A Collection of Letters — Letter 31 — To Sergius the Physician and Sophist

From the letter of the holy Severus to Sergius the physician and sophist. Written 515–8.

Letter 31

From the letter of the holy Severus to Sergius the physician and sophist.

OF THE HOLY SEVERUS FROM THE LETTER TO SERGIUS THE PHYSICIAN AND SOPHIST.

Regarding the acceptance of Eutyches—that it was done in a canonical way and casts no blame on the holy Dioscorus or the synod assembled with him at Ephesus—I addressed arguments on this matter to certain people some time ago and dealt with it completely as the truth requires. I have thought it important and urgent to send a copy of these things to your learning. Not only the wretched man from Scythopolis, but many others before and after him, used the same blasphemous absurdities. They did not know what they were saying but turned empty-mindedness into fullness of blasphemy against God. The holy synod that assembled at Ephesus with the saintly witness of the truth Dioscorus taught nothing new about the faith. It only removed and expelled those infected with the Jewish poison of Nestorius. As for Eutyches, who presented a petition and anathematized the heresy for which he was accused, the synod accepted him based on the petition itself and on the minutes that were written at Constantinople before Flavian. It did not recognize the poison in his heart—the disease that was hard to discover was properly hidden from them according to human limitations. For the divine Scripture plainly teaches that "man looks on the face, but God looks on the heart." But what will anyone say about those who assembled at Chalcedon? They received Theodoret and Ibas, who not only hid the foul heresy of Nestorius in their hearts but actually displayed it openly. When the contents of the minutes that led to Ibas's removal had been read, along with his letter to Mari the Persian, which was full of many blasphemies (a copy of which I have also sent to you), the representatives of Leo, who had become prelate of the church of the Romans, pronounced him blameless and made the following declaration: "Pascasinus and Lucentius the reverend bishops and Boniface the presbyter representing the apostolic throne said by the mouth of Pascasinus, 'From the reading of the documents and from the statement of the reverend bishops we know that the reverend Ibas has been shown to be innocent. For when his letter was read, we recognized that it is orthodox. Therefore our decision is that the episcopal rank and the church from which he was wrongfully ejected in his absence be restored.'" The whole synod agreed with these things and promulgated the same decision. How then can those who defend those men dare to charge the holy Dioscorus and the synod assembled with him with accepting Eutyches, when that acceptance took place according to the canons?

But with regard to the reception of Eutyches that it was done in a canonical way, and that it casts no slur on the holy. Dioscorus, and on the synod which assembled with him at Ephesus, I addressed the arguments on this head to certain persons some time ago, and I also dealt completely with it as the truth demands; and I have thought it good and urgent to send a copy of these things to your learning. Not only the wretched man from Scythopolis, but many others besides before him and after him, employed the same blasphemous absurdities, not knowing what they are saying, but made empty-mindedness fulness of blasphemy against God. The holy synod which assembled at Ephesus with the saintly witness of the truth Dioscorus taught nothing new whatever with regard to the faith, but only effected the deprivation of those who were infected with the Jewish poison of Nestorius and cast them off: but Eutyches, who presented a petition and anathematized his heresy, on account of which he was accused, it accepted on the ground of the actual petition itself and on the ground of the minutes that were written at Constantinople before Flavian, since it did not recognise the poison that was in his heart, and the disease hard to be discovered was in accordance with the human standard properly hidden from it; for the divine Scripture plainly teaches that 'man looks on the face, but God looks on the heart'. But what will anyone say about those who assembled at Chalcedon, who received Theodoret and Hiba, who not merely hid the foul heresy of Nestorius in the heart, but actually displayed it with open face. When the contents of the minutes' on account of which Hiba's deprivation took place had been read, and his letter to Mari the Persian, which was full of many blasphemies (a copy of which I have also sent to you), the representatives of Leo, who had become prelate of the church of the Romans, pronounced him blameless, making the following declaration: «Pascasinus and Lucentius the reverend bishops and Boniface the presbyter representing the apostolic throne said by the mouth of Pascasinus, 'From the reading of the documents, and from the statement of the reverend bishops we know that the reverend Hiba has been shown to be innocent. For, when his letter was read, we recognised that it is orthodox; and therefore our decision is that the episcopal rank also and the church from which he was wrongfully ejected in his absence be restored'». And to these things the whole synod assented; and they promulgated the same decision. How then can those who defend those men dare to make the reception of Eutyches, which took place according to the canons, a charge against the holy Dioscorus and the synod which assembled with him?