A Collection of Letters — Letter 30 — To the Presbyter Victor

From the letter of the holy Severus to the presbyter Victor, written because someone, while reading with Victor in a book by the same patriarch, told him it is not proper to say that the bread consecrated on the holy altars—which is the body of Emmanuel—is…

Letter 30

From the letter of the holy Severus to the presbyter Victor, written because someone, while reading with Victor in a book by the same patriarch, told him it is not proper to say that the bread consecrated on the holy altars—which is the body of Emmanuel—is impassible and immortal and gives impassibility and immortality to those who receive it. This person admitted that the bread after being changed is the body, but claimed it is not impassible because it is broken and divided. The holy man responds as follows.

OF THE HOLY SEVERUS, FROM THE LETTER TO THE PRESBYTER VICTOR, BECAUSE SOMEONE WHEN READING WITH THE SAME VICTOR IN THE BOOK OF THE SAME PATRIARCH SAID TO HIM THAT IT IS NOT PROPER TO SAY THAT THE BREAD WHICH IS CONSECRATED UPON THE HOLY ALTARS, WHICH IS THE BODY OF EMMANUEL, IS IMPASSIBLE AND IMMORTAL, AND IS A GIVER OF IMPASSIBILITY AND IMMORTALITY TO THOSE WHO PARTAKE OF IT, THOUGH EVEN HE HIMSELF SAID AND CONFESSED THAT THE BREAD WHICH HAS BEEN TRANSMUTED IS THE BODY, BUT NOT IMPASSIBLE, BECAUSE IT IS BROKEN AND DIVIDED; IN ANSWER TO WHICH THE HOLY MAN HIMSELF SPEAKS AS FOLLOWS.

The bread that is consecrated on the holy tables and mystically transformed is truly the body—the body of him in whose name it was actually transformed, that is, of him who voluntarily died and rose for our sake. But if it is the body of him who rose, it is clear that it is impassible and immortal. If we do not look at the bread that is mystically transformed, but at what appears to our physical senses, and, seeing it broken, do not confess it to be truly immortal, then we should also say that it is not God's body either—for what is seen is indeed bread. Therefore, by the same faith through which we understand and believe it to be the body of God who became incarnate without change for our sake, and voluntarily suffered and rose, by that same faith we understand and confess that it is also immortal and impassible, and grants impassibility and immortality to us. For he who allowed it to be cut and divided, because it was otherwise impossible for us to partake of it, in the same mercifulness also allows God's body which has already been transformed to appear as bread. And as confirmation of the transformation that is accomplished, this has been seen by many even with their physical eyes themselves, and they have seen bloodstained flesh being broken, not the bread that is laid upon the altar.

For the bread that is consecrated on the holy tables and mystically transmuted is itself truly the body, the body of him in whose name it was in fact transmuted, that is of him who voluntarily died and rose for our sakes. But, if it is the body of him who rose, it is plain that it is impassible and immortal. If we do not look at the bread that is mystically transmuted, but at that which comes under the eyes of the senses, and, seeing it broken, do not confess it to be indeed immortal, it is time for us to say that neither is it God's body: for what is seen is indeed bread. By the faith therefore by which we understand and believe it to be the body of God who became incarnate without variation for our sakes, and voluntarily suffered and rose, by the same faith we understand and confess that it is also immortal and impassible, and bestows impassibility and immortality on us. For he who allowed it to be cut and divided, because indeed it was otherwise impossible for us to partake of it, in the same mercifulness also allows God's body which has been already transmuted to appear as bread. And for a confirmation of the transmutation that is accomplished this has been seen by many even with the eyes of their senses themselves, and they have seen bloodstained flesh being broken, not the bread that is laid upon the altar.