A Collection of Letters — Letter 52 — To Philip the Presbyter and Monk

From the same author, from the second letter to the same Philip, presbyter and monk, concerning the formation of humanity, and that the monastic habit frees one from previous sins.

Letter 52

From the same author, from the second letter to the same Philip, presbyter and monk, concerning the formation of humanity, and that the monastic habit frees one from previous sins.

OF THE SAME FROM THE 2nd LETTER TO THE SAME PHILIP THE PRESBYTER AND MONK ABOUT THE FORMATION OF MAN, AND THAT THE MONASTIC HABIT FREES FROM PREVIOUS SINS.

And now I turn to the statement made by your religiousness, that one of those who live an ascetic life of philosophical labor came and presented himself for ordination so that he might serve as a priest to God. But afterwards he remembered his earlier life and the sins he had committed in his youth and throughout the rest of his life. Having learned that the canon requires blamelessness, he sought to exclude himself from the priestly ministry, in a way renouncing ordination to satisfy the canon. How is this acceptable? Tell me, how is this anything but the result of false modesty? You write that this man has lived both earnestly and according to the rules of philosophy and, to use Scripture's language, watches over himself. If the facts of that great sin which bars one from the priesthood or from ministry had happened after his profession of monastic life, then there would have been reason for modesty to play its part. But when the facts of the sin happened first and enrollment in philosophy followed, how is it right to feel fear where no fear exists? We believe, not without the divine Spirit, that the holy habit of monastic life carries forgiveness of sins and strips off the old man "who is corrupted in the lusts of error" and puts on "the new man who was created in God, in righteousness and sanctity of truth," as the wise Paul somewhere wrote. I offer, though I am addressing those who know, in confirmation of what has been stated, the vision which that heavenly man, the great Antony, saw. What does the man who told the story of his life say—the divine Athanasius who is among the high priests? "When he was about to eat and had risen to pray at the ninth hour, he felt his consciousness lifted up, and (wonderful to relate!) he felt himself standing and seeing himself as if he had been taken outside himself, and as if he were being led into the air by some men. Afterwards some grievous and cruel men standing in the air sought to prevent him from passing. When the conductors opposed them, these demanded an account to know if he were liable to them. But when they sought to make an account from his birth, those who were leading Antony prevented it, saying to these: 'What happened from his birth the Lord has wiped out; but you may inquire into the time since he became a monk and made profession to God.' Then when they made charges and failed to convict, the road was made free and unimpeded before him. And immediately he saw himself standing, as if he had come to himself, and he was again wholly Antony." Guided therefore by this divine command, I have answered the present question, and I affirm and say with confidence that that modest man must retain the priestly ministry. By his very scrupulousness and carefulness he has conferred a great benefit upon us, and by this wise and modest question has restrained with apostolic salt those who gape for priestly offices and run after ordinations like the pomp and honors of the world, those whose minds are fixed on pride or on visions of earthly things, and who treat as of no account the judgments we shall receive for these things when the day of judgment arrives—which will assuredly come and is spoken of by everyone's mouth but is looked for by few as it should be.

And now I turn to the statement made by your religiousness, that one of those who live an ascetic life of philosophic labour, after he had come and presented himself for ordination in order that he might officiate as a priest to God, having afterwards come to remember his life, and the sins that he had committed in his boyhood, and all the rest of his life, and having learned that the canon requires blamelessness, sought to range himself outside the priestly ministry, and in a way renounce ordination, and satisfy the canon. How is this endurable? tell me; and how is it anything but a result of false modesty? You write that this man has lived both with earnestness and according to the ordinances of philosophy, and, to speak in the language of Scripture, looks to himself. If the facts of that great sin which cuts off from the priesthood or from the ministry had happened after the profession of monastic life, then there would have been reason for modesty to play its part. But, where the facts of the sin happened firsthand the enrolling in philosophy followed, how is it right to feel fear where no fear is? We believe, not without the divine Spirit, that the holy habit of the monastic life carries forgiveness of sins, and strips off the old man 'who is corrupted in the lusts of error', and puts on 'the new man who was created in God, in righteousness and sanctity of truth', as the wise Paul somewhere said in writing. I adduce, although I am addressing those who know, in confirmation of what has been stated, the vision which that heavenly man the great Antony saw. What in fact does the man who told the story of his life say, the divine Athanasius who is among the high-priests? «When he was about to eat, and had risen to pray at the 9th hour, he felt his consciousness lifted up, and (wonderful to relate!) he felt himself standing and seeing himself, as if he had been taken outside him, and as if he were being led into the air by some men, and afterwards some grievous and cruel men standing in the air and seeking to prevent him from passing. And, when the conductors opposed, these required an account to know if he were not liable to them; but, when they sought to make an account from his birth, those who were leading Antony prevented it, saying to these: 'What happened from his birth the Lord has wiped out; but you may inquire into the time since he became a monk and made profession to God'. Then upon their making charges and failing to convict, the road was made free and unimpeded before him. And immediately he saw himself standing, as if he had come to himself, and that he was again wholly Antony». Guided therefore by this divine command, I have answered the present question; and I affirm and say with confidence that that modest man must retain the priestly ministry, since with his very scrupulousness and carefulness he has conferred a great benefit upon us, and by the wise and modest question has astringed with apostolic salt those who gape for priestly offices, and fun after ordinations, like the pomp and honours of the world, and those whose minds are fixed on pride or on visions of things here, and who treat as of no account the judgments which we shall receive for these things, when the day of judgment arrives, which will assuredly come, and is spoken of by every one's mouth, but is looked for by few as it should be looked for.