Four Discourses Against the Arians — Discourse II

Hebrews 3:2, Acts 2:36 and Proverbs 8:22 (‘The Lord created me’) explained: such words refer to the Incarnation, for the Son is not a creature.

Source: Translated by John Henry Newman and Archibald Robertson. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series , Vol. 4. Edited by Philip Schaff and Henry Wace. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1892. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/28162.htm>.

Contents · 9 chapters
  1. Opening
  2. Chapter 15. Texts explained; Fifthly, Acts 2:36. The Regula Fidei must be observed; madeapplies to our Lord's manhood; and to His manifestation; and to His office relative to us; and is relative to the Jews. Parallel instance in Genesis 27:29, 37. The context contradicts the Arianinterpretation.
  3. Chapter 16. Introductory to Proverbs 8:22, that the Son is not a Creature. Arianformula, a creature but not as one of the creatures; but each creature is unlike all other creatures; and no creature can create. The Word then differs from all creatures in that in which they, though otherwise differing, all agree together, as creatures; viz. in being an efficient cause; in being the one medium or instrumental agent in creation; moreover in being the revealer of the Father; and in being the object of worship.
  4. Chapter 17. Introduction to Proverbs 8:22 continued. Absurdity of supposing a Son or Word created in order to the creation of other creatures; as to the creation being unable to bear God's immediate hand, God condescends to the lowest. Moreover, if the Son a creature, He too could not bear God's hand, and an infiniteseries of media will be necessary. Objected, that, as Moseswho led out the Israelites was a man, so our Lord; but Moseswas not the Agent in creation:– again, that unity is found in created ministrations, but all such ministrations are defective and dependent:– again, that He learned to create, yet could God's Wisdom need teaching? And why should He learn, if the Father works hitherto? If the Son was created to create us, He is for our sake, not we for His
  5. Chapter 18. Introduction to Proverbs 8:22 continued. Contrast between the Father's operations immediately and naturally in the Son, instrumentally by the creatures; Scripture terms illustrative of this. Explanation of these illustrations; which should be interpreted by the doctrine of the Church; perverse sense put on them by the Arians, refuted. Mystery of Divine Generation. Contrast between God's Word and man's word drawn out at length. Asterius betrayed into holding two Unoriginates; his inconsistency. Baptism how by the Son as well as by the Father. On the Baptism of heretics. Why Arianworse than other heresies.
  6. Chapter 19. Texts explained; Sixthly, Proverbs 8:22. Proverbs are of a figurative nature, and must be interpreted as such. We must interpret them, and in particular this passage, by the Regula Fidei. 'He created me' not equivalent to 'I am a creature.' Wisdom a creature so far forth as Its human body. Again, if He is a creature, it is as 'a beginning of ways,' an office which, though not an attribute, is a consequence, of a higher and divine nature. And it is 'for the works,' which implied the works existed, and therefore much more He, before He was created. Also 'the Lord' not the Father 'created' Him, which implies the creation was that of a servant.
  7. Chapter 20. Texts Explained; Sixthly, Proverbs viii. 22 Continued. Our Lord is said to be created 'for the works,' i.e. with a particular purpose, which no mere creatures are ever said to be. Parallel of Isaiah 49:5, etc. When His manhood is spoken of, a reason for it is added; not so when His Divine Nature; Texts in proof.
  8. Chapter 21. Texts Explained; Sixthly, Proverbs 8:22, Continued. Our Lord not said in Scripture to be 'created,' or the works to be 'begotten.' 'In the beginning' means in the case of the works 'from the beginning.' Scripture passages explained. We are made by God first, begotten next; creatures by nature, sons by grace. Christ begotten first, made or created afterwards. Sense of 'First-born of the dead;' of 'First-born among many brethren;' of 'First-born of all creation,' contrasted with 'Only-begotten.' Further interpretation of 'beginning of ways,' and 'for the works.' Why a creature could not redeem; why redemption was necessary at all. Texts which contrast the Word and the works.
  9. Chapter 22. Texts Explained; Sixthly, the Context of Proverbs 8:22, and application of it to created Wisdom as seen in the works. The Son reveals the Father, first by the works, then by the Incarnation.

Opening

I thought I had already said enough against the empty teachers of Arius's madness, both to refute them and to defend the truth, so that they would stop and repent of their evil thoughts and words about the Savior. But for whatever reason, they still do not give up. Instead, like pigs and dogs wallowing in their own vomit and filth, they keep inventing new ways to be irreligious. They misinterpret the passage in Proverbs, "The Lord has created me a beginning of His ways for His works," and the words of the Apostle, "Who was faithful to Him that made Him," and immediately argue that the Son of God is a work and a creature. Even though they could have learned from what was said earlier—if they had not completely lost their ability to understand—that the Son is not from nothing and is not counted among created things at all (the Truth itself testifies to this, for being God, He cannot be a work, and it is wrong to call Him a creature; we say "out of nothing" and "it was not before its generation" only about creatures and works), yet because they seem afraid to abandon their own invention, they habitually quote these Scripture passages, which have a good meaning but which they twist. So let us examine again what these passages mean, to reassure the faithful and to show from each passage that these people know nothing at all about Christianity. If they did, they would not have trapped themselves in the unbelief of today's Jews, but would have inquired and learned that since "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God," it follows that when the Word became man at the Father's good pleasure, it was said of Him, as John said, "The Word became flesh," as Peter said, "He has made Him Lord and Christ," as by Solomon in the person of the Lord Himself, "The Lord created me a beginning of His ways for His works," as Paul said, "Become so much better than the Angels," and again, "He emptied Himself, and took upon Him the form of a servant," and again, "Wherefore, holy brethren, partakers of the heavenly calling, consider the Apostle and High Priest of our profession, Jesus, who was faithful to Him that made Him." All these texts have the same meaning and purpose, a reverent one, declaring the divinity of the Word—even those that speak of Him in human terms as having become the Son of man. Though this distinction is enough to refute them, still, because they misunderstand the Apostle's words (to mention them first) and think the Word of God is one of the works because it is written "Who was faithful to Him that made Him," I have thought it necessary to answer this further argument of theirs, taking up their claim as I did before.

1. I did indeed think that enough had been said already against the hollow professors of Arius's madness, whether for their refutation or in the truth's behalf, to insure a cessation and repentance of their evil thoughts and words about the Saviour. They, however, for whatever reason, still do not succumb; but, as swine and dogs wallow in their own vomit and their own mire, rather invent new expedients for their irreligion. Thus they misunderstand the passage in the Proverbs, 'The Lord has created me a beginning of His ways for His works,' and the words of the Apostle, 'Who was faithful to Him that made Him Hebrews 3:2,' and straightway argue, that the Son of God is a work and a creature. But although they might have learned from what is said above, had they not utterly lost their power of apprehension, that the Son is not from nothing nor in the number of things originate at all, the Truth witnessing it (for, being God, He cannot be a work, and it is impious to call Him a creature, and it is of creatures and works that we say, 'out of nothing,' and 'it was not before its generation'), yet since, as if dreading to desert their own fiction, they are accustomed to allege the aforesaid passages of divine Scripture, which have a good meaning, but are by them practised on, let us proceed afresh to take up the question of the sense of these, to remind the faithful, and to show from each of these passages that they have no knowledge at all of Christianity. Were it otherwise, they would not have shut themselves up in the unbelief of the present Jews, but would have inquired and learned that, whereas 'In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God,' in consequence, it was when at the good pleasure of the Father the Word became man, that it was said of Him, as by John, 'The Word became flesh John 1:14;' so by Peter, 'He has made Him Lord and Christ Acts 2:36 ' — as by means of Solomon in the Person of the Lord Himself, 'The Lord created me a beginning of His ways for His works Proverbs 8:22;' so by Paul, 'Become so much better than the Angels Hebrews 1:4;' and again, 'He emptied Himself, and took upon Him the form of a servant Philippians 2:7;' and again, 'Wherefore, holy brethren, partakers of the heavenly calling, consider the Apostle and High Priest of our profession, Jesus, who was faithful to Him that made Him.' For all these texts have the same force and meaning, a religious one, declarative of the divinity of the Word, even those of them which speak humanly concerning Him, as having become the Son of man. But, though this distinction is sufficient for their refutation, still, since from a misconception of the Apostle's words (to mention them first), they consider the Word of God to be one of the works, because of its being written, 'Who was faithful to Him that made Him,' I have thought it needful to silence this further argument of theirs, taking in hand, as before, their statement.

If He is not a Son, then let Him be called a work, and let everything that is said about created works be said about Him. Let Him not be called Son, or Word, or Wisdom—and let God not be called Father, but only Maker and Creator of the things that come to be through Him. And let the creature be the image and expression of His creative will, and let Him be without generative nature, as they would have it, so that there is neither Word nor Wisdom, nor even an Image, of His proper ousia. For if He is not Son, neither is He Image. But if there is no Son, how can you say that God is a Creator? Since all things that come to be exist through the Word and in Wisdom, and nothing can exist without this, yet you say He does not have that in and through which He makes all things. For if the divine essence is not fruitful in itself but barren, as they claim—like a light that does not shine or a dry spring—are they not ashamed to speak of His possessing creative power? And while they deny what exists by nature, do they not blush to put before it what exists by will? But if He creates things that are external to Him and did not exist before, by willing them to be, and becomes their Maker, how much more will He first be Father of an Offspring from His proper ousia. For if they attribute to God the willing of things that do not exist, why do they not recognize in God what is above will? Now it is something that surpasses will, that He should exist by nature and should be Father of His proper Word. If, then, what comes first—what is according to nature—did not exist, as they foolishly claim, how could what is second—what is according to will—come to be? For the Word is first, and then the creation. On the contrary, the Word exists, whatever these irreligious people claim; for through Him creation came to be, and God, being Maker, plainly also has His creative Word—not external, but proper to Him, for this must be repeated. If He has the power of will, and His will is effective and sufficient for the existence of the things that come to be, and His Word is effective and a Maker, that Word must surely be the living Will of the Father, and an essential energy, and a real Word, in whom all things both exist and are excellently governed. No one can even doubt that He who orders is prior to the ordering and the things ordered. And thus, as I said, God's creating is second to His begetting; for Son implies something proper to Him and truly from that blessed and everlasting essence; but what is from His will comes into existence from without, and is created through His proper Offspring who is from it.

2. If then He be not a Son, let Him be called a work, and let all that is said of works be said of Him, nor let Him and Him alone be called Son, nor Word, nor Wisdom; neither let God be called Father, but only Framer and Creator of things which by Him come to be; and let the creature be Image and Expression of His framing will, and let Him, as they would have it, be without generative nature, so that there be neither Word, nor Wisdom, no, nor Image, of His proper substance. For if He be not Son, neither is He Image. But if there be not a Son, how then say you that God is a Creator? Since all things that come to be are through the Word and in Wisdom, and without This nothing can be, whereas you say He has not That in and through which He makes all things. For if the Divine Essence be not fruitful itself, but barren, as they hold, as a light that lightens not, and a dry fountain, are they not ashamed to speak of His possessing framing energy? And whereas they deny what is by nature, do they not blush to place before it what is by will? But if He frames things that are external to Him and before were not, by willing them to be, and becomes their Maker, much more will He first be Father of an Offspring from His proper Essence. For if they attribute to God the willing about things which are not, why recognise they not that in God which lies above the will? Now it is a something that surpasses will, that He should be by nature, and should be Father of His proper Word. If then that which comes first, which is according to nature, did not exist, as they would have it in their folly, how could that which is second come to be, which is according to will? For the Word is first, and then the creation. On the contrary the Word exists, whatever they affirm, those irreligious ones; for through Him did creation come to be, and God, as being Maker, plainly has also His framing Word, not external, but proper to Him — for this must be repeated. If He has the power of will, and His will is effective, and suffices for the consistence of the things that come to be, and His Word is effective, and a Framer, that Word must surely be the living Will of the Father, and an essential energy, and a real Word, in whom all things both consist and are excellently governed. No one can even doubt, that He who disposes is prior to the disposition and the things disposed. And thus, as I said, God's creating is second to His begetting; for Son implies something proper to Him and truly from that blessed and everlasting Essence; but what is from His will, comes into consistence from without, and is framed through His proper Offspring who is from It.

We have shown, then, that those who say the Lord is not the Son of God but a work are guilty of great extravagance, and it follows that we must all necessarily confess that He is Son. And if He is Son—as He indeed is—and a son is understood to be not external to his father but from him, then they should not raise questions about the terms the sacred writers use of the Word Himself, namely not "to Him that begot Him" but "to Him that made Him." As I said before, once we have established what His nature is, the words used in such cases need not raise any question. For terms do not diminish His nature; rather that nature draws those terms to itself and changes them. Terms are not prior to essences; essences come first, and terms come second. Therefore, when the essence is a work or creature, then the words "He made," "He became," and "He created" are used properly and designate the work. But when the essence is an offspring and son, then "He made," "He became," and "He created" no longer properly apply to it, nor do they designate a work. Instead, we use "He made" without question to mean "He begot." In this way, fathers often call the sons born of them their servants, yet without denying the genuineness of their nature; and often they affectionately call their own servants children, yet without overlooking the fact that they originally purchased them. They use the one term because of their authority as fathers, but in the other case they speak from affection. Thus Sarah called Abraham lord, though she was not a servant but a wife. And while the Apostle joined Onesimus the servant to Philemon the master as a brother, Bathsheba, although mother, called her son servant, saying to his father, "Your servant Solomon" (1 Kings 1:19). Afterward Nathan the prophet also came in and repeated her words to David: "Solomon your servant." They did not hesitate to call the son a servant, for while David heard it, he recognized the nature, and while they spoke it, they did not forget the genuineness. They prayed that he might be made his father's heir, though they gave him the name of servant, for to David he was son by nature.

3. As we have shown then they are guilty of great extravagance who say that the Lord is not Son of God, but a work, and it follows that we all of necessity confess that He is Son. And if He be Son, as indeed He is, and a son is confessed to be not external to his father but from him, let them not question about the terms, as I said before, which the sacred writers use of the Word Himself, viz. not 'to Him that begot Him,' but 'to Him that made Him;' for while it is confessed what His nature is, what word is used in such instances need raise no question. For terms do not disparage His Nature; rather that Nature draws to Itself those terms and changes them. For terms are not prior to essences, but essences are first, and terms second. Wherefore also when the essence is a work or creature, then the words 'He made,' and 'He became,' and 'He created,' are used of it properly, and designate the work. But when the Essence is an Offspring and Son, then 'He made,' and 'He became,' and 'He created,' no longer properly belong to it, nor designate a work; but 'He made' we use without question for 'He begot.' Thus fathers often call the sons born of them their servants, yet without denying the genuineness of their nature; and often they affectionately call their own servants children, yet without putting out of sight their purchase of them originally; for they use the one appellation from their authority as being fathers, but in the other they speak from affection. Thus Sara called Abraham lord, though not a servant but a wife; and while to Philemon the master the Apostle joined Onesimus the servant as a brother, Bathsheba, although mother, called her son servant, saying to his father, 'Your servant Solomon 1 Kings 1:19;'– afterwards also Nathan the Prophet came in and repeated her words to David, 'Solomon your servant.' Nor did they mind calling the son a servant, for while David heard it, he recognised the 'nature,' and while they spoke it, they forgot not the 'genuineness,' praying that he might be made his father's heir, to whom they gave the name of servant; for to David he was son by nature.

When we read Scripture this way, we interpret it fairly. We don't consider Solomon a servant just because we hear him called that, but rather a natural and genuine son. In the same way, even though the Savior is confessed to be truly the Son and to be the Word by nature, if the saints say "Who was faithful to Him that made Him," or if He says of Himself "The Lord created me" and "I am Your servant and the Son of Your handmaid" and similar things, no one should deny that He is proper to the Father and from Him. Just as in the case of Solomon and David, people should have a right understanding of the Father and the Son. If people acknowledge Solomon to be a son even though they hear him called a servant, aren't those people deserving of many deaths who, instead of keeping the same interpretation when it comes to the Lord, forcibly misinterpret and deny the natural and genuine generation of the Son from the Father whenever they hear "Offspring" and "Word" and "Wisdom"? Yet when they hear words and terms proper to a work, they immediately jump to the idea that He is by nature a work and deny the Word—even though it is possible to refer all these terms to His humanity, since He was made man. Aren't they proved to be "an abomination" also "unto the Lord," since they have "diverse weights" with them, using one standard to evaluate those other cases and another standard to blaspheme the Lord? Perhaps they grant that the word "servant" is used with a certain understanding, but they insist on "Who made" as some great support for their heresy. But this support of theirs is also just a broken reed, for if they are aware of Scripture's style, they must immediately pass judgment against themselves. Just as Solomon, though a son, is called a servant, so—to repeat what was said above—even though parents call the sons springing from themselves "made" and "created" and "becoming," they do not for all this deny their nature. Thus Hezekiah, as it is written in Isaiah, said in his prayer, "From this day I will make children, who shall declare Your righteousness, O God of my salvation." He said "I will make," but the Prophet in that very book and in the Fourth Book of Kings speaks this way: "And the sons who shall come forth of you." He uses "make" for "beget," and he calls those who were to spring from him "made," and no one questions whether the term refers to a natural offspring. Again, Eve on bearing Cain said, "I have gotten a man from the Lord." She too used "gotten" for "brought forth." First she saw the child, yet then she said "I have gotten." No one would consider, because of "I have gotten," that Cain was purchased from outside instead of being born of her. Again, the Patriarch Jacob said to Joseph, "And now your two sons, Ephraim and Manasseh, which became yours in Egypt, before I came unto you into Egypt, are mine." And Scripture says about Job, "And there came to him seven sons and three daughters." Moses too has said in the Law, "If sons become to any one" and "If he make a son." Here again they speak of those who are begotten as "become" and "made," knowing that while they are acknowledged to be sons, we need not question "they became" or "I have gotten" or "I made." For nature and truth draw the meaning to themselves.

4. As then, when we read this, we interpret it fairly, without accounting Solomon a servant because we hear him so called, but a son natural and genuine, so also, if, concerning the Saviour, who is confessed to be in truth the Son, and to be the Word by nature, the saints say, 'Who was faithful to Him that made Him,' or if He say of Himself, 'The Lord created me,' and, 'I am Your servant and the Son of Your handmaid,' and the like, let not any on this account deny that He is proper to the Father and from Him; but, as in the case of Solomon and David, let them have a right idea of the Father and the Son. For if, though they hear Solomon called a servant, they acknowledge him to be a son, are they not deserving of many deaths, who, instead of preserving the same explanation in the instance of the Lord, whenever they hear 'Offspring,' and 'Word,' and 'Wisdom,' forcibly misinterpret and deny the generation, natural and genuine, of the Son from the Father; but on hearing words and terms proper to a work, immediately drop down to the notion of His being by nature a work, and deny the Word; and this, though it is possible, from His having been made man, to refer all these terms to His humanity? And are they not proved to be 'an abomination' also 'unto the Lord,' as having 'diverse weights Proverbs 20:23 ' with them, and with this estimating those other instances, and with that blaspheming the Lord? But perhaps they grant that the word 'servant' is used under a certain understanding, but lay stress upon 'Who made' as some great support of their heresy. But this stay of theirs also is but a broken reed; for if they are aware of the style of Scripture, they must at once give sentence against themselves. For as Solomon, though a son, is called a servant, so, to repeat what was said above, although parents call the sons springing from themselves 'made' and 'created' and 'becoming,' for all this they do not deny their nature. Thus Hezekiah, as it is written in Isaiah, said in his prayer, 'From this day I will make children, who shall declare Your righteousness, O God of my salvation.' He then said, 'I will make;' but the Prophet in that very book and the Fourth of Kings, thus speaks, 'And the sons who shall come forth of you 2 Kings 20:18; Isaiah 39:7.' He uses then 'make' for 'beget,' and he calls them who were to spring from him, 'made,' and no one questions whether the term has reference to a natural offspring. Again, Eve on bearing Cain said, 'I have gotten a man from the Lord;' thus she too used 'gotten' for 'brought forth.' For, first she saw the child, yet next she said, 'I have gotten.' Nor would any one consider, because of 'I have gotten,' that Cain was purchased from without, instead of being born of her. Again, the Patriarch Jacob said to Joseph, 'And now your two sons, Ephraim and Manasseh, which became yours in Egypt, before I came unto you into Egypt, are mine.' And Scripture says about Job, 'And there came to him seven sons and three daughters.' As Moses too has said in the Law, 'If sons become to any one,' and 'If he make a son.' Here again they speak of those who are begotten, as 'become' and 'made,' knowing that, while they are acknowledged to be sons, we need not make a question of 'they became,' or 'I have gotten,' or 'I made.' For nature and truth draw the meaning to themselves.

Given this, when people ask whether the Lord is a creature or a work, we should first ask them this: whether He is Son and Word and Wisdom. If this is demonstrated, then the speculation about work and creation immediately collapses and ends. A work could never be Son and Word, nor could the Son be a work. And again, since this is how things stand, the proof is clear to everyone that the phrase "to Him who made Him" does not support their heresy but actually condemns it. For it has been shown that the expression "He made" is applied in divine Scripture even to children who are genuine and natural. Therefore, since the Lord is proven to be the Father's Son naturally and genuinely, and Word and Wisdom, even if "He made" is used concerning Him, or "He became," this is not said of Him as if He were a work. Rather, the saints have no hesitation about using such expressions—for instance, in the case of Solomon and Hezekiah's children. For even though the fathers had begotten them from themselves, it is still written "I have made" and "I have gotten" and "He became." Therefore God's enemies, despite their repeated citing of such phrases, ought now—even if belatedly, after what has been said—to renounce their irreligious ideas and think of the Lord as a true Son, Word, and Wisdom of the Father, not a work, not a creature. For if the Son is a creature, then by what word and by what wisdom was He Himself made? For all the works were made through the Word and the Wisdom, as it is written: "In wisdom You have made them all," and "All things were made by Him, and without Him nothing was made." But if He is the one who is the Word and the Wisdom by which all things come to be, it follows that He is not among the works, nor indeed among things that have an origin, but is the Offspring of the Father.

5. This being so, when persons ask whether the Lord is a creature or work, it is proper to ask of them this first, whether He is Son and Word and Wisdom. For if this is shown, the surmise about work and creation falls to the ground at once and is ended. For a work could never be Son and Word; nor could the Son be a work. And again, this being the state of the case, the proof is plain to all, that the phrase, 'To Him who made Him' does not serve their heresy, but rather condemns it. For it has been shown that the expression 'He made' is applied in divine Scripture even to children genuine and natural; whence, the Lord being proved to be the Father's Son naturally and genuinely, and Word, and Wisdom, though 'He made' be used concerning Him, or 'He became,' this is not said of Him as if a work, but the saints make no question about using the expression — for instance in the case of Solomon, and Hezekiah's children. For though the fathers had begotten them from themselves, still it is written, 'I have made,' and 'I have gotten,' and 'He became.' Therefore God's enemies, in spite of their repeated allegation of such phrases, ought now, though late in the day, after what has been said, to disown their irreligious thoughts, and think of the Lord as of a true Son, Word, and Wisdom of the Father, not a work, not a creature. For if the Son be a creature, by what word then and by what wisdom was He made Himself? For all the works were made through the Word and the Wisdom, as it is written, 'In wisdom have You made them all,' and, 'All things were made by Him, and without Him was not anything made.' But if it be He who is the Word and the Wisdom, by which all things come to be, it follows that He is not in the number of works, nor in short of things originate, but the Offspring of the Father.

Consider how serious an error it is to call God's Word a work. Solomon says in one place in Ecclesiastes that "God shall bring every work into judgment, with every secret thing, whether it be good or whether it be evil." If then the Word is a work, do you mean that He as well as others will be brought into judgment? And what room is there for judgment when the Judge is on trial? Who will give the just their blessing and the unworthy their punishment, if the Lord, as you must suppose, is standing on trial with the rest? By what law shall He, the Lawgiver, Himself be judged? These things are proper to the works: to be on trial, to be blessed, and to be punished by the Son. Now then fear the Judge, and let Solomon's words convince you. For if God shall bring all the works into judgment, but the Son is not in the number of things put on trial, but rather is Himself the Judge of all works, is not the proof clearer than the sun that the Son is not a work but the Father's Word, in whom all the works both come to be and come into judgment? Further, if the expression "who was faithful" is a difficulty to them, from the thought that "faithful" is used of Him as of others—as if He exercises faith and so receives the reward of faith—they must proceed at this rate to find fault with Moses for saying "God faithful and true," and with St. Paul for writing "God is faithful, who will not suffer you to be tempted above that you are able." But when the saints spoke this way, they were not thinking of God in a human way, but they acknowledged two senses of the word "faithful" in Scripture: first "believing," then "trustworthy," of which the former belongs to man, the latter to God. Thus Abraham was faithful because he believed God's word; and God is faithful, for, as David says in the Psalm, "The Lord is faithful in all His words," or is trustworthy, and cannot lie. Again, "If any faithful woman have widows," she is so called for her right faith; but "It is a faithful saying" because what He has spoken has a claim on our faith, for it is true and not otherwise. Accordingly the words "who is faithful to Him that made Him" imply no parallel with others, nor mean that by having faith He became well-pleasing; but that, being Son of the True God, He too is faithful and ought to be believed in all He says and does, Himself remaining unalterable and not changed in His human economy (divine plan of salvation) and fleshly presence.

6. For consider how grave an error it is, to call God's Word a work. Solomon says in one place in Ecclesiastes, that 'God shall bring every work into judgment, with every secret thing, whether it be good or whether it be evil Ecclesiastes 12:14.' If then the Word be a work, do you mean that He as well as others will be brought into judgment? And what room is there for judgment, when the Judge is on trial? Who will give to the just their blessing, who to the unworthy their punishment, the Lord, as you must suppose, standing on trial with the rest? By what law shall He, the Lawgiver, Himself be judged? These things are proper to the works, to be on trial, to be blessed and to be punished by the Son. Now then fear the Judge, and let Solomon's words convince you. For if God shall bring the works one and all into judgment, but the Son is not in the number of things put on trial, but rather is Himself the Judge of works one and all, is not the proof clearer than the sun, that the Son is not a work but the Father's Word, in whom all the works both come to be and come into judgment? Further, if the expression, 'Who was faithful,' is a difficulty to them, from the thought that 'faithful' is used of Him as of others, as if He exercises faith and so receives the reward of faith, they must proceed at this rate to find fault with Moses for saying, 'God faithful and true,' and with St. Paul for writing, 'God is faithful, who will not suffer you to be tempted above that you are able 1 Corinthians 10:13.' But when the saints spoke thus, they were not thinking of God in a human way, but they acknowledged two senses of the word 'faithful' in Scripture, first 'believing,' then 'trustworthy,' of which the former belongs to man, the latter to God. Thus Abraham was faithful, because He believed God's word; and God faithful, for, as David says in the Psalm, 'The Lord is faithful in all His words,' or is trustworthy, and cannot lie. Again, 'If any faithful woman have widows 1 Timothy 5:16,' she is so called for her right faith; but, 'It is a faithful saying,' because what He has spoken has a claim on our faith, for it is true, and is not otherwise. Accordingly the words, 'Who is faithful to Him that made Him,' implies no parallel with others, nor means that by having faith He became well-pleasing; but that, being Son of the True God, He too is faithful, and ought to be believed in all He says and does, Himself remaining unalterable and not changed in His human Economy and fleshly presence.

Thus we can confront these shameless people and show from the single expression "He made" that they are mistaken in thinking the Word of God is a work. But further, since the meaning of the context is orthodox, showing the time and circumstances to which this expression refers, I should demonstrate from it as well how unreasonable the heretics are. We should consider, as we did above, the occasion when this was said and for what purpose. Now the Apostle is not discussing things before creation when he speaks this way, but rather when "the Word became flesh." For it is written: "Therefore, holy brothers, partakers of the heavenly calling, consider the Apostle and High Priest of our profession Jesus, who was faithful to Him that made Him." When did He become "Apostle" except when He put on our flesh? And when did He become "High Priest of our profession" except when, after offering Himself for us, He raised His Body from the dead and now Himself brings near and offers to the Father those who approach Him in faith, redeeming all and making propitiation to God for all? The Apostle did not say "who was faithful to Him that made Him" intending to indicate the essence (ousia) of the Word or His natural generation from the Father—God forbid, for the Word is not made but makes—but rather to indicate His descent to mankind and His priesthood, which did "become." This is easily seen from the account of the Law and of Aaron. Aaron was not born a high priest but a man, and in due time, when God willed, he became a high priest. Yet he became so not simply or as indicated by his ordinary garments, but by putting on over them the ephod, the breastplate, the robe which the women made at God's command, and going in them into the holy place, he offered the sacrifice for the people. In these garments he mediated, as it were, between the vision of God and the sacrifices of men. In the same way the Lord also—"In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God"—but when the Father willed that ransoms should be paid for all and grace should be given to all, then truly the Word took earthly flesh, just as Aaron took his robe, having Mary for the Mother of His Body as if she were virgin earth. As a High Priest having an offering as others do, He offered Himself to the Father and cleansed us all from sins in His own blood and rose from the dead.

7. Thus then we may meet these men who are shameless, and from the single expression 'He made,' may show that they err in thinking that the Word of God is a work. But further, since the drift also of the context is orthodox, showing the time and the relation to which this expression points, I ought to show from it also how the heretics lack reason; viz. by considering, as we have done above, the occasion when it was used and for what purpose. Now the Apostle is not discussing things before the creation when he thus speaks, but when 'the Word became flesh;' for thus it is written, 'Wherefore, holy brethren, partakers of the heavenly calling, consider the Apostle and High Priest of our profession Jesus, who was faithful to Him that made Him.' Now when became He 'Apostle,' but when He put on our flesh? And when became He 'High Priest of our profession,' but when, after offering Himself for us, He raised His Body from the dead, and, as now, Himself brings near and offers to the Father those who in faith approach Him, redeeming all, and for all propitiating God? Not then as wishing to signify the Essence of the Word nor His natural generation from the Father, did the Apostle say, 'Who was faithful to Him that made Him'– (perish the thought! For the Word is not made, but makes)– but as signifying His descent to mankind and High- priesthood which did 'become'– as one may easily see from the account given of the Law and of Aaron. I mean, Aaron was not born a high-priest, but a man; and in process of time, when God willed, he became a high-priest; yet became so, not simply, nor as betokened by his ordinary garments, but putting over them the ephod, the breastplate Exodus 29:5, the robe, which the women wrought at God's command, and going in them into the holy place, he offered the sacrifice for the people; and in them, as it were, mediated between the vision of God and the sacrifices of men. Thus then the Lord also, 'In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God;' but when the Father willed that ransoms should be paid for all and to all, grace should be given, then truly the Word, as Aaron his robe, so did He take earthly flesh, having Mary for the Mother of His Body as if virgin earth, that, as a High Priest, having He as others an offering, He might offer Himself to the Father, and cleanse us all from sins in His own blood, and might rise from the dead.

What happened long ago was a shadow of this reality, and what the Savior did when He came, Aaron foreshadowed according to the Law. Just as Aaron remained the same person and did not change by putting on the high-priestly robes, but stayed the same while simply being clothed, so that if someone had seen him offering sacrifice and said, "Look, Aaron has today become high priest," they would not have meant that he was then born as a man—for he was a man even before becoming high priest—but rather that he had been made high priest in his ministry by putting on the garments made and prepared for the high priesthood. In the same way, it is possible to understand rightly in the Lord's case that He did not become something other than Himself when He took on flesh, but being the same as before, He was clothed in it. The expressions "He became" and "He was made" must not be understood as if the Word, considered as the Word, were made, but rather that the Word, being the Framer of all things, was afterwards made High Priest by putting on a body that was originate and made, and such as He can offer for us. This is why He is said to be made. Now if the Lord did not become man, that is a point for the Arians to argue about; but if "the Word became flesh," what else should have been said about Him when He became man, except "who was faithful to Him that made Him"? For just as it is proper to the Word to have it said of Him, "In the beginning was the Word," so it is proper to man to "become" and to be "made." Who then, seeing the Lord as a man walking about, yet appearing to be God from His works, would not have asked, "Who made Him man?" And who again, when asked such a question, would not have answered that the Father made Him man and sent Him to us as High Priest? This meaning, time, and character the Apostle himself, the writer of the words "who is faithful to Him that made Him," will best make clear to us if we pay attention to what comes before them. For there is one train of thought, and the entire passage is about One and the Same. He writes in the Epistle to the Hebrews: "Forasmuch then as the children are partakers of flesh and blood, He also Himself likewise took part of the same; that through death He might destroy him that had the power of death, that is, the devil; and deliver them who through fear of death were all their lifetime subject to bondage. For verily He took not on Him the nature of Angels; but He took on Him the seed of Abraham. Wherefore in all things it behooved Him to be made like His brethren, that He might be a merciful and faithful High Priest in things pertaining to God, to make reconciliation for the sins of the people. For in that He Himself has suffered being tempted, He is able to succour them that are tempted. Wherefore, holy brethren, partakers of a heavenly calling, consider the Apostle and High Priest of our profession, Jesus; who was faithful to Him that made Him."

8. For what happened of old was a shadow of this; and what the Saviour did on His coming, this Aaron shadowed out according to the Law. As then Aaron was the same and did not change by putting on the high-priestly dress, but remaining the same was only robed, so that, had any one seen him offering, and had said, 'Lo, Aaron has this day become high-priest,' he had not implied that he then had been born man, for man he was even before he became high-priest, but that he had been made high-priest in his ministry, on putting on the garments made and prepared for the high- priesthood; in the same way it is possible in the Lord's instance also to understand aright, that He did not become other than Himself on taking the flesh, but, being the same as before, He was robed in it; and the expressions 'He became' and 'He was made,' must not be understood as if the Word, considered as the Word, were made, but that the Word, being Framer of all, afterwards was made High Priest, by putting on a body which was originate and made, and such as He can offer for us; wherefore He is said to be made. If then indeed the Lord did not become man, that is a point for the Arians to battle; but if the 'Word became flesh,' what ought to have been said concerning Him when become man, but 'Who was faithful to Him that made Him?' for as it is proper to the Word to have it said of Him, 'In the beginning was the Word,' so it is proper to man to 'become' and to be 'made.' Who then, on seeing the Lord as a man walking about, and yet appearing to be God from His works, would not have asked, Who made Him man? And who again, on such a question, would not have answered, that the Father made Him man, and sent Him to us as High Priest? And this meaning, and time, and character, the Apostle himself, the writer of the words, 'Who is faithful to Him that made Him,' will best make plain to us, if we attend to what goes before them. For there is one train of thought, and the lection is all about One and the Same. He writes then in the Epistle to the Hebrews thus; 'Forasmuch then as the children are partakers of flesh and blood, He also Himself likewise took part of the same; that through death He might destroy him that had the power of death, that is, the devil; and deliver them who through fear of death were all their lifetime subject to bondage. For verily He took not on Him the nature of Angels; but He took on Him the seed of Abraham. Wherefore in all things it behooved Him to be made like His brethren, that He might be a merciful and faithful High Priest in things pertaining to God, to make reconciliation for the sins of the people. For in that He Himself has suffered being tempted, He is able to succour them that are tempted. Wherefore, holy brethren, partakers of a heavenly calling, consider the Apostle and High Priest of our profession, Jesus; who was faithful to Him that made Him. '

Anyone who reads this entire passage must condemn the Arians and admire the blessed Apostle, who has spoken well. For when was Christ "made," when did He become "Apostle," except when, like us, He "took part in flesh and blood"? And when did He become "a merciful and faithful High Priest," except when "in all things He was made like His brethren"? And He was "made like" when He became man, having put upon Himself our flesh. Therefore Paul was writing concerning the Word's human economy when he said, "Who was faithful to Him that made Him," and not concerning His ousia. So do not have the madness any longer to say that the Word of God is a work, whereas He is Son by nature Only-begotten, and then had "brethren" when He took on flesh like ours. Moreover, by offering Himself, He was named and became "merciful and faithful"—merciful, because in mercy to us He offered Himself for us, and faithful, not as sharing faith with us, nor as having faith in anyone as we have, but as deserving to receive faith in all He says and does, and as offering a faithful sacrifice, one which remains and does not come to nothing. For those sacrifices which were offered according to the Law did not have this faithfulness, passing away with the day and needing further cleansing. But the Saviour's sacrifice, taking place once, has perfected everything and has become faithful as remaining forever. And Aaron had successors, and in a word the priesthood under the Law exchanged its first ministers as time and death went on. But the Lord, having a high priesthood without transition and without succession, has become a "faithful High Priest" as continuing forever, and faithful too by promise, so that He may hear and not mislead those who come to Him. This may also be learned from the Epistle of the great Peter, who says, "Let them that suffer according to the will of God, commit their souls to a faithful Creator." For He is faithful as not changing, but abiding ever, and rendering what He has promised.

9. Who can read this whole passage without condemning the Arians, and admiring the blessed Apostle, who has spoken well? For when was Christ 'made,' when became He 'Apostle,' except when, like us, He 'took part in flesh and blood.' And when became He 'a merciful and faithful High Priest,' except when 'in all things He was made like His brethren.' And then was He 'made like,' when He became man, having put upon Him our flesh. Wherefore Paul was writing concerning the Word's human Economy, when he said, 'Who was faithful to Him that made Him,' and not concerning His Essence. Have not therefore any more the madness to say that the Word of God is a work; whereas He is Son by nature Only-begotten, and then had 'brethren,' when He took on Him flesh like ours; which moreover, by Himself offering Himself, He was named and became 'merciful and faithful,'– merciful, because in mercy to us He offered Himself for us, and faithful, not as sharing faith with us, nor as having faith in any one as we have, but as deserving to receive faith in all He says and does, and as offering a faithful sacrifice, one which remains and does not come to nought. For those which were offered according to the Law, had not this faithfulness, passing away with the day and needing a further cleansing; but the Saviour's sacrifice, taking place once, has perfected everything, and has become faithful as remaining forever. And Aaron had successors, and in a word the priesthood under the Law exchanged its first ministers as time and death went on; but the Lord having a high priesthood without transition and without succession, has become a 'faithful High Priest,' as continuing for ever; and faithful too by promise, that He may hear and not mislead those who come to Him. This may be also learned from the Epistle of the great Peter, who says, 'Let them that suffer according to the will of God, commit their souls to a faithful Creator 1 Peter 4:19.' For He is faithful as not changing, but abiding ever, and rendering what He has promised.

Now the so-called gods of the Greeks, unworthy of the name, are faithful neither in their essence nor in their promises. They are not present everywhere. Rather, these local deities eventually come to nothing and undergo natural dissolution. This is why the Word cries out against them, saying that "faith is not strong in them," but they are "waters that fail," and "there is no faith in them." But the God of all, being one really and truly, is faithful. He is always the same and says, "See now, that I, even I am He," and "I change not." Therefore His Son is faithful, being always the same and unchanging, deceiving neither in His essence nor in His promise. As the Apostle again says when writing to the Thessalonians, "Faithful is He who calls you, who also will do it" (1 Thessalonians 5:24). In doing what He promises, He is faithful to His words. And he writes to the Hebrews about the word's meaning "unchangeable": "If we believe not, yet He abides faithful; He cannot deny Himself" (2 Timothy 2:13). Therefore the Apostle reasonably, when discussing the bodily presence of the Word, says he is "an Apostle and faithful to Him that made Him," showing us that even when made man, "Jesus Christ" is "the same yesterday, and today, and forever" (Hebrews 13:8)—unchangeable. And just as the Apostle mentions His being made man when speaking of His High Priesthood, so too he did not keep silent about His Godhead. Rather, he mentions it immediately, giving us protection on every side, and especially when he speaks of His humility, so that we may immediately know His loftiness and His majesty, which is the Father's. For instance, he says, "Moses as a servant, but Christ as a Son" (Hebrews 3:5-6), and the former "faithful in his house" and the latter "over the house," since He Himself built it and is its Lord and Framer, and as God sanctifying it. For Moses, a man by nature, became faithful by believing God who spoke to him by His Word. But the Word was not as one of created things in a body, nor as creature in creature, but as God in flesh, and Framer of all and Builder in that which was built by Him. Men are clothed in flesh in order to exist and subsist, but the Word of God was made man in order to sanctify the flesh, and though He was Lord, was in the form of a servant. For the whole creation is the Word's servant, which came to be through Him and was made.

10. Now the so-called gods of the Greeks, unworthy the name, are faithful neither in their essence nor in their promises; for the same are not everywhere, nay, the local deities come to nought in course of time, and undergo a natural dissolution; wherefore the Word cries out against them, that ' faith is not strong in them,' but they are 'waters that fail,' and 'there is no faith in them.' But the God of all, being one really and indeed and true, is faithful, who is ever the same, and says, 'See now, that I, even I am He,' and I 'change not;' and therefore His Son is 'faithful,' being ever the same and unchanging, deceiving neither in His essence nor in His promise — as again says the Apostle writing to the Thessalonians, 'Faithful is He who calls you, who also will do it 1 Thessalonians 5:24;' for in doing what He promises, 'He is faithful to His words.' And he thus writes to the Hebrews as to the word's meaning 'unchangeable;' 'If we believe not, yet He abides faithful; He cannot deny Himself 2 Timothy 2:13.' Therefore reasonably the Apostle, discoursing concerning the bodily presence of the Word, says, an 'Apostle and faithful to Him that made Him,' showing us that, even when made man, ' Jesus Christ ' is 'the same yesterday, and today, and for ever Hebrews 13:8 ' is unchangeable. And as the Apostle makes mention in his Epistle of His being made man when mentioning His High Priesthood, so too he kept no long silence about His Godhead, but rather mentions it immediately, furnishing to us a safeguard on every side, and most of all when he speaks of His humility, that we may immediately know His loftiness and His majesty which is the Father's. For instance, he says, ' Moses as a servant, but Christ as a Son Hebrews 3:5-6;' and the former 'faithful in his house,' and the latter 'over the house,' as having Himself built it, and being its Lord and Framer, and as God sanctifying it. For Moses, a man by nature, became faithful, in believing God who spoke to Him by His Word; but the Word was not as one of things originate in a body, nor as creature in creature, but as God in flesh, and Framer of all and Builder in that which was built by Him. And men are clothed in flesh in order to be and to subsist; but the Word of God was made man in order to sanctify the flesh, and, though He was Lord, was in the form of a servant; for the whole creature is the Word's servant, which by Him came to be, and was made.

Therefore, what the Apostle says—"He made"—does not prove that the Word is made, but rather refers to the body which He took on like ours. Consequently, He is called our brother because He became man. But if it has been demonstrated that even when the word "made" is applied to the Word Himself, it means "begot," what further distorted argument will they be able to devise? The present discussion has clarified the word from every angle and shown that the Son is not a created work. Rather, in His essence (ousia) He is the Father's offspring, while in the divine plan—according to the Father's good pleasure—He was made on our behalf and exists as man. For this reason the Apostle says, "Who was faithful to Him that made Him," and in Proverbs even creation is mentioned. For as long as we confess that He became man, there is no problem with saying—as noted before—whether "He became," or "He has been made," or "created," or "formed," or "servant," or "son of a handmaid," or "son of man," or "was constituted," or "took His journey," or "bridegroom," or "brother's son," or "brother." All these terms properly apply to man's nature, and expressions like these do not designate the essence (ousia) of the Word, but rather indicate that He has become man.

11. Hence it holds that the Apostle's expression, 'He made,' does not prove that the Word is made, but that body, which He took like ours; and in consequence He is called our brother, as having become man. But if it has been shown, that, even though the word 'made' be referred to the Very Word, it is used for 'begot,' what further perverse expedient will they be able to fall upon, now that the present discussion has cleared up the word in every point of view, and shown that the Son is not a work, but in Essence indeed the Father's offspring, while in the Economy, according to the good pleasure of the Father, He was on our behalf made, and consists as man? For this reason then it is said by the Apostle, 'Who was faithful to Him that made Him;' and in the Proverbs, even creation is spoken of. For so long as we are confessing that He became man, there is no question about saying, as was observed before, whether 'He became,' or 'He has been made,' or 'created,' or 'formed,' or 'servant,' or 'son of an handmaid,' or ' son of man,' or 'was constituted,' or 'took His journey,' or 'bridegroom,' or 'brother's son,' or 'brother.' All these terms happen to be proper to man's constitution; and such as these do not designate the Essence of the Word, but that He has become man.

Chapter 15. Texts explained; Fifthly, Acts 2:36. The Regula Fidei must be observed; madeapplies to our Lord's manhood; and to His manifestation; and to His office relative to us; and is relative to the Jews. Parallel instance in Genesis 27:29, 37. The context contradicts the Arianinterpretation.

The same meaning applies to the passage from Acts which they also cite, where Peter says, 'He has made both Lord and Christ that same Jesus whom you have crucified.' For here too it is not written, 'He made for Himself a Son,' or 'He made Himself a Word,' which would justify their interpretations. If they have not forgotten that they are speaking about the Son of God, let them search whether it is anywhere written, 'God made Himself a Son,' or 'He created for Himself a Word,' or again, whether anywhere it is written in plain terms, 'The Word is a work or creation.' Then let them proceed to make their argument, these foolish men, so that they may receive their answer even on those grounds. But if they cannot produce anything of this kind, and only seize upon such isolated expressions as 'He made' and 'He has been made,' I fear that from hearing, 'In the beginning God made the heaven and the earth,' and 'He made the sun and the moon,' and 'He made the sea,' they might eventually come to call the Word the heaven, and the Light which came into being on the first day, and the earth, and each particular thing that has been made, so that they would end up resembling the Stoics, as they are called—the one extending their God into all things, the other ranking God's Word alongside each individual created work. They have nearly done this already, saying that He is one of His works.

11 ( continued). The same is the meaning of the passage in the Acts which they also allege, that in which Peter says, that 'He has made both Lord and Christ that same Jesus whom you have crucified.' For here too it is not written, 'He made for Himself a Son,' or 'He made Himself a Word,' that they should have such notions. If then it has not escaped their memory, that they speak concerning the Son of God, let them make search whether it is anywhere written, 'God made Himself a Son,' or 'He created for Himself a Word.' or again, whether it is anywhere written in plain terms, 'The Word is a work or creation.' and then let them proceed to make their case, the insensate men, that here too they may receive their answer. But if they can produce nothing of the kind, and only catch at such stray expressions as 'He made' and 'He has been made,' I fear lest, from hearing, 'In the beginning God made the heaven and the earth,' and 'He made the sun and the moon,' and 'He made the sea,' they should come in time to call the Word the heaven, and the Light which took place on the first day, and the earth, and each particular thing that has been made, so as to end in resembling the Stoics, as they are called, the one drawing out their God into all things, the other ranking God's Word with each work in particular; which they have well near done already, saying that He is one of His works.

Here they must receive the same answer as before. First, they should be told that the Word is a Son, as has been said above, and not a created work. Such terms should not be understood as referring to His Godhead, but their reason and manner should be investigated. To those who inquire in this way, the human Economy that He undertook for our sake will plainly present itself. For Peter, after saying "He has made Lord and Christ," immediately added "this Jesus whom you crucified." This makes it plain to anyone, even to them if they pay attention to the context, that it is not the Essence of the Word but He according to His manhood that is said to have been made. For what was crucified except the body? And how could what was bodily in the Word be signified except by saying "He made"? The phrase "He made" has a meaning especially consistent with orthodoxy, in that Peter has not said, as I observed before, "He made Him Word," but "He made Him Lord." Nor did he say this in general terms, but "towards" us and "in the midst of" us, as much as to say "He manifested Him." Peter himself carefully expressed this when he began his primary teaching, saying to them, "You men of Israel, hear these words: Jesus of Nazareth, a man manifested of God towards you by miracles and wonders and signs, which God did by Him in the midst of you, as you yourselves know." Consequently, the term he uses at the end, "made," he has explained at the beginning by "manifested." For by the signs and wonders that the Lord did, He was manifested to be not merely man, but God in a body and also Lord, the Christ. The passage in the Gospel according to John is similar: "Therefore the Jews persecuted Him all the more, because He not only broke the Sabbath but also said that God was His own Father, making Himself equal with God." For the Lord did not then fashion Himself to be God—nor indeed is a made God conceivable—but He manifested it by His works, saying, "Though you believe not Me, believe My works, that you may know that I am in the Father and the Father in Me." Thus the Father has "made" Him Lord and King in the midst of us and towards us who were once disobedient. It is plain that He who is now displayed as Lord and King does not then begin to be King and Lord, but begins to show His Lordship and to extend it even over the disobedient.

12. But here they must have the same answer as before, and first be told that the Word is a Son, as has been said above, and not a work, and that such terms are not to be understood of His Godhead, but the reason and manner of them investigated. To persons who so inquire, the human Economy will plainly present itself, which He undertook for our sake. For Peter, after saying, 'He has made Lord and Christ,' straightway added, 'this Jesus whom you crucified;' which makes it plain to any one, even, if so be, to them, provided they attend to the context, that not the Essence of the Word, but He according to His manhood is said to have been made. For what was crucified but the body? And how could be signified what was bodily in the Word, except by saying 'He made?' Especially has that phrase, 'He made,' a meaning consistent with orthodoxy; in that he has not said, as I observed before, 'He made Him Word,' but 'He made Him Lord,' nor that in general terms, but 'towards' us, and 'in the midst of' us, as much as to say, 'He manifested Him.' And this Peter himself, when he began this primary teaching, carefully expressed, when he said to them, 'You men of Israel, hear these words: Jesus of Nazareth, a man manifested of God towards you by miracles, and wonders, and signs, which God did by Him in the midst of you, as you yourselves know Acts 2:22.' Consequently the term which he uses in the end, 'made', this He has explained in the beginning by 'manifested,' for by the signs and wonders which the Lord did, He was manifested to be not merely man, but God in a body and Lord also, the Christ. Such also is the passage in the Gospel according to John, 'Therefore the more did the Jews persecute Him, because He not only broke the Sabbath, but said also that God was His own Father, making Himself equal with God.' For the Lord did not then fashion Himself to be God, nor indeed is a made God conceivable, but He manifested it by the works, saying, 'Though you believe not Me, believe My works, that you may know that I am in the Father, and the Father in Me.' Thus then the Father has 'made' Him Lord and King in the midst of us, and towards us who were once disobedient; and it is plain that He who is now displayed as Lord and King, does not then begin to be King and Lord, but begins to show His Lordship, and to extend it even over the disobedient.

If they suppose that the Savior was not Lord and King even before He became human and endured the Cross, but only began to be Lord at that point, they should know that they are openly reviving the teachings of the Samosatene. But if, as we have quoted and shown above, He is Lord and King everlasting—since Abraham worships Him as Lord, and Moses says, "Then the Lord rained upon Sodom and upon Gomorrah brimstone and fire from the Lord out of heaven," and David says in the Psalms, "The Lord said to my Lord, Sit on My right hand," and "Your Throne, O God, is forever and ever; a scepter of righteousness is the scepter of Your Kingdom," and "Your Kingdom is an everlasting Kingdom"—it is clear that even before He became human, He was King and Lord everlasting, being the Image and Word of the Father. And since the Word is everlasting Lord and King, it is very clear again that Peter was not saying that the ousia of the Son was made, but was speaking of His Lordship over us, which came into being when He became human, and by redeeming all through the Cross, became Lord of all and King. But if they continue to argue based on the fact that it is written "He made," refusing to accept that "He made" should be understood as "He manifested"—whether from lack of understanding or from their Christ-opposing purpose—let them pay attention to another sound interpretation of Peter's words. For someone who becomes Lord of others comes into possession of beings that already exist. But if the Lord is Maker of all and everlasting King, and when He became human, He then gained possession of us, here too we have a way in which Peter's language clearly does not mean that the ousia of the Word is a work, but rather the subsequent subjection of all things and the Savior's Lordship which came to be over all. And this agrees with what we said before. For just as we earlier introduced the words "Become my God and defense" and "the Lord became a refuge for the oppressed," and it made sense that these expressions do not show that God is originated but that His beneficence comes into being toward each individual, Peter's expression has the same meaning.

13. If then they suppose that the Saviour was not Lord and King, even before He became man and endured the Cross, but then began to be Lord, let them know that they are openly reviving the statements of the Samosatene. But if, as we have quoted and declared above, He is Lord and King everlasting, seeing that Abraham worships Him as Lord, and Moses says, 'Then the Lord rained upon Sodom and upon Gomorrha brimstone and fire from the Lord out of heaven Genesis 19:24;' and David in the Psalms, 'The Lord said to my Lord, Sit on My right hand;' and, 'Your Throne, O God, is for ever and ever; a sceptre of righteousness is the sceptre of Your Kingdom;' and, 'Your Kingdom is an everlasting Kingdom;' it is plain that even before He became man, He was King and Lord everlasting, being Image and Word of the Father. And the Word being everlasting Lord and King, it is very plain again that Peter said not that the Essence of the Son was made, but spoke of His Lordship over us, which 'became' when He became man, and, redeeming all by the Cross, became Lord of all and King. But if they continue the argument on the ground of its being written, 'He made,' not willing that 'He made' should be taken in the sense of 'He manifested,' either from want of apprehension, or from their Christ-opposing purpose, let them attend to another sound exposition of Peter's words. For he who becomes Lord of others, comes into the possession of beings already in existence; but if the Lord is Framer of all and everlasting King, and when He became man, then gained possession of us, here too is a way in which Peter's language evidently does not signify that the Essence of the Word is a work, but the after-subjection of all things, and the Saviour's Lordship which came to be over all. And this coincides with what we said before; for as we then introduced the words, 'Become my God and defense,' and 'the Lord became a refuge for the oppressed,' and it stood to reason that these expressions do not show that God is originate, but that His beneficence 'becomes' towards each individual, the same sense has the expression of Peter also.

The Son of God, who is Himself the Word, is Lord of all. But we were once subject from the beginning to the slavery of corruption and the curse of the Law. Then, gradually making for ourselves things that did not exist, we served what the blessed Apostle calls "them which by nature are no Gods" (Galatians 4:8). Being ignorant of the true God, we preferred what was not real to the truth. But afterward, just as the ancient people groaned when they were oppressed in Egypt, so we too, when we had the Law "engrafted" (James 1:21) in us and made our intercession according to the unspeakable groanings (Romans 8:26) of the Spirit, cried "O Lord our God, take possession of us." Then, just as He became "a house of refuge" and "a God and defense," so also He became our Lord. He did not then begin to exist, but we began to have Him as our Lord. For at that point, God being good and Father of the Lord, in pity and desiring to be known by all, makes His own Son put on a human body and become man and be called Jesus, so that in this body offering Himself for all, He might deliver all from false worship and corruption, and might Himself become Lord and King of all. His becoming Lord and King in this way—this is what Peter means by "He has made Him Lord" and "has sent Christ"—as much as to say that the Father, in making Him man (for being made belongs to man), did not simply make Him man, but has made Him in order that He might be Lord of all people and hallow all through the Anointing. For though the Word, existing in the form of God, took a servant's form, the assumption of the flesh did not make a servant of the Word, who was by nature Lord. Rather, not only was there the liberation of all humanity that takes place by the Word, but that very Word who was by nature Lord and was then made man has, by means of a servant's form, been made Lord of all and Christ—that is, in order to hallow all by the Spirit. And just as God, when "becoming a God and defense" and saying "I will be a God to them," does not then become God more than before, nor then begins to become God, but what He always is He then becomes to those who need Him when it pleases Him, so Christ also, being by nature Lord and King everlasting, does not become Lord more than He was at the time He is sent forth, nor then begins to be Lord and King, but what He always is, that He is then made according to the flesh. And having redeemed all, He becomes thereby again Lord of the living and the dead. For all things henceforth serve Him, and this is David's meaning in the Psalm: "The Lord said to my Lord, Sit on My right hand, until I make Your enemies Your footstool." For it was fitting that the redemption should take place through none other than Him who is Lord by nature, lest, though created by the Son, we should name another Lord and fall into the Arian and Greek folly of serving the creature rather than the all-creating God.

14. For the Son of God indeed, being Himself the Word, is Lord of all; but we once were subject from the first to the slavery of corruption and the curse of the Law, then by degrees fashioning for ourselves things that were not, we served, as says the blessed Apostle, 'them which by nature are no Gods Galatians 4:8,' and, ignorant of the true God, we preferred things that were not to the truth; but afterwards, as the ancient people when oppressed in Egypt groaned, so, when we too had the Law 'engrafted James 1:21 ' in us, and according to the unutterable sighings Romans 8:26 of the Spirit made our intercession, 'O Lord our God, take possession of us,' then, as 'He became for a house of refuge' and a 'God and defense,' so also He became our Lord. Nor did He then begin to be, but we began to have Him for our Lord. For upon this, God being good and Father of the Lord, in pity, and desiring to be known by all, makes His own Son put on Him a human body and become man, and be called Jesus, that in this body offering Himself for all, He might deliver all from false worship and corruption, and might Himself become of all Lord and King. His becoming therefore in this way Lord and King, this it is that Peter means by, 'He has made Him Lord,' and 'has sent Christ.' as much as to say, that the Father in making Him man (for to be made belongs to man), did not simply make Him man, but has made Him in order to His being Lord of all men, and to His hallowing all through the Anointing. For though the Word existing in the form of God took a servant's form, yet the assumption of the flesh did not make a servant of the Word, who was by nature Lord; but rather, not only was it that emancipation of all humanity which takes place by the Word, but that very Word who was by nature Lord, and was then made man, has by means of a servant's form been made Lord of all and Christ, that is, in order to hallow all by the Spirit. And as God, when 'becoming a God and defense,' and saying, 'I will be a God to them,' does not then become God more than before, nor then begins to become God, but, what He ever is, that He then becomes to those who need Him, when it pleases Him, so Christ also being by nature Lord and King everlasting, does not become Lord more than He was at the time He is sent forth, nor then begins to be Lord and King, but what He is ever, that He then is made according to the flesh; and, having redeemed all, He becomes thereby again Lord of quick and dead. For Him henceforth do all things serve, and this is David's meaning in the Psalm, 'The Lord said to my Lord, Sit on My right hand, until I make Your enemies Your footstool.' For it was fitting that the redemption should take place through none other than Him who is the Lord by nature, lest, though created by the Son, we should name another Lord, and fall into the Arian and Greek folly, serving the creature beyond the all-creating God.

According to my humble understanding, this is what this passage means. Moreover, Peter's words have a true and good meaning when directed toward the Jews. For the Jews, having strayed from the truth, do expect the Christ to come, but they do not accept that He undergoes suffering, saying what they do not understand: "We know that when the Christ comes, He remains forever, so how can You say that He must be lifted up?" Furthermore, they suppose Him to be not the Word coming in flesh, but merely a man, like all the other kings. The Lord, therefore, when instructing Cleopas and the other disciple, taught them that the Christ must first suffer. And to the rest of the Jews, He taught that God had come among them, saying: "If He called them gods to whom the word of God came, and the Scripture cannot be broken, do you say of Him whom the Father has sanctified and sent into the world, 'You blaspheme,' because I said, 'I am the Son of God'?"

15. This, at least according to my nothingness, is the meaning of this passage; moreover, a true and a good meaning have these words of Peter as regards the Jews. For Jews, astray from the truth, expect indeed the Christ as coming, but do not reckon that He undergoes a passion, saying what they understand not; 'We know that, when the Christ comes, He abides for ever, and how do You say, that He must be lifted up?' Next they suppose Him, not the Word coming in flesh, but a mere man, as were all the kings. The Lord then, admonishing Cleopas and the other, taught them that the Christ must first suffer; and the rest of the Jews that God had come among them, saying, 'If He called them gods to whom the word of God came, and the Scripture cannot be broken, say ye of Him whom the Father has sanctified and sent into the world, Thou blaspheme, because I said, I am the Son of God John 10:36?'

Peter, having learned this from the Savior, corrected the Jews on both points. He said: O Jews, the divine Scriptures announce that Christ comes, and you consider Him a mere man, one of David's descendants. But what is written about Him shows He is not as you say. Rather, Scripture announces Him as Lord and God, immortal and the giver of life. For Moses said, "You shall see your Life hanging before your eyes." And David in Psalm 109 says, "The Lord said to My Lord, Sit on My right hand, till I make Your enemies Your footstool," and in Psalm 15, "You shall not leave my soul in hades, neither shall You suffer Your Holy One to see corruption." David himself witnesses that these passages are not about him, declaring that the one who was coming was his own Lord. Indeed, you yourselves know that he is dead and his remains are with you. You will plainly confess that the Christ must be as the Scriptures say. For those announcements come from God, and there can be no falsehood in them. If you can state that such a one has already come and can prove him God from the signs and wonders he did, you have reason to maintain the argument. But if you cannot prove His coming and are still expecting such a one, recognize the true time from Daniel, for his words relate to the present time. If this present time is the one announced long ago, and you have seen what has taken place among us, be sure that this Jesus, whom you crucified, is the expected Christ. For David and all the Prophets died, and the tombs of all are with you. But the resurrection that has now taken place has shown that these passages refer to Jesus. The crucifixion is indicated by "You shall see your Life hanging," and the wound in the side by the spear fulfills "He was led as a sheep to the slaughter" (Isaiah 53:7). The resurrection—indeed, the rising of the ancient dead from their tombs, which most of you have seen—this is "You shall not leave My soul in hades" and "He swallowed up death in strength" (Isaiah 25:8) and again, "God will wipe away." The signs that actually took place show that He who was in a body was God, and also the Life and Lord of death. For it was fitting that the Christ, when giving life to others, should not Himself be held by death. But this could not have happened if He had been, as you suppose, a mere man. In truth He is the Son of God, for all men are subject to death. Let no one doubt, but let the whole house of Israel know with certainty that this Jesus, whom you saw in the form of a man, doing signs and works such as no one had ever done before, is Himself the Christ and Lord of all. For though made man and called Jesus, as we said before, He suffered no loss by that human suffering. Rather, by being made man, He is revealed as Lord of the living and the dead. For since, as the Apostle said, "in the wisdom of God the world by wisdom knew not God, it pleased God by the foolishness of preaching to save them that believe" (1 Corinthians 1:21). And so, since we humans would not acknowledge God through His Word, nor serve the Word of God our natural Master, it pleased God to show His own Lordship in man, and thus to draw all people to Himself. But to do this through a mere man would not be fitting, lest, having a man for our Lord, we should become worshippers of man. Therefore the Word Himself became flesh, and the Father called His name Jesus, and so "made" Him Lord and Christ—which is to say, He made Him to rule and to reign. This was so that when in the name of Jesus, whom you crucified, every knee bows, we may acknowledge as Lord and King both the Son and through Him the Father.

16. Peter then, having learned this from the Saviour, in both points set the Jews right, saying, O Jews, the divine Scriptures announce that Christ comes, and you consider Him a mere man as one of David's descendants, whereas what is written of Him shows Him to be not such as you say, but rather announces Him as Lord and God, and immortal, and dispenser of life. For Moses has said, 'You shall see your Life hanging before your eyes.' And David in the hundred and ninth Psalm, 'The Lord said to My Lord, Sit on My right hand, till I make Your enemies Your footstool;' and in the fifteenth, 'You shall not leave my soul in hades, neither shall Thou suffer Your Holy One to see corruption.' Now that these passages have not David for their scope he himself witnesses, avowing that He who was coming was His own Lord. Nay you yourselves know that He is dead, and His remains are with you. That the Christ then must be such as the Scriptures say, you will plainly confess yourselves. For those announcements come from God, and in them falsehood cannot be. If then ye can state that such a one has come before, and can prove him God from the signs and wonders which he did, you have reason for maintaining the contest, but if you are not able to prove His coming, but are expecting such an one still, recognise the true season from Daniel, for his words relate to the present time. But if this present season be that which was of old, afore-announced, and you have seen what has taken place among us, be sure that this Jesus, whom you crucified, this is the expected Christ. For David and all the Prophets died, and the sepulchres of all are with you, but that Resurrection which has now taken place, has shown that the scope of these passages is Jesus. For the crucifixion is denoted by 'You shall see your Life hanging,' and the wound in the side by the spear answers to 'He was led as a sheep to the slaughter Isaiah 53:7,' and the resurrection, nay more, the rising of the ancient dead from out their sepulchres (for these most of you have seen), this is, 'You shall not leave My soul in hades,' and 'He swallowed up death in strength Isaiah 25:8,' and again, 'God will wipe away.' For the signs which actually took place show that He who was in a body was God, and also the Life and Lord of death. For it became the Christ, when giving life to others, Himself not to be detained by death; but this could not have happened, had He, as you suppose, been a mere man. But in truth He is the Son of God, for men are all subject to death. Let no one therefore doubt, but the whole house of Israel know assuredly that this Jesus, whom you saw in shape a man, doing signs and such works, as no one ever yet had done, is Himself the Christ and Lord of all. For though made man, and called Jesus, as we said before, He received no loss by that human passion, but rather, in being made man, He is manifested as Lord of quick and dead. For since, as the Apostle said, 'in the wisdom of God the world by wisdom knew not God, it pleased God by the foolishness of preaching to save them that believe 1 Corinthians 1:21.' And so, since we men would not acknowledge God through His Word, nor serve the Word of God our natural Master, it pleased God to show in man His own Lordship, and so to draw all men to Himself. But to do this by a mere man beseemed not; lest, having man for our Lord, we should become worshippers of man. Therefore the Word Himself became flesh, and the Father called His Name Jesus, and so 'made' Him Lord and Christ, as much as to say, 'He made Him to rule and to reign;' that while in the Name of Jesus, whom you crucified, every knee bows, we may acknowledge as Lord and King both the Son and through Him the Father.

The Jews, most of them, upon hearing this came to their senses and immediately acknowledged the Christ, as it is written in the Acts. But the Arian-maniacs, on the contrary, choose to remain like Jews and to argue with Peter. So let us set before them some parallel phrases—perhaps it may have some effect on them to discover how divine Scripture typically uses such language. Now that Christ is everlasting Lord and King has become clear from what has gone before, nor is there anyone to doubt it. For being Son of God, He must be like Him, and being like, He is certainly both Lord and King, for He Himself says, "He who has seen Me has seen the Father." On the other hand, that Peter's simple words, "He has made Him both Lord and Christ," do not imply the Son is a creature may be seen from Isaac's blessing, though this illustration is only a faint one for our subject. Now Isaac said to Jacob, "Become lord over your brother," and to Esau, "Behold, I have made him your lord." Now even if the word "made" referred to Jacob's essence and his coming into being, it still would not be right for them to imagine the same of the Word of God, for the Son of God is no creature as Jacob was. Besides, they might inquire and so rid themselves of that absurdity. But if they do not understand it as referring to his essence or to his coming into being, though Jacob was by nature (physis) a creature and a work, is not their madness worse than the Devil's, if what they dare not ascribe to things that are by nature (physis) originated, even when similar phrasing is used, they attach to the Son of God, saying that He is a creature? For Isaac said "Become" and "I have made," signifying neither the coming into being nor the essence of Jacob (for he said this more than thirty years after his birth), but his authority over his brother, which came about subsequently.

17. The Jews then, most of them, hearing this, came to themselves and immediately acknowledged the Christ, as it is written in the Acts. But, the Ario-maniacs on the contrary choose to remain Jews, and to contend with Peter; so let us proceed to place before them some parallel phrases; perhaps it may have some effect upon them, to find what the usage is of divine Scripture. Now that Christ is everlasting Lord and King, has become plain by what has gone before, nor is there a man to doubt about it; for being Son of God, He must be like Him, and being like, He is certainly both Lord and King, for He says Himself, 'He that has seen Me, has seen the Father.' On the other hand, that Peter's mere words, 'He has made Him both Lord and Christ,' do not imply the Son to be a creature, may be seen from Isaac's blessing, though this illustration is but a faint one for our subject. Now he said to Jacob, 'Become thou lord over your brother;' and to Esau, 'Behold, I have made him your lord.' Now though the word 'made' had implied Jacob's essence and the coming into being, even then it would not be right in them as much as to imagine the same of the Word of God, for the Son of God is no creature as Jacob was; besides, they might inquire and so rid themselves of that extravagance. But if they do not understand it of his essence nor of his coming into being, though Jacob was by nature creature and work, is not their madness worse than the Devil's, if what they dare not ascribe in consequence of a like phrase even to things by nature originate, that they attach to the Son of God, saying that He is a creature? For Isaac said 'Become' and 'I have made,' signifying neither the coming into being nor the essence of Jacob (for after thirty years and more from his birth he said this); but his authority over his brother, which came to pass subsequently.

Peter said this without meaning that the essence (ousia) of the Word was something created. He knew Christ was God's Son, confessing, "You are the Christ, the Son of the Living God" (Matthew 16:16). Rather, he meant Christ's Kingdom and Lordship, which were formed and came to be according to grace, and existed in relation to us. While saying this, Peter was not silent about the Son of God's eternal Godhead, which belongs to the Father. He had already said that Christ poured out the Spirit on us. Now, giving the Spirit with authority is not within the power of any creature or created thing, since the Spirit is God's Gift. Creatures are sanctified by the Holy Spirit, but the Son is not sanctified by the Spirit. On the contrary, He Himself gives the Spirit to all. Therefore, He is not a creature but the true Son of the Father. Yet the one who gives the Spirit is also said to be made—that is, made Lord among us because of His manhood, while giving the Spirit because He is God's Word. For He always was and is, as Son, also Lord and Sovereign of all, being like the Father in all things and having all that belongs to the Father, as He Himself has said.

18. Much more then did Peter say this without meaning that the Essence of the Word was a work; for he knew Him to be God's Son, confessing, 'You are the Christ, the Son of the Living God Matthew 16:16;' but he meant His Kingdom and Lordship which was formed and came to be according to grace, and was relatively to us. For while saying this, he was not silent about the Son of God's everlasting Godhead which is the Father's; but He had said already, that He had poured the Spirit on us; now to give the Spirit with authority, is not in the power of creature or work, but the Spirit is God's Gift. For the creatures are hallowed by the Holy Spirit; but the Son, in that He is not hallowed by the Spirit, but on the contrary Himself the Giver of it to all, is therefore no creature, but true Son of the Father. And yet He who gives the Spirit, the same is said also to be made; that is, to be made among us Lord because of His manhood, while giving the Spirit because He is God's Word. For He ever was and is, as Son, so also Lord and Sovereign of all, being like in all things to the Father, and having all that is the Father's as He Himself has said.

Chapter 16. Introductory to Proverbs 8:22, that the Son is not a Creature. Arianformula, a creature but not as one of the creatures; but each creature is unlike all other creatures; and no creature can create. The Word then differs from all creatures in that in which they, though otherwise differing, all agree together, as creatures; viz. in being an efficient cause; in being the one medium or instrumental agent in creation; moreover in being the revealer of the Father; and in being the object of worship.

Now let us consider the passage in Proverbs: "The Lord created me a beginning of His ways for His works." However, in showing that the Word is no work, it has also been shown that He is no creature. For it is the same to say "work" or "creature," so that the proof that He is no work is also a proof that He is no creature. One may marvel at these men who devise such excuses for their irreligion and are not deterred by the refutations they meet on every point. First, they set about deceiving simple people with their questions: "Did He who exists make from what did not exist something that did not exist or something that existed?" and "Did you have a son before begetting him?" When this was proved worthless, next they invented the question: "Is the Unoriginate one or two?" Then, when they were refuted in this, they immediately formed another question: "Does He have free will and an alterable nature?" But being forced to give this up, they next started saying: "Being made so much better than the Angels." And when the truth exposed this pretense, now again, gathering all these together, they think to promote their heresy through "work" and "creature." For they mean those very same things over again and remain true to their own perverseness, putting the same errors into various shapes and turning them this way and that, hoping thereby to deceive some through that variety. Although abundant proof of this reckless expedient of theirs has been given above, yet since they make every place echo with this passage from Proverbs, and seem to many who are ignorant of the faith of Christians to be saying something significant, it is necessary to examine separately both "He created" and "who was faithful to Him that made Him," so that in this text, as in all others, they may be proved to have achieved nothing more than a fantasy.

18. ( continued). Now in the next place let us consider the passage in the Proverbs, 'The Lord created me a beginning of His ways for His works;' although in showing that the Word is no work, it has been also shown that He is no creature. For it is the same to say work or creature, so that the proof that He is no work is a proof also that He is no creature. Whereas one may marvel at these men, thus devising excuses to be irreligious, and nothing daunted at the refutations which meet them upon every point. For first they set about deceiving the simple by their questions, 'Did He who is make from that which was not one that was not or one that was?' and, 'Had you a son before begetting him?' And when this had been proved worthless, next they invented the question, 'Is the Unoriginate one or two?' Then, when in this they had been confuted, straightway they formed another, 'Has He free-will and an alterable nature?' But being forced to give up this, next they set about saying, 'Being made so much better than the Angels;' and when the truth exposed this pretence, now again, collecting them all together, they think to recommend their heresy by 'work' and 'creature.' For they mean those very things over again, and are true to their own perverseness, putting into various shapes and turning to and fro the same errors, if so be to deceive some by that variousness. Although then abundant proof has been given above of this their reckless expedient, yet, since they make all places sound with this passage from the Proverbs, and to many who are ignorant of the faith of Christians, seem to say somewhat, it is necessary to examine separately, 'He created' as well as 'Who was faithful to Him that made Him;' that, as in all others, so in this text also, they may be proved to have got no further than a fantasy.

Let us first examine the responses that the Arians gave to the blessed Alexander in the beginning, while their heresy was still being formed. They wrote this: "He is a creature, but not as one of the creatures; a work, but not as one of the works; an offspring, but not as one of the offsprings." Everyone should consider the wickedness and cunning of this heresy. Knowing the bitterness of its own evil teaching, it tries to disguise itself with attractive words. It says what it actually believes—that He is a creature—yet thinks it can hide this by adding "but not as one of the creatures." However, by writing this way, they only convict themselves of impiety. For if you believe He is simply a creature, why add the pretense "but not as one of the creatures"? And if He is simply a work, how can He be "not as one of the works"? In this we can see the poison of the heresy. For by saying "offspring, but not as one of the offsprings," they imagine many sons, and declare that the Lord is one of these. According to them, He is no longer the Only-begotten, but one among many brothers, and is called offspring and son. What good is this pretense of saying that He is a creature and not a creature? For even though you say "not as one of the creatures," I will prove this argument of yours to be foolish. You still declare Him to be one of the creatures, and whatever one might say about the other creatures, you hold the same view about the Son—you truly "fools and blind." For is any one creature exactly the same as another, that you should claim this as some special privilege for the Son? All the visible creation was made in six days: on the first, the light which He called day; on the second, the firmament; on the third, He gathered the waters together, exposed the dry land, and brought forth the various plants in it; on the fourth, He made the sun and moon and all the host of stars; on the fifth, He created living creatures in the sea and birds in the air; on the sixth, He made the land animals and finally man. And "the invisible things of Him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made"; and the light is not like the night, nor the sun like the moon, nor irrational creatures like rational man, nor the Angels like the Thrones, nor the Thrones like the Authorities. Yet they are all creatures, and each thing that was made exists and remains in its own essence according to its kind, just as it was made.

19. And first let us see the answers, which they returned to Alexander of blessed memory, in the outset, while their heresy was in course of formation. They wrote thus: 'He is a creature, but not as one of the creatures; a work, but not as one of the works; an offspring, but not as one of the offsprings.' Let every one consider the profligacy and craft of this heresy; for knowing the bitterness of its own malignity, it makes an effort to trick itself out with fair words, and says, what indeed it means, that He is a creature, yet thinks to be able to screen itself by adding, 'but not as one of the creatures.' However, in thus writing, they rather convict themselves of irreligion; for if, in your opinion, He is simply a creature, why add the pretence, 'but not as one of the creatures?' And if He is simply a work, how 'not as one of the works?' In which we may see the poison of the heresy. For by saying, 'offspring, but not as one of the offsprings,' they reckon many sons, and one of these they pronounce to be the Lord; so that according to them He is no more Only begotten, but one out of many brethren, and is called offspring and son. What use then is this pretence of saying that He is a creature and not a creature? For though you shall say, Not as 'one of the creatures,' I will prove this sophism of yours to be foolish. For still ye pronounce Him to be one of the creatures; and whatever a man might say of the other creatures, such ye hold concerning the Son, you truly 'fools and blind Matthew 23:19.' For is any one of the creatures just what another is, that you should predicate this of the Son as some prerogative? And all the visible creation was made in six days:– in the first, the light which He called day; in the second the firmament; in the third, gathering together the waters, He bared the dry land, and brought out the various fruits that are in it; and in the fourth, He made the sun and the moon and all the host of the stars; and on the fifth, He created the race of living things in the sea, and of birds in the air; and on the sixth, He made the quadrupeds on the earth, and at length man. And 'the invisible things of Him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made Romans 1:20;' and neither the light is as the night, nor the sun as the moon; nor the irrational as rational man; nor the Angels as the Thrones, nor the Thrones as the Authorities, yet they are all creatures, but each of the things made according to its kind exists and remains in its own essence, as it was made.

Let the Word then be set apart from created works, and as Creator be restored to the Father, and be confessed to be Son by nature. Or if He is simply a creature, then let Him be assigned the same status as the rest in relation to one another, and let each of them be said to be "a creature but not as one of the creatures, offspring or work, but not as one of the works or offsprings." For you say that an offspring is the same as a work, writing "generated or made." Even if the Son surpasses the rest by comparison, He is still a creature just as they are, since among things that are creatures by nature one may find some surpassing others. For instance, star differs from star in glory, and all the rest have their own differences when compared to one another. Yet it does not follow that some are lords and others servants to the superior ones, nor that some are efficient causes while others come into being through them. Rather, all have a nature that comes to be and is created, acknowledging in themselves their Maker, as David says in the Psalms: "The heavens declare the glory of God, and the firmament shows His handy work." And as Zorobabel the wise says: "All the earth calls upon the Truth, and the heaven blesses it: all works shake and tremble at it." But if the whole earth hymns the Maker and the Truth, and blesses and fears it, and its Maker is the Word, and He Himself says "I am the Truth," it follows that the Word is not a creature, but alone proper to the Father, in whom all things are ordered, and He is celebrated by all as Maker. For "I was by Him disposing," and "My Father works until now, and I work." And the word "until now" shows His eternal existence in the Father as the Word, for it is proper to the Word to work the Father's works and not to be external to Him.

20. Let the Word then be excepted from the works, and as Creator be restored to the Father, and be confessed to be Son by nature; or if simply He be a creature, then let Him be assigned the same condition as the rest one with another, and let them as well as He be said every one of them to be 'a creature but not as one of the creatures, offspring or work, but not as one of the works or offsprings.' For you say that an offspring is the same as a work, writing 'generated or made.' For though the Son excel the rest on a comparison, still a creature He is nevertheless, as they are; since in those which are by nature creatures one may find some excelling others. Star, for instance, differs from star in glory, and the rest have all of them their mutual differences when compared together; yet it follows not for all this that some are lords, and others servants to the superior, nor that some are efficient causes, others by them come into being, but all have a nature which comes to be and is created, confessing in their own selves their Framer: as David says in the Psalms, 'The heavens declare the glory of God, and the firmament shows His handy work;' and as Zorobabel the wise says, 'All the earth calls upon the Truth, and the heaven blesses it: all works shake and tremble at it Ezra 4:36.' But if the whole earth hymns the Framer and the Truth, and blesses, and fears it, and its Framer is the Word, and He Himself says, 'I am the Truth John 14:6,' it follows that the Word is not a creature, but alone proper to the Father, in whom all things are disposed, and He is celebrated by all, as Framer; for 'I was by Him disposing;' and 'My Father works hitherto, and I work John 5:17.' And the word 'hitherto' shows His eternal existence in the Father as the Word; for it is proper to the Word to work the Father's works and not to be external to Him.

But if the Father's works are also the Son's works, and what the Son creates is the Father's creation, and yet the Son is the Father's work or creature, then either He will work Himself and be His own creator (since the Father's works are also the Son's works), which is absurd and impossible; or, since He creates and works the Father's things, He Himself is not a work or a creature. Otherwise, being Himself an efficient cause, He might cause things caused to have what He Himself has become—or rather, He would have no power to cause anything at all.

21. But if what the Father works, that the Son works also, and what the Son creates, that is the creation of the Father, and yet the Son be the Father's work or creature, then either He will work His own self, and will be His own creator (since what the Father works is the Son's work also), which is absurd and impossible; or, in that He creates and works the things of the Father, He Himself is not a work nor a creature; for else being Himself an efficient cause, He may cause that to be in the case of things caused, which He Himself has become, or rather He may have no power to cause at all.

For how, if as you claim He came from nothing, is He able to create things that are nothing into existence? Or if He, being a creature, actually creates another creature, then the same thing would be possible for every creature—namely, the power to create others. And if this idea pleases you, what is the need for the Word, since inferior things could be brought into existence by superior things? Or at any rate, everything that is brought into being could have simply heard God's words in the beginning, "Become" and "be made," and so would have been created. But this is not what is written, nor could it be. For none of the things that are brought into being is an efficient cause, but all things were made through the Word. He would not have created all things if He Himself were numbered among the creatures. For the Angels would not be able to create either, since they too are creatures, even though Valentinus and Marcion and Basilides think so, and you are copying them. Nor will the sun, being a creature, ever make what does not exist into what exists. Nor will a human being fashion a human being, nor will stone produce stone, nor will wood make wood grow. But God is the one who fashions the human being in the womb, establishes the mountains, and makes wood grow. Meanwhile, a human being, having the capacity for knowledge, puts together and arranges existing material and works with things that already exist, as he has learned. And he is satisfied if they merely come to be, and being conscious of what his nature is, if he needs anything, he knows to ask it of God.

For how, if, as you hold, He has come of nothing, is He able to frame things that are nothing into being? Or if He, a creature, withal frames a creature, the same will be conceivable in the case of every creature, viz. the power to frame others. And if this pleases you, what is the need of the Word, seeing that things inferior can be brought to be by things superior? Or at all events, every thing that is brought to be could have heard in the beginning God's words, 'Become' and 'be made,' and so would have been framed. But this is not so written, nor could it be. For none of things which are brought to be is an efficient cause, but all things were made through the Word: who would not have wrought all things, were He Himself in the number of the creatures. For neither would the Angels be able to frame, since they too are creatures, though Valentinus, and Marcion, and Basilides think so, and you are their copyists; nor will the sun, as being a creature, ever make what is not into what is; nor will man fashion man, nor stone devise stone, nor wood give growth to wood. But God is He who fashions man in the womb, and fixes the mountains, and makes wood grow; whereas man, as being capable of science, puts together and arranges that material, and works things that are, as he has learned; and is satisfied if they are but brought to be, and being conscious of what his nature is, if he needs anything, knows to ask it of God.

If God worked with and shaped pre-existing materials, this is a pagan idea—according to which God is a craftsman rather than a Creator—but even in that case, let the Word work with the materials at the Father's command and in His service. But if God calls into existence things that did not exist by His own Word, then the Word is not among the things that are non-existent and called into being; otherwise we would need to look for another Word through whom He too was called, for it is by the Word that things which did not exist have come to be. And if the Father creates and makes through Him, then He is not Himself among created and made things; rather He is the Word of the Creator God and is known from the Father's works which He Himself performs, so that He is "in the Father and the Father in Him," and "whoever has seen Him has seen the Father," because the Son's ousia is proper to the Father, and He is in all respects like Him. How then does the Father create through Him, unless He is His Word and His Wisdom? And how can He be Word and Wisdom, unless He is the proper offspring of His ousia, and did not come into being, as all other things did, out of nothing? While all things are from nothing and are creatures, and the Son—according to what they say—is one of the creatures and among things that once did not exist, how does He alone reveal the Father, and how does no one but He know the Father? For if He, being a created work, could possibly know the Father, then the Father must also be known by all according to the capacity of each one, for all of them are works just as He is. But if it is impossible for created things either to see or to know, because the sight and knowledge of Him surpasses all (since God Himself says, "No one shall see My face and live"), yet the Son has declared, "No one knows the Father except the Son," therefore the Word is different from all created things, in that He alone knows and alone sees the Father, as He says, "Not that anyone has seen the Father, except He who is from the Father," and "no one knows the Father except the Son"—though Arius thinks otherwise. How then did He alone know, except that He alone is proper to Him? And how is He proper, if He is a creature and not a true Son from Him? (For one must not hesitate to say the same thing often for the sake of true religion.) Therefore it is irreligious to think that the Son is one among all things, and blasphemous and meaningless to call Him "a creature, but not as one of the creatures, and a work, but not as one of the works, and an offspring, but not as one of the offspring." For how is He not as one of these, if, as they say, He did not exist before His generation? For it is characteristic of creatures and works not to exist before they originate, and to come into being out of nothing, even if they surpass other creatures in glory; for this difference between one and another is found in all creatures, as is evident in those which are visible.

22. If then God also wrought and compounded out of materials, this indeed is a gentile thought, according to which God is an artificer and not a Maker, but yet even in that case let the Word work the materials, at the bidding and in the service of God. But if He calls into existence things which existed not by His proper Word, then the Word is not in the number of things non-existing and called; or we have to seek another Word, through whom He too was called; for by the Word the things which were not have come to be. And if through Him He creates and makes, He is not Himself of things created and made; but rather He is the Word of the Creator God and is known from the Father's works which He Himself works, to be 'in the Father and the Father in Him,' and 'He that has seen Him has seen the Father,' because the Son's Essence is proper to the Father, and He in all points like Him. How then does He create through Him, unless it be His Word and His Wisdom? And how can He be Word and Wisdom, unless He be the proper offspring of His Essence, and did not come to be, as others, out of nothing? And whereas all things are from nothing, and are creatures, and the Son, as they say, is one of the creatures too and of things which once were not, how does He alone reveal the Father, and none else but He know the Father? For could He, a work, possibly know the Father, then must the Father be also known by all according to the proportion of the measures of each: for all of them are works as He is. But if it be impossible for things originate either to see or to know, for the sight and the knowledge of Him surpasses all (since God Himself says, 'No one shall see My face and live '), yet the Son has declared, 'No one knows the Father, save the Son Matthew 11:27,' therefore the Word is different from all things originate, in that He alone knows and alone sees the Father, as He says, 'Not that any one has seen the Father, save He that is from the Father,' and 'no one knows the Father save the Son,' though Arius think otherwise. How then did He alone know, except that He alone was proper to Him? And how proper, if He were a creature, and not a true Son from Him? (For one must not mind saying often the same thing for religion's sake.) Therefore it is irreligious to think that the Son is one of all things; and blasphemous and unmeaning to call Him 'a creature, but not as one of the creatures, and a work, but not as one of the works, an offspring, but not as one of the offsprings.' for how not as one of these, if, as they say, He was not before His generation? For it is proper to the creatures and works not to be before their origination, and to subsist out of nothing, even though they excel other creatures in glory; for this difference of one with another will be found in all creatures, which appears in those which are visible.

Moreover, if the Son were a creature or work—but not like the other creatures because he exceeds them in glory, as the heretics claim—then Scripture would naturally describe and display him through favorable comparisons with other works. For instance, it would say he is greater than the Archangels, more honorable than the Thrones, brighter than the sun and moon, and greater than the heavens. But in fact this is not how he is referred to. Instead, the Father shows him to be his own proper and only Son, saying, "You are My Son," and "This is My beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased." Accordingly, the Angels ministered to him as one beyond themselves, and they worship him not as someone greater in glory, but as someone beyond all creatures, beyond themselves, and alone the Father's proper Son according to ousia. For if he were worshipped because he excels them in glory, then each subordinate thing ought to worship whatever excels it. But this is not the case. For creature does not worship creature, but servant worships Lord, and creature worships God. Thus the Apostle Peter prevents Cornelius from worshipping him, saying, "I myself also am a man" (Acts 10:26). And an Angel, when John would worship him in the Apocalypse, prevents him, saying, "See that you do it not; for I am your fellow-servant, and of your brethren the Prophets, and of them that keep the sayings of this book: worship God" (Revelation 22:9). Therefore worship belongs to God alone, and the very Angels know this—that though they excel other beings in glory, they are all creatures and are not to be worshipped, but worship the Lord. Thus Manoah, the father of Samson, when wishing to offer sacrifice to the Angel, was prevented by him, who said, "Offer not to me, but to God." On the other hand, the Lord is worshipped even by the Angels, for it is written, "Let all the Angels of God worship Him" (Hebrews 1:6), and by all the Gentiles, as Isaiah says, "The labor of Egypt and merchandise of Ethiopia and of the Sabeans, men of stature, shall come over unto you, and they shall be your servants," and then, "they shall fall down unto you, and shall make supplication unto you, saying, Surely God is in you, and there is none else, there is no God" (Isaiah 45:14). And he accepts his disciples' worship and confirms to them who he is, saying, "Call ye me not Lord and Master? And you say well, for so I am." And when Thomas said to him, "My Lord and my God," he allows his words, or rather accepts him instead of preventing him. For he is, as the other Prophets declare and David says in the Psalm, "the Lord of hosts, the Lord of Sabaoth"—which is interpreted "the Lord of Armies"—and God True and Almighty, though the Arians burst at the news.

23. Moreover if, as the heretics hold, the Son were creature or work, but not as one of the creatures, because of His excelling them in glory, it were natural that Scripture should describe and display Him by a comparison in His favour with the other works; for instance, that it should say that He is greater than Archangels, and more honourable than the Thrones, and both brighter than sun and moon, and greater than the heavens. But he is not in fact thus referred to; but the Father shows Him to be His own proper and only Son, saying, 'You are My Son,' and 'This is My beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased.' Accordingly the Angels ministered unto Him, as being one beyond themselves; and they worship Him, not as being greater in glory, but as being some one beyond all the creatures, and beyond themselves, and alone the Father's proper Son according to essence. For if He was worshipped as excelling them in glory, each of things subservient ought to worship what excels itself. But this is not the case; for creature does not worship creature, but servant Lord, and creature God. Thus Peter the Apostle hinders Cornelius who would worship him, saying, 'I myself also am a man Acts 10:26.' And an Angel, when John would worship him in the Apocalypse, hinders him, saying, 'See thou do it not; for I am your fellow-servant, and of your brethren the Prophets, and of them that keep the sayings of this book: worship God Revelation 22:9.' Therefore to God alone appertains worship, and this the very Angels know, that though they excel other beings in glory, yet they are all creatures and not to be worshipped, but worship the Lord. Thus Manoah, the father of Samson, wishing to offer sacrifice to the Angel, was thereupon hindered by him, saying, 'Offer not to me, but to God.' On the other hand, the Lord is worshipped even by the Angels; for it is written, 'Let all the Angels of God worship Him Hebrews 1:6;' and by all the Gentiles, as Isaiah says, 'The labour of Egypt and merchandize of Ethiopia and of the Sabeans, men of stature, shall come over unto you, and they shall be your servants;' and then, 'they shall fall down unto you, and shall make supplication unto you, saying, Surely God is in you, and there is none else, there is no God Isaiah 45:14.' And He accepts His disciples' worship, and certifies them who He is, saying, 'Call ye Me not Lord and Master? And you say well, for so I am.' And when Thomas said to Him, 'My Lord and my God,' He allows his words, or rather accepts him instead of hindering him. For He is, as the other Prophets declare, and David says in the Psalm, 'the Lord of hosts, the Lord of Sabaoth,' which is interpreted, 'the Lord of Armies,' and God True and Almighty, though the Arians burst at the tidings.

But He would not have been worshipped this way or spoken of in these terms if He were merely a creature. But since He is not a creature, but rather the proper offspring of the ousia of that God who is worshipped, and His Son by nature, therefore He is worshipped and believed to be God, and is Lord of armies, and in authority, and Almighty, just as the Father is. For He Himself has said, "All things that the Father has are Mine" (John 16:15). For it is proper to the Son to have the things of the Father, and to be such that the Father is seen in Him, and that through Him all things were made, and that the salvation of all comes to pass and exists in Him.

24. But He had not been thus worshipped, nor been thus spoken of, were He a creature merely. But now since He is not a creature, but the proper offspring of the Essence of that God who is worshipped, and His Son by nature, therefore He is worshipped and is believed to be God, and is Lord of armies, and in authority, and Almighty, as the Father is; for He has said Himself, 'All things that the Father has, are Mine John 16:15.' For it is proper to the Son, to have the things of the Father, and to be such that the Father is seen in Him, and that through Him all things were made, and that the salvation of all comes to pass and consists in Him.

Chapter 17. Introduction to Proverbs 8:22 continued. Absurdity of supposing a Son or Word created in order to the creation of other creatures; as to the creation being unable to bear God's immediate hand, God condescends to the lowest. Moreover, if the Son a creature, He too could not bear God's hand, and an infiniteseries of media will be necessary. Objected, that, as Moseswho led out the Israelites was a man, so our Lord; but Moseswas not the Agent in creation:– again, that unity is found in created ministrations, but all such ministrations are defective and dependent:– again, that He learned to create, yet could God's Wisdom need teaching? And why should He learn, if the Father works hitherto? If the Son was created to create us, He is for our sake, not we for His

Here it would be good to ask them this question too, to refute their heresy even more clearly: Since all things are creatures brought into existence from nothing, and the Son Himself, according to you, is a creature and work who once did not exist, why has God made all things through Him alone, and without Him not one thing was made? Or why is it that when Scripture speaks of all things, no one thinks the Son is included in that number, but only created things? Yet when Scripture speaks of the Word, it does not count Him among all things, but places Him with the Father as the one through whom Providence and salvation for all things are accomplished and carried out by the Father. Surely all things could have come to be at the same command by which He was brought into being by God alone. For God does not grow weary by commanding, nor is His strength insufficient for making all things, so that He would need to create the only Son alone and then require His service and help for forming the rest. God does not leave undone anything He wills to be done. He willed only, and all things came into existence, and no one has resisted His will. Why then were not all things brought into being by God alone at that same command by which the Son came into being? Or let them tell us why all things came to be through Him, who was Himself merely a created being. How unreasonable! Yet they say concerning Him that God, wanting to create originate nature but seeing that it could not endure the untempered hand of the Father and be created by Him, makes and creates first and alone one only being, and calls Him Son and Word, so that through Him as a medium all things might then be brought into being. They have not only said this but have dared to put it in writing, namely Eusebius, Arius, and Asterius who sacrificed.

24. ( continued). And here it were well to ask them also this question, for a still clearer refutation of their heresy — Wherefore, when all things are creatures, and all are brought into consistence from nothing, and the Son Himself, according to you, is creature and work, and once was not, wherefore has He made 'all things through Him' alone, 'and without Him was made not one thing John 1:3?' or why is it, when 'all things' are spoken of, that no one thinks the Son is signified in the number, but only things originate; whereas when Scripture speaks of the Word, it does not understand Him as being in the number of 'all,' but places Him with the Father, as Him in whom Providence and salvation for 'all' are wrought and effected by the Father, though all things surely might at the same command have come to be, at which He was brought into being by God alone? For God is not wearied by commanding, nor is His strength unequal to the making of all things, that He should alone create the only Son, and need His ministry and aid for the framing of the rest. For He lets nothing stand over, which He wills to be done; but He willed only, and all things subsisted, and no one 'has resisted His will Romans 9:19.' Why then were not all things brought into being by God alone at that same command, at which the Son came into being? Or let them tell us, why did all things through Him come to be, who was Himself but originate? How void of reason! However, they say concerning Him, that 'God willing to create originate nature, when He saw that it could not endure the untempered hand of the Father, and to be created by Him, makes and creates first and alone one only, and calls Him Son and Word, that, through Him as a medium, all things might thereupon be brought to be.' This they not only have said, but they have dared to put it into writing, namely, Eusebius, Arius, and Asterius who sacrificed.

Is this not full proof of the irreligion they have poisoned themselves with through such great madness that they are not ashamed to be drunk on opposition to the truth? For if they claim that God made only the Son because the toil of making all things was too much, the whole creation will cry out against them for speaking unworthily of God, as will Isaiah, who has said in Scripture, "The Everlasting God, the Lord, the Creator of the ends of the earth, neither faints nor grows weary; there is no searching of His understanding." And if God made only the Son, not deigning to make the rest but assigning them to the Son as an assistant, this too is unworthy of God, for there is no pride in Him. Indeed, the Lord rebukes this very thought when He says, "Are not two sparrows sold for a farthing, and one of them shall not fall to the ground without your Father which is in heaven?" And again, "Take no thought for your life, what you shall eat, nor yet for your body, what you shall put on. Is not the life more than meat, and the body than raiment? Behold the fowls of the air, for they sow not, neither do they reap, nor gather into barns; yet your heavenly Father feeds them; are you not much better than they? Which of you by taking thought can add one cubit unto his stature? And why take ye thought for raiment? Consider the lilies of the field, how they grow; they toil not, neither do they spin: and yet I say unto you, that even Solomon in all his glory was not arrayed like one of these. Wherefore if God so clothe the grass of the field which today is, and tomorrow is cast into the oven, shall He not much more clothe you, O you of little faith?" If then it is not unworthy of God to exercise His providence even down to such small things as a hair of the head, a sparrow, and the grass of the field, it was also not unworthy of Him to make them. For whatever things are subjects of His providence, of those He is Maker through His proper Word. Indeed, an even worse absurdity confronts these men who speak this way; for they distinguish between the creatures and the making, considering the latter the work of the Father and the creatures the work of the Son. Yet either all things must be brought into being by the Father with the Son, or if all that is originated comes to be through the Son, we must not call Him one of the originated things.

25. Is not this a full proof of that irreligion, with which they have drugged themselves with much madness, till they blush not to be intoxicate against the truth? For if they shall assign the toil of making all things as the reason why God made the Son only, the whole creation will cry out against them as saying unworthy things of God; and Isaiah too who has said in Scripture, 'The Everlasting God, the Lord, the Creator of the ends of the earth, faints not, neither is weary: there is no searching of His understanding Isaiah 40:28.' And if God made the Son alone, as not deigning to make the rest, but committed them to the Son as an assistant, this on the other hand is unworthy of God, for in Him there is no pride. Nay the Lord reproves the thought, when He says, 'Are not two sparrows sold for a farthing?' and 'one of them shall not fall on the ground without your Father which is in heaven.' And again, 'Take no thought for your life, what you shall eat, nor yet for your body, what you shall put on. Is not the life more than meat, and the body than raiment? Behold the fowls of the air, for they sow not, neither do they reap, nor gather into barns; yet your heavenly Father feeds them; are you not much better than they? Which of you by taking thought, can add one cubit unto his stature? And why take ye thought for raiment? Consider the lilies of the field, how they grow; they toil not, neither do they spin: and yet I say unto you, that even Solomon in all his glory was not arrayed like one of these. Wherefore if God so clothe the grass of the field which today is, and tomorrow is cast into the oven, shall He not much more clothe you, O you of little faith?' If then it be not unworthy of God to exercise His Providence, even down to things so small, a hair of the head, and a sparrow, and the grass of the field, also it was not unworthy of Him to make them. For what things are the subjects of His Providence, of those He is Maker through His proper Word. Nay a worse absurdity lies before the men who thus speak; for they distinguish between the creatures and the framing; and consider the latter the work of the Father, the creatures the work of the Son; whereas either all things must be brought to be by the Father with the Son, or if all that is originate comes to be through the Son, we must not call Him one of the originated things.

Next, their foolishness can be shown as follows: if even the Word is of created nature, then since this nature is too weak to be God's own direct work, how could He alone out of everything endure being made by the uncreated and undiminished Essence of God, as you claim? For it follows that either, if He could endure it, all could endure it, or, if it was endurable by none, it was not endurable by the Word either, since you say He is one of created things. And again, if a mediator became necessary because created nature could not endure being God's own direct work, it must follow that, since the Word is created and a creature, a medium is also needed for His making, since He too is of that created nature which cannot endure being made by God but needs a medium. But if some being is found as a medium for Him, then again a fresh mediator is needed for that second one, and thus tracing backward and forward, we will invent a vast crowd of accumulating mediators. And so it will be impossible for creation to exist, since it will always need a mediator, and that medium cannot come into being without another mediator, for all of them will be of that created nature which cannot endure being made by God alone, as you say. How abundant is the foolishness that forces them to hold that what has already come into being cannot admit of coming into being! Or perhaps they think that these things have not even come to be, since they are still seeking their mediator. For on the basis of their irreligious and futile notion, what exists would have no existence for lack of the medium.

26. Next, their folly may be exposed thus:– if even the Word be of originated nature, how, whereas this nature is too feeble to be God's own handywork, could He alone of all endure to be made by the unoriginate and unmitigated Essence of God, as you say? For it follows either that, if He could endure it, all could endure it, or, it being endurable by none, it was not endurable by the Word, for you say that He is one of originate things. And again, if because originate nature could not endure to be God's own handywork, there arose need of a mediator, it must follow, that, the Word being originate and a creature, there is need of medium in His framing also, since He too is of that originate nature which endures not to be made of God, but needs a medium. But if some being as a medium be found for Him, then again a fresh mediator is needed for that second, and thus tracing back and following out, we shall invent a vast crowd of accumulating mediators; and thus it will be impossible that the creation should subsist, as ever wanting a mediator, and that medium not coming into being without another mediator; for all of them will be of that originate nature which endures not to be made of God alone, as you say. How abundant is that folly, which obliges them to hold that what has already come into being, admits not of coming! Or perhaps they opine that they have not even come to be, as still seeking their mediator; for, on the ground of their so irreligious and futile notion, what is would not have subsistence, for want of the medium.

But again they make this claim: 'Look, God led the people out of Egypt through Moses, and through him He gave the Law, yet Moses was a man; so it is possible for like to be brought into being by like.' They should cover their faces when they say this, to hide their great shame. For Moses was not sent to form the world, nor to call into existence things that did not exist, or to fashion men like himself, but only to serve as a messenger of words to the people and to King Pharaoh. And this is very different, because to serve is the role of created beings as servants, but to form and to create belongs to God alone, and to His own Word and His Wisdom. Therefore, in the matter of forming, we find none but God's Word; for 'all things are made in Wisdom,' and 'without the Word was made not one thing.' But regarding services, there are not one only, but many from their whole number, whomever the Lord chooses to send. For there are many Archangels, many Thrones, and Authorities, and Dominions, thousands of thousands, and myriads of myriads, standing before Him, serving and ready to be sent. And many Prophets, and twelve Apostles, and Paul. And Moses himself was not alone, but Aaron was with him, and then seventy others were filled with the Holy Spirit. And Moses was succeeded by Joshua the Son of Nun, and he by the Judges, and they not by one, but by a number of Kings. If then the Son were a creature and one of the things that have come into being, there must have been many such sons, so that God might have many such ministers, just as there is a multitude of those others. But if this is not what we observe, and while the creatures are many, the Word is one, anyone will conclude from this that the Son differs from all, and is not on the same level with the creatures, but is proper to the Father. Hence there are not many Words, but one only Word of the one Father, and one Image of the one God. 'But look,' they say, 'there is one sun only, and one earth.' Let them maintain, foolish as they are, that there is one water and one fire, and then they may be told that everything that is brought into being is one in its own essence; but for the ministry and service assigned to it, by itself it is not adequate nor sufficient alone. For God said, 'Let there be lights in the firmament of heaven, to give light upon the earth and to divide the day from the night; and let them be for signs and for seasons and for days and years.' And then he says, 'And God made two great lights, the greater light to rule the day, and the lesser light to rule the night: He made the stars also. And God set them in the firmament of the heaven, to give light upon the earth, and to rule over the day and over the night.'

27. But again they allege this:– 'Behold, through Moses too did He lead the people from Egypt, and through him He gave the Law, yet he was a man; so that it is possible for like to be brought into being by like.' They should veil their face when they say this, to save their much shame. For Moses was not sent to frame the world, nor to call into being things which were not, or to fashion men like himself, but only to be the minister of words to the people, and to King Pharaoh. And this is a very different thing, for to minister is of things originate as of servants, but to frame and to create is of God alone, and of His proper Word and His Wisdom. Wherefore, in the matter of framing, we shall find none but God's Word; for 'all things are made in Wisdom,' and 'without the Word was made not one thing.' But as regards ministrations there are, not one only, but man out of their whole number, whomever the Lord will send. For there are many Archangels, many Thrones, and Authorities, and Dominions, thousands of thousands, and myriads of myriads, standing before Him, ministering and ready to be sent. And many Prophets, and twelve Apostles, and Paul. And Moses himself was not alone, but Aaron with him, and next other seventy were filled with the Holy Ghost. And Moses was succeeded by Joshua the Son of Nun, and he by the Judges, and they not by one, but by a number of Kings. If then the Son were a creature and one of things originate, there must have been many such sons, that God might have many such ministers, just as there is a multitude of those others. But if this is not to be seen, but while the creatures are many, the Word is one, any one will collect from this, that the Son differs from all, and is not on a level with the creatures, but proper to the Father. Hence there are not many Words, but one only Word of the one Father, and one Image of the one God. 'But behold,' they say, 'there is one sun only, and one earth.' Let them maintain, senseless as they are, that there is one water and one fire, and then they may be told that everything that is brought to be, is one in its own essence; but for the ministry and service committed to it, by itself it is not adequate nor sufficient alone. For God said, 'Let there be lights in the firmament of heaven, to give light upon the earth and to divide the day from the night; and let them be for signs and for seasons and for days and years.' And then he says, 'And God made two great lights, the greater light to rule the day, and the lesser light to rule the night: He made the stars also. And God set them in the firmament of the heaven, to give light upon the earth, and to rule over the day and over the night. '

Behold there are many lights, not just the sun or the moon, but each is one in ousia (essence), and yet the service of all is one and common. What each lacks is supplied by the other, and the work of lighting is performed by all. Thus the sun has authority to shine throughout the day and no more, and the moon through the night, and the stars together with them accomplish the seasons and years, and become signs, each according to the need that calls for it. Likewise the earth is not for all things, but for fruits only, and to be a ground for the living things that inhabit it to walk on. And the firmament is to divide between waters and waters, and to be a place to set the stars in. So also fire and water, with other things, have been brought into being to be the constituent parts of bodies. In short, no one thing is alone, but all things that are made, as if members of each other, make up as it were one body, namely the world. If then they conceive of the Son in this way, let all men throw stones at them, considering the Word to be a part of this universe, and a part insufficient without the rest for the service committed to Him. But if this is clearly irreligious, let them acknowledge that the Word is not in the number of things originate, but the sole and proper Word of the Father, and their Framer. But they say, though He is a creature and of things originate, yet as from a master and craftsman He has learned to frame, and thus ministered to God who taught Him. For thus the Sophist Asterius, on the strength of having learned to deny the Lord, has dared to write, not observing the absurdity which follows. For if framing is a thing to be taught, let them beware lest they say that God Himself is a Framer not by nature but by knowledge, so as to admit of His losing the power. Besides, if the Wisdom of God attained to frame by teaching, how is He still Wisdom when He needs to learn? And what was He before He learned? For it was not Wisdom if it needed teaching. It was surely but some empty thing, and not essential Wisdom, but from advancement it had the name of Wisdom, and will be Wisdom only so long as it can keep what it has learned. For what has accrued not by any nature but from learning admits of being at some time unlearned. But to speak thus of the Word of God is not the part of Christians but of Greeks.

28. Behold there are many lights, and not the sun only, nor the moon only, but each is one in essence, and yet the service of all is one and common; and what each lacks, is supplied by the other, and the office of lighting is performed by all. Thus the sun has authority to shine throughout the day and no more; and the moon through the night; and the stars together with them accomplish the seasons and years, and become for signs, each according to the need that calls for it. Thus too the earth is not for all things, but for the fruits only, and to be a ground to tread on for the living things that inhabit it. And the firmament is to divide between waters and waters, and to be a place to set the stars in. So also fire and water, with other things, have been brought into being to be the constituent parts of bodies; and in short no one thing is alone, but all things that are made, as if members of each other, make up as it were one body, namely, the world. If then they thus conceive of the Son, let all men throw stones at them, considering the Word to be a part of this universe, and a part insufficient without the rest for the service committed to Him. But if this be manifestly irreligious, let them acknowledge that the Word is not in the number of things originate, but the sole and proper Word of the Father, and their Framer. 'But,' say they, 'though He is a creature and of things originate; yet as from a master and artificer has He learned to frame, and thus ministered to God who taught Him.' For thus the Sophist Asterius, on the strength of having learned to deny the Lord, has dared to write, not observing the absurdity which follows. For if framing be a thing to be taught, let them beware lest they say that God Himself be a Framer not by nature but by science, so as to admit of His losing the power. Besides, if the Wisdom of God attained to frame by teaching, how is He still Wisdom, when He needs to learn? And what was He before He learned? For it was not Wisdom, if it needed teaching; it was surely but some empty thing, and not essential Wisdom, but from advancement it had the name of Wisdom, and will be only so long Wisdom as it can keep what it has learned. For what has accrued not by any nature, but from learning, admits of being one time unlearned. But to speak thus of the Word of God, is not the part of Christians but of Greeks.

If the ability to create comes to someone through teaching, then these foolish people are attributing jealousy and weakness to God. Jealousy, because He has not taught many how to create, so that just as there are many Archangels and Angels around Him, there might also be many creators. And weakness, because He could not make things by Himself but needed a fellow-worker or subordinate worker. Yet it has already been shown that created nature can be made by God alone, since they consider the Son to be of that nature and made in that way. But God lacks nothing—God forbid! For He Himself has said, "I am full." Nor did the Word become Creator of all through teaching. Rather, being the Image and Wisdom of the Father, He does the Father's works. Nor has the Father made the Son for the purpose of making created things. For look—even though the Son exists, the Father is still seen to work, as the Lord Himself says, "My Father works until now, and I work." However, if, as you say, the Son came into being for the purpose of making the things after Him, and yet the Father is seen to work even after the Son exists, you must conclude that even in this view the making of such a Son is pointless. Besides, why would God seek a mediator at all when He wants to create us, as if His will were not sufficient to bring into existence whatever seemed good to Him? Yet the Scriptures say, "He has done whatever pleased Him," and "Who has resisted His will?" And if His will alone is sufficient for the creation of all things, you make the role of a mediator unnecessary. Your example of Moses, and of the sun and moon, has been shown not to apply. And here is another argument to silence you. You say that God, wanting to create originated nature and deliberating about it, plans and creates the Son so that through Him He may create us. Now if this is so, consider what a great impiety you have dared to speak.

29. For if the power of framing accrues to anyone from teaching, these insensate men are ascribing jealousy and weakness to God — jealousy, in that He has not taught many how to frame, so that there may be around Him, as Archangels and Angels many, so framers many; and weakness, in that He could not make by Himself, but needed a fellow-worker, or under-worker; and that, though it has been already shown that created nature admits of being made by God alone, since they consider the Son to be of such a nature and so made. But God is deficient in nothing: perish the thought! For He has said Himself, 'I am full Isaiah 1:11.' Nor did the Word become Framer of all from teaching; but being the Image and Wisdom of the Father, He does the things of the Father. Nor has He made the Son for the making of things created; for behold, though the Son exists, still the Father is seen to work, as the Lord Himself says, 'My Father works hitherto and I work John 5:17.' If however, as you say, the Son came into being for the purpose of making the things after Him, and yet the Father is seen to work even after the Son, you must hold even in this light the making of such a Son to be superfluous. Besides, why, when He would create us, does He seek for a mediator at all, as if His will did not suffice to constitute whatever seemed good to Him? Yet the Scriptures say, 'He has done whatsoever pleased Him,' and 'Who has resisted His will Romans 9:19?' And if His mere will is sufficient for the framing of all things, you make the office of a mediator superfluous; for your instance of Moses, and the sun and the moon has been shown not to hold. And here again is an argument to silence you. You say that God, willing the creation of originated nature, and deliberating concerning it, designs and creates the Son, that through Him He may frame us; now, if so, consider how great an irreligion you have dared to utter.

If the Son was created for us, then it seems He exists for our sake rather than we for His. We were not created for Him; rather, He was made for us. By this reasoning, He should thank us, not we Him—just as Scripture says the woman should thank the man: "For the man was not created for the woman, but the woman for the man." Therefore, just as "the man is the image and glory of God, and the woman the glory of the man," so we are made in God's image and for His glory, while the Son becomes our image and exists for our glory. We were brought into being simply to exist, but God's Word was made—according to this view—not to exist for His own sake, but as a tool for our needs. On this view, we do not derive from Him; rather, He derives from our need. Are not people who even think such thoughts worse than senseless? For if the Word was made for us, He has no priority over us with God. God did not take counsel about us while already having the Word within Himself; instead, having us in His mind, He then deliberated about His own Word. If this were so, perhaps the Father had no desire for the Son at all, since He did not create Him out of desire for Him, but formed Him for our sake out of desire for us. He designed the Son after designing us, so that—according to these irreligious people—the Son, who was made as an instrument, is now superfluous once those for whom He was created have been made. But if the Son alone was made by God alone because He could endure it, while we were made by the Word because we could not endure God's direct hand, why does God not first take counsel about the Word, who could endure being made by Him, instead of taking counsel about us? Why does He not pay more attention to the one who was strong rather than to us who were weak? Why, if He makes the Son first, does He not deliberate about Him first? Why, if He deliberates about us first, does He not make us first, since His will is sufficient to bring all things into existence? Yet He creates the Son first but deliberates about us first. He desires us before the Mediator. When He wills to create us and deliberates about us, He calls us creatures, but the one He fashions for us He calls Son and rightful Heir. Yet we, for whose sake He supposedly made Him, ought rather to be called sons; or certainly the one who is His Son should be the primary object of His thought and will, the one for whom He makes all of us. Such is the sickness, such is the vomit of the heretics.

30. First, the Son appears rather to have been for us brought to be, than we for Him; for we were not created for Him, but He is made for us; so that He owes thanks to us, not we to Him, as the woman to the man. 'For the man,' says Scripture, 'was not created for the woman, but the woman for the man.' Therefore, as 'the man is the image and glory of God, and the woman the glory of the man 1 Corinthians 11:7, 9,' so we are made God's image and to His glory; but the Son is our image, and exists for our glory. And we were brought into being that we might be; but God's Word was made, as you must hold, not that He might be; but as an instrument for our need, so that not we from Him, but He is constituted from our need. Are not men who even conceive such thoughts, more than insensate? For if for us the Word was made, He has not precedence of us with God; for He did not take counsel about us having Him within Him, but having us in Himself, counselled, as they say, concerning His own Word. But if so, perchance the Father had not even a will for the Son at all; for not as having a will for Him, did He create Him, but with a will for us, He formed Him for our sake; for He designed Him after designing us; so that, according to these irreligious men, henceforth the Son, who was made as an instrument, is superfluous, now that they are made for whom He was created. But if the Son alone was made by God alone, because He could endure it, but we, because we could not, were made by the Word, why does He not first take counsel about the Word, who could endure His making, instead of taking counsel about us? Or why does He not make more of Him who was strong, than of us who were weak? Or why making Him first, does He not counsel about Him first? Or why counselling about us first, does He not make us first, His will being sufficient for the constitution of all things? But He creates Him first, yet counsels first about us; and He wills us before the Mediator; and when He wills to create us, and counsels about us, He calls us creatures; but Him, whom He frames for us, He calls Son and proper Heir. But we, for whose sake He made Him, ought rather to be called sons; or certainly He, who is His Son, is rather the object of His previous thoughts and of His will, for whom He makes all us. Such the sickness, such the vomit of the heretics.

Chapter 18. Introduction to Proverbs 8:22 continued. Contrast between the Father's operations immediately and naturally in the Son, instrumentally by the creatures; Scripture terms illustrative of this. Explanation of these illustrations; which should be interpreted by the doctrine of the Church; perverse sense put on them by the Arians, refuted. Mystery of Divine Generation. Contrast between God's Word and man's word drawn out at length. Asterius betrayed into holding two Unoriginates; his inconsistency. Baptism how by the Son as well as by the Father. On the Baptism of heretics. Why Arianworse than other heresies.

The truth about this matter must not be concealed but openly declared. For the Word of God was not made for us, but rather we for Him, and "in Him all things were created" (Colossians 1:16). Nor was He made strong by the Father alone because we were weak, so that the Father might use Him as an instrument to create us—certainly not! It is not like that. For even if God had chosen not to make created things, the Word would still have been with God, and the Father in Him. At the same time, created things could not have come into being without the Word; therefore they were made through Him—and rightly so. For since the Word is the Son of God by nature proper to His ousia, and is from Him and in Him, as He Himself said, the creatures could not have come to be except through Him. For just as light illuminates all things by its radiance, and without its radiance nothing would be illuminated, so also the Father, as if by a hand, worked all things in the Word, and without Him makes nothing. For example, God said, as Moses records, "Let there be light," and "Let the waters be gathered together," and "let the dry land appear," and "Let Us make man"; as also Holy David says in the Psalm, "He spoke and they were made; He commanded and they were created." And He spoke, not so that, as with humans, some subordinate worker might hear and, learning the will of the one who spoke, might go away and do it; for this is proper to creatures, but it is improper to think or speak this way about the Word. For the Word of God is Framer and Maker, and He is the Father's Will. Therefore Scripture does not say that someone heard and answered concerning the manner or nature of the things He wished to be made; but God only said, "Let it become," and Scripture adds, "And it became"; for what He thought good and purposed, the Word immediately began to do and complete. For when God commands others, whether the Angels, or converses with Moses, or commands Abraham, then the hearer answers; and one says, "How shall I know?" (Genesis 15:8) and another, "Send someone else" (Exodus 4:13); and again, "If they ask me, what is His Name, what shall I say to them?" and the Angel said to Zacharias, "Thus says the Lord"; and he asked the Lord, "O Lord of hosts, how long will You not have mercy on Jerusalem?" and waits to hear good and comforting words. For each of these has the Mediator Word, and the Wisdom of God which makes known the will of the Father. But when that Word Himself works and creates, then there is no questioning and answering, for the Father is in Him and the Word in the Father; but it is sufficient to will, and the work is done; so that the expression "He said" signifies the will for our sake, and "It was so" denotes the work that is accomplished through the Word and the Wisdom, in which Wisdom also is the Will of the Father. And "God said" is explained in "the Word," for Scripture says, "You have made all things in Wisdom"; and "By the Word of the Lord the heavens were made firm"; and "There is one Lord Jesus Christ, by whom are all things, and we by Him."

31. But the sentiment of Truth in this matter must not be hidden, but must have high utterance. For the Word of God was not made for us, but rather we for Him, and 'in Him all things were created Colossians 1:16.' Nor for that we were weak, was He strong and made by the Father alone, that He might frame us by means of Him as an instrument; perish the thought! It is not so. For though it had seemed good to God not to make things originate, still had the Word been no less with God, and the Father in Him. At the same time, things originate could not without the Word be brought to be; hence they were made through Him — and reasonably. For since the Word is the Son of God by nature proper to His essence, and is from Him, and in Him, as He said Himself, the creatures could not have come to be, except through Him. For as the light enlightens all things by its radiance, and without its radiance nothing would be illuminated, so also the Father, as by a hand, in the Word wrought all things, and without Him makes nothing. For instance, God said, as Moses relates, 'Let there be light,' and 'Let the waters be gathered together,' and 'let the dry land appear,' and 'Let Us make man;' as also Holy David in the Psalm, 'He spoke and they were made; He commanded and they were created.' And He spoke, not that, as in the case of men, some under-worker might hear, and learning the will of Him who spoke might go away and do it; for this is what is proper to creatures, but it is unseemly so to think or speak of the Word. For the Word of God is Framer and Maker, and He is the Father's Will. Hence it is that divine Scripture says not that one heard and answered, as to the manner or nature of the things which He wished made; but God only said, 'Let it become,' and he adds, 'And it became;' for what He thought good and counselled, that immediately the Word began to do and to finish. For when God commands others, whether the Angels, or converses with Moses, or commands Abraham, then the hearer answers; and the one says, 'Whereby shall I know Genesis 15:8?' and the other, 'Send some one else Exodus 4:13;' and again, 'If they ask me, what is His Name, what shall I say to them?' and the Angel said to Zacharias, 'Thus says the Lord;' and he asked the Lord, 'O Lord of hosts, how long will You not have mercy on Jerusalem.' and waits to hear good words and comfortable. For each of these has the Mediator Word, and the Wisdom of God which makes known the will of the Father. But when that Word Himself works and creates, then there is no questioning and answer, for the Father is in Him and the Word in the Father; but it suffices to will, and the work is done; so that the word 'He said' is a token of the will for our sake, and 'It was so,' denotes the work which is done through the Word and the Wisdom, in which Wisdom also is the Will of the Father. And 'God said' is explained in 'the Word,' for, he says, 'You have made all things in Wisdom;' and 'By the Word of the Lord were the heavens made fast.' and 'There is one Lord Jesus Christ, by whom are all things, and we by Him. '

It is clear from this that the Arians are not really fighting with us about their heresy; rather, while they pretend to oppose us, their real fight is against the Godhead itself. For if it were our voice saying, "This is My Son," our complaint against them would be minor; but since it is the Father's voice, and the disciples heard it, and the Son also says of Himself, "Before all the mountains He begot me," are they not fighting against God, like the giants in mythology, having their tongue, as the Psalmist says, a sharp sword for irreligion? For they neither feared the Father's voice, nor reverenced the Savior's words, nor trusted the Saints, one of whom writes, "Who being the Brightness of His glory and the Expression of His hypostasis," and "Christ the power of God and the Wisdom of God;" and another says in the Psalm, "With You is the well of life, and in Your Light shall we see light," and "You made all things in Wisdom;" and the Prophets say, "And the Word of the Lord came to me;" and John says, "In the beginning was the Word," and Luke says, "As they delivered them unto us which from the beginning were eye-witnesses and ministers of the Word;" and as David again says, "He sent His Word and healed them." All these passages condemn the Arian heresy in every way, and signify the eternity of the Word, and that He is not foreign but proper to the Father's ousia. For when has anyone seen light without radiance? Or who dares to say that the expression can be different from the hypostasis? Or has not a man lost his mind who even entertains the thought that God was ever without Reason and without Wisdom? For Scripture has proposed such illustrations and such images so that, considering human nature's inability to comprehend God, we might be able to form ideas even from these, however poorly and dimly, and as far as is possible. And just as the creation contains abundant material for the knowledge of the being of a God and a Providence ("for by the greatness and beauty of the creatures proportionably the Maker of them is seen"), and we learn from them without asking for voices, but hearing the Scriptures we believe, and surveying the very order and harmony of all things, we acknowledge that He is Maker and Lord and God of all, and apprehend His marvelous Providence and governance over all things; so in the same way concerning the Son's Godhead, what has been said above is sufficient, and it becomes unnecessary, or rather it is very mad to dispute about it, or to ask in a heretical way, How can the Son be from eternity? Or how can He be from the Father's ousia, yet not a part? Since what is said to be of another, is a part of him; and what is divided, is not whole.

32. It is plain from this that the Arians are not fighting with us about their heresy; but while they pretend us, their real fight is against the Godhead Itself. For if the voice were ours which says, 'This it My Son,' small were our complaint of them; but if it is the Father's voice, and the disciples heard it, and the Son too says of Himself, 'Before all the mountains He begot me,' are they not fighting against God, as the giants in story, having their tongue, as the Psalmist says, a sharp sword for irreligion? For they neither feared the voice of the Father, nor reverenced the Saviour's words, nor trusted the Saints, one of whom writes, 'Who being the Brightness of His glory and the Expression of His subsistence,' and 'Christ the power of God and the Wisdom of God;' and another says in the Psalm, 'With You is the well of life, and in Your Light shall we see light,' and 'You made all things in Wisdom;' and the Prophets say, 'And the Word of the Lord came to me Jeremiah 2:1;' and John, 'In the beginning was the Word.' and Luke, 'As they delivered them unto us which from the beginning were eye-witnesses and ministers of the Word John 1:1; Luke 1:2;' and as David again says, 'He sent His Word and healed them.' All these passages proscribe in every light the Arian heresy, and signify the eternity of the Word, and that He is not foreign but proper to the Father's Essence. For when saw any one light without radiance? Or who dares to say that the expression can be different from the subsistence? Or has not a man himself lost his mind who even entertains the thought that God was ever without Reason and without Wisdom? For such illustrations and such images has Scripture proposed, that, considering the inability of human nature to comprehend God, we might be able to form ideas even from these however poorly and dimly, and as far as is attainable. And as the creation contains abundant matter for the knowledge of the being of a God and a Providence ('for by the greatness and beauty of the creatures proportionably the Maker of them is seen Wisdom 13:5 '), and we learn from them without asking for voices, but hearing the Scriptures we believe, and surveying the very order and the harmony of all things, we acknowledge that He is Maker and Lord and God of all, and apprehend His marvellous Providence and governance over all things; so in like manner about the Son's Godhead, what has been above said is sufficient, and it becomes superfluous, or rather it is very mad to dispute about it, or to ask in an heretical way, How can the Son be from eternity? Or how can He be from the Father's Essence, yet not a part? Since what is said to be of another, is a part of him; and what is divided, is not whole.

These are the evil sophistries of the heterodox. Yet, though we have already shown their shallowness, the exact sense of these passages themselves and the force of these illustrations will serve to show the baseless nature of their loathsome doctrine. For we see that reason is always present, and comes from the one whose reason it is and is proper to his essence, and does not admit a before and an after. So again we see that the radiance from the sun is proper to it, and the sun's essence is not divided or impaired. Rather, its essence is whole and its radiance perfect and whole, yet without impairing the essence of light, but as a true offspring from it. We understand in the same way that the Son is begotten not from outside but from the Father, and while the Father remains whole, the Expression of His Subsistence always exists and preserves the Father's likeness and unchanging Image, so that whoever sees Him sees in Him the Subsistence too, of which He is the Expression. And from the operation of the Expression we understand the true Godhead of the Subsistence, as the Savior Himself teaches when He says, "The Father who dwells in Me, He does the works which I do," and "I and the Father are one," and "I in the Father and the Father in Me." Therefore let this Christ-opposing heresy first attempt to divide the examples found in created things, and say, "Once the sun was without its radiance," or "Radiance is not proper to the essence of light," or "It is indeed proper, but it is a part of light by division." And then let it divide Reason, and declare that it is foreign to mind, or that once it was not, or that it was not proper to its essence, or that it is by division a part of mind. And so with His Expression and the Light and the Power, let it do violence to these as in the case of Reason and Radiance, and instead let it imagine what it will. But if such extravagance is impossible for them, are they not greatly beside themselves, presumptuously intruding into what is higher than created things and their own nature, and attempting impossibilities?

33. These are the evil sophistries of the heterodox; yet, though we have already shown their shallowness, the exact sense of these passages themselves and the force of these illustrations will serve to show the baseless nature of their loathsome tenet. For we see that reason is ever, and is from him and proper to his essence, whose reason it is, and does not admit a before and an after. So again we see that the radiance from the sun is proper to it, and the sun's essence is not divided or impaired; but its essence is whole and its radiance perfect and whole, yet without impairing the essence of light, but as a true offspring from it. We understand in like manner that the Son is begotten not from without but from the Father, and while the Father remains whole, the Expression of His Subsistence is ever, and preserves the Father's likeness and unvarying Image, so that he who sees Him, sees in Him the Subsistence too, of which He is the Expression. And from the operation of the Expression we understand the true Godhead of the Subsistence, as the Saviour Himself teaches when He says, 'The Father who dwells in Me, He does the works John 14:10 ' which I do; and 'I and the Father are one,' and 'I in the Father and the Father in Me John 10:30.' Therefore let this Christ — opposing heresy attempt first to divide the examples found in things originate, and say, 'Once the sun was without his radiance,' or, 'Radiance is not proper to the essence of light,' or 'It is indeed proper, but it is a part of light by division; and then let it divide Reason, and pronounce that it is foreign to mind, or that once it was not, or that it was not proper to its essence, or that it is by division a part of mind.' And so of His Expression and the Light and the Power, let it do violence to these as in the case of Reason and Radiance; and instead let it imagine what it will. But if such extravagance be impossible for them, are they not greatly beside themselves, presumptuously intruding into what is higher than things originate and their own nature, and essaying impossibilities?

If offspring can be found in the case of these created and non-rational things that are not parts of the essences from which they come, nor exist through passion, nor damage the essences of their sources, are they not foolish again in seeking and imagining parts and passions in the case of the immaterial and true God, and attributing divisions to Him who is beyond passion and change, thereby confusing the ears of the simple and turning them away from the Truth? For who hears of a son but thinks of that which is proper to the father's essence? Who heard, in his first instruction, that God has a Son and has made all things by His proper Word, but understood it in the sense in which we now mean it? Who, when this hateful heresy of the Arians arose, was not immediately shocked by what he heard, as something strange, and a second sowing, different from that Word which had been sown from the beginning? For what is sown in every soul from the beginning is that God has a Son, the Word, the Wisdom, the Power, that is, His Image and Radiance; from which it immediately follows that He always exists; that He is from the Father; that He is like; that He is the eternal offspring of His essence; and there is no idea of creature or work involved in these. But when the man who is an enemy, while men slept, made a second sowing, of 'He is a creature,' and 'There was once when He was not,' and 'How can it be?' then the wicked heresy of Christ's enemies rose like weeds, and immediately, as if stripped of every right thought, they interfere like robbers, and dare to say, 'How can the Son always exist with the Father?' For men come from men and are sons, after a time; and the father is thirty years old when the son begins to exist, being begotten; and in short, of every son of man, it is true that he did not exist before his generation. And again they whisper, 'How can the Son be Word, or the Word be God's Image? For the word of men is composed of syllables, and only signifies the speaker's will, and then is over and is lost.'

34. For if in the case of these originate and irrational things offsprings are found which are not parts of the essences from which they are, nor subsist with passion, nor impair the essences of their originals, are they not mad again in seeking and conjecturing parts and passions in the instance of the immaterial and true God, and ascribing divisions to Him who is beyond passion and change, thereby to perplex the ears of the simple and to pervert them from the Truth? For who hears of a son but conceives of that which is proper to the father's essence? Who heard, in his first catechising, that God has a Son and has made all things by His proper Word, but understood it in that sense in which we now mean it? Who on the rise of this odious heresy of the Arians, was not at once startled at what he heard, as strange, and a second sowing, besides that Word which had been sown from the beginning? For what is sown in every soul from the beginning is that God has a Son, the Word, the Wisdom, the Power, that is, His Image and Radiance; from which it at once follows that He is always; that He is from the Father; that He is like; that He is the eternal offspring of His essence; and there is no idea involved in these of creature or work. But when the man who is an enemy, while men slept, made a second sowing, of 'He is a creature,' and 'There was once when He was not,' and 'How can it be?' thenceforth the wicked heresy of Christ's enemies rose as tares, and immediately, as bereft of every right thought, they meddle like robbers, and venture to say, 'How can the Son always exist with the Father.' for men come of men and are sons, after a time; and the father is thirty years old, when the son begins to be, being begotten; and in short of every son of man, it is true that he was not before his generation. And again they whisper, 'How can the Son be Word, or the Word be God's Image? For the word of men is composed of syllables, and only signifies the speaker's will, and then is over and is lost.'

They then once again, as if forgetting the proofs already urged against them, pierce themselves through with these bonds of irreligion and argue in this way. But the word of truth refutes them as follows: if they were disputing about any human being, then let them use human reasoning in this way concerning both His Word and His Son. But if they are discussing God who created humanity, they should no longer entertain human thoughts but ones that are above human nature. For whatever the one who begets is like, so necessarily is the offspring; and whatever the Word's Father is like, so also must His Word be. Now a human being, begotten in time, also begets his child in time; and since he came to be from nothing, his word also passes away and does not continue. But God is not like a human being, as Scripture has said, but exists and is forever; therefore His Word also exists and is everlastingly with the Father, as radiance is of light. A human being's word is composed of syllables and neither lives nor accomplishes anything, but only signifies the speaker's intention, and merely goes forth and passes by, never to appear again, since it did not exist at all before it was spoken. Therefore a human being's word neither lives nor accomplishes anything, nor in short is it a human being. This happens to it, as I said before, because the human being who begets it has his nature out of nothing. But God's Word is not merely pronounced, as one might say, nor a sound of accents, nor is His command meant by His Son; but as radiance is of light, so He is perfect offspring from perfect. Hence He is also God, as being God's Image, for Scripture says "the Word was God." And human words do not avail for accomplishment; hence a human being works not by means of words but of hands, for they have being, and a human being's word does not subsist. But the "Word of God," as the Apostle says, "is living and powerful and sharper than any two-edged sword, piercing even to the dividing asunder of soul and spirit, and of the joints and marrow, and is a discerner of the thoughts and intents of the heart. Neither is there any creature that is not manifest in His sight; but all things are naked and opened unto the eyes of Him with whom we have to do." He is then the Framer of all, "and without Him was made not one thing," nor can anything be made without Him.

35. They then afresh, as if forgetting the proofs which have been already urged against them, 'pierce themselves through ' with these bonds of irreligion, and thus argue. But the word of truth confutes them as follows:– if they were disputing concerning any man, then let them exercise reason in this human way, both concerning His Word and His Son; but if of God who created man, no longer let them entertain human thoughts, but others which are above human nature. For such as he that begets, such of necessity is the offspring; and such as is the Word's Father, such must be also His Word. Now man, begotten in time, in time also himself begets the child; and whereas from nothing he came to be, therefore his word also is over and continues not. But God is not as man, as Scripture has said; but is existing and is ever; therefore also His Word is existing and is everlastingly with the Father, as radiance of light. And man's word is composed of syllables, and neither lives nor operates anything, but is only significant of the speaker's intention, and does but go forth and go by, no more to appear, since it was not at all before it was spoken; wherefore the word of man neither lives nor operates anything, nor in short is man. And this happens to it, as I said before, because man who begets it, has his nature out of nothing. But God's Word is not merely pronounced, as one may say, nor a sound of accents, nor by His Son is meant His command; but as radiance of light, so is He perfect offspring from perfect. Hence He is God also, as being God's Image; for 'the Word was God John 1:1 ' says Scripture. And man's words avail not for operation; hence man works not by means of words but of hands, for they have being, and man's word subsists not. But the ' Word of God,' as the Apostle says, 'is living and powerful and sharper than any two-edged sword, piercing even to the dividing asunder of soul and spirit, and of the joints and marrow, and is a discerner of the thoughts and intents of the heart. Neither is there any creature that is not manifest in His sight; but all things are naked and opened unto the eyes of Him with whom we have to do. Hebrews 4:12-13 ' He is then Framer of all, 'and without Him was made not one thing John 1:3,' nor can anything be made without Him.

We must not ask why God's Word is not like our word, since God is not like us, as has already been said. Nor is it right to seek how the Word comes from God, or how He is God's radiance, or how God begets, and what the manner of His begetting is. For a person must be out of his mind to venture into such questions, since this is something ineffable and proper to God's nature, known to Him alone and to the Son, and yet he demands it be explained in words. It is the same as if they were asking where God is, and how God is, and of what nature the Father is. But just as asking such questions is irreligious and shows ignorance of God, so it is unholy to venture such questions about the generation of the Son of God, or to measure God and His Wisdom by our own nature and weakness. Nor may a person use that as an excuse to stray in his thoughts from the truth, nor, if anyone is puzzled by such inquiries, should he disbelieve what is written. For it is better in puzzlement to be silent and believe, than to disbelieve on account of the puzzlement. For he who is puzzled may somehow obtain mercy, because though he has questioned, he has still kept quiet. But when a person is led by his puzzlement into forming doctrines for himself that are unworthy, and utters what is unworthy of God, such boldness receives a sentence without mercy. For in such puzzlements divine Scripture is able to offer him some relief, so as to understand rightly what is written, and to consider our word as an illustration: that just as it is proper to us and is from us, and not an external work to us, so also God's Word is proper to Him and from Him, and is not a work. And yet He is not like the word of man, or else we must suppose God to be man. For observe, many and varied are human words which pass away day by day, because those that come before others do not continue but vanish. Now this happens because their authors are human and have seasons that pass away and ideas that are successive, and what strikes them first and second, that they utter. So they have many words, and yet after them all nothing at all remains, for the speaker ceases and his word is immediately spent. But God's Word is one and the same, and as it is written, "The Word of God endures forever," not changed, not before or after another, but existing the same always. For it was fitting, since God is One, that His Image should also be One, and His Word One and His Wisdom One.

36. Nor must we ask why the Word of God is not such as our word, considering God is not such as we, as has been before said; nor again is it right to seek how the word is from God, or how He is God's radiance, or how God begets, and what is the manner of His begetting. For a man must be beside himself to venture on such points; since a thing ineffable and proper to God's nature, and known to Him alone and to the Son, this he demands to be explained in words. It is all one as if they sought where God is, and how God is, and of what nature the Father is. But as to ask such questions is irreligious, and argues an ignorance of God, so it is not holy to venture such questions concerning the generation of the Son of God, nor to measure God and His Wisdom by our own nature and infirmity. Nor is a person at liberty on that account to swerve in his thoughts from the truth, nor, if any one is perplexed in such inquiries, ought he to disbelieve what is written. For it is better in perplexity to be silent and believe, than to disbelieve on account of the perplexity: for he who is perplexed may in some way obtain mercy, because, though he has questioned, he has yet kept quiet; but when a man is led by his perplexity into forming for himself doctrines which beseem not, and utters what is unworthy of God, such daring recurs a sentence without mercy. For in such perplexities divine Scripture is able to afford him some relief, so as to take rightly what is written, and to dwell upon our word as an illustration; that as it is proper to us and is from us, and not a work external to us, so also God's Word is proper to Him and from Him, and is not a work; and yet is not like the word of man, or else we must suppose God to be man. For observe, many and various are men's words which pass away day by day; because those that come before others continue not, but vanish. Now this happens because their authors are men, and have seasons which pass away, and ideas which are successive; and what strikes them first and second, that they utter; so that they have many words, and yet after them all nothing at all remaining; for the speaker ceases, and his word immediately is spent. But God's Word is one and the same, and, as it is written, 'The Word of God endures for ever,' not changed, not before or after other, but existing the same always. For it was fitting, whereas God is One, that His Image should be One also, and His Word One and One His Wisdom.

I am amazed that, even though God is One, these men introduce according to their own private ideas many images and wisdoms and words. They say that the Father's proper and natural Word is something other than the Son, and that by this Word He even made the Son. They claim that He who is really the Son is only called Word notionally, like vine and way and door and tree of life, and that He is called Wisdom in name only. They assert that the proper and true Wisdom of the Father, which coexists ingenerately with Him, is other than the Son, and that by this Wisdom He even made the Son and named Him Wisdom as one who partakes of it. They have not kept this to mere words, but Arius composed it in his Thalia, and the sophist Asterius wrote what we stated above, as follows: "Blessed Paul did not say that he preached Christ, the Power of God or the Wisdom of God, but without the article, 'God's power' and 'God's wisdom,' thus preaching that the proper Power of God Himself which is natural to Him and coexistent in Him ingenerately is something besides, which generated Christ and created the whole world. Concerning this he teaches in his Epistle to the Romans thus: 'The invisible things of Him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even His eternal Power and Godhead.' For just as no one would say that the Godhead mentioned there was Christ, but the Father Himself, so, as I think, His eternal Power and Godhead also is not the Only-Begotten Son, but the Father who begot Him." And he teaches that there is another power and wisdom of God, manifested through Christ. And shortly after, the same Asterius says, "However His eternal power and wisdom, which truth argues to be without beginning and ingenerate, must surely be one. For there are many wisdoms which are created one by one by Him, of whom Christ is the first-born and only-begotten. Yet all equally depend on their Possessor. And all the powers are rightly called His who created and uses them, just as the Prophet says that the locust, which came to be a divine punishment of human sins, was called by God Himself not only a power, but a great power, and blessed David in most of the Psalms invites not the Angels alone, but the Powers to praise God."

37. Wherefore I am in wonder how, whereas God is One, these men introduce, after their private notions, many images and wisdoms and words, and say that the Father's proper and natural Word is other than the Son, by whom He even made the Son and that He who is really Son is but notionally called Word, as vine, and way, and door, and tree of life; and that He is called Wisdom also in name, the proper and true Wisdom of the Father, which coexist ingenerately with Him, being other than the Son, by which He even made the Son, and named Him Wisdom as partaking of it. This they have not confined to words, but Arius composed in his Thalia, and the Sophist Asterius wrote, what we have stated above, as follows: 'Blessed Paul said not that he preached Christ, the Power of God or the Wisdom of God,' but without the addition of the article, 'God's power' and 'God's wisdom 1 Corinthians 1:24,' thus preaching that the proper Power of God Himself which is natural to Him, and co-existent in Him ingenerately, is something besides, generative indeed of Christ, and creative of the whole world, concerning which he teaches in his Epistle to the Romans thus –'The invisible things of Him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even His eternal Power and Godhead Romans 1:20.' For as no one would say that the Godhead there mentioned was Christ, but the Father Himself, so, as I think, 'His eternal Power and Godhead also is not the Only Begotten Son, but the Father who begot Him.' And he teaches that there is another power and wisdom of God, manifested through Christ. And shortly after the same Asterius says, 'However His eternal power and wisdom, which truth argues to be without beginning and ingenerate, the same must surely be one. For there are many wisdoms which are one by one created by Him, of whom Christ is the first-born and only-begotten; all however equally depend on their Possessor. And all the powers are rightly called His who created and uses them:– as the Prophet says that the locust, which came to be a divine punishment of human sins, was called by God Himself not only a power, but a great power; and blessed David in most of the Psalms invites, not the Angels alone, but the Powers to praise God.'

Are they not worthy of every hatred for merely saying this? For if, as they claim, He is called Son not because He is begotten of the Father and proper to His ousia, but is called Word only because of rational things, and Wisdom because of things gifted with wisdom, and Power because of things gifted with power, surely He must be named Son because of those who are made sons. And perhaps because things exist, He has even His existence only in our notions. And then what is He after all? For He is none of these Himself if they are merely His names, and He has only a semblance of being and is decorated with these names from us. Rather, this is some recklessness of the devil, or worse, if they are not unwilling that they themselves should truly exist, but think that God's Word exists only in name. Is this not outrageous, to say that Wisdom coexists with the Father, yet not to say that this is the Christ, but that there are many created powers and wisdoms, of which one is the Lord whom they go on to compare to the caterpillar and locust? And are they not shameless, when they hear us say that the Word coexists with the Father and immediately object, "Are you not speaking of two Unoriginates?" yet when they themselves speak of "His Unoriginate Wisdom," do not see that they have already incurred the very charge which they so rashly urge against us? Moreover, what folly is there in that thought of theirs, that the Unoriginate Wisdom coexisting with God is God Himself! For what coexists does not coexist with itself, but with someone else, as the Evangelists say of the Lord that He was together with His disciples—for He was not together with Himself, but with His disciples—unless indeed they would say that God is of a compound nature, having wisdom as a constituent or complement of His ousia, unoriginate as well as Himself, which moreover they claim to be the framer of the world, so that they may deprive the Son of the framing of it. For there is nothing they would not maintain, sooner than hold the truth concerning the Lord.

38. Now are they not worthy of all hatred for merely uttering this? For if, as they hold, He is Son, not because He is begotten of the Father and proper to His Essence, but that He is called Word only because of things rational, and Wisdom because of things gifted with wisdom, and Power because of things gifted with power, surely He must be named a Son because of those who are made sons: and perhaps because there are things existing, He has even His existence, in our notions only. And then after all what is He? For He is none of these Himself, if they are but His names: and He has but a semblance of being, and is decorated with these names from us. Rather this is some recklessness of the devil, or worse, if they are not unwilling that they should truly subsist themselves, but think that God's Word is but in name. Is not this portentous, to say that Wisdom coexists with the Father, yet not to say that this is the Christ, but that there are many created powers and wisdoms, of which one is the Lord whom they go on to compare to the caterpillar and locust? And are they not profligate, who, when they hear us say that the Word coexists with the Father, immediately murmur out, 'Are you not speaking of two Unoriginates?' yet in speaking themselves of 'His Unoriginate Wisdom,' do not see that they have already incurred themselves the charge which they so rashly urge against us? Moreover, what folly is there in that thought of theirs, that the Unoriginate Wisdom coexisting with God is God Himself! For what coexists does not coexist with itself, but with some one else, as the Evangelists say of the Lord, that He was together with His disciples; for He was not together with Himself, but with His disciples — unless indeed they would say that God is of a compound nature, having wisdom a constituent or complement of His Essence, unoriginate as well as Himself, which moreover they pretend to be the framer of the world, that so they may deprive the Son of the framing of it. For there is nothing they would not maintain, sooner than hold the truth concerning the Lord.

Where have they found in divine Scripture, or from whom have they heard, that there is another Word and another Wisdom besides this Son, that they should construct such a doctrine for themselves? True, it is written, "Are not My words like fire, and like a hammer that breaks the rock in pieces?" (Jeremiah 23:29), and in Proverbs, "I will make known My words unto you" (Proverbs 1:23). But these are precepts and commands which God has spoken to the saints through His proper and only true Word, concerning which the Psalmist said, "I have refrained my feet from every evil way, that I may keep Your words." The Savior shows that such words are distinct from Himself when He says in His own person, "The words which I have spoken unto you" (John 6:63). For certainly such words are not offspring or sons, nor are there so many words that create the world, nor so many images of the One God, nor so many who have become men for us, nor as if from many such there were one who has become flesh, as John says. Rather, He was preached by John as the only Word of God: "The Word was made flesh," and "all things were made by Him." Therefore concerning Him alone, our Lord Jesus Christ, and of His oneness with the Father, are the testimonies written and set forth, both of the Father signifying that the Son is One, and of the saints, aware of this and saying that the Word is One and that He is Only-Begotten. His works also are set forth, for all things, visible and invisible, have been brought into being through Him, and "without Him was made not one thing." But concerning another or anyone else they have no thought, nor do they construct for themselves words or wisdoms of which neither name nor deed are indicated by Scripture, but are named only by these heretics. For it is their invention and Christ-opposing speculation, and they make the most of the name of the Word and the Wisdom. By constructing others for themselves, they deny the true Word of God and the real and only Wisdom of the Father, and thereby, miserable men, rival the Manichees. For they too, when they behold the works of God, deny Him the only and true God, and construct for themselves another whom they can show neither by work nor in any testimony drawn from the divine oracles.

39. For where at all have they found in divine Scripture, or from whom have they heard, that there is another Word and another Wisdom besides this Son, that they should frame to themselves such a doctrine? True, indeed, it is written, 'Are not My words like fire, and like a hammer that breaks the rock in pieces Jeremiah 23:29?' and in the Proverbs, 'I will make known My words unto you Proverbs 1:23;' but these are precepts and commands, which God has spoken to the saints through His proper and only true Word, concerning which the Psalmist said, 'I have refrained my feet from every evil way, that I may keep Your words.' Such words accordingly the Saviour signifies to be distinct from Himself, when He says in His own person, 'The words which I have spoken unto you John 6:63.' For certainly such words are not offsprings or sons, nor are there so many words that frame the world, nor so many images of the One God, nor so many who have become men for us, nor as if from many such there were one who has become flesh, as John says; but as being the only Word of God was He preached by John, 'The Word was made flesh,' and 'all things were made by Him.' Wherefore of Him alone, our Lord Jesus Christ, and of His oneness with the Father, are written and set forth the testimonies, both of the Father signifying that the Son is One, and of the saints, aware of this and saying that the Word is One, and that He is Only-Begotten. And His works also are set forth; for all things, visible and invisible, have been brought to be through Him, and 'without Him was made not one thing.' But concerning another or any one else they have not a thought, nor frame to themselves words or wisdoms, of which neither name nor deed are signified by Scripture, but are named by these only. For it is their invention and Christ-opposing surmise, and they make the most of the name of the Word and the Wisdom; and framing to themselves others, they deny the true Word of God, and the real and only Wisdom of the Father, and thereby, miserable men, rival the Manichees. For they too, when they behold the works of God, deny Him the only and true God, and frame to themselves another, whom they can show neither by work, nor in any testimony drawn from the divine oracles.

Therefore, if neither in the divine Scriptures is found another wisdom besides this Son, nor from the fathers have we heard of any such, yet they have confessed and written of the Wisdom coexisting with the Father without beginning, proper to Him, and the Maker of the world, this must be the Son who even according to them exists eternally with the Father. For He is Maker of all, as it is written, "In Wisdom have You made them all." Indeed, Asterius himself, as if forgetting what he wrote before, afterwards, in the manner of Caiaphas, involuntarily, when addressing the Greeks, instead of naming many wisdoms or the caterpillar, confesses only one, in these words: "God the Word is one, but many are the things rational; and one is the essence and physis of Wisdom, but many are the things wise and beautiful." And soon afterwards he says again: "Who are they whom they honor with the title of God's children? For they will not say that they too are words, nor maintain that there are many wisdoms. For it is not possible, whereas the Word is one, and Wisdom has been set forth as one, to distribute to the multitude of children the Essence of the Word, and to bestow on them the name of Wisdom." It is not at all surprising, then, that the Arians should fight against the truth, when they clash with their own principles and conflict with each other, at one time saying that there are many wisdoms, at another maintaining one; at one time grouping wisdom with the caterpillar, at another saying that it coexists with the Father and is proper to Him; now that the Father alone is without beginning, and then again that His Wisdom and His Power are also without beginning. And they fight with us for saying that the Word of God is eternal, yet forget their own teachings, and say themselves that Wisdom coexists with God without beginning. So confused are they in all these matters, denying the true Wisdom, and inventing one which does not exist, like the Manichees who make for themselves another God, after denying Him who is.

40. Therefore, if neither in the divine oracles is found another wisdom besides this Son, nor from the fathers have we heard of any such, yet they have confessed and written of the Wisdom coexisting with the Father unoriginately, proper to Him, and the Framer of the world, this must be the Son who even according to them is eternally coexistent with the Father. For He is Framer of all, as it is written, 'In Wisdom have You made them all.' Nay, Asterius himself, as if forgetting what he wrote before, afterwards, in Caiaphas's fashion, involuntarily, when urging the Greeks, instead of naming many wisdoms, or the caterpillar, confesses but one, in these words –' God the Word is one, but many are the things rational; and one is the essence and nature of Wisdom, but many are the things wise and beautiful.' And soon afterwards he says again:– 'Who are they whom they honour with the title of God's children? For they will not say that they too are words, nor maintain that there are many wisdoms. For it is not possible, whereas the Word is one, and Wisdom has been set forth as one, to dispense to the multitude of children the Essence of the Word, and to bestow on them the appellation of Wisdom.' It is not then at all wonderful, that the Arians should battle with the truth, when they have collisions with their own principles and conflict with each other, at one time saying that there are many wisdoms, at another maintaining one; at one time classing wisdom with the caterpillar, at another saying that it coexists with the Father and is proper to Him; now that the Father alone is unoriginate, and then again that His Wisdom and His Power are unoriginate also. And they battle with us for saying that the Word of God is ever, yet forget their own doctrines, and say themselves that Wisdom coexists with God unoriginately. So dizzied are they in all these matters, denying the true Wisdom, and inventing one which is not, as the Manichees who make to themselves another God, after denying Him that is.

However, let the other heresies and the Manichees also know that the Father of Christ is One, and is Lord and Maker of creation through His own Word. And let the Ario-maniacs in particular know that the Word of God is One, being the only Son who is proper and genuine from His ousia, and having with His Father an indivisible oneness of Godhead, as we have said many times, taught by the Savior Himself. For if this were not so, why does the Father create through Him and reveal Himself in Him to whomever He wishes, and enlighten them? Or why is the Son named together with the Father in baptismal consecration? If they say the Father is not all-sufficient, then their answer is irreligious. But if He is all-sufficient, it is right to ask: what need is there of the Son for creating the worlds or for the holy washing? What fellowship exists between creature and Creator? Why is something created classified with the Maker in the consecration of all of us? Why, according to your view, is faith in one Creator and one creature delivered to us? If it was so we might be joined to the Godhead, what need is there of the creature? But if it was so we might be united to the Son as a creature, then according to you, naming the Son in Baptism is superfluous, because the God who made Him a Son can make us sons as well. Besides, if the Son is a creature, then since the nature of rational creatures is one, no help will come to creatures from a creature, because all need grace from God. We said a few words earlier about how fitting it is that all things should be made by Him. But since the discussion has led us to mention holy Baptism, it is necessary to state what I think and believe: the Son is named with the Father not as if the Father were not all-sufficient, not without meaning, and not by accident. Rather, since He is God's Word and own Wisdom, and being His Radiance, is always with the Father, it is impossible for the Father to bestow grace without giving it in the Son, because the Son is in the Father as the radiance is in the light. Not as if in need, but as a Father in His own Wisdom, God has founded the earth and made all things in the Word who is from Him, and in the Son He confirms the Holy Laver. For where the Father is, there is the Son, and where the light is, there is the radiance. Just as what the Father works, He works through the Son, and the Lord Himself says, "What I see the Father do, that I also do," so too when baptism is given, whoever the Father baptizes, the Son baptizes. And whoever the Son baptizes is consecrated in the Holy Ghost. Again, just as when the sun shines, one might say that the radiance illuminates—for the light is one and indivisible and cannot be detached—so where the Father is or is named, there plainly is the Son also. Is the Father named in Baptism? Then the Son must be named with Him.

41. But let the other heresies and the Manichees also know that the Father of the Christ is One, and is Lord and Maker of the creation through His proper Word. And let the Ario-maniacs know in particular, that the Word of God is One, being the only Son proper and genuine from His Essence, and having with His Father the oneness of Godhead indivisible, as we said many times, being taught it by the Saviour Himself. Since, were it not so, wherefore through Him does the Father create, and in Him reveal Himself to whom He will, and illuminate them? Or why too in the baptismal consecration is the Son named together with the Father? For if they say that the Father is not all-sufficient, then their answer is irreligious, but if He be, for this it is right to say, what is the need of the Son for framing the worlds, or for the holy laver? For what fellowship is there between creature and Creator? Or why is a thing made classed with the Maker in the consecration of all of us? Or why, as you hold, is faith in one Creator and in one creature delivered to us? For if it was that we might be joined to the Godhead, what need of the creature? But if that we might be united to the Son a creature, superfluous, according to you, is this naming of the Son in Baptism, for God who made Him a Son is able to make us sons also. Besides, if the Son be a creature, the nature of rational creatures being one, no help will come to creatures from a creature, since all need grace from God. We said a few words just now on the fitness that all things should be made by Him; but since the course of the discussion has led us also to mention holy Baptism, it is necessary to state, as I think and believe, that the Son is named with the Father, not as if the Father were not all-sufficient, not without meaning, and by accident; but, since He is God's Word and own Wisdom, and being His Radiance, is ever with the Father, therefore it is impossible, if the Father bestows grace, that He should not give it in the Son, for the Son is in the Father as the radiance in the light. For, not as if in need, but as a Father in His own Wisdom has God founded the earth, and made all things in the Word which is from Him, and in the Son confirms the Holy Laver. For where the Father is, there is the Son, and where the light, there the radiance; and as what the Father works, He works through the Son, and the Lord Himself says, 'What I see the Father do, that do I also;' so also when baptism is given, whom the Father baptizes, him the Son baptizes; and whom the Son baptizes, he is consecrated in the Holy Ghost. And again as when the sun shines, one might say that the radiance illuminates, for the light is one and indivisible, nor can be detached, so where the Father is or is named, there plainly is the Son also; and is the Father named in Baptism? Then must the Son be named with Him.

Therefore, when He made His promise to the saints, He spoke this way: "I and the Father will come and make Our abode in him," and again, "that, as I and You are One, so they may be one in Us." And the grace given is one, given from the Father in the Son, as Paul writes in every letter: "Grace to you and peace from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ." For the light must be with the ray, and the radiance must be contemplated together with its own light. This is why the Jews, in denying the Son, do not have the Father either. For having abandoned the "Fountain of Wisdom," as Baruch accuses them, they rejected the Wisdom springing from it, our Lord Jesus Christ (for "Christ," says the Apostle, is "God's power and God's wisdom"), when they said, "We have no king but Caesar." The Jews therefore have the penalty of their denial, for both their city and their reasoning came to nothing. And these heretics too put at risk the fullness of the mystery—I mean Baptism. For if the consecration is given to us into the Name of Father and Son, and they do not confess a true Father because they deny what is from Him and like His ousia, and deny also the true Son and name instead another of their own invention as created out of nothing, is not the rite administered by them completely empty and useless, making a show but in reality providing no help toward true religion? For the Arians do not baptize into Father and Son, but into Creator and creature, and into Maker and work. And just as a creature is different from the Son, so the Baptism supposedly given by them is different from the truth, even though they pretend to name the Name of the Father and the Son because of the words of Scripture. For it is not the one who simply says "O Lord" who gives Baptism, but the one who has the right faith along with the Name. For this reason our Savior also did not simply command to baptize, but first said, "Teach," and then, "Baptize into the Name of Father, and Son, and Holy Spirit," so that the right faith might follow upon learning, and together with faith might come the consecration of Baptism.

42. Therefore, when He made His promise to the saints, He thus spoke; 'I and the Father will come, and make Our abode in him;' and again, 'that, as I and Thou are One, so they may be one in Us.' And the grace given is one, given from the Father in the Son, as Paul writes in every Epistle, 'Grace unto you, and peace from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ.' For the light must be with the ray, and the radiance must be contemplated together with its own light. Whence the Jews, as denying the Son as well as they, have not the Father either; for, as having left the 'Fountain of Wisdom Baruch 3:12,' as Baruch reproaches them, they put from them the Wisdom springing from it, our Lord Jesus Christ (for 'Christ,' says the Apostle, is 'God's power and God's wisdom 1 Corinthians 1:24),' when they said, 'We have no king but Cæsar John 19:15.' The Jews then have the penal award of their denial; for their city as well as their reasoning came to nought. And these too hazard the fullness of the mystery, I mean Baptism; for if the consecration is given to us into the Name of Father and Son, and they do not confess a true Father, because they deny what is from Him and like His Essence, and deny also the true Son, and name another of their own framing as created out of nothing, is not the rite administered by them altogether empty and unprofitable, making a show, but in reality being no help towards religion? For the Arians do not baptize into Father and Son, but into Creator and creature, and into Maker and work. And as a creature is other than the Son, so the Baptism, which is supposed to be given by them, is other than the truth, though they pretend to name the Name of the Father and the Son, because of the words of Scripture, For not he who simply says, 'O Lord,' gives Baptism; but he who with the Name has also the right faith. On this account therefore our Saviour also did not simply command to baptize, but first says, 'Teach;' then thus: 'Baptize into the Name of Father, and Son, and Holy Ghost;' that the right faith might follow upon learning, and together with faith might come the consecration of Baptism.

There are many other heresies that use the words, but not in the right sense, as I have said, and not with sound faith. As a result, the water they administer is useless, being deficient in piety, so that anyone sprinkled by them is polluted by irreligion rather than redeemed. Similarly, Gentiles also, though the name of God is on their lips, face the charge of atheism because they do not know the real and true God, the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ. Likewise, the Manichees and Phrygians, and the disciples of the Samosatene, though using the Names, are nevertheless heretics, and the Arians follow the same course. Though they read the words of Scripture and use the Names, they too mock those who receive the rite from them, being more irreligious than the other heresies and going beyond them, making them seem innocent by comparison through their own reckless speech. These other heresies lie against the truth in some specific respect, either erring about the Lord's Body, as if He did not take flesh from Mary, or as if He did not die at all or become man but only appeared and was not truly so, seeming to have a body when He had none and seeming to have the form of man like visions in a dream. But the Arians are openly irreligious against the Father Himself. For hearing from the Scriptures that His Godhead is represented in the Son as in an image, they blaspheme by saying that it is a creature, and everywhere they carry around the phrase "He was not" like mud in a bag, spitting it out like serpents their venom. Then, since their doctrine is repulsive to all people, they immediately prop up the heresy with human patronage as support against its collapse, so that simple people, at the sight or even from fear, may overlook the evil of their perversity. It is right to pity those they deceive and proper to weep over them, because they sacrifice their own interest for that fleeting fantasy that pleasures provide and forfeit their future hope. In thinking they are baptized into the name of one who does not exist, they will receive nothing. Ranking themselves with a creature, they will receive no help from the creation. Believing in one unlike and foreign to the Father in ousia, they will not be joined to the Father, not having His own Son by physis, who is from Him, who is in the Father, and in whom the Father is, as He Himself has said. Being led astray by them, these wretched people remain destitute and stripped of the Godhead. This fantasy of earthly goods will not follow them after death, and when they see the Lord whom they have denied sitting on His Father's throne and judging the living and the dead, they will not be able to call for help from any of those who have now deceived them. They will see them also at the judgment seat, repenting for their sinful and irreligious deeds.

43. There are many other heresies too, which use the words only, but not in a right sense, as I have said, nor with sound faith, and in consequence the water which they administer is unprofitable, as deficient in piety, so that he who is sprinkled by them is rather polluted by irreligion than redeemed. So Gentiles also, though the name of God is on their lips, incur the charge of Atheism, because they know not the real and very God, the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ. So Manichees and Phrygians, and the disciples of the Samosatene, though using the Names, nevertheless are heretics, and the Arians follow in the same course, though they read the words of Scripture, and use the Names, yet they too mock those who receive the rite from them, being more irreligious than the other heresies, and advancing beyond them, and making them seem innocent by their own recklessness of speech. For these other heresies lie against the truth in some certain respect, either erring concerning the Lord's Body, as if He did not take flesh of Mary, or as if He has not died at all, nor become man, but only appeared, and was not truly, and seemed to have a body when He had not, and seemed to have the shape of man, as visions in a dream; but the Arians are without disguise irreligious against the Father Himself. For hearing from the Scriptures that His Godhead is represented in the Son as in an image, they blaspheme, saying, that it is a creature, and everywhere concerning that Image, they carry about with them the phrase, 'He was not,' as mud in a wallet, and spit it forth as serpents their venom. Then, whereas their doctrine is nauseous to all men, immediately, as a support against its fall, they prop up the heresy with human patronage, that the simple, at the sight or even by the fear may overlook the mischief of their perversity. Right indeed is it to pity their dupes; well is it to weep over them, for that they sacrifice their own interest for that immediate phantasy which pleasures furnish, and forfeit their future hope. In thinking to be baptized into the name of one who exists not, they will receive nothing; and ranking themselves with a creature, from the creation they will have no help, and believing in one unlike and foreign to the Father in essence, to the Father they will not be joined, not having His own Son by nature, who is from Him, who is in the Father, and in whom the Father is, as He Himself has said; but being led astray by them, the wretched men henceforth remain destitute and stripped of the Godhead. For this phantasy of earthly goods will not follow them upon their death; nor when they see the Lord whom they have denied, sitting on His Father's throne, and judging quick and dead, will they be able to call to their help any one of those who have now deceived them; for they shall see them also at the judgment-seat, repenting for their deeds of sin and irreligion.

Chapter 19. Texts explained; Sixthly, Proverbs 8:22. Proverbs are of a figurative nature, and must be interpreted as such. We must interpret them, and in particular this passage, by the Regula Fidei. 'He created me' not equivalent to 'I am a creature.' Wisdom a creature so far forth as Its human body. Again, if He is a creature, it is as 'a beginning of ways,' an office which, though not an attribute, is a consequence, of a higher and divine nature. And it is 'for the works,' which implied the works existed, and therefore much more He, before He was created. Also 'the Lord' not the Father 'created' Him, which implies the creation was that of a servant.

We have covered all this before discussing the passage in Proverbs, refuting the senseless tales their hearts have invented, so they may know that the Son of God should not be called a creature, and may learn to read correctly what truly admits of a right interpretation. For it is written, 'The Lord created me a beginning of His ways, for His works.' However, since these are proverbs and expressed in the manner of proverbs, we must not interpret them simply according to their surface meaning, but we must investigate the person speaking, and thus interpret the sense religiously. For what is said in proverbs is not said plainly, but is presented in a hidden way, as the Lord Himself taught us in the Gospel according to John, saying, 'These things have I spoken unto you in proverbs, but the time comes when I shall no more speak unto you in proverbs, but openly.' Therefore it is necessary to unpack the meaning of what is said, and to seek it as something hidden, and not to interpret it simply as if the meaning were spoken plainly, lest we stray from the truth through false interpretation. If what is written concerns an angel or any other created thing, as concerning one of us who are works, then let it be said, 'created me.' But if it is the Wisdom of God, in whom all created things have been framed, that speaks concerning Itself, what should we understand except that 'He created' means nothing contrary to 'He begot'? Nor, as if forgetting that It is Creator and Framer, or ignorant of the difference between the Creator and the creatures, does It count Itself among the creatures. Rather, It signifies a certain meaning, as in proverbs, not plainly but hidden—which It inspired the saints to use in prophecy—while soon after It does Itself give the meaning of 'He created' in other but parallel expressions, saying, 'Wisdom made herself a house.' Now it is clear that our body is Wisdom's house, which It took upon Itself to become man. Hence John consistently says, 'The Word was made flesh,' and through Solomon, Wisdom says of Itself with careful precision, not 'I am a creature,' but only 'The Lord created me a beginning of His ways for His works'—yet not 'created me that I might have being,' nor 'because I have a creature's beginning and origin.'

44. We have gone through thus much before the passage in the Proverbs, resisting the insensate fables which their hearts have invented, that they may know that the Son of God ought not to be called a creature, and may learn lightly to read what admits in truth of a right explanation. For it is written, 'The Lord created me a beginning of His ways, for His works;' since, however, these are proverbs, and it is expressed in the way of proverbs, we must not expound them nakedly in their first sense, but we must inquire into the person, and thus religiously put the sense on it. For what is said in proverbs, is not said plainly, but is put forth latently, as the Lord Himself has taught us in the Gospel according to John, saying, 'These things have I spoken unto you in proverbs, but the time comes when I shall no more speak unto you in proverbs, but openly John 16:25.' Therefore it is necessary to unfold the sense of what is said, and to seek it as something hidden, and not nakedly to expound as if the meaning were spoken 'plainly,' lest by a false interpretation we wander from the truth. If then what is written be about Angel, or any other of things originate, as concerning one of us who are works, let it be said, 'created me;' but if it be the Wisdom of God, in whom all things originate have been framed, that speaks concerning Itself, what ought we to understand but that 'He created' means nothing contrary to 'He begot.' Nor, as forgetting that It is Creator and Framer, or ignorant of the difference between the Creator and the creatures, does It number Itself among the creatures; but It signifies a certain sense, as in proverbs, not 'plainly,' but latent; which It inspired the saints to use in prophecy, while soon after It does Itself give the meaning of 'He created' in other but parallel expressions, saying, 'Wisdom made herself a house Proverbs 9:1.' Now it is plain that our body is Wisdom's house, which It took on Itself to become man; hence consistently does John say, 'The Word was made flesh John 1:14;' and by Solomon Wisdom says of Itself with cautious exactness, not 'I am a creature,' but only 'The Lord created me a beginning of His ways for His works,' yet not 'created me that I might have being,' nor 'because I have a creature's beginning and origin.'

For in this passage, the Word spoken by Solomon does not signify the essence of His Godhead or His own everlasting and genuine generation from the Father, but rather His manhood and His plan for our salvation. And as I said before, He has not said "I am a creature" or "I became a creature," but only "He created." For creatures, having a created essence, are originate and are said to be created, and of course the creature is created. But this mere term "He created" does not necessarily signify the essence or the generation, but indicates something else coming to pass in Him of whom it speaks, and not simply that He who is said to be created is at once in His nature and essence a creature. And divine Scripture recognizes this difference, saying concerning the creatures, "The earth is full of Your creation," and "the creation itself groans together and travails together." And in the Apocalypse it says, "And the third part of the creatures in the sea died which had life." As also Paul says, "Every creature of God is good, and nothing is to be refused if it be received with thanksgiving." And in the book of Wisdom it is written, "Having ordained man through Your wisdom, that he should have dominion over the creatures which You have made." And these, being creatures, are also said to be created, as we may further hear from the Lord, who says, "He who created them, made them male and female," and from Moses in the Song, who writes, "Ask now of the days that are past, which were before you since the day that God created man upon the earth, and from the one side of heaven unto the other." And Paul in Colossians, "Who is the Image of the Invisible God, the Firstborn of every creature, for in Him were all things created that are in heaven, and that are on earth, visible and invisible, whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers; all things were created through Him, and for Him, and He is before all."

45. For in this passage, not as signifying the Essence of His Godhead, nor His own everlasting and genuine generation from the Father, has the Word spoken by Solomon, but on the other hand His manhood and Economy towards us. And, as I said before, He has not said 'I am a creature,' or 'I became a creature,' but only 'He created.' For the creatures, having a created essence, are originate, and are said to be created, and of course the creature is created: but this mere term 'He created' does not necessarily signify the essence or the generation, but indicates something else as coming to pass in Him of whom it speaks, and not simply that He who is said to be created, is at once in His Nature and Essence a creature. And this difference divine Scripture recognises, saying concerning the creatures, 'The earth is full of Your creation,' and 'the creation itself groans together and travails together;' and in the Apocalypse it says, 'And the third part of the creatures in the sea died which had life;' as also Paul says, 'Every creature of God is good, and nothing is to be refused if it be received with thanksgiving;' and in the book of Wisdom it is written, 'Having ordained man through Your wisdom, that he should have dominion over the creatures which You have made Wisdom 9:2.' And these, being creatures, are also said to be created, as we may further hear from the Lord, who says, 'He who created them, made them male and female;' and from Moses in the Song, who writes, 'Ask now of the days that are past, which were before you since the day that God created man upon the earth, and from the one side of heaven unto the other Deuteronomy 4:32.' And Paul in Colossians, 'Who is the Image of the Invisible God, the Firstborn of every creature, for in Him were all things created that are in heaven, and that are on earth, visible and invisible, whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers; all things were created through Him, and for Him, and He is before all. '

That being called creatures and being created belongs to things which have by nature a created essence, these passages are enough to remind us, though Scripture is full of similar examples. On the other hand, that the single word "He created" does not simply denote the essence and mode of generation, David shows in the Psalm: "This shall be written for another generation, and the people that is created shall praise the Lord," and again, "Create in me a clean heart, O God." And Paul says in Ephesians, "Having abolished the law of commandments contained in ordinances, for to create in Himself of two one new man," and again, "Put on the new man, which after God is created in righteousness and true holiness." For David spoke of no people created in essence, nor prayed to have a different heart than the one he had, but meant renovation according to God and renewal. Nor did Paul signify two persons created in essence in the Lord, nor did he counsel us to put on any other man. Rather, he called the life according to virtue "the man after God," and by "created" in Christ he meant the two peoples who are renewed in Him. Such too is the language of the book of Jeremiah: "The Lord created a new salvation for a planting, in which salvation men shall walk to and fro." In thus speaking, he does not mean any essence of a creature, but prophesies of the renewal of salvation among men, which has taken place in Christ for us. Such then being the difference between "the creatures" and the single word "He created," if you find anywhere in divine Scripture the Lord called "creature," produce it and fight. But if it is nowhere written that He is a creature, only He Himself says about Himself in the Proverbs, "The Lord created me," shame upon you, both on the ground of the distinction mentioned before and because the diction is like that of proverbs. Accordingly let "He created" be understood, not of His being a creature, but of that human nature which became His, for to this belongs creation. Indeed is it not evidently unfair in you, when David and Paul say "He created," then indeed not to understand it of the essence and the generation, but of renewal, yet when the Lord says "He created" to number His essence with the creatures? And again when Scripture says, "Wisdom built her a house, she set it upon seven pillars," to understand "house" allegorically, but to take "He created" as it stands, and to fasten on it the idea of creature? Neither His being Framer of all has had any weight with you, nor have you feared His being the sole and proper Offspring of the Father, but recklessly, as if you had enlisted against Him, you fight, and think less of Him than of men.

46. That to be called creatures, then, and to be created belongs to things which have by nature a created essence, these passages are sufficient to remind us, though Scripture is full of the like; on the other hand that the single word 'He created' does not simply denote the essence and mode of generation, David shows in the Psalm, 'This shall be written for another generation, and the people that is created shall praise the Lord;' and again, 'Create in me a clean heart, O God;' and Paul in Ephesians says, 'Having abolished the law of commandments contained in ordinances, for to create in Himself of two one new man Ephesians 2:15;' and again, 'Put on the new man, which after God is created in righteousness and true holiness.' For neither David spoke of any people created in essence, nor prayed to have another heart than that he had, but meant renovation according to God and renewal; nor did Paul signify two persons created in essence in the Lord, nor again did he counsel us to put on any other man; but he called the life according to virtue the 'man after God,' and by the 'created' in Christ he meant the two people who are renewed in Him. Such too is the language of the book of Jeremiah; 'The Lord created a new salvation for a planting, in which salvation men shall walk to and fro;' and in thus speaking, he does not mean any essence of a creature, but prophesies of the renewal of salvation among men, which has taken place in Christ for us. Such then being the difference between 'the creatures' and the single word 'He created,' if you find anywhere in divine Scripture the Lord called 'creature,' produce it and fight; but if it is nowhere written that He is a creature, only He Himself says about Himself in the Proverbs, 'The Lord created me,' shame upon you, both on the ground of the distinction aforesaid and for that the diction is like that of proverbs; and accordingly let 'He created' be understood, not of His being a creature, but of that human nature which became His, for to this belongs creation. Indeed is it not evidently unfair in you, when David and Paul say 'He created,' then indeed not to understand it of the essence and the generation, but the renewal; yet, when the Lord says 'He created' to number His essence with the creatures? And again when Scripture says, 'Wisdom built her a house, she set it upon seven pillars Proverbs 9:1,' to understand 'house' allegorically, but to take 'He created' as it stands, and to fasten on it the idea of creature? And neither His being Framer of all has had any weight with you, nor have you feared His being the sole and proper Offspring of the Father, but recklessly, as if you had enlisted against Him, do ye fight, and think less of Him than of men.

The very passage itself proves that calling the Lord a creature is just your own invention. For the Lord, knowing His own Essence to be the Only-begotten Wisdom and Offspring of the Father, and to be other than originated things and natural creatures, says in love for humanity, "The Lord created me a beginning of His ways," as if to say, "My Father has prepared for Me a body, and has created Me for the sake of humanity and their salvation." For just as when John says, "The Word was made flesh," we do not understand the whole Word Himself to be flesh, but rather to have put on flesh and become man, and when we hear, "Christ has become a curse for us," and "He has made Him sin for us who knew no sin," we do not simply understand this to mean that the whole Christ has become curse and sin, but that He took upon Himself the curse that lay against us (as the Apostle has said, "has redeemed us from the curse," and "has carried," as Isaiah has said, "our sins," and as Peter has written, "has borne them in the body on the wood")—so, if it is said in the Proverbs "He created," we must not understand that the whole Word is by nature a creature, but that He put on the created body and that God created Him for our sakes, preparing for Him the created body, as it is written, for us, so that in Him we might be capable of being renewed and deified. What then has deceived you, O senseless ones, to call the Creator a creature? Or where did you acquire this new idea to parade around? For the Proverbs say "He created," but they do not call the Son creature, but Offspring; and, according to the distinction in Scripture mentioned earlier between "He created" and "creature," they acknowledge what is by nature proper to the Son, that He is the Only-begotten Wisdom and Framer of the creatures, and when they say "He created," they do not say it in respect of His Essence, but signify that He was becoming a beginning of many ways; so that "He created" stands in contrast to "Offspring," and His being called the "Beginning of ways" stands in contrast to His being the Only-begotten Word.

47. For the very passage proves that it is only an invention of your own to call the Lord creature. For the Lord, knowing His own Essence to be the Only-begotten Wisdom and Offspring of the Father, and other than things originate and natural creatures, says in love to man, 'The Lord created me a beginning of His ways,' as if to say, 'My Father has prepared for Me a body, and has created Me for men in behalf of their salvation.' For, as when John says, 'The Word was made flesh John 1:14,' we do not conceive the whole Word Himself to be flesh, but to have put on flesh and become man, and on hearing, 'Christ has become a curse for us,' and 'He has made Him sin for us who knew no sin,' we do not simply conceive this, that whole Christ has become curse and sin, but that He has taken on Him the curse which lay against us (as the Apostle has said, 'Has redeemed us from the curse,' and 'has carried,' as Isaiah has said, 'our sins,' and as Peter has written, 'has borne them in the body on the wood '); so, if it is said in the Proverbs 'He created,' we must not conceive that the whole Word is in nature a creature, but that He put on the created body and that God created Him for our sakes, preparing for Him the created body, as it is written, for us, that in Him we might be capable of being renewed and deified. What then deceived you, O senseless, to call the Creator a creature? Or whence did you purchase for you this new thought, to parade it? For the Proverbs say 'He created,' but they call not the Son creature, but Offspring; and, according to the distinction in Scripture aforesaid of 'He created' and 'creature,' they acknowledge, what is by nature proper to the Son, that He is the Only-begotten Wisdom and Framer of the creatures, and when they say 'He created,' they say it not in respect of His Essence, but signify that He was becoming a beginning of many ways; so that 'He created' is in contrast to 'Offspring,' and His being called the 'Beginning of ways ' to His being the Only-begotten Word.

For if He is Offspring, how can you call Him creature? No one says that He begets what He creates, nor calls His own offspring creatures. And again, if He is Only-begotten, how does He become 'beginning of the ways'? For necessarily, if He was created as a beginning of all things, He is no longer alone, since He would have those who came into being after Him. For Reuben, when he became a beginning of the children, was not only-begotten, but first in time indeed, yet in nature and relationship one among those who came after him. Therefore if the Word is also 'a beginning of the ways,' He must be such as the ways are, and the ways must be such as the Word, though in point of time He may be created first of them. For the beginning or starting point of a city is such as the other parts of the city are, and the members joined to it make the city whole and one, like the many members of one body. Nor does one part of it make while another comes to be and is subject to the former, but all the city equally has its government and constitution from its maker. If then the Lord is created as a 'beginning' of all things in this sense, it would follow that He and all other things together make up the unity of creation, and He neither differs from all others, though He becomes the 'beginning' of all, nor is He Lord of them, though older in point of time. But He would have the same manner of formation and the same Lord as the rest. Indeed, if He is a creature, as you claim, how can He be created sole and first at all, so as to be beginning of all? When it is clear from what has been said that among the creatures, none is of a constant nature and of prior formation, but each has its origin together with all the rest, however it may excel others in glory. For as to the separate stars or the great lights, this one did not appear first and that one second, but in one day and by the same command, they were all called into being. And such was the original formation of the quadrupeds, and of birds, and fishes, and cattle, and plants. Thus also the race made after God's Image came to be, namely humans. For though Adam alone was formed out of earth, yet in him was involved the succession of the whole race.

48. For if He is Offspring, how call ye Him creature? For no one says that He begets what He creates, nor calls His proper offspring creatures; and again, if He is Only-begotten, how becomes He 'beginning of the ways?' for of necessity, if He was created a beginning of all things, He is no longer alone, as having those who came into being after Him. For Reuben, when he became a beginning of the children, was not only-begotten, but in time indeed first, but in nature and relationship one among those who came after him. Therefore if the Word also is 'a beginning of the ways,' He must be such as the ways are, and the ways must be such as the Word, though in point of time He be created first of them. For the beginning or initiative of a city is such as the other parts of the city are, and the members too being joined to it, make the city whole and one, as the many members of one body; nor does one part of it make, and another come to be, and is subject to the former, but all the city equally has its government and constitution from its maker. If then the Lord is in such sense created as a 'beginning' of all things, it would follow that He and all other things together make up the unity of the creation, and He neither differs from all others, though He become the 'beginning' of all, nor is He Lord of them, though older in point of time; but He has the same manner of framing and the same Lord as the rest. Nay, if He be a creature, as you hold, how can He be created sole and first at all, so as to be beginning of all? When it is plain from what has been said, that among the creatures not any is of a constant nature and of prior formation, but each has its origination with all the rest, however it may excel others in glory. For as to the separate stars or the great lights, not this appeared first, and that second, but in one day and by the same command, they were all called into being. And such was the original formation of the quadrupeds, and of birds, and fishes, and cattle, and plants; thus too has the race made after God's Image come to be, namely men; for though Adam only was formed out of earth, yet in him was involved the succession of the whole race.

And from the visible creation, we clearly understand that His invisible things also, "being perceived by the things that are made" (Romans 1:20), are not independent of each other. For it was not first one thing and then another, but all things were constituted at once according to their kind. The Apostle did not list them individually, saying "whether Angel, or Throne, or Dominion, or Authority," but he mentions all together according to their kind: "whether Angels, or Archangels, or Principalities." This is how the creatures came into existence. If then, as I have said, the Word were a creature, He must have been brought into being not first among them, but together with all the other Powers, even though He might greatly excel the rest in glory. For we find this to be the case with them: they all came to be at once, with neither first nor second, and they differ from each other in glory—some on the right of the throne, some all around, and some on the left—but all praising and standing in service before the Lord. Therefore, if the Word were a creature, He would not be first or beginning of the rest. Yet if He is before all, as indeed He is, and is Himself alone First and Son, it does not follow that He is beginning of all things in His ousia. For whatever is the beginning of all is counted among all. And if He is not such a beginning, then neither is He a creature. Rather, it is very plain that He differs in ousia and physis from the creatures, and is other than they, and is Likeness and Image of the sole and true God, being Himself sole also. Hence He is not classed with creatures in Scripture, but David rebukes those who dare even to think of Him as such, saying, "Who among the gods is like the Lord?" and "Who is like the Lord among the sons of God?" and Baruch says, "This is our God, and another shall not be reckoned with Him" (Baruch 3:35). For the One creates, and the rest are created; and the One is the own Word and Wisdom of the Father's ousia, and through this Word the things which came to be, which before did not exist, were made.

49. And from the visible creation, we clearly discern that His invisible things also, 'being perceived by the things that are made Romans 1:20,' are not independent of each other; for it was not first one and then another, but all at once were constituted after their kind. For the Apostle did not number individually, so as to say 'whether Angel, or Throne, or Dominion, or Authority,' but he mentions together all according to their kind, 'whether Angels, or Archangels, or Principalities:' for in this way is the origination of the creatures. If then, as I have said, the Word were creature He must have been brought into being, not first of them, but with all the other Powers, though in glory He excel the rest ever so much. For so we find it to be in their case, that at once they came to be, with neither first nor second, and they differ from each other in glory, some on the right of the throne, some all around, and some on the left, but one and all praising and standing in service before the Lord. Therefore if the Word be creature He would not be first or beginning of the rest; yet if He be before all, as indeed He is, and is Himself alone First and Son, it does not follow that He is beginning of all things as to His Essence, for what is the beginning of all is in the number of all. And if He is not such a beginning, then neither is He a creature, but it is very plain that He differs in essence and nature from the creatures, and is other than they, and is Likeness and Image of the sole and true God, being Himself sole also. Hence He is not classed with creatures in Scripture, but David rebukes those who dare even to think of Him as such, saying, 'Who among the gods is like the Lord?' and 'Who is like the Lord among the sons of God.' and Baruch, 'This is our God, and another shall not be reckoned with Him Baruch 3:35.' For the One creates, and the rest are created; and the One is the own Word and Wisdom of the Father's Essence, and through this Word things which came to be, which before existed not, were made.

Your famous claim that the Son is a creature is not true but merely your fantasy. In fact, Solomon convicts you of slandering him many times. He has not called Him a creature but God's Offspring and Wisdom, saying "God in Wisdom established the earth" and "Wisdom built her a house." The very passage in question proves your irreligious spirit. It is written, "The Lord created me a beginning of His ways for His works." Therefore, if He exists before all things yet says "He created me" (not "that I might make the works" but "for the works"), then unless "He created" refers to something later than Himself, He would seem to be later than the works, finding them already existing before Him when He is created—works for whose sake He is also brought into being. If that were so, how is He before all things? And how were all things made through Him and consist in Him? Look, you are saying that the works existed before Him, works for which He is created and sent. But this is not so—perish the thought! The heretics' supposition is false. For the Word of God is not a creature but Creator, and He says in the manner of proverbs "He created me" when He put on created flesh. Something else can also be understood from the passage itself. Although He is Son and has God for His Father, being His proper Offspring, here He names the Father Lord—not because He was a servant, but because He took the servant's form. For it was fitting that, on the one hand, being the Word from the Father, He should call God Father, which is proper for a son toward a father. On the other hand, having come to finish the work and having taken a servant's form, He should name the Father Lord. He Himself taught this distinction clearly, saying in the Gospels, "I thank You, O Father" and then "Lord of heaven and earth." He calls God His Father, but He names Him Lord of the creatures, showing clearly from these words that when He put on the creature, then He called the Father Lord. In David's prayer, the Holy Spirit marks the same distinction, saying in the Psalms, "Give Your strength unto Your Child, and help the Son of Your handmaid." For the natural and true child of God is one thing, and the sons of the handmaid—that is, of the nature of created things—are another. Therefore the One, as Son, has the Father's might, but the rest need salvation.

50. Your famous assertion then, that the Son is a creature, is not true, but is your fantasy only; nay Solomon convicts you of having many times slandered him. For he has not called Him creature, but God's Offspring and Wisdom, saying, 'God in Wisdom established the earth,' and 'Wisdom built her an house.' And the very passage in question proves your irreligious spirit; for it is written, 'The Lord created me a beginning of His ways for His works.' Therefore if He is before all things, yet says 'He created me' (not 'that I might make the works,' but) 'for the works,' unless 'He created' relates to something later than Himself, He will seem later than the works, finding them on His creation already in existence before Him, for the sake of which He is also brought into being. And if so, how is He before all things notwithstanding? And how were all things made through Him and consist in Him? For behold, you say that the works consisted before Him, for which He is created and sent. But it is not so; perish the thought! false is the supposition of the heretics. For the Word of God is not creature but Creator; and says in the manner of proverbs, 'He created me' when He put on created flesh. And something besides may be understood from the passage itself; for, being Son and having God for His Father, for He is His proper Offspring, yet here He names the Father Lord; not that He was servant, but because He took the servant's form. For it became Him, on the one hand being the Word from the Father, to call God Father: for this is proper to son towards father; on the other, having come to finish the work, and taken a servant's form, to name the Father Lord. And this difference He Himself has taught by an apt distinction, saying in the Gospels, 'I thank You, O Father,' and then, 'Lord of heaven and earth Matthew 11:25.' For He calls God His Father, but of the creatures He names Him Lord; as showing clearly from these words, that, when He put on the creature, then it was He called the Father Lord. For in the prayer of David the Holy Spirit marks the same distinction, saying in the Psalms, 'Give Your strength unto Your Child, and help the Son of Your handmaid.' For the natural and true child of God is one, and the sons of the handmaid, that is, of the nature of things originate, are other. Wherefore the One, as Son, has the Father's might; but the rest are in need of salvation.

Even if they make empty arguments because He was called child, they should know that Isaac was also named Abraham's child, and the son of the Shunamite was called young child. It makes sense, then, that when He became as we are—we being servants—He too calls the Father Lord, as we do. He has done this from love for humanity, so that we too, though servants by nature, might receive the Spirit of the Son and have confidence to call by grace Father the one who is by nature our Lord. But just as we, in calling the Lord Father, do not deny our servitude by nature (for we are His works, and it is He who has made us, and not we ourselves), so when the Son, after taking the servant's form, says "The Lord created me a beginning of His ways," they must not deny the eternity of His Godhead, and that "in the beginning was the Word," and "all things were made by Him," and "in Him all things were created."

51. (But if, because He was called child, they idly talk, let them know that both Isaac was named Abraham's child, and the son of the Shunamite was called young child.) Reasonably then, we being servants, when He became as we, He too calls the Father Lord, as we do; and this He has so done from love to man, that we too, being servants by nature, and receiving the Spirit of the Son, might have confidence to call Him by grace Father, who is by nature our Lord. But as we, in calling the Lord Father, do not deny our servitude by nature (for we are His works, and it is 'He that has made us, and not we ourselves '), so when the Son, on taking the servant's form, says, 'The Lord created me a beginning of His ways,' let them not deny the eternity of His Godhead, and that 'in the beginning was the Word,' and 'all things were made by Him,' and 'in Him all things were created. '

Chapter 20. Texts Explained; Sixthly, Proverbs viii. 22 Continued. Our Lord is said to be created 'for the works,' i.e. with a particular purpose, which no mere creatures are ever said to be. Parallel of Isaiah 49:5, etc. When His manhood is spoken of, a reason for it is added; not so when His Divine Nature; Texts in proof.

The passage in Proverbs, as I've said before, refers not to the Essence but to the manhood of the Word. If it says He was created 'for the works,' it shows the intention to signify not His Essence but the Economy that took place 'for His works,' which comes second to being. Things that are being formed and created are made specifically so they may be and exist, and after that they do whatever the Word commands them, as can be seen in all things. Adam was created not so that he might work, but so that first he might be human. Only after this did he receive the command to work. Noah was created not because of the ark, but so that first he might exist and be a man. Only after this did he receive the command to prepare the ark. The same pattern can be found in every case when you examine it. The great Moses first became a man, and only then was entrusted with governing the people. Therefore, we must suppose the same pattern here. You see, the Word is not created into existence, but 'In the beginning was the Word,' and He is sent afterward 'for the works' and the Economy toward them. Before the works were made, the Son always existed, and there was not yet any need for Him to be created. But when the works were created and afterward there arose a need for the Economy for their restoration, then the Word took upon Himself this condescension and likeness to the works, which He has shown us by the word 'He created.' Through the Prophet Isaiah, wishing to signify the same thing, He says again: 'And now thus says the Lord, who formed me from the womb to be His servant, to gather together Jacob unto Him and Israel, I shall be brought together and be glorified before the Lord.'

51 ( continued). For the passage in the Proverbs, as I have said before, signifies, not the Essence, but the manhood of the Word; for if He says that He was created 'for the works,' He shows His intention of signifying, not His Essence, but the Economy which took place 'for His works,' which comes second to being. For things which are in formation and creation are made specially that they may be and exist, and next they have to do whatever the Word bids them, as may be seen in the case of all things. For Adam was created, not that He might work, but that first he might be man; for it was after this that he received the command to work. And Noah was created, not because of the ark, but that first he might exist and be a man; for after this he received commandment to prepare the ark. And the like will be found in every case on inquiring into it — thus the great Moses first was made a man, and next was entrusted with the government of the people. Therefore here too we must suppose the like; for you see, that the Word is not created into existence, but, 'In the beginning was the Word,' and He is afterwards sent 'for the works' and the Economy towards them. For before the works were made, the Son was ever, nor was there yet need that He should be created; but when the works were created and need arose afterwards of the Economy for their restoration, then it was that the Word took upon Himself this condescension and assimilation to the works; which He has shown us by the word 'He created.' And through the Prophet Isaiah willing to signify the like, He says again: 'And now thus says the Lord, who formed me from the womb to be His servant, to gather together Jacob unto Him and Israel, I shall be brought together and be glorified before the Lord. '

Look at this too: He is formed, not into existence, but in order to gather together the tribes, which already existed before He was formed. For just as in the former passage it says 'He created,' so in this one 'He formed'; and just as there it says 'for the works,' so here 'to gather together.' Therefore from every perspective it is clear that 'He created' and 'He formed' are said after 'the Word was.' For just as the tribes existed before His forming, for whose sake He was formed, so the works exist, for which He was created. And when 'in the beginning was the Word,' the works did not yet exist, as I have said before. But when the works were made and the need arose, then 'He created' was said. Consider this analogy: if some son, when the servants were lost and in the hands of the enemy through their own carelessness, and the need was urgent, were sent by his father to rescue and recover them, and upon setting out were to put on clothing like theirs, and fashion himself as they are, lest the captors, recognizing him as the master, should flee and prevent him from descending to those who were hidden under the earth by them—and then if someone were to ask him why he did this, he would answer, 'My Father thus formed and prepared me for his works.' In speaking this way, he neither implies that he is a servant or one of the works, nor speaks of the beginning of his origination, but of the subsequent charge given him over the works. In the same way the Lord also, having put on our flesh and 'being found in fashion as a man,' if questioned by those who saw Him thus and marveled, would say, 'The Lord created Me the beginning of His ways for His works,' and 'He formed Me to gather together Israel.' The Spirit foretells this again in the Psalms, saying, 'You set Him over the works of Your hands,' which elsewhere the Lord signified of Himself: 'I am set as King by Him upon His holy hill of Sion.' And just as when He shone in the body upon Sion, He had not His beginning of existence or of reign, but being God's Word and everlasting King, He graciously allowed His kingdom to shine in a human way in Sion, so that by redeeming them and us from the sin which reigned in them, He might bring them under His Father's Kingdom—so too, when set 'for the works,' He is not set for things which did not yet exist, but for such as already were and needed restoration.

52. See here too, He is formed, not into existence, but in order to gather together the tribes, which were in existence before He was formed. For as in the former passage stands 'He created,' so in this 'He formed;' and as there 'for the works,' so here 'to gather together;' so that in every point of view it appears that 'He created' and 'He formed' are said after 'the Word was.' For as before His forming the tribes existed, for whose sake He was formed, so does it appear that the works exist, for which He was created. And when 'in the beginning was the Word,' not yet were the works, as I have said before; but when the works were made and the need required, then 'He created' was said; and as if some son, when the servants were lost, and in the hands of the enemy by their own carelessness, and need was urgent, were sent by his father to succour and recover them, and on setting out were to put over him the like dress with them, and should fashion himself as they, lest the capturers, recognising him as the master, should take to flight and prevent his descending to those who were hidden under the earth by them; and then were any one to inquire of him, why he did so, were to make answer, 'My Father thus formed and prepared me for his works,' while in thus speaking, he neither implies that he is a servant nor one of the works, nor speaks of the beginning of His origination, but of the subsequent charge given him over the works — in the same way the Lord also, having put over Him our flesh, and 'being found in fashion as a man,' if He were questioned by those who saw Him thus and marvelled, would say, 'The Lord created Me the beginning of His ways for His works,' and 'He formed Me to gather together Israel.' This again the Spirit foretells in the Psalms, saying, 'You set Him over the works of Your hands Hebrews 2:7;' which elsewhere the Lord signified of Himself, 'I am set as King by Him upon His holy hill of Sion.' And as, when He shone in the body upon Sion, He had not His beginning of existence or of reign, but being God's Word and everlasting King, He vouchsafed that His kingdom should shine in a human way in Sion, that redeeming them and us from the sin which reigned in them, He might bring them under His Father's Kingdom, so, on being set 'for the works,' He is not set for things which did not yet exist, but for such as already were and needed restoration.

The phrases "He created," "He formed," and "He set" all mean the same thing. They do not indicate the beginning of His existence or suggest that His essence was created. Instead, they refer to His gracious work of renewal that happened for our sake. Accordingly, even though He speaks this way, He also taught that He existed before this when He said, "Before Abraham came to be, I am" (John 8:58), and "when He prepared the heavens, I was present with Him," and "I was with Him disposing things." Just as He Himself existed before Abraham came to be, and Israel came into being after Abraham, clearly He exists first and is formed afterwards. His forming does not signify His beginning of being but His taking on of manhood, in which He also gathers together the tribes of Israel. Similarly, since He is "always with the Father," He Himself is the Framer of creation, and His works are clearly later than Himself. Therefore "He created" does not signify His beginning of being, but the divine plan that took place for the works, which He accomplished in the flesh. For it was fitting that He, being different from the works—indeed their Framer—should take upon Himself their renewal, so that since He is created for us, all things may now be created in Him. When He said "He created," He immediately added the reason by naming "the works," so that His creation for the works might signify His becoming human for their renewal. This is typical of divine Scripture: when it indicates the fleshly origin of the Son, it also adds the reason why He became human. But when He speaks, or His servants declare anything about His Godhead, everything is said in simple language, with absolute meaning, and without any reason being added. For He is the Father's Radiance, and just as the Father exists without any reason, we must not seek a reason for that Radiance either. Thus it is written, "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God" (John 1:1), and no reason is given. But when "the Word was made flesh" (John 1:14), then it adds the reason, saying, "and dwelt among us." Again, when the Apostle says, "Who being in the form of God," he does not introduce the reason until "He took on Him the form of a servant." Then he continues, "He humbled Himself unto death, even the death of the cross" (Philippians 2:6-8), for it was for this purpose that He both became flesh and took the form of a servant.

53. 'He created' then and 'He formed' and 'He set,' having the same meaning, do not denote the beginning of His being, or of His essence as created, but His beneficent renovation which came to pass for us. Accordingly, though He thus speaks, yet He taught also that He Himself existed before this, when He said, 'Before Abraham came to be, I am John 8:58;' and 'when He prepared the heavens, I was present with Him;' and 'I was with Him disposing things.' And as He Himself was before Abraham came to be, and Israel had come into being after Abraham, and plainly He exists first and is formed afterwards, and His forming signifies not His beginning of being but His taking manhood, wherein also He collects together the tribes of Israel; so, as 'being always with the Father,' He Himself is Framer of the creation, and His works are evidently later than Himself, and 'He created' signifies, not His beginning of being, but the Economy which took place for the works, which He effected in the flesh. For it became Him, being other than the works, nay rather their Framer, to take upon Himself their renovation, that, whereas He is created for us, all things may be now created in Him. For when He said 'He created,' He immediately added the reason, naming 'the works,' that His creation for the works might signify His becoming man for their renovation. And this is usual with divine Scripture; for when it signifies the fleshly origination of the Son, it adds also the cause for which He became man; but when he speaks or His servants declare anything of His Godhead, all is said in simple diction, and with an absolute sense, and without reason being added. For He is the Father's Radiance; and as the Father is, but not for any reason, neither must we seek the reason of that Radiance. Thus it is written, 'In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God John 1:1;' and the wherefore it assigns not; but when 'the Word was made flesh John 1:14,' then it adds the reason why, saying, 'And dwelt among us.' And again the Apostle saying, 'Who being in the form of God,' has not introduced the reason, till 'He took on Him the form of a servant;' for then he continues, 'He humbled Himself unto death, even the death of the cross Philippians 2:6-8;' for it was for this that He both became flesh and took the form of a servant.

The Lord Himself has spoken many things in proverbs, but when giving us information about Himself, He has spoken absolutely: "I in the Father and the Father in Me," and "I and the Father are one," and "He that has seen Me has seen the Father," and "I am the Light of the world," and "I am the Truth." He does not specify in every case the reason or the purpose, lest He should seem secondary to those things for which He was made. For that reason would necessarily take precedence over Him, without which He Himself would not have come into being. Paul, for instance, "separated an Apostle for the Gospel, which the Lord had promised before by the Prophets," was thereby made subordinate to the Gospel of which he was made minister, and John, being chosen to prepare the Lord's way, was made subordinate to the Lord. But the Lord, not being made subordinate to any reason why He should be Word, except only that He is the Father's Offspring and Only-begotten Wisdom, when He becomes man, then assigns the reason why He is about to take flesh. For the need of humanity preceded His becoming man, apart from which He would not have taken on flesh. And what the need was for which He became man, He Himself indicates in this way: "I came down from heaven, not to do My own will, but the will of Him that sent Me. And this is the will of Him which has sent Me, that of all which He has given Me, I should lose nothing, but should raise it up again at the last day. And this is the will of My Father, that every one which sees the Son and believes in Him may have everlasting life, and I will raise him up at the last day." And again: "I have come a light into the world, that whosoever believes in Me, should not abide in darkness." And again he says: "To this end was I born, and for this cause came I into the world, that I should bear witness unto the truth." And John has written: "For this was manifested the Son of God, that He might destroy the works of the devil."

54. And the Lord Himself has spoken many things in proverbs; but when giving us notices about Himself, He has spoken absolutely; 'I in the Father and the Father in Me,' and 'I and the Father are one,' and, 'He that has seen Me, has seen the Father,' and 'I am the Light of the world,' and, 'I am the Truth;' not setting down in every case the reason, nor the wherefore, lest He should seem second to those things for which He was made. For that reason would needs take precedence of Him, without which not even He Himself had come into being. Paul, for instance, 'separated an Apostle for the Gospel, which the Lord had promised afore by the Prophets Romans 1:1-2,' was thereby made subordinate to the Gospel, of which he was made minister, and John, being chosen to prepare the Lord's way, was made subordinate to the Lord; but the Lord, not being made subordinate to any reason why He should be Word, save only that He is the Father's Offspring and Only-begotten Wisdom, when He becomes man, then assigns the reason why He is about to take flesh. For the need of man preceded His becoming man, apart from which He had not put on flesh. And what the need was for which He became man, He Himself thus signifies, 'I came down from heaven, not to do My own will, but the will of Him that sent Me. And this is the will of Him which has sent Me, that of all which He has given Me, I should lose nothing, but should raise it up again at the last day. And this is the will of My Father, that every one which sees the Son and believes in Him may have everlasting life, and I will raise him up at the last day.' And again; 'I have come a light into the world, that whosoever believes in Me, should not abide in darkness.' And again he says; 'To this end was I born, and for this cause came I into the world, that I should bear witness unto the truth.' And John has written: 'For this was manifested the Son of God, that He might destroy the works of the devil 1 John 3:8.'

To give witness, and to undergo death for our sake, to raise humanity and destroy the devil's works, the Savior came—and this is the reason for His incarnate presence. Otherwise, there would have been no resurrection unless there had been death; and how could there have been death unless He had possessed a mortal body? The Apostle, learning from Him, expresses this as follows: "Forasmuch then as the children are partakers of flesh and blood, He also Himself likewise took part of the same; that through death He might bring to nought him that had the power of death, that is, the devil, and deliver them who through fear of death were all their lifetime subject to bondage" (Hebrews 2:14-15). And, "Since by man came death, by man came also the resurrection of the dead" (1 Corinthians 15:21). And again, "For what the Law could not do, in that it was weak through the flesh, God, sending His own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh, and for sin, condemned sin in the flesh; that the ordinance of the Law might be fulfilled in us, who walk not after the flesh but after the Spirit" (Romans 8:3-4). And John says, "For God sent not His Son into the world to condemn the world, but that the world through Him might be saved" (John 3:17). And again, the Savior has spoken in His own person, "For judgment am I come into this world, that they who see not might see, and that they which see might become blind." He came not for Himself, then, but for our salvation, and to abolish death, condemn sin, give sight to the blind, and raise everyone from the dead. But if not for Himself, but for us, then consequently He is created not for Himself but for us. But if He is not created for Himself but for us, then He is not Himself a creature; rather, having put on our flesh, He uses such language. And that this is the sense of the Scriptures we may learn from the Apostle, who says in Ephesians: "Having broken down the middle wall of partition between us, having abolished in His flesh the enmity, even the law of commandments contained in ordinances, to create in Himself of two one new man, so making peace" (Ephesians 2:14-15). But if the two are created in Him, and these are in His body, then reasonably, bearing the two in Himself, He is as if Himself created; for those who were created in Himself He made one, and He was in them as they were in Him. And thus, with the two being created in Him, He may suitably say, "The Lord created me." For just as by receiving our infirmities He is said to be infirm Himself, though He is not Himself infirm—for He is the Power of God—and He became sin for us and a curse, though He had not sinned Himself, but because He Himself bore our sins and our curse, so, by creating us in Him, let Him say, "He created me for the works," though He is not Himself a creature.

55. To give a witness then, and for our sakes to undergo death, to raise man up and destroy the works of the devil, the Saviour came, and this is the reason of His incarnate presence. For otherwise a resurrection had not been, unless there had been death; and how had death been, unless He had had a mortal body? This the Apostle, learning from Him, thus sets forth, 'Forasmuch then as the children are partakers of flesh and blood, He also Himself likewise took part of the same; that through death He might bring to nought him that had the power of death, that is, the devil, and deliver them who through fear of death were all their lifetime subject to bondage Hebrews 2:14-15.' And, 'Since by man came death, by man came also the resurrection of the dead 1 Corinthians 15:21.' And again, 'For what the Law could not do, in that it was weak through the flesh, God, sending His own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh, and for sin, condemned sin in the flesh; that the ordinance of the Law might be fulfilled in us, who walk not after the flesh but after the Spirit Romans 8:3-4.' And John says, 'For God sent not His Son into the world to condemn the world, but that the world through Him might be saved John 3:17.' And again, the Saviour has spoken in His own person, 'For judgment am I come into this world, that they who see not might see, and that they which see might become blind.' Not for Himself then, but for our salvation, and to abolish death, and to condemn sin, and to give sight to the blind, and to raise up all from the dead, has He come; but if not for Himself, but for us, by consequence not for Himself but for us is He created. But if not for Himself is He created, but for us, then He is not Himself a creature, but, as having put on our flesh, He uses such language. And that this is the sense of the Scriptures, we may learn from the Apostle, who says in Ephesians, 'Having broken down the middle wall of partition between us, having abolished in His flesh the enmity, even the law of commandments contained in ordinances, to create in Himself of two one new man, so making peace Ephesians 2:14-15.' But if in Him the two are created, and these are in His body, reasonably then, bearing the two in Himself, He is as if Himself created; for those who were created in Himself He made one, and He was in them, as they. And thus, the two being created in Him, He may say suitably, 'The Lord created me.' For as by receiving our infirmities, He is said to be infirm Himself, though not Himself infirm, for He is the Power of God, and He became sin for us and a curse, though not having sinned Himself, but because He Himself bare our sins and our curse, so, by creating us in Him, let Him say, 'He created me for the works,' though not Himself a creature.

For if, as they claim, the essence (ousia) of the Word is of created nature, and therefore He says "The Lord created me"—being a creature—then He was not created for us. But if He was not created for us, we are not created in Him. And if not created in Him, we do not have Him in ourselves but only externally, like receiving instruction from Him as from a teacher. If this were the case with us, sin would not have lost its reign over the flesh, since it would remain inherent and not cast out of it. But the Apostle contradicts such teaching a little earlier when he says, "For we are His workmanship, created in Christ Jesus" (Ephesians 2:10). And if we are created in Christ, then it is not He who is created, but we in Him. Thus the words "He created" are for our sake. Because of our need, the Word, though being Creator, accepted words that are used of creatures—words that are not proper to Him as the Word, but are ours who are created in Him. And just as the Father always exists, so does His Word, and being always, He always says "I was daily His delight, rejoicing always before Him" (Proverbs 8:30), and "I am in the Father and the Father in Me" (John 14:10). So when He became man for our need, He consistently uses language as we do: "The Lord has created Me," so that by His dwelling in the flesh, sin might be completely expelled from the flesh, and we might have a free mind. For what ought He to say when made man? "In the beginning I was man"? This would neither be fitting for Him nor true. And just as it would not be fitting to say this, so it is natural and proper in the case of man to say "He created" and "He made" Him. Therefore, the reason for "He created" is added, namely, the need of the works. And where the reason is added, surely that reason correctly explains the text. Thus here, when He says "He created," He sets down the cause: "the works." On the other hand, when He indicates absolutely the generation from the Father, He immediately adds, "Before all the hills He begets me" (Proverbs 8:25). But He does not add the "why," as in the case of "He created" when He says "for the works," but absolutely "He begets me," as in the text "In the beginning was the Word" (John 1:1). For even if no works had been created, still the Word of God existed, and the Word was God. And His becoming man would not have taken place if the need of humanity had not become a cause. Therefore, the Son is not a creature.

56. For if, as they hold, the Essence of the Word being of created nature, therefore He says, 'The Lord created me,' being a creature, He was not created for us; but if He was not created for us, we are not created in Him; and, if not created in Him, we have Him not in ourselves but externally; as, for instance, as receiving instruction from Him as from a teacher. And it being so with us, sin has not lost its reign over the flesh, being inherent and not cast out of it. But the Apostle opposes such a doctrine a little before, when he says, 'For we are His workmanship, created in Christ Jesus Ephesians 2:10;' and if in Christ we are created, then it is not He who is created, but we in Him; and thus the words 'He created' are for our sake. For because of our need, the Word, though being Creator, endured words which are used of creatures; which are not proper to Him, as being the Word, but are ours who are created in Him. And as, since the Father is always, so is His Word, and always being, always says 'I was daily His delight, rejoicing always before Him Proverbs 8:30,' and 'I am in the Father and the Father in Me John 14:10;' so, when for our need He became man, consistently does He use language, as ourselves, 'The Lord has created Me,' that, by His dwelling in the flesh, sin might perfectly be expelled from the flesh, and we might have a free mind. For what ought He, when made man, to say? 'In the beginning I was man?' this were neither suitable to Him nor true; and as it beseemed not to say this, so it is natural and proper in the case of man to say, 'He created' and 'He made' Him. On this account then the reason of 'He created' is added, namely, the need of the works; and where the reason is added, surely the reason rightly explains the lection. Thus here, when He says 'He created,' He sets down the cause, 'the works;' on the other hand, when He signifies absolutely the generation from the Father, straightway He adds, 'Before all the hills He begets me Proverbs 8:25;' but He does not add the 'wherefore,' as in the case of 'He created,' saying, 'for the works,' but absolutely, 'He begets me,' as in the text, 'In the beginning was the Word John 1:1.' For, though no works had been created, still 'the Word' of God 'was,' and 'the Word was God.' And His becoming man would not have taken place, had not the need of men become a cause. The Son then is not a creature.

Chapter 21. Texts Explained; Sixthly, Proverbs 8:22, Continued. Our Lord not said in Scripture to be 'created,' or the works to be 'begotten.' 'In the beginning' means in the case of the works 'from the beginning.' Scripture passages explained. We are made by God first, begotten next; creatures by nature, sons by grace. Christ begotten first, made or created afterwards. Sense of 'First-born of the dead;' of 'First-born among many brethren;' of 'First-born of all creation,' contrasted with 'Only-begotten.' Further interpretation of 'beginning of ways,' and 'for the works.' Why a creature could not redeem; why redemption was necessary at all. Texts which contrast the Word and the works.

If He had been a creature, He would not have said "He begets me," for creatures come from outside and are works of the Maker. But the Offspring is not from outside nor a work, but from the Father and proper to His ousia. Therefore they are creatures, while this is God's Word and Only-begotten Son. For example, Moses did not say of creation "In the beginning He begot" or "In the beginning was," but "In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth." Nor did David say in the Psalm "Your hands have begotten me," but "made me and fashioned me," everywhere applying the word "made" to creatures. But to the Son it is the opposite—he has not said "I made" but "I begot" and "He begets me" and "My heart uttered a good Word." And in the case of creation, "In the beginning He made," but in the case of the Son, "In the beginning was the Word." And there is this difference: creatures are made at a beginning and have a beginning of existence connected with an interval. Therefore what is said of them, "In the beginning He made," means the same as "From the beginning He made"—as the Lord, knowing what He had made, taught when He silenced the Pharisees with the words "He which made them from the beginning, made them male and female." For from some beginning, when they did not yet exist, created things were brought into being and created. The Holy Spirit has signified this in the Psalms, saying "You, Lord, at the beginning have laid the foundation of the earth," and again "O think upon Your congregation which You have purchased from the beginning." Now it is clear that what takes place at the beginning has a beginning of creation, and that from some beginning God purchased His congregation. And that "In the beginning He made," by saying "made," means "began to make," Moses himself shows by saying after the completion of all things, "And God blessed the seventh day and sanctified it, because that in it He had rested from all His work which God began to make." Therefore the creatures began to be made. But the Word of God, not having a beginning of being, certainly did not begin to be or begin to come to be, but always was. And the works have their beginning in their making, and their beginning comes before their coming to be. But the Word, not being one of the things that come to be, rather comes to be Himself the Framer of those which have a beginning. And the being of created things is measured by their becoming, and from some beginning God begins to make them through the Word, so that it may be known that they did not exist before their creation. But the Word has His being in no other beginning than the Father, whom they allow to be without beginning, so that He too exists without beginning in the Father, being His Offspring, not His creature.

57. For had He been a creature, He had not said, 'He begets me,' for the creatures are from without, and are works of the Maker; but the Offspring is not from without nor a work, but from the Father, and proper to His Essence. Wherefore they are creatures; this God's Word and Only-begotten Son. For instance, Moses did not say of the creation, 'In the beginning He begot,' nor 'In the beginning was,' but 'In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth Genesis 1:1.' Nor did David say in the Psalm, 'Your hands have begotten me, ' but 'made me and fashioned me,' everywhere applying the word 'made' to the creatures. But to the Son contrariwise; for he has not said 'I made,' but 'I begot,' and 'He begets me,' and 'My heart uttered a good Word.' And in the instance of the creation, 'In the beginning He made;' but in the instance of the Son, 'In the beginning was the Word John 1:1.' And there is this difference, that the creatures are made upon the beginning, and have a beginning of existence connected with an interval; wherefore also what is said of them, 'In the beginning He made,' is as much as saying of them, 'From the beginning He made:'– as the Lord, knowing that which He had made, taught, when He silenced the Pharisees, with the words, 'He which made them from the beginning, made them male and female Matthew 19:4;' for from some beginning, when they were not yet, were originate things brought into being and created. This too the Holy Spirit has signified in the Psalms, saying, 'Thou, Lord, at the beginning hast laid the foundation of the earth;' and again, 'O think upon Your congregation which You have purchased from the beginning;' now it is plain that what takes place at the beginning, has a beginning of creation, and that from some beginning God purchased His congregation. And that 'In the beginning He made,' from his saying 'made,' means 'began to make,' Moses himself shows by saying, after the completion of all things, 'And God blessed the seventh day and sanctified it, because that in it He had rested from all His work which God began to make Genesis 2:3.' Therefore the creatures began to be made; but the Word of God, not having beginning of being, certainly did not begin to be, nor begin to come to be, but was ever. And the works have their beginning in their making, and their beginning precedes their coming to be; but the Word, not being of things which come to be, rather comes to be Himself the Framer of those which have a beginning. And the being of things originate is measured by their becoming, and from some beginning does God begin to make them through the Word, that it may be known that they were not before their origination; but the Word has His being, in no other beginning than the Father, whom they allow to be without beginning, so that He too exists without beginning in the Father, being His Offspring, not His creature.

Divine Scripture recognizes the difference between the Offspring and created things, showing that the Offspring is a Son who did not begin from any starting point but is eternal. Created things, however, as external works of the Maker, began to come into existence. Therefore John, when teaching divine doctrine about the Son and understanding the difference in these terms, did not say "In the beginning has become" or "been made," but "In the beginning was the Word." This shows us that we should understand "Offspring" from the word "was," and not think of Him in terms of time intervals, but believe that the Son exists always and eternally. Given these proofs, how could you Arians, misunderstanding the passage in Deuteronomy, dare to commit this fresh act of irreligion against the Lord by saying that He is a work, a creature, or even offspring? For you treat offspring and work as meaning the same thing. But here too you will be shown to be as ignorant as you are irreligious. Your first passage is this: "Is not He your Father that bought you? Did He not make you and create you?" Shortly after in the same Song he says, "You deserted God Who begot you, and forgot God Who nourished you." The meaning conveyed in these passages is very striking. He does not say first "He begot," in case that term should be taken as interchangeable with "He made," and these people should have an excuse for saying, "Moses tells us that God said from the beginning, 'Let Us make man,'" but he soon after says himself, "God that begot you you deserted," as if the terms were equivalent—as if offspring and work were the same. But after the words "bought" and "made," he has added last of all "begot," so that the sentence might carry its own interpretation. In the word "made" he accurately indicates what belongs to human beings by nature—to be works and created things. But in the word "begot" he shows God's loving kindness exercised toward human beings after He had created them. And since they proved ungrateful for this, Moses reproaches them, saying first, "Do you thus repay the Lord?" and then adds, "Is not He your Father that bought you? Did He not make you and create you?" Next he says, "They sacrificed to demons, not to God, to gods whom they knew not. New gods and strange came up, whom your fathers knew not; the God that begot you you deserted."

58. Thus does divine Scripture recognise the difference between the Offspring and things made, and show that the Offspring is a Son, not begun from any beginning, but eternal; but that the thing made, as an external work of the Maker, began to come into being. John therefore delivering divine doctrine about the Son, and knowing the difference of the phrases, said not, 'In the beginning has become' or 'been made,' but 'In the beginning was the Word.' that we might understand 'Offspring' by 'was,' and not account of Him by intervals, but believe the Son always and eternally to exist. And with these proofs, how, O Arians, misunderstanding the passage in Deuteronomy, did you venture a fresh act of irreligion against the Lord, saying that 'He is a work,' or 'creature,' or indeed 'offspring?' for offspring and work you take to mean the same thing; but here too you shall be shown to be as unlearned as you are irreligious. Your first passage is this, 'Is not He your Father that bought you? Did He not make you and create you?' And shortly after in the same Song he says, 'You deserted God Who begot you, and forgot God Who nourished you.' Now the meaning conveyed in these passages is very remarkable; for he says not first 'He begot,' lest that term should be taken as indiscriminate with 'He made,' and these men should have a pretence for saying, ' Moses tells us indeed that God said from the beginning, Let Us make man Genesis 1:26, ' but he soon after says himself, 'God that begot you you deserted,' as if the terms were indifferent; for offspring and work are the same. But after the words 'bought' and 'made,' he has added last of all 'begot,' that the sentence might carry its own interpretation; for in the word 'made' he accurately denotes what belongs to men by nature, to be works and things made; but in the word 'begot' he shows God's lovingkindness exercised towards men after He had created them. And since they have proved ungrateful upon this, thereupon Moses reproaches them, saying first, 'Do ye thus requite the Lord.' and then adds, 'Is not He your Father that bought you? Did He not make you and create you Deuteronomy 32:6?' And next he says, 'They sacrificed unto devils, not to God, to gods whom they knew not. New gods and strange came up, whom your fathers knew not; the God that begot you you deserted. '

God not only created people to be human, but called them to be sons, having begotten them. The term "begot" here, as elsewhere, refers to a Son, as He says through the Prophet, "I begot sons and exalted them." Generally, when Scripture wants to signify a son, it does so not by the term "created," but certainly by "begot." John seems to say this: "He gave to them power to become children of God, even to them that believe in His Name; which were begotten not of blood, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God." Here too the careful distinction is well maintained, for first he says "become," because they are not called sons by nature but by adoption. Then he says "were begotten," because they too had at least received the name of son. But the People, as the Prophet says, "despised" their Benefactor. This is God's kindness to humanity: those of whom He is Maker, of them according to grace He afterwards becomes Father also. He becomes Father when people, His creatures, receive into their hearts, as the Apostle says, "the Spirit of His Son, crying, Abba, Father." These are they who, having received the Word, gained power from Him to become sons of God, for they could not become sons, being by physis creatures, except by receiving the Spirit of the natural and true Son. Therefore, so that this might happen, "The Word became flesh," that He might make humanity capable of Godhead. This same meaning can also be gained from the Prophet Malachi, who says, "Hath not One God created us? Have we not all one Father?" First he puts "created," next "Father," to show, like the other writers, that from the beginning we were creatures by nature, and God is our Creator through the Word. But afterwards we were made sons, and from then on God the Creator becomes our Father also. Therefore "Father" is proper to the Son, and not "creature," but "Son" is proper to the Father. Accordingly this passage also proves that we are not sons by nature, but the Son who is in us is. And again, God is not our Father by nature, but of that Word in us, in whom and because of whom we "cry, Abba, Father." Likewise, the Father calls them sons in whomever He sees His own Son, and says, "I begot," since begetting signifies a Son, and making indicates the works. Thus it is that we are not begotten first, but made, for it is written, "Let Us make man." But afterwards, on receiving the grace of the Spirit, we are said from then on to be begotten also, just as the great Moses in his Song with fitting meaning says first "He bought," and afterwards "He begot," lest, hearing "He begot," they might forget their own original nature. Rather, they might know that from the beginning they are creatures, but when according to grace they are said to be begotten as sons, still no less than before are they works according to nature.

59. For God not only created them to be men, but called them to be sons, as having begotten them. For the term 'begot' is here as elsewhere expressive of a Son, as He says by the Prophet, 'I begot sons and exalted them;' and generally, when Scripture wishes to signify a son, it does so, not by the term 'created,' but undoubtedly by that of 'begot.' And this John seems to say, 'He gave to them power to become children of God, even to them that believe in His Name; which were begotten not of blood, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God John 1:12-13.' And here too the cautious distinction is well kept up, for first he says 'become,' because they are not called sons by nature but by adoption; then he says 'were begotten,' because they too had received at any rate the name of son. But the People, as says the Prophet, 'despised' their Benefactor. But this is God's kindness to man, that of whom He is Maker, of them according to grace He afterwards becomes Father also; becomes, that is, when men, His creatures, receive into their hearts, as the Apostle says, 'the Spirit of His Son, crying, Abba, Father.' And these are they who, having received the Word, gained power from Him to become sons of God; for they could not become sons, being by nature creatures, otherwise than by receiving the Spirit of the natural and true Son. Wherefore, that this might be, 'The Word became flesh,' that He might make man capable of Godhead. This same meaning may be gained also from the Prophet Malachi, who says, 'Hath not One God created us? Have we not all one Father Malachi 2:10?' for first he puts 'created,' next 'Father,' to show, as the other writers, that from the beginning we were creatures by nature, and God is our Creator through the Word; but afterwards we were made sons, and thenceforward God the Creator becomes our Father also. Therefore 'Father' is proper to the Son; and not 'creature,' but 'Son' is proper to the Father. Accordingly this passage also proves, that we are not sons by nature, but the Son who is in us; and again, that God is not our Father by nature, but of that Word in us, in whom and because of whom we 'cry, Abba, Father Galatians 4:6.' And so in like manner, the Father calls them sons in whomsoever He sees His own Son, and says, 'I begot.' since begetting is significant of a Son, and making is indicative of the works. And thus it is that we are not begotten first, but made; for it is written, 'Let Us make man Genesis 1:26;' but afterwards, on receiving the grace of the Spirit, we are said thenceforth to be begotten also; just as the great Moses in his Song with an apposite meaning says first 'He bought,' and afterwards 'He begot.' lest, hearing 'He begot,' they might forget their own original nature; but that they might know that from the beginning they are creatures, but when according to grace they are said to be begotten, as sons, still no less than before are men works according to nature.

The Lord Himself shows in Proverbs that creature and offspring are not the same but differ from each other in nature and in the meaning of the words. After saying, "The Lord created me a beginning of His ways," He added, "But before all the hills He begot me." If the Word were by nature and in His ousia a creature, and if there were no difference between offspring and creature, He would not have added "He begot me" but would have been satisfied with "He created," as if that term meant the same as "He begot." But as it is, after saying "He created me a beginning of His ways for His works," He added not simply "begot me" but with the connecting word "But," thereby guarding the term "created" when He says, "But before all the hills He begot me." The phrase "begot me" following so closely after "created me" makes the meaning unified and shows that "created" is said with a purpose, while "begot me" comes before "created me." Just as if He had said the reverse—"The Lord begot me" and then continued "But before the hills He created me"—"created" would certainly come before "begot," so having first said "created" and then added "But before all the hills He begot me," He necessarily shows that "begot" came before "created." In saying "Before all He begot me," He indicates that He is different from all things, since it was shown to be true earlier in this book that no one creature was made before another, but all things came into existence together at once upon one and the same command. Therefore the words that follow "created" do not also follow "begot me." With "created" is added "beginning of ways," but with "begot me" He does not say "He begot me as a beginning" but "before all He begot me." But He who is before all is not a beginning of all but is different from all. If He is different from all—in which "all" includes the beginning of all—it follows that He is different from the creatures. The point becomes clear that the Word, being different from all things and before all, was afterwards created "a beginning of the ways for works" because He became man, so that, as the Apostle has said, He who is the "Beginning" and "First-born from the dead" might "in all things have the preeminence."

60. And that creature and offspring are not the same, but differ from each other in nature and the signification of the words, the Lord Himself shows even in the Proverbs. For having said, 'The Lord created me a beginning of His ways;' He has added, 'But before all the hills He begot me.' If then the Word were by nature and in His Essence a creature, and there were no difference between offspring and creature, He would not have added, 'He begot me,' but had been satisfied with 'He created,' as if that term implied 'He begot.' but, as it is, after saying, 'He created me a beginning of His ways for His works,' He has added, not simply 'begot me,' but with the connection of the conjunction 'But,' as guarding thereby the term 'created,' when he says, 'But before all the hills He begot me.' For 'begot me' succeeding in such close connection to 'created me,' makes the meaning one, and shows that 'created' is said with an object, but that 'begot me' is prior to 'created me.' For as, if He had said the reverse, 'The Lord begot me,' and went on, 'But before the hills He created me,' 'created' would certainly precede 'begot,' so having said first 'created,' and then added 'But before all the hills He begot me,' He necessarily shows that 'begot' preceded 'created.' For in saying, 'Before all He begot me,' He intimates that He is other than all things; it having been shown to be true in an earlier part of this book, that no one creature was made before another, but all things originate subsisted at once together upon one and the same command. Therefore neither do the words which follow 'created,' also follow 'begot me;' but in the case of 'created' is added 'beginning of ways,' but of 'begot me,' He says not, 'He begot me as a beginning,' but 'before all He begot me.' But He who is before all is not a beginning of all, but is other than all; but if other than all (in which 'all' the beginning of all is included), it follows that He is other than the creatures; and it becomes a clear point, that the Word, being other than all things and before all, afterwards is created 'a beginning of the ways for works,' because He became man, that, as the Apostle has said, He who is the 'Beginning' and 'First-born from the dead, in all things might have the preeminence Colossians 1:18.'

Such, then, is the difference between "created" and "begot me," and between "beginning of ways" and "before all." God, being first Creator, next becomes Father of people because His Word dwells in them, as has been said. But in the case of the Word, the reverse happens. God, being His Father by nature, becomes afterwards both His Creator and Maker when the Word takes on that flesh which was created and made, and becomes human. Just as people, receiving the Spirit of the Son, become children through Him, so the Word of God, when He Himself takes on human flesh, is then said both to be created and to have been made. If we are sons by nature, then He is by nature creature and work. But if we become sons by adoption and grace, then the Word also, when in grace toward us He became human, said, "The Lord created me." And furthermore, when He took on a created nature and became like us in body, He was reasonably called both our Brother and "First-born." For though it was after us that He was made human for us, and our brother by similarity of body, still He is therefore called and is the "First-born" of us because, when all people were lost according to the transgression of Adam, His flesh before all others was saved and liberated, as being the Word's body. And from then on we, becoming incorporate with It, are saved after Its pattern. For in It the Lord becomes our guide to the Kingdom of Heaven and to His own Father, saying, "I am the way" and "the door," and "through Me all must enter." This is also why He is said to be "First-born from the dead," not that He died before us, for we had died first, but because having undergone death for us and abolished it, He was the first to rise, as human, raising His own Body for our sakes. From then on, since He has risen, we too from Him and because of Him rise in due course from the dead.

61. Such then being the difference between 'created' and 'begot me,' and between 'beginning of ways' and 'before all,' God, being first Creator, next, as has been said, becomes Father of men, because of His Word dwelling in them. But in the case of the Word the reverse; for God, being His Father by nature, becomes afterwards both His Creator and Maker, when the Word puts on that flesh which was created and made, and becomes man. For, as men, receiving the Spirit of the Son, become children through Him, so the Word of God, when He Himself puts on the flesh of man, then is said both to be created and to have been made. If then we are by nature sons, then is He by nature creature and work; but if we become sons by adoption and grace, then has the Word also, when in grace towards us He became man, said, 'The Lord created me.' And in the next place, when He put on a created nature and became like us in body, reasonably was He therefore called both our Brother and 'First-born.' For though it was after us that He was made man for us, and our brother by similitude of body, still He is therefore called and is the 'First-born' of us, because, all men being lost, according to the transgression of Adam, His flesh before all others was saved and liberated, as being the Word's body; and henceforth we, becoming incorporate with It, are saved after Its pattern. For in It the Lord becomes our guide to the Kingdom of Heaven and to His own Father, saying, 'I am the way' and 'the door,' and 'through Me all must enter.' Whence also is He said to be 'First-born from the dead Revelation 1:5,' not that He died before us, for we had died first; but because having undergone death for us and abolished it, He was the first to rise, as man, for our sakes raising His own Body. Henceforth He having risen, we too from Him and because of Him rise in due course from the dead.

But if He is also called "First-born of the creation," this is not because He is reduced to the level of creatures and is simply first among them in time (for how could that be, since He is "Only-begotten?"). Rather, it is because of the Word's condescension to the creatures, through which He has become the "Brother" of "many." For the term "Only-begotten" is used where there are no brothers, but "First-born" is used because of brothers. Accordingly, it is nowhere written in the Scriptures "the first-born of God" or "the creature of God." But "Only-begotten" and "Son" and "Word" and "Wisdom" refer to Him as belonging properly to the Father. Thus, "We have seen His glory, the glory as of the Only-begotten of the Father" (John 1:14), and "God sent His Only-begotten Son" (1 John 4:9), and "O Lord, Your Word endures forever," and "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God," and "Christ the Power of God and the Wisdom of God" (1 Corinthians 1:24), and "This is My beloved Son," and "You are the Christ, the Son of the Living God." But "First-born" refers to His descent to the creation, for it is of the creation that He has been called first-born, and "He created" refers to His grace toward the works, for it is for them that He is created. If then He is Only-begotten, as He truly is, "First-born" needs some explanation. But if He is really First-born, then He is not Only-begotten. For the same person cannot be both Only-begotten and First-born, except in different relations—that is, Only-begotten because of His generation from the Father, as has been said, and First-born because of His condescension to the creation and His making the many His brothers. Certainly, since these two terms are inconsistent with each other, one should say that the attribute of being Only-begotten rightly has preference in the case of the Word, in that there is no other Word or other Wisdom, but He alone is the true Son of the Father. Moreover, as was said before, He is called "The Only-begotten Son who is in the bosom of the Father" (John 1:18) without any qualifying reason, but absolutely. But the word "First-born" has the creation as a reason connected with it, which Paul goes on to state: "for in Him all things were created" (Colossians 1:16). But if all the creatures were created in Him, He is other than the creatures and is not a creature, but the Creator of the creatures.

62. But if He is also called 'First-born of the creation,' still this is not as if He were levelled to the creatures, and only first of them in point of time (for how should that be, since He is 'Only-begotten?'), but it is because of the Word's condescension to the creatures, according to which He has become the 'Brother' of 'many.' For the term 'Only-begotten' is used where there are no brethren, but 'First-born ' because of brethren. Accordingly it is nowhere written in the Scriptures, 'the first-born of God,' nor 'the creature of God;' but 'Only-begotten' and 'Son' and 'Word' and 'Wisdom,' refer to Him as proper to the Father. Thus, 'We have seen His glory, the glory as of the Only-begotten of the Father John 1:14;' and 'God sent His Only-begotten Son 1 John 4:9;' and 'O Lord, Your Word endures for ever;' and 'In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God;' and 'Christ the Power of God and the Wisdom of God 1 Corinthians 1:24;' and 'This is My beloved Son.' and 'You are the Christ, the Son of the Living God.' But ' first-born ' implied the descent to the creation; for of it has He been called first-born; and 'He created' implies His grace towards the works, for for them is He created. If then He is Only-begotten, as indeed He is, 'First-born' needs some explanation; but if He be really First-born, then He is not Only-begotten. For the same cannot be both Only-begotten and First-born, except in different relations;– that is, Only-begotten, because of His generation from the Father, as has been said; and First-born, because of His condescension to the creation and His making the many His brethren. Certainly, those two terms being inconsistent with each other, one should say that the attribute of being Only-begotten has justly the preference in the instance of the Word, in that there is no other Word, or other Wisdom, but He alone is very Son of the Father. Moreover, as was before said, not in connection with any reason, but absolutely it is said of Him, 'The Only-begotten Son which is in the bosom of the Father John 1:18;' but the word 'First-born' has again the creation as a reason in connection with it, which Paul proceeds to say, 'for in Him all things were created Colossians 1:16.' But if all the creatures were created in Him, He is other than the creatures, and is not a creature, but the Creator of the creatures.

The title "First-born" was not given to Him because He is from the Father, but because creation came into being in Him. Just as He was the Son before creation existed—the Son through whom creation came to be—so also before He was called the First-born of the whole creation, the Word Himself was already with God and the Word was God. But these irreligious people do not understand this, and they go around saying, "If He is First-born of all creation, then clearly He too is one of the creatures." How foolish! If He is simply "First-born of the whole creation," then He is distinct from the whole creation. The text does not say "He is First-born above the rest of the creatures," which would suggest He is counted as one of the creatures. Rather, it says "of the whole creation," to show that He is distinct from creation. For example, Reuben is not called the first-born of all the children of Jacob, but of Jacob himself and his brothers, so that he would not be thought to be someone other than one of Jacob's children. Similarly, the Apostle does not say concerning the Lord that He became First-born of all, which would suggest He has a body different from ours, but rather "among many brethren," because of the likeness of the flesh. Therefore, if the Word were one of the creatures, Scripture would have said that He was First-born of other creatures. But since the saints say that He is "First-born of the whole creation," the Son of God is clearly shown to be distinct from the whole creation and not a creature. For if He is a creature, He would be First-born of Himself. How then is it possible, O Arians, for Him to be both before and after Himself? Furthermore, if He is a creature, and the whole creation came to be through Him and holds together in Him, how can He both create the creation and be one of the things that hold together in Him? Since such an idea is absurd in itself, the truth proves against them that He is called "First-born among many brethren" because of the relationship of the flesh, and "First-born from the dead" because the resurrection of the dead comes from Him and after Him, and "First-born of the whole creation" because of the Father's love for humanity. This love brought it about that in His Word not only do "all things hold together," but the creation itself, of which the Apostle speaks when he says it is "waiting for the manifestation of the sons of God" and "shall be delivered from the bondage of corruption into the glorious liberty of the children of God," will one day be delivered. The Lord will be First-born of this delivered creation and of all those who are made children, so that by His being called first, those who come after Him may remain secure, depending on the Word as their beginning.

63. Not then because He was from the Father was He called 'First-born,' but because in Him the creation came to be; and as before the creation He was the Son, through whom was the creation, so also before He was called the First-born of the whole creation, not the less was the Word Himself with God and the Word was God. But this also not understanding, these irreligious men go about saying, 'If He is First-born of all creation, it is plain that He too is one of the creation.' Senseless men! If He is simply 'First-born of the whole creation,' then He is other than the whole creation; for he says not, 'He is First-born above the rest of the creatures,' lest He be reckoned to be as one of the creatures, but it is written, 'of the whole creation,' that He may appear other than the creation. Reuben, for instance, is not said to be first-born of all the children of Jacob, but of Jacob himself and his brethren; lest he should be thought to be some other beside the children of Jacob. Nay, even concerning the Lord Himself the Apostle says not, 'that He may become First-born of all,' lest He be thought to bear a body other than ours, but 'among many brethren Romans 8:29,' because of the likeness of the flesh. If then the Word also were one of the creatures, Scripture would have said of Him also that He was First-born of other creatures; but in fact, the saints saying that He is 'First-born of the whole creation Colossians 1:15,' the Son of God is plainly shown to be other than the whole creation and not a creature. For if He is a creature, He will be First-born of Himself. How then is it possible, O Arians, for Him to be before and after Himself? Next, if He is a creature, and the whole creation through Him came to be, and in Him consists, how can He both create the creation and be one of the things which consist in Him? Since then such a notion is in itself unseemly, it is proved against them by the truth, that He is called 'First-born among many brethren?' because of the relationship of the flesh, and 'First-born from the dead,' because the resurrection of the dead is from Him and after Him; and 'First-born of the whole creation,' because of the Father's love to man, which brought it to pass that in His Word not only 'all things consist,' but the creation itself, of which the Apostle speaks, 'waiting for the manifestation of the sons of God, shall be delivered' one time 'from the bondage of corruption into the glorious liberty of the children of God.' Of this creation thus delivered, the Lord will be First-born, both of it and of all those who are made children, that by His being called first, those that come after Him may abide, as depending on the Word as a beginning.

I believe even those who oppose the faith will be ashamed of such a view. For if the situation is not as we have explained, but they insist that He is "First-born of the whole creation" in terms of His essential nature—a creature among creatures—then they should realize they are conceiving Him as brother and companion to things that lack reason and life. For these too are parts of the whole creation, and the "First-born" must indeed be first in time, but only in that way, and must be the same in kind and likeness with everything else. How then can they say this without going beyond all bounds of impiety? Who will tolerate them if this is what they are saying? Who can help but hate them for even imagining such things? It is clear to everyone that He has not been called "First-born" of creation either for His own sake as a creature, or because He has any connection according to essence with the whole creation. Rather, it is because the Word, when He formed the creatures in the beginning, condescended to created things so that it might be possible for them to come into being. For they could not have endured His nature, which was untempered splendor—even that of the Father—unless He had condescended through the Father's love for humanity and sustained them and took hold of them and brought them into existence. And furthermore, because through this condescension of the Word, the creation itself is also made a son through Him, so that He might be in all respects "First-born" of it, as has been said, both in creating and also in being brought into this very world for the sake of all. For it is written, "When He brings the First-born into the world, He says, Let all the Angels of God worship Him." Let Christ's enemies hear this and tear themselves apart, because His coming into the world is what causes Him to be called "First-born" of all. And so the Son is the Father's "Only-begotten" because He alone is from Him, and He is the "First-born of creation" because of this adoption of all as sons. And just as He is First-born among brethren and rose from the dead "the first fruits of them that slept," so, since it was fitting for Him "in all things to have the preeminence," He is therefore created "a beginning of ways," so that we, walking along it and entering through Him who says, "I am the Way" and "the Door," and sharing in the knowledge of the Father, may also hear the words, "Blessed are the undefiled in the Way," and "Blessed are the pure in heart, for they shall see God."

64. And I think that the irreligious men themselves will be shamed from such a thought; for if the case stands not as we have said, but they will rule it that He is 'First-born of the whole creation' as in essence — a creature among creatures, let them reflect that they will be conceiving Him as brother and fellow of the things without reason and life. For of the whole creation these also are parts; and the 'First-born' must be first indeed in point of time but only thus, and in kind and similitude must be the same with all. How then can they say this without exceeding all measures of irreligion? Or who will endure them, if this is their language? Or who can but hate them even imagining such things? For it is evident to all, that neither for Himself, as being a creature, nor as having any connection according to essence with the whole creation, has He been called 'First-born' of it: but because the Word, when at the beginning He framed the creatures, condescended to things originate, that it might be possible for them to come to be. For they could not have endured His nature, which was untempered splendour, even that of the Father, unless condescending by the Father's love for man He had supported them and taken hold of them and brought them into existence; and next, because, by this condescension of the Word, the creation too is made a son through Him, that He might be in all respects 'First-born' of it, as has been said, both in creating, and also in being brought for the sake of all into this very world. For so it is written, 'When He brings the First-born into the world, He says, Let all the Angels of God worship Him Hebrews 1:6.' Let Christ's enemies hear and tear themselves to pieces, because His coming into the world is what makes Him called 'First-born' of all; and thus the Son is the Father's 'Only-begotten,' because He alone is from Him, and He is the 'First-born of creation,' because of this adoption of all as sons. And as He is First-born among brethren and rose from the dead 'the first fruits of them that slept 1 Corinthians 15:20;' so, since it became Him 'in all things to have the preeminence Colossians 1:18,' therefore He is created 'a beginning of ways,' that we, walking along it and entering through Him who says, 'I am the Way' and 'the Door,' and partaking of the knowledge of the Father, may also hear the words, 'Blessed are the undefiled in the Way,' and 'Blessed are the pure in heart, for they shall see God. '

Since the truth declares that the Word is not by nature (physis) a creature, it is now fitting to explain in what sense He is "beginning of ways." When the first way, which was through Adam, was lost, and instead of paradise we strayed into death and heard the words "Dust you are, and to dust you shall return" (Genesis 3:19), the Word of God, who loves humanity, took on created flesh according to the Father's will. This was so that, whereas the first man had made it dead through transgression, He Himself might give it life in the blood of His own body and might open "for us a new and living way," as the Apostle says, "through the veil, that is to say, His flesh" (Hebrews 10:20). He indicates this elsewhere saying, "Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation; old things have passed away, behold all things have become new" (2 Corinthians 5:17). But if a new creation has come to pass, someone must be first of this creation. Now this could not be a man made of earth only, such as we have become from the transgression. For in the first creation, people had become unfaithful, and through them that first creation had been lost. There was need of someone else to renew the first creation and preserve the new one that had come to be. Therefore, out of love for humanity, none other than the Lord, the "beginning" of the new creation, is created as "the Way," and accordingly says, "The Lord created me a beginning of ways for His works." This is so that humanity might no longer walk according to that first creation, but there being, as it were, a beginning of a new creation, and with Christ "a beginning of its ways," we might henceforth follow Him, who says to us, "I am the Way"—as the blessed Apostle teaches in Colossians, saying, "He is the Head of the body, the Church, who is the Beginning, the First-born from the dead, that in all things He might have the preeminence."

65. And thus since the truth declares that the Word is not by nature a creature, it is fitting now to say, in what sense He is 'beginning of ways.' For when the first way, which was through Adam, was lost, and in place of paradise we deviated unto death, and heard the words, 'Dust you are, and unto dust Genesis 3:19 shall you return,' therefore the Word of God, who loves man, puts on Him created flesh at the Father's will, that whereas the first man had made it dead through the transgression, He Himself might quicken it in the blood of His own body, and might open 'for us a way new and living,' as the Apostle says, 'through the veil, that is to say, His flesh Hebrews 10:20;' which he signifies elsewhere thus, 'Wherefore, if any man be in Christ, he is a new creation; old things are passed away, behold all things have become new 2 Corinthians 5:17.' But if a new creation has come to pass, some one must be first of this creation; now a man, made of earth only, such as we have become from the transgression, he could not be. For in the first creation, men had become unfaithful, and through them that first creation had been lost; and there was need of some one else to renew the first creation, and preserve the new which had come to be. Therefore from love to man none other than the Lord, the 'beginning' of the new creation, is created as 'the Way,' and consistently says, 'The Lord created me a beginning of ways for His works;' that man might walk no longer according to that first creation, but there being as it were a beginning of a new creation, and with the Christ 'a beginning of its ways,' we might follow Him henceforth, who says to us, 'I am the Way:'– as the blessed Apostle teaches in Colossians, saying, 'He is the Head of the body, the Church, who is the Beginning, the First-born from the dead, that in all things He might have the preeminence.'

If, as has already been stated, He is called a beginning because of the resurrection from the dead, and if this resurrection took place when He bore our flesh and gave Himself to death for us, then it is clear that His words, "He created me a beginning of ways," refer not to His ousia but to His bodily presence. For death properly belongs to the body, and in the same way the words "The Lord created me a beginning of His ways" properly belong to His bodily presence. Since the Savior was thus created according to the flesh and became a beginning of the newly created things, and since He possessed our first fruits—that is, the human flesh He took to Himself—therefore after Him the people to come are also created, as is fitting. David says, "Let this be written for another generation, and the people that shall be created shall praise the Lord." And again in the twenty-first Psalm, "The generation to come shall declare unto the Lord, and they shall declare His righteousness, unto a people that shall be born whom the Lord made." For we shall no longer hear, "In the day that you eat thereof, you shall surely die," but "Where I am, there you shall be also," so that we may say, "We are His workmanship, created unto good works." Again, since God's work—that is, man—though created perfect, has become deficient through transgression and dead by sin, and since it was inappropriate for the work of God to remain imperfect (which is why all the saints were praying about this, for instance in the hundred and thirty-seventh Psalm, saying, "Lord, You shall requite for me; despise not then the works of Your hands"), therefore the perfect Word of God takes on an imperfect body and is said to be created "for the works." By paying the debt in our place, He might perfect in Himself what was lacking to man. Now what was lacking to man was immortality and the way to paradise. This is what the Savior means when He says, "I glorified You on the earth, I perfected the work which You have given Me to do," and again, "The works which the Father has given Me to perfect, the same works that I do, bear witness of Me." But the works He says the Father has given Him to perfect are those for which He is created, as He says in the Proverbs, "The Lord created me a beginning of His ways, for His works." For it is the same thing to say, "The Father has given me the works," and "The Lord created me for the works."

66. For if, as has been said, because of the resurrection from the dead He is called a beginning, and then a resurrection took place when He, bearing our flesh, had given Himself to death for us, it is evident that His words, 'He created me a beginning of ways,' is indicative not of His essence, but of His bodily presence. For to the body death was proper; and in like manner to the bodily presence are the words proper, 'The Lord created me a beginning of His ways.' For since the Saviour was thus created according to the flesh, and had become a beginning of things new created, and had our first fruits, viz. that human flesh which He took to Himself, therefore after Him, as is fit, is created also the people to come, David saying, 'Let this be written for another generation, and the people that shall be created shall praise the Lord.' And again in the twenty-first Psalm, 'The generation to come shall declare unto the Lord, and they shall declare His righteousness, unto a people that shall be born whom the Lord made.' For we shall no more hear, 'In the day that you eat thereof, you shall surely die Genesis 2:17,' but 'Where I am, there ye' shall 'be also;' so that we may say, 'We are His workmanship, created unto good works John 14:3; Ephesians 2:10.' And again, since God's work, that is, man, though created perfect, has become wanting through the transgression, and dead by sin, and it was unbecoming that the work of God should remain imperfect (wherefore all the saints were praying concerning this, for instance in the hundred and thirty-seventh Psalm, saying, 'Lord, You shall requite for me; despise not then the works of Your hands '); therefore the perfect Word of God puts around Him an imperfect body, and is said to be created 'for the works;' that, paying the debt in our stead, He might, by Himself, perfect what was wanting to man. Now immortality was wanting to him, and the way to paradise. This then is what the Saviour says, 'I glorified You on the earth, I perfected the work which You have given Me to do John 17:4;' and again, 'The works which the Father has given Me to perfect, the same works that I do, bear witness of Me;' but 'the works ' He here says that the Father had given Him to perfect, are those for which He is created, saying in the Proverbs, 'The Lord created me a beginning of His ways, for His works;' for it is all one to say, 'The Father has given me the works,' and 'The Lord created me for the works.'

When then did He receive the works to perfect, O enemies of God? For from this also "He created" will be understood. If you say, "At the beginning when He brought them into being out of what was not," this is untrue, for they were not yet made, whereas He appears to be speaking as if taking what was already in being. Nor is it right to refer to the time before the Word became flesh, lest His coming should then seem unnecessary, since it was for the sake of these works that this coming took place. Therefore it remains for us to say that when He became man, then He took the works. For then He perfected them, by healing our wounds and granting us resurrection from the dead. But if, when the Word became flesh, the works were then given to Him, clearly when He became man, then also is He created for the works. Not of His ousia then is "He created" indicative, as has been said many times, but of His bodily generation. For then, because the works had become imperfect and damaged from the transgression, He is said with respect to the body to be created, so that by perfecting them and making them whole, He might present the Church to the Father, as the Apostle says, "not having spot or wrinkle or any such thing, but holy and without blemish." Mankind then is perfected in Him and restored, as it was made at the beginning—indeed, with greater grace. For, on rising from the dead, we shall no longer fear death, but shall reign forever in Christ in the heavens. And this has been done, since the own Word of God Himself, who is from the Father, has put on the flesh and become man. For if, being a creature, He had become man, man would have remained just what he was, not joined to God; for how could a work be joined to the Creator by a work? Or what help could come from like to like, when both equally needed it? And how, if the Word were a creature, could He have power to undo God's sentence and to forgive sin, whereas it is written in the Prophets that this is God's doing? For "who is a God like You, that pardons iniquity, and passes by transgression?" For whereas God has said, "Dust you are, and to dust you shall return," men have become mortal; how then could things originate undo sin? But the Lord is He who has undone it, as He says Himself, "Unless the Son shall make you free"; and the Son, who made free, has shown in truth that He is no creature, nor one of things originate, but the proper Word and Image of the Father's Ousia, who at the beginning pronounced sentence, and alone forgives sins. For since it was said in the Word, "Dust you are, and to dust you shall return," fittingly through the Word Himself and in Him the freedom and the undoing of the condemnation has come to pass.

67. When then received He the works to perfect, O God's enemies? For from this also 'He created' will be understood. If you say, 'At the beginning when He brought them into being out of what was not,' it is an untruth; for they were not yet made; whereas He appears to speak as taking what was already in being. Nor is it pious to refer to the time which preceded the Word's becoming flesh, lest His coming should thereupon seem superfluous, since for the sake of these works that coming took place. Therefore it remains for us to say that when He has become man, then He took the works. For then He perfected them, by healing our wounds and vouchsafing to us the resurrection from the dead. But if, when the Word became flesh, then were given to Him the works, plainly when He became man, then also is He created for the works. Not of His essence then is 'He created' indicative, as has many times been said, but of His bodily generation. For then, because the works had become imperfect and mutilated from the transgression, He is said in respect to the body to be created; that by perfecting them and making them whole, He might present the Church unto the Father, as the Apostle says, 'not having spot or wrinkle or any such thing, but holy and without blemish Ephesians 5:27.' Mankind then is perfected in Him and restored, as it was made at the beginning, nay, with greater grace. For, on rising from the dead, we shall no longer fear death, but shall ever reign in Christ in the heavens. And this has been done, since the own Word of God Himself, who is from the Father, has put on the flesh, and become man. For if, being a creature, He had become man, man had remained just what he was, not joined to God; for how had a work been joined to the Creator by a work? Or what succour had come from like to like, when one as well as other needed it? And how, were the Word a creature, had He power to undo God's sentence, and to remit sin, whereas it is written in the Prophets, that this is God's doing? For 'who is a God like You, that pardons iniquity, and passes by transgression Micah 7:18?' For whereas God has said, 'Dust you are, and unto dust shall you return Genesis 3:19,' men have become mortal; how then could things originate undo sin? But the Lord is He who has undone it, as He says Himself, 'Unless the Son shall make you free;' and the Son, who made free, has shown in truth that He is no creature, nor one of things originate, but the proper Word and Image of the Father's Essence, who at the beginning sentenced, and alone remits sins. For since it is said in the Word, 'Dust you are, and unto dust you shall return,' suitably through the Word Himself and in Him the freedom and the undoing of the condemnation has come to pass.

Yet, they say, 'Even if the Savior were a creature, God was able to speak the word alone and undo the curse.' And so someone will tell them likewise, 'Without His coming among us at all, God was able simply to speak and undo the curse.' But we must consider what was expedient for humanity, not merely what is possible with God. He could have destroyed the transgressors before Noah's Ark, but He did it after the ark. He could also, without Moses, have spoken the word alone and brought the people out of Egypt, but it was profitable to do it through Moses. And God was able without the judges to save His people, but it was profitable for the people that for a time judges should be raised up for them. The Savior too might have come among us from the beginning, or when He came might not have been handed over to Pilate, but He came 'at the fullness of the ages' (Galatians 4:4), and when sought for said, 'I am He' (John 18:5). For what He does is profitable for humanity and could not be fitting in any other way, and what is profitable and fitting, that He provides. Accordingly He came 'not to be served but to serve' and to work our salvation. Certainly He was able to speak the Law from heaven, but He saw that it was expedient for humanity for Him to speak from Sinai, and He did this so that it might be possible for Moses to go up, and so that they, hearing the word near them, would be more likely to believe. Moreover, the good reason for what He did may be seen thus: if God had merely spoken, because it was in His power, and so the curse had been undone, the power of Him who gave the word would have been shown, but humanity would have become such as Adam was before the transgression, having received grace from outside and not having it united to the body (for he was such when he was placed in Paradise). Indeed, perhaps humanity would have become worse, because it had learned to transgress. Being in such a condition, if humanity had been seduced by the serpent, there would have been fresh need for God to give command and undo the curse, and thus the need would have become endless, and humanity would have remained under guilt no less than before, being enslaved to sin. And, ever sinning, they would have always needed someone to pardon them, and would never have become free, being in themselves flesh and always defeated by the Law because of the weakness of the flesh.

68. 'Yet,' they say, 'though the Saviour were a creature, God was able to speak the word only and undo the curse.' And so another will tell them in like manner, 'Without His coming among us at all, God was able just to speak and undo the curse.' but we must consider what was expedient for mankind, and not what simply is possible with God. He could have destroyed, before the Ark of Noah, the then transgressors; but He did it after the ark. He could too, without Moses, have spoken the word only and have brought the people out of Egypt; but it profited to do it through Moses. And God was able without the judges to save His people; but it was profitable for the people that for a season judges should be raised up to them. The Saviour too might have come among us from the beginning, or on His coming might not have been delivered to Pilate; but He came 'at the fullness of the ages Galatians 4:4,' and when sought for said, 'I am He John 18:5.' For what He does, that is profitable for men, and was not fitting in any other way; and what is profitable and fitting, for that He provides. Accordingly He came, not 'that He might be ministered unto, but that He might minister,' and might work our salvation. Certainly He was able to speak the Law from heaven, but He saw that it was expedient to men for Him to speak from Sinai; and that He has done, that it might be possible for Moses to go up, and for them hearing the word near them the rather to believe. Moreover, the good reason of what He did may be seen thus; if God had but spoken, because it was in His power, and so the curse had been undone, the power had been shown of Him who gave the word, but man had become such as Adam was before the transgression, having received grace from without, and not having it united to the body; (for he was such when he was placed in Paradise) nay, perhaps had become worse, because he had learned to transgress. Such then being his condition, had he been seduced by the serpent, there had been fresh need for God to give command and undo the curse; and thus the need had become interminable, and men had remained under guilt not less than before, as being enslaved to sin; and, ever sinning, would have ever needed one to pardon them, and had never become free, being in themselves flesh, and ever worsted by the Law because of the infirmity of the flesh.

Again, if the Son were a creature, humanity would have remained mortal as before, not being united to God. For a creature could not have joined creatures to God, since it would itself need someone to join it. Nor could a portion of creation have brought salvation to creation, since it would itself need salvation. To address this situation, God sends His own Son, who becomes Son of Man by taking created flesh. Since all were under sentence of death, He—being different from all of them—could offer His own body to death on behalf of all. In this way, as if all had died through Him, the words of that sentence would be fulfilled (for 'all died' in Christ), and all through Him could then become free from sin and from the curse that came with it, and could truly remain forever, risen from the dead and clothed in immortality and incorruption. For when the Word was clothed in flesh, as has been explained many times, every bite of the serpent began to be completely removed from it. Whatever evil sprang from the movements of the flesh was cut away, and along with these, death—the companion of sin—was also abolished. As the Lord Himself says, 'The prince of this world comes and finds nothing in Me,' and 'For this purpose He was manifested,' as John wrote, 'that He might destroy the works of the devil.' With these things destroyed from the flesh, we all were freed by our kinship with the flesh, and from then on we—even we—were joined to the Word. Being joined to God, we no longer remain on earth. As He Himself said, where He is, there we shall be also. From now on we no longer fear the serpent, for he was brought to nothing when he was confronted by the Savior in the flesh and heard Him say, 'Get behind Me, Satan,' and thus he is cast out of paradise into eternal fire. Nor do we need to guard against woman deceiving us, for 'in the resurrection they neither marry nor are given in marriage, but are as the Angels,' and in Christ Jesus there shall be 'a new creation,' and 'neither male nor female, but all and in all Christ.' And where Christ is, what fear or danger can still occur?

69. Again, if the Son were a creature, man had remained mortal as before, not being joined to God; for a creature had not joined creatures to God, as seeking itself one to join it; nor would a portion of the creation have been the creation's salvation, as needing salvation itself. To provide against this also, He sends His own Son, and He becomes Son of Man, by taking created flesh; that, since all were under sentence of death, He, being other than them all, might Himself for all offer to death His own body; and that henceforth, as if all had died through Him, the word of that sentence might be accomplished (for 'all died 2 Corinthians 5:14 ' in Christ), and all through Him might thereupon become free from sin and from the curse which came upon it, and might truly abide for ever, risen from the dead and clothed in immortality and incorruption. For the Word being clothed in the flesh, as has many times been explained, every bite of the serpent began to be utterly staunched from out it; and whatever evil sprung from the motions of the flesh, to be cut away, and with these death also was abolished, the companion of sin, as the Lord Himself says, 'The prince of this world comes, and finds nothing in Me;' and 'For this end was He manifested,' as John has written, 'that He might destroy the works of the devil 1 John 3:8.' And these being destroyed from the flesh, we all were thus liberated by the kinship of the flesh, and for the future were joined, even we, to the Word. And being joined to God, no longer do we abide upon earth; but, as He Himself has said, where He is, there shall we be also; and henceforward we shall fear no longer the serpent, for he was brought to nought when he was assailed by the Saviour in the flesh, and heard Him say, 'Get behind Me, Satan Matthew 16:23,' and thus he is cast out of paradise into the eternal fire. Nor shall we have to watch against woman beguiling us, for 'in the resurrection they neither marry nor are given in marriage, but are as the Angels Mark 12:25;' and in Christ Jesus it shall be 'a new creation,' and 'neither male nor female, but all and in all Christ;' and where Christ is, what fear, what danger can still happen?

But this would not have happened if the Word had been a creature. If He were a creature, the devil, who is himself a creature, would have continued the battle forever, and humanity, caught between the two, would have remained in constant danger of death, having no one in whom and through whom they could be joined to God and delivered from all fear. The truth shows us that the Word is not one of the created things, but is rather their Creator. This is why He took on a created human body—so that as its Creator, He might renew it and deify it in Himself, and in this way bring all of us into the kingdom of heaven according to His likeness. Humanity could not have been deified if joined to a creature, or unless the Son were truly God. Nor could humanity have been brought into the Father's presence unless He had been His natural and true Word who took on a body. Just as we would not have been delivered from sin and the curse unless it had been truly human flesh by nature that the Word took on (since we would have had nothing in common with something foreign to us), so also humanity could not have been deified unless the Word who became flesh had been by nature from the Father and truly proper to Him. This is why the union was of this kind—so that He might unite what is human by nature to Him who is divine by nature, and so that our salvation and deification might be secure. Therefore, let those who deny that the Son is from the Father by nature and proper to His ousia also deny that He took true human flesh from Mary Ever-Virgin. In neither case would it have benefited us if the Word were not truly and naturally the Son of God, or if the flesh He assumed were not real. But He did take true flesh, even though Valentinus raves otherwise. Yes, the Word was by nature truly God, even though the Arian maniacs rave otherwise. And in that flesh the beginning of our new creation has taken place, with Him being created as a human being for our sake and making for us that new way, as has been said.

70. But this would not have come to pass, had the Word been a creature; for with a creature, the devil, himself a creature, would have ever continued the battle, and man, being between the two, had been ever in peril of death, having none in whom and through whom he might be joined to God and delivered from all fear. Whence the truth shows us that the Word is not of things originate, but rather Himself their Framer. For therefore did He assume the body originate and human, that having renewed it as its Framer, He might deify it in Himself, and thus might introduce us all into the kingdom of heaven after His likeness. For man had not been deified if joined to a creature, or unless the Son were very God; nor had man been brought into the Father's presence, unless He had been His natural and true Word who had put on the body. And as we had not been delivered from sin and the curse, unless it had been by nature human flesh, which the Word put on (for we should have had nothing common with what was foreign), so also the man had not been deified, unless the Word who became flesh had been by nature from the Father and true and proper to Him. For therefore the union was of this kind, that He might unite what is man by nature to Him who is in the nature of the Godhead, and his salvation and deification might be sure. Therefore let those who deny that the Son is from the Father by nature and proper to His Essence, deny also that He took true human flesh of Mary Ever-Virgin; for in neither case had it been of profit to us men, whether the Word were not true and naturally Son of God, or the flesh not true which He assumed. But surely He took true flesh, though Valentinus rave; yea the Word was by nature Very God, though Ario-maniacs rave; and in that flesh has come to pass the beginning of our new creation, He being created man for our sake, and having made for us that new way, as has been said.

The Word is neither a creature nor a work, for creature, thing made, and work all mean the same thing. If He were a creature and thing made, He would also be a work. Therefore, He did not say "He created Me as a work" or "He made Me with the works," to avoid appearing to be a creature by nature and ousia. Nor did He say "He created Me to make works," to prevent the irreligious from wrongly claiming He is merely an instrument made for our benefit. He also did not say "He created Me before the works," because although He truly exists before all things as an Offspring, if He had been created before the works, "Offspring" and "He created" would mean the same thing. Instead, He said with precise distinction "for the works," meaning "The Father has made Me into flesh so that I might be man," which again demonstrates that He is not a work but an offspring. Just as someone who enters a house is not part of the house but different from it, so He who is created for the works must by physis be different from the works. But if it were otherwise, as you Arians claim, and the Word of God were a work, by what Hand and Wisdom did He Himself come into being? For all things that came to be came by the Hand and Wisdom of God, who Himself says, "My hand has made all these things," and David says in the Psalm, "And You, Lord, in the beginning laid the foundations of the earth, and the heavens are the work of Your hands," and again in the one hundred forty-second Psalm, "I remember the time past, I meditate on all Your works, yes I reflect on the works of Your hands." Therefore, if the works are made by the Hand of God, and it is written that "all things were made through the Word," and "without Him was not made one thing," and again, "One Lord Jesus, through whom are all things," and "in Him all things consist," it is very clear that the Son cannot be a work, but He is the Hand of God and the Wisdom. Knowing this, the martyrs in Babylon—Ananias, Azarias, and Misael—condemn Arian irreligion. For when they say, "O all you works of the Lord, bless the Lord," they list things in heaven, things on earth, and the whole creation as works, but they do not name the Son. They do not say, "Bless, O Word, and praise, O Wisdom," to show that all other things both praise and are works, but the Word is not a work nor among those that praise. Rather, He is praised with the Father and worshipped and confessed as God, being His Word and Wisdom and the Maker of the works. The Spirit has declared this in the Psalms with a most fitting distinction: "the Word of the Lord is true, and all His works are faithful," and in another Psalm He says, "O Lord, how manifold are Your works! In Wisdom You have made them all."

71. The Word then is neither creature nor work; for creature, thing made, work, are all one; and were He creature and thing made, He would also be work. Accordingly He has not said, 'He created Me a work,' nor 'He made Me with the works,' lest He should appear to be in nature and essence a creature; nor, 'He created Me to make works,' lest, on the other hand, according to the perverseness of the irreligious, He should seem as an instrument made for our sake. Nor again has He declared, 'He created Me before the works,' lest, as He really is before all, as an Offspring, so, if created also before the works, He should give 'Offspring' and 'He created' the same meaning. But He has said with exact discrimination, 'for the works;' as much as to say, 'The Father has made Me, into flesh, that I might be man,' which again shows that He is not a work but an offspring. For as he who comes into a house, is not part of the house, but is other than the house, so He who is created for the works, must be by nature other than the works. But if otherwise, as you hold, O Arians, the Word of God be a work, by what Hand and Wisdom did He Himself come into being? For all things that came to be, came by the Hand and Wisdom of God, who Himself says, 'My hand has made all these things Isaiah 66:2;' and David says in the Psalm, 'And You, Lord, in the beginning hast laid the foundations of the earth, and the heavens are the work of Your hands;' and again, in the hundred and forty-second Psalm, 'I do remember the time past, I muse upon all Your works, yea I exercise myself in the works of Your hands.' Therefore if by the Hand of God the works are wrought, and it is written that 'all things were made through the Word,' and 'without Him was not made one thing John 1:3,' and again, 'One Lord Jesus, through whom are all things 1 Corinthians 8:9,' and 'in Him all things consist Colossians 1:17,' it is very plain that the Son cannot be a work, but He is the Hand of God and the Wisdom. This knowing, the martyrs in Babylon, Ananias, Azarias, and Misael, arraign the Arian irreligion. For when they say, 'O all you works of the Lord, bless ye the Lord,' they recount things in heaven, things on earth, and the whole creation, as works; but the Son they name not. For they say not, 'Bless, O Word, and praise, O Wisdom;' to show that all other things are both praising and are works; but the Word is not a work nor of those that praise, but is praised with the Father and worshipped and confessed as God, being His Word and Wisdom, and of the works the Framer. This too the Spirit has declared in the Psalms with a most apposite distinction, 'the Word of the Lord is true, and all His works are faithful;' as in another Psalm too He says, 'O Lord, how manifold are Your works! In Wisdom have You made them all. '

But if the Word were a work, then He certainly would have been made in Wisdom just like everything else; nor would Scripture distinguish Him from the works, nor would it preach Him as Word and own Wisdom of God while calling the others works. But as it is, by distinguishing Him from the works, Scripture shows that Wisdom is the Maker of the works, not Himself a work. Paul also observes this distinction when writing to the Hebrews: "The Word of God is quick and powerful, and sharper than any two-edged sword, reaching even to the dividing of soul and spirit, joints and marrow, and a discerner of the thoughts and intents of the heart, neither is there any creature hidden before Him, but all things are naked and open unto the eyes of Him with whom is our account." Notice that he calls created things "creature," but he recognizes the Son as the Word of God, as if He were different from the creatures. And when he says, "All things are naked and open to the eyes of Him with whom is our account," he indicates that He is different from all of them. For this is why He judges, while each created thing must give account to Him. Likewise, when the whole creation groans together with us in order to be set free from the bondage of corruption, the Son is shown to be different from the creatures. For if He were a creature, He too would be one of those who groan, and would need someone to bring adoption and deliverance to Himself as well as to others. But the whole creation groans together for freedom from the bondage of corruption, while the Son is not among those who groan or who need freedom. Rather, He is the one who gives sonship and freedom to all, saying to the Jews of His time, "The servant remains not in the house forever, but the Son remains forever; if then the Son shall make you free, you shall be free indeed." From these considerations it is clearer than light that the Word of God is not a creature but the true Son, genuine by nature, of the Father. Concerning "The Lord has created me a beginning of the ways," I think this is sufficient, though in few words, to provide material for the learned to frame fuller refutations of the Arian heresy.

72. But if the Word were a work, then certainly He as others had been made in Wisdom; nor would Scripture distinguish Him from the works, nor while it named them works, preach Him as Word and own Wisdom of God. But, as it is, distinguishing Him from the works, He shows that Wisdom is Framer of the works, and not a work. This distinction Paul also observes, writing to the Hebrews, 'The Word of God is quick and powerful, and sharper than any two-edged sword, reaching even to the dividing of soul and spirit, joints and marrow, and a discerner of the thoughts and intents of the heart, neither is there any creature hidden before Him, but all things are naked and open unto the eyes of Him with whom is our account Hebrews 4:12-13.' For behold he calls things originate 'creature;' but the Son he recognises as the Word of God, as if He were other than the creatures. And again saying, 'All things are naked and open to the eyes of Him with whom is our account,' he signifies that He is other than all of them. For hence it is that He judges, but each of all things originate is bound to give account to Him. And so also, when the whole creation is groaning together with us in order to be set free from the bondage of corruption, the Son is thereby shown to be other than the creatures. For if He were creature, He too would be one of those who groan, and would need one who should bring adoption and deliverance to Himself as well as others. But if the whole creation groans together, for the sake of freedom from the bondage of corruption, whereas the Son is not of those that groan nor of those who need freedom, but He it is who gives sonship and freedom to all, saying to the Jews of His time, 'The servant remains not in the house for ever, but the Son remains for ever; if then the Son shall make you free, you shall be free indeed John 8:35-36;' it is clearer than the light from these considerations also, that the Word of God is not a creature but true Son, and by nature genuine, of the Father. Concerning then 'The Lord has created me a beginning of the ways,' this is sufficient, as I think, though in few words, to afford matter to the learned to frame more ample refutations of the Arian heresy.

Chapter 22. Texts Explained; Sixthly, the Context of Proverbs 8:22, and application of it to created Wisdom as seen in the works. The Son reveals the Father, first by the works, then by the Incarnation.

Since the heretics read the next verse and take a distorted view of it as well—because it is written, "He founded me before the world" (Proverbs 8:23)—claiming that this refers to the Godhead of the Word and not to His incarnate presence, it is necessary to explain this verse also and expose their error.

But since the heretics, reading the next verse, take a perverse view of that also, because it is written, 'He founded me before the world Proverbs 8:23,' namely, that this is said of the Godhead of the Word and not of His incarnate Presence, it is necessary, explaining this verse also, to show their error.

It is written, "The Lord in Wisdom founded the earth" (Proverbs 3:19). If the earth is founded by Wisdom, how can the one who founds be himself founded? No, this too is said in the manner of proverbs, and we must investigate its meaning in the same way. We need to understand that while the Father frames and founds the earth to be firm and steadfast by Wisdom, Wisdom itself is founded for us so that it may become the beginning and foundation of our new creation and renewal. Therefore, here as before, he does not say, "Before the world he made me Word or Son," to avoid implying some kind of beginning to his making. We must seek this above all things—whether he is Son—and on this point especially search the Scriptures. This was the issue when the apostles were questioned and Peter answered, saying, "You are the Christ, the Son of the Living God" (Matthew 16:16). The father of the Arian heresy also asked this as one of his first questions: "If you are the Son of God" (Matthew 4:3), for he knew that this is the truth and the ruling principle of our faith. He knew that if Christ were himself the Son, the devil's tyranny would come to an end, but if he were a creature, he too would be one of those descended from the Adam whom the devil had deceived, and the devil would have no reason for concern. For the same reason the Jews of that day were angered because the Lord said he was Son of God and that God was his own Father. If he had called himself one of the creatures or said, "I am a work," they would not have been startled by this statement nor considered such words blasphemy, since they knew that even angels had come among their fathers. But because he called himself Son, they recognized that this was not the characteristic of a creature, but of Godhead and of the Father's nature (physis). The Arians then ought, even following the example of their own father the devil, to take special care on this point. If he had said, "He founded me to be Word or Son," then they could think as they do. But since he has not spoken this way, they should not invent for themselves what is not there.

73. It is written, 'The Lord in Wisdom founded the earth Proverbs 3:19;' if then by Wisdom the earth is founded, how can He who founds be founded? Nay, this too is said after the manner of proverbs, and we must in like manner investigate its sense; that we may know that, while by Wisdom the Father frames and founds the earth to be firm and steadfast, Wisdom Itself is founded for us, that It may become beginning and foundation of our new creation and renewal. Accordingly here as before, He says not, 'Before the world He has made me Word or Son,' lest there should be as it were a beginning of His making. For this we must seek before all things, whether He is Son, 'and on this point specially search the Scriptures;' for this it was, when the Apostles were questioned, that Peter answered, saying, 'You are the Christ, the Son of the Living God Matthew 16:16.' This also the father of the Arian heresy asked as one of his first questions; 'If Thou be the Son of God Matthew 4:3;' for he knew that this is the truth and the sovereign principle of our faith; and that, if He were Himself the Son, the tyranny of the devil would have its end; but if He were a creature, He too was one of those descended from that Adam whom he deceived, and he had no cause for anxiety. For the same reason the Jews of the day were angered, because the Lord said that He was Son of God, and that God was His proper Father. For had He called Himself one of the creatures, or said, 'I am a work,' they had not been startled at the intelligence, nor thought such words blasphemy, knowing, as they did, that even Angels had come among their fathers; but since He called Himself Son, they perceived that such was not the note of a creature, but of Godhead and of the Father's nature. The Arians then ought, even in imitation of their own father the devil, to take some special pains on this point; and if He has said, 'He founded me to be Word or Son,' then to think as they do; but if He has not so spoken, not to invent for themselves what is not.

He does not say, "Before the world He founded me as Word or Son," but simply, "He founded me," to show again, as I have said, that He speaks here not for His own sake but for those who are built upon Him, in keeping with the way of proverbs. Understanding this, the Apostle also writes, "No one can lay any foundation other than the one already laid, which is Jesus Christ; but let everyone be careful how they build on it." The foundation must be suited to the things built upon it, so they can be properly joined together. Being the Word, He has no one like Himself who could be joined with Him as Word, for He is Only-begotten. But having become man, He has those who are like Him—namely, those whose flesh He has taken on. Therefore, according to His humanity He is founded, so that we, like precious stones, may be built upon Him and become a temple of the Holy Spirit who dwells in us. Just as He is a foundation and we are stones built upon Him, so He is a Vine and we are joined to Him as branches—not according to the essence of the Godhead, for this is surely impossible, but according to His humanity, for the branches must be like the vine, since we are like Him according to the flesh. Moreover, since the heretics have such human notions, we may fittingly refute them with human comparisons contained in the very matter they raise. Thus He does not say, "He made me a foundation," lest He might seem to be made and to have a beginning of existence, and they might find from this a shameless opportunity for irreligion. Instead, He says, "He founded me." Now what is founded is founded for the sake of the stones placed upon it. This is not a random process—first a stone is moved from the mountain and set down in the depths of the earth. While a stone is still in the mountain, it is not yet founded; but when the need arises and it is moved and laid in the depths of the earth, then immediately, if the stone could speak, it would say, "He has now founded me, who brought me here from the mountain." Therefore the Lord also did not receive a beginning of existence when He was founded, for He was the Word before that. But when He put on our body, which He took and separated from Mary, then He says, "He has founded me"—as if to say, "Me, being the Word, He has clothed in an earthly body." For He is founded in this way for our sake, taking on what is ours, so that we, being incorporated and joined together and united in Him through the likeness of the flesh, may reach full maturity as human beings and remain immortal and incorruptible.

74. For He says not, 'Before the world He founded me as Word or Son,' but simply, 'He founded me,' to show again, as I have said, that not for His own sake but for those who are built upon Him does He here also speak, after the way of proverbs. For this knowing, the Apostle also writes, 'Other foundation can no man lay than that is laid, which is Jesus Christ; but let every man take heed how he builds thereupon.' And it must be that the foundation should be such as the things built on it, that they may admit of being well compacted together. Being then the Word, He has not, as Word, any such as Himself, who may be compacted with Him; for He is Only-begotten; but having become man, He has the like of Him, those namely the likeness of whose flesh He has put on. Therefore according to His manhood He is founded, that we, as precious stones, may admit of building upon Him, and may become a temple of the Holy Ghost who dwells in us. And as He is a foundation, and we stones built upon Him, so again He is a Vine and we knit to Him as branches — not according to the Essence of the Godhead; for this surely is impossible; but according to His manhood, for the branches must be like the vine, since we are like Him according to the flesh. Moreover, since the heretics have such human notions, we may suitably confute them with human resemblances contained in the very matter they urge. Thus He says not, 'He made me a foundation,' lest He might seem to be made and to have a beginning of being, and they might thence find a shameless occasion of irreligion; but, 'He founded me.' Now what is founded is founded for the sake of the stones which are raised upon it; it is not a random process, but a stone is first transported from the mountain and set down in the depth of the earth. And while a stone is in the mountain, it is not yet founded; but when need demands, and it is transported, and laid in the depth of the earth, then immediately if the stone could speak, it would say, 'He now founded me, who brought me hither from the mountain.' Therefore the Lord also did not when founded take a beginning of existence; for He was the Word before that; but when He put on our body, which He severed and took from Mary, then He says 'He has founded me;' as much as to say, 'Me, being the Word, He has enveloped in a body of earth.' For so He is founded for our sakes, taking on Him what is ours, that we, as incorporated and compacted and bound together in Him through the likeness of the flesh, may attain unto a perfect man, and abide immortal and incorruptible.

Don't let the phrases "before the world" and "before He made the earth" and "before the mountains were settled" trouble anyone, for they fit perfectly well with "founded" and "created." Here again, reference is being made to the Economy according to the flesh. For although the grace that came to us from the Savior appeared, as the Apostle says, just recently and came when He dwelt among us, this grace had actually been prepared even before we came into existence—indeed, before the foundation of the world. The reason for this is both kind and wonderful. It would not have been fitting for God to make plans concerning us only afterward, or else He would appear ignorant of our destiny. The God of all, then—creating us by His own Word and knowing our destinies better than we do ourselves, and foreseeing that though made "good" we would eventually transgress the commandment and be cast out of paradise for disobedience—being loving and kind, prepared beforehand in His own Word (by whom He also created us) the Economy of our salvation. This was so that even though we fell from Him through the serpent's deception, we would not remain completely dead. Rather, having in the Word the redemption and salvation that was prepared for us ahead of time, we might rise again and remain immortal, when He should have been created for us as "a beginning of the ways," and He who was the "First-born of creation" should become "firstborn" of the "brethren," and again should rise as "first-fruits of the dead." Paul the blessed Apostle teaches this in his writings. As an interpretation of the words from Proverbs "before the world" and "before the earth was," he speaks to Timothy this way: "Be partaker of the afflictions of the Gospel according to the power of God, who has saved us and called us with a holy calling, not according to our works, but according to His own purpose and grace, which was given us in Christ Jesus before the world began, but is now made manifest by the appearing of our Savior Jesus Christ, who has abolished death, and brought to light life." And to the Ephesians: "Blessed be God even the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us with all spiritual blessing in heavenly places in Christ Jesus, according as He has chosen us in Him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and without blame before Him in love, having predestinated us to the adoption of children by Jesus Christ to Himself."

75. Nor let the words 'before the world' and 'before He made the earth' and 'before the mountains were settled' disturb any one; for they very well accord with 'founded' and 'created;' for here again allusion is made to the Economy according to the flesh. For though the grace which came to us from the Saviour appeared, as the Apostle says, just now, and has come when He sojourned among us; yet this grace had been prepared even before we came into being, nay, before the foundation of the world, and the reason why is kindly and wonderful. It beseemed not that God should counsel concerning us afterwards, lest He should appear ignorant of our fate. The God of all then — creating us by His own Word, and knowing our destinies better than we, and foreseeing that, being made 'good Genesis 1:31,' we should in the event be transgressors of the commandment, and be thrust out of paradise for disobedience — being loving and kind, prepared beforehand in His own Word, by whom also He created us, the Economy of our salvation; that though by the serpent's deceit we fell from Him, we might not remain quite dead, but having in the Word the redemption and salvation which was afore prepared for us, we might rise again and abide immortal, what time He should have been created for us 'a beginning of the ways,' and He who was the 'First-born of creation' should become ' first-born ' of the 'brethren,' and again should rise ' first-fruits of the dead.' This Paul the blessed Apostle teaches in his writings; for, as interpreting the words of the Proverbs 'before the world' and 'before the earth was,' he thus speaks to Timothy; 'Be partaker of the afflictions of the Gospel according to the power of God, who has saved us and called us with a holy calling, not according to our works, but according to His own purpose and grace, which was given us in Christ Jesus before the world began, but is now made manifest by the appearing of our Saviour Jesus Christ, who has abolished death, and brought to light life 2 Timothy 1:8-10.' And to the Ephesians; 'Blessed be God even the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us with all spiritual blessing in heavenly places in Christ Jesus, according as He has chosen us in Him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and without blame before Him in love, having predestinated us to the adoption of children by Jesus Christ to Himself Ephesians 1:3-5.'

How then has He chosen us before we came into existence, except that, as he says himself, we were represented beforehand in Him? And how could He have predestined us to adoption before humans were created, except that the Son Himself was 'founded before the world,' taking upon Himself that economy which was for our sake? Or how, as the Apostle goes on to say, do we 'have an inheritance being predestined,' except that the Lord Himself was founded 'before the world,' since He had a purpose, for our sakes, to take upon Himself through the flesh all that inheritance of judgment which lay against us, and we thereafter were made sons in Him? And how did we receive it 'before the world was,' when we were not yet in being, but afterwards in time, except that the grace which has reached us was stored in Christ? Therefore also in the Judgment, when everyone shall receive according to his conduct, He says, 'Come, you blessed of My Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world.' How then, or in whom, was it prepared before we came to be, except in the Lord who 'before the world' was founded for this purpose—that we, as built upon Him, might partake, as well-fitted stones, the life and grace which is from Him? And this took place, as naturally suggests itself to the religious mind, so that, as I said, we, rising after our brief death, may be capable of an eternal life, of which we would not have been capable, humans as we are, formed of earth, except that 'before the world' there had been prepared for us in Christ the hope of life and salvation. Therefore there is reason that the Word, on coming into our flesh, and being created in it as 'a beginning of ways for His works,' is laid as a foundation according as the Father's will was in Him before the world, as has been said, and before land was, and before the mountains were settled, and before the fountains burst forth—so that, though the earth and the mountains and the shapes of visible nature pass away in the fullness of the present age, we on the contrary may not grow old after their pattern, but may be able to live after them, having the spiritual life and blessing which before these things have been prepared for us in the Word Himself according to election. For thus we shall be capable of a life not temporary, but ever afterwards abide and live in Christ; since even before this our life had been founded and prepared in Christ Jesus.

76. How then has He chosen us, before we came into existence, but that, as he says himself, in Him we were represented beforehand? And how at all, before men were created, did He predestinate us unto adoption, but that the Son Himself was 'founded before the world,' taking on Him that economy which was for our sake? Or how, as the Apostle goes on to say, have we 'an inheritance being predestinated,' but that the Lord Himself was founded 'before the world,' inasmuch as He had a purpose, for our sakes, to take on Him through the flesh all that inheritance of judgment which lay against us, and we henceforth were made sons in Him? And how did we receive it 'before the world was,' when we were not yet in being, but afterwards in time, but that in Christ was stored the grace which has reached us? Wherefore also in the Judgment, when every one shall receive according to his conduct, He says, 'Come, you blessed of My Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world Matthew 25:34.' How then, or in whom, was it prepared before we came to be, save in the Lord who 'before the world' was founded for this purpose; that we, as built upon Him, might partake, as well-compacted stones, the life and grace which is from Him? And this took place, as naturally suggests itself to the religious mind, that, as I said, we, rising after our brief death, may be capable of an eternal life, of which we had not been capable, men as we are, formed of earth, but that 'before the world' there had been prepared for us in Christ the hope of life and salvation. Therefore reason is there that the Word, on coming into our flesh, and being created in it as 'a beginning of ways for His works,' is laid as a foundation according as the Father's will was in Him before the world, as has been said, and before land was, and before the mountains were settled, and before the fountains burst forth; that, though the earth and the mountains and the shapes of visible nature pass away in the fullness of the present age, we on the contrary may not grow old after their pattern, but may be able to live after them, having the spiritual life and blessing which before these things have been prepared for us in the Word Himself according to election. For thus we shall be capable of a life not temporary, but ever afterwards abide and live in Christ; since even before this our life had been founded and prepared in Christ Jesus.

Nor could our life have been established in any other way except in the Lord who exists before the ages, and through whom the ages came into being. This way, since our life was established in Him, we too can inherit eternal life. For God is good, and being always good, He willed this, knowing that our weak nature needed the help and salvation that comes from Him. Just as a wise architect planning to build a house also plans for its repair, should it ever become damaged after construction, and in planning for this prepares and provides materials for repair to the workers—so the means of repair are provided before the house itself—in the same way, the repair of our salvation was established in Christ before we existed, so that in Him we might be newly created. The will and purpose were made ready before the world, but they took effect when the need arose and the Savior came among us. For the Lord Himself will be everything we need in heaven when He receives us into eternal life. This is sufficient to prove that the Word of God is not a creature, and that the meaning of the passage is correct. But since that passage, when examined closely, has a right meaning from every perspective, it is worth explaining what that meaning is—perhaps many words will bring these foolish men to shame. Here I must return to what was said before, for what I have to say concerns the same proverb and the same Wisdom. The Word has not called Himself a creature by nature, but has said in proverbs, "The Lord created me," and He clearly indicates a meaning that is not stated plainly but is hidden, which we can discover by removing the veil from the proverb. For who, upon hearing from the creative Wisdom, "The Lord created me a beginning of His ways," does not immediately question the meaning, wondering how the creative Wisdom can be created? Who, upon hearing the Only-begotten Son of God say that He was created "a beginning of ways," does not investigate the meaning, wondering how the Only-begotten Son can become a beginning of many others? For it is a dark saying, but "a man of understanding," he says, "shall understand a proverb and the interpretation, the words of the wise and their dark sayings."

77. Nor in any other way was it fitting that our life should be founded, but in the Lord who is before the ages, and through whom the ages were brought to be; that, since it was in Him, we too might be able to inherit that everlasting life. For God is good; and being good always, He willed this, as knowing that our weak nature needed the succour and salvation which is from Him. And as a wise architect, proposing to build a house, consults also about repairing it, should it at any time become dilapidated after building, and, as counselling about this, makes preparation and gives to the workmen materials for a repair; and thus the means of the repair are provided before the house; in the same way prior to us is the repair of our salvation founded in Christ, that in Him we might even be new-created. And the will and the purpose were made ready 'before the world,' but have taken effect when the need required, and the Saviour came among us. For the Lord Himself will stand us in place of all things in the heavens, when He receives us into everlasting life. This then suffices to prove that the Word of God is not a creature, but that the sense of the passage is right. But since that passage, when scrutinized, has a right sense in every point of view, it may be well to state what it is; perhaps many words may bring these senseless men to shame. Now here I must recur to what has been said before, for what I have to say relates to the same proverb and the same Wisdom. The Word has not called Himself a creature by nature, but has said in proverbs, 'The Lord created me;' and He plainly indicates a sense not spoken 'plainly' but latent, such as we shall be able to find by taking away the veil from the proverb. For who, on hearing from the Framing Wisdom, 'The Lord created me a beginning of His ways,' does not at once question the meaning, reflecting how that creative Wisdom can be created? Who on hearing the Only-begotten Son of God say, that He was created 'a beginning of ways,' does not investigate the sense, wondering how the Only-begotten Son can become a Beginning of many others? For it is a dark saying; but 'a man of understanding,' says he, 'shall understand a proverb and the interpretation, the words of the wise and their dark sayings Proverbs 1:5-6.'

Now the Only-begotten and very Wisdom of God is Creator and Framer of all things. As Scripture says, "in Wisdom have You made them all," and "the earth is full of Your creation." But so that what came into being might not only exist but be good, it pleased God that His own Wisdom should condescend to the creatures in order to introduce an imprint and likeness of Its Image on all things in common and on each individually, so that what was made might be manifestly wise works and worthy of God. For just as our word is an image of the Son of God considered as the Word, so the wisdom that is implanted in us is an image of the same Son considered as Wisdom. In this wisdom we, having the power of knowledge and thought, become recipients of the All-framing Wisdom, and through It we are able to know Its Father. For as He says, "he who has the Son has the Father also," and "he that receives Me receives Him that sent Me." Since such an imprint of Wisdom is created in us and is in all the works, the true and framing Wisdom rightly takes to Itself what belongs to its own imprint and says, "The Lord created me for His works." For what the wisdom in us says, the Lord Himself speaks as if it were His own. And though He is not Himself created, being Creator, yet because of the image of Him created in the works, He says this as if of Himself. And just as the Lord Himself has said, "He that receives you receives Me," because His imprint is in us, so though He is not among the creatures, yet because His image and imprint is created in the works, He says as if in His own person, "The Lord created me a beginning of His ways for His works." And this is why this imprint of Wisdom in the works has been brought into being: so that, as I said before, the world might recognize in it its own Creator the Word, and through Him the Father. And this is what Paul said: "Because that which may be known of God is manifest in them, for God has showed it unto them, for the invisible things of Him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made." But if this is so, the Word is not a creature in essence. Rather, the wisdom which is in us and so called is what is spoken of in this passage in the Proverbs.

78. Now the Only-begotten and very Wisdom of God is Creator and Framer of all things; for 'in Wisdom have You made them all,' he says, and 'the earth is full of Your creation.' But that what came into being might not only be, but be good, it pleased God that His own Wisdom should condescend to the creatures, so as to introduce an impress and semblance of Its Image on all in common and on each, that what was made might be manifestly wise works and worthy of God. For as of the Son of God, considered as the Word, our word is an image, so of the same Son considered as Wisdom is the wisdom which is implanted in us an image; in which wisdom we, having the power of knowledge and thought, become recipients of the All-framing Wisdom; and through It we are able to know Its Father. 'For he who has the Son,' says He, 'has the Father also;' and 'he that receives Me, receives Him that sent Me.' Such an impress then of Wisdom being created in us, and being in all the works, with reason does the true and framing Wisdom take to Itself what belongs to its own impress, and say, 'The Lord created me for His works;' for what the wisdom in us says, that the Lord Himself speaks as if it were His own; and, whereas He is not Himself created, being Creator, yet because of the image of Him created in the works, He says this as if of Himself. And as the Lord Himself has said, 'He that receives you, receives Me Matthew 10:40,' because His impress is in us, so, though He be not among the creatures, yet because His image and impress is created in the works, He says, as if in His own person, 'The Lord created me a beginning of His ways for His works.' And therefore has this impress of Wisdom in the works been brought into being, that, as I said before, the world might recognise in it its own Creator the Word, and through Him the Father. And this is what Paul said, 'Because that which may be known of God is manifest in them, for God has showed it unto them: for the invisible things of Him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made Romans 1:19-20.' But if so, the Word is not a creature in essence; but the wisdom which is in us and so called, is spoken of in this passage in the Proverbs.

If this still does not persuade them, let them answer this question themselves: is there wisdom in the creatures or not? If not, then how can the Apostle complain, "For after that in the Wisdom of God the world by wisdom knew not God"? And how, if there is no wisdom, does Scripture mention many wise men? For "a wise man fears and departs from evil," and "through wisdom is a house built," and the Preacher says, "A man's wisdom makes his face to shine." He also criticizes those who are reckless, saying, "Say not, what is the cause that the former days were better than these? For you do not inquire in wisdom concerning this." But if, as the Son of Sirach says, "He poured her out upon all His works; she is with all flesh according to His gift, and He has given her to them that love Him," and this pouring out refers not to the Essence of the Very Wisdom and Only-begotten, but to that wisdom which is imaged in the world, then why is it unbelievable that the All-framing and true Wisdom Itself, whose impress is the wisdom and knowledge poured out in the world, should say, as I have already explained, as if speaking of Itself, "The Lord created me for His works"? For the wisdom in the world is not creative, but is that which is created in the works, according to which "the heavens declare the glory of God, and the firmament shows His handywork." If people have this within them, they will acknowledge the true Wisdom of God and will know that they are truly made after God's Image. Suppose a king's son, when his father wanted to build a city, had his own name printed on each of the works being constructed, both to secure the works by displaying his name on everything and to make people remember him and his father through the name. After the city was finished, if someone asked how it was made, he would answer, "It is made securely, for according to my father's will, I am imaged in each work, for my name was made in the works." In saying this, he does not mean that his own essence is created, but that he impressed himself through his name. In the same way, to apply this illustration, when people admire the wisdom in the creatures, the true Wisdom answers, "The Lord created me for the works," for my impress is in them, and I have thus condescended for the framing of all things.

79. But if this too fails to persuade them, let them tell us themselves, whether there is any wisdom in the creatures or not? If not how is it that the Apostle complains, 'For after that in the Wisdom of God the world by wisdom knew not God 1 Corinthians 1:21?' or how is it if there is no wisdom, that a 'multitude of wise men ' are found in Scripture? For 'a wise man fears and departs from evil Proverbs 14:16;' and 'through wisdom is a house built;' and the Preacher says, 'A man's wisdom makes his face to shine;' and he blames those who are headstrong thus, 'Say not thou, what is the cause that the former days were better than these? For thou dost not inquire in wisdom concerning this.' But if, as the Son of Sirach says, 'He poured her out upon all His works; she is with all flesh according to His gift, and He has given her to them that love Him Sirach 1:9-10,' and this outpouring is a note, not of the Essence of the Very Wisdom and Only-begotten, but of that wisdom which is imaged in the world, how is it incredible that the All-framing and true Wisdom Itself, whose impress is the wisdom and knowledge poured out in the world, should say, as I have already explained, as if of Itself, 'The Lord created me for His works?' For the wisdom in the world is not creative, but is that which is created in the works, according to which 'the heavens declare the glory of God, and the firmament shows His handywork.' This if men have within them, they will acknowledge the true Wisdom of God; and will know that they are made really after God's Image. And, as some son of a king, when the father wished to build a city, might cause his own name to be printed upon each of the works that were rising, both to give security to them of the works remaining, by reason of the show of his name on everything, and also to make them remember him and his father from the name, and having finished the city might be asked concerning it, how it was made, and then would answer, 'It is made securely, for according to the will of my father, I am imaged in each work, for my name was made in the works;' but saying this, he does not signify that his own essence is created, but the impress of himself by means of his name; in the same manner, to apply the illustration, to those who admire the wisdom in the creatures, the true Wisdom makes answer, 'The Lord created me for the works,' for my impress is in them; and I have thus condescended for the framing of all things.

Moreover, that the Son should speak of the impress that is within us as if it were Himself should not startle anyone, considering (for we must not shrink from repetition) that when Saul was persecuting the Church, in which was His impress and image, He said, as if He Himself were under persecution, "Saul, why do you persecute Me?" Therefore (as has been said), just as if the impress itself of Wisdom which is in the works had said, "The Lord created me for the works," no one would have been startled, so if He, the True and Framing Wisdom, the Only-begotten Word of God, should use what belongs to His image as about Himself, namely, "The Lord created me for the works," let no one, overlooking the wisdom created in the world and in the works, think that "He created" refers to the ousia of the Very Wisdom itself, lest, diluting the wine with water, he be judged a defrauder of the truth. For It is Creative and Framer, but Its impress is created in the works, as the copy of the image. And He says, "Beginning of ways," since such wisdom becomes a sort of beginning and, as it were, rudiments of the knowledge of God. For a man entering, as it were, upon this way first and keeping it in the fear of God (as Solomon says, "The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom"), then advancing upward in his thoughts and perceiving the Framing Wisdom which is in the creation, will perceive in It also Its Father, as the Lord Himself has said, "He that has seen Me, has seen the Father," and as John writes, "He who acknowledges the Son, has the Father also." And He says, "Before the world He founded me," since in Its impress the works remain settled and eternal. Then, lest anyone, hearing concerning the wisdom thus created in the works, should think the true Wisdom, God's Son, to be by nature a creature, He has found it necessary to add, "Before the mountains, and before the earth, and before the waters, and before all hills He begets me," so that in saying, "before every creature" (for He includes all creation under these heads), He may show that He is not created together with the works according to ousia. For if He was created "for the works," yet is before them, it follows that He exists before He was created. He is not then a creature by nature and ousia, but as He Himself has added, an Offspring. But how a creature differs from an offspring, and how it is distinct by nature, has been shown in what has gone before.

80. Moreover, that the Son should be speaking of the impress that is within us as if it were Himself, should not startle any one, considering (for we must not shrink from repetition) that, when Saul was persecuting the Church, in which was His impress and image, He said, as if He were Himself under persecution, 'Saul, why do you persecute Me Acts 9:4?' Therefore (as has been said), as, supposing the impress itself of Wisdom which is in the works had said, 'The Lord created me for the works,' no one would have been startled, so, if He, the True and Framing Wisdom, the Only-begotten Word of God, should use what belongs to His image as about Himself, namely, 'The Lord created me for the works,' let no one, overlooking the wisdom created in the world and in the works, think that 'He created' is said of the Substance of the Very Wisdom, lest, diluting the wine with water, he be judged a defrauder of the truth. For It is Creative and Framer; but Its impress is created in the works, as the copy of the image. And He says, 'Beginning of ways,' since such wisdom becomes a sort of beginning. and, as it were, rudiments of the knowledge of God; for a man entering, as it were, upon this way first, and keeping it in the fear of God (as Solomon says, 'The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom'), then advancing upwards in his thoughts and perceiving the Framing Wisdom which is in the creation, will perceive in It also Its Father, as the Lord Himself has said, 'He that has seen Me, has seen the Father,' and as John writes, 'He who acknowledges the Son, has the Father also.' And He says, 'Before the world He founded me,' since in Its impress the works remain settled and eternal. Then, lest any, hearing concerning the wisdom thus created in the works, should think the true Wisdom, God's Son, to be by nature a creature, He has found it necessary to add, 'Before the mountains, and before the earth, and before the waters, and before all hills He begets me,' that in saying, 'before every creature' (for He includes all the creation under these heads), He may show that He is not created together with the works according to Essence. For if He was created 'for the works,' yet is before them, it follows that He is in being before He was created. He is not then a creature by nature and essence, but as He Himself has added, an Offspring. But in what differs a creature from an offspring, and how it is distinct by nature, has been shown in what has gone before.

But since He proceeds to say, "When He prepared the heaven, I was present with Him," we ought to know that He does not say this as if the Father prepared the heaven or the clouds above without Wisdom (for there is no room to doubt that all things are created in Wisdom, and without It not even one thing was made). Rather, this is what He is saying: "All things took place in Me and through Me, and when there was a need for Wisdom to be created in the works, I was with the Father in My ousia, but by condescending to created things, I was arranging My own impress over the works, so that the whole world, being in one body, might not be at variance but in harmony with itself." All those then who, with an upright understanding according to the wisdom given to them, come to contemplate the creatures are able to say for themselves, "By Your appointment all things continue." But those who make light of this must be told, "Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools," for "that which may be known of God is manifest in them, for God has revealed it to them; for the invisible things of Him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being perceived by the things that are made, even His eternal Power and Godhead, so that they are without excuse. Because when they knew God, they did not glorify Him as God, but served the creature more than the Creator of all, who is blessed forever. Amen." And they will surely be shamed at hearing, "For after the world, in the wisdom of God (in the mode we have explained above), did not know God by wisdom, it pleased God by the foolishness of preaching to save those who believe." For no longer, as in former times, has God willed to be known by an image and shadow of wisdom—that is, the wisdom that is in the creatures—but He has made the true Wisdom Itself take flesh and become man and undergo the death of the cross, so that through faith in Him all who believe may henceforth obtain salvation. However, it is the same Wisdom of God which, through Its own Image in the creatures (which is why It is said to be created), first manifested Itself and through Itself Its own Father, and afterward, being Itself the Word, "became flesh," as John says, and after abolishing death and saving our race, revealed Himself even more fully, and through Him His own Father, saying, "Grant to them that they may know You, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom You have sent."

81. But since He proceeds to say, 'When He prepared the heaven, I was present with Him,' we ought to know that He says not this as if without Wisdom the Father prepared the heaven or the clouds above (for there is no room to doubt that all things are created in Wisdom, and without It was made not even one John 1:3 thing); but this is what He says, 'All things took place in Me and through Me, and when there was need that Wisdom should be created in the works, in My Essence indeed I was with the Father, but by a condescension to things originate, I was disposing over the works My own impress, so that the whole world as being in one body, might not be at variance but in concord with itself.' All those then who with an upright understanding, according to the wisdom given unto them, come to contemplate the creatures, are able to say for themselves, 'By Your appointment all things continue;' but they who make light of this must be told, 'Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools;' for 'that which may be known of God is manifest in them; for God has revealed it unto them; for the invisible things of Him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being perceived by the things that are made, even His eternal Power and Godhead, so that they are without excuse. Because that when they knew God, they glorified Him not as God, but served the creature more than the Creator of all, who is blessed forever. Amen.' And they will surely be shamed at hearing, 'For, after that in the wisdom of God (in the mode we have explained above), the world by wisdom knew not God, it pleased God by the foolishness of the preaching to save them that believe 1 Corinthians 1:21.' For no longer, as in the former times, God has willed to be known by an image and shadow of wisdom, that namely which is in the creatures, but He has made the true Wisdom Itself to take flesh, and to become man, and to undergo the death of the cross; that by the faith in Him, henceforth all that believe may obtain salvation. However, it is the same Wisdom of God, which through Its own Image in the creatures (whence also It is said to be created), first manifested Itself, and through Itself Its own Father; and afterwards, being Itself the Word, has 'become flesh John 1:14,' as John says, and after abolishing death and saving our race, still more revealed Himself and through Him His own Father, saying, 'Grant unto them that they may know You the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom You have sent. '

The entire earth is therefore filled with knowledge of Him, because the knowledge of the Father through the Son and of the Son from the Father is one and the same. The Father delights in Him, and the Son rejoices in the Father with the same joy, saying, "I was by Him, daily His delight, rejoicing always before Him." This again demonstrates that the Son is not foreign to the Father, but belongs to the Father's ousia. Look—He did not come into existence because of us, as the irreligious claim, nor is He out of nothing (for God did not obtain from outside Himself a cause for rejoicing). Rather, the words indicate what is His own and what is like Him. When was there ever a time when the Father did not rejoice? But if He always rejoiced, then the one in whom He rejoiced always existed. And in whom does the Father rejoice, except when seeing Himself in His own Image, which is His Word? And though He also delighted in the sons of men when He finished the world, as is written in these same Proverbs, even this has a consistent meaning. For even then He delighted not because joy was added to Him, but again because He saw the works made after His own Image—so that even this rejoicing of God is on account of His Image. And how does the Son have delight, except by seeing Himself in the Father? For this is the same as saying, "He who has seen Me has seen the Father," and "I am in the Father and the Father in Me." Your boasting is therefore useless, as is demonstrated from every angle, you enemies of Christ, and you paraded and circulated everywhere in vain your text, "The Lord created me a beginning of His ways," distorting its meaning and publishing not Solomon's meaning but your own interpretation. For look—your interpretation is proven to be merely a fantasy, but the passage in Proverbs, along with everything said above, proves that the Son is not a creature in nature and essence, but the proper Offspring of the Father, true Wisdom and Word, by whom "all things were made," and "without Him was made not one thing."

82. Hence the whole earth is filled with the knowledge of Him; for the knowledge of Father through Son and of Son from Father is one and the same, and the Father delights in Him, and in the same joy the Son rejoices in the Father, saying, 'I was by Him, daily His delight, rejoicing always before Him Proverbs 8:30.' And this again proves that the Son is not foreign, but proper to the Father's Essence. For behold, not because of us has He come to be, as the irreligious men say, nor is He out of nothing (for not from without did God procure for Himself a cause of rejoicing), but the words denote what is His own and like. When then was it, when the Father rejoiced not? But if He ever rejoiced, He was ever, in whom He rejoiced. And in whom does the Father rejoice, except as seeing Himself in His own Image, which is His Word? And though in sons of men also He had delight, on finishing the world, as it is written in these same Proverbs Proverbs 8:31, yet this too has a consistent sense. For even thus He had delight, not because joy was added to Him, but again on seeing the works made after His own Image; so that even this rejoicing of God is on account of His Image. And how too has the Son delight, except as seeing Himself in the Father? For this is the same as saying, 'He that has seen Me, has seen the Father,' and 'I am in the Father and the Father in Me John 14:9-10.' Vain then is your vaunt as is on all sides shown, O Christ's enemies, and vainly did ye parade and circulate everywhere your text, 'The Lord created me a beginning of His ways,' perverting its sense, and publishing, not Solomon's meaning, but your own comment. For behold your sense is proved to be but a fantasy; but the passage in the Proverbs, as well as all that is above said, proves that the Son is not a creature in nature and essence, but the proper Offspring of the Father, true Wisdom and Word, by whom 'all things were made,' and 'without Him was made not one thing. John 1:3 '


Four Discourses Against the Arians — Discourse I

Against Arius’ Thalia: the Son is eternal and of the Father’s own essence, not a creature; Philippians 2:9-10, Psalm 45:7 and Hebrews 1:4 explained.

Source: Translated by John Henry Newman and Archibald Robertson. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series , Vol. 4. Edited by Philip Schaff and Henry Wace. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1892. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/28161.htm>.

Contents · 13 chapters
  1. Chapter 1. Introduction. Reason for writing; certain personsindifferent about Arianism; Ariansnot Christians, because sectaries always take the name of their founder.
  2. Chapter 2. Extracts from the Thalia of Arius. Ariusmaintains that God became a Father, and the Son was not always; the Son out of nothing; once He was not; He was not before his generation; He was created; named Wisdom and Word after God's attributes; made that He might make us; one out of many powers of God; alterable; exalted on God's foreknowledge of what He was to be; not very God; but called so as others by participation; foreign in essence from the Father; does not knowor see the Father; does not knowHimself.
  3. Chapter 3. The Importance of the Subject. The Ariansaffect Scripture language, but their doctrine new, as well as unscriptural. Statement of the Catholic doctrine, that the Son is proper to the Father's substance, and eternal. Restatement of Arianismin contrast, that He is a creature with a beginning: the controversy comes to this issue, whether one whom we are to believein as God, can be so in name only, and is merely a creature. What pretence then for being indifferent in the controversy? The Ariansrely on state patronage, and dare not avow their tenets
  4. Chapter 4. That the Son is Eternal and Increate. These attributes, being the points in dispute, are first proved by direct texts of Scripture. Concerning the 'eternal power' of God in Romans 1:20, which is shown to mean the Son. Remarks on the Arian formula, 'Once the Son was not,' its supporters not daring to speak of 'a time when the Son was not.'
  5. Chapter 5. Subject Continued. Objection, that the Son's eternity makes Him coordinate with the Father, introduces the subject of His Divine Sonship, as a second proof of His eternity. The word Son is introduced in a secondary, but is to be understood in real sense. Since all things partake of the Father in partaking of the Son, He is the whole participation of the Father, that is, He is the Son by nature; for to be wholly participated is to beget.
  6. Chapter 6. Subject Continued. Third proof of the Son's eternity, viz. from other titles indicative of His coessentiality; as the Creator; One of the Blessed Trinity; as Wisdom; as Word; as Image. If the Son is a perfect Image of the Father, why is He not a Father also? Because God, being perfect, is not the origin of a race. Only the Father a Father because the Only Father, only the Son a Son because the Only Son. Men are not really fathers and really sons, but shadows of the True. The Son does not become a Father, because He has received from the Father to be immutable and ever the same
  7. Chapter 7. Objections to the Foregoing Proof. Whether, in the generation of the Son, God made One that was already, or One that was not.
  8. Chapter 8. Objections Continued. Whether we may decide the question by the parallel of human sons, which are born later than their parents. No, for the force of the analogy lies in the idea of connaturality. Time is not involved in the idea of Son, but is adventitious to it, and does not attach to God, because He is without parts and passions. The titles Word and Wisdom guard our thoughts of Him and His Son from this misconception. God not a Father, as a Creator, in posse from eternity, because creation does not relate to the essence of God, as generation does.
  9. Chapter 9. Objections Continued. Whether is the Unoriginate one or two? Inconsistent in Ariansto use an unscriptural word; necessary to define its meaning. Different senses of the word. If it means 'without Father,' there is but One Unoriginate; if 'without beginning or creation,' there are two. Inconsistency of Asterius. 'Unoriginate' a title of God, not in contrast with the Son, but with creatures, as is 'Almighty,' or 'Lord of powers.' 'Father' is the truer title, as not only Scriptural, but implying a Son, and our adoption as sons
  10. Chapter 10. Objections Continued. How the Word has free will, yet without being alterable. He is unalterable because the Image of the Father, proved from texts.
  11. Chapter 11. Texts Explained; And First, Philippians 2:9, 10. Whether the words 'Wherefore God has highly exalted' prove moral probation and advancement. Argued against, first, from the force of the word 'Son;' which is inconsistent with such an interpretation. Next, the passage examined. Ecclesiastical sense of 'highly exalted,' and 'gave,' and 'wherefore;' viz. as being spoken with reference to our Lord's manhood. Secondary sense; viz. as implying the Word's 'exaltation' through the resurrection in the same sense in which Scripture speaks of His descent in the Incarnation; how the phrase does not derogate from the nature of the Word.
  12. Chapter 12. Texts Explained; Secondly, Psalm 45:7, 8.}}–> Whether the words 'therefore,' 'anointed,' etc., imply that the Word has been rewarded. Argued against first from the word 'fellows' or 'partakers.' He is anointed with the Spirit in His manhood to sanctify human nature. Therefore the Spirit descended on Him in Jordan, when in the flesh. And He is said to sanctify Himself for us, and give us the gloryHe has received. The word 'wherefore' implies His divinity. 'You have loved righteousness,' etc., do not imply trial or choice.
  13. Chapter 13. Texts Explained; Thirdly, Hebrews i. 4. Additional texts brought as objections; e.g. Hebrews 1:4; 7:22. Whether the word 'better' implies likeness to the Angels; and 'made' or 'become' implies creation. Necessary to consider the circumstances under which Scripture speaks. Difference between 'better' and 'greater;' texts in proof. 'Made' or 'become' a general word. Contrast in Hebrews 1:4, between the Son and the Works in point of nature. The difference of the punishments under the two Covenants shows the difference of the natures of the Son and the Angels. 'Become' relates not to the nature of the Word, but to His manhood and office and relation towards us. Parallel passages in which the term is applied to the Eternal Father.

Chapter 1. Introduction. Reason for writing; certain personsindifferent about Arianism; Ariansnot Christians, because sectaries always take the name of their founder.

Of all other heresies that have departed from the truth, it is recognized that they have simply invented madness, and their irreligion has long been obvious to everyone. For since their founders went out from us, it clearly follows, as the blessed John has written, that they never thought as we do, nor do they now. Therefore, as the Savior says, because they do not gather with us, they scatter with the devil and watch for those who are asleep, so that by spreading their own deadly poison again, they may gain companions in death. But one heresy, the most recent one, has now risen as a forerunner of Antichrist—the Arian heresy, as it is called. Seeing that other heresies, her older sisters, have been openly condemned, she uses craft and cunning to clothe herself in the language of Scripture, like her father the devil, and is forcing her way back into the Church's paradise. With the appearance of Christianity, her deceptive arguments (for she has no real reasoning) may mislead people into wrong ideas about Christ. In fact, she has already deceived some foolish people, not only corrupting what they hear but even leading them to take and eat with Eve, until in their resulting ignorance they think bitter is sweet and admire this disgusting heresy. For this reason, at your request, I have thought it necessary to unfold the layers of its armor and expose the foul smell of its foolishness. In this way, those who are far from it may continue to avoid it, and those it has deceived may repent. By opening the eyes of their heart, they may understand that darkness is not light, falsehood is not truth, and Arianism is not good. Indeed, those who call these people Christians are making a great and serious mistake, having neither studied Scripture nor understood Christianity at all, nor the faith it contains.

1. Of all other heresies which have departed from the truth it is acknowledged that they have but devised a madness, and their irreligiousness has long since become notorious to all men. For that their authors went out from us, it plainly follows, as the blessed John has written, that they never thought nor now think with us. Wherefore, as says the Saviour, in that they gather not with us, they scatter with the devil, and keep an eye on those who slumber, that, by this second sowing of their own mortal poison, they may have companions in death. But, whereas one heresy, and that the last, which has now risen as harbinger of Antichrist, the Arian, as it is called, considering that other heresies, her elder sisters, have been openly proscribed, in her craft and cunning, affects to array herself in Scripture language, like her father the devil, and is forcing her way back into the Church's paradise — that with the pretence of Christianity, her smooth sophistry (for reason she has none) may deceive men into wrong thoughts of Christ — nay, since she has already seduced certain of the foolish, not only to corrupt their ears, but even to take and eat with Eve, till in their ignorance which ensues they think bitter sweet, and admire this loathsome heresy, on this account I have thought it necessary, at your request, to unrip 'the folds of its breast-plate,' and to show the ill savour of its folly. So while those who are far from it may continue to shun it, those whom it has deceived may repent; and, opening the eyes of their heart, may understand that darkness is not light, nor falsehood truth, nor Arianism good; nay, that those who call these men Christians are in great and grievous error, as neither having studied Scripture, nor understanding Christianity at all, and the faith which it contains.

What have they found in this heresy that resembles the true religious Faith, that they presume to claim its supporters say nothing wrong? This is truly like calling even Caiaphas a Christian, counting the traitor Judas still among the Apostles, saying that those who asked for Barabbas instead of the Saviour did no evil, and praising Hymenaeus and Alexander as right-minded men, as if the Apostle slandered them. But no Christian can bear to hear this, nor can he consider anyone who dares say such things to be sound in his understanding. For with them Arius takes the place of Christ, just as with the Manichees Maniches does; and instead of Moses and the other saints they have discovered one Sotades, a man whom even pagans mock, and the daughter of Herodias. For Arius has imitated the dissolute and effeminate style of the one, writing his Thalia on that model; and he has rivaled the other in her dance, reeling and frolicking in his blasphemies against the Saviour; until the victims of his heresy lose their minds and go mad, and change the Name of the Lord of glory into the likeness of the image of corruptible man, and instead of being called Christians they are called Arians, bearing this badge of their irreligion. For let them not make excuses, nor turn their disgrace back on those who are not like them by calling Christians after the names of their teachers, so that they themselves may appear to have that Name in the same way. Nor let them make a joke of it when they feel shame at their disgraceful name; rather, if they are ashamed, let them hide their faces, or let them turn away from their own irreligion. For never at any time did Christian people take their name from the Bishops among them, but from the Lord, on whom we rest our faith. Thus, though the blessed Apostles have become our teachers and have ministered the Saviour's Gospel, yet we do not take our title from them, but from Christ we are and are named Christians. But for those who derive the faith they profess from others, it is fitting that they should bear their name, since they have become their property.

2. For what have they discovered in this heresy like to the religious Faith, that they vainly talk as if its supporters said no evil? This in truth is to call even Caiaphas a Christian, and to reckon the traitor Judas still among the Apostles, and to say that they who asked Barabbas instead of the Saviour did no evil, and to recommend Hymenæus and Alexander as right-minded men, and as if the Apostle slandered them. But neither can a Christian bear to hear this, nor can he consider the man who dared to say it sane in his understanding. For with them for Christ is Arius, as with the Manichees Manichæus; and for Moses and the other saints they have made the discovery of one Sotades, a man whom even Gentiles laugh at, and of the daughter of Herodias. For of the one has Arius imitated the dissolute and effeminate tone, in writing Thaliæ on his model; and the other he has rivalled in her dance, reeling and frolicking in his blasphemies against the Saviour; till the victims of his heresy lose their wits and go foolish, and change the Name of the Lord of glory into the likeness of the 'image of corruptible man,' and for Christians come to be called Arians, bearing this badge of their irreligion. For let them not excuse themselves; nor retort their disgrace on those who are not as they, calling Christians after the names of their teachers, that they themselves may appear to have that Name in the same way. Nor let them make a jest of it, when they feel shame at their disgraceful appellation; rather, if they be ashamed, let them hide their faces, or let them recoil from their own irreligion. For never at any time did Christian people take their title from the Bishops among them, but from the Lord, on whom we rest our faith. Thus, though the blessed Apostles have become our teachers, and have ministered the Saviour's Gospel, yet not from them have we our title, but from Christ we are and are named Christians. But for those who derive the faith which they profess from others, good reason is it they should bear their name, whose property they have become.

We are all Christians and are called by that name because of Christ. But Marcion introduced a heresy long ago and was expelled. Those who remained with the one who expelled him stayed Christians, but those who followed Marcion were no longer called Christians but became known as Marcionites. In the same way, Valentinus, Basilides, Manichaeus, and Simon Magus passed their own names on to their followers. Some are addressed as Valentinians, Basilidians, Manichees, or Simonians, while others are called Cataphrygians after Phrygia, and Novatians after Novatus. Likewise, when Peter the Bishop and Martyr expelled Meletius, his party was no longer called Christian but Meletian. Similarly, when Alexander of blessed memory expelled Arius, those who remained with Alexander stayed Christians, but those who left with Arius abandoned the Savior's name to us who were with Alexander, and from that point on were called Arians. Notice that even after Alexander's death, those who are in communion with his successor Athanasius, and those with whom Athanasius is in communion, follow the same pattern. None of them bear his name, nor is he named after them, but all alike are called Christians as is customary. Though we have a succession of teachers and become their students, because we are taught by them the things of Christ, we both are and are called Christians just the same. But those who follow the heretics, even though they have countless successors in their heresy, still bear the name of the one who invented it. So although Arius is dead and many of his party have succeeded him, those who think like him are called Arians because they are identified by Arius. Here is striking evidence of this: when Greeks even today enter the Church and abandon the superstition of idols, they do not take the name of their instructors but of the Savior, and begin to be called Christians instead of Greeks. But those among them who go off to the heretics, and all who leave the Church for this heresy, abandon Christ's name and from then on are called Arians, since they no longer hold Christ's faith but have inherited Arius's madness.

3. Yes surely; while all of us are and are called Christians after Christ, Marcion broached a heresy a long time since and was cast out; and those who continued with him who ejected him remained Christians; but those who followed Marcion were called Christians no more, but henceforth Marcionites. Thus Valentinus also, and Basilides, and Manichæus, and Simon Magus, have imparted their own name to their followers; and some are accosted as Valentinians, or as Basilidians, or as Manichees, or as Simonians; and other, Cataphrygians from Phrygia, and from Novatus Novatians. So too Meletius, when ejected by Peter the Bishop and Martyr, called his party no longer Christians, but Meletians, and so in consequence when Alexander of blessed memory had cast out Arius, those who remained with Alexander, remained Christians; but those who went out with Arius, left the Saviour's Name to us who were with Alexander, and as to them they were hence-forward denominated Arians. Behold then, after Alexander's death too, those who communicate with his successor Athanasius, and those with whom the said Athanasius communicates, are instances of the same rule; none of them bear his name, nor is he named from them, but all in like manner, and as is usual, are called Christians. For though we have a succession of teachers and become their disciples, yet, because we are taught by them the things of Christ, we both are, and are called, Christians all the same. But those who follow the heretics, though they have innumerable successors in their heresy, yet anyhow bear the name of him who devised it. Thus, though Arius be dead, and many of his party have succeeded him, yet those who think with him, as being known from Arius, are called Arians. And, what is a remarkable evidence of this, those of the Greeks who even at this time come into the Church, on giving up the superstition of idols, take the name, not of their catechists, but of the Saviour, and begin to be called Christians instead of Greeks: while those of them who go off to the heretics, and again all who from the Church change to this heresy, abandon Christ's name, and henceforth are called Arians, as no longer holding Christ's faith, but having inherited Arius's madness.

How then can they be Christians, when instead of being Christians they are Ario-maniacs? Or how are they part of the Catholic Church, when they have shaken off the Apostolic faith and become authors of new evils? After abandoning the oracles of divine Scripture, they call Arius's Thalia a new wisdom—and rightly so, for they are announcing a new heresy. This makes one marvel: although many people have written many treatises and abundant homilies on the Old Testament and the New, not one Thalia is found in any of them—nor even among the more respectable of the pagans, but only among those who sing such songs over their cups, amid cheers and jokes when people are merry, so the rest may laugh. Yet this remarkable Arius, taking no serious model and ignorant even of what is respectable, has stolen largely from other heresies while trying to be original in the ridiculous, with no one but Sotades as his rival. For what suited him better, when he would dance forth against the Savior, than to throw his wretched words of irreligion into dissolute and loose meters? In this way, while "a man," as Wisdom says, "is known from the utterance of his word," so from those meters the writer's effeminate soul and corruption of thought would be seen. In truth, that crafty one did not escape detection. For all his many writhings to and fro, like the serpent, he simply fell into the error of the Pharisees. They, in order to transgress the Law, pretended to be anxious for the words of the Law, and in order to deny the expected and then present Lord, they were hypocritical with God's name and were convicted of blaspheming when they said, "Why do You, being a man, make Yourself God," and say, "I and the Father are one"? And so too, this counterfeit and Sotadean Arius pretends to speak of God, introducing Scripture language, but is on all sides recognized as godless Arius, denying the Son and reckoning Him among the creatures.

4. How then can they be Christians, who for Christians are Ario-maniacs? Or how are they of the Catholic Church, who have shaken off the Apostolical faith, and become authors of fresh evils? Who, after abandoning the oracles of divine Scripture, call Arius's Thaliæ a new wisdom? And with reason too, for they are announcing a new heresy. And hence a man may marvel, that, whereas many have written many treatises and abundant homilies upon the Old Testament and the New, yet in none of them is a Thalia found; nay nor among the more respectable of the Gentiles, but among those only who sing such strains over their cups, amid cheers and jokes, when men are merry, that the rest may laugh; till this marvellous Arius, taking no grave pattern, and ignorant even of what is respectable, while he stole largely from other heresies, would be original in the ludicrous, with none but Sotades for his rival. For what beseemed him more, when he would dance forth against the Saviour, than to throw his wretched words of irreligion into dissolute and loose metres? That, while 'a man,' as Wisdom says, 'is known from the utterance of his word,' so from those numbers should be seen the writer's effeminate soul and corruption of thought. In truth, that crafty one did not escape detection; but, for all his many writhings to and fro, like the serpent, he did but fall into the error of the Pharisees. They, that they might transgress the Law, pretended to be anxious for the words of the Law, and that they might deny the expected and then present Lord, were hypocritical with God's name, and were convicted of blaspheming when they said, 'Why do You, being a man, make Yourself God,' and say, 'I and the Father are one John 10:30?' And so too, this counterfeit and Sotadean Arius, feigns to speak of God, introducing Scripture language, but is on all sides recognised as godless Arius, denying the Son, and reckoning Him among the creatures.

Chapter 2. Extracts from the Thalia of Arius. Ariusmaintains that God became a Father, and the Son was not always; the Son out of nothing; once He was not; He was not before his generation; He was created; named Wisdom and Word after God's attributes; made that He might make us; one out of many powers of God; alterable; exalted on God's foreknowledge of what He was to be; not very God; but called so as others by participation; foreign in essence from the Father; does not knowor see the Father; does not knowHimself.

The beginning of Arius's Thalia, which is frivolous and has an effeminate quality in both its melody and character, goes as follows:

5. Now the commencement of Arius's Thalia and flippancy, effeminate in tune and nature, runs thus:–

According to the faith of God's elect, God's prudent ones, holy children, rightly dividing and receiving God's Holy Spirit, I have learned this from the partakers of wisdom, accomplished, divinely taught, and wise in all things. I have been walking along their track, with like opinions. I am the very famous one, the much suffering one for God's glory, and taught of God, I have acquired wisdom and knowledge.

'According to faith of God's elect, God's prudent ones, Holy children, rightly dividing, God's Holy Spirit receiving, Have I learned this from the partakers of wisdom, Accomplished, divinely taught, and wise in all things. Along their track, have I been walking, with like opinions. I the very famous, the much suffering for God's glory; And taught of God, I have acquired wisdom and knowledge.'

The mockeries he utters in it are repulsive and utterly irreligious, such as these: "God was not always a Father," but "once God was alone and not yet a Father, but afterwards He became a Father." "The Son was not always," for since all things were made out of nothing, and all existing creatures and works were made, so the Word of God Himself was "made out of nothing," and "once He was not," and "He was not before His origination," but He like others "had an origin of creation." "For God," he says, "was alone, and the Word did not yet exist, nor the Wisdom. Then, wishing to form us, He made a certain one and named Him Word and Wisdom and Son, so that He might form us through Him." Accordingly, he says that there are two wisdoms: first, the attribute that co-exists with God, and second, that in this wisdom the Son was originated and was only named Wisdom and Word by participating in it. "For Wisdom," he says, "by the will of the wise God, had its existence in Wisdom." In the same way, he says there is another Word in God besides the Son, and that the Son again, by participating in it, is named Word and Son according to grace. And this too is an idea characteristic of their heresy, as shown in their other works: that there are many powers, one of which is God's own by nature and eternal, but Christ, on the other hand, is not the true power of God but, like the others, one of the so-called powers, one of which—namely the locust and the caterpillar—is called in Scripture not merely the power but the "great power." The others are many and are like the Son, and of them David speaks in the Psalms when he says "The Lord of hosts" or "powers." And by nature, like all the others, the Word Himself is alterable and remains good by His own free will while He chooses; however, when He wills, He can change as we can, since He has an alterable nature. For "therefore," he says, "because God foreknew that He would be good, He bestowed on Him in advance this glory, which afterwards, as man, He attained from virtue. Thus because of His works known beforehand, God brought it about that He, being such, should come to be."

And the mockeries which he utters in it, repulsive and most irreligious, are such as these:– 'God was not always a Father.' but 'once God was alone, and not yet a Father, but afterwards He became a Father.' 'The Son was not always;' for, whereas all things were made out of nothing, and all existing creatures and works were made, so the Word of God Himself was 'made out of nothing,' and 'once He was not,' and 'He was not before His origination,' but He as others 'had an origin of creation.' 'For God,' he says, 'was alone, and the Word as yet was not, nor the Wisdom. Then, wishing to form us, thereupon He made a certain one, and named Him Word and Wisdom and Son, that He might form us by means of Him.' Accordingly, he says that there are two wisdoms, first, the attribute co-existent with God, and next, that in this wisdom the Son was originated, and was only named Wisdom and Word as partaking of it. 'For Wisdom,' says he, 'by the will of the wise God, had its existence in Wisdom.' In like manner, he says, that there is another Word in God besides the Son, and that the Son again, as partaking of it, is named Word and Son according to grace. And this too is an idea proper to their heresy, as shown in other works of theirs, that there are many powers; one of which is God's own by nature and eternal; but that Christ, on the other hand, is not the true power of God; but, as others, one of the so-called powers, one of which, namely, the locust and the caterpillar, is called in Scripture, not merely the power, but the 'great power.' The others are many and are like the Son, and of them David speaks in the Psalms, when he says, 'The Lord of hosts' or 'powers.' And by nature, as all others, so the Word Himself is alterable, and remains good by His own free will, while He chooses; when, however, He wills, He can alter as we can, as being of an alterable nature. For 'therefore,' says he, 'as foreknowing that He would be good, did God by anticipation bestow on Him this glory, which afterwards, as man, He attained from virtue. Thus in consequence of His works fore- known, did God bring it to pass that He being such, should come to be.'

Furthermore, he has dared to say that 'the Word is not the very God.' 'Though He is called God, yet He is not very God,' but 'by participation of grace, He, as others, is God only in name.' And just as all beings are foreign and different from God in essence, so too is 'the Word alien and unlike in all things to the Father's essence and propriety,' but belongs to things originated and created, and is one of these. Afterwards, as if he had inherited the devil's recklessness, he has stated in his Thalia that 'even to the Son the Father is invisible,' and 'the Word cannot perfectly and exactly either see or know His own Father.' But even what He knows and what He sees, He knows and sees 'in proportion to His own measure,' just as we also know according to our own power. For he says the Son not only does not know the Father exactly, because He fails in comprehension, but 'He knows not even His own essence.' And he says that 'the essences of the Father and the Son and the Holy Ghost are separate in nature, and estranged, and disconnected, and alien, and without participation of each other,' and in his own words, 'utterly unlike from each other in essence and glory, unto infinity.' Thus regarding 'likeness of glory and essence,' he says that the Word is entirely different from both the Father and the Holy Ghost. With such words has this irreligious man spoken, maintaining that the Son is distinct by Himself and in no respect a partaker of the Father. These are portions of Arius's fables as they occur in that frivolous composition.

6. Moreover he has dared to say, that 'the Word is not the very God;' 'though He is called God, yet He is not very God,' but 'by participation of grace, He, as others, is God only in name.' And, whereas all beings are foreign and different from God in essence, so too is 'the Word alien and unlike in all things to the Father's essence and propriety,' but belongs to things originated and created, and is one of these. Afterwards, as though he had succeeded to the devil's recklessness, he has stated in his Thalia, that 'even to the Son the Father is invisible,' and 'the Word cannot perfectly and exactly either see or know His own Father.' but even what He knows and what He sees, He knows and sees 'in proportion to His own measure,' as we also know according to our own power. For the Son, too, he says, not only knows not the Father exactly, for He fails in comprehension, but 'He knows not even His own essence;'– and that 'the essences of the Father and the Son and the Holy Ghost, are separate in nature, and estranged, and disconnected, and alien, and without participation of each other;' and, in his own words, 'utterly unlike from each other in essence and glory, unto infinity.' Thus as to 'likeness of glory and essence,' he says that the Word is entirely diverse from both the Father and the Holy Ghost. With such words has the irreligious spoken; maintaining that the Son is distinct by Himself, and in no respect partaker of the Father. These are portions of Arius's fables as they occur in that jocose composition.

Anyone who hears all this—indeed, the tune of the Thalia itself—must hate, and rightly hate, this Arius for making jokes about such matters as if he were on a stage. Who could regard him, when he claims to name God and speak of God, as anything but the serpent advising the woman? Who, on reading what follows in his work, could fail to recognize in his irreligious doctrine that same error into which the serpent later seduced the woman through his trickery? Who is not outraged at such blasphemies? As the Prophet says, "The heaven was astonished, and the earth shuddered" at the transgression of the Law. But the sun, with even greater horror, unable to bear the physical insults that the common Lord of all voluntarily endured for us, turned away and withdrew its rays, making that day sunless. And shall not all humanity be struck speechless at Arius's blasphemies, stopping their ears and shutting their eyes to avoid hearing them or seeing their author? Rather, will not the Lord Himself have reason to denounce such irreligious—indeed, such ungrateful—people, using the words He has already spoken through the prophet Hosea: "Woe to them, for they have fled from Me; destruction upon them, for they have transgressed against Me; though I have redeemed them, yet they have spoken lies against Me." And soon after, "They imagine mischief against Me; they turn away to nothing." For to turn away from the Word of God, which is, and to fashion for themselves one that is not, is to fall into what is nothing. For this reason the Ecumenical Council, when Arius spoke in this way, expelled him from the Church and anathematized him, unable to tolerate such irreligion. And ever since, Arius's error has been counted as an especially grave heresy, known as the enemy of Christ and the forerunner of Antichrist. Though such great condemnation is itself especially weighty in making people flee from that irreligious heresy, as I said above, yet since certain people called Christian, whether out of ignorance or pretense, think it, as I said before, little different from the Truth, and call its followers Christians, let us proceed to put some questions to them, as best we can, in order to expose the recklessness of the heresy. Perhaps, when thus caught, they will be silenced and flee from it as from the sight of a serpent.

7. Who is there that hears all this, nay, the tune of the Thalia, but must hate, and justly hate, this Arius jesting on such matters as on a stage? Who but must regard him, when he pretends to name God and speak of God, but as the serpent counselling the woman? Who, on reading what follows in his work, but must discern in his irreligious doctrine that error, into which by his sophistries the serpent in the sequel seduced the woman? Who at such blasphemies is not transported? 'The heaven,' as the Prophet says, 'was astonished, and the earth shuddered Jeremiah 2:12 ' at the transgression of the Law. But the sun, with greater horror, impatient of the bodily contumelies, which the common Lord of all voluntarily endured for us, turned away, and recalling his rays made that day sunless. And shall not all human kind at Arius's blasphemies be struck speechless, and stop their ears, and shut their eyes, to escape hearing them or seeing their author? Rather, will not the Lord Himself have reason to denounce men so irreligious, nay, so unthankful, in the words which He has already uttered by the prophet Hosea, 'Woe unto them, for they have fled from Me; destruction upon them, for they have transgressed against Me; though I have redeemed them, yet they have spoken lies against Me Hosea 7:13.' And soon after, 'They imagine mischief against Me; they turn away to nothing.' For to turn away from the Word of God, which is, and to fashion to themselves one that is not, is to fall to what is nothing. For this was why the Ecumenical Council, when Arius thus spoke, cast him from the Church, and anathematized him, as impatient of such irreligion. And ever since has Arius's error been reckoned for a heresy more than ordinary, being known as Christ's foe, and harbinger of Antichrist. Though then so great a condemnation be itself of special weight to make men flee from that irreligious heresy, as I said above, yet since certain persons called Christian, either in ignorance or pretence, think it, as I then said, little different from the Truth, and call its professors Christians; proceed we to put some questions to them, according to our powers, thereby to expose the unscrupulousness of the heresy. Perhaps, when thus caught, they will be silenced, and flee from it, as from the sight of a serpent.

Chapter 3. The Importance of the Subject. The Ariansaffect Scripture language, but their doctrine new, as well as unscriptural. Statement of the Catholic doctrine, that the Son is proper to the Father's substance, and eternal. Restatement of Arianismin contrast, that He is a creature with a beginning: the controversy comes to this issue, whether one whom we are to believein as God, can be so in name only, and is merely a creature. What pretence then for being indifferent in the controversy? The Ariansrely on state patronage, and dare not avow their tenets

If the use of certain phrases from divine Scripture changes the blasphemy of the Thalia into reverent language in their opinion, then of course they ought also to deny Christ along with the present-day Jews, when they see how the Jews study the Law and the Prophets. Perhaps too they will deny the Law and the Prophets like the Manichees, because the Manichees read some portions of the Gospels. If such bewilderment and empty speaking comes from ignorance, Scripture will teach them that the devil, the author of heresies, borrows Scripture language as a cloak because of the foul smell that attaches to evil, so that he can also sow the ground with his own poison and seduce the simple. This is how he deceived Eve; this is how he framed earlier heresies; this is how he persuaded Arius at this time to make a show of speaking against those earlier heresies, so that he might introduce his own without being noticed. And yet, after all, the man of craft did not escape. For being irreligious toward the Word of God, he lost everything at once and betrayed to all people his ignorance of other heresies too. Having not a particle of truth in his belief, he only pretends to it. For how can he speak truth concerning the Father when he denies the Son who reveals concerning Him? Or how can he be orthodox concerning the Spirit while he speaks profanely of the Word that supplies the Spirit? And who will trust him concerning the Resurrection when he denies Christ for us, the first-begotten from the dead? And how shall he not err regarding His incarnate presence when he is simply ignorant of the Son's genuine and true generation from the Father? For thus, the former Jews also, denying the Word and saying, "We have no king but Caesar," were immediately stripped of all they had and forfeited the light of the Lamp, the fragrance of ointment, knowledge of prophecy, and the Truth itself. Until now they understand nothing but are walking as in darkness. For who was ever yet a hearer of such a doctrine? Or from where or from whom did the supporters and hirelings of the heresy gain it? Who explained it to them this way when they were at school? Who told them, "Abandon the worship of the creation, and then draw near and worship a creature and a work"? But if they themselves admit that they have heard it now for the first time, how can they deny that this heresy is foreign and not from our fathers? But what is not from our fathers, but has come to light in this day, how can it be anything other than what the blessed Paul has foretold: that "in the latter times some shall depart from the sound faith, giving heed to seducing spirits and doctrines of devils, in the hypocrisy of liars, cauterized in their own conscience, and turning from the truth"?

8. If then the use of certain phrases of divine Scripture changes, in their opinion, the blasphemy of the Thalia into reverent language, of course they ought also to deny Christ with the present Jews, when they see how they study the Law and the Prophets; perhaps too they will deny the Law and the Prophets like Manichees, because the latter read some portions of the Gospels. If such bewilderment and empty speaking be from ignorance, Scripture will teach them, that the devil, the author of heresies, because of the ill savour which attaches to evil, borrows Scripture language, as a cloak wherewith to sow the ground with his own poison also, and to seduce the simple. Thus he deceived Eve; thus he framed former heresies; thus he persuaded Arius at this time to make a show of speaking against those former ones, that he might introduce his own without observation. And yet, after all, the man of craft did not escape. For being irreligious towards the Word of God, he lost his all at once, and betrayed to all men his ignorance of other heresies too; and having not a particle of truth in his belief, does but pretend to it. For how can he speak truth concerning the Father, who denies the Son, that reveals concerning Him? Or how can he be orthodox concerning the Spirit, while he speaks profanely of the Word that supplies the Spirit? And who will trust him concerning the Resurrection, denying, as he does, Christ for us the first-begotten from the dead? And how shall he not err in respect to His incarnate presence, who is simply ignorant of the Son's genuine and true generation from the Father? For thus, the former Jews also, denying the Word, and saying, 'We have no king but Cæsar John 19:15,' were immediately stripped of all they had, and forfeited the light of the Lamp, the odour of ointment, knowledge of prophecy, and the Truth itself; till now they understand nothing, but are walking as in darkness. For who was ever yet a hearer of such a doctrine? Or whence or from whom did the abettors and hirelings of the heresy gain it? Who thus expounded to them when they were at school? Who told them, 'Abandon the worship of the creation, and then draw near and worship a creature and a work?' But if they themselves own that they have heard it now for the first time, how can they deny that this heresy is foreign, and not from our fathers? But what is not from our fathers, but has come to light in this day, how can it be but that of which the blessed Paul has foretold, that 'in the latter times some shall depart from the sound faith, giving heed to seducing spirits and doctrines of devils, in the hypocrisy of liars; cauterized in their own conscience, and turning from the truth?'

Look, we take divine Scripture and from it speak freely about the religious faith. We set it up as a light on its stand, saying: He is the true Son of the Father, natural and genuine, proper to His ousia, the Only-begotten Wisdom, and the true and only Word of God. He is not a creature or something made, but an offspring proper to the Father's ousia. Therefore He is truly God, existing as one in ousia with the Father. Other beings, to whom He said "I said you are gods," received this grace from the Father only by participation in the Word, through the Spirit. For He is the expression of the Father's person, and Light from Light, and Power, and the true Image of the Father's ousia. This is why the Lord said, "He who has seen Me has seen the Father" (John 14:9). And He always was and is and never was not. For since the Father is everlasting, His Word and His Wisdom must be everlasting. On the other hand, what can these people show us from the disgraceful Thalia? Or first, let them read it themselves and copy the writer's tone. At least the mockery they will face from others may teach them how far they have fallen. Then let them proceed to explain themselves. For what can they say from it except that "God was not always a Father, but became so afterward; the Son was not always, for He was not before His generation; He is not from the Father, but He, like others, came into existence out of nothing; He is not proper to the Father's ousia, for He is a creature and something made"? And "Christ is not truly God, but He, like others, was made God by participation; the Son does not have exact knowledge of the Father, nor does the Word see the Father perfectly; and neither exactly understands nor knows the Father. He is not the true and only Word of the Father, but is called Word and Wisdom in name only, and is called Son and Power by grace. He is not unalterable as the Father is, but alterable in nature like the creatures, and He falls short of grasping the perfect knowledge of the Father." This is a remarkable heresy—not even plausible, but making arguments against Him who exists, that He might not exist, and everywhere putting forward blasphemy as reverent language! If anyone, after examining both sides, were asked which of the two he would follow in faith, or which of the two spoke fittingly about God—or rather let these supporters of irreligion say themselves what it would be fitting to answer if someone asks about God (for "the Word was God"). For from this one question the whole case on both sides can be determined—what is fitting to say. Was He, or was He not? Always, or before His birth? Eternal, or from this time and from then? True, or by adoption and from participation and in concept? To call Him one of the things created, or to unite Him to the Father? To consider Him unlike the Father in ousia, or like and proper to Him? A creature, or Him through whom the creatures came into being? That He is the Father's Word, or that there is another word besides Him, and that by this other word He was created, and by another wisdom? And that He is only named Wisdom and Word, and has become a partaker of this wisdom, and is second to it?

9. For, behold, we take divine Scripture, and thence discourse with freedom of the religious Faith, and set it up as a light upon its candlestick, saying:– Very Son of the Father, natural and genuine, proper to His essence, Wisdom Only-begotten, and Very and Only Word of God is He; not a creature or work, but an offspring proper to the Father's essence. Wherefore He is very God, existing one in essence with the very Father; while other beings, to whom He said, 'I said you are Gods,' had this grace from the Father, only by participation of the Word, through the Spirit. For He is the expression of the Father's Person, and Light from Light, and Power, and very Image of the Father's essence. For this too the Lord has said, 'He that has seen Me, has seen the Father John 14:9.' And He ever was and is and never was not. For the Father being everlasting, His Word and His Wisdom must be everlasting. On the other hand, what have these persons to show us from the infamous Thalia? Or, first of all, let them read it themselves, and copy the tone of the writer; at least the mockery which they will encounter from others may instruct them how low they have fallen; and then let them proceed to explain themselves. For what can they say from it, but that 'God was not always a Father, but became so afterwards; the Son was not always, for He was not before His generation; He is not from the Father, but He, as others, has come into subsistence out of nothing; He is not proper to the Father's essence, for He is a creature and work?' And 'Christ is not very God, but He, as others, was made God by participation; the Son has not exact knowledge of the Father, nor does the Word see the Father perfectly; and neither exactly understands nor knows the Father. He is not the very and only Word of the Father, but is in name only called Word and Wisdom, and is called by grace Son and Power. He is not unalterable, as the Father is, but alterable in nature, as the creatures, and He comes short of apprehending the perfect knowledge of the Father.' Wonderful this heresy, not plausible even, but making speculations against Him that is, that He be not, and everywhere putting forward blasphemy for reverent language! Were any one, after inquiring into both sides, to be asked, whether of the two he would follow in faith, or whether of the two spoke fitly of God — or rather let them say themselves, these abettors of irreligion, what, if a man be asked concerning God (for 'the Word was God?'), it were fit to answer. For from this one question the whole case on both sides may be determined, what is fitting to say — He was, or He was not; always, or before His birth; eternal, or from this and from then; true, or by adoption, and from participation and in idea; to call Him one of things originated, or to unite Him to the Father; to consider Him unlike the Father in essence, or like and proper to Him; a creature, or Him through whom the creatures were originated; that He is the Father's Word, or that there is another word beside Him, and that by this other He was originated, and by another wisdom; and that He is only named Wisdom and Word, and has become a partaker of this wisdom, and second to it?

Which of the two theologies presents our Lord Jesus Christ as God and Son of the Father—the one you vomited forth, or the one we have spoken and maintain from the Scriptures? If the Savior is not God, nor Word, nor Son, then you have permission to say whatever you wish, as do the Gentiles and the present-day Jews. But if He is the Word of the Father and true Son, and God from God, and "blessed forever over all" (Romans 9:5), is it not fitting to erase and blot out those other phrases and that Arian Thalia, as nothing but a pattern of evil, a storehouse of all irreligion, into which whoever falls "knows not that giants perish with her, and reaches the depths of Hades"? They know this themselves, and in their craftiness they conceal it, not having the courage to speak openly, but saying something else instead. For if they speak plainly, condemnation will follow; and if they are suspected, proofs from Scripture will be thrown at them from every side. Therefore, in their craftiness, as children of this world, after feeding their so-called lamp from the wild olive, and fearing that it will soon be extinguished (for it is said, "the light of the wicked shall be put out," Job 18:5), they hide it under the bushel of their hypocrisy, and make a different profession, and boast of the patronage of friends and the authority of Constantius, so that through their hypocrisy and their professions, those who come to them may be kept from seeing how foul their heresy is. Is it not detestable even in this—that it dares not speak openly, but is kept hidden by its own friends, and fostered like serpents? For from what sources have they gathered these words? Or from whom have they received what they venture to say? They cannot point to any single person who has supplied it. For who is there among all mankind, Greek or barbarian, who ventures to rank among creatures One whom he confesses at the same time to be God, and says that He did not exist until He was made? Or who is there who, regarding the God in whom he has put faith, refuses to give Him credit when He says, "This is My beloved Son" (Matthew 3:17), on the pretense that He is not a Son but a creature? Rather, such madness would provoke universal indignation. Nor does Scripture afford them any pretext, for it has been often shown, and it shall be shown now, that their doctrine is alien to the divine oracles. Therefore, since all that remains is to say that their mania came from the devil (for he alone is the sower of such opinions), let us proceed to resist him—for with him is our real conflict, and they are merely instruments—so that, with the Lord's help, and the enemy being overcome with arguments as he is accustomed to be, they may be put to shame when they see him who sowed this heresy in them left without resources, and may learn, though late, that as Arians they are not Christians.

10. Which of the two theologies sets forth our Lord Jesus Christ as God and Son of the Father, this which you vomited forth, or that which we have spoken and maintain from the Scriptures? If the Saviour be not God, nor Word, nor Son, you shall have leave to say what you will, and so shall the Gentiles, and the present Jews. But if He be Word of the Father and true Son, and God from God, and 'over all blessed for ever Romans 9:5,' is it not becoming to obliterate and blot out those other phrases and that Arian Thalia, as but a pattern of evil, a store of all irreligion, into which, whoever falls, ' knows not that giants perish with her, and reaches the depths of Hades?' This they know themselves, and in their craft they conceal it, not having the courage to speak out, but uttering something else. For if they speak, a condemnation will follow; and if they be suspected, proofs from Scripture will be cast at them from every side. Wherefore, in their craft, as children of this world, after feeding their so-called lamp from the wild olive, and fearing lest it should soon be quenched (for it is said, 'the light of the wicked shall be put out Job 18:5,') they hide it under the bushel of their hypocrisy, and make a different profession, and boast of patronage of friends and authority of Constantius, that what with their hypocrisy and their professions, those who come to them may be kept from seeing how foul their heresy is. Is it not detestable even in this, that it dares not speak out, but is kept hidden by its own friends, and fostered as serpents are? For from what sources have they got together these words? Or from whom have they received what they venture to say? Not any one man can they specify who has supplied it. For who is there in all mankind, Greek or Barbarian, who ventures to rank among creatures One whom he confesses the while to be God and says, that He was not till He was made? Or who is there, who to the God in whom he has put faith, refuses to give credit, when He says, 'This is My beloved Son Matthew 3:17,' on the pretence that He is not a Son, but a creature? Rather, such madness would rouse an universal indignation. Nor does Scripture afford them any pretext; for it has been often shown, and it shall be shown now, that their doctrine is alien to the divine oracles. Therefore, since all that remains is to say that from the devil came their mania (for of such opinions he alone is sower), proceed we to resist him — for with him is our real conflict, and they are but instruments — that, the Lord aiding us, and the enemy, as he is wont, being overcome with arguments, they may be put to shame, when they see him without resource who sowed this heresy in them, and may learn, though late, that, as being Arians, they are not Christians.

Chapter 4. That the Son is Eternal and Increate. These attributes, being the points in dispute, are first proved by direct texts of Scripture. Concerning the 'eternal power' of God in Romans 1:20, which is shown to mean the Son. Remarks on the Arian formula, 'Once the Son was not,' its supporters not daring to speak of 'a time when the Son was not.'

Following your advice, then, you have maintained and you think that "there was once when the Son was not." This is the first cover of your doctrinal views that must be stripped away. Tell us, then, what was once when the Son was not, you slanderous and irreligious people? If you say the Father, your blasphemy is even greater, for it is impious to say that He was "once" or to refer to Him with the word "once." For He is eternal, and is now, and just as the Son is, so is He, and He Himself is the One who exists, and the Father of the Son. But if you say that the Son was once, when He Himself was not, the answer is foolish and meaningless. For how could He both be and not be? In this difficulty, you can only answer that there was a time when the Word was not, for your very word "once" naturally signifies this. And your other statement, "The Son was not before His generation," is equivalent to saying, "There was once when He was not," for both expressions signify that there is a time before the Word. Where, then, did you come up with this? Why do you, like the pagans, rage and imagine empty phrases against the Lord and against His Christ? For no holy Scripture has used such language about the Savior, but rather speaks of Him as "always" and "eternal" and "always coexisting with the Father." For, "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God." And in the Apocalypse he speaks this way: "Who is and who was and who is to come." Now who can strip "who is" and "who was" of eternity? Paul has also written this in his letter to the Romans to refute the Jews: "Of whom as concerning the flesh is Christ, who is over all, God blessed forever," and in silencing the Greeks, he has said, "The visible things of Him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even His eternal Power and Godhead." And what the Power of God is, he teaches us elsewhere himself: "Christ the Power of God and the Wisdom of God." Surely in these words he does not designate the Father, as you often whisper to one another, claiming that the Father is "His eternal power." This is not so, for he does not say "God Himself is the power," but "His is the power." It is very plain to all that "His" is not "He," yet not something alien but rather something proper to Him. Study the context too and "turn to the Lord"—now "the Lord is that Spirit"—and you will see that it is the Son who is being signified.

11. At his suggestion then you have maintained and you think, that 'there was once when the Son was not;' this is the first cloke of your views of doctrine which has to be stripped off. Say then what was once when the Son was not, O slanderous and irreligious men? If you say the Father, your blasphemy is but greater; for it is impious to say that He was 'once,' or to signify Him by the word 'once.' For He is ever, and is now, and as the Son is, so is He, and is Himself He that is, and Father of the Son. But if you say that the Son was once, when He Himself was not, the answer is foolish and unmeaning. For how could He both be and not be? In this difficulty, you can but answer, that there was a time when the Word was not; for your very adverb 'once' naturally signifies this. And your other, 'The Son was not before His generation,' is equivalent to saying, 'There was once when He was not,' for both the one and the other signify that there is a time before the Word. Whence then this your discovery? Why do you, as 'the heathen, rage, and imagine vain phrases against the Lord and against His Christ.' for no holy Scripture has used such language of the Saviour, but rather 'always' and ' eternal ' and 'coexistent always with the Father.' For, 'In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God John 1:1.' And in the Apocalypse he thus speaks; 'Who is and who was and who is to come.' Now who can rob 'who is' and 'who was' of eternity? This too in confutation of the Jews has Paul written in his Epistle to the Romans, 'Of whom as concerning the flesh is Christ, who is over all, God blessed for ever Romans 9:5;' while silencing the Greeks, he has said, 'The visible things of Him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even His eternal Power and Godhead;' and what the Power of God is, he teaches us elsewhere himself, 'Christ the Power of God and the Wisdom of God.' Surely in these words he does not designate the Father, as you often whisper one to another, affirming that the Father is 'His eternal power.' This is not so; for he says not, 'God Himself is the power,' but 'His is the power.' Very plain is it to all that 'His' is not 'He;' yet not something alien but rather proper to Him. Study too the context and 'turn to the Lord.' now 'the Lord is that Spirit;'and you will see that it is the Son who is signified.

After mentioning the creation, Paul naturally speaks of the Framer's Power as seen in it. This Power, I say, is the Word of God, by whom all things have been made. If the creation by itself were sufficient, without the Son, to make God known, then be careful not to think that it came into being without the Son. But if it came to be through the Son, and "in Him all things consist" (Colossians 1:17), then it must follow that whoever rightly contemplates creation is also contemplating the Word who framed it, and through Him begins to understand the Father. And if, as the Savior also says, "No one knows the Father except the Son, and anyone to whom the Son reveals Him" (Matthew 11:27), and if when Philip asked, "Show us the Father," He did not say, "Look at the creation," but rather, "Whoever has seen Me has seen the Father" (John 14:8-9), then Paul reasonably accuses the Greeks of contemplating the harmony and order of creation without reflecting on the Framing Word within it (for the creatures witness to their own Framer) so as to apprehend the true God through creation and abandon their worship of it. He reasonably said, "His Eternal Power and Godhead" (Romans 1:20), thereby signifying the Son. And where the sacred writers say, "Who exists before the ages," and "By whom He made the ages" (Hebrews 1:2), they thereby clearly preach the eternal and everlasting being of the Son, even while they are speaking of God Himself. Thus, if Isaiah says, "The Everlasting God, the Creator of the ends of the earth" (Isaiah 40:28), and Susanna said, "O Everlasting God," and Baruch wrote, "I will cry unto the Everlasting in my days," and shortly after, "My hope is in the Everlasting, that He will save you, and joy has come unto me from the Holy One," yet because the Apostle, writing to the Hebrews, says, "Who being the radiance of His glory and the Expression of His Person" (Hebrews 1:3), and David too in the eighty-ninth Psalm says, "And the brightness of the Lord be upon us," and, "In Your Light shall we see Light," who has so little sense as to doubt the eternity of the Son? For when did anyone see light without the brightness of its radiance, that he may say of the Son, "There was once when He was not," or "Before His generation He was not"? And the words addressed to the Son in the one hundred and forty-fourth Psalm, "Your kingdom is a kingdom of all ages," forbid anyone to imagine any interval at all in which the Word did not exist. For if every interval in the ages is measured, and the Word is King and Maker of all the ages, therefore, since no interval at all exists prior to Him, it would be madness to say, "There was once when the Everlasting was not," and "The Son is from nothing." And since the Lord Himself says, "I am the Truth," not "I became the Truth," but always, "I am"—"I am the Shepherd," "I am the Light"—and again, "Do you not call Me Lord and Master? And you call Me well, for so I am," who, hearing such language from God, and the Wisdom, and Word of the Father, speaking of Himself, will any longer hesitate about the truth, and not immediately believe that in the phrase "I am," is signified that the Son is eternal and without beginning?

12. For after making mention of the creation, he naturally speaks of the Framer's Power as seen in it, which Power, I say, is the Word of God, by whom all things have been made. If indeed the creation is sufficient of itself alone, without the Son, to make God known, see that you fall not, from thinking that without the Son it has come to be. But if through the Son it has come to be, and 'in Him all things consist Colossians 1:17,' it must follow that he who contemplates the creation rightly, is contemplating also the Word who framed it, and through Him begins to apprehend the Father. And if, as the Saviour also says, 'No one knows the Father, save the Son, and he to whom the Son shall reveal Him Matthew 11:27,' and if on Philip's asking, 'Show us the Father,' He said not, 'Behold the creation,' but, 'He that has seen Me, has seen the Father John 14:8-9,' reasonably does Paul — while accusing the Greeks of contemplating the harmony and order of the creation without reflecting on the Framing Word within it (for the creatures witness to their own Framer) so as through the creation to apprehend the true God, and abandon their worship of it — reasonably has he said, 'His Eternal Power and Godhead Romans 1:20,' thereby signifying the Son. And where the sacred writers say, 'Who exists before the ages,' and 'By whom He made the ages Hebrews 1:2,' they thereby as clearly preach the eternal and everlasting being of the Son, even while they are designating God Himself. Thus, if Isaiah says, 'The Everlasting God, the Creator of the ends of the earth Isaiah 40:28;' and Susanna said, 'O Everlasting God;' and Baruch wrote, 'I will cry unto the Everlasting in my days,' and shortly after, 'My hope is in the Everlasting, that He will save you, and joy has come unto me from the Holy One;' yet forasmuch as the Apostle, writing to the Hebrews, says, 'Who being the radiance of His glory and the Expression of His Person Hebrews 1:3;' and David too in the eighty-ninth Psalm, 'And the brightness of the Lord be upon us,' and, 'In Your Light shall we see Light,' who has so little sense as to doubt of the eternity of the Son? For when did man see light without the brightness of its radiance, that he may say of the Son, 'There was once, when He was not,' or 'Before His generation He was not.' And the words addressed to the Son in the hundred and forty-fourth Psalm, 'Your kingdom is a kingdom of all ages,' forbid any one to imagine any interval at all in which the Word did not exist. For if every interval in the ages is measured, and of all the ages the Word is King and Maker, therefore, whereas no interval at all exists prior to Him, it were madness to say, 'There was once when the Everlasting was not,' and 'From nothing is the Son.' And whereas the Lord Himself says, 'I am the Truth,' not 'I became the Truth.' but always, 'I am — I am the Shepherd, — I am the Light,'– and again, 'Call Me not, Lord and Master? And you call Me well, for so I am,' who, hearing such language from God, and the Wisdom, and Word of the Father, speaking of Himself, will any longer hesitate about the truth, and not immediately believe that in the phrase 'I am,' is signified that the Son is eternal and without beginning?

It's clear from the passages above that the Scriptures declare the Son's eternity. It's equally clear from what follows that the Arian phrases "He was not," "before," and "when" are used in these same Scriptures for creatures. For example, Moses in his account of how our world came to be says, "And every plant of the field, before it was in the earth, and every herb of the field before it grew; for the Lord God had not caused it to rain upon the earth, and there was not a man to till the ground." In Deuteronomy it says, "When the Most High divided to the nations." The Lord said in His own Person, "If you loved Me, you would rejoice because I said, I go unto the Father, for My Father is greater than I. And now I have told you before it come to pass, that when it has come to pass, you might believe." Concerning creation He says through Solomon, "Or ever the earth was, when there were no depths, I was brought forth; when there were no fountains abounding with water. Before the mountains were settled, before the hills, was I brought forth." And, "Before Abraham was, I am." Concerning Jeremiah He says, "Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you." David says in the Psalm, "Before the mountains were brought forth, or ever the earth and the world were made, You are, God from everlasting and world without end." And in Daniel, "Susanna cried out with a loud voice and said, O everlasting God, that know the secrets, and know all things before they be." So it's clear that the phrases "once was not," "before it came to be," "when," and similar expressions belong to created things that come from nothing, but are foreign to the Word. If such terms are used in Scripture for created things, but "ever" is used for the Word, then it follows, you enemies of God, that the Son did not come from nothing, nor is He among created things at all, but is the Father's Image and Word who is eternal, never having not existed, but always existing as the eternal Radiance of a Light that is eternal. Why then do you imagine times before the Son? Why do you blaspheme the Word as coming after times, when He is the one through whom even the ages were made? How could time or age even exist when the Word, as you claim, had not yet appeared—He through whom all things have been made and without whom not one thing was made? Why, when you actually mean time, don't you plainly say "a time was when the Word was not"? You drop the word "time" to deceive simple people, but you don't hide your real meaning at all, and even if you did, you couldn't escape detection. You still clearly mean times when you say "There was when He was not" and "He was not before His generation."

13. It is plain then from the above that the Scriptures declare the Son's eternity; it is equally plain from what follows that the Arian phrases 'He was not,' and 'before' and 'when,' are in the same Scriptures predicated of creatures. Moses, for instance, in his account of the generation of our system, says, 'And every plant of the field, before it was in the earth, and every herb of the field before it grew; for the Lord God had not caused it to rain upon the earth, and there was not a man to till the ground Genesis 2:5.' And in Deuteronomy, 'When the Most High divided to the nations Deuteronomy 32:8.' And the Lord said in His own Person, 'If you loved Me, you would rejoice because I said, I go unto the Father, for My Father is greater than I. And now I have told you before it come to pass, that when it has come to pass, you might believe John 14:28-29.' And concerning the creation He says by Solomon, 'Or ever the earth was, when there were no depths, I was brought forth; when there were no fountains abounding with water. Before the mountains were settled, before the hills, was I brought forth Proverbs 8:23.' And, 'Before Abraham was, I am John 8:58.' And concerning Jeremiah He says, 'Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you Jeremiah 1:5.' And David in the Psalm says, 'Before the mountains were brought forth, or ever the earth and the world were made, You are, God from everlasting and world without end.' And in Daniel, 'Susanna cried out with a loud voice and said, O everlasting God, that know the secrets, and know all things before they be.' Thus it appears that the phrases 'once was not,' and 'before it came to be,' and 'when,' and the like, belong to things originate and creatures, which come out of nothing, but are alien to the Word. But if such terms are used in Scripture of things originate, but 'ever' of the Word, it follows, O you enemies of God, that the Son did not come out of nothing, nor is in the number of originated things at all, but is the Father's Image and Word eternal, never having not been, but being ever, as the eternal Radiance of a Light which is eternal. Why imagine then times before the Son? Or why blaspheme the Word as after times, by whom even the ages were made? For how did time or age at all subsist when the Word, as you say, had not appeared, 'through' whom 'all things have been made and without' whom 'not one thing was made John 1:3?' Or why, when you mean time, do you not plainly say, 'a time was when the Word was not?' But while you drop the word 'time' to deceive the simple, you do not at all conceal your own feeling, nor, even if you did, could you escape discovery. For you still simply mean times, when you say, 'There was when He was not,' and 'He was not before His generation.'

Chapter 5. Subject Continued. Objection, that the Son's eternity makes Him coordinate with the Father, introduces the subject of His Divine Sonship, as a second proof of His eternity. The word Son is introduced in a secondary, but is to be understood in real sense. Since all things partake of the Father in partaking of the Son, He is the whole participation of the Father, that is, He is the Son by nature; for to be wholly participated is to beget.

When these points are proved in this way, their profaneness goes even further. "If there never was a time when the Son was not," they say, "but He is eternal and coexists with the Father, you no longer call Him the Father's Son, but His brother." How senseless and argumentative! If we only said that He was eternally with the Father and not His Son, their pretended concern would have some plausibility. But if, while we say that He is eternal, we also confess Him to be Son from the Father, how can He who is begotten be considered the brother of Him who begets? And if our faith is in Father and Son, what brotherhood exists between them? And how can the Word be called the brother of Him whose Word He is? This is not an objection from men who are truly ignorant, for they understand how the truth stands. Rather, it is a Jewish pretense from those who, in Solomon's words, "through desire separate themselves" from the truth. For the Father and the Son were not generated from some preexisting origin, so that we should account them brothers. Rather, the Father is the origin of the Son and begot Him. The Father is Father and not born the Son of anyone, and the Son is Son and not brother. Further, if He is called the eternal offspring of the Father, He is rightly so called. For the essence of the Father was never imperfect, so that what is proper to it should be added afterwards. Nor has the Son been begotten as man is from man, so as to be later than His Father's existence. Rather, He is God's offspring, and as being the proper Son of God who is eternal, He exists eternally. For whereas it is proper to men to beget in time because of the imperfection of their nature, God's offspring is eternal because His nature is always perfect. If then He is not a Son but a work made out of nothing, they have only to prove it, and then they are free, as if speculating about a creature, to cry out, "There was once when He was not," for things that are originated did not exist and have come to be. But if He is Son, as the Father says and the Scriptures proclaim, and "Son" is nothing else than what is generated from the Father, and what is generated from the Father is His Word and Wisdom and Radiance, what is to be said except that in maintaining "Once the Son was not," they rob God of His Word like plunderers, and openly assert of Him that He was once without His proper Word and Wisdom, and that the Light was once without radiance, and that the Fountain was once barren and dry? For though they pretend to be alarmed at the name of time because of those who reproach them with it, and say that He was before times, yet since they assign certain intervals in which they imagine He was not, they are still most irreligious, as they equally suggest times and impute to God an absence of Reason.

14. When these points are thus proved, their profaneness goes further. 'If there never was, when the Son was not,' say they, 'but He is eternal, and coexists with the Father, you call Him no more the Father's Son, but brother.' O insensate and contentious! For if we said only that He was eternally with the Father, and not His Son, their pretended scruple would have some plausibility; but if, while we say that He is eternal, we also confess Him to be Son from the Father, how can He that is begotten be considered brother of Him who begets? And if our faith is in Father and Son, what brotherhood is there between them? And how can the Word be called brother of Him whose Word He is? This is not an objection of men really ignorant, for they comprehend how the truth lies; but it is a Jewish pretence, and that from those who, in Solomon's words, 'through desire separate themselves Proverbs 18:1 ' from the truth. For the Father and the Son were not generated from some pre-existing origin, that we may account Them brothers, but the Father is the Origin of the Son and begot Him; and the Father is Father, and not born the Son of any; and the Son is Son, and not brother. Further, if He is called the eternal offspring of the Father, He is rightly so called. For never was the essence of the Father imperfect, that what is proper to it should be added afterwards; nor, as man from man, has the Son been begotten, so as to be later than His Father's existence, but He is God's offspring, and as being proper Son of God, who is ever, He exists eternally. For, whereas it is proper to men to beget in time, from the imperfection of their nature, God's offspring is eternal, for His nature is ever perfect. If then He is not a Son, but a work made out of nothing, they have but to prove it; and then they are at liberty, as if imagining about a creature, to cry out, 'There was once when He was not;' for things which are originated were not, and have come to be. But if He is Son, as the Father says, and the Scriptures proclaim, and 'Son' is nothing else than what is generated from the Father; and what is generated from the Father is His Word, and Wisdom, and Radiance; what is to be said but that, in maintaining 'Once the Son was not,' they rob God of His Word, like plunderers, and openly predicate of Him that He was once without His proper Word and Wisdom, and that the Light was once without radiance, and the Fountain was once barren and dry? For though they pretend alarm at the name of time, because of those who reproach them with it, and say, that He was before times, yet whereas they assign certain intervals, in which they imagine He was not, they are most irreligious still, as equally suggesting times, and imputing to God an absence of Reason.

But if, on the other hand, they acknowledge the name 'Son' along with us—because they don't want to be publicly and universally condemned—yet deny that the Son is the proper offspring of the Father's essence on the grounds that this would involve parts and divisions, what is this except denying that He is truly Son and calling Him Son in name only? And is it not a serious error to think materially about what is immaterial, and to deny what is natural and proper to the Father simply because of the weakness of their own nature? All that remains is for them to deny Him altogether, since they don't understand what God is and what the Father is—these foolish people measure the Father's Offspring by their own standards. People whose state of mind leads them to think there cannot be a Son of God deserve our pity, but they must be questioned and exposed in hopes of bringing them to their senses. If, as you claim, 'the Son is from nothing' and 'did not exist before His generation,' then of course He, like all others, must be called Son and God and Wisdom only by participation, for that is how all other creatures exist and are glorified through sanctification. So you must tell us what He participates in. All other things participate in the Spirit, but according to you, what does He participate in? The Spirit? No, rather the Spirit Himself receives from the Son, as the Son Himself says, and it is not reasonable to say that the latter is sanctified by the former. Therefore He participates in the Father—this is the only remaining option. But what is this thing that is participated, and where does it come from? If it is something external provided by the Father, then He will not be a partaker of the Father but of what is external to Him. He will no longer even be second after the Father, since this other thing comes before Him, nor could He be called Son of the Father, but rather son of that thing, since it is by partaking of it that He is called Son and God. If this is inappropriate and irreligious—when the Father says, 'This is My Beloved Son,' and when the Son says that God is His own Father—it follows that what is participated is not external but comes from the essence of the Father. And regarding this again, if it is other than the essence of the Son, an equally absurd consequence confronts us, since there would be something between what comes from the Father and the essence of the Son, whatever that might be.

15. But if on the other hand, while they acknowledge with us the name of 'Son,' from an unwillingness to be publicly and generally condemned, they deny that the Son is the proper offspring of the Father's essence, on the ground that this must imply parts and divisions; what is this but to deny that He is very Son, and only in name to call Him Son at all? And is it not a grievous error, to have material thoughts about what is immaterial, and because of the weakness of their proper nature to deny what is natural and proper to the Father? It does but remain, that they should deny Him also, because they understand not how God is, and what the Father is, now that, foolish men, they measure by themselves the Offspring of the Father. And persons in such a state of mind as to consider that there cannot be a Son of God, demand our pity; but they must be interrogated and exposed for the chance of bringing them to their senses. If then, as you say, 'the Son is from nothing,' and 'was not before His generation,' He, of course, as well as others, must be called Son and God and Wisdom only by participation; for thus all other creatures consist, and by sanctification are glorified. You have to tell us then, of what He is partaker. All other things partake of the Spirit, but He, according to you, of what is He partaker? Of the Spirit? Nay, rather the Spirit Himself takes from the Son, as He Himself says; and it is not reasonable to say that the latter is sanctified by the former. Therefore it is the Father that He partakes; for this only remains to say. But this, which is participated, what is it or whence? If it be something external provided by the Father, He will not now be partaker of the Father, but of what is external to Him; and no longer will He be even second after the Father, since He has before Him this other; nor can He be called Son of the Father, but of that, as partaking which He has been called Son and God. And if this be unseemly and irreligious, when the Father says, 'This is My Beloved Son Matthew 3:17,' and when the Son says that God is His own Father, it follows that what is partaken is not external, but from the essence of the Father. And as to this again, if it be other than the essence of the Son, an equal extravagance will meet us; there being in that case something between this that is from the Father and the essence of the Son, whatever that be.

Since such thoughts are clearly improper and false, we must say that what comes from the Father's essence and is proper to Him is entirely the Son. For it means the same thing to say that God is wholly participated and that He begets, and what does begetting mean except a Son? And so all things partake of the Father by partaking of the Son Himself, according to the grace of the Spirit coming from Him. This shows that the Son Himself partakes of nothing, but what is partaken from the Father is the Son. For by partaking of the Son Himself, we are said to partake of God, which is what Peter meant when he said "that you may be partakers in a divine nature," and what the Apostle meant when he said "Do you not know that you are a temple of God" and "We are the temple of a living God." When we see the Son, we see the Father, because the thought and understanding of the Son is knowledge about the Father, since He is the Father's proper offspring from His essence. And since none of us would ever call God's being partaken an affection or division of God's essence (for it has been shown and acknowledged that God is participated, and to be participated is the same as to beget), therefore what is begotten is neither an affection nor a division of that blessed essence. So it is not unbelievable that God should have a Son, the offspring of His own essence. Nor do we imply affection or division of God's essence when we speak of "Son" and "offspring." Rather, we believe in acknowledging the genuine, true, and Only-begotten of God. If then, as we have stated and are showing, what is the offspring of the Father's essence is the Son, we cannot hesitate—rather we must be certain—that the same is the Wisdom and Word of the Father, in and through whom He creates and makes all things; and His Brightness too, in whom He enlightens all things and is revealed to whom He wills; and His Expression and Image also, in whom He is contemplated and known. Therefore "He and His Father are one," and whoever looks on Him looks on the Father; and the Christ, in whom all things are redeemed and the new creation is made anew. And conversely, since the Son is such an offspring, it is not fitting but rather full of danger to say that He is a work out of nothing or that He did not exist before His generation. For whoever speaks this way about what is proper to the Father's essence already blasphemes the Father Himself, since he really thinks about Him what he falsely imagines about His offspring.

16. Such thoughts then being evidently unseemly and untrue, we are driven to say that what is from the essence of the Father, and proper to Him, is entirely the Son; for it is all one to say that God is wholly participated, and that He begets; and what does begetting signify but a Son? And thus of the Son Himself, all things partake according to the grace of the Spirit coming from Him; and this shows that the Son Himself partakes of nothing, but what is partaken from the Father, is the Son; for, as partaking of the Son Himself, we are said to partake of God; and this is what Peter said 'that you may be partakers in a divine nature 2 Peter 1:4;' as says too the Apostle, 'Do you not know, that you are a temple of God.' and, 'We are the temple of a living God.' And beholding the Son, we see the Father; for the thought and comprehension of the Son, is knowledge concerning the Father, because He is His proper offspring from His essence. And since to be partaken no one of us would ever call affection or division of God's essence (for it has been shown and acknowledged that God is participated, and to be participated is the same thing as to beget); therefore that which is begotten is neither affection nor division of that blessed essence. Hence it is not incredible that God should have a Son, the Offspring of His own essence; nor do we imply affection or division of God's essence, when we speak of 'Son' and 'Offspring;' but rather, as acknowledging the genuine, and true, and Only-begotten of God, so we believe. If then, as we have stated and are showing, what is the Offspring of the Father's essence be the Son, we cannot hesitate, rather we must be certain, that the same is the Wisdom and Word of the Father, in and through whom He creates and makes all things; and His Brightness too, in whom He enlightens all things, and is revealed to whom He will; and His Expression and Image also, in whom He is contemplated and known, wherefore 'He and His Father are one John 10:30,' and whoever looks on Him looks on the Father; and the Christ, in whom all things are redeemed, and the new creation wrought afresh. And on the other hand, the Son being such Offspring, it is not fitting, rather it is full of peril, to say, that He is a work out of nothing, or that He was not before His generation. For he who thus speaks of that which is proper to the Father's essence, already blasphemes the Father Himself; since he really thinks of Him what he falsely imagines of His offspring.

Chapter 6. Subject Continued. Third proof of the Son's eternity, viz. from other titles indicative of His coessentiality; as the Creator; One of the Blessed Trinity; as Wisdom; as Word; as Image. If the Son is a perfect Image of the Father, why is He not a Father also? Because God, being perfect, is not the origin of a race. Only the Father a Father because the Only Father, only the Son a Son because the Only Son. Men are not really fathers and really sons, but shadows of the True. The Son does not become a Father, because He has received from the Father to be immutable and ever the same

This in itself is enough to refute the Arian heresy, but its false teaching will also be clear from what follows. If God is Maker and Creator, and creates His works through the Son, and we cannot think of things that come into being except as existing through the Word, is it not blasphemous—since God is Maker—to say that His creating Word and His Wisdom once did not exist? This is the same as saying that God is not Maker, if He did not have His own proper creating Word which is from Him, but instead that by which He creates came to Him from outside, is alien to Him, and unlike in ousia. Next, let them answer this—or rather learn from it how irreligious they are in saying "Once He was not" and "He was not before His generation." For if the Word is not with the Father from everlasting, the Trinity is not everlasting. Instead, a Monad existed first, and afterwards by addition it became a Trinity. And so as time passed, it seems that what we know about God grew and took shape. Furthermore, if the Son is not the proper offspring of the Father's ousia but came to be from nothing, then the Trinity consists of nothing, and once there was not a Trinity but a Monad. The Trinity was once deficient and then complete—deficient before the Son was originated, complete when He came to be. From then on, something originated is counted together with the Creator, and what once was not receives divine worship and glory alongside Him who always existed. Even more serious, the Trinity turns out to be unlike itself, consisting of strange and alien natures and ousiai. This is another way of saying that the Trinity has an originated existence. What kind of religion is this, which is not even consistent with itself but is in the process of being completed as time goes on, and is now one way and then another way? For it will probably receive some new addition, and so on without limit, since from the very beginning it gained its existence through additions. And so clearly it could also decrease in the opposite direction, for what is added can obviously be subtracted.

17. This is of itself a sufficient refutation of the Arian heresy; however, its heterodoxy will appear also from the following:– If God be Maker and Creator, and create His works through the Son, and we cannot regard things which come to be, except as being through the Word, is it not blasphemous, God being Maker, to say, that His Framing Word and His Wisdom once was not? It is the same as saying, that God is not Maker, if He had not His proper Framing Word which is from Him, but that that by which He frames, accrues to Him from without, and is alien from Him, and unlike in essence. Next, let them tell us this — or rather learn from it how irreligious they are in saying, 'Once He was not,' and, 'He was not before His generation;'– for if the Word is not with the Father from everlasting, the Triad is not everlasting; but a Monad was first, and afterwards by addition it became a Triad; and so as time went on, it seems what we know concerning God grew and took shape. And further, if the Son is not proper offspring of the Father's essence, but of nothing has come to be, then of nothing the Triad consists, and once there was not a Triad, but a Monad; and a Triad once with deficiency, and then complete; deficient, before the Son was originated, complete when He had come to be; and henceforth a thing originated is reckoned with the Creator, and what once was not has divine worship and glory with Him who was ever. Nay, what is more serious still, the Triad is discovered to be unlike Itself, consisting of strange and alien natures and essences. And this, in other words, is saying, that the Triad has an originated consistence. What sort of a religion then is this, which is not even like itself, but is in process of completion as time goes on, and is now not thus, and then again thus? For probably it will receive some fresh accession, and so on without limit, since at first and at starting it took its consistence by way of accessions. And so undoubtedly it may decrease on the contrary, for what is added plainly admits of being subtracted.

But this is not the case—perish the thought! The Triad is not originated. There is an eternal and one Godhead in a Triad, and there is one glory of the Holy Triad. Yet you presume to divide it into different natures. You say the Father is eternal, but of the Word who is seated beside Him you say, "Once He was not." Though the Son is seated beside the Father, you think to place Him far from Him. The Triad is Creator and Framer, yet you do not fear to degrade it to the level of things that are from nothing. You do not scruple to equate servile beings with the nobility of the Triad, and to rank the King, the Lord of Sabaoth, with subjects. Stop this confusion of things that cannot be associated, or rather of things that have no being with Him who is. Such statements do not glorify and honor the Lord, but the reverse, for whoever dishonors the Son dishonors the Father also. For if the doctrine of God is now perfect in a Triad, and this is the true and only religion, and this is the good and the truth, it must have been always so—unless the good and the truth are something that came later, and the doctrine of God is completed by additions. I say it must have been eternally so. But if not eternally, then not so at present either, but at present as you suppose it was from the beginning—I mean, not a Triad now. But no Christian would tolerate such heretics. It belongs to the Greeks to introduce an originated Triad and to level it with originated things, for these do admit of deficiencies and additions. But the faith of Christians acknowledges the blessed Triad as unalterable and perfect and ever what it was, neither adding to it what is more nor imputing to it any loss (for both ideas are irreligious). Therefore it separates the Triad from all things generated, guards as indivisible the unity of the Godhead itself, and worships it. It shuns the Arian blasphemies and confesses and acknowledges that the Son always was, for He is eternal, as is the Father, of whom He is the eternal Word—to which subject let us now return again.

18. But this is not so: perish the thought; the Triad is not originated; but there is an eternal and one Godhead in a Triad, and there is one Glory of the Holy Triad. And you presume to divide it into different natures; the Father being eternal, yet you say of the Word which is seated by Him, 'Once He was not;' and, whereas the Son is seated by the Father, yet you think to place Him far from Him. The Triad is Creator and Framer, and you fear not to degrade It to things which are from nothing; you scruple not to equal servile beings to the nobility of the Triad, and to rank the King, the Lord of Sabaoth with subjects. Cease this confusion of things unassociable, or rather of things which are not with Him who is. Such statements do not glorify and honour the Lord, but the reverse; for he who dishonours the Son, dishonours also the Father. For if the doctrine of God is now perfect in a Triad, and this is the true and only Religion, and this is the good and the truth, it must have been always so, unless the good and the truth be something that came after, and the doctrine of God is completed by additions. I say, it must have been eternally so; but if not eternally, not so at present either, but at present so, as you suppose it was from the beginning — I mean, not a Triad now. But such heretics no Christian would bear; it belongs to Greeks, to introduce an originated Triad, and to level It with things originate; for these do admit of deficiencies and additions; but the faith of Christians acknowledges the blessed Triad as unalterable and perfect and ever what It was, neither adding to It what is more, nor imputing to It any loss (for both ideas are irreligious), and therefore it dissociates It from all things generated, and it guards as indivisible and worships the unity of the Godhead Itself; and shuns the Arian blasphemies, and confesses and acknowledges that the Son was ever; for He is eternal, as is the Father, of whom He is the Eternal Word, — to which subject let us now return again.

If God exists and is called the Fountain of wisdom and life—as He says through Jeremiah, "They have forsaken Me the Fountain of living waters," and again, "A glorious high throne from the beginning, is the place of our sanctuary; O Lord, the Hope of Israel, all that forsake You shall be ashamed, and they that depart from Me shall be written in the earth, because they have forsaken the Lord, the Fountain of living waters;" and in the book of Baruch it is written, "You have forsaken the Fountain of wisdom"—this means that life and wisdom are not foreign to the ousia of the Fountain, but are proper to it, and were never at any time without existence, but always existed. Now the Son is all this, who says, "I am the Life," and, "I Wisdom dwell with prudence." Is it not then irreligious to say, "Once the Son was not?" For it is the same as saying, "Once the Fountain was dry, destitute of Life and Wisdom." But then it would cease to be a fountain; for what does not beget from itself is not a fountain. What a load of absurdity! For God promises that those who do His will shall be as a fountain whose water does not fail, saying through Isaiah the prophet, "And the Lord shall satisfy your soul in drought, and make your bones fat; and you shall be like a watered garden, and like a spring of water, whose waters fail not." And yet these people, though God is called and is a Fountain of wisdom, dare to insult Him as barren and void of His proper Wisdom. But their teaching is false; truth witnesses that God is the eternal Fountain of His proper Wisdom; and if the Fountain is eternal, the Wisdom also must be eternal. For in it all things were made, as David says in the Psalm, "In Wisdom have You made them all;" and Solomon says, "The Lord by Wisdom has formed the earth, by understanding has He established the heavens." And this Wisdom is the Word, and through Him, as John says, "all things were made," and "without Him was made not one thing." And this Word is Christ; for "there is One God, the Father, from whom are all things, and we for Him; and One Lord Jesus Christ, through whom are all things, and we through Him." And if all things are through Him, He Himself is not to be counted with that "all." For whoever dares to call Him, through whom all things exist, one of that "all," will surely have similar ideas concerning God, from whom are all. But if he shrinks from this as improper, and excludes God from that all, it is only consistent that he should also exclude from that all the Only-Begotten Son, as being proper to the Father's ousia. And if He is not one of the all, it is sinful to say concerning Him, "He was not," and "He was not before His generation." Such words may be used of the creatures; but as to the Son, He is such as the Father is, of whose ousia He is proper Offspring, Word, and Wisdom. For this is proper to the Son, as regards the Father, and this shows that the Father is proper to the Son; so that we may neither say that God was ever without Word, nor that the Son was non-existent. For why a Son, if not from Him? Or why Word and Wisdom, if not always proper to Him?

19. If God be, and be called, the Fountain of wisdom and life — as He says by Jeremiah, 'They have forsaken Me the Fountain of living waters Jeremiah 2:13;' and again, 'A glorious high throne from the beginning, is the place of our sanctuary; O Lord, the Hope of Israel, all that forsake You shall be ashamed, and they that depart from Me shall be written in the earth, because they have forsaken the Lord, the Fountain of living waters;' and in the book of Baruch it is written, 'You have forsaken the Fountain of wisdom Baruch 3:12,'– this implies that life and wisdom are not foreign to the Essence of the Fountain, but are proper to It, nor were at any time without existence, but were always. Now the Son is all this, who says, 'I am the Life John 14:6,' and, 'I Wisdom dwell with prudence Proverbs 8:12.' Is it not then irreligious to say, 'Once the Son was not?' for it is all one with saying, 'Once the Fountain was dry, destitute of Life and Wisdom.' But a fountain it would then cease to be; for what begets not from itself, is not a fountain. What a load of extravagance! For God promises that those who do His will shall be as a fountain which the water fails not, saying by Isaiah the prophet, 'And the Lord shall satisfy your soul in drought, and make your bones fat; and you shall be like a watered garden, and like a spring of water, whose waters fail not Isaiah 58:11.' And yet these, whereas God is called and is a Fountain of wisdom, dare to insult Him as barren and void of His proper Wisdom. But their doctrine is false; truth witnessing that God is the eternal Fountain of His proper Wisdom; and, if the Fountain be eternal, the Wisdom also must needs be eternal. For in It were all things made, as David says in the Psalm, 'In Wisdom have You made them all;' and Solomon says, 'The Lord by Wisdom has formed the earth, by understanding has He established the heavens Proverbs 3:19.' And this Wisdom is the Word, and by Him, as John says, 'all things were made,' and 'without Him was made not one thing.' And this Word is Christ; for 'there is One God, the Father, from whom are all things, and we for Him; and One Lord Jesus Christ, through whom are all things, and we through Him 1 Corinthians 8:6.' And if all things are through Him, He Himself is not to be reckoned with that 'all.' For he who dares to call Him, through whom are things, one of that 'all,' surely will have like speculations concerning God, from whom are all. But if he shrinks from this as unseemly, and excludes God from that all, it is but consistent that he should also exclude from that all the Only-Begotten Son, as being proper to the Father's essence. And, if He be not one of the all, it is sin to say concerning Him, 'He was not,' and 'He was not before His generation.' Such words may be used of the creatures; but as to the Son, He is such as the Father is, of whose essence He is proper Offspring, Word, and Wisdom. For this is proper to the Son, as regards the Father, and this shows that the Father is proper to the Son; that we may neither say that God was ever without Word, nor that the Son was non-existent. For wherefore a Son, if not from Him? Or wherefore Word and Wisdom, if not ever proper to Him?

When, then, was God without that which is proper to Him? Or how can anyone think that what is proper to Him is foreign and different in ousia? For all other things, according to the nature of created things, have no likeness in ousia with the Maker. They are external to Him, made by the Word through His grace and will, and so can cease to exist if He who made them so pleases—for such is the nature of created things. But regarding what is proper to the Father's ousia (for we have already determined this to be the Son), what outrageous irreligion it is to say that "This comes from nothing" and that "It was not before generation," but came from outside and can at some time cease to exist again! Anyone who reflects on this will see how this heresy diminishes the perfection and fullness of the Father's ousia. However, he will see its inappropriateness even more clearly if he considers that the Son is the Image and Radiance of the Father, and Expression, and Truth. For if, when Light exists, there exists with it its Image—namely, Radiance—and when a Subsistence (hypostasis) exists, there exists of it the entire Expression, and when a Father exists, there exists His Truth (namely, the Son), then let them consider what depths of irreligion they fall into when they make time the measure of the Image and Form of the Godhead. For if the Son was not before His generation, Truth was not always in God, which would be sinful to say. Since the Father existed, there always existed in Him the Truth, which is the Son, who says, "I am the Truth." And the Subsistence existing, of course there was immediately its Expression and Image, for God's Image is not drawn from outside, but God Himself has begotten it. In it, seeing Himself, He has delight, as the Son Himself says, "I was His delight." When, then, did the Father not see Himself in His own Image? Or when did He not have delight, that anyone should dare to say, "the Image is out of nothing" and "The Father had no delight before the Image came into existence"? And how could the Maker and Creator see Himself in a created and originated ousia? For such as the Father is, such must the Image be.

20. When then was God without that which is proper to Him? Or how can a man consider that which is proper, as foreign and alien in essence? For other things, according to the nature of things originate, are without likeness in essence with the Maker; but are external to Him, made by the Word at His grace and will, and thus admit of ceasing to be, if it so pleases Him who made them; for such is the nature of things originate. But as to what is proper to the Father's essence (for this we have already found to be the Son), what daring is it in irreligion to say that 'This comes from nothing,' and that 'It was not before generation,' but was adventitious, and can at some time cease to be again? Let a person only dwell upon this thought, and he will discern how the perfection and the plenitude of the Father's essence is impaired by this heresy; however, he will see its unseemliness still more clearly, if he considers that the Son is the Image and Radiance of the Father, and Expression, and Truth. For if, when Light exists, there be withal its Image, viz. Radiance, and, a Subsistence existing, there be of it the entire Expression, and, a Father existing, there be His Truth (viz. the Son); let them consider what depths of irreligion they fall into, who make time the measure of the Image and Form of the Godhead. For if the Son was not before His generation, Truth was not always in God, which it were a sin to say; for, since the Father was, there was ever in Him the Truth, which is the Son, who says, 'I am the Truth John 14:6.' And the Subsistence existing, of course there was immediately its Expression and Image; for God's Image is not delineated from without, but God Himself has begotten it; in which seeing Himself, He has delight, as the Son Himself says, 'I was His delight Proverbs 8:30.' When then did the Father not see Himself in His own Image? Or when had He not delight, that a man should dare to say, 'the Image is out of nothing,' and 'The Father had not delight before the Image was originated?' and how should the Maker and Creator see Himself in a created and originated essence? For such as is the Father, such must be the Image.

Let us continue by examining the attributes of the Father, and we will come to know whether this Image is truly His. The Father is eternal, immortal, powerful, light, King, Sovereign, God, Lord, Creator, and Maker. These attributes must be present in the Image to make it true that whoever has seen the Son has seen the Father. If the Son is not all these things, but as the Arians claim is originate and not eternal, then this is not a true Image of the Father—unless they abandon all shame and go on to say that the title of Image given to the Son does not indicate a similar ousia but is merely His name. But this, you enemies of Christ, is not an Image, nor is it an expression. For what resemblance does something created from nothing have to Him who brought what was nothing into being? Or how can that which once was not be like Him who is, since it falls short of Him in once not existing and in having its place among originate things? Nevertheless, wanting the Son to be such, the Arians have devised arguments like this: "If the Son is the Father's offspring and Image, and is like the Father in all things, then it necessarily follows that just as He was begotten, so He begets, and He too becomes father of a son. And again, the one begotten from Him begets in turn, and so on without limit; for this is what it means to make the Begotten like the one who begot Him." These foes of God are truly authors of blasphemy! Rather than confess that the Son is the Father's Image, they conceive material and earthly ideas about the Father Himself, attributing to Him divisions and emissions and outflows. If God were like man, then let Him become a parent like man, so that His Son would be father of another, and so on in succession from one to another, until the series they imagine grows into a multitude of gods. But if God is not like man—and He is not—we must not attribute to Him the characteristics of man. For animals and humans, after a Creator has brought them into being, are begotten through succession; and the son, having been begotten by a father who was himself a son, accordingly becomes in his turn a father to a son, inheriting from his father that by which he himself came to be. Therefore in such cases there is not, properly speaking, either a real father or a real son, nor do the father and son remain fixed in their respective roles, for the son himself becomes a father, being son of his father but father of his son. But it is not so in the Godhead, for God is not like man. The Father is not from a father; therefore He does not beget one who will become a father. Nor is the Son from an effluence of the Father, nor is He begotten from a father who was himself begotten; therefore He is not begotten in such a way as to beget. Thus it belongs to the Godhead alone that the Father is properly Father and the Son properly Son, and in Them and Them only does it hold that the Father is forever Father and the Son forever Son.

21. Proceed we then to consider the attributes of the Father, and we shall come to know whether this Image is really His. The Father is eternal, immortal, powerful, light, King, Sovereign, God, Lord, Creator, and Maker. These attributes must be in the Image, to make it true that he 'that has seen' the Son 'has seen the Father John 14:9.' If the Son be not all this, but, as the Arians consider, originate, and not eternal, this is not a true Image of the Father, unless indeed they give up shame, and go on to say, that the title of Image, given to the Son, is not a token of a similar essence, but His name only. But this, on the other hand, O you enemies of Christ, is not an Image, nor is it an Expression. For what is the likeness of what is out of nothing to Him who brought what was nothing into being? Or how can that which is not, be like Him that is, being short of Him in once not being, and in its having its place among things originate? However, such the Arians wishing Him to be, devised for themselves arguments such as this –'If the Son is the Father's offspring and Image, and is like in all things to the Father, then it necessarily holds that as He is begotten, so He begets, and He too becomes father of a son. And again, he who is begotten from Him, begets in his turn, and so on without limit; for this is to make the Begotten like Him that begot Him.' Authors of blasphemy, verily, are these foes of God! Who, sooner than confess that the Son is the Father's Image, conceive material and earthly ideas concerning the Father Himself, ascribing to Him severings and effluences and influences. If then God be as man, let Him become also a parent as man, so that His Son should be father of another, and so in succession one from another, till the series they imagine grows into a multitude of gods. But if God be not as man, as He is not, we must not impute to Him the attributes of man. For brutes and men, after a Creator has begun them, are begotten by succession; and the son, having been begotten of a father who was a son, becomes accordingly in his turn a father to a son, in inheriting from his father that by which he himself has come to be. Hence in such instances there is not, properly speaking, either father or son, nor do the father and the son stay in their respective characters, for the son himself becomes a father, being son of his father, but father of his son. But it is not so in the Godhead; for not as man is God; for the Father is not from a father; therefore does He not beget one who shall become a father; nor is the Son from effluence of the Father, nor is He begotten from a father that was begotten; therefore neither is He begotten so as to beget. Thus it belongs to the Godhead alone, that the Father is properly father, and the Son properly son, and in Them, and Them only, does it hold that the Father is ever Father and the Son ever Son.

Therefore, whoever asks why the Son does not beget a son must also ask why the Father did not have a father. But both questions are improper and full of impiety. For just as the Father is always Father and could never become Son, so the Son is always Son and could never become Father. For in this way He is shown to be the Father's Expression and Image, remaining what He is and not changing, but receiving from the Father to be one and the same. So if the Father changes, let the Image change, for this is how the Image and Radiance relates to Him who begot It. But if the Father is unchangeable, and He continues to be what He is, then necessarily the Image also continues to be what He is and will not change. Now He is Son from the Father, therefore He will not become different from what is proper to the Father's ousia. So these foolish people have devised this objection pointlessly, wanting to separate the Image from the Father so they might reduce the Son to the level of created things.

22. Therefore he who asks why the Son is not to beget a son, must inquire why the Father had not a father. But both suppositions are unseemly and full of impiety. For as the Father is ever Father and never could become Son, so the Son is ever Son and never could become Father. For in this rather is He shown to be the Father's Expression and Image, remaining what He is and not changing, but thus receiving from the Father to be one and the same. If then the Father change, let the Image change; for so is the Image and Radiance in its relation towards Him who begot It. But if the Father is unalterable, and what He is that He continues, necessarily does the Image also continue what He is, and will not alter. Now He is Son from the Father; therefore He will not become other than is proper to the Father's essence. Idly then have the foolish ones devised this objection also, wishing to separate the Image from the Father, that they might level the Son with things originated.

Chapter 7. Objections to the Foregoing Proof. Whether, in the generation of the Son, God made One that was already, or One that was not.

Ranking him among these created things according to Eusebius's teaching, and considering him to be like the things that come into existence through him, Arius and his followers turned away from the truth. When they started this heresy, they used to go around with dishonest phrases they had collected. Even now, some of them approach young men in the marketplace and question them—not from divine Scripture, but as if overflowing with "the abundance of their heart"—saying: "Did the One who exists make someone who did not exist, from what did not exist, or someone who already existed? So did he make the Son when the Son already existed, or when he did not yet exist?" And again, "Is the Unoriginate one or two?" and "Does he have free will, and yet not change by his own choice, since he has a changeable nature? For he is not like a stone that remains unmoved by itself." Then they turn to foolish women and address them in this manner suited to women: "Did you have a son before giving birth? Well, just as you did not, neither did the Son of God exist before his generation." In such language do these disgraceful men amuse themselves and revel, comparing God to humans, pretending to be Christians while changing God's glory "into an image made like to corruptible man."

22 ( continued). Ranking Him among these, according to the teaching of Eusebius, and accounting Him such as the things which come into being through Him, Arius and his fellows revolted from the truth, and used, when they commenced this heresy, to go about with dishonest phrases which they had got together; nay, up to this time some of them, when they fall in with boys in the market-place, question them, not out of divine Scripture, but thus, as if bursting with 'the abundance of their heart Matthew 12:34;'– 'He who is, did He make him who was not, from that which was [not], or him who was? Therefore did He make the Son, whereas He was, or whereas He was not?' And again, 'Is the Unoriginate one or two?' and 'Has He free will, and yet does not alter at His own choice, as being of an alterable nature? For He is not as a stone to remain by Himself unmoveable.' Next they turn to silly women, and address them in turn in this womanish language; 'Had you a son before bearing? Now, as you had not, so neither was the Son of God before His generation.' In such language do the disgraceful men sport and revel, and liken God to men, pretending to be Christians, but changing God's glory 'into an image made like to corruptible man. '

Words this foolish and ignorant deserved no answer at all. However, to prevent their heresy from appearing to have any foundation, it may be right—even if we have to go out of our way—to refute them here, especially for the sake of the gullible women who are so easily deceived by them. When they speak this way, they should ask a builder whether he can construct something without materials. And if he cannot, does it follow that God could not make the universe without materials? Or they should ask anyone whether they can exist without occupying space. And if they cannot, does it follow that God exists in a place? In this way they might be put to shame even by their own audience. Or why is it that when they hear God has a Son, they deny it by comparing Him to themselves, but when they hear that He creates and makes, they no longer raise objections based on human experience? They ought to apply the same reasoning to creation as well—to insist that God needs materials, and thus deny that He is Creator—until they end up groveling alongside the Manichees. But if the simple idea of God transcends such thoughts, and upon first hearing a person believes and knows that He exists, not as we exist but as God exists, and creates not as man creates but as God creates, then it is clear that He also begets not as men beget, but begets as God. For God does not pattern Himself after man. Rather, we men are also called fathers of our own children because God is properly and alone truly Father of His Son. For from Him "every fatherhood in heaven and earth is named" (Ephesians 3:15). Their arguments may seem to make sense on the surface, but if anyone examines them with reason, they will be found worthy of much ridicule and mockery.

23. Words so senseless and dull deserved no answer at all; however, lest their heresy appear to have any foundation, it may be right, though we go out of the way for it, to refute them even here, especially on account of the silly women who are so readily deceived by them. When they thus speak, they should have inquired of an architect, whether he can build without materials; and if he cannot, whether it follows that God could not make the universe without materials. Or they should have asked every man, whether he can be without place; and if he cannot, whether it follows that God is in place, that so they may be brought to shame even by their audience. Or why is it that, on hearing that God has a Son, they deny Him by the parallel of themselves; whereas, if they hear that He creates and makes, no longer do they object their human ideas? They ought in creation also to entertain the same, and to supply God with materials, and so deny Him to be Creator, till they end in grovelling with Manichees. But if the bare idea of God transcends such thoughts, and, on very first hearing, a man believes and knows that He is in being, not as we are, and yet in being as God, and creates not as man creates, but yet creates as God, it is plain that He begets also not as men beget, but begets as God. For God does not make man His pattern; but rather we men, for that God is properly, and alone truly, Father of His Son, are also called fathers of our own children; for of Him 'is every fatherhood in heaven and earth named Ephesians 3:15.' And their positions, while unscrutinized, have a show of sense; but if any one scrutinize them by reason, they will be found to incur much derision and mockery.

First of all, their opening question is extremely dull and unclear. They don't explain who they're asking about in a way that allows for an answer. Instead, they speak in abstract terms: "He who is," "him who is not." So who exactly "is," and what exactly "is not," O Arians? Who "is," and who "is not"? What things are said "to be," and what things "not to be"? The One who is can make things that are not, things that are, and things that were before. For example, a carpenter, a goldsmith, and a potter each works with pre-existing materials according to his craft, making whatever items he wishes. And God Himself, having taken the dust of the earth that already existed and had already been brought into being, fashions man. Yet that very earth, which did not exist at one time, He made at a certain point through His own Word. If this is what their question means, then clearly the created order did not exist before it originated, while human craftsmen work with existing materials. Thus their reasoning is inconsistent, since both "what is" comes into being and "what is not" comes into being, as these examples demonstrate. But if they're speaking about God and His Word, let them complete their question properly and then ask: Was the God "who is" ever without Reason? And since He is Light, was He ever without radiance? Or was He always Father of the Word? Or ask it this way: Has the Father "who is" made the Word "who is not," or does He have His Word always with Him as the proper offspring of His ousia? This will expose the fact that they are simply being presumptuous and engaging in sophisms about God and the One who is from Him. Who indeed can bear to hear them say that God was ever without Reason? This is what they fall into a second time, though they try in vain to escape it and hide it with their sophisms. Indeed, one would prefer not to hear them arguing at all that God was not always Father but became so later (which is necessary for their fantasy that His Word once was not), considering the number of proofs already presented against them. Besides, John says, "The Word was," and Paul writes, "Who being the brightness of His glory," and "Who is over all, God blessed forever. Amen."

24. For first of all, as to their first question, which is such as this, how dull and vague it is! They do not explain who it is they ask about, so as to allow of an answer, but they say abstractedly, 'He who is,' 'him who is not.' Who then 'is,' and what 'are not,' O Arians? Or who 'is,' and who 'is not?' what are said 'to be,' what 'not to be?' for He that is, can make things which are not, and which are, and which were before. For instance, carpenter, and goldsmith, and potter, each, according to his own art, works upon materials previously existing, making what vessels he pleases; and the God of all Himself, having taken the dust of the earth existing and already brought to be, fashions man; that very earth, however, whereas it was not once, He has at one time made by His own Word. If then this is the meaning of their question, the creature on the one hand plainly was not before its origination, and men, on the other, work the existing material; and thus their reasoning is inconsequent, since both 'what is' becomes, and 'what is not' becomes, as these instances show. But if they speak concerning God and His Word, let them complete their question and then ask, Was the God, 'who is,' ever without Reason? And, whereas He is Light, was He ray-less? Or was He always Father of the Word? Or again in this manner. Has the Father 'who is' made the Word 'who is not,' or has He ever with Him His Word, as the proper offspring of His substance? This will show them that they do but presume and venture on sophisms about God and Him who is from Him. Who indeed can bear to hear them say that God was ever without Reason? This is what they fall into a second time, though endeavouring in vain to escape it and to hide it with their sophisms. Nay, one would fain not hear them disputing at all, that God was not always Father, but became so afterwards (which is necessary for their fantasy, that His Word once was not), considering the number of the proofs already adduced against them; while John besides says, 'The Word was John 1:1,' and Paul again writes, 'Who being the brightness of His glory Hebrews 1:3,' and, 'Who is over all, God blessed forever. Amen Romans 9:5.'

Perhaps they should have remained silent. But since they have not, we need to answer their shameless question with a bold response. Maybe when they see the contradictions that afflict their own position, they will stop fighting against the truth. So, after many prayers that God would be gracious to us, we might ask them in return: Did God, who is, come into being when he previously was not? Or does he exist even before his coming into being? Since he is, did he make himself? Or is he from nothing—being nothing beforehand and then suddenly appearing? Such an inquiry is improper, both improper and very blasphemous, yet it parallels their own. For the answer they give is full of irreligion. But if it is blasphemous and utterly irreligious to ask such questions about God, then it will be blasphemous as well to make similar inquiries about his Word. However, to expose how senseless and dull their question is, we must answer as follows: Since God is, he always has been; therefore, since the Father is eternal, his Radiance is eternal—which is his Word. And again, God who is has from himself his Word who also is. Neither was the Word added when he did not exist before, nor was the Father ever without Reason. For this attack on the Son makes the blasphemy rebound upon the Father—as if he devised for himself a Wisdom, Word, and Son from outside. For whichever of these titles you use, you denote the offspring from the Father, as has been said. So their objection does not hold. And naturally so, for in denying the Logos they consequently ask questions that are illogical. Just as if someone saw the sun and then inquired about its radiance, saying, "Did that which is make that which was, or that which was not," he would be considered not to reason sensibly but to be utterly confused—because he imagined what comes from the Light to be external to it and was raising questions about when and where and whether it was made—in the same way, to speculate about the Son and the Father in this manner and to make such inquiries is far greater madness. For it is to conceive of the Word of the Father as external to him and to foolishly call the natural offspring a work, with the claim "He was not before his generation." Let them also take this answer to their question: The Father who was made the Son who was, for "the Word was made flesh," and whereas he was Son of God, he made him at the consummation of the ages also Son of Man—unless, following the Samosatene, they claim that he did not even exist at all until he became man.

25. They had best have been silent; but since it is otherwise, it remains to meet their shameless question with a bold retort. Perhaps on seeing the counter absurdities which beset themselves, they may cease to fight against the truth. After many prayers then that God would be gracious to us, thus we might ask them in turn; God who is, has He so become, whereas He was not? Or is He also before His coming into being? Whereas He is, did He make Himself, or is He of nothing, and being nothing before, did He suddenly appear Himself? Unseemly is such an enquiry, both unseemly and very blasphemous, yet parallel with theirs; for the answer they make abounds in irreligion. But if it be blasphemous and utterly irreligious thus to inquire about God, it will be blasphemous too to make the like inquiries about His Word. However, by way of exposing a question so senseless and so dull, it is necessary to answer thus:– whereas God is, He was eternally; since then the Father is ever, His Radiance ever is, which is His Word. And again, God who is, has from Himself His Word who also is; and neither has the Word been added, whereas He was not before, nor was the Father once without Reason. For this assault upon the Son makes the blasphemy recoil upon the Father; as if He devised for Himself a Wisdom, and Word, and Son from without; for whichever of these titles you use, you denote the offspring from the Father, as has been said. So that this their objection does not hold; and naturally; for denying the Logos they in consequence ask questions which are illogical. As then if a person saw the sun, and then inquired concerning its radiance, and said, 'Did that which is make that which was, or that which was not,' he would be held not to reason sensibly, but to be utterly mazed, because he fancied what is from the Light to be external to it, and was raising questions, when and where and whether it were made; in like manner, thus to speculate concerning the Son and the Father and thus to inquire, is far greater madness, for it is to conceive of the Word of the Father as external to Him, and to idly call the natural offspring a work, with the avowal, 'He was not before His generation.' Nay, let them over and above take this answer to their question — The Father who was, made the Son who was, for 'the Word was made flesh John 1:14;' and, whereas He was Son of God, He made Him in consummation of the ages also Son of Man, unless forsooth, after the Samosatene, they affirm that He did not even exist at all, till He became man.

This is a sufficient response from us to their first question. Now it's your turn, Arians: remembering your own words, tell us whether the one who had a need required someone who already existed for the creation of the universe, or someone who did not exist? You said that he made his Son for himself out of nothing, as an instrument by which to make the universe. Which is greater: the one who needs something, or the one who supplies what is needed? Or doesn't each one fill the lack of the other? You actually prove the weakness of the Maker if he didn't have the power by himself to make the universe, but had to provide himself with an instrument from outside, like a carpenter or shipbuilder who can't work without an adze and saw! Can anything be more irreligious? Yet why should anyone dwell on how outrageous this is, when enough has already been said to show that their doctrine is mere fantasy?

26. This is sufficient from us in answer to their first question. And now on your part, O Arians, remembering your own words, tell us whether He who was needed one who was not for the framing of the universe, or one who was? You said that He made for Himself His Son out of nothing, as an instrument whereby to make the universe. Which then is superior, that which needs or that which supplies the need? Or does not each supply the deficiency of the other? You rather prove the weakness of the Maker, if He had not power of Himself to make the universe, but provided for Himself an instrument from without, as carpenter might do or shipwright, unable to work anything without adze and saw! Can anything be more irreligious? Yet why should one dwell on its heinousness, when enough has gone before to show that their doctrine is a mere fantasy?

Chapter 8. Objections Continued. Whether we may decide the question by the parallel of human sons, which are born later than their parents. No, for the force of the analogy lies in the idea of connaturality. Time is not involved in the idea of Son, but is adventitious to it, and does not attach to God, because He is without parts and passions. The titles Word and Wisdom guard our thoughts of Him and His Son from this misconception. God not a Father, as a Creator, in posse from eternity, because creation does not relate to the essence of God, as generation does.

Nor is it necessary to answer their other very simplistic and foolish question, which they put to gullible women—or rather, no answer is needed beyond what has already been given: that it is not appropriate to measure divine generation by the nature of human beings. However, so that they may once again condemn themselves, it is worthwhile to engage them on the same ground in this way: Clearly, if they question parents about their son, let them consider where the child who is begotten comes from. For even though the parent did not have a son before begetting him, still, after having him, he had him not as something external or foreign, but as from himself, and belonging to his ousia and being his exact image, so that the former is seen in the latter, and the latter is contemplated in the former. If then they conclude from human examples that generation implies time, why do they not from the same examples infer that it implies the natural and the proper, instead of extracting like a serpent from the earth only what turns to poison? Those who ask parents, "Did you have a son before you begot him?" should add, "And if you had a son, did you purchase him from outside as you would a house or any other possession?" And then they would be answered, "He is not from outside, but from myself. For things which are from outside are possessions and pass from one person to another; but my son is from me, proper to and similar to my ousia, not having become mine from another, but begotten of me; therefore I too am wholly in him, while I remain myself what I am." For this is how it is: although the parent is distinct in time, being human and having himself come to be in time, he too would have had his child coexistent with him always, except that his nature was a constraint and made it impossible. For Levi too was already in the loins of his great-grandfather before his own actual generation or that of his grandfather. When then the man reaches that age at which nature supplies the power, immediately, with nature unrestrained, he becomes father of the son from himself.

26. ( continued). Nor is answer needful to their other very simple and foolish inquiry, which they put to silly women; or none besides that which has been already given, namely, that it is not suitable to measure divine generation by the nature of men. However, that as before they may pass judgment on themselves, it is well to meet them on the same ground, thus:– Plainly, if they inquire of parents concerning their son, let them consider whence is the child which is begotten. For, granting the parent had not a son before his begetting, still, after having him, he had him, not as external or as foreign, but as from himself, and proper to his essence and his exact image, so that the former is beheld in the latter, and the latter is contemplated in the former. If then they assume from human examples that generation implies time, why not from the same infer that it implies the Natural and the Proper, instead of extracting serpent-like from the earth only what turns to poison? Those who ask of parents, and say, 'Had you a son before you begot him?' should add, 'And if you had a son, did you purchase him from without as a house or any other possession.' And then you would be answered, 'He is not from without, but from myself. For things which are from without are possessions, and pass from one to another; but my son is from me, proper and similar to my essence, not become mine from another, but begotten of me; wherefore I too am wholly in him, while I remain myself what I am.' For so it is; though the parent be distinct in time, as being man, who himself has come to be in time, yet he too would have had his child ever coexistent with him, but that his nature was a restraint and made it impossible. For Levi too was already in the loins of his great-grandfather, before his own actual generation, or that of his grandfather. When then the man comes to that age at which nature supplies the power, immediately, with nature, unrestrained, he becomes father of the son from himself.

Therefore, if when asking parents about children they get the answer that children who exist by nature are not from outside but from their parents, let them confess in the same way concerning the Word of God that He is simply from the Father. And if they raise questions about time, let them explain what would prevent God—for it is necessary to prove their irreligion on the very ground where they make their mockery—let them tell us what there is to prevent God from being always Father of the Son, since it is undeniable that what is begotten must be from its father. Moreover, they will pass judgment on themselves in attributing such things to God if, just as they questioned women about time, they also ask the sun about its radiance and the fountain about its stream. They will find that these offspring always exist together with the things from which they come. And if parents like these share both nature and duration in common with their children, why do they not openly state their irreligion if they suppose God is inferior to things that come into being? But if they do not dare to say this openly, and if the Son is confessed to be not from outside but a natural offspring from the Father, and if there is nothing that restrains God (for He is not like a human being, but greater than the sun, or rather the God of the sun), it follows that the Word is from Him and exists eternally with Him, through whom the Father also caused all things that were not to come into being. That the Son does not come from nothing but is eternal and from the Father is therefore certain even from the nature of the case, and the heretics' question to parents exposes their perverseness, for they acknowledge the point about nature but have now been put to shame on the point about time.

27. Therefore, if on asking parents about children, they get for answer, that children which are by nature are not from without, but from their parents, let them confess in like manner concerning the Word of God, that He is simply from the Father. And if they make a question of the time, let them say what is to restrain God — for it is necessary to prove their irreligion on the very ground on which their scoff is made — let them tell us, what is there to restrain God from being always Father of the Son; for that what is begotten must be from its father is undeniable. Moreover, they will pass judgment on themselves in attributing such things to God, if, as they questioned women on the subject of time, so they inquire of the sun concerning its radiance, and of the fountain concerning its issue. They will find that these, though an offspring, always exist with those things from which they are. And if parents, such as these, have in common with their children nature and duration, why, if they suppose God inferior to things that come to be, do they not openly say out their own irreligion? But if they do not dare to say this openly, and the Son is confessed to be, not from without, but a natural offspring from the Father, and that there is nothing which is a restraint to God (for not as man is He, but more than the sun, or rather the God of the sun), it follows that the Word is from Him and is ever co-existent with Him, through whom also the Father caused that all things which were not should be. That then the Son comes not of nothing but is eternal and from the Father, is certain even from the nature of the case; and the question of the heretics to parents exposes their perverseness; for they confess the point of nature, and now have been put to shame on the point of time.

As we said before, we repeat now that the divine generation must not be compared to human nature, nor should the Son be considered a part of God, nor should the generation imply any passion at all. God is not like man, for men beget through passion, having a changeable nature that must wait for certain periods because of its weakness. But this cannot be so with God, for He is not composed of parts. Being impassible and simple, He is Father of the Son impassibly and indivisibly. This is strongly evidenced and proved by divine Scripture. For the Word of God is His Son, and the Son is the Father's Word and Wisdom. And the Word and Wisdom is neither a creature nor a part of Him whose Word He is, nor an offspring begotten through passion. Uniting these two titles, Scripture speaks of 'Son' in order to proclaim the natural and true offspring of His essence. On the other hand, so that no one may think of the Offspring in human terms, while signifying His essence it also calls Him Word, Wisdom, and Radiance—to teach us that the generation was impassible, eternal, and worthy of God. What affection, then, or what part of the Father is the Word and the Wisdom and the Radiance? This much can be impressed even on these foolish men. For just as they asked women about God's Son, let them ask men about the Word, and they will find that the word they speak is neither an affection of them nor a part of their mind. But if such is the word of men, who are subject to passion and divisible, why do they speculate about passions and parts in the case of the immaterial and indivisible God? They do this so that under the pretense of reverence they may deny the true and natural generation of the Son. Enough was said above to show that the offspring from God is not an affection, and now it has been shown in particular that the Word is not begotten according to affection. The same can be said of Wisdom. God is not like man, nor must they think of Him in human terms here. For while men are capable of wisdom, God partakes in nothing but is Himself the Father of His own Wisdom, and those who partake of it are given the name of wise. And this Wisdom is not a passion or a part, but an offspring proper to the Father. Therefore He is always Father, nor is the character of Father something added to God, lest He seem changeable. For if it is good that He be Father but He has not always been Father, then good has not always been in Him.

28. As we said above, so now we repeat, that the divine generation must not be compared to the nature of men, nor the Son considered to be part of God, nor the generation to imply any passion whatever; God is not as man; for men beget passibly, having a transitive nature, which waits for periods by reason of its weakness. But with God this cannot be; for He is not composed of parts, but being impassible and simple, He is impassibly and indivisibly Father of the Son. This again is strongly evidenced and proved by divine Scripture. For the Word of God is His Son, and the Son is the Father's Word and Wisdom; and Word and Wisdom is neither creature nor part of Him whose Word He is, nor an offspring passibly begotten. Uniting then the two titles, Scripture speaks of 'Son,' in order to herald the natural and true offspring of His essence; and, on the other hand, that none may think of the Offspring humanly, while signifying His essence, it also calls Him Word, Wisdom, and Radiance; to teach us that the generation was impassible, and eternal, and worthy of God. What affection then, or what part of the Father is the Word and the Wisdom and the Radiance? So much may be impressed even on these men of folly; for as they asked women concerning God's Son, so let them inquire of men concerning the Word, and they will find that the word which they put forth is neither an affection of them nor a part of their mind. But if such be the word of men, who are passible and partitive, why speculate they about passions and parts in the instance of the immaterial and indivisible God, that under pretence of reverence they may deny the true and natural generation of the Son? Enough was said above to show that the offspring from God is not an affection; and now it has been shown in particular that the Word is not begotten according to affection. The same may be said of Wisdom; God is not as man; nor must they here think humanly of Him. For, whereas men are capable of wisdom, God partakes in nothing, but is Himself the Father of His own Wisdom, of which whoever partake are given the name of wise. And this Wisdom too is not a passion, nor a part, but an Offspring proper to the Father. Wherefore He is ever Father, nor is the character of Father adventitious to God, lest He seem alterable; for if it is good that He be Father, but has not ever been Father, then good has not ever been in Him.

They ask: "Look, God was always a Maker, and the power to create isn't something added to Him later. Does it follow, then, that because He is the Maker of all things, His works must also be eternal? And would it be wrong to say of them too that they didn't exist before they were made?" These Arians are foolish. What similarity is there between a Son and a created work that they should compare a father's role with a maker's role? How is it that, given the difference between offspring and work that has been demonstrated, they remain so poorly taught? Let me say again: a work is external to one's nature, but a son is the proper offspring of one's essence (ousia). It follows that a work need not always exist, because the workman makes it when he chooses. But offspring is not subject to will—it is proper to the essence. A man can exist and can be called a Maker even when his works don't yet exist, but he cannot be called or actually be a father unless a son exists. If they ask curiously why God, though He always had the power to create, doesn't always create (though this too is presumptuous madness, for "who has known the mind of the Lord, or who has been His counselor?" and how shall "the thing formed say to the potter, 'why did you make me like this?'"), yet not to leave even a weak argument unaddressed, they must be told this: although God always had the power to create, the created things themselves did not have the power to be eternal. For they come from nothing and therefore didn't exist before they were made. But things that didn't exist before they were made—how could they coexist with the ever-existing God? Therefore God, considering what was good for them, made them all when He saw that once they were created, they would be able to endure. And just as, though He was able even from the beginning in the time of Adam, Noah, or Moses to send His own Word, He didn't send Him until the end of the ages (for He saw this was good for all creation), so also He made created things when He willed and as was good for them. But the Son, not being a created work but proper to the Father's offspring, always exists. For since the Father always exists, what is proper to His essence must always exist, and this is His Word and His Wisdom. That creatures don't exist doesn't diminish the Maker, for He has the power to make them when He wills. But for the offspring not to exist eternally with the Father would diminish the perfection of His essence. Therefore His works were made when He willed, through His Word, but the Son is eternally the proper offspring of the Father's essence.

29. But, observe, say they, God was always a Maker, nor is the power of framing adventitious to Him; does it follow then, that, because He is the Framer of all, therefore His works also are eternal, and is it wicked to say of them too, that they were not before origination? Senseless are these Arians; for what likeness is there between Son and work, that they should parallel a father's with a maker's function? How is it that, with that difference between offspring and work, which has been shown, they remain so ill-instructed? Let it be repeated then, that a work is external to the nature, but a son is the proper offspring of the essence; it follows that a work need not have been always, for the workman frames it when he will; but an offspring is not subject to will, but is proper to the essence. And a man may be and may be called Maker, though the works are not as yet; but father he cannot be called, nor can he be, unless a son exist. And if they curiously inquire why God, though always with the power to make, does not always make (though this also be the presumption of madmen, for 'who has known the mind of the Lord, or who has been His Counsellor?' or how 'shall the thing formed say to' the potter, 'why did you make me thus?' however, not to leave even a weak argument unnoticed), they must be told, that although God always had the power to make, yet the things originated had not the power of being eternal. For they are out of nothing, and therefore were not before their origination; but things which were not before their origination, how could these coexist with the ever-existing God? Wherefore God, looking to what was good for them, then made them all when He saw that, when originated, they were able to abide. And as, though He was able, even from the beginning in the time of Adam, or Noah, or Moses, to send His own Word, yet He sent Him not until the consummation of the ages (for this He saw to be good for the whole creation), so also things originated did He make when He would, and as was good for them. But the Son, not being a work, but proper to the Father's offspring, always is; for, whereas the Father always is, so what is proper to His essence must always be; and this is His Word and His Wisdom. And that creatures should not be in existence, does not disparage the Maker; for He has the power of framing them, when He wills; but for the offspring not to be ever with the Father, is a disparagement of the perfection of His essence. Wherefore His works were framed, when He would, through His Word; but the Son is ever the proper offspring of the Father's essence.

Chapter 9. Objections Continued. Whether is the Unoriginate one or two? Inconsistent in Ariansto use an unscriptural word; necessary to define its meaning. Different senses of the word. If it means 'without Father,' there is but One Unoriginate; if 'without beginning or creation,' there are two. Inconsistency of Asterius. 'Unoriginate' a title of God, not in contrast with the Son, but with creatures, as is 'Almighty,' or 'Lord of powers.' 'Father' is the truer title, as not only Scriptural, but implying a Son, and our adoption as sons

These considerations encourage the faithful and trouble the heretics, since they recognize that their heresy is overthrown by them. Furthermore, their additional question—whether the Unoriginate is one or two—shows how false their views are, how treacherous and full of deception. They do not ask this for the Father's honor, but to dishonor the Word. Accordingly, if anyone, unaware of their cunning, answers that the Unoriginated is one, they immediately pour out their own poison, saying, "Therefore the Son is among originated things," and "We were right to say He did not exist before His generation." In this way they create every kind of disturbance and confusion, as long as they can separate the Son from the Father and count the Maker of all among His works. First, they can be convicted on this charge: while they blame the Nicene bishops for using phrases not found in Scripture—even though these phrases are not harmful but actually undermine their false teaching—they themselves commit the same fault by using words not in Scripture, and those words dishonor the Lord. They know "neither what they say nor whereof they affirm" (1 Timothy 1:7). For example, let them ask the Greeks, who have been their teachers (for it is a word of their invention, not Scripture), and when they have been instructed in its various meanings, then they will discover that they cannot even ask properly about the subject they have taken up. They have led me to learn that "unoriginate" can mean what has not yet come to be but is possible to be, like wood that has not yet become a vessel but is capable of becoming one. Again, it can mean what neither has nor ever can come to be, like a triangle becoming quadrangular or an even number becoming odd. For a triangle neither has nor ever can become quadrangular, nor has an even number ever become, nor can it ever become, odd. Moreover, "unoriginate" can mean what exists but has not come into being from anyone, nor has a father at all. Furthermore, Asterius, the unprincipled sophist and patron of this heresy, has added in his own treatise that what is not made but always exists is "unoriginate." Therefore, when they ask their question, they ought to specify in what sense they are using the word "unoriginate," and then those being questioned would be able to answer appropriately.

30. These considerations encourage the faithful, and distress the heretical, perceiving, as they do, their heresy overthrown thereby. Moreover, their further question, 'whether the Unoriginate be one or two,' shows how false are their views, how treacherous and full of guile. Not for the Father's honour ask they this, but for the dishonour of the Word. Accordingly, should any one, not aware of their craft, answer, 'the Unoriginated is one,' immediately they spirit out their own venom, saying, 'Therefore the Son is among things originated,' and well have we said, 'He was not before His generation.' Thus they make any kind of disturbance and confusion, provided they can but separate the Son from the Father, and reckon the Framer of all among His works. Now first they may be convicted on this score, that, while blaming the Nicene Bishops for their use of phrases not in Scripture, though these not injurious, but subversive of their irreligion, they themselves went off upon the same fault, that is, using words not in Scripture, and those in contumely of the Lord, knowing 'neither what they say nor whereof they affirm 1 Timothy 1:7.' For instance, let them ask the Greeks, who have been their instructors (for it is a word of their invention, not Scripture), and when they have been instructed in its various significations, then they will discover that they cannot even question properly, on the subject which they have undertaken. For they have led me to ascertain that by 'unoriginate' is meant what has not yet come to be, but is possible to be, as wood which is not yet become, but is capable of becoming, a vessel; and again what neither has nor ever can come to be, as a triangle quadrangular, and an even number odd. For a triangle neither has nor ever can become quadrangular; nor has even ever, nor can ever, become odd. Moreover, by 'unoriginate' is meant, what exists, but has not come into being from any, nor having a father at all. Further, Asterius, the unprincipled sophist, the patron too of this heresy, has added in his own treatise, that what is not made, but is ever, is 'unoriginate.' They ought then, when they ask the question, to add in what sense they take the word 'unoriginate,' and then the parties questioned would be able to answer to the point.

If they are still content merely to ask, "Is the Unoriginate one or two?" they must first be told, as poorly educated people, that many things are such and nothing is such—many things that are capable of origination, and nothing that is not capable, as has already been said. But if they ask according to Asterius's definition, treating as unoriginate "what is not a work but has always existed," then they must be constantly reminded that the Son as well as the Father must in this sense be called unoriginate. For He is neither among originated things nor a work, but has always been with the Father, as has already been shown, despite their many variations designed solely to speak against the Lord, saying "He is from nothing" and "He did not exist before His generation." When, after failing at every turn, they shift to the other meaning of the question—"existing but not generated from anyone nor having a father"—we shall tell them that the unoriginate in this sense is only one, namely the Father, and they will gain nothing by their question. For to say that God is unoriginate in this sense does not show that the Son is an originated thing, since it is evident from the above proofs that the Word is such as He who begot Him is. Therefore, if God is unoriginate, His Image is not originated but an Offspring, which is His Word and His Wisdom. For what likeness does the originated have to the unoriginate? (One must not tire of using repetition.) For if they insist that the one is like the other, so that whoever sees the one beholds the other, they are likely to say that the Unoriginate is the image of creatures. The result of this is a confusion of the entire subject, an equating of originated things with the Unoriginate, and a denial of the Unoriginate by measuring Him with the works—all to reduce the Son to their number.

31. But if they still are satisfied with merely asking, 'Is the Unoriginate one or two?' they must be told first of all, as ill- educated men, that many are such and nothing is such, many, which are capable of origination, and nothing, which is not capable, as has been said. But if they ask according as Asterius ruled it, as if 'what is not a work but was always' were unoriginate, then they must constantly be told that the Son as well as the Father must in this sense be called unoriginate. For He is neither in the number of things originated, nor a work, but has ever been with the Father, as has already been shown, in spite of their many variations for the sole sake of speaking against the Lord, 'He is of nothing' and 'He was not before His generation.' When then, after failing at every turn, they betake themselves to the other sense of the question, 'existing but not generated of any nor having a father,' we shall tell them that the unoriginate in this sense is only one, namely the Father; and they will gain nothing by their question. For to say that God is in this sense Unoriginate, does not show that the Son is a thing originated, it being evident from the above proofs that the Word is such as He is who begot Him. Therefore if God be unoriginate, His Image is not originated, but an Offspring, which is His Word and His Wisdom. For what likeness has the originated to the unoriginate? (one must not weary of using repetition;) for if they will have it that the one is like the other, so that he who sees the one beholds the other, they are like to say that the Unoriginate is the image of creatures; the end of which is a confusion of the whole subject, an equalling of things originated with the Unoriginate, and a denial of the Unoriginate by measuring Him with the works; and all to reduce the Son into their number.

However, I suppose even they will be unwilling to go this far if they follow Asterius the sophist. For he, though zealous in his defense of the Arian heresy and maintaining that the Unoriginate is one, contradicts them by saying that the Wisdom of God is also unoriginate and without beginning. Here is a passage from his work: 'The Blessed Paul did not say that he preached Christ the power of God or the wisdom of God, but, without the article, 'God's power and God's wisdom' (1 Corinthians 1:24); thus preaching that the proper power of God Himself, which is natural to Him and coexists with Him unoriginatedly, is something distinct.' And again, soon after: 'However, His eternal power and wisdom, which reason argues to be without beginning and unoriginate, must surely be one.' For though he misunderstood the Apostle's words and thought there were two wisdoms, yet by speaking of a wisdom coexisting with Him, he declares that the Unoriginate is not simply one, but that there is another Unoriginate with Him. For what is coexistent does not coexist with itself, but with another. So if they agree with Asterius, let them never ask again, 'Is the Unoriginate one or two,' or they will have to argue the point with him. If, on the other hand, they differ even from him, let them not rely on his treatise, lest 'biting one another, they be consumed one of another' (Galatians 5:15). So much for their ignorance; but who can adequately describe their crafty character? Who would not justly hate them while they are possessed by such madness? For when they were no longer allowed to say 'out of nothing' and 'He was not before His generation,' they seized upon this word 'unoriginate' so that, by saying among the simple that the Son was 'originate,' they might imply the very same phrases 'out of nothing' and 'He once was not'; for such phrases imply originated things and creatures.

32. However, I suppose even they will be unwilling to proceed to such lengths, if they follow Asterius the sophist. For he, earnest as he is in his advocacy of the Arian heresy, and maintaining that the Unoriginate is one, runs counter to them in saying, that the Wisdom of God is unoriginate and without beginning also. The following is a passage out of his work: 'The Blessed Paul said not that he preached Christ the power of God or the wisdom of God, but, without the article, 'God's power and God's wisdom 1 Corinthians 1:24;' thus preaching that the proper power of God Himself, which is natural to Him and co-existent with Him unoriginatedly, is something besides.' And again, soon after: 'However, His eternal power and wisdom, which truth argues to be without beginning and unoriginate; this must surely be one.' For though, misunderstanding the Apostle's words, he considered that there were two wisdoms; yet, by speaking still of a wisdom coexistent with Him, he declares that the Unoriginate is not simply one, but that there is another Unoriginate with Him. For what is coexistent, coexists not with itself, but with another. If then they agree with Asterius, let them never ask again, 'Is the Unoriginate one or two,' or they will have to contest the point with him; if, on the other hand, they differ even from him, let them not rely upon his treatise, lest, 'biting one another, they be consumed one of another Galatians 5:15.' So much on the point of their ignorance; but who can say enough on their crafty character? Who but would justly hate them while possessed by such a madness? For when they were no longer allowed to say 'out of nothing' and 'He was not before His generation,' they hit upon this word 'unoriginate,' that, by saying among the simple that the Son was 'originate,' they might imply the very same phrases 'out of nothing,' and 'He once was not;' for in such phrases things originated and creatures are implied.

If they have confidence in their own positions, they should stick to them and not keep changing so inconsistently. But they won't, because they think they can easily succeed if they just hide their heresy behind the word 'unoriginate.' Yet in the end, this term is not used in contrast with the Son, no matter how much they protest, but in contrast with originated things. The same is true of words like 'Almighty' and 'Lord of the Powers.' For if we say that the Father has power and authority over all things through the Word, and the Son rules the Father's kingdom and has power over all things as His Word and as the Image of the Father, it is quite clear that the Son is not counted among that 'all,' nor is God called Almighty and Lord with reference to Him, but to those things which come into being through the Son, and over which He exercises power and authority through the Word. Therefore 'Unoriginate' is defined not by contrast to the Son, but to the things which come into being through the Son. And rightly so, since God is not like originated things, but is their Creator and Framer through the Son. And just as the word 'Unoriginate' is defined in relation to originated things, so the word 'Father' indicates the Son. When someone calls God Maker and Framer and Unoriginate, he considers and understands created and made things. But when someone calls God Father, he thereby conceives and contemplates the Son. From this one might marvel at the stubbornness added to their irreligion, for although the term 'unoriginate' has the good meaning mentioned above and can be used religiously, they in their heresy bring it out to dishonor the Son, not having read that whoever honors the Son honors the Father, and whoever dishonors the Son dishonors the Father. If they had any concern at all for reverent speech and the honor due to the Father, they ought rather—and this would be better and higher—to acknowledge and call God Father than to give Him this name. For in calling God unoriginate, they are, as I said before, calling Him from His works, and only as Maker and Framer, supposing that from this they can imply that the Word is a work according to their own pleasure. But whoever calls God Father signifies Him from the Son, being well aware that if there is a Son, necessarily through that Son all originated things were created. When they call Him Unoriginate, they name Him only from His works and know the Son no more than the Greeks do. But whoever calls God Father names Him from the Word, and knowing the Word, he acknowledges Him to be Framer of all and understands that through Him all things have been made.

33. If they have confidence in their own positions, they should stand to them, and not change about so variously; but this they will not, from an idea that success is easy, if they do but shelter their heresy under color of the word 'unoriginate.' Yet after all, this term is not used in contrast with the Son, clamour as they may, but with things originated; and the like may be found in the words 'Almighty,' and 'Lord of the Powers.' For if we say that the Father has power and mastery over all things by the Word, and the Son rules the Father's kingdom, and has the power of all, as His Word, and as the Image of the Father, it is quite plain that neither here is the Son reckoned among that all, nor is God called Almighty and Lord with reference to Him, but to those things which through the Son come to be, and over which He exercises power and mastery through the Word. And therefore the Unoriginate is specified not by contrast to the Son, but to the things which through the Son come to be. And excellently: since God is not as things originated, but is their Creator and Framer through the Son. And as the word 'Unoriginate' is specified relatively to things originated, so the word 'Father' is indicative of the Son. And he who names God Maker and Framer and Unoriginate, regards and apprehends things created and made; and he who calls God Father, thereby conceives and contemplates the Son. And hence one might marvel at the obstinacy which is added to their irreligion, that, whereas the term 'unoriginate' has the aforesaid good sense, and admits of being used religiously, they, in their own heresy, bring it forth for the dishonour of the Son, not having read that he who honours the Son honours the Father, and he who dishonours the Son, dishonours the Father. John 5:23 If they had any concern at all for reverent speaking and the honour due to the Father, it became them rather, and this were better and higher, to acknowledge and call God Father, than to give Him this name. For, in calling God unoriginate, they are, as I said before, calling Him from His works, and as Maker only and Framer, supposing that hence they may signify that the Word is a work after their own pleasure. But that he who calls God Father, signifies Him from the Son being well aware that if there be a Son, of necessity through that Son all things originate were created. And they, when they call Him Unoriginate, name Him only from His works, and know not the Son any more than the Greeks; but he who calls God Father, names Him from the Word; and knowing the Word, he acknowledges Him to be Framer of all, and understands that through Him all things have been made.

Therefore it is more reverent and more precise to identify God from the Son and call Him Father, than to name Him from His works alone and call Him Unoriginate. For the latter title, as I have said, does nothing more than signify all the works, both individually and collectively, that have come into being by God's will through the Word; but the title Father has its meaning and significance only from the Son. And just as the Word surpasses created things, so calling God Father surpasses calling Him Unoriginate by that much and more. For the latter term is unscriptural and questionable, because it has multiple meanings; so when someone is asked about it, his mind is pulled in many different directions. But the word Father is simple and scriptural and more accurate, and refers only to the Son. "Unoriginate" is a word of the Greeks, who do not know the Son; but "Father" has been acknowledged and revealed by our Lord. For He, knowing whose Son He was, said, "I am in the Father, and the Father is in Me," and "He who has seen Me has seen the Father," and "I and the Father are One." But nowhere is He found calling the Father Unoriginate. Moreover, when He teaches us to pray, He does not say, "When you pray, say, O God Unoriginate," but rather, "When you pray, say, Our Father, who art in heaven." And He willed that the summary of our faith should have the same emphasis, commanding us to be baptized not in the name of Unoriginate and originate, nor in the name of Creator and creature, but into the Name of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. For with this initiation we too, though numbered among created works, are made sons, and by using the name of the Father, we acknowledge from that name the Word also in the Father Himself. So their argument about the term "Unoriginate" is pointless, as is now proven, and nothing more than an illusion.

34. Therefore it is more pious and more accurate to signify God from the Son and call Him Father, than to name Him from His works only and call Him Unoriginate. For the latter title, as I have said, does nothing more than signify all the works, individually and collectively, which have come to be at the will of God through the Word; but the title Father has its significance and its bearing only from the Son. And, whereas the Word surpasses things originated, by so much and more does calling God Father surpass the calling Him Unoriginate. For the latter is unscriptural and suspicious, because it has various senses; so that, when a man is asked concerning it, his mind is carried about to many ideas; but the word Father is simple and scriptural, and more accurate, and only implies the Son. And 'Unoriginate' is a word of the Greeks, who know not the Son; but 'Father' has been acknowledged and vouchsafed by our Lord. For He, knowing Himself whose Son He was, said, 'I am in the Father, and the Father is in Me;' and, 'He that has seen Me, has seen the Father,' and 'I and the Father are One;' but nowhere is He found to call the Father Unoriginate. Moreover, when He teaches us to pray, He says not, 'When you pray, say, O God Unoriginate,' but rather, 'When you pray, say, Our Father, which art in heaven Luke 11:2.' And it was His will that the Summary of our faith should have the same bearing, in bidding us be baptized, not into the name of Unoriginate and originate, nor into the name of Creator and creature, but into the Name of Father, Son, and Holy Ghost. For with such an initiation we too, being numbered among works, are made sons, and using the name of the Father, acknowledge from that name the Word also in the Father Himself. A vain thing then is their argument about the term 'Unoriginate,' as is now proved, and nothing more than a fantasy.

Chapter 10. Objections Continued. How the Word has free will, yet without being alterable. He is unalterable because the Image of the Father, proved from texts.

Regarding their question about whether the Word is alterable, it is unnecessary to examine it. It is enough simply to write down what they say, and this will show how daringly irreligious it is. Their frivolous approach appears from the following questions: "Does He have free will, or does He not? Is He good by choice according to free will, and can He, if He wills, alter, being of an alterable physis? Or, like wood or stone, does He lack the freedom of choice to be moved and incline in different directions?" It is consistent with their heresy to speak and think this way. After all, once they have constructed for themselves a God out of nothing and a created Son, they naturally adopt such language, since it suits a creature. However, when in their debates with Church members they hear from them about the real and only Word of the Father, and yet dare to speak this way about Him, does not their doctrine become the most detestable possible? Is it not enough to disturb anyone upon merely hearing it, even if unable to reply, and to make him cover his ears in astonishment at the novelty of what he hears them say—which even to mention is blasphemy? For if the Word is alterable and changing, where will He remain, and what will be the end of His development? How can the alterable possibly be like the Unalterable? How could one who has seen the alterable be considered to have seen the Unalterable? At what state must He arrive for us to be able to see the Father in Him? For clearly we will not be able to see the Father in the Son at all times, because the Son is always altering and is of a changing physis. For the Father is unalterable and unchangeable, and is always in the same state and the same. But if, as they claim, the Son is alterable and not always the same, but of an ever-changing physis, how can such a one be the Father's Image, not having the likeness of His unalterableness? How can He be truly in the Father if His purpose is unstable? Indeed, perhaps, being alterable and advancing daily, He is not yet perfect. But away with such madness of the Arians, and let the truth shine out and show that they are foolish. For must not He who is equal to God be perfect? And must not He who is one with the Father, and His Son proper to His ousia, be unalterable? And since the Father's ousia is unalterable, the proper Offspring from it must also be unalterable. And if they slanderously attribute alteration to the Word, let them realize how much danger their own reasoning is in. For from the fruit the tree is known. This is why the one who has seen the Son has seen the Father, and why knowledge of the Son is knowledge of the Father.

35. As to their question whether the Word is alterable, it is superfluous to examine it; it is enough simply to write down what they say, and so to show its daring irreligion. How they trifle, appears from the following questions:– 'Has He free will, or has He not? Is He good from choice according to free will, and can He, if He will, alter, being of an alterable nature? Or, as wood or stone, has He not His choice free to be moved and incline hither and there?' It is but agreeable to their heresy thus to speak and think; for, when once they have framed to themselves a God out of nothing and a created Son, of course they also adopt such terms, as being suitable to a creature. However, when in their controversies with Churchmen they hear from them of the real and only Word of the Father, and yet venture thus to speak of Him, does not their doctrine then become the most loathsome that can be found? Is it not enough to distract a man on mere hearing, though unable to reply, and to make him stop his ears, from astonishment at the novelty of what he hears them say, which even to mention is to blaspheme? For if the Word be alterable and changing, where will He stay, and what will be the end of His development? How shall the alterable possibly be like the Unalterable? How should he who has seen the alterable, be considered to have seen the Unalterable? At what state must He arrive, for us to be able to behold in Him the Father? For it is plain that not at all times shall we see the Father in the Son, because the Son is ever altering, and is of changing nature. For the Father is unalterable and unchangeable, and is always in the same state and the same; but if, as they hold, the Son is alterable, and not always the same, but of an ever-changing nature, how can such a one be the Father's Image, not having the likeness of His unalterableness? How can He be really in the Father, if His purpose is indeterminate? Nay, perhaps, as being alterable, and advancing daily, He is not perfect yet. But away with such madness of the Arians, and let the truth shine out, and show that they are foolish. For must not He be perfect who is equal to God? And must not He be unalterable, who is one with the Father, and His Son proper to His essence? And the Father's essence being unalterable, unalterable must be also the proper Offspring from it. And if they slanderously impute alteration to the Word, let them learn how much their own reason is in peril; for from the fruit is the tree known. For this is why he who has seen the Son has seen the Father; and why the knowledge of the Son is knowledge of the Father.

Therefore the Image of the unalterable God must be unchangeable, for "Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, today, and forever" (Hebrews 13:8). And David says of Him in the Psalm, "You, Lord, in the beginning laid the foundation of the earth, and the heavens are the work of Your hands. They will perish, but You remain; they will all wear out like a garment. Like a robe You will roll them up, and they will be changed, but You are the same, and Your years will not fail." And the Lord Himself says of Himself through the Prophet, "See now that I, even I am He," and "I do not change." It could be argued that what is expressed here refers to the Father; yet it is also appropriate for the Son to say this, especially because, when He became man, He demonstrates His own identity and unchangeableness to those who assume that because of the flesh He has been altered and become different from what He was. More trustworthy are the saints—or rather the Lord—than the perversity of the irreligious. For Scripture, as in the passage from the Psalms quoted above, indicates by the terms "heaven and earth" that the physis of all things that are originated and created is alterable and changeable, yet it excludes the Son from these things, thereby showing us that He is in no way an originated being. Indeed, it teaches that He changes everything else while He Himself is not changed, saying, "You are the same, and Your years will not fail" (Hebrews 1:12). And rightly so, for originated things, being from nothing and not existing before they came to be—since they truly come into being after not being—have a changeable nature. But the Son, being from the Father and proper to His ousia, is unchangeable and unalterable just as the Father Himself is. For it would be sinful to say that from that ousia which is unalterable there was begotten an alterable word and a changeable wisdom. For how can He still be the Word if He is alterable? Or how can that be Wisdom which is changeable? Unless perhaps, as an accident in ousia, they would have it—meaning that, as in any particular ousia a certain grace and habit of virtue exists accidentally, which is called Word and Son and Wisdom, and can be removed from it or added to it. For they have often expressed this view, but it is not the faith of Christians, since it does not declare that He is truly Word and Son of God, or that the wisdom in question is true Wisdom. For what alters and changes, and has no stability in one and the same condition—how can that be true? Yet the Lord says, "I am the Truth" (John 14:6). So if the Lord Himself speaks this way about Himself and declares His unalterableness, and the Saints have learned and testify to this—indeed, even our understanding of God acknowledges it as religiously proper—where did these irreligious men derive this novelty? They vomited it forth from their hearts as from a seat of corruption.

36. Therefore the Image of the unalterable God must be unchangeable; for ' Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, today, and for ever Hebrews 13:8.' And David in the Psalm says of Him, 'Thou, Lord, in the beginning hast laid the foundation of the earth, and the heavens are the work of Your hands. They shall perish, but You remain; and they all shall wax old as does a garment. And as a vesture shall Thou fold them up, and they shall be changed, but You are the same, and Your years shall not fail.' And the Lord Himself says of Himself through the Prophet, 'See now that I, even I am He,' and 'I change not.' It may be said indeed that what is here signified relates to the Father; yet it suits the Son also to say this, specially because, when made man, He manifests His own identity and unalterableness to such as suppose that by reason of the flesh He is changed and become other than He was. More trustworthy are the saints, or rather the Lord, than the perversity of the irreligious. For Scripture, as in the above-cited passage of the Psalter, signifying under the name of heaven and earth, that the nature of all things originate and created is alterable and changeable, yet excepting the Son from these, shows us thereby that He is no wise a thing originate; nay teaches that He changes everything else, and is Himself not changed, in saying, 'You are the same, and Your years shall not fail Hebrews 1:12.' And with reason; for things originate, being from nothing, and not being before their origination, because, in truth, they come to be after not being, have a nature which is changeable; but the Son, being from the Father, and proper to His essence, is unchangeable and unalterable as the Father Himself. For it were sin to say that from that essence which is unalterable was begotten an alterable word and a changeable wisdom. For how is He longer the Word, if He be alterable? Or can that be Wisdom which is changeable? Unless perhaps, as accident in essence, so they would have it, viz. as in any particular essence, a certain grace and habit of virtue exists accidentally, which is called Word and Son and Wisdom, and admits of being taken from it and added to it. For they have often expressed this sentiment, but it is not the faith of Christians; as not declaring that He is truly Word and Son of God, or that the wisdom intended is true Wisdom. For what alters and changes, and has no stay in one and the same condition, how can that be true? Whereas the Lord says, 'I am the Truth John 14:6.' If then the Lord Himself speaks thus concerning Himself, and declares His unalterableness, and the Saints have learned and testify this, nay and our notions of God acknowledge it as religious, whence did these men of irreligion draw this novelty? From their heart as from a seat of corruption did they vomit it forth.

Chapter 11. Texts Explained; And First, Philippians 2:9, 10. Whether the words 'Wherefore God has highly exalted' prove moral probation and advancement. Argued against, first, from the force of the word 'Son;' which is inconsistent with such an interpretation. Next, the passage examined. Ecclesiastical sense of 'highly exalted,' and 'gave,' and 'wherefore;' viz. as being spoken with reference to our Lord's manhood. Secondary sense; viz. as implying the Word's 'exaltation' through the resurrection in the same sense in which Scripture speaks of His descent in the Incarnation; how the phrase does not derogate from the nature of the Word.

But since they cite the divine Scriptures and force a misinterpretation on them according to their own private understanding, it becomes necessary to answer them just enough to defend these passages and to show that they have an orthodox meaning and that our opponents are wrong. They say that the Apostle writes, 'Wherefore God also has highly exalted Him, and given Him a Name which is above every name; that in the Name of Jesus every knee should bow, of things in heaven and things in earth and things under the earth,' and David says, 'Wherefore God even Your God, has anointed You with the oil of gladness above Your fellows.' Then they argue, as if it were clever: 'If He was exalted and received grace because of a "wherefore," and was anointed because of a "wherefore," He received a reward for His conduct; but having acted from deliberate choice, He is completely of a changeable nature.' This is what Eusebius and Arius have dared to say and even to write, while their followers do not hesitate to talk about it openly in the marketplace, not seeing how insane an argument they are using. For if He received what He had as a reward for His conduct, and would not have had it unless He had needed it and had His works to prove it, then having gained it through virtue and advancement, He would rightly have been called Son and God 'therefore,' without being truly Son. For what comes from another by physis is a real offspring, as Isaac was to Abraham, and Joseph to Jacob, and the radiance to the sun; but those called sons through virtue and grace have only grace by acquisition instead of physis, and are something other than the gift itself—like the men who have received the Spirit by participation, about whom Scripture says, 'I begot and exalted children, and they rebelled against Me.' And of course, since they were not sons by physis, when they changed, the Spirit was taken away and they were disinherited; and again when they repent, that God who gave them grace at the beginning will receive them, and give light, and call them sons again.

37. But since they allege the divine oracles and force on them a misinterpretation, according to their private sense, it becomes necessary to meet them just so far as to vindicate these passages, and to show that they bear an orthodox sense, and that our opponents are in error. They say then, that the Apostle writes, 'Wherefore God also has highly exalted Him, and given Him a Name which is above every name; that in the Name of Jesus every knee should bow, of things in heaven and things in earth and things under the earth Philippians 2:9-10;' and David, 'Wherefore God even Your God, has anointed You with the oil of gladness above Your fellows.' Then they urge, as something acute: 'If He was exalted and received grace, on a 'wherefore,' and on a 'wherefore' He was anointed, He received a reward of His purpose; but having acted from purpose, He is altogether of an alterable nature.' This is what Eusebius and Arius have dared to say, nay to write; while their partizans do not shrink from conversing about it in full market-place, not seeing how mad an argument they use. For if He received what He had as a reward of His purpose, and would not have had it, unless He had needed it, and had His work to show for it, then having gained it from virtue and promotion, with reason had He 'therefore' been called Son and God, without being very Son. For what is from another by nature, is a real offspring, as Isaac was to Abraham, and Joseph to Jacob, and the radiance to the sun; but the so called sons from virtue and grace, have but in place of nature a grace by acquisition, and are something else besides the gift itself; as the men who have received the Spirit by participation, concerning whom Scripture says, 'I begot and exalted children, and they rebelled against Me.' And of course, since they were not sons by nature, therefore, when they altered, the Spirit was taken away and they were disinherited; and again on their repentance that God who thus at the beginning gave them grace, will receive them, and give light, and call them sons again.

If they say this about the Savior as well, it follows that He is neither truly God nor truly Son, nor like the Father, nor in any way has God as the Father of His being according to essence. Instead, He would have God only through the grace given to Him, and a Creator of His being according to essence, just like everyone else. And being such, as they claim, it will be clear that He did not have the name 'Son' from the beginning, if it was the reward for works done and for that very advancement which He made when He became man and took the form of a servant. Rather, it was only when, after becoming 'obedient unto death,' He was, as the text says, 'highly exalted' and received that 'Name' as a grace, 'that in the Name of Jesus every knee should bow.' What then existed before this, if He was exalted then, and began to be worshiped then, and was called Son then, when He became man? For it seems He did not promote the flesh at all, but rather was Himself promoted through it, if, according to their twisted view, He was exalted and called Son when He became man. What then existed before this? We must press the question on them again, to make clear what their irreligious doctrine leads to. For if the Lord is God, Son, Word, but was not all these before He became man, then either He was something else besides these and later became a partaker of them because of His virtue, as we have said, or they must adopt the alternative (may it fall back on their own heads!) that He did not exist before that time and is entirely human by nature and nothing more. But this is not a belief of the Church, but of the Samosatene and of the present-day Jews. Why then, if they think like Jews, are they not circumcised with them too, instead of pretending to be Christians while being enemies of Christianity? For if He did not exist, or existed but was later promoted, how were all things made by Him, or how did the Father delight in Him if He was not perfect? And how, if He was only now promoted, did He rejoice before in the presence of the Father? And if He received His worship after dying, how did Abraham worship Him in the tent, and Moses in the bush? And as Daniel saw, myriads of myriads and thousands of thousands were ministering to Him. And if, as they say, He received His promotion now, how did the Son Himself mention that glory of His before and above the world, when He said, 'Glorify Me, O Father, with the glory which I had with You before the world was'? If, as they say, He was exalted then, how did He before that 'bow the heavens and come down,' and again, 'The Highest gave His thunder'? Therefore, if even before the world was made, the Son had that glory and was Lord of glory and the Highest, and descended from heaven and is always to be worshiped, it follows that He did not receive promotion from His descent, but rather He Himself promoted the things that needed promotion. And if He descended to bring about their promotion, therefore He did not receive as a reward the name of the Son and God, but rather He Himself has made us sons of the Father and deified men by becoming man Himself.

38. But if they say this of the Saviour also, it follows that He is neither very God nor very Son, nor like the Father, nor in any wise has God for a Father of His being according to essence, but of the mere grace given to Him, and for a Creator of His being according to essence, after the similitude of all others. And being such, as they maintain, it will be manifest further that He had not the name 'Son' from the first, if so be it was the prize of works done and of that very same advance which He made when He became man, and took the form of the servant; but then, when, after becoming ' obedient unto death,' He was, as the text says, 'highly exalted,' and received that 'Name' as a grace, 'that in the Name of Jesus every knee should bow Philippians 2:8.' What then was before this, if then He was exalted, and then began to be worshipped, and then was called Son, when He became man? For He seems Himself not to have promoted the flesh at all, but rather to have been Himself promoted through it, if, according to their perverseness, He was then exalted and called Son, when He became man. What then was before this? One must urge the question on them again, to make it understood what their irreligious doctrine results in. For if the Lord be God, Son, Word, yet was not all these before He became man, either He was something else beside these, and afterwards became partaker of them for His virtue's sake, as we have said; or they must adopt the alternative (may it return upon their heads!) that He was not before that time, but is wholly man by nature and nothing more. But this is no sentiment of the Church. but of the Samosatene and of the present Jews. Why then, if they think as Jews, are they not circumcised with them too, instead of pretending Christianity, while they are its foes? For if He was not, or was indeed, but afterwards was promoted, how were all things made by Him, or how in Him, were He not perfect, did the Father delight Proverbs 8:30? And He, on the other hand, if now promoted, how did He before rejoice in the presence of the Father? And, if He received His worship after dying, how is Abraham seen to worship Him in the tent, and Moses in the bush? And, as Daniel saw, myriads of myriads, and thousands of thousands were ministering unto Him? And if, as they say, He had His promotion now, how did the Son Himself make mention of that His glory before and above the world, when He said, 'Glorify Thou Me, O Father, with the glory which I had with You before the world was John 17:5.' If, as they say, He was then exalted, how did He before that 'bow the heavens and come down;' and again, 'The Highest gave His thunder?' Therefore, if, even before the world was made, the Son had that glory, and was Lord of glory and the Highest, and descended from heaven, and is ever to be worshipped, it follows that He had not promotion from His descent, but rather Himself promoted the things which needed promotion; and if He descended to effect their promotion, therefore He did not receive in reward the name of the Son and God, but rather He Himself has made us sons of the Father, and deified men by becoming Himself man.

Therefore, He was not a man who then became God. Rather, He was God who then became man, and He did this to deify us. For if He was called Son and God only when He became man, while before He became man God had already called the ancient people sons and made Moses a god of Pharaoh (and Scripture says of many, "God stands in the congregation of gods"), then it is clear that He is called Son and God later than they were. How then are all things through Him, and how is He before all? Or how is He "first-born of the whole creation" if He has others before Him who are called sons and gods? And how is it that those first participants do not partake of the Word? This opinion is not true; it is a scheme of our present Judaizers. For how in that case could anyone at all know God as their Father? For adoption could not exist apart from the real Son, who says, "No one knows the Father, except the Son, and anyone to whom the Son chooses to reveal Him." And how can there be deifying apart from the Word and before Him? Yet He says to their brothers the Jews, "If He called them gods, to whom the Word of God came." And if all who are called sons and gods, whether on earth or in heaven, were adopted and deified through the Word, and the Son Himself is the Word, it is plain that all of them exist through Him, and He Himself is before all. Or rather, He Himself alone is truly Son, and He alone is truly God from the true God, not receiving these prerogatives as a reward for His virtue, nor being something other besides them, but being all these by nature and according to ousia. For He is Offspring of the Father's ousia, so that one cannot doubt that, after the resemblance of the unalterable Father, the Word also is unalterable.

39. Therefore He was not man, and then became God, but He was God, and then became man, and that to deify us. Since, if when He became man, only then He was called Son and God, but before He became man, God called the ancient people sons, and made Moses a god of Pharaoh (and Scripture says of many, 'God stands in the congregation of Gods '), it is plain that He is called Son and God later than they. How then are all things through Him, and He before all? Or how is He ' first-born of the whole creation,' if He has others before Him who are called sons and gods? And how is it that those first partakers do not partake of the Word? This opinion is not true; it is a device of our present Judaizers. For how in that case can any at all know God as their Father? For adoption there could not be apart from the real Son, who says, 'No one knows the Father, save the Son, and he to whomsoever the Son will reveal Him Matthew 11:27.' And how can there be deifying apart from the Word and before Him? Yet, says He to their brethren the Jews, 'If He called them gods, unto whom the Word of God came John 10:35.' And if all that are called sons and gods, whether in earth or in heaven, were adopted and deified through the Word, and the Son Himself is the Word, it is plain that through Him are they all, and He Himself before all, or rather He Himself only is very Son, and He alone is very God from the very God, not receiving these prerogatives as a reward for His virtue, nor being another beside them, but being all these by nature and according to essence. For He is Offspring of the Father's essence, so that one cannot doubt that after the resemblance of the unalterable Father, the Word also is unalterable.

Up to this point, we have challenged their irrational ideas with the true understanding implied in the word "Son," as the Lord Himself has given it to us. But it will be good next to quote the divine scriptures, so that the unchangeableness of the Son and His unchangeable nature, which is the Father's, as well as their error, may be proven even more fully. The Apostle, then, writing to the Philippians, says, "Have this mind in you, which was also in Christ Jesus; who, being in the form of God, thought it not a prize to be equal with God; but emptied Himself, taking the form of a servant, being made in the likeness of men. And, being found in fashion as a man, He humbled Himself, becoming obedient to death, even the death of the cross. Wherefore God also highly exalted Him, and gave Him a Name which is above every name; that in the Name of Jesus every knee should bow, of things in heaven, and things in earth, and things under the earth, and that every tongue should confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father." Could anything be clearer and more explicit than this? He was not promoted from a lower state; rather, existing as God, He took the form of a servant, and in taking it, He was not promoted but humbled Himself. Where then is there any reward of virtue here, or what advancement and promotion exists in humiliation? For if, being God, He became man, and descending from on high He is still said to be exalted, where is He exalted, being God? This much is clear: since God is highest of all, His Word must necessarily be highest also. Where then could He be exalted higher, who is in the Father and like the Father in all things? Therefore He is beyond the need of any addition, and is not such as the Arians think Him. For though the Word descended in order to be exalted, and so it is written, yet what need was there that He should humble Himself, as if to seek what He already had? And what grace did He receive who is the Giver of grace? Or how did He receive that Name for worship, when He is always worshipped by His Name? Indeed, even before He became man, the sacred writers invoke Him, "Save me, O God, for Your Name's sake," and again, "Some put their trust in chariots, and some in horses, but we will remember the Name of the Lord our God." And while He was worshipped by the Patriarchs, concerning the Angels it is written, "Let all the Angels of God worship Him."

40. Hitherto we have met their irrational conceits with the true conceptions implied in the Word 'Son,' as the Lord Himself has given us. But it will be well next to cite the divine oracles, that the unalterableness of the Son and His unchangeable nature, which is the Father's, as well as their perverseness, may be still more fully proved. The Apostle then, writing to the Philippians, says, 'Have this mind in you, which was also in Christ Jesus; who, being in the form of God, thought it not a prize to be equal with God; but emptied Himself, taking the form of a servant, being made in the likeness of men. And, being found in fashion as a man, He humbled Himself, becoming obedient to death, even the death of the cross. Wherefore God also highly exalted Him, and gave Him a Name which is above every name; that in the Name of Jesus every knee should bow, of things in heaven, and things in earth, and things under the earth, and that every tongue should confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father Philippians 2:5-11.' Can anything be plainer and more express than this? He was not from a lower state promoted: but rather, existing as God, He took the form of a servant, and in taking it, was not promoted but humbled Himself. Where then is there here any reward of virtue, or what advancement and promotion in humiliation? For if, being God, He became man, and descending from on high He is still said to be exalted, where is He exalted, being God? This withal being plain, that, since God is highest of all, His Word must necessarily be highest also. Where then could He be exalted higher, who is in the Father and like the Father in all things? Therefore He is beyond the need of any addition; nor is such as the Arians think Him. For though the Word has descended in order to be exalted, and so it is written, yet what need was there that He should humble Himself, as if to seek that which He had already? And what grace did He receive who is the Giver of grace? Or how did He receive that Name for worship, who is always worshipped by His Name? Nay, certainly before He became man, the sacred writers invoke Him, 'Save me, O God, for Your Name's sake;'and again, 'Some put their trust in chariots, and some in horses, but we will remember the Name of the Lord our God.' And while He was worshipped by the Patriarchs, concerning the Angels it is written, 'Let all the Angels of God worship Him Hebrews 1:6.'

If, as David says in Psalm 71, "His Name remains before the sun, and before the moon, from one generation to another," how did He receive what He always had, even before He now received it? Or how is He exalted, when before His exaltation He was already the Most High? Or how did He receive the right to be worshipped, when before He now received it He was always worshipped? This is not a confusing riddle but a divine mystery. "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God," but for our sake the Word was later made flesh. The term "highly exalted" does not mean that the essence of the Word was exalted, for He was always and is "equal to God," but the exaltation refers to the manhood. This is not said before the Word became flesh, so that it might be clear that "humbled" and "exalted" are spoken of His human nature. For wherever there is a humble state, there can also be exaltation; and if "humbled" is written because of His taking on flesh, it is clear that "highly exalted" is also said because of it. For this is what human nature needed, because of the humble state of the flesh and of death. Since the Word, being the Image of the Father and immortal, took the form of a servant and as man underwent death in His flesh for us, so that He might offer Himself for us through death to the Father, therefore also as man He is said because of us and for us to be highly exalted, so that just as by His death we all died in Christ, so again in Christ Himself we might be highly exalted, being raised from the dead and ascending into heaven, "where the forerunner Jesus has entered for us, not into the figures of the true, but into heaven itself, now to appear in the presence of God for us." But if Christ has now entered into heaven itself for us, though He was even before and always Lord and Maker of the heavens, this present exaltation is therefore written for us. And just as He Himself, who sanctifies all, says also that He sanctifies Himself to the Father for our sake—not that the Word may become holy, but that He Himself may in Himself sanctify all of us—in the same way we must understand the present phrase "He highly exalted Him," not that He Himself should be exalted, for He is the highest, but that He may become righteousness for us, and we may be exalted in Him, and that we may enter the gates of heaven, which He has also opened for us. The forerunners say, "Lift up your gates, O you rulers, and be lifted up, you everlasting doors, and the King of Glory shall come in." For here also the gates were not shut against Him, since He is Lord and Maker of all, but this too is written because of us, to whom the door of paradise was shut. And therefore in human terms, because of the flesh which He bore, it is said of Him, "Lift up your gates," and "shall come in," as if a man were entering; but in divine terms on the other hand it is said of Him, since the Word was God, that He is the "Lord" and the "King of Glory." The Spirit foretold this exaltation of ours in Psalm 89, saying, "And in Your righteousness shall they be exalted, for You are the glory of their strength." And if the Son is Righteousness, then He is not exalted as being Himself in need, but we are exalted in that Righteousness, which is He.

41. And if, as David says in the 71st Psalm, 'His Name remains before the sun, and before the moon, from one generation to another,' how did He receive what He had always, even before He now received it? Or how is He exalted, being before His exaltation the Most High? Or how did He receive the right of being worshipped, who before He now received it, was ever worshipped? It is not a dark saying but a divine mystery. 'In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God;' but for our sakes afterwards the ' Word was made flesh.' And the term in question, 'highly exalted,' does not signify that the essence of the Word was exalted, for He was ever and is 'equal to God Philippians 2:6,' but the exaltation is of the manhood. Accordingly this is not said before the Word became flesh; that it might be plain that 'humbled' and 'exalted' are spoken of His human nature; for where there is humble estate, there too may be exaltation; and if because of His taking flesh 'humbled' is written, it is clear that 'highly exalted' is also said because of it. For of this was man's nature in want, because of the humble estate of the flesh and of death. Since then the Word, being the Image of the Father and immortal, took the form of the servant, and as man underwent for us death in His flesh, that thereby He might offer Himself for us through death to the Father; therefore also, as man, He is said because of us and for us to be highly exalted, that as by His death we all died in Christ, so again in the Christ Himself we might be highly exalted, being raised from the dead, and ascending into heaven, 'whither the forerunner Jesus is for us entered, not into the figures of the true, but into heaven itself, now to appear in the presence of God for us.' But if now for us the Christ is entered into heaven itself, though He was even before and always Lord and Framer of the heavens, for us therefore is that present exaltation written. And as He Himself, who sanctifies all, says also that He sanctifies Himself to the Father for our sakes, not that the Word may become holy, but that He Himself may in Himself sanctify all of us, in like manner we must take the present phrase, 'He highly exalted Him,' not that He Himself should be exalted, for He is the highest, but that He may become righteousness for us, and we may be exalted in Him, and that we may enter the gates of heaven, which He has also opened for us, the forerunners saying, 'Lift up your gates, O you rulers, and be lifted up, you everlasting doors, and the King of Glory shall come in.' For here also not on Him were shut the gates, as being Lord and Maker of all, but because of us is this too written, to whom the door of paradise was shut. And therefore in a human relation, because of the flesh which He bore, it is said of Him, 'Lift up your gates,' and 'shall come in,' as if a man were entering; but in a divine relation on the other hand it is said of Him, since 'the Word was God,' that He is the 'Lord' and the 'King of Glory.' Such our exaltation the Spirit foreannounced in the eighty-ninth Psalm, saying, 'And in Your righteousness shall they be exalted, for You are the glory of their strength.' And if the Son be Righteousness, then He is not exalted as being Himself in need, but it is we who are exalted in that Righteousness, which is He 1 Corinthians 1:30.

The phrase "gave Him" is not written because of the Word Himself. Even before He became man, He was worshipped—as we have already said—by the Angels and all creation, precisely because He is proper to the Father. Rather, this is written about Him because of us and for us. Just as Christ died and was exalted as man, so as man He is said to receive what He always had as God, so that even such a gift of grace might reach us. The Word was not diminished by receiving a body so that He would need to receive grace. Instead, He deified what He put on and, more than that, graciously gave it to the human race. Just as He was always worshipped as the Word and as existing in the form of God, so being what He always was—though He became man and is called Jesus—He nonetheless has all creation under His feet. They bend their knees to Him in this Name and confess that the Word's becoming flesh and undergoing death in flesh has not happened against the glory of His Godhead, but rather to the glory of God the Father. It is the Father's glory that man, who was made and then lost, should be found again, and when dead should be made alive and become God's temple. The powers in heaven—both Angels and Archangels—have always worshipped the Lord, and they worship Him now in the Name of Jesus. This is our grace and high exaltation: that even when He became man, the Son of God is worshipped, and the heavenly powers will not be shocked to see all of us, who are of one body with Him, brought into their realms. This would not have happened unless He who existed in the form of God had taken on a servant's form and humbled Himself, yielding His body to death.

42. And so too the words 'gave Him' are not written because of the Word Himself; for even before He became man He was worshipped, as we have said, by the Angels and the whole creation in virtue of being proper to the Father; but because of us and for us this too is written of Him. For as Christ died and was exalted as man, so, as man, is He said to take what, as God, He ever had, that even such a grant of grace might reach to us. For the Word was not impaired in receiving a body, that He should seek to receive a grace, but rather He deified that which He put on, and more than that, 'gave' it graciously to the race of man. For as He was ever worshipped as being the Word and existing in the form of God, so being what He ever was, though become man and called Jesus, He none the less has the whole creation under foot, and bending their knees to Him in this Name, and confessing that the Word's becoming flesh, and undergoing death in flesh, has not happened against the glory of His Godhead, but 'to the glory of God the Father.' For it is the Father's glory that man, made and then lost, should be found again; and, when dead, that he should be made alive, and should become God's temple. For whereas the powers in heaven, both Angels and Archangels, were ever worshipping the Lord, as they are now worshipping Him in the Name of Jesus, this is our grace and high exaltation, that even when He became man, the Son of God is worshipped, and the heavenly powers will not be astonished at seeing all of us, who are of one body with Him, introduced into their realms. And this had not been, unless He who existed in the form of God had taken on Him a servant's form, and had humbled Himself, yielding His body to come unto death.

Look at what people considered the foolishness of God because of the Cross—it has become the most honored of all things. For our resurrection is stored up in it, and no longer Israel alone, but from now on all the nations, as the Prophet foretold, leave their idols and acknowledge the true God, the Father of the Christ. And the deception of demons has been destroyed, and He alone who is truly God is worshiped in the Name of our Lord Jesus Christ. For the fact that the Lord, even when He came in a human body and was called Jesus, was worshiped and believed to be God's Son, and that through Him the Father was known, shows, as has been said, that the Word, considered as the Word, did not receive this great grace, but rather we did. For because of our relationship to His Body, we too have become God's temple, and as a result are made God's sons, so that even in us the Lord is now worshiped, and observers report, as the Apostle says, that God is truly in them. As John also says in the Gospel, "As many as received Him, to them gave He power to become children of God," and in his Epistle he writes, "By this we know that He abides in us by His Spirit which He has given us." And this too is evidence of His goodness toward us: that while we were exalted because the Highest Lord is in us, and grace was given to Him on our account because the Lord who supplies the grace became a man like us, He on the other hand, the Savior, humbled Himself by taking our body of humiliation and took a servant's form, putting on that flesh which was enslaved to sin. And He gained nothing from us for His own advancement, for the Word of God lacks nothing and is complete; but rather we were advanced by Him, for He is the Light that enlightens every person coming into the world. And the Arians stress the word "wherefore" in vain because Paul said, "Wherefore God has highly exalted Him." For in saying this he did not mean any reward for virtue or advancement through progress, but rather the reason why the exaltation was given to us. And what is this reason except that He who existed in the form of God, the Son of a noble Father, humbled Himself and became a servant in our place and for our sake? For if the Lord had not become man, we would not have been redeemed from sins, not raised from the dead, but would have remained dead under the earth; not exalted into heaven, but lying in Hades. Therefore, because of us and for our sake are the words "highly exalted" and "given" written.

43. Behold then what men considered the foolishness of God because of the Cross, has become of all things most honoured. For our resurrection is stored up in it; and no longer Israel alone, but henceforth all the nations, as the Prophet has foretold, leave their idols and acknowledge the true God, the Father of the Christ. And the illusion of demons has come to nought, and He only who is really God is worshipped in the Name of our Lord Jesus Christ. For the fact that the Lord, even when come in human body and called Jesus, was worshipped and believed to be God's Son, and that through Him the Father was known, shows, as has been said, that not the Word, considered as the Word, received this so great grace, but we. For because of our relationship to His Body we too have become God's temple, and in consequence are made God's sons, so that even in us the Lord is now worshipped, and beholders report, as the Apostle says, that God is in them of a truth. As also John says in the Gospel, 'As many as received Him, to them gave He power to become children of God John 1:12;' and in his Epistle he writes, 'By this we know that He abides in us by His Spirit which He has given us 1 John 3:24.' And this too is an evidence of His goodness towards us that, while we were exalted because that the Highest Lord is in us, and on our account grace was given to Him, because that the Lord who supplies the grace has become a man like us, He on the other hand, the Saviour, humbled Himself in taking 'our body of humiliation Philippians 3:21,' and took a servant's form, putting on that flesh which was enslaved to sin. And He indeed has gained nothing from us for His own promotion: for the Word of God is without want and full; but rather we were promoted from Him; for He is the 'Light, which lightens every man, coming into the world John 1:9.' And in vain do the Arians lay stress upon the conjunction 'wherefore,' because Paul has said, 'Wherefore, has God highly exalted Him.' For in saying this he did not imply any prize of virtue, nor promotion from advance, but the cause why the exaltation was bestowed upon us. And what is this but that He who existed in form of God, the Son of a noble Father, humbled Himself and became a servant instead of us and in our behalf? For if the Lord had not become man, we had not been redeemed from sins, not raised from the dead, but remaining dead under the earth; not exalted into heaven, but lying in Hades. Because of us then and in our behalf are the words, 'highly exalted' and 'given.'

Here is my interpretation of what this passage says. I believe it makes good ecclesiastical sense. However, there is another way to look at it that gives the same basic meaning from a different angle. Although the passage does not speak of the exaltation of the Word Himself as Word (for He is, as just mentioned, most high and like His Father), it does indicate His resurrection from the dead by reason of His becoming man. After saying "He has humbled Himself even unto death," Paul immediately added "Wherefore He has highly exalted Him." He wanted to show that although as man He is said to have died, yet as being Life itself, He was exalted in the resurrection, for "He who descended is the same also who rose again." He descended in body, and He rose again because He was God Himself in the body. This is also the reason why, according to this interpretation, Paul used the conjunction "Wherefore"—not as a reward for virtue or advancement, but to indicate the cause why the resurrection took place and why, while all other people from Adam down to this time have died and remained dead, He alone rose intact from the dead. The cause is this, which He Himself has already taught us: that being God, He became man. For all other people, being merely born of Adam, died, and death reigned over them. But He, the Second Man, is from heaven, for "the Word was made flesh," and this Man is said to be from heaven and heavenly because the Word descended from heaven. Therefore He was not held under death. For though He humbled Himself, yielding His own Body to come to death (in that it was capable of death), yet He was highly exalted from earth because He was God's Son in a body. Accordingly, what is said here—"Wherefore God also has highly exalted Him"—corresponds to Peter's words in the Acts: "Whom God raised up, having loosed the bonds of death, because it was not possible that He should be held by it." For just as Paul has written, "Since being in form of God He became man and humbled Himself unto death, therefore God also has highly exalted Him," so also Peter says, "Since being God He became man, and signs and wonders proved Him to beholders to be God, therefore it was not possible that He should be held by death." For man it was not possible to accomplish this, because death belongs to man. Therefore the Word, being God, became flesh so that, being put to death in the flesh, He might give life to all people by His own power.

44. This then I consider the sense of this passage, and that, a very ecclesiastical sense. However, there is another way in which one might remark upon it, giving the same sense in a parallel way; viz. that, though it does not speak of the exaltation of the Word Himself, so far as He is Word (for He is, as was just now said, most high and like His Father), yet by reason of His becoming man it indicates His resurrection from the dead. For after saying, 'He has humbled Himself even unto death,' He immediately added, 'Wherefore He has highly exalted Him;' wishing to show, that, although as man He is said to have died, yet, as being Life, He was exalted on the resurrection; for 'He who descended, is the same also who rose again.' He descended in body, and He rose again because He was God Himself in the body. And this again is the reason why according to this meaning he brought in the conjunction 'Wherefore;' not as a reward of virtue nor of advancement, but to signify the cause why the resurrection took place; and why, while all other men from Adam down to this time have died and remained dead, He only rose in integrity from the dead. The cause is this, which He Himself has already taught us, that, being God, He has become man. For all other men, being merely born of Adam, died, and death reigned over them; but He, the Second Man, is from heaven, for 'the Word was made flesh John 1:14,' and this Man is said to be from heaven and heavenly, because the Word descended from heaven; wherefore He was not held under death. For though He humbled Himself, yielding His own Body to come unto death, in that it was capable of death, yet He was highly exalted from earth, because He was God's Son in a body. Accordingly what is here said, 'Wherefore God also has highly exalted Him,' answers to Peter's words in the Acts, 'Whom God raised up, having loosed the bonds of death, because it was not possible that He should be holden of it Acts 2:24.' For as Paul has written, 'Since being in form of God He became man, and humbled Himself unto death, therefore God also has highly exalted Him,' so also Peter says, 'Since, being God, He became man, and signs and wonders proved Him to beholders to be God, therefore it was not possible that He should be holden of death.' To man it was not possible to succeed in this; for death belongs to man; wherefore, the Word, being God, became flesh, that, being put to death in the flesh, He might quicken all men by His own power.

But since He Himself is said to be 'exalted,' and God 'gave' Him, and the heretics think this indicates a defect or something that happened to the ousia of the Word, we need to explain how these words are used. He is said to be exalted from the lower parts of the earth because death is attributed even to Him. Both events belong to Him, since it was His Body, and no one else's, that was exalted from the dead and taken up into heaven. And again, since the Body is His, and the Word is not separate from it, it is natural that when the Body was exalted, He, as man, should be spoken of as exalted because of the body. If He did not become man, then this should not be said of Him. But if the Word became flesh, then necessarily the resurrection and exaltation, as in the case of a man, must be attributed to Him, so that the death attributed to Him may be a redemption of human sin and an abolition of death, and so that the resurrection and exaltation may remain secure for us because of Him. In both respects Scripture says of Him, 'God has highly exalted Him,' and 'God has given to Him.' This also shows that it is not the Father who became flesh, but His Word, who has become man and receives from the Father in the manner of humans, and is exalted by Him, as has been said. And it is clear, and no one would dispute it, that what the Father gives, He gives through the Son. And it is marvelous and truly overwhelming: for the grace which the Son gives from the Father, that same grace the Son Himself is said to receive; and the exaltation which the Son bestows from the Father, with that same exaltation the Son is Himself exalted. For He who is the Son of God became Himself the Son of Man. And as Word, He gives from the Father, for all things which the Father does and gives, He does and supplies through Him. And as the Son of Man, He Himself is said, in the manner of humans, to receive what proceeds from Him, because His Body is none other than His and is naturally capable of receiving grace, as has been said. For He received it to the extent that His human nature was exalted, which exaltation was its being deified. But such an exaltation the Word Himself always had according to the Father's Godhead and perfection, which was His.

45. But since He Himself is said to be 'exalted,' and God 'gave' Him, and the heretics think this a defect or affection in the essence of the Word, it becomes necessary to explain how these words are used. He is said to be exalted from the lower parts of the earth, because death is ascribed even to Him. Both events are reckoned His, since it was His Body, and none other's, that was exalted from the dead and taken up into heaven. And again, the Body being His, and the Word not being external to it, it is natural that when the Body was exalted, He, as man, should, because of the body, be spoken of as exalted. If then He did not become man, let this not be said of Him: but if the Word became flesh, of necessity the resurrection and exaltation, as in the case of a man, must be ascribed to Him, that the death which is ascribed to Him may be a redemption of the sin of men and an abolition of death, and that the resurrection and exaltation may for His sake remain secure for us. In both respects he has said of Him, 'God has highly exalted Him,' and 'God has given to Him;' that herein moreover he may show that it is not the Father that has become flesh, but it is His Word, who has become man, and receives after the manner of men from the Father, and is exalted by Him, as has been said. And it is plain, nor would any one dispute it, that what the Father gives, He gives through. the Son. And it is marvellous and overwhelming verily; for the grace which the Son gives from the Father, that the Son Himself is said to receive; and the exaltation, which the Son bestows from the Father, with that the Son is Himself exalted. For He who is the Son of God, became Himself the Son of Man; and, as Word, He gives from the Father, for all things which the Father does and gives, He does and supplies through Him; and as the Son of Man, He Himself is said after the manner of men to receive what proceeds from Him, because His Body is none other than His, and is a natural recipient of grace, as has been said. For He received it as far as His man's nature was exalted; which exaltation was its being deified. But such an exaltation the Word Himself always had according to the Father's Godhead and perfection, which was His.

Chapter 12. Texts Explained; Secondly, Psalm 45:7, 8.}}–> Whether the words 'therefore,' 'anointed,' etc., imply that the Word has been rewarded. Argued against first from the word 'fellows' or 'partakers.' He is anointed with the Spirit in His manhood to sanctify human nature. Therefore the Spirit descended on Him in Jordan, when in the flesh. And He is said to sanctify Himself for us, and give us the gloryHe has received. The word 'wherefore' implies His divinity. 'You have loved righteousness,' etc., do not imply trial or choice.

This explanation of the Apostle's words refutes the irreligious men. What the sacred poet says also admits the same orthodox interpretation, which they misinterpret but which in the Psalmist is clearly religious. He says, 'Your throne, O God, is for ever and ever; a sceptre of righteousness is the sceptre of Your Kingdom. You have loved righteousness, and hated iniquity, therefore God, even Your God, has anointed You with the oil of gladness above Your fellows.' Look, you Arians, and recognize even from this the truth. The Singer speaks of us all as 'fellows' or 'partakers' of the Lord. But if He were one of the things that came from nothing and one of the things that had a beginning, He Himself would have been one of those who partake. However, since the psalmist hymned Him as the eternal God, saying, 'Your throne, O God, is for ever and ever,' and has declared that all other things partake of Him, what conclusion must we draw except that He is distinct from created things, and He alone is the Father's true Word, Radiance, and Wisdom, which all created things partake of, being sanctified by Him in the Spirit? Therefore He is here 'anointed,' not so that He may become God, for He was God even before, nor so that He may become King, for He had the Kingdom eternally, existing as God's Image, as the sacred Scripture shows. Rather this is written for our sake, as stated before. For the Israelite kings, when they were anointed, became kings at that point, not having been kings before, like David, like Hezekiah, like Josiah, and the rest. But the Saviour, in contrast, being God and always ruling in the Father's Kingdom, and being Himself the one who supplies the Holy Spirit, is nevertheless said here to be anointed. This is so that, as before, being said as man to be anointed with the Spirit, He might provide for us men not only exaltation and resurrection, but the indwelling and intimacy of the Spirit. The Lord Himself has indicated this by His own mouth in the Gospel according to John: 'I have sent them into the world, and for their sakes do I sanctify Myself, that they may be sanctified in the truth.' In saying this He has shown that He is not the sanctified one, but the Sanctifier. For He is not sanctified by another, but sanctifies Himself, so that we may be sanctified in the truth. He who sanctifies Himself is Lord of sanctification. How then does this happen? What does He mean except this: 'I, being the Father's Word, give to Myself, when becoming man, the Spirit. And I Myself, having become man, sanctify Myself in Him, so that from now on in Me, who am Truth (for Your Word is Truth), all may be sanctified.'

46. Such an explanation of the Apostle's words confutes the irreligious men; and what the sacred poet says admits also the same orthodox sense, which they misinterpret, but which in the Psalmist is manifestly religious. He says then, 'Your throne, O God, is for ever and ever; a sceptre of righteousness is the sceptre of Your Kingdom. You have loved righteousness, and hated iniquity, therefore God, even Your God, has anointed You with the oil of gladness above Your fellows.' Behold, O you Arians, and acknowledge even hence the truth. The Singer speaks of us all as 'fellows' or 'partakers' of the Lord: but were He one of things which come out of nothing and of things originate, He Himself had been one of those who partake. But, since he hymned Him as the eternal God, saying, 'Your throne, O God, is for ever and ever,' and has declared that all other things partake of Him, what conclusion must we draw, but that He is distinct from originated things, and He only the Father's veritable Word, Radiance, and Wisdom, which all things originate partake, being sanctified by Him in the Spirit? And therefore He is here 'anointed,' not that He may become God, for He was so even before; nor that He may become King, for He had the Kingdom eternally, existing as God's Image, as the sacred Oracle shows; but in our behalf is this written, as before. For the Israelitish kings, upon their being anointed, then became kings, not being so before, as David, as Hezekiah, as Josiah, and the rest; but the Saviour on the contrary, being God, and ever ruling in the Father's Kingdom, and being Himself He that supplies the Holy Ghost, nevertheless is here said to be anointed, that, as before, being said as man to be anointed with the Spirit, He might provide for us men, not only exaltation and resurrection, but the indwelling and intimacy of the Spirit. And signifying this the Lord Himself has said by His own mouth in the Gospel according to John, 'I have sent them into the world, and for their sakes do I sanctify Myself, that they may be sanctified in the truth.' In saying this He has shown that He is not the sanctified, but the Sanctifier; for He is not sanctified by other, but Himself sanctifies Himself, that we may be sanctified in the truth. He who sanctifies Himself is Lord of sanctification. How then does this take place? What does He mean but this? 'I, being the Father's Word, I give to Myself, when becoming man, the Spirit; and Myself, become man, do I sanctify in Him, that henceforth in Me, who am Truth (for Your Word is Truth), all may be sanctified.'

If He sanctifies Himself for our sake, and does this when He has become man, it is very clear that the Spirit's descent on Him in Jordan was a descent upon us, because He was bearing our body. This did not happen to promote the Word, but again for our sanctification, so that we might share His anointing, and it might be said of us, "Do you not know that you are God's temple, and the Spirit of God dwells in you?" For when the Lord, as man, was washed in Jordan, it was we who were washed in Him and by Him. And when He received the Spirit, we were the ones who by Him were made recipients of It. Moreover, for this reason He was not anointed with oil as Aaron or David or the rest were, but in another way above all His fellows, "with the oil of gladness," which He Himself interprets to be the Spirit, saying through the Prophet, "The Spirit of the Lord is upon Me, because the Lord has anointed Me," as also the Apostle has said, "How God anointed Him with the Holy Spirit." When then were these things spoken of Him except when He came in the flesh and was baptized in Jordan, and the Spirit descended on Him? And indeed the Lord Himself said, "The Spirit shall take of Mine," and "I will send Him," and to His disciples, "Receive the Holy Spirit." And yet, He who, as the Word and Radiance of the Father, gives to others, is now said to be sanctified, because now He has become man, and the Body that is sanctified is His. From Him then we have begun to receive the anointing and the seal, John saying, "And you have an anointing from the Holy One," and the Apostle, "And you were sealed with the Holy Spirit of promise." Therefore because of us and for us are these words. What advance then of promotion, and reward of virtue or generally of conduct, is proved from this in our Lord's case? For if He was not God, and then had become God, if not being King He was promoted to the Kingdom, your reasoning would have had some slight plausibility. But if He is God and the throne of His kingdom is everlasting, in what way could God advance? Or what was lacking to Him who was sitting on His Father's throne? And if, as the Lord Himself has said, the Spirit is His, and takes from His, and He sends It, it is not the Word, considered as the Word and Wisdom, who is anointed with the Spirit which He Himself gives, but the flesh assumed by Him that is anointed in Him and by Him, so that the sanctification coming to the Lord as man may come to all men from Him. For the Spirit does not speak of Itself, He says, but the Word is He who gives It to the worthy. For this is like the passage considered above; for just as the Apostle has written, "Who existing in the form of God thought it not a prize to be equal with God, but emptied Himself, and took a servant's form," so David celebrates the Lord as the everlasting God and King, but sent to us and assuming our body which is mortal. For this is his meaning in the Psalm, "All your garments smell of myrrh, aloes, and cassia," and it is represented by Nicodemus and by Mary's company, when the one came bringing "a mixture of myrrh and aloes, about a hundred pounds weight," and the others "the spices which they had prepared" for the burial of the Lord's body.

47. If then for our sake He sanctifies Himself, and does this when He has become man, it is very plain that the Spirit's descent on Him in Jordan was a descent upon us, because of His bearing our body. And it did not take place for promotion to the Word, but again for our sanctification, that we might share His anointing, and of us it might be said, 'Do you not know that you are God's Temple, and the Spirit of God dwells in you 1 Corinthians 3:16?' For when the Lord, as man, was washed in Jordan, it was we who were washed in Him and by Him. And when He received the Spirit, we it was who by Him were made recipients of It. And moreover for this reason, not as Aaron or David or the rest, was He anointed with oil, but in another way above all His fellows, 'with the oil of gladness,' which He Himself interprets to be the Spirit, saying by the Prophet, 'The Spirit of the Lord is upon Me, because the Lord has anointed Me Isaiah 61:1;' as also the Apostle has said, 'How God anointed Him with the Holy Ghost. Acts 10:38 ' When then were these things spoken of Him but when He came in the flesh and was baptized in Jordan, and the Spirit descended on Him? And indeed the Lord Himself said, 'The Spirit shall take of Mine;' and 'I will send Him;' and to His disciples, 'Receive the Holy Ghost.' And notwithstanding, He who, as the Word and Radiance of the Father, gives to others, now is said to be sanctified, because now He has become man, and the Body that is sanctified is His. From Him then we have begun to receive the unction and the seal, John saying, 'And you have an unction from the Holy One;' and the Apostle, 'And you were sealed with the Holy Spirit of promise.' Therefore because of us and for us are these words. What advance then of promotion, and reward of virtue or generally of conduct, is proved from this in our Lord's instance? For if He was not God, and then had become God, if not being King He was preferred to the Kingdom, your reasoning would have had some faint plausibility. But if He is God and the throne of His kingdom is everlasting, in what way could God advance? Or what was there wanting to Him who was sitting on His Father's throne? And if, as the Lord Himself has said, the Spirit is His, and takes of His, and He sends It, it is not the Word, considered as the Word and Wisdom, who is anointed with the Spirit which He Himself gives, but the flesh assumed by Him which is anointed in Him and by Him; that the sanctification coming to the Lord as man, may come to all men from Him. For not of Itself, says He, does the Spirit speak, but the Word is He who gives It to the worthy. For this is like the passage considered above; for as the Apostle has written, 'Who existing in form of God thought it not a prize to be equal with God, but emptied Himself, and took a servant's form,' so David celebrates the Lord, as the everlasting God and King, but sent to us and assuming our body which is mortal. For this is his meaning in the Psalm, 'All your garments smell of myrrh, aloes, and cassia;' and it is represented by Nicodemus and by Mary's company, when the one came bringing 'a mixture of myrrh and aloes, about an hundred pounds weight;' and the others John 19:39; Luke 24:1 'the spices which they had prepared' for the burial of the Lord's body.

What advancement, then, was it for the Immortal to take on mortality? Or what promotion is it for the Everlasting to put on what is temporal? What reward can be great for the Everlasting God and King who is in the bosom of the Father? Don't you see that this too was done and written for our sake and on our behalf—so that the Lord, by becoming human, might make us who are mortal and temporal immortal and bring us into the everlasting kingdom of heaven? Aren't you ashamed, speaking lies against the divine Scriptures? For when our Lord Jesus Christ came among us, we were the ones who were promoted, being rescued from sin. But He remains the same. He did not change when He became human (to repeat what I have said). Rather, as it is written, 'The Word of God abides forever.' Just as, before He became human, He the Word gave the Spirit to the saints as His own, so also when He became human, He sanctifies everyone by the Spirit and says to His disciples, 'Receive the Holy Spirit.' He gave the Spirit to Moses and the other seventy, and through Him David prayed to the Father, saying, 'Take not Your Holy Spirit from me.' On the other hand, when He became human, He said, 'I will send to you the Paraclete, the Spirit of truth,' and He sent Him—He, the Word of God, being faithful. Therefore 'Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, today, and forever,' remaining unalterable. He both gives and receives at once—giving as God's Word, receiving as human. It is not the Word, considered as the Word, who is promoted, for He had all things and always has them. Rather, it is human beings who have in Him and through Him their source of receiving them. For when He is now said to be anointed in a human respect, it is we who are anointed in Him. Similarly, when He is baptized, it is we who are baptized in Him. But the Savior sheds much light on all these things when He says to the Father, 'And the glory which You gave Me, I have given to them, that they may be one, even as We are one.' It was for our sake, then, that He asked for glory, and the words 'took' and 'gave' and 'highly exalted' occur so that we might take, and so that these things might be given to us, and so that we might be exalted in Him. Just as He also sanctifies Himself for our sake, so that we might be sanctified in Him.

48. What advancement then was it to the Immortal to have assumed the mortal? Or what promotion is it to the Everlasting to have put on the temporal? What reward can be great to the Everlasting God and King in the bosom of the Father? See ye not, that this too was done and written because of us and for us, that us who are mortal and temporal, the Lord, become man, might make immortal, and bring into the everlasting kingdom of heaven? Blush ye not, speaking lies against the divine oracles? For when our Lord Jesus Christ had been among us, we indeed were promoted, as rescued from sin; but He is the same; nor did He alter, when He became man (to repeat what I have said), but, as has been written, 'The Word of God abides forever.' Surely as, before His becoming man, He, the Word, dispensed to the saints the Spirit as His own, so also when made man, He sanctifies all by the Spirit and says to His Disciples, 'Receive the Holy Ghost.' And He gave to Moses and the other seventy; and through Him David prayed to the Father, saying, 'Take not Your Holy Spirit from me.' On the other hand, when made man, He said, 'I will send to you the Paraclete, the Spirit of truth John 15:26;' and He sent Him, He, the Word of God, as being faithful. Therefore ' Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, today, and for ever Hebrews 13:8,' remaining unalterable, and at once gives and receives, giving as God's Word, receiving as man. It is not the Word then, viewed as the Word, that is promoted; for He had all things and has them always; but men, who have in Him and through Him their origin of receiving them. For, when He is now said to be anointed in a human respect, we it is who in Him are anointed; since also when He is baptized, we it is who in Him are baptized. But on all these things the Saviour throws much light, when He says to the Father, 'And the glory which You gave Me, I have given to them, that they may be one, even as We are one John 17:22.' Because of us then He asked for glory, and the words occur, 'took' and 'gave' and 'highly exalted,' that we might take, and to us might be given, and we might be exalted in Him; as also for us He sanctifies Himself, that we might be sanctified in Him.

But if they take advantage of the word "wherefore" as it connects to the passage in the Psalm, "Wherefore God, even Your God, has anointed You," for their own purposes, let these novices in Scripture and masters in irreligion understand that, as before, the word "wherefore" does not imply a reward for virtue or conduct in the Word, but rather the reason why He came down to us, and explains the Spirit's anointing which took place in Him for our sakes. For He does not say, "Wherefore He anointed You in order that You might become God or King or Son or Word," for He was these things before and is forever, as has been shown. Rather, He says, "Since You are God and King, therefore You were anointed, since none but You could unite man to the Holy Spirit, You the Image of the Father, in which we were made in the beginning; for the Spirit is Yours as well." For the nature of created things could give no guarantee for this, since Angels had transgressed and men had disobeyed. Therefore there was need of God, and the Word is God, so that He Himself might set free those who had come under a curse. If He had come from nothing, He would not have been the Christ or Anointed One, being merely one among others and having fellowship like the rest. But since He is God, as being Son of God, and is everlasting King, and exists as Radiance and Expression of the Father, therefore He is fittingly the expected Christ, whom the Father announces to mankind by revelation to His holy Prophets—so that just as through Him we have come into being, so also in Him all people might be redeemed from their sins, and by Him all things might be ruled. And this is the reason for the anointing which took place in Him, and for the incarnate presence of the Word. The Psalmist, foreseeing this, first celebrates His Godhead and kingdom, which is the Father's, in these words: "Your throne, O God, is for ever and ever; a scepter of righteousness is the scepter of Your Kingdom." Then he announces His descent to us in this way: "Wherefore God, even Your God, has anointed You with the oil of gladness above Your fellows."

49. But if they take advantage of the word 'wherefore,' as connected with the passage in the Psalm, 'Wherefore God, even Your God, has anointed You,' for their own purposes, let these novices in Scripture and masters in irreligion know, that, as before, the word 'wherefore' does not imply reward of virtue or conduct in the Word, but the reason why He came down to us, and of the Spirit's anointing which took place in Him for our sakes. For He says not, 'Wherefore He anointed You in order to Your being God or King or Son or Word.' for so He was before and is for ever, as has been shown; but rather, 'Since You are God and King, therefore You were anointed, since none but You could unite man to the Holy Ghost, Thou the Image of the Father, in which we were made in the beginning; for Yours is even the Spirit.' For the nature of things originate could give no warranty for this, Angels having transgressed, and men disobeyed. Wherefore there was need of God and the Word is God; that those who had become under a curse, He Himself might set free. If then He was of nothing, He would not have been the Christ or Anointed, being one among others and having fellowship as the rest. But, whereas He is God, as being Son of God, and is everlasting King, and exists as Radiance and Expression Hebrews 1:3 of the Father, therefore fitly is He the expected Christ, whom the Father announces to mankind, by revelation to His holy Prophets; that as through Him we have come to be, so also in Him all men might be redeemed from their sins, and by Him all things might be ruled. And this is the cause of the anointing which took place in Him, and of the incarnate presence of the Word, which the Psalmist foreseeing, celebrates, first His Godhead and kingdom, which is the Father's, in these tones, 'Your throne, O God, is for ever and ever; a sceptre of righteousness is the sceptre of Your Kingdom;' then announces His descent to us thus, 'Wherefore God, even Your God, has anointed You with the oil of gladness above Your fellows. '

What is there to wonder at or disbelieve if the Lord who gives the Spirit is here said Himself to be anointed with the Spirit, at a time when necessity required that He did not refuse, with respect to His manhood, to call Himself inferior to the Spirit? For when the Jews said that He cast out devils in Beelzebub, He answered and said to them, to expose their blasphemy, "But if I through the Spirit of God cast out demons" (Matthew 12:28). Notice that the Giver of the Spirit here says that He cast out demons in the Spirit. But this is not said except because of His flesh. For since human nature (physis) is not equal of itself to casting out demons, but only in the power of the Spirit, therefore as man He said, "But if I through the Spirit of God cast out demons." Of course He also indicated that the blasphemy offered to the Holy Spirit is greater than that against His humanity when He said, "Whoever shall speak a word against the Son of Man, it shall be forgiven him"—such as those who said, "Is not this the carpenter's son?"—but those who blaspheme against the Holy Spirit and ascribe the deeds of the Word to the devil shall have inevitable punishment. This is what the Lord spoke to the Jews as man. But to the disciples, showing His Godhead and His majesty and indicating that He was not inferior but equal to the Spirit, He gave the Spirit and said, "Receive the Holy Spirit," and "I send Him," and "He shall glorify Me," and "Whatever He hears, that He shall speak." So then, just as in this passage the Lord Himself, the Giver of the Spirit, does not refuse to say that through the Spirit He casts out demons, as man, in the same way He, the same Giver of the Spirit, did not refuse to say, "The Spirit of the Lord is upon Me, because He has anointed Me" (Isaiah 61:1), with respect to His having become flesh, as John has said. This was so that it might be shown in both these particulars that we are the ones who need the Spirit's grace in our sanctification, and again that we are unable to cast out demons without the Spirit's power. Through whom then and from whom ought the Spirit to be given except through the Son, whose Spirit He also is? And when were we enabled to receive it, except when the Word became man? And as the passage of the Apostle shows that we would not have been redeemed and highly exalted had not He who exists in the form of God taken a servant's form, so David also shows that we could not otherwise have partaken of the Spirit and been sanctified, except that the Giver of the Spirit, the Word Himself, has spoken of Himself as anointed with the Spirit for us. And therefore we have securely received it, He being said to be anointed in the flesh. For the flesh being first sanctified in Him, and He being said, as man, to have received it for its sake, we have the consequence of the Spirit's grace, receiving "out of His fullness" (John 1:16).

50. What is there to wonder at, what to disbelieve, if the Lord who gives the Spirit, is here said Himself to be anointed with the Spirit, at a time when, necessity requiring it, He did not refuse in respect of His manhood to call Himself inferior to the Spirit? For the Jews saying that He cast out devils in Beelzebub, He answered and said to them, for the exposure of their blasphemy, 'But if I through the Spirit of God cast out demons Matthew 12:28.' Behold, the Giver of the Spirit here says that He cast out demons in the Spirit; but this is not said, except because of His flesh. For since man's nature is not equal of itself to casting out demons, but only in power of the Spirit, therefore as man He said, 'But if I through the Spirit of God cast out demons.' Of course too He signified that the blasphemy offered to the Holy Ghost is greater than that against His humanity, when He said, 'Whosoever shall speak a word against the Son of man, it shall be forgiven him;' such as were those who said, 'Is not this the carpenter's son?' but they who blaspheme against the Holy Ghost, and ascribe the deeds of the Word to the devil, shall have inevitable punishment. This is what the Lord spoke to the Jews, as man; but to the disciples showing His Godhead and His majesty, and intimating that He was not inferior but equal to the Spirit, He gave the Spirit and said, 'Receive the Holy Ghost,' and 'I send Him,' and 'He shall glorify Me,' and 'Whatsoever He hears, that He shall speak.' As then in this place the Lord Himself, the Giver of the Spirit, does not refuse to say that through the Spirit He casts out demons, as man; in like manner He the same, the Giver of the Spirit, refused not to say, 'The Spirit of the Lord is upon Me, because He has anointed Me Isaiah 61:1,' in respect of His having become flesh, as John has said; that it might be shown in both these particulars, that we are they who need the Spirit's grace in our sanctification, and again who are unable to cast out demons without the Spirit's power. Through whom then and from whom behooved it that the Spirit should be given but through the Son, whose also the Spirit is? And when were we enabled to receive It, except when the Word became man? And, as the passage of the Apostle shows, that we had not been redeemed and highly exalted, had not He who exists in form of God taken a servant's form, so David also shows, that no otherwise should we have partaken the Spirit and been sanctified, but that the Giver of the Spirit, the Word Himself, hast spoken of Himself as anointed with the Spirit for us. And therefore have we securely received it, He being said to be anointed in the flesh; for the flesh being first sanctified in Him, and He being said, as man, to have received for its sake, we have the sequel of the Spirit grace, receiving 'out of His fullness John 1:16.'

Nor do the words "You have loved righteousness and hated iniquity," which are added in the Psalm, demonstrate—as you again suppose—that the physis (nature) of the Word is changeable. Rather, by their very force they signify His unchangeableness. For since the physis of created things is changeable, and one part had transgressed while the other disobeyed (as has been said), and it is uncertain how they will act—since it often happens that someone who is now good later changes and becomes different, so that one who was just now righteous is soon found unrighteous—there was need here also for one who is unchangeable, so that people might have the immutability of the Word's righteousness as an image and model for virtue. And this thought strongly commends itself to right-minded people. For since the first man Adam changed, and through sin death entered the world, it was necessary for the second Adam to be unchangeable, so that if the Serpent should attack again, even the Serpent's deceit might be defeated, and with the Lord being unalterable and unchangeable, the Serpent might become powerless in his assault against all. For just as when Adam transgressed his sin reached all people, so when the Lord became man and overthrew the Serpent, that great strength of His extends through all people, so that each of us may say, "For we are not ignorant of his devices." With good reason, then, the Lord—who is ever unchangeable in his physis, loving righteousness and hating iniquity—should be anointed and Himself sent, so that He, being and remaining the same, by taking this changeable flesh, might condemn sin in it and might secure its freedom and its ability from then on to fulfill the righteousness of the law in itself, so as to be able to say, "But we are not in the flesh but in the Spirit, if indeed the Spirit of God dwells in us."

51. Nor do the words, 'You have loved righteousness and hated iniquity,' which are added in the Psalm, show, as again you suppose, that the Nature of the Word is alterable, but rather by their very force signify His unalterableness. For since of things originate the nature is alterable, and the one portion had transgressed and the other disobeyed, as has been said, and it is not certain how they will act, but it often happens that he who is now good afterwards alters and becomes different, so that one who was but now righteous, soon is found unrighteous, wherefore there was here also need of one unalterable, that men might have the immutability of the righteousness of the Word as an image and type for virtue. And this thought commends itself strongly to the right-minded. For since the first man Adam altered, and through sin death came into the world, therefore it became the second Adam to be unalterable; that, should the Serpent again assault, even the Serpent's deceit might be baffled, and, the Lord being unalterable and unchangeable, the Serpent might become powerless in his assault against all. For as when Adam had transgressed, his sin reached unto all men, so, when the Lord had become man and had overthrown the Serpent, that so great strength of His is to extend through all men, so that each of us may say, 'For we are not ignorant of his devices. 2 Corinthians 2:11 ' Good reason then that the Lord, who ever is in nature unalterable, loving righteousness and hating iniquity, should be anointed and Himself sent, that, He, being and remaining the same, by taking this alterable flesh, 'might condemn sin in it,' and might secure its freedom, and its ability henceforth 'to fulfil the righteousness of the law?' in itself, so as to be able to say, 'But we are not in the flesh but in the Spirit, if so be that the Spirit of God dwells in us Romans 8:9.'

The Arians have made this conjecture in vain and have wrongly appealed to the words of Scripture. For God's Word is unalterable and is always in one state, not as circumstances might dictate, but as the Father is. For how could He be like the Father unless this were so? Or how could all that belongs to the Father also belong to the Son, if He did not have the Father's unalterableness and unchangeableness? He does not love one thing and hate another as if subject to laws and pulled to one side, lest by choosing one through fear of falling away, we would have to admit that He is also alterable in other ways. Rather, as God and the Father's Word, He is a just judge and lover of virtue, or rather its giver. Therefore, being just and holy by nature (physis), He is said to love righteousness and hate iniquity. This is as much as saying that He loves and chooses the virtuous and rejects and hates the unrighteous. Divine Scripture says the same of the Father: "The Righteous Lord loves righteousness; You hate all them that work iniquity," and "The Lord loves the gates of Sion more than all the dwellings of Jacob," and "Jacob have I loved, but Esau have I hated," and in Isaiah there is the voice of God again saying, "I the Lord love righteousness, and hate robbery of unrighteousness." Let them interpret those former words as these latter ones, for the former are also written of the Image of God. Otherwise, if they misinterpret these as they do those, they will conclude that the Father too is alterable. But since it is dangerous even to hear others say this, we do well to think that when God is said to love righteousness and to hate robbery of unrighteousness, it is not as if He is pulled to one side and capable of the contrary, so as to select one and not choose the other—for this belongs to created things—but rather that, as a judge, He loves and draws to Himself the righteous and withdraws from the bad. It follows then to think the same concerning the Image of God also, that He loves and hates in no other way than this. For the nature (physis) of the Image must be such as Its Father is, though the Arians in their blindness fail to see either that image or any other truth of the divine oracles. For being driven away from the conceptions—or rather misconceptions—of their own hearts, they fall back upon passages of divine Scripture, and here too from lack of understanding, as is their habit, they fail to grasp their meaning. Instead, laying down their own false religion as a kind of rule of interpretation, they twist the whole of the divine oracles to agree with it. And so on the bare mention of such doctrine, they deserve nothing but the reply, "You do err, not knowing the Scriptures nor the power of God," and if they persist in it, they must be silenced by the words, "Render to man the things that are man's, and to God the things that are God's."

52. Vainly then, here again, O Arians, have you made this conjecture, and vainly alleged the words of Scripture; for God's Word is unalterable, and is ever in one state, not as it may happen, but as the Father is; since how is He like the Father, unless He be thus? Or how is all that is the Father's the Son's also, if He has not the unalterableness and unchangeableness of the Father? Not as being subject to laws, and biassed to one side, does He love the one and hate the other, lest, if from fear of falling away He chooses the one, we admit that He is alterable otherwise also; but, as being God and the Father's Word, He is a just judge and lover of virtue, or rather its dispenser. Therefore being just and holy by nature, on this account He is said to love righteousness and to hate iniquity; as much as to say, that He loves and chooses the virtuous, and rejects and hates the unrighteous. And divine Scripture says the same of the Father; 'The Righteous Lord loves righteousness; Thou hate all them that work iniquity,' and 'The Lord loves the gates of Sion, more than all the dwellings of Jacob;' and, 'Jacob have I loved, but Esau have I hated Malachi 1:2-3;' and in Isaiah there is the voice of God again saying, 'I the Lord love righteousness, and hate robbery of unrighteousness Isaiah 61:8.' Let them then expound those former words as these latter; for the former also are written of the Image of God: else, misinterpreting these as those, they will conceive that the Father too is alterable. But since the very hearing others say this is not without peril, we do well to think that God is said to love righteousness and to hate robbery of unrighteousness, not as if biassed to one side, and capable of the contrary, so as to select the latter and not choose the former, for this belongs to things originated, but that, as a judge, He loves and takes to Him the righteous and withdraws from the bad. It follows then to think the same concerning the Image of God also, that He loves and hates no otherwise than thus. For such must be the nature of the Image as is Its Father, though the Arians in their blindness fail to see either that image or any other truth of the divine oracles. For being forced from the conceptions or rather misconceptions of their own hearts, they fall back upon passages of divine Scripture, and here too from want of understanding, according to their wont, they discern not their meaning; but laying down their own irreligion as a sort of canon of interpretation, they wrest the whole of the divine oracles into accordance with it. And so on the bare mention of such doctrine, they deserve nothing but the reply, 'You do err, not knowing the Scriptures nor the power of God Matthew 22:29;' and if they persist in it, they must be put to silence, by the words, 'Render to' man 'the things that are' man's, 'and to God the things that are' God's.

Chapter 13. Texts Explained; Thirdly, Hebrews i. 4. Additional texts brought as objections; e.g. Hebrews 1:4; 7:22. Whether the word 'better' implies likeness to the Angels; and 'made' or 'become' implies creation. Necessary to consider the circumstances under which Scripture speaks. Difference between 'better' and 'greater;' texts in proof. 'Made' or 'become' a general word. Contrast in Hebrews 1:4, between the Son and the Works in point of nature. The difference of the punishments under the two Covenants shows the difference of the natures of the Son and the Angels. 'Become' relates not to the nature of the Word, but to His manhood and office and relation towards us. Parallel passages in which the term is applied to the Eternal Father.

They say the following is written in Proverbs: "The Lord created me the beginning of His ways, for His Works." In the Letter to the Hebrews the Apostle says, "Being made so much better than the Angels, as He has by inheritance obtained a more excellent Name than they." Soon after, it says, "Therefore, holy brethren, partakers of the heavenly calling, consider the Apostle and High Priest of our profession, Christ Jesus, who was faithful to Him that made Him." And in Acts, "Therefore let all the house of Israel know assuredly, that God has made that same Jesus whom you have crucified both Lord and Christ." They bring these passages forward constantly, misunderstanding their meaning, thinking these texts prove that the Word of God was a creature, a work, and one of the things that came into existence. In this way they deceive the thoughtless, using the language of Scripture as their excuse but spreading the poison of their own heresy instead of the true meaning. If they had known the truth, they would not have blasphemed against "the Lord of glory," nor would they have twisted the good words of Scripture. If from now on they openly adopt Caiaphas's approach and have decided to become Jewish in their thinking, being ignorant of the text that truly God will dwell upon the earth, then they should not examine the Apostolic writings, for this is not the Jewish way. But if they mix themselves with the godless Manichees and deny that "the Word was made flesh" and His incarnate presence, then they should not quote Proverbs, for this is inappropriate for Manichees. However, if for the sake of advancement and the profit of greed that comes with it and the desire for good reputation they dare not deny the text "The Word was made flesh," since it is written that way, then either let them correctly interpret the words of Scripture as referring to the Savior's embodied presence, or if they deny this meaning, let them deny that the Lord became human at all. For it is improper to confess that "the Word became flesh" while being ashamed of what is written about Him, and on that account to corrupt the meaning.

53. But it is written, say they, in the Proverbs, 'The Lord created me the beginning of His ways, for His Works;' and in the Epistle to the Hebrews the Apostle says, 'Being made so much better than the Angels, as He has by inheritance obtained a more excellent Name than they.' And soon after, 'Wherefore, holy brethren, partakers of the heavenly calling, consider the Apostle and High Priest of our profession, Christ Jesus, who was faithful to Him that made Him.' And in the Acts, 'Therefore let all the house of Israel know assuredly, that God has made that same Jesus whom you have crucified both Lord and Christ.' These passages they brought forward at every turn, mistaking their sense, under the idea that they proved that the Word of God was a creature and work and one of things originate; and thus they deceive the thoughtless, making the language of Scripture their pretence, but instead of the true sense sowing upon it the poison of their own heresy. For had they known, they would not have been irreligious against 'the Lord of glory 1 Corinthians 2:8,' nor have wrested the good words of Scripture. If then henceforward openly adopting Caiaphas's way, they have determined on judaizing, and are ignorant of the text, that verily God shall dwell upon the earth, let them not inquire into the Apostolical sayings; for this is not the manner of Jews. But if, mixing themselves up with the godless Manichees, they deny that 'the Word was made flesh,' and His Incarnate presence, then let them not bring forward the Proverbs, for this is out of place with the Manichees. But if for preferment-sake, and the lucre of avarice which follows, and the desire for good repute, they venture not on denying the text, 'The Word was made flesh,' since so it is written, either let them rightly interpret the words of Scripture, of the embodied presence of the Saviour, or, if they deny their sense, let them deny that the Lord became man at all. For it is unseemly, while confessing that 'the Word became flesh,' yet to be ashamed at what is written of Him, and on that account to corrupt the sense.

Regarding the phrase "so much better than the Angels," let us first examine this carefully. It is right and necessary, as with all divine Scripture, to faithfully determine the time about which the Apostle was writing, the person he was discussing, and the specific point he was making. Otherwise, a reader who misses any of these details through ignorance may completely miss the true meaning. The Ethiopian eunuch understood this when he asked Philip, "I beg you, about whom does the Prophet say this? About himself or about someone else?" He was concerned that if he interpreted the passage in a way that didn't fit the person being discussed, he would miss the correct sense. Similarly, the disciples wanted to understand the timing of what was foretold, so they asked the Lord, "Tell us, when will these things happen? And what is the sign of Your coming?" And again, after hearing from the Savior about the events of the end times, they wanted to know when it would occur so they could avoid error themselves and teach others correctly—just as they later corrected the Thessalonians who had gone astray. When someone properly understands these details, their grasp of the faith is sound and healthy. But if they mistake any of these points, they immediately fall into heresy. For example, Hymenaeus and Alexander and their followers missed the correct time when they claimed the resurrection had already happened. The Galatians were mistaken about time in the opposite direction, continuing to emphasize circumcision after its proper time had passed. Missing the correct person was the error of the Jews, and still is, since they think that "Behold, the Virgin shall conceive and bear a Son, and they shall call his Name Emmanuel, which means God with us," refers to one of their own people. They believe that "A prophet shall the Lord your God raise up to you" refers to one of the Prophets, and regarding the words "He was led as a sheep to the slaughter," instead of learning from Philip, they guess it was spoken about Isaiah or some other earlier prophet.

54. For it is written, 'So much better than the Angels.' let us then first examine this. Now it is right and necessary, as in all divine Scripture, so here, faithfully to expound the time of which the Apostle wrote, and the person, and the point; lest the reader, from ignorance missing either these or any similar particular, may be wide of the true sense. This understood that inquiring eunuch, when he thus besought Philip, 'I pray you, of whom does the Prophet speak this? Of himself, or of some other man Acts 8:34?' for he feared lest, expounding the lesson unsuitably to the person, he should wander from the right sense. And the disciples, wishing to learn the time of what was foretold, besought the Lord, 'Tell us,' said they, 'when shall these things be? And what is the sign of Your coming Matthew 24:3?' And again, hearing from the Saviour the events of the end, they desired to learn the time of it, that they might be kept from error themselves, and might be able to teach others; as, for instance, when they had learned, they set right the Thessalonians, who were going wrong. When then one knows properly these points, his understanding of the faith is right and healthy; but if he mistakes any such points, immediately he falls into heresy. Thus Hymenæus and Alexander and their fellows were beside the time, when they said that the resurrection had already been; and the Galatians were after the time, in making much of circumcision now. And to miss the person was the lot of the Jews, and is still, who think that of one of themselves is said, 'Behold, the Virgin shall conceive, and bear a Son, and they shall call his Name Emmanuel, which is being interpreted, God with us Isaiah 7:14; Matthew 1:23;' and that, 'A prophet shall the Lord your God raise up to you Deuteronomy 18:15,' is spoken of one of the Prophets; and who, as to the words, 'He was led as a sheep to the slaughter Isaiah 53:7,' instead of learning from Philip, conjecture them spoken of Isaiah or some other of the former Prophets.

The enemies of Christ have fallen into their horrible heresy because of this state of mind. If they had understood the person being discussed, the subject matter, and the timing of the Apostle's words, they would not have interpreted what refers to Christ's humanity as if it referred to His divinity, nor would they have committed such a great act of irreligion in their foolishness. This will become clear if one properly explains the beginning of this passage. The Apostle says, "God who at sundry times and various manners spoke in times past unto the fathers by the prophets, has in these last days spoken unto us by His Son." Then shortly after he says, "when He had by Himself purged our sins, He sat down on the right hand of the Majesty on high, having become so much better than the Angels, as He has by inheritance obtained a more excellent Name than they." It is clear that the Apostle's words refer to the time when God spoke to us through His Son and when the purging of sins took place. When did He speak to us through His Son, and when did the purging of sins happen? And when did He become man? It was after the Prophets, in the last days. Next, as he continues his account of the economy that concerns us and speaks of the last times, he naturally observes that God was not silent with people in former times either, but spoke to them through the Prophets. Since the prophets served as ministers, and the Law was spoken by Angels, while the Son also came to earth to minister, he had to add "become so much better than the Angels," wanting to show that just as much as a son surpasses a servant, so much more does the ministry of the Son surpass the ministry of servants. Contrasting the old ministry and the new, the Apostle speaks plainly to the Jews, writing "become so much better than the Angels." This is why throughout he uses no comparison such as "become greater" or "more honorable," so that we would not think of Him and them as being of the same kind. Instead his word is "better," which marks the difference between the Son's nature and created things. We have proof of this from divine Scripture. For example, David says in the Psalm, "One day in Your courts is better than a thousand," and Solomon cries out, "Receive my instruction and not silver, and knowledge rather than choice gold. For wisdom is better than rubies; and all the things that may be desired are not to be compared to it." Are not wisdom and earthly stones different in essence and separate in nature? Are heavenly courts at all similar to earthly houses? Or is there any resemblance between things eternal and spiritual and things temporal and mortal? This is what Isaiah says: "Thus says the Lord unto the eunuchs that keep My sabbaths, and choose the things that please Me, and take hold of My Covenant; even unto them will I give in Mine house, and within My walls, a place and a name better than of sons and of daughters: I will give them an everlasting name that shall not be cut off." In the same way, there is nothing similar between the Son and the Angels. So the word "better" is not used to compare but to contrast, because of the difference of His nature from theirs. Therefore the Apostle himself, when he interprets the word "better," places its meaning in nothing less than the Son's excellence over created things, calling the one Son and the others servants; the one, as a Son with the Father, sitting on the right; and the others, as servants, standing before Him, being sent, and fulfilling tasks.

55. (3.) Such has been the state of mind under which Christ's enemies have fallen into their execrable heresy. For had they known the person, and the subject, and the season of the Apostle's words, they would not have expounded of Christ's divinity what belongs to His manhood, nor in their folly have committed so great an act of irreligion. Now this will be readily seen, if one expounds properly the beginning of this lection. For the Apostle says, 'God who at sundry times and various manners spoke in times past unto the fathers by the prophets, has in these last days spoken unto us by His Son Hebrews 1:1-2;' then again shortly after he says, 'when He had by Himself purged our sins, He sat down on the right hand of the Majesty on high, having become so much better than the Angels, as He has by inheritance obtained a more excellent Name than they.' It appears then that the Apostle's words make mention of that time, when God spoke unto us by His Son, and when a purging of sins took place. Now when did He speak unto us by His Son, and when did purging of sins take place? And when did He become man? When, but subsequently to the Prophets in the last days? Next, proceeding with his account of the economy in which we were concerned, and speaking of the last times, he is naturally led to observe that not even in the former times was God silent with men, but spoke to them by the Prophets. And, whereas the prophets ministered, and the Law was spoken by Angels, while the Son too came on earth, and that in order to minister, he was forced to add, 'Become so much better than the Angels,' wishing to show that, as much as the son excels a servant, so much also the ministry of the Son is better than the ministry of servants. Contrasting then the old ministry and the new, the Apostle deals freely with the Jews, writing and saying, 'Become so much better than the Angels.' This is why throughout he uses no comparison, such as 'become greater,' or 'more honourable,' lest we should think of Him and them as one in kind, but 'better' is his word, by way of marking the difference of the Son's nature from things originated. And of this we have proof from divine Scripture; David, for instance, saying in the Psalm, 'One day in Your courts is better than a thousand:' and Solomon crying out, 'Receive my instruction and not silver, and knowledge rather than choice gold. For wisdom is better than rubies; and all the things that may be desired are not to be compared to it Proverbs 8:10-11.' Are not wisdom and stones of the earth different in essence and separate in nature? Are heavenly courts at all akin to earthly houses? Or is there any similarity between things eternal and spiritual, and things temporal and mortal? And this is what Isaiah says, 'Thus says the Lord unto the eunuchs that keep My sabbaths, and choose the things that please Me, and take hold of My Covenant; even unto them will I give in Mine house, and within My walls, a place and a name better than of sons and of daughters: I will give them an everlasting name that shall not be cut off Isaiah 56:4-5.' In like manner there is nought akin between the Son and the Angels; so that the word 'better' is not used to compare but to contrast, because of the difference of His nature from them. And therefore the Apostle also himself, when he interprets the word 'better,' places its force in nothing short of the Son's excellence over things originated, calling the one Son, the other servants; the one, as a Son with the Father, sitting on the right; and the others, as servants, standing before Him, and being sent, and fulfilling offices.

Scripture, in speaking this way, implies—O Arians—not that the Son is originate, but rather that He is other than originate things and proper to the Father, being in His bosom. (4.) Nor does the expression "become," which appears here, show that the Son is originate, as you suppose. If the text simply said "become" and nothing more, the Arians might have a case. But since they are confronted throughout the passage with the word "Son," showing that He is other than originate things, the word "become" does not occur by itself—"better" is immediately added to it. The writer considered the expression unproblematic, knowing that in the case of one who is admittedly a genuine Son, to say "become" is the same as saying that He had been made and is "better." It makes no difference even if we speak of what is generate as "become" or "made." But by contrast, originate things cannot be called generate, being God's handiwork as they are, except insofar as after their making they partake of the generate Son, and are therefore said to have been generated also—not at all in their own nature, but because of their participation in the Son in the Spirit. Divine Scripture recognizes this again. It says in the case of originate things, "All things came to be through Him, and without Him nothing came to be" (John 1:3), and "In wisdom have You made them all." But in the case of sons who are generate, "To Job there came to be seven sons and three daughters" (Job 1:2), and "Abraham was a hundred years old when there came to be to him Isaac his son" (Genesis 21:5), and Moses said (Deuteronomy 21:15), "If to any one there come to be sons." Therefore, since the Son is other than originate things, being alone the proper offspring of the Father's essence, this argument of the Arians about the word "become" is worthless.

56. Scripture, in speaking thus, implies, O Arians, not that the Son is originate, but rather other than things originate, and proper to the Father, being in His bosom. (4.) Nor does even the expression 'become,' which here occurs, show that the Son is originate, as you suppose. If indeed it were simply 'become' and no more, a case might stand for the Arians; but, whereas they are forestalled with the word 'Son' throughout the passage, showing that He is other than things originate, so again not even the word 'become' occurs absolutely, but 'better' is immediately subjoined. For the writer thought the expression immaterial, knowing that in the case of one who was confessedly a genuine Son, to say 'become' is the same with saying that He had been made, and is, 'better.' For it matters not even if we speak of what is generate, as 'become' or 'made;' but on the contrary, things originate cannot be called generate, God's handiwork as they are, except so far as after their making they partake of the generate Son, and are therefore said to have been generated also, not at all in their own nature, but because of their participation of the Son in the Spirit. And this again divine Scripture recognises; for it says in the case of things originate, 'All things came to be through Him, and without Him nothing came to be John 1:3,' and, 'In wisdom have You made them all;' but in the case of sons which are generate, 'To Job there came to be seven sons and three daughters Job 1:2,' and, ' Abraham was an hundred years old when there came to be to him Isaac his son Genesis 21:5;' and Moses said Deuteronomy 21:15, 'If to any one there come to be sons.' Therefore since the Son is other than things originate, alone the proper offspring of the Father's essence, this plea of the Arians about the word 'become' is worth nothing.

If, despite being refuted thus far, they still stubbornly insist that the language involves comparison, and that comparison therefore implies sameness of kind, so that the Son shares the nature of the Angels, they will first of all incur the disgrace of rivaling and repeating what Valentinus held, and Carpocrates, and those other heretics. The former said that the Angels were of one kind with the Christ, and Carpocrates said that Angels are makers of the world. Perhaps it is under the instruction of these teachers that they compare the Word of God with the Angels.

(5.) If moreover, baffled so far, they should still violently insist that the language is that of comparison, and that comparison in consequence implies oneness of kind, so that the Son is of the nature of Angels, they will in the first place incur the disgrace of rivalling and repeating what Valentinus held, and Carpocrates, and those other heretics, of whom the former said that the Angels were one in kind with the Christ, and Carpocrates that Angels are framers of the world. Perchance it is under the instruction of these masters that they compare the Word of God with the Angels.

Though surely amid such speculations, they will be moved by the sacred poet, saying, "Who is he among the gods that shall be like the Lord," and, "Among the gods there is none like You, O Lord." However, they must be answered, with the chance of their profiting by it, that comparison admittedly does belong to subjects that are one in kind, not to those which differ. No one, for instance, would compare God with man, or again man with animals, nor wood with stone, because their natures are unlike. But God is beyond comparison, and man is compared to man, and wood to wood, and stone to stone. Now in such cases we should not speak of "better," but of "rather" and "more." Thus Joseph was comely rather than his brothers, and Rachel than Leah; star is not better than star, but is the rather excellent in glory. Whereas in bringing together things which differ in kind, then "better" is used to mark the difference, as has been said in the case of wisdom and jewels. If then the Apostle had said, "by so much has the Son precedence of the Angels," or "by so much greater," you would have had a case, as if the Son were compared with the Angels. But, as it is, in saying that He is "better," and differs as far as Son from servants, the Apostle shows that He is other than the Angels in nature.

57. Though surely amid such speculations, they will be moved by the sacred poet, saying, 'Who is he among the gods that shall be like the Lord,' and, 'Among the gods there is none like You, O Lord.' However, they must be answered, with the chance of their profiting by it, that comparison confessedly does belong to subjects one in kind, not to those which differ. No one, for instance, would compare God with man, or again man with brutes, nor wood with stone, because their natures are unlike; but God is beyond comparison, and man is compared to man, and wood to wood, and stone to stone. Now in such cases we should not speak of 'better,' but of 'rather' and 'more;' thus Joseph was comely rather than his brethren, and Rachel than Leah; star is not better than star, but is the rather excellent in glory; whereas in bringing together things which differ in kind, then 'better' is used to mark the difference, as has been said in the case of wisdom and jewels. Had then the Apostle said, 'by so much has the Son precedence of the Angels,' or 'by so much greater,' you would have had a plea, as if the Son were compared with the Angels; but, as it is, in saying that He is 'better,' and differs as far as Son from servants, the Apostle shows that He is other than the Angels in nature.

Furthermore, by saying that He is the one who has "laid the foundation of all things" (Hebrews 1:10), the author shows that He is other than all created things. But if He is other and different in ousia from their nature, what comparison of His ousia can there be, or what likeness to them? Though even if they have any such thoughts, Paul shall refute them, speaking directly to this point: "For unto which of the Angels said He at any time, You are My Son, this day have I begotten You? And of the Angels He says, Who makes His Angels spirits, and His ministers a flame of fire" (Hebrews 1:7).

(6.) Moreover by saying that He it is who has 'laid the foundation of all things Hebrews 1:10,' he shows that He is other than all things originate. But if He be other and different in essence from their nature, what comparison of His essence can there be, or what likeness to them? Though, even if they have any such thoughts, Paul shall refute them, who speaks to the very point, 'For unto which of the Angels said He at any time, You are My Son, this day have I begotten You? And of the Angels He says, Who makes His Angels spirits, and His ministers a flame of fire Hebrews 1:7.'

Notice here that the word "made" applies to created things, and he calls them things that have been made. But when speaking of the Son, he doesn't talk about making or becoming, but about eternity and kingship and the work of a Creator, proclaiming, "Your Throne, O God, is for ever and ever," and "You, Lord, in the beginning laid the foundation of the earth, and the heavens are the works of Your hands; they shall perish, but You remain." From these words, even they might understand—if they were willing—that the Creator is different from created things: the former is God, the latter are created things, made out of nothing. The statement "They shall perish" doesn't mean creation is actually destined for destruction, but rather expresses the nature of created things by describing what they naturally tend toward. Things that are capable of perishing, even though they don't actually perish because of their Maker's grace, have come out of nothing and themselves testify that they once did not exist. For this reason, since their nature is like this, it is said of the Son, "You remain," to show His eternity. Since He doesn't have the capacity for perishing that created things have, but has eternal duration, it is wrong to say of Him, "He was not before His generation," and right to say He always exists and endures together with the Father. Even if the Apostle had not written this way in his Epistle to the Hebrews, his other Epistles and all of Scripture would certainly prevent them from thinking such things about the Word. But since he has written it expressly here, and as has been shown above, the Son is Offspring of the Father's ousia, and He is Creator while other things are created by Him, and He is the Radiance and Word and Image and Wisdom of the Father, and created things stand and serve in their place below the Triad—therefore the Son is different in kind and different in ousia from created things, and on the contrary is proper to the Father's ousia and one in physis with it. This is why the Son too does not say, "My Father is better than I," lest we should think He is foreign to His Nature, but "greater"—not greater in greatness or in time, but because of His generation from the Father Himself. Indeed, in saying "greater" He again shows that He is proper to His ousia.

58. Observe here, the word 'made' belongs to things originate, and he calls them things made; but to the Son he speaks not of making, nor of becoming, but of eternity and kingship, and a Framer's office, exclaiming, 'Your Throne, O God, is for ever and ever;' and, 'Thou, Lord, in the beginning hast laid the foundation of the earth, and the heavens are the works of Your hands; they shall perish, but You remain.' From which words even they, were they but willing, might perceive that the Framer is other than things framed, the former God, the latter things originate, made out of nothing. For what has been said, 'They shall perish,' is said, not as if the creation were destined for destruction, but to express the nature of things originate by the issue to which they tend. For things which admit of perishing, though through the grace of their Maker they perish not, yet have come out of nothing, and themselves witness that they once were not. And on this account, since their nature is such, it is said of the Son, 'You remain,' to show His eternity; for not having the capacity of perishing, as things originate have, but having eternal duration, it is foreign to Him to have it said, 'He was not before His generation,' but proper to Him to be always, and to endure together with the Father. And though the Apostle had not thus written in his Epistle to the Hebrews, still his other Epistles, and the whole of Scripture, would certainly forbid their entertaining such notions concerning the Word. But since he has here expressly written it, and, as has been above shown, the Son is Offspring of the Father's essence, and He is Framer, and other things are framed by Him, and He is the Radiance and Word and Image and Wisdom of the Father, and things originate stand and serve in their place below the Triad, therefore the Son is different in kind and different in essence from things originate, and on the contrary is proper to the Father's essence and one in nature with it. And hence it is that the Son too says not, 'My Father is better than I John 14:28,' lest we should conceive Him to be foreign to His Nature, but 'greater,' not indeed in greatness, nor in time, but because of His generation from the Father Himself, nay, in saying 'greater' He again shows that He is proper to His essence.

Notice that when the Apostle says "so much better than the Angels," his primary intention was not to compare the essence of the Word to created things (since He cannot be compared—they are actually incommeasurable). Rather, he was considering the Word's coming in the flesh and the economy he then carried out. He wanted to show that the Word was not like those who had come before Him. Just as much as He surpassed in nature those who were sent before Him, by that same measure the grace that came from and through Him was better than the ministry through Angels. For it is the role of servants to demand the fruits and nothing more, but it is the role of the Son and Master to forgive the debts and to transfer the vineyard.

59. (7). And the Apostle's own reason for saying, 'so much better than the Angels,' was not any wish in the first instance to compare the essence of the Word to things originate (for He cannot be compared, rather they are incommeasurable), but regarding the Word's visitation in the flesh, and the Economy which He then sustained, he wished to show that He was not like those who had gone before Him; so that, as much as He excelled in nature those who were sent afore by Him, by so much also the grace which came from and through Him was better than the ministry through Angels. For it is the function of servants, to demand the fruits and no more; but of the Son and Master to forgive the debts and to transfer the vineyard.

The Apostle's subsequent words clearly demonstrate the Son's excellence over created things: "Therefore we ought to give the more earnest heed to the things which we have heard, lest at any time we should let them slip. For if the word spoken by Angels was steadfast, and every transgression and disobedience received a just recompense of reward; how shall we escape, if we neglect so great salvation; which at the first began to be spoken by the Lord, and was confirmed unto us by them that heard Him." However, if the Son were numbered among created things, He would not be better than they are, nor would disobedience bring greater punishment because of Him. In the same way, when Angels ministered, there was no greater or lesser guilt for transgressors depending on which Angel was involved—the Law was one, and its punishment for transgressors was one. But since the Word is not among created things but is the Son of the Father, His person and His works are better and surpass all others, and therefore the punishment is also worse. Let them consider the grace that comes through the Son, and let them recognize the testimony He gives through His works: that He is different from created things, and that He alone is truly the Son in the Father and the Father in Him. The Law was spoken by Angels and made no one perfect, needing the Word's visitation, as Paul said. But that visitation has completed the Father's work. Previously, from Adam to Moses, death reigned, but the Word's presence destroyed death. We are no longer all dying in Adam; instead, in Christ we are all being raised to life. Previously, the Law was proclaimed from Dan to Beersheba, and God was known only in Judea. But now their voice has gone out to all the earth, and all the earth has been filled with knowledge of God. The disciples have made disciples of all nations, and now what is written is fulfilled: "They shall be all taught of God." Previously, what was revealed was only a type, but now the truth has been made manifest. The Apostle himself describes this more clearly later, saying, "By so much was Jesus made a surety of a better testament," and again, "But now has He obtained a more excellent ministry, by how much also He is the Mediator of a better covenant, which was established upon better promises." Also, "For the Law made nothing perfect, but the bringing in of a better hope did." And again, "It was therefore necessary that the patterns of things in the heavens should be purified with these; but the heavenly things themselves with better sacrifices than these." Both in the verse we are discussing and throughout Scripture, the Apostle applies the word "better" to the Lord, who is better than and different from created things. The sacrifice through Him is better, the hope in Him is better, and the promises through Him are better—not merely as something great compared to something small, but as one differing from the other in nature, because He who carries out this divine plan is "better" than created things.

(8.) Certainly what the Apostle proceeds to say shows the excellence of the Son over things originate; 'Therefore we ought to give the more earnest heed to the things which we have heard, lest at any time we should let them slip. For if the word spoken by Angels was steadfast, and every transgression and disobedience received a just recompense of reward; how shall we escape, if we neglect so great salvation; which at the first began to be spoken by the Lord, and was confirmed unto us by them that heard Him Hebrews 2:1-3.' But if the Son were in the number of things originate, He was not better than they, nor did disobedience involve increase of punishment because of Him; any more than in the Ministry of Angels there was not, according to each Angel, greater or less guilt in the transgressors, but the Law was one, and one was its vengeance on transgressors. But, whereas the Word is not in the number of originate things, but is Son of the Father, therefore, as He Himself is better and His acts better and transcendent, so also the punishment is worse. Let them contemplate then the grace which is through the Son, and let them acknowledge the witness which He gives even from His works, that He is other than things originated, and alone the very Son in the Father and the Father in Him. And the Law was spoken by Angels, and perfected no one Hebrews 7:19, needing the visitation of the Word, as Paul has said; but that visitation has perfected the work of the Father. And then, from Adam unto Moses death reigned Romans 5:14; but the presence of the Word abolished death. 2 Timothy 1:10 And no longer in Adam are we all dying 1 Corinthians 15:22; but in Christ we are all reviving. And then, from Dan to Beersheba was the Law proclaimed, and in Judæa only was God known; but now, unto all the earth has gone forth their voice, and all the earth has been filled with the knowledge of God, and the disciples have made disciples of all the nations Matthew 28:19, and now is fulfilled what is written, 'They shall be all taught of God John 6:45; Isaiah 54:13.' And then what was revealed was but a type; but now the truth has been manifested. And this again the Apostle himself describes afterwards more clearly, saying, 'By so much was Jesus made a surety of a better testament;' and again, 'But now has He obtained a more excellent ministry, by how much also He is the Mediator of a better covenant, which was established upon better promises.' And, 'For the Law made nothing perfect, but the bringing in of a better hope did.' And again he says, 'It was therefore necessary that the patterns of things in the heavens should be purified with these; but the heavenly things themselves with better sacrifices than these.' Both in the verse before us, then, and throughout, does he ascribe the word 'better' to the Lord, who is better and other than originated things. For better is the sacrifice through Him, better the hope in Him; and also the promises through Him, not merely as great compared with small, but the one differing from the other in nature, because He who conducts this economy, is 'better' than things originated.

Moreover, the words "He has become surety" indicate the pledge He has provided on our behalf. For just as, being the Word, He "became flesh" and we attribute "became" to the flesh—since it is originated and created—so also here we interpret the expression "He has become" according to a second sense, namely, because He has become man. Let these contentious people know that they fail in this perverse purpose of theirs. Let them know that Paul does not mean that His essence has become, knowing as he did that He is Son and Wisdom and Radiance and Image of the Father. Rather, Paul refers the word "become" to the ministry of that covenant in which death, which once ruled, is abolished. For here too, the ministry through Him has become better, in that "what the Law could not do in that it was weak through the flesh, God sending His own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh, and for sin condemned sin in the flesh," freeing it from the trespass in which, being continually held captive, it did not admit the Divine mind. And having made the flesh capable of receiving the Word, He made us walk no longer according to the flesh but according to the Spirit, and say again and again, "But we are not in the flesh but in the Spirit," and, "For the Son of God came into the world, not to judge the world, but to redeem all people, and that the world might be saved through Him." Previously the world, as guilty, was under judgment from the Law; but now the Word has taken the judgment upon Himself, and having suffered in the body for all, has given salvation to all. With this in view, John exclaimed, "The law was given by Moses, but grace and truth came by Jesus Christ." Grace is better than the Law, and truth is better than the shadow.

60. (9.) Moreover the words 'He has become surety' denote the pledge in our behalf which He has provided. For as, being the 'Word,' He 'became flesh John 1:14 ' and 'become' we ascribe to the flesh, for it is originated and created, so do we here the expression 'He has become,' expounding it according to a second sense, viz. because He has become man. And let these contentious men know, that they fail in this their perverse purpose; let them know that Paul does not signify that His essence has become, knowing, as he did, that He is Son and Wisdom and Radiance and Image of the Father; but here too he refers the word 'become' to the ministry of that covenant, in which death which once ruled is abolished. Since here also the ministry through Him has become better, in that 'what the Law could not do in that it was weak through the flesh, God sending His own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh, and for sin condemned sin in the flesh Romans 8:3,' ridding it of the trespass, in which, being continually held captive, it admitted not the Divine mind. And having rendered the flesh capable of the Word, He made us walk, no longer according to the flesh, but according to the Spirit, and say again and again, 'But we are not in the flesh but in the Spirit,' and, 'For the Son of God came into the world, not to judge the world, but to redeem all men, and that the world might be saved through Him John 3:17.' Formerly the world, as guilty, was under judgment from the Law; but now the Word has taken on Himself the judgment, and having suffered in the body for all, has bestowed salvation to all. With a view to this has John exclaimed, 'The law was given by Moses, but grace and truth came by Jesus Christ John 1:17.' Better is grace than the Law, and truth than the shadow.

"Better" then, as has already been said, could not have been brought about by anyone other than the Son, who sits at the right hand of the Father. And what does this indicate except the Son's genuine nature, and that the Godhead of the Father is the same as the Son's? Because the Son reigns in His Father's kingdom, is seated upon the same throne as the Father, and is contemplated in the Father's Godhead, therefore the Word is God, and whoever sees the Son sees the Father; and thus there is one God. Though sitting on the right, He does not place His Father on the left; instead, whatever is right and precious in the Father, the Son also has, and says, "All things that the Father has are Mine John 16:15." Therefore also the Son, though sitting on the right, also sees the Father on the right, though it is as one who has become man that He says, "I saw the Lord always before My face, for He is on My right hand, therefore I shall not fall." This moreover shows that the Son is in the Father and the Father in the Son; for with the Father being on the right, the Son is on the right; and while the Son sits on the right of the Father, the Father is in the Son. And the Angels indeed minister by ascending and descending; but concerning the Son he says, "And let all the Angels of God worship Him Hebrews 1:6." And when Angels minister, they say, "I am sent unto you," and, "The Lord has commanded;" but the Son, though He says in human fashion, "I am sent," and comes to finish the work and to minister, nevertheless says, as being Word and Image, "I am in the Father, and the Father in Me;" and, "He that has seen Me, has seen the Father," and, "The Father that abides in Me, He does the works;" for what we see in that Image are the Father's works.

61. (10.) 'Better' then, as has been said, could not have been brought to pass by any other than the Son, who sits on the right hand of the Father. And what does this denote but the Son's genuineness, and that the Godhead of the Father is the same as the Son's? For in that the Son reigns in His Father's kingdom, is seated upon the same throne as the Father, and is contemplated in the Father's Godhead, therefore is the Word God, and whoever beholds the Son, beholds the Father; and thus there is one God. Sitting then on the right, yet He does not place His Father on the left; but whatever is right and precious in the Father, that also the Son has, and says, 'All things that the Father has are Mine John 16:15.' Wherefore also the Son, though sitting on the right, also sees the Father on the right, though it be as become man that He says, 'I saw the Lord always before My face, for He is on My right hand, therefore I shall not fall.' This shows moreover that the Son is in the Father and the Father in the Son; for the Father being on the right, the Son is on the right; and while the Son sits on the right of the Father, the Father is in the Son. And the Angels indeed minister ascending and descending; but concerning the Son he says, 'And let all the Angels of God worship Him Hebrews 1:6.' And when Angels minister, they say, 'I am sent unto you,' and, 'The Lord has commanded;' but the Son, though He say in human fashion, 'I am sent,' and comes to finish the work and to minister, nevertheless says, as being Word and Image, 'I am in the Father, and the Father in Me;' and, 'He that has seen Me, has seen the Father.' and, 'The Father that abides in Me, He does the works;' for what we behold in that Image are the Father's works.

What has already been said ought to shame those persons who are fighting against the very truth. However, if they refuse to understand the word "become," as used of the Son, to mean "has been and is"—or to refer to the better covenant having come into being, as we have said—but instead insist on this expression to claim that the Word is created, then let them hear the same thing again in brief, since they have forgotten what has been said.

(11.) What has been already said ought to shame those persons who are fighting against the very truth; however, if, because it is written, 'become better,' they refuse to understand 'become,' as used of the Son, as 'has been and is;' or again as referring to the better covenant having come to be, as we have said, but consider from this expression that the Word is called originate, let them hear the same again in a concise form, since they have forgotten what has been said.

If the Son is counted among the Angels, then let the word 'become' apply to Him as it does to them, and let Him not differ from them at all in nature. But then either they must be sons along with Him, or He must be an Angel along with them. Either they all sit together on the right hand of the Father, or the Son stands with them all as a ministering Spirit, sent forth to minister just as they are. But if, on the other hand, Paul distinguishes the Son from created things, saying, 'To which of the Angels did He say at any time, You are My Son,' and the one creates heaven and earth while they are made by Him, and He sits with the Father while they stand by ministering, who does not see that he has not used the word 'become' of the essence of the Word, but of the ministry that came through Him? For just as, being the 'Word,' He 'became flesh,' so when He became man, He became by so much better in His ministry than the ministry which came by the Angels, as Son excels servants and Creator excels things created. Let them therefore stop taking the word 'become' as referring to the substance of the Son, for He is not one of created things. Let them acknowledge that it indicates His ministry and the Economy which came to pass.

62. If the Son be in the number of the Angels, then let the word 'become' apply to Him as to them, and let Him not differ at all from them in nature; but be they either sons with Him, or be He an Angel with them; sit they one and all together on the right hand of the Father, or be the Son standing with them all as a ministering Spirit, sent forth to minister Himself as they are. But if on the other hand Paul distinguishes the Son from things originate, saying, 'To which of the Angels said He at any time, You are My Son.' and the one frames heaven and earth, but they are made by Him; and He sits with the Father, but they stand by ministering, who does not see that he has not used the word 'become' of the essence of the Word, but of the ministration come through Him? For as, being the 'Word,' He 'became flesh,' so when become man, He became by so much better in His ministry, than the ministry which came by the Angels, as Son excels servants and Framer things framed. Let them cease therefore to take the word 'become' of the substance of the Son, for He is not one of originated things; and let them acknowledge that it is indicative of His ministry and the Economy which came to pass.

But how He became better in His ministry, while being better in nature than created things, is clear from what has been said before, which I think is sufficient by itself to put them to shame. But if they continue the argument, it will be appropriate to meet their reckless boldness by confronting them with similar expressions that are used concerning the Father Himself. This may shame them into restraining their tongue from evil, or may teach them how deep their folly is. Now it is written, 'Become my strong rock and house of defense, that You may save me.' And again, 'The Lord became a defense for the oppressed,' and similar passages found in divine Scripture. If they apply these passages to the Son, which is perhaps closest to the truth, then let them acknowledge that the sacred writers ask Him, as one who is not originate, to become for them 'a strong rock and house of defense.' And from now on let them understand 'become,' and 'He made,' and 'He created,' as referring to His incarnate presence. For it was then that He became 'a strong rock and house of defense,' when He bore our sins in His own body upon the tree, and said, 'Come unto Me, all you that labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest Matthew 11:28.'

(12.) But how He became better in His ministry, being better in nature than things originate, appears from what has been said before, which, I consider, is sufficient in itself to put them to shame. But if they carry on the contest, it will be proper upon their rash daring to close with them, and to oppose to them those similar expressions which are used concerning the Father Himself. This may serve to shame them to refrain their tongue from evil, or may teach them the depth of their folly. Now it is written, 'Become my strong rock and house of defense, that You may save me.' And again, 'The Lord became a defense for the oppressed,' and the like which are found in divine Scripture. If then they apply these passages to the Son, which perhaps is nearest to the truth, then let them acknowledge that the sacred writers ask Him, as not being originate, to become to them 'a strong rock and house of defense;' and for the future let them understand 'become,' and 'He made,' and 'He created,' of His incarnate presence. For then did He become 'a strong rock and house of defense,' when He bore our sins in His own body upon the tree, and said, 'Come unto Me, all you that labour and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest Matthew 11:28.'

But if they apply these passages to the Father, will they dare to claim that God is originated simply because it says "become" and "He became"? Yes, they will dare to do so, since they argue this way about His Word. For the logic of their argument leads them to speculate the same things about the Father as they imagine about His Word. But may such a notion be far from the minds of all the faithful! For the Son is not numbered among originated things, nor do these scriptural phrases "become" and "He became" indicate a beginning of being, but rather the help that was given to those in need. For God is always the same and unchanging, but human beings came into existence later through the Word, when the Father willed it. God is invisible and inaccessible to originated things, and especially to people on earth. So when people in their weakness call upon Him, when in persecution they ask for help, when under injuries they pray, then the Invisible One, being a lover of humanity, shines upon them with His kindness, which He exercises through and in His own Word. And immediately the divine manifestation is given to each person according to their need: to the weak it becomes health, to the persecuted a refuge and house of defense, and to the injured He says, "While you speak I will say, Here I am" (Isaiah 58:9). Whatever defense comes to each person through the Son, each person says that God has become something to them, since help comes from God Himself through the Word. Moreover, common human usage recognizes this, and everyone will acknowledge its correctness. Often help comes from one person to another: one person has undertaken labor for someone who was wronged, as Abraham did for Lot; another has opened his home to the persecuted, as Obadiah did for the sons of the prophets; another has welcomed a stranger, as Lot did for the Angels; and another has provided for the needy, as Job did for those who begged from him. And when each of these benefited people says, "Such a person became a help to me," and another says "and to me a refuge," and another "to me a supply," in saying this they would not be speaking about the original coming-to-be or the ousia of their benefactors, but about the kindness that came to them from these people. So also when the saints say about God, "He became" and "become Thou," they do not indicate any original coming-to-be, for God is without beginning and unoriginate, but rather the salvation that is brought to people from Him.

63. But if they refer these passages to the Father, will they, when it is here also written, 'Become' and 'He became,' venture so far as to affirm that God is originate? Yea, they will dare, as they thus argue concerning His Word; for the course of their argument carries them on to conjecture the same things concerning the Father, as they devise concerning His Word. But far be such a notion ever from the thoughts of all the faithful! For neither is the Son in the number of things originated, nor do the words of Scripture in question, 'Become,' and 'He became,' denote beginning of being, but that succour which was given to the needy. For God is always, and one and the same; but men have come to be afterwards through the Word, when the Father Himself willed it; and God is invisible and inaccessible to originated things, and especially to men upon earth. When then men in infirmity invoke Him, when in persecution they ask help, when under injuries they pray, then the Invisible, being a lover of man, shines forth upon them with His beneficence, which He exercises through and in His proper Word. And immediately the divine manifestation is made to every one according to his need, and is made to the weak health, and to the persecuted a 'refuge' and 'house of defense;' and to the injured He says, 'While you speak I will say, Here I am Isaiah 58:9.' Whatever defense then comes to each through the Son, that each says that God has come to be to himself, since succour comes from God Himself through the Word. Moreover the usage of men recognises this, and every one will confess its propriety. Often succour comes from man to man; one has undertaken toil for the injured, as Abraham for Lot; and another has opened his home to the persecuted, as Obadiah to the sons of the prophets; and another has entertained a stranger, as Lot the Angels; and another has supplied the needy, as Job those who begged of him. And then, should one and the other of these benefited persons say, 'Such a one became an assistance to me,' and another 'and to me a refuge,' and 'to another a supply,' yet in so saying would not be speaking of the original becoming or of the essence of their benefactors, but of the beneficence coming to themselves from them; so also when the saints say concerning God, 'He became' and 'become Thou,' they do not denote any original becoming, for God is without beginning and unoriginate, but the salvation which is made to be unto men from Him.

This being properly understood, the same principle applies to the Son: whatever is said and however often it is said—phrases like "He became" and "become"—should always carry the same meaning. So when we hear the expressions in question, "become better than the Angels" and "He became," we should not imagine any original becoming of the Word, nor should we in any way suppose from such terms that He is originate. Rather, we should understand Paul's words as referring to His ministry and Economy when He became man. For when "the Word became flesh and dwelt among us" and came to minister and grant salvation to all, then He became salvation to us, and became life, and became propitiation. Then His Economy on our behalf became much better than the Angels, and He became the Way and became the Resurrection. And just as the words "Become my strong rock" do not mean that the essence of God Himself became, but rather His lovingkindness, as has been said, so also here the "having become better than the Angels," and "He became," and "by so much is Jesus become a better surety" do not signify that the essence of the Word is originate (perish the thought!), but rather the beneficence that came to us through His becoming Man—despite the fact that the heretics are unthankful and obstinate in their irreligion.

64. This being so understood, it is parallel also respecting the Son, that whatever, and however often, is said, such as, 'He became' and 'become,' should ever have the same sense: so that as, when we hear the words in question, 'become better than the Angels' and 'He became,' we should not conceive any original becoming of the Word, nor in any way fancy from such terms that He is originate; but should understand Paul's words of His ministry and Economy when He became man. For when 'the Word became flesh and dwelt among us John 1:14 ' and came to minister and to grant salvation to all, then He became to us salvation, and became life, and became propitiation; then His economy in our behalf became much better than the Angels, and He became the Way and became the Resurrection. And as the words 'Become my strong rock' do not denote that the essence of God Himself became, but His lovingkindness, as has been said, so also here the 'having become better than the Angels,' and, 'He became,' and, 'by so much is Jesus become a better surety,' do not signify that the essence of the Word is originate (perish the thought!), but the beneficence which towards us came to be through His becoming Man; unthankful though the heretics be, and obstinate in behalf of their irreligion.


Five Tomes Against Nestorius — Book V

On the Passion: the Son of God suffered in His own flesh while remaining impassible as God, and so freed us from death.

Jewish disbelief in Christ followed by some Christian teachers. The SON GOD by Nature gave His own body to death to free us, albeit His Godhead might not suffer. "Glory before the world was," can be no man's glory but that of GOD. Father most strictly God the FATHER though He permit such relations to us. 'Crucified out of weakness,' yet, Lord of glory. 'Servant's form.' 'Not Mine own will.' The forsaking on the Cross. He raised His own Body. S. Thomas' confession. Nicene Fathers. Testimony of GOD and man to the SON.

Source: Cyril of Alexandria, Five Tomes Against Nestorius (1881) Book 5. pp.155-184.. Transcribed by Roger Pearse (tertullian.org); public domain.

Contents · 8 chapters
  1. Opening
  2. §1
  3. §2
  4. §3
  5. §4
  6. §5
  7. §6
  8. §7

Opening

The God-inspired Paul takes pride in the sufferings of Christ and says at one time, "But may I never boast except in the cross of Christ, through whom the world has been crucified to me and I to the world," and at another time, "For I am not ashamed of the gospel, for it is the power of God for salvation to everyone who believes, to the Jew first and also to the Greek." The Spirit-filled apostle thought it right both to think this way himself and to teach others, for he did not write without purpose, but to persuade us to be eager for the correctness of the faith that was in him, choosing to help us delight in Christ's sufferings. But some are ashamed of the cross and impiously rise up against those who have been made teachers of everyone under the sun, because they choose to think the opposite. These wretched people practically mock Christ's sufferings and are ashamed of the gospel, infected with Jewish ignorance and in no way less foolish than they are. For the Savior's cross has become an offense to them. Indeed, when they saw the Prince of Life, the fulfillment of the Law, fastened to the wood, they shook their impious heads at him, not believing that God had truly become man and descended to our lowly state, but supposing instead that he was simply a man like us. They said, bringing forth evil things from the evil treasury of their heart, "You who destroy the temple and rebuild it in three days, save yourself; if you are the Son of God, come down from the cross," and again, "He saved others, he cannot save himself; if he is the king of Israel, let him come down from the cross now and we will believe in him." For they did not think, as I just said, that he was God by physis, nor truly the Son of God the Father, but rather that he was boasting and daring to claim for himself the glory of the Godhead. So they used to say at one time, "We are not stoning you for a good work, but for blasphemy, because you, being a man, make yourself God," and at another time they brought him to Pilate and asked that he be crucified, and when Pilate demanded that they tell the reason for their hostility toward him, they immediately began to accuse him, saying that he made himself the Son of God. But look, even now he clearly suffers the same treatment, not at the hands of Israelites or the crowd of Pharisees, but at the hands of those who appear to be Christians and are counted among teachers and those who hold the divine priesthood. For he is disbelieved to be both God by physis and the one and only true Son of God the Father, and the excuse for their wrong thinking about this very thing is that he chose to suffer death in the flesh, even though he descended to our lowly state for this very purpose according to the economy, so that by suffering for us in the flesh, he might destroy the dominion of death, since he himself is by physis Life and comes from Life, God the Father. For human physis was sick with corruption in its firstfruits and original root, that is, Adam. Since it offended through its disobedience its lawgiver and God who brought it into being, it was immediately cursed and subject to death, and death reigned from Adam to Moses, with this sentence extending over the whole seed and race that comes from him. For as those sprung from a corruptible root, we too are corruptible and remain (wretchedly!) held fast in the snares of death. But when the Creator planned good things for us and wanted to transform human physis—with corruption removed—back to what it was in the beginning, he established a new root (so to speak) for us, one that could not be overcome by death, the one Lord Jesus the Christ, that is, God the Word from his ousia made man like us, born of a woman. For we do not say that a mere man is God-bearing, but that the Word from God has truly been united to flesh in its very self, so that having laid down his life for us and given his own body to death for our sake according to the economy, and then shown it superior to corruption through the resurrection from the dead, he might give assurance to all who believe in him that he will raise us up too and make us superior to the chains of death and hardly troubled by the snares of decay.

THE Divine-uttering Paul glories in the Sufferings of Christ and says, one while, But to me be it not that I should glory save in the Cross of Christ through Whom the world has been crucified to me and I to the world, another while again, For I am not ashamed of the Gospel, for it is the power of God unto salvation unto every one that believeth, to the Jew first and to the Greek. And thus did the Spirit-clad deem right both himself to think and besides to teach others, for he hath written not without purpose, but that he might persuade us to be zealous for the rightness of the faith that was in him, choosing to delight us in the Sufferings of Christ. But some are ashamed of the Cross and impiously rising up against them that have been made teachers of all below the sun, by reason that they choose to think contrarily, they (wretched ones!) all but smile at Christ's sufferings and and are ashamed of the Gospel, sick with the Jewish unlearning and in no way inferior to them in infatuation. For the Saviour's Cross hath become to them an offence: and verily they beholding the Prince of Life, the fulfilment of the Law, affixed to the wood, they were wagging at Him their impious heads, not believing that God is of a truth made Man and come down unto emptiness, but supposing rather that He was simply a man as we, and they said, putting forth as out of the evil treasure of their heart evil things, Thou That destroyest the temple and buildest it in three days save Thyself; if Thou be the Son of God, come down from the Cross: and again, He saved others, Himself He cannot save, if He be the king of Israel, let Him now come down from the Gross and we will believe on Him. For they thought not, as I said just now, that He was God by Nature, nor yet in truth Son of God the Father but rather that He was bragging and daring to allot to Himself the glory of the Godhead. Hence they used to say, one while, For a good work we stone Thee not, but for blasphemy, because THOU being a man makest Thyself God; another while they brought Him to Pilate and besought that He should be crucified, and when he demanded that they should tell the reason of their awkwardness towards Him, they straightway began to accuse Him saying that He made Himself the Son of God. But lo now too, not at the hands of them of Israel nor yet from the multitude of the Pharisees, but at their hands who seem to be Christians and are ranked among teachers and them whose lot is the Divine Priesthood, doth He manifestly suffer equal case. For He is disbelieved to be both God by Nature, and One and Alone and Verily Son of God the Father, and the plea of their ill-counsel as to this very thing, that He chose to suffer death in the flesh, albeit for this cause He descended unto emptiness economically, in order that suffering for us in the flesh, He might bring to nought the mastery of death, as being Himself by Nature Life and sprung of Life, God the Father. For the nature of man was sick of decay, in its firstfruits and original root, i. e., Adam. For since it offended through its disobedience its Law-giver and God and That brought it forth unto being, straightway it was accursed and liable to death, and death hath reigned from Adam unto Moses, the doom for this extending over the whole seed and race that is from him. For as sprung from corruptible root, corruptible are WE too, and abide (wretched!) holden in the meshes of death. But when the Creator planned good things concerning us and willed to transelement the nature of man, decay being taken away, unto what it was at the beginning, He adorned a new root (so to speak) for us, which endured not to be overmastered by death, the One Lord Jesus the Christ, that is, God the Word out of His Essence made man as we, made of a woman. For we do not say that just a man is God-bearing, but that the Word out of God has been of a truth Its very Self united to flesh, in order, having laid down His Life for us, and given to death His own Body for our sakes economically, and then shewn it superior to corruption through the Resurrection from the dead, to give pledge to all who believe on Him that He will raise up us too, and make us superior to the bonds of death, and little heedful of the nets of decay.

Hence I think this is why the divinely-inspired Paul also speaks at length and with wonder about the love of God the Father toward us. For he said, "What shall we say therefore to these things? If God be for us, who is against us? He that spared not His own Son but gave Him up for us all, how shall He not with Him too freely give us all things?" Yet there are very many sons by grace and by adoption (for we too have been called gods and all are sons of the Most High), but One and Alone is He Who is so by physis and is His own, that is, God the Word Who is out of Him even when He was made flesh. For thus we say that He has been given even for all, as He Himself also says somewhere, "For God so loved the world that He gave His Only-Begotten Son that whosoever believeth in Him should not perish, but have eternal life." Therefore He who was given is Only-Begotten, for He alone sprang from the essence of God the Father, the Word both out of Him and in Him. But since He has been made man, therefore we make our faith in Him declaring His death after the flesh and confessing His Resurrection, knowing that the Same is both Son before the ages and man economically in the last times, and that He suffered in the flesh for our sakes and has risen from the dead.1

Hence I deem it is that the Divine-uttering Paul too, makes a matter of much speech and marvel, the love towards us of God the Father. For he said thus, What shall we say therefore to these things? if God he for us, who is against us? He that spared not His own Son but gave Him up for us all, how shall He not with Him too freely give us all things? albeit exceeding many are the sons by grace and of adoption (for we too have been called gods and all are sons of the Most High), but One and Alone is He Who is so by Nature and is His Own, that is, God the Word Who is out of Him even when He was made Flesh. For thus do we say that He has been given even for all, as Himself too somewhere saith, For God so loved the world that He gave His Only-Begotten Son that whosoever believeth in Him should not perish, but have eternal life. Only-Begotten therefore is He Who was given, for He Alone sprung from the Essence of God the Father, the Word both out of Him and in Him: but since He hath, been made Man, therefore do we make our faith in Him declaring His death after the Flesh and confessing His Resurrection, knowing that the Same is both Son before the ages and Man economically in the last times and that He suffered in the flesh for our sakes and hath risen from the dead.1

But somehow the advocate of the Jews' ignorance is indignant at our words, for he said again,

But (I know not how) the advocate of the Jews' unlearning is indignant at our words, for he said again,

§1

Nestorius: "We have shown that the divine Scripture uses the term 'Son' for the birth from the Virgin, the Mother of Christ. Now hear also about His death, whether God is anywhere used in such a way that we might introduce a passible God: 'Being enemies,' it says, 'we were reconciled to God through the death of His Son.' It did not say, 'Through the death of God the Word.'"

Nestorius: "That therefore the divine Scripture puts, Son, of the birth from the Virgin, Mother of Christ, we have shewn. Hear of His death also, whether God is any where put, so as we might bring in a passible God: Being enemies, it says, we were reconciled to God through the death of His Son, it said not, Through the death of God the Word."

True it is, as it is written, "There is a righteous man that perishes in his righteousness," for whoever by nature is inclined to harm, sometimes putting on the appearance of being helpful, turns aside from what is right, even the well-established mind. For he thinks he is being pious in no small degree, attempting to confirm what is confessed by all, and therefore saying, "In His own physis the Word out of God the Father is as God beyond sufferings and superior to death; for how should Life die?" Yet nonetheless he offends against the doctrines of the Church, completely disregarding the economy with flesh of the Only-Begotten, and in no way considering the depth of the mystery.

True is it, according as it is written, There is a righteous man that perisheth in his righteousness: for that whoso nature is to hurt, putting on sometimes the shew of being helpful, turns aside from what is right, even the well stablished mind. For he thinks he is pious in no slight degree, essaying to confirm what is confessed by all, therefore saying, In His own Nature the Word out of God the Father is as God beyond sufferings and superior to death; for how should Life die? Yet he not a whit the less too offends against the doctrines of the Church, wholly unrecking of the economy with flesh of the Only-Begotten, and in no wise considering the depth of the mystery.

If we were examining what the Nature of the Word is, or had to explain it to those who asked and wanted to learn it, it would surely be fitting and necessary to carefully go through every wise and true thought to show that it is beyond the reach of death and completely removed from sufferings. But since the mode of the Incarnation gives Him—as far as the plan of the Economy is concerned—the ability to die in the flesh even though He chooses to do so, without suffering anything in His own Nature, why do you rob us of our greatest boasts? For you heard Him say, "The Good Shepherd lays down His life for His sheep." Therefore, even though He is said to suffer, we know that He is Impassible as God. We say that He suffered death economically in His own Flesh, so that by trampling on it and rising—being Life and Life-giving—He might transform into incorruption that which is tyrannized by death, namely the body. And so the power of this achievement spreads to us as well, extending to the whole human race. And indeed the divinely-inspired Paul says, "I through the Law died to the law that I might live to God. I am crucified with Christ. I live, yet no longer I, but Christ lives in me. And the life I now live, I live by faith in the flesh of the Son of God who loved me and gave Himself for me. I do not frustrate the grace of God." For we no longer live our own life but rather that which is in Christ, and it is true that One died for all so that those who live should no longer live for themselves but for Him who died for them and rose. For before the Only-Begotten Word of God shone upon us, we were mastered by ignorance and darkness, bearing the yoke of sin, impiously offering worship to the creature rather than to our Creator and Maker, and practicing every kind of baseness without shame. We wretchedly remained in separation from Him, hostile to Him in our minds, but we have been reconciled through the death of His Son, as it is written.2

If it were under examination by us, what were the Nature of the Word, or we had to declare it to them who asked and were desirous of learning it; it would I suppose be of a surety meet and necessary, hastening to go through every wise and true thought, to shew that It is unapproachable by death and utterly removed from sufferings. But since the mode of the Incarnation gives Him, so far as pertains to the plan of the Economy, even though He choose to die in the flesh, to suffer nought in His own Nature, why bereavest thou us of our fairest boasts? for thou heard'st Him say. The Good Shepherd layeth down His Life for His sheep. Hence even though He be said to suffer, we know that He is Impassible as God, we say that He hath suffered death economically in His own Flesh, in order that treading it and risen in that He is Life and Life-giving, He might transelement unto incorruption that which is tyrannized over by death, i. e., the body: and so unto us too spreadeth the might of the achievement, extending unto the whole race. And verily the Divine-uttering Paul saith, I through the Law died to the law that I might live unto God, I am crucified with Christ, I live, no longer I, but Christ liveth in me, and wherein I now live, I live in faith, in the flesh of the Son of God Who loved me and gave Himself for me. I do not frustrate the grace of God. For no longer do we live our own life but rather that in Christ, and true is it that One died for all that they who live should no more live unto themselves but to Him which died for them and rose. For before that the Only-Begotten Word of God beamed on us, mastered by unlearning and darkness and having the yoke of sin and impiously ascribing worship to the creature rather than our Creator and Maker and practising unblamed every kind of baseness, we wretched abode in severance [from Him], in mind hostile to Him, but we have been reconciled through the death of His Son, as it is written.2

But you have again shown little regard for the truth, and putting forward your speech that rushes headlong into foolishness, you say that the world has been reconciled to God, not through the Only-Begotten—that is, the Word who came forth from the Father. And when you hear about the death of His Son and examine closely, as you suppose, the words of the Divine, you were not afraid to say, "He did not say, 'Through the death of God the Word.'" Then how, tell me, could such a statement be wise? Or rather, how could it not be filled with complete madness? For how could it be appropriate, tell me, to present the Life as subject to death? And to accuse the Nature that gives life to all things of being subject to decay—how could that not be utterly deranged, and would it not be, and rightly so, a charge of blasphemy reaching to the very extreme? By no means, therefore, does the mind of the saints agree with your subtle arguments here, or rather your empty words. For it knows, it knows that the Word of God suffered in the flesh for our sake, and through the death of His own Body has called the world to reconciliation with the Father who is in Heaven. And indeed, when making His conversation with one of the holy disciples, He said somewhere, "I am the Way and the Truth and the Life, and no one comes to the Father except through Me." But who else could be Truth and Life and Way, except the Word who came forth from God, even though He became as we are by taking the form of a servant?

But THOU again hast made but slight account of the truth, and putting forth unto us thy speech unbridled unto vapidness, sayest that the world has been reconciled to God, not through the Only-Begotten, i. e. the Word That sprang of the Father; and hearing, the death of His Son, and investigating subtilly as thou supposest, the words of the Divine, thou fearedst not to say, "He said not, Through the death of God the Word." Then how (tell me) were such a word wise, yea rather, how were it not replete with utter distraction? for how were it meet (tell me) to set forth the Life as subject to death; and to the Nature Which quickeneth all things to lay a charge of decay, how were it not wholly distraught and would it not be, and that with reason, a charge of blasphemy reaching unto the very extreme? By no means therefore does the mind of the saints go along with thy subtilties herein, or rather thy idle words: for it knows, it knows that the Word of God suffered in the flesh for our sakes, and through the death of His own Body hath called the world unto reconciliation with the Father Which is in Heaven. And verily when making His discourse with one of the holy disciples He somewhere said, I am the Way and the Truth and the Life and no man cometh unto the Father but by Me: but Truth and Life and Way, who else may be, save the Word which sprang of God, even though He have been made as we, by taking servant's form?

The fact that through him we have been shown to be partakers of the divine physis, and that we who were once far off have been brought near and united participatively through him to the Father and also to one another in one faith and unity of soul because we have been made participants of one Spirit—he himself will confirm this when he says to God the Father in heaven: "I do not ask for these alone, but also for those who believe in me through their word, that they all may be one, just as you, Father, are in me and I in you, that they also may be one in us, so that the world may believe that you sent me. And the glory which you have given me I have given them, that they may be one even as we are one, both I in them and you in me, that they may be perfected into one." Understand therefore how he himself is of physis in his own Father but is presented as a Mediator and Reconciler through being made as we are. He is in us both through his own Flesh which gives us life in spirit and through partaking of his holiness—I mean again through the Holy Spirit. And he asks for glory from the Father to make his own physis manifest to us, that it is both life-giving and superior to corruption as God. And truly he said again: "I glorified you on the earth by completing the work which you have given me to do, and now glorify me, O Father, with yourself, with the glory which I had before the world was, with you." And we are a completed work, as he first overcame decay and trampled on the power of death, for he lived again from the dead, having all things in himself.

And that through Him we have been manifested partakers of the Divine Nature and, we who once were far, have been made nigh, united participatively through Him to the FATHER and besides to one another in one faith and unity of soul by reason of being made participant of One Spirit; Himself will give assurance saying unto God the Father in Heaven, Not for these alone do I ask but for them also which believe on Me through their word, that they all may be one, as THOU Father art in Me and I in Thee, that they also may be one in us, that the world may believe that THOU sentest Me, and I. the glory which Thou hast given Me, have given them, that they may be one even as WE are one, both I in them, and THOU in Me that they may be perfected into one. Understand therefore how Himself is of Nature in His own Father but is set forth a Mediator and Reconciler through being made as we: He is in us, both through His own Flesh Which quickeneth us in spirit and through partaking of His holiness, I mean again through the Holy Ghost. And He asketh as glory from the Father to make His own Nature manifest unto us, that It is both Life-giving and superior to corruption as God. And verily He said again, I glorified Thee on the earth by perfecting the work which Thou hast given Me to do, and now do Thou glorify Me, o Father, with Thyself with the glory which I had before the world was, with Thee. And a perfected work are WE, in Him first overcoming decay and treading on the might of death, for He lived anew from the dead, having all in Himself.

But perhaps you twist what has been said toward other ideas. You say that these things should not be understood of God the Word, but rather you remove from Him and set apart by himself the one born of the holy Virgin as another son. You claim that it is him to whom such things belong, and you are eager to teach others also to think and say as you do. And you will surely say, I suppose, that the Only-Begotten Word of God, being Lord of glory, would not have sought glory from the Father as though He lacked it. Hear therefore from us as well: If you say that the Only-Begotten Son Who is out of God by physis is not He Who here asks glory from the Father, who was it who said, "Glorify Me with the glory which I had before the world was, with Thee"? How then, tell me, was the one from the holy Virgin, conceived according to you as a man separately, before the world? Will it not belong to the Creator of the ages to have an existence older than the world and co-eternal with the Father? No one who is accustomed to thinking rightly will doubt it. Therefore, when He emptied Himself, receiving the form of a servant, then—at that time—desiring to ascend to the glory inherent in Him by physis and along with the Flesh which was united to Him, He says at the proper time, "Do Thou Father glorify Me with Thyself with the glory that I had before the world was with Thee, that the world may believe that Thou sentest Me, and I, the glory which Thou hast given Me, have given them, that they may be one as We are One, I in them, and Thou in Me that they may be perfected into one." Through Him therefore we have had the reconciliation, for thus He has completed the work which the Father has given Him to accomplish. And I will make the most holy Paul the supporter of my words, who wrote thus to those who have been called out of the Gentiles: "But now in Christ Jesus ye who sometime were far off were made nigh in the Blood of Christ: for He is our Peace, Who made both one and undid the middle wall of partition, having abolished in His Flesh the enmity, the law of commandments in ordinances, for to make in Himself of twain one new man, making peace; and that He might reconcile both unto God in one body through the cross, having slain the enmity therein, and came and preached peace to you which were afar off and to them that were nigh," and again elsewhere too, "Justified therefore by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ." Therefore we have been reconciled to God the Father through the death of His Son, who brought to nothing or slew the enmity in His Flesh, according to the faith of the sacred scriptures.

But haply bearing off to other ideas what has been said, thou sayest that not of God the Word ought these things to be understood, but removing from Him and putting apart by himself him that is born of the holy Virgin as another son, thou affirmest that him it is whom such things befit and art zealous to teach others also to think and say with thee: and wilt (I suppose) surely say that the Only-Begotten Word of God being Lord of glory, would not as though lacking glory, have sought it from the Father. Hear therefore from us too, If thou sayest that the Only-Begotten Son Who is out of God by Nature is not He Who here asketh glory from the Father; who was it who said, Glorify Me with the glory which I had before the world was, with Thee? How then (tell me) was he that is of the holy Virgin, conceived of according to thee as man separately, before the world? will it not pertain to the Creator of the ages, to have a being elder than the world and Co-eternal with the Father? no one will doubt it of those who are accustomed to think aright. When therefore He emptied Himself receiving servant's form, then, then, desirous to mount up unto the glory inherent in Him by Nature and along with the Flesh which was united to Him, in fit season does He say, Do THOU Father glorify Me with Thyself with the glory that I had before the world was with Thee; that the world may believe that THOU sentest Me, and I, the glory which Thou hast given Me, have given them, that they may be one as WE are One, I in them, and THOU in Me that they may be perfected into one. Through Him therefore have we had the reconciliation, for thus hath He perfected the work which the Father hath given Him for consummation. And the supporter of my words will I make again the most holy Paul who thus wrote to those who have been called out of the Gentiles, But now in Christ Jesus YE who sometime were far off were made nigh in the Blood of Christ: for He is our Peace, Who made both one and undid the middle wall of partition, having abolished in His Flesh the enmity, the law of commandments in ordinances, for to make in Himself of twain one new man, making peace; and that He might reconcile both unto God in one body through the cross, having slain the enmity therein, and came and preached peace to you which were afar off and to them that were nigh, and again elsewhere too, Justified therefore by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ. Therefore we have been reconciled to God the Father through the death of His Son, who brought to nought or slew the enmity in His Flesh, according to the faith of the sacred scriptures.

But you are undermining the language of the divine economy and refuse to confess that the Word of God has suffered in the flesh for our sakes, employing a certain unskilled way of speaking. For you say that Son is a name common to the Word who came forth from God and to ourselves. Then, having made God the Word—through whom we have been saved—no agent of the good things that have been accomplished for us, you will evidently be caught assigning the things in which he is glorified to someone like us, conceived as other than and separate from him. And you suppose that sharing a common name will suffice quite well for proving what you said and wrongly thought. You fail to consider that even though certain other beings may be said to share the same name with things that exist by nature as they ought, one must not therefore push aside the things that are by nature, constantly transferring their properties to those which are by adoption or imitation. Instead, we must always examine the natures of things and assign them to whomever they rightly belong. For example, the Father is named and truly is God, and from him every fatherhood both in heaven and on earth is named, as it is written, yet there are also other fathers among us, both physical and spiritual. If, therefore, something most befitting God is said of God the Father, will it also belong to those who obtain the same title with him by adoption, and will the identity of name push him away from the things that most properly belong to him alone? Yet how is it not obvious to everyone that it is both absurd and contradictory for anyone among us to think and say such things? Why then do you, constantly talking to us about sharing a common name, dishonor the Son by nature and in truth, setting him aside and making him a stranger to the kindly deeds done for us? Although you ought to bring together into unity what you shamelessly completely separate, and you ought to consider as one with his own flesh the Word who is from God the Father. For in this way you will free yourself from much labor, and thinking rightly you will at last be commended. And you will in no way say that the Godhead of the Only-Begotten is passible, but you will confess with us that he is Life and Life-giving by nature and moreover beyond all suffering. Next, that the flesh suffering which was united to him—he by the grace of God, as it is written, tasted death for every man, so that having shown his own Temple superior to the one who had conquered all who are on earth, he might be called the firstfruits of those who slept and the firstborn from the dead. He transmits to us also the grace, so that being One and Only Son, both before the Incarnation and after it, he might still be called Savior and Redeemer of all. And, as I said, freeing from sin all who believe in him, he might become peace to those who are far off and to those who are near, reconciling through himself to God the Father those who formerly worshiped the creature and through sin were at enmity with the All-good God.

But thyself art undoing the words of the economy and deignest not to confess that the Word of God hath suffered in the flesh for our sakes, making use of certain unskilful loquacity: for thou sayest that Son is a name common to the Word Which sprang of God and to ourselves. Then having made God the Word, through Whom we have been saved, no worker of the good things that have been wrought to us-ward, thou wilt be evidently caught allotting the things wherein He is glorified to one as we, conceived of as other than He and apart, and thou supposest that community of name will suffice full well for demonstration of what thou saidst and unrightly thoughtest; not considering that even though with things which obtain by nature the being ought, certain other of things that be, be said to be co-named, one must not therefore thrust away the things that are by nature, ever putting their properties about those which are by adoption or imitation. But we must (I deem) ever test the natures of things done and allot them to whomsoever they rightly pertain. As for example, the Father is named and is in truth God, and from Him is every father-hood both in heaven and upon earth named, as it is written, yet are there with us other fathers too both fleshly and spiritual. If therefore ought of things most God-befitting be said of God the Father, will it belong to those too who by adoption obtain the same title with Him, and will the identity of name thrust Him away from the things which in the highest degree befit Him alone? yet how is it not evident to all that it is both absurd and discordant that any of ours should be minded thus to think and say? Why then dost thou ever talking to us of community of name, dishonour the by Nature and truly Son, putting Him forth and rendering Him alien from kindly deeds to usward? albeit thou oughtest to gather into union what thou blushest not utterly to sever, and [oughtest] to deem one with His own Flesh the Word that is out of God the Father: for thus wilt thou free thyself from much toil, and deeming aright wilt at length be praised. And thou wilt in no wise say that the Godhead of the Only-Begotten is passible, but wilt with us confess that He is Life and Life-giving by Nature and moreover beyond all suffering; next that the flesh suffering which was united to Him, He by the grace of God, as it is written, tasted death for every man, that having shewn His own Temple superior to him who had conquered all that are on the earth, He might be called the firstfruits of them that slept and the firstborn from the dead: transmitting to us too the grace, that being One and Only Son, both before the Incarnation and after it He might yet be called Saviour and Redeemer of all: and freeing (as I said) from sin all who believe on Him, might become peace to them that are afar and to the near, reconciling through Himself to God the Father them who of old worshipped the creature and through sin were at enmity with the All-good God.

But by dividing once again the One Lord Jesus Christ into a pair of sons, he speaks in this way:

But severing again into a pair of sons the One Lord Jesus Christ, he says after this wise:

§2

Nestorius: "Listen to their other testimony as well, for if they had known, they would not have crucified the Lord of glory. Look—he says 'the Lord of glory.' He does not call the manhood this, but the Godhead. Yet this objection belongs to those who tear apart the proper union, because when you say, 'This is not Lord, but the other one is,' you make Christ a mere man. So what do you say, you heretic dressed in clergy's clothing? Is the man also Lord or not? If he is Lord, then what is said agrees. If he is not Lord, then don't accuse me of making Christ a mere man when you yourself are doing it." Then he says, "Let us hear the blessed Paul openly proclaiming who it is that was crucified. Hear then most plainly his words: 'For he was crucified out of weakness, yet he lives out of the power of God.' If he was crucified out of weakness, who was it who was weak, heretic? God the Word?"3

Nestorius: "Hear their other testimony also; for had they known, they would not have crucified the Lord of glory. Lo he says the Lord of glory, he calls not so the manhood but the Godhead. But this belongs to those who pluck asunder the accurate connection, for when thou sayest, This is not Lord, but the other is, THOU makest Christ a mere man. What then dost thou say, o heretic in clerical form? is the man too Lord or not? if then he be Lord, the things said agree; if he be not Lord, do not THOU making Christ a mere man, fasten the reproach of it on me." Then he says, "Hear we the blessed Paul openly crying out who He is who is crucified. Hear then most plainly the voice, For (says he) He was crucified out of weakness, yet He liveth out of the Power of God. If He were crucified out of weakness, who was it who was weak, heretic? God the Word?"3

He is carried away to absurd thoughts and to a reprobate mind, in no way understanding the force of the mystery, as it seems to me, but rather in every way following his own devices and perhaps afraid, lest he should be caught either thinking or saying anything that pertains to rightness or truth. For he arrays against himself, as he supposes, the words of the orthodox, but is caught again putting forward things which no one of those who are accustomed to walk rightly in the Faith would even endure another person saying. For we say that He who was crucified is Lord of glory, and He is so in truth: yet acknowledging that the Word of God is inseparable and one with the flesh united to Him, having a reasonable soul, we say that it is He who offered Himself, as it were the Immaculate Offering and most sweet-smelling Sacrifice of His Own Body, to God the Father, and nailed to the wood the handwriting that was against us. And one may hear Him say by the mouth of David, Sacrifice and offering You did not want but a Body You prepared for Me, whole burnt offerings and offerings for sin You took no pleasure in: then I said, Behold I come (in the volume of the book it has been written of Me) to do Your Will, O God. The commandment according to the Law now being of no effect, and perfecting nothing, and God the Father holding the sacrifices through blood unacceptable—He says that a Body has been prepared for Himself, in order that giving it as a Ransom for the salvation and life of all, He might redeem all, from both death and decay and yet more from sins.

He is carried away unto absurd thoughts and unto a reprobate mind, in no wise understanding the force of the mystery, as seems to me, but rather every way following his own devices and haply afraid, lest he should be caught either thinking or saying ought that pertains to Tightness or truth. For he arrays against himself, as he supposes, the words of the orthodox, but is caught again putting those things which no one of those who are wont to walk aright as to the Faith, would even so much as endure another saying. For we say that He which was crucified is Lord of glory, and He is so of a truth: yet acknowledging that the Word of God is inseverable and one with the flesh united, to Him having a reasonable soul, we say that He it is Who offered Himself, as it were the Immaculate Offering and most sweet-smelling Sacrifice of His Own Body, to God the Father, and nailed to the wood the handwriting that was against us. And one may hear Him say by the mouth of David, Sacrifice and offering Thou wouldest not but a Body preparedst Thou Me, whole burnt sacrifices and for sin Thou tookest no pleasure in: then said I, Lo I come (in the volume of the book it has been written of Me) to do Thy Will, o God. The commandment according to the Law now availing nought, and perfecting nothing, and God the Father holding the sacrifices through blood unacceptable;—-He says that a Body has been prepared for Himself, in order that giving it a Ransom for the salvation and life of all, He might redeem all, from both death and decay and yet more from sins.

We say, then, that the very Word from God the Father chose to suffer for us in the flesh, according to the Scriptures. This is how the most holy Paul instructed us: "Who, being in the form of God, did not regard equality with God as something to be grasped, but emptied himself, taking the form of a servant, being made in the likeness of man and found in fashion as a man. He humbled himself and became obedient unto death, even the death of the cross, wherefore God also highly exalted him." Consider now how he who is in the form of God the Father as God, the impress of his hypostasis (personal subsistence) and in no way falling short, being and being conceived of in equality in everything, has emptied himself and brought himself down of his own will to lowliness.

We say then that the very Word out of God the Father chose even to suffer for us in the flesh, according to the Scriptures: thus hath the most holy Paul instructed us, Who being in the Form of God held not the being Equal with God a thing to seize, but emptied Himself taking servant's form, made in likeness of man and found in fashion as a man, He humbled Himself and became obedient unto death, the death of the cross, wherefore God also highly exalted Him. View now how He That is in the Form of God the Father as God, the Impress of His Person and in no wise falling short, being and being conceived of in Equality in everything, hath emptied Himself and brought Himself down of His own will unto lowliness.

What then (tell me) will be the manner of the emptying, and how again has He been brought low by receiving servant's form and being made obedient to death, the death of the Cross? Is it not clear to everyone that what is High is brought low, not what is by its own nature already in lowliness and brought down? That (I suppose) is emptied which is full and in need of nothing; what receives the servant's form is what was previously free by nature. He is found to be man who was not man before He was so found when He was not. Who then is He who was High by Nature and brought Himself down to lowliness? Who is the full one, that He may be understood as emptied? Who is He who is beyond the conditions of bondage, so that He may be said to take the bondman's form? Who is it that, not previously being man as we are and an ordinary man, is said to have been found as such? For I suppose that to dare to assign this to one who is like us and to an ordinary man would be foolishness and truly filled with the greatest of all ignorance, but it will belong with all reason to the Supreme Nature.

What then (tell me) will be the mode of the emptying, how again has He been abased receiving servant's form and made obedient unto death, the death of the Cross? is it not clear to all that the High is abased, not that which from itself and of its own nature is in abasement and brought low; that (I suppose) is emptied which is full and in need of nought; receives the servant's form which before it was free by nature, He is found to be man too Who was not so, before He was so found when He was not? Who then is He That was High by Nature and abased Himself unto lowliness? who the full, that He may be conceived of as emptied? who He That is beyond the measures of bondage, that so He may be said to take the bondman's form? who that not being aforetime man as we is said to have been so found? For I suppose that to dare to allot this to one of those as we and to a common man, would be folly and verily replete with the uttermost of all unwit, but it will pertain with all reason to the Supreme Nature.

But the Word of God, out of his exceeding mercy and kindness toward us, has offered his own body for us. Having taken the servant's form, he has become obedient to God the Father even to death. And the choice to suffer in the flesh, he did not regard as something to be rejected, even though he is by physis impassible as God. Yet this man foolishly objects to his most God-befitting plans for us, and thinking he honors him, actually wrongs him. For he removes him from the suffering, though no one else claims that he suffers in his own physis. And he does not perceive that he forbids him to be confessed as Savior and Redeemer of all, if it is the case that the one who is son and lord is someone other than he, separately and apart, through whom we have been saved and redeemed through the precious Cross. And if he is simply man, and not rather the Word from God the Father appearing in human form, let him come and show that he is both in the form of the Father and in equality with him (for he did not consider being equal with God a thing to grasp), and moreover that he took the form of the servant as one who did not possess it before, and came to be in emptiness, as one who possesses fullness in his own nature. For the divinely-inspired Paul says that he who is in the form and equality with God the Father was made obedient to him even to death, the death of the Cross.

But the Word of God, of His exceeding Clemency and Kindness towards us, hath offered for us His own Body and having taken the servant's form, hath become obedient to God the Father unto death: and the choice to suffer in the Flesh, He made not a thing to be spurned, albeit by Nature Impassible as God. Yet does this man foolishly blush at His most God-befitting schemes for us, and thinking he honours Him, wrongs Him: for he bears Him away from the suffering, though no one else says that He suffers in His own Nature; and does not perceive that he forbids Him to be confessed Saviour and Redeemer of all, if so be that he is son and lord other than He, separately and apart, through whom we have been saved and redeemed through the precious Cross. And if so be he be simply man, and not rather the Word out of God the Father appearing in human form, let him come, let him shew that he is both in the Form of the Father and in Equality with Him (for He thought not the being equal with God a thing to seize) and moreover that he took the form of the servant as at one time not possessing it, and came to be in emptiness, as possessing fulness in his own nature: for the Divine-uttering Paul says that He Who is in the Form and Equality with God the Father, was made obedient unto Him even to death, the death of the Cross.

Isn't the absurdity of their ideas obvious? When blessed Paul calls the one who was crucified the Lord of glory, no one will say, "He is not speaking about the human nature but about the Godhead." For we confess one Christ and Son and Lord of Glory, the Word from God the Father who became man for our sake and suffered for us in the flesh, according to the Scriptures.

Is not then the absurdity of their notions manifest? when blessed Paul calls Him that was crucified Lord of glory, no one will say, 'He is not speaking of the human nature but the Godhead.' For we confess One Christ and Son and Lord of Glory, the Word out of God the Father made man for our sakes and suffering for us in the flesh, according to the Scriptures.

But he sharply criticizes those who assign the title of Lordship to God the Word and take it away from the human nature, accusing them of wanting to tear apart the precise union (as he himself puts it). Yet forgetting what he said, he is caught tearing the One into two and caring little about the precise union (according to him). For he foolishly asks, "Is the man also lord or not? If he is lord, then what is said makes sense." Therefore, according to your senseless question, if the Word is Lord by Himself and the man is lord, there are surely two lords and sons. The force of precise union will in no way benefit those who have believed that one ought to conceive of One Christ and Son and Lord with the Flesh united to Him. For when the prosopon of Immanuel is set forth and presented, even if one should say "man," we conceive of the Word from God the Father having taken the form of a servant and say that He is shown by the measures of self-emptying; and if we say Only-Begotten God, we believe the Same now Incarnate and made Flesh. But he (as I said), assigning to a man who is individual and alone and considered apart from the Word Who is from the Father, the accomplishments of the Economy with flesh, says that he too endured the cross for us and claims that he is the Lord of glory, placing upon a mere creature the glories of the Supreme Nature. For he says, "Let us hear the blessed Paul openly declaring who it is that is crucified; for indeed He was crucified out of weakness but He lives by the Power of God. Who is weak, O heretic—is it God the Word?"

But he in no small measure blaming, as wishing to pluck asunder the accurate connection (as himself says), those who allot to God the Word the name of Lordship and bear it away from the human nature:—-he falling into forgetfulness of what he said, is caught plucking asunder into two the One, and little recking of accurate (according to him) connection. For he unlearnedly enquires, "Is the man too lord or not? if then he be lord, the things said harmonize." Hence if according to thy witless enquiry, the Word is Lord by Himself and the man lord, two surely are the lords and sons. The force then of accurate connection will in no wise profit them who have believed that one ought to conceive of One Christ and Son and Lord with the Flesh united to Him. For the Person of Immanuel being put and brought forward, though one should say man, we conceive of the Word out of God the Father having taken the servant's form and say that He is shewn by the measures of emptiness: and if [we say] Only-Begotten God, we believe the Same now Incarnate and made Flesh. But he (as I said) allotting to a man, individual and alone and considered apart from the Word Which is out of the Father, the achievements of the Economy with flesh, says that he too endured the cross for us and affirms that he is the Lord of glory, putting about a mere creature the glories of the Supreme Nature, for he says, "Let us hear the blessed Paul openly exclaiming who he is that is crucified; for verily He was crucified out of weakness but He liveth out of the Power of God; who is weak o heretic, is it God the Word?"

He is utterly without any share in weakness, this Word from God the Father whom we believe in, for He is the Lord of Hosts. But tell me this: are you afraid to apply the term weakness to Him? Why? The Economy with flesh sets Him apart from all blame, even if He is said to suffer anything that is outside His own Nature and glory. For if, being Rich, He became poor and was made like us, receiving the form of a servant, then even if He should be called weak because of the human nature, there is nothing contradictory in seeing the Rich One poor, the High One in lowly condition, the Lord of Hosts in weakness like us. The mystery concerning Him is marvelous for this reason as well. For how is He said to hunger, though He Himself is the Bread of Life who came down from Heaven and gives Life to the world? How was He wearied by the journey, when He establishes the Heavens by His own Spirit?

Utterly imparticipate therefore of all weakness is the Word out of God the Father by us believed to be: for He is the Lord of Hosts. But tell me this, art thou afraid to admit the appellation of weakness in respect to Him? why? albeit the Economy with flesh puts Him apart from all blame, even though He be said to suffer ought of what is beside His own Nature and glory: for if being Rich He became poor and was made as we receiving servant's form, even though He should be said to be weak by reason of the human nature, there is nought repugnant, that you should see the Hich poor, the High in low estate, the Lord of Hosts in weakness as we. Marvellous on this account also is the mystery respecting Him. For how is He said also to hunger, albeit Himself the Bread of Life and Who came down from Heaven and giveth Life to the world? how was He wearied with the journey, Who stablisheth the Heavens with His own Spirit?

But it seems you cannot tolerate it if someone says these things about the Only-Begotten Himself, even though when I examine your own words I find them clearly stating this as belonging to the prosopon of the Only-Begotten.

But thou wilt not endure (it seems) if one say these things of the Only-Begotten Himself, albeit investigating thine own words I find them clearly saying, as of the Person of the Only-Begotten,

§3

Nestorius: "I am clothed in the form of a servant, though I am in the form of God. I am seen in flesh, though I am God the Word. I am clothed in the prosopon of a poor man for your sake, though I am Lord of all. I visibly hunger, yet I supply food to the hungry."

Nestorius: "The form of God, I am clad in servant's form: being God the Word, am seen in flesh: Lord of all, am clad for your sakes in person of a poor man: hungering visibly, I supply food to the hungry."

How then, tell me, did you, fearing the label of weakness and trying to remove it from Him—even though the plan of the economy does not permit this—say that He hungers visibly, that is, humanly, yet divinely supplies food to the hungry? Are you not saying that it is a form of weakness to need food and to be said to hunger as we do? But against those who want to find fault, the method of the economy will stand very strong in defense. We must therefore either remove Him completely from all things said humanly and in lowly terms and attribute such sufferings to a mere man, or, recognizing that He who is God has been made as we are, confess that He is impassible with respect to the physis of the Godhead, but say in addition that He endured the weakness on our behalf, according to the human nature and according to the flesh, I mean. Since, tell me—I ask you again—the divinely-inspired Paul says that He was crucified out of weakness; but do you take this away from God the Word, saying, I suppose, that it is petty and ignoble and not worthy of Him? Then it is someone other than Him who was crucified, whom our divine teacher also calls Lord of glory, saying, "For had they known, they would not have crucified the Lord of glory." Did He then still remain Lord of glory, who set it aside and endured this ignoble and lowly suffering? If therefore He remained so, then He suffered no loss through being weak. How then did you fear to say that the Word of God came to be in this condition economically? But if He truly fell from being any longer Lord of glory, and anyone claims that this is so, he will incur the charge of the most complete blasphemy, and rightly so, for to Him every knee shall bow and every tongue shall confess Lord Jesus Christ, to the glory of God the Father. For the glory of Christ who suffered for us in the flesh extends over all that is under heaven, as we have very often said. When therefore you hear the Spirit-inspired saying, "He was crucified out of weakness but He lives by the power of God," understand it piously, for he says that He suffered humanly, though He has a physis utterly beyond passion. And possessing this, He bore with the weak flesh, and having suffered death humanly, He lived again divinely, Himself quickening His own temple as the power of the Father.

How then, say, didst thou fearing the appellation of weakness and bearing it away from Him, albeit the plan of the economy will it not, say that He hungers visibly, i. e., humanly, yet Divinely supplies food to the hungry? dost thou not say that it is a form of weakness to be in need of food and to be said to hunger as we? but against them who desire to be fault-finders, full strong will the mode of the economy array itself. We must therefore, either bearing Him away from all things that are said humanly and in mean wise, put such passions about a mere man, or considering that He being God has been made as we, confess that He is impassible in respect of the Nature of the Godhead, but say besides that He endured the weakness in our behalf, according to the human nature and after the flesh, I mean. Since, tell me who ask thee again, The Divine-uttering Paul says that He has been crucified out of weakness; but dost thou bear away this thing from God the Word, saying (I suppose) that it is small and ignoble and not worthy of Him? Other therefore than He is he that was crucified, Whom also our Divine instructor calls Lord of glory, saying, For had they known, they would not have crucified the Lord of glory. Hath He, then yet remained Lord of Glory Who put it aside and endured this ignoble and mean suffering? If therefore He hath remained so, neither hath He any loss through being weak. How then fearedst thou to say that the Word of God came to be in this case economically? But if He truly fell from being any longer Lord of glory, and any one affirm that it is so, he will incur the charge of the most utter blasphemy and that with reason: for to Him boweth every knee and every tongue shall confess Lord Jesus Christ, to the glory of God the Father. For over all that is under Heaven extendeth the glory of Christ Who suffered for us in the flesh, as we have full often said. When therefore thou nearest the Spirit-clad saying, He was crucified out of weakness but He liveth of the Power of God, understand it piously: for he says that He hath suffered humanly, albeit He hath a nature utterly beyond passion. And so having, He bare with the weak flesh and having suffered death humanly, He lived again Divinely, Himself quickening His own Temple, as the Might of the Father.

And truly when the time was now at hand when He had to endure the Cross for us, He went away and prayed, saying, "Father, if it is possible, let this cup pass from Me," but He added at the end of His prayer, "Nevertheless not as I will but as You will." But since He, though being the Word and God Almighty, was once held to be in weakness like us, He gave the reason for this most economically when He said, "The spirit indeed is willing, but the flesh is weak." Consider therefore how He, though letting go of nothing Himself and not suffering any weakness in His own physis, permitted His flesh to follow its own natural laws, and this thing is said to be His because His body is His own. Thus His being weak according to the flesh proved to us that He was man, while His not yielding to death and driving away decay from His own body proved that He is God, who does not know weakness, for He is the Life and Might of the Father. That the weakness involved here was unusual and unwilled by Him, yet He made it voluntary in the good pleasure of God the Father in order to save all under heaven—He Himself will teach this, saying, "For I have come down from heaven, not to do My own will but the will of Him who sent Me, that of all which He has given Me I should lose nothing but should raise it up at the last day."4

And verily when the time was now at hand in which He must endure the Cross for us, He went away and prayed saying, Father if it he possihle, let this cup pass from Me, but added hereto at the close of His Prayer, Nevertheless not as I will but as THOU. But since He albeit Word and God all-Powerful, has once been held to be in weakness like we, He giving the cause of this most economically, says, The spirit indeed is willing, the flesh weak. Consider therefore how He though Himself letting go nought, nor yet suffering weakness in His own Nature, permitted His Flesh to go after its own laws, and this thing is said to be His, because His Body is His own. Hence the being weak according to the Flesh proved to us that He was Man, the not enduring death and scaring away decay from His own Body that He is God Who knows not to be weak: for He is the Life and Might of the Father. For that the weakness herein unwonted and unwilled by Him, He made voluntary in the good-pleasure of God the Father, to save all under Heaven, Himself will teach saying, For I have come down from Heaven, not to do Mine own Will but the Will of Him That sent Me, that of all which He hath given Me I should lose nothing but should raise it up at the last day.4

Yet how, if the will of the Father is good, does the Son say that He has His own will—surely a good one—and different from this? For if it is not good, how can He still be believed to be His Image and Impress? How will He be true when He says, "I and the Father are One," and "He that has seen Me has seen the Father"? For one would not behold the Good by nature in what is not good. But truly the Son, being Good, has come forth from a Good Father and is His exact Image in everything. What will, then, which He says is His own, does He set aside when He says that He has done that of the Father? He was about to set free from death those who had become subject to it—that is, us—by the death of His own Flesh. But to die in the Flesh was ignoble and unusual (as I said) and repugnant to Him. Yet He endured this too for our sakes in the good pleasure of the Father. For He knew, He knew well that though dishonored a little because of the sufferings of the Flesh, He would save all, transforming them into what was incomparably better. For if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creature; old things have passed away; behold, all things have become new, as it is written.

Yet how, if the will of the Father be good, does the Son say that He has His own Will, a good one surely, and other than this? For if it be not good, how is He any longer believed to be His Image and Impress? how will He be true, saying, I and the Father are One, and, He that hath seen Me hath seen the Father? for not in the not good, would one behold the Good by Nature. But verily the Son being Good hath sprung from a Good Father and is His exact Image in everything. What Will therefore, which He says is His own, does He letting go, say that He hath done that of the Father? He was about by the death of His own Flesh to set free from death those who had become subject thereto, i. e., us. But to die in the Flesh was ignoble, and unwonted (as I said) and repugnant to Him: yet hath He endured this too for our sakes in the Good-pleasure of the Father. For He knew, He knew and that well that a little dishonoured by reason of the sufferings of the Flesh He should save all, transforming them unto what was incomparably better. For if any be in Christ, a new creature, old things are gone by, behold all things have become new, as it is written.

The God-inspired Scriptures therefore proclaim to the world one Christ and Son and Lord, and say that He is the Lord of Glory and that by His own will He bore for our sake the insults of the Jews and in accordance with the economy endured death upon the wood. He did this not to remain dead with us, but so that having destroyed the undefeatable power of death, He might restore the physis of humanity to immortality. For He was God in flesh.

The God-inspired Scriptures therefore proclaim to the world One Christ and Son and Lord and say that He is the Lord of Glory and that He of His own Will bare for our sakes the contumelies of the Jews, and economically endured Death upon the wood, not in order with us to remain dead, but that having undone the might of death which none might withstand, He might bring again to immortality the nature of man: for He was God in Flesh.

But this man, in his attempt to gather from every possible source reasons for dividing the One into two, uselessly sets himself against people who do not even exist. He accuses certain individuals of speaking against the truth and wanting to corrupt the plan of the mystery, and he says,

But this man again essaying to gather to himself from all quarters occasions of severing into two the One, arrays himself to no purpose against those who exist not at all, and makes accusal of certain as though they spake against the truth and desired to adulterate the plan of the mystery, and says,

§4

Nestorius: "Here I would gladly ask the heretics who mix the physis of the Godhead and the Manhood into one essence: who is it here that the traitor betrayed to the Jews? For if there had been a mixture of both, then both were held together by the Jews—both God the Word and the physis of the manhood. Which one endured the slaughter? I must use simpler words so that what I say may be clear to everyone. To whom, tell me, did this deed happen? For if it was the physis of the Godhead, how do you dare to mix both together? God has both remained unheld by the Jews and has not shared with the flesh in its slaughter. From where, tell me, do you get this mixture?"56

Nestorius: "Here I would gladly enquire of the heretics who mix up into one essence the Nature of the Godhead and of the Manhood, who he is here who is by the traitor betrayed to the Jews: for if there have been a mixture of both, both were together holden of the Jews, both God the Word and the nature of the manhood: which is it that endured the slaughter? I am obliged to use meaner words that what I say may be plain to all. To whom (tell me) befell this deed? for if the Nature of the Godhead, how darest thou commingle both? God hath both remained unholden of the Jews and hath not shared with the flesh in its slaughter: whence (tell me) dost thou get in the mixture?56

If there are those who say that the natures have been commingled with one another and that they undergo an impossible fusion, and who maintain that the physis of the Word could suffer change into flesh, or that the flesh united to him could ever pass into Godhead, they have erred from the truth and, out of their right mind—indeed sick with the most complete distraction—they shall hear from us: You err, not knowing the Scriptures nor the power of God. For the physis of God the Word is steadfast and does not know how to suffer a shadow of turning, but participating in flesh and blood and taking part with us in the same, as it is written, he remained the same. But if everyone who is educated in the Holy Scriptures considers it repugnant even to hear that any change was brought about in the Only-Begotten, why do you, while admitting as true and actually spoken things so disgraceful and condemned by everyone with one voice and utterly rejected, attempt to separate the indivisible, and that after the union? For if you would truly learn who it is that is given up by the traitor to the Jews and endured slaughter, you will clearly hear: the one and only Christ and Son and Lord, that is, the Word from God who took the servant's form, made man and incarnate. For he was sold by the traitor to the rulers of the Jews and was held humanly, because he was man too along with remaining God, but divinely he was convicting the weakness of those who held him. And the divinely-inspired evangelist John makes this manifest to us, writing thus: Judas therefore having received the band and officers from the chief priests and Pharisees came there with torches and lanterns and weapons; Jesus knowing all things that were coming upon him, went forth and said to them, Whom do you seek? They answered him, Jesus of Nazareth. Jesus said to them, I am. And Judas who betrayed him was standing with them. When therefore he said to them, I am, they went backward and fell to the ground. Do you hear that he does not let those who have been gathered together by the traitor behave themselves proudly against his glory? For he offered himself saying, I am, but they, unstrung by the voice alone, went backward.

If then there be who say that there has been a commingling of the natures one with another and that they undergo an impossible fusion, and who maintain that the Nature of the Word could suffer change into flesh, or the Flesh united to Him ever pass into Godhead; they have erred from the truth and, out of their right mind, yea rather sick with the veriest distraction, they shall hear from us, Ye do err not knowing the Scriptures nor the Power of God; for steadfast is the Nature of God the Word, nor knows it to suffer a shadow of turning, but participate in flesh and blood and taking part with us in the same, as it is written, He abode the Same. But if every one who is educated in the Holy Scriptures holds it repugnant to so much as hear that any change was wrought in the Only-Begotten, why dost thou admitting as true and really spoken things so disgraceful and condemned by one voice by all and utterly rejected, essay to sever the Indivisible and that after the Union? For if thou wouldest indeed of a truth learn who it is who is by the traitor given up to the Jews, and endured slaughter, thou wilt clearly hear, The One and Only Christ and Son and Lord, that is the Word out of God Who took the servant's form, made man and Incarnate: for He was sold by the traitor to the rulers of the Jews, and was holden humanly, because He was Man too along with abiding God, but Divinely He was convicting the weakness of them who hold Him. And this the Divine-uttering Evangelist John makes manifest to us, thus writing, Judas therefore having received the band and officers from the chief priests and Pharisees cometh thither with torches and lanterns and weapons; Jesus knowing all things that were coming upon Him, went forth and said unto them, Whom seek ye? they answered Him, Jesus of Nazareth. Jesus saith unto them, I am. And Judas which betrayed Him was standing with them. When therefore He said unto them, I am, they went backward and fell to the ground. Hearest thou that He does not let them who have been gathered together by the traitor behave themselves proudly against His Glory? for He offered Himself saying, I am, but they unstrung by the voice alone, went backward.

That it was not by their own strength that they were able to hold Him, but that at the right time and according to His purpose He willingly accepted death for our sake, He proved by saying, "Did you come out with swords and clubs to arrest Me as if I were a robber? I sat daily in the Temple teaching, and you did not lay hold of Me, but all this has happened so that the Scriptures of the Prophets might be fulfilled." For what He had long ago foretold through the holy Prophets, this He fulfilled, humbling Himself to the point of emptiness though He is above all creation, and appearing in the form of a man though He exists in the Form and Equality with the Father.

And that it was no work of their own strength to hold Him, but that in his season and in need He made death for us welcome, He hath proved saying, As a robber came ye forth with swords and staves to take Me? daily did I sit in the Temple teaching, and ye laid no hold on Me, but all this has been done that the Scriptures of the Prophets might be fulfilled. For what He hath of old foretold through the holy Prophets, this hath He fulfilled, abasing Himself unto emptiness Who is above all the creation, and found in fashion as a man Who is in the Form and Equality with the Father.

Why then do you attempt to smuggle in the term "mixture" and thus misrepresent to the ears of simpler believers the marvel of the incarnate dispensation? It is not appropriate for you to come forward harshly and bitterly saying, "Was God the Word captured? Did the nature of the Godhead undergo slaughter?" That you are speaking these things without precision, you will easily understand from the following. We say that the holy martyrs have been perfected, choosing to endure all things so that having fought the good fight, finished their course, and kept the faith, they might receive the crown of true relationship to Christ. Now if someone were to come forward and ask, "When the bodies of the saints were torn by the sword or consumed by fire, or when they first became prisoners, were their souls captured along with their bodies? Did they too become subject to fire and sword?"—even though we say that they were separate from their bodies, suffering none of these outrages in their own nature—will they therefore (tell me) be excluded from the crowns because they did not suffer what the body suffered? But surely the word of truth does not exclude them from suffering, for they suffered the things of their own bodies, not those of others' bodies.

Why then dost thou, essaying to bring in privily the name of mixture, wrong in the ears of the more simple the marvel of the economy with flesh? for it does not befit thee bitterly and harshly to come forward saying, "Was God the Word holden? did the nature of the Godhead undergo slaughter?" That of no accurate…. thou art saying such things, thou wilt know hence and that easily. We say that the holy Martyrs have been perfected, choosing to suffer all things in order that having striven the good strife, finished their course, kept the faith, they might bind on them the crown of true relationship to Christ. If then any were to come forward and ask, When the bodies of the saints were torn by the steel or wasted by fire or again when they first became prisoners, were their souls holden along with their bodies? did they too become the work of fire and sword? albeit we say that they [the souls] were apart from their bodies, enduring nought of such contumelies in their own nature. Will they therefore (tell me) be for this reason imparticipate of the crowns, because they have not suffered the things of the body? But verily the word of truth does not put them apart from suffering, for they suffered the things of their own, not those of others' bodies.

It is therefore ignorant to want to ask whether the nature of the Godhead was betrayed along with the flesh, or whether it was caught in the snares of the Jews or also endured the slaughter. Rather, it is pious to understand that the Word will surely and entirely make His own the sufferings that befell His own flesh, yet remained impassible (incapable of suffering) as God, while not being separate from His suffering body. But he, by charging with absurdity the things so carefully arranged according to the economy, and repeatedly saying that the nature of the Godhead ought not to be said by anyone to have undergone slaughter, impiously limits the power of the mystery to a mere man by himself, and says that it is this man who was crucified and endured death for the life of the world. For I hear him saying in another exposition of his,7

Unlearned then is it to want to ask whether the nature of the Godhead have been betrayed along with the flesh, or whether It were holden in the meshes of the Jews or endured the slaughter also: but it is pious to conceive rather that the Word will surely and entirely make His own the sufferings that have befallen His own Flesh, but abode Impassible as God yet not external to His suffering Body. But he involving in charges of absurdity the things so economically wrought, and again and again saying that the Nature of the Godhead ought not to be said by any to have undergone slaughter, unholily arrays the force of the Mystery about a man by himself, and says that he it is who was crucified and endured death for the life of the world. For I hear him saying in another exposition of his,7

§5

Nestorius: "This is the one who was encircled by the crown of thorns, the one who says, 'My God, My God, why have You forsaken Me?' This is the one who endured a three-day death."8

Nestorius: "This is he who was encircled in the thorny Crown, this he who saith, My God, My God why forsookest Thou Me? this he who endured a three days' death."8

Such things he says, following his own purpose, but we will show him a wiser and truer Emmanuel, the Savior and Redeemer of the whole world. For the Word, as we have said very often, was made flesh, and making His own a body that could suffer insults and death, He gave it for us and, as the divinely-speaking Paul says, endured the cross, despising the shame. For was it not shame and a kind of humiliation to Him who has a nature that is all-powerful and life-giving and above suffering, to appear to be crucified out of human weakness and to come to death according to the flesh? And truly the Same says through the voice of Isaiah, "I gave my back to scourges, my cheeks to blows, I did not turn my face away from the shame of spitting," and again, "Therefore I was not confounded, but I set my face as a firm rock and I know that I shall not be ashamed, for He is near who justifies me." For as far as the impious multitudes of the Greeks and also of the Jews are concerned, the Mystery of Christ is considered both a stumbling block and foolishness, for they mock (miserable ones!) the precious Cross. But the outcome of the weakness (as it seemed to them) resulted in power of glory most truly befitting God. For through the Resurrection from the dead it has been testified that He is God and Son of God in truth, as superior to death and decay, and is worshipped by all together with Him who begot Him.

Such things then doth he say, following his own aim, but WE will shew him a wiser and truer Emmanuel, the whole world's Saviour and Redeemer. For the Word, as we have full often said, was made flesh, and making His own, a Body which knew to suffer contumelies and death, He hath given it for us and, as the Divine-uttering Paul saith, endured the cross, despising the shame. For was it not shame and a sort of abashment to Him that hath a Nature All-Strong and Quickening and above suffering, to seem to be crucified out of human weakness and to come to death after the flesh? And verily the Same saith through the voice of Isaiah, My Back I have given to scourges, My Cheeks to blows, My Face turned I not away from the shame of spittings, and again, Therefore was I not confounded, but I set My Face as a firm rock and I know that I shall not be ashamed, for He is near that justifieth Me. For as far as regards the impious multitudes of the Greeks and also of the Jews, the Mystery of Christ is reputed a stumbling block alike and foolishness, for they deride (miserable ones!) the Precious Cross; but the end of the weakness (as it seemed to them) resulted in might of glory most truly God-befitting. For through the Resurrection from the dead it has been testified that He is God and Son of God in truth, as superior to death and decay, and is worshipped by all together with Him Who begat Him.

And hear the sacred Scriptures proclaiming this very thing to us: "Thus says the Lord, sanctify Him who held His soul lightly, Him who is abhorred by the nations, the servants, the rulers: kings shall see Him and princes shall rise up and worship Him." Confess (it said) that He is holy by nature as God—He who held His own soul cheaply, that is, despised His own life (for He laid it down for His sheep, as a good shepherd). The nations regarded Him vilely, servants and officers insulted Him with blows, and the crowds of Pharisees impiously outraged Him. Yet kings shall see Him and rise up, and princes shall worship Him as God—that is, the One who descended into emptiness so that, suffering in the flesh, He might save all under heaven. This is He who for us was encircled with the thorny crown, this One and no other, He who as man is crucified and says, "My God, My God, why have you forsaken Me?" Yet as God He restrains the light of the sun and makes it night at midday, so that we should not confess Him to be merely a man honored with a simple connection (according to you) with the Word who is from God, but should rather believe that He is God, in likeness as we are, and in the form of a servant. Remember Him who says through a saint's voice, "And I will clothe the heavens with darkness, and I will make their covering as sackcloth." For He who speaks is present, and what He as God foretold long ago, He was fulfilling in due season, crucified as man. For the heaven put on darkness, practically a mourning garment, and the sun no longer gave the brightness of its rays to those who had dared to outrage the Lord and God of all. This foreshadowed the darkness they would have in mind and heart. For the blessed David also sings somewhere about them, "Let their eyes be darkened so that they do not see, and bow down their back always." And the veil of the temple was also torn, now revealing to those who believe in Him the holy of holies and showing the innermost parts, for the first tabernacle no longer stands, but the way into the holy place is now made manifest, that is, into the holy of holies. For the Law too was confessedly holy, in that it furnished righteousness and was our guide to Christ. Yet the life in Christ is judged incomparably holier, and the worship in spirit and in truth is more excellent and in better condition than that in shadows and types. Will not such achievements then be God-befitting and above the nature of man? Has not the saving Passion put to shame the flaming sword and brought man back into Paradise? For Christ said to the robber who hung with Him, "Today you shall be with Me in Paradise." Did He not shine upon those who were in darkness, saying with authority, "Show yourselves"? For as God He emptied Hell and loosed those who were in it from their bonds. And it was He who long ago cried out to the most enduring Job, "Did you come into the springs of the sea? Did you walk in the tracks of the depth? Are the gates of death opened to you in fear of you? Did the doorkeepers of hell tremble when they saw you?"

And hear the sacred Scriptures proclaiming to us this very thing: Thus saith the Lord, Sanctify Him That holdeth light His Soul, Him that is abhorred by the nations, the servants, the rulers: kings shall see Him and princes shall rise up and worship Him. Confess (it said) that He is Holy by Nature as God, Who held cheaply His own Soul, i. e., despised His own life (for He hath laid it down for His sheep, as Good Shepherd): Him Whom the nations vilely esteemed, servants and officers insulted with blows, while the multitudes of the Pharisees impiously outraged Him, Him shall kings see and rise up, Him shall princes worship, as God, that is, who descended into emptiness, in order that suffering in the flesh, He might save all under Heaven. This is He Who for us was encircled with the Thorny Crown, this, not another, He Who as Man is crucified and says, My God My God why forsookest Thou Me? yet who restrains as God the Light of the sun, and makes it night in mid-day that we should not confess Him Man, simply honoured with mere connection (according to thee) with the Word I mean That is out of God, but should believe rather that He is God, in likeness as we, and in servant's form, remembering Him Who saith by a Saint's voice, And I will clothe the Heavens with darkness, and I will make their covering as sackcloth. For He Who speaketh is at hand, and what He of old hath as God foresignified would be, He in due season was fulfilling, crucified as Man. For the Heaven put on darkness, all but a mourning dress, the sun no longer giving the brightness of its rays to them who had durst outrage the Lord and God of all, hath foresignified the darkness which they should have in mind and heart. For the blessed David too sings somewhere of them, Let their eyes he darkened that they see not and bow down their back alway. And the veil too of the Temple was rent, revealing now to those who believe on Him the holy of holies and shewing the most inward parts, the first tabernacle no longer standing, but the way into the holy now made manifest, that is into the holy of holies. For holy confessedly was the Law too, in that it was the furnisher of righteousness, our guide too unto Christ: yet incomparably holier is the life in Christ esteemed, and more excellent and in better case the worship in spirit and in truth than that in shadows and types. Will not such achievements then be God-befitting and above the nature of man? hath not the saving Passion shamed the waving sword, brought man again into Paradise? for Christ said to the robber who hung with Him, Today shalt thou be with Me in Paradise: beamed He not on them that were in darkness, uttering with authority, Shew yourselves? For He has emptied Hell as God, and loosed from their bonds those who were in it: and He it was Who of old crieth out to the most enduring Job, Camest thou into the springs of the sea? walkedst thou in the tracks of the depth? are the gates of death open to thee in fear [ of thee]? did the doorkeepers of hell seeing thee tremble?

Why then are you not ashamed to assign things that are fitting for God to someone who is merely one of us and a mere man? The all-wise Paul will provide us proof that the Word of God Himself, taking the form of a servant, participated in flesh and blood, endured giving His own Body to death for our sake, and, being Impassible by Nature (physis), suffered in the Flesh by His own will. Paul writes: "Giving thanks to the Father who made us fit to share in the inheritance of the saints in light, who delivered us from the authority of darkness and transferred us into the kingdom of the Son of His love, in whom we have redemption, the forgiveness of sins, who is the Image of the invisible God, the firstborn of all creation; for in Him all things in heaven and on earth were created, visible and invisible, whether thrones or dominions or principalities or authorities—all things were created through Him and for Him, and He is before all things and in Him all things hold together, and He is the head of the body, the Church, who is the beginning, the firstborn from the dead, that in all things He might have the preeminence." Notice now that the priest of His mysteries said—and very clearly—that the very God the Word, through whom are all things and in whom are all things, who is the Image of the invisible God, through whom both the things in heaven and those on earth were brought into being, the visible and invisible, who is before all things, in whom all things hold together, has been given as Head to the Church, and is Himself the firstborn from the dead.

Wherefore then blushest thou not allotting things that are yet God-befitting to one as we and to a mere man? For that the Word of God Himself, taking servant's form, participate in flesh and blood, endured to give His own Body to death for our sakes and, being Impassible by Nature, suffered in the Flesh of His own will, the all-wise Paul will give us proof, writing, Giving thanks unto the Father Which made us meet to be partakers of the lot of the saints in light, Who delivered us from the authority of darkness and translated us into the kingdom of the Son of His Love, in Whom we have redemption, the forgiveness of sins, Who is the Image of the Invisible God, the firstborn of every creature; for in Him were created all things in Heaven and upon earth, visible and invisible, whether thrones or lordships or principalities or authorities, all things were created through Him and unto Him, and He is before all things and in Him all things consist, and He is the Head of the body, the Church, Who is the beginning, the firstborn from the dead, that in all things He might have the preeminence. See now the Priest of His Mysteries said and that very clearly that the Very God the Word, through Whom are all things and in Whom are all things, Who is the Image of the Invisible God; He through Whom were brought into being both the things which are in Heaven and those on earth, the visible and invisible; He Who is before all things, in Whom all things consist; has been given as Head to the Church, and is Himself the firstborn from the dead.

But you will perhaps say: the Word from God the Father is by nature Life; how then, or in what way, might Life die? Well, your question is necessary and useful. Therefore, to understand the power of this mystery, we must grasp and say that the ever-living and life-giving Word of God was made flesh—that is, He made His own a body capable of receiving death—so that He Himself might be understood to suffer, because His very own body suffered. For this is how we say that He became the firstfruits of those who slept and the firstborn from the dead: He is said to have been laid with us in a tomb through His own flesh, even though He is the one who raises the dead, so that we too might be raised together with Him. For this is the way He opened up for us, and for this He humbled Himself, lowering Himself to emptiness and to humanity with us, even though the Only-Begotten is God by nature and shone forth from God the Father.

But (you will perhaps say) the Word out of God the Father is by Nature Life; how then or in what way might Life die? well: necessary and useful is your question. Therefore unto the force of the mystery is serviceably taken, that we conceive and say that the ever-living and Life-giving Word of God was made Flesh, i. e., made His own a Body recipient of death, that Himself might be conceived to suffer, because His Very own Body suffered. For thus do we say that He became the firstfruits of them that slept, and the firstborn from the dead: for He is said to have been laid with us in a tomb through His own flesh, Who raiseth the dead, that we too might be co-raised with Him: for this w ay did He inaugurate for us and for this hath He humbled Himself, abasing Himself unto emptiness and unto manhood with us; albeit the Only-Begotten is God by Nature and beamed from God the Father.

But he thinks (it seems) that those who suppose these things are true, and who hold the right view, have reached the extreme limit of confusion. And by constantly insisting that we ought to confess the Word from God the Father to be Impassible, he removes from Him—and removes completely—the manner of His Economy (divine plan of salvation). He thinks it neither appropriate to think nor to say that He suffered for us, even though the God-inspired Scripture says that He suffered in the Flesh—He who is both Impassible and Unembodied—because the Body that is His own and united to Him suffered. He says again as follows,

But he thinks (it seems) that they who suppose that these things are so, and who deem aright, have advanced to the goal of the uttermost distraction; and everywhere alleging that we ought to confess the Word out of God the Father to be Impassible, he removes from Him and that utterly the mode of His Economy: and thinks it not meet either to think or say that He suffered for us, albeit the God-inspired Scripture says that He suffered in the Flesh, He both Impassible and Unembodied, because the Body suffered that is His own and united to Him. He says again thus,

Therefore concerning our first-fruits, blessed Peter, when telling and relating the exaltation by the Godhead of the nature that is seen, says, "This Jesus God raised up." God did not die; He raised up. Hear, O Apollinarius, the words of Peter; hear with Apollinarius, you too, Arius. "This Jesus," he says, "God raised up"—the visible one, him who was seen with the eyes, affixed to the wood, handled by the hands of Thomas, who cried to him, "Handle Me, for a spirit does not have flesh and bones as you see Me have." And the disciple, persuaded by these words and by the handling of the crucified body convinced of the resurrection, began to glorify the wonder-working God: "Glory to You, my Lord and my God"—not addressing as God that which was handled, for the Godhead is not discerned by handling. And after other things, "Of this that was handled, Peter too was exclaiming, 'This Jesus God raised up, being therefore exalted by the Right Hand of God.' God the Word had no need of an aiding right hand, O Arius."9

"Therefore concerning our first-fruits, blessed Peter telling, and relating the exaltation by the Godhead of the nature that is seen, says, This Jesus God raised up. God did not dio, He raised up. Hear, o Apolinarius, the words of Peter, hear with Apolinarius, thou too Arius. This Jesus, he says, God raised up, the visible, him who was seen with the eyes, affixed to the wood, handled by the hands of Thomas, who cried to him, Handle Me, for a spirit hath not flesh and bones as ye see Me have. And by these words the disciple persuaded, and by the handling of the crucified body persuaded of the resurrection, began to glorify the wonder-working God, Glory to Thee, my Lord and my God: not addressing as God that which was handled, for not by handling is the Godhead discerned." And after other, "Of this that was handled was Peter too exclaiming, This Jesus God raised up, being therefore by the Right Hand of God exalted. God the Word had no need of an aiding right hand, o Arius."9

§6

The Son raises the dead, and we say He is superior to death, because we remember the One who openly said, "I am the Resurrection and the Life." Yet when the divinely-inspired Peter announces to us, "This Jesus God raised up," we believe that the Word made man is Jesus Himself. How then can one say that He has been raised by the Father and exalted by His Right Hand? I think this should be clearly explained to those who cannot understand, so that by removing any cause for stumbling, we may set forth the way of truth as straight and completely without error.

The Son raiseth up the dead and we say that He is superior to death, for we remember Him Who hath openly said, I am the Resurrection and the Life: yet when the Divine-uttering Peter announces to us saying, This Jesus God raised up, we believe that the Word made man is Jesus Himself. How then will one say that He has been raised by the Father and exalted by His Right Hand? for I think that this should be clearly set forth to those who cannot understand, in order that cutting off occasion of stumbling, we may set forth the way of truth straight and most unerring.

He gave His own body to death for a little while, for by the grace of God, as Paul says, He tasted death for every man. Then, being Himself the life-giving Right Hand and Power of God the Father, He made it superior to decay and death. He gives us assurance of this when He says to the Jews, "Destroy this temple and in three days I will raise it up." Understand therefore that He Himself promises to raise His own temple, even though God the Father is said to raise it. For the Son is, as I said, the life-giving Right Hand and Power of the Father. So even though the Father is said to accomplish the quickening of the divine temple, He has accomplished it through the Son; and though the Son again is seen to accomplish it, yet not without the Father in the Spirit. For one is the physis of Godhead, conceived of in three distinct hypostases, and having its motion and operation—spiritual I mean and befitting God—in regard to all things that are done.

He gave therefore His own Body to death for a little while: for by the grace of God, as Paul saith, He tasted death for every man. Then being Himself the Life-giving Right Hand and Power of God the Father, He rendered it superior to decay and death: and of this He gives us assurance saying to the Jews, Destroy this Temple and in three days I will raise it up. Understand therefore that Himself promises to rear His own Temple, albeit God the Father is said to raise it: for the Son is, as I said, the Life-giving Right Hand and Power of the Father. So that even though the Father be said to work the quickening of the Divine Temple, He hath wrought it through the Son, and though the Son again be seen to work it, yet not without the Father in the Spirit. For One is the Nature of Godhead, conceived of in three several Persons, and having Its motion and Operation, spiritual I mean and God-befitting, in regard to all things that are done.

The body therefore yielded to the laws of its own nature and experienced the taste of death, with the Word united to it permitting this to happen for the sake of benefit. But the body was brought to life by the divine power of the Word personally united to it. We think of the whole Emmanuel—which means "God is with us"—when we hear the divinely inspired Peter say, "This Jesus God raised up." And even when you speak of the visible one who was nailed to the wood, of "him whom Thomas's hands touched," we still understand this to be the Word from God the Father incarnate, and we confess one and the same Son. For though he is invisible by nature, he has become visible because the visible body is also his. The divine David sings to us, "God shall come manifestly, our God and shall not keep silence," and the blessed Habakkuk says, "God shall come from Teman and the Holy One from the deep-shaded mountain." Though he is also untouchable, he is said to have become touchable by reason of the body united to him. Luke writes, "Since many have undertaken to set in order an account of those things which have been most surely believed among us, even as they handed them to us who from the beginning were eyewitnesses and ministers of the Word." And the wise John says to this point, "That which was from the beginning, which we have heard, which we have seen with our eyes, which we looked upon and our hands handled, of the Word of Life, and the Life was manifested and we have seen and bear witness and declare to you the eternal life which was with the Father and was manifested to us." Yet if he had not become touchable and visible, having for his own a body that is subject to touch and sight, how could the all-wise disciples have been made eyewitnesses of the Word? How could they have both seen and said that they handled the Word of Life, which was with the Father and was manifested to us? This very same one who was both touchable and visible, who was nailed to the wood, Thomas recognized and rightly confessed to be God and Lord, for he immediately said, "My Lord and my God." Then our Lord Jesus Christ said to him, "Because you have seen me, you have believed. Blessed are they who have not seen and believed." Believed what, I ask you? Is it not that being God by nature, he raised from the dead his own temple? Yet how could there be any doubt of this?

The body therefore yielded to the laws of its own nature, and admitted the taste of death, the Word united thereto permitting it for profit's sake to suffer this: but was quickened by the Divine power of the Word Personally united to it. We conceive then of Whole Emmanuel, which is interpreted, With us is God, when we hear the Divine-uttering Peter say, This Jesus God raised up; and though thou speak of the visible and affixed to the wood, of "him who was handled by the hands of Thomas," no less do WE conceive of the Word out of God the Father Incarnate, and confess One and the Same Son. For being Invisible by Nature He hath become visible, because His too was the visible Body. And verily the Divine David sings to us, God shall come manifestly, our God and shall not keep silence, and moreover the blessed Habaccuc, God shall come from Teman and the Holy One from the deep-shaded mountain. He being also Impalpable is said to have become palpable by reason of the Body united to Him. And Luke writes, Since many essayed to set forth in order an account of those things which have been most surely believed among us, even as they handed them to us which from the beginning were eye-witnesses and ministers of the Word, and to this the wise John saith, That which was from the beginning, which we have heard, which we have seen with our eyes, which we looked on and our hands handled, of the Word of Life, and the Life was manifested and we have seen and bear witness and declare to you the eternal life which was with the Father and was manifested to us. Yet had He not become palpable and visible, as having for His own a Body which is subject to touch and sight, how had the all-wise disciples been made eye-witnesses of the Word? how had they both seen, and say that they handled the Word of Life, Which was with the Father and was manifested to us? This very Same therefore Which was both palpable and visible, Which was affixed to the wood, Thomas recognized and did rightly confess to be God and Lord: for he said immediately, My Lord and my God. Then said to him our Lord Jesus Christ, Because thou hast seen Me, thou hast believed, blessed they which have not seen and believed. Believed what, tell me? is it not that being God by Nature, He raised from the dead His own Temple? yet how could there be any doubt of this?

But this man, almost foolishly embarrassed by the disciple's words, does not say, "He confessed that He is both Lord and God, the Firstborn from the dead." Instead, he twists the meaning of the words to suit himself and says that Thomas "began to glorify the wonder-working God, saying, My Lord and my God," and adds, "Not addressing as God that which was handled, for the Godhead is not discerned by touch."

But this good man, all but foolishly ashamed of the words of the disciple, says not, 'He confessed Him that He is both Lord and God, the Firstborn from the dead: ' but rather he perverts to his own pleasure the force of the word and says that he "began to glorify the wonder-working God, saying, My Lord and my God," and subjoins, "Not addressing as God that which was handled, for not by the touch is the Godhead discerned."

Are you really blaming the disciple for calling Christ Lord and God? Our argument has just shown that the Only Begotten, who is by physis God, Impalpable and Invisible, became palpable and visible. But when you say, "for not by the touch is the Godhead discerned," we will respond again: Why do you push aside the Economy and speak of the Godhead as if it were bare? And why, rushing headlong into forgetfulness that the Impalpable and Unembodied became both Incarnate and made Man, do you refuse to accept that God-inspired Scripture calls Him God, even though He was handled in flesh and seen by the holy Apostles? But we, my friend, together with blessed Thomas, crown with fitting praises the One who was nailed to the wood, the One who was handled by hands and seen by human eyes, and we say, My Lord and my God.

Blamest thou therefore (tell me) the disciple calling Christ Lord and God? though our argument has but just now shewn that the Only Begotten being by Nature God, Impalpable and Invisible, became palpable and visible. But when thou sayest, "for not by the touch is the Godhead discerned," we again will say, Why dost thou, thrusting aside the Economy discourse of Godhead as though bare? and rushing full speed to forgetfulness that the Impalpable and Unembodied was both Incarnate and made Man, endurest not the God-inspired Scripture naming Him God, because that He had been both handled in flesh and likewise seen of the holy Apostles? But WE, my friend, together with blessed Thomas, crowning with the praises befitting Him, Him That was affixed to the wood, Him That was handled by hands and seen of human eyes, say, My Lord and my God.

But I will attempt to show once again from what you yourself have written or said in the Church that even if someone were to say that the Word of God suffered in His own Flesh, he would still deserve praise and would have chosen to think the truth (for even in this way He has remained Impassible). You consider our holy Fathers praiseworthy—I mean those who were gathered together at Nicea in their time—because they formed for us an accurate and complete confession of faith. Yet you do not understand what they actually do (how could you?), nor do you fix your mind on the doctrines of the truth and desire to go straight. Instead, you halt on both thighs, as it is written: foolishly blaming those who love right doctrine, yet holding as truth whatever pleases you, or rather not even caring to abide by what you yourself said. For I find you saying about the holy fathers,

But that though a man should say that the Word of God suffered in His own Flesh, he would not be without share in being praise-worthy nor in having chosen to think the truth (for even thus hath He abode Impassible): I will essay to shew again from what thyself hast written or saidst in Church. For thou deemest worthy of praise our holy Fathers, those (I mean) who were in their season gathered together at Nicea, as having formed full well for us an accurate and finished confession of faith: yet thou thinkest not what they do (whence should'st thou?) nor yet fixing thy mind on the doctrines of the truth, dost thou long to go straight, but haltest on both thighs, as it is written: foolishly blaming the lovers of right doctrine, yet holding for truth what liketh thyself, yea rather not even caring to abide in what thyself saidst, for I find thee saying of the holy fathers,

§7

Nestorius says: "If they had stated 'We believe in One God the Word,' death would have been attributed to the Divine Nature. Instead, they acknowledge a common term, Christ Jesus, so that they may point to both the one who died and the one who did not die." He continues: "In the same way, if someone says 'So-and-so is dead,' even though the soul is immortal, because he used a word that indicates the two natures—both the mortal body and the immortal soul—the statement is without error. For both are called man: both the body and the soul. This is how that great assembly spoke of Christ."

Nestorius: "For since if they had said, We believe in One God the Word, death would have been imputed to the Divine Nature, they admit a common term, Christ Jesus, that they may indicate both Him That died, and him that did not die." And he adds, "So that if a man should say, Such an one is dead, though the soul is immortal, yet since he said the word which iudicates the two natures, both the mortal body and the immortal soul, the expression is free from risk: for both are called man, both the body and the soul: thus it is therefore that that great band spake of Christ."

When they named Christ Jesus, they did not mean two separate sons who share a common name, Christ Jesus, but rather the Word from God made Man. I think no one who judges rightly will disagree with this, and I think it is unnecessary for us to add many more words on this matter beyond what has already been said. But if you are not persuaded by our words to think that, though we say the Word of God suffered in the Flesh for our sakes, we still hold Him to be Impassible as God, at least grant that your own words seem to have been correctly framed. For just as someone who said "man" indicated the soul together with the body, even though the soul is of a different nature than the body, and even if that person's body were said to be dead, the whole person would reasonably be considered to have suffered this, although he possesses a soul that cannot receive death—so it is also with Christ the Saviour of us all. For since the Word from God the Father (as we have said repeatedly) partook of blood and flesh in the same way as we do, and made His own the Body from the holy Virgin and was thus also called Son of man, for this reason when His Flesh died, the plan of true union attributes the suffering to Him, yet knows that He remained apart from suffering because He is both God by Nature and Life. And indeed the divinely-inspired Peter, setting this teaching before us, says of Him somewhere to those who believe in Him: "Whom having not seen you love, in Whom, though now you do not see Him, yet believing, you rejoice with joy inexpressible and full of glory, receiving the fulfillment of your faith, the salvation of your souls, concerning which salvation the prophets searched and inquired carefully, who prophesied about the grace that would come to you, searching what person or time the Spirit of Christ that was in them was indicating, when It testified beforehand to the sufferings of Christ and the glory that would follow them, to whom it was revealed that they were serving not themselves but us in these things which have now been announced to us through those who preached the Gospel to us with the Holy Spirit sent down from Heaven—things into which angels long to look."

That in naming Christ Jesus, they did not indicate two several sons, having a common name, Christ Jesus, but rather the Word out of God made Man, I think no one that deems aright will gainsay, and I think it superfluous for us to yet array many words on this matter besides what have been already said. Yet if thou be not persuaded by our words to think that though we say that the Word of God hath suffered in the Flesh for our sakes, we hold Him even thus Impassible as God, at least allow to thine own words that they appear to have been rightly framed. For just as he who said man, indicated the soul together with the body although it be of other nature than it; and even though such an one's body were said to be dead, the whole person would reasonably be held to have suffered this, albeit he possess a soul which is not recipient of death: so of Christ too the Saviour of us all. For since the Word out of God the Father (as we have repeatedly said) hath partaken of blood and flesh in like manner as we, and made His own the Body that is of the holy Virgin and has thus been called Son of man too; for this reason when His Flesh died, the plan of true union attributes the suffering to Him, yet knows that He hath remained apart from suffering because He is both God by Nature and Life. And verily the Divine-uttering Peter setting before us this teaching says of Him somewhere to them that believe on Him, Whom having not seen ye love, on Whom, though now ye see Him. not, yet believing, ye exult with joy unutterable and glorified, receiving the fulfilment of your faith, the salvation of your souls, of which salvation the prophets searched out and examined into, who prophesied of the grace to youward, searching what or what manner of time the Spirit of Christ Which was in them was signifying, when It testified beforehand the sufferings of Christ and the glory that should follow, unto whom it was revealed that not unto themselves but to us they were ministering the things which are now declared unto us through them that preached the Gospel unto us with the Holy Ghost sent down from Heaven: which things the Angels long to look into.

Do you hear that the Spirit of Christ was in the holy prophets too, and that they proclaimed beforehand the sufferings of Christ and the glory that should follow? Did they then proclaim to the world that a mere man was suffering for us? Is this the mystery which has been entrusted through our holy apostles and evangelists, and are these the things into which the angels long to look? Yet how can anyone not be utterly rejected who tries to confine the power of the mystery within the limits of human nature alone? God the Word himself, who exists in the form of God the Father, has emptied himself, taking the form of a servant, and has undergone birth in the flesh for our sake. He himself has suffered for us in his own flesh, and he came back to life as God, having emptied Hades and said to those who were in bonds, "Come forth," and to those who were in darkness, "Show yourselves." Why then do you try to overturn the awesome and marvelous plan of salvation through which we have both been saved and brought into all good? What we have gained through it you will know very clearly, since blessed Paul has written: "And you who were once alienated and enemies in your mind by wicked works, yet now he has reconciled in the body of his flesh through death, to present you holy and blameless and beyond reproach in his sight, if indeed you continue in the faith." Therefore the faith benefits those who hold it unshaken. How it benefits, the most wise John will assure us, saying: "Who is he that overcomes the world but he who believes that Jesus is the Son of God? This is he who came through water and blood, Jesus Christ, not in water only, but in water and blood, and the Spirit is truth. For there are three that testify: the Spirit, the water, and the blood, and the three are one. If we receive the testimony of men, the testimony of God is greater, for this is the testimony of God, that he has testified concerning his Son. He who believes in the Son of God has the testimony in himself. He who does not believe God has made him a liar, because he has not believed the testimony which he has given regarding his Son." And how God the Father has testified to his Son, John the Baptist, who spoke divine words, will declare, saying: "And I did not know him, but he who sent me to baptize with water said to me, 'Upon whom you shall see the Spirit descending and remaining upon him, this is he who baptizes with the Holy Spirit.' And I saw and have testified that this is the Son of God." Our Lord Jesus Christ is therefore witnessed to through the Father's voice, that he is by nature and in truth his Son. He is witnessed to no less through the water and the blood and the Spirit. For by the holy water he cleanses away the sins of those who believe, he gives life through his own blood and connects to God those on earth. And since he is God by nature, he also richly grants the Holy Spirit, pouring it forth as his own into the hearts of those who believe, and making them partakers of the divine nature, and crowning them with the hope of the good things to come.

Hearest thou that the Spirit of Christ was in the holy Prophets too, and that they proclaimed beforehand the sufferings of Christ and the glory that should follow? Did they then proclaim to the world as though a mere man were suffering for us? and is this the mystery which through our holy Apostles and Evangelists hath been given in trust, and into these things does he say that the Angels long to look? yet how is not he to be utterly repudiated who essays to shut up the might of the mystery within the limits of the human nature alone? God the Word Himself, Who is in the Form of God the Father, hath emptied Himself taking servant's form and hath undergone birth in the flesh for our sakes, Himself hath suffered for us in His own Flesh, and He lived again as God, having emptied Hades and said to them that were in bonds, Come forth, and to them that were in darkness, Shew yourselves. Why then essayest thou to overturn the so dread and marvellous economy through which we have been both saved and have been brought within all good? for what we gained through it, thou wilt know and that very clearly, since blessed Paul hath thus written, And you that were sometime alienated and enemies n your mind in wicked works, yet now hath He reconciled in the body oj His flesh through death to present you holy and unblameable and unreproveable in His sight if so be ye endure in the Faith. Therefore the faith profits them who will hold it unshaken; how it profits, the all-wise John will assure us saying, Who is he that overcometh the world but he that believeth that Jesus is the Son of God? This is He that came through water and blood, Jesus Christ, not in water only, but in water and blood, and the Spirit is Truth; for three testify, the Spirit, the water and the Blood, and the Three are One. If we receive the witness of men, the witness of God is greater, for this is the witness of God, because He hath witnessed concerning His Son: he that believeth on the Son of God hath the witness in himself, he that believeth not God hath made him a liar, because he believed not the testimony which He hath testified regarding His Son. And how God the Father hath testified to His Son, the Divine-uttering John the Baptist will declare saying. And I knew Him not, but He That sent me to baptize with water, He said to me, Upon Whom thou shalt see the Spirit descending and remaining upon Him, This is He Which baptizeth with the Holy Ghost. And I saw and have testified that This is the Son of God. Our Lord Jesus Christ therefore is witnessed to through the Father's Voice, that He is by Nature and in truth His Son, He is witnessed to no less through the water and the Blood and the Spirit. For by the holy water He purgeth away the sins of them that believe, He quickeneth through His own Blood and connecteth to God them on the earth: and since He is God by Nature He maketh also richly the grant of the Holy Ghost, pouring It forth as His own into the hearts of them who believe, and making them partakers of the Divine Nature, and crowning them with the hope of the good things to come.

We therefore confess one Son, Christ Jesus the Lord—that is, the Word of God who became man and took on flesh—and confess him as crucified, raised from the dead, and coming at the appointed time in the glory of God the Father with the holy angels. Through him and with him, glory belongs to God the Father together with the Holy Spirit forever. Amen.

We confess therefore One Son, Christ Jesus the Lord, that is, the Word of God made Man and Incarnate and Him crucified and raised from the dead and to come in due time in the Glory of God the Father with the holy Angels; through Him and with Him to God the Father be glory with the Holy Ghost for ever. Amen.


Five Tomes Against Nestorius — Book IV

Every divine work is the work of the whole Trinity; Christ gives the Holy Spirit as His own Spirit and works as God through Him.

Brazen serpent a type: how to be cured of the stings. In HOLY TRINITY Each Person exists yet each work is the work of the Whole TRINITY. Meaning of "Made flesh." Christ gives the SPIRIT as His own, and works as God through His own SPIRIT. Nicene Fathers spake through the HOLY GHOST. "Commended." The HOLY GHOST Spirit of the Truth, i. e., of CHRIST. All Divine Work work of Whole TRINITY. HOLY GHOST out of the FATHER and the Own of the SON. S. John xvii. 1. Flesh of CHRIST quickens in the Eucharist, because it is the flesh of the WORD. Its type the Lamb, its mode a mystery. Nestorius confessed that Godhead and manhood belong to the Same, and contradicts himself: yet the Eucharist does quicken us: and He is Man having remained GOD. No one taught confusion of Person in Christ.

Source: Cyril of Alexandria, Five Tomes Against Nestorius (1881) Book 4. pp.125-154.. Transcribed by Roger Pearse (tertullian.org); public domain.

Contents · 8 chapters
  1. Opening
  2. §1
  3. §2
  4. §3
  5. §4
  6. §5
  7. §6
  8. §7

Opening

The divinely inspired Paul shows that the shadow in the Law is not ineffective for the benefit of those who have chosen to live godly lives. He clearly presents to everyone's minds, as a picture and representation of the truer reality, the things that happened long ago to the people of old. He says, "But these things happened to them as types, but were written for our instruction, upon whom the ends of the ages have come." So let us now select from the writings of the Law and say this: the Israelites were camping in the desert long ago when they left the land of Egypt and were traveling toward the Promised Land. But when they—wretched people!—forgot the wonders done in Egypt and their love toward God, they began to murmur impiously, and they were destroyed by serpents, as it is written. Yet they escaped the bites of the poisonous creatures when Moses raised up the bronze serpent for them, since God the Savior of all had commanded, "Make yourself a serpent and set it as a sign, and it shall be that if a serpent has bitten anyone, everyone who is bitten and looks at it shall live." The image, then, was the mystery pointing toward Christ, for the Only-Begotten Word of God, being God and Good by nature from a Good Father, partook of flesh and blood—that is, was made man—and became like us sinful people, in the sense that He is human as we are. And He too was lifted up on high, that is, He endured the cross on the wood and death according to the flesh, even though He rose again on the third day, having trampled on the power of death.

The Divine-uttering Paul, shewing that not ineffective for the profit of those who have elected to live piously, is the shadow in the Law and besides full well setting before the minds of all, as a picture and representation of the truer, the things which long ago befell them of old, says, But these things happened unto them typically, but were written for our admonition unto whom the ends of the world are come. Come now therefore selecting out of the writings of the Law let us say, that they of Israel were camping in the desert of old time when they departed out of the land of the Egyptians and were speeding unto the Land of Promise: but when (wretched ones!) unmindful of the wonders in Egypt and of their love to Godward, they began unholily to murmur, they were destroyed of serpents, as it is written. Yet they escaped the bites of the venomous creatures, Moses having reared up for them the brazen Serpent, God the Saviour of all having commanded, Make thee a serpent and set it for a sign and it shall be, if a serpent have bitten a man, that every one that is bitten, seeing it shall live. The figure then was the mystery Christ-ward, for the Only-Begotten Word of God being God, and Good by Nature out of a Good Father, partook of flesh and blood, i. e., was made man, and like unto us wicked ones, in regard I mean that He is man as we. And He has been set up on high too, that is, He endured the cross on the wood and death after the flesh, even though He rose again the third day having trampled on the might of death.

When we are burdened by profound misunderstanding and complain about the economy with flesh, viewing it as inappropriate, we become ashamed to think or say that the Word of God became human like us and was truly united to flesh. At such times the dragon, the prince of evil, will destroy us, pouring into our minds error like the poison of his own wickedness. Yet we will escape and ward off the harm of his deceitfulness if we look with the eyes of our heart upon the serpent—that is, if we consider with careful attention the mystery of Christ. For then, indeed then, thinking rightly we will confess without hesitation that the Word of God has been made flesh and was born of a woman while remaining God, and is the same, both God and man at once. He is neither ashamed of the limitations of human nature because of the dignity of his excellence, nor stripped of his God-befitting authority and supreme glory on account of his human nature. And those who are well practiced in discerning such things, clearly and through careful examination understanding through both natures the one Christ and the mystery concerning him, say, "O the depth of the riches and wisdom and knowledge of God, how unsearchable his judgments and his ways impossible to trace; for who has known the mind of the Lord?"

When therefore of exceeding great lack of understanding murmuring against the economy with flesh and charging it with uncomeliness, we are ashamed to think or say that the Word of God became Man as we and was united to flesh in verity, then will the dragon, the prince of evil, slay us, infusing into our minds error, as it were the venom of his own perverseness: yet shall we escape and repel the damage of his crookedness, if with the eyes of our heart we look on the serpent, that is, if we consider with accurate mind the mystery of Christ. For then, then, deeming right shall we confess unhesitatingly that the Word of God has been made flesh, and proceeded forth of a woman along with remaining God, and is the Same God alike and Man, neither shaming of the measures of the human nature by reason of the Dignity of the Excellence, nor yet reft of His God-befitting Authority and Supreme Glory on account of the human nature. And they who are used full well to discern such things, clearly and by accurate scrutiny understanding through both the one, and the Mystery regarding Him, say, O the depth of the riches and wisdom and knowledge of God, how unsearchable His judgements and His ways not to be tracked; for who knew the mind of the Lord?

Yet this man somehow pushes these things aside as impossible and unseemly, and dares to make no small accusation against the glory and excellence of our Savior. He assigns to Him our measure and nothing else, saying that He has been glorified by the Holy Spirit—not using as His own power the ability to work signs through Himself, but receiving from outside and from elsewhere the power to accomplish anything miraculous. This would make Him appear, like us, as the recipient of a gift of healing, perhaps, and bound to say with blessed Paul, "By the grace of God I am what I am." For those to whom both existence and the ability to accomplish anything are imported and come from outside will reasonably speak such words as these.

Yet doth somehow this man thrusting away these things as impossible and uncomely, dare to make no small accusal against the glory and excellence of our Saviour, and allotting to Him our measure and nought else, says that He has been glorified by the Holy Ghost, not using as His own Power, that through Him to work signs, but gaining from without and introduced, the power of achieving ought miraculous, that He may appear as we the recipient of a gift haply of healing, and be bound to say with blessed Paul, By the Grace of God I am what I am. For to whom being and being able to achieve ought is imported and from without, these will with reason utter such word as this.

For in desiring (as he thinks) to prove the Holy Trinity equal in operation in all things, he says again as follows:

For he desiring (as he thinks) to prove the Holy Trinity equal in operation unto all things, says again thus;

§1

Nestorius: "God the Word was made Flesh and dwelt among us. The Father seated together with Himself the manhood that was assumed, for it says, 'The Lord said to my Lord, Sit at My Right Hand.' The Spirit descending completed the glory of what was assumed, for when He says, 'When the Spirit of Truth comes, He will glorify Me.' Do you also want another work of the Trinity regarding these same things? The Son dwelt in the body, the Father approved Him when He was baptized, the Spirit formed Him in the Virgin." Then again he says concerning the holy Apostles, "The Son chose them, for He says, 'I chose you.' The Father sanctified them, for He says, 'Father, sanctify them in Your Truth.' The Spirit made them speakers."

Nestorius: " God the Word was made Flesh and tabernacled in us. The Father co-seated with Himself the manhood which was assumed: for (it saith) The Lord said unto my Lord, Sit Thou on My Right Hand; the Spirit descending consummated the glory of that which was assumed, for when (He saith) the Spirit of Truth is come, He shall glorify Me. Desirest thou also another operation of the Trinity in respect of these very things? The Son indwelt in the body, the Father commended Him when baptized, the Spirit fashioned him in the Virgin." Then again he says of the holy Apostles, "The Son chose them out, for I (He says) chose you forth; the Father sanctified, for (He says) Father, sanctify them in Thy Truth, the Spirit rendered them orators."

That his entire argument has been constructed both foolishly and unfortunately is very easy to demonstrate. And in this matter too he goes astray, and I will explain how. For the Nature of the Godhead is indeed One, but the Father exists in His own proper mode, and the Son also, and likewise the Spirit. Yet all things are accomplished by the Father and through the Son in the Spirit, and when the Father is moved (so to speak) to do anything, the Son truly works in the Spirit. And though the Son or the Spirit is said to accomplish anything, this is certainly of the Father. And throughout the entire Holy and Consubstantial Trinity, the Operation and Will toward everything runs alike.1

That his whole discourse has been framed both unwisely and unhappily, is full easy to shew. And in this too he wanders, and how, I will say. For One indeed is the Nature of the Godhead, but the Father exists in His Proper mode and the Son too and likewise the Spirit: yet are all things wrought by the Father and through the Son in the Spirit, and when the Father is (so to say) moved to ought, yet does the Son surely work in the Spirit; and though the Son or the Spirit be said to fulfil ought, this is full surely of the Father: and through the whole Holy and Consubstantial Trinity runs the Operation alike and Will unto everything.1

On this subject we say this. But see again how clearly and evidently, although he says that the Word from God has been made Flesh, he distorts the force of these concepts and carries it far away from correctness, representing the Incarnation as an operation of His. For he immediately adds, "Will you have another operation of the Trinity besides these?" as though he had already shown the first operation of God the Word to be His being made Flesh according to the Scriptures. And what the other operation after the first one is, he shows, as he thinks. He says, "The Son indwelt in the body." Christ is therefore a God-bearing man. Next, the Word of God the Father is shown to be operating this alone for man, so that even though the blessed Evangelist says, "The Word was made Flesh and dwelt among us," it indicates nothing else to us but just this alone: that the Word, being God, dwelt in a man just as He does in us too. For we are temples of the living God, and by this we know that He is in us, because He gave us of His Spirit. But you will not say this, I suppose, shuddering at the blasphemy, but will confess with us that the Word of God has been made Man (and this is the Incarnation), and will agree that He has remained God and kept the Beauty of His proper Nature, even though He has the name Son of Man and has truly been made so. Why then did you learn and say that the Father co-seated with Himself the manhood that was assumed, and not rather that there sits on the Throne of His proper Godhead, in the Good-Pleasure of God the Father, the Word who sprang from Him, when made Man too? This is so that His Human Nature may not be conceived and spoken of by us as something other than He, although the union that is of truth shows us that He is One and that His Flesh is not alien from Him.2

On this subject we say thus. But view again how clearly and evidently, although he says that the Word out of God has been made Flesh, he mis-coins the force of the ideas, and bears it far away from rightness, representing the Incarnation as an operation of His: for he adds forthwith, "wilt thou another operation of the Trinity besides these?" as though he had already shewn the first operation of God the Word, His being made Flesh according to the Scriptures. And what is the other after the first operation, he shews as he supposes. He says, "The Son indwelt in the body:" a God-clad man therefore is Christ. Next the Word of God the Father is shewn operating this alone for man: so that even though the blessed Evangelist say, The Word was made Flesh and tabernacled in us, it indicates nothing else to us but just this alone, that the Word being God dwelt in a man just as in ourselves too. For we are temples of the living God, and herein know we that He is in us because He gave us of His Spirit. But thou wilt not (I suppose) say this, shuddering at the blasphemy, but wilt confess with us, that the Word of God has been made Man (and this is the Incarnation): and wilt agree that He hath remained God, and kept the Beauty of His proper Nature, even though He have the name, Sow of Man, and have been made so of a truth. What then didst thou learn, and say that the Father co-seated with Himself the manhood that was assumed, and not rather that there sitteth on the Throne of His proper Godhead, in the Good-Pleasure of God the Father, the Word That sprang from Him, when made Man too: in order that His Human Nature be not conceived and spoken of by us as something other than He, albeit the union that is of truth shews us that He is One and that His Flesh is not alien from Him?2

In this too you will be caught speaking falsely and making no small error in proper reasoning. And if to say that the Word has been made Flesh is nothing other than that He, while being in the Excellence of Godhead and remaining what He was, has become Man, what glory from outside will He need, being Himself the Lord of Glory? For admittedly He was being glorified, with the Spirit working divine signs; yet not as a God-bearing man, receiving this from an alien and superior Nature, as we do, but rather as using His own Spirit: for He was God by physis and His Spirit is not alien to Him. Therefore we say that the operation of the Spirit has not been given to Him from outside or by adoption, as it has to us or to the holy Apostles: for Christ has given them authority over unclean spirits to cast them out, and commanded them to heal every sickness and every disease among the people.

In this too thou wilt therefore be caught speaking falsely and in no slight degree erring from fit reasoning. And if to say that the Word has been made Flesh is nought else than that He being in the Excellence of Godhead and abiding what He was, hath become Man, what glory from without will He be in need of, Himself the Lord of Glory? For confessedly was He being glorified, the Spirit working Divine signs; yet not as a God-clad man, gaining this thing from an alien and superior Nature, even as do WE, but rather as using of His own Spirit: for He was God by Nature and not alien to Him is His Spirit. Hence we say that not from without nor by adoption has the operation of the Spirit been given to Him, even as unto us, or to the holy Apostles: for to them hath Christ given authority over unclean spirits to cast them out, and commanded them to heal both every sickness and every ailment in the people.

From within therefore and from Himself is His Spirit. And a clear demonstration of this will be His ability to supply It to others too, and not by measure, as the blessed Evangelist says. For the God of all measured out to the saints the grace through the Spirit, and to one He gave the word of wisdom, to another the word of knowledge, to another gifts of healing. And I think this means that those who have the operation possess power in measure. But our Lord Jesus Christ, putting forth the Spirit out of His own fullness, just as the Father Himself does, gives It not by measure to those who are worthy to receive It. Why then, most excellent sir, do you count Him Who gives the Spirit not by measure as numbered together with those who have It in measure, saying that His glory has been cemented by the Spirit and that He has been operated upon, like one of us, receiving as a grace support from Him, rather than working Divine signs through His own Spirit?

From within therefore and from Himself is His Spirit, And an evident demonstration of this will be His being able to supply It to others too and not of measure, as the blessed Evangelist saith. For the God of all measured to the saints the grace through the Spirit, and to one He gave the word of wisdom, to another the word of knowledge, to another, gifts of healing: and this I think is that those who have the operation have power of measure: but our Lord Jesus Christ, putting forth the Spirit out of His own fulness, even as doth the Father Himself, gives It not as of measure to those who are worthy to receive It. Why then, most excellent sir, dost thou make Him Who giveth the Spirit not of measure, connumerate with those who have It in measure, saying that His glory has been cemented by the Spirit and that He has been operated on, like one of us, receiving as a grace support from Him, rather than working Divine signs through His own Spirit.

For the recklessly bold Jews, sharpening their bitter tongues against Him, said impiously, "This man does not cast out demons except by Beelzebub the prince of demons." But our Lord Jesus Christ, convicting them of no small foolishness and indeed of impiety, says, "If I cast out demons by Beelzebub, prince of demons, by whom do your sons cast them out?" For the glorious and mighty group of the holy Apostles, performing miracles in the Name of Jesus Christ of Nazareth, is marveled at. And truly they returned rejoicing and saying, "Lord, even the demons are subject to us in Your Name." But if it is possible that through the name of any person who has been worked upon, others too should be able to accomplish similar things, let such a person come and tell us why no one is marveled at for rebuking unclean spirits or for having accomplished anything else that surpasses reason in the name of any saint.

For the all-daring Jews, whetting against Him a bitter tongue, unholily said, This man casteth not out devils save in Beelzebub the prince of the devils; but our Lord Jesus Christ convicting them of no small folly yea rather of impiety, says, If I in Beelzebub, prince of devils, cast out devils, by whom do your sons cast them out? for the glorious and mighty choir of the holy Apostles, performing miracles in the Name of Jesus Christ of Nazareth, is marvelled at: and of a truth they returned rejoicing and saying, Lord even the devils are subject to. us in Thy Name. But if it be possible that in the name of any one of those operated on, others too should avail to accomplish the like, let him come, let him tell us why no ono is marvelled at for rebuking unclean spirits or having accomplished ought else that passes reason, in the name of any saint.

But they are operated upon by the Spirit and have a measured grace, while He, as God, works inwardly and through His own Spirit accomplishes effortlessly the things for which He is marveled at. And truly the woman who was sick with the issue of blood came one time secretly behind Him (as it is written) and touched the border of His garment, and immediately her flow of blood stopped. Christ, perceiving this, says, "Who touched Me?" And when the divinely-inspired disciples said, "Master, the crowds are surrounding You and pressing against You," He said again, "Someone touched Me, for I know that power went out from Me." Do you understand, then, that He has the power to work inwardly and to free people from weaknesses not as something introduced from outside, but from within and out of Himself?

But they are operated upon by the Spirit and have a measured grace, He, as God in-worketh, and through His own Spirit achieveth without toil the things whereby He is marvelled at. And verily the woman who was sick of the issue of blood came one time secretly behind Him (thus is it written) and touched the border of His garment and immediately her issue of blood stanched, which Christ now understanding, says Who touched Me? and when at this the Divine-speaking disciples said, Master, the multitude are thronging Thee and pressing Thee, He said again, Somebody touched Me, for I know that might went forth of Me. Understandest thou then that not as introduced from without, but from within and out of Himself hath He the power to inwork and to free from weaknesses?

The blessed Evangelist Matthew also writes somewhere, "And the whole multitude were seeking to touch Him, for there went power out of Him and healed all." His power, then, is His Spirit, and the divinely-inspired David will give us proof, saying, "By the Word of the Lord were the heavens established and by the Spirit of His Mouth all their power." He says that the Mouth of God the Father is the Word who comes from Him, by whose Spirit the things made through Him are established in their existence. I have now therefore said that he brings to nothing the Mystery of Godliness, which has been marveled at even by the holy Angels themselves, and caring nothing for the doctrines that pertain to truth, he dismisses them saying, "Do you want another operation of the Trinity besides these? The Son dwelt in the body, the Father commended him when baptized, the Spirit fashioned him in the Virgin." And that the truth will surely follow upon the things which we have said, and that we have made no mere condemnation of his words, but rather a clear and true conviction of them, he himself will show by saying elsewhere in this way,

And the blessed Evangelist Matthew too somewhere writeth, And the whole multitude were seeking to touch Him, for there went might out of Him and healed all. His might then is His Spirit, and the Divine-uttering David will give us proof, saying, By the Word of the Lord were the Heavens stablished and by the Spirit of His Mouth all their might. The Mouth of God the Father he says is the Word That is out of Him, by Whose Spirit the things made through Him, are stablished in being. I have now therefore said that he brings down to nothing the Mystery of Godliness, which has been marvelled at by the holy Angels themselves too, and recking nought of the dogmas that pertain unto truth, he makes light of them saying, "Wilt thou another operation of the Trinity besides these? the Son dwelt in the body, the Father commended him when baptized, the Spirit fashioned him in the Virgin." And that the truth will follow surely upon the things which we have said, and that we have made no mere condemnation of his words, but rather a clear and true conviction of them, himself will shew saying elsewhere on this wise,

§2

The proof that they work together is clear: The Son became man, the Father enthroned Him, and the Spirit honored Him through signs.

Nestorius: "And the proof of co-work is evident, The Son became man, the Father enthroned Him, the Spirit honoured Him by signs."

Will anyone doubt even after this that the aim of his ideas leads to both ignorance and ungodliness, and is audacious against the doctrines of piety? For just as he unwisely rejects the idea that the Word of God was made Flesh and says instead that He simply dwelt within a man, so too he also reinterprets the meaning of being made man—even though the holy Churches in every region under Heaven, and the venerable Fathers themselves who set forth for us the definition of the right and undefiled Faith (the Holy Spirit speaking through them), taught that the Word of God was made flesh and became Man. He understands this to mean nothing other than being made man just as we are, and being born according to the flesh from a woman, because He has also been placed under the Law along with us—He who as God is above the Law.

Will any one doubt even after this that the aim of his ideas looks to unlearning alike and unholiness, and is bold against the doctrines of piety? for like as he unwisely casts forth the Word of God from being made Flesh and says that He wrought an indwelling in man, so too again does he take the being made man, albeit the holy Churches in every region under Heaven, and the venerable Fathers themselves who put forth unto us the definition of the right and undefiled Faith, viz. (the Holy Ghost speaking in them) that the Word of God was made flesh and became Man, conceiving that this is nought else save only the being made man as we, and being born after the flesh of a woman, because He hath also been made with us under the Law, Who as God is above the Law.

But since (as I have already said many times) his aim is to destroy the Truth, he alone vigorously exalts himself and opposes everyone else's opinions. He raises arms against the Ineffable glory, and what he alone thinks, he tries to smuggle in secretly like rubbish into the churches of God. For he maintains that the Incarnation is an indwelling, rather than that the Word from God partook of blood and flesh just as we do—even though the Word has dwelt and still dwells in all the saints, yet he has been made as we are once, and has partaken personally in a single flesh. In that flesh he is believed both to have died and to have risen for us, for he willingly suffered in the flesh.

But since (as I have already full often said) his aim is to undo the Truth, therefore he alone (and that strenuously) lifts himself up, and opposes the opinions of all, and brandishes arms against the Ineffable glory, and what he alone thinks, endeavours to bring in secretly as a kind of rubbish upon the churches of God: for he maintains that the Incarnation is indwelling, and not rather that the Word out of God partook like us of blood and flesh, albeit the Word hath indwelt and indwells yet in all the saints, but has once been made as we, and has partaken Personally in a single flesh, wherein He is believed both to have died and to have risen for us: for of His own will He suffered in the flesh.

But that he is flinging words about carelessly and paying little attention to the absurdity of his language when he says that Christ was ennobled by signs through the Spirit, the words just cited have already shown sufficiently, I think. But let us examine, if you please, his other words. "The Father," he says, "commended." What "commended" means here, I cannot understand, for the word is admittedly a word of the marketplace and the crowd, and full of commonplace trickery. But I suppose he wanted to indicate "set forth," for example, or "has witnessed to." How then, tell me, did the Father commend? Did He present someone counted worthy of divine indwelling? Or was it not this at all, but rather His own Son made man, yet remaining even in flesh what He was and is and shall be, that is, God? For Jesus Christ who was yesterday and today is the same even forever.

But that to no purpose is he flinging about words, and recking little of the absurdity of his language, says that Christ was ennobled by signs through the Spirit, the words which have been just cited, sufficiently (as I think) shewed: but let us examine, if you please, his other words. 'The Father (he says) commended;' what then commended here is, I cannot understand: for the word is confessedly a word of the market and the mob, and replete with commonplace trickery; but I suppose that he wanted to indicate, set forth, for example, or, hath witnessed to. How then (tell me) did the Father commend? did He exhibit one counted worthy of Divine Indwelling? or was it not this at all, but rather His own Son made man, yet abiding even in Flesh, what He was and is and shall be, i. e. God? For Jesus Christ Who was yesterday and to-day is the Same even for ever.

Let's examine what is said about Him. What does the Evangelist say? "And John bore witness, saying, I have seen the Spirit descending from Heaven like a dove and abiding upon Him. This is He who baptizes with the Holy Ghost: and I have seen and testified that This is the Son of God." For our Lord Jesus Christ was about to sanctify the Jordan economically, and He graciously chose to be baptized with us, ordering the Mystery of the Economy with flesh in the ways that are fitting for it. For it was necessary that the Word from God the Father should be known to have been made Man. Yet He was baptized as Man, while He baptized divinely in the Holy Ghost. And we do not say that He ministered the participation of the Holy Ghost to those being baptized either as a servant or through any intermediary, but rather He sanctified them, Himself infusing into them out of His own Fullness as God by Nature. How then do you, disregarding both words and thoughts that belong to right understanding, say that indwelling in man was accomplished by God the Word? Even though very many saints have had the God of all indwelling in them, none of them baptized with his own spirit or has been said to indwell divinely in anyone and has so indwelt. And Christ Himself dwells in us through the Holy Ghost, which is His own too, just as it is God the Father's. And He Himself confirms this to us saying, "But when the Comforter has come, whom I will send to you from the Father, the Spirit of Truth, who proceeds from the Father, He shall testify of Me."3

Come then, let us examine what is spoken of Him. What says the Evangelist? And John bare record, saying, I have seen the Spirit descending from, Heaven like a dove,…. and abiding upon Him, This is He That baptizeth with the Holy Ghost: and I have seen and testified that This is the Son of God. For our Lord Jesus Christ was about to sanctify economically the Jordan, and deigned with us to be baptized, ordering the Mystery of the Economy with flesh through the ways that beseem it: for it was necessary that the Word out of God the Father should be known to have been made Man. Yet was He baptized as Man, He baptized Divinely in the Holy Ghost. And we do not say that He ministered the participation of the Holy Ghost to the baptized either as a servant or by means of any other, but hallowed them, Himself infusing into them out of His own Fulness as God by Nature. How then dost thou, disregarding words alike and thoughts that belong to rightness, say that indwelling in man was wrought by God the Word; albeit whereas very many saints have had the God of all indwelling in them, none of them baptized with his own spirit or has been said to indwell Divinely in any and has so indwelt? and Christ Himself dwells in us through the Holy Ghost, Which is His own too, even as God the Father's. And this Himself ratifies to us saying, But when the Comforter is come, Whom I will send unto you from the Father, the Spirit of the Truth, Which proceedeth from the Father, He shall testify of Me.3

See then how He says that the Spirit who proceeds from God the Father is also the own Spirit of the Truth, and He Himself is certainly the Truth. How then, if He is truly not rather God made man, but man having the Divine Indwelling as His Energy, does He promise to send down the Spirit of God the Father as His own upon those who believe in Him? Yes, as I said, he destroys the glory of the Mystery, dividing the operation of the Holy Trinity with respect to the things done, and assigning to each of the Persons separately what the other has not accomplished.

See then how He says that the Spirit Which proceedeth from God the Father is the own Spirit of the Truth also: and He Himself is of a surety the Truth. How then, if He be of a truth not rather God made man, but man having the Divine Indwelling as His Energy, doth He promise to send down, as His own, the Spirit of God the Father upon them who believe on Him? Yea, as I said, he shakes to nothing the glory of the Mystery, distributing the operation of the Holy Trinity in respect of the things done, and allotting to each of the Persons by Himself what the other hath not wrought.

Again he says this: "The Son chose, for I, He says, chose you; the Father sanctified; the Spirit made them orators." What utter confusion! If all things have been done by the Father through the Son in the Spirit, and nothing is done by God the Father except in exactly this way—how is he not clearly out of his mind, distributing to each Person separately the operations of the undefiled and One Godhead, instead of maintaining that each thing that is done has been accomplished by the Father through the Son in the Spirit? For if the Son is both the Counsel and Wisdom and Power of the Father, then surely the Father will work all things through the Son, as through His Counsel and Wisdom and Power. Thus He chose His disciples for their excellence, thus we say that those who were chosen were sanctified, thus that they were made orators, from out of One Godhead—that is, by the Father through the Son in the Spirit. For He says, Holy Father, sanctify them in Your Truth. Therefore the Truth sanctifies—that is, the Son. He also infuses wisdom into them and renders them devoutly eloquent through the operation of the Holy Spirit. And truly He said in the book of Matthew to His own disciples, When they deliver you up, take no thought how or what you shall speak, for it shall be given you in that hour what you shall speak, for it is not you who are the speakers, but the Spirit of your Father who speaks in you; and through the book of Luke, Settle it therefore in your hearts not to think beforehand what you shall answer, for I will give you a mouth and wisdom which all your adversaries shall not be able to contradict or resist. Do you hear how when the Holy Spirit speaks in them, He Himself gives the mouth? For He is as Word the Giver of word and Bestower of the Spirit, as having It as His own naturally—just as the Father Himself does too. The Holy Trinity therefore has the same operation, and whatever things the Father does and wills to accomplish, these things the Son also does in equal manner, and likewise the Spirit also. But giving the operations separately to each of the Persons individually is nothing else than setting forth three gods separately and wholly distinct from one another. For the count of natural unity in regard to the Holy Trinity shows, I suppose, one motion toward everything that is done. But if we say that while one Person is moved, for example, to work, the two remain inactive, how is a gross separation not secretly introduced, assigning to each Person a certain position—being conceived of as external to and isolated from the rest? Not in respect of His individual being (for that would be true), but in respect of utter diversity which does not allow language that gathers them into natural union. For one physis of Godhead is conceived of in the Holy and Consubstantial Trinity.45

Again he says on this wise, "The Son chose forth, for I, He says, chose you: the Father sanctified, the Spirit made orators." O distraction without measure! if all things have been done by the Father through the Son in the Spirit and nothing be done by God the Father, save in this very way;—-how is he not surely distraught, who distributes to the Persons severally the Operations unto ought of the Untaint and One Godhead, and doth not rather maintain that each thing that is done has been wrought by the Father through the Son in the Spirit? For if the Son is both the Counsel and Wisdom and Might of the Father, full surely will the Father work all things through the Son, as through His Counsel and Wisdom and Might. Thus chose He for their excellence His disciples, thus do we say that those who were chosen out were sanctified, thus that they were made orators, from out One Godhead; that is, by the Father through the Son in the Spirit. For He says, Holy Father, sanctify them in Thy Truth. The Truth therefore sanctifies, i. e. the Son; He infuses….. too and renders them wise and through the operation of the Holy Ghost; devoutly eloquent. And verily He said in the book of Matthew to His own Disciples, When they deliver you up take no thought how or what ye shall speak, for it shall be given yon in that hour what ye shall speak, for not YE are the speakers, but the Spirit of your Father which speaketh in you; and through that of Luke, Settle it therefore in your hearts not to meditate before what ye shall answer, for I will give you a mouth and wisdom which all your adversaries shall not be able to gainsay or resist. Hearest thou how when the Holy Ghost speaketh in them, Himself gives the mouth? For He is as Word Giver of word and Bestower of the Spirit, as having It as His own Naturally; even as the Father Himself too. The Holy Trinity has therefore the same Operation, and whatsoever things the Father doth and willeth to accomplish, these things doth the Son too in equal manner, likewise the Spirit also. But the giving of the Operations severally to Each of the Persons individually is nought else than to set forth three gods severally and wholly distinct from one another. For the count of Natural Unity in regard to the Holy Trinity, shews I suppose one motion unto every thing that is done. But if now we say that while One Person is moved, e. g., to work, the Two remain ineffective, how is not a gross severance privily introduced, allotting as a certain position to each Person, the being conceived of external to and isolated from the rest, not in respect of His Individual Being (for that were true), but in respect of utter diversity which does not endure language that gathers them into Natural Union? For One Nature of Godhead is conceived of in the Holy and Consubstantial Trinity.45

But this man dares to diminish God the Word, who is Consubstantial with God the Father, as though he does not know that He became human without casting aside what He was, but rather by taking on what He was not. For he is an advocate for (as has been said) the Holy Spirit and insults the Son, saying this to some who have chosen to think along with Arius:

But this good man dares to abridge God the Word Consubstantial with God the Father as though he knows not that He has been made Man, not casting away what He was, but assuming rather what He was not: for he is an advocate for (as has been said) the Holy Ghost and insults the Son, thus saying to some who have elected to think with Arius,

§3

Nestorius says: They devise an even greater insult against Him by separating from the Divine Nature the Spirit who formed His Human Nature (for Scripture says, "that which is conceived in Mary is of the Holy Ghost"), who restored to righteousness what had been formed (for it says, "He was manifested in flesh, was made righteous in Spirit"), who made Him terrifying to demons (for He says, "I in the Spirit of God cast out devils"), who made His Flesh a Temple (for it says, "I saw the Spirit descending from Heaven like a dove and it abode upon Him"), and who granted Him to be taken up (for it says, "having given commandment to the holy Apostles whom He chose forth, He was taken up through the Holy Ghost"). This Spirit, I say, who bestowed such great glory on Christ, they make into Christ's servant.6

Nestorius: "They (he says) contriving greater insult against Him, and severing from the Divine Nature the Spirit Which having formed His Human Nature (for that, it says, which is conceived in Mary is of the Holy Ghost), reformed unto righteousness that which was formed (for He was manifested, it says, in flesh, was made righteous in Spirit), Which made Him terrible to devils (for I, He says, in the Spirit of God, cast out devils); Which made His Flesh a Temple (for I saw, it says, the Spirit descending from Heaven like a dove and it abode upon Him); Which granted Him to be taken up (for, it says, having given commandment to the holy Apostles whom He chose forth, He was taken up through the Holy Ghost): This I say which bestowed on Christ so great glory they make Christ's bondman."6

To dare to sever the Spirit from the Divine and Untainted Nature is, I agree, the mark of a wicked and sinful mind, one far removed from what is proper. For the Spirit is Consubstantial with God the Father and also with the Son Himself, and is believed to be God and from God. But I think we should set this aside for now and examine the words before us, paying close attention to what they mean. For he says, "Doing a greater insult against Him (that is, the Word from God the Father) and severing from the Divine Nature the Spirit which formed His Human Nature." Whose Human Nature, my good man, are you saying has been formed through the Spirit? Yet you were just speaking to us about the Only-Begotten Himself, who was begotten ineffably from God the Father. You were calling Him "Divine Nature," and it is His Human Nature, I suppose, and no one else's, that you say it is. So remember your own words, for you said it was the Word's own Flesh—that is, with a rational soul in it—for this is how the manhood will be His. Then how, if the Word from God the Father is one with His own Flesh, can you suppose that He lacks God-befitting power and that the Holy Spirit made Him terrible to devils, as though He could not do this by His own nature? And again, how could the ability to crush Satan be something given by another and merely borrowed?

The daring then to sever the Spirit from the Divine and Untaint Nature, is (I assent) the part of a bad and sinful mind and one far removed from what is fit (for He is Consubstantial with God the Father, and moreover with the Son Himself and is believed to be God and out of God): but I think that we should, letting this be for the present, examine the words before us and with all attention see whither they look. For says he "Doing a greater insult against Him (i. e., the Word out of God the Father) and severing from the Divine Nature the Spirit Which formed His Human Nature." Whose Human Nature, most excellent sir, sayest thou has been formed through the Spirit? albeit thou hadst but now made discourse to us about the Only-Begotten Himself Who was begotten Ineffably out of God the Father; for thou wert calling Him "Divine Nature," and His I suppose and none else's you say the Human Nature is. Therefore call to mind thine own words, for thou saidst it was the own Flesh of the Word, i. e., with a reasonable soul therein, for thus will the manhood be His. Then how, if the Word out of God the Father be One with His own Flesh, dost thou suppose that he lacks God-befitting Might and that the Holy Ghost made him terrible to devils, as though he could not do this of his own nature? and again the being able to crush Satan, as by the gift of another and hardly borrowed?

If you know that separating the Spirit from His Divine Nature is (quite rightly) the most disgraceful accusation possible, then the Spirit clearly belongs to Him, proceeding through His Ineffable Nature Itself and being Consubstantial with Him. Therefore He will not need the power that comes from the Spirit as something external and added from outside, but will rather use Him as His own Spirit, and will make Himself terrible to the demons through Him. But if you want to show that those who separate the Spirit are free from charges of impiety, why did you just now call them insolent? And how do you not realize that you are counting yourself among them, if you say that the Word from God the Father, united to flesh, needed the help of the Spirit just like any of us or a mere man, in order to be terrible to the unclean spirits? For even though He says that He casts out demons in the Spirit of God, how can one not see that the arrangement of this expression is worthy of admiration? The leaders of the Jews, envious of our Savior's reputation and opening their mouths unrestrainedly against Him, used to babble (wretched as they were) saying that He cast out demons by Beelzebub the prince of demons. But He, with His natural clemency toward all, drawing those who had erred or who were choosing to let loose their tongues against Him toward what was better and true, was attributing the glory of being able to crush Satan to God Who is by Nature, saying that He drove away the wicked spirits in the Spirit of God. He did this not by placing Himself outside of being God by Nature and having the Holy Spirit as His own, but because it was appropriate and worthy of God-befitting skill to intercept the wrath of those who desired His death and to cut off opportunities from those who were offended at Him. For they were attacking Him saying, "We do not stone You for a good work but for blasphemy, because You, being a man, make Yourself God." Therefore He skillfully condescends to those who were still weak by saying "the Spirit of God." For He knows, as I said, that He is God by Nature together with the One Who begot Him, and has all things that are His, except only being Father. This is why He also said to Him, "All Mine are Yours and Yours are Mine, and I have been glorified in them," and speaking to us concerning the Holy Spirit, He says, "All things that the Father has are Mine, therefore I said to you that He will take of Mine and declare it to you." For just as the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father, being His by Nature, in the same way He is also through the Son Himself, His Naturally and Consubstantial with Him. Therefore, even though He is glorified through the Spirit, He is still understood as glorifying Himself through His own Spirit, and not as though it came to Him from outside, even though He is seen as made Man like us.

If then thou knowest that to sever the Spirit from His Divine Nature is (and justly) the most disgraceful of charges, His (it is manifest) is the Spirit, as proceeding through His Ineffable Nature Itself and Consubstantial with Him, and He will not need the might that is from It as something external and adventitious, but will use Him rather as His own Spirit, and will render Himself terrible to the devils through Him. But if it seem good to thee to shew that they who sever are unimplicated in charges of impiety, how didst thou just now call them to us insolent? and how dost thou not perceive that thou art numbering thyself with them, if thou sayest that the Word out of God the Father united to flesh, needed just like any of ours and a mere man, the aid of the Spirit that He might be terrible to the unclean spirits? For even though He say that He casts out devils in the Spirit of God, how must one not see that the economy of the expression is worthy of marvel? For the chiefs of the Jews, envious of the renown of our Saviour and opening against Him an unbarred mouth, used to babble (miserable ones!) saying that He cast out devils in Beelzebub prince of the devils: but He with His innate clemency toward all, drawing unto what was better and true those who have erred or who were choosing to let loose their tongues upon Him, was attributing rather to God Who is by Nature, the glory of being able to crush Satan, saying that in the Spirit of God He chased away the wicked spirits: and not as putting Himself outside of being God by Nature and of having the Holy Ghost as His own: but since it was meet and worthy of God-befitting skill to intercept the wrath of those who were desiring His death and to cut off occasions from those who were offended at Him, for they were attacking Him saying, For a good work we stone Thee not but for blasphemy, because THOU, being a man, makest Thyself God: therefore skilfully does He condescending to them who were yet weak say, the Spirit of God,: for He knows, as I said, that He is God by Nature together with Him Who begot Him, and has all things of His, save only the being Father. Wherefore did He also say to Him, All Mine are Thine and Thine Mine and I have been glorified in them, and to ourselves making discourse concerning the Holy Ghost, He says, All things that the Father hath are Mine, therefore I said unto you that of Mine shall He take and, declare it unto you. For as the Holy Ghost proceedeth out of the Father being His by Nature, in equal wise is He through the Son Himself too, His Naturally and Consubstantial with Him. Hence even though He be glorified through the Spirit, yet is He conceived of as glorifying Himself through His own Spirit, and not as though it came to Him from without even though He be seen as made Man like us.

It is also unsafe to say this about the Spirit: "Which has made His Flesh a Temple." For it was the Word's own Flesh, and you yourself have just acknowledged this to us, since you said that the human nature is His, and the Holy Body taken from the holy Virgin is called His Temple. His Spirit is also His own, and the Word from God the Father will never be conceived of without His own Spirit. Therefore it would be better and wiser to say that the Body is the Temple of the Word and the flesh is His own, and to believe that His Spirit is always with the Word, just as the Spirit is also always with the Father Himself.

It is besides unsafe to say this also concerning the Spirit, "Which hath made His Flesh a Temple." For it was the own Flesh of the Word, and this thyself has just now acknowledged to us, for thou saidst that His is the human nature, and the Holy Body taken out of the holy Virgin is called His Temple: His own again is His Spirit, and never will the Word out of God the Father be conceived of without His own Spirit. Better therefore were it and wiser, to say that the Body is the Temple of the Word and the flesh His own, and to believe that with the Word is ever His Spirit, just as also with the Father Himself too.

I would say his claim that the Spirit gave the Assumption into Heaven to Him as a mere man is not without blame. For He chose His disciples through the Holy Spirit, and He was taken up as God, not receiving this as a gift from Another. Rather, He Himself presented Himself to God the Father as a first-fruit of human nature renewed unto immortality, consecrating for us a new and living way that enters into the inner part of the veil, where the forerunner is said to have entered on our behalf, made a High Priest forever after the order of Melchizedek. But no one will doubt that when Christ ascended above, the Holy Spirit was in Him as His own. How then did you not fear, tell me, to say that "They make Christ's bondman of This Which gave such great glory to Christ"? For those who make Him Christ's bondman are clearly impious and dishonor the Very Word Who is Consubstantial with God Himself, treating the Spirit—Which is of Him and in Him by nature (physis) and is His own—as befitting a slave. But to say that the glory was given to Him by the Spirit is clear proof of the greatest delusion.

Not without blame moreover would I say that is his saying that Assumption into Heaven has been given Him by the Spirit as to a mere man. For He chose His Disciples through the Holy Ghost, He was taken up as God, not receiving this as a gift from Another; but Himself rather as a first-fruit of the human nature renewed unto immortality presenting Himself to God the Father and consecrating for us a new and living way and that entereth into the inner part of the veil, whither the forerunner is said to have entered in our behalf, after the order of Melchiscdech made an High Priest for ever. But that when Christ ascended above, the Holy Ghost was in Him as His own, none will doubt. How then didst thou not fear (tell me) to say that "This Which gave this so great glory to Christ, they make Christ's bondman?" For they who make Him Christ's bondman are confessedly impious and dishonour the Very Word Who is Consubstantial with God Himself, arraying in slave-befitting measures the Spirit Which is of Him and in Him by Nature and His own: but the saying that the glory was given Him by the Spirit, is a manifest proof of the uttermost infatuation.

But you will be caught talking nonsense here, not understanding the mystery concerning Him—indeed, both thinking and saying things that completely contradict yourself. For if you have believed that the Word, being God, was made flesh (since you said that the human nature was His), why do you say that the Lord of glory, as though He had no glory of His own, needed it from the Spirit, and why do you count Him among created things to which everything comes from outside and is given? For "what do you have that you did not receive?" is something that befits the creature to hear.

But you will be caught idly babbling herein, and not understanding the Mystery to Him-ward, yea rather both thinking and saying clean contrary to yourself. For if thou hast believed that the Word being God has been made Flesh (for thou saidst that His was the human nature) why dost thou say that the Lord of glory, as though He had not glory of His own, needed it from the Spirit, and reckonest Him in the measures of the creature to which all things are from without and given? for what hast thou that thou receivedst not, will it befit the creature to hear.

Yes, but he says, I find Emmanuel saying, "Father, glorify Your Son," so add what comes next: "that Your Son also may glorify You." If you claim that the Son, as if lacking glory, desires the Father's glory, what do you say when the Father is also glorified by the Son? Is it because He doesn't have glory or needs it from another? Away with this bad advice! For truly it is trickery and ungodly thinking and nothing else. For the Divine Nature, which surpasses all natures, dwells in unapproachable light and has authority over all things, and to Him is attributed the glory that most fittingly belongs to Him alone. But when the Only-Begotten Word of God was made man and was about to taste death for every man by the grace of God through His own flesh, and undo death's overwhelming power, quickening His own Temple as God, He makes the prayer as Man, and wills the Father to agree with Him who was transforming the nature of man back to what it was in the beginning and renewing it to incorruption, and displaying it victorious over the traps of death—so that the ancient curse and the sentence upon the First-formed might be undone.

Yea but (he says) I find Emmanuel saying. Father, glorify Thy Son: add therefore what remains; this is, That Thy Son too may glorify Thee. If thou assert that the Son, as lacking glory, desires that of the Father, what dost thou say, when the Father too is glorified of the Son? is it as not having glory or needing it of another? away with the mis-counsel! for verily is it trickery and unholy thought and nought else. For the Divine Nature and that passeth all natures dwelleth in the light unapproachable and hath authority over all things and to Him is ascribed the glory which most befits it alone: but when the Only-Begotten Word of God was made man and was about by the grace of God through His own flesh to taste death for every man, and undo its might hard-to-withstand, quickening as God His own Temple, He devises the prayer as Man, and wills the Father to consent with Him Who was transforming the nature of man to what it was at the beginning and renewing it unto incorruption, and displaying it superior to the meshes of death: that ancient curse and the sentence upon the First-formed being undone.

Since He is visible in the flesh, He is preached as Son of God by physis and in truth. He says, "Father glorify Your Son," making Him as Man superior to both death and decay, so that He may be believed to be Yours, being as God Life by physis, according to the measure of His own physis. For then the Son too will glorify You. It is truly glory to God the Father that we believe He begat—as Very God and Life and Life-giving—One equal and like to Himself in everything, ineffably and beyond understanding: the Son, who was in no lesser state even though He became flesh, but preserved wholly unimpaired the supernatural and excellent beauty of His inherent natural nobility, being Himself also Life from Life, and all-powerful and achieving without effort and bestowing incorruption on those subject to death and decay.

Hence since visible in flesh, He is preached Son of God by Nature and in truth, He says, Father glorify Thy Son, rendering Him as Man, superior to both death and decay, that He may be believed to be Thine, being as God Life by Nature, according to the count of His own Nature: for then will the Son too glorify Thee. Glory truly is it to God the Father that it be believed by us, that He, Very God and Life and Life-giving, begat equal and like to Himself in everything, ineffably and beyond understanding, the Son, Who was in no lesser state, even though He have been made in flesh, but preserved wholly unimpaired the Supernatural and Choice Beauty of His inherent Natural Nobility, being Himself too Life as out of Life, and all-availing and achieving without toil and bestowing in-corruption on those subject to death and decay.

Hence, even though the Son is said to be glorified by the Father, consider the measure of human nature, but do not divide the One Christ and Son and Lord into two [after the Union]. Instead, confess One and the Same, God made Man, and the Same likewise Lord of glory as God, and recipient of glory in His human nature. For consider this: although He is by nature and in truth God and King of all and Lord, He is said to have been appointed King when, having become man as we are, He humbled Himself and was made obedient to God the Father and, along with us, under the Law. Therefore, the things that belong to the limitations of the self-emptying will in no way trouble those who are wise and understanding and established in the faith. Rather, from these things alike and from the things that belong to the divine nature, they acknowledge the Son as the Same, both God and Man.7

Hence even though the Son be said to be glorified by the Father, consider the measure of the human nature, sever not into two [after the Union] the One Christ and Son and Lord, but confess One and the Same, God made Man, and the Same in like manner Lord of glory as God, and recipient of glory in His Human Nature. For consider that, albeit by Nature and in verity God and King of all and Lord, He is said to have been set King, when, made man as we, He hath humbled Himself and been made obedient to God the Father and with us under the Law. In no wise therefore will the things that pertain to the measures of the emptiness trouble the wise and understanding and settled in the faith; but from them alike and from the things that befit the Divine Nature, do they acknowledge the Son, the Same God and Man.7

But he does not come forward with sound words. Instead, having swerved exceedingly toward what is unruly, he busies himself without understanding and deems it fit to hold only what pleases himself and what he thinks is rightly understood. And in addition to what he has said, he destroys others too by severing the One Lord Jesus Christ into two, and by slandering our Divine Mystery itself through his refusal to confess with us that Christ was not like one of the holy Prophets, or again like the Apostles and Evangelists, a God-clad man, but rather God made Man, who has truly partaken of blood and flesh. He spoke again in this way, putting forth his words as though from the prosopon of Christ:

But he comes not forward with sound words, but having swerved exceedingly to what is unruly, he busies himself without understanding, and deems fit to hold what please himself alone and what he thinks well to deem are understood aright. And he destroys others too, in addition to to what he has said severing into two the One Lord Jesus Christ, calumniating also our Divine Mystery itself from not enduring to confess with us, that not like one of the holy Prophets, or again Apostles and Evangelists, was Christ a God-clad man, but God rather made Man, and hath partaken in verity of blood and flesh. He said in this wise again, putting forth his words as of the Person of Christ,

§4

Nestorius: "He that eats My flesh and drinks My Blood abides in Me and I in him. Remember that what is said concerns the flesh. As the Living Father sent Me—Me, the visible one—but sometimes I misinterpret. Let us listen to what follows: As the living Father sent Me, he says the Godhead, I the Manhood. Let us see who is actually misinterpreting. The heretic says that here the Godhead sent Me, God the Word. As the living Father sent Me, according to him, and I live, God the Word, because of the Father. After this: And he that eats Me shall also live. Do we eat the Godhead or the flesh?"89

Nestorius: " He that eateth My flesh and drinketh My Blood abideth in Me and I in him. Remember that what is said is about the flesh. As the Living Father sent Me, Me, the visible: but sometimes I misinterpret. Let us hear from what follows: As the living Father sent Me, he says the Godhead, I the Manhood: let us see who it is who is mis-interpreting. The heretic says [he says] here the Godhead, Sent Me God the Word. As the living Father sent Me, according to him, and I live, God the Word, because of the Father. After this, And he that eateth Me he too shall live. Whether do we eat, the Godhead or the flesh?"89

You are therefore saying that the flesh alone has been sent, and you claim that this is what is seen. According to this, the flesh by itself would be sufficient to give life to what is tyrannized by death. Why then do the God-inspired Scriptures speak pointlessly and repeatedly assert that the Word from God the Father was made flesh? For what need would there be at all for the Word, if human nature is sufficient for us—even when understood alone and by itself—to be able to destroy death and undo the power of decay? And if things are as you suppose and choose to think—that it is not God the Word who has been sent by being made as we are, but the flesh alone which is seen has been sent by the Father—how is it not clear to everyone that we have been made partakers of a human body that differs in no way whatever from our own? How then do you elsewhere ridicule those who think this way? For you said again,10

Thou sayest therefore that the flesh alone has been sent, and affirmest that it it is which is seen: it therefore suffices also alone by itself to quicken that which is tyrannized by death. Why then do the God-inspired Scriptures tell a tale to no purpose and over and over assert that the Word out of God the Father was made Flesh? for what need at all would there be of the Word, if the human nature sufficeth for us, even though conceived of alone and by itself, so as to be able to bring to nought death and to undo the might of decay? and if it is as you suppose and choose to think, not God the Word Who has been sent through being made as we, but the flesh alone which is seen has been sent by the Father, how is it not clear to all, that we have been made participant of a human body and one in no wise whatever differing from our own? how therefore do you elsewhere laugh at those who so think? for thou saidst again,10

§5

Nestorius says: "I will also speak the offensive words. The Lord Christ was speaking to them about His own Flesh when He said, 'Unless you eat the Flesh of the Son of Man and drink His Blood, you have no life in you.' The hearers could not tolerate the elevated nature of what was said. In their ignorance, they thought He was introducing cannibalism."

Nestorius: "I will speak the words too of offence. Of His own Flesh was the Lord Christ discoursing to them; Except ye eat, He says, the Flesh of the Son of Man and drink His Blood, ye have no Life in you: the hearers endured not the loftiness of what was said, they imagined of their unlearning that He was bringing in cannibalism."

And how is this not simply cannibalism, and in what way is the Mystery still lofty, unless we say that the Word from God the Father has been sent, and confess that the manner of that sending was the Incarnation? For then, only then, shall we see clearly that the Flesh which was united to Him and not someone else's flesh is able to give Life, but only because it has been made the very own of Him who is mighty to quicken all things. For if this visible fire infuses the force of its natural inherent power into those substances with which it comes in contact, and changes even water—though cold by nature—into what is contrary to its nature and makes it hot, what wonder is it, or how can one disbelieve, that the Word from God the Father, being the Life by physis (nature), rendered the Flesh which is united to Him Life-giving? For it is His very own and not that of another conceived of as apart from Him and as one of us. But if you remove the Life-giving Word of God from the mystical and true union with His Body and sever them utterly, how can you show that it is still Life-giving? And who was it who said, He that eateth My Flesh and drinketh My Blood, abideth in Me and I in him? If then it is a man by himself and the Word of God has not rather been made as we, the deed would be cannibalism and the participation wholly unprofitable (for I hear Christ Himself say, The flesh profiteth nothing, it is the Spirit that quickeneth, for as far as pertains to its own physis, the flesh is corruptible, and will in no wise quicken others, being itself sick with the decay that is its own). But if you say that it is the own Body of the Word Himself, why do you speak portentously and utter vain things, contending that not the very Word from God the Father has been sent, but some other than Him—"the visible," or His Flesh—although the God-inspired Scripture everywhere proclaims One Christ, clearly affirming that the Word was made Man as we and defining in this the tradition of the right Faith?11

And how is the thing not plain cannibalism, and in what way is the Mystery yet lofty, unless we say that the Word out of God the Father has been sent, and confess that the mode of that sending was the Incarnation? For then, then we shall see clearly, that the Flesh which was united to Him and not another's flesh, avails to give Life, yet 'because it has been made the very own of Him who is mighty to quicken all things,' For if this visible fire infuses the force of its natural inherent power into those substances with which it comes in contact, and changes water itself though cold by nature into that which is contrary to its nature and makes it hot; what wonder or how can one disbelieve that the Word out of God the Father being the Life by Nature rendered the Flesh which is united to Him, Life-giving? for it is His very own and not that of another conceived of as apart from Him and of one of us. But if thou remove the Life-giving Word of God from the Mystical and true Union with His Body and sever them utterly, how canst thou shew that it is still Life-giving? And Who was it who said, He that eateth My Flesh and drinketh My Blood, abideth in Me and I in him? If then it be a man by himself and the Word of God have not rather been made as we, the deed were cannibalism and wholly unprofitable the participation (for I hear Christ Himself say, The flesh profiteth nothing, it is the Spirit that quickeneth, for as far as pertains to its own nature, the flesh is corruptible, and will in no wise quicken others, sick itself of the decay that is its own): but if thou say that it is the Own Body of the Word Himself, why dost thou speak portentously and utter vain things, contending that not the very Word out of God the Father has been sent, but some other than of Him, "the visible," or His Flesh, albeit the God-inspired Scripture every where proclaimeth One Christ, full well affirming that the Word was made Man as we and defining herein the tradition of the right Faith.11

But out of excessive reverence, he apparently recoils at the measures of emptiness and cannot endure to see the Son co-eternal with God the Father—Him who exists in the form and equality in everything with the One who begat Him—come down to lowliness. He finds fault with the economy and perhaps does not leave the divine counsel and plan unblamable. For he pretends to investigate the force of the things said by Christ, and claims to grasp the depth of the ideas. Then, trying to twist my words (as he thinks) into a seeming absurdity and ignorance, he says: "Let us see who is misinterpreting. 'As the living Father sent Me, for I live'—according to him, God the Word lives because of the Father—'and he that eats Me shall also live.' Which do we eat, the Godhead or the flesh?" Don't you see at last how confused your mind has become? For when the Word of God says that He is sent, He also says, "He that eats Me shall also live." But we eat—not consuming the Godhead (away with such folly!)—but the very flesh of the Word, which has been made life-giving because it has been made the possession of Him who lives because of the Father. And we do not say that the Word is quickened by the Father through some participation from outside and coming from elsewhere; rather, we maintain that He is Life by physis, for He has been begotten out of the Father who is Life. For just as the sun's brightness that is sent forth, though it may be said (for example) to be bright because of the sender or because of that from which it comes, yet does not have its brightness by participation but wears the excellence of him who sent it or flashed it forth as a natural nobility—in the same way and manner, I believe, even though the Son says that He lives because of the Father, He will bear witness to His own noble birth from the Father, and will not confess promiscuously with the rest of creation that He has life imparted and from outside.12

But out of overmuch reverence, he blushes (it appears) at the measures of emptiness and endures not to see the Son Co-Eternal with God the Father, Him who is in the Form and Equality in everything with Him Who begat Him, come down unto lowliness: he finds fault with the economy and haply leaves not unblamed the Divine Counsel and Plan. For he pretends to investigate the force of the things said by Christ, and as it were taking in the depth of the ideas; then bringing round (as he thinks) my words to a seeming absurdity and ignorance; "Let us see, he says, who it is that mis-interprets. As the Living Father sent Me, for I live (according to him) God the "Word, because of the Father, and he that eateth Me he too shall live: which do we eat, the Godhead or the flesh?" Perceivest thou not therefore at length how thy mind is gone? for the Word of God saying that He is sent, says, he also that eateth Me, he too shall live. But WE eat, not consuming the Godhead (away with the folly) but the Very Flesh of the Word Which has been made Lifergiving, because it has been made His Who liveth because of the Father. And we do not say that by a participation from without and adventitious is the Word quickened by the Father, but rather we maintain that He is Life by Nature, for He has been begotten out of the Father who is Life. For as the sun's brightness which is sent forth, though it be said (for example) to be bright because of the sender, or of that out of which it comes, yet not of participation hath it the being bright, but as of natural nobility it weareth the Excellence of him who sent it or flashed it forth: in the same way and manner, I deem, even though the Son say that He lives because of the Father, will He bear witness to Himself His own Noble Birth from forth the Father, and not with the rest of the creation promiscuously, confess that He has Life imparted and from without.12

Since the Body of the Word Himself is life-giving—He having made it His own through a true union that surpasses understanding and language—we too who partake of His holy Flesh and Blood are quickened in all respects and wholly, with the Word dwelling in us divinely through the Holy Spirit, and humanly again through His holy Flesh and precious Blood. The most holy Paul will confirm the truth of what I said, writing to those believers in Corinth in our Lord Jesus Christ: "I speak as to wise men; judge what I say. The cup of blessing which we bless, is it not the communion of the Blood of Christ? The bread which we break, is it not the communion of the Body of Christ? For we, who are many, are one bread and one body, for we all partake of the one bread." For having partaken of the Holy Spirit, we are made one both with Christ Himself, the Savior of all, and with one another. We are of the same body in this way: though we are many, we are one bread and one body, for we all partake of the one bread. The Body of Christ which is in us binds us together into unity and is in no way divided. But that through the Body of Christ we have been brought together into unity with Him and with one another, the blessed Paul will confirm, writing: "For this reason I, Paul, the prisoner of Jesus Christ on behalf of you Gentiles—if you have heard of the economy of the grace of God which was given to me for you, how He made known to me by revelation the mystery, as I wrote before in few words, by which when you read you may understand my knowledge in the mystery of Christ, which in other ages was not made known to the sons of men as it has now been revealed to His holy apostles and prophets in the Spirit: that the Gentiles should be fellow heirs and of the same body and co-participants in the promise in Christ."

And as the Body of the Word Himself is Life-giving, He having made it His own by a true union passing understanding and language; so WE too who partake of His holy Flesh and Blood, are quickened in all respects and wholly, the Word dwelling in us Divinely through the Holy Ghost, humanly again through His Holy Flesh and Precious Blood. The most holy Paul will confirm the truth of what I said, writing thus to those in Corinth who believed in our Lord Jesus Christ, I speak as to wise men, judge YE what I say, the Cup of Blessing which we bless is it not the communion of the Blood of Christ? the Bread which we break is it not the communion of the Body of Christ? for one bread one body are we who are many, for we all are partakers of One Bread. For having partaken of the Holy Ghost, we are made one both with Christ Himself the Saviour of all and with one another: we are of the same body in this way, that we being many are one bread one body, for we all are partakers of the One Bread. For the Body of Christ which is in us binds us together into unity and is in no way divided. But that through the Body of Christ wo have been brought together into unity with Him and with one another, the blessed Paul will confirm, writing, For this cause I Paul the Prisoner of Jesus Christ in behalf of you Gentiles, if ye heard of the economy of the grace of God which was given me to you-ward, how that by revelation He made known unto me the mystery, as I wrote afore in few words, whereby when ye read, ye may understand my knowledge in the mystery of Christ which in other ages was not made known to the sons of men as now it is revealed unto His holy Apostles and prophets in the Spirit, that the Gentiles should be fellow-heirs and of the same body and co-participant in the promise in Christ.

Some believers, though they initially had faith, were ignorant of the tradition and meaning of the Mystery. They were pleased to turn away from what was right by celebrating banquets and public feasts in the churches. The blessed Paul criticized those who did this, writing: "Do you not have houses to eat and drink in? Or do you despise the Church of God and shame those who have nothing? What shall I say to you? Shall I praise you in this? I do not praise you. For I received from the Lord what I also delivered to you: that the Lord Jesus Christ, on the night when He was betrayed, took bread and gave thanks and broke it and said, 'This is My Body given for you; do this in remembrance of Me.' Likewise also the Cup after supper, saying, 'This Cup is the New Testament in My Blood; do this, as often as you drink it, in remembrance of Me. For as often as you eat this bread and drink this cup, you are proclaiming the Lord's death until He comes.'"

But since some of those who at first believed, ignorant of the tradition and force of the Mystery were pleased to be borne aside from what was right, celebrating in the churches banquetings and public feastings, the blessed Paul found fault with those who used so to do, writing, For have ye not houses to eat and to drink in? or despise ye the Church of God and shame them that have not? what shall I say to you? shall I praise you in this? I praise you not; for I received of the Lord what I also delivered to you, that the Lord Jesus Christ in the night in which He was delivered up, took bread and gave thanks and brake and said, This is My Body given for you, this do in remembrance of Me. Likewise the Cup too after supper saying, This Cup is the New Testament in My Blood, do this as oft as ye drink it in remembrance of Me: for as oft as ye eat this bread and drink this cup, ye are declaring the Lord's death, till He come.

It is easy to see that the Mystery is divine, that participation in it is life-giving, and that the power of this unbloody sacrifice is far superior to the worship under the Law. We can see this from the fact that what was ordained through Moses to the people of old was a shadow, while Christ and what belongs to Him is the truth. The most wise Paul supports this when he writes: "One who despised Moses' Law died without mercy under two or three witnesses. Of how much worse punishment do you suppose he will be thought worthy who has trampled underfoot the Son of God, counted as common the Blood of the covenant by which he was sanctified, and insulted the Spirit of grace?" Those who sacrificed the lamb in ancient times ate from it, but the purpose of eating it was not simply to satisfy their hunger, nor were the sacrifices under the Law performed for that reason. Rather, when death fell upon the rest, those who ate the lamb were able to avoid suffering death and to escape the destroyer. Indeed, in one night the firstborn of the Egyptians were destroyed, but those who were protected by this mere type alone were saved by it. Having the shadow as their shield, they gloriously prevailed even over death itself. If the types saved those who came before us, what about our situation—we upon whom the Truth itself, that is Christ, has finally shone, who sets before us His own life-giving Flesh to partake of? Is this not clear to everyone? Our situation is exceedingly and vastly superior. Our Lord Jesus Christ makes clear the power of the Mystery when He says: "Truly I say to you, he who believes in Me has everlasting life. I am the Bread of Life. Your fathers ate the manna in the wilderness and died. This is the Bread which comes down from Heaven so that a man may eat of it and not die. I am the Living Bread which came down from Heaven. If anyone eats of this Bread, he will live forever, and the Bread which I will give is My Flesh, which is for the life of the world." The people of Israel had marveled at Moses for the gift of manna sent down to those in the desert at that time. This manna provides a type of the Mystic Eucharist, since the Law is a shadow. Therefore, with great skill our Lord Jesus Christ diminishes the type, driving them from it to the truth. He says that the manna was not the Bread of Life, but rather He Himself is—He who is from Heaven, who gives life to all things, and who infuses Himself into those who eat Him through His Flesh which is united to Him. He made this even clearer when He said: "Truly I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink His Blood, you have no life in you. He who eats My Flesh and drinks My Blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day. For My Flesh is true food and My Blood is true drink. He who eats My Flesh and drinks My Blood abides in Me and I in him. As the Living Father sent Me and I live because of the Father, so also he who eats Me will live because of Me." Consider, then, how He abides in us and makes us superior to corruption by infusing Himself into our bodies, as I said, through His own Flesh, which is true food, whereas the shadow in the Law and the worship under it do not possess the truth.

And that the Mystery is Divine and the participation Life-giving and the might of this unbloody Sacrifice far better than the worship under the Law, is easy to see even from his saying that the things ordained through Moses to them of old time were a shadow, but Christ and what is His the truth. The most wise Paul too will help us herein, thus writing, One that despised Moses' Law died without mercy under two or three witnesses, of how much sorer punishment, suppose ye, shall he be thought worthy who trod under foot the Son of God and accounted common the Blood of the covenant wherein he was sanctified, and did despite unto the Spirit of grace? For they that of old did sacrifice the lamb ate thereof, but the force of the eating amounted not simply to the satisfying of the belly, nor was it for this that the sacrifices were performed under the Law: but that when death fell on the rest, they might be superior to its suffering and might escape the destroyer. And verily in one night were the first-born of the Egyptians destroyed, but these fenced by the bare type, alone were saved by it, and having the shadow for their shield, prevailed gloriously over death itself too. The types then saved those before us; in what condition are our matters, on whom at length beamed the Truth itself, that is, Christ, Who setteth before us His own Life-giving Flesh to partake of? is it not clear to all? For very exceedingly better and in vast superiority are they. And the might of the Mystery our Lord Jesus Christ making manifest saith, Verily I say to you, he that helieveth on Me hath everlasting life, I am the Bread of Life: your fathers ate the manna in the wilderness and died, this is the Bread which cometh down from Heaven that a man may eat thereof and not die, I am the Living Bread Which came down from Heaven, if any man eat of this Bread he shall live for ever and the Bread Which I w ill give is My Flesh Which is for the Life of the world. For since they of the blood of Israel had marvelled at Moses for the largess of manna sent down to those of that time in the desert, which fills up a type of the Mystic Eucharist (for the Law is a shadow), therefore with exceeding skill doth our Lord Jesus Christ minish the type, driving them [from it] unto the truth. For not that (He says) was the Bread of Life, but rather, I Who am out of Heaven and Who quicken all things and infuse Myself into them that eat Me, through My Flesh too that is united to Me. Which indeed He made clearer saying, Verily I say unto you, Except ye eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink His Blood, ye have not Life in you: he that eateth My Flesh and drinketh My Blood hath eternal Life and I will raise him up at the last day, for My Flesh is true meat and My Blood is true drink; he that eateth My Flesh and drinketh My Blood abideth in Me and I in him. As the Living Father sent Me and I live because of the Father, he also that eateth Me, he too shall live. Consider then how He abideth in us and maketh us superior to corruption, infusing Himself into our bodies, as I said, through His own Flesh too, which is true meat, whereas the shadow in the Law and the worship under it possess not the truth.

The plan of the Mystery is simple and true, not overburdened with complicated schemes of imagination that lead to ungodliness, but simple as I said. For we believe that the Word from God the Father united Himself to the body born through the holy Virgin, which had a rational soul (the union is unspeakable and wholly a Mystery!), and made it Life-giving, since He is by physis Life as God. In this way, by making us partakers of Himself both spiritually and bodily, He might make us superior to decay and through Himself abolish the law of sin which is in the members of the flesh, and condemn sin in the flesh, as it is written. But this does not at all please (I think) this teacher of new doctrines, who like a wandering calf runs after only what pleases himself and diminishes the power of the mystery by saying,

And the plan of the Mystery is simple and true, not overwrought with varied devices of imaginations unto unholiness but simple as I said. For we believe that to the body born through the holy Virgin, having a reasonable soul, the Word out of God the Father having united Himself (unspeakable is the union, and wholly a Mystery!) rendered it Life-giving, being as God Life by Nature, that making us partakers of Himself spiritually alike and bodily, He might both make us superior to decay and might through Himself bring to nought the law of sin which is in the members of the flesh, might condemn sin in the flesh, as it is written. But this no wise (I deem) pleases this dogmatist of new inventions, who like some straying calf runs after only what pleases himself: and minishes the force of the mystery saying,

§6

Nestorius: "Notice that the word 'Lord' is sometimes used of Christ's human nature, sometimes of His Godhead, and sometimes of both. 'As often as you eat this Bread and drink this Cup, you proclaim the Lord's Death.' Learn from what precedes how to correct those who oppose us—how they should understand the great benefit of the mystery and whose memorial it conveys to people. Do not listen to me saying these things, but to the blessed Paul: 'As often as you eat this bread.' He did not say, 'As often as you eat this Godhead.' 'As often as you eat this bread.' See what stands before us concerning the Lord's Body. 'As often as you eat this Bread,' of which the Body is the antitype. Let us therefore see whose Death it is. 'As often as you eat this bread and drink this Cup, you proclaim the Lord's Death.' Listen even more plainly to what follows: 'Till He come.' Who is it that is coming? 'They will see the Son of Man coming in the clouds of heaven with great glory.' And even more clearly, the Prophet before the Apostles revealed more plainly the One who is coming and cried out proclaiming concerning the Jews, 'They will look on Him Whom they pierced.' Who then is the one who was pierced? The Side. Does the Side belong to the body or the Godhead?"

Nestorius: "Hear the word Lord too, sometimes put of the human nature of Christ, sometimes of His Godhead, sometimes of both. As oft as ye eat this Bread and drink this Cup, ye declare the Lord's Death. Hear from the foregoing the unlearning of the gainsayers, how they read the mighty profit of the mystery, and whose memorial it imparts to men, and hear not me saying these things, but the blessed Paul, As oft as ye cat this bread, he said not, As oft as ye eat this Godhead. As oft as ye eat this bread. See what is before us concerning the Lord's Body. As oft as ye eat this Bread, whereof the Body is the antitype. Let us see therefore whose is the Death. As oft as ye eat this bread and drink this Cup, ye declare the Lord's Death. Hear yet plainer in what follows, Till He come, who is it Who is coming? They shall see the Son of Man coming in the clouds of heaven with great glory. And greater still, the Prophet before the Apostles did more clearly shew Him Who is coming and hath cried aloud proclaiming of the Jews, They shall look on Him Whom they pierced. Who then is he that was pierced? the Side: belongs the Side to the body, or the Godhead?"

Again we must speak on behalf of the doctrines of the Truth and oppose your words, sir, and before all else we must say this to those who will hear: Your aim is, with all diligence, to present two christs to whom the title of lordship might separately belong, but it shall be shown by us, without any great effort, that you arrive at this in a most unlearned manner. For come, tell me who asks you: which Christ are you defining when you say that both the manhood and likewise the Godhead belong to him? If you mean the Word from God the Father, you have clearly confessed that the Same is also man, for you said that the human nature is His. But if you mean him who is born of the Virgin according to your understanding, you will be caught no less pronouncing that He is God too, for you said that the Godhead is also His. Therefore, driven on all sides even against your will to the Truth, confess with us One Christ and Lord. For in this way you will stop saying, "Hear the word Lord too, sometimes applied to the human nature of Christ, sometimes to His Godhead, and other times to both"—for where there is One Son, what room is there to speak of both? And why do you mock those who honor our Divine Mystery, saying most unholily, "As often as you eat this bread and drink the cup, you declare the Lord's death"? Hear from what has been said the ignorance of those who oppose, how they reckon the mighty benefit of the mystery and whose memorial is set before men.

Again must we speak for the doctrines of the Truth, and oppose, sir, thy words, and before all else must say this to those who will hear: Thy aim is and with all diligence to represent two christs, to whom severally may belong the title of lordship, but it shall be shewn by us, without any great toil, that you go to this in most unlearned wise. For come tell me who ask thee, what Christ you are defining, whose you say is both the manhood and likewise the Godhead: if the Word out of God the Father, you have clearly confessed that the Same is man also, for you said that His is the human nature: but if him that is born of the Virgin according to thee, you will be caught no less pronouncing that He is God too: for you said that His is the Godhead also. On all sides therefore driven even against thy will to the Truth, confess with us One Christ and Lord: for thus will you cease from saying, "Hear the word Lord too, one while put of the human nature of Christ, one while of His Godhead, other while, of both:" for where there is One Son, what room is there to speak of both? and why dost thou smile at those who honour our Divine Mystery, saying most unholily, " As oft as ye eat this bread and drink the cup, ye declare the Lord's death? Hear from the foregoing the unlearning of the gainsayers, how they read the mighty profit of the mystery and Whoso memorial is set before men."

There is therefore nothing excellent in the unbloody sacrifice, but it profits very little, and he will place the force of its benefit in merely declaring a man's death and making a memorial of one like us. Therefore He lies in saying that He is Life-giving, He Who does not know how to lie, Christ: We too have been deceived, holding a vain opinion of Him, and only now late and with difficulty are we being guided to the discovery of the truth by reading these words of yours. But to you who choose to think in this way, what is spoken through the Prophet's voice shall be said: Behold, your eyes are not good, nor is your heart. For he does not understand at all that we, setting forth the Death of Christ and also confessing His Resurrection, and thereby gaining perfection in the faith, then becoming partakers of His Divine Nature through participating in unity with Him, are sanctified both spiritually and bodily and are made alive. For this corruptible must put on incorruption and this mortal put on immortality, and Christ has become for us the robe that is from Heaven, undecaying and productive of immortality. And our proof is the most holy Paul writing, at one time, Put on the Lord Jesus Christ, and at another, For as many of you as were baptized into Christ put on Christ, Who says in a manner befitting God and truly, I am the Resurrection and the Life.

There is therefore nothing excellent in the unbloody sacrifice, but it profits exceeding little, and he will put the force of the gain thereof in just merely declaring a man's death and making a memorial of one like us. Therefore He lies in saying that He is Life-giving Who knows not how to lie, Christ: "WE too have been cozened having a vain opinion of Him: and now late and with difficulty are we being guided unto the finding of the truth, by reading these thy words. But to you who choose to think thus, shall be said what is spoken through the Prophet's voice, Lo thine eyes are not, nor thine heart comely. For he by no means understandeth, that we setting forth the Death of Christ, confessing too His Resurrection, and gaining thereby perfection in the faith, then becoming partakers of His Divine Nature and that through participating of unity with Him, are sanctified spiritually alike and bodily and are quickened. For this corruptible must put on incorruption and this mortal put on immortality: and the robe that is out of Heaven and undecaying and productive of immortality hath Christ become to us. And our proof is the most holy Paul writing, one while, Put ye on our Lord Jesus Christ, at another again, For as many of you as were baptized into Christ put on Christ, Who saith in God-befitting way and truly, I am the Resurrection and the Life.

He adds even fouler impiety to these things without any fear, saying: "Don't listen to me saying these things, but listen to blessed Paul: 'As often as you eat this bread, of which the Body is the antitype.' Let us see from this whose death it is. 'As often as you eat this bread and drink this cup, you proclaim the Lord's death.' Listen even more plainly to what follows: 'Until He comes.' Who then is the one who is to come? 'They will see the Son of Man coming in the clouds of heaven with great glory.' And even greater, the Prophet before the Apostles showed more clearly the One who is coming and cried out proclaiming concerning the Jews: 'They will look on Him whom they pierced.' Who then is He who was pierced? Does the side belong to the Body or to the Godhead?" Therefore, as I said, the profit of the Unbloody Sacrifice is petty, because perhaps it has not been feasible that the physis of the Godhead should also be consumed along with the Flesh, since we do not possess impossibilities and cannot eat the Incorporeal by Itself. But you seem to me to forget that it is by no means the physis of Godhead that lies upon the holy Tables of the Churches; yet it is the own Body of the Word Begotten of God the Father, and the Word is God by physis and in truth. Why then do you confound all things and jumble them without understanding, all but mocking at our Bread which is out of Heaven and gives Life to the world, because it is not called Godhead by the voice of theologians but is rather called the Body of Him who has become Man for us—that is, of the Word out of God the Father? And why, tell me, do you call it the Lord's Body at all, unless you know it to be Divine and God's? For all things serve their Maker.

To those things does he fearing nought put forth yet fouler impiety, adding, "Hear not me saying these things but the blessed Paul, As oft as ye do eat this bread, whereof the Body is the antitype. Let us see therefore herefrom whose is the death. As oft as ye eat this bread, and drink this Cup, ye declare the Lord's death. Hear yet plainer in what follows, Till He come: who then is he that is to come? They shall see the son of man coming in the clouds of heaven with great glory. And greater yet, the Prophet before the Apostles did more clearly shew Him Who is coming and hath cried proclaiming concerning the Jews, They shall look on Him whom they pierced. Who then is He which was pierced? The Side, belongs the Side to the Body, or to the Godhead?" Petty therefore as I said, is the profit of the Unbloody Sacrifice, because perchance it hath not been, feasible that the Nature of the Godhead too should be consumed along with the Flesh, because we are not in possession of impossibilities, having the Incorporeal by Itself to eat. But you seem to me to forget that it is by no means the Nature of Godhead that lieth upon the holy Tables of the Churches, yet is it the own Body of the Word Begotten of God the Father: and God by Nature and in truth is the Word. Why therefore dost thou confound all things and jumble them without understanding, all but mocking at our Bread Which is out of Heaven and giveth Life to the world, because it is not called Godhead by the voice of the Divines, but rather the Body of Him Who hath become Man for us, that is, of the Word out of God the Father? And why (tell me) dost thou call it the Lord's Body at all, save because thou knowest it to be Divine and God's? for all things serve their Maker.

Your thoughts are not correct; instead, you believe that Emmanuel is merely a God-bearing man. And then, showing complete disregard for thoughts and words that belong to true piety, you assume that the Priest of Truth, the wise master-builder and teacher of the Gentiles, the truly holy and all-wise Paul, will support you in your false accusations by twisting the meaning of what he rightly and purely stated away from the straight and most reliable path.

Yea the things in thy mind are not right, but thou believest Emmanuel to be merely a God-clad man. And then utterly heedless of thoughts and words that belong to piety, thou supposest that the Priest of the Truth, the wise master-builder and teacher of the Gentiles, the truly holy and all-wise Paul will support thee in thy calumniating, bearing away from the straight and most approved path the force of what are rightly and without adulteration said by him.

For "let us see," he says, "whose is the death from this point. Till He come. Who is He Who is coming? They shall look on Him Whom they pierced." Therefore He will come Who suffered death humanly, has been raised divinely, Who also ascended into the Heavens, Who with all majesty is on the Throne of the Ineffable Godhead and sits together with the Father, the Seraphim standing around, and the Highest Powers, not ignorant of the extent of their subjection to Him. Every Authority and Power and Lordship worships Him, for to Him shall every knee bow and every tongue confess, "Lord Jesus," to the glory of God the Father. He shall come (as I said) seen not in our lowliness, but rather in most God-befitting glory, Heaven and the Spirits above surrounding Him as their God and King and standing by the Lord of all. If therefore the Word of God the Father is not rather in flesh, or made Man, but is a God-clad man with a bodily side who endured the piercing, how is He seen on the Throne of the Supreme Godhead, revealed to us as a new god, fourth after the Holy Trinity? Have you not shuddered at presenting a mere man for worship of the creature? Are we then held in the ancient snares? Have we then insulted God and has the holy multitude of the spirits above gone astray with us? If we have been set free from the ancient deceit, refusing as blasphemous to worship the creature, why do you, casting us again into the old charges, present us as man-worshippers? For we know and believe that the Word from God the Father assumed flesh and blood. But since He has remained the Same, that is, God, He retained the Dignity of His inherent Excellence over all, even though in flesh as we are, yet being no less God now than before, even though He has been made Man. He has Heaven as His worshipper and the earth worshipping Him, for it is written, "The earth is full of Your praise, Your Power covered the Heavens, O Lord."13

For "let us see (he says) herefrom whose is the death. Till He come. Who is He Who is coming? they shall look on Him Whom they pierced. " He will come therefore Who suffered death humanly, has been raised Divinely, Who ascended too into the Heavens, Who with all state is on the Throne of the Ineffable Godhead and co-sitteth with the Father, the Seraphim standing around, and the Highest Powers, not unknowing of the measure of their subjection to Him; every Authority and Power and Lordship worshipping Him: for to Him shall bend every knee and every tongue shall confess, Lord Jesus, to the glory of God the Father. He shall come (as I said) seen not in our littleness, but rather in most God-befitting glory. Heaven and the Spirits above encompassing Him as their God and King and standing by the Lord of all. If therefore the Word of God the Father be not rather in flesh, or made Man, but a God-clad man with bodily side and who endured the piercing, how is He seen on the Throne of the Supreme Godhead, revealed to us as a new god fourth after the Holy Trinity? hast thou not shuddered at a mere man, devising worship for the creature? are we then holden in the ancient snares? have we then done insult to God and has the holy multitude of the spirits above gone astray with us? if we have been set free from the ancient deceit, refusing as blasphemous to worship the creature, why dost thou casting us again into the old charges, exhibit us man-worshippers? for WE know and believe that the Word out of God the Father assumed flesh and blood: but since He hath remained the Same, i.e., God, He retained the Dignity of His inherent Excellence over all, albeit in flesh as we, yet being no less God, now too than of old, even though He have been made Man, He hath the Heaven His adorer and the earth worshipping Him: for it is written, that the earth is full of Thy praise, Thy Virtue covered the Heavens, O Lord.13

But you, in your extreme foolishness, do not see that He is this way in Nature and Glory. You said, "Who is he who comes? They will see the Son of man coming in the clouds of heaven," as if you were afraid people might not believe you when you say that the one who comes is son of man. You confirm your proof with prophetic testimony as well, saying that it is written, "They will look on Him whom they pierced." And thinking it would be even stronger proof, you most foolishly added, "Who then is the one who is pierced? The Side—does the Side belong to body or to Godhead?" If there were people who claimed that the Word of God did not become like us but came among those on earth in bare Godhead alone—that is, in appearance and as if in shadow, as some of the unholy heretics chose to think—you would have some excuse for framing your words this way, though still not staying within proper bounds. But since the preaching of the truth says clearly and plainly that the Word of God was made Flesh and was called son of man like us, and suffered for us in the flesh, and will also come in the same way He ascended into Heaven according to the Angel's voice too—then tell me, whom are you opposing? Whose teaching are you cutting down as ignorant and worthless when you try to show us that the One who comes is a man with a bodily side that was pierced through with the spear?

But THOU again, of thy over much infatuation, seest not that thus He is in Nature and Glory: for thou saidst, "Who is he who cometh? they shall see the Son of man coming in the clouds of heaven," as though thou fearedst lest any should disbelieve thee saying that He Which cometh is son of man. Thou confirmest the proof thereof with prophetic testimony also: for thou sayest that it is written, They shall look on Him Whom they pierced. And yet mightier for proof as thou supposedst, most foolishly adding, "Who then is it (he says) that is pierced? the Side: belongs the Side to body or to the Godhead?" If there were any who say that the Word of God have not been made as we, but came among those on earth in bare Godhead, i.e., in semblance and as it were in shadow, as some of the unholy heretics thought good to think, you would have had some plea for such like framing of words; not passing the bound of what was meet: but since the preaching of the truth says clearly and manifestly that the Word of God was made Flesh and was called as we son of man too and suffered for us in the flesh and will also so come as He went up into Heaven, according to the Angel's voice too: whom (tell me) dost thou opposing, and whose opinion cutting off as unlearned and of no account, dost thou strive to shew us that HE Who cometh is a man with bodily side which has been pierced through with the spear?

But your goal (as I said) is to smuggle in to us Emmanuel as a God-clad man and not rather God made Man, for the Word of God has been made Man. And this faith agrees with the holy and Divine Scriptures, and the intent of the Apostolic and Evangelic Tradition points to this same thing. But YOU are also talking arrogantly in another way: for you pretend to be finding fault with those who blend into one ousia the physis of the flesh and of the Godhead (although there is no one as I believe who blends them together or mixes them with one another), and you say,

But thine aim (as I said) is to bring in privily to us Emmanuel as a God-clad man and not rather God made Man, for the Word of God has been made Man. And this faith goes along with the holy and Divine Scriptures and the aim of the Apostolic and Evangelic Tradition tends to this same thing. But THOU again art talking big in another way too: for thou pretendest to be finding fault with those who mingle into one essence, the nature of the flesh and of the Godhead (albeit there is no one as I deem who mingles them up or mixes them one with other), and sayest,

§7

Nestorius: "Why, as we were just now hearing, when both are mingled together according to you, does our Lord, as He gives the disciples the power of the Mystery, say this: He took bread and gave thanks and gave it to His disciples saying, 'Take, eat, all of you, for this is My Body'? Why did He not say, 'This is My Godhead which is being broken for you'? And again, when giving the cup of the Mysteries, He did not say, 'This is My Godhead which is being poured out for you,' but rather, 'This is My Blood which is being shed for you for the remission of sins.'"14

Nestorius: "Why, as we were just now hearing, when both are according to thee mingled, does our Lord, delivering to the disciples the force of the Mystery, thus say, He took bread and gave thanks and gave to His disciples saying, Take, eat all of you for this is My Body. Why said He not, This is My Godhead Which is being broken for you? and again giving the cup of the Mysteries, He said not, This is My Godhead Which is being poured forth for you, but This is My Blood which is being shed for you for the remission of sins. "14

It is therefore utterly foolish to want to oppose positions that no one actually holds, and pointless to rush forward claiming to refute what nobody (I suppose) has bothered to think or say—how is this not obvious to everyone? For if someone chose to argue that an ox is not by physis a horse, nor is a man a horse, when no one would even consider thinking or saying such a thing, wouldn't he be laughed at as someone who talks in vain, beating the air and fighting against uncertain things, creating pointless effort and struggle against something that doesn't exist? For I am saying that what is actually confessed must first be established, so that then our own arguments can be properly set against it in due order.

That it is therefore an exceeding folly to want to oppose oneself to those who are not at all, and to no purpose to march forth, taking for contradiction that which no one (I suppose) cared either to think or say, how is it not manifest to all? for if one chose to contend that the ox is not by nature an horse, nor yet man an horse, whereas no one would even endure to think or say this;—-how would he not be laughed at and besides a vain talker, beating the air and fighting against things uncertain and devising for himself sweat and toil against what was not there? For I say that something confessed ought first to be laid down, in order that then in duo order ours may be ranged against it.

But let us consider this: if anyone should dare to say that the Word from God had been transformed into the physis of the body, one might very reasonably object to him that He, when giving His Body, did not rather say, "Take, eat, this is My Godhead which is being broken for you," and "this is not My Blood but rather My Godhead which is being poured forth for you." But since the Word, being God, made His own the Body born of a woman without undergoing any alteration or turning, how must not He who speaks no untruth say, "Take, eat, this is My Body"? For being Life as God, He made it Life and Life-giving.

But let us come to this: for if there be any who should dare to say the Word out of God had been transformed into the nature of the body, one might very reasonably object to him, that He on giving His Body did not rather say, Take eat this is My Godhead which is being broken for you, and, this is not My Blood but rather My Godhead which is being poured forth for you. But since the Word being God made His own the Body born of a woman, without undergoing any alteration or turning, how must not He who saith no untruth say, Take eat this is My Body? for being Life as God, He rendered it Life and Life-giving.

Having opened your eyes even a little to the Truth, I suppose you will now accuse yourself of your own excessive talking, which on all sides stammers and ignorantly directs this false and joyless argument of yours against the doctrines of piety.

Having therefore opened your eyes but a little to the Truth, you will I suppose charge, yourself against yourself, your superfluity of language, on all sides stuttering and unlearnedly arraying against the Doctrines of piety this thy counterfeit and joyless discourse.


Five Tomes Against Nestorius — Book III

The Word made flesh is worshipped by angels, yet as man worships with us and is our High Priest: sent by the Father, He makes us His brothers.

Ps. xviii. 11 hints at the depth of Christ's mystery. Gifts through Incarnation. Is, xlv. 14, 15 the Incarnate Son. S. John i. 14. 2 Sam. vii. 12-14 explained by S. Paul. 1 Sam. ii. 35. The WORD Incarnate worshipped by Angels worships with us and is our High Priest. GOD the WORD sent and how: so our High Priest. Sent and High Priest when Incarnate., Possessor of Godhead, a misnomer. Heb. v. 1. He makes us His brothers. 'Yesterday to-day and for ever.' S. John i. 30: iii. 13: Micah v. 2, Is. liii. 8. Gen. xxxii. 24 sqq. High Priesthood belongs to Incarnation. 'Sent' of God is a human word and to be understood worthily of God. The Son Incarnate gives the Holy Ghost as God, receives as man. High priesthood. Growth "in wisdom and stature and favour." Union alone permits to attribute to One the properties of either manhood or Godhead. The Paschal Lamb and the sacrifice for sin of a young bullock types of the sinlessness of our Sacrifice.

Source: Cyril of Alexandria, Five Tomes Against Nestorius (1881) Book 3. pp.81-….. Transcribed by Roger Pearse (tertullian.org); public domain.

Contents · 7 chapters
  1. Opening
  2. §1
  3. §2
  4. §3
  5. §4
  6. §5
  7. §6

Opening

Great indeed is the mystery of godliness, marveled at by the holy angels themselves, and the most wise Paul confirms this for us when he says, "To the intent that now unto the principalities and powers in heavenly places might be known through the Church the manifold wisdom of God according to the eternal purpose which He purposed in our Lord Jesus Christ, in Whom we have boldness and access with confidence through faith." For the Mystery of Christ is truly wisdom—not human wisdom (how could it be?), but rather divine wisdom, stored in certain ineffable depths and incomprehensibilities. And the blessed David sings, "And He made darkness His secret place, around Him His pavilion dark water in clouds of the skies," calling darkness, I suppose, nothing other than the altogether dim conception of ideas that falls like mist upon the eyes of the understanding.

Great confessedly is the mystery of godliness, and marvelled at by the holy Angels themselves also, and hereto the most wise Paul confirms us saying, To the intent that now unto the principalities and powers in heavenly places might be known through the Church the manifold wisdom of God according to the eternal purpose which He purposed in our Lord Jesus Christ, in Whom we have boldness and access with confidence through faith. For wisdom verily, and that not human (how could it?) but Divine rather and deposited in certain ineffable depths and incomprehensibilities, is the Mystery of Christ. And the blessed David singeth, And He made darkness His secret place, around Him His pavilion dark water in clouds of the skies, palling darkness (I suppose) nought else save altogether the dim conception of ideas, falling like mist upon the eyes of the understanding.

We say, therefore, that the mystery of Christ has not at all required subtle investigations and searching beyond the reach of the mind, but rather faith that holds the tradition in a simple and sincere way. We ourselves have been taught and have believed that God the Father sent His own Son, who is God by physis, made man and born of a woman according to the flesh, so that He might justify those who believe in Him. Having freed them from stumbling through ignorance by His good and most gentle authority, He might present them clean and undefiled through Himself to God the Father, and might make those who are under death and decay partakers of His own divine physis. Indeed, He might preach recovery of sight to the blind, and might bring the flocks that had strayed into the light of the true knowledge of God, and might teach at last who it is who is truly and by physis God and the Creator of all. For He became the fragrance of the knowledge of God the Father, and in Him we have seen the One from whom He was begotten by physis, and we clearly know the way that leads us to everlasting life. The blessed prophet Isaiah cried out beforehand that the Son should shine upon the multitude of the Gentiles as well, saying, "Thus says the Lord, Egypt toiled and the merchandise of the Ethiopians, and the Sabeans, men of stature, shall pass over to You and they shall be Your servants, and they shall come after You bound in fetters: and they shall worship You, and in You shall they pray; for in You is God, and there is no God except You, for You are God and we knew it not, the God of Israel the Savior." And it is said somewhere to the Son, as from the person again of God the Father, "Behold, I have set You for a covenant of the race, for a light of the nations, that You may be for salvation to the end of the earth." For He established the new covenant for those of the blood and race of Israel, the first having grown old, and He shone as far as the boundaries of all that is under the sky also, to the nations and people in every place and city. For they have worshiped Him and they follow Him spiritually, held by the unbreakable chains of love, as in fetters, and nearly say what is in the prophet Jeremiah, "Behold, we will be Yours for You are the Lord our God." See, I ask, the keenness of the prophet's thoughts. "They shall worship You," he says, "and in You shall they pray, for in You is God, and there is no God besides You." Being clothed with the Spirit, he knew without question the Word from God the Father, who was to dwell in us, as the blessed evangelist John says. Therefore he says that God is in You. Yet he has not allowed Emmanuel to be separated into two gods, but even though the Only-Begotten was made man, he acknowledged Him even so as One and immediately added, "There is no God except You." For consider the prophet's utterance carefully. Having first declared, as I said, that God is in You, he has not added, "And there is no God except He who is in You," but gathering it into the unity of the economy (divine plan), says, "There is no God besides You."

We say therefore that the mystery of Christ hath by no means needed subtil investigations and search beyond the reach of mind, but faith rather that holds the tradition simple and guileless. Thus we ourselves also have been taught and believed that God the Father sent His own Son who is by Nature God, made Man and born of a woman after the flesh, that He might justify them that believe on Him and having freed from stumblings through ignorance, by His Good and most gentle authority, might present them clean and undefiled through Him to God the Father, and might make partakers of His own Divine Nature them who are under death and decay, yea and might preach recovery of sight to the blind, and might bring over the flocks which had strayed into the light of the true knowledge of God, and might teach at length who it is Who is by Nature and truly God and the Creator of all. For He became the savour of the knowledge of God the Father, and in Him we have beheld Him out of Whom He was begotten by Nature and know clearly the way that leadeth us unto everlasting life. That thus the Son should beam upon the crowd of the Gentiles too, hath the blessed Prophet Isaiah cried beforehand saying, Thus saith the Lord, Egypt toiled and the merchandise of the Ethiopians, and the Sabeans, men of stature, shall pass over unto Thee and they shall be Thy servants, and they shall come after Thee bound in fetters: and they shall worship Thee, and in Thee shall they pray; for in Thee is God, and there is no God save Thee, for THOU art God and we knew it not, the God of Israel the Saviour. And it is said somewhere to the Son, as from the Person again of God the Father, Lo, I have set Thee for a covenant of the race, for a light of the nations, that Thou mayest be for salvation unto the end of the earth. For He hath instituted to them of the blood and race of Israel, the new covenant, the first having waxen old, and He beamed as far as the boundaries of that beneath the sky also, to the nations and people in every place and city. For they have worshipped Him yea and they follow Him spiritually, holden by the indissoluble chains of love, as in fetters and well-nigh say what is in the Prophet Jeremiah, Behold WE will be Thine for THOU art the Lord our God. See (I pray) the vigilance of the Prophet's thoughts, They shall worship Thee (he says) and in Thee shall they pray, for in Thee is God, and there is no God beside Thee. He knew then confessedly as being Spirit-clad the Word Out of God the Father, Who should tabernacle in us, as saith the blessed Evangelist John: therefore he saith that God is in Thee; yet hath he not suffered Emmanuel to be Severed into two gods, but even though the Only-Begotten was made man, he acknowledged Him even so as One and straightway added, There is no God save Thee. For Consider accurately the Prophet's utterance. For having first declared (as I said) that God is in Thee, he hath not added, And there is no God save He that is in Thee, but gathering it into the Unity of the Economy, says There is no God beside Thee.

But that the only-begotten Word of God became man is declared to us by (so to speak) the whole God-inspired Scripture, and this is easy to show without effort by very many proofs. However, I think it is enough for now to say this. God said somewhere to blessed David, And I will raise up your offspring after you, who shall proceed from your body, and I will establish his kingdom. He shall build a house for my name and I will establish his throne forever, and I will be to him a Father and he shall be to me a Son. But someone (I suppose) will say that these things were spoken not of Emmanuel, but rather of Solomon. Yet the most wise Paul will strenuously oppose those who would understand it this way, for he takes the words of Christ and says that it is he to whom it has been said by God the Father, I will be to him a Father and he shall be to me a Son. But that when made like us—that is, man—he should offer to God the Father all under heaven who are saved through faith in him, he made known saying elsewhere, And I will raise up for myself a faithful priest who shall do all that is in my heart and in my soul, and I will build him a sure house and he shall walk before me forever. Observe (I ask) that having elsewhere said, He shall build a house for my name, the Father here promises to build the house for the Son. And the divine Paul, understanding this, said that Moses was faithful in all my house having the measure belonging to a servant, but Christ as a Son over his own house, whose house we are. And the manner of the ministry is things pertaining to us, not the blood of bulls and calves, but the confession of the faith of us all. And blessed Paul will again confirm it, writing thus: Therefore, holy brothers, partakers of the heavenly calling, consider the Apostle and High Priest of our confession, Jesus, who was faithful to him who appointed him. We say therefore that the Word from God the Father, when receiving the form of a servant and said to have been emptied for our sake, then also humbled himself to the measure of human nature, to which will belong (and very reasonably) both the appearance of being sent and the reckoning of the ministry as the sign of the very highest honor. For if when he became as we are, he worshiped with us as man, even though the host above and the holy spirits worship him, and Moses says of him, Rejoice, O heavens, with him and let all the sons of God worship him, what is there strange or what is inconvenient to the nature of the economy if he has been called High Priest as offering for us as a fragrance of a sweet smell himself and us through himself and in himself to God the Father? For we are a sweet fragrance of Christ, as it is written. But this noble person again affirms that these things have been done in no proper order, and all but smiles at those who conceive that these things were so, and impiously finding fault with the divine purposes, says thus:

But that the Only-Begotten Word of God made man, is declared to us by the (so to speak) whole God-inspired Scripture, is easy to shew without toil by very many proofs: but I think it is enough for the present to say this. God said somewhere to blessed David, And I will set up out of thy seed after thee Him who shall proceed out of thy bowels and I will prepare His Kingdom: He shall build an house for My Name and I will stablish His Throne for ever, and\ will be to Him a Father and He shall be to Me a Son. But some one (I suppose) will say that these things were said not of Emmanuel, but of Solomon rather: yet the most wise Paul will strenuously oppose those who would thus understand it, for he takes the words of Christ and says that it is He to Whom it has been said by God the Father, I will be to Him a Father and He shall be to Me a Son. But that when made like unto us, i. e., Man, He should offer to God the Father, all beneath the sky saved through faith in Him, He made known saying elsewhere, And I will raise Me up a faithful Priest who shall do all which is in Mine heart and in My soul, and I will build Him a sure house and He shall walk before Me for ever. Observe (I pray) that having elsewhere said, He shall build an house for My Name, the Father here promises to rear the house for the Son. And the Divine Paul understanding this, said that Moses was faithful in all My house having the measure pertaining to a servant, but Christ as a Son over His own house, Whose House are WE; and the mode of the ministry, things pertaining to us, not the blood of bulls and of calves, but the confession of the faith of us all. And blessed Paul will again certify it, writing thus, Wherefore holy brethren partakers of the heavenly calling, consider the Apostle and High Priest of our confession, Jesus, who was faithful to Him That appointed Him. We say therefore that the Word out of God the Father, when receiving servant's form He is said to have been emptied for our sake, then too did abase Himself in the measure of the human nature, whereto will pertain (and very reasonably) both the seeming to be sent and the accounting the ministry the token of the very highest honour. For if when He became as we, He have worshipped with us as Man, albeit the Host above and the holy spirits worship Him, and Moses says of Him, Re joice O ye heavens with Him and let all the sons of God worship Him; what is there strange or what inconvenient to the nature of the Economy if He have been called High Priest as offering for us for an odour of a sweet smell Himself and us through Himself and in Himself to God the Father? for we are a sweet savour of Christ, as it is written. But this noble person again affirms that these things have been wrought in no fit order, and all but smiles at those who conceive that these things were so, and impiously finding fault with the Divine purposes, says thus:

§1

When people hear the title Apostle, they think God the Word was an Apostle; when they read the title High Priest, they imagine—through a kind of absurd madness—that the Godhead was High Priest. For who, learning about the work of an Apostle, would not immediately recognize that a human being is meant? Who, hearing the title High Priest, would suppose that the ousia (essence) of the Godhead was High Priest? For if the Godhead is High Priest, who is the one served by the ministry of the High Priesthood? If God is the one who offers, there is no one to whom the offering is made, since there is nothing worthy of the Godhead to which it should offer as if to something greater. And to this he adds: "Why then do they suppose that God, who does not need sacrifices for his own advancement as the high priests do, has now been called High Priest? Is the possessor of Godhead taken from among human beings and ordained for human beings in matters relating to God?"

Nestorius: "For they hearing the name of Apostle, deem that God the Word was Apostle; reading the name High Priest, they fancy that the Godhead was High Priest, by a species of paradoxical craziness: for who learning of the ministry of an Apostle, would not forthwith know that a man is indicated? who on hearing the appellation of High Priest, would suppose that the Essence of Godhead were High Priest? for if the Godhead be High Priest, who is he who is served by the ministry of the High Priesthood? if God be the Offerer, there is none to whom offering is made: for what is there worthy of Godhead that as less It should offer to the greater?" And hereto he adds, "Whence then is God supposed by them to have been now called High Priest Who needeth not sacrifices for His own advancement like the high priests? Is the possessor of Godhead, taken from among men, ordained for men in things God-ward?"

Therefore do you say that the Word of God has not even been sent into the world? The very wise Paul has apparently deceived those who were called through him, for he said, "God sent forth His Son made of a woman, made under the law." The blessed David too will be found, according to you, idly fantasizing and seeking impossible things, for he said somewhere to God the Father in Heaven, "O send out Thy Light and Thy Truth." And what (tell me) will not the Son Himself also speak falsely in saying, "For God sent not His Son into the world to judge the world, but that the world through Him might be saved," and again, "I came forth from the Father and am come"? The wise John too writes somewhere of Him, "He that receiveth His testimony set to his seal that God is true, for He Whom God sent speaketh God's words." But we say that the Word of God has been sent, having with the measures of the emptying the name and reality of being sent. But YOU—why do you ignorantly fear and blush to assign to Him the name and reality both of the apostolate and the High-priesthood? Would it be fitting, do you suppose, as if He were someone other than Himself—the man born of a woman having, according to you, a mere connection and that in equality of dignity only? How then is the Word, being God, seen to benefit our condition any longer, if we have been presented to God the Father through another? For we no longer have access through Him, but a man like us has become our mediator, having the name of Godhead put on him.

Therefore dost thou say that the Word of God has not been even sent into the world? The most wise Paul hath cozened (it appears) those who were called through him, for he said, God sent forth His Son made of a woman, made under the law: the blessed David too will be found according to thee idly romancing and seeking impossible things, for he said somewhere to God the Father in Heaven, O send out Thy Light and Thy Truth. And what (tell me) will not the Son Himself too speak falsely in saying, For God sent not His Son into the world to judge the world, but that the world through Him might he saved, and again, I came forth from the Father and am come. The wise John too writes somewhere of Him, He that receiveth His testimony set to his seal that God is true, for He Whom God sent speaketh God's words. But we say that the Word of God hath been sent, having with the measures of the emptying the name and fact of being sent: but YOU why do you unlearnedly fear and blush to allot to Him the name and fact both of the apostolate and the High-priesthood? would it befit (do you suppose) as other than He, the man born of a woman having (according to you) a mere connection and that in equality of dignity only? how then is the Word being God seen to profit any longer our condition, if we have been even presented to God the Father through another? for no longer have we had the access through Him, but a man like us has become our mediator having the name of Godhead put on.

Yes, he says, the priesthood is too small for the Word begotten from God the Father. Too small, I agree—you are stating the truth—but He did not appear to those on earth in bare Godhead. Rather, He became human like us, and for us the priesthood is something great and excellent. But if He refused the priesthood as something belonging to humanity, or indeed anything that pertains to the condition of servanthood, would it not have been far better to refuse the Incarnation itself before this?

Yea (says he) the priest's office is petty to the Word begotten out of God the Father. Petty confessedly, I agree with you enunciating the truth, but not in bare Godhead did He dawn on those upon the earth, but rather made man as we, to whom the priesthood is some great and choice thing. But if He refused the priest's office as belonging to man, or indeed ought that appertains to the measure of bond-service, how were it not better far, before this to refuse too the Incarnation?

He did not reject being born for our sake. But this man, as I said, is ashamed of the truth, showing himself foolish and ignorant, even though blessed Paul says, "For I am not ashamed of the Gospel, for it is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believes." One may well marvel that the Word of God, for the salvation and life of all, endured such great humiliation—yet the inventor of these pointless teachings for us is somehow ashamed even to acknowledge it, though he ought to wonder at this and cry out with the blessed Prophet, "O Lord, I have heard Your report and was afraid, I considered Your works and was amazed." But since the whole God-inspired Scripture in effect rises up against him and arrays the truth against him, showing that his argument in favor of his own inventions is cold, lacks any real substance, and is without support from anywhere, and is greatly lacking in the concepts and ideas that lead to what is right and true—therefore what no one who has a good reputation for correct doctrine has ever thought or said, this he makes the subject of his argument. He fights with shadows and exhausts himself pointlessly, with no one opposing him or wanting to argue about these matters. I consider this to be beating the air. For he said, "Who, upon learning of the ministry of an apostle, would not immediately know that a man is indicated? Who, upon hearing the title of High Priest, would suppose that the ousia of Godhead were High Priest?" Since there is no one who says this, with whom, tell me, are you contending? And as though you alone were refuting what is condemned by everyone's voice, are you perhaps thinking your opposition is even worthy of honors? Yet how is it not true that since no one says this, it is you who are bringing forward what it would be better to keep silent about and not instill into the souls of the simpler people? For who is so insane as to suppose that the ousia of Godhead were High Priest? Aaron was a man, though he obtained preeminence over the rest in Divine Priesthood. How then will anyone suppose that the ousia of Godhead is High Priest, or how will he not completely and certainly confess that a man is being mentioned when the brother of Moses is named to us as High Priest? Yet he, putting forth some language that commonly belongs to and befits every high priest among us, tries to undo the marvel of the Economy understood in Christ, and dares to shake our Divine Mystery from its very foundations, not considering that Christ has founded the Church upon a rock, and the gates of Hell shall not prevail against her. For he does not at all condescend to follow the common doctrine and that of all who are accustomed to think rightly, but he alone introduces without examination whatever he pleases. For WE, as I said before, say that the Word out of God the Father, made Man, offered to Himself and to the Father the confession of our faith and carried out an Economy befitting and by no means out of harmony with the measures of the emptying. But this does not seem right to him. Instead, taking separately and apart him that is from the holy Virgin as though he were another Christ than the Word That is out of God the Father, he says that he became the Apostle and high priest of our confession, and he supposes that he is thinking what contributes to piety when he says, "If God is the offerer, there is no one to whom offering is made, for what is there worthy of Godhead that, as though It were lesser, It should make offering to the greater?" Now if there were anyone contending and saying that He That is truly Word out of God the Father had been appointed to the office of priesthood even before the Incarnation and was in the measure of ministry and was for this reason to be called High Priest and Apostle, he would have given a wise rebuke, and one would say that his argument on this had been made at the right time. For the physis That rules all is not lacking in priests, that He should minister in that capacity Himself. But since the Only-Begotten, being God by physis and receiving from the hands of those who execute the Priest's office their ministrations, has descended to the measure of those appointed to the priesthood, having become Man (as I said), it will be nothing strange if He is also called by us High Priest. Has He not come down in servant's form, having taken the form of a servant, though He is the Impress and Brightness of the Father's Glory? No one will doubt it. When therefore He Who is in His own physis Free as God, He Who is in the Form and Equality of the Father, has been called a slave—economically not rejecting the measure of those who are under the yoke of bondage—why do you fear to call Him High Priest too by reason of the Manhood? For He dedicates us as an odor of a sweet smell through faith, and He Himself has offered Himself for us as a most sweet-smelling offering to the Father.1

Yet He rejected not for our sakes the Birth. But this man (as I said) is ashamed of the truth, shewing himself unwise and unskilled, albeit the blessed Paul saith, For I am not ashamed of the Gospel, for it is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth. And one may well marvel that the Word of God for the salvation and life of all endured to suffer so great abasement, which the inventor for us of idle teachings is (I know not how) ashamed merely to acknowledge, albeit he ought to wonder hereat and to cry with the blessed Prophet, O Lord, I have heard Thy report and was afraid, I considered Thy works and was amazed. But since the whole God-inspired Scripture in a manner rises up against him, and arrays against him the truth, shewing that his discourse in favour of his own inventions, cold and without any real being and destitute of support from any quarter, lacks in no small degree the conceptions and ideas that tend unto Tightness and truth; hence what no one of those well reported of for rightness of doctrine, ever either thought or said, this he makes the occasion of his discourse, and fights with shadows and strains himself to no purpose, no one opposing him or wishing to contend about these matters. And this (I deem) is to beat the air. For he said "Who on learning of the ministry of an apostle would not forthwith know that a man is indicated? who on hearing the appellation of High Priest would suppose that the Essence of Godhead were High-Priest?" Since therefore there is no one who says this, with whom (tell me) are you striving, and as though yourself alone were overthrowing what is condemned by the voice of all, are haply thinking that your opposition is worthy even of honours? albeit how is it not true that since no one saith this, it is you who are bringing forward what it were better to be silent on and not to instil into the souls of the more simple? For who is so crazed as to, suppose that the Essence 'of Godhead were High Priest?' Aaron was a man, albeit he obtained preeminence of the rest in Divine Priesthood. How then will any one suppose that the Essence of Godhead is High Priest, or how will he not wholly and surely confess that mention is made of a man when the brother of Moses is named to us as High Priest? Yet he putting forth some language that commonly belongs to and befits every High Priest of those among us, essays to undo the marvel of the Economy understood in Christ, and dares to shake from the very foundations our Divine Mystery, not considering that Christ hath founded the Church upon a rock, and the gates of Hell shall not prevail against her. For he no wise condescends to follow the common doctrine and that of all who are wont to think aright, but he alone innovates without examination what he pleases. For WE (as I said before) say that the Word out of God the Father, made Man, offered to Himself and to the Father the confession of our faith and wrought an Economy befitting and by no means out of harmony with the measures of the emptying. But not so does it seem to him, but he taking separately and apart him that is from forth the holy Virgin as though another Christ than the Word That is out of God the Father, says that he became the Apostle and high priest of our confession and supposes that he is thinking what conduce unto piety when he says, "If God be the offerer, there is none to whom offering is made, for what is there worthy of Godhead that as though less It should make offering to the greater?" Now if there were any who were contending and saying that He That is truly Word out of God the Father had been appointed to office of priesthood even before the Incarnation and were in the measure of ministry and were for this reason to be called High Priest and Apostle, he would have given a wise rebuke, and one would say that his argument hereon had been made in season. For not in lack of priests is the Nature That rules all, that Himself should minister therein. But since the Only-Begotten, being God by Nature and receiving from the hands of those who execute the Priest's office their ministrations, hath descended unto the measure of those appointed unto the priesthood, having become Man (as I said), nought strange will it be if He be called by us High Priest too. Hath He not come down in servant's form, having taken that is the form of a servant, albeit Impress and Brightness of the Father's Glory? None will doubt it. When therefore He Who is in His own Nature Free as God, He Who is in the Form and Equality of the Father, has been called bond, economically not thrusting from Him the measure of those who are under the yoke of bondage, why dost thou fear to call Him High Priest too by reason of the Manhood? for He dedicates us for an odour of a sweet smell through faith, and Himself hath He offered for us as a most sweet-smelling offering to the Father.1

But he (saying I don't know what) immediately adds to these things: "From where then were God supposed by them to have been now called High Priest, who does not need sacrifices for His own advancement? Is the possessor of Godhead taken from among men and appointed for men in things pertaining to God?" From where then Christ, that is, the Word from God made man, came, or why He was called Apostle and High Priest, our discussion has already clearly shown. But I think it is right not to leave his unusual and strange statement unexamined. For does he say that the Word from God is Possessor of Godhead, even if anyone should wish to think of Him apart and without flesh? Does he define His Godhead as something other than Himself? I don't know how (as he says) He has become possessor of it, as though it came to Him and was added to Him from outside, although He was not once God by Nature—like what that ancient woman, I mean Eve, said when she bore Seth: "I gained a man through God." But I think this must be completely rejected by him and by all. Why then does he speak so imprecisely, and throw around words without understanding in matters so important? Would not someone earn laughter and be accused of insanity if one chose to say that any among us were the possessor of human nature, or a horse of horse-nature? Who then is the possessor of Godhead, who is taken from men and ordained in things pertaining to God? Perhaps he will say, dividing into two the One Christ, that it is Him who is from the Holy Virgin—for I suppose this is where his aim is now directed as well.

But he (saying I know not what) straightway subjoins to these things; "Whence then were God supposed by them to have been now called High Priest Who needeth not sacrifices for His own advancement? is the possessor of Godhead taken from among men appointed for men in things God-ward?" Whence then Christ, i. e., the Word out of God made man, was, or why He was called, Apostle and High Priest, our discourse has already clearly shewn, but I think it right not to leave unexamined his unwonted and strange utterance. For doth he say that the Word out of God is Possessor of Godhead, even though any should wish to conceive of Him apart and without flesh? doth he define His Godhead as other than He? whereof I don't know how (as he saith) He hath become possessor, as though it accrued to Him and came to Him from without, although once not God by Nature, like what was said by that ancient woman, I mean Eve, when she bare Seth, I gat a man through God. But this I deem is wholly to be spurned by him and by all. Why then doth he speak with inexactness, and fling about words without understanding, in matters so cogent? would not one earn laughter and accusal of insanity, if one chose to say that any among us were the possessor of human nature, or a horse of horse-nature? who then is the possessor of Godhead, who taken from men is ordained in things to Godward? Haply he will say severing into two the One Christ, Him that is forth of the Holy Virgin: for to this I suppose now too is his aim directed.

Has the Godhead (tell me) become the possession of a man, and has it happened to any one of us to become God by physis and in truth and to be rich in the excellence of the ousia that is above all and supreme? Away with this bad advice, O man, for none of those counted among created things may acquire and possess as their own the physis of Godhead. The Body of the Word was His own, and as one with it, God and Christ and Son and Lord have been worshipped by creation, and the Heavens praise, and we praise with them. For as the Prophet says, His Goodness covered the Heavens and the earth was full of His Praise—not as though a man obtained Godhead (for how or from where could he?), but because the Word from God the Father had taken possession of human flesh. But suppose that the one who was taken from among men was the possessor of Godhead (as you seem to think)—how is he ordained in things pertaining to God, that is, as High Priest? Will he therefore, lacking the Godhead which he obtained, minister in the priestly office to God, or already having it as his own? For this and nothing else is what saying that he obtained it would mean. But if he lacks it, he did not obtain it; if he has it as his own, then Godhead will surely minister in the priestly office to God. Why then do you wander around confused and mix everything together and feel no shame, falsely marking the tradition of the Faith?

Hath the Godhead then (tell me) become the acquisition of a man, and hath it befallen any one of us, to become God by Nature and in truth and to be rich in the excellence of the Essence that is above all and Supreme? Away with the ill-counsel, o man, for none of those accounted among things generate may acquire and have as his own the Nature of Godhead: His own was the Body of the Word and as one therewith God and Christ and Son and Lord hath the creation worshipped, and the Heavens do praise and we with them. For as the Prophet saith, His Goodness covered the Heavens and of His Praise was the earth full, not as though a man gat Godhead (for how or whence could he?) but that the Word out of God the Father had come into possession of flesh of man. But be it that he who was taken out of men was owner of Godhead (as seems good to yourself), how is he ordained in things to Godward, i. e., as High Priest? will he therefore bare of the Godhead which he gat, minister in the Priest's office to God, or already having it as his own? for this and nought else will the saying that he gat it signify. But if bare of it, he gat it not; if having it as his own, Godhead will surely minister in the Priest's office to God. Why then do you wander distractedly and jumble all together and blush not, stamping with false mark the tradition of the Faith?

The Word from God the Father has compelling reason to be said to carry out the priestly office before the Father, for He has been called Priest not separately from flesh, but having been made like us (as I said), to whom the glory of the priesthood is considered an honor.

The Word out of God the Father hath cogent reason even though He be said to execute the Priest's Office before the Father; for He has been styled Priest not apart from flesh, but made (as I said) as we, to whom the glory of the priesthood is accounted an honour.

There is another way to see that it is utterly absurd and full of foolishness to say that the one who was taken from among human beings and appointed to serve God possesses Godhead. If he was taken by God, how could he possess the physis (nature) that took him? Whatever is taken belongs to the one who takes it as a possession; it is not the case that what is taken becomes the possessor. For example, when a man comes to possess wealth or acquires skill in something, isn't it obvious to everyone that he will not himself be the possession of the wealth or of the skill that came to him, but rather the possessor of what he has obtained? This, I think, is beyond doubt.

In another way too it is not hard to see that it is the absurdest possible thing and replete with much folly to say that he who was taken out of men and ordained unto God-ward, is possessor of Godhead; for if he were taken by God, how possessed he the Nature Which took him? for that which is taken will rather belong to him who took it, as a possession, not that which is taken be the possessor. As for example, A man has become the possessor of wealth, or again of skill unto anything: is it not plain to all that he will not himself be the possession of wealth or again of the skill that accrued to him, but rather the possessor of what he has gotten? but this is I think in no way doubtful.

Therefore, if when we investigate the manner of the Incarnation of the Only-Begotten, we find that a man became God by coming to possess Godhead, then let him be called (using your expression) possessor of Godhead, since the Godhead has become his. But if the Word, being God, took possession of the seed of Abraham, and being in the form of the Father became man by receiving the servant's form, how could anyone not be out of his mind if he chose to say that what was taken possessed the physis that acquired it, rather than having become the very own property of the one who took it?

Hence if on enquiring into the mode of the Incarnation of the Only-Begotten, we find that man became God as coming into possession of Godhead, let him be called (after your phrase) possessor of Godhead, for his hath the Godhead become. But if the Word being God came into possession of the seed of Abraham, and being in the form of the Father, hath become Man, receiving the servant's form, how would one not be distraught, if he chose to say that that which was taken possessed the Nature That acquired it and hath not rather become the very own of Him Who took it?

But he shows that he carries the force of his own words and inventions, and even the very name of high priesthood itself, in an unlearned way to a mere man born from a woman, taking it away from the Only-Begotten and Word who is from the Father. He will make this clear in what follows, for he has written again in this way:

But that he carries round the force of his own words and inventions and moreover the very name of high Priesthood in unlearned wise unto a mere man born from forth a woman, bearing it away from the Only-Begotten and Word That is out of the Father, he will make manifest by what follows too: for he has written again on this wise:

§2

Nestorius: "He does not take hold of angels, but He takes hold of Abraham's seed. Is the Godhead Abraham's seed? Listen also to this statement: 'Therefore it was necessary for Him,' he says, 'to be made like His brothers in all things.' Did God the Word have brothers who were like His Godhead? Notice what immediately follows: 'That He might become a merciful and faithful High Priest in things pertaining to God, for in that He Himself has suffered being tempted, He is able to help those who are tempted.' Therefore, the One who suffered is a merciful High Priest. What is passible is the Temple, not the life-giving God of the one who has suffered. The seed of Abraham is the one who is yesterday and today, as Paul says, not the One who says, 'Before Abraham was, I am.' The one who is like his brothers in all things is the one who took on the brotherhood of human soul and flesh, not the One who says, 'He who has seen Me has seen the Father.'"2

Nestorius: " Not Angels doth He take hold of, but Abraham's seed He taketh hold of. Is the Godhead Abraham's seed? Hear the following utterance too: Wherefore it behoved Him, he saith, in all things to be made like unto His brethren. Had God the Word any brothers like unto His Godhead? Mark what is straightway joined on to these, That He might be made a merciful and faithful High Priest in things to God-ward, for in that He Himself hath suffered being tempted, He is able to succour them that are tempted. Therefore He Who suffered is a merciful High Priest: passible is the Temple, not the quickening God of him that has suffered: the seed of Abraham is he which is yesterday and to-day, as Paul saith, not He That saith, Before Abraham was I am. Like to his brethren in all things is he which assumed brother-hood of human soul and flesh and not He which saith, He that hath seen Me hath seen the Father. "2

The Word, being God, took Abraham's seed (as Nestorius has just now confessed). How then can he who comes from the seed of Abraham still possess Godhead, if he was taken by God rather than himself taking Godhead? The seed of Abraham will by no means be the physis of Godhead, but rather has become the Body of God the Word, according to the Scriptures, and His own. And He who in His own proper physis is not counted among the creation, as God, when He became Man who is part of the creation—then, and rightly so, He condescends to call us brothers, saying, "I will declare Your Name to My brethren." But that because of the extent of emptiness, the Word from God the Father has descended even to the point of calling those on earth His brothers, the most wise Paul will clearly show, writing of Him and us: "For both He who sanctifies and those who are being sanctified are all from one, for which reason He is not ashamed to call them brethren, saying, 'I will declare Your Name to My brethren.'" For before the Incarnation, the name of brotherhood with us was exceedingly insignificant to the Word who sprang from God. But when He had descended to voluntary emptiness, it was still insignificant, yet it has come fittingly, for He has partaken of blood and flesh and has been called Brother of those in flesh and blood. For if He is sanctified in that He has become Man although He is God by physis and Himself the Giver of the Spirit, how, if He is also called Brother, will it not be said in proper order? For He has become as we are so that He might make us brothers and free, for "as many as received Him, to them He gave authority to become children of God, to those who believe on His Name, who were begotten not out of blood nor out of the will of the flesh nor out of the will of man but out of God." For the Word from God the Father has been born among us according to the flesh so that we too might be enriched with the birth from God through the Spirit, no longer called children of flesh but transformed rather into what was above nature and called sons of God by grace. For He has been made as one of us who is by physis and truly Only-Begotten Son.

The Word therefore being God took (as he too hath just now confessed) Abraham's seed; how then is he that is forth of the seed of Abraham any longer possessor of Godhead, if he were taken by God, did not himself take Godhead? The seed of Abraham then will by no means be the Nature of Godhead, but rather hath become the Body of God the Word, according to the Scriptures, and His Own, and He Who in His own proper Nature is uncounted among the creation as God, when He became Man who is part of the creation, then, then and with reason deigns He to call us brothers saying, I will declare Thy Name unto My brethren. But that by reason of the measure of emptiness, the Word out of God the Father hath descended even to having to call those upon the earth His brothers, the most wise Paul will clearly shew, writing of Him and us, For both He That sanctifieth and they who are being sanctified are all out of one, for which cause He is not ashamed to call them brethren saying, I will declare Thy Name unto My brethren. For before the Incarnation, exceeding petty to the Word Which sprang of God was the name of brotherhood with us: but when He had descended unto voluntary emptiness, petty was it thus too, yet hath it come fitly in, for He hath partaken of blood and flesh and of those in flesh and blood has been styled Brother. For if He is sanctified in that He have become Man albeit God by Nature and Himself the Giver of the Spirit, how if He be called Brother too, will it not be so said in due order? for for this cause He hath become as we that He might render us brothers and free, for as many (it says) as received Him, to them gave He authority to become children of God, to them that believe on His Name, which were begotten not out of blood nor out of the will of the flesh nor out of the will of man but out of God. For the Word out of God the Father has been with us born after the flesh that we too might be enriched with the birth out of God through the Spirit, no longer termed children of flesh but transelemented rather into what was above nature and termed sons of God by grace: for He has been made as one of us who is by Nature and truly Only-Begotten Son.

And the word is unerring; Paul, who speaks divine truth, will give us assurance of this, saying, "And because you are sons, God sent forth the Spirit of His Son into your hearts, crying Abba Father." Why then do you do violence to the wisdom of the economy as if it had been accomplished in some unfitting order, when you say, "Is the Godhead Abraham's seed? Did he have any brothers like to the Godhead?" Is this not clear madness? For to absurdly investigate and twist into blasphemy things so right and blameless regarding the economy in Christ—what else is this but proof of complete distraction? For confessedly, with respect to the physis of the body or of human nature perfect as far as it is concerned, the Word out of God the Father has been made like us and in every way like us except sin alone. But I will ask him who says "Did God the Word have any brothers like to the Godhead?"—what idea, I ask, did the most holy Paul have in mind when he wrote to certain people, "Little children, of whom I travail in birth again until Christ be formed in you," and elsewhere too to those who through faith are perfected in spirit, "But we all with unveiled face reflecting the glory of the Lord are changed into his image from glory to glory as by the Lord the Spirit; now the Lord is the Spirit, and where the Spirit of the Lord, there is liberty"? Does he therefore say this to the Galatians because they do not have the impress, in regard to bodily form, of that which is of the seed of David after the flesh, but is he travailing again with them that Christ after the flesh may somehow be engraved on them and formed in them? Yet surely everyone, I suppose, will unhesitatingly say that all who are on earth are conformed to one another and to Christ himself, insofar as he is conceived of as man, who is both man and with us. What formation unto Christ, then, was being sought for in them? Or how are we transformed from glory to glory? What form are we leaving, and into what are we being changed? Let therefore the divine initiator come forward and teach us, the priest of the divine mysteries, the teacher of the Gentiles in faith and truth; for "whom he knew, and predestined to be conformed to the image of his Son, them he also called." Therefore, as I just said, in that he was made man and was of the seed of Abraham, we all are conformed to him. All therefore who are on earth, the Father both foreknew and foreordained; and these having called, he sanctified and glorified. But truly not all were foreordained, not all were sanctified or glorified. The fact therefore of conformation to the Son will not be conceived of as existing in the physis alone of the flesh or of manhood, but in another way also, and this the blessed Paul sets before us saying, "And as we bore the image of the earthy we shall bear the image too of the heavenly"—calling the image of the earthy that of our forefather Adam, and of the heavenly, that of Christ. What then first is the image of our forefather? Proneness to sin, becoming subject to death and decay. What again is that of the heavenly? Being in no way overcome by passions, not knowing how to transgress, not being subject to death and decay, holiness, righteousness, and whatever is akin to and like these. But these, I suppose, will befit the divine and untainted physis to possess, for holiness and righteousness are superior to both sin and decay. Herein does the Word out of God the Father restore us too, rendering us partakers of his own divine physis through the Spirit.

And unerring is the word; the Divine-uttering Paul will give us assurance thereto, saying on this wise, And because ye are sons, God sent forth the Spirit of His Son into your hearts, crying Abba Father. Why then do you offer violence to the wisdom of the economy as though it appeared to have been wrought in no fitting order, in that you say, "Is the Godhead Abraham's seed? had He any brothers like to the Godhead?" Is not this clear madness? for the absurdly enquiring into and bearing away unto blasphemy, things so right and unblameable in respect of the Economy in Christ, what else is it than proof of the most utter distraction? for confessedly in respeot of the nature of the body or of human nature perfect as far as itself is concerned, has the Word out of God the Father been made like unto us and in every thing like save sin alone. But I will ask him who says "Had God the Word any brothers like to the Godhead?" what idea (I pray) had the most holy Paul in his mind when he wrote to certain, Little children of whom I travail in birth again until Christ be formed in you, and elsewhere too to those who through faith are perfected in spirit, But WE all with unveiled face reflecting the glory of the Lord are changed into His image from glory to glory as by the Lord the Spirit; now the Lord is the Spirit, and where the Spirit of the Lord, there liberty? Doth he therefore say this to the Galatians as not having the impress in regard to bodily freedom, of that which is of the seed of David after the flesh, but is he travailing again with them that Christ after the flesh may somehow be engraven on them and formed in them? albeit how will not every body (I suppose) unhesitatingly say, that all who are on the earth are conformed one to another and to Christ Himself, in so far as He is conceived of as man, Who is both Man and with us? what formation then unto Christ was it that was sought for in them? or how are WE transformed from glory to glory, what form leaving, unto what are we transelemented? Let therefore the Divine initiator come forward and teach us, the Priest of the Divine Mysteries, the teacher of the Gentiles in faith and verity; for whom (says he) He knew, and predestinated to be conformed to the image of His Son, them, He also called. Therefore (as I said just now) in that He was made man and was of the seed of Abraham, we all are conformed to Him: all therefore who are on earth, the Father both fore-knew and fore-ordained; and these having called He sanctified and glorified. But verily not all were fore-ordained, not all were sanctified or glorified:—-the fact therefore of conformation unto the Son will not be conceived of as existing in the nature alone of the flesh or of manhood, but in another way also, and this the blessed Paul sets before ua saying, And as we bare the image of the earthy we shall bear the image too of the heavenly; calling the image of the earthy, that of our forefather Adam, of the heavenly, that of Christ. What then first is the image of our forefather? proneness to sin, becoming under death and decay. What again that of the heavenly? being in no wise overcome of passions, not knowing to transgress, not being subject to death and decay, holiness, righteousness, and whatever are akin to and like these. But these (I suppose) will befit the Divine and Untaint Nature to possess: for superior to both sin and decay is Holiness and Righteousness. Herein does the Word out of God the Father restore us too, rendering us partakers of His own Divine Nature through the Spirit.

He has brothers like Himself who bear the image of His Divine Nature with regard to holiness, for this is how Christ is formed in us—the Holy Spirit, as it were, transforming us from human things into things that are His own. Therefore the blessed Paul also said to us, "But you are not in the flesh, but in the spirit." So the Son does not transfer anything that has been made into the Nature of His own Godhead (for that would be impossible). Rather, the spiritual likeness with Him is impressed on those who have been made partakers of His Divine Nature through their partaking of the Holy Spirit, and the Beauty of the Ineffable Godhead shines upon the souls of the saints. Why then, assigning only the likeness of the flesh, do you not blush with shame, disregarding the Divine and Spiritual forming—indeed, taking it away entirely? Yet the Lord of all and Only-Begotten God lowered Himself to emptiness for our sakes, so that He might bestow on us the dignity of brotherhood with Him and the Beauty, worthy of all love, of His Innate Nobility. And this man, robbing us of all that is most lovely, says that a mere man has become our brother and shows that his account of this is certain (as he supposes), adding: "Mark too what is straightway joined on to these, 'That He might be a merciful and faithful High Priest in things God-ward, for in that He Himself hath suffered being tempted, He is able to succour them that are tempted.' Therefore a merciful High Priest is He That suffered: passible is the Temple, not the quickening God of him which hath suffered." Therefore, by choosing to think this way and moreover daring to say it, he severs again into distinct hypostases and into two prosopa the Word from God the Father and him whom he has just introduced to us as a God-bearing man—if indeed one person by himself is he that suffered, and another is he that quickens. I suppose no one will doubt this.

He has therefore brothers like to Himself and bearing the image of His Divine Nature, in regard of holiness; for thus is Christ formed in us, the Holy Ghost as it were transelementing us from things human unto those that are His own. Therefore to us too said the blessed Paul, But YE are not in the flesh, but in the spirit. Therefore the Son transfers not ought at all of things that have been made into the Nature of His own Godhead (for that were impossible): but there is impressed on those who have been made partakers of His Divine Nature through their partaking of the Holy Ghost the spiritual Likeness with Him, and the Beauty of the Ineffable Godhead flashes upon the souls of the saints. Why then dost thou assigning the mere and alone likeness of the flesh, not blush, disregarding the Divine and Spiritual forming, yea rather taking it utterly away? Yet the Lord of all and Only-Begotten God lowered Himself unto emptiness for our sakes, that He might bestow on us the Dignity of brother-hood with Him and the Beauty worthy of all love, of His Innate Nobility: and this man, bereaving us of all that is most lovely, says that a mere man hath become our brother and shews that sure (as he supposes) is his account hereof, adding "Mark too what is straightway joined on to these, That He might be a merciful and faithful High Priest in things God-ward, for in that He Himself hath suffered being tempted, He is able to succour them that are tempted. Therefore a merciful High Priest is He That suffered: passible is the Temple, not the quickening God of him which hath suffered." Therefore that by choosing thus to think and moreover daring to say it too, he severs again into distinct hypostases and into two Persons, the Word from forth God the Father and him whom himself has just introduced to us as a God-bearing man, if so be that one and apart by himself is he that suffered, and another he that quickeneth, I suppose that no one whatever will doubt.

But he is also mistaken in another way, having drunk wine from the vine of Sodom and become intoxicated with error, perhaps not even knowing what he is saying. For where has the Word from God the Father been called (I shudder to say it) the God of Christ? There is one Lord Jesus Christ, and one faith in Him—not as if in two distinct prosopa, but as through one baptism into one Son and God and Lord, the Word from God the Father even when He became man. For He will not lose being God simply because He became as we are (how could He?), nor does He consider likeness to us inadmissible or reject being man simply because He is God by physis. Rather, just as He has remained God in human nature, so being both in the physis and preeminence of the Godhead, He is nonetheless man. Therefore both are in the same one, and one God and man is Emmanuel.

But in another way also is he beside himself, having quaffed wine from forth the vine of Sodom, and drunk with error and haply not even knowing what he saith: for where hath the Word out of God the Father been called (I shudder at saying it) the God of Christ? for there is One Lord Jesus Christ, and one faith in Him, not as though in two distinct persons, but as through one Baptism into One Son and God and Lord, the Word out of God the Father even when He became Man. For not because He became as we, will He lose the being God (how should He?) nor yet because He is God by Nature, doth He hold the likeness to us inadmissible nor will He reject the being man; but as He hath remained in human nature God, so being both in the Nature and Pre-eminence of the Godhead, none the less is He Man. Both therefore in the Same, and One God and Man is Emmanuel.

But this fellow, rejecting the pattern of the Economy as inappropriate, removes the human nature from God the Word, so that he may finally be clearly seen to have in no way helped our condition. For he says that it was not the Word who became a merciful and faithful High Priest, but assigns this instead to the one who suffered as being someone other than the Word. Yet how could he not, if he had wanted to be a wise teacher, have carefully examined the expressions and concepts that are in the God-inspired Scripture and recognized that this is something which is both truly fitting for God and not incompatible with what befits and is appropriate to the emptying? And we will explain how, as briefly as we can.

But this good man rejecting the mode of the Economy as uncomely, removeth from God the Word the human, that He may at last be clearly seen to have in no way aided our condition. For he says that not He became an High Priest both Merciful and Faithful, but allots this rather to him that suffered as being other than He. Yet how should he not, if he had desired to be a wise initiator, have made an exact muster of the expressions and ideas that are in the God-inspired Scripture and considered that this is a thing which is both truly God-befitting and not apart from what befits and beseems the emptying: and how we will say as briefly as we can.

The God of all gave the Law to the people of old, with Moses as mediator. But the Law did not have the power to enable those who wanted it to do good without any fault, for it perfected nothing. Nor was the first covenant found to be without fault, but the all-wise Paul called it the ministry of condemnation. I hear him say, "We know that whatever the law says, it says to those who are under the law, so that every mouth may be stopped and all the world may come under judgment before God, because by the deeds of the law no flesh will be justified in His sight" (for the Law produces wrath, and the Letter kills), and as he himself says somewhere, "He who despised Moses' law dies without mercy on the testimony of two or three witnesses." Therefore, since the Law condemns those who sin and sometimes decrees the most extreme punishment on those who disregard it, and shows no pity at all, how was it not necessary for a Compassionate and truly Merciful High Priest to appear to them on earth? One who would make the curse cease, stop the condemnation, and free sinners with forgiving grace and with the inclination of mercy? For "I," He says, "am He who blots out your transgressions and will not remember." For we have been justified by faith and not by the works of the Law, as it is written. In whom, then, are we justified by believing? Is it not in Him who suffered death for us according to the flesh? Is it not in one Lord Jesus Christ? Have we not been redeemed by proclaiming His Death and confessing His Resurrection? Therefore, if we have believed in a man like us and not rather in God, this is man-worship and clearly nothing else. But if we believe that He who suffered in the flesh is God, who has also been made our High Priest, we have not erred at all, but acknowledge the Word from God made Man. And thus faith directed toward God is required of us, who removes from condemnation and frees from sin those who are held by it. For the Son of man has authority on earth also to forgive sins, as He Himself says. Therefore, contrasting the salvation and grace that comes through Christ with the harshness (so to speak) of the law's severity, we say that Christ was made a Merciful High Priest. For He was and is God Good by physis and Compassionate and Merciful always, and did not become this in time but was revealed to us as such. And He has been called Faithful, as remaining what He is always, according to what is also said of the Father Himself: "But God is faithful, who will not allow you to be tempted beyond what you are able."3

The God of all uttered the Law to them of old, Moses being mediator. But there was not in the Law the power of achieving good without any blame, to those who wished it (for it hath perfected nothing). But neither was the first covenant found faultless, but the all-wise Paul called it the ministry of condemnation. I hear him say, We know that what things soever the law saith, it saith to them who are under the law, that every mouth may be stopped and all the world may become under sentence before God, because by the deeds of the law there shall no flesh be justified in His sight, (for the Law worketh unto wrath, and the Letter killeth), and as himself somewhere saith, He that despised Moses' law dieth without mercy under two or three witnesses. Seeing therefore that the Law condemneth them that sin and decreeth sometimes the uttermost punishment to them that disregard it, and in no wise pitieth, how was not the manifestation to them on the earth of a Compassionate and truly Merciful High Priest necessary? of One Who should make the curse to cease, should stop the condemnation and free sinners with forgiving grace and with the bending of clemency? for I (He says) am He that blotteth out thy transgressions and will not remember. For we have been justified by faith and not out of the works of the Law, as it is written. On Whom then believing are we justified? is it not on Him who suffered death for us after the flesh? is it not on One Lord Jesus Christ? have we not on declaring His Death and confessing His Resurrection been redeemed? If therefore we have believed on a man like us and not rather on God, the thing is man-worship, and confessedly nothing else: but if we believe that He That suffered in the flesh is God, Who hath been made also our High Priest, we have no ways erred, but acknowledge the Word out of God made Man: and thus is required of us faith God-ward, Who putteth out of condemnation and freeth from sin those that are taken thereby. For the Son of man hath authority on the earth also to forgive sins, as Himself too saith. Contrasting therefore with the salvation and grace that is through Christ the harshness (so to speak) of the law's severity, we say that Christ was made a Merciful High Priest. For He was and is God Good by Nature and Compassionate and Merciful always, and hath not become this in time but was so manifested to us. And He has been named Faithful, as abiding what He is always, according to what is said of the Father Himself too, But God is faithful Who will not suffer you to be tempted above that ye are able.3

Emmanuel has therefore been made for us a merciful and faithful High Priest. For, as Paul says, the former priests were many because death prevented them from continuing, but He, because He continues forever, has a priesthood that does not pass away. Therefore He is able to save completely those who come to God through Him, since He always lives to intercede for them. That the Word from the Father has remained God, even though made priest as it is written, on account of the manner and mode fitting the Economy with flesh—the word of the blessed Paul has been sufficient for our full assurance, for he said again: Now this is the sum of what has been said: We have such a High Priest who sat at the right hand of the throne of the Majesty in the heavens, a minister of the sanctuary and of the true tabernacle which the Lord pitched and not man. See therefore how the Word who sprang from God is shown to be God in supreme excellencies and in the seat of Godhead, and the same One executing the priest's office as man and offering to the Father no earthly sacrifice but rather a divine and spiritual one, and how He has heaven as His holy tabernacle. For He has been made High Priest not according to the law of a carnal commandment, but according to the power of an indestructible life, as it is written. Therefore He is faithful in this also, and certain to those who come to Him, that He is able quite easily to save them completely, for with His own blood and with one offering He has perfected forever those who are sanctified. For I think this is what the holy Paul shows us when he says: for in that He Himself has suffered, being tempted, He is able to help those who are tempted. Why then, disregarding thoughts that pertain to piety and straying from words of rightness and truth, does he say, "He who suffered is a merciful High Priest, the passible temple, not the life-giving God of Him who suffered"?

A merciful and faithful High-Priest therefore has Emmanuel been made unto us; for (as Paul saith) the one were many priests because they were by death hindered from remaining, He, because He continneth for ever, hath a priest-hood that passeth not, wherefore He is able to save also unto the uttermost them that come unto God through Him, ever living to intercede for them. That the Word out of the Father hath remained God, albeit made priest, as it is written, on account of the fashion and mode that befitteth the Economy with flesh, the word of the blessed Paul hath been sufficient unto our full assurance, for he said again, Now of the things which have been said this is the sum, We have such an High Priest, Who sat at the Right Hand of the Throne of the Majesty in the heavens, a Minister of the sanctuary and of the Very Tabernacle which the Lord pitched and not man. Yiew therefore view the Word Which sprang of God illustrious as God in supremest excellencies and in the Seat of Godhead, and the Same executing the Priest's Office as man and offering to the Father no sacrifice of earth but Divine rather and spiritual and how He has Heaven as His Holy Tabernacle. For not after the law of a carnal commandment has He been made High Priest, but after the power of an indissoluble life, as it is written. Faithful therefore is He in this too, and sure to them who come to Him, that He is able full easily to save them quite, for with His own Blood and with One Offering hath He perfected for ever them that are sanctified. For this I deem doth the holy Paul shew us saying, for in that He Himself hath suffered, being tempted, He is able to succour them that are tempted. Why then unrecking of thoughts which pertain unto piety and straying from words of rightness and truth, does he say, "He That suffered is a Merciful High Priest, Passible the Temple, not the Life-giving God of Him Who suffered?"

That the Word of God has willingly suffered in the flesh for our sake will be demonstrated at the appropriate time. However, the author will be convicted of dividing the Indivisible and presenting two Christs through the implications of his ideas—even though he clearly states there is One Christ—based on what he immediately adds next. For he said again,

That the Word of God then hath of His own Will suffered in the flesh for our sakes, shall be shewn in its own time: but that he is severing the Inseverable and setting forth two christs by the effect of his ideas, even though he clearly say One Christ, he shall be no less convicted through what has been forthwith subjoined, for he said again,

§3

According to Nestorius, the seed of Abraham is the one who was yesterday and today, as Paul says—not the one who says, "Before Abraham was, I am." The one who took on the brotherhood of human soul and body, being like his brothers in every way, is not the one who says, "Whoever has seen me has seen the Father." The one who was sent is consubstantial with us and has been anointed to proclaim freedom to the captives and recovery of sight to the blind, for "the Spirit of the Lord is upon me, and therefore he anointed me."

Nestorius: "Abraham's seed is He Who was yesterday and to-day, according to the voice of Paul, not He Who saith, Before Abraham was, I am. Like to His brethren in all things, He Who assumed brotherhood of human soul and body, not He Who saith, He that hath seen Me hath seen the Father, He was sent Who is consubstantial with us and has been anointed to preach remission to the captives and recovery of sight to the blind, for the Spirit of the Lord is upon Me, wherefore He anointed Me."

You therefore clearly divide Him into two again, so how are you not convicted of being fleshly and not having the Spirit, as the Saviour's disciple says? But the power of the Truth will stand against your words, O man. For we affirm that the Word Himself from God the Father took hold of Abraham's seed, and made His own the body having a rational soul, the body which was assumed from the holy Virgin. And truly by true union we say that One and the Same is He Who was yesterday and today and forever, and Who before Abraham existed divinely, and was made man afterward and underwent birth from a woman. Therefore He will not lie in saying, Truly I say to you, Before Abraham was I am.

Thou severest therefore into two again and that patently, then how art thou not convicted of being sensual and having not the Spirit, as saith the disciple of the Saviour? but the might of the Truth will array itself (o man) against thy words. For we affirm that the Word Himself out of God the Father took hold of Abraham's seed, and made His own body having a reasonable soul the body which was assumed of the holy Virgin. And verily by true union do we say that One and the Same is He Who was yesterday and to-day and for ever, and Who before Abraham Divinely, was made man after and underwent birth of a woman. Hence He will not lie in saying, Verily I say unto you, Before Abraham was I am.

But he does not understand at all what "yesterday and today and forever" means. For in order to show that the Word of God is eternal and unchangeable by nature, even though He has become man, the writer divided all of time into three periods and put "yesterday" for past time, "today" for present time, and "forever" for future time. But this crude man unreasonably says that "yesterday" and "today" are spoken by the writer of a common man, not considering that this will certainly show Him to have been older and pre-existent to His own birth, if He were at all of "yesterday," which indicates past time. That He who is "yesterday and today," Jesus Christ, is not one person, and He who says "before Abraham was I am" is another person, but One and the Same through a true union—the Word having become man like us and having preserved to His own nature, even when He became man, the attribute of being without beginning in time—one can see this without difficulty in the God-inspired Scripture. For as the blessed Evangelist John says about Christ the Savior of us all, "John bears witness of Him and cried out saying, 'He that comes after me has been made before me, for He was before me,'" and again, "The next day he looks at Jesus coming to him and says, 'Behold the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world. This is He of whom I said, After me comes a Man who has been made before me, for He was before me.'" You see then, very clearly, the divinely-inspired Baptist calling Jesus a man and coming after him, as being born later and after him, yet preceding him and pre-existing, for this, I think, is what the words "for He was before me" and "has been made before me" mean. How then, if He is a man, is He conceived of as pre-existing and said to be before him who had the start of Him in time and whose birth in the flesh was older than His? For if this were said of a man like us, everyone would (I suppose) be at a loss to defend it, but regarding Christ the Savior of us all, there is no difficulty. For He who is from God makes His own the birth of His own flesh, yet He is not ignorant that He is Maker of the worlds and has pre-existence as God, and is co-eternal with His own Father. For we do not say that He has His being contemporaneous with the birth of His own body, but was (as I said) ineffably begotten of the essence (ousia) of God the Father. Therefore having His being before Abraham as God, even though He became man, He will not speak falsely in saying, as One in truth both Son and Lord, "Before Abraham was I am."

But he does not the least understand what yesterday and to-day and for ever is. For that he may shew that the Word of God is Eternal and that by Nature and superior to change and turn, even though He have been made Man, he parted the whole of time into three periods, and puts yesterday of past time, to-day of the present, and for ever of the future. But this boorish man against reason [says] that yesterday and to-day are spoken by him of a common man, not considering that it will full surely shew Him to have been older and pre-existent to His own Birth, if He were at all of yesterday, which is indicative of time past. That not one is He that is yesterday and to-day, Jesus Christ, another He Who saith, before Abraham was I am, but One and the Same by a true Union, the Word having been made Man as we and having preserved to His own Nature, even when He was made man, the being without beginning in time, one may see and that without trouble, in the God-inspired Scripture. For as the blessed Evangelist John saith of Christ the Saviour of us all, John beareth witness of Him and hath cried saying, He That cometh after me has been made before me, for He was before me, and again, The next day he looketh at Jesus coming unto him and saith, Behold the Lamb of God Which taketh away the sin of the world, This is He of Whom I said, After me cometh a Man Which has been made before me, for He was before me. Thou seest then and that very clearly the Divine-uttering Baptist calling Jesus a Man and coming after, as being late-born and after him, yet preceding him and pre-existing, for this, I deem, the words, for He was before me and has been made before me, mean. How then if He is a Man, is He conceived of as pre-existing and is said to be before: him who had the start of Him in time and had his birth in the flesh older than His? For if this were said of a man like us, every body would (I suppose) be at a loss to defend it, but in regard to Christ the Saviour of us all, there is no difficulty. For He Who is out of God makes His own the birth of His own flesh, yet is He not ignorant that He is Maker of the worlds and hath pre-existence as God, and is Co-eternal with His own Father. For we do not say that He hath His Being contemporaneous with the birth of His own body, but was (as I said) ineffably begotten of the Essence of God the Father. Therefore having His Being before Abraham as God even though He was made Man, He will not speak falsely in saying, as One in truth both Son and Lord, Before Abraham was I am.

Do not be surprised if He has assigned to His own physis the existence before Abraham. Rather, consider that although He had taken a body from the holy Virgin, He said to Nicodemus, "If I have told you earthly things and you do not believe, how will you believe if I tell you heavenly things?" and "No one has ascended up into heaven but He who came down from Heaven, the Son of Man"—although He was also called son of man, born of a woman according to the flesh. Will He then be false in saying that the son of man, that is, Himself, has come down from Heaven? Not at all, for He is Himself the Truth. How then can the son of man be rightly understood as from above? Because the Word, being God and out of the ousia that is above all, is said to have come down and to have taken the servant's form. Therefore He speaks with us, no longer as bare Word, but as man like us, and as already understood as One with the Flesh united to Him. And just as, by reason of what befits the emptying, He makes His own all that belongs to His own Flesh, although by physis unembodied, so Himself being from above and out of Heaven, He assigns again the coming from above to Himself even when He has been made Man, even though He has been born according to the flesh with us of a woman. The properties therefore of the human nature have become the very own of the Word, and those of the Word Himself, the very own of the human nature. For thus is understood One Christ and Son and Lord.

And marvel not if He hath apportioned to His own Nature the being before Abraham, but consider rather that albeit He had taken a body of the holy Virgin, He said to Nicodemus, If I have told you earthly things and ye believe not, how shall ye believe if I tell you heavenly things? and no man hath ascended up into heaven but He That came down from Heaven, the Son of Man, albeit He was called son of man too, born of a woman after the flesh. Will He then be false in saying that there hath come down from Heaven the son of man, i. e., Himself? Not so, for He is Himself the Truth. How then will the son of man be rightly conceived of as from above? because the Word being God and out of the Essence That is above all, is said to have come down and to have taken the servant's form. Therefore He converseth with us, not as any longer bare Word, but man as we, and as already conceived of as One with the Flesh united to Him. And as by reason of what beseemeth the emptiness, He maketh His own all that belongs to His own Flesh, albeit by Nature unembodied; so Himself being from above and out of Heaven, He allotteth again the coming from above to Himself even when He hath been made Man, even though He hath been born according to the flesh with us of a woman. The properties therefore of the human nature have become the very own of the Word, those again of the Word Himself, the very own of the human nature: for thus is conceived of One Christ and Son and Lord.

But since this innovator has added that "like to His brethren in all things is He Who assumed brotherhood of human soul and flesh, not He Who says, 'He that has seen Me has seen the Father,'" let us now consider again, as best we can, what he is saying here. For he too has confessed that the Son is the Image and Impress of God the Father. But let him come forward and teach who it is that "assumed brotherhood" of human soul and body—that is, with us. For no one would say that a man like us, such as (for example) Barnabas or Paul or any other of those counted among human beings, could be said to take brotherhood of human soul and body, as though he were something other than this and thus took it. Rather, he simply is what he is by being it. Therefore no one who is a man could be thought of as taking what he already is, as though it were something other than himself. But it would be fitting for the Word who came forth from God, who has no place among us in regard to the count of His own physis, to take "brotherhood of human soul and body" with us. And the word of truth contends on our side, as does the tradition of the undefiled Faith. It holds that God the Word in the Form of God the Father has been made our Brother in all things, taking "brotherhood of human soul and body," and will not speak falsely in saying, "He that has seen Me has seen the Father." For if anyone among us had fallen into such unlearning in his ideas as to suppose that God the Father Himself who is in Heaven must necessarily come down, even to having likeness with us (I mean bodily), he might well have feared that when Christ says, "He that has seen Me has seen the Father," he might be imagining that He too from Whom He is was in form as we are, and in bodily fashion. But since when He was made man He preserved His being as God, and holds the Beauty of His own physis untarnished, I would in no way shrink from saying that He possesses likeness with us, in respect of His being man as we are, Who is of soul and body, although He is God by physis and Impress of the prosopon of Him Who begot Him. Therefore one and the same is He, like to His brethren after the flesh, yet showing in His own physis Him too Who begot Him, in regard, I say, to His being God.

But since this innovator has added that " like to His brethren in all things is He Who assumed brotherhood of human soul and flesh, not He Who saith, He that hath seen Me hath seen the Father," come now let us again consider as we can what it is which he here saith. For that the Son is the Image and Impress of God the Father, he too hath confessed: who again "He is Who of human soul and body assumed brotherhood," i. e., with us, let him come forward and teach; for no one would say that a man like us, such as (for example) Barnabas or Paul or any other of those who are reckoned among men, would be said to take brotherhood of human soul and body, as though he were ought else than this, and so took it, but he is so rather in being what he is. Not one therefore who is man could be conceived as taking the being what he is, as though it were other than he: but it will beseem rather the Word which sprang forth of God, having no rank among us in regard to the count of His own Nature, to take "brotherhood of human soul and body" with us. And the word of the truth contends on our side and the tradition of the undefiled Faith. It holds then that God the Word in the Form of God the Father has been made our Brother in all things, taking "brotherhood of human soul and body," and will not speak falsely in saying, He that hath seen Me hath seen the Father. For if any among us had fallen into such unlearning in his ideas as to suppose that God the Father Himself Which is in Heaven must needs come down, even to the having likeness with us (I mean bodily); he might well have feared lest that when Christ says, He that hath seen Me hath seen the Father, he might be imagining that He too out of Whom He is, was in form as we, and in fashion of body. But since when He was made man, He preserved the being God, and holdeth the Beauty of His own Nature untarnished, I would no wise shrink from saying that He possesseth likeness with us, in respect of His being man as we, Who is of soul and body, albeit God by Nature and Impress of the Person of Him Who hath begotten Him. One therefore and the Same is He, like to His brethren after the flesh, yet shewing in His own Nature Him too Who begat Him, in regard I say to His being God.

But this man does not understand this (how could he?). Instead, he corrupts (so to speak) the plan of the mystery which is right and pure, and introduces to us one christ and another christ. Caught up in Jewish accusations, he does not perceive where he is or into what depths of evil he has fallen. For those of the blood of Israel heard God crying aloud through one of the holy Prophets concerning Emmanuel, "And you Bethlehem house of Ephratha, little are you to be among the thousands of Judah; out of you shall He come to Me to be ruler in Israel, and His goings forth from the beginning from the days of eternity," and again, "His generation who shall tell? because His life is raised from the earth." They did not understand the mystery at all, nor did they know that although He is God by physis and has the origin of His Being as Invisible and Incomprehensible, He was called a Bethlehemite because He was born there in the flesh from the root of Jesse and David. They said to one another, "Is not this the one they seek to kill? Look, He speaks boldly and they say nothing to Him. Do the rulers know that this man is the Christ? Yet we know this man and where He is from, but when Christ comes, no one knows where He is from." For they heard (as I said) the Prophet saying plainly, "His generation who shall tell?" and that He has His goings forth or His Being before every age. Consider again (I pray) the vastness of Jewish stupor: for after saying "When Christ comes, no one knows where He is from," they said again to one another, "Of a truth this is the Prophet." Others said, "Shall Christ come out of Galilee? Did not the Scripture say that Christ comes from the seed of David and from Bethlehem the village where David was?" Do you see how they stagger, confessing both His being apart from beginning, Divinely, and His fleshly generation in time? But they would not have been carried away into such extravagant misunderstanding if they had truly known that the Word, being God, proceeded as Man from the root of Jesse and David and from the holy Virgin, and that the Lord of earth and Heaven and of all was also called a Bethlehemite, for He shared poverty with us though being Rich, as it is written.

But this man doth not understand this (whence should he?) but adulterating (so to speak) the plan of the mystery which is right and unalloyed, he introduces to us one and another christ, and caught in Jewish accusals, perceives not where he is nor in what reach of ills he hath come. For they of the blood of Israel heard God crying aloud through one of the holy Prophets respecting Emmanuel, And THOU Bethlehem house of Ephratha, little art thou to be among the thousands of Judah; out of thee shall He come to Me to be ruler in Israel, and His goings forth from the beginning from the days of eternity: and again, His generation who shall tell? because His life is raised from the earth. And they, no wise understanding the mystery nor yet knowing that albeit God by Nature and having the origin of His Being Invisible and Incomprehensible, He was called Bethlehemite as being there born after the flesh out of the root of Jesse and David, said one to another, Is not this He Whom they seek to hill? lo, He speaketh boldly and they say nothing unto Him; do the rulers know that This Man is the Christ? Yet we know this Man whence He is, but Christ when He cometh, no man knoweth whence He is. For they heard (as I said) the Prophet saying plainly, His generation who shall tell? and that He hath His goings forth or His Being before every age. View again (I pray) the vastness of Jewish stupor: for on saying The Christ when He cometh, no one knoweth whence He is, they said again one to another, Of a truth this is the Prophet: others (it says) said, Shall Christ come out of Galilee? said not the Scripture that out of the seed of David and from Bethlehem the village where was David, the Christ cometh? Seest thou how they stagger, confessing both His being apart from beginning, Divinely, and His fleshly Generation in time? But they would not have been carried away into mis-counsel thus extravagant, if they had known truly that the Word being God, proceeded Man out of the root of Jesse and David and of the holy Virgin, and that the Lord of earth and Heaven and of all was called a Bethlehemite too, for He shared poverty with us being Rich, as it is written.

Why therefore are you plunging yourself into the deceptions of the Jews, both thinking and saying what it is neither lawful to say nor harmless to conceive? Confess with us one Christ, and do not divide him into two again by saying this: "He who was sent is consubstantial with us and has been anointed to preach remission to the captives and recovery of sight to the blind." Where then will the teaching of the inspired teachers go, who have instructed everyone under heaven? For they have proclaimed that the very Word from God the Father was made Savior and Redeemer of all—not as though some man other than he were mediating, like Moses, but rather as having come down to us in bodily likeness and form, for thus he has been anointed as High Priest and Apostle. And indeed he rebuked the Jews saying, "Is it not written in your Law, 'I said, you are gods'? If he called them gods to whom the word of God came, and the scripture cannot be broken, do you say to him whom the Father sanctified and sent into the world, 'You blaspheme,' because I said, 'I am the Son of God'?" Why, I ask, should we exclude him who emptied himself to save all under heaven from the most God-befitting and truly admirable achievements that have been wrought for us, by saying that someone other than he, consubstantial with ourselves, has been sent? Yet would it not be better to say and to think that he has been both sent and has been made consubstantial with us—that is, man—yet remaining consubstantial with God the Father himself also, as he is both conceived of and was and is God? For he is what he was, even when he assumed the humanity, and having the same ousia with God the Father who is in heaven, he grasped in wisdom the likeness with us too. He has also been set forth as Mediator, combining through himself into a union of relation things completely separated from one another according to the pattern of their physis. For being God by physis, he was made man in truth, so that we too might be called offspring no longer of the first, that is, of the earthy one to whom it was said by God, "Earth you are and to earth you shall return," who leads even to death, but of the second, from above and out of heaven—Christ I mean, who brings us again to purest life, and makes incorrupt what is held by death and frees from sins what was enfolded by the toils of sin. Thus the Father himself says somewhere to the Son, "Behold I have given you for a covenant of the race, for a light of the Gentiles, to open the eyes of the blind, to bring forth from chains the bound and from the prison-house those who sat in darkness." And again by the voice of Isaiah, "The beasts of the field shall honor me, the sirens and the daughters of the ostriches, because I gave water in the wilderness and rivers in the thirsty land to give drink to my offspring, chosen, my people whom I won for myself, to declare my virtues." Understanding this very well of the Gentiles called through faith to true knowledge of God, the divinely-speaking Peter writes and says, "But you are a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a peculiar people, that you should tell out the virtues of him who calls you out of darkness into his wondrous light, once not a people, but now a people."

Why therefore plunging thee in the sleights of the Jews dost thou both deem and say what it is neither lawful to say nor yet harmless to conceive of? confess with us One Christ, and do not severing into two again say this, "He was sent that is consubstantial with us and has been anointed to preach remission to the captives and recovery of sight to the blind. " Whither then will go the word of the divines, who have been initiators of all under Heaven? for they have cried aloud that the very Word out of God the Father, was made Saviour and Redeemer of all, not as though a man other than He were mediating, like as Moses, but rather as come down to us in bodily likeness and form, for thus has He been anointed as High Priest and Apostle. And indeed He rebuked the Jews saying, Is it not written in your Law, I said, Ye are gods? if he called them gods to whom the word of God came and the scripture cannot be broken: Him Whom the Father sanctified and sent into the world, do YE say [to Him], thou blasphemest, because I said, I am the Son of God? why (I pray) shall we put Him Who abased Himself unto emptiness that He might save all under Heaven, forth of the most God-befitting and truly admirable achievements that have been wrought unto us-ward, by saying that there has been sent some other than He consubstantial with ourselves? albeit how were it not better to say and thus to chuse to think, that He has been both sent and hath been made consubstantial with us, i. e., man: yet abiding Consubstantial with God the Father Himself too, as He is both conceived of and was and is God? for He is, He is what He was, even when He assumed the humanity, and having sameness of Essence with God the Father Which is in Heaven, He grasped in wisdom the likeness with us too; as Mediator too has He been set forth, combining through Himself unto an union of relation things completely dissevered one from another as to the plan of their nature. For He being God by Nature has been made man in truth, that we too might be called offspring, no more of the first, that is, of the earthy, to whom it was said by God, Earth thou art and unto earth shalt thou return, who conducteth even unto death, but of the second, from above and out of Heaven, Christ I mean Who bringeth us again unto purest life, and rendereth incorrupt that which is holden of death and freeth from sins that which was enfolden by the toils of sin. Thus saith somewhere the Father Himself to the Son, Behold I have given Thee for a Covenant of the race for a Light of the Gentiles, to open the eyes of the blind, to bring forth of chains the bound and of the prison-house them that sat in darkness; and again by the voice of Isaiah, The beasts of the field shall honour Me, the Sirens and the daughters of the ostriches, because I gave water in the wilderness and rivers in the thirsty land to give drink to Mine offspring, chosen, My people whom I won for Myself, to declare My Virtues. The which understanding very well of those of the Gentiles called through faith unto true knowledge of God, the Divine-uttering Peter writeth and saith, But YE are a chosen race, a royal priesthood, an holy nation, a peculiar people, that ye should tell out the Virtues of Him Who calleth you out of darkness into His wondrous light, of old not a people, but now a people.

But if, as you think it good to think and say, "he who was sent is consubstantial with us," then he is no longer consubstantial with the Father. In that case, we have in no way been made partakers of the Divine Nature, but have remained, as I said, and still are, offspring of the first man, who leads us to curse and death and under the penalty of sin. We have therefore been deceived and are still in the same condition we were in long ago, before the Advent. How then did old things pass away and become new? And where is the truth of "If anyone is in Christ, he is a new creature"?4

But if as seems good to thee to think and say, "he was sent who is consubstantial with us," no longer with the Father, in no wise have WE been made partakers of the Divine Nature, but have abode as I said, and are yet offspring of the first, of him who conducteth unto curse and death and under penalty of sin. We have therefore been deceived and are no less now too in that case wherein we were of old and before the Advent. How then did old things pass away and lo they have become new? and where is, If any be in Christ, he is a new creature?4

But are you ashamed to confess the Word of God made man as we are? Do you therefore criticize Him and say that He planned nothing wise when He emptied Himself for our sakes? Therefore you will hear Him say, "Get behind Me, Satan, you are an offense to Me, for you do not savor the things that are of God but those of men." Search with us the God-inspired Scripture: He appeared long ago to the Patriarch Jacob too, when he was departing from Laban's household and was at the very fords of Jabbok, as it is written: "For Jacob was left alone, and there wrestled a man with him until morning, and he knows that he does not prevail against him, and he touched the hollow of his thigh, and the hollow of Jacob's thigh stiffened in his wrestling with him. And he said to him, 'Let me go, for the dawn has come,' and he said, 'I will not let you go unless you bless me.'" And after this again, "And Jacob called the name of that place, The Form of God, for I saw God face to face and my life was preserved; and the sun rose upon him when he passed by the Form of God." Understand therefore how He did not deign to show Himself then to the Patriarch as an incorporeal and impalpable Word, foreshadowing to him the type of the mystery, but He who wrestled and spent the whole night at it was a man. But when the day was dawning and it was morning, He says, "Let me go," which was clearly the word of one who was bringing the wrestling to an end.

But are you ashamed to confess the Word of God God made man as we? do you therefore chide Him and say that He hath planned no wise matter when He emptied Himself for our sakes? Therefore thou shalt hear Him say, Get thee behind Me Satan, thou art an offence unto Me, for thou savourest not the things that be of God but those of men. Search with us the God-inspired Scripture; He appeared of old to the Patriarch Jacob too when he was departing from Laban's hearth, and was at the very fords of Jabok, as it is written: for Jacob was left alone and there was wrestling a man with him until morning, and he knows that he prevaileth not against him and he touched the flat of his thigh and the flat of Jacob's thigh stiffened in his wrestling with him; and he said to him, Dismiss me for the dawn hath gone up, and he said, I will not dismiss Thee except Thou bless me. And after other again, And Jacob called the name of that place, The Form of God, for I saw God Face to face and my life was preserved; and the sun rose upon him when he passed by the Form of God. Understand therefore how not as incorporeal and impalpable Word did He deign to shew Himself then to the Patriarch, foreshewing to him the type of the mystery, but He Who wrestled and consumed the whole night thereupon was a man. But when the day was dawning and it was morning, He says, Dismiss Me, which was clearly the word of one who was bringing to an end the wrestling.

And we must explain what the plan of the mystery is. With those who remain as if in night and darkness, and have a spiritual mist over their mind and heart and cannot yet understand the mystery concerning Him, He typically wrestles and fights and overcomes. But with those who are now in light and, so to speak, in spiritual morning and have good understanding of the mystery, He no longer thinks it good to wrestle, but instead dispenses spiritual blessings to them. Therefore, if even eventually and with difficulty you yourself should also enter into the light and, so to speak, into the morning, He who conquers all would stop fighting with you. And see how, although it was a man who wrestled, the divinely-speaking Jacob says that he had seen God face to face, and the sacred Scripture added that the sun rose upon him when he passed by the Form of God. Why then, I ask, are you ashamed of the measures of the emptiness, even though everyone (I suppose) who both holds the right faith and examines accurately the purpose of the God-inspired Scripture says that the Word from God the Father was both incarnate and made man? He therefore who is consubstantial with us in that He has been made man, and with the Father Himself in that He has remained God even in human nature, was sent preaching remission to the captives and recovery of sight to the blind, and to heal the broken in heart, and to call the acceptable year of the Lord. For these deeds which have been done for us are His alone and no one else's, and one of the holy prophets shall be our guarantee, saying thus: No ambassador, no angel, but the Lord Himself saved us, who also most clearly says to us, Therefore My people shall know My Name in that day, I who speak am present. Yet if the one who has been sent were some mere man, how would He Himself be thought of as having spoken the Law which was given long ago to those of old? For if He were not proceeding as man, He would not be said to have been made man, lest He should be seen to have an existence earlier than His coming into being. But preexisting as God, He has indeed spoken the Law, but says that He is present in some strange and unusual way when He has been made man.

And what is the plan of the mystery, it is necessary to say. With them who abide as it were in night and darkness, and have a spiritual mist o'er mind and heart and I cannot yet understand the mystery Him-ward, He useth to wrestle and fight and overcome; but with them who are now in light and so to speak in spiritual morning and have good understanding of the Mystery, He thinketh not good any longer to wrestle, but dispenseth to them instead spiritual blessings. Hence if even at length and hardly you should enter in yourself too into the light and so to speak into the morning, He Who conquereth all would cease fighting with you. And see how whereas it was a man who wrestled, the Divine-uttering Jacob says that he had seen God Face to face: and the sacred Scripture added that the sun arose upon him when he passed by the Form of God. Why therefore (I pray) are you ashamed at the measures of the emptiness, albeit every one (I suppose) who both holds the right faith and examines accurately the aim of the God-inspired Scripture says that the Word out of God the Father was both Incarnate and made Man? He therefore Who is consubstantial with us, in that He has been made Man, and to the Father Himself, in that He hath remained God even in human nature, was sent preaching remission to the captives and recovery of sight to the blind, and to heal the broken in heart, and to call the acceptable year of the Lord: for His Alone and of none other are the deeds which have been wrought us, and one of the holy Prophets shall be our pledge, thus saying, No ambassador, no angel, but the Lord Himself saved us, who also most clearly saith to us, Therefore My people shall know My Name in that day, I Who speak am present. Albeit if he who has been sent were some mere man, how would Himself be conceived of as having spoken the Law which was long ago given to them of old? for not at all proceeding as man, would He be said to have been made man, lest He should be seen to have an existence elder to His coming into being: but preexisting as God, He hath spoken indeed the Law, but says that He is present in some strange and unwonted way when He has been made Man.

But yes, he says, the Word being God fulfills all things: how then was He also sent, for where was He not Who fulfills all things? What shall we admit—that the Divine and Consubstantial Trinity has been contracted rather than that it is spread over all and fulfills all things? Then how has the great Moses, when some of the people of old were building the tower reaching to Heaven, presented God saying, "Come let us go down and there confound their tongues"? What descent did the Nature that fills both Heaven and earth need? It is written of the Holy Spirit too, "The Spirit of the Lord has filled the earth." The blessed David sings and says of those who lie in the earth to God Who is able to give life, "You shall send forth Your Spirit and they shall be created and You shall renew the face of the earth." How is that sent forth which fills all things? Do not therefore put forward as something clever and hard to overturn the idea that He Who is able to fulfill all things, the Word out of God the Father, cannot possibly have been sent. Do not rush to undo the truth and overturn the power of the Mystery. Rather, consider that He speaks in human terms about the things that belong to God, and they are understood by us only in such a way as He alone may know, and as He is accustomed to act.

"But yes (says he) the Word being God fulfils all things: how then was He also sent, for where was He not Who fulfils all things?" what (tell me) shall we admit that the Divine and Consubstantial Trinity has been contracted rather than that it is spread over all and fulfils all things? Then how hath the great Moses, when some of them of old were building the Heaven-reaching tower, introduced God saying, Come let us go down and there confound their tongues? what descent needed the Nature That fills both Heaven and earth? it is written of the Holy Ghost too, The Spirit of the Lord hath filled the earth; the blessed David sings and says of them that lie in the earth to God Who is mighty to quicken, Thou shalt send forth Thy Spirit and they shall be created and Thou shalt renew the face of the earth. How is That sent forth which filleth all things? Do not therefore (putting forward as something clever and hard to be overturned, that He Who is mighty to fulfil all things, the Word out of God the Father, has His mission an impossibility) hasten to undo the truth and to overturn the power of the Mystery; but consider rather that He speaketh in human wise of the things that belong to God and they are conceived of by us in such sort as both Himself Alone may know, and as He is wont to act.

But since He receives the anointing as something small and human and vastly beneath the dignity of the Only Begotten, come, let us say what is reasonable about this point too, clearing away stumbling blocks. If He had not been made Man, let Him cast off human things, let Him reject the Economy as placing Him in an inferior position and putting Him below the Supreme Glory and God-befitting Excellence, for what is ours is petty to the Word. But since the Mystery is truly wise and the fact of the emptying cannot be rejected by Him, why do you recklessly find fault with things that are right? And why do you turn away as unseemly what is crowned with His approval? Did you see Him anointed humanly? Behold the same One also anointing divinely, for it is written that John also bore witness saying, I saw the Spirit descending like a dove and abiding upon Him, and I knew Him not, but He who sent me to baptize with water said to me, Upon whom you shall see the Spirit descending and remaining on Him, This is He who baptizes with the Holy Ghost, and I have seen and borne witness that This is the Son of God. For do you say that it is the work of the human nature to have power to baptize with the Holy Ghost those who believe? Yet how would it not be foolish to think this were so? For how would the lesser bestow the participation of that which is immeasurably superior? And observe that this very person upon whom the Spirit is said to descend and remain upon Him baptizes with the Holy Ghost, anointing (it is clear) as God with His own Spirit those who believe. And truly He rose from the dead and breathed on His disciples, saying, Receive the Holy Ghost. And they, receiving it, say, We received not the spirit of the world but the Spirit who is from God, that we might know the things that were freely given to us by God. The most wise Paul too writes, They that are in the flesh cannot please God, but you are not in the flesh but in the Spirit if indeed the Spirit of God dwells in you: if anyone does not have the Spirit of Christ, this person is not His. And elsewhere too, For as many as are led by the Spirit of God, these are the sons of God. Therefore when you see Him anointed with His own Spirit, remember the economy with flesh and take account of the human nature: when you see Him give the Spirit, marvel at this—God in human nature too.5

But since as little and human and in boundless degree below the dignity of the Only Begotten He receives the unction, come let us say what is reasonable upon this point too, undoing occasions of offence. If therefore He have not been made Man, let Him shake off things human, let Him repudiate the Economy as putting Him in inferior position and setting Him behind the Supreme Glory and God-befitting Excellence; for petty to the Word is what is ours. But since the Mystery is of a truth wise and the fact of the emptying not to be rejected by Him, why dost thou foolhardily find fault with things that are right? and turn away as uncomely what is crowned with His Approval? didst thou see Him anointed humanly? behold the same also anointing Divinely: for it is written that John too bare record saying, I saw the Spirit descending like a dove and abiding upon Him and I knew Him not, but He That sent me to baptize with water, He said unto me, Upon Whom thou shalt see the Spirit descending and remaining on Him, This is He which baptizeth with the Holy Ghost, and I have seen and borne record that This is the Son of God, For dost thou say that it is the work of the human nature to have power to baptize with the Holy Ghost them that believe? albeit how were it not folly to think that this were so? for how would the less bestow the participation of that which is immeasurably superior? And observe that this very person upon Whom the Spirit is said to soar down and to remain upon Him, baptizeth with the Holy Ghost, anointing (it is plain) as God with His own Spirit them that believe. And verily He rose from the dead, and breathed on His disciples, saying, Receive ye the Holy Ghost. And they receiving, say, WE received not the spirit of the world but the Spirit Which is out of God, that we might know the things that were freely given to us of God. The most wise Paul too writes, They that are in the flesh cannot please God, but YE are not in the flesh but in the spirit if so be that the Spirit of God dwell in you: if any man have not the Spirit of Christ, this man is not His. And elsewhere too, For as many as are led by the Spirit of God, these are the sons of God. Therefore when thou seest Him anointed with His own Spirit, remember the economy with flesh and take count of the human nature: when thou seest Him give the Spirit, with this marvel at God in human nature too.5

But this contentious man pays no attention to these things and says the following again:

But taking no account of these things this contentious man says again thus:

§4

Nestorius: "This is the one who was made a faithful High Priest to God, for he was made so—he was not so from eternity. This, heretic, is the one who gradually advanced to the dignity of the high priesthood. Hear a clearer voice calling out to you: 'Who in the days of His Flesh, when He offered up prayers and supplications with mighty cry and tears to Him who was able to save Him from death and was heard for His Piety, though He were Son, He learned obedience by the things He suffered and, made perfect, became to them that obey Him the Author of indissoluble salvation.' What is perfected is what advances gradually, heretic. Concerning this, John also cries out in the Gospels: 'Jesus was advancing in stature and wisdom and grace.' In keeping with these things, Paul also says: 'Made perfect He became to all them that obey Him the Author of eternal salvation, called of God a High Priest after the order of Melchizedek.' This is the one who is compared with Moses in regard to leadership, who is called the seed of Abraham, who is like his brethren in all things, who was made High Priest in time, who was perfected through sufferings, who because he suffered being tempted is able to help those who are tempted, who is called a High Priest after the order of Melchizedek. Why then do you interpret contrary to Paul, mixing together the Impassible God the Word with an earthly body and making Him a passible High Priest?"6

Nestorius: "This is he who was made a faithful High Priest to God, for he was made so, he was not so from eternity, this, heretic, is he who by little and little advanced unto the dignity of the high priesthood. Hear a clearer voice calling out to thee, Who in the days (it says) of His Flesh, when He offered up prayers and supplications with mighty cry and tears unto Him That was able to save Him from death and was heard for His Piety, though He were Son, He learned obedience by the things He suffered and, made perfect, became unto them that obey Him the Author of indissoluble salvation. That is perfected which advances by little and little, heretic. Respecting which John too cries out in the Gospels, Jesus was advancing in stature and wisdom and grace, conformably to which things Paul too speaking says, Made perfect He became unto all them that obey Him the Author of eternal salvation, called of God an High Priest after the order of Melchisedelc, this is he who is compared with Moses in regard to generalship, that is called seed of Abraham, that is like in all things to his brethren, that was made High Priest in time, that was perfected through sufferings, that in that he suffered beting tempted is able to succour them that are tempted, that is called an High Priest after the order of Melchisedek. Why then interpret contrary to Paul, commingling the Impassible God the Word with earthly body and making Him a passible High Priest?"6

Most vigorous attack, my friend, and truly spirited you have made upon the doctrines of piety. And the divine-speaking Baruch, pointing out the Word of God already Incarnate and seen in likeness to us, says, This is our God, there shall be no other accounted in comparison with Him. He found out all the way of knowledge and gave it to Jacob His servant and to Israel His beloved: afterward He showed Himself upon earth and conversed with men. But you, calling out and that very often, This, indeed almost putting forth your hand—who is it that you manifest to believers and cause to be seen by them, and say that he advanced little by little to the High Priesthood? I suppose it is surely he of whom you just now specifically said, "Therefore a Merciful High Priest is he who suffered, not the quickening God of him who suffered: the seed of Abraham is he who is yesterday and today, as Paul says, not he who says, Before Abraham was I am; like his brethren in all things is he who assumed brotherhood of human soul and flesh, not He who says, He who has seen Me has seen the Father." And that in affirming that the Life-giving Word of God is God of him who suffered, involving yourself in the charge of inevitable blasphemy, you have done no small wrong, as sufficient reasoning made clear to us. But I marvel that you, oblivious of your own words, think it right to say and believe that He advanced little by little to the dignity of the High Priest, whom you say is even God Almighty. For with the Epistle written to the Hebrews before you, you are caught saying, "Yet this is the man who according to the flesh is akin to Israel, who in what is visible is Man, who according to Paul's statement was made from the seed of David, by connection God Almighty." How then did He advance, according to that idle talk, to the dignity of High Priest although testified by your own voice as Almighty God?

Most vigorous onslaught, my friend, and truly spirited hast thou made upon the doctrines of piety. And the Divine-uttering Baruch, pointing out the Word of God already Incarnate and seen in likeness to us, says, This is our God, there shall none other be accounted of in comparison of Him, He found out all the way of knowledge and gave it to Jacob His servant and to Israel His beloved: afterward did He shew Himself upon earth and conversed with men. But THOU calling out and that full often, This, yea all but putting forth thine hand;—-who is it that you manifest to believers and cause to be seen of them, yea, and say that he advanced by little and little unto High Priesthood? I suppose it is surely he of whom but now specifying thou saidst, "Therefore a Merciful High Priest is he that suffered, not the quickening God of him that suffered: the seed of Abraham he who is yesterday and to-day, as Paul saith, not he who saith, Before Abraham was I am; like to his brethren in all things he that assumed brotherhood of human soul and flesh, not He Who saith, He that hath seen Me, hath seen the Father." And that in affirming that the Life-giving Word of God is God of him who suffered, involving yourself in the charge of inevitable blasphemy, you have done no slight wrong, sufficient reasoning made clear to us. But I marvel that thyself oblivious of thine own words, thou deemest right to say alike and think that He by little and little advanced unto the dignity of the High Priest, Whom thou sayest is even God Almighty. For the Epistle written to the Hebrews being before thee, thou art caught saying, "Yet is This man Who after the flesh is akin to Israel, Who in that which is visible is Man, Who according to Paul's speech was made out of the seed of David, by connection God Almighty." How did He yet advance, according to that idle talk, to the dignity of High Priest albeit testified by thy voice too as Almighty God?

And though you bring up that notorious connection, invented I don't know where by you alone, I will pass over it for now. But I will ask, letting the argument proceed straight along its own proper course: Does not that which advances toward priesthood and glory make its advance or progress toward something better and more excellent? And who would not agree that this is true? If so, then the high priesthood would be greater than being Almighty God. But then how does the one who has the priesthood also minister and stand as a worshiper before God, and as a servant before his master, offering what is customary and bringing sacrifices, while the One who is crowned with supreme glory receives the sacrifices and is honored by the service?

And though you utter the ill-famed connection and invented I know not whence by yourself alone, I will pass it over for the present: but I will ask, bidding the argument advance straight on its own befitting and proper course, Does not that which advances unto Priesthood and glory make its advance or progress unto the better and more excellent? and how will not every one whatever give his vote for the truth of this? Greater therefore than the being Almighty God, is the High Priesthood. Then how does he whose lot is the Priesthood minister too and stand as a worshipper by God, and as a servant by his master, offering what is customable and bringing sacrifices, and He Who is crowned with the Supreme glory receives the sacrifices and is honoured by the service?

But you say (I suppose) this: Being God Almighty, the Same has become High Priest. He has therefore been emptied and has humbled Himself by descending into the inferior. How then did He yet advance to dignity when made a High Priest? Remember again your own words, for you said a little earlier: "If the Godhead is High Priest, who is He who is served by the ministry of the High Priesthood? If He who offers is God, there is no one to whom the offering is made, for what is there worthy of Godhead that, as inferior, it should make offering to a greater?" Stand by your own words at least now. But you cannot do this, for you will be tossed about (so to speak) by every wind, and you do not perceive that you are being driven around, sometimes jumping from one position to another, and then from that one back again, and you are not at all afraid of what Paul says: For if I build again what I destroyed, I make myself a transgressor.7

But thou sayest (I suppose) this, Being God Almighty the Same hath become High-Priest. He hath been emptied therefore and hath abased Himself by descent into the inferior. How therefore did He yet advance unto dignity when made an High Priest? Remember again thine own words, for thus thou saidst a little above, "If the Godhead be High Priest, who is He who is served by the ministry of the High Priesthood? if He Who offereth be God, there is none to whom the offering is made, for what is there worthy of Godhead that as inferior It should make offering to a greater?" Stand now at least to your own words; but this you cannot do, for you will be borne about (so to say) by every wind, and perceive not that you are being driven about, one while springing off from those into these, other while again from these into those, and in no wise are you afraid of what Paul saith, For if what I destroyed this I build again, I make myself a transgressor.7

But you will perhaps say: If you affirm that the Word from God the Father is everywhere one Christ and Son and Lord together with His own Flesh, how can you now say that He has been set forth as a High Priest and Apostle? By saying this, are you not insulting the supreme dignity of His divine glory?

But you will perhaps say, Affirming that the Word out of God the Father is everywhere One Christ and Son and Lord, with His own Flesh, how sayest thou now that He has been set forth as an High Priest and Apostle? dost thou not in so saying insult the Supreme Dignity of His Divine Glory?

Because, good sir, I would say that the Only Begotten Word of God has been made man and within the limits of human nature, the fact of priesthood does not ill suit Him, and moreover the statement that He has been sent, for He despised the shame, as the divinely inspired Paul writes, and endured yet lower and worse things for our sakes: for He gave His back to the scourges, He did not turn His face away from the shame of spitting, and He patiently bore the insults of the Jews. But do you think it inappropriate to call Him priest, since He is God? Accept the words pertaining to the Economy, consider the emptying, the descent to the form of a servant. For we do not say that the Word of God advanced and hurried toward dignity if He has been called our high priest, but rather that in this too He descended to emptiness. Since how has He been emptied and is He said to have been humbled, even though He possesses unchangeableness and is in form and equality in everything with His Father? How also did He advance little by little and this (as you yourself say) to the dignity of the high priesthood? What sort of growth did He receive for this? If it was a bodily one, I will ask again: Does bodily growth lead up to the glory of the priesthood? Then let this be common to all and let this method of reasoning of yours belong to everyone who advances bodily. But in truth the priesthood does not suit all those who customarily advance to bodily growth. How then are you not ashamed in putting forth to us as proof of those things which you said, what was spoken by the divinely inspired Luke: "But Jesus was advancing in stature and wisdom and grace"?

Because, good Sir, (shall I say) the Only Begotten Word of God has been made man and in the measures of the human nature, the fact of Priesthood will not unbefit Him, and moreover the saying that He has been sent, for He despised the shame, as the Divine-uttering Paul writes, and endured yet lower and worser things for our sakes: for He gave His bach to the scourges, His Face He turned not away from the shame of spittings, and endurant He bore the contumelies of the Jews. But thou deemest not meet to call Him Priest, as being God? admit the words pertaining to the Economy, consider the emptying, the descent unto the servant's form. For we say not that the Word of God advanced and hastened unto dignity, if He have been styled our High Priest, but rather that He descended herein too unto emptiness. Since how has He been emptied and is He said to have been abased, albeit He possesseth unchangeableness and is in Form and Equality in everything with His Father? how too advanced He by little and little and this (as thyself sayest) unto the dignity of the High Priesthood? what sort of growth received He hereunto? If then it were a bodily one, I will ask again, Doth bodily growth lead up to the glory of the Priesthood: be then this common [to all] and let this method of reasoning of yours belong to every one who advanceth bodily, But of a truth the Priesthood beseemeth not all those who customably advance unto bodily growth; how therefore blushest thou not in putting forth unto us for demonstration of those things which thou saidst, what was spoken by the Divine-uttering Luke, But Jesus was advancing in stature and wisdom and grace?

But you say that the growth was toward wisdom, yet how is this not without learning? For we believe that from the very belly and womb of the Virgin, Emmanuel—being God—came forth as Man, fully possessing the wisdom and grace that are inherent by nature. What kind of growth, then, will He admit of, in whom are all the treasures of wisdom, who is with God the Father the co-giver of grace from above? How then is He said to advance? It is, I think, by God the Word measuring out alongside the increase and stature of His own body the manifestation of the most God-befitting goods that are in Him. For let us consider that although He was made man as we are, He was eager to remain hidden at first, and administered little by little, as it were quietly and in silence, the power of the mystery. And of this, God the Father Himself will be our assurance, saying: "Jacob My Servant, I will defend Him, Israel My chosen, My Soul received Him, I gave My Spirit upon Him, He shall bring forth judgment to the Gentiles: He shall not cry nor lift up, nor shall His voice be heard without: a bruised reed He shall not break and smoking flax He shall not quench." And somewhere He was rebuking the holy apostles themselves that they should not make Him known. Therefore something unusual and strange and worthy of examining would have been shown if, while still an infant, He had made a God-befitting demonstration of wisdom. But by extending it little by little and proportionably to His bodily stature and making it manifest to all, He will be said to advance—and that with good reason. How, therefore, did He advance little by little toward the priesthood, tell me, by being perfected in virtue? Then how or why may anyone doubt that what falls short of perfection in virtue will be under blame and not wholly an object of admiration—indeed perhaps even under charge of sin? But it is truly written that He committed no sin, nor was guile found in His mouth. Therefore He is fully perfect, being such in every way, and in no way will He lack what is needed to be complete in achieving virtue. And when was He who was God even in the womb not perfect toward good—of whom the prophet Isaiah also says, "Butter and honey shall He eat, before He has knowledge to prefer evil, He shall choose the good," because "before the Child shall know good or evil, He shall disobey vice to choose the good"? Where, then, will you be able to demonstrate Christ's imperfection toward good? Or what advance will He need who is so perfect as to disobey vice and prefer to it—indeed, only choose—good?8

But thou sayest that the growth was unto wisdom, albeit how is not this without learning? for we believe that out of the very belly and womb of the Virgin, Emmanuel being God proceeded forth Man, full surely of the wisdom and grace that are inherent of Nature. What sort of growth then will He admit of, in Whom are all the treasures of wisdom, Who is with God the Father Co-giver of the grace from above? how then is He said to advance? it is, I deem, by God the Word co-measuring with the increase and stature of His own Body, the manifestation of the most God-befitting goods that are in Him. For let us consider that although He has been made Man as we, He was zealous to lie hid at the first, and administered by little and little as it were noiselessly and in silence the might of the Mystery; and of this God the Father Himself will be our assurance saying, Jacob My Servant, I will defend Him, Israel My chosen, My Soul received Him, I gave My Spirit upon Him, He shall bring forth judgement to the Gentiles: He shall not cry nor lift up, nor shall His voice be heard without: a bruised reed. He shall not break and smoking flax He shall not quench. And He was somewhere rebuking the holy Apostles themselves that they should not make Him, known. Hence a thing unwonted and strange and worthy of looking into, would have been shewn, if being yet a babe, He had made a God-befitting demonstration of wisdom: but He little and little and proportionably to bodily stature, extending it and making it manifest to all, will be said to advance and that with reason. How therefore did He advance by little and little unto the Priesthood, tell me, by being perfected in virtue? Then how or whence may one doubt that that which faileth of perfection in virtue, will be under blame, and not wholly an object of admiration, yea rather haply under charge of sin? But it is indeed true that He hath done no sin neither was guile found in His Mouth, as it is written. Full-perfect therefore is He being such unto every thing, and in no wise will He have the lack of being complete unto the achievement of virtue. And when was He That was God in the womb too not Perfect unto good, of Whom the Prophet Isaiah too saith, Butter and honey shall He eat, before He have knowledge to prefer evil, He shall choose the good, because before the Child shall know good or ill, He shall disobey vice to choose the good? where then will you be able to demonstrate Christ's yet imperfectness unto good? or what advance will He need who is so Perfect as to disobey vice and to prefer to it, yea only choose, good?8

Yet I don't know how someone who affirms and says "This is he who gradually advanced to the dignity of the high priesthood," and who brought forward as proof of his words the text "Jesus advanced in stature and wisdom and grace"—almost marking out the impropriety of his own words and slipping into forgetfulness of what he claimed was right—now tells us that the mode of perfection was accomplished in a different way, saying "This is he who in time has been made High Priest, who was perfected through sufferings." Is this not obvious confusion? Or rather, proof of complete recklessness? For our Lord Jesus Christ has been made perfect through sufferings, but this man, even though he was not ignorant of the mode of being made perfect, leads the minds of simpler people astray into certain strange distortions of ideas and says that He advanced to being High Priest and has been perfected to this point, "who is said to have been emptied because this took place." And as though he had clearly shown that neither was the Word of God made flesh, nor did a Man proceed from a woman, he rebukes those who have chosen to believe this way and says, "Why then do you misinterpret Paul, mixing the Impassible God the Word with an earthly body and making Him a passible High Priest?" Hear then from us too, for whom the truth is dear: Why do you misinterpret Paul, or rather slander the whole God-inspired Scripture, removing the Word of God from the economy with flesh, and setting over us as priest a mere man honored with a connection? Yet you hear that the Same is both High Priest and Co-Throned with God the Father, as we have already said. For Paul said, "We have such an High Priest, who sat on the right hand of the throne of the Majesty in the heavens." That the Word out of God the Father is Impassible is, I suppose, clear to everyone; that He suffered for us in the flesh, the voice of inspired men will confirm as truth. But if you yourself take the Word out of God away from an earthly body, the whole thing falls apart. For if He has not been made Man, neither did He die for us, and if He has not given His own Body to death, how is He said to be the firstborn from the dead? Therefore Christ neither died nor rose again. So let the divinely-speaking Paul come forward and cry aloud, saying, "If the dead are not raised, neither has Christ been raised; if Christ has not been raised, your faith is worthless, you are still in your sins; those also who fell asleep in Christ have perished." But Christ has been raised from the dead, for the Only-Begotten Word of God has been made Man and, taking an earthly body and uniting it personally to Himself, by the grace of God, as it is written, tasted death for every man. He has been named firstfruits of those who slept, having been raised from the dead. Therefore our faith is now sure and not worthless, which we have as an anchor of the soul both sure and steadfast, as it is written.

Yet I know not how he who affirmeth and saith "This is he who by little and little advanced to the dignity of the high priesthood," and who brought forward in proof of his words, Jesus advanced in stature and wisdom and grace, all but marking out the uncomeliness of his own words and gliding into forgetfulness of the things of which he assumed were right, affirms to us that the mode of perfection was wrought in another way, saying, "This is he who in time has been made High Priest, who was perfected through sufferings." Is not this manifest distraction? yea rather a proof of utter recklessness? for our Lord Jesus Christ has been made perfect through sufferings, but this man albeit he was not ignorant of the mode of being made perfect, carries away the minds of the simpler unto certain strange perversions of ideas and says that He advanced unto being High Priest and has been perfected unto this, "Who is said to have been emptied because this took place. And as though he had full clearly shewn that neither was the Word of God made flesh, nor yet proceeded Man out of woman, he chides those who have chosen thus to hold and says, "Why therefore doth thou mis-interpret Paul, commingling with earthly body the Impassive God the Word and making Him a passible High Priest?" Hear therefore from us too, to whom rather the truth is dear, Why dost thou mis-interpret Paul, yea rather slanderest the whole God-inspired Scripture, withdrawing the Word of God from the economy with flesh, and settest over us as priest a man honoured with mere connection? albeit thou hearest that the Same is at once High Priest and Co-Throned with God the Father, as we have already said. For Paul said, We have such an High Priest, Who sat on the Right Hand of the Throne of the Majesty in the heavens. For that the Word out of God the Father is Impassible, is I suppose clear to every one: that He hath suffered for us in the flesh, the voice of inspired men will seal up for a truth. But if thyself bear away the Word out of God from earthly body, the whole will come to nothing. For if He have not been made Man, neither did He die for us, and if He have not given unto death His own Body, how is He said to be the first begotten from the dead? Hence Christ neither died nor revived. Let the Divine-uttering Paul therefore come forward, let him cry aloud saying, If the dead are not raised, neither has been Christ raised, if Christ have not been raised, vain is your faith, ye are yet in your sins: they also which fell asleep in Christ perished. But Christ has been raised from the dead, for the Only-Begotten Word of God has been made Man and, taking an earthly body and uniting it Personally to Him, by the grace of God, as it is written, tasted death for every man. He has been named first-fruits of them that slept, having been raised from the dead. Sure therefore and not vain is now our faith, which we have as an anchor of the soul both sure and stedfast, as it is written.

And he, as though he had not at all wronged the plan of the economy with flesh by saying such things and pouring out unrestrained and most foul vomit upon the doctrines of the truth, proceeds to another piece of bad advice—or rather to open blasphemy—and says,

And he, as though he had in no wise wronged the plan of the economy with flesh, through saying such things and pouring forth untempered and foulest vomit upon the doctrines of the truth, proceeds to another mis-counsel, yea rather manifest blasphemy and says,

§5

Nestorius: "This man alone is therefore our High Priest, who feels for us and is our kinsman and is trustworthy. Do not turn away from the faith toward Him, for He was sent as the blessing that was promised to us from the seed of Abraham, offering the sacrifice of His Body for Himself and His race alike."9

Nestorius: "This man alone therefore being our High Priest, feeling and kin and sure, turn ye not away from the faith Him-ward; for He was sent, the blessing which was proraised us out of the seed of Abraham, as offering the sacrifice of His Body for Himself alike and His race."9

You say that the High Priest who is kin to us and feeling and sure and moreover only is the one whom your discourse just now clearly taught us about. For you said, "The seed of Abraham is he who is yesterday and today, as Paul says, not He Who says, Before Abraham was I am; like his brethren in all things, he who assumed brotherhood of human soul and flesh, not He Who said, He that has seen Me has seen the Father; sent was he who is consubstantial with us and has been anointed to preach remission to the captives and recovery of sight to the blind." This man therefore will be conceived of as being kin to those on the earth, and not as you say, He That says, He that has seen Me has seen the Father. For if you gather both into one according to true union and confess with us One Son, you have labored in vain in carrying away each separately and apart from the other, severing into hypostases and prosopa completely—not in the mere knowledge that the nature (physis) of flesh is other than the Divine Nature but by concurrence into true union has become Its own. If on the other hand you desire to show yourself irreconcilable in opinion with us and utterly reject the union, and you say that He is one and another, and that the One has been begotten out of God the Father, the other of kin and consubstantial with us—how, tell me, do you say that we ought not now to turn aside from faith toward Him? And we shall believe him to be our kin, letting go Him Who says, Before Abraham was I am. We shall take as our god him who assumed brotherhood with us of human soul and flesh, letting go Him Who says, He that has seen Me has seen the Father, although He Himself says, For so God loved the world that He gave His Only-Begotten Son that whoever believes in Him should not perish but have everlasting life, and again, He that believes in Him is not condemned, but he that believes not is condemned already, because he has not believed in the Name of the Only-Begotten Son of God. Is he therefore who is from the seed of Abraham conceived of as Only-Begotten apart and by himself, although John has clearly written, The Only-Begotten Son which is in the Bosom of the Father, He declared Him, and moreover another Holy Scripture, But when He brings in the First-begotten into the world, He says, And let all Angels of God worship Him? But First-born wholly and surely will He be Who is among many brethren, not He Who is begotten Alone of the Alone God the Father. For thus far will we follow, sir, your distinctions, keenly awaiting for the economy's sake where the words burst through upon us. Hence—for I will call back the argument to its beginning—he that assumed brotherhood with us of human soul and flesh, yet was made out of the seed of Abraham, will be the Firstborn among many brethren, but He that is in the Bosom of God the Father, the Only-Begotten God the Word. Then when the God-inspired Scripture says that our faith must be had in the Only-Begotten Son of God, why do you, putting forward one kin and consubstantial with us, say that we ought not to turn away from faith toward him? It is therefore necessary to link together the two in One Lord and Christ, by personal coalescence, that is, in order that the Same may be conceived of as Only-Begotten and First-Begotten in the Same, in that the Word out of God the Father being God by Nature has been made Man as we and out of the seed of Abraham.

Thou sayest that a High Priest both kin to us and feeling and sure and moreover only, is he whom thy discourse but now clearly taught us of. For thou saidst, "The seed of Abraham is he who is yesterday and to-day, as Paul saith, not He Who saith, Before Abraham was I am; Like to His brethren in all things, he who assumed brother-hood of human soul and flesh, not He Who said, He that hath seen Me hath seen the Father; sent was he who is consubstantial with us and has been anointed to preach remission unto the captives and recovery of sight to the blind. " This man therefore will be conceived of as of kin too to those on the earth, and not as THOU sayest, He That saith, He that hath seen Me hath seen the Father. For if gathering both into one according to true union thou with us confessest One Son, thou hast laboured in vain, in bearing away each separately and apart from other, severing into hypostases and persons, completely, not in the mere knowledge that the nature of flesh is other than the Divine Nature yet by concurrence unto true union hath become Its own: if on the other hand desiring to shew thyself irreconcileable in opinion with us and utterly repudiating the union, thou sayest that He is one and another, and that the One has been begotten out of God the Father, the other of kin and consubstantial with us; how (tell me) dost thou say that we ought not now to turn aside from faith to Him-ward? and we shall believe him to be our kin, letting go Him Who saith, Before Abraham was I am: we shall take as our god him who assumed brotherhood with us of human soul and flesh, letting go Him Who saith, He that hath seen Me hath seen the Father, albeit Himself saith, For so God loved the world that He gave His Only-Begotten Son that whosoever believeth in Him should not perish but have everlasting life, and again, He that believeth on Him is not condemned, but he that believeth not is condemned already, because he hath not believed in the Name of the Only-Begotten Son of God. Is he therefore who is forth of the seed of Abraham conceived of as Only-Begotten apart and by himself, albeit John hath clearly written, The Only-Begotten Son which is in the Bosom of the Father, He declared Him, and moreover another Holy Scripture, But when He bringeth in the First-begotten into the world, He saith, And let all Angels of God worship Him? But First-born wholly and surely will He be Who is among many brethren, not He Who is begotten Alone of the Alone God the Father: for thus far will we follow, sir, thy distinctions, keenly awaiting for the economy's sake, whither the words burst through upon us. Hence (for I will call back the argument to its commencement) "he that assumed brotherhood with us of human soul and flesh," yet was made out of the seed of Abraham, will be the Firstborn among many brethren, but He that is in the Bosom of God the Father, the Only-Begotten God the Word. Then when the God-inspired Scripture says that our faith must be had in the Only-Begotten Son of God, why dost thou, putting forward one kin and consubstantial with us, say that we ought not to turn away from faith in him-ward? It is therefore necessary to link together 3 in One Lord and Christ, by personal coalescence that is, in order that the Same may be conceived of as Only-Begotten and First-Begotten in the Same, in that the Word out of God the Father being God by Nature has been made Man as we and out of the seed of Abraham.

But now he thinks he has discovered something clever, and so he says again:

But now something clever has been found out as he thinks by him and thus again says he:

§6

Nestorius: "Remember above all what I have often said to you, rejecting two natures in our Lord Christ that are twofold in nature but single in dignity: for the rule of the natures is one for the sake of their connection, while the natures always remain in their own proper order, but the dignity is connected as I said before to a single rule."

Nestorius: "Remember by all means what I have full often said to you, refusing two-fold natures in our Lord Christ, two-fold in nature, single in dignity: for the sway of the natures is for the connection's sake, one, the natures abiding ever in their own order, but the dignity connected as I said before unto a single sway."

Yes, you were an eager student, choosing to follow the God-inspired Scripture, which says "One Lord Jesus Christ" and does not separate Him who is from the seed of Abraham from the Word who is from God the Father. And we must also consider this: Godhead is one thing, and manhood like ours is another, according to the inherent nature of things. But through coalescence into true union, there is One Christ from both, as we have often said. But when the hypostases, as YOU say, have been separated into two and are thought of as existing separately and apart, how will there be a coalescence in one prosopon, unless one is thought of as the property of the other? This is just as a man's body will be thought of as the property of his soul, even though it is of a different nature than the soul, for soul and body are not the same things.

Yea apt at learning wert thou, who hast chosen to follow the God-inspired Scripture, which says One Lord Jesus Christ and does not put apart Him Who is out of the seed of Abraham and the Word out of God the Father. And besides one must consider this too: for one thing indeed is Godhead, another, manhood like ours, according to the inherent nature of things; but by coalescence unto true union, One Christ out of both, as we have full often said. But when the hypostases, as YOU say, have been severed into two and are conceived of as existing separately and apart, how will there be a coalescence in one Person, except one be conceived of as the property of the other: just as of a man's soul his body will be conceived of as the property, albeit of other nature than it, for not the same things are soul and body?

But (one may perhaps say) how is the Holy and Adorable Trinity distinguished into Three Hypostases, yet results in One Nature of Godhead? Because (I would say) the identity of Essence necessarily following upon the difference of [persons] leads the mind of believers upward to One Nature of Godhead. But with respect to Emmanuel, since Godhead is something other than manhood, unless we say that the Body of the Word became His own by true Union, how will One Prosopon be brought about, when each hypostasis, separately by itself, presents to us the distinctive property of both? And unless what was assumed has been made the own of the one who assumed it, a mere connection by coming together in dignity and authority alone will not be sufficient to bring about One Only Christ, the Same both God and Man. For then, truly indeed, it will be necessary not to turn aside from the faith toward Him, even though He is understood to be from the seed of Abraham according to the flesh. But if you say that He is one thing and another thing, and then affirm that our faith must be placed in him who is from the seed of Abraham, be well assured that you are bringing down upon your own head the charge of worshipping a man, even though you reject and rightly so the reputation of being a man-worshipper.1011

But (one may perchance say) how is the Holy and Adorable Trinity distinguished into Three Hypostases, yet issues in One Nature of Godhead? Because (I would say) the identity of Essence following of necessity upon the difference of…., carries up the mind of believers unto One Nature of Godhead: but in respect to Emmanuel, since Godhead is something other than manhood, unless we say that the Body of the Word became His own by true Union, how will One Person be effected, when either hypostasis, apart by itself, brings before us the property of both? And except the assumed have been made the own of the assumer, connection by concurrence simply in dignity alone and sway will not suffice to effect One Only Christ, the Same God Alike and Man. For then, then, in very sooth, [it will behove not] to turn aside from the faith unto Himward, even though He be conceived of as out of the seed of Abraham after the flesh. But if you say that He is one and other and then affirm that our faith must be put in him that is out of the seed of Abraham, be well assured that you are pouring down upon your own head the charge of man-worship, albeit you repudiate and rightly the repute of being a man-worshipper.1011

Yes, and considering it too insignificant to think correctly, he slanders the great Mystery of godliness in yet another way as well. For he immediately adds the following:

Yea and thinking it too little to deem aright, he slanders in another way too the great Mystery of godliness. For he subjoins forthwith,

Nestorius: "For he was sent to us, the blessing having been promised from the seed of Abraham, offering the sacrifice of his body for himself and also for his race."

Nestorius: "For he was sent to us, the blessing being promised out of the seed of Abraham, offering the sacrifice of his body for himself alike and his race."

Was Christ Himself also made subject to sin? He through whom sin's accusation against us is silenced, according to the Psalmist's voice? Did the darkness of accursed crime touch the Very Light Himself? Did He who is all redemption and hope of salvation need a redeemer and Savior along with us? It would suit him, it seems, to offer thanksgiving along with us when God in His clemency says, I am He who blots out your sins and I will not remember them. The father of sin will accuse him too, just as he accuses us. And then how will he not speak falsely when saying, The prince of this world comes, and in Me he shall find nothing? The leaders of the synagogue of the Jews once blasphemed against Him, for when they were worn out by the arrows of envy at seeing the man blind from birth healed in an unprecedented way, they impiously said, Give glory to God, we know that this man is a sinner. But our Lord Jesus Christ, convicting them of their unbridled speech, said plainly, Which of you convicts Me of sin? And if I say the truth, why do you not believe Me? Therefore, if He has offered sacrifice both for us and moreover for Himself too, He surely has needed it, just as we too who are under the yoke of sin. Convict Him therefore of sin. If He has offered sacrifice with us, show Him to be a co-sinner with us. Being the Good Shepherd, for whom has He laid down His life—for Himself or for the sheep? I hear Him saying of us, For their sakes do I sanctify Myself. And as the divinely-inspired Paul says, By the grace of God He tasted death for every man, and again, He was delivered up because of our transgressions and was raised because of our justification. And as the Prophet Isaiah says, The chastisement of our peace was upon Him, with His stripes we were healed—not He Himself has been healed by the suffering of His own Flesh. He was delivered up because of our transgressions, not because of His own—far from it, for confessedly has the physis of man been brought down by the transgression in Adam to curse and death, and it is moreover sick with proneness to sin in the flesh—in order that the righteousness of the Law might be fulfilled in us who walk not after the flesh but after the spirit. For this reason He was also named the last Adam, not enduring to be sick with the things of the first one, but rather ridding the physis of man in Himself first from the blame of that ancient transgression. For it was condemned in Adam, but in Christ was seen most approved and worthy of wonder. Therefore the first is earthy, but Christ is heavenly. And it was put to shame in the first, brought down to disobedience which is sin, but in Christ it has preserved non-transgression, and as in a second firstfruits of the race, was seen both unwounded by sins and superior to curse and doom and death and decay. And the most wise Paul confirms us in this, writing thus: For as through one man's disobedience the many were made sinners, so too by the obedience of one shall the many be made righteous. Everyone who has become guilty of sin therefore needs sacrifice for his own transgressions, and Christ has offered Himself for His kin according to the flesh, that is, for us. But for Himself not at all, being superior to sin as God. For if He has been sacrificed for Himself, not we alone have been bought by His Blood according to the Scriptures, but Himself too will have been co-bought with us. No longer according to Isaiah's voice did the Lord give Him up for our sins, but He has been given rather for His own. For where there is sacrifice and offering, there surely is also remission of sins. The divinely-inspired Paul therefore has exposed those everywhere under heaven by writing regarding Him: For such a High Priest was fitting for us, holy, harmless, undefiled, separated from sinners and made higher than the heavens, Who does not need daily, as the high priests do, to offer up sacrifice, first for his own sins then for the people's, for this He did once when He offered up Himself. For the Law makes men high priests who have infirmity, but the word of the oath which came after the Law makes the Son Who has been perfected for evermore. How therefore is Christ a holy High Priest? Or in what way is He harmless and undefiled? And if He needs sacrifice with us, having made His offering for remission of transgressions and for justification of those who have sinned, how has He been separated from sinners if He is justified along with them, the sacrifice having been offered for none other than these very persons? But I marvel that whereas Paul has cried aloud and very clearly that He is not like those who have been commanded to offer for their own transgressions and then for the people's, you were not afraid to put forth the contrary to what he said, and dared to say that after the likeness of those who were made priests according to the Law, He too offered up sacrifice for Himself. And if it is true that the Law makes men high priests who have infirmity, but the word of the oath which came after the Law makes the Son Who has been perfected for evermore, why do you count among those who are subject to infirmity Him who has been removed from their multitude and possesses the perfection which is above the Law, of His own and by physis, if indeed He is truly Son and therefore God?

Was Christ then Himself too made under sin? He through whom sin's mouth against us is stopped, according to the Psalmist's voice? did the darkness of accursed crime touch the Very Light Himself? needed then with us He through Whom is all redemption and hope of salvation a redeemer and Saviour? it will befit him (it seems) with us to offer thanksgiving, when God in His Clemency says, I am He That blotteth out thy sins and I will not remember them; him too even as we will the father of sin accuse. And then how will he not speak falsely saying, The prince of this world cometh, and in Me he shall find nothing? The presidents of the synagogue of the Jews once blasphemed against Him, for when they were worn out by the darts of envy, at seeing the blind from his birth in unwonted manner healed, they impiously said. Give glory to God, WE know that this man is a sinner, but our Lord Jesus Christ, convicting them of unbridled utterance said plainly, Which of you convicteth Me of sin? and if I say the truth, why do YE not believe Me? Hence, if He have offered sacrifice, both for us and moreover for Himself too, He surely hath needed it, even as we too who are under the yoke of sin: convict Him therefore of sin; if He hath offered sacrifice with us, shew Him co-sinner with us. Being the Good Shepherd, for whom hath He laid down His Life, for Himself rather or for the sheep? I hear Him saying of us, For their sakes do I sanctify Myself, and as the Divine-speaking Paul saith, By the grace of God for every man tasted He death, and again, He was delivered up because of our transgressions and was raised because of our justification, and as the Prophet Esaias saith, The chastisement of our peace was upon Him, with His stripes were WE healed, not Himself has been healed by the suffering of His own Flesh. He was delivered up because of our transgressions (not because of His own, far from it, for confessedly has the nature of man been borne down by the transgression in Adam unto curse and death, it is moreover sick of proneness to sin in the flesh), in order that the righteousness of the Law might be fulfilled in its who walk not after the flesh but after the spirit. For therefore was He also named the last Adam, not enduring to be sick of the things of the first one, but rather ridding in Himself first the nature of man from the blame of that ancient transgression. For it was condemned in Adam, but in Christ was seen most approved and worthy of wonder. Earthy therefore is he, but Christ heavenly. And it was put to shame in the first, borne down to disobedience which is sin, but in Christ hath it preserved untransgression, and as in a second firstfruits of the race, was seen both unwounded by sins, and superior to curse and doom and death and decay. And the most wise Paul confirms us herein, thus writing, For as through one man's disobedience the many were made sinners, so too by its obedience of one shall the many be made righteous. Every one who has become guilty of sin needs therefore sacrifice for his own transgressions: and Christ hath offered Himself for His kin according to the flesh, i. e., for us; but for Himself not a whit, being superior to sin, as God. For if He have been sacrificed for Himself, not WE alone have been bought by His Blood according to the Scriptures but Himself too will have been co-bought with us, no longer according to Isaiah's voice did the Lord give Him up for our sins, but He has been given rather for His own. For where is at all sacrifice and offering, there surely is also remission of sins. The Divine-uttering Paul therefore hath beguiled those throughout all under heaven by writing regarding Him, For such an High Priest became us, holy harmless undefiled, separated from sinners and made higher than the heavens, Who needeth not daily as the high priests to offer up sacrifice, first for his own sins then for the people's, for this He did once when He offered up Himself: for the Law maketh men high priests which have infirmity, but the word of the oath which was since the Law, the Son Who hath been perfected for evermore. How therefore is Christ an holy High Priest? or in what way harmless and undefiled? And if He need with us sacrifice, having made His offering for remission of transgressions and for justification of them that have sinned, how has He been separated from sinners, if He be justified along with them, the sacrifice having been offered for none else than these very persons? But I marvel that whereas Paul hath cried aloud and that full clearly that He is not like those who have been bidden to offer for their own transgressions, and then for the people's, thou wert not afraid to put forth the contrary to what he said, and durst say that after the likeness of them who were made priests according to the Law, He too offered up sacrifice for Himself. And if it be true that the Law maketh men High Priests which have infirmity, but the word of the oath which was since the Law, the Son Who hath been perfected for evermore, why makest thou connumerate with those who are used to infirmity Him Who has been removed from their multitude; and possesses the perfection which is above the Law, of His own and by Nature, if so be He be Son of a truth and therefore God?

But let us also examine the legal and more ancient scripture to understand in what manner and for whom Emmanuel offered Himself as a fragrant aroma to God the Father. For the Law was admittedly a shadow, yet it contains the outline of the mystery pointing toward Christ and struggles to express the form of the Truth. Indeed, Christ said somewhere when speaking with the Jews, "If you had believed Moses, you would have believed Me, for he wrote about Me." How then did those of the blood of Israel sacrifice the Lamb when they were about to leave the Land of the Egyptians? Did they sacrifice it for themselves alone or for the Lamb's sake as well? Whom did it redeem by its blood? Was it those who were under the yoke of slavery and were enduring the unbearable oppression of the Egyptians, or itself as well? Whose destroyer did it drive away? To whom did the God of all say, "And I will see the blood and will protect you"? Was it to those who needed His protection, or to the Lamb itself as well?

But let us see from the legal and more ancient scripture too in what manner and for whom, Emmanuel hath offered Himself for an odour of a sweet smell unto God the Father. For a shadow confessedly was the Law, yet hath it the outline of the mystery Christ-ward and travails with the form of the Truth. And indeed Christ said somewhere when conversing with the Jews, Had ye believed Moses ye would have believed Me, for of Me he wrote. How therefore did they of the blood of Israel when about to depart out of the Land of the Egyptians sacrifice the Lamb? for their own selves alone or for the Lamb's sake too? whom did it redeem by its blood? was it them who were under the yoke of bondage, and were enduring the oppression hard to bear of the Egyptians, or itself too? whose destroyer did it scare away? to whom said the God of all, And I will see the blood and will shelter you? was it to those who needed His shelter or to the Lamb itself too?

In the Law, God the Father was depicting the sacrifices that would be made for sins, as if on a tablet, sketching out the mystery of Christ. He said to the high priest Moses: "If the whole congregation of the children of Israel sins unintentionally and the matter is hidden from the eyes of the assembly, and they have done something against any of the Lord's commandments that should not be done, and have transgressed, and the sin they committed becomes known to them, the congregation shall offer a young bull without blemish from the herd for the sin." After explaining in full detail how the sacrifice should be performed, He adds: "And the priest shall make atonement for them and the sin shall be forgiven them." Notice, then, that the bull was offered as a type of Christ the All-Pure, who has no spot, and that those who offer it—not the bull itself—were set free from their guilt. For He was sacrificed not for Himself, as you claim, but for the weak, for whom the high priest under the Law used to make supplication, so that you may again understand Him who was made an Advocate for us, a High Priest undefiled and holy, separated from sinners.

For God the Father was representing the sacrifices that were to be made for sins, in the Law as on a tablet, outlining yet the mystery of Christ, and thus He said to the hierophant Moses, If the whole congregation of the children of Israel sin unwillingly and the thing be hid from the eyes of the assembly and they have done one of all the commandments of the Lord which should not be done, and have transgressed and the sin be known to them which they have sinned therein, the congregation shall offer a young bullock without blemish from among the herd for the sin. And having fully gone through how the details of the sacrifice should be done, He adds and says, And the priest shall make an atonement for them and the sin shall be forgiven them. Observe then that the bullock was offered as a type of Christ the All-Pure and That hath no spot, and they who offer and not surely the bullock were set free from their guilt. For He has been sacrificed not rather for Himself, as THOU sayest, but for the infirm, for whom the high priest according to the Law used to make supplication, that you may again understand Him That was made an Advocate for us, a High Priest undefiled and holy, separated from sinners.

Since our opponent is thoroughly afflicted with confused speech, we say that the Word from God the Father became the High Priest and Apostle of our confession when He became Man, humbling Himself to the point of emptiness and taking on our human condition. He did this so that by offering Himself to the Father as a fragrant sacrifice on behalf of all people, He might win everyone under heaven, remove the ancient guilt, justify by grace through faith, make those who confess Him as their Savior and Redeemer superior to death and decay—people who are holy, sanctified, and thoroughly trained in every kind of virtue. Through Him and with Him, glory to God the Father with the Holy Spirit forever. Amen.

Since therefore our opponent is on all sides sick of uncomeliness of speech, we say that the Word out of God the Father was made the High Priest and Apostle of our confession when He was made Man, abasing Himself unto emptiness and in our condition: in order that having offered Himself to the Father for an odour of sweet smell in behalf of all, He might win all under Heaven, might remove the ancient guilt, might justify by grace through faith, might render superior to death and decay, holy and hallowed and full well versed in every kind of virtue, confessing Him their Saviour and Redeemer, through Whom and with Whom to God the Father be glory with the Holy Ghost for evermore. Amen.


Five Tomes Against Nestorius — Book II

After the union the Word is one incarnate Person: mere ‘connection’ does not unite, and Christ’s anointing and glory are His own, not a man’s.

The Word after the Union One Incarnate Person. Similitudes of unlike things united. ' Connection ' does not unite. The Name Christ means God the Son Incarnate. Jacob's pillar a type. To His human nature belong the anointing and His subjection to the Law: yet He is God. Cyrus how christ, the Babylonians how holy. Personal Union. Christ's glory no imparted glory but His own inherent glory. If community of names unite, Emmanuel has nought more than we. The human cannot be allotted to a distinct person. God the Son incarnate to be worshipped just as before His Incarnation. Speak not of 'hidden' and 'manifest' as though Two, they are One. Worship of Him taught by God the Father.

Source: Cyril of Alexandria, Five Tomes Against Nestorius (1881) Book 2. pp.38-80.. Transcribed by Roger Pearse (tertullian.org); public domain.

Contents · 15 chapters
  1. Opening
  2. §1
  3. §2
  4. §3
  5. §4
  6. §5
  7. §6
  8. §7
  9. §8
  10. §9
  11. §10
  12. §11
  13. §12
  14. §13
  15. §14

Opening

The tongue is a fire and an unruly evil, as it is written. Driving away the harm that comes from it, the God-inspired David says, Set a watch, O Lord, before my mouth, a door of protection around my lips, incline not my heart to words of wickedness. To be able to speak correctly and to have precise control over the tongue—knowing what it should say and what it should not—is truly a gift from God, and is no small matter for those who live a life worthy of admiration. But carelessness in speech and unrestrained freedom to deceive are full of danger and drag down to the pit of hell those who practice them. And it is written, Death and life are in the power of the tongue, and those who master it shall eat its fruits. Another wise man has also said to us, If you have a word of understanding, answer, but if not, lay your hand upon your mouth. For how is silence not better than ignorant speech? But it is cursed in yet another way to pour out bitter words and to pile sinful sayings upon the ineffable Glory, even though it ought to be honored by us with unceasing praises. And when we sin against the brethren and wound their weak conscience, we sin against Christ, for so the God-inspired Paul has written.

The tongue is a fire and an unruly evil, as it is written; thrusting from him the mischief therefrom, the Divine-uttering David says, Set a watch, O Lord, before my mouth, a door of fencing around my lips, incline not mine heart to words of wickedness. For to be able to speak aright, and to have an exact control over the tongue, as to what it should speak, what not, is of a truth God-given, and is no slight matter with those who practise a conversation not void of admiration. But recklessness in speech and unbridled licence unto trickery, are replete with danger and bear down to the pit-fall of hell those who use it. And it is written, Death and life are in the hand of the tongue, they that master it shall eat the fruits thereof. A certain other too of the wise men hath said to us, If thou hast a word of understanding, answer, if not, lay thine hand upon thy mouth; for how is not silence better than unlearned speech? But accursed is it in another way too to belch forth bitter words, and to heap down sinful sayings upon the ineffable Glory, albeit it ought to be honoured by us with unceasing praises. And when we sin against the brethren and wound their weak conscience, we sin against Christ, for so hath written the Divine-uttering Paul.

And I say this having read Nestorius' words and seeing that he not only says we should not call the holy Virgin Mother of God and that she gave birth to Emmanuel who is God, but also in many other ways he is determined to attack the glory of Christ. For he tries to show us that Christ is God-bearing and not truly God, but a man associated with God in a relationship of equal rank. For this is how he alone—apart from everyone else—thinks it right to think and speak, even though the Catholic Church, which Christ Himself presented to Himself, does not have the wrinkles of one who has put together such things. Rather, as unblemished, she keeps completely beyond reproach her knowledge of Him and has fully preserved her tradition of the Faith. For we believe in One God, the Father Almighty, Maker of all things both visible and invisible, and in One Lord Jesus Christ, and in the Holy Spirit. And following the confessions attached to this of the holy Fathers, we say that the very Word, who essentially came forth from God the Father, became as we are and was Incarnate and made Man—that is, took to Himself a body from the holy Virgin and made it His own. For in this way He will be truly One Lord Jesus Christ; in this way let us worship Him as One, not separating Man and God, but believing that He is one and the same in Godhead and in Manhood—that is, God and Man alike.

And this I say having read Nestorius' words and observing that he not only says that we ought not to say that the holy Virgin is Mother of God and that she hath borne Emmanuel Who is God, but yet in addition to this and in many ways is he minded to make war upon the glory of Christ. For he endeavours to shew us that He is God-bearing and not truly God, but man associated with God; as in equality of rank. For thus seems good to him alone apart from every one else, to think and to speak, albeit the Catholic Church, which Christ Himself presented to Himself, has not the wrinkles of him who has compiled such things, but rather as unblemished, she keeps wholly without rebuke her knowledge of Him, and hath made full well her tradition of the Faith. For we believe in One God, the Father Almighty, of all things both visible and invisible the Maker, and in One Lord Jesus the Christ, and in the Holy Ghost: and following the confessions annexed hereto of the holy Fathers, we say that the Very Word Essentially sprung from forth God the Father, was made as we and was Incarnate and made Man, that is, took to Himself a Body from forth the holy Virgin, and made it His Own: for thus will He be truly One Lord Jesus Christ, thus let us worship Him as One, not putting apart Man and God, but believing that He is One and the Same, in Godhead and in Manhood, that is, God alike and Man.

But the inventor of the most recent impiety, although pretending to speak of One Christ, constantly divides the natures and sets each one apart by itself, saying that they did not truly come together. Instead, making excuses in sins, as it is written, he devises some mode of connection consisting merely (as I said) of equality of rank, as will be shown from his own words. He makes the Word from God indwell by participation, as in an ordinary man, and distributes the sayings in the Gospels so that sometimes he attributes certain ones to the Word alone and by Himself, and at other times to the one born from a woman separately. Yet how is it not obvious to everyone that the Only-Begotten, being God by nature, has been made man—not by mere connection (as he says) considered as external or accidental, but by true union, ineffable and beyond understanding? And thus He is conceived of as One and Only, and everything said befits Him and all will be said of One Person. For the incarnate physis of the Word Himself is, after the union, now conceived of as One, just as will reasonably be conceived regarding ourselves too, for man is truly one, compounded of unlike things—soul I mean and body. But it is necessary now to point out that we say the body united to God the Word is ensouled with a reasonable soul. And I will add this too for profit's sake: the flesh is other than the Word from God in regard to its proper nature, and the physis of the Word Itself is again other essentially. But even though the things named are conceived of as diverse and separated in diversity of nature, Christ is still conceived of as One out of both, the Godhead and manhood having come together with one another in true union.12

But the inventor of the most recent impiety, albeit making feint of saying One Christ, ever divides the Natures and sets Each by itself, saying that they did not truly come together; but making excuses in sins, as it is written, devises some mode of connection, of merely (as I said) equality of rank, as shall be shewn from his own words: and he makes the Word out of God indwell by participation, as in a common man, and distributes the sayings in the Gospels, so as one while to attribute certain to the Word alone and by Himself, other while to him that is born from forth a woman separately. Yet how is it not obvious to all that the Only-Begotten being God by Nature has been made man, not by connection simply (as he says) considered as external or accidental, but by true union, ineffable and passing understanding. And thus He is conceived of as One and Only, and every thing said befits Him and all will be said of One Person. For the Incarnate Nature of the Word Himself is after the Union now conceived of as One, just as will reasonably be conceived in regard to ourselves too, for man is really One, compounded of unlike things, soul I mean and body. But it is necessary now too to notify that we say that the Body united to God the Word is ensouled with a reasonable Soul. And I will for profit's sake add this too: other than the Word out of God is the flesh, in regard to its proper nature, other again Essentially the Nature of the Word Itself. But even though the things named be conceived of as diverse and sundered in diverseness of nature, yet is Christ conceived of as One out of both, the Godhead and manhood having come together one to another in true union.12

The God-inspired Scripture confirms this for us through countless words and acts, using similitudes by which one may (and without difficulty) clearly advance to behold the Mystery of Christ. The blessed Prophet Isaiah therefore said, "And there was sent to me one of the Seraphim and in his hand a live coal which he had taken with the tongs from off the altar and he touched my mouth and said, Lo this hath touched thy lips and shall take away thine iniquities and purge thy sins." When we search according to our ability into the depth of this vision, we say that none other than our Lord Jesus Christ is the spiritual coal laid on the altar where it gives forth to God the Father the sweet savor of incense through us, for through Him we have had access and are acceptable, offering the spiritual worship. This Divine Coal, therefore, when it touches the lips of the one who approaches it, will immediately show him to be pure and wholly without participation in any sin. And the blessed Paul will teach us in what way it touches our lips, saying, "Nigh thee is the word, in thy mouth and in thy heart, that if thou say with thy mouth Lord Jesus and believe in thy heart that God hath raised Him from the dead, thou shalt be saved, for with the heart man believeth unto righteousness, and with the mouth confession is made unto salvation." And He is compared to a Coal because He is conceived as being from two unlike things, yet by a true coming together they are nearly knit together into union. For the fire entering into the wood will somehow transform it into its own glory and might, although it has retained what it was.

And the God-inspired Scripture confirms us hereto by ten thousand words and acts: using similitudes whereby one may (and that without labour) clearly advance so as we may behold the Mystery of Christ. The blessed Prophet Isaiah said therefore, And there was sent to me one of the Seraphim and in his hand a live coal which he had taken with the tongs from off the altar and he touched my mouth and said, Lo this hath touched thy lips and shall take away thine iniquities and purge thy sins. And searching according to our power into the depth of the vision, we say that none other save our Lord Jesus Christ is the spiritual coal laid on the altar whereon by us it gives forth the sweet savour of incense to God the Father: for through Him have we had access and are acceptable, offering the spiritual worship. This Divine Coal therefore, when it touches the lips of him who approaches thereto, will straightway exhibit 'him pure and wholly imparticipate in any sin. And in what way it touches our lips, the blessed Paul will teach saying, Nigh thee is the word, in thy mouth and in thy heart, that if thou say with thy mouth Lord Jesus and believe in thy heart that God hath raised, Him from the dead, thou shalt be saved, for with the heart man believeth unto righteousness, and with the mouth confession is made unto salvation. And He is compared to a Coal, because conceived of as from two unlike things, yet by a true concurrence they are all but knit together unto union. For the fire entering into the wood, will transelement it somehow into its own glory and might albeit it hath retained what it was.

Our Lord Jesus Christ also compares Himself to a pearl, saying, "The kingdom of heaven is like a merchant seeking fine pearls, who, when he had found one pearl of great price, went and sold all that he had and bought it." I hear Him revealing Himself to us in another way when He says, "I am the flower of the plain, the lily of the valleys." For He has in His proper nature the God-befitting brightness of God the Father, and He gives forth His fragrance—I mean in respect of spiritual fragrance. Therefore, just as in the pearl and also the lily, the thing itself is understood as a body, while the brilliance or fragrance within it is considered in its proper definition as something other than the things in which they exist, yet these properties remain inseparably inherent and belong to those which possess them—in this same way, I believe, we should both reason and think about Emmanuel. For Godhead and flesh are of different kinds by physis, yet the Body of the Word was His own, and the Word is not separated from His Body to which He is united; for only in this way can Emmanuel, that is, God with us, be rightly understood. Therefore, at one time as Man, manifesting Himself to us from the measures of the emptying as well, He said, "No one takes My life from Me." At another time, understood as God the Word and from Heaven and one with His proper flesh, He says, "No one has ascended into Heaven except He who came down from Heaven, the Son of Man."3

Our Lord Jesus Christ again likens Himself to a Pearl, saying, The kingdom of heaven is like unto a merchant man seeking goodly pearls, who when he had found one Pearl of great price hath gone and sold all that he had and bought it. I hear Him in another way manifesting Himself to us and saying, I am the flower of the plain, the lily of the valleys. For He has in His Proper Nature the God-befitting Brightness of God the Father, and gives forth again His Savour, in respect I mean of spiritual fragrance. As therefore in the pearl and also the lily, the thing itself is conceived of as body, the brilliancy or fragrance therein considered in its proper definition as other than they in whom they are, yet are the things inseparably innate again the own properties and not alien from those which possess them:—- in this way (I deem) shall we both reason and think of Emmanuel too. For of diverse kind by nature are Godhead and flesh, yet was the Body of the Word His own, and not severed from His Body is the Word which is united thereto; for thus and not otherwise will Emmanuel, i.e., God with us, be conceived of. Hence one while as Man, and making Himself manifest to us from the measures of the emptiness too, He said, No man takes My life from Me, another while again conceived of as God the Word and out of Heaven and One with His proper flesh, He says, No man hath ascended up to Heaven but He That came down from Heaven, the Son of Man.3

The Holy Scripture therefore from every side weaves the Son together into an inseparable and true union, and leads us back in faith to One Person. But this extraordinary man divides this in many ways and has spoken foolishly, calling the Word from God the Father "God of Christ Himself too," as our discussion will clearly demonstrate in its proper time and place as it proceeds. For he pretends to be afraid that anyone, overcome by reverence for the holy Virgin and calling her Mother of God, might suppose there is a mixture and blending of the Persons one with another and thus pour forth indecency upon the doctrines of the Church—although no one actually thinks this way. And while correcting (as he imagines) something so terrible, he completely confuses everything, disregarding ideas that pertain to correctness and truth. For he said this:

The Holy Scripture therefore from every side knitting together unto inseverable and true union the Son and bearing us back in faith unto One Person, this extraordinary man manifoldly severs, and hath babbled idly, calling the Word out of God the Father God of Christ Himself too, as our discourse as it advances will clearly demonstrate in its own time and place. For he feigns that he is afraid lest any overcome by reverence for the holy Virgin, and calling her Mother of God, should, supposing that there is a mixture and immingling of the Persons one with another pour forth uncomeliness upon the doctrines of the Church, albeit no one thus thinks: and rectifying (as he deems) a thing so dire, he utterly confuses all things, regardless of ideas which pertain to rightness and truth: for he said thus;

§1

Nestorius: "If you had been promoting the term Mother of God out of simple faith, I would not have objected after examining what the term means. But since I see that under the pretext of honoring the blessed Mary, you are actually maintaining the blasphemy of the heretics, I therefore resist the use of this term, suspecting the danger hidden in it. But to speak clearly and more intelligibly to everyone, it is the goal of the followers of Arius and Eunomius and Apollinarius and all who share their beliefs to introduce Theotokos, as if a mixing had taken place and the two physis were not divided, so that nothing of the lower things were taken from the human physis, and they ultimately applied them to the Divinity, as though all things were spoken of One, not in regard to rank from connection, but to physis. For One is Christ, and One Lord: but with respect to Christ, I mean the Only-Begotten Son, both Christ and Son are said sometimes of the Godhead, other times of the Manhood and Godhead."45

Nestorius: "If in simple faith you had been putting forward the word Mother of God, I would not have grudged it you, on examining the sense of the word. But since I see that you, on plea of honouring the blessed Mary, are maintaining the blasphemy of the heretics, I therefore ward off the putting forth of the word, suspecting the danger that is concealed therein. But to speak clearly and more intelligibly to all, it is the aim of the party of Arius and Eunomius and Apolinarius and of all who are of like brotherhood, to bring in Theotokus, as though, a mingling having taken place and the two natures not divided, nought of the meaner things were taken of the human nature, and they had place at length against the Divinity, as though all things were spoken of One, not in regard to the rank from connection, but to Nature. For One is Christ, and One Lord: but in respect of Christ, I mean of the Only-Begotten Son, both Christ and Son are said, one while, of the Godhead, another while of the Manhood and Godhead."45

Do you see how, with various inventions of ideas, he impiously embellishes even the fleshly generation of the Only-Begotten? He tries to show that it cannot take place except through some infusion or mixing of the substances. But the Teachers of the Church do not instruct us this way. We say that a true coming together took place—the Word united the Body to Himself while remaining what He was. But this man, paying no attention to these things, has blasphemed to no small degree. He divides Him into two prosopa and hypostases that are completely separate from each other, assigning to each separately the words that belong to it. Then he says "One Lord Jesus Christ," as though man were connected to God by rank only, not by true Union—that is, by Nature. How then is He One Christ and Son and Lord, if to both separately will belong, as you say, the title and the reality of being called this and truly being this? This would be the case because the hypostases would not come together in any way by union with one another, but would be united only in respect to rank or rule or authority. Yet if we examine the nature of things, we will observe that things which have equality of dignity have not for this reason given up their individual existence. Nor will having equal degree of glory be sufficient for union. For example, Peter and John were both Apostles, holy, and adorned with equal honors and power through the Spirit by Christ the Savior of us all. They, along with the rest, heard "You are the light of the world," and again, "Heal the sick, raise the dead, cleanse the lepers, cast out demons." Shall we therefore say that from their equality of rank or rule it follows that they too should be counted as one man, and that this is sufficient for unity—I mean unity of their prosopa? And how will such an opinion not reasonably be regarded as extremely foolish? Why then do you pretend that you are right in the Faith, saying that Christ Jesus the Lord is One, yet then dividing the One into two prosopa and hypostases? You dishonor the mode of the True Union through which the Christ is One and Alone, and you ignorantly call equality of honor a connection. What is this mode of connection? Do you not know that it is always precious to those in this life who are rich in honors from the rulers to be in worldly renown? Yet they, being sometimes in equal dignity, are still separate from one another in individual being and also in their desire to think and do the same things. But if the kind of rank were any necessary bond gathering them into unity just like a physical coming together, they would not, being in equality of honors or rank, have been divided from one another in prosopa and mind so as to be one and another. Where then shall we place your connection? What shall we count that it accomplished? Did it persuade them to be of one alliance? Did it cause them to come together into a mystical union? But you cannot say this, for reason has shown that the connection is utterly weak for both these purposes.6

Seest thou how with manifold inventions of ideas he impiously embellishes the generation after the flesh also of the Only-Begotten, how he essays to shew that it will take place no otherwise than by some infusion or commingling of the substances having place: albeit the Teachers of the Church do not initiate us this fashion; for we say that a true concurrence had place, the Word uniting to Himself the Body, yet abiding what He was. But this man taking nought of these things to mind, hath blasphemed in no mean degree, parting Him into two persons and hypostases wholly severed one from the other, and attributing to either separately the words to it belonging: and again he says One Lord Jesus Christ, as though man were connected with God by rank only, not by true Union i. e., by Nature. How then is He One Christ and Son and Lord, if to both severally will belong, as thou sayest, the being thus called and so being in truth, by reason of the hypostases coming together in no wise by union one with another, but being united in respect of rank only or sway or authority? And yet if we examine into the nature of things, we shall observe that things which are in equality of dignity, have not for this reason parted with their individual existence: nor yet will the having equal degree in point of glory, suffice to union, as for example, Peter and John were both of them Apostles and holy and adorned with equal honours and might through the Spirit by Christ the Saviour of us all. For they along with the rest heard, Ye are the light of the world, and again, Heal the sick, raise the dead, cleanse the lepers, cast out devils. Shall we therefore say that from their equality of rank or sway accrues to them that they too should be counted as one man, and this is sufficient for unity, I mean unity of their persons? And how will not such an opinion be with reason conceived of as foolish exceedingly? Why then dost thou feign that thou art right in the Faith, saying that One is Christ Jesus the Lord, and then, severing into two persona and hypostases the One, dishonourest the mode of the True Union through which the Christ is One and Alone, and unlearnedly callest equality of honour connection? What is this mode of connection? knowest thou not that dear it always is to those in this life who are rich in honours from the rulers to be in worldly renown? yet they being in. equal dignity sometimes, are yet separate one from another in individual being and moreover in their desire of thinking and doing the same things. But if the kind of rank were any necessary bond gathering them into unity just like a physical coming together;—-they would not, being in equality of honours or rank, have been parted one from another in persons and mind so as to be one and another. Where then shall we put thy connection, what shall we count that it wrought? did it persuade them to be of one league, did it cause that they should come together unto a mystic union? But you cannot say this, for reason has shewn that the connection is utterly weak to both these.6

Tell me this too (for I will ask it as well, since it is necessary): what good did the rank do for the man born from a woman who was (as you said) connected with God the Word? Did it make him equal in glory and excellence, and render him as great as He is believed to be? And how then will He not speak falsely when saying, "My Glory will I not give to another," and how has the divinely inspired Psalmist not spoken in vain when he said, "Who among the clouds shall be made equal to the Lord? Who shall be made like to the Lord among the sons of God?" Is not the man other than the Word, who is One and by physis (nature) from God the Father, since he has in his own person been truly separated from union with Him? And how is this not clear to everyone? Now rank has not made the one who was connected equal to God the Word, but he is seen to be and is in a lower place. How then do you say there is One Christ and Son and Lord, even though one excels while the other, at least according to the force of your reasoning, settles down below equality with Him in glory? Besides (for I will add this too to what I have said), the Word who is from God the Father has given (according to him) His own rank to the one born of a woman. But we need to examine how he says this very thing has been accomplished. Has that man too been made Very Light? Is he by physis God and Life and Creator and Wisdom and Might, Image and Brightness of the hypostasis (Person) of the Father? And have the endowments of the Supreme Glory passed naturally into one of the created things? What then is the excellence in God by physis? What is great and above us, if it is possible for the creature to be rich essentially in the good things in which God Himself is? But perhaps it has been clothed in rank as a participant in the Divine Preeminence? Then there are again undoubtedly two sons, if it is true that something other and inferior by physis to Him who worked the participation in him is what has been honored with relationship to Him. You are therefore caught now as not even knowing what you are saying. For why do you blame those who attribute the words in the Gospels to One prosopon (Person)? Is it not because you are inventing two sons? For how is there any longer One Lord and Christ and Son, if each has his own prosopon and mode of being and moreover hypostasis withdrawing into diversity, repudiating the reality of true union and having utter irreconcilability with the other? And what is strange and shows the loathsomeness of his blasphemies, he says that the names are common—I mean Son and Christ and Lord. And if he were to say that they are common, that is, to One Christ and to others besides Him, his statement would have some probability. But if he ignorantly divides them and supposes that these terms apply to the Word by Himself and also to the one from a woman, then there are again surely and unmistakably two christs and sons and lords. For he said, "The name Christ must sometimes be understood of the Godhead Itself, other times of the Manhood too, or also of both." But the sharing of names will not help him at all to conceive of one Christ and Son and Lord while he divides (even though the hypostases themselves do not separate from one another), and the prosopa (Persons) are disjoined in their own proper diversity.7

Tell me this too (for I will ask it as well, as matter of necessity), what good did the rank do for the man born from out a woman who was (as you said) connected with God the Word? for did it make him equal in glory and excellency, and render him as great as He too is believed to be? And how then will He not speak falsely saying, My Glory will I not give to another, and vainly hath the Divine-uttering Psalmist too prated, saying on this wise, Who among the clouds shall be made equal to the Lord? who shall be made like to the Lord among the sons of God? Is not he other than the Word, One and by Nature and forth of God the Father, who in his proper person has been verily parted from union with Him? and how is this not clear to all? Now rank has not made equal to God the Word that which was connected, but it is seen to be and is in lower place: how then dost thou say One Christ and Son and Lord, although one excels, at least according to the force of reasoning, the other settles down below equality with Him and glory? Besides (for I will add this too to what I said) the Word That is forth of God the Father has given (according to him) His proper rank to him that is born of a woman: but how he says that this very thing has been wrought, it is meet to examine. Has he too been made Very Light? is he by Nature God and Life and Creator and Wisdom and Might, Image and Brightness of the Person of the Father? and the Endowments of the Supreme Glory, have they passed Naturally into some one of things made? what then is the Excellence in God by Nature? what great and above us, if it is possible for the creature to be rich and that essentially, in the good things wherein Itself is? But perchance it has been clad in rank, as participant of the Divine Preeminence? there are again two undoubted sons, if it is true that something other and inferior by nature to Him Who wrought in him the participation is that which is honoured with relationship to Him: you are therefore caught now as not even knowing what you are saying. For why do you blame those who attribute the words in the Gospels to One Person? is it not because you are inventing two sons? for how is there any longer One Lord and Christ and Son, if each have his proper person and mode of being and moreover hypostasis withdrawing unto diverse-ness, repudiating the reality of true union and having utter irreconcilability with the other? And what is strange and shews the loathsomeness of his blasphemies, he says that the names are common. I mean Son and Christ and Lord. And if he say that they are common, i. e., to One Christ and to others besides Him, his statement would have probability: but if he ignorantly sever and supposes that these terms befit the Word by Himself and moreover him that is forth of a woman, there are again surely and unmistakably two christs and sons and lords. For he said, "The name Christ must one while be put for the Godhead Itself, other while for the Manhood too, or also for both." But the community of name will help him not a whit to conceive of one Christ and Son and Lord while he severs (even though the hypostases themselves part not one from another), and the Persons are disjoined in their own proper diverseness.7

For by revealing to us the strength of his inborn lack of learning, he adds and says,

For making manifest to us the force of his innate unlearning he subjoins and says,

§2

When therefore the Divine Scripture is about to speak of either the birth of Christ from the blessed Virgin or His Death, it never uses the name God, but rather Christ or Son or Lord, since these three names signify the two natures—sometimes one nature, sometimes the other, sometimes both together. For example, when Scripture tells us of the Generation from humanity, what does it say? God sent forth His Son; it did not say God sent forth God the Word, but instead uses the name that indicates the two natures. For since the Son is both Man and God, it says, Sent forth His Son made from a woman, so that when you hear the phrase made from a woman, you may notice the name used indicates the two natures, and you may call the Birth from the blessed Virgin the Son's Birth, for the Virgin mother of Christ also bore the Son of God. But since the Son of God is twofold in His natures, she bore indeed the Son of God, but bore the manhood which is son by reason of the connected Son.8

Nestorius: "When therefore the Divine Scripture is about to speak of either the birth of Christ which was forth of the blessed Virgin, or His Death, it is never seen to put God, but either Christ or Son or Lord, seeing that these three are significant of the two natures, one while of this, other while of that, other while of this and that. As for example when the Scripture declares to us the Generation out of man, what says it? God sent forth His Son; it did not say, God sent forth God the Word, but it takes the name which indicates the two natures. For since the Son is Man and God, it says, Sent forth His Son made from out a woman, that when you hear the word made out of a woman, then you may see the name put forth which indicates the two natures, that you may call the Birth from forth the blessed Virgin, the Son's Birth, for the Virgin mother of Christ too bare the Son of God. But since the Son of God is two-fold in His Natures, she bare indeed the Son of God, but bare the manhood which is son by reason of the connected Son."8

But we, my friend, know how to think better than your empty whistlings, and we trace out the pattern of God-inspired Scripture, which says that there is one God the Father from whom all things come, and one Lord Jesus Christ through whom all things were brought into being. When we hear that Christ was born of the holy Virgin, then—with all wisdom and eagerness to walk the straight path of truth—we say that the Word who came forth from God the Father was both incarnate and united personally to flesh and born according to the flesh. We will not tolerate your trickery, but we will assign the name Christ, with good reason, to the one and only Son who is such by nature when we speak of the birth through the holy Virgin. For such names will admittedly be common to him along with others—as I said—since many are sons by grace and gods and lords both in heaven and on earth, as the divinely inspired Paul also writes to us. Yet they are so by participating in the one who is so by nature and by imitating him. Still, the name Christ and its reality will in no way apply to the bare Word from the Father, considered by us as bare Word by himself and apart from flesh. But if he is now said to have emptied himself and to have come down in the form of a servant and been made as we are by reason of the flesh, then he too will be called Christ by reason of the anointing. For the Word, being God in his own nature, was not anointed, but the anointing happened to him with regard to his humanity. Therefore, when that has first entered in with regard to which the anointing takes place—for the incarnation is his, and the anointing belongs to it—when Christ is named by us, we will not (according to your unbridled speech) suppose that just a man, severed from the Word and set apart, was born of the holy Virgin, but rather the very Word himself (as I said) from God the Father, united to flesh and anointed humanly with the oil of gladness by God the Father.

But WE my friend, who know how to think better than thine empty whistlings and who track out the order of the God-inspired Scripture which says that One is God the Father out of whom are all things and One Lord Jesus Christ through Whom all things were brought into being: when we hear that Christ has been born of the holy Virgin, then, then in all wisdom and zealous to go the straight way of the Truth, do wo say that the Word Which sprang forth of God the Father was both Incarnate and united Personally to flesh and born after the flesh: and we will not endure thy trickery, but to One and Only, the Son That is by Nature, will we allot the name Christ, with reason, when the Birth through the holy Virgin is spoken of. For common (as I said) to Him with others also will such names confessedly "be, for many are sons by grace and gods and lords both in heaven and in earth, as the Divine-uttering Paul too writes to us: yet [they are so] as participating with Him Who is so by Nature and in imitation [of Him]. Still the name Christ and its reality will pertain in no wise to the bare Word from forth the Father, conceived of by us as bare [Word] by Himself and apart from flesh: but if now He be said to have emptied Himself and to have come down [to be] in servant's form and been made as we by reason of the flesh, He too will be called by reason of the anointing, Christ; for not in His own Nature has the Word being God been Anointed, but the anointing hath happened to Him in regard to His Humanity. Thus therefore when that has first entered in, in regard to which the anointing takes place (for His is the Incarnation whereto belongs the anointing), when Christ is named by us we will not (according to thy unbridled speech) suppose that just a man, severed from the Word and put apart, has been born of the holy Virgin but the very Word (as I said) out of God the Father united to flesh and anointed humanly with the oil of gladness by God the Father.

But that the anointing happened to God the Word with respect to his manhood, when he became as we are, holy Scripture will prove to us. For the divinely-inspired Jacob, departing from his father's home, was hurrying on his way to Mesopotamia and going to Laban the son of Bethuel. He came upon a certain place on the journey and was staying there, and laying his head on a stone, he slept. He saw a ladder stretching upward from earth to heaven, with angels both ascending and descending on it, and the Lord resting upon it. He marveled greatly at the vision and took the stone and set it up as a pillar and poured oil on the top of it. Now see in this our Lord Jesus Christ, the one and only and truly Son, as a pillared stone. For indeed he is a choice stone, a head corner-stone, precious, set as the head of the corner and as the foundation of Zion by God the Father. Notice, I ask, how it was anointed—for the divinely-inspired Jacob did not pour oil on the whole stone throughout, but rather poured it on the top of it. Therefore not wholly (so to speak), nor in that the Only-Begotten is Word, has he been anointed with respect to his proper physis (for how could he be thought of as partaking of his own Spirit?), but rather is anointed (as I said) on the surface, that is, externally and as it were in part and on the surface on the body that was his own by true union. And just as he is said to suffer in the flesh humanly, though by physis impassible as God, so is he conceived of as anointed in regard to the human nature, though he himself anoints with his own Spirit those whom it is fitting to partake of his holiness.

But that the anointing hath happened to God the Word in respect of the manhood, when He became as we, holy Scripture will prove to us; for the Divine-uttering Jacob departing from his father's hearth was hastening on his way unto Mesopotamia and going to Laban the son of Bethuel, and having lighted on a certain place on the way thither he was lodging there and, laying his head on a stone, he sleeps: and having seen a ladder, stretching on high from earth to heaven and angels both ascending and descending by means of it and the Lord resting thereupon, he marvelled much at the vision and taking the stone he set it up as a pillar and poured oil upon the top of it. Regard now herein our Lord Jesus Christ, the One and only and truly Son, as a pillared stone. For indeed He is a choice stone, a head corner-stone, precious, set for the head of the corner and for the foundation of Zion by God the Father. Regard (I pray) moreover how it was anointed, for not the whole stone throughout did the Divine-uttering Jacob bedew with oil, but rather poured it upon the top of it. Therefore not wholly (so to speak) nor in that the Only-Begotten is Word, has He been anointed in respect of His proper Nature (for how could He be conceived of as participate of His own Spirit?) but rather is anointed (as I said) on the surface, i. e., externally and as in part and on the surface on the Body that was His own by true union: and as He is said to suffer in the flesh humanly, albeit by Nature Impassible as God; so is He conceived of as anointed in regard to the human nature, albeit Himself anointing with His own Spirit those whom it befits to partake of His holiness.

Thus we are inclined to think and are accustomed to walk rightly, going on the royal and straight road. But he, saying that such names are indicative of the two natures, assigns to each with authority whatever seems good to him and is ashamed of the humble language belonging to the economy with flesh. And though you hear the blessed Paul say, "God sent forth His Son made from a woman, made under the law," this man says, "Away with that! Do not think that the Word who sprang forth from God has been sent, for He has not been made from a woman, He has not been made under the law."

Thus are WE minded to think and are accustomed to walk aright, going on the royal and unperverted road: but he saying that such names are indicative of the two natures, allots to either with authority what seems good to him and is ashamed of the lowliness of speech belonging to the economy with flesh, and though you hear the blessed Paul say, God sent forth His Son made from out a woman, made under the law, Away, says this man, think not that the Word Which sprang forth of God has been sent, for He has not been made from out a woman, He has not been made under the law.

And to prove that our words are not empty deception but that we have actually used his own statements, I will once again present the very things he said.

And that our words are no empty guile, but we have used rather his own speech, I will again bring forward the very things he said,

§3

Nestorius says: "For God sent forth His Son made of a woman, if made under the law." Here he points out the two natures. He says what took place regarding the human nature, because the objector demands: Who was made under the law? Was it God the Word?9

Nestorius: "For God (he says) sent forth His Son made of a woman, if made under the law. Here he points out the two natures, he says what took place as to the human nature, for demand of the wrangler, Who was made under the law? was it God the Word?"9

And how could someone not be truly confused who tries to overturn, as far as he is able, things that are so clear, universally known, and beyond doubt? Whom has the Father sent to us from heaven as Savior and Redeemer? Was it not the Word who came forth from His Essence? Who is the one who descended and ascended far above the heavens so that He might fill all things? Do you claim that the ability to fill all things belongs to our nature, and will you assign it to the limits of humanity? Of whom has the blessed John written, "He who comes from above is above all"? Or will He also be lying when He rebukes the Jewish people, saying, "You are from beneath, I am from above," and again, "I am not of this world"? For if He were a man from a woman like everyone else, and not rather the Word who is from above and from God the Father, who became incarnate and appeared in human form, how could He be understood as both from above and from heaven? How could He be above all and not of this world? Although He is part of the world by reason of the flesh and, so to speak, according to the measure appropriate to human nature, created along with everything else under God. Therefore He called the Father His God, even though He too is God by nature (physis) and shone forth from His Essence as Only-Begotten Son. Of whom does the blessed David say, "He sent forth His Word and healed them"? For no elder, no angel, but the Lord Himself has saved us, according to the Scriptures.

And how will not he be verily distraught, who essays to overturn, as far as in him lies, things so clear and known of all and undoubted? Whom hath the Father sent to us out of heaven, Saviour and Redeemer? was it not the Word Which sprang forth of His Essence? Who is He That descended and ascended far above the Heavens that He might fill all things? Dost thou say that the being able to fill all things is the work of our nature and will you affix it to the measures of humanity? of whom hath the blessed John written, He that cometh from above is above all? Or will haply Himself too lie in rebuking the people of the Jews and saying, Ye are from beneath, I am from above, and again, I am not of this world? For if He were man out of woman like one of the rest, and not rather the Word That is from above and out of God the Father, Incarnate and appearing in human form, how will He be conceived of as both above and out of heaven? how above all and not of this world? albeit a part of the world by reason of the flesh and (so to speak), according to the measure that befits the human nature, made along with all under God. Therefore He called the Father His God, though He too is God by Nature and beamed forth out of His Essence Only-Begotten Son. Of whom says the blessed David, He sent forth His Word and healed them? for no elder, no angel but the Lord Himself hath saved us, according to the Scriptures.

Nestorius: "But yes, he says, God the Word who is able to fill all things has been sent. How? For where do we say that He is not? Or where will He be sent to?"

Nestorius: "But yea, he saith, God the Word able to fill all things has been sent. How? for where do we say that He is not? or whither will He be sent?"

Will you therefore also accuse the all-wise Moses of having seriously wronged the ineffable glory of God? For he said that God descended in the form of fire upon Mount Sinai. And if you hear the blessed David say to God who is mighty over all, "You shall send forth Your Spirit and they shall be created, and You shall renew the face of the earth," will you then perhaps dismiss the Spirit-inspired writer and suppose that he speaks falsely? For the Godhead does not make any motion that involves a change of place, nor does it pass from place to place, as though being in all things and filling all things were not inherent in it. You understand these things yourself too, I suppose; but you will be reasoning again and rising up against the true doctrines, choosing to follow yourself alone. But you would surely think better if you reasoned like this: that all our speech about God has been framed in human terms, but is to be understood as befits him alone.10

Will you accuse therefore the all-wise Moses too, as having wronged in no slight degree the Ineffable glory of God? for he said that God descended in the form of fire upon the Mount Sinai. And if you hear the blessed David say unto God mighty over all, Thou shalt send forth Thy Spirit and they shall be created and Thou shalt renew the face of the earth, wilt thou then perchance put aside the Spirit-clad and suppose that he speaks falsely? for no motion involving change of place does the Godhead make, nor will It pass from place to place, as though the being in all and filling all things were not inherent in It. These things (I suppose)……..thyself too; but you will be reasoning again, and rising up against the true doctrines, choosing to follow yourself alone. But you would surely have better thoughts if you reasoned thus, that our whole speech as to God has been framed in human wise, but is understood as befits Him Alone.10

But it has troubled him not a little that the Word from God the Father is said to have been made under the Law. But there is no real danger here, for He has remained what He was—that is, Lawgiver and God. And if He had not been made man, He would not have been made under the Law. But since it is true that He who in His own physis is above and exalted has humbled Himself, that He who is above all creation has been made as we are, and that being rich He became poor through being made as we are, how will He not be said to have been made under the Law along with us? Shall we not, if we think rightly, conclude that the measure of human nature is defined by the fact that it must be subject to the Law? For no one is exempt and above the Law and by nature and in truth free except the Godhead. Therefore, when He was made flesh, then He was made under the Law too, for He paid the two-drachma tax to the collectors, even though in His own physis He was free as God and Son even when He was made flesh. But if it seems good to you to divide the One into two and to declare to us that the one who came forth from a woman is a man separate and by himself, how will he be said to have been made under the Law too, when he is of the nature that is already under the Law? For it is not what already has to be subject to the Law that will be made under the Law, but rather what has a physis above the Law and outside the Law. For the divine and Most High physis alone, as I said, is both beyond law and also free, and has no master whatsoever, but rather itself rules all and subjects all to its own yoke.11

But it has troubled him not a little that the Word out of God the Father is said to have been made under the Law. But the fear herein is nought, for He hath remained what He was, Lawgiver (that is) and God. And if He have not been made man, He hath not been made under the Law; but since it is true that He hath humbled Himself Who in His own Nature is above and high, hath been made as we Who is above the whole creation, and being Rich became poor through being made as we, how will He not be said with us to have been made under the Law too? Shall we not, if we think aright, conclude that the measure of man's nature is defined to lie in his having to be subject to the Law? for the exempt and above the Law and by Nature and in truth free will be none other than the Godhead. Hence when He was made flesh then was He made under the Law too, for He paid to the collectors the didrachm, albeit in His own Nature Free as God and Son oven when He was made flesh. But if to thee it seems good to sever into two the One and to declare to us that he which was forth of a woman is man apart by himself, how will he be said to have been made under the Law too, who is of the nature which is under the Law? for not that which hath to be subject to the Law, will be made under the Law, but that which, hath a Nature above Law and external to Law. For the Divine and Most High Nature alone (as I said) is both beyond law and also free, and hath no master whatever, but Itself rather ruleth all and subjecteth all to His own yoke.11

But this man, having missed correct reasoning, slid down to this extent of impiety in his ideas and reached such a height of awkwardness by dividing the One Lord Jesus Christ into two, that he unshrinkingly said that Emmanuel is neither truly God nor Son by physis, but is called Christ and holy in the same way as certain other men like us or those who have worshipped impure demons. For this is what he said again:

But this man having missed right reasoning, slid down to this extent of impiety in his ideas and arrived at such height of awkwardness, from dividing into two the One Lord Jesus Christ, as unshrinkingly to say that Emmanuel is neither truly God nor yet by Nature Son, but is so called Christ and holy, as certain other too of men like us or of those who have worshipped impure devils: for thus again hath he said:

§4

Nestorius: "Just as we say that the Creator of all is God and Moses is god (for Scripture says, 'I have made you a god to Pharaoh'), and Israel is God's son (for it says, 'Israel is My firstborn son'), and just as we say that Saul was christ (for it says, 'I will not stretch out my hand against him, because he is the Lord's christ'), and Cyrus likewise ('Thus says the Lord to Cyrus My christ'), and the Babylonian holy (for it says, 'I marshal them')—in the same way we say that the Lord is christ and god and son and holy. But while the names are shared in common, the rank is not the same."12

Nestorius: "But as we say that the Creator of all is God and Moses god; for it says, I have made thee a god unto Pharaoh: and Israel God's son, for it says, Israel is My firstborn son; and as we say that Saul was christ, for it says, I will not stretch forth my hand upon him, because he is the Lord's christ, and Cyrus likewise, Thus saith the Lord to Cyrus My christ, and the Babylonian holy, for I (it says) marshal them: so do we say that the Lord is christ and god and son and holy. But the community of names is similar, the rank not the same."12

What are you saying? What word are you belching forth from your own heart and not from the mouth of the Lord, as it is written? No one calls Jesus anathema except in Beelzebub. For instance, just as we may conceive of Moses or call him God, so will Christ be too? Will He also be Son after the likeness of Israel, tell me? O impiety! O words that do not hesitate to lift themselves up against the glory of our Savior! O sheer stupidity! And that overcomes all hesitation, I mean, in respect of unholy daring against the doctrines of the Church. Let the blessed David now also sing, "The enemies of the Lord lied to Him." For the divinely-inspired Moses was by physis (nature) a man as we are and nothing else. But when God said, "Come, I am sending you to Pharaoh king of Egypt and you shall bring the children of Israel forth from the land of Egypt," and Moses put forward as a reason for begging off his slowness of speech and lack of eloquence since yesterday and the third day, he heard God say, "See, I have made you a god to Pharaoh and Aaron your brother shall be your interpreter." For the law was too feeble to free anyone from bondage to the devil, but when Christ became our Mediator, this too was achieved, just as here when Aaron was alongside the divinely-inspired Moses, Israel was delivered from bondage in Egypt. But since Christ was going to be made under the Law in due course of time, in that He was as we are and was man, Aaron was put in second place to Moses. And the plan of the mystery is thus—but if one should choose to say this too, that by the calling of God that mighty Moses too has been honored, according to what has been said to us in common and as by God's favor and generosity, "I said, you are gods and all of you sons of the Most High"—is Christ God in this way? Yet how is this not madness and the empty froth of an unlearned mind? For the one (as I said), being man by physis, has been honored with the mere title only, while the Other is truly God (for the Word was God) in human form, having the preeminence over all with His own physis unmutilated (for the Divine physis will not undergo change for the worse by reason of descending to share in blood and flesh), and truly He is recognized as God even when appearing as Man also. And a clear demonstration of this are the things that have been written in the Gospels concerning Him. For the divinely-inspired John said, "Now when He was in Jerusalem at the feast, many believed in His Name when they saw the miracles which He was doing, but Jesus Himself did not trust Himself to them, because He knew all things and needed not that anyone should testify of man, for He knew what was in man." Yet the ability to see the heart of man and to know its secrets will not belong to anyone (how could it?) of men like us, nor yet to anything else that is made, but rather to Him alone who is said to fashion our hearts by Himself. Then how has Emmanuel, being called God, been honored like Moses with the mere title alone, and is He not rather in truth that which He is also said to be? Thus again John writes of Him, "For He whom God sent speaks the words of God and gives not the Spirit by measure." Do you understand then how, although He is beheld as a man like us, He speaks the words of God? For to God alone who is by physis and truly will belong as something distinctive and above the creature the ability to achieve what He wills by a word and to make partakers of the Holy Spirit those who have been justified in faith—and one may see that Christ is in this case. For He said to the leper, "I will, be clean," to the widow's son, "Young man, to you I say, Arise," and He manifested His own disciples as partakers of the Holy Spirit, for He breathed on them, saying, "Receive the Holy Spirit." Then how will He who has advanced to this point and been crowned with God-befitting renown be god in the same way as Moses was? Whose heart did Moses know? Who has believed on his name? Whom has he justified through faith in himself? Where has he as son spoken the words of God? Yet he has openly cried to those of Israel, "Thus says the Lord," and has a servant's measure, for he was made faithful as a servant in the house of God.1314

What are you saying? what word are you belching forth out of your own heart and not out of the mouth of the Lord, as it is written? No one calleth Jesus Anathema save in Beelzebub. As Moses for instance may be conceived of or called by us God, so will Christ too? after the likeness of Israel, will He too be Son, tell me? O impiety! O words that reck not of lifting up themselves against the glory of our Saviour! O sheer stupidity! and that overcomes all hesitancy in respect I mean of unholy daring against the doctrines of the Church. Let the blessed David now too sing, The enemies of the Lord lied unto Him: for the Divine-uttering Moses was by nature a man as we and nought else: but when on God saying, Come I am sending thee to Pharaoh king of Egypt and thou shalt bring the children of Israel forth of the land of Egypt, he was putting forward as reason for begging off, his slowness of speech and want of utterance, since yesterday and the third day, he heard God say, See I have made thee a god to Pharaoh and Aaron thy brother shall be thy interpreter. For feeble was the law to rid any from bondage unto the devil, but on Christ becoming our Mediator, this too has been achieved, just as here when Aaron was along with the Divine-uttering Moses, Israel was delivered from the bondage in Egypt. But since Christ was about in due course of time to be made under the Law too, in that He was as we and was man, Aaron was put in second place to Moses. And the plan of the mystery is thus,—-but if one should choose to say this too, that by the calling of God has that mighty Moses too been honoured, according to this which has been said to us in common and as by God's favour and munificence, I said, Ye are gods and all of you sons of the Most High: —-is Christ in this way God? yet how is not this madness and the empty froth of an unlearned mind? for the one (as I said) being man by nature has been honoured with the mere title only, the Other is truly God (for the Word was God) in human form, having the preeminence over all of His own Nature unmutilated (for not in change for the worse will be the Divine Nature by reason of Its descending to communicate in blood and flesh), and verily He is recognized as God when appearing as Man also. And a clear demonstration of this are the things that have been written in the Gospels concerning Him. For the Divine-uttering John said, Now when He was in Jerusalem in the feast, many believed in His Name when they saw the miracles which He was doing, but Jesus Himself did not trust Himself to them, because He knew all things and needed not that any one should testify of man, for He knew what was in man: albeit the being able to see the heart of man and to know its secrets, will not belong to any one (whence should it?) of men like us, nor yet to ought other of things made, but rather to Him Alone Who is said to fashion our hearts by Himself. Then how has Emmanuel, being called God, been honoured like Moses with the mere title alone, and is not rather in truth that which He is also said to be? Thus again does John write of Him, for He whom God sent speaketh the words of God and giveth not the Spirit by measure. Understandest thou then how, albeit beheld a man as we, He speaketh the words of God? For to God Alone Who is by Nature and truly will pertain as something choice and above the creature, the being able by a word to achieve what He will and to render partakers of the Holy Ghost them who have been justified in faith:—-and one may see that Christ is in this case. For He said to the leper, I will, be clean. to the widow's son, Young man, to thee say I, Arise: and His own Disciples He manifested partakers of the Holy Ghost, for He breathed on them, saying, Receive ye the Holy Ghost. Then how will He Who has advanced to this point and been crowned with God-befitting renown be god after such sort as was Moses? whose heart knew he? who hath believed on his name? whom hath he justified through faith in himself? where hath he as son spoken the words of God? albeit he hath openly cried unto them of Israel, Thus saith the Lord, and hath a servant's measure, for he was made faithful as a servant in the house of God.1314

And if Emmanuel was a son in the same way as Israel, who was made so according to the flesh, you have brought down among slaves the One who is Free by His own physis, even though He became in the form of a slave because of the flesh and the things that belong to it. You have placed on equal footing with the sons by grace the One because of whom they have been enriched with the grace of sonship. For He has been called firstborn of us because of the manhood, yet even so He has remained Only-begotten as God. Therefore, as the most wise Paul says, the powers above are commanded to worship the Firstborn when introduced by the Father into the world, and upon learning the mystery regarding Him, they extol with ceaseless praises the One who is by physis and truly Son. For if He gives authority to those who received Him to become children of God, as John says, and if it is true that His Spirit brings it about that we too should become sons (for God sent forth the Spirit of His Son into our hearts crying Abba, Father), no one who is accustomed to think rightly will tolerate this man saying that He too is a son in the same manner as Israel was.15

And if Emmanuel was son in the same way too as was Israel who was made so after the flesh, thou hast brought down among bondservants Him Who is in His own Nature Free, even though He became in the form of a bondman by reason of the flesh and the things thereto pertaining: thou hast set in equal measure with the sons by grace Him on account of whom they have been enriched with the grace of sonship: for He has been called first-born of us by reason of the manhood, yet even so hath remained Only-begotten as God. Therefore (as saith the most wise Paul) the powers above are bidden to worship the First-begotten when introduced by the Father into the world, and on learning the mystery regarding Him, with ceaseless praises do they extol the One and by Nature and truly Son. For if He gives authority to them that received Him to become children of God, as John saith, and if it is true that His Spirit effects that we too should become sons (for God sent forth the Spirit of His Son into our hearts crying Abba, Father), none who are accustomed to think aright will endure this man saying that He too is son in such manner as was Israel.15

And how was He Christ and holy in the same way that both Cyrus the King of the Persians and the Persians and Medes themselves may be called christ and holy? For it would be time to say that Christ has not been sanctified in a human way, even though the Holy Spirit descended upon Him in the form of a dove. For Cyrus son of Cambyses led an expedition against the land of the Babylonians in his time, but he was in error and used to worship foul demons. But when God stirred him up and roused him to anger, and he took the land of the Babylonians, he was called christ by a common title, though he was not anointed with the Holy Spirit. And in this way the Persians and Medes who were his companions were holy (for they too served the creature rather than God the Creator and worshipped the works of their own hands). But since the offering that was once set apart for God according to the words of the Mosaic Law, whether calf or sheep, was called holy, therefore they too have been called holy through the Prophet's voice, because they were set apart by Divine consent to take captive the land of the Babylonians. If then Emmanuel is christ in the same way that Cyrus was, and holy in the same way that the Medes and Persians were, one might reasonably say—considering the absurdity of such a notion—that He has neither been anointed with the Holy Spirit nor is He holy at all. The Divine David will therefore be lying when he says to Him, "You loved righteousness and hated wrong, therefore God, Your God, anointed You with the oil of gladness above Your fellows."

And how was He in such wise too christ and holy, as may be called christ both Cyrus the King of the Persians and yet again the Persians and Medes themselves? for it were time to say that neither has Christ been sanctified humanly albeit the Holy Ghost soared down upon Him in form of a dove. For Cyrus son of Cambyses led an expedition against the land of the Babylonians in his time, but he was in error, and used to offer worship to foul devils: but when, on God stirring him up and rousing him into wrath, he took the land of the Babylonians, by a name common, albeit not anointed with the Holy Ghost, he was called christ. And in this way were the Persians and Medes holy who were his fellows (for they too served the creature more than God the Creator and worshipped the works of their own hands); but since the offering that was once, according to the words of the Mosaic Law, separated unto God, whether calf or sheep, was called holy; therefore have they too been called holy through the Prophet's voice, by reason they were set apart by the Divine assent to take captive the land of the Babylonians. If then Emmanuel is in such sort christ as was Cyrus too, and in such wise holy as were the Medes and Persians, one might with reason say as of their absurdity of notion that neither hath He been anointed with the Holy Ghost nor is He holy at all. The Divine David will therefore lie saying unto Him, Thou lovedst righteousness and hatedst wrong, therefore God, Thy God, anointed Thee with the oil of gladness above Thy fellows.

And after babbling on in this way against the preeminence and glory of our Savior, he thinks he pushes away the charge of impiety by saying something childish and lacking understanding: "for the community (he says) of names is alike, not the rank the same." How is this so, tell me, for I do not understand? For if He is God in the same way that Moses was too, and Son in the same way that Israel was, and christ in the same way that Cyrus was, and moreover holy in the same way that the Medes were, how will He escape being placed in equality of rank with them?

And he chattering after this sort against the Preeminence and glory of our Saviour, thinks that he thrusts away the charge of impiety, by saying something childish and without understanding, "for the community (he says) of names is like, not the rank the same." How, tell me, for I do not understand? For if He is in such wise God as was Moses too, and in such wise son as was Israel, and in such wise christ as was Cyrus and moreover in such wise holy as were the Medes, how will He escape having to be in equality of rank with them?

Now therefore you will be caught having blasphemed against the very Nature of the Word itself, for you said again,

Now therefore you will be caught in having blasphemed against the very Nature of the Word too, for thou saidst again,

§5

Nestorius: "Say that the one who assumed is God, and add that what was assumed is the servant's form. Then bring in the dignity of the connection, so that the authority is common to both and the dignity is the same for both. While the natures remain, acknowledge the union of rank."

Nestorius: "Say of Him Who assumed that He is God, add of that which is assumed that it is the servant's form, bring in next the dignity of connection, that of the two the sway is common, that of the two the dignity is the same; while the natures remain, acknowledge the union of rank."

He divides things into two again, and in his great lack of understanding he attributes the power of union to rank alone, perhaps not understanding what union really is or what rank actually means. But we say this: he claimed that one sway and one dignity belong to the two natures. Since therefore the one who is in equality of glory with God the Word will not surpass Moses in being god, it is clear, I think, that the very Word who is from God will have equal status in nature and glory with Moses. For if the middle term is like the first and third and has exact resemblance to both in every respect, the structure of their nature will not be different.

He divides therefore again into two, in exceeding lack of understanding he lavishes on rank the force of union, haply not understanding what union is, and what the rank really is. But this we say; he said that of the two natures one is the sway, one the Dignity. Since then he who is in equality of glory with God the Word will not surpass Moses in respect of being god, it is I suppose clear that the very Word which is forth of God, will have equal status in nature and glory with Moses, for if the mean be like and in every respect have exact resemblance with the first and third, the plan of their nature will not be diverse.

But perhaps he will say that the mode of rank is not physis: how then do you think it fitting to gather into one (as you yourself say) sway and to crown with equal rank things that are essentially so far separated from participation with one another and also from equality? For where one physis is wholly in an inferior place, with the other surpassing it, how will there come to it both equality of honors and even dignity, and how will the mode of glory not be different?

But haply he will say that the mode of rank is not nature: how therefore do you deem it fit to gather into one (as yourself say) sway and to crown with equal rank things essentially so far severed from participation one with another and also from equality? for where a nature is wholly in inferior place, the other overtopping it, how will there accrue to it both equality of honours and even dignity and the mode of glory be not diverse?

But the fact that when he mentions connection—which he perhaps understands as merely being close together and placed side by side, or as something accidental—he actually contradicts his own words, rebuilding what he tore down and setting up again what he had overthrown, will also be clear from this: for he said the following:

But that on mentioning connection, haply conceived of as that of mere proximity and juxtaposition, or as an accidental one, himself rises up against his own words, building what he undid and setting up what has been overthrown, will be clear by this again also: for he said thus;

§6

Nestorius: "Therefore I want you to hold firmly with complete confidence: there is no separation of the connection of the dignity of sonship, there is no separation of his being Christ. Of the Godhead and Manhood there is a separation; Christ is indivisible in that He is Christ, for we do not have two christs or two sons, since there is not with us a first and a second, nor one thing and another thing, nor one son and another son; rather, the One is Himself twofold, not in rank but in physis."16

Nestorius: "Therefore I would have you hold fast with all assurance: there is no severance of the connection of the dignity of the sonship, there is no severance of his being Christ, of the Godhead and Manhood there is a severance; Christ is indivisible, in that He is Christ, for we have not two christs nor two sons, for there is not with us a first and a second, nor yet other and other, nor again another son and another again; but the One is Himself twofold, not in rank but in nature."16

Tell me again what you mean by inseverable connection: is it the union in respect of prosopon that we set forth, striving together for the doctrines of the truth? Or is it what is conceived of as one of juxtaposition and proximity of one thing to another? For this is how the God-inspired Scripture uses the word. Indeed, he spoke to the most holy Moses when discoursing with him about that ancient tabernacle: "And you shall make fifty clasps of gold and connect the curtains one to another with the clasps." For though there were five curtains, each having individually a being other than the rest, they were connected by the clasps. But we do not say that the union has been accomplished in Christ in this way, for neither was he united as one person might be connected with another—whether in respect to like-mindedness or bodily nearness. Rather, as I have repeatedly said, he made his own the body which was taken from the holy Virgin, and we say that the Word from God has been truly united to flesh not without a soul.

Tell me again what it is you term inseverable connection: is it the union, I mean in respect of Person, which WE set forth, striving together for the doctrines of the Truth? or is it this which is conceived of as one of juxtaposition and proximity of any to anything? for thus does the God-inspired Scripture take the word. And verily He spake to the most holy Moses, when He was discoursing with him respecting that olden tabernacle, And thou shalt make fifty taches of gold and connect the curtains one to other with the taches. For being five and each having individually the being other than the rest, they were connected by the taches. But not thus do WE say that the union has been wrought as to Christ, for neither as one may be connected with another, either in respect to like mindedness or bodily nearness, was He too like this, but (as I have repeatedly said) He made His own the Body which was taken from forth the holy Virgin; and we say that the Word out of God has been truly united to flesh not without a soul.

Hence, if the force of the connection he has spoken of signifies the union we mean—that is, of Person—he will reasonably have said that there is no severance of Christ, in that He is Christ. For He is "not one and another, nor yet son and son, other and other, first and second," but One both before flesh and with flesh. For in this way He will be inseverable—indeed, rather the Same—in respect of rank (as you say) and also of authority. Then how do you say that the One and Inseverable is twofold, and that not in regard of rank but of physis? For the Word out of God the Father did not become twofold simply because He took flesh and came forth as man like us. He is One—and not without flesh—He who in His proper physis is external to flesh and body. For instance, if someone were to kill a man such as we are, he would not reasonably be accused of having wronged two men but one alone, even though the man is conceived of as being composed of soul and body, and the physis of the things that have been brought together is not the same but diverse. So again must we conceive of Christ, for He is not twofold, but One and Only Lord and Son is the Word from God the Father, not without flesh. For I myself would also allow that the difference or interval between Manhood and Godhead is very vast, for the things which have been named are plainly other in respect of the mode of their being and nothing like one another. But when the mystery Christ-ward is brought before us, the plan of the union does not ignore the difference, but puts aside the severance, not confounding the physeis or mingling them, but because the Word of God, when He partook of flesh and blood, is even thus conceived of and called One Son. But you, in saying that they ought not to be called two christs, nor should one confess two sons, and hereby stealing the appearance of rightness in doctrine, are caught in the act of saying two christs and dividing into his own separateness man and God, and you try to show that the one is operated upon, the other operates. For your words are thus:1718

Hence if the force of the connection which has been spoken of by him, signify the union which we mean, i. e. of Person, reasonably will he have said that there is no severance of Christ, in that He is Christ; for He is "not one and another, nor yet son and son, other and other, first and second," but One both before flesh and with flesh: for thus will He be in respect of rank (as THOU sayest) and also of sway, inseverable, yea rather the Same. Then how dost thou say that the One and Inseverable is twofold, and that not in regard of rank but of nature? for not because the Word out of God the Father having taken flesh, proceeded forth man as we, will He for this reason be called also twofold, for One and that not without flesh is He Who is in His proper Nature external to flesh and body. For as, were one to kill a man such as we are, he would not with reason be accused of having wronged two men but one alone, even though the man be conceived of as being of soul and body, and the nature of the things that have been brought together be not the same, but diverse: so again must we conceive of Christ, for He is not twofold, but One and Only Lord and Son is the Word from forth God the Father, not without flesh. For that of Manhood and Godhead most vast is the difference or interval I myself too would allow, for other in respect of the mode of their being and nothing like one to another are plainly the things which have been named. But when the mystery Christ-ward is brought before us, the plan of the union ignores not indeed the difference, but puts aside the severance, not confounding the natures or immingling them but, because the Word of God when He partook of flesh and blood, even thus is conceived of and called One Son. But you in saying that they ought not to be called two christs, nor should one confess two sons, and hereby filching the semblance of rightness in dogma, are caught in the act of saying two christs, and dividing into his own diverseness man and God, and you endeavour to shew that the one is operated, the other operates: for your words are thus,1718

§7

Nestorius: "The good glory of the Only-Begotten is sometimes ascribed to the Father, for He says, 'My Father glorifies Me,' sometimes to the Spirit, for He says, 'the Spirit of Truth shall glorify Me,' and sometimes to the power of Christ, for it says, 'they went forth and preached the word everywhere, the Lord co-working and confirming the word through the signs that followed.'"18

Nestorius: "The good glory of the Only-Begotten one while is ascribed to the Father, for it is, He says, My Father which glorifieth Me, other while to the Spirit, for the Spirit of Truth, He says, shall glorify Me, other while to the power of Christ, for they, it says, went forth and preached the word everywhere, the Lord co-working and confirming the word through the signs that followed. "18

If he says that the Only-Begotten Word of God, as though lacking glory in what He is and is conceived of as Word before becoming incarnate, is glorified by the Father and the Holy Spirit—I will leave aside for now saying that he both blunders and has missed the truth (since the occasion leads us to something else). But he seems to me to have forgotten what he had just thought out and said, for he said, "Not one and another is Christ, not other and other son, for we have not two Christs and two sons." But, most understanding one, I would say: if you affirm that the good glory of the Only-Begotten is ascribed to the power of Christ, how will He be not one and another, or how not wholly and surely two? For if the giver and receiver are not the same, or if he ascribes to another than himself the things which belong to him by nature, then Christ has worked being possessed, as being other than the Only-Begotten. For if the good glory of the Only-Begotten has been (as you say) ascribed to him, and the divinely-speaking disciples used the power that came from him to preach and work miracles, how is what I said not true? For he has worked using another's power, so that the one who worked—and not himself—may rather be glorified by those in the world. What then, tell me, appears more in Him than in the holy Apostles? For they have worked wonders not by their own power, and they themselves clearly confessed this. They were worthy of admiration in knowing this too and glorifying Him Who works in them. Then how ought not Christ—who according to you was possessed by another and had the good glory of the Only-Begotten from outside—to have proclaimed to those who approach Him as God and supplicate help from Him: "In the name of the Only-Begotten, or in His might, let this good thing come to you"? For this is how the all-wise disciples used to do it, everywhere naming Jesus of Nazareth. But to no one at all has He declared this; rather, He used to attribute what was accomplished to His own power, one time saying to the blind man, "Do you believe that I am able to do this?" and requiring their assent, at another time commanding with authority, saying, "I will, be clean." Why do you not let go of these old wives' tales which have been invented by yourself alone, and occupy yourself with wise mind about the depth of the mystery?1920

If he says that the Only-Begotten Word of God, as though lacking glory in that He is and is conceived of as Word and not yet Incarnate, is glorified by the Father and the Holy Ghost:—-that he both blunders and has missed the truth, I will leave saying for the present (for occasion leads us to something else); but he seems to me to have forgotten what he had just now thought out and said, for he said, "Not one and another is Christ, not other and other son, for we have not two Christs and two sons." But, O most understanding, would I say, if thou affirm that the good glory of the Only-Begotten is ascribed to the power of Christ, how will He be not one and another, or how not wholly and surely two? for if not the same be giver and receiver, or he ascribe to another than himself the things which accrue to him by nature, Christ hath wrought being possessed, as being other than the Only-Begotten: for if the good glory of the Only-Begotten have been (as you say) ascribed to him; and the Divine-uttering disciples using the power that came from him, preached and wrought miracles, how is that not true that I said? for he hath wrought using other's power, that he which wrought and not himself rather may be glorified by those in the world. What then (tell me) appears there more in Him than in the holy Apostles? for they have wrought wonders not by their own power, and this themselves clearly confessed, for they were worthy of admiration in knowing this too and glorifying Him Who worketh in them. Then how ought not Christ Who according to thee was possessed by another and had from without the good glory of the Only-Begotten, to have proclaimed to those who approach Him as God, and supplicate succour from Him, In the name of the Only-Begotten, or in His Might, be to thee this good thing: for so used to do the all-wise disciples, every where naming Jesus of Nazareth. But to no one whatever hath He declared this, but rather to His own power used He to attribute what was accomplished, one time saying to the blind man, Believe ye that I am able to do this? and requiring their assent, at another ordering with authority saying, I will, be clean. Why dost thou not, letting go the fables fit for old women which have been invented by thyself alone, occupy thyself with wise mind about the depth of the mystery?1920

But one can see that he cares little about things necessary for spiritual benefit, and is afraid that he might let slip anything true or be caught thinking anything praiseworthy. He considers everything that is most contradictory and makes utterly thoughtless condemnations of the church's doctrines, even though he should have remembered God speaking through the mouth of Ezekiel to those who shepherd the spiritual flocks: "You ate the good pasture and drank the pure water and troubled the rest with your feet, and My flock fed on what your feet had trampled and drank the water your feet had muddied." For when we apply our minds to the God-inspired Scriptures, we eat the good pasture, as it is written, and we drink the untroubled water—that is, the word of the Spirit unmixed with falsehood, clear and most pure. But if we make it thick and mix into it, like mud, the dreariness of our own inventions, we plot against the Saviour's flocks.

But one may see that he little recks of things needful unto profit, but is afraid lest he let drop ought true and be caught thinking anything praiseworthy: and thinks every thing that is most discordant and makes a condemnation utterly inconsiderate of the doctrines of the church, albeit he should have remembered God saying by the mouth of Ezekiel to those who are over the spiritual flocks, Ye ate the good pasture and drank the pure water and troubled the residue with your feet, and My flock fed on the treadings down of your feet and drank the water troubled by your feet. For when WE apply our minds to the God-inspired Scriptures, we eat the good pasture, as it is written, and we drink the untroubled water, i. e. the unmixed with falsehood, translucent and most pure word of the Spirit: but if we thicken it and immingle therewith like mud the cheerlessness of our own devices, we plot against the flocks of the Saviour.

And that this too is true will be shown by the things he has thought out and carelessly said about Christ, for it is as follows:

And that this too is true, the things which he has thought out and heedlessly said of Christ, will shew; for it is thus:

§8

Nestorius: "For God the Word, even before the Incarnation, was Son and God and of one mind with the Father, but in the last times He took the form of a servant. Yet since He was Son before this, and was called such, after the assumption He cannot be called Son separately, or else we would be teaching the doctrine of two sons. But since He has been united with Him who is Son from the beginning, the one who was united with Him may not be separated in respect of the dignity of sonship—I mean in respect of the dignity of sonship, not in respect of the natures. Therefore God the Word is also called Christ, since He has His connection with Christ perpetually. And it is not possible that God the Word should do anything without the manhood, for it has been brought into exact connection with complete precision—not into deification, as the wise ones among the neo-dogmatists say."

Nestorius: "For God the Word even before the Incarnation was Son and God and of one mind with the Father, but in the last times He took the form of a servant. Yet being before this Son, and being [so] called, after the assumption He cannot be called Son separately, lest we teach the doctrine of two sons. But since he has been connected with Him which is in the beginning Son, Him who was connected with him, he may not admit of severance in respect of the dignity of sonship, in respect I say of the dignity of sonship, not in respect of the natures. Wherefore God the Word is called Christ also, since He has His connection with Christ perpetual. And it is not possible that God the Word should do ought without the manhood, for it has been with all exactitude brought unto exact connection, not unto deification, as the wise ones of the neo-dogmatists say."

The one who dared to say that the good glory of the Only-Begotten has been attributed to the power of Christ, and who tore apart the bond of Oneness, brings things back into union and then dissolves them again, separating the natures from one another. He talks endlessly and boastfully to us about these matters, so that even if he should say something that tends toward orthodoxy, he may be clearly convicted of not knowing what he is saying. For he says here that the Word of God "is both Son and God even before the Incarnation, and that in the last times He took the form of a servant." Tell me then, if I do not seem to you to be speaking appropriately, who is it now who is said to be made man? And what do you say that being made man is? Who is he that took the servant's form? And how was it taken by him? Therefore, in saying that a man was made man, you will show your own understanding to be worthy of ridicule—how can anyone doubt this? For how will someone who is man by nature be made what he already was, and pass as though to something else, in respect of nature I mean? How will that which is not free in its own nature be said to have become bond, as though it were not so at the beginning? Hence, to have been made man will not pertain to a man—far from it—and to take the form of a servant does not belong to him who even at the beginning has the measure of servitude, but rather to Him who, not being man by nature, is believed to have been made so, and who, being Lord of all as God, abased Himself in our condition, uniting to Himself personally the human nature and taking the form of the servant. For thus will that too be true which you said, that "after the assumption, He cannot be called Son separately lest we teach the doctrine of two sons."2021

He that durst say that the good glory of the Only-Begotten has been ascribed to the power of Christ, and that plucked asunder the bond of Oneness, gathers again into union and again dissolves it and parts the natures one from other. And most plentifully does he vainly talk and rhodomontade to us respecting these things, so that even though he should say ought that tendeth unto orthodoxy, he may be clearly convicted of not knowing what he saith. For he says here that the Word of God "is both Son and God even before the Incarnation, moreover that in the last times He took the form of a servant." Tell me therefore, if I do not seem to thee to say what is meet, Who is it now that is said to be made man? and what dost thou say that being made man is? who is he that took the servant's form? and how was it taken by him? That in saying therefore that a man was made man, you will display as worthy of ridicule your own understanding, how can one doubt? for he that is man by nature, how will he be made what he was, and pass as though to somewhat else, in respect I mean of nature? that which in its own nature is not free, how will it be said to have become bond, as though it were not so at the beginning? Hence to have been made man, will not pertain unto a man, far from it, and to take the form of a servant, belongs not to him who even at the beginning has the measure of bondservice, but to Him rather Who being not man by Nature, is believed to have been made so, and Who being Lord of all as God, abased Himself in our condition, uniting to Himself Personally the human nature, and taking the form of the servant. For thus will that too be true which thou saidst, that "after the assumption, He cannot be called Son separately lest we teach the doctrine of two sons."2021

And the right, unperverted, and straight path of doctrines is this and no other. But he who mentioned to us the becoming-man of the Word Who is forth from the Father is carried almost immediately into forgetfulness of what he said, and severs again into two the One. He drifts about feebly in the weakest ideas and uses words that are always untested, for he said, "But since he has been connected with Him Who is in the beginning Son, Who was connected with him, he may not admit of severance as regards the dignity of sonship—as regards dignity of sonship I say, not as regards the natures." Rightly, my friend, do you reject as unprofitable what seems to be insecure; it has been carefully set before you to use an ever-vigilant mode of speech. For look, look—severing the natures, you gather them into union as regards the dignity of sonship. Does sameness or identity of names and dignity in respect of this suffice for true union in things severed one from another by nature? For so it seems good to you to say. Therefore, since the name Christ, and moreover son and lord, have been given to others too as names common to several (for very many have been made christs and have been called sons and lords), they too will be, as regards the dignity of sonship, both severable one from another and all of them one in respect of the union which you think was wrought in respect of Christ too. But a man such as we are will be wholly distinct from the Word out of God. How therefore they have not been severed, how too there is one son, I cannot conceive, unless we say that the human nature (physis) and the Word have come together by a true union.

And the right and unperverted and straight-going path of doctrines, is this and no other. But he again who mentioned to us the being-made-man of the Word Which is forth of the Father, borne almost straightway unto forgetfulness of what he said, severs again into two the One, both in vile sort floating in feeblest ideas and using ever words untested, for he said, "But since he has been connected with Him, Who is in the beginning Son, Who was connected with him, he may not admit of severance, as regards the dignity of sonship, as regards dignity I say of sonship, not as regards the natures." Rightly, my friend, dost thou reject as unprofitable that which seems to be insecure, studiously has it been set before thee to use ever vigilant mode of speech. For lo, lo, severing the natures, thou gatherest them into union as regards the dignity of sonship. Sufficeth therefore unto true union in things by nature severed one from another, the sameness or identity of names and the dignity in respect of this? for thus too does it seem good to thee to say. Therefore since the name Christ, and moreover son and lord, have been given to others too as names common [to several] (for very many have been made christs and have been called sonsand lords); they too will be as regards the dignity of sonship, both disseverable one from another and all of them one in respect of the union which you think was wrought in respect of Christ too. But a man such as we will be wholly distinct from the Word out of God: how therefore they have not been severed, how too there is one son, I cannot conceive, unless we say that the human nature and the Word have come together by a true union.

But since we must, because of his words, take the argument to its absurd conclusion so that he may be shown on all sides to have thought incorrectly, come now, let us say this too. For if the dignity of sonship is sufficient for union, since the Word who is from the Father is called and is Son of God the Father, and since the name is common to many others, what is to prevent us (tell me) from saying that all the rest have also been united with him, so that Emmanuel would have nothing more than they do? For the claim of the same names will apparently be competing with him and striving for equality, and the mode of connection will lie in bare and mere appellation or community of name. What then is being made man understood to be? What also is the descent in the servant's form? For if the mode of being made man is (according to him) a mere connection, and consists only in the dignity of sonship, what is to prevent us from saying that it has been accomplished in all the rest as well? But the friend of learning surely sees the unseemliness of what is being said. Where then is he now being carried off to, distracted, toward things not lawful? We shall say to him what is spoken by Jeremiah's voice: You grew weary in much journeying, for he is tossed back and forth, carried about with every wind, as the most wise Paul says. Therefore receive the anchor of the soul sure and steadfast, set your feet upon a rock. If you say that the Word of God was made man, this will suffice to show that he who is above all creation was made as we are. He took the servant's form although he possessed freedom as God, for he was in equality with the Father, who possesses dominion over all. Stop severing the natures after the union, for that the divine physis and the physis of man are one thing and another, it will be fitting to know, and I consider it necessary for those who are sound in mind (for they are separated from one another by incomparable differences), but with regard to Christ the Savior of us all, having brought them together into true union and of prosopon, reject severance, for thus you will confess one Christ and Son and Lord.

But since one must, on account of these words of his, carry round the argument even unto absurdity, that on all sides he may be convicted of having thought not aright, come now, come, let us say this too. For if the dignity of sonship suffices unto union, since the Word Which is from forth Him is called and is Son of God the Father, and the name is common to many more, where is the harm (tell me) of saying that the rest too all of them have themselves been united with Him, in order that Emmanuel may have nought more than they? for the claim 7 of the same names will (it seems) be contending with Him and be striving for equality, and the mode of connection will lie in bare and mere appellation or community of name. What then is being made man understood to be? what too the descent in the servant's form? for if the mode of the being made man is (according to him) a mere connection, and consist in the dignity only of sonship what is to hinder our saying that it has been effected in regard to all the rest too? But the friend of learning sees assuredly the uncomeliness of what is said. Whither therefore is he now borne off, distraught, unto things not lawful? by us shall be said to him what is uttered by Jeremiah's voice, Thou waxedst weary in much journeying, for he is tossed to and fro borne about with every wind, as saith the most wise Paul. Therefore receive the anchor of the soul sure and stedfast, set thy feet upon a rock. If thou sayest that the Word of God was made man, this will suffice to shew that He Who is above all the creation was made as we. He took the servant's form although He possessed freedom as God; for He was in equality with the Father, Who possesseth dominion over all. Cease to sever the natures after the union: for that one thing and another is the Divine Nature and the nature of man it will be fit to know, and needful I deem to those who are sound in mind (for they are parted one from another by incomparable differences), but in regard to Christ the Saviour of us all, do thou having brought them togetherinto union true andof Person, reject severance, for thus wilt thou confess one Christ and Son and Lord.

I don't understand how the one who invents weak doctrines has made so little of the union itself. Pushing aside both the union (it seems) and the power of the truth, he has gone back to what he personally prefers and says, "Therefore God the Word is also called Christ, since He has a perpetual connection with Christ. And it is not possible for God the Word to do anything without the manhood, for it has been accurately adjusted to exact connection, not deification, as the wise ones among those with new teachings say." So when he says that the Word from God the Father has been separately called Christ, because He has a connection with Christ—that is, with another person—how has he not spoken foolishly in saying that after the assumption He cannot be called this separately? What is conceived of by us is not one thing that happens to be connected with something else, for the things that come together will rightly be understood as two, and not as one thing connected with itself. Therefore his words are false, and in another sense they are nonsense. But we, after the union, even if someone names God the Word, do not think of Him apart from His own flesh. Even if someone says Christ, we recognize the Word made flesh. What then do you think is the nature of the connection you are talking about? For if you say that the human nature has been united in hypostasis with the Word who came forth from God, why (tell me) do you insult the divine flesh? You do not refuse to worship it, even though the duty of being worshipped belongs only to the divine and ineffable physis. But if you do not think that a true union took place, but instead call it by the name of connection—referring to a status that consists in having the same name and merely the same title—why do you speak so solemnly, saying that the one born of the woman has "been accurately adjusted to exact connection," that is, with the Word? For they are synonymous with each other, son with son, and lord with lord, and the names are in no way inferior to one another. To investigate any superiority among them is (I suppose) pointless, for son compared to son as son has neither greater nor less. You are therefore speaking unnecessarily (clearly so) in saying that he has been "accurately adjusted to exact connection." But to say that they have been accurately adjusted to one another will belong (as it appears to me) not to things that share the same name, but rather to things that possess equality and likeness in every respect to things that are believed to be one. For example, we say that there has been accurately adjusted to exact correspondence with the form of someone either the son who is begotten from him, or one might say his image. But regarding connection, how can things be conceived of and said to have been accurately adjusted?2122

But I know not how the inventor of feeble doctrines has made exceeding petty account of the fact of union, and thrusting away both it (as seems) and the might of the truth, hath gone again unto what liketh himself and saith, "Therefore is God the Word called Christ also, seeing that He hath His connection with Christ perpetual. And it is not possible for God the Word to work ought without the manhood; for it hath been accurately adjusted unto exact connection, not deification, as the wise ones of the neo-dogmatists say." When therefore he says that the Word from forth God the Father has been separately called Christ, as having connection with Christ, i. e., with another, how has he not idly prated in saying that after the assumption He cannot be so styled separately? since not as One is that conceived of by us which is said to have been accidentally connected with ought else, for two of a surety will be rightly conceived to be the things which come together, and not one, itself connected with itself. False speech therefore are his words, and in another sense are they idle talk: but WE after the union, though one name God the Word, conceive not of Him apart from His own flesh; though one say Christ, we recognize the Word Incarnate. What then is the mode of the connection which you speak of conceived to be? for if you say that the human nature has been united Personally with the Word That sprang forth from God, why (tell me) do you insult the Divine Flesh? albeit you refuse not to worship it, while the duty of being worshipped belongs only to the Divine and Ineffable Nature: but if you do not think that a true union took place, but call rather by the name of connection, the rank which consists in identity of name and in mere and only equality of style, why do you prate in solemn language, saying that he that is born of the woman has "been accurately adjusted unto exact connection," i. e., with the Word? for they are synonymous one with another, son with son, and lord with lord, nor are the names a whit inferior one to another, and to inquire into any superiority in them is (I suppose) idle, for son than son qua son, hath neither greater nor less. You are therefore talking superfluously (clearly so) in saying that he has been "accurately adjusted unto exact connection." But to say that they have been accurately adjusted one to another will belong (as appears to me) not to things possessing an identity of name, but to those rather, which obtain the equality and likeness in every thing of things that are believed to be one. As for example we say that there hath been accurately adjusted unto exact correspondence to the form of such an one, either the son that is begotten from out him, or one might say his image: but as regards connection, how can things be conceived of and said to have been accurately adjusted?2122

But he himself explained to us what he means by "connection": for "it is not possible," he says, "that God the Word should do anything without the human nature." Therefore, according to you, we must believe that the pair of sons you speak of are like-minded with one another and harmonious, advancing to each action from common counsel. How then are there not two christs and sons and lords? But you claim (it seems) that the Word used His Body as an instrument. Yet if you say One Son and One prosopon, the Incarnate prosopon of the Word, He will not be an instrument of Deity, but rather will use as an instrument His own Body, just as a man's soul does. Therefore confess One, not dividing the natures, while at the same time knowing and maintaining that the flesh has one count; the Godhead again has that which befits It alone: for we say that the flesh of the Word by no means became Godhead, but rather Divine, as being His own. For if the flesh of a man is called human, what prevents that of God the Word from being called Divine? Why then do you mock the beauty of the Truth, telling us about the deification of the holy flesh, and all but throwing in the teeth of those who have chosen to think rightly a charge of god-making, although you yourself say,

But himself interpreted to us the force of connection: for "it is not possible (he says) that God the Word should do ought without the human nature." Likeminded therefore with one another and harmonious according to thee, and from common counsel advancing unto each action shall we believe the pair of sons spoken of by thee. How then are there not two christs and sons and lords? But you affirm (it is like) that the Word used His Body as an instrument. Yet if you say One Son and One Person, the Incarnate Person of the Word, He will not be an instrument of Deity, but rather will use as an instrument His own Body, just as a man's soul too does. Therefore confess One, not dividing the natures, at the same time knowing and holding, that of the flesh the count is one; of the Godhead again, that which beseems It alone: for we say that the flesh of the Word by no means became Godhead, but rather Divine, as being His own. For if the flesh of a man is called human, what hinders that that of God the Word should be called Divine? why then dost them mock at the beauty of the Truth, telling us of the deification of the holy flesh, and all but casting in the teeth of those who have chosen to think aright, a god-making, albeit thyself sayest,

§9

Nestorius: "So that it might be shown to the Magi as well who this one is whom they worshiped, and to whom the grace of the Holy Spirit led them—that it was not simply a baby by itself, but a body ineffably united with God."

Nestorius: "In order therefore that it might be pointed out to the Magi too, Who this is That is worshipped by them, and to Whom the grace of the Holy Ghost led them—-that it was not to a mere babe viewed by itself, but to a body connected ineffably with God."

Since he says that the body has been ineffably united to God, and that which is truly ineffable is beyond understanding and speech, then the union or the connection (as he calls it) must truly be real. For such things are ineffable, and when things come together with one another in this way, one would not (I think) know the manner of it. But if you are able to say it, and you think you can explain the force of the connection, how is it any longer ineffable?

Since therefore he says that the body has been ineffably united to God, and that which is truly ineffable is beyond understanding and speech, true of a surety is the union or the (according to him) connection. For such things are ineffable, and of things that thus come together with one another one would not (I deem) know the mode. But if thou art able to say it, and deemest that thou canst declare the force of the connection, how is it any longer ineffable?

But I am amazed that although he says the Body has been connected with God and that ineffably, he does not say it is His very own, so that it might be understood as one with Him. Instead, he divides again into man and God, separately and apart, the one Christ and Lord Jesus, and pretends that he thinks correctly when he says,

But I marvel that albeit he says that the Body has been connected with God and that ineffably, he does not say that it is His very own, in order that it might be conceived of as one with Him, but parts again into man and God, separately and apart, the One Christ and Lord Jesus, and feigns that he thinks aright, when he says,

§10

Nestorius: "Yet Christ is not merely a man (O accuser), but both Man and God alike. If He had been God alone, it would have been right for Apollinarius to say, 'Why do you seek to kill Me, God, Who have told you the truth?' This is the one who was crowned with thorns, this is the one who said, 'My God, My God, why have You forsaken Me?' This is the one who endured death for three days. This one I worship together with the Godhead as sharing equally in the Divine rule."22

Nestorius: "Yet not mere man is Christ (o accuser) but Man alike and God: had He been God alone, it had been right, of Apolinarius, to say, Why seek ye to kill Me, God, Who have told you the truth? This is He Who was encircled with the Thorny Crown, this He Who said, My God, My God, why forsookest Thou Me? this He Who endured the three days death, this do I worship with the Godhead as co-partner in the Divine sway."22

Look now, I ask you, at how he seizes upon and wraps his own words in the appearance of truth (for he says, "Christ is not mere man, but both Man and God"), yet he separates them again and says that He is not One, and foolishly grasps at something without foundation and constructs whatever pleases him. For as though someone were saying that the Word had appeared to us on earth bare and without flesh, and had conversed with us and performed His divine signs, or that He was an ordinary man and that the Word Himself had not become Man—he says, "Christ is not mere man, but God also." But we, most excellent sir, even though we say that He is both Man and God, do not speak this way as if separating them, but rather knowing that the Same, even before the Incarnation, was Son and God and Word of the Father, and after it has become man like us and been made flesh. But he, asserting that He ought not to be conceived of as mere man but as God and Man, assigns the Thorny Crown and the rest of the Sufferings to man separately and apart, while he confesses that he worships this man with the Godhead, and even greater impiety, as if he were not truly God and Son, but a co-partner in the rule of the Word. For that he clearly separates them, his confession that he ought to be worshipped along with the Godhead will clearly show. For that which is co-worshipped with another is altogether other than that with which it is co-worshipped. But we are accustomed to worship Emmanuel with one worship, not severing from the Word the Body that was personally united to Him.

View now I pray again how he snatches at and puts around his own words the form of the truth (for "not mere man, says he, is Christ, but Man alike and God,") yet severs again and says that He is not One, and stupidly takes hold of something without foundation and constructs what pleases himself. For as though some one were saying that the Word had appeared to us upon earth bare and without flesh, and had conversed with us, and wrought His Divine signs, or that He was common man and that not the Word Himself has been made Man:—-he says, "Not mere man is Christ, but God also." But WE, most excellent sir (will I say), even though we say that He is Man alike and God, do not speak thus as putting them apart, but rather knowing that the Same even before the Incarnation was Son and God and Word of the Father, and after it hath become man as we and been made flesh. But he asserting that He ought not to be conceived of as mere man but God and Man, allots the Thorny Crown and the rest of the Sufferings to man severally and apart, while he confesses that he worships this man with the Godhead, and yet greater impiety, as not being (it is like) truly God and Son, but co-partner in the sway of the Word. For that he clearly severs, his confession that he ought to be worshipped along with the Godhead will clearly shew. For that which is co-worshipped with other is altogether other than that with which it is co-worshipped. But WE are accustomed to worship Emmanuel with one worship, not severing from the Word the Body That was Personally united to Him.

But we need to investigate what being "advocate of the Divine Sway" means. For did our Lord Jesus Christ Himself, like one of the holy Apostles and Evangelists, preach to the world another christ or son and lord as having the Divine Sway or Authority over all, and did He Himself speak for the glory of another? Yet the choir of God's heralds proclaim to the world Jesus Christ who came from the seed of David according to the flesh, and the plan of our faith advances through our confession directed toward Him, and we are justified, believing not in a mere man like us, but in Him who is by physis and truly God. The Gentiles indeed were living in the world without God when they did not know Christ, as blessed Paul says, but since they came to know Him they have not remained in ignorance of Him who is by physis God. Let him therefore teach us whose glory and sway it was that Christ spoke for, even though He demanded faith in Himself from those who came to Him, and He attributed this faith in Him to the Father. And truly He said, "Believe in Me and believe in God," and again, "He who believes in Me believes not in Me but in Him who sent Me," and "He who sees Me sees Him who sent Me."

But it is meet to investigate what the being "advocate of the Divine Sway" means. For did our Lord Jesus Christ Himself too like one of the holy Apostles and Evangelists preach to the world another christ or son and lord, as having the Divine Sway or Authority over all, and Himself too speak for the glory of another? albeit the choir of God's heralds proclaim to the world Jesus Christ who is forth of the seed of David according to the flesh, and the plan of our faith advances through our confession to Himward, and we are justified, believing not on a mere man like us, but on Him Who is by Nature and truly God. And the Gentiles indeed were living in the world without God, when they knew not Christ, as blessed Paul saith, but since they knew Him they have not remained in ignorance of Him Who is by Nature God. Let him therefore teach us Whose glory and sway it was that Christ spoke for, albeit of them that came to Him He demanded faith in Himself, and this faith in Him He attributed to the Father: and verily He said, Believe in Me and in God believe, and again, He that believeth on Me believeth not on Me but on Him That sent Me, and he that seeth Me seeth Him That sent Me.

But perhaps "to speak for" according to him may mean the same as "to speak as." I concede this, although the word has another meaning. Then how can a man speak as God (according to you) when enduring the insults of the Jews? Come, let us consider the speech appropriate to each. It will be fitting for Him who is truly God by physis to say, "I am invisible, impalpable and superior to suffering, moreover Incorporeal, Life and Life-giving," and above all as God. The other, explaining to us his own physis as it is, will reasonably say, "I am visible and palpable, passible, subject to decay and subject to God." Will he who says such things then speak as He who excels and is superior, with regard to the account of His own physis? How could this not be an ignorant thing to say? For one will surely speak falsely, either that one or this. But in saying advocacy or speaking for, that it is nothing else than to speak for another, you confess even against your will—you who tell us of connection and of One Christ and Lord—and severing them into two you worship them, or rather you co-worship them, and think that you are freeing the Church from the charge of god-making. Yet you yourself are making a god of a man, and not saying One Son even though He is not to be conceived of apart from His own flesh. For then you would worship Him blamelessly, and will know where you were, as it is written, going astray from the doctrines of the truth.

But haply to speak for according to him may mean the same as to speak as: I concede, albeit the word has other meaning. Then how may man speak as God (according to thee) when enduring the contumelies of the Jews? For come let us view the speech befitting each. It will be meet for Him Who is in truth God by Nature to say, I am invisible, impalpable and superior to suffering, moreover Incorporeal, Life and Life-giving and above all as God: the other expounding to us his own nature how it is, will reasonably say, I am visible and palpable, passible, subject to decay and subject to God. Will then he who says such things speak as He That excels and is superior, as regards the count of His own Nature? how were this not an unlearned thing to say? for one surely will speak falsely, either that one or this. But in saying advocacy or speaking for, that it is nought else than to speak for another, you confess even against your will who tell us of connection and of One Christ and Lord: and severing them into two you worship them, yea rather you co-worship, and think that you are freeing the Church from the charge of god-making, yourself engoddening a man, and not saying One Son even though He be not conceived of apart from His own flesh: for then would you worship Him unblamed, and will know where you were, as it is written, going astray from the doctrines of the truth.

But yes, he says, Christ said to the leper, "I will, be thou cleansed," and to the ruler of the synagogue's daughter, "Maid, arise," and to the sea, "Peace, be still," and in this he was a co-partner, for he spoke the Divine words by which it was possible to accomplish all things easily. So there are two who command, and let us grant that the words on all subjects belong to both. When it says, "Why do you seek to kill me, a man who has told you the truth," whose words (tell me) do you say these are? Or do you assign those words to the Word, and these to a man born of a woman as someone other than He? Where then will you place the most holy Paul who clearly says, "But to us one God the Father from whom are all things and we for Him, and one Lord Jesus Christ through whom are all things and we through Him"? But he, repeatedly saying "one Son and not one and another, nor Christ and a second christ," argues against his own words, and assigns the expressions of the Divine Scriptures and his own statements to two prosopa (persons) and distinct hypostases.

"But yea (saith he) he hath said to the leper, I will, be thou cleansed, and to the ruler of the synagogue's daughter, Maid, arise, and to the sea, Peace, be still, and herein was he a co-partner, for he uttered the Divine words whereby it was possible to achieve all things easily." Two then are they that command, and let us grant that the words on all matters belong to both. When then it says, Why seek ye to kill me, a man which have told you the truth, whose words (tell me) do you say that these be? or dost thou allot those to the Word, these to a man born of a woman as other than He? Where then wilt thou put the most holy Paul who says clearly, But to us One God the Father out of Whom all things and we unto Him, and One Lord Jesus Christ through Whom all things and we through Him. But he, over and over saying, "One Son and not one and other, nor yet Christ and a second christ," contends against his own words, and to two persons and distinct hypostases allots the expressions of the Divines and His own.

Yet he does not put this forward without regard to his own ideas, but instead brings it up again,

Yet not regardless of his own notions, he puts forth again,

§11

I honor him as the image of Almighty Godhead, for God highly exalted him and gave him a name that is above every name, so that at the name of Jesus Christ every knee should bow—in heaven and on earth and under the earth—and every tongue should confess that Jesus Christ is Lord.23

Nestorius: "I venerate him as image of Almighty Godhead; for He highly exalted Him and gave Him a Name which is above every name, that at the name of Jesus Christ every knee should bow, of heavenly and earthly and beneath the earth and every tongue should confess Lord Jesus Christ. "23

And who will be understood as the one whom (as Nestorius supposes) he confesses to venerate and claims to honor with likeness to God, except surely the one he just mentioned to us, calling him an advocate or co-worker of the Divine rule? Nestorius foolishly said this one ought to be co-worshipped with the Godhead, as a son who is other and separate from the Word of God. He says that this one has also been exalted by God the Father, that he moreover received the Name which is above every name, that to him every knee should bow, of those in heaven and on earth and under the earth, and every tongue should confess that Jesus Christ is Lord.

And who again will be conceived of as he whom (as he supposes) he confesses he venerates and pretends to honour with likeness to God, save surely him whom he but now mentioned to us, calling him an advocate or co-worker of the Divine sway? whom he foolishly said ought to be co-worshipped with the Godhead, as son other and severally than the Word of God: he says that he has also been exalted by God the Father, that he moreover received the Name which is above every name, that to him should both every knee how, of heavenly and earthly and neath the earth and every tongue confess Lord Jesus Christ.

If therefore the Father has placed him, being God by nature, on high even before the exaltation mentioned here, then when we examine the manner of the humiliation that came between, we will find some wise economy in regard to which, though dishonored for a time, he became again in the exaltation what he always was—an exaltation that exists essentially and is truly proper to him. If this is not so (as he thinks and says), but rather God made some other than the Word of God, the man connected with him, an object of worship by heaven and earth and those lower still, then he has made a man like us into God. He will no longer be able to rightly blame us for wanting to make a god of one who is not God, because the charge of transgression in this matter must be fastened on God the Father himself. Anyone who is eager to learn can see, therefore, in what direction his words burst forth, and at what conclusion the inventions of his unbalanced folly end up. For we say that the Son, being by nature God—that is, the Word out of God the Father—descended to a voluntary emptying, and ascended again with the flesh to the God-befitting dignity of his inherent excellence. For he is worshipped with flesh as well, since he was an object of worship even before it, for he was still by nature God, both before the emptying and when he is said to endure the emptiness, made as we are. But this man, disdaining such magnificent and spotless doctrines, connects a man with God by mere outward accident, and is not ashamed to co-worship him as if in equality of dignity and as one with another. He maintains (he says) that this man received as something unwonted and strange and as a matter of favor that every knee should bow to him, and besides that every tongue should confess Jesus Christ as Lord. And if you say that he was made God by nature, he has blasphemed openly by saying that the nature of the Godhead is generated. And if not by nature, but he receives the dignity as a gift from outside and by mere title, how is he not openly saying that we worship one who is not by nature God? And along with us (it seems) the seriousness of the spirits above is also in error. And the Father himself is the origin and justification to us of these things. How then will he still find fault with those who have chosen to worship the creature rather than himself? And why does he indict and punish those who have erred, if the error has been by his own will, in exhibiting to us as an object of worship one who is not by nature God?

If therefore the Father hath placed Him, being God by Nature, on high even before the here-mentioned exaltation: on investigating the mode of the intervening abasement, we shall find some wise Economy in regard to which dishonoured meanwhile, He had become again in the exaltation wherein He ever was, exaltation essentially inexisting and verily Proper to Him. If this be not so (as he deems and says) but He made some other than the Word of God, the man connected with Him, an object of worship by heaven and earth and those lower yet:—-He hath engodded a man like us: no longer will He meetly blame us as though we desired to engod him that is not God, whereas one must fasten on God the Father Himself the charge of the transgression hereto pertaining. He that is studious for learning sees therefore in what direction his words burst forth, and the inventions of his untempered miscounsel at what a word they terminate. For WE say that the Son being by Nature God, i. e., the Word out of God the Father, descended unto voluntary emptying, ascended again with the flesh too unto the God-befitting Dignity of His inherent Excellence: for He is worshipped with flesh too, as being an object of worship even before it, for He was even yet by Nature God, both before the emptying and when He is said to endure the emptiness, made as we. But this man disdaining so august and spotless doctrines connecteth a man with God by mere outward accident, and is not ashamed to co-worship him as in equality of dignity and as one with another, and maintains (he says) that he received as somewhat unwonted and strange and as a matter of favour that to him every knee should bow, and besides that every tongue should confess Lord Jesus Christ. And shouldst thou say that he was made God by Nature, he hath blasphemed openly saying that the Nature of the Godhead is generate; and if not by Nature but he receive the dignity of gift and from outside and by mere title, how is he not openly saying that we worship him who is not by Nature God? And together with us (it is like) the gravity of the spirits above too is in error. And the Father Himself is the beginning and plea to us of these things. How then will He yet find fault with them who have chosen to worship the creature rather than Himself? and why does He indict and punish those that have erred, if the error have been by the will of Himself, in exhibiting to us as an object of worship him who is not by Nature God?

But since he cited this passage—I mean the one before us, that "to Him shall bow every knee" and "every tongue shall confess Lord Jesus Christ"—he (I do not know what he was thinking) omitted what remains and was necessarily added in order by blessed Paul. So let us add it and say this: for "every tongue confesses Lord Jesus Christ to the glory of God the Father." Therefore, if He is not God by physis, but he says that on account of an accidental connection—I mean with the Word from God—He is worshipped both by ourselves and by the holy angels, then some mode of honor has been invented by the Father so that the creature should be made god along with Himself, and He has no reason to be displeased with anyone for having done this. And if this thing were to His honor, how would He not consider worthy of recompense, praise, and glory those who have chosen to do this?

But since citing here this word, I mean the one before us, that to Him shall bow every knee and every tongue shall confess Lord Jesus Christ, he (I know not how minded) pretermitted what remains and was of necessity added in order by the blessed Paul, come let us adding it say this, for every tongue confesses Lord Jesus Christ to the glory of God the Father. Hence if He be not by Nature God, but he says that on account of accidental connection, I mean with the Word out of God, he is worshipped both by ourselves and by the holy angels:—-some mode of honour has been invented by the Father, so that the creature should be engodded along with Himself, and to no purpose has He displeasure against any for having done this: and if this thing were to His honour, how should He not deem worthy of recompense, praise and glory them who have chosen to do this?

But perhaps they will say this: How is it any honor to the Father that every knee should bow to Emmanuel?

But haply they will say this, How is it any honour to the Father that every knee should bow to Emmanuel?

Because the Word, being by physis God and out of Him—that is, out of His ousia—has been made flesh, and is worshipped (as I said) as One and Alone and Truly Son with His proper Flesh. And the Father is glorified as God, having as Very Son Him who was begotten from His ousia, whom He has also given for us after making Him flesh, so that having suffered in the flesh He might save all under Heaven, so that everyone who believes in Him should not perish but have everlasting life, and so that everyone who sees Him might see the Father. Now the Son Himself has shown that this too is truly a life-giving thing for us, for He said, "This is eternal life, that they might know You, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom You sent."

Because the Word being by Nature God and out of Him, that is, out of His Essence, has been made flesh, and is worshipped (as I said) as One and Alone and Truly Son with His proper Flesh. And the Father is glorified as God, having Very Son Him who was begotten from forth His Essence, whom made flesh also He hath given for us, in order that He having suffered in the flesh might save all under Heaven, that every one who believeth on Him should not perish but have everlasting life, that every one that seeth Him might see the Father. Now that this too is to us verily a life-giving thing, the Son Himself hath shewn: for He said, This is Life Eternal that they might know Thee, the Only Very God and Jesus Christ whom Thou sentest.

And this alone is the way to right and completely unerring thinking, but he is utterly confusing everything and says,

And this and none other is the way to the right and most unerring line of thought, but he utterly confounding every thing says,

§12

Nestorius: "I reverence what is worn because of the one who wears it; I worship the one who is seen because of the one who is hidden."24

Nestorius: "Because of the wearer I reverence the worn, because of the hidden I worship him that is seen. "24

Look again, I ask you, at how he everywhere avoids the union and fears the truth and rejects the correctness of the divine teachings. The one who wears was not different from what is worn, but rather the same one conceived of in the coming together of Godhead and manhood, and One and Alone in truth, Son of God the Father. Therefore worship the Word from God as one with his own flesh. For tell me, if I do not seem to you to think correctly, pushing aside your weak and slow speech on this matter as feeble. For suppose someone should choose to say of any human being like us or of any one of the kings of the earth, "Because of the king's soul I reverence his body, because of the hidden I worship him that is seen"—would not someone immediately rebuke him and say, "Sir, what are you doing? The ruler is surely one man, even though he is clearly composed of two things, I mean soul and body. Why then are you babbling idly to us, speaking of a wearer and a worn, a hidden and an apparent, and confessing that you worship-together as one with another, and dishonoring the mode of union, when the God-inspired Scriptures reveal to us one Christ and Lord, the Word from God the Father with his own body?" Do you not know that he healed in Jerusalem the man blind from birth, and afterward, finding him in the temple, he planted in him a firm and established faith in himself? For he came to him and asked, "Do you believe in the Son of God?" And when the man cried out to this, "Who is he, Lord, that I might believe in him?" he said again, "You have both seen him and it is he who is speaking with you." You see how he has shown him not the wearer, not the one hidden within, but rather himself as one with the flesh? And truly the wise John says, "That which was from the beginning, which we have heard, which we have seen with our eyes, which we viewed and our hands handled, concerning the Word of Life." Although the Godhead is untouchable, yet the Word has been made touchable through his own flesh; invisible by nature, he was yet manifest through the body. But you again completely separate and deal cunningly with the truth, dividing the physis, uniting (as you say) the worship. But if you divide the physis, along with them the natural properties of each will also diverge, the accounting of their difference will rush apart: hence they are confessedly two.25

View again (I pray) how he every where shuns the union and fears the truth and refuses the rightness of the Divine doctrines. Not other than the worn was He who weareth, but rather the same conceived of in concurrence of Godhead and manhood, and One and Alone in truth Son of God the Father. Worship therefore the Word out of God as One with His own Flesh. For tell me, if I do not seem to thee to think aright, thrusting aside as feeble thy slow speech herein. For suppose one should choose to say of any man such as we are or of any one of the kings of the earth, Because of the king's soul I reverence his body, because of the hidden I worship him that is seen, would not one straightway chide him and say, O sir what are you doing? one man surely is the Ruler, even though he be evidently compounded of two, soul I mean and body. Why then are you idly blabbing to us, speaking of a wearer and a worn, a hidden and an apparent, and confessing that you co-worship as one with another and dishonouring the mode of union, whereas the God-inspired Scripturs reveals to us One Christ and Lord, the Word out of God the Father with His own Body? Knowest thou not that He healed in Jerusalem the blind from his birth, afterward finding him in the temple, He engrafted into him a firm and stablished faith in Himself? for He came to him and asked, Dost THOU believe on the Son of God? and when to this he cried out, Who is He, Lord, that I might believe on Him? He again said, Thou hast both seen Him and it is He that talketh with thee. Thou seest how He hath shewn him not the wearer, not the hidden within, but rather Himself as One with the flesh? And verily the wise John says, That Which was from the beginning, which we have heard, which we have seen with our eyes, which we viewed and our hands handled, of the Word of Life. Albeit the Godhead is impalpable, yet the Word has been made palpable through His own flesh; invisible by Nature, He was yet manifest through the Body; but Thou again completely severest and dealest subtilly with the truth, parting the natures, uniting (as you say) the worship. But if you part the natures, along with them will diverge the natural properties too of either, the count of their difference will speed apart: hence two are they confessedly.25

But tell me, I ask you, what is it that separates the natures from one another, and what will be the mode of their difference? You will surely answer, I suppose, that one thing by physis is man or the manhood, another is God or the Godhead, and the one is exalted incomparably above the other, and the other is as much inferior as man is less than God. How then, tell me, do you consider it right to honor with one worship things of such unlike physis that are separated, as regards their mode of being, by incomparable differences? For would you, if you put a man's glory around a horse, be doing anything praiseworthy? Would you not rather be insulting the superior, dragging down the better physis into dishonor?

But tell me who ask, what is it that severs the natures one from another and what will be the mode of their difference. You will (I suppose) surely answer that one thing by nature is man or the manhood, another God or the Godhead: and the one exalted incomparably above the other, and it as much inferior as is man less than God. How then (tell me) dost thou deem right to honour with one worship things of so unlike nature and parted, as regards their mode of being, by incomparable differences? For would you, if you put about a horse a man's glory, be doing anything praiseworthy? would you not rather be insulting the superior, dragging down the better nature into dishonour?

But he has invented something clever in his defense, for he adds:

But he has invented something clever in his defence, for he subjoins:

§13

Nestorius: "What was formed in the womb is not God by itself, what was formed from the Spirit is not God by itself, what was buried in the tomb is not God by itself—for if this were the case, we would be worshippers of a mere man and indeed worshippers of the dead. But because God is present in what is assumed, the assumed nature receives the name 'God' from the one who assumes it, since it is united with the assumer."26

Nestorius: "Not by itself God is that which was formed in the womb, not by itself God that which was formed forth of the Spirit, not by itself God that which was buried in the tomb; for so should we have been man-worshippers and very worshippers of the dead. But since God is in that which is assumed, from that which assumeth is the assumed co-named God, as connected with the assumer."26

Look, once again the one who constantly speaks to us about connection and fears the accusation of man-worship is caught in the act of being a man-worshipper. He is trapped in the net of his own bad reasoning and is exposed as falling into a corrupt way of thinking. "For," he says, "that which is born from the womb is not by itself God." How I marvel at your cleverness and your supposedly subtle mind! For who has ever dared to say this? Or who does not know that what is born of the flesh is flesh? Yet it was the Word's own flesh, and He is understood as one with it, just as we said a moment ago that the soul of a man is also one with his own body. If therefore someone should choose to say of us too, "The body by itself is not man," would not such a person reasonably be called superfluous in his words and a rambling speaker? For no one will deny that the body by itself is not man, but it will rather be called the body of a man. Nevertheless, one will not separate them and set soul and body apart, saying that the body is co-named with the soul in order to signify a single man, for such speech would not be orderly but would rather be full of ignorance. But when bringing both together by physical union into the condition of one man, he will then call him a man, and will not in this way seem to say what is trivial and inappropriate. One must therefore, if one would be altogether wise and sensible, say: a body which is from a woman, and confess that joined by hypostatic union to the Word, it has made the Same both God and Man, One Christ and Son and Lord. But now, passing over this and falling completely away from the straight path, he proceeds along the perverted way and proclaims to us two gods: one, as if by physis and in truth, the Word from God the Father, and other than Him, the one who is co-named with Him. For just as no one of us would be said to live, for example, with himself alone, but rather he would live with another, and if anyone were to say that any of the kings of the earth co-reigned with himself, such a person would reasonably incur ridicule and would be babbling, attributing and saying what belongs to one only as though he were speaking of two—just so it is extremely lacking in understanding to suppose that being co-named can apply with respect to one only. For they will surely be two; and the one is God by physis, the other having, it seems, the mere being co-named as something from outside and added to him, is presented to us as a new god. Does therefore He Who is by physis and truly God of all lie when saying to us, "If you will listen to Me, there shall be no new god in you, neither shall you worship an alien god"? Then how have we worshipped Christ and how shall every knee bow to Him? How do you confess that you venerate Him, even though you fear, as you said, to be called a man-worshipper?27

Lo again is he who every where telleth us of connection, and feareth the charge of man-worship, caught in the act of being a man-worshipper, and is holden in the meshes of his own mis-counsel and is detected falling into a reprobate mind. 'For (says he) that which is born from the womb is not by itself God.' How I marvel at thy shrewdness and thy so subtle mind: for who ever is there who hath dared to say this? or who that knows not that that which is born of the flesh is flesh? yet was it the own flesh of the Word and He is conceived of as one with it, just as we said but now that the soul of man too is one with his own body. If therefore one should choose say of us too, The body by itself is not man, would not such an one reasonably be called superfluous in his words and a random talker? for none will deny that the body by itself is not man, but it will be rather called the body of a man: natheless one will not severing them asunder and putting soul and body apart say that the body is co-named with the soul in order to signify a single man, for such a speech would not have been made orderly but would rather be replete with unlearning; but on bringing both together by physical union unto the condition of one man, he will then style him a man, and will not in this way seem to say what is paltry and uncomely. One must therefore if one would be in all wise and sensible say, A body which is from forth a woman, and confess that conjoined by personal union to the Word, it has rendered the Same, God and Man, One Christ and Son and Lord. But now pretermitting this, falling quite away from the straight road he thinks…… b the perverted way, and proclaims unto us two gods: one, as if by Nature and in truth, the Word forth of God the Father, and other than He, him who is co-named with Him. For just as no one of us would be said to live (for example) with himself alone, but rather he would live with another, and if any one were to say that any of the kings of the earth co-reigned with himself, such an one would reasonably incur ridicule, and would be blabbing 8, putting and saying what belonged to one only, as though [he were speaking] of two: just so is it exceeding lack of understanding to suppose that to be co-named can have place in respect of one only. For they will surely be two; and the one is God by Nature, the other having (it seems) the mere being co-named [as something] from without and accruing to him, is exhibited to us as a new god. Does therefore He That is by Nature and truly God of all lie in saying to us, If thou wilt hearken unto Me, there shall be no new god be in thee, neither shalt thou worship an alien god? Then how have we worshipped Christ and how to Him shall every knee bow? how dost thou confess that thou veneratest Him? albeit thou fearest (as thou saidst) to be called a man-worshipper.27

But he thinks he has a clever answer to this: "He is called God because of His connection with the one who assumes Him." Tell me, how was He assumed, and what is the nature of this connection? If it is by a true union—I mean a union of Person—then stop dividing what has been united. For I think we can rightly say to you, who are separating what cannot be separated, "What therefore God has joined together, let not man put asunder." But if you say that the assumption or connection is external and accidental, don't you realize that God is in us too, and we are connected to Him in a relative way and have been made partakers of His divine nature? Yes, the divinely-inspired David sings, "My soul clings fast to You." So shall we too be called gods by nature because we share God's name? Shall every knee bow to us as well? Let the divinely-inspired Paul come forward and teach what God the Father has commanded the heavenly spirits: "For when He brings the First-begotten into the world, He says, 'And let all the angels of God worship Him.'" Since your wise argument has not been included here, but God has instead commanded that He should be worshipped as certainly One and not one together with another, who is He whom the angels worship, even though the divine Scripture calls Him First-born? We say that the Word from God the Father has been called First-born, although He is God by nature and Only-Begotten Son and is not counted among the creatures as far as His Godhead is concerned, because He became man and was the First-born among many brethren.

But he has as he thinks some clever answer to this, "he is co-named god as connected with the assumer:" how was he assumed (tell) or what the mode of the connection? If therefore by true union, I mean of Person, cease dividing what has been united; for seasonably (I deem) by us too shall be said to thee who art severing the inseverable, What, therefore God joined together let not man put asunder. But if thou say that the assumption or the connection is extraneous and of accident, how knowest thou not that in us too is God and WE are connected to Him relatively and have been made partakers of His Divine Nature? yea the Divine-uttering David singeth, My soul is fast joined after Thee. Shall WE too therefore be co-named with God by Nature gods according to him, to us too shall every knee bow? What God the Father hath enjoined to the spirits above let the Divine-uttering Paul come forward and teach; For when (saith he) He bringeth the First-begotten into the world He saith, And let all the Angels of God worship Him. Since therefore herein thy wise word has not been added, but He has enjoined rather that He should be worshipped as of a surety One and not one along with another: who is He who is worshipped by the Angels, albeit the Divine Scripture calls Him First-born? We say that the Word out of God the Father has been called First-born albeit He is God by Nature and Only-Begotten Son and not reckoned with the creature, as far as regards Godhead, because He was made Man and First-born among many brethren.

The one who is worshipped by the spirits above is therefore the Word from God the Father together with His own flesh, for He bore it then, and being conceived of as having preeminence in all things, He is the First-born. The God-inspired Scriptures proclaim entirely one Christ and Son and Lord. But this overly inquisitive man says there are two, and he is not ashamed to add a worshipped man to the Holy and Consubstantial Trinity, for he says again:

One therefore is He Who is worshipped by the spirits above, the Word forth of God the Father with His own flesh: for then did He bear Him and, as having the preeminence in all things, is He conceived of as First-born. And the God-inspired Scriptures wholly proclaim One Christ and Son and Lord: but this too-curious man says Two and he is not ashamed to add a worshipped man to the Holy and Consubstantial Trinity: for he says again,

§14

Nestorius: "But this kinsman according to the flesh of Israel, a man according to what is visible, born according to Paul's words from the seed of David, is Almighty God by connection." Then he adds, "Hear Paul proclaiming both. He confesses the man first and then deifies what is visible by connection with God, so that no one may suspect the Christian of being a worshipper of a mere man. Let us therefore keep the connection of the natures unconfused. Let us confess One God. Let us reverence the man who is worshipped together by a divine connection along with Almighty God."28

Nestorius: "But this kinsman after the flesh of Israel, man according to what is manifest, begotten according to Paul's voice of the seed of David, is by connection Almighty God" and then adds, "Hear Paul proclaiming both, he confesses the man first and then deifies what is manifest by connection with God, that none may suspect the Christian of being a man-worshipper. Keep we therefore unconfused the connection of the natures, confess we One God, reverence we the man who is co-worshipped by a Divine connection along with the Almighty God."28

If therefore, when you name Man, you understand that He is with God by physis, that is well and I will say no more. But if you are severing the natures—not merely in the sense of knowing which is the human and which again the Divine, but rather separating them from their convergence into unity—you are confessedly a man-worshipper, and we will say to you: You shall eat the fruit of your labors. And being stubborn and rejecting correction, go alone on your twisted path. But we, following the pious and blameless path of the holy fathers and being thoroughly instructed in the writings of the Apostles and Evangelists, will honor together with God the Father and the Holy Spirit, with one worship, the One Lord Jesus Christ, through whom and with whom to God the Father be glory with the Holy Spirit unto ages of ages.

If therefore on naming Man thou knowest that He is with this God by Nature, it is well and I will stop: but if severing the natures, not merely in respect of knowing which is the human, which again the Divine, but rather parting them from their concurrence unto unity, confessedly thou art a man-worshipper, and it shall be said to thee by us, Thou shalt eat the fruit of thy labours: and being hard and spurning admonition, go alone on the perverted way. But WE, tracking the pious and blameless path of the holy fathers, instructed full well in the writings of the Apostles and Evangelists, will honour together with God the Father and the Holy Ghost, with one worship, the One Lord Jesus Christ, through Whom and with Whom to God the Father be glory with the Holy Ghost unto ages of ages.


Five Tomes Against Nestorius — Translator’s Introduction

P. E. and E. B. Pusey’s 1881 introduction: the history of the Nestorian controversy and of this work.

Source: Cyril of Alexandria, Five Tomes Against Nestorius. Oxford (1881) Introduction by P.E & E.B. Pusey. pp.i-cv.. Transcribed by Roger Pearse (tertullian.org); public domain.

Opening

When Theophilus, Archbishop of Alexandria, died in A.D. 412, his nephew and successor, Cyril, suddenly appears before us. We have only a few scattered references to Cyril's earlier life. We do not know what year he was born, anything about his parents, or where he was raised. That Cyril received a thoroughly good education is abundantly clear—not only from his very extensive reading, which a mind as broad as Cyril's would always seek out for itself, but also because his reading was so well digested, which indicates good early training. The great accuracy of his theology indicates a most accurate theological education. That education included a wide range of secular study as well as divinity, and probably involved a good deal of memorization, not only of the holy Scriptures but also of non-Christian authors, as shown by a line of Antipater Sidonius quoted in his Commentary on Zechariah. He also quotes Josephus on the Jewish war. On Habakkuk 3:2, he mentions interpretations of that verse of two different kinds; on Hosea he gives a long excerpt from a writer whose works we apparently do not possess. Tillemont remarks that "his books against Julian show that he had a large acquaintance with secular writers."1

On the death of Theophilus, Archbishop of Alexandria, in A.D. 412, his nephew and successor, S. Cyril, comes suddenly before us. For of S. Cyril's previous life we have only a few scattered notices. We do not know in what year he was born, nor any thing of his parents, nor where he was brought up. That S. Cyril had received a thoroughly good education, is abundantly clear; not only from his very extensive reading, which a mind of such large grasp as S. Cyril's would ever provide for itself, but that his reading being so well digested implies good early training. The great accuracy of his Theology implies a most accurate Theological education. That education included a large range of secular study as well as of Divinity, and probably comprised a good deal of learning by heart, not only of the holy Scriptures but also of profane authors, as witness a line of Antipater Sidonius quoted in his Commentary on Zechariah. He quotes too Josephus on the Jewish war. On Hab. iii. 2, he mentions interpretations of that verse of two different kinds: on Hosea he gives a long extract from a writer whom we do not apparently possess. Tillemont remarks, that " his books against Julian shew that he had a large acquaintance with secular writers."1

We can deduce that Cyril was raised in a monastery, which served as a place for Christian education. Given the great respect he always showed to Isidore, Abbot of Pelusium, it seems quite possible that Isidore was his teacher during part of his early life. Isidore hints at some special connection in one of his short letters to Cyril when he was Archbishop. Near the start, Isidore writes, "If I am your father as you say I am, or if I am your son as I know I am, since you occupy the chair of Mark, etc." The many Platonic terms in Isidore's letters seem to suggest that he too had read Plato extensively, and Cyril may have gained some of his knowledge of Aristotle from him.2

We may infer that S. Cyril was brought up at some monastery, as a place of Christian education, and from the great reverence which he ever paid to S. Isidore, Abbot of Pelusium, it seems not unlikely that S. Isidore was his instructor during some part of his early life. S. Isidore alludes to some especial tie, in one of his brief letters to S. Cyril, when Archbishop. Near the beginning, S. Isidore says, " If I be your father as you say I be,…..or if I be your son as I know I am, seeing that you hold the chair of S. Mark &c." The large number of Platonic words in S. Isidore's letters seem to indicate that he too had extensive reading of Plato, and S. Cyril may have acquired from him some of his knowledge of Aristotle.2

But a mind of Cyril's breadth would have felt itself lost in the desert, longing for its own calling, and another letter from the same Isidore to Cyril, reproaching him for having his heart set on the world, may belong to this period. His uncle, Archbishop Theophilus, invited him to live with him and, we may reasonably conclude, ordained him as a priest and made him one of his clergy. In a very long letter that Cyril wrote around A.D. 432 to the elderly Acacius, Bishop of Beroea, he mentions in passing the fact that he was present at the Synod of the Oak in A.D. 403, where Chrysostom's troubles began. Cyril would naturally have been there as part of Archbishop Theophilus' official entourage. Cyril says, "When your holy synod was gathered at great Constantinople, and I was one of those standing by, I know that I heard your holiness saying this—"34

But a mind of S. Cyril's grasp would feel itself lost in the desert, yearning for its own calling, and another Letter of the same S.Isidore to S.Cyril, reproaching him with his heart being in the world, may belong to this period. His uncle Archbishop Theophilus had him to live with him and, we may infer, ordained him priest and made him one of his Clergy. In a very long letter which S. Cyril wrote about A.D. 432 to the aged Acacius, Bishop of Beroea, he incidentally mentions the fact that he was at the synod of the Oak, in A.D. 403, where S. Chrysostom's troubles began. S. Cyril would of course be there, as a portion of Archbishop Theophilus' official attendance. S. Cyril says, " When your holy Synod was gathered at great Constantinople…. and I was one of those standing by, I know that I heard your holiness saying thus.—-"34

When Cyril became Archbishop of Alexandria, he immediately gained a position of great power in the city. The early part of his time as archbishop brought trials related to the conflict between him and Orestes the governor, which resulted from a Jewish uprising against the Christians. This was followed by several years of relative peace, during which Cyril seems to have been rarely heard of outside his large diocese. Even in the quietest times, the Archbishops of Alexandria maintained yearly contact with churches everywhere through the annual letter they wrote to announce the date on which Easter would fall. Cyril's letters were clearly intended primarily for his own Egypt. For example, in his seventh Paschal homily in 419, he speaks very strongly about acts of violence in Egypt and mentions the famine there. Cyril introduces the subject with "And these things we now say to you most especially, who inhabit Egyptian territory," showing that the letters themselves had a broader scope. I do not know at what time the letter was sent out so that it would reach the distant churches of Rome, Constantinople, and Antioch in time to announce when Lent would begin. However, although Cyril became Archbishop in October 412, his first letter was for 414, in the early part of which (as Tillemont points out) Cyril speaks of having succeeded his uncle. He introduces the subject by mentioning the natural fear that people of old had regarding "the greatness of the Divine Ministry," and speaking of Moses and Jeremiah as examples of this, adds that "since the role of the priesthood calls one to preach, in fear of the words, Speak and hold not thy peace, I come of necessity to write thus."567

S. Cyril's accession to the Archiepiscopal Throne of Alexandria brought him at once into a position of great power in Alexandria; and brought too, in the early part of it, trials in regard of the disunion between him and Orestes the Governor resulting from the Jewish insurrection against the Christians. To this succeeded some years of great quiet, during which S. Cyril seems to have been very little heard of, outside his Great Diocese. The Archbishops of Alexandria, even in the very stillest times, were brought into yearly contact with the Churches every where by the annual Letter which they wrote to announce the day on which Easter would fall. S. Cyril's letters were evidently intended primarily for his own Egypt. Thus in his seventh Paschal homily A.D. 419, he speaks very strongly about deeds of violence in Egypt and mentions the famine there. S. Cyril introduces the subject with, " And these things we now say to you most especially, who inhabit Egyptian territory," shewing that the Letters themselves had a larger scope. I do not know at what time the Letter was sent out, so as to reach the distant churches of Rome and Constantinople and Antioch in good time to announce when Lent would begin. But although S. Cyril became Archbishop in October A.D. 412, his first Letter was for 414, in the early part of which (as Tillemont points out) S. Cyril speaks of having succeeded his Uncle. He introduces the subject by mentioning the natural dread of those of old, of " the greatness of the Divine Ministry," and speaking of Moses and Jeremiah as instances of this, adds, that "since the garb of the priesthood calls to preach, in fear of the words, Speak and hold not thy peace, I come of necessity to write thus."567

During these quiet years, Cyril probably spent much of his time working on his earlier writings. Two of these dealt with selected passages from the Pentateuch: one volume was dedicated to passages Cyril believed could be understood as types of our Lord, while the other covered the remaining passages as types of the church. The commentaries on Isaiah and the Minor Prophets, as well as the books written against the Emperor Julian, likely belong to this period. In addition, Cyril followed the example of his great predecessor Athanasius by writing two books against the Arians: first, the Thesaurus, in which Cyril applied his knowledge of Aristotle; then the de Trinitate, which was written before A.D. 424, though not published until later. In his Paschal homily for A.D. 424, Cyril also discussed the Eternal Generation of the Son, and toward the end of the homily he opposed the Arian terms "Generate" and "Ingenerate."8

Much of these quiet years S. Cyril probably employed on his earlier writings: of these, two were on select passages of the Pentateuch; one volume being allotted to those which S. Cyril thought could in any way be adapted as types of our Lord, the other to the rest, as being types of the church. The commentaries on Isaiah and the Minor Prophets and the Books against the Emperor Julian probably belong to this period. Besides these S. Cyril, following the example of his great predecessor S. Athanasius, wrote two Books against the Arians: first, the Thesaurus, in which S. Cyril brought to bear his knowledge of Aristotle; then the de Trinitate, which was written, though not published till later, before A.D. 424. In his Paschal homily for that year A.D. 424, S. Cyril also speaks of the Eternal Generation of the Son, and towards the close of the homily he opposes the Arian terms "Generate," "Ingenerate."8

In A.D. 429, when writings by Nestorius began circulating in Egypt, Cyril first wrote about the heresy of Nestorius. There is little doubt that the powerful mind of Leo, who was the driving force behind the Council of Chalcedon, learned through those writings in his younger days when he served as Archdeacon under Pope Celestine in 429, just as Cyril himself had been taught by the writings of Athanasius.

A. D. 429, the circulation of tracts of Nestorius in Egypt occasioned him first to write on the heresy of Nestorius. There can be little doubt that the powerful mind of S. Leo, who was the soul of the Council of Chalcedon, was, in his young days when S. Celestine's Archdeacon in 429, taught through those writings; as S. Cyril himself had been taught by the writings of S. Athanasius.

The 12 Chapters, which were attached to his final letter to Nestorius, caused problems for Cyril later in his time as bishop. Because of this, it is worth presenting them in full here. They were written to prevent any evasion of what that letter stated.

The 12 Chapters, appended to his last letter to Nestorius, were made a trouble to S. Cyril at a later period of his Episcopate, so that it may be well to give them in full. They were framed to preclude any evasion of that letter.

1. If anyone does not confess that Emmanuel is truly God, and that the holy Virgin is therefore Mother of God because she bore in the flesh the Word from God who became flesh, let him be anathema.

1. If any one confess not, that Emmanuel is in truth God, and that the holy Virgin is therefore Mother of God, for she hath borne after the flesh the Word out of God made Flesh, be he anathema.

2. If anyone does not confess that the Word from God the Father has been personally united to flesh, and that He is one Christ with His own flesh—the same being both God and man—let him be anathema.

2. If any one confess not, that the Word out of God the Father hath been personally united to Flesh, and that He is One Christ with His own Flesh, the Same (that is) God alike and Man, be he anathema.

3. If anyone divides the Hypostases of the one Christ after the Union, joining them only by a connection of dignity or authority or power, and not rather by a coming together into Unity of Nature, let him be anathema.

3. If any one sever the Hypostases of the One Christ after the Union, connecting them with only a connection of dignity or authority or sway, and not rather with a concurrence unto Unity of Nature, be he anathema.

4. If anyone distributes the words in the Gospels and apostolic writings—whether spoken about Christ by the saints or by Christ about Himself—to two persons or hypostases, attributing some to a man considered separately from the Word who is from God, and others as befitting God to the Word alone who is from God the Father, let him be anathema.

4. If any one allot to two Persons or Hypostases the words in the Gospels and Apostolic writings, said either of Christ by the saints or by Him of Himself, and ascribe some to a man conceived of by himself apart from the Word That is out of God, others as God-befitting to the Word alone That is out of God the Father, be he anathema.

5. If anyone dares to say that Christ is a man bearing God, and not rather that He is truly God as being the one Son and that by nature, because the Word became flesh and shared in blood and flesh like us, let him be anathema.

5. If any one dare to say, that Christ is a God-clad man, and not rather that He is God in truth as being the One Son, and That by Nature, in that the Word hath been made Flesh, and hath shared like us in blood and flesh, be he anathema.

6. If anyone dares to say that the Word who is from God the Father is the God or Lord of Christ, rather than confessing that the same one is both God and man because the Word has been made flesh according to the Scriptures, let him be anathema.

6. If any one dare to say that the Word That is out of God the Father is God or Lord of Christ and do not rather confess that the Same is God alike and Man, in that the Word hath been made Flesh, according to the Scriptures, be he anathema.

7. If anyone says that Jesus was indwelt as a man by God the Word, and that the Glory of the Only-Begotten was placed upon Him, as though He were someone other than the Word Himself, let him be anathema.9

7. If any one say that Jesus hath been in-wrought-in as man by God the Word, and that the Glory of the Only-Begotten hath been put about Him, as being another than He, be he anathema.9

8. If anyone dares to say that the assumed man ought to be worshipped together with God the Word, and glorified together with Him, and called God together with Him, as one person in another person (for the prefix "co-" that is constantly added forces us to understand it this way), and does not instead honor Emmanuel with a single act of worship and offer to Him one doxology, since the Word has been made Flesh, let him be anathema.

8. If any one shall dare to say that the man that was assumed ought to be co-worshipped with God the Word and co-glorified and co-named God as one in another (for the co-, ever appended, compels us thus to deem) and does not rather honour Emmanuel with one worship, and send up to Him One Doxology, inasmuch as the Word has been made Flesh, be he anathema.

9. If anyone says that the one Lord Jesus Christ was glorified by the Spirit, using the Spirit's power as if it belonged to another, and receiving from the Spirit the power to work against unclean spirits and to accomplish divine signs among men, and does not rather say that the Spirit is His own, through whom He also worked the divine signs, let him be anathema.

9. If any one say that the One Lord Jesus Christ hath been glorified by the Spirit, using His Power as though it were Another's, and from Him receiving the power of working against unclean spirits and of accomplishing Divine signs towards men, and does not rather say that His own is the Spirit, through Whom also He wrought the Divine signs, be he anathema.

The Divine Scripture says that Christ has been made the High Priest and Apostle of our Confession and that He offered Himself for us as a fragrance of a sweet smell to God the Father. If anyone therefore says that it was not the very Word from God who was made our High Priest and Apostle when He was made flesh and man like us, but that the man born of a woman was made this separately by himself as someone other than He, or if anyone says that He offered the sacrifice on His own behalf as well and not only for us alone (for He who knows no sin had no need of an offering), let him be anathema.

10. The Divine Scripture says that Christ hath been made the Sigh Priest and Apostle of our Confession and that He offered Himself for us for an odour of a sweet smell to God the Father. If any one therefore say that, not the Very Word out of God was made our High Priest and Apostle when He was made Flesh and man as we, but that man of a woman apart by himself as other than He, was [so made]: or if any one say that in His own behalf also He offered the Sacrifice and not rather for us alone (for He needed not offering Who knoweth not sin), be he anathema.

If anyone does not confess that the flesh of the Lord is life-giving and that it is the very own flesh of the Word Himself who is from God the Father, but instead says that it belongs to someone other than Him, connected to Him only by dignity or as having divine indwelling, and does not rather confess that it is life-giving (as we said) because it has become the very own flesh of the Word who is able to give life to all things, let him be anathema.

11. If any one confess not, that the Flesh of the Lord is Life-giving and that it is the own Flesh of the Word Himself That is out of God the Father, but says that it belongs to another than He, connected with Him by dignity or as possessed of Divine Indwelling only, and not rather that it is Life-giving (as we said) because it hath been made the own Flesh of the Word Who is mighty to quicken all things, be he anathema.

If anyone does not confess that the Word of God suffered in the flesh and was crucified in the flesh and tasted death in the flesh and became the firstborn from the dead—since as God He is both Life and Life-giving—let him be anathema.

12. If any one confess not that the Word of God suffered in the Flesh and hath been crucified in the Flesh and tasted death in the Flesh and hath been made First-born of the Dead, inasmuch as He is both Life and Life-giving as God, be he anathema.

The great diocese of Antioch, barely recovering from its terrible devastation by Arian wickedness, oppression, and false belief, had been closely confronted with Apollinarianism—a false belief that the Only-Begotten Son took flesh only without a rational soul, and that His mindless body was somehow mixed together with the Godhead. Saint Athanasius and others add, among the forms of this false belief, that some Apollinarians thought that our Lord's body was consubstantial with His Godhead. Saint Cyril in his Dialogue speaks of the great fear widespread among some people that if one Incarnate physis (nature) were held, the body must be believed to be consubstantial with the Godhead. Succensus, Bishop of Diocaesarea, at almost the extreme western boundary of that great diocese or province of Antioch, sent to Saint Cyril a question to the same effect. Theodore of Mopsuestia, who had died only about two years before these chapters were issued, had held that the manhood of the Only-Begotten was a distinct man, having some undefined connection with God the Son, and this had appeared in his writings. So great was Theodore's reputation and the dread of the Apollinarian heresy that there seems to have been an unconscious vagueness in the minds of some of the Eastern bishops. Nestorius had cleverly sent the chapters to John of Antioch apart from the letter to himself, which would have made misinterpretation impossible. He sent them as propositions circulated in the royal city to the injury of the common Church. John of Antioch, who at that time believed Nestorius to be orthodox, immediately pronounced them, thus unexplained, to be Apollinarian. He applied in an encyclical letter to the bishops of his patriarchate to have them disclaimed, but without naming the author, whom John did not believe to be Saint Cyril, and asked two of the bishops of his province, Andrew Bishop of Samosata and Theodoret, to reply to them. Theodoret's reply shows that he read the chapters with the conviction that they were Apollinarian, and he accordingly replies not to the chapters themselves but to the sense which he himself imagined that they contained. His reply is mainly orthodox, though it looks in one or two places as if his belief was rather vague, but he twists Saint Cyril's words so as to mean mixture, and so replies. Theodoret seems never to have gotten over his misapprehension. For in his long letter to the monks of his province—Euphratesia, Osroene, Syria, Phoenicia, Cilicia—he still speaks of chapter 1 as teaching that God the Word was changed into flesh, and of chapters 2 and 3 as bringing in the terms personal union and natural union, teaching through these names a mixture and confusion of the divine physis and the bondman's form. This is the offspring of Apollinarius' heretical innovation. And after speaking of chapter 4, he sums up, These are the Egyptian's brood, the truly more wicked descendants of a wicked parent. In his letter to John Bishop of Germanicia, written after the Robbers' council in 449, Theodoret says of it, Let them deny now the chapters which they many times condemned, but have in Ephesus now confirmed.10111213141516

The Great Diocese of Antioch, barely rallying from its terrible devastation by Arian wickedness oppression and misbelief, had been in close quarters with Apollinarianism, a misbelief that the Only-Begotten Son took flesh only without a reasonable soul, and that His mind-less Body was somehow immingled with the Godhead. S. Athanasius and others add, among the forms of the misbelief, that some Apollinarians thought that our Lord's Body was consubstantial with His Godhead. S. Cyril in his Dialogue speaks of the great fear prevalent among some, that if One Incarnate Nature were holden, the Body must be believed to be consubstantial with the Godhead. Succensus, Bishop of Diocaesarea, at almost the extreme west boundary of that great Diocese or Province of Antioch, sent to S. Cyril a question to the same effect. Theodore of Mopsuestia, who had died only about two years before these Chapters were issued, had held that the Manhood of the Only-Begotten was a man distinct, having some undefined connection with God the Son, and this had appeared in his writings; and so great was Theodore's reputation and the dread of the Apollinarian heresy, that there seems to have been an unconscious vagueness in the minds of some of the Eastern Bishops. [Nestorius had dexterously sent the Chapters to John of Antioch apart from the Epistle to himself, which would have made misinterpretation impossible. He sent them as 'propositions circulated in the royal city to the injury of the common Church.'] John of Antioch, who at that time believed Nestorius to be orthodox, pronounced them at once (thus unexplained) to be Apollinarian; applied in an Encyclical letter to the Bishops of his Patriarchate to have them 'disclaimed, but without naming the author,' whom John did not believe to be S. Cyril, and asked two of the Bishops of his Province, Andrew Bishop of Samosata, and Theodoret, to reply to them. Theodoret's reply shews that he read the Chapters with the conviction that they were Apollinarian, and he accordingly replies, not to the Chapters themselves but to the sense which he himself imagined that they contained. His reply is in the main orthodox, though it looks in one or two places as if his belief was rather vague, but he twists S. Cyril's words so as to mean 'mixture,' and so replies. Theodoret seems never to have got over his misapprehension. For in his long Letter to the Monks of his Province, Euphratesia, Osroene, Syria, Phoenicia, Cilicia, he still speaks of Chapter 1 as teaching that God the Word was changed into flesh; of chapters 2 and 3 as bringing in the terms, Personal Union and Natural Union, "teaching through these names a mixture and confusion of the Divine Nature and the bondman's form: this is the offspring of Apollinarius' heretical innovation." And after speaking of Chapter 4, he sums up, "These are the Egyptian's brood, the truly more wicked descendants of a wicked parent." In his letter to John Bishop of Germanicia, written after the Robbers' council in 449, Theodoret says of it, "Let them deny now the chapters which they many times condemned, but have in Ephesus now confirmed."10111213141516

Andrew of Samosata, on the other hand, seems to have had a much clearer position on the Incarnation and to have believed that some of Cyril's chapters were Apollinarian without objecting to all of them. Andrew's main objection to chapter 1 appears to have been that he misunderstood the phrase "for she bore according to the flesh (σαρκικῶς)" to mean that the Birth was entirely natural and therefore not from a Virgin. Andrew passes over chapter 2 as if the term "Personal Union" had not even struck him as problematic. In chapter 3, Andrew thinks that φυσικὴ, Natural Union, or Unity of Nature is an unacceptable expression for something that is above our nature. In chapter 4, Andrew thinks that because the words are not to be assigned to distinct Persons, Cyril must have meant that they are not to be assigned at all, either to the Godhead or to the Manhood in the One Person of the Incarnate God. Cyril had said throughout his life that they were to be assigned in this way, but Andrew had obviously not read Cyril's writings. Andrew shows his own clear belief by using the expression ἡ ἄκρα ἕνωσις (entire union) here, and the closing words of his reply to chapter 11 are "we confess the union entire (τὴν ἕνωσιν ἄκραν) and divine and incomprehensible to us." These are almost identical to Cyril's expressions "we shall not take away the difference in nature by uniting them entirely (διὰ τὸ εἰς ἄκρον ἑνοῦν)" and in his reply to Andrew, διὰ τὴν εἰς ἄκρον ἕνωσιν.1718

Andrew of Samosata, on the other hand, seems to have been decidedly more definite in his belief on the Incarnation, and to have thought that some of S. Cyril's chapters were Apollinarian without objecting to all. Thus Andrew's chief objection to chapter 1 appears to have been that he mistook the words "for she hath borne after the flesh ( σαρκικῶς)" to mean that the Birth was entirely in the order of nature and so not of a Virgin. Andrew passes over chapter 2, as though the term, "Personal Union," had not even struck him as a difficulty. In chapter 3, Andrew thinks that φυσικὴ, Natural Union, or Unity of Nature is an inadmissible expression, as to what is above our nature. In chapter 4, Andrew thinks that because the words are not to be apportioned to distinct Persons, therefore S. Cyril meant, that they are not to be apportioned at all, either to the Godhead or to the Manhood in the One Person of the Incarnate God. S. Cyril had all his life said that they were to be so apportioned, but Andrew had of course not read S. Cyril's writings. Andrew shews his own definite belief by the expression ἡ ἄκρα ἕνωσις, entire union, here; and, ' we confess the union entire ( τὴν ἕνωσιν ἄκραν) and Divine and incomprehensible to us,' are the closing words of his reply to chapter 11. These are almost identical with S. Cyril's expressions, "we shall not take away the unlike by nature through wholly uniting them ( διὰ τὸ εἰς ἄκρον ἑνοῦν)," and in his reply to Andrew, διὰτὴν εἰς ἄκρον ἕνωσιν.1718

Andrew says nothing on chapters 5 and 6, and there is nothing in them that one would expect him to reject. He agrees with chapter 7, simply adding that in rejecting what Cyril rejects, we must not reject the apostolic words which speak of Christ in his human nature. Andrew also agrees with chapter 8, but does not fully understand it. In chapter 9, he overlooks the words "as though it were Another's." In chapter 10, Andrew thinks that the statement "the very Word out of God was made our High-Priest and Apostle" means that the Godhead by itself was made such.

Andrew says nothing on chapters 5 and 6, nor is there anything in them which one would expect him not to accept. With chapter 7 he agrees, merely saying that in rejecting what S. Cyril rejects, we must not reject the Apostolic words which speak of Him in His human nature. "With chapter 8 too Andrew agrees, but does not quite understand the co. In chapter 9, he overlooks the words, "as though it were Another's:" in chapter 10, Andrew thinks that " the Yery Word out of God was made our High-Priest and Apostle" means 'the Godhead apart by Itself was so made.'

We can see in our own times how prejudice can distort the meaning of words that are in themselves perfectly clear. Otherwise it seems inconceivable that language as plain as that of the Anathematisms, if read with the aim of understanding their author's meaning, could be misunderstood as it was by John of Antioch, Theodoret, and Andrew. Much unholy dissension would have been avoided if John, instead of asking Theodoret and Andrew to respond to them, had sought an explanation from Saint Cyril himself. Saint Cyril, fully conscious of his own meaning, would naturally have given the explanation which later satisfied John of Antioch, Acacius of Beroea, and Paul of Emesa.

[We see in our own times, how prejudice can distort the meaning of words in themselves perfectly intelligible; else it seems inconceivable that language so clear as that of the Anathematisms, if read with a view to understand their author's meaning, could be misunderstood as it was by John of Antioch, Theodoret, and Andrew. Much unhallowed dissension would have been saved, if John, instead of asking Theodoret and Andrew to reply to them, had sought an explanation from S. Cyril himself. S. Cyril, in clear consciousness of his own meaning, would, of course, have given the explanation which afterwards satisfied John of Antioch, Acacius of Beroea, and Paul of Emesa.

Petavius examined S. Cyril's anathematisms with his characteristic thoroughness, comparing them with Nestorius's counter-anathematisms, the criticisms from the Orientals and from Theodoret, and S. Cyril's responses. His conclusion is that there is nothing in S. Cyril's Anathematisms that is not correct and consistent with the Catholic rule, and that those who criticized or opposed them failed to make their case against him except through nitpicking and foolish slander. De Incarn. L. vi. c. xvii. They have also been carefully examined in English in Dr. Bright's Later Treatises of S. Athanasius, pp. 149-170.

S. Cyril's anathematisms have been weighed by Petavius with his usual solidity, as compared with the counter-anathematisms of Nestorius, the criticisms of the Orientals and of Theodoret, and S. Cyril's answers. His summary is, 'There is nothing in S. Cyril's Anathematisms not right and in harmony with the Catholic rule, nor did those who detract from or oppose them maintain their ground against him except through cavils and foolish calumnies.' De Incarn. L. vi. c. xvii. They have also been carefully compared in English in Dr. Bright's Later Treatises of S. Athanasius, pp. 149-170.]

Though Apollinarianism in its early form, before it spread widely as Eutychianism, seems to have mainly troubled Asia rather than Egypt, Cyril always writes with full knowledge of it. In his Thesaurus, he clearly mentions and rejects Apollinarian errors and denies the claim "made man, came not into a man like as He was in the Prophets." Cyril's tenth Paschal homily for A.D. 420, in its most carefully weighed language, contradicts both Apollinarianism and Nestorianism, just as much as what Cyril wrote when the Nestorian troubles had begun. In his commentary on Habakkuk, Cyril affirms, as he does throughout his whole life, that our Lord was not diminished by the Incarnation: "Yet even though He has been made flesh and has been set forth by the Father as a propitiation, He has not cast away what He was, that is, being God, but is even thus in God-befitting authority and glory."1920

Though Apollinarianism in its early form, ere its great spread as Eutychianism, seems to have chiefly troubled Asia rather than Egypt, S. Cyril always writes with full knowledge of it. In his Thesaurus, he distinctly mentions and repudiates Apollinarian errors and denies the οὐκ ἐν ἀνθρώπῳ γέγονε, "made man, came not into a man like as He was in the Prophets." S. Cyril's tenth Paschal homily for A.D. 420, in its most carefully weighed language, contradicts both Apollinarianism and Nestorianism, not less than what S. Cyril wrote when the Nestorian troubles had begun. On Habaccuc S. Cyril affirms, as he does through his whole life, that our Lord was not worsened by the Incarnation; "Yet even though He has been made flesh and hath been set forth by the Father as a propitiation, He hath not cast away what He was, i.e., the being God, but is even thus in God-befitting authority and glory."1920

In A.D. 428, Nestorius was brought from Antioch to become Archbishop of Constantinople. Because S. Cyril's famous Paschal homily for the following year, A.D. 429, dealt with the subject of the Incarnation, some have assumed that rumors of the denial of that Faith in Constantinople had already reached him. However, the Paschal homilies for A.D. 420 and 423 show that the Incarnation, the foundation and support of our souls, was a subject S. Cyril loved to focus on. During the year 429, however, even Egypt was disturbed by the false teaching of Nestorius. Some of Nestorius' sermons made their way into Egypt and were read and studied in the monasteries. This caused so much trouble in the minds of some of the monks that S. Cyril wrote a letter to them, explaining that the Incarnation means that God the Son united to Himself His own human nature which He took, as completely as soul and body are united in each of us, and in this way His Passion and Death were His own, though He, as God, could not suffer. This letter circulated widely and reached Constantinople. It annoyed Nestorius. There was still a lingering bitterness toward Alexandria stemming from Theophilus' treatment of S. Chrysostom. Besides this, the Catholic doctrine of the Incarnation—the manhood united by God the Son to His own self—was to Nestorius Apollinarianism or mixture. Nestorius says so himself. In his letter to S. Celestine he speaks of the 'corruption of orthodoxy among some' and describes it this way,2122232425

In A.D. 428, Nestorius was brought from Antioch to be Archbishop of Constantinople. From the circumstance that S. Cyril's celebrated Paschal homily for the next year, A.D. 429, was on the subject of the Incarnation, it has been supposed that rumours of the denial of that Faith in Constantinople had already reached him. But the Paschal homilies for A.D. 420 and 423, shew that the Incarnation, the foundation and stay of our souls, was a subject, which S. Cyril loved to dwell on. In the course of the year 429, however, even Egypt was troubled by the false teaching of Nestorius. Some of Nestorius' sermons passed into Egypt, and were read and pondered over in the Monasteries. This occasioned so much disturbance in the minds of some of the Monks, that S. Cyril wrote a Letter to them, pointing out that the Incarnation means, that God the Son united to Him His own human nature which He took, as completely as soul and body are united in each of us, and in this way His Passion and Death were His own, though He, as God, could not suffer. This Letter had an extended circulation and reached Constantinople. It vexed Nestorius. There was still a traditional soreness towards Alexandria, from the behaviour of Theophilus to S. Chrysostom. Besides this, the Catholic doctrine of the Incarnation, the manhood united by God the Son to His own self, was to Nestorius, Apollinarianism or mixture. Nestorius says so. In his letter to S. Celestine he tells of the 'corruption of orthodoxy among some' and thus describes it,2122232425

This is no small illness, but one closely related to the corrupt teachings of Apollinarius and Arius. For they reduce the Lord's union with humanity to a kind of confused mixture, to the point that even certain clergy among us—some from lack of understanding, others from heretical deception long hidden within them—are infected with heresy and openly blaspheme God the Word who is Consubstantial with the Father. They act as though He began His existence from the Virgin mother of Christ, was constructed together with His Temple, and was buried together with His flesh. They claim that the flesh after the resurrection did not remain flesh but passed into the physis of Godhead. They trace the Godhead of the Only-Begotten back to the beginning of the flesh that was joined with it, they make it subject to death along with the flesh, and they blasphemously say that the flesh joined with Godhead passed over into Godhead—using the very term "deifying," which amounts to nothing less than corrupting both.26

'It is a sickness not small, but akin to the putrid sore of Apollinarius and Arius. For they mingle the Lord's union in man to a confusion of some sort of mixture, insomuch that even certain clerks among us, of whom some from lack of understanding, some from heretical guile of old time concealed within them.. are sick as heretics, and openly blaspheme God the Word Consubstantial with the Father, as though He had taken beginning of His Being of the Virgin mother of Christ, and had been built up with His Temple and buried with His flesh, and say that the flesh after the resurrection did not remain [miscuisse seems an error for mansisse] flesh but passed into the Nature of Godhead, and they refer the Godhead of the Only-Begotten to the beginning of the flesh which was connected with It, and they put It to death with the flesh, and blasphemously say that the flesh connected with Godhead passed into Godhead, using the very word deifying, which is nothing else than to corrupt both.'26

Nestorius repeats the same thing in his second letter to Saint Celestine. Saint Cyril had clearly set forth the mode of the Union in his first Ecumenical Letter to Nestorius using these words. Nestorius does not understand this language and says the following about it:27

Nestorius repeats the same in his second letter to S. Celestine. S. Cyril having in his first Ecumenical Letter to Nestorius put forth clearly the mode of the Union in these words, Nestorius does not understand the language and says thus of it,27

I now turn to the second chapter of your letter, where I begin to praise the separation of the natures with regard to Godhead and Manhood and their union into one prosopon, and that we must not say that God the Word needed a second birth from a woman, and must confess that the Godhead cannot receive suffering. For such statements are truly orthodox and oppose the bad reputations of all the heresies regarding the Lord's natures. As for the rest, whether they bring to the readers' ears some hidden, incomprehensible wisdom is for your precision to determine; to me they seem to overturn what came before. For the one who in the preceding section is proclaimed impassible and incapable of receiving a second birth, they introduce as somehow capable of suffering and newly created, as though the qualities naturally inherent in God the Word were corrupted by union with the Temple, etc.28

'I come now to the second chapter of your Love, wherein I begin to praise the parting of the natures in regard to Godhead and Manhood and their connection into one Person, and that we must not say that God the Word needed a second generation out of a woman, and must confess that the Godhead is unrecipient of suffering. For such statements are truly orthodox and counter to the ill-reputes of all the heresies, as to the Lord's natures. As to the rest, whether they bring to the ears of the readers some hidden incomprehensible wisdom, pertains to your accuracy to know; to me they seem to overturn what preceded. For Him Who in the preceding is proclaimed Impassible and non-recipient of a second birth, they introduce as somehow passible and new-created, as though the qualities by nature adherent in God the Word were corrupted by connection with the Temple &c. '28

And yet St. Cyril's language is so carefully guarded that no one who believed in the true union of Godhead and Manhood in the incarnate Son would mistake it.

And yet S. Cyril's language is so carefully guarded, that no one who believed in True Union of Godhead and Manhood in the Incarnate Son would mistake it.

Nestorius appears not to have paid any attention to Cyril's Paschal Homily, but he preached against the Letter to the Monks more than once, as we can see from the excerpts of his sermons that Cyril had access to. The passages from the Letter to the Monks that Nestorius referred to are:

Nestorius does not appear to have taken any notice of S. Cyril's Paschal Homily, but he preached against the Letter to the Monks more than once, as we see from the extracts of such of his sermons as S. Cyril had access to. The passages of the Letter to the Monks referred to by Nestorius are;

These letters were directed by me against the Egyptian…. He, omitting to tell me by letter whether anything appeared to him to need marking as blasphemous or wicked, moved by fear of proofs and looking out therefore for disturbances which should aid him, turns to Celestine of Rome, as one too simple to understand the force of the doctrines. And finding the man's simplicity in regard to this matter, he in childish fashion deceives his ears with crafty letters, having long ago sent him my writings as irrefutable proof, as though I were making Christ out to be a mere man—I who at the very beginning of my consecration obtained a Law against those who say that Christ is a mere man and against other heresies.29

' These letters were directed by me against the Egyptian…. He, omitting to tell me by letter whether any thing appeared to him to need marking as blasphemous or wicked, moved by fear of proofs and looking out therefore for disturbances which should aid him, turns him to Celestine of Rome, as one too simple to fathom the force of the doctrines. And finding the simplicity of the man in regard to this matter, he in childish fashion circumvents his ears with crafty letters, long ago sending him my writings, as a proof which might not be gainsaid, as though I were making Christ out to be a mere man, I who at the very beginning of my consecration obtained a Law against those who say that Christ is a mere man and against other heresies.29

But he compiled writings by weaving together extracts from my sermons, so that the slander against me created by piecing together these extracts would not be discovered. He added some things to my sermons, broke off bits of others, and took what I had said about the Lord's Incarnation as if I had said it about a mere man. Things I had said in praise of the Godhead he cut away entirely from their context, leaving some out of their proper place, and thus created a plausible deception. To expose his wickedness in a few instances as it appears in the rest: I said somewhere, speaking against the pagans who claim we preach that the Essence of God was newly created from a Virgin, "Mary, my friends, did not bear the Godhead; she bore a man, the inseparable instrument of Godhead." But he changed the word "Godhead" and made it, "Mary, my friends, did not bear God." Now, to say "God" and to say "the Godhead" makes a very great difference. For the one signifies the Divine and unembodied Essence, but does not mean the flesh. For flesh is composite and created. But the word "God" also applies to the temple of the Godhead, which obtains its dignity by union with the Divine Essence of God, yet is not changed into that Divine Essence.

'But he compiled writings, interweaving extracts of my sermons, in order that the slander put on me by the piecing of extracts might not be found out. And some things he added to my sermons, he broke off bits of others and pieced what I had said of the Lord's Incarnation as though I had said them of a mere man. Things again which I had said in praise of the Godhead he cut entirely away from the context, leaving some out of their proper place, and thus made out a plausible misleading. And to publish his wickedness in a few instances such as it is in the rest, I said somewhere, speaking against the heathen who say that we preach that the Essence of God has been newly created from a Virgin, 'Mary, my friends, bare not the Godhead; she bare a man the inseparable instrument of Godhead.' But he changing the word, Godhead, made it, 'Mary, my friends, bare not God.' Here to say God, and to say the Godhead, makes very much difference. For the one signifies the Divine and unembodied Essence, but does not mean the flesh. For flesh is compound and created. But the word God belongs to the temple also of the Godhead, which obtains the dignity by union with the Divine Essence of God, yet is not changed into that Divine Essence.

In another place I spoke against those who, when they hear the same name used, are offended as though the same honor were also being given. When I say "Mother of Christ," they shudder as though the Godhead of the Lord Christ were being denied by this name, since many have been called by this name in the Old Testament. And so they think we are calling Him Christ in the same way as these others. Against these people therefore (as I said) I said in church sermons that equality of honor does not follow from similarity of name. And this is what I said: "Or if the Temple of Godhead—we say that the descent of the Holy Spirit is not the same as what was accomplished in the Prophets, not the same as what was celebrated in the Apostles, nor yet the same as what takes place with regard to the Angels who are strengthened for the Divine Mysteries. For the Lord Christ is Lord of all, even as to the body. Therefore, just as we say that God is the Creator of all things, yet Scripture also calls Moses god, for it says, 'I have made you a god to Pharaoh,' and yet we by no means attach equal honor to that word, so neither should we stumble at the similarity of expression just because the word by which we say 'Christ' and 'Son' is common. For just as Israel is named son, for He says, 'Israel is My first-born son,' and the Lord is also called Son, for He says, 'This is My Beloved Son,' yet the expression being one does not mean the meaning is also one. And just as Saul is called christ and David christ and again Cyrus christ and, besides, the Babylonian, although they were surely not equal in piety to David, so we call the Lord also Christ or Son, yet the community of names does not make an equality of dignity." From this which I said, he everywhere removed the last words, that is, "Christ," and "we say that not the same is the indwelling as was accomplished in the prophets, not the same as was accomplished in the Apostles," and "we by no means assign like honor by like words," and "yet the community of names does not make equality of dignity." Cutting out all these expressions with the teeth of slander, he throws in people's ears what comes before these words, that is, "We call the Creator of all God, yet Scripture also calls Moses god," and "Israel is called God's son, the Lord too is called Son," and "Saul is called christ and David christ and even the Babylonian; thus then do we also call the Lord Christ christ." He therefore, by piecing these things together and cutting them off from the rest (as we said), created here through his slander something like what would happen if, from Paul's words by which he argues in writing, "If you are circumcised Christ will profit you nothing," one were to tear off what he says first, "If you are circumcised," and accuse Paul as though he preached, "Christ will profit you nothing." And why should we prolong our account by going through each instance? In short, Cyril, using many such thefts and additions as pleased him, soon led astray not only others but also Celestine by his deceptions.30

'Again in another place I spoke against those who, hearing the like name, are offended as though like honour were also given. And when I say, Mother of Christ, they shudder as though the Godhead of the Lord Christ were denied by this name, seeing that many have been similarly called by this name in the Old Testament. And hence they think that we are calling Him Christ like these. Against these people therefore (as I said) I said in church-sermons, that equality of honour does not follow likeness of name. And this is what I said, 'Or if the Temple of Godhead, wo say that the descent of the Holy Ghost is not the same as was wrought on the Prophets, not the same as was celebrated on the Apostles, nor yet the same as takes place in regard to the Angels who are strengthened unto the Divine Mysteries. For the Lord Christ is Lord of all, as to the body too. As therefore we say that God is the Creator of all things, yet does the Scripture call Moses too god, for it says, I have made thee a god to Pharoah, and yet we by no means attach equal honour to that word, so neither, because the word is common by which we say, Christ and Son, ought we to stumble at the likeness of expression. For as Israel is named son, for He says, Israel is My first-born son, and the Lord again Son, for He says, This is My Beloved Son, yet not, as the expression is one, is the meaning also one. And as Saul is called christ and David christ and again Cyrus christ and, besides, the Babylonian, albeit they were surely not equal in piety to David; so we call the Lord too Christ or Son, yet the community of names does not makes an equality of dignity.' From this which I said, he every where subtracting the last words, i.e. 'Christ,' and, 'we say, that not the same is the indwelling as was wrought on the prophets, not the same as was wrought on the Apostles,' and, ' we by no means allot like honour by like words,' and, 'yet the community of names does not make equality of dignity; ' cutting out all these expressions with the teeth of slander, he flings in the ears of men what precedes these words: i.e., ' We call the Creator of all God, yet does the Scripture also call Moses god:, and, 'Israel is called God's son, Son too is the Lord called;' and, 'Saul is called christ and David christ yea and the Babylonian; thus then do we call Christ the Lord also christ.' He therefore thus piecing these things and chipping them off from the rest (as we said), made up here by his slander like as if from Paul's words by which he contests writing, If ye be circumcised Christ shall profit you nothing, one were to rend off what he says first, If ye he circumcised, and accuse Paul as though he preached, Christ shall profit you nothing. And why need we prolong our recital by going through each instance? In short Cyril using many such robberies and additions as pleased him, soon not others only but Celestine also were led away by his misleadings.'30

Around this time, Cyril probably wrote his Scholia on the Incarnation. The treatise is very simple and almost free of controversy, explaining the Incarnation through simple analogies and biblical types. It contains one of Cyril's most careful statements of the doctrine, explicitly rejecting Apollinarianism. In the concluding sections, which may have been written at the very beginning of the controversy with Nestorius, are striking and simple statements showing how the Passion belongs to God the Son, even though the Godhead cannot suffer.31323334

Much about this time S. Cyril probably wrote his Scholia on the Incarnation. The treatise is very simple and almost uncontroversial, illustrating the Incarnation by simple analogies and Bible-types. It contains one of S. Cyril's most careful statements of the doctrine, excluding Apollinarianism. In the concluding sections, which may have been written at the very beginning of the controversy with Nestorius, are striking and simple statements, how God the Son's Passion is His, though Godhead cannot suffer.31323334

Shortly after this, Cyril wrote his first surviving letter to Nestorius, a brief letter in which he said he had heard that Nestorius was very angry about Cyril's letter to the monks. However, since certain teachings, whether Nestorius's or not, had been brought to Egypt and had seriously misled many people, it became his duty to God to set forth the correct doctrine. Cyril also mentioned that Celestine and the bishops with him had asked whether those teachings that had reached them were Nestorius's or not. Cyril did not know. Finally, Cyril asked him to resolve the confusion by using the single term Theotokos for the Holy Virgin. To avoid being misunderstood, he also mentioned a book he had written during the episcopate of Atticus of blessed memory, on the Holy and Consubstantial Trinity, in which he had woven in some material on the Incarnation similar to what he had now written.

Soon after this S. Cyril wrote his first extant letter to Nestorius, a short letter, saying that he hears that Nestorius was very angry at S. Cyril's letter to the Monks, yet that since 'expositions,' whether Nestorius' or not, had been brought to Egypt and had gravely misled many, it became a duty to God to put forth the right doctrine. S. Cyril also says that S. Celestine and the Bishops with him had asked whether those 'expositions' which had come thither were Nestorius' or not. S. Cyril did not know. Finally, S. Cyril asked him to heal the confusion by the use of the one word Theotocos, of the Holy Virgin. For fear of misapprehension he mentions also a book, which he had written in the Episcopate of Atticus of blessed memory, on the Holy and Consnbstantial Trinity, in which he had interwoven some things on the Incarnation, like what he had now written.

We do not know how much time passed between this and the second letter that Cyril wrote in synod to Nestorius, containing an exposition of the Incarnation. Because of its acceptance by the Council of Ephesus and the whole Church afterward, this letter has ecumenical authority. It was probably written before the end of 429 and is the letter quoted above, which Nestorius' reply showed that he could not understand. It has been suggested that because of Nestorius' reference to the imperial court at the end of his reply, Cyril wrote his three treatises de recta fide. The first of these is addressed to the Emperor Theodosius, and the other two are addressed to the emperor's queen and sisters. John, Bishop of Caesarea in Palestine, in the century following Cyril, quotes from both among his extracts in defense of the Council of Chalcedon. From the title with which he introduces his extracts, we learn that the longer treatise was addressed to the emperor's two younger sisters, the Princesses Marina and Arcadia, and the last of the three to the two Augustas, Theodosius' Empress Eudocia and his eldest sister Pulcheria, who had the title of Augusta from having been regent for the emperor during his minority. Cyril later recast his treatise to the emperor in the form of a dialogue, omitting what was specifically addressed to the emperor and making small adjustments to the language here and there. Thus the expression "neither do we say two Christs, even though we believe that the temple united to the Word has been ensouled with rational soul" becomes in the dialogue "neither do we say two Christs, even though we believe that out of perfect man and out of God the Word has been wrought the concurrence unto unity of Emmanuel." A little further on, "we say that the whole Word out of God has been co-united with the whole manhood that is of us" becomes "we say therefore that the whole Word has been united to whole man." This dialogue was probably appended by Cyril to his older dialogues de Trinitate. It is quoted as the seventh of those dialogues. The other two treatises are mainly made up of expositions of biblical texts to prove that Christ is God and man. Near the beginning of the one addressed to the Augustas, Cyril refers to his earlier treatise.35363738394041

We do not know what time intervened between this and the second Letter which S. Cyril wrote in Synod to Nestorius, containing an exposition of the Incarnation, which, from its acceptance by the Council of Ephesus and the whole Church subsequently, has Ecumenical authority. It was probably written before the close of A.D. 429 and is the Letter quoted above, which Nestorius' reply shewed that he could not understand. It has been supposed that it was in consequence of Nestorius' allusion to the Imperial Court in the close of his reply, that S. Cyril wrote his Three Treatises de recta fide; whereof the first is to the Emperor Theodosius; the other two to the Emperor's Queen and Sisters. John Bishop of Caesarea in Palestine, in the century following S. Cyril, quotes from both among his extracts in defence of the Council of Chalcedon. From the title with which he introduces his extracts, we learn that the longer Treatise was addressed to the Emperor's two younger sisters, the Princesses Marina and Arcadia, and the last of the Three to the Two Augusta's, Theodosius' Empress Eudocia, and his eldest sister Pulcheria who had the title of Augusta, from having been Regent for the Emperor in his minority. S. Cyril afterwards recast his Treatise to the Emperor in the form of a Dialogue, omitting what was specially addressed to the Emperor, and giving little touches here and there to the language. Thus the expression " neither do we say Two christs, even though we believe that the Temple united to the Word has been ensouled with rational soul," becomes in the Dialogue, " neither do we say Two christs, even though we believe that out of perfect man and out of God the Word has been wrought the concurrence unto unity of Emmanuel." A little further on, " we say that the whole Word out of Grod has been co-united with the whole manhood that is of us," becomes, " we say therefore that the whole Word has been united to whole man." This Dialogue was probably appended by S. Cyril to his older Dialogues de Trinitate. It is quoted as the seventh of those Dialogues. The other two treatises are chiefly made up of expositions of texts to prove that Christ is God and Man. Near the beginning of that to the Augusta's, S. Cyril alludes to his former treatise.35363738394041

In my treatise to the holy Virgins (that is, the Princesses Marina and Arcadia who had embraced the virgin life), I provided a very large collection of more straightforward statements that had nothing difficult to understand. But in this work I have included the more obscure points. For your Pious Authority should both know these and not be ignorant of the others, so that through both, perfection in knowledge may dwell like a light in your most pure understanding.42

"In my treatise to the holy Virgins [i. e. the Princesses Marina and Arcadia who had embraced the virgin estate] I made a very large provision of more obvious sayings which had nothing hard to understand; but in this I have made mention of the obscurer. For your Pious Authority ought both to know these and not to be ignorant of the other, in order that by means of both, perfection in knowledge, like a light, may dwell in your most pure understanding "42

Bishop Hefele believes there are signs that the two Princesses had, in contrast with the Emperor, supported Cyril and opposed Nestorius.43

Bishop Hefele thinks that there are indications that the two Princesses had, in contrast with the Emperor, spoken for Cyril and against Nestorius.43

Of the five sermons of Nestorius on the Incarnation that Marius Mercator translated into Latin, Saint Cyril quoted extensively from the second one. The fourth and fifth sermons in Mercator's collection belong to the end of A.D. 430. The fourth is dated December 6 (the eighth of the Ides of December), the Saturday after Nestorius received Saint Celestine's Letter through Saint Cyril's four bishops, along with Saint Cyril's letter containing the 12 Chapters. In this sermon, Nestorius repeats some of the teaching that Saint Cyril had quoted from an earlier sermon, specifically concerning God sending forth His Son. We have only fragments of that earlier sermon, but it was preached against Saint Cyril's letter to the monks. Nestorius refers to Saint Cyril as "the wrangler" and "the heretic," and he directly addresses Saint Cyril or Saint Proclus as "O heretic in clerical form."44454647

Of the five sermons of Nestorius on the Incarnation which Marius Mercator translated into Latin, S. Cyril has cited copiously from the second: the fourth and fifth of Mercator's collection belong to the close of A.D. 430; for the fourth is dated the eighth of the Ides of December (Dec. 6), the Saturday after Nestorius had received S. Cyril's four Bishops with S. Celestine's Letter and S. Cyril's with the 12 Chapters. In it Nestorius recapitulates some of the teaching which S. Cyril had quoted from an earlier sermon, i.e. on God sending forth His Son. Of that earlier sermon we have only fragments, but it was preached against S. Cyril's letter to the Monks. Nestorius speaks of S. Cyril as the " wrangler, " the heretic," and he apostrophises S. Cyril or S. Proclus, "O heretic in clerical form."44454647

The last sermon in that series from Mercator's collection was preached on Sunday, December 7.

The last of that series in Mercator's collection was preached on Sunday Dec. 7.

Count Irenaeus has also preserved it; the compiler of the Synodicon provides it in a different translation.48

Count Irenaeus has also preserved it; the compiler of the Synodicon gives it in another translation.48

One of the interests and activities of the bishops during their first days at Ephesus would have been getting to know some whom they had never met before. This time was probably the beginning of a lasting friendship between St. Cyril and Acacius, the metropolitan of Melitene, on the borders of Armenia toward Cappadocia. The long letter which he wrote to Valerian, Bishop of Iconium, suggests that St. Cyril had reached some degree of closeness with him. He also wrote to Donatus, Bishop of Nicopolis, on the west coast of Greece, and no doubt there were other friendships as well that came from the long stay at Ephesus. Some of St. Cyril's letters show how warm-hearted and sensitive he was, despite his strong will and unwavering purpose.

One of the interests and employments of the Bishops during their first days at Ephesus will have been the becoming acquainted with some whom they had never before seen. This time was probably the beginning of a lasting friendship between S. Cyril and Acacius the metropolitan of Melitene, on the borders of Armenia towards Cappadocia: the long letter which he wrote to Valerian Bishop of Iconium points at S. Cyril's having readied some degree of intimacy with him; he wrote too to Donatus, Bishop of Nicopolis, on the west of Greece, and no doubt there were other friendships too as the fruit of the long sojourn at Ephesus. Some of S. Cyril's letters shew how warm-hearted and sensitive he was, notwithstanding his mighty will and unswerving purpose.

But there were other sadder things belonging to that summer at Ephesus: sickness and death. The sickness was probably the fever so common now along all that unhealthy coast, and in many cases it turned into dysentery. We do not know which Bishops the Council lost, for our knowledge of those who were present comes from the lists of names at the opening of the first and sixth sessions and the signatures to those two sessions. But the fact is mentioned several times. S. Cyril in the first session of the Council says,

But there were other sadder things belonging to that summer at Ephesus, sickness and death, the sickness probably the fever so prevalent now along all that poisonous coast, and passing in many cases into dysentery. "We do not know what Bishops the Council lost; for our knowledge of those who composed it is derived from the lists of names at the opening of the first and sixth session and the signatures to those two sessions. But the fact is mentioned several times: S. Cyril in the first session of the Council says,

some have fallen into sickness and some are dead;

"some have fallen into sickness and some are dead;"

the Council, in its report to the Emperors, says,

the Council in its Relatio to the Emperors, says,

Some of the holy bishops, burdened by old age, could not endure staying in a foreign place; some were endangered by illness; some even met their death in the city of Ephesus.

"and some of the holy Bishops weighed down by age did not endure their stay in a strange place; some were imperilled in weakness; some have even undergone the close of their life in the Capital of the Ephesians;"

in its report to Saint Celestine,

in its account to S. Celestine,

although many bishops and clergy were both afflicted by sickness and burdened by expense, and some had even died.

"although many both Bishops and Clergy were both pressed by sickness and oppressed by expense and some had even deceased."

After waiting two weeks—during which time, if everyone had been present, the business could have been finished and the bishops sent home—St. Cyril wrote to John, Archbishop of Antioch. John, in his report to the Emperors, says,

After waiting a fortnight, during which time, if all had been there, the business might have been completed and the Bishops dismissed, S. Cyril wrote to John Archbishop of Antioch. John, in his Relatio to the Emperors, says,

Two days before they held their assembly [the Council], Cyril of Alexandria himself sent word to me in Antioch that the entire Synod was waiting for my arrival.49

"and Cyril himself of Alexandria sent to me of Antioch two days before the assembly made by them [the Council], that the whole Synod is awaiting my presence."49

Cyril also refers to the Letter. He says about John,

S. Cyril too alludes to the Letter. He says of John,

He was always friendly and dear to me, never once finding fault with my words. He wrote to me kindly and received letters from me.50

"he who was ever friendly and dear, who never at any time found fault with my words, who wrote kindly and received letters from me."50

While this letter was being delivered, some of the bishops from John's party arrived, bringing with them a letter to Saint Cyril in which John said he was only about four days away. The bishops from John's party were Alexander, Metropolitan of Apamea, and Alexander, Metropolitan of Hierapolis; and apparently, though we are not explicitly told this, Theodoret and Meletius, bishop of Neocaesarea, were with them as well. The Council, in its report to Saint Celestine, describes their arrival and says,

While this letter was on its way, some of the Bishops of John's party arrived, and with them a letter to S. Cyril in which John spoke of being only about four days off. The Bishops of John's party were Alexander Metropolitan of Apamea and Alexander Metropolitan of Hierapolis; and, to all appearance, though we are not told so, Theodoret and Meletius bishop of Neocaesarea. The Council, speaking of the arrival in their Eelatio to S. Celestine, says,

Nevertheless, after the sixteenth day, some of the bishops who were with him went ahead—two metropolitans, Alexander of Apamea and another Alexander of Hierapolis. When we complained about the late arrival of the most reverend Bishop John, they said repeatedly, "He told us to inform your Reverence that even if he should still delay, the synod was not to be postponed, but rather should do what was right."51

" Nevertheless after the sixteenth day there preceded him some of the Bishops who were with him, two Metropolitans, Alexander of Apamea and another Alexander of Hierapolis; and when we complained of the tardy arrival of the most reverend Bishop John, they said not once but over and over, 'he bid us tell your Reverence that, if he should even yet loiter, the synod was not to be put off, but rather to do what was meet.' "51

Saint Cyril says nearly the same thing in his Apology to the Emperor. Nevertheless, it is clear that John meant the words "if I yet loiter" to be understood in connection with his own letter to Saint Cyril stating that he was only five or six days away, and so he should be allowed that interval.52

S. Cyril says nearly the same in his Apology to the Emperor. Nevertheless it is plain that John meant the words, 'if I yet loiter,' to be taken in connection with his own letter to S. Cyril that he was but 5 or 6 days off, and so that he should have that interval allowed him.52

The Council, however, despite the distress of many of its members, decided to meet the next day. Nestorius' friends, led by Tranquillinus, Bishop of Antioch in Pisidia, drafted a petition to the Council asking them to wait for John of Antioch, "who is now at the very door, as he has indicated in his letters," and for some Western bishops. The document also speaks of the unlawfulness of allowing excommunicated or deposed bishops to be admitted into the Council and concludes with these threatening words,53

The Council however, in the distress of many of its members, determined to assemble the next day. Nestorius' friends headed by Tranquillinus, Bishop of Antioch in Pisidia, got up a memorial to the Council that they should wait for John of Antioch, "who is himself now at the door, as he has intimated by his Letters," and for some Western Bishops. The document further speaks of the unlawfulness of excommunicated or deposed Bishops being admitted into the Council and ends with the threatening words,53

And let your Reverence know that everything done in a hasty way by reckless men will be turned back against the recklessness of those who act so presumptuously, both by Christ the Lord and by the Divine Canons.

"And let your Reverence know, that all that shall be done in an abrupt way by daring men will be turned back against the daring of them who so presume, both by Christ the Lord and by the Divine Canons."

There follow 68 signatures, 16 from the Province of Antioch including the two newly-arrived Alexanders (an indication that they, while delivering John's message, did not consider it as preventing a four-day delay), and about 30 other friends of Nestorius. They also obtained about 23 other signatures. However, these 23 joined the Council the next day as a matter of course and signed the deposition of Nestorius. Among the signatures is that of Euprepius Bishop of Byza, who signs for himself and for his Nestorian Metropolitan Fritilas of Heraclea. But Euprepius did not remain with his Metropolitan. I do not see his name on the entry-roll of the Council at its opening session, but he does sign the deposition of Nestorius. His name is among the last signatures, as though he had arrived late.

There follow 68 signatures, 16 of the Province of Antioch including the two newly-arrived Alexanders (an indication that they, while they delivered John's message, did not consider it as precluding four days' delay) about 30 other friends of Nestorius. They procured also about 23 other signatures. These 23 however joined the Council next day as a matter of course, and signed the deposition of Nestorius. Among the signatures is that of Euprepius Bishop of Byza who signs for himself and for his Nestorian Metropolitan Fritilas of Heraclea. But Euprepius did not remain with his Metropolitan. I do not see his name on the entry-roll of the Council at its opening session; but he signs the deposition of Nestorius. His name is among the last signatures, as though he had come in late.

No deliberative body would accept such an insulting memorial as this one from Nestorius's friends, and naturally it does not appear in the Acts of the Council. Count Irenaeus, who was a friend of Nestorius and later became Bishop of Tyre, preserved it for us along with other interesting documents from his party.

No deliberative body whatever would accept such an insulting memorial as this of the friends of Nestorius, and of course it does not appear in the Acts of the Council. Count Irenaeus, the friend of Nestorius, afterwards Bishop of Tyre, has preserved it to us with other curious documents of his party.

Christian Lupus at the end of the 17th century copied most of a unique manuscript from the Monastery Library of Monte Cassino. The compiler is believed to be African; he lived at the same time as Facundus, Bishop of Hermaeum, and just as Facundus wrote very enthusiastically on behalf of Theodore of Mopsuestia, this compiler wrote very forcefully in defense of Theodoret. His main source was an interesting and extensive collection of documents and letters assembled by Count Irenaeus, Bishop of Tyre, after the Council of Ephesus; it contains letters that were exchanged between the different bishops in the Province of Antioch concerning Nestorius and St. Cyril, and their views about reconciliation with St. Cyril, and one can see how eagerly the leading bishops obtained a copy of any new letter that St. Cyril wrote. This collection alone preserves St. Cyril's important letter to Acacius, Bishop of Beroea, in response to the first demand of the Eastern bishops that the Nicene Creed was sufficient and that St. Cyril should destroy everything else he had written on doctrine. St. Cyril refers to this letter of his in his letter to his representatives at Constantinople, and a fragment of it is preserved by John, Archbishop of Caesarea in Palestine, in his Thesaurus of excerpts from St. Cyril in defense of the Council of Chalcedon, and two or three fragments of it by John's opponent, Severus of Antioch, both belonging to the first half of the sixth century.5455

Christian Lupus at the end of the 17th century transcribed the greater part of an unique manuscript in the Monastery Library of Monte Cassino. The compiler is thought to be an African; he was a contemporary of Facundus, Bishop of Hermaeum, and just as Facundus wrote very eagerly in behalf of Theodore of Mopsuestia, this compiler wrote very strongly in defence of Theodoret. His principal material was a curious and extensive collection of documents and Letters made by Count Irenaeus, Bishop of Tyre, after the Council of Ephesus; it contains Letters that passed between the different Bishops in the Province of Antioch about Nestorius and S. Cyril, and their views as to reconciliation with S. Cyril, and one sees how eagerly the principal Bishops got hold of a copy of any fresh letter which S. Cyril wrote. This collection alone preserves S. Cyril's great Letter to Acacius Bishop of Beroea, in reply to the first demand of the Eastern Bishops that the Nicene Creed was enough and that S. Cyril should burn all else which he had written on dogma. S. Cyril alludes to this Letter of his in his letter to his Proctors at Constantinople and a fragment of it is preserved by John Archbishop of Caesarea in Palestine in his Thesaurus of extracts of S. Cyril in Defence of the Council of Chalcedon, and two or three fragments of it by John's opponent, Severus of Antioch, both belonging to the earlier half of the sixth century.5455

Irenaeus was a contemporary of the Council of Ephesus, and all the letters and documents he collected seem to have been accepted without any question about whether they were genuine. We also have several documents from other sources. However, the Compiler, who used Count Irenaeus' collection, also added near the end of his compilation some documents from other manuscripts he had access to. One of these is completely worthless: a confession of faith claiming to be from Acacius, Bishop of Beroea, but clearly written at a later date.

Irenaeus being a contemporary of the Council of Ephesus, all the letters and documents collected by him seem to have been accepted without any doubt as to their genuineness. We also possess several from other sources. But the Compiler, who made use of Count Irenaeus' collection, has also inserted towards the end of his compilation, some documents from other MSS. to which he had access: one of these is absolutely worthless, viz. a confession of faith, purporting to be that of Acacius Bishop of Beroea, but evidently of later date.

Irenaeus' compilation is called a Tragedy. Renaudot, in his history, has pointed out that Ebed-jesu of Soba, who lived at the end of the 12th century, mentioned this work in his catalogue of church writers. Ebed-jesu says, "Irenaeus of Tyre compiled five Ecclesiastica on the persecution of Nestorius and everything that happened at that time." Two or three pages earlier, Ebed-jesu, in his catalogue of Nestorius' writings, also lists "A Book of a Tragedy."5657585960

Irenaeus' compilation is called a Tragedy. Renaudot, in his history, has pointed out that Ebed-jesu of Soba, who lived in the end of the 12th century, has mentioned the work in his catalogue of Ecclesiastical writers. Ebedjesu says, "Irenaeus of Tyre compiled five Ecclesiastica on the persecution of Nestorius and all that happened at that time." Two or three pages before, Ebedjesu, in his catalogue of Nestorius' writings, gives also, "A Book of a Tragedy."5657585960

The short treatise or confession of Saint Athanasius from which Saint Cyril quotes in his book against Theodore is placed by Montfaucon, Saint Athanasius' editor, among the doubtful works. Montfaucon's reasons for doing this are twofold: first, that the very famous expression "One Incarnate Nature of the Word" seems to contradict what Saint Athanasius says in other writings; second, that the treatise was challenged by Leontius of Byzantium at the beginning of the seventh century.6162

The little treatise or rather Confession of S. Athanasius from which S. Cyril cites in his Book against Theodore is put by Montfaucon, S. Athanasius' Editor, among the dubia. Montfaucon's grounds for doing so are twofold; 1, that the very famous expression, One Incarnate Nature of the Word, seems to contradict what S. Athanasius says in other writings; 2, that the treatise was objected to by Leontius of Byzantium, at the beginning of the seventh Century.6162

Regarding the first reason for doubt, only someone who has studied Athanasius extensively has any right to offer an opinion. The second reason amounts to nothing. Leontius says,

Of the first ground of doubt, no one but a student of S. Athanasius has any right to speak. The second dwindles to nothing. Leontius says,

The party of Severus, the great Monophysite Bishop of Antioch, presents another passage as belonging to Athanasius, from his treatise on the Incarnation. It goes like this: "And that the Same is Son of God after the Spirit, Son of man after the flesh; not that the one Son is two natures, the one to be worshipped, the other not to be worshipped, but One Nature Incarnate of God the Word." To this we respond: first, it does not oppose us at all, because we do not hold two natures, one to be worshipped and the other not. Rather, we hold One Nature Incarnate of God the Word. Second, it is not by Athanasius. When we ask them where this passage is found and they cannot easily show it, they produce in their confusion some small treatise, about two pages long, which contains this passage. But it is clear to everyone that all of Athanasius' writings are very lengthy.

"They [the party of Severus, the great Monophysite Bishop of Antioch] put forward another passage as S. Athanasius', from his treatise on the Incarnation. It is on this wise, 'And that the Same is Son of God after the Spirit, Son of man after the flesh; not that the one Son is two natures, the one to be worshipped, the other not to be worshipped, but One Nature Incarnate of God the Word.' To this we say, that first it in no wise opposes us, for neither do we hold two natures, one to be worshipped, the other not, but we hold One Nature Incarnate of God the Word. Next it is not S. Athanasius'. For when they are asked by us, where it is, and cannot easily shew it, in their perplexity they put forward some small treatise, about two leaves, in which this passage is: but it is evident to all, that all S. Athanasius' writings are very large.

But what can we say when they bring forward blessed Cyril, citing this passage against Theodore as though it were Saint Athanasius's? We say that it does indeed appear in blessed Cyril's writings against Theodore, yet this is an old mistake. For Dioscorus, who succeeded blessed Cyril and found his works, might well have added whatever he wanted. We might even suppose that blessed Cyril himself did not cite it against Theodore, and that this is so is clear from the following. For Theodoret, speaking in defense of Theodore and overturning all the passages that blessed Cyril cited against him from the holy Fathers, nowhere mentioned this one. To this they reply that Theodoret passed over it deliberately, for being unable to answer it since it was so obvious, he intentionally ignored it. To this we say that far from passing it by if it had been there, when Saint Cyril said elsewhere "One Nature Incarnate of God the Word," if Theodoret had known that this passage had been presented by blessed Cyril as quoted from Saint Athanasius, he would not have so ignorantly said, "Which of the Fathers said 'the One Nature Incarnate of God the Word'?" But they say again that he knew so certainly that it was said by Saint Athanasius that he said, "As the Fathers have said." To this we say that everyone is eager to show that the Fathers said what he says, if not word for word, then at least in meaning.63

"But what can we say, when they put forward blessed Cyril, citing this against Theodore, as being S. Athanasius?' To this we say, that it does indeed lie in the blessed Cyril's utterings against Theodore, yet it is an old error. For Dioscorus succeeding blessed Cyril, and finding his works, would perchance not have minded adding what he pleased: we might even conjecture that the blessed Cyril did not cite it against Theodore; and that it is so, is clear from this. For Theodoret speaking in behalf of Theodore, overturning all the passages which blessed Cyril cited against him from the holy Fathers, has no where mentioned this. To this they say that Theodoret passed it over craftily: for not able to answer it as patent, he of purpose passed it by. To this we say that so far from passing it by if it had been there, when S. Cyril said elsewhere, One Nature Incarnate of God the Word, if he had known that this passage had been put by blessed Cyril as cited from S. Athanasius, he would not so unlearnedly have said, 'Who of the Fathers said, the One Nature Incarnate of God the Word?' But they say again that he knew so certainly that it was said by S. Athanasius that he said, 'As the Fathers have said.' To this we say that every one is anxious to shew that the Fathers said what he says, if not word for word, yet in sense."63

It is clear that no serious objection could be based on a treatise or Confession of Faith being short, and that the fact that one's opponent passes over an objection would not prove that the objection, which is admittedly there, was not made. The rest of Leontius' objection rests on the suggestion that "perhaps Dioscorus added something."

It is clear that no serious objection could be founded on a treatise or Confession of Faith being short, and that the fact of one's opponent passing over an objection would be no proof that the objection, which is confessedly there, was not made. The remainder of Leontius' objection lies in the, " perhaps Dioscorus added something."

This confession was very well known to Saint Cyril; for besides citing it here, he cites (as Montfaucon observes) almost the whole of it at the beginning of his Treatise on the True Faith to the Princesses Arcadia and Marina, to show that Saint Athanasius used the term Mother of God. Saint Cyril also cited two portions of it to show that in his eighth chapter, where he says that Emmanuel must be worshipped with one worship, he had only said what Saint Athanasius had also said. In all three citations the words "One Physis Incarnate of the Word" occur, and in the case of Saint Cyril's defense of his eighth chapter, the whole passage exists in the Latin translation (believed to be by Saint Cyril's contemporary, Marius Mercator), which leaves no room for possible monophysite insertion—besides the fact that the citation forms an integral part of Saint Cyril's defense of his chapter.64

This confession was very well known by S. Cyril; for besides citing it here, he cites (as Montfaucon observes) almost the whole of it in the beginning of his Treatise de recta Fide to the Princesses Arcadia and Marina, to shew that S. Athanasius used the term, Mother of God; S. Cyril also cited two pieces of it, to shew that in his eighth chapter in which he says, that 'Emmanuel must be worshipped with one worship, he had but said what S. Athanasius too had said. In all three citations occur the words, One Nature Incarnate of the Word, and in the case of S. Cyril's defence of his eighth chapter, the whole passage is extant in the latin translation (believed to be by S. Cyril's contemporary, Marius Mercator) which leaves no room for possible monophysite insertion: besides that the citation forms an integral part of S. Cyril's Defence of his chapter.64

It is therefore proven that these words were quoted as belonging to Saint Athanasius by Saint Cyril, the same Saint Cyril whose own thinking had been shaped and instructed by the writings of Saint Athanasius, and who in A.D. 431 brought out from the archives, probably of his own Church of Saint Mark, an authentic copy of Saint Athanasius' Letter to Epictetus.

It is then proved that the words were cited as S. Athanasius' by S. Cyril, the same S. Cyril who had had his own mind moulded and taught by the writings of S. Athanasius, and who in A. D. 431, produced from the archives, probably of his own Church of S. Mark, an authentic copy of S. Athanasius' Letter to Epictetus.

If this Confession is not genuine, it simply shows that, being only human, we make mistakes even in areas we know best.

If this Confession is not genuine, it is but an illustration of how, being but men, we make mistakes in what we know best.

Montfaucon concludes, "I would not dare to say whether the excerpts were inserted into Cyril's writings after his death, or whether someone created a short work like this before Cyril's time and attributed it to Athanasius."

Montfaucon sums up, "I would not venture to say whether the extracts were added in the writings of Cyril after his decease or whether before Cyril a little book of this sort was made up and ascribed to Athanasius."

My son had printed these fragments of a preface to the volume before he was so suddenly called away. They seemed to me clearly fragments of a larger whole. But there were no indications of how they were to be completed. I have thought it might be useful to compile as a supplement some accounts of the development of the heresy of Nestorius and of the character of St. Cyril as they illuminate his controversy against him. E. B. P.

[My son had had these fragments of a preface to the volume printed, before he was so suddenly called away. They seemed to me manifestly fragments of a larger whole. But there were no indications, how they were to be filled up. I have thought it might be useful to put together as a supplement, some notices of the course of the heresy of Nestorius, and of the character of S. Cyril as illustrating his controversy against him. E. B. P.]

The specific form of the disease to which the name of Nestorius became attached was hereditary in the great Province of Antioch. This is all the sadder because it came to him lurking in the writings of men of even great reputation, commentators on large parts of Holy Scripture, who seem to have inherited it unawares: Diodore of Tarsus and Theodore of Mopsuestia. Both had died in the peace of the Church. Diodore, who had the very highest reputation, had shared in the persecution of Saint Meletius by the Arians, had been one of the Bishops of the Second General Council, and had helped to form the mind of Saint Chrysostom. Theodore, in whom the heresy appears more abundantly yet incidentally, had during the thirty-eight years of his episcopate written against other heretics—Arians, Eunomians, Origen, Apollinarius—and was intimate with Saint Chrysostom and with Saint Gregory of Nazianzus. The way of truth, as well as the way of life, is narrow.65

THE special form of the disease, to which the name of Nestorius became attached, was hereditary in the great Province of Antioch. It is the sadder, because it came to him, lurking in the writings of men of even great name, commentators on large parts of Holy Scripture, who seem to have inherited it unawares; Diodore of Tarsus, and Theodore of Mopsuestia. Both had fallen asleep in the peace of the Church. Diodore, of the very highest reputation, had shared in the persecution of S. Meletius by the Arians, had been one of the Bishops of the Second General Council, and had helped to form the mind of S. Chrysostom. Theodore, in whom the heresy appears more copiously yet incidentally, had, during the thirty-eight years of his Episcopate, written against other heretics, Arians, Eunomians, Origen, Apollinarius, and was intimate with S. Chrysostom and with S. Gregory of Nazianzus. The way of truth as well as the way of life is narrow.65

It appears to have been a tradition of heresy standing over against the tradition of faith. There is no doubt about the last two stages of this heretical tradition. This is clear from the fragments of their writings that still survive. Saint Cyril speaks fully about Diodore of Tarsus, saying that Nestorius's mind was darkened by his books. Leontius says that Diodorus had been for Theodore the author, leader, and father of those evils and impieties. In the ninth century, the Nestorians counted Diodorus, Theodore, and Nestorius as their three fathers. A Nestorian Patriarch-elect promised that he would hold to the true Nestorian faith, the synods of East and West, and the three fathers: Diodorus, Theodore, and Nestorius. An eminent Syrian writer of the century after Saint Cyril, Simeon Bishop of Beth-arsham, who held the title of honor "the Persian Preacher or Philosopher," says that Paul of Samosata derived his heresy through Artemon from Ebion, that Diodore derived his from Paul, and Theodore from Diodore and Paul. Theodore held the true faith of the Holy Trinity, which Paul did not, but the heresy concerning the Incarnation was much alike in both.66676869

It appears to have been a tradition of heresy over against the tradition of faith. Of the last two stages of the heretical tradition there is no doubt. Of both it is clear from the fragments of their writings still extant. S. Cyril speaks fully as to Diodore of Tarsus, 'by whose books,' he says, 'the mind of Nestorius was darkened.' Leontius says, that 'Diodorus had been to Theodorus the author and leader and father of those evils and impieties.' In the 9th century the Nestorians counted Diodorus, Theodorus and Nestorius their 'three fathers.' A Nestorian Patriarch elect promised, ' that he would adhere to the true [Nestorian] faith, and the Synods of East and West, and the three fathers, Diodorus, Theodorus, Nestorius.' An eminent Syrian writer in the century after S. Cyril, Simeon Bishop of Beth-arsham (who had the title of honour of, 'the Persian Preacher or Philosopher ') says, that Paul of Samosata derived his heresy through Artemon from Ebion; that Diodore derived his from Paul, and Theodore from Diodore and Paul. Theodore held the true faith of the Holy Trinity, which Paul did not; but the heresy on the Incarnation was in much alike.66676869

A parallel was drawn between the teaching of Nestorius and that of Paul of Samosata on the doctrine of the Incarnation in a public adjuration issued by the clergy of Constantinople at the beginning of the Nestorian heresy and published in a church. The parallel went as follows:70

In an Adjuration publicly put forth by the Clergy of Constantinople at the beginning of the Nestorian heresy and published in a Church, a parellel was drawn between the teaching of Nestorius and that of Paul of Samosata on the doctrine of the Incarnation. The parallel ran;70

Paul said, "Mary did not bear the Word." Nestorius, in agreement, said, "Mary, my good man, did not bear the Godhead." [The Anathema approved by Nestorius denied that "Mary bore God," not "the Godhead."] Paul said, "For he did not exist before all ages." Nestorius said, "And he assigns a temporal Mother to the Godhead, the Creator of times." Paul said, "Mary received the Word and is not older than the Word." Nestorius said, "How then did Mary bear Him who is older than herself?" Paul said, "Mary bore a man like us." Nestorius said, "He who was born of the Virgin is man." Paul said, "but a man superior in all things, since He is from the Holy Spirit, and from the promises, and from the Scripture is the grace upon Him." Nestorius said, "It says, 'I saw the Spirit descending like a dove upon Him and abiding on Him,' which granted Him the Ascension. 'Commanding, it says, the Apostles whom He had chosen, He was taken up through the Holy Spirit.' This then was what conferred on Christ such glory." Paul said, "that neither should He who is of David, having been anointed, be alien from Wisdom, nor should Wisdom dwell in any other in the same way, for it was in the Prophets and yet more in Moses and in many Saints, and yet more in Christ as in the Temple of God." And elsewhere he says, "the Word is one thing and Jesus Christ is another." Nestorius said, "That it was not possible that He who was born before all ages should be born again, and that according to the Godhead." Look, the transgressor is revealed, saying that He who was begotten of the Father was not born of Mary. Look, he agrees with the heretic Paul of Samosata who says that "the Word is one thing and Jesus Christ is another" and is not one, as the right Faith teaches.

Paul said, 'Mary did not hear the Word;' Nestorius, in harmony, said, 'Mary, my good man, did not bear the Godhead;' [the Anathema approved by Nestorius denied that 'Mary bare God' not 'the Godhead.'] Paul, 'For he was not before ages.' Nestorius,—- 'And he assigns a temporal Mother to the Godhead, the Creator of times.' Paul, 'Mary received the Word and is not older than the Word.' 'Nestorius, 'How then did Mary bear Him Who is older than herself?' Paul, 'Mary bore a man like unto us.' Nestorius, 'He Who was born of the Virgin is man.' Paul,—- 'but a man in all things superior, since He is from the Holy Ghost, and from the promises, and from the Scripture is the grace upon Him.' Nestorius said, 'It saith, "I saw the Spirit descending like a dove upon Him and abiding on Him," which bestowed upon Him the Ascension. "Commanding, it saith, the Apostles whom He had chosen He was taken up through the Holy Ghost." This then it was, which conferred on Christ such glory.' Paul said, 'that neither He Who is of David having been anointed be alien from Wisdom, nor that Wisdom should dwell in any other in like way, for it was in the Prophets and yet more in Moses and in many Saints, and yet more in Christ as in the Temple of God.' And elsewhere he says, that 'other is Jesus Christ and other the Word.' Nestorius said, 'That it was not possible that He Who was born before all ages should anew be born, and that, according to the Godhead.' See, the transgressor is made manifest, saying, that He Who was begotten of the Father was not born of Mary. See, he agrees with the heretic Paul of Samosata who says that 'Other is the Word and other Jesus Christ' and is not one, as the right Faith teaches.

The heresy stumbled at humanity's usual stumbling-block: God's love in the Incarnation, "when Thou tookest upon Thee to deliver man, Thou didst not abhor the Virgin's womb." Theodore held it was madness to say that God was born of a Virgin. He held that the man who was born in this way was united to God only by grace, and that he was a son only by adoption.717273

The heresy stumbled at man's wonted stumbling-block, the love of God in the Incarnation, "when Thou tookest upon Thee to deliver man, Thou didst not abhor the Virgin's womb." Theodore held it to be madness to say that God was born of a Virgin; he held that the man who was so born was united to God only by grace, that he was a son only by adoption.717273

This false doctrine and others likely went unnoticed because they were scattered throughout controversial writings against the Apollinarians or in scriptural commentaries. They were brought to light by the vanity of Nestorius.

This and other false doctrines had probably escaped notice, because they were scattered up and down in controversial writings against the Apollinarians, or in interpretations of Holy Scripture. They were brought out by the vanity of Nestorius.

Born of at least humble origins, he possessed the dangerous gift of great fluency in impromptu preaching and "a very beautiful and powerful voice." He was also considered an ascetic. Saint Cyril said to the Emperor,74

Born of low parentage at least, he had the perilous gift of great fluency of extempore preaching and 'a very beautiful and powerful voice.' He was moreover accounted an ascetic. S. Cyril said to the Emperor,74

He was chosen as someone practiced in the teachings of the Gospels and Apostles, trained in godliness, and holding the right faith, entirely without blame. Your Pious Majesty desired to have such a man, as did all who were set over the holy Churches, and I myself as well. And indeed when the letters of the most pious Bishops concerning his consecration were sent around by those who promoted him to this position, I wrote back without delay, rejoicing, praising, and praying that by the decree from above every choicest good should come to our brother and fellow-minister.75

' he was chosen as one practised in the doctrines of the Gospels and the Apostles, trained in godliness, and holding the right faith, altogether blamelessly. Your Pious Majesty longed to have such a man, and all who were set over the holy Churches, and I myself also. And indeed when the letters of the most pious Bishops about his consecration were sent round by those who advanced him thereto, I wrote hack without delay, rejoicing, praising, praying that by the decree from above all choicest good should come to our brother and fellow-minister.'75

Saint Celestine wrote to Nestorius himself that he had been concerned about the bishops who were successively appointed to his see.

S. Celestine wrote to Nestorius himself, that he had been anxious as to the Bishops successively appointed to his see,

because good things tend not to last, and what joy he had experienced in the successor of the blessed John Chrysostom, Atticus of blessed memory, the teacher of the Catholic faith; then in the holy Sisinnius, who was so soon to leave us, for his simple piety and pious simplicity; and when he was removed, the report of the messenger who came gladdened our soul; and this was immediately confirmed by the account of our colleagues, who were present at your consecration, who gave you such testimony as was fitting for one who had been elected from elsewhere [Antioch]. For you had lived before with such high reputation that another city envied you to your own people… Evil (as far as we can see) has followed upon your good beginnings; beginnings so good, so well reported to us, that in our response to the account of the brethren, we showed how we shared in the joy.76

' because good is apt not to be lasting, and what joy he had had in the successor of the blessed John [Chrysostom], Atticus of blessed memory, the teacher of the Catholic faith; then in the holy Sisinnius, who was so soon to leave us, for his simple piety and pious simplicity; and when he was removed, the relation of the messenger who came rejoiced our soul; and this was straightway confirmed by the relation of our colleagues, who were present at thy consecration, who bare thee such testimony as was meet to one who had been elected from elsewhere [Antioch]. For thou hadst lived before with so high estimation, that another city envied thee to thy own people… Evil (as far as we see) has followed on thy good beginnings; beginnings, so good, so well reported of to us, that, in our answer to the relation of the brethren, we shewed how we were partakers of the joy.'76

Saint Celestine dwells even fondly on this recollection, which stood in such sad contrast to the letter he had to answer.

S. Celestine lingers even fondly over the reminiscence, which was such a sad contrast to the letter which he had to answer.

Who could easily believe, asks Vincent of Lérins, that he was in error, when they saw he had been chosen by such judgment of the Empire and held in such high regard by the Bishops? He was so loved by the holy, so favored by the people, and daily taught the words of God while refuting the poisonous errors of Jews and Greeks. Who could he not persuade that he taught rightly, preached rightly, and believed rightly, when he persecuted the blasphemies of all other heresies in order to make room for his own heresy? But to pass over Nestorius, who had more admirers than usefulness, more fame than experience, and whom human favor had made great in the eyes of the people for a time rather than Divine grace—77

'Who could readily believe,' asks Vincentius of Lerins, 'that he was in error, whom he saw to have been chosen by such judgement of the Empire, the object of such estimation of the Bishops? who was so loved by the holy, in such favour with the people, who daily discoursed on the words of God, and confuted the poisonous errors of Jews and Grentiles. Whom could he not persuade that he taught aright, preached aright, held aright, who in order to make way for his own heresy persecuted the blasphemies of all [other] heresies? But to pass by Nestorius who had ever more admiration than usefulness, more fame than experience, whom human favour had made for a season great in the eyes of the people rather than Divine grace—-'77

The outward change was sudden, Vincentius also says,

The outward change was sudden, Vincentius too says,

What a temptation that was recently, when this unhappy Nestorius suddenly changed from a sheep into a wolf and began to attack Christ's flock, while those who were being attacked still largely believed him to be a sheep, and so fell all the more easily into his jaws!77

' What a temptation was that lately, when this unhappy Nestorius, suddenly changed from a sheep to a wolf, began to rend the flock of Christ, when they too who were torn, in great part still believed him to be a sheep, and so the more easily fell into his jaws!'77

Theodoret, who had defended him for so many years, spoke more harshly of him than any other writer after he had once condemned him at Chalcedon. Theodoret had an affectionate nature. The great curse of his life was that he would believe any evil of St. Cyril rather than suspect his former friend Nestorius to be in the wrong. Under this prejudice, he believed St. Cyril to be an Apollinarian, which he was not, rather than suspect Nestorius to be the heretic, which he was. When St. Leo took up his cause against the worthless successor of St. Cyril, Dioscorus, and showed at once how the two opposite heresies of Eutyches and Nestorius were equally inconsistent with Catholic truth, his eyes may have been opened, and he may have felt toward Nestorius as the cause of an almost lifelong error from which he was rescued by his own deposition and disgrace. Nestorius too had, as far as was known, died unrepentant in a heresy which denied the Incarnation. His later account of Nestorius is,7778

Theodoret, who had for so many years defended him, after he had once condemned him at Chalcedon, spoke more severely of him than any other writer. Theodoret was of an affectionate disposition. The great bane of his life was, that he would believe any evil of S. Cyril, rather than suspect his former friend Nestorius to be in the wrong. Under this prejudice, he believed S. Cyril to be an Apollinarian which he was not, rather than suspect Nestorius to be the heretic which he was. When then S. Leo espoused his cause against the worthless successor of S. Cyril, Dioscorus, and shewed at once how the two opposite heresies of Eutyches and Nestorius were equally inconsistent with Catholic truth, his eyes may have been opened, and he may have felt towards Nestorius as the occasion to him of an almost lifelong error, from which he was rescued by his own deposition and disgrace. Nestorius too had, as far as was known, died unrepentant in an heresy which denied the Incarnation. His later account of Nestorius is,7778

From the start, Nestorius showed what he would be throughout his life: he cultivated a merely popular eloquence that drew empty applause and attracted the unstable crowd. He went about dressed in mourning clothes, walking with a heavy step, avoiding public gatherings, and trying to appear ascetic through his pale appearance. At home he was mostly occupied with books and lived quietly by himself. He continued into old age enticing many people through such habits and pretenses, seeking to seem to be a Christian rather than actually being one, and preferring his own glory to the glory of Christ.79

' From the first, Nestorius shewed what he was going to be all his life through: that he cultivated a mere popular eloquence, eliciting empty applause and attracting to himself the unstable multitude; that he went about, clad in a mourning garment, walking heavily, avoiding public throngs, seeking by the pallor of his looks to appear ascetic, at home mostly given to books and living quietly by himself. He went on to advanced age enticing the many by such habits and counterfeits, seeking to seem to be a Christian rather than to be one, and preferring his own glory to the glory of Christ.'79

The progression of his heresy is described in summary by Theodoret.

The course of his heresy Theodoret describes in summary.

His innovation began with the claim that we must not confess the Holy Virgin who bore the Word of God, having taken flesh from her, to be Theotokos, but only Christotokos, whereas the heralds of the orthodox faith long ago taught us to call her Theotokos and believe her to be the Mother of the Lord.79

' The first step of his innovation was that we must not confess the Holy Virgin who bare the Word of God having taken flesh of her, to be Theotocos, but Christotocos only, whereas the heralds of the orthodox faith long ago (tw~n pa&lai kai\ pro&palai) taught to call her Theotocos, and believe her the Mother of the Lord.'79

Then he mentions the defense offered by Nestorius.

Then he mentions the plea of Nestorius,

that the name Christ signifies the two natures (physis), the Godhead and Manhood of the Only-Begotten, but that the name God refers absolutely to the simple and incorporeal essence (ousia) of God the Word, and that the name man refers to human nature (physis) alone. Therefore it is necessary to confess that the Virgin is Christotokos and not Theotokos, lest we unwittingly say that God the Word received the beginning of His existence from the holy Virgin, and so be forced logically to confess that the Mother was older than the One who was born from her.

'that the name Christ signifies the two Natures, the Godhead and Manhood of the Only-Begotten, but that of God absolutely the simple and incorporeal essence of God the Word; and that of man the human nature alone; therefore it is necessary to confess the Virgin to be Christotocos and not Theotocos, lest unawares we say that God the Word took the beginning of His Being from the holy Virgin, and so should be obliged consistently to confess that the Mother was older than He Who was born of her.'

Finally, he mentions the preaching of Nestorius, that in the Church of the orthodox he shouted out many such words as "Mary, my good man, did not bear God; she bore a man who was the instrument of God," and again among other follies, "The pagan is blameless when he gives a mother to the gods."

Lastly he mentions the preaching of Nestorius, that in the Church of the orthodox he shouted out many such words as 'Mary, my good man, did not bear God; she bore a man the instrument of God;' 'and again among other follies,' 'The Gentile is blameless, when he gives a mother to the gods.'

Here is his teaching at Constantinople in outline. He concentrated his efforts on replacing Theotocos with Christotocos, and instead of "God made Man," he promoted a human Christ connected with God, corrupting through frivolous statements the minds he was able to influence.

Such is the outline of his teaching at Constantinople. His efforts were concentrated on the substitution of Christotocos for Theotocos; for 'God made Man,' a human Christ connected with God, corrupting by flippant sayings the minds which he could influence.

He gained favor with Theodosius, who relied on those around him. His elevation to the Patriarchate was a marked distinction, since it involved a call from a different Patriarchate at the nomination of Emperor Theodosius, and the people received him with joy. He seemed to himself called to great things. According to Socrates, he had not yet, in the words of the proverb, tasted the waters of the city when, in an inaugural speech before the Emperor and a large crowd of people, he addressed the Emperor: "Give me, O king, the land cleared of heretics, and I in turn will give you heaven. Destroy the heretics with me, and I will destroy the Persians with you." He must have meant, of course, that he could promise victory over the Persians in the name of God. People noticed, we are told, the vanity, passion, and vainglory of the speech. At the very least, it was a summons of civil power against those he himself knew nothing about and for whose conversion his predecessors had waited patiently, and it promised victory over a warlike people based not on self-humiliation before God but on the extermination of men who did not share his errors. An Arian congregation, seeing their church destroyed, in desperation set it on fire and threw themselves into the flames. This earned Nestorius, among all the faithful as well as heretics, the title of "the Incendiary." The persecution caused much bloodshed at Miletus and Sardis. The Emperor had to restrain his violence against the Novatians. The Macedonians and the Quartodecimans in Asia, Lydia, and Caria were also persecuted. He had conferred with Theodore of Mopsuestia on his way from Antioch to his See, so that it was even thought he had absorbed his heresy at that time. Those he brought with him were from the same school.8080818283

He gained favour with Theodosius who leaned on those around him. His elevation to the Patriarchate was a marked distinction, as being a call from a different Patriarchate, at the nomination of the Emperor Theodosius, and the people received him with joy. He seemed to himself called to great things. 'He had not,' Socrates says, 'tasted, according to the proverb, the waters of the city,' when in an inaugural oration before the Emperor and a large concourse of people, he apostrophised the Emperor, "Give me, O king, the land clear from heretics and I in turn will give thee heaven. Destroy the heretics with me, and I will destroy the Persians with thee." He must have meant, of course, that he could promise victory over the Persians in the name of God. Men noticed, we are told, the vanity and passionateness and vainglory of the speech. It was, at the least, a calling in of the civil sword against those, of whom he himself knew nothing, and for whose conversion his predecessors had waited patiently, and promising victory over a warlike people, not upon self-humiliation before God, but upon the extirpation of men who had not the same errors with himself. An Arian congregation, seeing their church destroyed, in desperation fired it and threw themselves into the flames. This gained to Nestorius, with all the faithful as well as heretics, the title of 'the Incendiary.' The persecution occasioned much bloodshed at Miletus and Sardis. The Emperor had to repress his violence against the Novatians. The Macedonians and the Quartodecimans in Asia, Lydia, Caria, were also persecuted. He had conferred with Theodore of Mopsuestia in his way from Antioch to his See; so that it was even thought that he had imbibed his heresy then. Those whom he brought with him were of the same school.8080818283

He began cautiously at first. He used ambiguous language, but all of it was directed against the one crucial term Theotocos. Unless the blessed Virgin bore God—that is, Him Who was at once both God and Man—our Lord plainly would not have been God. And with that, the doctrine of the Atonement would have perished too, which Nestorius also did not believe. For a brother cannot redeem a man; he cannot give to God a ransom for him. Too dear is the redemption of their souls, and it ceases forever.84

He began at first warily. He used ambiguous language, but all directed against the one crucial term Theotocos. Unless the blessed Virgin 'bare God,' i. e. Him Who was at once both God and Man, our Lord plainly would not have been God. And therewith would have perished the doctrine of the Atonement too, which also Nestorius did not believe. For a "brother cannot redeem a man; he cannot give to God a ransom for him. Too dear is the redemption of their souls, and it ceaseth for ever."84

He used whatever terms he could to make up for the inadequacy of his conception. He could think of our Lord as a man, an instrument of Deity, a temple created of the Virgin for God the Word to inhabit, and having a close or continual or the highest connection with God. But still, the connection was different in degree, not in kind, from that with any Saint.85

He used what terms he could, to eke out the poverty of his conception. He could think of our Lord as a man, an instrument of Deity;' ' a temple created of the Virgin for God the Word to inhabit,' and haying a close or continual or the highest connection with God; but still the 'connection' was different in degree, not in kind, from that with any Saint.85

The ancient title of the Mother of the Lord, which even Theodoret recognized as "the Apostolical tradition" after his conflict with Cyril ended, ruled out this way of making our Lord merely human. And so Nestorius (a serious historian says) kept teaching about this in the Church and tried in every way to get rid of the term Theotocos, fearing it like people fear hobgoblins. He did this, Socrates adds, "out of great ignorance."868788

The hereditary title of the Mother of the Lord, which even Theodoret, when his strife with S. Cyril was over, recognised as ' the Apostolical tradition,' excluded this humanising of our Lord. And so Nestorius (a grave historian says) continuously teaching hereon in the Church, endeavoured in all ways to expel the term Theotocos, and dreaded the term as they do hobgoblins. This he did, Socrates adds, 'out of great ignorance.'868788

Being naturally a fluent speaker, he was thought to be well-educated. But in truth, he was poorly trained and scorned to study the books of the ancient interpreters. For being puffed up by his fluency of speech, he did not pay careful attention to the ancients, but thought himself superior to everyone.

'Being by nature fluent of speech, he was thought to have been educated; but in truth, he was ill-trained, and disdained to learn the books of the ancient interpreters. For being puffed up for his fluency of speech, he did not attend accurately to the ancients, but thought himself superior to all.'

Yet the term Theotokos had been in such familiar use by every school for nearly two centuries that the aversion of Nestorius to it can hardly have been simple ignorance. It was probably the instinctive aversion of heresy to the term which condemns it. Socrates himself mentions that it was used by Origen and Eusebius: it was used alike by Alexander, the predecessor of Saint Athanasius, whose Council first condemned Arius; by Saint Athanasius himself; by the Arian Eusebius; and by Saint Cyril of Jerusalem, who did not use the word Homoousios. The Emperor Julian the Apostate said, in controversy with the Christians, 'Did Isaiah say that a Virgin should bear God? But you do not cease calling Mary Theotokos,' confirming that the word was in the mouths of all Christians. A little later it was used by the two Saint Gregories. It was also used by the great predecessor of Nestorius in the see of Constantinople, Saint Chrysostom, as well as by Ammon, Bishop of Adrianople in Egypt, and by Antiochus, Bishop of Ptolemais in Phoenicia. The corresponding title, Mater Dei, was used in the Latin Church by Saint Ambrose, Cassian, and Vincent of Lérins.89909192939495969798

Yet the term Theotocos had been in such familiar use by every school for nearly two centuries, that the aversion of Nestorius to it can hardly have been simple ignorance. It was probably the instinctive aversion of heresy to the term which condemns it. Socrates himself mentions that it was used by Origen and Eusebius: it was used alike by Alexander, the predecessor of S. Athanasius, whose Council first condemned Arius; by S. Athanasius himself; by the Arian Eusebius; and by S. Cyril of Jerusalem, who did not use the word Homoousion. The Apostate Emperor Julian said, in controversy with the Christians, ' Did Isaiah say that a Virgin should bear God? but ye do not cease calling Mary Theotocos,' attesting that the word was in the mouths of all Christians. A little later it was used by the two S. Gregories. It was used also by the great predecessor of Nestorius in the see of Constantinople, S. Chrysostom, as also by Ammon Bishop of Adrianople in Egypt, and by Antiochus Bishop of Ptolemais in Phoenicia. The corresponding title, Mater Dei, was used in the Latin Church by S. Ambrose, Cassian, and Vincent of Lerins.89909192939495969798

John of Antioch, at a later time, urged Nestorius to accept the term in order to prevent the coming schism, saying to him,

John of Antioch, at a later period, entreating Nestorius to accept the term, in order to prevent the impending schism, said to him,

This title has not been rejected by any of the church's teachers. Many distinguished figures have used it, and those who have not used it have never accused those who did use it of being in error.

'This name no one of the ecclesiastical teachers has declined. For those who have used it have been many and eminent, and those who have not used it have never imputed any error to those who used it.'

John tried to make it easier for him to accept the word.

John endeavoured to smoothe to him the adoption of the word.

The ten days that Celestine allowed are very short, but the matter could be settled in a single day, or perhaps even in just a few hours. For it is easy to use a suitable word in the divine plan of our Sovereign Ruler Christ for us—a word that has been used by many of the fathers and is true regarding the saving Birth from the Virgin. Your holiness should not refuse this, nor consider it a reason for concern that one should not act contrary to established practice. For if your mind agrees with that of the fathers and teachers of the Church (and this, my lord, I have heard from many mutual friends), what difficulty is there in expressing a pious thought with the appropriate word?99

' The ten days, which Celestine allowed, are very short, but it might be made matter of a single day, perhaps only of a few hours. For to use a convenient word in the dispensation of our Sovereign Ruler Christ for us, which has been used by many of the fathers, and is true as to the saving Birth of the Virgin, is easy; which thy holiness ought not to decline, nor take that into account, that one ought not to do things contrary. For if thy mind is the same as that of the fathers and teachers of the Church (for this, my lord, I have heard from many common friends), what grief has it, to utter a pious thought in a corresponding word?'99

Nestorius seems to have thought it was his role to convert the Church to his false belief. He says,

Nestorius seems to have thought it to have been his office to convert the Church to his misbelief. He says,

I see in our people much reverence and the most fervent piety, but they are blind when it comes to the dogma of the knowledge of God. However, this is not the people's fault, but rather (how can I say this politely?) the teachers did not have the opportunity to present to you any of the more accurate teaching.100

' I see in our people much reverence and most fervent piety, but that they are blinded as to the dogma of the knowledge of God. But this is not the fault of the people, but (how shall I say it courteously?) that the teachers had not opportunity to set before you aught of the more accurate teaching.'100

This was strong language—that the people of Constantinople were in error regarding the faith because of the fault of its former bishops. But by this he also acknowledged that his faith was different from theirs. Cassian then challenges him: "Are you, then, the one who corrects former bishops, the one who condemns former priests? Are you more excellent than Gregory, more approved than Nectarius, surpassing John?"101

This was strong language, that the people of Constantinople were in error as to the faith through the fault of its former Bishops; but he also owned thereby, that his faith was different from theirs. 'Art thou then,' Cassian apostrophises him, 'the amender of former Bishops, the condemner of former Priests? art thou more excellent than Gregory, more approved than Nectarius, surpassing John?'101

Nestorius appears to have taken on the role of mediator between opposing factions. In his third letter to Saint Celestine, he says,

Nestorius seems to have chosen for himself the office of arbiter between ideal parties. In his third Epistle to S. Celestine he says,

Your Holiness knows that if two sects oppose each other, and one uses only the word Theotocos while the other uses only Anthropotocos, and each sect tries to force the other to accept its own confession—so that if it does not succeed, there is danger that it will separate from the Church—then it will be necessary for someone appointed to examine this matter, having concern for each sect, to remedy the danger facing both parties by using a word provided by the Evangelist that signifies both physis. For that word, Christotocos, moderates the claim of both sides, because it both removes the blasphemy of the Samosatene which speaks of Christ, the Lord of all, as if He were merely a man, and also drives away the wickedness of Arius and Apollinarius.102

' It is known to your Blessedness, that if two sects stand over against one another, and one of them only uses the word Theotocos, and the other only Anthropotocos, and each sect draws the other to its own confession, so that, if it do not obtain this, there is peril lest it fall from the Church, it will be necessary, that one deputed to the consideration of this matter, having care for each sect, should remedy the peril of either party, by a word delivered by the Evangelist which signifies both natures. For that word, Christotocos, tempers the assertion of both, because it both removes the blasphemy of the Samosatene which is spoken of Christ, the Lord of all, as if He were a pure man, and also puts to flight the malice of Arius and Apollinarius.'102

It is strange that he did not see (if indeed he failed to see what everyone else saw), that Christotocos, as opposed to Theotocos, could only mean 'mother of the Messiah,' that is, mother of Him who would be the Messiah. Vincent of Lérins uses the simple illustration,

It is strange that he did not see (if indeed he did not see what every one else saw), that Christotocos, as opposed to Theotocos, could only mean 'mother of the Messiah,' i. e. mother of Him who should be the Messiah. Vincent of Lerins uses the homely illustration,

just as we speak of the mother of a presbyter or a bishop, not meaning that she gave birth to someone who was already a presbyter or bishop, but to a man who later became a presbyter or bishop.103

' as we speak of the mother of a Presbyter or a Bishop, not that she bare one who was already a Presbyter or a Bishop, but a man who was afterwards made a Presbyter or Bishop.'103

Saint John Damascene says that we must understand that the Virgin is the Mother of God, not as if the divinity of the Word took its beginning from her (since the Word was in the beginning, and the Word was God, and the Word was with God, being perfect from eternity), but because from her the Word was born according to the flesh. For the Word became flesh, and dwelt among us. The flesh was united to the Word hypostatically from the very moment of conception, and therefore she is called Mother of God, because God was born from her according to the flesh. For it is not accurate to say that a mere man was born from her, and that afterward God came to dwell in him, but rather that God was united to the flesh in her womb itself, and was therefore born according to the flesh, condescending to grant birth to himself.

S. John Damascene says,

We do not call the holy Virgin Christotocos because Nestorius invented it to deny the term Theotocos.104

' We do not call the holy Virgin Christotocos, because Nestorius invented it to deny the word Theotocos.'104

The name 'Anthropotocos' must have been something he invented himself, in order to make room for his own term Christotocos as a middle option. No one would use that name as a descriptive title, no matter how much they believed our Lord to be merely a man; and Nestorius speaks of those who called the Blessed Virgin Anthropotocos as if they were within the Church.

The name 'Anthropotocos' must have been a fiction of his own, in order to make room for his own term Christotocos, as an intermediate term. No one would give the name as a descriptive name, however they may have held our Lord to be a mere man; and Nestorius speaks of those, who called the Blessed Virgin Anthropotocos, as in the Church.

However, in his own Patriarchate, Nestorius had his own way for three years. S. Cyril mentions this period in his full letter of explanation to Acacius of Beroea, who must have been aware of the accuracy of the statement.

However, in his own Patriarchate, for three years Nestorius had his own way. S. Cyril names that period in his full letter of explanation to Acacius of Beroea, who must have been cognizant of the accuracy of the statement.

But when we all waited for Nestorius while he spent a period of three years blaspheming, both we and your holiness and the whole Council with us tried to bring him back from those errors and to the doctrines that belong to rightness and truth.105

' But when we all waited for Nestorius, while he spent a period of three years in blaspheming, and we and your holiness and the whole Council with us tried to bring him back from them, and to those doctrines which appertain to rightness and truth.'105

Peter, the notary, read out the same statement in the first session of the Council. "Not many days having elapsed" after his consecration. Saint Cyril says this in his letter to Saint Celestine.106

Peter, the notary, rehearsed the same in the first session of the Council. ' Not many days having elapsed' [after his consecration]. S. Cyril in his letter to S. Celestine says,106

During the past I have kept silent and have written absolutely nothing either to your Religiousness or to any of our fellow ministers about the one who is now at Constantinople and rules the Church, believing that hastiness in these matters is not without blame.107

' During the past I have kept silence and have written absolutely nothing either to your Religiousness, or any of our Fellow-ministers, about him who is now at Constantinople and ruleth the Church, believing that hastiness in these things is not without blame.'107

Within Constantinople, Nestorius on two apparent occasions provoked a strong public outcry by statements he approved that flatly denied the doctrine of the Incarnation. The first was by Anastasius, a priest he had brought from Antioch, whom he held in high regard and used as an advisor—a passionate supporter of Nestorius and his Jewish teachings. Anastasius declared openly in a sermon, "Let no one call Mary theotocos: for Mary was human, and it is impossible for a human being to give birth to God." The people could hardly tolerate this. Nestorius defended it vigorously.108109

Within Constantinople, Nestorius, twice apparently, gave occasion to a great expression of popular feeling by utterances which he sanctioned, absolutely denying the doctrine of the Incarnation. The first was by Anastasius, a priest whom he had brought from Antioch, whom 'he held in great honour, and employed as a counsellor; a fiery lover of Nestorius and his Jewish dogmas.' He burst out in a sermon openly, ' let no one call Mary theotocos: for Mary was human; but it is impossible that one human should bear God.' This the people could ill-endure. Nestorius supported it with vehemence.108109

The other statement that reached Cyril, which he mentioned to some people in Constantinople who criticized him for his letter to the monks, came from Dorotheus, Bishop of Marcianopolis. Dorotheus said openly, "Anathema if anyone calls the holy Mary Theotocos."110

The other statement which reached S. Cyril, and which he mentioned to some at Constantinople, who blamed him for his letter to the monks, was by Dorotheus Bishop of Marcianopolis, who said openly, 'Anathema, if any call the holy Mary, Theotocos.'110

This went much further than the former statement. It pronounced anathema (as S. Cyril understood) upon all who held what everyone held and expressed, upon the whole Catholic Church. Nestorius immediately received him into communion.

This went much further than the former. It pronounced Anathema (as S. Cyril saw) upon all who held what all held and expressed, upon the whole Catholic Church. Nestorius at once received him to Communion.

Nestorius supported the denial of the Theotokos. In his first sermon, he says that he had been asked whether the Blessed Virgin should be called Anthropotokos or Theotokos. He appealed to his hearers,

Nestorius supported the denial of the Theotocos. In his first Sermon he says, that he had been asked whether the Blessed Virgin was to be called 'Anthropotocos or Theotocos.' He appealed to his hearers,

Does God have a mother? If so, then paganism can be excused for giving mothers to its gods. Then Paul is a liar when he says of Christ's Deity, "without father, without mother, without descent." Mary did not give birth to God, my good friends. For what is born of the flesh is flesh, and what is born of the Spirit is spirit. The creature did not bear the Uncreated. The Father did not beget God the Word. For "in the beginning was the Word," as John says. The creature did not bear the Creator, but she bore a man, the instrument of Deity. The Holy Spirit did not create God the Word, for what was born of her was of the Holy Spirit. Rather, He formed from the Virgin a temple for God the Word to dwell in.111

' Has God a mother? Then heathendom may be excused, bringing in mothers to its gods. Then Paul is a liar, who saith of the Deity of Christ, 'without father, without mother, without descent.' Mary bore not God, my good friends. For that which is born of the flesh is flesh, and that which is born of the Spirit is spirit. The creature bare not the Uncreated: the Father did not beget God the Word. For 'in the beginning was the Word,' as John saith. The creature did not bear the Creator, but she bare a Man, the instrument of Deity: the Holy Spirit did not create God the Word; for that which was born of her was of the Holy Spirit; but He framed of the Virgin for God the Word a temple wherein He should dwell.'111

Nestorius continued to preach the same message, sometimes using language that was sound in itself, but within the context of what is unsound.

Nestorius continued to preach the same, sometimes in terms, in themselves sound, but in the context of what is unsound.

From his position as Patriarch in New Rome, the residence of the Emperor, or through his personal influence with Theodosius, he was able to overpower most opposition. As had been observed, what opposition there was came first from the laity, then from the clergy, and lastly from the bishops.

From his position as Patriarch in New Rome, the residence of the Emperor, or his personal influence with Theodosius, he could overbear most opposition. What opposition there was came, it had been observed, first from the Laity, then from the Clergy, lastly from the Bishops.

In his first letter to Saint Celestine, Nestorius told him that he had used both "anger and gentleness" every day in suppressing the Theotokos. What he meant by "anger and gentleness" can be seen from a formal petition to the Emperors submitted by Basil, a deacon and archimandrite, and Thalassius, a reader and monk. According to the words of this petition,

Nestorius, in his first epistle to S. Celestine, told him that he had daily used both 'anger and gentleness' in repressing the Theotocos. His idea of 'anger and gentleness' may be gathered from a formal petition to the Emperors from Basil, a deacon and Archimandrite, and Thalassius a reader and monk, in their petition to the Emperors. In the words of this petition,

By his command and invitation, we went to the bishop's residence to be fully instructed whether what we had heard concerning him is true. He put us off a second and a third time, and then scarcely allowed us to say what we wished. But when he had heard from us that what he had said—that 'Mary only bore a man consubstantial with herself' and 'what is born of the flesh is flesh'—is not orthodox language, he immediately had us seized. From there, beaten by the crowd of officers, we were led to the prison, and there they stripped us naked as prisoners subject to punishment, bound us to pillars, threw us down and kicked us. What we do not say that clerks, archimandrites, or monks, or indeed any secular persons, suffer in the civil courts, we endured in the Church unlawfully from lawless men. Oppressed and starving, we remained a long time under guard, and his mania was not satisfied with this. After all this, by some deceit we were handed over to the most Excellent Prefect of this renowned city, and loaded with irons we were led back to the prison. Afterwards we were brought up in the Praetorium in the same way with chains, and since there was no accuser, we were again led back by the guard to the prison. Thus he again punished us, striking us on the face, and having spoken and agreed deceitfully (as appeared from what followed) about Him Who is by nature Son of God, that He was born of the holy Mary the Theotocos, since there is another Son—so he dismissed us.112

' By his command and invitation, we went to the See-house, to be fully instructed whether what we had heard concerning him is true. He put us off a second and a third time, and then scarcely bade us say what we wished. But when he had heard from us, that what he had said, that 'Mary only bore a man consubstantial with herself,' and 'what is born of the flesh is flesh,' is not orthodox language, immediately he had us seized, and thence, beaten by the crowd of the officers, we were led to the prison, and there they stripped us naked as prisoners and subject to punishment, bound us to pillars, threw us down and kicked us. What in the civil courts we do not say that Clerks, Archimandrites, or monks, nay, or any secular persons do not suffer, we endured in the Church lawlessly from the lawless ones. Oppressed, famished, we remained a long time under guard, and his mania was not satisfied with this, but after all this, by some deceit we were delivered over to the most Excellent Eparch of this renowned city, and loaded with irons we were led back to the prison, and afterwards were brought up in the Praetorium in the same way with chains, and since there was no accuser, we were again led back by the guard in the prison and thus he again chastised us smiting us on the face, and having discoursed and agreed deceitfully (as appeared from what followed) about Him Who is by nature Son of Grod, that He was born of the holy Mary the Theotocos, since there is another Son; so he dismissed us.'112

Basil, who tells this story, also says that

Basil who relates this, says also,

Some of the most respected presbyters frequently rebuked to his face the man who is now entrusted with the episcopate (if he should be called a bishop), and because of his stubbornness in refusing to call the Holy Virgin Theotokos or Christ by nature true God, they have withdrawn from communion with him and still remain separated. Others do so secretly. Still others, because they spoke against the misguided renewal of this teaching in the holy church of Eirene-by-the-Sea, have been silenced. At this, the people, wanting to have the usual sound teaching, cried out, "We have a king, but we have no bishop." But this protest by the people did not go unpunished. Some were seized by the attendants and beaten in various ways in the imperial city, using methods not even practiced among barbarians. Some publicly contradicted him to his face in the church and suffered no small trouble. A monk of simpler background was driven by zeal to block this preacher of impiety from entering during the liturgical celebration, calling him a heretic. After beating him, Nestorius handed him over to the high-ranking governors, and after being beaten again and paraded publicly with a crier announcing his offense, Nestorius sent him into exile. And not only this, but even in the most holy church after his impious sermon, his supporters who controlled everything would have shed blood, had God's help not prevented it.113

' Some of the most reverend Presbyters frequently rebuked to the face him who is now entrusted with the Episcopate (if he should be called a Bishop) and, because of his self-will that he will not call the Holy Virgin Theotocos, or Christ by nature true God, have put themselves out of his communion, and so still remain; others do so secretly; others, because they spoke in this holy Church Eirene-by-the-sea against the ill-renewal of this dogma, have been silenced. On this the people, desiring to have the wonted sound teaching, cried out, 'A King we have; a Bishop we have not.' But this essay of the people did not remain unavenged; some were seized by the attendants, and beaten in divers ways in the royal city, as is not practised even among the Barbarians. Some contradicted him publicly to the face in the Church and underwent no little trouble. A monk of the simpler sort was constrained by zeal in the midst of the Church to hinder this herald of impiety from entering in at the Celebration, being a heretic. Him having beaten, he delivered to the Magnificent Governors and being again beaten and paraded publicly, the crier proclaiming (his offence), he [Nestorius] sent him into exile. And not this only, but even in the most holy Church after his impious homily, those on his side who held down every thing, would have shed blood, had not the aid of God prevented it.'113

They conclude by asking the Emperor to convene a General Council, 'not, God knows, to avenge our wrongs,' but 'to unite the most holy Church, restore the priests of the true faith, before the untrue teaching spread abroad.' They speak of Nestorius as

They conclude by asking the Emperor to convene a General Council, 'not, Grod knows, to avenge our wrongs,' but 'to unite the most holy Church, restore the priests of the true faith, before the untrue teaching spread abroad.' They speak of Nestorius as

intimidating, threatening, driving out, expelling, mistreating, acting recklessly and wickedly, and doing everything without restraint to establish his own madness and ungodliness. He neither fears God nor feels shame before men, but is clothed with contempt for all, confident in his anger and in the power of some who have been corrupted, and—to speak boldly—in your Majesty.

'intimidating, threatening, driving, expelling, maltreating, acting recklessly and ill, and doing all unsparingly to establish his own mania and ungodliness, neither fearing God, nor ashamed before men, but clothed with contempt of all, confident in his wrath and in the might of some who have been corrupted, and (to speak fearlessly) in your Majesty.'

It is strong language, but language that is all the more responsible because it was formally addressed to someone who held absolute power, who used that power in ways no modern ruler could, and who was known to favor the Patriarch against whom it was directed.

It is strong language, but language, the more responsible, as formally addressed to one who held absolute power, who used it as no modern Sovereign could, and who was known to favour the Patriarch, against whom it was directed.

Nestorius boasted to Saint Celestine about his success against those who had left him.

Nestorius boasted to S. Celestine of his success against those who had departed from him.

Moreover, they have dared to call the Virgin who bore Christ (Christotocos) in a certain way Theotocos. They do not shrink from calling her Theotocos, even though those holy fathers at Nicaea above all are recorded as having said nothing more about the holy Virgin than that our Lord Jesus Christ was incarnate from the Holy Spirit and the Virgin Mary. I am not even speaking of the Holy Scriptures, which everywhere, both through angels and apostles, present the Virgin as the mother of Christ, not of God the Word. Because of these things, your Blessedness has probably already been informed by reports about what conflicts we have endured. Note also that we have not struggled in vain, but by the grace of the Lord, many of those who had been departing from us have been corrected.114

' Moreover they have dared to call the Virgin who hare Christ (Christotocos) in a certain way Theotocos. For they do not shudder at calling her Theotocos, although those holy fathers above all praise at Nice are read to have said nothing more as to the holy Virgin than that our Lord Jesus Christ was incarnate of the Holy Ghost and the Virgin Mary. I do not speak of the Holy Scriptures, which every where, both by Angels and Apostles, set forth the Virgin as the mother of Christ, not of God the Word. For which things' sake what strifes we have endured, I suppose that report has, before this, instructed your Blessedness; observing this also, that we have not striven in vain, but by the grace of the Lord, many of those who were departing from us have been amended.'114

To Saint Cyril he says,

To S. Cyril he says,

Know that you have been deceived by the clerks of your own persuasion, who have been deprived of their positions here by the holy Synod because they held the same views as the Manichees.115

' Know that those hast been deceived by the Clerks of thine own persuasion, who have been deprived here by the holy Synod, because they were minded as the Manichees.'115

Cyril in the synodal letter from Alexandria, announcing Nestorius's impending excommunication, mentions those whom Nestorius had excommunicated or degraded, as Cyril had informed Celestine, the most holy bishop of great Rome and fellow-bishop. Celestine also requires as a condition of communion that Nestorius should restore to the Church all those excluded for the sake of Christ its head. In his letter to John of Antioch, Celestine suggests that others may have done this as well.116117

S. Cyril in the Synodal letter from Alexandria, announcing his impending excommunication, mentions those whom Nestorius had excommunicated or degraded, as he had 'indicated to Celestine the most holy Bishop of Great Rome and our fellow-bishop.' S. Celestine also requires as a condition of Communion that he should ' restore to the Church all excluded for the sake of Christ its Head.' In his letter to John of Antioch he supposes that this may have been done by others also.116117

Within Constantinople, Nestorius was opposed by those whose position protected them from his aggression: by S. Proclus, who had been appointed Bishop of Cyzicus but whom the Cyzicans refused because they wanted to appoint their own bishop, and who therefore remained a bishop without a see; and by Eusebius of Dorylaeum, who

Within Constantinople Nestorius was opposed by those whose position secured them from his aggression: by S. Proclus, appointed Bishop of Cyzicus, whom the Cyzicans declined, wishing to appoint their own Bishop, and who remained a Bishop without a see; and by Eusebius of Dorylaeum, who

being a man of great piety and skill among the laity, and having acquired no small amount of learning, was stirred by fervent and devout zeal and declared with a piercing cry that the Word himself, who exists before the ages, underwent a second generation through his birth in the flesh from a woman.118

' being of great piety and skill among the laymen, having gathered within himself no mean learning, was moved with fervent and devout zeal, and said with piercing cry, that the Word Himself Who is before the ages endured a second Generation by that after the flesh and from a woman.'118

Nestorius responded to him by speaking of the "pollution" of these wretches and saying that if there were two births, there must be two sons. In other words, he claimed that our "one Lord Jesus Christ" could not be begotten of the Father before all worlds and yet also be born of the Virgin Mary for us and for our salvation.

Nestorius answered him by speaking of the 'pollution' of these wretches and saying, "that if there were two births, there must be two sons," i. e. that our 'one Lord Jesus Christ' 'could not be Begotten of the Father before all worlds' and yet 'for us men and for our salvation' be born of the Virgin Mary.

Leontius says that Eusebius was also reported to be the author of the comparison between Paul of Samosata and Nestorius.119

Leontius says that Eusebius was also said to be the author of the parallel between Paul of Samosata and Nestorius.119

Different accounts exist of how people's minds were affected. St. Cyril says that when Dorotheus pronounced the Anathema,

Different accounts are given of the way in which the minds of the people were affected. S. Cyril says that on the Anathema pronounced by Dorotheus,

There was a great outcry from all the people, and they rushed out of the church. They refused to be in communion with those who held such views. Even now the people of Constantinople remain out of communion, except for some frivolous individuals and his flatterers. But nearly all the monasteries and their archimandrites, along with many members of the senate, do not commune with him. They fear being deceived concerning his faith and the faith of those who came with him from Antioch, all of whom speak perverse things.120

' There was a great cry from all the people, and a running out [of the Church.] For they would not communicate with those so minded. And now too the people of Constantinople remain out of communion, except some of the lighter sort and his flatterers. But nearly all the monasteries and their Archimandrites and many of the senate do not communicate: fearing lest they should be wronged as to his faith and that of those with him, whom he brought when he came up from Antioch, who all speak perverse things.'120

Nestorius, on the other hand, boasts at the end of his response to Saint Cyril's second letter,121

Nestorius, on the other hand, boasts at the close of his answer to S. Cyril's second letter,121

Church affairs among us are making daily progress, and through God's grace the people are growing so much that those who see their numbers cry out with the prophet that the earth is filled with the knowledge of the Lord as abundant water covers the sea, and the Emperors are exceedingly joyful, being enlightened regarding the doctrine; and, to put it briefly, one may see daily, concerning all the heresies that fight against God and the orthodoxy of the Church, that this word is daily being fulfilled among us: the house of Saul grew weaker and weaker, and the house of David grew stronger and stronger.

'Church matters with us advance daily, and the people through the grace of God so grow, that those who see their multitude, cry out with the prophet, that the earth is filled with the knowledge of the Lord, as much water covereth the sea, and the Emperors are in exceeding joy, being enlightened as to the doctrine; and, to speak briefly, one may see daily, as to all the heresies which fight with God and the orthodoxy of the Church, that word is daily fulfilled with us, the house of Saul waxed weaker and weaker, and the house of David waxed stronger and stronger.'

It is not particularly significant that the Emperor told Saint Cyril that the Churches were united and would become even more so, and that he was forgiven (for Nestorius had convinced him that Saint Cyril was merely a troublemaker), or that Nestorius once mentioned that the people were crowded together. But some were even ready to oppose those who objected to his teaching, and many clergy and laymen from Constantinople who came to Antioch and Beroea agreed with what Dorotheus said, believing it contained nothing contrary to apostolic doctrine or the faith of Nicaea.122123124125

It is not much that the Emperor told S. Cyril, that the Churches were united and would be yet more, and that he [S. Cyril] was forgiven; (for Nestorius had persuaded him that S. Cyril was a mere disturber of the peace) or that Nestorius on one occasion speaks of the people being thronged. But some were even ready to turn against those who objected to his teaching, and 'many Clergy and laymen from Constantinople coming to Antioch and Beroea agreed with the saying of Dorotheus, as having nothing contrary to Apostolic doctrine or the faith of Nicaea.'122123124125

During these three years, Cyril had broken his silence only three times: first in his letter to the monks in Egypt; then in a letter to Nestorius explaining why he had written that first letter after hearing that Nestorius was offended by it; and finally in his second complete statement of doctrine in the letter that was received by the Council of Ephesus.

In these three years, S. Cyril had only broken silence three times; once in his letter to the monks in Egypt; a letter to Nestorius, explaining the occasion of that letter when he heard that Nestorius was offended by it; and the second full statement of doctrine in the Epistle, which was received by the Council of Ephesus.

The first was his 'letter to the Monks of Egypt.' Some of them had been deeply troubled—even concerning the Divinity of our Lord—by certain writings attributed to Nestorius. St. Cyril answered them, but without any mention of Nestorius. He himself gives the account of his writing,

i. The first was his 'letter to the Monks of Egypt.' Grave perplexity had been occasioned to some of them, even as to the Divinity of our Lord, through some writings attributed to Nestorius. S. Cyril answered them, but without any mention of Nestorius. He himself gives the account of his writing,

When Nestorius' homilies were brought to Egypt, I learned that some of the less serious people were influenced, and said doubtfully among themselves, 'Is he right?' 'Is he wrong?' Fearing that this problem might take root in the minds of simple believers, I wrote a general letter to the monasteries of Egypt, strengthening them in the right faith.126

' When his [Nestorius'] homilies were brought to Egypt, I learnt that some of the lighter sort were carried away, and said doubtingly among themselves, 'does he say right?' 'Is he in error?' Fearing lest the disease should root in the minds of the simple, I wrote a general Epistle to the monasteries of Egypt, confirming them to the right faith.'126

No bishop who was competent in his office could have done anything other than work to remove those uncertainties from the minds of the people under his care. Others distributed what he had written in Constantinople. Saint Cyril continues his account,

No Bishop, competent for his office, could have done otherwise than set himself to remove those perplexities in the minds of the people committed to his charge. Others circulated what he had written, in Constantinople. S. Cyril continues his account,

Some people took copies to Constantinople. Those who read them benefited greatly, and many officials wrote letters thanking me. But this only increased his anger toward me, and he [Nestorius] opposed me as an enemy, having no other basis for criticism than that I cannot agree with his views.

'Some took copies to Constantinople. And those who read them were much benefited, so that very many of those in office wrote, thanking me. But that too was fresh nutriment of displeasure against me, and he [Nestorius] contended against me as an enemy, having no other ground of censure than that I cannot think as he does.'

Cyril's two letters to Nestorius, written before the sentence of condemnation that he was authorized to announce if Nestorius did not retract his views, were letters of explanation.

ii. iii. S. Cyril's two Epistles to Nestorius (previous to the sentence of condemnation which he was commissioned to announce, unless Nestorius should retract) were letters of explanation.

The first letter was intended to address the offense that Nestorius had taken at 'the letter to the monks.' It reads as follows:

The first was to remove the offence, which Nestorius had taken at 'the letter to the monks.' It runs;

People who are completely trustworthy have come to Alexandria and have told me that Your Piety is extremely angry and is doing everything possible to cause me grief. When I tried to find out the reason for Your Piety's distress, they said that some people from Alexandria were circulating the letter I wrote to the holy monks, and that this was the cause of the hatred and displeasure. I was surprised that Your Piety did not instead consider that the disturbance concerning the faith did not begin with my letter, but with certain papers or exegeses that were circulated—whether written by Your Piety or not. We then worked hard, wanting to restore those who had been misled. For some people would barely acknowledge that Christ is God, but rather said He was merely an organ or instrument of the Deity and a God-bearing man, and even things worse than this. I therefore had reason to complain about the things that Your Piety either wrote or did not write. (For I do not fully trust the papers that are being passed around.) How then could I remain silent when the faith is so damaged and so many people are being led astray? Will we not be brought before the judgment seat of Christ? Will we not have to give an account for our untimely silence, having been appointed by Him to say what is proper? What should I do now? For I must consult with Your Piety. And when the most religious and God-beloved Bishop of the Roman Church, and the God-beloved bishops with him, report concerning the papers brought there—I do not know how, whether by Your Piety or not—they write that they are extremely scandalized. And how shall we appease those who come from the East from all the churches and complain about the papers? Or does Your Piety think that only a small disturbance has arisen in the churches from such homilies? We are all struggling and working hard, bringing back those who have somehow been wrongly persuaded to think differently. When it is Your Piety who has necessarily made everyone complain, how does It justly find fault? Why does It cry out against me, and that for no reason, and not instead correct Its own speech to stop this worldwide scandal? For although the speech is in the past, since it is still spreading among the people, let it be corrected through revision, and please grant one word to those who are offended by calling the holy Virgin Theotokos, so that by soothing those who have been grieved and having a good reputation among all, we may celebrate the Communions in the peace and harmony of the peoples. But let Your Piety not doubt that we are ready to endure all things for the faith in Christ and to undergo imprisonments and death itself. But I speak the truth: even while Atticus of blessed memory was still alive, I composed a book on the Holy and Consubstantial Trinity, in which I also wrote about the Incarnation of the Only-Begotten in agreement with what I have now written, and I read it to bishops and clergy and those laypeople who were eager to hear, but I have not given it out to anyone until now. If it should be published, it is likely that I may be blamed again, even though the little work was composed even before Your Piety's consecration.127

' Persons deserving of all credit have come to Alexandria and have informed me that thy Piety is exceeding angry, and setting every thing in motion to grieve me. And when I would learn the cause of the grief of thy Piety, they said that some from Alexandria were circulating the letter written to the holy Monks, and that this was the occasion of the hatred and displeasure. I wondered then, that thy Piety did not rather think with Itself, that the disturbance as to the faith did not originate with my letter, but with some, whether written by thy Piety or no, but any how papers or exegeses which were circulated. We then toiled, wishing to restore those misled. For some would hardly admit that Christ is God; but that He was rather an organ or instrument of the Deity and a God-bearing man, and things even beyond this. I had then reason to complain of the things, which thy Piety did or did not write. (For I do not much trust the papers which are carried about.) How then should I be silent, when faith is so injured and so many are perverted? Shall we not be placed before the Judgement-seat of Christ? Shall we not give account for the unseasonable silence, having been appointed by Him to say what is meet? What shall I do now? For I must consult with thy Piety. And that, when the most religious and God-beloved Bishop of the Roman Church, and the God-beloved Bishops with him, report about the papers brought thither, I know not how, whether by thy Piety or no. For they write, as exceedingly scandalized. And how shall we soothe those who come from the East from all the Churches, and murmur against the papers? Or does thy Piety think, that only a little disturbance has sprung up in the Churches from such homilies? We are all struggling and toiling, bringing back those who are somehow mispersuaded to think otherwise. When then it is thy Piety, who made all of necessity murmur, how does It justly find fault? Why does It cry out against me, and that to no purpose, and does not rather correct Its own speech, to stop this world-wide scandal? For though the speech is past, yet as being diffused among the people, let it be set straight by revision, and do thou vouchsafe to concede one word to those who are offended, by calling the holy Virgin Theotocos, that soothing those who have been, grieved, and having a right repute among all, we may celebrate the Communions amid the peace and harmony of the peoples. But let not thy Piety doubt, that we are ready to endure all things for the Faith in Christ and to undergo imprisonments and death itself. But I say the truth, that even while Atticus of blessed memory still survived, I composed a book on the Holy and Consubstantial Trinity, in which I wrote also about the Incarnation of the Only-Begotten agreeably to what I have now written, and I read it to Bishops and Clerks and those of the laity who were fond of hearing, but I have not given it out hitherto to any one. If then it should be published, it is probable that I may again be blamed, whereas the little tract was composed even before the consecration of thy Piety.'127

Writing to a Patriarch was certainly an unpleasant task, especially to one who was in high favor with the Emperor of both East and West, who had a very high opinion of himself and his writings, and who was extremely angry with Saint Cyril for writing against them. The task was to tell him that he was actually in the wrong, that Saint Cyril could not have acted differently than he did with the judgment seat of Christ before him, and that Nestorius had to undo what he had done, which had turned both East and West against him. These were not pleasant things to write, but I do not know how they could have been expressed more gently. Saint Cyril assures Nestorius that there was nothing personal in what he had written, since he did not even know for certain whose writings he was responding to, but that they were spreading wrong doctrine among those entrusted to Saint Cyril's care—wrong doctrine that Nestorius would not agree with. He explains that he had no part in circulating what he had written in Constantinople, that he had written similar things many years before, and that this earlier writing too might become a fresh subject of accusation if it were published, even though its date showed it could have no connection to Nestorius. He makes only one request of him, the same request that John of Antioch, Nestorius's friend, also made—by accepting which Nestorius might have escaped his own shameful legacy and avoided being the author of the miserable division in the body of Christ—that he would be willing to accept one word, Theotokos. But doing so would have meant giving up his heresy.

It was, of course, an unpleasant office to write to a Patriarch, in high favour with the Sovereign of both, who had no slight opinion of himself and of his writings, and was very angry with S. Cyril himself for writing against them, to tell him that he was in fact himself in the wrong; that he, S. Cyril, could not have done otherwise than he did, having before him the judgement-seat of Christ, and that Nestorius had to undo what he had done, which had set East and West against him. They were not smooth things to write; but I do not know how they could have been conveyed more smoothly. S. Cyril assures Nestorius, that there was nothing personal in what he had written, for he did not even know certainly, whose writings he was answering, but that they were conveying wrong doctrine among those with whom S. Cyril was put in trust; wrong doctrine, which Nestorius would not go along with; that he [S. Cyril] had had no part in the circulation of what he had written in Constantinople; that he had written the like many years before, and that this too might become a fresh subject of incrimination, if it should be published, whereas from its date it could have no bearing on Nestorius. One only request he makes him, the same, which John of Antioch the friend of Nestorius also made, by acceding to which he might have escaped his own evil memory and being the author of the miserable rent in the body of Christ, that he would vouchsafe to concede one word, Theotocos. But it would have been to give up his heresy.

The presbyter Lampon, who delivered Cyril's letter, could only get the following arrogant response from Nestorius, in which he avoided every topic that Cyril's letter had addressed.

The Presbyter Lampon who took S. Cyril's letter, could only obtain from Nestorius the following haughty answer, in which he avoided every topic of the letter of S. Cyril.

Nothing is more powerful than Christian fairness. We have therefore been compelled to write this present letter through the most religious presbyter Lampon, who said many things to us about your Piety and also heard much, and finally would not yield to us until he extracted this letter from us, and we have been overcome by the man's persistence. For I admit that I have great reverence for all Christian goodness in every person, since God dwells in him. We then, although many things have been done by your Religiousness (to put it gently) that are not in keeping with brotherly love, continue in patience and the friendly exchange of letters. But experience will show what the result is of the pressure applied by the most religious Presbyter Lampon. I and those with me greet all the brotherhood together with you.128

' Nothing is mightier than Christian equity. We have then been constrained thereby to the present letter through the most religious presbyter Lampon, who said many things about thy Piety to us, and heard also much, and at last did not give way to us, until he wrung the letter from us, and we have been conquered by the man's importunity. For I own that I have great awe of all Christian goodness of every man, as having God residing in him. We then, although many things have been done by your Religiousness (to speak mildly) not according to brotherly love, continue in long-suffering and the friendly intercourse of letters. But experience will shew, what is the fruit of the constraint of the most religious Presbyter Lampon. I and those with me salute all the brotherhood together with thee.'128

The response from Nestorius was essentially an apology he made to himself for condescending to write to Cyril.

The answer of Nestorius was in fact an apology to himself for vouchsafing to write to S. Cyril.

The second letter of Saint Cyril is also an apology.

The second Epistle of S. Cyril is also Apologetic,

in response to some people who are constantly gossiping to your Piety against my reputation, especially watching for opportunities when those in power are meeting.129

' in answer to some who are babbling to thy Piety against my reputation and that incessantly, watching, above all, the seasons of the meetings of those in power.'129

The letter is entirely doctrinal in content. However, there is no real dispute with Nestorius in it, except for the appeal at the end asking him to think and teach these things. It is simply a careful statement of the doctrine of the Incarnation that explicitly excludes what Nestorius called Apollinarian.

The Epistle is throughout doctrinal. But there is not the slightest controversy with Nestorius, except in the appeal at the end that he would think and teach these things. It is only a careful statement of the doctrine of the Incarnation, expressly excluding what Nestorius called Apollinarian.

Nestorius's reply is written in a tone of mocking condescension. He claims to overlook "the insults of your remarkable letters, since they call for patient forbearance like medicine"; "the supposedly all-wise words of your Love"; he advises Cyril to pay attention to doctrine—meaning that Cyril should not, as he had done, read the tradition of the most holy fathers [the Nicene Creed] superficially and thereby display an ignorance that required forgiveness. Nestorius treated Cyril's letter as self-contradictory and concluded in a tone of triumph. Further correspondence was obviously pointless. In fact, Nestorius's quotation from Saint Paul seems intended to close the discussion entirely.130

The answer of Nestorius is in a tone of ironical condescension. He professes to pass by 'the contumelies of thy wondrous letters, as needing a medicinal long-suffering;' 'the all-wise words of thy Love;' advises him to attend to doctrine, i. e. not as he had, reading superficially the tradition of the all-holy fathers [the Nicene Creed] to shew an ignorance, which needed forgiveness; treated his letter as self-contradictory and ended in a tone of triumph. Further correspondence was of course useless. Indeed, the quotation from S. Paul seems intended by Nestorius to close the subject.130

These are our recommendations, given from one brother to another. But if anyone seems inclined to argue, Paul will call out through us as well: "We have no such custom, nor does the Church of God."

'These are the counsels from us, as from a brother to a brother. But if any one seem to be contentious, to such an one Paul will cry out through us also, We have no such custom, neither the Church of God.'

It's possible that St. Cyril's letters to the Imperial family were prompted by Nestorius's claim that the Emperor was delighted to be instructed about the dogma. However, while Cyril clearly explains the facts to them, he neither mentions Nestorius by name nor quotes any known statement of his.

It may be that S. Cyril's letters to the Imperial family may have been occasioned by the statement which Nestorius gives of the joy of the Sovereign on being enlightened as to the dogma. But although he states the fact clearly to them, he neither mentions Nestorius, nor quotes any known saying of his.

He himself waited. He had probably learned from his passionate loyalty to his uncle and early benefactor, Theophilus, and the injustice it caused to the memory of Saint Chrysostom. He tells those who criticized him for his letter to the monks of Egypt that he could have responded to anathema with anathema.

He himself waited. He had learned probably from his fiery adhesion to his uncle and early benefactor, Theophilus, and its injustice to the memory of S. Chrysostom. He says to those who reproached him for his letter to the monks of Egypt, that he might have returned anathema for anathema,

Since we who are still living, and the bishops throughout the world, and our fathers who have departed to God, have been anathematized. For what prevented me from writing the opposite of his words: 'If anyone does not say that Mary is Theotokos, let him be anathema?' But I have not done this up to now for his sake, so that no one should say that the Bishop of Alexandria—that is, the Egyptian Synod—has anathematized him. But if the most devout bishops in East and West learn that all have been anathematized (for all say and confess that the holy Mary is Theotokos), how will they react? How will they not be distressed, if not for themselves, then for the holy fathers, in whose writings we find the holy Virgin Mary called Theotokos? If I did not think it would be burdensome, I would send many books of the holy Fathers, in which you may find this word used not once but many times, whereby they confess that the holy Virgin Mary is Theotokos.131

' Since we who are yet living, and the Bishops throughout the world, and our fathers who have departed to God have been anathematised. For what hindered me too from writing the converse of his words, 'If any one say not that Mary is Theotocos, be he anathema?' But I have not done this hitherto for his sake, lest any should say, that the Bishop of Alexandria, i. e. the Egyptian Synod, has anathematised him. But if the most religious Bishops in East and West shall learn, that all have been anathematised, (for all say and confess that the holy Mary is Theotocos) how will they be disposed? How will they not be grieved, if not for themselves, yet for the holy fathers, iu whose writings we find the holy Virgin Mary named Theotocos? If I did not think it would be burdensome, I would send many books of the holy Fathers, in which you may find not once but many times this word used, whereby they confess that the holy Virgin Mary is Theotocos.'131

When he finally wrote to ask the advice of Saint Celestine, he says.132

When at last he wrote to ask the advice of S. Celestine, he says.132

During the past time I have been silent and have written absolutely nothing about the man who is now in Constantinople and leads the Church, either to your Piety or to any of our fellow ministers, believing that hasty action in these matters deserves blame.

'During the time past I have been silent and have written absolutely nothing concerning him who is now at Constantinople and rules the Church, either to your Piety or to any other of our fellow-ministers, believing that precipitancy in these things is not without blame.'

However, the confusion was already significant. St. Cyril says to a friend of Nestorius:

Yet the confusion was already not slight. S. Cyril says to a friend of Nestorius;

There is no one from any city or country who does not say that these things are on everyone's lips, and ask what new teaching is being brought into the Churches.133

' There is no one from any city or country, who does not say that these things are in every one's mouth, and, what new learning is being brought into the Churches?'133

To Nestorius himself he said, "The books of your exegeses are circulated everywhere."134

To Nestorius himself he said, ' the books of your exegeses are circulated every where.'134

Vanity probably hastened the condemnation of Nestorius. He had a low opinion of the abilities of S. Celestine.

Vanity probably precipitated the condemnation of Nestorius. He had a low estimate of the abilities of S. Celestine.

Nestorius says, "The Egyptian [S. Cyril], frightened by the fear of being found guilty, and looking for some problem to help him, turns to Celestine of Rome, viewing him as too simple-minded to understand the power of theological teachings. Finding that man to be indeed simple, he childishly deceives him with the illusions of his letters."135

' The Egyptian [S.Cyril] terrified,' he says, 'by the dread of being convicted, and seeking for some trouble to stand him in stead, betakes himself to Celestine of Rome, as one too simple to penetrate the force of dogmas. Finding moreover the simplicity of that man, he childishly circumvents his ears with the illusions of letters.'135

It did not occur to Nestorius that divine truth is seen through simple piety, not through proud intellect. He was also unaware that S. Celestine had a deacon who, like S. Athanasius when he was a deacon at Nicaea, possessed that intuitive perception of truth which was later to be developed on these very subjects—the one who became S. Leo the Great, who entrusted the letters of Nestorius to be translated and refuted by Cassian.136

It did not occur to Nestorius that Divine truth is seen by simple piety, not by proud intellect. He was not aware also, that S. Celestine had a deacon who, like S. Athanasius when a deacon at Nicaea, possessed that intuitive perception of truth which was afterwards to be developed on these very subjects; him, who became S. Leo the Great, who entrusted the letters of Nestorius to be translated and refuted by Cassian.136

To this same Celestine, whom he thought so little of, Nestorius wrote two letters. Ostensibly he was consulting him about Julian and other Pelagians, but in reality he was presenting his own heresy in the most persuasive way he could. He began by laying down,137

To this S. Celestine, of whom he thought so lightly, Nestorius wrote two letters, ostensibly to consult him about Julian and other Pelagians, but in reality to propound his own heresy in as plausible a manner as he could. He began by laying down,137

We owe each other brotherly discussion, since we must fight together in unity against the devil, the enemy of peace. What is the purpose of this introduction?

'We owe to each other brotherly conference, as having to fight in harmony together against the devil, the enemy of peace. To what end this preface?'

Julian and others, claiming to be bishops of the West, complained both to the Emperor and to him that they were being persecuted despite being orthodox. Since he was unaware of the facts of the case, he asked Saint Celestine to inform him, because a new sect requires great vigilance from true pastors.

Julian and others, alleging that they were Bishops of the West, complained both to the Emperor and to him, that they were persecuted being orthodox; so he, being in ignorance of the merits of the case, asked S. Celestine to inform him. 'For a new sect claims great watchfulness from true pastors.'

In his second letter, Nestorius says that he had written 'often' about these Pelagian Bishops. He himself might have known (as Celestine reminds him), since his predecessor Atticus had written to Celestine, what Celestine had done in their case. In both letters, Nestorius speaks of his efforts against 'something similar to Apollinarianism.' In his second letter, he says that he is working hard to 'root it out.' Cyril, in his letter to Juvenal, says that Nestorius wrote this letter to the Church of the Romans, hoping to win it over to his side.138

In the second letter, he says that he had 'often' written about these Pelagian Bishops. He himself might have known (S. Celestine reminds him) since Atticus his predecessor had written to S. Celestine, what he had done in their matter. In both letters, he speaks of his efforts against 'something akin to Apollinarianism:' in his second, that he is at much pains to 'extirpate' it. S. Cyril, in his letter to Juvenal, says that Nestorius wrote this letter to the Church of the Romans, hoping to carry it away with him.138

Through these letters to Celestine, Cyril became the reason why a letter in which he finally consulted Celestine about the matter of Nestorius was shown to Celestine. Cyril had instructed his deacon Posidonius: if he should find Nestorius's books of scriptural interpretations and his letters already delivered to Celestine, then deliver my letters as well; if not, bring them back here to me undelivered. Posidonius, finding that the interpretations and letters had been delivered, was therefore obliged to deliver Cyril's letters as well.139

By these letters to S. Celestine, he was himself the occasion of a letter, in which S. Cyril at last consulted him about the matter of Nestorius, being shewn to S. Celestine. For S. Cyril had given instructions to his Deacon Posidonius,' if he should find the books of his [Nestorius] exegeses and his letters delivered to him [S. Celestine], deliver my letters also; if not, bring them here [to S. Cyril] undelivered. He then, finding the exegeses and the letters delivered, had himself also to deliver them.'139

A synod was then held at Rome in which, after many sessions, the bishops declared that he had devised a new and very serious heresy, and they condemned him.140

A synod then was held at Rome, in which, after many sessions, the Bishops declared him to have devised a new very grievous heresy, and condemned him.140

A fragment of a speech by Saint Celestine is preserved, in which he cited the authorities of Saint Ambrose in his "Veni redemptor gentium," Saint Hilary, and Saint Damasus. Saint Celestine announced the result to Nestorius.141

A fragment of a speech of S. Celestine is preserved, in which he cited the authorities of S. Ambrose in his Veni redemptor gentium, S. Hilary and S. Damasus. S. Celestine announced to Nestorius the result;141

Unless you teach about Christ our God the same doctrine that the Church of Rome, the Alexandrians, and the holy Church in great Constantinople held excellently well before you came, and unless within ten days counted from the date of this warning you revoke by an open written confession that faithless innovation which attempts to divide what holy Scripture unites, you are expelled from all communion with the Catholic Church.

'Unless you teach as to Christ our God the same which the Church of the Romans and the Alexandrians and the holy Church in great Constantinople held excellently well till you, and, within the tenth day counted from the day of this admonition, annul by an open confession in writing that faithless novelty which undertakes to sever what holy Scripture unites, thou art cast out of all communion with the Catholic Church.'

Saint Celestine wrote the same message to John of Antioch. He had entrusted this decision to Saint Cyril, who was acting in his place. Saint Cyril wrote to John of Antioch about what had happened and about the condemnation of Nestorius by the Roman Synod, informing him that the Council had written similar letters to Rufus, Bishop of Thessalonica, and other bishops of Macedonia, who always agree with them, and to Juvenal, Bishop of Aelia. He urged John to follow their decision and asked him to consider what steps to take to prevent this break in communion.142143

S. Celestine wrote the same to John of Antioch. This judgement he had entrusted to S. Cyril, holding his place. S. Cyril wrote what had passed and the condemnation of Nestorius by the Roman Synod to John of Antioch, telling him, that the Council had written the like to 'Rufus Bishop of Thessalonica, and other Bishops of Macedonia, who always agree with them,' and to Juvenal Bishop of Aelia; that he himself should follow their decision, and asking him to consider what to do to hinder this breach of communion.142143

John of Antioch was alarmed at the prospect of this division and wrote to Nestorius to prevent it by accepting the word Theotokos. He wrote not only in his own name but also in the name of six other bishops who were with him at the time, including Theodoret. He wrote in complete sympathy with Nestorius and in opposition to those who opposed him. He speaks of the many as "unrestrained against us" and asks, "what will they be now that they have gained support from these wretched letters?" He assumes that Nestorius's faith was sound. He had heard that Nestorius had said he would use the word Theotokos if anyone of high standing in the Church suggested it. John tells him that he is not urging him to make a disgraceful change or engage in what might be called "boyish stubbornness." He notes that "though my lord Celestine had set a very short time for the answer, yet one day, perhaps even a few hours, would be enough." He urges Nestorius to seek the counsel of those who share his views, allowing them to speak fearlessly about what is useful, not what is pleasant. John himself held and stated the true faith, and he believed the word Theotokos was the appropriate and true way to express it, and that rejecting it would endanger the unspeakable mystery of the Only-Begotten Son of God.144

John of Antioch was alarmed at this prospect of a rent, and wrote to Nestorius to prevent it by accepting the word Theotocos. He wrote not in his own name only, bat in that of six other Bishops who were then with him, among them Theodoret. He wrote in entire sympathy with Nestorius, in antagonism to those opposed to him. He speaks of the many, as 'unrestrained against us,' and asks, 'what will they be, now that they have gained support from these wretched letters? He takes it for granted that the faith of Nestorius was sound; he had heard that he had said that he would use the word [Theotocos] if any of those in high repute in the Church suggested it, tells him that he does not exhort him to disreputable change, or, so to say, 'boyish contradiction;' that 'though my lord Celestine had fixed a very narrow time for the answer, yet one day, perhaps a few hours would be enough; and urges him to take the counsel of those of his own mind, allowing them to speak fearlessly what was useful, not what was pleasant.' John himself held and stated the true faith, and thought the word Theotocos the convenient and true way to express it, and that to reject it would jeopardise the unspeakable mystery of the Only-Begotten Son of God.144

Nestorius had however taken his line. He answers in apparent amazement:

Nestorius had however taken his line. He answers in apparent amazement;

I thought people could have launched any accusation against me except the false charge that I do not hold correct views about the piety of faith—I who have been pleased that thousands of hostilities have arisen against me because of my battle against all heretics. But I must endure this trial too with joy, for it also, if we are very careful, may give us much confidence in piety.145

' I thought that people could have set anything in motion against me rather than the calumny that I do not hold aright as to the piety of faith, I who hitherto have been delighted that many thousand hostilities rise against me on account of the battle which I have against all heretics. But this temptation too I must bear with joy; for it too, if we watch very carefully, may confer on us much confidence to piety.'145

He says in response that many heretics have adopted the word Theotokos as their own, and that some people here, by using the word carelessly, fall into heretical and irreligious thoughts, especially those of the impious Arius and Apollinarius. His own solution was that the word Theotokos should be explained harmoniously after we all deliberate together. He commands John

He says in answer, that 'the word Theotocos is assumed by many heretics as their own;' that 'some here, using the word incautiously, fall thereby into heretical and irreligious thoughts, especially those of the impious Arius and Apollinarius:' that his own solution was that 'the word Theotocos should be explained harmoniously after the deliberation of us all.' He bids John

dismiss all anxiety, knowing that by the grace of God we have thought and do think the same regarding the piety of the faith. For it is clear that if we meet, since God has granted us this Synod for which we hope, we will settle this matter and whatever else must be done for the correction and benefit of everyone, without scandal and in harmony; so that all things that are decided by a common and universal decree may receive the dignity of matters of faith, and will give no one an occasion for objection even if he is very eager to object. But regarding the customary presumption of the Egyptian, your Religiousness should not be surprised, since we have had many examples of this for a long time. Shortly, if God wills, our counsel in this matter too will be worthy of praise.

'dismiss all anxiety, knowing that hy the grace of God we have and do think the same in what relates to the piety of faith. For it is plain that if we meet, since He has given us this Synod which we hope, we shall dispose this and whatever else must be done for the correction and benefit of the whole, without scandal and in harmony; so that all things which may be ordained by a common and universal decree may receive the dignity of matters of faith, and shall give no one an occasion of contradiction even if he be very ready for it. But as to the wonted presumption of the Egyptian, your Religiousness ought not to wonder, since we have of old very many instances of this. After a little, if God shall will, our counsel herein also will be matter of praise.'

He adds in a postscript,

He adds in a postscript,

We have, by the grace of God, drawn more people—both clergy and laity, as well as those in the imperial court—to the teaching we publicly proclaim in the Church, through the letters from your Religiousness.

'We have by the grace of God attracted more both the Clergy and people and those who are in the imperial mansions, through the Epistles of your Religiousness, to that doctrine which we give publicly in the Church.'

To Saint Celestine, after writing in his usual manner about the terms Theotocos, Anthropotocos, and Christotocos, he writes triumphantly:

To S. Celestine, after writing in his wonted strain about the terms Theotocos, Anthropotocos, Christotocos, he writes exultingly:

The most devout Emperors have decided, with God's help, to call a worldwide Synod from which no one may excuse themselves, in order to investigate other church matters. I don't think any uncertainty about terminology will require difficult inquiry or prevent us from discussing the divinity of the Lord Jesus.146

' The most pious Emperors have been pleased, with the help of God, to appoint a Synod of the whole world, from which no one is to excuse himself [inexcusabiliter] for the enquiry into other ecclesiastical matters. For any doubt about words will not, I suppose, involve any difficult enquiry, nor be a hindrance to treating of the Divinity of the Lord Jesus.'146

Saint Celestine says,147

S. Celestine says,147

He asks for a field of battle; he calls for an examination by priests, though he would not be present at it. Who would have thought that the one who requested a synod would be absent from the synod?

'He asks a field for battle; he calls for a sacerdotal examination, at which he would not be present. Who would have thought that he who asked for a synod [petitorem synodi] would be absent from the Synod?'

The Emperor's relationship to the Synod is best explained by the personal letter he wrote to Cyril, commanding him to attend. The letter can hardly have had any purpose other than to intimidate Cyril, since he had already received the circular summons to the Council, of which the only surviving copy is addressed to him. The letter was written entirely from Nestorius's perspective, for the Emperor treats Cyril as the one who caused the current confusion, and presents the doctrine as something yet to be examined and settled by the Council.148

The relation of the Emperor to the Synod is best explained by the personal letter which he wrote to S. Cyril, commanding his attendance at it. The letter can hardly have had any other object than to intimidate S. Cyril. For he had already received the circular summons to the Council, of which the only extant copy is addressed to him. The letter was written altogether in the mind of Nestorius. For he treats S. Cyril as the author of the existing confusion, and the doctrine as one hereafter to be examined and settled by the Council.148

Everyone knows that religion stands firm not because someone orders it to, but because of understanding. Now explain to us why you have ignored us—knowing as you do how much we care about godliness—and all the priests everywhere who could have resolved this dispute better, and have instead, as far as it depends on you, thrown confusion and division into the Church. It is as if rash impulsiveness is appropriate for questions about godliness rather than careful precision, or as if we value recklessness more than carefulness, or as if we prefer complexity in these matters to simplicity. We did not think that your Piety would receive our high regard this way, or that everything would be thrown into confusion, especially since we also know how to be displeased. But for now we will look after the sacred peace. But understand that you have disturbed everything in a way you should not have.149

' It is plain to every one that religion has its firmness not from any one's bidding but from intelligence. Now then let thy Piety instruct Us, why, overlooking Us (whom thou knowest to have such care of godliness) and all the priests every where, who could better have solved this dispute, thou hast, as far as in thee lies, cast confusion and severance into the Church. As if a rash impetuosity became questions as to godliness, rather than accuracy; or as if carefulness had not more weight with Ourselves than rashness; or as if intricacy in these things were more pleasing to Us than, simplicity. And yet we did not think that Our high estimation would be so received by thy Piety, or that every thing would be thrown into confusion, inasmuch as We too know how to be displeased. But now We shall take heed to the sacred calm. But know that thou hast disturbed every thing as thou oughtest not.'149

Then, after reproaching him for trying to sow division within the Imperial family through his letters to the Emperor, the Empress Eudocia, and his sister Augusta Pulcheria, and telling him that wanting to split apart both Churches and royal power belongs to the same kind of person, as if there were no other way to gain prominence, he continues:

Then, having reproached him, as having tried to sow dissension in the Imperial family, by his letters to him and the Empress Eudocia, and his sister Augusta Pulcheria, and told him that it belonged to one and the same, to wish to dissever Churches and Royalties, as though there were no other way of obtaining distinction, he resumes,

But so that you may know our position, be assured that the Churches and the kingdoms are united, and will be even more united at our command, with the providence of our Savior Christ, and that your Piety is forgiven, so that you may have no excuse, nor be able to say that you are blamed on account of religion. For we desire that all things shall be laid open at the holy Synod and that what seems good shall prevail, whether the defeated obtain forgiveness from the fathers or not. We certainly will not tolerate that cities and Churches should be thrown into confusion, nor that the question should remain unexamined. Those who everywhere preside over the Priesthood must sit in judgment on these matters; and through them we have and shall have firmer possession of the true doctrine. Nor shall anyone, who has even the slightest share in the polity, be allowed freedom of speech, if in his self-confidence he chooses to evade such a judgment. He shall not be permitted; for our Majesty must praise those who shall eagerly and readily come to this inquiry, and will not tolerate it if any choose to command rather than be counseled about these matters. So then your Reverence must come at the time appointed in the other letters, sent to all the Metropolitans; and must not expect to recover the relation to us in any other way than by ceasing from all grievousness and turbulence, and coming willingly to the investigation of these questions. For thus you will appear to have done what has hitherto been done harshly and inconsiderately, yet still on behalf of your opinion, not through any private spite or undue hostility to anyone, and to be willing to do with justice what remains to be done. For if you choose to do otherwise, we will not endure it.

'But that thou mayest know Our state, be assured that the Churches and the kingdoms are united, and will be yet more united at Our command, with the providence of our Saviour Christ, and that thy Piety is forgiven, that thou mayest have no pretext, nor be able to say that thou art blamed on account of religion. For we will that all shall be laid open at the holy Synod and that what shall seem good shall prevail, whether the defeated obtain forgiveness from the fathers or no. We certainly will not endure that cities and Churches should be thrown into confusion, nor that the question should remain unsifted. Of these they must sit in judgment, who every where preside over the Priesthood; and by them We have and shall have firmer possession of the true doctrine. Nor shall any one, who has ever so little share in the polity, be allowed liberty of speech, if in his self-confidence he choose to evade such a judgement. He shall not be permitted; for Our Majesty [lit. Divinity] must praise those who shall eagerly and readily come to this enquiry, and will not endure if any choose to command rather than be counselled about these matters. So then thy Reverence must come at the time appointed in the other letters, sent to all the Metropolitans; and must not expect to recover the relation to Ourselves in any other way than that, ceasing from all grievousness and turbulence, thou come willingly to the investigation of these questions. For thus thou wilt appear to have done what has hitherto been done harshly and inconsiderately, yet still in behalf of thy opinion, not through any private pique or undue hostility to any one, and to will to do with justice what remains to be done. For if thou willest to do otherwise, We will not endure it.'

A Caesar who wrote in this way could not be approached. It appears that he expected Saint Cyril to be condemned rather than Nestorius. Saint Cyril did not attempt to address the offense of his letters to the Imperial family until he had been permitted to return from the Council to his own diocese.

A Caesar who so wrote could not be approached. It seems that he expected S. Cyril to be condemned rather than Nestorius. S. Cyril did not attempt to remove the offence of his letters to the Imperial family, until he had been allowed to return from the Council to his own diocese.

Cyril explains his own attitude toward Nestorius to a zealous supporter of Nestorius with remarkable straightforwardness.150

S.Cyril explains his own mind towards Nestorius to a zealous adherent of Nestorius, with a singular simplicity.150

If I were writing to someone who didn't know my character, I might use many words to convince them that I am an extremely peaceful person, not inclined to strife, not fond of conflict, but someone who desires to love everyone and to be loved by everyone. But since I am writing to someone who knows me, I will say this briefly: if a brother's distress could be removed by the loss of money or possessions, I would gladly have done it, so that I would not appear to value anything more than love. However, since this is a question of faith, and all the Churches throughout the entire Roman Empire (so to speak) are offended—what are we to do, we who have been entrusted by God with the divine mysteries? For those who have been taught the faith will accuse us on the Day of Judgment, saying that they held the faith as we taught it to them. Let the faith alone be preserved, and I am his dear friend and yield to no one in loving the most God-beloved Bishop Nestorius more than I love myself. God is my witness that I wish he might be of good reputation in Christ and remove the stain of the past, and show that what is commonly said by some concerning his faith are false accusations.151152

' If I were writing to one who knew not my disposition, I might have used many words, persuading that I am a person exceeding peaceful, not given to strife, not fond of warfare, but one who longs to love all and to be loved by all. But because I write to one who knows me, I say briefly, 'If a brother's grief could be removed by loss of money or goods, I would gladly have done it, that I might not seem to hold anything of more value than love. But since it is a question of faith, and all the Churches (so to say) in the whole Roman Empire are offended,—- what shall we do, who are entrusted by God with the Divine mysteries?' For those who are taught the faith will accuse us in the Day of Judgement, saying that they held the faith as taught by us….. Only be the faith preserved, and I am his dear friend and yield to none as loving more than myself the most God-beloved Bishop Nestorius, who (God is my witness) I would might be of good repute in Christ and efface the blot of the past, and shew that what is commonly said by some as to his faith, are untrue accusations.'151152

And again to the clergy at Constantinople:

And again to Clergy at Constantinople,

I must make my meaning plain to you, and so I write again. Although I naturally love peace and am very ignorant of strife, I still wish that the Churches should have peace, and that the priests of God living in peace should remember us, since Jesus Christ the Saviour of all says, "My peace I give unto you, My peace I leave with you." Say then in conferences that much has passed from them to injure us. Yet there will be peace when he ceases to think or speak such things. If he professes the right faith, there will be a full and most firm peace. If he desires this, let him write the Catholic faith and send it to Alexandria. If this is written from his inmost heart, I too am ready, as far as it lies within me, to write the same and publish a book and say that none of our fellow-bishops ought to be aggrieved, because we learn that his words have a right intention and clear purpose. But if he continues in the perverseness of vain-glory and asks for peace, nothing remains but that we resist with all our might, lest we should seem to agree with him. For to me my chiefest desire is to labor and live and die for the faith which is in Christ.153

' I must make my meaning plain to you and so I write again, that although I by nature love peace, and am very ignorant of strife, yet I wish that the Churches should have peace, and that the priests of God living in peace should remember us, since Jesus Christ the Saviour of all saith, "My peace I give unto you, My peace 1 leave with you." Say then in conferences, that much has passed from them to injure us; yet there will be peace, when he shall cease to think or speak such things. If he profess the right faith, there will be a full and most firm peace. If he desires this, let him write the Catholic faith and send it to Alexandria. If this be written from his inmost heart, I too am ready, as far as in me lies, to write the like and publish a book and say that none of our fellow-bishops ought to be aggrieved, because we learn that his words have a right intention and manifest purpose. But if he continue in the perverseness of vain-glory and asks for peace, nothing remains but that we resist with all our might, lest we should seem to agree with him. For to me my chiefest desire is to labour and live and die for the faith which is in Christ.'153

There could hardly be a more straightforward offer—setting aside everything of his own to "write the Catholic faith." Nestorius was not bound to any theological expressions, but only to the simple faith. He could not write it because he had stopped holding it.

There could scarcely be a franker offer, putting aside every thing of his own, to 'write the Catholic faith.' Nestorius is tied down to no Theological expressions, but to the simple faith. He could not write it, because he had ceased to hold it.

The bishops assembled in that synod were of no ordinary character. Vincentius of Lérins, writing about three years after it was held, speaks of its

The Bishops assembled in that Synod were of no ordinary character. Vincentius of Lerins, writing about three years after it was holden, speaks of its

great humility and holiness, noting that they were mostly metropolitans of such character and learning that nearly all of them were capable of debating matters of faith. Yet they claimed no authority for themselves, but took care to pass down to those who came after them only what they themselves had received from the Fathers.154

' great humility and holiness, that they were for the more part metropolitans, of such condition and doctrine, that almost all could dispute about matters of faith, and yet they claimed nothing for themselves, but were careful to hand down nothing to those after them, which they had not themselves received from the Fathers.'154

Saint Cyril, in his Apology to the Emperor, calls them "men very well known to your Majesty, and highly praised for their excellence in all things."155

S. Cyril in his Apology to the Emperor, calls them ' men, very well known to your Mightiness, and exceeding well spoken of for excellence in all things.'155

Nestorius came to the Council immediately after the Feast of Easter with ten or fifteen bishops who were his supporters. He was also backed by a few Pelagian bishops whom he had admitted to Communion and who were temporarily kept in their positions by Theodosius's order that everything should remain unchanged until the Council made its decision. It is said that he found many bishops already present. If this is true, they must have been bishops from the Exarchate of Ephesus, since the others are reported to have arrived later. The Council was Nestorius's idea, and he naturally came among the first to guide its decisions, as he hoped to do. When S. Cyril arrived, he found that there had been active but unsuccessful efforts against the faith. He wrote, "The Evil one, the sleepless beast, is going about, plotting against the faith of Christ, but achieves nothing." The Evil one is, of course, Satan, but Satan works through human agents. Nestorius says that he had no contact with S. Cyril. He wrote to Scholasticus, a eunuch of the Emperor and his friend: "Cyril has previously avoided any conversation with us entirely, and continues to avoid it until now, thinking that he will thereby escape the conviction of the Chapters [the anathemas] because without being challenged they are heretical." If, as has been suggested, it was at this time that S. Cyril made the extracts from the works of Nestorius, and possibly those from older writers containing the true doctrine, he had enough to keep him busy. There is no reason to think that S. Cyril preached against Nestorius at this time.156157158159160161

Nestorius came to the Council ' immediately after the Feast of Easter' with 10 or 15 Bishops, his adherents. He was also supported by a few Pelagian Bishops, whom he had admitted to Communion, and who for the time were retained in their office by the requirement of Theodosius, that everything should remain as it was, until the decision of the Council. He is said to have found many Bishops present. If so, they must have been Bishops from the Exarchate of Ephesus. For the rest are related to have arrived later. The Council was the plan of Nestorius, and he naturally came among the first, to guide, as he hoped, its decisions. S. Cyril, on his arrival, found that there had been active, though ineffectual, efforts against the faith. He wrote, ' The Evil one, the sleepless beast, is going about, plotting against the faith of Christ, but avails nothing.' The Evil one is, of course, Satan; but Satan acts through human agents. Nestorius says, that he had no intercourse with S. Cyril. He wrote to Scholasticus, an Eunuch of the Emperor and his friend; 'Cyril has both heretofore entirely avoided any converse with us, and until now avoids it, thinking that he shall thereby escape the conviction of the Chapters [the anathemas] because without contradiction they are heretical.' If (as has been conjectured) it was at this time that S. Cyril made the extracts from the works of Nestorius, and possibly those from older writers, containing the true doctrine, he had enough to do. There is no reason to think that S. Cyril preached at this time against Nestorius.156157158159160161

The pure humanitarianism of Nestorius was revealed through the attempts of Theodotus of Ancyra and his pious friend Acacius, Bishop of Melitene, to bring him back to the faith. To Theodotus and several others, he repeated the well-known blasphemies about our Lord's sacred infancy and childhood—that he would not call him God who was two or three months old, or who was nursed at the breast, or who fled into Egypt. This was stated under oath to the Council. There was nothing further to investigate. It provided what was still missing: the knowledge that Nestorius had not abandoned the heresy for which he had been condemned the year before. Saint Celestine had given formal advice to Saint Cyril that if Nestorius came to a better mind, he should be received. He had, up to the moment of the Council's opening, made things worse. He had taken into his own mouth the blasphemies which before he had sanctioned in his adherent Dorotheus. If one who plainly denied the Incarnation was not fit to be Patriarch of Constantinople, Nestorius had decided against himself. It brought out what lay in his letter to Saint Cyril, which was formally condemned by the Council: that our Lord's relation to God was the same in kind, although not in degree, as that of any devout Christian.162163

The pure humanitarianism of Nestorius was elicited by the attempts of Theodotus of Ancyra, and his pious friend, Acacius, Bishop of Melitene, to bring him back to the faith. To Theodotus and several others, he repeated the well-known blasphemies about our Lord's sacred Infancy and Childhood, that he would not call Him God, who was two or three months old, or who was nurtured at the breast, or who fled into Egypt. This was stated upon oath to the Council. There was nothing further to investigate. It supplied what was yet wanting, the knowledge that Nestorius had not laid aside the heresy, for which he had been condemned the year before. S. Celestine had given the formal advice to S. Cyril, that if Nestorius came to a better mind, he should be received. He had, up to the moment of the opening of the Council, made things worse. He had taken into his own mouth the blasphemies, which before he had sanctioned in his adherent, Dorotheus. If one who nakedly denied the Incarnation was not fit to be Patriarch of Constantinople, Nestorius had decided against himself. It brought out what lay in his letter to S. Cyril which was formally condemned by the Council, that our Lord's relation to God was the same in kind, although not in degree, as that of any devout Christian.162163

There could be no question among anyone who listened to the evidence, just as there was none among those who heard it. He was deposed based on the evidence from his own letter to Saint Cyril, from twenty statements in his acknowledged works, and from contradictions to the faith made in Ephesus itself.

There could be no question among any who listened to the evidence, as there was none among any of those who heard it. He was deposed on the evidence of his own letter to S. Cyril, of twenty sayings in his acknowledged works, and of contradictions to the faith in Ephesus itself.

Saint Celestine had, it appears, gathered a new Synod at Rome, from which he wrote to the Council. The Council itself reported that164

S. Celestine had, it seems, collected a new Synod at Rome, from which he wrote to the Council. The Council itself reported that164

Although the entire body of bishops was prevented from coming to Ephesus because of the distance, they gathered in their own regions under Celestine's leadership and unanimously expressed our position on the faith. Those who did come explained to our Synod by letter the thinking of the whole Western Church.165

' although the whole multitude of Bishops were hindered from coming to Ephesus by the distance, yet being gathered in those parts, they, Celestine presiding, with entire consent, uttered our mind as to the faith. Those who came, explained to this our Synod by letter the mind of the whole Western Church.'165

Philip, a presbyter and Roman legate, declared after reading the Acts that all things had been judged according to the Canons and Ecclesiastical discipline.166

Philip, a presbyter, and Roman legate, after reading the Acts, declared that all things had been adjudged ' according to the Canons and Ecclesiastical discipline.'166

After the representatives of John's party had spent a long time trying to get the Synod's sentence overturned, the Prefect finally wrote to Nestorius.

After long canvass on the part of the deputies of John's party to obtain a rescinding of the sentence of the Synod, the Prefect at last wrote to Nestorius,

We have long delayed what appeared to be accomplished by the judgment of the Synod, even though many people strongly criticized us and urgently pressed for it to happen. But now the letters from your Holiness have been delivered to us, showing that the prolonged stay at Ephesus is unpleasant to you, and that your Religiousness wishes to travel. We have ordered those who should attend to you throughout the entire journey to serve you by sea or land, all the way to your monastery. We do not think you need consolation, given the wisdom of your soul and the countless good qualities with which you are blessed beyond all others.167

' We have delayed long what seemed to be done by the judgment of the Synod, although many greatly blamed us and were instant that it should be. But now the letters of your Holiness have been delivered to us, shewing that the lingering at Ephesus is distasteful to you, and that your Religiousness desires to journey, we have directed those, who ought to minister to you along the whole journey, to minister to you [by sea or land], on the whole way to your monastery…..We do not suppose that you need consolation, considering the wisdom of your soul, and the many thousand goods by which you are endowed above all others.'167

Nestorius in his response accepts as a gift the command to live in his monastery.

Nestorius in his answer accepts as a gift the command to live in his monastery.

For nothing is more honorable to us than being removed for the sake of piety. But I beg your Highness, for the sake of religion, to frequently remind the pious Emperor to publicly note everywhere, through official Imperial letters, the verbosities of Cyril which his Piety has judged against, so that this should be read throughout the orthodox Churches. Otherwise, in the absence of letters from the pious Emperor, if Cyril's writings should be said to be condemned by him, this could cause scandal among the simple believers, as if it were not truly said.168

' For nothing is more honourable to us, than a removal for piety. But I beseech your Highness, for the sake of religion, often to remind the pious Prince to set a note everywhere, by public Imperial letters, on the verbosities of Cyril which his Piety has adjudged, so that it should be read throughout the orthodox Churches, lest in the absence of letters of the pious Emperor, if the writings of Cyril should be said to be condemned by him, an occasion of scandal should arise to the simple, as if it were not said truly.'168

Nestorius does not appear to be troubled by his own deposition, as long as the sentence against Cyril and Memnon is also upheld. This is confirmed by Count John's report to the Emperor that John's party calmly accepted the announcement of Nestorius's deposition when it was issued together with those of Cyril and Memnon.169

Nestorius does not seem to mind his own deposition, so that the sentence against Cyril and Memnon be also confirmed; as Count John reported to the Emperor, that the party of John bore patiently the notice of the deposition of Nestorius, when united with that of Cyril and Memnon.169

The public statement that Nestorius gave was that he was permitted, at his own request, to retire to his monastery, which was located no more than two furlongs outside of Antioch.170

The public account which Nestorius gave, was, that 'he was allowed, at his own request, to retire to his monastery,' which was not more than two furlongs outside of Antioch.170

There, Nestorius says, he 'received all kinds of honors and respectful gifts.'

There, Nestorius says, he 'received all sorts of honours and respectful presents.'

There, he says himself, he stayed for four years. The strong appeal of Saint Celestine to Theodosius to "remove him from all contact with others, so that he might have no opportunity to destroy others" went ignored. After four years, by decree of Theodosius, he was banished to the Oasis. Evagrius provides the detail that his former friend John of Antioch reported to the Emperor his continuing blasphemies, and so "Theodosius condemned him to perpetual banishment."171172

There, he himself says, he remained for four years. The adjuration of S. Celestine to Theodosius to 'remove him from all intercourse [with others], that he might have no facility to destroy others,' remained unheeded. After four years, by the decree of Theodosius, he was banished to the Oasis. Evagrius supplies the fact, that his former friend John of Antioch reported to the Emperor his continued blasphemies, and so 'Theodosius condemned him to perpetual banishment.'171172

He was prevented from spreading his heresy in person, but he could and did write in its defense. The Oasis, where he was finally sent, was not an unpleasant place in itself. However, it was exposed to raids by a hostile tribe, the Blemmyes. The Church had no responsibility for his sufferings there, which resulted from the Emperor's edicts. The Emperor's treatment of him remains unexplained. But these sufferings were God's temporal judgment carried out through the State. The Church bore no guilt for them. Yet since "whom the Lord loveth He chasteneth," they showed that God had not abandoned him to the very end.

He was removed from propagating his heresy personally, but could and did write in defence of it. The Oasis, to which he was finally removed, was a place not unpleasant in itself. It was however open to the incursions of a hostile tribe, the Blemmyes. With his sufferings there, in consequence of edicts of the Emperor, the Church had nothing to do. His treatment by the Emperor is unexplained. But the sufferings were God's temporal judgement inflicted through the State. The Church was guiltless of them. Yet since "whom the Lord loveth He chasteneth," they shewed that God had not abandoned him to the last.

Saint Cyril's relationship with Nestorius ended with the sentence passed against him. His own troubles then began. Saint Cyril himself, upon his arrival, had expected the Council to conclude quickly. The Bishops had urged Saint Cyril to speed up the hearing. Some of the Bishops were burdened by old age; some were in danger of dying from illness; some had already died; some were struggling with poverty. The Council had waited sixteen days after Pentecost, which the Emperor had strictly fixed as the opening date for the Council. The entire Synod had declared that he did not wish to be present. They assumed that he was afraid that the Most Reverend Nestorius, who had been taken from the Church under his authority, would be deposed, and was perhaps embarrassed by the whole affair.173174175

S. Cyril's relation to Nestorius ended with the sentence upon him. His own troubles then began. S. Cyril himself, on his arrival, had anticipated a speedy close of the Council. The Bishops had urged S. Cyril to hasten the hearing. ' Some of the Bishops were weighed down by years; some were in peril of life through illness; some had died; some were straitened by poverty.' The Council had waited 16 days after the day of Pentecost, which the Emperor had peremptorily fixed for the opening of the Council. The whole Synod had exclaimed that he did not wish to be present. They supposed that he feared, ' lest the Most Reverend Nestorius, who had been taken from the Church under his jurisdiction, should be deposed, and was perhaps ashamed of the business.'173174175

John's delay might well have been puzzling in those days when news traveled slowly. He did not explain it to the Council himself, though he did explain it later to the Emperor. There had been a food shortage at Antioch and resulting riots among the people, so much time was lost in departing. Constant rains made the roads poor. The Bishops at Ephesus naturally knew nothing of all this. They knew only that he had chosen the slow land journey instead of coming by sea, and even so, under normal circumstances, he could have arrived on time. Antioch was, by land, only 30 days' journey from Ephesus. From the end of Easter week to Pentecost there are 41 days, and 14 more had passed before there was any news of his arrival. Why would he delay, unless he did not want to be there? Even Eutherius, a Nestorian, thought that he delayed on purpose.176177

John's delay might well be puzzling in those days when tidings travelled slowly. He himself did not explain it to the Council, although he did subsequently to the Emperor. There had been a scarcity at Antioch and consequent tumults among the people, so that much time was wasted in setting out. Incessant rains made the roads bad. Of all this the Bishops at Ephesus naturally knew nothing. They knew only that he had chosen the slow land-journey instead of coming by sea, and even thus, under ordinary circumstances, he might have been punctual. Antioch was, by land, only 30 days' journey from Ephesus. From the close of Easter-week to Pentecost there are 41 days, and 14 more had elapsed before there was any notice of his arrival. Why should he delay, except that he did not wish to be there? Even Eutherius, a Nestorian, thought that he delayed on purpose.176177

According to John's statement, Cyril wrote to him two days before the Council opened, saying that the whole Council was waiting for his arrival. Cyril intended, then, to wait for him. Modern scholars describe Cyril as arbitrary, but no one has dared to say he was inconsistent. Therefore, something must have happened that caused him to give in to the bishops' wishes. The change would make sense if Cyril had meanwhile learned about the attitude in which the Antiochenes were coming to the Council. They made no secret of it. Their representatives may have informed Cyril. Theodoret, who was one of them and who at that time used Nestorianizing language that was condemned at the Fifth General Council, says,

According to the statement of John, S. Cyril wrote to him two days before the opening of the Council, that the whole Council was awaiting his arrival. He meant then to wait for him. Moderns speak of S. Cyril as arbitrary; no one has ventured to say he was fickle. Something then must have intervened, which occasioned him to yield to the wish of the Bishops. The change would be explained, if S. Cyril had come in the meantime to know of the mind, in which the Antiochenes were coming to the Council. They made no secret of it. Their deputies may have informed S. Cyril. Theodoret, who was one of them, and who at that time used Nestorianising language which was condemned at the 5th General Council, says,

Before we left for Ephesus, the blessed John wrote to the most God-beloved Bishop Eutherius of Tyana, Firmus of Caesarea, and Theodotus of Ancyra, calling these Chapters the teaching of Apollinarius. At Ephesus, our basis for deposing the bishop of Alexandria and the bishop of Ephesus was the setting forth and confirmation of the Chapters. Many synodical letters were written to the victorious Emperor, the high magistrates, and likewise to the people at Constantinople and the most reverend clergy. Moreover, when we were summoned to Constantinople, we held five formal meetings in the presence of the Emperor himself, and afterward we sent three protests to him.178

' Before we departed to Ephesus, the blessed John wrote to the most-God-beloved Bishop Eutherius of Tyana, and Firmus of Caesarea, and Theodotus of Ancyra, calling these Chapters, teaching of Apollinarius. And at Ephesus our deposing him of Alexandria and him of Ephesus had for its ground the setting forth and confirmation of the Chapters. And there were many Synodical letters written to the Victorious Emperor, and the High Magistrates, and in like way to the people at Constantinople, and the most reverend Clergy. And moreover, when summoned to Constantinople, we had five resolutions in the presence of the Emperor himself, and we sent three protests to him subsequently.'178

These accusations were the core substance of the various documents issued by John's irregular council. Naturally, violation of the Emperor's commands was placed first; but no assembly calling itself a Synod could have deposed a Patriarch and a Bishop simply for ignoring or violating an Emperor's orders. The heresy that was claimed could be the only basis for deposition. John presented this in the preamble that was accepted by his irregular council.

These charges were the pith of the different documents put forth by John's Conciliabulum. Of course, contravention of the Emperor's orders was put in the forefront; but no assembly, calling itself a Synod, could have deposed a Patriarch and a Bishop for neglecting or contravening the orders of an Emperor. The heresy alleged could be the only ground of deposition. John set forth this in the preamble which was accepted by his Conciliabulum.

I wish that none of those set apart as priests of God should be cast out of the Church. But since cutting off incurable members is necessary for the health of the whole body, it is fitting that Cyril and Memnon should be deposed as the leaders of the recent lawlessness and of the trampling upon ecclesiastical ordinances and the pious decrees of our most pious Emperor, and because of the heretical meaning of the aforementioned Chapters, and that those under their authority should be excommunicated until, recognizing their offense, they anathematize the heretical Chapters of Cyril and agree to abide by the holy faith set forth by the holy fathers assembled at Nicaea, not adding anything other than it or foreign to godliness, and come together according to the pious letter of our most pious Emperor and examine as brothers the subjects under investigation, and establish the pious faith.179

' I would that no one of those set apart as priests of God should be cast out of the Church. But since the excision of incurable members is necessary for the health of the whole body, it is meet that Cyril and Memnon should be deposed, as the chiefs of the past lawlessness and of the trampling upon Ecclesiastical ordinances and the pious decrees of our most pious Emperor, and on account of the heretical meaning of the aforesaid Chapters, and that those subject to them should be excommunicated, until, recognizing their offence, they anathematize the heretical Chapters of Cyril, and agree to abide by the holy faith set forth by the holy fathers assembled at Nice, not superadding any thing other than it or foreign to godliness, and come together according to the pious letter of our most pious Emperor and examine as brothers the subjects of enquiry, and establish the pious faith.'179

This same tone appears throughout every document from John's assembly.180

This same note sounds throughout, in every document of John's Conciliabulum.180

If Cyril had any knowledge of this attitude among the Antiochenes, it explains his sudden decision not to wait for them but to grant the wishes of the other bishops and open the Council without them. The mind of the Church had been expressed the previous year. The Council itself was only a scheme by Nestorius to avoid his condemnation. He had already been cut off from communion with the greater part of Christendom. The Council represented the whole West, North Africa, Egypt, Jerusalem, Macedonia, Illyricum, Pontus, Cappadocia, and Armenia. The fifteen or seventeen bishops with John of Antioch, even if united with the ten or fifteen bishops with Nestorius, were only a small fraction of the Church. No injustice was done to Nestorius. But serious confusion and scandal might have followed John's arrival. If John had brought into the Council the charge of heresy that his Conciliabulum so persistently alleged against Cyril and Memnon, it would have fallen to Candidian, the friend of Nestorius, to decide in what order the charges should be heard. Candidian threw himself so completely onto John's side—even intercepting the Council's report to the Emperor—that he would undoubtedly have given priority to the charge of heresy against Cyril. What the result would have been, only He can know Who sees the things that have not happened as if they had happened. We cannot describe what has not happened, since God alone knows the hearts He made and how they would have responded under trials He spared them. But Nestorius had shown himself skilled at inflicting violence, as Dioscorus had not up to the eve of the Latrocinium. The soldiers of Theodosius had little respect for bishops. Those who carried the news of Nestorius's deposition to Count Irenaeus brought back to the Council the marks of their mistreatment. Nestorius had brought his own guard of soldiers and a large number of peasants and others from the worst parts of Constantinople. Candidian had drawn troops from the garrison at Tripoli in Lydia. It has been noted that the sailors who brought Cyril were ready to support him, and the peasants from the lands of the see of Ephesus to support Memnon. The entire population of Ephesus was enthusiastic for the ancient doctrine, as they showed by their overflowing joy when the sentence for which they had waited from morning to evening was announced.181182183184

If S. Cyril had any intimation of this mind of the Antiochenes, it accounts for his sudden resolve not to wait for them, but to accede to the wishes of the other Bishops and open the Council without them. The mind of the Church had been expressed in the previous year. The Council itself was only a device of Nestorius to ward off his condemnation. He had already been severed from the Communion of the greater part of Christendom. The Council represented the whole West, North Africa, Egypt, Jerusalem, Macedonia, Illyricum, Pontus, Cappadocia, Armenia. The 15 or 17 Bishops of John of Antioch, even if united with the 10 or 15 Bishops of Nestorius, were but a fraction of the Church. No injustice was done to Nestorius. But grave confusion and scandal might have ensued upon John's arrival. If John had brought into the Council the charge of heresy, which his Conciliabulum alleged so perseveringly against S. Cyril and Memnon, it would have rested with Candidian, the friend of Nestorius, to rule in what order the charges should be taken. Candidian threw himself so entirely into John's side (even in intercepting the Relation of the Council to the Emperor), that he would, without doubt, have preferred the charge of heresy against S. Cyril. What the result would have been, He only can know, Who sees the things which have not been, as if they had been. We cannot write the things which have not been, since God Alone knows the hearts which He made, and how they would have developed under trials which He spared. But Nestorius had shewn himself practised in inflicting violence, as Dioscorus up to the eve of the Latrocinium had not. Soldiers of Theodosius had not much respect for Bishops. Those who carried the news of the deposition of Nestorius to Count Irenaeus brought back to the Council the marks of their ill-treatment. Nestorius had brought his own guard of soldiers and a great number of peasants and others from the worst parts of Constantinople. Candidian had drawn troops from the garrison at Tripoli in Lydia. It has been noticed that the seamen who brought S. Cyril were ready to support him, and the peasantry of the lands of the see of Ephesus to support Memnon. The whole population of Ephesus were enthusiastic in behalf of the ancient doctrine, as they shewed by their exuberant joy, when the sentence, for which they had waited from morning to evening, was announced.181182183184

We can't know anything more about this beyond speculation. However, the second Council of Ephesus, which became known as the Latrocinium under Dioscorus's leadership, was convened with just as much legitimacy as the first Council.

It would be mere matter of imagination to picture anything further. But the second Council of Ephesus, which became the Latrocinium under the guidance of Dioscorus, was called just as legitimately as the first.

However this may have been, it doesn't require much humility to think that Cyril, in the midst of the events, knew more than we do, since we see them only through some fragmentary records of the past. Even apart from the threat posed by Candidian, someone as far-sighted as Cyril must have known that he would incur the serious displeasure of Theodosius by overriding his orders, that there was a strong prima facie case against him for violating them, and that the Emperor, who had written to him as he had, was not one to be trifled with. Yet he braved it all. It was important to the Church that the heresy of Nestorius should be condemned. Once the sentence was passed it could not be reversed, because the whole Church except the Antiochenes agreed with it.

However this may have been, it does not require much humility to think that S. Cyril, in the midst of the events, knew more than we, who see them only through some fragmentary records of the past. Even apart from the menace of Candidian, one so long-sighted as S. Cyril must have known that he would incur the grave displeasure of Theodosius, by superseding his orders; that there was a strong prima-facie case of contravening them against him; and that the Emperor, who had written to him as he had, was not one to be trifled with. Yet he braved it all. It was of moment to the Church, that the heresy of Nestorius should be condemned. The sentence once passed could not be reversed; because the whole Church except the Antiochenes agreed in it.

So Cyril agreed to the Council's wish not to delay, and faced the Emperor's displeasure, expecting it to fall on himself alone.

So S. Cyril assented to the wish of the Council not to delay, and braved the Emperor's displeasure, expecting it to fall on himself alone.

His earthly future, after the Council ended, remained uncertain for some time. Candidian sent an unfavorable report to the Emperor; John's Conciliabulum sent their complaints as if they had been the Council; Nestorius sent his account; Cyril was not heard. Theodosius first condemned the condemnation of Nestorius, annulled the proceedings of the Council, and forbade any bishop to leave Ephesus, to come to his court, or to return home. The supporters of Nestorius in Constantinople prevented any news of his deposition from arriving either by sea or by land. Candidian blocked access from a distance. Cyril's deposition by John's Conciliabulum was reported at Constantinople as if it were the act of the Council; consequently, Cyril understood that it was being deliberated at court whether he should be banished.185186187188189190191192

His earthly future, after the Council was over, remained for some time in the balance. Candidian sent to the Emperor an adverse report; John's Conciliabulum sent their complaints, as if they had been the Council; Nestorius sent his account; S. Cyril was not heard. Theodosius first condemned the condemnation of Nestorius; annulled the proceedings of the Council; forbade any Bishop to leave Ephesus, to come to his Court or to return home. The adherents of Nestorius in Constantinople hindered any tidings of his deposition coming both by sea and by land: Candidian precluded access at a distance. S. Cyril's deposition by John's Conciliabulum was reported at Constantinople, as if it were the act of the Council; it was (S. Cyril understood) consequently deliberated at Court, whether he should not be banished.185186187188189190191192

His deposition was accepted, and he himself was placed under guard, with soldiers stationed even at his bedroom door. Memnon wrote that they were sometimes deprived of necessities and were insulted by the country people and the mob that Nestorius had brought with him. S. Cyril was at peace. He wrote,193194

His deposition was accepted, and he himself put under a guard of soldiers placed even at his bedroom door. Memnon wrote, that they were sometimes deprived of necessaries, were insulted by the rustics and the rabble which Nestorius had brought. S. Cyril was at peace. He wrote,193194

Since the letter from the most religious and Christ-loving Emperors has been read, stating that the deposition of the three was to be accepted, we have been held under guard, not knowing what the outcome will be. But we give thanks to God if we are thought worthy for His Name's sake not only to be prisoners, but also to endure everything else besides. For it is not without its reward—as the blessed David says, "I am ready for the scourge."195

' Since the letter of the most religious and Christ-loving Emperors has been read, in which it was said that the deposing of the three was to be accepted, we have been kept in ward, not knowing what will be the issue. But we give thanks to God, if we be thought worthy for His Name's sake not to be prisoners only, but also to endure all besides. For it is not without its reward.—-As the blessed David says, "I am ready for the scourge." '195

At the request of the Council, he used the free time during his imprisonment to explain his Anathematisms.196

At the wish of the Council, he employed the leisure of his imprisonment in explaining his Anathematisms.196

The Conciliabulum, when sending out 'the Alexandrian's new exposition of the heretical chapters,' said that he 'thereby showed his impiety more clearly.' They were even surprised that the Council kept going, despite the fact that Cyril and Memnon were imprisoned. They write as a Synod,197

The Conciliabulum, in transmitting 'the Alexandrian's new exposition of the heretical chapters,' said that he 'thereby shewed his impiety more evidently.' They even wondered at the perseverance of the Council, notwithstanding the imprisonment of Cyril and Memnon. They write as a Synod,197

Count John is keeping Cyril and Memnon under very strict guard, separating each one and placing many soldiers around each man's house. Yet even this has not quieted those who turn everything upside down and have filled the world with confusion and rebellion. Instead, acting as they usually do, they create disorder and set in motion a rule against themselves. For though they have been excommunicated, they have boldly taken upon themselves the ministry of the priesthood, and so on.198

' Count John holds in most guarded custody Cyril and Memnon, thrusting [detrudens] each apart, and placing a multitude of soldiers around the house of each. Yet not even thus are they still, who turn every thing upside down and have filled the world with confusion and sedition, but acting as usual, make a confusion, and set in motion a rule against themselves. For, being excommunicated, they have audaciously assumed to themselves the ministry of the priesthood, &c.'198

And again in their letter to Acacius of Beroea,

And again in their Epistle to Acacius of Berrhoea,

Your Religiousness should know that they [the Bishops of the Council] have been excommunicated by us because they cooperated with the insanity of the heretic Cyril and what he did unlawfully and wickedly, and have presumed to exercise their office and to communicate with the condemned. And they commit these things knowing that those most harmful persons Cyril and Memnon have been thrust away and are kept under guard by a multitude of soldiers. For thrusting each one apart, they guard them night and day; therefore let your Holiness pray, etc.199

' Your Religiousness should know that they [the Bishops of the Council] have been excommunicated by us, because they co-operated with the insanity of the heretic Cyril and what he did unlawfully and iniquitously, and have presumed to exercise their office and to communicate with the condemned.—-And these things they commit, knowing that those most injurious persons Cyril and Memnon have been thrust [trusi] away and are kept by a multitude of soldiers. For thrusting [trudentes] each apart, they guard them night and day; wherefore let your Holiness pray &c.'199

The Bishops of the Council also appear to have believed that the Nestorianizers intended to exhaust them in order to reverse what they had accomplished. A short statement at the end of their letter to the Clergy of Constantinople says,

The Bishops of the Council seem also to have thought that it was the intention of the Nestorianisers to wear them out to undo what they had done. A brief memorial at the end of their letter to the Clergy of Constantinople says,

We are dying from the heat because of the oppressive atmosphere, and nearly every day someone is buried. All the servants have been sent home, and all the other bishops are in the same condition. Therefore, we ask your Reverences to go to the gracious Emperor and tell him that the Synod is being oppressed by those who refuse to allow any deadline to be set, so that we are completely dying from exhaustion. But your Reverences should know that even if they pressure us until we all die, we will not decree anything other than what our Savior Christ has taught us.200

' We are being killed with the heat through the heaviness of the air, and some one is buried almost daily; so that all the servants are sent home, and all the other Bishops are in the same state. Whence we pray your Reverences to go to the gracious Sovereign and say that the Synod is oppressed by those, who prevent any term being given, so that we are altogether perishing by exhaustion. But your Reverences should know, that although they press upon us till we all die, we will not do any thing other than our Saviour Christ has taught us to decree.'200

The barrier was set up with complete security to prevent any news from the Council from reaching the Emperor's ears. It was broken through by a beggar. The clergy of Constantinople wrote,

The cordon was drawn with all safety to hinder any report from the Council reaching the Emperor's ears. It was snapped by a mendicant. The Clergy of Constantinople wrote,

Since no one can do anything against God (for what is man?), by God's ordering a letter written from Ephesus arrived to the holy bishops and monks, sent by a beggar who tied it inside a reed and thus, begging and carrying his reed, brought it. Immediately all the monasteries with the archimandrites rose up and went to the palace. The holy Dalmatius, one of the archimandrites, had not left his monastery for forty-eight years but remained enclosed. Our most pious emperor went to him and saw him. Since there were frequent earthquakes in Constantinople, the emperor often asked him to come out and say litanies, but he never would. But when he was praying about this matter, a voice came down from heaven commanding him to go out. For God did not want His flock to perish utterly.201

' Since no one can do any thing against God (for what is man?), by the ordering of God there arrived an Epistle written from Ephesus to the holy Bishops and monks sent by a beggar who tied it within a reed, and thus, begging and carrying his reed, brought it. Forthwith all the monasteries with the Archimandrites arose and went to the palace. The holy Dalmatius, one of the Archimandrites, had not left his monastery for 48 years, but remained enclosed. Our most pious Emperor went to him and saw him. There being ofttimes earthquakes in Constantinople, the Emperor ofttimes requested him to come forth and say litanies; he never would. But when he was praying about this, a voice came down from heaven bidding him go forth. For He did not will that His flock should perish utterly.'201

The Archimandrites were admitted and prevailed. Theodosius learned with surprise that while the Nestorians had free access to come and go, the deputies of the Council had been refused access to him.202

The Archimandrites, who were admitted, prevailed. Theodosius learnt with surprise that while the Nestorians had free ingress and regress, the deputies of the Council had been refused access to him.202

The Emperor tried unsuccessfully to reconcile the Antiochenes with St. Cyril.

The Emperor tried in vain to reconcile the Antiochenes with S. Cyril.

The Antiochenes, in their third indignant protest, reproached the Emperor for ignoring their obedience and reminded him that the East was no small part of his Empire. They warned that he needed the true faith to prevail in the war then engulfing Africa, that God would fight for him if he would defend the holy faith, and that He would not allow the body of the Church to be cut off—yet it would be cut off if the meaning imposed upon the faith by Cyril and confirmed by others were allowed to stand. They claimed that people mixed in with the Churches were teaching the doctrine of Apollinarius, Arius, and Eunomius, and were unlawfully and irregularly exercising the priesthood. They concluded with a prayer that he would not allow anything to be secretly introduced against the faith of the holy fathers who met at Nicaea. If, after this warning before God, the Emperor did not comply, they declared—echoing Saint Paul—that they shook off the dust from their feet against them, saying, "We are clean from the blood of all men." "We have not stopped, night and day, from the time we arrived at the holy Synod, protesting to the Emperor, judges, soldiers, priests, and laymen not to be betrayers of the faith handed down by the fathers."203

The Antiochenes, in their third indignant protest, reproached the Emperor with their obedience, reminded him that the East was no small part of his Empire, that he needed the true faith to prevail in the war which then encircled Africa, that God would fight for him, if he would defend the holy faith, and would not allow the body of the Church to be cut of, but it would be cut off, if the meaning superinduced on the faith by Cyril and confirmed by others should stand; that persons intermixed with the Churches taught the doctrine of Apollinarius and Arius and Eunomius, and unlawfully and irregularly exercised the office of the priesthood. They conclude with the prayer that he would not allow any thing to be stealthily introduced against the faith of the holy fathers who met at Nice. If after this admonition before God the Emperor did not acquiesce, they 'with S. Paul shook off the dust from their feet against them, saying, "We are clean from the blood of all men." "We have not ceased night and day, from the time we came to the holy Synod to protest to the Emperor, Judges, soldiers, priests, and laymen, not to be the betrayers of the faith delivered by the fathers.'203

It was a destructive internal conflict that continued even after the Eastern bishops returned to their sees. The Easterns still absolutely demanded the deposition of Cyril, Memnon, and all their supporters, and that their teaching should be condemned.

It was an internecine war, continued even after the return of the Eastern Bishops to their sees; the Easterns still absolutely demanded the deposition of S. Cyril Memnon and all their adherents, and that their teaching should be proscribed.

When Cyril returned to Egypt, he demonstrated his peace-loving character. The Orientals had caused his imprisonment, its hardships and humiliations, and the threat of exile. They did this by mimicking a Council, but without the proper procedures of a Council and without investigating what the real Council had actually done. They assumed the real Council had done what it had not—that is, formally approved the Anathematisms that Cyril had written not as a rule of faith but to block the evasions of Nestorius, and that these Anathemas were heretical. They convinced the Emperor that their 40 Bishops, who represented only one Patriarchate, were the Council of the whole world that he had called together. Until they realized it was pointless to mention Nestorius's name to the Emperor, they pressed for his restoration and Cyril's deposition. Cyril had escaped in spite of their efforts. They refused to accept that Nestorius was the heretic he actually was, and they kept repeating that Cyril was an Arian, Eunomian, Apollinarian, even though they must have known that he was at least neither Eunomian nor Arian.204

S. Cyril shewed his peace-loving disposition on his return to Egypt. The Orientals had brought upon him his imprisonment, its privations and indignities, and the prospect of banishment. This they had done by aping a Council, yet without the formalities of a Council, without enquiring into anything which the real Council had done, assuming that they had done what they had not done—-formally sanctioned the Anathematisms which S. Cyril had framed, not as a rule of faith but to cut off the evasions of Nestorius, and that these Anathemas were heretical. They had persuaded the Emperor, that their 40 Bishops, who represented one Patriarchate, were the Council of the whole world, which he had convoked. Until they found it useless to mention the name of Nestorius to the Emperor, they urged his restoration and the deposition of S. Cyril. He had escaped in despite of them. They would not be persuaded that Nestorius was the heretic which he was; and they would repeat that S. Cyril was an Arian, Eunomian, Apollinarian, although they must have known that at the least he was neither Eunomian nor Arian.204

There was nothing Saint Cyril could do regarding them. They had fallen into the trap Nestorius had set by sending the Anathemas, which were meant to test his own sincerity, without the Epistle that would have explained them. It became a fixed principle for Theodoret that the Anathemas were heretical. Saint Cyril could only wait. Saint Sixtus III, a peace-loving bishop who had succeeded Saint Celestine, testifies that Cyril immediately showed how mindful he was of the faith and how unconcerned he was with the insults he suffered gloriously, according to the Apostle. Cyril wanted the Churches to be well-ordered rather than seeking vindication for himself. Since one person (Nestorius) had shipwrecked himself, Cyril was eager that all the rest should be saved from the waves. Sixtus writes: "We share the same mind: to act gently toward them when they stop being impious toward God. Let those who wish to return to the right way be received." He addresses Saint Cyril himself,

There was nothing then for S. Cyril to do in regard to them. They had fallen into the trap which Nestorius had laid for them by sending the Anathemas meant to test his own sincerity, without the Epistle which would have explained them. It became an axiom with Theodoret that they were heretical. S. Cyril then could but wait. S. Sixtus iii., a peace-loving Bishop who had succeeded S. Celestine, bears him witness that he had shewed at once how mindful he was of the faith and how regardless of contumelies, which he suffered gloriously, according to the Apostle, wishing that the Churches should be well-ordered, rather than that he should be righted himself; that one [Nestorius] having wrecked himself, he was anxious that all the rest should be saved out of the waves. 'The same mind is in us also; to act tenderly towards them, when they cease to be impious towards God. Let those then, who will to return to the right way, be received.' He addresses S. Cyril himself,

Hold on firmly, dearly beloved brother, to what has been accomplished by the Council and what has been decided by us. For a brother sets aside insults that benefit him before the Lord of all. Such insult is actually victory. Therefore he has endured all the harsh attacks patiently, and those things did not trouble him in which he now rejoices, because he was striving for a crown. He knows what rewards await the victors in such struggles.205

' Hold fast, most beloved brother, what has been done by the Council, and what has been defined by us. For a brother dismisses contumelies which benefit him before the Lord of all. For such contumely is victory. Whence he has borne meekly all the sharp blows, nor did those things grieve him, wherein he now rejoices; for he strove for a crown. For he knows what prizes are in store for the victors in such conflicts.'205

Sixtus completely agreed with Cyril, but spoke forcefully: "Let him [John] know that he will be one of the Catholic body only if, by reversing everything that was undone by the Synod, he shows himself to be a Catholic priest."

S. Sixtus coincided altogether with S. Cyril, but spoke strongly; 'let him [John] know that he shall be one of the Catholic body, if, undoing all undone by the Synod, he shew himself a Catholic priest.'

Cyril required nothing for himself. The bishops whom the Emperor assembled at Constantinople proposed the terms, which greatly pleased the Emperor.

S. Cyril required nothing for himself. The Bishops, whom the Emperor assembled at Constantinople, propounded the terms, at which the Emperor was 'exceedingly pleased.'

The devout Bishop John of Antioch must anathematize the doctrine of Nestorius and acknowledge his deposition in writing. Once this is done, the Bishop of Alexandria will, out of love, completely forget and consider as nothing the insults he suffered at Ephesus, even though they were very serious and difficult to bear.206

' The Bishop, full of piety, John of Antioch, must anathematise the doctrine of Nestorius, and acknowledge in writing his deposition; and this being done, the Bishop of Alexandria will, out of love, forget altogether and regard as nothing the contumelies which he endured at Ephesus, very grievous as they were, and hard to endure.'206

John's party would not accept these terms. The first conditions for peace from John's side, which Aristolaus, the Emperor's deputy, selected as the mildest option, were in reality conditions of unconditional submission.207

John's party would not accept them. The first conditions of peace on John's side, which Aristolaus, the Emperor's deputy, selected as the mildest, were in fact, of unconditional submission.207

The terms were,

The terms were,

We recognize the Nicene Creed as sufficient, but the letter of St. Athanasius to Epictetus explains its meaning. We therefore stand by it and reject all teachings that have been recently introduced, whether through letters or chapters, as disturbing the common faith.208

' We acknowledge the Nicene Creed as sufficient, but the letter of S. Athanasius to Epictetus explains its meaning. We abide therefore therein, and cast off all doctrines recently superinduced, either by Epistles or Chapters, as disturbing the common faith:'208

In other words, he was to acknowledge that he, not Nestorius, had been the one who disturbed the Church. Cyril most gladly received the Epistle to Epictetus, but showed them that their own copies had been corrupted by heretics. As for the rest, he said that withdrawing what he had written would mean taking back everything that had been said against the heresy of Nestorius. He was, in fact, expected to withdraw by his own single action those Epistles—one of which had been accepted by the Council of Ephesus both individually and as a body, while the other, with the anathemas, had been placed among its Acts with no one objecting—and undo his entire work at the command of John and five other bishops.209210211

i. e. he was to acknowledge that he, not Nestorius, had been the disturber of the Church. S. Cyril most gladly received the Epistle to Epictetus, but shewed them that their own copies had been corrupted by heretics. For the rest, he said that to withdraw what he had written would be to unsay all which had been said against the heresy of Nestorius. He was, in fact, to withdraw by his single act Epistles, of which one had been accepted by the Council of Ephesus, individually and as a body, the other, with the anathemas, had been placed among its Acts (no one excepting), and undo his whole work at the dictum of John and five other Bishops.209210211

The Orientals then chose a wiser envoy, Paul of Emesa. Yet even him they burdened with complaints, 'as if some things had been said and done wrongly' at the Synod. This brought about the only reminder of past ill-treatment: 'They who ought to seek pardon for the past, how do they add fresh insults?' When these complaints were withdrawn, S. Cyril says, 'we were filled with gladness of heart,' and 'contrary perhaps to his expectations,' Paul found him fully ready for peace. S. Cyril's account shows how deeply he felt the division as a work of Satan. He accepted at once a Confession, written (John said in his letter to S. Cyril) 'by us in harmony.' He gave to Paul a statement of faith, which John accepted. Paul preached in the great Church of Alexandria. 'The people cried out, This is the Faith, the gift of God, orthodox Cyril. This we sought to hear.' S. Cyril wrote to John the joyful letter, beginning with the words of the Psalm, 'Let the heavens rejoice and the earth be glad. For the middle-wall of partition is dissolved; what caused sadness has ceased; all manner of discord is removed. For Christ, the Saviour of us all, has bestowed peace upon all His Churches.'212213214215

The Orientals then selected a wiser envoy, Paul of Emesa. Yet even him they burthened with complaints, 'as if some things had been said and done wrongly' in the Synod. This occasioned the only reminiscence of the past ill-treatment, ' They who ought to seek pardon for the past, how do they add fresh contumelies?' When these were withdrawn, S. Cyril says, 'we were filled with gladness of heart;' and 'contrary perhaps to his expectations,' Paul found him fully disposed for peace. S. Cyril's relation shews how deeply he felt the rent as a work of Satan. He accepted at once a Confession, written (John said in his letter to S. Cyril) 'by us in harmony.' He gave to Paul a statement of faith, which John accepted. Paul preached in the great Church of Alexandria. 'The people cried out, This is the Faith, the gift of God, orthodox Cyril. This we sought to hear.' S. Cyril wrote to John the exulting letter, beginning with the words of the Psalm, 'Let the heavens rejoice and the earth be glad. For the middle-wall of partition is dissolved; what saddened has ceased; all manner of discord is removed. For Christ, the Saviour of us all, has bestowed peace upon all His Churches.'212213214215

He says, in a kind of undertone to Maximian who had succeeded Nestorius,216

He says, in a sort of under-tone to Maximian who had succeeded Nestorius,216

He says, speaking as if in private to Maximian who had succeeded Nestorius: "Strife and contention do not rule among us. Instead, we all have one goal, aiming for peace. If those who from the beginning disagreed with us and separated themselves from us had been willing, there would have been no strife or division among the churches. But blessed be the Savior, who has calmed the storm, and so on."

'Strife and contention reign not among us, but we have all one mark, looking to peace. And if those who from the first have differed in opinion from us and cut themselves off from us, had willed, there would have been no strife or difference among the Churches. But blessed be the Saviour, Who hath lulled the storm &c.'

It was Cyril's lot, then as now, to be misunderstood. He was blamed for making peace, just as he had been blamed earlier for the conflict. Theodoret could not help but accept the approval of his own synodal letter, but he believed it directly contradicted the Twelve Chapters. Writing to "his lord and truly God-loving and venerable holy father Nestorius," he apologizes for the peace and assures him that he holds Cyril in abhorrence as the author of all the disturbance throughout the whole world. The Nestorianizers were of course very angry, but he had to explain himself even to his old friend Acacius of Melitene and to others as well. The man whom the Orientals had so relentlessly persecuted was now their defender, showing that they were not Nestorians and patiently trying to win back to the communion of the Church individuals who were still alienated.217218219

It was S. Cyril's lot, then as now, to be misunderstood. He was blamed as to the peace, as, before, for the conflict. Theodoret could not but acquiesce in the acceptance of his own Synodal letter, but held it to be directly contradictory of the twelve Chapters. To his lord and truly God-loving and venerable holy father Nestorius' he apologises for the peace, and assures him, that he holds Cyril in abhorrence, as being the author of all the disturbance of the whole world. The Nestorianizers were of course very angry; but he had to explain himself, even to his old friend Acacius of Melitene as also to others. He whom the Orientals had so unrelentingly persecuted was now their defender, shewing that they were not Nestorians, and trying patiently to win back to the Communion of the Church individuals still alienated.217218219

He had to endure something even more difficult: the reproaches of S. Isidore, for whom he had a son's affection. S. Isidore had earlier told him about the mockery of many at Ephesus, as if he were acting out of personal hostility rather than seeking, as an orthodox believer, the things of Jesus Christ. For they said, "He is a nephew of Theophilus."220221

He had to bear what was still harder, the reproaches of S. Isidore, to whom he had a filial affection. S. Isidore had told him before of 'the jeers of many at Ephesus, as if thou wert wreaking thine own enmity, and not seeking, as one orthodox, the things of Jesus Christ. For, say they, he is a nephew of Theophilus.'220221

He had explained to him again the faith concerning the Incarnation as something "you yourself would not deny," and now, when St. Cyril had accepted that same statement as Isidore presented it, Isidore wrote,222

He had again set forth to him the faith of the Incarnation as something which 'thou thyself wouldest not deny,' and now, when S. Cyril had himself accepted the same statement as propounded by him, he wrote,222

Amazing man, you should remain always consistent, not betraying heavenly things or appearing to contradict yourself. For if you compare what you have now written with your earlier writings, you will appear guilty of flattery or of being a servant of carelessness, giving in to vain-glory, instead of imitating the struggles of all those great holy fighters who endured mistreatment their whole lives in a foreign land rather than even listen to a single thought of evil doctrine.223

' Wondrous man, thou oughtest to remain ever unchanged, not betraying the things of heaven, nor appearing contradictory to thyself. For if thou comparest what thou hast now written with thy former writings, thou wilt seem chargeable with flattery, or the minister of off-handed ness, yielding to vain-glory, instead of imitating the strivings of all those great holy combatants, who endured to be ill-treated all their life in a foreign land, rather than even hear a thought of evil doctrine.'223

Saint Isidore, in his eagerness for Saint Cyril's spiritual growth, appears to have written to him based on what others had said. It must have been difficult to be so unfairly criticized by a saint, but Saint Cyril seems to have accepted the undeserved rebuke in silence.

S. Isidore, in his zeal for S. Cyril's perfecting, seems to have written to him according to the sayings of others. It must have been hard to be so unjustly blamed by a saint, but S. Cyril seems to have received the undeserved censure in silence.

One more occasion is recorded when he was asked to give a public statement about the writings of Theodore of Mopsuestia.

One more occasion is recorded in which a public expression of opinion was asked of him, as to the writings of Theodore of Mopsuestia.

The Council, while avoiding his name, had already condemned one of his creeds, which some Nestorians had presented to many Quartodecimans and Novatians who wished to return to the Church. St. Proclus sent John of Antioch a document containing Nestorian passages from Theodore (equally avoiding his name), asking him to have them condemned. Maximus, the messenger, contrary to his instructions, inserted the name. After this, the Antiochenes would not condemn the passages, even without the name. Maximus, an archimandrite, came to Alexandria, "speaking much and strongly" against the Easterners, saying "the orthodox have no room there nor freedom to speak the faith." A high-ranking palace official presented to St. Cyril, when at Jerusalem, a long letter from many clergy, monks, and lay people, accusing the Eastern bishops that they, while suppressing Nestorius' name, claimed to oppose him, yet clung to Theodore's books on the Incarnation, in which lie many more serious blasphemies than those of Nestorius. For he was the father of Nestorius' false teachings, and by speaking his words, the ungodly man is in his present condition. The Alexandrians, having refused to sign St. Proclus' document, appealed to St. Cyril. St. Cyril indignantly rejected any similarity between "the disreputable doctrine of Diodore and Theodore" and that of the great fathers whom John cited. To John of Antioch he wrote that no one should speak Theodore's ungodly doctrines in church, but he emphasized the gentleness with which those returning should be received, and not be reproached for the past. To Proclus, he wrote that Theodore had died in communion with the Church; that in rejecting his creed the Council had deliberately spared his name, lest some should separate from the Church; that in rejecting Nestorius' blasphemies they had effectively condemned what resembled them; that if it could be done without disturbance, it would be best for the sake of others; but since John of Antioch wrote that "they would rather be burned with fire than do anything of that sort, why should we fan the stilled flame?" He added that those who wished the writings condemned might be persuaded to be quiet rather than cause scandal to the Church. To Maximus, who would not commune with John because of some suspected of Nestorianism, he wrote urging the reception of those willing to return to communion, even though ashamed to admit their fall.224225226227228229230231232

The Council, while sparing his name, had already condemned a Creed of his, which had been presented by some Nestorians to many Quartodecimans and Novatians who wished to return to the Church. S. Proclus sent to John of Antioch a Tome containing Nestorian passages of Theodore (equally sparing his name), requesting him to have them condemned. Maximus, the bearer, contrary to his instructions, inserted the name. The Antiochenes, after this, would not condemn the passages, even without the name. Maximus, an Archimandrite, came to Alexandria, 'speaking much and strongly' against the Easterns, the 'orthodox have no room there nor freedom to speak the faith.' ' A noble officer of the Palace presented to S. Cyril, when at Jerusalem, a long Epistle of many Clergy and monks and laity, accusing the Eastern Bishops, that they, suppressing the name of Nestorius, professed to be averse to him, and bounded down to the books of Theodore on the Incarnation, in which lie many more grievous blasphemies than those of Nestorius. For he was the father of the ill-doctrines of Nestorius, and by speaking his words, the ungodly man is in his present condition.' The Alexandrians, having refused to sign the Tome of S. Proclus, appealed to S. Cyril. S. Cyril indignantly set aside any likeness of 'the ill-reputed doctrine of Diodore and Theodore' to that of the great fathers whom John alleged. To John of Antioch he wrote, that no one should utter in Church the ungodly doctrines of Theodore; but he dwelt on the tenderness, with which those returning should be received, and not be reproached for the past: to Proclus, that Theodore had died in the communion of the Church; that in rejecting his Creed the Council had purposely spared his name, lest some should separate from the Church; that in rejecting the blasphemies of Nestorius they had virtually condemned what was like them; that if it could be done without disturbance, it would be best for the sake of others; but that since John of Antioch wrote, that 'they would rather be burned with fire than do anything of that sort, why should we fan the stilled flame?' that those who wished the writings to be condemned might be persuaded to be quiet rather than give occasion of scandal to the Church. To Maximus, who would not communicate with John because of some suspected of Nestorianism, he wrote urging the reception of those willing to return to communion, even though ashamed to own their fall.224225226227228229230231232

Everywhere he acted as a peacemaker. The experienced pilot who, under God, had steered the ship through the storm sat watching each cloud as it appeared. His single concern was: "Peace has been restored; let us be careful not to break it again."

Everywhere he is the peace-maker. The veteran pilot, who, under God, had guided the ship through the storm, sat, watching each cloud, as it arose. His one thought was, 'Peace has been restored; take we heed that it be not again broken.'

Cyril thought it was right to correct Theodore's errors in writing, but this disturbed no peace since Theodore was dead. Theodoret, as usual, wrote against him, but Theodoret did not have Cyril's accurate theological mind. Cyril, in his ninth Anathema, called God the Holy Spirit "the very own Spirit of our Lord Jesus Christ," adopting the language of Athanasius, that "the Holy Spirit was the very own Spirit of the Son." Theodoret objected chiefly as if Cyril had said this of the humanity of our Lord, not of his divinity. But Theodoret added, at the end, the sad words: "If he calls him this as one in physis and proceeding from the Father, we will receive it; but if as having his existence from the Son or through the Son, we will reject it as blasphemous and ungodly." Theodoret could not have been, at that time, familiar with the great writers before him—Dionysius of Alexandria, Athanasius, Basil, Gregory of Nyssa, Didymus, Epiphanius, Cyril of Jerusalem—who used the "from" or the "through" which he rejected. Cyril's carefully weighed and complete language has continued to teach humanity until now. The impulsive language of Theodoret, if it had had any lasting weight, would have fostered the disbelief of any relation between God the Son and God the Holy Spirit, contrary to our baptismal creed.233234

S. Cyril thought it indeed right to correct in writing the errors of Theodore; but this disturbed no peace, since Theodore was gone. Theodoret, as usual, wrote against him, but Theodoret had not S. Cyril's accurate Theological mind. S. Cyril, in his 9th Anathematism, called God the Holy Ghost, 'the Very own Spirit of our Lord Jesus Christ' adopting the language of S. Athanasius, that ' the Holy Spirit was the Very own Spirit of the Son.' Theodoret declaimed chiefly, as if S. Cyril had said this of the Humanity of our Lord, not of His Godhead; but adds, at the end, the sad words, 'If he so calls Him as One in Nature and proceeding from the Father, we will receive it; but if, as having His existence from the Son or through the Son, we will fling it away as blasphemous and ungodly.' Theodoret could not have been, at that time, acquainted with the great writers before him, S. Dionysius of Alexandria, S. Athanasius, S. Basil, S. Gregory of Nyssa, Didymus, S. Epiphanius, S. Cyril of Jerusalem, who used the 'from' or the 'through' which he 'flings' from him. S. Cyril's well-weighed and full language has continued to teach man until now. The impetuous language of Theodoret, if it had had any lasting weight, would have fostered the disbelief of any relation between God the Son and God the Holy Ghost, contrary to our Baptismal Creed.233234

Theodoret decided to defend Theodore against Cyril, arguing against all the authorities that Cyril had cited. The one fragment that survives is sharply written. Cyril had explained and re-explained his Anathematisms in response to Theodoret's attacks, because the estranged Antiochenes had to be reconciled and a breach had to be healed. This criticism of his work against Theodore concerned only himself, so he continued on his way in peace.235236

Theodoret thought good to defend Theodore against S. Cyril, arguing against all the authorities which S. Cyril had adduced. The one fragment which remains is written sharply. S. Cyril had explained and re-explained his Anathematisms against Theodoret's attacks; for the alienated Antiochenes had to be reconciled, and a breach to be healed. This censure of his work against Theodore concerned only himself, so he went on his way in peace.235236

Cyril's strong natural affection has been mentioned in passing. It would be hard to imagine him, as he is usually portrayed, in his later years embracing and kissing a letter from his friend Acacius, Bishop of Melitene, who was asking about a typological figure in the Old Testament—the scapegoat. Yet since all service to God must involve self-denial, perhaps someone with strong natural affection was better suited as God's instrument for the difficult work of that wearisome conflict, just as it must have helped him in the more agreeable task of reconciling those who had become alienated.237238

S. Cyril's strong natural love has been incidentally noticed. One could hardly picture him, such as he has been ordinarily represented, in advancing years, enfolding and kissing the letter of his friend Acacius, Bishop of Melitene, enquiring about a type in the Old Testament, 'the scapegoat.' Yet since all service to God must involve self-denial, perhaps one of strong natural love was the fitter instrument of God for the hard service of that dreary warfare, as it must have aided him in the congenial office of reconciling the alienated.237238

External events reveal little about a person's inner thoughts. Cyril is now mainly known (to the extent he is known at all) as an eager defender of the Faith. But it was the Faith in Him—his God and his All. He must have spent many peaceful years before his own people's needs called him to defend God's truth against a living opponent. His work against the Emperor Julian (which even his critic Theodoret admired, despite his intense hostility) was written, he says, at many people's urging, because pagans were troubling Christians by claiming that Julian went unanswered because he could not be refuted. So this too was written out of love for souls. He himself explained to Nestorius that in his book on the Holy Trinity, he had written some things similar to what he was then writing, but with no reference to Nestorius, since it was written before Nestorius himself had written.239240

Outward events give but little insight into the inward mind. S. Cyril is now chiefly known (as far as he is known at all) as the zealous defender of the Faith. But it was the Faith in Him, his God and his All. Many must have been his peaceful years before he was called out by the needs of his own people, to defend the truth of God against a living assailant. His work against the Emperor Julian (which even his opponent Theodoret admired, in the midst of his hottest hostility) was written, he says, on the exhortation of many, because the heathen perplexed Christians, alleging that he was not refuted, because he could not. This then too was written out of a love for souls. He himself explained to Nestorius that, in his book on the Holy Trinity, he had written some things akin to what he then wrote, but with no reference to him, since it was written before Nestorius himself wrote.239240

Controversy was not his natural element. Cassiodorus lists him among those who were said to have written commentaries on all of Holy Scripture. His commentaries make up the largest portion of his surviving works, yet even these are only part of a larger body of writing. He was drawn away from these peaceful reflections on God's word when his monks were disturbed by the writings of Nestorius.241242

Controversy was not his natural element. Cassiodorus counts him among those who were said at least to have commented on the whole of Holy Scripture. His Commentaries are the largest portion of His extant works, yet these are but a part of a larger whole. From these peaceful meditations on God's word he was roused by the disturbance of his monks through writings of Nestorius.241242

We have already noted that in his first book on the Pentateuch, "On Worship in Spirit and in Truth," his main interest was in types of our Lord. His faith in the Incarnation and our union with God through it naturally stands out, as this theme shines through his work everywhere. His approach was the exact opposite of Theodore of Mopsuestia from the Antiochene school. As has been said of Bishop Horne and another figure, "one sees Christ everywhere, the other nowhere." A mind that meditates on God's word in this way—not focusing on isolated phrases but on the whole—is not the mind of a fierce controversialist, as some recent writers have portrayed him.243244

It has been noticed already that types of our Lord were the chief object of interest to him in his first book on the Pentateuch, 'on the adoration in spirit and in truth:' his faith in the Incarnation and our union to God through It, are naturally prominent, as indeed it gleams through everywhere. His was the exact contrary of the mind of Theodore of Mopsuestia of the Antiochene school: as has been said of our Bishop Horne and another, 'the one sees Christ every where, the other no where.' A mind which so meditates on God's word, not on particular expressions, but on the whole, is not that of the fierce controversialist which some of late have pictured him.243244

It only remains to gather together what has been said about the contents of this volume.

It remains only to collect what has been said as to the contents of this volume.

The Five Books against Nestorius have been described as essentially a defense of St. Proclus. In this work, St. Cyril primarily responds to the sermons that Nestorius preached against St. Proclus. The first two books deal with the Virgin being Theotokos (God-bearer) and with the term "birth" being applied to God. The third book concerns Christ being our Priest, who is God. The fourth and fifth books focus mostly on God suffering and dying.245

i. The Five books against Nestorius. 'These,' it has been said, 'may be well called, a Defence of S. Proclus. For S. Cyril in it mainly answers the sermons preached by Nestorius against S. Proclus. For the first two books are on the Virgin being Θεοτόκος, and the term 'birth' ascribed to God; the third is of His being our Priest, Who is God; the fourth and fifth are for the most part on God suffering and dying.'245

Cyril himself says that he took on this work reluctantly, but the homilies were written in a popular and appealing style and were filled with serious accusations against orthodox doctrines, leaving him no choice. Nestorius is not mentioned by name in it. Because of this, scholars have concluded that the work was written before the Council of Ephesus. Photius notes that "in the first book, he refutes six points of Nestorius's blasphemies; in the second, fourteen; in the third, six; in the fourth and fifth, seven each." He adds that "his method of interpretation follows his usual manner of expression, though adapted to a simpler style."246247248

S. Cyril himself says that he undertook the work with reluctance, but that the homilies were written in a popular and attractive style and were full of heavy accusations against the doctrines of the truth, and left him no choice. Nestorius is not named in it. Hence it has been inferred that the work was written before the Council of Ephesus. Photius notices that 'in the first book, he refutes six heads of the blasphemies of Nestorius; in the second, 14; in the third, 6; in the fourth and fifth, 7 each.' He adds that 'his mode of interpretation is framed according to his wonted way of expression, yet brought down to a lower style.'246247248

Photius says the Scholia contain much that is useful. St. Cyril, with his customary simplicity, describes them as brief expositions of the dispensation of Christ, very good and useful. A modern writer says the value of the work can be inferred from the fact that almost every later writer who used Cyril's authority to explain the mystery of the Incarnation included at least one passage from the Scholia. This work was also quoted, along with two other passages of St. Cyril, among the testimonies from the books of Catholic fathers that were attached to St. Leo's Epistle to the Emperor Leo. It concluded the collection presented to the Council of Chalcedon, and then came the acclamations: Eternal be the memory of Cyril. Leo and Cyril taught alike. It is even quoted by Theodoret along with sayings of nineteen other fathers as proof that the Saints distinguished the natures (physeis) after the union. He cites three passages from it, two from Cyril's Commentary on the Epistle to the Hebrews, one from the Epistle to Nestorius, one from the defense against the Easterns, and two more that cannot be identified. The Scholia are also quoted repeatedly by Facundus, Leontius of Byzantium, and St. Ephrem of Antioch. They not only quote it as St. Cyril's but also confirm the faith by citing testimonies from it.249250251252253254255256257258259260

ii. The Scholia are said by Photius to 'contain much which is useful.' S. Cyril, with his wonted simplicity, speaks of them as ' brief expositions of the dispensation of Christ, very good and useful.' A modern writer says, ' The value of the work may be inferred from this, that scarce any subsequent writer, who employed the authority of Cyril in explaining the mystery of the Incarnation, failed to take a passage or more from the Scholia.' This work also was quoted, with two other passages of S. Cyril, among the testimonies from the books of Catholic fathers, appended to the Epistle of S. Leo to the Emperor Leo. It closed the collection laid before the Council of Chalcedon and then ensued the acclamations, 'Eternal be the memory of Cyril.—-Leo and Cyril taught alike.' It is quoted even by Theodoret with sayings of 19 other fathers, in proof that 'Saints distinguished the Natures after the Union.' He alleges three places from it, two from his Commentary on the Epistle to the Hebrews, one from the Epistle to Nestorius, one from the defence against the Easterns, and two more not identified. The Scholia are quoted also by Facundus, Leontius of Byzantium, and S. Ephrem of Antioch repeatedly. They not only quote it as S. Cyril's, but confirm the faith by testimonies from it.249250251252253254255256257258259260

It was translated into Latin by Marius Mercator, a contemporary of S. Cyril. It also exists in a Syriac translation, which my son used occasionally to correct or clarify Mercator's Latin text.

It was translated into Latin by S. Cyril's contemporary, Marius Mercator. It is extant also in a Syriac translation, from which my son, here and there, corrected or explained the Latin text of Mercator.

Garnier comments on the careful organization that St. Cyril used in constructing this work. He first explains individual terms: what is Christ; what is Emmanuel; what is Jesus; what is One; what is Union. Then he addresses the statements commonly used about these terms and discusses in what way Christ is One; Emmanuel is One; Jesus is One—that is, One Lord, and so forth. Further, he examines how the Word is said to have been "emptied," united with the flesh, made Man, and yet not thereby changed or ceasing to be God. From there, he shows how Christ is not a man who is Theophoros (bearing God) or inspired by God, but is truly God-Man. Then he explains in what way the Word is said to dwell in us, to be sent to us, to have His own proper Body, and how the Holy Virgin is said to be Theotocos (God-bearer). Finally, he shows that the Only-Begotten, appearing in visible flesh, is called God and Man, and how He suffered. In this last section he refutes those who assume that things belonging to man can be spoken of God only in a relative sense. I have already said that nearly every chapter is full of distinctions useful for countering the objections of heretics. Photius divides the work into ten topics. He said these things are clearly explained in it: What is Christ; in what way the word "Emmanuel" is to be understood, and what is "Jesus the Christ"; and in what respect the Word of God is called Man; then, in what respect the Word of God is said to have been emptied; and how Christ is One, and how Emmanuel is One; and what we mean by the Union, and about the coal that Isaiah saw, and other similar matters.261

Garnier remarks upon the careful arrangement which S. Cyril employed in its construction. 'He first explains single words; what is Christ; what, Emmanuel; what, Jesus; what, One; what, Union. Then, he turns to the propositions, commonly used herein, and discusses in what way Christ is One; Emmanuel, One; Jesus, One; i.e. One Lord, &c. Further, how the Word is said to have been 'emptied,' united with the flesh, made Man, and yet not therefore changed, or ceasing to be God. Thence, how Christ is not a man Θεοφόρος, [bearing God,] or inspired by God, but is really man-God [better, God-Man]; then, in what way the Word is said to dwell in us, to be sent to us, to have His own proper Body, and how the Holy Virgin is said to be Theotocos. Lastly, that the Only-Begotten, appearing in visible flesh is called God and Man; how He suffered: in which last he refutes those who suppose, that things belonging to man can be spoken of God, relatively only. I have already said, that almost every chapter is full of distinctions useful in turning aside the objections of heretics.' Photius divides it into ten heads; ' These things,' he said, 'are clearly explained in it; What is Christ; in what way the word 'Emmanuel' is to be understood, and what is 'Jesus the Christ;' and in what respect the Word of God is called Man; then, in what respect the Word of God is said to have been emptied; and how Christ is One, and how Emmanuel is One; and what we say is the Union, and about the coal which Elias saw, and other things like these.'261

That Christ is One. This treatise must have been written after Nestorius was condemned, since he is refuted by name in it. However, it must have been written no later than A.D. 441, since Andrew of Samosata quotes it. It is quoted with praise by S. Eulogius and Leontius of Byzantium. Father Garnier says of it: "Cyril wrote nothing more precise and carefully worked out concerning the history of the doctrine, so that the work appears to be that of a craftsman thoroughly trained by his previous labors."262263264

iii. That Christ is One. The treatise must have been written after the condemnation of Nestorius, since he is refuted by name in it. It must, however, have been written not later than A. D. 441, since it is quoted by Andrew of Samosata. It is quoted with praise by S. Eulogius and Leontius of Byzantium… The Père Garnier says of it; ' Eo nihil exactius elucubratiusque ad historiam dogmatis Cyrillus scripsit, ut videatur opus artificis praecedentibus laboribus absolute eruditi.'262263264

Cyril wrote the three books against Diodore and Theodore of Mopsuestia and the one against the Synousiastae (those who hold a particular Christological position associated with Apollinarius) at a later time. This was when the writings of Nestorius had been condemned, and supporters of Nestorian views turned instead to the works of Diodore and Theodore, who were the actual founders of Nestorianism. The fragments have been carefully gathered from every source known up to this point. Some were readily available, having been collected for the Fifth Ecumenical Council and included in its official records. Others were collected by John, Bishop of Caesarea, in his defense of the Council of Chalcedon, which still exists in manuscript form in both Syriac and Greek at Venice and at Cairo, where my son saw it. Still others were collected by Severus of Antioch. The sources from which these excerpts are taken are indicated in the notes. The original texts, as they exist in Greek and Syriac, are among the collection of fragments attached to my son's third volume of Cyril's Commentary on John. This is the most complete collection in existence.265266

iv. S. Cyril wrote the three books against Diodore and Theodore of Mopsuestia and that against the Synousiastae or Apollinarians at a later period, when, the writings of Nestorius being proscribed, Nestorianisers betook themselves to those of Diodore and Theodore, the real originators of Nestorianism. The fragments have been collected with great pains from every source, hitherto known. Some were ready at hand, having been collected for the 5th General Council, and embodied in its Acts; others were collected by John, Bishop of Caesarea, in his defence of the Council of Chalcedon, which is still extant in MS., in Syriac and in Greek at Venice and at Cairo (where my son saw it); others by Severus of Antioch. The sources, whence the extracts are derived, are mentioned in the notes. The originals, as extant in Greek and Syriac, are among the collection of Fragments appended to my son's third volume of S. Cyril's Commentary on S. John. It is the completest collection extant.265266

Saint Cyril was my own early teacher on the connection between the doctrine of the Incarnation and the Holy Eucharist, which Hooker almost reached. At my request, in his constant filial love, my son took as the central work of his life to make the text of his works as accurate as it could be made. For this purpose he visited libraries in France, Spain, Italy, Germany, Russia, Mount Athos, Cairo, Mount Sinai, and applied to this work his knowledge of Syriac, which he had perfected with another goal in mind that I had suggested to him: the re-editing of that now much undervalued critical authority, the Peshitta. Almighty God chose to break off the work "in the midst of the years." If in this completion of his Preface to his volume I have clarified anything regarding the self-forgetful, God-devoted character of my early benefactor, Saint Cyril, thanks be for this also to Him Who gave and Who took away.

S. Cyril was my own early teacher on the connection of the doctrine of the Incarnation and the Holy Eucharist, which Hooker all but reached. It was at my wish that, in his uniform filial love, my son took as the central work of his life, to make the text of his works as exact as it could be made. For this he visited libraries in France, Spain, Italy, Germany, Russia, Mt. Athos, Cairo, Mt. Sinai, and applied to this the knowledge of Syriac, which he had perfected in view of another object which I had suggested to him, the re-editing of that now much undervalued Critical authority, the Peshito. Almighty God was pleased to break off the work "in the midst of the years." If in this completion of his Preface to his volume I have cleared any thing as to the self-forgetful, God-devoted character of my early Benefactor, S. Cyril, thanks be for this also to Him Who gave and Who took away.

E. B. P.

E. B. P.

CHRISTMAS EVE, 1881.

C HRISTMAS E VE, 1881.


Five Tomes Against Nestorius — Book I

Cyril answers Nestorius’ sermons on the title Mother of God (Theotokos): the Word Himself became flesh and was born of the Virgin, so she is truly Mother of God.

Truth of human writings must be tested by Scripture. Arian errors and against Holy Ghost. Errors of heretics on their heads. Nestorius' book of Homilies. S. John i. 1,3,14,18. True Union of Person. Mother of God. "Made Flesh;" Manichees have no plea; without it, the curse and decay would still have been our lot. " Mother of God" except it express a Truth, may no ways be allowed. 'Passed through,' objected to. To be Incarnate, belongs to one who was, before He was Man. " Mixture " of old used in right sense. One of Nestorius' sermons quoted as owning God and Man in one. συνάφεια . A mother, mother of a man, though the body only is taken of her. Elizabeth mother of S. John the Baptist. Eusebius of Dorylaeum opposes Nestorius in church. GOD the SON had two Births. The Creed of Nicea on the Incarnation. The Creed recited. Nestorius cites from that of Constantinople. "Incarnate" begotten after the flesh. If it did but mean indwelt it would be common to all. S. John's most careful accurate language. That the Virgin Mary bare God, does not exclude the Eternal Generation, nor render her an object of worship.

Source: Cyril of Alexandria, Five Tomes Against Nestorius (1881) Book 1. pp.1-37.. Transcribed by Roger Pearse (tertullian.org); public domain.

Contents · 11 chapters
  1. Opening
  2. §1
  3. §2
  4. §3
  5. §4
  6. §5
  7. §6
  8. §7
  9. §8
  10. §9
  11. §10

Opening

Those who want to study the holy Scriptures and who drive away laziness in doing so, and instead thirst to master them, and apply themselves energetically and without any laziness—such people will possess every good thing, because they fill their minds with the divine light. Then, applying it to the teachings of the Church, they readily accept everything that is correct and pure, and store it in the hidden treasures of their souls. They rejoice as much in what they have gathered through their desire for knowledge as worldly people do in endlessly collecting Indian gems or gold—or rather, even more. For wisdom is better than costly stones, and no precious thing is worthy to be compared with her, as it is written. I say that those who are wise and prudent and skilled in the divine teachings ought to remember what was profitably written by one of the holy disciples: "Brethren, try the spirits whether they be of God." And the divine Paul says that the saints have been given discernment of spirits.

THOSE who wish to explore the holy Scripture and who drive away negligence in doing so, and thirst rather for the attainment thereof, and apply themselves vigorously and apart from all sloth—-the being in every good shall be their's, for they fill their mind with the Divine Light: and then applying it to the doctrines of the Church, they admit every thing that is right and unadulterate, and that most readily, and lay it up in the hidden treasures of their soul, and rejoice as much in what they in their desire of knowledge have collected, as others who are worldly, in insatiably collecting Indian gems or gold, yea rather, yet more: for wisdom is better than costly stones, and every precious thing is not worthy of her, as it is written. For I say that they who are wise and prudent and skilled in the Divine doctrines, ought to remember what has been profitably written by one of the holy Disciples, Brethren try the spirits whether they he of God. And the Divine Paul says that to the saints has been given discerning of spirits.

Those who say "Lord Jesus" will say it only through the Holy Spirit, while those who out of ignorance let loose a contradictory tongue against them, and think wrongly where others think rightly, practically say "Jesus is Anathema"—they will do so from Beelzebub. We must therefore study to examine all things carefully and thoroughly and with an alert mind, search through the writings of certain people, and test skillfully what words they use concerning Christ the Savior of us all. We should imitate, and correctly so, the most approved and experienced money changers, who accept proven coins and diligently reject the counterfeit and faulty ones. The blessed Paul invites us to this, saying: "Be skillful bankers, prove all things, hold fast that which is good, abstain from every form of evil." It is also in other ways completely disgraceful and unseemly that in the affairs of this life we should be seen sparing nothing that leads to profit, and rather make it important to aim and strive after those things by which we may live splendidly, yet neglect such sacred things and count the salvation of the soul as nothing, but let it sink down in pits and swamps. Sometimes we expose our mind—not vigilant for the truth, nor choosing to search diligently what is the true and profitable meaning of what has been read, what is the perverted meaning that oversteps accuracy in doctrine and causes loss in the soul that looks to it—to the mere pleasure of those who choose to say what they ought not. Yet for those who are perfect in understanding, nothing is equal in value to the soul.1

For the one who say Lord Jesus, will say it none otherwise than through the Holy Ghost: and they who out of unlearning let loose a contradicting tongue against them, and wherein those think rightly, these all but say Jesus Anathema, from Beelzebub will they do so. We must then studying to prove all things subtilly and in a finished manner and with mind awake, light on the writings of certain, and test skillfully what words they use of Christ the Saviour of us all, and imitate, and that aright, the most approved and experienced of money dealers, who admit proved coin, and diligently reject the counterfeit and amiss. And to this the blessed Paul invites us saying, Be ye skilful bankers, prove all things, hold fast that which is good, abstain from every form of evil. And it is in other ways also all-disgraceful and unseemly, that in the affairs of this life we should be seen no whit sparing of what conduceth to profit, but rather make it of moment to aim and strive after those things whereby we may live splendidly, and neglect things so sacred and count for nothing the salvation of the soul, but let it sink down in pits and swamps, sometimes exposing unto the mere pleasure of those who choose to say what they ought not, our mind, not vigilant for the truth, nor choosing to search diligently what is the true and profitable meaning of what has been read, what the perverted one and that outsteps accuracy in doctrine and works loss in the soul that looks to it. Yet to the soul is there nought equal in value in their sight who are perfect in understanding.1

We must therefore examine very carefully writings on divine doctrines, and if any should agree with the sacred Scriptures and advance clearly along their most unerring path, let us also acclaim it with testimony to its orthodoxy. But if it fashions its language in a cold, wandering, and faulty way—or rather, in a way that brings destruction to its readers—let it hear from every mouth: "You are uttering and telling us another error."

We must try therefore and that most straitly, writings on the Divine doctrines, and if any should go along with the sacred Scriptures and speed its clear and most unerring way therein, let it be acclaimed by us too with testimonies to its orthodoxy: but if it form its language cold and astray and amiss, yea rather giver of destruction to the readers, let it hear from every mouth, But ye are uttering and telling us another error.

Therefore, either let them make the tree good and its fruit good, or let them make the tree corrupt and its fruit corrupt. For the good man brings forth good things from the good treasure of his heart, and the evil man brings forth evil things from the evil treasure of his heart, according to the truthful word of the Savior. For the god of this world has blinded the minds of unbelieving heretics, so that the light of the gospel of the glory of Christ should not shine on them, and they have been deceived in many ways. For some—wretched people!—say that the Word who came forth from God the Father is lesser than the One who begot Him, and they have not hesitated to assign to Him a measure that is foreign and fitting only for a slave. Others, sharpening their unholy and unrestrained mouths against the Holy Spirit, rightly hear the Prophet say, "But draw near here, you ungodly sons, seed of adulterers and the whore; against whom did you amuse yourselves? Against whom did you open your mouth, and against whom did you let loose your tongue? Are you not children of destruction, a lawless seed?" But these shall walk in their own light and find the flames they themselves kindled. For us whose concern is orthodoxy, it is fitting that we should give a wise and accurate account of each of the divine doctrines and should avoid the charges from their unbridled mouths, lest in any way stumbling and sinning against the brethren and wounding their weak conscience, we sin against Christ. Let us therefore listen to Him who says, "If the enemy had reproached Me, I could have borne it, and if he who hated Me had spoken proudly against Me, I would have hidden Myself from him, but you, a man My intimate, My guide and My friend, who shared sweet food together with Me—in the house of God we walked in harmony." But let these things fall upon the heads of the enemy who war against the glory of our Savior and consider blasphemy against Him to be their delicate food. For us it is fitting and necessary, as I said, that we who are zealous to appreciate those things that please Him should not follow doctrine that is alien to truth or that diverges in any other direction and tends toward decay, but rather that which is for the good of our flock and is crowned by the Truth itself with testimonies to its correctness.2

Therefore either let them make the tree good and his fruit good, or let them make the tree corrupt and his fruit corrupt; for the good man out of the good treasure of his heart bringeth forth good things, and the evil man out of the evil treasure of his heart bring eth forth evil things, according to the unlying word of the Saviour. For the god of this world blinded the understandings of the unbelieving heretics, lest the light of the gospel of the glory of Christ should shine: and they have been deceived manifoldly. For some (miserable!) say that the Word sprung of God the Father is lesser than He that begot Him, and have not shuddered at apportioning to Him an alien and slave-befitting measure; others, whetting against the Holy Ghost their unholy and intemperate mouth, do rightly hear the Prophet say, But draw YE near hither, ungodly sons, seed of the adulterers and the whore, against Whom did ye sport yourselves? and against Whom opened ye your mouth and on Whom let loose your tongue? are YE not children of destruction, a lawless seed? But these shall walk in their own light and find the flames that themselves kindled: for us whose care is orthodoxy, it is meet that we should give a wise and accurate account of each of the Divine doctrines and should shun the charges [put forth by] their unbridled mouth, lest in ought stumbling and sinning against the brethren and wounding their weak conscience, we sin against Christ, Let us therefore hearken unto Him Who saith, If the enemy had reproached Me, I could have borne it, and if he that hated Me had spoken proudly against Me, I would have hid Myself from him, but THOU, a man Mine intimate, My guide and My friend, who sweetenedst food together with Me, in the house of God we went in harmony. But let these things go upon the heads of the enemy, who war against the glory of our Saviour, and esteem blasphemy against Him, their delicate meat: for us it is meet and necessary (as I said) that we, zealous to savour those things that please Him, should not follow [doctrine] which is alien from truth or which diverges in any other direction, and tends to decay, [but follow] that which is for the good of our flock and is crowned by the Truth itself with testimonies to its rightness.2

I say this because I have come across a certain book compiled by someone, containing a large collection of homilies arranged in an orderly and systematic way, with everything needed for the reader. If the author had said something that would simply fade into forgetfulness and come to nothing, I would have considered it my duty both to remain silent myself and to advise others to do the same, so that these carelessly and thoughtlessly spoken things would not become known to many others and to future generations. But since a multitude of blasphemies has been heaped into this book and a serious accusation has been made, barking against the doctrines of the truth, how could we not prepare ourselves for combat and fight on behalf of its readers, so they may not be harmed by it, but rather know how to bravely repel the damage from what is wrongly said? For the divine John was called by Christ the Savior of us all the Son of Thunder, and with good reason, because he practically sounded forth over everything under heaven and thundered across the earth, uttering something vast and immense. He makes known very clearly the truly awesome and mighty mystery of the Incarnation of the Only-Begotten, for he said: In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. All things were made through Him, and without Him was not anything made. But when he had provided accurate and complete instruction and declared that the Only-Begotten, being God and ineffably begotten of God by physis, is Maker and Creator of all things, then—at that point—he at last begins to explain the wise plan that was carried out for our sake and on our behalf, and says: And the Word was made flesh and tabernacled among us (and we saw His glory, the glory as of the Only-Begotten of the Father) full of grace and truth. He said that the Word was flesh, showing the force of the true union, that is, understood as one of prosopon, and by saying that He tabernacled among us, he does not allow us to think that the Word who is from God by physis passed into flesh which is from the earth. For someone not thoroughly precise about what the divine physis that surpasses everything created is might suppose that it was perhaps capable of change and could become indifferent to its own essentially inherent goods, and change into something other than what it is, and be brought down to the level of creation, unexpectedly subjected to changes and alterations. But that this is utterly impossible (for the physis of God is established and has unshaken stability in what it is), he has testified by saying that the Word tabernacled among us, although made flesh. In this way he both skillfully explains the wisdom of the plan and carefully guards against anyone accusing the physis of the Word as though it had become flesh by change and transformation.

And this I say having met with a certain book compiled by some one, having a large collection of homilies, orderly and systematically arranged and in no wise lacking in due appliances for the reader. And if ought had been said by its author, which by passing into forgetfulness should come to nought, I would have deemed it a duty both myself to hold my peace and to counsel others to do the same; lest things so unmeetly and unheedfully said should become known to many others, and to those after us. But since a multitude of blasphemies has been heaped into this book and some great accusation has been made, baying against the doctrines of the truth, how was it not necessary that we in turn should (so to say) strip for combat and should fight in behalf of its readers, that they may not take harm thence, but may rather know how to repulse bravely the damage from what is unrightly said? For the Divine John was called by Christ the Saviour of us all the Son of thunder, and with reason, for that he well-nigh sounded forth o'er all beneath the heaven and thundered over the earth, uttering something vast and immense. For he makes known full well the truly dread and mighty Mystery of the Incarnation of the Only-Begotten: for he said, In the, beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God: all things were made through Him, and without Him was not any thing made. But when he had made accurate and complete initiation, and declared that the Only-Begotten being God and ineffably begotten of God by Nature, is Maker and Creator of all things; then, then, in fit season, does he at length begin the allwise economy that for our sakes and in our behalf was wrought, and says, And the Word was made flesh and tabernacled in us (and we saw His glory, the glory as of the Only-Begotten of the Father) full of grace and truth. For he said that the Word was flesh, shewing the force of the true union, i.e., understood as one "of Person:" and by saying that He tabernacled in us, he does not allow us to conceive that the Word which is out of God by Nature passed into flesh which is of the earth. For one not thoroughly exact as to what the Divine Nature Which surpasses every thing generate is, might (I suppose) have deemed that It was haply recipient of change and could become regardless of Its own Essentially-accruing goods, and change (so to say) into something other than what It is, and be brought down to the measures of the creation, subjected in unlooked-for way to changes and alterations. But that this is utterly impossible (for the Nature of God is stablished and hath unshaken abidance in that wherein it is), he hath testified saying, that the Word tabernacled in us, albeit made flesh: both skilfully explaining the wisdom of the Economy and guarding full well that the Nature of the Word be not accused by any as though It had become flesh by change and turning aside.

We ourselves therefore say, following the intent of the inspired writers and in no way transgressing the definition of the Faith, that He Who is out of God by Nature, the Only-Begotten, He Who is in the Bosom of the Father, He through Whom are all things and in Whom all things exist—though He had His own existence before every age and time and eternally coexisted with Him Who begot Him—descended to voluntary emptiness in the last times of the world and took the servant's form. That is, He became Man according to the economy and was made like His brothers in all things by sharing similarly in blood and flesh. Thus He underwent birth with us and like us, and took into Himself the coming into being of His own flesh. He did this not because He needed a second beginning of existence (for the Word was in the beginning and was God), but so that He might gather together the human race, becoming a second first-fruits of all things after that first one, born according to the flesh of a woman, according to the Scriptures. For though He was rich, He became poor, bringing us again to His own wealth and having all things in Himself through the flesh which was united to Him. For thus we have been buried with Christ through Holy Baptism, have been raised and made to sit with Him in heavenly places. For so has written the steward of His mysteries, the herald and Apostle, and minister of the Gospel oracles, the most wise Paul. Therefore, both for the faith of the Mystery and for its exact demonstration, the fact of true union—I mean according to prosopon—is necessary, so that the mode of generation according to the flesh of the Only-Begotten may be without blame. He was not called to a second existence (for He Himself is the Maker of the worlds, as I said), but lowered Himself according to the economy to manhood for our sakes, and did not despise the laws of human nature but chose rather to have as His own, together with the flesh, the fleshly generation as well. Therefore we say that He Who eternally coexists with the Father was born according to the flesh. For thus He condemned sin in the flesh and has brought to nothing the power of death in us, being made as we are, though He knew no sin, He in Whom we live and move and are.3

We ourselves too then say, tracking the aim of the inspired, and in no way outstepping the definition of the Faith, that He Who is out of God by Nature, the Only-Begotten, He Which is in the Bosom of the Father, He through Whom are all things and in Whom all things, albeit having before every age and time His Own Existence, and ever co-existing with Him Who begot Him, descended unto voluntary emptiness in the last times of the world, and took the servant's form, i.e., became in our condition and Man economically, and was made like in all things unto His brethren, by partaking similarly of blood and flesh, and that He thus underwent birth with us and like us, and took into Himself the passing into being of His own Flesh, not as needing a second beginning unto being (for the Word was in the beginning and was God) but, that He might gather together the human race, a second first-fruits of all things after that first one, born after the flesh of a woman, according to the Scriptures. For so being Rich, became He poor, bringing us again unto His own wealth and having all in Himself through the flesh which was united to Him. For thus have we been buried with Christ through Holy Baptism, have been raised and made to sit with Him in heavenly places. For so hath written the steward of His mysteries, the herald and Apostle, and minister of the Gospel oracles, the most wise Paul. Necessary therefore, alike to the faith of the Mystery and to the exact demonstration thereof, is the fact of true Union, I mean of Person, that the mode of generation according to the flesh of the Only-Begotten may be without blame, Who was (as I said) called to no second existence (for Himself is the Maker of the worlds), but lowered Himself economically to manhood for our sakes, and despised not the laws of human nature but chose rather to have as His own together with the flesh the fleshly generation too. Therefore do we say that He was born after the flesh Who is ever Co-existent with the Father. For thus condemned He sin in the flesh and He hath brought to nought the might of death in us, made as we, Who knew no sin, in Whom we live and move and are.3

But some people—I don't know how—distort the most sacred beauty of the Church's teachings and disfigure the holy and all-pure Virgin, dragging her down to the unseemly corruption of their own ideas and arming themselves against us with a multitude of newfangled inventions. For they accuse the word Mother of God, which the holy fathers before us constructed for the holy Virgin, as something illegitimate and improper—indeed as going beyond all fitting language. They split apart and divide into two separate sons the One Lord Jesus Christ, and they strip away from God the Word the sufferings of the Flesh. Yet even we have not said that He suffered in His own physis as God, but rather we attribute to Him along with the Flesh the sufferings that happened to the Flesh, so that He too may be confessed to be Savior (for by His stripes we were healed, as it is written, and He was wounded for our transgressions, though He did not receive any wound as suffering). And we have been saved by His undergoing death for us through His own Body.

But some (I know not how) wrong the most sacred beauty of the dogmas of the Church and wrinkle the holy and all-pure Virgin, bringing her down to the unseemly rottenness of their own ideas and arming against us a multitude of new-fangled inventions. For they accuse, as something bastard and uncomely, yea rather as going beyond all fit language, the word Mother of God, which the holy fathers before us have constructed for the holy Virgin; and sunder, dividing into two several sons, the One Lord Jesus Christ, and take away from God the Word the sufferings of the Flesh, though not even we have said that He suffered in His own Nature, as God, but we attribute rather to Him along with the Flesh the Sufferings also that befel the Flesh, that He too may be confessed to be Saviour (for with His stripes were WE healed, as it is written, and He has been wounded for our transgressions, albeit not recipient of suffering any wound): and WE have been saved by His undergoing death for us through His own Body.

I will now try to demonstrate clearly what I said, because I am going to read the words of the person who compiled this book, beginning with those statements he made attacking the word Mother of God in no uncertain terms. But since he repeatedly goes through the same arguments, and we must necessarily address the same ideas repeatedly, please forgive us—we are not repeating ourselves by choice, but we have decided that wherever his arguments are aimed, we too must oppose them. He spoke as follows, degrading the title of the Holy Virgin, namely Mother of God:

But I will essay to demonstrate clearly what I said, for I will now read the words of him who has compiled this book, and first of all those which he made, inveighing in no slight terms against the word Mother of God. But since he repeatedly goes through the same words, and it is necessary that we should repeatedly go through the same ideas, pardon (I pray) pardon us who do not wilfully repeat ourselves but have resolved that in whatever direction the aim of his words goes off, thither we too ought to oppose. He then spake thus, debasing the title of the Holy Virgin, I mean Mother of God:

§1

Nestorius says: "I often asked them" (that is, those who oppose him) "do you claim that the Godhead was born from the holy Virgin? They immediately draw back from such a statement: Who (says one) is so afflicted with such extreme blasphemy as to say that in her who bore the temple by the Spirit, God was formed in her? Then when I respond to this, What then is improper in what WE say when we advise fleeing from that word and adopting the common expression that refers to both natures? It seems to them that what is said is blasphemy. Either clearly admit that the Godhead was born from the blessed Mary, or if you reject this expression as blasphemy, why do you, while saying the same thing as I do, pretend that you are not saying it?"

Nestorius. "I often (he says) asked them" (i. e., those who contradict him) "do you say that the Godhead has been begotten of the holy Virgin? They straightway recoil at the saying: who (says one) is sick of such exceeding blasphemy, as to say that in her who bare the temple by the Spirit, in her was God formed? then when I reply to this, What then that is incongruous do WE say in advising to flee the word, and come to the common phrase significant of the two natures? then seems it to them that what is said is blasphemy. Either clearly acknowledge that the Godhead has been born of the blessed Mary, or if you flee this expression as blasphemy, why saying the same as I, dost thou feign thou sayest it not?"

Those who think contrary to what you yourself said and think it good (I don't know how) to hold this position have been clearly testified to by your own mouth as having a right and most accurate opinion regarding Christ the Savior of us all, and as holding in their mind the faith that was delivered to the churches by those who from the beginning were eyewitnesses and ministers of the word and priests of our Mysteries and faithful stewards. For they shake off (and most rightly so) as a clear proof of both ignorance and extreme impiety the mere idea that the Word from God the Father has been called to a second beginning of being or took flesh from the holy Virgin as a foundation of His own existence. Still, they call her Mother of God, since she bore Emmanuel, who is by physis God. For the Word has been made with us, being God by physis and above us. Do they therefore say things contrary to what they think? For someone who thinks as you do will probably say, "If you say that the physis of the Word is not offspring of the flesh, and free yourself from this charge, how do you affirm that the holy Virgin bore God?" But you in turn will hear from us: The God-inspired Scripture says that the Word from God the Father was made Flesh, that is, was without confusion and personally united to flesh. For the Body that was united to Him and born of a woman is not alien to Him, but just as each of us has his own body, in this same way the Body of the Only Begotten is His own and no one else's, for in this way He was also born according to the flesh. Then how, tell me, would He have been made Flesh, unless He had received birth from a woman, since the laws of human nature called Him to this, and bodily existence could have its beginning in no other way? For we will not, I suppose, pay attention to the fantasies of the Greeks and imagine like them that human bodies are born from oak or rock. But the laws of nature were set for us, or rather by nature's Creator, for just as the offspring of each existing thing belongs to its kind, so too with ourselves, and it could not be otherwise. For nothing at all that the Divine and Ineffable Power wills to accomplish is impossible for It, yet It proceeds through what befits the physis of existing things, not dishonoring the laws It has set for Itself. And it would not have been impossible for the Word who can do all things, having determined for our sakes to become as we are, to refuse birth from a woman and to fashion a body for Himself from outside by His own Power, just as we say was done in the case of our forefather Adam, for God took, it says, dust from the ground and formed man. But since this would give occasion to the unbelievers who desire to accuse the Mystery of the Incarnation, and especially to the unholy Manichees (whom you say repeatedly that you fear lest they attack those who call the holy Virgin Mother of God, as though they were affirming that the Incarnation of the Word existed in mere appearance), He necessarily proceeded through the laws of human nature. And since His aim was to assure everyone that He has truly become Man, He took hold of the seed of Abraham, and with the blessed Virgin being the means to this end, He took part like us in blood and flesh, for in this way and no other could He become God with us. The Incarnation or taking human nature by the Word was most necessary in another way too for those on earth. For if He had not been born as we are according to the flesh, if He had not taken part like us in the same nature, He would not have freed human nature from the blame contracted in Adam, nor would He have driven away from our bodies the decay, nor would the power of the curse that we say came upon the first woman have ceased, for it was said to her, "In sorrows you shall bring forth children."

They therefore who think contrary to what yourself said and think good (I know not how) to hold, these have been clearly testified to by your own mouth as having a right and most unerring opinion in regard to Christ the Saviour of us all, and as holding with their mind the faith which they had delivered to the churches which from the beginning were eye-witnesses and ministers of the word and priests of our Mysteries and faithful stewards. For they shake off (and that most rightly) as a patent proof of unlearning alike and extremest impiety, the mere imagining that the Word from forth God the Father has been called unto a second beginning of being or took flesh of the holy Virgin as a root of His own existence: still they call her Mother of God, as having borne Immanuel Who is by Nature God: for the Word has been made with us, being God by Nature and above us. Do they therefore say contrary to what they think? For some one of those who think with thee will (I suppose) say, "If thou say that the Nature of the Word is not Offspring of the flesh, and free thyself from this charge, how dost thou affirm that the holy Virgin bare God?" But thou in turn wilt hear from us, The God-inspired Scripture says that the Word out of God the Father was made Flesh, i. e., was without confusion and Personally united to flesh: for not alien to Him is the Body which was united to Him and born of a woman, but as with each of us his body is his own, in this same way is the Body of the Only Begotten His own and none other's: for thus was He also born according to the flesh. Then how (tell me) would He have been made Flesh, except He had received birth of a woman, the laws of human nature calling Him thereto, and bodily existence being able no otherwise to have its beginning? For not (I suppose) giving heed to the juggleries of the Greeks, shall we too romance that the bodies of men are born of oak or rock: but our laws nature set us, yea rather nature's Creator, for as of each of existing things is the kin to it born, so of ourselves too, and no otherwise (how could it be?) For nought at all of what It willeth to accomplish is impracticable to the Divine and Ineffable Power, yet doth It proceed through what befits the nature of things that are, not dishonouring the laws set by Itself. And it were not impracticable to the Word That can do all things, having determined indeed for our sakes to become as we, yet to refuse the birth of a woman, and from without to fashion to Himself a body by His own Power, just as we say was done in the case of our forefather, Adam: for God took (it says) dust of the ground and formed man. But since this were occasion to the unbelievers who desire to accuse the Mystery of the Incarnation, and (before all) to the unholy Manichees, whom thou sayest over and over that thou fearest lest they should spring upon those who call the holy Virgin Mother of God, as though they were affirming that the Incarnation of the Word existed in mere phantasy; needs did He progress through the laws of human nature, and since His aim was to assure all that He hath become truly Man, He took hold of the seed of Abraham, and the blessed Virgin being the mean to this same end, He took part like us in blood and flesh; for so and no otherwise could He become God with us. Most needful in another way too unto those on the earth was the Incarnation or Inhumanation of the Word. For if He had not been born as we according to the flesh, if He had not taken part like us of the same, He would not have freed the nature of man from the blame [contracted] in Adam, nor would He have driven away from our bodies the decay, nor would the might of the curse have ceased which we say came on the first woman; for it was said to her, In sorrows shalt thou bring forth children.

But human nature fell into the disease of disobedience in Adam, yet it has now been vindicated in Christ through complete obedience. For it is written, "As by one man's disobedience many were made sinners, so too by the obedience of one shall many be made righteous." In Adam it suffered, "Dust you are and to dust you shall return," but in Christ it gained the riches of being able to overcome the struggles of death and, so to speak, to triumph over decay, saying those words of the Prophet, "O death, where is your victory? O grave, where is your sting?" It became accursed, as I said, but in Christ this too was abolished. And truly it has been said somewhere to the holy Virgin, with Elizabeth prophesying in the Spirit, "Blessed are you among women and blessed is the fruit of your womb." Sin reigned over us and the inventor and father of sins behaved arrogantly over all under the skies, holding against them the transgression of the divine laws. But in Christ we see human nature, as in a second firstfruits of our race, having confidence before God. For He said clearly, "The prince of this world comes, and in me he will find nothing."

But the nature of man hath fallen into the disease of disobedience in Adam, it has become now approved in Christ through the utter obedience: for it is written. As by one mail's disobedience many were made sinners, so too by the obedience of one shall many be made righteous. For in Adam hath it suffered, Dust thou art and unto dust shalt thou return, in Christ hath it gained the riches of being able to be superior to the toils of death, and (so to say) to exult over decay, saying those words of the Prophet, O death, where thy victory? o grave, where thy sting? it became accursed, as I said, but in Christ was this too brought to nought. And verily it has been said somewhere to the holy Virgin, Elizabeth prophesying in spirit, Blessed art thou among women and blessed is the fruit of thy womb. Sin hath reigned over us and the inventor and father of sins behaved himself proudly over all beneath the skies, objecting [to them] the transgression of the Divine Laws: but in Christ we see the nature of man, as in a second firstfruits of our race, having confidence with God. For He said clearly, The prince of this world cometh, and in Me shall find nothing.

But, good sir (I would reasonably say), if the Only-Begotten had not become as we are—and He became as we are in no other way than through birth in the flesh from a woman—we would not have been enriched with what is His. As the most wise Paul writes to us, Emmanuel the second Adam appeared to us not from the earth like the first, but from heaven. For the Word who is from above and from the Father came down not into the flesh of any particular person nor into alien flesh (as I already said), nor did He descend upon any one of those like us to dwell in him, as He did in the Prophets. Rather, having made His own the body that came from a woman and was born from her according to the flesh, He gathered up human birth through Himself, having been made as we are according to the flesh, He who is from the Father before all ages. The divine Scriptures delivered this confession of faith to us. But you pretend to fear that any of us might suppose the Word begotten of God had the beginning of His existence from earthly flesh. You completely remove the mystery of the Economy with flesh, saying that the holy Virgin ought not to be called by us Mother of God. You redirect those who call her Mother of God toward an inevitable confession, one that would require them to suppose that the Word from God became the product of flesh. But this is not so—far from it. For He who has His existence from God the Father before all time (for He is the Maker of the ages), in the last times of the age, since He became flesh, is said to have been begotten according to the flesh. For if the body is understood as His own, how will He not wholly and entirely claim as His own the birth of His own body? Yes, you yourself would have approved the right and undefiled faith of those who hold this position, if you would have persuaded yourself to reason and to confess that Christ is truly God, the one and only Son of God the Father, not divided into man separately and likewise into God, but the same—both Word from God the Father and man from woman as we are, while He remains God.

But, good sir (would I with reason say) except the Only-Begotten had become as we, had become as we no otherwise than by means of birth in the flesh from forth a woman, WE had not been enriched with what is His. For as the most wise Paul writeth to us, Emmanuel the second Adam hath appeared to us, not from the earth like the first, but from Heaven. For the Word That is from above and from forth the Father hath come down not into the flesh of any one nor into alien flesh (as I already said), nor again hath He descended upon any one of those like us to dwell in him, as He was in the Prophets; but having made His own the body which was from forth a woman and born from her after the Flesh, He gathered up man's birth through Himself, made as we after the flesh, Who is before all ages from the Father. This confession of faith the Divine Scriptures delivered to us. But THOU feignest to fear lest any of us should suppose that the Word Begotten of God had the beginning of His Being from earthly flesh: thou takest away utterly the Mystery of the Economy with flesh, saying that the holy Virgin ought not to be called by us Mother of God: thou turnest round those who call her Mother of God unto a confession inevitable and as of necessity, of supposing that the Word out of God became fruit of flesh. But it is not so, far from it. For He That hath His Being of God the Father before all time (for He is the Framer of the ages), in the last times of the age, since He became Flesh, is said to have been begotten after the flesh. For if the Body is conceived of as His own, how will He not wholly and entirely appropriate the birth of His own Body? Yea yourself too would have approved the right and undefiled faith of these who thus hold, if you would have persuaded yourself to reason and to confess that Christ is truly God, the One and Only of God the Father, not severed into man separately and likewise into God, but the Same, both Word out of God the Father and Man out of woman as we, while He abideth God.

But the fact that you condemn the Birth according to the flesh of the Word, declaring in every way two sons and dividing the One Lord Jesus Christ, will be shown not by my words but by your own.

But that thou dost accuse the Birth after the flesh of the Word, every way declaring two sons and dividing the One Lord Jesus Christ, shall be shewn not by my words but by thine own.

Nestorius: "Look at what follows, heretic. I do not begrudge calling the Virgin 'mother of Christ,' but I know that she is august—she who received God, through whom the Lord of all passed, and through whom the Sun of righteousness shone forth. Again I suspect your applause: how did you understand 'passed through'? I have not said 'passed through' in the sense of 'born,' for I do not forget my own words so quickly. Divine Scripture taught me that God passed through from the Virgin mother of Christ; nowhere was I taught that God was born from her." And after more: "Therefore Divine Scripture never says that God was born of the mother of Christ, but that Jesus, Christ, Son, Lord, was so born."

Nestorius: "Look what follows, heretic. I grudge not the word to the Virgin mother-of-Christ, but I know that she is august who received God, through whom the Lord of all passed, and through whom the Sun of righteousness beamed. Again I suspect your applause: how did ye understand passed through? I have not said passed through, in the sense of born, for not so quickly do I forget my own words: that God passed through from out the Virgin mother of Christ was I taught by the Divine Scripture, that God was born from her, was I nowhere taught." And after more; "Never therefore does the Divine Scripture say that God was born of the mother of Christ, but that Jesus, Christ, Son, Lord, [was so born]."

And to this he adds that Christ was not truly God, but rather a God-bearing man, as he supposes, putting forward the Angel's voice saying to blessed Joseph, "Arise, take the young child," and says that the Angels too, though wiser than we, knew that He was a child.

And hereto he subjoins that Christ was not truly God, but rather a God-bearing man, as he supposes, putting forward the Angel's voice saying to blessed Joseph, Arise take the young child, and says that the Angels too, though wiser than we, knew that He was a child.

§2

In this passage, he labels as a heretic the person who holds the correct and admirable faith about Christ and who, because Christ is truly God, calls the one who bore Him the mother of God. But it will be clear to anyone who thinks correctly that he himself is the one who, while pinning the accusation of heresy on those who choose to believe rightly, is demonstrating the ugliness of his own words and has almost openly admitted that he is straying from the straight path and making crooked roads. Next, how is it (tell me) that you do not begrudge this title to the holy Virgin, even though you take away the dignity of the Divine Birth and say that she is not Mother of God? You debase the expression and claim that it is full of blasphemy, yet how do you tell those who wish to do so to apply it to the holy Virgin (though I hear you call her august)? And then you consider this blasphemous word (as you alone think it is) suitable to honor the most august one, and you pretend to crown her, placing around her as some special honor a slander against God the Word? For if it is completely repugnant to the Word who proceeds from God to undergo fleshly birth, and you permit her who did not bear God to be called Mother of God, is it not accurate to say that you have openly despised the Lord's will? Will you not be caught insulting the august one rather than (as you suppose and claim) choosing to honor her, by assigning to her a name that is hateful to God? For we do not give to those we intend to honor names by which the glory of the Supreme Nature is dishonored, since first of all we will unwittingly be involving ourselves in the charge of such impiety, and second we will do them no small wrong, adorning as if in honor those we praise with what is no praise, and fashioning for them a tribute that is hateful to God.

Herein therefore he stiles heretic him who holds the right and admirable faith about Christ, and who since He is truly God, calls her mother of God who bare Him. But there will be no doubt to any of those who think aright, that it is himself who, fastening the blame of heresies on them who choose to deem aright, is establishing the unbeauty of his own words, and has all but confessed openly that he is being borne outside of the straight way, and is making crooked paths. Next how (tell me) do you not grudge this title to the holy Virgin, albeit you take away the dignity of the Divine Birth, and say that she is not Mother of God? but debasing the expression and affirming that it is full of blasphemy, how do you bid those who so will, to apply it to the holy Virgin (though I hear you call her august)? and then deem the so blasphemous word (as you alone think it) meet to adorn the most august one, and you feign to crown her, putting about her as some choice honour, a calumny against God the Word? For if it be wholly abhorrent to the Word Who is sprung of God to endure fleshly birth and you permit her who did not bear God to be called Mother of God, is it not true to say that you have openly depised the Lord's will? will you not be caught insulting rather the august one, than (as you suppose and say) electing to honour her, by allotting to her a name hated of God? For not to those whom we determine to honour [do] we give names whereby the glory of the Supreme Nature is dishonoured, first of all we shall unawares be involving our own selves in the charge of such impiety, next we shall do them no slight wrong, decking as if in honour those we praise with what is no praise, and weaving for them a laudation hated of God.

One may also marvel at this: you strike out in all directions at the words of the unholy heretics and refuse to allow them to prevail, because they take away the truth of the divine doctrines. Yet you then assign no small blame to the term Mother of God and accuse it, among other things, of being untrue and impious. Then you say that you pardon it and will not begrudge it to the Virgin, even if someone should choose to call her Mother of God. Will you then also permit those who are infected with the madness of Arius to say that the Son is inferior to the Father? Or again, will you permit the rest who drag down the physis of the Holy Spirit from its God-befitting excellence? But you would not choose to do this. And if anyone wants to learn why, you will surely say, I suppose, that you cannot endure a blasphemous word. Therefore, if she is not Mother of God, and you permit this to be said, know that you are abandoning the truth and care little about still appearing wise. For do you not say that Elizabeth or any other of the holy women is worthy of all reverence? Will you then not begrudge it if anyone chooses to call them mothers of God as well? But I suppose you will surely and utterly oppose them and say, This is not so, for they bore sanctified men, and none among them was God by physis. Therefore either drive this away from every woman, or if you allow the holy Virgin alone among all to have it, what words will you use for your defense? For if it is true of her and she has truly borne God, in that the Word of God has been made flesh, confess this with us, and you will free yourself from the charge of impiety. But if she has not borne God, to permit anyone to call her Mother of God is to share in their impiety. But she is Mother of God, because the Only-Begotten has been made man as we are, united in truth to flesh, and undergoing fleshly birth without dishonoring the laws of our nature, as I said before.

One may moreover marvel at this too: that striking right and left at the words of the unholy heretics and in no wise allowing them to prevail, because they take away the truth of the Divine doctrines, next allotting no slight blame to the word Mother of God and accusing it amongst other things as untrue and impious, you said that you pardon it and will not grudge it to the Virgin even if one should choose to call her Mother of God. Will you permit it therefore to those too who are diseased with the madness of Arius, to say that the Son is inferior to the Father? or again to the rest who bring down the Nature of the Holy Ghost from its God-befitting excellency? But you would not choose to do this; and if any one desire to learn why, you will (I suppose) surely say, I do not endure a blasphemous word. Hence if she be not Mother of God, and you permit this to be said, know that you are deserting the truth, and reck little about any longer appearing wise. For do you not say that Elisabeth too or any other of the holy women is worthy of all reverence? will you then not grudge it, if any one choose to call them too mothers of God? But I suppose that you will surely and utterly withstand them and say, This is not so; for they bare sanctified men and none among them was God by Nature. Hence either drive away this from every woman; or if you allow the holy Virgin alone among all to have it, what words will you use for your defence? For if it be true of her and she has truly borne God, in that the Word of God has been made flesh, confess this with us, and you will free yourself from the charge of impiety: but if she hath not borne God, to permit any to call her Mother of God is to partake of their impiety. But she is Mother of God, because the Only-Begotten has been made man as we, united of a truth to flesh, and enduring fleshly birth and not dishonouring the laws of our nature, as I said before.

But since he says that he knows that she, meaning the holy Virgin, is august, come I pray come let us consider the reason too for the reverence that was shown to her: "for I know (he says) that she is august, through whom the Lord of all passed, through whom the Sun of righteousness beamed." How then do you say that she received God? Or in what way did the Lord of all pass through her? Or how did the Sun of righteousness beam? For if she has not borne God—in the flesh I mean—how did she receive God? How did He pass through her? But perhaps you will speak this clever word of yours as you think and dare to say it: "The Word was God both connected with man and indwelling him." But the tradition of the faith stands ready against your words on this matter. We have been taught to worship no God-bearing man, but God Incarnate. But you do not speak this way. How then do you not see that you are babbling and falsely representing the truth that is in the divine teachings? For the Word has been made flesh. How did you now say that she received God unless you have believed that she has borne Emmanuel who is God by nature (physis)? How did the Lord of all pass through her and how did the Sun of righteousness beam? And who is he that you think fit to embellish with such names? Is he a common man, like one of us, yet hallowed because he has the Word of God indwelling? Then how will such a one be Lord of all, and Sun of righteousness? For the power of lordship and dominion over all and of illumining things possessing intelligence will not pertain to our measures, but will be attributed to the Supreme and Most High Nature alone.4

But since he says that he knows that she, i.e. the holy Virgin, is august, come I pray come let us consider the reason too of the reverence that was done her: "for I know (he says) that she is august, through whom the Lord of all passed, through whom the Sun of righteousness beamed." How then do you say that she received God? or in what way did the Lord of all pass through her? or how beamed the Sun of righteousness? For if she hath not borne God, after the flesh I mean, how received she God? how passed He through her? But haply you will say this wise word of yours as you think and dare to speak it " The Word was God both connected with man and indwelling him." But the tradition of the faith makes itself ready against your words as to this, No God-bearing man, but God Incarnate have we been taught to worship: but not so speakest THOU: how then do you not see that you are babbling and falsely marking the truth that is in the Divine dogmas? For the Word has been made flesh. How did you now say that she received God except you have believed that she hath borne Emmanuel Who is God by Nature? how passed the Lord of all through her and how beamed the Sun of righteousness? And who is he that you think fit to embellish by such names? is he a common man, like one of us, yet hallowed, as having the Word of God indwelling? Then how will such an one be Lord of all, and Sun of righteousness? For the power of lordship and dominion over all and of illumining things possessing intelligence, will pertain not to our measures, but will be attributed to the Supreme and Most High Nature alone.4

But since you have taken the phrase "passed through" (I don't know from where) and applied it to God, explain what this phrase means. It will be up to your wisdom to tell those of us who don't know what this "passing through" actually signifies. If the Word of God passed through her in the sense of moving from one place to another, you immediately degrade Him, because you will hear Him saying through the voice of the saints, "Do I not fill heaven and earth, says the Lord?" The Godhead does not exist in physical space and does not undergo bodily changes of location, for it fills all things. But if, while waiting for the proper time of birth, He temporarily dwelt in human nature, and you therefore say that God passed through or made passage through the holy Virgin (I will use all your holy words), then we see nothing more in the holy Virgin than in other women. For Elizabeth bore the blessed Baptist, who had been sanctified through the Spirit, through whom the Son Himself also dwells in us. And the wise John will testify, saying, "By this we know that He is in us, because He gave us of His Spirit." Therefore the Word of God passed through Elizabeth as well, dwelling in the child through the Spirit even before his birth.

But since taking (I know not whence) the word passed through, you have applied it to God, explain the word; the meaning of the passage through here spoken of, will belong to your wisdom to tell us who know it not. For if the Word of God so passed through her, as to pass from one place to another, you cast Him down forthwith; for you will hear Him saying by the voice of the saints, Do not I fill Heaven and earth saith the Lord? For not in place is the Godhead nor knoweth It bodily changes of place, for it filleth all things. But if while awaiting the fit period of birth, He made an incidental indwelling in man, and so you say that God made passage through the holy Virgin, or passed through her (for I will use in all thy holy words): we see nought in the holy Virgin more than in other women. For Elisabeth bare the blessed Baptist who had been hallowed through the Spirit through Whom the Son Himself also makes His abode in us. And the wise John will witness saying, Hereby know we that He is in us, because He gave us of His Spirit. The Word of God therefore passed through Elisabeth herself too, indwelling in the babe through the Spirit even before its birth.

But you feel suspicious of the applause as though it came to you from the people for having chosen to speak rightly? For having called Him who was born of the holy Virgin "Sun of righteousness" and "Lord of all"? You then again pretend to speak with precision, and find fault with the applause, and accuse those who are rejoicing over you of not having understood. What great power there is in your words! You have made no delay in frustrating them where it was needed; you turned their joy into mourning at once, you tore away their rejoicing and clothed them with sackcloth, immediately adding, "Again I suspect your applause. How did you understand 'passed through'? I have not said 'passed through' in the sense of 'was born,' for I do not forget my own words so quickly. That God passed through from out of the Virgin Mother of Christ, I was taught by the Divine Scriptures; that God was born of her, I was nowhere taught."

But you feel suspicious of the applause as though it came to you from the people for having chosen to speak right things? for having called Him Who was born of the holy Virgin Sun of righteousness and Lord of all; you then again feign to speak with precision, and find fault with the applause, and accuse again those who are rejoicing over you of not having understood. O great strength which is in your words! you have made no delay in the needed vexing of them, you turned straightway their joy into mourning, you rent off their rejoicing and girt them with sackcloth, straightway adding, "Again I suspect your applause, how did ye understand passed through? I have not said passed through in the sense of was born, for not so quickly do I forget my own words. That God passed through from out the Virgin Mother of Christ, was I taught by the Divine Scriptures, that God was born of her, was I nowhere taught."

Those are your perverted statements. The applause came from love, because your thinking had some appearance of orthodoxy. But I will press on no less and say: What does "passed through" mean, if not birth? Will you claim that the Word from God Himself, by Himself and apart from flesh, hastened through the Virgin? Yet how would this not be completely foolish? For it would be necessary to assume that the Godhead was capable of receiving quantity and of movement from one place to another. Or if the Godhead is without body, unlimited and everywhere, and not in a place or confined by boundaries, how will it pass through a single body? But whatever you are saying, why do you not need to clarify it and speak more plainly, if you are confident in your own views about it and able to testify to their soundness? Where, I ask, have you heard the divinely inspired Scripture say that the Word of God passed through the holy Virgin? For the blessed David taught that the life of those on earth is brief and limited, saying, "Man, his days are as grass; as a flower of the field, so he flourishes; for the wind passes through him and he shall not be." But what thing of this sort can you say has been written about the holy Virgin? That God has been born of her—in the flesh, I mean—divinely inspired Scripture has clearly shown.

Those therefore are thy perverted sayings; the applause was of love, in that your mind had some guise of orthodoxy. But I will press on now too no less and say, What is passed through, if it mean not birth? will you say that the Word out of God Himself by Himself and apart from flesh hastened through the Virgin? yet how would not this be replete with all folly? For it would be necessary to suppose that the Godhead were recipient of quantity, and of movement which bears from one place to another; or if the Godhead be unembodied, at large and everywhere, and not in place and circumscript, how will it pass through a single body? But whatever it be that you are saying, how do you not need to clear it up and say it more openly, if confident in your own opinions about it, you are able to testify to their incorruption? where (I pray) have you heard the God-inspired Scripture say that the Word of God passed through the holy Virgin? For that brief and contracted is the life of those upon earth, the blessed David taught saying, Man, I his days as grass, as a flower of the field so he flourisheth; for the wind passeth through him and he shall not be, but of the holy Virgin what thing of this sort can you say has been written? That God has been born of her, after the flesh I mean, God-inspired Scripture has clearly shewn.

But I will turn again to your own words, most excellent one, for you yourself have also confessed, and very often at that, that the Word has been made Flesh, and you do not reject this. You say this as well, for you say that the Godhead of the Only-Begotten was clearly and openly Incarnate. You have written in this manner,

But I will go again to your own words, O all-excellent, for you have yourself too confessed and this most often that the Word has been made Flesh, and you reject it not. And this too you say besides: for you say that the Godhead of the Only-Begotten was clearly and openly Incarnate. You have written in this wise,

§3

Nestorius: "So Scripture says elsewhere too, 'He spoke to us in His Son Whom He appointed Heir of all things through Whom also He made the worlds, Who being the Brightness of His Glory.' After using the word 'Son,' it fearlessly calls Him both 'Brightness of His Glory' and 'appointed Heir'—Heir appointed according to the Flesh, Brightness of the Father's Glory according to the Godhead, for when He became flesh He did not depart from likeness to the Father. And in addition it says again, 'For the times of ignorance God overlooked, but now commands all people to repent, because He fixed a Day in which He will judge the world by the Man Whom He appointed, having given assurance to all people in that He raised Him from the dead.' Having first said 'By the Man,' Paul then adds 'In that He raised Him from the dead,' so that no one might suppose that the Godhead Incarnate had died."5

Nestorius: "Thus it says elsewhere too, He spoke to us in His Son Whom He appointed Heir of all things through Whom also He made the worlds, Who being the Brightness of His Glory: having put Son, it calls Him fearlessly both Brightness of His Glory, and appointed Heir; Heir, appointed after the Flesh, Brightness of the Father's Glory after the Godhead: for He departed not, made flesh, from likeness to the Father. And in addition it again says thus, for the times of ignorance God winked at, but now commandeth all men to repent, because He fixed a Day in which He will judge the world by the Man Whom He appointed, having given assurance unto all men in that He raised Him from the dead. Having first said, By the Man, he then adds, In that He raised Him from the dead, that no one might suppose that the Godhead Incarnate had died."5

Who then is He Who was Incarnate, or in what way was He incarnate, what Godhead was incarnate—tell us, most excellent sir, who would learn it. Shall we grant that the Word, God out of God, was Incarnate, and say that He was made Man, having been made as we are and born in flesh? Or shall we not allow this at all, but suppose that a man came into existence, connected with God, according to your view? But you will, I suppose, say that it is better and wiser to think that the Word out of God was Incarnate and made flesh, according to the Scriptures. For one is not seen assuming that wherein one already is, but if one comes somehow to be in that wherein one was not at first, reason will immediately admit that something new has been done regarding him. Therefore it is ignorant to say that any of us, having stepped out of the boundaries of human nature, have been incarnate and been made flesh. But the Incarnation, or being made flesh, will suit (and that very reasonably) the Nature that is beyond humanity. But if He was truly Incarnate and has been made flesh, He is recognized as Man, and not connected with a man by mere indwelling or external relation or connection, as you say. Yet even though He became Man, He possesses the being God in complete security, nor do we say that any change took place of the flesh into the Nature of Godhead, and we hold that the reverse did not take place either, for the physis of the Word has remained what it is even when united to flesh. Why then do you put in your book something that no one even in bare thought thinks of holding, as though it were actually spoken, and pretend to be defending the doctrines of piety? For some of the holy fathers have also used the term mixture, but since you say you are afraid lest any confusion be thought to take place, as in the case of liquids mingled with one another, I free you from your fears. For they did not think this way—how could they?—but they used the word improperly, wanting to declare the extreme union of the things that had come together. And we say that the Word of God came together with His proper Flesh in union indissoluble and unalterable. And we find that the God-inspired Scripture itself does not examine the word closely, but uses it rather improperly and simply. And indeed the Divine Paul has written of some, "But the word preached did not profit them, who were not mixed in faith with its hearers." Were those of whom he spoke going to be mixed with one another in this fashion, as wine with water, and undergo a confusion of persons? Or were they rather to be united in soul, as it is written in the Acts of the holy Apostles, "And of the multitude of them that believed was the heart and the soul one"? But this, I suppose, is the truth, not the other. Be free then from all fear on this matter, for the mind of the saints is firmly established.

Who then is He Who was Incarnate, or in what way was He incarnate, what Godhead was incarnate, tell (O most excellent sir) to us who would learn it. Shall we grant that the Word, God out of God, was Incarnate, and say that He was made Man, as having been made as we and born in flesh? or shall we allow this in no wise, but suppose that a man came hereto, connected with God, according to thee? But you will (I suppose) say, that it is better and wise to think that the Word out of God was Incarnate and made flesh, according to the Scriptures: for one is not I suppose seen assuming that wherein one is, but if one come somehow to be in that wherein one was not at first, reason will forthwith admit that something new has been wrought regarding him. Hence it is unlearned to say that any of us having stepped forth of the definitions of human nature have been incarnate and been made flesh; but the Incarnation, or being made flesh, will beseem (and that with much reason) the Nature That is beyond humanity. But if He was truly Incarnate and has been made flesh, He is accredited as Man, and not connected with a man, by mere indwelling or external relation or connection, as you say. Yet even though He became Man, He possesseth the being God in all security, nor do we say that any change took place of the flesh into the Nature of Godhead, and we hold that neither did the reverse take place, for the nature of the Word hath remained what it is even when united to flesh. What no one therefore even in bare idea thinks of holding, why do you putting this in your book, as though actually uttered, pretend to be contending for the doctrines of piety? For the name mixture, some of the holy fathers too have put: but since you say that you are afraid lest any confusion be deemed to take place, as in the case of liquids mingled with one another, I rid you from your fears, for not so did they deem (how could they?) but they used the word improperly, anxious to declare the extreme union of the things that had come together; and we say that the Word of God came together with His proper Flesh, in union indissoluble and unalterable. And we find that the God-inspired Scripture itself too, does not look minutely into the word, but uses it rather improperly and simply. And verily the Divine Paul hath written of some, But the Word preached did not profit them, who wore not mixed in faith with its hearers. Were they of whom he spoke going to be mixed one with another, after this fashion, as wine with water, and to undergo a confusion of persons, or were they rather to be united in soul, as it is written in the Acts of the holy Apostles, And of the multitude of them that believed was the heart and the soul one? But this I suppose is the truth, not the other. Be free then from all fear on this score, for firmly established is the mind of the saints.

But since to say that the physis of the Word was Incarnate is (I believe) nothing other than to hold that It has been made Man and not without birth from a woman (for this is the only way that the physis of human bodies knows of), how were you not taught by the God-inspired Scripture about the Birth according to the flesh of the Only-Begotten? Yet you yourself too, when the prophetic lessons were before you, "Unto us a Child was born, unto us a Son was given," say this about the Child who was born: "Great is the mystery of the gift, for this is the Babe Who is seen, this the newborn That appears, this that needed bodily swaddling bands, this the just-born according to the ousia (essence) that is seen, in the hidden part Everlasting Son, Son Creator of all, Son Who by the swaddling-bands of His own aid binds the instability of the creation." And elsewhere again, "And the Babe is God All-free, so far removed is God the Word, O Arius, from being subject to God." In these words he called even the body connected with Him God. And again, "We recognize therefore the human physis of the Babe and His Godhead, we preserve the oneness of the Sonship in the physis of manhood and Godhead." Look here with complete clarity you say that the Babe, the just-born, the visible, the newborn, the swaddled, is Son and Creator of all; and the Babe the holy Virgin has borne to us. You know therefore that God has been born according to the flesh, and this you have learned from the God-inspired Scripture. For who will be conceived to be Creator of all, except He alone through Whom the Father has made all?

But since to say that the Nature of the Word was Incarnate is (I deem) nought else than to hold that It has been made Man and not without birth of woman (for this only way does the nature of human bodies know of), how were you not taught by the God-inspired Scripture the Birth after the flesh of the Only-Begotten? albeit yourself too, when the prophetic lessons were before you, Unto us a Child was horn, unto us a Son was given, say thus of the Child that was born, " Great the mystery of the gift, for this is the Babe That is seen, this the new-born That appears, this that needed bodily swaddling bands, this the just-born after the Essence that is seen, in the hidden part Everlasting Son, Son Creator of all, Son Who by the swaddling-bands of His own aid binds the instability of the creation. " And elsewhere again, " And the Babe is God All-free, so far removed is God the Word, O Arius, from being subject to God." In which words he styled even the body connected with Him God. And again, We recognise therefore the human nature of the Babe and His Godhead, we preserve the oneness of the Sonship in the nature of manhood and Godhead. " Lo here with all clearness you say that the Babe, the just-born, the visible, the new-born, the swaddled, is Son and Creator of all; and the Babe the holy Virgin hath borne to us. You know therefore that God has been born after the flesh, and this you have learnt out of the God-inspired Scripture. For who will be conceived to be Creator of all, save He alone through Whom the Father hath made all?

But I said (you will perhaps say) "in the secret part Son and Creator of all." Well, I agree, but I will ask you: You say that the hidden one is the Word of God and that this is the Creator of all. How then did you just now point out with your finger the infant just born, newborn and in swaddling clothes, and call this same one both Son of God and Creator of all? Or do you perhaps suppose that the Word out of God has been transformed into the physis of the flesh, and thereby accuse yourself, not others, of daring to say this? Surely if the infant is the hidden Son and Creator of all, and has been born of the holy Virgin, you have acknowledged with us even against your will that she is Mother of God in some unexpected way, since how is an infant God all-free? For if you use the word "all-free" in the sense in which each one of us too may be so conceived, as entrusted by God with the reins of his own free will, what is there special in him beyond the rest? Or why do you attribute to him this freedom as some God-befitting and truly exceptional dignity? Yet it is in the power of all upon the earth to possess it, and indeed they already have it. But if freedom here signifies not being subject to the laws of another, and he is free in the way that the Divine Nature itself is also conceived of, how do you say that the newborn infant is in a condition so august and befitting only the Supreme Nature and glory? Yet everything that is called into being is subject to God and runs under the yoke of bondage. But you will perhaps think that empty word of yours suffices for all this—that I mean in respect of the physeis being connected one with another, and that not personally but rather in honor unvarying in each and equality of rank. For this is what you are always saying to us without learning. But that in saying such things you will be caught relying upon rotten and fragile conceptions will be shown, and not at great length, when opportunity arises for us to speak upon this too.6

But I said (you will haply say) " in the secret part Son and Creator of all." Well, I agree, but I will ask you: You say that the hidden is the Word of God and that this is the Creator of all: how then did you but now point out as with your finger the Babe just-born and new-born and in swaddling clothes, and called this same both Son of God and Creator of all? or do you haply suppose that the Word out of God has been transformed into the nature of the flesh, and accuse yourself, not others, of daring to say this? Surely if the Babe be the hidden Son and Creator of all, and have been born of the holy Virgin, you have acknowledged with us even against your will that she is Mother of God in some unlooked-for way, since how is a babe God all-free? For if you use the word, all-free, in the sense in which each one of us too may be so conceived, as entrusted by God with the reins of his own free-will, what is there special in Him beyond the rest? or why do you put about Him the freedom, as some God-befitting and truly choice Dignity? albeit it is in the power of all upon the earth to possess it and indeed they already have it. But if the freedom here signify the being not subject to the laws of another, and He be free in such sort as the Divine Nature itself too is conceived of, how do you say that the new-born Babe is in case so august and befitting only the Supreme Nature and glory? albeit that all which is called into being is subject unto God and runs under the yoke of bondage. But you will perchance deem that that empty word of yours suffices unto all this, that I mean in respect of the natures being connected one with another, and that, not Personally, but rather in honour unvarying [in each] and equality of rank: for this is what you are always unlearnedly saying to us. But that in saying such things, you will be caught to be staying yourself upon rotten and fragile conceptions, will be shewn and not at length, when opportunity offers to us to speak upon this too.6

But after these points he adds some others by which he thinks he can demonstrate—and skillfully at that—that a mode of generation like ours is unfitting and impossible. And he arrays our words against himself, and thinks he can easily overpower them and show that they are nothing, even though they set forth the truth. He says this:

But to these he subjoins some others by which he deems that he can shew and that skillfully that the mode of a generation like ours is unmeet and impossible. And our words he arrays against himself, and deems that he can over-master them easily and shew that they are nothing although they set forth the truth. He says thus:

§4

Nestorius says: "If Christ is God, and Christ was born of the blessed Mary, how is the Virgin not the mother of God?" I am not hiding any of their objections, because the lover of truth considers and objects to himself everything that comes from falsehood. Then he tries to provide a solution using ideas like these. He says: "The baby is formed in the womb, but as long as it has not yet been formed, it has no soul. Once it is formed, God gives it a soul. Just as a woman bears the body and God gives it a soul, the woman is not called mother of the soul just because she bore a human being endowed with a soul, but rather mother of the human being. In the same way," he says, "the blessed Virgin, even though she bore a human being with the Word of God passing forth along with him"—this was the word he used—"is not therefore mother of God."7

Nestorius: "'If Christ (says he) be God, and Christ be born of the blessed Mary, how is not the Virgin mother of God?' I hide none of their objections: for the lover of the truth takes and objects to himself all that comes of the falsehood;" and then he endeavours to apply the solution, using some such conceptions as these. " For the babe (he says) is formed in the womb, but so long as it have not yet been formed, it hath no soul, but being formed at length, it has a soul made it of God. As then the woman bears the body, God ensouls it, and the woman is not called mother of soul, because she bare a man endowed with soul, but rather mother of man, so (he says) the blessed Virgin too, even though she have borne a man, the Word of God passing forth along with him" (for this word did he use) "not therefore is she mother of God."7

Is therefore (tell me) what we say blamed by you? Does it seem right to you to find fault without understanding what is said so rightly and purely, and do you not rather attribute the blame of not being able to think correctly to your own understanding? For those to whom the truth is repugnant will too readily be receptive to what is false, and the rebuke of those who are accustomed to speak most excellently will not be without harm. Indeed, it will even be a clear demonstration of having declined into falsehood and of choosing to honor what it would be more right to hate, since one has missed right reason. But no man, having conceived of such base things…, he said that he himself was the lover of truth and that we had contrived the lie, although one may see on the contrary that ours is right and true. For the advocate of lies and fraud tries to fasten the blame of his falsehood on the champions of truth, perhaps driven to forgetfulness of the Prophet who says, "Woe unto them that call evil good and good evil, that put darkness for light and light for darkness."8

Is therefore (tell me) that blamed by you which is said by us? does it seem right to you without understanding to find fault with what is so rightly and purely said, and do you not rather attach the blame of not being able to think aright to your own understanding? For they to whom the truth is repugnant, to them will belong (and too readily) the receptivity of what is not so, and the rebuke of those who are wont to speak most excellently, will not be without its harm, yea rather will be even a manifest demonstration of the having declined unto falsehood and of choosing to honour what it would be more right to hate, in that one has missed of right reason. But no man, having conceived of things so base…, he said that himself was the lover of the truth, and that we had contrived the lie; albeit one may see on the contrary that ours is right and true. For the advocate of the lie and fraud endeavours to fasten the blame of his falsehood on the champions of the truth, haply driven to forgetfulness of the Prophet who says, Woe unto them that call evil good and good evil, that put darkness for light and light for darkness.8

But I will try to show by the example he used that he doesn't even clearly know what he is saying. For flesh is admittedly born of flesh, and the Creator of all things performs the ensouling in the manner and way that He knows. Yet the woman who gives birth, even though she is the source of the flesh only, is believed to give birth to the whole man, composed (I mean) of soul and body, although she contributes nothing of her own to the existence of the soul. Yet when someone says "man," one surely means the soul united to the body. Therefore, just as the woman, even though she gives birth to the body alone, is said to give birth to one who is made up of soul and body, and this in no way damages the understanding of the soul, as though it found the origin of its existence in flesh—so too should you think about the blessed Virgin. For even though she is mother of the holy Flesh, she has nevertheless given birth to God the Word from God truly united to it, and though anyone may call her Mother of God, he will not be defining a more recent beginning for God the Word, nor claiming that the flesh has been made the starting point of His existence. Rather, he will understand the manner of the economy and, marveling at it, will say, "O Lord, I have heard Your hearing and was afraid; I considered Your works and was astonished."9

But I will endeavour to shew by the example adduced by him that he does not even clearly know what he is saying. For flesh confessedly is born of flesh, and the Artificer of all performs the ensouling in the mode and way that He knows. Yet is the woman who bears, albeit she is the source of the flesh only, believed to bear the whole man, made up (I mean) of soul and body, although she contribute nothing of her own to the being of the soul. Yet when one says man, one signifies surely the soul united to the body. As therefore the woman, albeit she bear the body alone, is said to bear him that is made up of soul and body, and this no wise damages the account of the soul, as though it found in flesh the origin of its being; so will you conceive as to the blessed Virgin too: for even though she be mother of the holy Flesh, she hath nevertheless borne God the Word out of God truly united thereto, and though any call her Mother of God, he will not be defining a more recent beginning of God the Word nor that the flesh hath been made the commencement of His Being: but will understand rather the mode of the economy and wondering at it will say, O Lord, I have heard Thy hearing and was afraid, I considered Thy works and was astonished.9

But our all-wise and prudent interpreter, having carefully considered the force of the example says, "In the same way, the holy Virgin, even though she has given birth to a man with God the Word passing along with him, is nevertheless not therefore Mother of God. For the Dignity of the Word did not come from the blessed Virgin, but He was God by physis."

Bat our all-wise and prudent expounder, having pondered the force of the example says, "Thus the holy Virgin, too, even though she hath borne man, God the Word passing along with him, yet not therefore is she Mother of God: for not from the blessed Virgin was the Dignity of the Word, but He was God by Nature."

What therefore he means by saying that the Word passed forth along with the flesh, he alone knows, but I am greatly amazed at his subtle refinement. For the word of truth declares that the Word of God has been personally united to the flesh, yet he keeps insisting on the passing forth along with—meaning something I do not understand. Next, when our entire discussion concerned nature and personal union, and aimed at investigating not what the Word from God is with respect to dignity, but whether He has been made man economically, making His own the flesh born of a woman—he shifts the question to completely different matters and says, "Not from the holy Virgin was the Dignity of the Word, but He was God by physis," although how are not dignity and physis two entirely different things? But our discussion on this point does not require excessive skill. We must therefore see what comes next. For he fortifies yet another defensive position against what has been said by us, which he thinks is invincible and capable of demonstrating with full force that the birth from a woman of Emmanuel is merely empty talk on our part. He says again as follows:10

What therefore is the meaning of, that the Word passed forth along with the flesh, he alone knows, but I marvel much at his subtil refinement. For the word of truth sets forth that the Word of God has been Personally united to the Flesh; and he keeps affirming the passing forth along with, meaning I know not what. Next, when our discussion was all about nature and Personal Union, and aimed at enquiring not what the Word out of God is in respect to Dignity, but whether He has been made Man economically, making His own the flesh born of a woman: he removing the question to quite other matters says, "Not from the holy Virgin was the Dignity of the Word, but He was God by Nature:" albeit how are not Dignity and Nature two entirely different things? But our discourse hereupon does not need overmuch skill 4: we must therefore see what comes next. For he fortifies yet another outpost against what has been said by us, as he thinks invincible and competent to shew with all force that the Birth out of woman of Emmanuel is empty talk of ours: he says again thus,10

§5

Nestorius: "The blessed John the Baptist is announced beforehand by the holy Angels, saying that the child will be filled with the Holy Spirit even from his mother's womb, and having the Holy Spirit, this blessed Baptist was born. What then? Do you call Elizabeth mother of the Spirit? Pay attention here, even though there are some among you who are shocked at what is being said—forgive their lack of experience."

Nestorius: "The blessed John Baptist is fore-heralded by the holy Angels, that the babe shall be filled with the Holy Ghost even from his mother's womb, and having the Holy Ghost, was this blessed Baptist born. What then? call you Elizabeth mother of the Spirit? apply your mind here, although there be some among you who are startled at what is said, pardon their inexperience."

And who on hearing such words will not immediately say in the Prophet's voice, "The fool will utter folly and his heart will conceive vanity, to accomplish iniquity and to utter error against the Lord"? For this is admittedly error and nothing else—to trust in such weak and childish thoughts as though they were true. One may marvel at him for his gentleness, since he said that those who had no acquaintance with his words ought to be considered worthy of pardon and mercy. Yet this would be something we ourselves would long for three times over (if it were possible), and indeed all who are Christians would long for it too. For how could everyone not long to be freed from words so burdensome and perverse? But we say this: Elizabeth admittedly bore the blessed Baptist anointed in the womb with the Holy Spirit, and if the God-inspired Scriptures had said anywhere that the Spirit too was made flesh, you would be right to say that she ought to be called by us mother of the Spirit. But if the child is said to have been honored with bare anointing only, why do you think it right to put the fact of incarnation on an equal footing with the grace of participation? For it is not the same thing to say that the Word was made flesh and that one has been anointed through the Spirit with prophetic spirit. For of the holy Virgin it is written, "Behold a Virgin shall conceive and bear a Son," and He who is born is called the fruit and moreover Emmanuel, which being interpreted is "God with us." But of Elizabeth, "she shall bear a son who shall go before Him in the spirit and power of Elijah, and shall go before the face of the Lord to prepare His ways." By no means therefore is Elizabeth mother of the Spirit, for she bore a prophet of the Most High. But the holy Virgin is truly mother of God, for she has borne carnally—that is, according to the flesh—God united to flesh. For since she is human who bore, therefore and rightly do we say that the mode of generation has been accomplished in human fashion. For in this way and no other way was it possible that He Who is over all nature could become as we are, not ceasing to be what He is (how could He?), but rather remaining what He was and is and will be. For the Divine and Most High Nature is superior to change.11

And who on hearing such words will not straightway say in Prophet's voice, For the fool will utter folly and his heart will conceive vanity, to accomplish iniquity and to utter error against the Lord? For error confessedly is it and nought else, to trust in such frigid and childish thoughts as though they were true. One may then marvel at him for his gentleness, for he said that they ought to be esteemed worthy of pardon and clemency who had no acquaintance with those words of his: yet were it a thing thrice-longed for by us ourselves (if so be), yea rather by all too who are Christians; for how should not all long to be rid from words so burdensome and perverse? But we say this: Elizabeth hath confessedly borne the blessed Baptist anointed in the womb with the Holy Ghost: and if it had been any where said by the God-inspired Scriptures, that the Spirit too was made flesh, rightly would you have said that she ought to be called by us mother of the Spirit; but if the bairn is said to have been honoured with bare anointing only, why deem you it right to put the fact of incarnation on an equal footing with the grace of participation? for it is not the same thing, to say that the Word was made flesh and that one has been anointed through the Spirit with prophetic spirit. For of the holy Virgin it is written, Behold a Virgin shall conceive and bear a Son, and He who is born is called the fruit and moreover Emmanuel, which being interpreted is, God with us; but of Elizabeth, she shall bear a son who shall go before Him in the spirit and power of Elias, and shall go before the face of the Lord to prepare His ways. By no means therefore is Elizabeth mother of the Spirit, for she bare a prophet of the Highest: but the holy Virgin is truly mother of God, for she hath borne carnally, i. e., according to the flesh, God united to flesh. For since she is human who bare, therefore and rightly do we say that the mode of generation has been wrought in human wise; for thus and no otherwise was it possible that He Who is over all nature could become as we, not slighting the being what He is (how could He?) but rather abiding what He was and is and will be: for superior to change is the Divine and Most High Nature.11

That we think correctly in affirming that God has been born according to the flesh for the salvation of all, God-inspired Scripture has testified. But since he opposes the truth and the very symbol of the Church's Faith with his most novel doctrines—the symbol which the fathers once gathered together at Nicaea defined through the illumination of the Spirit—he fears that some might keep the Faith whole, having been instructed in the truth by their words. So he tries to slander it, alters the meaning of the words, and dares to falsify the very force of its ideas with a counterfeit stamp. For while he himself was using profane babblings in the midst of the Church, a certain man of great piety, though a layman, who possessed no small learning, was moved with fervent and devout zeal and cried out sharply that the Word Himself, Who exists before the ages, endured a second generation also—namely, that according to the flesh and from a woman. The people were disturbed at this. The majority and the wiser ones honored him with considerable praise as pious, full of wisdom, and not lacking in doctrinal uprightness, while the rest were enraged against him. Nestorius, interrupting, immediately approved those whom he had destroyed by teaching them his own doctrine, and sharpened his tongue against the man who could not endure his words—and indeed against the holy fathers who have decreed for us the pious definition of the Faith, which we have as an anchor of the soul both sure and steadfast, as it is written.1213

That we therefore think aright in affirming that God has been born according to the flesh for the salvation of all,.. God-inspired Scripture hath testified: but since to his most novel dogmas he opposes the truth and the very symbol of the Church's Faith, which the fathers once gathered together at Nicea through the illumination of the Spirit defined; he, fearing lest any should keep whole the Faith, instructed unto the Truth by their words, endeavours to calumniate it and alters the significance of the words, and dares to coin with false stamp the very force of its ideas. For while himself in the midst of the Church was using profane babblings, a certain man of those who were of great piety and yet among the laity, but who had gathered within himself no mean learning, was moved with fervent and devout zeal and with piercing cry said that the Word Himself Who is before the ages endured a second Generation also, viz., that after the flesh and forth of a woman; the people being disturbed hereat, and the more part and wiser having honoured him with no mean praises, as pious and most full of wisdom and not imparticipate in uprightness of doctrine, the rest being mad against him, he [Nestorius] interrupting, straightway approves those whom by teaching his own he had destroyed, and whets his tongue against him who could not endure his words, yea and against the holy fathers who have decreed for us the pious definition of the Faith which we have as an anchor of the soul both sure and steadfast, as it is written.1213

§6

Nestorius said: "I rejoice when I see your zeal, but the matter itself clearly refutes what has been said through the pollution of this wretched man. For where there are two births, there are two sons, but the Church knows one Son, Christ the Lord."14

Nestorius: "For (said he) I rejoice at beholding your zeal; but from the thing itself is a clear confutation of what has been said by the pollution of this wretched man; for whereof the births are two, two sons are they, but the Church knoweth one Son Christ the Lord."14

Most foolishly, therefore, he puts forward the definition of his ideas on this matter, saying, "for whereof the births are two, two sons are they." But leaving aside for a while his subtle precision on this point, come, let us gather what pertains to accurate investigation for the consideration of the matter. He therefore made it inadmissible to speak of two generations, but says that one ought to be confessed by us, so that we do not conceive of two sons (as though it were necessary, if the births are two, that two sons also should be introduced). Let him come forward and tell us which of the generations he will admit: that before the ages from out the Father, in which the Word was God not yet Incarnate, or this one, recent and out of a woman.15

Most foolishly therefore put he forth the definition of his ideas on this matter saying, "for whereof the births are two two sons are they." But letting alone for a while his subtil accuracy herein, come, come let us gather what pertains to accurate investigation for the consideration of the matter. He therefore made it inadmissible [to speak of two generations] but says that one ought to be confessed by us, that we conceive not of two sons (as though it were necessary if the births be two, that two sons also should be introduced): let him come forward and tell us which of the generations he will admit, that before the ages from out the Father, wherein the Word was God not yet Incarnate, or this one, recent and out of a woman.15

If then he says that alone—I mean the one before the ages from the Father—that one alone will be Son who is out of Him by physis and not yet a participant in flesh and blood, then the Mystery of the Incarnation is spoken of in vain (as it seems), and in no way has He emptied Himself or been made in the form of a servant, but has remained as He was, rejecting the true union with flesh even until now. But if the one who is in the last times out of woman shall be called by himself son, and we will admit this one generation—I mean out of woman—then the Word from God the Father has necessarily fallen away from being Son by physis.

If then he say that alone, I mean the one before the ages from out the Father, that one alone will be Son Who is out of Him by Nature and not yet participate of flesh and blood: and vainly (as it seems) is the Mystery of the Incarnation uttered, and in no wise hath He emptied Himself nor been made in servant's form, but hath remained thus, rejecting the true concurrence with flesh even until now. But he who is in the last times out of woman, shall be styled by himself son, and we will admit this one generation, I mean out of woman; needs has the Word out of God the Father fallen away from being by Nature Son.

But the devout person clearly sees the absurdity of such ideas and how severely they swerve toward impiety. So that we may proceed along the royal road, we say that there were two births, yet one Son through both: the Word from God not yet made flesh, and the Same afterwards incarnate and enduring for us the birth of a woman according to the flesh. For if someone said with regard to human beings that two sons must surely be conceived of if we speak of two births, he would speak rightly and it would be true. But since the Mystery of Christ and the mode of the Incarnation follows another path and is not seen in the same way as ours, why does he, looking at our situation and then fixing his mind on what is marvelous and beyond speech, get caught falling into the weakest and most ignorant narrowness of belief? What surprises me is this: while confessing here that the Church knows one Son and adding "the Lord Christ," he has no longer kept to One, for he severs from one another things that are united and sets each apart. He does not ask what the Word is by physis, or what the flesh is, but instead gathers into one, man and God, in equality of glory only, as he supposes—which is something utterly implausible, or rather impossible—and he brings down the pattern of the mystery to uncomeliness. Thus he says:

But the pious man sees full surely the absurdity of such ideas and its exceeding swerving unto impiety. In order then that we may proceed along the royal road, we say. that two were the Births, one the Son through both, the Word out of God not yet made in flesh, the Same afterwards Incarnate and enduring for us the birth of a woman after the flesh. For if one said in regard of men that two sons must surely be conceived of, if we speak of two births, he would say rightly and it would be true; but since the Mystery of Christ and the mode of the Incarnation hath another path, and is not beheld in like wise with what is ours, why is he, looking at our habits, and then fastening his mind on what is marvellous and above speech, caught fall ing into feeblest and unlearned pettiness of belief? What surprises me is this: he confessing herein that the Church knows one Son, and adding, The Lord Christ, hath no longer kept One, for he sunders one from another things united, and putteth each apart, not enquiring what the Word is by Nature, what the flesh also; but gathering rather into one, man and God in equality of glory only, as he deemeth, which is a thing utterly implausible, yea rather impossible, he casts down the scheme of the mystery unto uncomeliness. Thus he saith:

§7

Nestorius: "But we must (since this has now come to mind) recognize that the Synod of Nicaea also nowhere dared to say that God was born of Mary. Instead, it said, 'We believe in One God the Father Almighty and in One Lord Jesus Christ.' Notice that having first used the word Christ, which indicates the two natures (physeis), they did not say 'in one God the Word,' but used the name that signifies both, so that when you hear about death later on, you would not find it strange, so that the words 'crucified' and 'buried' would not strike the ear as if the Godhead suffered these things." Then it continues, "We believe in One Lord Jesus Christ, the Only Begotten Son, begotten from the Father, consubstantial (homoousios) with the Father, who came down from heaven for our sake, and was incarnate by the Holy Spirit. They did not say 'and begotten by the Holy Spirit.'" And he says that the holy fathers, interpreting what "incarnate" means, say "made man." And explaining what "made man" means, he himself said again, "His own physis not undergoing change into flesh, but dwelling in man."

Nestorius: "But we must (for it has now come into my mind) learn that the Synod of Nicea too nowhere durst say that God was born of Mary; for it said, We believe in One God the Father Almighty and in One Lord Jesus Christ. Observe that having first put the word Christ, which is the indication of the two natures, they did not say, in one God the Word, but took the name that signifies both, in order that when lower down you hear of death, you think it not strange; in order that the words crucified and buried may not strike the ear as though the Godhead suffered these things." Then it goes on, "We believe in One Lord Jesus Christ, the Only Begotten Son, the Begotten out of the Father, the Consubstantial with the Father, Who came down from the heavens for our sakes, and was Incarnate of the Holy Ghost. They said not, and begotten of the Holy Ghost." And he says that the holy fathers interpreting what is the meaning of Incarnate say, Made Man. And what being made Man means he himself making clear, said again, "His own Nature not undergoing change into flesh, but inhabitation in man. "

Will any Christian tolerate either the delusion found in these words or the impiety of his ideas? To those with truly sound minds, aren't these things obviously absurd and no small outburst of blasphemy against Christ? For he slanders the truth, saying that He is not truly Son, assigning this to another (for "observe," he says, "that having first put the word Christ which is the indication of the two natures, they did not say, We believe in One God the Word"). Regarding the name Christ, I will soon examine whether it indicates the two natures or not, but let us focus on what is before us as best we can. For what he babbles forth so absurdly and carelessly is completely intolerable, but one might well say, speaking on behalf of the holy fathers: What are you doing, good sir, directing your crude tongue against holy men, to whom applies what Christ Himself, the Savior of us all, said: "It is not you who speak, but the Spirit of your Father who speaks through you"? For what have they not conceived of things refined to admirable subtlety? What needful doctrine have they overlooked, or what method of safeguarding neglected? "They have not dared," he says, "insert in their words concerning the Faith that God the Word was born of Mary." If you therefore accuse our predecessors for this reason, and say you are aggrieved because they are not found to use your exact words, then I suppose it is time to accuse along with them the holy Apostles and Evangelists too, for they compiled the books of instruction concerning Christ, yet one will not find them using word for word your expressions. But (if you please) pass this over… but consider instead that they have done well in their explanation of this matter, for faith in the Holy and Consubstantial Trinity is required of us. But since they say they believe in One God the Father Almighty, Maker of all things visible and invisible, and in One Lord Jesus Christ His Son, and no other (according to us) is Jesus Christ the Lord than the One who is by nature and truly Son, who shining forth from God and being God the Word has been made Man, by birth (that is) from a woman, how will those who proclaim the manner of the economy not be found also to speak of His birth from a woman according to the flesh? For then truly has the Word who is God and Wisdom and Life and Light, the Son, been named Christ Jesus. It is therefore clear that the time of such naming coincides with the birth, namely through the holy Virgin. That believing in Christ Jesus, we believe in the One who is by nature and truly Son, our faith ascending to the Father through Him, will be evident, since He Himself has proclaimed to the whole world, "He who believes in Me believes not in Me but in Him who sent Me," and "He who sees Me sees Him who sent Me," and again, "Believe in God, and believe in Me." And we do not (I suppose) say that He asks of us two faiths, but rather He teaches that if anyone admits the faith directed toward Him, he has believed in the Father Himself.1617

Will any one of those who rank as Christians endure either the infatuation that there is in these words or the impiety of his ideas? To those of really sound mind are not these things a manifest ribaldry, and no mean kind of openmouthedness against Christ? for he slanders the truth, he says that He is not truly Son, allotting this to another (for " observe, he says, that having first put the word Christ which is the indication of the two natures, they did not say, We believe in One God the Word)." And as regards the Name, I mean Christ, I will presently enquire whether it be significative of the two Natures or not, but what is before us we will exercise ourselves in, as we can. For in no wise to be borne may those things be that are so absurdly and heedlessly babbled forth by him, but one might (I deem) say, speaking in behalf of the holy fathers, What art thou doing, noble sir, putting forth rude tongue against holy men, to whom will beseem that which was said by Christ Himself the Saviour of us all, It is not YE that speak, but the Spirit of your Father Which speaketh in you? for what has there not been conceived of by them of things exceeding well polished unto an admirable subtilty? what of needful doctrines has been overlooked, or what method of safeguard neglected by them? " They have not dared (he says) insert in their words concerning the Faith that God the Word was born of Mary." If therefore thou for this reason accuse those who have been before us, and sayest thou art aggrieved because they are not found to use thy exact words, it is time (I suppose) to accuse along with them the holy Apostles and Evangelists too, for they have compiled the books of instruction concerning Christ, yet one will not find them using word for word your expressions. But (if it please you) pass this over as……..but consider rather that they have well wrought out their explanation of this matter, for faith in the Holy and Consubstantial Trinity is exacted of us. But since they say that they believe in One God the Father Almighty, Maker of all things both visible and invisible, and in One Lord Jesus Christ His Son, and none other (according to us) is Jesus Christ the Lord than the One and by Nature and truly Son, Who beaming from out of God and being God the Word has been made Man, by birth (that is) out of woman, how will they who proclaim the mode of the economy not be found to speak also of His Birth of a woman after the flesh? for then in truth has the Word which is God and Wisdom and Life and Light, the Son, been named Christ Jesus. It is manifest therefore that the time of such naming has concurrent with it the Birth, that I mean through the holy-Virgin. That believing on Christ Jesus, we believe in the One and by Nature and truly Son, our faith mounting up unto the Father through Him, will be clear, in that He Himself hath cried aloud to the whole world, He that believeth on Me believeth not on Me but on Him that sent Me, and he that seeth Me seeth Him that sent Me, and again, Believe on God, and believe on Me. And we do not (I suppose) say that He asks of us two faiths, but rather He teaches that if any admit the faith to Himward, he hath believed on the Father Himself.1617

But since (as is likely) he will make use of the shared nature of these names, claiming that Christ and Lord, and indeed Son, are common titles, and will assert that they apply to the Word who came from the Father even when He is thought of as alone and not yet sharing in flesh, and likewise to the Temple born from a virgin, this matter requires (I think) considerable investigation. Setting it aside for now until a time (as I said) that properly belongs to it, let us move to another statement of the holy Synod which this man, twisting it to suit his own preference, does violence to the force of truth. For he says that the fathers have written, "We believe in One Lord Jesus Christ, the Only-Begotten Son, begotten from the Father, consubstantial with the Father, who came down for our sake, and was incarnate of the Holy Spirit." He adds to this and says of the holy fathers, "Later on they explain that He who was made man is the one who is said to be incarnate, the divine physis not undergoing change into flesh but dwelling in man." In his explanation he again holds to the same view and moreover says this:

But since (as is probable) he will be making use of the community of the names, saying that Christ and Lord, yea and Son, are common titles, and will be affirming that they suit the Word That sprung of the Father even though He be conceived of as alone and not yet participate of flesh, and likewise the Temple that sprang of a virgin, this matter needs (I think) considerable investigation: putting it off' for the present to a season (as I said) fitly belonging to it, let us go to another utterance of the holy Synod which this man perverting unto his own liking, does violence to the force of truth. For he says that the fathers have written, We believe in One Lord Jesus Christ, the Only-Begotten Son, the Begotten from forth the Father, the Consubstantial with the Father, Who came down for our sakes, and was Incarnate of the Holy Ghost. He adds hereto and says of che holy fathers, " lower down they interpret that He who was made man, He it is who is said to be Incarnate, the Divine Nature not enduring change into flesh but inhabitation in man." In his explanation he again keeps hold of the same mind and moreover says thus;

§8

Nestorius: "They followed the Evangelist, because the Evangelist also, when he came to the becoming man, avoided saying 'Birth' with respect to God the Word, and used 'Incarnation' instead. Where? Listen: 'And the Word was made flesh.' He did not say, 'Was born through the flesh.' When the Apostles or the Evangelists mention the Son, they say that He was born of a woman. Pay attention to what is being said, I beg you. When they speak the name of the Son and say that He was brought forth from a woman, they use the word 'Born.' But when they mention the Word, none of them dared to speak of birth through the human nature. For the blessed John the Evangelist, when he came to the Word and to His Incarnation, listen to what he says: 'The Word was made flesh.'"

Nestorius: "They followed the Evangelist, for the Evangelist too when he comes to the being made man, shunned saying Birth in respect of God the Word, and hath put Incarnation. Where? Hear, And the Word was made flesh; he said not, Was born through the flesh. For where the Apostles or the Evangelists make mention of the Son, they put that He was born of a woman. Give heed to what is said, I beseech you; for where they utter the name of the Son, and that He was borne from forth a woman, they put the word, Born; where they mention the Word, no one of them durst speak of birth through the human nature. For the blessed John the Evangelist, when he came to the Word and to His Incarnation, hear what he says, The Word was made flesh."

Come then, let us place side by side what he said and the definition of our Creed, and see whether this man has introduced any innovation regarding it as well.

Come therefore putting beside what he said, the definition of our Creed, let us see if ought has been innovated by this man regarding it too.

We believe in one God the Father Almighty, Maker of all things visible and invisible, and in one Lord Jesus Christ, the Son of God, begotten from the Father, only-begotten, that is, from his ousia, God from God, Light from Light, true God from true God, begotten not made, consubstantial with the Father, through whom all things were made, both those in heaven and those on earth. He came down for us men and for our salvation, and was incarnate and made man, suffered and rose on the third day, ascended into the heavens, and will come to judge the living and the dead. And we believe in the Holy Spirit.

W E BELIEVE IN ONE G OD THE F ATHER ALMIGHTY, MAKER OF ALL THINGS VISIBLE AND INVISIBLE, AND IN ONE LORD J ESUS C HRIST, THE SON OF G OD, BEGOTTEN OUT OF THE F ATHER, ONLY-BEGOTTEN THAT IS OUT OF HIS ESSENCE, G OD OUT OF G OD LIGHT OUT OF LIGHT VERY G OD OUT OF VERY G OD, BEGOTTEN NOT MADE, CONSUBSTANTIAL WITH THE F ATHER, THROUGH WHOM ALL THINGS WERE MADE, BOTH THOSE IN HEAVEN AND THOSE ON EARTH: WHO FOR US MEN AND FOR OUR SALVATION CAME DOWN AND WAS INCARNATE AND MADE MAN, SUFFERED AND ROSE THE THIRD DAY, ASCENDED INTO THE HEAVENS, COMETH TO JUDGE QUICK AND DEAD, AND IN THE HOLY GHOST.

Come now, good sir, where (tell me) have they placed the Son, who was incarnate of the Holy Spirit and the Virgin Mary? But this he cannot show at all. But consider this: They say that the Word out of God, the Only-Begotten, He who is from the ousia of the Father, He through whom all things were made, the very Light, was both incarnate and made man, suffered and rose, and also that He will come again in due time as Judge.18

Come now therefore, noble sir, where (tell me) have they put of the Son, Incarnate of the Holy Ghost and the Virgin Mary? but this he can by no means shew. But consider this. They say that the Word out of God, the Only-Begotten, He That is from forth the Essence of the Father, He through Whom are all things, the Very Light, was both incarnate and made man, suffered and rose, and too, that He will in season come again the Judge.18

But in order to subject his words to careful examination and see the extent of the ignorance in them, he affirms in plain terms that they say the Word out of God was both incarnate and made man, and he approves them with his vote as speaking the truth and saying what was fitting. So tell me, when they say that He was both incarnate and made man, do they mean anything other than that He was begotten according to the flesh? For this would be the only mode of incarnation for one who exists both outside of flesh and in his proper nature. No one would say (I suppose) that flesh has been made flesh, nor will anyone be made what he already was. But if one should conceive that a certain economic change has been made regarding him toward something else which he was not, then the expression will have great fitness. Therefore, if they say that the Only-Begotten has been incarnate, and this would be accomplished (I suppose) through fleshly generation and in no other way, how have they not plainly said that the Word, being God, has been begotten according to the flesh?

But in order that submitting to accurate scrutiny his words also, we may see what is the amount of the unlearning that is in them, he affirms in plain terms that they say that the Word out of God was both incarnate and made man, and he crowns them with his vote unto their truth as saying what was convenient. Do they therefore (tell me) in saying that He was both Incarnate and made Man mean ought else than that He was begotten after the flesh? for this would be (and alone) the mode of incarnation to one who has his existence both external to flesh and in his proper nature; for no one would say (I suppose) that flesh has been made flesh nor will any one be made what he was [already]. But if one should conceive a certain economic change to have been made regarding him unto somewhat else which he was not, the expression will then have great fitness. Hence if they say that the Only-Begotten has been Incarnate, and this would be wrought (I suppose) through fleshly generation and in no other way, how have they not plainly said that the Word being God has been begotten after the flesh?

But he says the Birth is not named in plain terms. Yes, but the nature of the thing knows (as I already said) no other way of being incarnate. So even though it is not stated in plain terms in matters of this kind, we will not abandon the only way recognized by nature and go off to another. For it is written in the Book of Genesis, "And to Seth there was made a son, and he called his name Enos." Should we then, because Scripture has used "was made," refuse to admit the mode of birth? How would that not be foolish? For the very nature of the thing will almost compel us, even against our will, to acknowledge the reality of birth. How then, on hearing of the Incarnation, does he not immediately admit the reality of Birth? And when being made man has been plainly mentioned, how did he not straightway understand that being made man would be appropriate not for a man, lest he should seem to be made what he already was, but for the Word originating from God? But where being made man is believed to truly take place, there is assuredly the birth by which he may be seen to be made man.

But (he says) the Birth is not named in plain terms. Yes, but the nature of the thing knows (as I already said) no other way of being incarnate. So that, although it be not in plain terms said in matters of this kind, we will not for this, forsaking the only way recognized by nature, go off to another. For it is written in the Book of Genesis, And to Seth there was made a son, and he called his name Enos. Shall we then, because the Scripture has put, was made, not admit the mode of birth? how would not this be unlearned? for the very nature of the thing will all but compel us even against our will to confess the idea of birth. How then on hearing of the Incarnation does he not forthwith admit the idea of Birth? and when the being made man has been plainly mentioned, how did he not straightway understand, that being made man would befit not a man, lest he should seem to be made that he already was, but the Word originating from God? But where being made man is believed to truly take place, there is full surely the birth whereby he may be seen to be made man.

But you do not think this is how the saying should be understood—that the Word of God was both Incarnate and was made Man. For you said again, trying to oppose everyone else's view, that "being made man" means not the transformation of the Divine Nature into flesh, but its indwelling in man. He says then that the conversion of the Divine Nature into flesh is both impossible and does not happen to it at all (and quite rightly, for I approve of him speaking correctly here; for I say that it is stable and will not be transformed into anything other than what it is believed to be). But I will attempt to show that his argument has missed what is fitting and true when he maintained that "being made Man" is the indwelling in man. For if he says that this applies to Emmanuel alone, let him explain why (for I cannot understand it), or no one will tolerate him as someone who defines and lays down the law about things he is pleased to speak about carelessly. But perhaps the force of these definitions does not apply to one person alone; then there will be no problem even if it applies to all. Therefore, not once but many times we shall find that God has been made man—and not only the Word from God the Father, but I will add both the Father Himself and, besides, the Holy Spirit. For He said through one of the holy Prophets concerning those who have been justified in faith, "I will dwell in them and walk in them, and I will be their God and they shall be My people." And Christ Himself also said, "And if any man hear Me, we will come—I and My Father—and make Our abode with him and lodge in him." The most wise Paul too has written somewhere, "And Moses was faithful in all his house as a servant, for a testimony of the things which were to be spoken of, but Christ as a Son over His own house whose house are we." And moreover concerning the Holy Spirit too, "Know ye not that ye are the temple of God and that the Spirit of God dwelleth in you?" Therefore, if whenever the God of all is said to dwell in anyone, this is what "being made man" or the Incarnation means, then let it be said of each one of those who were made partakers of the Divine Nature and have moreover had Him indwelling them that he has both been made man and besides was incarnate. This being so and admitted as true, the Word from God the Father might even be said to have been most often made flesh, and indeed He indwells even now in many of those who fear Him.1920

But not thus does it seem to you is the saying to be conceived of, that the Word of God was both Incarnate and was made Man; for you said again, endeavouring to oppose the idea of every one else, that the being made man, means, not the change into flesh of the Divine Nature, but its indwelling in man. He says then that the conversion into flesh of the Divine Nature is both impossible and that it in no wise befalls it (and very rightly, for we will approve him who herein has chosen to speak aright; for I say that It is stable and that It will not be transformed into ought else than what It is believed to be): but that his discourse hath missed of the fitting and true, in that he maintained that the being made Man is the indwelling in man, I shall essay to shew. For if he says that this matter is true of Emmanuel singly and alone, let him teach the reason why (for I cannot learn it), or no one will tolerate him as a definer and layer down of the law in respect of those things as to which he is pleased to speak inconsiderately. But perchance the force of the things defined does not extend unto one [alone], there will then be no blame, even though it extend unto all. Hence not once for all but many times over shall we find that God has been made man, and not only the Word out of God the Father, but I will add both the Father Himself and besides, the Holy Ghost. For He said through one of the holy Prophets of them that have been justified in faith, I will dwell in them and walk in them and I will be their God and they shall be My people. And Christ Himself also said, And if any man hear Me, we will come I and My Father and make Our abode with him and lodge in him. The most wise Paul too hath somewhere written, And Moses was faithful in all his house as a servant, for a testimony of the things which were to be spoken of, but Christ as a Son over Bis own house whose house are WE; and moreover of the Holy Ghost too, Know ye not that ye are the temple of God and that the Spirit of God dwelleth in you? Hence if when the God of all is said to dwell in any, if this be the being made man or the incarnation, let it be said in respect of each one also of those who were made partakers of the Divine Nature and have moreover had Him indwelling them, that he has both been made man and besides was incarnate. This now being so and admitted as true, the Word out of God the Father might even be said to have been most often made flesh, yea and He indwelleth even now in many of those who fear Him.1920

Yes, he says, for it is written of God the Word that He tabernacled in us. The divinely-inspired Paul also said of Christ the Savior of us all that in Him dwelt all the fullness of the Godhead bodily.

Yea (he says) for it is written of God the Word, that He tabernacled in us; the Divine-uttering Paul too said of Christ the Saviour of us all, that in Him hath dwelt all the fulness of the Godhead bodily.

He tabernacled in us, admittedly, for that is what is written; and also that He has dwelt—I will not argue against you saying this, but I will rather examine the words of the inspired writers. For the blessed Evangelist, having first said "And the Word was made flesh," profitably added "tabernacled in us," so that through both expressions he might give us complete knowledge of the mystery concerning Christ. By saying that He was made flesh, he openly declared that the Word from God the Father was united personally to flesh. That being made flesh, He did not pass into the nature of flesh by changing into what He was not, but while becoming as we are, He remained what He was—this he again clearly states by adding to the former expression "tabernacled in us." And the divinely inspired Paul says that in Christ dwelt all the fullness of the Godhead bodily, so that no one might suppose the indwelling was simple or accidental, but (as I just said) real and personal. The Spirit-filled writer was not ignorant that the Word of God is incorporeal and not subject to touch; but since it was necessary that the explanation of the mystery should be seen as in no way blameworthy, but should be made so accurate and exact regarding what is right and true as to be beyond all wonder—he seems to be straining and almost disregarding what befits the unembodied and supreme nature, for he added "bodily," being unable to speak in any other way than what our mind and tongue can attain.21

He tabernacled in us confessedly, for so it is written; and moreover that He hath dwelt: I will not oppose you saying it, but rather will I search into the words of the Divines. For the blessed Evangelist, having aforesaid, And the Word was made flesh, profitably added too the, tabernacled in us, that by means of both he might work in us unmutilated the knowledge of the mystery Christward. For that the Word out of God the Father was united Personally to flesh, he hath openly declared by saying that He was made flesh: that made flesh, He hath not passed into the nature of flesh, undergoing change into what He was not, but together with becoming as we, hath abode what He was, he again clearly states, adding to the former, the tabernacled in us. And the Divine-uttering Paul saith that in Christ dwelt all the fullness of the Godhead bodily, that no one might suppose that the Indwelling was simple or accidental but (as I said just now) Very and Personal. For that the Word of God is Incorporeal and not subject to touch, the Spirit-clad was not ignorant; but since it was needful that the declaration of the mystery should be seen to be in no wise a matter of blame, but should be made so accurate and exact unto what is right and true as to be beyond all marvel:—-he is doing violence (it seems) and all but overlooking what befits the Unembodied and Supreme Nature, for he hath added, Bodily, being able in no other way to speak than may be attained by our mind and tongue.21

Do not think, then, when he speaks of simple indwelling, that he is saying anything that doesn't deserve the strongest condemnation. For while he thinks he is vigorously overturning the birth according to the flesh of the Son, he constructs an argument fit for old women and foolish people, one that has no foundation in truth. For he writes again in this way; his discussion was directed against the Arians:

Do not therefore, when he tells us of simple indwelling, think that he is saying ought that needs not the strongest reprobation. For overthrowing as he thinks and that with vigour the birth according to the flesh of the Son, he compounds an argument befitting old wives and foolish and having no foundation of truth. For he writes again after this manner; his discourse was made touching the Arians:

§9

Nestorius: "Even though these people chatter that God the Word is less than the greater Godhead, they make him subordinate to the blessed Mary. They place a mother born in time above the Godhead, the Creator of times. In fact, they do not even allow that the woman who gave birth to Christ is the mother of Christ. For if what came from her was not the nature of man but God the Word, as they claim, then the woman who gave birth was not the mother of what was born. How can anyone be the mother of someone who is alien to her nature? But if they call her mother, then what was born is manhood, not Godhead, because it is the property of every mother to give birth to what is consubstantial with her. So either she is not a mother, since she did not give birth to what is consubstantial with herself, or if they call her mother, she gave birth to what was essentially like herself."22

Nestorius: "Yet though they prate that God the Word is junior to the greater Godhead, these make Him second to the blessed Mary, and over the Godhead, Creator of times, they set a mother born in time, yea rather they do not even allow that she who bare Christ is mother of Christ. For if not the nature of man but God the Word was, as these say, that which is of her, she that bare was no mother of that which was born. For how will any one be mother of him who is alien from her nature? But if she be called mother by them, that which is born is manhood not Godhead, for it is the property of every mother to bear what is consubstantial [with her]. Either then she will not be mother, not bearing what is consubstantial with herself, or being called mother by them, she bare that which was in essence like to herself."22

How profound the subject of his thoughts! The compulsion arising from the arguments of the one who has put such things together is clearly dreadful and difficult to avoid! Where does he come from, bringing such fables into our midst? Who has ever sunk to such a level of ignorance in his thinking as to believe or say that the Godhead of the Only-Begotten does not have its existence from the Father before the ages, but instead makes flesh and blood the beginning of its coming into being? Who is so confused and weak in understanding and completely deaf to the holy Scriptures? Who does not remember Isaiah, who cried out concerning Him, "Who shall declare His generation?" Or John, who clearly wrote, "In the beginning was the Word and the Word was with God and the Word was God; all things were made through Him and without Him nothing was made"? And if all things came to be through Him, how can He who exists before every age and time have been born later than the things that were made through Him? Why then do you introduce what everyone rejects, as if it had actually been said? Stop accusing those who rightly criticize what you say and who laugh at the enormous ignorance in it. Since no one says that the Virgin gave birth to the physis of the Godhead from her own flesh, do not argue pointlessly, weaving together for us arguments that are not based on premises that are true and accepted by all.

How deep the matter of his cogitations! dread and hard to escape is clearly the compulsion resulting from the reasonings of him who hath compiled such things! Whence comes he having gathered into the midst unto us such fables? or who ever sank down to this extent of unlearning in his conceptions, as to think or say that the Godhead of the Only-Begotten has not its existence before the ages from the Father but rather makes flesh and blood the beginning of its passing into being? who is so distraught and slight of understanding and wholly without ear for the holy Scriptures? who remembereth hot Isaiah who hath cried aloud of Him, Who shall declare His generation? John too who hath written clearly, In the beginning was the Word and the Word was with God and the Word was God; all things were made through Him and without Him was not any thing made? And if all things through Him, how will He Who is before every age and time be later in birth than the things that were made through Him? why then do you bring in what is repudiated by all, as though it had been said? cease accusing those who rightly blame what you say, and who laugh at the vastness of the unlearning that is therein. Since therefore there is no one who says that the Virgin hath borne from forth her own flesh the nature of the Godhead, do not contend to no purpose, twining for us reasonings not made out of premises that are true and acknowledged by all.

But what persuaded you to unleash such a reckless and unrestrained tongue against those who are eager to think correctly, and to pour out terrible and utterly cruel accusations upon every worshipper of God? For you said again in the Church,

But what was it that persuaded you to let loose a tongue so sheer and unguarded against those who are zealous to think aright, and to pour down accusal dire and all-cruel upon every worshipper of God? For you said again in Church,

§10

Nestorius: "But I have already said many times that if any simpler person, whether among us or elsewhere, takes joy in the word Mother of God, I have no objection to the word; only let him not make the Virgin a goddess."

Nestorius: "But I have already full often said that if any simpler one either among us or any other, rejoice in the word Mother of God, I have no grudge against the word; only let him not make the Virgin a goddess."

Again you rail against us and speak so bitterly, and you reproach the congregation of the Lord, as it is written? But we, my friend, who call her mother of God, have never deified anyone who is numbered among creatures. Rather, we are accustomed to know as God the One who is God by nature and truly so, and we know that the blessed Virgin was a woman just as we are human. But you yourself will be caught, and that before long, when you represent Emmanuel to us as a God-bearing man and assign to another the condemnation that is due to your own attempts.

Again dost thou rail upon us, and put on a mouth so bitter? and reproachest the congregation of the Lord, as it is written? But WE, my friend, who call her mother of God, have never at all deified any one of those that are numbered among creatures, but are accustomed to know as God the One and by Nature and truly so: and we know that the blessed Virgin was woman as we. But thyself wilt be caught, and that at no long interval, representing to us Emmanuel as a God-bearing man, and putting upon another the condemnation due to your own essays.