A Collection of Letters — Letter 33 — To Neon the Presbyter and Archimandrite

From the holy Severus, from the letter to Neon the presbyter and archimandrite, about the reception of Eutyches. Written 513–8.

Letter 33

From the holy Severus, from the letter to Neon the presbyter and archimandrite, about the reception of Eutyches.

OF THE HOLY SEVERUS, FROM THE LETTER TO NEON THE PRESBYTER AND ARCHIMANDRITE, ABOUT THE RECEPTION OF EUTYCHES.

And, to keep this letter from becoming too long, these statements have clearly shown that, as we said, the holy synod that assembled in the city of Ephesus made its decision declaring this man innocent based on the document and the minutes written in the royal city, and the depositions on behalf of Eutyches contained in them. The synod can never be accused because of the fact that afterward this same Eutyches returned to the vomit of his own evil opinion. This brought no reproach against the holy fathers, because many heretics agreed to a temporary hypocrisy and then returned to their impiety. Even with the 318 holy fathers, Eusebius Pamphili both sat in assembly with them and was one of their number, yet he contended with them on behalf of the madness of Arius and armed himself against those who held the right opinions.

And, in order not to extend the letter to a great length, from these declarations it has been clearly made known that, as we said, in consequence of the document' and of the minutes written in the royal city, and of the depositions on behalf of Eutyches that are contained in them the holy synod which then assembled in the city of the Ephesians gave a decision by which it declared this man innocent; and it can never be accused on account of the fact that after these things the same Eutyches ran back to the vomit of his own evil opinion. For neither against the holy fathers did this bring a reproach, because many heretics consented to a temporary hypocrisy, and again returned to their impiety; since even with the 318 holy fathers Eusebius Pamphili both sat in concourse with them and was one of their number; and he contended with these on behalf of the madness of Arius, and armed himself against those who held the right opinions.

And a little farther on.

( And a little farther on.)

But in the synod at Chalcedon, Dioscorus said this: "But if Eutyches holds anything outside the doctrines of the church, he deserves not merely punishment, but even fire. But I am concerned for the catholic and apostolic faith, not for any man whatever." But why do we need any other testimony that the saintly man of blessed memory acknowledged that Emmanuel, who is of the Father's nature in the Godhead, himself also became of our nature in the manhood? The minutes that were written in Constantinople before Flavian and brought in again at Ephesus plainly contain this statement, which was confessed by Eutyches and confirmed by him, in that he asked that synod, "Do we all also agree to these things?" and they said, "We agree."

But in the synod at Chalcedon Dioscorus said this: «But, if Eutyches holds anything outside the doctrines of the church, he deserves not merely punishment, but even fire. But I concern myself for the catholic and apostolic faith, not for any man soever». But that the saintly man of saintly memory acknowledged Emmanuel who is of the Father's nature in the Godhead himself to have become also of our nature in the manhood, how do we need any other testimony, since the minutes that were written in Constantinople before Flavian, and brought in again at Ephesus, plainly contain this expression, which was confessed by Eutyches, and confirmed by him, in that he asked that synod, «Do we all also agree to these things?» and they said, «We agree»?