A Collection of Letters — Letter 108 — To Thomas Bishop of Germanicea

From the holy Severus, patriarch of Antioch, from the 27th letter of the 9th book written after his exile, which was addressed to Thomas, bishop of Germanicea. Written 519–38.

Letter 108

From the holy Severus, patriarch of Antioch, from the 27th letter of the 9th book written after his exile, which was addressed to Thomas, bishop of Germanicea.

OF THE HOLY SEVERUS PATRIARCH OF ANTIOCH, FROM THE 27th LETTER OF THE 9th BOOK AFTER EXILE WHICH WAS ADDRESSED TO THOMAS BISHOP OF GERMANICEA.

The Lord says: "I found a hot one in the wilderness with the slain of the sword. Go and destroy not Israel. The Lord shall be revealed upon him afar off. With perfect love I loved thee; therefore I drew thee with mercy. Again I will build thee and thou shalt be built, virgin Jerusalem." Men experienced in warfare say that army generals customarily bring physicians along with their armed forces, and after the armies engage each other in battle and the opposing side is defeated, they send the physicians to search among those who have fallen and examine them carefully to see if there is anyone among them who is still warm and has breath in him, and who might recover from the fatal wounds he has suffered through medical treatment. Therefore, the meaning of this figurative prophecy we have quoted is that when Israel was counted among the dead, he restored him to life. But some have failed to discover the meaning contained in this figure or the explanation of the words "I found a hot one in the wilderness," and have given a foolish interpretation. They changed the reading "hot" and instead of saying "hot" said "solitary," and supposed from this that there is some plant that grows by itself in the wilderness, signifying the solitariness of Israel. But this is not so. The words of the following context refute and truly reject their interpretation; and the words of Scripture are as follows: "I found a hot one in the wilderness with the slain of the sword." So I too am in this way encouraged and compelled to take courage and say a few words about the communications that have been sent to me by your eloquent wisdom.

«Thus saith the Lord: 'I found a hot one in the wilderness with the slain of the sword. Go and destroy not Israel. The Lord shall be revealed upon him afar off. With perfect love I loved thee; therefore I drew thee with mercy. Again I will build thee and thou shalt be built, virgin Jerusalem'». Certain men with experience of war say that generals of armies have a custom of bringing besides the armed forces physicians also, and, after the hosts engage with one another and the battle is joined, and the opposite side is defeated, they send the physicians to search among the fallen, and examine carefully lest there be found a man among them who is warm and has breath in him, and may by medical skill recover from the deadly wounds that are upon him. Therefore also the purport of this figurative prophecy which we have cited is that, when Israel was reckoned with the dead, he restored him to life; but some have not discovered the meaning contained in this figure, or the explanation of the words, 'I found a hot one in the wilderness', but have given a foolish interpretation. They changed the reading 'hot', and instead of saying 'hot' said 'solitary', and supposed from this that there is some herb which grows of itself in the wilderness, and signifies the solitariness of Israel. For it is not so. The words of the following context refute and truly banish their supposition; and the words of Scripture are as follows: «I found a hot one in the wilderness with the slain of the sword». So therefore I also am in this manner lifted up, and am constrained to take courage and speak a few words about the communications that have been addressed to me by your eloquent wisdom.

And after other things.

(And after other things.)

Our Lord Jesus Christ our God was pierced in the side with a lance by a soldier after he gave up the spirit, and blood and water came forth from it in a miraculous way. The divine John the Evangelist recorded this, and no one else wrote about it. But certain people have clearly falsified the Gospel of Matthew and inserted this same passage, when the truth is the opposite. They did this to show that the soldier pierced his side with the spear while he was still alive, and that he gave up the spirit afterwards. This question was examined very carefully when I was in the royal city at the time when the case of Macedonius was being examined. He had become archbishop of that city. The Gospel of Matthew was produced, written in large letters and preserved with great honor in the royal palace. It was said to have been found in the days of Zeno of honored memory in a city of the island of Cyprus, buried with the holy Barnabas, who traveled with Paul and spread the divine preaching. When the Gospel of Matthew was opened, it was found to be free from the falsification contained in this addition about the soldier and the spear. I do not know how or why the holy John who became bishop of the same royal city, and the admirable Cyril, bishop of Alexandria, did not examine this question. They allowed the two passages to stand in the two evangelists, neglecting the evidence to the contrary. But perhaps this was so that it might be known that, while they speak and write everything under the operation of the Holy Spirit, and while these men are higher than we are (for we are men who creep along the earth), as the heaven is higher than the earth, they themselves might also be known to be men. They left omniscience to God alone, and showed that there is something in affairs which cannot be expressed, and whose complete revelation is not made known. Thus Samuel also, who as one may say saw with the eye of prophecy everything that was about to happen, did not know Saul when he was present and standing among all Israel. God was instructing his servants through these things, and teaching them to pay attention to humility. Therefore the divine Scripture is written thus: "And Samuel asked the Lord and said, 'Is the man coming here?' And the Lord said, 'Look! He is hidden among the baggage.' And he ran and took him from there." And when the Shunammite woman's son died, and she came to Elisha in great distress as a mother who had been deprived of her beloved son, and when she had just fallen at the feet of the prophet of God, and Gehazi tried to prevent her, the servant of God, being moved by love and sorrow, said to Gehazi, "Let her alone, because her soul is bitter in her, and the Lord hid it from me and did not show it to me." So you should know that Eusebius of Caesarea, also called 'Pamphili', who wrote the canons of the gospel and imitated those who wrote on this subject before him, and had more complete knowledge of this question than the others, in the tenth canon, in which he recorded the places peculiar to one of the evangelists, inserted this passage also about the soldier and the lance, saying that John alone recorded it. And we also agree with this careful accuracy, not that we argue against our fathers (God forbid!), but that we place the evangelists at a greater height than them, and assign to the evangelists alone the intention which properly belongs to them. This is so that in everything Jesus, who is God, who spoke in the evangelists, may be glorified, "in whom are all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge hidden," according to the saying of Paul. But for the rest we find that the holy John himself also, the bishop of Constantinople, in the commentary on the same Matthew the Evangelist regarding this same addition which we are now discussing, himself also said things that fit the truth. For he expressed himself thus: "'But another came up and perforated his side with a lance.' And what could be more wicked than these men? And who could be lawless like them? And who could be more savage than these same men, who showed their madness to such an extent that they attacked a dead body? But do you notice how their madness was brought about for our salvation? For after the wound the fountain of life welled forth for us." But these are the words of a man who follows the account of John the Evangelist and nothing else. For he called the body 'dead', because it was after he gave up the spirit that the soldier pierced him and gave occasion for the fountain of our salvation to well forth from there, as the doctor John the bishop said. But this addition to the narrative of Matthew the Evangelist has never been inserted by any of the earlier commentators who wrote, not by Origen, who examined such questions minutely (though he sinned in matters that are necessary for the truth of the faith of the church), nor by Didymus, nor by any other man who has written on this subject. But Eusebius of Caesarea, who is called 'Pamphili', whom we mentioned a little above, when writing to a man called Marinus about questions concerning the passions of our Savior and about his Resurrection, showed us nothing whatever about the said addition, as it was unknown and had no place in the books of the gospel. But in the same letters to Marinus, who had asked him for an interpretation on the subject of our Savior's passions and his Resurrection, he also inserted the following exposition in his letters. The divine Mark the Evangelist said that it was the third hour at the time when Christ who is God and our Savior was crucified, but the divine John (he said) wrote that it was at the sixth hour that Pilate sat upon his judgment seat at the place called 'the pavement' and judged Christ. Therefore Eusebius said that this is an error of a scribe who was inattentive when writing the Gospel. For it is the letter gamal that denotes three hours, while the letter which is called in Greek episemon denotes the number of six hours, and these letters are like one another in Greek. The scribe, wishing to write 'three' quickly and having turned the letter a little backwards, made it appear to be 'six', because, since the letter had been turned backwards, it was supposed to be the letter that denotes 'six'. Since therefore the three other evangelists Matthew, Mark, and Luke stated alike as with one mouth that from the sixth hour to the ninth there was darkness over all the land, it is clear that our Lord and God Jesus Christ was crucified before the sixth hour, at which the darkness took place, that is from the third hour, as the blessed John himself wrote. Similarly we say that it is the third hour, because those who wrote before, as we have said, changed the letter. We must also insert in this our letter upon this matter a part of what Eusebius himself stated at length. His words are as follows: "We do not agree with any random person, but with the evangelist who gave this testimony, Mark. For it happened that there was an error on the part of the scribe so that he changed the letter by adding length to it, and it was thought that the letter which represents 'three' was 'six', on account of the likeness of the two letters (of that which denotes 'three' and that which denotes 'six'). Therefore if it is stated by John that it was the preparation of the day of unleavened bread, and it was about the sixth hour, and Pilate said to the Jews, 'Behold! your king,' and so on, let there be read instead of 'sixth' 'third', since the beginning of his trial took place at that time. In the middle of the hour or after it had been completed they crucified him, so that the result is that they judged and crucified him at the same hour." If you look for and find the volume addressed to Marinus about the interpretation of these things, you will find the accuracy of the writer regarding these matters. For our part we do not wish to write much on these subjects in this our letter. May the diligence of your holiness be preserved for us meditating on these things and occupied with these things in a priestly manner, and rousing up the gloom of our silence and urging it to speak.

But that our Lord Jesus Christ our God was pierced in the side with a lance by that soldier after he gave up the ghost, and blood and water came forth from it in a miraculous manner, the divine John the Evangelist recorded, and no one else wrote about this. But certain persons have clearly falsified the Gospel of Matthew and inserted this same passage, when the contrary is the fact, in order to show that it was while he was alive that the soldier pierced his side with the spear, and afterwards he gave up the ghost. This question was examined with great carefulness when my meanness was in the royal city, at the time when the affair of Macedonius was being examined, who became archbishop of that city, and there was produced the Gospel of Matthew, which was written in large letters, and was preserved with great honour in the royal palace, which was said to have been found in the days of Zeno of honourable memory in a city of the island of Cyprus buried with the holy Barnabas, who went about with Paul and spread the divine preaching; and, when the Gospel of Matthew was opened, it was found to be free from the falsification contained in this addition, of the story of the soldier and the spear. I do not know how and for what reason the holy John who became bishop of the same royal city, and the admirable Cyril, bishop of Alexandria, did not test this question, and allowed the two passages to stand, in the two evangelists, neglecting the evidence to the contrary; but perhaps in order that this also might be known, that, while they speak and write everything under the operation of the Holy Spirit, and while these men are higher than we (for we are men who creep along the earth), as the heaven is higher than the earth, and that they themselves also might be known to be men, and to leave omniscience to God only, and that there is something in affairs which cannot be expressed, the complete revelation of which is not made known. Thus Samuel also, who as one may say saw with the eye of prophecy everything that was about to happen, did not know Saul when he was present and standing among all Israel, Because God by means of these things was instructing his bondmen, and teaching them to pay regard to humility. Wherefore also the divine Scripture is written thus: «And Samuel asked in the Lord and said, 'Cometh that man hither?' And the Lord said, ' Lo! he is hidden among the vessels'. And he ran and took him thence». And at the time when the Shilumite woman's son died, and she had come to Elisha in great distress, as a mother who had been deprived of her beloved son, and, when she had just fallen at the feet of the prophet of God, and Gehazi tried to prevent her, the bondman of God, being moved by love and sorrow, said to Gehazi, «Let her alone, because her soul is bitter in her, and the Lord hid it from me and showed it not to me». Accordingly you should know that Eusebius of Caesarea also who is called 'Pamphili', who wrote the canons of the gospel, and imitated those who wrote on this subject before him, and had more complete knowledge of this question than the others, in the 10th canon, in which he recorded the places peculiar to one of the evangelists, inserted this passage also about the soldier and the lance, saying that John alone recorded it. And we also agree with this careful accuracy, not that we contend against our fathers (far be it!), but that we place the evangelists at a greater height than them, and assign to the evangelists only the intention which properly belongs to them, in order that in everything Jesus, who is God, who spoke in the evangelists, may be glorified, 'in whom are all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge hidden', according to the saying of Paul. But for the rest we find that the holy John himself also, the bishop of Constantinople, in the commentary on the same Matthew the Evangelist with regard to this same addition which we are now discussing, himself also said things that fit the truth; for he expressed himself thus: «'But another came up and perforated his side with a lance'. And what could be more wicked than these men? And who could be lawless like them? And who could be more savage than these same men, who showed their madness to such an extent, that they attacked a dead body. But do you mark how their madness was brought about for our salvation. For after the wound the fountain of life welled forth for us». But these are the words of a man who follows the footsteps of the narrative of John the Evangelist and nothing else; for he called the body 'dead'; because it was after he gave up the ghost that the soldier pierced him, and gave occasion for the fountain of our salvation to well forth thence, as the doctor John the bishop said. But this addition to the narrative of Matthew the Evangelist has never been inserted by any of the earlier commentators who wrote, not by Origen, who examined such questions minutely, though he sinned in matters that are necessary for the truth of the faith of the church, nor by Didymus, nor by any other man who has written on this subject. But Eusebius of Caesarea, who is called 'Pamphili', whom we mentioned a little above, when writing to a man called Marinus about questions concerning the passions of our Saviour and about his Resurrection, showed us nothing whatever about the said addition, as being unknown and having no place in the books of the gospel. But in the same letters to Marinus, who had asked him for an interpretation on the subject of our Saviour's passions and his Resurrection, he inserted the following exposition also in his letters, that the divine Mark the Evangelist said that it was the 3rd hour at the time when Christ who is God and our Saviour was crucified, but the divine John (he said) wrote that it was at the 6th hour that Pilate sat upon his judgment-seat at the place called 'the pavement', and judged Christ. And therefore Eusebius said that this is an error of a scribe, who was inattentive when writing the Gospel. For it is the letter gamal that denotes 3 hours, while the letter which is called in Greek episemon denotes the number of 6 hours, and these letters are like one another in Greek, and, the scribe wishing to write '3' quickly, and having turned the letter a little backwards, it was thereby found to be '6', because, since the letter had been turned backwards, it was supposed to be the letter that denotes '6'. Since therefore the three other evangelists Matthew, Mark, and Luke stated alike as with one mouth that from the 6th hour to the 9th there was darkness over all the land, it is plain that our Lord and God Jesus Christ was crucified before the 6th hour, at which the darkness took place, that is from the 3rd hour, as the blessed John himself wrote. Similarly we say that it is the 3rd hour, because those who wrote before, as we have said, changed the letter. We must insert also in this our letter upon this matter a part of what Eusebius himself stated at length; and his words are as follows: «We agree not with any chance man, but with the evangelist who gave this testimony, Mark. For it happened that there was an error on the part of the scribe so that he changed the letter by adding length to it, and it was thought that the letter which represents '3' was '6', on account of the likeness of the two letters [of that which denotes '3' and that which denotes '6'. If the refore it is stated by John that it was the preparation of the day of unlevened bread, and it was about the 6th hour, and Pilate said to the Jews «Behold! your king», and so on, let there be read instead of '6th ' '3rd ', since the beginning of his trial took place at that time, and in the middle of the hour or after it had been completed they crucified him, so that the result is that they judged and crucified him at the same hour»; If you look for and find the volume addressed to Marinus about the interpretation of these things, you will find the accuracy of the writer as regards these matters. For our part we do not wish to write much on these subjects in this our letter. May the industry of your holiness be preserved for us meditating on these things and occupied with these things in priestly fashion, and rousing up the gloom of our silence and urging it to speak.