A Collection of Letters — Letter 46 — To Hippocrates the Scholastic

From the works of Holy Severus, from the letter to Hippocrates the Scholastic, which begins, “I have not learned to jest at divine things as on a stage.”. Written 516–7.

Letter 46

From the works of Holy Severus, from the letter to Hippocrates the Scholastic, which begins, "I have not learned to jest at divine things as on a stage."

OF THE HOLY SEVERUS, FROM THE LETTER TO HIPPOCRATES THE SCHOLASTIC, WHICH BEGINS, «I have not learned to jest at divine things as on a stage ».

For the holy Cyril also, after he had written a critical book against Theodore and Diodorus, the teachers of Nestorius's impiety (and he argues against them and says, "You have surpassed the blasphemous speech of the pagans, you have shown the impieties of Jewish arrogance to be nothing"), sent a message by letter to Proclus of saintly memory, bishop of Constantinople, not to remove the names of such men from the sacred diptychs, because those in the East held fast to the memory of these men.

For the holy Cyril also, after he had written a derisive book against Theodore and Diodorus, the teachers of the impiety of Nestorius (and he contends against them and says, «You have surpassed the open-mouthedness of the heathen, you have shown the impieties of Jewish pride to be nothing»), sent a message by letter to Proclus of saintly memory bishop of Constantinople not to remove the name of such men from the sacred diptychs, because those of the East clung to the memory of this man.

From the holy Severus, from the letter to Hippocrates, which begins, "Not to jest as on a stage."

Of the holy Severus, from the letter to Hippocrates, which begins, «Not to jest as on a stage».

For I believe that we face equal danger if we reduce strictness when dealing with strict and perfect men, and if we show untimely strictness toward men who need a dispensation and lawful concession, and give our neighbor turbid dregs to drink, as it is written.

For I believe that we incur equal danger if we abate anything from strictness in the case of strict and perfect men, and if we show untimely strictness in the case of men who need a dispensation and lawful concession, and give our neighbour, as it is written, turbid dregs to drink.

From the same author, from the letter to Hippocrates the scholar, which begins, "I have not learned to mock divine things as if on a stage."

Of the same from the letter to Hippocrates the scholastic, which begins, «I have not learned to jest at divine things as on a stage».

Being pricked by these words and divine laws as if by goads, and feeling fear and trembling, I brought up the matter of those from Cappadocia who wish to be united to us with the saintly Dioscorus, bishop of Alexandria and our fellow minister. I also consulted with your learning, revealing to you all my affairs from the beginning and hiding nothing at all. And I do not know how it is that you have set aside the letters and consultations that have passed since that time, and now tell us to take no account of those from Cappadocia, calling it a waste country, and to treat the divine laws that I have just mentioned with contempt.

In the first place, the same account is due to one soul and to many. Next, how can we call the two Cappadocias and Armenia waste places? But in this you thought or spoke rather like the natives of the country—allow me with your pardon to say so—and not truly. For it is the habit of the Alexandrians to think that the sun rises for them only, and that the lamp burns toward them only, so that they even jokingly call outside cities "lampless." If for the purpose of right judgments it is possible to weigh the numbers of a people like weights that are distinguished by the inclinations of the scale of a balance, the inhabitants of all these countries will produce no less than the whole city of the Alexandrians.

But you say that in the case of men who make right requests we should have regard to our understanding. But in this also we have a better principle, as we showed in what we said a little before, having countless other texts of the God-inspired Scriptures also which command us that those who are strong should bear the infirmities of those who are weak, and that we should not have regard to our own affairs but to the interest of others, and texts that agree with those.

And while I was writing and speaking these things, I showed caution in every point and did not trust to myself in everything, but awaited the assent of the saintly Dioscorus my fellow minister who shares my opinions. I took Eleusinius and Proclus, the God-loving bishops from Cappadocia, as my fellow communicants from the beginning and now hold them as such, since they have anathematized the synod of Chalcedon by many signatures in no small number of tomes. But Soteric, who offered us a covenant of union and conjunction, I passed over, for I did not wish to call him our fellow communicant by letter—how could I so call one who is not bound in communion? Therefore also Asterius, his God-loving brother and bishop of Nyssa, is ready to leave the see.

So for our part we held to our own principles and did not give any man, to speak in the words of Scripture, cause of offense. For we know positively and we say openly that you have formed an execrable purpose that is not pleasing to God. And I beg your learning not to bestow this foolish favor on me at all and hide what was written by me, but make it known, if possible, to everyone. What sense is there in our promising something difficult on account of an insignificant cause of fear and in fact taking the opposite course?

Being pricked by these words and divine laws as by goads, and fearing and trembling, I mentioned the matter of those from Cappadocia who wish to be united to us to the saintly Dioscorus bishop of Alexandria and our fellow-minister, and 1 consulted with your learning also, revealing to you all my affairs from the beginning, and hiding nothing whatever; and I do not know how it is that you have thrown over the letters and consultations that have passed since that time, and tell us to take no account of those from Cappadocia the waste country, but to treat the divine laws that I have just mentioned with contempt. In the first place the same account is due to one soul and to many; and next how can we call the two Cappadocias and Armenia waste places? But in this you thought or spoke rather like the natives of the country (allow me with your pardon to say), and not truly. For it is the habit of the Alexandrines to think that the sun rises for them only, and towards them only the lamp burns, so that they even jestingly term outside cities 'lampless'. If for the purpose of right judgments it is possible to weigh the numbers of a people, like weights that are distinguished by the inclinations of the scale of a balance, the inhabitants of all these countries will produce no less than the whole city of the Alexandrines. But you say that in the case of men who make right requests we should have regard to our understanding. But in this also we have a better principle, as we showed in what we said a little before, having countless other texts of the God-inspired Scriptures also which command us, that those that are strong should bear the infirmities of those that are weak, and that we should not have regard to our own affairs but to the interest of others, and texts that agree with those. And, while was writing and speaking these things, I showed caution in every point, and did not trust to myself in everything, but awaited the assent of the saintly Dioscorus my fellow-minister who shares my opinions, and Eleusinius and Proclus the God-loving bishops from Cappadocia I took from the beginning as my fellow-communicants and now hold them as such, since they have anathematized the synod of Chalcedon by many signatures in no small number of tomes: but Soteric who offered us a covenant of union and conjunction I passed over, for I did not wish to term him our fellow-communicant by letter (how could I so term one who is not bound in communion?) Wherefore also Asterius, his God-loving brother, and bishop of Nyssa, is ready to leave the see. So for our part we held to our own principles and did not give any man, to speak in the words of Scripture, cause of offence. For we know positively and we say openly that you have formed an execrable purpose that is not pleasing to God. And I beg your learning not to bestow this foolish favour on me at all, and hide what was written by me, but make it known, if possible, to everyone. What sense is there in our promising something difficult on account of an insignificant cause of fear, and in fact taking the opposite course?

Of the same from the letter to Hippocrates the Alexandrine scholastic, the beginning of which is, "And I have not learned to jest at divine things as on a stage."

Of the same from the letter to Hippocrates the Alexandrine scholastic, the beginning of which is, «And I have not learned to jest at divine things as on a stage».

But as to the edict, I have often told your wisdom what my position is, and it seems pointless that we should keep going over the same things for no reason; for whether you remember or not makes no difference to me. As long as the wicked things done at Chalcedon against the orthodox faith are not condemned by name, no argument can persuade me to act like an interpreter of dreams and explain the text of the edict as though it were a rejection of those unlawful things. (And again he says of the Henotikon.) For it contains only a right confession of faith, though by itself it lacks the healing power that is needed.

But as to the edict I have often said to your wisdom what my position is, and it seems a piece of perversity that we should sing to no purpose about the same things; for whether you remember or do not remember is the same to me. While the things wickedly done at Chalcedon against the orthodox faith are not anathematized by name, no argument can persuade me like an interpreter of dreams to expound and forcibly understand the text of the edict as a rejection of the unlawful things. ( And again he says of the Henotikon.) For it contains a right confession of faith only, though by itself it be destitute of healing for what is required.

Of the same from the same letter.

Of the same from the same letter.

When all the bishops of the East were present at Antioch, they anathematized the synod in writing. We sent a synodical letter to Timothy, the prelate of the royal city. In it, we anathematized what was done at Chalcedon against the orthodox faith, the Jewish Tome of Leo, and those who call our one Lord and God Jesus Christ two natures after the incomprehensible union. Afterward, countless attacks were made against me. The glorious Asterius, the former prefect of the city who held the office called *a secretis*, was even sent after me. But I was not at all frightened or afraid, and I did not yield to the pressure of the times. Though he said, "The kingdom of the Romans is in turmoil because of this," I plainly said, "I am ready to leave the city and resign the see rather than change one stroke of what I wrote from the beginning in the synodical words addressed to Timothy." I did not just say this—I also wrote it down. I expressed myself with freedom in writing to the pious king as well.

And, when all the bishops of the East were present at Antioch, and anathematized the synod in writing, and we addressed a synodical letter to Timothy the prelate of the royal city, we anathematized what was done at Chalcedon against the orthodox faith, and the Jewish Tome of Leo, and those who call our one Lord and God Jesus Christ two natures after the incomprehensible union. And afterwards, when innumerable attacks were made upon me, insomuch that the glorious Asterius, the ex-prefect of the city, who held the office called a secretis, was sent after me, I was not in the least frightened, nor did I fear, nor yield to the time, though he said, «The kingdom of the Romans is in a turmoil on account of this», but I plainly said, «I am ready to leave the city and resign the see, rather than upset one stroke of what I wrote from the beginning in the synodical words addressed to Timothy»: and this I did not say without writing it down, but I expressed myself with freedom in writing to the religious king also.