On the Trinity — Book IV

Why the Son was sent: the one death and resurrection of Christ heal our double death; the Son is sent by the Father without being less than Him.

Explains for what the Son of God was sent, viz, that by Christ's dying for sinners, we were to be convinced how great is God's love for us, and also what manner of men we are whom He loved. That the Word came in the flesh, to the purpose also of enabling us to be so cleansed as to contemplate and cleave to God. That our double death was abolished by His death, being one and single. And hereupon is discussed, how the single of our Saviour harmonizes to salvation with our double; and the perfection is treated at length of the senary number, to which the ratio itself of single to double is reducible. That all are gathered together from many into one by the one Mediator of life, viz. Christ, through Whom alone is wrought the true cleansing of the soul. Further it is demonstrated that the Son of God, although made less by being sent, on account of the form of a servant which He took, is not therefore less than the Father according to the form of God, because He was sent by Himself: and that the same account is to be given of the sending of the Holy Spirit.

Source: Translated by Arthur West Haddan. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 3. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1887. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/130104.htm>.

Contents · 22 chapters
  1. Preface.– The Knowledge of God is to Be Sought from God.
  2. Chapter 1.– We are Made Perfect by Acknowledgement of Our Own Weakness. The Incarnate Word Dispels Our Darkness.
  3. Chapter 2.– How We are Rendered Apt for the Perception of Truth Through the Incarnate Word.
  4. Chapter 3.– The One Death and Resurrection of The Body of Christ Harmonizes with Our Double Death and Resurrection of Body and Soul, to the Effect of Salvation. In What Way the Single Death of Christ is Bestowed Upon Our Double Death.
  5. Chapter 4.– The Ratio of the Single to the Double Comes from the Perfection of the Senary Number. The Perfection of The Senary Number is Commended in the Scriptures. The Year Abounds in The Senary Number.
  6. Chapter 5.– The Number Six is Also Commended in the Building Up of the Body of Christ and of the Temple at Jerusalem.
  7. Chapter 6.– The Three Days of the Resurrection, in Which Also the Ratio of Single to Double is Apparent.
  8. Chapter 7.– In What Manner We are Gathered from Many into One Through One Mediator.
  9. Chapter 8.– In What Manner Christ Wills that All Shall Be One in Himself.
  10. Chapter 9.– The Same Argument Continued.
  11. Chapter 10.– As Christ is the Mediator of Life, So the Devil is the Mediator of Death.
  12. Chapter 11.– Miracles Which are Done by Demons are to Be Spurned.
  13. Chapter 12.– The Devil the Mediator of Death, Christ of Life.
  14. Chapter 13.– The Death of Christ Voluntary. How the Mediator of Life Subdued the Mediator of Death. How the Devil Leads His Own to Despise the Death of Christ.
  15. Chapter 14.– Christ the Most Perfect Victim for Cleansing Our Faults. In Every Sacrifice Four Things are to Be Considered.
  16. Chapter 15.– They are Proud Who Think They are Able, by Their Own Righteousness, to Be Cleansed So as to See God.
  17. Chapter 16.– The Old Philosophers are Not to Be Consulted Concerning the Resurrection and Concerning Things to Come.
  18. Chapter 17.– In How Many Ways Things Future are Foreknown. Neither Philosophers, Nor Those Who Were Distinguished Among the Ancients, are to Be Consulted Concerning the Resurrection of the Dead.
  19. Chapter 18.– The Son of God Became Incarnate in Order that We Being Cleansed by Faith May Be Raised to the Unchangeable Truth.
  20. Chapter 19.– In What Manner the Son Was Sent and Proclaimed Beforehand. How in the Sending of His Birth in the Flesh He Was Made Less Without Detriment to His Equality with the Father.
  21. Chapter 20.– The Sender and the Sent Equal. Why the Son is Said to Be Sent by the Father. Of the Mission of the Holy Spirit. How and by Whom He Was Sent. The Father the Beginning of the Whole Godhead.
  22. Chapter 21.– Of the Sensible Showing of the Holy Spirit, and of the Coeternity of the Trinity. What Has Been Said, and What Remains to Be Said.

Preface.– The Knowledge of God is to Be Sought from God.

People commonly think highly of knowledge about earthly and heavenly things. Yet those who prefer knowing themselves to that knowledge surely judge better. A mind that knows even its own weakness is more praiseworthy than one that searches out and even discovers the workings of the stars, or holds onto such knowledge already gained, while remaining ignorant of the way to enter into its own proper health and strength. But if anyone has already awakened toward God, kindled by the warmth of the Holy Spirit, and in the love of God has become worthless in his own eyes, and through wanting but lacking the strength to come to Him, and through the light He gives, has paid attention to himself, and has discovered himself, and has learned that his own filthiness cannot mix with God's purity, and finds it sweet to weep and to beg Him that again and again He will have compassion until he has cast off all his wretchedness, and to pray confidently as one who has already received as a free gift the pledge of salvation through his only Savior and Enlightener of humanity—such a person, acting and lamenting this way, is not puffed up by knowledge, because charity builds up. For he has preferred one knowledge to another knowledge: he has preferred to know his own weakness rather than to know the walls of the world, the foundations of the earth, and the heights of heaven. And by obtaining this knowledge, he has also obtained sorrow—but sorrow for wandering away from the desire to reach his own proper homeland and the Creator of it, his own blessed God. And if among such people, in the family of Your Christ, O Lord my God, I groan among Your poor, give me from Your bread to answer people who do not hunger and thirst after righteousness, but are satisfied and have plenty. But it is the empty image of those things that has satisfied them, not Your truth, which they have pushed away and shrunk back from, and so they fall into their own emptiness. I certainly know how many fantasies the human heart produces. And what is my own heart but a human heart? But I pray to the God of my heart that I may not vomit forth into these writings any of these fantasies as solid truths, but that only what the breath of His truth has breathed into me may pass into them—cast out though I am from the sight of His eyes, and striving from far away to return by the way which the divinity of His only-begotten Son has made through His humanity. And this truth, changeable though I am, I drink in to the extent that in it I see nothing changeable: not in place and time, as is the case with bodies, nor in time alone and in a certain sense place, as with the thoughts of our own spirits, nor in time alone and not even in any appearance of place, as with some of the reasonings of our own minds. For the ousia of God, by which He is, has absolutely nothing changeable, neither in eternity, nor in truth, nor in will, since there truth is eternal, love eternal, and there love is true, eternity true, and there eternity is loved, and truth is loved.

1. The knowledge of things terrestrial and celestial is commonly thought much of by men. Yet those doubtless judge better who prefer to that knowledge, the knowledge of themselves; and that mind is more praiseworthy which knows even its own weakness, than that which, without regard to this, searches out, and even comes to know, the ways of the stars, or which holds fast such knowledge already acquired, while ignorant of the way by which itself to enter into its own proper health and strength. But if any one has already become awake towards God, kindled by the warmth of the Holy Spirit, and in the love of God has become vile in his own eyes; and through wishing, yet not having strength to come in unto Him, and through the light He gives, has given heed to himself, and has found himself, and has learned that his own filthiness cannot mingle with His purity; and feels it sweet to weep and to entreat Him, that again and again He will have compassion, until he have put off all his wretchedness; and to pray confidently, as having already received of free gift the pledge of salvation through his only Saviour and Enlightener of man:– such an one, so acting, and so lamenting, knowledge does not puff up, because charity edifies; for he has preferred knowledge to knowledge, he has preferred to know his own weakness, rather than to know the walls of the world, the foundations of the earth, and the pinnacles of heaven. And by obtaining this knowledge, he has obtained also sorrow; but sorrow for straying away from the desire of reaching his own proper country, and the Creator of it, his own blessed God. And if among men such as these, in the family of Your Christ, O Lord my God, I groan among Your poor, give me out of Your bread to answer men who do not hunger and thirst after righteousness, but are sated and abound. But it is the vain image of those things that has sated them, not Your truth, which they have repelled and shrunk from, and so fall into their own vanity. I certainly know how many figments the human heart gives birth to. And what is my own heart but a human heart? But I pray the God of my heart, that I may not vomit forth ( eructuem) into these writings any of these figments for solid truths, but that there may pass into them only what the breath of His truth has breathed into me; cast out though I am from the sight of His eyes, and striving from afar to return by the way which the divinity of His only-begotten Son has made by His humanity. And this truth, changeable though I am, I so far drink in, as far as in it I see nothing changeable: neither in place and time, as is the case with bodies; nor in time alone, and in a certain sense place, as with the thoughts of our own spirits; nor in time alone, and not even in any semblance of place, as with some of the reasonings of our own minds. For the essence of God, whereby He is, has altogether nothing changeable, neither in eternity, nor in truth, nor in will; since there truth is eternal, love eternal; and there love is true, eternity true; and there eternity is loved, and truth is loved.

Chapter 1.– We are Made Perfect by Acknowledgement of Our Own Weakness. The Incarnate Word Dispels Our Darkness.

Since we are exiled from unchangeable joy, yet not completely cut off or torn away from it so that we no longer seek eternity, truth, and blessedness even in changeable and temporal things (for we do not wish to die, to be deceived, or to be troubled), visions have been sent to us from heaven suited to our pilgrim state to remind us that what we seek is not here, but that we must return from this pilgrimage to the place from which we came—for unless we originated there, we would not seek these things here. First, we had to be persuaded how much God loved us, so that we would not despair and refuse to look up to Him. We also needed to be shown what kind of people we are whom He loved, so that we would not become proud as if we had our own merits, which would cause us to distance ourselves from Him and fail even more by relying on our own strength. Therefore He dealt with us in such a way that we might instead benefit from His strength, and so in the weakness of humility the virtue of charity might be perfected. This is indicated in the Psalm where it says, "You, O God, sent a spontaneous rain, by which You made Your inheritance perfect when it was weary." By spontaneous rain nothing else is meant than grace, not given in return for merit but given freely, which is why it is called grace—for He gave it not because we were worthy, but because He willed it. Knowing this, we shall not trust in ourselves, and this is to be made weak. But He Himself makes us perfect, He who also says to the Apostle Paul, "My grace is sufficient for you, for my strength is made perfect in weakness." Man, then, had to be persuaded how much God loved us and what kind of people we were whom He loved—the former so we would not despair, the latter so we would not be proud. The apostle explains this most necessary point as follows: "But God commends His love toward us, in that while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us. Much more then, being now justified by His blood, we shall be saved from wrath through Him. For if when we were enemies we were reconciled to God by the death of His Son, much more, being reconciled, we shall be saved by His life." Also in another place he says: "What shall we then say to these things? If God be for us, who can be against us? He that spared not His own Son, but delivered Him up for us all, how has He not with Him also freely given us all things?" Now what is declared to us as already done was also shown to the ancient righteous as about to be done, so that through the same faith they themselves might also be humbled and so made weak, and being made weak, be made perfect.

2. But since we are exiled from the unchangeable joy, yet neither cut off nor torn away from it so that we should not seek eternity, truth, blessedness, even in those changeable and temporal things (for we wish neither to die, nor to be deceived, nor to be troubled); visions have been sent to us from heaven suitable to our state of pilgrimage, in order to remind us that what we seek is not here, but that from this pilgrimage we must return there, whence unless we originated we should not here seek these things. And first we have had to be persuaded how much God loved us, lest from despair we should not dare to look up to Him. And we needed to be shown also what manner of men we are whom He loved, lest being proud, as if of our own merits, we should recede the more from Him, and fail the more in our own strength. And hence He so dealt with us, that we might the rather profit by His strength, and that so in the weakness of humility the virtue of charity might be perfected. And this is intimated in the Psalm, where it is said, You, O God, sent a spontaneous rain, whereby You made Your inheritance perfect, when it was weary. For by spontaneous rain nothing else is meant than grace, not rendered to merit, but given freely, whence also it is called grace; for He gave it, not because we were worthy, but because He willed. And knowing this, we shall not trust in ourselves; and this is to be made weak. But He Himself makes us perfect, who says also to the Apostle Paul, My grace is sufficient for you, for my strength is made perfect in weakness. Man, then, was to be persuaded how much God loved us, and what manner of men we were whom He loved; the former, lest we should despair; the latter, lest we should be proud. And this most necessary topic the apostle thus explains: But God commends, he says, His love towards us, in that, while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us. Much more then, being now justified by His blood, we shall be saved from wrath through Him. For if, when we were enemies, we were reconciled to God by the death of His Son; much more, being reconciled, we shall be saved by His life. Romans 5:8-10 — Donavit Also in another place: What, he says, shall we then say to these things? If God be for us, who can be against us? He that spared not His own Son, but delivered Him up for us all, how has He not with Him also freely given us all things? Now that which is declared to us as already done, was shown also to the ancient righteous as about to be done; that through the same faith they themselves also might be humbled, and so made weak; and might be made weak, and so perfected.

Because the Word of God is One, by which all things were made, which is the unchangeable truth, all things exist in him simultaneously in a potential and unchangeable way. This includes not only the things that are now in this whole creation, but also those that have existed in the past and those that will exist in the future. In him, they neither have existed in the past nor will exist in the future, but simply exist. All things are life, and all things are one—or rather, he is one being and one life. All things were made by him in such a way that whatever was made in creation was not made in him as something created, but was life in him. In the beginning, the Word was not made but was with God, and the Word was God, and all things were made by him. All things could not have been made by him unless he himself had existed before all things and was not made. Even in those things that were made by him—including the body, which is not itself life—nothing would have been made by him unless it had been life in him before it was made. What was made was already life in him, and not just any kind of life. The soul is the life of the body, but the soul too is made, for it is changeable. By what was it made, except by the unchangeable Word of God? All things were made by him, and without him nothing was made that was made. Therefore, what was made was already life in him, and not just any kind of life, but the life that was the light of men—the light of rational minds, by which humans differ from animals and are therefore human. This is not bodily light, which is the light of the flesh, whether it shines from heaven or is kindled by earthly fires. It is not the light only of human flesh, but also of animals, and even down to the smallest worms, for all these see that light. But that life was the light of men. Nor is it far from any of us, for in it we live and move and have our being.

3. Because therefore the Word of God is One, by which all things were made, which is the unchangeable truth, all things are simultaneously therein, potentially and unchangeably; not only those things which are now in this whole creation, but also those which have been and those which shall be. And therein they neither have been, nor shall be, but only are; and all things are life, and all things are one; or rather it is one being and one life. For all things were so made by Him, that whatsoever was made in them was not made in Him, but was life in Him. Since, in the beginning, the Word was not made, but the Word was with God, and the Word was God, and all things were made by Him; neither had all things been made by Him, unless He had Himself been before all things and not made. But in those things which were made by Him, even body, which is not life, would not have been made by Him, except it had been life in Him before it was made. For that which was made was already life in Him; and not life of any kind soever: for the soul also is the life of the body, but this too is made, for it is changeable; and by what was it made, except by the unchangeable Word of God? For all things were made by Him; and without Him was not anything made that was made. What, therefore, was made was already life in Him; and not any kind of life, but the life [which] was the light of men; the light certainly of rational minds, by which men differ from beasts, and therefore are men. Therefore not corporeal light, which is the light of the flesh, whether it shine from heaven, or whether it be lighted by earthly fires; nor that of human flesh only, but also that of beasts, and down even to the minutest of worms. For all these things see that light: but that life was the light of men; nor is it far from any one of us, for in it we live, and move, and have our being.

Chapter 2.– How We are Rendered Apt for the Perception of Truth Through the Incarnate Word.

But the light shines in darkness, and the darkness did not comprehend it. The darkness is the foolish minds of people, blinded by vicious desires and unbelief. So that the Word, through whom all things were made, might care for these minds and heal them, the Word became flesh and lived among us. Our enlightenment is the partaking of the Word, that is, of that life which is the light of humanity. But we were completely unfit for this partaking and fell short of it because of the uncleanness of sins. Therefore we needed to be cleansed. Further, the one cleansing for the unrighteous and the proud is the blood of the Righteous One and the humbling of God Himself. We are cleansed through Him, who was made what we are by nature and what we are not by sin, so that we might contemplate God, which by nature we are not. For by nature we are not God: by nature we are human beings, by sin we are not righteous. Therefore God, having become a righteous man, interceded with God for sinful humanity. For the sinner does not correspond to the righteous, but human corresponds to human. By joining to us the likeness of His humanity, He took away the unlikeness of our unrighteousness. And by being made a partaker of our mortality, He made us partakers of His divinity. For the death of the sinner, arising from the necessity of condemnation, is rightly abolished by the death of the Righteous One, arising from the free choice of His compassion, while His single death and resurrection answers to our double death and resurrection. For this congruity, or suitableness, or concord, or consonance, or whatever more appropriate word there may be, by which one is united to two, is of great importance in all compacting, or better perhaps, co-adaptation, of the creature. For, as it just occurs to me, what I mean is precisely that co-adaptation which the Greeks call harmonia. However, this is not the place to explain the power of that consonance of single to double which is found especially in us and which is naturally implanted in us (and by whom, except by Him who created us?), so that even the ignorant cannot fail to perceive it, whether when singing themselves or hearing others. For by this consonance, treble and bass voices are in harmony, so that anyone who departs from it in their note offends extremely, not only trained skill, which most people lack, but the very sense of hearing itself. To demonstrate this no doubt requires a long discourse, but anyone who knows it can make it plain to the very ear on a properly tuned monochord.

4. But the light shines in darkness, and the darkness comprehended it not. Now the darkness is the foolish minds of men, made blind by vicious desires and unbelief. And that the Word, by whom all things were made, might care for these and heal them, The Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us. For our enlightening is the partaking of the Word, namely, of that life which is the light of men. But for this partaking we were utterly unfit, and fell short of it, on account of the uncleanness of sins. Therefore we were to be cleansed. And further, the one cleansing of the unrighteous and of the proud is the blood of the Righteous One, and the humbling of God Himself; that we might be cleansed through Him, made as He was what we are by nature, and what we are not by sin, that we might contemplate God, which by nature we are not. For by nature we are not God: by nature we are men, by sin we are not righteous. Wherefore God, made a righteous man, interceded with God for man the sinner. For the sinner is not congruous to the righteous, but man is congruous to man. By joining therefore to us the likeness of His humanity, He took away the unlikeness of our unrighteousness; and by being made partaker of our mortality, He made us partakers of His divinity. For the death of the sinner springing from the necessity of comdemnation is deservedly abolished by the death of the Righteous One springing from the free choice of His compassion, while His single [death and resurrection] answers to our double [death and resurrection]. For this congruity, or suitableness, or concord, or consonance, or whatever more appropriate word there may be, whereby one is [united] to two, is of great weight in all compacting, or better, perhaps, co-adaptation, of the creature. For (as it just occurs to me) what I mean is precisely that co-adaptation which the Greeks call ἁρμονία. However this is not the place to set forth the power of that consonance of single to double which is found especially in us, and which is naturally so implanted in us (and by whom, except by Him who created us?), that not even the ignorant can fail to perceive it, whether when singing themselves or hearing others. For by this it is that treble and bass voices are in harmony, so that any one who in his note departs from it, offends extremely, not only trained skill, of which the most part of men are devoid, but the very sense of hearing. To demonstrate this, needs no doubt a long discourse; but any one who knows it, may make it plain to the very ear in a rightly ordered monochord.

Chapter 3.– The One Death and Resurrection of The Body of Christ Harmonizes with Our Double Death and Resurrection of Body and Soul, to the Effect of Salvation. In What Way the Single Death of Christ is Bestowed Upon Our Double Death.

For our present purpose, we must discuss, as far as God enables us, how the single death of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ corresponds to and harmonizes with our double death for the purpose of salvation. We are certainly dead in both soul and body, as no Christian doubts: in soul, because of sin; in body, because of the punishment of sin, and through this also in body because of sin. Both parts of ourselves—that is, both soul and body—needed both medicine and resurrection, so that what had been changed for the worse might be renewed for the better. Now the death of the soul is ungodliness, and the death of the body is corruptibility, which also brings about the soul's departure from the body. For just as the soul dies when God leaves it, so the body dies when the soul leaves it, whereby the former becomes foolish and the latter lifeless. The soul is raised up again by repentance, and the renewal of life begins in the still-mortal body through faith, by which people believe in Him who justifies the ungodly. This renewal is increased and strengthened by good habits from day to day, as the inner person is renewed more and more. But the body, being the outer person, becomes more corrupted the longer this life lasts, whether by age, disease, or various afflictions, until it reaches that final affliction which everyone calls death. Its resurrection is delayed until the end, when our justification itself will be perfected beyond description. For then we will be like Him, because we will see Him as He is. But now, as long as the corruptible body weighs down the soul and human life on earth is all trial, no living person will be justified in His sight, compared to the righteousness in which we will be made equal to the angels and the glory that will be revealed in us. But why give more proofs about the difference between the death of the soul and the death of the body, when the Lord in one Gospel sentence has made each death easily distinguishable, where He says, "Let the dead bury their dead"? Burial was the proper handling of a dead body. But by those who were to bury it He meant those who were dead in soul through the ungodliness of unbelief—the kind who are awakened when it is said, "Awake, you who sleep, and rise from the dead, and Christ will give you light." And there is a death which the apostle condemns, saying of the widow, "But she who lives in pleasure is dead while she lives." Therefore the soul that was formerly ungodly and is now godly is said to have come alive again from the dead and to live, because of the righteousness of faith. But the body is not only said to be going to die because of that future departure of the soul, but because of the great weakness of flesh and blood it is even said to be dead now, in a certain place in Scripture, namely where the apostle says that the body is dead because of sin, but the spirit is life because of righteousness. Now this life is produced by faith, since the just will live by faith. But what follows? "But if the Spirit of Him who raised up Jesus from the dead dwells in you, He who raised up Christ from the dead will also give life to your mortal bodies by His Spirit who dwells in you."

5. But for our present need we must discuss, so far as God gives us power, in what manner the single of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ answers to, and is, so to say, in harmony with our double to the effect of salvation. We certainly, as no Christian doubts, are dead both in soul and body: in soul, because of sin; in body, because of the punishment of sin, and through this also in body because of sin. And to both these parts of ourselves, that is, both to soul and to body, there was need both of a medicine and of resurrection, that what had been changed for the worse might be renewed for the better. Now the death of the soul is ungodliness, and the death of the body is corruptibility, through which comes also a departure of the soul from the body. For as the soul dies when God leaves it, so the body dies when the soul leaves it; whereby the former becomes foolish, the latter lifeless. For the soul is raised up again by repentance, and the renewing of life is begun in the body still mortal by faith, by which men believe in Him who justifies the ungodly; and it is increased and strengthened by good habits from day to day, as the inner man is renewed more and more. But the body, being as it were the outward man, the longer this life lasts is so much the more corrupted, either by age or by disease, or by various afflictions, until it come to that last affliction which all call death. And its resurrection is delayed until the end; when also our justification itself shall be perfected ineffably. For then we shall be like Him, for we shall see Him as He is. But now, so long as the corruptible body presses down the soul, and human life upon earth is all temptation, in His sight shall no man living be justified, in comparison of the righteousness in which we shall be made equal with the angels, and of the glory which shall be revealed in us. But why mention more proofs respecting the difference between the death of the soul and the death of the body, when the Lord in one sentence of the Gospel has made either death easily distinguishable by any one from the other, where He says, Let the dead bury their dead? For burial was the fitting disposal of a dead body. But by those who were to bury it He meant those who were dead in soul by the impiety of unbelief, such, namely, as are awakened when it is said, Awake you that sleep, and arise from the dead, and Christ shall give you light. And there is a death which the apostle denounces, saying of the widow, But she that lives in pleasure is dead while she lives. Therefore the soul, which was before ungodly and is now godly, is said to have come alive again from the dead and to live, on account of the righteousness of faith. But the body is not only said to be about to die, on account of that departure of the soul which will be; but on account of the great infirmity of flesh and blood it is even said to be now dead, in a certain place in the Scriptures, namely, where the apostle says, that the body is dead because of sin, but the spirit is life because of righteousness. Now this life is wrought by faith, since the just shall live by faith. But what follows? But if the spirit of Him that raised up Jesus from the dead dwell in you, He that raised up Christ from the dead shall also quicken your mortal bodies by His Spirit which dwells in you.

Therefore, our Savior bestowed His own single death upon this double death of ours, and to bring about both our resurrections, He appointed beforehand and set forth in mystery and type His own one resurrection. For He was not a sinner or ungodly person who, as though dead in spirit, would need to be renewed in the inner man and recalled as it were to the life of righteousness through repentance. But being clothed in mortal flesh, and dying in that alone, and rising again in that alone, in that alone He answered to both for us, since in it a mystery was worked out regarding the inner man and a type regarding the outer. For it was a mystery concerning our inner man, signifying the death of our soul, that those words were spoken not only in the Psalm but also on the cross: My God, my God, why have You forsaken me? The apostle agrees with these words, saying, Knowing this, that our old man is crucified with Him, that the body of sin might be destroyed, that from now on we should not serve sin. For by the crucifixion of the inner man are understood the pains of repentance and a certain wholesome agony of self-control, by which death the death of ungodliness is destroyed, and in this death God has forsaken us. And so the body of sin is destroyed through such a cross, so that now we should not yield our members as instruments of unrighteousness to sin. Because even if the inner man is certainly renewed day by day, yet undoubtedly it is old before it is renewed. For that which the same apostle speaks of is done inwardly: Put off the old man and put on the new—which he goes on to explain by saying, Therefore, putting away lying, speak every man truth. But where is lying put away except inwardly, so that he who speaks the truth from his heart may inhabit the holy hill of God? But the resurrection of the body of the Lord is shown to belong to the mystery of our own inner resurrection, where, after He had risen, He says to the woman, Touch me not, for I am not yet ascended to my Father. With this mystery the apostle's words agree where he says, If you then be risen with Christ, seek those things which are above, where Christ sits on the right hand of God; set your thoughts on things above. For not to touch Christ unless when He had ascended to the Father means not to think of Christ in a fleshly manner. Again, the death of the flesh of our Lord contains a type of the death of our outer man, since it is by such suffering especially that He exhorts His servants that they should not fear those who kill the body but are not able to kill the soul. Therefore the apostle says, That I may fill up that which is lacking of the afflictions of Christ in my flesh. And the resurrection of the body of the Lord is found to contain a type of the resurrection of our outward man, because He says to His disciples, Handle me and see, for a spirit does not have flesh and bones as you see me have. And one of the disciples also, handling His scars, exclaimed, My Lord and my God! And since the entire integrity of that flesh was evident, this was shown in what He had said when exhorting His disciples: There shall not a hair of your head perish. For how is it that first it is said, Touch me not, for I am not yet ascended to my Father, and how is it that before He ascends to the Father He actually is touched by the disciples—unless because in the former the mystery of the inner man was indicated, and in the latter a type was given of the outer man? Or can anyone possibly be so lacking in understanding and so turned away from the truth as to dare to say that He was touched by men before He ascended but by women when He had ascended? It was on account of this type, which went before in the Lord, of our future resurrection in the body, that the apostle says, Christ the firstfruits; afterward they that are Christ's. For it was the resurrection of the body to which this passage refers, on account of which he also says, Who has changed our vile body that it may be fashioned like His glorious body. Therefore the one death of our Savior brought salvation to our double death, and His one resurrection accomplished for us two resurrections, since His body in both cases—that is, both in His death and in His resurrection—was ministered to us by a kind of healing appropriateness, both as a mystery of the inner man and as a type of the outer.

6. Therefore on this double death of ours our Saviour bestowed His own single death; and to cause both our resurrections, He appointed beforehand and set forth in mystery and type His own one resurrection. For He was not a sinner or ungodly, that, as though dead in spirit, He should need to be renewed in the inner man, and to be recalled as it were to the life of righteousness by repentance; but being clothed in mortal flesh, and in that alone dying, in that alone rising again, in that alone did He answer to both for us; since in it was wrought a mystery as regards the inner man, and a type as regards the outer. For it was in a mystery as regards our inner man, so as to signify the death of our soul, that those words were uttered, not only in the Psalm, but also on the cross: My God, my God, why have You forsaken me? To which words the apostle agrees, saying, Knowing this, that our old man is crucified with Him, that the body of sin might be destroyed, that henceforth we should not serve sin; since by the crucifixion of the inner man are understood the pains of repentance, and a certain wholesome agony of self-control, by which death the death of ungodliness is destroyed, and in which death God has left us. And so the body of sin is destroyed through such a cross, that now we should not yield our members as instruments of unrighteousness unto sin. Because, if even the inner man certainly is renewed day by day, yet undoubtedly it is old before it is renewed. For that is done inwardly of which the same apostle speaks: Put off the old man, and put on the new; which he goes on to explain by saying, Wherefore, putting away lying, speak every man truth. But where is lying put away, unless inwardly, that he who speaks the truth from his heart may inhabit the holy hill of God? But the resurrection of the body of the Lord is shown to belong to the mystery of our own inner resurrection, where, after He had risen, He says to the woman, Touch me not, for I am not yet ascended to my Father; with which mystery the apostle's words agree, where he says, If you then be risen with Christ, seek those things which are above, where Christ sits on the right hand of God; set your thoughts on things above. For not to touch Christ, unless when He had ascended to the Father, means not to have thoughts of Christ after a fleshly manner. Again, the death of the flesh of our Lord contains a type of the death of our outer man, since it is by such suffering most of all that He exhorts His servants that they should not fear those who kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul. Wherefore the apostle says, That I may fill up that which is behind of the afflictions of Christ in my flesh. And the resurrection of the body of the Lord is found to contain a type of the resurrection of our outward man, because He says to His disciples, Handle me, and see; for a spirit has not flesh and bones, as you see me have. And one of the disciples also, handling His scars, exclaimed, My Lord and my God! And whereas the entire integrity of that flesh was apparent, this was shown in that which He had said when exhorting His disciples: There shall not a hair of your head perish. For how comes it that first is said, Touch me not, for I am not yet ascended to my Father; and how comes it that before He ascends to the Father, He actually is touched by the disciples: unless because in the former the mystery of the inner man was intimated, in the latter a type was given of the outer man? Or can any one possibly be so without understanding, and so turned away from the truth, as to dare to say that He was touched by men before He ascended, but by women when He had ascended? It was on account of this type, which went before in the Lord, of our future resurrection in the body, that the apostle says, Christ the first-fruits; afterward they that are Christ's. For it was the resurrection of the body to which this place refers, on account of which he also says, Who has changed our vile body, that it may be fashioned like His glorious body. The one death therefore of our Saviour brought salvation to our double death, and His one resurrection wrought for us two resurrections; since His body in both cases, that is, both in His death and in His resurrection, was ministered to us by a kind of healing suitableness, both as a mystery of the inner man, and as a type of the outer.

Chapter 4.– The Ratio of the Single to the Double Comes from the Perfection of the Senary Number. The Perfection of The Senary Number is Commended in the Scriptures. The Year Abounds in The Senary Number.

This ratio of the single to the double certainly arises from the ternary number, since one added to two makes three; but the whole that these make reaches to the senary, for one and two and three make six. This number is called perfect because it is completed in its own parts: it has three parts—a sixth, a third, and a half—and no other part can be found in it that we can call an aliquot part. Its sixth part is one, its third part is two, and its half is three. But one and two and three together complete the same six. Holy Scripture commends to us the perfection of this number, especially in that God finished His works in six days, and on the sixth day man was made in the image of God. The Son of God came and was made the Son of man to re-create us after the image of God in the sixth age of the human race. That is the present age, whether we assign a thousand years to each age, or whether we trace memorable and remarkable epochs or turning points of time in the divine Scriptures. The first age is found from Adam to Noah, the second from there to Abraham, and then, following the division of Matthew the evangelist, from Abraham to David, from David to the carrying away to Babylon, and from there to the labor of the Virgin. These three ages joined to those other two make five. Accordingly, the nativity of the Lord began the sixth age, which is now continuing until the hidden end of time. We also recognize in this senary number a kind of figure of time in that threefold mode of division by which we compute one portion of time before the Law, a second under the Law, and a third under grace. In this last time we have received the sacrament of renewal so that we may be renewed also at the end of time in every part by the resurrection of the flesh, and thus be made whole from our entire infirmity, not only of soul but also of body. From this, that woman is understood to be a type of the church who was made whole and upright by the Lord after being bowed down by infirmity through the binding of Satan. For those words of the Psalm lament such hidden enemies: "They bowed down my soul." This woman had her infirmity eighteen years, which is three times six. The months of eighteen years are found in number to be the cube of six, that is, six times six times six. Also, nearly in the same place in the Gospel is that fig tree which was convicted by the third year of its miserable barrenness. But intercession was made for it so that it might be let alone that year; if it bore fruit, well; if not, it should be cut down. For both three years belong to the same threefold division, and the months of three years make the square of six, which is six times six.

7. Now this ratio of the single to the double arises, no doubt, from the ternary number, since one added to two makes three; but the whole which these make reaches to the senary, for one and two and three make six. And this number is on that account called perfect, because it is completed in its own parts: for it has these three, sixth, third, and half; nor is there any other part found in it, which we can call an aliquot part. The sixth part of it, then, is one; the third part, two; the half, three. But one and two and three complete the same six. And Holy Scripture commends to us the perfection of this number, especially in this, that God finished His works in six days, and on the sixth day man was made in the image of God. And the Son of God came and was made the Son of man, that He might re-create us after the image of God, in the sixth age of the human race. For that is now the present age, whether a thousand years apiece are assigned to each age, or whether we trace out memorable and remarkable epochs or turning-points of time in the divine Scriptures, so that the first age is to be found from Adam until Noah, and the second thence onwards to Abraham, and then next, after the division of Matthew the evangelist, from Abraham to David, from David to the carrying away to Babylon, and from thence to the travail of the Virgin, which three ages joined to those other two make five. Accordingly, the nativity of the Lord began the sixth, which is now going onwards until the hidden end of time. We recognize also in this senary number a kind of figure of time, in that threefold mode of division, by which we compute one portion of time before the Law; a second, under the Law; a third, under grace. In which last time we have received the sacrament of renewal, that we may be renewed also in the end of time, in every part, by the resurrection of the flesh, and so may be made whole from our entire infirmity, not only of soul, but also of body. And thence that woman is understood to be a type of the church, who was made whole and upright by the Lord, after she had been bowed by infirmity through the binding of Satan. For those words of the Psalm lament such hidden enemies: They bowed down my soul. And this woman had her infirmity eighteen years, which is thrice six. And the months of eighteen years are found in number to be the cube of six, viz. six times six times six. Nearly, too, in the same place in the Gospel is that fig tree, which was convicted also by the third year of its miserable barrenness. But intercession was made for it, that it might be let alone that year, that year, that if it bore fruit, well; if otherwise, it should be cut down. For both three years belong to the same threefold division, and the months of three years make the square of six, which is six times six.

A single year, when all twelve months are considered—each made up of thirty days (for the month that has been kept since ancient times is the one determined by the moon's revolution)—abounds in the number six. What six is in the first order of numbers, which consists of units up to ten, sixty is in the second order, which consists of tens up to a hundred. Sixty days, then, are a sixth part of the year. Furthermore, if that which stands as the sixth of the second order is multiplied by the sixth of the first order, we get six times sixty, which equals three hundred and sixty days—the full twelve months. But since the moon's revolution determines the month for people while the year is marked by the sun's revolution, there remain five days and a quarter of a day for the sun to complete its course and finish the year. Four quarters make one day, which must be added in every fourth year (called bissextile or leap year) so that the order of time is not disturbed. If we also consider these five and a quarter days themselves, the number six prevails in them. First, because it is customary to calculate the whole from a part, we should not call it five days but rather six, counting the quarter days as one day. Second, because five days themselves are the sixth part of a month, while the quarter of a day contains six hours. For the entire day, including its night, is twenty-four hours, and the fourth part of this—a quarter of a day—is found to be six hours. This is how much the number six prevails throughout the course of the year.

8. A single year also, if the whole twelve months are taken into account, which are made up of thirty days each (for the month that has been kept from of old is that which the revolution of the moon determines), abounds in the number six. For that which six is, in the first order of numbers, which consists of units up to ten, that sixty is in the second order, which consists of tens up to a hundred. Sixty days, then, are a sixth part of the year. Further, if that which stands as the sixth of the second order is multiplied by the sixth of the first order, then we make six times sixty, i.e. three hundred and sixty days, which are the whole twelve months. But since, as the revolution of the moon determines the month for men, so the year is marked by the revolution of the sun; and five days and a quarter of a day remain, that the sun may fulfill its course and end the year; for four quarters make one day, which must be intercalated in every fourth year, which they call bissextile, that the order of time may not be disturbed: if we consider, also, these five days and a quarter themselves, the number six prevails in them. First, because, as it is usual to compute the whole from a part, we must not call it five days, but rather six, taking the quarter days for one day. Next, because five days themselves are the sixth part of a month; while the quarter of a day contains six hours. For the entire day, i.e. including its night, is twenty-four hours, of which the fourth part, which is a quarter of a day, is found to be six hours. So much in the course of the year does the sixth number prevail.

Chapter 5.– The Number Six is Also Commended in the Building Up of the Body of Christ and of the Temple at Jerusalem.

And it is reasonable that the number six is understood to represent a year in the building up of the body of the Lord, as a figure of which He said that He would raise up in three days the temple destroyed by the Jews. For they said, This temple was forty-six years in building. And six times forty-six makes two hundred and seventy-six. And this number of days completes nine months and six days, which are reckoned as roughly ten months for the labor of women. This is not because all births come to the sixth day after the ninth month, but because the perfection itself of the body of the Lord is found to have been brought to birth in exactly this many days, as the authority of the church maintains based on the tradition of the elders. For He is believed to have been conceived on the twenty-fifth of March, the same day on which He also suffered. So the womb of the Virgin, in which He was conceived, where no mortal was ever begotten, corresponds to the new grave in which He was buried, where no man was ever laid, neither before nor since. But He was born, according to tradition, on December the twenty-fifth. If, then, you count from that day to this, you find two hundred and seventy-six days, which is forty-six times six. And in this number of years the temple was built, because in that number of sixes the body of the Lord was perfected. This body, being destroyed by the suffering of death, He raised again on the third day. For He spoke this of the temple of His body, as is declared by the most clear and solid testimony of the Gospel, where He said, For as Jonas was three days and three nights in the whale's belly, so shall the Son of man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.

9. And not without reason is the number six understood to be put for a year in the building up of the body of the Lord, as a figure of which He said that He would raise up in three days the temple destroyed by the Jews. For they said, Forty and six years was this temple in building. And six times forty-six makes two hundred and seventy-six. And this number of days completes nine months and six days, which are reckoned, as it were, ten months for the travail of women; not because all come to the sixth day after the ninth month, but because the perfection itself of the body of the Lord is found to have been brought in so many days to the birth, as the authority of the church maintains upon the tradition of the elders. For He is believed to have been conceived on the 25th of March, upon which day also He suffered; so the womb of the Virgin, in which He was conceived, where no one of mortals was begotten, corresponds to the new grave in which He was buried, wherein was never man laid, neither before nor since. But He was born, according to tradition, upon December the 25th. If, then you reckon from that day to this you find two hundred and seventy-six days which is forty-six times six. And in this number of years the temple was built, because in that number of sixes the body of the Lord was perfected; which being destroyed by the suffering of death, He raised again on the third day. For He spoke this of the temple of His body, as is declared by the most clear and solid testimony of the Gospel; where He said, For as Jonas was three days and three nights in the whale's belly, so shall the Son of man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.

Chapter 6.– The Three Days of the Resurrection, in Which Also the Ratio of Single to Double is Apparent.

Scripture also confirms that the three-day period itself was not complete in its entirety. The first day is counted as a whole based on its final portion, and the third day is likewise counted as a whole based on its first portion. However, the middle day—the second day—was genuinely complete with its full twenty-four hours: twelve hours of daylight and twelve hours of night. Christ was first crucified by the voices of the Jews at the third hour on the sixth day of the week. He was then suspended on the cross at the sixth hour and gave up His spirit at the ninth hour. He was buried when evening had come, as the evangelist states, which means at the end of the day. So regardless of where you begin counting—even if some other explanation can be offered that doesn't contradict the Gospel of John and allows us to understand that He was hung on the cross at the third hour—you still cannot make the first day a complete day. It will be counted as a complete day based on its final portion, just as the third day is counted complete based on its first portion. The night leading up to dawn, when the Lord's resurrection was made known, belongs to the third day. This is because God, who commanded light to shine out of darkness so that through the grace of the New Testament and participation in Christ's resurrection these words could be spoken to us: "For you were once darkness, but now you are light in the Lord," somehow indicates to us that the day begins from night. Just as the first days of creation were counted from light to night because of humanity's future fall, so these days are counted from darkness to light because of humanity's restoration. From the hour of His death to the dawn of the resurrection, then, there are forty hours, including the ninth hour itself. This number also corresponds to His forty days of earthly life after His resurrection. This number appears very frequently in Scripture to express the mystery of perfection in the fourfold world. The number ten has a certain perfection, and when multiplied by four it makes forty. But from the evening of the burial to the dawn of the resurrection there are thirty-six hours, which is six squared. This relates to the ratio of single to double, in which there exists the greatest harmony of proper fitting together. For twelve added to twenty-four follows the ratio of single added to double and makes thirty-six: namely, a complete night with a complete day and a complete night, and this is not without the mystery I mentioned above. It is quite fitting to liken the spirit to day and the body to night. For the body of the Lord in His death and resurrection was a figure of our spirit and a pattern of our body. In this way, then, the ratio of single to double is also evident in the thirty-six hours when twelve is added to twenty-four. As for the reasons why these numbers are placed in Holy Scripture, other people may discover other explanations—either ones that make my explanations preferable by comparison, or ones equally probable as mine, or even more probable than mine. But surely no one is so foolish or absurd as to argue that these numbers are placed in Scripture for no purpose at all and that there are no mystical reasons for their mention. The explanations I have given here I have gathered either from the authority of the church according to the tradition of our ancestors, or from the testimony of divine Scripture, or from the very nature of numbers and symbolic correspondences. No reasonable person will decide against reason, no Christian against the Scriptures, no peaceable person against the church.

10. Scripture again witnesses that the space of those three days themselves was not whole and entire, but the first day is counted as a whole from its last part, and the third day is itself also counted as a whole from its first part; but the intervening day, i.e. the second day, was absolutely a whole with its twenty-four hours, twelve of the day and twelve of the night. For He was crucified first by the voices of the Jews in the third hour, when it was the sixth day of the week. Then He hung on the cross itself at the sixth hour, and yielded up His spirit at the ninth hour. But He was buried, now when the evening had come, as the words of the evangelist express it; which means, at the end of the day. Wheresoever then you begin — even if some other explanation can be given, so as not to contradict the Gospel of John, but to understand that He was suspended on the cross at the third hour — still you cannot make the first day an entire day. It will be reckoned then an entire day from its last part, as the third from its first part. For the night up to the dawn, when the resurrection of the Lord was made known, belongs to the third day; because God (who commanded the light to shine out of darkness, that through the grace of the New Testament and the partaking of the resurrection of Christ the words might be spoken to us For you were sometimes darkness, but now are you light in the Lord) intimates to us in some way that the day takes its beginning from the night. For as the first days of all were reckoned from light to night, on account of the future fall of man; so these on account of the restoration of man, are reckoned from darkness to light. From the hour, then, of His death to the dawn of the resurrection are forty hours, counting in also the ninth hour itself. And with this number agrees also His life upon earth of forty days after His resurrection. And this number is most frequently used in Scripture to express the mystery of perfection in the fourfold world. For the number ten has a certain perfection, and that multiplied by four makes forty. But from the evening of the burial to the dawn of the resurrection are thirty-six hours which is six squared. And this is referred to that ratio of the single to the double wherein there is the greatest consonance of co-adaptation. For twelve added to twenty-four suits the ratio of single added to double and makes thirty-six: namely a whole night with a whole day and a whole night, and this not without the mystery which I have noticed above. For not unfitly do we liken the spirit to the day and the body to the night. For the body of the Lord in His death and resurrection was a figure of our spirit and a type of our body. In this way, then, also that ratio of the single to the double is apparent in the thirty-six hours, when twelve are added to twenty-four. As to the reasons, indeed, why these numbers are so put in the Holy Scriptures, other people may trace out other reasons, either such that those which I have given are to be preferred to them, or such as are equally probable with mine, or even more probable than they are; but there is no one surely so foolish or so absurd as to contend that they are so put in the Scriptures for no purpose at all, and that there are no mystical reasons why those numbers are there mentioned. But those reasons which I have here given, I have either gathered from the authority of the church, according to the tradition of our forefathers, or from the testimony of the divine Scriptures, or from the nature itself of numbers and of similitudes. No sober person will decide against reason, no Christian against the Scriptures, no peaceable person against the church.

Chapter 7.– In What Manner We are Gathered from Many into One Through One Mediator.

This mystery, this sacrifice, this priest, this God—before He was sent and came, being made of a woman—all those things that appeared to our fathers in a sacred and mystical way through angelic miracles, or that were done by the fathers themselves, were images of Him. This was so that every creature through its actions might somehow speak of that One who was to come, in whom there would be salvation in the recovery of all from death. Because through the wickedness of ungodliness we had turned back and fallen away in discord from the one true and supreme God, and had become empty in many things, being scattered among many things and clinging to many things, it was necessary by the decree and command of God in His mercy that these same many things should join together in announcing the One who would come, that this One should come as proclaimed by these many things, and that these many things should join together in testifying that this One had come. And so, freed from the burden of these many things, we should come to that One. Dead as we were in our souls through many sins, and destined to die in the flesh because of sin, we should love that One who, without sin, died in the flesh for us. By believing in Him now raised again, and by rising again with Him in spirit through faith, we should be made righteous by being made one in the one righteous One. We should not despair of our own resurrection in the flesh itself when we consider that the one Head has gone before us, the many members. In Him, now cleansed through faith and later renewed by sight, and through Him as mediator reconciled to God, we are to cling to the One, to feast upon the One, to remain one.

11. This mystery, this sacrifice, this priest, this God, before He was sent and came, being made of a woman — of Him, all those things which appeared to our fathers in a sacred and mystical way by angelical miracles, or which were done by the fathers themselves, were similitudes; in order that every creature by its acts might speak in some way of that One who was to be, in whom there was to be salvation in the recovery of all from death. For because by the wickedness of ungodliness we had recoiled and fallen away in discord from the one true and supreme God, and had in many things become vain, being distracted through many things and cleaving fast to many things; it was needful, by the decree and command of God in His mercy, that those same many things should join in proclaiming the One that should come, and that One should come so proclaimed by these many things, and that these many things should join in witnessing that this One had come; and that so, freed from the burden of these many things, we should come to that One, and dead as we were in our souls by many sins, and destined to die in the flesh on account of sin, that we should love that One who, without sin, died in the flesh for us; and by believing in Him now raised again, and by rising again with Him in the spirit through faith, that we should be justified by being made one in the one righteous One; and that we should not despair of our own resurrection in the flesh itself, when we consider that the one Head had gone before us the many members; in whom, being now cleansed through faith, and then renewed by sight, and through Him as mediator reconciled to God, we are to cleave to the One, to feast upon the One, to continue one.

Chapter 8.– In What Manner Christ Wills that All Shall Be One in Himself.

So the Son of God Himself, the Word of God, Himself also the Mediator between God and men, the Son of man, equal to the Father through the unity of the Godhead, and sharing with us through taking on humanity, interceding for us with the Father in that He was man, yet not hiding that He was God, one with the Father, among other things speaks like this: "I do not pray for these alone," He says, "but also for those who will believe in me through their word, that they all may be one; as You, Father, are in me, and I in You, that they also may be one in us, so that the world may believe that You have sent me. And the glory which You gave me I have given them, that they may be one, even as we are one."

12. So the Son of God Himself, the Word of God, Himself also the Mediator between God and men, the Son of man, equal to the Father through the unity of the Godhead, and partaker with us by the taking upon Him of humanity, interceding for us with the Father in that He was man, yet not concealing that He was God, one with the Father, among other things speaks thus: Neither pray I for these alone, He says, but for them also which shall believe in me through their word; that they all may be one; as You, Father, art in me, and I in You, that they also may be one in us: that the world may believe that You have sent me. And the glory which You gave me I have given them; that they may be one, even as we are one.

Chapter 9.– The Same Argument Continued.

He did not say, "I and they are one thing." Although, because He is the head of the church which is His body, He might have said "they and I are one person" (not one thing), since the head and the body is one Christ. But to show His own Godhead consubstantial with the Father—which is why He says elsewhere, "I and my Father are one"—He wills His own to be one in His own kind, that is, in the consubstantial equality of the same nature, but in Himself. They could not be one in themselves, since they are separated from one another by various pleasures, desires, and the uncleanness of sin. Therefore they are cleansed through the Mediator so that they may be one in Him, not only through the same nature by which all become equal to the angels from being mortal humans, but also through the same will harmoniously united in the same blessedness and melted together into one spirit, so to speak, by the fire of charity. This is what His words mean: "That they may be one, even as we are one"—namely, that just as the Father and Son are one, not only in equality of substance but also in will, so those for whom God the Son is mediator may also be one, not only by being of the same nature but also through the same bond of love. Then He goes on to reveal the truth itself, that He is the Mediator through whom we are reconciled to God, by saying, "I in them, and You in me, that they may be made perfect in one."

He did not say, I and they are one thing; although, in that He is the head of the church which is His body, He might have said, and they are, not one thing, but one person, because the head and the body is one Christ; but in order to show His own Godhead consubstantial with the Father (for which reason He says in another place, I and my Father are one), in His own kind, that is, in the consubstantial parity of the same nature, He wills His own to be one, but in Himself; since they could not be so in themselves, separated as they are one from another by various pleasures and desires and uncleannesses of sin; whence they are cleansed through the Mediator, that they may be one in Him, not only through the same nature in which all become from mortal men equal to the angels, but also through the same will most harmoniously conspiring to the same blessedness, and fused in some way by the fire of charity into one spirit. For to this His words come, That they may be one, even as we are one; namely, that as the Father and Son are one, not only in equality of substance, but also in will, so those also may be one, between whom and God the Son is mediator, not only in that they are of the same nature, but also through the same union of love. And then He goes on thus to intimate the truth itself, that He is the Mediator, through whom we are reconciled to God, by saying, I in them, and You in me, that they may be made perfect in one.

Chapter 10.– As Christ is the Mediator of Life, So the Devil is the Mediator of Death.

Our true peace and firm bond of union with our Creator comes from being purified and reconciled through the Mediator of life, just as we were polluted and alienated, departing from Him, through the mediator of death. For just as the devil through pride led man through pride to death, so Christ through lowliness led man back through obedience to life. Since the one fell through being lifted up and also cast down man who consented to him, the other was raised up through being brought low and also lifted up man who believed in Him. Because the devil had not himself gone to the place where he led the way (since he indeed bore the death of the spirit in his ungodliness, but had not experienced the death of the flesh, because he had not taken on bodily covering), he appeared to man to be a mighty leader among the legions of devils, through whom he exercises his reign of deception. So he puffs up man all the more—man who is more eager for power than for righteousness—through the pride of self-exaltation, or through false philosophy, or else entangles him through sacrilegious rituals. In these rituals, while casting down headlong through deceit and illusion the minds of the more curious and proud, he also holds them captive to magical trickery, promising the cleansing of the soul through those initiations they call teletai (ritual initiations) by transforming himself into an angel of light through various schemes involving false signs and wonders.

13. Therein is our true peace and firm bond of union with our Creator, that we should be purified and reconciled through the Mediator of life, as we had been polluted and alienated, and so had departed from Him, through the mediator of death. For as the devil through pride led man through pride to death; so Christ through lowliness led back man through obedience to life. Since, as the one fell through being lifted up, and cast down [man] also who consented to him; so the other was raised up through being abased, and lifted up [man] also who believed in Him. For because the devil had not himself come there whither he had led the way (inasmuch as he bare indeed in his ungodliness the death of the spirit, but had not undergone the death of the flesh, because he had not assumed the covering of the flesh), he appeared to man to be a mighty chief among the legions of devils, through whom he exercises his reign of deceits; so puffing up man the more, who is eager for power more than righteousness, through the pride of elation, or through false philosophy; or else entangling him through sacrilegious rites, in which, while casting down headlong by deceit and illusion the minds of the more curious and prouder sort, he holds him captive also to magical trickery; promising too the cleansing of the soul, through those initiations which they call τελεταί, by transforming himself into an angel of light, through various machinations in signs and prodigies of lying.

Chapter 11.– Miracles Which are Done by Demons are to Be Spurned.

Even the most worthless spirits can easily do many things through their aerial bodies that cause wonder in souls weighed down by earthly bodies, even if those souls are better disposed. If earthly bodies themselves, when trained by certain skill and practice, display such great marvels to people in theatrical performances that those who never saw such things scarcely believe them when told about them, why would it be difficult for the devil and his angels to create things out of bodily elements through their own aerial bodies that make the flesh marvel? Or they can even produce deceptive visions through hidden influences to mislead people's senses, deceiving them whether awake or asleep, or driving them into madness. But just as someone who is better in life and character than worthless men might watch them walking on a rope or performing many hard-to-believe feats through various bodily movements, yet not desire to do such things himself or think those men are superior to him on that account, so the faithful and devout soul—not only if it sees the miracles of demons, but even if it shudders at them because of bodily weakness—will not regret its own lack of power to do such things or judge the demons to be better than itself because of this. This is especially true since the soul is in the company of the holy ones, who, whether they are human beings or good angels, accomplish through the power of God, to whom all things are subject, wonders that are far greater and completely free from deception.

14. For it is easy for the most worthless spirits to do many things by means of aerial bodies, such as to cause wonder to souls which are weighed down by earthly bodies, even though they be of the better inclined. For if earthly bodies themselves, when trained by a certain skill and practice, exhibit to men so great marvels in theatrical spectacles, that they who never saw such things scarcely believe them when told; why should it be hard for the devil and his angels to make out of corporeal elements, through their own aerial bodies, things at which the flesh marvels; or even by hidden inspirations to contrive fantastic appearances to the deluding of men's senses, whereby to deceive them, whether awake or asleep, or to drive them into frenzy? But just as it may happen that one who is better than they in life and character may gaze at the most worthless of men, either walking on a rope, or doing by various motions of the body many things difficult of belief, and yet he may not at all desire to do such things, nor think those men on that account to be preferred to himself; so the faithful and pious soul, not only if it sees, but even if on account of the frailty of the flesh it shudders at, the miracles of demons; yet will not for that either deplore its own want of power to do such things, or judge them on this account to be better than itself; especially since it is in the company of the holy, who, whether they are men or good angels, accomplish, through the power of God, to whom all things are subject, wonders which are far greater and the very reverse of deceptive.

Chapter 12.– The Devil the Mediator of Death, Christ of Life.

In no way, therefore, are souls cleansed and reconciled to God by sacrilegious imitations, or curious arts that are impious, or magical incantations. The false mediator does not lift souls to higher things but instead blocks and cuts off the way there through the passions he inspires in those who belong to him—passions that are malignant in proportion to their pride. These passions cannot nourish the wings of virtues so they may fly upward, but rather pile up the weight of vices so they press downward. The soul will fall more heavily the more it imagines it has been carried upward. Therefore, just as the Magi, when warned by God after the star led them to worship the humble Lord, returned to their country by a different route than the one by which they came, so we also ought to return to our country not by the way we came but by another way that the lowly King has taught and which the proud king, the adversary of that lowly King, cannot block. For to us too, so that we may worship the lowly Christ, the heavens have declared the glory of God when their sound went into all the earth and their words to the ends of the world. A way to death was made for us through sin in Adam. For by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin, and so death passed upon all men, in whom all have sinned. Of this way the devil was the mediator, the one who persuaded us to sin and cast us down into death. For he too applied his one death to bring about our double death. Since he died in spirit through ungodliness but certainly did not die in the flesh, yet he persuaded us to ungodliness and thereby brought it about that we deserved to come into the death of the flesh. We chose the one through wicked persuasion, and the other followed us by just condemnation. Therefore it is written, God made not death, since He was not Himself the cause of death. Yet death was inflicted on the sinner through His most just retribution, just as the judge inflicts punishment on the guilty; yet it is not the justice of the judge but the desert of the crime that is the cause of the punishment. To that place where the mediator of death caused us to pass but did not come himself—that is, to the death of the flesh—our Lord God introduced for us the medicine of correction, which He did not deserve, by a hidden and deeply mysterious decree of divine and profound justice. Therefore, just as by one man came death, so by one man might also come the resurrection of the dead. Because people strove more to avoid what they could not avoid, namely the death of the flesh, than the death of the spirit—that is, punishment more than the desert of punishment (for people are either not concerned or too little concerned about not sinning, but eagerly seek after not dying, although that is beyond their reach)—the Mediator of life, making it plain that death is not to be feared, which by the human condition cannot now be escaped, but rather ungodliness, which can be guarded against through faith, meets us at the end to which we have come, but not by the way by which we came. For we came to death through sin; He through righteousness. Therefore, just as our death is the punishment of sin, so His death was made a sacrifice for sin.

15. In no wise therefore are souls cleansed and reconciled to God by sacrilegious imitations, or curious arts that are impious, or magical incantations; since the false mediator does not translate them to higher things, but rather blocks and cuts off the way there through the affections, malignant in proportion as they are proud, which he inspires into those of his own company; which are not able to nourish the wings of virtues so as to fly upwards, but rather to heap up the weight of vices so as to press downwards; since the soul will fall down the more heavily, the more it seems to itself to have been carried upwards. Accordingly, as the Magi did when warned of God, whom the star led to adore the low estate of the Lord; so we also ought to return to our country, not by the way by which we came, but by another way which the lowly King has taught, and which the proud king, the adversary of that lowly King, cannot block up. For to us, too, that we may adore the lowly Christ, the heavens have declared the glory of God, when their sound went into all the earth, and their words to the ends of the world. A way was made for us to death through sin in Adam. For, By one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men, in whom all have sinned. Of this way the devil was the mediator, the persuader to sin, and the caster down into death. For he, too, applied his one death to work out our double death. Since he indeed died in the spirit through ungodliness, but certainly did not die in the flesh: yet both persuaded us to ungodliness, and thereby brought it to pass that we deserved to come into the death of the flesh. We desired therefore the one through wicked persuasion, the other followed us by a just condemnation; and therefore it is written, God made not death, since He was not Himself the cause of death; but yet death was inflicted on the sinner, through His most just retribution. Just as the judge inflicts punishment on the guilty; yet it is not the justice of the judge, but the desert of the crime, which is the cause of the punishment. Whither, then, the mediator of death caused us to pass, yet did not come himself, that is, to the death of the flesh, there our Lord God introduced for us the medicine of correction, which He deserved not, by a hidden and exceeding mysterious decree of divine and profound justice. In order, therefore, that as by one man came death, so by one man might come also the resurrection of the dead; because men strove more to shun that which they could not shun, viz. the death of the flesh, than the death of the spirit, i.e. punishment more than the desert of punishment (for not to sin is a thing about which either men are not solicitous or are too little solicitous; but not to die, although it be not within reach of attainment, is yet eagerly sought after); the Mediator of life, making it plain that death is not to be feared, which by the condition of humanity cannot now be escaped, but rather ungodliness, which can be guarded against through faith, meets us at the end to which we have come, but not by the way by which we came. For we, indeed, came to death through sin; He through righteousness: and, therefore, as our death is the punishment of sin, so His death was made a sacrifice for sin.

Chapter 13.– The Death of Christ Voluntary. How the Mediator of Life Subdued the Mediator of Death. How the Devil Leads His Own to Despise the Death of Christ.

Since the spirit is to be preferred to the body, and the death of the spirit means that God has left it, while the death of the body means that the spirit has left it, the punishment in bodily death lies in this: the spirit leaves the body against its will because it left God willingly. So while the spirit left God by its own choice, it leaves the body unwillingly and does not leave when it wishes unless it does violence to itself, resulting in the body's death. The spirit of the Mediator demonstrated that He came to the death of the flesh not through any punishment for sin, because He did not leave it unwillingly but because He willed it, when He willed it, and as He willed it. For because He is so united with the flesh by the Word of God as to be one, He says: I have power to lay down my life, and I have power to take it again. No man takes it from me, but I lay down my life that I might take it again. And as the Gospel tells us, those who were present were greatly astonished that after that final word, in which He represented our sin, He immediately gave up His spirit. For those who are hung on crosses usually suffer a prolonged death. This is why the legs of the thieves were broken, so that they might die quickly and be taken down from the cross before the Sabbath. That He was already found dead caused wonder. And this was also what amazed Pilate, as we read, when the Lord's body was requested from him for burial.

16. Wherefore, since the spirit is to be preferred to the body, and the death of the spirit means that God has left it, but the death of the body that the spirit has left it; and since herein lies the punishment in the death of the body, that the spirit leaves the body against its will, because it left God willingly; so that, whereas the spirit left God because it would, it leaves the body although it would not; nor leaves it when it would, unless it has offered violence to itself, whereby the body itself is slain: the spirit of the Mediator showed how it was through no punishment of sin that He came to the death of the flesh, because He did not leave it against His will, but because He willed, when He willed, as He willed. For because He is so commingled [with the flesh] by the Word of God as to be one, He says: I have power to lay down my life, and I have power to take it again. No man takes it from me, but I lay down my life that I might take it again. And, as the Gospel tells us, they who were present were most astonished at this, that after that [last] word, in which He set forth the figure of our sin, He immediately gave up His spirit. For they who are hung on the cross are commonly tortured by a prolonged death. Whence it was that the legs of the thieves were broken, in order that they might die directly, and be taken down from the cross before the Sabbath. And that He was found to be dead already, caused wonder. And it was this also, at which, as we read, Pilate marvelled, when the body of the Lord was asked of him for burial.

Because that deceiver—who acted as a mediator to death for humanity and falsely presented himself as a mediator to life through the name of cleansing by means of sacrilegious rites and sacrifices that lead the proud astray—can neither share in our death nor rise again from his own. He has indeed been able to apply his single death to our double one, but he certainly has not been able to apply a single resurrection that would serve both as a mystery of our renewal and as a pattern of the final awakening. Therefore, He who being alive in the spirit raised His own dead flesh—the true Mediator of life—has cast out the one who is dead in the spirit and the mediator of death from the spirits of those who believe in Him, so that the devil cannot reign within but can only assault from outside, and even then without prevailing. Christ also offered Himself to be tempted, so that He might be a mediator to overcome the devil's temptations not only by providing help but also by setting an example. But when the devil, from the very beginning, tried through every opening to creep into Christ's inward being and was thrust out—having finished all his tempting allurements in the wilderness after the baptism—because being dead in the spirit he could force no entrance into Him who was alive in the spirit, the devil turned his eagerness for human death in any form toward accomplishing the only death he could. He was permitted to carry it out upon that mortal element which the living Mediator had received from us. And where the devil could do anything, there he was completely conquered in every respect. And in the very act of receiving outward power to kill the Lord in the flesh, his inward power by which he held us was slain. For it came about that the bonds of many sins in many deaths were loosed through the one death of One whom no sin had preceded. This death, though not owed, the Lord rendered for us so that the death we owed might not harm us. For He was not stripped of the flesh by obligation to any authority, but He stripped Himself. Surely He who could have avoided death if He had chosen instead died because He chose to, and so He made a show of principalities and powers, openly triumphing over them in Himself. For by His death the one and most real sacrifice was offered up for us, and whatever fault existed by which principalities and powers held us fast as if by right to pay its penalty, He cleansed, abolished, and extinguished. And by His own resurrection He also called us whom He predestined to a new life, and whom He called, He justified, and whom He justified, He glorified. And so the devil, in that very death of the flesh, lost the human being he had been possessing as if by absolute right—seduced by his own consent—and over whom he ruled, himself unhindered by any corruption of flesh and blood, through that frailty of our mortal body which made us both poor and weak. He was proud in proportion to being, as it were, both richer and stronger, ruling over one who was, as it were, both clothed in rags and full of troubles. For where he drove the sinner to fall without following himself, there by following he compelled the Redeemer to descend. And so the Son of God chose to become our friend in the fellowship of death—and because the enemy did not come to that death, he thought himself better and greater than us. For our Redeemer says, "Greater love has no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends." Therefore the devil also thought himself superior to the Lord Himself, since the Lord in His sufferings yielded to him. For that passage in the Psalm is understood of Him too: "For You have made Him a little lower than the angels." The result was that He, being Himself put to death though innocent by the unjust one acting against us as if by just right, might by a most just right overcome him, and so might lead captive the captivity brought about through sin, and free us from a captivity that was just on account of sin, by blotting out the handwriting and redeeming us who were to be justified though sinners, through His own righteous blood unrighteously poured out.

17. Because that deceiver then — who was a mediator to death for man, and feignedly puts himself forward as to life, under the name of cleansing by sacrilegious rites and sacrifices, by which the proud are led away — can neither share in our death, nor rise again from his own: he has indeed been able to apply his single death to our double one; but he certainly has not been able to apply a single resurrection, which should be at once a mystery of our renewal, and a type of that waking up which is to be in the end. He then who being alive in the spirit raised again His own flesh that was dead, the true Mediator of life, has cast out him, who is dead in the spirit and the mediator of death, from the spirits of those who believe in Himself, so that he should not reign within, but should assault from without, and yet not prevail. And to him, too, He offered Himself to be tempted, in order that He might be also a mediator to overcome his temptations, not only by succor, but also by example. But when the devil, from the first, although striving through every entrance to creep into His inward parts, was thrust out, having finished all his alluring temptation in the wilderness after the baptism; because, being dead in the spirit, he forced no entrance into Him who was alive in the spirit, he betook himself, through eagerness for the death of man in any way whatsoever, to effecting that death which he could, and was permitted to effect it upon that mortal element which the living Mediator had received from us. And where he could do anything, there in every respect he was conquered; and wherein he received outwardly the power of slaying the Lord in the flesh, therein his inward power, by which he held ourselves, was slain. For it was brought to pass that the bonds of many sins in many deaths were loosed, through the one death of One which no sin had preceded. Which death, though not due, the Lord therefore rendered for us, that the death which was due might work us no hurt. For He was not stripped of the flesh by obligation of any authority, but He stripped Himself. For doubtless He who was able not to die, if He would not, did die because He would: and so He made a show of principalities and powers, openly triumphing over them in Himself. For whereas by His death the one and most real sacrifice was offered up for us, whatever fault there was, whence principalities and powers held us fast as of right to pay its penalty, He cleansed, abolished, extinguished; and by His own resurrection He also called us whom He predestinated to a new life; and whom He called, them He justified; and whom He justified, them He glorified. And so the devil, in that very death of the flesh, lost man, whom he was possessing as by an absolute right, seduced as he was by his own consent, and over whom he ruled, himself impeded by no corruption of flesh and blood, through that frailty of man's mortal body, whence he was both too poor and too weak; he who was proud in proportion as he was, as it were, both richer and stronger, ruling over him who was, as it were, both clothed in rags and full of troubles. For whither he drove the sinner to fall, himself not following, there by following he compelled the Redeemer to descend. And so the Son of God deigned to become our friend in the fellowship of death, to which because he came not, the enemy thought himself to be better and greater than ourselves. For our Redeemer says, Greater love has no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends. Wherefore also the devil thought himself superior to the Lord Himself, inasmuch as the Lord in His sufferings yielded to him; for of Him, too, is understood what is read in the Psalm, For You have made Him a little lower than the angels: so that He, being Himself put to death, although innocent, by the unjust one acting against us as it were by just right, might by a most just right overcome him, and so might lead captive the captivity wrought through sin, and free us from a captivity that was just on account of sin, by blotting out the handwriting, and redeeming us who were to be justified although sinners, through His own righteous blood unrighteously poured out.

So even today the devil mocks those who belong to him. He presents himself to them as a false mediator, claiming they will be cleansed by his rituals when in fact they are being entangled and drowned by them. He easily persuades the proud to ridicule and despise the death of Christ, because the more removed he himself is from that death, the more they believe him to be holier and more divine. Yet very few have remained with him, since the nations now acknowledge the price paid for them, drink it in with devout humility, abandon their enemy in trust upon it, and gather together to their Redeemer. The devil does not understand how God's supreme wisdom uses both his traps and his rage to accomplish the salvation of God's faithful ones, extending from the first end, which is the beginning of the spiritual creature, all the way to the final end, which is the death of the body, and so reaching from one end to the other, ordering all things mightily and sweetly. For wisdom passes through and moves through all things because of her purity, and nothing defiled can enter into her. And since the devil has nothing to do with the death of the flesh, which is the source of his great pride, a different kind of death is prepared in the eternal fire of hell, by which not only spirits that have earthly bodies, but also those who have aerial bodies, can be tormented. But proud people, who despise Christ because He died—the very means by which He purchased us at such a great price—bring back the earlier death and also bring humanity back to that miserable condition of nature which comes from the first sin, and they will be cast down into the final death along with the devil. They prefer the devil to Christ because the devil cast them into that first death, which he himself did not fall into due to the difference in his nature, and which Christ descended into out of His great mercy for their sake. Yet they do not hesitate to believe themselves better than the devils, and they never stop attacking and condemning them with every kind of curse, even while knowing that the devils at least have nothing to do with suffering this kind of death, which is the very reason they despise Christ. They refuse to consider that it might be possible for the Word of God, while remaining in Himself and unchangeable in Himself in every way, to be able through taking on a lower nature to suffer something of a lower kind, which the unclean spirit cannot suffer because he does not have an earthly body. Thus, although they themselves are better than the devils, yet because they have a body of flesh, they can die in a way that the devils certainly cannot die, since the devils do not have such a body. They place great confidence in the deaths of their own sacrifices, not realizing that they are sacrificing to deceitful and proud spirits. Or if they have come to realize it, they think the friendship of these spirits—treacherous and envious as they are—is somehow good for them, even though their only purpose is to prevent our return.

18. Hence also the devil mocks those who are his own until this very day, to whom he presents himself as a false mediator, as though they would be cleansed or rather entangled and drowned by his rites, in that he very easily persuades the proud to ridicule and despise the death of Christ, from which the more he himself is estranged, the more is he believed by them to be the holier and more divine. Yet those who have remained with him are very few, since the nations acknowledge and with pious humility imbibe the price paid for themselves, and in trust upon it abandon their enemy, and gather together to their Redeemer. For the devil does not know how the most excellent wisdom of God makes use of both his snares and his fury to bring about the salvation of His own faithful ones, beginning from the former end, which is the beginning of the spiritual creature, even to the latter end, which is the death of the body, and so reaching from the one end to the other, mightily and sweetly ordering all things. For wisdom passes and goes through all things by reason of her pureness, and no defiled thing can fall into her. And since the devil has nothing to do with the death of the flesh, whence comes his exceeding pride, a death of another kind is prepared in the eternal fire of hell, by which not only the spirits that have earthly, but also those who have aerial bodies, can be tormented. But proud men, by whom Christ is despised, because He died, wherein He bought us with so great a price, both bring back the former death, and also men, to that miserable condition of nature, which is derived from the first sin, and will be cast down into the latter death with the devil. And they on this account preferred the devil to Christ, because the former cast them into that former death, whither he himself fell not through the difference of his nature, and whither on account of them Christ descended through His great mercy: and yet they do not hesitate to believe themselves better than the devils, and do not cease to assail and denounce them with every sort of malediction, while they know them at any rate to have nothing to do with the suffering of this kind of death, on account of which they despise Christ. Neither will they take into account that the case may possibly be, that the Word of God, remaining in Himself, and in Himself in no way changeable, may yet, through the taking upon Him of a lower nature, be able to suffer somewhat of a lower kind, which the unclean spirit cannot suffer, because he has not an earthly body. And so, whereas they themselves are better than the devils, yet, because they bear a body of flesh, they can so die, as the devils certainly cannot die, who do not bear such a body. They presume much on the deaths of their own sacrifices, which they do not perceive that they sacrifice to deceitful and proud spirits; or if they have come to perceive it, think their friendship to be of some good to themselves, treacherous and envious although they are, whose purpose is bent upon nothing else except to hinder our return.

Chapter 14.– Christ the Most Perfect Victim for Cleansing Our Faults. In Every Sacrifice Four Things are to Be Considered.

They do not understand that not even the most arrogant spirits themselves could take pleasure in the honor of sacrifices unless a true sacrifice was owed to the one true God, in whose place they wish to be worshipped. This sacrifice cannot be properly offered except by a holy and righteous priest, and unless what is offered comes from those for whom it is being offered, and unless it is without fault so that it can be offered to cleanse those who are faulty. At least everyone who wants a sacrifice offered for themselves to God desires these things. Who, then, is such a righteous and holy priest as the only Son of God, who had no need to cleanse his own sins through sacrifice—neither original sins nor those acquired through human life? And what could men more appropriately choose to offer for themselves than human flesh? And what is more suitable for this sacrificial killing than mortal flesh? And what is so pure for cleansing the sins of mortal people as the flesh born from the womb of a virgin, without any taint of fleshly desire? And what could be more acceptably offered and received than the flesh of our sacrifice, which is the body of our priest? In this way, since four things must be considered in every sacrifice—to whom it is offered, by whom it is offered, what is offered, and for whom it is offered—this same one true Mediator himself, reconciling us to God through the sacrifice of peace, remains one with the one to whom he offered it, makes those for whom he offered it one in himself, and is himself in one person both the one who offers and the offering.

19. They do not understand, that not even the proudest of spirits themselves could rejoice in the honor of sacrifices, unless a true sacrifice was due to the one true God, in whose stead they desire to be worshipped: and that this cannot be rightly offered except by a holy and righteous priest; nor unless that which is offered be received from those for whom it is offered; and unless also it be without fault, so that it may be offered for cleansing the faulty. This at least all desire who wish sacrifice to be offered for themselves to God. Who then is so righteous and holy a priest as the only Son of God, who had no need to purge His own sins by sacrifice, neither original sins, nor those which are added by human life? And what could be so fitly chosen by men to be offered for them as human flesh? And what so fit for this immolation as mortal flesh? And what so clean for cleansing the faults of mortal men as the flesh born in and from the womb of a virgin, without any infection of carnal concupiscence? And what could be so acceptably offered and taken, as the flesh of our sacrifice, made the body of our priest? In such wise that, whereas four things are to be considered in every sacrifice — to whom it is offered, by whom it is offered, what is offered, for whom it is offered, — the same One and true Mediator Himself, reconciling us to God by the sacrifice of peace, might remain one with Him to whom He offered, might make those one in Himself for whom He offered, Himself might be in one both the offerer and the offering.

Chapter 15.– They are Proud Who Think They are Able, by Their Own Righteousness, to Be Cleansed So as to See God.

There are, however, some who think they are capable of being cleansed by their own righteousness so that they can contemplate God and dwell in God. Their very pride stains them more than anything else. There is no sin that the divine law opposes more strongly, and over which that most prideful of spirits—who acts as a mediator to lower things but as a barrier against higher things—receives a greater right of dominion. This is true unless either his hidden snares are avoided by taking another path, or if he rages openly through a sinful people (which is what Amalek means when interpreted), and forbids passage to the promised land by fighting, then he is overcome by the cross of the Lord, which is prefigured by the holding out of Moses' hands. These people promise themselves cleansing by their own righteousness because some of them have been able to penetrate beyond the whole creation with the eye of the mind and to touch, even if only in a very small way, the light of unchangeable truth. This is something they mock many Christians for not yet being able to do, who in the meantime live by faith alone. But what use is it for the proud person, who for this reason is ashamed to board the ship of wood, to see from a distance his homeland beyond the sea? Or how can it harm the humble person not to see it from such a great distance when he is actually coming to it on that wood which the other person disdains to be carried upon?

20. There are, however, some who think themselves capable of being cleansed by their own righteousness, so as to contemplate God, and to dwell in God; whom their very pride itself stains above all others. For there is no sin to which the divine law is more opposed, and over which that proudest of spirits, who is a mediator to things below, but a barrier against things above, receives a greater right of mastery: unless either his secret snares be avoided by going another way, or if he rage openly by means of a sinful people (which Amalek, being interpreted, means), and forbid by fighting the passage to the land of promise, he be overcome by the cross of the Lord, which is prefigured by the holding out of the hands of Moses. For these persons promise themselves cleansing by their own righteousness for this reason, because some of them have been able to penetrate with the eye of the mind beyond the whole creature, and to touch, though it be in ever so small a part, the light of the unchangeable truth; a thing which they deride many Christians for being not yet able to do, who, in the meantime, live by faith alone. But of what use is it for the proud man, who on that account is ashamed to embark upon the ship of wood, to behold from afar his country beyond the sea? Or how can it hurt the humble man not to behold it from so great a distance, when he is actually coming to it by that wood upon which the other disdains to be borne?

Chapter 16.– The Old Philosophers are Not to Be Consulted Concerning the Resurrection and Concerning Things to Come.

These people also criticize us for believing in the resurrection of the flesh, and would rather have us believe them about these matters. As though, simply because they have been able to understand the high and unchangeable substance through the things that are made, this gives them the right to be consulted about the cycles of changeable things or about the connected order of the ages. For consider this: even though they argue most truly and persuade us with most certain proofs that all temporal things are made according to an eternal science, does this mean they can see clearly within this science itself, or gather from it, how many kinds of animals there are, what the seeds of each are at their beginnings, what their measure is as they grow, what numbers govern their conceptions, births, ages, and deaths, and what movements they make in seeking things suited to their nature and avoiding the opposite? Haven't they discovered all these things not through that unchangeable wisdom, but through the actual record of places and times, or by trusting the written experiences of others? Therefore it is even less surprising that they have completely failed in investigating the sequence of longer ages and in finding any end point to that course along which, as though down a river, the human race is traveling, and the transition from there of each person to their own appropriate end. For these are subjects that historians could not describe, since they are far in the future and have been experienced and recorded by no one. Nor have those philosophers who have advanced further than others in that high and eternal science been able to grasp such subjects with their understanding; otherwise they would not be investigating past things of this kind as best they could, such as fall within the province of historians, but would instead also foreknow future things; and those who can do this are called soothsayers by them, but prophets by us.

21. These people also blame us for believing the resurrection of the flesh, and rather wish us to believe themselves concerning these things. As though, because they have been able to understand the high and unchangeable substance by the things which are made, for this reason they had a claim to be consulted concerning the revolutions of mutable things, or concerning the connected order of the ages. For pray, because they dispute most truly, and persuade us by most certain proofs, that all things temporal are made after a science that is eternal, are they therefore able to see clearly in the matter of this science itself, or to collect from it, how many kinds of animals there are, what are the seeds of each in their beginnings, what measure in their increase, what numbers run through their conceptions, births, ages, settings; what motions in desiring things according to their nature, and in avoiding the contrary? Have they not sought out all these things, not through that unchangeable wisdom, but through the actual history of places and times, or have trusted the written experience of others? Wherefore it is the less to be wondered at, that they have utterly failed in searching out the succession of more lengthened ages, and in finding any goal of that course, down which, as though down a river, the human race is sailing, and the transition thence of each to its own appropriate end. For these are subjects which historians could not describe, inasmuch as they are far in the future, and have been experienced and related by no one. Nor have those philosophers, who have profiled better than others in that high and eternal science, been able to grasp such subjects with the understanding; otherwise they would not be inquiring as they could into past things of the kind, such as are in the province of historians, but rather would foreknow also things future; and those who are able to do this are called by them soothsayers, but by us prophets:

Chapter 17.– In How Many Ways Things Future are Foreknown. Neither Philosophers, Nor Those Who Were Distinguished Among the Ancients, are to Be Consulted Concerning the Resurrection of the Dead.

Although the name of prophets is not entirely foreign to their writings, there is a very great difference in how future things are known. Future events may be guessed through experience of past events (just as doctors have written down many predictions based on their own experience, or as farmers and sailors also predict many things; when such predictions are made long in advance, they are considered divinations). Or future things may have already begun their journey toward us, and being seen from far away, are announced according to how sharp the senses are of those who see them—by doing this, the aerial powers are thought to divine (just as if someone from the top of a mountain saw someone coming from far away and announced it beforehand to those living nearby in the plain). Or future events are either announced beforehand to certain people, or are heard by them and passed on to others, through holy angels, to whom God shows these things by His Word and His Wisdom, in which both future and past things exist. Or the minds of certain people themselves are lifted up so far by the Holy Spirit that they behold, not through angels but by themselves, the unchangeable causes of future things in that very highest summit of the universe itself. For the aerial powers also hear these things, either by message through angels or through people, and hear only as much as He judges fitting, to whom all things are subject. Many things are also predicted by a kind of instinct and inner impulse by those who do not understand them, just as Caiaphas did not know what he said, but being the high priest, he prophesied.

22.– although the name of prophets, too, is not altogether foreign to their writings. But it makes the greatest possible difference, whether things future are conjectured by experience of things past (as physicians also have committed many things to writing in the way of foresight, which they themselves have noted by experience; or as again husbandmen, or sailors, too, foretell many things; for if such predictions are made a long while before, they are thought to be divinations), or whether such things have already started on their road to come to us, and being seen coming far off, are announced in proportion to the acuteness of the sense of those who see them, by doing which the aerial powers are thought to divine (just as if a person from the top of a mountain were to see far off some one coming, and were to announce it beforehand to those who dwelt close by in the plain); or whether they are either fore-announced to certain men, or are heard by them and again transmitted to other men, by means of holy angels, to whom God shows those things by His Word and His Wisdom, wherein both things future and things past consist: or whether the minds of certain men themselves are so far borne upwards by theHoly Spirit, as to behold, not through the angels, but of themselves, the immoveable causes of things future, in that very highest pinnacle of the universe itself. [And I say, behold,] for the aerial powers, too, hear these things, either by message through angels, or through men; and hear only so much as He judges to be fitting, to whom all things are subject. Many things, too, are foretold by a kind of instinct and inward impulse of such as know them not: as Caiaphas did not know what he said, but being the high priest, he prophesied.

We should not consult those philosophers about the succession of ages or the resurrection of the dead, even though they have understood as much as they could about the eternity of the Creator, in whom we live and move and have our being. While they knew God through the things He made, they did not glorify Him as God or give thanks. Instead, claiming to be wise, they became fools. They were not able to focus the mind's eye firmly enough on the eternity of the spiritual and unchangeable nature to see, in the very wisdom of the Creator and Governor of the universe, those cycles of the ages which already existed and always existed in that wisdom, but which here were still to come and did not yet exist. Nor were they able to see in that wisdom the changes for the better, not only of human souls but also of human bodies, leading to the perfection of their full measure. Since they were completely unable to see these things there, they were not even considered worthy of receiving any announcement of them through the holy angels, whether externally through the bodily senses or through interior revelations shown in the spirit. These things were actually revealed to our fathers who possessed true piety, and who, by foretelling them and gaining trust either through present signs or through nearby events that happened as they predicted, earned the right to be believed about things in the distant future, even to the end of the world. But the proud and deceitful powers of the air, even when they are found to have spoken through their fortune-tellers about the fellowship and citizenship of the saints and the true Mediator—things they heard from the holy prophets or angels—did so with the intention of deceiving even God's faithful ones, if possible, by using these borrowed truths to lead them away to their own falsehoods. But God caused those who did not know what they were saying to speak these things, so that the truth might be proclaimed from every direction, to help the faithful and to witness against the ungodly.

23. Therefore, neither concerning the successions of ages, nor concerning the resurrection of the dead, ought we to consult those philosophers, who have understood as much as they could the eternity of the Creator, in whom we live, and move, and have our being. Since, knowing God through those things which are made, they have not glorified Him as God, neither were thankful but professing themselves wise, they became fools. And whereas they were not fit to fix the eye of the mind so firmly upon the eternity of the spiritual and unchangeable nature, as to be able to see, in the wisdom itself of the Creator and Governor of the universe, those revolutions of the ages, which in that wisdom were already and were always, but here were about to be so that as yet they were not; or, again, to see therein those changes for the better, not of the souls only, but also of the bodies of men, even to the perfection of their proper measure; whereas then, I say, they were in no way fit to see these things therein, they were not even judged worthy of receiving any announcement of them by the holy angels; whether externally through the senses of the body, or by interior revelations exhibited in the spirit; as these things actually were manifested to our fathers, who were gifted with true piety, and who by foretelling them, obtaining credence either by present signs, or by events close at hand, which turned out as they had foretold, earned authority to be believed respecting things remotely future, even to the end of the world. But the proud and deceitful powers of the air, even if they are found to have said through their soothsayers some things of the fellowship and citizenship of the saints, and of the true Mediator, which they heard from the holy prophets or the angels, did so with the purpose of seducing even the faithful ones of God, if they could, by these alien truths, to revolt to their own proper falsehoods. But God did this by those who knew not what they said, in order that the truth might sound abroad from all sides, to aid the faithful, to be a witness against the ungodly.

Chapter 18.– The Son of God Became Incarnate in Order that We Being Cleansed by Faith May Be Raised to the Unchangeable Truth.

Since we were unable to grasp eternal things, and since the filth of our sins weighed us down—sins we had acquired through our love of temporal things and which had become implanted in us almost naturally from the root of our mortality—it was necessary for us to be cleansed. But we could not be cleansed in such a way as to be united with eternal things except through temporal things, with which we were already united and held fast. For health is the opposite of disease, but the intermediate process of healing does not lead us to perfect health unless it has some connection with the disease. Useless temporal things merely deceive the sick, while useful temporal things take up those who need healing and, once they are healed, pass them on to eternal things. The rational mind, just as it owes contemplation to eternal things when cleansed, likewise owes faith to temporal things when it needs cleansing. Even one of those who were formerly considered wise among the Greeks said that truth relates to faith in the same way eternity relates to that which has a beginning. He is undoubtedly correct in saying this. For what we call temporal, he describes as having had a beginning. We ourselves also fall under this category, not only with respect to the body but also with respect to the changeableness of the soul. For nothing that undergoes any degree of change can properly be called eternal. Therefore, insofar as we are changeable, we are separated from eternity. But eternal life is promised to us through the truth, and our faith stands as far apart from clear knowledge of that truth as mortality does from eternity. We now place faith in things done in time for our sake, and through that very faith we are cleansed, so that when we come to sight—just as truth follows faith—eternity may follow mortality. Therefore, since our faith will become truth when we attain what is promised to us who believe, and what is promised to us is eternal life, and the Truth has said (not the truth that will come to be according to what our faith shall be, but the Truth which always is, because in it is eternity), "And this is life eternal, that they might know You the only true God, and Jesus Christ, whom You have sent"—when our faith through seeing becomes truth, then eternity will possess our now-changed mortality. Until this happens, and in order that it may happen—because we direct the faith of belief toward things which have a beginning, just as in eternal things we hope for the truth of contemplation, lest the faith of mortal life be at odds with the truth of eternal life—the Truth itself, co-eternal with the Father, took a beginning from earth when the Son of God came in such a way as to become the Son of man and to take our faith to Himself, so that He might thereby lead us to His own truth. He took on our mortality without losing His own eternity. For truth relates to faith in the way eternity relates to that which has a beginning. Therefore, we must be cleansed in such a way that we may come to have the kind of beginning that remains eternal, so that we do not have one beginning in faith and another in truth. We could not pass from the condition of having a beginning to eternal things unless we were transferred to His own eternity by the union of the eternal to ourselves through our own beginning. Therefore our faith has now, in some measure, followed to where He in whom we have believed has ascended: born, dead, risen again, taken up. Of these four things, we already knew the first two in ourselves, for we know that people both have a beginning and die. But the remaining two—to be raised and to be taken up—we rightly hope will happen in us because we have believed them accomplished in Him. Since, therefore, in Him that which had a beginning has passed over to eternity, it will likewise pass over in us when faith arrives at truth. For to those who believe in this way, so that they might remain in the word of faith and from there be led on to truth, and through that to eternity, and be freed from death, He speaks thus: "If you continue in my word, then are you my disciples indeed." And as though they would ask, "With what result?" He continues, "And you shall know the truth." And again, as though they would say, "Of what benefit is truth to mortal people?" He says, "And the truth shall make you free." Free from what, except from death, from corruption, from changeableness? Since truth remains immortal, incorrupt, unchangeable. But true immortality, true incorruptibility, true unchangeableness, is eternity itself.

24. Since, then, we were not fit to take hold of things eternal, and since the foulness of sins weighed us down, which we had contracted by the love of temporal things, and which were implanted in us as it were naturally, from the root of mortality, it was needful that we should be cleansed. But cleansed we could not be, so as to be tempered together with things eternal, except it were through things temporal, wherewith we were already tempered together and held fast. For health is at the opposite extreme from disease; but the intermediate process of healing does not lead us to perfect health, unless it has some congruity with the disease. Things temporal that are useless merely deceive the sick; things temporal that are useful take up those that need healing, and pass them on healed, to things eternal. And the rational mind, as when cleansed it owes contemplation to things eternal; so, when needing cleansing, owes faith to things temporal. One even of those who were formerly esteemed wise men among the Greeks has said, The truth stands to faith in the same relation in which eternity stands to that which has a beginning. And he is no doubt right in saying so. For what we call temporal, he describes as having had a beginning. And we also ourselves come under this kind, not only in respect to the body, but also in respect to the changeableness of the soul. For that is not properly called eternal which undergoes any degree of change. Therefore, in so far as we are changeable, in so far we stand apart from eternity. But life eternal is promised to us through the truth, from the clear knowledge of which, again, our faith stands as far apart as mortality does from eternity. We then now put faith in things done in time on our account, and by that faith itself we are cleansed; in order that when we have come to sight, as truth follows faith, so eternity may follow upon mortality. And therefore, since our faith will become truth, when we have attained to that which is promised to us who believe: and that which is promised us is eternal life; and the Truth (not that which shall come to be according as our faith shall be, but that truth which is always, because in it is eternity — the Truth then) has said, And this is life eternal, that they might know You the only true God, and Jesus Christ, whom You have sent: when our faith by seeing shall come to be truth, then eternity shall possess our now changed mortality. And until this shall take place, and in order that it may take place — because we adapt the faith of belief to things which have a beginning, as in things eternal we hope for the truth of contemplation, lest the faith of mortal life should be at discord with the truth of eternal life — the Truth itself, co-eternal with the Father, took a beginning from earth, when the Son of God so came as to become the Son of man, and to take to Himself our faith, that He might thereby lead us on to His own truth, who so undertook our mortality, as not to lose His own eternity. For truth stands to faith in the relation in which eternity stands to that which has a beginning. Therefore, we must needs so be cleansed, that we may come to have such a beginning as remains eternal, that we may not have one beginning in faith, and another in truth. Neither could we pass to things eternal from the condition of having a beginning, unless we were transferred, by union of the eternal to ourselves through our own beginning, to His own eternity. Therefore our faith has, in some measure, now followed there, whither He in whom we have believed has ascended; born, dead, risen again, taken up. Of these four things, we knew the first two in ourselves. For we know that men both have a beginning and die. But the remaining two, that is, to be raised, and to be taken up, we rightly hope will be in us, because we have believed them done in Him. Since, therefore, in Him that, too, which had a beginning has passed over to eternity, in ourselves also it will so pass over, when faith shall have arrived at truth. For to those who thus believe, in order that they might remain in the word of faith, and being thence led on to the truth, and through that to eternity, might be freed from death, He speaks thus: If you continue in my word, then are you my disciples indeed. And as though they would ask, With what fruit? He proceeds to say, And you shall know the truth. And again, as though they would say, Of what good is truth to mortal men? And the truth, He says, shall make you free. From what, except from death, from corruptions, from changeableness? Since truth remains immortal, incorrupt, unchangeable. But true immortality, true incorruptibility, true unchangeableness, is eternity itself.

Chapter 19.– In What Manner the Son Was Sent and Proclaimed Beforehand. How in the Sending of His Birth in the Flesh He Was Made Less Without Detriment to His Equality with the Father.

Here is what it means for the Son of God to be sent—indeed, what the sending of the Son of God actually is. All the things that were done in time to produce faith, so we could be cleansed and able to see truth, had their beginning in what was set forth from eternity and will return to eternity. These things were either testimonies to this mission, or they were the mission of the Son of God itself. Some of these testimonies announced beforehand that He would come, while others testified that He had already come. Since He who created all things was Himself made a creature, the whole creation must necessarily bear witness to this. For unless the one being sent were proclaimed by many witnesses, the one would not be connected to the sending away of many. And unless there were testimonies that would seem great to lowly people, they would not believe that He who is great could make people great by coming as lowly to the lowly. For the heavens and the earth and everything in them are incomparably greater works of the Son of God—since all things were made by Him—than the signs and wonders that appeared as testimony to Him. Yet people, being lowly, needed to tremble at those lowly things as though they were great, so they could believe that these great things had been accomplished by Him.

25. Behold, then, why the Son of God was sent; nay, rather behold what it is for the Son of God to be sent. Whatever things they were which were wrought in time, with a view to produce faith, whereby we might be cleansed so as to contemplate truth, in things that have a beginning, which have been put forth from eternity, and are referred back to eternity: these were either testimonies of this mission, or they were the mission itself of the Son of God. But some of these testimonies announced Him beforehand as to come, some testified that He had come already. For that He was made a creature by whom the whole creation was made, must needs find a witness in the whole creation. For except one were preached by the sending of many [witnesses] one would not be bound to, the sending away of many. And unless there were such testimonies as should seem to be great to those who are lowly, it would not be believed, that He being great should make men great, who as lowly was sent to the lowly. For the heaven and the earth and all things in them are incomparably greater works of the Son of God, since all things were made by Him, than the signs and the portents which broke forth in testimony of Him. But yet men, in order that, being lowly, they might believe these great things to have been wrought by Him, trembled at those lowly things, as if they had been great.

When the fullness of time had come, God sent forth His Son, made of a woman, made under the Law. He was lowly to such a degree that He was made, and therefore sent in that He was made. So if the greater sends the less, we too acknowledge that He was made less—less in so far as He was made, and made in so far as He was sent. For He sent forth His Son made of a woman. And yet, because all things were made by Him, not only before He was made and sent, but before all things existed at all, we confess that the same one whom we call less because He was sent is equal to the sender. How then could He be seen by the fathers when certain angelic visions were shown to them before that fullness of time when it was fitting He should be sent—that is, before He was sent, when He who was not yet sent was seen as He is equal with the Father? For how does He say to Philip, by whom He was certainly seen as by all the rest, and even by those who crucified Him in the flesh, "Have I been so long time with you, and yet have you not known me, Philip? He that has seen me has seen the Father also"—unless because He was both seen and yet not seen? He was seen as He had been made in being sent; He was not seen as the one by whom all things were made. Or how does He also say this: "He that has my commandments and keeps them, he it is that loves me; and he that loves me shall be loved of my Father, and I will love him, and will manifest myself to him," at a time when He was already manifest before the eyes of men—unless because He was offering that flesh, which the Word was made in the fullness of time, to be accepted by our faith, but was keeping back the Word itself, by whom all things were made, to be contemplated in eternity by the mind when cleansed by faith?

26. When, therefore, the fullness of time had come, God sent forth His Son, made of a woman, made under the Law; to such a degree lowly, that He was made; in this way therefore sent, in that He was made. If, therefore, the greater sends the less, we too, acknowledge Him to have been made less; and in so far less, in so far as made; and in so far made, in so far as sent. For He sent forth His Son made of a woman. And yet, because all things were made by Him, not only before He was made and sent, but before all things were at all, we confess the same to be equal to the sender, whom we call less, as having been sent. In what way, then, could He be seen by the fathers, when certain angelical visions were shown to them, before that fullness of time at which it was fitting He should be sent, and so before He was sent, at a time when not yet sent He was seen as He is equal with the Father? For how does He say to Philip, by whom He was certainly seen as by all the rest, and even by those by whom He was crucified in the flesh, Have I been so long time with you, and yet have you not known me, Philip? He that has seen me, has seen the Father also; unless because He was both seen and yet not seen? He was seen, as He had been made in being sent; He was not seen, as by Him all things were made. Or how does He say this too, He that has my commandments and keeps them, he it is that loves me; and he that loves me shall be loved of my Father, and I will love him, and will manifest myself to him, at a time when He was manifest before the eyes of men; unless because He was offering that flesh, which the Word was made in the fullness of time, to be accepted by our faith; but was keeping back the Word itself, by whom all things were made, to be contemplated in eternity by the mind when cleansed by faith?

Chapter 20.– The Sender and the Sent Equal. Why the Son is Said to Be Sent by the Father. Of the Mission of the Holy Spirit. How and by Whom He Was Sent. The Father the Beginning of the Whole Godhead.

If the Son is said to be sent by the Father because one is the Father and the other is the Son, this does not prevent us from believing the Son to be equal, consubstantial, and co-eternal with the Father, and yet to have been sent as Son by the Father. This is not because one is greater and the other less, but because one is Father and the other Son; one is the begetter and the other the begotten; one is He from whom the one who is sent comes, and the other is He who comes from the one who sends. For the Son is from the Father, not the Father from the Son. Following this understanding, we can now see that the Son is not only said to have been sent because the Word became flesh, but was sent so that the Word might become flesh and perform through his bodily presence those things that were written. That is, he is understood to have been sent not only as man, which the Word became, but the Word itself was sent so that it might become man. He was not sent because of any inequality of power, substance, or anything in him that was not equal to the Father, but because the Son is from the Father, not the Father from the Son. The Son is the Word of the Father, which is also called his wisdom. What is surprising, then, if he is sent, not because he is unequal with the Father, but because he is a pure emanation (manatio) flowing from the glory of the Almighty God? For there, what flows out and that from which it flows are of one and the same substance. It does not flow out as water flows from an opening in earth or stone, but as light flows from light. For the words "she is the brightness of the everlasting light"—what else do they mean than "she is light of everlasting light"? For what is the brightness of light, except light itself? And so it is co-eternal with the light from which the light comes. But it is better to say "the brightness of light" rather than "the light of light," so that what flows out should not be thought to be darker than what it flows from. When one hears of the brightness of light as being light itself, it is easier to believe that the former shines by means of the latter than that the latter shines less. But because there was no need to warn people not to think that the light which begot the other was less (for no heretic ever dared say this, nor is it believable that anyone will dare to do so), Scripture addresses that other thought, by which the light that flows out might seem darker than that from which it flows. It has removed this assumption by saying it is the brightness of that light, namely, of eternal light, and so shows it to be equal. For if it were less, it would be its darkness, not its brightness; but if it were greater, it could not flow from it, for it could not surpass that from which it comes. Therefore, because it flows from it, it is not greater than it is; and because it is not its darkness but its brightness, it is not less than it is; therefore it is equal. Nor should it trouble us that it is called a pure emanation flowing from the glory of the Almighty God, as if it were not itself omnipotent but an emanation from the Omnipotent. For soon after it is said of it, "And being but one, she can do all things." But who is omnipotent unless he who can do all things? It is sent, therefore, by him from whom it flows, for so she is sought after by him who loved and desired her. "Send her," he says, "out of your holy heavens, and from the throne of your glory, that, being present, she may labor with me"—that is, may teach me to labor willingly so that I may not labor painfully. For her labors are virtues. But she is sent in one way so that she may be with man; she has been sent in another way so that she herself may be man. For, entering into holy souls, she makes them friends of God and prophets; so she also fills the holy angels and works all things fitting for such ministries through them. But when the fullness of time had come, she was sent, not to fill angels or to be an angel (except insofar as she announced the counsel of the Father, which was also her own), nor again to be with men or in men, for this too took place before, both in the fathers and in the prophets. But she was sent so that the Word itself should become flesh, that is, should become man. In this future mystery, when revealed, was to be the salvation of those wise and holy men also who, before he was born of the Virgin, were born of women. And in this mystery, when accomplished and made known, is the salvation of all who believe, hope, and love. For this is the great mystery of godliness, which was revealed in the flesh, justified in the Spirit, seen by angels, preached to the Gentiles, believed on in the world, and received up into glory.

27. But if the Son is said to be sent by the Father on this account, that the one is the Father, and the other the Son, this does not in any manner hinder us from believing the Son to be equal, and consubstantial, and co-eternal with the Father, and yet to have been sent as Son by the Father. Not because the one is greater, the other less; but because the one is Father, the other Son; the one begetter, the other begotten; the one, He from whom He is who is sent; the other, He who is from Him who sends. For the Son is from the Father, not the Father from the Son. And according to this manner we can now understand that the Son is not only said to have been sent because the Word was made flesh, but therefore sent that the Word might be made flesh, and that He might perform through His bodily presence those things which were written; that is, that not only is He understood to have been sent as man, which the Word was made but the Word, too, was sent that it might be made man; because He was not sent in respect to any inequality of power, or substance, or anything that in Him was not equal to the Father; but in respect to this, that the Son is from the Father, not the Father from the Son; for the Son is the Word of the Father, which is also called His wisdom. What wonder, therefore, if He is sent, not because He is unequal with the Father, but because He is a pure emanation ( manatio) issuing from the glory of the Almighty God? For there, that which issues, and that from which it issues, is of one and the same substance. For it does not issue as water issues from an aperture of earth or of stone, but as light issues from light. For the words, For she is the brightness of the everlasting light, what else are they than, she is light of everlasting light? For what is the brightness of light, except light itself? And so co-eternal, with the light, from which the light is. But it is preferable to say, the brightness of light, rather than the light of light; lest that which issues should be thought to be darker than that from which it issues. For when one hears of the brightness of light as being light itself, it is more easy to believe that the former shines by means of the latter, than that the latter shines less. But because there was no need of warning men not to think that light to be less, which begot the other (for no heretic ever dared say this, neither is it to be believed that any one will dare to do so), Scripture meets that other thought, whereby that light which issues might seem darker than that from which it issues; and it has removed this surmise by saying, It is the brightness of that light, namely, of eternal light, and so shows it to be equal. For if it were less, then it would be its darkness, not its brightness; but if it were greater, then it could not issue from it, for it could not surpass that from which it is educed. Therefore, because it issues from it, it is not greater than it is; and because it is not its darkness, but its brightness, it is not less than it is: therefore it is equal. Nor ought this to trouble us, that it is called a pure emanation issuing from the glory of the Almighty God, as if itself were not omnipotent, but an emanation from the Omnipotent; for soon after it is said of it, And being but one, she can do all things. But who is omnipotent, unless He who can do all things? It is sent, therefore, by Him from whom it issues; for so she is sought after by him who loved and desired her. Send her, he says, out of Your holy heavens, and from the throne of Your glory, that, being present, she may labor with me; that is, may teach me to labor [heartily] in order that I may not labor [irksomely]. For her labors are virtues. But she is sent in one way that she may be with man; she has been sent in another way that she herself may be man. For, entering into holy souls, she makes them friends of God and prophets; so she also fills the holy angels, and works all things fitting for such ministries by them. But when the fullness of time had come, she was sent, not to fill angels, nor to be an angel, except in so far as she announced the counsel of the Father, which was her own also; nor, again, to be with men or in men, for this too took place before, both in the fathers and in the prophets; but that the Word itself should be made flesh, that is, should be made man. In which future mystery, when revealed, was to be the salvation of those wise and holy men also, who, before He was born of the Virgin, were born of women; and in which, when done and made known, is the salvation of all who believe, and hope, and love. For this is the great mystery of godliness, which was manifest in the flesh, justified in the Spirit, seen of angels, preached unto the Gentiles, believed on in the world, received up into glory.

Therefore the Word of God is sent by the one whose Word He is. He is sent by the one who begot Him. The one who begot sends, and what is begotten is sent. And He is sent to each person when that person apprehends and perceives Him, to the extent that He can be apprehended and perceived, according to the capacity of the rational soul either advancing toward God or already perfected in God. The Son, therefore, is not properly said to have been sent simply because He is begotten of the Father. Rather, He is sent either when the Word made flesh appeared to the world, which is why He says, "I came forth from the Father, and have come into the world," or when from time to time He is perceived by each person's mind, as in the saying, "Send her, that, being present with me, she may labor with me." What is born from eternity is eternal, for it is the brightness of the everlasting light. But what is sent from time to time is what is apprehended by each person. When the Son of God was made manifest in the flesh, He was sent into this world in the fullness of time, made of a woman. For since, in the wisdom of God, the world through wisdom did not know God (because the light shines in darkness, and the darkness did not comprehend it), it pleased God through the foolishness of preaching to save those who believe, and for the Word to be made flesh and dwell among us. But when from time to time He comes forth and is perceived by each person's mind, He is indeed said to be sent, but not into this world, because He does not appear sensibly—that is, He does not present Himself to the bodily senses. For we ourselves are not in this world when we grasp with our minds, as far as we can, what is eternal. And the spirits of all the righteous are not in this world, even those still living in the flesh, insofar as they have discernment in divine things. But the Father is not said to be sent when from time to time He is apprehended by anyone, because He has no one from whom to be or from whom to proceed. For Wisdom says, "I came out of the mouth of the Most High," and it is said of the Holy Spirit, "He proceeds from the Father," but the Father is from no one.

28. Therefore the Word of God is sent by Him, of whom He is the Word; He is sent by Him, from whom He was begotten ( genitum); He sends who begot, That is sent which is begotten. And He is then sent to each one, when He is apprehended and perceived by each, in so far as He can be apprehended and perceived, in proportion to the comprehension of the rational soul, either advancing towards God, or already perfect in God. The Son, therefore, is not properly said to have been sent in that He is begotten of the Father; but either in that the Word made flesh appeared to the world, whence He says, I came forth from the Father, and have come into the world; or in that from time to time, He is perceived by the mind of each, according to the saying, Send her, that, being present with me, she may labor with me. What then is born ( natum) from eternity is eternal, for it is the brightness of the everlasting light; but what is sent from time to time, is that which is apprehended by each. But when the Son of God was made manifest in the flesh, He was sent into this world in the fullness of time, made of a woman. For after that, in the wisdom of God, the world by wisdom knew not God (since the light shines in darkness, and the darkness comprehended it not), it pleased God by the foolishness of preaching to save them that believe, and that the Word should be made flesh, and dwell among us. But when from time to time He comes forth and is perceived by the mind of each, He is said indeed to be sent, but not into this world; for He does not appear sensibly, that is, He does not present Himself to the corporeal senses. For we ourselves, too, are not in this world, in respect to our grasping with the mind as far as we can that which is eternal; and the spirits of all the righteous are not in this world, even of those who are still living in the flesh, in so far as they have discernment in things divine. But the Father is not said to be sent, when from time to time He is apprehended by any one, for He has no one of whom to be, or from whom to proceed; since Wisdom says, I came out of the mouth of the Most High, and it is said of the Holy Spirit, He proceeds from the Father, but the Father is from no one.

Just as the Father begets and the Son is begotten, so the Father sends and the Son is sent. And just as the one who begets and the one who is begotten are one, so both the one who sends and the one who is sent are one, since the Father and the Son are one. The Holy Spirit is likewise one with them, since these three are one. For just as being born, in relation to the Son, means to be from the Father, so being sent, in relation to the Son, means to be known to be from the Father. And just as being the gift of God, in relation to the Holy Spirit, means to proceed from the Father, so being sent means to be known to proceed from the Father. We cannot say that the Holy Spirit does not also proceed from the Son, for the same Spirit is reasonably called the Spirit of both the Father and the Son. I see no other meaning in what Jesus intended when he breathed on the faces of the disciples and said, "Receive the Holy Spirit." That physical breath, coming from his body with the sensation of physical touch, was not the substance of the Holy Spirit, but a declaration through an appropriate sign that the Holy Spirit proceeds not only from the Father but also from the Son. Only the greatest of fools would claim that the Spirit he gave when he breathed on them was different from the one he sent after his ascension. For there is one Spirit of God, the Spirit of the Father and of the Son, the Holy Spirit, who works all things in all. The fact that he was given twice certainly had significant meaning, which we will discuss in its proper place, as the Lord allows. When the Lord says, "Whom I will send to you from the Father," this shows the Spirit to be of both the Father and the Son, because when he had said, "Whom the Father will send," he also added, "in my name." Yet he did not say, "Whom the Father will send from me," as he said, "Whom I will send to you from the Father," showing that the Father is the principium of the whole Godhead, or if it is better expressed, deity. Therefore, the one who proceeds from the Father and from the Son is traced back to him from whom the Son was born. As for what the evangelist says, "For the Holy Spirit was not yet given, because Jesus was not yet glorified," how should we understand this except that the special giving or sending of the Holy Spirit after Christ's glorification would be such as had never existed before? It was not that the Spirit did not exist previously, but that he had not been given in this particular way before. For if the Holy Spirit was not given before, what filled the prophets who spoke? Scripture clearly says and shows in many places that they spoke by the Holy Spirit. John the Baptist was told, "He will be filled with the Holy Spirit, even from his mother's womb." His father Zechariah was found to have been filled with the Holy Spirit, enabling him to say such things about John. Mary too was filled with the Holy Spirit, enabling her to foretell such things about the Lord she was carrying in her womb. Simeon and Anna were filled with the Holy Spirit, enabling them to recognize the greatness of the infant Christ. How then was the Spirit not yet given, since Jesus was not yet glorified, unless that particular giving, granting, or mission of the Holy Spirit was to have a certain unique quality in its very coming, such as never existed before? We read nowhere that people spoke in languages they did not know through the Holy Spirit coming upon them, as happened then, when it was necessary that his coming be made clear through visible signs, in order to show that the whole world and all nations with their different languages should believe in Christ through the gift of the Holy Spirit, fulfilling what is sung in the Psalm: "There is no speech nor language where their voice is not heard; their sound has gone out through all the earth, and their words to the end of the world."

29. As, therefore, the Father begot, the Son is begotten; so the Father sent, the Son was sent. But in like manner as He who begot and He who was begotten, so both He who sent and He who was sent, are one, since the Father and the Son are one. So also the Holy Spirit is one with them, since these three are one. For as to be born, in respect to the Son, means to be from the Father; so to be sent, in respect to the Son, means to be known to be from the Father. And as to be the gift of God in respect to the Holy Spirit, means to proceed from the Father; so to be sent, is to be known to proceed from the Father. Neither can we say that the Holy Spirit does not also proceed from the Son, for the same Spirit is not without reason said to be the Spirit both of the Father and of the Son. Nor do I see what else He intended to signify, when He breathed on the face of the disciples, and said, Receive the Holy Ghost. For that bodily breathing, proceeding from the body with the feeling of bodily touching, was not the substance of the Holy Spirit, but a declaration by a fitting sign, that the Holy Spirit proceeds not only from the Father, but also from the Son. For the veriest of madmen would not say, that it was one Spirit which He gave when He breathed on them, and another which He sent after His ascension. For the Spirit of God is one, the Spirit of the Father and of the Son, the Holy Spirit, who works all in all. But that He was given twice was certainly a significant economy, which we will discuss in its place, as far as the Lord may grant. That then which the Lord says — Whom I will send unto you from the Father, — shows the Spirit to be both of the Father and of the Son; because, also, when He had said, Whom the Father will send, He added also, in my name. Yet He did not say, Whom the Father will send from me, as He said, Whom I will send unto you from the Father, — showing, namely, that the Father is the beginning ( principium) of the whole divinity, or if it is better so expressed, deity. He, therefore, who proceeds from the Father and from the Son, is referred back to Him from whom the Son was born ( natus). And that which the evangelist says, For the Holy Ghost was not yet given, because that Jesus was not yet glorified; how is this to be understood, unless because the special giving or sending of the Holy Spirit after the glorification of Christ was to be such as it had never been before? For it was not previously none at all, but it had not been such as this. For if the Holy Spirit was not given before, wherewith were the prophets who spoke filled? Whereas the Scripture plainly says, and shows in many places, that they spoke by the Holy Spirit. Whereas, also, it is said of John the Baptist, And he shall be filled with the Holy Ghost, even from his mother's womb. And his father Zacharias is found to have been filled with the Holy Ghost, so as to say such things of him. And Mary, too, was filled with the Holy Ghost, so as to foretell such things of the Lord, whom she was bearing in her womb. And Simeon and Anna were filled with the Holy Spirit, so as to acknowledge the greatness of the little child Christ. How, then, was the Spirit not yet given, since Jesus was not yet glorified, unless because that giving, or granting, or mission of the Holy Spirit was to have a certain speciality of its own in its very advent, such as never was before? For we read nowhere that men spoke in tongues which they did not know, through the Holy Spirit coming upon them; as happened then, when it was needful that His coming should be made plain by visible signs, in order to show that the whole world, and all nations constituted with different tongues, should believe in Christ through the gift of the Holy Spirit, to fulfill that which is sung in the Psalm, There is no speech nor language where their voice is not heard; their sound is gone out through all the earth, and their words to the end of the world.

Therefore, a human being was united and in a certain way joined together with the Word of God to form One Person. This happened when the fullness of time came and the Son of God, born of a woman, was sent into this world so that He might also be the Son of man for the sake of the sons of men. Angelic nature could prefigure this person beforehand in order to announce it in advance, but could not take it on so as to actually be that person itself.

30. Therefore man was united, and in some sense commingled, with the Word of God, so as to be One Person, when the fullness of time had come, and the Son of God, made of a woman, was sent into this world, that He might be also the Son of man for the sake of the sons of men. And this person angelic nature could prefigure beforehand, so as to pre-announce, but could not appropriate, so as to be that person itself.

Chapter 21.– Of the Sensible Showing of the Holy Spirit, and of the Coeternity of the Trinity. What Has Been Said, and What Remains to Be Said.

Regarding the visible manifestation of the Holy Spirit, whether in the form of a dove or tongues of fire—when the subordinate and obedient creature through temporal movements and forms revealed His substance that is coeternal with the Father and the Son, and equally unchangeable with them, though it was not united to become one person with Him as the flesh was that the Word became—I do not venture to say that nothing similar happened in earlier times. However, I would confidently say that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, of one and the same substance, God the Creator, the Omnipotent Trinity, work indivisibly. But this cannot be shown indivisibly through the creature, which is far inferior, and especially not through the bodily creature. This is just as the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit cannot be named by our words, which are certainly bodily sounds, except in their own distinct time intervals, divided by clear separation, intervals that the individual syllables of each word occupy. For in their own substance, wherein they exist, the three are one—the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit—the very same, without any temporal movement, above all creation, without any interval of time and place, and eternally one and the same from eternity to eternity, as if they were eternity itself, which exists with truth and charity. But in my words, the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are separated and cannot be named simultaneously, and they occupy their own distinct places in separate visible letters. And just as when I name my memory, intellect, and will, each name refers to each one individually, yet each name is spoken by all three together—for there is not one of these three names that is not spoken by my memory, intellect, and will together as a whole soul—so the Trinity together produced both the voice of the Father, the flesh of the Son, and the dove of the Holy Spirit, while each of these things is referred individually to each person. Through this analogy it becomes somewhat clear that the Trinity, which is inseparable in itself, is manifested separately through the visible appearance of the creature, and that the operation of the Trinity is also inseparable in each individual instance of those things said to pertain specifically to the manifestation of either the Father, the Son, or the Holy Spirit.

But with respect to the sensible showing of the Holy Spirit, whether by the shape of a dove, or by fiery tongues, when the subjected and subservient creature by temporal motions and forms manifested His substance co-eternal with the Father and the Son, and alike with them unchangeable, while it was not united so as to be one person with Him, as the flesh was which the Word was made; I do not dare to say that nothing of the kind was done aforetime. But I would boldly say, that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, of one and the same substance, God the Creator, the Omnipotent Trinity, work indivisibly; but that this cannot be indivisibly manifested by the creature, which is far inferior, and least of all by the bodily creature: just as the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit cannot be named by our words, which certainly are bodily sounds, except in their own proper intervals of time, divided by a distinct separation, which intervals the proper syllables of each word occupy. Since in their proper substance wherein they are, the three are one, the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit, the very same, by no temporal motion, above the whole creature, without any interval of time and place, and at once one and the same from eternity to eternity, as it were eternity itself, which is not without truth and charity. But, in my words, the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are separated, and cannot be named at once, and occupy their own proper places separately invisible letters. And as, when I name my memory, and intellect, and will, each name refers to each severally, but yet each is uttered by all three; for there is no one of these three names that is not uttered by both my memory and my intellect and my will together [by the soul as a whole]; so the Trinity together wrought both the voice of the Father, and the flesh of the Son, and the dove of the Holy Spirit, while each of these things is referred severally to each person. And by this similitude it is in some degree discernible, that the Trinity, which is inseparable in itself, is manifested separably by the appearance of the visible creature; and that the operation of the Trinity is also inseparable in each severally of those things which are said to pertain properly to the manifesting of either the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Spirit.

If I am asked in what way words or sensible forms and appearances were produced before the incarnation of the Word of God to prefigure his coming, I answer that God brought these things about through angels. I think I have also shown this sufficiently through testimonies from the Holy Scriptures. If I am asked how the incarnation itself came to pass, I answer that the Word of God himself was made flesh—that is, was made man—yet he was not turned or changed into what was made. Rather, he was made in such a way that there should be present not only the Word of God and the flesh of man, but also the rational soul of man, and this whole should be called both God on account of God and man on account of man. If this is understood with difficulty, the mind must be cleansed by faith, by increasingly abstaining from sins and doing good works, and by praying with the groaning of holy desires, so that by making progress through divine help, it may both understand and love. If I am asked how, after the incarnation of the Word, either a voice of the Father was produced or a bodily appearance by which the Holy Spirit was shown, I do not doubt that this was done through a created thing. But whether it was only through a bodily and sensible creature, or whether it also involved a rational or intellectual spirit (for this is the term some prefer to use for what the Greeks call noeron), certainly not in such a way as to form one person (for who could possibly say that whatever creature it was through which the Father's voice sounded is God the Father in that sense, or that whatever creature it was through which the Holy Spirit was shown in the form of a dove or in fiery tongues is the Holy Spirit in that sense, as the Son of God is that man who was made from a virgin?), but only for the service of bringing about such signs as God judged necessary—or whether something else should be understood—is difficult to discover and not wise to affirm rashly. Yet I do not see how those things could have been brought about without a rational or intellectual creature. But this is not yet the proper place to explain, as the Lord may give me strength, why I think this. For the arguments of heretics must first be discussed and refuted—arguments they produce not from the divine books but from their own reasoning, by which they think they forcibly compel us to understand the testimonies of Scripture that deal with the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit in the way they themselves want.

31. If then I am asked, in what manner either words or sensible forms and appearances were wrought before the incarnation of the Word of God, which should prefigure it as about to come, I reply that God wrought those things by the angels; and this I have also shown sufficiently, as I think, by testimonies of the Holy Scriptures. And if I am asked how the incarnation itself was brought to pass, I reply that the Word of God itself was made flesh, that is, was made man, yet not turned and changed into that which was made; but so made, that there should be there not only the Word of God and the flesh of man, but also the rational soul of man, and that this whole should both be called God on account of God, and man on account of man. And if this is understood with difficulty, the mind must be purged by faith, by more and more abstaining from sins, and by doing good works, and by praying with the groaning of holy desires; that by profiting through the divine help, it may both understand and love. And if I am asked, how, after the incarnation of the Word, either a voice of the Father was produced, or a corporeal appearance by which the Holy Spirit was manifested: I do not doubt indeed that this was done through the creature; but whether only corporeal and sensible, or whether by the employment also of the spirit rational or intellectual (for this is the term by which some choose to call what the Greeks name νοερόν), not certainly so as to form one person (for who could possibly say that whatever creature it was by which the voice of the Father sounded, is in such sense God the Father; or whatever creature it was by which the Holy Spirit was manifested in the form of a dove, or in fiery tongues, is in such sense the Holy Spirit, as the Son of God is that man who was made of a virgin?), but only to the ministry of bringing about such intimations as God judged needful; or whether anything else is to be understood: is difficult to discover, and not expedient rashly to affirm. Yet I see not how those things could have been brought to pass without the rational or intellectual creature. But it is not yet the proper place to explain, as the Lord may give me strength, why I so think; for the arguments of heretics must first be discussed and refuted, which they do not produce from the divine books, but from their own reasons, and by which, as they think, they forcibly compel us so to understand the testimonies of the Scriptures which treat of the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit, as they themselves will.

I believe I have now sufficiently shown that the Son is not inferior simply because He is sent by the Father, nor is the Holy Spirit inferior because He was sent by both the Father and the Son. These things are presented in the Scriptures either because of the visible creature, or rather to help us understand the emanation within the Godhead—but not because of any inequality, disparity, or difference of ousia. Even if God the Father had chosen to appear visibly through a created being, it would be completely absurd to say that He was sent either by the Son, whom He begot, or by the Holy Spirit, who proceeds from Him. Let this be the end of the present book. From here on, in the remaining books, we will examine, with the Lord's help, the nature of the heretics' deceptive arguments and how they can be refuted.

32. But now, as I think, it has been sufficiently shown, that the Son is not therefore less because He is sent by the Father, nor the Holy Spirit less because both the Father sent Him and the Son. For these things are perceived to be laid down in the Scriptures, either on account of the visible creature; or rather on account of commending to our thoughts the emanation [within the Godhead]; but not on account of inequality, or imparity, or unlikeness of substance; since, even if God the Father had willed to appear visibly through the subject creature, yet it would be most absurd to say that He was sent either by the Son, whom He begot, or by the Holy Spirit, who proceeds from Him. Let this, therefore, be the limit of the present book. Henceforth in the rest we shall see, the Lord helping, of what sort are those crafty arguments of the heretics, and in what manner they may be confuted.


On the Trinity — Book III

How God appeared to the patriarchs and to Moses: through created things and the ministry of angels, not by showing His own substance.

The question is discussed with respect to the appearances of God spoken of in the previous book, which were made under bodily forms, whether only a creature was formed, for the purpose of manifesting God to human sight in such way as He at each time judged fitting; or whether angels, already existing, were so sent as to speak in the person of God; and this, either by assuming a bodily appearance from the bodily creature, or by changing their own bodies into whatever forms they would, suitable to the particular action, according to the power given to them by the Creator; while the essence itself of God was never seen in itself.

Source: Translated by Arthur West Haddan. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 3. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1887. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/130103.htm>.

Contents · 12 chapters
  1. Preface.– Why Augustine Writes of the Trinity. What He Claims from Readers. What Has Been Said in the Previous Book.
  2. Chapter 1.– What is to Be Said Thereupon.
  3. Chapter 2.– The Will of God is the Higher Cause of All Corporeal Change. This is Shown by an Example.
  4. Chapter 3.– Of the Same Argument.
  5. Chapter 4.– God Uses All Creatures as He Will, and Makes Visible Things for the Manifestation of Himself.
  6. Chapter 5.– Why Miracles are Not Usual Works.
  7. Chapter 6.– Diversity Alone Makes a Miracle.
  8. Chapter 7.– Great Miracles Wrought by Magic Arts.
  9. Chapter 8.– God Alone Creates Those Things Which are Changed by Magic Art.
  10. Chapter 9.– The Original Cause of All Things is from God.
  11. Chapter 10.– In How Many Ways the Creature is to Be Taken by Way of Sign. The Eucharist.
  12. Chapter 11.– The Essence of God Never Appeared in Itself. Divine Appearances to the Fathers Wrought by the Ministry of Angels. An Objection Drawn from the Mode of Speech Removed. That the Appearing of God to Abraham Himself, Just as that to Moses, Was Wrought by Angels. The Same Thing is Proved by the Law Being Given to Moses by Angels. What Has Been Said in This Book, and What Remains to Be Said in the Next.

Preface.– Why Augustine Writes of the Trinity. What He Claims from Readers. What Has Been Said in the Previous Book.

I would prefer to spend my time reading rather than writing for others to read, and those who are willing should believe this. But for those who won't believe it yet are able and willing to put me to the test, let them first grant me whatever answers can be gathered from reading—whether for my own questions or for questions others ask me, which I must endure because of my position serving Christ and because of my passionate concern that our faith be strengthened against the errors of fleshly and worldly-minded people. Then let them see how gladly I would avoid this work and how joyfully I would set aside my pen. However, if what we have read on these subjects is either insufficiently explained, or cannot be found at all, or at least cannot easily be found by us in Latin, while we are not familiar enough with Greek to be competent to read and understand books on such topics in that language (though from the little that has been translated for us, I have no doubt that everything we could profitably seek is contained in those Greek writings), and yet I cannot refuse my brothers and sisters when they require of me, by that law which has made me their servant, that I minister above all to their worthy studies in Christ through my speaking and writing—these two being yoked together in me with Love as the driver—and while I myself confess that through writing I have learned many things I did not know: if all this is so, then this labor of mine should not seem pointless to any idle reader or to any very learned reader, since it is greatly needed by many who are busy and by many who are not learned, and among the latter, by myself. Therefore, greatly supported and helped by the writings of others I have already read on this subject, I have undertaken to inquire into and discuss whatever seems to my judgment can be reverently inquired into and discussed concerning the Trinity, the one supreme and supremely good God—with him urging me to this inquiry and helping me in the discussion of it—so that, if there are no other writings of this kind, there may be something for those willing and able to have and read; but if any already exist, then it may be all the easier to find such writings, the more of this kind there are in existence.

1. I Would have them believe, who are willing to do so, that I had rather bestow labor in reading, than in dictating what others may read. But let those who will not believe this, but are both able and willing to make the trial, grant me whatever answers may be gathered from reading, either to my own inquiries, or to those interrogations of others, which for the character I bear in the service of Christ, and for the zeal with which I burn that our faith may be fortified against the error of carnal and natural men, I must needs bear with; and then let them see how easily I would refrain from this labor, and with how much even of joy I would give my pen a holiday. But if what we have read upon these subjects is either not sufficiently set forth, or is not to be found at all, or at any rate cannot easily be found by us, in the Latin tongue, while we are not so familiar with the Greek tongue as to be found in any way competent to read and understand therein the books that treat of such topics, in which class of writings, to judge by the little which has been translated for us, I do not doubt that everything is contained that we can profitably seek; while yet I cannot resist my brethren when they exact of me, by that law by which I am made their servant, that I should minister above all to their praiseworthy studies in Christ by my tongue and by my pen, of which two yoked together in me, Love is the charioteer; and while I myself confess that I have by writing learned many things which I did not know: if this be so, then this my labor ought not to seem superfluous to any idle, or to any very learned reader; while it is needful in no small part, to many who are busy, and to many who are unlearned,and among these last to myself. Supported, then, very greatly, and aided by the writings we have already read of others on this subject, I have undertaken to inquire into and to discuss, whatever it seems to my judgment can be reverently inquired into and discussed, concerning the Trinity, the one supreme and supremely good God; He himself exhorting me to the inquiry, and helping me in the discussion of it; in order that, if there are no other writings of the kind, there may be something for those to have and read who are willing and capable; but if any exist already, then it may be so much the easier to find some such writings, the more there are of the kind in existence.

Certainly, just as in all my writings I want not only a devout reader but also someone free to correct me, I especially want this in the present investigation, which is so important that I wish there were as many inquirers as there are critics. But just as I don't want my reader to be bound to me, so I don't want my corrector to be bound to himself. The reader should not love me more than the catholic faith, and the corrector should not love himself more than the catholic truth. To the reader I say: Don't be willing to accept my writings as you would the canonical Scriptures. In Scripture, when you discover something you didn't previously believe, believe it without hesitation. But in my writings, unless you have understood with certainty what you didn't previously hold as certain, don't hold it fast. To the corrector I say: Don't be willing to correct my writings by your own opinion or argument, but from the divine text or by irrefutable reasoning. If you recognize anything true in them, its presence there doesn't make it mine, but by understanding and loving it, let it belong to both you and me. But if you prove anything false, even though it was once mine because I was guilty of the error, let us both now avoid it so that it belongs to neither you nor me.

2. Assuredly, as in all my writings I desire not only a pious reader, but also a free corrector, so I especially desire this in the present inquiry, which is so important that I would there were as many inquirers as there are objectors. But as I do not wish my reader to be bound down to me, so I do not wish my corrector to be bound down to himself. Let not the former love me more than the catholic faith, let not the latter love himself more than the catholic verity. As I say to the former, Do not be willing to yield to my writings as to the canonical Scriptures; but in these, when you have discovered even what you did not previously believe, believe it unhesitatingly; while in those, unless you have understood with certainty what you did not before hold as certain, be unwilling to hold it fast: so I say to the latter, Do not be willing to amend my writings by your own opinion or disputation, but from the divine text, or by unanswerable reason. If you apprehend anything of truth in them, its being there does not make it mine, but by understanding and loving it, let it be both yours and mine; but if you convict anything of falsehood, though it have once been mine, in that I was guilty of the error, yet now by avoiding it let it be neither yours nor mine.

Let this third book begin where the second one ended. After we reached the point where we wanted to show that the Son was not less than the Father simply because the Father sent and the Son was sent, and that the Holy Spirit was not less than both simply because we read in the Gospel that He was sent by both of them, we then undertook to inquire into the following: Since the Son was sent to where He already was—for He came into the world and was in the world—and since the Holy Spirit was also sent to where He already was—for the Spirit of the Lord fills the world, and that which contains all things has knowledge of the voice—was the Lord therefore sent because He was born in the flesh so as to be no longer hidden, and, as it were, came forth from the bosom of the Father and appeared to the eyes of men in the form of a servant? And was the Holy Spirit also therefore sent because He too was seen as a dove in bodily form and in divided tongues like fire? In other words, does "to be sent," when spoken of them, mean to go forth to the sight of mortals in some bodily form from a spiritual hiding place? And because the Father did not do this, is He said only to have sent but not to be sent? Our next inquiry was: Why is the Father also not sometimes said to be sent, if He Himself was manifested through those bodily forms which appeared to the eyes of the ancients? But if the Son was manifested at those times, why should He be said to be sent only much later, when the fullness of time had come for Him to be born of a woman, since indeed He was sent before as well—namely, when He appeared bodily in those forms? Or if He could not rightly be said to be sent except when the Word was made flesh, why should the Holy Spirit be read of as sent, when such an incarnation never took place for Him? But if neither the Father nor the Son but the Holy Spirit was manifested through these ancient appearances, why should He too be said to be sent now when He was also sent before in these various ways? Next we divided the subject to handle it most carefully, and we made the question threefold, of which one part was explained in the second book, and two remain, which I shall now proceed to discuss. For we have already inquired and determined that not only the Father, nor only the Son, nor only the Holy Spirit appeared in those ancient bodily forms and visions, but either the Lord God without distinction, who is understood to be the Trinity itself, or some one person of the Trinity, whichever the text of the narrative might indicate through clues supplied by the context.

3. Let this third book, then, take its beginning at the point to which the second had reached. For after we had arrived at this, that we desired to show that the Son was not therefore less than the Father, because the Father sent and the Son was sent; nor the Holy Spirit therefore less than both, because we read in the Gospel that He was sent both by the one and by the other; we undertook then to inquire, since the Son was sent there, where He already was, for He came into the world, and was in the world; since also the Holy Spirit was sent there, where He already was, for the Spirit of the Lord fills the world, and that which contains all things has knowledge of the voice; whether the Lord was therefore sent because He was born in the flesh so as to be no longer hidden, and, as it were, came forth from the bosom of the Father, and appeared to the eyes of men in the form of a servant; and the Holy Spirit also was therefore sent, because He too was seen as a dove in a corporeal form, and in cloven tongues, like as of fire; so that, to be sent, when spoken of them, means to go forth to the sight of mortals in some corporeal form from a spiritual hiding-place; which, because the Father did not, He is said only to have sent, not also to be sent. Our next inquiry was, Why the Father also is not sometimes said to be sent, if He Himself was manifested through those corporeal forms which appeared to the eyes of the ancients. But if the Son was manifested at these times, why should He be said to be sent so long after, when the fullness of time had come that He should be born of a woman; since, indeed, He was sent before also, viz., when He appeared corporeally in those forms? Or if He were not rightly said to be sent, except when the Word was made flesh; why should the Holy Spirit be read of as sent, of whom such an incarnation never took place? But if neither the Father, nor the Son, but the Holy Spirit was manifested through these ancient appearances; why should He too be said to be sent now, when He was also sent before in these various manners? Next we subdivided the subject, that it might be handled most carefully, and we made the question threefold, of which one part was explained in the second book, and two remain, which I shall next proceed to discuss. For we have already inquired and determined, that not only the Father, nor only the Son, nor only the Holy Spirit appeared in those ancient corporeal forms and visions, but either indifferently the Lord God, who is understood to be the Trinity itself, or some one person of the Trinity, whichever the text of the narrative might signify, through intimations supplied by the context.

Chapter 1.– What is to Be Said Thereupon.

Let us continue our inquiry in order. Under the second part of that division, the question arose whether the creature was formed only for that work in which God, in whatever way He then judged fitting, might be manifested to human sight; or whether angels who already existed were sent in such a way as to speak in the person of God, taking on a bodily appearance from the bodily creature for the purpose of their ministry; or else changing and transforming their own body itself—which is not over them but is governed by them as subject to themselves—into whatever forms they wished that were appropriate and suitable for their actions, according to the power given to them by the Creator. When this part of the question has been investigated as far as God permits, then finally we must examine the question with which we started: whether the Son and the Holy Spirit were also sent before; and if so, what difference exists between that sending and the one we read about in the Gospel; or whether neither of them was sent except when either the Son was made of the Virgin Mary, or when the Holy Spirit appeared in a visible form, whether as a dove or in tongues of fire.

4. Let us, then, continue our inquiry now in order. For under the second head in that division the question occurred, whether the creature was formed for that work only, wherein God, in such way as He then judged it to be fitting, might be manifested to human sight; or whether angels, who already existed, were so sent as to speak in the person of God, assuming a corporeal appearance from the corporeal creature for the purpose of their ministry; or else changing and turning their own body itself, to which they are not subject, but govern it as subject to themselves, into whatever forms they would, that were appropriate and fit for their actions, according to the power given to them by the Creator. And when this part of the question shall have been investigated, so far as God permit, then, lastly, we shall have to see to that question with which we started, viz., whether the Son and the Holy Spirit were also sent before; and if it be so, then what difference there is between that sending and the one of which we read in the Gospel; or whether neither of them were sent, except when either the Son was made of the Virgin Mary, or when the Holy Spirit appeared in a visible form, whether as a dove or in tongues of fire.

I confess, however, that it goes beyond what I can achieve to investigate whether angels, while secretly working through the spiritual quality of their body that remains in them, take something from the lower and more bodily elements, which they fit to themselves and can change and turn like a garment into whatever bodily appearances they wish—and those appearances themselves are also real, just as real water was changed by our Lord into real wine—or whether they transform their own bodies themselves into what they desire, suitable to the particular action. But it makes no difference to the present question which of these it is. And although I am not able to understand these things through actual experience, since I am a man, in the way the angels do who perform these things and know them better than I know them—namely, how far my body can be changed by the working of my will, whether through my own experience of myself or through what I have learned from others—still, it is not necessary here to say which of these alternatives I should believe based on the authority of the divine Scriptures, or else I would be forced to prove it, and my discussion would become too lengthy on a subject that does not relate to the present question.

5. I confess, however, that it reaches further than my purpose can carry me to inquire whether the angels, secretly working by the spiritual quality of their body abiding still in them, assume somewhat from the inferior and more bodily elements, which, being fitted to themselves, they may change and turn like a garment into any corporeal appearances they will, and those appearances themselves also real, as real water was changed by our Lord into real wine; or whether they transform their own bodies themselves into that which they would, suitably to the particular act. But it does not signify to the present question which of these it is. And although I be not able to understand these things by actual experience, seeing that I am a man, as the angels do who do these things, and know them better than I know them, viz., how far my body is changeable by the operation of my will; whether it be by my own experience of myself, or by that which I have gathered from others; yet it is not necessary here to say which of these alternatives I am to believe upon the authority of the divine Scriptures, lest I be compelled to prove it, and so my discourse become too long upon a subject which does not concern the present question.

Our present inquiry, then, is whether the angels were the agents both in showing those bodily appearances to the eyes of men and in sounding those words in their ears when the sensible creature itself, serving the Creator at His command, was transformed for the time into whatever was needed. As it is written in the book of Wisdom: "For the creature serves You, who are the Maker, increases his strength against the unrighteous for their punishment, and abates his strength for the benefit of such as put their trust in You. Therefore, even then was it altered into all fashions, and was obedient to Your grace, that nourishes all things according to the desire of them that longed for You." For the power of God's will reaches through the spiritual creature even to the visible and sensible effects of the corporeal creature. For where does the wisdom of the omnipotent God not work what He wills, which reaches from one end to another mightily, and sweetly orders all things?

6. Our present inquiry then is, whether the angels were then the agents both in showing those bodily appearances to the eyes of men and in sounding those words in their ears when the sensible creature itself, serving the Creator at His beck, was turned for the time into whatever was needful; as it is written in the book of Wisdom, For the creature serves You, who art the Maker, increases his strength against the unrighteous for their punishment, and abates his strength for the benefit of such as put their trust in You. Therefore, even then was it altered into all fashions, and was obedient to Your grace, that nourishes all things according to the desire of them that longed for You. For the power of the will of God reaches through the spiritual creature even to visible and sensible effects of the corporeal creature. For where does not the wisdom of the omnipotent God work that which He wills, which reaches from one end to another mightily, and sweetly does order all things?

Chapter 2.– The Will of God is the Higher Cause of All Corporeal Change. This is Shown by an Example.

But there is one kind of natural order in the transformation and changeability of physical bodies. Although this order also serves God's command, people have stopped being amazed by it because it happens continuously and without interruption. This includes things that change either very quickly or at least within not-too-long periods of time in heaven, on earth, or in the sea—whether they rise, set, or change in appearance from time to time. Then there are other things that also arise from this same natural order but are less familiar because they happen at longer intervals. Even though ordinary people foolishly marvel at these things, they are understood by those who study this present world, and as generations pass they become less and less wonderful the more often they occur and the more people know about them. Examples include eclipses of the sun and moon, certain stars appearing rarely, earthquakes, abnormal births of living creatures, and other similar things. Not one of these takes place without the will of God, yet this fact is not obvious to most people. Therefore, the vanity of philosophers has found room to attribute these things to other causes—perhaps true causes, but only immediate ones—while they are completely unable to see the cause that is higher than all others, namely, the will of God. Or they attribute them to false causes that are not even proposed through any careful investigation of physical things and motions, but merely from their own guesswork and error.

7. But there is one kind of natural order in the conversion and changeableness of bodies, which, although itself also serves the bidding of God, yet by reason of its unbroken continuity has ceased to cause wonder; as is the case, for instance, with those things which are changed either in very short, or at any rate not long, intervals of time, in heaven, or earth, or sea; whether it be in rising, or in setting, or in change of appearance from time to time; while there are other things, which, although arising from that same order, yet are less familiar on account of longer intervals of time. And these things, although the many stupidly wonder at them, yet are understood by those who inquire into this present world, and in the progress of generations become so much the less wonderful, as they are the more often repeated and known by more people. Such are the eclipses of the sun and moon, and some kinds of stars, appearing seldom, and earthquakes, and unnatural births of living creatures, and other similar things; of which not one takes place without the will of God; yet, that it is so, is to most people not apparent. And so the vanity of philosophers has found license to assign these things also to other causes, true causes perhaps, but proximate ones, while they are not able to see at all the cause that is higher than all others, that is, the will of God; or again to false causes, and to such as are not even put forward out of any diligent investigation of corporeal things and motions, but from their own guess and error.

I will bring forward an example, if I can, to make this clearer. There is, we know, in the human body a certain bulk of flesh and an outward form, an arrangement and distribution of limbs, and a temperament of health. A soul breathed into it governs this body, and that soul is a rational one. This soul, therefore, although changeable, can nevertheless partake of that unchangeable wisdom, so that it may share in that which is in and of itself, as it is written in the Psalm concerning all the saints. From these saints, as from living stones, is built that Jerusalem which is the mother of us all, eternal in the heavens. For so it is sung: "Jerusalem is built as a city, that is partaker of that which is in and of itself." For "in and of itself," in that passage, is understood to refer to that supreme and unchangeable good, which is God, and to His own wisdom and will. To Him is sung in another place: "You shall change them, and they shall be changed; but You are the same."

8. I will bring forward an example, if I can, that this may be plainer. There is, we know, in the human body, a certain bulk of flesh and an outward form, and an arrangement and distraction of limbs, and a temperament of health; and a soul breathed into it governs this body, and that soul a rational one; which, therefore, although changeable, yet can be partaker of that unchangeable wisdom, so that it may partake of that which is in and of itself; as it is written in the Psalm concerning all saints, of whom as of living stones is built that Jerusalem which is the mother of us all, eternal in the heavens. For so it is sung, Jerusalem is built as a city, that is partaker of that which is in and of itself. For in and of itself, in that place, is understood of that chiefest and unchangeable good, which is God, and of His own wisdom and will. To whom is sung in another place, You shall change them, and they shall be changed; but You are the same.

Chapter 3.– Of the Same Argument.

Let us consider the case of a wise man whose rational soul already shares in unchangeable and eternal truth. He consults this truth about all his actions and does nothing at all without knowing through it that the action ought to be done, so that by submitting to it and obeying it he may act rightly. Now suppose this man, after consulting with the highest reason of divine righteousness—which he hears with the ear of his heart in secret—and following its command, wears out his body through labor in some work of mercy and becomes ill. When he consults doctors, one tells him the cause of his disease is too much dryness in the body, while another says it is too much moisture. One of them would certainly identify the true cause and the other would be wrong, but both would speak only of immediate causes—that is, bodily ones. But if we inquire into the cause of that dryness and find it was the self-imposed labor, then we would arrive at a higher cause, one that proceeds from the soul so as to affect the body that the soul governs. Yet this still would not be the first cause, for that was certainly a still higher cause, located in unchangeable wisdom itself. By serving this wisdom in love and obeying its unutterable commands, the soul of the wise man had undertaken that self-imposed labor. Thus nothing other than the will of God would truly be found to be the first cause of that illness. But suppose that in carrying out this work of pious labor, this wise man had employed the help of others to cooperate in the good work—people who did not serve God with the same will as he did, but either desired to gain rewards for their own fleshly desires or simply wished to avoid physical discomforts. Suppose too he had used pack animals, if completing the work required such resources. These pack animals would certainly be irrational creatures and would not therefore move their limbs under their burdens because they had any thought of that good work, but from the natural appetite of their own preference and to avoid discomfort. Finally, suppose he had used material things themselves that lack all sensation but were necessary for the work—for example, grain, wine, oils, clothes, money, a book, or anything of that kind. Certainly, in all these material things employed in this work, whether living or non-living, whatever movement, wear and tear, repair, destruction, renewal, or change of any kind took place as places and times affected them—could there be, I ask, any other cause of all these visible and changeable facts except the invisible and unchangeable will of God? This will uses all these things—both wicked and irrational souls, and finally bodies, whether those animated and given life by those souls or those lacking all sensation—by means of that upright soul as the seat of His wisdom, since primarily that good and holy soul itself employed them, having been subjected to His wisdom in pious and religious obedience.

Let us take, then, the case of a wise man, such that his rational soul is already partaker of the unchangeable and eternal truth, so that he consults it about all his actions, nor does anything at all, which he does not by it know ought to be done, in order that by being subject to it and obeying it he may do rightly. Suppose now that this man, upon counsel with the highest reason of the divine righteousness, which he hears with the ear of his heart in secret, and by its bidding, should weary his body by toil in some office of mercy, and should contract an illness; and upon consulting the physicians, were to be told by one that the cause of the disease was overmuch dryness of the body, but by another that it was overmuch moisture; one of the two no doubt would allege the true cause and the other would err, but both would pronounce concerning proximate causes only, that is, corporeal ones. But if the cause of that dryness were to be inquired into, and found to be the self-imposed toil, then we should have come to a yet higher cause, which proceeds from the soul so as to affect the body which the soul governs. Yet neither would this be the first cause, for that doubtless was a higher cause still, and lay in the unchangeable wisdom itself, by serving which in love, and by obeying its ineffable commands, the soul of the wise man had undertaken that self-imposed toil; and so nothing else but the will of God would be found most truly to be the first cause of that illness. But suppose now in that office of pious toil this wise man had employed the help of others to co-operate in the good work, who did not serve God with the same will as himself, but either desired to attain the reward of their own carnal desires, or shunned merely carnal unpleasantnesses;– suppose, too, he had employed beasts of burden, if the completion of the work required such a provision, which beasts of burden would be certainly irrational animals, and would not therefore move their limbs under their burdens because they at all thought of that good work, but from the natural appetite of their own liking, and for the avoiding of annoyance — suppose, lastly, he had employed bodily things themselves that lack all sense, but were necessary for that work, as e.g. grain, and wine, and oils, clothes, or money, or a book, or anything of the kind — certainly, in all these bodily things thus employed in this work, whether animate or inanimate, whatever took place of movement, of wear and tear, of reparation, of destruction, of renewal or of change in one way or another, as places and times affected them; pray, could there be, I say, any other cause of all these visible and changeable facts, except the invisible and unchangeable will of God, using all these, both bad and irrational souls, and lastly bodies, whether such as were inspired and animated by those souls, or such as lacked all sense, by means of that upright soul as the seat of His wisdom, since primarily that good and holy soul itself employed them, which His wisdom had subjected to itself in a pious and religious obedience?

Chapter 4.– God Uses All Creatures as He Will, and Makes Visible Things for the Manifestation of Himself.

What we have illustrated with the example of a single wise person—even though he still carries a mortal body and still sees only in part—can also be rightly applied to a household where such people live together, or to a city, or even to the entire world, if the highest rule and government of human affairs were in the hands of the wise and those who are piously and perfectly subject to God. But because this is not yet the case (for we must first be trained in this pilgrimage while still mortal, and taught through discipline by the power of gentleness and patience), let us turn our thoughts to that country above, the heavenly one from which we are now pilgrims. For there the will of God, who makes His angels spirits and His ministers a flaming fire, rules over spirits joined in perfect peace and friendship, united in one will by a kind of spiritual fire of love, as though in an exalted, holy, and hidden throne, as in His own house and His own temple. From there His will flows through all things by means of perfectly ordered movements in creation—first through spiritual creation, then through corporeal. He uses all things according to the unchanging purpose of His own will, whether they are incorporeal or corporeal, whether rational or irrational spirits, whether good by His grace or evil through their own will. Just as the denser and lower bodies are governed in proper order by the more refined and powerful ones, so all bodies are governed by living spirit. The living spirit that lacks reason is governed by the rational living spirit. The rational living spirit that falls short and sins is governed by the living and rational spirit that is devout and just. And that spirit is governed by God Himself, and so the entire created order is governed by its Creator, from whom and through whom and in whom it is also created and established. Thus it happens that the will of God is the first and highest cause of all visible forms and motions. For nothing happens visibly or perceptibly except by command or permission from the interior palace, invisible and intelligible, of the supreme Governor, according to the unspeakable justice of rewards and punishments, favor and retribution, in that vast and limitless commonwealth of all creation.

9. What, then, we have alleged by way of example of a single wise man, although of one still bearing a mortal body and still seeing only in part, may be allowably extended also to a family, where there is a society of such men, or to a city, or even to the whole world, if the chief rule and government of human affairs were in the hands of the wise, and of those who were piously and perfectly subject to God; but because this is not the case as yet (for it behooves us first to be exercised in this our pilgrimage after mortal fashion, and to be taught with stripes by force of gentleness and patience), let us turn our thoughts to that country itself that is above and heavenly, from which we here are pilgrims. For there the will of God, who makes His angels spirits, and His ministers a flaming fire, presiding among spirits which are joined in perfect peace and friendship, and combined in one will by a kind of spiritual fire of charity, as it were in an elevated and holy and secret seat, as in its own house and in its own temple, thence diffuses itself through all things by certain most perfectly ordered movements of the creature; first spiritual, then corporeal; and uses all according to the unchangeable pleasure of its own purpose, whether incorporeal things or things corporeal, whether rational or irrational spirits, whether good by His grace or evil through their own will. But as the more gross and inferior bodies are governed in due order by the more subtle and powerful ones, so all bodies are governed by the living spirit; and the living spirit devoid of reason, by the reasonable living spirit; and the reasonable living spirit that makes default and sins, by the living and reasonable spirit that is pious and just; and that by God Himself, and so the universal creature by its Creator, from whom and through whom and in whom it is also created and established. And so it comes to pass that the will of God is the first and the highest cause of all corporeal appearances and motions. For nothing is done visibly or sensibly, unless either by command or permission from the interior palace, invisible and intelligible, of the supreme Governor, according to the unspeakable justice of rewards and punishments, of favor and retribution, in that far-reaching and boundless commonwealth of the whole creature.

If, therefore, the Apostle Paul, although he still carried the burden of the body which is subject to corruption and weighs down the soul, and although he still saw only in part and as in a riddle, desiring to depart and be with Christ, and groaning within himself while waiting for his adoption—that is, the redemption of his body—was nevertheless able to preach the Lord Jesus Christ meaningfully in various ways: by his spoken words, by letter, and by the sacrament of His body and blood (since we certainly do not call the apostle's tongue, or the parchments, or the ink, or the meaningful sounds his tongue made, or the alphabetical marks written on skins, the body and blood of Christ; but only that which we take from the fruits of the earth and consecrate through mystical prayer, and then receive properly for our spiritual health in remembrance of our Lord's suffering for us—and this, although it is brought by human hands to that visible form, is not made holy to become so great a sacrament except by the Spirit of God working invisibly, since God accomplishes everything that happens in that work through bodily movements by first setting in motion the invisible realities of His servants, whether the souls of people or the service of hidden spirits subject to Him): what wonder is it if God also works the perceptible and visible things He desires in the created realm of heaven and earth, sea and air, in order to signify and reveal Himself through them, as He Himself knows is fitting, without any appearance of His very substance itself—that by which He exists, which is completely unchangeable and more inwardly and secretly exalted than all the spirits He has created?

10. If, therefore, the Apostle Paul, although he still bare the burden of the body, which is subject to corruption and presses down the soul, and although he still saw only in part and in an enigma, wishing to depart and be with Christ, and groaning within himself, waiting for the adoption, to wit, the redemption of his body, yet was able to preach the Lord Jesus Christ significantly, in one way by his tongue, in another by epistle, in another by the sacrament of His body and blood (since, certainly, we do not call either the tongue of the apostle, or the parchments, or the ink, or the significant sounds which his tongue uttered, or the alphabetical signs written on skins, the body and blood of Christ; but that only which we take of the fruits of the earth and consecrate by mystic prayer, and then receive duly to our spiritual health in memory of the passion of our Lord for us: and this, although it is brought by the hands of men to that visible form, yet is not sanctified to become so great a sacrament, except by the spirit of God working invisibly; since God works everything that is done in that work through corporeal movements, by setting in motion primarily the invisible things of His servants, whether the souls of men, or the services of hidden spirits subject to Himself): what wonder if also in the creature of heaven and earth, of sea and air, God works the sensible and visible things which He wills, in order to signify and manifest Himself in them, as He Himself knows it to be fitting, without any appearing of His very substance itself, whereby He is, which is altogether unchangeable, and more inwardly and secretly exalted than all spirits whom He has created?

Chapter 5.– Why Miracles are Not Usual Works.

For since the divine power administers the whole spiritual and corporeal creature, the waters of the sea are summoned and poured out upon the face of the earth on certain days of every year. But when this was done at the prayer of the holy Elijah, because such a continued and long course of fair weather had gone before that people were starving, and because at that very hour in which the servant of God prayed the air itself had not, by any moist appearance, shown signs of the coming rain, the divine power was apparent in the great and rapid showers that followed, and through which that miracle was granted and dispensed. In the same way, God ordinarily works through thunders and lightnings, but because these were produced in an unusual manner on Mount Sinai, and those sounds were not uttered with a confused noise but in such a way that it appeared by the most certain proofs that definite communications were being given through them, they were miracles. Who draws up the sap through the root of the vine to the bunch of grapes and makes the wine, except God, who, while man plants and waters, Himself gives the increase? But when, at the command of the Lord, the water was turned into wine with extraordinary quickness, the divine power was made manifest, by the confession even of the foolish. Who ordinarily clothes the trees with leaves and flowers except God? Yet when the rod of Aaron the priest blossomed, the Godhead in some way conversed with doubting humanity. Again, earthy matter certainly serves in common to the production and formation both of all kinds of wood and of the flesh of all animals, and who makes these things but He who said, Let the earth bring them forth, and who governs and guides by the same word of His those things which He has created? Yet when He changed the same matter out of the rod of Moses into the flesh of a serpent, immediately and quickly, that change, which was unusual, although of a thing which was changeable, was a miracle. But who is it that gives life to every living thing at its birth, unless He who gave life to that serpent also for the moment, as there was need?

11. For since the divine power administers the whole spiritual and corporeal creature, the waters of the sea are summoned and poured out upon the face of the earth on certain days of every year. But when this was done at the prayer of the holy Elijah; because so continued and long a course of fair weather had gone before, that men were famished; and because at that very hour, in which the servant of God prayed, the air itself had not, by any moist aspect, put forth signs of the coming rain; the divine power was apparent in the great and rapid showers that followed, and by which that miracle was granted and dispensed. In like manner, God works ordinarily through thunders and lightnings: but because these were wrought in an unusual manner on Mount Sinai, and those sounds were not uttered with a confused noise, but so that it appeared by most sure proofs that certain intimations were given by them, they were miracles. Who draws up the sap through the root of the vine to the bunch of grapes, and makes the wine, except God; who, while man plants and waters, Himself gives the increase? But when, at the command of the Lord, the water was turned into wine with an extraordinary quickness, the divine power was made manifest, by the confession even of the foolish. Who ordinarily clothes the trees with leaves and flowers except God? Yet, when the rod of Aaron the priest blossomed, the Godhead in some way conversed with doubting humanity. Again, the earthy matter certainly serves in common to the production and formation both of all kinds of wood and of the flesh of all animals: and who makes these things, but He who said, Let the earth bring them forth; and who governs and guides by the same word of His, those things which He has created? Yet, when He changed the same matter out of the rod of Moses into the flesh of a serpent, immediately and quickly, that change, which was unusual, although of a thing which was changeable, was a miracle. But who is it that gives life to every living thing at its birth, unless He who gave life to that serpent also for the moment, as there was need.

Chapter 6.– Diversity Alone Makes a Miracle.

Who restored to the dead bodies their proper souls when the dead rose again, if not the same one who gives life to the flesh in the mother's womb so that those who will eventually die may come into being? But when such things happen in a continuous stream of constantly flowing succession, passing from the hidden to the visible and from the visible to the hidden along a regular and well-worn path, they are called natural. When they are introduced with unusual variation in order to warn people, they are called miracles.

And who is it that restored to the corpses their proper souls when the dead rose again, unless He who gives life to the flesh in the mother's womb, in order that they may come into being who yet are to die? But when such things happen in a continuous kind of river of ever-flowing succession, passing from the hidden to the visible, and from the visible to the hidden, by a regular and beaten track, then they are called natural; when, for the admonition of men, they are thrust in by an unusual changeableness, then they are called miracles.

Chapter 7.– Great Miracles Wrought by Magic Arts.

I see here what might occur to a weak judgment, namely, why such miracles are also performed through magic arts; for Pharaoh's wise men likewise made serpents and did other similar things. Yet it is even more remarkable how the power of those magicians, which was able to make serpents, completely failed when it came to very small flies. For the lice, by which the proud people of Egypt were struck as a third plague, are very short-lived little flies; yet there the magicians certainly failed, saying, This is the finger of God. And from this we are given to understand that not even those angels and powers of the air who transgressed—who have been cast down into that lowest darkness as into a kind of prison, from their dwelling in that lofty ethereal purity—through whom magic arts have whatever power they have, can do anything except by power given from above. Now that power is given either to deceive the deceitful, as it was given against the Egyptians and also against the magicians themselves, so that through the seduction of those spirits they might appear admirable by whom these things were performed, but be condemned by the truth of God; or for the warning of the faithful, so they should not desire to do such things as though they were great, for which reason they have been handed down to us also by the authority of Scripture; or lastly, for exercising, proving, and manifesting the patience of the righteous. For it was not by any small power of visible miracles that Job lost all that he had, including both his children and his bodily health itself.

12. I see here what may occur to a weak judgment, namely, why such miracles are wrought also by magic arts; for the wise men of Pharaoh likewise made serpents, and did other like things. Yet it is still more a matter of wonder, how it was that the power of those magicians, which was able to make serpents, when it came to very small flies, failed altogether. For the lice, by which third plague the proud people of Egypt were smitten, are very short-lived little flies; yet there certainly the magicians failed, saying, This is the finger of God. And hence it is given us to understand that not even those angels and powers of the air that transgressed, who have been thrust down into that lowest darkness, as into a peculiar prison, from their habitation in that lofty ethereal purity, through whom magic arts have whatever power they have, can do anything except by power given from above. Now that power is given either to deceive the deceitful, as it was given against the Egyptians, and against the magicians also themselves, in order that in the seducing of those spirits they might seem admirable by whom they were wrought, but to be condemned by the truth of God; or for the admonishing of the faithful, lest they should desire to do anything of the kind as though it were a great thing, for which reason they have been handed down to us also by the authority of Scripture; or lastly, for the exercising, proving, and manifesting of the patience of the righteous. For it was not by any small power of visible miracles that Job lost all that he had, and both his children and his bodily health itself.

Chapter 8.– God Alone Creates Those Things Which are Changed by Magic Art.

Yet we should not think that the matter of visible things obeys the commands of those wicked angels, but rather obeys God, who gives this power only to the extent that He, who is unchangeable, decides to give it from His lofty and spiritual dwelling place. For water and fire and earth obey even wicked men who are condemned to the mines, so that they may do with these elements what they want, but only as far as is permitted. Nor should those evil angels be called creators because magicians, opposing God's servant, made frogs and serpents through their means. They did not create them. In truth, hidden seeds of all things that are born in bodily and visible form are concealed in the bodily elements of this world. Those seeds that are now visible to our eyes from fruits and living things are quite different from the hidden seeds of those original seeds, from which, at the Creator's command, the water produced the first swimming creatures and birds, and the earth produced the first plants according to their kind and the first living creatures according to their kind. At that time, those seeds were not brought forth into their various kinds in such a way that their productive power was exhausted in those products. Rather, suitable conditions are often lacking that would enable them to burst forth and complete their species. Consider that even the smallest shoot is a seed, for if properly planted in the earth, it produces a tree. But this shoot has an even more subtle seed in some grain of the same species, which is visible even to us. But this grain also has yet another seed which, although we cannot see it with our eyes, we can infer must exist through reason. For unless there were some such power in those elements, things would not so often spring up from the earth that had not been planted there, nor would so many animals appear without any prior mating of male and female, whether on land or in water, which nevertheless grow and produce others by mating, though they themselves arose without any union of parents. And certainly bees do not conceive the seeds of their offspring through mating, but gather them with their mouths as they lie scattered over the earth. For the Creator of these invisible seeds is the Creator of all things Himself. Whatever comes forth to our sight by being born receives the first beginnings of its development from hidden seeds and takes the successive stages of its proper size and distinctive forms from these original patterns, as it were. Therefore, just as we do not call parents the creators of human beings, nor farmers the creators of grain—even though it is through the outward application of their actions that God's power works within to create these things—so it is not right to consider not only the bad but even the good angels to be creators, if through the subtlety of their perception and body they know seeds of things that are more hidden to us, and scatter them secretly through suitable arrangements of the elements, and thus provide opportunities for producing things and accelerating their growth. But the good angels do not do these things except as far as God commands, nor do the evil ones do them wrongfully except as far as He righteously permits. For the malice of the wicked one makes his own will wrongful, but the power to do so he receives righteously, whether for his own punishment, or in the case of others, for the punishment of the wicked or for the praise of the good.

13. Yet it is not on this account to be thought that the matter of visible things is subservient to the bidding of those wicked angels; but rather to that of God, by whom this power is given, just so far as He, who is unchangeable, determines in His lofty and spiritual abode to give it. For water and fire and earth are subservient even to wicked men, who are condemned to the mines, in order that they may do therewith what they will, but only so far as is permitted. Nor, in truth, are those evil angels to be called creators, because by their means the magicians, withstanding the servant of God, made frogs and serpents; for it was not they who created them. But, in truth, some hidden seeds of all things that are born corporeally and visibly, are concealed in the corporeal elements of this world. For those seeds that are visible now to our eyes from fruits and living things, are quite distinct from the hidden seeds of those former seeds; from which, at the bidding of the Creator, the water produced the first swimming creatures and fowl, and the earth the first buds after their kind, and the first living creatures after their kind. For neither at that time were those seeds so drawn forth into products of their several kinds, as that the power of production was exhausted in those products; but oftentimes, suitable combinations of circumstances are wanting, whereby they may be enabled to burst forth and complete their species. For, consider, the very least shoot is a seed; for, if fitly consigned to the earth, it produces a tree. But of this shoot there is a yet more subtle seed in some grain of the same species, and this is visible even to us. But of this grain also there is further still a seed, which, although we are unable to see it with our eyes, yet we can conjecture its existence from our reason; because, except there were some such power in those elements, there would not so frequently be produced from the earth things which had not been sown there; nor yet so many animals, without any previous commixture of male and female; whether on the land, or in the water, which yet grow, and by commingling bring forth others, while themselves sprang up without any union of parents. And certainly bees do not conceive the seeds of their young by commixture, but gather them as they lie scattered over the earth with their mouth. For the Creator of these invisible seeds is the Creator of all things Himself; since whatever comes forth to our sight by being born, receives the first beginnings of its course from hidden seeds, and takes the successive increments of its proper size and its distinctive forms from these as it were original rules. As therefore we do not call parents the creators of men, nor farmers the creators of grain — although it is by the outward application of their actions that the power of God operates within for the creating these things — so it is not right to think not only the bad but even the good angels to be creators, if, through the subtlety of their perception and body, they know the seeds of things which to us are more hidden, and scatter them secretly through fit temperings of the elements, and so furnish opportunities of producing things, and of accelerating their increase. But neither do the good angels do these things, except as far as God commands, nor do the evil ones do them wrongfully, except as far as He righteously permits. For the malignity of the wicked one makes his own will wrongful; but the power to do so, he receives rightfully, whether for his own punishment, or, in the case of others, for the punishment of the wicked, or for the praise of the good.

Therefore, the Apostle Paul distinguishes between God's creating and forming from within and the operations of creatures that are applied from outside. Drawing a comparison from farming, he says, "I planted, Apollos watered; but God gave the increase." Just as in the case of spiritual life itself, no one except God can produce righteousness in our minds—yet people are still able to preach the gospel as an outward means, whether good people doing so sincerely or evil people doing so pretentiously—so also in the creation of visible things, it is God who works from within. However, the outward operations, whether performed by good or bad angels, by human beings, or even by any kind of animal, are applied by Him to that nature of things in which He creates all things, according to His own absolute power, the distribution of abilities, and the various desires for pleasant things that He Himself has given—just as agriculture is applied to the soil. Therefore, I can no more call the evil angels, summoned by magic arts, the creators of the frogs and serpents than I can say that evil people were creators of the grain crop that I see has sprung up through their labor.

14. Accordingly, the Apostle Paul, distinguishing God's creating and forming within, from the operations of the creature which are applied from without, and drawing a similitude from agriculture, says, I planted, Apollos watered; but God gave the increase. As, therefore, in the case of spiritual life itself, no one except God can work righteousness in our minds, yet men also are able to preach the gospel as an outward means, not only the good in sincerity, but also the evil in pretence; so in the creation of visible things it is God that works from within; but the exterior operations, whether of good or bad, of angels or men, or even of any kind of animal, according to His own absolute power, and to the distribution of faculties, and the several appetites for things pleasant, which He Himself has imparted, are applied by Him to that nature of things wherein He creates all things, in like manner as agriculture is to the soil. Wherefore I can no more call the bad angels, evoked by magic arts, the creators of the frogs and serpents, than I can say that bad men were creators of the grain crop, which I see to have sprung up through their labor.

Just as Jacob was not the creator of the colors in the flocks when he placed the multicolored rods for the various mothers to look at while drinking and conceiving. Nor were the cattle themselves creators of the variety of their own offspring, even though the variegated image, impressed through their eyes by the sight of the varied rods, attached to their soul and could only affect the body animated by that soul through a kind of sympathetic connection with this mingling, to the extent that it stained with color the tender beginnings of their offspring. The fact that they are affected from within themselves—whether the soul affects the body or the body affects the soul—arises in truth from fitting principles that exist unchangeably in the highest wisdom of God himself, which no physical space contains. This wisdom, while itself unchangeable, does not abandon even one of those things which are changeable, because there is not one of them that was not created by it. For it was the unchangeable and invisible principle of God's wisdom, by which all things are created, that caused cattle to be born from cattle, not rods. But the fact that the color of the conceived cattle was influenced to some degree by the variety of the rods happened because the soul of the pregnant cattle was affected through their eyes from outside, and thus according to its own capacity drew inward the pattern of formation, which it received from the innermost power of its own Creator. How great the soul's power might be in affecting and changing bodily substance—although it certainly cannot be called the creator of the body, because every cause of changeable and sensible substance, and all its measure, number, and weight by which its existence and its specific nature come about, arise from the intelligible and unchangeable life that is above all things and reaches even to the most distant and earthly things—is a very extensive topic and not necessary now. But I thought Jacob's act concerning the cattle should be noted for this reason: so that it might be understood that if the man who placed those rods cannot be called the creator of the colors in the lambs and kids, and if even the souls of the mothers themselves, which colored the seeds conceived in the flesh by the image of variegated color received through the eyes of the body insofar as nature permitted, cannot be called creators, then much less can the bad angels through whom Pharaoh's magicians made frogs and serpents be said to have been the creators of those frogs and serpents.

15. Just as Jacob, again, was not the creator of the colors in the flocks, because he placed the various colored rods for the several mothers, as they drank, to look at in conceiving. Yet neither were the cattle themselves creators of the variety of their own offspring, because the variegated image, impressed through their eyes by the sight of the varied rods, clave to their soul, but could affect the body that was animated by the spirit thus affected only through sympathy with this commingling, so far as to stain with color the tender beginnings of their offspring. For that they are so affected from themselves, whether the soul from the body, or the body from the soul, arises in truth from suitable reasons, which immutably exist in that highest wisdom of God Himself, which no extent of place contains; and which, while it is itself unchangeable, yet quits not one even of those things which are changeable, because there is not one of them that is not created by itself. For it was the unchangeable and invisible reason of the wisdom of God, by which all things are created, which caused not rods, but cattle, to be born from cattle; but that the color of the cattle conceived should be in any degree influenced by the variety of the rods, came to pass through the soul of the pregnant cattle being affected through their eyes from without, and so according to its own measure drawing inwardly within itself the rule of formation, which it received from the innermost power of its own Creator. How great, however, may be the power of the soul in affecting and changing corporeal substance (although certainly it cannot be called the creator of the body, because every cause of changeable and sensible substance, and all its measure and number and weight, by which are brought to pass both its being at all and its being of such and such a nature, arise from the intelligible and unchangeable life, which is above all things, and which reaches even to the most distant and earthly things), is a very copious subject, and one not now necessary. But I thought the act of Jacob about the cattle should be noticed, for this reason, viz. in order that it might be perceived that, if the man who thus placed those rods cannot be called the creator of the colors in the lambs and kids; nor yet even the souls themselves of the mothers, which colored the seeds conceived in the flesh by the image of variegated color, conceived through the eyes of the body, so far as nature permitted it; much less can it be said that the creators of the frogs and serpents were the bad angels, through whom the magicians of Pharaoh then made them.

Chapter 9.– The Original Cause of All Things is from God.

For it is one thing to make and govern creation from the innermost and highest point of causation, which God the Creator alone does; but it is quite another thing to apply some external operation according to the powers and capacities He has assigned to each thing, so that what is created may come into existence at one time or another, and in one way or another. For all these things have already been created in their original and beginning state within a kind of weaving together of the elements, but they emerge into being when they receive the opportunity. Just as mothers are pregnant with their young, so the world itself is pregnant with the causes of the things that are born; these causes are not created in the world except from that highest essence, where nothing springs up or dies, neither begins to exist nor ceases to exist. But the applying of external causes from outside—which, though they are not natural in themselves, must still be applied according to nature—so that those things contained and hidden in the secret depths of nature may break forth and be brought into outward existence through the unfolding of the proper measures, numbers, and weights they have received in secret from Him who has ordered all things in measure, number, and weight: this power belongs not only to evil angels but also to evil men, as I have demonstrated above by the example of agriculture.

16. For it is one thing to make and administer the creature from the innermost and highest turning-point of causation, which He alone does who is God the Creator; but quite another thing to apply some operation from without in proportion to the strength and faculties assigned to each by Him, so that what is created may come forth into being at this time or at that, and in this or that way. For all these things in the way of original and beginning have already been created in a kind of texture of the elements, but they come forth when they get the opportunity. For as mothers are pregnant with young, so the world itself is pregnant with the causes of things that are born; which are not created in it, except from that highest essence, where nothing either springs up or dies, either begins to be or ceases. But the applying from without of adventitious causes, which, although they are not natural, yet are to be applied according to nature, in order that those things which are contained and hidden in the secret bosom of nature may break forth and be outwardly created in some way by the unfolding of the proper measures and numbers and weights which they have received in secret from Him who has ordered all things in measure and number and weight: this is not only in the power of bad angels, but also of bad men, as I have shown above by the example of agriculture.

However, some might be troubled by the somewhat different nature of animals, since they have the breath of life along with the ability to desire what is natural to them and avoid what is contrary to their nature. We must also consider how many people know from what herbs or meat, or from what juices or liquids of whatever kind—whether positioned in a certain way, buried in a certain way, crushed in a certain way, or mixed in a certain way—this or that animal is commonly produced. Yet who could be so foolish as to dare call himself the creator of these animals? Therefore, should we be surprised if, just as the most worthless person can know where such and such worms and flies come from, so evil angels, in proportion to the sharpness of their perception, discern in the more hidden seeds of the elements where frogs and serpents come from? And through certain known and opportune combinations, they apply these seeds through secret movements and cause them to be created—but they do not actually create them. People simply do not marvel at things that are commonly done by people. But if anyone happens to wonder at how quickly these organisms grow—at how quickly these living beings were made—let him consider how even this can be accomplished by people according to the measure of human capability. For why is it that the same bodies generate worms more quickly in summer than in winter, or in hotter places than in colder ones? The only reason these things are more difficult for people to accomplish is that their earthly and sluggish bodies lack sharpness of perception and quickness of bodily movement. And from this it follows that with any kind of angels, the easier it is for them to draw out the immediate causes from the elements, the more marvelous is their speed in works of this kind.

17. But lest the somewhat different condition of animals should trouble any one, in that they have the breath of life with the sense of desiring those things that are according to nature, and of avoiding those things that are contrary to it; we must consider also, how many men there are who know from what herbs or flesh, or from what juices or liquids you please, of whatever sort, whether so placed or so buried, or so bruised or so mixed, this or that animal is commonly born; yet who can be so foolish as to dare to call himself the creator of these animals? Is it, therefore, to be wondered at, if just as any, the most worthless of men, can know whence such or such worms and flies are produced; so the evil angels in proportion to the subtlety of their perceptions discern in the more hidden seeds of the elements whence frogs and serpents are produced, and so through certain and known opportune combinations applying these seeds by secret movements, cause them to be created, but do not create them? Only men do not marvel at those things that are usually done by men. But if any one chance to wonder at the quickness of those growths, in that those living beings were so quickly made, let him consider how even this may be brought about by men in proportion to the measure of human capability. For whence is it that the same bodies generate worms more quickly in summer than in winter, or in hotter than in colder places? Only these things are applied by men with so much the more difficulty, in proportion as their earthly and sluggish members are wanting in subtlety of perception, and in rapidity of bodily motion. And hence it arises that in the case of any kind of angels, in proportion as it is easier for them to draw out the proximate causes from the elements, so much the more marvellous is their rapidity in works of this kind.

But the only true creator is the one who is the chief maker of these things. No one can be this creator unless he holds the primary authority over the measure, number, and weight of all existing things. He is God, the one Creator, and by his unspeakable power it happens that what these angels would be able to do if they were permitted, they are therefore unable to do because they are not permitted. There is no other reason why those who made frogs and serpents were unable to make the tiniest flies, except that the greater power of God was present prohibiting them through the Holy Spirit. Even the magicians themselves confessed this, saying, "This is the finger of God." But what they are able to do by nature yet cannot do because they are prohibited, and what the very condition of their nature itself does not allow them to do—this is difficult, indeed impossible, for humans to investigate, except through that gift of God which the apostle mentions when he says, "To another the discerning of spirits." For we know that a man can walk, yet cannot do so if he is not permitted. But he cannot fly even if he is permitted. So these angels too are able to do certain things if they are permitted by more powerful angels, according to the supreme command of God. But they cannot do certain other things, not even if they are permitted by them, because he does not permit it—he from whom they have received such and such a measure of natural powers. Even through his angels, he does not usually permit what he has given them the power to be able to do.

18. But He only is the creator who is the chief former of these things. Neither can any one be this, unless He with whom primarily rests the measure, number, and weight of all things existing; and He is God the one Creator, by whose unspeakable power it comes to pass, also, that what these angels were able to do if they were permitted, they are therefore not able to do because they are not permitted. For there is no other reason why they who made frogs and serpents were not able to make the most minute flies, unless because the greater power of God was present prohibiting them, through the Holy Spirit; which even the magicians themselves confessed, saying, This is the finger of God. But what they are able to do by nature, yet cannot do, because they are prohibited; and what the very condition of their nature itself does not suffer them to do; it is difficult, nay, impossible, for man to search out, unless through that gift of God which the apostle mentions when he says, To another the discerning of spirits. For we know that a man can walk, yet that he cannot do so if he is not permitted; but that he cannot fly, even if he be permitted. So those angels, also, are able to do certain things if they are permitted by more powerful angels, according to the supreme commandment of God; but cannot do certain other things, not even if they are permitted by them; because He does not permit from whom they have received such and such a measure of natural powers: who, even by His angels, does not usually permit what He has given them power to be able to do.

Leaving aside, then, those bodily events that happen in the regular, ordinary sequence of nature—such as the rising and setting of the stars, the births and deaths of animals, the countless varieties of seeds and shoots, the mists and clouds, the snow and rain, the lightning and thunder, the thunderbolts and hail, the winds and fire, cold and heat, and all similar things—and leaving aside also those things that happen rarely within that same natural order, such as eclipses, unusual appearances of stars, monstrous births, earthquakes, and the like—all these things, I say, must be set apart, because their first and primary cause is the will of God alone. This is why in the Psalm, after mentioning some things of this kind—fire and hail, snow and vapor, stormy wind—lest anyone should think these events come about either by chance or only through bodily causes, or even through spiritual causes that exist apart from God's will, it immediately adds, fulfilling His word.

19. Excepting, therefore, those corporeal things which are done in the order of nature in a perfectly usual series of times, as e.g., the rising and setting of the stars, the generations and deaths of animals, the innumerable diversities of seeds and buds, the vapors and the clouds, the snow and the rain, the lightnings and the thunder, the thunderbolts and the hail, the winds and the fire, cold and heat, and all like things; excepting also those which in the same order of nature occur rarely, such as eclipses, unusual appearances of stars, and monsters, and earthquakes, and such like — all these, I say, are to be excepted, of which indeed the first and chief cause is only the will of God; whence also in the Psalm, when some things of this kind had been mentioned, Fire and hail, snow and vapor, stormy wind, lest any one should think those to be brought about either by chance or only from corporeal causes, or even from such as are spiritual, but exist apart from the will of God, it is added immediately, fulfilling His word.

Chapter 10.– In How Many Ways the Creature is to Be Taken by Way of Sign. The Eucharist.

Excluding all these things, as I just said, there are also some of another kind. Although they come from the same bodily substance, they are brought within reach of our senses to announce something from God, and these are properly called miracles and signs. Yet the person of God Himself is not assumed in all things that are announced to us by the Lord God. However, when that person is assumed, it is sometimes made manifest as an angel. Sometimes it appears in a form that is not an angel in his own proper being, although it is ordered and ministered by an angel. Again, when it is assumed in a form that is not an angel in his own proper being, sometimes in this case it is an already existing body, assumed after some kind of change, in order to make that message manifest. Sometimes it is a body that comes into being for the purpose, and once that is accomplished, is discarded. Just as when human beings are the messengers, sometimes they speak the words of God in their own person, as when it is stated beforehand, "The Lord said," or "Thus says the Lord," or any other such phrase. But sometimes, without any such introduction, they take upon themselves the very person of God, as for example: "I will instruct you and teach you in the way wherein you shall go." So, not only in word but also in action, the signifying of the person of God is imposed upon the prophet, so that he may bear that person in the ministering of the prophecy—just as the one who divided his garment into twelve parts and gave ten of them to the servant of King Solomon, to the future king of Israel, bore that person. Sometimes, also, a thing that was not a prophet in his own proper self, and which already existed among earthly things, was assumed to signify this, as Jacob did with the stone that had been under his head when he was asleep, after waking up from the dream. Sometimes a thing is made in the same way for the mere purpose: either to continue existing for a little while, as the bronze serpent that was lifted up in the wilderness was able to do, and as written records are likewise able to do; or to pass away after having accomplished its ministry, as the bread made for the purpose is consumed in the receiving of the sacrament.

Excepting, therefore, all these things as I just now said, there are some also of another kind; which, although from the same corporeal substance, are yet brought within reach of our senses in order to announce something from God, and these are properly called miracles and signs; yet is not the person of God Himself assumed in all things which are announced to us by the Lord God. When, however, that person is assumed, it is sometimes made manifest as an angel; sometimes in that form which is not an angel in his own proper being, although it is ordered and ministered by an angel. Again, when it is assumed in that form which is not an angel in his own proper being; sometimes in this case it is a body itself already existing, assumed after some kind of change, in order to make that message manifest; sometimes it is one that comes into being for the purpose, and that being accomplished, is discarded. Just as, also, when men are the messengers, sometimes they speak the words of God in their own person, as when it is premised, The Lord said, or, Thus says the Lord, or any other such phrase, but sometimes without any such prefix, they take upon themselves the very person of God, as e.g.: I will instruct you, and teach you in the way wherein you shall go: so, not only in word, but also in act, the signifying of the person of God is imposed upon the prophet, in order that he may bear that person in the ministering of the prophecy; just as he, for instance, bore that person who divided his garment into twelve parts, and gave ten of them to the servant of King Solomon, to the future king of Israel. Sometimes, also, a thing which was not a prophet in his own proper self, and which existed already among earthly things, was assumed in order to signify this; as Jacob, when he had seen the dream, upon waking up did with the stone, which when asleep he had under his head. Sometimes a thing is made in the same kind, for the mere purpose; so as either to continue a little while in existence, as that brazen serpent was able to do which was lifted up in the wilderness, and as written records are able to do likewise; or so as to pass away after having accomplished its ministry, as the bread made for the purpose is consumed in the receiving of the sacrament.

Because these actions are familiar to people since people perform them, they deserve respect as holy things, but they cannot inspire amazement as miracles do. For this reason, the things angels do are more amazing to us because they are more difficult and more extraordinary, though they are familiar and easy to angels since these are their own works. An angel speaks to a person in the person of God, saying, "I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob," though Scripture had just said beforehand, "The angel of the Lord appeared to him." And a human being also speaks in the person of God, saying, "Hear, O my people, and I will testify unto you, O Israel: I am the Lord your God." A rod was used as a sign and was changed into a serpent by angelic power. Though human beings lack that power, a stone was also used by a man for a similar sign. There is a vast difference between what the angel did and what the man did. The angel's deed is both to be wondered at and to be understood, while the man's deed is only to be understood. What is understood from both may be one and the same thing, but the means by which it is understood are different. It is like writing the name of God in both gold and ink: the gold would be more valuable, the ink more ordinary, yet what is signified in both is one and the same. Although the serpent that came from Moses' rod signified the same thing as Jacob's stone, Jacob's stone signified something better than the serpents of the magicians did. For just as the anointing of the stone signified Christ in the flesh, in which He was anointed with the oil of gladness above His companions, so Moses' rod turned into a serpent signified Christ Himself made obedient unto death, even the death of the cross. This is why it says, "And as Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, even so must the Son of man be lifted up, that whosoever believes in Him should not perish, but have everlasting life," just as by looking at that serpent lifted up in the wilderness, they did not perish from the bites of the serpents. For our old man is crucified with Him, so that the body of sin might be destroyed. Death is understood by the serpent, because death was brought about by the serpent in paradise—the figure of speech expressing the effect through the cause. Therefore the rod became the serpent, and Christ became death; then the serpent became the rod again, just as the whole Christ with His body passes into the resurrection. That body is the Church, and this will happen at the end of time, signified by the tail, which Moses grasped so that it might return to being a rod. But the magicians' serpents, like those who are dead in the world, will not be able to rise again in Him unless by believing in Christ they are swallowed up by and enter into His body. Jacob's stone, therefore, as I said, signified something better than the magicians' serpents did, yet the magicians' deed was far more amazing. But these differences do not hinder understanding the matter, just as it would not matter if a human name were written in gold and God's name in ink.

20. But because these things are known to men, in that they are done by men, they may well meet with reverence as being holy things, but they cannot cause wonder as being miracles. And therefore those things which are done by angels are the more wonderful to us, in that they are more difficult and more known; but they are known and easy to them as being their own actions. An angel speaks in the person of God to man, saying, I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob; the Scripture having said just before, The angel of the Lord appeared to him. And a man also speaks in the person of God, saying, Hear, O my people, and I will testify unto you, O Israel: I am the Lord your God. A rod was taken to serve as a sign, and was changed into a serpent by angelical power; but although that power is wanting to man, yet a stone was taken also by man for a similar sign. There is a wide difference between the deed of the angel and the deed of the man. The former is both to be wondered at and to be understood, the latter only to be understood. That which is understood from both, is perhaps one and the same; but those things from which it is understood, are different. Just as if the name of God were written both in gold and in ink; the former would be the more precious, the latter the more worthless; yet that which is signified in both is one and the same. And although the serpent that came from Moses' rod signified the same thing as Jacob's stone, yet Jacob's stone signified something better than did the serpents of the magicians. For as the anointing of the stone signified Christ in the flesh, in which He was anointed with the oil of gladness above His fellows; so the rod of Moses, turned into a serpent, signified Christ Himself made obedient unto death, even the death of the cross. Whence it is said, And as Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, even so must the Son of man be lifted up, that whosoever believes in Him should not perish, but have everlasting life; just as by gazing on that serpent which was lifted up in the wilderness, they did not perish by the bites of the serpents. For our old man is crucified with Him, that the body of sin might be destroyed. For by the serpent death is understood, which was wrought by the serpent in paradise, the mode of speech expressing the effect by the efficient. Therefore the rod passed into the serpent, Christ into death; and the serpent again into the rod, whole Christ with His body into the resurrection; which body is the Church; and this shall be in the end of time, signified by the tail, which Moses held, in order that it might return into a rod. But the serpents of the magicians, like those who are dead in the world, unless by believing in Christ they shall have been as it were swallowed up by, and have entered into, His body, will not be able to rise again in Him. Jacob's stone, therefore, as I said, signified something better than did the serpents of the magicians; yet the deed of the magicians was much more wonderful. But these things in this way are no hindrance to the understanding of the matter; just as if the name of a man were written in gold, and that of God in ink.

No one knows how the angels created or assumed those clouds and fires to communicate the message they were carrying, even if we suppose that the Lord or the Holy Spirit appeared in those bodily forms. Just as infants do not know about what is placed on the altar and consumed after the holy celebration is performed—where it comes from, how it is made, or where it is obtained for religious use. And if they were never to learn from their own experience or from others, and never saw that kind of thing except during the celebration of the sacrament when it is being offered and given, and if the most reliable authority told them whose body and blood it is, they would believe nothing else except that the Lord actually appeared in this form to human eyes, and that the liquid truly flowed from the piercing of a side that looked like this. But it is certainly a useful warning to myself that I should remember my own limitations, and remind my brothers that they also remember theirs, so that human weakness does not go beyond what is safe. For how the angels do these things, or rather, how God does these things through His angels, and how far He allows them to be done even by the evil angels—whether by permitting, commanding, or compelling them from the hidden throne of His own supreme power—this I cannot perceive with my eyes, make clear through rational certainty, or grasp with my intellect well enough to speak about all questions that might be asked concerning these matters as confidently as if I were an angel, prophet, or apostle. For the thoughts of mortal people are miserable, and our plans are uncertain. The corruptible body weighs down the soul, and the earthly dwelling burdens the mind that thinks about many things. We barely guess correctly about things on earth, and we discover with difficulty the things right in front of us; but who has searched out the things that are in heaven? But because it goes on to say, "And who has known Your counsel, unless You give wisdom and send Your Holy Spirit from above?"—therefore we refrain from searching out the things that are in heaven, under which category are included both angelic bodies according to their proper dignity and any bodily action of those bodies. Yet, according to the Spirit of God sent to us from above and His grace given to our minds, I dare to say confidently that neither God the Father, nor His Word, nor His Spirit—who is the one God—is in any way changeable in regard to what He is and by which He is what He is, and much less is He visible in this regard. For there are certainly some things that are changeable yet not visible, such as our thoughts, memories, and wills, and the whole incorporeal creation; but there is nothing that is visible that is not also changeable.

21. What man, again, knows how the angels made or took those clouds and fires in order to signify the message they were bearing, even if we supposed that the Lord or the Holy Spirit was manifested in those corporeal forms? Just as infants do not know of that which is placed upon the altar and consumed after the performance of the holy celebration, whence or in what manner it is made, or whence it is taken for religious use. And if they were never to learn from their own experience or that of others, and never to see that species of thing except during the celebration of the sacrament, when it is being offered and given; and if it were told them by the most weighty authority whose body and blood it is; they will believe nothing else, except that the Lord absolutely appeared in this form to the eyes of mortals, and that that liquid actually flowed from the piercing of a side which resembled this. But it is certainly a useful caution to myself, that I should remember what my own powers are, and admonish my brethren that they also remember what theirs are, lest human infirmity pass on beyond what is safe. For how the angels do these things, or rather, how God does these things by His angels, and how far He wills them to be done even by the bad angels, whether by permitting, or commanding, or compelling, from the hidden seat of His own supreme power; this I can neither penetrate by the sight of the eyes, nor make clear by assurance of reason, nor be carried on to comprehend it by reach of intellect, so as to speak thereupon to all questions that may be asked respecting these matters, as certainly as if I were an angel, or a prophet, or an apostle. For the thoughts of mortal men are miserable, and our devices are but uncertain. For the corruptible body presses down the soul, and the earthly tabernacle weighs down the mind, that muses upon many things. And hardly do we guess aright at things that are upon earth, and with labor do we find the things that are before us; but the things that are in heaven, who has searched out? But because it goes on to say, And Your counsel who has known, except Thou give wisdom, and send Your Holy Spirit from above; therefore we refrain indeed from searching out the things which are in heaven, under which kind are contained both angelical bodies according to their proper dignity, and any corporeal action of those bodies; yet, according to the Spirit of God sent to us from above, and to His grace imparted to our minds, I dare to say confidently, that neither God the Father, nor His Word, nor His Spirit, which is the one God, is in any way changeable in regard to that which He is, and whereby He is that which He is; and much less is in this regard visible. Since there are no doubt some things changeable, yet not visible, as are our thoughts, and memories, and wills, and the whole incorporeal creature; but there is nothing that is visible that is not also changeable.

Chapter 11.– The Essence of God Never Appeared in Itself. Divine Appearances to the Fathers Wrought by the Ministry of Angels. An Objection Drawn from the Mode of Speech Removed. That the Appearing of God to Abraham Himself, Just as that to Moses, Was Wrought by Angels. The Same Thing is Proved by the Law Being Given to Moses by Angels. What Has Been Said in This Book, and What Remains to Be Said in the Next.

Therefore the substance, or if it is better to say it this way, the ousia of God—in which we understand, according to our limited capacity and to whatever small degree, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit—since it is in no way changeable, can in no way be visible in its proper self.

Wherefore the substance, or, if it is better so to say, the essence of God, wherein we understand, in proportion to our measure, in however small a degree, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit, since it is in no way changeable, can in no way in its proper self be visible.

It is clear, then, that all those appearances to the fathers, when God presented Himself to them according to His own dispensation suited to the times, were accomplished through the created order. And even if we cannot determine exactly how He accomplished them through the ministry of angels, we still say they were accomplished by angels. But we say this not from our own power of discernment, lest anyone think we are wise beyond our proper measure, whereas we are wise so as to think soberly, as God has dealt to each of us the measure of faith; and we believe, and therefore we speak. For the authority of the divine Scriptures is present, from which our reasoning ought not to turn aside; nor should we leave the solid support of the divine utterance and fall headlong over the cliff of our own guesses in matters where neither bodily perception rules nor the clear reasoning of truth shines forth. Now certainly it is written very clearly in the Epistle to the Hebrews, when the dispensation of the New Testament was to be distinguished from the dispensation of the Old according to the appropriate ages and times, that not only those visible things but also the word itself was accomplished by angels. For it says: But to which of the angels did He ever say, Sit at my right hand until I make your enemies your footstool? Are they not all ministering spirits sent out to serve for the sake of those who will inherit salvation? From this it appears that all those things were not only accomplished by angels but were also accomplished for our sake, that is, for the sake of the people of God, to whom the inheritance of eternal life is promised. As it is also written to the Corinthians, Now all these things happened to them as examples, and they were written for our instruction, on whom the end of the ages has come. And then, demonstrating by clear reasoning that just as the word was spoken at that time by angels, so now it is spoken by the Son, he says: Therefore we must pay much closer attention to what we have heard, lest we drift away from it. For if the word spoken by angels was binding, and every transgression and disobedience received a just penalty, how shall we escape if we neglect such a great salvation? And then, as if you were asking, What salvation?—in order to show that he is now speaking of the New Testament, that is, of the word that was spoken not by angels but by the Lord, he says: which was first declared by the Lord, and it was confirmed to us by those who heard Him, while God also bore witness by signs and wonders and various miracles and by gifts of the Holy Spirit distributed according to His will.

22. It is manifest, accordingly, that all those appearances to the fathers, when God was presented to them according to His own dispensation, suitable to the times, were wrought through the creature. And if we cannot discern in what manner He wrought them by ministry of angels, yet we say that they were wrought by angels; but not from our own power of discernment, lest we should seem to any one to be wise beyond our measure, whereas we are wise so as to think soberly, as God has dealt to us the measure of faith; and we believe, and therefore speak. For the authority is extant of the divine Scriptures, from which our reason ought not to turn aside; nor by leaving the solid support of the divine utterance, to fall headlong over the precipice of its own surmisings, in matters wherein neither the perceptions of the body rule, nor the clear reason of the truth shines forth. Now, certainly, it is written most clearly in the Epistle to the Hebrews, when the dispensation of the New Testament was to be distinguished from the dispensation of the Old, according to the fitness of ages and of times, that not only those visible things, but also the word itself, was wrought by angels. For it is said thus: But to which of the angels said He at any time, Sit on my right hand, until I make your enemies your footstool? Are they not all ministering spirits, sent forth to minister for them who shall be heirs of salvation? Whence it appears that all those things were not only wrought by angels, but wrought also on our account, that is, on account of the people of God, to whom is promised the inheritance of eternal life. As it is written also to the Corinthians, Now all these things happened unto them in a figure: and they are written for our admonition, upon whom the ends of the world have come. And then, demonstrating by plain consequence that as at that time the word was spoken by the angels, so now by the Son; Therefore, he says, we ought to give the more earnest heed to the things which we have heard, lest at any time we should let them slip. For if the word spoken by angels was steadfast, and every transgression and disobedience received a just recompense of reward; how shall we escape, if we neglect so great salvation? And then, as though you asked, What salvation?– in order to show that he is now speaking of the New Testament, that is, of the word which was spoken not by angels, but by the Lord, he says, Which at the first began to be spoken by the Lord, and was confirmed unto us by them that heard Him; God also bearing them witness, both with signs and wonders, and with various miracles, and gifts of the Holy Ghost, according to His own will.

Because when a herald proclaims the words of a judge, it is not usually written in the official record "so-and-so the herald said," but rather "so-and-so the judge said." In the same way, when the holy prophet speaks, although we say "the prophet said," we mean nothing else to be understood than that the Lord said. And if we were to say "the Lord said," we would not be setting the prophet aside, but only indicating who spoke through him. Indeed, these Scriptures often reveal the angel to be the Lord, whose speaking is repeatedly described as "the Lord said," as we have already shown. But because of those who, since the Scripture in that place mentions an angel, want to understand the Son of God Himself and in Himself, because He is called an angel by the prophet as one announcing the will of His Father and of Himself—for this reason I have thought it fitting to produce a clearer testimony from this epistle, where it is said not by an angel, but by angels.

23. But some one may say, Why then is it written, The Lord said to Moses; and not, rather, The angel said to Moses? Because, when the crier proclaims the words of the judge, it is not usually written in the record, so and so the crier said, but so and so the judge. In like manner also, when the holy prophet speaks, although we say, The prophet said, we mean nothing else to be understood than that the Lord said; and if we were to say, The Lord said, we should not put the prophet aside, but only intimate who spoke by him. And, indeed, these Scriptures often reveal the angel to be the Lord, of whose speaking it is from time to time said, the Lord said, as we have shown already. But on account of those who, since the Scripture in that place specifies an angel, will have the Son of God Himself and in Himself to be understood, because He is called an angel by the prophet, as announcing the will of His Father and of Himself; I have therefore thought fit to produce a plainer testimony from this epistle, where it is not said by an angel, but by angels.

Stephen, too, in the Acts of the Apostles, retells these events in the same way they are written in the Old Testament. He says, "Men, brothers, and fathers, listen: The God of glory appeared to our father Abraham when he was in Mesopotamia." But to prevent anyone from thinking that the God of glory appeared at that time to the eyes of any mortal person in what He is in Himself, Stephen goes on to say that an angel appeared to Moses. He says, "Then Moses fled at that saying and was a stranger in the land of Midian, where he had two sons. And when forty years had passed, an angel of the Lord appeared to him in the wilderness of Mount Sinai in a flame of fire in a bush. When Moses saw it, he was amazed at the sight, and as he came near to look at it, the voice of the Lord came to him, saying, 'I am the God of your fathers, the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob.' Then Moses trembled and did not dare to look. Then the Lord said to him, 'Take off your shoes from your feet,'" and so on. Here, clearly, he speaks of both an angel and the Lord, and refers to the same one as the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob, just as it is written in Genesis.

24. For Stephen, too, in the Acts of the Apostles, relates these things in that manner in which they are also written in the Old Testament: Men, brethren, and fathers, hearken, he says; The God of glory appeared unto our father Abraham, when he was in Mesopotamia. But lest any one should think that the God of glory appeared then to the eyes of any mortal in that which He is in Himself, he goes on to say that an angel appeared to Moses. Then fled Moses, he says, at that saying, and was a stranger in the land of Midian, where he begot two sons. And when forty years were expired, there appeared to him in the wilderness of mount Sinai an angel of the Lord in a flame of fire in a bush. When Moses saw it, he wondered at the sight: and as he drew near to behold it, the voice of the Lord came unto him, saying, I am the God of your fathers, the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob. Then Moses trembled, and dared not behold. Then said the Lord to him, Put off your shoes from your feet, etc. Here, certainly, he speaks both of angel and of Lord; and of the same as the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob; as is written in Genesis.

Is anyone going to claim that the Lord appeared to Moses through an angel but appeared to Abraham directly? Let's not answer this from Stephen's account, but from the book itself where Stephen got his narrative. Just because it says "And the Lord God said to Abraham" and shortly after "And the Lord God appeared unto Abraham," does this mean these things were not done through angels? Yet it says similarly in another place, "And the Lord appeared to him in the plains of Mamre, as he sat in the tent door in the heat of the day," and yet it immediately adds, "And he lift up his eyes and looked, and, lo, three men stood by him"—we have already discussed this. For how will these people, who either refuse to rise from the words to their meaning or carelessly fall from the meaning back to the words—how, I ask, will they be able to explain that God was seen in three men, unless they admit these were angels, as what follows also demonstrates? Just because it doesn't say "an angel spoke or appeared to him," will they dare to claim that the vision and voice given to Moses were accomplished through an angel because it is written that way, but that God appeared and spoke to Abraham in His own substance because no angel is mentioned? What about the fact that even regarding Abraham, an angel is mentioned? For when his son was ordered to be offered as a sacrifice, we read: "And it came to pass after these things that God did tempt Abraham, and said to him, Abraham: and he said, Behold, here I am. And He said, Take now your son, your only son Isaac, whom you love, and go to the land of Moriah; and offer him there for a burnt-offering upon one of the mountains that I will tell you of." Certainly God is mentioned here, not an angel. But shortly afterward Scripture says: "And Abraham stretched forth his hand, and took the knife to slay his son. And the angel of the Lord called unto him out of heaven, and said, Abraham, Abraham: and he said, Here am I. And he said, Lay not your hand upon the lad, neither do anything unto him." What can be said to this? Will they claim that God commanded Isaac to be killed and that an angel forbade it? And furthermore, that the father himself, in opposition to God's decree commanding the slaying, obeyed the angel who told him to spare the boy? Such an interpretation must be rejected as absurd. Yet Scripture leaves no room even for this crude and base interpretation, for it immediately adds: "For now I know that you fear God, seeing you have not withheld your son, your only son, on account of me." What does "on account of me" mean except on account of Him who had commanded the slaying? Was the God of Abraham the same as the angel, or was it rather God acting through an angel? Consider what follows. Here an angel has most clearly been mentioned; yet notice the context: "And Abraham lifted up his eyes, and looked, and behold behind him a ram caught in a thicket by his horns: and Abraham went and took the ram, and offered him up for a burnt-offering in the stead of his son. And Abraham called the name of that place, The Lord saw: as it is said to this day, In the mount the Lord was seen." Just as when God said through the angel a little earlier, "For now I know that you fear God"—not because it should be understood that God then came to know, but that He brought it about that through God Abraham himself came to know what strength of heart he had to obey God, even to sacrificing his only son—this follows that manner of speaking in which the effect is signified by the cause, just as cold is called sluggish because it makes people sluggish. So He was said to know because He made Abraham himself know, since Abraham might well not have discerned the firmness of his own faith had it not been tested by such a trial. So here too, Abraham called the place "The Lord saw," meaning He caused Himself to be seen. For he immediately continues, "As it is said to this day, In the mount the Lord was seen." Here you see the same angel is called Lord—why, except that the Lord was speaking through the angel? But if we continue to what follows, the angel clearly speaks as a prophet and reveals explicitly that God is speaking through the angel. "And the angel of the Lord," it says, "called unto Abraham out of heaven the second time, and said, By myself I have sworn, says the Lord; for because you have done this thing, and hast not withheld your son, your only son, on account of me," and so on. Certainly these words—that he through whom the Lord speaks should say "Thus says the Lord"—are commonly used by the prophets as well. Does the Son of God say of the Father "The Lord says," while He Himself is that Angel of the Father? What then? Don't they see how hard pressed they are concerning these three men who appeared to Abraham, when it had been said before, "The Lord appeared to him"? Were they not angels just because they are called men? Let them read Daniel, saying, "Behold the man Gabriel."

25. Can there be any one who will say that the Lord appeared to Moses by an angel, but to Abraham by Himself? Let us not answer this question from Stephen, but from the book itself, whence Stephen took his narrative. For, pray, because it is written, And the Lord God said to Abraham; and a little after, And the Lord God appeared unto Abraham; were these things, for this reason, not done by angels? Whereas it is said in like manner in another place, And the Lord appeared to him in the plains of Mamre, as he sat in the tent door in the heat of the day; and yet it is added immediately, And he lift up his eyes and looked, and, lo, three men stood by him: of whom we have already spoken. For how will these people, who either will not rise from the words to the meaning, or easily throw themselves down from the meaning to the words — how, I say, will they be able to explain that God was seen in three men, except they confess that they were angels, as that which follows also shows? Because it is not said an angel spoke or appeared to him, will they therefore venture to say that the vision and voice granted to Moses was wrought by an angel because it is so written, but that God appeared and spoke in His own substance to Abraham because there is no mention made of an angel? What of the fact, that even in respect to Abraham an angel is not left unmentioned? For when his son was ordered to be offered up as a sacrifice, we read thus: And it came to pass after these things that God did tempt Abraham, and said to him, Abraham: and he said, Behold, here I am. And He said, Take now your son, your only son Isaac, whom you love, and go to the land of Moriah; and offer him there for a burnt-offering upon one of the mountains that I will tell you of. Certainly God is here mentioned, not an angel. But a little afterwards Scripture has it thus: And Abraham stretched forth his hand, and took the knife to slay his son. And the angel of the Lord called unto him out of heaven, and said, Abraham, Abraham: and he said, Here am I. And he said, Lay not your hand upon the lad, neither do anything unto him. What can be answered to this? Will they say that God commanded that Isaac should be slain, and that an angel forbade it? And further, that the father himself, in opposition to the decree of God, who had commanded that he should be slain, obeyed the angel, who had bidden him spare him? Such an interpretation is to be rejected as absurd. Yet not even for it, gross and abject as it is, does Scripture leave any room, for it immediately adds: For now I know that you fear God, seeing you have not withheld your son, your only son, on account of me. What is on account of me, except on account of Him who had commanded him to be slain? Was then the God of Abraham the same as the angel, or was it not rather God by an angel? Consider what follows. Here, certainly, already an angel has been most clearly spoken of; yet notice the context: And Abraham lifted up his eyes, and looked, and behold behind him a ram caught in a thicket by his horns: and Abraham went and took the ram, and offered him up for a burnt-offering in the stead of his son. And Abraham called the name of that place, The Lord saw: as it is said to this day, In the mount the Lord was seen. Just as that which a little before God said by an angel, For now I know that you fear God; not because it was to be understood that God then came to know, but that He brought it to pass that through God Abraham himself came to know what strength of heart he had to obey God, even to the sacrificing of his only son: after that mode of speech in which the effect is signified by the efficient — as cold is said to be sluggish, because it makes men sluggish; so that He was therefore said to know, because He had made Abraham himself to know, who might well have not discerned the firmness of his own faith, had it not been proved by such a trial. So here, too, Abraham called the name of the place The Lord saw, that is, caused Himself to be seen. For he goes on immediately to say, As it is said to this day, In the mount the Lord was seen. Here you see the same angel is called Lord: wherefore, unless because the Lord spoke by the angel? But if we pass on to that which follows, the angel altogether speaks as a prophet, and reveals expressly that God is speaking by the angel. And the angel of the Lord, he says, called unto Abraham out of heaven the second time, and said, By myself I have sworn, says the Lord; for because you have done this thing, and hast not withheld your son, your only son, on account of me, etc. Certainly these words, viz. that he by whom the Lord speaks should say, Thus says the Lord, are commonly used by the prophets also. Does the Son of God say of the Father, The Lord says, while He Himself is that Angel of the Father? What then? Do they not see how hard pressed they are about these three men who appeared to Abraham, when it had been said before, The Lord appeared to him? Were they not angels because they are called men? Let them read Daniel, saying, Behold the man Gabriel.

Why do we delay any longer to silence them with another very clear and compelling proof, where neither an angel in the singular nor men in the plural are mentioned, but simply angels? Through these angels not just some particular word was accomplished, but the Law itself is most clearly declared to have been given. Certainly none of the faithful doubts that God gave the Law to Moses for governing the children of Israel, or that it was given through angels. Stephen speaks this way: "You stiff-necked," he says, "and uncircumcised in heart and ears, you always resist the Holy Spirit. As your fathers did, so do you. Which of the prophets have your fathers not persecuted? They have killed those who foretold the coming of the Just One, of whom you have now become the betrayers and murderers—you who received the Law through the arrangement of angels, and have not kept it." What is clearer than this? What carries stronger authority? The Law was indeed given to that people through the arrangement of angels. But the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ was prepared and announced beforehand through it. And He Himself, as the Word of God, was in some wonderful and unexplainable way present in the angels, through whose arrangement the Law itself was given. Hence He said in the Gospel, "For if you had believed Moses, you would have believed me, for he wrote of me." Therefore the Lord was speaking through the angels, and the Son of God, who was to be the Mediator between God and humanity, from the seed of Abraham, was preparing His own coming through the angels, so that He might find some who would receive Him—people confessing their guilt, whom the unfulfilled Law had made transgressors. For this reason the apostle also says to the Galatians, "Why then the Law? It was added because of transgressions, until the seed should come to whom the promise was made, and it was arranged through angels by the hand of a mediator"—that is, arranged through angels in His own hand. For He was not born in limitation, but in power. But you learn in another place that he does not mean any one of the angels as the mediator, but the Lord Jesus Christ Himself, insofar as He chose to be made man. For, "There is one God," he says, "and one Mediator between God and humanity, the man Christ Jesus." From this came that Passover in the killing of the lamb; from this came all those things spoken symbolically in the Law about Christ who would come in the flesh and suffer, but also rise again. This Law was given through the arrangement of angels, in which angels the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit were certainly present. In these angels, sometimes the Father, sometimes the Son, sometimes the Holy Spirit, and sometimes God without any distinction of person, was symbolically represented by them, appearing in visible and sensible forms, yet through His own creation, not through His substance, since the seeing of that substance requires hearts to be cleansed through all those things which are seen by the eyes and heard by the ears.

26. But why do we delay any longer to stop their mouths by another most clear and most weighty proof, where not an angel in the singular nor men in the plural are spoken of, but simply angels; by whom not any particular word was wrought, but the Law itself is most distinctly declared to be given; which certainly none of the faithful doubts that God gave to Moses for the control of the children of Israel, or yet, that it was given by angels. So Stephen speaks: You stiff-necked, he says, and uncircumcised in heart and ears, you do always resist the Holy Ghost: as your fathers did, so do you. Which of the prophets have not your fathers persecuted? And they have slain them which showed before of the coming of the Just One; of whom you have been now the betrayers and murderers: who have received the Law by the disposition of angels, and have not kept it. What is more evident than this? What more strong than such an authority? The Law, indeed, was given to that people by the disposition of angels; but the advent of our Lord Jesus Christ was by it prepared and pre-announced; and He Himself, as the Word of God, was in some wonderful and unspeakable manner in the angels, by whose disposition the Law itself was given. And hence He said in the Gospel, For had you believed Moses, you would have believed me; for he wrote of me. Therefore then the Lord was speaking by the angels; and the son of God, who was to be the Mediator of God and men, from the seed of Abraham, was preparing His own advent by the angels, that He might find some by whom He would be received, confessing themselves guilty, whom the Law unfulfilled had made transgressors. And hence the apostle also says to the Galatians, Wherefore then serves the Law? It was added because of transgressions, till the seed should come to whom the promise was made, which [seed] was ordered through angels in the hand of a mediator; that is, ordered through angels in His own hand. For He was not born in limitation, but in power. But you learn in another place that he does not mean any one of the angels as a mediator, but the Lord Jesus Christ Himself, in so far as He deigned to be made man: For there is one God, he says, and one Mediator between God and man, the man Christ Jesus. Hence that passover in the killing of the lamb: hence all those things which are figuratively spoken in the Law, of Christ to come in the flesh, and to suffer, but also to rise again, which Law was given by the disposition of angels; in which angels, were certainly the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit; and in which, sometimes the Father, sometimes the Son, sometimes the Holy Spirit, and sometimes God, without any distinction of person, was figuratively signified by them, although appearing in visible and sensible forms, yet by His own creature, not by His substance, in order to the seeing of which, hearts are cleansed through all those things which are seen by the eyes and heard by the ears.

I believe we have now adequately discussed and demonstrated what we set out to show in this book, to the best of my ability. We have established both by reasonable argument—as far as a person, or rather as far as I am able—and by the force of authority—as far as divine declarations from Holy Scripture have made clear—that those words and bodily appearances given to our ancient fathers before the Savior's incarnation, when God was said to appear, were accomplished through angels. Either the angels themselves spoke or did something in the person of God, as we have shown the prophets also customarily did, or they took on from creation something they themselves were not, so that God might be shown figuratively to people. Scripture teaches through many examples that the prophets also used this manner of showing. Therefore, what remains for us now to consider is this: in the Lord's birth from a virgin, in the Holy Spirit's descent in bodily form like a dove, and in the tongues as of fire that appeared with a sound from heaven on Pentecost after the Lord's ascension, it was not the Word of God himself in his own substance—in which he is equal and eternal with the Father—nor the Spirit of the Father and of the Son in his own substance—in which he himself is also equal and coeternal with both—but certainly a creature that could be formed and exist in these appearances, which were visible to bodily and mortal senses. What remains, I say, is to consider what difference exists between these manifestations and those that were proper to the Son of God and to the Holy Spirit, though accomplished through visible creation. We will more conveniently begin this subject in another book.

27. But now, as I think, that which we had undertaken to show in this book has been sufficiently discussed and demonstrated, according to our capacity; and it has been established, both by probable reason, so far as a man, or rather, so far as I am able, and by strength of authority, so far as the divine declarations from the Holy Scriptures have been made clear, that those words and bodily appearances which were given to these ancient fathers of ours before the incarnation of the Saviour, when God was said to appear, were wrought by angels: whether themselves speaking or doing something in the person of God, as we have shown that the prophets also were wont to do, or assuming from the creature that which they themselves were not, wherein God might be shown in a figure to men; which manner of showing also, Scripture teaches by many examples, that the prophets, too, did not omit. It remains, therefore, now for us to consider — since both in the Lord as born of a virgin, and in the Holy Spirit descending in a corporeal form like a dove, and in the tongues like as of fire, which appeared with a sound from heaven on the day of Pentecost, after the ascension of the Lord, it was not the Word of God Himself by His own substance, in which He is equal and eternal with the Father, nor the Spirit of the Father and of the Son by His own substance, in which He Himself also is equal and co-eternal with both, but assuredly a creature, such as could be formed and exist in these fashions, which appeared to corporeal and mortal senses — it remains, I say, to consider what difference there is between these manifestations and those which were proper to the Son of God and to the Holy Spirit, although wrought by the visible creature; which subject we shall more conveniently begin in another book.


On the Trinity — Book II

Rules for reading Scripture about the Son ‘in the form of a servant’ and ‘in the form of God’; the sending of the Son and the Spirit, and the appearances of God in the Old Testament.

Augustine pursues his defense of the equality of the Trinity; and in treating of the sending of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and of the various appearances of God, demonstrates that He who is sent is not therefore less than He who sends, because the one has sent, the other has been sent; but that the Trinity, being in all things equal, and alike in its own nature unchangeable and invisible and omnipresent, works indivisibly in each sending or appearance.

Source: Translated by Arthur West Haddan. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 3. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1887. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/130102.htm>.

Contents · 19 chapters
  1. Preface
  2. Chapter 1.– There is a Double Rule for Understanding the Scriptural Modes of Speech Concerning the Son of God. These Modes of Speech are of a Threefold Kind.
  3. Chapter 2.– That Some Ways of Speaking Concerning the Son are to Be Understood According to Either Rule.
  4. Chapter 3.– Some Things Concerning the Holy Spirit are to Be Understood According to the One Rule Only.
  5. Chapter 4.– The Glorification of the Son by the Father Does Not Prove Inequality.
  6. Chapter 5.– The Son and Holy Spirit are Not Therefore Less Because Sent. The Son is Sent Also by Himself. Of the Sending of the Holy Spirit.
  7. Chapter 6.– The Creature is Not So Taken by the Holy Spirit as Flesh is by the Word.
  8. Chapter 7.– A Doubt Raised About Divine Appearances.
  9. Chapter 8.– The Entire Trinity Invisible.
  10. Chapter 9.– Against Those Who Believed the Father Only to Be Immortal and Invisible. The Truth to Be Sought by Peaceful Study.
  11. Chapter 10– Whether God the Trinity Indiscriminately Appeared to the Fathers, or Any One Person of the Trinity. The Appearing of God to Adam. Of the Same Appearance. The Vision to Abraham.
  12. Chapter 11.– Of the Same Appearance.
  13. Chapter 12.– The Appearance to Lot is Examined.
  14. Chapter 13.– The Appearance in the Bush.
  15. Chapter 14.– Of the Appearance in the Pillar of Cloud and of Fire.
  16. Chapter 15.– Of the Appearance on Sinai. Whether the Trinity Spoke in that Appearance or Some One Person Specially.
  17. Chapter 16.– In What Manner Moses Saw God.
  18. Chapter 17.– How the Back Parts of God Were Seen. The Faith of the Resurrection of Christ. The Catholic Church Only is the Place from Whence the Back Parts of God are Seen. The Back Parts of God Were Seen by the Israelites. It is a Rash Opinion to Think that God the Father Only Was Never Seen by the Fathers.
  19. Chapter 18.– The Vision of Daniel.

Preface

When people seek to know God and apply their minds—within the limits of human weakness—to understanding the Trinity, they learn through experience how difficult and exhausting this task is. This difficulty comes either from the mind itself trying to look upon unapproachable light, or from the many different ways of speaking found in the sacred writings. In these writings, it seems to me, the mind is put through rigorous exercise so that it may find sweetness when glorified by the grace of Christ. Such people, once they have cleared up every confusion and reached something certain, ought to be the most willing to show patience toward those who make mistakes in investigating so profound a mystery. But there are two things that are very hard to tolerate in those who are in error: jumping to conclusions before the truth is clear, and then defending the falsehood they hastily assumed once the truth has been made clear. I pray and hope that God will defend and protect me from these two faults—which work against discovering truth and properly handling the divine and sacred books—with the shield of His goodwill and the grace of His mercy. If He does, I will not hesitate to search out the ousia of God, whether through His Scripture or through creation. Both of these are set before us for contemplation so that we may seek Him and love Him—the one who inspired Scripture and created the world. I will not be afraid to give my opinion, and I would rather have upright people examine it than fear criticism from those who twist things. Love, which is most excellent and humble, gladly welcomes the gentle eye of the dove, but against the dog's tooth nothing is left except to avoid it through careful humility or to dull it with solid truth. I would much rather be criticized by anyone at all than be praised by someone who is mistaken or by a flatterer. For the lover of truth need not fear anyone's criticism. Anyone who criticizes must be either an enemy or a friend. If an enemy attacks, he must be endured. But if a friend makes a mistake, he must be taught; if he teaches, he must be listened to. However, if someone who is wrong praises you, he confirms your error; if a flatterer praises you, he lures you into error. Therefore, let the righteous strike me—it will be a kindness—and let him correct me; but the oil of the sinner shall not anoint my head.

When men seek to know God, and bend their minds according to the capacity of human weakness to the understanding of the Trinity; learning, as they must, by experience, the wearisome difficulties of the task, whether from the sight itself of the mind striving to gaze upon light unapproachable, or, indeed, from the manifold and various modes of speech employed in the sacred writings (wherein, as it seems to me, the mind is nothing else but roughly exercised, in order that it may find sweetness when glorified by the grace of Christ);– such men, I say, when they have dispelled every ambiguity, and arrived at something certain, ought of all others most easily to make allowance for those who err in the investigation of so deep a secret. But there are two things most hard to bear with, in the case of those who are in error: hasty assumption before the truth is made plain; and, when it has been made plain, defense of the falsehood thus hastily assumed. From which two faults, inimical as they are to the finding out of the truth, and to the handling of the divine and sacred books, should God, as I pray and hope, defend and protect me with the shield of His good will, and with the grace of His mercy, I will not be slow to search out the substance of God, whether through His Scripture or through the creature. For both of these are set forth for our contemplation to this end, that He may Himself be sought, and Himself be loved, who inspired the one, and created the other. Nor shall I be afraid of giving my opinion, in which I shall more desire to be examined by the upright, than fear to be carped at by the perverse. For charity, most excellent and unassuming, gratefully accepts the dovelike eye; but for the dog's tooth nothing remains, save either to shun it by the most cautious humility, or to blunt it by the most solid truth; and far rather would I be censured by any one whatsoever, than be praised by either the erring or the flatterer. For the lover of truth need fear no one's censure. For he that censures, must needs be either enemy or friend. And if an enemy reviles, he must be borne with: but a friend, if he errs, must be taught; if he teaches, listened to. But if one who errs praises you, he confirms your error; if one who flatters, he seduces you into error. Let the righteous, therefore, smite me, it shall be a kindness; and let him reprove me; but the oil of the sinner shall not anoint my head.

Chapter 1.– There is a Double Rule for Understanding the Scriptural Modes of Speech Concerning the Son of God. These Modes of Speech are of a Threefold Kind.

We hold firmly to what may be called the canonical rule concerning our Lord Jesus Christ, as it is spread throughout the Scriptures and has been demonstrated by learned and Catholic interpreters of those same Scriptures. This rule is that the Son of God is understood to be equal to the Father according to the form of God in which He exists, and less than the Father according to the form of a servant which He took. In this form, He was found to be not only less than the Father but also less than the Holy Spirit, and not only so, but less even than Himself—not than Himself who was, but than Himself who is. By taking the form of a servant, He did not lose the form of God, as the testimonies of the Scriptures teach us, which we referred to in the earlier book. However, some things in the sacred text are expressed in such a way that it is unclear which rule they should be understood by: whether by the rule that makes us understand the Son as less because He has taken upon Himself the creature, or by the rule that makes us understand that the Son is not less than but equal to the Father, yet He is from Him, God of God, Light of light. We call the Son God of God, but the Father, God only, not of God. From this it is clear that the Son has another from whom He is and to whom He is Son, but the Father does not have a Son from whom He is, but only to whom He is Father. Every son is what he is from his father and is son to his father, but no father is what he is from his son, but is father to his son.

2. Wherefore, although we hold most firmly, concerning our Lord Jesus Christ, what may be called the canonical rule, as it is both disseminated through the Scriptures, and has been demonstrated by learned and Catholic handlers of the same Scriptures, namely, that the Son of God is both understood to be equal to the Father according to the form of God in which He is, and less than the Father according to the form of a servant which He took; in which form He was found to be not only less than the Father, but also less than the Holy Spirit; and not only so, but less even than Himself — not than Himself who was, but than Himself who is; because, by taking the form of a servant, He did not lose the form of God, as the testimonies of the Scriptures taught us, to which we have referred in the former book: yet there are some things in the sacred text so put as to leave it ambiguous to which rule they are rather to be referred; whether to that by which we understand the Son as less, in that He has taken upon Him the creature, or to that by which we understand that the Son is not indeed less than, but equal to the Father, but yet that He is from Him, God of God, Light of light. For we call the Son God of God; but the Father, God only; not of God. Whence it is plain that the Son has another of whom He is, and to whom He is Son; but that the Father has not a Son of whom He is, but only to whom He is father. For every son is what he is, of his father, and is son to his father; but no father is what he is, of his son, but is father to his son.

Some things in the Scriptures concerning the Father and the Son are expressed in ways that point to the unity and equality of their substance. For instance, "I and the Father are one," and "Who, being in the form of God, thought it not robbery to be equal with God," along with other similar texts. Other passages present the Son as less on account of the form of a servant, that is, because He took upon Himself a changeable human substance. Examples include "For my Father is greater than I" and "The Father judges no man, but has committed all judgment unto the Son." A little later it continues, "And has given Him authority to execute judgment also, because He is the Son of man." Still other passages present Him neither as less nor as equal, but simply indicate that He is from the Father. For instance, "For as the Father has life in Himself, so has He given to the Son to have life in Himself," and "The Son can do nothing of Himself, but what He sees the Father do." If we interpret this last statement to mean the Son is less because of the nature He took from creation, it would follow that the Father must have walked on water, or opened the eyes of some other blind person with clay and spittle, and done all the other things which the Son did among people when appearing in the flesh, before the Son did them. This would be necessary so that the Son could do these things, since He said He could do nothing of Himself except what He has seen the Father do. But who, even if insane, would think this? Therefore, these texts are expressed this way because the Son's life is as unchangeable as the Father's life is, and yet He is from the Father. The Father and Son's working is undivided, yet the ability to work is given to the Son by the one from whom He Himself exists, that is, from the Father. The Son sees the Father in such a way that He is the Son in the very act of seeing Him. For the Son, to be from the Father—that is, to be born of the Father—is nothing other than to see the Father, and to see Him working is nothing other than to work with Him. But He does not work from Himself because He is not from Himself. Therefore, the things which He sees the Father do, these the Son also does in the same way, because He is from the Father. He does not do different things in a similar manner, as a painter paints different pictures in the same way he has seen pictures painted by another. Nor does He do the same things in a different manner, as the body expresses the same letters that the mind has thought. Rather, He says, "Whatsoever things the Father does, these same things also does the Son likewise." He said both "these same things" and "likewise," which shows that the working of both Father and Son is undivided and equal, but it comes from the Father to the Son. Therefore the Son cannot do anything of Himself, except what He sees the Father do. From this rule, by which the Scriptures speak not to present one as less than another but only to show which is from which, some have mistakenly concluded that the Son is being called less. Some among us who are less educated and least instructed in these matters try to interpret these texts according to the form of a servant, and by misinterpreting them this way, become confused. To prevent this, the rule in question must be observed: the Son is not less, but it is simply indicated that He is from the Father, and in these words not His inequality but His birth is being declared.

3. Some things, then, are so put in the Scriptures concerning the Father and the Son, as to intimate the unity and equality of their substance; as, for instance, I and the Father are one; and, Who, being in the form of God, thought it not robbery to be equal with God; and whatever other texts there are of the kind. And some, again, are so put that they show the Son as less on account of the form of a servant, that is, of His having taken upon Him the creature of a changeable and human substance; as, for instance, that which says, For my Father is greater than I; and, The Father judges no man, but has committed all judgment unto the Son. For a little after he goes on to say, And has given Him authority to execute judgment also, because He is the Son of man. And further, some are so put, as to show Him at that time neither as less nor as equal, but only to intimate that He is of the Father; as, for instance, that which says, For as the Father has life in Himself, so has He given to the Son to have life in Himself; and that other: The Son can do nothing of Himself, but what He sees the Father do. For if we shall take this to be therefore so said, because the Son is less in the form taken from the creature, it will follow that the Father must have walked on the water, or opened the eyes with clay and spittle of some other one born blind, and have done the other things which the Son appearing in the flesh did among men, before the Son did them; in order that He might be able to do those things, who said that the Son was not able to do anything of Himself, except what He has seen the Father do. Yet who, even though he were mad, would think this? It remains, therefore, that these texts are so expressed, because the life of the Son is unchangeable as that of the Father is, and yet He is of the Father; and the working of the Father and of the Son is indivisible, and yet so to work is given to the Son from Him of whom He Himself is, that is, from the Father; and the Son so sees the Father, as that He is the Son in the very seeing Him. For to be of the Father, that is, to be born of the Father, is to Him nothing else than to see the Father; and to see Him working, is nothing else than to work with Him: but therefore not from Himself, because He is not from Himself. And, therefore, those things which He sees the Father do, these also does the Son likewise, because He is of the Father. For He neither does other things in like manner, as a painter paints other pictures, in the same way as he sees others to have been painted by another man; nor the same things in a different manner, as the body expresses the same letters, which the mind has thought; but whatsoever things, says He, the Father does, these same things also does the Son likewise. He has said both these same things, and likewise; and hence the working of both the Father and the Son is indivisible and equal, but it is from the Father to the Son. Therefore the Son cannot do anything of Himself, except what He sees the Father do. From this rule, then, whereby the Scriptures so speak as to mean, not to set forth one as less than another, but only to show which is of which, some have drawn this meaning, as if the Son were said to be less. And some among ourselves who are more unlearned and least instructed in these things, endeavoring to take these texts according to the form of a servant, and so misinterpreting them, are troubled. And to prevent this, the rule in question is to be observed whereby the Son is not less, but it is simply intimated that He is of the Father, in which words not His inequality but His birth is declared.

Chapter 2.– That Some Ways of Speaking Concerning the Son are to Be Understood According to Either Rule.

There are some things in the sacred books, as I said at the beginning, that are stated in such a way that it's unclear which rule they should be referred to: whether to the rule that the Son is less because He took on created nature, or to the rule that indicates He is equal to the Father yet still from the Father. In my opinion, if something is so unclear that what it really means cannot be explained or determined, then such passages can safely be understood according to either rule. For example, take the statement "My doctrine is not mine, but His that sent me." This can be understood according to the form of a servant, as we already discussed in the previous book, or according to the form of God, in which He is equal to the Father while still being from the Father. For according to the form of God, just as the Son is not one thing and His life another thing, but the life itself is the Son, so too the Son is not one thing and His doctrine another thing, but the doctrine itself is the Son. Therefore, just as the text "He has given life to the Son" should be understood to mean "He has begotten the Son, who is life," so also when it says "He has given doctrine to the Son," it can rightly be understood to mean "He has begotten the Son, who is doctrine." Thus, when it says "My doctrine is not mine, but His who sent me," it should be understood as if it were saying "I am not from myself, but from Him who sent me."

4. There are, then, some things in the sacred books, as I began by saying, so put, that it is doubtful to which they are to be referred: whether to that rule whereby the Son is less on account of His having taken the creature; or whether to that whereby it is intimated that although equal, yet He is of the Father. And in my opinion, if this is in such way doubtful, that which it really is can neither be explained nor discerned, then such passages may without danger be understood according to either rule, as that, for instance, My doctrine is not mine, but His that sent me. For this may both be taken according to the form of a servant, as we have already treated it in the former book; or according to the form of God, in which He is in such way equal to the Father, that He is yet of the Father. For according to the form of God, as the Son is not one and His life another, but the life itself is the Son; so the Son is not one and His doctrine another, but the doctrine itself is the Son. And hence, as the text, He has given life to the Son, is no otherwise to be understood than, He has begotten the Son, who is life; so also when it is said, He has given doctrine to the Son, it may be rightly understood to mean, He has begotten the Son, who is doctrine so that, when it is said, My doctrine is not mine, but His who sent me, it is so to be understood as if it were, I am not from myself, but from Him who sent me.

Chapter 3.– Some Things Concerning the Holy Spirit are to Be Understood According to the One Rule Only.

Even concerning the Holy Spirit, of whom it is not said that He emptied Himself and took upon Him the form of a servant, the Lord Himself says, "When He the Spirit of Truth has come, He will guide you into all truth. For He shall not speak of Himself, but whatsoever He shall hear that shall He speak; and He will show you things to come. He shall glorify me; for He shall receive of mine, and shall show it unto you." If He had not immediately added after this, "All things that the Father has are mine; therefore said I, that He shall take of mine, and shall show it unto you," it might perhaps have been believed that the Holy Spirit was born of Christ in the same way that Christ is of the Father. Since He had said of Himself, "My doctrine is not mine, but His that sent me," but of the Holy Spirit, "For He shall not speak of Himself, but whatsoever He shall hear, that shall He speak," and "For He shall receive of mine, and shall show it unto you." But because He has given the reason why He said, "He shall receive of mine"—for He says, "All things that the Father has are mine; therefore said I, that He shall take of mine"—it remains that the Holy Spirit be understood to have of that which is the Father's, just as the Son also has. How can this be, unless according to what we said above: "But when the Comforter has come, whom I will send unto you from the Father, even the Spirit of truth which proceeds from the Father, He shall testify of me"? He is said, therefore, not to speak of Himself in that He proceeds from the Father. Just as it does not follow that the Son is less because He said, "The Son can do nothing of Himself, but what He sees the Father do"—for He did not say this according to the form of a servant, but according to the form of God, as we have already shown, and these words do not set Him forth as less than, but as of the Father—so it does not follow that the Holy Spirit is less because it is said of Him, "For He shall not speak of Himself, but whatsoever He shall hear, that shall He speak," for the words refer to Him as proceeding from the Father. But whereas both the Son is of the Father and the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father, why both are not called sons and both not said to be begotten, but the former is called the one only-begotten Son and the latter, namely the Holy Spirit, is neither son nor begotten—because if begotten, then certainly a son—we will discuss in another place, if God grants, and as far as He grants.

5. For even of the Holy Spirit, of whom it is not said, He emptied Himself, and took upon Him the form of a servant; yet the Lord Himself says, Howbeit, when He the Spirit of Truth has come, He will guide you into all truth. For He shall not speak of Himself, but whatsoever He shall hear that shall He speak; and He will show you things to come. He shall glorify me; for He shall receive of mine, and shall show it unto you. And except He had immediately gone on to say after this, All things that the Father has are mine; therefore said I, that He shall take of mine, and shall show it unto you; it might, perhaps, have been believed that the Holy Spirit was so born of Christ, as Christ is of the Father. Since He had said of Himself, My doctrine is not mine, but His that sent me; but of the Holy Spirit, For He shall not speak of Himself, but whatsoever he shall hear, that shall He speak; and, For He shall receive of mine, and shall show it unto you. But because He has rendered the reason why He said, He shall receive of mine (for He says, All things that the Father has are mine; therefore said I, that He shall take of mine); it remains that the Holy Spirit be understood to have of that which is the Father's, as the Son also has. And how can this be, unless according to that which we have said above, But when the Comforter has come, whom I will send unto you from the Father, even the Spirit of truth which proceeds from the Father, He shall testify of me? He is said, therefore, not to speak of Himself, in that He proceeds from the Father; and as it does not follow that the Son is less because He said, The Son can do nothing of Himself, but what He sees the Father do (for He has not said this according to the form of a servant, but according to the form of God, as we have already shown, and these words do not set Him forth as less than, but as of the Father), so it is not brought to pass that the Holy Spirit is less, because it is said of Him, For He shall not speak of Himself, but whatsoever He shall hear, that shall He speak; for the words belong to Him as proceeding from the Father. But whereas both the Son is of the Father, and the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father, why both are not called sons, and both not said to be begotten, but the former is called the one only-begotten Son, and the latter, viz. the Holy Spirit, neither son nor begotten, because if begotten, then certainly a son, we will discuss in another place, if God shall grant, and so far as He shall grant.

Chapter 4.– The Glorification of the Son by the Father Does Not Prove Inequality.

Those who think this passage shows that the Father is greater than the Son because the Son said "Father, glorify me" need to wake up. After all, the Holy Spirit also glorifies Him. Does that mean the Spirit is greater than He is? Furthermore, if the Holy Spirit glorifies the Son because He receives from what belongs to the Son, and He receives from what belongs to the Son because all things that the Father has also belong to the Son, then it's clear that when the Holy Spirit glorifies the Son, the Father glorifies the Son. From this we can understand that all things the Father has belong not only to the Son but also to the Holy Spirit, since the Holy Spirit is able to glorify the Son whom the Father glorifies. But if the one who glorifies is greater than the one being glorified, then they should admit that those who mutually glorify each other are equal. Scripture also says that the Son glorifies the Father, for He says, "I have glorified You on the earth." They had better be careful not to conclude that the Holy Spirit is greater than both, since He glorifies the Son whom the Father glorifies, yet Scripture never says that He Himself is glorified by either the Father or the Son.

6. But here also let them wake up if they can, who have thought this, too, to be a testimony on their side, to show that the Father is greater than the Son, because the Son has said, Father, glorify me. Why, the Holy Spirit also glorifies Him. Pray, is the Spirit, too, greater than He? Moreover, if on that account the Holy Spirit glorifies the Son, because He shall receive of that which is the Son's, and shall therefore receive of that which is the Son's because all things that the Father has are the Son's also; it is evident that when the Holy Spirit glorifies the Son, the Father glorifies the Son. Whence it may be perceived that all things that the Father has are not only of the Son, but also of the Holy Spirit, because the Holy Spirit is able to glorify the Son, whom the Father glorifies. But if he who glorifies is greater than he whom he glorifies, let them allow that those are equal who mutually glorify each other. But it is written, also, that the Son glorifies the Father; for He says, I have glorified You on the earth. Truly let them beware lest the Holy Spirit be thought greater than both, because He glorifies the Son whom the Father glorifies, while it is not written that He Himself is glorified either by the Father or by the Son.

Chapter 5.– The Son and Holy Spirit are Not Therefore Less Because Sent. The Son is Sent Also by Himself. Of the Sending of the Holy Spirit.

Having been proved wrong on those points, people then resort to saying that the one who sends is greater than the one who is sent. Therefore, they argue, the Father is greater than the Son because the Son continually speaks of himself as being sent by the Father. They also claim the Father is greater than the Holy Spirit because Jesus said of the Spirit, "Whom the Father will send in my name." And they say the Holy Spirit is less than both, because both the Father sends him, as we have noted, and the Son does too, when he says, "But if I depart, I will send him to you." So I first ask in this investigation: from where and to where was the Son sent? He says, "I came forth from the Father and have come into the world." Therefore, to be sent means to come forth from the Father and to come into the world. But then what about what the same evangelist says concerning him: "He was in the world, and the world was made by him, and the world knew him not"? And then he adds, "He came to his own." Certainly he was sent to the place where he came. But if he was sent into the world because he came forth from the Father, then he both came into the world and was already in the world. He was sent, therefore, to the place where he already was. Consider also what is written in the prophet, where God said, "Do not I fill heaven and earth?" If this is said of the Son—for some interpret it to mean that the Son himself spoke either by the prophets or in the prophets—where was he sent except to the place where he already was? For he who says "I fill heaven and earth" was everywhere. But if this is said of the Father, where could he be without his own Word and without his own Wisdom, which "reaches from one end to another mightily and sweetly orders all things"? Yet he cannot be anywhere without his own Spirit. Therefore, if God is everywhere, his Spirit also is everywhere. So the Holy Spirit too was sent to the place where he already was. For the psalmist who finds no place where he might go from God's presence, who says, "If I ascend up into heaven, you are there; if I go down into hell, behold, you are there"—wanting it to be understood that God is present everywhere—named his Spirit in the previous verse. For he says, "Where shall I go from your Spirit? Or where shall I flee from your presence?"

7. But being proved wrong so far, men betake themselves to saying, that he who sends is greater than he who is sent: therefore the Father is greater than the Son, because the Son continually speaks of Himself as being sent by the Father; and the Father is also greater than the Holy Spirit, because Jesus has said of the Spirit, Whom the Father will send in my name; and the Holy Spirit is less than both, because both the Father sends Him, as we have said, and the Son, when He says, But if I depart, I will send Him unto you. I first ask, then, in this inquiry, whence and whither the Son was sent. I, He says, came forth from the Father, and have come into the world. Therefore, to be sent, is to come forth forth from the Father, and to come into the world. What, then, is that which the same evangelist says concerning Him, He was in the world, and the world was made by Him, and the world knew Him not; and then he adds, He came unto His own? Certainly He was sent there, whither He came; but if He was sent into the world, because He came forth from the Father, then He both came into the world and was in the world. He was sent therefore there, where He already was. For consider that, too, which is written in the prophet, that God said, Do not I fill heaven and earth? If this is said of the Son (for some will have it understood that the Son Himself spoke either by the prophets or in the prophets), whither was He sent except to the place where He already was? For He who says, I fill heaven and earth, was everywhere. But if it is said of the Father, where could He be without His own word and without His own wisdom, which reaches from one end to another mightily, and sweetly orders all things? But He cannot be anywhere without His own Spirit. Therefore, if God is everywhere, His Spirit also is everywhere. Therefore, the Holy Spirit, too, was sent there, where He already was. For he, too, who finds no place to which he might go from the presence of God, and who says, If I ascend up into heaven, You are there; if I shall go down into hell, behold, You are there; wishing it to be understood that God is present everywhere, named in the previous verse His Spirit; for He says, Whither shall I go from Your Spirit? Or whither shall I flee from Your presence?

If both the Son and the Holy Spirit are sent to where they already were, we must ask how this sending—whether of the Son or of the Holy Spirit—is to be understood, since we nowhere read that the Father is sent. Now, concerning the Son, the apostle writes: "But when the fullness of the time had come, God sent forth His Son, made of a woman, made under the law, to redeem them that were under the law." He says God sent His Son, made of a woman. What Catholic does not know that by the term "woman" he did not mean to deny virginity, but rather, following Hebrew usage, to indicate the female sex? Therefore, when he says "God sent His Son, made of a woman," he clearly shows that the Son was sent precisely in being made of a woman. So while He was in the world by being born of God, He was sent and came into the world by being born of Mary. Furthermore, the Son could not be sent by the Father without the Holy Spirit, not only because when the Father sent Him—that is, when He made Him of a woman—the Father certainly must be understood as not having done so without His own Spirit, but also because it is stated most plainly and explicitly in the Gospel, when the Virgin Mary asked the angel, "How shall this be?" The answer was: "The Holy Ghost shall come upon you, and the power of the Highest shall overshadow you." And Matthew says, "She was found with child of the Holy Ghost." Even in the prophet Isaiah, Christ Himself is understood to speak of His own future coming: "And now the Lord God and His Spirit has sent me."

8. For this reason, then, if both the Son and the Holy Spirit are sent there where they were, we must inquire, how that sending, whether of the Son or of the Holy Spirit, is to be understood; for of the Father alone, we nowhere read that He is sent. Now, of the Son, the apostle writes thus: But when the fullness of the time had come, God sent forth His Son, made of a woman, made under the law, to redeem them that were under the law. He sent, he says, His Son, made of a woman. And by this term, woman, what Catholic does not know that he did not wish to signify the privation of virginity; but, according to a Hebraism, the difference of sex? When, therefore, he says, God sent His Son, made of a woman, he sufficiently shows that the Son was sent in this very way, in that He was made of a woman. Therefore, in that He was born of God, He was in the world; but in that He was born of Mary, He was sent and came into the world. Moreover, He could not be sent by the Father without the Holy Spirit, not only because the Father, when He sent Him, that is, when He made Him of a woman, is certainly understood not to have so made Him without His own Spirit; but also because it is most plainly and expressly said in the Gospel in answer to the Virgin Mary, when she asked of the angel, How shall this be? The Holy Ghost shall come upon you, and the power of the Highest shall overshadow you. And Matthew says, She was found with child of the Holy Ghost. Although, too, in the prophet Isaiah, Christ Himself is understood to say of His own future advent, And now the Lord God and His Spirit has sent me.

Someone might want to push us to say that the Son is also sent by Himself, since the conception and birth from Mary is the work of the Trinity, through whose creative act all things are created. "How," he might continue, "has the Father sent Him if He sent Himself?" My first response is to ask him to tell me, if he can, how the Father has sanctified Him if He has sanctified Himself. For the same Lord says both things: "Say of Him," He says, "whom the Father has sanctified and sent into the world, 'You blaspheme,' because I said, 'I am the Son of God,'" while in another place He says, "And for their sake I sanctify myself." I also ask how the Father delivered Him if He delivered Himself. For the Apostle Paul says both: "Who," he says, "spared not His own Son, but delivered Him up for us all," while elsewhere he says of the Savior Himself, "Who loved me, and delivered Himself for me." If he has a right understanding of these things, he will reply, I suppose, "Because the will of the Father and the Son is one, and their working indivisible." In the same way, then, let him understand that the incarnation and birth from the Virgin, in which the Son is understood as sent, was accomplished by one and the same operation of the Father and of the Son indivisibly—with the Holy Spirit certainly not excluded, since it is expressly said, "She was found with child by the Holy Spirit." Perhaps our meaning will be more clearly explained if we ask how God sent His Son. Did He command that He should come, and did He comply with the command and come? Did He request, or did He only suggest? But whichever of these it was, it was certainly done by a word, and the Word of God is the Son of God Himself. Therefore, since the Father sent Him by a word, His being sent was the work of both the Father and His Word. Therefore the same Son was sent by the Father and the Son, because the Son Himself is the Word of the Father. For who would embrace such an impious opinion as to think that the Father uttered a word in time so that the eternal Son might thereby be sent and appear in the flesh in the fullness of time? But surely it was in that Word of God itself which was in the beginning with God and was God—namely, in the wisdom itself of God—apart from time, that it was determined at what time that wisdom should appear in the flesh. Therefore, since the Word was in the beginning without any beginning of time, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God, it was in the Word itself without any time that it was determined when the Word was to be made flesh and dwell among us. And when this fullness of time came, God sent His Son, made of a woman—that is, made in time—so that the Incarnate Word might appear to men, while it was in that Word Himself, apart from time, when this was to be done. For the order of times exists in the eternal wisdom of God without time. Since, then, the Son's appearing in the flesh was accomplished by both the Father and the Son, it is appropriate to say that He who appeared in that flesh was sent, and that He who did not appear in it sent Him, because those things which happen outwardly before bodily eyes have their existence from the inward structure (apparatu) of the spiritual nature, and for that reason are appropriately said to be sent. Furthermore, that form of man which He took is the person of the Son, not also of the Father. For this reason the invisible Father, together with the Son who with the Father is invisible, is said to have sent the same Son by making Him visible. But if He became visible in such a way that He ceased to be invisible with the Father—that is, if the substance of the invisible Word were turned by a change and transition into a visible creature—then the Son would be understood to be sent by the Father in such a way that He would be found to be only sent, not also sending with the Father. But since He took the form of a servant in such a way that the unchangeable form of God remained, it is clear that what became apparent in the Son was done by the Father and the Son not being apparent—that is, by the invisible Father with the invisible Son, the same Son Himself was sent so as to be visible. Why, therefore, does He say, "Neither came I of myself"? We may now say that this is said according to the form of a servant, in the same way as "I judge no man" is said.

9. Perhaps some one may wish to drive us to say, that the Son is sent also by Himself, because the conception and childbirth of Mary is the working of the Trinity, by whose act of creating all things are created. And how, he will go on to say, has the Father sent Him, if He sent Himself? To whom I answer first, by asking him to tell me, if he can, in what manner the Father has sanctified Him, if He has sanctified Himself? For the same Lord says both; Say of Him, He says, whom the Father has sanctified and sent into the world, You blaspheme, because I said, I am the Son of God; while in another place He says, And for their sake I sanctify myself. I ask, also, in what manner the Father delivered Him, if He delivered Himself? For the Apostle Paul says both: Who, he says, spared not His own Son, but delivered Him up for us all; while elsewhere he says of the Saviour Himself, Who loved me, and delivered Himself for me. He will reply, I suppose, if he has a right sense in these things, Because the will of the Father and the Son is one, and their working indivisible. In like manner, then, let him understand the incarnation and nativity of the Virgin, wherein the Son is understood as sent, to have been wrought by one and the same operation of the Father and of the Son indivisibly; the Holy Spirit certainly not being thence excluded, of whom it is expressly said, She was found with child by the Holy Ghost. For perhaps our meaning will be more plainly unfolded, if we ask in what manner God sent His Son. He commanded that He should come, and He, complying with the commandment, came. Did He then request, or did He only suggest? But whichever of these it was, certainly it was done by a word, and the Word of God is the Son of God Himself. Wherefore, since the Father sent Him by a word, His being sent was the work of both the Father and His Word; therefore the same Son was sent by the Father and the Son, because the Son Himself is the Word of the Father. For who would embrace so impious an opinion as to think the Father to have uttered a word in time, in order that the eternal Son might thereby be sent and might appear in the flesh in the fullness of time? But assuredly it was in that Word of God itself which was in the beginning with God and was God, namely, in the wisdom itself of God, apart from time, at what time that wisdom must needs appear in the flesh. Therefore, since without any commencement of time, the Word was in the beginning, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God, it was in the Word itself without any time, at what time the Word was to be made flesh and dwell among us. And when this fullness of time had come, God sent His Son, made of a woman, that is, made in time, that the Incarnate Word might appear to men; while it was in that Word Himself, apart from time, at what time this was to be done; for the order of times is in the eternal wisdom of God without time. Since, then, that the Son should appear in the flesh was wrought by both the Father and the Son, it is fitly said that He who appeared in that flesh was sent, and that He who did not appear in it, sent Him; because those things which are transacted outwardly before the bodily eyes have their existence from the inward structure ( apparatu) of the spiritual nature, and on that account are fitly said to be sent. Further, that form of man which He took is the person of the Son, not also of the Father; on which account the invisible Father, together with the Son, who with the Father is invisible, is said to have sent the same Son by making Him visible. But if He became visible in such way as to cease to be invisible with the Father, that is, if the substance of the invisible Word were turned by a change and transition into a visible creature, then the Son would be so understood to be sent by the Father, that He would be found to be only sent; not also, with the Father, sending. But since He so took the form of a servant, as that the unchangeable form of God remained, it is clear that that which became apparent in the Son was done by the Father and the Son not being apparent; that is, that by the invisible Father, with the invisible Son, the same Son Himself was sent so as to be visible. Why, therefore, does He say, Neither came I of myself? This, we may now say, is said according to the form of a servant, in the same way as it is said, I judge no man.

If, therefore, the Son is said to be sent insofar as He appeared outwardly in bodily form, while inwardly in His spiritual nature He is always hidden from mortal eyes, it is now easy to understand why the Holy Spirit is also said to be sent. For at the proper time a certain outward appearance through created means was produced, in which the Holy Spirit might be visibly shown—whether when He descended upon the Lord Himself in bodily form as a dove, or when, ten days after His ascension, on the day of Pentecost a sound came suddenly from heaven like a rushing mighty wind, and divided tongues as of fire appeared and rested upon each of them. This work, visibly displayed and presented to mortal eyes, is called the sending of the Holy Spirit. This does not mean that His very substance appeared, in which He Himself is also invisible and unchangeable like the Father and the Son, but rather that human hearts, moved by things seen outwardly, might be turned from the temporal manifestation of Him as coming to His hidden eternity as always present.

10. If, therefore, He is said to be sent, in so far as He appeared outwardly in the bodily creature, who inwardly in His spiritual nature is always hidden from the eyes of mortals, it is now easy to understand also of the Holy Spirit why He too is said to be sent. For in due time a certain outward appearance of the creature was wrought, wherein the Holy Spirit might be visibly shown; whether when He descended upon the Lord Himself in a bodily shape as a dove, or when, ten days having past since His ascension, on the day of Pentecost a sound came suddenly from heaven as of a rushing mighty wind, and cloven tongues like as of fire were seen upon them, and it sat upon each of them. This operation, visibly exhibited, and presented to mortal eyes, is called the sending of the Holy Spirit; not that His very substance appeared, in which He himself also is invisible and unchangeable, like the Father and the Son, but that the hearts of men, touched by things seen outwardly, might be turned from the manifestation in time of Him as coming to His hidden eternity as ever present.

Chapter 6.– The Creature is Not So Taken by the Holy Spirit as Flesh is by the Word.

This is why Scripture nowhere says that the Father is greater than the Holy Spirit, or that the Holy Spirit is less than God the Father. The creature through which the Holy Spirit was to appear was not taken in the same way that the Son of man was taken as the form in which the person of the Word of God Himself would be revealed. This was not so that He might possess the word of God as other holy and wise people have possessed it, but above His fellows. It was not that He possessed the word more than they did, making Him wiser than the rest, but that He was the very Word Himself. For the word in the flesh is one thing, and the Word made flesh is another—that is, the word in man is one thing, but the Word that is man is another. Here "flesh" stands for man, as when it says "the Word was made flesh," and again, "And all flesh shall see the salvation of God." This does not mean flesh without soul and without mind, but "all flesh" is the same as saying "every man." Therefore, the creature through which the Holy Spirit appeared was not taken in the same way that the flesh and human form were taken from the Virgin Mary. For the Spirit did not make the dove, the wind, or the fire blessed and join them forever to Himself and to His person in unity and form. Nor is the nature of the Holy Spirit changeable and mutable, so that these things were made from the creature by Him changing and transforming Himself first into one thing and then into another, as water changes into ice. Rather, these things appeared at the appropriate times, with the creature serving the Creator and being changed and transformed at the command of the One who remains unchangeably in Himself, in order to signify and reveal Him in the way that was fitting for mortal people. Therefore, although that dove is called the Spirit, and speaking of that fire it says, "There appeared unto them cloven tongues, like as of fire, and it sat upon each of them, and they began to speak with other tongues, as the Spirit gave them utterance"—showing that the Spirit was manifested by that fire just as by the dove—we still cannot call the Holy Spirit both God and a dove, or both God and fire, in the same way we call the Son both God and man, or as we call the Son the Lamb of God. Not only does John the Baptist say "Behold the Lamb of God," but John the Evangelist also sees the Lamb slain in the Apocalypse. That prophetic vision was not shown to bodily eyes through bodily forms, but in the spirit through spiritual images of bodily things. But whoever saw that dove and that fire saw them with their eyes. Though there may be a question about the fire, whether it was seen with the eyes or in the spirit, because of how the sentence is constructed. The text does not say "They saw cloven tongues like fire," but "There appeared to them." We do not usually say "It appeared to me" with the same meaning as "I saw." In those spiritual visions of bodily images, the usual expressions are both "It appeared to me" and "I saw," but for things shown to the eyes through actual bodily forms, the common expression is not "It appeared to me" but "I saw." Therefore, there may be a question about that fire—how it was seen, whether inwardly in the spirit as if outwardly, or actually outwardly before the eyes of the flesh. But regarding that dove, which is said to have descended in bodily form, no one has ever doubted that it was seen with the eyes. Nor can we call the Spirit a dove or fire in the same way we call the Son a Rock, for it is written, "And that Rock was Christ." That rock was something already created that was called by the name of Christ, whom it signified, according to how it functioned—like the stone placed under Jacob's head and also anointed, which he used to signify the Lord, or as Isaac was Christ when he carried the wood for his own sacrifice. A particular symbolic action was added to these already existing things; they did not, like that dove and fire, suddenly come into being simply in order to signify. The dove and the fire seem to me more like that flame which appeared to Moses in the bush, or that pillar which the people followed in the wilderness, or the thunders and lightnings that came when the Law was given on the mount. For the bodily form of these things came into being for the very purpose of signifying something, and then passing away.

11. It is, then, for this reason nowhere written, that the Father is greater than the Holy Spirit, or that the Holy Spirit is less than God the Father, because the creature in which the Holy Spirit was to appear was not taken in the same way as the Son of man was taken, as the form in which the person of the Word of God Himself should be set forth not that He might possess the word of God, as other holy and wise men have possessed it, but above His fellows; not certainly that He possessed the word more than they, so as to be of more surpassing wisdom than the rest were, but that He was the very Word Himself. For the word in the flesh is one thing, and the Word made flesh is another; i.e. the word in man is one thing, the Word that is man is another. For flesh is put for man, where it is said, The Word was made flesh; and again, And all flesh shall see the salvation of God. For it does not mean flesh without soul and without mind; but all flesh, is the same as if it were said, every man. The creature, then, in which the Holy Spirit should appear, was not so taken, as that flesh and human form were taken, of the Virgin Mary. For the Spirit did not beatify the dove, or the wind, or the fire, and join them for ever to Himself and to His person in unity and fashion. Nor, again, is the nature of the Holy Spirit mutable and changeable; so that these things were not made of the creature, but He himself was turned and changed first into one and then into another, as water is changed into ice. But these things appeared at the seasons at which they ought to have appeared, the creature serving the Creator, and being changed and converted at the command of Him who remains immutably in Himself, in order to signify and manifest Him in such way as it was fit He should be signified and manifested to mortal men. Accordingly, although that dove is called the Spirit; and in speaking of that fire, There appeared unto them, he says, cloven tongues, like as of fire, and it sat upon each of them; and they began to speak with other tongues, as the Spirit gave them utterance; in order to show that the Spirit was manifested by that fire, as by the dove; yet we cannot call the Holy Spirit both God and a dove, or both God and fire, in the same way as we call the Son both God and man; nor as we call the Son the Lamb of God; which not only John the Baptist says, Behold the Lamb of God, but also John the Evangelist sees the Lamb slain in the Apocalypse. For that prophetic vision was not shown to bodily eyes through bodily forms, but in the spirit through spiritual images of bodily things. But whosoever saw that dove and that fire, saw them with their eyes. Although it may perhaps be disputed concerning the fire, whether it was seen by the eyes or in the spirit, on account of the form of the sentence. For the text does not say, They saw cloven tongues like fire, but, There appeared to them. But we are not wont to say with the same meaning, It appeared to me; as we say, I saw. And in those spiritual visions of corporeal images the usual expressions are, both, It appeared to me; and, I saw: but in those things which are shown to the eyes through express corporeal forms, the common expression is not, It appeared to me; but, I saw. There may, therefore, be a question raised respecting that fire, how it was seen; whether within in the spirit as it were outwardly, or really outwardly before the eyes of the flesh. But of that dove, which is said to have descended in a bodily form, no one ever doubted that it was seen by the eyes. Nor, again, as we call the Son a Rock (for it is written, And that Rock was Christ), can we so call the Spirit a dove or fire. For that rock was a thing already created, and after the mode of its action was called by the name of Christ, whom it signified; like the stone placed under Jacob's head, and also anointed, which he took in order to signify the Lord; or as Isaac was Christ, when he carried the wood for the sacrifice of himself. A particular significative action was added to those already existing things; they did not, as that dove and fire, suddenly come into being in order simply so to signify. The dove and the fire, indeed, seem to me more like that flame which appeared to Moses in the bush, or that pillar which the people followed in the wilderness, or the thunders and lightnings which came when the Law was given in the mount. For the corporeal form of these things came into being for the very purpose, that it might signify something, and then pass away.

Chapter 7.– A Doubt Raised About Divine Appearances.

The Holy Spirit, then, is also said to be sent, on account of these bodily forms that came into existence in time, in order to signify and reveal Him as He must be revealed to human senses. Yet He is not said to be less than the Father, as the Son is said to be because He was in the form of a servant. This is because that form of a servant was united to the one person of the Son, but those bodily forms appeared temporarily to show what needed to be shown and then ceased to exist. Why, then, is the Father not also said to be sent through those bodily forms—the fire of the bush, the pillar of cloud or fire, the lightning on the mountain, and whatever other similar things appeared at that time when, as we have learned from Scripture, He spoke face to face with the fathers—if He Himself was revealed through those modes and forms of created things, presented bodily to human sight? But if the Son was revealed through them, why is He said to be sent only much later, when He was made of a woman, as the apostle says: "But when the fullness of time had come, God sent forth His Son, made of a woman," since He was also sent before when He appeared to the fathers through those changeable forms of created things? Or if He cannot rightly be said to be sent unless when the Word was made flesh, why is the Holy Spirit said to be sent, when no such incarnation ever happened with Him? But if through those visible things presented to us in the Law and the prophets, neither the Father nor the Son but the Holy Spirit was revealed, why is He also said to be sent now, when He was sent before in these same ways?

12. The Holy Spirit, then, is also said to be sent, on account of these corporeal forms which came into existence in time, in order to signify and manifest Him, as He must needs be manifested, to human senses; yet He is not said to be less than the Father, as the Son, because He was in the form of a servant, is said to be; because that form of a servant inhered in the unity of the person of the Son, but those corporeal forms appeared for a time, in order to show what was necessary to be shown, and then ceased to be. Why, then, is not the Father also said to be sent, through those corporeal forms, the fire of the bush, and the pillar of cloud or of fire, and the lightnings in the mount, and whatever other things of the kind appeared at that time, when (as we have learned from Scripture testimony) He spoke face to face with the fathers, if He Himself was manifested by those modes and forms of the creature, as exhibited and presented corporeally to human sight? But if the Son was manifested by them, why is He said to be sent so long after, when He was made of a woman, as the apostle says, But when the fullness of time had come, God sent forth His Son, made of a woman, seeing that He was sent also before, when He appeared to the fathers by those changeable forms of the creature? Or if He cannot rightly be said to be sent, unless when the Word was made flesh, why is the Holy Spirit said to be sent, of whom no such incarnation was ever wrought? But if by those visible things, which are put before us in the Law and in the prophets, neither the Father nor the Son but the Holy Spirit was manifested, why also is He said to be sent now, when He was sent also before after these modes?

In the confusion this investigation brings, and with the Lord's help, we must first ask whether the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Spirit—or whether sometimes the Father, sometimes the Son, sometimes the Holy Spirit—or whether it was without any distinction of persons, in the same way that the one and only God is spoken of (that is, the Trinity itself)—appeared to the Fathers through those created forms. Next, whichever of these options turns out to be true or seems true, we must ask whether the creature was fashioned only for this purpose, so that God might be shown to human sight in whatever way He judged suitable at that time, or whether angels who already existed were sent in such a way as to speak in the person of God, taking on a bodily form from the bodily creation for their ministry, as each situation required. Or perhaps, according to the power the Creator has given them, they changed and transformed their own body itself—which is not in authority over them, but which they govern as subject to themselves—into whatever appearances they wished that were suitable and appropriate for their various tasks. Finally, we shall determine what we set out to ask, namely whether the Son and the Holy Spirit were also sent before, and if they were sent, what difference there is between that sending and the one we read about in the Gospel. Or whether in truth neither of them was sent except when the Son was made of the Virgin Mary, or when the Holy Spirit appeared in a visible form, whether as the dove or as tongues of fire.

13. In the perplexity of this inquiry, the Lord helping us, we must ask, first, whether the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Spirit; or whether, sometimes the Father, sometimes the Son, sometimes the Holy Spirit; or whether it was without any distinction of persons, in such way as the one and only God is spoken of, that is, that the Trinity itself appeared to the Fathers by those forms of the creature. Next, whichever of these alternatives shall have been found or thought true, whether for this purpose only the creature was fashioned, wherein God, as He judged it suitable at that time, should be shown to human sight; or whether angels, who already existed, were so sent, as to speak in the person of God, taking a corporeal form from the corporeal creature, for the purpose of their ministry, as each had need; or else, according to the power the Creator has given them, changing and converting their own body itself, to which they are not subject, but govern it as subject to themselves, into whatever appearances they would that were suited and apt to their several actions. Lastly, we shall discern that which it was our purpose to ask, viz. whether the Son and the Holy Spirit were also sent before; and, if they were so sent, what difference there is between that sending, and the one which we read of in the Gospel; or whether in truth neither of them were sent, except when either the Son was made of the Virgin Mary, or the Holy Spirit appeared in a visible form, whether in the dove or in tongues of fire.

Chapter 8.– The Entire Trinity Invisible.

Let us therefore say nothing of those who, with an overly carnal mind, have thought that the nature of the Word of God and the Wisdom—which, remaining in herself, makes all things new, and whom we call the only Son of God—is not only changeable but also visible. These people approach the investigation of divine things with more audacity than genuine religion, bringing a very dull heart to the task. The soul is a spiritual substance, and it was made—and could only have been made by Him through whom all things were made and without whom nothing is made. Although the soul is changeable, it is not visible. Yet these people have believed that the Word Himself and the Wisdom of God itself, by which the soul was made, shares this same character. But this Wisdom is not only invisible, as the soul also is, but also unchangeable, which the soul is not. This unchangeableness is precisely what is referred to when it was said, Remaining in herself she makes all things new. Nevertheless, these people try to support their collapsing error with testimonies from the divine Scriptures by citing the words of the Apostle Paul. They take what is said of the one only God—in whom the Trinity itself is understood—to be said only of the Father, and not of the Son or the Holy Spirit: Now unto the King eternal, immortal, invisible, the only wise God, be honor and glory for ever and ever; and that other passage, The blessed and only Potentate, the King of kings, and Lord of lords; who only has immortality, dwelling in the light which no man can approach unto; whom no man has seen, nor can see. How these passages are to be understood, I think we have already discussed sufficiently.

14. Let us therefore say nothing of those who, with an over carnal mind, have thought the nature of the Word of God, and the Wisdom, which, remaining in herself, makes all things new, whom we call the only Son of God, not only to be changeable, but also to be visible. For these, with more audacity than religion, bring a very dull heart to the inquiry into divine things. For whereas the soul is a spiritual substance, and whereas itself also was made, yet could not be made by any other than by Him by whom all things were made, and without whom nothing is made, it, although changeable, is yet not visible; and this they have believed to be the case with the Word Himself and with the Wisdom of God itself, by which the soul was made; whereas this Wisdom is not only invisible, as the soul also is, but likewise unchangeable, which the soul is not. It is in truth the same unchangeableness in it, which is referred to when it was said, Remaining in herself she makes all things new. Yet these people, endeavoring, as it were, to prop up their error in its fall by testimonies of the divine Scriptures, adduce the words of the Apostle Paul; and take that, which is said of the one only God, in whom the Trinity itself is understood, to be said only of the Father, and neither of the Son nor of the Holy Spirit: Now unto the King eternal, immortal, invisible, the only wise God, be honor and glory for ever and ever; and that other passage, The blessed and only Potentate, the King of kings, and Lord of lords; who only has immortality, dwelling in the light which no man can approach unto; whom no man has seen, nor can see. How these passages are to be understood, I think we have already discoursed sufficiently.

Chapter 9.– Against Those Who Believed the Father Only to Be Immortal and Invisible. The Truth to Be Sought by Peaceful Study.

Those who insist these texts apply only to the Father and not to the Son or the Holy Spirit claim that the Son is visible not merely by taking flesh from the Virgin, but was visible beforehand in Himself. They say He appeared to the eyes of the Fathers. If you tell them that whatever makes the Son visible in Himself would also make Him mortal in Himself, so that the statement "Who only has immortality" would also apply only to the Father, and if the Son is mortal because He took on our flesh, then they should admit He is also visible because of this flesh, they respond that they do not say the Son is mortal because of the flesh. Rather, just as He was visible before, so He was also mortal before. If they said the Son is mortal from taking our flesh, then the Father alone would not have immortality without the Son, because His Word, by which all things were made, would also have immortality. He did not lose His immortality by taking mortal flesh, just as the human soul cannot die with the body, since the Lord Himself says, "Fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul." Surely the Holy Spirit did not take flesh. They will certainly have difficulty explaining, if the Son is mortal because He took our flesh, how they understand that the Father alone has immortality without the Son and the Holy Spirit, since the Holy Spirit did not take our flesh. If the Holy Spirit does not have immortality, then the Son is not mortal because of taking our flesh. But if the Holy Spirit has immortality, then "Who only has immortality" is not said only of the Father. Therefore they think they can prove that the Son in Himself was mortal even before the incarnation, because changeableness itself can properly be called mortality, according to which the soul is also said to die. This is not because it is changed and turned into body or some other substance, but because whatever in its own substance exists in a different mode than it once was is found to be mortal, insofar as it has ceased to be what it was. Because the Son of God, they say, before He was born of the Virgin Mary, appeared to our fathers not in one and the same form only, but in many forms, first in one form, then in another, He is both visible in Himself, because His substance was visible to mortal eyes when He had not yet taken our flesh, and mortal, inasmuch as He is changeable. The same applies to the Holy Spirit, who appeared at one time as a dove and another time as fire. Therefore, they say, the following texts do not belong to the Trinity but belong singularly and properly to the Father only: "Now unto the King eternal, immortal, and invisible, the only wise God," and "Who only has immortality, dwelling in the light which no man can approach unto; whom no man has seen, nor can see."

15. But they who will have these texts understood only of the Father, and not of the Son or the Holy Spirit, declare the Son to be visible, not by having taken flesh of the Virgin, but aforetime also in Himself. For He Himself, they say, appeared to the eyes of the Fathers. And if you say to them, In whatever manner, then, the Son is visible in Himself, in that manner also He is mortal in Himself; so that it plainly follows that you would have this saying also understood only of the Father, viz., Who only has immortality; for if the Son is mortal from having taken upon Him our flesh, then allow that it is on account of this flesh that He is also visible: they reply, that it is not on account of this flesh that they say that the Son is mortal; but that, just as He was also before visible, so He was also before mortal. For if they say the Son is mortal from having taken our flesh, then it is not the Father alone without the Son who has immortality; because His Word also has immortality, by which all things were made. For He did not therefore lose His immortality, because He took mortal flesh; seeing that it could not happen even to the human soul, that it should die with the body, when the Lord Himself says, Fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul. Or, forsooth, also the Holy Spirit took flesh: concerning whom certainly they will, without doubt, be troubled to say — if the Son is mortal on account of taking our flesh — in what manner they understand that the Father only has immortality without the Son and the Holy Spirit, since, indeed, the Holy Spirit did not take our flesh; and if He has not immortality, then the Son is not mortal on account of taking our flesh; but if the Holy Spirit has immortality, then it is not said only of the Father, Who only has immortality. And therefore they think they are able to prove that the Son in Himself was mortal also before the incarnation, because changeableness itself is not unfitly called mortality, according to which the soul also is said to die; not because it is changed and turned into body, or into some substance other than itself, but because, whatever in its own selfsame substance is now after another mode than it once was, is discovered to be mortal, in so far as it has ceased to be what it was. Because then, say they, before the Son of God was born of the Virgin Mary, He Himself appeared to our fathers, not in one and the same form only, but in many forms; first in one form, then in another; He is both visible in Himself, because His substance was visible to mortal eyes, when He had not yet taken our flesh, and mortal, inasmuch as He is changeable. And so also the Holy Spirit, who appeared at one time as a dove, and another time as fire. Whence, they say, the following texts do not belong to the Trinity, but singularly and properly to the Father only: Now unto the King eternal, immortal, and invisible, the only wise God; and, Who only has immortality, dwelling in the light which no man can approach unto; whom no man has seen, nor can see.

Setting aside those thinkers who are unable to understand even the nature of the soul, which is invisible, and therefore are extremely far from understanding that the ousia of the one and only God—that is, the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit—remains always not only invisible but also unchangeable, and therefore possesses true and real immortality; let us, who deny that God, whether the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Spirit, ever appeared to bodily eyes except through the corporeal creation made subject to His own power; let us—ready to be corrected if we are reproved in a brotherly and honest spirit, ready to be so even if criticized by an enemy, as long as he speaks the truth—in catholic peace and with peaceful study inquire whether God appeared without distinction to our fathers before Christ came in the flesh, or whether it was any one person of the Trinity, or whether they appeared individually, as if taking turns.

16. Passing by, then, these reasoners, who are unable to know the substance even of the soul, which is invisible, and therefore are very far indeed from knowing that the substance of the one and only God, that is, the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, remains ever not only invisible, but also unchangeable, and that hence it possesses true and real immortality; let us, who deny that God, whether the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Spirit, ever appeared to bodily eyes, unless through the corporeal creature made subject to His own power; let us, I say — ready to be corrected, if we are reproved in a fraternal and upright spirit, ready to be so, even if carped at by an enemy, so that he speak the truth — in catholic peace and with peaceful study inquire, whether God indiscriminately appeared to our fathers before Christ came in the flesh, or whether it was any one person of the Trinity, or whether severally, as it were by turns.

Chapter 10– Whether God the Trinity Indiscriminately Appeared to the Fathers, or Any One Person of the Trinity. The Appearing of God to Adam. Of the Same Appearance. The Vision to Abraham.

And first, concerning what is written in Genesis—that God spoke with the man He had formed from dust—if we set aside the figurative meaning and treat the narrative as trustworthy even in its literal sense, it appears that God spoke with man in the appearance of a man. This is not explicitly stated in the book, but the general flow of the reading suggests this sense, especially in the passage where Adam heard the voice of the Lord God walking in the garden in the cool of the evening and hid himself among the trees of the garden. When God said, "Adam, where are you?" Adam replied, "I heard Your voice, and I was afraid because I was naked, and I hid myself from Your face." I do not see how such walking and conversation of God can be understood literally unless He appeared as a man. We cannot say that only a voice of God was produced when God is said to have walked, nor that He who was walking in a place was invisible, since Adam says he hid himself from the face of God. Who then was He? The Father, the Son, or the Holy Spirit? Did God the Trinity Himself speak to man in human form without distinction? The flow of Scripture itself nowhere seems to indicate a change from person to person. Rather, it seems that the same one who said "Let there be light" and "Let there be a firmament," and so on through each of those days, continues speaking to the first man. We usually understand this to be God the Father, creating by a word whatever He willed to create. For He made all things by His Word, which Word we know, according to the correct rule of faith, to be His only Son. If, therefore, God the Father spoke to the first man, and He Himself was walking in the garden in the cool of the evening, and if it was from His face that the sinner hid himself among the trees of the garden, why should we not continue to understand that it was He also who appeared to Abraham and to Moses, and to whomever He chose, and in whatever manner He chose, through the changeable and visible creation subjected to Himself, while He Himself remains in Himself and in His own substance, in which He is unchangeable and invisible? But perhaps Scripture passed over from person to person in a hidden way, and while it had related that the Father said "Let there be light" and the rest which it mentioned Him doing by the Word, it went on to indicate the Son as speaking to the first man—not revealing this openly, but suggesting it for understanding by those who could grasp it.

17. And first, in that which is written in Genesis, viz., that God spoke with man whom He had formed out of the dust; if we set apart the figurative meaning, and treat it so as to place faith in the narrative even in the letter, it should appear that God then spoke with man in the appearance of a man. This is not indeed expressly laid down in the book, but the general tenor of its reading sounds in this sense, especially in that which is written, that Adam heard the voice of the Lord God, walking in the garden in the cool of the evening, and hid himself among the trees of the garden; and when God said, Adam, where are you? replied, I heard Your voice, and I was afraid because I was naked, and I hid myself from Your face. For I do not see how such a walking and conversation of God can be understood literally, except He appeared as a man. For it can neither be said that a voice only of God was framed, when God is said to have walked, or that He who was walking in a place was not visible; while Adam, too, says that he hid himself from the face of God. Who then was He? Whether the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Spirit? Whether altogether indiscriminately did God the Trinity Himself speak to man in the form of man? The context, indeed, itself of the Scripture nowhere, it should seem, indicates a change from person to person; but He seems still to speak to the first man, who said, Let there be light, and, Let there be a firmament, and so on through each of those days; whom we usually take to be God the Father, making by a word whatever He willed to make. For He made all things by His word, which Word we know, by the right rule of faith, to be His only Son. If, therefore, God the Father spoke to the first man, and Himself was walking in the garden in the cool of the evening, and if it was from His face that the sinner hid himself among the trees of the garden, why are we not to go on to understand that it was He also who appeared to Abraham and to Moses, and to whom He would, and how He would, through the changeable and visible creature, subjected to Himself, while He Himself remains in Himself and in His own substance, in which He is unchangeable and invisible? But, possibly, it might be that the Scripture passed over in a hidden way from person to person, and while it had related that the Father said Let there be light, and the rest which it mentioned Him to have done by the Word, went on to indicate the Son as speaking to the first man; not unfolding this openly, but intimating it to be understood by those who could understand it.

Let the person who has the ability to penetrate this mystery with his mind's eye—so that it becomes clear to him whether the Father is also able, or whether only the Son and Holy Spirit are able, to appear to human eyes through a visible creature—let him, I say, go ahead and examine these things if he can, or even express and discuss them in words. But as far as this particular Scripture passage is concerned, where God spoke with man, I do not think we can determine the answer, because it does not clearly show whether Adam normally saw God with his bodily eyes. This is especially true since there is a major question about what kind of eyes were opened when they ate the forbidden fruit, since before they ate, these eyes were closed. However, even if Scripture indicates that Paradise was a physical place, I would not rashly claim that God could only have walked there in some bodily form. For it could be argued that only words were created for the man to hear, without his seeing any form. And just because it is written that Adam hid himself from the face of God, it does not automatically follow that he normally saw His face. For what if Adam himself could not see, but was afraid of being seen by God, whose voice he had heard and whose presence he had sensed as God walked? For Cain also said to God, "From Your face I will hide myself," yet we are not therefore forced to admit that he was accustomed to seeing the face of God with his bodily eyes in any visible form, although he had heard the voice of God questioning and speaking with him about his sin. But what kind of speech it was that God then uttered to the outward ears of men, especially in speaking to the first man, is both difficult to discover, and we have not set out to explain it in this discussion. But if only words and sounds were produced to create some sensible presence of God to those first men, I do not know why I should not understand this as the person of God the Father, since His person is also manifested in that voice when Jesus appeared in glory on the mountain before the three disciples, and in that voice when the dove descended upon Him at His baptism, and in that voice where He cried to the Father concerning His own glorification and was answered, "I have both glorified, and will glorify again." This does not mean that the voice could be produced without the work of the Son and of the Holy Spirit (since the Trinity works indivisibly), but rather that such a voice was produced so as to manifest the person of the Father only—just as the Trinity produced that human form from the Virgin Mary, yet it is the person of the Son alone, for the invisible Trinity produced the visible person of the Son alone. Nor does anything prevent us from understanding those words spoken to Adam not only as spoken by the Trinity, but also as manifesting the person of that Trinity. For we are compelled to understand as referring to the Father only what is said: "This is my beloved Son." For Jesus can neither be believed nor understood to be the Son of the Holy Spirit, or even His own Son. And where the voice said, "I have both glorified, and will glorify again," we acknowledge it was only the person of the Father, since it is the answer to the Lord's words when He had said, "Father, glorify your Son," which He could only say to God the Father alone, and not also to the Holy Spirit, whose Son He was not. But here, where it is written, "And the Lord God said to Adam," no reason can be given why the Trinity itself should not be understood.

18. Let him, then, who has the strength whereby he can penetrate this secret with his mind's eye, so that to him it appears clearly, either that the Father also is able, or that only the Son and Holy Spirit are able, to appear to human eyes through a visible creature; let him, I say, proceed to examine these things if he can, or even to express and handle them in words; but the thing itself, so far as concerns this testimony of Scripture, where God spoke with man, is, in my judgment, not discoverable, because it does not evidently appear even whether Adam usually saw God with the eyes of his body; especially as it is a great question what manner of eyes it was that were opened when they tasted the forbidden fruit; for before they had tasted, these eyes were closed. Yet I would not rashly assert, even if that scripture implies Paradise to have been a material place, that God could not have walked there in any way except in some bodily form. For it might be said, that only words were framed for the man to hear, without seeing any form. Neither, because it is written, Adam hid himself from the face of God, does it follow immediately that he usually saw His face. For what if he himself indeed could not see, but feared to be himself seen by Him whose voice he had heard, and had felt His presence as he walked? For Cain, too, said to God, From Your face I will hide myself; yet we are not therefore compelled to admit that he was wont to behold the face of God with his bodily eyes in any visible form, although he had heard the voice of God questioning and speaking with him of his sin. But what manner of speech it was that God then uttered to the outward ears of men, especially in speaking to the first man, it is both difficult to discover, and we have not undertaken to say in this discourse. But if words alone and sounds were wrought, by which to bring about some sensible presence of God to those first men, I do not know why I should not there understand the person of God the Father, seeing that His person is manifested also in that voice, when Jesus appeared in glory on the mount before the three disciples; and in that when the dove descended upon Him at His baptism; and in that where He cried to the Father concerning His own glorification and it was answered Him, I have both glorified, and will glorify again. Not that the voice could be wrought without the work of the Son and of the Holy Spirit (since the Trinity works indivisibly), but that such a voice was wrought as to manifest the person of the Father only; just as the Trinity wrought that human form from the Virgin Mary, yet it is the person of the Son alone; for the invisible Trinity wrought the visible person of the Son alone. Neither does anything forbid us, not only to understand those words spoken to Adam as spoken by the Trinity, but also to take them as manifesting the person of that Trinity. For we are compelled to understand of the Father only, that which is said, This is my beloved Son. For Jesus can neither be believed nor understood to be the Son of the Holy Spirit, or even His own Son. And where the voice uttered, I have both glorified, and will glorify again, we confess it was only the person of the Father; since it is the answer to that word of the Lord, in which He had said, Father, glorify your Son, which He could not say except to God the Father only, and not also to the Holy Spirit, whose Son He was not. But here, where it is written, And the Lord God said to Adam, no reason can be given why the Trinity itself should not be understood.

Similarly, in the passage that says "Now the Lord had said to Abraham, Get you out of your country, and from your kindred, and your father's house," it is not clear whether only a voice came to Abraham's ears or whether something also appeared to his eyes. But shortly afterward, it is stated somewhat more clearly, "And the Lord appeared unto Abraham, and said, Unto your seed will I give this land." Yet even there it is not explicitly stated in what form God appeared to him, or whether the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Spirit appeared to him. Perhaps some think it was the Son who appeared to Abraham because it is not written "God appeared to him" but "the Lord appeared to him." For the Son seems to be called the Lord as if that name belonged especially to Him, as for example the apostle says, "For though there be that are called gods, whether in heaven or in earth, (as there be gods many and lords many,) but to us there is but one God, the Father, of whom are all things, and we in Him; and one Lord Jesus Christ, by whom are all things, and we by Him." But since we find that God the Father is also called Lord in many places—for instance, "The Lord has said to me, You are my Son; this day have I begotten You"; and again, "The Lord said to my Lord, Sit at my right hand"; since also the Holy Spirit is found to be called Lord, as where the apostle says, "Now the Lord is that Spirit"; and then, lest anyone should think the Son is meant and is called the Spirit because of His incorporeal substance, he continues by saying, "And where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is liberty"; and no one ever doubted that the Spirit of the Lord is the Holy Spirit—therefore, even here it does not appear plainly whether it was any person of the Trinity that appeared to Abraham, or God Himself the Trinity, of which one God it is said, "You shall fear the Lord your God, and Him only shall you serve." But under the oak at Mamre he saw three men, whom he invited, hospitably received, and served as they ate. Yet Scripture at the beginning of that account does not say "three men appeared to him" but "The Lord appeared to him." And then, explaining in proper order how the Lord appeared to him, it adds the account of the three men, whom Abraham invites to his hospitality using the plural, and afterwards speaks to them in the singular as one person; and as one He promises him a son by Sarah, namely the one whom Scripture calls Lord, as at the beginning of the same account, "The Lord," it says, "appeared to Abraham." So he invites them, washes their feet, and escorts them at their departure as though they were men; but he speaks as with the Lord God, both when a son is promised to him and when the destruction about to come upon Sodom is shown to him.

19. Likewise, also, in that which is written, Now the Lord had said to Abraham, Get you out of your country, and from your kindred, and your father's house, it is not clear whether a voice alone came to the ears of Abraham, or whether anything also appeared to his eyes. But a little while after, it is somewhat more clearly said, And the Lord appeared unto Abraham, and said, Unto your seed will I give this land. But neither there is it expressly said in what form God appeared to him, or whether the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Spirit appeared to him. Unless, perhaps, they think that it was the Son who appeared to Abraham, because it is not written, God appeared to him, but the Lord appeared to him. For the Son seems to be called the Lord as though the name was appropriated to Him; as e.g. the apostle says, For though there be that are called gods, whether in heaven or in earth, (as there be gods many and lords many,) but to us there is but one God, the Father, of whom are all things, and we in Him; and one Lord Jesus Christ, by whom are all things, and we by Him. But since it is found that God the Father also is called Lord in many places — for instance, The Lord has said to me, You are my Son; this day have I begotten You; and again, The Lord said to my Lord, Sit at my right hand; since also the Holy Spirit is found to be called Lord, as where the apostle says, Now the Lord is that Spirit; and then, lest any one should think the Son to be signified, and to be called the Spirit on account of His incorporeal substance, has gone on to say, And where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is liberty; and no one ever doubted the Spirit of the Lord to be the Holy Spirit: therefore, neither here does it appear plainly whether it was any person of the Trinity that appeared to Abraham, or God Himself the Trinity, of which one God it is said, You shall fear the Lord your God, and Him only shall you serve. But under the oak at Mamre he saw three men, whom he invited, and hospitably received, and ministered to them as they feasted. Yet Scripture at the beginning of that narrative does not say, three men appeared to him, but, The Lord appeared to him. And then, setting forth in due order after what manner the Lord appeared to him, it has added the account of the three men, whom Abraham invites to his hospitality in the plural number, and afterwards speaks to them in the singular number as one; and as one He promises him a son by Sara, viz. the one whom the Scripture calls Lord, as in the beginning of the same narrative, The Lord, it says, appeared to Abraham. He invites them then, and washes their feet, and leads them forth at their departure, as though they were men; but he speaks as with the Lord God, whether when a son is promised to him, or when the destruction is shown to him that was impending over Sodom.

Chapter 11.– Of the Same Appearance.

That passage of Scripture requires neither a slight nor a passing consideration. For if one man had appeared, what else would those who say that the Son was visible also in His own substance before He was born of the Virgin immediately cry out, except that it was Himself? Since it is said, they argue, of the Father, "To the only invisible God." And yet I could still go on to ask, in what manner was He found in fashion as a man before He had taken our flesh, seeing that His feet were washed and that He fed upon earthly food? How could that be, when He was still in the form of God and thought it not robbery to be equal with God? For had He already emptied Himself, taking upon Him the form of a servant, and made in the likeness of men, and found in fashion as a man? We know when it was that He did this through His birth of the Virgin. How, then, before He had done this, did He appear as one man to Abraham? Or was that form not a reality? I could pose these questions if it had been one man who appeared to Abraham, and if that one were believed to be the Son of God. But since three men appeared, and no one of them is said to be greater than the rest either in form, or age, or power, why should we not understand here, as visibly indicated by the visible creature, the equality of the Trinity and one and the same substance in three persons?

20. That place of Scripture demands neither a slight nor a passing consideration. For if one man had appeared, what else would those at once cry out, who say that the Son was visible also in His own substance before He was born of the Virgin, but that it was Himself? Since it is said, they say, of the Father, To the only invisible God. And yet, I could still go on to demand, in what manner He was found in fashion as a man, before He had taken our flesh, seeing that his feet were washed, and that He fed upon earthly food? How could that be, when He was still in the form of God, and thought it not robbery to be equal with God? For, pray, had He already emptied Himself, taking upon Him the form of a servant, and made in the likeness of men, and found in fashion as a man? when we know when it was that He did this through His birth of the Virgin. How, then, before He had done this, did He appear as one man to Abraham? Or, was not that form a reality? I could put these questions, if it had been one man that appeared to Abraham, and if that one were believed to be the Son of God. But since three men appeared, and no one of them is said to be greater than the rest either in form, or age, or power, why should we not here understand, as visibly intimated by the visible creature, the equality of the Trinity, and one and the same substance in three persons?

For, in case anyone should think that one among the three was indicated to be the greater, and that this one should be understood to have been the Lord, the Son of God, while the other two were His angels (because, although three appeared, Abraham speaks to one as the Lord), Holy Scripture has not forgotten to anticipate such future thoughts and opinions by contradicting them. A little while after, Scripture says that two angels came to Lot, among whom that righteous man, who deserved to be freed from the burning of Sodom, also speaks to one as to the Lord. For Scripture continues to say, "And the Lord went His way, as soon as He left communing with Abraham; and Abraham returned to his place."

21. For, lest any one should think that one among the three is in this way intimated to have been the greater, and that this one is to be understood to have been the Lord, the Son of God, while the other two were His angels; because, whereas three appeared, Abraham there speaks to one as the Lord: Holy Scripture has not forgotten to anticipate, by a contradiction, such future cogitations and opinions, when a little while after it says that two angels came to Lot, among whom that just man also, who deserved to be freed from the burning of Sodom, speaks to one as to the Lord. For so Scripture goes on to say, And the Lord went His way, as soon as He left communing with Abraham; and Abraham returned to his place.

Chapter 12.– The Appearance to Lot is Examined.

But there came two angels to Sodom at even. Here, what I have begun to set forth must be considered more carefully. Certainly Abraham was speaking with three and called that one, in the singular, the Lord. Perhaps someone may say he recognized one of the three to be the Lord, but the other two His angels. What, then, does it mean when Scripture goes on to say, And the Lord went His way, as soon as He had left communing with Abraham; and Abraham returned to his place: and there came two angels to Sodom at even? Are we to suppose that the one who, among the three, was recognized as the Lord, had departed and had sent the two angels who were with Him to destroy Sodom? Let us see, then, what follows. There came, it is said, two angels to Sodom at even; and Lot sat in the gate of Sodom: and Lot seeing them, rose up to meet them; and he bowed himself with his face toward the ground; and he said, Behold now, my lords, turn in, I pray you, into your servant's house. Here it is clear both that there were two angels and that in the plural they were invited to receive hospitality, and that they were respectfully called lords, when they were perhaps thought to be men.

But there came two angels to Sodom at even. Here, what I have begun to set forth must be considered more attentively. Certainly Abraham was speaking with three, and called that one, in the singular number, the Lord. Perhaps, some one may say, he recognized one of the three to be the Lord, but the other two His angels. What, then, does that mean which Scripture goes on to say, And the Lord went His way, as soon as He had left communing with Abraham; and Abraham returned to his place: and there came two angels to Sodom at even? Are we to suppose that the one who, among the three, was recognized as the Lord, had departed, and had sent the two angels that were with Him to destroy Sodom? Let us see, then, what follows. There came, it is said, two angels to Sodom at even; and Lot sat in the gate of Sodom: and Lot seeing them, rose up to meet them; and he bowed himself with his face toward the ground; and he said, Behold now, my lords, turn in, I pray you, into your servant's house. Here it is clear, both that there were two angels, and that in the plural number they were invited to partake of hospitality, and that they were honorably designated lords, when they perchance were thought to be men.

Yet again, it is objected that unless they were known to be angels of God, Lot would not have bowed himself with his face to the ground. Why, then, is hospitality and food offered to them, as if they needed such human help? But whatever may be hidden here, let us now continue with what we have set out to do. Two appear; both are called angels; they are invited in the plural; he speaks with the two in the plural, until the departure from Sodom. And then Scripture goes on to say, And it came to pass, when they had brought them forth abroad, that they said, Escape for your life; look not behind you, neither stay in all the plain; escape to the mountain, and there you shall be saved, lest you be consumed. And Lot said to them, Oh! not so, my lord: behold now, your servant has found grace in your sight, etc. What does it mean that he says to them, Oh! not so, my lord, if He who was the Lord had already departed and had sent the angels? Why is it said, Oh! not so, my lord, and not, Oh! not so, my lords? Or if he wanted to speak to one of them, why does Scripture say, But Lot said to them, Oh! not so, my lord: behold now, your servant has found grace in your sight, etc.? Are we here also to understand two persons in the plural number, but when the two are addressed as one, then the one Lord God of one substance? But which two persons do we understand here—of the Father and of the Son, or of the Father and of the Holy Spirit, or of the Son and of the Holy Spirit? The last is perhaps more suitable, for they said of themselves that they were sent, which is what we say of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. For we find nowhere in the Scriptures that the Father was sent.

22. Yet, again, it is objected that except they were known to be angels of God, Lot would not have bowed himself with his face to the ground. Why, then, is both hospitality and food offered to them, as though they wanted such human succor? But whatever may here lie hidden, let us now pursue that which we have undertaken. Two appear; both are called angels; they are invited plurally; he speaks as with two plurally, until the departure from Sodom. And then Scripture goes on to say, And it came to pass, when they had brought them forth abroad, that they said, Escape for your life; look not behind you, neither stay in all the plain; escape to the mountain, and there you shall be saved, lest you be consumed. And Lot said to them, Oh! not so, my lord: behold now, your servant has found grace in your sight, etc. What is meant by his saying to them, Oh! not so, my lord, if He who was the Lord had already departed, and had sent the angels? Why is it said, Oh! not so, my lord, and not, Oh! not so, my lords? Or if he wished to speak to one of them, why does Scripture say, But Lot said to them, Oh! not so, my lord: behold now, your servant has found grace in your sight, etc.? Are we here, too, to understand two persons in the plural number, but when the two are addressed as one, then the one Lord God of one substance? But which two persons do we here understand?– of the Father and of the Son, or of the Father and of the Holy Spirit, or of the Son and of the Holy Spirit? The last, perhaps, is the more suitable; for they said of themselves that they were sent, which is that which we say of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. For we find nowhere in the Scriptures that the Father was sent.

Chapter 13.– The Appearance in the Bush.

When Moses was sent to lead the children of Israel out of Egypt, it is written that the Lord appeared to him this way: Moses was keeping the flock of his father-in-law Jethro, the priest of Midian, and he led the flock to the far side of the desert and came to the mountain of God, to Horeb. And the Angel of the Lord appeared to him in a flame of fire from the middle of a bush. He looked and saw that the bush was burning with fire, but the bush was not consumed. Moses said, "I will turn aside and see this great sight, why the bush is not burned." When the Lord saw that he turned aside to see, God called to him from the middle of the bush and said, "I am the God of your father, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob." Here also He is first called the Angel of the Lord, and then God. Was an angel, then, the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob? Therefore He may rightly be understood to be the Savior Himself, about whom the apostle says, "Whose are the fathers, and from whom according to the flesh Christ came, who is over all, God blessed forever." He, therefore, who is over all, God blessed forever, is reasonably understood here also to be Himself the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. But why is He previously called the Angel of the Lord when He appeared in a flame of fire from the bush? Was it because it was one of many angels who by an economy (a dispensation or arrangement) carried the prosopon of his Lord? Or was something from creation assumed by Him in order to bring about a visible appearance for the task at hand, and so that words might be audibly spoken from there, whereby the presence of the Lord might be shown in a fitting way to the bodily senses of man by means of the created order made subject? For if he was one of the angels, who could easily say whether it was the prosopon of the Son that was imposed upon him to announce, or that of the Holy Spirit, or that of God the Father, or altogether of the Trinity itself, who is the one and only God, so that he might say, "I am the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob"? For we cannot say that the Son of God is the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, but the Father is not; nor will anyone dare to deny that either the Holy Spirit or the Trinity itself, whom we believe and understand to be the one God, is the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. For whoever is not God is not the God of those fathers. Furthermore, if not only the Father is God, as everyone, even heretics, admit, but also the Son—which, whether they want to or not, they are compelled to acknowledge, since the apostle says, "who is over all, God blessed forever"—and the Holy Spirit—since the same apostle says, "Therefore glorify God in your body," after having said earlier, "Do you not know that your body is the temple of the Holy Spirit, which is in you, which you have from God?"—and these three are one God, as Catholic soundness believes, then it is not sufficiently clear which prosopon of the Trinity that angel carried, if he was one of the other angels, and whether any prosopon at all, rather than that of the Trinity itself. But if the creature was assumed for the purpose of the task at hand, in order both to appear to human eyes and to sound in human ears, and to be called the Angel of the Lord, and the Lord, and God, then God cannot here be understood to be the Father, but either the Son or the Holy Spirit. Although I cannot recall that the Holy Spirit is anywhere else called an angel, yet this may be understood from His work; for it is said of Him, "And He will show you things to come," and "angel" in Greek is certainly equivalent to "messenger" in Latin. But we read most clearly in the prophet that the Lord Jesus Christ is called the Angel of Great Counsel, while both the Holy Spirit and the Son of God is God and Lord of the angels.

23. But when Moses was sent to lead the children of Israel out of Egypt, it is written that the Lord appeared to him thus: Now Moses kept the flock of Jethro his father-in-law, the priest of Midian: and he led the flock to the back side of the desert, and came to the mountain of God, even to Horeb. And the Angel of the Lord appeared unto him in a flame of fire, out of the midst of a bush; and he looked, and, behold, the bush burned with fire, and the bush was not consumed. And Moses said, I will now turn aside, and see this great sight, why the bush is not burnt. And when the Lord saw that he turned aside to see, God called unto him out of the midst of the bush, and said, I am the God of your father, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob. He is here also first called the Angel of the Lord, and then God. Was an angel, then, the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob? Therefore He may be rightly understood to be the Saviour Himself, of whom the apostle says, Whose are the fathers, and of whom as concerning the flesh Christ came, who is over all, God blessed forever. He, therefore, who is over all, God blessed for ever, is not unreasonably here understood also to be Himself the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob. But why is He previously called the Angel of the Lord, when He appeared in a flame of fire out of the bush? Was it because it was one of many angels, who by an economy [or arrangement] bare the person of his Lord? Or was something of the creature assumed by Him in order to bring about a visible appearance for the business in hand, and that words might thence be audibly uttered, whereby the presence of the Lord might be shown, in such way as was fitting, to the corporeal senses of man, by means of the creature made subject? For if he was one of the angels, who could easily affirm whether it was the person of the Son which was imposed upon him to announce, or that of the Holy Spirit, or that of God the Father, or altogether of the Trinity itself, who is the one and only God, in order that he might say, I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob? For we cannot say that the Son of God is the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob, and that the Father is not; nor will any one dare to deny that either the Holy Spirit, or the Trinity itself, whom we believe and understand to be the one God, is the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob. For he who is not God, is not the God of those fathers. Furthermore, if not only the Father is God, as all, even heretics, admit; but also the Son, which, whether they will or not, they are compelled to acknowledge, since the apostle says, Who is over all, God blessed for ever; and the Holy Spirit, since the same apostle says, Therefore glorify God in your body; when he had said above, Do you not know that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost, which is in you, which you have of God? and these three are one God, as Catholic soundness believes: it is not sufficiently apparent which person of the Trinity that angel bare, if he was one of the rest of the angels, and whether any person, and not rather that of the Trinity itself. But if the creature was assumed for the purpose of the business in hand, whereby both to appear to human eyes, and to sound in human ears, and to be called the Angel of the Lord, and the Lord, and God; then cannot God here be understood to be the Father, but either the Son or the Holy Spirit. Although I cannot call to mind that the Holy Spirit is anywhere else called an angel, which yet may be understood from His work; for it is said of Him, And He will show you things to come; and angel in Greek is certainly equivalent to messenger in Latin: but we read most evidently of the Lord Jesus Christ in the prophet, that He is called the Angel of Great Counsel, while both the Holy Spirit and the Son of God is God and Lord of the angels.

Chapter 14.– Of the Appearance in the Pillar of Cloud and of Fire.

Also, regarding the departure of the children of Israel from Egypt, it is written, "And the Lord went before them, by day in a pillar of cloud to lead them the way, and by night in a pillar of fire. He took not away the pillar of cloud by day, nor the pillar of fire by night, from before the people." Here too, who would doubt that God appeared to the eyes of mortal human beings through the bodily creature made subject to Him, and not through His own substance? But it is not equally clear whether it was the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Spirit, or the Trinity itself, the one God. Nor is this distinguished in that passage either, in my judgment, where it is written, "The glory of the Lord appeared in the cloud," and "the Lord spoke unto Moses, saying, I have heard the murmurings of the children of Israel," and so forth.

24. Also in the going forth of the children of Israel from Egypt it is written, And the Lord went before them, by day in a pillar of cloud to lead them the way, and by night in a pillar of fire. He took not away the pillar of the cloud by day, nor the pillar of fire by night, from before the people. Who here, too, would doubt that God appeared to the eyes of mortal men by the corporeal creature made subject to Him, and not by His own substance? But it is not similarly apparent whether the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Spirit, or the Trinity itself, the one God. Nor is this distinguished there either, in my judgment, where it is written, The glory of the Lord appeared in the cloud, and the Lord spoke unto Moses, saying, I have heard the murmurings of the children of Israel, etc.

Chapter 15.– Of the Appearance on Sinai. Whether the Trinity Spoke in that Appearance or Some One Person Specially.

But now concerning the clouds, voices, lightning, trumpet, and smoke on Mount Sinai, when it was said, "And Mount Sinai was completely covered in smoke, because the Lord descended upon it in fire, and its smoke rose up like the smoke of a furnace; and all the people who were in the camp trembled; and when the sound of the trumpet grew long and louder and louder, Moses spoke, and God answered him with a voice." And a little later, after the Law had been given in the ten commandments, the text continues, "And all the people saw the thunder and the lightning and the noise of the trumpet and the mountain smoking." And a little after that, "And when the people saw it, they moved back and stood at a distance, and Moses drew near to the thick darkness where God was, and the Lord said to Moses," etc. What should I say about this, except that no one can be so foolish as to believe that the smoke, fire, cloud, darkness, and whatever else of this kind, were the ousia of the Word and Wisdom of God, which is Christ, or of the Holy Spirit? For not even the Arians ever dared to say that these were the ousia of God the Father. All these things, then, were produced through the created order serving the Creator, and were presented through a fitting dispensatio to human senses—unless perhaps, because it says, "And Moses drew near to the cloud where God was," fleshly thinking must insist that the cloud was indeed seen by the people, but that within the cloud Moses saw the Son of God with his physical eyes, whom foolish heretics insist can be seen in His own ousia. As if Moses could have seen Him with physical eyes, just as not only the wisdom of God which is Christ, but even the wisdom of any man, however wise, can be seen with physical eyes! Or as if, because it is written of the elders of Israel that they saw the place where the God of Israel had stood, and that under His feet there was something like a pavement of sapphire stone, and like the very appearance of heaven in its clearness, we must therefore believe that the Word and Wisdom of God in His own ousia stood within the boundaries of an earthly location—He who indeed reaches powerfully from end to end and orders all things graciously—and that the Word of God, through whom all things were made, is so changeable that He now contracts, now expands Himself (may the Lord cleanse the hearts of His faithful ones from such thoughts!). Rather, all these visible and perceptible things are, as we have often said, manifested through the created order made subject to God, in order to signify the invisible and intelligible God—not only the Father, but also the Son and the Holy Spirit, from whom are all things, and through whom are all things, and in whom are all things—even though the invisible things of God, from the creation of the world, are clearly seen, being understood through the things that are made, even His eternal power and divinity.

25. But now of the clouds, and voices, and lightnings, and the trumpet, and the smoke on Mount Sinai, when it was said, And Mount Sinai was altogether on a smoke, because the Lord descended upon it in fire, and the smoke thereof ascended as the smoke of a furnace; and all the people that was in the camp trembled; and when the voice of the trumpet sounded long and waxed louder and louder, Moses spoke, and God answered him by a voice. And a little after, when the Law had been given in the ten commandments, it follows in the text, And all the people saw the thunderings, and the lightnings, and the noise of the trumpet, and the mountain smoking. And a little after, And [when the people saw it,] they removed and stood afar off, and Moses drew near unto the thick darkness where God was, and the Lord said to Moses, etc. What shall I say about this, save that no one can be so insane as to believe the smoke, and the fire, and the cloud, and the darkness, and whatever there was of the kind, to be the substance of the word and wisdom of God which is Christ, or of the Holy Spirit? For not even the Arians ever dared to say that they were the substance of God the Father. All these things, then, were wrought through the creature serving the Creator, and were presented in a suitable economy ( dispensatio) to human senses; unless, perhaps, because it is said, And Moses drew near to the cloud where God was, carnal thoughts must needs suppose that the cloud was indeed seen by the people, but that within the cloud Moses with the eyes of the flesh saw the Son of God, whom doting heretics will have to be seen in His own substance. Forsooth, Moses may have seen Him with the eyes of the flesh, if not only the wisdom of God which is Christ, but even that of any man you please and howsoever wise, can be seen with the eyes of the flesh; or if, because it is written of the elders of Israel, that they saw the place where the God of Israel had stood, and that there was under His feet as it were a paved work of a sapphire stone, and as it were the body of heaven in his clearness, therefore we are to believe that the word and wisdom of God in His own substance stood within the space of an earthly place, who indeed reaches firmly from end to end, and sweetly orders all things; and that the Word of God, by whom all things were made, is in such wise changeable, as now to contract, now to expand Himself; (may the Lord cleanse the hearts of His faithful ones from such thoughts!) But indeed all these visible and sensible things are, as we have often said, exhibited through the creature made subject in order to signify the invisible and intelligible God, not only the Father, but also the Son and the Holy Spirit, of whom are all things, and through whom are all things, and in whom are all things; although the invisible things of God, from the creation of the world, are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even His eternal power and Godhead.

Regarding our present purpose, I don't see how all those things fearfully displayed to the senses of mortal people on Mount Sinai make it clear whether God the Trinity spoke, or the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Spirit individually. But if it's permissible to venture a modest and tentative guess about this passage without being rash, and if it's possible to understand it as referring to one person of the Trinity, why shouldn't we understand it to refer to the Holy Spirit? After all, the Law itself, which was given there, is said to have been written on stone tablets with the finger of God, and we know from the Gospel that this name signifies the Holy Spirit. Also, fifty days are counted from the slaying of the lamb and the celebration of Passover until the day when these things began to happen on Mount Sinai, just as fifty days are counted from our Lord's resurrection after his passion before the Holy Spirit came, whom the Son of God had promised. In that very coming of the Spirit, which we read about in the Acts of the Apostles, there appeared divided tongues like fire, and it sat upon each of them. This agrees with Exodus, where it says, "And Mount Sinai was altogether covered in smoke, because the Lord descended upon it in fire," and a little later it says, "And the sight of the glory of the Lord was like devouring fire on the top of the mountain in the eyes of the children of Israel." Or if these things happened because neither the Father nor the Son could be presented there in that manner without the Holy Spirit, by whom the Law itself had to be written, then we certainly know that God appeared there not by his own substance, which remains invisible and unchangeable, but through the previously mentioned appearance of the creature. But as far as I can understand, we don't see that some specific person of the Trinity appeared, distinguished by a particular identifying mark.

26. But as far as concerns our present undertaking, neither on Mount Sinai do I see how it appears, by all those things which were fearfully displayed to the senses of mortal men, whether God the Trinity spoke, or the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Spirit severally. But if it is allowable, without rash assertion, to venture upon a modest and hesitating conjecture from this passage, if it is possible to understand it of one person of the Trinity, why do we not rather understand the Holy Spirit to be spoken of, since the Law itself also, which was given there, is said to have been written upon tables of stone with the finger of God, by which name we know the Holy Spirit to be signified in the Gospel. And fifty days are numbered from the slaying of the lamb and the celebration of the Passover until the day in which these things began to be done in Mount Sinai; just as after the passion of our Lord fifty days are numbered from His resurrection, and then came the Holy Spirit which the Son of God had promised. And in that very coming of His, which we read of in the Acts of the Apostles, there appeared cloven tongues like as of fire, and it sat upon each of them: which agrees with Exodus, where it is written, And Mount Sinai was altogether on a smoke, because the Lord descended upon it in fire; and a little after, And the sight of the glory of the Lord, he says, was like devouring fire on the top of the mount in the eyes of the children of Israel. Or if these things were therefore wrought because neither the Father nor the Son could be there presented in that mode without the Holy Spirit, by whom the Law itself must needs be written; then we know doubtless that God appeared there, not by His own substance, which remains invisible and unchangeable, but by the appearance above mentioned of the creature; but that some special person of the Trinity appeared, distinguished by a proper mark, as far as my capacity of understanding reaches, we do not see.

Chapter 16.– In What Manner Moses Saw God.

There is another difficulty that troubles most people: it is written, "And the Lord spoke unto Moses face to face, as a man speaks unto his friend." Yet a little later, this same Moses says, "Now therefore, I pray You, if I have found grace in Your sight, show me now Yourself plainly, that I may see You, that I may find grace in Your sight, and that I may consider that this nation is Your people." And a little after that, Moses again said to the Lord, "Show me Your glory." What does this mean? In everything that was done, as mentioned above, God was thought to have appeared by His own substance (ousia). From this, these miserable people have believed that the Son of God is visible not through the creature, but by Himself. They think that when Moses entered into the cloud, he did so precisely so that a cloudy darkness would be shown to the people's eyes, but that Moses within would hear God's words as though he beheld His face. And as it says, "And the Lord spoke unto Moses face to face, as a man speaks unto his friend." Yet behold, this same Moses says, "If I have found grace in Your sight, show me Yourself plainly." Clearly he knew that he saw bodily, and he sought the true sight of God spiritually. That manner of speech which was conveyed in words was so arranged as if it were a friend speaking to a friend. Yet who sees God the Father with bodily eyes? And that Word which was in the beginning, the Word which was with God, the Word which was God, by which all things were made—who sees Him with bodily eyes? And who sees the spirit of wisdom with bodily eyes? Yet what does "Show me now Yourself plainly, that I may see You" mean, except "Show me Your substance (ousia)"? If Moses had not said this, we would indeed have to tolerate as best we could those foolish people who think that God's substance (ousia) was made visible to his eyes through those things which, as mentioned above, were said or done. But when it is demonstrated here most clearly that this was not granted to him, even though he desired it, who will dare to say that through the visible forms that appeared to him, not the creature serving God, but God Himself appeared to the eyes of a mortal man?

26. There is yet another difficulty which troubles most people, viz. that it is written, And the Lord spoke unto Moses face to face, as a man speaks unto his friend; whereas a little after, the same Moses says, Now therefore, I pray You, if I have found grace in Your sight, show me now Yourself plainly, that I may see You, that I may find grace in Your sight, and that I may consider that this nation is Your people; and a little after Moses again said to the Lord, Show me Your glory. What means this then, that in everything which was done, as above said, God was thought to have appeared by His own substance; whence the Son of God has been believed by these miserable people to be visible not by the creature, but by Himself; and that Moses, entering into the cloud, appeared to have had this very object in entering, that a cloudy darkness indeed might be shown to the eyes of the people, but that Moses within might hear the words of God, as though he beheld His face; and, as it is said, And the Lord spoke unto Moses face to face, as a man speaks unto his friend; and yet, behold, the same Moses says, If I have found grace in Your sight, show me Yourself plainly? Assuredly he knew that he saw corporeally, and he sought the true sight of God spiritually. And that mode of speech accordingly which was wrought in words, was so modified, as if it were of a friend speaking to a friend. Yet who sees God the Father with the eyes of the body? And that Word, which was in the beginning, the Word which was with God, the Word which was God, by which all things were made, — who sees Him with the eyes of the body? And the spirit of wisdom, again, who sees with the eyes of the body? Yet what is, Show me now Yourself plainly, that I may see You, unless, Show me Your substance? But if Moses had not said this, we must indeed have borne with those foolish people as we could, who think that the substance of God was made visible to his eyes through those things which, as above mentioned, were said or done. But when it is here demonstrated most evidently that this was not granted to him, even though he desired it; who will dare to say, that by the like forms which had appeared visibly to him also, not the creature serving God, but that itself which is God, appeared to the eyes of a mortal man?

Consider also what the Lord later said to Moses: "You cannot see my face, for no man shall see my face and live." And the Lord said, "Look, there is a place near me, and you will stand on a rock. When my glory passes by, I will put you in a cleft of the rock and cover you with my hand while I pass by. Then I will take away my hand, and you will see my back, but my face will not be seen."

28. Add, too, that which the Lord afterward said to Moses, You can not see my face: for there shall no man see my face, and live. And the Lord said, Behold, there is a place by me, and you shall stand upon a rock: and it shall come to pass, while my glory passes by, that I will put you into a watchtower of the rock, and will cover you with my hand while I pass by: and I will take away my hand, and you shall see my back parts; but my face shall not be seen.

Chapter 17.– How the Back Parts of God Were Seen. The Faith of the Resurrection of Christ. The Catholic Church Only is the Place from Whence the Back Parts of God are Seen. The Back Parts of God Were Seen by the Israelites. It is a Rash Opinion to Think that God the Father Only Was Never Seen by the Fathers.

It's commonly understood that this prefigures our Lord Jesus Christ: His back parts are taken to mean His flesh, in which He was born of the Virgin, died, and rose again. They are called back parts either because mortality came later, or because He chose to take on flesh near the end of the world, at a late period. But His face was that form of God, in which He thought it not robbery to be equal with God, which no one can certainly see and live. This is either because after this life, in which we are absent from the Lord and where the corruptible body weighs down the soul, we shall see face to face, as the apostle says—for it is said in the Psalms about this life, "Verily every man living is altogether vanity," and again, "For in Your sight shall no man living be justified," and also in this life, according to John, "It does not yet appear what we shall be, but we know that when He shall appear, we shall be like Him, for we shall see Him as He is," which he certainly meant to be understood as after this life, when we have paid the debt of death and received the promise of the resurrection. Or it may be that even now, to whatever degree we spiritually understand the wisdom of God, by which all things were made, to that same degree we die to carnal affections, so that considering this world dead to us, we also die to this world, and say what the apostle says: "The world is crucified unto me, and I unto the world." For it was of this death that he also says, "Wherefore, if you be dead with Christ, why as though living in the world are you subject to ordinances?" Not without cause, then, will no one be able to see the face, that is, the manifestation itself of the wisdom of God, and live. For it is this very appearance that everyone sighs for who strives to love God with all his heart, soul, and mind, and for whose contemplation he who loves his neighbor as himself also builds up his neighbor as much as he can. On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets. This is also signified in Moses himself. For when he said, because of the love of God with which he was specially inflamed, "If I have found grace in your sight, show me now Yourself plainly, that I may find grace in Your sight," he immediately added, because of the love also of his neighbor, "And that I may know that this nation is Your people." It is therefore that appearance which draws every rational soul with desire for it, and more ardently the purer that soul is. It is more pure the more it rises to spiritual things, and it rises more to spiritual things the more it dies to carnal things. But while we are absent from the Lord and walk by faith, not by sight, we ought to see the back parts of Christ, that is His flesh, by that very faith, standing on the solid foundation of faith, which the rock signifies, and beholding it from such a safe watchtower, namely in the Catholic Church, of which it is said, "And upon this rock I will build my Church." For the more certainly we love that face of Christ, which we earnestly desire to see, the more we recognize in His back parts how much Christ first loved us.

Not unfitly is it commonly understood to be prefigured from the person of our Lord Jesus Christ, that His back parts are to be taken to be His flesh, in which He was born of the Virgin, and died, and rose again; whether they are called back parts on account of the posteriority of mortality, or because it was almost in the end of the world, that is, at a late period, that He deigned to take it: but that His face was that form of God, in which He thought it not robbery to be equal with God, which no one certainly can see and live; whether because after this life, in which we are absent from the Lord, and where the corruptible body presses down the soul, we shall see face to face, as the apostle says — (for it is said in the Psalms, of this life, Verily every man living is altogether vanity; and again, For in Your sight shall no man living be justified; and in this life also, according to John, It does not yet appear what we shall be, but we know, he says, that when He shall appear, we shall be like Him, for we shall see Him as He is, which he certainly intended to be understood as after this life, when we shall have paid the debt of death, and shall have received the promise of the resurrection);– or whether that even now, in whatever degree we spiritually understand the wisdom of God, by which all things were made, in that same degree we die to carnal affections, so that, considering this world dead to us, we also ourselves die to this world, and say what the apostle says, The world is crucified unto me, and I unto the world. For it was of this death that he also says, Wherefore, if you be dead with Christ, why as though living in the world are you subject to ordinances? Not therefore without cause will no one be able to see the face, that is, the manifestation itself of the wisdom of God, and live. For it is this very appearance, for the contemplation of which every one sighs who strives to love God with all his heart, and with all his soul, and with all his mind; to the contemplation of which, he who loves his neighbor, too, as himself builds up his neighbor also as far as he may; on which two commandments hang all the law and the prophets. And this is signified also in Moses himself. For when he had said, on account of the love of God with which he was specially inflamed, If I have found grace in your sight, show me now Yourself plainly, that I may find grace in Your sight; he immediately subjoined, on account of the love also of his neighbor, And that I may know that this nation is Your people. It is therefore that appearance which hurries away every rational soul with the desire of it, and the more ardently the more pure that soul is; and it is the more pure the more it rises to spiritual things; and it rises the more to spiritual things the more it dies to carnal things. But while we are absent from the Lord, and walk by faith, not by sight, we ought to see the back parts of Christ, that is His flesh, by that very faith, that is, standing on the solid foundation of faith, which the rock signifies, and beholding it from such a safe watchtower, namely in the Catholic Church, of which it is said, And upon this rock I will build my Church. For so much the more certainly we love that face of Christ, which we earnestly desire to see, as we recognize in His back parts how much first Christ loved us.

But in the flesh itself, faith in His resurrection saves and justifies us. For scripture says, "If you believe in your heart that God has raised Him from the dead, you shall be saved," and again, "He was delivered for our offenses and was raised again for our justification." So the reward of our faith is the resurrection of the body of our Lord. For even His enemies believe that His flesh died on the cross of His passion, but they do not believe it rose again. We believe this most firmly and gaze upon it as if from the solid footing of a rock. From this position we wait with certain hope for the adoption, that is, the redemption of our body, because we hope for in the members of Christ—that is, in ourselves—what we acknowledge by sound faith to be already perfect in Him as in our Head. This is why He would not allow His back parts to be seen except as He passed by, so that His resurrection may be believed. For what is Pascha in Hebrew is translated Passover. This is also why the Evangelist John says, "Before the feast of the Passover, when Jesus knew that His hour had come that He should pass out of this world unto the Father."

29. But in the flesh itself, the faith in His resurrection saves and justifies us. For, If you shall believe, he says, in your heart, that God has raised Him from the dead, you shall be saved; and again, Who was delivered, he says, for our offenses, and was raised again for our justification. So that the reward of our faith is the resurrection of the body of our Lord. For even His enemies believe that that flesh died on the cross of His passion, but they do not believe it to have risen again. Which we believing most firmly, gaze upon it as from the solidity of a rock: whence we wait with certain hope for the adoption, to wit, the redemption of our body; because we hope for that in the members of Christ, that is, in ourselves, which by a sound faith we acknowledge to be perfect in Him as in our Head. Thence it is that He would not have His back parts seen, unless as He passed by, that His resurrection may be believed. For that which is Pascha in Hebrew, is translated Passover. Whence John the Evangelist also says, Before the feast of the Passover, when Jesus knew that His hour had come, that He should pass out of this world unto the Father.

However, those who believe this but do not believe it within the Catholic Church—instead believing it in some schism or heresy—do not see the back parts of the Lord from the place that is by Him. For what does the Lord mean when He says, "Behold, there is a place by me, and you shall stand upon a rock"? What earthly place is by the Lord, unless it is that which touches Him spiritually? For what place is not by the Lord, who reaches from one end to another mightily and sweetly orders all things, and of whom it is said, "Heaven is His throne, and earth is His footstool," and who said, "Where is the house that you build unto me, and where is the place of my rest? For has not my hand made all those things?" But clearly the Catholic Church itself is understood to be the place by Him, in which one stands upon a rock, where he healthfully sees the Pascha Domini, that is, the Passing by of the Lord, and His back parts, that is, His body, who believes in His resurrection. And He says, "You shall stand upon a rock while my glory passes by." For in reality, immediately after the majesty of the Lord had passed by in the glorification of the Lord—in which He rose again and ascended to the Father—we stood firm upon the rock. And Peter himself then stood firm, so that he preached Him with confidence, whom before he stood firm he had three times denied out of fear. Yet indeed he was already placed beforehand in predestination upon the watchtower of the rock, but with the hand of the Lord still held over him so that he might not yet see. For he was to see His back parts, and the Lord had not yet passed by—namely, from death to life—He had not yet been glorified by the resurrection.

30. But they who believe this, but believe it not in the Catholic Church, but in some schism or in heresy, do not see the back parts of the Lord from the place that is by Him. For what does that mean which the Lord says, Behold, there is a place by me, and you shall stand upon a rock? What earthly place is by the Lord, unless that is by Him which touches Him spiritually? For what place is not by the Lord, who reaches from one end to another mightily, and sweetly does order all things, and of whom it is said, Heaven is His throne, and earth is His footstool; and who said, Where is the house that you build unto me, and where is the place of my rest? For has not my hand made all those things? But manifestly the Catholic Church itself is understood to be the place by Him, wherein one stands upon a rock, where he healthfully sees the Pascha Domini, that is, the Passing by of the Lord, and His back parts, that is, His body, who believes in His resurrection. And you shall stand, He says, upon a rock while my glory passes by. For in reality, immediately after the majesty of the Lord had passed by in the glorification of the Lord, in which He rose again and ascended to the Father, we stood firm upon the rock. And Peter himself then stood firm, so that he preached Him with confidence, whom, before he stood firm, he had thrice from fear denied; although, indeed, already before placed in predestination upon the watchtower of the rock, but with the hand of the Lord still held over him that he might not see. For he was to see His back parts, and the Lord had not yet passed by, namely, from death to life; He had not yet been glorified by the resurrection.

For as to what follows in Exodus, "I will cover you with my hand while I pass by, and I will take away my hand and you shall see my back parts," many Israelites, of whom Moses was then a symbolic figure, believed in the Lord after His resurrection, as if His hand had been removed from their eyes and they now saw His back parts. This is why the evangelist also mentions that prophecy of Isaiah: "Make the heart of this people fat, and make their ears heavy, and shut their eyes." Finally, in the Psalm, what is said can reasonably be understood as spoken in their person: "For day and night Your hand was heavy upon me." By day, perhaps, when He performed obvious miracles yet was not recognized by them; but by night, when He died in suffering, when they thought even more certainly that, like any ordinary man, He was cut off and brought to an end. But since, when He had already passed by so that His back parts were seen, upon the Apostle Peter's preaching to them that it was necessary for Christ to suffer and rise again, they were pierced in their hearts with the grief of repentance, so that what is said at the beginning of that Psalm might come true among the baptized: "Blessed are they whose transgressions are forgiven, and whose sins are covered." Therefore, after it had been said, "Your hand is heavy upon me," the Lord, as it were passing by so that now He removed His hand and His back parts were seen, there follows the voice of one who grieves and confesses and receives forgiveness of sins by faith in the resurrection of the Lord: "My moisture," he says, "is turned into the drought of summer. I acknowledged my sin unto You, and mine iniquity have I not hidden. I said, I will confess my transgressions unto the Lord, and You forgave the iniquity of my sin." For we ought not to be so wrapped up in the darkness of the flesh as to think that the face of God is indeed invisible, but His back visible, since both appeared visibly in the form of a servant. But far be it from us to think anything of the kind in the form of God. Far be it from us to think that the Word of God and the Wisdom of God has a face on one side and a back on the other, as a human body does, or is at all changed either in place or time by any appearance or motion.

31. For as to that, too, which follows in Exodus, I will cover you with mine hand while I pass by, and I will take away my hand and you shall see my back parts; many Israelites, of whom Moses was then a figure, believed in the Lord after His resurrection, as if His hand had been taken off from their eyes, and they now saw His back parts. And hence the evangelist also mentions that prophesy of Isaiah, Make the heart of this people fat, and make their ears heavy, and shut their eyes. Lastly, in the Psalm, that is not unreasonably understood to be said in their person, For day and night Your hand was heavy upon me. By day, perhaps, when He performed manifest miracles, yet was not acknowledged by them; but by night, when He died in suffering, when they thought still more certainly that, like any one among men, He was cut off and brought to an end. But since, when He had already passed by, so that His back parts were seen, upon the preaching to them by the Apostle Peter that it behooved Christ to suffer and rise again, they were pricked in their hearts with the grief of repentance, that that might come to pass among the baptized which is said in the beginning of that Psalm, Blessed are they whose transgressions are forgiven, and whose sins are covered; therefore, after it had been said, Your hand is heavy upon me, the Lord, as it were, passing by, so that now He removed His hand, and His back parts were seen, there follows the voice of one who grieves and confesses and receives remission of sins by faith in the resurrection of the Lord: My moisture, he says, is turned into the drought of summer. I acknowledged my sin unto You, and mine iniquity have I not hid. I said, I will confess my transgressions unto the Lord, and You forgave the iniquity of my sin. For we ought not to be so wrapped up in the darkness of the flesh, as to think the face indeed of God to be invisible, but His back visible, since both appeared visibly in the form of a servant; but far be it from us to think anything of the kind in the form of God; far be it from us to think that the Word of God and the Wisdom of God has a face on one side, and on the other a back, as a human body has, or is at all changed either in place or time by any appearance or motion.

Therefore, if the Lord Jesus Christ was revealed in those words spoken in Exodus and in all those physical appearances, or if in some cases Christ was revealed (as examination of this passage convinces us) and in others the Holy Spirit (as what we said above indicates), it does not necessarily follow that God the Father never appeared in any such form to the Fathers. Many such appearances occurred in those times without the Father, Son, or Holy Spirit being explicitly named and identified in them, yet with certain indications given through quite plausible interpretations. Thus it would be too hasty to say that God the Father never appeared through any visible forms to the fathers or the prophets. This opinion arose among those who were unable to understand, regarding the unity of the Trinity, texts such as "Now unto the King eternal, immortal, invisible, the only wise God" and "Whom no man has seen, nor can see." These texts are understood by sound faith as referring to that very substance—the highest and most supremely divine and unchangeable—by which the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit is the one and only God. However, those visions were produced through the changeable creation, which is subject to the unchangeable God, and they did not reveal God properly as He is in Himself, but through signs suited to the particular circumstances and times of each event.

32. Wherefore, if in those words which were spoken in Exodus, and in all those corporeal appearances, the Lord Jesus Christ was manifested; or if in some cases Christ was manifested, as the consideration of this passage persuades us, in others the Holy Spirit, as that which we have said above admonishes us; at any rate no such result follows, as that God the Father never appeared in any such form to the Fathers. For many such appearances happened in those times, without either the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Spirit being expressly named and designated in them; but yet with some intimations given through certain very probable interpretations, so that it would be too rash to say that God the Father never appeared by any visible forms to the fathers or the prophets. For they gave birth to this opinion who were not able to understand in respect to the unity of the Trinity such texts as, Now unto the King eternal, immortal, invisible, the only wise God; and, Whom no man has seen, nor can see. Which texts are understood by a sound faith in that substance itself, the highest, and in the highest degree divine and unchangeable, whereby both the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit is the one and only God. But those visions were wrought through the changeable creature, made subject to the unchangeable God, and did not manifest God properly as He is, but by intimations such as suited the causes and times of the several circumstances.

Chapter 18.– The Vision of Daniel.

I do not know how these men understand that the Ancient of Days appeared to Daniel, from whom the Son of man—which He chose to become for our sake—is understood to have received the kingdom; that is, from Him who says to Him in the Psalms, "You are my Son; this day have I begotten You; ask of me, and I shall give You the heathen for Your inheritance," and who has put all things under His feet. However, if both the Father giving the kingdom and the Son receiving it appeared to Daniel in bodily form, how can those men say that the Father never appeared to the prophets, and therefore that He alone ought to be understood to be invisible whom no man has seen, nor can see? For Daniel has told us this: "I beheld," he says, "till the thrones were set, and the Ancient of Days did sit, whose garment was white as snow, and the hair of His head like the pure wool: His throne was like the fiery flame, and His wheels as burning fire; a fiery stream issued and came forth from before Him: thousand thousands ministered unto Him, and ten thousand times ten thousand stood before Him: the judgment was set, and the books were opened," and so on. And a little later, "I saw," he says, "in the night visions, and behold, one like the Son of man came with the clouds of heaven, and came to the Ancient of Days, and they brought Him near before Him. And there was given Him dominion, and glory, and a kingdom, that all peoples, nations, and languages should serve Him: His dominion is an everlasting dominion, which shall not pass away, and His kingdom that which shall not be destroyed." Here we see the Father giving and the Son receiving an eternal kingdom, and both are in the sight of the one who prophesies, in a visible form. Therefore, it is not unreasonable to believe that God the Father also customarily appeared in that manner to mortals.

33. I do not know in what manner these men understand that the Ancient of Days appeared to Daniel, from whom the Son of man, which He deigned to be for our sakes, is understood to have received the kingdom; namely, from Him who says to Him in the Psalms, You are my Son; this day have I begotten You; ask of me, and I shall give You the heathen for Your inheritance; and who has put all things under His feet. If, however, both the Father giving the kingdom, and the Son receiving it, appeared to Daniel in bodily form, how can those men say that the Father never appeared to the prophets, and, therefore, that He only ought to be understood to be invisible whom no man has seen, nor can see? For Daniel has told us thus: I beheld, he says, till the thrones were set, and the Ancient of Days did sit, whose garment was white as snow, and the hair of His head like the pure wool: His throne was like the fiery flame, and His wheels as burning fire; a fiery stream issued and came forth from before Him: thousand thousands ministered unto Him, and ten thousand times ten thousand stood before Him: the judgment was set, and the books were opened, etc. And a little after, I saw, he says, in the night visions, and behold, one like the Son of man came with the clouds of heaven, and came to the Ancient of Days, and they brought Him near before Him. And there was given Him dominion, and glory, and a kingdom, that all peoples, nations, and languages should serve Him: His dominion is an everlasting dominion, which shall not pass away, and His kingdom that which shall not be destroyed. Behold the Father giving, and the Son receiving, an eternal kingdom; and both are in the sight of him who prophesies, in a visible form. It is not, therefore, unsuitably believed that God the Father also was wont to appear in that manner to mortals.

Unless, perhaps, someone might say that the Father is not visible because He appeared in a vision to someone who was dreaming, but that the Son and the Holy Spirit are visible because Moses saw all those things while awake. As if Moses actually saw the Word and Wisdom of God with physical eyes! Or as if even the human spirit that gives life to the flesh can be seen, or even that physical thing called wind—how much less can the Spirit of God be seen, who surpasses the minds of all people and angels by the ineffable excellence of the divine substance? Or can anyone fall into such error as to dare say that the Son and the Holy Spirit are visible even to people who are awake, but that the Father is visible only to those who dream? How, then, would they understand that statement about the Father alone: "Whom no man has seen, nor can see"? When people sleep, are they suddenly not human? Or cannot He who can create the likeness of a body to represent Himself through the visions of dreamers also create that same bodily form to represent Himself to the eyes of those who are awake? His own very substance, by which He Himself is what He is, cannot be shown by any bodily likeness to one who sleeps or by any bodily appearance to one who is awake—and this applies not only to the Father, but also to the Son and to the Holy Spirit. And certainly, as for those who are persuaded by the visions of waking people to believe that not the Father, but only the Son or the Holy Spirit, appeared to the physical sight of human beings—setting aside the great extent of the sacred writings and their many interpretations, which mean that no one of sound reason should claim that the person of the Father was never shown to the eyes of waking people by any bodily appearance—but, as I said, setting this aside, what do they say about our father Abraham, who was certainly awake and serving when, after Scripture had stated, "The Lord appeared unto Abraham," not one or two, but three men appeared to him? None of these is said to have stood out above the others, none to have shone with greater glory than the others, or to have acted more authoritatively.

34. Unless, perhaps, some one shall say, that the Father is therefore not visible, because He appeared within the sight of one who was dreaming; but that therefore the Son and the Holy Spirit are visible, because Moses saw all those things being awake; as if, forsooth, Moses saw the Word and the Wisdom of God with fleshly eyes, or that even the human spirit which quickens that flesh can be seen, or even that corporeal thing which is called wind — how much less can that Spirit of God be seen, who transcends the minds of all men, and of angels, by the ineffable excellence of the divine substance? Or can any one fall headlong into such an error as to dare to say, that the Son and the Holy Spirit are visible also to men who are awake, but that the Father is not visible except to those who dream? How, then, do they understand that of the Father alone, Whom no man has seen, nor can see.? When men sleep, are they then not men? Or cannot He, who can fashion the likeness of a body to signify Himself through the visions of dreamers, also fashion that same bodily creature to signify Himself to the eyes of those who are awake? Whereas His own very substance, whereby He Himself is that which He is, cannot be shown by any bodily likeness to one who sleeps, or by any bodily appearance to one who is awake; but this not of the Father only, but also of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. And certainly, as to those who are moved by the visions of waking men to believe that not the Father, but only the Son, or the Holy Spirit, appeared to the corporeal sight of men — to omit the great extent of the sacred pages, and their manifold interpretation, such that no one of sound reason ought to affirm that the person of the Father was nowhere shown to the eyes of waking men by any corporeal appearance — but, as I said, to omit this, what do they say of our father Abraham, who was certainly awake and ministering, when, after Scripture had premised, The Lord appeared unto Abraham, not one, or two, but three men appeared to him; no one of whom is said to have stood prominently above the others, no one more than the others to have shone with greater glory, or to have acted more authoritatively?

Since we set out in our three-part investigation to examine whether it was the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Spirit, or whether sometimes the Father, sometimes the Son, sometimes the Holy Spirit, or whether—without any distinction of persons—the one and only God (that is, the Trinity itself) who appeared to the fathers through those created forms, we have now examined as many passages of Holy Scripture as seemed sufficient. A modest and cautious consideration of divine mysteries leads us, as far as I can tell, to this conclusion: we must not rashly declare which person of the Trinity appeared to any particular father or prophet in some bodily form or bodily likeness, unless the context of the narrative provides some clear indication on the matter. For the nature itself, or substance, or essence, or whatever other name we should use for that very thing which is God, cannot be seen with bodily eyes. However, we must believe that through the creature subject to Him, not only the Son or the Holy Spirit, but also the Father, may have revealed Himself to mortal senses through a bodily form or likeness. Since this is how things stand, let us consider what remains in the books that follow, so that this second book does not grow to an excessive length.

35. Wherefore, since in that our threefold division we determined to inquire, first, whether the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Spirit; or whether sometimes the Father, sometimes the Son, sometimes the Holy Spirit; or whether, without any distinction of persons, as it is said, the one and only God, that is, the Trinity itself, appeared to the fathers through those forms of the creature: now that we have examined, so far as appeared to be sufficient what places of the Holy Scriptures we could, a modest and cautious consideration of divine mysteries leads, as far as I can judge, to no other conclusion, unless that we may not rashly affirm which person of the Trinity appeared to this or that of the fathers or the prophets in some body or likeness of body, unless when the context attaches to the narrative some probable intimations on the subject. For the nature itself, or substance, or essence, or by whatever other name that very thing, which is God, whatever it be, is to be called, cannot be seen corporeally: but we must believe that by means of the creature made subject to Him, not only the Son, or the Holy Spirit, but also the Father, may have given intimations of Himself to mortal senses by a corporeal form or likeness. And since the case stands thus, that this second book may not extend to an immoderate length, let us consider what remains in those which follow.


On the Trinity — Book I

Father, Son and Holy Spirit are one God of one substance; Augustine answers the Scripture passages that seem to make the Son less than the Father.

Source: Translated by Arthur West Haddan. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 3. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1887. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/130101.htm>.

Contents · 14 chapters
  1. Introduction
  2. Chapter 1.– This Work is Written Against Those Who Sophistically Assail the Faith of the Trinity, Through Misuse of Reason. They Who Dispute Concerning God Err from a Threefold Cause. Holy Scripture, Removing What is False, Leads Us on by Degrees to Things Divine. What True Immortality is. We are Nourished by Faith, that We May Be Enabled to Apprehend Things Divine.
  3. Chapter 2.– In What Manner This Work Proposes to Discourse Concerning the Trinity.
  4. Chapter 3.– What Augustine Requests from His Readers. The Errors of Readers Dull of Comprehension Not to Be Ascribed to the Author.
  5. Chapter 4.– What the Doctrine of the Catholic Faith is Concerning the Trinity.
  6. Chapter 5.– Of Difficulties Concerning the Trinity: in What Manner Three are One God, and How, Working Indivisibly, They Yet Perform Some Things Severally.
  7. Chapter 6.– That the Son is Very God, of the Same Substance with the Father. Not Only the Father, But the Trinity, is Affirmed to Be Immortal. All Things are Not from the Father Alone, But Also from the Son. That the Holy Spirit is Very God, Equal with the Father and the Son.
  8. Chapter 7.– In What Manner the Son is Less Than the Father, and Than Himself.
  9. Chapter 8.– The Texts of Scripture Explained Respecting the Subjection of the Son to the Father, Which Have Been Misunderstood. Christ Will Not So Give Up the Kingdom to the Father, as to Take It Away from Himself. The Beholding Him is the Promised End of All Actions. The Holy Spirit is Sufficient to Our Blessedness Equally with the Father.
  10. Chapter 9.– All are Sometimes Understood in One Person.
  11. Chapter 10.– In What Manner Christ Shall Deliver Up the Kingdom to God, Even the Father. The Kingdom Having Been Delivered to God, Even the Father, Christ Will Not Then Make Intercession for Us.
  12. Chapter 11.– By What Rule in the Scriptures It is Understood that the Son is Now Equal and Now Less.
  13. Chapter 12.– In What Manner the Son is Said Not to Know the Day and the Hour Which the Father Knows. Some Things Said of Christ According to the Form of God, Other Things According to the Form of a Servant. In What Way It is of Christ to Give the Kingdom, in What Not of Christ. Christ Will Both Judge and Not Judge.
  14. Chapter 13.– Diverse Things are Spoken Concerning the Same Christ, on Account of the Diverse Natures of the One Hypostasis [Theanthropic Person]. Why It is Said that the Father Will Not Judge, But Has Given Judgment to the Son.

Introduction

In the Retractations (ii. 15) Augustine describes this work in the following way:

In the Retractations (ii. 15) Augustine speaks of this work in the following terms:–

I spent several years writing fifteen books about the Trinity, which is God. However, when I had not yet finished the thirteenth book, some people who were extremely eager to have the work were being made to wait longer than they could endure, and it was stolen from me in a less polished state than it either could have been or would have been if it had been published when I intended. As soon as I discovered this, since I had other copies of it, I had initially decided not to publish it myself, but instead to mention what had happened in some other work. However, at the urgent request of fellow believers whom I could not refuse, I corrected it as much as I thought appropriate, and finished and published it, adding at the beginning a letter that I had written to the venerable Aurelius, Bishop of Carthage, in which I explained, by way of introduction, what had happened, what I had originally intended to do, and what the love of my fellow believers had compelled me to do.

I spent some years in writing fifteen books concerning the Trinity, which is God . When, however, I had not yet finished the thirteenth Book, and some who were exceedingly anxious to have the work were kept waiting longer than they could bear, it was stolen from me in a less correct state than it either could or would have been had it appeared when I intended. And as soon as I discovered this, having other copies of it, I had determined at first not to publish it myself, but to mention what had happened in the matter in some other work; but at the urgent request of brethren, whom I could not refuse, I corrected it as much as I thought fit, and finished and published it, with the addition, at the beginning, of a letter that I had written to the venerable Aurelius, Bishop of Carthage , in which I set forth, in the way of prologue, what had happened, what I had intended to do of myself, and what love of my brethren had forced me to do.

The letter he refers to here is as follows:

The letter to which he here alludes is the following:–

To the most blessed Lord, whom he respects with entirely genuine love, to his holy brother and fellow priest, Pope Aurelius, Augustine sends greetings in the Lord. I began as a very young man, and have published in my old age, some books concerning the Trinity, who is the supreme and true God. I had actually set the work aside when I discovered that it had been prematurely, or rather secretly, stolen from me before I had completed it and before I had revised and finished it as I had planned. I had not intended to publish the books one by one, but all at once, since the development of the investigation led me to add the later books to the ones that came before them. When these people prevented the fulfillment of my plan (because some of them had gained access to the work before I intended), I had stopped dictating it, intending to make my complaint public in some other work I might write, so that whoever could might know that the books had not been published by me but had been taken from my possession before they were in my own judgment ready for publication. However, compelled by the urgent requests of many of my brothers, and especially by your command, I have taken the trouble, with God's help, to complete the work, laborious as it is. As now corrected (not as I wished, but as I could, so that the books would not differ too greatly from those that had secretly gotten into people's hands), I have sent them to your Reverence through my very dear son and fellow deacon, and have allowed them to be heard, copied, and read by anyone who wishes. Certainly, if I could have carried out my original plan, although they would have contained the same ideas, they would have been worked out much more thoroughly and clearly, as far as the difficulty of explaining so profound a subject, and as far as my own abilities, might have permitted. There are some people, however, who have the first four, or rather five, books without the prefaces, and the twelfth with a considerable part of its later chapters missing. But these people, if they wish and are able, will correct the whole if they become familiar with the present edition. In any case, I must ask that you order this letter to be placed separately, but at the beginning of the books. Farewell. Pray for me.

To the most blessed Lord, whom he reveres with most sincere love , to his holy brother and fellow priest , Pope Aurelius, Augustine sends health in the Lord. I began as a very young man, and have published in my old age, some books concerning the Trinity, who is the supreme and true God. I had in truth laid the work aside, upon discovering that it had been prematurely, or rather surreptitiously, stolen from me before I had completed it, and before I had revised and put the finishing touches to it, as had been my intention. For I had not designed to publish the Books one by one, but all together, inasmuch as the progress of the inquiry led me to add the later ones to those which precede them. When, therefore, these people had hindered the fulfillment of my purpose (in that some of them had obtained access to the work before I intended), I had given over dictating it, with the idea of making my complaint public in some other work that I might write, in order that whoever could might know that the Books had not been published by myself, but had been taken away from my possession before they were in my own judgment fit for publication. Compelled, however, by the eager demands of many of my brethren, and above all by your command, I have taken the pains, by God's help, to complete the work, laborious as it is; and as now corrected (not as I wished, but as I could, lest the Books should differ very widely from those which had surreptitiously got into people's hands), I have sent them to your Reverence by my very dear son and fellow deacon , and have allowed them to be heard, copied, and read by every one that pleases. Doubtless, if I could have fulfilled my original intention, although they would have contained the same sentiments, they would have been worked out much more thoroughly and clearly, so far as the difficulty of unfolding so profound a subject, and so far, too, as my own powers, might have allowed. There are some persons , however, who have the first four, or rather five, Books without the prefaces, and the twelfth with no small part of its later chapters omitted. But these, if they please and can, will amend the whole, if they become acquainted with the present edition. At any rate, I have to request that you will order this letter to be prefixed separately, but at the beginning of the Books. Farewell. Pray for me.

Chapter 1.– This Work is Written Against Those Who Sophistically Assail the Faith of the Trinity, Through Misuse of Reason. They Who Dispute Concerning God Err from a Threefold Cause. Holy Scripture, Removing What is False, Leads Us on by Degrees to Things Divine. What True Immortality is. We are Nourished by Faith, that We May Be Enabled to Apprehend Things Divine.

This discussion about the Trinity, as the reader should know, has been written to guard against the clever arguments of those who refuse to begin with faith and are misled by an immature and twisted love of reasoning. One group of such people tries to apply ideas they have formed about physical things—whether through bodily sense experience, natural human intelligence and careful observation, or through systematic study—to things that are incorporeal and spiritual. They try to measure and understand the latter by means of the former. A second group forms whatever thoughts they have about God based on the nature or experiences of the human mind, and because of this mistake, they guide their arguments about God using distorted and deceptive rules. A third group does try to rise above the entire created order, which is certainly changeable, in order to lift their thinking to the unchangeable substance, which is God. But they are weighed down by the burden of mortality, and while they seem to want to know what they do not know and cannot know what they want to know, they block themselves from the very path of understanding through an overly bold assertion of their own presumptuous judgments. They would rather not correct their opinion when it is wrong than change what they have already defended. This is actually the common problem of all three groups I have mentioned—those who think about God based on physical things, those who do so based on the spiritual creature such as the soul, and those who consider neither the body nor the spiritual creature yet still think falsely about God. These last are even further from the truth because nothing corresponding to their ideas can be found either in the body, in the made or created spirit, or in the Creator himself. For example, whoever thinks that God is white or red is wrong, even though these things are found in the body. Likewise, whoever thinks of God as sometimes forgetting and sometimes remembering, or anything similar, is equally wrong, even though these things are found in the mind. But whoever thinks that God is so powerful as to have generated himself is even more wrong, because not only does God not exist in this way, but neither does the spiritual nor the bodily creature—for there is nothing at all that generates its own existence.

1. The following dissertation concerning the Trinity, as the reader ought to be informed, has been written in order to guard against the sophistries of those who disdain to begin with faith , and are deceived by a crude and perverse love of reason. Now one class of such men endeavor to transfer to things incorporeal and spiritual the ideas they have formed, whether through experience of the bodily senses, or by natural human wit and diligent quickness, or by the aid of art, from things corporeal; so as to seek to measure and conceive of the former by the latter. Others, again, frame whatever sentiments they may have concerning God according to the nature or affections of the human mind; and through this error they govern their discourse, in disputing concerning God , by distorted and fallacious rules. While yet a third class strive indeed to transcend the whole creation, which doubtless is changeable, in order to raise their thought to the unchangeable substance, which is God ; but being weighed down by the burden of mortality, while they both would seem to know what they do not, and cannot know what they would, preclude themselves from entering the very path of understanding, by an over-bold affirmation of their own presumptuous judgments; choosing rather not to correct their own opinion when it is perverse, than to change that which they have once defended. And, indeed, this is the common disease of all the three classes which I have mentioned — viz. , both of those who frame their thoughts of God according to things corporeal, and of those who do so according to the spiritual creature, such as is the soul ; and of those who neither regard the body nor the spiritual creature, and yet think falsely about God ; and are indeed so much the further from the truth , that nothing can be found answering to their conceptions, either in the body, or in the made or created spirit, or in the Creator Himself. For he who thinks, for instance, that God is white or red, is in error ; and yet these things are found in the body. Again, he who thinks of God as now forgetting and now remembering, or anything of the same kind, is none the less in error ; and yet these things are found in the mind . But he who thinks that God is of such power as to have generated Himself, is so much the more in error , because not only does God not so exist, but neither does the spiritual nor the bodily creature; for there is nothing whatever that generates its own existence .

To purify the human mind from errors of this kind, Holy Scripture has adapted itself to those who are immature. It has not avoided using words drawn from any category of things that actually exist, through which, like food, our understanding might gradually rise to divine and transcendent realities. When speaking of God, Scripture has used words taken from physical things, as when it says, "Hide me under the shadow of Your wings." It has also borrowed many things from the spiritual creation to signify what is not literally true but must be expressed this way—for example, "I the Lord your God am a jealous God" and "It repents me that I have made man." However, Scripture has drawn no words at all, whether for figures of speech or mysterious sayings, from things that do not exist whatsoever. This is why those who are blocked from the truth by this third type of error are more harmfully and emptily foolish than others, since they imagine things about God that can be found neither in Him nor in any creature. Divine Scripture customarily creates, as it were, attractions for children from things found in creation, by which the affections of the weak may be moved, according to their capacity and as if by steps, to seek what is above and leave what is below. But this same Scripture rarely uses things that are spoken properly of God alone and are not found in any creature—for instance, what was said to Moses: "I am that I am" and "I Am has sent me to you." Since both body and soul are also said in some sense to be, Holy Scripture certainly would not express itself this way unless it meant to be understood in some special sense. Similarly, what the Apostle says: "Who only has immortality." Since the soul is also said to be, and is, in a certain manner immortal, Scripture would not say "only has" unless true immortality is unchangeableness, which no creature can possess since it belongs to the creator alone. Likewise James says, "Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above, and comes down from the Father of Lights, with whom is no variableness, neither shadow of turning." And David says, "You shall change them, and they shall be changed; but You are the same."

2. In order, therefore, that the human mind might be purged from falsities of this kind, Holy Scripture , which suits itself to babes has not avoided words drawn from any class of things really existing, through which, as by nourishment, our understanding might rise gradually to things divine and transcendent. For, in speaking of God , it has both used words taken from things corporeal, as when it says, Hide me under the shadow of Your wings; and it has borrowed many things from the spiritual creature, whereby to signify that which indeed is not so, but must needs so be said: as, for instance, I the Lord your God am a jealous God ; and, It repents me that I have made man. But it has drawn no words whatever, whereby to frame either figures of speech or enigmatic sayings, from things which do not exist at all. And hence it is that they who are shut out from the truth by that third kind of error are more mischievously and emptily vain than their fellows; in that they surmise respecting God , what can neither be found in Himself nor in any creature. For divine Scripture is wont to frame, as it were, allurements for children from the things which are found in the creature; whereby, according to their measure, and as it were by steps, the affections of the weak may be moved to seek those things that are above, and to leave those things that are below. But the same Scripture rarely employs those things which are spoken properly of God , and are not found in any creature; as, for instance, that which was said to Moses , I am that I am; and, I Am has sent me to you. For since both body and soul also are said in some sense to be , Holy Scripture certainly would not so express itself unless it meant to be understood in some special sense of the term. So, too, that which the Apostle says, Who only has immortality . Since the soul also both is said to be, and is, in a certain manner immortal , Scripture would not say only has, unless because true immortality is unchangeableness; which no creature can possess, since it belongs to the creator alone. So also James says, Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above, and comes down from the Father of Lights, with whom is no variableness, neither shadow of turning. So also David, You shall change them, and they shall be changed; but You are the same.

It is difficult to contemplate and fully grasp the substance of God, who fashions changeable things without any change in Himself, and creates temporal things without any temporal movement in Himself. Therefore, we must purge our minds to be able to see ineffably that which is ineffable. Since we have not yet reached this point, we need to be nourished by faith and led along paths better suited to our capacity, so that we may become fit and able to comprehend it. This is why the Apostle says that all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge are indeed hidden in Christ. Yet he presented Christ to those who were babes in Christ—people already born again by His grace but still carnal and psychical—not through that divine virtue by which He is equal to the Father, but through that human weakness by which He was crucified. For Paul says, I determined not to know anything among you, save Jesus Christ and Him crucified, and then continues, And I was with you in weakness, and in fear, and in much trembling. Shortly afterward he tells them, And I, brethren, could not speak unto you as unto spiritual, but as unto carnal, even as unto babes in Christ. I have fed you with milk, and not with meat: for hitherto you were not able to bear it, neither yet now are you able. Some people become angry at this kind of language and think it is meant to insult them. They mostly prefer to believe that those who speak this way have nothing to say, rather than accept that they themselves cannot understand what has been said. Sometimes we do present to them not the full explanation they seek in their inquiries about God—because neither can they receive it, nor can we perhaps fully grasp or express it ourselves—but rather an explanation that demonstrates to them how incapable and completely unfit they are to understand what they are asking of us. But because they do not hear what they want, they think we are either deceiving them to hide our own ignorance or speaking maliciously because we begrudge them knowledge. And so they leave angry and upset.

3. Further, it is difficult to contemplate and fully know the substance of God ; who fashions things changeable, yet without any change in Himself, and creates things temporal, yet without any temporal movement in Himself. And it is necessary, therefore, to purge our minds, in order to be able to see ineffably that which is ineffable; whereto not having yet attained, we are to be nourished by faith , and led by such ways as are more suited to our capacity, that we may be rendered apt and able to comprehend it. And hence the Apostle says, that in Christ indeed are hid all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge ; and yet has commended Him to us, as to babes in Christ , who, although already born again by His grace , yet are still carnal and psychical, not by that divine virtue wherein He is equal to the Father , but by that human infirmity whereby He was crucified. For he says, I determined not to know anything among you, save Jesus Christ and Him crucified; and then he continues, And I was with you in weakness, and in fear , and in much trembling. And a little after he says to them, And I, brethren, could not speak unto you as unto spiritual, but as unto carnal, even as unto babes in Christ . I have fed you with milk, and not with meat: for hitherto you were not able to bear it, neither yet now are you able. There are some who are angry at language of this kind, and think it is used in slight to themselves, and for the most part prefer rather to believe that they who so speak to them have nothing to say, than that they themselves cannot understand what they have said. And sometimes, indeed, we do allege to them, not certainly that account of the case which they seek in their inquiries about God — because neither can they themselves receive it, nor can we perhaps either apprehend or express it — but such an account of it as to demonstrate to them how incapable and utterly unfit they are to understand that which they require of us. But they, on their parts, because they do not hear what they desire, think that we are either playing them false in order to conceal our own ignorance , or speaking in malice because we grudge them knowledge ; and so go away indignant and perturbed.

Chapter 2.– In What Manner This Work Proposes to Discourse Concerning the Trinity.

With the Lord our God helping us, we will attempt to explain, as far as we are able, the very thing they so insistently demand: namely, that the Trinity is the one and only true God, and also how the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit are rightly said, believed, and understood to be of one and the same substance or ousia, so that they cannot imagine we are putting them off with excuses, but may discover through actual experience both that the highest good is perceived only by the most purified minds, and that for this reason they themselves cannot perceive or understand it, because the eye of the human mind, being weak, is overwhelmed in such overwhelming light unless it is strengthened by the nourishment of the righteousness of faith. First, however, we must demonstrate according to the authority of the Holy Scriptures whether the faith is indeed so. Then, if God is willing and helps us, we may perhaps serve these talkative debaters—more prideful than capable, and therefore suffering from a more dangerous disease—well enough to enable them to find something they cannot doubt, so that when they cannot find the same clarity elsewhere, they may recognize the fault lies in their own minds rather than in the truth itself or in our arguments. In this way, if they have any love or fear of God in them, they may turn back and begin from faith in proper order, finally understanding how beneficial a remedy has been provided for the faithful in the holy Church, by which careful piety, healing the weakness of the mind, may make it able to perceive the unchangeable truth and prevent it from falling headlong through reckless disorder into destructive and false opinion. I myself will not shrink from investigation if I am uncertain about anything, nor be ashamed to learn if I am wrong about anything.

4. Wherefore, our Lord God helping, we will undertake to render, as far as we are able, that very account which they so importunately demand: viz ., that the Trinity is the one and only and true God , and also how the Father , the Son , and the Holy Spirit are rightly said, believed , understood, to be of one and the same substance or essence ; in such wise that they may not fancy themselves mocked by excuses on our part, but may find by actual trial, both that the highest good is that which is discerned by the most purified minds, and that for this reason it cannot be discerned or understood by themselves, because the eye of the human mind , being weak, is dazzled in that so transcendent light, unless it be invigorated by the nourishment of the righteousness of faith . First, however, we must demonstrate, according to the authority of the Holy Scriptures , whether the faith be so. Then, if God be willing and aid us, we may perhaps at least so far serve these talkative arguers — more puffed up than capable, and therefore laboring under the more dangerous disease — as to enable them to find something which they are not able to doubt , that so, in that case where they cannot find the like, they may be led to lay the fault to their own minds, rather than to the truth itself or to our reasonings; and thus, if there be anything in them of either love or fear towards God , they may return and begin from faith in due order: perceiving at length how healthful a medicine has been provided for the faithful in the holy Church, whereby a heedful piety , healing the feebleness of the mind , may render it able to perceive the unchangeable truth , and hinder it from falling headlong, through disorderly rashness, into pestilent and false opinion. Neither will I myself shrink from inquiry, if I am anywhere in doubt ; nor be ashamed to learn, if I am anywhere in error .

Chapter 3.– What Augustine Requests from His Readers. The Errors of Readers Dull of Comprehension Not to Be Ascribed to the Author.

Further, let me ask my reader: wherever he is certain about something, as I am, let him continue with me; wherever he has doubts, as I do, let him join me in searching for answers; wherever he recognizes that he is wrong, let him come back to me; wherever he recognizes that I am wrong, let him call me back. In this way we may enter together upon the path of love and advance toward Him of whom it is said, Seek His face evermore. I would make this devout and safe agreement, in the presence of our Lord God, with all who read my writings—both in all other cases and especially in the case of those writings which investigate the unity of the Trinity, of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit. In no other subject is error more dangerous, inquiry more difficult, or the discovery of truth more rewarding. If any reader should say, This is not well said, because I do not understand it, such a person is finding fault with my language, not with my faith. It might perhaps have been put more clearly, yet no one has ever spoken in such a way as to be understood in all things by all people. Therefore, let the reader who finds this fault with my writing see whether he can understand other authors who have handled similar subjects and questions, when he does not understand me. If he can, let him put down my book, or even, if he wishes, throw it away, and let him spend his effort and time instead on those whom he understands. Yet let him not think on that account that I ought to have been silent, just because I have not been able to express myself as smoothly and clearly to him as those authors do whom he understands. For not all things which all people have written come into the hands of all. It is possible that some who are capable of understanding even these writings of mine may not find those more readable works, and may come across mine only. For this reason it is useful that many people should write many books, differing in style but not in faith, concerning even the same questions, so that the subject matter itself may reach the greatest number of people—some in one way, some in another. But if the person who complains that he has not understood these things has never been able to comprehend any careful and precise reasonings at all upon such subjects, then in that case let him deal with himself through determination and study, so that he may know better—not with me through quarrels and disputes, demanding that I keep silent. Again, let the reader who says, when he reads my book, Certainly I understand what is said, but it is not true, assert, if he pleases, his own opinion, and refute mine if he is able. And if he does this with love and truth, and takes the trouble to make it known to me (if I am still alive), I shall then receive the most abundant fruit of this labor of mine. And if he cannot inform me myself, I would be most willing and glad if he would inform those whom he can. Yet, for my part, I meditate on the law of the Lord, if not day and night, at least for such brief times as I can, and I commit my meditations to writing lest they should escape me through forgetfulness. I hope by the mercy of God that He will make me hold firmly to all truths of which I feel certain; but if I am mistaken about anything, that He will Himself reveal even this to me, whether through secret inspiration and warning, or through His own plain words, or through the arguments of my brothers. This I pray for, and this hope and desire I commit to Him, who is fully able to keep those things which He has given me and to fulfill those things which He has promised.

5. Further let me ask of my reader, wherever, alike with myself, he is certain, there to go on with me; wherever, alike with myself, he hesitates, there to join with me in inquiring; wherever he recognizes himself to be in error , there to return to me; wherever he recognizes me to be so, there to call me back: so that we may enter together upon the path of charity, and advance towards Him of whom it is said, Seek His face evermore. And I would make this pious and safe agreement, in the presence of our Lord God , with all who read my writings, as well in all other cases as, above all, in the case of those which inquire into the unity of the Trinity, of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit ; because in no other subject is error more dangerous, or inquiry more laborious, or the discovery of truth more profitable. If, then, any reader shall say, This is not well said, because I do not understand it; such an one finds fault with my language, not with my faith : and it might perhaps in very truth have been put more clearly; yet no man ever so spoke as to be understood in all things by all men . Let him, therefore, who finds this fault with my discourse, see whether he can understand other men who have handled similar subjects and questions, when he does not understand me: and if he can, let him put down my book, or even, if he pleases, throw it away; and let him spend labor and time rather on those whom he understands. Yet let him not think on that account that I ought to have been silent, because I have not been able to express myself so smoothly and clearly to him as those do whom he understands. For neither do all things, which all men have written, come into the hands of all. And possibly some, who are capable of understanding even these our writings, may not find those more lucid works, and may meet with ours only. And therefore it is useful that many persons should write many books, differing in style but not in faith , concerning even the same questions, that the matter itself may reach the greatest number — some in one way, some in another. But if he who complains that he has not understood these things has never been able to comprehend any careful and exact reasonings at all upon such subjects, let him in that case deal with himself by resolution and study, that he may know better; not with me by quarrellings and wranglings, that I may hold my peace. Let him, again, who says, when he reads my book, Certainly I understand what is said, but it is not true , assert, if he pleases, his own opinion, and refute mine if he is able. And if he do this with charity and truth , and take the pains to make it known to me (if I am still alive), I shall then receive the most abundant fruit of this my labor. And if he cannot inform myself, most willing and glad should I be that he should inform those whom he can. Yet, for my part, I meditate in the law of the Lord, if not day and night, at least such short times as I can; and I commit my meditations to writing, lest they should escape me through forgetfulness; hoping by the mercy of God that He will make me hold steadfastly all truths of which I feel certain; but if in anything I be otherwise minded, that He will himself reveal even this to me, whether through secret inspiration and admonition, or through His own plain utterances, or through the reasonings of my brethren. This I pray for, and this my trust and desire I commit to Him, who is sufficiently able to keep those things which He has given me, and to render those which He has promised.

I do expect that some readers who are slower to understand will imagine that in certain parts of my books I have held opinions which I have not actually held, or have not held opinions which I actually have. But their error, as everyone knows, should not be blamed on me if they have strayed into false teaching by following my steps without understanding me, while I am forced to carefully navigate a difficult and unclear subject. After all, no one can rightly blame the holy testimonies of the divine books themselves for the many different errors of heretics, even though all heretics try to defend their own false and mistaken opinions from those same Scriptures. The law of Christ, which is charity, clearly teaches me and commands me with a gentle compulsion that when people think I have held some falsehood in my books which I have not held, and that same falsehood displeases one person and pleases another, I should prefer to be criticized by the one who condemns the falsehood rather than praised by the one who approves it. For although I, who never held the error, am not rightly blamed by the former person, the error itself is rightly condemned. Meanwhile, the latter person neither rightly praises me, since I am thought to have held what truth condemns, nor the opinion itself, which truth also condemns. Let us therefore undertake the work we have begun in the name of the Lord.

6. I expect, indeed, that some, who are more dull of understanding, will imagine that in some parts of my books I have held sentiments which I have not held, or have not held those which I have. But their error , as none can be ignorant , ought not to be attributed to me, if they have deviated into false doctrine through following my steps without apprehending me, while I am compelled to pick my way through a hard and obscure subject: seeing that neither can any one, in any way, rightly ascribe the numerous and various errors of heretics to the holy testimonies themselves of the divine books; although all of them endeavor to defend out of those same Scriptures their own false and erroneous opinions. The law of Christ , that is, charity, admonishes me clearly, and commands me with a sweet constraint, that when men think that I have held in my books something false which I have not held, and that same falsehood displeases one and pleases another, I should prefer to be blamed by him who reprehends the falsehood , rather than praised by him who praises it. For although I, who never held the error , am not rightly blamed by the former, yet the error itself is rightly censured; while by the latter neither am I rightly praised, who am thought to have held that which the truth censures, nor the sentiment itself, which the truth also censures. Let us therefore essay the work which we have undertaken in the name of the Lord.

Chapter 4.– What the Doctrine of the Catholic Faith is Concerning the Trinity.

All those Catholic interpreters of the divine Scriptures, both Old and New, whom I have been able to read, who have written before me concerning the Trinity, Who is God, have intended to teach, according to the Scriptures, this doctrine: that the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit reveal a divine unity of one and the same ousia in an indivisible equality; and therefore they are not three Gods, but one God. Although the Father has begotten the Son, and so He who is the Father is not the Son; and the Son is begotten by the Father, and so He who is the Son is not the Father; and the Holy Spirit is neither the Father nor the Son, but only the Spirit of the Father and of the Son, Himself also co-equal with the Father and the Son, and belonging to the unity of the Trinity. Yet it was not this Trinity that was born of the Virgin Mary, and crucified under Pontius Pilate, and buried, and rose again the third day, and ascended into heaven, but only the Son. Nor, again, did this Trinity descend in the form of a dove upon Jesus when He was baptized; nor on the day of Pentecost, after the ascension of the Lord, when there came a sound from heaven, as of a rushing mighty wind, did the same Trinity sit upon each of them with cloven tongues like fire, but only the Holy Spirit. Nor yet did this Trinity say from heaven, You are my Son, whether when He was baptized by John, or when the three disciples were with Him on the mount, or when the voice sounded, saying, I have both glorified it, and will glorify it again; but it was a word of the Father only, spoken to the Son. Although the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit, as they are indivisible, so work indivisibly. This is also my faith, since it is the Catholic faith.

7. All those Catholic expounders of the divine Scriptures , both Old and New, whom I have been able to read, who have written before me concerning the Trinity, Who is God , have purposed to teach, according to the Scriptures , this doctrine, that the Father , and the Son , and the Holy Spirit intimate a divine unity of one and the same substance in an indivisible equality; and therefore that they are not three Gods, but one God: although the Father has begotten the Son , and so He who is the Father is not the Son; and the Son is begotten by the Father , and so He who is the Son is not the Father; and the Holy Spirit is neither the Father nor the Son , but only the Spirit of the Father and of the Son , Himself also co-equal with the Father and the Son , and pertaining to the unity of the Trinity. Yet not that this Trinity was born of the Virgin Mary , and crucified under Pontius Pilate , and buried, and rose again the third day, and ascended into heaven, but only the Son. Nor, again, that this Trinity descended in the form of a dove upon Jesus when He was baptized ; nor that, on the day of Pentecost, after the ascension of the Lord, when there came a sound from heaven, as of a rushing mighty wind, the same Trinity sat upon each of them with cloven tongues like as of fire, but only the Holy Spirit . Nor yet that this Trinity said from heaven, You are my Son, whether when He was baptized by John, or when the three disciples were with Him in the mount, or when the voice sounded, saying, I have both glorified it, and will glorify it again; but that it was a word of the Father only, spoken to the Son; although the Father , and the Son , and the Holy Spirit , as they are indivisible, so work indivisibly. This is also my faith , since it is the Catholic faith .

Chapter 5.– Of Difficulties Concerning the Trinity: in What Manner Three are One God, and How, Working Indivisibly, They Yet Perform Some Things Severally.

Some people, however, find this faith difficult. When they hear that the Father is God, and the Son God, and the Holy Spirit God, and yet that this Trinity is not three Gods but one God, they ask how they are to understand this. This is especially true when it is said that the Trinity works indivisibly in everything that God does, and yet a certain voice of the Father spoke that is not the voice of the Son; that only the Son was born in the flesh, suffered, rose again, and ascended into heaven; and that only the Holy Spirit came in the form of a dove. They want to understand how the Trinity uttered that voice which belonged only to the Father, how the same Trinity created that flesh in which only the Son was born of the Virgin, and how this very same Trinity produced that form of a dove in which only the Holy Spirit appeared. Otherwise, they argue, the Trinity does not work indivisibly, but the Father does some things, the Son does other things, and the Holy Spirit does yet other things. Or if they do some things together and some things separately, then the Trinity is not indivisible. It is also difficult for them to understand in what manner the Holy Spirit exists in the Trinity, whom neither the Father nor the Son, nor both together, have begotten, although He is the Spirit of both the Father and the Son. Since people weary us by asking such questions, let us explain to them, as well as we are able, whatever wisdom God's gift has bestowed upon our weakness on this subject, and let us not proceed with consuming envy. If we said we are not accustomed to thinking about such things, it would not be true. But if we acknowledge that such subjects commonly occupy our thoughts, since we are carried away by the love of investigating the truth, then by the law of charity they require us to make known to them what we have been able to discover about this. Not that I have already attained or am already perfect (for if the Apostle Paul said this, how much more must I, who lie far beneath his feet, count myself as not having apprehended!). But according to my measure, if I forget what is behind and reach forward to what is ahead, and press toward the goal for the prize of the high calling, I am asked to reveal how much of the road I have already traveled and the point I have reached, from which the course still remains to bring me to the end. And those who make this request are people whom generous charity compels me to serve. It must be that God will grant that in providing them with material to read, I shall also profit myself, and that in seeking to reply to their inquiries, I shall likewise find what I was looking for. Accordingly, I have undertaken this task by the command and help of the Lord my God, not so much to speak with authority about things I already know, as to learn these things by discussing them devoutly.

8. Some persons , however, find a difficulty in this faith ; when they hear that the Father is God , and the Son God , and the Holy Spirit God , and yet that this Trinity is not three Gods, but one God ; and they ask how they are to understand this: especially when it is said that the Trinity works indivisibly in everything that God works, and yet that a certain voice of the Father spoke, which is not the voice of the Son; and that none except the Son was born in the flesh, and suffered, and rose again, and ascended into heaven; and that none except the Holy Spirit came in the form of a dove. They wish to understand how the Trinity uttered that voice which was only of the Father; and how the same Trinity created that flesh in which the Son only was born of the Virgin; and how the very same Trinity itself wrought that form of a dove, in which the Holy Spirit only appeared. Yet, otherwise, the Trinity does not work indivisibly, but the Father does some things, the Son other things, and the Holy Spirit yet others: or else, if they do some things together, some severally, then the Trinity is not indivisible. It is a difficulty, too, to them, in what manner the Holy Spirit is in the Trinity, whom neither the Father nor the Son , nor both, have begotten, although He is the Spirit both of the Father and of the Son. Since, then, men weary us with asking such questions, let us unfold to them, as we are able, whatever wisdom God's gift has bestowed upon our weakness on this subject; neither let us go on our way with consuming envy . Should we say that we are not accustomed to think about such things, it would not be true ; yet if we acknowledge that such subjects commonly dwell in our thoughts, carried away as we are by the love of investigating the truth , then they require of us, by the law of charity, to make known to them what we have herein been able to find out. Not as though I had already attained, either were already perfect (for, if the Apostle Paul , how much more must I, who lie far beneath his feet, count myself not to have apprehended!); but, according to my measure, if I forget those things that are behind, and reach forth unto those things which are before, and press towards the mark for the prize of the high calling, I am requested to disclose so much of the road as I have already passed, and the point to which I have reached, whence the course yet remains to bring me to the end. And those make the request, whom a generous charity compels me to serve. Needs must too, and God will grant that, in supplying them with matter to read, I shall profit myself also; and that, in seeking to reply to their inquiries, I shall myself likewise find that for which I was inquiring. Accordingly I have undertaken the task, by the bidding and help of the Lord my God , not so much of discoursing with authority respecting things I know already, as of learning those things by piously discoursing of them.

Chapter 6.– That the Son is Very God, of the Same Substance with the Father. Not Only the Father, But the Trinity, is Affirmed to Be Immortal. All Things are Not from the Father Alone, But Also from the Son. That the Holy Spirit is Very God, Equal with the Father and the Son.

Those who have said that our Lord Jesus Christ is not God, or not very God, or not the One and only God with the Father, or not truly immortal because he is changeable, are proven wrong by the clearest and most unified voice of divine testimonies. For instance: "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God." It is clear that we should understand the Word of God to be the only Son of God, of whom it is said later, "And the Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us," referring to that birth of his incarnation, which took place in time from the Virgin. But this passage declares not only that he is God, but also that he is of the same ousia with the Father, because after saying "And the Word was God," it also says, "The same was in the beginning with God: all things were made by him, and without him was not anything made." Not simply all things, but only all things that were made—that is, the whole creation. From this it is evident that he himself was not made, since all things were made by him. And if he was not made, then he is not a creature. But if he is not a creature, then he is of the same ousia with the Father. For all ousia that is not God is creature, and all that is not creature is God. And if the Son is not of the same ousia with the Father, then he is an ousia that was made. And if he is an ousia that was made, then all things were not made by him. But all things were made by him, therefore he is of one and the same ousia with the Father. And so he is not only God, but also very God. And the same John most clearly affirms this in his epistle: "For we know that the Son of God has come, and has given us an understanding, that we may know the true God, and that we may be in his true Son Jesus Christ. This is the true God, and eternal life."

9. They who have said that our Lord Jesus Christ is not God , or not very God , or not with the Father the One and only God , or not truly immortal because changeable, are proved wrong by the most plain and unanimous voice of divine testimonies; as, for instance, In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God , and the Word was God. For it is plain that we are to take the Word of God to be the only Son of God , of whom it is afterwards said, And the Word was made flesh , and dwelt among us, on account of that birth of His incarnation , which was wrought in time of the Virgin . But herein is declared, not only that He is God , but also that He is of the same substance with the Father; because, after saying, And the Word was God , it is said also, The same was in the beginning with God: all things were made by Him, and without Him was not anything made. Not simply all things; but only all things that were made , that is; the whole creature. From which it appears clearly, that He Himself was not made, by whom all things were made. And if He was not made, then He is not a creature; but if He is not a creature, then He is of the same substance with the Father. For all substance that is not God is creature; and all that is not creature is God . And if the Son is not of the same substance with the Father , then He is a substance that was made: and if He is a substance that was made, then all things were not made by Him; but all things were made by Him, therefore He is of one and the same substance with the Father. And so He is not only God , but also very God. And the same John most expressly affirms this in his epistle: For we know that the Son of God has come, and has given us an understanding, that we may know the true God , and that we may be in His true Son Jesus Christ . This is the true God , and eternal life.

This means that when the Apostle Paul said "Who alone has immortality," he was not referring only to the Father, but to the One and only God, which is the Trinity itself. Whatever is itself eternal life cannot be mortal through any change. Therefore the Son of God, because He is Eternal Life, is also included with the Father when it says "Who only has immortality." We become partakers of this eternal life and become immortal in our own measure. But the eternal life itself, of which we become partakers, is one thing, while we ourselves, who will live eternally by partaking of it, are another. Even if Paul had said, "Whom in His own time the Father will show, who is the blessed and only Potentate, the King of kings, and Lord of lords; who only has immortality," it would not necessarily mean that the Son is excluded. For the Son has not separated the Father from Himself, because He Himself, speaking elsewhere with the voice of wisdom (for He Himself is the Wisdom of God), says, "I alone compassed the circuit of heaven." Therefore it is even less necessary to understand the words "Who has immortality" as referring to the Father alone, excluding the Son, when they are stated like this: "That you keep this commandment without spot, unrebukeable, until the appearing of our Lord Jesus Christ: whom in His own time He will show, who is the blessed and only Potentate, the King of kings, and Lord of lords; who only has immortality, dwelling in the light which no man can approach unto; whom no man has seen, nor can see: to whom be honor and power everlasting. Amen." In these words, neither the Father is specifically named, nor the Son, nor the Holy Spirit, but the blessed and only Potentate, the King of kings, and Lord of lords—that is, the One and only and true God, the Trinity itself.

10. Hence also it follows by consequence, that the Apostle Paul did not say, Who alone has immortality , of the Father merely; but of the One and only God , which is the Trinity itself. For that which is itself eternal life is not mortal according to any changeableness; and hence the Son of God , because He is Eternal Life, is also Himself understood with the Father , where it is said, Who only has immortality . For we, too, are made partakers of this eternal life, and become, in our own measure, immortal . But the eternal life itself, of which we are made partakers, is one thing; we ourselves, who, by partaking of it, shall live eternally , are another. For if He had said, Whom in His own time the Father will show, who is the blessed and only Potentate, the King of kings, and Lord of lords; who only has immortality ; not even so would it be necessarily understood that the Son is excluded. For neither has the Son separated the Father from Himself, because He Himself, speaking elsewhere with the voice of wisdom (for He Himself is the Wisdom of God), says, I alone compassed the circuit of heaven. And therefore so much the more is it not necessary that the words, Who has immortality , should be understood of the Father alone, omitting the Son; when they are said thus: That you keep this commandment without spot, unrebukeable, until the appearing of our Lord Jesus Christ : whom in His own time He will show, who is the blessed and only Potentate, the King of kings, and Lord of lords; who only has immortality , dwelling in the light which no man can approach unto; whom no man has seen, nor can see: to whom be honor and power everlasting. Amen . In which words neither is the Father specially named, nor the Son , nor the Holy Spirit ; but the blessed and only Potentate, the King of kings, and Lord of lords; that is, the One and only and true God , the Trinity itself.

11. But perhaps what follows may interfere with this meaning, because it says, "Whom no man has seen, nor can see." However, this may also be understood as referring to Christ according to His divinity, which the Jews did not see, even though they saw and crucified Him in the flesh. His divinity cannot be seen by human sight in any way, but is seen with that kind of sight by which those who see are no longer merely human, but beyond human. Therefore, God Himself, the Trinity, is rightly understood to be the blessed and only Potentate, who shows the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ in His own time. For the words "Who only has immortality" are said in the same way as it is said, "Who only does wondrous things." And I would like to know of whom they take these words to be said. If only of the Father, how then is that true which the Son Himself says: "For whatever things the Father does, these also the Son does likewise"? Is there any work, among wonderful works, more wonderful than to raise up and give life to the dead? Yet the same Son says, "As the Father raises up the dead and gives them life, even so the Son gives life to whom He will." How, then, does the Father alone do wondrous things, when these words allow us to understand neither the Father only, nor the Son only, but assuredly the one only true God—that is, the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit?

11. But perhaps what follows may interfere with this meaning; because it is said, Whom no man has seen, nor can see: although this may also be taken as belonging to Christ according to His divinity, which the Jews did not see, who yet saw and crucified Him in the flesh; whereas His divinity can in no way be seen by human sight, but is seen with that sight with which they who see are no longer men, but beyond men. Rightly, therefore, is God Himself, the Trinity, understood to be the blessed and only Potentate, who shows the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ in His own time. For the words, Who only has immortality , are said in the same way as it is said, Who only does wondrous things. And I should be glad to know of whom they take these words to be said. If only of the Father , how then is that true which the Son Himself says, For whatever things the Father does, these also does the Son likewise? Is there any, among wonderful works , more wonderful than to raise up and quicken the dead? Yet the same Son says, As the Father raises up the dead, and quickens them, even so the Son quickens whom He will. How, then, does the Father alone do wondrous things, when these words allow us to understand neither the Father only, nor the Son only, but assuredly the one only true God , that is, the Father , and the Son , and the Holy Spirit ?

When the same apostle says, "But to us there is but one God, the Father, of whom are all things, and we in Him; and one Lord Jesus Christ, by whom are all things, and we by Him," who can doubt that he is speaking of all created things? This is the same as when John says, "All things were made by Him." I ask, therefore, about whom the apostle speaks in another place: "For of Him, and through Him, and in Him, are all things: to whom be glory forever. Amen." If this refers to the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit, with each clause assigned to each person—"of Him" meaning of the Father, "through Him" meaning through the Son, "in Him" meaning in the Holy Spirit—then it is clear that the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit is one God, since the words that follow remain in singular number: "To whom be glory forever." For at the beginning of the passage he does not say, "O the depth of the riches both of the wisdom and knowledge of the Father," or "of the Son," or "of the Holy Spirit," but "of the wisdom and knowledge of God! How unsearchable are His judgments, and His ways past finding out! For who has known the mind of the Lord? Or who has been His counsellor? Or who has first given to Him and it shall be repaid to him again? For of Him, and through Him, and in Him, are all things: to whom be glory forever. Amen." But if they insist this should be understood only of the Father, then how are all things by the Father, as is said here, and also all things by the Son, as is said to the Corinthians, "And one Lord Jesus Christ, by whom are all things," and as in the Gospel of John, "All things were made by Him"? For if some things were made by the Father and some by the Son, then not all things were made by the Father, nor all things by the Son. But if all things were made by the Father, and all things by the Son, then the same things were made by the Father and by the Son. Therefore, the Son is equal with the Father, and the working of the Father and the Son is indivisible. For if the Father made even the Son—whom the Son Himself certainly did not make—then not all things were made by the Son. But all things were made by the Son. Therefore He Himself was not made, so that with the Father He might make all things that were made. And the apostle has not refrained from using the very word itself, but has said most expressly, "Who, being in the form of God, thought it not robbery to be equal with God," using here the name of God specially for the Father, as elsewhere, "But the head of Christ is God."

12. Also, when the same apostle says, But to us there is but one God , the Father , of whom are all things, and we in Him; and one Lord Jesus Christ , by whom are all things, and we by Him, who can doubt that he speaks of all things which are created; as does John, when he says, All things were made by Him ? I ask, therefore, of whom he speaks in another place: For of Him, and through Him, and in Him, are all things: to whom be glory forever. Amen . For if of the Father , and the Son , and the Holy Spirit , so as to assign each clause severally to each person: of Him, that is to say, of the Father; through Him, that is to say, through the Son; in Him, that is to say, in the Holy Spirit — it is manifest that the Father , and the Son , and the Holy Spirit is one God , inasmuch as the words continue in the singular number, To whom be glory forever. For at the beginning of the passage he does not say, O the depth of the riches both of the wisdom and knowledge of the Father , or of the Son , or of the Holy Spirit , but of the wisdom and knowledge of God! How unsearchable are His judgments, and His ways past finding out! For who has known the mind of the Lord? Or who has been His counsellor? Or who has first given to Him and it shall be recompensed unto him again? For of Him, and through Him, and in Him, are all things: to whom be glory forever. Amen . But if they will have this to be understood only of the Father , then in what way are all things by the Father , as is said here; and all things by the Son , as where it is said to the Corinthians, And one Lord Jesus Christ , by whom are all things, and as in the Gospel of John , All things were made by Him? For if some things were made by the Father , and some by the Son , then all things were not made by the Father , nor all things by the Son; but if all things were made by the Father , and all things by the Son , then the same things were made by the Father and by the Son. The Son, therefore, is equal with the Father , and the working of the Father and the Son is indivisible. Because if the Father made even the Son , whom certainly the Son Himself did not make, then all things were not made by the Son; but all things were made by the Son: therefore He Himself was not made, that with the Father He might make all things that were made. And the apostle has not refrained from using the very word itself, but has said most expressly, Who, being in the form of God , thought it not robbery to be equal with God ; using here the name of God specially of the Father; as elsewhere, But the head of Christ is God .

Similar evidence has been gathered concerning the Holy Spirit. Earlier writers who have discussed this subject have made full use of this evidence to show that the Holy Spirit is also God, and not a creature. If He is not a creature, then He is not only God in the ordinary sense (since even human beings are sometimes called gods), but truly God. Therefore, He is absolutely equal with the Father and the Son, and within the unity of the Trinity He is consubstantial and coeternal with them. That the Holy Spirit is not a creature is made especially clear by the passage where we are commanded not to serve the creature but the Creator. This is not the kind of service we are commanded to show one another through love, which in Greek is douleuein, but the kind of service that belongs to God alone, which in Greek is latreuein. This is why those who give to images the service that is due to God are called idolaters. This is the service referred to when it says, "You shall worship the Lord your God, and Him only shall you serve." This is found even more clearly in the Greek Scriptures, which use latreuein. Now if we are forbidden to serve the creature with this kind of service, since it is written, "You shall worship the Lord your God, and Him only shall you serve"—and the apostle likewise condemns those who worship and serve the creature rather than the Creator—then certainly the Holy Spirit is not a creature, since all the saints offer Him this service. As the apostle says, "For we are the circumcision, which serve the Spirit of God," which in Greek is latreuontes. Most Latin copies also have it this way: "We who serve the Spirit of God." Nearly all Greek copies have it so. Although in some Latin copies we find not "We worship the Spirit of God" but "We worship God in the Spirit," let those who are mistaken on this point and refuse to yield to the stronger authority tell us whether they also find this text varied in the manuscripts: "Do you not know that your body is the temple of the Holy Spirit, which is in you, which you have from God?" What could be more foolish or more profane than for anyone to dare say that the members of Christ are the temple of one who, in their view, is a creature inferior to Christ? The apostle says elsewhere, "Your bodies are members of Christ." But if the members of Christ are also the temple of the Holy Spirit, then the Holy Spirit is not a creature, because we must owe to Him, whose temple our body is, that service which is to be given to God alone, which in Greek is called latreia. Accordingly the apostle says, "Therefore glorify God in your body."

13. Similar evidence has been collected also concerning the Holy Spirit , of which those who have discussed the subject before ourselves have most fully availed themselves, that He too is God , and not a creature. But if not a creature, then not only God (for men likewise are called gods ), but also very God ; and therefore absolutely equal with the Father and the Son , and in the unity of the Trinity consubstantial and co-eternal. But that the Holy Spirit is not a creature is made quite plain by that passage above all others, where we are commanded not to serve the creature, but the Creator; not in the sense in which we are commanded to serve one another by love , which is in Greek δουλεύειν , but in that in which God alone is served, which is in Greek λατρεύειν . From whence they are called idolaters who tender that service to images which is due to God . For it is this service concerning which it is said, You shall worship the Lord your God , and Him only shall you serve. For this is found also more distinctly in the Greek Scriptures, which have λατρεύσεις . Now if we are forbidden to serve the creature with such a service, seeing that it is written, You shall worship the Lord your God , and Him only shall you serve (and hence, too, the apostle repudiates those who worship and serve the creature more than the Creator), then assuredly the Holy Spirit is not a creature, to whom such a service is paid by all the saints ; as says the apostle, For we are the circumcision , which serve the Spirit of God , which is in the Greek λατρεύοντες . For even most Latin copies also have it thus, We who serve the Spirit of God ; but all Greek ones, or almost all, have it so. Although in some Latin copies we find, not We worship the Spirit of God , but, We worship God in the Spirit . But let those who err in this case, and refuse to give up to the more weighty authority, tell us whether they find this text also varied in the mss.: Do you not know that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost , which is in you, which you have of God? Yet what can be more senseless or more profane, than that any one should dare to say that the members of Christ are the temple of one who, in their opinion, is a creature inferior to Christ? For the apostle says in another place, Your bodies are members of Christ . But if the members of Christ are also the temple of the Holy Spirit , then the Holy Spirit is not a creature; because we must needs owe to Him, of whom our body is the temple, that service wherewith God only is to be served, which in Greek is called λατρεία . And accordingly the apostle says, Therefore glorify God in your body.

Chapter 7.– In What Manner the Son is Less Than the Father, and Than Himself.

In these and similar testimonies from the divine Scriptures, which our predecessors freely used (as I have said) to refute the sophistries or errors of the heretics, the unity and equality of the Trinity are communicated to our faith. However, because many things are said in the sacred books in such a way as to signify, or even most clearly declare, the Father to be greater than the Son—due to the incarnation of the Word of God for accomplishing our salvation, so that the man Christ Jesus might be the Mediator between God and men—some people have made errors through failing to carefully examine or consider the whole scope of the Scriptures. They have tried to apply those things which are said of Jesus Christ according to the flesh to that substance of His which was eternal before the incarnation and is eternal. For instance, they say that the Son is less than the Father because it is written that the Lord Himself said, "My Father is greater than I." But the truth shows that in the same sense the Son is less also than Himself, for how was He not made less also than Himself, who emptied Himself and took upon Himself the form of a servant? For He did not take the form of a servant in such a way that He lost the form of God, in which He was equal to the Father. If, then, the form of a servant was taken without losing the form of God, since He Himself is the same only-begotten Son of God the Father both in the form of a servant and in the form of God—in the form of God equal to the Father, in the form of a servant the Mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus—is there anyone who cannot understand that He Himself in the form of God is also greater than Himself, but likewise in the form of a servant less than Himself? And therefore Scripture rightly says both things: both that the Son is equal to the Father and that the Father is greater than the Son. For there is no confusion when the former is understood as referring to the form of God and the latter as referring to the form of a servant. In truth, this principle for resolving the question throughout all the sacred Scriptures is set forth in one chapter of an epistle of the Apostle Paul, where this distinction is clearly enough commended to us. For he says, "Who, being in the form of God, thought it not robbery to be equal with God, but emptied Himself and took upon Him the form of a servant, and was made in the likeness of men, and was found in fashion as a man." The Son of God, then, is equal to God the Father in nature, but less in fashion. For in the form of a servant which He took, He is less than the Father; but in the form of God, in which He also existed before He took the form of a servant, He is equal to the Father. In the form of God He is the Word, by whom all things are made; but in the form of a servant He was made of a woman, made under the law, to redeem those who were under the law. Similarly, in the form of God He made man; in the form of a servant He was made man. For if the Father alone had made man without the Son, it would not have been written, "Let us make man in our image, after our likeness." Therefore, because the form of God took the form of a servant, both is God and both is man; but both God, on account of God who takes; and both man, on account of man who is taken. For neither by that taking is one of them turned and changed into the other: the Divinity is not changed into the creature so as to cease to be Divinity, nor the creature into Divinity so as to cease to be creature.

14. In these and like testimonies of the divine Scriptures , by free use of which, as I have said, our predecessors exploded such sophistries or errors of the heretics , the unity and equality of the Trinity are intimated to our faith . But because, on account of the incarnation of the Word of God for the working out of our salvation , that the man Christ Jesus might be the Mediator between God and men, many things are so said in the sacred books as to signify, or even most expressly declare, the Father to be greater than the Son; men have erred through a want of careful examination or consideration of the whole tenor of the Scriptures , and have endeavored to transfer those things which are said of Jesus Christ according to the flesh, to that substance of His which was eternal before the incarnation , and is eternal . They say, for instance, that the Son is less than the Father , because it is written that the Lord Himself said, My Father is greater than I. But the truth shows that after the same sense the Son is less also than Himself; for how was He not made less also than Himself, who emptied Himself, and took upon Him the form of a servant? For He did not so take the form of a servant as that He should lose the form of God , in which He was equal to the Father. If, then, the form of a servant was so taken that the form of God was not lost, since both in the form of a servant and in the form of God He Himself is the same only-begotten Son of God the Father , in the form of God equal to the Father , in the form of a servant the Mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus; is there any one who cannot perceive that He Himself in the form of God is also greater than Himself, but yet likewise in the form of a servant less than Himself? And not, therefore, without cause the Scripture says both the one and the other, both that the Son is equal to the Father , and that the Father is greater than the Son. For there is no confusion when the former is understood as on account of the form of God , and the latter as on account of the form of a servant. And, in truth , this rule for clearing the question through all the sacred Scriptures is set forth in one chapter of an epistle of the Apostle Paul , where this distinction is commended to us plainly enough. For he says, Who, being in the form of God , thought it not robbery to be equal with God ; but emptied Himself, and took upon Him the form of a servant, and was made in the likeness of men: and was found in fashion as a man . The Son of God , then, is equal to God the Father in nature, but less in fashion. For in the form of a servant which He took He is less than the Father; but in the form of God , in which also He was before He took the form of a servant, He is equal to the Father. In the form of God He is the Word, by whom all things are made; but in the form of a servant He was made of a woman , made under the law, to redeem them that were under the law. In like manner, in the form of God He made man; in the form of a servant He was made man. For if the Father alone had made man without the Son , it would not have been written, Let us make man in our image, after our likeness. Therefore, because the form of God took the form of a servant, both is God and both is man; but both God , on account of God who takes; and both man, on account of man who is taken. For neither by that taking is the one of them turned and changed into the other: the Divinity is not changed into the creature, so as to cease to be Divinity; nor the creature into Divinity, so as to cease to be creature.

Chapter 8.– The Texts of Scripture Explained Respecting the Subjection of the Son to the Father, Which Have Been Misunderstood. Christ Will Not So Give Up the Kingdom to the Father, as to Take It Away from Himself. The Beholding Him is the Promised End of All Actions. The Holy Spirit is Sufficient to Our Blessedness Equally with the Father.

As for what the apostle says, "And when all things shall be subdued unto Him, then shall the Son also Himself be subject unto Him that put all things under Him": either the text has been expressed this way to prevent anyone from thinking that the form of Christ, which He took according to human nature, would later be transformed into the Divinity, or (to put it more precisely) into the Godhead itself, which is not a creature but is the unity of the Trinity—a nature incorporeal, unchangeable, consubstantial, and co-eternal with itself; or if anyone argues, as some have thought, that the text "Then shall the Son also Himself be subject unto Him that put all things under Him" is expressed this way so that one may believe that very subjection to be a future change and conversion of the creature into the substance or ousia itself of the Creator—that is, that what had been the substance of a creature shall become the substance of the Creator—such a person at least admits this, which truly cannot be doubted, that this had not yet happened when the Lord said, "My Father is greater than I." For He said this not only before He ascended into heaven, but also before He had suffered and risen from the dead. But those who think that the human nature in Him is to be changed and converted into the substance of the Godhead, and that it was said "Then shall the Son also Himself be subject unto Him that put all things under Him"—as if to say, Then also the Son of man Himself, and the human nature taken by the Word of God, shall be changed into the nature of Him who put all things under Him—must also think that this will happen when, after the day of judgment, He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God, even the Father. And therefore even still, according to this opinion, the Father is greater than that form of a servant which was taken from the Virgin. But if some claim even further that the man Christ Jesus has already been changed into the substance of God, at least they cannot deny that the human nature still remained when He said before His passion, "For my Father is greater than I"; so there is no question that it was said in this sense, that the Father is greater than the form of a servant, while in the form of God the Son is equal to Him. Nor should anyone, hearing what the apostle says, "But when He says all things are put under Him, it is manifest that He is excepted which did put all things under Him," think the words "that He has put all things under the Son" are to be understood of the Father in such a way that he should not think that the Son Himself put all things under Himself. For this the apostle plainly declares when he says to the Philippians, "For our conversation is in heaven; from whence also we look for the Saviour, the Lord Jesus Christ: who shall change our vile body, that it may be fashioned like His glorious body, according to the working whereby He is able even to subdue all things unto Himself." For the working of the Father and of the Son is indivisible. Otherwise, neither has the Father Himself put all things under Himself, but the Son has put all things under Him, who delivers the kingdom to Him and puts down all rule and all authority and power. For these words are spoken of the Son: "When He shall have delivered up," says the apostle, "the kingdom to God, even the Father; when He shall have put down all rule, and all authority, and all power." For the same one who puts down also makes subject.

15. As for that which the apostle says, And when all things shall be subdued unto Him, then shall the Son also Himself be subject unto Him that put all things under Him: either the text has been so turned, lest any one should think that the fashion of Christ , which He took according to the human creature, was to be transformed hereafter into the Divinity, or (to express it more precisely) the Godhead itself, who is not a creature, but is the unity of the Trinity, — a nature incorporeal, and unchangeable, and consubstantial, and co-eternal with itself; or if any one contends, as some have thought, that the text, Then shall the Son also Himself be subject unto Him that put all things under Him, is so turned in order that one may believe that very subjection to be a change and conversion hereafter of the creature into the substance or essence itself of the Creator, that is, that that which had been the substance of a creature shall become the substance of the Creator;– such an one at any rate admits this, of which in truth there is no possible doubt , that this had not yet taken place, when the Lord said, My Father is greater than I. For He said this not only before He ascended into heaven, but also before He had suffered, and had risen from the dead. But they who think that the human nature in Him is to be changed and converted into the substance of the Godhead, and that it was so said, Then shall the Son also Himself be subject unto Him that put all things under Him, — as if to say, Then also the Son of man Himself, and the human nature taken by the Word of God , shall be changed into the nature of Him who put all things under Him — must also think that this will then take place, when, after the day of judgment, He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God , even the Father. And hence even still, according to this opinion, the Father is greater than that form of a servant which was taken of the Virgin . But if some affirm even further, that the man Christ Jesus has already been changed into the substance of God , at least they cannot deny that the human nature still remained, when He said before His passion , For my Father is greater than I; whence there is no question that it was said in this sense, that the Father is greater than the form of a servant, to whom in the form of God the Son is equal. Nor let any one, hearing what the apostle says, But when He says all things are put under Him, it is manifest that He is excepted which did put all things under Him, think the words, that He has put all things under the Son , to be so understood of the Father , as that He should not think that the Son Himself put all things under Himself. For this the apostle plainly declares, when he says to the Philippians, For our conversation is in heaven; from whence also we look for the Saviour , the Lord Jesus Christ : who shall change our vile body, that it may be fashioned like His glorious body, according to the working whereby He is able even to subdue all things unto Himself. For the working of the Father and of the Son is indivisible. Otherwise, neither has the Father Himself put all things under Himself, but the Son has put all things under Him, who delivers the kingdom to Him, and puts down all rule and all authority and power. For these words are spoken of the Son: When He shall have delivered up, says the apostle, the kingdom to God , even the Father; when He shall have put down all rule, and all authority, and all power. For the same that puts down, also makes subject.

We should not think that Christ will hand over the kingdom to God the Father in such a way that He takes it away from Himself. Some foolish talkers have actually thought this. When it says "He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God, even the Father," He Himself is not excluded, because He is one God together with the Father. But the word "until" deceives those who read the divine Scriptures carelessly yet are eager for controversies. The text continues, "For He must reign, until He has put all enemies under His feet," as if when He had done so, He would no longer reign. They do not realize that this is said in the same way as that other text, "His heart is established: He shall not be afraid, until He see His desire upon His enemies." For He will not then be afraid when He has seen it. What then does "When He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God, even the Father" mean, as if God and the Father does not have the kingdom now? Because He is going to bring all the just—over whom the Mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus, now reigns as they live by faith—to that sight which the same apostle calls face to face, therefore the words "When He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God, even the Father" mean the same as "When He shall have brought believers to the contemplation of God, even the Father." For He says, "All things are delivered unto me of my Father, and no man knows the Son but the Father; neither knows any man the Father save the Son, and he to whomsoever the Son will reveal Him." The Father will then be revealed by the Son when He shall have put down all rule, and all authority, and all power—that is, in such a way that there will no longer be any need for any economy of similitudes through angelic rulers, authorities, and powers. This is what is appropriately understood in what is said in the Song of Songs to the bride: "We will make you borders of gold, with studs of silver, while the King sits at His table"—that is, as long as Christ is in His secret place, since "your life is hid with Christ in God; when Christ, who is our life, shall appear, then shall you also appear with Him in glory." Before that time, "we see now through a glass, in an enigma"—that is, in similitudes—"but then face to face."

16. Neither may we think that Christ shall so give up the kingdom to God , even the Father , as that He shall take it away from Himself. For some vain talkers have thought even this. For when it is said, He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God , even the Father , He Himself is not excluded; because He is one God together with the Father. But that word until deceives those who are careless readers of the divine Scriptures , but eager for controversies. For the text continues, For He must reign, until He has put all enemies under His feet; as though, when He had so put them, He would no more reign. Neither do they perceive that this is said in the same way as that other text, His heart is established: He shall not be afraid, until He see His desire upon His enemies. For He will not then be afraid when He has seen it. What then means, When He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God , even the Father , as though God and the Father has not the kingdom now? But because He is hereafter to bring all the just, over whom now, living by faith , the Mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus, reigns, to that sight which the same apostle calls face to face; therefore the words, When He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God , even the Father , are as much as to say, When He shall have brought believers to the contemplation of God , even the Father. For He says, All things are delivered unto me of my Father: and no man knows the Son , but the Father; neither knows any man the Father , save the Son , and he to whomsoever the Son will reveal Him. The Father will then be revealed by the Son , when He shall have put down all rule, and all authority, and all power; that is, in such wise that there shall be no more need of any economy of similitudes, by means of angelic rulers, and authorities, and powers. Of whom that is not unfitly understood, which is said in the Song of Songs to the bride, We will make you borders of gold, with studs of silver, while the King sits at His table; that is, as long as Christ is in His secret place: since your life is hid with Christ in God ; when Christ, who is our life, shall appear, then shall you also appear with Him in glory . Before which time, we see now through a glass, in an enigma, that is, in similitudes, but then face to face.

For this contemplation is presented to us as the goal of all our actions and the everlasting fullness of joy. For we are the sons of God, and it does not yet appear what we shall be, but we know that when He shall appear, we shall be like Him, for we shall see Him as He is. For what He said to His servant Moses—I am that I am, thus shall you say to the children of Israel, I Am has sent me to you—this is what we shall contemplate when we shall live in eternity. For so it is said, And this is life eternal, that they might know You, the only true God, and Jesus Christ, whom You have sent. This shall happen when the Lord shall have come and shall have brought to light the hidden things of darkness, when the darkness of this present mortality and corruption shall have passed away. Then will be our morning, which is spoken of in the Psalm, In the morning will I direct my prayer unto You, and will contemplate You. Of this contemplation I understand it to be said, When He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God, even the Father—that is, when He shall have brought the righteous, over whom now, living by faith, the Mediator between God and man, the man Christ Jesus, reigns, to the contemplation of God, even the Father. If in this I am foolish, let him who knows better correct me; to me at least the case seems as I have said. For we shall not seek anything else when we shall have come to the contemplation of Him. But that contemplation is not yet, so long as our joy is in hope. For hope that is seen is not hope, for what a man sees, why does he yet hope for? But if we hope for that we see not, then do we with patience wait for it, as long as the King sits at His table. Then will take place that which is written, In Your presence is fullness of joy. Nothing more than that joy will be required, because there will be nothing more that can be required. For the Father will be revealed to us, and that will satisfy us. And this much Philip had well understood, so that he said to the Lord, Show us the Father, and it satisfies us. But he had not yet understood that he himself was able to say this very same thing in this way also: Lord, show Yourself to us, and it satisfies us. For, that he might understand this, the Lord replied to him, Have I been so long time with you, and yet have you not known me, Philip? He that has seen me has seen the Father. But because He intended him, before he could see this, to live by faith, He went on to say, Do you not believe that I am in the Father, and the Father in me? For while we are at home in the body, we are absent from the Lord, for we walk by faith, not by sight. For contemplation is the reward of faith, for which reward our hearts are purified by faith, as it is written, Purifying their hearts by faith. And that our hearts are to be purified for this contemplation is proved above all by this text, Blessed are the pure in heart, for they shall see God. And that this is life eternal, God says in the Psalm, With long life will I satisfy him, and show him my salvation. Whether, therefore, we hear, Show us the Son, or whether we hear, Show us the Father, it is all the same, since neither can be revealed without the other. For they are one, as He also Himself says, My Father and I are one. Finally, on account of this very indivisibility, it is sufficient that sometimes the Father alone, or the Son alone, should be named, as hereafter to fill us with the joy of His countenance.

17. For this contemplation is held forth to us as the end of all actions, and the everlasting fullness of joy . For we are the sons of God ; and it does not yet appear what we shall be: but we know that, when He shall appear, we shall be like Him; for we shall see Him as He is. For that which He said to His servant Moses , I am that I am; thus shall you say to the children of Israel , I Am has sent me to you; this it is which we shall contemplate when we shall live in eternity . For so it is said, And this is life eternal , that they might know You, the only true God , and Jesus Christ , whom You have sent. This shall be when the Lord shall have come, and shall have brought to light the hidden things of darkness; when the darkness of this present mortality and corruption shall have passed away. Then will be our morning, which is spoken of in the Psalm, In the morning will I direct my prayer unto You, and will contemplate You. Of this contemplation I understand it to be said, When He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God , even the Father; that is, when He shall have brought the just, over whom now, living by faith , the Mediator between God and man , the man Christ Jesus, reigns, to the contemplation of God , even the Father. If herein I am foolish, let him who knows better correct me; to me at least the case seems as I have said. For we shall not seek anything else, when we shall have come to the contemplation of Him. But that contemplation is not yet, so long as our joy is in hope. For hope that is seen is not hope: for what a man sees, why does he yet hope for? But if we hope for that we see not, then do we with patience wait for it, viz . as long as the King sits at His table. Then will take place that which is written, In Your presence is fullness of joy . Nothing more than that joy will be required; because there will be nothing more than can be required. For the Father will be manifested to us, and that will suffice for us. And this much Philip had well understood, so that he said to the Lord, Show us the Father , and it suffices us. But he had not yet understood that he himself was able to say this very same thing in this way also: Lord, show Yourself to us, and it suffices us. For, that he might understand this, the Lord replied to him, Have I been so long time with you, and yet have you not known me, Philip? He that has seen me has seen the Father. But because He intended him, before he could see this, to live by faith , He went on to say, Do you not believe that I am in the Father , and the Father in me? For while we are at home in the body, we are absent from the Lord: for we walk by faith , not by sight. For contemplation is the recompense of faith , for which recompense our hearts are purified by faith ; as it is written, Purifying their hearts by faith . And that our hearts are to be purified for this contemplation , is proved above all by this text, Blessed are the pure in heart, for they shall see God. And that this is life eternal , God says in the Psalm, With long life will I satisfy him, and show him my salvation . Whether, therefore, we hear, Show us the Son; or whether we hear, Show us the Father; it is even all one, since neither can be manifested without the other. For they are one, as He also Himself says, My Father and I are one. Finally, on account of this very indivisibility, it suffices that sometimes the Father alone, or the Son alone, should be named, as hereafter to fill us with the joy of His countenance.

The Spirit of neither the Father nor the Son is excluded here—that is, the Holy Spirit who is specially called the Spirit of truth, whom the world cannot receive. To enjoy God the Trinity, in whose image we are made, is truly the fullness of our joy, and there is no joy greater than this. For this reason, the Holy Spirit is sometimes spoken of as if He alone is enough for our blessedness. And He is indeed enough by Himself, because He cannot be separated from the Father and the Son. The Father alone is sufficient because He cannot be separated from the Son and the Holy Spirit. The Son alone is sufficient because He cannot be separated from the Father and the Holy Spirit. What does Christ mean when He says, "If you love me, keep my commandments; and I will pray the Father, and He shall give you another Comforter, that He may abide with you forever; even the Spirit of truth, whom the world cannot receive"—that is, whom the lovers of the world cannot receive? For the natural man does not receive the things of the Spirit of God. But it might seem, furthermore, as if the words "And I will pray the Father, and He shall give you another Comforter" were spoken as if the Son alone were not sufficient. And that passage speaks of the Spirit as if He alone were completely sufficient: "When He, the Spirit of truth, has come, He will guide you into all truth." Tell me, then, is the Son excluded here, as if He did not teach all truth, or as if the Holy Spirit were to complete what the Son could not fully teach? Let them say, if they wish, that the Holy Spirit is greater than the Son, whom they usually call lesser. Or is it perhaps because the text does not say "He alone" or "No one else except Himself will guide you into all truth" that they allow that the Son also may be believed to teach together with Him? In that case, the apostle has excluded the Son from knowing the things of God where he says, "Even so the things of God knows no one, but the Spirit of God"—so that these misguided people might on this basis go on to say that only the Holy Spirit teaches even the Son the things of God, as the greater teaches the lesser. To this Holy Spirit the Son Himself gives so much importance that He says, "But because I have said these things to you, sorrow has filled your heart. Nevertheless I tell you the truth: it is expedient for you that I go away, for if I do not go away, the Comforter will not come to you."

18. Neither is the Spirit of either thence excluded, that is, the Spirit of the Father and of the Son; which Holy Spirit is specially called the Spirit of truth , whom the world cannot receive. For to have the fruition of God the Trinity, after whose image we are made, is indeed the fullness of our joy , than which there is no greater. On this account the Holy Spirit is sometimes spoken of as if He alone sufficed to our blessedness: and He does alone so suffice, because He cannot be divided from the Father and the Son ; as the Father alone is sufficient, because He cannot be divided from the Son and the Holy Spirit ; and the Son alone is sufficient because He cannot be divided from the Father and the Holy Spirit . For what does He mean by saying, If you love me, keep my commandments; and I will pray the Father , and He shall give you another Comforter, that He may abide with you for ever; even the Spirit of truth , whom the world cannot receive, that is, the lovers of the world? For the natural man receives not the things of the Spirit of God . But it may perhaps seem, further, as if the words, And I will pray the Father , and He shall give you another Comforter, were so said as if the Son alone were not sufficient. And that place so speaks of the Spirit , as if He alone were altogether sufficient: When He, the Spirit of truth , has come, He will guide you into all truth . Pray, therefore, is the Son here excluded, as if He did not teach all truth , or as if the Holy Spirit were to fill up that which the Son could not fully teach? Let them say then, if it pleases them, that the Holy Spirit is greater than the Son , whom they are wont to call less. Or is it, forsooth, because it is not said, He alone — or, No one else except Himself — will guide you into all truth , that they allow that the Son also may be believed to teach together with Him? In that case the apostle has excluded the Son from knowing those things which are of God , where he says, Even so the things of God knows no one, but the Spirit of God : so that these perverse men might, upon this ground, go on to say that none but the Holy Spirit teaches even the Son the things of God , as the greater teaches the less; to whom the Son Himself ascribes so much as to say, But because I have said these things unto you, sorrow has filled your heart. Nevertheless I tell you the truth ; it is expedient for you that I go away: for if I go not away, the Comforter will not come unto you.

Chapter 9.– All are Sometimes Understood in One Person.

This is said not because the Word of God and the Holy Spirit are unequal, but because the presence of the Son of man with them would hinder the coming of the one who was not less—since he did not empty himself by taking the form of a servant as the Son did. It was necessary, then, for the form of a servant to be removed from their sight, because by gazing upon it they thought that what they saw was all that Christ was. This also explains what is said: "If you loved me, you would rejoice because I said, 'I go unto the Father; for my Father is greater than I.'" This means: it is necessary for me to go to the Father because, while you see me in this way, you consider me less than the Father through what you see. Being focused on the creature and the form I have taken upon myself, you do not perceive the equality I have with the Father. This also explains: "Touch me not; for I am not yet ascended to my Father." Touch, as it were, limits their understanding, and he did not want the thought of the heart directed toward him to be so limited that he would be considered only what he appeared to be. But the ascension to the Father meant appearing as he is equal to the Father, so that the limit of the sight that suffices us might be reached there. Sometimes it is also said of the Son alone that he himself suffices, and the whole reward of our love and longing is presented as the sight of him. For it is said: "He that has my commandments, and keeps them, he it is that loves me; and he that loves me shall be loved of my Father; and I will love him, and will manifest myself to him." Because he did not say here, "And I will show the Father also to him," has he therefore excluded the Father? On the contrary, because it is true that "I and my Father are one," when the Father is manifested, the Son also, who is in him, is manifested; and when the Son is manifested, the Father also, who is in him, is manifested. Therefore, just as when it is said, "And I will manifest myself to him," it is understood that he manifests the Father also, so likewise in what is said, "When He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God, even the Father," it is understood that he does not take it away from himself. For when he brings believers to the contemplation of God, even the Father, he will doubtless bring them to the contemplation of himself, since he has said, "And I will manifest myself to him." Consequently, when Judas said to him, "Lord, how is it that You will manifest Yourself unto us, and not unto the world?" Jesus answered and said to him, "If a man love me, he will keep my words: and my Father will love him, and we will come unto him, and make our abode with him." See, he manifests not only himself to the one who loves him, because he comes to him together with the Father and abides with him.

But this is said, not on account of any inequality of the Word of God and of the Holy Spirit , but as though the presence of the Son of man with them would be a hindrance to the coming of Him, who was not less, because He did not empty Himself, taking upon Him the form of a servant, as the Son did. It was necessary, then, that the form of a servant should be taken away from their eyes, because, through gazing upon it, they thought that alone which they saw to be Christ. Hence also is that which is said, If you loved me, you would rejoice because I said, 'I go unto the Father; for my Father is greater than I:' that is, on that account it is necessary for me to go to the Father , because, while you see me thus, you hold me to be less than the Father through that which you see; and so, being taken up with the creature and the fashion which I have taken upon me, you do not perceive the equality which I have with the Father. Hence, too, is this: Touch me not; for I am not yet ascended to my Father. For touch, as it were, puts a limit to their conception, and He therefore would not have the thought of the heart, directed towards Himself, to be so limited as that He should be held to be only that which He seemed to be. But the ascension to the Father meant, so to appear as He is equal to the Father , that the limit of the sight which suffices us might be attained there. Sometimes also it is said of the Son alone, that He himself suffices, and the whole reward of our love and longing is held forth as in the sight of Him. For so it is said, He that has my commandments, and keeps them, he it is that loves me; and he that loves me shall be loved of my Father; and I will love him, and will manifest myself to him. Pray, because He has not here said, And I will show the Father also to him, has He therefore excluded the Father? On the contrary, because it is true , I and my Father are one, when the Father is manifested, the Son also, who is in Him, is manifested; and when the Son is manifested, the Father also, who is in Him, is manifested. As, therefore, when it is said, And I will manifest myself to him, it is understood that He manifests also the Father; so likewise in that which is said, When He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God , even the Father , it is understood that He does not take it away from Himself; since, when He shall bring believers to the contemplation of God , even the Father , doubtless He will bring them to the contemplation of Himself, who has said, And I will manifest myself to him. And so, consequently, when Judas had said to Him, Lord, how is it that You will manifest Yourself unto us, and not unto the world? Jesus answered and said to him, If a man love me, he will keep my words: and my Father will love him, and we will come unto him, and make our abode with him. Behold, that He manifests not only Himself to him by whom He is loved, because He comes to him together with the Father , and abides with him.

Perhaps someone might think that when the Father and the Son make their home with the person who loves them, the Holy Spirit is excluded from that home. But what about what is said earlier concerning the Holy Spirit: "Whom the world cannot receive, because it does not see Him, but you know Him; for He abides with you, and is in you"? He is therefore not excluded from that home, since it is said of Him, "He abides with you, and is in you"—unless perhaps someone is foolish enough to think that when the Father and the Son have come to make their home with the one who loves them, the Holy Spirit will leave and make room for those who are greater. But Scripture itself opposes this fleshly notion, for it says a little earlier: "I will pray the Father, and He shall give you another Comforter, that He may abide with you forever." He will not therefore leave when the Father and the Son come, but will be in the same home with them eternally, because He will not come without them, nor they without Him. But in order to indicate the Trinity, certain things are stated separately, with each Person being individually named; yet these are not to be understood as though the other Persons were excluded, because of the unity of the same Trinity and the one ousia and Godhead of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.

19. Will it perhaps be thought, that when the Father and the Son make their abode with him who loves them, the Holy Spirit is excluded from that abode? What, then, is that which is said above of the Holy Spirit : Whom the world cannot receive, because it sees Him not: but you know Him; for He abides with you, and is in you ? He, therefore, is not excluded from that abode, of whom it is said, He abides with you, and is in you; unless, perhaps, any one be so senseless as to think, that when the Father and the Son have come that they may make their abode with him who loves them, the Holy Spirit will depart thence, and (as it were) give place to those who are greater. But the Scripture itself meets this carnal idea; for it says a little above: I will pray the Father , and He shall give you another Comforter, that He may abide with you forever. He will not therefore depart when the Father and the Son come, but will be in the same abode with them eternally ; because neither will He come without them, nor they without Him. But in order to intimate the Trinity, some things are separately affirmed, the Persons being also each severally named; and yet are not to be understood as though the other Persons were excluded, on account of the unity of the same Trinity and the One substance and Godhead of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit .

Chapter 10.– In What Manner Christ Shall Deliver Up the Kingdom to God, Even the Father. The Kingdom Having Been Delivered to God, Even the Father, Christ Will Not Then Make Intercession for Us.

Our Lord Jesus Christ will therefore deliver up the kingdom to God, even the Father, without excluding Himself or the Holy Spirit from it. He will do this when He brings believers to the contemplation of God, which is the goal of all good actions and represents everlasting rest and joy that will never be taken from us. He indicates this in His words: I will see you again, and your heart shall rejoice; and your joy no man takes from you. Mary, sitting at the Lord's feet and earnestly listening to His word, gave us a picture of this joy. She rested from all activity and focused on the truth in the way this present life allows, thereby prefiguring what will exist for eternity. While her sister Martha was busy with necessary tasks—good and useful though they were, but destined to pass away when rest comes—Mary herself was resting in the Lord's word. When Martha complained that her sister wasn't helping her, the Lord replied: Mary has chosen the best part, which shall not be taken away from her. He didn't say Martha was doing something bad, but rather that Mary had chosen the best part that will not be taken away. The part occupied with serving a need will be taken away when the need itself passes away, since the reward for good work that passes away is rest that will not pass away. In that contemplation, then, God will be all in all, because nothing else but Himself will be needed. It will be enough to be enlightened by and to enjoy Him alone. Therefore, the one in whom the Spirit makes intercession with groanings which cannot be uttered says: One thing have I desired of the Lord, that I will seek after; that I may dwell in the house of the Lord all the days of my life, to contemplate the beauty of the Lord. For we shall then contemplate God—the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit—when the Mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus, shall have delivered up the kingdom to God, even the Father. At that point He will no longer make intercession for us as our Mediator and Priest, Son of God and Son of man. Instead, He Himself too, insofar as He is a Priest who took the form of a servant for us, shall be put under Him who has put all things under Him, and under whom He has put all things. This means that insofar as He is God, He with the Father will have put us under Himself; insofar as He is a Priest, He with us will be put under the Father. Therefore, since the incarnate Son is both God and man, it is more accurate to say that the manhood in the Son is another substance from the Son, than to say that the Son in the Father is another substance from the Father. This is similar to how the bodily nature of my soul is more another substance in relation to my soul itself, even though they exist in one and the same man, than the soul of another man is in relation to my soul.

20. Our Lord Jesus Christ , therefore, will so deliver up the kingdom to God , even the Father , Himself not being thence excluded, nor the Holy Spirit , when He shall bring believers to the contemplation of God , wherein is the end of all good actions, and everlasting rest, and joy which never will be taken from us. For He signifies this in that which He says: I will see you again, and your heart shall rejoice ; and your joy no man takes from you. Mary, sitting at the feet of the Lord, and earnestly listening to His word, foreshowed a similitude of this joy ; resting as she did from all business, and intent upon the truth , according to that manner of which this life is capable, by which, however, to prefigure that which shall be for eternity . For while Martha, her sister, was cumbered about necessary business, which, although good and useful, yet, when rest shall have succeeded, is to pass away, she herself was resting in the word of the Lord. And so the Lord replied to Martha, when she complained that her sister did not help her: Mary has chosen the best part, which shall not be taken away from her. He did not say that Martha was acting a bad part; but that best part that shall not be taken away. For that part which is occupied in the ministering to a need shall be taken away when the need itself has passed away. Since the reward of a good work that will pass away is rest that will not pass away. In that contemplation , therefore, God will be all in all; because nothing else but Himself will be required, but it will be sufficient to be enlightened by and to enjoy Him alone. And so he in whom the Spirit makes intercession with groanings which cannot be uttered, says, One thing have I desired of the Lord, that I will seek after; that I may dwell in the house of the Lord all the days of my life, to contemplate the beauty of the Lord. For we shall then contemplate God , the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit , when the Mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus, shall have delivered up the kingdom to God , even the Father , so as no longer to make intercession for us, as our Mediator and Priest, Son of God and Son of man ; but that He Himself too, in so far as He is a Priest that has taken the form of a servant for us, shall be put under Him who has put all things under Him, and under whom He has put all things: so that, in so far as He is God , He with Him will have put us under Himself; in so far as He is a Priest, He with us will be put under Him. And therefore as the [incarnate] Son is both God and man , it is rather to be said that the manhood in the Son is another substance [from the Son], than that the Son in the Father [is another substance from the Father]; just as the carnal nature of my soul is more another substance in relation to my soul itself, although in one and the same man, than the soul of another man is in relation to my soul .

When Christ delivers up the kingdom to God, even the Father—that is, when He brings those who believe and live by faith, for whom He now makes intercession as Mediator, to that contemplation for which we now long and groan, and when labor and groaning have passed away—then, since the kingdom will have been delivered up to God, even the Father, He will no longer make intercession for us. He indicates this when He says: "These things I have spoken to you in similitudes; but the time comes when I will no longer speak to you in similitudes, but I will declare to you plainly of the Father"—that is, they will no longer be similitudes when the sight is face to face. For this is what He means by "I will declare to you plainly of the Father," as if He said, "I will plainly show you the Father." He says "I will declare to you" because He is His Word. For He continues: "At that day you will ask in my name; and I do not say to you that I will pray the Father for you, for the Father Himself loves you, because you have loved me and have believed that I came out from God. I came forth from the Father and have come into the world; again, I leave the world and go to the Father." What does "I came forth from the Father" mean, except that I have not appeared in that form in which I am equal to the Father, but otherwise—that is, as less than the Father in the creature I have taken upon myself? And what does "I have come into the world" mean, except that I have revealed to the eyes even of sinners who love this world the form of a servant that I took, making myself of no reputation? And what does "Again, I leave the world" mean, except that I take away from the sight of the lovers of this world what they have seen? And what does "I go to the Father" mean, except that I teach those who are my faithful ones to understand me in that being in which I am equal to the Father? Those who believe this will be counted worthy of being brought by faith to sight—that is, to that very sight, in bringing them to which He is said to deliver up the kingdom to God, even the Father. For His faithful ones, whom He has redeemed with His blood, are called His kingdom, for whom He now intercedes; but then, making them to abide in Himself there where He is equal to the Father, He will no longer pray the Father for them. For He says, "the Father Himself loves you." Indeed, He prays insofar as He is less than the Father, but as He is equal with the Father, He grants with the Father. Therefore He certainly does not exclude Himself from what He says, "The Father Himself loves you," but He means it to be understood in the manner I have spoken of above and sufficiently indicated—namely, that for the most part each Person of the Trinity is so named that the other Persons are also to be understood. Accordingly, "For the Father Himself loves you" is said in such a way that consequently both the Son and the Holy Spirit are also to be understood. This does not mean He does not love us now, since He spared not His own Son but delivered Him up for us all. But God loves us as we shall be, not as we are, for those whom He loves are such as those whom He keeps eternally, which will be the case when He who now makes intercession for us will have delivered up the kingdom to God, even the Father, so as no longer to ask the Father, because the Father Himself loves us. But for what merit, except that of faith, by which we believe before we see what is promised? For by this faith we will arrive at sight, so that He may love us, being such as He loves us in order that we may become—and not such as He hates us because we are, and exhorts and enables us to wish not to be always.

21. When, therefore, He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God , even the Father , — that is, when He shall have brought those who believe and live by faith , for whom now as Mediator He makes intercession, to that contemplation , for the obtaining of which we sigh and groan, and when labor and groaning shall have passed away — then, since the kingdom will have been delivered up to God , even the Father , He will no more make intercession for us. And this He signifies, when He says: These things have I spoken unto you in similitudes; but the time comes when I shall no more speak unto you in similitudes, but I shall declare to you plainly of the Father: that is, they will not then be similitudes, when the sight shall be face to face. For this it is which He says, But I will declare to you plainly of the Father; as if He said I will plainly show you the Father. For He says, I will declare to you, because He is His word. For He goes on to say, At that day you shall ask in my name; and I say not unto you, that I will pray the Father for you: for the Father Himself loves you, because you have loved me, and have believed that I came out from God . I came forth from the Father , and have come into the world: again, I leave the world, and go to the Father. What is meant by I came forth from the Father , unless this, that I have not appeared in that form in which I am equal to the Father , but otherwise, that is, as less than the Father , in the creature which I have taken upon me? And what is meant by I have come into the world, unless this, that I have manifested to the eyes even of sinners who love this world, the form of a servant which I took, making myself of no reputation ? And what is meant by Again, I leave the world, unless this, that I take away from the sight of the lovers of this world that which they have seen? And what is meant by I go to the Father , unless this, that I teach those who are my faithful ones to understand me in that being in which I am equal to the Father? Those who believe this will be thought worthy of being brought by faith to sight, that is, to that very sight, in bringing them to which He is said to deliver up the kingdom to God , even the Father. For His faithful ones, whom He has redeemed with His blood, are called His kingdom, for whom He now intercedes; but then, making them to abide in Himself there, where He is equal to the Father , He will no longer pray the Father for them. For, He says, the Father Himself loves you. For indeed He prays , in so far as He is less than the Father; but as He is equal with the Father , He with the Father grants. Wherefore He certainly does not exclude Himself from that which He says, The Father Himself loves you; but He means it to be understood after that manner which I have above spoken of, and sufficiently intimated — namely, that for the most part each Person of the Trinity is so named, that the other Persons also may be understood. Accordingly, For the Father Himself loves you, is so said that by consequence both the Son and the Holy Spirit also may be understood: not that He does not now love us, who spared not His own Son, but delivered Him up for us all; but God loves us, such as we shall be, not such as we are, for such as they are whom He loves, such are they whom He keeps eternally ; which shall then be, when He who now makes intercession for us shall have delivered up the kingdom to God , even the Father , so as no longer to ask the Father , because the Father Himself loves us. But for what deserving, except of faith , by which we believe before we see that which is promised? For by this faith we shall arrive at sight; so that He may love us, being such, as He loves us in order that we may become; and not such, as He hates us because we are, and exhorts and enables us to wish not to be always.

Chapter 11.– By What Rule in the Scriptures It is Understood that the Son is Now Equal and Now Less.

Therefore, once we have mastered this rule for interpreting the Scriptures concerning the Son of God—that we must distinguish what relates to the form of God, in which He is equal to the Father, and what relates to the form of a servant which He took, in which He is less than the Father—we will not be troubled by apparently contradictory and conflicting statements in the sacred books. For both the Son and the Holy Spirit, according to the form of God, are equal to the Father, because neither of them is a creature, as we have already shown. But according to the form of a servant, He is less than the Father, because He Himself said, "My Father is greater than I." And He is less than Himself, because it is said of Him, "He emptied Himself." And He is less than the Holy Spirit, because He Himself says, "Whoever speaks a word against the Son of man will be forgiven, but whoever speaks against the Holy Spirit will not be forgiven." And in the Spirit He also worked miracles, saying, "But if I cast out demons by the Spirit of God, then the kingdom of God has come upon you." And in Isaiah He says—in the passage which He Himself read in the synagogue and showed without any doubt to be fulfilled concerning Himself—"The Spirit of the Lord God is upon me, because He has anointed me to preach good news to the poor. He has sent me to proclaim liberty to the captives," and so on. He declares that He was sent to do these things because the Spirit of God is upon Him. According to the form of God, all things were made by Him. According to the form of a servant, He was Himself made of a woman, made under the law. According to the form of God, He and the Father are one. According to the form of a servant, He came not to do His own will, but the will of Him who sent Him. According to the form of God, "As the Father has life in Himself, so He has given to the Son to have life in Himself." According to the form of a servant, His soul is sorrowful even to death, and He says, "O my Father, if it is possible, let this cup pass from me." According to the form of God, He is the true God and eternal life. According to the form of a servant, He became obedient to death, even death on a cross. According to the form of God, all things that the Father has are His, and He says, "All that is mine is Yours, and Yours is mine." According to the form of a servant, the teaching is not His own, but belongs to Him who sent Him.

22. Wherefore, having mastered this rule for interpreting the Scriptures concerning the Son of God , that we are to distinguish in them what relates to the form of God , in which He is equal to the Father , and what to the form of a servant which He took, in which He is less than the Father; we shall not be disquieted by apparently contrary and mutually repugnant sayings of the sacred books. For both the Son and the Holy Spirit , according to the form of God , are equal to the Father , because neither of them is a creature, as we have already shown: but according to the form of a servant He is less than the Father , because He Himself has said, My Father is greater than I; and He is less than Himself, because it is said of Him, He emptied Himself; and He is less than the Holy Spirit , because He Himself says, Whosoever speaks a word against the Son of man , it shall be forgiven him; but whosoever speaks against the Holy Ghost , it shall not be forgiven Him. And in the Spirit too He wrought miracles , saying: But if I with the Spirit of God cast out devils, no doubt the kingdom of God has come upon you. And in Isaiah He says — in the lesson which He Himself read in the synagogue , and showed without a scruple of doubt to be fulfilled concerning Himself — The Spirit of the Lord God , He says, is upon me: because He has anointed me to preach good tidings unto the meek He has sent me to proclaim liberty to the captives, etc.: for the doing of which things He therefore declares Himself to be sent, because the Spirit of God is upon Him. According to the form of God , all things were made by Him; according to the form of a servant, He was Himself made of a woman , made under the law. According to the form of God , He and the Father are one; according to the form of a servant, He came not to do His own will, but the will of Him that sent Him. According to the form of God , As the Father has life in Himself, so has He given to the Son to have life in Himself; according to the form of a servant, His soul is sorrowful even unto death; and, O my Father, He says, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me. According to the form of God , He is the True God , and eternal life; according to the form of a servant, He became obedient unto death, even the death of the cross. — 23. According to the form of God , all things that the Father has are His, and All mine, He says, are Yours, and Yours are mine; according to the form of a servant, the doctrine is not His own, but His that sent Him.

Chapter 12.– In What Manner the Son is Said Not to Know the Day and the Hour Which the Father Knows. Some Things Said of Christ According to the Form of God, Other Things According to the Form of a Servant. In What Way It is of Christ to Give the Kingdom, in What Not of Christ. Christ Will Both Judge and Not Judge.

Again, "Of that day and that hour knows no man, no, not the angels which are in heaven; neither the Son, but the Father." For He is ignorant of this in the sense of making others ignorant—that is, He did not know it in such a way as to reveal it to His disciples at that time. This is similar to what was said to Abraham, "Now I know that you fear God," which means "now I have caused you to know it," because Abraham, being tested in that trial, came to know this about himself. For Christ was certainly going to tell His disciples this same thing at the proper time. Speaking of this future event as if it were already past, He says, "From now on I call you not servants, but friends; for the servant does not know what his Lord does, but I have called you friends, for all things that I have heard of my Father I have made known to you." He had not yet done this, but spoke as though He had already done it, because He certainly would do it. For He says to the disciples themselves, "I have yet many things to say to you, but you cannot bear them now." Among these things is to be understood also the matter of the day and hour. For the apostle Paul also says, "I determined not to know anything among you, except Jesus Christ, and Him crucified," because he was speaking to those who were not able to receive higher teachings concerning the Godhead of Christ. To them he also says a little later, "I could not speak to you as to spiritual people, but as to fleshly." He was ignorant, therefore, among them of what they were not able to learn from him. And he said he knew only what it was fitting for them to know from him. In short, he knew among the mature what he did not know among infants, for he says there, "We speak wisdom among those who are mature." For a man is said not to know what he conceals, according to that kind of speech by which a ditch is called blind when it is hidden. For the Scriptures do not use any other kind of speech than may be found in use among people, because they speak to people.

Again, Of that day and that hour knows no man, no, not the angels which are in heaven; neither the Son , but the Father. For He is ignorant of this, as making others ignorant ; that is, in that He did not so know as at that time to show His disciples : as it was said to Abraham , Now I know that you fear God , that is, now I have caused you to know it; because he himself, being tried in that temptation , became known to himself. For He was certainly going to tell this same thing to His disciples at the fitting time; speaking of which yet future as if past, He says, Henceforth I call you not servants, but friends; for the servant knows not what his Lord does: but I have called you friends; for all things that I have heard of my Father I have made known unto you; which He had not yet done, but spoke as though He had already done it, because He certainly would do it. For He says to the disciples themselves, I have yet many things to say unto you; but you cannot bear them now. Among which is to be understood also, Of the day and hour. For the apostle also says, I determined not to know anything among you, save Jesus Christ , and Him crucified; because he was speaking to those who were not able to receive higher things concerning the Godhead of Christ . To whom also a little while after he says, I could not speak unto you as unto spiritual, but as unto carnal. He was ignorant , therefore, among them of that which they were not able to know from him. And that only he said that he knew , which it was fitting that they should know from him. In short, he knew among the perfect what he knew not among babes; for he there says: We speak wisdom among them that are perfect. For a man is said not to know what he hides, after that kind of speech, after which a ditch is called blind which is hidden. For the Scriptures do not use any other kind of speech than may be found in use among men , because they speak to men.

According to the form of God, it is said "Before all the hills He begot me," that is, before all the heights of created things, and "Before the dawn I begot You," that is, before all times and temporal things. But according to the form of a servant, it is said "The Lord created me in the beginning of His ways." Because, according to the form of God, He said "I am the truth," and according to the form of a servant, "I am the way." Since He Himself, being the first-begotten of the dead, made a passage to the kingdom of God and to eternal life for His Church, to which He is the Head in such a way as to make the body also immortal, therefore He was created in the beginning of the ways of God in His work. For according to the form of God, He is the beginning who also speaks to us, in which beginning God created the heaven and the earth. But according to the form of a servant, He is a bridegroom coming out of His chamber. According to the form of God, He is the first-born of every creature, and He is before all things and by Him all things hold together. According to the form of a servant, He is the head of the body, the Church. According to the form of God, He is the Lord of glory. From this it is clear that He Himself glorifies His saints, for "Whom He predestined, them He also called; and whom He called, them He also justified; and whom He justified, them He also glorified." Accordingly, it is said of Him that He justifies the ungodly. Of Him it is said that He is just and a justifier. If, therefore, He has also glorified those whom He has justified, then He who justifies also Himself glorifies. He is, as I have said, the Lord of glory. Yet according to the form of a servant, He replied to His disciples when they were inquiring about their own glorification: "To sit on my right hand and on my left is not mine to give, but it shall be given to them for whom it is prepared by my Father."

24. According to the form of God , it is said Before all the hills He begot me, that is, before all the loftinesses of things created and, Before the dawn I begot You, that is, before all times and temporal things: but according to the form of a servant, it is said, The Lord created me in the beginning of His ways. Because, according to the form of God , He said, I am the truth ; and according to the form of a servant, I am the way. For, because He Himself, being the first-begotten of the dead, made a passage to the kingdom of God to life eternal for His Church, to which He is so the Head as to make the body also immortal , therefore He was created in the beginning of the ways of God in His work. For, according to the form of God , He is the beginning, that also speaks unto us, in which beginning God created the heaven and the earth; but according to the form of a servant, He is a bridegroom coming out of His chamber. According to the form of God , He is the first-born of every creature, and He is before all things and by him all things consist; according to the form of a servant, He is the head of the body, the Church . According to the form of God , He is the Lord of glory . From which it is evident that He Himself glorifies His saints : for, Whom He did predestinate , them He also called; and whom He called, them He also justified; and whom He justified, them He also glorified . Of Him accordingly it is said, that He justifies the ungodly; of Him it is said, that He is just and a justifier. If, therefore, He has also glorified those whom He has justified, He who justifies, Himself also glorifies; who is, as I have said, the Lord of glory . Yet, according to the form of a servant, He replied to His disciples , when inquiring about their own glorification: To sit on my right hand and on my left is not mine to give, but [it shall be given to them] for whom it is prepared by my Father.

According to the form of God, He and the Father are one, so what the Father prepares is also prepared by the Son Himself. We have already shown through many passages in the divine Scriptures that in this Trinity, what is said of each person is also said of all, because of the indivisible working of one and the same substance. For example, Christ says of the Holy Spirit, "If I depart, I will send Him unto you." He did not say "We will send," but spoke as if the Son alone would send Him, not the Father. Yet in another place He says, "These things have I spoken unto you, being yet present with you; but the Comforter, which is the Holy Ghost, whom the Father will send in my name, He shall teach you all things." Here again He speaks as if the Son would not send Him, but only the Father. Therefore, just as in these texts, so also when He says, "But for them for whom it is prepared by my Father," He means us to understand that He Himself, together with the Father, prepares seats of glory for those for whom He will. But someone may object: In the passages about the Holy Spirit, He says He will send Him without denying the Father will send Him, and says the Father will send Him without denying He will do so Himself; but here He explicitly says, "It is not mine to give," and then says these things are prepared by the Father. However, this is exactly what we have already established as being said according to the form of a servant: namely, that we should understand "It is not mine to give" as if He said, "This is not in the power of man to give," so that He may be understood to give it through that wherein He is God equal to the Father. "It is not mine," He says, "to give"—that is, I do not give these things by human power, but to those for whom it is prepared by my Father; but understand also that if all things which the Father has are mine, then this certainly is mine also, and I together with the Father have prepared these things.

25. But that which is prepared by His Father is prepared also by the Son Himself, because He and the Father are one. For we have already shown, by many modes of speech in the divine Scriptures , that, in this Trinity, what is said of each is also said of all, on account of the indivisible working of the one and same substance. As He also says of the Holy Spirit , If I depart, I will send Him unto you. He did not say, We will send; but in such way as if the Son only should send Him, and not the Father; while yet He says in another place, These things have I spoken unto you, being yet present with you; but the Comforter, which is the Holy Ghost , whom the Father will send in my name, He shall teach you all things. Here again it is so said as if the Son also would not send Him, but the Father only. As therefore in these texts, so also where He says, But for them for whom it is prepared by my Father, He meant it to be understood that He Himself, with the Father , prepares seats of glory for those for whom He will. But some one may say: There, when He spoke of the Holy Spirit , He so says that He Himself will send Him, as not to deny that the Father will send Him; and in the other place, He so says that the Father will send Him, as not to deny that He will do so Himself; but here He expressly says, It is not mine to give, and so goes on to say that these things are prepared by the Father. But this is the very thing which we have already laid down to be said according to the form of a servant: viz. , that we are so to understand It is not mine to give, as if it were said, This is not in the power of man to give; that so He may be understood to give it through that wherein He is God equal to the Father. It is not mine, He says, to give; that is, I do not give these things by human power, but to those for whom it is prepared by my Father; but then take care you understand also, that if all things which the Father has are mine, then this certainly is mine also, and I with the Father have prepared these things.

26. I ask again, in what sense is it said, "If any man does not hear my words, I will not judge him"? Perhaps He said "I will not judge him" here in the same sense as He said elsewhere "It is not mine to give." But what follows here? "I came not," He says, "to judge the world, but to save the world"; and then He adds, "He that rejects me and does not receive my words has one that judges him." Now here we would naturally understand this to mean the Father, except that He added, "The word that I have spoken, the same shall judge him in the last day." Well then, will neither the Son judge, because He says "I will not judge him," nor the Father, but rather the word which the Son has spoken? No, but hear what follows next: "For I," He says, "have not spoken of myself; but the Father who sent me, He gave me a commandment, what I should say and what I should speak; and I know that His commandment is life everlasting: therefore whatever I speak, even as the Father said to me, so I speak." If therefore the Son does not judge, but the word which the Son has spoken does; and the word which the Son has spoken judges because the Son has not spoken of Himself, but the Father who sent Him gave Him a commandment what He should say and what He should speak: then certainly the Father judges, whose word it is that the Son has spoken; and this same Son Himself is the very Word of the Father. For the commandment of the Father is not one thing and the word of the Father another; for He has called it both a word and a commandment. Let us see, therefore, whether perhaps when He says "I have not spoken of myself," He meant to be understood thus: "I am not born of myself." For if He speaks the word of the Father, then He speaks Himself, because He is Himself the Word of the Father. Ordinarily when He says "The Father gave to me," He means it to be understood that the Father begot Him—not that He gave something to Him who already existed and did not possess it, but that the very meaning of "To have given that He might have" is "To have begotten that He might be." For it is not with the Son of God—before the incarnation and before He took upon Him our flesh, the Only-begotten by whom all things were made—as it is with the creature: that He is one thing and has another. Rather He is in such a way as to be what He has. And this is said more plainly, if anyone is able to receive it, in that place where He says: "For as the Father has life in Himself, so has He given to the Son to have life in Himself." For He did not give to Him—already existing and not having life—that He should have life in Himself; rather, in that He is, He is life. Therefore "He gave to the Son to have life in Himself" means He begot the Son to be unchangeable life, which is life eternal. Since, therefore, the Word of God is the Son of God, and the Son of God is the true God and eternal life, as John says in his Epistle, what else are we to acknowledge here when the Lord says "The word which I have spoken, the same shall judge him at the last day," and calls that very word the word of the Father and the commandment of the Father, and that very commandment everlasting life? And "I know," He says, "that His commandment is life everlasting."

26. For I ask again, in what manner this is said, If any man hear not my words, I will not judge him? For perhaps He has said here, I will not judge him, in the same sense as there, It is not mine to give. But what follows here? I came not, He says, to judge the world, but to save the world; and then He adds, He that rejects me, and receives not my words, has one that judges him. Now here we should understand the Father , unless He had added, The word that I have spoken, the same shall judge him in the last day. Well, then, will neither the Son judge, because He says, I will not judge him, nor the Father , but the word which the Son has spoken? Nay, but hear what yet follows: For I, He says, have not spoken of myself; but the Father which sent me, He gave me a commandment, what I should say, and what I should speak; and I know that His commandment is life everlasting: whatsoever I speak therefore, even as the Father said to me, so I speak. If therefore the Son judges not, but the word which the Son has spoken; and the word which the Son has spoken therefore judges, because the Son has not spoken of Himself, but the Father who sent Him gave Him a commandment what He should say, and what He should speak: then the Father assuredly judges, whose word it is which the Son has spoken; and the same Son Himself is the very Word of the Father. For the commandment of the Father is not one thing, and the word of the Father another; for He has called it both a word and a commandment. Let us see, therefore, whether perchance, when He says, I have not spoken of myself, He meant to be understood thus — I am not born of myself. For if He speaks the word of the Father , then He speaks Himself, because He is Himself the Word of the Father. For ordinarily He says, The Father gave to me; by which He means it to be understood that the Father begot Him: not that He gave anything to Him, already existing and not possessing it; but that the very meaning of, To have given that He might have, is, To have begotten that He might be. For it is not, as with the creature so with the Son of God before the incarnation and before He took upon Him our flesh, the Only-begotten by whom all things were made; that He is one thing, and has another: but He is in such way as to be what He has . And this is said more plainly, if any one is fit to receive it, in that place where He says: For as the Father has life in Himself, so has He given to the Son to have life in Himself. For He did not give to Him, already existing and not having life, that He should have life in Himself; inasmuch as, in that He is , He is life. Therefore He gave to the Son to have life in Himself means, He begot the Son to be unchangeable life, which is life eternal . Since, therefore, the Word of God is the Son of God , and the Son of God is the true God and eternal life, as John says in his Epistle; so here, what else are we to acknowledge when the Lord says, The word which I have spoken, the same shall judge him at the last day, and calls that very word the word of the Father and the commandment of the Father , and that very commandment everlasting life? And I know , He says, that His commandment is life everlasting.

I'm asking, then, how we should understand "I will not judge him; but the Word which I have spoken shall judge him." From what follows, this seems to be said as if He meant, "I will not judge, but the Word of the Father will judge." But the Word of the Father is the Son of God Himself. Should we understand it this way: "I will not judge, but I will judge"? How can this be true unless we take it like this: I will not judge by human power, because I am the Son of man; but I will judge by the power of the Word, because I am the Son of God? Or if it still seems contradictory and inconsistent to say "I will not judge, but I will judge," what should we say about that passage where He says, "My doctrine is not mine"? How is it His when it is not His? He didn't say "This doctrine is not mine," but "My doctrine is not mine." What He called His own, He also called not His own. How can this be true unless He called it His own in one respect and not His own in another? According to the form of God, it is His own; according to the form of a servant, it is not His own. When He says "It is not mine, but His that sent me," He directs us back to the Word itself. For the doctrine of the Father is the Word of the Father, which is the Only Son. And what does this mean: "He that believes in me, believes not on me"? How can someone believe in Him yet not believe in Him? How can such an opposite and inconsistent thing be understood—"Whoever believes in me," He says, "believes not on me, but on Him that sent me"—unless you understand it this way: whoever believes in me believes not in what he sees, so that our hope won't rest in the creature, but in Him who took the creature in order to appear to human eyes and so cleanse our hearts by faith to see Himself as equal to the Father? So when He directs the attention of believers to the Father and says "believes not on me, but on Him that sent me," He certainly didn't mean to separate Himself from the Father, that is, from Him that sent Him. Rather, He meant that people should believe in Himself in the same way they believe in the Father, to whom He is equal. He says this explicitly in another place: "You believe in God, believe also in me"—that is, in the same way as you believe in God, so also believe in me, because I and the Father are One God. Therefore, just as here He has, in a sense, withdrawn people's faith from Himself and transferred it to the Father by saying "believes not on me, but on Him that sent me"—from whom He certainly didn't separate Himself—so also when He says "It is not mine to give, but it shall be given to them for whom it is prepared by my Father," it's clear, I think, in what respect both should be taken. That other statement is of the same kind: "I will not judge," whereas He Himself shall judge the living and the dead. But because He will not do so by human power, He therefore, returning to the Godhead, lifts people's hearts upward—hearts which He Himself came down to raise up.

27. I ask, therefore, how we are to understand, I will not judge him; but the Word which I have spoken shall judge him: which appears from what follows to be so said, as if He would say, I will not judge; but the Word of the Father will judge. But the Word of the Father is the Son of God Himself. Is it to be so understood: I will not judge, but I will judge? How can this be true , unless in this way: viz ., I will not judge by human power, because I am the Son of man ; but I will judge by the power of the Word, because I am the Son of God ? Or if it still seems contradictory and inconsistent to say, I will not judge, but I will judge; what shall we say of that place where He says, My doctrine is not mine? How mine, when not mine? For He did not say, This doctrine is not mine, but My doctrine is not mine: that which He called His own, the same He called not His own. How can this be true , unless He has called it His own in one relation; not His own, in another? According to the form of God , His own; according to the form of a servant, not His own. For when He says, It is not mine, but His that sent me, He makes us recur to the Word itself. For the doctrine of the Father is the Word of the Father , which is the Only Son. And what, too, does that mean, He that believes in me, believes not on me? How believe in Him, yet not believe in Him? How can so opposite and inconsistent a thing be understood — Whoever believes in me, He says, believes not on me, but on Him that sent me; — unless you so understand it, Whoever believes in me believes not on that which he sees, lest our hope should be in the creature; but on Him who took the creature, whereby He might appear to human eyes, and so might cleanse our hearts by faith , to contemplate Himself as equal to the Father? So that in turning the attention of believers to the Father , and saying, Believes not on me, but on Him that sent me, He certainly did not mean Himself to be separated from the Father , that is, from Him that sent Him; but that men might so believe in Himself, as they believe in the Father , to whom He is equal. And this He says in express terms in another place, You believe in God , believe also in me: that is, in the same way as you believe in God , so also believe in me; because I and the Father are One God. As therefore, here, He has as it were withdrawn the faith of men from Himself, and transferred it to the Father , by saying, Believes not on me, but on Him that sent me, from whom nevertheless He certainly did not separate Himself; so also, when He says, It is not mine to give, but [it shall be given to them] for whom it is prepared by my Father, it is I think plain in what relation both are to be taken. For that other also is of the same kind, I will not judge; whereas He Himself shall judge the quick and dead. But because He will not do so by human power, therefore, reverting to the Godhead, He raises the hearts of men upwards; which to lift up, He Himself came down.

Chapter 13.– Diverse Things are Spoken Concerning the Same Christ, on Account of the Diverse Natures of the One Hypostasis [Theanthropic Person]. Why It is Said that the Father Will Not Judge, But Has Given Judgment to the Son.

Yet unless the very same person were the Son of man because of the form of a servant which He took, who is the Son of God because of the form of God in which He exists, the apostle Paul would not say of the rulers of this world, "For had they known it, they would not have crucified the Lord of glory." For He was crucified according to the form of a servant, and yet the Lord of glory was crucified. For that taking was such that it made God man, and man God. Yet what is said because of what, and what is said according to what, the thoughtful, diligent, and pious reader discerns for himself, with the Lord's help. For instance, we have said that He glorifies His own as being God, and certainly then as being the Lord of glory; and yet the Lord of glory was crucified, because even God is rightly said to have been crucified, not according to the power of the divinity, but according to the weakness of the flesh. Just as we say that He judges as God, that is, by divine power, not by human power; and yet the man Himself will judge, just as the Lord of glory was crucified. For so He expressly says, "When the Son of man shall come in His glory, and all the holy angels with Him, and before Him shall be gathered all nations," and the rest that is foretold of the future judgment in that passage even to the last sentence. And the Jews, inasmuch as they will be punished in that judgment for persisting in their wickedness, as it is written elsewhere, shall look upon Him whom they have pierced. For whereas both good and bad shall see the Judge of the living and dead, without doubt the bad will not be able to see Him except according to the form in which He is the Son of man; but yet in the glory in which He will judge, not in the lowliness in which He was judged. But the ungodly without doubt will not see that form of God in which He is equal to the Father. For they are not pure in heart, and "Blessed are the pure in heart, for they shall see God." And that sight is face to face, the very sight that is promised as the highest reward to the righteous, and which will then take place when He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God, even the Father. And in this kingdom He means the sight of His own form also to be understood, the whole creation being made subject to God, including that wherein the Son of God was made the Son of man. Because, according to this creation, "The Son also Himself shall be subject unto Him who put all things under Him, that God may be all in all." Otherwise, if the Son of God, judging in the form in which He is equal to the Father, shall appear when He judges to the ungodly also, what becomes of that which He promises, as some great thing, to him who loves Him, saying, "And I will love him, and will manifest myself to him"? Therefore He will judge as the Son of man, yet not by human power, but by that whereby He is the Son of God; and on the other hand, He will judge as the Son of God, yet not appearing in that form in which He is God equal to the Father, but in that form in which He is the Son of man.

28. Yet unless the very same were the Son of man on account of the form of a servant which He took, who is the Son of God on account of the form of God in which He is; Paul the apostle would not say of the princes of this world, For had they known it, they would not have crucified the Lord of glory . For He was crucified after the form of a servant, and yet the Lord of glory was crucified. For that taking was such as to make God man, and man God. Yet what is said on account of what, and what according to what, the thoughtful, diligent, and pious reader discerns for himself, the Lord being his helper. For instance, we have said that He glorifies His own, as being God , and certainly then as being the Lord of glory ; and yet the Lord of glory was crucified, because even God is rightly said to have been crucified, not after the power of the divinity, but after the weakness of the flesh: just as we say, that He judges as God , that is, by divine power, not by human ; and yet the man Himself will judge, just as the Lord of glory was crucified: for so He expressly says, When the Son of man shall come in His glory , and all the holy angels with Him, and before Him shall be gathered all nations; and the rest that is foretold of the future judgment in that place even to the last sentence. And the Jews , inasmuch as they will be punished in that judgment for persisting in their wickedness , as it is elsewhere written, shall look upon Him whom they have pierced. For whereas both good and bad shall see the Judge of the quick and dead, without doubt the bad will not be able to see Him, except after the form in which He is the Son of man ; but yet in the glory wherein He will judge, not in the lowliness wherein He was judged. But the ungodly without doubt will not see that form of God in which He is equal to the Father. For they are not pure in heart; and Blessed are the pure in heart: for they shall see God. And that sight is face to face, the very sight that is promised as the highest reward to the just, and which will then take place when He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God , even the Father; and in this kingdom He means the sight of His own form also to be understood, the whole creature being made subject to God , including that wherein the Son of God was made the Son of man . Because, according to this creature, The Son also Himself shall be subject unto Him, that put all things under Him, that God may be all in all. Otherwise if the Son of God , judging in the form in which He is equal to the Father , shall appear when He judges to the ungodly also; what becomes of that which He promises, as some great thing, to him who loves Him, saying, And I will love him, and will manifest myself to him? Wherefore He will judge as the Son of man , yet not by human power, but by that whereby He is the Son of God ; and on the other hand, He will judge as the Son of God , yet not appearing in that [unincarnate] form in which He is God equal to the Father , but in that [incarnate form] in which He is the Son of man .

Therefore we can speak both ways: the Son of man will judge, and the Son of man will not judge. The Son of man will judge, so that the text "When the Son of man shall come, then before Him shall be gathered all nations" may be true. And the Son of man will not judge, so that the texts "I will not judge him" and "I seek not my own glory: there is One that seeks and judges" may be true. For in the judgment, it is not the form of God but the form of the Son of man that will appear, and in this respect the Father Himself will not judge. For according to this it is said, "For the Father judges no man, but has committed all judgment unto the Son." This statement is made either according to that mode of speech we mentioned above, where it says "So has He given to the Son to have life in Himself," which signifies that in this way He begot the Son, or according to what the apostle says: "Wherefore God also has highly exalted Him, and given Him a name which is above every name." This is said of the Son of man, in respect to whom the Son of God was raised from the dead, since He, being in the form of God equal to the Father, from which He emptied Himself by taking the form of a servant, both acts and suffers and receives in that same form of a servant what the apostle continues to mention: "He humbled Himself, and became obedient unto death, even the death of the cross; wherefore God also has highly exalted Him, and given Him a name which is above every name; that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, of things in heaven, and things in earth, and things under the earth; and that every tongue should confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, in the Glory of God the Father." Whether then the words "He has committed all judgment unto the Son" are said according to this or that mode of speech, it is sufficiently clear from this passage that if they were said according to the sense in which it says "He has given to the Son to have life in Himself," it certainly would not be said "The Father judges no man." For in respect to this, that the Father has begotten the Son equal to Himself, He judges with Him. Therefore it is in this respect that it is said that in the judgment, not the form of God but the form of the Son of man will appear. This does not mean He will not judge who has committed all judgment unto the Son, since the Son says of Him, "There is One that seeks and judges." Rather, it is said "The Father judges no man, but has committed all judgment unto the Son" as if to say: No one will see the Father in the judgment of the quick and the dead, but all will see the Son, because He is also the Son of man, so that He can be seen even by the ungodly, since they too shall see Him whom they have pierced.

29. Therefore both ways of speaking may be used; the Son of man will judge, and, the Son of man will not judge: since the Son of man will judge, that the text may be true which says, When the Son of man shall come, then before Him shall be gathered all nations; and the Son of man will not judge, that the text may be true which says, I will not judge him; and, I seek not my own glory : there is One that seeks and judges. For in respect to this, that in the judgment, not the form of God , but the form of the Son of man will appear, the Father Himself will not judge; for according to this it is said, For the Father judges no man, but has committed all judgment unto the Son. Whether this is said after that mode of speech which we have mentioned above, where it is said, So has He given to the Son to have life in Himself, that it should signify that so He begot the Son; or, whether after that of which the apostle speaks, saying, Wherefore God also has highly exalted Him, and given Him a name which is above every name: — (For this is said of the Son of man , in respect to whom the Son of God was raised from the dead; since He, being in the form of God equal to the Father , wherefrom He emptied Himself by taking the form of a servant, both acts and suffers, and receives, in that same form of a servant, what the apostle goes on to mention: He humbled Himself, and became obedient unto death, even the death of the cross; wherefore God also has highly exalted Him, and given Him a name which is above every name; that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, of things in heaven, and things in earth, and things under the earth; and that every tongue should confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, in the Glory of God the Father: — whether then the words, He has committed all judgment unto the Son , are said according to this or that mode of speech; it sufficiently appears from this place, that if they were said according to that sense in which it is said, He has given to the Son to have life in Himself, it certainly would not be said, The Father judges no man. For in respect to this, that the Father has begotten the Son equal to Himself, He judges with Him. Therefore it is in respect to this that it is said, that in the judgment, not the form of God , but the form of the Son of man will appear. Not that He will not judge, who has committed all judgment unto the Son , since the Son says of Him, There is One that seeks and judges: but it is so said, The Father judges no man, but has committed all judgment unto the Son; as if it were said, No one will see the Father in the judgment of the quick and the dead, but all will see the Son: because He is also the Son of man , so that He can be seen even by the ungodly, since they too shall see Him whom they have pierced.

However, to avoid appearing to conjecture this rather than proving it clearly, let us present a certain and plain statement of the Lord Himself, by which we may show that this was the reason why He said, The Father judges no man, but has committed all judgment unto the Son—namely, because He will appear as Judge in the form of the Son of man, which is not the form of the Father but of the Son. Nor is it even that form of the Son in which He is equal to the Father, but that in which He is less than the Father, so that in the judgment He may be visible both to the good and to the bad. For a little while later He says, Verily, verily, I say unto you, He that hears my word, and believes in Him that sent me, has everlasting life, and shall not come into condemnation; but shall pass from death unto life. Now this eternal life is that vision which does not belong to the bad. Then follows, Verily, verily, I say unto you, The hour is coming, and now is, when the dead shall hear the voice of the Son of God, and they that hear shall live. And this applies to the godly, who hear of His incarnation in such a way as to believe that He is the Son of God—that is, who receive Him, made less than the Father for their sake in the form of a servant, while believing Him equal to the Father in the form of God. And then He continues, emphasizing this very point, For as the Father has life in Himself, so has He given to the Son to have life in Himself. And then He comes to the vision of His own glory, in which He shall come to judgment, which vision will be common to the ungodly and to the just. For He goes on to say, And has given Him authority to execute judgment also, because He is the Son of man. I think nothing can be more clear. For insofar as the Son of God is equal to the Father, He does not receive this power of executing judgment, but He has it with the Father in secret. But He receives it so that the good and the bad may see Him judging, insofar as He is the Son of man. Since the vision of the Son of man will be shown to the bad also, for the vision of the form of God will not be shown except to the pure in heart, for they shall see God—that is, to the godly only, to whose love He promises this very thing, that He will show Himself to them. And see accordingly what follows: Marvel not at this, He says. Why does He forbid us to marvel, unless it be that, in truth, everyone marvels who does not understand that He said the Father gave Him power also to execute judgment because He is the Son of man, whereas it might rather have been expected that He would say, since He is the Son of God? But because the wicked are not able to see the Son of God as He is in the form of God equal to the Father, and yet it is necessary that both the just and the wicked should see the Judge of the living and dead when they are judged in His presence—Marvel not at this, He says, for the hour is coming, in which all that are in the graves shall hear His voice, and shall come forth; they that have done good, unto the resurrection of life; and they that have done evil, unto the resurrection of damnation. For this purpose, then, it was necessary that He should receive that power because He is the Son of man, so that all in rising again might see Him in the form in which He can be seen by all, but by some to damnation, by others to eternal life. And what is eternal life, unless that vision which is not granted to the ungodly? That they might know You, He says, the One true God, and Jesus Christ, whom You have sent. And how are they to know Jesus Christ Himself also, unless as the One true God, who will show Himself to them—not as He will show Himself in the form of the Son of man to those also who shall be punished?

30. Lest, however, we may seem to conjecture this rather than to prove it clearly, let us produce a certain and plain sentence of the Lord Himself, by which we may show that this was the cause why He said, The Father judges no man, but has committed all judgment unto the Son , viz . because He will appear as Judge in the form of the Son of man , which is not the form of the Father , but of the Son; nor yet that form of the Son in which He is equal to the Father , but that in which He is less than the Father; in order that, in the judgment, He may be visible both to the good and to the bad. For a little while after He says, Verily, verily, I say unto you, He that hears my word, and believes in Him that sent me, has everlasting life, and shall not come into condemnation; but shall pass from death unto life. Now this life eternal is that sight which does not belong to the bad. Then follows, Verily, verily, I say unto you, The hour is coming, and now is, when the dead shall hear the voice of the Son of God , and they that hear shall live. And this is proper to the godly, who so hear of His incarnation , as to believe that He is the Son of God , that is, who so receive Him, as made for their sakes less than the Father , in the form of a servant, that they believe Him equal to the Father , in the form of God . And thereupon He continues, enforcing this very point, For as the Father has life in Himself, so has He given to the Son to have life in Himself. And then He comes to the sight of His own glory , in which He shall come to judgment; which sight will be common to the ungodly and to the just. For He goes on to say, And has given Him authority to execute judgment also, because He is the Son of man . I think nothing can be more clear. For inasmuch as the Son of God is equal to the Father , He does not receive this power of executing judgment, but He has it with the Father in secret; but He receives it, so that the good and the bad may see Him judging, inasmuch as He is the Son of man . Since the sight of the Son of man will be shown to the bad also: for the sight of the form of God will not be shown except to the pure in heart, for they shall see God ; that is, to the godly only, to whose love He promises this very thing, that He will show Himself to them. And see, accordingly, what follows: Marvel not at this, He says. Why does He forbid us to marvel, unless it be that, in truth , every one marvels who does not understand, that therefore He said the Father gave Him power also to execute judgment, because He is the Son of man ; whereas, it might rather have been anticipated that He would say, since He is the Son of God ? But because the wicked are not able to see the Son of God as He is in the form of God equal to the Father , but yet it is necessary that both the just and the wicked should see the Judge of the quick and dead, when they will be judged in His presence; Marvel not at this, He says, for the hour is coming, in the which all that are in the graves shall hear His voice, and shall come forth; they that have done good, unto the resurrection of life; and they that have done evil , unto the resurrection of damnation. For this purpose, then, it was necessary that He should therefore receive that power, because He is the Son of man , in order that all in rising again might see Him in the form in which He can be seen by all, but by some to damnation, by others to life eternal . And what is life eternal , unless that sight which is not granted to the ungodly? That they might know You, He says, the One true God , and Jesus Christ , whom You have sent. And how are they to know Jesus Christ Himself also, unless as the One true God , who will show Himself to them; not as He will show Himself, in the form of the Son of man , to those also that shall be punished?

He is good according to that sight by which God appears to the pure in heart, for truly God is good to Israel, even to those who are clean in heart. But when the wicked see the Judge, He will not seem good to them, because they will not rejoice in their heart to see Him. Instead, all kindreds of the earth will wail because of Him, being counted among all the wicked and unbelievers. For this reason, He also replied to the man who had called Him Good Master, when seeking His advice on how to attain eternal life, Why do you ask me about good? There is none good but One, that is, God. And yet the Lord Himself, in another place, calls man good: A good man, He says, out of the good treasure of his heart, brings forth good things, and an evil man, out of the evil treasure of his heart, brings forth evil things. But because that man was seeking eternal life, and eternal life consists in that contemplation in which God is seen, not for punishment, but for everlasting joy, and because he did not understand with whom he was speaking, and thought Him to be only the Son of man, He says, Why do you ask me about good? That is, with respect to that form which you see, why do you ask about good, and call me, according to what you see, Good Master? This is the form of the Son of man, the form which has been taken, the form that will appear in judgment, not only to the righteous, but also to the ungodly, and the sight of this form will not be for good to those who are wicked. But there is a sight of that form of mine, in which when I was, I thought it not robbery to be equal with God, but in order to take this form I emptied myself. That one God, therefore, the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, who will not appear except for joy which cannot be taken away from the just, for which future joy he sighs who says, One thing have I desired of the Lord, that will I seek after, that I may dwell in the house of the Lord all the days of my life, to behold the beauty of the Lord. That one God, therefore, Himself, I say, is alone good, for this reason, that no one sees Him for sorrow and wailing, but only for salvation and true joy. If you understand me according to this latter form, then I am good, but if according to that former only, then why do you ask me about good? If you are among those who shall look upon Him whom they have pierced, that very sight itself will be evil to them, because it will be penal. That the Lord said, Why do you ask me about good? There is none good but One, that is, God, with this meaning, is probable based on the proofs I have given, because that sight of God, by which we shall contemplate the ousia (substance) of God unchangeable and invisible to human eyes, which is promised to the saints alone, which the Apostle Paul speaks of as face to face, and of which the Apostle John says, We shall be like Him, for we shall see Him as He is, and of which it is said, One thing have I desired of the Lord, that I may behold the beauty of the Lord, and of which the Lord Himself says, I will both love him, and will manifest myself to him, and on account of which alone we cleanse our hearts by faith, that we may be those pure in heart who are blessed for they shall see God, and whatever else is spoken of that sight, which whosoever turns the eye of love to seek it may find most abundantly scattered through all the Scriptures, that sight alone, I say, is our chief good, for the attaining of which we are directed to do whatever we do rightly. But that sight of the Son of man which is foretold, when all nations shall be gathered before Him, and shall say to Him, Lord, when saw we You hungry, or thirsty, and so on, will neither be a good to the ungodly, who shall be sent into everlasting fire, nor the chief good to the righteous. For He still goes on to call these to the kingdom which has been prepared for them from the foundation of the world. For, as He will say to those, Depart into everlasting fire, so to these, Come, you blessed of my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you. And as those will go into everlasting burning, so the righteous will go into life eternal. But what is life eternal, except that they may know You, He says, the One true God, and Jesus Christ, whom You have sent, but know Him now in that glory of which He says to the Father, Which I had with You before the world was. For then He will deliver up the kingdom to God, even the Father, that the good servant may enter into the joy of his Lord, and that He may hide those whom God keeps in the hiding of His countenance from the confusion of men, namely, of those men who shall then be confounded by hearing this sentence, of which evil hearing the righteous man shall not be afraid if only he be kept in the tabernacle, that is, in the true faith of the Catholic Church, from the strife of tongues, that is, from the sophistries of heretics. But if there is any other explanation of the Lord's words, where He says, Why do you ask me about good? There is none good, but One, that is, God, provided only that the ousia of the Father not therefore be believed to be of greater goodness than that of the Son, according to which He is the Word by whom all things were made, and if there is nothing in it contrary to sound doctrine, let us securely use it, and not one explanation only, but as many as we are able to find. For the more outlets are open for avoiding their snares, the more powerfully are the heretics proved wrong. But let us now start afresh, and address ourselves to the consideration of that which still remains.

31. He is good, according to that sight, according to which God appears to the pure in heart; for truly God is good unto Israel even to such as are of a clean heart. But when the wicked shall see the Judge, He will not seem good to them; because they will not rejoice in their heart to see Him, but all kindreds of the earth shall then wail because of Him, namely, as being reckoned in the number of all the wicked and unbelievers. On this account also He replied to him, who had called Him Good Master, when seeking advice of Him how he might attain eternal life, Why do you ask me about good? there is none good but One, that is, God. And yet the Lord Himself, in another place, calls man good: A good man, He says, out of the good treasure of his heart, brings forth good things: and an evil man, out of the evil treasure of his heart, brings forth evil things. But because that man was seeking eternal life, and eternal life consists in that contemplation in which God is seen, not for punishment, but for everlasting joy ; and because he did not understand with whom he was speaking, and thought Him to be only the Son of man : Why, He says, do you ask me about good? That is, with respect to that form which you see, why do you ask about good, and call me, according to what you see, Good Master? This is the form of the Son of man , the form which has been taken, the form that will appear in judgment, not only to the righteous, but also to the ungodly; and the sight of this form will not be for good to those who are wicked . But there is a sight of that form of mine, in which when I was, I thought it not robbery to be equal with God: but in order to take this form I emptied myself. That one God , therefore, the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit , who will not appear, except for joy which cannot be taken away from the just; for which future joy he sighs, who says, One thing have I desired of the Lord, that will I seek after; that I may dwell in the house of the Lord all the days of my life, to behold the beauty of the Lord: that one God , therefore, Himself, I say, is alone good, for this reason, that no one sees Him for sorrow and wailing, but only for salvation and true joy . If you understand me after this latter form, then I am good; but if according to that former only, then why do you ask me about good? If you are among those who shall look upon Him whom they have pierced, that very sight itself will be evil to them, because it will be penal. That after this meaning, then, the Lord said, Why do you ask me about good? There is none good but One, that is, God , is probable upon those proofs which I have alleged, because that sight of God , whereby we shall contemplate the substance of God unchangeable and invisible to human eyes (which is promised to the saints alone; which the Apostle Paul speaks of, as face to face; and of which the Apostle John says, We shall be like Him, for we shall see Him as He is; and of which it is said, One thing have I desired of the Lord, that I may behold the beauty of the Lord, and of which the Lord Himself says, I will both love him, and will manifest myself to him; and on account of which alone we cleanse our hearts by faith , that we may be those pure in heart who are blessed for they shall see God: and whatever else is spoken of that sight: which whosoever turns the eye of love to seek it, may find most copiously scattered through all the Scriptures ) — that sight alone, I say, is our chief good, for the attaining of which we are directed to do whatever we do aright. But that sight of the Son of man which is foretold, when all nations shall be gathered before Him, and shall say to Him, Lord, when saw we You an hungered, or thirsty, etc.? will neither be a good to the ungodly, who shall be sent into everlasting fire , nor the chief good to the righteous. For He still goes on to call these to the kingdom which has been prepared for them from the foundation of the world. For, as He will say to those, Depart into everlasting fire ; so to these, Come, you blessed of my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you. And as those will go into everlasting burning; so the righteous will go into life eternal . But what is life eternal , except that they may know You, He says, the One true God , and Jesus Christ , whom You have sent? but know Him now in that glory of which He says to the Father , Which I had with You before the world was. For then He will deliver up the kingdom to God , even the Father , that the good servant may enter into the joy of his Lord, and that He may hide those whom God keeps in the hiding of His countenance from the confusion of men , namely, of those men who shall then be confounded by hearing this sentence; of which evil hearing the righteous man shall not be afraid if only he be kept in the tabernacle, that is, in the true faith of the Catholic Church , from the strife of tongues, that is, from the sophistries of heretics . But if there is any other explanation of the words of the Lord, where He says, Why do you ask me about good? There is none good, but One, that is, God ; provided only that the substance of the Father be not therefore believed to be of greater goodness than that of the Son , according to which He is the Word by whom all things were made; and if there is nothing in it abhorrent from sound doctrine; let us securely use it, and not one explanation only, but as many as we are able to find. For so much the more powerfully are the heretics proved wrong, the more outlets are open for avoiding their snares. But let us now start afresh, and address ourselves to the consideration of that which still remains.


On the Mortality — On the Mortality

Written during a plague at Carthage: why Christians should not fear death or mourn excessively for the faithful departed, since death is a passage to a better life.

Source: Translated by Robert Ernest Wallis. From Ante-Nicene Fathers , Vol. 5. Edited by Alexander Roberts, James Donaldson, and A. Cleveland Coxe. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1886. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/050707.htm>.

Opening

The deacon Pontius briefly explains the purpose of this treatise in his Life of Cyprian. First, he points out that Christ foretold afflictions of this kind. He then tells his readers that the mortality or plague should not be feared, since it leads to immortality, and therefore anyone who is not eager for a better world lacks faith. Nor is it surprising that the evils of this life affect Christians just as they do pagans, since Christians must suffer even more than others in the world. Thus, following the example of Job and Tobias, there is a need for patience without complaint. For unless the struggle comes first, the victory cannot follow. And however much diseases are common to both the virtuous and the wicked, death itself is not common to them, for the righteous are taken to consolation, while the unrighteous are taken to punishment.

Argument.– The Deacon Pontius in a Few Words Unfolds the Burthen of This Treatise in His Life of Cyprian. First of All, Having Pointed Out that Afflictions of This Kind Had Been Foretold by Christ, He Tells Them that the Mortality or Plague Was Not to Be Feared, in that It Leads to Immortality, and that Therefore, that Man is Wanting in Faith Who is Not Eager for a Better World. Nor is It Wonderful that the Evils of This Life are Common to the Christians with the Heathens, Since They Have to Suffer More Than Others in the World, and Thence, After the Example of Job and Tobias, There is Need of Patience Without Murmuring. For Unless the Struggle Preceded, the Victory Could Not Ensue; And How Much Soever Diseases are Common to the Virtuous and Vicious, Yet that Death is Not Common to Them, for that the Righteous are Taken to Consolation, While the Unrighteous are Taken to Punishment.

Although many of you, dearly beloved brothers and sisters, possess a steadfast mind and firm faith, and a devoted spirit that is not disturbed by the frequency of this present mortality, but rather like a strong and stable rock shatters the turbulent attacks of the world and the raging waves of time, while remaining unshattered itself, and is not overcome but tested by these trials—nevertheless, I observe that some among the people are standing less steadily. This is either because of weakness of mind, decay of faith, attachment to this worldly life, physical weakness, or what is even more serious, error from the truth. These individuals are not showing the divine and unconquerable strength of heart. Therefore, this matter cannot be hidden or kept silent. As far as my limited abilities allow, and with all my strength, and with teaching drawn from the Lord's instruction, the laziness that comes from a self-indulgent attitude must be restrained, and whoever has begun to be a man of God and of Christ must prove himself worthy of God and of Christ.

1. Although in very many of you, dearly beloved brethren, there is a steadfast mind and a firm faith, and a devoted spirit that is not disturbed at the frequency of this present mortality, but, like a strong and stable rock, rather shatters the turbulent onsets of the world and the raging waves of time, while it is not itself shattered, and is not overcome but tried by these temptations; yet because I observe that among the people some, either through weakness of mind, or through decay of faith, or through the sweetness of this worldly life, or through the softness of their sex, or what is of still greater account, through error from the truth, are standing less steadily, and are not exerting the divine and unvanquished vigour of their heart, the matter may not be disguised nor kept in silence, but as far as my feeble powers suffice with my full strength, and with a discourse gathered from the Lord's lessons, the slothfulness of a luxurious disposition must be restrained, and he who has begun to be already a man of God and of Christ, must be found worthy of God and of Christ.

For he who fights for God, dearest brothers and sisters, ought to recognize himself as one who, stationed in the heavenly camp, already hopes for divine things. This means we should have no fear of the storms and whirlwinds of the world, and no disturbance, since the Lord had foretold that these would come. Through the exhortation of His foreseeing word, instructing, teaching, preparing, and strengthening the people of His Church for complete endurance of things to come, He predicted and said that wars, famines, earthquakes, and plagues would arise in every place. And so that an unexpected and unfamiliar dread of disasters would not shake us, He warned us beforehand that adversity would increase more and more in the last times. Look, the very things are happening that were spoken of. And since those things are occurring that were foretold earlier, whatever things were promised will also follow, just as the Lord Himself promises, saying, "But when you see all these things come to pass, know that the kingdom of God is at hand." The kingdom of God, beloved brothers and sisters, is beginning to be at hand. The reward of life, the rejoicing of eternal salvation, and the perpetual gladness and possession of paradise that was recently lost are now coming as the world passes away. Already heavenly things are replacing earthly ones, great things are replacing small ones, and eternal things are replacing things that fade away. What room is there here for anxiety and worry? Who, in the midst of these things, is trembling and sad, except the one who is without hope and faith? For it is his lot to fear death who is not willing to go to Christ. It is his lot to be unwilling to go to Christ who does not believe that he is about to reign with Christ.

2. For he who wars for God, dearest brethren, ought to acknowledge himself as one who, placed in the heavenly camp, already hopes for divine things, so that we may have no trembling at the storms and whirlwinds of the world, and no disturbance, since the Lord had foretold that these would come. With the exhortation of His fore-seeing word, instructing, and teaching, and preparing, and strengthening the people of His Church for all endurance of things to come, He predicted and said that wars, and famines, and earthquakes, and pestilences would arise in each place; and lest an unexpected and new dread of mischiefs should shake us, He previously warned us that adversity would increase more and more in the last times. Behold, the very things occur which were spoken; and since those occur which were foretold before, whatever things were promised will also follow; as the Lord Himself promises, saying, But when you see all these things come to pass, know that the kingdom of God is at hand. Luke 21:31 The kingdom of God, beloved brethren, is beginning to be at hand; the reward of life, and the rejoicing of eternal salvation, and the perpetual gladness and possession lately lost of paradise, are now coming, with the passing away of the world; already heavenly things are taking the place of earthly, and great things of small, and eternal things of things that fade away. What room is there here for anxiety and solicitude? Who, in the midst of these things, is trembling and sad, except he who is without hope and faith? For it is for him to fear death who is not willing to go to Christ. It is for him to be unwilling to go to Christ who does not believe that he is about to reign with Christ.

If it is written that the just person lives by faith, and if you are just and live by faith, if you truly believe in Christ—then why don't you embrace the certainty that you are called to Christ and rejoice that you are freed from the devil, since you are about to be with Christ and are confident in the Lord's promise? Consider Simeon, that just man who was truly just and who kept God's commands with complete faith. Heaven had promised him that he would not die before he had seen the Christ. When Christ came as an infant into the temple with His mother, Simeon recognized in the Spirit that Christ was now born, the one who had been foretold to him. When he saw Him, Simeon knew that he would soon die. So, rejoicing about his approaching death and confident of his immediate departure, he took the child into his arms and blessed the Lord, saying, "Now let your servant depart in peace, according to your word; for my eyes have seen your salvation." Simeon was clearly proving and witnessing that God's servants have peace, freedom, and tranquil rest when they are withdrawn from the storms of this world and reach the harbor of their home and eternal security—when, having completed this death, they come to immortality. For that is our peace, our faithful tranquility, our steadfast, enduring, and perpetual security.

3. For it is written that the just lives by faith. If you are just, and live by faith, if you truly believe in Christ, why, since you are about to be with Christ, and are secure of the Lord's promise, do you not embrace the assurance that you are called to Christ, and rejoice that you are freed from the devil? Certainly Simeon, that just man, who was truly just, who kept God's commands with a full faith, when it had been pledged him from heaven that he should not die before he had seen the Christ, and Christ had come an infant into the temple with His mother, acknowledged in spirit that Christ was now born, concerning whom it had before been foretold to him; and when he had seen Him, he knew that he should soon die. Therefore, rejoicing concerning his now approaching death, and secure of his immediate summons, he received the child into his arms, and blessing the Lord, he exclaimed, and said, Now let Your servant depart in peace, according to Your word; for my eyes have seen Your salvation; Luke 2:29 assuredly proving and bearing witness that the servants of God then had peace, then free, then tranquil repose, when, withdrawn from these whirlwinds of the world, we attain the harbour of our home and eternal security, when having accomplished this death we come to immortality. For that is our peace, that our faithful tranquillity, that our steadfast, and abiding, and perpetual security.

Every day we wage a battle against the devil, fighting constantly against his attacks and weapons. We struggle with greed, immorality, anger, and ambition. We wrestle diligently and laboriously against bodily vices and the temptations of the world. The human mind is under siege, attacked on every side by the devil's assaults, and can barely meet each attack, barely resist it. If greed is defeated, lust rises up. If lust is conquered, ambition takes its place. If ambition is rejected, anger provokes us, pride inflates us, drunkenness tempts us, envy destroys harmony, jealousy destroys friendship. We are pressured to curse, which God's law forbids. We are compelled to swear oaths, which is unlawful.

4. But for the rest, what else in the world than a battle against the devil is daily carried on, than a struggle against his darts and weapons in constant conflicts? Our warfare is with avarice, with immodesty, with anger, with ambition; our diligent and toilsome wrestle with carnal vices, with enticements of the world. The mind of man besieged, and in every quarter invested with the onsets of the devil, scarcely in each point meets the attack, scarcely resists it. If avarice is prostrated, lust springs up. If lust is overcome, ambition takes its place. If ambition is despised, anger exasperates, pride puffs up, wine-bibbing entices, envy breaks concord, jealousy cuts friendship; you are constrained to curse, which the divine law forbids; you are compelled to swear, which is not lawful.

The soul endures so many persecutions every day, and the heart is exhausted by so many dangers. Yet it still loves to remain here for a long time among the devil's weapons, even though we should instead long and desire to hurry to Christ through a quicker death. Christ Himself teaches us this and says, "Truly, truly, I say to you that you will weep and mourn, but the world will rejoice; and you will be sorrowful, but your sorrow will be turned into joy" (John 16:20). Who would not want to be free from sadness? Who would not rush to reach joy? But the Lord Himself explains again when our sadness will be turned into joy, saying, "I will see you again, and your heart will rejoice; and no one will take your joy from you" (John 16:22). Therefore, since seeing Christ means rejoicing, and we cannot have joy except when we see Christ, what blindness of mind or what foolishness is it to love the world's sufferings, punishments, and tears, rather than hurrying toward the joy that can never be taken away!

5. So many persecutions the soul suffers daily, with so many risks is the heart wearied, and yet it delights to abide here long among the devil's weapons, although it should rather be our craving and wish to hasten to Christ by the aid of a quicker death; as He Himself instructs us, and says, Verily, verily, I say unto you, That you shall weep and lament, but the world shall rejoice; and you shall be sorrowful, but your sorrow shall be turned into joy. John 16:20 Who would not desire to be without sadness? Who would not hasten to attain to joy? But when our sadness shall be turned into joy, the Lord Himself again declares, when He says, I will see you again, and your heart shall rejoice; and your joy no man shall take from you. John 16:22 Since, therefore, to see Christ is to rejoice, and we cannot have joy unless when we shall see Christ, what blindness of mind or what folly is it to love the world's afflictions, and punishments, and tears, and not rather to hasten to the joy which can never be taken away!

But, dear brothers and sisters, this happens because faith is lacking, because no one believes that the things God promises are true, even though He is true, and His word to believers is eternal and unchangeable. If a serious and honorable person promised you something, you would certainly trust the one making the promise, and you would not think you were being cheated and deceived by someone you knew to be reliable in his words and actions. Now God is speaking with you, and yet you faithlessly waver in your unbelieving mind? God promises you immortality and eternity when you depart from this world, and you doubt? This is not to know God at all. This is to offend Christ, the Teacher of believers, with the sin of unbelief. This is to be established in the Church yet have no faith in the house of faith.

6. But, beloved brethren, this is so, because faith is lacking, because no one believes that the things which God promises are true, although He is true, whose word to believers is eternal and unchangeable. If a grave and praiseworthy man should promise you anything, you would assuredly have faith in the promiser, and would not think that you should be cheated and deceived by him whom you knew to be steadfast in his words and his deeds. Now God is speaking with you; and do you faithlessly waver in your unbelieving mind? God promises to you, on your departure from this world, immortality and eternity; and do you doubt? This is not to know God at all; this is to offend Christ, the Teacher of believers, with the sin of incredulity; this is for one established in the Church not to have faith in the house of faith.

How great is the benefit of leaving the world, Christ Himself, the Teacher of our salvation and of our good works, shows us. When His disciples were saddened because He said He would soon depart, He spoke to them and said, "If you loved me, you would surely rejoice because I go to the Father" (John 16:28). By this He was teaching and making clear that when loved ones depart from the world, we should rejoice rather than grieve. Remembering this truth, the blessed Apostle Paul declares in his letter, "To me to live is Christ, and to die is gain" (Philippians 1:21). He considered it the greatest gain to no longer be held by the snares of this world, to no longer be vulnerable to the sins and vices of the flesh, but instead to be taken away from painful troubles and freed from the poisonous fangs of the devil, going at Christ's call to the joy of eternal salvation.

7. How great is the advantage of going out of the world, Christ Himself, the Teacher of our salvation and of our good works, shows to us, who, when His disciples were saddened that He said that He was soon to depart, spoke to them, and said, If you loved me, you would surely rejoice because I go to the Father; John 16:28 teaching thereby, and manifesting that when the dear ones whom we love depart from the world, we should rather rejoice than grieve. Remembering which truth, the blessed Apostle Paul in his epistle lays it down, saying, To me to live is Christ, and to die is gain; Philippians 1:21 counting it the greatest gain no longer to be held by the snares of this world, no longer to be liable to the sins and vices of the flesh, but taken away from smarting troubles, and freed from the envenomed fangs of the devil, to go at the call of Christ to the joy of eternal salvation.

However, it troubles some people that this disease strikes our people just as much as the pagans, as if Christians believed in order to enjoy the world and this life free from contact with evils, rather than as people who endure all hardships here and are kept for future joy. It troubles some that this mortality is shared by us with others. Yet what is there in this world that is not shared by us with others, as long as this flesh of ours still remains common to us with them according to the law of our first birth? As long as we are here in the world, we are joined with the human race in fleshly equality, but we are separated in spirit. Therefore, until this corruptible puts on incorruption and this mortal receives immortality, and the Spirit leads us to God the Father, whatever disadvantages affect the flesh are shared by us with the human race. When the earth is barren with an unproductive harvest, famine makes no distinction. When a city is captured by an invading enemy, captivity immediately devastates everyone. When clear skies withhold the rain, the drought affects everyone alike. When jagged rocks tear apart a ship, the shipwreck is shared without exception by all who sail in it. Eye disease, fever attacks, and weakness in all the limbs are shared by us with others, as long as we carry this common flesh in the world.

8. But nevertheless it disturbs some that the power of this Disease attacks our people equally with the heathens, as if the Christian believed for this purpose, that he might have the enjoyment of the world and this life free from the contact of ills; and not as one who undergoes all adverse things here and is reserved for future joy. It disturbs some that this mortality is common to us with others; and yet what is there in this world which is not common to us with others, so long as this flesh of ours still remains, according to the law of our first birth, common to us with them? So long as we are here in the world, we are associated with the human race in fleshly equality, but are separated in spirit. Therefore until this corruptible shall put on incorruption, and this mortal receive immortality, and the Spirit lead us to God the Father, whatsoever are the disadvantages of the flesh are common to us with the human race. Thus, when the earth is barren with an unproductive harvest, famine makes no distinction; thus, when with the invasion of an enemy any city is taken, captivity at once desolates all; and when the serene clouds withhold the rain, the drought is alike to all; and when the jagged rocks rend the ship, the shipwreck is common without exception to all that sail in her; and the disease of the eyes, and the attack of fevers, and the feebleness of all the limbs is common to us with others, so long as this common flesh of ours is borne by us in the world.

Furthermore, if the Christian understands and holds firmly to the condition and law under which he has believed, he will realize that he must suffer more than others in the world, because he must struggle more against the attacks of the devil. Holy Scripture teaches and warns ahead of time, saying, "My son, when you come to the service of God, stand in righteousness and fear, and prepare your soul for temptation." And again: "In pain endure, and in your humility have patience; for gold and silver is tried in the fire, but acceptable men in the furnace of humiliation." Sirach 2:5

9. Moreover, if the Christian know and keep fast under what condition and what law he has believed, he will be aware that he must suffer more than others in the world, since he must struggle more with the attacks of the devil. Holy Scripture teaches and forewarns, saying, My son, when you come to the service of God, stand in righteousness and fear, and prepare your soul for temptation. And again: In pain endure, and in your humility have patience; for gold and silver is tried in the fire, but acceptable men in the furnace of humiliation. Sirach 2:5

Job provides an example of this truth. After losing his wealth and his children, and being severely afflicted with sores and worms, he was not defeated but proven faithful. In the midst of his struggles and anguish, he demonstrated the patience of a godly mind, saying, "I came naked from my mother's womb, and naked I shall go under the earth. The Lord gave, the Lord has taken away. As it seemed right to the Lord, so it has happened. Blessed be the name of the Lord." When his wife urged him, because of his unbearable pain, to speak against God with a complaining and bitter voice, he answered, "You speak like one of the foolish women. If we have received good from the hand of the Lord, why should we not endure evil?" In all these things that happened to him, Job did not sin with his lips in the sight of the Lord. Therefore the Lord God gives this testimony about him: "Have you considered my servant Job? For there is no one like him in all the earth, a man without complaint, a true worshiper of God." Likewise Tobias, after his excellent works and many glorious displays of his merciful character, suffered the loss of his sight. Yet by fearing and blessing God in his adversity, he grew in praise through his very physical affliction. His wife also tried to turn him away, saying, "Where are your righteous deeds? Look at what you are suffering!" But he remained steadfast and firm in his fear of God, and armed by the faith of his religion to endure all suffering, he did not yield to the temptation of his weak wife in his trouble. Instead, he earned even greater favor from God through his greater patience. Afterward, the angel Raphael praised him, saying, "It is honorable to reveal and confess the works of God. For when you and your daughter-in-law Sarah prayed, I brought the remembrance of your prayer before the glory of God. And when you buried the dead with a sincere heart, and did not hesitate to get up and leave your dinner to go and bury the dead, I was sent to test you. And God has now sent me to heal both you and your daughter-in-law Sarah. For I am Raphael, one of the seven holy angels who stand present and go in and out before the glory of God."

10. Thus Job, after the loss of his wealth, after the death of his children, grievously afflicted, moreover, with sores and worms, was not overcome, but proved; since in his very struggles and anguish, showing forth the patience of a religious mind, he says, Naked came I out of my mother's womb, naked also I shall go under the earth: the Lord gave, the Lord has taken away; as it seemed fit to the Lord, so it has been done. Blessed be the name of the Lord. And when his wife also urged him, in his impatience at the acuteness of his pain, to speak something against God with a complaining and envious voice, he answered and said, You speak as one of the foolish women. If we have received good from the hand of the Lord, why shall we not suffer evil? In all these things which befell him, Job sinned not with his lips in the sight of the Lord. Job 1:8 Therefore the Lord God gives him a testimony, saying, Have you considered my servant Job? For there is none like him in all the earth, a man without complaint, a true worshipper of God. Job 2:10 And Tobias, after his excellent works, after the many and glorious illustrations of his merciful spirit, having suffered the loss of his sight, fearing and blessing God in his adversity, by his very bodily affliction increased in praise; and even him also his wife tried to pervert, saying, Where are your righteousnesses? Behold what you suffer. Tobit 2:14 But he, steadfast and firm in respect of the fear of God, and armed by the faith of his religion to all endurance of suffering, yielded not to the temptation of his weak wife in his trouble, but rather deserved better from God by his greater patience; and afterwards Raphael the angel praises him, saying, It is honourable to show forth and to confess the works of God. For when you prayed, and Sara your daughter-in-law, I did offer the remembrance of your prayer in the presence of the glory of God. And when you buried the dead in singleness of heart, and because you did not delay to rise up and leave your dinner, and went and buried the dead, I was sent to make proof of you. And God again has sent me to heal you and Sara your daughter-in-law. For I am Raphael, one of the seven holy angels, who are present, and go in and out before the glory of God. Tobit 12:11-15

Righteous people have always possessed this endurance. The apostles maintained this discipline from the law of the Lord—not to complain in adversity, but to accept bravely and patiently whatever things happen in the world. The people of the Jews, however, always offended in this matter, constantly murmuring against God, as the Lord God testifies in the book of Numbers, saying, "Let their murmuring cease from me, and they shall not die." We must not complain in adversity, beloved brothers and sisters, but must bear with patience and courage whatever happens, since it is written, "The sacrifice to God is a broken spirit; a contrite and humbled heart God does not despise." Also in Deuteronomy the Holy Spirit warns through Moses and says, "The Lord your God will test you and will bring hunger upon you, and it shall be known in your heart if you have kept His commandments well or not." And again: "The Lord your God tests you, that He may know whether you love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul."

11. Righteous men have ever possessed this endurance. The apostles maintained this discipline from the law of the Lord, not to murmur in adversity, but to accept bravely and patiently whatever things happen in the world; since the people of the Jews in this matter always offended, that they constantly murmured against God, as the Lord God bears witness in the book of Numbers, saying, Let their murmuring cease from me, and they shall not die. Numbers 17:10 We must not murmur in adversity, beloved brethren, but we must bear with patience and courage whatever happens, since it is written, The sacrifice to God is a broken spirit; a contrite and humbled heart God does not despise; since also in Deuteronomy the Holy Spirit warns by Moses. and says, The Lord your God will vex you, and will bring hunger upon you; and it shall be known in your heart if you have well kept His commandments or no. Deuteronomy 8:2 And again: The Lord your God proves you, that He may know whether you love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul. Deuteronomy 13:3

Thus Abraham pleased God, who was willing to lose his son or even commit the act of killing him in order to please God. If you cannot bear to lose your son through the natural law and chance of mortality, what would you do if you were commanded to kill your son? The fear and faith of God should make you ready for anything—whether it means the loss of personal property, the constant and cruel torment of your body by painful diseases, or the deadly and sorrowful separation from your wife, children, and departing loved ones. Do not let these things offend you, but see them as battles. Do not let them weaken or break a Christian's faith, but rather let them demonstrate his strength in the struggle, since all the harm inflicted by present troubles should be looked down upon in the confidence of future blessings. Unless the battle comes first, there can be no victory. When victory comes in the heat of battle, then the crown is also given to the victors. The helmsman is recognized in the storm; the soldier is proven in warfare. It is mere show when there is no danger. Struggle in adversity is the test of truth. The tree that is deeply rooted is not moved by the force of winds, and the ship that is built with solid timbers is struck by the waves but not destroyed. When the threshing floor brings out the grain, the strong and sturdy grains ignore the winds, while the empty chaff is carried away by the blast that strikes it.

12. Thus Abraham pleased God, who, that he might please God, did not shrink even from losing his son, or from doing an act of parricide. You, who cannot endure to lose your son by the law and lot of mortality, what would you do if you were bidden to slay your son? The fear and faith of God ought to make you prepared for everything, although it should be the loss of private estate, although the constant and cruel harassment of your limbs by agonizing disorders, although the deadly and mournful wrench from wife, from children, from departing dear ones; Let not these things be offenses to you, but battles: nor let them weaken nor break the Christian's faith, but rather show forth his strength in the struggle, since all the injury inflicted by present troubles is to be despised in the assurance of future blessings. Unless the battle has preceded, there cannot be a victory: when there shall have been, in the onset of battle, the victory, then also the crown is given to the victors. For the helmsman is recognised in the tempest; in the warfare the soldier is proved. It is a wanton display when there is no danger. Struggle in adversity is the trial of the truth. The tree which is deeply founded in its root is not moved by the onset of winds, and the ship which is compacted of solid timbers is beaten by the waves and is not shattered; and when the threshing-floor brings out the grain, the strong and robust grains despise the winds, while the empty chaff is carried away by the blast that falls upon it.

The Apostle Paul, after experiencing shipwrecks, beatings, and many serious torments of his flesh and body, says that he is not harmed but actually helped by his hardships, so that through intense suffering he might be more fully tested. He says, "There was given to me a thorn in the flesh, the messenger of Satan to torment me, so that I would not become proud. I asked the Lord three times to take it away from me, and He said to me, 'My grace is sufficient for you, for strength is made perfect in weakness.'" Therefore, when weakness, inability, or any kind of destruction comes upon us, our strength is made complete. Then our faith, if it stands firm when tested, receives its reward, as Scripture says: "The furnace tests the potter's vessels, and the trial of tribulation tests just men." This, in fact, is the difference between us and others who do not know God: in misfortune they complain and grumble, while hardship does not turn us away from the truth of virtue and faith, but strengthens us through suffering.

13. Thus, moreover, the Apostle Paul, after shipwrecks, after scourgings, after many and grievous tortures of the flesh and body, says that he is not grieved, but benefited by his adversity, in order that while he is sorely afflicted he might more truly be proved. There was given to me, he says, a thorn in the flesh, the messenger of Satan to buffet me, that I should not be lifted up: for which thing I besought the Lord thrice, that it might depart from me; and He said to me, My grace is sufficient for you, for strength is made perfect in weakness. 2 Corinthians 12:7-9 When, therefore, weakness and inefficiency and any destruction seize us, then our strength is made perfect; then our faith, if when tried it shall stand fast, is crowned; as it is written, The furnace tries the vessels of the potter, and the trial of tribulation just men. Sirach 27:5 This, in short, is the difference between us and others who know not God, that in misfortune they complain and murmur, while adversity does not call us away from the truth of virtue and faith, but strengthens us by its suffering.

This trial—where the bowels, loosened into constant diarrhea, drain the body's strength; where a fire originating in the bone marrow erupts into throat ulcers; where the intestines are wracked with continual vomiting; where the eyes burn with injected blood; where in some cases the feet or parts of limbs are amputated because of spreading diseased decay; where from the weakness caused by the mutilation and loss of bodily parts, either walking becomes feeble, or hearing is blocked, or sight is dimmed—is valuable as a test of faith. What greatness of spirit it is to struggle with all the strength of an unshaken mind against so many assaults of devastation and death! What nobility, to stand upright amid the destruction of the human race, and not to lie prostrate with those who have no hope in God; but rather to rejoice, and to embrace the benefit of the opportunity; that in thus courageously demonstrating our faith, and through suffering endured, advancing to Christ by the narrow path that Christ walked, we may receive the reward of His life and faith according to His own judgment! Surely the one who may fear to die is he who, not having been regenerated by water and the Spirit, is handed over to the fires of Gehenna; he may fear to die who is not enrolled in the cross and passion of Christ; he may fear to die, who from this death will pass over to a second death; he may fear to die, whom upon his departure from this world eternal flame will torment with never-ending punishments; he may fear to die who has this advantage in a prolonged delay, that in the meantime his groaning and his anguish are being postponed.

14. This trial, that now the bowels, relaxed into a constant flux, discharge the bodily strength; that a fire originated in the marrow ferments into wounds of the fauces; that the intestines are shaken with a continual vomiting; that the eyes are on fire with the injected blood; that in some cases the feet or some parts of the limbs are taken off by the contagion of diseased putrefaction; that from the weakness arising by the maiming and loss of the body, either the gait is enfeebled, or the hearing is obstructed, or the sight darkened — is profitable as a proof of faith. What a grandeur of spirit it is to struggle with all the powers of an unshaken mind against so many onsets of devastation and death! What sublimity, to stand erect amid the desolation of the human race, and not to lie prostrate with those who have no hope in God; but rather to rejoice, and to embrace the benefit of the occasion; that in thus bravely showing forth our faith, and by suffering endured, going forward to Christ by the narrow way that Christ trod, we may receive the reward of His life and faith according to His own judgment! Assuredly he may fear to die, who, not being regenerated of water and the Spirit, is delivered over to the fires of Gehenna; he may fear to die who is not enrolled in the cross and passion of Christ; he may fear to die, who from this death shall pass over to a second death; he may fear to die, whom on his departure from this world eternal flame shall torment with never-ending punishments; he may fear to die who has this advantage in a lengthened delay, that in the meanwhile his groanings and his anguish are being postponed.

Many of our people die in this plague, which means many of our people are freed from this world. This plague is a disaster for Jews and Gentiles and enemies of Christ, but it is a passage to salvation for God's servants. The fact that the righteous die along with the unrighteous, without any distinction between them, is no reason to think this is the same kind of death for both good and evil people. The righteous are called to their place of rest, while the unrighteous are dragged away to punishment. Safety comes more quickly to the faithful, penalty to the unbelieving. We are thoughtless and ungrateful, beloved brothers and sisters, for God's gifts, and we fail to recognize what is given to us. Look, virgins depart in peace, their purity intact, not having to fear the threats of the coming Antichrist with his corruptions and brothels. Boys escape the dangers of their unstable age and joyfully receive the reward of self-control and innocence. Now the refined woman does not face torture, for a swift death has spared her the terror of persecution and the hands and torments of the executioner. The terror of this plague and these times sets the lukewarm on fire, stiffens the resolve of the lax, spurs on the lazy, compels deserters to return, forces pagans to believe, calls the long-established congregation of the faithful to rest, and gathers a new and numerous army for battle with greater courage—to fight without fear of death when the battle comes, because it enters the struggle during the time of this plague.

15. Many of our people die in this mortality, that is, many of our people are liberated from this world. This mortality, as it is a plague to Jews and Gentiles, and enemies of Christ, so it is a departure to salvation to God's servants. The fact that, without any difference made between one ant another, the righteous die as well as the unrighteous, is no reason for you to suppose that it is a common death for the good and evil alike. The righteous are called to their place of refreshing, the unrighteous are snatched away to punishment; safety is the more speedily given to the faithful, penalty to the unbelieving. We are thoughtless and ungrateful, beloved brethren, for the divine benefits, and do not acknowledge what is conferred upon us. Lo, virgins depart in peace, safe with their glory, not fearing the threats of the coming Antichrist, and his corruptions and his brothels. Boys escape the peril of their unstable age, and in happiness attain the reward of continence and innocence. Now the delicate matron does not fear the tortures; for she has escaped by a rapid death the fear of persecution, and the hands and the torments of the executioner. By the dread of the mortality and of the time the lukewarm are inflamed, the slack are nerved up, the slothful are stimulated, the deserters are compelled to return, the heathens are constrained to believe, the ancient congregation of the faithful is called to rest, the new and abundant army is gathered to the battle with a braver vigour, to fight without fear of death when the battle shall come, because it comes to the warfare in the time of the mortality.

Furthermore, beloved brothers and sisters, what a significant, relevant, and necessary thing it is that this pestilence and plague, which seems horrible and deadly, actually examines the righteousness of each person and tests the minds of the human race. It reveals whether the healthy care for the sick, whether family members show genuine love for their relatives, whether masters show compassion to their suffering servants, whether doctors refuse to abandon their pleading patients, whether violent people restrain their aggression, whether the greedy can extinguish the unquenchable fire of their raging greed even when faced with the fear of death, whether the proud humble themselves, whether the wicked soften their defiance, and whether the rich, even as their loved ones die, will give anything away when they are about to die without heirs. Even if this mortality accomplished nothing else, it has done Christians and God's servants this benefit: we begin to gladly desire martyrdom as we learn not to fear death. These are training exercises for us, not deaths. They give our minds the glory of courage and prepare us for the crown through contempt of death.

16. And further, beloved brethren, what is it, what a great thing is it, how pertinent, how necessary, that pestilence and plague which seems horrible and deadly, searches out the righteousness of each one, and examines the minds of the human race, to see whether they who are in health tend the sick; whether relations affectionately love their kindred; whether masters pity their languishing servants; whether physicians do not forsake the beseeching patients; whether the fierce suppress their violence; whether the rapacious can quench the ever insatiable ardour of their raging avarice even by the fear of death; whether the haughty bend their neck; whether the wicked soften their boldness; whether, when their dear ones perish, the rich, even then bestow anything, and give, when they are to die without heirs. Even although this mortality conferred nothing else, it has done this benefit to Christians and to God's servants that we begin gladly to desire martyrdom as we learn not to fear death. These are trainings for us, not deaths: they give the mind the glory of fortitude; by contempt of death they prepare for the crown.

Perhaps someone may object and say, "What saddens me about this present plague is that I had prepared myself for public confession of faith and had devoted myself to enduring suffering with my whole heart and abundant courage, but now I am deprived of martyrdom because death has come first." In the first place, martyrdom is not in your power but depends on God's condescension. You cannot say you have lost what you do not even know whether you would deserve to receive. Besides, God searches the inner depths and the heart, and investigates and knows hidden things. He sees you and praises and approves you. The one who sees that virtue was ready in you will reward you for your virtue. Had Cain already killed his brother when he offered his gift to God? Yet God, foreseeing the murder conceived in his mind, condemned it in advance. Just as in that case the evil thought and harmful intention were foreseen by a foreseeing God, so also in God's servants, among whom confession is intended and martyrdom conceived in the mind, the intention dedicated to good is crowned by God the judge. It is one thing for the spirit to be lacking for martyrdom, and another for martyrdom to have been lacking for the spirit. God judges you as he finds you when he calls you, since he himself testifies and says, "And all the churches shall know that I am the searcher of the reins and heart." For God does not ask for our blood but for our faith. Neither Abraham, nor Isaac, nor Jacob were killed, and yet, being honored by the merits of faith and righteousness, they deserved to be first among the patriarchs, to whose feast is gathered everyone who is found faithful, righteous, and praiseworthy.

17. But perchance some one may object, and say, It is this, then, that saddens me in the present mortality, that I, who had been prepared for confession, and had devoted myself to the endurance of suffering with my whole heart and with abundant courage, am deprived of martyrdom, in that I am anticipated by death. In the first place, martyrdom is not in your power, but in the condescension of God; neither can you say that you have lost what you do not know whether you would deserve to receive. Then, besides, God the searcher of the reins and heart, and the investigator and knower of secret things, sees you, and praises and approves you; and He who sees that your virtue was ready in you, will give you a reward for your virtue. Had Cain, when he offered his gift to God, already slain his brother? And yet God, foreseeing the fratricide conceived in his mind, anticipated its condemnation. As in that case the evil thought and mischievous intention were foreseen by a foreseeing God, so also in God's servants, among whom confession is purposed and martyrdom conceived in the mind, the intention dedicated to good is crowned by God the judge. It is one thing for the spirit to be wanting for martyrdom, and another for martyrdom to have been wanting for the spirit. Such as the Lord finds you when He calls you, such also He judges you; since He Himself bears witness, and says, And all the churches shall know that I am the searcher of the reins and heart. Revelation 2:23 For God does not ask for our blood, but for our faith. For neither Abraham, nor Isaac, nor Jacob were slain; and yet, being honoured by the deserts of faith and righteousness, they deserved to be first among the patriarchs, to whose feast is collected every one that is found faithful, and righteous, and praiseworthy.

We should remember that we ought to do God's will, not our own, in line with what our Lord has commanded us to pray daily. How absurd and contradictory it is that while we ask for God's will to be done, when God calls and summons us from this world, we don't immediately obey the command of His will! We struggle and resist, and like stubborn servants we are dragged into the Lord's presence with sadness and grief, leaving this life under the compulsion of necessity rather than with the obedience of free will. And yet we expect to be honored with heavenly rewards by Him to whom we come unwillingly. Why, then, do we pray and ask for the kingdom of heaven to come if earthly captivity delights us? Why do we repeatedly entreat and beg in our prayers for the day of His kingdom to arrive quickly, if our greater desires and stronger wishes are to obey the devil here rather than to reign with Christ?

18. We ought to remember that we should do not our own will, but God's, in accordance with what our Lord has bidden us daily to pray. How preposterous and absurd it is, that while we ask that the will of God should be done, yet when God calls and summons us from this world, we should not at once obey the command of His will! We struggle and resist, and after the manner of froward servants we are dragged to the presence of the Lord with sadness and grief, departing hence under the bondage of necessity, not with the obedience of free will; and we wish to be honoured with heavenly rewards by Him to whom we come unwillingly. Why, then, do we pray and ask that the kingdom of heaven may come, if the captivity of earth delights us? Why with frequently repeated prayers do we entreat and beg that the day of His kingdom may hasten, if our greater desires and stronger wishes are to obey the devil here, rather than to reign with Christ?

Besides, to show more clearly the workings of divine providence—proving that the Lord, knowing the future, provides for the true salvation of His people—when one of our fellow bishops and priests, exhausted by illness and anxious about his approaching death, prayed for more time, a young man appeared to him as he prayed and was near death. This youth was impressive in dignity and majesty, tall in height and radiant in appearance, and the human eye could scarcely look upon him with ordinary vision, though the man about to leave this world was already able to see such a being. The youth rebuked him with some displeasure in both manner and voice, saying, "You are afraid to suffer, you do not want to leave; what shall I do with you?" This was the rebuke and warning of one who, when people are anxious about persecution and indifferent to their summons, does not grant their present wish but plans for their future good. Our dying brother and fellow priest heard what he was meant to tell others. For he who heard while dying heard precisely so that he might report it; he did not hear it for himself, but for us. What could he, who was already about to depart, learn for himself? No, he certainly learned it for us who remain, so that when we discover that the priest who asked for delay was rebuked, we might recognize what is beneficial for everyone.

19. Besides, that the indications of the divine providence may be more evidently manifest, proving that the Lord, prescient of the future, takes counsel for the true salvation of His people, when one of our colleagues and fellow priests, wearied out with infirmity, and anxious about the present approach of death, prayed for a respite to himself; there stood by him as he prayed, and when he was now at the point of death, a youth, venerable in honour and majesty, lofty in stature and shining in aspect, and on whom, as he stood by him, the human glance could scarcely look with fleshly eyes, except that he who was about to depart from the world could already behold such a one. And he, not without a certain indignation of mind and voice, rebuked him, and said, You fear to suffer, you do not wish to depart; what shall I do to you? It was the word of one rebuking and warning, one who, when men are anxious about persecution, and indifferent concerning their summons, consents not to their present desire, but consults for the future. Our dying brother and colleague heard what he was to say to others. For he who heard when he was dying, heard for the very purpose that he might tell it; he heard not for himself, but for us. For what could he, who was already on the eve of departure, learn for himself? Yea, doubtless, he learned it for us who remain, in order that, when we find the priest who sought for delay rebuked, we might acknowledge what is beneficial for all.

To me also, the very least and last, how often it has been revealed, how frequently and clearly it has been commanded by God's gracious condescension, that I should diligently testify and publicly declare that our brothers and sisters who are freed from this world by the Lord's summons are not to be mourned, since we know that they are not lost but sent ahead of us; that in departing from us they go before us like travelers, as sailors customarily do; that they should be longed for but not lamented; that we should not put on black clothing here when they have already put on white garments there; that we should not give the unbelievers a reason to justly and rightly criticize us for mourning those who, we say, are alive with God, as if they were destroyed and lost; and that we do not confirm with the testimony of our heart and conscience the faith that we express with our speech and words. We are betrayers of our hope and faith: what we say appears to be false, pretended, and fake. There is no benefit in proclaiming virtue with our words while destroying the truth with our actions.

20. To myself also, the very least and last, how often has it been revealed, how frequently and manifestly has it been commanded by the condescension of God, that I should diligently bear witness and publicly declare that our brethren who are freed from this world by the Lord's summons are not to be lamented, since we know that they are not lost, but sent before; that, departing from us, they precede us as travellers, as navigators are accustomed to do; that they should be desired, but not bewailed; that the black garments should not be taken upon us here, when they have already taken upon them white raiment there; that occasion should not be given to the Gentiles for them deservedly and rightly to reprehend us, that we mourn for those, who, we say, are alive with God, as if they were extinct and lost; and that we do not approve wills the testimony of the heart and breast the faith which we express with speech and word. We are prevaricators of our hope and faith: what we say appears to be simulated, feigned, counterfeit. There is no advantage in setting forth virtue by our words, and destroying the truth by our deeds.

Finally, the Apostle Paul reproaches, rebukes, and blames anyone who grieves over the departure of their friends. He says, "I would not have you ignorant, brethren, concerning those who are asleep, that you may not sorrow as others who have no hope. For if we believe that Jesus died and rose again, even so God will bring with Him those who are asleep in Jesus." He says that those who sorrow at the departure of their friends are those who have no hope. But we who live in hope and believe in God and trust that Christ suffered for us and rose again, remaining in Christ and through Him and in Him rising again—why are we ourselves unwilling to depart from this life, or why do we mourn and grieve for our friends when they depart as if they were lost? This is especially true when Christ Himself, our Lord and God, encourages us and says, "I am the resurrection and the life: he who believes in me, though he die, yet shall live; and whoever lives and believes in me shall not die eternally." If we believe in Christ, let us have faith in His words and promises; and since we shall not die eternally, let us come with joyful confidence to Christ, with whom we are both to conquer and to reign forever.

21. Finally, the Apostle Paul reproaches, and rebukes, and blames any who are in sorrow at the departure of their friends. I would not, says he, have you ignorant, brethren, concerning them which are asleep, that you sorrow not, even as others which have no hope. For if we believe that Jesus died and rose again, even so them which are asleep in Jesus Will God bring with Him. He says that those have sorrow in the departure of their friends who have no hope. But we who live in hope, and believe in God, and trust that Christ suffered for us and rose again, abiding in Christ, and through Him and in Him rising again, why either are we ourselves unwilling to depart hence from this life, or do we bewail and grieve for our friends when they depart as if they were lost, when Christ Himself, our Lord and God, encourages us and says, I am the resurrection and the life: he that believes in me, though he die, yet shall live; and whosoever lives and believes in me shall not die eternally? John 11:25 If we believe in Christ, let us have faith in His words and promises; and since we shall not die eternally, let us come with a glad security unto Christ, with whom we are both to conquer and to reign forever.

When we die, we are transitioning to immortality through death. Eternal life cannot follow unless we depart from this life. Death is not an ending but a passage—a crossing through this journey of time into eternity. Who would not eagerly pursue better things? Who would not desire to be transformed and renewed into the likeness of Christ, and to arrive more quickly at the dignity of heavenly glory? The apostle Paul proclaims this when he says, "For our conversation is in heaven, from whence also we look for the Lord Jesus Christ; who shall change the body of our humiliation, and conform it to the body of His glory" (Philippians 3:21). Christ the Lord also promises that we will become like this. So that we may be with Him, live with Him in eternal dwellings, and rejoice in the heavenly kingdoms, He prays to the Father for us, saying, "Father, I will that they also whom You have given me be with me where I am, and may see the glory which You have given me before the world was made" (John 17:24). Anyone who is going to reach Christ's throne and the glory of the heavenly kingdoms should not mourn or grieve. Rather, according to the Lord's promise and according to faith in the truth, he should rejoice in his departure and passage.

22. That in the meantime we die, we are passing over to immortality by death; nor can eternal life follow, unless it should befall us to depart from this life. That is not an ending, but a transit, and, this journey of time being traversed, a passage to eternity. Who would not hasten to better things? Who would not crave to be changed and renewed into the likeness of Christ, and to arrive more quickly to the dignity of heavenly glory, since Paul the apostle announces and says, For our conversation is in heaven, from whence also we look for the Lord Jesus Christ; who shall change the body of our humiliation, and conform it to the body of His glory? Philippians 3:21 Christ the Lord also promises that we shall be such, when, that we may be with Him, and that we may live with Him in eternal mansions, and may rejoice in heavenly kingdoms, He prays the Father for us, saying, Father, I will that they also whom You have given me be with me where I am, and may see the glory which You have given me before the world was made. John 17:24 He who is to attain to the throne of Christ, to the glory of the heavenly kingdoms, ought not to mourn nor lament, but rather, in accordance with the Lord's promise, in accordance with his faith in the truth, to rejoice in this his departure and translation.

We also find that Enoch was taken up because he pleased God, as Holy Scripture testifies in Genesis: "And Enoch pleased God; and afterwards he was not found, because God translated him." To have been pleasing in God's sight meant he deserved to be removed from this world's corruption. Furthermore, the Holy Spirit teaches through Solomon that those who please God are taken from here earlier and set free more quickly, so that they won't be polluted by this world's corruptions if they remain here longer. Scripture says, "He was taken away, lest wickedness should change his understanding. For his soul was pleasing to God; wherefore hasted He to take him away from the midst of wickedness." Likewise in the Psalms, the soul that is devoted to its God in spiritual faith eagerly calls out to the Lord, saying, "How amiable are your dwellings, O God of hosts! My soul longs, and hastes unto the courts of God."

23. Thus, moreover, we find that Enoch also was translated, who pleased God, as in Genesis the Holy Scripture bears witness, and says, And Enoch pleased God; and afterwards he was not found, because God translated him. Genesis 5:24 To have been pleasing in the sight of God was thus to have merited to be translated from this contagion of the world. And moreover, also, the Holy Spirit teaches by Solomon, that they who please God are more early taken hence, and are more quickly set free, lest while they are delaying longer in this world they should be polluted with the contagions of the world. He was taken away, says he, lest wickedness should change his understanding. For his soul was pleasing to God; wherefore hasted He to take him away from the midst of wickedness. Wisdom 4:11 So also in the Psalms, the soul that is devoted to its God in spiritual faith hastens to the Lord, saying, How amiable are your dwellings, O God of hosts! My soul longs, and hastes unto the courts of God.

The person who wants to remain long in the world is the one whom the world delights, whom this life invites through the enticements of earthly pleasure by flattering and deceiving him. Furthermore, since the world hates the Christian, why do you love what hates you? And why do you not rather follow Christ, who both redeemed you and loves you? John in his letter cries out and says, urging that we should not follow fleshly desires and love the world: "Do not love the world, nor the things which are in the world. If anyone loves the world, the love of the Father is not in him. For all that is in the world is the lust of the flesh, and the lust of the eyes, and the pride of life, which is not of the Father, but of the lust of the world. And the world will pass away, and its lust, but he who does the will of God remains forever, even as God remains forever." Rather, beloved brothers and sisters, with a sound mind, with a firm faith, with a strong virtue, let us be prepared for the whole will of God. Setting aside the fear of death, let us think about the immortality which follows. By this let us show ourselves to be what we believe: that we do not grieve over the departure of those dear to us, and that when the day of our summons arrives, we come without delay and without resistance to the Lord when he himself calls us.

24. It is for him to wish to remain long in the world whom the world delights, whom this life, flattering and deceiving, invites by the enticements of earthly pleasure. Again, since the world hates the Christian, why do you love that which hates you? And why do you not rather follow Christ, who both redeemed you and loves you? John in his epistle cries and says, exhorting that we should not follow carnal desires and love the world. Love not the world, says he, neither the things which are in the world. If any man love the world, the love of the Father is not in him. For all that is in the world is the lust of the flesh, and the lust of the eyes, and the pride of life, which is not of the Father, but of the lust of the world. And the world shall pass away, and the lust thereof; but he who does the will of God abides for ever, even as God abides forever. 1 John 2:15 Rather, beloved brethren, with a sound mind, with a firm faith, with a robust virtue, let us be prepared for the whole will of God: laying aside the fear of death, let us think on the immortality which follows. By this let us show ourselves to be what we believe, that we do not grieve over the departure of those dear to us, and that when the day of our summons shall arrive, we come without delay and without resistance to the Lord when He Himself calls us.

25. This attitude, which should always be held by God's servants, ought to be held even more strongly now—now that the world is collapsing and oppressed by storms of destructive evils. We who see that terrible things have already begun, and who know that even more terrible things are coming, should consider it the greatest advantage to leave this world as quickly as possible. If the walls of your house were shaking from old age, if the roofs above you were trembling, and if the house, now worn out and exhausted, threatened imminent destruction as its aging structure crumbled, wouldn't you leave with all speed? If you were on a voyage and an angry, raging storm violently stirred up waves that warned of coming shipwreck, wouldn't you quickly seek the harbor? Look—the world is changing and passing away, and it testifies to its ruin not simply through its age, but through the end of all things. Yet do you not thank God? Do you not congratulate yourself that through an earlier departure you are taken away and delivered from the shipwrecks and disasters that are coming?

25. And this, as it ought always to be done by God's servants, much more ought to be done now — now that the world is collapsing and is oppressed with the tempests of mischievous ills; in order that we who see that terrible things have begun, and know that still more terrible things are imminent, may regard it as the greatest advantage to depart from it as quickly as possible. If in your dwelling the walls were shaking with age, the roofs above you were trembling, and the house, now worn out and wearied, were threatening an immediate destruction to its structure crumbling with age, would you not with all speed depart? If, when you were on a voyage, an angry and raging tempest, by the waves violently aroused, foretold the coming shipwreck, would you not quickly seek the harbour? Lo, the world is changing and passing away, and witnesses to its ruin not now by its age, but by the end of things. And do you not give God thanks, do you not congratulate yourself, that by an earlier departure you are taken away, and delivered from the shipwrecks and disasters that are imminent?

We should consider, dearly beloved brethren—we should now and always reflect that we have renounced the world and are in the meantime living here as guests and strangers. Let us greet the day which assigns each of us to his own home, which snatches us from here and sets us free from the snares of the world, and restores us to paradise and the kingdom. Who that has been placed in foreign lands would not hurry to return to his own country? Who that is hurrying to return to his friends would not eagerly desire a favorable wind, so that he might embrace those dear to him all the sooner? We regard paradise as our country—we already begin to consider the patriarchs as our parents. Why do we not hurry and run, so that we may see our country and greet our parents? A great number of our dear ones is waiting for us there, and a dense crowd of parents, brothers, and children is longing for us, already assured of their own safety and still concerned for our salvation. What gladness both for them and for us in common to reach their presence and their embrace! What pleasure there is in the heavenly kingdom, without fear of death, and how lofty and perpetual a happiness with eternity of living! There is the glorious company of the apostles—there is the host of the rejoicing prophets—there is the innumerable multitude of martyrs, crowned for the victory of their struggle and passion—there are the triumphant virgins, who subdued the lust of the flesh and of the body by the strength of their continency—there are merciful men rewarded, who by feeding and helping the poor have done the works of righteousness—who, keeping the Lord's precepts, have transferred their earthly patrimonies to the heavenly treasuries. To these, beloved brethren, let us hasten with an eager desire. Let us crave quickly to be with them and quickly to come to Christ. May God see this eager desire of ours. May the Lord Christ look upon this purpose of our mind and faith, He who will give the larger rewards of His glory to those whose desires in respect of Himself were greater.

26. We should consider, dearly beloved brethren — we should now and always reflect that we have renounced the world, and are in the meantime living here as guests and strangers. Let us greet the day which assigns each of us to his own home, which snatches us hence, and sets us free from the snares of the world, and restores us to paradise and the kingdom. Who that has been placed in foreign lands would not hasten to return to his own country? Who that is hastening to return to his friends would not eagerly desire a prosperous gale, that he might the sooner embrace those dear to him? We regard paradise as our country — we already begin to consider the patriarchs as our parents: why do we not hasten and run, that we may behold our country, that we may greet our parents? There a great number of our dear ones is awaiting us, and a dense crowd of parents, brothers, children, is longing for us, already assured of their own safety, and still solicitous for our salvation. To attain to their presence and their embrace, what a gladness both for them and for us in common! What a pleasure is there in the heavenly kingdom, without fear of death; and how lofty and perpetual a happiness with eternity of living! There the glorious company of the apostles — there the host of the rejoicing prophets — there the innumerable multitude of martyrs, crowned for the victory of their struggle and passion — there the triumphant virgins, who subdued the lust of the flesh and of the body by the strength of their continency — there are merciful men rewarded, who by feeding and helping the poor have done the works of righteousness — who, keeping the Lord's precepts, have transferred their earthly patrimonies to the heavenly treasuries. To these, beloved brethren, let us hasten with an eager desire; let us crave quickly to be with them, and quickly to come to Christ. May God behold this our eager desire; may the Lord Christ look upon this purpose of our mind and faith, He who will give the larger rewards of His glory to those whose desires in respect of Himself were greater!


On the Priesthood — Book VI

On the Priesthood, Book VI: the dialogue with Basil on the dignity and dangers of priestly ministry.

Source: Translated by W.R.W. Stephens. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 9. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/19226.htm>.

Opening

Our situation here is exactly as you have heard. But how will we endure our situation in the age to come, when we are forced to give an account for each person who has been entrusted to us? Our penalty is not limited to shame alone, but everlasting punishment awaits us as well. Regarding the passage, "Obey them that have the rule over you, and submit to them, for they watch in behalf of your souls as they that shall give account," though I have already mentioned it once, I will speak of it again now, because the fear of its warning constantly troubles my soul. For if for the person who causes even one person to stumble, and that the least important, it would be better that a large millstone be hung around his neck and that he be drowned in the depths of the sea, and if those who wound the consciences of the brethren sin against Christ Himself, what then will they suffer one day, what kind of penalty will they pay, who destroy not just one, or two, or three, but so many multitudes? For it is not possible to plead inexperience as an excuse, nor to take refuge in ignorance, nor to put forward the claim of necessity or force. Indeed, if it were possible, one of those under their charge could more easily use this refuge for his own sins than bishops can in the case of the sins of others. Do you ask why? Because the one who has been appointed to correct the ignorance of others and to warn them beforehand of the conflict with the devil that is coming upon them will not be able to put forward ignorance as his excuse or to say, "I never heard the trumpet sound, I did not foresee the conflict." For he is appointed for this very purpose, says Ezekiel, that he may sound the trumpet for others and warn them of the dangers at hand. And therefore his punishment is unavoidable, even if the one who perishes happens to be only one person. For if when the sword comes, the watchman does not sound the trumpet to the people nor give them a sign, and the sword comes and takes any person away, that person is indeed taken away because of his iniquity, but his blood I will require at the watchman's hands.

1. Our condition here, indeed, is such as you have heard. But our condition hereafter how shall we endure, when we are compelled to give our account for each of those who have been entrusted to us? For our penalty is not limited to shame, but everlasting chastisement awaits us as well. As for the passage, Obey them that have the rule over you, and submit to them, for they watch in behalf of your souls as they that shall give account; Hebrews 13:17 though I have mentioned it once already, yet I will break silence about it now, for the fear of its warning is continually agitating my soul. For if for him who causes one only, and that the least, to stumble, it is profitable that a great millstone should be hanged about his neck, and that he should be sunk in the depth of the sea; Matthew 18:6 and if they who wound the consciences of the brethren, sin against Christ Himself, 1 Corinthians 8:12 what then will they one day suffer, what kind of penalty will they pay, who destroy not one only, or two, or three, but so many multitudes? For it is not possible for inexperience to be urged as an excuse, nor to take refuge in ignorance, nor for the plea of necessity or force to be put forward. Yea, if it were possible, one of those under their charge could more easily make use of this refuge for his own sins than bishops in the case of the sins of others. Do you ask why? Because he who has been appointed to rectify the ignorance of others, and to warn them beforehand of the conflict with the devil which is coming upon them, will not be able to put forward ignorance as his excuse, or to say, I have never heard the trumpet sound, I did not foresee the conflict. For he is set for that very purpose, says Ezekiel, that he may sound the trumpet for others, and warn them of the dangers at hand. And therefore his chastisement is inevitable, though he that perishes happen to be but one. For if when the sword comes, the watchman does not sound the trumpet to the people, nor give them a sign, and the sword come and take any man away, he indeed is taken away on account of his iniquity, but his blood will I require at the watchman's hands. Ezekiel 33:6

Cease then to urge us toward a penalty so inevitable, for our discussion is not about an army or a kingdom, but about an office that requires the virtues of an angel. The soul of the priest ought to be purer than the very sunbeams, so that the Holy Spirit may not abandon him, so that he may be able to say, "Now I live; and yet no longer I, but Christ lives in me" (Galatians 2:20). For if those who dwell in the desert, far removed from the city, the marketplace, and its tumult, who enjoy all their time in a haven of rest and peacefulness, are not willing to rely on the security of that way of life, but add to it countless other safeguards, hedging themselves in on every side and studying to speak and act with great circumspection so that to the fullest extent of human power they may draw near to God with confidence and with unstained purity—what power and strength do you think the ordained priest needs in order to tear his soul away from every defilement and keep its spiritual beauty unsullied? For he needs far greater purity than they do, and whoever needs greater purity is also subject to more pressing temptations than they, which can defile him, unless by constant self-denial and much labor he renders his soul inaccessible to them. For beauty of face, elegance of movement, an affected gait and lisping voice, penciled eyebrows and enameled cheeks, elaborate braiding and dyeing of hair, costly dress, an array of golden ornaments, and the glory of precious stones, the scent of perfumes, and all those other matters to which womankind devotes itself, are enough to disorder the mind, unless it happens to be hardened against them through much austerity of self-restraint. Now to be disturbed indeed by such things is nothing wonderful. But on the other hand, that the devil should be able to strike down and shoot down the souls of men by the opposite of these—this is a matter that fills us with astonishment and perplexity.

2. Cease then to urge us on to a penalty so inevitable; for our discourse is not about an army, or a kingdom; but about an office which needs the virtues of an angel. For the soul of the Priest ought to be purer than the very sunbeams, in order that the Holy Spirit may not leave him desolate, in order that he may be able to say, Now I live; and yet no longer I, but Christ lives in me. Galatians 2:20 For if they who dwell in the desert, and are removed far from the city and the market-place, and the tumult therein, and who enjoy all their time a haven of rest, and of peacefulness, are not willing to rely on the security of that manner of life, but add to it numberless other safeguards, hedging themselves round on every side, and studying both to speak and to act with great circumspection, so that to the utmost extent of human power they may draw near to God with assurance, and with unstained purity, what power and strength, do you think, does the ordained Priest need so as to be able to tear his soul away from every defilement, and to keep its spiritual beauty unsullied? For he has need of far greater purity than they; and whoever has need of greater purity, he too is subject to more pressing temptations than they, which are able to defile him, unless by using constant self-denial and much labor, he renders his soul inaccessible to them. For beauty of face, elegance of movement, an affected gait and lisping voice, pencilled eyebrows and enamelled cheeks, elaborate braiding and dyeing of hair, costliness of dress, variety of golden ornaments, and the glory of precious stones, the scent of perfumes, and all those other matters to which womankind devote themselves, are enough to disorder the mind, unless it happen to be hardened against them, through much austerity of self restraint. Now to be disturbed indeed by such things is nothing wonderful. But on the other hand, that the devil should be able to hit and shoot down the souls of men by the opposite of these — this is a matter which fills us with astonishment and perplexity.

Some men who have escaped these traps have been caught by others that are completely different. For example, a neglected appearance, unkempt hair, shabby clothing, and a face without makeup, simple behavior and plain speech, an unstudied way of walking, an unaffected voice, a life of poverty, and a despised, friendless, and isolated condition—these things first move the observer to pity, and then to complete ruin. Many who have escaped the earlier snares involving gold ornaments, perfumes, fine clothing, and all the other things I mentioned have easily fallen into these very different ones and perished. So when war is stirred up in the soul of the observer both by poverty and by wealth, both by attention to personal appearance and by its neglect, both by studied and by unaffected manners—in short, by all the means I have listed—and its tricks surround him on every side, how will he be able to breathe freely while so many snares encircle him? And what refuge will he be able to find—I do not mean to avoid being forcibly seized by them, for that is not altogether difficult—but to keep his own soul undisturbed by polluting thoughts?

3. For ere now some men who have escaped these snares, have been caught by others widely differing from these. For even a neglected appearance, unkempt hair, squalid dress, and an unpainted face, simple behavior, and homely language, unstudied gait, and unaffected voice, a life of poverty, a despised, unpatronized and lonely condition, have first drawn on the beholder to pity, and next to utter ruin; and many who have escaped the former nets, in the way of gold ornaments and perfumes, and apparel, and all the rest, of which I have spoken as connected with them, have easily fallen into these so widely differing from them, and have perished. When then both by poverty and by riches, both by the adornment and the neglect of the personal appearance, both by studied and unaffected manners, in short by all those means which I have enumerated, war is kindled in the soul of the beholder, and its artifices surround him on every side, how will he be able to breathe freely while so many snares encompass him? And what hiding-place will he be able to find — I do not say so as to avoid being forcibly seized by them (for this is not altogether difficult)– but so as to keep his own soul undisturbed by polluting thoughts?

And I pass by honors, which cause countless evils. Those that come from women are ruinous to the strength of self-restraint, and often overthrow it when a man does not know how to guard constantly against such designs. Those that come from men, unless a man receives them with great nobility of mind, lead him into two opposite emotions: servile flattery and senseless pride. He is forced to cringe before those who patronize him, and he becomes puffed up toward his inferiors because of the honors others give him, and he is driven into the pit of arrogance. We have mentioned these matters, but no one could really learn how harmful they actually are without experiencing them. Not only these snares, but greater and more deceptive ones than these, must be faced by the person who lives in the world. But the person who is content with solitude is free from all this, and if at times a strange thought creates such an image, the image is weak and can be quickly overcome, because no fuel is added to the flame from outside through actual sight. For the recluse has only himself to fear for, or if he is forced to care for others, they are easily counted. And if they are many, they are still fewer than those in our churches, and they give him who is set over them much lighter anxiety, not only because of their small number, but because they are all free from worldly concerns and have neither wife nor children nor anything like that to care about. This makes them very respectful toward their rulers and allows them to share the same dwelling, so that the rulers can accurately see their faults at a glance and correct them, since the constant supervision of a teacher is no small help toward progress in virtue.

And I pass by honors, which are the cause of countless evils. For those which come from the hands of women are ruinous to the vigor of self-restraint, and often overthrow it when a man does not know how to watch constantly against such designs; while those which come from the hands of men, unless a man receive them with much nobleness of mind, he is seized with two contrary emotions, servile flattery and senseless pride. To those who patronize him, he is obliged to cringe; and towards his inferiors he is puffed up, on account of the honors which the others confer, and is driven into the gulf of arrogance. We have mentioned these matters indeed, but how harmful they actually are, no one could well learn without experience. For not only these snares, but greater and more delusive than these, he must needs encounter, who has his conversation in the world. But he who is content with solitude, has freedom from all this, and if at any time a strange thought creates a representation of this kind, the image is weak, and capable of being speedily subdued, because there is no fuel added to the flame from without, arising from actual sight. For the recluse has but himself to fear for; or should he be forced to have the care of others they are easily counted: and if they be many, yet they are less than those in our Churches, and they give him who is set over them much lighter anxiety about them, not only on account of their fewness, but because they are all free from worldly concerns, and have neither wife nor children, nor any such thing to care about; and this makes them very deferential to their rulers, and allows them to share the same abode with them, so that they are able to take in their failings accurately at a glance and correct them, seeing that the constant supervision of a teacher is no little help towards advance in virtue.

But most of those who are under the care of the Priest are weighed down by the concerns of this life, and this makes them slower in carrying out spiritual responsibilities. Therefore the teacher must sow seed every day, so to speak, so that through constant repetition at least, the teaching may be grasped by those who hear it. For excessive wealth, an abundance of power, laziness born from luxury, and many other things besides these choke out the seeds that have been planted. Often too, a thick overgrowth of thorns prevents the seed from even landing on the surface of the soil. On the other hand, overwhelming troubles, the pressure of poverty, constant insults, and other such things opposite to those mentioned earlier draw the mind away from concern for divine matters. And of their people's sins, not even the smallest portion can become visible to them, for how could it, when they do not even know most of them by sight?

4. But of those who are subject to the Priest, the greater number are hampered with the cares of this life, and this makes them the slower in the performance of spiritual duties. Whence it is necessary for the teacher to sow every day (so to speak), in order that by its frequency at least, the word of doctrine may be able to be grasped by those who hear. For excessive wealth, and an abundance of power, and sloth the offspring of luxury, and many other things beside these, choke the seeds which have been let fall. Often too the thick growth of thorns does not suffer the seed to drop even upon the surface of the soil. Again, excess of trouble, stress of poverty, constant insults, and other such things, the reverse of the foregoing, take the mind away from anxiety about things divine; and of their people's sins, not even the smallest part can become apparent; for how should it, in the case of those the majority of whom they do not know even by sight?

The priest's relationships with his people involve this much difficulty. But if anyone asks about his relationships with God, he will find the others to be as nothing, since these require a greater and more thorough seriousness. For the one who acts as an ambassador on behalf of the whole city—but why do I say the city? On behalf of the whole world indeed—prays that God would be merciful toward the sins of all, not only of the living, but also of the departed. What kind of man ought he to be? For my part, I think that the boldness of speech of Moses and Elijah is insufficient for such supplication. For as though he were entrusted with the whole world and were himself the father of all people, he draws near to God, begging that wars may be extinguished everywhere, that disturbances may be calmed, asking for peace and prosperity, and a swift deliverance from all the troubles that afflict each person, publicly and privately. And he ought to excel in every respect all those on whose behalf he prays, as much as rulers should excel their subjects.

The Priest's relations with his people involve thus much difficulty. But if any inquire about his relations with God, he will find the others to be as nothing, since these require a greater and more thorough earnestness. For he who acts as an ambassador on behalf of the whole city — but why do I say the city? On behalf of the whole world indeed — prays that God would be merciful to the sins of all, not only of the living, but also of the departed. What manner of man ought he to be? For my part I think that the boldness of speech of Moses and Elias, is insufficient for such supplication. For as though he were entrusted with the whole world and were himself the father of all men, he draws near to God, beseeching that wars may be extinguished everywhere, that tumults may be quelled; asking for peace and plenty, and a swift deliverance from all the ills that beset each one, publicly and privately; and he ought as much to excel in every respect all those on whose behalf he prays, as rulers should excel their subjects.

And whenever he invokes the Holy Spirit and offers the most awesome sacrifice and constantly handles the common Lord of all, tell me what rank should we give him? What great purity and what genuine piety must we require of him? Consider what kind of hands ought to be ministering in these things, and what kind of tongue speaking such words. Should not the soul that receives so great a Spirit be purer and holier than anything in the world? At such a time angels stand beside the priest, and the whole sanctuary and the space around the altar is filled with the heavenly powers, in honor of Him who lies there. This can indeed be proven from the very rites that are being celebrated. I myself have heard someone relate that a certain elderly, venerable man, accustomed to seeing revelations, used to tell him that when he was granted a vision of this kind at such a time, he suddenly saw, as far as he was able, a multitude of angels clothed in shining garments, surrounding the altar and bowing down, as one might see soldiers in the presence of their king—and I for one believe it. Another person told me, not learning it from someone else but being himself deemed worthy to be both hearer and eyewitness of it, that in the case of those who are about to depart from this life, if they happen to be partakers of the mysteries with a pure conscience, when they are about to breathe their last, angels keep watch over them for the sake of what they have received and bear them away. And do you not yet tremble to introduce into so sacred a mystery a soul like this, and to advance to the dignity of the priesthood one clothed in filthy garments, whom Christ has shut out from the rest of the company of guests? The soul of the priest should shine like a light beaming over the whole world. But mine has such great darkness hanging over it because of my evil conscience that it is always cast down and never able to look up with confidence to its Lord. Priests are the salt of the earth. But who would easily put up with my lack of understanding and my inexperience in all things except you, who have always loved me beyond measure? For the priest ought not only to be pure, as befits one who has been honored with so high a ministry, but also very discerning and skilled in many matters, and to be as well versed in the affairs of this life as those who are engaged in the world, and yet to be free from them all more than the hermits who occupy the mountains. Since he must mix with men who have wives and bring up children, who possess servants and are surrounded with wealth and fill public positions and are people of influence, he too must be versatile—I say versatile, not fake, nor fawning and hypocritical, but full of much freedom and confidence, and knowing how to adapt himself profitably where circumstances require it, and to be both kind and severe. For it is not possible to treat all those under one's charge according to one plan, since it is not good for physicians to apply one course of treatment to all their sick, nor for a pilot to know only one way of contending with the winds. Indeed, continual storms beset this ship of ours, and these storms do not only assail from outside but arise from within, and there is need of much adaptability and circumspection. All these different matters have one end in view: the glory of God and the building up of the Church.

And whenever he invokes the Holy Spirit, and offers the most dread sacrifice, and constantly handles the common Lord of all, tell me what rank shall we give him? What great purity and what real piety must we demand of him? For consider what manner of hands they ought to be which minister in these things, and of what kind his tongue which utters such words, and ought not the soul which receives so great a spirit to be purer and holier than anything in the world? At such a time angels stand by the Priest; and the whole sanctuary, and the space round about the altar, is filled with the powers of heaven, in honor of Him who lies thereon. For this, indeed, is capable of being proved from the very rites which are being then celebrated. I myself, moreover, have heard some one once relate, that a certain aged, venerable man, accustomed to see revelations, used to tell him, that he being thought worthy of a vision of this kind, at such a time, saw, on a sudden, so far as was possible for him, a multitude of angels, clothed in shining robes, and encircling the altar, and bending down, as one might see soldiers in the presence of their King, and for my part I believe it. Moreover another told me, without learning it from some one else, but as being himself thought worthy to be both an ear and eye witness of it, that, in the case of those who are about to depart hence, if they happen to be partakers of the mysteries, with a pure conscience, when they are about to breathe their last, angels keep guard over them for the sake of what they have received, and bear them hence. And do you not yet tremble to introduce a soul into so sacred a mystery of this kind, and to advance to the dignity of the Priesthood, one robed in filthy raiment, whom Christ has shut out from the rest of the band of guests? Matthew 22:13 The soul of the Priest should shine like a light beaming over the whole world. But mine has so great darkness overhanging it, because of my evil conscience, as to be always cast down and never able to look up with confidence to its Lord. Priests are the salt of the earth. Matthew 5:13 But who would easily put up with my lack of understanding, and my inexperience in all things, but thou, who hast been wont to love me beyond measure. For the Priest ought not only to be thus pure as one who has been dignified with so high a ministry, but very discreet, and skilled in many matters, and to be as well versed in the affairs of this life as they who are engaged in the world, and yet to be free from them all more than the recluses who occupy the mountains. For since he must mix with men who have wives, and who bring up children, who possess servants, and are surrounded with wealth, and fill public positions, and are persons of influence, he too should be a many-sided man — I say many-sided, not unreal, nor yet fawning and hypocritical, but full of much freedom and assurance, and knowing how to adapt himself profitably, where the circumstances of the case require it, and to be both kind and severe, for it is not possible to treat all those under one's charge on one plan, since neither is it well for physicians to apply one course of treatment to all their sick, nor for a pilot to know but one way of contending with the winds. For, indeed, continual storms beset this ship of ours, and these storms do not assail from without only, but take their rise from within, and there is need of much condescension, and circumspection, and all these different matters have one end in view, the glory of God, and the edifying of the Church.

Great is the struggle that those who withdraw from the world undergo, and their labor is considerable. But if anyone compares their efforts with those involved in the proper exercise of the priesthood, he will find the difference as great as that between a king and an ordinary citizen. For in their case, though the labor is indeed great, the struggle belongs to both body and soul together—or rather the greater part of it is accomplished through the body's condition. And if the body is not strong, the desire remains undeveloped and unable to be put into action. For the practices of intense fasting, sleeping on the ground, staying awake through the night, abstaining from bathing, hard physical labor, and all other means they use to discipline the body must be abandoned when the body being disciplined is not strong. But in the case of the priesthood, purity of soul is what matters, and no bodily strength is needed to demonstrate its excellence. For what does physical strength contribute toward our being not self-willed, or proud, or stubborn, but sober-minded and prudent and well-ordered, and everything else that St. Paul included in his description of the perfect priest? But no one could say this about the virtues of the recluse.

5. Great is the conflict which recluses undergo, and much their toil. But if any one compare their exertions with those which the right exercise of the Priesthood involves, he will find the difference as great as the distance between a king and a commoner. For there, if the labor is great indeed, yet the conflict is common to body and soul, or rather the greater part of it is accomplished by the condition of the body, and if this be not strong, the inclination remains undeveloped, and is unable to come out into action. For the habit of intense fasting, and sleeping on the ground, and keeping vigil, and refraining from the bath, and great toil, and all other means which they use for the affliction of the body are given up, when the body to be thus disciplined is not strong. But in this case purity of soul is the business in hand, and no bodily vigor is required to show its excellence. For what does strength of body contribute towards our being not self-willed, or proud, or headstrong, but sober and prudent, and orderly, and all else, wherein St. Paul filled up the picture of the perfect Priest? But no one could say this of the virtues of the recluse.

But just as stage magicians need a large apparatus with wheels, ropes, and daggers, while a philosopher has his entire art stored in his mind and requires no external equipment, the same applies here. The recluse needs good physical health and a suitable location for his way of life—a place not too far removed from human contact, with the quietness of the wilderness, and also a favorable climate. For nothing is more unbearable to a body weakened by fasting than an unstable climate. I need not mention the trouble they must take in preparing their clothing and daily food, since they insist on doing everything with their own hands. But the priest requires none of these things for his needs. He is unconcerned about them and freely uses whatever is harmless, while keeping all his skill stored in the treasury of his mind. If anyone admires the solitary life and withdrawal from society, I would say that such a life shows patience but does not provide sufficient proof of complete strength of soul. For a person who sits at the helm in harbor has not yet given any clear proof of his skill. But if someone can guide his ship safely through the open sea, no one would deny that he is an excellent steersman.

6. But as in the case of wonder-workers, a large apparatus is required, both wheels and ropes and daggers; while the philosopher has the whole of his art stored up in his mind, not requiring any external appliances: So accordingly in the case before us. The recluse requires both a good condition of body, and a place suitable for his course of life, in order that such may not be settled too far from intercourse with their fellow men, and may have the tranquillity which belongs to desert places, and yet further, may not fail to enjoy the most favorable climate. For nothing is so unbearable to a body worn with fastings as a climate which is not equable. And what trouble they are compelled to take in the preparation of their clothing and daily food, as they are themselves ambitious of doing all with their own hands, I need not speak of now. But the Priest will require none of these things to supply his wants, but is unconcerned about them, and participates in all things which are harmless, while he has all his skill stored up in the treasure-house of his mind. But if any one admire a solitary life, and retirement from the society of the multitude, I should say myself that such a life was a token of patience, but not a sufficient proof of entire fortitude of soul. For the man who sits at the helm in harbor, does not yet give any certain proof of his art. But if one is able to guide his ship safely in the midst of the sea, no one would deny him to be an excellent steersman.

It would not be at all surprising to us that the recluse, living by himself as he does, remains undisturbed and does not commit many great sins. After all, he does not encounter things that irritate and agitate his mind. But if someone who has devoted himself to entire communities and has been forced to bear the sins of many has remained steadfast and firm, guiding his soul through the storm as though he were in calm waters, he is the one who deserves to be justly praised and admired by everyone, for he has shown sufficient proof of personal courage. Therefore, do not wonder that I, who avoid the marketplace and crowded places, do not have many people accusing me. For I should not be surprised if I did not sin while asleep, nor fell when I did not wrestle, nor got hit when I did not fight. Who, tell me, who will be able to speak against me and reveal my wickedness? Can this roof or cell? No, they cannot speak. Would my mother, who knows my affairs best of all? Well, certainly I am not in contact with her, and we have never come to a quarrel. Even if this had happened, no mother is so heartless and lacking in affection for her child as to revile and publicly accuse the one she carried, gave birth to, and raised, unless there were some reason compelling her or someone urging her to do so. Nevertheless, if anyone wants to carefully examine my mind, he will discover much corruption there. And you are aware of this, you who are especially accustomed to praising me before everyone. That I do not say these things out of mere modesty, remember how often I told you when we discussed this subject between us: If someone were to give me the choice of whether I would rather excel in the oversight of the Church or in the life of the recluse, I would choose the former a thousand times over. For I have always congratulated those who have been able to discharge this office well, and no one will deny that I would not have avoided what I considered blessed if I were able to take part in it properly. But what am I to do? Nothing is so harmful to the oversight of the Church as this inactivity and negligence of mine, which others think is a kind of self-discipline, but which I consider to be a veil covering most of my personal weaknesses and preventing them from being seen. For someone who is accustomed to such great freedom from responsibilities and to spending his time in much leisure, even if he has a noble nature, becomes confused by his inexperience, gets disturbed, and his inactivity deprives him of no small part of his natural ability. But when, in addition, he has a slow intellect and is also ignorant of these severe trials, which I believe is my case, he will carry out the ministry he has received no better than a statue. Therefore, of those who have come to such great trials from that school, few shine, and most betray themselves, fall, and undergo much hardship and suffering—and no wonder. For the trials and the training are not concerned with the same things. The person who is competing is no different from those who are untrained. Anyone entering this contest should despise glory, be superior to anger, and be full of great discretion. But there is no opportunity for exercising these qualities in the case of someone who lives a secluded life. For he does not have many people to provoke him so that he may practice controlling the force of his anger, nor admirers and applauders so that he may be trained to despise the praises of the crowds. And the discretion required in the Church cannot be developed in their case. Therefore, whenever they come to trials they have never experienced practically, they become bewildered, their heads spin, they fall into helplessness, and besides adding nothing to their virtue, they often lose what they brought with them.

7. It would be, therefore, in no wise excessively surprising to us, that the recluse, living as he does by himself, is undisturbed and does not commit many and great sins. For he does not meet with things which irritate and excite his mind. But if any one who has devoted himself to whole multitudes, and has been compelled to bear the sins of many, has remained steadfast and firm, guiding his soul in the midst of the storm as if he were in a calm, he is the man to be justly applauded and admired of all, for he has shown sufficient proof of personal manliness. Do not thou, therefore, for your part wonder if I, who avoid the market-place and the haunts of the multitude, have not many to accuse me. For I ought not to wonder, if I sinned not when asleep, nor fell when I did not wrestle, nor was hit if I did not fight. For who, tell me, who will be able to speak against me, and reveal my depravity? Can this roof or cell? Nay, they would not be able to give tongue? Would my mother, who best of all knows my affairs? Well, certainly with her I am neither in communication, nor have we ever come to a quarrel, and if this had happened, no mother is so heartless and wanting in affection for her child as to revile and accuse before all him whom she travailed with, and brought forth, and reared, if there were no reason to constrain her, nor any person to urge her to such an act. Nevertheless, if any one desires to make a careful inspection of my mind, he will discover much which is corrupt there. Nor are you unaware of this who art specially wont to extol me with praises before all. Now that I do not say these things out of mere modesty, recollect how often I said to you, when this subject was being discussed between us, If any one were to give me my choice whether I would rather gain distinction in the oversight of the Church, or in the life of the recluse, I would vote a thousand times over for accepting the former. For I have never failed to congratulate those who have been able to discharge this office well, and no one will gainsay that what I counted blessed I would not have shunned were I able to take part in it fitly. But what am I to do? There is nothing so prejudicial to the oversight of the Church as this inactivity and negligence of mine, which others think to be a sort of self-discipline, but which I hold to be a veil as it were of my personal infirmity, covering the greater number of my defects and not suffering them to appear. For he who is accustomed to enjoy such great freedom from business, and to pass his time in much repose, even if he be of a noble nature, is confused by his inexperience, and is disturbed, and his inactivity deprives him of no small part of his natural ability. But when, besides, he is of slow intellect, and ignorant also of these severe trials, which I take it is my case, he will carry on this ministry which he has received no better than a statue. Wherefore of those who have come to such great trial, out of that school, few shine; and the greater part betray themselves, and fall, and undergo much hardship and sufferings; and no wonder. For the trials and the discipline are not concerned with the same things. The man who is contending in no wise differs from those who are untrained. He who thus enters this list should despise glory, be superior to anger, full of great discretion. But for the exercise of these qualities there is no scope in his case who affects a secluded life. For he does not have many to provoke him in order that he may practise chastising, the force of his anger: nor admirers and applauders in order that he may be trained to despise the praises of the multitudes. And of the discretion which is required in the Church, there is no taking account in their case. Whenever, therefore, they come to the trials of which they have never had practical experience, they get bewildered, their heads are turned, they fall into a state of helplessness, and besides adding nothing to their excellence, may have often lost that which they brought with them.

8. Basil: What then? Should we place in charge of the Church's administration those who are involved in society and concerned with worldly affairs, who are skilled in arguing and insults, full of endless tricks, and experienced in luxurious living?

8. Basil: What then? Shall we set over the administration of the Church those who move in society, and who are careful about the concerns of this world, who are adepts at wrangling and vituperation, are full of countless artifices, and versed in luxurious ways?

Chrysostom: Stop, my dear friend! You should never think of such men when discussing the priesthood, but only of those who can mix and associate with everyone while keeping their purity undefiled, their unworldliness, holiness, constancy, and sobriety unshaken, and who possess all the other virtues that belong to recluses to an even greater degree than they do. A person who has many defects but is able to hide them through seclusion and make them ineffective because he doesn't associate with anyone will gain nothing when he enters society except becoming a laughingstock, and he will face even greater dangers—which I myself nearly experienced, had not God's providence quickly turned such fire away from my head. For it is impossible for someone in such a position to escape notice when he is so conspicuously placed; instead, everything is detected, and just as fire tests the quality of metals, so the trial of the clerical office searches the souls of mortal men. If anyone is passionate or mean or ambitious for fame, if he is boastful or has any other such flaw, it unveils everything and quickly lays bare his defects. Not only does it expose them, but it also increases their painfulness and strength. For wounds of the body, when they are irritated, become harder to heal, and the emotions of the mind, when chafed and irritated, naturally become more exasperated, and those who possess them are driven to commit greater sins. These emotions excite anyone who does not restrain them to love of glory, boastfulness, and desire for worldly goods, and they drag him down to luxury, lax living, and laziness, and little by little to evils worse than these that result from them. For there are many circumstances in society that have the power to upset the balance of the mind and hinder its straightforward course. First of all is his social interaction with women. For it is not possible for the bishop, who is concerned with the whole flock, to care for the male portion of it while passing over the female, which needs more particular forethought because of its propensity to sins. But the man appointed to the administration of a bishopric must care for the moral health of these women, if not more, at least no less than the others. For it is necessary to visit them when they are sick, to comfort them when they are sorrowful, to reprove them when they are idle, and to help them when they are distressed. In such cases the evil one would find many opportunities to approach, if a man did not fortify himself with a very strict guard. For the eye not only of the unchaste woman, but of the modest woman, pierces and disturbs the mind. Flatteries weaken it, and favors enslave it, and fervent love—which one may say is the spring of all good—becomes the cause of countless evils to those who do not make right use of it. Constant cares have before now blunted the edge of the understanding and have made what was buoyant heavier than lead, while anger has burst in like smoke and taken possession of all the inner man.

Chrysostom: Hush, dear friend that you are! You should never entertain in your thoughts such men as these, when the Priesthood is under discussion, but only such as are able after mixing and associating with all, to keep their purity undefiled, and their unworldliness, their holiness, constancy and sobriety unshaken, and to possess all other virtues which belong to recluses, in a greater degree than they. He who has many defects, but is able to hide them, by means of his seclusion, and to make them ineffectual, because he does not associate with any one, when he comes into society will gain nothing, but the position of a laughing-stock, and will run greater risks still, which I was very nearly experiencing myself, had not the providence of God quickly warded off such fire from my head. For it is not possible for one in such a position to escape notice when he is so conspicuously placed, but everything then is detected, and as the fire tests the material of metals, so too the trial of the clerical office searches the souls of mortal men; and if any one be passionate or mean, or ambitious of fame, if he be boastful, or anything else of the kind, it unveils all; and speedily lays bare his defects, and not only lays them bare, but increases their painfulness and strength. For the wounds of the body, if they are galled, become harder to heal, and the emotions of the mind when chafed and irritated, are naturally more exasperated, and those who possess them are driven to commit greater sins. For they excite him who does not restrain them, to love of glory, and to boastfulness, and to desire for this world's goods, and draw him downwards, both to luxury and laxity of life, and to laziness, and, little by little, to evils worse than these which result from them. For many are the circumstances in society which have the power to upset the balance of the mind, and to hinder its straightforward course; and first of all is his social intercourse with women. For it is not possible for the Bishop, and one who is concerned with the whole flock, to have a care for the male portion of it, but to pass over the female, which needs more particular forethought, because of its propensity to sins. But the man who is appointed to the administration of a Bishopric must have a care for the moral health of these, if not in a greater, at least in no less a degree than the others. For it is necessary to visit them when they are sick, to comfort them when they are sorrowful, and to reprove them when they are idle, and to help them when they are distressed; and in such cases the evil one would find many opportunities of approach, if a man did not fortify himself with a very strict guard. For the eye, not only of the unchaste, but of the modest woman pierces and disturbs the mind. Flatteries enervate it, and favors enslave it, and fervent love — the spring one may say of all good — becomes the cause of countless evils to those who do not make a right use of it. Constant cares too have ere now blunted the edge of the understanding, and have made that which was buoyant heavier than lead, while anger has burst in like smoke, and taken possession of all the inner man.

Why should anyone speak of the harm that comes from grief, the insults, the abuse, the criticism from superiors, from inferiors, from the wise, and from fools? For those who lack right judgment are particularly fond of criticizing and will rarely accept any excuse. But the truly excellent Bishop ought neither to take these lightly nor ignore them, but should clear himself before all people of the charges they bring against him, with great patience and gentleness, pardoning their unreasonable fault-finding rather than becoming indignant and angry about it. For if St. Paul feared that he might arouse suspicion of theft among his disciples, and therefore brought in others to manage the money, so that "no one," he says, "should blame us in this abundance which is administered by us," how much more ought we to do everything necessary to remove evil suspicions, even if they happen to be false, completely unreasonable, and very far from our thoughts? For we are not as utterly free from sin as St. Paul was from theft. Yet despite being so far removed from this evil practice, he did not disregard the suspicion of the world, even though it was absurd and even insane. For it was madness to have any such suspicion about that blessed and admirable man. But nonetheless he removed the causes of this suspicion from a distance, unreasonable though it was, and such that no one in his right mind would entertain it. He neither scorned the foolishness of the crowds nor said, "Who would ever think to suspect such things of us, after the signs I have worked, the patience that has marked my life, and when you all respected and admired us?" Quite the opposite: he foresaw and anticipated this base suspicion and pulled it up by the roots, or rather did not allow it to grow at all. Why? Because, he says, "we provide things honest not only before the Lord, but before all men." We must use equally great, indeed far greater, zeal to uproot and prevent unfavorable rumors, to see them from far off before they arrive, and to remove their causes beforehand, not waiting until they are established and become common topics in everyone's mouth. For then it is not easy to destroy them later, but very difficult, perhaps impossible, and not without harm, because this happens only after many have been injured. But how long shall I continue pursuing the unattainable? For to list all the difficulties in this area is nothing more than measuring the ocean. Even when someone clears himself from every passion—which is impossible—in order to correct the failings of others, he is forced to undergo countless trials. And when his own weaknesses are added, there you have an abyss of toil and care, and all that he must suffer who wishes to overcome the evils in himself and in those around him.

9. Why should any one speak of the injuries that result from grief, the insults, the abuse, the censure from superiors, from inferiors, from the wise, and from fools; for the class who are wanting in right judgment are particularly fond of censuring, and will never readily allow any excuse. But the truly excellent Bishop ought neither to think lightly of these, but to clear himself with all men of the charges which they bring against him, with great forbearance and meekness, pardoning their unreasonable fault-finding, rather than being indignant and angry about it. For if St. Paul feared lest he should incur a suspicion of theft, among his disciples, and therefore procured others for the management of the money, that no one he says, should blame us in this abundance which is administered by us, 2 Corinthians 8:20 how ought we not to do all so as to remove evil suspicions, even if they happen to be false, and most unreasonable, and very foreign to our thought? For we are not so utterly removed from any sin as St. Paul from theft; notwithstanding, though so far from this evil practice, he did not, therefore, slight the suspicion of the world, although it was very absurd, and even insane. For it was madness to have any such suspicion about that blessed and admirable character. But none the less does he remove far off the causes of this suspicion, unreasonable though it was, and such as no one who was in his senses would entertain, and he neither disdained the folly of the multitudes, nor did he say, To whose mind did it ever occur to suspect such things of us, after the signs which I have wrought, and the forbearance which has marked my life, and when you all revered and admired us? Quite the contrary: he foresaw and expected this base suspicion, and pulled it up by the roots, or rather did not suffer it to grow at all. Why? Because, says he, we provide things honest not only before the Lord, but before all men. So great, yea and far greater zeal must we use, to uproot and prevent floating reports which are not good, but to see beforehand from afar whence they come, and to remove beforehand the causes from which they are produced, not to wait till they are established and are the common topics in every one's mouth. For then it is not easy in the future to destroy them, but very difficult, perhaps impossible, and not without mischief, because this is done after many have been injured. But how far shall I continue pursuing the unattainable? For to enumerate all the difficulties in this direction, is nothing more nor less than measuring the ocean. Even when any one should clear himself from every passion (which is a thing impossible) in order to correct the failings of others, he is forced to undergo countless trials, and when his own infirmities are added, behold, an abyss of toil and care, and all that he must suffer, who wishes to subdue the evils in himself and in those around him.

10. Basil: And now, are you free from hard work? Do you have no worries while you live by yourself?

10. Basil: And now, art thou free from toils? Have you no cares while you live by yourself?

Chrysostom: I do have cares even now. How could someone who is human and living this difficult life of ours be free from worries and struggles? But there's a huge difference between plunging into a boundless ocean and crossing a river—that's how different these cares are from those earlier ones. Now, if I were able to be useful to others, I would want that myself, and I would pray for it. But if it's not possible to help someone else, yet if I can at least save and rescue myself from the waves, I'll be satisfied with that.

Chrysostom: I have indeed even now. For how is it possible for one who is a man, and who is living this toilsome life of ours, to be free from cares and conflict? But it is not quite the same thing for man to plunge into a boundless ocean and to cross a river, so great is the difference between these cares and those. For now, indeed, if I were able to become serviceable to others, I should wish it myself, and this would be a matter of prayer with me. But if it is not possible to help another, yet if it be practicable to save and rescue myself from the waves, I shall be contented.

Basil: So do you think this is some great accomplishment? Do you imagine that you will be saved when you are not useful to anyone else?

Basil: Do you then think this to be a great thing? And do you fancy that you will be saved when you are not profitable to any other?

Chrysostom: You have spoken well and nobly, for I cannot believe that someone who has not worked for the salvation of others can be saved. The wretched man in the Gospel was not helped by the fact that he had not diminished his talent; he perished because he did not increase it and bring it back doubled to his master. Matthew 25:24 Nevertheless, I think my punishment will be lighter when I am called to account for not saving others than it would be if I destroyed both myself and others by becoming far worse after receiving such great honor. For now I trust that my punishment will match the extent of my sins, but after receiving this office, I fear it would be not just double or triple, but many times greater, because I would have caused very many to stumble, and after receiving additional honor would have offended the God who honored me.

Chrysostom: You have spoken well and nobly, for I am not myself able to believe that it is possible for one who has not labored for the salvation of his fellow to be saved, nor did it at all profit the wretched man in the Gospel that he had not diminished his talent; but he perished through not increasing it and bringing it doubled to his master. Matthew 25:24 Nevertheless, I think that my punishment will be milder when I am called to account, because I have not saved others, than it would be if I should destroy myself and others too by becoming far worse after so great an honor. For now I trust that my chastisement will be proportioned to the amount of my sins, but after receiving this office, I fear it would be not double, or threefold, but manifold, because I should have caused very many to stumble, and after additional honor should have offended the God who honored me.

For this very reason, God accuses the Israelites more harshly and shows that they deserved greater punishment because they sinned after receiving so many honors from Him. In one place He says: "But you only have I known of all the families of the earth, therefore will I punish you for your iniquities," and again, "and I raised up of your sons for prophets, and of your young men for Nazarites." Before the time of the prophets, wanting to show that sins receive far more severe punishment when committed by a priest than by a layperson, He commands that just as great a sacrifice be offered for a priest as for the whole people. This amounts to proof that the wounds of the priesthood need more help—as much as those of all the people together. They would not need more help unless they were worse, and they are not worse in their nature but are made worse by the dignity of the priest who dares to commit them. And why should I speak only of the men who carry out this ministry? Even the daughters of priests, who have no part in the priestly office, undergo far more severe punishment for the same sins as others because of their father's dignity. The offense is the same in their case and in the daughters of laypeople—namely, fornication in both—yet the penalty is far more severe for the former. Do you see with what abundant proof God shows you that He demands much greater punishment for the ruler than for the ruled? For surely He who punishes the daughter of a certain man more severely than others for that man's sake will not exact the same penalty from the man who is the cause of her additional punishment as from others, but a much heavier one—and very reasonably. For the harm does not merely involve himself, but it destroys the souls of the weaker brethren and of those who look up to him. Ezekiel, writing to show this, distinguishes from one another the judgment of the rams and of the sheep.

11. For this very cause God accuses the Israelites more vehemently, and shows that they were worthy of greater chastisement, because they sinned after so many honors had come to them from Him, saying in one place: But you only have I known of all the families of the earth, therefore will I punish you for your iniquities, Amos 3:2 and again, and I raised up of your sons for prophets, and of your young men for Nazarites; Amos 2:11 and before the times of the prophets, wishing to show that sins receive sorer punishment by far when they occur in the case of the Priest than in the case of the laity, He enjoins as great a sacrifice to be offered for the Priest as for the whole people, and this amounts to a proof on his part, that the wounds of the Priesthood need more assistance — that is, as great as those of all the people together, and they would not have needed a greater, except they were worse; and they are not worse in their nature, but are aggravated through the dignity of the Priest, who dares to commit them. And why do I speak of the men who follow this ministration. For the daughters of the Priests, Leviticus 21:9 who have no part in the Priestly office, yet on account of their father's dignity undergo a far bitterer punishment for the same sins as others, and the offense is the same in their case and in the daughters of the laity; namely, fornication in both; yet the penalty is far severer for the former. Do you see with what abundant proof God shows you that he demands much greater punishment for the ruler than for the ruled? For no doubt he who punishes to a greater degree than others the daughter of a certain man for that man's sake, will not exact the same penalty from the man who is the cause of her additional chastisement as from others, but a much heavier one; and very reasonably; for the mischief does not merely involve himself, but it destroys the souls of the weaker brethren and of them who look up to him, and Ezekiel, writing to show this, distinguishes from one another the judgment of the rams and of the sheep. Ezekiel 34:17

Does our fear seem reasonable to you? Beyond what has already been said, although much hard work is required on my part to keep from being completely overwhelmed by the passions of my soul, I still endure the work and do not avoid the struggle. Even now I am captured by vainglory, but I often recover myself and see immediately that I have been caught, and there are times when I rebuke my soul for being enslaved. Sinful desires still come over me, but they kindle only a weak flame, since my physical eyes cannot find any fuel to feed the fire. I am completely removed from speaking evil of anyone or from hearing anyone spoken of badly, since I have no one to talk with—surely these walls would never speak. Yet it is not quite as possible to avoid anger, even though there is no one to provoke it. Often when the memory of terrible people comes over me, and of the deeds they have done, it makes my heart swell with anger. But not permanently, for I quickly subdue its kindling and persuade it to be quiet, saying that it is very foolish and extremely contemptible to ignore one's own fault and to busy oneself with the faults of one's neighbors. But if I were to go among the crowds and be involved in countless disturbances, I would not be able to benefit from this warning or to experience reflections that correct me in this way. Just as those who are driven over cliffs by a torrent or in some other way can foresee the destruction they are heading toward but cannot think of any means of help, so I, when I have fallen into the great tumult of my passions, will be able to see my punishment increasing daily. But to be master of myself as I am now, and to rebuke such diseases raging on every side, would not be equally easy for me as it was before. For my soul is weak and small and easily mastered, not only by these passions but by envy, which is more bitter than all of them. It does not know how to bear insults or honors with moderation. These greatly inflate it, while those depress it. Therefore, just as savage wild beasts, when they are well-fed and at full strength, overcome those who fight with them, especially if those fighters are weak and unskilled, but if someone weakens them by starvation, he will put their rage to sleep and extinguish most of their strength, so that even someone not particularly brave might take up the conflict and battle with them—so it is also with the passions of the soul. The one who makes them weak places them under the control of right reason, but the one who carefully nourishes them makes his battle with them harder and makes them so formidable that he spends all his time in bondage and fear.

12. Do we then seem to you to entertain a reasonable fear? For in addition to what has been said, although much toil is needful on my part, so that I should not be completely overwhelmed by the passions of my soul, yet I endure the toil, and I do not shun the conflict. For even now I am taken captive by vainglory, but I often recover myself, and I see at a glance that I have been taken, and there are times when I rebuke my soul, which has been enslaved; outrageous desires even now come over me, but they kindle only a languid flame, since my bodily eyes cannot fasten upon any fuel to feed the fire. From speaking ill of any, or from hearing any one evil spoken of, I am utterly removed, since I have no one to talk with; for surely these walls would never give tongue; yet it is not altogether in like manner possible to avoid anger, although there be none to provoke it. For often when the recollection of outrageous men has come over me, and of the deeds done by them, it makes my heart swell. But not permanently, for I quickly subdue its kindling, and persuade it to be quiet, saying that it is very inexpedient and extremely despicable to leave one's own fault alone, and to busy one's self about the faults of one's neighbors. But were I to come among the multitude, and to be involved in countless excitements, I should not be able to have the benefit of this warning, nor to experience reflections which take me thus to task. But just as they who are driven over precipices by a torrent, or in some other way, are able to foresee the destruction to which they are finally going, and are unable to think of any means of help, so I, when I have fallen into the great tumult of my passions, shall be able to see at a glance my chastisement daily increasing. But to be master of myself as I am now, and to rebuke diseases of this sort raging on every side, would not be equally easy for me as it was before. For my soul is weak and puny, and easily mastered, not only by these passions, but by envy, which is bitterer than all of them. Neither does it know how to bear insults or honors temperately. But these do exceedingly elate it, while those depress it. As, then, savage wild beasts, when they are in good condition, and in full vigor, overcome those that fight with them, particularly, too, if they be feeble and unskillful; but if any one were to weaken them by starvation, he will put their rage to sleep, and will extinguish most of their strength; so that one, not over valiant, might take up the conflict and battle with them: so also with the passions of the soul. He who makes them weak, places them in subjection to right reason; but he who nourishes them carefully, makes his battle with them harder, and renders them so formidable that he passes all his time in bondage and fear.

What then is the food of these wild beasts? For vainglory, it is honors and applause; for pride, it is an abundance of authority and power; for envy, it is the reputation of one's neighbors; for greed, it is the generosity of those who give freely; for lack of self-control, it is luxury and the constant company of women; and other passions have their own proper nourishment. All these things will fiercely attack me if I go out into the world and will tear my soul to pieces. They will be more dangerous and will make my battle against them much harder. But while I remain here, they will be subdued—though only with great effort. Yet at the same time, by the grace of God, they will be subdued, and there will be nothing worse than their barking. For these reasons I stay in this cell and remain inaccessible, self-contained, and unsociable, and I put up with hearing countless complaints about this, although I would gladly remove them and have been troubled and grieved because I cannot. For it is not easy for me to become sociable and at the same time to remain in my present security. Therefore I ask you, too, to pity rather than to blame one who is caught in such great difficulty.

What then is the food of these wild beasts? Of vainglory, indeed, it is honors and applause; of pride, abundance of authority and power; of envy, the reputation of one's neighbors; of avarice, the munificence of the generous; of incontinence, luxury and the constant society of women; and other passions have their proper nutriment? And all these things will sorely attack me if I come forth into the world, and will tear my soul to pieces, will be the more formidable and will make my battle with them the harder. Whereas, while I am established here they will be subdued; and then, indeed, only with great exertion; yet at the same time, by the Grace of God, they will be subdued, and there will not be anything worse then than their bark. For these reasons I keep to this cell, and am inaccessible, self-contained, and unsociable, and I put up with hearing countless complaints of this kind, although I would gladly efface them, and have been vexed and grieved because I cannot; for it is not easy for me to become sociable, and at the same time to remain in my present security. Therefore I beseech you, too, to pity rather than to censure one beset with such great difficulty.

But we cannot yet persuade you. So the time has now come for me to tell you the one thing I have left unsaid. Perhaps it may seem unbelievable to many, but even so I will not be ashamed to bring it out into the open, for though what I say proves an evil conscience and many sins, still, since God who is about to judge us knows everything accurately, what benefit will we gain from human ignorance? What then is this thing that remains unspoken? From the day you raised the possibility of my becoming bishop, my entire being has often been in danger of complete collapse, such was the fear, such the despondency that seized my soul. For when I considered the glory of the Bride of Christ—the holiness, the spiritual beauty and wisdom and loveliness—and then counted up my own faults, I could not stop mourning both for her and for myself, and amid constant distress and confusion I kept saying: Who made such a suggestion as this? Why has the Church of God made so great a mistake? Why has she so provoked her Master as to be handed over to me, the most unworthy of all men, and to suffer such great disgrace? Thinking about these things often by myself, and being unable to bear the thought of so monstrous a thing, I was like people struck by lightning—speechless and unable either to see or hear. And when this condition of great helplessness left me (for there were times when it passed), tears and despondency took its place, and after the flood of tears, fear would enter again in their place, disturbing, confusing, and agitating my mind. I spent the time that has passed in such a storm, but you were ignorant of it and thought I was spending my time in perfect tranquility. But now I will try to unveil to you the storm of my soul, for perhaps you will from now on pardon me and abandon your accusations. How then shall I unveil this to you? For if you would see this clearly, it would only be possible by laying bare my own heart. But since this is impossible, I will try to show you as well as I can, through a certain faint illustration, the gloom of my despondency, and from this image please infer my condition.

But we cannot yet persuade you. Accordingly the time is now come that I should utter to you the only thing which I have left unspoken. Perhaps it may seem to many to be incredible, but even so I shall not be ashamed to bring it before the world, for though what is said is proof of an evil conscience and of many sins, yet, since God, who is about to judge us, knows all accurately, what gain will result to us from the ignorance of men? What then is this, which is yet unspoken? From that day on which you imparted to me the suspicion of the bishopric, my whole system has often been in danger of being completely unhinged, such was the fear, such the despondency which seized my soul; for on considering the glory of the Bride of Christ, the holiness, the spiritual beauty and wisdom, and comeliness, and then reckoning up my own faults, I used not to cease bewailing both her and myself, and amidst continual distress and perplexity, I kept saying — who then made such a suggestion as this? Why has the Church of God made so great a mistake? Why has she so provoked her Master, as to be delivered over to me, the unworthiest of all men, and to undergo such great disgrace? Considering these things often by myself, and being unable to bear the thought of so monstrous a thing, I used to be like thunderstruck people, speechless, and unable either to see or hear. And when this condition of great helplessness left me, for there were times when it passed off, tears and despondency succeeded to it, and after the flood of tears, then fear again, entered in their stead, disturbing, confusing and agitating my mind. In such a tempest I used to pass the time that is gone; but you were ignorant of it, and thought that I was spending my time in a perfect tranquillity, but I will now try and unveil to you the storm of my soul, for it may be you will henceforth pardon me, abandoning your accusations. How then shall I unveil this to you? For if you would see this clearly, it is not otherwise possible than by laying bare my own heart; but as this is impossible, I will try and show you as well as I can, by a certain faint illustration, the gloom of my despondency, and from this image please to infer my condition.

Let us imagine that the daughter of the King of all the earth under the sun is engaged to a certain man, and that this young woman has matchless beauty that surpasses human nature, and in this respect she far exceeds the entire race of women. Imagine also that she has virtues of soul so great as to far surpass the whole generation of people who have lived or ever will live, and that the grace of her character transcends all standards of art, and that the loveliness of her appearance is overshadowed by the beauty of her face. Imagine that her betrothed is not only in love with the young woman for these reasons, but also has affection for her apart from these things, and by his passion he puts to shame the most passionate lovers who ever existed. Then let us suppose that while he is burning with love, he hears from somewhere that some lowly, contemptible man—of low birth and crippled in body, in fact a thoroughly wicked person—was about to marry this wonderful, beloved young woman. Have we then shown you some small portion of our grief? And is it enough to stop my illustration at this point? As far as my despair is concerned, I think it is enough, for this was the only purpose for which I introduced the comparison. But in order to show you the extent of my fear and my terror, let me continue to another description.

Let us suppose that the daughter of the King of all the earth under the sun is the betrothed of a certain man, and that this damsel has matchless beauty, transcending that of human nature, and that in this respect she outstrips by a long distance the whole race of women; also that she has virtues of the soul, so great as to distance by a long way the whole generation of men that have been, or that shall be; and that the grace of her manners transcends all standards of art, and that the loveliness of her person is eclipsed by the beauty of her countenance; and that her betrothed, not only for the sake of these things, is enamored of the maiden, but apart from these things has an affection for her, and by his ardor throws into the shade the most passionate of lovers that ever were. Then let us suppose, while he is burning with love, he hears from some quarter that some mean, abject man, low born, and crippled in body, in fact a thoroughly bad fellow, was about to wed this wondrous, well-beloved maiden. Have we then presented to you some small portion of our grief? And is it enough to stay my illustration at this point? So far as my despondency is concerned, I think it is enough; for this was the only purpose for which I introduced the comparison, but that I may show you the measure of my fear, and my terror, let me proceed to another description.

Let there be an army made up of foot soldiers, cavalry, and naval forces, and let many warships cover the sea while formations of infantry and cavalry cover most of the plains and the mountain ridges, and let the metal of their armor reflect the sunlight, and the gleam of the helmets and shields be reflected by the rays that shine from them. Let the clash of spears and the neighing of horses rise up to the very heavens, and let neither sea nor land be visible, but only bronze and iron in every direction. Let the enemy be arranged in battle formation opposite them, fierce and savage men, and let the time for battle be close at hand. Then let someone suddenly grab some young boy, one of those raised in the countryside who knows nothing but how to use a shepherd's pipe and staff. Let him be dressed in bronze armor, and let him be led around the whole camp and shown the squadrons and their officers, the archers, slingers, captains, generals, the infantry and cavalry, the spearmen, the warships and their commanders, the dense mass of soldiers in the ships, and the quantity of siege engines lying ready on board. Let him also be shown the entire arrangement of the enemy, their frightening appearance, and the varied supplies and unusual amount of their weapons. Show him also the ravines and cliffs of the mountains, deep and dangerous. Let him further be shown on the enemies' side horses flying by some magic and infantry carried through the air, and sorcery of every kind and form. And let him consider the disasters of war: the cloud of spears, the hailstorm of arrows, that great mist and darkness, that most gloomy night which the mass of weapons creates, blocking out the sun's rays with their cloud, the dust no less than the darkness hindering sight. The streams of blood, the groans of the falling, the shouts of the survivors, the piles of dead bodies, wheels soaked in blood, horses with their riders thrown headlong because of the number of corpses, the ground a scene of complete chaos, blood and bows and arrows, hooves of horses and heads of men lying together, a human arm and a chariot wheel and a helmet, a chest pierced through, brains sticking to swords, the point of a spear broken off with an eye impaled upon it. Then let him consider the sufferings of the naval force: the warships burning in the middle of the waves and sinking with their armed crews, the roar of the sea, the confusion of the sailors, the shout of the soldiers, the foam of the waves mixed with blood and splashing over into all the ships, the corpses on the decks, some sinking, some floating, some thrown upon the beach, overwhelmed by the waves and blocking the passage of the ships. And when he has been thoroughly taught about the whole tragedy of warfare, let the horrors of captivity and slavery be added to it, worse than any kind of death. And having told him all this, command him to mount his horse immediately and take command of that entire army.

Let there be an armament composed of infantry, cavalry, and marines, and let a number of triremes cover the sea, and phalanxes of foot and horse cover most of the plains, and the ridges of the mountains, and let the metal of their armor reflect the sunshine, and the glitter of the helmets and shields be reflected by the beams which are emitted from them; let the clashing of spears and the neighing of horses be borne up to the very heavens, and let neither sea nor land appear, but only brass and iron in every direction. Let the enemy be drawn up in battle array opposite to these, fierce and savage men, and let the time of the engagement be now at hand. Then let some one suddenly seize some young lad, one of those brought up in the country, knowing nothing but the use of the shepherd's pipe and crook; let him be clad in brazen armor, and let him be led round the whole camp and be shown the squadrons and their officers, the archers, slingers, captains, generals, the foot and horse, the spearmen, the triremes and their commanders, the dense mass of soldiers in the ships, and the multitude of engines of war lying ready on board. Let him be shown, moreover, the whole array of the enemy, their repulsive aspect, and the varied stores and unusual quantity of their arms; the ravines also and precipices of the mountains, deep and difficult. Let him be shown further on the enemies' side, horses flying by some enchantment and infantry borne through the air, and sorcery of every power and form; and let him consider the calamities of war, the cloud of spears, the hailstorm of arrows, that great mist and obscurity that gloomiest night which the multitude of weapons occasions, eclipsing the sunbeams with their cloud, the dust no less than the darkness baffling the eyesight. The torrents of blood, the groanings of the falling, the shouts of the surviving, the heaps of slain, wheels bathed in blood, horses with their riders thrown headlong down, owing to the number of corpses, the ground a scene of general confusion, blood, and bows, and arrows, hoofs of horses and heads of men lying together, a human arm and a chariot wheel and a helmet, a breast pierced through, brains sticking to swords, the point of a dart broken off with an eye transfixed upon it. Then let him reckon up the sufferings of the naval force, the triremes burning in the midst of the waves, and sinking with their armed crews, the roaring of the sea, the tumult of the sailors, the shout of the soldiers, the foam of the waves mixed with blood, and dashing over into all the ships; the corpses on the decks, some sinking, some floating, some cast upon the beach, overwhelmed by the waves, and obstructing the passage of the ships. And when he has been carefully instructed in all the tragedy of warfare, let the horrors of captivity and of slavery be added to it, worse than any kind of death; and having told him all this, bid him mount his horse straightway, and take command of all that armament.

Do you really think this young man would be capable of anything more than just describing it, and wouldn't he lose heart at the very first sight of it?

Do you really think that this lad would be equal to more than the mere description, and would not, at the very first glance, lose heart?

Don't think I've exaggerated in my description, or imagine that because we are confined in this body, as in some prison, and unable to see anything of the invisible world, I've overstated things. If you could see with your own eyes the devil's terrifying battle formation and his frenzied attack, you would witness a far greater and more dreadful conflict than this. There's no brass or iron there, no horses, chariots, or wheels, no fire or javelins—these are visible things. But there are other far more fearful weapons than these. You don't need breastplate, shield, sword, or spear against these enemies, yet the mere sight of this cursed army is enough to paralyze the soul, unless it happens to be very noble and enjoys to a high degree, as protection for its own courage, God's providential care. And if it were possible, by leaving this body behind or while still keeping it, to see clearly and fearlessly with the naked eye his entire battle formation and his warfare against us, you would see no streams of blood or dead bodies, but so many fallen souls and such disastrous wounds that all that warfare I just described to you would seem like mere child's play and amusement rather than war. So many are struck down every day, and the wounds in these two cases don't bring about the same kind of death—the difference between them is as great as the difference between the soul and the body. When the soul receives a wound and falls, it doesn't lie there like a lifeless body. Instead, it is tormented from then on, gnawed by an evil conscience, and after its departure from here, at the time of judgment, it is handed over to eternal punishment. And if anyone feels no grief over the wounds inflicted by the devil, his danger becomes greater because of his insensitivity. Whoever is not pained by the first wound will readily receive a second, and then a third. The unclean spirit will never stop attacking until the last breath, whenever he finds a soul lazy and indifferent to its first wounds. And if you were to examine his method of attack, you would find it much more severe and varied. No one has ever known as many forms of cunning and deceit as that unclean spirit possesses. This, in fact, is how he has acquired most of his power, nor can anyone have as relentless a hatred toward their worst enemies as the evil one has toward the human race. And if anyone were to examine the intensity with which he fights, here again it would be laughable to compare men with him. But if someone were to select the fiercest and most savage of beasts and compare their fury with his, they would find those beasts meek and gentle by comparison—such rage does he breathe out when he attacks our souls. The period of warfare in the former case is brief, and in this brief time there are breaks. The coming of night and the exhaustion from slaughter, mealtimes too, and many other things give the soldier a break, so he can take off his armor and rest a little, refresh himself with food and drink, and in many other ways recover his former strength. But in the case of the evil one, it's never possible to lay aside one's armor, never possible even to sleep, for one who wants to remain unharmed at all times. One of two things must happen: either to fall and perish unarmed, or to stand equipped and always watchful. For he always stands ready with his own battle formation, watching for our carelessness and working more eagerly for our destruction than we work for our salvation.

13. Do not think that I have exaggerated the matter by my account, nor suppose that because we are shut up in this body, as in some prison house, and are unable to see anything of the invisible world, that what has been said is overstated. For you would see a far greater and more formidable conflict than this, could you ever behold, with these eyes of yours, the devil's most gloomy battle array, and his frantic onset. For there is no brass or iron there. No horses, or chariots or wheels, no fire and darts. These are visible things. But there are other much more fearful engines than these. One does not need against these enemies breastplate or shield, sword and spear, yet the sight only of this accursed array is enough to paralyze the soul, unless it happen to be very noble, and to enjoy in a high degree as a protection to its own courage the providential care of God. And if it were possible by putting off this body, or still keeping it, to see clearly and fearlessly with the naked eye the whole of his battle array, and his warfare against us, you would see no torrents of blood, nor dead bodies, but so many fallen souls, and such disastrous wounds that the whole of that description of warfare which I just now detailed to you you would think to be mere child's sport and pastime rather than war: so many are there smitten every day, and the wounds in the two cases do not bring about the same death, but as great as is the difference between the soul from the body, so great is the difference between that death and this. For when the soul receives a wound, and falls, it does not lie as a lifeless body, but it is thenceforth tormented, being gnawed by an evil conscience; and after its removal hence, at the time of judgment, it is delivered over to eternal punishment; and if any one be without grief in regard to the wounds given by the devil, his danger becomes the greater for his insensibility. For whoever is not pained by the first wound, will readily receive a second, and after that a third. For the unclean spirit will not cease assaulting to the last breath, whenever he finds a soul supine and indifferent to his first wounds; and if you would inquire into the method of attack, you would find this much more severe and varied. For no one ever knew so many forms of craft and deceit as that unclean spirit. By this indeed, he has acquired the greater part of his power, nor can any one have so implacable a hatred against his worst enemies as the evil one against the human race. And if any one inquire into the vehemence with which he fights, here again it would be ludicrous to bring men into comparison with him. But if any one choose out the fiercest and most savage of beasts, and is minded to set their fury against his, he will find that they were meek and quiet in comparison, such rage does he breathe forth when he attacks our souls; and the period of the war fare indeed in the former case is brief, and in this brief space there are respites; for the approach of the night and the fatigue of slaughter, meal-times also, and many other things, afford a respite to the soldier, so that he can doff his armor and breathe a little, and refresh himself with food and drink, and in many other ways recover his former strength. But in the case of the evil one it is not possible ever to lay aside one's armor, it is not possible even to take sleep, for one who would remain always unscathed. For one of two things must be: either to fall and perish unarmed, or to stand equipped and ever watchful. For he ever stands with his own battle array, watching for our indolence, and laboring more zealously for our destruction, than we for our salvation.

The fact that the devil is invisible to us and attacks suddenly—which causes endless problems for those who don't stay alert—proves that this kind of warfare is harder than physical combat. Would you really want us, then, to command Christ's soldiers in such a situation? No, that would actually be commanding them to serve the devil, because whenever someone who should be leading and organizing others is actually the most inexperienced and weak of all people, by abandoning those entrusted to his care through his inexperience, he ends up commanding them for the devil's benefit rather than Christ's.

And that he is not seen by us, and suddenly assails us, which things are a source of countless evils to those who are not always on the watch, proves this kind of war to be harder than the other. Could you wish us, then, in such a case to command the soldiers of Christ? Yea, this were to command them for the devil's service, for whenever he who ought to marshal and order others is the most inexperienced and feeble of all men, by betraying through this inexperience those who have been entrusted to his charge, he commands them in the devil's interests rather than in Christ's.

But why do you sigh? Why do you weep? My peace now does not call for wailing, but for joy and gladness.

But why do you sigh? Why weep? For my ease does not now call for wailing, but for joy and gladness.

But not my case—this indeed calls for countless lamentations. For I can hardly yet understand to what degree of evil you have brought me. I came to you wanting to learn what excuse I should make on your behalf to those who find fault with you, but you send me back after replacing the case I had with another. For I am no longer concerned about what excuses I shall give them on your behalf, but what excuse I shall make to God for myself and my own faults. But I beg you and implore you, if my welfare matters at all to you, if there is any consolation in Christ, any comfort of love, any compassion and mercies, for you know that you above all have brought me into this danger—stretch forth your hand, both saying and doing what is able to restore me. Do not have the heart to leave me for even the briefest moment, but now more than before let me spend my life with you.

Basil: But not my case, yea this calls for countless lamentations. For I am hardly able yet to understand to what degree of evil you have brought me. For I came to you wanting to learn what excuse I should make on your behalf to those who find fault with you; but you send me back after putting another case in the place of that I had. For I am no longer concerned about the excuses I shall give them on your behalf, but what excuse I shall make to God for myself and my own faults. But I beseech you, and implore you, if my welfare is at all regarded by you, if there be any consolation in Christ, if any comfort of love, if any bowels, and mercies, Philippians 2:1 for you know that yourself above all hast brought me into this danger, stretch forth your hand, both saying and doing what is able to restore me, do not have the heart to leave me for the briefest moment, but now rather than before let me pass my life with you.

Chrysostom: But I smiled and said, "How will I be able to help you or benefit you when you're weighed down by such a great burden of office?" But since this pleases you, take courage, dear soul. Whenever you can find free time in the midst of your own responsibilities, I will come and comfort you, and I won't hold back anything that's within my power to do.

Chrysostom: But I smiled, and said, how shall I be able to help, how to profit you under so great a burden of office? But since this is pleasant to you, take courage, dear soul, for at any time at which it is possible for you to have leisure amid your own cares, I will come and will comfort you, and nothing shall be wanting of what is in my power.

At this point, he wept even more and stood up. I embraced him, kissed his head, and led him out, urging him to bear his situation courageously. I said to him, "I believe that through Christ, who has called you and placed you over his own sheep, you will gain such confidence from this ministry that you will even receive me, if I am in danger on the last day, into your eternal dwelling place."

On this, he weeping yet more, rose up. But I, having embraced him and kissed his head, led him forth, exhorting him to bear his lot bravely. For I believe, said I, that through Christ who has called you, and set you over his own sheep, you will obtain such assurance from this ministry as to receive me also, if I am in danger at the last day, into your everlasting tabernacle.


On the Priesthood — Book IV

On the Priesthood, Book IV: the dialogue with Basil on the dignity and dangers of priestly ministry.

Source: Translated by W.R.W. Stephens. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 9. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/19224.htm>.

Opening

Basil heard this, and after a brief pause he replied as follows:

Basil heard this, and after a little pause thus replied:

If you had been ambitious to obtain this office yourself, your fear would be reasonable. When someone is ambitious to take on this responsibility, he admits that he is qualified to carry it out. If he then fails after it has been entrusted to him, he cannot claim inexperience as his defense, because he has already deprived himself of this excuse by seizing the ministry hastily. Anyone who enters into it willingly and deliberately can no longer say, "I have sinned in this matter against my will—and against my will I have ruined such and such a soul." For the one who will judge him one day will say to him, "Since you were aware of such inexperience and lacked the ability to undertake this matter without bringing reproach on yourself, why were you so eager and presumptuous as to take on what was so far beyond your ability? Who forced you to do so? Did you resist or flee, and did anyone drag you on by force?" But you will hear nothing like this, for you have nothing of this kind to condemn yourself for. It is clear to everyone that you were not at all ambitious for this position, since what happened came about through the action of others. Therefore, the circumstances that leave those who are ambitious for this office no chance of pardon when they fail in it provide you with ample grounds for excuse.

If you were yourself ambitious of obtaining this office, your fear would have been reasonable; for in being ambitious of undertaking it, a man confesses himself to be qualified for its administration, and if he fail therein, after it has been entrusted to him, he cannot take refuge in the plea of inexperience, for he has deprived himself of this excuse beforehand, by having hurriedly seized upon the ministry, and whoever willingly and deliberately enters upon it, can no longer say, I have sinned in this matter against my will — and against my will I have ruined such and such a soul; for He who will one day judge him, will say to him, Since then thou were conscious of such inexperience, and had not ability for undertaking this matter without incurring reproach, why were thou so eager and presumptuous as to take in hand what was so far beyond your power? Who compelled you to do so? Did you shrink or fly, and did any one drag you on by force? But you will hear nothing like this, for you can have nothing of this kind to condemn yourself for; and it is evident to all that thou were in no degree ambitious of this dignity, for the accomplishment of the matter was due to the action of others. Hence, circumstances which leave those who are ambitious of this office no chance of pardon when they err therein, afford you ample ground for excuse.

Chrysostom: At this I shook my head and smiled a little, admiring how naïve the man was, and I said to him: I certainly wish things were as you describe them, my good friend, but not so that I could accept the office I recently fled from. Even if no punishment awaited me for taking on the care of Christ's flock without proper thought and experience, it would still be worse than any punishment to me if, after being entrusted with such a great responsibility, I appeared so worthless to the one who entrusted it to me. Why, then, did I wish you were not mistaken in your opinion? It was truly for the sake of those miserable and unfortunate people—for that is what I must call those who have not learned how to fulfill the duties of this office well, no matter how many times you say they were forced to take it on and that their mistakes are therefore sins of ignorance. I wish this for their sake, so that they might escape that unquenchable fire, the outer darkness, the worm that does not die, and the punishment of being cut in two and perishing together with the hypocrites.

Chrysostom: At this I shook my head and smiled a little, admiring the simple-mindedness of the man, and thus addressed him: I could wish indeed that matters were as you say, most excellent of men, but not in order that I might be able to accept that office from which I lately fled. For if, indeed, no chastisement were to await me for undertaking the care of the flock of Christ without consideration and experience, yet to me it would be worse than all punishment, after being entrusted with so great a charge, to have seemed so base towards Him who entrusted me with it. For what reason, then, did I wish that thou were not mistaken in this opinion of yours? truly for the sake of those wretched and unhappy beings (for so must I call them, who have not found out how to discharge the duties of this office well, though thou were to say ten thousand times over that they had been driven to undertake it, and that, therefore, their errors therein are sins of ignorance)– for the sake, I say, of such that they might succeed in escaping that unquenchable fire, and the outer darkness Matthew 25:30 and the worm that dies not Mark 9:44 and the punishment of being cut asunder, and perishing together with the hypocrites.

But what am I to do for you? Things are not as you say, no, not at all. And if you wish, I will prove my point using the example of a kingdom, which does not matter as much to God as the priesthood. Saul, the son of Kish, was not at all ambitious about becoming king. He was simply looking for his donkeys and came to ask the prophet about them. The prophet, however, began to speak to him about the kingdom, but even then he did not eagerly pursue it. Though he heard about it from a prophet, he pulled back and objected, saying, "Who am I, and what is my father's house?" What happened then? When he made bad use of the honor that God had given him, were those words of his able to save him from the anger of the One who had made him king? And was he able to say to Samuel, when Samuel rebuked him: Did I greedily run and rush after the kingdom and royal power? I wanted to lead the quiet and peaceful life of ordinary people, but you dragged me to this position of honor. Had I remained in my lowly condition I would have easily escaped all these stumbling blocks, for if I were one of the obscure crowd, I would never have been sent out on this military campaign, nor would God have entrusted to me the war against the Amalekites, and if He had not entrusted it to me, I would not have committed this sin. But all such arguments are weak as excuses, and not only weak, but dangerous, since they actually provoke God's anger. For someone who has been raised to great honor by God must not use the greatness of his honor as an excuse for his mistakes, but should make God's special favor toward him the reason for further improvement. On the other hand, whoever thinks he is free to sin because he has obtained some exceptional position, what is he doing but trying to show that God's lovingkindness is the cause of his personal sin? This is always the argument of those who live godless and careless lives. But we should never think this way, nor fall into the insane foolishness of such people. Rather, we should always be eager to make the most of whatever abilities we have, and to be reverent in both our speech and our thought.

But what am I to do for you? It is not as you say, no, by no means. And if you will, I will give you a proof of what I maintain, from the case of a kingdom, which is not of such account with God as the priesthood. Saul, that son of Kish, was not himself at all ambitious of becoming a king, but was going in quest of his asses, and came to ask the prophet about them. The prophet, however, proceeded to speak to him of the kingdom, but not even then did he run greedily after it, though he heard about it from a prophet, but drew back and deprecated it, saying, Who am I, and what is my father's house. 1 Samuel 9:21 What then? When he made a bad use of the honor which had been given him by God, were those words of his able to rescue him from the wrath of Him who had made him king? And was he able to say to Samuel, when rebuked by him: Did I greedily run and rush after the kingdom and sovereign power? I wished to lead the undisturbed and peaceful life of ordinary men, but thou dragged me to this post of honor. Had I remained in my low estate I should easily have escaped all these stumbling blocks, for were I one of the obscure multitude, I should never have been sent forth on this expedition, nor would God have committed to my hands the war against the Amalekites, and if I had not had it committed to me, I should not have sinned this sin. But all such arguments are weak as excuses, and not only weak, but perilous, inasmuch as they rather kindle the wrath of God. For he who has been promoted to great honor by God, must not advance the greatness of his honor as an excuse for his errors, but should make God's special favor towards him the motive for further improvement; whereas he who thinks himself at liberty to sin because he has obtained some uncommon dignity, what does he but study to show that the lovingkindness of God is the cause of his personal transgression, which is always the argument of those who lead godless and careless lives. But we ought to be on no account thus minded, nor to fall away into the insane folly of such people, but be ambitious at all times to make the most of such powers as we have, and to be reverent both in speech and thought.

To set aside the kingdom and turn to the priesthood, which is our main subject: Eli was not ambitious to obtain his high office either, yet what good did that do him when he sinned in it? And why do I even say "obtain it"? He could not have avoided it even if he had wanted to, because he was legally required to accept it. He was from the tribe of Levi and was obligated to take on the high office that came down to him from his ancestors. Nevertheless, he still paid a heavy penalty for the lawlessness of his sons. And the very first High Priest of the Jews, about whom God spoke so many words to Moses—when he was unable to withstand alone the frenzy of such a great crowd, wasn't he nearly destroyed, except that his brother's intercession turned away God's wrath? And since we've mentioned Moses, it would be good to demonstrate the truth of what we're saying from what happened to him. This same holy Moses was so far from grasping at the leadership of the Jews that he rejected the offer and declined it when God commanded him to take it, and so provoked the anger of the one who appointed him. And not only then, but afterward when he had entered into his rule, he would gladly have died to be free from it. "Kill me," he says, "if you are going to deal with me like this." But what then? When he sinned at the waters of strife, could these repeated refusals be used as an excuse for him? Could they persuade God to grant him pardon? And why was he denied the promised land? For no other reason, as we all know, than for this sin of his, for which that remarkable man was prevented from enjoying the same blessings that those he ruled obtained. After many labors and sufferings, after that unspeakable wandering, after so many battles fought and victories won, he died outside the land he had endured so much toil and trial to reach. Though he had weathered the storms of the wilderness, he failed to enjoy the blessings of the haven after all. From this you can see that not only those who grasp at this office are left without excuse for the sins they commit while carrying it out, but also those who come to it through others' ambition for them. For truly, if those who have been chosen for this high office by God himself, though they have refused it many times, have paid such heavy penalties, and if nothing has been able to deliver any of them from this danger—not Aaron, not Eli, not that holy man, the saint, the prophet, the wonder-worker, the one more meek than all the people on the face of the earth, who spoke with God as a man speaks to his friend—then we who fall so infinitely short of the excellence of that great man will hardly be able to claim as a sufficient excuse our awareness that we have never been ambitious for the position, especially when many ordinations nowadays do not proceed from God's grace but are due to human ambition. God chose Judas and counted him as one of the sacred group, and entrusted to him, as to the rest, the dignity of the apostolic office. Yes, he gave him something beyond the others: the stewardship of the money. But what of that? When he later abused both these trusts, betraying the one he was commissioned to preach and misusing the money he should have used well, did he escape punishment? No, for this very reason he even brought upon himself greater punishment, and very reasonably too. For we must not use the high honors God gives us in ways that offend him, but in ways that please him better. But someone who claims exemption from punishment when it is due, because he has been raised to higher honor than others, acts very much like one of those unbelieving Jews who, after hearing Christ say, "If I had not come and spoken to them, they would not have sin; if I had not done among them the works that no one else did, they would not have sin," would reproach the Savior and benefactor of mankind by replying, "Why then did you come and speak? Why did you work miracles? Was it so that you might punish us more?" But these are the words of madness and utter senselessness. For the Great Physician did not come to condemn you but to heal you—not to pass you by when you were sick, but to rid you entirely of disease. But you have voluntarily withdrawn yourself from his hands; therefore receive the more severe punishment. For just as you would have been freed from your former diseases if you had yielded to his treatment, so if when you saw him coming to your aid you fled from him, you will no longer be able to cleanse yourself of these ailments, and since you are unable, you will both suffer punishment for them and also because on your part you made God's care for your good worthless. Therefore we who act like this are not subjected to the same torment after receiving honor at God's hands as before, but to far more severe torment afterward than before. For someone who has not become good even by being well treated deserves all the more bitter punishment. Since, then, this excuse of yours has been shown to be weak, and not only fails to save those who take refuge in it but exposes them all the more, we must provide ourselves with some other means of safety.

For (to leave the kingdom and to come to the priesthood, which is the more immediate subject of our discourse) neither was Eli ambitious of obtaining his high office, yet what advantage was this to him when he sinned therein? But why do I say obtain it? Not even had he wished could he have avoided it, because he was under a legal necessity to accept it. For he was of the tribe of Levi, and was bound to undertake that high office which descended to him from his forefathers, notwithstanding which even he paid no small penalty for the lawlessness of his sons. And the very first High Priest of the Jews, concerning whom God spoke so many words to Moses, when he was unable to withstand alone the frenzy of so great a multitude, was he not very nearly being destroyed, but for the intercession of his brother, which averted the wrath of God? Exodus 32:10-11 And since we have mentioned Moses, it will be well to show the truth of what we are saying from what happened to him. For this same saintly Moses was so far from grasping at the leadership of the Jews as to deprecate the offer, Exodus 4:13 and to decline it when God commanded him to take it, and so to provoke the wrath of Him who appointed him; and not only then, but afterwards when he entered upon his rule, he would gladly have died to have been set free from it: Kill me, says he, if you are going to deal thus with me. But what then? When he sinned at the waters of strife, Numbers 20:12 could these repeated refusals be pleaded in excuse for him? Could they prevail with God to grant him pardon? And wherefore was he deprived of the promised land? For no other reason, as we all know, than for this sin of his, for which that wondrous man was debarred from enjoying the same blessings which those over whom he ruled obtained; but after many labors and sufferings, after that unspeakable wandering, after so many battles fought and victories won, he died outside the land to reach which he had undergone so much toil and trial; and though he had weathered the storms of the deep, he failed to enjoy the blessings of the haven after all. From hence then you see that not only they who grasp at this office are left without excuse for the sins they commit in the discharge thereof, but they too who come to it through the ambitious desire of others; for truly if those persons who have been chosen for this high office by God himself, though they have never so often refused it, have paid such heavy penalties, and if nothing has availed to deliver any of them from this danger, neither Aaron nor Eli, nor that holy man the Saint, the prophet, the wonder worker, the meek above all the men which were upon the face of the earth, Numbers 12:3 who spoke with God, as a man speaks unto his friend, Exodus 33:11 hardly shall we who fall so infinitely short of the excellence of that great man, be able to plead as a sufficient excuse the consciousness that we have never been ambitious of the dignity, more especially when many of the ordinations now-a-days do not proceed from the grace of God, but are due to human ambition. God chose Judas, and counted him one of the sacred band, and committed to him, as to the rest, the dignity of the apostolic office; yea he gave him somewhat beyond the others, the stewardship of the money. John 12:6 But what of that? When he afterwards abused both these trusts, betraying Him whom he was commissioned to preach, and misapplying the money which he should have laid out well; did he escape punishment? nay for this very reason he even brought upon himself greater punishment, and very reasonably too. For we must not use the high honors given to us by God so as to offend Him, but so as to please Him better. But he who claims exemption from punishment where it is due, because he has been exalted to higher honor than others, acts very much like one of those unbelieving Jews, who after hearing Christ say, If I had not come and spoken unto them, they had not had sin, If I had not done among them the works which none other did, they had not had sin, John 15:22-24 should reproach the Saviour and benefactor of mankind by replying, Why, then, did you come and speak? Why did you work miracles? Was it that you might punish us the more? But these are the words of madness and of utter senselessness. For the Great Physician came not to give you over, but to heal you — not to pass you by when thou were sick, but to rid you entirely of disease. But you have of your own accord withdrawn yourself from his hands; receive therefore the sorer punishment. For as you would have been freed from your former maladies if you had yielded to his treatment, so if, when you saw him coming to your aid you fled from him, you will no longer be able to cleanse yourself of these infirmities, and as you are unable, you will both suffer punishment for them, and also because for your part you made God's solicitude for your good of none effect. Therefore we who act like this are not subjected to the same torment after as before we received honor at God's hands, but far severer torment after than before. For he who has not become good even by being well treated, deserves all the bitterer punishment. Since, then, this excuse of yours has been shown to be weak, and not only fails to save those who take refuge in it, but exposes them so much the more, we must provide ourselves with some other means of safety.

Basil: Tell me, what kind of nature is that? As for me, I'm barely in control of myself right now—you've reduced me to such a state of fear and trembling by what you've said.

Basil: Tell me of what nature is that? Since, as for me, I am at present scarce master of myself, you have reduced me to such a state of fear and trembling by what you have said.

Chrysostom: Please, I beg and implore you, do not be so downcast. For while we who are weak find safety in not taking on this office at all, you who are strong also have safety, and this consists in placing your hopes of salvation, next to the grace of God, on avoiding every act unworthy of this gift and of the God who gave it. For those who obtain this dignity through their own ambition and then abuse the office—whether through laziness, wickedness, or even inexperience—would certainly deserve the greatest punishment. This does not mean there is pardon waiting for those who have not been ambitious in this way. No, even they are left without excuse. For in my judgment, even if ten thousand people were to plead and urge, a man should pay them no attention. Instead, he should first search his own heart and examine the whole matter carefully before giving in to their demands. Now, no one would dare to undertake building a house if he were not an architect, nor would anyone attempt to cure sick bodies who is not a skilled physician. Even if many people urge him, he will decline and will not be ashamed to admit his ignorance. So should not someone who is going to have the care of so many souls entrusted to him examine himself beforehand? Will he accept this ministry even though he is completely inexperienced, just because one person commands him, another pressures him, or he fears offending a third? And if so, how will he escape throwing himself together with them into obvious misery? Had he remained as he was, it would have been possible for him to be saved, but now he brings others down to destruction with him. For where can he hope for salvation? Where can he obtain pardon? Who will successfully intercede for us then? Those who are now perhaps urging us and forcibly dragging us on? But who will save them at such a moment? For even they will need intercession in their turn, so that they may escape the fire. Now, I do not say these things to frighten you, but to represent the matter as it truly is. Hear what the holy Apostle Paul says to Timothy his disciple, his own and beloved son: "Lay hands suddenly on no man, neither be partaker of other men's sins." Do you not see from what great blame, and indeed vengeance, we have delivered those who were ready to put us forward for this office, insofar as it lies within us?

Chrysostom: Do not, I beseech and implore you, do not be so downcast. For while there is safety for us who are weak, namely, in not undertaking this office at all, there is safety for you too who are strong, and this consists in making your hopes of salvation depend, next to the grace of God, on avoiding every act unworthy of this gift, and of God who gave it. For they certainly would be deserving of the greatest punishment who, after obtaining this dignity through their own ambition, should then either on account of sloth, or wickedness, or even inexperience, abuse the office. Not that we are to gather from this that there is pardon in store for those who have not been thus ambitious. Yea, even they too are deprived of all excuse. For in my judgment, if ten thousand were to entreat and urge, a man should pay them no attention, but should first of all search his own heart, and examine the whole matter carefully before yielding to their importunities. Now no one would venture to undertake the building of a house were he not an architect, nor will any one attempt the cure of sick bodies who is not a skilled physician; but even though many urge him, will beg off, and will not be ashamed to own his ignorance; and shall he who is going to have the care of so many souls entrusted to him, not examine himself beforehand? will he accept this ministry even though he be the most inexperienced of men, because this one commands him, or that man constrains him, or for fear of offending a third? And if so, how will he escape casting himself together with them into manifest misery. Had he continued as he was, it were possible for him to be saved, but now he involves others in his own destruction. For whence can he hope for salvation? Whence to obtain pardon? Who will then successfully intercede for us? They who are now perhaps urging us and forcibly dragging us on? But who will save these same at such a moment? For even they too will stand in need in their turn of intercession, that they may escape the fire. Now, that I say not these things to frighten you, but as representing the matter as in truth it is, hear what the holy Apostle Paul says to Timothy his disciple, his own and beloved son, Lay hands suddenly on no man, neither be partaker of other men's sins. 1 Timothy 5:22 Do you not see from what great blame, yea and vengeance, we, so far as in us lies, have delivered those who were ready to put us forward for this office.

Just as it is not enough for those who are chosen to say in their defense, "I did not summon myself to this office, nor could I avoid what I did not foresee," neither will it be sufficient for those who ordain them to say that they did not know the person being ordained. The charge against them becomes greater because of their ignorance of the one they brought forward, and what seems to excuse them only accuses them more. How absurd is it? When people want to buy a slave, they show him to the physician, require guarantees for the sale, and seek information about him from their neighbors, and after all this they still do not venture to purchase him without asking for some time for a trial. Yet those who are going to admit someone to so great an office as this give their testimonial and their approval loosely and carelessly, without further investigation, just because someone wishes it, or to gain someone's favor, or to avoid someone's displeasure. Who then will successfully intercede for us on that day, when those who ought to defend us themselves stand in need of defenders? The one who is going to ordain, therefore, ought to make diligent inquiry, and even more so the one who is to be ordained. For though those who ordain him share his punishment for any sins he may commit in his office, he will not escape vengeance but will even pay a greater penalty than they—except only if those who chose him acted from some worldly motive contrary to what seemed justifiable to themselves. For if they are detected doing so, and knowing a man to be unworthy have brought him forward on some pretext or other, the amount of their punishment will be equivalent to his, or perhaps the punishment will be even greater for those who appointed the unfit man. For the one who gives authority to someone who is minded to destroy the Church would certainly be to blame for the outrages that person commits. But if he is guilty of no such thing and says that he has been misled by the opinions of others, even then he will not altogether remain unpunished, but his punishment will be a little lighter than that of the one who has been ordained. What then? It is possible that those who elect may come to the election deceived by a false report. But the one who is elected could not say, "I am ignorant of myself," as others were of him. Since he will receive a more severe punishment than those who put him forward, he should make his scrutiny of himself more careful than that which they make of him. And if they in ignorance drag him on, he ought to come forward and instruct them carefully about any matters by which he may stop them from being misled, and so, having shown himself unworthy of trial, may escape the burden of so high an office.

2. For as it is not enough for those who are chosen to say in excuse for themselves, I did not summon myself to this office, nor could I avoid what I did not see beforehand; so neither will it be a sufficient plea for those who ordain them to say that they did not know him who was ordained. The charge against them becomes greater on account of their ignorance of him whom they brought forward, and what seems to excuse them only serves to accuse them the more. For how absurd a thing, is it not? That they who want to buy a slave, show him to the physician, and require sureties for the sale, and information about him from their neighbours, and after all this do not yet venture on his purchase without asking for some time for a trial of him; while they who are going to admit any one to so great an office as this, give their testimonial and their sanction loosely and carelessly, without further investigation, just because some one wishes it, or to court the favor, or to avoid the displeasure of some one else. Who shall then successfully intercede for us in that day, when they who ought to defend us stand themselves in need of defenders? He who is going to ordain, therefore, ought to make diligent inquiry, and much more he who is to be ordained. For though they who ordain him share his punishment, for any sins which he may commit in his office, yet so far from escaping vengeance he will even pay a greater penalty than they — save only if they who chose him acted from some worldly motive contrary to what seemed justifiable to themselves. For if they should be detected so doing, and knowing a man to be unworthy have brought him forward on some pretext or other, the amount of their punishment shall be equivalent to his, nay perhaps the punishment shall be even greater for them who appointed the unfit man. For he who gives authority to any one who is minded to destroy the Church, would be certainly to blame for the outrages which that person commits. But if he is guilty of no such thing, and says that he has been misled by the opinions of others, even then he shall not altogether remain unpunished, but his punishment shall be a little lighter than his who has been ordained. What then? It is possible that they who elect may come to the election deceived by a false report. But he who is elected could not say, I am ignorant of myself, as others were of him. As one who will receive therefore a sorer punishment than they who put him forward, so should he make his scrutiny of himself more careful than that which they make of him; and if they in ignorance drag him on, he ought to come forward and instruct them carefully about any matters whereby he may stop their being misled; and so having shown himself unworthy of trial may escape the burden of so high an office.

Why is it that in the arts of war, trade, farming, and other areas of life, when some plan is proposed, the farmer will not take on the task of navigating a ship, nor the soldier that of tilling the ground, nor the pilot that of leading an army, even under threat of ten thousand deaths? Isn't it plainly this: that each person foresees the danger that would come from his incompetence? Well then, when the loss involves trivial matters, shall we use so much forethought and refuse to yield to the pressure of compulsion, but when the punishment is eternal—as it is for those who do not know how to handle the Priesthood—shall we rashly and thoughtlessly run into such great danger, and then offer as our excuse the pressing entreaties of others? But He who will one day judge us will not accept any such plea. For we ought to show far more caution in spiritual matters than in earthly ones. But now we are not found showing as much caution. For tell me: if we invited a man to do a piece of work, supposing him to be a craftsman when he is not, and he responded to the call, and then having set his hand to the materials prepared for the building, he ruined the wood and ruined the stone, and built the house in such a way that it immediately fell to pieces, would it be a sufficient excuse for him to claim that he had been urged by others and did not come of his own accord? Not at all, and very reasonably and justly so. For he ought to have refused even when called by others. So if the man who only ruins wood and stone will have no escape from paying the penalty, is the one who destroys souls and builds the temple of God carelessly to think that the compulsion of others is his warrant for escaping punishment? Isn't this utterly absurd? For I am setting aside for now the fact that no one is able to compel the man who is unwilling. But suppose he was subjected to excessive pressure and various artful devices, and then fell into a snare—will this therefore rescue him from punishment? I beg you, let us not deceive ourselves and pretend that we do not know what is obvious to a mere child. For surely this pretense of ignorance will not be able to help us on the day of reckoning. You were not ambitious, you say, to receive this high office, being conscious of your own weakness. Fine. Then you ought, with the same mindset, to have declined the solicitation of others. Or were you weak and incapable when no one called you, but when people were found ready to offer you this dignity, did you suddenly become competent? What ridiculous nonsense! Worthy of the severest punishment. For this reason the Lord also counsels the man who wishes to build a tower not to lay the foundation before he has taken his own ability to build into account, lest he should give passersby countless opportunities to mock him. But in his case the penalty consists only in becoming a laughingstock, while in the case before us the punishment is that of unquenchable fire, and of an undying worm, gnashing of teeth, outer darkness, and being cut in two, and having a portion with the hypocrites.

For what is the reason why, in the arts of war, and merchandize, and husbandry, and other departments of this life, when some plan is proposed, the husbandman will not undertake to navigate the ship, nor the soldier to till the ground, nor the pilot to lead an army, under pain of ten thousand deaths? Is it not plainly this? That each foresees the danger which would attend his incompetence? Well, where the loss is concerned with trifles shall we use so much forethought, and refuse to yield to the pressure of compulsion, but where the punishment is eternal, as it is for those who know not how to handle the Priesthood, shall we want only and inconsiderately run into so great danger, and then advance, as our excuse, the pressing entreaties of others? But He who one day will judge us will entertain no such plea as this. For we ought to show far more caution in spiritual matters than in carnal. But now we are not found exhibiting as much caution. For tell me: if supposing a man to be an artificer, when he is not so, we invited him to do a piece of work, and he were to respond to the call, and then having set his hand to the material prepared for the building, were to spoil the wood and spoil the stone, and so to build the house that it straightway fell to pieces, would it be sufficient excuse for him to allege that he had been urged by others and did not come of his own accord? In no wise; and very reasonably and justly so. For he ought to have refused even at the call of others. So for the man who only spoils wood and stone, there will be no escape from paying the penalty, and is he who destroys souls, and builds the temple of God carelessly, to think that the compulsion of others is his warrant for escaping punishment? Is not this very absurd? For I omit the fact as yet that no one is able to compel the man who is unwilling. But be it that he was subjected to excessive pressure and various artful devices, and then fell into a snare; will this therefore rescue him from punishment? I beseech you, let us not deceive ourselves, and pretend that we know not what is obvious to a mere child. For surely this pretence of ignorance will not be able to profit in the day of reckoning. You were not ambitious, you say, of receiving this high office, conscious of your own weakness. Well and good. Then you ought, with the same mind, to have declined the solicitation of others; or, when no one called you, were you weak and incapable, but when those were found ready to offer you this dignity, did you suddenly become competent? What ludicrous nonsense! Worthy of the extremest punishment. For this reason also the Lord counsels the man who wishes to build a tower, not to lay the foundation before he has taken his own ability to build into account, lest he should give the passers by innumerable opportunities of mocking at him. But in his case the penalty only consists in becoming a laughing-stock; while in that before us the punishment is that of fire unquenchable, and of an undying worm, Isaiah 66:24 gnashing of teeth, outer darkness, and being cut asunder, and having a portion with the hypocrites.

But my accusers are unwilling to consider any of these things. If they did, they would stop blaming someone who simply doesn't want to perish for no reason. What we're considering now is not the management of grain and barley, oxen or sheep, or anything like that, but the very Body of Jesus. For the Church of Christ, according to St. Paul, is Christ's Body, and whoever is entrusted with caring for it must train it up to a state of health and unspeakable beauty, and look everywhere to make sure no spot or wrinkle or any other such blemish mars its strength and beauty. For what else is this but making it appear worthy, as far as human power can manage, of the incorruptible and eternally blessed Head which is set over it? If those who want to achieve an athletic physical condition need the help of physicians and trainers, and precise diet, and constant exercise, and a thousand other rules—since leaving out the smallest detail upsets and ruins everything—then how will those who are responsible for caring for the body that struggles not against flesh and blood, but against unseen powers, be able to keep it sound and healthy, unless they far surpass ordinary human virtue and are skilled in all healing proper for the soul?

But my accusers are unwilling to consider any of these things. For otherwise they would cease to blame a person who is unwilling to perish without cause. It is not the management of grain and barley, oxen or sheep, that is now under our consideration, nor any such like matters, but the very Body of Jesus. For the Church of Christ, according to St. Paul, is Christ's Body, and he who is entrusted with its care ought to train it up to a state of healthiness, and beauty unspeakable, and to look everywhere, lest any spot or wrinkle, Ephesians 5:27 or other like blemish should mar its vigor and comeliness. For what is this but to make it appear worthy, so far as human power can, of the incorruptible and ever-blessed Head which is set over it? If they who are ambitious of reaching an athletic condition of body need the help of physicians and trainers, and exact diet, and constant exercise, and a thousand other rules (for the omission of the merest trifle upsets and spoils the whole), how shall they to whose lot falls the care of the body, which has its conflict not against flesh and blood, but against powers unseen, be able to keep it sound and healthy, unless they far surpass ordinary human virtue, and are versed in all healing proper for the soul?

Surely you realize that the Church is subject to more diseases and attacks than our physical bodies, is more quickly corrupted, and slower to recover? For those who heal physical bodies, various medicines have been discovered, along with an assortment of different instruments and suitable diets for the sick. Often the condition of the atmosphere is by itself enough for a sick person's recovery, and there are cases where timely sleep has saved the physician any further effort. But in the case before us, it is impossible to rely on any of these things. No, there is only one method and way of healing appointed after we have gone wrong, and that is the powerful application of the Word. This is the one instrument, the only diet, the finest atmosphere. This takes the place of medicine, cautery and cutting, and if it is necessary to sear and amputate, this is the means we must use. If this is of no use, everything else is wasted. With this we both rouse the soul when it sleeps and calm it when it is inflamed. With this we cut off excesses and fill up defects, and perform all kinds of other operations that are necessary for the soul's health. Now as regards ordering our daily life for the best, it is true that another person's life may provoke us to imitation. But in the matter of false doctrine, when any soul is diseased by it, then there is great need of the Word, not only for the safety of our own people, but also for the enemy outside. If indeed one had the sword of the Spirit and the shield of faith, so as to be able to work miracles and by means of these wonders to stop the mouths of shameless opponents, one would have little need of the Word's assistance. Still, even in the days of miracles the Word was by no means useless, but absolutely necessary. For Saint Paul used it himself, although he was everywhere such a great object of wonder for his miracles. And another of those who belonged to the glorious company of the Apostles urges us to apply ourselves to acquiring this power when he says: Be ready always to give an answer to every man that asks you a reason concerning the hope that is in you. And they all, with one accord, committed the care of the poor widows to Stephen for no other reason than that they themselves might have leisure for the ministry of the Word. We ought equally to apply ourselves to this, unless we are endowed with a power of working miracles. But if there is not the slightest sign of such a power left to us, while on every side many enemies are constantly attacking us, then it necessarily follows that we should arm ourselves with this weapon, both so that we may not be wounded ourselves with the enemy's darts, and so that we may wound him.

3. Pray, are you not aware that that body is subject to more diseases and assaults than this flesh of ours, is more quickly corrupted, and more slow to recover? And by those who have the healing of these bodies, various medicines have been discovered, and an apparatus of different instruments, and diet suitable for the sick; and often the condition of the atmosphere is of itself enough for the recovery of a sick man; and there are instances of seasonable sleep having saved the physician all further labor. But in the case before us, it is impossible to take any of these things into consideration; nay there is but one method and way of healing appointed, after we have gone wrong, and that is, the powerful application of the Word. This is the one instrument, the only diet, the finest atmosphere. This takes the place of physic, cautery and cutting, and if it be needful to sear and amputate, this is the means which we must use, and if this be of no avail, all else is wasted; with this we both rouse the soul when it sleeps, and reduce it when it is inflamed; with this we cut off excesses, and fill up defects, and perform all manner of other operations which are requisite for the soul's health. Now as regards the ordering of our daily life for the best, it is true that the life of another may provoke us to emulation. But in the matter of spurious doctrine, when any soul is diseased thereby, then there is great need of the Word, not only in view of the safety of our own people, but in view of the enemy without. If, indeed, one had the sword of the spirit, and the shield of faith, Ephesians 6:16-17 so as to be able to work miracles, and by means of these marvels to stop the mouths of impudent gainsayers, one would have little need of the assistance of the Word; still in the days of miracles the Word was by no means useless, but essentially necessary. For St. Paul made use of it himself, although he was everywhere so great an object of wonder for his miracles; and another of those who belonged to the glorious company of the Apostles exhorts us to apply ourselves to acquiring this power, when he says: Be ready always to give an answer to every man that asks you a reason concerning the hope that is in you, and they all, with one accord, committed the care of the poor widows to Stephen, for no other reason than that they themselves might have leisure for the ministry of the Word. Acts 6:4 To this we ought equally to apply ourselves, unless indeed we are endued with a power of working miracles. But if there is not the least sign of such a power being left us, while on every side many enemies are constantly attacking us, why then it necessarily follows that we should arm ourselves with this weapon, both in order that we may not be wounded ourselves with the darts of the enemy, and in order that we may wound him.

We should make it our goal that the Word of Christ dwell in us richly. This is because we do not need to be prepared for just one kind of battle. This warfare has many forms and involves a great variety of enemies. Not all of them use the same weapons, nor do they practice the same method of attack. Anyone who must fight against all of them needs to know the tactics of all and must be at once both archer and slinger, captain and general, in the ranks and in command, on foot and on horseback, in sea battles and in sieges. In ordinary warfare, each person repels the enemy by carrying out the particular duty he has taken on. But here things are different. If anyone wishes to win this warfare, he must understand all forms of the art, since the devil knows well how to send in his own attackers through any one spot that happens to be unguarded, and to carry off the sheep. But he cannot do this when he sees the shepherd coming equipped with accurate knowledge at all points and well acquainted with his plots. Therefore we ought to be well-guarded in all areas. A city that is surrounded with a wall laughs at its attackers and remains in great security. But if anyone makes a breach in the wall, even one only the size of a gate, the rest of the wall is useless, even if all of it stands quite securely. It is the same with the city of God. As long as the presence of mind and wisdom of the shepherd, which corresponds to the wall, protects it on all sides, all the enemy's schemes end in his confusion and ridicule, and those who live within the wall remain undisturbed. But wherever anyone has been able to demolish a single part, even if the rest stands firm, ruin will enter through that breach upon the whole. What is the point if a man contends earnestly with the Greeks but at the same time becomes a victim to the Jews? Or what if he gets the better of both these but then falls into the clutches of the Manicheans? Or what if, after he has proved himself superior even to them, those who teach fatalism enter in and destroy the flock? Without listing all the heresies of the devil, it is enough to say that unless the shepherd is well skilled in refuting them all, the wolf can enter by means of any one of them and devour the greater part of the flock. In ordinary warfare we must always expect victory to be won or defeat to be suffered by the soldiers who are on the battlefield. But in spiritual warfare the situation is quite different. There it often happens that the battle with one set of enemies secures a victory for others who never engaged in battle at all, nor took any trouble, but were sitting still the whole time. Anyone who does not have much experience in such situations will get pierced, so to speak, with his own sword, and become the laughing-stock of friends and enemies alike. I will try to make clear what I am saying with an example. Those who accept the wild doctrines of Valentinus and Marcion, and of all whose minds are similarly diseased, exclude the Law given by God to Moses from the list of the Divine Scriptures. But Jews revere the Law so much that although the time has come which annuls it, they still argue for the observance of all its contents, contrary to the purpose of God. But the Church of God, avoiding either extreme, has followed a middle path. She is neither persuaded on the one hand to place herself under its yoke, nor on the other does she tolerate its being slandered. Rather, she commends it, though its day is over, because of its usefulness during the season when it was in force. Now it is necessary for anyone who is going to fight with both these enemies to be fully conversant with this middle course. If in wishing to teach the Jews that they are out of date in clinging to the old law, he begins to criticize it excessively, he gives no small opportunity to those heretics who wish to tear it apart. And if in his desire to silence them he praises it excessively and speaks of it with admiration, as necessary for the present time, he opens the mouths of the Jews. Again, those who suffer under the madness of Sabellius and the delusion of Arius have both fallen from sound faith for lack of observing a middle course. The name of Christian is applied to both these heretics. But if anyone examines their doctrines, he will find that the one group is not much better than the Jews, differing from them only in name, and the other very nearly holds the heresy of Paul of Samosata, and that both are very far from the truth. Therefore, the danger in such cases is great, and the way of orthodoxy is narrow and hemmed in by threatening crags on either side, and there is considerable fear that when intending to strike at one enemy we might be wounded by the other. If anyone asserts the unity of the Godhead, Sabellius immediately turns that expression to the advantage of his own mental error. And if he distinguishes the Persons, and says that the Father is one, and the Son another, and the Holy Spirit a third, up gets Arius, ready to twist that distinction of Persons into a difference of ousia (substance). So we must turn and flee both from the impious confounding of the Persons by the one, and the senseless division of the ousia by the other, confessing indeed that the Godhead of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit is all one, while we add to this a Trinity of Persons. For then we shall be able to fortify ourselves against the attacks of both heretics. Besides these, I could tell you of several other adversaries against which, unless we contend bravely and carefully, we shall leave the field covered with wounds.

4. Wherefore it should be our ambition that the Word of Christ dwell in us richly. Colossians 3:16 For it is not for one kind of battle only that we have to be prepared. This warfare is manifold, and is engaged with a great variety of enemies; neither do all these use the same weapons, nor do they practice the same method of attack; and he who has to join battle with all, must needs know the artifices of all, and be at once both archer and slinger, captain and general, in the ranks and in command, on foot and on horseback, in sea-fight and in siege. In common warfare, indeed, each man repels the enemy by discharging the particular duty which he has undertaken. But here it is otherwise; and if any one wishes to come off conqueror in this warfare, he must understand all forms of the art, as the devil knows well how to introduce his own assailants through any one spot which may happen to be unguarded, and to carry off the sheep. But not so where he perceives the shepherd coming equipped with accurate knowledge at all points, and well acquainted with his plottings. Wherefore we ought to be well-guarded in all parts: for a city, so long as it happens to be surrounded with a wall, laughs to scorn the besiegers, abiding in great security; but if any one makes a breach in the wall, though but of the size of a gate, the rest of the circuit is of no use, although the whole of it stand quite securely; so it is with the city of God: so long as the presence of mind and wisdom of the shepherd, which answers to the wall, protect it on all sides, all the enemy's devices end in his confusion and ridicule, and they who dwell within the wall abide unmolested, but wherever any one has been able to demolish a single part, though the rest stand never so fast, through that breach ruin will enter upon the whole. For to what purpose does a man contend earnestly with the Greeks, if at the same time he becomes a prey to the Jews? Or get the better of both these and then fall into the clutches of the Manichæans? or after he has proved himself superior to them even, if they who introduce fatalism enter in, and make havoc of the flock? But not to enumerate all the heresies of the devil, it will be enough to say that unless the shepherd is well skilled in refuting them all, the wolf, by means of any one of them, can enter, and devour the greater part of the flock. In ordinary warfare we must always look for victory being won or defeat sustained by the soldiers who are on the field of battle. But in the spiritual warfare the case is quite different. For there it often happens that the combat with one set of enemies secures a victory for others who never engaged in battle at all, nor took any trouble, but were sitting still all the while; and he who has not much experience in such occurrences will get pierced, so to say, with his own sword, and become the laughing-stock of friends and foes alike. I will try by an example to make clear what I am saying. They who receive the wild doctrines of Valentinus and Marcion, and of all whose minds are similarly diseased, exclude the Law given by God to Moses from the catalogue of the Divine Scriptures. But Jews so revere the Law, that although the time has come which annuls it, they still contend for the observance of all its contents, contrary to the purpose of God. But the Church of God, avoiding either extreme, has trodden a middle path, and is neither induced on the one hand to place herself under its yoke, nor on the other does she tolerate its being slandered, but commends it, though its day is over, because of its profitableness while its season lasted. Now it is necessary for him who is going to fight with both these enemies, to be fully conversant with this middle course. For if in wishing to teach the Jews that they are out of date in clinging to the old law, he begins to find fault with it unsparingly, he gives no little handle to those heretics who wish to pull it to pieces; and if in his ambition to stop their mouths he extols it immoderately, and speaks of it with admiration, as necessary for this present time, he unseals the lips of the Jews. Again they who labor under the frenzy of Sabellius and the craze of Arius, have both fallen from a sound faith for want of observing a middle course. The name of Christian is applied to both these heretics; but if any one examines their doctrines, he will find the one sect not much better than the Jews, and differing from them only in name, and the other very nearly holding the heresy of Paul of Samosata, and that both are very wide of the truth. Great, therefore, is the danger in such cases, and the way of orthodoxy is narrow and hemmed in by threatening crags on either side, and there is no little fear lest when intending to strike at one enemy we should be wounded by the other. For if any one assert the unity of the Godhead, Sabellius straightway turns that expression to the advantage of his own mental vagary, and if he distinguish the Persons, and say that the Father is one, and the Son another, and the Holy Spirit a third, up gets Arius, ready to wrest that distinction of Persons into a difference of substance; so we must turn and flee both from the impious confounding of the Persons by the one, and the senseless division of the substance by the other, confessing, indeed, that the Godhead of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost, is all one, while we add thereunto a Trinity of Persons. For then we shall be able to fortify ourselves against the attacks of both heretics. I might tell you besides these, of several other adversaries against which, except we contend bravely and carefully, we shall leave the field covered with wounds.

Why should anyone describe the foolish talk of our own people? For these internal problems are no less serious than the attacks from outside, and they give the teacher even more trouble. Some people, out of idle curiosity, rashly insist on occupying themselves with matters that they cannot possibly know and that would be of no benefit to them even if they could know them. Others demand that God give them an account of his judgments, and they force themselves to probe the depth of that abyss which cannot be fathomed. For the Scriptures say, "Your judgments are a great deep," yet you would find few of them anxious about their faith and conduct, but the majority curiously inquiring into matters that cannot be discovered, and the mere inquiry into which provokes God. For when we make a determined effort to learn what he does not wish us to know, we fail to succeed (for how could we succeed against God's will?), and there remains for us only the danger arising from our inquiry. Now, though this is the case, whenever someone authoritatively stops the search into such fathomless depths, he gets a reputation for being proud and ignorant, so that at such times much tact is needed on the bishop's part, both to lead his people away from these unprofitable questions and to escape the criticisms mentioned above. In short, to meet all these difficulties, there is no help available except the power of speech, and if anyone lacks this ability, the souls of those placed under his charge (I mean the weaker and more meddlesome sort) are no better off than ships continually storm-tossed. Therefore the priest should do everything in his power to gain this means of strength.

5. Why should any one describe the silly chatter of our own people? For these are not less than the attacks upon us from without, while they give the teacher even more trouble. Some out of an idle curiosity are rashly bent upon busying themselves about matters which are neither possible for them to know, nor of any advantage to them if they could know them. Others again demand from God an account of his judgments, and force themselves to sound the depth of that abyss which is unfathomable. For your judgments, says the Scriptures, are a great deep, and about their faith and practice you would find few of them anxious, but the majority curiously inquiring into matters which it is not possible to discover, and the mere inquiry into which provokes God. For when we make a determined effort to learn what He does not wish us to know, we fail to succeed (for how should we succeed against the will of God?); and there only remains for us the danger arising from our inquiry. Now, though this be the case, whenever any one authoritatively stops the search, into such fathomless depths, he gets himself the reputation of being proud and ignorant; so that at such times much tact is needed on the Bishop's part, so as to lead his people away from these unprofitable questions, and himself escape the above-named censures. In short, to meet all these difficulties, there is no help given but that of speech, and if any be destitute of this power, the souls of those who are put under his charge (I mean of the weaker and more meddlesome kind) are no better off than ships continually storm-tossed. So that the Priest should do all that in him lies, to gain this means of strength.

6. Basil: Why, then, did St. Paul not strive to become perfect in this art? He makes no secret of his lack of eloquence but openly admits that he is unskilled in it, even telling this to the Corinthians, who were admired for their eloquence and took pride in it.

6. Basil: Why, then, was not St. Paul ambitious of becoming perfect in this art? He makes no secret of his poverty of speech, but distinctly confesses himself to be unskilled, even telling the Corinthians so, who were admired for their eloquence, and prided themselves upon it.

This is the very thing that has ruined many people and made them careless in studying true doctrine. They failed to grasp the depths of the apostle's mind and to understand what his words meant, so they spent all their time drowsy and inattentive, showing respect not to the kind of ignorance St. Paul acknowledged, but to a kind from which he was as free as anyone who ever lived.

Chrysostom: This is the very thing which has ruined many and made them remiss in the study of true doctrine. For while they failed to fathom the depths of the apostle's mind, and to understand the meaning of his words, they passed all their time slumbering and yawning, and paying respect not to that ignorance which St. Paul acknowledges, but to a kind from which he was as free as any man ever was in the world.

But setting this subject aside for now, let me say this much for the moment. Even if we grant that St. Paul was as unskilled in this respect as they claim him to be, what does that have to do with the people of today? For he had a far greater power than eloquence, a power which produced far greater results too—namely, that his mere presence, even when he was silent, was terrifying to demons. But the people of the present day, if they were all gathered in one place, would not be able, even with endless prayers and tears, to accomplish the wonders that were once done by St. Paul's handkerchief. He also raised the dead through his prayers, Acts 20:10, and performed such other miracles that he was considered a god by pagans, Acts 14:11. And before he departed this life, he was counted worthy to be caught up to the third heaven and to participate in such conversation as it is not lawful for mortal ears to hear. 2 Corinthians 12:2-4. But the people of today—not that I would say anything harsh or severe, for I am not speaking to insult them, but only in amazement—how is it that they do not tremble when they compare themselves with so great a man as this? For if we set aside the miracles and turn to the life of this blessed saint, and examine his angelic way of life, it is in this rather than in his miracles that you will find this Christian athlete victorious. For how can one describe his zeal and endurance, his constant dangers, his continual concerns and unceasing anxiety for the Churches, his compassion for the weak, his many afflictions, his extraordinary persecutions, his daily deaths? Where is the place in the world, where is the continent or sea, that is unfamiliar with the labors of this righteous man? Even the desert has known his presence, for it often sheltered him in times of danger. For he endured every kind of attack and achieved every kind of victory, and there was never any end to his struggles and his triumphs.

But leaving this subject to await our consideration, I say this much in the meantime. Granting that St. Paul was in this respect as unskilled as they would have him to be, what has that to do with the men of today? For he had a greater power by far than power of speech, power which brought about greater results too; which was that his bare presence, even though he was silent, was terrible to the demons. But the men of the present day, if they were all collected in one place, would not be able, with infinite prayers and tears, to do the wonders that once were done by the handkerchief of St. Paul. He too by his prayers raised the dead, Acts 20:10 and wrought such other miracles, that he was held to be a god by heathen; Acts 14:11 and before he was removed from this life, he was thought worthy to be caught up as far as the third heaven, and to share in such converse as it is not lawful for mortal ears to hear. 2 Corinthians 12:2-4 But the men of today — not that I would say anything harsh or severe, for indeed I do not speak by way of insult to them, but only in wonder — how is it that they do not shudder when they measure themselves with so great a man as this? For if we leave the miracles and turn to the life of this blessed saint, and look into his angelic conversation, it is in this rather than in his miracles that you will find this Christian athlete a conqueror. For how can one describe his zeal and forbearance, his constant perils, his continual cares, and incessant anxiety for the Churches; his sympathy with the weak, his many afflictions, his unwonted persecutions, his deaths daily? Where is the spot in the world, where is the continent or sea, that is a stranger to the labours of this righteous man? Even the desert has known his presence, for it often sheltered him in time of danger. For he underwent every species of attack, and achieved every kind of victory, and there was never any end to his contests and his triumphs.

Yet without realizing it, I have ended up doing this man an injustice. For his achievements are beyond all powers of description, and especially beyond mine, just as the masters of eloquence surpass me. Nevertheless, since that holy apostle will judge us not by the outcome but by the intention, I will not hold back until I have mentioned one more circumstance that surpasses everything already said, as much as he himself surpasses all other people. And what is this? After so many achievements, after such a multitude of victories, he prayed that he might go into hell and be handed over to eternal punishment, if only those Jews who had often stoned him and done everything they could to kill him might be saved and come over to Christ. Romans 9:3 Now who has ever longed for Christ like this? Indeed, his feelings toward him should probably be described as something nobler than longing. Shall we then continue to compare ourselves with this saint, after such great grace was given to him from above, after such great virtue was shown in him? What could be more presumptuous?

Yet, all unawares, I have been led to do this man an injury. For his exploits are beyond all powers of description, and beyond mine in particular, just as the masters of eloquence surpass me. Nevertheless, since that holy apostle will judge us, not by the issue, but by the motive, I shall not forbear till I have stated one more circumstance which surpasses anything yet mentioned, as much as he himself surpasses all his fellow men. And what is this? After so many exploits, after such a multitude of victories, he prayed that he might go into hell, and be handed over to eternal punishment, if so be that those Jews, who had often stoned him, and done what they could to make away with him, might be saved, and come over to Christ. Romans 9:3 Now who so longed for Christ? If, indeed, his feelings towards him ought not to be described as something nobler than longing; shall we then any more compare ourselves with this saint, after so great grace was imparted to him from above, after so great virtue was manifested in himself? What could be more presumptuous?

Now, I will try to show in what follows that he was not as unskilled as some people consider him to be. The unskilled person in people's judgment is not only someone who is unpracticed in the techniques of secular rhetoric, but someone who is incapable of arguing in defense of the right faith—and they are correct about this. But Saint Paul did not say he was unskilled in both these areas, only in one. He makes a careful distinction to support this when he says he was unskilled in speech, but not in knowledge (2 Corinthians 11:6). Now, if I were to demand the polish of Isocrates, the weight of Demosthenes, the dignity of Thucydides, and the sublimity of Plato in any bishop, Saint Paul would be strong evidence against me. But I set aside all such matters and the elaborate ornaments of secular rhetoric. I take no account of style or delivery. Yes, let a man's word choice be poor and his composition simple and plain, but let him not be unskilled in the knowledge and accurate statement of doctrine. Nor should anyone, in order to excuse his own laziness, deprive that holy apostle of the greatest of his gifts and the sum of his praises.

Now, that he was not so unskilled, as some count him to be, I shall try to show in what follows. The unskilled person in men's estimation is not only one who is unpracticed in the tricks of profane oratory, but the man who is incapable of contending for the defense of the right faith, and they are right. But St. Paul did not say that he was unskilled in both these respects, but in one only; and in support of this he makes a careful distinction, saying that he was rude in speech, but not in knowledge. 2 Corinthians 11:6 Now were I to insist upon the polish of Isocrates, the weight of Demosthenes, the dignity of Thucydides, and the sublimity of Plato, in any one bishop, St. Paul would be a strong evidence against me. But I pass by all such matters and the elaborate ornaments of profane oratory; and I take no account of style or of delivery; yea let a man's diction be poor and his composition simple and unadorned, but let him not be unskilled in the knowledge and accurate statement of doctrine; nor in order to screen his own sloth, deprive that holy apostle of the greatest of his gifts, and the sum of his praises.

For how was it, tell me, that he confounded the Jews who lived in Damascus, though he had not yet begun to work miracles? How was it that he wrestled with the Greeks and threw them? And why was he sent to Tarsus? Was it not because he was so powerful and victorious in his use of words, and brought his opponents to such a point that they, unable to endure their defeat, were provoked to seek his life? At that time, as I said, he had not begun to work miracles, nor could anyone say that the crowds looked upon him with astonishment because of any glory belonging to his mighty works, or that those who contended with him were overpowered by the force of public opinion concerning him. For at this time he conquered by argument alone. How was it, moreover, that he contended and disputed successfully with those who tried to Judaize in Antioch? And how was it that that Areopagite, an inhabitant of Athens, that most devoted of all cities to the gods, followed the apostle, he and his wife? Was it not because of the discourse which they heard? And when Eutychus fell from the lattice, was it not because of his long attendance even until midnight to St. Paul's preaching? How do we find him employed at Thessalonica and Corinth, in Ephesus and in Rome itself? Did he not spend whole nights and days interpreting the Scriptures in their order? And why should anyone recount his disputes with the Epicureans and Stoics? For if we resolved to enter into every particular, our story would grow to an unreasonable length.

7. For how was it, tell me, that he confounded the Jews which dwelt at Damascus, Acts 9:22 though he had not yet begun to work miracles? How was it that he wrestled with the Grecians and threw them? and why was he sent to Tarsus? Was it not because he was so mighty and victorious in the word, and brought his adversaries to such a pass that they, unable to brook their defeat, were provoked to seek his life? At that time, as I said, he had not begun to work miracles, nor could any one say that the masses looked upon him with astonishment on account of any glory belonging to his mighty works, or that they who contended with him were overpowered by the force of public opinion concerning him. For at this time he conquered by dint of argument only. How was it, moreover, that he contended and disputed successfully with those who tried to Judaize in Antioch? And how was it that that Areopagite, Acts 17:34 an inhabitant of Athens, that most devoted of all cities to the gods, followed the apostle, he and his wife? Was it not owing to the discourse which they heard? And when Eutychus Acts 20:9 fell from the lattice, was it not owing to his long attendance even until midnight to St. Paul's preaching? How do we find him employed at Thessalonica and Corinth, in Ephesus and in Rome itself? Did he not spend whole nights and days in interpreting the Scriptures in their order? And why should any one recount his disputes with the Epicureans and Stoics. Acts 17:18 For were we resolved to enter into every particular, our story would grow to an unreasonable length.

When, therefore, both before working miracles and after, St. Paul appears to have made much use of argument, how can anyone dare to pronounce him unskilled when his sermons and disputations were so exceedingly admired by all who heard them? Why did the Lycaonians imagine that he was Hermes? The opinion that he and Barnabas were gods indeed arose from seeing their miracles; but the notion that he was Hermes did not arise from this, but was a consequence of his speech. In what else did this blessed saint excel the rest of the apostles? And how is it that up and down the world he is so much on everyone's tongue? How is it that not merely among ourselves, but also among Jews and Greeks, he is the wonder of wonders? Is it not from the power of his epistles? Through them, not only to the faithful of today, but from his time to this, yes and up to the end, even the appearing of Christ, he has been and will be profitable, and will continue to be so as long as the human race shall last. For like a wall built of adamant, his writings fortify all the Churches of the known world, and he as a most noble champion stands in the midst, bringing into captivity every thought to the obedience of Christ, casting down imaginations and every high thing which exalts itself against the knowledge of God, and all this he does through those epistles which he has left to us full of wonders and of divine wisdom. For his writings are not only useful to us for the overthrow of false doctrine and the confirmation of the true, but they help not a little toward living a good life. For by the use of these, the bishops of the present day fit and fashion the chaste virgin, which St. Paul himself espoused to Christ, and conduct her to the state of spiritual beauty; with these, too, they drive away from her the noisome pestilences which beset her and preserve the good health thus obtained. Such are the medicines and such their efficacy left us by this so-called unskilled man, and they know them and their power best who constantly use them. From all this it is evident that St. Paul had given himself to the study of which we have been speaking with great diligence and zeal.

When, therefore, both before working miracles, and after, St. Paul appears to have made much use of argument, how can any one dare to pronounce him unskillful whose sermons and disputations were so exceedingly admired by all who heard them? Why did the Lycaonians Acts 14:11 imagine that he was Hermes? The opinion that he and Barnabas were gods indeed, arose out of the sight of their miracles; but the notion that he was Hermes did not arise from this, but was a consequence of his speech. In what else did this blessed saint excel the rest of the apostles? And how comes it that up and down the world he is so much on every one's tongue? How comes it that not merely among ourselves, but also among Jews and Greeks, he is the wonder of wonders? Is it not from the power of his epistles? Whereby not only to the faithful of today, but from his time to this, yea and up to the end, even the appearing of Christ, he has been and will be profitable, and will continue to be so as long as the human race shall last. For as a wall built of adamant, so his writings fortify all the Churches of the known world, and he as a most noble champion stands in the midst, bringing into captivity every thought to the obedience of Christ, casting down imaginations, and every high thing which exalts itself against the knowledge of God, 2 Corinthians 10:5 and all this he does by those epistles which he has left to us full of wonders and of Divine wisdom. For his writings are not only useful to us, for the overthrow of false doctrine and the confirmation of the true, but they help not a little towards living a good life. For by the use of these, the bishops of the present day fit and fashion the chaste virgin, which St. Paul himself espoused to Christ, 2 Corinthians 11:2 and conduct her to the state of spiritual beauty; with these, too, they drive away from her the noisome pestilences which beset her, and preserve the good health thus obtained. Such are the medicines and such their efficacy left us by this so-called unskillful man, and they know them and their power best who constantly use them. From all this it is evident that St. Paul had given himself to the study of which we have been speaking with great diligence and zeal.

Listen also to what he says when instructing his disciple: "Give heed to reading, to exhortation, to teaching," and he goes on to show how useful this is by adding, "For in doing this you will save both yourself and those who hear you." And again he says, "The Lord's servant must not strive, but be gentle toward all, apt to teach, forbearing," and he continues, "But continue in the things you have learned and have been assured of, knowing from whom you learned them, and that from childhood you have known the sacred writings which are able to make you wise unto salvation," and again, "Every Scripture is inspired of God, and also profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, for instruction which is in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete." Listen to what he adds further in his directions to Titus about the appointment of bishops. The bishop, he says, must hold to "the faithful word which is according to the teaching, that he may be able to convict those who oppose." But how can anyone who is unskilled, as these men claim, be able to convict those who oppose and silence them? Or what need is there to pay attention to reading and to the Holy Scriptures if such a state of being unskilled is to be welcomed among us? Such arguments are mere excuses and pretexts, the signs of laziness and sloth. But someone will say these instructions are given to the priests—certainly, for they are the subjects of our discussion. But that the apostle gives the same charge to the laity, listen to what he says in another epistle to those who are not priests: "Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly in all wisdom," and again, "Let your speech be always with grace seasoned with salt, that you may know how you ought to answer each one," and there is a general charge to all that they be ready to give an account of their faith, and to the Thessalonians he gives the following command: "Build each other up, even as you also do." But when he speaks of priests he says, "Let the elders that rule well be counted worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in the word and in teaching." For this is the perfection of teaching when the teachers bring their disciples to that blessed state of life which Christ appointed for them both by what they do and by what they say. For example alone is not enough to instruct others. Nor do I say this of myself; it is our Savior's own word. For "whosoever shall do and teach them, he shall be called great." Now if doing were the same as teaching, the second word here would be unnecessary, and it would have been enough to say "whosoever shall do" simply. But now by distinguishing the two, he shows that practice is one thing and doctrine another, and that each needs the help of the other in order to complete edification. You also hear what the chosen vessel of Christ says to the Ephesian elders: "Therefore watch, remembering that for the space of three years I ceased not to admonish every one, night and day, with tears." But what need was there for his tears or for admonition by word of mouth while his life as an apostle was so illustrious? His holy life might be a great encouragement for men to keep the commandments, yet I dare not say that it alone could accomplish everything.

8. Hear also what he says in his charge to his disciple: 1 Timothy 4:13 Give heed to reading, to exhortation, to teaching, and he goes on to show the usefulness of this by adding, For in doing this you shall save both yourself and them that hear you. 1 Timothy 4:16 And again he says, The Lord's servant must not strive, but be gentle towards all, apt to teach, forbearing; 2 Timothy 2:24 and he proceeds to say, But abide thou in the things which you have learned, and hast been assured of, knowing of whom you have learned them, and that from a babe you have known the sacred writings which are able to make you wise unto salvation, 2 Timothy 3:14-15 and again, Every Scripture is inspired of God, and also profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, for instruction which is in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete. Hear what he adds further in his directions to Titus about the appointment of bishops. The bishop, he says, must be holding to the faithful word which is according to the teaching, that he may be able to convict the gainsayers. But how shall any one who is unskillful as these men pretend, be able to convict the gainsayers and stop their mouths? Or what need is there to give attention to reading and to the Holy Scriptures, if such a state of unskillfulness is to be welcome among us? Such arguments are mere makeshifts and pretexts, the marks of idleness and sloth. But some one will say, it is to the priests that these charges are given: — certainly, for they are the subjects of our discourse. But that the apostle gives the same charge to the laity, hear what he says in another epistle to other than the priesthood: Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly in all wisdom, Colossians 3:16 and again, Let your speech be always with grace seasoned with salt, that you may know how ye ought to answer each one, Colossians 4:6 and there is a general charge to all that they be ready to 1 Peter 3:15 render an account of their faith, and to the Thessalonians, he gives the following command: Build each other up, even as also ye do. 1 Thessalonians 5:11 But when he speaks of priests he says, Let the elders that rule well be counted worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in the word, and in teaching. 1 Timothy 5:17 For this is the perfection of teaching when the teachers both by what they do, and by what they say as well, bring their disciples to that blessed state of life which Christ appointed for them. For example alone is not enough to instruct others. Nor do I say this of myself; it is our Saviour's own word. For whosoever shall do and teach them, he shall be called great. Matthew 5:19 Now if doing were the same as teaching, the second word here would be superfluous; and it had been enough to have said whosoever shall do simply. But now by distinguishing the two, he shows that practice is one thing, and doctrine another, and that each needs the help of the others in order to complete edification. You hear too what the chosen vessel of Christ says to the Ephesian elders: Wherefore watch ye, remembering that for the space of three years, I ceased not to admonish every one, night and day, with tears. Acts 20:31 But what need was there for his tears or for admonition by word of mouth, while his life as an apostle was so illustrious? His holy life might be a great inducement to men to keep the commandments, yet I dare not say that it alone could accomplish everything.

But when a dispute arises concerning matters of doctrine, and all parties draw their weapons from the same Scriptures, what weight will anyone's manner of life be able to prove? What good will his many austerities be if, after such painful exercises, someone falls into heresy because of the priest's great lack of skill in argument, and is cut off from the body of the Church—a misfortune I have myself seen many people suffer? What profit will his patience be to him then? None at all, any more than a sound faith will profit someone if his life is corrupt. Therefore, for this reason more than all others, it is essential for the person whose office is to teach others to be experienced in disputations of this kind. For even if he himself stands safely and is unhurt by those who oppose him, the simple multitude under his direction, when they see their leader defeated and without any answer for those who oppose him, will be likely to blame his defeat not on his own weakness, but on the doctrines themselves, as though they were faulty. And so because of one person's inexperience, great numbers are brought to utter ruin. For even if they do not entirely go over to the adversary, they are forced to doubt matters in which they formerly believed firmly, and those whom they used to approach with unwavering confidence they can no longer hold to steadfastly. Because of their leader's defeat, so great a storm settles upon their souls that the harm ends in their complete shipwreck. But you do not need to learn from me how dire is the destruction and how terrible the fire which such a leader brings upon his own wretched head for every soul that is lost in this way, since you know all this perfectly well. Is this then pride? Is this vainglory in me, to be unwilling to be the cause of so many souls' destruction and to bring upon myself greater punishment in the world to come than what now awaits me there? Who would say so? Surely no one, unless he wanted to find fault where there is none and to moralize over other people's calamities.

9. But when a dispute arises concerning matters of doctrine, and all take their weapons from the same Scriptures, of what weight will any one's life be able to prove? What then will be the good of his many austerities, when after such painful exercises, any one from the Priest's great unskillfulness in argument fall into heresy, and be cut off from the body of the Church, a misfortune which I have myself seen many suffering. Of what profit then will his patience be to him? None; no more than there will be in a sound faith if the life is corrupt. Wherefore, for this reason more than for all others, it concerns him whose office it is to teach others, to be experienced in disputations of this kind. For though he himself stands safely, and is unhurt by the gainsayers, yet the simple multitude under his direction, when they see their leader defeated, and without any answer for the gainsayers, will be apt to lay the blame of his discomfiture not on his own weakness, but on the doctrines themselves, as though they were faulty; and so by reason of the inexperience of one, great numbers are brought to extreme ruin; for though they do not entirely go over to the adversary, yet they are forced to doubt about matters in which formerly they firmly believed, and those whom they used to approach with unswerving confidence, they are unable to hold to any longer steadfastly, but in consequence of their leader's defeat, so great a storm settles down upon their souls, that the mischief ends in their shipwreck altogether. But how dire is the destruction, and how terrible the fire which such a leader brings upon his own wretched head for every soul which is thus lost, you will not need to learn from me, as you know all this perfectly. Is this then pride, is this vainglory in me, to be unwilling to be the cause of the destruction of so many souls? And of procuring for myself greater punishment in the world to come, than that which now awaits me there? Who would say so? Surely no one, unless he should wish to find fault where there is none, and to moralize over other men's calamities.


On the Priesthood — Book III

On the Priesthood, Book III: the dialogue with Basil on the dignity and dangers of priestly ministry.

Source: Translated by W.R.W. Stephens. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 9. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/19223.htm>.

Opening

As for the insult to those who honored me, what I have already said should be enough to prove that by avoiding this office I had no wish to shame them. But I will now try, as best I can, to show that I was not driven by any kind of arrogance. If the choice of a generalship or a kingdom had been offered to me and I had made this decision, anyone might naturally suspect me of this fault—or rather, everyone would rightly judge me guilty not of arrogance but of senseless foolishness. But when the priesthood is offered to me, which surpasses a kingdom as much as spirit differs from flesh, will anyone dare accuse me of disdain? Is it not absurd to charge with foolishness those who refuse small things, yet when people do this with matters of supreme importance, to exempt them from accusations of mental derangement but instead charge them with pride? It would be like accusing a man not of pride but of insanity if he looked with contempt on a herd of oxen and refused to be a herdsman, yet saying that a man who declined the empire of the world and command of all the earth's armies was not mad but simply puffed up with pride. But this is clearly not the case. Those who say such things harm themselves even more than they harm me. The mere idea that human nature could despise this dignity reveals what those making this charge really think of the office. If they did not consider it an ordinary thing of little value, such a suspicion would never have entered their minds. Why has no one ever dared to entertain such a suspicion about the dignity of the angels and say that arrogance is the reason human nature would not aspire to angelic rank? It is because we imagine great things about those powers, and this does not allow us to believe that anyone could conceive of anything greater than that honor. Therefore, one could more justly accuse of arrogance those very people who accuse me of it. They would never have suspected this of others if they had not first downgraded the matter as being of no account. But if they say I did this to gain glory, they will be caught openly fighting against themselves and falling into their own trap. I do not know what arguments they could have looked for better than these if they had wanted to clear me of the charge of vainglory.

1. Chrysostom: As regards the insult to those who have done me honor, what I have already said might be sufficient to prove that in avoiding this office I had no desire to put them to shame; but I will now endeavor to make it evident, to the best of my ability, that I was not puffed up by arrogance of any kind. For if the choice of a generalship or a kingdom had been submitted to me, and I had then formed this resolution, any one might naturally have suspected me of this fault, or rather I should have been found guilty by all men, not of arrogance, but of senseless folly. But when the priesthood is offered to me, which exceeds a kingdom as much as the spirit differs from the flesh, will any one dare to accuse me of disdain? And is it not preposterous to charge with folly those who reject small things, but when any do this in matters of pre-eminent importance, to exempt such persons from accusations of mental derangement, and yet subject them to the charge of pride? It is just as if one were to accuse, not of pride, but of insanity, a man who looked with contempt on a herd of oxen and refused to be a herdsman, and yet were to say that a man who declined the empire of the world, and the command of all the armies of the earth, was not mad, but inflated with pride. But this assuredly is not the case; and they who say such things do not injure me more than they injure themselves. For merely to imagine it possible for human nature to despise this dignity is an evidence against those who bring this charge of the estimate which they have formed of the office. For if they did not consider it to be an ordinary thing of no great account, such a suspicion as this would never have entered their heads. For why is it that no one has ever dared to entertain such a suspicion with reference to the dignity of the angels, and to say that arrogance is the reason why human nature would not aspire to the rank of the angelic nature? It is because we imagine great things concerning those powers, and this does not suffer us to believe that a man can conceive anything greater than that honor. Wherefore one might with more justice indite those persons of arrogance who accuse me of it. For they would never have suspected this of others if they had not previously depreciated the matter as being of no account. But if they say that I have done this with a view to glory, they will be convicted of fighting openly against themselves and falling into their own snare; for I do not know what kind of arguments they could have sought in preference to these if they had wished to release me from the charge of vainglory.

If this desire had ever entered my mind, I should have accepted the office rather than avoided it. Why? Because it would have brought me much glory. The fact that someone of my age, who had so recently abandoned secular pursuits, should suddenly be deemed by everyone worthy of such admiration as to be advanced to honor before those who have spent their entire lives in labors of this kind, and to obtain more votes than all of them, might have persuaded everyone to anticipate great and marvelous things from me. But as it is, the greater part of the Church does not even know me by name, so that even my refusal of the office will not be evident to all, but only to a few. I am not sure that all even of these know it for certain, but probably many of them either imagine that I was not elected at all, or that I was rejected after the election, being considered unsuitable—not that I avoided the office of my own accord.

2. For if this desire had ever entered my mind, I ought to have accepted the office rather than avoided it. Why? Because it would have brought me much glory. For the fact that one of my age, who had so recently abandoned secular pursuits, should suddenly be deemed by all worthy of such admiration as to be advanced to honor before those who have spent all their life in labors of this kind, and to obtain more votes than all of them, might have persuaded all men to anticipate great and marvellous things of me. But, as it is, the greater part of the Church does not know me even by name: so that even my refusal of the office will not be manifest to all, but only to a few, and I am not sure that all even of these know it for certain; but probably many of them either imagine that I was not elected at all, or that I was rejected after the election, being considered unsuitable, not that I avoided the office of my own accord.

But those who know the truth will be surprised.

3. Basil: But those who do know the truth will be surprised.

Chrysostom: And look! These are the very people who, according to you, falsely accuse me of vainglory and pride. So where am I to find praise? From the majority? They don't know what actually happened. From the few? Here again the situation is twisted against me. After all, the only reason you've come here now is to learn what answer should be given to them. What am I supposed to say about all this? Just wait a bit, and you'll clearly see that even if everyone knows the truth, they still shouldn't condemn me for pride and love of glory. And there's something else to consider: not only those who actually do this (if there are any such people, which I don't believe there are), but also those who suspect others of it, will face no small danger.

Chrysostom: And lo! These are they who, according to you, falsely accuse me of vainglory and pride. Whence then am I to hope for praise? From the many? They do not know the actual fact. From the few? Here again the matter is perverted to my disadvantage. For the only reason why you have come here now is to learn what answer ought to be given to them. And what shall I now certainly say on account of these things? For wait a little, and you will clearly perceive that even if all know the truth they ought not to condemn me for pride and love of glory. And in addition to this there is another consideration: that not only those who make this venture, if there be any such (which for my part I do not believe), but also those who suspect it of others, will be involved in no small danger.

The priestly office is carried out on earth, but it belongs among heavenly institutions—and this is entirely fitting. For it was not a human being, nor an angel, nor an archangel, nor any other created power, but the Paraclete Himself who established this calling and persuaded human beings, while still living in the flesh, to represent the ministry of angels. Therefore, the consecrated priest must be as pure as if he were standing in the heavens themselves, in the midst of those powers. Truly, the things used before the dispensation of grace were fearful and filled with awe: the bells, the pomegranates, the stones on the breastplate and on the ephod, the girdle, the mitre, the long robe, the golden plate, the holy of holies, and the deep silence within. But if anyone examines the things that belong to the dispensation of grace, he will find that, though they seem small, they are fearful and full of awe, and that what was said about the law is also true in this case—that what was made glorious has no glory in comparison to the surpassing glory (2 Corinthians 3:10). When you see the Lord sacrificed and laid upon the altar, and the priest standing and praying over the victim, and all the worshippers stained with that precious blood, can you still think you are among ordinary people and standing on earth? Are you not instead immediately transported to heaven, casting out every fleshly thought from your soul, and with a disembodied spirit and pure reason contemplating the things that are in heaven? What a marvel! What love of God for humanity! He who sits on high with the Father is at that moment held in the hands of all and gives Himself to those who are willing to embrace and grasp Him. And all do this through the eyes of faith! Do these things seem to you worthy of contempt, or such that anyone could be arrogant toward them?

4. For the priestly office is indeed discharged on earth, but it ranks among heavenly ordinances; and very naturally so: for neither man, nor angel, nor archangel, nor any other created power, but the Paraclete Himself, instituted this vocation, and persuaded men while still abiding in the flesh to represent the ministry of angels. Wherefore the consecrated priest ought to be as pure as if he were standing in the heavens themselves in the midst of those powers. Fearful, indeed, and of most awful import, were the things which were used before the dispensation of grace, as the bells, the pomegranates, the stones on the breastplate and on the ephod, the girdle, the mitre, the long robe, the plate of gold, the holy of holies, the deep silence within. But if any one should examine the things which belong to the dispensation of grace, he will find that, small as they are, yet are they fearful and full of awe, and that what was spoken concerning the law is true in this case also, that what has been made glorious has no glory in this respect by reason of the glory which excels. 2 Corinthians 3:10 For when you see the Lord sacrificed, and laid upon the altar, and the priest standing and praying over the victim, and all the worshippers empurpled with that precious blood, can you then think that you are still among men, and standing upon the earth? Are you not, on the contrary, straightway translated to Heaven, and casting out every carnal thought from the soul, do you not with disembodied spirit and pure reason contemplate the things which are in Heaven? Oh! What a marvel! What love of God to man! He who sits on high with the Father is at that hour held in the hands of all, and gives Himself to those who are willing to embrace and grasp Him. And this all do through the eyes of faith! Do these things seem to you fit to be despised, or such as to make it possible for any one to be uplifted against them?

Would you also learn from another miracle the exceeding holiness of this office? Picture Elijah and the vast crowd standing around him, and the sacrifice laid upon the stone altar, and all the rest of the people hushed into a deep silence while the prophet alone offers up prayer: then the sudden rush of fire from heaven upon the sacrifice—these are marvelous things, filled with awe. Now then pass from this scene to the rites which are celebrated in the present day; they are not only marvelous to behold, but surpassing in awe. There stands the priest, not bringing down fire from heaven, but the Holy Spirit: and he makes prolonged supplication, not that some flame sent down from on high may consume the offerings, but that grace descending on the sacrifice may thereby enlighten the souls of all, and make them more brilliant than silver purified by fire. Who can despise this most awesome mystery, unless he is completely mad and senseless? Or do you not know that no human soul could have endured that fire in the sacrifice, but all would have been utterly consumed, had not the assistance of God's grace been great?

Would you also learn from another miracle the exceeding sanctity of this office? Picture Elijah and the vast multitude standing around him, and the sacrifice laid upon the altar of stones, and all the rest of the people hushed into a deep silence while the prophet alone offers up prayer: then the sudden rush of fire from Heaven upon the sacrifice:– these are marvellous things, charged with terror. Now then pass from this scene to the rites which are celebrated in the present day; they are not only marvellous to behold, but transcendent in terror. There stands the priest, not bringing down fire from Heaven, but the Holy Spirit: and he makes prolonged supplication, not that some flame sent down from on high may consume the offerings, but that grace descending on the sacrifice may thereby enlighten the souls of all, and render them more refulgent than silver purified by fire. Who can despise this most awful mystery, unless he is stark mad and senseless? Or do you not know that no human soul could have endured that fire in the sacrifice, but all would have been utterly consumed, had not the assistance of God's grace been great.

If anyone will consider what a great thing it is for a person, being human and clothed in flesh and blood, to be able to draw near to that blessed and pure nature, he will then clearly see what great honor the grace of the Spirit has granted to priests. Through their work these rites are celebrated, along with others no less important for our dignity and salvation. Those who live on earth and dwell here are entrusted with administering things that are in heaven, and have received an authority that God has not given to angels or archangels. This has not been said to them: "Whatsoever you shall bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatsoever you shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven." Those who rule on earth do have authority to bind, but only the body, whereas this binding takes hold of the soul and reaches into the heavens. What priests do here below, God ratifies above, and the Master confirms the sentence of his servants. What else is this but complete heavenly authority that he has given them when he says, "Whose sins you remit they are remitted, and whose sins you retain they are retained"? What authority could be greater than this? The Father has committed all judgment to the Son, but I see it all placed into the hands of these men by the Son. They have been raised to this dignity as if they were already transported to heaven, had transcended human nature, and were freed from the passions to which we are subject. Moreover, if a king were to grant this honor to any of his subjects, authorizing him to cast into prison whom he pleased and to release them again, that person would become an object of envy and respect to everyone. But the one who has received from God an authority as much greater as heaven is more precious than earth and souls more precious than bodies seems to some to have received so small an honor that they can actually imagine that one of those entrusted with these things would despise the gift. Away with such madness! For it is transparent madness to despise so great a dignity, without which it is not possible to obtain either our own salvation or the good things that have been promised to us. If no one can enter the kingdom of heaven unless he is regenerate through water and the Spirit, and if the one who does not eat the flesh of the Lord and drink his blood is excluded from eternal life, and if all these things are accomplished only by means of those holy hands—I mean the hands of the priest—how will anyone without these be able to escape the fire of hell or to win those crowns that are reserved for the victorious?

5. For if any one will consider how great a thing it is for one, being a man, and compassed with flesh and blood, to be enabled to draw near to that blessed and pure nature, he will then clearly see what great honor the grace of the Spirit has vouchsafed to priests; since by their agency these rites are celebrated, and others nowise inferior to these both in respect of our dignity and our salvation. For they who inhabit the earth and make their abode there are entrusted with the administration of things which are in Heaven, and have received an authority which God has not given to angels or archangels. For it has not been said to them, Whatsoever you shall bind on earth shall be bound in Heaven, and whatsoever you shall loose on earth shall be loosed in Heaven. Matthew 18:18 They who rule on earth have indeed authority to bind, but only the body: whereas this binding lays hold of the soul and penetrates the heavens; and what priests do here below God ratifies above, and the Master confirms the sentence of his servants. For indeed what is it but all manner of heavenly authority which He has given them when He says, Whose sins ye remit they are remitted, and whose sins ye retain they are retained? John 20:23 What authority could be greater than this? The Father has committed all judgment to the Son? John 5:22 But I see it all put into the hands of these men by the Son. For they have been conducted to this dignity as if they were already translated to Heaven, and had transcended human nature, and were released from the passions to which we are liable. Moreover, if a king should bestow this honor upon any of his subjects, authorizing him to cast into prison whom he pleased and to release them again, he becomes an object of envy and respect to all men; but he who has received from God an authority as much greater as heaven is more precious than earth, and souls more precious than bodies, seems to some to have received so small an honor that they are actually able to imagine that one of those who have been entrusted with these things will despise the gift. Away with such madness! For transparent madness it is to despise so great a dignity, without which it is not possible to obtain either our own salvation, or the good things which have been promised to us. For if no one can enter into the kingdom of Heaven except he be regenerate through water and the Spirit, and he who does not eat the flesh of the Lord and drink His blood is excluded from eternal life, and if all these things are accomplished only by means of those holy hands, I mean the hands of the priest, how will any one, without these, be able to escape the fire of hell, or to win those crowns which are reserved for the victorious?

These are the ones who are entrusted with the labor pains of spiritual birth and the new life that comes through baptism. Through them we put on Christ, are buried with the Son of God, and become members of that blessed Head. For this reason they deserve not only to be feared by us more than rulers and kings, but also to be honored more than parents. Our parents gave us birth through blood and physical desire, but priests are the means of our birth from God—that blessed rebirth which is true freedom and sonship according to grace. The Jewish priests had authority to release the body from leprosy, or rather not to release it but only to examine those who were already healed, and you know how eagerly people sought the office of priest at that time. But our priests have received authority to deal not with bodily leprosy but with spiritual uncleanness—not to pronounce it removed after examination, but actually and completely to take it away. Therefore those who despise these priests would be far more cursed than Dathan and his company, and deserve more severe punishment. For although Dathan's group laid claim to a dignity that did not belong to them, they nevertheless had an excellent opinion of it, which they demonstrated by their great eagerness in pursuing it. But these people, even though the priesthood has been better established and has received such great development, have shown an audacity that exceeds the others, though expressed in the opposite way. For there is not an equal amount of contempt involved in reaching for an honor that does not belong to you and in despising such great blessings—the latter far exceeds the former, as much as scorn differs from admiration. What soul then is so corrupt as to despise such great blessings? None at all, I would say, unless it were one under some demonic impulse. For I return once more to the point where I started: not only in the way of discipline but also in the way of blessing, God has given priests a power greater than that of our natural parents. The two differ as much as the present life and the life to come. For our natural parents give us life only for this world, but priests give us life for the world to come. Our natural parents cannot prevent death from claiming their children or ward off the attacks of disease, but priests have often saved a sick soul or one that was on the point of perishing, obtaining for some a lighter punishment and preventing others from falling altogether—not only by instruction and warning, but also by the help provided through prayers. For not only at the time of rebirth but afterward as well, they have authority to forgive sins. "Is any sick among you?" it is written, "let him call for the elders of the Church and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord. And the prayer of faith shall save the sick, and the Lord will raise him up; and if he have committed sins they shall be forgiven him." Again, our natural parents, if their children come into conflict with any people of high rank and great power in the world, are unable to help them. But priests have reconciled not rulers and kings, but God Himself when His wrath has often been provoked against them.

6. These verily are they who are entrusted with the pangs of spiritual travail and the birth which comes through baptism: by their means we put on Christ, and are buried with the Son of God, and become members of that blessed Head. Wherefore they might not only be more justly feared by us than rulers and kings, but also be more honored than parents; since these begot us of blood and the will of the flesh, but the others are the authors of our birth from God, even that blessed regeneration which is the true freedom and the sonship according to grace. The Jewish priests had authority to release the body from leprosy, or, rather, not to release it but only to examine those who were already released, and you know how much the office of priest was contended for at that time. But our priests have received authority to deal, not with bodily leprosy, but spiritual uncleanness — not to pronounce it removed after examination, but actually and absolutely to take it away. Wherefore they who despise these priests would be far more accursed than Dathan and his company, and deserve more severe punishment. For the latter, although they laid claim to the dignity which did not belong to them, nevertheless had an excellent opinion concerning it, and this they evinced by the great eagerness with which they pursued it; but these men, when the office has been better regulated, and has received so great a development, have displayed an audacity which exceeds that of the others, although manifested in a contrary way. For there is not an equal amount of contempt involved in aiming at an honor which does not pertain to one, and in despising such great advantages, but the latter exceeds the former as much as scorn differs from admiration. What soul then is so sordid as to despise such great advantages? None whatever, I should say, unless it were one subject to some demoniacal impulse. For I return once more to the point from which I started: not in the way of chastising only, but also in the way of benefiting, God has bestowed a power on priests greater than that of our natural parents. The two indeed differ as much as the present and the future life. For our natural parents generate us unto this life only, but the others unto that which is to come. And the former would not be able to avert death from their offspring, or to repel the assaults of disease; but these others have often saved a sick soul, or one which was on the point of perishing, procuring for some a milder chastisement, and preventing others from falling altogether, not only by instruction and admonition, but also by the assistance wrought through prayers. For not only at the time of regeneration, but afterwards also, they have authority to forgive sins. Is any sick among you? it is said, let him call for the elders of the Church and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord. And the prayer of faith shall save the sick, and the Lord will raise him up: and if he have committed sins they shall be forgiven him. James 5:14-15 Again: our natural parents, should their children come into conflict with any men of high rank and great power in the world, are unable to profit them: but priests have reconciled, not rulers and kings, but God Himself when His wrath has often been provoked against them.

Well! After all this, will anyone dare to accuse me of arrogance? For my part, after what has been said, I expect such godly fear will take hold of my listeners' souls that they will no longer condemn those who avoid this office as arrogant and reckless, but will instead condemn those who willingly step forward and eagerly seek this position for themselves. For if those who have been entrusted with governing cities have sometimes destroyed those cities and ruined themselves as well when they lacked wisdom and watchfulness, how much ability do you think a person needs—both from within himself and from above—to avoid sinning, when his task is to adorn the Bride of Christ?

Well! After this will any one venture to condemn me for arrogance? For my part, after what has been said, I imagine such religious fear will possess the souls of the hearers that they will no longer condemn those who avoid the office for arrogance and temerity, but rather those who voluntarily come forward and are eager to obtain this dignity for themselves. For if they who have been entrusted with the command of cities, should they chance to be wanting in discretion and vigilance, have sometimes destroyed the cities and ruined themselves in addition, how much power think you both in himself and from above must he need, to avoid sinning, whose business it is to beautify the Bride of Christ?

No one loved Christ more than Paul. No one showed greater zeal, and no one received more grace. Yet even after all these advantages, he still felt fear and trembling about his leadership and those under his care. He says, "I fear, lest by any means, as the serpent beguiled Eve through his subtlety, so your minds should be corrupted from the simplicity which is in Christ." And again, "I was with you in fear and in much trembling." This was a man who had been caught up to the third heaven and made partaker of the unspeakable mysteries of God, and had endured as many deaths as he had lived days after becoming a believer. This was also a man who refused to use the authority Christ gave him, lest any of his converts should be offended. So if Paul, who went beyond God's commandments and never sought his own advantage but only that of those he governed, was always filled with fear when he considered the greatness of his leadership, what will our condition be? We often seek our own interests. We not only fail to go beyond Christ's commandments, but we often break them. Paul says, "Who is weak, and I am not weak? Who is offended and I burn not?" The priest ought to be like this, or rather, not just like this—for these are small things, practically nothing compared to what I'm about to say. And what is that? "I could wish that myself were accursed from Christ for my brethren, my kinsmen according to the flesh." If anyone can speak such words, if anyone has a soul capable of such a prayer, he might justly be blamed for running away. But if anyone lacks such excellence as much as I do, he deserves to be hated not if he avoids the office, but if he accepts it. Suppose the matter at hand were an appointment to a military position, and those with the right to confer the honor dragged forward a metalworker, a shoemaker, or some similar craftsman and put the army in his hands. I would not praise the poor man if he didn't run away and do everything in his power to avoid throwing himself into such obvious disaster. If it's enough simply to bear the title of pastor and take on the work carelessly, and there's no danger in this, then let anyone who wishes accuse me of vainglory. But if one who undertakes this responsibility must have much understanding, and before understanding, great grace from God, along with uprightness of conduct, purity of life, and superhuman virtue, do not deprive me of forgiveness if I am unwilling to perish needlessly and without cause.

7. No man loved Christ more than Paul: no man exhibited greater zeal, no man was counted worthy of more grace: nevertheless, after all these great advantages, he still has fears and tremblings concerning this government and those who were governed by him. I fear, he says, lest by any means, as the serpent beguiled Eve through his subtlety, so your minds should be corrupted from the simplicity which is in Christ. 2 Corinthians 11:3 And again, I was with you in fear and in much trembling; 1 Corinthians 2:3 and this was a man who had been caught up to the third Heaven, and made partaker of the unspeakable mysteries of God, 2 Corinthians 12:4 and had endured as many deaths as he had lived days after he became a believer — a man, moreover, who would not use the authority given him from Christ lest any of his converts should be offended. If, then, he who went beyond the ordinances of God, and nowhere sought his own advantage, but that of those whom he governed, was always so full of fear when he considered the greatness of his government, what shall our condition be who in many ways seek our own, who not only fail to go beyond the commandments of Christ, but for the most part transgress them? Who is weak, he says, and I am not weak? Who is offended and I burn not? 2 Corinthians 11:29 Such an one ought the priest to be, or, rather, not such only: for these are small things, and as nothing compared with what I am about to say. And what is this? I could wish, he says, that myself were accursed from Christ for my brethren, my kinsmen according to the flesh. Romans 9:3 If any one can utter such a speech, if any one has the soul which attains to such a prayer, he might justly be blamed if he took to flight: but if any one should lack such excellence as much as I do, he would deserve to be hated, not if he avoided the office, but if he accepted it. For if an election to a military dignity was the business in hand, and they who had the right of conferring the honor were to drag forward a brazier, or a shoemaker, or some such artisan, and entrust the army to his hands, I should not praise the wretched man if he did not take to flight, and do all in his power to avoid plunging into such manifest trouble. If, indeed, it be sufficient to bear the name of pastor, and to take the work in hand hap-hazard, and there be no danger in this, then let whoever pleases accuse me of vainglory; but if it behooves one who undertakes this care to have much understanding, and, before understanding, great grace from God, and uprightness of conduct, and purity of life and superhuman virtue, do not deprive me of forgiveness if I am unwilling to perish in vain without a cause.

Moreover, if someone in charge of a full-sized merchant ship, full of rowers and loaded with expensive cargo, were to put me at the helm and tell me to cross the Aegean or Tyrrhenian sea, I would refuse the proposal immediately. And if anyone asked me why, I would say: so that I would not sink the ship. Well, when the loss concerns material wealth and the danger extends only to bodily death, no one will blame those who exercise great caution. But when the shipwrecked are destined to fall, not into the ocean, but into the abyss of fire, and the death that awaits them is not the one that separates the soul from the body, but one that along with this sends it to eternal punishment, shall I face your anger and hatred because I did not plunge headlong into so great an evil?

Moreover, if any one in charge of a full-sized merchant ship, full of rowers, and laden with a costly freight, were to station me at the helm and bid me cross the Ægean or the Tyrrhene sea, I should recoil from the proposal at once: and if any one asked me why? I should say, Lest I should sink the ship. Well, where the loss concerns material wealth, and the danger extends only to bodily death, no one will blame those who exercise great prudence; but where the shipwrecked are destined to fall, not into the ocean, but into the abyss of fire, and the death which awaits them is not that which severs the soul from the body, but one which together with this dismisses it to eternal punishment, shall I incur your wrath and hate because I did not plunge headlong into so great an evil?

I beg and plead with you, do not do this. I know my own soul—how weak and small it is. I know how great this ministry is and how difficult the work is. The storms that trouble a priest's soul are more violent than the winds that stir up the sea.

8. Do not thus, I pray and beseech you. I know my own soul, how feeble and puny it is: I know the magnitude of this ministry, and the great difficulty of the work; for more stormy billows vex the soul of the priest than the gales which disturb the sea.

The first danger is the terrible rock of vainglory, more dangerous than the rock of the Sirens that storytellers describe in such amazing tales. Many people were able to sail past the Sirens and escape safely, but this rock is so dangerous to me that even now, when no necessity of any kind forces me toward that abyss, I cannot avoid the trap. If anyone were to give me this responsibility, it would be the same as tying my hands behind my back and handing me over to the wild beasts living on that rock to tear me apart day after day. Do you ask what those wild beasts are? They are anger, depression, envy, conflict, slander, accusations, lies, hypocrisy, scheming, rage against those who have done nothing wrong, delight at the improper actions of fellow ministers, grief at their success, love of praise, desire for honor (which above all else drives the human soul headlong to destruction), teachings designed to please people, servile flattery, disgraceful fawning, contempt for the poor, courting the rich, foolish and harmful honors, favors that bring danger to both those who give them and those who receive them, shameful fear fit only for the lowest slaves, the elimination of frank speech, great pretense of humility but the banishment of truth, the suppression of honest opinions and rebukes, or rather the excessive use of them against the poor, while against those who hold power no one dares to open his mouth.

9. And first of all is that most terrible rock of vainglory, more dangerous than that of the Sirens, of which the fable-mongers tell such marvellous tales: for many were able to sail past that and escape unscathed; but this is to me so dangerous that even now, when no necessity of any kind impels me into that abyss, I am unable to keep clear of the snare: but if any one were to commit this charge to me, it would be all the same as if he tied my hands behind my back, and delivered me to the wild beasts dwelling on that rock to rend me in pieces day by day. Do you ask what those wild beasts are? They are wrath, despondency, envy, strife, slanders, accusations, falsehood, hypocrisy, intrigues, anger against those who have done no harm, pleasure at the indecorous acts of fellow ministers, sorrow at their prosperity, love of praise, desire of honor (which indeed most of all drives the human soul headlong to perdition), doctrines devised to please, servile flatteries, ignoble fawning, contempt of the poor, paying court to the rich, senseless and mischievous honors, favors attended with danger both to those who offer and those who accept them, sordid fear suited only to the basest of slaves, the abolition of plain speaking, a great affectation of humility, but banishment of truth, the suppression of convictions and reproofs, or rather the excessive use of them against the poor, while against those who are invested with power no one dare open his lips.

For all these wild beasts, and more than these, are bred upon that rock of which I have spoken, and those whom they have once captured are inevitably dragged down into such a depth of servitude that even to please women they often do many things which are better left unmentioned. The divine law has indeed excluded women from the ministry, but they try to thrust themselves into it; and since they can accomplish nothing by themselves, they do everything through the agency of others. They have become invested with so much power that they can appoint or remove priests at their will. Things are in fact turned upside down, and the proverbial saying may be seen realized—the ruled lead the rulers. Would that it were men who do this instead of women, who have not received a commission to teach. Why do I say teach? For the blessed Paul did not allow them even to speak in the Church. But I have heard someone say that they have obtained such a large privilege of free speech as even to rebuke the prelates of the Churches and censure them more severely than masters do their own servants.

For all these wild beasts, and more than these, are bred upon that rock of which I have spoken, and those whom they have once captured are inevitably dragged down into such a depth of servitude that even to please women they often do many things which it is well not to mention. The divine law indeed has excluded women from the ministry, but they endeavor to thrust themselves into it; and since they can effect nothing of themselves, they do all through the agency of others; and they have become invested with so much power that they can appoint or eject priests at their will: things in fact are turned upside down, and the proverbial saying may be seen realized — The ruled lead the rulers: and would that it were men who do this instead of women, who have not received a commission to teach. Why do I say teach? For the blessed Paul did not suffer them even to speak in the Church. But I have heard some one say that they have obtained such a large privilege of free speech, as even to rebuke the prelates of the Churches, and censure them more severely than masters do their own domestics.

No one should think that I am making these charges against everyone. There are some—indeed many—who are above these entanglements and outnumber those who have been caught by them. Nor would I blame the priesthood itself for these evils. Far from it—such an idea would be madness. People with understanding do not say that the sword is to blame for murder, or wine for drunkenness, or strength for violence, or courage for recklessness. Instead, they blame those who misuse the gifts God has given them, and they punish them accordingly. In fact, the priesthood itself has every right to accuse us if we do not handle it properly. It is not the cause of the evils I have mentioned, but we are—we who, as far as we are able, have defiled it with so many pollutions by entrusting it to ordinary men who readily accept what is offered to them without first gaining knowledge of their own souls or considering the seriousness of the office. When these men enter the work, they are blinded by inexperience and overwhelm with countless evils the people committed to their care. This is the very thing that nearly happened in my case, had not God quickly delivered me from those dangers, mercifully sparing his Church and my own soul. For tell me, where do you think such great troubles in the Churches come from? I believe the only source is the thoughtless and random way in which prelates are chosen and appointed. The head ought to be the strongest part, so that it can regulate and control the harmful influences rising from the rest of the body below. But when the head happens to be weak in itself and unable to repel those destructive attacks, it becomes even weaker than it really is and ruins the rest of the body as well. To prevent this from happening to me, God kept me in the position of the feet, which was the rank originally assigned to me. There are many other qualities, Basil, besides those I have already mentioned, that the priest ought to have but which I do not possess. Above all, there is this one: his soul ought to be completely purged of any desire for the office. If he happens to have a natural inclination for this dignity, as soon as he attains it a stronger flame is kindled, and the man, being completely captivated, will endure countless evils to keep a secure hold on it—even resorting to flattery, submitting to something base and disgraceful, or spending large sums of money. I will not now speak of the murders with which some have filled the Churches, or the devastation they have brought upon cities while contending for this dignity, lest some people think what I say is unbelievable. But I believe one ought to exercise so much caution in this matter as to avoid the burden of the office, and when one has entered it, not to wait for the judgment of others if any fault is committed that warrants deposition, but to anticipate it by removing oneself from the dignity. For in this way one might probably obtain mercy from God. But to cling to it despite what is proper is to deprive oneself of all forgiveness, or rather to kindle the wrath of God by adding a second error more offensive than the first.

10. And let not any one suppose that I subject all to the aforesaid charges: for there are some, yea many, who are superior to these entanglements, and exceed in number those who have been caught by them. Nor would I indeed make the priesthood responsible for these evils: far be such madness from me. For men of understanding do not say that the sword is to blame for murder, nor wine for drunkenness, nor strength for outrage, nor courage for foolhardiness, but they lay the blame on those who make an improper use of the gifts which have been bestowed upon them by God, and punish them accordingly. Certainly, at least, the priesthood may justly accuse us if we do not rightly handle it. For it is not itself a cause of the evils already mentioned, but we, who as far as lies in our power have defiled it with so many pollutions, by entrusting it to commonplace men who readily accept what is offered them, without having first acquired a knowledge of their own souls, or considered the gravity of the office, and when they have entered on the work, being blinded by inexperience, overwhelm with innumerable evils the people who have been committed to their care. This is the very thing which was very nearly happening in my case, had not God speedily delivered me from those dangers, mercifully sparing his Church and my own soul. For, tell me, whence do you think such great troubles are generated in the Churches? I, for my part, believe the only source of them to be the inconsiderate and random way in which prelates are chosen and appointed. For the head ought to be the strongest part, that it may be able to regulate and control the evil exhalations which arise from the rest of the body below; but when it happens to be weak in itself, and unable to repel those pestiferous attacks, it becomes feebler itself than it really is, and ruins the rest of the body as well. And to prevent this now coming to pass, God kept me in the position of the feet, which was the rank originally assigned to me. For there are very many other qualities, Basil, besides those already mentioned, which the priest ought to have, but which I do not possess; and, above all, this one:– his soul ought to be thoroughly purged from any lust after the office: for if he happens to have a natural inclination for this dignity, as soon as he attains it a stronger flame is kindled, and the man being taken completely captive will endure innumerable evils in order to keep a secure hold upon it, even to the extent of using flattery, or submitting to something base and ignoble, or expending large sums of money. For I will not now speak of the murders with which some have filled the Churches, or the desolation which they have brought upon cities in contending for the dignity, lest some persons should think what I say incredible. But I am of opinion one ought to exercise so much caution in the matter, as to shun the burden of the office, and when one has entered upon it, not to wait for the judgment of others should any fault be committed which warrants deposition, but to anticipate it by ejecting oneself from the dignity; for thus one might probably win mercy for himself from God: but to cling to it in defiance of propriety is to deprive oneself of all forgiveness, or rather to kindle the wrath of God, by adding a second error more offensive than the first.

But no one will always endure the strain, for the eager desire for this honor is truly fearful. In saying this I am not disagreeing with the blessed Paul, but in complete harmony with his words. For what does he say? "If anyone desires the office of a bishop, he desires a good work." Now I have not said that it is a terrible thing to desire the work, but only the authority and power. I think one ought to expel this desire from the soul with all possible earnestness, not allowing it from the outset to be possessed by such a feeling, so that one may be able to do everything with freedom. For whoever does not desire to be seen possessing this authority does not fear being removed from it, and not fearing this will be able to do everything with the freedom that befits Christian people. But those who fear and tremble lest they be removed undergo a bitter slavery, filled with all kinds of evils, and are often compelled to offend against both God and man. Now the soul ought not to be affected in this way. But just as in warfare we see noble-spirited soldiers fight willingly and fall bravely, so those who have attained this stewardship should be content to be consecrated to the dignity or removed from it, as befits Christian people, knowing that removal of this kind brings no less reward than the discharge of the office. For when anyone suffers anything of this kind in order to avoid submitting to something unbecoming or unworthy of this dignity, he procures punishment for those who wrongfully remove him and a greater reward for himself. "Blessed are you," says our Lord, "when men shall revile you and persecute you, and shall say all manner of evil against you falsely for my sake; rejoice and be exceedingly glad, for great is your reward in Heaven." And this is indeed the case when anyone is expelled by those of his own rank either on account of envy, with a view to gaining favor with others, or through hatred, or from any other wrong motive. But when it is the lot of anyone to experience this treatment at the hand of opponents, I do not think a word is needed to prove what great gain they confer upon him by their wickedness.

11. But no one will always endure the strain; for fearful, truly fearful is the eager desire after this honor. And in saying this I am not in opposition to the blessed Paul, but in complete harmony with his words. For what says he? If any man desires the office of a bishop, he desires a good work. 1 Timothy 3:1 Now I have not said that it is a terrible thing to desire the work, but only the authority and power. And this desire I think one ought to expel from the soul with all possible earnestness, not permitting it at the outset to be possessed by such a feeling, so that one may be able to do everything with freedom. For he who does not desire to be exhibited in possession of this authority, does not fear to be deposed from it, and not fearing this will be able to do everything with the freedom which becomes Christian men: whereas they who fear and tremble lest they should be deposed undergo a bitter servitude, filled with all kinds of evils, and are often compelled to offend against both God and man. Now the soul ought not to be affected in this way; but as in warfare we see those soldiers who are noble-spirited fight willingly and fall bravely, so they who have attained to this stewardship should be contented to be consecrated to the dignity or removed from it, as becomes Christian men, knowing that deposition of this kind brings its reward no less than the discharge of the office. For when any one suffers anything of this kind, in order to avoid submitting to something which is unbecoming or unworthy of this dignity, he procures punishment for those who wrongfully depose him, and a greater reward for himself. Blessed, says our Lord, are you when men shall revile you and persecute you, and shall say all manner of evil against you falsely for my sake; rejoice and be exceeding glad, for great is your reward in Heaven. Matthew 5:1 And this, indeed, is the case when any one is expelled by those of his own rank either on account of envy, with a view to the favor of others, or through hatred, or from any other wrong motive: but when it is the lot of any one to experience this treatment at the hand of opponents, I do not think a word is needed to prove what great gain they confer upon him by their wickedness.

We need, then, to be watchful on all fronts and to search carefully lest any spark of this desire should be secretly smoldering somewhere. For it is much to be hoped that those who are originally free from this passion should also be able to avoid it when they have come into this office. But if anyone, before he obtains the honor, cherishes within himself this terrible and savage monster, it is impossible to say into what a furnace he will throw himself after he has attained it. Now I possessed this desire to a high degree (and do not suppose that I would ever tell you something untrue in speaking against myself), and this, combined with other reasons, alarmed me greatly and induced me to flee. For just as lovers of another person, as long as they are permitted to be near the objects of their affection, suffer more severe torment from their passion, but when they remove themselves as far as possible from those objects of desire, they drive away the frenzy, so it is when those who desire this dignity are near it—the evil becomes intolerable. But when they cease to hope for it, the desire is extinguished together with the expectation.

It behooves us, then, to be on the watch on all sides, and to make a careful search lest any spark of this desire should be secretly smouldering somewhere. For it is much to be wished that those who are originally free from this passion, should also be able to avoid it when they have lighted upon this office. But if any one, before he obtains the honor, cherishes in himself this terrible and savage monster, it is impossible to say into what a furnace he will fling himself after he has attained it. Now I possessed this desire in a high degree (and do not suppose that I would ever tell you what was untrue in self-disparagement): and this, combined with other reasons, alarmed me not a little, and induced me to take flight. For just as lovers of the human person, as long as they are permitted to be near the objects of their affection, suffer more severe torment from their passion, but when they remove as far as possible from these objects of desire, they drive away the frenzy: even so when those who desire this dignity are near it, the evil becomes intolerable: but when they cease to hope for it, the desire is extinguished together with the expectation.

This single reason, then, is no small matter. By itself it would have been enough to keep me away from this position. But as things stand, I must add another reason no less serious than the first. What is it? A priest ought to be clear-minded, sharp in judgment, and equipped with countless eyes looking in every direction, since he does not live for himself alone but for such a great multitude. But that I am sluggish and lazy, scarcely able to work out my own salvation—even you yourself would admit this, you who out of love for me are especially eager to hide my faults. Do not talk to me in this matter about fasting, keeping vigil, sleeping on the ground, or other harsh bodily disciplines. You know how lacking I am in these things. And even if I had practiced them carefully, they could not, given my present sluggishness, have been of any use to me for this office of authority. Such things might be of great benefit to a man shut up in a cell and concerned only with his own affairs. But when a man is divided among such a great multitude and enters separately into the private concerns of those under his care, what real help can be given for their improvement unless he possesses a strong and exceptionally vigorous character?

12. This single motive then is no slight one: and even taken by itself it would have sufficed to deter me from this dignity: but, as it is, another must be added not less than the former. And what is this? A priest ought to be sober minded, and penetrating in discernment, and possessed of innumerable eyes in every direction, as one who lives not for himself alone but for so great a multitude. But that I am sluggish and slack, and scarcely able to bring about my own salvation, even you yourself would admit, who out of love to me art especially eager to conceal my faults. Talk not to me in this connection of fasting, and watching, or sleeping on the ground, and other hard discipline of the body: for you know how defective I am in these matters: and even if they had been carefully practised by me they could not with my present sluggishness have been of any service to me with a view to this post of authority. Such things might be of great service to a man who was shut up in a cell, and caring only for his own concerns: but when a man is divided among so great a multitude, and enters separately into the private cares of those who are under his direction, what appreciable help can be given to their improvement unless he possesses a robust and exceedingly vigorous character?

Don't be surprised if, along with this kind of endurance, I look for another test of strength in the soul. We see that for many people—especially those who are naturally tough or who have been raised this way from childhood, and for many others as well—it's not particularly difficult to be indifferent to food and drink and a soft bed. Physical discipline and habit soften the harshness of these difficult practices. But insult, abuse, coarse language, and mockery from inferiors—whether spoken out of malice or with some justification—and criticism that is pointless and idle, spoken by both rulers and the ruled: this is what few can endure, in fact only one or two here and there. You can see men who are strong in the former practices completely undone by these things, becoming more furious than the most savage beasts. Now we should especially exclude such men from the priesthood. For if a bishop didn't avoid food or went without shoes, no harm would come to the common interests of the Church. But a furious temper causes great disasters both to the person who has it and to his neighbors. And there is no divine threat against those who fail to do the things I mentioned earlier, but hell and hellfire are threatened against those who are angry without a cause. As then the lover of vainglory, when he takes on the government of many people, supplies additional fuel to the fire, so he who by himself or in the company of a few is unable to control his anger but is readily carried away by it—should he be entrusted with the direction of a whole multitude—would be like some wild beast goaded on all sides by countless tormentors, never able to live in tranquility himself, and would cause incalculable harm to those who have been committed to his charge.

13. And do not be surprised if, in connection with such endurance, I seek another test of fortitude in the soul. For to be indifferent to food and drink and a soft bed, we see is to many no hard task, especially at least to such as are of a rough habit of life and have been brought up in this way from early youth, and to many others also; bodily discipline and custom softening the severity of these laborious practices: but insult, and abuse, and coarse language, and gibes from inferiors, whether wantonly or justly uttered, and rebukes vainly and idly spoken both by rulers and the ruled — this is what few can bear, in fact only one or two here and there; and one may see men, who are strong in the former exercises, so completely upset by these things, as to become more furious than the most savage beasts. Now such men especially we should exclude from the precincts of the priesthood. For if a prelate did not loathe food, or go barefoot, no harm would be done to the common interests of the Church; but a furious temper causes great disasters both to him who possesses it, and to his neighbours. And there is no divine threat against those who fail to do the things referred to, but hell and hell-fire are threatened against those who are angry without a cause. Matthew 5:22 As then the lover of vainglory, when he takes upon him the government of numbers, supplies additional fuel to the fire, so he who by himself, or in the company of a few, is unable to control his anger, but readily carried away by it, should he be entrusted with the direction of a whole multitude, like some wild beast goaded on all sides by countless tormentors, would never be able to live in tranquillity himself, and would cause incalculable mischief to those who have been committed to his charge.

Nothing clouds the purity of reason and the clarity of mental vision as much as undisciplined anger rushing along with violent force. For anger, as someone says, destroys even the prudent. When the soul's eye is darkened as if in a nighttime battle, it cannot distinguish friends from enemies or what is honorable from what is unworthy, but treats them all the same way. It will even readily endure harm in order to satisfy the soul's pleasure. For the fire of anger is a kind of pleasure and tyrannizes over the soul more harshly than pleasure itself, completely upsetting its healthy order. It easily drives people to arrogance, inappropriate hostilities, and irrational hatred, and continually makes them ready to commit reckless and empty offenses. It forces them to say and do many other such things, as the soul is swept along by the rush of passion and has nothing to grip onto so it can resist such a powerful impulse.

14. For nothing clouds the purity of the reason, and the perspicuity of the mental vision so much as undisciplined wrath, rushing along with violent impetuosity. For wrath, says one, destroys even the prudent. For the eye of the soul being darkened as in some nocturnal battle is not able to distinguish friends from foes, nor the honorable from the unworthy, but handles them all in turn in the same way; even if some harm must be suffered, readily enduring everything, in order to satisfy the pleasure of the soul. For the fire of wrath is a kind of pleasure, and tyrannizes over the soul more harshly than pleasure, completely upsetting its healthy organization. For it easily impels men to arrogance, and unseasonable enmities, and unreasonable hatred, and it continually makes them ready to commit wanton and vain offenses; and forces them to say and do many other things of that kind, the soul being swept along by the rush of passion, and having nothing on which to fasten its strength and resist so great an impulse.

Basil: I will not put up with this false modesty of yours any longer, for who does not know how far you are from this weakness?

Basil: I will not endure this irony of yours any longer: for who knows not how far removed you are from this infirmity?

Why then, my good friend, do you want to bring me close to the fire and provoke the wild beast when he is calm? Don't you realize that I have reached this condition not through any natural virtue, but through my love of solitude? When someone with my disposition stays content by himself, or only spends time with one or two friends, he can escape the fire that comes from this passion. But if he plunges into the abyss of all these responsibilities, he cannot. Then he drags not only himself but many others with him to the edge of destruction, and makes them less concerned about showing gentleness. The mass of people under authority generally look at the behavior of their leaders as a kind of model and pattern themselves after them. How could anyone stop their fury when he himself is swelling with rage? Who among the crowd would immediately want to become moderate when he sees his leader is irritable? It is completely impossible for the faults of priests to be hidden—even minor ones quickly become obvious. An athlete who stays at home and fights with no one can hide his weakness, even if it is very great. But when he strips for the contest, he is easily exposed. In the same way, for some who live this private and inactive life, their isolation serves as a veil to hide their faults. But when they are brought into public, they are forced to remove this cloak of seclusion and lay bare their souls to everyone through their visible actions. Just as their good deeds benefit many by provoking them to equal zeal, so their shortcomings make people more indifferent to practicing virtue and encourage them toward laziness in striving for what is excellent. Therefore his soul ought to shine with beauty on every side, so it can gladden and enlighten the souls of those who see it. The faults of ordinary people, being committed as it were in the dark, ruin only those who practice them. But the errors of someone in a prominent position, known to many, inflict a common injury on everyone, making those who have fallen more lazy in their efforts for good and driving to despair those who want to be careful. And apart from these things, the faults of insignificant people, even if they are exposed, cause no real injury to anyone. But those who occupy the highest seat of honor are in the first place clearly visible to all, and if they err in the smallest matters, these trifles seem great to others. Everyone measures the sin not by the size of the offense, but by the rank of the offender. Thus the priest ought to be protected on all sides by a kind of adamantine armor, by intense earnestness and constant watchfulness over his way of life, lest someone discovering an exposed and unguarded spot should inflict a deadly wound. For all who surround him are ready to strike and overthrow him—not only enemies and adversaries, but many even of those who claim to be friends.

Chrysostom: Why then, my good friend, do you wish to bring me near the pyre, and to provoke the wild beast when he is tranquil? Are you not aware that I have achieved this condition, not by any innate virtue, but by my love of retirement? And that when one who is so constituted remains contented by himself, or only associates with one or two friends, he is able to escape the fire which arises from this passion, but not if he has plunged into the abyss of all these cares? For then he drags not only himself but many others with him to the brink of destruction, and renders them more indifferent to all consideration for mildness. For the mass of people under government are generally inclined to regard the manners of those who govern as a kind of model type, and to assimilate themselves to them. How then could any one put a stop to their fury when he is swelling himself with rage? And who among the multitude would straightway desire to become moderate when he sees the ruler irritable? For it is quite impossible for the defects of priests to be concealed, but even trifling ones speedily become manifest. So an athlete, as long as he remains at home, and contends with no one, can dissemble his weakness even if it be very great, but when he strips for the contest he is easily detected. And thus for some who live this private and inactive life, their isolation serves as a veil to hide their defects; but when they have been brought into public they are compelled to divest themselves of this mantle of seclusion, and to lay bare their souls to all through their visible movements. As therefore their right deeds profit many, by provoking them to equal zeal, so their shortcomings make men more indifferent to the practice of virtue, and encourage them to indolence in their endeavours after what is excellent. Wherefore his soul ought to gleam with beauty on every side, that it may be able to gladden and to enlighten the souls of those who behold it. For the faults of ordinary men, being committed as it were in the dark, ruin only those who practise them: but the errors of a man in a conspicuous position, and known to many, inflicts a common injury upon all, rendering those who have fallen more supine in their efforts for good, and driving to desperation those who wish to take heed to themselves. And apart from these things, the faults of insignificant men, even if they are exposed, inflict no injury worth speaking of upon any one: but they who occupy the highest seat of honor are in the first place plainly visible to all, and if they err in the smallest matters these trifles seem great to others: for all men measure the sin, not by the magnitude of the offense, but by the rank of the offender. Thus the priest ought to be protected on all sides by a kind of adamantine armour, by intense earnestness, and perpetual watchfulness concerning his manner of life, lest some one discovering an exposed and neglected spot should inflict a deadly wound: for all who surround him are ready to smite and overthrow him: not enemies only and adversaries, but many even of those who profess friendship.

The souls of men chosen for the priesthood, then, ought to be equipped with the same kind of power that the grace of God gave to the bodies of those saints who were thrown into the Babylonian furnace. Wood and pitch and tow are not the fuel of this fire, but things far more terrible. For it is not a material fire they face, but the all-consuming flame of envy that surrounds them, rising up on every side, attacking them and testing their life far more severely than that fire tested the bodies of those young men. Whenever it finds even the smallest trace of stubble, it quickly seizes upon it. This weak part it completely destroys, but all the rest of the structure, even if it shines brighter than the sun's rays, is scorched and blackened by the smoke. For as long as the priest's life is well ordered in every respect, it cannot be harmed by plots. But if he happens to overlook some small thing, as is natural for a human being crossing the treacherous ocean of this life, none of his other good deeds helps him escape the mouths of his accusers. That one little mistake overshadows everything else. And everyone is ready to judge the priest as if he were not clothed with flesh or did not inherit human nature, but were like an angel, free from every kind of weakness. And just as everyone fears and flatters a tyrant as long as he is strong, because they cannot overthrow him, but when they see his affairs going badly, those who were lately his friends abandon their pretended respect and suddenly become his enemies and opponents, discovering all his weak points, attacking him, and removing him from power—so it is also with priests. Those who honored him and courted his favor a short time before, while he was strong, as soon as they find some little handle, eagerly prepare to remove him—not merely as a tyrant, but as something far more dreadful than that. And just as the tyrant fears his bodyguards, so the priest dreads most of all his neighbors and fellow ministers. For no one else covets his position so much or knows his affairs so well as these. And if anything happens, being close at hand, they notice it before others, and even if they slander him, they can easily be believed, and by exaggerating trifles, they take their victim captive. For the apostolic saying is reversed: whether one member suffers, all the members suffer with it, or one member is honored, all the members rejoice with it—unless a man is able by his great discretion to stand his ground against everything.

The souls therefore of men elected to the priesthood ought to be endued with such power as the grace of God bestowed on the bodies of those saints who were cast into the Babylonian furnace. Daniel 3 Faggot and pitch and tow are not the fuel of this fire, but things far more dreadful: for it is no material fire to which they are subjected, but the all-devouring flame of envy encompasses them, rising up on every side, and assailing them, and putting their life to a more searching test than the fire then was to the bodies of those young men. When then it finds a little trace of stubble, it speedily fastens upon it; and this unsound part it entirely consumes, but all the rest of the fabric, even if it be brighter than the sunbeams, is scorched and blackened by the smoke. For as long as the life of the priest is well regulated in every direction, it is invulnerable to plots; but if he happens to overlook some trifle, as is natural in a human being, traversing the treacherous ocean of this life, none of his other good deeds are of any avail in enabling him to escape the mouths of his accusers; but that little blunder overshadows all the rest. And all men are ready to pass judgment on the priest as if he was not a being clothed with flesh, or one who inherited a human nature, but like an angel, and emancipated from every species of infirmity. And just as all men fear and flatter a tyrant as long as he is strong, because they cannot put him down, but when they see his affairs going adversely, those who were his friends a short time before abandon their hypocritical respect, and suddenly become his enemies and antagonists, and having discovered all his weak points, make an attack upon him, and depose him from the government; so is it also in the case of priests. Those who honored him and paid court to him a short time before, while he was strong, as soon as they have found some little handle eagerly prepare to depose him, not as a tyrant only, but something far more dreadful than that. And as the tyrant fears his body guards, so also does the priest dread most of all his neighbours and fellow-ministers. For no others covet his dignity so much, or know his affairs so well as these; and if anything occurs, being near at hand, they perceive it before others, and even if they slander him, can easily command belief, and, by magnifying trifles, take their victim captive. For the apostolic saying is reversed, whether one member suffer, all the members suffer with it; or one member be honored, all the members rejoice with it; 1 Corinthians 12:26 unless indeed a man should be able by his great discretion to stand his ground against everything.

Are you really planning to send me out into such a great war? And did you think my soul would be equal to a contest so varied in character and form? Where did you learn this, and from whom? If God revealed this to you, show me the oracle, and I will obey. But if you cannot, and you're forming your judgment based only on human opinion, please free yourself from this delusion. For in matters concerning my own affairs, it is fairer to trust me than others, since no one knows the things of a person except the spirit of that person which is in him. I trust I have now convinced you through these remarks, if not before, that I would have made myself and those who chose me look ridiculous had I accepted this office, and I would have returned to this way of life in which I now am, but with great loss. For it is not only malice, but something much stronger—the lust for this dignity—that usually arms many people against whoever holds it. And just as greedy children are burdened by the old age of their parents, so some of these people, when they see the priestly office held by anyone for an extended time—since it would be wicked to destroy him—hurry to depose him from it, all of them desiring to take his place, and each one expecting that the dignity will be transferred to himself.

Are you then for sending me forth into so great a warfare? And did you think that my soul would be equal to a contest so various in character and shape? Whence did you learn this, and from whom? If God certified this to you, show me the oracle, and I obey; but if you cannot, and form your judgment from human opinion only, please to set yourself free from this delusion. For in what concerns my own affairs it is fairer to trust me than others; inasmuch as no man knows the things of a man, save the spirit of man which is in him. 1 Corinthians 2:11 That I should have made myself and my electors ridiculous, had I accepted this office, and should with great loss have returned to this condition of life in which I now am, I trust I have now convinced you by these remarks, if not before. For not malice only, but something much stronger — the lust after this dignity — is wont to arm many against one who possesses it. And just as avaricious children are oppressed by the old age of their parents, so some of these, when they see the priestly office held by any one for a protracted time — since it would be wickedness to destroy him — hasten to depose him from it, being all desirous to take his place, and each expecting that the dignity will be transferred to himself.

Would you like me to show you yet another aspect of this struggle, filled with countless dangers? Come, then, and look at the public festivals when elections to church offices are usually held, and you will see the priest attacked with accusations as numerous as the people he governs. For all who have the privilege of conferring the honor are divided into many factions, and you can never find the council of elders in agreement with each other or about the man who has won the position of leadership. Each stands apart from the others, one preferring this person, another that. The reason is that they do not all look to the one thing that ought to be the only consideration: excellence of character. Instead, other qualifications are put forward as recommending someone for this honor. For instance, of one it is said, let him be elected because he belongs to a distinguished family; of another, because he is very wealthy and would not need to be supported from the Church's revenues; of a third, because he has come over from the enemy's camp. One is eager to give preference to a man who is on friendly terms with himself, another to the man who is related to him by birth, a third to the flatterer, but no one will look to the man who is truly qualified or examine his character. Now I am so far from thinking these things are reliable measures of a man's fitness for the priesthood that even if someone displayed great piety, which is no small help in carrying out that office, I would not dare to approve him on that basis alone, unless he also combined good abilities with his piety. For I know many men who have practiced constant self-discipline and worn themselves out with fasting, who, as long as they were allowed to be alone and attend to their own affairs, were acceptable to God and day by day made considerable progress in this kind of learning. But as soon as they entered public life and were required to correct the ignorance of the multitude, some of them proved from the beginning incompetent for so great a task, and others, when forced to continue in it, abandoned their former strict way of living, and thus inflicted great harm on themselves without benefiting others at all. And if someone spent his entire time in the lowest rank of ministry and reached extreme old age, I would not, merely out of respect for his years, promote him to the higher office. For what if, after reaching that stage of life, he should still remain unfit for the office? And I say this now, not because I wish to dishonor gray hair, nor because I am laying down a law absolutely excluding from this authority those who come from the monastic circle (for there are many instances of those who came from that group who have distinguished themselves brilliantly in this office). But the point I am eager to prove is that if neither piety by itself nor advanced age would be enough to show that a man who obtained the priesthood truly deserved it, the reasons mentioned earlier would hardly accomplish this. There are also men who put forward other pretexts even more absurd. For some are enrolled in the clergy so that they may not join the opposition, and others because of their evil disposition, lest they should do great harm if they are passed over. Could anything be more contrary to proper order than this? That bad men, burdened with wickedness, should be courted for the very things for which they ought to be punished, and ascend to the priestly office because of things for which they ought to be barred from the very threshold of the Church. Tell me, then, shall we look any further for the cause of God's anger, when we allow things so holy and awesome to be defiled by men who are either wicked or worthless? For when some men are entrusted with the administration of things that are not at all suitable to them, and others with things that exceed their natural capacity, they make the condition of the Church like that of Euripus.

15. Would you like me to show you yet another phase of this strife, charged with innumerable dangers? Come, then, and take a peep at the public festivals when it is generally the custom for elections to be made to ecclesiastical dignities, and you will then see the priest assailed with accusations as numerous as the people whom he rules. For all who have the privilege of conferring the honor are then split into many parties; and one can never find the council of elders of one mind with each other, or about the man who has won the prelacy; but each stands apart from the others, one preferring this man, another that. Now the reason is that they do not all look to one thing, which ought to be the only object kept in view, the excellence of the character; but other qualifications are alleged as recommending to this honor; for instance, of one it is said, let him be elected because he belongs to an illustrious family, of another because he is possessed of great wealth, and would not need to be supported out of the revenues of the Church, of a third because he has come over from the camp of the adversary; one is eager to give the preference to a man who is on terms of intimacy with himself, another to the man who is related to him by birth, a third to the flatterer, but no one will look to the man who is really qualified, or make some test of his character. Now I am so far from thinking these things trustworthy criteria of a man's fitness for the priesthood, that even if any one manifested great piety, which is no small help in the discharge of that office, I should not venture to approve him on that account alone, unless he happened to combine good abilities with his piety. For I know many men who have exercised perpetual restraint upon themselves, and consumed themselves with fastings, who, as long as they were suffered to be alone, and attend to their own concerns, have been acceptable to God, and day by day have made no small addition to this kind of learning; but as soon as they entered public life, and were compelled to correct the ignorance of the multitude, have, some of them, proved from the outset incompetent for so great a task, and others when forced to persevere in it, have abandoned their former strict way of living, and thus inflicted great injury on themselves without profiting others at all. And if any one spent his whole time in the lowest rank of the ministry, and reached extreme old age, I would not, merely out of reverence for his years, promote him to the higher dignity; for what if, after arriving at that time of life, he should still remain unfit for the office? And I say this now, not as wishing to dishonor the grey head, nor as laying down a law absolutely to exclude from this authority those who come from the monastic circle (for there are instances of many who issued from that body, having shone conspicuously in this dignity); but the point which I am anxious to prove is, that if neither piety of itself, nor advanced age, would suffice to show that a man who had obtained the priesthood really deserved it, the reasons formerly alleged would scarcely effect this. There are also men who bring forward other pretexts yet more absurd; for some are enrolled in the ranks of the clergy, that they may not range themselves among opponents, and others on account of their evil disposition, lest they should do great mischief if they are overlooked. Could anything be more contrary to right rule than this? That bad men, laden with iniquity, should be courted on account of those things for which they ought to be punished, and ascend to the priestly dignity on account of things for which they ought to be debarred from the very threshold of the Church. Tell me, then, shall we seek any further the cause of God's wrath, when we expose things so holy and awful to be defiled by men who are either wicked or worthless? For when some men are entrusted with the administration of things which are not at all suitable to them, and others of things which exceed their natural power, they make the condition of the Church like that of Euripus.

Now I used to make fun of secular rulers because when distributing their honors they are not guided by considerations of moral excellence, but by wealth, seniority, and human social standing. But when I heard that this kind of foolishness had forced its way into our affairs as well, I no longer regarded their conduct as so terrible. For what wonder is it that worldly people, who love the praise of the crowd and do everything for the sake of profit, should commit these sins, when those who claim at least to be free from all these influences are no better than they are? Although they are engaged in a contest for heavenly things, they act as if the question being decided concerns acres of land or something else of that kind. For they take ordinary men on a whim and set them to preside over those things for the sake of which the only begotten Son of God did not refuse to empty Himself of His glory and become man, and take the form of a servant, and be spat upon, and struck, and die a shameful death in the flesh. Nor do they stop even here, but add to these offenses others still more monstrous. For not only do they elect unworthy men, but they actually expel those who are well qualified. As if it were necessary to destroy the safety of the Church on both sides, or as if the former provocation were not sufficient to kindle the wrath of God, they have devised yet another no less destructive. For I consider it as wicked to expel useful men as to force in useless ones. And this in fact takes place, so that the flock of Christ is unable to find consolation in any direction or breathe freely. Now do not such deeds deserve to be punished by ten thousand thunderbolts and a hell-fire hotter than that with which we are threatened in Holy Scripture? Yet these monstrous evils are tolerated by Him who does not will the death of a sinner, that he may be converted and live. And how can one sufficiently marvel at His lovingkindness and be amazed at His mercy? Those who belong to Christ destroy the property of Christ more than enemies and adversaries do, yet the good Lord still deals gently with them and calls them to repentance. Glory be to You, O Lord! Glory to You! How vast is the depth of Your lovingkindness! How great the riches of Your forbearance! Men who on account of Your name have risen from insignificance and obscurity to positions of honor and distinction use the honor they enjoy against Him who has given it. They commit deeds of outrageous audacity and insult holy things, rejecting and expelling men of zeal so that the wicked may ruin everything at their pleasure in complete security and with the utmost fearlessness. And if you would know the causes of this dreadful evil, you will find that they are similar to those that were mentioned before. For they have one root and mother, so to speak—namely, envy—but this is manifested in several different forms. For we are told that one is to be struck from the list of candidates because he is young, another because he does not know how to flatter, a third because he has offended such and such a person, a fourth lest such and such a man should be pained at seeing one whom he has put forward rejected and this man elected, a fifth because he is kind and gentle, a sixth because he is formidable to the sinful, a seventh for some other similar reason. For they are never at a loss to find as many pretexts as they want, and can even make the abundance of a man's wealth an objection when they have no other. Indeed they would be capable of discovering as many other reasons as they wish why a man ought not to be brought suddenly to this honor but gently and gradually. And here I should like to ask the question, What then is the prelate to do who has to contend with such blasts? How shall he hold his ground against such waves? How shall he repel all these assaults?

Now formerly I used to deride secular rulers, because in the distribution of their honors they are not guided by considerations of moral excellence, but of wealth, and seniority, and human distinction; but when I heard that this kind of folly had forced its way into our affairs also, I no longer regarded their conduct as so atrocious. For what wonder is it that worldly men, who love the praise of the multitude, and do everything for the sake of gain, should commit these sins, when those who affect at least to be free from all these influences are in no wise better disposed than they, but although engaged in a contest for heavenly things, act as if the question submitted for decision was one which concerned acres of land, or something else of that kind? For they take commonplace men off-hand, and set them to preside over those things, for the sake of which the only begotten Son of God did not refuse to empty Himself of His glory and become man, and take the form of a servant, and be spat upon, and buffeted, and die a death of reproach in the flesh. Nor do they stop even here, but add to these offenses others still more monstrous; for not only do they elect unworthy men, but actually expel those who are well qualified. As if it were necessary to ruin the safety of the Church on both sides, or as if the former provocation were not sufficient to kindle the wrath of God, they have contrived yet another not less pernicious. For I consider it as atrocious to expel the useful men as to force in the useless. And this in fact takes place, so that the flock of Christ is unable to find consolation in any direction, or draw its breath freely. Now do not such deeds deserve to be punished by ten thousand thunder-bolts, and a hell-fire hotter than that with which we are threatened [in Holy Scripture]? Yet these monstrous evils are borne with by Him who wills not the death of a sinner, that he may be converted and live. And how can one sufficiently marvel at His lovingkindness, and be amazed at His mercy? They who belong to Christ destroy the property of Christ more than enemies and adversaries, yet the good Lord still deals gently with them, and calls them to repentance. Glory be to You, O Lord! Glory to You! How vast is the depth of Your lovingkindness! How great the riches of Your forbearance! Men who on account of Your name have risen from insignificance and obscurity to positions of honor and distinction, use the honor they enjoy against Him who has bestowed it, do deeds of outrageous audacity, and insult holy things, rejecting and expelling men of zeal in order that the wicked may ruin everything at their pleasure in much security, and with the utmost fearlessness. And if you would know the causes of this dreadful evil, you will find that they are similar to those which were mentioned before; for they have one root and mother, so to say — namely, envy; but this is manifested in several different forms. For one we are told is to be struck out of the list of candidates, because he is young; another because he does not know how to flatter; a third because he has offended such and such a person; a fourth lest such and such a man should be pained at seeing one whom he has presented rejected, and this man elected; a fifth because he is kind and gentle; a sixth because he is formidable to the sinful; a seventh for some other like reason; for they are at no loss to find as many pretexts as they want, and can even make the abundance of a man's wealth an objection when they have no other. Indeed they would be capable of discovering other reasons, as many as they wish, why a man ought not to be brought suddenly to this honor, but gently and gradually. And here I should like to ask the question, What, then, is the prelate to do, who has to contend with such blasts? How shall he hold his ground against such billows? How shall he repel all these assaults?

For if he manages the business according to upright principles, all those who are enemies and adversaries both to him and to the candidates do everything with an eye to causing conflict, provoking daily strife and heaping endless scorn upon the candidates, until they have either gotten them struck off the list or introduced their own favorites. In fact, it is just as if some ship's pilot had pirates sailing with him on his vessel, constantly plotting every hour against him and the sailors and marines. And if he should choose to curry favor with such men rather than secure his own salvation, accepting unworthy candidates, he will have God as his enemy in their place—and what could be more dreadful than that? And yet his relations with them will be more difficult than before, since they will all join forces with each other and thereby become more powerful than they were. For just as when fierce winds blowing from opposite directions clash with one another, the ocean, previously calm, suddenly becomes violent and raises its crested waves, destroying those who are sailing on it, so also when the Church has admitted corrupt men, its once peaceful surface is covered with rough surf and strewn with shipwrecks.

For if he manages the business upon upright principles, all those who are enemies and adversaries both to him and to the candidates do everything with a view to contention, provoking daily strife, and heaping infinite scorn upon the candidates, until they have got them struck off the list, or have introduced their own favorites. In fact it is just as if some pilot had pirates sailing with him in his ship, perpetually plotting every hour against him, and the sailors, and marines. And if he should prefer favor with such men to his own salvation, accepting unworthy candidates, he will have God for his enemy in their stead; and what could be more dreadful than that? And yet his relations with them will be more embarrassing than formerly, as they will all combine with each other, and thereby become more powerful than before. For as when fierce winds coming from opposite directions clash with one another, the ocean, hitherto calm, becomes suddenly furious and raises its crested waves, destroying those who are sailing over it, so also when the Church has admitted corrupt men, its once tranquil surface is covered with rough surf and strewn with shipwrecks.

Consider, then, what kind of person someone must be to withstand such a storm and skillfully manage such great obstacles to the common good. He must be dignified yet free from arrogance, formidable yet kind, able to command yet sociable, impartial yet courteous, humble yet not servile, strong yet gentle, so that he can successfully contend against all these difficulties. He must bring forward with great authority the person who is properly qualified for the office, even if everyone opposes him, and with the same authority reject the person who is not qualified, even if everyone conspires in his favor. He must keep one aim only in view: the building up of the Church, motivated neither by enmity nor favor. Now do you think I acted reasonably in declining the ministry of this office? But I have not yet gone through all my reasons with you, for I still have others to mention. Do not grow impatient with listening to a friendly and sincere man who wishes to clear himself from your accusations, for these statements are not only useful for the defense you must make on my behalf, but they will also prove very helpful for the proper administration of the office. For someone who is going to enter upon this way of life must investigate all matters thoroughly before he undertakes the ministry. Why, you ask? Because someone who knows all things clearly will have this advantage, if no other: he will not feel surprised when these things happen to him. Would you like me, then, to address first the question of supervising widows, or the care of virgins, or the difficulty of the judicial function? For in each of these cases there is a different kind of anxiety, and the fear is greater than the anxiety.

16. Consider, then, what kind of man he ought to be who is to hold out against such a tempest, and to manage skillfully such great hindrances to the common welfare; for he ought to be dignified yet free from arrogance, formidable yet kind, apt to command yet sociable, impartial yet courteous, humble yet not servile, strong yet gentle, in order that he may contend successfully against all these difficulties. And he ought to bring forward with great authority the man who is properly qualified for the office, even if all should oppose him, and with the same authority to reject the man who is not so qualified, even if all should conspire in his favor, and to keep one aim only in view, the building up of the Church, in nothing actuated either by enmity or favor. Well, do you now think that I acted reasonably in declining the ministry of this office? But I have not even yet gone through all my reasons with you; for I have some others still to mention. And do not grow impatient of listening to a friendly and sincere man, who wishes to clear himself from your accusations; for these statements are not only serviceable for the defense which you have to make on my behalf, but they will also prove of no small help for the due administration of the office. For it is necessary for one who is going to enter upon this path of life to investigate all matters thoroughly well, before he sets his hand to the ministry. Do you ask why? Because one who knows all things clearly will have this advantage, if no other, that he will not feel strange when these things befall him. Would you like me then to approach the question of superintending widows, first of all, or of the care of virgins, or the difficulty of the judicial function. For in each of these cases there is a different kind of anxiety, and the fear is greater than the anxiety.

Now in the first place, to start with what seems to be the simpler matter, the care of widows appears to cause concern for those who look after them only in terms of financial expense. But this is not the case, and here too careful examination is needed when they are to be enrolled, for endless harm has been caused by putting them on the list without proper discernment. They have destroyed households, broken up marriages, and have often been caught stealing and pilfering and committing disgraceful acts of that kind. Now supporting such women from the Church's funds provokes punishment from God and severe condemnation among people, and weakens the enthusiasm of those who want to do good. For who would ever choose to spend the wealth he was commanded to give to Christ on those who slander the name of Christ? For these reasons a strict and careful examination ought to be made to prevent the resources meant for the needy from being wasted, not only by the women already mentioned, but also by those who can provide for themselves. And this examination is followed by no small concern of another kind, to ensure an abundant and unfailing flow of supply as from a fountain, for enforced poverty is an insatiable kind of evil, complaining and ungrateful. And great wisdom and great dedication is required to silence the complainers, depriving them of every excuse. Now most people, when they see someone free from the love of money, immediately present him as well qualified for this responsibility. But I do not think that this nobility of character is ever sufficient by itself, although it ought to be possessed before all other qualities, for without this a man would be a destroyer rather than a protector, a wolf instead of a shepherd. Nevertheless, combined with this, the possession of another quality also should be required. And this quality is patience, the source of all good things in people, driving and leading the soul into a peaceful harbor. For widows are a group who, because of their poverty, their age, and their natural temperament, indulge in unlimited outspokenness (so I had best call it), and they make untimely noise and pointless complaints and lamentations about matters for which they ought to be thankful, and bring accusations concerning things which they ought to accept contentedly. Now the supervisor should endure all these things with a generous spirit, and not be provoked either by their unreasonable troublesomeness or their unreasonable complaints. For this group of people deserve to be pitied for their misfortunes, not to be insulted, and to trample upon their troubles and add the pain of insult to that which poverty brings would be an act of extreme cruelty. For this reason one of the wisest of men, considering the greed and pride of human nature, and thinking about the nature of poverty and its terrible power to degrade even the noblest character and often induce it to act in these same ways without shame, in order that a man should not be irritated when accused nor be provoked by constant begging to become an enemy where he ought to bring help, he instructs him to be kind and approachable to the one asking for help, saying, "Incline your ear to a poor man and give him a friendly answer with meekness." And passing over the case of one who succeeds in becoming angry (for what can one say to him who is overcome?), he addresses the man who is able to bear the other's weakness, urging him before he gives his gift to correct the one asking by the gentleness of his expression and the mildness of his words. But if anyone, although he does not take the property of these widows, nevertheless burdens them with countless reproaches and insults them and is angry with them, he not only fails through his gift to relieve the depression caused by poverty, but makes the distress worse by his abuse. For although they may be forced to act very shamelessly through the necessity of hunger, they are nevertheless troubled by this compulsion. When, then, because of the fear of starvation, they are forced to beg, and because of their begging are forced to set aside shame, and then again because of their shamelessness are insulted, the force of depression becoming complex and accompanied by much gloom settles down upon the soul. And one who has charge of these people ought to be so patient as not only not to increase their depression by his outbursts of anger, but also to remove the greater part of it by his encouragement. For just as the man who has been insulted, although he enjoys great abundance, does not feel the benefit of his wealth because of the blow he has received from the insult, so on the other hand, the man who has been addressed with kind words, and for whom the gift has been accompanied with encouragement, rejoices and is glad all the more, and the thing given becomes doubled in value through the manner in which it is offered. And I say this not of myself, but borrow from him whose instruction I quoted just now: "My son, do not spoil your good deeds, neither use unpleasant words when you give anything. Will not the dew relieve the heat? So is a word better than a gift. Look! Is not a word better than a gift? But both are with a gracious man."

Now in the first place, to start from that subject which seems to be simpler than the others, the charge of widows appears to cause anxiety to those who take care of them only so far as the expenditure of money is concerned; but the case is otherwise, and here also a careful scrutiny is needed, when they have to be enrolled, for infinite mischief has been caused by putting them on the list without due discrimination. For they have ruined households, and severed marriages, and have often been detected in thieving and pilfering and unseemly deeds of that kind. Now that such women should be supported out of the Church's revenues provokes punishment from God, and extreme condemnation among men, and abates the zeal of those who wish to do good. For who would ever choose to expend the wealth which he was commanded to give to Christ upon those who defame the name of Christ? For these reasons a strict and accurate scrutiny ought to be made so as to prevent the supply of the indigent being wasted, not only by the women already mentioned, but also by those who are able to provide for themselves. And this scrutiny is succeeded by no small anxiety of another kind, to ensure an abundant and unfailing stream of supply as from a fountain; for compulsory poverty is an insatiable kind of evil, querulous and ungrateful. And great discretion and great zeal is required so as to stop the mouths of complainers, depriving them of every excuse. Now most men, when they see any one superior to the love of money, immediately represent him as well qualified for this stewardship. But I do not think that this greatness of soul is ever sufficient of itself, although it ought to be possessed prior to all other qualities; for without this a man would be a destroyer rather than a protector, a wolf instead of a shepherd; nevertheless, combined with this, the possession of another quality also should be demanded. And this quality is forbearance, the cause of all good things in men, impelling as it were and conducting the soul into a serene haven. For widows are a class who, both on account of their poverty, their age and natural disposition, indulge in unlimited freedom of speech (so I had best call it); and they make an unseasonable clamor and idle complaints and lamentations about matters for which they ought to be grateful, and bring accusations concerning things which they ought contentedly to accept. Now the superintendent should endure all these things in a generous spirit, and not be provoked either by their unreasonable annoyance or their unreasonable complaints. For this class of persons deserve to be pitied for their misfortunes, not to be insulted; and to trample upon their calamities, and add the pain of insult to that which poverty brings, would be an act of extreme brutality. On this account one of the wisest of men, having regard to the avarice and pride of human nature, and considering the nature of poverty and its terrible power to depress even the noblest character, and induce it often to act in these same respects without shame, in order that a man should not be irritated when accused, nor be provoked by continual importunity to become an enemy where he ought to bring aid, he instructs him to be affable and accessible to the suppliant, saying, Incline your ear to a poor man and give him a friendly answer with meekness. Sirach 4:8 And passing by the case of one who succeeds in exasperating (for what can one say to him who is overcome?), he addresses the man who is able to bear the other's infirmity, exhorting him before he bestows his gift to correct the suppliant by the gentleness of his countenance and the mildness of his words. But if any one, although he does not take the property (of these widows), nevertheless loads them with innumerable reproaches, and insults them, and is exasperated against them, he not only fails through his gift to alleviate the despondency produced by poverty, but aggravates the distress by his abuse. For although they may be compelled to act very shamelessly through the necessity of hunger, they are nevertheless distressed at this compulsion. When, then, owing to the dread of famine, they are constrained to beg, and owing to their begging are constrained to put off shame, and then again on account of their shamelessness are insulted, the power of despondency becoming of a complex kind, and accompanied by much gloom, settles down upon the soul. And one who has the charge of these persons ought to be so long-suffering, as not only not to increase their despondency by his fits of anger, but also to remove the greater part of it by his exhortation. For as the man who has been insulted, although he is in the enjoyment of great abundance, does not feel the advantage of his wealth, on account of the blow which he has received from the insult; so on the other hand, the man who has been addressed with kindly words, and for whom the gift has been accompanied with encouragement, exults and rejoices all the more, and the thing given becomes doubled in value through the manner in which it is offered. And this I say not of myself, but borrow from him whose precept I quoted just now: My son, blemish not your good deeds, neither use uncomfortable words when you give anything. Shall not the dew assuage the heat? So is a word better than a gift. Lo! Is not a word better than a gift? But both are with a gracious man. Sirach 18:15-17

But the person who oversees these people ought not only to be gentle and patient, but also skilled in managing property. If this skill is lacking, the affairs of the poor fall back into the same distress. Someone who was entrusted not long ago with this ministry gathered together a large sum of money, but neither used it himself nor spent it, except in a few cases, on those who needed it. Instead he kept most of it buried in the ground until a time of trouble came, when it was all handed over to the enemy. Therefore, much careful thought is needed so that the resources of the Church are neither too abundant nor too scarce, but that all the supplies that are provided should be quickly distributed to those who need them, and the treasures of the Church stored up in the hearts of those who are under her care.

But the superintendent of these persons ought not only to be gentle and forbearing, but also skillful in the management of property; for if this qualification is wanting, the affairs of the poor are again involved in the same distress. One who was entrusted not long ago with this ministry, and got together a large hoard of money, neither consumed it himself, nor expended it with a few exceptions upon those who needed it, but kept the greater part of it buried in the earth until a season of distress occurred, when it was all surrendered into the hands of the enemy. Much forethought, therefore, is needed, that the resources of the Church should be neither over abundant, nor deficient, but that all the supplies which are provided should be quickly distributed among those who require them, and the treasures of the Church stored up in the hearts of those who are under her rule.

Moreover, in welcoming strangers and caring for the sick, consider how much money is required and how much precision and good judgment are needed from those who oversee these matters. Often this expenditure must be even greater than what I just mentioned, and the person in charge must combine prudence and wisdom with skill in managing resources. He must persuade the wealthy to be generous and willing in their giving, so that while providing relief for the sick, he does not trouble the consciences of those who supply what is needed. But dedication and enthusiasm must be shown here to an even greater extent, because sick people are hard to please and easily discouraged. Unless great precision and care are taken, even a small mistake is enough to cause the patient serious harm.

Moreover, in the reception of strangers, and the care of the sick, consider how great an expenditure of money is needed, and how much exactness and discernment on the part of those who preside over these matters. For it is often necessary that this expenditure should be even larger than that of which I spoke just now, and that he who presides over it should combine prudence and wisdom with skill in the art of supply, so as to dispose the affluent to be emulous and ungrudging in their gifts, lest while providing for the relief of the sick, he should vex the souls of those who supply their wants. But earnestness and zeal need to be displayed here in a far higher degree; for the sick are difficult creatures to please, and prone to languor; and unless great accuracy and care are used, even a slight oversight is enough to do the patient great mischief.

When it comes to caring for virgins, the fear is greater in proportion to how precious this possession is, and this flock is more noble than the others. Already, an infinite number of women with countless bad qualities have rushed into the ranks of these holy ones. In this case our grief is greater than in the other, for there is the same difference between a virgin going astray and a widow going astray as between a free-born young woman and her slave. With widows, it has become common practice to act frivolously, to insult one another, to flatter or be impudent, to appear everywhere in public, and to walk about in the marketplace. But the virgin has striven for nobler goals and eagerly sought the highest kind of philosophy. She professes to display on earth the life that angels lead, and while still in the flesh she proposes to do deeds that belong to the incorporeal powers. Moreover, she should not make numerous or unnecessary trips, nor is it permissible for her to speak idle and random words. As for insults and flattery, she should not even know them by name. For this reason she needs the most careful guardianship and the greater assistance. The enemy of holiness is always watching and lying in wait for these persons, ready to devour any one of them if she should slip and fall. Many men also lay snares for them. Besides all these things, there is the passionateness of their own human nature, so that, generally speaking, the virgin has to equip herself for a twofold war—one that attacks her from outside, and the other that presses upon her from within. For these reasons, the one who has the superintendence of virgins suffers great alarm, and the danger and distress is yet greater should any of the things contrary to his wishes occur, which God forbid. If a daughter kept in seclusion is a cause of sleeplessness to her father, his anxiety about her depriving him of sleep, where the fear is so great lest she should be childless, or pass the flower of her age unmarried, or be hated by her husband, what will he suffer whose anxiety is not concerned with any of these things but with others far greater? In this case it is not a man who is rejected, but Christ Himself. Nor is this barrenness merely the subject of reproach, but the evil ends in the destruction of the soul, for every tree, it is said, which does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire. And for one who has been repudiated by the divine Bridegroom, it is not sufficient to receive a certificate of divorce and depart—she has to pay the penalty of everlasting punishment. Moreover, a father according to the flesh has many things that make the custody of his daughter easy, for the mother, nurse, and a multitude of maidservants share in helping the parent to keep the maiden safe. She is not permitted to be constantly rushing into the marketplace, nor when she does go there is she compelled to show herself to any of the passersby, with evening darkness concealing one who does not wish to be seen no less than the walls of the house. And apart from these things, she is relieved from every cause that might otherwise compel her to meet the gaze of men, for no anxiety about the necessities of life, no threats from oppressors, nor anything of that kind reduces her to this unfortunate necessity, with her father acting in her place in all these matters. She herself has only one anxiety, which is to avoid doing or saying anything unworthy of the modest conduct that becomes her. But in the other case there are many things that make the custody of the virgin difficult, or rather impossible for the father, for he could not have her in his house with himself, as living together in that way would be neither seemly nor safe. Even if they themselves should suffer no loss but continue to preserve their innocence unsullied, they would have to give an account for the souls they have offended, just as much as if they happened to sin with one another. Since it is impossible for them to live together, it is not easy to understand the movements of her character and to suppress the impulses that are poorly regulated, or train and improve those that are better ordered and tuned. Nor is it an easy thing to interfere in her habits of going out, for her poverty and want of a guardian does not permit him to become an exact investigator of the propriety of her conduct. Since she is compelled to manage all her affairs, she has many pretexts for going out, if at least she is not inclined to be self-controlled. Now he who commands her to stay always at home ought to cut off these pretexts, providing for her independence in the necessities of life and giving her some woman who will see to the management of these things. He must also keep her away from funeral services and nocturnal festivals, for that crafty serpent knows only too well how to scatter his poison through the medium even of good deeds. And the maiden must be fenced on every side and rarely go out of the house during the whole year, except when she is compelled by inexorable necessity. Now if anyone should say that none of these things is the proper work of a bishop to take in hand, let him be assured that the anxieties and the concerns about what takes place in every case have to be referred to him. And it is far more expedient that he should manage everything and so be delivered from the complaints which he must otherwise undergo on account of the faults of others, than that he should abstain from the management and then have to dread being called to account for things which other men have done. Moreover, he who does these things by himself gets through them all with great ease, but he who is compelled to do it by converting everyone's opinion does not get relief from being saved from working single-handedly equivalent to the trouble and turmoil which he experiences through those who oppose him and combat his decisions. However, I could not enumerate all the anxieties concerned with the care of virgins, for when they have to be entered on the list, they occasion no small trouble to him who is entrusted with this business.

17. But in the care of virgins, the fear is greater in proportion as the possession is more precious, and this flock is of a nobler character than the others. Already, indeed, even into the band of these holy ones, an infinite number of women have rushed full of innumerable bad qualities; and in this case our grief is greater than in the other; for there is just the same difference between a virgin and a widow going astray, as between a free-born damsel and her handmaid. With widows, indeed, it has become a common practice to trifle, and to rail at one another, to flatter or to be impudent, to appear everywhere in public, and to perambulate the market-place. But the virgin has striven for nobler aims, and eagerly sought the highest kind of philosophy, and professes to exhibit upon earth the life which angels lead, and while yet in the flesh proposes to do deeds which belong to the incorporeal powers. Moreover, she ought not to make numerous or unnecessary journeys, neither is it permissible for her to utter idle and random words; and as for abuse and flattery, she should not even know them by name. On this account she needs the most careful guardianship, and the greater assistance. For the enemy of holiness is always surprising and lying in wait for these persons, ready to devour any one of them if she should slip and fall; many men also there are who lay snares for them; and besides all these things there is the passionateness of their own human nature, so that, speaking generally, the virgin has to equip herself for a twofold war, one which attacks her from without, and the other which presses upon her from within. For these reasons he who has the superintendence of virgins suffers great alarm, and the danger and distress is yet greater, should any of the things which are contrary to his wishes occur, which God forbid. For if a daughter kept in seclusion is a cause of sleeplessness to her father, his anxiety about her depriving him of sleep, where the fear is so great lest she should be childless, or pass the flower of her age (unmarried), or be hated (by her husband), Sirach 42:9 what will he suffer whose anxiety is not concerned with any of these things, but others far greater? For in this case it is not a man who is rejected, but Christ Himself, nor is this barrenness the subject merely of reproach, but the evil ends in the destruction of the soul; for every tree, it is said, which brings not forth good fruit, is hewn down and cast into the fire. Matthew 3:10 And for one who has been repudiated by the divine Bridegroom, it is not sufficient to receive a certificate of divorce and so to depart, but she has to pay the penalty of everlasting punishment. Moreover, a father according to the flesh has many things which make the custody of his daughter easy; for the mother, and nurse, and a multitude of handmaids share in helping the parent to keep the maiden safe. For neither is she permitted to be perpetually hurrying into the market-place, nor when she does go there is she compelled to show herself to any of the passers-by, the evening darkness concealing one who does not wish to be seen no less than the walls of the house. And apart from these things, she is relieved from every cause which might otherwise compel her to meet the gaze of men; for no anxiety about the necessaries of life, no menaces of oppressors, nor anything of that kind reduces her to this unfortunate necessity, her father acting in her stead in all these matters; while she herself has only one anxiety, which is to avoid doing or saying anything unworthy the modest conduct which becomes her. But in the other case there are many things which make the custody of the virgin difficult, or rather impossible for the father; for he could not have her in his house with himself, as dwelling together in that way would be neither seemly nor safe. For even if they themselves should suffer no loss, but continue to preserve their innocence unsullied, they would have to give an account for the souls which they have offended, just as much as if they happened to sin with one another. And it being impossible for them to live together, it is not easy to understand the movements of the character, and to suppress the impulses which are ill regulated, or train and improve those which are better ordered and tuned. Nor is it an easy thing to interfere in her habits of walking out; for her poverty and want of a guardian does not permit him to become an exact investigator of the propriety of her conduct. For as she is compelled to manage all her affairs she has many pretexts for going out, if at least she is not inclined to be self-controlled. Now he who commands her to stay always at home ought to cut off these pretexts, providing for her independence in the necessaries of life, and giving her some woman who will see to the management of these things. He must also keep her away from funeral obsequies, and nocturnal festivals; for that artful serpent knows only too well how to scatter his poison through the medium even of good deeds. And the maiden must be fenced on every side, and rarely go out of the house during the whole year, except when she is constrained by inexorable necessity. Now if any one should say that none of these things is the proper work of a bishop to take in hand, let him be assured that the anxieties and the reasons concerning what takes place in every case have to be referred to him. And it is far more expedient that he should manage everything, and so be delivered from the complaints which he must otherwise undergo on account of the faults of others, than that he should abstain from the management, and then have to dread being called to account for things which other men have done. Moreover, he who does these things by himself, gets through them all with great ease; but he who is compelled to do it by converting every one's opinion does not get relief by being saved from working single-handed, equivalent to the trouble and turmoil which he experiences through those who oppose him and combat his decisions. However, I could not enumerate all the anxieties concerned with the care of virgins; for when they have to be entered on the list, they occasion no small trouble to him who is entrusted with this business.

The judicial side of a bishop's work brings countless irritations, consumes enormous amounts of time, and involves difficulties greater than those faced by judges who handle secular cases. It is hard work to discover true justice, and even when you find it, it is difficult to avoid undermining it. This work brings not only lost time and difficulty but also considerable danger. Before now, some of the weaker believers have thrown themselves into these disputes, and because they did not receive support, they have suffered shipwreck concerning the faith. Many of those who have been wronged, just as much as those who have done the wrong, hate those who do not help them. They refuse to take into account either the complexity of the issues involved, or the difficulty of the circumstances, or the limits of priestly authority, or anything else of that sort. Instead, they are merciless judges who recognize only one acceptable defense: freedom from the troubles that are weighing them down. Anyone who cannot provide this, no matter how many excuses he offers, will never escape their judgment.

Again, the judicial department of the bishop's office involves innumerable vexations, great consumption of time, and difficulties exceeding those experienced by men who sit to judge secular affairs; for it is a labor to discover exact justice, and when it is found, it is difficult to avoid destroying it. And not only loss of time and difficulty are incurred, but also no small danger. For ere now, some of the weaker brethren having plunged into business, because they have not obtained patronage have made shipwreck concerning the faith. For many of those who have suffered wrong, no less than those who have inflicted wrong, hate those who do not assist them, and they will not take into account either the intricacy of the matters in question, or the difficulty of the times, or the limits of sacerdotal authority, or anything of that kind; but they are merciless judges, recognizing only one kind of defense — release from the evils which oppress them. And he who is unable to furnish this, although he may allege innumerable excuses, will never escape their condemnation.

And speaking of patronage, let me reveal another excuse for finding fault. If the bishop does not make a round of visits every day—even more visits than idle men make around town—terrible offense results. Not only the sick but also the healthy want to be attended to, and piety does not motivate them in this; rather, in most cases they are claiming honor and distinction. And if he should ever happen to visit one of the wealthier and more powerful people more frequently, compelled by some necessity for the common benefit of the Church, he is immediately labeled as a flatterer and toady. But why do I speak of patronage and visiting? Simply from the way bishops greet people, they have to endure such a burden of criticism that they are often weighed down and overwhelmed by despair. In fact, they also have to undergo examination of the way they use their eyes. People rigorously criticize their simplest actions, taking note of the tone of their voice, their facial expression, and how much they laugh. He laughed heartily at that man, someone will say, and greeted him with a cheerful face and a clear voice, whereas to me he addressed only a brief and casual remark. And in a large gathering, if he does not turn his eyes in every direction when he is speaking, most people declare that his behavior is insulting.

And talking of patronage, let me disclose another pretext for fault-finding. For if the bishop does not pay a round of visits every day, more even than the idle men about town, unspeakable offense ensues. For not only the sick, but also the whole, desire to be looked after, not that piety prompts them to this, but rather that in most cases they pretend claims to honor and distinction. And if he should ever happen to visit more constantly one of the richer and more powerful men, under the pressure of some necessity, with a view to the common benefit of the Church, he is immediately stigmatized with a character for fawning and flattery. But why do I speak of patronage and visiting? For merely from their mode of accosting persons, bishops have to endure such a load of reproaches as to be often oppressed and overwhelmed by despondency; in fact, they have also to undergo a scrutiny of the way in which they use their eyes. For the public rigorously criticize their simplest actions, taking note of the tone of their voice, the cast of their countenance, and the degree of their laughter. He laughed heartily to such a man, one will say, and accosted him with a beaming face, and a clear voice, whereas to me he addressed only a slight and passing remark. And in a large assembly, if he does not turn his eyes in every direction when he is conversing, the majority declare that his conduct is insulting.

Someone who wants to handle so many accusers successfully must be exceptionally strong. He needs either to avoid being accused at all, or if he is accused, to clear himself. Since it's not easy to avoid accusers—some people simply enjoy making empty and malicious charges—he must bravely resist the discouragement these complaints produce. A person who is justly accused can more easily bear the accuser, because no accuser is harsher than one's own conscience. Therefore, if we are first convicted by this most terrible opponent within, we can readily endure the milder ones outside us. But someone who has nothing evil on his conscience, when subjected to a groundless charge, is quickly stirred to anger and easily falls into discouragement, unless he has already practiced enduring the foolishness of the crowd. For it is completely impossible for someone who is falsely accused without reason and then condemned not to feel some irritation and distress at such great injustice.

Who, then, unless he is exceedingly strong, could cope with so many accusers, so as either to avoid being indited altogether, or, if he is indited, to escape? For he must either be without any accusers, or, if this is impossible, purge himself of the accusations which are brought against him; and if this again is not an easy matter, as some men delight in making vain and wanton charges, he must make a brave stand against the dejection produced by these complaints. He, indeed, who is justly accused, may easily tolerate the accuser, for there is no bitterer accuser than conscience; wherefore, if we are caught first by this most terrible adversary, we can readily endure the milder ones who are external to us. But he who has no evil thing upon his conscience, when he is subjected to an empty charge, is speedily excited to wrath, and easily sinks into dejection, unless he happens to have practised beforehand how to put up with the follies of the multitude. For it is utterly impossible for one who is falsely accused without cause, and condemned, to avoid feeling some vexation and annoyance at such great injustice.

And how can one describe the distress that bishops experience whenever it is necessary to cut someone off from the full communion of the Church? If only the problem went no further than distress! But in fact the harm is not minor. For there is a real fear that if the person has been punished more severely than he deserves, he might suffer what blessed Paul spoke of and be swallowed up by excessive sorrow. The most careful precision is therefore required in this matter as well, so that what is meant to be helpful does not become for him an occasion of greater harm. For whatever sins he may commit after such treatment, the anger caused by each of them must be shared by the physician who so unskillfully applied his knife to the wound. What severe punishment, then, must be expected by someone who not only has to give an account of the offenses he himself has individually committed, but also incurs extreme danger because of the sins committed by others? For if we shudder at undergoing judgment for our own misdeeds, believing that we will not be able to escape the fire of the world to come, what must someone expect to suffer who has to answer for so many others? To prove the truth of this, listen to blessed Paul, or rather not to him, but to Christ speaking in him, when he says: Obey those who have rule over you, and submit, for they watch for your souls as those who must give account. Can the dread of this threat be slight? It is impossible to say so, but these considerations are sufficient to convince even the most skeptical and obstinate that I did not make this escape under the influence of pride or vainglory, but simply out of fear for my own safety and consideration of the gravity of the office.

And how can one speak of the distress which bishops undergo, whenever it is necessary to cut some one off from the full communion of the Church? Would indeed that the evil went no further than distress! But in fact the mischief is not trifling. For there is a fear lest the man, if he has been punished beyond what he deserves, should experience that which was spoken of by the blessed Paul and be swallowed up by overmuch sorrow. 2 Corinthians 2:7 The nicest accuracy, therefore, is required in this matter also, lest what is intended to be profitable should become to him an occasion of greater damage. For whatever sins he may commit after such a method of treatment, the wrath caused by each of them must be shared by the physician who so unskillfully applied his knife to the wound. What severe punishment, then, must be expected by one who has not only to render an account of the offenses which he himself has separately committed, but also incurs extreme danger on account of the sins committed by others? For if we shudder at undergoing judgment for our own misdeeds, believing that we shall not be able to escape the fire of the other world, what must one expect to suffer who has to answer for so many others? To prove the truth of this, listen to the blessed Paul, or rather not to him, but to Christ speaking in him, when he says: Obey them that have the rule over you, and submit, for they watch for your souls as they that shall give account. Hebrews 13:17 Can the dread of this threat be slight? It is impossible to say: but these considerations are sufficient to convince even the most incredulous and obdurate that I did not make this escape under the influence of pride or vainglory, but merely out of fear for my own safety, and consideration of the gravity of the office.


On the Priesthood — Book II

On the Priesthood, Book II: the dialogue with Basil on the dignity and dangers of priestly ministry.

Source: Translated by W.R.W. Stephens. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 9. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/19222.htm>.

Opening

It is possible, then, to use deceit for a good purpose—or rather, in such a case it should not be called deceit at all, but a kind of excellent management worthy of admiration. This could be demonstrated at greater length, but what has already been said is sufficient proof, and it would be tiresome and tedious to extend the discussion further on this subject. Now it remains for you to determine whether I have used this art for your benefit.

1. That it is possible then to make use of deceit for a good purpose, or rather that in such a case it ought not to be called deceit, but a kind of good management worthy of all admiration, might be proved at greater length; but since what has already been said suffices for demonstration, it would be irksome and tedious to lengthen out my discourse upon the subject. And now it will remain for you to prove whether I have not employed this art to your advantage.

Basil: And what kind of benefit have I gained from this good management, or wise policy, or whatever you want to call it, that would convince me I haven't been deceived by you?

Basil: And what kind of advantage have I derived from this piece of good management, or wise policy, or whatever you may please to call it, so as to persuade me that I have not been deceived by you?

What advantage, you ask, could be greater than to be seen doing those things which Christ with his own lips declared to be proofs of love for himself? When addressing the leader of the apostles, he said, "Peter, do you love me?" and when Peter confessed that he did, the Lord added, "If you love me, tend my sheep." The Master asked the disciple if he was loved by him, not to get information (how could he need that, when he knows the hearts of all people?), but to teach us how much he cares about the supervision of these sheep. Since this is clear, it will also be obvious that a great and indescribable reward will be kept for the person whose work involves these sheep, which Christ values so highly. When we see someone taking care of members of our household or our flocks, we consider his devotion to them a sign of love toward us—yet all these things can be bought with money. How much greater a gift, then, will he give to those who tend the flock which he purchased not with money or anything like that, but by his own death, giving his own blood as the price for the herd? Therefore, when the disciple said, "You know, Lord, that I love you," and called upon the beloved one himself as a witness of his love, the Savior did not stop there but added what was the sign of love. He did not want to show at that time how much Peter loved him, but how much he himself loved his own Church, and he wanted to teach Peter and all of us that we also should devote much effort to the same. Why did God not spare his only-begotten Son but handed him over, though he was the only one he had? It was so that he might reconcile to himself those who were hostile toward him and make them his special people. For what purpose did he shed his blood? It was so that he might win these sheep which he entrusted to Peter and his successors. Naturally, then, Christ said, "Who then is the faithful and wise servant whom his lord will make ruler over his household?" Again, these are the words of someone who is uncertain, yet the speaker did not say them out of uncertainty, but just as he asked Peter whether he loved him, not because he needed to learn the disciple's affection but because he wanted to show the surpassing depth of his own love—so also now when he says, "Who then is the faithful and wise servant?" he speaks not out of ignorance about who is faithful and wise, but because he wants to demonstrate the rarity of such a character and the greatness of this office. Notice, in any case, how great the reward is—"He will appoint him," he says, "ruler over all his goods."

Chrysostom: What advantage, pray, could be greater than to be seen doing those things which Christ with his own lips declared to be proofs of love to Himself? John 21:15-17 For addressing the leader of the apostles He said, Peter, do you love me? and when he confessed that he did, the Lord added, if you love me tend my sheep. The Master asked the disciple if He was loved by him, not in order to get information (how should He who penetrates the hearts of all men?), but in order to teach us how great an interest He takes in the superintendence of these sheep. This being plain, it will likewise be manifest that a great and unspeakable reward will be reserved for him whose labors are concerned with these sheep, upon which Christ places such a high value. For when we see any one bestowing care upon members of our household, or upon our flocks, we count his zeal for them as a sign of love towards ourselves: yet all these things are to be bought for money:– with how great a gift then will He requite those who tend the flock which He purchased, not with money, nor anything of that kind, but by His own death, giving his own blood as the price of the herd. Wherefore when the disciple said, You know Lord that I love You, and invoked the beloved one Himself as a witness of his love, the Saviour did not stop there, but added that which was the token of love. For He did not at that time wish to show how much Peter loved Him, but how much He Himself loved His own Church, and he desired to teach Peter and all of us that we also should bestow much zeal upon the same. For why did God not spare His only-begotten Son, but delivered Him up, although the only one He had? It was that He might reconcile to Himself those who were disposed towards Him as enemies, and make them His peculiar people. For what purpose did He shed His blood? It was that He might win these sheep which He entrusted to Peter and his successors. Naturally then did Christ say, Who then is the faithful and wise servant, whom his lord shall make ruler over His household. Again, the words are those of one who is in doubt, yet the speaker did not utter them in doubt, but just as He asked Peter whether he loved Him, not from any need to learn the affection of the disciple, but from a desire to show the exceeding depth of his own love: so now also when He says, Who then is the faithful and wise servant? he speaks not as being ignorant who is faithful and wise, but as desiring to set forth the rarity of such a character, and the greatness of this office. Observe at any rate how great the reward is — He will appoint him, he says, ruler over all his goods. Matthew 24:47

Will you still insist that you were not rightly deceived, when you are about to oversee the things that belong to God and are doing what the Lord said would enable Peter to surpass the rest of the apostles? For His words were, "Peter, do you love me more than these?" Yet He might have said to him, "If you love me, practice fasting, sleeping on the ground, and prolonged vigils, defend the wronged, be as a father to orphans, and supply the place of a husband to their mother." But in fact, setting aside all these things, what does He say? "Tend my sheep." For those things I have already mentioned might easily be performed by many even of those who are under authority, women as well as men. But when one is required to preside over the Church and to be entrusted with the care of so many souls, the whole female sex must retire before the magnitude of the task, and the majority of men also. We must bring forward those who to a large extent surpass all others and soar as much above them in excellence of spirit as Saul towered over the whole Hebrew nation in bodily stature—or rather far more. For in this case, let me not take the height of shoulders as the standard of measurement. Rather, let the distinction between the pastor and his charge be as great as that between rational man and irrational creatures, if not even greater, since the risk concerns things of far greater importance. The shepherd who has lost sheep, whether through the ravages of wolves, the attacks of robbers, disease, or any other disaster befalling them, might perhaps obtain some indulgence from the owner of the flock. And even if the owner should demand satisfaction, the penalty would only be a matter of money. But he who has human beings entrusted to him, the rational flock of Christ, incurs a penalty in the first place for the loss of the sheep that goes beyond material things and touches his own life. In the second place, he has to carry on a far greater and more difficult struggle. For he has not to contend with wolves, nor to dread robbers, nor to consider how he may avert disease from the flock. With whom then does he have to fight? With whom does he have to wrestle? Listen to the words of Saint Paul: "We wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world, against spiritual wickedness in high places." Do you see the terrible multitude of enemies and their fierce squadrons, not armored in steel but endowed with a nature which is of itself equivalent to a complete suit of armor? Would you see yet another host, stern and cruel, besieging this flock? This also you shall behold from the same vantage point. For he who has discoursed to us concerning the others also points out these enemies to us, speaking in a certain place in this way: "The works of the flesh are manifest, which are these: fornication, adultery, uncleanness, lasciviousness, idolatry, witchcraft, hatred, variance, emulation, wrath, strife, backbitings, whisperings, swellings, tumults," and many more besides, for he did not make a complete list but left us to understand the rest from these. Moreover, in the case of the shepherd of irrational creatures, those who wish to destroy the flock, when they see the guardian take flight, cease making war upon him and are content with seizing the cattle. But in this case, even if they capture the whole flock, they do not leave the shepherd unmolested but attack him all the more and grow bolder, not ceasing until they have either overthrown him or have themselves been vanquished. Again, the afflictions of sheep are obvious, whether it be famine, disease, wounds, or whatever else distresses them, and this might help not a little toward the relief of those who are oppressed in these ways. And there is yet another fact greater than this which facilitates release from this kind of affliction. And what is that? The shepherds with great authority compel the sheep to receive the remedy when they do not willingly submit to it. For it is easy to bind them when cautery or cutting is required, and to keep them inside the fold for a long time whenever it is expedient, and to bring them one kind of food instead of another, and to cut them off from their supplies of water, and all other things which the shepherds may decide to be conducive to their health they perform with great ease.

2. Will you, then, still contend that you were not rightly deceived, when you are about to superintend the things which belong to God, and are doing that which when Peter did the Lord said he should be able to surpass the rest of the apostles, for His words were, Peter, do you love me more than these? Yet He might have said to him, If you love me practise fasting, sleeping on the ground, and prolonged vigils, defend the wronged, be as a father to orphans, and supply the place of a husband to their mother. But as a matter of fact, setting aside all these things, what does He say? Tend my sheep. For those things which I have already mentioned might easily be performed by many even of those who are under authority, women as well as men; but when one is required to preside over the Church, and to be entrusted with the care of so many souls, the whole female sex must retire before the magnitude of the task, and the majority of men also; and we must bring forward those who to a large extent surpass all others, and soar as much above them in excellence of spirit as Saul overtopped the whole Hebrew nation in bodily stature: or rather far more. 1 Samuel 10:23 For in this case let me not take the height of shoulders as the standard of inquiry; but let the distinction between the pastor and his charge be as great as that between rational man and irrational creatures, not to say even greater, inasmuch as the risk is concerned with things of far greater importance. He indeed who has lost sheep, either through the ravages of wolves, or the attacks of robbers, or through murrain, or any other disaster befalling them, might perhaps obtain some indulgence from the owner of the flock; and even if the latter should demand satisfaction the penalty would be only a matter of money: but he who has human beings entrusted to him, the rational flock of Christ, incurs a penalty in the first place for the loss of the sheep, which goes beyond material things and touches his own life: and in the second place he has to carry on a far greater and more difficult contest. For he has not to contend with wolves, nor to dread robbers, nor to consider how he may avert pestilence from the flock. With whom then has he to fight? With whom has he to wrestle? Listen to the words of St. Paul. We wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world, against spiritual wickedness in high places. Ephesians 6:12 Do you see the terrible multitude of enemies, and their fierce squadrons, not steel clad, but endued with a nature which is of itself an equivalent for a complete suit of armor. Would you see yet another host, stern and cruel, beleaguering this flock? This also you shall behold from the same post of observation. For he who has discoursed to us concerning the others, points out these enemies also to us, speaking in a certain place on this wise: The works of the flesh are manifest, which are these, fornication, adultery, uncleanness, lasciviousness, idolatry, witchcraft, hatred, variance, emulation, wrath, strife, backbitings, whisperings, swellings, tumults, 2 Corinthians 12:20 and many more besides; for he did not make a complete list, but left us to understand the rest from these. Moreover, in the case of the shepherd of irrational creatures, those who wish to destroy the flock, when they see the guardian take to flight, cease making war upon him, and are contented with the seizure of the cattle: but in this case, even should they capture the whole flock, they do not leave the shepherd unmolested, but attack him all the more, and wax bolder, ceasing not until they have either overthrown him, or have themselves been vanquished. Again, the afflictions of sheep are manifest, whether it be famine, or pestilence, or wounds, or whatsoever else it may be which distresses them, and this might help not a little towards the relief of those who are oppressed in these ways. And there is yet another fact greater than this which facilitates release from this kind of infirmity. And what is that? The shepherds with great authority compel the sheep to receive the remedy when they do not willingly submit to it. For it is easy to bind them when cautery or cutting is required, and to keep them inside the fold for a long time, whenever it is expedient, and to bring them one kind of food instead of another, and to cut them off from their supplies of water, and all other things which the shepherds may decide to be conducive to their health they perform with great ease.

When it comes to human weaknesses, it is not easy in the first place for a person to discern them, for no one knows the things of a person except the spirit of that person which is in him. How then can anyone apply the remedy for a disease whose nature he does not know, often being unable to understand it even if he himself happens to fall sick with it? And even when it becomes clear, it causes him still more trouble, for it is not possible to treat all people with the same authority with which a shepherd treats his sheep. For in this case too it is necessary to bind and to restrict food, and to use cautery or the knife, but whether the treatment is received depends on the will of the patient, not on the one who applies the remedy. For that wonderful man (St. Paul) also understood this when he said to the Corinthians, "Not that we have dominion over your faith, but are helpers of your joy." For Christians above all people are not permitted to correct by force the failings of those who sin. Secular judges indeed, when they have captured criminals under the law, show their authority to be great and prevent them even against their will from following their own desires, but in our case the wrongdoer must be made better not by force but by persuasion. For neither has authority of this kind for restraining sinners been given to us by law, nor, if it had been given, would we have any opportunity for exercising our power, since God rewards those who abstain from evil by their own choice, not by necessity. Consequently much skill is required so that our patients may be induced to submit willingly to the treatment prescribed by the physicians, and not only this, but also so that they may be grateful for the cure. For if anyone when he is bound becomes restive (which it is in his power to be), he makes the problem worse, and if he pays no attention to the words that cut like steel, he inflicts another wound by means of this contempt, and the intention to heal only becomes the occasion of a worse disorder. For it is not possible for anyone to cure a person by compulsion against his will.

3. But in the case of human infirmities, it is not easy in the first place for a man to discern them, for no man knows the things of a man, save the spirit of man which is in him. 1 Corinthians 2:11 How then can any one apply the remedy for the disease of which he does not know the character, often indeed being unable to understand it even should he happen to sicken with it himself? And even when it becomes manifest, it causes him yet more trouble: for it is not possible to doctor all men with the same authority with which the shepherd treats his sheep. For in this case also it is necessary to bind and to restrain from food, and to use cautery or the knife: but the reception of the treatment depends on the will of the patient, not of him who applies the remedy. For this also was perceived by that wonderful man ( St. Paul) when he said to the Corinthians — Not for that we have dominion over your faith, but are helpers of your joy. 2 Corinthians 1:24 For Christians above all men are not permitted forcibly to correct the failings of those who sin. Secular judges indeed, when they have captured malefactors under the law, show their authority to be great, and prevent them even against their will from following their own devices: but in our case the wrong-doer must be made better, not by force, but by persuasion. For neither has authority of this kind for the restraint of sinners been given us by law, nor, if it had been given, should we have any field for the exercise of our power, inasmuch as God rewards those who abstain from evil by their own choice, not of necessity. Consequently much skill is required that our patients may be induced to submit willingly to the treatment prescribed by the physicians, and not only this, but that they may be grateful also for the cure. For if any one when he is bound becomes restive (which it is in his power to be), he makes the mischief worse; and if he should pay no heed to the words which cut like steel, he inflicts another wound by means of this contempt, and the intention to heal only becomes the occasion of a worse disorder. For it is not possible for any one to cure a man by compulsion against his will.

What then is one to do? If you treat too gently someone who needs the knife applied severely, and do not cut deep enough into someone who requires such treatment, you remove part of the disease but leave the rest. On the other hand, if you make the necessary incision without restraint, the patient, driven to desperation by his suffering, will often throw everything away at once—both the remedy and the bandage—and hurl himself down headlong, breaking the yoke and bursting the bonds. I could tell of many who have run into extreme evils because the full penalty for their sins was exacted. For in applying punishment, we ought not merely to proportion it to the scale of the offense, but rather to keep in view the disposition of the sinner, lest while wishing to mend what is torn, you make the tear worse, and in your eager efforts to restore what has fallen, you make the ruin greater. For weak and careless people, devoted mostly to the pleasures of the world, and having reason to be proud on account of birth and position, may yet, if gently and gradually brought to repent of their errors, be delivered—partially at least, if not perfectly—from the evils that possess them. But if someone were to inflict the discipline all at once, he would deprive them of this slight chance of improvement. For once the soul has been forced to cast off shame, it falls into a hardened condition and neither yields to kind words nor bends to threats, nor is capable of feeling gratitude, but becomes far worse than that city which the prophet reproached, saying, "You had the face of a harlot, refusing to be ashamed before all men." Therefore the pastor needs much discretion and countless eyes to observe on every side the condition of the soul. For just as many are lifted up to pride and then sink into despair of their salvation from inability to endure severe remedies, so there are some who, from paying no penalty equivalent to their sins, fall into negligence and become far worse, and are driven to greater sins. The priest must therefore leave none of these things unexamined, but after a thorough investigation of all of them, apply remedies appropriately to each case, lest his efforts prove to be in vain. And not only in this matter, but also in the work of reuniting the separated members of the Church, one can see that he has much to do. For the shepherd of sheep has his flock following him wherever he may lead them, and if any should stray from the straight path and, abandoning the good pasture, feed in barren or rocky places, a loud shout is enough to gather them and bring back to the fold those who have been separated from it. But if a human being wanders away from the right faith, great effort, perseverance, and patience are required, for he cannot be dragged back by force or constrained by fear, but must be led back by persuasion to the truth from which he originally departed. The pastor therefore ought to be of a noble spirit, so as not to lose heart or despair of the salvation of those who wander from the fold, but continually to reason with himself and say, "Perhaps God will give them repentance leading to the acknowledgment of the truth, and that they may recover themselves out of the snare of the devil." Therefore the Lord, when addressing His disciples, said, "Who then is the faithful and wise servant?" For he who disciplines himself secures only his own advantage, but the benefit of the pastoral function extends to the whole people. And one who distributes money to the needy or otherwise helps the oppressed benefits his neighbors to some extent, but so much less than the priest, in proportion as the body is inferior to the soul. Rightly therefore did the Lord say that care for the flock was a sign of love for Himself.

4. What then is one to do? For if you deal too gently with him who needs a severe application of the knife, and do not strike deep into one who requires such treatment, you remove one part of the sore but leave the other: and if on the other hand you make the requisite incision unsparingly, the patient, driven to desperation by his sufferings, will often fling everything away at once, both the remedy and the bandage, and throw himself down headlong, breaking the yoke and bursting the band. I could tell of many who have run into extreme evils because the due penalty of their sins was exacted. For we ought not, in applying punishment, merely to proportion it to the scale of the offense, but rather to keep in view the disposition of the sinner, lest while wishing to mend what is torn, you make the rent worse, and in your zealous endeavors to restore what is fallen, you make the ruin greater. For weak and careless characters, addicted for the most part to the pleasures of the world, and having occasion to be proud on account of birth and position, may yet, if gently and gradually brought to repent of their errors, be delivered, partially at least, if not perfectly, from the evils by which they are possessed: but if any one were to inflict the discipline all at once, he would deprive them of this slight chance of amendment. For when once the soul has been forced to put off shame it lapses into a callous condition, and neither yields to kindly words nor bends to threats, nor is susceptible of gratitude, but becomes far worse than that city which the prophet reproached, saying, you had the face of a harlot, refusing to be ashamed before all men. Jeremiah 3:3 Therefore the pastor has need of much discretion, and of a myriad eyes to observe on every side the habit of the soul. For as many are uplifted to pride, and then sink into despair of their salvation, from inability to endure severe remedies, so are there some, who from paying no penalty equivalent to their sins, fall into negligence, and become far worse, and are impelled to greater sins. It behooves the priest therefore to leave none of these things unexamined, but, after a thorough inquiry into all of them, to apply such remedies as he has appositely to each case, lest his zeal prove to be in vain. And not in this matter only, but also in the work of knitting together the severed members of the Church, one can see that he has much to do. For the pastor of sheep has his flock following him, wherever he may lead them: and if any should stray out of the straight path, and, deserting the good pasture, feed in unproductive or rugged places, a loud shout suffices to collect them and bring back to the fold those who have been parted from it: but if a human being wanders away from the right faith, great exertion, perseverance and patience are required; for he cannot be dragged back by force, nor constrained by fear, but must be led back by persuasion to the truth from which he originally swerved. The pastor therefore ought to be of a noble spirit, so as not to despond, or to despair of the salvation of wanderers from the fold, but continually to reason with himself and say, Peradventure God will give them repentance to the acknowledging of the truth, and that they may recover themselves out of the snare of the devil. 2 Timothy 2:25 Therefore the Lord, when addressing His disciples, said, Who then is the faithful and wise servant? Matthew 24:45 For he indeed who disciplines himself compasses only his own advantage, but the benefit of the pastoral function extends to the whole people. And one who dispenses money to the needy, or otherwise succors the oppressed, benefits his neighbors to some extent, but so much less than the priest in proportion as the body is inferior to the soul. Rightly therefore did the Lord say that zeal for the flock was a token of love for Himself.

Basil: But you yourself — do you not love Christ?

Basil: But you yourself — do you not love Christ?

Chrysostom: Yes, I love Him, and I will never stop loving Him. But I fear that I might provoke Him whom I love.

Chrysostom: Yea, I love Him, and shall never cease loving Him; but I fear lest I should provoke Him whom I love.

Basil: But what riddle could be more puzzling than this? Christ commanded the one who loves Him to tend His sheep, yet you say you refuse to tend them because you love the very One who gave this command.

Basil: But what riddle can there be more obscure than this — Christ has commanded him who loves Him to tend His sheep, and yet you say that you decline to tend them because you love Him who gave this command?

My statement is no riddle, but very clear and straightforward. If I were well qualified to carry out this office as Christ desired and then avoided it, my comment might be questionable. But since the weakness of my spirit makes me unfit for this ministry, why should my statement be called into question? For I am afraid that if I took charge of the flock when it was in good condition and well fed, and then destroyed it through my lack of skill, I would provoke against myself the God who loved the flock so much that He gave Himself up for their salvation and ransom.

Chrysostom: My saying is no riddle, but very intelligible and simple, for if I were well qualified to administer this office, as Christ desired it, and then shunned it, my remark might be open to doubt, but since the infirmity of my spirit renders me useless for this ministry, why does my saying deserve to be called in question? For I fear lest if I took the flock in hand when it was in good condition and well nourished, and then wasted it through my unskilfulness, I should provoke against myself the God who so loved the flock as to give Himself up for their salvation and ransom.

You're joking. If you were serious, I don't know how you could have proved that my grief is justified except through the very words you've used to try to lift my sadness. I knew before that you had deceived and betrayed me, but now, since you've tried to clear yourself of my charges, I see and understand even more clearly the extent of the troubles you've brought upon me. If you pulled back from this ministry because you knew your spirit wasn't equal to the weight of the task, then I should have been rescued from it before you were—even if I had greatly wanted it, let alone having left the entire decision about these matters to you. But as things stand, you've looked out only for your own interests and ignored mine. I wish you had completely ignored them—then I would be satisfied. Instead, you plotted to make it easier for those who wanted to seize me to capture me. You can't hide behind the excuse that public opinion deceived you and led you to imagine great and wonderful things about me. I wasn't one of your wonderful and distinguished men, and even if I had been, you shouldn't have preferred public opinion over truth. If I had never let you spend time with me, you might have had a reasonable excuse for basing your vote on public reports. But if no one knows my situation as thoroughly as you do, if you're more familiar with my character than my parents and those who raised me, what argument can you use that will be convincing enough to persuade your listeners that you didn't deliberately push me into this danger? Tell me, what answer will I give to your accusers?

Basil: You speak in jest: for if you were in earnest I know not how you would have proved me to be justly grieved otherwise than by means of these very words whereby you have endeavored to dispel my dejection. I knew indeed before that you had deceived and betrayed me, but much more now, when you have undertaken to clear yourself of my accusations, do I plainly perceive and understand the extent of the evils into which you have led me. For if you withdrew yourself from this ministry because you were conscious that your spirit was not equal to the burden of the task, I ought to have been rescued from it before you, even if I had chanced to have a great desire for it, to say nothing of having confided to you the entire decision of these matters: but as it is, you have looked solely to your own interest and neglected mine. Would indeed you had entirely neglected them; then I should have been well content: but you plotted to facilitate my capture by those who wished to seize me. For you cannot take shelter in the argument that public opinion deceived you and induced you to imagine great and wonderful things concerning me. For I was none of your wonderful and distinguished men, nor, had this been the case, ought you to have preferred public opinion to truth. For if I had never permitted you to enjoy my society, you might have seemed to have a reasonable pretext for being guided in your vote by public report; but if there is no one who has such thorough knowledge of my affairs, if you are acquainted with my character better than my parents and those who brought me up, what argument can you employ which will be convincing enough to persuade your hearers that you did not purposely thrust me into this danger: say, what answer shall I make to your accusers?

Chrysostom: No! I will not move on to those questions until I have answered the ones that concern you alone, even if you ask me ten thousand times to deal with these charges. You did say that ignorance would bring me forgiveness, and that I would have been free from all accusation if I had brought you into your present position without knowing anything about you. But you also said that because I did not betray you in ignorance, but was intimately familiar with your situation, I was stripped of all reasonable excuse or defense. But I say exactly the opposite: in such matters careful examination is necessary, and whoever is going to put someone forward as qualified for the priesthood should not rely on public reputation alone, but should himself, above all and before all, investigate the man's character. For when the blessed Paul says, "He must also have a good report of them which are without," he does not dispense with exact and rigorous inquiry, nor does he give such testimony priority over the scrutiny required in such cases. For after much prior discussion, he mentioned this additional testimony, showing that one must not be satisfied with it alone for appointments of this kind, but must consider it along with everything else. For public reputation often speaks falsely; but when careful investigation comes first, no further danger need be feared from it. For this reason, after the other kinds of evidence he places the testimony that comes from those who are without. For he did not simply say "he must have a good report," but added the words "from them which are without," wanting to show that before the report of those outside he must be carefully examined. Therefore, since I myself knew your affairs better than your parents, as you yourself acknowledged, I deserve to be released from all blame.

Chrysostom: Nay! I will not proceed to those questions until I have resolved such as concern yourself alone, if you were to ask me ten thousand times to dispose of these charges. You said indeed that ignorance would bring me forgiveness, and that I should have been free from all accusation if I had brought you into your present position not knowing anything about you, but that as I did not betray you in ignorance, but was intimately acquainted with your affairs, I was deprived of all reasonable pretext and excuse. But I say precisely the reverse: for in such matters there is need of careful scrutiny, and he who is going to present any one as qualified for the priesthood ought not to be content with public report only, but should also himself, above all and before all, investigate the man's character. For when the blessed Paul says, He must also have a good report of them which are without, 1 Timothy 3:7 he does not dispense with an exact and rigorous inquiry, nor does he assign to such testimony precedence over the scrutiny required in such cases. For after much previous discourse, he mentioned this additional testimony, proving that one must not be contented with it alone for elections of this kind, but take it into consideration along with the rest. For public report often speaks false; but when careful investigation precedes, no further danger need be apprehended from it. On this account, after the other kinds of evidence he places that which comes from those who are without. For he did not simply say, he must have a good report, but added the words, from them which are without, wishing to show that before the report of those without he must be carefully examined. Inasmuch, then, as I myself knew your affairs better than your parents, as you also yourself acknowledged, I might deserve to be released from all blame.

Basil: No, this is the very reason why you could not escape blame if someone chose to accuse you. Don't you remember hearing from me, and often learning from my actual behavior, how weak my character is? Weren't you constantly mocking me for my cowardice, because I was so easily discouraged by everyday troubles?

Basil: Nay this is the very reason why you could not escape, if any one chose to indite you. Do you not remember hearing from me, and often learning from my actual conduct, the feebleness of my character? Were you not perpetually taunting me for my pusillanimity, because I was so easily dejected by ordinary cares?

I do remember hearing you say such things often, and I won't deny it. But if I ever taunted you, I did it playfully, not seriously. However, I'm not going to argue about these matters now, and I ask the same tolerance from you while I want to mention some of the good qualities you possess. For if you try to prove that what I'm saying is false, I won't hold back, but will show that you're saying these things more to put yourself down than to speak the truth, and I'll use nothing but your own words and actions as evidence to prove my point. Now the first question I want to ask you is this: do you know how great the power of love is? For leaving aside all the miracles that were to be performed by the apostles, Christ said, "By this everyone will know that you are my disciples if you love one another" (John 13:35), and Paul said that it was the fulfillment of the law (Romans 13:10) and that without it no spiritual gift had any value. Well, this excellent virtue, the distinguishing mark of Christ's disciples, the gift that is greater than all other gifts—I have seen it deeply rooted in your soul and producing much fruit.

5. Chrysostom: I do indeed remember often hearing such things said by you; I would not deny it. But if I ever taunted you, I did it in sport and not in serious truth. However, I do not now dispute about these matters, and I claim the same degree of forbearance from you while I wish to make mention of some of the good qualities which you possess. For if you attempt to convict me of saying what is untrue, I shall not spare you, but shall prove that you say these things rather by way of self-depreciation than with a view to truth, and I will employ no evidence but your own words and deeds to demonstrate the truth of my assertion. And now the first question I wish to ask of you is this: do you know how great the power of love is? For omitting all the miracles which were to be wrought by the apostles, Christ said, Hereby shall men know that you are my disciples if you love one another, John 13:35 and Paul said that it was the fulfilling of the law, Romans 13:10 and that in default of it no spiritual gift had any profit. Well, this choice good, the distinguishing mark of Christ's disciples, the gift which is higher than all other gifts, I perceived to be deeply implanted in your soul, and teeming with much fruit.

I do acknowledge that this matter is of deep concern to me, and that I try very earnestly to keep this commandment, but I have not succeeded even halfway in doing so. You yourself would bear witness to this if you would stop speaking out of favoritism and simply respect the truth.

Basil: I acknowledge indeed that the matter is one of deep concern to me, and that I endeavor most earnestly to keep this commandment, but that I have not even half succeeded in so doing, even you yourself would bear me witness if you would leave off talking out of partiality, and simply respect the truth.

Chrysostom: Well then, I will turn to my evidence and do what I threatened—proving that you want to put yourself down rather than speak the truth. But I will mention something that just happened, so no one can suspect me of trying to obscure the truth by bringing up events from long ago, when the passage of time and forgetfulness would prevent anyone from objecting to things I might say just to flatter you. For when one of our close friends was falsely accused of insult and foolishness and was in extreme danger, you threw yourself into the middle of that danger, even though no one summoned you or the person in danger appealed to you. That is the fact. But to convict you out of your own mouth, I will remind you of the words you spoke. When some people disapproved of this zeal while others praised and admired it, you said to those who accused you: "How can I help myself? I do not know how to love in any other way than by giving up my life when it is necessary to save any of my friends who is in danger." In this you repeated, in different words but with the same meaning, what Christ said to his disciples when he defined perfect love: "Greater love has no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends." If it is impossible to find greater love than this, you have reached its limit, and by both your deeds and your words have reached the summit. This is why I betrayed you, this is why I devised that plot. Do I now convince you that it was not from any malicious intent or from any desire to thrust you into danger, but from a conviction of your future usefulness that I dragged you into this course?

6. Chrysostom: Well, then, I shall betake myself to my evidences, and shall now do what I threatened, proving that you wish to disparage yourself rather than to speak the truth. But I will mention a fact which has only just occurred, that no one may suspect me of attempting to obscure the truth by the great lapse of time in relating events long past, as oblivion would then prevent any objection being made to the things which I might say with a view to gratification. For when one of our intimate friends, having been falsely accused of insult and folly, was in extreme peril, you then flung yourself into the midst of the danger, although you were not summoned by any one, or appealed to by the person who was about to be involved in danger. Such was the fact: but that I may convict you out of your own mouth, I will remind you of the words you uttered: for when some did not approve of this zeal, while others commended and admired it, How can I help myself? you said to those who accused you, for I do not know how otherwise to love than by giving up my life when it is necessary to save any of my friends who is in danger: thus repeating, in different words, indeed, but with the same meaning, what Christ said to his disciples when he laid down the definition of perfect love. Greater love, He said, has no man than this that a man lay down his life for his friends. If then it is impossible to find greater love than this, you have attained its limit, and both by your deeds and words have crowned the summit. This is why I betrayed you, this is why I contrived that plot. Do I now convince you that it was not from any malicious intent, nor from any desire to thrust you into danger, but from a persuasion of your future usefulness that I dragged you into this course?

Basil: Do you think that love alone is enough to correct other people?

Basil: Do you then suppose that love is sufficient for the correction of one's fellowmen?

Chrysostom: It would certainly contribute greatly to this goal. But if you want me to provide evidence of your practical wisdom as well, I will do so, and I will prove that your understanding surpasses your lovingkindness.

Chrysostom: Certainly it would contribute in a great measure to this end. But if you wish me to produce evidence of your practical wisdom also, I will proceed to do so, and will prove that your understanding exceeds your lovingkindness.

At these remarks he blushed deeply and said, "Let my character be set aside now, for it was not about this that I originally asked for an explanation. But if you have any valid answer to make to those who are outside, I would gladly hear what you have to say. Therefore, abandoning this pointless argument, tell me what defense I shall make, both to those who have honored you and to those who are distressed on their behalf, since they consider themselves to be insulted."

At these remarks he blushed scarlet and said, Let my character be now dismissed: for it was not about this that I originally demanded an explanation; but if you have any just answer to make to those who are without, I would gladly hear what you have to say. Wherefore, abandoning this vain contest, tell me what defense I shall make, both to those who have honored you and to those who are distressed on their account, considering them to be insulted.

This is just the point I am finally hastening toward, for since my explanation to you has been completed, I shall easily turn to this part of my defense. What then is the accusation these persons make, and what are their charges? They say that they have been insulted and grievously wronged by me because I have not accepted the honor which they wished to confer upon me. Now in the first place I say that no account should be taken of the insult shown to men, seeing that by paying honor to them I should be compelled to offend God. And I should say to those who are displeased that it is not safe to take offense at these things, but that doing so does them much harm. For I think that those who ground themselves in God and look to Him alone ought to be so religiously disposed as not to consider such a thing an insult, even if they happened to be dishonored a thousand times. But that I have not gone so far as even to think of daring anything of this kind is clear from what I am about to say. For if indeed I had been motivated by arrogance and vainglory, as you have often said some slanderously claim, to agree with my accusers, I should have been one of the most wicked of mankind, having treated great and excellent men, who are moreover my benefactors, with contempt. For if men ought to be punished for wronging those who have never wronged them, how much more ought we to honor those who have spontaneously chosen to honor us? For no one could possibly say that they were repaying me for any benefits small or great which they had received at my hands. How great a punishment then would one deserve if one repaid them in the opposite manner. But if such a thing never entered my mind, and I declined the heavy burden with quite a different intention, why do they refuse to pardon me (even if they do not consent to approve), but accuse me of having selfishly spared my own soul? For far from having insulted the men in question I should say that I had even honored them by my refusal.

7. Chrysostom: This is just the point to which I am finally hastening, for as my explanation to you has been completed I shall easily turn to this part of my defense. What then is the accusation made by these persons, and what are their charges? They say that they have been insulted and grievously wronged by me because I have not accepted the honor which they wished to confer upon me. Now in the first place I say that no account should be taken of the insult shown to men, seeing that by paying honor to them I should be compelled to offend God. And I should say to those who are displeased that it is not safe to take offense at these things, but does them much harm. For I think that those who stay themselves on God and look to Him alone, ought to be so religiously disposed as not to account such a thing an insult, even if they happened to be a thousand times dishonored. But that I have not gone so far as even to think of daring anything of this kind is manifest from what I am about to say. For if indeed I had been induced by arrogance and vainglory, as you have often said some slanderously affirm, to assent to my accusers, I should have been one of the most iniquitous of mankind, having treated great and excellent men, my benefactors moreover, with contempt. For if men ought to be punished for wronging those who have never wronged them, how ought we to honor those who have spontaneously preferred to honor us? For no one could possibly say that they were requiting me for any benefits small or great which they had received at my hands. How great a punishment then would one deserve if one requited them in the contrary manner. But if such a thing never entered my mind, and I declined the heavy burden with quite a different intention, why do they refuse to pardon me (even if they do not consent to approve), but accuse me of having selfishly spared my own soul? For so far from having insulted the men in question I should say that I had even honored them by my refusal.

Do not be surprised by how paradoxical my statement sounds, because I will quickly explain it.

And do not be surprised at the paradoxical nature of my remark, for I shall supply a speedy solution of it.

For had I accepted the office, I do not say all people, but those who enjoy speaking maliciously might have suspected and said many things about me as the one elected and about them as the electors: for example, that they valued wealth, admired high social rank, or had been swayed by flattery to promote me to this honor—indeed I cannot say whether someone might not have suspected that they were bribed with money. Moreover, they would have said that Christ called fishermen, tentmakers, and tax collectors to this dignity, whereas these men reject those who support themselves by daily labor, but if there is anyone who devotes himself to secular learning and is raised in leisure, him they receive and admire. For why, I ask, have they passed over men who have undergone countless labors in the service of the Church and suddenly dragged into this dignity one who has never experienced any labors of this kind but has spent all his youth in the useless study of secular learning? These things and more they might have said had I accepted the office, but not so now. For every excuse for slander is now taken away from them, and they can accuse neither me of flattery nor the others of receiving bribes, unless some choose to act like complete madmen. For how could one who used flattery and spent money in order to obtain the dignity have handed it over to others when he could have obtained it? For this would be just as if a man who had devoted much labor to the ground so that the grain field might be loaded with abundant produce and the presses overflow with wine, after countless labors and great expenditure of money, were to hand over the fruits to others just when it was time to reap his grain and gather in his vintage. Do you see that although what was said might be far from the truth, nevertheless those who wished to slander the electors would then have had an excuse for claiming that the choice was made without sound judgment and consideration? But as it is I have prevented them from being loud-mouthed or even uttering a single word on the subject. Such then and more would have been their remarks at the outset. But after undertaking the ministry I would not have been able day by day to defend myself against accusers, even if I had done everything faultlessly, to say nothing of the many mistakes I inevitably would have made owing to my youth and inexperience. But now I have saved the electors from this kind of accusation as well, whereas in the other case I would have involved them in countless reproaches. For what would not the world have said? They have committed affairs of such vast interest and importance to thoughtless youths, they have defiled the flock of God, and Christian affairs have become a joke and a laughingstock. But now all iniquity shall stop her mouth. For although they may say these things on your account, you will quickly teach them by your actions that understanding is not to be measured by age, and the grey head is not to be the test of an elder—that the young man ought not to be absolutely excluded from the ministry, but only the novice: and the difference between the two is great.

8. For had I accepted the office, I do not say all men, but those who take pleasure in speaking evil, might have suspected and said many things concerning myself who had been elected and concerning them, the electors: for instance, that they regarded wealth, and admired splendor of rank, or had been induced by flattery to promote me to this honor: indeed I cannot say whether some one might not have suspected that they were bribed by money. Moreover, they would have said, Christ called fishermen, tentmakers, and publicans to this dignity, whereas these men reject those who support themselves by daily labor: but if there be any one who devotes himself to secular learning, and is brought up in idleness, him they receive and admire. For why, pray, have they passed by men who have undergone innumerable toils in the service of the Church, and suddenly dragged into this dignity one who has never experienced any labors of this kind, but has spent all his youth in the vain study of secular learning. These things and more they might have said had I accepted the office: but not so now. For every pretext for maligning is now cut away from them, and they can neither accuse me of flattery, nor the others of receiving bribes, unless some choose to act like mere madmen. For how could one who used flattery and expended money in order to obtain the dignity, have abandoned it to others when he might have obtained it? For this would be just as if a man who had bestowed much labor upon the ground in order that the grain field might be laden with abundant produce, and the presses overflow with wine, after innumerable toils and great expenditure of money were to surrender the fruits to others just when it was time to reap his grain and gather in his vintage. Do you see that although what was said might be far from the truth, nevertheless those who wished to calumniate the electors would then have had a pretext for alleging that the choice was made without fair judgment and consideration. But as it is I have prevented them from being open mouthed, or even uttering a single word on the subject. Such then and more would have been their remarks at the outset. But after undertaking the ministry I should not have been able day by day to defend myself against accusers, even if I had done everything faultlessly, to say nothing of the many mistakes which I must have made owing to my youth and inexperience. But now I have saved the electors from this kind of accusation also, whereas in the other case I should have involved them in innumerable reproaches. For what would not the world have said? They have committed affairs of such vast interest and importance to thoughtless youths, they have defiled the flock of God, and Christian affairs have become a jest and a laughing-stock. But now all iniquity shall stop her mouth. For although they may say these things on your account, you will speedily teach them by your acts that understanding is not to be estimated by age, and the grey head is not to be the test of an elder — that the young man ought not to be absolutely excluded from the ministry, but only the novice: and the difference between the two is great.


On the Priesthood — Book I

On the Priesthood, Book I: the dialogue with Basil on the dignity and dangers of priestly ministry.

Source: Translated by W.R.W. Stephens. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 9. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/19221.htm>.

Opening

I had many genuine and true friends who understood the laws of friendship and faithfully observed them. But out of this large number, there was one who exceeded all the rest in his attachment to me, striving to surpass them as much as they themselves surpassed ordinary acquaintances. He was one of those who were constantly at my side, for we were engaged in the same studies and employed the same teachers. We had the same eagerness and zeal about the studies at which we worked, and a passionate desire produced by the same circumstances was equally strong in both of us. For not only when we were attending school, but also after we had left it, when it became necessary to consider what course of life it would be best for us to adopt, we found ourselves to be of the same mind.

1. I had many genuine and true friends, men who understood the laws of friendship, and faithfully observed them; but out of this large number there was one who excelled all the rest in his attachment to me, striving to outstrip them as much as they themselves outstripped ordinary acquaintance. He was one of those who were constantly at my side; for we were engaged in the same studies, and employed the same teachers. We had the same eagerness and zeal about the studies at which we worked, and a passionate desire produced by the same circumstances was equally strong in both of us. For not only when we were attending school, but after we had left it, when it became necessary to consider what course of life it would be best for us to adopt, we found ourselves to be of the same mind.

And beyond these things, there were other factors that preserved and maintained this harmony unbroken and secure. Regarding the greatness of our homeland, neither of us had reason to boast over the other, nor was I weighed down with riches while he was constrained by poverty. Instead, our resources matched as closely as our interests. Our families were also of equal social standing, and so everything aligned with our natural inclination toward friendship.

2. And in addition to these, there were other things also which preserved and maintained this concord unbroken and secure. For as regarded the greatness of our fatherland neither had one cause to vaunt himself over the other, nor was I burdened with riches, and he pinched by poverty, but our means corresponded as closely as our tastes. Our families also were of equal rank, and thus everything concurred with our disposition.

But when it became our duty to pursue the blessed life of monks and the true philosophy, our balance was no longer even. His scale rose high, while I, still entangled in the lusts of this world, dragged mine down and kept it low, weighting it with those fantasies that young people are prone to indulge in. From that point forward our friendship remained as strong as it was before, but our contact was interrupted, for it was impossible for people who were not interested in the same things to spend much time together. But as soon as I too began to emerge a little from the flood of worldliness, he received me with open arms. Yet not even then could we maintain our former equality, for having gotten a head start in time and having shown great earnestness, he rose again above my level and soared to a great height.

3. But when it became our duty to pursue the blessed life of monks, and the true philosophy, our balance was no longer even, but his scale mounted high, while I, still entangled in the lusts of this world, dragged mine down and kept it low, weighting it with those fancies in which youths are apt to indulge. For the future our friendship indeed remained as firm as it was before, but our intercourse was interrupted; for it was impossible for persons who were not interested about the same things to spend much time together. But as soon as I also began to emerge a little from the flood of worldliness, he received me with open arms; yet not even thus could we maintain our former equality: for having got the start of me in time, and having displayed great earnestness, he rose again above my level, and soared to a great height.

Being a good man and valuing my friendship highly, he separated himself from all the rest of the brethren and spent all his time with me, which he had wanted to do before but had been prevented, as I was saying, by my frivolity. For it was impossible for a man who attended the law courts and was excited about the pleasures of the theater to spend much time with someone who was devoted to his books and never set foot in the marketplace. Consequently, when the obstacles were removed and he had brought me into the same way of life as himself, he freely expressed the desire he had long been holding. He could not bear to leave me even for a moment, and he persistently urged that we should each abandon our own home and share a common dwelling. In fact, he persuaded me, and the matter was set in motion.

4. Being a good man, however, and placing a high value on my friendship, he separated himself from all the rest (of the brethren), and spent the whole of his time with me, which he had desired to do before, but had been prevented as I was saying by my frivolity. For it was impossible for a man who attended the law-courts, and was in a flutter of excitement about the pleasures of the stage, to be often in the company of one who was nailed to his books, and never set foot in the market place. Consequently when the hindrances were removed, and he had brought me into the same condition of life as himself, he gave free vent to the desire with which he had long been laboring. He could not bear leaving me even for a moment, and he persistently urged that we should each of us abandon our own home and share a common dwelling:– in fact he persuaded me, and the affair was taken in hand.

But my mother's constant pleas prevented me from granting him this favor—or rather, from receiving this benefit from him. For when she realized I was considering this step, she brought me into her private room and sat down beside me on the bed where she had given birth to me. She poured out floods of tears, and then added words even more pitiful than her weeping, lamenting as follows: My child, Heaven did not allow me to enjoy for long the blessing of your father's virtue. His death came soon after the labor pains I suffered at your birth, leaving you an orphan and me a widow before my time to face all the terrible hardships of widowhood, which only those who have experienced them can truly understand. No words can adequately describe the turbulent situation of a young woman who has only recently left her father's house and has no experience in managing affairs, when she is suddenly overwhelmed by crushing grief and forced to carry a burden of responsibility too heavy for her age and sex. She must deal with lazy servants and watch out for their dishonesty, defend against scheming relatives, bravely endure the threats of tax collectors and harsh tax assessments. And if the deceased has left behind a child, even if it is a daughter, this causes the mother great anxiety, though with less expense and fear—but a son fills her with countless fears and many worries every day, not to mention the great expense she must bear if she wants to raise him properly. Yet none of these things persuaded me to remarry or bring a second husband into your father's house. Instead I persevered as I was, amid all the storm and chaos, and did not shrink from the iron furnace of widowhood. My primary help was indeed the grace from above, but it was no small comfort to me in those terrible trials to look constantly at your face and to preserve in you a living image of the one who had departed—an image that was truly a close likeness.

5. But the continual lamentations of my mother hindered me from granting him the favor, or rather from receiving this boon at his hands. For when she perceived that I was meditating this step, she took me into her own private chamber, and, sitting near me on the bed where she had given birth to me, she shed torrents of tears, to which she added words yet more pitiable than her weeping, in the following lamentable strain: My child, it was not the will of Heaven that I should long enjoy the benefit of your father's virtue. For his death soon followed the pangs which I endured at your birth, leaving you an orphan and me a widow before my time to face all the horrors of widowhood, which only those who have experienced them can fairly understand. For no words are adequate to describe the tempest-tossed condition of a young woman who, having but lately left her paternal home, and being inexperienced in business, is suddenly racked by an overwhelming sorrow, and compelled to support a load of care too great for her age and sex. For she has to correct the laziness of servants, and to be on the watch for their rogueries, to repel the designs of relations, to bear bravely the threats of those who collect the public taxes, and harshness in the imposition of rates. And if the departed one should have left a child, even if it be a girl, great anxiety will be caused to the mother, although free from much expense and fear: but a boy fills her with ten thousand alarms and many anxieties every day, to say nothing of the great expense which one is compelled to incur if she wishes to bring him up in a liberal way. None of these things, however, induced me to enter into a second marriage, or introduce a second husband into your father's house: but I held on as I was, in the midst of the storm and uproar, and did not shun the iron furnace of widowhood. My foremost help indeed was the grace from above; but it was no small consolation to me under those terrible trials to look continually on your face and to preserve in you a living image of him who had gone, an image indeed which was a fairly exact likeness.

On this account, even when you were an infant and had not yet learned to speak—a time when children give their parents the greatest delight—you gave me much comfort. You cannot complain that, although I bore my widowhood bravely, I diminished your inheritance, which I know has been the fate of many who have had the misfortune of being orphans. For besides keeping all of it intact, I spared no expense that was needed to give you an honorable position, spending for this purpose some of my own fortune and my marriage dowry. Yet do not think that I say these things to reproach you. In return for all these benefits I ask one favor: do not plunge me into a second widowhood or revive the grief that is now laid to rest. Wait for my death. Perhaps in a little while I will depart. The young look forward to a distant old age, but we who have grown old have nothing but death to wait for. When you have committed my body to the ground and mingled my bones with your father's, embark for a long voyage and set sail on any sea you wish. Then there will be no one to hinder you. But as long as my life lasts, be content to live with me. Do not, I beg you, oppose God in vain, involving me without cause—when I have done you no wrong—in these great calamities. For if you have any reason to complain that I drag you into worldly cares and force you to attend to business, do not be restrained by any reverence for the laws of nature, for training or custom, but flee from me as an enemy. But if, on the contrary, I do everything to provide leisure for your journey through this life, let this bond at least, if nothing else, keep you by me. For though you could say that ten thousand people loved you, no one will afford you the enjoyment of so much freedom, since there is no one who is equally anxious for your welfare.

On this account, even when you were an infant, and had not yet learned to speak, a time when children are the greatest delight to their parents, you afforded me much comfort. Nor indeed can you complain that, although I bore my widowhood bravely, I diminished your patrimony, which I know has been the fate of many who have had the misfortune to be orphans. For, besides keeping the whole of it intact, I spared no expense which was needful to give you an honorable position, spending for this purpose some of my own fortune, and of my marriage dowry. Yet do not think that I say these things by way of reproaching you; only in return for all these benefits I beg one favor: do not plunge me into a second widowhood; nor revive the grief which is now laid to rest: wait for my death: it may be in a little while I shall depart. The young indeed look forward to a distant old age; but we who have grown old have nothing but death to wait for. When, then, you shall have committed my body to the ground, and mingled my bones with your father's, embark for a long voyage, and set sail on any sea you will: then there will be no one to hinder you: but as long as my life lasts, be content to live with me. Do not, I pray you, oppose God in vain, involving me without cause, who have done you no wrong, in these great calamities. For if you have any reason to complain that I drag you into worldly cares, and force you to attend to business, do not be restrained by any reverence for the laws of nature, for training or custom, but fly from me as an enemy; but if, on the contrary, I do everything to provide leisure for your journey through this life, let this bond at least if nothing else keep you by me. For could thou say that ten thousand loved you, yet no one will afford you the enjoyment of so much liberty, seeing there is no one who is equally anxious for your welfare.

These words, and more, my mother spoke to me, and I related them to that noble young man. But he, far from being discouraged by these words, was even more insistent in making the same request as before. Now while we were in this situation, he continually pleading and I refusing to agree, we were both disturbed by a report that suddenly reached us that we were about to be raised to the office of bishop. As soon as I heard this rumor I was seized with alarm and confusion: alarm that I might be captured against my will, and confusion, asking myself repeatedly where these men could have gotten such an idea about us, for when I looked at myself I found nothing worthy of such an honor. But that noble young man came to me privately and discussed these things with me as if I knew nothing of the rumor. He begged that in this situation we should also, as we had done before, take the same action and follow the same plan. He would readily follow me whatever course I might take, whether I tried to flee or submitted to being captured. Seeing his eagerness, and considering that I would cause a loss to the whole Church if, because of my own weakness, I deprived the flock of Christ of a young man who was so good and so well qualified to oversee large numbers of people, I held back from revealing to him the plan I had formed, although I had never before kept any of my plans hidden from him. I now told him that it would be best to postpone our decision about this matter to another time, since it was not immediately urgent, and by doing this I persuaded him to put it out of his mind, and at the same time I encouraged him to hope that if such a thing should ever happen to us, I would be of the same mind with him. But after a short time, when someone who was to ordain us arrived, I kept myself hidden, but Basil, not knowing this, was taken away on another pretext and made to take on the yoke, hoping from the promises I had made to him that I would certainly follow, or rather thinking that he was following me. For some of those who were present, seeing that he resented being seized, deceived him by exclaiming how strange it was that the one who was generally considered to be more hot-tempered (meaning me) had yielded very mildly to the judgment of the Fathers, whereas he, who was considered a much wiser and milder person, had shown himself hot-headed and arrogant, being unruly, stubborn, and contrary. Having yielded to these criticisms, and afterwards having learned that I had escaped capture, he came to me in deep dejection, sat down near me and tried to speak, but was prevented by distress of mind and inability to put into words the violence that had been done to him. As soon as he opened his mouth he was prevented from speaking by grief cutting off his words before they could pass his lips. Seeing his tearful and agitated state, and knowing the cause, I laughed for joy, and, seizing his right hand, I forced a kiss on him and praised God that my plan had succeeded so well, as I had always prayed it would. But when he saw that I was delighted and beaming with joy, and understood that he had been deceived by me, he was even more upset and distressed.

6. These words, and more, my mother spoke to me, and I related them to that noble youth. But he, so far from being disheartened by these speeches, was the more urgent in making the same request as before. Now while we were thus situated, he continually entreating, and I refusing my assent, we were both of us disturbed by a report suddenly reaching us that we were about to be advanced to the dignity of the episcopate. As soon as I heard this rumor I was seized with alarm and perplexity: with alarm lest I should be made captive against my will, and perplexity, inquiring as I often did whence any such idea concerning us could have entered the minds of these men; for looking to myself I found nothing worthy of such an honor. But that noble youth having come to me privately, and having conferred with me about these things as if with one who was ignorant of the rumor, begged that we might in this instance also as formerly shape our action and our counsels the same way: for he would readily follow me whichever course I might pursue, whether I attempted flight or submitted to be captured. Perceiving then his eagerness, and considering that I should inflict a loss upon the whole body of the Church if, owing to my own weakness, I were to deprive the flock of Christ of a young man who was so good and so well qualified for the supervision of large numbers, I abstained from disclosing to him the purpose which I had formed, although I had never before allowed any of my plans to be concealed from him. I now told him that it would be best to postpone our decision concerning this matter to another season, as it was not immediately pressing, and by so doing persuaded him to dismiss it from his thoughts, and at the same time encouraged him to hope that, if such a thing should ever happen to us, I should be of the same mind with him. But after a short time, when one who was to ordain us arrived, I kept myself concealed, but Basil, ignorant of this, was taken away on another pretext, and made to take the yoke, hoping from the promises which I had made to him that I should certainly follow, or rather supposing that he was following me. For some of those who were present, seeing that he resented being seized, deceived him by exclaiming how strange it was that one who was generally reputed to be the more hot tempered (meaning me), had yielded very mildly to the judgment of the Fathers, whereas he, who was reckoned a much wiser and milder kind of man, had shown himself hotheaded and conceited, being unruly, restive, and contradictory. Having yielded to these remonstrances, and afterwards having learned that I had escaped capture, he came to me in deep dejection, sat down near me and tried to speak, but was hindered by distress of mind and inability to express in words the violence to which he had been subjected. No sooner had he opened his mouth than he was prevented from utterance by grief cutting short his words before they could pass his lips. Seeing, then, his tearful and agitated condition, and knowing as I did the cause, I laughed for joy, and, seizing his right hand, I forced a kiss on him, and praised God that my plan had ended so successfully, as I had always prayed it might. But when he saw that I was delighted and beaming with joy, and understood that he had been deceived by me, he was yet more vexed and distressed.

When he had calmed down a bit from this emotional turmoil, he began: If you have rejected the position assigned to you and no longer care about me (though I don't know why), you should at least consider your own reputation. But as things stand, you have set everyone talking, and people are saying that you turned down this ministry out of love of vainglory, and no one will acquit you of this charge. As for me, I can't bear to go to the marketplace; so many people approach me there and criticize me every day. Whenever they see me anywhere in the city, all my close friends pull me aside and put most of the blame on me. They say, "Since you knew his intention—for none of his affairs could have been hidden from you—you should not have concealed it but should have told us, and we would have found some way to capture him." But I'm too ashamed and embarrassed to tell them that I didn't know you had been plotting this trick for so long, in case they conclude that our friendship was only a pretense. For even if that's true, as it really is—and you yourself wouldn't deny it after what you've done to me—still it's better to hide our misfortune from outsiders and people who only have a moderate opinion of us. I'm reluctant to tell them the truth about how things really are between us, and so I'm forced from now on to keep quiet, look down at the ground, and turn away to avoid people I meet. For if I escape condemnation on the first charge, I'm forced to face judgment for lying. They will never believe me when I say that you counted Basil among those not allowed to know your private affairs. However, I won't dwell on this too much, since it seems acceptable to you, but how shall we endure the disgrace to come? Some people accuse you of arrogance, others of vainglory, while our more lenient critics charge us with both these offenses and add that we have insulted those who honored us—though even if they had suffered greater indignity it would have served them right for passing over so many distinguished men and promoting mere youths who until yesterday were absorbed in worldly affairs to such a dignity as they never dreamed of obtaining, just so they can for a short time knit their brows, wear dark clothing, and put on a serious expression. Those who from early manhood to extreme old age have diligently practiced self-discipline are now to be placed under the authority of youths who haven't even heard the laws that should govern their administration of this office. I am constantly attacked by people saying such things and worse, and I don't know how to respond to them. But please tell me: for I don't suppose you fled and incurred such hatred from such distinguished men without cause or thought, but that you made your decision with reasoning and careful consideration. So I assume you have some argument ready for your defense. Tell me, then, whether there is any reasonable excuse I can make to those who accuse us.

7. And when he had a little recovered from this agitation of mind, he began: If you have rejected the part allotted to you, and have no further regard for me (I know not indeed for what cause), you ought at least to consider your own reputation; but as it is you have opened the mouths of all, and the world is saying that you have declined this ministry through love of vainglory, and there is no one who will deliver you from this accusation. As for me, I cannot bear to go into the market place; there are so many who come up to me and reproach me every day. For, when they see me anywhere in the city, all my intimate friends take me aside, and cast the greater part of the blame upon me. Knowing his intention, they say, for none of his affairs could be kept secret from you, you should not have concealed it, but ought to have communicated it to us, and we should have been at no loss to devise some plan for capturing him. But I am too much ashamed and abashed to tell them that I did not know you had long been plotting this trick, lest they should say that our friendship was a mere pretence. For even if it is so, as indeed it is — nor would you yourself deny it after what you have done to me — yet it is well to hide our misfortune from the outside world, and persons who entertain but a moderate opinion of us. I shrink from telling them the truth, and how things really stand with us, and I am compelled in future to keep silence, and look down on the ground, and turn away to avoid those whom I meet. For if I escape the condemnation on the former charge, I am forced to undergo judgment for speaking falsehood. For they will never believe me when I say that you ranged Basil among those who are not permitted to know your secret affairs. Of this, however, I will not take much account, since it has seemed agreeable to you, but how shall we endure the future disgrace? For some accuse you of arrogance, others of vainglory: while those who are our more merciful accusers, lay both these offenses to our charge, and add that we have insulted those who did us honor, although had they experienced even greater indignity it would only have served them right for passing over so many and such distinguished men and advancing mere youths, who were but yesterday immersed in the interests of this world, to such a dignity as they never have dreamed of obtaining, in order that they may for a brief season knit the eyebrows, wear dusky garments, and put on a grave face. Those who from the dawn of manhood to extreme old age have diligently practised self-discipline, are now to be placed under the government of youths who have not even heard the laws which should regulate their administration of this office. I am perpetually assailed by persons who say such things and worse, and am at a loss how to reply to them; but I pray you tell me: for I do not suppose that you took to flight and incurred such hatred from such distinguished men without cause or consideration, but that your decision was made with reasoning and circumspection: whence also I conjecture that you have some argument ready for your defense. Tell me, then, whether there is any fair excuse which I can make to those who accuse us.

I'm not demanding any account for the wrongs I've suffered from you, nor for the deceit or treachery you've practiced, nor for the advantage you gained from me in the past. I placed my very life, so to speak, in your hands, yet you treated me with as much cunning as if you needed to guard yourself against an enemy. If you knew this decision of ours to be beneficial, you shouldn't have avoided the gain. If on the contrary it was harmful, you should have saved me from the loss as well, since you always said you valued me above everyone else. But you did everything to make me fall into the trap, and you had no need for cunning and pretense in dealing with someone who always displayed the utmost sincerity and openness in speech and action toward you. Nevertheless, as I said, I'm not now accusing you of any of these things or reproaching you for the lonely position you've placed me in by ending those conversations from which we often gained considerable pleasure and benefit. I pass over all these things and bear them in silence and gentleness—not because you've acted gently in wronging me, but because from the day I cherished your friendship I made it a rule for myself that whatever sorrow you might cause me, I would never force you into having to apologize. You know yourself that you've caused me no small loss, if you remember what we always said ourselves, and what others said about us: that it was a great gain for us to be of one mind and protected by each other's friendship. Everyone indeed said that our harmony would bring considerable advantage to many besides ourselves. I never saw, however, as far as I'm concerned, how it could benefit others, but I did say we would at least gain this benefit from it: that those who wished to oppose us would find us difficult to defeat. And I never stopped reminding you of these things, saying: the age is cruel, scheming people are many, genuine love no longer exists, and the deadly plague of envy has crept in to take its place. We walk amid snares and along the edge of walls. Those who are ready to rejoice in our misfortunes, should any befall us, are many and surround us on all sides, whereas there is no one to sympathize with us, or at least such people can easily be counted. Beware that through separation we don't incur much ridicule and damage worse than ridicule. A brother helped by a brother is like a strong city and well-fortified kingdom. Don't dissolve this genuine intimacy or break down the fortress. I was continually saying such things and more—not because I ever suspected anything of this kind, but supposing you to be entirely sound in your relationship toward me, I did it as an extra precaution, wishing to keep someone already healthy in good health. But unknowingly, it seems, I was giving medicine to a sick man, and even so I haven't been fortunate enough to do any good and have gained nothing from my excessive caution. Having completely cast aside all these considerations without giving them a thought, you've set me adrift like a ship without ballast on an untested ocean, paying no attention to those fierce waves I must face. If I should ever suffer slander or mockery or any other kind of insult or threat (and such things must happen frequently), to whom will I flee for refuge? To whom will I confide my distress? Who will be willing to help me, drive back my attackers, and stop their assaults? Who will comfort me and prepare me to bear the crude mockery that may still await me? There is no one, since you stand apart from this terrible struggle and cannot even hear my cry. Do you see then what harm you've caused? Now that you've struck the blow, do you realize what a deadly wound you've inflicted? But let all this pass, for it's impossible to undo the past or find a path through insurmountable difficulties. What will I say to the outside world? What defense will I make against their accusations?

For I do not demand any account for the wrongs which I have sustained at your hands, nor for the deceit or treachery you have practised, nor for the advantage which you have derived from me in the past. For I placed my very life, so to say, in your hands, yet you have treated me with as much guile as if it had been your business to guard yourself against an enemy. Yet if you knew this decision of ours to be profitable, you ought not to have avoided the gain: if on the contrary injurious, you should have saved me also from the loss, as you always said that you esteemed me before every one else. But you have done everything to make me fall into the snare: and you had no need of guile and hypocrisy in dealing with one who was wont to display the utmost sincerity and candor in speech and action towards you. Nevertheless, as I said, I do not now accuse you of any of these things, or reproach you for the lonely position in which you have placed me by breaking off those conferences from which we often derived no small pleasure and profit; but all these things I pass by, and bear in silence and meekness, not that you have acted meekly in transgressing against me, but because from the day that I cherished your friendship I laid it down as a rule for myself, that whatever sorrow you might cause me I would never force you to the necessity of an apology. For you know yourself that you have inflicted no small loss on me if at least you remember what we were always saying ourselves, and the outside world also said concerning us, that it was a great gain for us to be of one mind and be guarded by each other's friendship. Every one said, indeed, that our concord would bring no small advantage to many besides ourselves; I never perceived, however, so far as I am concerned, how it could be of advantage to others: but I did say that we should at least derive this benefit from it: that those who wished to contend with us would find us difficult to master. And I never ceased reminding you of these things: saying the age is a cruel one, and designing men are many, genuine love is no more, and the deadly pest of envy has crept into its place: we walk in the midst of snares, and on the edge of battlements; those who are ready to rejoice in our misfortunes, if any should befall us, are many and beset us from many quarters: whereas there is no one to condole with us, or at least the number of such may be easily counted. Beware that we do not by separation incur much ridicule, and damage worse than ridicule. Brother aided by brother is like a strong city, and well fortified kingdom. Do not dissolve this genuine intimacy, nor break down the fortress. Such things and more I was continually saying, not indeed that I ever suspected anything of this kind, but supposing you to be entirely sound in your relation towards me, I did it as a superfluous precaution, wishing to preserve in health one who was already sound; but unwittingly, as it seems, I was administering medicines to a sick man: and even so I have not been fortunate enough to do any good, and have gained nothing by my excess of forethought. For having totally cast away all these considerations, without giving them a thought, you have turned me adrift like an unballasted vessel on an untried ocean, taking no heed of those fierce billows which I must encounter. For if it should ever be my lot to undergo calumny, or mockery, or any other kind of insult or menace (and such things must frequently occur), to whom shall I fly for refuge: to whom shall I impart my distress, who will be willing to succour me and drive back my assailants and put a stop to their assaults? Who will solace me and prepare me to bear the coarse ribaldry which may yet be in store for me. There is no one since you stand aloof from this terrible strife, and cannot even hear my cry. Do you see then what mischief you have wrought? Now that you have dealt the blow, do you perceive what a deadly wound you have inflicted? But let all this pass: for it is impossible to undo the past, or to find a path through pathless difficulties. What shall I say to the outside world? What defense shall I make to their accusations.

Chrysostom: Cheer up, I replied, because I am not only ready to defend myself on these matters, but I will also try as best I can to give an account of those things you haven't even held me responsible for. In fact, if you want, I will start my defense with those very things. It would be absurd if I were so concerned about what the general public thinks of me, doing everything I can to answer their accusations, but failed to convince my dearest friend that I am not wronging him. It would be even worse if I showed less care for him than he has shown for me—since he has been so patient with me that he won't even accuse me of the wrongs he says he has suffered from me, and has set aside his own concerns out of consideration for mine.

8. Chrysostom: Be of good cheer, I replied, for I am not only ready to answer for myself in these matters, but I will also endeavor as well as I am able to render an account of those for which you have not held me answerable. Indeed, if you wish it, I will make them the starting-point of my defense. For it would be a strange piece of stupidity on my part if, thinking only of praise from the outside public, and doing my best to silence their accusations, I were unable to convince my dearest of all friends that I am not wronging him, and were to treat him with indifference greater than the zeal which he has displayed on my behalf, treating me with such forbearance as even to refrain from accusing me of the wrongs which he says he has suffered from me, and putting his own interests out of the question in consideration for mine.

What wrong have I done you, since I've decided to begin my defense at this point? Is it that I misled you and concealed my purpose? Yet I did it for the benefit of you who were deceived, and of those to whom I handed you over by means of this deception. For if the evil of deception is absolute, and it is never right to use it, I am prepared to accept any penalty you choose—or rather, since you will never bring yourself to inflict punishment on me, I will subject myself to the same condemnation that judges pronounce on wrongdoers when their accusers have convicted them. But if the thing is not always harmful, but becomes good or bad according to the intention of those who practice it, you must stop complaining about deception and prove that it has been devised against you for a bad purpose. And as long as this proof is lacking, it would only be fair for those who wish to conduct themselves wisely not only to refrain from reproaches and accusations, but even to give a friendly reception to the deceiver. For a well-timed deception, undertaken with an upright intention, has such advantages that many people have often had to undergo punishment for refusing to use fraud. And if you investigate the history of generals who have enjoyed the highest reputation from the earliest ages, you will find that most of their triumphs were achieved by stratagem, and that such victories are more highly praised than those won in open battle. For the latter conduct their campaigns with greater expenditure of money and men, so that they gain nothing by the victory but suffer just as much distress as those who have been defeated, both in the loss of troops and the exhaustion of funds. But besides this, they are not even permitted to enjoy all the glory that belongs to the victory, for no small part of it is claimed by those who have fallen, because in spirit they were victorious—their defeat was only a bodily one—so that if it had been possible for them not to fall when they were wounded, and death had not come and put the finishing stroke to their efforts, there would have been no end to their prowess. But one who has been able to gain victory by stratagem subjects the enemy to ridicule as well as disaster. Again, in the other case both sides equally carry off the honors bestowed upon valor, whereas in this case they do not equally obtain those which are bestowed on wisdom, but the prize falls entirely to the victors. And another point no less important is that they preserve the joy of victory for the state unmixed, for abundance of resources and multitudes of men are not like mental powers: the former, if continually used in war, necessarily become exhausted and fail those who possess them, whereas it is the nature of wisdom to increase the more it is exercised. And not in war only, but also in peace the need of deception may be found, not merely in affairs of the state, but also in private life, in the dealings of husband with wife and wife with husband, son with father, friend with friend, and also children with a parent. For the daughter of Saul would not have been able to rescue her husband out of Saul's hands except by deceiving her father. And her brother, wishing to save him whom she had rescued when he was again in danger, made use of the same weapon as the wife.

What is the wrong that I have done you, since I have determined to embark from this point upon the sea of apology? Is it that I misled you and concealed my purpose? Yet I did it for the benefit of yourself who wast deceived, and of those to whom I surrendered you by means of this deceit. For if the evil of deception is absolute, and it is never right to make use of it, I am prepared to pay any penalty you please: or rather, as you will never endure to inflict punishment upon me, I shall subject myself to the same condemnation which is pronounced by judges on evil-doers when their accusers have convicted them. But if the thing is not always harmful, but becomes good or bad according to the intention of those who practise it, you must desist from complaining of deceit, and prove that it has been devised against you for a bad purpose; and as long as this proof is wanting it would only be fair for those who wish to conduct themselves prudently, not only to abstain from reproaches and accusation, but even to give a friendly reception to the deceiver. For a well-timed deception, undertaken with an upright intention, has such advantages, that many persons have often had to undergo punishment for abstaining from fraud. And if you investigate the history of generals who have enjoyed the highest reputation from the earliest ages, you will find that most of their triumphs were achieved by stratagem, and that such are more highly commended than those who conquer in open fight. For the latter conduct their campaigns with greater expenditure of money and men, so that they gain nothing by the victory, but suffer just as much distress as those who have been defeated, both in the sacrifice of troops and the exhaustion of funds. But, besides this, they are not even permitted to enjoy all the glory which pertains to the victory; for no small part of it is reaped by those who have fallen, because in spirit they were victorious, their defeat was only a bodily one: so that had it been possible for them not to fall when they were wounded, and death had not come and put the finishing stroke to their labors, there would have been no end of their prowess. But one who has been able to gain the victory by stratagem involves the enemy in ridicule as well as disaster. Again, in the other case both sides equally carry off the honors bestowed upon valor, whereas in this case they do not equally obtain those which are bestowed on wisdom, but the prize falls entirely to the victors, and, another point no less important is that they preserve the joy of the victory for the state unalloyed; for abundance of resources and multitudes of men are not like mental powers: the former indeed if continually used in war necessarily become exhausted, and fail those who possess them, whereas it is the nature of wisdom to increase the more it is exercised. And not in war only, but also in peace the need of deceit may be found, not merely in reference to the affairs of the state, but also in private life, in the dealings of husband with wife and wife with husband, son with father, friend with friend, and also children with a parent. For the daughter of Saul would not have been able to rescue her husband out of Saul's hands except by deceiving her father. And her brother, wishing to save him whom she had rescued when he was again in danger, made use of the same weapon as the wife. 1 Samuel 20:11

But none of these cases apply to me, for I am not an enemy or one of those trying to harm you—quite the opposite. I entrusted all my interests to your judgment and always followed it whenever you directed me.

Basil: But none of these cases apply to me: for I am not an enemy, nor one of those who are striving to injure you, but quite the contrary. For I entrusted all my interests to your judgment, and always followed it whenever you bid me.

Chrysostom: But, my admirable and excellent sir, this is the very reason why I took care to say that it is good to use this kind of deception not only in war and when dealing with enemies, but also in peacetime and when dealing with our closest friends. As proof that it benefits not only those who deceive but also those who are deceived, if you go to any physician and ask how they relieve their patients from disease, they will tell you that they do not rely on their professional skill alone but sometimes lead the sick to health by using deception and mixing the help they get from it with their medical knowledge. For when the patient's stubbornness and the disease's resistance defeat the physicians' plans, it becomes necessary to put on the mask of deception so that, as on the stage, they can hide what is actually happening. But if you like, I will tell you one example of a clever plan out of many I have heard of that were devised by those in the medical profession. A man was once suddenly struck by a very severe fever; the burning heat increased, and the patient rejected the remedies that could have reduced it and craved a drink of pure wine, passionately begging everyone who came near to give it to him and let him satisfy this deadly craving—I say deadly, because if anyone had granted this request he would not only have made the fever worse but also driven the unhappy man insane. As a result, professional skill was defeated, exhausted, and completely useless, so trickery stepped in and displayed its power in the way I will now describe. The physician took an earthen cup brought straight out of the furnace, soaked it in wine, then drew it out empty, filled it with water, and having ordered the room where the sick man lay to be darkened with curtains so that the light would not reveal the trick, he gave it to him to drink, pretending it was filled with undiluted wine. And the man, before he had taken it in his hands, being deceived by the smell, did not wait to examine what was given to him but, convinced by the odor and deceived by the darkness, eagerly gulped down the drink, and being satisfied with it immediately shook off the feeling of suffocation and escaped the imminent danger. Do you see the advantage of deception? And if anyone were to count up all the tricks of physicians, the list would go on indefinitely. And not only those who heal the body but those who also treat the diseases of the soul can be found continually making use of this remedy. Thus the blessed Paul attracted those multitudes of Jews: with this purpose he circumcised Timothy, although he warned the Galatians in his letter that Christ would not benefit those who were circumcised. For this reason he submitted to the law, although he considered the righteousness that came from the law to be loss after receiving faith in Christ. For great is the value of deception, provided it is not introduced with a harmful intention. In fact, action of this kind should not be called deception but rather a kind of good management, cleverness and skill, capable of finding ways where resources fail and making up for the mind's deficiencies. For I would not call Phinehas a murderer, although he killed two human beings with one stroke, nor would I call Elijah one after the slaughter of the hundred soldiers and the captain, and the rivers of blood he caused to be shed by the destruction of those who sacrificed to demons. For if we were to accept this and examine the bare deeds in themselves apart from the intention of those who did them, one might if he pleased judge Abraham guilty of child-murder and accuse his grandson and descendant of wickedness and deceit. For the one obtained the birthright, and the other transferred the wealth of the Egyptians to the host of the Israelites. But this is not the case—away with such an outrageous thought! For we not only clear them of blame but also admire them because of these things, since even God commended them for the same. For that man would fairly deserve to be called a deceiver who made an unrighteous use of the practice, not one who did so with a beneficial purpose. And often it is necessary to deceive and to do the greatest good by means of this device, whereas someone who has taken a straight course has done great harm to the person he has not deceived.

Chrysostom: But, my admirable and excellent Sir, this is the very reason why I took the precaution of saying that it was a good thing to employ this kind of deceit, not only in war, and in dealing with enemies, but also in peace, and in dealing with our dearest friends. For as a proof that it is beneficial not only to the deceivers, but also to those who are deceived; if you go to any of the physicians and ask them how they relieve their patients from disease, they will tell you that they do not depend upon their professional skill alone, but sometimes conduct the sick to health by availing themselves of deceit, and blending the assistance which they derive from it with their art. For when the waywardness of the patient and the obstinacy of the complaint baffle the counsels of the physicians, it is then necessary to put on the mask of deceit in order that, as on the stage, they may be able to hide what really takes place. But, if you please, I will relate to you one instance of stratagem out of many which I have heard of being contrived by the sons of the healing art. A man was once suddenly attacked by a fever of great severity; the burning heat increased, and the patient rejected the remedies which could have reduced it and craved for a draught of pure wine, passionately entreating all who approached to give it him and enable him to satiate this deadly craving — I say deadly, for if any one had gratified this request he would not only have exasperated the fever, but also have driven the unhappy man frantic. Thereupon, professional skill being baffled, and at the end of its resources and utterly thrown away, stratagem stepped in and displayed its power in the way which I will now relate. For the physician took an earthen cup brought straight out of the furnace, and having steeped it in wine, then drew it out empty, filled it with water, and, having ordered the chamber where the sick man lay to be darkened with curtains that the light might not reveal the trick, he gave it him to drink, pretending that it was filled with undiluted wine. And the man, before he had taken it in his hands, being deceived by the smell, did not wait to examine what was given him, but convinced by the odor, and deceived by the darkness, eagerly gulped down the draught, and being satiated with it immediately shook off the feeling of suffocation and escaped the imminent peril. Do you see the advantage of deceit? And if any one were to reckon up all the tricks of physicians the list would run on to an indefinite length. And not only those who heal the body but those also who attend to the diseases of the soul may be found continually making use of this remedy. Thus the blessed Paul attracted those multitudes of Jews: Acts 21:26 with this purpose he circumcised Timothy, although he warned the Galatians in his letter Galatians 5:2 that Christ would not profit those who were circumcised. For this cause he submitted to the law, although he reckoned the righteousness which came from the law but loss after receiving the faith in Christ. Philippians 3:7 For great is the value of deceit, provided it be not introduced with a mischievous intention. In fact action of this kind ought not to be called deceit, but rather a kind of good management, cleverness and skill, capable of finding out ways where resources fail, and making up for the defects of the mind. For I would not call Phinees a murderer, although he slew two human beings with one stroke: Numbers 25:7 nor yet Elias after the slaughter of the 100 soldiers, and the captain, 2 Kings 1:9-12 and the torrents of blood which he caused to be shed by the destruction of those who sacrificed to devils. 1 Kings 18:34 For if we were to concede this, and to examine the bare deeds in themselves apart from the intention of the doers, one might if he pleased judge Abraham guilty of child- murder Genesis 22:3 and accuse his grandson and descendant Exodus 11:2 of wickedness and guile. For the one got possession of the birthright, and the other transferred the wealth of the Egyptians to the host of the Israelites. But this is not the case: away with the audacious thought! For we not only acquit them of blame, but also admire them because of these things, since even God commended them for the same. For that man would fairly deserve to be called a deceiver who made an unrighteous use of the practice, not one who did so with a salutary purpose. And often it is necessary to deceive, and to do the greatest benefits by means of this device, whereas he who has gone by a straight course has done great mischief to the person whom he has not deceived.