing this about them, as if you had done something contrary to the profession of philosophy, you then added that you take no «thought for them, know clearly that it is not a thing unworthy of your perfection that as regards the faith and in fitting spiritual matters you should take thought for those who are related to you, and perform all that is in your power, and give assistance with counsels and prayers. For in these things our duty consists; and to this also the apostolic saying extends, «If any man taketh no thought for his own and especially those of the house, he denieth the faith, and is worse than an unbeliever». And that we should take thought for their worldly opulence, or for anything else that is pleasant, is the part of those who are not philosophers. This distinction therefore I too made, and asked the love of God that is in you to write to me about them; and you have done well in telling everything both wisely and in accordance with truth; and it is proper that the distinction in this point also should not escape you. Upon another matter you have asked me questions of this kind. 1 have heard that Isaiah the unlawful, like Dathan and Abiram, has risen against the laws of the priesthood, and has trampled upon everything like a hog, with foul, disorderly, uncanonical feet; and that, having gone to Pamphylia, he has thought fit to whisper lies about me, and to say that in what I wrote about the incorruptibility of the body of God and our Saviour Jesus Christ I proclaimed the faith, and said that the body was corrupted and dissolved during the three days' burial, and certain similar blasphemies which are not plausible, which wound the ears, and disturb the souls, of those who listen without intelligence: and it is therefore in my mind to send a man there carrying all that has been written by me, in order to establish the truth. If then you also have heard of any similar report that has been whispered there, since some persons have perhaps written and told you, tell me. The statement on which you have dilated in the letter, as to how you have loved and still love my humility with peculiar warmth, I read with great pleasure, and I rejoiced with spiritual joy on learning the fervour of the love that is in you, the God-befitting and pure love, wherewith rational souls are smitten towards one another, even among those with whom you associate in the blood of Christ. But I believe of you that, even if you write at very great length in every letter, you will not be able to express even a small portion of the love and confidence that you have towards me, who am unworthy and fall far short of this. But I pray that for this perfect love you may receive rewards both in this world, and in the future and endless life.
The end of the letter to Anastasia the deaconess.
The end of the letter to Anastasia the deaconess.