Letter 97
From the same, from the 74th letter, from the 3rd book of those written after exile, which was addressed to Caesaria the hypatissa, which begins, "The various communications addressed to me by your highness".
OF THE SAME FROM THE 74th LETTER. OF THE 3rd BOOK OF THOSE AFTER EXILE WHICH WAS ADDRESSED TO CAESARIA THE HYPATISSA WHICH BEGINS, «The various communications addressed to me by your highness».
You also ask another question raised by the Phantasiasts, who hold Manichean views. They think they're making an argument that can't be refuted: "If our Lord underwent the circumcision required by the law—when, as the gospel says, 'eight days were accomplished for circumcising him, and his name was called Jesus'—what happened to his foreskin?" These wretched people think they've cornered us. They don't understand that it would be an act of their own godless foolishness for us to refuse to acknowledge what is written just because of what is not written. It's not only the gospel that testifies through these cited words that Christ was circumcised according to the law, but also Paul. Writing to the Romans, he says, "For I say that Christ became a minister of circumcision on behalf of the truth of God, that he might confirm the promises made to the fathers." To Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob our fathers, both the covenant of circumcision was given and the promise was made: "In your seed shall all the families of the nations be blessed"—for Christ was their seed. So in his letter to the Galatians, Paul says, "But to Abraham were the promises made and to his seed; for he does not say 'and to seeds' as to many, but as to one, 'and to your seed,' which is Christ." Christ came to fulfill those promises—truly to endure circumcision in the flesh and to carry out the dispensation that consists in this. The whole principle of the dispensation is dispensation and service. In this way he gathered all the nations by faith in him and made them Abraham's sons. Since the God-inspired Scripture says that he was truly circumcised, who would presume to say that he didn't undergo circumcision? This is what those who teach the phantasy seek to deny, along with everything else. Just because nothing is written about the portion of himself that was cut off—I mean the foreskin—we won't therefore stop confessing that he was truly circumcised. He said, "For so it is fitting for us to fulfill all righteousness," and was made like us in everything except sin. Perhaps some God-befitting miracle was performed with regard to the portion that was cut off, which Scripture left unknown to us. For us to guess about unknown matters is very dangerous. But what is already known for certain is this: when he rose from the dead, he took that portion too, since it is part of the whole body. He preserved it without corruption according to ineffable methods which he understands. We too will receive our own body complete at the resurrection, not bearing the diminishment caused by wounds or other injuries, but whole and perfect. It's good to ask these impious men—who think that such questions frighten those who believe rightly and make us not acknowledge that our Lord suffered real sufferings in the body—what they themselves say about the blood that came out from his pure side mixed with water. Did it reach the earth? The holy gospel Scripture doesn't declare this either. Let them themselves be frightened by the fear of loss. It's consistent for them to say that the blood was poured out only in appearance and didn't really flow. But John, who became bishop of Constantinople and was a bold preacher of the true dispensation, wasn't frightened by the fear of these impious men in his homily titled "Concerning the cross and concerning the robber, and concerning the fact that we should frequently pray for enemies." He said that the blood dropped upon the earth and purified all of it, writing as follows: "But why is he slaughtered at the height of the tree and not under a roof? To purify the nature of the air, therefore it is done high up, without a roof above him, but heaven. The air was purified by the sheep being sacrificed high up. But the earth also was purified, for the blood dropped from the side upon it." So if, by the same logic, the foreskin that was cut off touched the earth, it certainly also sanctified it. By methods which he himself understands—he who was voluntarily circumcised—he certainly preserved it, as I said before. At the time of the Resurrection, he rose with the whole body complete and without corruption, having this portion also undiminished, although he showed the scars of the nails and the lance. With these he will also appear to those who pierced him, according to the unerring words of the God-inspired Scripture.
And the other thing also which you ask is a question of the Phantasiasts who hold the opinions of the Manichees, since they think that they are propounding and saying something against which it is impossible to argue: «If our Lord underwent the circumcision required by the law, 'when', as the gospel says, 'eight days were accomplished for circumcising him, and his name was called Jesus', what happened to his foreskin?»; for those wretched men think that they are driving us into a corner, and do not understand that it would be an act of their own godless lack of intelligence for us to refuse to acknowledge things that are written on account of things that are not written. It is not the gospel only which testifies through these words which have been cited that Christ was circumcised according to the law, but Paul also, who in writing to the Romans says, «For I say that Christ became a minister of circumcision on behalf of the truth of God, that he might confirm the promises made to the fathers». For to Abraham and Isaac and Jacob our fathers both the covenant of circumcision was given, and the promise was made, «In thy seed shall all the families of the nations be blessed»; for Christ was their seed. Therefore also in writing the epistle to the Galatians he says, «But to Abraham were the promises made and to his seed; for he saith not 'and to seeds' as to many, but, as to one, 'and to thy seed', which is Christ». In order to carry out the accomplishment of those promises therefore Christ came, and truly to endure circumcision in the flesh, and to carry out the dispensation that consists in this; for the whole principle of the dispensation is dispensation and service; and so he caught all the nations by faith in him and made them Abraham's sons. Since therefore the God-inspired Scripture says that he was circumcised in reality, who is he who presumes to say that he did not undergo circumcision? a thing which those who teach the phantasy seek to deny along with the other things. Because nothing is written about the portion of himself that was cut off (I refer to the foreskin), we will not therefore refrain from confessing that he was circumcised in reality, he who said, «For so it becometh us to fulfil all justice», and was in everything made like unto us except sin. Perhaps indeed some God-befitting miracle was performed with regard to the portion that was cut off, which Scripture left unknown to us; and for us to guess about unknown matters is a thing of great danger. But what is assuredly already known is this, that, when he rose from the dead, he took that also, inasmuch as it is a portion of the whole body, and he preserved it with this without corruption according to ineffable methods which he understands. For we also shall receive our own body complete at the resurrection, not carrying the diminution caused by sores or other injuries, but whole and perfect. It is a good thing to ask the impious men, who think that by such questions they frighten those who believe rightly, so as to reduce us not to acknowledge that our Lord suffered real sufferings in the body, what they themselves say about the blood which came out from the pure rib mixed with water. Did it reach the earth? For this also is not declared by the holy Scripture of the gospel. But let them themselves be frightened by the fear of loss; and it is consistent for them to say that the blood was poured, out in semblance only, and did not flow in reality. But John, who became bishop of Constantinople and was a preacher of the true dispensation with boldness, in the homily entitled 'Concerning the cross and concerning the robber, and concerning the fact that we should frequently pray for enemies' was not frightened by the fear of these impious men, but said that the blood dropped upon the earth and purified the whole of it, inasmuch as he wrote thus: «But why is he slaughtered at the height of the tree, and not under a roof? In order to purify the nature of the air, therefore it is done high up, without a roof above him, but heaven. For the air was purified by the sheep being sacrificed high up. But the earth also was purified; for the blood dropped from the rib upon it». Accordingly therefore, if on this analogy the foreskin that was cut off touched the earth, it assuredly also sanctified it, and by methods which he himself understands who was voluntarily circumcised, he assuredly, as I said before, preserved it; and at the time of the Resurrection he rose with the whole body complete and without corruption, having this portion also undiminished, although he showed the scars of the nails and the lance; with which he will also appear to those who pierced him, according to the unerring words of the God-inspired Scripture.
