Letter 29
From the holy Severus, from the 63rd letter of the second book of those written during his episcopacy, to Antoninus bishop of Beroea.
OF THE HOLY SEVERUS FROM THE 63rd LETTER OF THE 2nd BOOK OF THOSE WRITTEN DURING EPISCOPACY, TO ANTONINUS BISHOP OF BERRHOEA.
But we hear that this Mara also said that the holy Virgin did not feel the birth, in clear opposition to the Holy Spirit and to the Scriptures which were spoken by him. Isaiah, the most eloquent of prophets, shows that he came forth from the bond of virginity like any other child, and was ineffably born from Mary the God-bearer without tearing her, saying: "Before she who was in labor gave birth, and before the pain of labor came, she escaped and bore a male child." The fact that she "escaped" shows that the birth took place with perception on the part of the one who gave birth, and not in phantasy. Gregory the Theologian also says in his sermon about Easter, speaking of the birth of the infant: "But she also cried out from the compulsion of the virgin and maternal bonds, with great power, when a male child was born from the prophetess, as Isaiah announces." How could the fact that she cried out from the compulsion and did not tear the bond of virginity happen without perception, rather than with such great perception on the part of the one who gave birth? And these things took place ineffably and beyond everything. He who wished to come truly in all our attributes and to be made like us his brothers without sin was certainly born in a fleshly manner through a clear and true birth, causing perception in the one who bore him, free from all pain and suffering. For the prophet proclaims that she gave birth before the pain of labor came. For how could she be subjected to the trial of pains and anguish, when she put an end to bearing children in anguish through the fact that joy was born for the whole human race? For, "Behold!" he says, "I announce to you great joy, which is for all the people, that there has been born to you today a Savior, who is the Lord Christ."
But we hear of the said Mara that he said this also as well, that the holy Virgin did not feel the birth, in manifest opposition to the Holy Spirit and to the Scriptures which were spoken by him. The loud-voiced among prophets, Isaiah, shows that he came forth from the bond of virginity like anything else, and he was ineffably born without rending her from Mary the God-bearer, saying thus, «Before she that travailed bare, and before the pain of the travail came, she escaped and bare a male child». The fact that she escaped shows that the birth took place with perception on the part of her who gave birth, and not in phantasy. So Gregory the Theologian also in the sermon about Easter says of the birth of the babe when it is born: «But she also cried from the compulsion of the virgin and maternal bonds, with great power, when a male child was born from the prophetess, as Isaiah announces». How could the fact that she cried from the compulsion and did not rend the bond of virginity happen without perception, and not with such great perception as this oh the part of her who bare? And these things took place ineffably and beyond everything. He who wished to come truly in all our attributes, and to be made like to us his brethren without sin, was. certainly born in fleshly fashion by a manifest and true birth, causing perception in her who bare, free from all pain and suffering; for the prophet proclaims that she gave birth before the pain of the travail came. For how was she to be subjected to the trial of pains and anguish, who put an end to the bearing of children in anguish through the fact that joy was born for the whole race of men? For, «Lo!», he says, «I announce unto you great joy, that is to all the people, that there hath been born to you to-day a Saviour, who is the Lord Christ».
