Letter 25
Of the holy Severus, the letter that was written by him to the Emesenes.
OF THE HOLY SEVERUS, THE LETTER THAT WAS WRITTEN BY HIM TO THE EMESENES.
To the devout presbyters and orthodox deacons, and to the rest who make up the holy order of the clergy, and to the distinguished and Christ-loving officials of the city, and to all the people of the holy church, Severus sends greetings in our Lord.
To the devout presbyters and orthodox deacons, and to the rest who compose the holy order of the clergy, and to the magnificent and Christ-loving magistrates of the city, and to all the people of the holy church, Severus greeting in our Lord.
For people who are not wise in their thinking or otherwise lack intelligence, and who are deficient in true instruction, the holy Scripture provides the proper rule and place, so that their mental emptiness and lack of instruction may be turned to wisdom. Indeed, it commands such people both to learn and to ask questions, or to remain silent altogether. For the holy book of Proverbs says somewhere: "To the fool who asks, wisdom shall be credited; but when a man keeps himself silent, he is thought to be wise." But Scripture raises and advances the person who keeps this rule, and urges him to learn things that are useful and profitable, saying, "Give your heart to wisdom, and prepare your ears for words of understanding." I am therefore surprised that the brother you mention (out of tenderness for his soul I do not mention his name) did not know his own limitations, and besides not originally knowing the subject he was talking about, he neglected this legally established and healthy rule. When he ought to have listened with an understanding ear to those wiser than himself, he instead threatened to take the ignorance within him to the city of Alexandria, like an invincible warrior who is able to overcome and capture all who meet him, and sell them wherever he likes. Therefore I have both accepted your wisdom in the Lord, which is worthy of the church and very honorable, and your patience, which befits Christians, and I have crowned them also with a decree of many praises, since in accordance with the apostolic model you both received and admonished him as your member and brother, and brought forward the teachings of the holy fathers. And whereas you refuted and corrected him once and twice, secretly and openly, on the points on which he spoke without knowledge, and he was again involved in the same errors, and you behaved like doctors and churchmen, and on all sides sought to gain his salvation, and by actual deeds showed that you look to the apostolic commandment which says, "Let everything be done decently and in order," but he, though he was thought worthy to receive so much attention, had no mercy on his soul, and did not restrain himself so as to show moderation and humility—I expressed blame and at the same time showed mercy and still show mercy, since ignorance is free from danger, for a person is not blamed because he does not know. He is trying to bring upon himself the sin that does not deserve forgiveness, in that he does not yield to those who are wise among the brethren, or seek from wiser men a cure for his ignorance through desire to learn, but pettily searches into things that are unknown and uncertain, and does his best to find people to share his opinions, so that he may seem to be saying something when he is saying nothing that is sound. But the other things which he said without knowledge he has with difficulty come to honor by silence, in that he agreed to the passages from the holy fathers that were brought before him. And he was reduced to one passage, the words used by the holy Cyril in the second volume against the blasphemies of Nestorius, which are as follows: "For, because the Word who is from God the Father took flesh and came forth as a man like us, he would not for this reason be also called a double thing. For he is one, and not without flesh, who in his own nature is without flesh and blood." After you quoted to him the words used by the doctor, he persisted and said that after his own Resurrection we must confess that God the Word is without flesh, inasmuch as he put off that which was without variation and without separation hypostatically united to him—a thing that is beyond all impiety and profanity, so that everyone who has natural (I will not say spiritual) intelligence must wonder if a fact which is so universally admitted has ever been made a subject of contention, and has passed the lips of anyone who has duly believed in our one Lord and God and Savior Jesus Christ. If he were skilled in divine doctrine, he should have (to omit everything else) considered the anathemas of Gregory the Theologian, who in the great letter to Cledonius which begins, "I wonder what this innovation is," clearly lays down these principles in it: "If anyone says that the flesh was now laid down by him, and the Godhead is stripped of a body, and does not confess that he both is and will come with the thing assumed itself, may he not see the glory of his coming. For where is the body now except with him who assumed it? For it has not been laid up in the sun, as the silly tale of the Manichees goes, in order that he may be honored through the object of contempt, or diffused and dissolved in the air, like the nature of a voice and the wafting of a smell, and the course of lightning that does not stand still. But what becomes of the fact that he was actually touched after the Resurrection, or that he will again some time be seen by those who pierced him? For the Godhead by itself is invisible. But he will come with the body, according to my account, and such as he was seen by, or was shown to, the disciples on the mount, inasmuch as the Godhead easily overcomes the flesh." Who that reads these words resplendent with truth, and flashing with the rays of the Holy Spirit, will dare to say that the Word of God, who was humanized immutably and without any phantasy, is without flesh after the inexplicable and incomprehensible union? Accordingly it is clear that you also have not gone beyond what is fitting in opposing the precipitous error of that man and saying in order to remove him from this error, "The words used by the doctor about the Word of God, 'In his own nature he is without flesh and blood,' refer to the time before the Humanization." Indeed, since he himself said that "he is one, and not without flesh," how can it be anything but wholly unreasonable, and presumptuous and irreverent, for us to contradict this and contend that he is without flesh? But the words which he went on to add, "who in his own nature is without flesh and blood," plainly introduce this thought: that in his own nature, that is in the Godhead, he has no association with flesh and blood. He did not take the flesh into the fullness of his own divine nature and mix it with it, nor did he mingle it with his own Godhead, but that in the dispensatory assumption we might understand him to be not without flesh, Emmanuel being wonderfully composed and consisting of two elements, the Godhead and the manhood. But even so he preserved the absence of mixture in the divine essence, and did not change the essence of the Godhead into the nature of flesh. And that this is so I bring as a witness to the accuracy of his doctrines the doctor himself, who by the operation of the Holy Spirit is an accurate doctor. In the first letter to Succensus, when certain people had advanced a similar objection, he expressed himself thus: "Since I found in the memorial an assertion of this kind stated, that since the Resurrection the holy body of Christ the Savior of us all has passed into the nature of the Godhead, so as to be all Godhead only, I thought it right to speak against this also." And then, after he has briefly gone through all the statement of the dispensation of the Humanization, he brings against it this argument: "It is impossible for a body taken from earth to endure the change into the divine nature. And, if not, we bring against the Godhead the charge that it is as a thing that is made and as a thing that has taken into it something that is not its by nature." See how plainly he denies that the divinity of the Word has taken anything into its essence which is not its by nature, though we confess that flesh possessing an intelligent soul was taken by God the Word, and he united this to him hypostatically, but not so that anything should be added to his divine essence, as if it were deficient (for he is truly complete in everything), but that from the unmixed union of the Incarnation, and the composition out of two elements, the Godhead and the manhood, Emmanuel should be made up, who in one hypostasis is ineffably composite—not simple, but composite. As the soul of a person like us, which by nature is bodiless and rational, which is naturally intertwined with the body, remains in its suprasensual and bodiless nature, but by reason of the composition with the body makes up one composite living being, a human being—accordingly the assumption of the body makes no addition to the essence of the soul, but makes up the composite living being, as it is reasonable to understand with regard to the theory of Emmanuel also. The Word did not take the flesh intelligently possessed of a soul in order to complete his being God, as we have said, but that one hypostasis might be wonderfully and immutably made up out of two elements, the Godhead we mean and the manhood, and the one incarnate nature of the Word himself, and one prosopon. For the Word of God, according to the saying of Paul the apostle, partook of blood and flesh after our pattern. And that this is so the approved Cyril further shows in the letter to Valerian bishop of
To those who are not wise in their mind or are otherwise without intelligence, and are lacking in true instruction, the holy Scripture gives the proper rule and place, in order that their emptiness of mind and lack of instruction may be turned to wisdom: for indeed it commands those who are such both to learn and to ask, or to be silent altogether; for the holy book of Proverbs somewhere said: «To the fool who asketh wisdom shall be reckoned: but, when a man maketh himself silent, he is thought to be wise». But the man who keeps this rule it raises and advances, and incites to learn things that are of use and profit, and it says, «Give thine heart to wisdom, and prepare thine ears for words of understanding». I am surprised therefore that the brother whom you mention (out of tenderness for his soul I do not mention his name) did not know his own measure, and, besides not knowing originally the subject on which he was talking, neglected this legally established and salutary rule; and, when he ought to have bent a ear of understanding to those who are wiser than he is, he on the contrary threatened to take the ignorance that is in him to the city of Alexandria, like an invincible warrior, who is able to overcome and take captive all that meet him, and sell them where he likes. Therefore I have both accepted your wisdom in the Lord, which is worthy of the church and very honourable, and your patience, which is such as befits Christians, and have crowned them also with a decree of many praises, since in accordance with the apostolic model you both received and admonished him as your member and brother, and brought forward the teachings of the holy fathers. And, whereas you once and twice secretly and openly refuted and corrected him on the points on which he spoke without knowledge, and he was again involved in the same errors, and you behaved like doctors and churchmen, and on all sides seek to gain his salvation, and by actual deeds show that you look to the apostolic commandment which commands, «Let everything be done decently and in order», but he, though he was thought worthy to receive so much attention, had no mercy on his soul, and did not restrain himself so as to show moderation and humility, I expressed blame and at the same time showed mercy and still show mercy, since ignorance is free from danger, for a man is not blamed because he does not know. He is trying to bring upon himself the sin that does not deserve forgiveness, in that he does not yield to those who are wise among the brethren, or seek from wiser men a cure for his ignorance by desire to learn, but pettily searches into things that are unknown and uncertain, and does his best to find men to share his opinions, in order that he may seem to be saying something when he is saying nothing that is sound. But the other things which he said without knowledge he has with difficulty come to honour by silence, in that he assented to the passages from the holy fathers (that were brought before him; and he was reduced to one passage, the words used by the holy Cyril in the second volume against the blasphemies of Nestorius, which are as follows: (( For, because the Word who is from God the Father took flesh and came forth as a man like us, he would not for this reason be also termed a double thing. For he is one, and not without flesh, who in his own nature is without flesh and blood». After you had quoted to him the words used by the doctor, he persisted and said that after his own Resurrection we must confess that God the Word is without flesh, inasmuch as he put off that which was without variation and without separation hypostatically united to him, a thing that is beyond all impiety and profanity, so that everyone who has natural (I will not say, spiritual) intelligence must wonder if a fact which is so universally admitted has ever been made a subject of contention, and has passed the lips of anyone who has duly believed in our one Lord and God and Saviour Jesus Christ. If he were skilled in divine doctrine, he should have (to omit everything else) considered the anathemas of Gregory the Theologian, who in the great letter to Cledonius which begins, 'I wonder what this innovation is', clearly lays down these principles in it, «If anyone says that the flesh was now laid down by him, and the Godhead is stripped of a body, and does not confess that he both is and will come with the thing assumed itself, may he not see the glory of his coming. For where is the body now except with him who assumed it? For it has not been laid up in the sun, as the silly tale of the Manichees goes, in order that he may be honoured through the object of contempt, or diffused and dissolved in the air, like the nature of a voice and the wafting of a smell, and the course of lightning that does not stand still. But what becomes of the fact that he was actually touched after the Resurrection, or that he will again some time be seen by those who pierced him? For the Godhead by itself is invisible. But he will come with the body, according to my account, and such as he was seen by, or was shown to, the disciples on the mount, inasmuch as the Godhead easily overcomes the flesh». Who.that reads these words resplendent with truth, and flashing with the rays of the Holy Spirit, will dare to say that the Word of God, who was humanized immutably and without any phantasy, is without flesh after the inexplicable and incomprehensible union? Accordingly it is clear that you also have not gone beyond what is fitting in opposing the precipitous error of that man and saying in order to remove him from this error, «The words used by the doctor about the Word of God, In his own nature he is without flesh and blood', refer to the time before the Humanization». Indeed, since he himself said that 'he is one, and not without flesh', how can it be anything but wholly unreasonable, and presumptuous and irreverent, for us to gainsay this, and contend that he is without flesh? But the words which he went on to add, 'who in his own nature is without flesh and blood', plainly introduce this thought, that in his own nature, that is in the Godhead, he has no association with flesh and blood. He did not take the flesh into the fulness of his own divine nature and mix it with it, nor did he mingle it with his own Godhead, but that in the dispensatory assumption we might understand him to be not without flesh, Emmanuel being wonderfully composed and consisting of two elements, the Godhead and the manhood: but even so he preserved the absence, of mixture in the divine essence, and did not change the essence of the Godhead into the nature of flesh. And that this is so I bring as a witness to the accuracy of his doctrines the doctor himself, who by the operation of the Holy Spirit is an accurate doctor. In the first letter to Succensus, when certain men had advanced a similar objection, he expressed himself thus: «Since I found in the memorial an assertion of this kind stated, that since the Resurrection the holy body of Christ the Saviour of us all has passed into the nature of the Godhead, so as to be all Godhead only, I thought it right to speak against this also». And thereupon, after he has above in a brief compass gone through all the statement of the dispensation of the Humanization, he brings against it this argument: «It is impossible for a body taken from earth to endure the change into the divine nature. And, if not, we bring against the Godhead the charge that it is as a thing that is made and as a thing that has taken into it something that is not its by nature». See! how plainly he denies that the divinity of the Word has taken anything into its essence which is not its by nature, though we confess that flesh possessing an intelligent soul was taken by God the Word, and he united this to him hypostatically, but not so that anything should be added to his divine essence, as if it were deficient (for he is truly complete in everything), but that from the unmixed union of the Incarnation, and the composition out of two elements, the Godhead and the manhood, Emmanuel should be made up, who in one hypostasis is ineffably composite; not simple, but composite: as the soul of a man like us, which by nature is bodiless and rational, which is naturally intertwined with the body, remains in its suprasensual and bodiless nature, but by reason of the composition with the body makes up one composite animal, man. Accordingly the assumption of the body makes no addition to the essence of the soul, but makes up the composite animal, as it is reasonable to understand with regard to the theory of Emmanuel also. The Word did not take the flesh intelligently possessed of a soul in order to complete his being God, as we have said, but that one hypostasis might be wonderfully and immutably made up out of two elements, the Godhead we mean and the manhood, and the one incarnate nature of the Word himself, and one person: for the Word of God, according to the saying of Paul the apostle, partook of blood and flesh after our pattern. And that this is so the approved Cyril further shows in the letter to Valerian bishop of Iconium; who wrote as follows: «For God and man did not come together, as they say, and make up one Christ; but, as I have already said, the Word, being God, partook of blood and flesh like us, in order that he may be known to be God who was humanized, and who took our flesh, and made this his, because, as the man who was composed of soul and body is known to be one, so also now he is acknowledged to be one Son and Lord. For one nature and hypostasis of a man is acknowledged, though he is known to be made of diverse and heterogeneous elements: for the body is truly different in nature from the soul; but it belongs to it, and with it makes up the hypostasis of the one man. And in mental conception and in theory the difference of the things that have been named is not obscure, but by combination and concurrence that cannot be cut asunder one animal, man, is made up. The Word therefore, the Only one of God, did not come forth as man by taking a man, but, though his birth from the Father is ineffable, he became man by forming a man for himself through the Holy Spirit which is of one essence with him. Accordingly he is known to be one, though in the theory which is according to reason his own body is different in nature from himself. Let it therefore be everywhere acknowledged that he was not without soul, but that he was possessed of an intelligent soul». Similarly also in the second volume against the blasphemies of Nestorius he clearly teaches that the assumption of flesh did not pass into the Godhead of the Word, but that the Word of God remained in his own nature, and apart from flesh, but by the immutable combination with flesh it was wisely and beyond all reason and understanding brought about that one Christ should be marvellously made up; for he speaks thus: «Accordingly confess one, not dividing the natures, while you know and understand that to flesh belongs one principle, and to Godhead that which befits it only. For we do not say that the flesh of the Word became Godhead, but rather that it is divine as being his. For, as the flesh of a man is called his, on what ground is it not right for us also to call that of the Word divine?» And again farther on: «If therefore he were a wise and intelligent man at all, he should say that the body is from a woman, but confess besides that by being combined in hypostatic union with the Word it has made up one Christ and one Son, and one Lord, who being the same is God and man». The expressions therefore that are used by this genuine and very accurate father, 'for he is one, and not without flesh', and, 'he who in his own nature is apart from flesh and blood', demonstrate this, as is plain from what we have demonstrated, that in the dispensatory conjunction he is not without flesh: for he is one composed of two elements, the Godhead and the manhood, which have a perfect existence in their own sphere; but in his own nature he is known to be apart from flesh and blood, and without a body; not that he mingled flesh with the nature or with the essence of the Godhead, but that he kept the Godhead sublime and pure and unmixed, in the characteristics of its own incorporeal character, as also he did not change the manhood which was hypostatically united to him, but kept it free and without change in its own characteristics. Wherefore also one may see that Nestorius and those who like Jews hold his opinions wish to reject the absence of change of the hypostatic union, and to put confusion into the minds of the believers, while they are everywhere making this charge, that we confess that the body was changed into the divine essence, and thereby hold one incarnate nature of God the Word, and they say that they themselves only, the wretched, unhappy men, keep the Godhead of the holy Trinity unmixed and pure, by confessing that the man from Mary, as they themselves say, in loving mercy was conjoined to God the Word and shares with him in sonship and divine authority, and by this self-created scruple they make the Trinity a quaternity. And for this reason the wise Cyril shows Nestorius also, who was their leader in this fatuity, speaking thus: «Therefore God the Word is named Christ also, because he has the eternal conjunction with Christ, and God the Word cannot do anything without the manhood: for he knows the coalescence exactly, not with the Godhead, as the new wise men amoug the doctors say». And the same man of small intellect weaves the same charge, and in the treatise entitled 'Against the Theopaschites or Cyrillians', which he composed in the form of question and answer, speaks thus:
The Theopaschite says: "How can we be accused of holding the Diphysite position on composition when we call Christ one incarnate nature of God?"
«The Theopaschite says: 'And how can we be accused of the composition of the Diphysites, we who call Christ one incarnate nature of God?'
The orthodox says: 'Your own refutation, which you think is a defense, refutes itself. For you have confessed that one physis is prepared for Christ, from incorporeality and a body, and a hypostasis with one physis of the incarnation of the Godhead. But this is the confusion of those who hold two physeis—that the physeis themselves are deprived of the hypostaseis which they severally possess, and are confounded with one another.'
The orthodox says: 'Your own refutation, which you think is a defence, itself refutes. For you have confessed that one nature is prepared for Christ, from incorporeality and a body, and a hypostasis with one nature of the incarnation of the Godhead. But this is the confusion of those who have two natures, that the natures themselves are deprived of the hypostases which they severally possess, that are confounded with one another'».
And again later in the same treatise:
And again farther on in the same treatise:
The Theopaschite says: "What do you think of an eggshell of water that has been poured into the sea?" The orthodox person says: "What else except that the unstable addition of the water has disappeared in the great volume of the sea?"
«The Theopaschite says: 'What do you think of an eggshell (?) of water that has been poured into the sea?' The orthodox says: 'What else except that the unstable addition of the water has disappeared in the great volume of the sea?'
The Theopaschite says: 'Something similar happened to the flesh as well: do not think that the Godhead is smaller than the sea in relation to the flesh, compared to the instability of the eggshell.'
The Theopaschite says: 'Something similar happened also to the flesh: for do not think that the Godhead is smaller than the sea in relation to the flesh as compared with the shifting character of the eggshell'.
The orthodox says: 'By "shifting character" do you mean a kind of instability, or the change of that which was swallowed up into that which swallowed it up?'
The orthodox says: 'By «shifting character» do you mean a kind of instability, or the change of that which was swallowed up into that which swallowed it up?'
The Theopaschite says: 'The change of the ousia of the body into the Godhead'.
The Theopaschite says: 'The change of the essence of the body into the Godhead'.
The orthodox person says: 'Does the physis of the body remain, or is it dissolved into non-existence?'
The orthodox says: 'The nature of the body remaining, or being dissolved into non-existence?'
The Theopaschite says: 'The flesh passing into the nature of the Godhead instead of the ousia of flesh.'
The Theopaschite says: 'The flesh passing into the nature of the Godhead instead of the essence of flesh'».
While putting together such empty arguments against the true confession of the Incarnation—arguments which, as I said before, fight against God—and saying that a man should be worshipped alongside the Trinity, Nestorius and his followers claim they preserve the unity of nature of the three hypostases unmixed by refusing to confess that God the Word was hypostatically united to flesh possessing an intelligent soul. They call this union, which is far beyond nature and immutable and wonderful, a "mingling." For this reason Dorotheus, who became bishop of Marcianopolis and belonged to the same Jewish faction and party, submitted a petition to Emperor Marcian himself at the very start of his reign. He criticized the position held by the bishops and the sound teaching of the holy churches, saying: "Therefore, merciful emperors, in light of their ridiculous—that is, lamentable—opinions, restore the firm maintenance of consubstantiality while it is still possible, while there is still time, by recalling Nestorius from exile, and reunite the divided people of Christ, lest—as I pray will not happen—the past be repeated." The holy Cyril therefore, having refuted such old wives' tales and Jewish fables throughout his writings, also said this in the first letter to Succensus, which I mentioned above: "But it is impossible for a body taken from earth to undergo change into the divine nature; it cannot be done. And if not, we speak of the Godhead as something created, and as something that has taken into itself something not naturally its own. For it is equally improper to say that the body was changed into the nature of the Godhead as to say that the Word was changed into the nature of flesh. For just as this is impossible (since he is unchangeable and immutable), so also is the other. For it is not possible for any created thing to pass into the ousia or physis of the Godhead. The body is also a created thing. Therefore we say that Christ's body is divine because it is God's body, radiant with ineffable glory, incorruptible, holy, and life-giving. But that it was changed into the nature of the Godhead—none of the holy fathers has either thought or said this, nor do we ourselves believe it." This fact, according to the teacher's statement, that the Word's body is radiant with ineffable glory, incorruptible, holy, and life-giving, Gregory the Theologian also demonstrated in his letter to Cledonius when he said that the Godhead overcame the incarnation. Accordingly, the flesh remained flesh even after the God-befitting Resurrection and Ascension, but adorned with divine and ineffable glory and with all the excellencies that befit God. It is divine as the body of God, but it was not changed into the ousia of the Godhead. It is in this sense that the teacher's expression we are now examining should rightly be understood: that God the Word is one and not without flesh, for he is incarnate by hypostatic union in flesh possessing an intelligent soul (though in his own nature he is without flesh and blood)—that is, without mixture with what he possesses in his ousia and physis, namely the bodiless, immutable, and incomprehensible Godhead.
While very vainly putting together such reasons against the right confession of the Humanization, as I said before, reasons which contend against God, and saying that a man should be worshipped with the Trinity, Nestorius and those who think with him state of themselves that they preserve the unity of nature of the three hypostases unmixed, in that they do not confess that God the Word was hypostatically united to flesh possessing an intelligent soul, and call the union that is so far above nature and immutable and wonderful mingling. Wherefore also Dorotheus, who became bishop of Marcianopolis, and belonged to the same Jewish company and party, presented a petition to Marcian's own self at the very beginning of his reign, and found fault with the position held by the bishops, and the sound opinion of the holy churches; and he speaks thus: «Therefore, merciful kings, in consideration of their so ridiculous, that is lamentable, opinions, renew the firm maintenance of the connaturality while it is possible, while there is time, by recalling Nestorius from exile, and join together the people of Christ who are divided, lest, as I pray may not happen, the past be repeated». The holy Cyril therefore, having exposed such old people's fables and Jewish tales in every part of his writings, in the first letter to Succensus also, which I mentioned above, said thus: «But it is impossible for a body taken from earth to endure the change into the divine nature; for it cannot be done. And, if not, we speak of the Godhead as a thing that is made, and as a thing that has taken into it something that is not its by nature. For on the score of impropriety it is equal for us to say that the body was changed into the nature of Godhead, and also the other thing too that the Word was changed into the nature of flesh. For, as this is impossible (for he is invariable and immutable), so also is the other. For it is not among possibilities that any created thing can pass into the essence or nature of Godhead. But the body too is a created thing. Accordingly we say that Christ's body is divine, because it is also God's body, and resplendent with ineffable glory, incorruptible, holy, life-giving: but, that it was changed into the nature of Godhead, none of the holy fathers has either thought or said, nor do we ourselves so hold». This fact therefore according to the expression of the doctor, that the body of the Word is resplendent with ineffable glory, incorruptible and holy and life-giving, Gregory the Theologian also in the demonstration contained in the letter to Gledonius demonstrated by saying that the Godhead overcame the incarnation. Accordingly the flesh remained flesh, even after the God-befitting Resurrection and Ascension, but adorned with divine and ineffable glory, and with all the excellencies that befit God; and it is divine as something that is the body of God, and it was not changed into the essence of the Godhead. It is in this meaning that the expression of the doctor with which we are now concerned also should rightly be understood that God the Word is one and not without flesh: for he is incarnate by hypostatic union in flesh possessing an intelligent soul (but in his own nature he is without flesh and blood), that is, without mixture with what he possesses in his essence and nature, that is the bodiless and immutable and incomprehensible Godhead.
Regarding what you say at the end—that the man who easily follows illusions and shifts his position widely said, on the advice of certain persons, that we must think of the Word of God in the infinity of his divine essence without flesh—this is very foolish and senseless. Even though the Word of God is infinite, the whole of him was united to the flesh that was received from the holy Virgin, the God-bearer and ever-virgin Mary, united in the very hypostasis of the Word and not by a partial operation as in the prophets. How then is it anything but ridiculous for us to say that he who was in the actual divine hypostasis wholly united to a body, both naturally and miraculously, is without flesh, even in the greatness of his infinite Godhead? For 'there is no limit to his greatness', as David said, and he fills everything, is above everything, and cannot be contained by anyone. And the subtlety of the mystery cannot be explored by reason and intellect—how the whole of him was in flesh, and the whole of him is in all things, and the whole of him is superior to all things, and he himself is Ruler of all in infinity. But that we believe that the very hypostasis of God the Word became incarnate, according to the apostolic tradition of the church that has been handed down from of old, it is superfluous for us to demonstrate by testimonies to those who have once believed in the Gospel, when John, who was divine in words beyond the evangelists, said, "The Word became flesh and came to dwell in us." However, since there is doubt about it, and in order that we may close the doors against all contention, on this point too let the words of the father himself—I mean the holy Cyril—come to our assistance. In the defense of the second chapter addressed to Theodoret the deceiver, he wrote thus: "Since Nestorius therefore everywhere eliminates the birth in flesh and introduces among us a union of authority only, and says that a man was conjoined to God who is honored by identity of name of sonship, in contending against his propositions we were compelled to say that the hypostatic union took place, in which expression the word 'hypostatic' denotes nothing else except this only: that the physis itself or his hypostasis, which is the Word himself, after it has been united to human physis without variation and confusion, as we have often said, is recognized as one Christ and is so, the same God and man." After the same fashion in the Scholia also he comes forward with the same words as follows: "'For in him dwelt all the fullness of the Godhead bodily,' that is not by assumption simply, like light that shines, or fire that imparts its heat to the objects near it, but, if we may so say, that the divine and incontaminable physis itself by a true union as I have said made the temple from the Virgin a dwelling-place for that which he is recognized to be. For thus Christ Jesus is recognized to be one." But that the whole of him was in a body and was hypostatically united to it—him of whom all things were divinely full—he himself confirms by his own words. For it is written in the Gospel of John also that he said to Nicodemus, "No man has gone up to heaven, except him who came down from heaven, the Son of man who is in heaven"; though he did not come down from heaven in that he became man, for he did not bring the flesh down from heaven, but he received it from the holy Virgin, flesh that is of our race and of our physis. Nor again, when he was speaking to Nicodemus, was he corporeally in heaven; but incorporeally, in that he is God, heaven and earth and what is above heaven were perpetually full of him. And in the eighth section of the second of the books against Julian the great in demon-worship, which were written by him in defense of the Christian religion, the doctor shows how the Word of God, while he is all in all, was hypostatically united to the flesh derived from the holy Mary, and, beyond every creature, filled all things by reception from him (in a suprasensual sense nothing is empty of him), though the infinity of his greatness surpasses and soars above all things that exist with a great space between (how great it is impossible to say): by whom according to the words of Isaiah "all the nations have been reckoned as a drop from a pot, and as the sand of a balance." But the holy Cyril again speaks thus: "He has become, as I said, in the likeness of men, as it is written, and in our human appearance truly. Nevertheless we did not say that he who cannot be contained was confined, nor that he was enclosed in the limits of the body. For it is utterly silly and complete folly to say anything of the kind of him who is by physis and in truth God. For, while he is one and the only Son, and completely above all human imagination, the whole of him is in virtue of a gift in every man, and in each one by presence, not being divided nor cleft asunder, but above everything by physis, and in everything as God. But in that all-pure and holy body 'all the fullness of the Godhead bodily has come to dwell,' as it is written. And he was as in his own flesh, but still even so he filled all things from him." And in the treatise addressed to the queens, the opening words of which are "Those who administer the divine and heavenly preaching," he explains the meaning of the statement that the Word of God and all the fullness of the Godhead came to dwell in flesh as written by Paul in this way: "But we believe that the Word became flesh, not by way of removal or change, but rather that he came to dwell in us, and, to speak correctly, made the body that was in truth united to him, possessing an intelligent soul, his own temple. And the divine Paul, declaring the indwelling of the Word in the holy flesh, or the true union, said that in him all the fullness of the Godhead came to dwell, not so much by way of assumption or presence, or by way of a gift of grace, but bodily, that is in essence; as in the case of a man also it is said that his spirit dwells in him, though it is not something different from him." How then shall we say that he who is wholly in everything by way of gift, and in each man in presence (for he receives all things from him and they depend upon his presence), and who further also is in everything and is nowhere cleft asunder or divided, and further is wholly in the all-holy flesh in essence, and so is united to it, after the fashion in which the soul of a man like us is united to its own body—how shall we say that he is without his own flesh, because he filled all these things with the gift of himself, he who is infinite, and is wholly in everything? But to inquire into such a marvelous subject is a piece of utter foolishness: for glorious things are sealed by faith only. In the other treatise addressed to the religious virgin queens, Arcadia and Marina, which begins "The world's boast," the same wise Cyril inserted a demonstration from the holy John who became bishop of Constantinople, who spoke about the God-bearer Mary, and about the birth of God the Word, as follows: "'And instead of a sun she contained without confining the Sun of righteousness. And do not ask how: for, where God wills, the order of physis is defeated. For he willed, he was able, he came down, and he saved. All things run into one for God. Today he who is is born, and he who is became that which he was not. For, being God, he became man, not by departing from being God; for he did not become man by departure from Godhead, nor did he become God by growth from man: but, being the Word, he became flesh on account of suffering, while he remained invariable in his physis.' And he adds to these things: 'He who sits upon a lofty and high throne is laid in a manger. He who is intangible and simple and bodiless is grasped by human hands. He who cuts asunder the bonds of sin is wrapped in swaddling-clothes.'" And the saintly Proclus who became bishop of the same city in the exposition which he delivered in the church of Anthimus on the feast of the Resurrection spoke to the same effect as follows: "The heaven cries, 'He who became man, who was crucified in flesh, is God: for as God he caused me to incline and came down.' The sun also cries, 'He who was crucified in flesh is my Lord: for I in fear of the light of the Godhead held back my rays.' The earth also cries, 'He who clothed himself in a body, who was crucified in flesh, is the Maker: for, though I embraced his flesh in a manger, yet I did not confine the might of his Godhead.'" It would have been possible to add other things
As for what you say at the end that the man who easily follows illusions (?) and shifts his ground widely said on the advice of certain persons, that we must think of the Word of God in the infinity of his divine essence without flesh, is very foolish and senseless. Even though the Word of God is infinite, the whole of him was united to the flesh that was received from the holy Virgin, the God-bearer and ever-virgin Mary, even the very person of the Word and not a partial operation as in the prophets. How then is it anything but ridiculous for us to say that he who was in the actual divine hypostasis wholly united to a body naturally as well as miraculously is without flesh, even in the greatness of his infinite Godhead? For 'there is no limit to his greatness', as David said, and he fills everything, and is above everything, and cannot be comprised by anyone. And the subtlety of the mystery cannot be explored by reason and intellect, how the whole of him was in flesh, and the whole of him is in all things and the whole of him is superior to all things and he himself is Ruler of all in infinity. But, that we believe that the very hypostasis of God the Word became incarnate, according to the apostolic tradition of the church that has been handed down from of old, it is superfluous for us to demonstrate by testimonies to those who have once believed in the Gospel, when John who was divine in words beyond the evangelists said, «The Word became flesh and came to dwell in us». How ever, since there is a doubt about it, and in order that we may close the doors against all contention, on this point too let the words of the father himself, I mean the holy Cyril, come to our assistance, who in the defence of the second chapter addressed to Theodoret the deceiver wrote thus: «Since Nestorius therefore everywhere eliminates the birth in flesh, and introduces among us a union of authority only, and says that a man was conjoined to God, who is honoured by identity of name of sonship, in contending against his propositions we were compelled to say that the hypostatic union took place, in which expression the word 'hypostatic' denotes nothing else except this only, that the nature itself or his hypostasis, which is the Word himself, after it has been united to human nature without variation and confusion, as we have often said, is recognised as one Christ [and] is so, the same God and man». After the same fashion in the Scholia also he comes forward with the same words as follows: «'For in him dwelt all the fulness of the Godhead bodily', that is not by assumption simply, like light that shines, or fire that imparts its heat [to] the objects near it, but, if we may so say, that the divine and incontaminable nature itself by a true union as I have said made the temple from the Virgin a dwelling-place for that which he is recognised to be. For thus Christ Jesus is recognised to be one». But, that the whole of him was in a body, and was hypostatically united to it, him of whom all things were divinely full, he himself confirms by his own words. For it is written in the Gospel of John also that he said to Nicodemus, «No man hath gone up to heaven, except him who came down from heaven, the Son of man who is in heaven»; though he did not come down from heaven in that he became man, for he did not bring the flesh down from heaven, but he received it from the holy Virgin, flesh that is of our race, and of our nature. Nor again, when he was speaking to Nicodemus, was he corporeally in heaven; but incorporeally, in that he is God, heaven and earth and what is above heaven were perpetually full of him. And in the eighth section of the second of the books against Julian the great in demon-worship, which were written by him in defence of the Christian religion, the doctor shows how the Word of God, while he is all in all, was hypostatic ally united to the flesh derived from the holy Mary, and, beyond every creature, filled all things by reception from him (in a suprasensual sense nothing is empty of him), though the infinity of his greatness surpasses and soars above all things that exist with a great space between (how great it is impossible to say): by whom according to the words of Isaiah «all the nations have been reckoned as a drop from a pot, and as the sand of a balance». But the holy Cyril again speaks thus: «He has become, as I said, in the likeness of men, as it is written, and in our human appearance truly. Nevertheless we did not say that he who cannot be comprised was confined, nor that he was inclosed in the limits of the body. For it is utterly silly and complete folly to say anything of the kind of him who is by nature and in truth God. For, while he is one and the only Son, and completely above all human phantasy, the whole of him is in virtue of a gift in every man, and in each [one] by presence, not being divided nor cleft asunder, but [above] everything by nature, and in everything as God. 'But in that all-pure and holy body 'all the fulness of the Godhead bodily has come to dwell', as it is written. And he was as in his own flesh, but still even so he filled all things from him». And in the treatise addressed to the queens the opening words of which are, Those who administer the divine and heavenly preaching', he explains the meaning of the statement that the Word of God and all the fulness of the Godhead came to dwell in flesh as written by Paul in this way: «But we believe that the Word became flesh, not by way of removal or change, but rather that he came to dwell in us, and, to speak correctly, made the body that was in truth united to him, possessing an intelligent soul, his own temple. And the divine Paul, declaring the indwelling of the Word in the holy flesh, or the true union, said that in him all the fulness of the Godhead came to dwell, not so much by way of assumption or presence, or by way of a gift of grace, but bodily, that is in essence; as in the case of a man also it is said [that] his spirit dwells in him, though it is not something different from him». How then shall we say [that] he who is wholly in everything by way of gift, and in each man in presence (for he receives all things from him and they depend upon his presence), and who further also is in everything and is nowhere cleft asunder or divided, and further is wholly in the all-holy flesh in essence, and so is united to it, after the fashion in which the soul of a man like us is united to its own body, how shall we say that he is without his own flesh, because he filled all these things with the gift of himself, he who is infinite, and is wholly in everything? But to inquire into such a marvellous subject is a piece of utter foolishness: for glorious things are sealed by faith only. In the other treatise addressed to the religious virgin queens, Arcadia and Marina, which begins, 'The world's boast', the same wise Cyril inserted a demonstration from the holy John who became bishop of Constantinople, who spoke about the God-bearer Mary, and about the birth of God the Word, as follows: «'And instead of a sun she contained without confining the Sun of righteousness. And do not ask how: for, where God wills, the order of nature is defeated. For he willed, he was able, he came down, and he saved. All things run into one for God. To-day he who is is born, and he who is became that which he was not. For, being God, he became man, not by departing from being God; for he did not became man by departure from Godhead, nor did he become God by growth from man: but, being the Word, he became flesh on account of suffering, while he remained invariable in his nature'. And he adds to these things: 'He who sits upon a lofty and high throne is laid in a manger. He who is intangible and simple and bodiless is grasped by human hands. He who cuts asunder the bonds of sin is wrapped in swaddling-clothes'». And the saintly Proclus who became bishop of the same city in the exposition which he delivered in the church of Anthimus on the feast of the Resurrection spoke to the same effect as follows: «The heaven cries, 'He who became man, who was crucified in flesh, is God: for as God he caused me to incline and came down'. The sun also cries, 'He who was crucified in flesh is my Lord: for I in fear of the light of the Godhead held-back my rays'. The earth also cries, 'He who clothed himself in a body, who was crucified in flesh, is the Maker: for, though I embraced his flesh in a manger, yet I did not confine the might of his Godhead'». It would have been possible to add other things also which are like these and resemble them, but it is superfluous to add to what has been so wisely said, and make the discussion inordinately long. But I pray your holy assembly and lawful church to be of the same mind, as the apostle said, and conform to the same rule, and, if any disputed point arises, not make this a cause of strife and division, and of useless contentions, but lovingly join with one another in the inquiry. But, if any of you has anything to say, let him speak with humble mind, as the words of God, as Peter the 'chosen apostle gave admonition. If anything also needs further explanation, you must not act hastily, nor be in a hurry, but await the proper time, and bring it before the saintly bishops, and accept the healing that they shall apply. As for the brother who gave occasion for this dispute, since we have written these few words, receive him lovingly, and strengthen him, and acknowledge him as your member. And, whether he is one man, or many who were associated with him in this dispute or ignorance, act in the same way towards them: for concerning those who are such the apostle commands us and says, at one time, «Him that is weak in the faith bring near to you», and at another, «And reckon them not as enemies, but admonish them as brothers». It is not because they made inquiries, or because they were ignorant that they are blameworthy; on the contrary they would actually have been praised, if they had discussed the point with humility, and not with haste and confusion, and with a desire to add to ignorance; for this is what prevented them from being received in regard to the discussion which they raised. However, now that we have written so much, let love vanquish everything, and let not these distressing matters come even into remembrance: for 'love' also, as it is written, 'covers a multitude of sins'; which love may the God of love and the lawgiver Christ also strengthen in you.
May you be made perfect in the Lord, being sound and living in the Spirit, and remembering me, our devout and Christ-loving brothers.
The signature. May you be made perfect in the Lord, being sound, and living in the Spirit, and remembering me, our religious and Christ-loving brothers.
The end.
The end.
