Four Discourses on the Rich Man and Lazarus — Discourse 4

The rich man and Lazarus concluded: conscience and confession of sins, illustrated by Joseph and his brothers.

Source: John Chrysostom, Four discourses, chiefly on the parable of the Rich man and Lazarus (1869) Discourse 4. pp.90-110.. Transcribed by Roger Pearse (tertullian.org); public domain.

Contents · 8 chapters
  1. Discourse 4
  2. Chapter 1
  3. Chapter 2
  4. Chapter 3
  5. Chapter 4
  6. Chapter 5
  7. Chapter 6
  8. Chapter 7

Discourse 4

Concerning the rich man and Lazarus—concerning conscience and confession—Joseph and his brethren.

CONCERNING THE RICH MAN AND LAZARUS—-CONCERNING CONSCIENCE AND CONFESSION—-JOSEPH AND HIS BRETHREN.

Chapter 1

Today we need to explain the rest of the parable concerning Lazarus. Perhaps you think we have explained all of it, but I would not take advantage of any lack of knowledge on your part in order to deceive you. Nor would I abandon the task before I can leave with the assurance that I have explored everything, as far as light is given to me—just as the farmer, when he gathers the fruit of the vine, does not stop until he has cut off every little bunch. Since I now perceive, as if beneath the leaves, some thoughts still hidden in these words, allow me to gather these up as well, using the mind as a sickle. A vine that has been completely stripped of fruit stands barren for the present, having only leaves. With respect to the spiritual vine of the sacred Scriptures, it is not so. When we have gathered all the fruit that is visible, more still remains. Thus many before us have also spoken on this subject; many perhaps after us will speak on it, but no one will be able to exhaust the whole store of wealth. For such is the nature of this abundance: the more deeply you dig down, the more plentifully divine instruction wells forth. It is a fountain that never fails.

To-day it is requisite that we should explain the rest of the parable concerning Lazarus. Perhaps you may suppose that we have explained the whole of it; but I would not avail myself of any want of knowledge on your part, in order to deceive; nor would I give up the task, before I can go away with the assurance that I have explored all, as far as light is given me: as the husbandman, when he gathers the fruit of the vine, ceases not until he has cut off every little bunch. Since, therefore, I now perceive, as if beneath the leaves, some thoughts still hidden in these words, permit me to gather up also these, using the mind as a sickle. A vine being entirely stripped of fruit stands for the present barren, having leaves only. With respect to the spiritual vine of the sacred Scriptures it is not so; but when we have gathered all the fruit that is to be seen, more still remains. Thus many also before us have spoken on this subject; many perhaps after us will speak on it; but no one will be able to exhaust the whole store of wealth. For such is the nature of this abundance, that the more deeply you dig down, the more plentifully divine instruction wells forth: it is a fountain never failing.

In the last assembly we should have fulfilled this obligation to you, but we did not think it right to pass over the memory of the good deeds of Saint Babylas and the two holy martyrs who followed him. So we postponed the rest of this topic, saving the completion of the parable for today. Since we have given the fathers their praise—not according to their worth, but according to our ability—allow us now to deliver the remainder of this subject. Do not grow weary until we have reached the end, taking up our discussion from the point where we recently left off. Where then did we leave the narrative? It was at the point where we came to the great chasm between the just and the unjust. When the rich man said, "Send Lazarus," Abraham answered him, "A great gulf is fixed between us and you, so that those who would pass from here to you cannot, nor can those who would come from there pass to us" (Luke 16:26). We also showed through many arguments that it is necessary to place our hope of salvation, according to God's grace, in our own right condition, and not to trust in fathers or grandfathers or great-grandfathers, or in relatives, friends, associates, and neighbors. For "no man can by any means redeem his brother" (Psalm 48:8). No matter how much those who depart this life in the company of sinners may beg and plead on their behalf, everything they say will be useless and in vain. Again, the five virgins begged their companions for a supply of oil and did not obtain it. The man who hid his talent in the earth also made many excuses, yet was still condemned. Those who did not feed the Lord when He was hungry, nor give Him drink when He was thirsty—they hoped to find refuge in the plea of ignorance, but gained no pardon or excuse. There are others who are unable to say a word, like the man who appeared at the feast clothed in vile garments, who, when charged with the fault, was speechless. And not only this man, but also another who was unforgiving to his neighbor, from whom he demanded the hundred pence, who afterwards, when charged by his lord with cruelty and inhumanity, had nothing to reply. From these examples it is clear that nothing can help us there if we do not have good deeds. Whether we use prayers and pleas, or whether we remain silent, the sentence of punishment and penalty will equally be pronounced against us. Listen then to how this man, having made two requests to Abraham, failed to gain either of them. First he pleaded for himself when he said, "Send Lazarus." Next he pleaded not for himself, but for his brothers, yet he obtained neither request. If the first request was impossible, much more so was the second—the one on behalf of his brothers. However, if it seems good, let us carefully examine the very words themselves. If when a magistrate brings an offender into the public court, summons officers of justice, and proceeds with the trial, everyone hastens eagerly to hear what questions the judge may ask and what replies the accused may give—how much more should we pay attention in this case to what this criminal (I mean the rich man) requests, and what the righteous judge, speaking through the mouth of Abraham, replies. For it was not the patriarch who was judging the case, even though he spoke the words. Rather, just as in our earthly courts, when robbers or murderers are under accusation, the law requires that they should stand at a distance and out of sight of the judge and not hear the sound of the judge's voice—in this way also marking their dishonor—but a messenger conveys the judge's questions and the accused's replies. The same thing took place then. The condemned man did not hear the voice of God himself speaking to him. Instead, Abraham acted as a deputy, conveying the judge's words to the criminal. For he did not speak what he said on his own authority, but he stated the divine laws to the rich man and uttered the decisions given to him from on high. And for this reason the rich man had nothing to reply.12

In the last assembly we ought to have discharged this debt owing to you, but we did not think it right to pass by the memory of the good deeds of Saint Babylas, and the two holy martyrs who followed him. Therefore, we put off the remainder of this subject, reserving the completion of the parable till to-day. Since, then, we have rendered to the fathers their praise, not according to their worth, but according to our ability; permit us now to deliver the remainder of this subject. And be not weary until we have arrived at the end, talcing up our discourse from the point at which we lately left off. Where then did we leave the narrative? It was at the point where we came to the great chasm between the just and the unjust. For, when the rich man said, "Send Lazarus," Abraham answered him, "A great gulf is fixed between us and you: so that they which would pass from hence to you cannot; neither can they pass to us, that would come from thence," (Luke xvi. 26.) We also showed by many arguments that it is necessary to place our hope of safety, according to the grace of God, in our own right condition, and not trust in fathers or grandfathers, or great-grandfathers, or in relations, and friends, and associates, and neighbours; for "no man can by any means redeem his brother," (Ps. xlviii. 8.) But how much soever they who depart this life in company with sinners, beseech and supplicate on their behalf, all that they say will be vain and useless. For again, the five virgins begged from their companions a supply of oil, and did not obtain it; he also who hid his talent in the earth, though he made many excuses, still was condemned. They, too, who fed not the Lord when He was hungry, nor gave Him drink when thirsting —-they, hoping to find refuge in the plea of ignorance, did not gain any pardon or excuse. Others there are who are unable to say a word, as he who appeared at the feast clad in vile garments, being charged with the fault, was speechless. And not this man only, but also another who was unforgiving to his neighbour, of whom he demanded the hundred pence, who afterwards, when charged by his lord with cruelty and inhumanity, had nothing to reply. From these instances it is plain that nothing can help us there, if we have not the good deeds; but whether we use prayers and entreaties, or whether we be silent, the sentence of punishment and penalty will equally be uttered against us. Hear then how this man, having made request to Abraham for two things, failed to gain either of them. For, first he made supplication for himself, when he said, "Send Lazarus;" next, not for himself, but for his brethren, but he obtained neither request. If the first request was impossible, much more was the second—-that on behalf of his brethren. However, if it seem good, let us carefully mark the very words themselves. For if when the magistrate causes an offender to be brought into the public court, summons officers of justice, and proceeds with the trial, all hasten with eagerness to hear what questions the judge may put, and what replies the accused may make,—-much more ought we to give attention in this case to what this criminal,—-I mean, the rich man, requests, and what the righteous judge, by the mouth of Abraham, replies. For it was not the patriarch that was judging the case, even though he uttered the words; but, as in our earthly courts, when robbers or murderers are under accusation, the law requires that they should stand at a distance and out of sight of the judge; it enjoins that they should not hear the sound of the judge's voice, in this manner also marking their dishonour; but a messenger conveys the questions of the judge and the replies of the accused. The same thing took place then. The condemned man heard not the voice of God himself speaking to him; but Abraham acted as a deputy, conveying the words of the judge to the criminal. For he did not speak that which he said on his own authority, but he stated the divine laws to the rich man, and uttered the decisions given him from on high. And for this reason the rich man had nothing to reply.12

Chapter 2

Let us pay careful attention to what is being said. I am deliberately moving slowly through this parable: even though this is the fourth day, I am not leaving the subject, because I see great benefit coming from this examination, both for the rich and for the poor, and for those who are troubled by the prosperity of the wicked and the poverty and suffering of the righteous. For in general, nothing causes such a great stumbling-block and brings so much religious doubt to many people as the fact that the rich who live in sin may enjoy great prosperity, while the righteous, who live virtuously, are reduced to extreme poverty and endure countless other things even worse than poverty.

Let us, therefore, carefully attend to that which is said. For I am purposely proceeding slowly through this parable: though this be the fourth day, I do not leave the subject; for I see great benefit arising from this examination, both to the rich and to the poor, and to those who are troubled because of the prosperity of the wicked and the poverty and tribulation of the just. For, in general, nothing is so great a stumbling-block and causes so much religious doubt to many people, as the fact that the rich who live in sin may enjoy great prosperity, while the just, who live virtuously, are reduced to extreme poverty, and endure numberless other things even worse than poverty.

This parable is enough to provide a remedy that makes the wealthy wiser and consoles the poor. It teaches the former not to be arrogant; it comforts the poor regarding their present situation. It forbids the wealthy from boasting if they live wickedly yet pay no penalty in this life, since a severe judgment awaits them in the next world. It persuades the poor not to be troubled by others' prosperity, and not to think that our affairs are not under God's control, even if the righteous suffer hardships here while the wicked and corrupt enjoy constant prosperity. For both will later receive what they deserve: the former will receive the crown that rewards patience and endurance, the latter will receive the punishments and penalties that belong to sin. Let both rich and poor inscribe this parable—the rich on the walls of their houses, the poor on the walls of their minds. And if it ever becomes obscured through the growth of forgetfulness, renew it completely through fresh recollection. Or rather, let the rich also write it in their minds instead of in their houses, and constantly carry it with them. Let it be their instructor and the foundation of all their philosophy. For if we have this permanently written in our minds, neither the delights of this present life will be able to elate us, nor its sorrows able to humiliate or overthrow us. Instead, we will be affected by both kinds of experience only as we are by pictures painted on a wall. For when looking at a wall we see a rich man or a poor man portrayed, we neither envy the one nor despise the other, because what we look at is only an image and not reality. In the same way, if we learn the real nature of riches and poverty, of honor and dishonor, and of all other things both gloomy and bright, we will be freed from the trouble that arises from each of these classes of things. For they are all more deceptive than a shadow, and neither will a brilliant and honorable position puff up a lofty and noble soul, nor will a lowly and despised position be able to trouble him.

But this parable is sufficient to afford a remedy to make the wealthy more wise, to console the poor; it teaches the former not to be high-minded; it comforts the poor with respect to their present condition; it forbids the former to boast if, while living wickedly, they pay no penalty in this life, since a severe examination awaits them in the next world; it persuades the latter not to be troubled on account of the prosperity of others, and not to imagine that our affairs are not under the control of Providence, even if the just suffer ills here, while the wicked and depraved enjoy continual prosperity. For both will hereafter receive their desert; the former the crown which is the reward of patience and endurance, the latter the punishments and penalties which belong to sin. Let both rich and poor inscribe this parable,—-the rich on the walls of their houses, the poor on the walls of their mind; and should it ever by the growth of forgetfulness be obscured, renew it completely by means of fresh recollection. Or rather, let the rich also, instead of in their houses, write it in their mind, and constantly bear it about; and let it be their instructor and the groundwork of all their philosophy. For if we have this lastingly written in our mind, neither the delights of the present life will be able to elate us, nor its sorrows to humiliate or overthrow us; but we shall be affected by both these kinds of experience, only as we are by pictures painted on the wall. For when looking at a wall we see portrayed a rich man or a poor, we neither envy the one nor despise the other; because that which we look at is an image only and not reality. Thus, also, if we learn the real nature of riches and poverty, of honour and dishonour; and of all other things both gloomy and bright, we shall be freed from the trouble which arises from each of these classes of things. For they all are more deceptive than a shadow; and neither will a brilliant and honourable position puff- up a lofty and noble soul, nor a lowly and despised position be able to trouble him.

However, it's time now for us to consider the words of the rich man: "I ask you, father"—that is, I beg you, I plead with you, I pray to you—"send Lazarus to my father's house, for I have five brothers, so that he may warn them, lest they also come into this place of torment" (Luke 16:27–28). Since he failed to get what he asked for himself, he made his request for others. Notice how kind and gentle he becomes when he is being punished. He who despised Lazarus when he was present now shows concern for others who are absent. He who ignored someone placed right before his eyes now remembers those he cannot see. He pleads with great urgency and passion that they be warned so they might escape the evils about to come upon them. And he begs that Lazarus be sent to his father's house—to the place that had been like an arena for Lazarus, the place where his virtue had been tested. Let those who saw him struggling see him crowned, he says. Let those who witnessed his poverty and hunger, his countless troubles, also witness his honor, his transformation, his complete glory. That way, taught by both sights, they may learn that our concerns are not limited to this present life. They may be prepared in advance so as to escape this punishment and ruin. What does Abraham reply? "They have Moses and the prophets," he says. "Let them hear them." You do not, he implies, care for your brothers as much as God does, who made them. He has given them many teachers, advisers, and counselors. What, then, does the rich man say? "No, father Abraham, but if someone went to them from the dead, they would repent."

However, it is time now for us to consider the words of the rich man: "I ask thee, father"—-that is, I beseech, I beg, I supplicate thee—-"that thou wouldest send Lazarus to my father's house; for I have five brethren; that he may testify unto them, lest they also come into this place of torment," (Luke xvi. 27, 28.) Since he failed to gain that which he sought for himself, he made supplication for others. Mark how benevolent and mild he becomes when under punishment. He who despised Lazarus when present, now has regard for others who are absent: he who passed by one who was placed before his eyes, is mindful of those whom he does not see, and he entreats with great earnestness and zeal that warning should be given to them, that they might escape the evils about to overtake them. And he begs that Lazarus should be sent to his father's house,—-to the place which had been to Lazarus as an arena, the place where his virtue had been tested. Let them see him crowned, he says, who have seen him contending; let the witnesses of his poverty and hunger, of his innumerable woes, be also witnesses of his honour, his transfiguration, his complete glory; that, being taught by both sights, they may learn that our interests are not bounded by this present life; that they may be prepared beforehand, so as to be able to escape this punishment and ruin. What does Abraham reply? "They have Moses and the prophets," he saith; "let them hear,them." Thou hast not, he implies, so much care for thy brethren as God has, who made them: He has given them many teachers, advisers, and counsellors. What, then, does the rich man say? "Nay, father Abraham; but if one went unto them from the dead, they would be persuaded."

The same thing is often said today. Where are those now who say, "Who has come from there? Who ever rose from the dead? Who can tell us what is in Hades?" How many things like this the rich man used to say to himself when he was living in luxury! He did not simply ask that someone should rise from the dead; but since he had been used to despising the Scriptures when he heard them, mocking them, and regarding what was said as myths, he assumed from his own experience that his brothers would feel the same way. "They," he would say, "are skeptical in the same way; but if someone should rise from the dead, they will not disbelieve or mock him, but will instead pay attention to his words."

The same thing is often said now. Where are now those who say, "Who has come from thence? Who ever rose from the dead? Who can tell us what is in Hades?" How many things of this kind the rich man used to say within himself when he was living luxuriously! He did not simply request that some one should rise from the dead; but since when he heard the Scriptures he had been accustomed to despise them, to deride, to regard the things said as myths; from that which he himself had felt, he supposed that the same would be felt by his brothers. "They," he would say, "are sceptical in the same way; but if one should arise from the dead, him they will not disbelieve nor deride, but will rather give heed to his words."

What, then, does Abraham reply? "If they don't listen to Moses and the prophets, they won't listen even if someone rises from the dead" (Luke 16:31). And that this is true—that someone who doesn't listen to the Scriptures won't listen even to those who rise from the dead—the Jews provide an example of this. Since they didn't listen to Moses and their own prophets, they didn't believe even when they saw the dead rise. Instead, at the very moment it happened, they tried to kill the risen Lazarus. And on another occasion, at the crucifixion, they strongly opposed the apostles even while many dead were rising.

What, then, does Abraham reply? "If they hear not Moses and the prophets, neither will they hear though one rose from the dead," (Luke xvi. 31.) And that this is true—-that he who listens not to the Scriptures, will not listen even to those who rise from the dead—-of this the Jews afford an instance, who, since they did not listen to Moses and their own prophets, did not believe even when they saw the dead arise; but at the very time of the event, tried to kill the risen Lazarus; and on another occasion, at the crucifixion, vehemently opposed the apostles even while many dead were rising.

Chapter 3

But to assure you for another reason that the teaching of the apostles is more convincing than that of someone brought back from the dead, consider this: a dead person is completely a servant, but what the Scriptures declare is spoken by the Lord himself. So even if someone should rise from the dead, even if an angel should descend from heaven, the Scriptures would still be the most reliable testimony. For the Ruler of angels and the Lord of the dead and of the living has himself given the written law. Furthermore, that those who wish for dead people to return wish for something unnecessary is proven, in addition to what has already been said, by comparing it to the case of our own courts. Gehenna does not seem to exist to those who do not believe. To the faithful it is clear and obvious, but to the unbelieving it does not seem to exist. There is a court of judgment in which we hear every day that one person is punished, another is fined, another is condemned to the mines, another to be burned, another to be put to death in some other way. Even though they hear all this, the evil, the wicked, and the depraved are not made wise. Indeed, often many such people, having been captured and escaped punishment, break out of prison and run away, then return to the same behavior and commit even greater crimes than before.

But that you may be assured for another reason that the teaching of the apostles is more convincing than that of the restored to life, consider this—-that a dead man is altogether a servant, but the things which the Scriptures declare are uttered by the Lord himself; so that though one should rise from the dead, though an angel should descend from heaven, the Scriptures would still be the surest testimony. For the Ruler of angels and the Lord of the dead and of the living has Himself given the written law. Again, that they who wish for dead men to come back, wish for a superfluous thing, is proved, in addition to that which has been said, by comparing the case of our own courts. Gehenna does not seem to exist to those who believe not. To the faithful it is plain and manifest, but still to the unbelieving it does not seem to exist. There is a court of judgment in which we hear each day that such a one is punished, another is mulcted of property, another is condemned to the mines, another to be burnt, another to be put to death in some other way. Notwithstanding that they hear all this, the evil, the wicked and abandoned are not made wise; often, indeed, many such having been captured, and escaping punishment, break out of prison, and running away, again return to the same courses, and commit even greater crimes than before.

We should not want to hear from the dead what the Scriptures teach us every day, and much more clearly. If God knew that raising certain people from the dead would help the living, He would not have overlooked it. He who has formed everything for our good would not have neglected this benefit. Besides, if the dead continually rose to tell us everything that happens in that place, even this phenomenon would eventually be ignored. The tempter could very easily adapt his evil teaching to such a situation. He would often be able to fake appearances, or prepare his agents to fake death and burial, then present them as having risen from the dead. By these methods he would plant in the minds of those he deceives everything he wanted them to believe. Even now, when nothing of that kind happens, images of departed people often appear in dreams and have deceived and ruined many. How much more, if many people returned from the dead, would that cunning spirit trap many in his schemes and bring great deception into our life. Therefore God has closed the gates and does not allow any of those who have died to return and tell us what happens there, so that the tempter cannot exploit such a situation and introduce all his lies. When there were prophets, Satan raised up false prophets. When there were apostles, he raised up false apostles. Even when Christ appeared, he raised up false Christs. Whenever sound doctrine has been delivered, he has introduced corrupt doctrine, sowing weeds among the wheat. So too, if this situation existed, he would devise ways to cause deception through his own agents—not actually raising the dead, but misleading the senses of observers through sorcery and trickery, or even, as I said before, preparing people to fake death, thus turning everything upside down and causing confusion. But God, foreseeing all these things, has prevented such an attempt and, out of concern for us, has not permitted anyone at any time to come from there to tell living people what takes place there. He has taught us to regard the Holy Scriptures as more trustworthy than everything else. He has made certain things clearer to us than they would have been made by the resurrection of the dead. He has instructed the whole world. He has driven away error and brought in the truth. Through fishermen and people of no reputation, He has accomplished all these benefits and given us sufficient proofs of His providence on every side. Therefore we should not imagine that our existence is limited to this present life. Instead, we should be certain that there will be an examination and either a reward or a punishment for everything that has happened here. This fact is so clear and obvious to everyone that Jews and Greeks, even heretics—indeed, all people of every kind—agree about it. Even if not everyone acts as wisely as they should regarding the resurrection, still everyone agrees about the judgment and future punishment and trial. Everyone agrees that there is a recompense in the future for everything that has happened here. If this were not the case, why did God stretch out such a heaven and spread the earth beneath, make the expanse of the sea, and pour out the air? Why did He show such foresight if He did not intend to be concerned with our affairs right to the end?

Let us not, therefore, wish to hear those things from the dead which the Scriptures each day teach us, and much more clearly. For if God knew this; namely, that if certain should rise from the dead, they would benefit the living, He would not have overlooked it; He who has formed all things for our good would not have neglected this benefit. Again, if the dead arose continually to declare to us all that takes place there, even this phenomenon would in time also be disregarded; for the tempter could, with the greatest ease, adapt his wicked teaching to such a state of affairs. He would be able often to feign appearances, or by preparing his ministers to feign death and burial, and exhibiting them as having: risen from the dead, by these means he would introduce into the minds of those whom he misleads everything that he wished them to believe. For even now, when nothing of that kind takes place, the forms of the departed often have appeared in dreams, and have deceived and ruined many. Much more if such a state of things, namely, that many returned from the dead, existed, that subtle spirit would involve many in his wiles, and introduce great deception into our life. Therefore God has closed the portals, and does not permit any of those who have departed to return to tell us the things that take place there; so that the tempter cannot take advantage of such a state of things, and introduce all his deceit. For, also, when there were prophets Satan raised up false prophets, and when apostles, he raised up false apostles; even when Christ appeared, he raised up false Christs; and whenever sound doctrine has been delivered, he has introduced corrupt doctrine, sowing tares among the wheat. So also, if this state of things had existed, he would have contrived to cause deception by his own instruments—-not really raising the dead, but by sorceries and guile misleading the senses of beholders, or even, as I said before, preparing those who should simulate death, thus turning upside down and confusing all things. But God, foreseeing all these things, has prevented such an attempt, and out of regard for us, has not permitted any one at any time to come from thence to relate to living men the things that take place there. He has taught us to regard the Holy Scriptures as more worthy of trust than everything else. For He has made certain things more clear to us than they would have been made by the resurrection of the dead; He has instructed the whole world; He has driven away error, and brought in the truth; He has, by the instrumentality of fishermen and men of no reputation, procured all these benefits, and afforded to us on all sides sufficient proofs of His own providence. Therefore let us not imagine that our affairs are bounded by the present life; but let us be assured that there will be a scrutiny, and a recompense or a retribution for all that has happened here. This fact is so clear and plain to all, that both Jews and Greeks, even heretics, agree concerning it; yea, all men of every class. For if also all men do not act as wisely as they ought, with regard to the resurrection, still all agree with respect to the judgment, and future punishment and trial. All agree that there is a recompense hereafter for all the things that have happened here. For if this were not the case, why did God stretch out such a heaven and spread the earth beneath, and make the expanse of the sea, and diffuse the air? Why did He display such foresight, if He did not intend to be concerned in our affairs even to the end?

Chapter 4

Do you not see many people who, after living a virtuous life and suffering countless evils, have departed from this world without receiving any good? Others, on the other hand, who have displayed every kind of wicked disposition, who have plundered the possessions of others, have robbed and oppressed widows and orphans—these have departed this life after enjoying wealth and luxury and endless other good things, and have suffered no misfortune whatsoever. When, then, do the former receive the reward of their virtue, and when do the latter pay the penalty of their wickedness, if our affairs are limited by the present life? For everyone will agree that if there is a God—as there certainly is—He is a just God; and everyone will also agree that if He is just, He will reward these two classes according to their deserts. But if He intends to give to each class what they deserve, whereas in this life neither class received it—neither the one, the punishment of their sin, nor the other, the reward of their virtue—it is clear that there is reserved a future time when each will receive their appropriate recompense.

Do you not see many who, after living a virtuous life, having suffered innumerable ills, have departed hence without receiving any good? Others, again, who have displayed every kind of evil disposition, who have plundered the possessions of others, have robbed and oppressed widows and orphans, these have departed this life after enjoying wealth and luxury and endless other good things, and have suffered no misfortune whatever. When, therefore, do the former receive the reward of their virtue,—-when do the latter pay the penalty of their wickedness, if our affairs are limited by the present life? For that, if there be a God—-as there assuredly is—-He is a just God, every one will allow; and that, if He is just, He will reward these two classes according to their deserts—-this also will be granted. But if He intends to render to each class their desert, whereas in this life neither class received it —-neither the one, the punishment of their sin, nor the other, the reward of their virtue—-it is manifest that an opportunity is reserved when each will receive their appropriate recompense.

And why has God placed within our minds such a watchful and vigilant judge—I mean conscience? No human judge could possibly be as tireless as our conscience is. Judges in worldly courts are sometimes corrupted by money, weakened by flattery, or made to dissemble through fear; and many other things can destroy the integrity of their decisions. But the judgment seat of conscience never yields to any of these influences. Whether you offer money, or flatter, or threaten, or do anything else of this sort, it still pronounces an impartial sentence against the schemes of sinners. And whoever commits iniquity condemns himself, even if no one else accuses him. And not just once or twice, but repeatedly and throughout one's entire life, it continues to do the same. Even if much time has passed, it never forgets what has happened. At the moment sin is committed, and before its commission, and after its commission, conscience sets itself up as our accuser—but especially after the commission. For at the time of committing the sin, being intoxicated by the pleasure, we are not so sensitive. But when the deed is past and has reached its conclusion, then, especially when all the pleasure is exhausted, the sharp sting of repentance is felt. And contrary to what happens to women in childbirth, who before the birth experience great and unbearable suffering and feel the pangs of labor causing intense pain, but afterward have relief because the pain ceases with the birth of the infant—in the case we are considering, it is not like this. For as long as we conceive and harbor corrupt desires in our minds, we are glad and rejoice. But when we have brought forth this evil offspring, sin, then we see the baseness of what has been produced and are pained; then we are in greater misery than women in labor. Therefore, I beg you, do not entertain any corrupt desire, especially the beginning of such a desire. But if we have admitted any such desire, let us extinguish its beginnings. And even if we have been negligent beyond this point, let us destroy the sin that has proceeded to deeds through confession, tears, and self-condemnation. Nothing is so effective an antidote to sin as condemning and repudiating it with penitence and tears. By condemning your own sin, you throw off its yoke. Who says this? God, the Judge himself: "Acknowledge first your sin, that you may be justified" (Isaiah 43:26, LXX). Why are you ashamed and embarrassed to confess your sin? Why speak of it to man, who may blame you? Why confess it to your fellow-servant, who may put you to shame? Rather show it to the Master, to Him who cares for you, who is kindly disposed. Show the wound to the Physician.3

And for what purpose has God put within our mind a judge so ever-watchful and vigilant,—-I mean conscience? It is impossible that any judge among men should be so indefatigable as our conscience is. For judges in worldly affairs are sometimes corrupted by money, or weakened by flattery, or dissemble because of fear; and many other things there are that destroy the rectitude of their decision; but the judgment-seat of conscience never yields to any of these influences; but whether you offer money, or flatter, or threaten, or do any other such thing, it utters still an impartial sentence against the schemes of sinners; and whosoever commits iniquity, himself condemns himself, even though no one else should accuse him. And not once, nor twice, but even frequently, and through one's whole life, it continues to do the same; though much time may have intervened, it never forgets what has happened. At the moment when sin is committed, and before its commission, and after its commission, conscience constitutes itself our accuser; but chiefly after the commission. For at the time of committing the sin, being intoxicated by the pleasure, we are not so sensitive; but when the affair is passed, and has reached its conclusion, then, especially when all the pleasure is exhausted, the sharp sting of repentance is felt. And contrary to that which happens to women in travail, who before the birth have great and unbearable suffering, who feel the pangs of labour causing intense pain, but afterwards have relief, since the pain ceases with the birth of the infant; in the case we are considering, it is not so. For as long as we conceive and have in our mind corrupt designs, we are glad and rejoice; but when we have brought forth this evil offspring, sin, then we see the baseness of that which is produced and are pained; then are we in greater misery than women in travail. Wherefore do not, I beseech you, entertain any corrupt desire, especially the beginning of such a desire. But if we have admitted any such desire, let us quench the beginnings of it; and, even if we have been negligent beyond this, let us destroy the sin which has proceeded to deeds, by confession, and tears, and self-condemnation. Nothing is so great an antidote to sin as condemnation and repudiation of it with penitence and tears. Condemning thy own sin, thou dost put off its yoke. Who is it that speaks thus? God, the Judge himself. "Acknowledge first thy sin, that thou mayest be justified," (Isa. xliii. 26, LXX.) Why are you ashamed and blush to confess your sin? Why speak of it to man, who may blame you? Why confess it to your fellow-servant, who may cause you shame? Rather show it to the Master, to Him who cares for you, who is kindly-disposed; show the wound to the Physician.3

Even if you don't confess, He is not ignorant of what you've done—He knew it before you even committed it. So why don't you speak of it? Does the sin become heavier by confessing it? No, it becomes lighter and less burdensome. This is why He wants you to confess: not so you'll be punished, but so you'll be forgiven; not so He may learn about your sin (how could that be, since He has already seen it?), but so you may learn what favor He grants you. He wants you to learn the greatness of His grace, so that you may praise Him fully, so that you may be slower to sin, and so that you may be quicker to pursue virtue. If you don't confess the greatness of your need, you won't understand the surpassing magnitude of His grace. "I don't require you," He says, "to come into the middle of the assembly before a crowd of witnesses. Confess the sin to Me alone in secret, so that I may heal the wound and remove the pain." This is why He has placed within us a conscience more faithful than a father. A father may warn his son once, twice, three times, or perhaps even ten times, but when he sees him remaining uncorrected, he publicly disowns him, dismisses him from the house, and severs the family bond. But conscience doesn't act this way. If it speaks once, twice, three times, or a thousand times and you don't obey, it will speak again and will not stop until your last breath. Both at home and in the street, at the table and in the marketplace, on the road, and often even in dreams, it places before us the image and appearance of our sins.

And even if you do not confess, He is not ignorant of the deed, who knew it before it was committed. Why then do you not speak of it? Does the transgression become heavier by the confession?—-nay, it becomes lighter and less troublesome. And it is for this reason that He would have you confess, not that you should be punished, but that you should be forgiven; not that He may learn thy sin, (how could this be, since He has seen it,) but that you may learn what favour He bestows. He wishes you to learn the greatness of His grace, that you may praise Him perfectly, that you may be slower to sin, that you may be quicker to virtue. And if you do not confess the greatness of the need, you will not understand the exceeding magnitude of His grace. I do not oblige you, He saith, to come into the midst of the assembly before a throng of witnesses; declare the sin in secret to Me only, that I may heal the sore and remove the pain. Therefore it is that He has placed within us a conscience more faithful than a father. For a father having warned his son once, or twice, or three times, or perhaps, ten times, when he sees him remaining uncorrected, publicly renounces him and dismisses him from the house, and severs the tie of relationship; but not so does conscience act. For if once, or twice, or thrice, or a thousand times it speaks, and you obey not, it will speak again, and will not cease until the latest breath; and both in the house and in the street, at table and in the market, and on the road, often even in dreams, it places before us the image and appearance of our sins.

Chapter 5

Look at the wisdom of God! He has made the reproach of conscience not constant (for if we were accused without pause, we could not bear the weight), nor has He made it so weak that it stops after one or two warnings. For if we felt self-condemnation every day and every hour, we would be overcome by grief. If, on the other hand, conscience warned us once or twice and then stopped rebuking us, we would not gain much benefit. Therefore He has made the warning lasting, but not constant: it is lasting so that we may not fall into carelessness, but so that always, to the end of our lives, being warned, we may remain watchful. Again, the warning is not constant, nor does it accumulate, so that we may not collapse under it, but so that we may be refreshed by periods of rest and other comforts. Thus complete freedom from mental pain would be destructive to sinners; it would produce in us total insensitivity; while, on the other hand, to feel this pain constantly and without limit would be even more harmful. For excessive sorrow, being often strong enough to overthrow a person's natural mental powers, overwhelms the soul and makes our good qualities entirely useless. For this reason God has made the convictions of conscience come upon us only at intervals, these convictions being extremely severe and often piercing the sinner more sharply than a goad. Not only when we ourselves have sinned, but also when others have committed the same acts, conscience is awakened and accuses us with great force. The fornicator, the adulterer, or the thief—not only when he himself is accused, but when he hears that others are accused of having dared the same sins—feels as if he himself were punished; he is reminded of his own sin by the blame thrown upon others; and though it is another who is accused, he himself, without being blamed, feels the charge, since he has dared to do the same things. In the same way, also, regarding good deeds, when others are praised and honored, those who have accomplished the same things rejoice with them, as though they were praised no less than the others. What, therefore, can be more miserable than the situation of the sinner who, as often as others are accused, himself feels ashamed? What, also, is more blessed than the lot of one who, living virtuously, whenever others are praised, himself feels joy and gladness, being reminded of his own good deeds by the praise bestowed upon others? These things are the work of God's wisdom; they are instances of His exceeding providence. The warning of conscience is a divine anchor, not allowing us to be completely wrecked in the abyss of iniquity.

Behold the wisdom of God! He has caused the reproof of conscience not to be unceasing, (for had we been constantly accused, we could not have endured the burden,) nor has He made it so weak as to cease after a first or second warning. For if we felt self-condemnation every day and every hour, we should have been overcome by sorrow. If, again, conscience having warned us once or twice, then ceased to rebuke, we should not have reaped much benefit. Therefore He has caused the warning to be lasting, but not unceasing: it is lasting, that we may not fall into negligence, but that always to the end of our life, being warned, we may be watchful. Again, the warning is not unceasing, nor made cumulative, in order that we may not sink under it, but that we may be refreshed by seasons of repose and other consolations. Thus complete freedom from mental pain would be ruinous to sinners; it would produce in us utter insensibility; while, on the other hand, to feel this pain unceasingly and without measure would be even more injurious. For excess of sorrow, being often strong enough to overthrow man's natural powers of mind, overwhelms the soul, and causes our good qualities to be wholly unserviceable. For this reason God has caused the convictions of conscience to be imposed on us only at intervals, these convictions being exceedingly severe, and often piercing the sinner more sharply than a goad. Not only at the time when we ourselves have sinned, but also when others have committed the same acts, conscience is roused, and with great vehemence accuses us. The fornicator, the adulturer, or the thief, not only when he himself is accused, but when he hears that others are accused of having dared the same sins, he feels as if he himself were punished; he is reminded of his own sin by the blame thrown upon others; and though it is another that is accused, he himself, without being blamed feels the charge, since he has dared to do the same things. In the same way, also, with regard to good deeds, when others are praised and honoured, those who have accomplished the same things rejoice with them, as though they were praised no less than the others. What, therefore, can be more miserable than the case of the sinner who, as often as others are accused, himself feels abashed? What, also, is more blessed than the lot of him who, living virtuously, whenever others are praised, himself feels joy and gladness, being reminded of his own good deeds by the praise bestowed upon others? These things are the work of God's wisdom; they are instances of His exceeding providence. The warning of conscience is a divine anchor, not permitting us to be altogether wrecked in the abyss of iniquity.

Not only when we commit the sin, but even after many years have passed, conscience can remind us of old faults. I will provide clear proof of this from the Scriptures themselves.

Not only at the time of committing the sin, but after long periods of years can conscience remind us of old faults. Of this I shall bring clear proof from the Scriptures themselves.

The brothers of Joseph once sold him, even though they had no charge to bring against him except that he foresaw in dreams his coming honor foreshadowed to him: for "I saw," he said, "your sheaves making obeisance to my sheaf" (Gen. 37:6). In fact, they should have cared for him all the more for this very reason, since he was to be the crown of the whole family and the glory of all his race. But this is what envy does: it makes war against its own honor. An envious person would rather suffer a thousand evils than see his neighbor honored, even if he himself would share in that honor. What could be more wretched than this? This kind of feeling possessed Joseph's brothers. Seeing him at a distance, coming to bring them provisions, they said to one another, "Come, let us kill him, and we shall see what will become of his dreams" (Gen. 37:20). Even if they had no regard for him as a brother and felt no natural bond, they should at least have respected the very help he brought and the manner of his service in coming to supply them with food. But notice how they unwittingly uttered a prophecy: "Come," they said, "let us kill him, and we shall see what will become of his dreams." If they had not plotted against him and concocted their treachery and planned that shameless scheme, they would not have experienced the full meaning of those dreams. For it was not likely that he, without meeting any misfortune, would rise as high as the throne of Egypt; yet through these difficulties and hindrances, he attained such a height of splendor. For if they had not conspired against him, they would not have sold him into Egypt; if they had not sold him into Egypt, the mistress would not have been infatuated with him; if the mistress had not been infatuated with him, he would not have been cast into prison, he would not have interpreted the dreams, he would not have been made ruler; if he had not been made ruler, the brothers would not have come to buy grain, nor would they have bowed down before him. Thus, precisely because they were ready to kill him, they themselves experienced the full meaning of the dreams. What then? Were they the ones who brought about all his future good and the cause of his glory? By no means. They were ready to expose him to death, or to grief, or to slavery—to the worst evils. But the God who rules over all used the wickedness of the conspirators for the testing and approval of the one who was sold and betrayed.

The brethren of Joseph one day sold him, without having any charge to bring against him, except that he foresaw in dreams his coming honour foreshadowed to him: for "I saw," said he, "your sheaves making obeisance to my sheaf," (Gen. xxxvii. 6.) Indeed, for this very thing they ought to have the more cared for him, for he was to be the crown of the whole family, and the glory of all his race. Such, however, is envy; it makes war against its own honour; and an envious man would rather suffer a thousand ills than see his neighbour renowned, even though a share of the renown were to fall to himself. Than this what can be more wretched? This kind of feeling possessed the brethren of Joseph. Seeing him at a distance, coming to bring them provisions, they said one to another, "Come, let us kill him, and we shall see what will become of his dreams," (Gen. xxxvii. 20.) If they had no regard for him as a brother, nor felt the bond of nature, they ought to have had regard to the very aid that he brought, and to the manner of his service, in coming to supply them with sustenance. But mark how they unwittingly uttered a prophecy: "Come," said they, "let us kill him, and we shall see what will become of his dreams." If they had not plotted against him and concocted treachery, and planned that shameless scheme, they would not have experienced the full intent of those dreams. For it was not likely that he, though meeting with no ill-fortune, would rise as high as the throne of Egypt; yet, by means of these difficulties and hindrances, he attained such a height of splendour. For if they had not conspired against him, they would not have sold him into Egypt; if they had not sold him into Egypt, the mistress would not have been enamoured of him; if the mistress had not been enamoured of him, he would not have been cast into prison, he would not have interpreted the dreams, he would not have been made ruler; if he had not been made ruler, the brethren would not have come to buy corn, nor have bowed down before him. Thus, since they were ready to kill him, for this very cause chiefly did they feel the full meaning of the dreams. What then? Were they the procurers of all his future good, and the cause of his glory? By no means; they were ready to expose him to death, or to sorrow, or to slavery—-to the uttermost ills. But the overruling God used the wickedness of the conspirators for the trial and approval of him who was sold and betrayed.

Chapter 6

So that you won't think this outcome happened by random chance or some accidental turn of events, God accomplished the very thing these opponents resisted by working through those same people who opposed it. He used His enemies to vindicate His servants so that you may learn that no one can prevent what God has determined, and no one can deflect His powerful hand. This way, whenever plots are made against you, you won't stumble or lose heart, but will be able to recognize that the conspiracy will ultimately result in good, as long as you endure your circumstances well.

In order that this result may not be thought to arise from any casual coincidence or accidental revolution of things, God, by means of the very men who opposed it, brought to pass the very result which they opposed, using His enemies for the approval of His servants, in order that you may learn, that what God has willed no one will hinder, and that none will turn aside His high hand; in order that whenever you are plotted against, you may not stumble or be downcast, but be enabled to know that the plot will result in good in the end, if only you bear your lot well.

Look, then, at how in this case envy produced a royal possession, how jealousy gained a crown for its victim and won him a throne. Those who plotted against him actually carried him forward to the height of his power. The one who was plotted against became the ruler, while those who plotted became servants. He received honor, they paid honor. Therefore, whenever troubles come upon you—frequent and piled up—do not be disturbed or discouraged, but endure to the end. The end will prove in every way worthy of God's kindness, if only you bear with gratitude whatever happens to you in the meantime.

Behold, therefore, in this instance, how envy produced a royal possession; how jealousy procured for its victim a crown, and gained him a throne; those who plotted against him, themselves bore him forward to the greatness of his power. He who was plotted against governed, they who plotted served; he received homage, they paid homage. Whensoever, therefore, ills, frequent and accumulated, come upon you, be not troubled nor downcast, but abide till the end. The end will turn out in every way worthy of the beneficence of God, if only you bear thankfully the things that in the meantime befall you.

The man who had these visions, while in extreme danger—sold by his brothers, wronged by his mistress, and then thrown into prison—did not say to himself, "What is all this? The visions were nothing but delusion! I am exiled from my country and stripped of freedom; because of my God, I have not given in to my mistress's seductions; because of self-control and virtue, I am punished, and He has not even in this situation defended me or reached out His hand, but has allowed me to be handed over to constant and increasing slavery. After the pit came slavery; after slavery, betrayal; after betrayal, false accusation; after false accusation, prison." But none of these things shook him; he remained firm in his hope, confident that none of the things that had been promised would ever fail.

He who had these visions, being in extreme danger, who was sold by his brethren, injured by his mistress, and again thrown into prison,—-he did not say within himself, "What is all this? The visions then are all delusion! I am an exile from my country and deprived of freedom; because of my God, I have not yielded to the seductions of my mistress; because of temperance and virtue, I am punished, and He has not even in this pass defended me, nor stretched forth. His hand, but has suffered me to be delivered to constant and increasing bondage. After the pit, slavery befell me; after slavery, treachery; after treachery, calumny; after calumny, a prison." But none of these things moved him; he remained steadfast in his hope, being confident that none of the things that had been promised would ever fail.

God was indeed able to fulfill everything on the very same day, but in order to display His own power and the faith of His servants, He allowed a long time to pass and many obstacles to arise. This was so that you may understand His power by His fulfilling the promises at the very moment when you would give in to despair, and that you may see the patience and faith of His servants by their not falling away from their expectation of good in the very midst of calamities.

God was, indeed, able to fulfil everything on the very same day; but in order to display His own might and the faith of His servants, he permitted a long time to intervene, and many hindrances to arise, so that you may understand His power, by His fulfilling the promises at the very time when you would give way to despair, and that you may see the patience and faith of His servants, by their not falling away from their expectation of good in the very midst of calamities.

However, as I said, the patriarchs came again, with famine driving them by force like an armed soldier and pushing them into the presence of Joseph, the governor. They wanted to buy grain. What, then, did he say to them? "You are spies." They said to themselves, "What is this! We came to get food, and we have put our lives in danger!" Yes, justly!—since he also came to you bringing food, and you put his life in danger. And he endured it then because of his integrity; you are suffering now because of hypocrisy. He was not, however, their enemy; he put on the appearance of hostility so that he might learn accurately the condition of the family. For since they had been wicked and heartless in his own case, and not seeing Benjamin with them, he feared for the child, lest he had also been a brother in suffering. He commands that one of them should be bound and left there, and that all the rest should take their grain and depart, threatening them with death if they did not bring back their other brother.

However, as I said, the patriarchs came again, famine as an armed soldier driving them by force, and urging them to the presence of Joseph, the governor; and they wished to buy corn. What, then, did he say to them? "Ye are spies." They then said within themselves, "What is this! we came to get food, and we have endangered our life!" Yes, justly!—-since he also came to you bringing food, and ye put him in danger of his life. And he then endured it beeause of his integrity; ye now are suffering because of hypocrisy. He was not, however, their enemy; he put on the appearance of hostility, that he might learn accurately the condition of the family. For since they had been wicked and heartless in his own case, not seeing Benjamin with them, he feared for the child, lest he had been also a brother in suffering. He commands that some one of them should be bound and left there; and that all the rest taking their corn should depart, threatening them with death if they should not bring back their other brother.

Since this had happened and he had said, "Leave one here, and bring back the other brother, or you shall die," what did they say to one another? "Truly we were guilty concerning our brother when he begged us." Do you see after how long a time they remember that crime? They had said to their father, "A wild beast has devoured him." Now, when Joseph himself is present and listening, they lament their crime. What can be more remarkable than this? Without a court, there is conviction; without accusation, a defense; proof without testimony; the very men who committed the deed condemn themselves and make public what was done in secret! Who had persuaded them or forced them to expose publicly the things they had dared so long ago? Is it not clear that conscience, the inexorable judge, had been constantly disturbing their thoughts and troubling their soul? He who had been murderously treated also sat there silently judging them; and while no one brought any charge against them, they themselves passed sentence upon themselves.

Since, then, this had happened and he had said, "Leave one here, and bring back the other brother, or ye shall die," what did they say one to another? "Verily we were guilty concerning our brother when he besought us." Do you observe after how long time they remember that crime? They then said to their father, "An evil beast hath devoured him," (Gen. xxxvii. 33.) Now, when Joseph himself is present and listening, they bewail their crime. What can be more extraordinary than this? Without a tribunal, there is conviction; without accusation, an apology; a proof without testimony; the very men who wrought the deed condemn themselves, and publish abroad that which was done in secret! Who had persuaded them, or obliged them, to expose in public the things dared so long before? Is it not plain that conscience, the inexorable judge, had been constantly disturbing their thoughts and troubling their soul? He also who had been murderously treated, sat there silently judging them; and while no one brought any charge against them, they themselves passed sentence upon themselves.

They spoke among themselves this way. Another one also spoke in his defense: "Didn't I tell you not to sin against the child or harm him, since he is our brother? And now his blood is required from us." Even though no one actually spoke this way or said anything about the crime or murder, and even though the victim himself, sitting there before them, asked nothing about such things but was only asking about the other brother, their conscience seized the opportunity, took control of their minds, and forced them to confess their deeds when no one was accusing them.

They spake thus among themselves: another also said in excuse: "Spake I not to you saying, Do not sin against the child, nor do him any harm, for he is our brother? and, behold, now his blood is required at our hands," (Gen. xlii. 22, loosely quoted.) Though there was no one who spoke thus, or said anything concerning the crime, or of murder; though the victim himself, sitting in their presence, inquired about no such thing, but rather was asking about the other brother; their conscience, taking advantage of the opportunity, arose and took possession of their mind, and when no person accused them, obliged them to confess their deeds.

We ourselves often experience such things when our sins are long past. When we are tested by suffering or misfortune, we recall our former wrongdoings.

Such things we ourselves often suffer, when the sins are long gone by. When we are searched by woe or misfortune, we call to mind our former ill-doings.

Chapter 7

Since we know all these things, whenever we commit any sin, let us not wait for disaster or hardship, for danger or imprisonment. Instead, let us set up this tribunal for ourselves at every hour of the day, and let us pass judgment on ourselves, and try in every way to make peace with God. Let us not have doubts about the resurrection and the future judgment, nor let ourselves be held back by what others say. Rather, by all means, according to the truths we have learned, let us refute them. For if we were not going to give an account for everything we have done, God would not have established such a tribunal within us. But this too is proof of His kindness. Since He will later require from us an account of our sins, He has placed this incorruptible judge within us, so that by condemning us for our sins now and making us wiser, He may save us from the future judgment. This is also what Saint Paul says: "For if we would judge ourselves, we should not be judged by the Lord" (1 Corinthians 11:31). Therefore, so that we may not be punished then, nor pay the penalty then, let each of us turn to his conscience. Let him unroll his past life and carefully examine all his faults. Let him condemn the soul that did such deeds. Let him discipline his thoughts. Let him be afflicted. Let him be troubled in his own mind. Let him demand from himself a penalty for his sins through self-condemnation, through complete repentance, through tears, through confession, through fasting and almsgiving, through self-control and love. Let us do this so that by every means available to us we may be able, with complete confidence, to reach the future kingdom, which may it be the destiny of us all to obtain by the grace and goodness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father be glory, and also to the Holy Spirit, forever and ever. Amen.

Knowing, therefore, all these things, whenever we have done any wrong, let us not wait for calamity or difficulty, for danger and chains; but let us each hour of the day set up for ourselves this tribunal, and let us pass judgment against ourselves, and endeavour in every way to make our peace with God. Let us not doubt about the resurrection and future judgment, nor be hindered by what others say; but by all means, according to the truths we have learnt, let us refute them. For if we were not to render account of all we have done, God would not have set up such a tribunal within us. But this also is a proof of His kindness. For since He will hereafter require from us an account of our sins, He has placed this incorruptible judge within us, that by condemning us for our sins now and making us wiser, He may rescue us from the future judgment. This also St Paul saith: "For if we would judge ourselves, we should not be judged by the Lord," (1 Cor. xi. 31.) In order, therefore, that we may not be punished then, nor pay the penalty then, let each of us betake himself to conscience; and unrolling his past life, and examining with care all his faults, let him condemn the soul that wrought such deeds; let him chastise his thoughts; let him be afflicted; let him be straitened in his own mind; let him require a penalty from himself for his sins, by self-condemnation, by thorough penitence, by tears, by confession, by fasting and alms-giving, by temperance and love. Let us do this that by all means in our power we may be able, with all confidence, to attain the future kingdom, which may it be the lot of us all to gain by the grace and goodness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father be glory, and also to the Holy Spirit, for ever and ever. Amen.


Four Discourses on the Rich Man and Lazarus — Discourse 3

On reading the Scriptures at home, why Abraham says ‘thou receivedst’ and not ‘thou hadst’, and why the just often suffer while the wicked prosper.

Source: John Chrysostom, Four discourses, chiefly on the parable of the Rich man and Lazarus (1869) Discourse 3. pp.59-89.. Transcribed by Roger Pearse (tertullian.org); public domain.

Contents · 11 chapters
  1. Discourse 3
  2. Chapter 1
  3. Chapter 2
  4. Chapter 3
  5. Chapter 4
  6. Chapter 5
  7. Chapter 6
  8. Chapter 7
  9. Chapter 8
  10. Chapter 9
  11. Chapter 10

Discourse 3

Concerning Lazarus – Concerning reading the Scriptures – The reason why it is not said, "You had," but "You received" – Why is it that the just often fall into troubles, while the wicked escape them?

CONCERNING LAZARUS—- CONCERNING READING THE SCRIPTURES —- THE REASON WHY IT IS NOT SAID, "THOU HADST," BUT "THOU RECEIVEDST "—-WHY IS IT THAT THE JUST OFTEN FALL INTO TROUBLES, WHILE THE WICKED ESCAPE THEM?

Chapter 1

The parable about Lazarus has benefited us greatly, both rich and poor, teaching the poor to endure poverty well and preventing the rich from being proud of their wealth. It shows, by the details of the story, that the person most to be pitied is the one who lives in luxury without sharing his wealth with others. Let me take up the same subject again, since those who work in mines, wherever they find many grains of gold, dig there again and do not stop until they have gathered all they can find. Let us continue, then, and pick up where we left off yesterday. It would be possible to explain the whole parable to you in a single day, but we do not aim to leave having said a great deal. Rather, we want you to receive and remember what has been said, so that through this careful attention you may gain real spiritual benefit. A caring mother who is changing her child's food from milk to solid diet would harm the child if she immediately gave it unmixed wine, for the child would reject the new food at once. She feeds it little by little, and in this way the new nourishment is received without trouble. So that you will not grow weary of the food being offered, we do not pour out the cup of instruction to you all at once without preparation. Instead, by spreading the teaching over several days, we give you time to rest from the work of listening, so that what has been said may be firmly fixed in your mind and heart, and you may receive what is to come with constant and growing eagerness.

The parable about Lazarus has benefited us not a little, both rich and poor, teaching the latter to bear poverty well, and not allowing the former to think highly of their riches; but showing, by the circumstances of the case, that he is of all men to be most pitied who lives in luxury without sharing his wealth with others. Allow me again to take up the same subject; since, also, those who work in mines, wherever they see many grains of gold, there they dig again, and do not cease until they have gathered out all that can be found. Let us, therefore, proceed, and, at the place where we left off yesterday, there again recommence the discourse. It might be possible, indeed, to unfold to you the whole parable in a single day; but we do not strive to be able to depart with the feeling that we have said a great deal, but that you, having received and retained the things spoken, may be able, through this carefulness, to gain a sense of real spiritual benefit. A tender mother about to change the food of her child from milk to more solid diet, if she were at once to give it unmixed wine would injure it, for the child would at once reject the new diet. She feeds it little by little, and thus the new nourishment is received without trouble. In order that you may not feel distaste for the offered food, we do not without preparation pour out to you from the cup of instruction; but distributing the portion over several days, we give an interval of repose from the toil of hearing, that both that which has been said may be firmly fixed in your understanding and in your heart, and that you may receive that which is about to be said with constant and increasing zeal.

This is why I often announce several days ahead of time what subject we're going to discuss, so that in the time between you can take a book and read through the entire passage. By noticing what has been stated and what has been left out, you'll be better prepared to understand more clearly what will be said.

Thus I often state several days beforehand the subject about to be considered, in order that, in the intervening time, you may take a book and go through the whole passage; and, noticing what has been stated and what reserved, you may be prepared to hear more intelligently that which is to be said.

I am constantly urging this, and I will not stop urging it: pay attention not only to the words spoken here, but also, when you are at home in your house, exercise yourselves continually in reading the Divine Scriptures. I have never stopped emphasizing this to those who come to me privately. Let no one say to me that these exhortations are pointless and irrelevant, claiming, "I am constantly busy in the courts; I am carrying out public duties; I am engaged in some art or craft; I have a wife; I am raising children; I have to manage a household; I am occupied with worldly business; reading the Scriptures is not for me, but for those who have renounced the world, for those who live on the mountaintops, those who constantly lead a withdrawn life." What are you saying? Is it not for you to pay attention to the Scriptures because you are caught up in many concerns? It is your duty even more than theirs, for they do not need the help from the Holy Scriptures as much as those who are engaged in much business. For those who lead a solitary life, who are free from business and from the anxiety that comes from business, who have made their home in the wilderness and have no dealings with anyone, but who meditate at their leisure on wisdom in the peace that comes from rest—they, like those who are anchored in the harbor, enjoy abundant security. But we, who are tossed about as if in the middle of the sea, cannot avoid many failures, and we constantly need the immediate and continual comfort of the Scriptures. They rest far from the battle, and therefore escape many wounds; but you stand continually in the battle line and are constantly liable to be wounded. For this reason, you need the healing remedies even more. For suppose a wife provokes you, a son causes grief, a slave arouses your anger, an enemy plots against you, a friend is envious, a neighbor is insulting, a fellow-soldier causes you to stumble—or often, perhaps, a judge threatens you, poverty pains you, or loss of property troubles you, or prosperity puffs you up, or misfortune overwhelms you. There are surrounding us on all sides many causes and occasions for anger, many for anxiety, many for dejection or grief, many for vanity or pride. From all directions, weapons are aimed at us. Therefore we continually need the whole armor of the Scriptures. For it says, "Understand that you pass through the midst of snares and walk on the battlements of a city" (Sirach 9:13). The lusts of the flesh also afflict more severely those who are engaged in the midst of business. For a noble appearance and beautiful form gain power over us through the eyes, and wicked words, entering through the ears, trouble our thoughts. Often, also, a well-tuned song softens the resolve of the mind. But why do I say these things? For what seems weaker than all these—even the scent of perfumes from the promiscuous crowd we encounter—falls upon our senses, captivates us, and by this chance occurrence we are taken captive.12

This, also, I am ever urging, and shall not cease to urge, that you give attention, not only to the words spoken, but that also, when at home in your house, you exercise yourselves constantly in reading the Divine Scriptures. This, also, I have never ceased to press upon those who come to me privately. Let not any one say to me that these exhortations are vain and irrelevant, for "I am constantly busy in the courts," (suppose him to say;) "I am discharging public duties; I am engaged in some art or handiwork; I have a wife; I am bringing up my children; I have to manage a household; I am full of worldly business; it is not for me to read the Scriptures, but for those who have bid adieu to the world, for those who dwell on the summit of the hills; those who constantly lead a secluded life." What dost thou say, O man? Is it not for thee to attend to the Scriptures, because thou art involved in numerous cares? It is thy duty even more than theirs, for they do not so much need the aid to be derived from the Holy Scriptures as they do who are engaged in much business. For those who lead a solitary life, who are free from business and from the anxiety arising from business, who have pitched their tent in the wilderness, and have no communion with any one, but who meditate at leisure on wisdom, in that peace that springs from repose—- they, like those who lie in the harbour, enjoy abundant security. But ourselves, who, as it were, are tossed in the midst of the sea, cannot avoid many failings, we ever stand in need of the immediate and constant comfort of the Scriptures. They rest far from the strife, and, therefore, escape many wounds; but you stand perpetually in the array of battle, and constantly are liable to be wounded: on this account, you have more need of the healing remedies. For, suppose, a wife provokes, a son causes grief, a slave excites to anger, an enemy plots against us, a friend is envious, a neighbour is insolent, a fellow-soldier causes us to stumble—-or often, perhaps, a judge threatens us, poverty pains us, or loss of property causes us trouble, or prosperity puffs us up, or misfortune overthrows us;—-there are surrounding us on all sides many causes and occasions of anger, many of anxiety, many of dejection or grief, many of vanity or pride; from all quarters, weapons are pointed at us. Therefore it is that there is need continually of the whole armour of the Scriptures. For, "understand," it says, "that thou passest through the midst of snares, and walkest on the battlements of a city," (Ecclus. ix. 13.) The lusts of the flesh also more grievously afflict those who are engaged in the midst of business. For a noble appearance and beautiful person gain power over us through the eyes; and wicked words, entering by the cars, trouble our thoughts. Often, also, a well-modulated song softens the constancy of the mind. But why do I say these things'? For that which seems to be weaker than all these, even the odour of sweet scents from the meretricious throng with whom we meet, falling upon the senses, entrances us, and, by this chance accident, we are made captive.12

Chapter 2

Many other things like this trouble our souls. We need divine remedies to heal wounds already inflicted and to prevent those that would otherwise come in the future—extinguishing Satan's arrows from a distance and protecting ourselves through constant reading of the Divine Scriptures. It is not possible—I say, it is not possible—for anyone to be safe without a steady supply of this spiritual instruction. In fact, we should count ourselves fortunate if, by constantly using this remedy, we are ever able to attain salvation. But when we receive wounds every day yet use no remedies, what hope can there be for salvation?34

Many other such things there are that beset our soul; and we have need of the divine remedies that we may heal wounds inflicted, and ward off those which, though not inflicted, would else be received in time to come—-thus quenching afar off the darts of Satan, and shielding ourselves by the constant reading of the Divine Scriptures. It is not possible—-I say, it is not possible, for any one to be secure without constant supplies of this spiritual instruction. Indeed, we may congratulate ourselves, if, constantly using this remedy, we ever are able to attain salvation. But when, though each day receiving wounds, we make use of no remedies, what hope can there be of salvation?34

Don't you see that workers in brass, goldsmiths, silversmiths, or those who practice any craft whatsoever carefully preserve all the tools of their trade? When hunger comes or poverty strikes them, they prefer to endure anything rather than sell any of the tools they use to support themselves. It frequently happens that many choose instead to borrow money to maintain their household and family rather than part with even the smallest of their tools. They do this for the best reasons, because they know that once those are sold, all their skill becomes useless and the entire foundation of their income is gone. If the tools remain, they may be able, by continuing to practice their craft, eventually to pay off their debts. But if they allow the tools to pass to others in the meantime, there is no way in the future by which they can find any relief from their poverty and hunger. We also ought to think in the same way. Just as the tools of their trade are the hammer, anvil, and tongs, so the tools of our work are the apostolic and prophetic books and all the inspired and profitable Scriptures. And just as they, by their tools, shape all the items they work on, so we also, by our tools, arm our mind, strengthen it when it is weak, and restore it when it is not functioning properly. Again, craftsmen display their skill in beautiful forms, being unable to change the material of what they produce or to transform silver into gold, but only to make their designs symmetrical. But it is not so with you, for you have a power beyond theirs—receiving a vessel of wood, you can make it gold. And Saint Paul testifies to this, speaking thus: "In a great house there are not only vessels of gold and of silver, but also of wood and of earth. If a man therefore purge himself from these, he shall be a vessel unto honour, sanctified and meet for the master's use, and prepared unto every good work" (2 Timothy 2:20–21). Let us then not neglect the possession of the sacred books, so that we receive no fatal injuries. Let us not hoard gold, but lay up these inspired books as our treasures. For gold, whenever it becomes abundant, causes trouble to its owners, but these books, when carefully preserved, provide great benefit to those who possess them. Just as where royal weapons are stored, even if no one uses them, they provide great security to those who live there—since neither thieves nor burglars nor any other evildoers dare attack that place—in the same way, where the inspired books are, all satanic influence is banished from there, and the great consolation of right principles comes to those who live there. Yes, even the very sight of these books by itself makes us less inclined to commit sin. Even if we attempt any forbidden thing and defile ourselves, when we return home and see these books, our conscience accuses us more sharply, and we become less likely to fall again into the same sins. Again, if we have been steadfast in our integrity, we gain even more benefit (if we are familiar with the word). For as soon as one comes to the gospel, by a mere look one both corrects one's understanding and stops dwelling on all worldly concerns. And if careful reading also follows, the soul, as if initiated in sacred mysteries, is thereby purified and made better, while holding conversation with God through the Scriptures.5

Do you not notice that workmen in brass, or goldsmiths, or silversmiths, or those who engage in any art whatsoever, preserve carefully all the instruments of their art; and if hunger come, or poverty afflict them, they prefer to endure anything rather than sell for their maintenance any of the tools which they use. It is frequently the case that many thus choose rather to borrow money to maintain their house and family, than part with the least of the instruments of their art. This they do for the best reasons; for they know that when those are sold, all their skill is rendered of no avail, and the entire groundwork of their gain is gone. If those are left, they may be able, by persevering in the exercise of their skill, in time to pay off their debts; but if they, in the meantime, allow the tools to go to others, there is, for the future, no means by which they can contrive any alleviation of their poverty and hunger. We also ought to judge in the same way. As the instruments of their art are the hammer and anvil and pincers, so the instruments of our work are the apostolic and prophetic books, and all the inspired and profitable Scriptures. And as they, by their instruments, shape all the articles they take in hand, so also do we, by our instruments, arm our mind, and strengthen it when relaxed, and renew it when out of condition. Again, artists display their skill in beautiful forms, being unable to change the material of their productions, or to transmute silver into gold, but only to make their figures symmetrical. But it is not so with thee, for thou hast a power beyond theirs—-receiving a vessel of wood, thou canst make it gold. And to this St Paul testifies, speaking thus: "In a great house there are not only vessels of gold and of silver, but also of wood and of earth. If a man therefore purge himself from these, he shall be a vessel unto honour, sanctified and meet for the master's use, and prepared unto every good work," (2 Tim. ii. 20, 21.) Let us then not neglect the possession of the sacred books, that we receive no fatal injuries. Let us not hoard gold, but lay up, as our treasures, these inspired books. For gold, whenever it becomes abundant, causes trouble to its possessors; but these books, when carefully preserved, afford great benefit to those who possess them. As also where royal arms are stored, though no one should use them, they afford great security to those who dwell there; since neither thieves nor burglars, nor any other evil-doers, dare attack that place. In the same way, where the inspired books are, from thence all satanical influence is banished, and the great consolation of right principles comes to those who live there; yea, even the very sight of these books by itself makes us slower to commit iniquity. Even if we attempt any forbidden thing, and make ourselves unclean, when we return home and see these books, our conscience accuses us more keenly, and we become less likely to fall again into the same sins. Again, if we have been steadfast in our integrity, we gain more benefit, (if we are acquainted with the word;) for as soon as one comes to the gospel, he by a mere look both rectifies his understanding and ceases from all worldly cares. And if careful reading also follows, the soul, as if initiated in sacred mysteries, is thus purified and made better, while holding converse with God through the Scriptures.5

"But what," they say, "if we do not understand the things we read?" Even if you do not understand the contents, your sanctification is greatly advanced by it. However, it is impossible that all these things should be equally misunderstood, for it was for this reason that the grace of the Holy Spirit ordained that tax collectors, fishermen, tent-makers, shepherds, goatherds, and uneducated and illiterate men should write these books—so that no untaught person should be able to make this excuse. The purpose was that the things delivered should be easily understood by all, so that the craftsman, the servant, the widow, and even the most unlearned of all people should profit and benefit from the reading. For it was not for empty glory, as worldly men do, but for the salvation of the hearers, that they composed these writings—these men who from the beginning were endowed with the gift of the Holy Spirit.

"But what," say they, "if we do not understand the things we read?" Even if you do not understand the contents, your sanctification in a high degree results from it. However, it is impossible that all these things should alike be misunderstood; for it was for this reason that the grace of the Holy Spirit ordained that tax-gatherers, and fishermen, and tent-makers, and shepherds, and goatherds, and uninstructed and illiterate men, should compose these books, that no untaught man should be able to make this pretext; in order that the things delivered should be easily comprehended by all—-in order that the handicraftsman, the domestic, the widow, yea, the most unlearned of all men, should profit and be benefited by the reading. For it is not for vain-glory, as men of the world, but for the salvation of the hearers, that they composed these writings, who, from the beginning, were endued with the gift of the Holy Ghost.

Chapter 3

Those without—philosophers, rhetoricians, and historians who were not working for the common good but seeking their own fame—even when they said something useful, they wrapped it in their typical obscurity, as if in a cloud. But the apostles and prophets always did the exact opposite. As the common teachers of the world, they made everything they taught clear to everyone, so that anyone, even without help, could understand simply by reading. This is what the prophet meant when he said earlier, "All shall be taught of God" (Isaiah 54:13), and "They shall no more say, every one to his neighbor, Know the Lord, for they shall all know me from the least to the greatest" (Jeremiah 31:34). Saint Paul also says, "And I, brethren, when I came to you, came not with excellency of speech, or of wisdom, declaring unto you the mystery of God" (1 Corinthians 2:1). And again, "My speech and my preaching was not with enticing words of man's wisdom, but in demonstration of the Spirit and of power" (1 Corinthians 2:4). And again, "We speak wisdom," he says, "but not the wisdom of this world, nor of the princes of this world that come to nought" (1 Corinthians 2:6). For who does not find the gospel plain? Who hears "Blessed are the meek; blessed are the merciful; blessed are the pure in heart," and such things, and needs a teacher to understand what is being said?

For those without—-philosphers, rhetoricians, and annalists, not striving for the common good, but having in view their own renown—-if they said anything useful, even this they involved in their usual obscurity, as in a cloud. But the apostles and prophets always did the very opposite; they, as the common instructors of the world, made all that they delivered plain to all men, in order that every one, even unaided, might be able to learn by the mere reading. Thus also the prophet spake before, when he said, "All shall be taught of God," (Isa. liv. 13.) "And they shall no more say, every one to his neighbour, Know the Lord, for they shall all know me from the least to the greatest," (Jer. xxxi. 34.) St Paul also says, "And I, brethren, when I came to you, came not with excellency of speech, or of wisdom, declaring unto you the mystery of God," (1 Cor. ii. 1.) And again, "My speech and my preaching was not with enticing words of man's wisdom, but in demonstration of the Spirit and of power," (1 Cor. ii. 4.) And again, "We speak wisdom," it is said, "but not the wisdom of this world, nor of the princes of this world that come to nought," (1 Cor. ii. 6.) For to whom is not the gospel plain? Who is it that hears, "Blessed are the meek; blessed are the merciful; blessed are the pure in heart," and such things as these, and needs a teacher in order to understand any of the things spoken?

But are the parts containing the signs and wonders and histories also clear and plain to everyone? This is just a pretense, an excuse, and a mere cover for laziness. You don't understand what's in the book? But how can you ever understand when you're not even willing to look carefully? Take the book in your hand. Read the whole history, and while keeping the easy parts in mind, read through the doubtful and obscure parts frequently. If you're unable to understand what is said through repeated reading, go to someone wiser. Find yourself a teacher and discuss with him what is said. Show great eagerness to learn. Then, when God sees that you are exercising such diligence, He will not ignore your perseverance and carefulness. But if no human being can teach you what you're trying to learn, He Himself will reveal the whole thing.

But (it is asked) are the parts containing the signs and wonders and histories also clear and plain to every one? This is a pretence, and an excuse, and a mere cloak of idleness. You do not understand the contents of the book? But how can you ever understand, while you are not even willing to look carefully? Take the book in your hand. Read the whole history; and, retaining in your mind the easy parts, peruse frequently the doubtful and obscure parts; and if you are unable, by frequent reading, to understand what is said, go to some one wiser; betake yourself to a teacher; confer with him about the things said. Show great eagerness to learn: then, when God sees that you are using such diligence, He will not disregard your perseverance and carefulness; but if no human being can teach you that which you seek to know, He himself will reveal the whole.

Remember the eunuch of the queen of Ethiopia. He was a man from a foreign nation, busy with many responsibilities and surrounded on every side by all kinds of business, and he was unable to understand what he was reading. Still, even as he sat in the chariot, he was reading. If he showed such diligence on a journey, think how diligent he must have been at home. If while traveling he did not let an opportunity pass without reading, how much more must this have been true when he was sitting in his house. If even when he did not fully understand what he was reading he did not stop reading, how much more would he not stop when he was able to understand. To show that he did not understand what he was reading, listen to what Philip said to him: "Do you understand what you are reading?" (Acts 8:30). When he heard this question he did not become irritated or ashamed, but confessed his ignorance and said: "How can I, unless someone guides me?" (verse 31). Since he was reading this way even when he had no one to guide him, for this reason he quickly received a teacher. God knew his willingness, He recognized his zeal, and immediately sent him a teacher.

Remember the eunuch of the queen of Ethiopia. Being a man of a barbarous nation, occupied with numerous cares, and surrounded on all sides by manifold business, he was unable to understand that which he read. Still, however, as he was seated in the chariot, he was reading. If he showed such diligence on a journey, think how diligent he must have been at home: if while on the road he did not let an opportunity pass without reading, much more must this have been the case when seated in his house; if when he did not fully understand the things he read, he did not cease from reading, much more would he not cease when able to understand. To show that he did not understand the things which he read, hear that which Philip said to him: "Understandest thou what thou readest?" (Acts viii. 30.) Hearing this question he did not show provocation or shame: but confessed his ignorance, and said: "How can I, except some man should guide me?" (ver. 31.) Since therefore, while he had no man to guide him, he was thus reading; for this reason, he quickly received an instructor. God knew his willingness, He acknowledged his zeal, and forthwith sent him a teacher.

But you say that Philip is not present with us now. Still, the Spirit that moved Philip is present with us. Let us not, beloved, neglect our own salvation! "All these things are written for our admonition upon whom the ends of the world are come" (1 Cor. x. 11). Reading the Scriptures is a great safeguard against sin; ignorance of the Scriptures is a great cliff and a deep chasm. To know nothing of the Scriptures is a great betrayal of our salvation. This ignorance is the cause of heresies; it leads to immoral living; it makes everything confused. It is impossible—I say, it is impossible—for anyone to remain without benefit who engages in persistent and thoughtful reading. For see how much one parable has profited us! How much spiritual good it has done us! I know well that many have left here taking with them lasting profit from what they heard. And even if there are some who have not gained as much benefit, still on that day when they heard these things, they were made better in every way. And it is not a small thing to spend one day in sorrow on account of sin, in consideration of higher wisdom, and in giving the soul a little breathing space from worldly cares. If we can accomplish this at each assembly without interruption, the continued hearing would produce for us a great and lasting benefit.

But, you say, Philip is not present with us now. Still, the Spirit that moved Philip is present with us. Let us not, beloved, neglect our own salvation! "All these things are written for our admonition upon whom the ends of the world are come," (1 Cor. x. 11.) The reading of the Scriptures is a great safeguard against sin; ignorance of the Scriptures is a great precipice and a deep gulf; to know nothing of the Scriptures, is a great betrayal of our salvation. This ignorance is the cause of heresies; this it is that leads to dissolute living; this it is that makes all things confused. It is impossible—-I say, it is impossible, that any one should remain unbenefited who engages in persevering and intelligent reading. For see how much one parable has profited us! how much spiritual good it has done us! For many I know well have departed, bearing away abiding profit from the hearing; and if there be some who have not reaped so much benefit, still for that day on which they heard these things, they were rendered in every way better. And it is not a small thing to spend one day in sorrow on account of sin, and in consideration of the higher wisdom, and in affording the soul a little breathing time from wordly cares. If we can effect this at each assembly without intermission, the continued hearing would work for us a great and lasting benefit.

Chapter 4

Let me deliver to you the rest of this parable. What comes next? After the rich man said, "Send Lazarus so he may dip the tip of his finger in water and cool my tongue," let us listen to Abraham's reply. "Son, remember that you received your good things in your lifetime, and likewise Lazarus received evil things, but now he is comforted and you are tormented. And besides all this, between us and you there is a great gulf fixed, so that those who would pass from here to you cannot, nor can they pass to us from there." These words are hard to bear and cause us grief. I know that the benefit received by the wounded mind is proportional to the wounds inflicted by conscience. For if these things were said to us in the next world, as they were to this rich man, we would truly have to lament and mourn and grieve, since time for repentance would no longer be left to us. But since we hear these things here, where it is possible to become wise and to purge away our sins and gain great confidence, and, fearing the evils that have befallen others, to repent—let us give thanks to the good God, who stirs up our sluggishness and wakes us from our slumber by the punishment of others. These things are foretold for this reason: so that we may not suffer the same. If God wished to punish us, He would not have foretold these things. But since He does not wish us to fall into punishment, He foretells the punishment for this reason: so that being made wise by the warning, we may escape the experience of such things.

Let me then deliver to you the remainder of this parable. What is it that follows? The rich man having said, "Send Lazarus that he may dip the tip of his finger in water and cool my tongue," let us listen to that which Abraham says in reply. "Son, remember that thou in thy lifetime receivedst thy good things, and likewise Lazarus evil things: but now he is comforted, and thou art tormented. And besides all this, between us and you there is a great gulf fixed: so that they which would pass from hence to you cannot; neither can they pass to us from thence," (Luke xvi. 25, 26.) These words are heavy to bear and cause us grief. I know, indeed, that in proportion to the wounds inflicted by conscience, is the benefit received by the wounded mind. For if it were in the next world that these things were said to us, as they were to this rich man, truly should we have to lament, and mourn, and grieve, since time of repentance would no longer have been left us; but since we hear these things here, where it is possible to become wise, and to purge away our sins, and gain great confidence, and, fearing the evils that have befallen others, to repent,—-let us give thanks to the good God, who, by the punishment of others, stirs up our sluggishness and wakes us from our slumber. For this reason it is that these things are foretold, in order that we may not suffer the same. If God wished to punish us, He would not have foretold these things; but since He does not wish that we should fall into punishment, for this reason He foretells the punishment, that being made wise by the warning, we may escape experience of such things.

But why does Abraham not say, "You had your good things," but "you received them back"? You remember, I think, that I said a vast and boundless sea of thought is opened before us here. For the word "received back" suggests and intimates the idea of debt; for anyone receives back what is owed to him. If then this rich man was wicked, indeed most wicked, cruel, or inhuman, why is it not said to him, "You had your good things," but "you received them back," as if it implied things deserved by or owed to him? What then do we learn from this? That some people, even wicked people, even those who have gone to the very extreme of wickedness, may often have done one, or two, or three good things. And that this statement is not mere conjecture is plain from the following case. For what greater wickedness could exist than that of the unjust judge? What could be more inhuman, what more impious? This man neither feared God nor regarded men. Still, though living in such wickedness, he performed one good act, namely, having pity on the widow who constantly troubled him; yielding to grace and granting her request and proceeding against those who troubled her. Thus it also happens that a man may be intemperate and at the same time often merciful; or he may be cruel but also sober; and if he is both intemperate and cruel, still, often in the business of life, he may do some good deed. And similarly we ought to think of the good. For just as the most depraved people often do some useful thing, so also the zealous and honorable often commit sin in some respect. "For who," it is said, "can boast that he has a clean heart, or who can say that he is free from iniquity?"

But why does Abraham not say, "Thou hadst " ( ἔλαβες) "thy good things," but "thou receivedst " ( ἀπέλαβες)? You remember, I dare say, that I said that here a vast and boundless sea of thought is opened before us. For the word ( ἀπέλαβες) receivedst suggests and intimates the idea of debt; for any one receives ( ἀπολάμβανει) that which is owing to him. If then this rich man was wicked, yea, most wicked, cruel, or inhuman, why is it not said to him," Thou hadst " ( ἔλαβες) "thy good things," but "thou receivedst " ( ἀπέλαβες), as if it implied things deserved by, or owed to him? What then do we learn from this? That some men, even wicked men, even those who have proceeded to the very extremity of wickedness, may often have done one, or two, or three good things. And that this statement is not mere conjecture is plain, from the following case. For what greater wickedness could exist than that of the unjust judge? What could be more inhuman, what more impious? This man neither feared God nor regarded men, (Luke xviii. 2.) Still, though living in such wickedness, he performed one good act, namely, the having pity on the widow who constantly troubled him; the yielding to grace, and granting her request, and proceeding against those who troubled her. Thus also it happens that a man may be intemperate, and at the same time often merciful; or he may be cruel, but also sober; and if he be both intemperate and cruel, still, often in the business of life, he may do some good deed. And similarly we ought to think of the good. For as the most depraved of men often do some useful thing, so also the zealous and honourable often commit sin in some respect. "For who," it is said, "can boast that he has a clean heart, or who can say that he is free from iniquity?" (Prov. xx. 9.)

Since it was likely that the rich man, even though he had reached the height of wickedness, had done some good work, and that Lazarus, even though he had reached the summit of virtue, had committed some sin, notice how the patriarch hints at both these things when he says, "You, in your lifetime, received your good things, and likewise Lazarus evil things." What he says means this: "If you also did good, and a reward was owed to you for that, you received all this reward in that life when you lived in luxury and wealth, enjoying great prosperity and success. This man, Lazarus, if he did anything wrong, has received the full equivalent in poverty and hunger, being oppressed with the most extreme evils. Each of you has arrived here free—this man from his sins, and you from righteous works. Therefore, he has unmixed consolation—you endure unrelieved punishment."

Since, therefore, it was likely that the rich man, though he had proceeded to the extreme of iniquity, had done some good work; and that Lazarus, even though he had arrived at the summit of virtue, had committed some sin, mark how the patriarch intimates both these things, when he says, "Thou, in thy lifetime, receivedst thy good things, and likewise Lazarus evil things." That which he says, implies this: "If thou also hast done good, and reward was owing to thee for that, all this reward thou receivedst in that life when thou didst live in luxury and wealthy enjoying great prosperity and success. This man (Lazarus) also, if he did any wrong, has received all the equivalent in poverty and hunger, being oppressed with the most extreme ills. Each of you has arrived here free —-this man from his sins, and thou from works of righteousness. Therefore, he has unmixed consolation—-thou endurest unmitigated punishment."

When our righteousness is small and slight, and the burden of our sins great and beyond measure, yet we still enjoy success here and suffer no harm, we will leave this life completely lacking and empty of any reward for good deeds, having "received all our good things in this life." Likewise, when our righteous works are great and many, and our sins few and minor, yet we also suffer certain kinds of hardship, we are cleansed from our sins here, and we receive there an undiluted reward for our good deeds, prepared for us. So whenever you see someone living in wickedness yet suffering no misfortune, do not consider him blessed, but mourn and grieve for him, since he is about to undergo his suffering there, just as this rich man did. Again, when you see someone pursuing virtue while enduring countless trials, consider him blessed; regard him with admiration as one paying the penalty for all his sins here, and about to receive the reward for his perseverance prepared for him there; just as it happened in the case of Lazarus.

Thus when our righteousness is small and slender, and the burden of our sins great and incalculable, and still we enjoy success here, and suffer no ill, we shall depart hence entirely destitute and devoid of that reward of good actions, having "received all our good things in this life." Also, when our works of righteousness are great and numerous, and our transgressions few and slight, and we also suffer some kinds of ill, we are purged from the transgressions here, and we receive there an unmixed recompense of our good acts, prepared for us. Whenever, then, you see any one living in wickedness, and suffering no misfortune, do not think him blessed, but mourn for and bewail him, as being about to undergo his woes there, as did also this rich man. Again, when you see any one striving after virtue, and enduring innumerable trials, consider him blessed; envy him as paying the penalty for all his transgressions here, and about to receive the reward of his constancy prepared for him there; as also it happened in the case of Lazarus.

Chapter 5

Some people are punished only in this life; others suffer no harm here but receive their entire punishment in the life to come; still others are punished both here and in the next life. Which of these three groups do you consider fortunate? Without doubt, the first—those who are punished and cleansed from their sins here. But which group comes second? You might say those who suffer nothing in this life but undergo the full punishment later. However, I would say not those, but rather those who are punished in both worlds. For the person who pays the penalty in this life will experience lighter pains in the next; but the one who must undergo the entire punishment later will face an unrelenting judgment. Thus this rich man, not being cleansed here of any of his sins, was so severely punished in the next world that he could not obtain even a drop of water. Also, regarding those who sin in this world but suffer no harm, I pity them far more than the others—those who, along with freedom from punishment, also enjoy luxury and security here. For just as freedom from penalty for sin in this world makes their future punishment more severe, so also when sinners enjoy great comfort, luxury, and success here, this prosperity becomes for them a means and cause of greater punishment and penalty. While in a state of sin, whenever we receive honors through divine providence, these very honors may more certainly cast us into the fire. If, for example, someone experiences only God's patience without using it rightly, he will receive heavier punishment. When, besides patience, he enjoys the highest honors and yet remains in his wickedness, who can save him from punishment? For to show that those who experience God's patience here prepare unrelieved punishment for themselves in the next life if they do not repent, hear what Saint Paul says: "Do you think, O man, that you who judge those who do such things and yet do the same will escape the judgment of God? Or do you despise the riches of His goodness, forbearance, and patience, not knowing that the goodness of God leads you to repentance? But according to your hardness and unrepentant heart you are storing up wrath for yourself against the day of wrath and revelation of the righteous judgment of God" (Romans 2:3-5). Therefore, whenever you see people abounding in wealth, living in luxury, using expensive perfumes, feasting every day, possessing power and great honor and splendor, and at the same time living in sin and suffering no harm—for this very reason especially we weep and mourn for them, that when they sin, they are not punished. Just as when you see someone afflicted with dropsy or any other disease, or having sores or wounds all over his body, if on top of this he indulges in drinking and eating and thus worsens his illness, you not only do not admire him or think him happy because of his luxury, but for this very reason you consider him miserable. In the same way we should judge concerning the affairs of the soul. Whenever you see a man living in wickedness and enjoying great prosperity and suffering no calamity, lament for him all the more on this account, because, being under the power of disease and terrible corruption, he increases his own weakness, becoming worse through luxury and idleness. For punishment is not in itself an evil, but the real evil is sin. The latter separates us from God; the former leads us to God and softens His anger. How is this shown? Hear the prophet saying, "O priests, comfort, comfort my people. Speak to the heart of Jerusalem, and say that she has received from the Lord's hand double for her sins" (Isaiah 40:1-2, LXX). And again: "O Lord our God, give us peace, for you have repaid everything to us" (Isaiah 26:12, LXX). And so that you may understand that some are punished here and others in the life to come, hear what Saint Paul says when reproving those who partake of the mysteries unworthily. For having said, "He who eats this bread and drinks this cup unworthily is guilty of the body and blood of the Lord" (1 Corinthians 11:27), he immediately adds, "For this reason many are weak and sick among you, and many have died. For if we would judge ourselves, we would not be judged; but now we are judged by the Lord and disciplined, so that we should not be condemned with the world" (1 Corinthians 11:30-32). Do you see how the punishment inflicted here frees us from punishment in the life to come? Also regarding the man who had committed fornication, it is said, "Deliver such a one to Satan for the destruction of the flesh, that the spirit may be saved in the day of our Lord Jesus Christ" (1 Corinthians 5:5). Also from the case of Lazarus it is clear that if he had committed any wrong, having been purged from it here, he departed from this life clean. And the same appears from the case of the paralyzed man, who, having lived in weakness for thirty-eight years, was freed from sin by the length of his affliction. And that it was sin for which he was thus afflicted, hear what Christ said: "Behold, you are made well: sin no more, lest something worse happen to you" (John 5:14). That some are punished here and purified from sin is therefore shown by these examples.

Some men are punished here only; others suffer here no ill, but receive the whole punishment hereafter; others are punished both here and hereafter. Which, then, of these three classes do you esteem fortunate? Without doubt, the first; those who are punished and purged from their sins here. But which class is second in order? You, perhaps, may say, those who suffer nothing in this life, but undergo the whole punishment hereafter. I, however, should say not those, but rather they who are punished in both worlds. For he who in this life pays the penalty, will hereafter feel lighter pains; but he who must undergo the whole infliction hereafter, will have an inexorable doom. Thus this rich man, not being cleansed here from any of his indwelling sins, was so severely punished in the next world as not to be able to procure even a drop of water. Also, with respect to those who sin in this world, but suffer no ill, I pity them by far the most who, together with freedom from punishment, also enjoy here luxury and security. For as the freedom from penalty for sin in this world makes their future punishment more severe, so also when sinners enjoy here great repose and luxury and success, this prosperity becomes to them a means and cause of greater punishment and penalty. While in a state of sin, whenever we, in the course of divine providence, receive honours, these very honours may the more surely cast us into the fire. If, for instance, any one should experience only long-suffering without making the right use of it, he will receive heavier punishment. When, besides long-suffering, he enjoys the highest honours, and, notwithstanding, remains in his wickedness, who can save him from punishment? For, to show that they who here experience long-suffering prepare for themselves unmitigated punishment hereafter, if they do not repent, hear what St Paul says: "Thinkest thou, O man, that judgest them which do such things, and doest the same, that thou shalt escape the judgment of God? Or despisest thou the riches of His goodness, and forbearance, and long-suffering, not knowing that the goodness of God leadeth thee to repentance? But after thy hardness and impenitent heart treasurest up for thyself wrath against the day of wrath and revelation of the righteous judgment of God," (Rom. ii. 3-5.) Whenever, then, thou seest any men abounding in riches, living in luxury, using precious ointments, surfeiting day by day, having power and great honour and splendour, and, at the same time, living in sin, and suffering no ill; for this very reason chiefly it is that we weep and lament for them, that when sinning, they are not punished. Just as when you see any one afflicted with dropsy, or any other disease, or having sores or wounds in all parts of his body; if, in addition to this, he indulges in drinking and eating, and thus aggravates his malady, you not only do not admire him, nor think him happy on account of his luxury, but, for this very reason, you think him wretched. In the same way, also, we should judge concerning the affairs of the soul. Whenever you see a man living in wickedness, and enjoying great prosperity, and suffering no calamity, on this account lament for him the more, because, being under the power of disease and grievous corruption, he increases his own weakness, becoming worse by luxury and indolence. For punishment is not in itself an evil, but the real evil is sin. The latter separates us from God; the former leads us to God, and mitigates His wrath. How is this shown? Hear the prophet saying, "O priests, comfort ye, comfort ye my people. Speak to the heart of Jerusalem, and say that she has received of the Lord's hand double for her sins," (Isa. xl. 1,2, LXX.) And again: "O Lord our God, give us peace, for thou hast repaid all to us," (Isa. xxvi. 12, LXX.) And in order that you may understand that some are punished here, others hereafter, hear what St Paul saith, reproving those who partake of the mysteries unworthily. For having said, "He who eateth this bread, and drinketh this cup unworthily, is guilty of the body and blood of the Lord," (1 Cor. xi. 27,) he immediately adds, "For this cause many are weak and sickly among you, and many sleep. For if we would judge ourselves, we should not be judged; but now we are judged of the Lord and chastened, in order that we should not be condemned with the world," (1 Cor. xi. 30-32.) Do you see how the punishment inflicted here frees from the punishment hereafter? Also with respect to him who had committed fornication, it is said, "Deliver such a one unto Satan for the destruction of the flesh, that the spirit may be saved in the day of our Lord Jesus Christ," (1 Cor. v. 5.) Also from the case of Lazarus this is clear, that if he had committed any ill, having been purged from it here, he departed hence clean. And the same appears from the case of the paralytic man, who, having lived in weakness thirty and eight years, was freed from sin by the length of his affliction. And that it was sin for which he was thus afflicted, hear what Christ said, "Behold, thou art made whole: sin no more, lest a worse thing come unto thee," (John v. 14.) That some are punished here and purified from sin, is therefore shown by these instances.

Chapter 6

Some people do not receive punishment here equal to the seriousness of their sins, but are punished both here and in the life to come. Listen to what Christ says about the Sodomites. After saying, "Whoever will not receive you, shake off the dust from your feet," He goes on to say, "It will be more tolerable for Sodom and Gomorrah in the day of judgment than for that city." The phrase "more tolerable" shows that they will indeed be punished, but more lightly, since they already paid a penalty here. And there are some who suffer nothing bad in this world but endure the full punishment in the next world. The case of the rich man teaches us this—he underwent such severe punishment there that he did not even receive the comfort of a drop of water, because the entire penalty was to be measured out to him there. Therefore, among those who commit sin, those who suffer nothing bad here undergo greater punishment in the life to come. Likewise, among those who live righteously, those who suffer many troubles here enjoy greater honor there. And if there are two sinners, one punished here and the other not punished, the one who is punished is more fortunate than the one who is not. Again, if there are two righteous people, one enduring more trials and the other fewer, the one who endures the most is the most fortunate, since each will be repaid according to his work.

And. that some men, when they do not receive punishment here equivalent to the magnitude of their offences, are punished both here and hereafter, hear what Christ saith concerning the Sodomites. For having said, "Whosoever will not receive you, shake off the dust from your feet," (Luke ix. 5; x. 11,) He proceeds to say, "It shall be more tolerable for Sodom and Gomorrah in the day of judgment than for that city," (Luke x. 12.) The expression more tolerable shows this, that they will be punished indeed, but more lightly, since also here they paid the penalty. And that there are some who, in this world suffer no ill, but in the next world endure the full punishment, the case of this rich man teaches us, who there underwent such unmitigated punishment, as not even to enjoy the consolation of a drop of water; for the whole infliction was to be meted out to him there. As therefore, of those who commit sin, they who suffer no ill here, undergo greater punishment hereafter; thus also, of those who live righteously, they who suffer many ills here, enjoy greater honour there. And if there be two sinners, the one punished here, the other not punished; the one who is punished is more fortunate than the one unpunished. Again, if there be two righteous men, of whom one endures more, and the other fewer trials; he that endures the most is the most fortunate, since to each will be rendered according to his work.

What then? Is it possible, they ask, to enjoy ease both here and in the life to come? This, O man, is unattainable. It is one of those impossible things. It cannot be that someone who enjoys ease and plenty here, who continually indulges in every luxury and lives a vain and aimless life, can also enjoy honor in the afterlife. At the same time, even if he is not troubled by poverty, he is still troubled by desire, and this causes him restraint—a source of no small trouble. Again, if disease does not afflict him, evil passion still burns within, and the pain that springs from anger is no slight thing. Also, if trials are not laid upon him, wicked thoughts constantly arise to vex him. It is by no means a trivial matter to restrain lawless desire, to stop vainglorious thoughts, to check senseless pride, to refrain from excess, and to live in self-denial. And whoever does not accomplish these things and others like them can never attain salvation. For the fact that those who live luxuriously are not saved, hear what St. Paul says concerning widows: "She that liveth in pleasure is dead while she liveth" (1 Tim. 5:6). And if this is said concerning a widow, how much more is it true concerning a man. Again, that it is not possible for one living a dissipated life to reach heaven, even Christ has made quite plain when He declares, "Strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it" (Matt. 7:14). How is it then that it is said, "My yoke is easy, and my burden is light" (Matt. 11:30)? For if the way is narrow and confined, how can it also be called light and easy? We answer: The former is true because of the very nature (physis) of trial; the latter, because of the determination of the one who endures trial. For it is possible that something which is by nature unbearable may become light when we bear it willingly. As, therefore, the apostles, being beaten, returned rejoicing that they were counted worthy to suffer shame for the name of the Lord, though the nature (physis) of such trial always causes tribulation and pain, still the prior determination of those who received the stripes even overcame the nature (physis) of things. With respect to this same thing, St. Paul says, "All that will live godly in Christ Jesus shall suffer persecution" (2 Tim. 3:12). So that if man does not persecute, the devil fights against us, and we need much wisdom and great perseverance, in order that, with the aid of prayer, we may be sober and watchful. We must not covet the possessions of others. We must be willing to distribute our substance to those who are in need. We must bid farewell to all self-indulgence, both with respect to dress and to food. We must avoid greed. We must flee drunkenness and evil-speaking. We must have the tongue in subjection. We must not utter any unbecoming word (for "let all bitterness, and wrath, and anger, and clamour, and evil speaking, be put away from you," Eph. 4:31). We must not speak base or deceitful words. There is no small labor required to exhibit perfect observance of all these things. And in order that you may learn how great a thing it is to live wisely, and that it is a work which admits no rest, hear what St. Paul says: "I keep under my body, and bring it unto subjection" (1 Cor. 9:27). By these words he indicates the force and great effort needed to render the body obedient in all things. Christ also said to His disciples, "In the world ye shall have tribulation; but be of good cheer, I have overcome the world" (John 16:33). This very tribulation, it is said, procures rest for you. The present life is an arena, and the one who is to be crowned can have no rest while in the arena and engaged in contest. Thus also, if anyone desires to be crowned, he must adopt a hard and laborious way of life, in order that having toiled here for a short period, he may hereafter enjoy perpetual rest.

What then? Is it not possible, they say, to enjoy ease both here and hereafter? This, O man, is unattainable; it is one of the things impossible. It cannot, it cannot be, that he who here enjoys ease and plenty, and continually indulges in every luxury—-who lives a vain and aimless life—-can also enjoy honour hereafter. At the same time, if he be not troubled by poverty, he still is troubled by desire, and from this cause suffers restraint—-a cause which gives rise to no small amount of trouble, Again, if disease do not afflict him, yet evil passion burns within, and it is no slight pain that springs from wrath; also, if trials be not laid upon him, yet wicked thoughts constantly arise to vex him. It is by no means a trivial matter to restrain lawless desire, to put a stop to vainglorious thoughts, to check insensate pride, to refrain from excess, to live in self-denial. And he who does not accomplish these things, and such as these, can never attain salvation. For that they who live luxuriously are not saved, hear what St Paul says concerning widows, "She that liveth in pleasure is dead while she liveth," (1 Tim. v. 6.) And if this is said concerning a widow, much more is it true concerning a man. Again, that it is not possible for one living a dissipated life to reach heaven, even Christ has made quite plain, when He declares, "Strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it," (Matt. vii. 4.) How is it then that it is said, "My yoke is easy, and my burden is light"? (Matt. xi. 30.) For if the way be narrow and confined, how can it again be called light and easy? We answer: The former is true, because of the very nature of trial; the latter, because of the determination of him who endures trial. For it is possible that that which is by nature unendurable, may become light, when we bear it willingly. As, therefore, the apostles, being beaten, returned rejoicing that they were counted worthy to suffer shame for the name of the Lord, though the nature of such trial always causes tribulation and pain, still the previous determination of those who received the stripes, even overcame the nature of things. With respect to this same thing, St Paul says, "All that will live godly in Christ Jesus shall suffer persecution," (2 Tim. iii. 12.) So that if man do not persecute, the devil fights against us, and we have need of much philosophy and great perseverance, in order that, with the aid of prayer, we may be sober and watchful,—-that we may not covet the possessions of others,—-that we may be willing to distribute of our substance to those who are in need,—-that we may bid farewell to all self-indulgence, both with respect to dress and with respect to food,—-that we may avoid covetousness,—-that we may flee drunkenness, and evil-speaking,—-that we may have the tongue in subjection,—-that we may not utter any unbecoming word, (for "let all bitterness, and wrath, and anger, and clamour, and evil speaking, be put away from you," Eph. iv. 31,)—-that we may not speak base or deceitful words. There is no small labour requisite to exhibit perfect observance of all these things. And in order that you may learn how great a thing it is to live wisely, and that it is a work which admits no repose, hear what St Paul saith, "I keep under my body, and bring it unto subjection," (1 Cor. ix. 27.) By these words he intimates the force and great effort which it is needful to put forth in order to render the body obedient in all things. Christ also said to His disciples, "In the world ye shall have tribulation; but be of good cheer, I have overcome the world," (John xvii. 33.) This very tribulation, it is said, procures for you rest. The present life is an arena, and he that is to be crowned can have no rest while in the arena, and engaged in contest. Thus also, if any one be desirous to be crowned, he must adopt a hard and laborious mode of life, in order that having toiled here for a short period, he may hereafter enjoy perpetual repose.

Chapter 7

Every day brings so many troubles! A person's soul must be truly great if they are not annoyed or upset by them, but instead gives thanks and praise, worshiping the one who ordains that these trials must be endured. There are so many unexpected things and so many difficulties! We must hold back evil thoughts and not let our tongues speak any improper words, just as blessed Job did when he praised God while enduring countless sufferings.

How many troubles arise each day! How great must that soul be that is not annoyed—-that is not vexed, but gives thanks and praise,—-that adores Him who ordains that these trials should be endured! How many unexpected things there are,—-how many difficulties! And we must restrain evil thoughts, and not suffer the tongue to speak any improper word, as did the blessed Job, who praised God while he endured a multitude of ills.

There are some people who, if they meet with any setback, or are slandered by anyone, or if they fall into any bodily illness, any pain in the foot or head, or any other disease, immediately blaspheme. In this way they endure the affliction, but are deprived of the benefit. What are you doing, O man, blaspheming against your benefactor and Savior! Don't you realize that you are on the edge of a cliff, and are throwing yourself into an abyss of utter destruction? You don't make your suffering lighter by blaspheming; instead, you increase it and make your pain more severe. This is the tempter's very purpose in bringing a multitude of troubles against you—that he may lead you into that abyss. And if he sees you blaspheming, how easily does he increase the anguish and make it greater, so that, being afflicted, you may rebel again. But if he sees you bearing it nobly, and that the more the suffering increases, the more you give thanks to God, he immediately stops; since in the future he would attack you fruitlessly and in vain. The tempter is like a dog waiting at the table: if he sees the man who is eating continually throwing him some morsel or other from the dishes on the table, he waits patiently; but if, having waited once or twice, he goes away without anything, he stops coming in the future, because he has waited fruitlessly and in vain. In the same way the evil one constantly attends us with open mouth; and if you throw to him, as to a dog, a wicked word, he snatches it up and prepares himself for more; but if you continue thankful, you starve him, as it were, and quickly drive him away and make him flee. But you say you are not able to be silent when goaded by pain. I don't prevent you from speaking: but instead of blasphemy, give utterance to praise—instead of discontent, to thankfulness.

There are some who, if they meet with any reverse, or are slandered by any one, or if they fall into any bodily malady, any pain in the foot or head, or any other disease, immediately blaspheme. In this way they endure the affliction, but are deprived of the benefit. What doest thou, O man, blaspheming against thy benefactor and Saviour! Dost thou not perceive that thou art on the brink of a precipice, and art casting thyself into an abyss of utter destruction? Nor dost thou, by blaspheming, make thy suffering lighter; but thou dost increase it, and makest thy pain more severe. It is with this intent that the tempter brings against thee a multitude of ills,—-that he may lead thee into that abyss; and if he see thee blaspheming, how easily does he increase the anguish and make it greater, that, being afflicted, thou mayest rebel again. But if he see thee bearing it nobly, and in proportion to the increase of the suffering, the more giving thanks to God, he at once desists; since for the future he would attack thee fruitlessly and in vain. Thus also the tempter, as a dog waiting at table, if he see the man who is eating, continually throwing to him some morsel or other from the dishes on the table he waits patiently; but if, having waited once or twice, he should go away without anything, he desists for the future, because he has waited fruitlessly and in vain. Thus also does the evil one constantly attend us with open mouth; and if you should throw to him, as to a dog, a wicked word, snatching it up, he again prepares himself for more; but if you continue thankful, you as it were starve him, and quickly drive him away and make him flee. But, you say, you are not able to be silent when goaded by. pain. Nor do I hinder you from speaking: but instead of blasphemy, give utterance to praise—-instead of discontent, to thankfulness.

Make confession to your Master; cry aloud in prayer: in this way your suffering will be relieved, the tempter will be driven away by thanksgiving, and God's help will be brought near. Moreover, if you blaspheme, you turn away God's help and make the tempter more powerful against you, and you involve yourself even more deeply in pain; but if you give thanks, you repel the attacks of the evil spirit and gain for yourself the care of a gracious God.

Make confession to your Master; cry aloud in prayer: thus your suffering will be alleviated, the tempter will be put to flight by thanksgiving, and the aid of God will be brought nigh. Besides, if you blaspheme, you avert the help of God, and cause the tempter to be more powerful against you, and you involve yourself the more in pains; but if you give thanks, you repel the assaults of the evil spirit, and gain for yourself the care of a gracious God.

But someone may say that the tongue often slips into speaking some evil word through force of habit. Whenever you are about to fail in this way, clench your teeth firmly before the word can be spoken. It is better for the tongue to shed a drop of blood now than for it later to crave a drop of water and be unable to obtain that comfort. It is better to endure pain at the right time than to undergo endless punishment afterward. For the tongue of the rich man, when it was consumed with heat, found no relief.

But, it is said, the tongue often by force of habit lapses into the utterance of some evil word. Whenever, then, you are failing, before the word can gain utterance, close your teeth against it firmly. Better for the tongue to shed a drop of blood now, than that hereafter craving a drop of water it should be unable to gain that comfort: better to endure pain in season, than to undergo ceaseless punishment hereafter. For the tongue of the rich man, when consumed with heat, found no relief.

God has commanded that you should love your enemies: do you turn away from the God who loves you? He has commanded that you should bless those who mistreat you, that you should speak well of those who slander you: do you, when you haven't been wronged at all, speak evil of your benefactor and patron? "But wasn't He able," you say, "to free you from this temptation?" Yes, but He allowed it so that you might be more proven. "But I'm falling! I'm perishing!" you say. Well, this isn't because of the temptation, but because of your laziness. For tell me, which is easier, blasphemy or praise? Doesn't the former make those who hear it your enemies and opponents, cause you to feel dejection, and produce great pain afterward? Doesn't the latter gain for you the abundant reward of wisdom, the admiration of everyone, and secure great reward from God? Why, then, do you leave behind what is useful, easy, and pleasant, and instead follow what is harmful, painful, and corrupting? Besides this, if the pressure of trial and poverty caused you to blaspheme, it would mean that those who live in poverty would always be blasphemers. But in fact, those who live in poverty—many of them in extreme poverty—are constantly thankful, while others who enjoy wealth and luxury are constantly blasphemers. So it is not the nature of circumstances, but rather our own state of mind, that causes one course of conduct or the other.

God has enjoined that you should love your enemies: do you turn away from the God who loves you? He has commanded that you should bless them that despitefully use you, that you should speak well of those that slander you: do you, when in no respect injured, speak evil of your benefactor and patron? Was He not able, you say, to free you from this temptation? Yes, but He permitted it that you might be the more approved. "But, alas!" you say, "I fall! I perish!" Then this is not because of the temptation, but because of your slothfulness. For, tell me, which is the easier, blasphemy or praise? Does not the former cause those who hear it to be your enemies and opponents, and cause yourself to feel dejection, and produce afterward great pain? Does not the latter gain for you the manifold reward of wisdom, and the admiration of all, and procure great reward from God? Why, then, leaving that which is useful, and easy, and agreeable, do you instead follow that which is injurious, and painful, and corrupting? Beside this, if the pressure of trial and poverty caused you to utter blasphemy, it would follow that those who live in poverty would always be blasphemers. But in fact, those who live in poverty—-many of them in extreme poverty—-are constantly thankful; while others who enjoy wealth and luxury are constantly blasphemers. Thus, it is not the nature of the things, but rather our own state of mind, that causes the one line of conduct or the other.

For this reason, then, let us read this parable so that we may learn that wealth does not benefit the lazy person, nor does poverty in any way harm the righteous. Indeed, what am I saying? Poverty? Rather, not all the evils that afflict humanity, even if they all attack him together, can ever overthrow the soul of the godly and wise person or persuade him to abandon virtue—and Lazarus is an example of this. Likewise, wealth can never benefit the idle and immoral person, nor can health, nor constant prosperity, nor anything else.

For this reason, therefore, let us read this parable, in order that we may learn that neither does wealth benefit the slothful man, nor does poverty in any way injure the upright. Yea, what do I say?—-poverty!—-rather not all the ills that afflict mankind, should they together assail him, can ever overthrow the soul of the godly and wise man, or persuade him to forsake virtue; and of this, Lazarus is an example. So also wealth can never benefit the idle and dissolute man, nor can health, nor continual prosperity, nor any other thing.

Chapter 8

Let us therefore not say that sickness, or poverty, or the presence of danger forces us to blaspheme. It is not poverty, but foolishness—not sickness, but arrogance—not the presence of danger, but the absence of piety—that leads the negligent to blasphemy and every other evil habit.

Let us, therefore, not say that sickness, or poverty, or the presence of danger, obliges us to blaspheme. It is not poverty, but folly,—-not sickness, but arrogance,—-not the presence of danger, but the absence of piety,—-that leads the negligent to blasphemy and every other evil habit.

But why, it is said, are some punished here and others there, and not all here? Why? Because if it were so, we would all perish, for all of us deserve punishment. Again, if no one were punished here, most people would become more careless; many would deny the existence of Providence. For if people say such things even now, when we see many of the wicked suffering punishment, what would they say if this were not the case? What limits would there be to evil? For this reason God punishes some people here and does not punish others. He punishes some, removing their wickedness and making their punishment in the next world lighter, or completely renewing them, and making those who live in wickedness wiser through the punishment of others. Again, some He does not punish, so that if they would pay attention to themselves—if, being moved by the display of God's patience, they would repent—then they may escape both punishment here and the penalty hereafter. But if they remain hardened and do not benefit from God's forbearance, then they will endure greater punishments hereafter because of their extreme neglect. And if any of those who know these things should say that those who are punished in this way are wronged (being unable to repent), we might answer this: if God had foreseen that they would repent, He would not have punished them. For if He passes over those whom He knows to be incorrigible, much more would He tolerate in the present life those whom He knows would benefit from His patience, so that they may profit from the opportunity to repent. Since He now deals with them in advance, He makes their future punishment lighter, and through these dealings—through the punishment of these people—He makes other people more careful and wise. But why does He not act this way toward all sinners alike? It is so that through fear arising from the punishment of others, they may be established in wisdom, and giving glory to God for His patience and feeling shame because of His mercy, they may turn away from evil. But, it is said, they do not act this way? Nevertheless, God is not the cause of their misery, but their own carelessness, since they are negligent about using these remedies to ensure their own salvation. And so you may be assured that God acts this way for this reason, notice this: Pilate on one occasion mixed the blood of some Galileans with the sacrifices. When certain people rushed to tell this to Christ, He said, "Do you suppose that only these Galileans were sinners? I tell you, no; but unless you repent, you will all likewise perish" (Luke 13:2-3). Again, on another occasion, eighteen men were buried under a fallen tower, and concerning them He said the same thing. The words, "Do you think that they only were sinners? I say to you, no," teach us that those who escaped alive deserved the same fate. The words, "Unless you repent, you will all likewise perish," teach us that it was appointed to those men to suffer, so that those who remained alive, made afraid by the disasters happening to others, might repent and become heirs of the kingdom. "What then?" they say; "is another punished so that I may become better?" Not so; but another is punished for his own individual wickedness, and this event also becomes a cause of salvation to those who pay attention to it, making them more zealous because of the very fear arising from those disasters. In this same way masters act; when they discipline one slave, they make the rest more careful through fear. Thus, whenever you see anyone shipwrecked, or buried under a collapsed house, or ruined by fire, or drowned in a river, or losing life in any other violent way—when you also see others who have committed the same things, or even worse, suffering none of these things—do not say in your confusion, "Why is it then that those who have sinned alike do not suffer the same troubles?" but think this: "One person was allowed to be destroyed or drowned, so that his future punishment should be more tolerable for him, or even to make him completely pure," while another was permitted to suffer no such disaster, so that being taught by another's punishment he might become more obedient. But should he still remain unchanged, then he, by his own carelessness, would heap up for himself unrelieved penalties; still, God is not the cause of this unbearable punishment.

But for what reason, it is said, are some punished here, and others there, and not all here? For what reason?—-because if it were so, we all should perish; for all of us are worthy of punishment. Again, if no one were punished here, the mass of mankind would become more negligent; many would deny the existence of a Providence. For if men say such things even now, when we see many of the wicked enduring punishment, what would they say if this were not so? What bounds would there be to evil? For this reason God punishes some men here, and some He does not punish. He punishes some, removing their wickedness, and making their punishment in the next world lighter, or completely renewing them, and making those who live in wickedness wiser by the punishment of others. Again, some He does not punish, in order that if they should take heed to themselves,—-if being touched by the manifestation of God's long-suffering they should repent—-that then they may escape both punishment here and the penalty hereafter; but if they should remain hardened and not profit by the forbearance of God, that then they may endure greater inflictions hereafter because of this their exceeding neglect. And if any of those who know these things should say that they who are thus punished are wronged, (being unable to repent,) we might reply thus:—-that if God had foreseen that they would repent, He would not have punished them. For if He passes over those whom He knows to be incorrigible, much more would He tolerate in the present life those whom He knows to be benefited by His long-suffering, in order that they may profit by the opportunity of repentance. Since He now deals with them beforehand, He causes their future punishment to be lighter, and by these His dealings,—-by the punishment of these, He makes other men more prudent and wise. But wherefore does He not act thus towards all sinners alike? It is in order that by fear arising from the punishment of others, they may be confirmed in wisdom; and giving glory to God, on account of His long-suffering, and feeling shame on account of His clemency, they may depart from iniquity. But, it is said, they do not act so? Notwithstanding after this, God is not the cause of their woe, but their own negligence, since they are careless about using these remedies to ensure their own salvation. And that you may be assured that God acts thus for this reason, mark this:—-Pilate on one occasion mingled the blood of some Galileans with the sacrifices, Certain men having hastened to tell this to Christ, He said, "Suppose ye that only these Galileans were sinners? I tell you, Nay; but except ye repent, ye shall all likewise perish," (Luke xiii. 2, 3.) Again, on another occasion, eighteen men were buried under a fallen tower, and concerning them He said the same. The words, "Think ye that they only were sinners? I say unto you, Nay," teach us that those who escaped alive were worthy of the same fate. The words, "Except ye repent, ye shall all likewise perish," teach us that it was allotted to those men to suffer, in order that those who remained alive, made afraid by the calamities happening to others, might repent and become heirs of the kingdom. "What then?" say they; "is another punished that I may become better?" Not so; but another is punished for his own individual iniquity; and this event also becomes a cause of salvation to those who pay heed to it, making them more zealous because of the very fear arising from those calamities. In this same way masters act; when they chastise one slave, they cause the rest to be more careful through fear. Thus, whenever you see any shipwrecked, or buried under a fallen house, or ruined by fire, or drowned in a river, or losing life in any other violent way,—-when you also see others who have committed the same things, or even worse, suffering none of these things, do not say in your perplexity, "Why then is it that those who have sinned alike do not suffer the same ills?" but think thus, "One man was permitted to be destroyed or drowned, that his future punishment should be more tolerable to him, or even to make him quite pure;" while another was ordained to suffer no such calamity, in order that being taught by another's punishment he might become more submissive; but should he still remain unchanged, that he, by his own negligence might heap up for himself unmitigated penalties; still of this unendurable punishment God is not the cause.

Again, when you see a righteous person suffering or experiencing all the troubles mentioned before, don't let it shake your faith. Even for that person, these troubles become the cause of a greater reward.

Again, when you see a just man afflicted, or suffering all the afore-mentioned woes, do not stumble at it; for even to himself the woes are the cause of a brighter reward.

In short, regarding all punishment: if it falls on sinners, it reduces the weight of their sin; if it falls on the just, it makes the soul more glorious—and the greatest benefit comes to each of us from affliction, as long as we bear it with gratitude. For this is the purpose of punishment.

In a word, with respect to all punishment, if it be inflicted on sinners, it lessens the burden of sin; if on the just, it makes the soul more glorious;—-and the greatest gain accrues to each of us from affliction, if only we bear it thankfully. For this is the design of punishment.

Chapter 9

For this reason, the history contained in the sacred Scriptures is filled with countless examples of this kind. Both righteous and unrighteous people are shown to us suffering troubles, so that whether a person is righteous or a sinner, having these examples, he may endure troubles well. And wicked people are shown to us not only suffering troubles but also prospering, so that you may not be disturbed by their prosperity, since you learn from what happened to this rich man that tormenting fire awaits them if they do not repent. And Scripture tells us that it is not possible to enjoy rest both here and in the life to come; it cannot be.

For this reason the history contained in the sacred Scriptures is filled with innumerable examples of this kind. Both just men and unjust are shown to us suffering ills, in order that, whether a man be just or whether he be a sinner, having these examples, he may bear ills well. And wicked men are shown to us not only suffering ills, but also prospering; so that you may not be troubled at their prosperity, since you learn from that which befell this rich man that the tormenting fire awaits them if they repent not. And the Scripture tells us that it is not possible to enjoy repose both here and hereafter; it cannot be.

This is why just men in this world live a difficult life. But some people ask, "What do you say about Abraham?" Yet who suffered as many hardships as he did? Wasn't he forced to leave his homeland? Wasn't he separated from all his relatives? Didn't he experience poverty in a foreign land? Didn't he, like a pilgrim, constantly move from place to place—from Babylon to Mesopotamia, from there to Palestine, and from there again to Egypt? How can anyone describe his troubles concerning his wife, the deadly conflict with the barbarians, the capture of his kinsman's household, and many other troubles like these? And when he finally had his son, didn't he suffer the hardest trial of all, being commanded to kill his cherished and beloved one with his own hand? And what shall we say about Isaac, the sacrifice? Wasn't he constantly troubled by his neighbors, deprived of his wife (as his father had been), and for such a long time separated from his child? What, again, shall we say about Jacob, who was raised in his father's house? Didn't he endure greater hardships than his grandfather? And not to make this discussion too long by going through all these things, hear what he himself says about his whole life: "Few and evil have been my days, and I have not reached the days of my fathers." Although he saw his son sitting on a royal throne and possessing such glory, he did not forget the hardships of the past; he had been so afflicted that even in such prosperity he could not forget the misfortunes that had happened to him. What shall we say about David? How many tragic events happened to him? Didn't he also cry out like Jacob: "The days of our years are seventy years; and if by reason of strength they reach eighty years, yet their strength is only labor and sorrow"? What about Jeremiah? Didn't he, because of overwhelming troubles, curse the day of his birth? What shall we say about Moses? Didn't he in despair cry out, "Kill me, if you deal with me this way"? Elijah also, that heavenly soul—he who shut up heaven—didn't he, after working so many wonders, lament before God like this: "Take away my life, for I am not better than my fathers"? And what need is there to go through each example? Saint Paul, taking all of them together, speaks of them this way: "They wandered about in sheepskins and goatskins; being destitute, afflicted, tormented; of whom the world was not worthy." And, in short, it is always necessary that whoever would please God and become approved and holy should not lead an easy, free, and undisciplined life, but a difficult life, full of hardship and toil. For "no man," it is said, "is crowned unless he strives lawfully," and in another place, "Every man who competes for the prize is disciplined in all things." He avoids evil words and looks, base conversation and slander, and blasphemy and evil speaking. From this we learn that, even if trial does not come upon us from any external source, it is our duty to discipline ourselves each day through fasting, self-denial, moderate eating, and a simple table, avoiding extravagance in any way. Otherwise we cannot please God. Let no one repeat the foolish saying that such and such a person has both the good things of this world and also of the next. It is impossible for rich and luxurious sinners that this saying could be true; but if it is right to say it at all, it should be said of those who are afflicted—of those who are in distress—that they have the good of this world and also of the next. For they have good things in the next world as their reward; they also have good things here, being sustained by the hope of the future and not feeling present hardships acutely, because of the anticipation of future good.6

Therefore it is that just men in this world live a laborious life. But "what," say they, "do you say with respect to Abraham?" Yet who suffered so many ills as he? Was he not obliged to leave his fatherland? Was he not separated from all his relatives? Did he not suffer want in a strange land? Did he not, like a pilgrim, continually change his abode—-from Babylon to Mesopotamia, from thence to Palestine, from thence again to Egypt? How can one relate his trouble about his wife, the deadly strife with the barbarians, the carrying captive of the household of his kinsman, the many other troubles like these? And when at length he had the son, did he not suffer the hardest trial of all, being commanded to slay his cherished and beloved one with his own hand? And what shall we say of Isaac, the sacrifice? Was he not vexed perpetually by his neighbours, deprived of his wife, (as his father had been,) and for so long a time bereaved of his child? What, again, shall we say concerning Jacob, who was brought up in his father's house? Did he not endure greater ills than his grandfather? And not to make the discourse too long by going through all these things, hear what he himself says concerning his whole life: "Few and evil have been my days, and I have not attained to the days of my fathers," (Gen. xlvii. 9.) Although he saw his son sitting on a royal throne and possessed of such glory, he did not forget the ills of the past; he had been so afflicted that even in such prosperity he could not be unmindful of the misfortunes that had befallen him. What shall we say about David? How many tragical events happened to him? Did he not also exclaim like Jacob: "The days of our years are threescore years and ten; and if by reason of strength they come to fourscore years, yet is their strength but labour and sorrow"? (Ps. xc. 10.) What with respect to Jeremiah? Did he not, because of overwhelming evils, curse the day of his birth? What shall we say of Moses? Did he not in despair exclaim, "Kill me, if thou thus deal with me"? (Numb. xi. 15.) Elijah also, that heavenly soul—-he that shut heaven —-did he not, after working so many wonders, lament before God thus: "Take away my life, for I am not better than my fathers "? (1 Kings xix. 4.) And what need is there to go through each instance? St Paul, taking them [the just] all together, proceeds to speak of them thus: "They wandered about in sheep-skins and goat-skins; being destitute, afflicted, tormented; of whom the world was not worthy," (Heb. xi. 37, 38.) And, in a word, it is ever necessary that he who would please God and become approved and holy should not lead an easy, free, and dissolute life, but a laborious life, full of hardship and toil. For "no man," it is said, "is crowned except he strive lawfully," (2 Tim. ii. 5;) and in another place, "Every man that striveth for the mastery is temperate in all things," (1 Cor. ix. 25.) He abstains from evil words and looks, from base conversation and slander, and from blasphemy and evil speaking. Prom this we learn that, though trial may not come upon us from any external source, it is our duty to exercise ourselves each day in fasting, self-denial, moderate diet, and a plain table, avoiding extravagance in any way. Otherwise we cannot please God. Let not any one repeat the foolish saying, that such and such a one has both the good things of this world and also of the next. It is impossible in the case of rich and luxurious sinners that the saying can be true; but if it be right to say it at all, it should be said of those who are afflicted,—-of those who are in distress,—-that they have the good of this world and also of the next. For they have good things in the next world as their reward; good things also they have here, being sustained by the hope of the future, and not feeling acutely present ills, because of the anticipation of future good.6

But let us hear the following words of the parable: "Besides all this, between us and you there is a great gulf fixed." David spoke well when he said, "None of them can by any means redeem his brother, nor give to God a ransom for him" (Psalm 49:7). No one can redeem even a brother, or a father, or a son. Notice that Abraham addressed the rich man as son, yet he had no power to act as a father. The rich man addressed Abraham as father, but he could not receive the paternal help that a son normally receives. This shows that neither family relationship, nor friendship, nor affection, nor anything else can secure release for someone who is handed over to destruction by his own evil way of life.

But let us hear the following words of the parable: "Besides all this, between us and you there is a great gulf fixed." Well, therefore, spake David, "None of them can by any means redeem his brother, nor give to God a ransom for him," (Ps. xlix. 7.) No one can redeem even a brother, or a father, or a son. For mark, Abraham addressed the rich man as son; yet had he no power to perform the part of a father. The rich man addressed Abraham as father; * but the paternal aid which a son commonly receives he was unable to gain;—-in order that you may learn that neither relationship, nor friendship, nor kind feeling, nor any other existing thing, can procure release for him who is delivered to destruction by his own evil life.

Chapter 10

I have said these things because it frequently happens that many people, when we urge them to pay attention to themselves and practice self-denial, are lazy and turn the warning into ridicule. They say, "You be my friend on that day, and then I will be confident and have no fear." Another says, "I have a father who was a martyr," and another, "I have a friend who is a bishop." Others bring forward their whole household. But all these excuses are empty words, for the goodness of others will not help us then. Remember that the wise virgins did not give any oil to the other five virgins; instead, they themselves went in to the wedding feast, while the others were shut out! It is a great blessing to base our hopes of salvation on our own condition, for there no friend will ever stand in our place. If even here it is said to Jeremiah, "Do not pray for this people" (Jeremiah 7:16), while it was still possible for them to repent, the difficulty will be much greater in the future.

I have said these things because it frequently happens that many, when we urge them to take heed to themselves and practise self-denial, are indolent, and turn the warning into ridicule. They say, "Do thou befriend me at that day, and then I shall be confident and have no fear." Another says, "I have a father who was a martyr;" and another, "I have a friend who is a bishop." Others bring forward their whole household. But all these excuses are idle words; for the goodness of others will not help us then. Remember "that the wise virgins did not bestow any oil on the other five virgins; but they themselves went in to the bridal feast, while the others were shut out! It is a great blessing to found our hopes of safety on our own condition; for there no friend will ever stand in our stead. If even here it is said to Jeremiah, "Pray not thou for this people," (Jer. vii. 16,) while it was still possible for them to repent, much more will the difficulty be increased hereafter.

What are you saying—that you had a father who was a martyr? This very fact will actually increase your condemnation, since you had an example of goodness in your own household yet proved yourself an unworthy child of a righteous father. But you have a friend who is noble and admirable? He won't help you then either. Why then does it say, "Make to yourselves friends of the mammon of unrighteousness, that when ye fail they may receive you into everlasting habitations" (Luke 16:9)? It is not the friendship that will help you then, but the charity. For if friendship alone could help, it would only be necessary to say, "Make to yourself friends." But now, showing that friendship alone does not help, it adds, "of the mammon of unrighteousness." Perhaps someone might say, "I am able to make friends without mammon, and much more zealous ones than those made by means of it." But so that you may know that it is charity that helps us—that it is our work and righteous act—he persuades us to rely not simply on the friendship of the saints, but on the friendship caused by the right use of mammon. Knowing all these things, beloved, let us pay attention to ourselves with all diligence. When we are afflicted, let us give thanks. When we live in prosperity, let us be on our guard, becoming wise by the misfortunes of others. Let us offer praise through repentance and compunction and continual confession. And if we transgress in any way in this present life, let us put away the sin and with the utmost zeal cleanse away every stain from our soul. Let us beseech God to make us all fit when we die, so to depart that we may not be with the rich man, but that, enjoying with Lazarus a place in the patriarch's bosom, we may be filled with undying blessedness. May it be the lot of us all to attain this, through the grace and kindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father, together with the Holy Spirit, be praise for ever and ever. Amen.

What dost thou say?—-that thou hadst a father who was a martyr? This very thing will then add to thy condemnation; since having had an example of goodness in thy own household, thou didst prove thyself an unworthy child of a righteous father. But thou hast a friend who is noble and admirable? Neither will he profit thee then. Why then is it said, "Make to yourselves friends of the mammon of unrighteousness, that when ye fail they may receive you into everlasting habitations"? (Luke xvi. 9.) It is not the friendship that will then avail thee, but the charity. For if the friendship alone could avail, it would be necessary to say only, "Make to yourself friends;" but now, showing that not friendship alone avails, it is added, "of the mammon of unrighteousness." As if perhaps some one might say, "I am able to make friends without the mammon, and much more zealous ones than those made by means of it. But that you may know that it is charity that avails us,—–that it is our work and righteous act,—-he persuades us to confide, not simply in the friendship of the saints, but in the friendship caused by the right use of mammon. Knowing all these things, beloved, let us give heed to ourselves with all diligence; when we are afflicted, let us give thanks; when we live in prosperity, let us be on our guard, becoming wise by the misfortunes of others; let us, by repentance and compunction and continual confession, offer praise; and if in any way we transgress in this present life, putting away the sin, and with the utmost zeal cleansing away every stain from our soul, let us beseech God to make us all fit when we die, thus to depart that we may not be with the rich man, but that, enjoying with Lazarus a place in the patriarch's bosom, we may be filled with undying blessedness; which may it be the lot of us all to attain, through the grace and kindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father, together with the Holy Spirit, be praise for ever and ever. Amen.


Four Discourses on the Rich Man and Lazarus — Discourse 2

Lazarus continued: the souls of those who die violently do not become wandering spirits, the coming judgment, and almsgiving.

Source: John Chrysostom, Four discourses, chiefly on the parable of the Rich man and Lazarus (1869) Discourse 2. pp.38-58.. Transcribed by Roger Pearse (tertullian.org); public domain.

Contents · 6 chapters
  1. Discourse 2
  2. Chapter 1
  3. Chapter 2
  4. Chapter 3
  5. Chapter 5
  6. Chapter 6

Discourse 2

Concerning Lazarus—and that the souls of those who die a violent death do not become wandering spirits—concerning also future judgment, and charity.

CONCERNING LAZARUS —- AND THAT THE SOULS OF THOSE THAT DIE A VIOLENT DEATH DO NOT BECOME WANDERING SPIRITS—-CONCERNING ALSO FUTURE JUDGMENT, AND CHARITY.

Chapter 1

I was pleased yesterday to see your right attitude when I discussed the subject of Lazarus, since you approved of the patience of the poor man and recoiled from the cruelty and inhumanity of the rich man. These are significant signs of a noble mind. For if we praise virtue even when we do not possess it, then we may at least be more able to attain it. Similarly, if we still condemn sin even though we do not flee from it, then we may at least be able to escape from it. Since you received that teaching with great favor, let me give you what still remains.

I was pleased yesterday to see your right feeling when I entered upon the subject of Lazarus, inasmuch as you approved of the patience of the poor man, and shrank from the cruelty and inhumanity of the rich man. These are no small tokens of a noble mind. For if, though not possessing virtue, we yet praise it, then we may be at all events more able to attain it. In like manner if, though we do not flee from sin, we still blame sin, then we may at all events be able to escape from it. Since, therefore, you received that address with great favour, let me deliver to you those things which still remain.

Yesterday you saw Lazarus at the rich man's gate; today see him in Abraham's bosom. You saw him then being licked by dogs; now see him guarded and cared for by angels. You saw him in poverty; now see him in abundance. You saw him lacking food; now see him enjoying the greatest plenty. You saw him engaged in the struggle; now see him crowned as victor. You saw his labor; now see his reward. See it, whether you are rich or poor—if rich, so that you may not value wealth apart from virtue; if poor, so that you may not think poverty is in itself an evil. This man can teach both groups. If he, living in poverty, did not resent his situation, what excuse will those have who do so while wealthy? If, living in need and amid so many troubles, he could give thanks, what defense can those make who possess abundance yet have no desire to attain the virtue of thankfulness? Again, those who are poor and who because of this are upset and discontented—what excuse can they have when this man, who lived in constant hunger and poverty, abandonment and weakness, and who spent his days right beside a rich man's house, who was scorned by everyone while there was no one else who had suffered the same to whom he might look, still showed such patience and acceptance? From him we may learn not to think the rich happy nor the poor miserable. Or rather, to speak the truth, he is not rich who is surrounded by many possessions, but he who does not need many possessions; and he is not poor who possesses nothing, but he who requires many things. We ought to consider this the distinction between poverty and wealth. When you see anyone longing for many things, consider him the poorest of all people, even if he possesses every kind of wealth. Again, when you see someone who does not wish for many things, judge him the most affluent of all, even if he possesses nothing. For we should distinguish between poverty and abundance by the condition of our mind, not by the quantity of our material wealth. Just as in the case of a man who is always thirsty, we do not say he is healthy, even if he enjoys abundance—even if he lies beside rivers and streams. For what is the use of this abundance of water while his thirst remains unquenched? So also we conclude in the case of the rich: we can never think those wealthy who are constantly desiring and thirsting for other people's possessions, not even if they enjoy a certain kind of abundance. For he who cannot restrain his desires, even if he should be surrounded by every kind of possessions, how can he ever be rich? Those, indeed, who are satisfied with their own property, enjoying what they have and not casting a greedy eye on the possessions of others, even if they are, as to means, the most limited of all people, ought to be regarded as the most affluent. For he who does not desire other people's possessions, but is willing to be satisfied with his own, is the wealthiest of all.

You then saw Lazarus in the gateway of the rich man; to-day behold him in Abraham's bosom. You saw him then licked by dogs; see him now guarded and tended by angels. You saw him then in poverty; behold him now in affluence. You saw him wanting food; behold him enjoying the greatest plenty. You saw him engaged in the contest; behold him crowned as victor. You saw his labour; behold his reward; behold it, whether you be rich or poor,—-if rich, that you may not think highly of wealth apart from virtue,—-if poor, that you may not think poverty, in itself, an evil. To both classes this man may afford instruction. If he, living in poverty, did not resent his lot, what excuse will they have who do so in wealth? If, living in want and amid so many ills, he could give thanks, what defence can they make who, while they possess abundance, have no desire to attain to the virtue of thankfulness? Again; those who are poor, and who on that account are vexed and discontented, what excuse can they have, when this man, who lived in continual hunger and poverty, desertion and weakness, and who passed his days hard by the dwelling of a rich man; who was scorned by all, while there was no one else who had suffered the like, to whom he might look, still showed such patience and resignation? Prom him we may learn not to think the rich happy nor the poor miserable. Or rather, to speak the truth, he is not rich who is surrounded by many possessions, but he who does not need many possessions; and he is not poor who possesses nothing, but he who requires many things. We ought to consider this to be the distinction between poverty and wealth. When, therefore, you see any one longing for many things, esteem him of all men the poorest, even though he possess all manner of wealth; again, when you see one who does not wish for many things, judge him to be of all men most affluent, even if he possess nothing. For by the condition of our mind, not by the quantity of our material wealth, should it be our custom to distinguish between poverty and affluence. As also in the case of a man who is always thirsty, we do not say that he is in health, even should he enjoy abundance,—-even should he lie beside rivers and streams; for what is the use of this abundance of water while his thirst is unquenched? Thus also we conclude in the case of the rich; we can never think those wealthy who are perpetually desiring and thirsting for other people's possessions, not even if they enjoy a certain kind of abundance. For he who cannot restrain his desires, even if he should be surrounded by every kind of possessions, how can he ever be rich? Those, indeed, who are satisfied with their own property, enjoying what they have, and not casting a covetous eye on the substance of others, even if they be, as to means, of all men the most limited, ought to be regarded as the most affluent. For he who does not desire other people's possessions, but is willing to be satisfied with his own, is the wealthiest of all.

With your permission, let me return to the topic at hand. Scripture says, "It came to pass that Lazarus died, and he was carried up by angels" (Luke 16:22). Before I continue, I want to clear up a misunderstanding in your minds. Many people who lack proper instruction believe that the souls of those who die violent deaths become wandering spirits (demons).

However, with your permission, let us return to the proposed subject. "It came to pass," it is said, "that Lazarus died; and he was carried up by angels," (Luke xvi. 22.) Here, before I proceed, I desire to remove a wrong impression from your minds. For it is a fact that many of the less instructed think that the souls of those who die a violent death become wandering spirits, (demons.)

But this is not true. I repeat, it is not true. The souls of those who die a violent death do not become demons. Rather, it is the souls of those who live in sin that do so—not because their physis changes, but because in their desires they imitate the evil nature of demons. Christ showed this very thing to the Jews when He said, "You are the children of the devil" (John 8:44). He said they were the children of the devil, not because they were changed into a physis like his, but because they performed actions like his. That is why He adds, "For you will do the lusts of your father." John also says, "O generation of vipers, who has warned you to flee from the wrath to come? Therefore do works worthy of repentance. And do not think to say, 'We have Abraham for our father'" (Matthew 3:7-9). Scripture, therefore, is accustomed to base the laws of relationship not on natural origin, but on good or evil disposition. Those to whom anyone shows similarity of manners and actions—Scripture declares him to be their son or their brother.1

But this is not so. I repeat it is not so. For not the souls of those who die a violent death become demons, but rather the souls of those who live in sin; not that their nature is changed, but that in their desires they imitate the evil nature of demons. Showing this very thing to the Jews, Christ said, "Ye are the children of the devil," (John vii. 44.) He said that they were the children of the devil, not because they were changed into a nature like his, but because they performed actions like his. Wherefore also He adds:—- "For the lusts of your father ye will do." Also John says: "O generation of vipers, who hath warned you to flee from the wrath to come? Do therefore works meet for repentance. And think not to say, We have Abraham for our father" (Matt. iii. 7-9.) The Scripture, therefore, is accustomed to base the laws of relationship, not on natural origin, but on good or evil disposition; and those to whom any one shows similarity of manners and actions, the Scripture declares him to be their son or their brother.1

Chapter 2

But why did the evil one introduce this wicked saying? It is because he wants to undermine the glory of the martyrs. Since the martyrs also died a violent death, he did this intending to spread a low opinion of them. However, he cannot accomplish this; they remain in possession of their former glory. But he has brought about another and more serious thing: by these means, he has persuaded the sorcerers who do his work to murder many innocent children, expecting them to become wandering spirits and afterward to be their servants. But these ideas are false—I repeat, they are false. What if the demons say, "I am the spirit of such and such a monk"? Even because of this I do not believe the idea, since evil spirits say such things to deceive those who listen to them.2

But for what object did the evil one introduce this wicked saying? It is because he would strive to undermine the glory of the martyrs. For since these also died a violent death, he did this with the intention of spreading a low estimation of them. This, however, he is unable to effect; they remain in possession of their former glory. But another and more grievous thing he has brought to pass; he has, by these means, persuaded the wizards who do his work to murder many innocent children, expecting them to become wandering spirits, and afterward to be their servants. But these notions are false: I repeat they are false. What then if the demons say, "I am the spirit of such and such a monk"? Neither because of this do I credit the notion, since evil spirits say so to deceive those who listen to them.2

For this reason St Paul stopped their mouth, even when speaking the truth, in order that they might not, on this pretext, at another time mingle falsehood with the truth, and still be deemed worthy of credit. For when they said, "These men are the servants of the most high God, which show unto us the way of salvation" (Acts 16:17), being grieved in spirit, he rebuked the sorceress and commanded the spirits to go out. What evil was there in saying, "These men are the servants of the most high God"? Even so, since many of the weaker-minded cannot always know how to decide rightly concerning things spoken by demons, he immediately put a stop to any credence in them. "If," he implied, "you are one of those in dishonor, you have no freedom to speak: be silent, and do not open your mouth; it is not your job to preach; this is the privilege of the apostles. Why do you claim for yourself that which is not yours? Be silent! you have fallen from honor." Christ also did the same thing when the evil spirits said to Him, "We know who You are" (Mark 1:24; Luke 4:34). He rebuked them with great severity, teaching us never to listen to spirits, not even when they say what is true. Having learned this, therefore, let us not trust at all in an evil spirit, even though he speaks the truth; let us avoid him and turn away. Sound doctrine and saving truth are to be learned with accuracy, not from evil spirits, but from the Holy Scripture.

For this reason St Paul stopped their mouth, even when speaking the truth, in order that they might not, on this pretext, at another time mingle falsehood with the truth, and still be deemed worthy of credit. For when they said, "These men are the servants of the most high God, which show unto us the way of salvation," (Acts xvi. 17;) being grieved in spirit, he rebuked the sorceress, and commanded the spirits to go out. What evil was there in saying, "These men are the servants of the most high God"? Be that as it may, since many of the more weak-minded cannot always know how to decide aright concerning things spoken by demons, he at once put a stop to any credence in them. "If," he implied, "thou art one of those in dishonour, thou hast no liberty of speaking: be silent, and open not thy mouth; it is not thy office to preach; this is the privilege of the apostles. Why dost thou arrogate to thyself that which is not thine? Be silent! thou art fallen from honour." The same thing also Christ did, when the evil spirits said to Him, "We know Thee who Thou art," (Mark i. 24; Luke iv. 24.) He rebuked them with great severity, teaching us never to listen to spirits, not even when they say what is true. Having learnt this, therefore, let us not trust at all in an evil spirit, even though he speak the truth; let us avoid him and turn away. Sound doctrine and saving truth are to be learned with accuracy, not from evil spirits, but from the Holy Scripture.

To show that it is not true that the soul, when it departs from the body, comes under the control of evil spirits, listen to what St. Paul says: "He that is dead is freed from sin" (Rom. 6:7)—that is, he no longer sins. For if the devil cannot use violence against the soul while it lives in the body, it is clear that he cannot do so after the soul has departed. How is it then, they ask, that people sin, if they suffer no violence? They sin voluntarily and intentionally, surrendering themselves without compulsion or coercion. All those who have overcome the evil one's schemes prove this. For example, Satan was unable to persuade Job to utter any blasphemous word, though he tried a thousand plans. This makes it clear that it is in our power either to be influenced or not to be influenced by his suggestions, and that we are under no necessity or tyranny from him. Not only from what has just been said, but also from the parable, it is quite certain that souls, when they leave the body, do not linger here, but are immediately led away. Listen to how this is shown: "It came to pass," it says, "that he died, and was carried away by the angels." Not only the souls of the righteous, but also those of sinners are led away. This too is clear from the case of another rich man. For when his land produced abundantly, he said to himself, "What shall I do? I will pull down my barns and build greater ones" (Luke 12:18). Nothing could be more wretched than this state of mind. He did in fact pull down his barns, for secure storehouses are not built with walls of stone; they are "the mouths of the poor." But this man, neglecting these, was busy with stone walls. What, however, did God say to him? "You fool, this night they shall require your soul of you." Notice also: in one passage it says that the soul is carried away by angels; in the other, that "they require it"; and in the latter case they lead it away as a prisoner, while in the former they guard and conduct it as a crowned victor. Just as in the arena a combatant, having received many wounds and drenched with blood, has his head encircled with a crown, and those standing ready nearby take him up and with great applause and praise bear him home amid shouting and admiration—in this way the angels on that occasion led Lazarus away as well. But in the other case, dreadful powers, probably sent for that purpose, required the soul. For the soul does not depart this life of its own accord; indeed, it is not able to. For if when we travel from one city to another we need guides, much more does the soul need those who can conduct it when it is separated from the flesh and is entering upon the future state of existence. For this reason it often rises up and again sinks down into the depths below; it fears and trembles as it is about to put off the flesh. The consciousness of sin always pierces us, and especially at that hour when we are about to be led from here to give an account and face the dreadful tribunal. Then, if a man has robbed, if he has been greedy, if he has been arrogant, if he has unjustly been anyone's enemy, if he has committed any other sin whatsoever, all the burden of guilt is brought fresh to light and, being placed before the eye, causes mental anguish. And just as those who live in prison are always in sorrow and pain, and especially on that day when they are to be led out and brought to the place where they are to be tried, placed at the bar, and hear the voice of the judge within—as they are then full of fear and seem no better than dead men—so the soul, though it is greatly pained at the very moment of the sinful act, is much more afflicted when about to be hurried away.345

To show that it is not true that the soul, when it departs from the body, comes under the dominion of evil spirits, hear what St Paul says: "He that is dead is freed from sin," (Rom. vi. 7,) that is, he no longer sins. For if while the soul dwells in the body, the devil can use no violence against it, it is clear that he cannot when the soul has departed. How is it then, say they, that men sin, if they do not suffer any violence? They sin voluntarily and intentionally, surrendering themselves without compulsion or coercion. And this all those prove who have overcome the evil one's devices. Thus [Satan] was unable to persuade Job to utter any blasphemous word, though he tried a thousand plans. Hence it is manifest that it is in our power either to be influenced or not to be influenced by his counsels; and that we are under no necessity nor tyranny from him. And not only from that which has just been said, but from the parable, it is quite certain that souls when they leave the body do not still linger here, but are forthwith led away. And hear how it is shown: "It came to pass," it is said, "that he died, and was carried away by the angels." Not the souls of the just only, but also those of sinners are led away. This also is clear from the case of another rich man. For when his land brought forth abundantly, he said within himself, "What shall I do? I will pull down my barns and build greater," (Luke xii. 18.) Than this state of mind nothing could be more wretched. He did in truth pull down his barns; for secure storehouses are not built with walls of stone; they are "the mouths of the poor." But this man neglecting these, was busy about stone walls. What, however, did God say to him? " Thou fool, this night shall they require thy soul of thee." Mark also: in one passage it is said that the soul is carried away by angels; in the other, that " they require it;" and in the latter case they lead it away as a prisoner; in the former, they guard and conduct it as a crowned victor. And like as in the arena a combatant, having received many wounds, is drenched with blood; his head being then encircled with a crown, those who stand ready by the spot take him up, and with great applause and praise they bear him home amid shouting and admiration. In this way the angels on that occasion led Lazarus also away. But in the other instance dreadful powers, probably sent for that purpose, required the soul. For it is not of its own accord that the soul departs this life; indeed, it is not able. For if when we travel from one city to another we need guides, much more does the soul stand in want of those who can conduct it, when it is separated from the flesh, and is entering upon the future state of existence. For this reason it often rises up and again sinks down into the depth below; it fears and shivers as it is about to put off the flesh. The consciousness of sin ever pierces us, and chiefly at that hour when we are about to be led hence to the account there to be rendered, and to the awful tribunal. Then, if a man has robbed, if he has been covetous, if he has been haughty, if he has unjustly been any one's enemy, if he has committed any other sin whatsoever, all the load of guilt is brought fresh to light, and being placed before the eye causes mental compunction. And as those who live in prison are always in sorrow and pain, and especially on that day when they are to be led forth, and brought to the place where they are to be tried, and placed at the bar, and hear the voice of the judge within; as they then are full of fear, and seem no better than dead men, so the soul, though it is much pained at the very moment of the sinful act, is much more afflicted when about to be hurried away.345

Chapter 3

You are silent as you listen to these things. I would much rather have silence than applause. Applause and praises contribute to my own glory, but silence helps to make you wiser. I know that what has been said causes pain, but it also brings great and inexpressible benefit. That rich man, if he had had someone to warn him of these things, and had not had those flatterers always advising him with a view to currying favor and encouraging him in luxury, would not have come to the place of punishment. He would not have endured those unbearable tortures, he would not afterward have repented so inconsolably. But since all his associates spoke with a view to favor, they betrayed him to the fire. If only we could at all times and constantly act wisely with respect to these things, and speak in this way concerning future punishment! "In all your words," it is said, "remember your latter end, and you will never sin." And again, "Prepare your work for going forth, and make ready for your journey." If you have defrauded anyone of anything, restore it, and say with Zacchaeus, "I restore him fourfold." If you have slandered anyone, if you have been anyone's enemy, be reconciled before you come before the Judge. Settle every matter here, so that you may see that tribunal with an untroubled mind. As long as we are here we have good hope, but when we come there, we no longer have it in our power to repent or to cleanse ourselves from our sins. Therefore it is necessary to be always ready for our going there. For what if this evening it should seem good to the Lord to call us? What if He should do so tomorrow? The future is left uncertain, so that we may be constantly striving and prepared for departure. Thus Lazarus was at all times submissive and patient, and therefore he was led away with such honor. The rich man also died and was buried. His soul also was buried in the body as in a tomb, and carried about its sepulcher, the flesh. Having fettered his soul by drinking and gluttony as by a chain, he had thus made it inactive and dead.6

Ye are silent as ye listen to these things. Much rather would I have silence than applause. Applause and praises tend to my own glory; but silence tends to make you wiser. I know that what has been said causes pain, but it brings also great and inexpressible advantage. That rich man, if he had had some one to admonish him of these things, and had not had those flatterers counselling him always with a view to favour, and encouraging him in luxury, would not have come to the place of punishment; he would not have endured those insupportable tortures, he would not afterwards have repented so inconsolably. But since all his associates spoke with a view to favour, they betrayed him to the fire. Oh that we could at all times and constantly act wisely with respect to these things, and speak thus concerning future punishment! "In all thy words," it is said, "remember thy latter end, and thou wilt never sin," (Ecclus. vii. 36.) And again, "Prepare thy work for going forth, and make ready for thy journey," (Prov. xxiv. 27, LXX.) If thou hast defrauded any one of anything, restore it, and say with Zacchaeus "I restore him fourfold," (Luke xix. 8.) If thou hast slandered any, if thou hast been any one's enemy, be reconciled before thou comest before the Judge. Settle every affair here, that thou mayest see that tribunal with untroubled mind. As long as we are here we have good hope, but when we come there, we no longer have it in our power to repent nor to cleanse ourselves from our sins. Wherefore it is necessary to be always ready for our going thither. For what if this evening it should seem good to the Lord to call us? What if He should do so to-morrow? The future is left uncertain, that we may be constantly striving and prepared for departure. Thus then Lazarus was at all times submissive and patient, and therefore he was led away with such honour. The rich man also died and was buried: his soul also was buried in the body as in a tomb, and bore about its sepulchre, the flesh. Having fettered his soul by drinking and gluttony as by a chain, he had thus made it inactive and dead.6

Beloved, do not carelessly pass by this phrase "he was buried." Let us think about the tables inlaid with silver, the couches, the carpets, the garments, all the ornaments throughout the house, the perfumes, the scents, the abundance of wine, the variety of foods, the sweets, the cooks, the flatterers, the servants, the household slaves, and all the rest of the display—all burned up and come to nothing. Everything is ashes, everything is cinders and dust, lamentations and mourning. No one could any longer help him or bring back his departing soul. Then the real power of gold and all the rest of his wealth was revealed. From all that crowd of attendants, he departed naked and alone, unable to carry anything away from all that abundance. He went away destitute and deserted. No one of all his servants, no one of his supporters was there to rescue him from punishment. Led away from all these things, he was taken alone to bear those unbearable penalties. Truly "all flesh is as grass, and all the glory thereof as the flower of grass. The grass withereth, and the flower fadeth; but the word of the Lord abideth for ever" (Isa. xl. 6, 7). Death came and withered all those things, and seizing the man himself as a captive, led him away downcast, filled with shame, speechless, trembling, afraid—him who had, as in a dream, enjoyed all that luxury. And after this, the rich man became a beggar to the poor man and needed a supply from the table of the one who once was starving and who lay at his gate, licked by dogs. The situation was now reversed. Everyone now learned who was the rich man and who the poor, and that Lazarus was one of the wealthiest of men, and the rich man one of the most destitute. Just as in a play, certain men enter wearing masks of kings and generals and physicians and orators and sophists and soldiers, while in reality they are none of these—so also, with respect to the present life, both poverty and wealth are only masks. Therefore, when sitting in the theater and you see one of the actors on the stage wearing the mask of a king, you do not think him happy or think him really a king. You would not wish to become like him. Since you know that he is some common man or other—perhaps a rope-maker or a worker in brass or someone else of that sort—you do not think him happy because of his mask and his costume, nor do you judge his condition in life by these things, but you rather look down upon him because of his insignificance in other respects. So truly also, here in this present life, it is as if we were sitting in a theater and looking at the actors on the stage. When you see many people abounding in wealth, do not think that they are really wealthy, but dressed up in the appearance of wealth. And as one man, representing a king or a general on the stage, may often prove to be a household servant or one of those who sell figs or grapes in the market—so the rich man may often turn out to be the poorest of all. For if you remove his mask and examine his conscience and enter into his inner mind, you will find there great poverty in virtue and discover that he is the meanest of men. Also, in the theater, as evening closes in and the spectators depart, those who come forth stripped of their theatrical ornaments, who seemed to everyone to be kings and generals, are now seen to be whatever they really are. Even so with respect to this life, when death comes and the theater is emptied, when all, having put off their masks of wealth or of poverty, depart from here, being judged only by their works, they appear, some truly rich, some poor; some in honor, some in dishonor. Thus it often happens that one of those who are here the wealthiest is there the poorest, as was also the case with this rich man. For when evening, that is, death, came and he went out from the theater of the present life and put off his mask, he was seen there to be the poorest of all, so poor as not to possess a drop of water, but obliged to beg for this and not obtain what he asked for. What could be more miserable than poverty like this? And hear how, having lifted up his eyes, he said to Abraham, "Father, have mercy on me and send Lazarus, that he may dip the tip of his finger in water and cool my tongue" (Luke xvi. 24). Do you see how great his tribulation is? The one he passed by when he was close at hand, he now calls to from far off. The one upon whom he often, in going out and coming in, did not bestow a glance, he now, from far off, regards steadfastly.

Beloved, do not carelessly pass by this word "he was buried;" but let us think of the tables inlaid with silver, the couches, the carpets, the vestments, all the ornaments throughout the house, the unguents, the perfumes, the abundance of wine, the variety of meats, the confections, the cooks, the flatterers, the attendants, the household slaves, and all the rest of the display, all burnt up and come to nought. All is ashes, all cinders and dust, lamentations and mourning; no one any longer able to help him, or to bring back the departing soul. Then was made manifest the real power of gold, and of all the rest of his wealth. From all that crowd of attendants, he departed naked and alone, not being able out of all that abundance to carry anything away; but he went away destitute and deserted. No one of all his servants, no one of his supporters was at hand to rescue him from punishment, but led away from all these, he is alone taken to bear those insupportable penalties. Truly "all flesh is as grass, and all the glory thereof as the flower of grass. The grass withereth, and the flower fadeth; but the word of the Lord abideth for ever," (Isa. xl. 6, 7.) Death came and withered all those things, and seizing the man himself as a captive, led him away downcast, filled with shame, speechless, trembling, afraid; him who had, as in a dream, enjoyed all that luxury. And after this, the rich man became a suppliant of the poor man, and required a supply from the table of him who once was famishing, and who lay at his gate, licked by dogs. Affairs were now reversed. All men now learned which was the rich man and which the poor, and that Lazarus was one of the most wealthy of men, and the rich man one of the most destitute. Just as in a play, certain men enter, wearing masks of kings and generals, and physicians and orators, and sophists and soldiers, being themselves in reality none of these; thus also, with respect to the present life, both poverty and wealth are only masks. As, therefore, when sitting in the theatre, you see one of the players on the stage, having on the mask of a king, you do not think him happy, nor think him really a king; neither would you wish to become like him; but since you know that he is some common man or other—-a rope-maker, perhaps, or a worker in brass, or some one else of that sort, you do not think him happy because of his mask and his dress, nor do you judge of his condition in life by these things, but you rather look down upon him because of his insignificance in other respects. Thus in truth also, here in this present life, it is as if we were sitting in a theatre, and looking at the players on the stage. Do not, when you see many abounding in wealth, think that they are in reality wealthy, but dressed up in the semblance of wealth. And as one man, representing on the stage a king or a general, often may prove to be a household servant, or one of those who sell figs or grapes in the market; thus the rich, man may often chance to be the poorest of all. For if you remove his mask and examine his conscience, and enter into his inner mind, you will find there great poverty as to virtue, and ascertain that he is the meanest of men. As also, in the theatre, as evening closes in, and the spectators depart, those who come forth divested of their theatrical ornaments, who seemed to all to be kings and generals, now are seen to be whatever they are in reality; even so with respect to this life, when death comes, and the theatre is deserted, when all, having put off their masks of wealth or of poverty, depart hence, being judged only by their works, they appear, some really rich, some poor; some in honour, some in dishonour. Thus it often happens, that one of those who are here the most wealthy, is there most poor, as it was also in the case of this rich man. For when evening, that is, death, came, and he went out from the theatre of the present life, and put off his mask, he was seen there to be poorest of all, even so poor as not to possess a drop of water, but obliged to beg for this, and not gain the object of his petition. What could be more abject than poverty like this? And hear how having lifted up his eyes, he said to Abraham, "Father, have mercy on me and send Lazarus, that he may dip the tip of his finger in water and cool my tongue," (Luke xvi. 24.) Do you see how great his tribulation is? Him whom he passed by when he was close at hand, he now calls to when far off; him upon whom he often, in going out and coming in, did not bestow a glance, he now, when far off, regards steadfastly.

But why does he now look at him? Very often, perhaps, the rich man had said, "What need do I have of piety and goodness? Everything flows to me as from a never-ending fountain. I enjoy great honor, great prosperity. I suffer no unwanted misfortune. Why should I strive after goodness? This poor man, though he lives in piety and goodness, suffers a thousand troubles." Many people today often say such things. Therefore, in order that these false ideas might be completely rooted out, it is shown to the rich man that for wickedness there is punishment in store, and for righteous labor, a crown and honor. And not only for this reason did the rich man then see the poor man, but also so that the rich man should endure the same things that the poor man had endured, and to a greater degree. Therefore, just as in the case of the poor man, his being laid at the gate of the rich man and thus seeing another's prosperity had made his affliction much heavier, so also in the case of the rich man, it made his pain greater that he, now lying in the place of punishment, also sees the blessedness of Lazarus—so that not only by the very nature of torture, but by the contrast with the other's honor, he should bear more unbearable punishment. And just as God, when He drove Adam out of Paradise, caused him to dwell opposite Paradise, so that the constant sight, ever renewing his grief, might produce in him a sense of his falling away from good, so also did He place this man within sight of Lazarus, so that he might see what he had deprived himself of. "I sent to you," He might say, "this poor man Lazarus to your gate, so that he might be to you a teacher of virtue and an opportunity for the exercise of benevolence. You overlooked the gain; you were not willing to use this means of salvation rightly. From now on find it to be a cause of increased pain and punishment."7

But why does he now look at him? Very often, perhaps, the rich man had said, "What need have I of piety and goodness? All things flow to me as from a perennial fountain. I enjoy great honour, great prosperity. I suffer no unwished-for casualty. Why should I strive after goodness? This poor man, though he lives in piety and goodness, suffers a thousand ills." Many in these days often say such things. In order, therefore, that these false notions might be completely rooted out, it is shown to the rich man, that for wickedness there is in store punishment, and for righteous toil, a crown and honour. And not only on this account did the rich man then see the poor man, but also that the rich man should endure the same that the poor man had endured, and in a higher degree. As therefore, in the case of the poor man, his being laid at the gate of the rich man, and thus seeing the prosperity of another, had made his affliction much heavier, thus also, in the case of the rich man, it made his pain greater, that he, now lying in the place of punishment, also sees the bliss of Lazarus; so that, not only by the very nature of torture, but by the contrast with the other's honour, he should bear more insufferable punishment. And as God, when He drove Adam forth from Paradise, caused him to dwell opposite to Paradise, that the constant sight, ever renewing his grief, might produce in him a sense of his falling away from good; thus also did He place this man within sight of Lazarus, that he might see of what he had deprived himself. "I sent to thee," He might say, "this poor man Lazarus to thy gate, that he might be to thee a teacher of virtue, and an oportunity for the exercise of benevolence. Thou didst overlook the gain; thou wert not willing to use aright this means of salvation. From henceforth find it to be a cause of increased pain and punishment."7

We learn from this that all those we have treated spitefully or wronged will then meet us face to face. Yet this man was not wronged by the rich man in any way: the rich man did not seize any of his property, though he gave him nothing of his own. And because he gave him nothing, he had the neglected poor man as his accuser. What mercy can he expect who has robbed other people's goods, when he is surrounded by all those he has injured! There is no need for witnesses, no need for accusers, no need for evidence or proofs; the very deeds themselves, whatever we have committed, will then be placed before our own eyes.

We learn from this that all those whom we have de-spitefully treated or wronged will then meet us face to face. Still this man was not in any way wronged by the rich man: for the rich man did not seize any of his property; yet he bestowed not upon him any of his own. And since he did not bestow anything on him, he had the neglected poor man for his accuser. What mercy can he expect who has robbed other men's goods, when he is surrounded by all those whom he has injured! No need is there of witnesses, none of accusers, none of evidences or proofs; but the very deeds themselves, whatsoever we have committed, will then be placed before our own eyes.

Look, then, it is said, at the man and his works. This too is robbery—not to share our good things with others. It may very likely seem a strange statement to you, but do not be surprised by it, for I will bring testimony from the Divine Scriptures showing that not only the robbery of other men's goods, but also the failure to share our own good things with others—that this too is robbery, covetousness, and fraud. What then is this testimony? God, rebuking the Jews, speaks thus through the prophet: "The earth has brought forth her fruit, and you have not brought in the tithes; but the plunder of the poor is in your houses" (Malachi 3:10). Since, it is said, you have not given the customary offerings, you have robbed the poor. This is said to show the rich that they possess things which belong to the poor, even if their property was gained by inheritance—in fact, from whatever source their wealth comes. And again, in another place, it is said, "Do not deprive the poor of life" (Sirach 4:1). Now, he who deprives, deprives some other person of property. It is called deprivation when we keep things taken from others. And in this way, therefore, we are taught that if we do not give alms, we shall be treated the same way as those who have been extortioners. They are our Lord's things, from wherever we may obtain them. And if we distribute to the needy we shall obtain great abundance for ourselves. And this is why God has permitted you to possess much—not so that you should spend it on fornication, drunkenness, gluttony, rich clothing, or any other kind of luxury, but so that you should distribute it to the needy. And just as a tax collector, having charge of the king's property, would pay the penalty and come to ruin if he did not distribute it to those for whom it is intended, but spent it for his own enjoyment; so also the rich man is, as it were, a receiver of goods which are meant to be distributed to the poor—to those of his fellow-servants who are in need. If he then should spend on himself more than he really needs, he will pay a heavy penalty hereafter. For the things he has are not his own, but are the things of his fellow-servants.

Behold, then, it is said, the man and his works. This also is robbery—-not to impart our good things to others. Very likely it may seem to you a strange saying; but wonder not at it, for I will, from the Divine Scriptures, bring testimony showing that not only robbery of other men's goods, but also the not imparting our own good things to others,—-that this also is robbery, and covetous-ness, and fraud. What then is this testimony? God, rebuking the Jews, speaks thus through the prophet: "The earth has brought forth her fruit, and ye have not brought in the tithes; but the plunder of the poor is in your houses," (Mal. iii. 10.) Since, it is said, ye have not given the customary oblations, ye have robbed the poor. This is said in order to show to the rich that they possess things which belong to the poor, even if their property be gained by inheritance,—-in fact, from what source soever their substance be derived. And, again, in another place, it is said, "Do not deprive the poor of life," (Ecclus. iv. 1.) Now, he who deprives, deprives some other man of property. It is said to be deprivation when we retain things taken from others. And in this way, therefore, we are taught that if we do not bestow alms, we shall be treated in the same way as those who have been extortioners. Our Lord's things they are, from whencesoever we may obtain them. And if we distribute to the needy we shall obtain for ourselves great abundance. And for this it is that God has permitted you to possess much,—-not that you should spend it in fornication, in drunkenness, in gluttony, in rich clothing, or any other mode of luxury, but that you should distribute it to the needy. And just as if a receiver of taxes, having in charge the king's property, should not distribute it to those for whom it is ordered, but should spend it for his own enjoyment, he would pay the penalty and come to ruin; thus also the rich man is, as it were, a receiver of goods which are destined to be dispensed to the poor—-to those of his fellow-servants who are in want. If he then should spend upon himself more than he really needs, he will pay hereafter a heavy penalty. For the things he has are not his own, but are the things of his fellow-servants.

Chapter 5

Let us be as careful with our possessions as we would be with someone else's property, so that they may truly become our own. How can we be as careful with them as we would be with someone else's property? By not spending them on unnecessary things, nor only on our own needs, but by sharing them with the poor as well. Even if you are a rich man, if you spend more than you need, you will give an account of the property that has been entrusted to you. The same thing happens in great households. Many people in this way entrust their entire property into the hands of servants; yet those who are trusted in this way take care of the things given to them, and do not waste what has been entrusted, but distribute to whomever and whenever the master commands. Do the same thing yourself. If you have received more than others, you have received it not so that you alone should spend it, but so that you should be a good steward of it for the benefit of others.

Let us then be as sparing of our possessions as we should be of those of other people, that they may become really our own. In what manner, then, can we be as sparing of them as of those of other people? By not expending them on superfluous wants, nor for our own needs only, but by imparting them also to the poor. Even if you are a rich man, if you spend more than you need, you will render an account of the property which has been entrusted to you. This same thing happens in great households. Many in this way entrust their entire property into the hands of dependants; yet those who are thus trusted take care of the things delivered to them, and do not squander the deposit, but distribute to whomsoever and whensoever the master orders. The same thing do you. If you have received more than others, you have received it, not that you only should spend it, but that you should be a good steward of it for the advantage of others.

It is worth asking here why the rich man saw Lazarus not with any other righteous person, but in Abraham's bosom. Abraham was hospitable, and so that there might be this rebuke of his own lack of hospitality, the rich man saw Lazarus there. Abraham used to watch for those who passed by and persuade them to come into his home; but this rich man neglected even someone who lay at his very door, and though he had such a treasure, such an opportunity for salvation, he overlooked it every day and did not show kindness to the poor man, even regarding the necessities of life. But the patriarch was not like this. He was the complete opposite. Sitting at his tent door he caught, as it were, all those who passed by, and just as a fisherman casting his net into the sea pulls up fish and sometimes also gold or pearls, so he too, a fisher of men, once entertained even angels; and this was the wonderful thing about it, that he did so without knowing it. St Paul also emphasizes this same thing with great admiration in these words: "Be not forgetful to entertain strangers; for thereby some have entertained angels unawares." And he rightly says "unawares," for if they had knowingly received them with such goodwill, they would have done nothing great or wonderful. All the praise depends on the fact that not knowing who they were that passed by, and supposing them to be simply travelers, they invited them in with such eagerness. If when you receive some noble and distinguished man you display such enthusiasm, you do nothing wonderful; for the nobility of the guest often compels even the inhospitable to show all kindness. This is what is great and admirable—that when they are chance guests, wanderers, people of modest means, we receive them with great goodwill. Christ also, speaking of those who acted in this way, said: "Inasmuch as you have done it to one of the least of these, you have done it to Me." And again, "It is not the will of your Father that one of these little ones should perish." And again, "Whoever offends one of these little ones, it would be better for him that a millstone were hung around his neck and that he were cast into the sea." And at all times Christ said much on behalf of the poor and lowly.8

It is worth while to inquire here, why it was that the rich man beheld Lazarus, not in company with any other of the just, but in the bosom of Abraham? Abraham was hospitable, and that there might be this rebuke of his own inhospitality, therefore it was that the rich man saw Lazarus there. Abraham used to lie in wait for those who passed by, and constrain them to enter his abode; but this rich man neglected even one that lay within his very porch; and while he had such a treasure, such an opportunity of salvation, overlooked it each day, and did not show kindness to the poor man, even with respect to the necessaries of life. But the patriarch was not like this. He was the very opposite. Sitting at the tent-door he captured, as it were, all those that passed by, and as a fisher casting his net into the sea, draws up fishes, and draws up also, it may be, sometimes gold or pearls, so also he, a fisher of men, once entertained even angels; and there was this wonderful circumstance, that he did so without knowing it. The same thing also St Paul with much admiration insists on, in these words: "Be not forgetful to entertain strangers; for thereby some have entertained angels unawares," (Heb. xiii. 2.) And well does he say unawares, (e1laqon.) For if they had knowingly received them with such good-will, they would have done no great or wonderful thing: all the praise depends on the fact that not knowing who they were that passed by, and supposing them to be simply wayfaring men, they with such alacrity invited them to enter. If when you receive some noble and honourable man you display such zeal as this, you do nothing wonderful; for the nobility of the guest obliges even the inhospitable often to show all kindness. It is this that is great and admirable,—-that when they are chance guests, wanderers, people of limited means, we receive them with great good-will. Thus also Christ, speaking of those who acted thus, said: "Inasmuch as ye have done it unto one of the least of these, ye have done it unto Me," (Matt. xxv. 45.) And again, "It is not the will of your Father that one of these little ones should perish," (Matt. xviii. 14.) And again, "Whoso shall offend one of these little ones, it were better for him that a millstone were hanged about his neck, and that he were cast into the sea," (Matt. xviii. 6.) And at all times Christ said much on behalf of the poor and lowly.8

Since Abraham was also wise in this way, he did not ask travelers who they were or where they came from, as we do nowadays. Instead, he simply received everyone who passed by. A truly well-disposed person should not demand an account of someone's past life, but simply relieve poverty and satisfy need. The poor man has only one plea—his poverty and his being in want. Demand nothing more from him. Even if he is the most wicked of all and is in need of necessary food, you ought to satisfy his hunger. This is what Christ commanded us to do when he said, "Be ye like your Father which is in heaven, for He maketh His sun to shine on the evil and on the good, and sendeth rain on the just and on the unjust" (Matt. v. 45). The merciful man is like a harbor to those who are in need. A harbor receives all who are escaping shipwreck and frees them from danger, whether they are evil or good. Whatever kind of people they are who are in peril, it receives them into its shelter. You also, when you see a man suffering shipwreck on land through poverty, do not sit in judgment on him or require explanations, but relieve his distress. Why give yourself unnecessary trouble? God frees you from all such anxiety and labor. How many things would many men have said, and how many difficulties would they have caused, if God had commanded us to inquire carefully into a man's life, his background, the things each man had previously done, and only then to have pity on him! But now we are free from all this trouble. Why, then, do we burden ourselves with superfluous cares? To be a judge is one thing; to be merciful is another. Mercy is called by that name for this reason: it gives even to the unworthy. This is what St. Paul also teaches when he says, "Be not weary in doing good, indeed to all, but especially unto them that are of the household of faith" (Gal. vi. 10). If we are concerned and troubled about keeping the unworthy away, it is not likely that the worthy will come within our reach. But if we give to the unworthy, the worthy—even those who are so worthy as to counterbalance all the rest—will assuredly come under our influence. This is what happened to Abraham, of blessed memory, who, not troubling himself or being curious about these wayfarers, was once privileged to entertain even angels. Let us zealously imitate him, and also his descendant Job. For Job also imitated with all diligence the magnanimity of his ancestor, and therefore spoke thus: "My door was open to every traveller" (Job xxxi. 32, LXX). It was not open to one and closed to another, but open to all alike.

Since Abraham also was wise in this respect, he did not inquire of travellers as to who they were, or from whence they came, as we do in these days; but he simply received all who passed by. It becomes him that is truly well-disposed not to require an account of a man's past life, but simply to relieve poverty and to satisfy want. The poor man has only one plea—-his poverty, and his being in want. Demand from him nothing more; but if he be the most wicked of all, and be in need of necessary food, you ought to satisfy his hunger. Thus did Christ command us to do, when he said, "Be ye like your Father which is in heaven, for He maketh His sun to shine on the evil and on the good, and sendeth rain on the just and on the unjust," (Matt. v. 45.) The merciful man is as a harbour to those who are in need; and the harbour receives all who are escaping shipwreck, and frees them from danger, whether they be evil or good; whatsoever kind of men they be that are in peril, it receives them into its shelter. You also, when you see a man suffering shipwreck on land through poverty, do not sit in judgment on him, nor require explanations, but relieve his distress. Why do you give yourself unnecessary trouble? God frees you from all such anxiety and labour. How many things would many men have said, and how many difficulties would they have caused, if God had commanded us to inquire accurately into a man's life, his antecedents, the things which each man had previously done; and after this, to have pity on him! But now are we free from all this trouble. "Why, then, do we burden ourselves with superfluous cares? To be a judge is one thing, to be merciful is another. Mercy is called by that name for this reason, that it gives even to the unworthy. This again St Paul teaches, when he says, "Be not weary in doing good, indeed to all, but especially unto them that are of the household of faith," (Gal. vi. 10.) If we are concerned and troubled about keeping the unworthy away, it will not be likely that the worthy come within our reach; but if we impart to the unworthy, also the worthy —-even those who are so worthy as to counterbalance all the rest—-will assuredly come under our influence. In this way it befell Abraham, of blessed memory, who, not troubling himself nor being inquisitive about these wayfarers, was once privileged to entertain even angels. Him let us zealously imitate, and also his descendant Job. For even he imitated with all diligence the magnanimity of his progenitor, and therefore spoke thus: "My door was open to every traveller," (Job xxxi. 32, LXX.) It was not open to one and. closed to another, but open to all alike.

Chapter 6

Therefore, I urge you, let us also act in this way, not making a more detailed investigation than necessary. For the need of the poor person is a sufficient reason in itself; and whoever comes to us with this qualification at any time, let us not trouble ourselves further. For we do not serve the character, but the person: we have pity on him, not because of his virtue, but because of his misfortune, so that we also may receive that great mercy from the Lord—that we also, though unworthy, may gain His favor. For if we seek for worthiness in our fellow-servants and make careful inquiry, God will do the same to us; and if we demand explanations from our fellow-servants, we ourselves will fail to gain favor from above. "With what judgment," it is said, "you judge, you shall be judged" (Matt. 7:2).9

Thus, I beseech you, let us also do, not making a more minute inquiry than is necessary. For the need of the poor man is a sufficient cause of itself; and whosoever with this qualification should at any time come to us, let us not trouble ourselves further; for we do not minister to the character, but to the man: we have pity on him, not on account of his virtue, but on account of his calamity, in order that we also may gain that great mercy from the Lord—-that we also, though unworthy, may gain His favour. For if we seek for worthiness in our fellow-servants, and make diligent inquiry, the same also will God do to us; and if we demand explanations from our fellow-servants, we ourselves shall fail to gain favour from above. "With what judgment," it is said, "ye judge, ye shall be judged," (Matt. viii. 2.)9

But let us turn our discussion back to the matter at hand. Seeing this poor man in the bosom of Abraham, the rich man said, "Father Abraham, have mercy on me, and send Lazarus." Why doesn't he speak directly to Lazarus? It seems to me that he was ashamed and afraid, and that he thought Lazarus would certainly remember with anger the things that had been done to him. He would say to himself, "If I, while I enjoyed such abundance and had no legitimate complaint against him, neglected this man when he lived in such misery and didn't even give him the crumbs, how much more will he who has been so neglected refuse to show pity." We're not saying this to criticize Lazarus, for he was not at all that way—far from it. But the rich man, fearing such a response, did not address him. Instead, he called out to Abraham, whom he might suppose was unaware of what had happened. And now he tried to obtain the service of that finger which he had often allowed to be licked by dogs.

But let us again turn our discourse to the subject on hand. Seeing this poor man, therefore, in the bosom of Abraham, the rich man said, "Father Abraham, have mercy on me, and send Lazarus." Why does he not address his words to Lazarus? It seems to me that he was ashamed and daunted, and that he thought that Lazarus would assuredly retain an angry remembrance of the things done to him. He would say within himself, "If I, while I enjoyed such abundance, and without any just complaint against him, neglected this man when he lived in such misery, and did not bestow upon him even the crumbs, much more will he who has been thus neglected, not yield to pity." We do not say this to disparage Lazarus; for he was not at all thus disposed—-far from it; but the rich man, fearing such things as this, did not address him, but raised his voice to Abraham, whom he might suppose to be ignorant of what had happened. And now he strove to gain the service of that finger which he had often allowed to be licked by dogs.

What then did Abraham say to him? "Son! You in your lifetime received your good things." (Luke 16:25) Notice the wisdom—notice the tenderness of the saint! He did not say, "Inhuman and cruel man! Full of all wickedness! Having inflicted such evils on this man, do you now speak of benevolence, or pity, or compassion! Do you not blush! Are you not ashamed!" But what does he say? "Son," he says, "you received your good things." For it is also written, "You shall not add trouble to an afflicted soul." (Sirach 4:3) The trouble he has brought upon himself is sufficient. Besides this, and so that you may not suppose that he prevents Lazarus from going to the rich man because of any feeling of revenge for the past, Abraham addresses him as "son," as if he would by this form of address excuse himself. "Whatever is in my power," he implies, "I grant to you; but to leave this place is not now in my power. You did receive your good things." Why also did he not say "you had" (elabes), but "you received" (apelabes)? Here I perceive a vast sea of thought opening out before us.

What then did Abraham say to him? "Son! thou in thy lifetime receivedst thy good things," (Luke xvi. 25.) Mark the wisdom—-mark the tenderness of the saint! He did not say, "Inhuman and cruel man! full of all wickedness! Having inflicted such evils on this man, dost thou now speak of benevolence, or pity, or compassion! Dost thou not blush! Art thou not ashamed!" But what does he say? "Son," he saith, "thou receivedst thy good things." For it is also written, "Thou shalt not add trouble to an afflicted soul," (Ecclus. iv. 3.) The trouble which he has brought upon himself is sufficient. Besides this, and to the end that you may not suppose that he hinders Lazarus from going to the rich man because of any feeling of revenge for the past, Abraham addresses him as "son," as if he would by this mode of address apologise for himself. "Whatever is in my power," he implies, "I grant to thee; but to leave this place is not now in my power. Thou didst receive thy good things." Why also did he not say "thou hadst" ( ἔλαβες), but "thou receivedst" ( ἀπέαβες)? Here I perceive a vast sea of thought opening out before us.

So, keeping carefully in mind everything that has already been said—both what was said today and what was said yesterday—let us store it safely in our minds. Through what has been said, make yourselves better prepared to hear what will be spoken on another occasion, and if possible, remember everything that has been said. If that is not possible, I ask that above all you will constantly remember this: that not to share our own wealth with the poor is theft from the poor and deprives them of their livelihood, and that what we possess belongs not only to us but also to them. If our minds are shaped by this truth, we will use all our possessions generously; we will feed Christ when he hungers here, and we will store up great treasures there; we will be able to attain future blessedness, by the grace and favor of our Lord, with whom, to the Father and the Holy Spirit, be glory, honor, might, now and ever, even to all eternity. Amen.

Therefore, keeping in mind with all care the things which have been already said, as well those now said as those yesterday, let us safely store them in the mind. By means of that which has been said, make yourselves better prepared to hear that which will be spoken on another occasion, and, if possible, remember all that has been said; and if that be not possible, I beg that, chiefest of all, you will remember constantly that not to share our own riches with the poor is a robbery of the poor, and a depriving them of their livelihood; and that that which we possess is not only our own, but also theirs. If our minds are disposed in accordance with this truth, we shall freely use all our possessions; we shall feed Christ while hungering here, and we shall lay up great treasures there; we shall, be enabled to attain future blessedness, by the grace and favour of our Lord, with whom, to the Father and the Holy Spirit, be glory, honour, might, now and ever, even to all eternity. Amen.


Four Discourses on the Rich Man and Lazarus — Discourse 1

Preached at Antioch after a pagan festival: against drunkenness, why a teacher must not despair of his hearers, and the opening of the parable of the rich man and Lazarus.

Source: John Chrysostom, Four discourses, chiefly on the parable of the Rich man and Lazarus (1869) Discourse 1. pp.1-37.. Transcribed by Roger Pearse (tertullian.org); public domain.

Contents · 12 chapters
  1. Discourse 1 — A Homily Delivered at Antioch on the Second Day of the Month
  2. Chapter 1
  3. Chapter 2
  4. Chapter 3
  5. Chapter 4
  6. Chapter 5
  7. Chapter 6
  8. Chapter 8
  9. Chapter 9
  10. Chapter 10
  11. Chapter 11
  12. Chapter 12

Discourse 1 — A Homily Delivered at Antioch on the Second Day of the Month

Concerning drunkards and those who frequent taverns, and festive processions in the streets—a teacher should not despair of his disciples even while they disregard his words—also, concerning Lazarus and the rich man.

CONCERNING DRUNKARDS AND FREQUENTERS OF TAVERNS, AND FESTAL PROCESSIONS IN THE STREETS—-A TEACHER OUGHT NOT TO DESPAIR OF HIS DISCIPLES EVEN 'WHILE THEY DISREGARD HIS WORDS—-ALSO, CONCERNING LAZARUS AND THE RICH MAN.

Chapter 1

Yesterday, on the festival of Satan, you celebrated a spiritual feast, welcoming with great favor the word we spoke to you. You spent a large part of the day drinking in that rapture which is full of sobriety, and rejoicing together with Saint Paul. In this way you gained a double benefit, since you were both separated from the disorderly crowd of feasters and rejoiced in a spiritual and proper manner. You also partook of that cup, not overflowing with unmixed wine, but filled with spiritual teaching. While others were following the festive gatherings of the evil one, you, by your presence in this place, prepared yourselves as instruments of spiritual music and surrendered your souls to the Divine Spirit so that He might influence them and breathe His own grace into your hearts. Thus you produced a melody of perfect harmony, pleasing not only to men but also to the heavenly powers.

Yesterday, on the festival of Satan, ye celebrated a spiritual feast, receiving with all favour the word we addressed to you; spending a great portion of the day in thus drinking in that rapture which is full of sobriety, and rejoicing in company with St Paul. In this way ye gained a twofold benefit, since ye were both separate from the disorderly throng of feasters, and rejoiced in a spiritual and decorous manner. Ye also partook of that cup, not overflowing with unmixed wine, but filled with spiritual instruction. While others were following the festive companies of the evil one, ye, by your presence in this place, prepared yourselves as instruments of spiritual music, and surrendered your souls to the Divine Spirit that He might influence them, and breathe His own grace into your hearts. Thus ye gave forth a melody of perfect harmony, pleasing not only to men but also to the heavenly powers.

Let us, therefore, today take up arms against drunkenness and expose the foolishness of a drunk and dissolute life. Let us oppose those who live in self-indulgence—not to shame them, but to put them beyond the reach of shame; not to blame them, but to reform them; not to hold them up to contempt, but to turn them away from all dishonorable exposure and snatch them from the grip of the tempter. For whoever lives daily in excess of wine and luxury and gluttony is under the very tyranny of the devil. And how I wish something better may come from our words! However, should they continue in the same course after our warning, we will not for that reason stop giving right counsel. For springs continue to flow even if no one drinks from them, and fountains still burst forth though no one should use their water, and rivers still run on though no one benefits from them. So then, it is also right that the preacher should fulfill all his duty, even if no one pays attention to his voice.

Let us, therefore, to-day, take up arms against inebriety, and expose the folly of a drunken and dissolute life. Let us oppose those who live in intemperance; not that we may shame them, but that we may put them beyond the reach of shame; not that we may blame them, but reform them; not that we may hold them up to contempt, but that we may turn them from all dishonourable exposure, and snatch them from the grasp of the tempter. For he who lives daily in excess of wine and luxury and. gluttony is under the very tyranny of the devil. And oh that something better may result from our words! Should they, however, continue in the same course after our warning, we shall not on that account cease from giving right counsel. For the springs, even if no one drink of them, continue to flow; and fountains, though no one should use their water, still burst forth; and rivers, though no man profit by them, still run on. So then, also, it is right that the preacher, even if no one attend to his voice, should fulfil all his duty.

God has given a law to those entrusted with the ministry of the word, rooted in His love for humanity: they must never stop fulfilling the duties of their office or fall silent, whether people listen to them or ignore them. Jeremiah proclaimed many threats and warnings of coming disasters to the Jews, but those who heard him mocked and ridiculed him all day long. Because of human weakness, he felt unable to bear the scorn and insults, and at one point he tried to escape from his ministry. Listen to what he says about this: "I am in derision daily; then I said, I will not make mention of Him, nor speak any more in the name of the Lord. But His word was in mine heart as a burning fire shut up in my bones, and I was weary with forbearing, and I could not stay" (Jer. 20:7, 9). This is what he means: "I wanted to stop prophesying, since the Jews would not listen to me. But all the while I wanted this, the influence of the Holy Spirit penetrated like fire into my innermost soul, consuming my inner being and my bones, devouring me so that I could not endure the burning." So if Jeremiah, who was laughed at and mocked every day and wanted to be silent, suffered such punishment, what forgiveness can we deserve if we grow faint because some people are slow to respond and we stop instructing them—especially when there are so many who do pay attention?

For also in His love to man, a law is given by God to those who are entrusted with the ministry of the word, never to cease to discharge the duties of their office nor to be silent, whether the people have regard to their voice, or whether they neglect it. Jeremiah, therefore, having declared many threatenings to the Jews and warnings of future evils, was mocked by those who heard his voice, and was ridiculed all the day long. From human infirmity, feeling unable to endure scoffs and reviling, he at one time endeavoured to escape from his ministry. Hear him speak concerning this when he says: "I am in derision daily; then I said, I will not make mention of Him, nor speak any more in the name of the Lord. But His word was in mine heart as a burning fire shut up in my bones, and I was weary with forbearing, and I could not stay," (Jer. xx. 7, 9.) This it is which he says;—- "I was desirous to escape from prophesying, since the Jews did not listen to me; and all the while I was desiring this, the influence of the Holy Spirit penetrated like fire into my inmost soul, consuming all my inward parts and my bones, and devouring me, so that I could not endure the burning." If, therefore, he, when he was laughed at and derided each day; when he desired to be silent, underwent such punishment; of what forgiveness can we be worthy, who never at any time are treated thus, if we faint on account of the slowness of some, and cease from instructing them, and especially when there are so many who are attentive!

Chapter 2

I do not say these things to console or comfort myself, for I have made up my mind that as long as I breathe, and as long as God sees fit for me to remain in this present life, I will fulfill this ministry and do the work assigned to me, whether anyone pays attention or not. But since there are some who discourage many people, and who not only contribute nothing useful to our present life but also weaken the zeal of others through mockery and ridicule, saying: "Stop giving advice; quit warning them; they don't listen to you: you have no sympathy for them"—since there are those who say such things—I address you at length in order to drive out this wicked and gloomy idea, this satanic counsel, from the minds of many. I know that such things were said even yesterday by many who, when they saw certain people spending time in taverns, said, laughing and mocking: "Are these fully persuaded? These are the ones who never enter a tavern! Have they all arrived at wisdom?" What are you saying, man? Is this what we set out to do, to catch everyone in the net in one day? For if only ten were persuaded—if only five—if even one—is not this sufficient to console us? For my part I can go even further than this. Suppose that no one were persuaded by our words, although it is impossible that the word spoken to so many hearers can be fruitless—suppose, however, even this—still the word would not be without benefit.

I do not say these things to console or to comfort myself, for I have made up my mind, as long as I breathe, and as long as it shall seem good to God that I remain in this present life, to fulfil this ministry, and, whether any one attends or not, to do the work allotted to me. But since there are some who weaken the hands of many, and who, besides that they bring forward nothing useful for our present life, and relax the zeal of others, by derision and ridicule, saying: "Cease counselling; leave off warning; they do not attend to you: you have no fellow-feeling with them;"—-since there are those who say such things,—-purposing to expel this wicked and morose idea, this satanic counsel, from the minds of many, I address you thus at length. I know that such things were said even yesterday by many who, when they saw certain people spending time in taverns, said, laughing and deriding: "Are these fully persuaded? These are they who never enter a tavern! Have they all arrived at wisdom?" What dost thou say, O man? Is it this that we undertook to do, to enclose all in the net in one day? For if ten only were persuaded—-if only five,—-if even one,—-is not this sufficient to console us? For my part I can even go beyond this. Suppose that none were persuaded by our words, although it is impossible that the word spoken to so many hearers can be fruitless—-suppose, however, even this, —-still the word would not be without profit.

For even if they did enter a tavern, they did not enter it with the same shamelessness as they usually did. Even at the festive table they often thought of our words—the rebuke, the blame. When they remembered these things, they would be ashamed and would inwardly blush. And though they continued to act in their usual way, they did not do so with their usual recklessness. This is the beginning of salvation and of the best kind of change—namely, being ashamed to some degree and disapproving to some extent of what is being done. Besides this, another gain comes to us from this work of ours, and it is not a small one. What is it? It is making those who are already wise more careful. It is persuading them by the word spoken that they are the best advised of all people, since they are not led away with the multitude. Did I not restore the sick to health? But I strengthened those who were well. Did the word not lead anyone away from their sin? But it made more steadfast those who were living virtuously.

For, if they did enter a tavern, they did not enter it with such shamelessness as was their wont; but even at the festive table they often thought of our words—-of the rebuke,—-of the blame; which, when they remembered, they would be ashamed—-they would inwardly blush. Neither, though acting in their usual way, did they do so with their usual recklessness. And this is the beginning of salvation, and of the best kind of change—-namely, the being in any degree ashamed—-the disapproving in some measure of that which was being done. Besides this, another and not smaller gain accrues to us from this our work. What then is it? It is the making those who are already wise more careful. It is the persuading them by the word spoken that they are of all men the best advised, since they are not led away with the multitude. I did not restore the sick to health? But I strengthened those that were well. The word did not lead any away from their sin? But it made more steadfast those who were living virtuously.

I'll add a third reason to these. Have I not persuaded you today? But perhaps I'll persuade you tomorrow. Or even if not tomorrow, I may the day after, or the day following that. The person who hears and rejects the word today may perhaps hear and obey tomorrow; the one who spurns the word today and tomorrow may perhaps in a few more days pay attention to what is spoken. For even the fisherman often casts his net all day long in vain, and in the evening, when he is about to leave, he captures and takes home the fish that had escaped him all day. And if, because of frequent lack of success, we were to live in idleness and stop all work, our whole life would come to nothing, and not only spiritual matters but also worldly ones would be ruined. For the farmer too, if because of one, two, or many times of bad weather he were to abandon his work, we would all die of starvation. Again, if the sailor, because of one, two, or many recurring storms, were to abandon the sea, the ocean would become impassable, and in that way our life would also be completely ruined. Thus, going through all occupations, if people were to act as you urge and advise us to do, everything would utterly fail, and the earth would become uninhabitable. All people, therefore, keeping this in mind, if once, twice, or even often they fail to achieve the goal of the work they're doing, still apply themselves to the work again with undiminished eagerness.

To these reasons I will add a third. I have not persuaded to-day? But I shall persuade, perhaps, to-morrow. Or even if not to-morrow, I may after to-morrow, or even the day following. He who to-day heard and rejected the word, perhaps will hear and obey to-morrow; he who spurns the word to-day and to-morrow, perhaps in a few more days will attend to that which is spoken. For even the fisherman often casts his net the whole day in vain; and in the evening, when he is about to depart, captures and takes home the fish that had escaped him all the day long. And if, on account of frequent want of success, we were to live in idleness, and cease from all work, our whole life would be brought to nought, and not only spiritual affairs but also temporal would be ruined. For also the husbandman, if on account of the once, or twice, or oft-repeated inclemency of the season, were to abandon his work, we all should perish by famine. Again, it the mariner, on account of the once, or twice, or oft-recurring storms, were to forsake the sea, the ocean would become impassable, and in that way also our life would be quite marred. Thus, going through all employments, if men should act as you urge and advise us to do, all would utterly fail, and the earth would become uninhabitable. All men, therefore, having this in view, if once, or twice, or if often they fail to gain the object of the labour in which they spend their time, still apply themselves to the work again with undiminished alacrity.

Chapter 3

Knowing all these things, beloved, let us not, I beg you, speak this way; let us not say, "What is the point of such talks? They produce no good results." A farmer who sows once, twice, or many times in the same field and fails to profit from it labors again on the same ground, and often recovers in one good year all the loss from his previous efforts. It often happens that a merchant, suffering many shipwrecks, does not avoid the sea; instead he prepares his ship, hires sailors, and spends money again on the same kind of venture, even though the future is just as uncertain as before. And everyone who is accustomed to working in any occupation behaves the same way as the farmer and the merchant. If they show such dedication in the affairs of this life, even though the outcome is uncertain, shall we stop immediately just because people don't listen when we speak? What excuse will we have? Besides, in their misfortunes, no one consoles them for their loss, no one who, if the sea swallows the ship, will remove the poverty caused by the wreck. If rain floods the field and destroys the seed, the farmer must necessarily return home empty-handed. But for us who preach and warn people, the situation is different. For when you sow the seed and the hearer does not receive it and does not produce the fruit of obedience, you still have the reward of your intention stored up with God; and you will receive the same reward whether the hearer obeys or disobeys, because you have done everything required of you.

Knowing, then, all these things, beloved, let us not, I beseech you, speak in this way; let us not say, "What is the need of such discourses? No good results from them." The husbandman once, or twice, or often sowing in the same field, and failing to profit by it, labours again in the same ground, and often recovers in one good year the loss of all his previous time. It often happens that the merchant, suffering from many shipwrecks, does not shun the sea; but prepares his vessel, and hires seamen, and spends money again in the same kind of undertaking, although the future is as uncertain as before. And all who are accustomed to engage in any occupation whatever act in the same way as the husbandman and the merchant. If then they show such zeal in the affairs of this life, although the result is doubtful, shall we, because when we speak we are not listened to, immediately desist? What excuse shall we have? Besides, in their misfortunes, there is no one to console them for their loss, no one who, if the sea engulf the ship, will remove the poverty caused by the wreck. If the rain flood the field and cause the seed to perish, the husbandman must of necessity return home with empty hands. But with us, who preach and warn men, the case is not so. For when thou sowest the seed, and the hearer receives it not, and does not bring forth the fruit of obedience, thou hast the reward of thy intent, laid up with God; and thou wilt receive the same recompense whether the hearer obey or disobey; for thou hast performed all thy duty.

We are not responsible for failing to convince those who hear us, but only for offering them counsel. It is our duty to warn; paying attention to the warning is their duty. And just as, if they do many good deeds without any exhortation from us, all the benefit would be theirs alone, since we did not counsel them; so, if they pay no attention when we warn them, all the punishment falls on them. There is no accusation against us, but rather a great reward from God awaits us, since we have fulfilled our duty. We are commanded only to give the money to the exchangers—that is, to speak and to give counsel. Therefore, speak and warn your brother. Does he not listen? Still you have your reward prepared. Only always act this way, and never give up as long as life continues, until you succeed in bringing about conversion. Let the end of your giving counsel be his acceptance of your warning.1

We are not responsible for not convincing those who hear, but only for giving them counsel. It is ours to warn; to give heed to the warning is theirs. And just as, if they do many good deeds without our giving any exhortation, all the gain would be theirs only, since we did not counsel them; so, if they give no heed when we warn, all the punishment falls on them; against us there is no accusation, but rather a great reward from God awaits us, since we have discharged our duty. We are commanded only to give the money to the exchangers, that is, to speak and to give counsel. Speak, therefore, and warn thy brother. He listens not? Still thou hast thy reward prepared. Only always act thus, and never give up as long as life lasts, until you succeed in producing conversion. Let the termination of your giving counsel be the reception of your warning.1

The Tempter constantly works to undermine our salvation, though he himself gains nothing and is in fact the ultimate loser in his efforts. Yet he is so consumed with madness that he often attempts impossible things, attacking not only those he expects to make stumble or fall completely, but also those who will very likely escape his traps. So when he heard Job praised by God, who knows all secrets, he thought he could overcome him, and in his cunning he kept trying every method and device to make the man fall. The Spirit of all evil and wickedness did not hold back from the attempt, even though God had attributed such grace to that righteous man. Are we not ashamed, then? Tell me, do we not blush when the Enemy never despairs of accomplishing our ruin but always expects it, while we despair of the salvation of our brothers and sisters? In fact, Satan should have stayed away from the contest before even attempting it, since it was God himself who testified to the virtue of the righteous man. Still he did not stop, but because of his insane hatred of us, even after God's favorable testimony, he hoped to deceive that righteous man. In our case there is no such circumstance to make us despair, and yet we give up! The devil, even though forbidden by God, does not stop fighting against us; but you, while God commands and urges you to recover the fallen, run away from the work! The tempter heard God saying: A righteous man, faithful, God-fearing, and abstaining from every evil work, and that there was none like him on the earth. Yet after such strong and lofty testimony in favor of Job, he persisted and said: "Will I not eventually, through the constant pressure and magnitude of the evils I bring upon him, be able to trap him and overthrow this great pillar?"

The Tempter continually goes to and fro to baffle our salvation, while he himself gains nothing, but rather is to the last degree a loser by his zeal; but still so maddened is he, that he often attempts impossible things, and attacks not only those whom he expects to cause utterly to stumble or fall, but also those who in all probability will escape his snares. Therefore, when he heard Job praised by that God who knows all secrets, he thought to be able to overcome, nor did he in his guile cease trying every method and every device in order to cause the man to fall. The Spirit of all evil and wickedness did not shrink from the attempt, though God had ascribed such grace to that just man. Are not we then ashamed? Tell me, do we not blush if, while the Enemy never despairs of accomplishing our ruin, but always expects it, we despair of the salvation of our brethren? In fact, Satan ought, before the attempt, to have abstained from the contest, for it was God himself who testified to the virtue of the righteous man. Still he did not desist, but because of his mad hatred of us, he, even after the favourable testimony of God himself, hoped to deceive that just man. In our case there is no such circumstance to cause us to despair, and still we desist! The devil, also, although forbidden by God, does not cease from fighting against us; but thou, whilst God enjoins and incites thee to the recovery of the fallen, dost fly from the work! The tempter heard God saying: A just man, true, God-fearing, and abstaining from every evil work, and that there was none like him on the earth; yet after such strong and high testimony in favour of Job, he persevered, and said: "Shall I not at length, by the continuousness and greatness of the evils brought upon him, be able to circumvent him, and overthrow this great pillar?"

Chapter 4

What forgiveness, then, will there be for us if, while we face such fury from the evil one against ourselves, we don't apply even the smallest part of this zeal for the salvation of our brothers and sisters—especially when in these matters we have God as our helper! For when you see your brother wicked and bitter and paying no attention to you, say this to yourself: "Won't I be able to persuade him at some point?" This is what Saint Paul commanded us to do: "The servant of the Lord must not strive, but be gentle unto all men, in meekness instructing those that oppose themselves, if God peradventure will give them repentance to the acknowledging of the truth" (2 Tim. 2:24–25). Don't you see how often fathers, when they despair about their children, sit down weeping, lamenting, embracing them, trying everything in their power until their last breath? Do this also for your brother. Although parents through their lamentations and tears can neither remove sickness nor turn away approaching death, you, in the case of a soul even when given up, can through persistence and diligence, by lamentation and tears, bring about recovery and restoration. Have you given counsel and failed to convince? Then weep, and make frequent efforts; groan deeply, so that, shamed by your constancy, he may turn to seek salvation. What can I do alone? For I by myself am not able to be present with you all every day, nor am I sufficient to convince such a multitude. But if you are willing to care for the salvation of one another, and each one takes responsibility for one of our neglected brothers and sisters, you would quickly advance the edification of us all.

What forgiveness, therefore, will there be for us, if (while we undergo such fury of the wicked one against ourselves) we do not bring to bear even the smallest part of this zeal for the salvation of our brethren, even while in these matters we have God for our helper! For when thou seest thy brother wicked and morose and giving no heed to thee, say thus within thyself: "Shall I not some time or other bo able to persuade him." Thus also St Paul commanded us to do: "The servant of the Lord must not strive, but be gentle unto all men, in meekness instructing those that oppose themselves, if God per-adventure will give them repentance to the acknowledging of the truth," (2 Tim. ii. 24, 25.) Dost thou not observe how often fathers, when in despair about their children, sit down weeping, bewailing, embracing them, trying everything in their power until the last breath? This do thou also for thy brother. Although parents by their lamentations and tears can neither remove sickness nor avert approaching death, yet thou, in the case of a soul even when given up, mayest through perseverance and assiduity, by lamentation and tears, bring about recovery and restoration. Hast thou given counsel and failed to convince? Then weep, and make frequent efforts; groan deeply, that, shamed by thy constancy, he may turn to seek salvation. What can I do alone? For I singly am not able to be present with you all every day, nor am I sufficient to convince such a multitude. But ye, if ye be minded to care for the salvation of each other, and every one to take in hand one of our neglected brethren—-ye would quickly further the edification of us all.

And why mention those who, after being warned repeatedly, have come to their senses? We ought not to abandon or neglect even those who are incurably sick, even if we clearly foresee that, after receiving our earnest care and good advice, they will gain nothing from it. And if what I say seems unreasonable to you, let me confirm it by things that Christ himself said and did. For we, being ignorant of the future, cannot be certain about our hearers—whether they will be persuaded or whether they will disbelieve what we say. But Christ, knowing both perfectly, did not stop instructing the disobedient even to the end.

And what need is there to speak of those who, after repeated warnings, have come to their right mind? It behoves us not to abandon or neglect even those who are diseased incurably, even if we foresee clearly that, after having had the benefit of our zeal and good counsel, they will not at all profit by it. And if this that I say seem to you unreasonable, suffer me to confirm it by things which Christ himself said and did. For we men being ignorant of the future, cannot therefore be certain, as to the hearers, whether they will be persuaded or whether they will disbelieve that which we say; but Christ, knowing both one and the other perfectly, did not cease instructing the disobedient even to the end.

Even though Jesus knew that Judas would not turn away from his betrayal, He did not stop trying to redirect him from his unfaithfulness through advice, warnings, kind actions, threats, every type of teaching, and by continually restraining him with His words as if with a rein. He did this to teach us that even when we know beforehand that our fellow believers will not be persuaded, we must do everything we can, since the reward for our warning is certain. Notice also how carefully and wisely the Lord restrained Judas when He said, "One of you shall betray me," and again, "I speak not of you all. I know whom I have chosen," and again, "One of you is a devil." He chose to put them all in a state of anxious uncertainty rather than reveal the traitor or make him more shameless through open rebuke. For these statements caused distress and fear in the others, even though they were conscious of no evil in themselves—hear how each one earnestly asked, "Lord, is it I?"

Thus, knowing that Judas would not be turned aside from his treachery, Christ did not desist from trying to turn him from his faithlessness, by counsel, by warnings, by kind treatment, by threatening, by every kind of instruction, and by continually checking him by His words as by a rein. This He did to teach us that, although we know beforehand that the brethren will not be persuaded, we must do all in our power, since the reward of our admonition is sure. Mark also how assiduously and wisely the Lord restrained Judas when He said, "One of you shall betray me," (Matt. xxvi. 21;) and again, "I speak not of you all. I know whom I have chosen," (John xiii. 18;) and again, "One of you is a devil," (John vi. 70.) He preferred to put them all in an agony of doubt rather than reveal the traitor or make him the more shameless by open reproof. For that these sayings produced trouble and dread in the others, although conscious in themselves of no evil, hear them each with earnest striving say, "Lord, is it I?" (Matt. xxvi. 22.)

He taught Judas not only through words but also through actions. For while Christ often and fully demonstrated His love for humanity—cleansing lepers, casting out demons, healing the sick, raising the dead, restoring the paralyzed, and doing good to all—on the other hand, He punished no one, and constantly said, "I came not to judge the world, but to save the world" (John 12:47). But so that Judas would not think that Christ only knew how to bless and not to punish, Christ also taught him this very thing: that He was able to punish and inflict penalties on sinners.

Not only by words did He instruct him, but also by acts. For while Christ often and fully manifested., His love to man,—-cleansing the lepers, casting out devils, healing the sick, raising the dead, restoring the paralytic, and doing good to all; on the other hand, He punished no one, and constantly said, "I came not to judge the world, but to save the world," (John xii. 47.) But that Judas should not think that Christ knew only how to bless and not to punish, Christ teaches him also this very thing, namely, that He was able to punish and inflict penalties on sinners.

Chapter 5

Look, then, at how wisely and fittingly He teaches him this truth; and notice that He does not agree to punish or impose a penalty on any human being. And why? So that the disciple might learn His power to punish. For if He had punished any person, He would have appeared to have acted contrary to His own statement when He said, "I came not to judge the world, but to save the world." On the other hand, if He had shown no power of punishment, the disciple would have remained in error, not learning from His actions His power to inflict punishment. How then did it happen?

Behold, then, how wisely and appropriately He teaches him this thing; and notice that He does not consent to punish or inflict a penalty on any human being. And why? In order that the disciple might learn His power to punish. For, had He punished any man, He would have seemed to have acted contrary to His own declaration when He said, "I came not to judge the world, but to save the world." On the other hand, had He exhibited no power of chastisement, the disciple would have remained in error, not learning from His deeds His power of inflicting punishment. How then did it come to pass?

Christ displayed this power on the fig tree so that the disciple would be made to fear and not become worse from lack of reverence, and so the disciple would not undergo punishment and penalty himself. Christ said, "Let no fruit grow on you from now on" (Matt. 21:19), and by His word alone caused it to wither instantly. In this way, without harming any person, He showed His might—though it was only a tree that suffered the punishment. If the disciple had paid attention to this example of punishment, he would have gained benefit from it. Yet even this did not correct him. Christ foresaw even this, so He not only did this thing but afterward worked an even greater wonder. When the Jews came against Him armed with swords and clubs, He caused them all to become blind. This is shown by His saying, "Whom do you seek?" Since Judas had said again and again, "What will you give me, and I will deliver Him to you?" (Matt. 26:15), the Lord wanted to prove to the Jews—and to let Judas himself know—that He went to His sufferings by His own choice, and that all these events were in His own power. He was not overpowered by another's wickedness. When the traitor stood still with all his companions, Jesus said, "Whom do you seek?" Judas did not recognize the one he came to betray, for his eyes were blinded. Not only that, but Christ by His word caused them all to fall backward to the ground. Even this did not make them less cruel or cause the wretched man to stop his treachery—for he was still incorrigible. Yet even now Christ did not give up His kindness and concern. Notice how movingly He deals with this shameless mind, and how He speaks words that ought to melt a heart of stone. When Judas came forward to kiss Him, what did Christ say? "Judas, are you betraying the Son of Man with a kiss?" (Luke 22:48). Are you not ashamed of the way you are betraying Me? Christ said this to touch him and bring his former intimacy to mind. But while the Lord acted and spoke this way, the betrayer did not change for the better—not because of any weakness in the one giving the counsel, but because of the worthlessness of the one receiving it. And Christ, although He foresaw all these things, did not stop—from the beginning to the end of the scene—doing everything that was consistent with His own character.

In order that the disciple should be made to fear, and not become worse for lack of reverence, nor himself undergo punishment and penalty, Christ displayed this His power on the fig-tree, saying, "Let no fruit grow on thee henceforward," (Matt. xxi. 3 9,) and, by His mere word, caused it instantly to wither. In this way, without causing harm to any man, Pie himself showed His might, though it was only a tree that bore the infliction. And the disciple, if he had attended to this instance of punishment, would have reaped profit from it. Still, however, even thus he was not corrected. And Christ, foreseeing even this, not only did this thing, but afterwards wrought a much greater wonder. For when the Jews came against Him, armed with swords and staves, He caused them all to become blind; this being shown by His saying, "Whom seek ye?" Since Judas had said again and again, "What will ye give me, and I will deliver Him unto you?" (Matt. xxvi. 15,) the Lord, wishing to prove to the Jews, and to let Judas also know, that He went of His own accord to His sufferings, and that all these events were in His own power;—-that He was not overpowered by the wickedness of another, He said, when the traitor with all his companions stood still, "Whom seek ye?" Judas did not know Him whom he came to betray, for his eyes were blinded. Nor was this all, but Christ by His word caused them all to fall backward to the ground. And since even this did not render them less cruel, nor cause the wretched man to desist from his treachery,—-for he was still incorrigible,—-Christ even now did not give up His kindness and regard; but mark how movingly He deals with this mind devoid of shame, and how He speaks words which ought to melt a heart of stone. For when Judas advances to kiss Him, what does Christ say? "Judas, betrayest thou the Son of Man with a kiss?" (Luke xxii. 48.) Art thou not ashamed of the manner in which thou betrayest Me? This Christ said to touch him, and bring his former intimacy to remembrance. But while the Lord acted and spoke thus, the betrayer did not change for the better—-not on account of the weakness of Him from whom the counsel came, but the worthlessness of him to whom it came. And Christ, although He foresaw all these things, did not cease, from the beginning to the close of the scene, to do all that was consistent with His own character.

Since we know all these things, we ought to teach and love our negligent brothers and sisters constantly and fully, even when we don't achieve the goal of our advice. For if the Lord showed such concern for someone who would gain nothing from the warning, knowing this outcome in advance, what excuse can we have when we don't know the outcome yet are so careless about our neighbor's salvation—when we give up after the second or third warning? Besides everything we have said, let us consider our own situation, since God speaks to us day after day through the prophets and apostles, and day after day we are disobedient; yet He still does not stop reasoning with and calling upon those who are always stubborn and inattentive. Paul also cries out, using these words: "We are ambassadors for Christ, as though God did beseech you by us, we pray you in Christ's stead be ye reconciled to God" (2 Cor. 5:20). If one may say something unusual, the person who foresees that the one receiving his counsel will be somewhat persuaded by it, and therefore gives his advice, is not as worthy of praise as the one who speaks and counsels repeatedly, fails, but nevertheless does not stop. For in the first case, the hope of convincing drives him to effort, even if he were the laziest man alive; but the other, who gives counsel and is ignored, yet still does not give up, demonstrates the most passionate and purest love. He is not motivated by any such hope as in the first case—only through love for his brother does he persist in his anxious care.

Since we know all these things, we ought to teach and to love, constantly and fully, those of our brethren who are negligent, even though we do not gain the object of our counsel. For if, knowing such a result, the Lord exhibited such solicitude for him who would profit nothing by the warning, what allowance can be made for us, when, not knowing the result, we are thus careless about the salvation of our neighbour,—-when we desist after the second or third warning? Besides all these things that we have said, let us take into consideration our own case, since God addresses us day after day, by the prophets, by the apostles, and day after day we are disobedient; and still He does not cease to reason with and to call upon those who are always obstinate and inattentive. Paul also cries aloud, using these words: "We are ambassadors for Christ, as though God did beseech you by us, we pray you in Christ's stead be ye reconciled to God," (2 Cor. v. 20.) If one may say a strange thing, he who foresees that the recipient of his counsel will in some degree be persuaded by it, and thus gives his advice, is not worthy of such praise as he who, oftentimes speaking and counselling, fails, but notwithstanding does not cease. For, in the first case, the hope of convincing stimulates him to exertion, even though he should be of all men most slothful; but the other, who gives counsel and is neglected, and still does not desist, gives proof of the most ardent and purest love; he is stimulated by no such hope as in the former instance;—-only through love towards his brother does he persevere in his anxious care.

But we have already shown clearly enough that we should never abandon those who have fallen, even when we know in advance that they will not be persuaded by us. In the rest of this teaching, we must bring charges against those who live in luxury. For as long as this feast continues, Satan inflicts the wounds of excess on the souls of those who indulge in revelry, and it is our duty to apply the healing remedies.

But that we ought never to desert the fallen, even when we foresee that they will not be persuaded by us, we have already sufficiently shown. In the rest of this discourse, we must proceed with a charge against those who live in luxury. For as long as this feast lasts, Satan inflicts the wounds of excess on the souls of those who indulge in revels, and it is our duty to apply the healing remedies.

Chapter 6

Yesterday, we used the testimony of St. Paul against such feasters, who says, "Whether ye eat or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God" (1 Cor. 10:31). Today, we will show them that the Lord of Paul not only advises or counsels us to abstain from luxury, but also punishes and inflicts penalties on one who lived in luxury. The story of the rich man and Lazarus, and what happened to them, proves exactly this. So that our examination of this subject will not be superficial, I will read the parable to you from the beginning: "There was a certain rich man, which was clothed in purple and fine linen, and fared sumptuously every day. And there was a certain beggar named Lazarus, which was laid at his gate, full of sores, and desiring to be fed with the crumbs which fell from the rich man's table: moreover, the dogs came and licked his sores" (Luke 16:19-21).

Yesterday, we alleged against such feasters the testimony of St Paul, who says, "Whether ye eat or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God," (1 Cor. x. 31.) To-day, we shall show them the Lord of Paul not only advising or counselling to abstain from luxury, but also punishing and inflicting penalties on one who lived in luxury; for the narrative of the rich man and Lazarus, and of the things which befell them, proves nothing less than this. And rather than that our consideration of this subject should be superficial, I will read to you the parable from the commencement. "There was a certain rich man, which was clothed in purple and fine linen, and fared sumptuously every day. And there was a certain beggar named Lazarus, which was laid at his gate, full of sores, and desiring to be fed with the crumbs which fell from the rich man's table: moreover, the dogs came and licked his sores," (Luke xvi. 19-21.)

Now why did the Lord speak to them in parables? Why did He explain some of these and leave others unexplained? And what exactly is a parable? We will set aside these questions and others like them for another time, so we don't get sidetracked from the argument we're dealing with right now.

Now for what reason did the Lord speak to them in parables? Why also did He explain some of these, and leave others unexplained? And what indeed is a parable? These, and other questions of this nature, we will reserve until another opportunity, so as not to digress from the argument now claiming our attention.

However, we will ask this: Which of the Gospel writers has passed down to us this parable as spoken by Christ? Which one is it? Only Luke. It is also necessary to know that some of the things recorded are recorded by all four, while some are recorded by only one, as if by special information. Why is this? So that it would be necessary to read the other Gospels, and so that their agreement with each other might be made clear. If they all recorded all the events, we would not examine them all so carefully, since one alone would be enough to inform us about everything. On the other hand, if they all spoke of different events, we would fail to discover their agreement. For this reason, they all wrote many things in common, while at the same time each received and passed down material particular to himself.

One thing, however, we will ask: Which of the evangelists has delivered to us this parable as spoken by Christ? Which then is it? It is St Luke only. For it is also necessary to know that, of the things which are related, some are related by all four; some, as by special information, by one only. And why? In order that the reading of the other Gospels might be necessary, and that their agreement with each other might be made manifest. For if they all delivered all the events, we should not examine them all with such care, since one only would be sufficient to inform us about everything. If, again, all spoke of different events, we should fail to discover their agreement. On this account they all wrote many things in common, while at the same time each received and delivered matters peculiar to himself.

Let's return to Christ's teaching in the parable. Here it is: A certain man, it says, who lived in great wickedness, was rich. He experienced no misfortune, but all good things flowed to him as from a never-ending spring. The fact that nothing undesirable happened to him—no cause of trouble, none of the hardships of human life—is implied when it says that "he feasted luxuriously every day." That he lived wickedly is clear from the end assigned to him, and even before his end, from the neglect he showed toward the poor man. He himself demonstrated that he felt no pity either for the poor man at his gate or for anyone else. If he had no pity on the man continually laid at his gate and placed before his eyes, whom every day—once or twice, or many times—he was forced to see as he went in and out (for the man was not placed in a side street or in a hidden and narrow place, but in a spot where the rich man, in his constant coming and going, was compelled to look at him even if he didn't want to), if therefore the rich man did not pity him lying there in such suffering and living in such distress—indeed, spending his whole life in misery because of sickness, and of the most terrible kind—would he ever have been moved with compassion toward any of the afflicted he might happen to meet? Even if the rich man passed him by on one occasion, it was likely that he would show some feeling the next day. And if even then he ignored the poor man, still on the third day, or the fourth, or even after that, he might be expected somehow to be moved to compassion, even if he were crueler than wild animals. But he had no feeling: he was harsher and more severe than that judge who neither feared God nor respected man. For the judge, though so cruel and stern, was moved by the widow's persistence to be gracious and listen to her request. But this man could not even be persuaded this way to give help to the poor man, despite the fact that his request was not like the widow's, but much simpler and more reasonable. For she asked for help against her enemies, while this poor man was begging that his hunger might be satisfied and that he not be allowed to die. The widow also caused trouble by her pleading. But this man, though often seen by the rich man during the day, only lay there without speaking—and this circumstance alone was quite enough to soften a heart harder than stone. When we are pestered, we often feel annoyed. But when we see those who need our help remaining perfectly silent and saying not a word, and though always failing to get what they need, not taking it badly, but only appearing before us in silence, even if we are more insensitive than stones themselves, we are shamed and moved by such great humility. There is also another circumstance of no less importance: the very appearance of the poor man was pitiful, since he was wasted away by hunger and long sickness. Yet none of these things influenced that cruel man.

To return, however, to Christ's teaching in the parable. It is this: A certain man, it is said, living in great wickedness, was rich; and he experienced no ill fortune, but all good things flowed to him as from a perennial fountain. For that nothing undesirable happened to him—-no cause of trouble—-none of the ills of human life —-is implied when it is said, that "he fared sumptuously every day." And that he lived wickedly is clear from the end allotted to him, and even before his end, from the neglect which he displayed in the case of the poor man; for that he felt pity neither for the poor man at his gate nor for any other, he himself showed. For if he had no pity on the man continually laid at his gate, and placed before his eyes, whom every day, once or twice, or oftentimes, as he went in and out, he was obliged to see;—-for the man was not placed in a by-way, nor in a hidden and narrow place, but in a spot where the rich man, in his continual coming-in and going-out, was obliged, even if unwilling, to look upon him;—-if, therefore, the rich man did not pity him lying there in such suffering, and living in such distress,—-yea, rather, all his life long in misery because of sickness, and that of the most grievous kind,—-would he ever have been moved with compassion towards any of the afflicted whom he might casually meet? For though on one occasion the rich man passed him by, it was likely that he would manifest some feeling the next day; and if even then he disregarded the poor man, still on the third day, or the fourth, or even after that, he might be expected in some way to be moved to compassion, even if he were more cruel than the wild beasts. But he had no feeling: he was more severe and harsh than that judge who neither feared God nor regarded man. For the judge, though so cruel and stern, was moved by the perseverance of the widow to be gracious and listen to her petition; but this man could not even thus be induced to give aid to the poor man, notwithstanding that his petition was not like that of the widow, but much easier and fairer. For she requested aid against her enemies, while this poor man was entreating that his hunger might be allayed, and that he should not be allowed to perish. The widow also caused trouble by her entreaties; but this man, though often in the day seen by the rich man, only lay without speaking: and this circumstance was quite sufficient to soften a heart harder than stone. When we are urged, we frequently feel annoyed; but when we see those who need our help remaining in perfect silence and saying not a word, and though always failing to gain their object, not bearing it hardly, but. only appearing before us in silence, even though we are more unfeeling than the very stones, we are shamed and moved by such exceeding humility. There is also another circumstance of not less weight, namely, that the very appearance of the poor man was pitiable, since he was emaciated by hunger and long sickness. Yet none of these things influenced that cruel man.

First, then, he possessed the vice of cruelty and inhumanity to an extreme degree. It is not the same thing for a poor person to fail to help those in need as it is for someone enjoying such luxury to ignore others who are starving to death. Moreover, it is not the same thing to pass by a poor man once or twice as it is to see him every day without being moved by the repeated sight to show pity and kindness. Furthermore, it is not the same thing for someone in difficulty and anxiety, troubled in soul, to fail to help his neighbor as it is for someone enjoying such good fortune and uninterrupted prosperity to neglect others who are dying of hunger, shutting up his compassion rather than becoming more generous precisely because of his own happiness. For know this for certain: unless we are the most cruel of all people, we are by our very physis inclined to become gentler and kinder when we ourselves are prosperous. But this rich man did not become better because of his prosperity. Instead, he remained ill-natured—or rather, he had deep within his character a cruelty and inhumanity greater than that of a wild beast.

First, then, there was this vice of cruelty and inhumanity in a degree that could not be exceeded. For it is not the same thing for one living in poverty not to assist those who are in need, as for one who enjoys such luxury to neglect others who are wasting away through hunger. Again, it is not the same thing for one to pass by a poor man when he sees him once or twice, as to see him every day without being moved by the oft-recurring sight to pity and benevolence. Again, it is not the same thing for one who is in difficulties and anxiety, and troubled in soul, not to help his neighbour, as for one enjoying such good fortune and unbroken prosperity, to neglect others who are perishing from hunger, and to shut up his bowels of compassion, and not rather, for the very sake of his own happiness, to become more benevolent. For know this of a truth, that unless we are the most cruel of all men, we are, by our very nature, apt, by our own prosperity, to be rendered milder and more gentle. But this rich man did not grow better on account of his prosperity, but remained ill-natured; or rather had, deep in his disposition, cruelty and inhumanity greater than that of a beast of the field.

Still it happened that a man living in wickedness and inhumanity enjoyed every kind of good fortune, while a just and virtuous man suffered the greatest evils. That Lazarus was a just man is made clear, as in the other case, by his end, and even before his end, by his patience and poverty. Don't you seem to see these things right before our eyes? The rich man's ship was loaded with merchandise and sailed with a favorable wind. But don't be amazed, for it was heading toward shipwreck, since he was unwilling to distribute its cargo wisely. Do you want me to give another proof of his wickedness? It is his living in luxury every day without fear. For this truly is the height of wickedness—and not only now, in this dispensation, when we are required to show such moderation, but even in the beginning, under the old covenant, when there was no revelation of the need for this self-control. For hear what the prophet says: "Woe to them that come to an evil day, that come near, and that make a Sabbath of lies" (Amos 6:3, LXX).

Still it came to pass that a man living in wickedness and inhumanity enjoyed every kind of good fortune, and a just and virtuous man lingered in the greatest ills. For that Lazarus was a just man is made plain, as in the other case, by his end, and even before his end, by his patience and poverty. Do you not, indeed, seem to see these things present before our eyes? The ship of the rich man was laden with merchandise, and sailed with a fair wind. But do not marvel; for it was borne on to shipwreck, since he was not willing to bestow its burden wisely. Would you that I should give another proof of his wickedness? It is his living in luxury every day without fear. For this in truth is the height of wickedness; and not only now, (in this dispensation,) when we are required to show such moderation, but even in the beginning, under the old covenant, when there was no revelation of the need of this self-control. For hear what the prophet says: "Woe to them that come to an evil day, that come near, and that make a Sabbath of lies," (Amos vi. 3, LXX.)

The Jews assumed that the Sabbath was given to them for the sake of rest. But this is not its purpose; rather, it was given so that, by separating themselves from worldly affairs, they might devote all that free time to spiritual matters. That the Sabbath was not meant for idleness but for spiritual work is clear from its very circumstances. The priest on that day does a double portion of work, since a single sacrifice is offered on each ordinary day, while on the Sabbath he is commanded to offer a double sacrifice. And if the Sabbath were meant for idleness, the priest above all others ought to be idle. Since the Jews, though separating themselves from worldly things, did not devote themselves to spiritual things—to self-control, gentleness, and hearing the divine word—but did the very opposite, feasting, drinking, and indulging in excess and luxury, it is for this reason that the prophet condemns them. For he says, "Woe to them that come to an evil day," and continues, "that make a Sabbath of lies." He shows by what follows how their Sabbath became unprofitable. How then did they make it unprofitable? By working wickedness, living in luxury, drinking, and doing countless other base and vile acts. And that this charge is true, hear what follows; for he confirms what I am saying by what he immediately adds, saying: "That lie upon beds of ivory, and stretch themselves upon their couches, and eat the lambs out of the flock, and the calves out of the midst of the stall; that drink refined wine, and anoint themselves with the chief ointments."

The Jews suppose that the Sabbath was given to them for the sake of ease. But this is not the object of it; but it was in order that, separating themselves from, worldly affairs, they might bestow all that leisure on spiritual things. For that the Sabbath was not for the sake of idleness, but for spiritual work, is clear from its very circumstances. The priest, on that day, does a double portion of work, a single sacrifice being offered each common day, while on that day he is commanded to offer a double sacrifice. And if the Sabbath were for the sake of idleness, the priest before all others ought to be idle. Since therefore the Jews, separating themselves from worldly things, devoted not themselves to spiritual things, to temperance, and gentleness, and hearing the divine word, but did the very opposite, feasting, drinking, indulging in excess and luxury; on this account it is, that the prophet condemns them. For he says, "Woe to them that come to an evil day," and, in continuation, "that make a Sabbath of lies." He shows by that which follows how their Sabbath became unprofitable. How then did they make it unprofitable? By their working wickedness, living in luxury, drinking, and doing numberless other base and vile acts. And that this charge is true, hear what follows; for he intimates that which I am affirming, by that which he immediately adds, saying: "That lie upon beds of ivory, and stretch themselves upon their couches, and eat the lambs out of the flock, and the calves out of the midst of the stall; that drink refined wine, and anoint themselves with the chief ointments," (Amos vi. 4, 6.)

You received the Sabbath so that you might purify your soul from wickedness, but you have increased wickedness instead. For what can be worse than this softness—this "sleeping upon beds of ivory"? Other sins, such as drinking, greed, or wastefulness, may be accompanied by some small amount of pleasure, but sleeping on beds of ivory—what pleasure is there in it? Does the beauty of the couch bring us more refreshing or sweeter sleep? No, rather this beauty is more burdensome and more troublesome to us, if we think about the matter. For whenever you consider that while you are sleeping on an ivory couch, another fellow human being cannot even be sure of having bread to eat, will not conscience condemn you and rise up to accuse this wrong? And if sleeping on an ivory couch is a reproach, what defense can we make when the bed is also decorated with silver? Do you want to know the true beauty of a couch? I will show you the adornment, not of a couch belonging to a private citizen, nor to a soldier, but to a king. Even if you were the most honor-loving of all people, be assured that you could not wish to have a couch more fitting than that of this king. It is also not that of an ordinary king, but of a very great king, a king of all kings most kingly, and even to this day magnified throughout the whole world. I show you the couch of the blessed David. What kind was it then? It was not decorated with silver and gold, but everywhere with tears and confessions. And he himself says this, speaking thus: "All the night make I my bed to swim, and water my couch with my tears" (Psalm 6:6). Thus with tears it was in all parts adorned as if with pearls.

Thou didst receive the Sabbath that thou mightest purify thy soul from wickedness; but thou hast increased wickedness. For what can be worse than this effeminacy —-this "sleeping upon beds of ivory?" The other sins, as drinking, covetousness, or prodigality, may be accompanied with some small amount of pleasure; but the sleeping on beds of ivory, what pleasure is there in it? Is more refreshing or sweeter sleep brought to us by the beauty of the couch? Nay, rather this beauty is more burdensome and more troublesome to us, if we reflect upon the matter. For whenever thou dost consider that while thou art sleeping on an ivory couch, another fellow-creature is not even able to enjoy the certainty of having bread to eat, will not conscience condemn thee and rise up to accuse this wrong? And if to sleep on an ivory couch be a reproach, what defence can we make when the bed is also decked with silver? Dost thou wish to know the true beauty of a couch? I will show thee the adornment, not of a couch belonging to one in private life, nor to a soldier, but to a king. Though thou shouldst be of all men the most desirous of honour, be assured that thou couldst not wish to have a couch more becoming than that of this king. It is also not that of an ordinary king, but of a very great king, a king of all kings most kingly, and even to this day magnified in the whole world. I show thee the couch of the blessed David. Of what kind then was it? It was not decked with silver and gold, but everywhere with tears and confessions. And this he himself says, speaking thus: "All the night make I my bed to swim, and water my couch with my tears," (Ps. vi. 6.) Thus with tears was it in all parts adorned as if with pearls.

Chapter 8

Mark then with me this godly soul. For although during the day countless concerns—about the rulers, about the governors, about the tribes, about the different peoples, about soldiers, about war, about peace, about state matters, about household matters, about distant things, about things close to home—distracted and disturbed him, nevertheless, the free time that we all give to sleep he spent in confessions and prayers and tears. And he did not do this for one night and then stop the next, not for two or three nights with breaks of rest in between; but he was doing this every night. For "every night," he said, "I wash my bed, and water my couch with my tears," indicating the abundance of his tears and their persistence. For when everyone else was quiet and at rest, he alone conversed with God; and the eye of Him who never sleeps was turned toward the man who mourned and lamented and confessed his indwelling sins. Prepare for yourself a bed like this. For silver ornaments both stir up the envy of man and kindle wrath from above. But tears like those of David can even extinguish the fire of Gehenna.

Mark then with me this godly soul. For although by day manifold cares—-about the rulers, about the governors, about the tribes, about the different races, about soldiers, about war, about peace, about affairs of state, about household affairs, about things far off, about things near home, distracted and disturbed him, nevertheless, the leisure time which we all give to sleep he spent in confessions and prayers and tears. And this he did not for one night to cease from it the next, not for two or three nights, after intervals of repose; but he was doing this every night; for "every night," said he, "wash I my bed, and water my couch with my tears," (Ps. vi. 6, Prayer-book version,) indicating the abundance of his tears and their continuance. For when all were quiet and at rest, he alone held converse with God; and the eye of Him who never sleepeth was turned towards the man who bewailed and lamented and confessed his indwelling sins. Such a couch as this do thou prepare. For silver ornaments both excite the envy of man and enkindle wrath from above. But such tears as those of David can even extinguish the fire of Gehenna.

Do you want me to show you another bed? I mean Jacob's bed. He lay on the ground with a stone under his head. That's why he saw the symbolic stone and the ladder with angels ascending and descending on it. Let us also have beds like this, so that we may see such visions. If we lie on silver, we not only gain no pleasure but also experience trouble. Whenever you consider that in the severest cold in the middle of the night, while you are sleeping on your couch, a poor man is lying on straw in the porticoes of the baths, covered with chaff, trembling, numb with cold, and fainting with hunger—even if you are the most hard-hearted person, you can be sure that you will condemn yourself for being content while you luxuriate in things you don't need and he cannot even enjoy the necessities of life. "No one who serves as a soldier," says the apostle, "gets entangled in the affairs of this life" (2 Tim. 2:4). You are a spiritual soldier. But such a soldier does not sleep on an ivory bed, but on the ground. He does not use scented perfumes, for that is the habit of sensual and dissolute men—those who live on the stage or in idleness. It is not the smell of perfume that you should have, but the fragrance of virtue. The soul is no purer when the body is scented like this. In fact, this fragrance of the body and clothing may even be a sign of inward corruption and uncleanness. For when Satan approaches to corrupt the soul and fill it with complete laziness, then he also uses perfumes to impress upon the body the stains that mark its inner defilement. And just as those who constantly suffer from discharge and mucus defile their garments and body by continually releasing these fluids, in the same way the soul stains the body with the evil of this corrupt discharge. What noble or useful deed can be expected from a man scented with myrrh and living in luxury—or rather keeping company with prostitutes and giving himself up to the company of low actors? Instead, let the soul exhale spiritual fragrances, so that you may greatly benefit both yourself and those around you.2

Do you wish me to show thee another couch? I mean that of Jacob. He lay on the ground, and a stone was under his head. Therefore also, he saw the symbolical stone, and that ladder on which angels were ascending and descending. Couches of this kind let us also have, that we may see such visions. If we lie upon silver, we not only gain no pleasure, but also endure trouble. For whenever thou dost consider that in the severest cold in the middle of the night, while thou art sleeping on thy couch, the poor man lying on chaff in the porticoes of the baths, covered with straw, is trembling, numb with cold, and fainting with hunger, even if thou shouldst be most stony-hearted, be assured that thou wilt condemn thyself for being content that while thou art luxuriating in things superfluous, he is not able to enjoy even the necessaries of life. "No man that warreth," saith the apostle, "entangleth himself with the affairs of this life," (2 Tim. ii. 4.) Thou art a spiritual soldier; but such a soldier does not sleep on an ivory bed, but on the ground; he does not use scented unguents, for this is the habit of sensual and dissolute men—-of those who live on the stage, or in indolence; and it is not the odour of ointment that thou shouldst have, but that of virtue. The soul is none the more pure when the body is thus scented. Yea, this fragrance of the body and of the dress may even be a sign of inward corruption and uncleanness. For when Satan makes his approaches to corrupt the soul and fill it with all indolence, then also by means of ointments he impresses upon the body the stains which mark its inner defilement. And just as those who suffer continually from flux and catarrh defile their garments and person, constantly discharging these humours; in the same way the soul denies the body with the evil of this corrupt discharge. What noble or useful deed can be expected from a man scented with myrrh and living effeminately, or rather keeping company with meretricious women, and giving himself up to the company of low actors? Rather let the soul exhale spiritual odours, in order that thou mayest in the greatest degree benefit both thyself and thy associates.2

For nothing—nothing is worse than luxury. Hear what Moses says about it again: "He is waxen fat, he is grown thick, he is increased, he that is beloved kicked" (Deut. 32:15, LXX). And he does not say "he rebelled," but "he kicked," showing us his wildness and uncontrollability. And again, in another place: "When thou hast eaten and art full, beware that thou forget not the Lord thy God" (Deut. 8:10–11). This is how luxury leads to forgetfulness. So you too, beloved, when you sit at the table, remember that after the meal you should pray. Refresh yourself moderately so that you will not be unable to bend your knee and call upon God because of being too full. Do you not see pack animals? After feeding, they resume their journey, they carry loads, they fulfill all the work assigned to them. But you, when you get up from the table, are unfit for any work; you have become useless. How will you avoid being thought less honorable than the very beasts? Why? Because that is the proper time to be sober and to watch. For the time after meals is the time for thanksgiving, and the one who gives thanks should not indulge in excess but be sober and watchful. Let us not go from the table to the couch, but to prayer, so that we do not become more irrational than the beasts.

For nothing—-nothing is worse than luxury. Hear what Moses again says concerning it: "He is waxen fat, he is grown thick, he is increased, he that is beloved kicked," (Deut. xxxii. 15, LXX.) And he does not say: "he rebelled," but he "kicked," indicating to us his wildness and intractableness. And again, in another place; "When thou hast eaten and art full, beware that thou forget not the Lord thy God," (Deut. viii. 10, 11.) Thus does luxury lead to forgetfulness. Then do thou also, beloved, when thou sittest at table, remember that after the meal thou shouldst pray: and so moderately refresh thyself that thou mayest not through fulness be unable to bend the knee and call upon God. Do you not see beasts of burden, how after feeding, they recommence the journey, they bear loads, they fulfil all the service that falls to their lot? But thou when thou risest from table, art unfit for any work; thou art become useless. How wilt thou avoid being thought less worthy of honour than the very beasts? Wherefore? Because it is then the proper time to be sober and to watch. For the time after meals is the time for thanksgiving; and he who gives thanks should not indulge in excess, but be sober and vigilant. Let us not turn from the table to the couch, but to prayer, that we become not more irrational than the beasts.

Chapter 9

I know that many will criticize what is being said here, claiming it promotes a new and unfamiliar way of life. But I criticize even more strongly the evil customs that are currently widespread among us. For Christ makes it very clear that when we get up from our meal and leave the table, we should turn not to sleep and the bed, but to prayers and the reading of the Holy Scriptures. When He fed the vast crowd in the wilderness, He did not send them away to sleep, but called them to hear the divine word. He did not stuff them full or let them fall into excess; instead, having satisfied their need, He led them to a spiritual feast. Let us also do the same, and let us train ourselves to eat only as much as will sustain our higher life, not hinder and burden it. For we were not born and do not exist simply to eat and drink; rather, let us eat so that we may live. We were not originally given life for the sake of eating, but we eat for the sake of living. Yet we act as if we came into the world merely to eat, and we spend everything on this.3

I am aware that many will condemn that which is said, as leading to a new and strange manner of living. But I the more condemn the evil customs that are now prevalent amongst us. For that when we rise from food, and from the table, we ought to proceed, not to sleep and the couch, but to prayers and the reading of the Holy Scriptures; this is made most clear by Christ. For when He had feasted the innumerable multitude in the wilderness, He did not dismiss them to lie down to sleep, but called them to hear the divine word. He did not fill them to repletion, nor allow them to fall into excess; but having satisfied their need, he led them to a spiritual feast. Thus let us also act, and let us accustom ourselves to eat so much only as will sustain our higher life, and not hinder and oppress it. For it was not for this that we were born, and exist—-namely, that we should eat and drink; but let us eat for this—-namely, that we may live. It was not given us at first to live for the sake of eating, but to eat for the sake of living. But we, as if we had come into the world merely to eat, upon this we spend everything.3

To strengthen this accusation against luxury and make it hit home for those who are living in it, let us return in our discussion to Lazarus. The warning will become clearer this way, and the advice more effective, since you will see those who live in excess being taught and corrected not by words alone, but by actual events. The rich man lived in this kind of wickedness and indulged himself day by day, and was splendidly dressed; but he was bringing more severe punishment upon himself, stirring up a fiercer flame, making his condemnation more complete, and the penalty more relentless.

In order that this charge against luxury may be corroborated, and come home to those who are living in it, let us return in our discourse to Lazarus. And thus the warning will become clearer, and the counsel more effectual, since you will see those who live in excess instructed and corrected, not by words only, but by acts. The rich man lived in this kind of wickedness, and luxuriated day by day, and was splendidly attired; but he was bringing on himself severer punishment, stirring up a fiercer flame, making his condemnation more complete, and the penalty more inexorable.

But the poor man who was thrown at his gate did not grieve, or blaspheme, or complain. He did not say to himself, as many do, "Why is this happening? This man living in wickedness, cruelty, and inhumanity enjoys everything beyond what he needs, and suffers no trouble or any of the unexpected hardships that often occur in human life. He enjoys pure pleasure, while I don't even have the chance to share in necessary food. To this man, who wastes all his wealth on parasites and flatterers and wine—to him all good things flow like a river; while I live as something to be stared at—an object of shame and mockery, and I am wasting away from hunger. Is this Providence? Can it be Justice that governs human affairs?"

But the poor man who was cast at his gate grieved not, nor blasphemed, nor complained. He did not say within himself, as many do, "Why is this so? This man living in wickedness and cruelty and inhumanity enjoys all things even beyond his need, and endures no trouble nor any of the unlooked-for reverses that often happen in human affairs. He enjoys unmixed pleasure, while I have not the opportunity of partaking even of necessary food. To this man, who squanders all his substance on parasites and flatterers and wine—-to him all good things flow like a river; while I live as an object to be gazed at —-an object of shame and derision, and am wasting through hunger. Is this Providence? Can it be Justice that overrules human affairs?"

He did not say any of these things, nor did he even think them. How do we know this? From the fact that guardian angels surrounded him at his death and carried him away to Abraham's bosom. If he had been a blasphemer, he would not have received this glory. Most people marvel at this man simply because of his poverty, but I am demonstrating that he endured these ninefold afflictions not as punishment, but so that he might become more glorious. This is exactly what happened.4

He did not say any of these things, nor had he them in his mind. How is this manifest? From the circumstance that guardian angels surrounded him at his death, and bore him away to Abraham's bosom. Had he been a blasphemer, he would not have gained this glory. Thus also most people wonder at this man merely because of his poverty; but I proceed to show that he endured these ninefold afflictions, not for punishment, but that he might become more glorious. This result accordingly happened.4

Poverty is truly a dreadful thing, as everyone who has experienced it knows. Words cannot express the trouble endured by those who live in poverty without the relief that true philosophy brings. In the case of Lazarus, there was not only this evil but also bodily weakness added on top of it, and to the highest degree. Notice how the text shows that both of these afflictions reached their extreme point. That Lazarus's poverty at that time surpassed all other poverty is clear when we're told that he could not even get the crumbs that fell from the rich man's table. That his weakness had reached the same extreme as his poverty, beyond which it could not go, is also shown when we're told that dogs licked his sores. He was so feeble that he couldn't even drive the dogs away. He lay there like a living corpse, seeing them approach but powerless to keep them at a distance. His limbs were that emaciated. He was that wasted by bodily sickness. He was that worn down by trials. You see that poverty and weakness in the highest degree besieged his body like an army. If each of these evils by itself is unbearable and dreadful, what adamantine strength must someone have who must bear them both united! Many people are often in poor health, but they don't at the same time lack necessary food. Others may live in utter poverty, but they may enjoy good health. The blessing on one hand may counterbalance the evil on the other. But in the case we're considering, both these evils came together.5

A dreadful thing, in truth, is poverty, as all who have had experience of it know. For no words can express the trouble which they endure who live in poverty, without knowing the relief of true philosophy. And in the case of Lazarus, there was not only this evil, but bodily 'weakness superadded, and that in the highest degree. Notice how it is shown that both these inflictions reached the highest pitch. That the poverty of Lazarus at that time surpassed all other poverty, is clear, when it is said that he did not obtain the crumbs which fell from the rich man's table. And that his weakness had reached the same pitch as his poverty, beyond which it could not go, this also is shown when it is said that the dogs licked his sores. He was so feeble as not to be able to drive away the dogs; but he lay like a living corpse, seeing their approach, but powerless to keep them at a distance-To such an extent were his limbs emaciated; so much was he wasted by bodily sickness; so far was he worn down by trials. You see that poverty and weakness in the highest degree, as it were, besieged his body. And if each of these evils by itself is unbearable and dreadful, what adamantine strength must he have who must bear them both united! Many people are often in ill health, but they do not at the same time lack necessary food. Others may live in utter poverty, but they may enjoy health; and the blessing on the one hand may counterbalance the evil on the other; but in the case we are considering, both these evils came together.5

Suppose, however, that there might be some relief even in weakness and poverty. But this cannot be when someone is in such a state of abandonment. For if there were no one related to him or at his home to pity him, he might have received compassion from some of the passersby when lying before the public. But in this case, the complete lack of helpers increased the evils already mentioned. And being laid at the gate of the rich man added to his distress. If he had been placed in a deserted and uninhabited place when he suffered this neglect, he would not have felt such grief, for the fact that no one was near would have led him, even unwillingly, to submit to these unavoidable evils. But being placed in the midst of so many people feasting and rejoicing, and receiving not the slightest attention from any of them, made the thought of his own sufferings more bitter and inflamed his grief all the more. For we are so constituted that we are not as much distressed by evils when all helpers are far away as when helpers who are nearby are unwilling to stretch out a hand to aid us. This grief, then, this poor man felt. There was no one either to console him with a word or to comfort him with a kind act—no friend, no neighbor, no relation, no one of those who saw him, not one of all the corrupt household of the rich man.

Suppose, however, that there may be some alleviation even in weakness and in poverty. But this cannot be, when in such a state of desertion. For if there were no one connected with him or at his home, to pity him, yet he might have met with compassion from some of the beholders, when lying before the public; but in this case the utter lack of helpers increased the afore-mentioned evils. And the being laid at the gate of the rich man added to his distress. If he had been placed in a desert and uninhabited place when he suffered this neglect, he would not have felt such grief; for the fact of there being no one nigh would have led him, even though unwillingly, to submit to these unavoidable evils; but being placed in the midst of so many people carousing and rejoicing, and meeting with not the slightest attention from any of them, made the thought of his own woes more bitter, and the more inflamed his grief. For we are so constituted as not to be so much distressed by evils when all helpers are at a distance, as when helpers who are near are unwilling to stretch out a hand to aid us. This grief, then, this poor man felt. There was no one either to console him by a word, or to comfort him by a kind act; no friend, no neighbour, no relation, no one of those who saw him; not one of all the corrupt household of the rich man.

Chapter 10

Besides all this, seeing another person enjoying such prosperity would bring Lazarus even more grief. This wasn't because he was envious or malicious, but because it's natural for all of us to feel our own troubles more sharply when we see others prospering. And there was another aspect of the rich man's situation that would have pained Lazarus. The truth is, he didn't just feel his own misfortune more keenly by comparing it with another's prosperity—he was also troubled by seeing that someone who acted with cruelty and inhumanity was completely fortunate, while he himself, despite his virtue and gentleness, suffered extreme misery. This thought would have filled him with unbearable sorrow. If the rich man had been just, gentle, admirable, and full of virtue, the thought wouldn't have grieved Lazarus so much. But the rich man was living in wickedness, going to the furthest extremes of evil, showing such inhumanity, and acting like an enemy—passing Lazarus by as shamelessly and mercilessly as if he were a stone. Yet despite all this, he was enjoying such prosperity. Consider how likely it was that this situation would plunge the poor man's soul into constant waves of misery! Think about how Lazarus must have felt when he saw parasites, flatterers, and servants going up and down, coming in and out, hurrying about noisily, drinking, dancing, and displaying every kind of excess. It was as if he had been placed there for the very purpose of witnessing another's prosperity. He lay at the rich man's gate with just enough life to remain aware of his own suffering. He was like someone who suffers shipwreck at the very entrance to the harbor, consumed with thirst at the very edge of a spring.

Besides, in addition to these things, it would cause another accession of woe to see another man in such prosperity. Not that he was envious and evil-minded, but because it is the nature of us all to feel our own private misfortunes more acutely when we see others in prosperity. And with respect to the rich man, there was another circumstance which would give Lazarus pain. For, in truth, not only by comparing his own ill-fortune with another's prosperity did he feel the more deeply his own woes, but also by the consideration that another who acted with cruelty and inhumanity was in every respect fortunate; while he himself, with his virtue and meekness, suffered extreme misery; and thus, again, he would feel inconsolable grief. For if the rich man had been just, if he had been gentle, if he had been worthy of admiration, full of all virtue, the thought would not thus have grieved Lazarus. But now, when the rich man was living in wickedness, proceeding to the extreme of evil, displaying such inhumanity, and acting as an enemy, passing him by as shamelessly and pitilessly as though he were a stone; and notwithstanding all this was enjoying such prosperity, consider how likely it would be that this state of things would plunge the soul of the poor man in continual waves of woe! Consider how Lazarus would feel when he saw parasites, flatterers' servants going up and down, coming in and out, as they hastened about, noisy, drinking, dancing, and displaying every form of wantonness. For, just as if he had come for the very purpose of being a witness of another's prosperity, he was laid at his gate, having life only sufficient to make him sensible of his own ills. He suffered, as it were, shipwreck at the very harbour's mouth, and was consumed with thirst at the very edge of the spring.

Shall I add yet another woe to these? It is this: that he could nowhere see another Lazarus. Even when we ourselves suffer countless troubles, we are still able to look at him (Lazarus) and gain real comfort and feel great consolation. For finding fellowship in one's private troubles, whether physical or mental, brings great relief to the sufferer. Lazarus, however, could not look to any other person suffering the same things as himself, or rather he could not even hear of anyone who had gone before him who had endured such things. This by itself was enough to cloud his mind. And besides this, we must mention another thing: that he was unable to console himself with any hope of the resurrection, but thought that present things are limited to the present existence, for he lived under the old dispensation, before the time of grace (πρὸ τῆς χάριτος). And if even now, in these days, after such a revelation of God's character, and the blessed hope of the resurrection, and the knowledge of the punishment stored up for sinners, and the good things prepared for the righteous, many people are so weak-minded and feeble as not even to be strengthened by such expectations as these, what would he, in all likelihood, endure who was without such an anchor of hope? This man could not at any time console himself in this way, because the time had not yet come when such revelations were given to humanity. And even in addition to this, there was yet another thing, namely, that his character was slandered by foolish people. For most people are accustomed, when they see anyone in hunger and thirst, or living in great trouble, not to have any charitable feeling toward them, but rather to pass judgment on their life by their misfortunes, and to assume that they are afflicted entirely because of their wickedness; and they say to each other many things of this kind—foolishly no doubt—but still they say so: "This person, if he were favorably regarded by God, would not have been allowed to be afflicted with poverty and other troubles." This is what happened to Job and to Paul. To the former they said: "Has it not often been said to you in trouble, The force of your words who can bear? For if you instructed many, and strengthened the weak hands, and raised up the feeble with your words, and gave power to the tottering knees; yet now trouble has come upon you, and you are over-anxious. Is not your fear the offspring of folly?" (Job 4:2-6, LXX). The meaning of these words is this: "If," they say, "you had acted rightly you would not have suffered these present troubles; but you are paying the penalty of sins and transgressions."67

Shall I add to these yet another woe? It is this,—- that he could nowhere see another Lazarus. We ourselves even though we suffer ten thousand ills, still are able looking at him (Lazarus) to gain effectual comfort and feel great consolation. For to find fellowship in his private ills, whether they be physical or mental, brings great alleviation to the sufferer. Lazarus, however, could not look to any other man suffering the same things as himself; or rather he could not even hear of any one of those going before him, who had endured such things. This of itself was enough to becloud his mind. And, besides this, we have to mention another thing:—-that he was unable to console himself with any hope of the resurrection, but thought that present things are bounded by the present existence, for he lived under the old dispensation, ( πρὸ τῆς χάριτος.) And if even now, in these days, after such a revelation of God's character, and the blessed hope of the resurrection, and the knowledge of the punishment laid up for sinners, and the good things prepared for the righteous, many men are so feeble-minded and weak as not even to be confirmed by such expectations as these, what would he, in all probability, endure who was without such an anchor of hope? This man could not at any time thus console himself, because the time had not yet arrived when such revelations were vouchsafed to man. And even in addition to this, there was yet another thing, namely, that his character was maligned by foolish men. For the generality of men are accustomed, when they see any in hunger and thirst, or living in great trouble, not to entertain any charitable feeling respecting them, but rather to pass judgment on their life by their misfortunes, and to suppose that they are thus afflicted entirely on account of their wickedness; and they say to each other many things of this kind—-foolishly no doubt—-but still they say so:—-"This man, if he were favourably regarded by God, would not have been suffered to be afflicted with poverty and other woes." In this way it happened to Job and to Paul. To the former they said:—-"Hath it not often been said to thee in trouble, The force of thy words who can bear? For if thou didst instruct many, and strengthen the weak hands, and raise up the feeble with thy words, and give power to the tottering knees; yet now trouble has come upon thee, and thou art over-anxious. Is not thy fear the offspring of folly?" (Job iv. 2-6, LXX.) The meaning of these words is this —-"If," they say, "thou hadst acted rightly thou wouldst not have suffered these present ills; but thou art paying the penalty of sins and transgressions."67

And this was especially what wounded the blessed Job.

And this it was especially that wounded the blessed Job.

Again, concerning Paul, the barbarians spoke in the same way. When they saw the viper hanging from his hand, they had no favorable opinion of him but supposed that he was one of those who dare to commit the greatest crimes. This is clear from what they said: "This man, though he has escaped the sea, yet vengeance does not allow him to live" (Acts 28:4). This same thing frequently troubles us not a little. But even though the waves of trouble, crashing against each other, were so great, the boat of this poor man was not overwhelmed. And though he was placed as if in a furnace, he preserved his calmness as if refreshed with continual dew.

Again concerning Paul, the barbarians spoke in the same strain; when they saw the viper hanging from his hand, they had no favourable opinion of him, but supposed that he was one of those who dare to commit the greatest crimes. This is plain from that which they said:—-"This man though he hath escaped the sea, yet vengeance suffereth not to live," (Acts xxviii. 4.) This same thing frequently disturbs ourselves not a little. But notwithstanding that the waves of trouble, dashing against each other, were so great, the bark of this poor man was not overwhelmed; and though he was placed as it were in a furnace, he preserved his tranquillity as if refreshed with perpetual dew.

Chapter 11

Nor did he say to himself anything like this—as it seems many do say, namely: "This rich man when he dies will undergo punishments and penalties, and then one will have become one again; but if he is honored there, two will have come to nothing." Now, do not many among you use such expressions in the marketplace, or introduce into the church words that belong to the circus or the theater? I would be ashamed and blush to speak such words aloud, except that it is necessary to mention such things so that you may avoid the reckless mockery and shame and harm that come from using such expressions. Many people frequently laugh when they say these things; but this is the result of satanic deception, intended to bring corrupt expressions into common use instead of sound words. Many people constantly repeat such things in the workshop, in the marketplace, in their homes—things full of complete unbelief and foolishness—things that are in reality ridiculous and childish. For to say, "if the wicked when they die are punished," and not to be fully convinced in one's own mind that they will truly be punished, is a mark of unbelief and skepticism. And even to entertain the thought that the evil will enjoy the same rewards as the just—as would result from such thinking—is utter foolishness.8

Nor did he say within himself anything of this kind—-as it seems many do say, namely:—-"This rich man when he departs this life will undergo punishments and penalties, and then one will have become one again; but if he there be honoured two will have come to nothing." Now, do not many among yourselves use such expressions in the market, or introduce into the church words which belong to the circus or the theatre? I should be ashamed, and blush to utter such words aloud, were it not necessary to say such things in order that you may avoid the unlicensed mirth and shame and harm springing from the use of such expressions. Many frequently laugh when they say these things; but this is the effect of satanical guile, in order to bring corrupt expressions into common use instead of sound words. Such things as these many constantly repeat in the workshop, in the market, in their houses,—-things full of utter unbelief and folly—-things that are in reality ridiculous and puerile. For to say, " if the wicked when they depart are punished," and not to be fully persuaded in one's own mind that they will in truth be punished, is a mark of unbelief and scepticism. If also it should result, even as it will result, even the very thought that the evil will enjoy the same rewards as the just, is utter folly.8

Tell me, what do you mean when you say that if the rich man receives punishment after he dies, "one has become one"—that is, there is equality? How is that statement true? For how many years do you want us to assume he enjoyed wealth here? Do you want to assume a hundred? I'm willing to assume two hundred, or three hundred, or twice as many, or even, if you like, a thousand, however impossible that may be. Scripture says, "The days of our years are eighty years" (referring to Psalm 90:10). But suppose it's a thousand. Can you show me in this world a life that has no end, one that knows no limit, like the life of the just in heaven? Tell me then, if someone over the course of a hundred years had for a single night a dream of prosperity, and after enjoying great luxury in his sleep was punished for a hundred years—would you be able to say of him "one has become one," that there is an equal balance, and place that one night of dreams as a counterweight to the hundred years? It's impossible to say so. Think in the same way about the life to come. For the proportion that one night's dream has to a hundred years is the same as the proportion the present life has to the future life—or rather, the latter proportion is much smaller. As a little drop is to the fathomless ocean, so is a thousand years to that future glory and bliss. And what more can one say, except that that life has no limit and knows no end, and that there is as much difference between dreams and realities as there is between our condition in this world and our condition in the next. Besides, even before the future punishment, those who live wickedly are punished now. Don't just tell me about enjoying sumptuous meals, being clothed in silk garments, being followed by troops of slaves, and processing in state through public places. Instead, lay open the conscience of such a man, and there you will see within great trouble on account of sins, perpetual dread, tempest and confusion. And the reason, as in a court of justice, ascends the royal throne of conscience, sits there as a judge, brings forward the thoughts as ministers of justice, racks the mind, tortures it on account of sin, and vehemently accuses it. And this state of things is known to no one else, except God alone, who sees all that takes place.

What dost thou mean, tell me, when thou sayest, if the rich man when he departs should receive punishment, " one has become one?" (There is equality.) And how is the saying true? For how many years do you wish that we suppose that he has here enjoyed wealth? Do you wish to suppose a hundred? I, for my part, am willing rather to suppose two hundred, or three hundred, or twice as many; or even, if you wish, a thousand, however impossible it may be. The days of our years, it is said, are eighty years, (alluding to Ps. xc. 10.) Suppose, however, a thousand. But can you, I pray, show me in this world a life that has no end?—-one that knows no limit, such as is the life of the just in heaven? Tell me then, if some one in the course of a hundred years, seeing for a single night a dream of prosperity; and, after enjoying in his sleep great luxury, should be punished for a hundred years—-would you be able to say of him one has become one, (there is an equal balance,) and place the one night of dreams as a counterpoise to the hundred years? It is impossible to say so. Think, then, in the same way concerning the life to come. For the proportion that the dream of one night has to the hundred years, the same the present life has to the future life; or, rather, the latter proportion is much the less. As a little drop to the fathomless ocean, so is a thousand years to that future glory and bliss. And what can one say more, except that that life has no limit, and knows no end; and that there is as much difference between dreams and realities as there is between our condition in this world and our condition in the next. Besides, even before the future punishment, those who live wickedly are punished now. For do not tell me only of enjoying a sumptuous table, and of being clothed in silken garments, and of being followed by troops of slaves, and of proceeding in state through the public places of resort; but lay open to me the conscience of such a man, and there you shall see within great trouble on account of sins, perpetual dread, tempest, and confusion, and the reason, as in a court of justice, ascending the royal throne of conscience, sitting there as a judge, bringing forward the thoughts as ministers of justice, racking the mind, torturing it on account of sin, and vehemently accusing it; and this state of things is known to no one else, save only God, who sees all that takes place.

Again, the person who commits fornication, even if he is extremely wealthy and has no one accusing him, never stops accusing himself inwardly. The pleasure is brief, while the pain lasts; there is fear on all sides and trembling, suspicion, and agony. He fears the side streets, he trembles at the very shadows, at his own servants, at those who know what he has done, at those who do not know, at the woman he wronged, at her injured husband. He walks around carrying with him a sharp accuser—his own conscience—being condemned by himself and unable to find the slightest relief. Even on his bed, or at his table, or in the marketplace, or in his house, by day, by night, even in his dreams he often sees the image of his sin. He lives the life of Cain, groaning and trembling on the earth, and though no one else knows it, he carries within himself the unquenchable fire.

Again, he who commits fornication, though he be rich in the highest degree, and though he have no accuser, never ceases inwardly to accuse himself. The pleasure is fleeting, while the pain is lasting; there is fear from all sides and trembling, suspicion, and agony; he fears the by-ways, he trembles at the very shadows, at his own domestics, at those who know his guilt, at those who know it not, at the injured one, at her wronged husband: he goes about bearing with him a keen accuser—-his own conscience—-being self-condemned, and unable to find the slightest relief. And even on his bed, or at his table, or in the market, or in his house, by day, by night, even in his very dreams he often sees the image of his sin; he lives the life of a Cain, groaning and trembling on the earth; and though no one knows it, he has within himself the unquenchable fire.

Those who steal and those who are greedy suffer this same thing; the drunkard suffers this too, and in short, everyone living in sin experiences this.

This also they who rob and who are covetous suffer; this also does the drunkard suffer, and, in short, every one living in sin.

It is impossible for that tribunal to be influenced in any way. And if we do not pursue virtue, we still feel pain for not pursuing it; and if we follow vice, as soon as we lose the pleasure that comes with the sin, we feel the pain. Therefore, let us not say concerning those who prosper here while doing evil, and concerning the righteous who enjoy happiness in the next world, that "one becomes one" (all is equally balanced), but rather that "two come to nothing" (all the good is on one side). For the righteous find much pleasure both in this life and in the life to come; but those who live in wickedness and luxury are punished both in this life and in the life to come. For even here they are tormented by the expectation of the coming penalty, as well as by the bad reputation they have among everyone, and by the fact that the sin itself corrupts their soul; and after their departure to that place, they endure unbearable penalties.

It is impossible that that tribunal can in any way be influenced. And if we do not follow after virtue, yet we are pained for not following after it; and if we follow vice, as soon as we lose the pleasure that accompanies the sin, we feel the pain. Let us therefore not say concerning those who are prosperous here, and yet do ill, and concerning the just who enjoy felicity in the next world, that " one becomes one " (all is equally balanced,) but that " two come to nothing'' (all the good is on one side.) For, to the just the life here and the life yonder both bring much pleasure; but they who live in wickedness and in luxury are punished both in the life here and the life yonder. For even here they are harassed by the expectation of the coming penalty, as well as by the bad opinion in which they are held by all, and by the fact that by the very sin itself their soul is corrupted; and after their departure thither they endure insupportable penalties.

Again, even if the just suffer a thousand hardships here, they are encouraged by pleasant hopes; they have unmixed, certain, and lasting pleasure; and after these things, countless blessings come to them, as we also see in the case of Lazarus.

Again, the just, even if they suffer a thousand ills here, are encouraged by pleasant hopes; they have unmixed, sure, and abiding pleasure; and after these things, innumerable blessings accrue to them, as also we see in the case of Lazarus.

Therefore do not say to me that he was full of sores; but notice this—that he had within him a soul more precious than all gold; or rather, notice not only his soul, but also his body. For bodily perfection does not consist in being fat and strong, but in being able to endure so many and such great afflictions. For if someone has wounds of this kind in his body, he is not therefore to be despised. But rather, if someone has so many defects in his soul, for him we should have no regard—and such was that rich man, covered with wounds within. And as dogs licked the wounds of the one, so the evil spirits aggravated the sins of the other; as the one starved for lack of food, so the other for lack of virtue.

Therefore do not say to me that he was full of sores; but mark this—-that he had within him a soul more precious than all gold; or rather, mark not only his soul, but also his body; for bodily perfection consists not in stoutness and vigour, but in being able to bear so many and so great afflictions. For, if one have in his body wounds of this kind, he is not therefore to be despised. But rather, if one have in his soul so many defects, for him we should have no regard;—-and such was that rich man, covered with wounds within. And as dogs licked the wounds of the one, so the evil spirits aggravated the sins of the other; as the one starved for lack of food, so the other for lack of virtue.

Chapter 12

Knowing these things, then, let us act wisely and not say that if God loved someone, He would not have allowed that person to be in poverty. This very thing is the greatest sign of love. For "whom the Lord loves He disciplines, and scourges every son whom He receives" (Heb. xii. 6). And again, "My son, if you intend to serve the Lord, prepare your soul for trial, make ready your heart, and be strong" (Ecclesiasticus ii. 1). So then, beloved, let us cast away from ourselves these empty ideas and common sayings; for "filthiness and foolish talking and jesting, let it not proceed out of your mouth" (Eph. v. 4). Let us not say such things; and if we see others speaking this way, let us correct them, let us boldly stand up and put a stop to such shameless speech. Tell me, if you saw a robber lurking on the road, lying in wait for those passing by and plundering the land, hiding gold and silver in caves and secret places, and storing up in such places a great amount of stolen goods, gaining from this way of life fine clothes and many captives—tell me, would you then consider him happy because of such wealth? Or would you consider him miserable because of the judgment about to fall on him? And even if he should escape this, if he should not be handed over to justice, nor fall into prison, nor have any accuser, nor come to trial, but eat and drink and enjoy great abundance, still we do not consider him happy because of present and visible circumstances; but we consider him miserable because of the things that are to come and that we look forward to.

Knowing, therefore, these things, let us act wisely, and let us not say that if God loved such a one, He would not have allowed him to be in poverty. This very thing is the greatest token of love. For "whom the Lord loveth He chasteneth, and scourgeth every son whom He receiveth," (Heb. xii. 6.) And again, "My son, if thou dost purpose to serve the Lord, prepare thy soul for trial, make ready thy heart, and be strong," (Ecclesiasticus ii. 1.) Let us then, beloved, cast these vain imaginations away from us, and these common sayings; for "filthiness and foolish talking and jesting, let it not proceed out of your mouth," (Eph. v. 4.) Let us not say such things; and if we see others speaking thus, let us refute them, let us boldly arise and put a stop to such shameless speech. Tell me, if you should see any robber prowling about the road, lying in wait for those that pass by, and plundering the land, secreting gold and silver in caves and hiding-places, and shutting up in such places a great quantity of booty, gaining from this course of life rich garments and many captives; tell me, should you then think him happy on account of such wealth? Or should you think him miserable on account of the judgment about to overtake him? And even if he should escape this, if he should not be delivered into the hand of justice, nor fall into prison, nor have any accuser, nor come to trial, but eat and drink and enjoy great abundance, still we do not think him happy because of present and visible circumstances; but we think him miserable on account of the things which are to come, and to which we look forward.

Think the same way about the rich and the greedy. Robbers hide along the road and attack travelers, then stash other people's wealth in their own hiding places—in caves or dens. Don't think they're happy because of their present circumstances. Think of them as miserable because of what's coming—the terrifying judgment, the unavoidable reckoning they must give, the outer darkness that will surround them. Even though robbers often escape human justice, we still wouldn't want such a life for ourselves. We wouldn't even wish such a cursed prosperity on our enemies. But with God, it's not like that. No one can escape His judgment. Everyone who lives in greed and theft will suffer the punishment He assigns—that undying punishment which has no end—just as this rich man did.

In the same way reason with yourself concerning the rich and the avaricious. Robbers lie in wait in the way and plunder travellers, and hide the wealth of others in their own lurking-places—-in caves or dens. Do not, therefore, think them happy on account of the present, but miserable on account of the future—-on account of the fearful judgment, the inevitable account to be rendered—-the outer darkness which will envelop them. Even though robbers often escape the hand of men, yet, notwithstanding though we know this, we deprecate for ourselves such a life as theirs, or even for our enemies we should deprecate such an accursed prosperity. Yet with respect to God such a thing cannot be said. No one can escape His judgment, but all who in any way live in covetousness and rapine will undergo the punishment allotted by Him—-that deathless punishment which has no end,—-in the same way as also did this rich man.

Taking all this into consideration, then, beloved, think those people blessed who live not in wealth but in virtue. Think those people miserable who live not in poverty but in wickedness. Let us look not at the present but at the future. Let us examine not the outward appearance but the conscience of each person. And pursuing the virtue and happiness that come from right actions, let us—whether we are wealthy or poor—imitate Lazarus. He endured not one, two, or three tests of his goodness, but many. These tests were his poverty, his weakness, his lack of anyone to help him, his suffering these evils in a place where complete relief was close at hand while no one offered even a word of comfort, his seeing the man who ignored him possessing all that abundance—and not only possessing abundance but living in wickedness and suffering no harm. Also, he had no other Lazarus to look to for encouragement, and he was unable to console himself with the thought of the resurrection. And besides all these evils, he had to bear a bad reputation among many people for the very reason that he was a sufferer. It was not just for two or three days, but for his whole life, that he saw himself in such circumstances and the rich man in the very opposite.

Taking all this, therefore, into consideration, beloved, think those blessed, not who live in wealth, but in virtue; think those miserable, not those who live in poverty, but in wickedness: let us look not at the present, but at the future; let us examine, not the outward appearance, but the conscience of each man; and following after the virtue and the bliss of right actions, let us, whether we be wealthy or poor, emulate Lazarus. He endured not one, nor two, nor three, but many tests of his goodness. These tests were his poverty, his weakness, his lack of helpers, his suffering these evils in a place where there was at hand the means of complete relief, while no one vouchsafed a word of comfort, his seeing him who disregarded him possessing all that abundance, and not only possessing abundance, but living in wickedness, and suffering no ill; also, his being able to look to no other Lazarus, and his being unable to console himself by the thought of the resurrection. And besides all the aforesaid ills, there was his having to bear an ill-character among many, for the very reason that he was a sufferer. There was, not only for two or three days, but for his whole life, the seeing himself in such circumstances, and the rich man in the very opposite.

What excuse will we have, then, if this man endured all these extreme sufferings with such courage, while we cannot bear even half as much? You cannot—I repeat, you cannot—show or even name any person who has borne such many and severe hardships. For this reason Christ brought these things to our attention, so that whenever we fall into trouble, seeing the overwhelming magnitude of his suffering, we may gain real consolation and comfort from his wisdom and patience. He is set before us as a universal teacher for the whole world, for all who are experiencing any kind of distress, enabling everyone to look toward one who surpassed them all in the overwhelming magnitude of his troubles. For all these things, then, let us give thanks to God—the merciful God. Let us benefit from this account, constantly keeping it in mind in the assembly, at home, in the marketplace, yes, everywhere. And let us carefully obtain all the wealth of wisdom contained in this story, so that we may pass through hardships without grief and attain the good things laid up for us. May we all be enabled to obtain these benefits by the grace and kindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom, with the Father, together with the Holy Spirit, be praise, honor, adoration, now and ever, even to all eternity. Amen.

What excuse, therefore, shall we have if, while this man bore all these excessive evils with such fortitude, we cannot bear even the half of them? for you are unable—-you are unable, I say, to show, or even to name, any man who has borne such numerous and heavy evils. For this cause, therefore, Christ brought them before our notice, in order that whensoever we fall into trouble, seeing in his case the exceeding greatness of his affliction, we may, from his wisdom and patience, gain effectual consolation and comfort; for he is set as a general instructor of the whole world, for all who are suffering any kind of distress; enabling all to look to one who surpassed them all in the exceeding greatness of his woes. For all these things, therefore, let us give thanks unto God—-the merciful God; let us reap the benefit of this narrative, continually bearing it in mind, in the assembly, at home, in the market, yea everywhere; and let us diligently gain all the wealth of wisdom contained in this parable, in order that we may without grief pass through evils, and that we may attain the good things in store. Which benefits may we all be enabled to gain, by the grace and kindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom, with the Father, together with the Holy Spirit, be praise, honour, adoration, now and ever, even to all eternity. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of Matthew — Homily 90

One of Chrysostom’s 90 homilies on the Gospel of Matthew, preached at Antioch.

Source: Translated by George Prevost and revised by M.B. Riddle. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 10. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1888. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/200190.htm>.

Opening

Matthew 28:11-14.

Matt. XXVIII. 11-14.

Now as they were going, some of the guards came into the city and reported to the chief priests everything that had happened. After the chief priests had gathered with the elders and formed a plan, they gave a large sum of money to the soldiers, telling them, "Say that His disciples came during the night and stole Him away while you were sleeping. And if this comes to the governor's attention, we will persuade him and keep you out of trouble."

Now when they were going, behold, some of the watch came into the city, and declared unto the chief priests all the things that were done. And when they had assembled with the elders, and had taken counsel, they gave large money unto the soldiers, saying, Say ye, His disciples came by night, and stole Him away while we slept. And if this come to the governor's ears, we will persuade him, and secure you.

For the sake of these soldiers that earthquake took place, in order to dismay them and so that testimony might come from them, which is exactly what happened. For the report was free from suspicion because it came from the guards themselves. Some of the signs were displayed publicly to the world, others privately to those who were present on the spot. The darkness was public for the world to see, while the appearance of the angel and the earthquake were private. When the guards came and showed what had happened (for truth shines forth, being proclaimed even by its adversaries), the authorities again gave money so that they might say, as it is expressed, that His disciples came and stole Him.

For the sake of these soldiers that earthquake took place, in order to dismay them, and that the testimony might come from them, which accordingly was the result. For the report was thus free from suspicion, as proceeding from the guards themselves. For of the signs some were displayed publicly to the world, others privately to those present on the spot; publicly for the world was the darkness, privately the appearance of the angel, the earthquake. When then they came and showed it (for truth shines forth, being proclaimed by its adversaries), they again gave money, that they might say, as it is expressed, that His disciples came and stole Him.

How did they steal him? You most foolish of all men! Because the truth is so clear and obvious, they cannot even construct a believable falsehood. What they said was highly incredible, and the lie did not even sound plausible. How, I ask, did the disciples steal him—poor and uneducated men who did not even dare to show themselves? What? Was there not a seal placed on it? What? Were there not so many guards, soldiers, and Jews stationed around it? What? Did these men not suspect this very thing and take precautions, losing sleep and remaining anxious about it? And why would they even steal it? To invent the doctrine of the resurrection? How would it occur to men who were content to remain hidden and simply survive to invent such a thing? And how could they remove the stone that had been secured? How could they have escaped notice from so many? Even if they had despised death, they would not have attempted something purposeless and futile, defying so many who were keeping watch. Moreover, their fearfulness was clearly shown by what they had done earlier—when they saw him seized, they all fled from him. If at that time they did not dare even to stand their ground when they saw him alive, how could they not have feared such a large number of soldiers when he was dead? What? Was it to break open a door? Was it so that one person could escape notice? A large stone lay upon it, requiring many hands to move it.

How did they steal Him? O most foolish of all men! For because of the clearness and conspicuousness of the truth, they are not even able to make up a falsehood. For indeed what they said was highly incredible, and the falsehood had not even speciousness. For how, I ask, did the disciples steal Him, men poor and unlearned, and not venturing so much as to show themselves? What? Was not a seal put upon it? What? Were there not so many watchmen, and soldiers, and Jews stationed round it? What? Did not those men suspect this very thing, and take thought, and break their rest, and continue anxious about it? And wherefore moreover did they steal it? That they might feign the doctrine of the resurrection? And how should it enter their minds to feign such a thing, men who were well content to be hidden and to live? And how could they remove the stone that was made sure? How could they have escaped the observation of so many? Nay, though they had despised death, they would not have attempted without purpose, and fruitlessly to venture in defiance of so many who were on the watch. And that moreover they were timorous, what they had done before showed clearly, at least, when they saw Him seized, all rushed away from Him. If then at that time they did not dare so much as to stand their ground when they saw Him alive, how when He was dead could they but have feared such a number of soldiers? What? Was it to burst open a door? Was it that one should escape notice? A great stone lay upon it, needing many hands to move it.

They were right in saying, "So the last error shall be worse than the first" (Matthew 27:64), making this declaration against themselves, for when after so much mad conduct they ought to have repented, they instead strove to outdo their former acts, inventing absurd fictions. Just as when He was alive they purchased His blood, so when He was dead and risen again, they again tried to use money to undermine the evidence of His resurrection. But notice, I ask you, how they are caught everywhere by their own actions. For if they had not come to Pilate, nor asked for the guard, they would have been more able to act this shamelessly, but as it was, they could not. For indeed, as though they were working to stop their own mouths, they did all things in just this way. For if the disciples did not have strength to watch with Him, and that even though He rebuked them, how could they have dared to do these things? And why did they not steal Him before this, but only when you had come? For if they had intended to do this, they would have done it when the tomb was not yet guarded on the first night, when it could have been done without danger and in security. For it was on the Sabbath that they came and begged Pilate to have the watch and kept guard, but during the first night none of these was present by the tomb.

They were right in saying, So the last error shall be worse than the first, Matthew 27:64 making this declaration against themselves, for that, when after so much mad conduct they ought to have repented, they rather strive to outdo their former acts, feigning absurd fictions, and as, when He was alive, they purchased His blood, so when He was dead and risen again, they again by money were striving to undermine the evidence of His resurrection. But do thou mark, I pray you, how by their own doings they are caught everywhere. For if they had not come to Pilate, nor asked for the guard, they would have been more able to act thus impudently, but as it was, not so. For indeed, as though they were laboring to stop their own mouths, even so did they all things. For if the disciples had not strength to watch with Him, and that, though upbraided by Him, how could they have ventured upon these things? And wherefore did they not steal Him before this, but when you had come? For if they had been minded to do this, they would have done it, when the tomb was not yet guarded on the first night, when it was to be done without danger, and in security. For it was on the Sabbath that they came and begged of Pilate to have the watch, and kept guard, but during the first night none of these was present by the sepulchre.

And what about the burial cloths that were stuck to the body with the myrrh? Peter saw these lying there. If they had intended to steal the body, they would not have stolen it naked—not only because that would dishonor it, but also to avoid wasting time unwrapping it and to prevent anyone who might wake up from catching them in the act. This is especially true since myrrh is a substance that adheres closely to the body and clings to the clothes, making it difficult to remove the cloths from the body. Anyone doing this would have needed a lot of time, which makes the story of the theft implausible from this perspective as well.

2. And what mean also the napkins that were stuck on with the myrrh; for Peter saw these lying. For if they had been disposed to steal, they would not have stolen the body naked, not because of dishonoring it only, but in order not to delay and lose time in stripping it, and not to give them that were so disposed opportunity to awake and seize them. Especially when it was myrrh, a drug that adheres so to the body, and cleaves to the clothes, whence it was not easy to take the clothes off the body, but they that did this needed much time, so that from this again, the tale of the theft is improbable.

What then? Did they not know how angry the Jews were? And that the Jews would take out their anger on them? And what benefit would it be to them at all, if He had not risen again?

What? Did they not know the rage of the Jews? And that they would vent their anger on them? And what profit was it at all to them, if He had not risen again?

So these men, knowing that they had made up this entire story, gave money and said, "Say these things, and we will persuade the governor." They wanted the report to spread, fighting uselessly against the truth. By their efforts to hide it, they actually caused it to appear clearly, even against their own will. Indeed, this very action confirms the resurrection—the fact that they said the disciples stole Him. This is the statement of men admitting that the body was not there. So when they acknowledge the body was not there, but the theft is shown to be false and unbelievable—because of the guards watching over it, the seals, and the disciples' fearfulness—the proof of the resurrection becomes undeniable even from this evidence.

So these men, being conscious that they had made up all this tale, gave money, and said, Say ye these things, and we will persuade the governor. For they desire that the report should be published, fighting in vain against the truth; and by their endeavors to obscure it, by these even against their will they occasioned it to appear clearly. For indeed even this establishes the resurrection, the fact I mean of their saying, that the disciples stole Him. For this is the language of men confessing, that the body was not there. When therefore they confess the body was not there, but the stealing it is shown to be false and incredible, by their watching by it, and by the seals, and by the timidity of the disciples, the proof of the resurrection even hence appears incontrovertible.

Nevertheless, these shameless and bold men, even though there were so many things to silence them, said, "Say this is what happened, and we will persuade the governor and will protect you." Do you see how everyone is corrupt? Pilate, because he was persuaded? The soldiers? The Jewish people? But don't be surprised if money prevailed over the soldiers. For if it showed itself to be so powerful with His disciple, how much more with these men.

Nevertheless, these shameless and audacious men, although there were so many things to stop their mouths, Say ye, these are their words, and we will persuade, and will secure you. Do you see all depraved? Pilate, for he was persuaded? The soldiers? The Jewish people? But marvel not, if money prevailed over soldiers. For if with His disciple it showed its might to be so great, much more with these.

This saying, it is said, is commonly reported even until this day. Do you see again the disciples' love of truth, how they are not ashamed to say even this—that such a report prevailed against them.

And this saying is commonly reported, it is said, until this day. Do you see again the disciples' love of truth, how they are not ashamed of saying even this, that such a report prevailed against them.

Then the eleven disciples went to Galilee, and some worshipped, while some doubted when they saw Him.

Then the eleven disciples went away into Galilee, and some worshipped, and some when they saw Him doubted.

This appears to me to be the final appearance in Galilee, when He commissioned them to go out and baptize. And if some doubted, we should admire once again their honesty in not hiding even their failures right up to the very end. Yet even these doubters were convinced by what they saw.

This seems to me to be the last appearance in Galilee, when He sent them forth to baptize. And if some doubted, herein again admire their truthfulness, how they conceal not even their shortcomings up to the last day. Nevertheless, even these are assured by their sight.

What does He say to them when He sees them? "All power is given to me in heaven and on earth." Again He speaks to them more in a human manner, because they had not yet received the Spirit which could lift them to higher understanding. "Go, make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all things that I have commanded you." He gives one charge regarding doctrine and the other regarding commandments. He makes no mention of the Jews, brings up nothing that had happened before, does not reproach Peter for his denial or any of the others for their flight. Instead, having placed in their hands a summary of the doctrine expressed in the baptismal formula, He commands them to spread it over the whole world.

What then says He unto them, when He sees them? All power is given unto me in heaven and on earth. Again He speaks to them more after the manner of man, for they had not yet received the spirit, which was able to raise them on high. Go, make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost: teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you; giving the one charge with a view to doctrine, the other concerning commandments. And of the Jews He makes no mention, neither brings forward what had been done, nor upbraids Peter with his denial, nor any one of the others with their flight, but having put into their hands a summary of the doctrine, that expressed by the form of baptism, commands them to pour forth over the whole world.

After this, because He had commanded them to do great things, to build up their courage He says, "Look! I am with you always, even to the end of the world." Do you see His own distinctive power again? Do you see how those other things were also spoken in condescension? And He promised to be not only with those men, but also with all who believe after them. For clearly the apostles were not going to remain here until the end of the world, but He speaks to the believers as to one body. For don't tell me, He says, about how difficult these things are, because I am with you—I who make all things easy. He said this to the prophets in the Old Testament as well, continually—both to Jeremiah when he objected because of his youth, and to Moses and Ezekiel when they shrank back from their calling—"I am with you." He says the same here to these men. And notice, I ask you, how excellent these men are, for the others, when sent to one nation, often made excuses, but these said nothing of the sort, though they were sent to the whole world. And He reminds them also of the final consummation, so that He may draw them forward more, and so that they may not look only at the present dangers, but also at the good things to come that are without end.

After that, because he had enjoined on them great things, to raise their courage, He says, Lo! I am with you always, even unto the end of the world. Matthew 28:20 Do you see His own proper power again? Do you see how those other things also were spoken for condescension? And not with those men only did He promise to be, but also with all that believe after them. For plainly the apostles were not to remain here unto the end of the world; but he speaks to the believers as to one body. For tell me not, says He, of the difficulty of the things: for I am with you, who make all things easy. This He said to the prophets also in the Old Testament continually, as well to Jeremiah objecting his youth, Jeremiah 1:6, 8 as to Moses and Ezekiel shrinking from the office, I am with you, this here also to these men. And mark, I pray you, the excellence of these, for the others, when sent to one nation, often excused themselves, but these said nothing of the sort, though sent to the world. And He reminds them also of the consummation, that He may draw them on more, and that they may look not at the present dangers only, but also at the good things to come that are without end.

The burdensome things you will experience, He says, will end along with this present life, since even the world itself will come to an end. But the good things you will enjoy remain immortal, as I have often told you before. By reminding them of that day, He strengthened and stirred up their minds, and then sent them out. For that day is something to be desired by those who live in good works, just as on the other hand it is terrible for those in sin, like it is for the condemned.

For the irksome things, says He, that you will undergo are finished together with the present life, since at least even this world itself shall come to an end, but the good things which you shall enjoy remain immortal, as I have often told you before. Thus having invigorated and roused their minds, by the remembrance of that day, He sent them forth. For that day to them that live in good works is to be desired, even as on the other hand to those in sin, it is terrible as to the condemned.

But let us not only fear and shudder—let us also change while there is still opportunity, and let us rise out of our wickedness, for we are able to do so if we are willing. For if many people did this before grace, how much more should we do so after grace.

But let us not fear only, and shudder, but let us change too, while there is opportunity, and let us rise out of our wickedness, for we can, if we be willing. For if before grace many did this, much more after grace.

For what difficult things are we commanded to do? To split mountains apart? To fly through the air? Or to cross the Tuscan sea? Not at all, but rather a way of life so easy that it doesn't even require any tools, but only a soul and determination. For what tools did those apostles have, who accomplished such things? Did they not go about with one garment and barefoot? And yet they overcame everyone.

3. For what grievous things are we enjoined? To cleave mountains asunder? To fly into the air? Or to cross the Tuscan sea? By no means, but a way of life so easy, as not so much as to want any instruments, but a soul and purpose only. For what instruments had these apostles, who effected such things? Did they not go about with one vestment and unshod? And they got the better of all.

What is difficult about the commands? Do not have enemies. Do not hate anyone. Do not speak badly about anyone. Actually, doing the opposite of these things is much harder. But you say, "He told us to give up our money." Is that really the difficult thing? First of all, He did not command it but advised it. But even if it were a command, what is so difficult about not carrying around burdens and unnecessary worries?

For what is difficult of the injunctions? Have no enemy. Hate no man. Speak ill of no man. Nay, the opposites of these things are the greater hardships. But He said, you reply, Throw away your money. Is this then the grievous thing? In the first place, He did not command, but advised it. Yet even if it were a command, what is it grievous not to carry about burdens and unseasonable cares?

But oh, the destructive power of greed! Everything has been reduced to money; this is why everything has been turned upside down. If anyone calls another person happy, he mentions this; if he pronounces someone miserable, the description of misery comes from the same source. And all calculations are made on this basis—how one person becomes rich, how another becomes poor. Whether it involves military service, marriage, a profession, or whatever anyone undertakes, he does not commit himself to the task at hand until he sees that wealth is flowing in rapidly. After all this, should we not gather together and consider how we can drive away this plague? Should we not look with shame at the good deeds of our fathers? Of the three thousand, of the five thousand, who held all things in common?

But oh covetousness! All things have become money; for this cause all things are turned upside down. If anyone declares another happy, he mentions this; should he pronounce him wretched, hence is derived the description of wretchedness. And all reckonings are made on this account, how such an one gets rich, how such an one gets poor. Should it be military service, should it be marriage, should it be a trade, should it be what you will that any man takes in hand, he does not apply to what is proposed, until he see these riches are coming in rapidly upon him. After this shall we not meet together and consult how we shall drive away this pest? Shall we not regard with shame the good deeds of our fathers? Of the three thousand, of the five thousand, who had all things common?

What is the benefit of this present life if we don't use it for our future gain? How long will you refuse to enslave the mammon that has enslaved you? How long will you be slaves of money? How long will you have no love for liberty and refuse to tear apart the bargains of covetousness? If you had become slaves of men, you would do everything possible if anyone promised you freedom. Yet being captives of covetousness, you don't even consider how you might be delivered from this bitter bondage. And yet the former would be nothing terrible, while the latter is the most bitter tyranny.

What is the profit of this present life, when we do not use it for our future gain? How long do ye not enslave the mammon that has enslaved you? How long are you slaves of money? How long have ye no love for liberty, and do not rend in pieces the bargains of covetousness? But while, if you should have become slaves of men, you do all things, if any one should promise you liberty; yet being captives of covetousness, you do not so much as consider how ye may be delivered from this bitter bondage. And yet the one were nothing terrible, the other is the most bitter tyranny.

Consider how great a price Christ paid for us. He shed His own blood; He gave up Himself. But you, even after all this, have become lazy and indifferent. The most serious thing of all is that you actually take pleasure in this slavery, you enjoy the dishonor, and what you ought to run from has become something you desire.

Consider how great a price Christ paid for us. He shed His own blood; He gave up Himself. But you, even after all this, are grown supine; and the most grievous thing of all is, that you even take delight in the slavery, you luxuriate in the dishonor, and that, from which you ought to flee, has become an object of desire to you.

But since it is right not only to lament and to blame, but also to correct, let us see what causes this passion and this evil to become desirable to you. Where does this desire come from? You say it is because riches bring honor and security. What kind of security, I ask you? The assurance that you will not suffer hunger or cold, that you will not be harmed or despised. If we promise you this security, will you then stop pursuing wealth? For if this is why riches are desirable, and if you can have security without them, what need do you have for them anymore? But how is it possible, you ask, for someone who is not rich to attain this? Rather, I say the opposite: how is it possible if one is rich? For it is necessary to flatter many people, both rulers and those under them, to beg countless others, to be a lowly slave, to live in fear and trembling, to watch suspiciously for the eyes of the envious, to fear the tongues of slanderers, and to fear the desires of other greedy men. But poverty is not like this; it is the complete opposite. It is a place of refuge and security, a calm harbor, a training ground and school for learning self-control, an imitation of the life of angels.

But since it is right not only to lament and to blame, but also to correct, let us see from what cause this passion and this evil have become an object of desire to you. Whence then, whence has this come to be an object of desire? Because, you say, it makes me to be in honor and in security. In what kind of security, I pray you? In the confidence, not to suffer hunger, nor cold, not to be harmed, not to be despised. Will you then, if we promise you this security, refrain from being rich? For if it is for this that riches are an object of desire, if it be in your power to have security without these, what need have you of these any more? And how is it possible, you say, for one who is not rich to attain to this? Nay, how is it possible (for I say the opposite thing) if one is rich? For it is necessary to flatter many, both rulers and subjects, and to entreat countless numbers, and to be a base slave, and to be in fear and trembling, and to regard with suspicion the eyes of the envious, and to fear the tongues of false accusers, and the desires of other covetous men. But poverty is not like this, but altogether the contrary. It is a place of refuge and security, a calm harbor, a wrestling ground, and school of exercise to learn self-command, an imitation of the life of angels.

Listen to these things, all you who are poor, or rather, all you who desire to be rich. It is not poverty itself that should be feared, but rather not being willing to be poor. Consider poverty to be nothing fearful, and it will not be fearful to you. For this fear does not exist in the nature of the thing itself, but in the judgment of weak-minded people. In fact, I am even ashamed that I have reason to say so much about poverty to show that it is nothing to be feared. For if you practice self-control, poverty is even a source of countless blessings for you. And if someone were to offer you kingship, political power, wealth, and luxury, and then set poverty against them and allow you to choose whichever you wanted, you would immediately seize upon poverty, if you truly understood its beauty.

Hear these things, as many as are poor; or rather also, as many as desire to be rich. It is not poverty that is the thing to be feared, but the not being willing to be poor. Account poverty to be nothing to fear, and it will not be to you a matter for fear. For neither is this fear in the nature of the thing, but in the judgment of feeble-minded men. Or rather, I am even ashamed that I have occasion to say so much concerning poverty, to show that it is nothing to be feared. For if you practise self-command, it is even a fountain to you of countless blessings. And if any one were to offer you sovereignty, and political power, and wealth, and luxury, and then having set against them poverty, were to give you your choice to take which thou would, you would straightway seize upon poverty, if indeed you knew the beauty thereof.

I know that many people laugh when these things are said, but we are not troubled by this. We ask you to stay, and soon you will agree with us. To me, poverty seems like a beautiful, attractive, and graceful young woman, while greed seems like some monstrous female figure—some Scylla or Hydra, or some other similar monster invented by writers of fables.

4. And I know that many laugh, when these things are said; but we are not troubled but we require you to stay, and soon ye will give judgment with us. For to me poverty seems like some comely, fair, and well-favored damsel, but covetousness like some monster shaped woman, some Scylla or Hydra, or some other like prodigies feigned by fabulous writers.

Don't bring forward, I ask you, those who accuse poverty, but rather those who have shone brightly through it. Nurtured in this, Elijah was caught up in that blessed assumption. With this Elisha shone; with this John; with this all the apostles; but with the other, Ahab, Jezebel, Gehazi, Judas, Nero, Caiaphas, were condemned.

For bring not forward, I pray you, them that accuse poverty, but them that have shone thereby. Nurtured in this, Elias was caught up in that blessed assumption. With this Eliseus shone; with this John; with this all the apostles; but with the other, Ahab, Jezebel, Gehazi, Judas, Nero, Caiaphas, were condemned.

But if you wish, let us not only look at those who have been glorious in poverty, but let us observe the beauty of this virtue itself. For indeed her eye is clear and sharp, having nothing clouded in it, unlike the eye of greed, which at one moment is full of anger, at another glutted with pleasure, and at another troubled by lack of self-control. But the eye of poverty is not like this—rather it is gentle, calm, looking kindly on everyone, meek, tender, hating no one, avoiding no one. For where there are riches, there is fuel for hostility and for countless conflicts. Again, the mouth of the other is full of insults, a certain arrogance, much boasting, cursing, and deceit; but the mouth and tongue of this one are wholesome, filled with continual thanksgiving, blessing, words of gentleness, affection, courtesy, praise, and commendation. And if you would also see the proportion of her form, she is of fine stature, and far taller than wealth. And if many flee from her, do not be surprised, for so do fools flee from the rest of virtue.

But if it please you, let us not look to those only that have been glorious in poverty, but let us observe the beauty itself of this damsel. For indeed her eye is clear and piercing, having nothing turbid in it, like the eye of covetousness, which is at one time full of anger, at another sated with pleasure, at another troubled by incontinence. But the eye of poverty is not like this, but mild, calm, looking kindly on all, meek, gentle, hating no man, shunning no man. For where there are riches, there is matter for enmity, and for countless wars. The mouth again of the other is full of insults, of a certain haughtiness, of much boasting, cursing, deceit; but the mouth and the tongue of this are sound, filled with continual thanksgiving, blessing, words of gentleness, of affection, of courtesy, of praise, of commendation. And if you would see also the proportion of her members, she is of a goodly height, and far loftier than wealth. And if many flee from her, marvel not at it, for indeed so do fools from the rest of virtue.

But the poor man, you will say, is insulted by the rich person. Again you are declaring to me the praise of poverty. For who, I ask you, is blessed—the one who insults or the one who is insulted? It is clearly the insulted person. But then, covetousness drives one to insult, while poverty persuades the other to endure. But the poor man suffers hunger, you will say. Paul also suffered hunger and was in famine. But he has no rest. Neither did the Son of Man have anywhere to lay His head. Matthew 8:20

But the poor man, you will say, is insulted by him that is rich. Again you are declaring to me the praise of poverty. For who, I pray you, is blessed, the insulter, or the insulted? It is manifest that it is the insulted person. But then, the one, covetousness, urges to insult the other; poverty persuades to endure. But the poor man suffers hunger, you will say. Paul also suffered hunger, and was in famine. But he has no rest. Neither had the Son of Man where to lay His head. Matthew 8:20

Do you see how far the praises of poverty have gone, and where it places you, to what men it leads you, and how it makes you a follower of the Lord? If it were good to have gold, Christ, who has unutterable blessings, would have given this to His disciples. But now, far from giving it to them, He forbade them to have it. Therefore Peter also, far from being ashamed of poverty, actually glories in it, saying, "Silver and gold have I none; but what I have give I you" (Acts 3:6). And who among you would not have wanted to say this? Indeed, we all would extremely desire to, perhaps someone may say. Then throw away your silver, throw away your gold. And if I throw it away, you will say, shall I receive the power of Peter? Why, what made Peter blessed, tell me? Was it really that he lifted up the lame man? By no means, but not having these riches—this is what brought him Heaven. For of those who performed these miracles, many fell into hell, but those who did good things attained a kingdom. And you may learn this even from Peter himself. For there were two things that he said: "Silver and gold have I none," and "In the name of Jesus Christ rise up and walk."

Do you see how far the praises of poverty have proceeded, and where it places you, to what men it leads you on, and how it makes you a follower of the Lord? If it were good to have gold, Christ, who have the unutterable blessings, would have given this to His disciples. But now so far from giving it them, He forbad them to have it. Wherefore Peter also, so far from being ashamed of poverty, even glories in it, saying, Silver and gold have I none; but what I have give I you. Acts 3:6 And who of you would not have desired to utter this saying? Nay, we all would extremely, perhaps some one may say. Then throw away your silver, throw away your gold. And if I throw it away, you will say, shall I receive the power of Peter? Why, what made Peter blessed, tell me? Was it indeed to have lifted up the lame man? By no means, but the not having these riches, this procured him Heaven. For of those that wrought these miracles, many fell into hell, but they, who did those good things, attained a kingdom. And this you may learn even of Peter himself. For there were two things that he said, Silver and gold have I none; and, In the name of Jesus Christ rise up and walk.

Which thing, then, made him glorious and blessed—raising up the lame man or casting away his money? You can learn this from the Master of the conflicts Himself. What does He Himself say to the rich man seeking eternal life? He did not say, "Raise up the lame," but "Sell your goods, and give to the poor, and come and follow me, and you shall have treasure in Heaven." And Peter again did not say, "Behold, in Your name we cast out devils," although he was casting them out, but "Behold, we have forsaken all and followed You; what shall we have?" And Christ again, in answering this apostle, did not say, "If any man raise up the lame," but "Whosoever has forsaken houses or lands shall receive a hundredfold in this world and shall inherit everlasting life."

Which sort of thing then made Him glorious and blessed, the raising up the lame man, or the casting away his money? And this you may learn from the Master of the conflicts Himself. What then does He Himself say to the rich man seeking eternal life? He said not, raise up the lame, but, Sell your goods, and give to the poor, and come and follow me, and you shall have treasure in Heaven. Matthew 19:21 And Peter again said not, Behold, in Your name we cast out devils; although he was casting them out, but, Behold, we have forsaken all and followed You what shall we have? Matthew 19:27 And Christ again, in answering this apostle, said not, If any man raise up the lame, but, Whosoever has forsaken houses or lands, shall receive an hundredfold in this world, and shall inherit everlasting life.

Let us also imitate this man, so that we may not be put to shame, but may stand with confidence at the judgment seat of Christ and win Him to be with us, just as He was with His disciples. For He will be with us, just as He was with them, if we are willing to follow them and to be imitators of their life and conduct. For it is because of these things that God crowns and commends people, not requiring you to raise the dead or to heal the lame. For these things do not make one like Peter, but rather the casting away of one's possessions, for this was the apostles' achievement.

Let us also then emulate this man, that we may not be confounded, but may with confidence stand at the judgment seat of Christ; that we may win Him to be with us, even as He was with His disciples. For He will be with us, like as He was with them, if we are willing to follow them, and to be imitators of their life and conversation. For in consequence of these things God crowns, and commends men, not requiring of you to raise the dead, or to cure the lame. For not these things make one to be like Peter, but the casting away one's goods, for this was the apostles' achievement.

But do you not find it possible to cast them away? In the first place, I say it is possible. But I do not compel you if you are unwilling, nor do I force you to do it. However, I do ask this: spend at least a portion on those in need, and seek for yourself nothing more than what is necessary. For in this way we will both live our life here without trouble and in security, and we will enjoy eternal life. May God grant that we all may attain this, through the grace and love toward mankind of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory and might, together with the Father and the Holy Spirit, now and always, and forever and ever. Amen.

But do you not find it possible to cast them away? In the first place, I say, it is possible; but I compel you not, if you are not willing, nor constrain you to it; but this I entreat, to spend at least a part on the needy, and to seek for yourself nothing more than is necessary. For thus shall we both live our life here without trouble, and in security, and enjoy eternal life; unto which God grant we all may attain, by the grace and love towards man of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory and might, together with the Father and the Holy Ghost, now and always, and world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of Matthew — Homily 89

One of Chrysostom’s 90 homilies on the Gospel of Matthew, preached at Antioch.

Source: Translated by George Prevost and revised by M.B. Riddle. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 10. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1888. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/200189.htm>.

Opening

Matthew 27:62-64.

Matt. XXVII. 62-64.

The next day, which followed the day of preparation, the chief priests and Pharisees came together to Pilate, saying, "Sir, we remember that this deceiver said, while he was still alive, 'After three days I will rise again.' Therefore command that the tomb be secured until the third day, in case his disciples come and steal him away and tell the people, 'He has risen from the dead.' Then the last deception would be worse than the first."

Now the next day, that followed the day of the preparation, the chief priests and Pharisees came together unto Pilate, saying, Sir, we remember that that deceiver said, while He was yet alive, After three days I will rise again. Command therefore that the sepulchre be made sure until the third day, lest His disciples come and steal Him away, and say to the people, He is risen from the dead: so the last error should be worse than the first.

Everywhere deceit backfires on itself and unwillingly supports the truth. And observe this. It was necessary for people to believe that He died, that He rose again, and that He was buried, and all these things were accomplished by His enemies. See how their words bear witness to every one of these facts. "We remember," they say, "that that deceiver said, when He was yet alive" (He was therefore now dead), "After three days I rise again. Command therefore that the sepulchre be sealed" (He was therefore buried), "lest His disciples come and steal Him away." So if the tomb is sealed, there will be no foul play. For there could not be. Therefore the proof of His resurrection has become irrefutable by what they themselves have put forward. For because it was sealed, there was no foul play. But if there was no foul play, and the tomb was found empty, it is clear that He is risen, plainly and irrefutably. Do you see how even against their will they contend for the proof of the truth?

Everywhere deceit recoils upon itself, and against its will supports the truth. And observe. It was necessary for it to be believed that He died, and that He rose again, and that He was buried, and all these things are brought to pass by His enemies. See, at any rate, these words bearing witness to every one of these facts. We remember, these are the words, that that deceiver said, when He was yet alive, (He was therefore now dead), After three days I rise again. Command therefore that the sepulchre be sealed, (He was therefore buried), lest His disciples come and steal Him away. So that if the sepulchre be sealed, there will be no unfair dealing. For there could not be. So then the proof of His resurrection has become incontrovertible by what you have put forward. For because it was sealed, there was no unfair dealing. But if there was no unfair dealing, and the sepulchre was found empty, it is manifest that He is risen, plainly and incontrovertibly. Do you see, how even against their will they contend for the proof of the truth?

Notice, I ask you, the disciples' love of truth—how they hide none of the things said by his enemies from us, even though they use insulting language. Look, for instance, they even call him a deceiver, and these men do not keep silent about that.

But mark thou, I pray you, the disciples' love of truth, how they conceal from us none of the things that are said by His enemies, though they use opprobrious language. Behold, at any rate, they even call Him a deceiver, and these men are not silent about that.

But these things also show their cruelty (that they didn't let go of their anger even at His death), and these men's simple and truthful disposition.

But these things show also their savageness (that not even at His death did they let go their anger), and these men's simple and truthful disposition.

But it would be worth asking about this point as well: where did He say, "After three days I rise again"? For one would not find this stated so clearly anywhere, but rather only the example of Jonah. So it appears they understood what He was saying and deliberately acted dishonestly.

But it were worth while to inquire concerning that point also, where He said, After three days I rise again? For one would not find this thus distinctly stated, but rather the example of Jonah. So that they understood His saying, and of their own will dealt unfairly.

What then does Pilate say? You have a guard; make it as secure as you can. And they made it secure, sealing the tomb and posting the guard. He does not allow the soldiers to seal it alone, because having learned about Christ, he was no longer willing to cooperate with them. But in order to be rid of them, he tolerates this also, and says, Seal it however you wish, so that you may not be able to blame others. For if the soldiers alone had sealed it, they might have said (although the claim would have been improbable and false, yet nevertheless just as in other matters they cast aside shame, so in this too they might have been able to say) that the soldiers, having allowed the body to be stolen, gave His disciples the opportunity to fabricate the story concerning His resurrection. But now, having made it secure themselves, they are not able to say even this much.

What then says Pilate? You have a watch; make it as sure as you can. And they made it sure, sealing the sepulchre, and setting the watch. He suffers not the soldiers alone to seal, for as having learned the things concerning Christ, he was no longer willing to co-operate with them. But in order to be rid of them, he endures this also, and says, Do ye seal it as you will, that you may not have it in your power to blame others. For if the soldiers only had sealed, they might have said (although the saying would have been improbable and false, yet nevertheless as in the rest they cast aside shame, so in this too they might have been able to say), that the soldiers, having given up the body to be stolen, gave His disciples opportunity to feign the history concerning His resurrection, but now having themselves made it sure, they are not able to say so much as this.

Do you see how they worked for the truth against their own will? They themselves came to Pilate, they themselves made the request, they themselves sealed the tomb and set the guard, so that they became accusers and refuters of one another. Indeed, when could the disciples have stolen Him? On the Sabbath? But how? It was not even lawful to go out. And even if they had broken the law, how would they have dared to come out, being so timid? And how could they have persuaded the crowd? By saying what? By doing what? And from what kind of enthusiasm would they have stood up for a dead man? Expecting what reward? What payment? When they saw Him still alive but merely arrested, they had fled. After His death, would they have spoken boldly on His behalf unless He had actually risen again? How could any of this make sense? That they were neither willing nor able to fake a resurrection that did not happen is clear from this evidence: He had talked to them much about a resurrection and repeatedly said, as even these very men have testified, "After three days I rise again." Therefore, if He did not rise again, it is completely clear that these men—having been deceived and having become enemies to an entire nation for His sake, and having become homeless and without a city—would have despised Him and would not have been willing to give Him such glory, since they had been deceived and had fallen into the greatest dangers on His account. That they would not even have been able to fake the resurrection unless it were true does not even require argument.

Do you see how they labor for the truth against their will? For they themselves came to Pilate, themselves asked, themselves sealed, setting the watch, so as to be accusers, and refuters one of another. And indeed when should they have stolen Him? On the Sabbath? And how? For it was not lawful so much as to go out. Exodus 16:29 And even if they transgressed the law, how should they have dared, who were so timid, to come forth? And how could they also have been able to persuade the multitude? By saying what? By doing what? And from what sort of zeal could they have stood in behalf of the dead? Expecting what recompense? What requital? Seeing Him yet alive and merely seized, they had fled; and after His death were they likely to speak boldly in His behalf, unless He had risen again? And how should these things be reasonable? For that they were neither willing nor able to feign a resurrection, that did not take place, is plain from hence. He discoursed to them much of a resurrection, and continually said, as indeed these very men have stated, After three days I rise again. If therefore He rose not again, it is quite clear that these men (having been deceived and made enemies to an entire nation for His sake, and come to be without home and without city) would have abhorred Him, and would not have been willing to invest Him with such glory; as having been deceived, and having fallen into the utmost dangers on His account. For that they would not even have been able, unless the resurrection had been true, to feign it, this does not so much as need reasoning.

What gave them confidence? Was it the cleverness of their arguments? No, they were the most uneducated of all people. Was it the abundance of their possessions? No, they had neither a walking stick nor shoes. Was it the nobility of their ancestry? No, they were lowly people from lowly families. Was it the greatness of their homeland? No, they came from obscure places. Was it their own numbers? No, there were only eleven of them at most, and they were scattered. Was it their Master's promises? But what kind of promises? If He had not risen again, they would not have been likely to trust those promises either. And how could they endure a hostile mob? If the chief among them could not stand up to the words of a woman guarding the door, and if all the rest were scattered when they saw Him arrested, how could they have thought to run to the ends of the earth and spread a fabricated story about a resurrection? For if he could not withstand a woman's threat, and they could not even bear the sight of chains, how were they able to stand against kings, rulers, and nations, where there were swords, gridirons, furnaces, and countless deaths day after day, unless they had the help of the power and grace of Him who rose again? So many miracles of such magnitude were performed, yet the Jews paid no attention to any of these things but crucified the one who had done them—would they have been likely to believe these men simply on their word about a resurrection? This is not the case, it is not so. Rather, the might of Him who rose again brought these things to pass.

For in what were they confident? In the shrewdness of their reasonings? Nay of all men they were the most unlearned. But in the abundance of their possessions? Nay, they had neither staff nor shoes. But in the distinction of their race? Nay, they were mean, and of mean ancestors. But in the greatness of their country? Nay, they were of obscure places. But in their own numbers? Nay, they were not more than eleven, and they were scattered abroad. But in their Master's promises? What kind of promises? For if He were not risen again, neither would those be likely to be trusted by them. And how should they endure a frantic people. For if the chief of them endured not the speech of a woman, keeping the door, and if all the rest too, on seeing Him bound, were scattered abroad, how should they have thought to run to the ends of the earth, and plant a feigned tale of a resurrection? For if he stood not a woman's threat, and they not so much as the sight of bonds, how were they able to stand against kings, and rulers, and nations, where were swords, and gridirons, and furnaces, and ten thousand deaths day by day, unless they had the benefit of the power and grace of Him who rose again? Such miracles and so many were done, and none of these things did the Jews regard, but crucified Him, who had done them, and were they likely to believe these men at their mere word about a resurrection? These things are not, they are not so, but the might of Him, who rose again, brought them to pass.

But notice, I ask you, how ridiculous their scheming is. "We remember," these are their words, "that that deceiver said, while He was still alive, 'After three days I rise again.'" Yet if He were a deceiver who arrogantly spoke lies, why are you afraid and rushing around using so much effort? "We are afraid," they reply, "that the disciples might steal Him away and deceive the crowd." And yet this has been shown to have no likelihood at all. Malice, however, is contentious and shameless, and tries to do what is unreasonable.

2. But mark, I pray you, their craft, how ridiculous it is. We remember, these are their words, that that deceiver said, while He was yet alive, After three days I rise again. Yet if He were a deceiver, and boastfully uttered falsehood, why are you afraid and run to and fro, and use so much diligence? We are afraid, it is replied, lest perchance the disciples steal Him away, and deceive the multitude. And yet this has been proved to have no probability at all. Malice, however, is a thing contentious and shameless, and attempts what is unreasonable.

They ordered the tomb to be secured for three days, as if they were defending their doctrines and were determined to prove that He was a deceiver even before that time, and they extended their hostility even to His tomb. For this reason, then, He rose sooner, so that they could not say He had lied and was stolen away. For His rising sooner could not be criticized, but rising later would have been full of suspicion. Indeed, if He had not risen then, while they were sitting there and watching, but instead after they had left following the three days, they would have had something to say and speak against it, though foolishly. For this reason, then, He anticipated the time. For it was fitting that the resurrection should take place while they were sitting there watching. Therefore it was also fitting that it should take place within the three days, since if it had occurred after they had passed and the men had withdrawn, the matter would have been regarded with suspicion. Therefore He also allowed them to seal it as they wished, and soldiers sat around it.

And they command it to be made sure for three days, as contending for doctrines, and being minded to prove that before that time also He was a deceiver, and they extend their malice even to His tomb. For this reason then He rose sooner, that they might not say that He spoke falsely, and was stolen. For this, His rising sooner, was open to no charge, but to be later would have been full of suspicion. For indeed if He had not risen then, when they were sitting there, and watching, but when they had withdrawn after the three days, they would have had something to say, and to speak against it, although foolishly. For this reason then He anticipated the time. For it was meet the resurrection should take place, while they were sitting by and watching. Therefore also it was fit it should take place within the three days, since if it had been when they were passed, and the men had withdrawn, the matter would have been regarded with suspicion. Therefore also He allowed them to seal it, as they were minded, and soldiers sat around it.

And they did not care about doing these things and working on a Sabbath day, but they looked to one goal only: their own wicked purpose, as though by that they were going to succeed. This was a mark of extreme foolishness and of fear now greatly dismaying them. For those who seized Him when He was living are afraid of Him when He is dead. And yet if He had been a mere man, they would have had reason to take courage. But so that they might learn that when He was living He also endured of His own will what He did endure, behold: there was both a seal, a stone, and a guard, and they were not able to hold Him. But there was only one result: the burial was made public, and the resurrection was thereby proved. For indeed soldiers sat by it, and Jews were on watch.

And they cared not about doing these things, and working on a Sabbath day, but they looked to one object only, their own wicked purpose, as though by that they were to succeed; which was a mark of extreme folly, and of fear now greatly dismaying them. For they who seized Him, when living, are afraid of Him when dead. And yet if He had been a mere man, they had reason to have taken courage. But that they might learn, that when living also He endured of His own will, what He did endure; behold, both a seal, a stone, and a watch, and they were not able to hold Him. But there was one result only, that the burial was published, and the resurrection thereby proved. For indeed soldiers sat by it, and Jews are on the watch.

In the end of the Sabbath, as it began to dawn toward the first day of the week, Mary Magdalene and the other Mary came to see the tomb. And there was a great earthquake. For an angel of the Lord descended from heaven, came and rolled back the stone from the door of the tomb, and sat on it. His appearance was like lightning, and his clothing white as snow.

But in the end of the Sabbath, as it began to dawn towards the first day of the week, came Mary Magdalene and the other Mary to see the sepulchre. And behold there was a great earthquake. For an angel of the Lord descended from Heaven, and came and rolled back the stone from the door of the tomb, and sat upon it. His countenance was like lightning, and his raiment white as snow.

The angel came after the resurrection. Why then did he come and roll away the stone? He did so because of the women, for they themselves had seen Him earlier in the tomb. Therefore, so they might believe that He had risen, they see the tomb empty of the body. For this reason he removed the stone, and for this reason an earthquake also occurred, so they might be thoroughly aroused and awakened. For they had come to anoint Him with oil, and these things happened at night, and it is likely that some had also become drowsy. And for what purpose and reason does he say, "Fear not ye"? First he frees them from their dread, and then tells them about the resurrection. And the "ye" shows them great honor, and indicates that extreme punishment awaits those who had dared to do what the others had dared, unless they repented. For to be afraid is not for you, he means, but for those who crucified Him.

After the resurrection came the angel. Why then came he, and took away the stone? Because of the women, for they themselves had seen Him then in the sepulchre. Therefore that they might believe that He was risen again, they see the sepulchre void of the body. For this cause he removed the stone, for this cause also an earthquake took place, that they might be thoroughly aroused and awakened. For they had come to pour oil on Him, and these things were done at night, and it is likely that some also had become drowsy. And for what intent and cause does he say, Fear not ye? First he delivers them from the dread, and then tells them of the resurrection. And the ye is of one showing them great honor, and indicating, that extreme punishment awaits them that had dared to do, what the others had dared, except they repented. For to be afraid is not for you, he means, but for them that crucified Him.

Having freed them from fear both through his words and his appearance (for he showed himself bright, as one bringing such good news), he went on to say, "I know that you seek Jesus the Crucified." And he is not ashamed to call Him crucified, for this is the greatest of blessings.

Having delivered them then from the fear both by his words, and by his appearance (for his form he showed bright, as bearing such good tidings), he went on to say, I know that you seek Jesus the Crucified. And he is not ashamed to call Him crucified; for this is the chief of the blessings.

He is risen. Matthew 28:6 From where is this evident? As He said. So if you refuse to believe me, he would say, remember His words, and then you will not disbelieve me either. Then he offers another proof: Come and see the place where He lay. For this reason he had lifted up the stone—so that from this too they might receive the proof. And tell His disciples that you will see Him in Galilee. And he prepares them to carry good news to others, which action most of all caused them to believe. And He spoke well in saying Galilee, freeing them from troubles and dangers, so that fear would not hinder their faith.

He is risen. Matthew 28:6 Whence is it evident? As He said. So that if you refuse to believe me, he would say, remember His words, and neither will you disbelieve me. Then also another proof, Come and see the place where He lay. For this he had lifted up the stone, in order that from this too they might receive the proof. And tell His disciples, that you shall see Him in Galilee. And he prepares them to bear good tidings to others, which thing most of all made them believe. And He said well in Galilee, freeing them from troubles and dangers, so that fear should not hinder their faith.

And they departed from the tomb with fear and joy. Why could this be? They had seen something amazing and beyond expectation—a tomb empty, where they had previously seen Him laid. Therefore He had led them to see it, so that they might become witnesses of both things: both His tomb and His resurrection. For they realized that no man could have taken Him when so many soldiers were sitting guard over Him, unless He raised Himself up. For this reason they both rejoice and wonder, and receive the reward of having remained with Him so long: that they should be the first to see and gladly declare not only what had been said, but also what they themselves had witnessed.

And they departed from the sepulchre with fear and joy. Why could this be? They had seen a thing amazing, and beyond expectation, a tomb empty, where they had before seen Him laid. Therefore also He had led them to the sight, that they might become witnesses of both things, both of His tomb, and of His resurrection. For they considered that no man could have taken Him, when so many soldiers were sitting by Him, unless He raised up Himself. For this cause also they rejoice and wonder, and receive the reward of so much continuance with Him, that they should first see and gladly declare, not what had been said only, but also what they beheld.

Therefore, after they had left with fear and joy, Jesus met them, saying, "Greetings!" They took hold of His feet, and with overwhelming joy and gladness ran to Him and received through this physical contact undeniable proof and complete assurance of the resurrection. And they worshiped Him. What does He say then? "Do not be afraid." Again, He drives out their fear, making room for faith. "But go, tell my brothers to go into Galilee, and there they will see me." Notice how He sends good news to His disciples through these women, bringing honor, as I have often said, to that sex which had been most dishonored, and bringing it to good hope, healing what had been diseased.

3. Therefore after then they had departed with fear and joy, Behold, Jesus met them, saying, All hail. But they held Him by the feet, and with exceeding joy and gladness ran unto Him, and received by the touch also, an infallible proof, and full assurance of the resurrection. And they worshipped Him. What then says He? Be not afraid. Again, He Himself casts out their fear, making way for faith, But go, tell my brethren, that they go into Galilee, and there shall they see me. Mark how He Himself sends good tidings to His disciples by these women, bringing to honor, as I have often said, that sex, which was most dishonored, and to good hopes; and healing that which was diseased.

Perhaps some of you would wish to be like them, to hold the feet of Jesus. You can even now, and not only His feet and hands, but you can even lay hold of that sacred head by receiving the awesome mysteries with a pure conscience. But not only here—you will also see Him in that day, coming with that unspeakable glory and the multitude of angels, if you are disposed to be compassionate. And you will hear not only these words, "All hail!" but also those others: "Come, you blessed of my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you before the foundation of the world."

Perchance some one of you would wish to be like them, to hold the feet of Jesus; ye can even now, and not His feet and His hands only, but even lay hold on that sacred head, receiving the awful mysteries with a pure conscience. But not here only, but also in that day you shall see Him, coming with that unspeakable glory, and the multitude of the angels, if you are disposed to be humane; and you shall hear not these words only, All hail! but also those others, Come ye blessed of my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you before the foundation of the world. Matthew 25:34

Be therefore humane, so that you may hear these things. And you women who wear gold, who have watched these women running, now at last, though late, put aside the disease of desiring golden ornaments. So if you admire these women, change the ornaments you wear and clothe yourselves instead with almsgiving. What is the use, I ask you, of these precious stones and the garments decorated with gold? My soul, you say, is glad and is pleased with these things. I asked you the benefit, but you tell me the harm. For nothing is worse than being absorbed with these things, delighting in them, and being attached to them. For this grievous slavery is more bitter when anyone finds delight even in being a slave. For in what spiritual matter will she ever be diligent as she ought? When will she laugh to scorn, as she should, the things of this world, if she thinks it is something worthy of joy that she has been chained in gold? For he who remains in prison and is pleased will never desire to be set free, and neither will this woman. But having become a kind of captive to this wicked desire, she will not endure even to hear spiritual words with proper desire and diligence, much less to engage in such work.

Be therefore humane, that you may hear these things; and you women, that wear gold, who have looked on the running of these women, at last, though late, lay aside the disease of the desire for golden ornaments. So that if you are emulous of these women, change the ornaments which you wear, and clothe yourselves instead with almsgiving. What is the use, I pray you, of these precious stones, and of the garments spangled with gold? My soul, you say, is glad, and is pleased with these things. I asked you the profit, but you tell me the hurt. For nothing is worse than being taken up with these things, and delighting in them, and being riveted to them. For more bitter is this grievous slavery, when any one finds delight even in being a slave. For in what spiritual matter will she ever be diligent as she ought; when will she laugh to scorn, as she should, the things of this world, who thinks it a worthy matter for joy, that she has been chained in gold? For he that continues in prison, and is pleased, will never desire to be set free; as indeed neither will this woman; but as having become a kind of captive to this wicked desire, she will not endure so much as to hear spiritual language with becoming desire and diligence, much less to engage in such work.

What then is the profit of these ornaments and this luxury, I ask you? "I am pleased with them," you say. Again you have described the harm and the ruin. "But I also enjoy much honor from those who look at me," you say. And what is this? This is the occasion of another destruction, when you are lifted up to pride and arrogance. Come now, since you have not told me of the profit, bear with me while I tell you of the harm. What then are the harmful results from this? Anxiety, which is greater than the pleasure. Therefore many of the onlookers—I mean those of a coarser sort—gain more pleasure from it than the woman who wears the gold. For you adorn yourself with anxiety, but they, without this burden, feast their eyes.

What then is the profit of these ornaments and this luxury? I pray you. I am pleased with them, you say. Again you have told of the hurt and the ruin. But I enjoy also, you say, much honor from the beholders. And what is this? This is the occasion of another destruction, when you are lifted up to haughtiness, to arrogance. Come now, since you have not told me of the profit, bear with me while I tell you of the mischiefs. What then are the mischiefs resulting therefrom? Anxiety, which is greater than the pleasure. Wherefore many of the beholders, these I mean of the grosser sort, derive more pleasure from it than she who wears the gold. For you indeed deck yourself with anxiety, but they, without this, feast their eyes.

Moreover, there are other harmful effects: the degrading of the soul and being viewed with envy on all sides. For neighboring women, stung by jealousy, turn against their own husbands and stir up serious conflicts against you. Along with these things comes the fact that all your free time and concern are consumed with this pursuit, that you don't devote yourself seriously to spiritual accomplishments; that you become filled with haughtiness, arrogance, and vainglory; that you are chained to the earth and lose your wings, and instead of being an eagle, you become a dog or a pig. For having given up gazing into heaven and soaring there, you bend down to the earth like a pig, being obsessed with mines and caves, and having an unmanly and base soul. But when you appear, do you turn the eyes of those in the marketplace toward you? Well then, for this very reason you should not wear gold, so that you don't become a spectacle for everyone and give many people reason to criticize you. For none of those whose eyes are on you admires you, but they mock you as someone obsessed with clothes, as boastful, as a worldly woman. And when you enter a church, you leave having gained nothing but countless mocking glances, insults, and curses, not only from the onlookers but also from the prophet. For immediately Isaiah, who has the most powerful voice of all, as soon as he sees you, will cry out, "These things says the Lord against the princely daughters of Sion; because they walked with a lofty neck, and with winkings of the eyes, and in their walking, trailing their garments, and mincing at the same time with their feet; the Lord shall take off their bravery, and instead of a sweet smell there shall be dust, and instead of a stomacher, you shall gird yourself with a cord."

Moreover, there are other things again, the debasing of the soul, the being looked upon with envy on all sides. For the neighboring women stung by it, arm themselves against their own husbands, and stir up against you grievous wars. Together with these things, the fact that all one's leisure and anxiety are spent on this object, that one does not apply one's self earnestly to spiritual achievements; that one is filled with haughtiness, arrogance, and vainglory; that one is riveted to the earth, and loses one's wings, and instead of an eagle, becomes a dog or a swine. For having given up looking up into Heaven, and flying there, you bend down to the earth like the swine, being curious about mines and caverns, and having an unmanly and base soul. But do you, when you appear, turn towards you the eyes of them at the market-place? Well then; for this very reason, you should not wear gold, that you may not become a common gazing stock, and open the mouths of many accusers. For none of those whose eyes are toward you admires you, but they jeer at you, as fond of dress, as boastful, as a carnal woman. And should you enter into a church, you go forth, without getting anything but countless leers, and revilings, and curses, not from the beholders only, but also from the prophet. For straightway Isaiah, that has the fullest voice of all, as soon as he has seen you, will cry out, These things says the Lord against the princely daughters of Sion; because they walked with a lofty neck, and with winkings of the eyes, and in their walking, trailing their garments, and mincing at the same time with their feet; the Lord shall take off their bravery, and instead of a sweet smell there shall be dust, and instead of a stomacher, you shall gird yourself with a cord. 1 Timothy 2:9

These things apply to your extravagant clothing. For these words are not addressed only to them, but to every woman who acts like them. And Paul also stands with him as an accuser, instructing Timothy to charge the women not to adorn themselves with braided hair, or gold, or pearls, or expensive clothing. So wearing gold is harmful everywhere, but especially when you are entering a church and passing through the poor. For if you were extremely eager to bring an accusation against yourself, you could not put on any other appearance than this display of cruelty and inhumanity.

These things for your gorgeous array. For not to them only are these words addressed, but to every woman that does like them. And Paul again with him stands as an accuser, telling Timothy to charge the women, not to adorn themselves with braided hair, or gold, or pearls, or costly array. So that everywhere the wearing of gold is hurtful, but especially when you are entering into a church, when you pass through the poor. For if you were exceedingly anxious to bring an accusation against yourself, you could not put on any other array than this visage of cruelty and inhumanity.

Consider how many hungry people you pass by with this clothing, how many naked bodies with this satanic display. How much better it would be to feed hungry souls than to pierce your earlobes and hang from them what could feed countless poor people for no purpose or benefit. What? Is being rich something to praise? What? Is wearing gold something to commend? Even if these things are put on you from honest earnings, what you have done is still a very serious charge against you; but when it comes from dishonesty as well, consider how much greater the offense is.

4. Consider at any rate how many hungry bellies you pass by with this array, how many naked bodies with this satanical display. How much better to feed hungry souls, than to bore through the lobes of your ears, and to hang from them the food of countless poor for no purpose or profit. What? Is to be rich a commendation? What? Is to wear gold a praise? Though it be from honest earnings that these things are put on you, even so what you have done is a very heavy charge against you; but when it is moreover from dishonesty, consider the exceeding greatness of it.

But do you love praise and honor? Then strip yourself of this ridiculous clothing, and everyone will admire you. Then you will enjoy both honor and pure pleasure, since as things stand now you are overwhelmed with mockery, creating for yourself many causes of distress arising from these things. For if any of these items goes missing, consider how many evils are born from that—how many servant girls are beaten, how many people are put to trouble, how many are led to execution, how many are thrown into prison. Lawsuits arise from this, and legal actions, and countless curses and accusations against the wife from the husband, against the husband from her friends, against the soul from itself. "But it won't be lost." In the first place, this is not easy to guarantee, but even if it is kept safe constantly, the very act of keeping it causes much anxiety and care and discomfort, with no benefit.

But do you love praises and honor? Strip yourself therefore of this ridiculous clothing, and then all will admire you; then shall you enjoy both honor and pure pleasure; since now at any rate you are overwhelmed with jeers, working for yourself many causes of vexation arising out of these things. For should any of these things be missing, consider how many are the evils that have their birth therefrom, how many maidservants are beaten, how many men put to trouble, how many led to execution, how many cast into prison. And trials arise hence, and actions, and countless curses and accusations against the wife from the husband, against the hus band from her friends, against the soul from itself. But it will not be lost. In the first place, this is not easy to secure, but even if it be kept safe constantly, yet by being kept, it occasions much anxiety and care and discomfort, and no advantage.

For what kind of benefit comes from this to the household? What advantage to the woman herself who wears it? No advantage at all, but much impropriety and criticism from every direction. How will you be able to kiss Christ's feet and cling to them when dressed this way? He turns away from this kind of adornment. For this reason He chose to be born in the house of the carpenter, or rather not even in that house, but in a shed and a manger. How then will you be able to see Him, not having beauty that is desirable in His eyes, not wearing the clothing that is lovely before Him, but what is hateful? For the person who comes to Him must not dress himself with such garments, but be clothed with virtue.

For what kind of profit arises from hence to the house? What advantage to the woman herself who wears it? No advantage indeed, but much unseemliness, and accusation from every quarter? How will you be able to kiss Christ's feet, and cling to them, when thus dressed? From this adorning He turns away. For this cause He vouchsafed to be born in the house of the carpenter, or rather not even in that house, but in a shed, and a manger. How then will you be able to behold Him, not having beauty that is desirable in His eyes, not wearing the array that is lovely before Him, but what is hateful. For he that comes unto Him must not deck himself out with such garments, but be clothed with virtue.

Think about what these jewels really are after all. They're nothing but earth and ashes. Mix water with them, and they become clay. Consider this and be ashamed to make clay your master, abandoning everything else to cling to it and to carry it around with you, even when you enter a church—the very place where you should most flee from it. The church was not built so that you could display these material riches there, but rather spiritual riches. Yet you, as if you were entering some showy parade, adorn yourself this way on every side, imitating the women on the stage, carrying about that ridiculous mass in abundance.

Consider what after all these jewels are. Nothing else than earth and ashes. Mix water with them, and they are clay. Consider and be ashamed to make clay your master, forsaking all, and abiding by it, and carrying and bearing it about, even when you enter into a church, when most of all you ought to flee from it. For neither for this cause was the church built, that you should display therein these riches, but spiritual riches. But you, as though you were entering into a pompous procession, thus deck yourself out on every side, imitating the women on the stage, even so do you carry about in profusion that ridiculous mass.

So I tell you that you come to do harm to many people. When the congregation is dismissed and people are in their homes at their tables, you can hear most of them talking about these things. They have stopped discussing what the prophet or the apostle said, and instead they describe how expensive your clothes are, how big your precious stones are, and all the other impropriety of those who wear such things.

Therefore, I tell you, you come for mischief to many, and when the congregation is dismissed, in their houses, at their tables, one may hear the more part describing these things. For they have left off saying, thus and thus said the prophet and the apostle, and they describe the costliness of your garments, the size of your precious stones, and all the other unseemliness of them that wear these things.

This makes both you and your husbands reluctant to give alms. For not one of you would easily agree to break up one of these ornaments to feed a poor person. When you would rather choose to be in distress yourself than to see these things broken to pieces, how could you feed another person at their expense?

This makes you backward in almsgiving, and your husbands. For one of you would not readily consent to break up one of these ornaments to feed a poor man. For when you would choose even yourself to be in distress rather than to behold these things broken to pieces, how should you feed another at the cost of them?

For most women feel about these things as though they were living beings, and no less than they feel toward their own children. You say, "God forbid!" Then prove it to me—prove it by your actions, since what I see now shows the opposite. For which of those who are completely enslaved by these things has ever melted them down to rescue a child's soul from death? And why do I speak of a child's soul? Who has redeemed his own soul from perishing by doing this? No, on the contrary, most people actually sell their soul for these things every day. And if any bodily sickness occurs, they do everything possible, but if they see their soul corrupted, they take no such trouble. Instead, they are careless about both their children's souls and their own souls, so that these things may remain until they rust away with time.

For most women feel towards these things, as to some living beings, and not less than towards their children. God forbid, you say. Prove me this then, prove it by your works, as now at least I see the contrary. For who ever of those that are completely taken captive, by melting down these things, would rescue a child's soul from death? And why do I say a child's? Who has redeemed his own soul thereby, when perishing? Nay, on the contrary, the more part even set it to sale for these things every day. And should any bodily infirmity take place, they do everything, but if they see their soul depraved, they take no such pains, but are careless both about their children's soul, and their own soul, in order that these things may remain to rust with time.

While you are wearing jewelry worth ten thousand talents, the member of Christ does not even enjoy basic food. And although the common Lord of all has given equally to everyone a share of heaven, the things in heaven, and the spiritual table, you do not share with Him even perishable things—and this on purpose, so that you may remain perpetually bound with these terrible chains.

And while you are wearing jewels worth ten thousand talents, the member of Christ has not the enjoyment so much as of necessary food. And whereas the common Lord of all has imparted to all alike of heaven, and of the things in Heaven, and of the spiritual table, thou dost not impart to Him even of perishing things, on purpose that you may continue perpetually bound with these grievous chains.

This is where the countless evils come from, and this is where the men's fornications come from—when you prepare them to abandon self-control, when you teach them to delight in those things that prostitutes use to decorate themselves. This is why they are so easily captured. If you had taught him to look down on these things and to take pleasure instead in chastity, godly fear, and humility, he would not have been so easily struck down by the arrows of fornication. A prostitute can adorn herself in this way to an even greater degree than you, but she cannot adorn herself with those other qualities in the same way. Train him, then, to take pleasure in those adornments which he cannot see on a prostitute. And how will you get him into this habit? If you take off the former things and put on the latter, then both your husband will be safe and you will be honored, and God will be favorable toward you, and all people will admire you, and you will attain the good things to come, by the grace and love toward mankind of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory and might, forever and ever. Amen.

Hence the countless evils, hence the fornications of the men, when you prepare them to cast off self-restraint, when you teach them to take delight in these things with which the harlot women deck themselves. For this cause they are so quickly taken captive. For if you had instructed him to look down upon these things, and to take delight in chastity, godly fear and humility, he would not have been so easily taken by the shafts of fornication. For the harlot is able to adorn herself in this way even to a greater degree than this, but with those other ornaments not so. Accustom him then to take delight in these ornaments, which he cannot see placed on the harlot. And how will you bring him into this habit? If you take off these, and put on those others, so shall both your husband be in safety, and thou in honor, and God will be propitious to you, and all men will admire you, and you will attain unto the good things to come, by the grace and love towards man of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory and might, world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of Matthew — Homily 88

One of Chrysostom’s 90 homilies on the Gospel of Matthew, preached at Antioch.

Source: Translated by George Prevost and revised by M.B. Riddle. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 10. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1888. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/200188.htm>.

Opening

Matthew 27:45-48.

Matt. XXVII. 45-48.

From the sixth hour until the ninth hour, darkness covered the entire earth. Around the ninth hour, Jesus cried out loudly, saying, "Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani?" which means, "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" When some of the people standing there heard this, they said, "This man is calling for Elijah." Immediately one of them ran and took a sponge, filled it with vinegar, put it on a reed, and gave it to Him to drink.

Now from the sixth hour there was darkness over all the earth until the ninth hour. And about the ninth hour Jesus cried with a loud voice, and said, Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani? That is to say, my God my God, why have you forsaken me? Some of them that stood there, when they heard that said, this man calls for Elias. And straight way one of them ran, and took a sponge, and filled it with vinegar, and put it on a reed, and gave Him to drink.

This is the sign he had promised to give them earlier when they asked for it, saying, "An evil and adulterous generation seeks after a sign, and there shall be no sign given to it except the sign of the prophet Jonah" (Matthew 12:39)—meaning his cross, his death, his burial, and his resurrection. And again, declaring the power of the cross in another way, he said, "When you have lifted up the Son of Man, then you shall know that I am he" (John 8:28). And what he means is this: when you have crucified me and think you have defeated me, then, above all, you will know my power.

This is the sign which before He had promised to give them when they asked it, saying, An evil and adulterous generation seeks after a sign, and there shall no sign be given to it, but the sign of the prophet Jonas; Matthew 12:39 meaning His cross, and His death, His burial, and His resurrection. And again, declaring in another way the virtue of the cross, He said, When you have lifted up the Son of Man, then shall you know that I am He. John 8:28 And what He says is to this purport: When you have crucified me, and think you have overcome me, then, above all, shall you know my might.

After the crucifixion, the city was destroyed and the Jewish state ended. They lost their political system and their freedom. Meanwhile, the gospel flourished and the word spread to the ends of the world. Sea and land, the inhabited world and the desert, all continually proclaim its power. This is what He means, along with the things that happened at the very moment of the crucifixion. Indeed, it was far more remarkable that these things occurred while He was nailed to the cross than when He was walking on earth. The wonder was not only in this, but also because what they had sought came from heaven, and it happened across the entire world. This had never happened before, except in Egypt alone when the Passover was to be fulfilled. Those events were a type of these.

For after the crucifixion, the city was destroyed, and the Jewish state came to an end, they fell away from their polity and their freedom, the gospel flourished, the word was spread abroad to the ends of the world; both sea and land, both the inhabited earth and the desert perpetually proclaim its power. These things then He means, and those which took place at the very time of the crucifixion. For indeed it was much more marvellous that these things should be done, when He was nailed to the cross, than when He was walking on earth. And not in this respect only was the wonder, but because from heaven also was that done which they had sought, and it was over all the world, which had never before happened, but in Egypt only, when the passover was to be fulfilled. For indeed those events were a type of these.

And notice when it took place. At midday, so that all who live on the earth might know it, when it was daytime all over the world. This was enough to convert them, not only by the greatness of the miracle but also by its happening at the right time. For after all their insulting and their lawless mocking, this happened when they had let go of their anger, when they had stopped mocking, when they were satisfied with their jeering and had said everything they wanted to say. Then He shows the darkness, so that at least in this way (having vented their anger) they might benefit from the miracle. For this was more marvelous than coming down from the cross—that while being on the cross He should accomplish these things. For whether they thought He Himself had done it, they ought to have believed and been afraid; or whether they thought it was not He but the Father, still they ought to have been moved to remorse, for that darkness was a sign of His anger at their crime. For that it was not an eclipse, but both wrath and indignation, is clear not only from this, but also from the duration of time, for it continued three hours, but an eclipse takes place in one moment of time, and those who have seen this know it—and indeed it has taken place even in our own generation.

And observe when it took place. At midday, that all that dwell on the earth may know it, when it was day all over the world; which was enough to convert them, not by the greatness of the miracle only, but also by its taking place in due season. For after all their insulting, and their lawless derision, this is done, when they had let go their anger, when they had ceased mocking, when they were satiated with their jeerings, and had spoken all that they were minded; then He shows the darkness, in order that at least so (having vented their anger) they may profit by the miracle. For this was more marvellous than to come down from the cross, that being on the cross He should work these things. For whether they thought He Himself had done it, they ought to have believed and to have feared; or whether not He, but the Father, yet thereby ought they to have been moved to compunction, for that darkness was a token of His anger at their crime. For that it was not an eclipse, but both wrath and indignation, is not hence alone manifest, but also by the time, for it continued three hours, but an eclipse takes place in one moment of time, and they know it, who have seen this; and indeed it has taken place even in our generation.

And how, you may ask, did not everyone marvel and recognize Him as God? Because the human race at that time was held in a state of great carelessness and vice. And this miracle was just one event, and when it had taken place, it immediately passed away; and no one was concerned to investigate the cause of it, and great was the prejudice and the habit of ungodliness. And they did not know what caused what took place, and they thought perhaps this happened in the manner of an eclipse or some natural phenomenon. And why do you marvel at those outside who knew nothing and did not inquire because of great indifference, when even those who were in Judea itself, after so many miracles, still continued to treat Him shamefully, although He plainly showed them that He Himself brought this thing about.

And how, you may say, did not all marvel, and account Him to be God? Because the race of man was then held in a state of great carelessness and vice. And this miracle was but one, and when it had taken place, immediately passed away; and no one was concerned to inquire into the cause of it, and great was the prejudice and the habit of ungodliness. And they knew not what was the cause of that which took place, and they thought perhaps this happened so, in the way of an eclipse or some natural effect. And why do you marvel about them that are without, that knew nothing, neither inquired by reason of great indifference, when even those that were in Judæa itself, after so many miracles, yet continued using Him despitefully, although He plainly showed them that He Himself wrought this thing.

And for this reason, even after this He speaks, so that they might learn that He was still alive, and that He Himself did this, and that they might become more gentle because of this as well. And He says, "Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani?" so that up to His last breath they might see that He honors His Father, and is no enemy of God. Therefore He also spoke a certain cry from the prophet, even to His last hour bearing witness to the Old Testament, and not simply a cry from the prophet, but also in Hebrew, so as to be plain and understandable to them, and by all things He shows how He is of one mind with the One who begot Him.

And for this reason, even after this He speaks, that they might learn that He was still alive, and that He Himself did this, and that they might become by this also more gentle, and He says, Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani? Matthew 27:46 that unto His last breath they might see that He honors His Father, and is no adversary of God. Wherefore also He uttered a certain cry from the prophet, even to His last hour bearing witness to the Old Testament, and not simply a cry from the prophet, but also in Hebrew, so as to be plain and intelligible to them, and by all things He shows how He is of one mind with Him that begot Him.

But notice here also their recklessness, lack of self-control, and foolishness. They thought (it is said) that He was calling Elijah, and immediately they gave Him vinegar to drink. But another came to Him and pierced His side with a spear. What could be more lawless, what more brutal, than these men, who carried their madness to such a great extent, offering insult at last even to a dead body?

But mark herein also their wantonness, and intemperance, and folly. They thought (it is said) that it was Elias whom He called, and straightway they gave Him vinegar to drink. Matthew 27:48 But another came unto Him, and pierced His side with a spear. What could be more lawless, what more brutal, than these men; who carried their madness to so great a length, offering insult at last even to a dead body?

Notice, I ask you, how He used their wicked acts for our salvation. For after the blow, the fountains of our salvation gushed forth from there.

But mark thou, I pray you, how He made use of their wickednesses for our salvation. For after the blow the fountains of our salvation gushed forth from thence.

And Jesus, when He had cried with a loud voice, yielded up the Ghost. This is what He said: "I have power to lay down my life, and I have power to take it again," and "I lay it down of myself." So for this reason He cried out with the voice, to show that the act was done by power. Notice that Mark says Pilate marveled if He were already dead, and that the centurion believed above all for this reason—because He died with power.

And Jesus, when He had cried with a loud voice, yielded up the Ghost. This is what He said, I have power to lay down my life, and I have power to take it again, and, I lay it down of myself. John 10:18 So for this cause He cried with the voice, that it might be shown that the act is done by power. Mark at any rate says, that Pilate marvelled if He were already dead: Mark 15:44 and that the centurion for this cause above all believed, because He died with power. Mark 15:39

This cry tore the veil, opened the tombs, and left the house desolate. He did this not to insult the temple (for how could He, who says, "Make not my Father's house a house of merchandise"), but to declare they were unworthy of His presence remaining there—just as when He handed it over to the Babylonians. But these things happened not only for this reason, but what took place was a prophecy of the coming desolation and of the change into a greater and higher state, and a sign of His might.

This cry rent the veil, and opened the tombs, and made the house desolate. And He did this, not as offering insult to the temple (for how should He, who says, Make not my Father's house a house of merchandise), John 2:16 but declaring them to be unworthy even of His abiding there; like as also when He delivered it over to the Babylonians. But not for this only were these things done, but what took place was a prophecy of the coming desolation, and of the change into the greater and higher state; and a sign of His might.

And along with these things, He showed Himself also by what followed afterward, by the raising of the dead. For in the instance of Elisha, one person who touched a dead body rose again, but now by a voice He raised them, while His body remained up there on the cross. And besides, those things were a type of this. For that this might be believed, that is why all that was done. And they are not merely raised, but also rocks are split, and the earth shaken, so that they might learn that He was able to strike them blind and to tear them to pieces. For He who split rocks apart and darkened the world could much more easily have done these things to them, had it been His will. But He would not, and having discharged His wrath upon the elements, it was His will to save them by mercy. But they did not lessen their madness. Such is envy, such is jealousy—it is not easily stopped. At that time then they were shameless in setting themselves against the actual events, and afterward even against the facts themselves, when a seal was put upon Him and soldiers were watching Him. He rose again, and they heard these things from the very guards, yet they even gave money in order both to corrupt others and to steal away the history of the resurrection.

And together with these things He showed Himself also by what followed after these things, by the raising of the dead. For in the instance of Elisha; one on touching a dead body rose again, but now by a voice He raised them, His body continuing up there, on the cross. And besides, those things were a type of this. For that this might be believed, therefore is that all done. And they are not merely raised, but also rocks are rent, and the earth shaken, that they might learn, that He was able to strike themselves blind, and to rend them in pieces. For He that cleft rocks asunder, and darkened the world, much more could have done these things to them, had it been His will. But He would not, but having discharged His wrath upon the elements, them it was His will to save by clemency. But they abated not their madness. Such is envy, such is jealousy, it is not easily stayed. At that time then they were impudent in setting themselves against the actual appearances; and afterwards even against the things themselves, when a seal being put upon Him, and soldiers watching Him, He rose again, and they heard these things from the very guards; they even gave money, in order both to corrupt others, and to steal away the history of the resurrection.

Marvel not therefore if at this time they were also perverse, being thus altogether prepared to set themselves impudently against all things. But observe this other point: how great the signs He had wrought were—some from heaven, some on earth, some in the very temple—at once marking His indignation and at the same time showing that what were unapproachable are now to be entered, and that heaven shall be opened, and the work removed to the true Holy of Holies. And they indeed said, "If He be the King of Israel, let Him come down now from the cross," but He shows that He is King of all the world. And whereas those men said, "Thou that destroyest this temple and buildest it in three days," He shows that it shall be made forever desolate. Again they said, "He saved others, Himself He cannot save," but He while abiding on the cross proved this most abundantly on the bodies of His servants. For if for Lazarus to rise on the fourth day was a great thing, how much more for all those who had long ago fallen asleep to appear alive at once, which was a sign of the future resurrection. For it is said that many bodies of the saints which slept arose and went into the holy city and appeared to many. For in order that what was done might not be accounted to be an imagination, they appear, even to many, in the city. And the centurion too then glorified God, saying, "Truly this was a righteous man." And the multitudes that came together to that sight returned beating their breasts. So great was the power of the crucified, that after so many mockings and scoffs and jeers, both the centurion was moved to compunction and the people. And some say that there is also a martyrdom of this centurion, who after these things grew to manhood in the faith.

Marvel not therefore if at this time also they were perverse, being thus altogether prepared to set themselves impudently against all things; but observe this other point, how great signs He had wrought, some from Heaven, some on earth, some in the very temple, at once marking His indignation, and at the same time showing that what were unapproachable are now to be entered, and that Heaven shall be opened; and the work removed to the true Holy of Holies. And they indeed said, If He be the King of Israel, let Him come down now from the cross, Matthew 27:42 but He shows that He is King of all the world. And whereas those men said, Thou that destroyest this temple, and buildest it in three days, Matthew 27:40 He shows that it shall be made forever desolate. Again they said, He saved others, Himself He cannot save, Matthew 27:42 but He while abiding on the cross proved this most abundantly on the bodies of His servants. For if for Lazarus to rise on the fourth day was a great thing, how much more for all those who had long ago fallen asleep, at once to appear alive, which was a sign of the future resurrection. For, many bodies of the saints which slept, arose, it is said, and went into the holy city, and appeared to many. For in order that what was done might not be accounted to be an imagination, they appear, even to many, in the city. And the Centurion too then glorified God, saying, Truly this was a righteous man. And the multitudes that came together to that sight, returned beating their breasts. Luke 23:47-48 So great was the power of the crucified, that after so many mockings, and scoffs, and jeers, both the centurion was moved to compunction, and the people. And some say that there is also a martyrdom of this centurion, who after these things grew to manhood in the faith.

Many women were there watching from a distance, who had followed Him and served Him: Mary Magdalene, Mary the mother of James and Joses, and the mother of Zebedee's sons.

And many women were there beholding afar off, which had followed Him, ministering unto Him, Mary Magdalene, and Mary the mother of James, and Joses, and the mother of Zebedee's sons.

These events were witnessed by the women who were most disposed to sympathize with Him and who were mourning Him most of all. Notice how great their devotion was. They had followed Him, serving Him, and remained present even through the time of danger. That is why they saw everything: how He cried out, how He gave up His spirit, how the rocks split, and all the rest.

These things the women see done, these who were most inclined to feel for Him, who were most of all bewailing Him. And mark how great their assiduity. They had followed Him ministering to Him, and were present even unto the time of the dangers. Wherefore also they saw all; how He cried, how He gave up the ghost, how the rocks were rent, and all the rest.

And these women were the first to see Jesus; the group that had been most condemned was the first to receive the sight of the blessings and showed the greatest courage. And when the disciples had fled, these women were present. But who were these? His mother, for she is called the mother of James, and the others. But another evangelist says that many also lamented over the things that happened and struck their breasts, which above all shows the cruelty of the Jews, because they celebrated things that others were mourning and were neither moved by pity nor restrained by fear. For indeed the things that happened showed great wrath and were not merely signs, but signs of anger—all of them: the darkness, the split rocks, the veil torn in half, the shaking of the earth—and the extent of the indignation was immense.

And these first see Jesus; and the sex that was most condemned, this first enjoys the sight of the blessings, this most shows its courage. And when the disciples had fled, these were present. But who were these? His mother, for she is called mother of James, and the rest. But another evangelist Luke 22:48 says, that many also lamented over the things that were done, and smote their breasts, which above all shows the cruelty of the Jews, for that they gloried in things for which others were lamenting, and were neither moved by pity, nor checked by fear. For indeed the things that were done were of great wrath, and were not merely signs, but signs of anger all of them, the darkness, the cloven rocks, the veil rent in the midst, the shaking of the earth, and great was the excess of the indignation.

Joseph went and asked for the body. This was the Joseph who had been concealing his discipleship until recently, but now he had become very bold after the death of Christ. He was not an obscure or unnoticed person, but a member of the council and highly distinguished. From this fact especially one can see his courage. He exposed himself to death and took upon himself the enmity of everyone by his affection for Jesus, both daring to ask for the body and not giving up until he obtained it. He showed his love and his courage not only by taking it and burying it in a costly manner, but also by laying it in his own new tomb. This was not arranged without purpose, but so that there would not be any suspicion that one person had risen instead of another.

But Joseph went, and begged the body. This was Joseph, who was concealing his discipleship of late; now however he had become very bold after the death of Christ. For neither was he an obscure person, nor of the unnoticed; but one of the council, and highly distinguished; from which circumstance especially one may see his courage. For he exposed himself to death, taking upon him enmity with all, by his affection to Jesus, both having dared to beg the body, and not having desisted until he obtained it. But not by taking it only, nor by burying it in a costly manner, but also by laying it in his own new tomb, he shows his love, and his courage. And this was not so ordered without purpose, but so there should not be any bare suspicion, that one had risen instead of another.

And there was Mary Magdalene, and the other Mary, sitting opposite the tomb. For what purpose did they wait by it? As yet they knew nothing great and lofty about Him, as they should have, which is why they had brought ointments and were waiting at the tomb, so that if the madness of the Jews should subside, they might go and embrace the body. Do you see the women's courage? Do you see their affection? Do you see their generosity with money? Their courage even in the face of death?

And there was Mary Magdalene, and the other Mary, sitting over against the sepulchre. For what purpose do these wait by it? As yet they knew nothing great, as was meet, and high about Him, wherefore also they had brought ointments, and were waiting at the tomb, so that if the madness of the Jews should relax, they might go and embrace the body. Do you see women's courage? Do you see their affection? Do you see their noble spirit in money? Their noble spirit even unto death?

Let us men imitate the women; let us not abandon Jesus in times of trial. For they spent so much even for Him when dead and risked their lives, but we (for I say the same things again) do not feed Him when hungry or clothe Him when naked. Instead, seeing Him begging, we pass Him by. And yet if you saw Him Himself, everyone would give away all their possessions. But even now it is the same. For He Himself has said, "I am He." Why then do you not give away everything? For even now you hear Him saying, "You do it unto Me," and there is no difference whether you give to this man or to Him; you have just as much as these women who fed Him then, and even much more. But don't be confused! For it is not as great to have fed Him appearing in His own person, which would be enough to move a heart of stone, as it is (because of His word alone) to serve the poor, the disabled, and the one who is bent down. For in the first case, the appearance and dignity of the One who appears shares the credit with you for what is done; but here the reward belongs entirely to your kindness, and there is proof of greater reverence toward Him when, at His word alone, you serve your fellow-servant and provide for him in all things. Provide for him, and believe Him who receives it and says, "You give to Me." For unless you had given to Him, He would not have counted you worthy of a kingdom. If you had not turned away from Him, He would not have sent you to hell—not if you had overlooked some random person—but because it is He Himself who is despised, the blame is great.

Let us men imitate the women; let us not forsake Jesus in temptations. For they for Him even dead spent so much and exposed their lives, but we (for again I say the same things) neither feed Him when hungry, nor clothe Him when naked, but seeing Him begging, we pass Him by. And yet if you saw Himself, every one would strip himself of all his goods. But even now it is the same. For He Himself has said, I am he. Why then do you not strip yourself of all? For indeed even now you hear Him say, You do it unto me; and there is no difference whether you give to this man or to Him; you have nothing less than these women that then fed Him, but even much more. But be not perplexed! For it is not so much to have fed Him appearing in His own person, which would be enough to prevail with a heart of stone, as (because of His mere word) to wait upon the poor, the maimed, him that is bent down. For in the former case, the look and the dignity of Him who appears divides with you that which is done; but here the reward is entire for your benevolence; and there is the proof of the greater reverence towards Him, when at His mere word waiting upon your fellow-servant you refresh him in all things. Refresh him, and believe Him, who receives it, and says, You give to me. For unless you had given to Him, He would not have counted you worthy of a kingdom. If you had not turned away from Him, He would not have sent you to hell, if you had overlooked a chance person; but because it is He Himself that is despised, therefore great is the blame.

Paul also persecuted Jesus by persecuting those who belong to Him. That's why Jesus said, "Why do you persecute me?" So let us think this way when we give—that we are giving to Christ Himself. His words are more reliable than what we see with our eyes. When you see a poor person, remember what He said, where He declared that it is He Himself who is being fed. Even though the person you see is not Christ in appearance, Christ Himself receives and begs in that person's form.

Thus also Paul persecuted Him, in persecuting them that are His; wherefore too He said, Why do you persecute me? Acts 9:4 Thus therefore let us feel, as bestowing on Christ Himself when we bestow. For indeed His words are more sure than our sight. When therefore you see a poor man, remember His words, by which He declared, that it is He Himself who is fed. For though that which appears be not Christ, yet in this man's form Christ Himself receives and begs.

Are you ashamed to hear that Christ begs? You should be more ashamed when you don't give to Him as He begs from you. That is what should bring shame – that brings judgment and punishment. Christ's begging comes from His goodness, which means we should even take pride in it. But when you don't give, that comes from your lack of compassion. If you don't believe now that when you pass by a poor believer you are passing by Christ Himself, you will believe it then, when He brings you forward and says, "Since you did not do it for these, you did not do it for me." But God forbid that we should learn it that way. May He grant instead that we believe now, produce fruit, and hear that most blessed voice that brings us into the kingdom.

But are you ashamed to hear that Christ begs? Rather be ashamed when thou dost not give to Him begging of you. For this is shame, this is vengeance and punishment. Since for Him to beg is of His goodness, wherefore we ought even to glory therein; but for you not to give, is of your inhumanity. But if you believe not now, that in passing by a poor man that is a believer, you pass by Him, you will believe it then, when He will bring you into the midst and say, Inasmuch as you did it not to these, you did it not to me. But God forbid that we should so learn it, and grant rather that we may believe now, and bring forth fruit, and hear that most blessed voice that brings us into the kingdom.

But perhaps someone will say, "You talk to us about almsgiving and kindness every day." I will not stop speaking about this. If you had actually achieved it, I still should not stop—for fear of making you more careless. Yet if you had achieved it, I might have eased up a little. But if you have not even reached the halfway point, do not say these things to me, but to yourselves. For indeed you do the same thing in blaming me as if a small child, hearing the letter alpha mentioned often and not learning it, were to blame his teacher because he is continually and constantly reminding him about it.

But perhaps some one will say, You are every day discoursing to us of almsgiving and humanity. Neither will I cease to speak of this. For if you had attained to it, in the first place, not even so ought I to desist, for fear of making you the more remiss; yet had ye attained, I might have relaxed a little; but if you have not arrived even at the half; say not these things to me, but to yourselves. For indeed you do the same in blaming me, as if a little child, hearing often of the letter alpha, and not learning it, were to blame its teacher, because he is continually and for ever reminding him about it.

Who from these talks has become more eager in giving alms? Who has thrown down his money? Who has given half his possessions? Who the third part? No one. How then could it be anything but absurd, when you do not learn, to demand that we stop teaching? You ought to do the opposite. Even if we wanted to stop, you ought to prevent us and say, "We have not yet learned these things, so why have you stopped reminding us of them?" If someone were suffering from his eye, and I happened to be a physician, and after covering it up and anointing it and applying other treatment, I had not helped it much and so had stopped; would he not have come to the doors of my clinic and cried out against me, accusing me of great negligence because I had withdrawn while the disease remained? And if, when blamed, I had said in reply that I had covered it up and anointed it, would he have accepted it? Not at all, but would immediately have said, "And what is the benefit if I still suffer pain?" Reason the same way about your soul. What if after repeatedly treating a hand that was lifeless and shrunken, I had not succeeded in softening it? Would I not have heard the same thing? Even now when a hand is shrunken and withered we bathe it, and for this reason, until we can stretch it out perfectly, we will not stop. If only you too would speak of nothing else, at home and in the marketplace, at the table and at night, even as a dream. For if we were always concerned about these things by day, even in our dreams we would be occupied with them.

For who from these discourses has become more forward in the giving of alms? Who has cast down his money? Who has given the half of his substance? Who the third part? No one. How then should it be other than absurd, when you do not learn, to require us to desist from teaching? You ought to do the contrary. Though we were minded to desist, you ought to stop us and to say, we have not yet learned these things, and how is it you have desisted from reminding us of them? If it befell any one to suffer from his eye, and I happened to be a physician, and then having covered it up and anointed it, and having applied other treatment, I had not benefited it much, and so had desisted; would he not have come to the doors of my surgery and cried out against me, accusing me of great remissness, for that I had of myself withdrawn, while the disease remained; and if, on being blamed, I had said in reply to these things, that I had covered it up, and anointed it; would he have endured it? By no means, but would immediately have said; And what is the advantage, if I still suffer pain. Reason thus also with respect to your soul. But what if after having often fomented a hand that was lifeless and shrunk, I had not succeeded in mollifying it? Should I not have heard the same thing? And even now a hand that is shrunk and withered we bathe, and for this reason, until we can stretch it out perfectly, we will not desist. Would that you too were to discourse of nothing else, at home and at market, at table and at night, and as a dream. For if we were always careful about these things by day, even in our dreams we should be engaged in them.

What do you say? Am I always talking about almsgiving? I would prefer that there were no great need for me to give you this advice, but that I could speak about the battle against the Jews, heathens, and heretics. But when you are not yet healthy, how can anyone arm you for the fight? How can he lead you into battle when you still have wounds and gashes? If I saw you completely sound in health, I would lead you out to that battle line, and by the grace of Christ you would see tens of thousands lying dead, with their heads piled one upon another. In other books, we have spoken many discourses about these things, but even so we are unable to fully triumph in victory because of the laziness of the crowd. For when we defeat them ten thousand times over in doctrines, they criticize us for the lives of the multitude of those who join our congregations—their wounds, their diseases in their souls.

What do you say? Am I forever speaking of almsgiving? I would wish myself that there were not great need for me to address this advice to you, but that I were to speak of the battle against the Jews, and heathens, and heretics; but when you are not yet sound, how can any one arm you for the fight? How should he lead you to the array, yet having wounds and gashes. Since if indeed I saw you thoroughly sound in health, I should lead you forth to that battle array, and you would see by the grace of Christ ten thousands lying dead, and their heads cast one upon another. In other books at any rate, many discourses have been spoken by us touching these things, but not even so are we able thoroughly to triumph in the victory, because of the remissness of the multitude. For when we conquer them ten thousand times over in doctrines, they reproach us with the lives of the multitude of those who join our congregations, their wounds, their diseases in their soul.

How then can we confidently place you in the battle line when you actually harm us, being immediately wounded by our enemies and made an object of ridicule? For one man's hand is diseased and shriveled so that it cannot give alms. How then can such a person hold a shield and thrust it forward and avoid being wounded by the taunts of cruelty? With others the feet are lame—as many as go to the theaters and to the brothels. How then can these be able to stand in battle and not be wounded by the accusation of licentiousness? Another suffers and is disabled in his eyes, not looking straight ahead but being full of lustfulness, assaulting women's purity, and destroying marriages. How then can this man be able to look the enemy in the face, brandish a spear, and throw his javelin, being mocked on all sides with jeers? We can also see many suffering with their belly no less than those with dropsy, when they are enslaved by gluttony and drunkenness. How then can I lead these drunken men out to war? With others the mouth is diseased—such are the quick-tempered, the abusive, and the blasphemers. How then can this man ever shout in battle and accomplish anything great and noble, when he too is drunk with another kind of drunkenness and provides much laughter to the enemy?

How then shall we with confidence show you in the battle array, when you rather do us mischief, being straightway wounded by our enemies, and made a mock of? For one man's hand is diseased, and shrunk so as not to be able to give away. How then should such a one hold a shield, and thrust it before him, and avoid being wounded by the jeers of cruelty. With others the feet halt, as many as go up to the theatres, and to the resorts of the harlot women. How shall these then be able to stand in the battle, and not to be wounded with the accusation of wantonness? Another suffers and is maimed in his eyes, not looking straight, but being full of lasciviousness, and assailing women's chastity, and overthrowing marriages. How then should this man be able to look in the face of the enemy, and brandish a spear, and throw his dart, being goaded on all sides with jeers. We may see also many suffering with the belly not less than the dropsical, when they are held in subjection by gluttony and drunkenness. How then shall I be able to lead forth these drunken men to war? With others the mouth is rotten; such are the passionate, and revilers, and blasphemers. How then shall this man ever shout in battle, and achieve anything great and noble, he too being drunk with another drunkenness, and affording much laughter to the enemy?

Therefore each day I go about this camp, dressing your wounds and healing your sores. But if you ever rouse yourselves up and become fit even to wound others, I will both teach you this art of war and instruct you how to handle these weapons, or rather your works themselves will be weapons to you, and all people will immediately submit, if you would become merciful, if forbearing, if mild and patient, if you would show forth all other virtue. But if anyone contradicts us, then we will also add the proof of what we can demonstrate on our part, bringing you forward, since now we are rather hindered (at least as far as your part is concerned) in this race.

Therefore each day I go about this camp, dressing your wounds, healing your sores. But if you ever rouse yourselves up, and become fit even to wound others, I will both teach you this art of war, and instruct you how to handle these weapons, or rather your works themselves will be weapons to you, and all men will immediately submit, if you would become merciful, if forbearing, if mild and patient, if you would show forth all other virtue. But if any gainsay, then we will also add the proof of what we can show on our part, bringing you forward, since now we rather are hindered (at least as to your part) in this race.

Notice this: We say that Christ has done great things by making angels out of men. But when we are called to give an account and required to show proof from this congregation, we are left speechless. For I am afraid that instead of producing angels, I bring forth pigs from a pigsty and horses crazed with lust.

And mark. We say that Christ has done great things, having made angels of men; then, when we are called upon to give account, and required to furnish a proof out of this flock, our mouths are stopped. For I am afraid, lest in the place of angels, I bring forth swine as from a style, and horses mad with lust.

I know you are pained, but these things are not spoken against all of you, but against the guilty—or rather, not even against them if they wake up, but for their sake. Since now everything is lost and ruined, and the church has become nothing better than a stable for oxen and a pen for donkeys and camels, and I go around looking for a sheep but am unable to see one. Everyone is kicking like horses or wild donkeys, and they fill this place with much dung, for their speech is like this. And if one could actually see the things spoken at each gathering by men and by women, you would see that their words are more unclean than that dung.

I know you are pained, but not against you all are these things spoken, but against the guilty, or rather not even against them if they awake, but for them. Since now indeed all is lost and ruined, and the church has become nothing better than a stable of oxen, and a fold for asses and camels, and I go round seeking for a sheep, and am not able to see it. So much are all kicking, like horses, and any wild asses, and they fill the place here with much dung, for like this is their discourse. And if indeed one could see the things spoken at each assemblage, by men, by women, you would see their words more unclean than that dung.

Therefore I ask you to change this evil custom, so that the church may have the fragrance of ointment. But now, while we store up in it perfumes for the senses, we use no great effort to purge out and drive away the uncleanness of the mind. What then is the benefit? For we do not disgrace the church so much by bringing dung into it, as we disgrace it by speaking such things to one another—about profits, about business, about petty trading, about things that are none of our concern—when there ought to be choirs of angels here, and we ought to make the church a heaven, and to know nothing else but earnest prayers, and silence with listening.

Therefore I entreat you to change this evil custom, that the church may smell of ointment. But now, while we lay up in it perfumes for the senses, the uncleanness of the mind we use no great diligence to purge out, and drive away. What then is the advantage? For we do not so much disgrace the church by bringing dung into it, as we disgrace it by speaking such things one to another, about gains, about merchandise, about petty tradings, about things that are nothing to us, when there ought to be choirs of angels here, and we ought to make the church a heaven, and to know nothing else but earnest prayers, and silence with listening.

So let us do this from now on, so that we may both purify our lives and attain the promised blessings, through the grace and love toward mankind of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory forever and ever. Amen.

This then let us do at any rate, from the present time, that we may both purify our lives, and attain unto the promised blessings, by the grace and love towards man of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of Matthew — Homily 87

One of Chrysostom’s 90 homilies on the Gospel of Matthew, preached at Antioch.

Source: Translated by George Prevost and revised by M.B. Riddle. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 10. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1888. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/200187.htm>.

Opening

Matthew 27:27-29.

Matt. XXVII. 27-29.

The soldiers of the governor then took Jesus into the common hall and assembled the entire band of soldiers around him. They stripped him and dressed him in a purple robe. After weaving a crown of thorns, they placed it on his head and put a reed in his right hand. They knelt before him and mocked him, saying, "Hail, king of the Jews."

Then the soldiers of the governor took Jesus into the common hall, and gathered unto him the whole band of soldiers; and they stripped Him, and put on Him a purple robe; and when they had platted a crown of thorns, they put it on His head, and a reed in His right hand; and they bowed the knee before Him, and mocked Him, saying, Hail, king of the Jews.

As if responding to some signal, the devil then entered in triumph into everyone. For while the Jews were consumed with envy and jealousy and mad against Him, what about the soldiers—where did this come from, and what kind of cause did they have? Is it not clear that it was the devil who was then entering in fury into the hearts of all? They actually took pleasure in insulting Him, being a savage and ruthless bunch. I mean, when they should have been awestruck, when they should have wept—which even the people did—they did not do this. Instead, they were spiteful and insolent, perhaps trying to please the Jews themselves, or perhaps acting entirely according to their own evil nature.

As though on some signal the devil then was entering in triumph into all. For, be it that Jews pining with envy and jealousy were mad against Him, as to the soldiers, whence was it, and from what sort of cause? Is it not clear that it was the devil who was then entering in fury into the hearts of all? For indeed they made a pleasure of their insults against Him, being a savage and ruthless set. I mean that, when they ought to have been awestruck, when they ought to have wept, which even the people did, this they did not, but, on the contrary, were despiteful, and insolent; perhaps themselves also seeking to please the Jews, or it may be doing all in conformity to their own evil nature.

The insults were varied and different. Sometimes they struck that divine Head, sometimes they mocked it with the crown of thorns, sometimes they beat it with the reed—unholy and accursed men!

And the insults were different, and varied. For that Divine Head at one time they buffeted, at another they insulted with the crown of thorns, at another they smote with the reed, men unholy and accursed!

What excuse will we have after this for being upset by injuries, when Christ suffered these things? For what was done was the ultimate expression of insolence. Not just one part, but the whole entire body was subjected to insult: the head through the crown, the reed, and the beating; the face by being spit upon; the cheeks by being struck with the palms of hands; the whole body by the whipping, by being wrapped in the robe, and by the mock worship; the hand by the reed they gave him to hold instead of a scepter; the mouth again by the offering of vinegar. What could be more painful than these things? What more insulting?

What plea shall we have after this for being moved by injuries, after Christ suffered these things? For what was done was the utmost limit of insolence. For not one member, but the whole entire body throughout was made an object of insolence; the head through the crown, and the reed, and the buffeting; the face, being spit upon; the cheeks, being smitten with the palms of the hands; the whole body by the stripes, by being wrapped in the robe, and by the pretended worship; the hand by the reed, which they gave him to hold instead of a sceptre; the mouth again by the offering of the vinegar. What could be more grievous than these things? What more insulting?

What happened goes beyond all words. It was as if they were afraid they might somehow fall short in their crime. They had killed the prophets with their own hands, but killed this man through a judge's sentence, so they acted the same way in every deed. They made it the work of their own hands, condemning and sentencing him both among themselves and before Pilate, saying, "His blood be on us and on our children" (Matthew 27:25). They insulted him and mistreated him themselves, binding him, leading him away, and made themselves responsible for the cruel acts done by the soldiers. They nailed him to the cross, mocked him, spat at him, and ridiculed him. Pilate contributed nothing to this—they themselves did everything, becoming accusers, judges, executioners, and all.

For the things that were done go beyond all language. For as though they were afraid lest they should seem to fall short at all in the crime, having killed the prophets with their own hands, but this man with the sentence of a judge, so they do in every deed; and make it the work of their own hands, and condemn and sentence both among themselves and before Pilate, saying, His blood be on us and on our children, Matthew 27:25 and insult Him, and do despite unto Him themselves, binding Him, leading Him away, and render themselves authors of the spiteful acts done by the soldiers, and nail Him to the cross, and revile Him, and spit at Him, and deride Him. For Pilate contributed nothing in this matter, but they themselves did every thing, becoming accusers, and judges, and executioners, and all.

And these things are read among us when we all gather together. The grace of the Spirit has brought it about that these events are read at the full festival, when crowds of men and women are present—indeed, practically everyone—on the great eve of the Passover, when the whole world is present, and all these acts are proclaimed with a clear voice. This prevents the pagans from claiming that we display to peoples and nations only the glorious and illustrious things, such as the signs and miracles, while hiding the things that are matters of reproach. When these passages are read and made known to all, Christ is believed to be God and, besides everything else, is worshipped even because of this: that He graciously stooped so low for us as actually to suffer these things and to teach us all virtue.

And these things are read among us, when all meet together. For that the heathens may not say, that you display to people and nations the things that are glorious and illustrious, such as the signs and the miracles, but that you hide these which are matters of reproach; the grace of the Spirit has brought it to pass, that in the full festival, when men in multitude and women are present, and all, as one may say, at the great eve of the passover, then all these things should be read; when the whole world is present, then are all these acts proclaimed with a clear voice. And these being read, and made known to all, Christ is believed to be God and, besides all the rest, is worshipped, even because of this, that He vouchsafed to stoop so much for us as actually to suffer these things, and to teach us all virtue.

We should read these things continually, for the gain is indeed great, and the advantage to be obtained from them is great. When you see him both mocked through gestures and deeds, worshipped with so much derision, beaten and suffering the utmost insults, even if you are made of stone, you will become softer than any wax and will cast out of your soul all haughtiness.

These things then let us read continually; for indeed great is the gain, great the advantage to be thence obtained. For when you see Him, both by gestures and by deeds, mocked and worshipped with so much derision, and beaten and suffering the utmost insults, though thou be very stone, you will become softer than any wax, and will cast out of your soul all haughtiness.

Listen, then, to what comes next. After they had mocked Him, they led Him away to crucify Him, it is said. When they had stripped Him, they took His garments and sat down and watched Him, waiting for Him to die. They divided His garments among themselves, which is the sort of thing done in the case of very vile and despised criminals who have no one belonging to them and are in utter desolation.

Hear therefore also what follows. For after they had mocked Him, they led Him to crucify Him, it is said, and when they had stripped Him, they took His garments, and sat down and watched Him, when He should die. And they divide His garments among them, which sort of thing is done in the case of very vile and abject criminals, and such as have no one belonging to them, and are in utter desolation.

They divided the garments through which such great miracles had been done. But the garments worked no miracles now, since Christ was restraining His unspeakable power. And this was no small addition to the insult. For they dared to do all these things to Him as though He were base and abject—as I said—and the vilest of all men. They did nothing of this sort to the thieves, but to Christ they dared to do it all. And they crucified Him in the middle of them so that He might share in their reputation.

They parted the garments, by which such great miracles were done. But they wrought none now, Christ restraining His unspeakable power. And this was no small addition of insult. For as to one base and abject, as I said, and the vilest of all men; so do they dare to do all things. To the thieves at any rate they did nothing of the kind, but to Christ they dare it all. And they crucified Him in the midst of them, that He might share in their reputation.

They gave Him gall to drink, and this was to insult Him, but He would not drink it. However, another evangelist says that after tasting it, He said, "It is finished." And what does "It is finished" mean? The prophecy concerning Him was fulfilled. For it is said, "They gave me gall for my food, and for my thirst they gave me vinegar to drink." But even that evangelist does not indicate that He actually drank it, for merely tasting something is not different from not drinking—the two have one and the same meaning.

And they gave Him gall to drink, and this to insult Him, but He would not. But another says, that having tasted it, He said, It is finished. John 19:30 And what means, It is finished? The prophecy was fulfilled concerning Him. For they gave me, it is said, gall for my meat, and for my thirst they gave me vinegar to drink. But neither does that evangelist indicate that He drank, for merely to taste differs not from not drinking, but has one and the same signification.

But nevertheless their contempt does not stop even here. After they have stripped and crucified Him, and offered Him vinegar, they go still further. As they watch Him hanging on the cross, they revile Him—both they themselves and those passing by. This was more painful than everything else: that He suffered these things under the charge of being an impostor and deceiver, and as a boaster vainly pretending what He said. Therefore they crucified Him publicly, so they might make a spectacle of it in the sight of all. And therefore they did it by the hands of soldiers, so that these things being carried out even by a public tribunal, the insult might be the greater.

But nevertheless not even here does their contumely stop, but after having stripped and crucified Him, and offered Him vinegar, they proceeded still further, and beholding Him impaled upon the cross, they revile Him, both they themselves and the passers by; and this was more grievous than all, that on the charge of being an impostor and deceiver He suffered these things, and as a boaster, and vainly pretending what He said. Therefore they both crucified Him publicly, that they might make a show of it in the sight of all; and therefore also they did it by the hands of the soldiers, that these things being perpetrated even by a public tribunal, the insult might be the greater.

Yet who would not have been moved by the crowd that was following Him and mourning Him? Not these savage people. That is why He grants an answer to the crowd, but not to these men. For after doing what they wanted, they also try to damage His honor, fearing His resurrection. Therefore they say these things publicly, and they crucified thieves with Him, and wanting to prove Him a deceiver, they say, "You who destroy the temple and rebuild it in three days, come down from the cross." For since when they told Pilate to remove the accusation (this was the inscription, "The King of the Jews"), they did not prevail, but he continued saying, "What I have written, I have written," they then try through mocking Him to show that He is not a king.

2. And yet who would not have been moved by the multitude that was following Him, and lamenting Him? Nay, not these wild beasts. Wherefore also He to the multitude vouchsafes an answer, but to these men not so. For after having done what they would, they endeavor also to injure His honor, fearing His resurrection. Therefore they say these things publicly, and crucified thieves with Him, and wishing to prove Him a deceiver, they say, Thou that destroyest the temple, and buildest it in three days come down from the cross. Matthew 27:40 For since on telling Pilate to remove the accusation (this was the writing, The king of the Jews), they prevailed not, but he persevered in saying, What I have written, I have written, John 19:22 they then endeavor by their derision of Him to show that He is not a king.

That's why they said those things and also these: "If he is the king of Israel, let him come down now from the cross. He saved others, but he cannot save himself" (Matthew 27:42), intending by this to discredit even his former miracles. And again, "If he is Son of God, and he will have him, let him save him."

Wherefore they said those things, and also these. If He is the king of Israel, let Him come down now from the cross. He saved others, Himself He cannot save, Matthew 27:42 aiming hereby to bring discredit even on His former miracles. And again, If He be Son of God, and He will have Him, let Him save Him.

How vile, how utterly vile! What then—were the prophets not prophets, and the righteous men not righteous, simply because God did not rescue them from their dangers? Indeed they were, even though they suffered these things. What then could match your foolishness? For if the coming of dangers upon them did not damage their honor in your eyes, how much more, in the case of this man, was it wrong for you to take offense, when both by what He did and by what He said, He was constantly correcting this mistaken notion of yours beforehand?

O execrable; most execrable! What, were not the prophets prophets, nor the righteous men righteous, because God rescued them not out of their dangers. Nay surely they were, though suffering these things. What then could be equal to your folly? For if the coming of the dangers upon them did not injure their honor with you, how much more in the case of this man, was it wrong for you to be offended, when both by what He did, by what He said, He was ever correcting beforehand this suspicion of yours.

Yet in spite of all this, even when these things were said and done, they accomplished nothing, not even at that very moment. In fact, the thief who was corrupt in such great wickedness and who had spent his entire life in murders and robberies—when these things were being said, he then confessed Him and spoke of a kingdom, and the people mourned for Him. And yet the things that happened seemed to testify to the opposite in the eyes of those who did not understand the mysterious dispensations, that He was weak and powerless. Nevertheless, truth prevailed even through these contrary circumstances.

Yet nevertheless, even when these things were said and done, they prevailed nothing, not even at the very time. At any rate, he, who was depraved in such great wickedness, and who had spent his whole life in murders and house-breakings, when these things were being said, then confessed Him, and made mention of a kingdom, and the people bewailed Him. And yet the things that were done seemed to testify the contrary in the eyes of those who knew not the mysterious dispensations, that He was weak and of no power, nevertheless truth prevailed even by the contrary things.

Hearing these things, then, let us arm ourselves against all rage and all anger. If you feel your heart swelling with anger, make the sign of the cross over your chest. Call to mind one of the things that happened then, and you will cast out all rage like dust through remembering what was done. Consider the words and the actions. Consider that He is Lord and you are a servant. He is suffering for you, you for yourself. He is suffering on behalf of those who had received benefits from Him and then crucified Him, you on behalf of yourself. He is suffering on behalf of those who had mistreated Him, you often at the hands of those you have wronged. He is suffering in the sight of the whole city—or rather, the whole nation of the Jews, both foreigners and those from the country—before whom He spoke those merciful words, but you in the presence of few. And what was more insulting to Him is that even His disciples abandoned Him. For those who had previously paid attention to Him had deserted Him, but His enemies and foes, having gotten Him in their midst on the cross, insulted, reviled, mocked, derided, and scoffed at Him—Jews and soldiers from below, thieves on either side from above. Indeed, both thieves insulted and reproached Him. How then does Luke say that one rebuked the other? Both things happened, for at first both reproached Him, but afterward one no longer did so. So that you would not think this had been done by any prior arrangement, or that the thief was not really a thief, by his insolence the text shows you that even upon the cross he was a thief and an enemy, and yet was instantly changed.

Hearing then these things, let us arm ourselves against all rage, against all anger. Should thou perceive your heart swelling, seal your breast setting upon it the cross. Call to mind some one of the things that then took place, and you will cast out as dust all rage by the recollection of the things that were done. Consider the words, the actions; consider that He is Lord, and thou servant. He is suffering for you, thou for yourself; He in behalf of them who had been benefited by Him and had crucified Him, thou in behalf of yourself; He in behalf of them who had used Him despitefully, thou oftentimes at the hands of them who have been injured. He in the sight of the whole city, or rather of the whole people of the Jews, both strangers, and those of the country, before whom He spoke those merciful words, but thou in the presence of few; and what was more insulting to Him, that even His disciples forsook Him. For those, who before paid Him attention, had deserted Him, but His enemies and foes, having got Him in the midst of themselves on the cross, insulted, reviled, mocked, derided, scoffed at Him, Jews and soldiers from below, from above thieves on either side: for indeed the thieves insulted, and upbraided Him both of them. How then says Luke that one rebuked? Luke 23:40 Both things were done, for at first both upbraided Him, but afterwards one did so no more. For that you might not think the thing had been done by any agreement, or that the thief was not a thief, by his insolence he shows you, that up on the cross he was a thief and an enemy, and at once was changed.

Thinking about all these things, then, exercise self-control. For what do you suffer that compares to what your Lord suffered? Were you publicly humiliated? But not like these things. Are you mocked? Yet not your whole body, not while being scourged and stripped like this. And even if you were struck in the face, it was not like this.

Considering then all these things, control yourself. For what do you suffer like what your Lord suffered? Were you publicly insulted? But not like these things. Are you mocked? Yet not your whole body, not being thus scourged, and stripped. And even if you were buffeted, yet not like this.

And on top of that, please consider: by whom these things were done, and for what reason, and when, and who He was. And the most painful thing is that even though these things were happening, no one objected, no one condemned what was being done. Instead, everyone actually approved and joined in mocking Him and jeering at Him. They insulted Him as a boaster, an impostor, and a deceiver who couldn't demonstrate through His actions the things He claimed. But He remained silent through it all, providing us with the most powerful examples of patient endurance.

3. And add to this, I pray you, by whom, and wherefore, and when, and who it was; and (the most grievous matter) that these things being done, no one found fault, no one blamed what was done, but on the contrary all rather approved, and joined in mocking Him and in jeering at Him; and as a boaster, impostor, and deceiver, and not able to prove in His works the things that He said, so did they revile Him. But He held His peace to all, preparing for us the most powerful incentives to long suffering.

But we, though we hear such things, are not patient even with servants. Instead we rush about and kick worse than wild donkeys when we are personally injured, being savage and inhuman. Yet we don't care much about injuries against God. We have the same attitude toward our friends too: if someone bothers us, we can't bear it; if someone insults us, we become more savage than wild beasts—we who read these things every day. A disciple betrayed Him, the rest abandoned Him and fled, those who had received benefits from Him spat at Him, the high priest's servants struck Him with their palms, the soldiers beat Him, those passing by mocked Him and insulted Him, the thieves accused Him. And to no one did He say a word, but overcame all through silence, teaching you through His actions that the more meekly you endure, the more you will prevail over those who do you evil, and you will be admired by everyone. For who will not admire someone who patiently endures the insults he receives from those who mistreat him? Even if someone suffers justly, if he endures the evil meekly, most people will consider him to suffer unjustly. Likewise, even if someone suffers unjustly, if he is violent, he will be suspected of suffering justly and will become an object of ridicule, being dragged captive by his anger and losing his own nobility. For such a person must not be called even a free man, even if he is master over ten thousand servants.

But we, though hearing such things, are not patient so much as to servants, but we rush and kick worse than wild asses, with respect to injuries against ourselves, being savage and inhuman; but of those against God not making much account. And with respect to friends too we have the same disposition; should any one vex us, we bear it not; should he insult us, we are savage more than wild beasts, we who are reading these things every day. A disciple betrayed Him, the rest forsook Him and fled, they that had been benefited by Him spat at Him, the servants of the high priest smote Him with the palm of the hand, the soldiers buffeted Him; they that passed by jeered Him and reviled Him, the thieves accused Him; and to no man did He utter a word, but by silence overcame all; instructing you by His actions, that the more meekly you shall endure, the more will you prevail over them that do you evil, and will be an object of admiration before all. For who will not admire him that endures with forbearance the insults he receives from them that are using him despitefully? For even as, though any man suffer justly, yet enduring the evil meekly, he is considered by the more part to suffer unjustly; so though one suffer unjustly, yet if he be violent, he will get the suspicion of suffering justly, and will be an object of ridicule, as being dragged captive by his anger, and losing his own nobility. For such a one, we must not call so much as a freeman, though he be lord over ten thousand servants.

But did someone really provoke you? What difference does that make? Self-control should be shown precisely at such times, since we see that even wild animals are gentle when no one is bothering them—they are not always savage, but only when someone stirs them up. So if we are only calm when no one is provoking us, what advantage do we have over them? For wild animals often have just cause for their anger and much excuse, since they are roused by being stirred and goaded. Besides, they lack reason and have savageness in their nature.

But did some person exceedingly provoke you? And what of that? For then should self-control be shown, since when there is no one to vex, we see even the wild beasts gentle; for neither are they always savage, but when any one rouses them. And we therefore, if we are only then quiet, when there is no one provoking us, what advantage have we over them. For they are both oftentimes justly indignant, and have much excuse, for by being stirred and goaded are they roused, and besides these things they are devoid of reason, and have savageness in their nature.

But where, I ask you, can you find a reason for being savage and fierce? What hardship have you endured? Have you been robbed? For this very reason you should endure it, so as to gain more abundantly. But were you deprived of reputation? And what of that? Your condition is in no way made worse by this, if you practice self-control. But if you have suffered no wrong, why are you angry with someone who has done you no harm, but has even benefited you? For those who honor us make those who are not watchful all the more vain; but those who insult and despise us make those who pay attention to themselves more steadfast. For the careless are more injured by being honored than by being insulted. And the one group of people, if we are sober, become for us sources of self-control, but the others stir up our pride, they fill us with boastfulness, vainglory, folly, they make our soul the weaker.

But whence, I pray you, can you find a plea for being savage and fierce? What hardship have you suffered? Have you been robbed? For this self-same reason should you endure it, so as to gain more amply. But were you deprived of character? And what is this? Your condition is in no way worsened by this, if you practise self-command. But if you suffer no grievance, whence are you angry with him that has done you no harm, but has even benefited you? For they who honor, make them that are not watchful the more vain; but they who insult and despise render those that take heed to themselves more steadfast. For the careless are more injured by being honored than by being insulted. And the one set of persons, if we be sober, become to us authors of self-control, but the others excite our pride, they fill us with boastfulness, vainglory, folly, they make our soul the feebler.

Fathers demonstrate this truth—they don't flatter their own children as much as they correct them, fearing that praise might harm them. Teachers use the same approach with their students. So if we're going to avoid anyone, it should be those who flatter us rather than those who insult us. Flattery brings greater harm than insult to those who don't pay attention, and this feeling is harder to control than anger at insults. The reward is also far greater from enduring insults, and the admiration is greater too. Indeed, it's more worthy of admiration to see someone insulted and remain unmoved than to see someone beaten and struck without falling.

And to this fathers bear witness, who do not flatter their own children so much as they chide them, fearing lest from the praise they should receive any harm, and their teachers use the same remedy to them. So that if we are to avoid any one, it should be those that flatter us rather than those that insult us; for this bait brings greater mischief than insult to them, who do not take heed, and it is more difficult to control this feeling than that. And the reward too is far more abundant from thence, and the admiration greater. For indeed it is more worthy of admiration to see a man insulted, and not moved, than beaten and smitten, and not falling.

And how is it possible not to be moved? someone may ask. Has anyone insulted you? Place the sign upon your breast, call to mind all the things that were done then, and all is quenched. Do not consider only the insults, but also whether any good has ever been done to you by the one who has insulted you, and immediately you will become meek. Or rather, consider before all things the fear of God, and soon you will be mild and gentle.

And how is it possible not to be moved? One may say. Hath any one insulted you? Place the sign upon your breast, call to mind all the things that were then done; and all is quenched. Consider not the insults only, but if also any good has been ever done unto you, by him that has insulted you, and straightway you will become meek, or rather consider before all things the fear of God, and soon you will be mild and gentle.

Take lessons about these matters from your own servants as well. When you see yourself insulting someone but your servant remaining silent, recognize that it is possible to practice self-control, and condemn yourself for being violent. In the very moment you are offering insults, learn not to insult, and then you will not be upset even when you yourself are insulted. Remember that the person who is insolent is out of his mind and mad, and you will not feel indignant when insulted, just as when demon-possessed people strike us, we are not provoked but rather pity them. Do the same thing: pity the person who is insolent to you, for he is held captive by a terrible monster—rage—by a grievous demon—anger. Free him, since he is under the power of a grievous demon and is quickly heading toward ruin. This disease is so severe that it does not even need time to destroy the one who is seized by it. This is why someone said, "The sway of his fury shall be his fall" (Sirach 1:22), showing above all its tyranny by the fact that in a short time it works great evils and does not need to remain with us long. If, in addition to its strength, it were also likely to last, it would indeed be hard to resist.

4. Together with these things even from your own servants take a lesson concerning these matters; and when you see yourself insulting, but your servant holding his peace, consider that it is possible to practise self-control, and condemn yourself for being violent; and in the very time of offering insults learn not to insult; and thus not even when insulted, will you be vexed. Consider that he who is insolent is beside himself and mad, and you will not feel indignant, when insulted, since the possessed strike us, and we, so far from being provoked, do rather pity them. This do thou also; pity him that is insolent to you, for he is held in subjection by a dreadful monster, rage, by a grievous demon, anger. Set him free as he is wrought upon by a grievous demon, and going quickly to ruin. For so great is this disease as not to need even time for the destruction of him that is seized with it. Wherefore also one said, The sway of his fury shall be his fall; Sirach 1:22 by this most of all showing its tyranny, that in a short time it works great ills, and needs not to continue long with us, so that if in addition to its strength it were apt to last, it would indeed be hard to strive against.

I want to show you what kind of person someone is when they insult others, and what kind of person practices self-control. I want to lay bare before you the soul of each one. You will see that one is like a sea tossed by a storm, while the other is like a harbor free from disturbance. The harbor is not disturbed by these evil blasts but easily calms them. Those who insult others do everything they can to make it sting. When they fail in that aim, even they become peaceful and go away corrected. It is impossible for an angry person not to condemn himself completely, just as it is impossible for someone who is not angry to condemn himself. Even if it is necessary to retaliate, it is possible to do this without anger—and it would be easier and wiser than doing it with anger—and to feel no pain. If we are willing, good things will come from ourselves, and with the grace of God we will be sufficient for our own safety and honor.

I should like to show what the man is who insults, what he that practises self-control, and to bring nakedly before you the soul of the one and the other. For you should see the one like a sea tost with a tempest, but the other like a harbor free from disturbance. For it is not disturbed by these evil blasts, but puts them to rest easily. For indeed they who are insulting, do everything in order to make it sting. When then they fail of that hope, even they are thenceforth at peace, and go away amended. For it is impossible that a man, who is angry, should not utterly condemn himself, even as on the other hand it is impossible for one who is not angry to be self-condemned. For though it be necessary to retaliate, it is possible to do this without anger (and it were more easy and more wise than with anger) and to have no painful feeling. For if we be willing, the good things will be from ourselves, and we shall be with the grace of God sufficient for our own safety and honor.

Why do you seek honor from another person? Honor yourself, and no one will be able to insult you. But if you dishonor yourself, even though everyone else honors you, you will not be honored. For just as no one else can put us in a bad condition unless we first put ourselves in that condition, so too no one else can shame us unless we first insult ourselves.

For why do you seek the glory that comes from another? Do thou honor yourself, and no one will be able to insult you; but if you dishonor yourself, though all should honor you, you will not be honored. For like as, unless we put ourselves in an evil state, no one else puts us in such a state; even so unless we insult ourselves, no one else can put us to shame.

Let someone be great and worthy of admiration, and let everyone call him an adulterer, a thief, a tomb robber, a murderer, and a criminal. If he is neither upset nor angry, and is not conscious in himself of any of these crimes, what disgrace does he suffer? None. What if many people hold such an opinion of him? Even then he is not disgraced. Rather, they bring shame upon themselves by judging someone to be what he is not. Tell me, if someone thinks the sun is dark, does he bring a bad reputation on that heavenly body, or on himself? Surely on himself, earning for himself the reputation of being blind or insane. In the same way, those who consider wicked people good, and those who make the opposite mistake, disgrace themselves.

For let any man be great and worthy of admiration, and let all men call him an adulterer, a thief, a violater of tombs, a murderer, a robber, and let him be neither provoked or indignant, nor be conscious to himself of any of these crimes, what disgrace will he thence undergo? None. What then, you may say, if many have such an opinion of him? Not even so is he disgraced, but they bring shame upon themselves, by accounting one, who is not such, to be such. For tell me, if any one think the sun to be dark, does he bring an ill name on that heavenly body, or on himself? Surely on himself, getting himself the character of being blind or mad. So also they that account wicked men good, and they that make the opposite error, disgrace themselves.

Therefore we should take great care to keep our conscience clear and to give no opportunity for anyone to accuse us or to suspect us of evil. But if others choose to act foolishly even when we conduct ourselves this way, we should not worry too much or be grieved by it. For a person who has the reputation of being wicked but is actually good suffers no harm in terms of what he truly is. But the person who has suspected another person wrongly and without cause receives the greatest harm. On the other hand, a wicked person who is thought to be good will gain nothing from this, but will face a heavier judgment and be led into greater carelessness. For when someone is wicked and is suspected of it, he may perhaps be humbled and acknowledge his sins. But when he escapes detection, he becomes hardened and insensible. For if offenders are hardly stirred to repentance even when everyone accuses them, when will those living in vice be able to open their eyes if no one accuses them—or worse, if some even praise them? Do you hear that Paul also blames the Corinthians for this very thing—that far from allowing the man guilty of fornication to acknowledge his own sin, they instead applauded and honored him, and by doing so urged him on in vice? Therefore, I beg you, let us ignore the suspicions of the crowd, their insults and their honors, and let us be diligent about this one thing only: that we be conscious of no evil in ourselves and that we do not dishonor ourselves. For in this way, both here and in the world to come, we shall enjoy great glory, which may God grant we all attain, by the grace and love toward mankind of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory world without end. Amen.

Wherefore we ought to give the greater diligence, to keep our conscience clear, and to give no handle against ourselves, nor matter for evil suspicion; but if others will be mad, even when this is our disposition, not to care very much, nor to grieve. For he that has got the character of a wicked man, being a good man, is in no degree thereby hurt as regards his being such as he is; but he that has been suspecting another vainly and causelessly, receives the utmost harm; as, on the other hand, the wicked man, if he be supposed to be the contrary, will gain nothing thence, but will both have a heavier judgment, and be led into greater carelessness. For he that is such and is suspected thereof, may perhaps be humbled, and acknowledge his sins; but when he escapes detection, he falls into a state past feeling. For if, while all are accusing them, offenders are hardly stirred up to compunction, when so far from accusing them, some even praise them, at what time will they who are living in vice be able to open their eyes? Do you hear that Paul also blames for this, that the Corinthians (so far from permitting him that had been guilty of fornication, to acknowledge his own sin), applauding and honoring him, did on the contrary urge him on in vice thereby? Wherefore, I pray, let us leave the suspicions of the multitude, their insults and their honors, and let us be diligent about one thing only, that we be conscious to ourselves of no evil thing, nor insult our own selves. For so both here, and in the world to come, we shall enjoy much glory, unto which God grant we all may attain, by the grace and love towards man of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of Matthew — Homily 86

One of Chrysostom’s 90 homilies on the Gospel of Matthew, preached at Antioch.

Source: Translated by George Prevost and revised by M.B. Riddle. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 10. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1888. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/200186.htm>.

Opening

I notice you've provided a biblical reference (Matthew 27:11-12) rather than a paragraph of text to rewrite.

Could you please provide the actual paragraph text that you'd like me to rewrite in clear, modern English? Once you share the paragraph, I'll be happy to simplify it while preserving all theological precision and technical Greek terms as you've specified.

Matthew 27:11-12.

And Jesus stood before the governor. The governor asked Him, "Are you the king of the Jews?" Jesus said to him, "You say so." And when the chief priests and elders accused Him, He answered nothing.

And Jesus stood before the governor; and the governor asked Him, saying, Are you the king of the Jews? And Jesus said to him, You say. And when He was accused of the chief priests and elders, He answered nothing.

Do you see what He is first asked? It's the very thing they kept bringing up constantly in every possible way. Since they saw that Pilate had no interest in matters of the law, they shifted their accusation to political charges. They did the same thing with the apostles, always bringing forward these accusations and saying that they were going around proclaiming a certain Jesus as king, Acts 17:7 speaking of him as if he were merely a man, and casting suspicion on them as rebels seeking to seize power.

Do you see what He is first asked? Which thing most of all they were continually bringing forward in every way? For since they saw Pilate making no account of the matters of the law, they direct their accusation to the state charges. So likewise did they in the case of the apostles, ever bringing forward these things, and saying that they were going about proclaiming king one Jesus, Acts 17:7 speaking as of a mere man, and investing them with a suspicion of usurpation.

This makes it clear that both the tearing of the garment and the show of shock were nothing but pretense. They fabricated everything and pressed forward with it all for the sole purpose of bringing Him to death.

Whence it is manifest, that both the rending the garment and the amazement were a pretense. But all things they got up, and plied, in order to bring Him to death.

This, at any rate, is what Pilate asked then. What did Christ say in response? You say so. He acknowledged that He was a king, but a heavenly king. This He also stated more clearly elsewhere when He replied to Pilate, My kingdom is not of this world, so that neither the Jewish leaders nor Pilate would have any excuse for accusing Him of such things. He provides a reason that cannot be contradicted, saying, If I were of this world, my servants would fight so that I should not be handed over. For this very purpose—to refute this suspicion—He both paid the tribute tax and commanded others to pay it, and when they wanted to make Him a king, He fled.

This at any rate Pilate then asked. What then said Christ? You say. He confessed that He was a king, but a heavenly king, which elsewhere also He spoke more clearly, replying to Pilate, My kingdom is not of this world; John 18:36 that neither they nor this man should have an excuse for accusing Him of such things. And He gives a reason that cannot be gainsaid, saying, If I were of this world, my servants would fight, that I should not be delivered. For this purpose I say, in order to refute this suspicion, He both paid tribute, Matthew 22:17 and commanded others to pay it, and when they would make Him a king, He fled. John 6:15

Why then, it may be asked, did he not bring these things forward at that time when he was accused of trying to seize power? Because although they had countless proofs from his actions—of his power, his meekness, his gentleness—they were deliberately blind and acted unfairly, and the court was corrupt. For these reasons he responds to nothing and remains silent, though he does answer briefly (so as not to appear arrogant through constant silence) when the high priest placed him under oath and when the governor questioned him. But he no longer says anything in response to their accusations, for he was not going to persuade them at that point. This is exactly what the prophet declared long ago when he said, "In his humiliation his judgment was taken away."

Wherefore then did he not bring forward these things, it may be said, at that time, when accused of usurpation? Because having the proofs from His acts, of His power, His meekness, His gentleness, beyond number, they were willfully blind, and dealt unfairly, and the tribunal was corrupt. For these reasons then He replies to nothing, but holds His peace, yet answering briefly (so as not to get the reputation of arrogance from continual silence) when the high priest adjured Him, when the governor asked, but in reply to their accusations He no longer says anything; for He was not now likely to persuade them. Even as the prophet declaring this self-same thing from of old, said, In His humiliation His judgment was taken away.

At these things the governor marveled, and indeed it was worthy of admiration to see Him showing such great patience and remaining silent, even though He had countless things to say. For they did not accuse Him because they knew of any evil thing in Him, but only from jealousy and envy. Consider this: when they had set up false witnesses, why, having nothing to say, did they still press their case? And when they saw that Judas was dead and that Pilate had washed his hands of it, why were they not struck with remorse? For indeed He did many things even at that very time so that they might recover themselves, but by none of these were they corrected.

At these things the governor marvelled, and indeed it was worthy of admiration to see Him showing such great forbearance, and holding His peace, Him that had countless things to say. For neither did they accuse Him from knowing of any evil thing in Him, but from jealousy and envy only. At least when they had set false witness, wherefore, having nothing to say, did they still urge their point? And when they saw Judas was dead, and that Pilate had washed his hands of it, why were they not pricked with remorse. For indeed He did many things even at the very time, that they might recover themselves, but by none were they amended.

What does Pilate say then? Don't you hear how many things these people are testifying against you? He wanted Him to defend Himself and be acquitted, which is why he said these things. But since He answered nothing, Pilate devises another plan again.

What then says Pilate? Do you not hear how many things these witness against you? He wished that He should defend Himself and be acquitted, wherefore also he said these things; but since He answered nothing, he devises another thing again.

What kind of thing was this? It was their custom to release one of the condemned prisoners, and through this approach he tried to set Him free. For if you are not willing to release Him as innocent, at least pardon Him as guilty for the sake of the feast.

Of what nature was this? It was a custom for them to release one of the condemned, and by this means he attempted to deliver Him. For if you are not willing to release Him as innocent, yet as guilty pardon Him for the feast's sake.

Do you see how things were turned upside down? Normally it was the people who would petition on behalf of the condemned, and the rulers who would grant the request. But now the opposite has happened, and the ruler is petitioning the people. Yet even this does not soften them. Instead they become more savage and bloodthirsty, driven into a frenzy by the passion of envy. For they had nothing of which to accuse Him, even though He was silent. But they were refuted even then because of the abundance of His righteous deeds, and being silent He overcame those who spoke ten thousand things and were driven mad.

Do you see order reversed? For the petition in behalf of the condemned it was customary to be with the people, and the granting it with the rulers; but now the contrary has come to pass, and the ruler petitions the people; and not even so do they become gentle, but grow more savage and bloodthirsty, driven to frenzy by the passion of envy. For neither had they whereof they should accuse Him, and this though He was silent, but they were refuted even then by reason of the abundance of His righteous deeds, and being silent He overcame them that say ten thousand things, and are maddened.

See what happens here—something significant enough to bring them all back to their senses. For along with the evidence from the actual events, the dream was no small matter. But why doesn't Pilate himself see it? Either because she was more worthy, or because if he had seen it, people wouldn't have believed him as readily, or he might not even have mentioned it at all. That's why it was arranged for his wife to see it, so that it would be clear to everyone. And she doesn't just see it—she actually suffers many things because of it, so that through his concern for his wife, the man might become more reluctant to participate in the murder. The timing also played an important role, since she saw it that very night.

And when he was set down on the judgment seat, his wife sent unto him, saying, have thou nothing to do with this just man, for I have suffered many things this day in a dream because of Him. See what a thing takes place again, sufficient to recall them all. For together with the proof from the things done, the dream too was no small thing. And wherefore does he not see it himself? Either because she was more worthy, or because he, if he had seen it, would not have been equally believed; or would not so much as have told it. Therefore it was ordered that the wife should see it, so that it might be manifest to all. And she does not merely see it, but also suffers many things, that from his feeling towards his wife, the man may be made more reluctant to the murder. And the time too contributed not a little, for on the very night she saw it.

But it might be said that it was not safe for him to let Him go, because they said He made Himself a king. He ought then to have looked for proofs and a conviction, and for all the things that are unmistakable signs of an attempt to seize power, such as whether He raised forces, whether He collected money, whether He manufactured weapons, whether He attempted anything else of that kind. But he is swayed without reason, and therefore Christ does not clear him of blame when He says, "He that betrays me to you has greater sin." So it was from weakness that he gave in and scourged Him and handed Him over.

But it was not safe, it may be said, for him to let Him go, because they said He made Himself a king. He ought then to have sought for proofs, and a conviction, and for all the things that are infallible signs of an usurpation, as, for instance, whether He levied forces, whether He collected money, whether He forged arms, whether He attempted any other such thing. But he is led away at random, therefore neither does Christ acquit him of the blame, in saying, He that betrays me unto you has greater sin. So that it was from weakness that he yielded and scourged Him, and delivered Him up.

He was then unmanly and weak, but the chief priests were wicked and criminal. For since he had found a way out, namely the law of the feast requiring him to release a condemned person, what did they devise in opposition to that? They persuaded the multitude, it is said, that they should ask for Barabbas.

He then was unmanly and weak; but the chief priests wicked and criminal. For since he had found out a device, namely, the law of the feast requiring him to release a condemned person, what do they contrive in opposition to that? They persuaded the multitude, it is said, that they should ask Barabbas.

See how much care Pilate takes to relieve them from blame, and how much diligence they employed so as not to leave themselves even a shadow of an excuse. For which was right? To release the acknowledged criminal, or him whose guilt was in question? For if it was fitting that there should be a release in the case of acknowledged offenders, how much more in those cases where there was doubt. For surely this man did not seem to them worse than acknowledged murderers. For this reason, it does not merely say they had a robber, but one noted—that is, who was infamous in wickedness and who had committed countless murders. But nevertheless, even him they preferred to the Savior of the world, and they reverenced neither the season because it was holy, nor the laws of humanity, nor anything else of the kind, but envy had completely blinded them. And besides their own wickedness, they corrupted the people also, so that for deceiving them too they might suffer the most extreme punishment.

2. See how much care he takes for them to relieve them from blame, and how much diligence they employed, so as not to leave to themselves so much as a shadow of an excuse. For which was right? To let go the acknowledged criminal, or Him about whose guilt there was a question? For, if in the case of acknowledged offenders it was fit there should be a liberation, much more in those of whom there was a doubt. For surely this man did not seem to them worse than acknowledged murderers. For on this account, it is not merely said they had a robber; but one noted, that is, who was infamous in wickedness, who had perpetrated countless murders. But nevertheless even him did they prefer to the Saviour of the world, and neither did they reverence the season because it was holy, nor the laws of humanity, nor any other thing of the kind, but envy had once for all blinded them. And besides their own wickedness, they corrupt the people also, that for deceiving them too they might suffer the most extreme punishment.

Since they were asking for the other prisoner, he says, "What shall I do then with the Christ?" In this way he wanted to shame them by giving them the power to choose, so that they might at least out of shame ask for Him, and the whole thing would come from their own generosity. For though saying "He had done nothing wrong" made them more argumentative, requiring that He be saved out of common humanity carries with it a persuasion and appeal that cannot be contradicted.

Since therefore they ask for the other, he says, What shall I do then with the Christ, in this way desiring to put them to the blush, by giving them the power to choose, that at least out of shame they might ask for Him, and the whole should be of their bountifulness. For though to say, He had not done wrong, made them more contentious, yet to require that He should be saved out of humanity, carries with it persuasion and entreaty that cannot be gainsaid.

But even then they said, "Crucify Him." But he said, "Why, what evil has He done?" But they cried out exceedingly, "Let Him be crucified." But when he saw that he was accomplishing nothing, he washed his hands, saying, "I am innocent." Why then did you hand Him over? Why did you not rescue Him, as the centurion did Paul? For that man too was aware that he would please the Jews, and a riot had broken out on his account, and a commotion, nevertheless he stood firm against everyone. But this man did not do so; instead he was extremely unmanly and weak, and all were corrupt together. For neither did this man stand firm against the crowd, nor the crowd against the Jews, and in every way their excuse was taken away. For they cried out exceedingly—that is, they cried out even more—"Let Him be crucified." For they wanted not only to put Him to death, but also that it should be on a charge of wickedness, and though the judge was contradicting them, they kept crying out the same thing.

But even then they said, Crucify Him. But he said, why, what evil has He done? But they cried out exceedingly, let Him be crucified. But he, when he saw that he profited nothing, washed his hands, saying, I am innocent. Why then did you deliver Him up? Why did you not rescue Him, as the centurion did Paul. Acts xxi For that man too was aware that he would please the Jews; and a sedition had taken place on his account, and a tumult, nevertheless he stood firm against all. But not so this man, but he was extremely unmanly and weak, and all were corrupt together. For neither did this man stand firm against the multitude, nor the multitude against the Jews, and in every way their excuse was taken away. For they cried out exceedingly, that is, cried out the more, Let Him be crucified. For they desired not only to put Him to death, but also that it should be on a charge of wickedness, and though the judge was contradicting them, they continued to cry out the same thing.

Do you see how many things Christ did in order to recover them? For just as He often restrained Judas, so He also held back these men, both throughout all His Gospel and at the very time of His condemnation. For surely when they saw the ruler and judge washing his hands of it and saying, "I am innocent of this blood," they should have been moved to repentance both by what was said and by what was done—when they saw that Judas had hanged himself, and when they saw Pilate himself begging them to take another in His place. For when the accuser and traitor condemns himself, and the one who gives sentence removes the guilt from himself, and such a vision appears that very night, and even as the condemned one he pleads for His release, what kind of defense will they have? For if they were not willing to accept that He was innocent, yet they should not have preferred to Him even a robber—one who was acknowledged to be such and very notorious.

Do you see how many things Christ did in order to recover them? For like as He often times checked Judas, so likewise did He restrain these men too, both throughout all His Gospel, and at the very time of His condemnation. For surely when they saw the ruler and the judge washing his hands of it, and saying, I am innocent of this blood, they should have been moved to compunction both by what was said, and by what was done, as well when they saw Judas had hanged himself, as when they saw Pilate himself entreating them to take another in the place of Him. For when the accuser and traitor condemns himself, and he who gives sentence puts off from himself the guilt, and such a vision appears the very night, and even as condemned he begs Him off, what kind of plea will they have? For if they were not willing that He should be innocent, yet they should not have preferred to him even a robber, one that was acknowledged to be such, and very notorious.

What then did they do? When they saw the judge washing his hands and saying, "I am innocent," they cried out, "His blood be on us and on our children" (Matthew 27:25). Then at last, when they had pronounced sentence against themselves, he gave in and allowed everything to be done.

What then did they? When they saw the judge washing his hands, and saying, I am innocent, they cried out His blood be on us, and on our children. Matthew 27:25 Then at length when they had given sentence against themselves, he yielded that all should be done.

Look at their great madness here as well. This is what passion and wicked desire are like. They don't allow people to see anything that is right. Even if you curse yourselves, why do you bring the curse down on your children too?

See here too their great madness. For passion and wicked desire are like this. They suffer not men to see anything of what is right. For be it that you curse yourselves; why do you draw down the curse upon your children also?

Nevertheless, the lover of mankind, though they acted with such madness both against themselves and against their children, so far from confirming their sentence upon their children, did not even confirm it on them. Instead, from both groups he received those who repented and counts them worthy of good things beyond number. For indeed, even Paul was one of them, and so were the thousands who believed in Jerusalem. As you see, it is said, "Brother, how many thousands of Jews there are who believe." And if some remained in their sin, let them blame themselves for their punishment.

Nevertheless, the lover of man, though they acted with so much madness, both against themselves, and against their children, so far from confirming their sentence upon their children, confirmed it not even on them, but from the one and from the other received those that repented, and counts them worthy of good things beyond number. For indeed even Paul was of them, and the thousands that believed in Jerusalem; for, you see it is said, brother, how many thousands of Jews there are which believe. And if some continued in their sin, to themselves let them impute their punishment.

Then he released Barabbas to them, but after having Jesus scourged, he handed him over to be crucified.

Then released he Barabbas unto them, but Jesus, when he had scourged Him, he delivered to be crucified.

And why did he scourge Him? Either as one already condemned, or wanting to give the judgment a proper appearance, or to please them. Yet he ought to have resisted them. Indeed, even before this he had said, "Take Him yourselves and judge Him according to your law." And there were many things that should have held him and those men back: the signs and the miracles, and the great patience of the One who was suffering these things, and above all His extraordinary silence. For since He had shown His humanity both by defending Himself and by His prayers, He now shows His exaltedness and the greatness of His nature again, both by His silence and by His contempt for what was being said—in all these ways leading them to marvel at Himself. But they yielded to none of these things.

And wherefore did he scourge Him. Either as one condemned, or willing to invest the judgment with due form, or to please them. And yet he ought to have resisted them. For indeed even before this he had said, Take ye Him, and judge Him according to your law. John 18:31 And there were many things that might have held back him and those men, the signs and the miracles, and the great patience of Him, who was suffering these things, and above all His untold silence. For since both by His defense of Himself, and by His prayers, He had shown His humanity, again He shows His exaltedness and the greatness of His nature, both by His silence, and by His contemning what is said; by all leading them on to marvel at Himself. But to none of these things did they give way.

When someone's reasoning abilities are overcome as though by drunkenness or some violent madness, it would be difficult for the failing soul to recover, unless it is very noble.

3. For when once the reasoning powers are overwhelmed as it were by intoxication or some wild insanity, it would be hard for the sinking soul to rise again, if it be not very noble.

It is a fearful thing, truly fearful, to give place to these wicked passions. Therefore we must do everything possible to prevent and repel them from entering in. For when they take hold of the soul and gain control over it, they kindle a blaze just like fire catching upon wood.

For it is fearful, it is fearful to give place to these wicked passions, wherefore it were fit in every way to ward off and repel their entering in. For when they have laid hold of the soul, and got the dominion over it, like as fire lighting upon a wood, so do they kindle the flame to a blaze.

Therefore I urge you to do everything necessary to block their entry, and not to bring all wickedness upon yourselves by comforting yourselves with this heartless reasoning, saying, "What about this? What about that?" For countless evils are born from this. For the devil, being depraved, uses much craftiness, effort, and self-abasement to ruin people, and he begins his attack on them with things of a more trivial nature.

Wherefore I entreat you to do all things so as to fence off their entrance; and not by comforting yourselves with this heartless reasoning to bring in upon yourselves all wickedness, saying, what of this? What of that? For countless ills have their birth from hence. For the devil, being depraved, makes use of much craft, and exertion, and self-abasement for the ruin of men, and begins his attack on them with things of a more trifling nature.

Notice that the devil wanted to lead Saul into the superstition of witchcraft. But if he had recommended this from the start, Saul would not have listened—for how could he have, when he was actually driving out such people? So the devil gradually and bit by bit led him toward it. For when Saul had disobeyed Samuel and had the burnt offering made in his absence, and was then rebuked for it, he said that the pressure from the enemy was too great. And when he should have lamented his sin, he acted as though he had done nothing wrong.

And mark it, he desired to bring Saul into superstition of witchcraft. But if he had counselled this at the beginning, the other would not have given heed; for how should he, who was even driving them out? Therefore gently and little by little he leads him on to it. For when he had disobeyed Samuel, and had caused the burnt-offering to be offered, when he was not present, being blamed for it, he says, The compulsion from the enemy was too great, and when he ought to have bewailed, he felt as though he had done nothing.

Again God gave him the commands about the Amalekites, but he transgressed these too. From there he moved on to his crimes against David, and thus slipping easily and little by little, he did not stop until he came to the very pit of destruction and threw himself in. In the same way with Cain, the devil did not immediately urge him to kill his brother, since he would not have persuaded him, but first worked on him to offer worthless things, saying, "This is no sin." Second, he stirred up envy and jealousy, saying, "There is nothing wrong with this either." Third, he persuaded him to kill and to deny his murder, and did not leave him before he had crowned him with the ultimate act of evil.

Again God gave him the commands about the Amalekites, but he transgressed these too. Thence he proceeded to his crimes about David, and thus slipping easily and little by little he stayed not, until he came unto the very pit of destruction, and cast himself in. So likewise in the case of Cain, he did not at once urge him to slay his brother, since he would not have persuaded him, but first wrought upon him to offer things more or less vile, saying, This is no sin: in the second place he kindled envy and jealousy, saying, neither is there anything in this; thirdly, he persuaded him to slay and to deny his murder; and did not leave him before he had put on him the crowning act of evil.

Therefore we must resist sin at its beginning. For even if the first sins stopped by themselves and went no further, it still would not be right to despise those first sins. But in reality they go on to greater sins when the mind is careless. Therefore we ought to do everything to remove their beginnings.

Wherefore it is necessary for us to resist the beginning. For at any rate, even if the first sins stopped at themselves, not even so were it right to despise the first sins; but now they go on also to what is greater, when the mind is careless. Wherefore we ought to do all things to remove the beginnings of them.

Don't focus on the nature of the sin being small, but rather on the fact that when neglected, it becomes the root of great sin. Here's something remarkable: great sins don't require as much vigilance as those that are small and seemingly insignificant. The very nature of serious sins makes us hate them, but small sins lead us into carelessness by this very fact. They prevent us from rousing ourselves earnestly to remove them. This is why they quickly grow into great sins while we remain asleep. You can see this same thing happening in the body as well.

For look not now at the nature of the sin, that it is little, but that it becomes a root of great sin when neglected. For if one may say something marvellous, great sins need not so much earnestness, as such as are little, and of small account. For the former the very nature of the sin causes us to abhor, but the little sins by this very thing cast us into remissness; and allow us not to rouse ourselves heartily for their removal. Wherefore also they quickly become great, while we sleep. This one may see happening in bodies also.

The same thing happened with Judas—his great wickedness started this way. If stealing money from the poor had not seemed like a small thing to him, he would not have been led on to his act of betrayal. If being enslaved by vainglory had not seemed like a small thing to the Jews, they would not have crashed onto the rock of becoming Christ's murderers. In fact, we can see that all evils arise from this.

So likewise in the instance of Judas, that great wickedness had its birth. For if it had not seemed to him a little thing to steal the money of the poor, he would not have been led on to this treachery. Unless it had seemed to the Jews a little thing to be taken captive by vainglory, they would not have run on the rock of becoming Christ's murderers. And indeed all evils we may see arise from this.

No one rushes into vice quickly and all at once. The soul has—yes, it has—a sense of shame implanted in us, and a reverence for what is right. It would not immediately become so shameless as to throw everything away in a single act, but it perishes slowly, little by little, when it is careless. This is also how idolatry entered in, with people being honored beyond measure, both the living and the dead. This is also how idols were worshipped, how sexual immorality prevailed, and how the other evils took hold.

For no one quickly and at once rushes out into vices. For the soul has, yea it has a shame implanted in us, and a reverence for right things; and it would not at once become so shameless as in one act to cast away everything, but slowly, and little by little does it perish, when it is careless. Thus also did idolatry enter in, men being honored beyond measure, both the living and the departed; thus also were idols worshipped; thus too did whoredom prevail, and the other evils.

And see how this happens. One person laughed at an inappropriate time; another person criticized him; a third person removed the fear by saying, "Nothing will come of this. After all, what is laughing? What can possibly come of it?" From this comes foolish jesting; from that comes filthy talking; then come filthy deeds.

And see. One man laughed unseasonably; another blamed him; a third took away the fear, by saying, nothing comes of this. For what is laughing? What can come of it? Of this is bred foolish jesting; from that filthy talking; then filthy doings.

Another person was criticized for slandering his neighbors, speaking abusively, and making false accusations, but he dismissed it, saying that evil-speaking is nothing. Through this he creates unspeakable hatred and endless verbal abuse; the abuse leads to physical violence, and the violence often leads to murder.

Again, another being blamed for slandering his neighbors, and reviling, and calumniating, despised it, saying, evil-speaking is nothing. By this he begets hatred unspeakable, revilings without end; by the revilings blows, and by the blows oftentimes murder.

So it is from these small things that the evil spirit introduces the great sins, and from the great sins, despair—having devised this other snare no less harmful than the first. For to sin does not destroy as much as to despair does. The person who has sinned, if he is vigilant, quickly corrects what he has done through repentance. But the person who has learned to despair and does not repent falls short of this correction because he does not apply the remedies that come from repentance.

4. From these little things then that wicked spirit thus brings in the great sins; and from the great despair; having invented this other while not less mischievous than the former. For to sin destroys not so much as to despair. For he that has offended, if he be vigilant, speedily by repentance amends what has been done; but he that has learned to despond, and does not repent, by reason thereof fails of this amendment by not applying the remedies from repentance.

The devil has a third terrible trap: he disguises sin as an act of devotion. Where has the devil succeeded so much as to deceive people to this extent? Listen carefully and be on guard against his schemes. Through Paul, Christ commanded that a wife should not separate from her husband, and that married couples should not deprive one another except by mutual agreement. Yet some women, supposedly out of love for continence, have withdrawn from their own husbands as though they were doing something devout, and have driven them to adultery. Now consider what an evil this is: these women endure so much hardship, yet they are blamed for committing the greatest injustice, suffer extreme punishment, and push their husbands into the pit of destruction.

And he has a third grievous snare; as when he invests the sin with a show of devotion. And where has the devil so far prevailed as to deceive to this degree? Hear, and beware of his devices. Christ by Paul commanded that a woman depart not from her husband, 1 Corinthians 7:10 and not to defraud one another, except by consent; 1 Corinthians 7:5 but some from a love of continence forsooth, having withdrawn from their own husbands, as though they were doing something devout, have driven them to adultery. Consider now what an evil it is that they, undergoing so much toil, should be blamed as having committed the greatest injustice, and should suffer extreme punishment, and drive their husbands into the pit of destruction.

Others, while abstaining from certain foods as a fasting rule, have gradually gone so far as to loathe them entirely—which in itself brings very severe punishment.

Others again, abstaining from meats by a rule of fasting, have by degrees gone so far as to abhor them; which even of itself brings a very great punishment.

But this happens when people hold onto their own biases that contradict what the Scriptures approve. Similarly, some among the Corinthians thought it was a mark of perfection to eat everything without distinction, even forbidden things, but this was not perfection at all—it was complete lawlessness. That is why Paul severely rebukes them and declares them worthy of extreme punishment. Others think it is a sign of piety to wear long hair. Yet this too is among the forbidden things and brings much disgrace.

But this comes to pass, when any hold fast their own prejudices contrary to what is approved by the Scriptures. Those also among the Corinthians thought it was a part of perfection to eat of all things without distinction, even of things forbidden, but nevertheless this was not of perfection, but of the utmost lawlessness. Wherefore also Paul earnestly reproves them, and pronounces them to be worthy of extreme punishment. Others again think it a sign of piety to wear long hair. And yet this is among the things forbidden, and carries with it much disgrace.

Some people pursue excessive sorrow for their sins as if it were beneficial, but this also comes from the devil's scheming, as Judas demonstrated—he even hanged himself because of it. This is why Paul feared for the man who had committed fornication, worried that something similar might happen to him, and urged the Corinthians to quickly restore him, lest perhaps such a one should be swallowed up with overmuch sorrow. Then, showing that such an outcome comes from the traps of that evil one, he says, Lest Satan should get an advantage over us, for we are not ignorant of his devices, meaning that he attacks us with great cunning. For if he fought against us plainly and openly, victory would be straightforward and easy; or rather, even now, if we remain watchful, victory will be straightforward. Indeed, God has equipped us with weapons against each one of these tactics.

Again, others follow after excessive sorrow for their sins as a profitable thing; yet it also comes of the devil's wiles, and Judas showed it; at least in consequence thereof he even hanged himself. Therefore Paul again was in fear about him that had committed fornication, lest any such thing should befall him, and persuaded the Corinthians speedily to deliver him, lest perhaps such a one should be swallowed up with overmuch sorrow. 2 Corinthians 2:7 Then, indicating that such a result comes of the snares of that wicked one, he says, Lest Satan should get an advantage over us, for we are not ignorant of his devices, 2 Corinthians 2:10-11 meaning that he assails us with much craft. Since if he fought against us plainly and openly, the victory would be ready and easy; or rather even now, if we be vigilant, victory will be ready. For indeed against each one of those ways God has armed us.

To convince us not to despise even these small things, listen to the warning He gives us, saying, "Whoever says to his brother, 'You fool,' shall be in danger of hell," and whoever has looked with lustful eyes is a complete adulterer. He pronounces a woe on those who laugh, and everywhere He removes the beginning and the seeds of evil, and says we must give an account of every idle word. Therefore Job also applied a remedy even for the thoughts of his children.

For to persuade us not to despise even these little things, hear what warning He gives us, saying, He that says to his brother, thou fool, shall be in danger of hell; Matthew 5:22 and he that has looked with unchaste eyes is a complete adulterer. Matthew 5:28 And on them that laugh he pronounces a woe, and everywhere He removes the beginning and the seeds of evil, and says we have to give an account of an idle word. Matthew 12:36 Therefore also Job applied a remedy even for the thoughts of his children. Job 1:5

Regarding not despairing, Scripture says, "Does he fall, and not arise? Does he turn away, and not return?" (Jeremiah 8:4), and "I do not desire the death of the sinner, but rather that he should turn and live," and "Today if you will hear His voice." Many other such sayings and examples are found in Scripture. And so that you are not destroyed under the appearance of godly fear, listen to Paul saying, "Lest perhaps such a one be swallowed up by excessive sorrow."

But about not despairing, it is said, Does he fall, and not arise? Does he turn away, and not return? Jeremiah 8:4 and, I do not will the death of the sinner, so much as that he should turn and live: and, Today if you will hear His voice: and many other such things, both sayings and examples are set in the Scripture. And in order not to be ruined under the guise of godly fear, hear Paul saying, Lest perhaps such a one be swallowed up by overmuch sorrow.

Knowing these things, then, let us set up a barrier on all the paths that lead the unwary astray—the wisdom that comes from the Scriptures. Don't say, "Why, what's wrong if I look at a beautiful woman with desire?" For if you commit adultery in your heart, you will soon dare to commit it in the flesh. Don't say, "Why, what's wrong if I pass by this poor man?" For if you pass by this man, you will also pass by the next one; if him, then the third.

Knowing therefore these things, let us set for a barrier in all the ways that pervert the unwary the wisdom which is drawn from the Scriptures. Neither say, why, what is it, if I gaze curiously at a beautiful woman? For if you should commit the adultery in the heart, soon you will venture on that in flesh. Say not, why, what is it if I should pass by this poor man? For if you pass this man by, you will also the next; if him, then the third.

Don't say, "Why? What's wrong with desiring my neighbor's possessions?" This very thing caused Ahab's downfall. Even though he would have paid for it, he took it from someone who didn't want to sell. A person should not buy by force, but only through persuasion. If someone who would have paid a fair price was punished so severely because he took from someone unwilling, what punishment does someone deserve who doesn't even do that much but uses violence to take from the unwilling—and does so while living under grace?

Neither again say, why, what is it, if I should desire my neighbor's goods. For this, this caused Ahab's ruin; although he would have paid a price, yet he took it from one unwilling. For a man ought not to buy by force, but on persuasion. But if he, who would have paid the fair price, was so punished, because he took from one unwilling, he who does not so much as this, and takes by violence from the unwilling, and that when living under grace, of what punishment will he not be worthy?

So that we may not be punished, let us keep ourselves completely pure from all violence and theft, and guard against the sources of sins along with the sins themselves. Let us give ourselves diligently to virtue, for in this way we will also enjoy the eternal good things through the grace and love toward humanity of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory forever and ever. Amen.

In order therefore that we be not punished, keeping ourselves quite pure from all violence and rapine, and guarding against the sources of sins together with the sins themselves, let us with much diligence give heed to virtue; for thus shall we also enjoy the good things eternal by the grace and love towards man of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of Matthew — Homily 85

One of Chrysostom’s 90 homilies on the Gospel of Matthew, preached at Antioch.

Source: Translated by George Prevost and revised by M.B. Riddle. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 10. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1888. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/200185.htm>.

Opening

Matthew 26:67-68.

Matthew 26:67-68.

Then they spit in His face, struck Him with their fists, and others slapped Him with the palms of their hands, saying, "Prophesy to us, you Christ, who is the one who struck you?"

Then did they spit in His face, and buffeted Him, and others smote Him with the palms of their hands, saying, Prophesy unto us, you Christ, who is he that smote you?

Why did they do these things when they were about to put Him to death? What need was there for this mockery? They did this so that you might learn from everything about their lack of self-control, and that having captured Him like prey, they displayed their intoxication in this way and gave free rein to their madness. They turned this into a celebration, attacking Him with pleasure and revealing their murderous nature.

Wherefore did they these things, when they were to put Him to death? What need of this mockery? That you might learn their intemperate spirit by all things, and that having taken Him like a prey, they thus showed forth their intoxication, and gave full swing to their madness; making this a festival, and assaulting Him with pleasure, and showing forth their murderous disposition.

But I ask you to admire the self-control of the disciples and the exactness with which they relate these things. This clearly shows their disposition to love the truth, because they report with complete truthfulness the things that seem disgraceful, hiding nothing and feeling no shame about them. Rather, they consider it very great glory—as indeed it was—that the Lord of the universe should endure to suffer such things for us. This demonstrates both His unutterable tenderness and the inexcusable wickedness of those men who had the heart to do such things to Him who was so mild and meek, and who was charming them with words that were enough to change a lion into a lamb. For He failed in nothing when it came to gentleness, nor did they fail in insolence and cruelty in what they did and what they said. All these things the prophet Isaiah foretold, proclaiming them beforehand and indicating all this insolence with one word. For he says, "Just as many were astonished at you, so shall your form be held inglorious by men, and your glory by the sons of men."

But admire, I pray you, the self command of the disciples, with what exactness they relate these things. Hereby is clearly shown their disposition to love the truth, because they relate with all truthfulness the things that seem to be opprobrious, disguising nothing, nor being ashamed thereof, but rather accounting it very great glory, as indeed it was, that the Lord of the universe should endure to suffer such things for us. This shows both His unutterable tenderness, and the inexcusable wickedness of those men, who had the heart to do such things to Him that was so mild and meek, and was charming them with such words, as were enough to change a lion into a lamb. For neither did He fail in any things of gentleness, nor they of insolence and cruelty, in what they did, in what they said. All which things the prophet Isaiah foretold, thus proclaiming beforehand, and by one word intimating all this insolence. For like as many were astonished at you, he says, so shall your form be held inglorious of men, and your glory of the sons of men.

For what could equal this insolence? On that face which the sea, when it saw it, had reverenced, from which the sun, when it beheld it on the cross, turned away its rays—they spat and struck it with the palms of their hands, and some struck the head, giving full expression in every way to their own madness. For they inflicted the blows that are most insulting of all: buffeting, striking with the palms of their hands, and to these blows adding the insult of spitting at Him. And they spoke words full of mockery, saying, "Prophesy to us, Christ! Who is it that struck you?"—because the crowd called Him a prophet.

For what could be equal to this insolence? On that face which the sea, when it saw it, had reverenced, from which the sun, when it beheld it on the cross, turned away his rays, they did spit, and struck it with the palms of their hands, and some upon the head; giving full swing in every way to their own madness. For indeed they inflicted the blows that are most insulting of all, buffeting, smiting with the palms of their hands, and to these blows adding the insult of spitting at Him. And words again teeming with much derision did they speak, saying, prophesy unto us, thou Christ, who is he that smote you? because the multitude called Him a prophet.

But another passage in Luke 22:64 says that they covered His face with His own garment and did these things as though they had captured some worthless and despicable person. And not only free people but slaves as well behaved without restraint in this way toward Him at that time.

But another Luke 22:64 says, that they covered His face with His own garment, and did these things, as though they had got in the midst of them some vile and worthless fellow. And not freemen only, but slaves also were intemperate with this intemperance towards Him at that time.

Let us read these things constantly, let us hear them properly, let us write them on our minds, for these are our honors. I take pride in these things—not only in the thousands of dead whom He raised, but also in the sufferings He endured. Paul puts these things forward in every way: the cross, the death, the sufferings, the insults, the abuse, the mockery. And now he says, "Let us go out to Him bearing His reproach" (Hebrews 13:13), and now, "who for the joy that was set before Him endured the cross, despising the shame" (Hebrews 12:2).

These things let us read continually, these things let us hear aright, these things let us write in our minds, for these are our honors. In these things do I take a pride, not only in the thousands of dead which He raised, but also in the sufferings which He endured. These things Paul puts forward in every way, the cross, the death, the sufferings, the revilings, the insults, the scoffs. And now he says, let us go forth unto Him bearing His reproach; Hebrews 13:13 and now, who for the joy that was set before Him endured the cross, despising the shame. Hebrews 12:2

Now Peter was sitting in the courtyard outside, and a servant girl came up to him, saying, "You also were with Jesus of Galilee." But he denied it in front of everyone, saying, "I don't know what you're talking about." When he had gone out to the gateway, another servant girl saw him and said, "This man was also with Jesus of Nazareth." And again he denied it with an oath. After a little while, those who were standing nearby came up and said to Peter, "Surely you are one of them too, because your accent gives you away." Then he began to curse and to swear, "I don't know the man." Immediately the rooster crowed. Peter remembered the words Jesus had spoken: "Before the rooster crows, you will deny me three times." And he went out and wept bitterly.

Now Peter sat in the court outside; and a damsel came to him, saying, you also were with Jesus of Galilee. But he denied before them all, saying, I know not what you say. And when he had gone out into the porch, another maid saw him, and says, this man also was there with Jesus of Nazareth. And again he denied with an oath. And after a while came to him they that stood by, and said to Peter, surely you also are one of them, for your speech betrays you. Then he began to curse and to swear, I know not the man. And immediately the cock crowed. And Peter remembered the words of Jesus, which said, before the cock crow, you shall deny me thrice. And he went out, and wept bitterly.

Oh, what strange and wonderful events! When he saw his master simply being arrested, he was so passionate that he both drew his sword and cut off the man's ear. But when it would have been natural for him to be more indignant, inflamed, and burning with anger—hearing such insults—then he becomes a denier. For who would not have been driven to fury by what was happening then? Yet the disciple, overcome by fear, far from showing indignation, actually denies Christ and cannot even endure the threat of a wretched and lowly girl. And not just once, but a second and third time he denies him, and within a short time. And not even before judges, for it was outside—when he had gone out into the porch, they asked him, and he did not even quickly come to realize his fall. And Luke says this (Luke 22:61), namely, that Christ looked at him, showing that he not only denied him but was not even brought to remembrance from within, even though the rooster had crowed. But he needed a further reminder from his master, and his look served him instead of a voice—so completely was he filled with fear.

Oh strange and wonderful acts! When indeed he saw his master seized only, he was so fervent as both to draw his sword, and to cut off the man's ear; but when it was natural for him to be more indignant, and to be inflamed and to burn, hearing such revilings, then he becomes a denier. For who would not have been inflamed to madness by the things that were then done? Yet the disciple, overcome by fears, so far from showing indignation, even denies, and endures not the threat of a miserable and mean girl, and not once only, but a second and third time does he deny Him; and in a short period, and not so much as before judges, for it was without for when he had gone out into the porch, they asked him, and he did not even readily come to a sense of his fall. And this Luke says, Luke 22:61 namely, that Christ looked on him showing that he not only denied Him, but was not even brought to remembrance from within, and this though the cock had crowed; but he needed a further remembrance from his master, and His look was to him instead of a voice; so exceedingly was he full of fear.

But Mark says that when Peter had denied Jesus once, the cock crowed for the first time, but when he had denied him three times, it crowed for the second time. Mark reports more precisely the disciple's weakness and the fact that he was utterly paralyzed by fear. He learned these details from his master, Peter himself, for he was a follower of Peter. In this respect, one would marvel at Mark all the more, because far from concealing his teacher's faults, he recounted them more clearly than the other Gospel writers did, for this very reason—that he was Peter's disciple.

But Mark says, that when he had once denied, then first the cock crew, but when thrice, then for the second time; for he declares more particularly the weakness of the disciple, and that he was utterly dead with fear; having learned these things of his master 1 Peter 5:13 himself, for he was a follower of Peter. In which respect one would most marvel at him, that so far from hiding his teacher's faults, he declared it more distinctly than the rest, on this very account, that he was his disciple.

How then is what is said true, when Matthew affirms that Christ said, "Verily I say unto you, that before the cock crow you shall deny me thrice," and Mark declares after the third denial that "the cock crew the second time"? Yet most certainly it is both true and in harmony. For because at each crowing the cock is accustomed to crow both a third and a fourth time, Mark, to show that not even the sound checked him and brought him to recollection, says this. So that both things are true. For before the cock had finished the one crowing, he had denied a third time. And not even when reminded of his sin by Christ did he dare to weep openly, lest he should be betrayed by his tears, but he went out and wept bitterly.

2. How then is what is said true, when Matthew affirms that Christ said, Verily I say unto you, that before the cock crow you shall deny me thrice; Matthew 26:34 and Mark declares after the third denial, that The cock crew the second time? Mark 14:72 Nay, most certainly is it both true and in harmony. For because at each crowing the cock is wont to crow both a third and a fourth time, Mark, to show that not even the sound checked him, and brought him to recollection says this. So that both things are true. For before the cock had finished the one crowing, he had denied a third time. And not even when reminded of his sin by Christ did he dare to weep openly, lest he should be betrayed by his tears, but he went out, and wept bitterly.

When day came, they led Jesus from Caiaphas to Pilate. Because they wanted to put Him to death but were unable to do so themselves because of the feast, they brought Him to the governor.

And when it was day, they led away Jesus from Caiaphas to Pilate. For because they were desirous to put Him to death, but were not able themselves because of the feast, they lead Him to the governor.

Notice, I ask you, how the action was pressed forward so that it would happen during the feast. For this is how it was prefigured from the beginning.

But mark, I pray you, how the act was forced on, so as to take place at the feast. For so was it typified from the first.

Then Judas, who had betrayed him, when he saw that Jesus was condemned, repented and brought back the thirty pieces of silver.

Then Judas, which had betrayed him, when he saw that He was condemned, repented, and brought again the thirty pieces of silver.

This charge applied to both Judas and to these men. It was against Judas not because he repented, but because he did so late and slowly, and he condemned himself—for he himself confessed that he had betrayed Jesus. And it was against them because, even though they had the power to reverse their decision, they did not repent.

This was a charge both against him, and against these men; against him, not because he repented, but because he did so, late, and slowly, and became self-condemned (for that he delivered Him up, he himself confessed); and against them, for that having the power to reverse it, they repented not.

But notice when he feels remorse. It is when his sin was completed and had reached its accomplishment. For the devil is like this: he does not allow those who are not watchful to see the evil beforehand, lest the one he has captured should repent. Certainly, when Jesus was saying so many things, he was not influenced, but when his offense was completed, then repentance came upon him—and not profitably even then. For to condemn it, to throw down the pieces of silver, and to disregard the Jewish people were all acceptable things; but to hang himself, this again was unpardonable, and a work of an evil spirit. For the devil led him out of his repentance too soon, so that he should gain no fruit from it, and carries him off by a most disgraceful death, one visible to all, having persuaded him to destroy himself.

But mark, when it is that he feels remorse. When his sin was completed, and had received an accomplishment. For the devil is like this; he suffers not those that are not watchful to see the evil before this, lest he whom he has taken, should repent. At least, when Jesus was saying so many things, he was not influenced, but when his offense was completed, then repentance came upon him; and not then profitably. For to condemn it, and to throw down the pieces of silver, and not to regard the Jewish people, were all acceptable things; but to hang himself, this again was unpardonable, and a work of an evil spirit. For the devil led him out of his repentance too soon, so that he should reap no fruit from thence; and carries him off, by a most disgraceful death, and one manifest to all, having persuaded him to destroy himself.

But notice, I ask you, how the truth shines forth from every direction, even through what the adversaries both do and experience. Indeed, even the very end of the traitor silences those who had condemned Him, and leaves them without even a trace of an excuse, however shameless it might be. For what could they possibly say when the traitor is shown to pass such a judgment on himself?

But mark, I pray you, the truth shining forth on every side, even by what the adversaries both do and suffer. For indeed even the very end of the traitor stops the mouths of them that had condemned Him, and suffers them not to have so much as any shadow of an excuse, that is surely shameless. For what could they have to say, when the traitor is shown to pass such a sentence on himself.

Let's look at what the text actually says. He brought the thirty pieces of silver back to the chief priests and said, "I have sinned in that I have betrayed innocent blood." They replied, "What is that to us? See to that yourself." He threw down the pieces of silver in the temple, left, and went and hanged himself.

But let us see also the words, what is said; He brought again the thirty pieces of silver to the chief priests, and says, I have sinned in that I have betrayed innocent blood. And they said, what is that to us? See thou to that. And he cast down the pieces of silver in the temple, and departed, and went and hanged himself.

Judas could not bear his conscience tormenting him. But notice, I ask you, that the Jews were suffering the same things. For they too, when they should have been corrected by what they suffered, did not stop until they had completed their sin. Judas's sin was already complete, since it was a betrayal, but theirs was not yet. But when they too had finished theirs and had nailed Him to the cross, then they also became troubled. At one time they were saying, "Do not write, 'This is the King of the Jews'" (and yet why are you afraid? Why are you troubled by a dead body nailed to a cross?). At another time they set a guard over Him, saying, "Otherwise His disciples might steal Him away and say that He has risen again, and the last deception will be worse than the first." And yet if they did it, the thing would be refuted if it were not true. But how could they say this, when they did not even dare to stand their ground when He was arrested? Even the chief among them denied Him three times, unable to endure a servant girl's accusation. But, as I said, the chief priests were now troubled, for they knew the act was a violation of the law—this is clear from their saying, "See to that yourself."

For neither could he bear his conscience scourging him. But mark, I pray you, the Jews too suffering the same things. For these men also, when they ought to have been amended by what they suffered, do not stop, until they have completed their sin. For his sin had been completed, for it was a betrayal; but theirs not yet. But when they too had accomplished theirs, and had nailed Him to the cross then they also are troubled; at one time saying, Write not, this is the king of the Jews John 19:21 (and yet why are you afraid? Why are you troubled at a dead body that is nailed upon the cross?); at another time they guard over Him, saying, Lest His disciples steal Him away, and say that He is risen again; so the last error shall be worse than the first. And yet if they do it, the thing is refuted, if it be not true. But how should they say so, which did not dare so much as to stand their ground, when He was seized; and the chief of them even thrice denied Him, not bearing a damsel's threat. But, as I said, the chief priests were now troubled; for that they knew the act was a transgression of the law is manifest, from their saying, See thou to that.

Listen, you who are greedy for money, think about what happened to him. He lost the money, committed the sin, and destroyed his own soul all at the same time. That is how tyrannical greed is. He did not enjoy the money, neither this present life nor the life to come, but lost everything at once. And having gained a bad reputation even with those very men, he hanged himself.

Hear, you covetous, consider what befell him; how he at the same time lost the money, and committed the sin, and destroyed his own soul. Such is the tyranny of covetousness. He enjoyed not the money, neither the present life, nor that to come, but lost all at once, and having got a bad character even with those very men, so hanged himself.

But, as I said, after the act, then some see clearly. See at any rate these men too for a time not willing to have a clear perception of the fact, but saying, "See thou to that"—which thing of itself is a most heavy charge against them. For this is the language of men bearing witness to their own daring and their own transgression, but intoxicated by their passion, and not willing to stop their satanical attempts, but senselessly wrapping themselves up in a veil of feigned ignorance.

But, as I said, after the act, then some see clearly. See at any rate these men too for a time not willing to have a clear perception of the fact, but saying, See thou to that: which thing of itself is a most heavy charge against them. For this is the language of men bearing witness to their daring and their transgression, but intoxicated by their passion, and not willing to forbear their satanical attempts, but senselessly wrapping themselves up in a veil of feigned ignorance.

For if these things had been said after the crucifixion and his killing, truly even then the statement would have made no reasonable sense, though it would not have condemned them as much. But now, while still having him in your own hands and having the power to release him, how could you say these things? For this defense would be a most severe accusation against you. How? And in what way? Because while throwing the entire blame on the traitor (for they say, "See thou to that"), even though they were able to free themselves from this murder of Christ, they abandoned the traitor and pressed the crime even further, adding the cross to the betrayal. For what prevented them, when they said to him "See thou to that," from stopping the criminal act themselves? But now they even do the opposite, adding murder to it, and in everything, both by what they do and by what they say, entangling themselves in unavoidable evils. For indeed after these things, when Pilate left it to them, they chose the robber to be released rather than Jesus; but him who had done no wrong and had even given them so many benefits, they killed.

For if indeed these things had been said after the crucifixion, and His being slain, of a truth even then the saying would have had no reasonable meaning, nevertheless it would not have condemned them so much; but now having Him yet in your own hands, and having power to release Him, how could ye be able to say these things? For this defense would be a most heavy accusation against you. How? And in what way? Because while throwing the whole blame upon the traitor (for they say, See thou to that), being able to have set themselves free from this murder of Christ, they left the traitor, and even pressed the crime further, adding the cross to the betrayal. For what hindered them, when they said to him, See thou to that, themselves to forbear the criminal act? But now they even do the contrary, adding to it the murder and in every thing, both by what they do, and by what they say, entangling themselves in inevitable ills. For indeed after these things, when Pilate left it to them, they choose the robber to be released rather than Jesus; but Him that had done no wrong, but had even conferred on them so many benefits, they slew.

What then did that man do? When he saw that his efforts were useless and that they would not agree to take back the pieces of silver, he threw them down in the temple and went and hanged himself. And the chief priests took the pieces of silver and said, "It is not lawful to put them into the treasury, because it is the price of blood." And they consulted together and bought with them the potter's field to bury strangers in. Therefore that field was called the field of blood, to this day. Then was fulfilled what was spoken by Jeremiah the prophet, saying, "And they took the thirty pieces of silver, the price of Him that was valued, and gave them for the potter's field, as the Lord appointed me."

3. What then did that man? When he saw that he was laboring to no profit, and that they would not consent to receive the pieces of silver, he cast them down in the temple, and went and hanged himself. And the chief priests took the pieces of silver, and said, it is not lawful for to put them into the treasury, because it is the price of blood. And they took counsel, and bought with them the potter's field to bury strangers in. Wherefore that field was called, the field of blood, unto this day. Then was fulfilled that which was spoken by Jeremy the prophet, saying, and they took the thirty pieces of silver, the price of Him that was valued, and gave them for the potter's field, as the Lord appointed me.

Do you see them condemned again by their own conscience? Because they knew they had been paying for murder, they did not put the money into the treasury but instead bought a field to bury strangers in. This also became a witness against them and proof of their treason. For the name of the place proclaimed their bloodguilt more clearly than a trumpet. They did not do this randomly, but after taking counsel, and in every case in the same way, so that no one would be free from the deed, but all would be guilty. But the prophecy foretold these things long ago. Do you see that not only the apostles but also the prophets declared exactly those things that were matters of reproach, and in every way proclaimed the passion and indicated it beforehand?

Do you see them again self-condemned by their conscience? For because they knew that they had been buying the murder, they put them not into the treasury, but bought a field to bury strangers in. And this also became a witness against them, and a proof of their treason. For the name of the place more clearly than a trumpet proclaimed their blood- guiltiness. Neither did they it at random, but having taking counsel, and in every case in like manner, so that no one should be clear of the deed, but all guilty. But these things the prophecy foretold from of old. Do you see not the apostles only, but the prophets also declaring exactly those things which were matters of reproach, and every way proclaiming the passion, and indicating it beforehand?

This happened to the Jews without them realizing it. If they had thrown the money into the treasury, what they had done would not have been so clearly revealed. But by purchasing a field, they made everything obvious even to later generations.

This was the case with the Jews without their being conscious of it. For if they had cast it into the treasury, the thing would not have been so clearly discovered; but now having bought a piece of ground, they made it all manifest even to subsequent generations.

Listen, all of you who think you can do good works from the proceeds of murders and take payment for people's lives. These acts of almsgiving are Jewish in character, or rather they are Satanic. For there are, yes there are even now, those who violently seize countless things belonging to others and think that everything is excused if they throw in ten or a hundred gold coins.

Hear ye as many as think to do good works out of murders, and take a reward for the lives of men. These almsgiving are Judaical, or rather they are Satanical. For there are, there are now also they, that take by violence countless things belonging to others, and think that an excuse is made for all if they cast in some ten or a hundred gold pieces.

About those the prophet also says, "You covered my altar with tears." Christ does not want to be fed by greed. He does not accept this kind of food. Why do you insult your Lord by offering him unclean things? It is better to leave people to starve than to feed them from these sources. The first would be the action of a cruel person, but this is the action of someone both cruel and insolent. It is better to give nothing than to give what belongs to one group of people to others. Tell me, if you saw two people, one naked and one with a garment, and then you stripped the one who had the garment to clothe the naked person, wouldn't you have committed an injustice? Surely this is obvious to everyone. But if when you give everything you have taken to another person, you have committed an injustice and not shown mercy, then when you don't even give a small portion of what you steal and call the deed almsgiving, what kind of punishment will you face? For if people offering lame animals were blamed, what favor will you receive for doing things even worse? For if a thief, making restitution to the owner himself, still commits an injustice—and commits such an injustice that only by adding back fourfold does he barely clear the charge against himself, and this was under the old covenant—then what about the person who is not stealing but taking by violence, and not even giving to the one who was robbed but to someone else instead, and not giving fourfold but not even half, and moreover not living under the old dispensation but under the new? Consider how much fire he is heaping up on his own head. And if he does not yet suffer his punishment, for this very reason I say bewail him, for he is storing up greater wrath against himself unless he repents. For what? "Do you think," he says, "that they alone were sinners on whom the tower fell down? No, I say to you, but unless you repent, you also will suffer the same things."

Touching whom also the prophet says, You covered my altar with tears. Malachi 2:13 Christ is not willing to be fed by covetousness, He accepts not this food. Why do you insult your Lord, offering Him unclean things? It is better to leave men to pine with hunger, than to feed them from these sources. That was the conduct of a cruel man, this of one both cruel and insolent. It is better to give nothing, than to give the things of one set of persons to others. For tell me, if you saw any two persons, one naked, one having a garment, and then having stripped the one that had the garment, thou were to clothe the naked, would you not have committed an injustice? It is surely plain to every one. But if when you have given all that you have taken to another, you have committed an injustice, and not shown mercy; when you give not even a small portion of what you rob, and callest the deed alms, what manner of punishment will you not undergo? For if men offering lame brutes were blamed, what favor will you obtain doing things more grievous? For if the chief, making restitution to the owner himself, still does an injustice, and so does an injustice, as by adding fourfold scarcely to do away the charge against himself, and this under the old covenant; Exodus 22:1 he that is not stealing, but taking by violence, and not even giving to him that is robbed, but instead of him to another; nor yet giving fourfold, but not so much as the half; and moreover not living under the old dispensation, but under the new; consider how much fire he is heaping together upon his own head. And if he do not as yet suffer his punishment, for this self-same thing I say bewail him, for he is treasuring up against himself a greater wrath, unless he repent. For what? Think ye, says He, that they alone were sinners upon whom the tower fell down? Nay, I say unto you, but except ye repent, you also shall suffer the same things.

Let us repent, then, and give alms that are pure from covetousness, and give them in great abundance. Consider that the Jews used to support eight thousand Levites, and along with the Levites, also widows and orphans, and they bore many other public expenses, and on top of all this also served as soldiers. But now there are fields, houses, rental properties, carriages, muleteers, mules, and a great array of this kind in the church because of you and your hardness of heart. For this store of the church ought to be with you, and your readiness of mind ought to be a revenue to her. But now two wrong things happen: both you remain unfruitful, and God's priests do not practice their proper duties.

Let us repent then, and give alms pure from covetousness, and in great abundance. Consider that the Jews used to feed eight thousand Levites, and together with the Levites, widows also and orphans, and they bore many other public charges, and together with these things also served as soldiers; but now there are fields, and houses, and hirings of lodgings, and carriages, and muleteers, and mules, and a great array of this kind in the church on account of you, and your hardness of heart. For this store of the church ought to be with you, and your readiness of mind ought to be a revenue to her; but now two wrong things come to pass, both you continue unfruitful, and God's priests do not practise their proper duties.

Was it not possible for the houses and lands to have remained in the time of the apostles? Why then did they sell them and give them away? Because this was the better thing to do.

Was it not possible for the houses and the lands to have remained in the time of the apostles? Wherefore then did they sell them and give away? Because this was a better thing.

But then a fear gripped our fathers (when you were so obsessed with worldly things, and because of your gatherings rather than spreading out), lest the groups of widows and orphans and virgins should die of starvation. Therefore they were forced to provide these things. For it was not their wish to take on what was so inappropriate for them, but their desire was that your generosity should be a provision for them, and that they should gather their resources from there, and that they themselves should devote themselves to prayers only.

4. But now a fear seized our fathers (when you were so mad after worldly things, and because of your gatherings, and not dispersing abroad), lest the companies of the widows and orphans, and of the virgins, should perish of famine; therefore were they constrained to provide these things. For it was not their wish to thrust themselves unto what was so unbecoming; but their desire was that your good will should have been a supply for them, and that they should gather their fruits from thence, and that they themselves should give heed to prayers only.

But now you have forced them to imitate the households of those who manage public affairs, by which everything is turned upside down. For when both you and we are entangled in the same things, who is there to propitiate God? Therefore it is not possible for us to open our mouths, when the state of the church is no better than that of worldly men. Have you not heard that the apostles would not consent even to distribute the money that was collected without any trouble? But now our bishops have surpassed agents, stewards, and merchants in their concern about these things. When they ought to be careful and thoughtful about your souls, they are troubling themselves every day about these things that innkeepers, tax collectors, accountants, and stewards are concerned with.

But now you have constrained them to imitate the houses of them that manage public affairs; whereby all things are turned upside down. For when both you and we are entangled in the same things, who is there to propitiate God? Therefore it is not possible for us to open our mouths, when the state of the church is no better than that of worldly men. Have ye not heard that the apostles would not consent so much as to distribute the money that was collected without any trouble? But now our bishops have gone beyond agents, and stewards, and hucksters in their care about these things; and when they ought to be careful and thoughtful about your souls, they are vexing themselves every day about these things, for which the innkeepers, and tax-gatherers, and accountants, and stewards are careful.

I do not bring up these things simply to complain, but so that there may be some correction and change, so that we may receive pity for enduring a harsh servitude, and so that you may become a source of income and supply for the church.

These things I do not mention for nought in the way of complaint, but in order that there may be some amendment and change, in order that we may be pitied for serving a grievous servitude, in order that you may become a revenue and store for the church.

But if you are unwilling, look at the poor right in front of you. We will continue to feed as many as we are able to provide for, but those we cannot help, we will leave to you, so that you may not hear those words on the terrible day that will be spoken to the unmerciful and cruel: "You saw me hungry, and did not feed me." Matthew 25:42

But if you are not willing, behold the poor before your eyes; as many as it is possible for us to suffice, we will not cease to feed; but those, whom it is not possible, we will leave to you, that you may not hear those words on the awful day, which shall be spoken to the unmerciful and cruel. You saw me an hungered, and fed me not. Matthew 25:42

For this inhumanity makes us laughing-stocks along with you, because we abandon our prayers, our teaching, and the other aspects of holiness, and spend all our time fighting—some with wine merchants, some with grain dealers, others with those who sell other provisions.

For together with you this inhumanity makes us laughing-stocks, because leaving our prayers, and our teaching, and the other parts of holiness, we are fighting all our time, some with wine merchants, some with grain-factors, others with them that retail other provisions.

This is why there are fights, conflicts, daily insults, accusations, and mockery, and each of the priests gets names that would be more fitting for secular households. It would have been proper instead to take different names and to be called according to those things the apostles appointed: feeding the hungry, protecting the wronged, caring for strangers, helping those who are mistreated, providing for orphans, supporting widows, and overseeing virgins. These duties should be distributed among us instead of managing lands and houses.

Hence come battles, and strifes, and daily revilings, and reproaches, and jeers, and on each of the priests names are imposed more suitable for houses of secular men; when it would have been fit to take other names in the place of these, and to be named from those things, from which also the apostles ordained, from the feeding of the hungry, from the protection of the injured, from the care of strangers, from succoring them that are despitefully used, from providing for the orphans, from taking part with the widows, from presiding over the virgins; and these offices should be distributed among us instead of the care of the lands and houses.

These are the resources of the church, these are the treasures that are proper to her and that provide both relief for us and benefit for you—or rather, relief along with benefit for you. For I believe that by the grace of God those who gather here number about one hundred thousand, and if each person gave one loaf to someone among the poor, all would have plenty. But if each gave only one farthing, no one would be poor, and we would not endure so many insults and mockery as a result of our concern about money. For indeed the saying "Sell your goods, and give to the poor, and come and follow me" could be appropriately addressed to the leaders of the church regarding the church's property. For in any other way it is not possible to follow Him as we should, if we are not freed from all coarser and more worldly concerns.

These are the stores of the church, these the treasures that become her, and that afford in great degree both ease to us and profit to you; or rather to you ease with the profit. For I suppose that by the grace of God they that assemble themselves here amount to the number of one hundred thousand; and if each bestowed one loaf to some one of the poor, all would be in plenty; but if one farthing only, no one would be poor; and we should not undergo so many revilings and jeers, in consequence of our care about the money. For indeed the saying, Sell your goods, and give to the poor, and come and follow me, might be seasonably addressed to the prelates of the church with respect to the property of the church. For in any other way it is not possible to follow Him as we ought, not being freed from all grosser and more worldly care.

But now the priests of God spend their time at the vineyard harvest and grain harvest, and at the selling and buying of produce. And whereas those who served the shadow had complete freedom from such matters, even though they were entrusted with a more carnal service, we who are invited to the very innermost shrines of the heavens and who enter into the true holy of holies take upon ourselves the cares of merchants and shopkeepers.

But now the priests of God attend at the vintage and harvest, and at the sale and purchase of the produce; and whereas they that served the shadow had an entire immunity from such matters, although entrusted with a more carnal service; we, who are invited to the very inmost shrines of the heavens, and who enter into the true holy of holies, take upon ourselves the cares of tradesmen and retail dealers.

This leads to serious neglect of the Scriptures, carelessness in prayers, and indifference toward all the other duties, because it is impossible to be divided between these two things with proper dedication. So I pray and beg you that many fountains may spring up for us from every direction, and that your eagerness may be for us the threshing floor and the wine press.

Hence great neglect of the Scriptures, and remissness in prayers, and indifference about all the other duties; for it is not possible to be split into the two things with due zeal. Where I pray and beseech you that many fountains may spring up to us from all quarters, and that your forwardness may be to us the threshing floor and the wine press.

In this way, the poor will be supported more easily, God will be glorified, and you will advance to a greater degree of love for humanity and will enjoy the eternal good things. May God grant that we all attain these things through the grace and love for humanity of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory forever and ever. Amen.

For in this way both the poor will more easily be supported, and God will be glorified, and you will advance unto a greater degree of love to mankind, and will enjoy the good things eternal; unto which God grant we may all attain, by the grace and love towards man of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory world without end. Amen.