A Collection of Letters — Letter 41 — To Musonius Bishop of Meloe in Isauria

From the letter to Musonius, bishop of Meloe in Isauria, the beginning of which is, “When I came to the high-priestly throne.”. Written 516–7.

Letter 41

From the letter to Musonius, bishop of Meloe in Isauria, the beginning of which is, "When I came to the high-priestly throne."

FROM THE LETTER TO MUSONIUS BISHOP OF MELOE IN ISAURIA, THE BEGINNING OF WHICH is, «When I came to the high-priestly throne ».

And understand this: when it came to general unions, the fathers did not want to investigate strict adherence to rules concerning names. Many of the 318 who gathered at Nicaea, as church histories tell us, were present at the synod at Ariminum and at Sardica; and yet, though the doctrines set forth there were not approved, no one argued about names. In the same way, the synod of bishops at Nicaea in Thrace, which declared that the Father is like the Son but not co-essential (homoousios), was rightly rejected; and yet there was no question about names at that time. It would take too long to recount the other rejected synods—the one at Sirmium, the one at Lampsacus, the one at Rome, the one at Zelo, the one at your Seleucia—all of which the synod of the 150 passed over in silence as if it had forgotten them, not introducing among us any empty talk or unnecessary inquiry about names, but only asserting the divinity of the Holy Spirit together with the Father and the Son, and explaining the intention of the 318. And when holy Cyril with the holy synod at Ephesus accomplished the deposition of the wicked Nestorius, the bishops of the East, though they had contended for his rejected teachings, later agreed to the deposition of that wolf and the rejection of those hateful doctrines; and there was never any discussion about names, even though how many do you think had died in the meantime who had contended for the wickedness of Nestorius? For these things, as I have said, have no place in general unions; instead they remained unexamined, since many are in fact passed over at councils, even though they have often been involved in impious opinions. Since now there is hope for some common agreement among the churches, do not lower your mind to untimely hair-splitting. Just as there is a time to speak and a time to be silent, so there is a time both to inquire into a matter of this kind and not to inquire. Keep these things in mind and be rightly disposed, and pay no attention to men who cling to division and find fault with everything in the same way, whom sacred Scripture calls backbiters and enemies of the common peace, and Christ the God of peace.

And know this, that, where general unions were concerned, the fathers did not wish to inquire into the observance of the strict rule with regard to names. Many of the 318 who assembled at Nicaea, as ecclesiastical histories relate, were present at the synod at Ariminus [ sic] and at Sardica; and still, though the doctrines there laid down were not approved, no one contended about names. And in the same way at Nicaea in Thrace also the synod of bishops which pronounced that the Father is like the Son, not co-essential, was rightly rejected; and yet there was no question about names at that time. It is a long matter to recount the other rejected synods, that at Sirmium, that at Lampsacus, that at Rome, that at Zelo, that at your Seleucia, all of which the synod of the 150 caused to be passed over in silence as if it had forgotten them, not introducing among us any vain talk or superfluous inquiry about names, but only asserting the divinity of the Holy Spirit together with the Father and the Son, and explaining the intention of the 318. And, when the holy Cyril with the holy synod at Ephesus accomplished the deprivation of the evil Nestorius, the bishops of the East, though they contended for his rejected tenets, afterwards agreed to the deprivation of that wolf and the rejections of the hateful tenets; and there was never any discussion about names, although how many do you think had died in the meanwhile, who contended for the wickedness of Nestorius? For these things, as I have said, general unions have no room; but they remained without examination; since many are in fact passed over at councils, although they have often been involved in impious opinions. Since then at the present time some common agreement among the churches is hoped for, do not lower your mind to untimely hair-splitting. As there is a time to speak and a time to be silent, so there is a time both to inquire into a matter of this kind and not to inquire. Bear these things in mind and be rightly disposed, and have no regard to men who cleave to division, and find fault with everything in the same way, whom the sacred Scripture calls backbiters and enemies of the common peace, and Christ the God of peace.