A Collection of Letters — Letter 52 — To Philip the Presbyter and Monk

From the same author, from the second letter to the same Philip, presbyter and monk, concerning the formation of humanity, and that the monastic habit frees one from previous sins.

Letter 52

From the same author, from the second letter to the same Philip, presbyter and monk, concerning the formation of humanity, and that the monastic habit frees one from previous sins.

OF THE SAME FROM THE 2nd LETTER TO THE SAME PHILIP THE PRESBYTER AND MONK ABOUT THE FORMATION OF MAN, AND THAT THE MONASTIC HABIT FREES FROM PREVIOUS SINS.

And now I turn to the statement made by your religiousness, that one of those who live an ascetic life of philosophical labor came and presented himself for ordination so that he might serve as a priest to God. But afterwards he remembered his earlier life and the sins he had committed in his youth and throughout the rest of his life. Having learned that the canon requires blamelessness, he sought to exclude himself from the priestly ministry, in a way renouncing ordination to satisfy the canon. How is this acceptable? Tell me, how is this anything but the result of false modesty? You write that this man has lived both earnestly and according to the rules of philosophy and, to use Scripture's language, watches over himself. If the facts of that great sin which bars one from the priesthood or from ministry had happened after his profession of monastic life, then there would have been reason for modesty to play its part. But when the facts of the sin happened first and enrollment in philosophy followed, how is it right to feel fear where no fear exists? We believe, not without the divine Spirit, that the holy habit of monastic life carries forgiveness of sins and strips off the old man "who is corrupted in the lusts of error" and puts on "the new man who was created in God, in righteousness and sanctity of truth," as the wise Paul somewhere wrote. I offer, though I am addressing those who know, in confirmation of what has been stated, the vision which that heavenly man, the great Antony, saw. What does the man who told the story of his life say—the divine Athanasius who is among the high priests? "When he was about to eat and had risen to pray at the ninth hour, he felt his consciousness lifted up, and (wonderful to relate!) he felt himself standing and seeing himself as if he had been taken outside himself, and as if he were being led into the air by some men. Afterwards some grievous and cruel men standing in the air sought to prevent him from passing. When the conductors opposed them, these demanded an account to know if he were liable to them. But when they sought to make an account from his birth, those who were leading Antony prevented it, saying to these: 'What happened from his birth the Lord has wiped out; but you may inquire into the time since he became a monk and made profession to God.' Then when they made charges and failed to convict, the road was made free and unimpeded before him. And immediately he saw himself standing, as if he had come to himself, and he was again wholly Antony." Guided therefore by this divine command, I have answered the present question, and I affirm and say with confidence that that modest man must retain the priestly ministry. By his very scrupulousness and carefulness he has conferred a great benefit upon us, and by this wise and modest question has restrained with apostolic salt those who gape for priestly offices and run after ordinations like the pomp and honors of the world, those whose minds are fixed on pride or on visions of earthly things, and who treat as of no account the judgments we shall receive for these things when the day of judgment arrives—which will assuredly come and is spoken of by everyone's mouth but is looked for by few as it should be.

And now I turn to the statement made by your religiousness, that one of those who live an ascetic life of philosophic labour, after he had come and presented himself for ordination in order that he might officiate as a priest to God, having afterwards come to remember his life, and the sins that he had committed in his boyhood, and all the rest of his life, and having learned that the canon requires blamelessness, sought to range himself outside the priestly ministry, and in a way renounce ordination, and satisfy the canon. How is this endurable? tell me; and how is it anything but a result of false modesty? You write that this man has lived both with earnestness and according to the ordinances of philosophy, and, to speak in the language of Scripture, looks to himself. If the facts of that great sin which cuts off from the priesthood or from the ministry had happened after the profession of monastic life, then there would have been reason for modesty to play its part. But, where the facts of the sin happened firsthand the enrolling in philosophy followed, how is it right to feel fear where no fear is? We believe, not without the divine Spirit, that the holy habit of the monastic life carries forgiveness of sins, and strips off the old man 'who is corrupted in the lusts of error', and puts on 'the new man who was created in God, in righteousness and sanctity of truth', as the wise Paul somewhere said in writing. I adduce, although I am addressing those who know, in confirmation of what has been stated, the vision which that heavenly man the great Antony saw. What in fact does the man who told the story of his life say, the divine Athanasius who is among the high-priests? «When he was about to eat, and had risen to pray at the 9th hour, he felt his consciousness lifted up, and (wonderful to relate!) he felt himself standing and seeing himself, as if he had been taken outside him, and as if he were being led into the air by some men, and afterwards some grievous and cruel men standing in the air and seeking to prevent him from passing. And, when the conductors opposed, these required an account to know if he were not liable to them; but, when they sought to make an account from his birth, those who were leading Antony prevented it, saying to these: 'What happened from his birth the Lord has wiped out; but you may inquire into the time since he became a monk and made profession to God'. Then upon their making charges and failing to convict, the road was made free and unimpeded before him. And immediately he saw himself standing, as if he had come to himself, and that he was again wholly Antony». Guided therefore by this divine command, I have answered the present question; and I affirm and say with confidence that that modest man must retain the priestly ministry, since with his very scrupulousness and carefulness he has conferred a great benefit upon us, and by the wise and modest question has astringed with apostolic salt those who gape for priestly offices, and fun after ordinations, like the pomp and honours of the world, and those whose minds are fixed on pride or on visions of things here, and who treat as of no account the judgments which we shall receive for these things, when the day of judgment arrives, which will assuredly come, and is spoken of by every one's mouth, but is looked for by few as it should be looked for.


A Collection of Letters — Letters 50–51

Of the same, from the letter to Dioscorus, bishop of Alexandria; And this again the holy Severus states in the letter to Amantius the chamberlain, in reference to Epiphanius metropolitan of Tyre: “Even if he repents, I cannot receive him, lest the church be…

Letter 50

Of the same, from the letter to Dioscorus, bishop of Alexandria.

OF THE SAME FROM THE LETTER TO DIOSCORUS BISHOP OF ALEXANDRIA.

But I cannot agree to the proposals that come from your reverence, nor is it reasonable for me to pass judgment on what the other party has written as if the matter were certain, even if it were an angel saying these things: for how can I confirm words without witnesses and without verification while we are separated by distance?

But neither can I consent to the proposals that come from your religiousness, nor is it reasonable for me to form a judgment upon the things written by the other party as if something certain were in question, even if it were an angel who says these things: for can I ratify words without witnesses and without verification while we are at a distance?

Letter 51

And this again the holy Severus states in the letter to Amantius the chamberlain, in reference to Epiphanius metropolitan of Tyre: "Even if he repents, I cannot receive him, lest the church be torn apart since he has wounded the feelings of many." For he said this:

AND THIS AGAIN THE HOLY SEVERUS STATES IN THE LETTER TO AMANTIUS THE CHAMBERLAIN, IN REFERENCE TO EPIPHANIUS METROPOLITAN OF TYRE, «Even if he repents, I cannot receive him, lest the church be rent asunder in that he has wounded the feelings of many»; FOR HE SAID THUS:

I have now decided it is necessary to write this brief letter and inform you that the good and gentle Epiphanius of the city of Tyre has set himself against my great weakness and has become an example to others to break away. He has also wounded the hearts of all the believers, as if I, who confess the right faith, were attacking that impious man who exalts himself both against the divine commands and against church order. As a result, even if I wanted to, I am no longer permitted to receive him in communion, even if he repents, since everyone's conscience has already been wounded because of him.

Now therefore I have thought it necessary to write this present short letter and inform you that the good and gentle Epiphanius of the city of the Tyrians exalted himself against my great weakness, and he became an example to others to secede; but he has also wounded the hearts of all the believers, as if I, who confess the right faith, were hurling myself against that impious man, who exalts himself both against the divine commands and against church order; so that, if I wish, it is no longer permissible for me to receive him in communion, even if he repents, since every man's conscience has already been wounded because of him.


A Collection of Letters — Letter 49 — To Dioscorus Patriarch of Alexandria

Of the same from the letter to Dioscorus, Patriarch of Alexandria. Written 516–7.

Letter 49

Of the same from the letter to Dioscorus, Patriarch of Alexandria.

OF THE SAME FROM THE LETTER TO DIOSCORUS PATRIARCH OF ALEXANDRIA.

But perhaps it is good to say, both to our own people and to all outsiders, that if the time for making concessions calls us to reach someone who is separated and to win him over, I prescribe a formula that does not exceed what is right but stays in the middle of the king's highway. This formula anathematizes by name the things done at Chalcedon against the orthodox faith and those who fought for this, as well as the wicked Tome of Leo, who was head of the church of the Romans, and those who call our one Lord and God Jesus Christ two physeis after the divine and ineffable union. There must also be expressly joined with these things the right confession contained in the edict of Zeno of pious memory, for the rejection of the wicked synod at Chalcedon. If the things blasphemously and unlawfully done at that synod, and the polluted Tome of Leo, and those who after the union divide the one Christ into a duality of physeis are not anathematized—even though the edict or Henotikon is accepted as a rejection of these things—I do not consider this sufficient for persuasion, as was also declared in the proceedings held among you.

But perhaps it is good to say, both to our people and to all strangers, that, if the time of concession call, to catch one who is separated and to gain him, I prescribe a formula that does not exceed what is right, but goes in the middle of the king's highway, a formula which anathematizes by name the things done at Chalcedon against the orthodox faith, and against those who contended on behalf of this, and the wicked Tome of Leo, who became chief of the church of the Romans, and those who call our one Lord and God Jesus Christ two natures after the divine and ineffable union, there being also expressly joined with these things the right confession contained in the edict of Zeno of pious ending, for the rejection of the wicked synod at Chalcedon. If the things blasphemously and unlawfully done at that synod, and the polluted Tome of Leo, and those who after the union divide the one Christ into a duality of natures, are not anathematized, though the edict or Henotikon is taken as a rejection of these things, I do not consider this sufficient for persuasion, as was also declared in the proceedings held among you.


A Collection of Letters — Letter 48 — To Hippocrates

For the holy Severus said in a letter to Hippocrates. Written 516–7.

Letter 48

For the holy Severus said in a letter to Hippocrates.

FOR THE HOLY SEVERUS SAID IN A LETTER TO HIPPOCRATES.

I therefore declare this to all who confess the right faith, according to the apostolic command, before God and Christ the Son, who will judge the living and the dead at his appearing and in his kingdom: I have believed even now that I have stood and do stand as a mediator between the holy church of the city of Alexander and that of the city of Antiochus. I hold the right hand of each of them, and I will hold inseparably to the confessions in which both have been united, even if I pass beyond the pillars of Hercules or to the end of the inhabited world.

This therefore I testify to all who confess the right faith according to the apostolic command, before God and Christ the Son, who shall judge living and dead at his appearance and in his kingdom, that for my part I even now also have believed that I have stood and stand as a mediator between the holy church of Alexander's city and that of the city of Antiochus, holding the right hand of each of them, and I will hold inseparably to the confessions in which both have been united, although I pass beyond the bounds of Gades or of the end of the inhabited earth.


A Collection of Letters — Letter 47 — To Hippocrates

From the same author, from another letter to the same Hippocrates, which begins with the words “That which brings your wisdom.”. Written 516–7.

Letter 47

From the same author, from another letter to the same Hippocrates, which begins with the words "That which brings your wisdom."

OF THE SAME FROM ANOTHER LETTER TO THE SAME HIPPOCRATES, THE BEGINNING OF WHICH IS, «That which brings your wisdom».

Keep this firmly and clearly in your mind: no one will be in communion with us, nor will we agree to exchange letters with anyone who at the same time accepts the wicked synod at Chalcedon contrary to the law, and does not anathematize the Tome of Leo. However, if some concession is necessary, I will stay within the guidelines set by holy Timothy, considering the common good of a union of the holy churches, and requiring an open anathema of the things done at Chalcedon against the orthodox faith, and of the wicked Tome of Leo, and of those who speak of two physeis after the union, and their operations and properties. But if these things are overturned, no argument or persuasion will convince me to agree to this wickedness. For I say like Paul, "It is better for me to die than that anyone should make my boasting empty; for if I preach this way, I have no reason to boast, for necessity is laid upon me, and woe to me if I do not preach this way, since this is what I have received."

But this you may keep firmly and fixedly in your mind, that no one shall be our fellow-communicant, nor will we consent to greet by letter any man who at the same time receives the wicked synod at Chalcedon contrary to the law, and does not anathematize the Tome of Leo. But, if any concession is necessary, I will stand within the ordinances of the holy Timothy, considering the general benefit of a union of the holy churches, and demanding an open anathema of the things done at Chalcedon against the orthodox faith, and of the wicked Tome of Leo, and of those who speak of two natures after the union, and the operations of these and their properties. But, if these things are upset, no argument nor inducement shall persuade me to assent to the wickedness. For I say like Paul, «It is better for me to die, than that anyone should make my boasting vain: for, if I so preach, I have no cause of boasting; for necessity is laid upon me, and woe to me unless I so preach, since so I have received».


A Collection of Letters — Letter 46 — To Hippocrates the Scholastic

From the works of Holy Severus, from the letter to Hippocrates the Scholastic, which begins, “I have not learned to jest at divine things as on a stage.”. Written 516–7.

Letter 46

From the works of Holy Severus, from the letter to Hippocrates the Scholastic, which begins, "I have not learned to jest at divine things as on a stage."

OF THE HOLY SEVERUS, FROM THE LETTER TO HIPPOCRATES THE SCHOLASTIC, WHICH BEGINS, «I have not learned to jest at divine things as on a stage ».

For the holy Cyril also, after he had written a critical book against Theodore and Diodorus, the teachers of Nestorius's impiety (and he argues against them and says, "You have surpassed the blasphemous speech of the pagans, you have shown the impieties of Jewish arrogance to be nothing"), sent a message by letter to Proclus of saintly memory, bishop of Constantinople, not to remove the names of such men from the sacred diptychs, because those in the East held fast to the memory of these men.

For the holy Cyril also, after he had written a derisive book against Theodore and Diodorus, the teachers of the impiety of Nestorius (and he contends against them and says, «You have surpassed the open-mouthedness of the heathen, you have shown the impieties of Jewish pride to be nothing»), sent a message by letter to Proclus of saintly memory bishop of Constantinople not to remove the name of such men from the sacred diptychs, because those of the East clung to the memory of this man.

From the holy Severus, from the letter to Hippocrates, which begins, "Not to jest as on a stage."

Of the holy Severus, from the letter to Hippocrates, which begins, «Not to jest as on a stage».

For I believe that we face equal danger if we reduce strictness when dealing with strict and perfect men, and if we show untimely strictness toward men who need a dispensation and lawful concession, and give our neighbor turbid dregs to drink, as it is written.

For I believe that we incur equal danger if we abate anything from strictness in the case of strict and perfect men, and if we show untimely strictness in the case of men who need a dispensation and lawful concession, and give our neighbour, as it is written, turbid dregs to drink.

From the same author, from the letter to Hippocrates the scholar, which begins, "I have not learned to mock divine things as if on a stage."

Of the same from the letter to Hippocrates the scholastic, which begins, «I have not learned to jest at divine things as on a stage».

Being pricked by these words and divine laws as if by goads, and feeling fear and trembling, I brought up the matter of those from Cappadocia who wish to be united to us with the saintly Dioscorus, bishop of Alexandria and our fellow minister. I also consulted with your learning, revealing to you all my affairs from the beginning and hiding nothing at all. And I do not know how it is that you have set aside the letters and consultations that have passed since that time, and now tell us to take no account of those from Cappadocia, calling it a waste country, and to treat the divine laws that I have just mentioned with contempt.

In the first place, the same account is due to one soul and to many. Next, how can we call the two Cappadocias and Armenia waste places? But in this you thought or spoke rather like the natives of the country—allow me with your pardon to say so—and not truly. For it is the habit of the Alexandrians to think that the sun rises for them only, and that the lamp burns toward them only, so that they even jokingly call outside cities "lampless." If for the purpose of right judgments it is possible to weigh the numbers of a people like weights that are distinguished by the inclinations of the scale of a balance, the inhabitants of all these countries will produce no less than the whole city of the Alexandrians.

But you say that in the case of men who make right requests we should have regard to our understanding. But in this also we have a better principle, as we showed in what we said a little before, having countless other texts of the God-inspired Scriptures also which command us that those who are strong should bear the infirmities of those who are weak, and that we should not have regard to our own affairs but to the interest of others, and texts that agree with those.

And while I was writing and speaking these things, I showed caution in every point and did not trust to myself in everything, but awaited the assent of the saintly Dioscorus my fellow minister who shares my opinions. I took Eleusinius and Proclus, the God-loving bishops from Cappadocia, as my fellow communicants from the beginning and now hold them as such, since they have anathematized the synod of Chalcedon by many signatures in no small number of tomes. But Soteric, who offered us a covenant of union and conjunction, I passed over, for I did not wish to call him our fellow communicant by letter—how could I so call one who is not bound in communion? Therefore also Asterius, his God-loving brother and bishop of Nyssa, is ready to leave the see.

So for our part we held to our own principles and did not give any man, to speak in the words of Scripture, cause of offense. For we know positively and we say openly that you have formed an execrable purpose that is not pleasing to God. And I beg your learning not to bestow this foolish favor on me at all and hide what was written by me, but make it known, if possible, to everyone. What sense is there in our promising something difficult on account of an insignificant cause of fear and in fact taking the opposite course?

Being pricked by these words and divine laws as by goads, and fearing and trembling, I mentioned the matter of those from Cappadocia who wish to be united to us to the saintly Dioscorus bishop of Alexandria and our fellow-minister, and 1 consulted with your learning also, revealing to you all my affairs from the beginning, and hiding nothing whatever; and I do not know how it is that you have thrown over the letters and consultations that have passed since that time, and tell us to take no account of those from Cappadocia the waste country, but to treat the divine laws that I have just mentioned with contempt. In the first place the same account is due to one soul and to many; and next how can we call the two Cappadocias and Armenia waste places? But in this you thought or spoke rather like the natives of the country (allow me with your pardon to say), and not truly. For it is the habit of the Alexandrines to think that the sun rises for them only, and towards them only the lamp burns, so that they even jestingly term outside cities 'lampless'. If for the purpose of right judgments it is possible to weigh the numbers of a people, like weights that are distinguished by the inclinations of the scale of a balance, the inhabitants of all these countries will produce no less than the whole city of the Alexandrines. But you say that in the case of men who make right requests we should have regard to our understanding. But in this also we have a better principle, as we showed in what we said a little before, having countless other texts of the God-inspired Scriptures also which command us, that those that are strong should bear the infirmities of those that are weak, and that we should not have regard to our own affairs but to the interest of others, and texts that agree with those. And, while was writing and speaking these things, I showed caution in every point, and did not trust to myself in everything, but awaited the assent of the saintly Dioscorus my fellow-minister who shares my opinions, and Eleusinius and Proclus the God-loving bishops from Cappadocia I took from the beginning as my fellow-communicants and now hold them as such, since they have anathematized the synod of Chalcedon by many signatures in no small number of tomes: but Soteric who offered us a covenant of union and conjunction I passed over, for I did not wish to term him our fellow-communicant by letter (how could I so term one who is not bound in communion?) Wherefore also Asterius, his God-loving brother, and bishop of Nyssa, is ready to leave the see. So for our part we held to our own principles and did not give any man, to speak in the words of Scripture, cause of offence. For we know positively and we say openly that you have formed an execrable purpose that is not pleasing to God. And I beg your learning not to bestow this foolish favour on me at all, and hide what was written by me, but make it known, if possible, to everyone. What sense is there in our promising something difficult on account of an insignificant cause of fear, and in fact taking the opposite course?

Of the same from the letter to Hippocrates the Alexandrine scholastic, the beginning of which is, "And I have not learned to jest at divine things as on a stage."

Of the same from the letter to Hippocrates the Alexandrine scholastic, the beginning of which is, «And I have not learned to jest at divine things as on a stage».

But as to the edict, I have often told your wisdom what my position is, and it seems pointless that we should keep going over the same things for no reason; for whether you remember or not makes no difference to me. As long as the wicked things done at Chalcedon against the orthodox faith are not condemned by name, no argument can persuade me to act like an interpreter of dreams and explain the text of the edict as though it were a rejection of those unlawful things. (And again he says of the Henotikon.) For it contains only a right confession of faith, though by itself it lacks the healing power that is needed.

But as to the edict I have often said to your wisdom what my position is, and it seems a piece of perversity that we should sing to no purpose about the same things; for whether you remember or do not remember is the same to me. While the things wickedly done at Chalcedon against the orthodox faith are not anathematized by name, no argument can persuade me like an interpreter of dreams to expound and forcibly understand the text of the edict as a rejection of the unlawful things. ( And again he says of the Henotikon.) For it contains a right confession of faith only, though by itself it be destitute of healing for what is required.

Of the same from the same letter.

Of the same from the same letter.

When all the bishops of the East were present at Antioch, they anathematized the synod in writing. We sent a synodical letter to Timothy, the prelate of the royal city. In it, we anathematized what was done at Chalcedon against the orthodox faith, the Jewish Tome of Leo, and those who call our one Lord and God Jesus Christ two natures after the incomprehensible union. Afterward, countless attacks were made against me. The glorious Asterius, the former prefect of the city who held the office called *a secretis*, was even sent after me. But I was not at all frightened or afraid, and I did not yield to the pressure of the times. Though he said, "The kingdom of the Romans is in turmoil because of this," I plainly said, "I am ready to leave the city and resign the see rather than change one stroke of what I wrote from the beginning in the synodical words addressed to Timothy." I did not just say this—I also wrote it down. I expressed myself with freedom in writing to the pious king as well.

And, when all the bishops of the East were present at Antioch, and anathematized the synod in writing, and we addressed a synodical letter to Timothy the prelate of the royal city, we anathematized what was done at Chalcedon against the orthodox faith, and the Jewish Tome of Leo, and those who call our one Lord and God Jesus Christ two natures after the incomprehensible union. And afterwards, when innumerable attacks were made upon me, insomuch that the glorious Asterius, the ex-prefect of the city, who held the office called a secretis, was sent after me, I was not in the least frightened, nor did I fear, nor yield to the time, though he said, «The kingdom of the Romans is in a turmoil on account of this», but I plainly said, «I am ready to leave the city and resign the see, rather than upset one stroke of what I wrote from the beginning in the synodical words addressed to Timothy»: and this I did not say without writing it down, but I expressed myself with freedom in writing to the religious king also.


A Collection of Letters — Letter 45 — To Setoric Bishop of Caesarea in Cappadocia

From the works of the holy Severus, taken from the letter to Setoric, bishop of Caesarea in Cappadocia, which begins, “The God-loving bishop of the city of the Nyssenes.”. Written 516.

Letter 45

From the works of the holy Severus, taken from the letter to Setoric, bishop of Caesarea in Cappadocia, which begins, "The God-loving bishop of the city of the Nyssenes."

OF THE HOLY SEVERUS, FROM THE LETTER TO SETORIC BISHOP OF CAESAREA IN CAPPADOCIA, WHICH BEGINS, «The God-loving bishop of the city of the Nyssenes».

Those who think that our offering is impure because of the names of people who have already died and who fell into heretical beliefs, and whose names have not been removed from the sacred lists, are wrong. Such matters did not affect the offering or orthodoxy of the holy fathers either. Even though Eusebius Pamphili championed the error of Arius, both in word and in deed, the members of the church of Caesarea mentioned his name until the holy Cyril passed through on his way to the city of Ephesus and had this name removed. What shall we say then? That during the entire time Eusebius's name stood in the sacred lists, it contaminated the offering of those who held correct beliefs? And what about when the same holy Cyril of blessed memory wrote to the holy Proclus, who was then bishop of Constantinople, asking him to spare the name of Theodore of Mopsuestia? Theodore was the rotten source of the hateful and rotten beliefs of Nestorius, but Cyril wanted to avoid giving an opportunity to those who wished to disturb the church. Should we think that this caused some pollution and stain of heresy on the offering of the orthodox? Absolutely not. If we investigate this, there is no time when we will find the church to be pure. It is already well known that such things have not and never will cause any harm to the whole fullness of the body of Christ. In fact, we find something similar written in Leviticus, where it deals with the pollution caused to something by a dead body: "And all food that you shall eat on which water shall come, and there fall upon it any of these dead things, it is pollution; and every drink that you shall drink in any vessel is polluted. However, springs of water and pools and cisterns of water shall be pure." What does this teach us? When certain people by themselves, in a church for instance or in one city, or perhaps in monasteries, mention the names of those who are under suspicion and of the dead, they are polluted by the mention, like a small amount of water contained in a vessel when something dead falls into it. But when churches of many provinces and dioceses are held together in one bond of faith and resemble beautiful springs and pools and cisterns of water, the dead thing that has the power to pollute if it falls cannot cause harm. It is overwhelmed by the flow and by the abundance of many streams. I have said these things to show from the God-inspired Scripture and from the bishops, the pastors and upholders of right reason, that trying to observe every detail in such matters is endless, and that this kind of mention does no harm to the beautiful body of the church. But your sanctity should know that we have also informed the saintly Dioscorus, bishop of Alexandria, of the above plan by letter, since we considered his agreement also most necessary.

They are not acting rightly who think that our oblation is not pure on account of the names of those who have already died, and who have fallen into heretical tenets, and have not been removed from the sacred tablets; because in fact such matters did not affect the oblation of orthodoxy of the holy fathers also. Though Eusebius Pamphili contended for the disease of Arius, both in speech and in act, the members of the church of Caesarea mentioned his name, until the holy Cyril passed by, when he was hastening to the city of the Ephesians, and had this name removed. What shall we then say? That throughout the time during which the name of Eusebius stood in the sacred tablets it perturbed the oblation of men who held right opinions? What? When again the same holy Cyril of saintly memory wrote to the holy Proclus bishop of Constantinople at that time to spare the name of Theodore of Mopsuestia, who was the putrid source of the hateful and putrid tenets of Nestorius, in order not to give an opportunity to those who wished to disturb the church, shall we think that thereby some pollution and stain of heresy was inflicted on the oblation of the orthodox? By no means. If we search into this, there is no time at which we shall see the church to be pure. If is already well-known that such things have not and never will cause any injury to the whole fulness of the body of Christ. In fact in Leviticus we find something like this written, where it is dealing with the pollution that is caused to anything by a dead body, as follows: «And all food that ye shall eat on which water shall come, and there fall upon it any of these dead things, it is pollution; and every drink that ye shall drink in any vessel is polluted. However of springs of water and of pools and of cisterns of water they shall be pure». What then is it that is made known to us by this? That, when certain men are by themselves, in a church for instance or in one city, or in monasteries perhaps make mention of the names of those who are under suspicion and of dead men, like the similarly small amount of water contained in a vessel they are polluted by the mention, as if something dead were falling; but, when churches of many provinces and of dioceses are held in one bond of faith, and resemble fair fountains and pools and cisterns of water, the dead thing which has the property of polluting if it fall cannot injure; for it is swamped by the flow, and by the abundance of many streams. I have said these things in order to show from the God-inspired Scripture, and from the bishops, the pastors, the upholders of right reason, that in such matters observance of every point is endless, and that mention of this kind does no injury to the fair body of the church. But your sanctity should know that we have by a letter made the above project known to the saintly Dioscorus also, bishop of Alexandria, since we considered his assent also most necessary.


A Collection of Letters — Letters 43–44 — To Urban the Grammarian

For in matters where we have examples from the fathers, we are not to blame, as the holy Severus teaches in the letter to Theophanes mentioned above; Of the same from the letter to Urban the grammarian, which begins, “When I read the letter of your learning.”.

Letter 43

For in matters where we have examples from the fathers, we are not to blame, as the holy Severus teaches in the letter to Theophanes mentioned above.

For in matters in which we have patristic examples we are not to blame, as the holy Severus teaches in the letter to Theophanes cited above.

But whoever does something that the fathers did acts according to the canons and lawfully, as the holy Severus also teaches in the letter to Theophanes cited above.

But he who does a thing which was done by the fathers, he acts canonically and lawfully, as the holy Severus also teaches, in the letter to Theophanes cited above.

Letter 44

Of the same from the letter to Urban the grammarian, which begins, "When I read the letter of your learning."

OF THE SAME FROM THE LETTER TO URBAN THE GRAMMARIAN, WHICH BEGINS, «When I read the letter of your learning».

When discussing whether to omit names preserved in the sacred tablets, we must carefully compare what sacred Scripture says. It says that when certain things fall into water contained in small vessels, they pollute it, but when they fall into pools, wells, or cisterns containing many streams, they cause no stain or pollution. For the law of the divine Spirit says this: "And every drink that you drink in any vessel shall be polluted, and everything on which anything from a dead body falls is polluted. However, fountains of water and pools and cisterns of water shall be pure." This principle should be observed in the present case as well. If a man separates himself from many people because they are infected with heresy or because they communicate with those who are infected, let him maintain abstention from the dead body with all his power. He should not even mention the name of those who are under suspicion and not genuine, lest it fall and pollute the purity of communion. But if the holding of the orthodox faith and an anathema of every heresy reigns in the churches—and whole countries and provinces and populous churches confess one uncorrupted confession—then names which are thought to pollute are inundated by the multitude of streams. It is good that no particle of a dead body should be introduced even into a large quantity of water. But if by chance it does happen to be introduced, it is cleansed by the quantity of streams and swamped by the quantity of cleansing. We find that in fact the holy fathers who in former times upheld the right word managed these things in this way. Show us from the compositions of the doctors of the church that after so large a number had found fault with the faith of the 318 at Ariminum, any question was raised about the names of those who had died. And, not to make the letter tedious by using many words, let us pass on in mind to times that are near and not far removed. We find that the holy Timothy, who underwent long exiles, united with everyone in the Encyclical and communicated with Paul, bishop of the city of the Ephesians, and with Peter who had become prelate of this great Christ-loving city of Antioch, while names under suspicion were preserved in the sacred tablets. And the holy Cyril, when he united with the Easterns after the deprivation of Nestorius, when many bishops had died and had departed under the stain of the Nestorian heresy, made no inquiry about names. If therefore those who set great store by strictness in respect of such names say that the oblation is not pure, let them know that their strictness also draws its origin and existence from such communion and descends from that source as from a root. For the saintly Timothy, as we have said, consented to hold communion with those of like opinions in company with such names, and his grandsons are those who now with a boastful front loudly proclaim, "You shall not approach me because I am pure." And we say this in addition: some of the bishops in the cities of the Easterns set even this also straight and ceased to mention all such names. For others found it impossible to set this same thing straight, and it was not right for them to enter into wrangles over such a reason and set themselves in array against the enthusiasm of the people of the cities, in order that they might suffer shipwreck in the most essential things.

In dealing with abstentions with regard to names preserved in the sacred tablets we must in fitness duly compare the things of which the sacred Scripture said that, when they fall into water that is contained in small vessels, they pollute it, but, when into pools or wells or cisterns containing many streams, they cause no stain or pollution. For the law of the divine Spirit said thus: «And every drink that ye shall drink in any vessel shall be polluted; and everything on which anything from a dead body falls is polluted. However fountains of water and pools and cisterns of water shall be pure». This principle then ought to be observed in the present case also. If a man separates from many on the ground that they are infected with heresy, or that they communicate with those who are infected, let him with all his power maintain abstention from the dead body, and not mention even the name of those who are under suspicion and not genuine, lest it fall and pollute the purity of the communion. But, if the holding of the orthodox faith, and an anathema of every heresy reigns in the churches, and whole countries and provinces, and populous churches, confess one uncorrupted confession, then names which are thought to pollute are inundated by the multitude of streams. It is good that no particle of a dead body should be introduced even into a large quantity of water; but if perchance it in fact happen to be introduced, it is cleansed by the quantity of streams, and swamped by the quantity of cleansing. We find that in fact the holy fathers also who were in former times upholders of the right word managed these things in this way. Show us from the compositions of the doctors of the church that, after so large a number had found fault with the faith of the 318 at Ariminus [sic], any question was raised about the names of those who had died. And, not to make the letter tedious by using many words, let us pass on in mind to times that are near and not far removed. We find that the holy Timothy, he who underwent long exiles, united with everyone in the Encyclical, and communicated with Paul bishop of the city of the Ephesians, and Peter who had become prelate of this great Christ-loving city of Antioch, while names under suspicion were preserved in the sacred tablets; and the holy Cyril, when he united with the Easterns after the deprivation of Nestorius, when many bishops had died, and had departed under the stain of the Nestorian heresy, made no inquiry about names. If therefore those who set great store by strictness in respect of such names say that the oblation is not pure, let them know that their strictness also draws its origin and existence from such communion, and descends from that source as from a root. For the saintly Timothy, as we have said, consented to hold communion with those of like opinions in company with such names, he whose grandsons they are who now with a boastful front loudly proclaim, «You shall not approach me because I am pure». And this we say superfluously, that some of the bishops in the cities of the Easterns set even this also straight, and ceased to mention all such names: for others found it impossible to set this same thing straight; and it was not right for such a reason for them to enter on wrangles, and set themselves in array against the enthusiasm of the people of the cities, in order that they might suffer shipwreck in the most essential things.


A Collection of Letters — Letter 42 — To Theophanes the Scholastic

Of the same from the letter to Theophanes the scholastic. Written 516–7.

Letter 42

Of the same from the letter to Theophanes the scholastic.

OF THE SAME FROM THE LETTER TO THEOPHANES THE SCHOLASTIC.

For the fact that being without dispensation destroys every action is testified also by the text of Proverbs which says: "They that have not dispensation fall like leaves."

For that to be devoid of dispensation is a subversal of every action is testified also by the text of Proverbs which says thus: «They that have not dispensation fall like leaves».

Of the same, from the same letter.

Of the same, from the same letter.

We see that the champion of truth, Timothy archbishop of Alexandria, a man of blessed and deeply beloved memory, also walks the same path. Through his Encyclical letter, he entered into communion with Paul of Ephesus, Peter of Antioch, and Anastasius of Jerusalem—and, in short, with all who signed the Encyclical letter. He did not demand that anyone reject particular names, but set only one goal before himself: to uproot the heresy from its foundations, to show that it had been unanimously condemned, and to free the right confession from every evil form of heresy and from the fog that rises from it. For all these men, being like Moses faithful servants in all God's house, were instructed by the sacred text of Proverbs, which wisely teaches and says, "He that does not manage his house rightly inherits winds."

We see that the champion of the truth also, the man of blessed and very beloved memory, Timothy archbishop of Alexandria, walks in the same paths, and through the Encyclical letter communicated with Paul of Ephesus and Peter of Antioch, and Anastasius of Jerusalem, and, to put it simply, with all who signed the Encyclical letter, and that he did not demand any rejection of names, but set one purpose only before himself, to root out the heresy from the foundations, and to show that it had been unanimously condemned, and to free the right confession from every evil species of heresy, and from the mist that arises therefrom. For all those, inasmuch as they were like Moses faithful servants in all God's house, were instructed in the sacred text of Proverbs which wisely teaches and says, «He that dispenseth not his house aright inheriteth winds».


A Collection of Letters — Letter 41 — To Musonius Bishop of Meloe in Isauria

From the letter to Musonius, bishop of Meloe in Isauria, the beginning of which is, “When I came to the high-priestly throne.”. Written 516–7.

Letter 41

From the letter to Musonius, bishop of Meloe in Isauria, the beginning of which is, "When I came to the high-priestly throne."

FROM THE LETTER TO MUSONIUS BISHOP OF MELOE IN ISAURIA, THE BEGINNING OF WHICH is, «When I came to the high-priestly throne ».

And understand this: when it came to general unions, the fathers did not want to investigate strict adherence to rules concerning names. Many of the 318 who gathered at Nicaea, as church histories tell us, were present at the synod at Ariminum and at Sardica; and yet, though the doctrines set forth there were not approved, no one argued about names. In the same way, the synod of bishops at Nicaea in Thrace, which declared that the Father is like the Son but not co-essential (homoousios), was rightly rejected; and yet there was no question about names at that time. It would take too long to recount the other rejected synods—the one at Sirmium, the one at Lampsacus, the one at Rome, the one at Zelo, the one at your Seleucia—all of which the synod of the 150 passed over in silence as if it had forgotten them, not introducing among us any empty talk or unnecessary inquiry about names, but only asserting the divinity of the Holy Spirit together with the Father and the Son, and explaining the intention of the 318. And when holy Cyril with the holy synod at Ephesus accomplished the deposition of the wicked Nestorius, the bishops of the East, though they had contended for his rejected teachings, later agreed to the deposition of that wolf and the rejection of those hateful doctrines; and there was never any discussion about names, even though how many do you think had died in the meantime who had contended for the wickedness of Nestorius? For these things, as I have said, have no place in general unions; instead they remained unexamined, since many are in fact passed over at councils, even though they have often been involved in impious opinions. Since now there is hope for some common agreement among the churches, do not lower your mind to untimely hair-splitting. Just as there is a time to speak and a time to be silent, so there is a time both to inquire into a matter of this kind and not to inquire. Keep these things in mind and be rightly disposed, and pay no attention to men who cling to division and find fault with everything in the same way, whom sacred Scripture calls backbiters and enemies of the common peace, and Christ the God of peace.

And know this, that, where general unions were concerned, the fathers did not wish to inquire into the observance of the strict rule with regard to names. Many of the 318 who assembled at Nicaea, as ecclesiastical histories relate, were present at the synod at Ariminus [ sic] and at Sardica; and still, though the doctrines there laid down were not approved, no one contended about names. And in the same way at Nicaea in Thrace also the synod of bishops which pronounced that the Father is like the Son, not co-essential, was rightly rejected; and yet there was no question about names at that time. It is a long matter to recount the other rejected synods, that at Sirmium, that at Lampsacus, that at Rome, that at Zelo, that at your Seleucia, all of which the synod of the 150 caused to be passed over in silence as if it had forgotten them, not introducing among us any vain talk or superfluous inquiry about names, but only asserting the divinity of the Holy Spirit together with the Father and the Son, and explaining the intention of the 318. And, when the holy Cyril with the holy synod at Ephesus accomplished the deprivation of the evil Nestorius, the bishops of the East, though they contended for his rejected tenets, afterwards agreed to the deprivation of that wolf and the rejections of the hateful tenets; and there was never any discussion about names, although how many do you think had died in the meanwhile, who contended for the wickedness of Nestorius? For these things, as I have said, general unions have no room; but they remained without examination; since many are in fact passed over at councils, although they have often been involved in impious opinions. Since then at the present time some common agreement among the churches is hoped for, do not lower your mind to untimely hair-splitting. As there is a time to speak and a time to be silent, so there is a time both to inquire into a matter of this kind and not to inquire. Bear these things in mind and be rightly disposed, and have no regard to men who cleave to division, and find fault with everything in the same way, whom the sacred Scripture calls backbiters and enemies of the common peace, and Christ the God of peace.