Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 8 — John 1:9

Homily 8 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240108.htm>.

John 1:9

Nothing stops us from dealing with these same words today, since we were previously prevented by the explanation of doctrines from considering everything that was read. Where now are those who deny that He is true God? For here He is called the true Light, and elsewhere the very Truth and very Life. We will discuss that saying more clearly when we reach that passage; but for now we must speak to your Charity for a while about that other matter.

1. Nothing hinders us from handling today also the same words, since before we were prevented by the setting forth of doctrines, from considering all that was read. Where now are those who deny that He is true God? For here He is called the true Light John 14:6, and elsewhere very Truth and very Life. That saying we will discuss more clearly when we come to the place; but at present we must for a while be speaking to your Charity of that other matter.

If He lights every man that comes into the world, how is it that so many remain unenlightened? For not all have known the majesty of Christ. How then does He light every man? He lights all as far as it depends on Him. But if some people willfully close the eyes of their mind and refuse to receive the rays of that Light, their darkness does not come from the nature of the Light, but from their own wickedness, by which they deliberately deprive themselves of the gift. For the grace is poured out upon all, turning away from neither Jew, nor Greek, nor barbarian, nor Scythian, nor free person, nor slave, nor male, nor female, nor old, nor young, but receiving all alike and inviting them with equal regard. And those who are unwilling to enjoy this gift ought rightly to blame their blindness on themselves; for if the gate is opened to all and there is no one to hinder them, yet some remain outside through their own deliberate evil, they perish through no one else but only through their own wickedness.

If He lights every man that comes into the world, how is it that so many continue unenlightened? For not all have known the majesty of Christ. How then does He light every man? He lights all as far as in Him lies. But if some, wilfully closing the eyes of their mind, would not receive the rays of that Light, their darkness arises not from the nature of the Light, but from their own wickedness, who willfully deprive themselves of the gift. For the grace is shed forth upon all, turning itself back neither from Jew, nor Greek, nor Barbarian, nor Scythian, nor free, nor bond, nor male, nor female, nor old, nor young, but admitting all alike, and inviting with an equal regard. And those who are not willing to enjoy this gift, ought in justice to impute their blindness to themselves; for if when the gate is opened to all, and there is none to hinder, any being willfully evil remain without, they perish through none other, but only through their own wickedness.

John 1:10

But not as having existed for the same length of time as the world. God forbid such a thought. That is why he adds, And the world was made by Him, leading you back again to the eternal existence of the Only-Begotten. For anyone who hears that this universe is His work, even if he is very slow-witted, even if he is hostile, even if he is an enemy of God's glory, will certainly be forced to admit, whether he wants to or not, that the maker exists before what he has made. This is why I am always amazed at the madness of Paul of Samosata, who dared to confront such an obvious truth and willingly threw himself off the cliff. For he did not err out of ignorance but with full knowledge, being in the same situation as the Jews. For just as they, out of regard for human opinion, abandoned sound faith—knowing that He was the only-begotten Son of God but refusing to confess Him because of their rulers, lest they be expelled from the synagogue—so it is said that he, to please a certain woman, sold his own salvation. A powerful thing, truly powerful, is the tyranny of vainglory; it can blind the eyes even of the wise, unless they remain sober. For if accepting bribes can have this effect, how much more will this even more violent passion. This is why Jesus said to the Jews, How can you believe, which receive honor one of another, and seek not the honor that comes from God only?

But not as of equal duration with the world. Away with the thought. Wherefore he adds, And the world was made by Him; thus leading you up again to the eternal existence of the Only-Begotten. For he who has heard that this universe is His work, though he be very dull, though he be a hater, though he be an enemy of the glory of God, will certainly, willing or unwilling, be forced to confess that the maker is before his works. Whence wonder always comes over me at the madness of Paul of Samosata, who dared to look in the face so manifest a truth, and voluntarily threw himself down the precipice. For he erred not ignorantly but with full knowledge, being in the same case as the Jews. For as they, looking to men, gave up sound faith, knowing that he was the only-begotten Son of God, but not confessing Him, because of their rulers, lest they should be cast out of the synagogue; so it is said that he, to gratify a certain woman, sold his own salvation. A powerful thing, powerful indeed, is the tyranny of vainglory; it is able to make blind the eyes even of the wise, except they be sober; for if the taking of gifts can effect this, much more will the yet more violent feeling of this passion. Wherefore Jesus said to the Jews, How can you believe, which receive honor one of another, and seek not the honor that comes from God only? John 5:44

And the world knew Him not. By "the world" he here means the multitude that is corrupt and closely attached to earthly things—the common turbulent, foolish people. For the friends and favorites of God all knew Him, even before His coming in the flesh. Concerning the Patriarch, Christ Himself speaks by name: "Your father Abraham rejoiced to see My day, and he saw it, and was glad" (John 8:56). And concerning David, refuting the Jews He said, "How then does David in spirit call Him Lord, saying, 'The Lord said to my Lord, Sit on My right hand'" (Matthew 22:43; Mark 12:36; Luke 20:42). And in many places, disputing with them, He mentions Moses, and the Apostle mentions the rest of the prophets. For Peter declares that all the prophets from Samuel knew Him and proclaimed His coming from afar, when he says, "All the prophets from Samuel and those that follow after, as many as have spoken, have likewise foretold of these days" (Acts 3:24). But Jacob and his father, as well as his grandfather—He both appeared to them and talked with them, and promised that He would give them many and great blessings, which He also brought to pass.

And the world knew Him not. By the world he here means the multitude, which is corrupt, and closely attached to earthly things, the common turbulent, silly people. For the friends and favorites of God all knew Him, even before His coming in the flesh. Concerning the Patriarch Christ Himself speaks by name, that your father Abraham rejoiced to see My day, and he saw it, and was glad. John 8:56 And concerning David, confuting the Jews He said, How then does David in spirit call Him Lord, saying, the Lord said to my Lord, Sit on My right hand. Matthew 22:43; Mark 12:36; Luke 20:42 And in many places, disputing with them, He mentions Moses; and the Apostle (mentions) the rest of the prophets; for Peter declares, that all the prophets from Samuel knew Him, and proclaimed beforehand His coming afar off, when he says, All the prophets from Samuel and those that follow after, as many as have spoken, have likewise foretold of these days. Acts 3:24 But Jacob and his father, as well as his grandfather, He both appeared to and talked with, and promised that He would give them many and great blessings, which also He brought to pass.

How then, someone asks, did He say Himself, "Many prophets have desired to see those things which you see, and have not seen them; and to hear those things which you hear, and have not heard them"? Luke 10:24 Did they then not share in the knowledge of Him? They certainly did, and I will try to make this clear from this very saying, which some think deprives them of it. For He says, "Many have desired to see the things which you see." So they knew that He would come to men from heaven, and would live and teach as He lived and taught; for if they had not known, they could not have desired, since no one can conceive desire for things of which he has no idea. Therefore they knew the Son of Man, and that He would come among men. What then are the things which they did not hear? What are those which they did not know? The things which you now see and hear. For if they did hear His voice and did see Him, it was not in the Flesh, not among men, nor when He was living so familiarly and conversing so frankly with them. And indeed, to show this, He did not say simply "to see Me," but what? "The things which you see." Nor "to hear Me," but what? "The things which you hear." So that even if they did not behold His coming in the Flesh, still they knew that it would be, and they desired it, and believed on Him without having seen Him in the Flesh.

How then, says one, did He say Himself, 'Many prophets have desired to see those things which you see, and have not seen them; and to hear those things which you hear, and have not heard them'? Luke 10:24 Did they then not share in the knowledge of Him? Surely they did; and I will endeavor to make this plain from this very saying, by which some think that they are deprived of it. For many, He says, have desired to see the things which you see. So that they knew that He would come [to men] from heaven, and would live and teach as He lived and taught; for had they not known, they could have not desired, since no one can conceive desire for things of which he has no idea; therefore they knew the Son of Man, and that He would come among men. What then are the things which they did not hear? What those which they did not know? The things which you now see and hear. For if they did hear His voice and did see Him, it was not in the Flesh, not among men; nor when He was living so familiarly, and conversing so frankly with them. And indeed He to show this said not simply, to see Me: but what? the things which you see; nor to hear Me: but what? the things which you hear. So that if they did not behold His coming in the Flesh, still they knew that it would be, and they desired it, and believed on Him without having seen Him in the Flesh.

When the Greeks bring such charges against us and say, "What was Christ doing in earlier times that He did not look upon the human race? And for what possible reason did He come at last to help with our salvation after neglecting us for so long?" we will answer that before this He was in the world, took care of His works, and was known to all who were worthy. But if you say that because not everyone knew Him then—because only those noble and excellent people knew Him—therefore He was not acknowledged, then by that reasoning you would not allow that He is worshipped even now, since even now not everyone knows Him. But just as today no one would, because of those who do not know Him, refuse to believe those who do, so regarding former times we must not doubt that He was known to many, or rather to all of those noble and admirable people.

When therefore the Greeks bring charges such as these against us, and say; What then did Christ in former time, that He did not look upon the race of men? And for what possible reason did He come at last to assist in our salvation, after neglecting us so long? we will reply, that before this He was in the world, and took thought for His works, and was known to all who were worthy. But if you should say, that, because all did not then know Him, because He was only known by those noble and excellent persons, therefore He was not acknowledged; at this rate you will not allow that He is worshipped even now, since even now all men do not know Him. But as at present no one, because of those who do not know Him, would refuse credit to those who do, so as regards former times, we must not doubt that He was known to many, or rather to all of those noble and admirable persons.

And if someone asks, "Why didn't all people pay attention to Him? Why didn't everyone worship Him, but only the righteous?" I will also ask, why even now do not all people know Him? But why do I speak of Christ, when not all people knew His Father then, or know Him now? For some say that all things happen by chance, while others attribute the providence of the universe to demons. Others invent another God besides Him, and some blasphemously claim that His power is opposed to good, and think that His laws are the laws of an evil demon. What then? Should we say that He is not God because some people say so? And should we confess Him to be evil? For there are some who even blaspheme Him in this way. Away with such mental wandering, such utter insanity. If we should form doctrines according to the judgment of madmen, there is nothing to prevent us from becoming mad ourselves with the most terrible madness. No one will claim, looking at those who have weak vision, that the sun is harmful to the eyes, but he will say that it is designed to give light, drawing his judgments from healthy people. And no one will call honey bitter because it seems so to the taste of the sick. And will anyone, based on the imaginations of people who are mentally diseased, decide that God either does not exist or is evil, or that He sometimes exercises His Providence and sometimes does not at all? Who can say that such people are of sound mind, or deny that they are out of their minds, delirious, utterly mad?

2. And if any one say, Why did not all men give heed to Him? Nor all worship Him, but the just only? I also will ask, why even now do not all men know him? But why do I speak of Christ, when not all men knew His Father then, or know Him now? For some say, that all things are borne along by chance, while others commit the providence of the universe to devils. Others invent another God besides Him, and some blasphemously assert, that His is an opposing power, and think that His laws are the laws of a wicked dæmon. What then? Shall we say that He is not God because there are some who say so? And shall we confess Him to be evil? For there are some who even so blaspheme Him. Away with such mental wandering, such utter insanity. If we should delineate doctrines according to the judgment of madmen, there is nothing to hinder us from being mad ourselves with most grievous madness. No one will assert, looking to those who have weak vision, that the sun is injurious to the eyes, but he will say that it is fitted to give light, drawing his judgments from persons in health. And no one will call honey bitter, because it seems so to the sense of the sick. And will any, from the imaginations of men diseased (in mind) decide that God either is not, or is evil; or that He sometimes indeed exerts His Providence, sometimes does not so at all? Who can say that such men are of sound mind, or deny that they are beside themselves, delirious, utterly mad?

The world, he says, did not know Him, but those of whom the world was not worthy did know Him. After speaking of those who did not know Him, he shortly explains the cause of their ignorance. He does not say absolutely that no one knew Him, but that the world did not know Him—that is, those people who are fixated on the world alone and who think only about worldly things. Christ was accustomed to call them this, as when He says, "O Holy Father, the world has not known You" (Luke 17:25). The world, then, was ignorant not only of Him but also of His Father, as we have said, for nothing darkens the mind as much as being closely attached to present things.

The world, he says, knew Him not; but they of whom the world was not worthy knew Him. And having spoken of those who knew Him not, he in a short time puts the cause of their ignorance; for he does not absolutely say, that no one knew Him, but that the world knew him not; that is, those persons who are as it were nailed to the world alone, and who mind the things of the world. For so Christ was wont to call them; as when He says, O Holy Father, the world has not known You. Luke 17:25 The world then was ignorant, not only of Him, but also of His Father, as we have said; for nothing so darkens the mind as to be closely attached to present things.

Knowing this, then, remove yourselves from the world and tear yourselves away as much as possible from fleshly things, for the loss that comes to you from these does not lie in ordinary matters, but in what is the greatest of goods. For it is not possible for someone who clings strongly to the things of this present life truly to lay hold of those in heaven, but whoever is earnest about the one must necessarily lose the other. You cannot, He says, serve God and Mammon, for you must hold to the one and hate the other. And this very experience itself proclaims aloud. Those, for instance, who despise the lust of money are especially the people who love God as they ought, just as those who respect that sovereignty of Mammon are the men who above all others have the weakest love for Him. For the soul, once made captive by covetousness, will not easily or readily refuse to do or say any of the things that anger God, since it is the slave of another master, one who gives all his commands in direct opposition to God. Return then at last to your right mind, and rouse yourselves, and remembering whose servants we are, let us love His kingdom only. Let us weep, let us wail for the past times in which we were servants of Mammon. Let us cast off once for all his yoke, so intolerable and so heavy, and continue to bear the light and easy yoke of Christ. For He lays no such commands upon us as Mammon does. Mammon commands us to be enemies to all people, but Christ, on the contrary, commands us to embrace and to love all. The one, having nailed us to the clay and the brickmaking (for gold is this), does not allow us even at night to catch our breath a little. The other releases us from this excessive and senseless care, and commands us to gather treasures in heaven, not by injustice toward others, but by our own righteousness. The one, after our many toils and sufferings, is not able to help us when we are punished in that place and suffer because of his laws—no, he increases the flame. The other, though He commands us to give only a cup of cold water, never allows us to lose our reward and recompense even for this, but repays us with great abundance. How then is it not the most extreme folly to reject a rule so mild, so full of all good things, and to serve a thankless, ungrateful tyrant, one who neither in this world nor in the world to come is able to help those who obey and give heed to him? Nor is this the only dreadful thing, nor is this the only penalty, that he does not defend them when they are being punished, but that besides this, he, as I said before, surrounds those who obey him with ten thousand evils. For of those who are punished in that place, one may see that the greater part are punished for this reason: that they were slaves to money, that they loved gold, and would not help those in need. That we may not be in this condition, let us scatter, let us give to the poor, let us deliver our souls from harmful cares in this world and from the vengeance that because of these things is appointed for us in that place. Let us store up righteousness in the heavens. Instead of riches on earth, let us collect treasures that cannot be taken, treasures that can accompany us on our journey to heaven, that can help us in our danger, and that can make the Judge favorable at that hour. May we all have Him gracious to us, both now and at that day, and may we enjoy with much confidence the good things prepared in the heavens for those who love Him as they ought, through the grace and loving-kindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom, to the Father and the Holy Spirit, be glory, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.

Knowing therefore this, remove yourselves from the world, and tear yourselves as much as possible from carnal things, for the loss which comes to you from these lies not in common matters, but in what is the chief of goods. For it is not possible for the man who clings strongly to the things of the present life really to lay hold on those in heaven, but he who is earnest about the one must needs lose the other. You cannot, He says, serve God and Mammon Matthew 6:24, for you must hold to the one and hate the other. And this too the very experience of the things proclaims aloud. Those, for instance, who deride the lust of money, are especially the persons who love God as they ought, just as those who respect that sovereignty (of Mammon), are the men who above all others have the slackest love for Him. For the soul when made captive once for all by covetousness, will not easily or readily refuse doing or saying any of the things which anger God, as being the slave of another master, and one who gives all his commands in direct opposition to God. Return then at length to your sober senses, and rouse yourselves, and calling to mind whose servants we are, let us love His kingdom only; let us weep, let us wail for the times past in which we were servants of Mammon; let us cast off once for all his yoke so intolerable, so heavy, and continue to bear the light and easy yoke of Christ. For He lays no such commands upon us as Mammon does. Mammon bids us be enemies to all men, but Christ, on the contrary, to embrace and to love all. The one having nailed us to the clay and the brickmaking, (for gold is this,) allows us not even at night to take breath a little; the other releases us from this excessive and insensate care, and bids us gather treasures in heaven, not by injustice towards others, but by our own righteousness. The one after our many toils and sufferings is not able to assist us when we are punished in that place and suffer because of his laws, nay, he increases the flame; the other, though He command us to give but a cup of cold water, never allows us to lose our reward and recompense even for this, but repays us with great abundance. How then is it not extremest folly to slight a rule so mild, so full of all good things, and to serve a thankless, ungrateful tyrant, and one who neither in this world nor in the world to come is able to help those who obey and give heed to him. Nor is this the only dreadful thing, nor is this only the penalty, that he does not defend them when they are being punished; but that besides this, he, as I before said, surrounds those who obey him with ten thousand evils. For of those who are punished in that place, one may see that the greater part are punished for this cause, that they were slaves to money, that they loved gold, and would not assist those who needed. That we be not in this case, let us scatter, let us give to the poor, let us deliver our souls from hurtful cares in this world, and from the vengeance, which because of these things is appointed for us in that place. Let us store up righteousness in the heavens. Instead of riches upon earth, let us collect treasures impregnable, treasures which can accompany us on our journey to heaven, which can assist us in our peril, and make the Judge propitious at that hour. Whom may we all have gracious unto us, both now and at that day, and enjoy with much confidence the good things prepared in the heavens for those who love Him as they ought, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom, to the Father and the Holy Ghost, be glory, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 7 — John 1:9

Homily 7 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240107.htm>.

John 1:9

The reason, dearly beloved children, why we share with you the thoughts taken from the Scriptures portion by portion, and do not pour everything out to you all at once, is to make it easy for you to retain what is successively set before you. For even in building, someone who lays additional stones before the first ones are settled constructs a wall that is completely rotten and easily knocked down, while someone who waits for the mortar to harden first and then adds what remains little by little finishes the whole house firmly and makes it strong—not one that will last only a short time or easily fall apart. We imitate these builders and build up your souls in the same way. For we fear that while the first foundation has only recently been laid, adding the subsequent teachings might harm what came before, since the mind is insufficient to contain them all at once.

1. The reason, O children greatly beloved, why we entertain you portion by portion with the thoughts taken from the Scriptures, and do not at once pour all forth to you, is, that the retaining what is successively set before you may be easy. For even in building, one who before the first stones are settled lays on others, constructs a rotten wall altogether, and easily thrown down: while one who waits that the mortar may first get hard, and so adds what remains little by little, finishes the whole house firmly, and makes it strong, not one to last for a short time, or easily to fall to pieces. These builders we imitate, and in like manner build up your souls. For we fear lest, while the first foundation is but newly laid, the addition of the succeeding speculations may do harm to the former, through the insufficiency of the intellect to contain them all at once.

What is it that has been read to us today?

What now is it that has been read to us today?

That was the true Light, which lights every man that comes into the world. Since earlier when speaking of John he said that John came to bear witness of that Light, and that he was sent in our own time, someone hearing this might suspect that the one being testified about also came recently, just because his witness did. To prevent this, he has lifted up our understanding and carried it to that existence which is before all beginning, which has neither end nor commencement.

That was the true Light, which lights every man that comes into the world. For since above in speaking of John he said, that he came to bear witness of that Light; and that he was sent in these our days; lest any one at hearing this should, on account of the recent coming of the witness, conceive some like suspicion concerning Him, who is witnessed of, he has carried up the imagination, and transported it to that existence which is before all beginning, which has neither end nor commencement.

Someone might ask, "How is it possible that being a Son, He should possess this nature?" We are speaking of God, and you ask how? Don't you fear or tremble? Yet if anyone asked you, "How will our souls and bodies have endless life in the world to come?" you would laugh at the question, believing it doesn't belong to human intellect to investigate such matters. You would say we should only believe and not be overly curious about this subject, since we have sufficient proof in the power of the One who spoke it. And if we say that He who created our souls and bodies, and who incomparably surpasses all created things, is without beginning, will you demand that we explain how? Who could claim this comes from a well-ordered soul or sound reasoning? You have heard that this was the true Light—why are you pointlessly and rashly trying to exceed by force of reasoning this unlimited Life? You cannot do it. Why seek what must not be sought? Why be curious about what is incomprehensible? Why search what is unsearchable? Try gazing directly at the source of sunbeams. You cannot, yet you are neither troubled nor frustrated by your weakness. How then have you become so bold and reckless in greater matters? The son of thunder, John who sounds the spiritual trumpet, when he heard from the Spirit "was," inquired no further. And are you, who do not share his grace but speak from your own miserable reasonings, ambitious to exceed the measure of his knowledge? For this very reason you will never even reach the measure of his knowledge. This is the devil's tactic: he leads those who obey him away from the limits God has set, as though to much greater things. But when he has enticed us with these hopes and cast us out from God's grace, he not only gives nothing more (how can he, being the devil?), but doesn't even allow us to return to our former situation where we lived safely and securely. Instead, he leads us wandering in all directions without any firm ground. This is how he caused the first created man to be banished from Paradise. Having inflated him with the expectation of greater knowledge and honor, he expelled him from what he already possessed securely. For he not only did not become like a god as the devil promised him, but even fell under the dominion of death. He gained no advantage by eating from the tree, but actually lost a significant portion of the knowledge he possessed through hoping for greater knowledge. The sense of shame and the desire to hide because of his nakedness then came upon him—he who before the deception was above all such shame. This very awareness of being naked, the need from then on for clothing to cover himself, and many other weaknesses became natural to him. To prevent this from happening to us, let us obey God, remain in His commandments, and not concern ourselves with anything beyond them, so that we won't be cast out from the good things already given to us. This is what has happened to those we are speaking of. By seeking to find a beginning of the Life that has no beginning, they lost what they could have kept. They didn't find what they sought (this is impossible), and they fell away from the true faith concerning the Only-Begotten.

And how is it possible, says one, that being a Son, He should possess this (nature)? We are speaking of God, and do you ask how? And do you not fear nor shudder? Yet should any one ask you, How should our souls and bodies have endless life in the world to come? you will laugh at the question, on the ground that it does not belong to the intellect of man to search into such questions, but that he ought only to believe, and not to be over-curious on the subject mentioned, since he has a sufficient proof of the saying, in the power of Him who spoke it. And if we say, that He, who created our souls and bodies, and who incomparably excels all created things, is without beginning, will you require us to say How? Who could assert this to be the act of a well-ordered soul, or of sound reason? You have heard that That was the true Light: why are you vainly and rashly striving to overshoot by force of reasoning this Life which is unlimited? You cannot do it. Why seek what may not be sought? Why be curious about what is incomprehensible? Why search what is unsearchable? Gaze upon the very source of the sunbeams. You cannot; yet you are neither vexed nor impatient at your weakness; how then have you become so daring and headlong in greater matters? The son of thunder, John who sounds the spiritual trumpet, when he had heard from the Spirit the was, enquired no farther. And are you, who share not in his grace, but speak from your own wretched reasonings, ambitious to exceed the measure of his knowledge? Then for this very reason you will never be able even to reach to the measure of his knowledge. For this is the craft of the devil: he leads away those who obey him from the limits assigned by God, as though to things much greater: but when, having enticed us by these hopes, he has cast us out of the grace of God, he not only gives nothing more, (how can he, devil as he is?) but does not even allow us to return again to our former situation, where we dwelt safely and surely, but leads us about in all directions wandering and not having any standing ground. So he caused the first created man to be banished from the abode of Paradise. Having puffed him up with the expectation of greater knowledge and honor, he expelled him from what he already possessed in security. For he not only did not become like a god as (the devil) promised him, but even fell beneath the dominion of death; having not only gained no further advantage by eating of the tree, but having lost no small portion of the knowledge which he possessed, through hope of greater knowledge. For the sense of shame, and the desire to hide himself because of his nakedness, then came upon him, who before the cheat was superior to all such shame; and this very seeing himself to be naked, and the need for the future of the covering of garments, and many other infirmities, became thenceforth natural to him. That this be not our case, let us obey God, continue in His commandments, and not be busy about anything beyond them, that we may not be cast out from the good things already given us. Thus they have fared (of whom we speak). For seeking to find a beginning of the Life which has no beginning, they lost what they might have retained. They found not what they sought, (this is impossible,) and they fell away from the true faith concerning the Only-Begotten.

Let us not remove the eternal boundaries that our fathers established, but let us always submit to the laws of the Spirit. When we hear that He was the true Light, let us not seek to discover anything more, for it is not possible to go beyond this statement. If His generation had been like that of a human being, there would necessarily have been an interval between the one who begets and the one begotten. But since it is ineffable and fitting for God, give up the ideas of before and after, for these are names of points in time, but the Son is the Creator even of all ages.

Let us not then remove the eternal bounds which our fathers set, but let us ever yield to the laws of the Spirit; and when we hear that That was the true Light, let us seek to discover nothing more. For it is not possible to pass beyond this saying. Had His generation been like that of a man, needs must there have been an interval between the begetter and the begotten; but since it is in a manner ineffable and becoming God, give up the before and the after, for these are the names of points in time, but the Son is the Creator even of all ages.

Then someone says, "He is not Father, but brother." What need is there for that? If we had claimed that the Father and the Son came from a different root, you might have spoken this rightly. But if we flee from this impiety and say that the Father, besides being without beginning, is also Unbegotten, while the Son, though without beginning, is Begotten of the Father, what kind of need is there that this unholy assertion should follow as a consequence? None at all. For He is an Effulgence, but an effulgence is included in the idea of the nature whose effulgence it is. For this reason Paul has called Him so, so that you may imagine no interval between the Father and the Son. This expression therefore declares the point, but the following part of the proof corrects an erroneous opinion which might trap simple people. For, says the Apostle, do not, because you have heard that He is an Effulgence, suppose that He is deprived of His proper hypostasis—this is impious and belongs to the madness of the Sabellians and of Marcellus' followers. We do not say this, but that He exists also in His proper hypostasis. And for this reason, after having called Him Effulgence, Paul has added that He is the express image of His hypostasis, in order to make evident His proper hypostasis, and that He belongs to the same ousia of which He is also the express image. For, as I said before, it is not sufficient by a single expression to set before people the doctrines concerning God, but it is necessary that we bring many together and choose from each what is suitable. In this way we shall be able to attain a worthy telling of His glory—worthy, I mean, as regards our power. For if anyone should think himself able to speak words suitable to His essential worthiness and be ambitious to do so, saying that he knows God as God knows Himself, he is the one who is most ignorant of God.

2. Then, says one, He is not Father, but brother. What need, pray? If we had asserted that the Father and the Son were from a different root, you might have then spoken this well. But, if we flee this impiety, and say the Father, besides being without beginning, is Unbegotten also, while the Son, though without beginning, is Begotten of the Father, what kind of need that as a consequence of this idea, that unholy assertion should be introduced? None at all. For He is an Effulgence: but an effulgence is included in the idea of the nature whose effulgence it is. For this reason Paul has called Him so, that you may imagine no interval between the Father and the Son. Hebrews 1:3 This expression therefore is declaratory of the point; but the following part of the proof quoted, corrects an erroneous opinion which might beset simple men. For, says the Apostle, do not, because you have heard that he is an Effulgence, suppose that He is deprived of His proper person; this is impious, and belongs to the madness of the Sabellians, and of Marcellus' followers. We say not so, but that He is also in His proper Person. And for this reason, after having called Him Effulgence, Paul has added that He is the express image of His Person Hebrews 1:3, in order to make evident His proper Personality, and that He belongs to the same Essence of which He is also the express image. For, as I before said, it is not sufficient by a single expression to set before men the doctrines concerning God, but it is desirable that we bring many together, and choose from each what is suitable. So shall we be able to attain to a worthy telling of His glory, worthy, I mean, as regards our power; for if any should deem himself able to speak words suitable to His essential worthiness, and be ambitious to do so, saying, that he knows God as God knows Himself, he it is who is most ignorant of God.

Knowing this, let us continue to hold firmly to what those who were eyewitnesses and ministers of the word from the beginning have delivered to us. And let us not be overly curious beyond this, for two evils will afflict those who suffer from this disease of curiosity: they will weary themselves in vain by seeking what is impossible to find, and they will provoke God by trying to overturn the boundaries He has set. Now, you who already know need not learn from us what anger this provokes. Therefore, avoiding their madness, let us tremble at His words so that He may continually build us up. For He says, "Upon whom shall I look, but upon the lowly and quiet, and who fears my words?" Let us then abandon this destructive curiosity and bruise our hearts. Let us mourn for our sins as Christ commanded, let us be pierced in our hearts for our transgressions, let us carefully reckon up all the wicked deeds we have dared to commit in the past, and let us earnestly strive to wipe them away in every possible way.

Knowing therefore this, let us continue steadfastly to hold what they have delivered unto us, which from the beginning were eye-witnesses, and ministers of the word. Luke 1:2 And let us not be curious beyond: for two evils will attend those who are sick of this disease, (curiosity,) the wearying themselves in vain by seeking what it is impossible to find, and the provoking God by their endeavors to overturn the bounds set by Him. Now what anger this excites, it needs not that you who know should learn from us. Abstaining therefore from their madness, let us tremble at His words, that He may continually build us up. For, upon whom shall I look Isaiah 66:2, Septuagint, says He, but upon the lowly, and quiet, and who fears my words? Let us then leave this pernicious curiosity, and bruise our hearts, let us mourn for our sins as Christ commanded, let us be pricked at heart for our transgressions, let us reckon up exactly all the wicked deeds, which in time past we have dared, and let us earnestly strive to wipe them off in all kinds of ways.

God has opened many ways for us to accomplish this purpose. First, He says, "Tell your sins, that you may be justified" (Isaiah 43:26), and again, "I said, I have declared my iniquity to You, and You have taken away the unrighteousness of my heart" (Psalm 32:5, Septuagint), since continually accusing ourselves and remembering our sins contributes greatly to reducing their severity. But there is another way more powerful than this: to bear no ill will against anyone who has wronged us, and to forgive the offenses of all who have sinned against us. Do you want to learn a third way? Listen to Daniel, who says, "Redeem your sins by almsdeeds, and your iniquities by showing mercy to the poor" (Daniel 4:27, Septuagint). And there is yet another way beyond these: persistence in prayer and faithful attendance at the intercessions made to God. Likewise, fasting brings us some—and not insignificant—comfort and release from committed sins, provided it is accompanied by kindness to others, and it quenches the intensity of God's wrath (1 Timothy 2:1). For water will put out a blazing fire, and sins are purged away by almsdeeds (Sirach 3:30, Septuagint).

Now to this end God has opened to us many ways. For, Tell you first, says He, your sins, that you may be justified Isaiah 43:26; and again, I said, I have declared mine iniquity unto You, and You have taken away the unrighteousness of my heart Psalm 32:5, Septuagint; since a continual accusation and remembrance of sins contributes not a little to lessen their magnitude. But there is another more prevailing way than this; to bear malice against none of those who have offended against us, to forgive their trespasses to all those who have trespassed against us. Will you learn a third? Hear Daniel, saying, Redeem your sins by almsdeeds, and your iniquities by showing mercy to the poor. Daniel 4:27, Septuagint And there is another besides this; constancy in prayer, and persevering attendance on the intercessions made with God. In like manner fasting brings to us some, and that not small comfort and release from sins committed, provided it be attended with kindness to others, and quenches the vehemence of the wrath of God. 1 Timothy 2:1 For water will quench a blazing fire, and by almsdeeds sins are purged away. Sirach 3:30, Septuagint

Let us then travel along all these ways. If we give ourselves completely to these activities and spend our time on them, we will not only wash away our past sins but also gain very great profit for the future. We will not allow the devil to attack us when we have leisure time for lazy living or for harmful curiosity. Through these means and as a result of them, he leads us to foolish questions and destructive arguments, seeing us at leisure, idle, and taking no thought for excellence in living. But let us block this approach against him. Let us watch and let us be sober, so that having toiled a little in this short time, we may obtain eternal goods in endless ages, by the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom and with whom to the Father and the Holy Spirit be glory forever and ever. Amen.

Let us then travel along all these ways; for if we give ourselves wholly to these employments, if on them we spend our time, not only shall we wash off our bygone transgressions, but shall gain very great profit for the future. For we shall not allow the devil to assault us with leisure either for slothful living, or for pernicious curiosity, since by these among other means, and in consequence of these, he leads us to foolish questions and hurtful disputations, from seeing us at leisure, and idle, and taking no forethought for excellency of living. But let us block up this approach against him, let us watch, let us be sober, that having in this short time toiled a little, we may obtain eternal goods in endless ages, by the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ; by whom and with whom to the Father and the Holy Ghost, be glory for ever and ever. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 6 — John 1:6

Homily 6 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240106.htm>.

John 1:6

Having spoken to us in the introduction about things of urgent importance concerning God the Word, the Evangelist proceeds on his course and in order afterward comes to the herald of the Word, his namesake John. And now that you hear he was sent from God, do not in the future imagine that any of the words spoken by him are merely man's words, for everything he utters is not his own but belongs to the One who sent him. This is why he is called messenger, for the excellence of a messenger is that he says nothing of his own. But the expression "was" in this place does not signify his coming into existence but refers to his office of messenger, for "there was" a man sent from God is used instead of a man "was sent" from God.

1. Having in the introduction spoken to us things of urgent importance concerning God the Word, (the Evangelist) proceeding on his road, and in order, afterwards comes to the herald of the Word, his namesake John. And now that you hear that he was sent from God, do not for the future imagine that any of the words spoken by him are mere man's words; for all that he utters is not his own, but is of Him who sent him. Wherefore he is called messenger Malachi 3:1, for the excellence of a messenger is, that he say nothing of his own. But the expression was, in this place is not significative of his coming into existence, but refers to his office of messenger; for 'there was' a man sent from God, is used instead of a man 'was sent' from God.

How then do some say that the expression "being in the form of God" (Philippians 2:6) is not used of His invariable likeness to the Father, because no article is added? Notice that the article is nowhere added here either. Are these words then not spoken of the Father? What shall we say to the prophet who says, "Behold, I send My messenger before Your face, who shall prepare Your way" (Malachi 3:1, as found in Mark 1:2)? For the expressions "My" and "Your" declare two persons.

How then do some say, that the expression, being in the form of God Philippians 2:6 is not used of His invariable likeness to the Father, because no article is added? For observe, that the article is nowhere added here. Are these words then not spoken of the Father? What then shall we say to the prophet who says, that, Behold, I send My messenger before Your face, who shall prepare Your way Malachi 3:1, as found in Mark 1:2? For the expressions My and Your declare two Persons.

John 1:7

What is this, perhaps someone may say—the servant bearing witness to his Master? When you see Him not only witnessed to by His servant, but even coming to him and being baptized by him along with Jews, will you not be even more astonished and perplexed? Yet you ought not to be troubled or confused, but amazed at such unspeakable goodness. Though if anyone still continues bewildered and confused, He will say to such a person what He said to John: Suffer it to be so now, for thus it becomes us to fulfill all righteousness (Matthew 3:15). And if anyone is still further troubled, again He will say to him what He said to the Jews: But I receive not testimony from man (John 5:34). If He does not need this witness, why was John sent from God? Not because He required his testimony—that would be the most extreme blasphemy. Why then? John himself informs us when he says,

What is this, perhaps one may say, the servant bear witness to his Master? When then you see Him not only witnessed to by His servant, but even coming to him, and with Jews baptized by him, will you not be still more astonished and perplexed? Yet you ought not to be troubled nor confused, but amazed at such unspeakable goodness. Though if any still continue bewildered and confused, He will say to such an one what He said to John, Suffer it to be so now, for thus it becomes us to fulfill all righteousness Matthew 3:15; and, if any be still further troubled, again He will say to him too what he said to the Jews, But I receive not testimony from man. John 5:34 If now he needs not this witness, why was John sent from God? Not as though He required his testimony — this were extremest blasphemy. Why then? John himself informs us, when he says,

That all men through him might believe.

That all men through him might believe.

And Christ also, after having said "I do not receive testimony from man" (John 5:34), adds an explanation so that He may not seem to foolish people to contradict Himself. For at one time He declared "There is another that bears witness of Me and I know that his witness is true" (John 5:32)—and He was pointing to John—and at another time He said "I receive not testimony from man" (John 5:34). He immediately gives the solution to this apparent problem: "But these things I say for your own sake, that you might be saved." It is as though He had said: As for the fact that I am God, and the truly Begotten Son of God, and am of that Simple and Blessed Essence (ousia), I need no one to witness to Me; and even if no one would do so, I am not by this diminished at all in My Essence (ousia). But because I care for the salvation of the many, I have descended to such humility as to entrust the witness of Me to a man. For because of the earthbound nature and weakness of the Jews, the faith in Him would in this way be more easily received and more acceptable. So then He clothed Himself with flesh, so that He might not, by confronting men with the unveiled Godhead, destroy them all. In the same way He sent forth a man as His herald, so that those who heard might approach more readily at the hearing of a kindred voice. For to prove that He had no need of that herald's testimony, it would have been enough for Him simply to have shown Himself who He was in His unveiled Essence (ousia) and to have overwhelmed them all. But He did not do this for the reason I have already mentioned. He would have annihilated all, since no one could have endured the encounter with that unapproachable light. Therefore, as I said, He put on flesh and entrusted the witness of Himself to one of our fellow-servants, since He arranged all for the salvation of men, looking not only to His own honor, but also to what might be readily received by and be profitable to His hearers. He alluded to this when He said, "These things I say for your sake, that you might be saved" (John 5:34). And the Evangelist, using the same language as his Master, after saying "to bear witness of that Light," adds,

And Christ also, after having said that I receive not testimony from man John 5:34, in order that He may not seem to the foolish to clash with Himself, by declaring at one time There is another that bears witness of Me and I know that his witness is true John 5:32 (for He pointed to John;) and at another, I receive not testimony from man John 5:34; He immediately adds the solution of the doubt, But these things I say for your own sake, that you might be saved. As though He had said, that I am God, and the really-Begotten Son of God, and am of that Simple and Blessed Essence, I need none to witness to Me; and even though none would do so, yet am not I by this anything diminished in My Essence; but because I care for the salvation of the many, I have descended to such humility as to commit the witness of Me to a man. For by reason of the groveling nature and infirmity of the Jews, the faith in Him would in this way be more easily received, and more palatable. As then He clothed Himself with flesh, that he might not, by encountering men with the unveiled Godhead, destroy them all; so He sent forth a man for His herald, that those who heard might at the hearing of a kindred voice approach more readily. For (to prove) that He had no need of that (herald's) testimony, it would have sufficed that He should only have shown Himself who He was in His unveiled Essence, and have confounded them all. But this He did not for the reason I have before mentioned. He would have annihilated all, since none could have endured the encounter of that unapproachable light. Wherefore, as I said, He put on flesh, and entrusted the witness (of Himself) to one of our fellow-servants, since He arranged all for the salvation of men, looking not only to His own honor, but also to what might be readily received by, and be profitable to, His hearers. Which He glanced at when He said, These things I say for your sake, that you might be saved. John 5:34 And the Evangelist using the same language as his Master, after saying, to bear witness of that Light, adds,

That all men through him might believe. This is nearly the same as saying: Do not think that John the Baptist came to bear witness in order to add anything to his Master's credibility. Rather, he came so that through him people of his own kind might believe. It is clear from what follows that John used this expression because he was eager to remove this suspicion in advance, since he adds,

That all men through Him might believe. All but saying, Think not that the reason why John the Baptist came to bear witness, was that he might add anything to the trustworthiness of his Master. No; (He came,) that by his means beings of his own class might believe. For it is clear from what follows, that he used this expression in his anxiety to remove this suspicion beforehand, since he adds,

John 1:8

Now if he did not introduce this to counter this suspicion, then the expression is completely superfluous, and it becomes repetition rather than clarification of his teaching. For why, after having said that he was sent to bear witness of that Light, does he again say, He was not that Light? He says it not carelessly or without reason. Rather, because in most cases among us, the person witnessing is considered to be greater and generally more trustworthy than the person being witnessed about, he therefore immediately removes this wrong suspicion from the very beginning so that no one might suspect this about John. Having torn it up by the roots, he shows who this witness-bearer is, and who the one being witnessed about is, and how great the distance is between the one witnessed about and the witness-bearer. After having done this and shown His incomparable superiority, he then proceeds confidently to the remaining narrative. Having carefully removed whatever strange ideas might secretly lodge in the minds of simpler people, he thus instills into everyone easily and without obstacle the word of doctrine in its proper sequence.

Now if he did not introduce this as setting himself against this suspicion, then the expression is absolutely superfluous, and tautology rather than elucidation of his teaching. For why, after having said that he was sent to bear witness of that Light, does he again say, He was not that Light? (He says it,) not loosely or without reason; but, because, for the most part, among ourselves, the person witnessing is held to be greater, and generally more trustworthy than the person witnessed of; therefore, that none might suspect this in the case of John, at once from the very beginning he removes this evil suspicion, and having torn it up by the roots, shows who this is that bears witness, and who is He who is witnessed of, and what an interval there is between the witnessed of, and the bearer of witness. And after having done this, and shown His incomparable superiority, he afterwards proceeds fearlessly to the narrative which remains; and after carefully removing whatever strange (ideas) might secretly harbor in the minds of the simpler sort, so instills into all easily and without impediment the word of doctrine in its proper order.

Let us pray, then, that from now on—along with the revelation of these teachings and correctness of doctrine—we may also have a pure life and virtuous conduct, since these things are worthless unless good works are present in us. For even if we have complete faith and complete knowledge of the Scriptures, if we are naked and lacking the protection that comes from holy living, nothing can prevent us from being thrown into the fire of hell and burning forever in the unquenchable flame. For just as those who have done good will rise to eternal life, so those who have dared to do the opposite will rise to eternal punishment, which never ends. Let us therefore show every eagerness not to destroy the benefit we receive from right faith through the wickedness of our actions, but by becoming pleasing to Him through these actions as well, to look boldly upon Christ. No happiness can equal this. And may it happen that all of us, having obtained what has been mentioned, may do everything for the glory of God; to whom, with the Only-Begotten Son and the Holy Spirit, be glory forever and ever. Amen.

Let us pray then, that henceforth with the revelation of these thoughts and rightness of doctrine, we may have also a pure life and bright conversation, since these things profit nothing unless good works be present with us. For though we have all faith and all knowledge of the Scriptures, yet if we be naked and destitute of the protection derived from ( holy) living, there is nothing to hinder us from being hurried into the fire of hell, and burning for ever in the unquenchable flame. For as they who have done good shall rise to life everlasting, so they who have dared the contrary shall rise to everlasting punishment, which never has an end. Let us then manifest all eagerness not to mar the gain which accrues to us from a right faith by the vileness of our actions, but becoming well-pleasing to Him by these also, boldly to look on Christ. No happiness can be equal to this. And may it come to pass, that we all having obtained what has been mentioned, may do all to the glory of God; to whom, with the Only-Begotten Son and the Holy Ghost, be glory for ever and ever. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 5 — John 1:3

Homily 5 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240105.htm>.

John 1:3

Moses at the beginning of the history and writings of the Old Testament speaks to us about physical objects and lists them at length. For he says, "In the beginning God made the heaven and the earth," and then he adds that light was created, and a second heaven and the stars, the various kinds of living creatures, and, so we do not waste time going through every detail, everything else. But this Evangelist, cutting everything short, includes both these things and the things above them in a single sentence. He does this reasonably, because his hearers already knew about them, and because he is hurrying to a greater subject. He has written his entire treatise so that he might speak not about the works but about the Creator, the one who produced them all. And therefore Moses, though he has selected the smaller portion of creation (for he has said nothing to us about the invisible powers), dwells on these things. Meanwhile John, as he hastens to ascend to the Creator himself, runs past both the things Moses mentioned and the things Moses was silent about, having compressed them in one brief statement: "All things were made by him." And so you may not think he merely speaks of all the things Moses mentioned, he adds that "without him was not anything made that was made." That is to say, of created things, not one, whether it be visible or intelligible, was brought into being without the power of the Son.

1. Moses in the beginning of the history and writings of the Old Testament speaks to us of the objects of sense, and enumerates them to us at length. For, In the beginning, he says, God made the heaven and the earth, and then he adds, that light was created, and a second heaven and the stars, the various kinds of living creatures, and, that we may not delay by going through particulars, everything else. But this Evangelist, cutting all short, includes both these things and the things which are above these in a single sentence; with reason, because they were known to his hearers, and because he is hastening to a greater subject, and has instituted all his treatise, that he might speak not of the works but of the Creator, and Him who produced them all. And therefore Moses, though he has selected the smaller portion of the creation, (for he has spoken nothing to us concerning the invisible powers,) dwells on these things; while John, as hastening to ascend to the Creator Himself, runs by both these things, and those on which Moses was silent, having comprised them in one little saying, All things were made by Him. And that you may not think that he merely speaks of all the things mentioned by Moses, he adds, that without Him was not anything made that was made. That is to say, that of created things, not one, whether it be visible or intelligible was brought into being without the power of the Son.

For we will not put the full stop after "not anything," as the heretics do. Because they wish to make the Spirit created, they say, "What was made, in Him was Life," yet saying it this way makes the passage unintelligible. First, this was not the time to make mention of the Spirit, and if he desired to do so, why did he state it so indistinctly? For how is it clear that this saying relates to the Spirit? Besides, we shall find by this argument not that the Spirit, but that the Son Himself, is created by Himself. But rouse yourselves, so that what is said may not escape you; and come, let us read for a while according to their fashion, for in this way its absurdity will become clearer to us. "What was made, in Him was Life." They say that the Spirit is called Life. But this Life is found to be also Light, for he adds, "And the Life was the Light of men" (John 1:4). Therefore, according to them the Light of men here means the Spirit. Well, but when he goes on to say that "There was a man sent from God, to bear witness of that Light" (verses 6-7), they must necessarily assert that this too is spoken of the Spirit; for whom he above called Word, Him as he proceeds he calls God, and Life, and Light. This Word he says was Life, and this Life was Light. If now this Word was Life, and if this Word and this Life became flesh, then the Life, that is to say, the Word, was made flesh, and we beheld Its glory, the glory as of the Only-Begotten of the Father. If then they say that the Spirit is here called Life, consider what strange consequences will follow. It will be the Spirit, not the Son, that was made flesh; the Spirit will be the Only-Begotten Son.

For we will not put the full stop after not anything, as the heretics do. They, because they wish to make the Spirit created, say, What was made, in Him was Life; yet so what is said becomes unintelligible. First, it was not the time here to make mention of the Spirit, and if he desired to do so, why did he state it so indistinctly? For how is it clear that this saying relates to the Spirit? Besides, we shall find by this argument, not that the Spirit, but that the Son Himself, is created by Himself. But rouse yourselves, that what is said may not escape you; and come, let us read for a while after their fashion, for so its absurdity will be clearer to us. What was made, in Him was Life. They say that the Spirit is called Life. But this Life is found to be also Light, for he adds, And the Life was the Light of men. John 1:4 Therefore, according to them the Light of men here means the Spirit. Well, but when he goes on to say, that There was a man sent from God, to bear witness of that Light vers. 6, 7, they needs must assert, that this too is spoken of the Spirit; for whom he above called Word, Him as he proceeds he calls God, and Life, and Light. This Word he says was Life, and this Life was Light. If now this Word was Life, and if this Word and this Life became flesh, then the Life, that is to say, the Word, was made flesh, and we beheld Its glory, the glory as of the Only-Begotten of the Father. If then they say that the Spirit is here called Life, consider what strange consequences will follow. It will be the Spirit, not the Son, that was made flesh; the Spirit will be the Only-Begotten Son.

And those who read the passage this way will fall, if not into this error, yet in avoiding it into another most strange conclusion. If they allow that the words are spoken of the Son, and yet do not stop or read as we do, then they will assert that the Son is created by Himself. For if the Word was Life, and what was made in Him was Life, then according to this reading He is created in Himself and through Himself. Then after some words in between, he has added, And we beheld His glory, the glory as of the Only-Begotten of the Father. John 1:14 Look, the Holy Spirit is found, according to the reading of those who assert these things, to be also an only-begotten Son, for it is concerning Him that all this declaration is spoken by him. See when the word has turned away from the truth, where it is twisted, and what strange consequences it produces!

And those who read the passage so will fall, if not into this, yet in avoiding this into another most strange conclusion. If they allow that the words are spoken of the Son, and yet do not stop or read as we do, then they will assert that the Son is created by Himself. Since, if the Word was Life, and what was made in Him was Life; according to this reading He is created in Himself and through Himself. Then after some words between, he has added, And we beheld His glory, the glory as of the Only-Begotten of the Father. John 1:14 See, the Holy Spirit is found, according to the reading of those who assert these things, to be also an only-begotten Son, for it is concerning Him that all this declaration is uttered by him. See when the word has swerved from the truth, whither it is perverted, and what strange consequences it produces!

What then, someone says, is the Spirit not Light? The Spirit is Light, but in this passage there is no mention of the Spirit. Even God the Father is called Spirit—that is, incorporeal—yet God the Father is not necessarily meant wherever Spirit is mentioned. And why are you surprised if we say this about the Father? We could not even say about the Comforter that wherever Spirit is mentioned, the Comforter is necessarily meant, even though this is His most distinctive name; still, the Comforter is not always meant wherever Spirit is mentioned. In the same way, Christ is called the power of God and the wisdom of God (1 Corinthians 1:24), yet Christ is not necessarily meant wherever the power and wisdom of God are mentioned. So in this passage, although the Spirit does give Light, the Evangelist is not now speaking about the Spirit.

What then, says one, is not the Spirit Light? It is Light: but in this place there is no mention of the Spirit. Since even God (the Father) is called Spirit, that is to say, incorporeal, yet God (the Father) is not absolutely meant wherever Spirit is mentioned. And why do you wonder if we say this of the Father? We could not even say of the Comforter, that wherever Spirit (is mentioned), the Comforter is absolutely meant, and yet this is His most distinctive name; still not always where Spirit (is mentioned is) the Comforter (meant). Thus Christ is called the power of God 1 Corinthians 1:24, and the wisdom of God; yet not always where the power and the wisdom of God are mentioned is Christ meant; so in this passage, although the Spirit does give Light, yet the Evangelist is not now speaking of the Spirit.

When we have excluded them from these strange opinions, those who make every effort to oppose the truth say (still holding to the same reading), "Whatever came into existence by him was life," because, one says, whatever came into existence was life. What then do you say about the punishment of the men of Sodom, the flood, hell fire, and countless similar things? But, one says, we are speaking of the material creation. Well, these too belong entirely to the material creation. But so that we may refute their argument from our abundance, we will ask them: Is wood life, tell me? Is stone life? These things that are lifeless and motionless? Moreover, is man absolutely life? Who would say so? He is not pure life, but is capable of receiving life.

When we have shut them out from these strange opinions, they who take all manner of pains to withstand the truth, say, (still clinging to the same reading,) Whatever came into existence by him was life, because, says one, whatever came into existence was life. What then do you say of the punishment of the men of Sodom, and the flood, and hell fire, and ten thousand like things? But, says one, we are speaking of the material creation. Well, these too belong entirely to the material creation. But that we may out of our abundance refute their argument, we will ask them, Is wood, life, tell me? Is stone, life? these things that are lifeless and motionless? Nay, is man absolutely life? Who would say so? He is not pure life, but is capable of receiving life.

See here again, an absurdity. By following the same chain of logical consequences, we will bring the argument to such a point that even from this you may learn their foolishness. In this way they assert things that are by no means fitting for the Spirit. Being driven from their other position, they apply to men those things which they previously thought were spoken worthily of the Spirit. However, let us examine the reading itself in this way also. The creature is now called life, therefore, the same is light, and John came to witness concerning it. Why then is he not also light? He says that he was not that light John 1:8, and yet he belonged to created things. How then is he not light? How was he in the world, and the world was made by him? John 1:10 Was the creature in the creature, and was the creature made by the creature? But how did the world not know him? How did the creature not know the creature? But as many as received him, to them he gave power to become the sons of God. John 1:12 But enough of laughter. For the rest I leave it to you to attack these absurd arguments, so that we may not seem to have chosen to raise a laugh for its own sake and waste time without cause. For if these things are neither said of the Spirit (and it has been shown that they are not) nor of anything created, and yet they still hold to the same reading, that stranger conclusion than any we previously mentioned will follow: that the Son was made by Himself. For if the Son is the true Light, and this Light was Life, and this Life was made in Him, this must necessarily be the result according to their own reading. Let us then abandon this reading and come to the recognized reading and explanation.

2. See here again, an absurdity; by the same succession of consequences we will bring the argument to such a point, that even hence you may learn their folly. In this way they assert things by no means befitting of the Spirit. Being driven from their other ground, they apply those things to men, which they before thought to be spoken worthily of the Spirit. However, let us examine the reading itself this way also. The creature is now called life, therefore, the same is light, and John came to witness concerning it. Why then is not he also light? He says that he was not that light John 1:8, and yet he belonged to created things? How then is he not light? How was he in the world, and the world was made by him? John 1:10 Was the creature in the creature, and was the creature made by the creature? But how did the world know him not? How did the creature not know the creature? But as many as received him, to them gave he power to become the sons of God. John 1:12 But enough of laughter. For the rest I leave it to you to attack these monstrous reasonings, that we may not seem to have chosen to raise a laugh for its own sake, and waste the time without cause. For if these things are neither said of the Spirit, (and it has been shown that they are not,) nor of anything created, and yet they still hold to the same reading, that stranger conclusion than any which we before mentioned, will follow, that the Son was made by Himself. For if the Son is the true Light, and this Light was Life, and this Life was made in Him, this must needs be the result according to their own reading. Let us then relinquish this reading, and come to the recognized reading and explanation.

And what is that? It is to make the sentence end at "was made," and to begin the next sentence with "In Him was Life." What the Evangelist says is this: "Without Him was not anything made that was made." Whatever created thing was made, he says, was not made without Him. Do you see how by this short addition he has corrected all the surrounding difficulties? For when he said that without Him nothing was made, and then added "which was made," he includes things perceived by the intellect but excludes the Spirit. For after he had said that all things were made by Him, and without Him nothing was made, he needed this addition, in case someone should say, "If all things were made by Him, then the Spirit also was made." He replies: I asserted that whatever was made was made by Him, even though it may be invisible, or incorporeal, or in the heavens. For this reason, I did not say absolutely "all things," but "whatever was made," that is, "created things," but the Spirit is uncreated.

And what is that? It is to make the sentence end at was made, and to begin the next sentence with, In Him was Life. What (the Evangelist) says is this, Without Him was not anything made that was made; whatever created thing was made, says he, was not made without Him. See you how by this short addition he has rectified all the besetting difficulties; for the saying, that without Him was not anything made, and then the adding, which was made, includes things cognizable by the intellect, but excludes the Spirit. For after he had said that all things were made by Him, and without Him was not anything made, he needed this addition, lest some one should say, If all things were made by Him, then the Spirit also was made. I, he replies, asserted that whatever was made was made by Him, even though it be invisible, or incorporeal, or in the heavens. For this reason, I did not say absolutely, 'all things,' but 'whatever was made,' that is, ' created things,' but the Spirit is uncreated.

Do you see how precise his teaching is? He has referred to the creation of material things (since Moses had already taught about these earlier), and after leading us to move beyond these to higher things—I mean the immaterial and invisible—he excludes the Holy Spirit from all creation. Paul, inspired by the same grace, said the same thing: "For by Him were all things created" (Colossians 1:16). Notice again the same precision here, for the same Spirit moved Paul's soul as well. So that no one would exclude any created things from God's works simply because they are invisible, or would confuse the Comforter with created things, Paul, after going through the sensible objects that everyone knows about, also lists the things in the heavens, saying "whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers." The word "whether" attached to each one shows us nothing other than this: that all things were made by Him, and without Him was not anything made that was made.

Do you see the precision of his teaching? He has alluded to the creation of material things, (for concerning these Moses had taught before him,) and after bringing us to advance from thence to higher things, I mean the immaterial and the invisible, he excepts the Holy Spirit from all creation. And so Paul, inspired by the same grace, said, For by Him were all things created. Colossians 1:16 Observe too here again the same exactness. For the same Spirit moved this soul also. That no one should except any created things from the works of God because of their being invisible, nor yet should confound the Comforter with them, after running through the objects of sense which are known to all, he enumerates also things in the heavens, saying, Whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers; for the expression whether subjoined to each, shows to us nothing else but this, that by Him all things were made, and without Him was not anything made that was made.

But if you think that the word "by" indicates inferiority (as if it makes Christ merely an instrument), listen to him say, "You, Lord, in the beginning, laid the foundation of the earth, and the heavens are the work of Your hands" (Psalm 102:25). He says about the Son what is said about the Father in His role as Creator. He would not have said this unless he considered Him to be a Creator who is not subordinate to anyone. And if the expression "by Him" is used here, it is for no other reason than to prevent anyone from thinking the Son is Unbegotten. To see that in His title as Creator He is not at all inferior to the Father, listen to what He Himself says: "As the Father raises up the dead and gives them life, even so the Son gives life to whom He will" (John 5:21). Now if it is said of the Son in the Old Testament, "You, Lord, in the beginning laid the foundation of the earth," His title of Creator is clear. But if you say the Prophet spoke this about the Father, and that Paul applied to the Son what was said about the Father, the conclusion is still the same. For Paul would not have decided that the same expression suited the Son unless he had been completely confident that there was an equality of honor between Father and Son. It would have been extremely reckless to apply what suited an incomparable nature to a nature that was inferior to it and fell short of it. But the Son is not inferior to, nor does He fall short of, the ousia of the Father. Therefore Paul has not only dared to use these expressions about Him, but also other similar ones. For the expression "from whom," which you claim belongs properly to the Father alone, he also uses concerning the Son when he says, "from which all the body by joints and bands having nourishment ministered, and knit together, increases with the increase of God" (Colossians 2:19).

But if you think that the expression by is a mark of inferiority, (as making Christ an instrument,) hear him say, You, Lord, in the beginning, hast laid the foundation of the earth, and the heavens are the work of Your hands. Psalm 102:25 He says of the Son what is said of the Father in His character of Creator; which he would not have said, unless he had deemed of Him as of a Creator, and yet not subservient to any. And if the expression by Him is here used, it is put for no other reason but to prevent any one from supposing the Son to be Unbegotten. For that in respect of the title of Creator He is nothing inferior to the Father; hear from Himself, where He says, As the Father raises up the dead and quickens them, even so the Son quickens whom He will. John 5:21 If now in the Old Testament it is said of the Son, You, Lord, in the beginning hast laid the foundation of the earth, His title of Creator is plain. But if you say that the Prophet spoke this of the Father, and that Paul attributed to the Son what was said of the Father, even so the conclusion is the same. For Paul would not have decided that the same expression suited the Son, unless he had been very confident that between Father and Son there was an equality of honor; since it would have been an act of extremest rashness to refer what suited an incomparable Nature to a nature inferior to, and falling short of it. But the Son is not inferior to, nor falls short of, the Essence of the Father; and therefore Paul has not only dared to use these expressions concerning Him, but also others like them. For the expression from Whom, which you decide to belong properly to the Father alone, he uses also concerning the Son, when he says, from which all the body by joints and bands having nourishment ministered, and knit together, increases with the increase of God. Colossians 2:19

And he is not content with this only—he stops your mouths in another way also, by applying to the Father the expression "by whom," which you say is a mark of inferiority. For he says, "God is faithful, by whom you were called unto the fellowship of His Son" (1 Corinthians 1:9), and again, "By His will" (1 Corinthians 1:1), and in another place, "For of Him, and through Him, and to Him, are all things" (Romans 11:26). Neither is the expression "from whom" assigned to the Son only, but also to the Spirit; for the angel said to Joseph, "Fear not to take unto you Mary your wife, for that which is conceived in her is of the Holy Ghost" (Matthew 1:20). The Prophet also does not consider it improper to apply to the Father the expression "in whom," which belongs to the Spirit, when he says, "In God we shall do valiantly" (Psalm 60:12). And Paul says, "Making request, if by any means now at length I might have a prosperous journey, in the will of God, to come unto you" (Romans 1:10). And again he uses it of Christ, saying, "In Christ Jesus" (Romans 6:11, 23, etc.). In short, we may often and continually find these expressions interchanged; now this would not have taken place, had not the same ousia been in every instance their subject. And so that you may not imagine that the words "All things were made by Him" are in this case used concerning His miracles (for the other Evangelists have discoursed concerning these), he further goes on to say, "He was in the world, and the world was made by Him" (but not the Spirit, for This is not of the number of created things, but of those above all creation).

3. And he is not content with this only, he stops your mouths in another way also, by applying to the Father the expression by whom, which you say is a mark of inferiority. For he says, God is faithful, by whom you were called unto the fellowship of His Son 1 Corinthians 1:9: and again, By His will 1 Corinthians 1:1, etc.; and in another place, For of Him, and through Him, and to Him, are all things. Romans 11:26 Neither is the expression from whom, assigned to the Son only, but also to the Spirit; for the angel said to Joseph, Fear not to take unto you Mary your wife, for that which is conceived in her is of the Holy Ghost. Matthew 1:20 As also the Prophet does not deem it improper to apply to the Father the expression in whom, which belongs to the Spirit, when he says, In God we shall do valiantly. Psalm 60:12 And Paul, Making request, if by any means now at length I might have a prosperous journey, in the will of God, to come unto you. Romans 1:10 And again he uses it of Christ, saying, In Christ Jesus. Romans 6:11, 23, etc. In short, we may often and continually find these expressions interchanged; now this would not have taken place, had not the same Essence been in every instance their subject. And that you may not imagine that the words, All things were made by Him, are in this case used concerning His miracles, (for the other Evangelists have discoursed concerning these;) he farther goes on to say, He was in the world, and the world was made by Him; (but not the Spirit, for This is not of the number of created things, but of those above all creation.)

Let us now pay attention to what comes next. After John spoke about the work of creation—that all things were made by Him, and without Him nothing was made that was made—he goes on to speak about His Providence, where he says, "In Him was Life." So that no one may doubt how so many and such great things were made by Him, he adds that "In Him was Life." For just as with a fountain that is the source of the great deeps, however much you take away, you do not diminish the fountain at all, so with the energy of the Only-Begotten, however much you believe has been produced and made by it, it has not become any less. Or, to use a more familiar example, I will take the case of light, which the Apostle himself immediately mentioned, saying, "And the Life was the Light." Just as light, however many tens of thousands it may enlighten, suffers no reduction of its own brightness, so also God, before beginning His work and after completing it, remains equally indefectible, nothing diminished, nor wearied by the greatness of the creation. Indeed, if it were necessary that ten thousand, or even an infinite number of such worlds be created, He remains the same, sufficient for them all not merely to produce them, but also to govern them after their creation. For the word "Life" here refers not merely to the act of creation, but also to the providence concerned with the permanence of the things created. It also establishes beforehand the doctrine of the resurrection, and is the beginning of these marvelous good tidings. Since when life has come to be with us, the power of death is destroyed, and when light has shone upon us, there is no longer darkness, but life continually abides within us, and death cannot overcome it. So that what is asserted of the Father might be asserted absolutely of Him—Christ—also, that "In Him we live and move and have our being." As Paul has shown when he says, "By Him were all things created, and by Him all things consist," for which reason He has also been called Root and Foundation.

Let us now attend to what follows. John having spoken of the work of creation, that All things were made by Him, and without Him was not anything made that was made, goes on to speak concerning His Providence, where he says, In Him was Life. That no one may doubt how so many and so great things were made by Him, he adds, that In Him was Life. For as with the fountain which is the mother of the great deeps, however much you take away you nothing lessen the fountain; so with the energy of the Only-Begotten, however much you believe has been produced and made by it, it has become no whit the less. Or, to use a more familiar example, I will instance that of light, which the Apostle himself added immediately, saying, And the Life was the Light. As then light, however many myriads it may enlighten, suffers no diminution of its own brightness; so also God, before commencing His work and after completing it, remains alike indefectible, nothing diminished, nor wearied by the greatness of the creation. Nay, if need were that ten thousand, or even an infinite number of such worlds be created, He remains the same, sufficient for them all not merely to produce, but also to control them after their creation. For the word Life here refers not merely to the act of creation, but also to the providence (engaged) about the permanence of the things created; it also lays down beforehand the doctrine of the resurrection, and is the beginning of these marvelous good tidings. Since when life has come to be with us, the power of death is dissolved; and when light has shone upon us, there is no longer darkness, but life ever abides within us, and death cannot overcome it. So that what is asserted of the Father might be asserted absolutely of Him (Christ) also, that In Him we live and move and have our being. Colossians 1:16-17 As Paul has shown when he says, By Him were all things created, and by Him all things consist; for which reason He has been called also Root and Foundation.

But when you hear that In Him was Life, do not think of Him as a compound being, since later on he says of the Father as well, As the Father has Life in Himself, so has He given to the Son also to have Life. Now just as you would not say that the Father is compounded because of this expression, neither can you say so of the Son. In the same way, in another place he says that God is Light, and elsewhere it is said that He dwells in light unapproachable. Yet these expressions are not used so that we might suppose a compounded nature, but so that little by little we may be led up to the highest teachings. For since one of the common people could not easily have understood how His life was Life in its own right, he first used that simpler expression, and afterwards leads those who have been trained in this way to the higher teaching. For He who had said that He has given Him (the Son) to have life, the same says in another place, I am the Life; and in another, I am the Light. And what, tell me, is the nature of this light? This kind of light is perceived not by the senses but by the intellect, enlightening the soul herself. And since Christ would later say that None can come unto Me except the Father draw him, the Apostle has in this place anticipated an objection and declared that it is He (the Son) who gives light. This is so that even though you hear a saying like this concerning the Father, you may not say that it belongs to the Father only, but also to the Son. For, All things, He says, which the Father has are Mine.

But when you hear that In Him was Life, do not imagine Him a compound Being, since farther on he says of the Father also, As the Father has Life in Himself, so has He given to the Son also to have Life John 5:26; now as you would not on account of this expression say that the Father is compounded, so neither can you say so of the Son. Thus in another place he says, that God is Light 1 John 1:5, and elsewhere (it is said), that He dwells in light unapproachable 1 Timothy 6:16; yet these expressions are used not that we may suppose a compounded nature, but that little by little we may be led up to the highest doctrines. For since one of the multitude could not easily have understood how His life was Life Impersonate, he first used that humbler expression, and afterwards leads them (thus) trained to the higher doctrine. For He who had said that He has given Him (the Son) to have life John 5:26; the Same says in another place, I am the Life John 14:6; and in another, I am the Light. John 8:12 And what, tell me, is the nature of this light? This kind (of light) is the object not of the senses, but of the intellect, enlightening the soul herself. And since Christ should hereafter say, that None can come unto Me except the Father draw him John 6:44; the Apostle has in this place anticipated an objection, and declared that it is He (the Son) who gives light John 1:9; that although you hear a saying like this concerning the Father, you may not say that it belongs to the Father only, but also to the Son. For, All things, He says, which the Father has are Mine. John 16:15

First, the Evangelist has instructed us about the creation, and after that he tells us about the goods relating to the soul that He provided to us by His coming. He has described these obscurely in one sentence when he says, "And the Life was the Light of men" (John 1:4). He does not say it was the light of the Jews, but universally of men. Not only the Jews but also the Greeks came to this knowledge, and this light was a common offer made to all. Why did he not add "Angels" but said "of men"? Because at present his discourse concerns the physis of men, and it was to them He came bearing glad tidings of good things.

First then, the Evangelist has instructed us respecting the creation, after that he tells us of the goods relating to the soul which He supplied to us by His coming; and these he has darkly described in one sentence, when he says, And the Life was the Light of men. John 1:4 He does not say, was the light of the Jews, but universally of men: nor did the Jews only, but the Greeks also, come to this knowledge, and this light was a common proffer made to all. Why did he not add 'Angels,' but said, 'of men?'? Because at present his discourse is of the nature of men, and to them he came bearing glad tidings of good things.

And the light shines in darkness. John 1:5 He calls death and error "darkness." For the light that our senses perceive does not shine in darkness, but separately from it. But the preaching of Christ has shone forth in the midst of prevailing error and made it disappear. And He, by enduring death, has so overcome death that He has recovered those already held by it. Since neither death overcame it nor error, and since it is bright everywhere and shines by its own proper strength, therefore he says,

And the light shines in darkness. John 1:5 He calls death and error, darkness. For the light which is the object of our senses does not shine in darkness, but apart from it; but the preaching of Christ has shone forth in the midst of prevailing error, and made it to disappear. And He by enduring death has so overcome death, that He has recovered those already held by it. Since then neither death overcame it, nor error, since it is bright everywhere, and shines by its proper strength, therefore he says,

And the darkness did not comprehend it. For the light cannot be overcome, and it will not dwell in souls that do not wish to be enlightened.

And the darkness comprehended it not. For it cannot be overcome, and will not dwell in souls which wish not to be enlightened.

But don't let it trouble you that it did not take hold of everyone, for God does not bring us to Himself by necessity and force, but by our own will and consent. Therefore, do not shut your doors against this light, and you will enjoy great happiness. This light comes through faith, and when it arrives, it abundantly illuminates the one who has received it. And if you demonstrate a pure life suitable for it, it remains dwelling within you continually. For He says, "He that loves Me will keep My commandments; and I and My Father will come unto him and make Our abode with him." Just as one cannot properly enjoy the sunlight unless he opens his eyes, so too one cannot fully share in this splendor unless he has opened the eye of the soul and made it thoroughly keen of sight.

4. But let it not trouble you that It took not all, for not by necessity and force, but by will and consent does God bring us to Himself. Therefore do not thou shut your doors against this light, and you shall enjoy great happiness. But this light comes by faith, and when it has come, it lights abundantly him that has received it; and if you display a pure life (meet) for it, remains indwelling within continually. For, He says, He that loves Me, will keep My commandments; and I and My Father will come unto him, and make Our abode with him. John 14:23; slightly varied As then one cannot rightly enjoy the sunlight, unless he opens his eyes; so neither can one largely share this splendor, unless he have expanded the eye of the soul, and rendered it in every way keen of sight.

But how is this accomplished? It happens when we have cleansed the soul from all the passions. For sin is darkness, and a deep darkness; this is clear because people do it unconsciously and secretly. For "every one that does evil hates the light, neither comes to the light" (John 3:20). And "It is a shame even to speak of those things which are done of them in secret" (Ephesians 5:12). For, just as in darkness a person knows neither friend nor foe and cannot perceive any of the properties of objects, so too is it in sin. For the person who desires to gain more makes no difference between friend and enemy; and the envious person regards with hostile eyes the one with whom he is very close; and the plotter is at mortal quarrel with everyone alike. In short, as to distinguishing the nature of objects, the person who commits sin is no better than those who are drunk or insane. And just as at night, wood, lead, iron, silver, gold, and precious stones all seem alike to us because of the absence of the light which shows their distinctions, so the person who leads an impure life knows neither the excellence of temperance nor the beauty of philosophy. For in darkness, as I said before, even precious stones if displayed do not show their luster, not because of their own nature, but because of the lack of discernment in those who look at them. Nor is this the only evil that happens to us who are in sin, but also this: we live in constant fear. And just as people walking on a moonless night tremble though no one is there to frighten them, so those who work iniquity cannot have confidence, though there is no one to accuse them; but they are afraid of everything and are suspicious, being pricked by their conscience. Everything to them is full of fear and distress; they look around at everything and are terrified at everything. Let us then flee such a painful life, especially since after this painfulness will follow death—a deathless death, for the punishment in that place will have no end. And in this life those who sin are no better than madmen, in that they are dreaming of things that have no existence. They think they are rich when they are not rich, that they are enjoying when they are not enjoying, nor do they properly perceive the deception until they are freed from the madness and have shaken off the sleep. Therefore Paul exhorts everyone to be sober and to watch, and Christ also commands the same. For the person who is sober and awake, although he may be captured by sin, quickly beats it off; while the person who sleeps and is beside himself does not perceive how he is held prisoner by it.

But how is this effected? Then when we have cleansed the soul from all the passions. For sin is darkness, and a deep darkness; as is clear, because men do it unconsciously and secretly. For, every one that does evil hates the light, neither comes to the light. John 3:20 And, It is a shame even to speak of those things which are done of them in secret. Ephesians 5:12 For, as in darkness a man knows neither friend nor foe, but cannot perceive any of the properties of objects; so too is it in sin. For he who desires to get more gain, makes no difference between friend and enemy; and the envious regards with hostile eyes the man with whom he is very intimate; and the plotter is at mortal quarrel with all alike. In short, as to distinguishing the nature of objects, he who commits sin is no better than men who are drunk or mad. And as in the night, wood, lead, iron, silver, gold, precious stones, seem to us all alike on account of the absence of the light which shows their distinctions; so he who leads an impure life knows neither the excellence of temperance nor the beauty of philosophy. For in darkness, as I said before, even precious stones if they be displayed do not show their luster, not by reason of their own nature, but because of the want of discernment in the beholders. Nor is this the only evil which happens to us who are in sin, but this also, that we live in constant fear: and as men walking in a moonless night tremble, though none be by to frighten them; so those who work iniquity cannot have confidence, though there be none to accuse them; but they are afraid of everything, and are suspicious, being pricked by their conscience: all to them is full of fear and distress, they look about them at everything, are terrified at everything. Let us then flee a life so painful, especially since after this painfulness shall follow death; a deathless death, for of the punishment in that place there will be no end; and in this life they (who sin) are no better than madmen, in that they are dreaming of things that have no existence. They think they are rich when they are not rich, that they enjoy when they are not enjoying, nor do they properly perceive the cheat until they are freed from the madness and have shaken off the sleep. Wherefore Paul exhorts all to be sober, and to watch; and Christ also commands the same. For he who is sober and awake, although he be captured by sin, quickly beats it off; while he who sleeps and is beside himself, perceives not how he is held prisoner of it.

Let us not sleep, then. This is not the time of night, but of day. So let us walk honestly as in the day, and nothing is more indecent than sin. When it comes to indecency, it is not as bad to go about naked as it is to live in sin and wrongdoing. Being naked is not such a great cause for blame, since it might even be caused by poverty. But nothing has more shame and less honor than the sinner. Let us think about those who come to the courthouse on some charge of extortion or fraud—how base and ridiculous they appear to everyone through their utter shamelessness, their lies, and their audacity. But we are such pitiful and wretched beings that we cannot bear to put on a garment awkwardly or crooked. In fact, if we see another person in this state, we straighten them out. And yet though we and all our neighbors are walking on our heads, we do not even notice it. For what, I ask, can be more shameful than a man who goes in to a prostitute? What is more contemptible than an insolent, foul-mouthed, or envious man? Why then do these things not seem as disgraceful as walking naked? Simply from habit. No one has ever willingly endured going naked, but all men are continually venturing into the other sins without any fear. Yet if one came into an assembly of angels, among whom nothing of the sort has ever taken place, there he would clearly see the great ridiculousness of such conduct. And why do I mention an assembly of angels? Even in the very palaces among us, should someone bring in a prostitute and enjoy her, or be overcome by excess of wine, or commit any other similar indecency, he would suffer extreme punishment. But if it is intolerable that men should dare such things in palaces, much more when the King is everywhere present and observes what is done, we shall undergo the severest punishment if we dare them. Therefore let us, I urge you, show forth in our lives much gentleness, much purity, for we have a King who continually observes all our actions. So that this light may ever richly enlighten us, let us gladly accept these bright beams, for so we shall enjoy both the good things present and those to come, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom, and with whom, to the Father, and the Holy Spirit, be glory for ever and ever. Amen.

Let us then not sleep. This is not the season of night, but of day. Let us therefore walk honestly as in the day Romans 13:13; and nothing is more indecent than sin. In point of indecency it is not so bad to go about naked as in sin and wrong doing. That is not so great matter of blame, since it might even be caused by poverty; but nothing has more shame and less honor than the sinner. Let us think of those who come to the justice-hall on some account of extortion, or overreaching; how base and ridiculous they appear to all by their utter shamelessness, their lies, and audacity. But we are such pitiable and wretched beings, that we cannot bear ourselves to put on a garment awkwardly or awry; nay, if we see another person in this state, we set him right; and yet though we and all our neighbors are walking on our heads, we do not even perceive it. For what, say, can be more shameful than a man who goes in to a harlot? What more contemptible than an insolent, a foul-tongued or an envious man? Whence then is it that these things do not seem so disgraceful as to walk naked? Merely from habit. To go naked no one has ever willingly endured; but all men are continually venturing on the others without any fear. Yet if one came into an assembly of angels, among whom nothing of the sort has ever taken place, there he would clearly see the great ridicule (of such conduct). And why do I say an assembly of angels? Even in the very palaces among us, should one introduce a harlot and enjoy her, or be oppressed by excess of wine, or commit any other like indecency, he would suffer extreme punishment. But if it be intolerable that men should dare such things in palaces, much more when the King is everywhere present, and observes what is done, shall we if we dare them undergo severest chastisement. Wherefore let us, I exhort you, show forth in our life much gentleness, much purity, for we have a King who beholds all our actions continually. In order then that this light may ever richly enlighten us, let us gladly accept these bright beams, for so shall we enjoy both the good things present and those to come, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom, and with whom, to the Father, and the Holy Spirit, be glory for ever and ever. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 4 — John 1:1

Homily 4 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240104.htm>.

John 1:1

When children are first learning, their teachers don't pile on many tasks one after another or assign everything all at once. Instead, they often repeat the same short lessons so that what is taught can be easily planted in their minds. This way the children won't be overwhelmed at the start by the sheer amount or the difficulty of remembering it all, which would make them less eager to absorb what they're being given—a kind of laziness that comes from the difficulty itself. I want to do the same thing with you and make your work easier, so I'm taking bit by bit the food that sits on this divine table and pouring it into your souls. That's why I'm going to work through the same words again, not to repeat the same things, but to put before you only what still remains. So come, let's turn our discussion back to the introduction.

1. When children are just brought to their learning, their teachers do not give them many tasks in succession, nor do they set them once for all, but they often repeat to them the same short ones, so that what is said may be easily implanted in their minds, and they may not be vexed at the first onset with the quantity, and with finding it hard to remember, and become less active in picking up what is given them, a kind of sluggishness arising from the difficulty. And I, who wish to effect the same with you, and to render your labor easy, take little by little the food which lies on this Divine table, and instill it into your souls. On this account I shall handle again the same words, not so as to say again the same things, but to set before you only what yet remains. Come, then, let us again apply our discourse to the introduction.

In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God. Why did John, when all the other Gospel writers had begun with the Dispensation (for Matthew says, The Book of the generation of Jesus Christ, the Son of David; and Luke too relates to us at the beginning of his Gospel the events concerning Mary; and likewise Mark focuses on the same accounts, detailing from that point the history of the Baptist), why did John, when they began with these matters, only briefly mention them at a later point, saying, the Word was made flesh, and pass over everything else—His conception, His birth, His upbringing, His growth—to speak to us at once about His Eternal Generation?

In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God. Why, when all the other Evangelists had begun with the Dispensation; (for Matthew says, The Book of the generation of Jesus Christ, the Son of David; and Luke too relates to us in the beginning of his Gospel the events relating to Mary; and in like manner Mark dwells on the same narratives, from that point detailing to us the history of the Baptist;) why, when they began with these matters, did John briefly and in a later place hint at them, saying, the Word was made flesh John 1:14; and, passing by everything else, His conception, His birth, His bringing up, His growth, at once discourse to us concerning His Eternal Generation?

Because the other Evangelists had focused mostly on the accounts of His coming in the flesh, there was a danger that some people with earthbound minds might stick only to these teachings, as was actually the case with Paul of Samosata. Therefore, to lift up from this earthly focus those who were likely to fall into it, and to draw them upward toward heaven, John rightly begins his account from above and from the eternal existence. While Matthew starts his story from King Herod, Luke from Tiberius Caesar, and Mark from the Baptism of John, this Apostle leaves all these things aside and rises beyond all time or age. He directs the imagination of his hearers upward to the "was in the beginning," not allowing it to rest at any point or setting any boundary, as the others did with Herod, Tiberius, and John.

I will now tell you what the reason of this is. Because the other Evangelists had dwelt most on the accounts of His coming in the flesh, there was fear lest some, being of grovelling minds, might for this reason rest in these doctrines alone, as indeed was the case with Paul of Samosata. In order, therefore, to lead away from this fondness for earth those who were like to fall into it, and to draw them up towards heaven, with good reason he commences his narrative from above, and from the eternal subsistence. For while Matthew enters upon his relation from Herod the king, Luke from Tiberius Cæsar, Mark from the Baptism of John, this Apostle, leaving alone all these things, ascends beyond all time or age. Thither darting forward the imagination of his hearers to the was in the beginning, not allowing it to stay at any point, nor setting any limit, as they did in Herod, and Tiberius, and John.

And what we may mention besides as especially deserving our admiration is that John, though he gave himself up to the higher doctrine, yet did not neglect the Dispensation; nor were the others, though intent upon relating this, silent about the subsistence before the ages. With good cause, for one Spirit moved the souls of all, and therefore they have shown great unanimity in their narrative. But you, beloved, when you have heard of the Word, do not tolerate those who say that He is a work, nor even those who think that He is simply a word. For there are many words of God which angels execute, but none of those words is God; they are all prophecies or commands. (For in Scripture it is usual to call the laws of God His commands, and prophecies, words; therefore in speaking of the angels, he says, "Mighty in strength, fulfilling His word," Psalm 103:20.) But this Word is a Being with subsistence, proceeding without affection from the Father Himself. For this, as I said before, he has shown by the term Word. As therefore the expression "In the beginning was the Word" shows His eternity, so "was in the beginning with God" has declared to us His co-eternity. For lest you, when you hear "In the beginning was the Word," suppose Him to be eternal, and yet imagine the life of the Father to differ from His by some interval and longer duration, and so assign a beginning to the Only-Begotten, he adds "was in the beginning with God"—so eternally even as the Father Himself, for the Father was never without the Word, but He was always God with God, yet each in His proper prosopon.

And what we may mention besides as especially deserving our admiration is, that John, though he gave himself up to the higher doctrine, yet did not neglect the Dispensation; nor were the others, though intent upon the relation of this, silent as to the subsistence before the ages. With good cause; for One Spirit It was that moved the souls of all; and therefore they have shown great unanimity in their narrative. But you, beloved, when you have heard of The Word, do not endure those who say, that He is a work; nor those even who think, that He is simply a word. For many are the words of God which angels execute, but of those words none is God; they all are prophecies or commands, (for in Scripture it is usual to call the laws of God His commands, and prophecies, words; wherefore in speaking of the angels, he says, Mighty in strength, fulfilling His word) Psalm 103:20, but this Word is a Being with subsistence, proceeding without affection from the Father Himself. For this, as I before said, he has shown by the term Word. As therefore the expression, In the beginning was the Word, shows His Eternity, so was in the beginning with God, has declared to us His Co- eternity. For that you may not, when you hear In the beginning was the Word, suppose Him to be Eternal, and yet imagine the life of the Father to differ from His by some interval and longer duration, and so assign a beginning to the Only-Begotten, he adds, was in the beginning with God; so eternally even as the Father Himself, for the Father was never without the Word, but He was always God with God, yet Each in His proper Person.

How then, someone asks, does John claim that He was in the world if He was with God? Because He was both with God and in the world at the same time. For neither Father nor Son are limited in any way. Since, if there is no end to His greatness (Psalm 145:3), and if His wisdom cannot be numbered (Psalm 147:5), it is clear that there cannot be any beginning in time to His ousia (essence). You have heard that "In the beginning God made the heaven and the earth" (Genesis 1:1); what do you understand from this beginning? Clearly, that they were created before all visible things. So, concerning the Only-Begotten, when you hear that He was in the beginning, think of Him as before all intelligible things, and before the ages.

How then, one says, does John assert, that He was in the world, if He was with God? Because He was both with God and in the world also. For neither Father nor Son are limited in any way. Since, if there is no end of His greatness Psalm 145:3, and if of His wisdom there is no number Psalm 147:5, it is clear that there cannot be any beginning in time to His Essence. You have heard, that In the beginning God made the heaven and the earth Genesis 1:1; what do you understand from this beginning? Clearly, that they were created before all visible things. So, respecting the Only-Begotten, when you hear that He was in the beginning, conceive of him as before all intelligible things, and before the ages.

But if someone asks, "How can He be a Son and yet not younger than the Father? Since whatever proceeds from something else must necessarily be later than what it proceeds from," we will say that, properly speaking, these are human reasonings. Anyone who questions this matter will also question other things that are even more improper, and we ought not even to listen to such people. For our discussion is now about God, not about the nature of human beings, which is subject to the sequence and necessary conclusions of these reasonings. Still, for the assurance of those who are weaker, we will address even these points.

But if any one say, How can it be that He is a Son, and yet not younger than the Father? Since that which proceeds from something else needs must be later than that from which it proceeds; we will say that, properly speaking, these are human reasonings; that he who questions on this matter will question on others yet more improper; and that to such we ought not even to give ear. For our speech is now concerning God, not concerning the nature of men, which is subject to the sequence and necessary conclusions of these reasonings. Still, for the assurance of the weaker sort, we will speak even to these points.

Tell me, then, does the radiance of the sun proceed from the substance itself of the sun, or from some other source? Anyone not deprived of his very senses must confess that it proceeds from the substance itself. Yet, although the radiance proceeds from the sun itself, we cannot say that it is later in time than the substance of that body, since the sun has never appeared without its rays. Now if in the case of these visible and sensible bodies there has been shown to be something that proceeds from something else, and yet is not after that from which it proceeds, why are you incredulous in the case of the invisible and ineffable nature? This same thing takes place there, but in a manner suitable to that ousia. For it is for this reason that Paul too calls Him Brightness in Hebrews 1:3, setting forth thereby His being from Him and His co-eternity. Again, tell me, were not all the ages and every interval created by Him? Any man not deprived of his senses must necessarily confess this. There is no interval therefore between the Son and the Father; and if there is none, then He is not after, but co-eternal with Him. For before and after are notions implying time, since, without age or time, no man could possibly imagine these words; but God is above times and ages.

2. Tell me, then, does the radiance of the sun proceed from the substance itself of the sun, or from some other source? Any one not deprived of his very senses needs must confess, that it proceeds from the substance itself. Yet, although the radiance proceeds from the sun itself, we cannot say that it is later in point of time than the substance of that body, since the sun has never appeared without its rays. Now if in the case of these visible and sensible bodies there has been shown to be something which proceeds from something else, and yet is not after that from whence it proceeds; why are you incredulous in the case of the invisible and ineffable Nature? This same thing there takes place, but in a manner suitable to That Substance. For it is for this reason that Paul too calls Him Brightness Hebrews 1:3; setting forth thereby His being from Him and His Co- eternity. Again, tell me, were not all the ages, and every interval created by Him? Any man not deprived of his senses must necessarily confess this. There is no interval therefore between the Son and the Father; and if there be none, then He is not after, but Co- eternal with Him. For before and after are notions implying time, since, without age or time, no man could possibly imagine these words; but God is above times and ages.

But if you claim that you have found a beginning to the Son, consider whether by the same reasoning and argument you are not forced to reduce the Father also to a beginning—an earlier one perhaps, but still a beginning. For when you have assigned to the Son a limit and beginning of existence, don't you proceed upward from that point and say that the Father existed before it? Clearly you do. Tell me then, what is the extent of the Father's prior existence? For whether you say the interval is small or whether you say it is large, you have equally brought the Father to a beginning. For it is clear that you are measuring the space when you say whether it is small or large; yet it would not be possible to measure it unless there were a beginning on either side. So as far as you are concerned, you have given the Father a beginning, and from now on, according to your argument, not even the Father will be without beginning. Do you see that the word spoken by the Savior is true, and the saying reveals its force everywhere? And what is that word? It is: He who does not honor the Son does not honor the Father. John 5:23

But if in any case you say that you have found a beginning to the Son, see whether by the same reason and argument you are not compelled to reduce the Father also to a beginning, earlier indeed, but still a beginning. For when you have assigned to the Son a limit and beginning of existence, do you not proceed upwards from that point, and say, that the Father was before it? Clearly you do. Tell me then, what is the extent of the Father's prior subsistence? For whether you say that the interval is little, or whether you say it is great, you equally have brought the Father to a beginning. For it is clear, that it is by measuring the space that you say whether it is little or great; yet it would not be possible to measure it, unless there were a beginning on either side; so that as far as you are concerned you have given the Father a beginning, and henceforth, according to your argument, not even the Father will be without beginning. See you that the word spoken by the Saviour is true, and the saying everywhere discovers its force? And what is that word? It is He that honors not the Son, honors not the Father. John 5:23

And I know that what has just been said cannot be understood by many people, which is why in many places we avoid stirring up questions of human reasoning, because most people cannot follow such arguments, and even if they could, these arguments still contain nothing firm or certain in them. For the thoughts of mortal men are miserable, and our devices are but uncertain. Wisdom 9:14 Still I would like to ask those who object to us, what does it mean when the Prophet says, Before Me there was no God formed, nor is there any after Me? Isaiah 43:10 For if the Son is younger than the Father, how can He say, Nor is there any after me? Will you take away the very existence of the Only-Begotten Himself? You must either dare to do this, or admit one Godhead with distinct Persons of the Father and Son.

And I know indeed that what now has been said cannot by many be comprehended, and therefore it is that in many places we avoid agitating questions of human reasonings, because the rest of the people cannot follow such arguments, and if they could, still they have nothing firm or sure in them. For the thoughts of mortal men are miserable, and our devices are but uncertain. Wisdom 9:14 Still I should like to ask our objectors, what means that which is said by the Prophet, Before Me there was no God formed, nor is there any after Me? Isaiah 43:10 For if the Son is younger than the Father, how, says He, Nor is there any after me? Will you take away the being of the Only-Begotten Himself? You either must dare this, or admit one Godhead with distinct Persons of the Father and Son.

Finally, how could the statement "All things were made by Him" be true? For if there is an age older than He is, how can that which existed before Him have been made by Him? Do you see to what reckless conclusion the argument has led them, once the truth has been abandoned? Why did the Evangelist not say that He was made from things that were not, as Paul declares of all things when he says, "Who calls those things which be not as though they were," but instead says, "Was in the beginning"? This is the opposite of that, and rightly so. For God neither is made, nor has anything older than Him; these are ideas of the Greeks. Tell me this as well: Would you not say that the Creator excels His works beyond all comparison? Yet since that which is from things that were not is similar to them, where is the superiority that admits no comparison? And what do the expressions mean: "I am the first and I am the last," and "before Me was no other God formed"? For if the Son is not of the same ousia, there is another God; and if He is not co-eternal, He is after Him; and if He did not proceed from His ousia, it is clear that He was made. But if they claim that these things were said to distinguish Him from idols, why do they not allow that it is to distinguish Him from idols that he says "the Only True God"? Besides, if this was said to distinguish Him from idols, how would you interpret the whole sentence? "After Me," He says, "is no other God." In saying this, He does not exclude the Son, but says that after Him there is no idol God, not that there is no Son. "Granted," he says; "what then?" And will you understand the expression "Before Me was no other God formed" to mean that no idol God indeed was formed before Him, but yet a Son was formed before Him? What evil spirit would assert this? I do not suppose that even Satan himself would do so.

Finally, how could the expression, All things were made by Him, be true? For if there is an age older than He, how can that which was before Him have been made by Him? Do you see to what daring the argument has carried them, when once the truth has been unsettled? Why did not the Evangelist say, that He was made from things that were not, as Paul declares of all things, when he says, Who calls those things which be not as though they were; but says, Was in the beginning? Romans 4:17 This is contrary to that; and with good reason. For God neither is made, nor has anything older; these are words of the Greeks. Tell me this too: Would you not say, that the Creator beyond all comparison excels His works? Yet since that which is from things that were not is similar to them, where is the superiority not admitting of comparison? And what mean the expressions, I am the first and I am the last Isaiah 44:6; and, before Me was no other God formed? Isaiah 43:10 For if the Son be not of the same Essence, there is another God; and if He be not Co- eternal, He is after Him; and if He did not proceed from His Essence, clear it is that He was made. But if they assert, that these things were said to distinguish Him from idols, why do they not allow that it is to distinguish Him from idols that he says, the Only True God? John 17:3 Besides, if this was said to distinguish Him from idols, how would you interpret the whole sentence? After Me, He says, is no other God. In saying this, He does not exclude the Son, but that After Me there is no idol God, not that there is no Son. Allowed, says he; what then? And the expression, Before Me was no other God formed, will you so understand, as that no idol God indeed was formed before Him, but yet a Son was formed before Him? What evil spirit would assert this? I do not suppose that even Satan himself would do so.

Moreover, if He is not co-eternal with the Father, how can you say that His life is infinite? For if it has a beginning from before, even though it is endless, it is still not infinite; for the infinite must be infinite in both directions. As Paul also declared when he said, "Having neither beginning of days, nor end of life" (Hebrews 7:3), by this expression showing that He is both without beginning and without end. For just as the one has no limit, so neither does the other. In one direction there is no end, in the other no beginning.

Moreover, if He be not Co- eternal with the Father, how can you say that His Life is infinite? For if it have a beginning from before, although it be endless, yet it is not infinite; for the infinite must be infinite in both directions. As Paul also declared, when he said, Having neither beginning of days, nor end of life Hebrews 7:3; by this expression showing that He is both without beginning and without end. For as the one has no limit, so neither has the other. In one direction there is no end, in the other no beginning.

And how, since He is Life, could there ever have been a time when He was not? Everyone must acknowledge that Life both exists always and is without beginning and without end, if it really is Life, as it truly is. For if there is ever a time when it does not exist, how can it be the life of others when it does not even exist itself?

3. And how again, since He is Life, was there ever when He was not? For all must allow, that Life both is always, and is without beginning and without end, if It be indeed Life, as indeed It is. For if there be when It is not, how can It be the life of others, when It even Itself is not?

How then, someone asks, does John establish a beginning by saying, "In the beginning was"? Tell me, have you paid attention to "In the beginning" and to "was," and do you not understand the expression "the Word was"? What! When the Prophet says, "From everlasting and to everlasting You are" (Psalm 90:2), does he say this to assign Him limits? No, but to declare His eternity. Consider now that the case is the same here. He did not use the expression to assign limits, since he did not say "had a beginning," but "was in the beginning." By the word "was" he carries you forward to the idea that the Son is without beginning. Yet observe, someone says, the Father is named with the addition of the article, but the Son without it. What then, when the Apostle says, "The Great God, and our Savior Jesus Christ" (Titus 2:13), and again, "Who is above all, God" (Romans 9:5)? It is true that here he has mentioned the Son without the article, but he does the same with the Father also—at least in his Epistle to the Philippians (Philippians 2:6) he says, "Who being in the form of God, thought it not robbery to be equal with God," and again to the Romans, "Grace to you, and peace, from God our Father, and the Lord Jesus Christ" (Romans 1:7). Besides, it was unnecessary for it to be attached in that place, when just above it was continually attached to the Word. For just as when speaking about the Father, he says, "God is a Spirit" (John 4:24), and we do not, because the article is not joined to Spirit, deny the spiritual nature of God, so here, although the article is not attached to the Son, the Son is not on that account a lesser God. Why so? Because in saying God, and again God, he does not reveal to us any difference in this Godhead, but the contrary. For having said before, "and the Word was God," lest anyone suppose the Godhead of the Son to be inferior, he immediately adds the characteristics of genuine Godhead, including eternity (for "He was," he says, "in the beginning with God"), and attributing to Him the office of Creator. "For by Him were all things made, and without Him was not anything made that was made"—which His Father also everywhere through the Prophets declares to be especially characteristic of His own ousia (essence). And the Prophets are continually busy with this kind of demonstration, not only by itself, but when they contend against the honor shown to idols: "Let the gods perish," says one, "who have not made heaven and earth" (Jeremiah 10:11); and again, "I have stretched out the heaven with My hand" (Isaiah 44:24). And it is as declaring it to be indicative of Divinity that He everywhere puts it. And the Evangelist himself was not satisfied with these words, but calls Him Life too and Light. If now He was always with the Father, if He Himself created all things, if He brought all things into existence and holds all things together (for this is what he meant by Life), if He enlightens all things, who is so senseless as to say that the Evangelist desired to teach an inferiority of Divinity by those very expressions by which, rather than by any others, it is possible to express its equality and sameness? Let us not then confuse the creation with the Creator, lest we too hear it said of us that they "served the creature rather than the Creator" (Romans 1:25). For although it may be asserted that this is said of the heavens, still in speaking of the heavens he clearly says that we must not serve the creature, for it is a heathen thing.

How then, says one, does John lay down a beginning by saying, 'In the beginning was'? Tell me, have you attended to the In the beginning, and to the was, and do you not understand the expression, the Word was? What! When the Prophet says, From everlasting and to everlasting You are Psalm 90:2, does he say this to assign Him limits? No, but to declare His Eternity. Consider now that the case is the same in this place. He did not use the expression as assigning limits, since he did not say, had a beginning, but was in the beginning; by the word was carrying you forward to the idea that the Son is without beginning. Yet observe, says he, the Father is named with the addition of the article, but the Son without it. What then, when the Apostle says, The Great God, and our Saviour Jesus Christ Titus 2:13; and again, Who is above all, God? Romans 9:5 It is true that here he has mentioned the Son, without the article; but he does the same with the Father also, at least in his Epistle to the Philippians Philippians 2:6, he says, Who being in the form of God, thought it not robbery to be equal with God; and again to the Romans, Grace to you, and peace, from God our Father, and the Lord Jesus Christ. Romans 1:7 Besides, it was superfluous for it to be attached in that place, when close above it was continually attached to the Word. For as in speaking concerning the Father, he says, God is a Spirit John 4:24, and we do not, because the article is not joined to Spirit, yet deny the Spiritual Nature of God; so here, although the article is not annexed to the Son, the Son is not on that account a less God. Why so? Because in saying God, and again God, he does not reveal to us any difference in this Godhead, but the contrary; for having before said, and the Word was God; that no one might suppose the Godhead of the Son to be inferior, he immediately adds the characteristics of genuine Godhead, including Eternity, (for He was, says he, in the beginning with God,) and attributing to Him the office of Creator. For by Him were all things made, and without Him was not anything made that was made; which His Father also everywhere by the Prophets declares to be especially characteristic of His own Essence. And the Prophets are continually busy on this kind of demonstration, not only of itself, but when they contend against the honor shown to idols; Let the gods perish, says one who have not made heaven and earth Jeremiah 10:11: and again, I have stretched out the heaven with My hand Isaiah 44:24; and it is as declaring it to be indicative of Divinity, that He everywhere puts it. And the Evangelist himself was not satisfied with these words, but calls Him Life too and Light. If now He was ever with the Father, if He Himself created all things, if He brought all things into existence, and keeps together all things, (for, this he meant by Life,) if He enlightens all things, who so senseless as to say, that the Evangelist desired to teach an inferiority of Divinity by those very expressions, by which, rather than by any others, it is possible to express its equality and not differing? Let us not then confound the creation with the Creator, lest we too hear it said of us, that they served the creature rather than the Creator Romans 1:25; for although it be asserted that this is said of the heavens, still in speaking of the heavens he positively says, that we must not serve the creature, for it is a heathenish thing.

Let us not bring this curse upon ourselves. The Son of God came to free us from this bondage. He took the form of a slave to liberate us from this slavery. He endured being spit upon, beaten, and suffered a shameful death for this purpose. I beg you, let us not make all these things meaningless. Let us not return to our former unrighteousness—or rather, to an even worse unrighteousness. For serving the creature is not the same as dragging the Creator down, as far as we are able, to the lowliness of the creature. Yet He remains what He is, as the Psalmist says: "You are the same, and Your years shall not fail" (Psalm 102:27). Let us glorify Him as we have received from our fathers. Let us glorify Him both through our faith and through our works, because correct doctrine profits us nothing for salvation if our life is corrupt. Let us order our lives according to what pleases God, setting ourselves far from all filthiness, unrighteousness, and greed, as strangers and foreigners and aliens to the things of this earth. If anyone has great wealth and possessions, let him use them as one who is merely passing through, and who, whether he wishes it or not, will soon depart from them. If someone is wronged by another, let him not remain angry forever—indeed, not even for a short time. For the Apostle has not permitted us more than a single day for expressing anger.

4. Let us therefore not lay ourselves under this curse. For this the Son of God came, that He might rid us from this service; for this He took the form of a slave, that He might free us from this slavery; for this He was spit upon, for this He was buffeted, for this He endured the shameful death. Let us not, I entreat you, make all these things of none effect, let us not go back to our former unrighteousness, or rather to unrighteousness much more grievous; for to serve the creature is not the same thing as to bring down the Creator, as far at least as in us lies, to the meanness of the creature. For He continues being such as He is; as says the Psalmist, You are the same, and Your years shall not fail. Psalm 102:27 Let us then glorify Him as we have received from our fathers, let us glorify Him both by our faith and by our works; for sound doctrines avail us nothing to salvation, if our life is corrupt. Let us then order it according to what is well-pleasing to God, setting ourselves far from all filthiness, unrighteousness, and covetousness, as strangers and foreigners and aliens to the things here on earth. If any have much wealth and possessions, let him so use them as one who is a sojourner, and who, whether he will or not, shall shortly pass from them. If one be injured by another, let him not be angry forever, nay rather not even for a time. For the Apostle has not allowed us more than a single day for the venting of anger.

Let not, he says, the sun go down upon your wrath (Ephesians 4:26)—and rightly so. For it is satisfying enough if nothing unpleasant happens even in so short a time. But if night also overtakes us, what has happened becomes more serious, because the fire of our wrath is increased tenfold by memory, and we examine it more bitterly when we have leisure. Before we obtain this destructive leisure and kindle a hotter fire, he tells us to prevent and quench the trouble beforehand. For the passion of wrath is fierce—fiercer than any flame—and so we need great haste to stop the flame and not allow it to blaze up high, for this disease becomes a cause of many evils. It has overturned whole houses, dissolved old friendships, and worked tragedies not to be remedied in a short moment of time. For, one says, the sway of his fury shall be his destruction (Sirach 1:22). Let us not then leave such a wild beast unbridled, but put upon him a muzzle that is strong in every way—the fear of the judgment to come. Whenever a friend grieves you, or one of your own family exasperates you, think of the sins you have committed against God, and that by kindness towards him you make that judgment more lenient to yourself ("Forgive," He says, "and you shall be forgiven," Luke 6:37), and your passion shall quickly skulk away.

Let not, says he, the sun go down upon your wrath Ephesians 4:26; and with reason; for it is matter for contentment that even in so short a time nothing unpleasant take place; but if night also overtake us, what has happened becomes more grievous, because the fire of our wrath is increased ten thousand times by memory, and we at our leisure enquire into it more bitterly. Before therefore we obtain this pernicious leisure and kindle a hotter fire, he bids us arrest beforehand and quench the mischief. For the passion of wrath is fierce, fiercer than any flame; and so we need much haste to prevent the flame, and not allow it to blaze up high, for so this disease becomes a cause of many evils. It has overturned whole houses, it has dissolved old companionships, and has worked tragedies not to be remedied in a short moment of time. For, says one, the sway of his fury shall be his destruction. Sirach 1:22 Let us not then leave such a wild beast unbridled, but put upon him a muzzle in all ways strong, the fear of the judgment to come. Whenever a friend grieves you, or one of your own family exasperates you, think of the sins you have committed against God, and that by kindness towards him you make that judgment more lenient to yourself, ( Forgive, says He, and you shall be forgiven) Luke 6:37, and your passion shall quickly skulk away.

And besides, consider this: whether there has been a time when you were being carried away into ferocity and controlled yourself, and another time when you were dragged along by the passion. Compare the two occasions, and you will gain great improvement from doing so. For tell me, when did you praise yourself? Was it when you were defeated, or when you had the mastery? Don't we in the first case strongly blame ourselves and feel ashamed even when no one reproves us, and don't many feelings of repentance come over us for both what we have said and done? But when we gain the mastery, aren't we then proud and exult as conquerors? For victory in the case of anger is not requiting evil with the like—that is utter defeat—but bearing meekly to be ill treated and ill spoken of. To get the better is not to inflict but to suffer evil. Therefore when angry do not say, "Certainly I will retaliate, certainly I will be revenged." Do not persist in saying to those who urge you to gain a victory, "I will not endure that the man mock me and escape clear." He will never mock you, except when you avenge yourself; or if he even should mock you, he will do so as a fool. Don't seek honor from fools when you conquer, but consider that sufficient which comes from men of understanding. In fact, why do I set before you a small and mean body of spectators when I make it up of men? Look up straight to God: He will praise you, and the man who is approved by Him must not seek honor from mortals. Mortal honor often arises from flattery or hatred of others and brings no profit, but the decision of God is free from this inequality and brings great advantage to the man whom He approves. This praise then let us pursue.

And besides, consider this, whether there has been a time when thou were being carried away into ferocity, and controlled yourself, and another time when you have been dragged along by the passion. Compare the two seasons, and you shall gain thence great improvement. For tell me, when did you praise yourself? Was it when you were worsted, or when you had the mastery? Do we not in the first case vehemently blame ourselves, and feel ashamed. even when none reproves us, and do not many feelings of repentance come over us, both for what we have said and done; but when we gain the mastery, then are we not proud, and exult as conquerors? For victory in the case of anger is, not the requiting evil with the like, (that is utter defeat,) but the bearing meekly to be ill treated and ill spoken of. To get the better is not to inflict but to suffer evil. Therefore when angry do not say, certainly I will retaliate, certainly I will be revenged; do not persist in saying to those who exhort you to gain a victory, I will not endure that the man mock me, and escape clear. He will never mock you, except when you avenge yourself; or if he even should mock you he will do so as a fool. Seek not when you conquer honor from fools, but consider that sufficient which comes from men of understanding. Nay, why do I set before you a small and mean body of spectators, when I make it up of men? Look up straight to God: He will praise you, and the man who is approved by Him must not seek honor from mortals. Mortal honor often arises from flattery or hatred of others, and brings no profit; but the decision of God is free from this inequality, and brings great advantage to the man whom He approves. This praise then let us follow after.

Do you want to learn what an evil anger is? Watch while others are quarreling in the forum. You cannot easily see the disgrace of the thing in yourself, because your reason is darkened and drunk; but when you are free from the passion, and while your judgment is sound, observe your own case in others. Notice, I urge you, the crowds gathering around, and the angry men acting shamefully in the midst like madmen. For when the passion boils up within the chest and becomes excited and savage, the mouth breathes fire, the eyes emit fire, the whole face becomes swollen, the hands extend disorderly, the feet move ridiculously, and they lunge at those who restrain them and differ in nothing from madmen in their insensibility to all these things; indeed, they differ not from wild donkeys, kicking and biting. Truly a passionate man is not a graceful one.

Will you learn what an evil is anger? Stand by while others are quarreling in the forum. In yourself you cannot easily see the disgrace of the thing, because your reason is darkened and drunken; but when you are clear from the passion, and while your judgment is sound, view your own case in others. Observe, I pray you, the crowds collecting round, and the angry men like maniacs acting shamefully in the midst. For when the passion boils up within the breast, and becomes excited and savage, the mouth breathes fire, the eyes emit fire, all the face becomes swollen, the hands are extended disorderly, the feet dance ridiculously, and they spring at those who restrain them, and differ nothing from madmen in their insensibility to all these things; nay, differ not from wild asses, kicking and biting. Truly a passionate man is not a graceful one.

After such extremely ridiculous behavior, when they return home and come to their senses, they experience even greater pain and much fear as they think about who was present when they were angry. Like people in a state of madness, they did not know who was watching at the time, but when they have recovered their right mind, they wonder: were they friends? Were they enemies and opponents looking on? They fear equally about both groups—the first because they will condemn them and increase their shame, the others because they will rejoice at what happened. And if they even came to blows, their fear becomes more urgent—for instance, that something very serious might happen to the victim: a fever might follow and bring death, or a dangerous swelling might arise and put him in mortal danger. And they say, what need did I have of fighting and violence and quarreling? Let such things perish. Then they curse the unfortunate matter that caused them to begin, and the more foolish blame wicked spirits and an unlucky hour for what has been done. But these things do not come from an unlucky hour (for there is no such thing as an unlucky hour) or from a wicked spirit, but from the wickedness of those captured by the passion. They draw the spirits to themselves and bring upon themselves all terrible things. But the heart swells, someone says, and is stung by insults. I know it, and that is why I admire those who master this dreadful wild beast. Yet it is possible, if we will, to beat off the passion. For why, when our rulers insult us, do we not feel it? It is because fear counterbalances the passion, frightens us away from it, and does not allow it to spring up at all. And why do our servants, though insulted by us in countless ways, bear everything in silence? Because they too have the same restraint laid upon them. Do not think merely of the fear of God, but that it is God Himself who is insulting you then, who commands you to be silent, and then you will bear all things meekly and say to the aggressor: How can I be angry with you? There is another who restrains both my hand and my tongue. This statement will suggest sound wisdom both to yourself and to him. Even now we bear unbearable things on account of men, and often say to those who have insulted us: Someone else insulted me, not you. Shall we not use the same caution in the case of God? How else can we hope for pardon? Let us say to our soul: It is God who holds our hands, who is insulting us now; let us not resist, let God not be less honored by us than men. Did you shudder at these words? I wish you would shudder not at the words only, but at the deed. For God has commanded us, when struck, not only to endure it but even to offer ourselves to suffer something worse. Yet we resist Him with such force that we not only refuse to offer ourselves to suffer evil, but even take revenge—indeed, we are often the first to attack, and we think we are disgraced if we do not do the same in return. The problem is that when utterly defeated we think ourselves victors, and when lying underneath and receiving countless blows from the devil, we imagine that we are conquering him. Therefore, I urge you, let us understand what the nature of this victory is, and let us pursue this kind of nature. To suffer evil is to receive the crown. If we wish to be proclaimed victors by God, let us not observe the laws of pagan games in these contests, but God's laws, and let us learn to bear all things with long-suffering. For in this way we may overcome our opponents and obtain both present and promised goods, through the grace and loving-kindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, through whom and with whom, to the Father and the Holy Spirit, be glory, power, and honor, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.

And then, when after this exceedingly ridiculous conduct, they return home and come to themselves, they have the greater pain, and much fear, thinking who were present when they were angry. For like raving men, they did not then know the standers by, but when they have returned to their right mind, then they consider, were they friends? Were they foes and enemies that looked on? And they fear alike about both; the first because they will condemn them and give them more shame; the others because they will rejoice at it. And if they have even exchanged blows, then their fear is the more pressing; for instance, lest anything very grievous happen to the sufferer; a fever follow and bring on death, or a troublesome swelling rise and place him in danger of the worst. And, what need (say they) had I of fighting, and violence, and quarreling? Perish such things. And then they curse the ill-fated business which caused them to begin, and the more foolish lay on wicked spirits, and an evil hour, the blame of what has been done; but these things are not from an evil hour, (for there is no such thing as an evil hour,) nor from a wicked spirit, but from the wickedness of those captured by the passion; they draw the spirits to them, and bring upon themselves all things terrible. But the heart swells, says one, and is stung by insults. I know it; and that is the reason why I admire those who master this dreadful wild beast; yet it is possible if we will, to beat off the passion. For why when our rulers insult us do we not feel it? It is because fear counterbalances the passion, and frightens us from it, and does not allow it to spring up at all. And why too do our servants, though insulted by us in ten thousand ways, bear all in silence? Because they too have the same restraint laid upon them. And think thou not merely of the fear of God, but that it is even God Himself who then insults you, who bids you be silent, and then you will bear all things meekly, and say to the aggressor, How can I be angry with you? There is another that restrains both my hand and my tongue; and the saying will be a suggestion of sound wisdom, both to yourself and to him. Even now we bear unbearable things on account of men, and often say to those who have insulted us, Such an one insulted me, not you. Shall we not use the same caution in the case of God? How else can we hope for pardon? Let us say to our soul, It is God who holds our hands, who now insults us; let us not be restive, let not God be less honored by us than men. Did you shudder at the word? I wish you would shudder not at the word only, but at the deed. For God has commanded us when buffeted not only to endure it, but even to offer ourselves to suffer something worse; and we withstand Him with such vehemence, that we not only refuse to offer ourselves to suffer evil, but even avenge ourselves, nay often are the first to act on the offensive, and think we are disgraced if we do not the same in return. Yes, and the mischief is, that when utterly worsted we think ourselves conquerors, and when lying undermost and receiving ten thousand blows from the devil, then we imagine that we are mastering him. Let us then, I exhort you, understand what is the nature of this victory, and this kind of nature let us follow after. To suffer evil is to get the crown. If then we wish to be proclaimed victors by God, let us not in these contests observe the laws of heathen games, but those of God, and learn to bear all things with longsuffering; for so we may get the better of our antagonists, and obtain both present and promised goods, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, through whom and with whom to the Father and the Holy Spirit be glory, power, and honor, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 3 — John 1:1

Homily 3 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240103.htm>.

John 1:1

On the subject of paying attention while listening, it is unnecessary to urge you any further, since you have so quickly demonstrated through your actions the results of my advice. For the way you rush together, your attentive postures, the way you push one another in your eagerness to reach the inner places where you can hear my voice more clearly, your unwillingness to leave the crowd until this spiritual assembly ends, the clapping of hands, the sounds of approval—in short, all these things can be considered proof of the fervor of your souls and of your desire to hear. So on this point it is unnecessary to urge you. One thing, however, we must ask and plead: that you continue to have the same zeal, and show it not only here, but also when you are at home, that you talk with your wife, and father with son, about these matters. Say something yourselves, and ask for something in return from them, and in this way everyone can contribute to this excellent banquet.

1. On the subject of attention in hearkening it is superfluous to exhort you any more, so quickly have you shown by your actions the effects of my advice. For your manner of running together, your attentive postures, the thrusting one another in your eagerness to get the inner places, where my voice may more clearly be heard by you, your unwillingness to retire from the press until this spiritual assembly be dissolved, the clapping of hands, the murmurs of applause; in a word, all things of this kind may be considered proofs of the fervor of your souls, and of your desire to hear. So that on this point it is superfluous to exhort you. One thing, however, it is necessary for us to bid and entreat, that you continue to have the same zeal, and manifest it not here only, but that also when you are at home, you converse man with wife, and father with son, concerning these matters. And say somewhat of yourselves, and require somewhat in return from them; and so all contribute to this excellent banquet.

For let no one tell me that our children should not be occupied with these things; they should not only be occupied with them, but be zealous about them alone. And although because of your weakness I do not insist on this, nor take them away from their secular learning, just as I do not draw you away from your civil business either, yet of these seven days I ask that you dedicate one to the common Lord of us all. For is it not strange that we command our household servants to work for us all their time, yet we ourselves do not assign even a little of our leisure to God, especially when all our service adds nothing to Him (for the Godhead is incapable of want) but turns out to our own advantage? And yet when you take your children to the theaters, you cite neither their mathematics lessons nor anything of the kind as an objection; but if it becomes necessary to gain or gather anything spiritual, you call the matter a waste of time. And how will you not anger God, if you find leisure and set aside time for everything else, yet think it a troublesome and untimely thing for your children to take up what relates to Him?

For let no one tell me that our children ought not to be occupied with these things; they ought not only to be occupied with them, but to be zealous about them only. And although on account of your infirmity I do not assert this, nor take them away from their worldly learning, just as I do not draw you either from your civil business; yet of these seven days I claim that you dedicate one to the common Lord of us all. For is it not a strange thing that we should bid our domestics slave for us all their time, and ourselves apportion not even a little of our leisure to God; and this too when all our service adds nothing to Him, (for the Godhead is incapable of want,) but turns out to our own advantage? And yet when you take your children into the theaters, you allege neither their mathematical lessons, nor anything of the kind; but if it be required to gain or collect anything spiritual, you call the matter a waste of time. And how shall you not anger God, if you find leisure and assign a season for everything else, and yet think it a troublesome and unseasonable thing for your children to take in hand what relates to Him?

Do not act this way, brothers, do not act this way. It is precisely this age that most of all needs to hear these things, because children's minds readily store up what is said due to their tender years, and what they hear is impressed like a seal on the wax of their minds. Furthermore, it is during this time that their lives begin to incline toward vice or virtue. If someone leads them away from wrongdoing from the very gates and doorways, and guides them by the hand to the best path, he will establish in them a kind of habit and nature for the future. They will not easily change for the worse, even if they want to, since the force of this habit draws them toward performing good actions. As a result, we will see them become more worthy of respect than those who have grown old, and they will be more useful in civic affairs, displaying in their youth the qualities of the elderly.

Do not so, brethren, do not so. It is this very age that most of all needs the hearing these things; for from its tenderness it readily stores up what is said; and what children hear is impressed as a seal on the wax of their minds. Besides, it is then that their life begins to incline to vice or virtue; and if from the very gates and portals one lead them away from iniquity, and guide them by the hand to the best road, he will fix them for the time to come in a sort of habit and nature, and they will not, even if they be willing, easily change for the worse, since this force of custom draws them to the performance of good actions. So that we shall see them become more worthy of respect than those who have grown old, and they will be more useful in civil matters, displaying in youth the qualities of the aged.

If, as I said before, people who hear such things and are in the company of such an apostle cannot leave without receiving some great and significant benefit—whether man, woman, or young person who shares in this meal—then consider this: If we can train our animals with words and tame them that way, how much more effectively can we accomplish this with human beings through this spiritual teaching, since there is a vast difference both in the remedy used in each case and in the one being healed. We do not have as much wildness in us as the beasts do, since theirs comes from nature and ours from choice. Nor is the power of the words the same, for the power of human words comes from human intellect, but the power of these words comes from the might and grace of the Spirit. So let anyone who despairs about himself consider the tame animals, and he will no longer feel that way. Let him come regularly to this house of healing, let him hear constantly the laws of the Spirit, and when he goes home let him write down in his mind the things he has heard. Then his hopes will be good and his confidence great, as he experiences his own progress firsthand. For when the devil sees the law of God written in the soul, and the heart becoming tablets to write on, he will not approach anymore. Wherever the king's writing is found—not engraved on a brass pillar, but stamped by the Holy Spirit on a mind that loves God and shines with abundant grace—that evil one will not even be able to look at it, but will turn his back on us from a distance. For nothing is so terrible to him and to the thoughts he suggests as a mind attentive to divine matters and a soul that constantly draws from this fountain. Such a person cannot be troubled by anything present, even if it is unpleasant, nor puffed up or made proud by anything, even if it is favorable. Instead, amid all this storm and turmoil, he will enjoy a great calm.

For, as I before said, it cannot be that they who enjoy the hearing of such things as these, and who are in the company of such an Apostle, should depart without receiving some great and remarkable advantage, be it man, woman, or youth, that partakes of this table. If we train by words the animals which we have, and so tame them, how much more shall we effect this with men by this spiritual teaching, when there is a wide difference between the remedy in each case, and the subject healed as well. For neither is there so much fierceness in us as in the brutes, since theirs is from nature, ours from choice; nor is the power of the words the same, for the power of the first is that of the human intellect, the power of the second is that of the might and grace of the Spirit. Let then the man who despairs of himself consider the tame animals, and he shall no longer be thus affected; let him come continually to this house of healing, let him hear at all times the laws of the Spirit, and on retiring home let him write down in his mind the things which he has heard; so shall his hopes be good and his confidence great, as he feels his progress by experience. For when the devil sees the law of God written in the soul, and the heart become tablets to write it on, he will not approach any more. Since wherever the king's writing is, not engraved on a pillar of brass, but stamped by the Holy Ghost on a mind loving God, and bright with abundant grace, that ( evil one) will not be able even to look at it, but from afar will turn his back upon us. For nothing is so terrible to him and to the thoughts which are suggested by him as a mind careful about Divine matters, and a soul which ever hangs over this fountain. Such an one can nothing present annoy, even though it be displeasing; nothing puff up or make proud, even though it be favorable; but amidst all this storm and surge it will even enjoy a great calm.

For confusion arises within us not from the nature of circumstances, but from the weakness of our minds. If we were affected this way because of what happens to us, then, since we all sail the same sea and it is impossible to escape waves and spray, all people would necessarily be troubled. But if there are some who stand beyond the influence of the storm and the raging sea, then it is clear that circumstances do not make the storm, but rather the condition of our own mind does. If we therefore arrange our mind so that it may bear all things with contentment, we shall have no storm or even a ripple, but always a clear calm.

2. For confusion arises within us, not from the nature of circumstances, but from the infirmity of our minds; for if we were thus affected by reason of what befalls us, then, (as we all sail the same sea, and it is impossible to escape waves and spray,) all men must needs be troubled; but if there are some who stand beyond the influence of the storm and the raging sea, then it is clear that it is not circumstances which make the storm, but the condition of our own mind. If therefore we so order the mind that it may bear all things contentedly, we shall have no storm nor even a ripple, but always a clear calm.

After saying I would not speak on these points, I don't know how I've been drawn into such lengthy exhortation. Forgive my wordiness, for I fear—yes, I greatly fear—that this zeal of ours might someday grow weaker. If I felt confident about it, I wouldn't now be saying anything to you about these matters, since confidence alone would be enough to make everything easy for you. But it's time to move on to the topics we set out to consider today, so that you don't come to the contest already tired. For we have contests against the enemies of the truth, against those who use every trick to destroy the honor of the Son of God—or rather, their own. His honor remains forever as it is now, not diminished in the slightest by their blaspheming tongues, but they, by eagerly seeking to pull down the one they claim to worship, fill their faces with shame and their souls with punishment.

After professing that I should say nothing on these points, I know not how I have been carried away into such a length of exhortation. Pardon my prolixity; for I fear, yes, I greatly fear lest this zeal of ours should ever become weaker. Did I feel confident respecting it, I would not now have said to you anything on these matters, since it is sufficient to make all things easy to you. But it is time in what follows to proceed to the matters proposed for consideration today; that you may not come weary to the contest. For we have contests against the enemies of the truth, against those who use every artifice to destroy the honor of the Son of God, or rather their own. This remains for ever as it now is, nothing lessened by the blaspheming tongue, but they, by seeking eagerly to pull down Him whom they say they worship, fill their faces with shame and their souls with punishment.

What then do they say when we assert what we have asserted? That the words, "in the beginning was the Word," do not denote eternity absolutely, because this same expression was also used concerning heaven and earth. What enormous shamelessness and irreverence! I am speaking to you about God, and you bring the earth into the argument, and people who are of the earth? At this rate, since Christ is called Son of God and God, any person who is called son of God must be God also. For it says, "You are gods, and all of you are children of the Most High" (Psalm 82:6). Will you compete with the Only-Begotten concerning Sonship and claim that in that respect He has nothing more than you? "By no means," is the reply. And yet you do exactly this even if you don't say so in words. How? Because you say that you are a partaker of the adoption by grace, and He is in the same way. For by saying that He is not Son by nature, you are only making Him to be so by grace.

What then do they say when we assert what we have asserted? That the words, 'in the beginning was the Word,' do not denote eternity absolutely, for that this same expression was used also concerning heaven and earth. What enormous shamelessness and irreverence! I speak to you concerning God, and do you bring the earth into the argument, and men who are of the earth? At this rate, since Christ is called Son of God, and God, Man who is called Son of God must be God also. For, I have said, You are Gods, and all of you are children of the Most High. Psalm 82:6 Will you contend with the Only-Begotten concerning Sonship, and assert that in that respect He enjoys nothing more than thou? By no means, is the reply. And yet you do this even though thou say not so in words. How? Because you say that thou by grace art partaker of the adoption, and He in like manner. For by saying that He is not Son by nature, thou only makest him to be so by grace.

However, let's look at the proofs they present to us. "In the beginning, God made the heaven and the earth, and the earth was invisible and unformed" (Genesis 1:2). And, "There 'was' a man of Ramathaim Zophim" (1 Samuel 1:1). These are what they consider strong arguments, and they are strong—but they actually prove the correctness of the doctrines we assert, while being utterly powerless to support their blasphemy. Tell me, what does the word "was" have in common with the word "made"? What does God have in common with man? Why do you mix things that shouldn't be mixed? Why do you confuse things that are distinct? Why do you bring down what is above? In that passage, it's not just the word "was" alone that indicates eternity, but the fact that the One "was in the beginning." And then, "The Word was"—for just as the word "being," when used about man, only indicates present time, but when used about God indicates eternity, so "was," when used regarding our nature, signifies past time to us, and limited time at that, but when used regarding God it declares eternity. It would have been enough, then, when someone heard the words "earth" and "man," to imagine nothing more about them than what one should properly think about a nature that came into being. For whatever has come to be, whatever it may be, has come to be either in time or in the age before time existed, but the Son of God is above not only times but all ages that existed before, for He is the Creator and Maker of them, as the Apostle says, "by whom also He made the ages." Now the Maker necessarily exists before the thing made. Yet since some are so foolish as to have higher notions about creatures than they deserve, even after this, through the expression "He made" and that other one, "there was a man," he seizes the mind of his hearer beforehand and cuts up all shamelessness by the roots. For everything that has been made, both heaven and earth, has been made in time and has its beginning in time, and none of them is without beginning, since it has been made. So when you hear that he made the earth, and that there was a man, you are wasting your effort and weaving a tissue of useless nonsense.

However, let us see the proofs which they produce to us. In the beginning, it is said, God made the Heaven and the earth, and the earth was invisible and unformed. Genesis 1:2 And, There 'was' a man of Ramathaim Zophim. 1 Samuel 1:1 These are what they think strong arguments, and they are strong; but it is to prove the correctness of the doctrines asserted by us, while they are utterly powerless to establish their blasphemy. For tell me, what has the word was in common with the word made? What has God in common with man? Why do you mix what may not be mixed? Why confound things which are distinct, why bring low what is above? In that place it is not the expression was only which denotes eternity, but that One was in the beginning. And that other, The Word was; for as the word being, when used concerning man, only distinguishes present time, but when concerning God, denotes eternity, so was, when used respecting our nature, signifies to us past time, and that too limited, but when respecting God it declares eternity. It would have been enough then when one had heard the words earth and man, to imagine nothing more concerning them than what one may fitly think of a nature that came into being, for that which came to be, be it what it may, has come to be either in time, or the age before time was, but the Son of God is above not only times, but all ages which were before, for He is the Creator and Maker of them, as the Apostle says, by whom also He made the ages. Now the Maker necessarily is, before the thing made. Yet since some are so senseless, as even after this to have higher notions concerning creatures than is their due, by the expression He made, and by that other, there was a man, he lays hold beforehand of the mind of his hearer, and cuts up all shamelessness by the roots. For all that has been made, both heaven and earth, has been made in time, and has its beginning in time, and none of them is without beginning, as having been made: so that when you hear that he made the earth, and that there was a man, you are trifling to no purpose, and weaving a tissue of useless folly.

For I can mention another point to take this further. What is it? If Scripture had said about the earth, "In the beginning was the earth," and about man, "In the beginning was the man," we should not even then have imagined anything greater about them than what we now understand. For the terms "earth" and "man," as they are already understood, do not allow the mind to think anything greater about them than what we currently know, no matter what is said about them. In the same way, the Word, even if little is said about It, does not allow us to think anything low or poor concerning It. In what follows, Scripture says of the earth, "The earth was invisible and unformed." For having said that He made it, and having established its proper boundary, the writer then declares without hesitation what comes next, knowing that no one is foolish enough to suppose that it is without beginning and uncreated, since the word "earth," along with that other word "made," are sufficient to convince even a very simple person that it is not eternal or increate, but one of those things created in time.

For I can mention even another thing by way of going further. What is it? It is, that if it had been said of the earth, In the beginning was the earth, and of man, In the beginning was the man, we must not even then have imagined any greater things concerning them than what we have now determined. For the terms earth and man as they are presupposed, whatever may be said concerning them, do not allow the mind to imagine to itself anything greater concerning them than what we know at present. Just as the Word, although but little be said of It, does not allow us to think (respecting It) anything low or poor. Since in proceeding he says of the earth, The earth was invisible and unformed. For having said that He made it, and having settled its proper limit, he afterwards declares fearlessly what follows, as knowing that there is no one so silly as to suppose that it is without beginning and uncreated, since the word earth, and that other made, are enough to convince even a very simple person that it is not eternal nor increate, but one of those things created in time.

Besides, the expression "was," when applied to the earth and to man, does not indicate absolute existence. But in the case of a man it denotes his being from a certain place, and in the case of the earth its being in a certain way. For Scripture has not said absolutely "the earth was" and then stopped, but has taught how it was even after its creation—that it was invisible and unformed, still covered by the waters and in confusion. So in the case of Elkanah, Scripture does not merely say that there was a man, but also adds where he was from: Armathaim Zophim. But in the case of the Word, it is not like this. I am ashamed to compare these cases one against the other, for if we find fault with those who do this in the case of men, when there is a great difference in the virtue of those being compared, though in truth their ousia is one, then where the difference both of physis and of everything else is so infinite, is it not the most extreme madness to raise such questions? But may He who is blasphemed by them be merciful to us. For it was not we who invented the necessity of such discussions, but those who war against their own salvation laid it on us.

3. Besides, the expression was, applied to the earth and to man, is not indicative of absolute existence. But in the case of a man (it denotes) his being of a certain place, in that of the earth its being in a certain way. For he has not said absolutely the earth was, and then held his peace, but has taught how it was even after its creation, as that it was invisible and unformed, as yet covered by the waters and in confusion. So in the case of Elkanah he does not merely say that there was a man, but adds also whence he was, of Armathaim Zophim. But in the case of the Word, it is not so. I am ashamed to try these cases, one against the other, for if we find fault with those who do so in the case of men, when there is a great difference in the virtue of those who are so tried, though in truth their substance be one; where the difference both of nature and of everything else is so infinite, is it not the extremest madness to raise such questions? But may He who is blasphemed by them be merciful to us. For it was not we who invented the necessity of such discussions, but they who war against their own salvation laid it on us.

What then am I saying? That this first "was," applied to the Word, indicates only His eternal Being (for he says, "In the beginning was the Word"), and that the second "was" ("and the Word was with God") denotes His relative Being. For since being eternal and without beginning is most peculiar to God, he puts this first. Then, lest anyone hearing that He was in the beginning should assert that He was unbegotten also, he immediately corrects this by saying, before he declares what He was, that He was with God. And he has prevented anyone from supposing that this Word is simply such a word as is either uttered or conceived, by the addition, as I said before, of the article, as well as by this second expression. For he does not say "was in God," but "was with God," declaring to us His eternity as to person. Then, as he continues, he has more clearly revealed it by adding that this Word also was God.

What then do I say? That this first was, applied to the Word, is only indicative of His eternal Being, (for In the beginning, he says, was the Word,) and that the second was, ( and the Word was with God,) denotes His relative Being. For since to be eternal and without beginning is most peculiar to God, this he puts first; and then, lest any one hearing that He was in the beginning, should assert, that He was unbegotten also, he immediately remedies this by saying, before he declares what He was, that He was with God. And he has prevented any one from supposing, that this Word is simply such a one as is either uttered or conceived, by the addition, as I beforesaid, of the article, as well as by this second expression. For he does not say, was in God, but was with God: declaring to us His eternity as to person. Then, as he advances, he has more clearly revealed it, by adding, that this Word also was God.

But someone might say He was created. What stopped John from saying that in the beginning God made the Word? At least Moses, speaking of the earth, does not say that in the beginning the earth was, but that He made it, and then it was. So what prevented John from saying the same way that in the beginning God made the Word? If Moses was concerned that someone might claim the earth was uncreated, John should have been much more concerned about this regarding the Son, if He was indeed created. The world, being visible, by this very fact proclaims its Maker (the heavens, says the Psalmist, declare the glory of God Psalm 19:1), but the Son is invisible and is greatly, infinitely higher than all creation. Now then, in the case where we needed neither argument nor teaching to know that the world is created, the prophet still records this fact clearly and before all other things; how much more should John have declared the same concerning the Son, if He had truly been created.

But yet created, it may be said. What then hindered him from saying, that In the beginning God made the Word? At least Moses speaking of the earth says, not that in the beginning was the earth, but that He made it, and then it was. What now hindered John from saying in like manner, that In the beginning God made the Word? For if Moses feared lest any one should assert that the earth was uncreated, much more ought John to have feared this respecting the Son, if He was indeed created. The world being visible, by this very circumstance proclaims its Maker, ( the heavens, says the Psalmist, declare the glory of God Psalm 19:1), but the Son is invisible, and is greatly, infinitely, higher than all creation. If now, in the one instance, where we needed neither argument nor teaching to know that the world is created, yet the prophet sets down this fact clearly and before all others; much more should John have declared the same concerning the Son, if He had really been created.

Yes, it may be said, but Peter has stated this clearly and openly. Where and when? When speaking to the Jews he said that "God has made Him both Lord and Christ." Why do you not include what follows: "That same Jesus whom you have crucified"? Or do you not know that some of these words relate to His unmixed physis, and some to His Incarnation? But if this is not the case, and you insist on understanding everything as referring to the Godhead, then you will make the Godhead capable of suffering. But if it is not capable of suffering, then it is not created. For if blood had flowed from that divine and ineffable physis, and if that physis, and not the flesh, had been torn and cut by the nails upon the cross, then your objection would have some reason. But if not even the devil himself could speak such a blasphemy, why do you pretend ignorance so inexcusable that not even the evil spirits themselves could feign it? Besides, the terms Lord and Christ do not refer to His ousia, but to His dignity. For the one refers to His Power, the other to His having been anointed. What then would you say concerning the Son of God? For even if He were created, as you claim, this argument could not apply. For He was not first created and then chosen by God, nor does He hold a kingdom that could be set aside, but one that belongs by nature to His ousia. For when asked if He were a King, He answers, "To this end was I born." But Peter speaks as if concerning one chosen, because his argument entirely refers to the Incarnation.

Yes, it may be said, but Peter has asserted this clearly and openly. Where and when? When speaking to the Jews he said, that 'God has made Him both Lord and Christ.' Acts 2:36 Why do you not add what follows, That same Jesus whom you have crucified? Or do you not know that of the words, part relate to His unmixed Nature, part to His Incarnation? But if this be not the case, and you will absolutely understand all as referring to the Godhead, then you will make the Godhead capable of suffering; but if not capable of suffering, then not created. For if blood had flowed from that divine and ineffable Nature, and if that Nature, and not the flesh, had been torn and cut by the nails upon the cross, on this supposition your quibbling would have had reason; but if not even the devil himself could utter such a blasphemy, why do you feign to be ignorant with ignorance so unpardonable, and such as not the evil spirits themselves could pretend? Besides the expressions Lord and Christ belong not to His Essence, but to His dignity; for the one refers to His Power, the other to his having been anointed. What then would you say concerning the Son of God? For if he were even, as you assert, created, this argument could not have place. For He was not first created and afterwards God chose Him, nor does He hold a kingdom which could be thrown aside, but one which belongs by nature to His Essence; since, when asked if He were a King, He answers, To this end was I born. John 18:37 But Peter speaks as concerning one chosen, because his argument wholly refers to the Dispensation.

And why do you wonder if Peter says this? For Paul, reasoning with the Athenians, calls Him Man only, saying, "By that Man whom He has ordained, whereof He has given assurance to all men, in that He has raised Him from the dead." He speaks nothing concerning the form of God, nor that He was equal to Him, nor that He was the brightness of His glory. And with reason. The time for words like these had not yet come; but it would have contented him that they should in the meanwhile admit that He was Man, and that He rose again from the dead. Christ Himself acted in the same manner, and Paul, having learned from Him, used this same restraint. For He did not at once reveal to us His Divinity, but was at first held to be a Prophet and a good man; but afterwards His real nature was shown by His works and words. For this reason Peter too at first used this method (for this was the first sermon that he made to the Jews), and because they were not yet able clearly to understand anything concerning His Godhead, he dwelt on the arguments relating to His Incarnation, so that their ears, being trained in these, might open a way to the rest of his teaching. And if anyone will go through all the sermon from the beginning, he will find what I say very striking, for he (Peter) calls Him Man, and dwells on the accounts of His Passion, His Resurrection, and His generation according to the flesh. Paul too, when he says "Who was born of the seed of David according to the flesh," only teaches us that the word "made" is taken with a view to His Incarnation, as we allow. But the son of thunder is now speaking to us concerning His Ineffable and Eternal Existence, and therefore he leaves the word "made" and puts "was"; yet if He were created, this point he would have especially needed to establish. For if Paul feared that some foolish persons might suppose that He shall be greater than the Father, and have Him who begot Him made subject to Him (for this is the reason why the Apostle in sending to the Corinthians writes, "But when He says, All things are put under Him, it is manifest that He is excepted which did put all things under Him," yet who could possibly imagine that the Father, even in common with all things, will be subject to the Son?), if, I say, he nevertheless feared these foolish imaginations, and says, "He is excepted that did put all things under Him," much more if the Son of God were indeed created, ought John to have feared lest anyone should suppose Him uncreated, and to have taught on this point before any other.

4. And why do you wonder if Peter says this? For Paul, reasoning with the Athenians, calls Him Man only, saying, By that Man whom He has ordained, whereof He has given assurance to all men, in that He has raised Him from the dead. Acts 17:31 He speaks nothing concerning the form of God Philippians 2:6, nor that He was equal to Him, nor that He was the brightness of His glory. Hebrews 1:3 And with reason. The time for words like these was not yet come; but it would have contented him that they should in the meanwhile admit that He was Man, and that He rose again from the dead. Christ Himself acted in the same manner, from whom Paul having learned, used this reserve. For He did not at once reveal to us His Divinity, but was at first held to be a Prophet and a good man; but afterwards His real nature was shown by His works and words. On this account Peter too at first used this method, (for this was the first sermon that he made to the Jews;) and because they were not yet able clearly to understand anything respecting His Godhead, he dwelt on the arguments relating to His Incarnation; that their ears being exercised in these, might open a way to the rest of his teaching. And if any one will go through all the sermon from the beginning, he will find what I say very observable, for he (Peter) calls Him Man, and dwells on the accounts of His Passion, His Resurrection, and His generation according to the flesh. Paul too when he says, Who was born of the seed of David according to the flesh Romans 1:3, only teaches us that the word made is taken with a view to His Incarnation, as we allow. But the son of thunder is now speaking to us concerning His Ineffable and Eternal Existence, and therefore he leaves the word made and puts was; yet if He were created, this point he needs must most especially have determined. For if Paul feared that some foolish persons might suppose that He shall be greater than the Father, and have Him who begot Him made subject to Him, (for this is the reason why the Apostle in sending to the Corinthians writes, But when He says, All things are put under Him, it is manifest that He is excepted which did put all things under Him, yet who could possibly imagine that the Father, even in common with all things, will be subject to the Son?) if, I say, he nevertheless feared these foolish imaginations, and says, He is excepted that did put all things under Him; much more if the Son of God were indeed created, ought John to have feared lest any one should suppose Him uncreated, and to have taught on this point before any other.

But now, since He was Begotten, it makes perfect sense that neither John nor any other apostle or prophet has claimed that He was created. And if it had been otherwise, the Only-Begotten Himself would certainly not have left this unmentioned. For He who spoke of Himself so humbly out of condescension would certainly not have been silent on this matter. And I think it's quite reasonable to suppose that He would be more likely to possess the higher nature and say nothing about it, than to lack it and fail to make known through this silence that He did not have it. In the first case there was a good reason for silence: His desire to teach humankind humility by remaining silent about the greatness of His attributes. But in the second case you can find no just reason for silence. Why would He who set aside many of His real attributes have been silent, if He were created, about His having been made? He who, in order to teach humility, often spoke in lowly terms that did not properly belong to Him, would much more certainly not have failed to speak of this if He had actually been created. Don't you see Him doing and saying everything to show that He was begotten, so that no one might imagine He was not begotten? He utters words unworthy both of His dignity and His ousia, descending to the humble character of a prophet. For the expression "As I hear, I judge," and that other one, "He has told Me what I should say, and what I should speak," and similar statements, belong merely to a prophet. If now, from His desire to remove this suspicion, He did not hesitate to speak such lowly words, much more would He have said many similar words if He were created, so that no one might suppose Him to be uncreated—words like: "Think not that I am begotten of the Father; I am created, not begotten, nor do I share His ousia." But instead, He does the very opposite, and speaks words that compel people, even against their will and desire, to accept the opposite view. Such as: "I am in the Father, and the Father in Me," and "Have I been so long time with you, and yet have you not known Me, Philip? He that has seen Me, has seen the Father," and "That all men should honor the Son, even as they honor the Father." "As the Father raises up the dead and quickens them, even so the Son quickens whom He will." "My Father works hitherto, and I work." "As the Father knows Me, even so know I the Father." "I and My Father are One." And everywhere by using "as" and "so" and by speaking of being with the Father, He declares His undeviating likeness to Him. He manifests His power in Himself through these words, as well as through many others—such as when He says, "Peace, be still," "I will, be thou clean," "Thou dumb and deaf spirit, I charge you, come out of him." And again, "You have heard that it was said by them of old time, You shall not kill; but I say unto you, That whosoever is angry with his brother without a cause, shall be in danger." And all the other laws which He gave and wonders which He worked are sufficient to show His power—or rather, I should say, a very small part of them is enough to bring over and convince anyone, except the utterly senseless.

But now, since He was Begotten, with good reason neither John nor any other, whether apostle or prophet, has asserted that He was created. Neither had it been so would the Only-Begotten Himself have let it pass unmentioned. For He who spoke of Himself so humbly from condescension would certainly not have been silent on this matter. And I think it not unreasonable to suppose, that He would be more likely to have the higher Nature, and say nothing of it, than not having it to pass by this omission, and fail to make known that He had it not. For in the first case there was a good excuse for silence, namely, His desire to teach mankind humility by being silent as to the greatness of His attributes; but in the second case you can find no just excuse for silence. For why should He who declined many of His real attributes have been, if He were created, silent as to His having been made? He who, in order to teach humility, often uttered expressions of lowliness, such as did not properly belong to Him, much more if He had been indeed created, would not have failed to speak of this. Do you not see Him, in order that none may imagine Him not to have been begotten, doing and saying everything to show that He was so, uttering words unworthy both of His dignity and His essence, and descending to the humble character of a Prophet? For the expression, As I hear, I judge John 5:30; and that other, He has told Me what I should say, and what I should speak John 12:49, and the like, belong merely to a prophet. If now, from His desire to remove this suspicion, He did not disdain to utter words thus lowly, much more if He were created would He have said many like words, that none might suppose Him to be uncreated; as, Think not that I am begotten of the Father; I am created, not begotten, nor do I share His essence. But as it is, He does the very contrary, and utters words which compel men, even against their will and desire, to admit the opposite opinion. As, I am in the Father, and the Father in Me John 14:11; and, Have I been so long time with you, and yet have you not known Me, Philip? He that has seen Me, has seen the Father. John 14:9 And, That all men should honor the Son, even as they honor the Father. John 5:23 As the Father raises up the dead and quickens them, even so the Son quickens whom He will. John 5:21 My Father works hitherto, and I work. John 5:17 As the Father knows Me, even so know I the Father. John 10:15 I and My Father are One. John 10:30 And everywhere by putting the as, and the so, and the being with the Father, He declares His undeviating likeness to Him. His power in Himself He manifests by these, as well as by many other words; as when He says, Peace, be still. Mark 4:39 I will, be thou clean. Matthew 8:3 Thou dumb and deaf spirit, I charge you, come out of him. Mark 9:25 And again, You have heard that it was said by them of old time, You shall not kill; but I say unto you, That whosoever is angry with his brother without a cause, shall be in danger. Matthew 5:21-22 And all the other laws which He gave, and wonders which He worked, are sufficient to show His power, or rather, I should say, a very small part of them is enough to bring over and convince any, except the utterly insensate.

But vainglory is a powerful thing that can blind even very obvious truths to the minds of those trapped by it, and persuade them to argue against what others accept. In fact, it drives some who know and are convinced of the truth to pretend ignorance and to oppose it. This is what happened with the Jews, for they did not deny the Son of God out of ignorance, but so that they might receive honor from the crowd. They believed, the Evangelist says, but were afraid they would be put out of the synagogue. And so they gave up their salvation for the sake of others. For it is impossible that someone who is such a zealous slave to the glory of this present world can obtain the glory that comes from God. Therefore He rebuked them, saying, "How can you believe, which receive honor of men, and seek not the honor which comes from God?" This passion is like a deep intoxication and makes whoever is conquered by it hard to restore. And having detached the souls of its captives from heavenly things, it pins them to earth and does not let them look up to the true light, but persuades them always to wallow in the mud, giving them masters so powerful that they rule over them without needing to give commands. For the person who is sick with this disease does on his own, without being told, everything he thinks will please his masters. For their sake he dresses himself in expensive clothing and beautifies his face, taking these pains not for himself but for others. And he leads a train of followers through the marketplace so that others may admire him, and everything he does he performs merely out of servile flattery toward the rest of the world. Can any state of mind be more miserable than this? So that others may admire him, he is constantly rushing headlong toward ruin.

5. But vainglory is a thing powerful to blind even to very evident truths the minds of those ensnared by it, and to persuade them to dispute against what is allowed by others; nay, it instigates some who know and are persuaded of the truth to pretended ignorance and opposition. As took place in the case of the Jews, for they did not through ignorance deny the Son of God, but that they might obtain honor from the multitude; they believed, says the Evangelist, but were afraid, lest they should be put out of the synagogue. John 12:40 And so they gave up their salvation to others. For it cannot be that he who is so zealous a slave to the glory of this present world can obtain the glory which is from God. Wherefore He rebuked them, saying, How can you believe, which receive honor of men, and seek not the honor which comes from God? John 5:44 This passion is a sort of deep intoxication, and makes him who is subdued by it hard to recover. And having detached the souls of its captives from heavenly things, it nails them to earth, and lets them not look up to the true light, but persuades them ever to wallow in the mire, giving them masters so powerful, that they have the rule over them without needing to use commands. For the man who is sick of this disease, does of his own accord, and without bidding, all that he thinks will be agreeable to his masters. On their account he clothes himself in rich apparel, and beautifies his face, taking these pains not for himself but for others; and he leads about a train of followers through the market-place, that others may admire him, and all that he does he goes through, merely out of obsequiousness to the rest of the world. Can any state of mind be more wretched than this? That others may admire him, he is ever being precipitated to ruin.

Would you like to learn what a tyrannical power it exercises? Surely the words of Christ are enough to show it all. But listen to these further remarks as well. If you ask any of those men who are involved in government affairs and incur great expenses why they spend so much gold and what their vast expenditure means, you will hear from them that it is for nothing else but to please the people. If you ask again what the people may be, they will say that it is something full of confusion and turbulence, made up for the most part of foolishness, tossed blindly back and forth like the waves of the sea, and often composed of varying and opposing opinions. Must not the man who has such a master be more pitiable than anyone? And yet, strange though it is, it is not so strange that worldly men should be eager about these things. But that those who say they have withdrawn from the world should be sick with this same disease, or rather with one more serious still—this is the strangest thing of all. For with the first, the loss extends only to money, but in the last case the danger reaches the soul. For when men alter a right faith for reputation's sake and dishonor God so that they may be in high repute themselves, tell me, what excess of stupidity and madness must there not be in what they do? Other passions, even if they are very harmful, at least bring some pleasure with them, though it may be only for a time and fleeting. Those who love money, or wine, or women have, along with their harm, a pleasure, though a brief one. But those who are taken captive by this passion live a life continually embittered and stripped of enjoyment, for they do not obtain what they earnestly desire—glory, I mean, from the many. They think they enjoy it, but do not really, because the thing they aim at is not glory at all. And therefore their state of mind is not called glory, but something void of glory, vaingloriousness, as all the ancients have named it, and with good reason. For it is quite empty and contains nothing bright or glorious within it, but just as actors' masks seem to be bright and lovely but are hollow within—for which reason, though they are more beautiful than natural faces, they never draw anyone to love them—even so, or rather yet more wretchedly, has the applause of the multitude dressed up for us this passion, dangerous as an opponent and cruel as a master. Its appearance alone is bright, but within it is not like the mask's mere emptiness, but crammed with dishonor and full of savage tyranny. From where then, it may be asked, does this passion, so unreasonable and so devoid of pleasure, have its birth? From where else but from a low, mean soul? It cannot be that one who is captivated by love of applause should imagine anything great or noble readily. He must necessarily be base, mean, dishonorable, small. The one who does nothing for virtue's sake but to please men worthy of no consideration, and who always takes account of their mistaken and erring opinions—how can he be worth anything? Consider: if anyone should ask him, "What do you think of the many?" he clearly would say that they are thoughtless and not to be regarded. Then if anyone again should ask him, "Would you choose to be like them?" I do not suppose he could possibly desire to be like them. Must it not then be extremely ridiculous to seek the good opinion of those whom you would never choose to resemble?

Would you learn what a tyrannous sway it exercises? Why surely, the words of Christ are sufficient to show it all. But yet listen to these further remarks. If you will ask any of those men who mingle in state affairs and incur great expenses, why they lavish so much gold, and what their so vast expenditure means; you will hear from them, that it is for nothing else but to gratify the people. If again you ask what the people may be; they will say, that it is a thing full of confusion and turbulent, made up for the most part of folly, tossed blindly to and fro like the waves of the sea, and often composed of varying and adverse opinions. Must not the man who has such a master be more pitiable than any one? And yet strange though it be, it is not so strange that worldly men should be eager about these things; but that those who say that they have started away from the world should be sick of this same disease, or rather of one more grievous still, this is the strangest thing of all. For with the first the loss extends only to money, but in the last case the danger reaches to the soul. For when men alter a right faith for reputation's sake, and dishonor God that they may be in high repute themselves, tell me, what excess of stupidity and madness must there not be in what they do? Other passions, even if they are very hurtful, at least bring some pleasure with them, though it be but for a time and fleeting; those who love money, or wine, or women, have, with their hurt, a pleasure, though a brief one. But those who are taken captives by this passion, live a life continually embittered and stripped of enjoyment, for they do not obtain what they earnestly desire, glory, I mean, from the many. They think they enjoy it, but do not really, because the thing they aim at is not glory at all. And therefore their state of mind is not called glory, but a something void of glory, vaingloriousness, so have all the ancients named it, and with good reason; inasmuch as it is quite empty, and contains nothing bright or glorious within it, but as players' masks seem to be bright and lovely, but are hollow within, (for which cause, though they be more beautiful than natural faces, yet they never draw any to love them,) even so, or rather yet more wretchedly, has the applause of the multitude tricked out for us this passion, dangerous as an antagonist, and cruel as a master. Its countenance alone is bright, but within it is no more like the mask's mere emptiness, but crammed with dishonor, and full of savage tyranny. Whence then, it may be asked, has this passion, so unreasonable, so devoid of pleasure, its birth? Whence else but from a low, mean soul? It cannot be that one who is captivated by love of applause should imagine readily anything great or noble; he needs must be base, mean, dishonorable, little. He who does nothing for virtue's sake, but to please men worthy of no consideration, and who ever makes account of their mistaken and erring opinions, how can he be worth anything? Consider; if any one should ask him, What do you think of the many? He clearly would say, that they are thoughtless, and not to be regarded. Then if any one again should ask him, Would you choose to be like them? I do not suppose he could possibly desire to be like them. Must it not then be excessively ridiculous to seek the good opinion of those whom you never would choose to resemble?

Do you say that they are many and form a kind of collective body? This is the very reason why you should despise them most. If they are contemptible when taken individually, they will be even more so when they are many, because when they gather together, their individual foolishness is multiplied by numbers and becomes greater. So a person might possibly take one of them alone and correct him, but could not do so when they are together, because then their foolishness becomes intense, and they are led like sheep and follow one another's opinions in every direction. Tell me, will you seek to obtain this common glory? Do not, I beg and plead with you. It turns everything upside down; it is the mother of greed, of slander, of false testimony, of betrayals; it arms and enrages those who have received no injury against those who have done no wrong. The person who has fallen into this disease neither knows friendship nor remembers old companionship, and does not know how to respect anyone at all; he has cast away from his soul all goodness, and is at war with everyone, unstable, without natural affection.

6. Do you say that they are many and a sort of collective body? This is the very reason why you ought most to despise them. If when taken singly they are contemptible, still more will this be the case when they are many; for when they are assembled together, their individual folly is increased by numbers, and becomes greater. So that a man might possibly take a single one of them and set him right, but could not do so with them when together, because then their folly becomes intense, and they are led like sheep, and follow in every direction the opinions of one another. Tell me, will you seek to obtain this vulgar glory? Do not, I beg and entreat you. It turns everything upside down; it is the mother of avarice, of slander, of false witness, of treacheries; it arms and exasperates those who have received no injury against those who have inflicted none. He who has fallen into this disease neither knows friendship nor remembers old companionship, and knows not how to respect any one at all; he has cast away from his soul all goodness, and is at war with every one, unstable, without natural affection.

The passion of anger, tyrannical and difficult to bear though it is, does not constantly disturb us but only when people provoke it. But the passion of vainglory is always active, and there is virtually no time when it can stop, since reason neither prevents nor restrains it. It is always with us, not only persuading us to sin but snatching away from our hands whatever we might happen to do rightly, or sometimes preventing us from doing right at all. If Paul calls covetousness idolatry, what should we call that which is the mother, root, and source of it—I mean, vainglory? We cannot possibly find any term adequate to its wickedness. Beloved, let us now come to our senses. Let us take off this filthy garment, let us tear it off and cut it away from ourselves, let us at some point become free with true freedom, and be conscious of the nobility that has been given to us by God. Let us despise popular applause. For nothing is as ridiculous and disgraceful as this passion, nothing as full of shame and dishonor. We can see in many ways that loving honor is actually dishonor, and that true honor consists in neglecting honor, in making no account of it, but in saying and doing everything according to what seems good to God. In this way we will be able to receive a reward from Him who sees all our actions exactly, if we are content to have Him alone as our spectator. What need do we have of other eyes, when He who will give the prize is always watching our actions? Is it not strange that whatever a servant does, he should do to please his master, should seek nothing more than his master's observation, and should not want to attract the eyes of others—even if they are great men who are watching—to his conduct, but aim at one thing only, that his master observe him; while we who have such a great Lord seek other spectators who cannot profit us but rather hurt us by their observation and make all our labor vain? Not so, I beg you. Let us call Him to applaud and view our actions, from whom we will receive our rewards. Let us have nothing to do with human eyes. For if we should even desire to attain this honor, we will attain it when we seek only that which comes from God alone. For He says, "Them that honor Me, I will honor." And just as we are best supplied with riches when we despise them and seek only the wealth that comes from God ("Seek the kingdom of God, and all these things shall be added to you"), so it is in the case of honor. When the granting of either riches or honor is no longer attended with danger to us, then God gives them freely. And it is then not dangerous when they do not have rule or power over us, do not command us as slaves, but belong to us as masters and free people. The reason He wants us not to love them is so that we may not be ruled by them. And if we succeed in this, He gives them to us with great generosity. Tell me, what is brighter than Paul when he says, "We seek not honor of men, neither of you, nor yet of others"? What then is richer than him who has nothing yet possesses all things? For as I said, when we are not mastered by them, then we will master them, then we will receive them. If then we desire to obtain honor, let us shun honor, so we will be enabled, after accomplishing the laws of God, to obtain both the good things that are here and those which are promised, by the grace of Christ, with whom, to the Father and the Holy Ghost, be glory for ever and ever. Amen.

Again, the passion of anger, tyrannical though it be and hard to bear, still is not wont always to disturb, but only when it has persons that excite it; but that of vainglory is ever active, and there is no time, as one may say, when it can cease, since reason neither hinders nor restrains it, but it is always with us not only persuading us to sin, but snatching from our hands anything which we may chance to do aright, or sometimes not allowing us to do right at all. If Paul calls covetousness idolatry, what ought we to name that which is mother, and root, and source of it, I mean, vainglory? We cannot possibly find any term such as its wickedness deserves. Beloved, let us now return to our senses; let us put off this filthy garment, let us rend and cut it off from us, let us at some time or other become free with true freedom, and be sensible of the nobility which has been given to us by God; let us despise vulgar applause. For nothing is so ridiculous and disgraceful as this passion, nothing so full of shame and dishonor. One may in many ways see, that to love honor, is dishonor; and that true honor consists in neglecting honor, in making no account of it, but in saying and doing everything according to what seems good to God. In this way we shall be able to receive a reward from Him who sees exactly all our doings, if we are content to have Him only for a spectator. What need we other eyes, when He who shall confer the prize is ever beholding our actions? Is it not a strange thing that, whatever a servant does, he should do to please his master, should seek nothing more than his master's observation, desire not to attract other eyes (though they be great men who are looking on) to his conduct, but aim at one thing only, that his master may observe him; while we who have a Lord so great, seek other spectators who can nothing profit, but rather hurt us by their observation, and make all our labor vain? Not so, I beseech you. Let us call Him to applaud and view our actions from whom we shall receive our rewards. Let us have nothing to do with human eyes. For if we should even desire to attain this honor, we shall then attain to it, when we seek that which comes from God alone. For, He says, Them that honor Me, I will honor. 1 Samuel 2:30 And even as we are best supplied with riches when we despise them, and seek only the wealth which comes from God ( Seek, he says, the kingdom of God, and all these things shall be added to you Matthew 6:33); so it is in the case of honor. When the granting either of riches or honor is no longer attended with danger to us, then God gives them freely; and it is then unattended with danger, when they have not the rule or power over us, do not command us as slaves, but belong to us as masters and free men. For the reason that He wishes us not to love them is, that we may not be ruled by them; and if we succeed in this respect, He gives us them with great liberality. Tell me, what is brighter than Paul, when he says, We seek not honor of men, neither of you, nor yet of others. 1 Thessalonians 2:6 What then is richer than him who has nothing, and yet possesses all things? For as I said, when we are not mastered by them, then we shall master them, then we shall receive them. If then we desire to obtain honor, let us shun honor, so shall we be enabled after accomplishing the laws of God to obtain both the good things which are here, and those which are promised, by the grace of Christ, with whom, to the Father and the Holy Ghost, be glory for ever and ever. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 2 — John 1:1

Homily 2 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240102.htm>.

John 1:1

If John were going to speak with us using his own words, we would need to describe his family, his country, and his education. But since it is not he himself, but God speaking through him to mankind, it seems to me unnecessary and distracting to investigate these things. Yet even so, it is not unnecessary, but actually very necessary. For when you learn who he was, where he came from, who his parents were, and what his character was like, and then you hear his voice and all his heavenly wisdom, you will know clearly that these doctrines do not belong to him, but to the Divine power moving his soul.

Were John about to converse with us, and to say to us words of his own, we needs must describe his family, his country, and his education. But since it is not he, but God by him, that speaks to mankind, it seems to me superfluous and distracting to enquire into these matters. And yet even thus it is not superfluous, but even very necessary. For when you have learned who he was, and from whence, who his parents, and what his character, and then hear his voice and all his heavenly wisdom, then you shall know right well that these (doctrines) belong not to him, but to the Divine power stirring his soul.

What country was he from, then? He was from no country, but from a poor village in a land that was little respected and produced nothing good. The scribes spoke badly of Galilee, saying, "Search and look, for out of Galilee arises no prophet." And the Israelite spoke ill of it too, saying, "Can any good thing come out of Nazareth?" And being from this land, he was not even from any notable place in it, but from one not even distinguished by name. This was where he came from, and his father was a poor fisherman, so poor that he brought his sons into the same work. Now you all know that no workman will choose to raise his son to follow him in his trade unless poverty presses him very hard, especially when the trade is a lowly one. But nothing can be poorer, more humble, or more ignorant than fishermen. Yet even among them there are some greater and some lesser, and even there our apostle occupied the lower rank, for he did not take his catch from the sea but spent his time on a small lake. And as he was working there with his father and his brother James, mending their broken nets—something that by itself showed extreme poverty—Christ called him.

From what country then was he? From no country; but from a poor village, and from a land little esteemed, and producing no good thing. For the Scribes speak evil of Galilee, saying, Search and look, for out of Galilee arises no prophet. John 7:52 And the Israelite indeed speaks ill of it, saying, Can any good thing come out of Nazareth? And being of this land, he was not even of any remarkable place in it, but of one not even distinguished by name. Of this he was, and his father a poor fisherman, so poor that he took his sons to the same employment. Now you all know that no workman will choose to bring up his son to succeed him in his trade, unless poverty press him very hard, especially where the trade is a mean one. But nothing can be poorer, meaner, no, nor more ignorant, than fishermen. Yet even among them there are some greater, some less; and even there our Apostle occupied the lower rank, for he did not take his prey from the sea, but passed his time on a certain little lake. And as he was engaged by it with his father and his brother James, and they mending their broken nets, a thing which of itself marked extreme poverty, so Christ called him.

As for worldly education, we can learn from these facts that he had absolutely none of it. Besides, Luke testifies to this when he writes not only that he was ignorant, but that he was completely unlettered. This was to be expected. For someone who was so poor, never attending public gatherings, never encountering people of high status, but practically tied to his fishing trade, or even if he did meet anyone, only talking with fish sellers and cooks—how could he possibly be in a condition better than that of irrational animals? How could he avoid imitating the very silence of his fish?

As for worldly instruction, we may learn from these facts that he had none at all of it. Besides, Luke testifies this when he writes not only that he was ignorant, but that he was absolutely unlettered. Acts 4:13 As was likely. For one who was so poor, never coming into the public assemblies, nor falling in with men of respectability, but as it were nailed to his fishing, or even if he ever did meet any one, conversing with fishmongers and cooks, how, I say, was he likely to be in a state better than that of the irrational animals? How could he help imitating the very dumbness of his fishes?

This fisherman then, whose work involved lakes, nets, and fish; this native of Bethsaida in Galilee; this son of a poor fisherman, poor in the extreme; this ignorant man, ignorant in the extreme, who never learned to read or write either before or after he followed Christ—let us see what he says and what subjects he discusses with us. Does he speak about things in the field? About things in rivers? About the fish trade? Perhaps one would expect to hear these things from a fisherman. But don't worry; we will hear nothing of these things. Instead, we will hear about things in heaven, and what no one ever learned before this man. For, as we might expect from someone who speaks from the very treasures of the Spirit, he has come bringing us sublime doctrines and the best way of life and wisdom, as though he just arrived from heaven itself—or rather, such things as not even everyone there would be likely to know, as I said before. Do these things belong to a fisherman? Tell me. Do they belong to a rhetorician at all? To a sophist or philosopher? To anyone trained in the wisdom of the Gentiles? Not at all. The human soul is simply unable to philosophize in this way about that pure and blessed nature; about the powers that come next to it; about immortality and endless life; about the nature of mortal bodies that will later be immortal; about punishment and the coming judgment; about the examination that will concern deeds and words, thoughts and imaginations. It cannot tell what man is, what the world is; what man truly is, and what he who seems to be man but is not; what the nature of virtue is, what the nature of vice is.

2. This fisherman then, whose business was about lakes, and nets, and fish; this native of Bethsaida of Galilee; this son of a poor fisherman, yes, and poor to the last degree; this man ignorant, and to the last degree of ignorance too, who never learned letters either before or after he accompanied Christ; let us see what he utters, and on what matters he converses with us. Is it of things in the field? Is it of things in rivers? On the trade in fish? For these things, perhaps, one expects to hear from a fisherman. But fear not; we shall hear nought of these; but we shall hear of things in heaven, and what no one ever learned before this man. For, as might be expected of one who speaks from the very treasures of the Spirit, he has come bringing to us sublime doctrines, and the best way of life and wisdom, [as though just arrived from the very heavens; yea, rather such as it was not likely that all even there should know, as I said before.] Do these things belong to a fisherman? Tell me. Do they belong to a rhetorician at all? To a sophist or philosopher? To every one trained in the wisdom of the Gentiles? By no means. The human soul is simply unable thus to philosophize on that pure and blessed nature; on the powers that come next to it; on immortality and endless life; on the nature of mortal bodies which shall hereafter be immortal; on punishment and the judgment to come; on the enquiries that shall be as to deeds and words, as to thoughts and imaginations. It cannot tell what is man, what the world; what is man indeed, and what he who seems to be man, but is not; what is the nature of virtue, what of vice.

Some of these things were indeed explored by the disciples of Plato and Pythagoras. We need not mention the other philosophers at all; they have all been extremely ridiculous on this point. Even those who have been held in greater esteem among them and who have been considered the leading figures in this field are more ridiculous than the rest. They have composed and written something on the subject of government and doctrines, and in all of this have been more shamefully ridiculous than children. For they have spent their whole lives advocating that women should be common to all, overthrowing the very order of life, doing away with the honor of marriage, and making other such ridiculous laws. As for doctrines concerning the soul, there is nothing excessively shameful that they have left unsaid. They assert that the souls of men become flies, gnats, and bushes, and that God Himself is a soul, along with other such indecencies.

3. Some of these things indeed the disciples of Plato and Pythagoras enquired into. Of the other philosophers we need make no mention at all; they have all on this point been so excessively ridiculous; and those who have been among them in greater esteem than the rest, and who have been considered the leading men in this science, are so more than the others; and they have composed and written somewhat on the subject of polity and doctrines, and in all have been more shamefully ridiculous than children. For they have spent their whole life in making women common to all, in overthrowing the very order of life, in doing away the honor of marriage, and in making other the like ridiculous laws. As for doctrines on the soul, there is nothing excessively shameful that they have left unsaid; asserting that the souls of men become flies, and gnats, and bushes, and that God Himself is a soul; with some other the like indecencies.

And this is not the only thing in them worthy of blame, but also their constantly shifting flow of words. Since they base everything on uncertain and deceptive arguments, they are like men carried back and forth in the Euripus, and they never remain in the same place.

And not this alone in them is worthy of blame, but so is also their ever-shifting current of words; for since they assert everything on uncertain and fallacious arguments, they are like men carried here and there in Euripus, and never remain in the same place.

Not so this fisherman; for everything he says is infallible, and standing as if upon a rock, he never shifts his ground. Since he has been deemed worthy to be in the most secret places, and has the Lord of all speaking within him, he is subject to nothing that is human. But they, like people who are not considered worthy even in a dream to set foot in the king's palace, but who spend their time in the forum with other men, guessing from their own imagination at what they cannot see, have fallen into great error. Like blind or drunken men in their wandering, they have collided with each other, and not only with each other, but with themselves, by continually changing their opinion, and always on the same matters.

Not so this fisherman; for all he says is infallible; and standing as it were upon a rock, he never shifts his ground. For since he has been thought worthy to be in the most secret places, and has the Lord of all speaking within him, he is subject to nothing that is human. But they, like persons who are not held worthy even in a dream to set foot in the king's palace, but who pass their time in the forum with other men, guessing from their own imagination at what they cannot see, have erred a great error, and, like blind or drunken men in their wandering, have dashed against each other; and not only against each other, but against themselves, by continually changing their opinion, and that ever on the same matters.

But this uneducated man, the ignorant one, the native of Bethsaida, the son of Zebedee (though the Greeks may mock ten thousand times at the roughness of these names, I will speak them with even greater boldness). For the more barbarous his nation seems to them, and the more he seems removed from Greek education, the brighter what we possess appears. For when a barbarian and an untaught person speaks things that no one on earth ever knew, and does not merely speak them (though if this were the only thing it would be a great marvel), but beyond this, provides another and stronger proof that what he says is divinely inspired—namely, convincing all his hearers throughout all time—who will not marvel at the power dwelling in him? Since this is, as I said, the strongest proof that he lays down no laws of his own. This barbarian, then, through his writing of the Gospel, has occupied all the inhabited world. With his body he has taken possession of the center of Asia, where formerly all those of the Greek party practiced philosophy, shining forth in the midst of his enemies, dispersing their darkness, and breaking down the stronghold of demons. But in soul he has withdrawn to that place which is fitting for one who has done such things.

4. But this unlettered man, the ignorant, the native of Bethsaida, the son of Zebedee, (though the Greeks mock ten thousand times at the rusticity of the names, I shall not the less speak them with the greater boldness.) For the more barbarous his nation seems to them, and the more he seems removed from Grecian discipline, so much the brighter does what we have with us appear. For when a barbarian and an untaught person utters things which no man on earth ever knew, and does not only utter, (though if this were the only thing it were a great marvel,) but besides this, affords another and a stronger proof that what he says is divinely inspired, namely, the convincing all his hearers through all time; who will not wonder at the power that dwells in him? Since this is, as I said, the strongest proof that he lays down no laws of his own. This barbarian then, with his writing of the Gospel, has occupied all the habitable world. With his body he has taken possession of the center of Asia, where of old philosophized all of the Grecian party, shining forth in the midst of his foes, dispersing their darkness, and breaking down the stronghold of devils: but in soul he has retired to that place which is fit for one who has done such things.

And as for the writings of the Greeks, they are all extinguished and vanished, but this man's writings shine brighter day by day. For from the time that he and the other fishermen appeared, the doctrines of Pythagoras and of Plato, which seemed before to prevail, have ceased to be spoken of, and most people do not even know them by name. Yet Plato was, they say, the invited companion of kings, had many friends, and sailed to Sicily. And Pythagoras occupied Magna Graecia and practiced there ten thousand kinds of sorcery. For to converse with oxen, which they say he did, was nothing else but a piece of sorcery. This is most clear from the following: He who supposedly conversed with animals did not in any way benefit the human race, but even did them the greatest wrong. Yet surely, human nature was better suited for philosophical reasoning; still he did, as they say, converse with eagles and oxen, using sorceries. For he did not make their irrational nature rational—this was impossible for man—but by his magic tricks he deceived the foolish. And neglecting to teach men anything useful, he taught that they might as well eat the heads of those who begot them as beans. And he persuaded those who associated with him that the soul of their teacher had actually been at one time a bush, at another a girl, at another a fish.

5. And as for the writings of the Greeks, they are all put out and vanished, but this man's shine brighter day by day. For from the time that he (was) and the other fishermen, since then the (doctrines) of Pythagoras and of Plato, which seemed before to prevail, have ceased to be spoken of, and most men do not know them even by name. Yet Plato was, they say, the invited companion of kings, had many friends, and sailed to Sicily. And Pythagoras occupied Magna Græcia, and practiced there ten thousand kinds of sorcery. For to converse with oxen, (which they say he did,) was nothing else but a piece of sorcery. As is most clear from this. He that so conversed with brutes did not in anything benefit the race of men, but even did them the greatest wrong. Yet surely, the nature of men was better adapted for the reasoning of philosophy; still he did, as they say, converse with eagles and oxen, using sorceries. For he did not make their irrational nature rational, (this was impossible to man,) but by his magic tricks he deceived the foolish. And neglecting to teach men anything useful, he taught that they might as well eat the heads of those who begot them, as beans. And he persuaded those who associated with him, that the soul of their teacher had actually been at one time a bush, at another a girl, at another a fish.

These things have rightly become extinct and completely vanished—and with good reason. But the words of this ignorant and unlettered man have not suffered the same fate. Syrians, Egyptians, Indians, Persians, Ethiopians, and countless other nations, though they are barbarians, have translated the doctrines he introduced into their own languages and have learned to philosophize. I did not say without reason, then, that all the world has become his theater. For he did not abandon his own kind to waste his effort on irrational creatures—an act of excessive vainglory and extreme folly. Rather, being free from this passion as well as others, he was intent on one thing only: that all the world might learn something of the things that would benefit it, and be able to transfer itself from earth to heaven.

Are not these things with good cause extinct, and vanished utterly? With good cause, and reasonably. But not so the words of him who was ignorant and unlettered; for Syrians, and Egyptians, and Indians, and Persians, and Ethiopians, and ten thousand other nations, translating into their own tongues the doctrines introduced by him, barbarians though they be, have learned to philosophize. I did not therefore idly say that all the world has become his theater. For he did not leave those of his own kind, and waste his labor on the irrational creatures, (an act of excessive vainglory and extreme folly,) but being clear of this as well as of other passions, he was earnest on one point only, that all the world might learn somewhat of the things which might profit it, and be able to translate it from earth to heaven.

For this reason too, he did not hide his teaching in fog and darkness, as those did who threw obscurity of speech, like a kind of veil, around the harmful things stored up within. But this man's teachings are clearer than the sun's rays, which is why they have been spread to all people throughout the world. For he did not teach as Pythagoras did, commanding those who came to him to be silent for five years, or to sit like senseless stones. Nor did he invent fables claiming the universe consists of numbers. Instead, casting away all this devilish rubbish and harm, he spread such simplicity through his words that everything he said was plain, not only to wise men, but also to women and young people. For he was convinced that the words were true and profitable to all who would listen to them. And all time after him is his witness, since he has drawn the whole world to himself and has freed our life, when we have listened to these words, from all monstrous display of wisdom. For this reason, we who hear them would rather give up our lives than the teachings he delivered to us.

For this reason too, he did not hide his teaching in mist and darkness, as they did who threw obscurity of speech, like a kind of veil, around the mischiefs laid up within. But this man's doctrines are clearer than the sunbeams, wherefore they have been unfolded to all men throughout the world. For he did not teach as Pythagoras did, commanding those who came to him to be silent for five years, or to sit like senseless stones; neither did he invent fables defining the universe to consist of numbers; but casting away all this devilish trash and mischief, he diffused such simplicity through his words, that all he said was plain, not only to wise men, but also to women and youths. For he was persuaded that the words were true and profitable to all that should hearken to them. And all time after him is his witness; since he has drawn to him all the world, and has freed our life when we have listened to these words from all monstrous display of wisdom; wherefore we who hear them would prefer rather to give up our lives, than the doctrines by him delivered to us.

From all this and from every other circumstance, it is clear that nothing about this man is human, but the teachings that come to us through this divine soul are divine and heavenly. For we will observe not high-sounding sentences, nor impressive language, nor excessive and pointless arrangement and organization of words and sentences (these things are far removed from all true wisdom), but invincible and divine strength, irresistible force of right doctrines, and a rich supply of countless good things. For their excessive concern about expression was so extreme, so typical of mere sophists, or rather not even of sophists but of foolish young men, that even their own chief philosopher presents his own teacher as greatly ashamed of this art, and as saying to the judges that what they hear from him will be spoken plainly and without preparation, not adorned rhetorically nor decorated with fine sentences and words; since, he says, it cannot surely be fitting, O men, that one at my age should come before you like a young man crafting speeches. And notice the extreme absurdity of the thing: what he has described his teacher avoiding as disgraceful, unworthy of philosophy and the work of young men, this above all he himself has practiced. So completely were they devoted to mere love of recognition.

6. From this then, and from every other circumstance, it is plain, that nothing of this man's is human, but divine and heavenly are the lessons which come to us by this divine soul. For we shall observe not sounding sentences, nor magnificent diction, nor excessive and useless order and arrangement of words and sentences, (these things are far from all true wisdom,) but strength invincible and divine, and irresistible force of right doctrines, and a rich supply of unnumbered good things. For their over-care about expression was so excessive, so worthy of mere sophists, or rather not even of sophists, but of silly striplings, that even their own chief philosopher introduces his own master as greatly ashamed of this art, and as saying to the judges, that what they hear from him shall be spoken plainly and without premeditation, not tricked out rhetorically nor ornamented with (fine) sentences and words; since, says he, it cannot surely be becoming, O men, that one at my age should come before you like a lad inventing speeches. And observe the extreme absurdity of the thing; what he has described his master avoiding as disgraceful, unworthy of philosophy and work for lads, this above all he himself has cultivated. So entirely were they given up to mere love of distinction.

Just as whitewashed tombs, when uncovered, are found full of corruption, stench, and decayed bones, so too the teachings of the philosopher, if you strip away their flowery language, will be seen as full of much abomination—especially when he philosophizes about the soul, which he both honors and dishonors without measure. This is the devil's snare: never to maintain proper balance, but through excess on either side to lead those caught by it into error. At one time he says the soul is of the ousia of God; at another, after exalting it so immoderately and impiously, he goes to excess again in the opposite direction and treats it with contempt, making it pass into swine and donkeys and other animals even less honorable than these.

And as, if you uncover those sepulchers which are whitened without you will find them full of corruption, and stench, and rotten bones; so too the doctrines of the philosopher, if you strip them of their flowery diction, you will see to be full of much abomination, especially when he philosophizes on the soul, which he both honors and speaks ill of without measure. And this is the snare of the devil, never to keep due proportion, but by excess on either hand to lead aside those who are entangled by it into evil speaking. At one time he says, that the soul is of the substance of God; at another, after having exalted it thus immoderately and impiously, he exceeds again in a different way, and treats it with insult, making it pass into swine and asses, and other animals of yet less esteem than these.

But enough of this—or rather, this is already too much. For if it were possible to learn anything useful from these things, we should have spent more time on them. But if the point is only to observe their indecency and absurdity, we have already said more than enough. We will therefore leave their myths behind and turn to our own teachings, which have been brought down to us from above by the words of this fisherman, and which contain nothing merely human in them.

But enough of this; or rather even this is out of measure. For if it were possible to learn anything profitable from these things, we must have been longer occupied with them; but if it be only to observe their indecency and absurdity, more than requisite has been said by us already. We will therefore leave their fables, and attach ourselves to our own doctrines, which have been brought to us from above by the tongue of this fisherman, and which have nothing human in them.

Let us now bring forward these words, but I remind you again, just as I urged you at the beginning, to pay close attention to what is being said. So what does this Evangelist say right at the start?

7. Let us then bring forward the words, having reminded you now, as I exhorted you at the first, earnestly to attend to what is said. What then does this Evangelist say immediately on his outset?

In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God. John 1:1 Do you see the great boldness and power of these words, how he speaks without doubting or guessing, but declaring everything plainly? For this is the teacher's role: not to waver in anything he says, because if someone who is supposed to guide others needs another person to establish him with certainty, he would rightly be ranked not among teachers, but among disciples.

In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God. John 1:1 Do you see the great boldness and power of the words, how he speaks nothing doubting nor conjecturing, but declaring all things plainly? For this is the teacher's part, not to waver in anything he says, since if he who is to be a guide to the rest require another person who shall be able to establish him with certainty, he would be rightly ranked not among teachers, but among disciples.

But if anyone asks why the evangelist has passed over the first cause and spoken to us immediately about the second, we will refuse to speak of first and second, for the Divinity is above number and the succession of times. Therefore we reject these expressions. But we confess that the Father is from none, and that the Son is begotten of the Father. Yes, someone may say, but why then does he leave the Father aside and speak concerning the Son? Why? Because the former was manifest to all—if not as Father, at least as God—but the Only-Begotten was not known. Therefore he reasonably hastened from the very beginning to plant knowledge of Him in those who did not know Him.

But if any one say, What can be the reason that he has neglected the first cause, and spoken to us at once concerning the second? we shall decline to speak of first and second, for the Divinity is above number, and the succession of times. Wherefore we decline these expressions; but we confess that the Father is from none, and that the Son is begotten of the Father. Yes, it may be said, but why then does he leave the Father, and speak concerning the Son? Why? Because the former was manifest to all, if not as Father, at least as God; but the Only-Begotten was not known; and therefore with reason did he immediately from the very beginning hasten to implant the knowledge of Him in those who knew Him not.

Besides, he has not been silent about the Father in his writings on these points. And observe, I ask you, his spiritual wisdom. He knows that people most honor the eldest of beings which existed before all things, and consider this to be God. Therefore he begins from this point first, and as he proceeds, declares that God is, and does not like Plato assert sometimes that He is intellect, sometimes that He is soul. For these things are far removed from that divine and unmixed Nature which has nothing in common with us, but is separated from any fellowship with created things—I mean as to ousia, though not as to relation.

Besides, he has not been silent as to the Father in his writings on these points. And observe, I beg of you, his spiritual wisdom. He knows that men most honor the eldest of beings which was before all, and account this to be God. Wherefore from this point first he makes his beginning, and as he advances, declares that God is, and does not like Plato assert, sometimes that He is intellect, sometimes that He is soul; for these things are far removed from that divine and unmixed Nature which has nothing common with us, but is separated from any fellowship with created things, I mean as to substance, though not as to relation.

And for this reason he calls Him The Word. Since he is about to teach that this Word is the only-begotten Son of God, he gives Him the title of The Word so that no one might think His generation involves passibility. By using this title, he addresses and removes in advance the wrong suspicion, showing that the Son is from the Father without the Father suffering any change.

And for this reason he calls Him The Word. For since he is about to teach that this Word is the only-begotten Son of God, in order that no one may imagine that His generation is passible, by giving Him the appellation of The Word, he anticipates and removes beforehand the evil suspicion, showing that the Son is from the Father, and that without His suffering (change).

Do you see, then, that as I said, he has not been silent about the Father when speaking about the Son? And if these examples are not sufficient to fully explain the entire matter, do not be surprised, for our subject is God, whom it is impossible to describe or worthily conceive. For this reason, this man nowhere assigns the name of His ousia (for it is not possible to say what God is, as to ousia), but everywhere he declares Him to us by His workings. For this Word one may see shortly after called Light, and the Light in turn named Life.

8. Do you see then that as I said, he has not been silent as to the Father in his words concerning the Son? And if these instances are not sufficient fully to explain the whole matter, marvel not, for our argument is God, whom it is impossible to describe, or to imagine worthily; hence this man nowhere assigns the name of His essence, (for it is not possible to say what God is, as to essence,) but everywhere he declares Him to us by His workings. For this Word one may see shortly after called Light, and the Light in turn named Life.

Although this was not the only reason he named Him this way—it was the first reason—the second was because He was going to reveal to us the things of the Father. For "all things that I have heard from my Father, I have made known unto you" (John 15:15). He calls Him both Light and Life, because He has freely given to us the light that comes from knowledge and the life that follows it. In short, one name is not sufficient, nor two, nor three, nor many more, to teach us what belongs to God. But we must be content to be able, even by means of many names, to understand His attributes, though only dimly.

Although not for this reason only did he so name Him; this was the first reason, and the second was because He was about to declare to us the things of the Father. For all things, He says, that I have heard from my Father, I have made known unto you. John 15:15 He calls Him both Light and Life, for He has freely given to us the light which proceeds from knowledge, and the life which follows it. In short, one name is not sufficient, nor two, nor three, nor more, to teach us what belongs to God. But we must be content to be able even by means of many to apprehend, though but obscurely, His attributes.

And he has not called Him simply Word, but with the addition of the article, distinguishing Him from the rest in this way also. Do you see then that I did not say without reason that this Evangelist speaks to us from heaven? Just see from the very beginning where he has lifted up the soul, giving it wings, and has carried up the minds of his hearers with him. For having placed it higher than all sensible things, than earth, than sea, than heaven, he leads it by the hand above the very angels, above cherubim and seraphim, above thrones and principalities and powers; in short, he persuades it to journey beyond all created things.

And he has not called Him simply Word, but with the addition of the article, distinguishing Him from the rest in this way also. Do you see then that I said not without cause that this Evangelist speaks to us from heaven? Only see from the very beginning whither he has drawn up the soul, having given it wings, and has carried up with him the mind of his hearers. For having set it higher than all the things of sense, than earth, than sea, than heaven, he leads it by the hand above the very angels, above cherubim and seraphim, above thrones and principalities and powers; in a word, persuades it to journey beyond all created things.

What then? When he has brought us to such a great height as this, is he truly able to stop us there? Not at all; but just as someone who transports a person standing on the beach—looking at cities, beaches, and harbors—into the middle of the sea removes him from those former sights yet does not fix his gaze anywhere but brings him to a view without boundary; so this Evangelist, having brought us above all creation and escorted us toward the eternal ages that lie beyond it, leaves our sight suspended, not allowing it to reach any upper limit, since indeed there is none.

9. What then? When he has brought us to such a height as this, is he in truth able to stop us there? By no means; but just as one by transporting into the midst of the sea a person who was standing on the beach, and looking on cities, and beaches, and havens, removes him indeed from the former objects, yet does not stay his sight anywhere, but brings him to a view without bound; so this Evangelist, having brought us above all creation, and escorted us towards the eternal periods which lie beyond it, leaves the sight suspended, not allowing it to arrive at any limit upwards, as indeed there is none.

For the intellect, having risen to "the beginning," asks what kind of beginning this is. Then, finding that "was" always surpasses its imagination, it has no point at which to fix its thought. Looking intently forward and being unable to stop at any point, it becomes exhausted and turns back to lower things. For "was in the beginning" means nothing other than eternal existence and infinite being.

For the intellect, having ascended to the beginning, enquires what beginning; and then finding the was always outstripping its imagination, has no point at which to stay its thought; but looking intently onwards, and being unable to cease at any point, it becomes wearied out, and turns back to things below. For this was in the beginning, is nothing else than expressive of ever being and being infinitely.

Do you see true philosophy and divine teaching? This is not like that of the Greeks, who assign times and say that some of the gods are younger and others older. Nothing like this exists among us. For if God exists, as He certainly does, then nothing existed before Him. If He is Creator of all things, He must be first. If He is Master and Lord of all, then everything—both creatures and ages—comes after Him.

Do you see true philosophy and divine doctrines? Not like those of the Greeks, who assign times, and say that some indeed of the gods are younger, some elder. There is nothing of this with us. For if God Is, as certainly He Is, then nothing was before Him. If He is Creator of all things, He must be first; if Master and Lord of all, then all, both creatures and ages, are after Him.

I had wanted to tackle other difficulties as well, but our minds are probably worn out. So after I've given you some advice about things that will help us understand both what has already been said and what is still to come, I'll stop again. What are these points? I know that many people have become confused because of how long this discussion has been. This happens when the soul is weighed down with many burdens from this life. Just as the eye, when it is clear and transparent, sees sharply and won't easily get tired even when making out the tiniest objects, but when some bad fluid from the head pours into it, or some smoky vapors rise up to it from below, a kind of thick cloud forms over the eyeball that prevents it from clearly perceiving even larger objects—the same thing naturally happens with the soul. When it is purified and has no passion disturbing it, it looks intently at the proper objects of its attention. But when it is darkened by many passions, it loses its natural excellence. Then it isn't easily able to handle anything lofty, but quickly grows tired and falls back. Turning instead to sleep and laziness, it lets pass by the things that concern its excellence and the life that comes from it, instead of receiving them with great eagerness.

10. I had desired to enter the lists yet on other difficulties, but perhaps our minds are wearied out; when therefore I have advised you on those points which are useful to us for the hearing, both of what has been said, and of what is yet to be said, I again will hold my peace. What then are these points? I know that many have become confused by reason of the length of what has been spoken. Now this takes place when the soul is heavy laden with many burdens of this life. For as the eye when it is clear and transparent is keen-sighted also, and will not easily be tired in making out even the minutest bodies; but when from some bad humor from the head having poured into it, or some smoke-like fumes having ascended to it from beneath, a kind of thick cloud is formed before the ball, this does not allow it clearly to perceive even any larger object; so is naturally the case with the soul. For when it is purified, and has no passion to disturb it, it looks steadfastly to the fit objects of its regard; but when, darkened by many passions, it loses its proper excellence, then it is not easily able to be sufficient for any high thing, but soon is wearied, and falls back; and turning aside to sleep and sloth, lets pass things that concern it with a view to excellence and the life thence arising, instead of receiving them with much readiness.

And to prevent this from happening to you—I will keep warning you about this continually—strengthen your minds so that you won't hear what the faithful among the Hebrews heard from Paul. He told them he had many things to say that were hard to explain (see Hebrews 5:11), not because these things were inherently difficult, but because, as he says, "you are dull of hearing." It is characteristic of the weak and feeble person to be confused even by a few words as much as by many, and to think that what is clear and easy is hard to understand. Don't let anyone here be like that. Instead, drive away all worldly concerns and listen to these teachings with a clear mind.

And that you may not suffer this, (I shall not cease continually thus to warn you,) strengthen your minds, that you may not hear what the faithful among the Hebrews heard from Paul. For to them he said that he had many things to say, and hard to be uttered Hebrews 5:11; not as though they were by nature such, but because, says he, you are dull of hearing. For it is the nature of the weak and infirm man to be confused even by few words as by many, and what is clear and easy he thinks hard to be comprehended. Let not any here be such an one, but having chased from him all worldly care, so let him hear these doctrines.

When the desire for money takes hold of the hearer, the desire for hearing cannot take hold of him as well, since the soul, being one, cannot accommodate many desires. One of the two is damaged by the other, and through this division becomes weaker as its rival grows stronger and consumes everything for itself.

For when the desire of money possesses the hearer, the desire of hearing cannot possess him as well; since the soul, being one, cannot suffice for many desires; but one of the two is injured by the other, and, from division, becomes weaker as its rival prevails, and expends all upon itself.

This tends to happen with children. When a man has only one child, he loves that child intensely. But when he becomes the father of many children, his affections are divided and therefore become weaker.

And this is wont to happen in the case of children. When a man has only one, he loves that one exceedingly. But when he has become father of many, then also his dispositions of affection being divided become weaker.

If this happens where nature has absolute rule and power, and the objects of love are related to one another, what can we say about desire and disposition that come from deliberate choice—especially where these desires directly oppose each other? For the love of wealth opposes this kind of love for hearing. We enter heaven when we enter here, not in place but in disposition, for it is possible for someone on earth to stand in heaven, to see the things that are there, and to hear the words from there.

If this happens where there is the absolute rule and power of nature, and the objects beloved are akin one with another, what can we say as to that desire and disposition which is according to deliberate choice; especially where these desires lie directly opposed to each other; for the love of wealth is a thing opposed to the love of this kind of hearing. We enter heaven when we enter here; not in place, I mean, but in disposition; for it is possible for one who is on earth to stand in heaven, and to have vision of the things that are there, and to hear the words from thence.

Let no one bring earthly concerns into heaven. Let no one standing here worry about what is happening at his house. For he ought to carry with him and preserve both at home and in his work what he gains from this place, not allowing it to be weighed down with the burdens of household and marketplace. Our reason for coming into the teaching chair is to cleanse ourselves from the filth of the outside world. But if we are likely even in this small space to be harmed by things said or done outside, it would be better for us not to enter at all. Let no one in the assembly be thinking about household matters, but let him at home be stirring up what he heard in the assembly. Let these things be more precious to us than anything else. These concern the soul, but those concern the body—or rather, what is said here concerns both body and soul. Therefore let these things be our main business, and all other things merely occasional tasks. For these belong both to the future life and the present life, but the rest belong to neither one nor the other, unless they are managed according to the law laid down for these. Since from these it is possible to learn not only what we shall be hereafter and how we shall then live, but also how we shall rightly direct this present life.

11. Let none then introduce the things of earth into heaven; let no one standing here be careful about what is at his house. For he ought to bear with him, and to preserve both at home and in his business, what he gains from this place, not to allow it to be loaded with the burdens of house and market. Our reason for entering in to the chair of instruction is, that thence we may cleanse ourselves from the filth of the outer world; but if we are likely even in this little space to be injured by things said or done without, it is better for us not to enter at all. Let no one then in the assembly be thinking about domestic matters, but let him at home be stirring with what he heard in the assembly. Let these things be more precious to us than any. These concern the soul, but those the body; or rather what is said here concerns both body and soul. Wherefore let these things be our leading business, and all others but occasional employments; for these belong both to the future and the present life, but the rest neither to the one nor the other, unless they be managed according to the law laid down for these. Since from these it is impossible to learn not only what we shall hereafter be, and how we shall then live, but how we shall rightly direct this present life also.

This house is a spiritual hospital, so that whatever wounds we have received outside, we may heal them here, not so that we may gather fresh ones to take away with us. Yet if we do not pay attention to the Spirit speaking to us, we will not only fail to clear ourselves of our former hurts, but we will get others in addition.

For this house is a spiritual surgery, that whatever wounds we may have received without, here we may heal, not that we may gather fresh ones to take with us hence. Yet if we do not give heed to the Spirit speaking to us, we shall not only fail to clear ourselves of our former hurts, but shall get others in addition.

Let us then pay close attention with great earnestness to the book as it is being explained to us. If we learn its first principles and fundamental doctrines precisely, we will not need much detailed study afterward. Instead, after working hard at the beginning, we will be able, as Paul says, to instruct others as well. For this Apostle is very profound, rich in many doctrines, and he focuses on these more than on other matters.

Let us then with much earnestness attend to the book as it is being unfolded to us; since if we learn exactly its first principles and fundamental doctrines, we shall not afterwards require much close study, but after laboring a little at the beginning, shall be able, as Paul says, to instruct others also. Romans 15:14 For this Apostle is very sublime, abounding in many doctrines, and on these he dwells more than on other matters.

Let us not be careless listeners, then. This is why we present these things to you bit by bit, so that everything may be easily understood and will not slip from your memory. Let us fear, then, that we might fall under the condemnation of that saying which says, "If I had not come and spoken to them, they would not have had sin." For what benefit will we have over those who have not heard, if even after hearing we go home carrying nothing away with us, but only marveling at what was said?

Let us not then be careless hearers. And this is the reason why we set them forth to you little by little, so that all may be easily intelligible to you, and may not escape your memory. Let us fear then lest we come under the condemnation of that word which says, If I had not come and spoken unto them, they had not had sin. John 15:22 For what shall we be profited more than those who have not heard, if even after hearing we go our way home bearing nothing with us, but only wondering at what has been said.

Allow us then to sow in good ground; allow us, so that you may draw us the more to you. If anyone has thorns, let him cast the fire of the Spirit among them. If anyone has a hard and stubborn heart, let him use the same fire to make it soft and yielding. If anyone lies by the wayside, trodden down by all kinds of thoughts, let him enter into more sheltered places and not lie exposed for those who wish to invade and plunder, so that we may see your cornfields waving with grain. Moreover, if we exercise this kind of care over ourselves and apply ourselves diligently to this spiritual hearing, if not at once then gradually, we shall surely be freed from all the cares of life.

Allow us then to sow in good ground; allow us, that you may draw us the more to you. If any man has thorns, let him cast the fire of the Spirit among them. If any has a hard and stubborn heart, let him by employing the same fire make it soft and yielding. If any by the wayside is trodden down by all kind of thoughts, let him enter into more sheltered places, and not lie exposed for those that will to invade for plunder: that so we may see your cornfields waving with grain. Besides, if we exercise such care as this over ourselves, and apply ourselves industriously to this spiritual hearing, if not at once yet by degrees, we shall surely be freed from all the cares of life.

Let us therefore take care that it is not said of us that our ears are those of a deaf adder. For tell me, how does this kind of hearer differ from a beast? And how could he be anything other than more irrational than any irrational animal, when he does not pay attention while God is speaking? And if being pleasing to God is truly what it means to be human, what else but a beast can he be who will not even listen to how he might succeed in this? Consider then what a misfortune it would be for us to fall down by our own choice from the nature of humanity to that of beasts, when Christ is willing to make us equal to angels instead of merely human. For serving the belly, being controlled by the desire for riches, being given to anger, biting, kicking—these things are fitting not for humans but for beasts. In fact, even the beasts each have, one might say, a single passion, and that by nature. But when a human being casts away the rule of reason and tears himself away from the divinely ordered community, he gives himself over to all the passions and is no longer merely a beast, but a kind of many-formed, motley monster. Nor does he even have the excuse of nature, for all his wickedness comes from deliberate choice and decision.

Let us therefore take heed that it be not said of us, that our ears are those of a deaf adder. Psalm 58:4 For tell me, in what does a hearer of this kind differ from a beast? And how could he be otherwise than more irrational than any irrational animal, who does not attend when God is speaking? And if to be well-pleasing to God is really to be a man, what else but a beast can he be who will not even hear how he may succeed in this? Consider then what a misfortune it would be for us to fall down of our own accord from (the nature of) men to (that of) beasts, when Christ is willing of men to make us equal to angels. For to serve the belly, to be possessed by the desire of riches, to be given to anger, to bite, to kick, become not men, but beasts. Nay, even the beasts have each, as one may say, one single passion, and that by nature. But man, when he has cast away the dominion of reason, and torn himself from the commonwealth of God's devising, gives himself up to all the passions, is no longer merely a beast, but a kind of many-formed motley monster; nor has he even the excuse from nature, for all his wickedness proceeds from deliberate choice and determination.

May we never have reason to suspect this of the Church of Christ. Indeed, we are convinced of better things concerning you, things that belong to salvation. But the more convinced we are, the more careful we will be not to stop giving warnings. This is so that, having climbed to the height of excellence, we may receive the promised blessings. May we all attain to these through the grace and loving-kindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom and with whom, to the Father and the Holy Spirit, be glory forever and ever. Amen.

May we never have cause to suspect this of the Church of Christ. Indeed, we are concerning you persuaded of better things, and such as belong to salvation; but the more we are so persuaded, the more careful we will be not to desist from words of caution. In order that having mounted to the summit of excellencies, we may obtain the promised goods. Which may it come to pass that we all attain to, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom and with whom, to the Father and the Holy Ghost, be glory world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 1

Homily 1 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240101.htm>.

Opening

People who attend pagan games, when they hear that a famous athlete and champion has arrived from somewhere, all rush together to watch him wrestle and see all his skill and strength. You can see the entire theater filled with tens of thousands of people, all straining their physical and mental sight so they don't miss anything that happens. Likewise, these same people, if an excellent musician comes to them, abandon whatever they were doing—even if it's necessary and urgent business—and climb the steps and sit down, listening very carefully to the words and the music, and judging how well the two fit together. This is what most people do.

1. They that are spectators of the heathen games, when they have learned that a distinguished athlete and winner of crowns has come from any quarter, run all together to view his wrestling, and all his skill and strength; and you may see the whole theater of many ten thousands, all there straining their eyes both of body and mind, that nothing of what is done may escape them. So again these same persons, if any admirable musician come among them, leave all that they had in hand, which often is necessary and pressing business, and mount the steps, and sit listening very attentively to the words and the accompaniments, and criticising the agreement of the two. This is what the many do.

People who are skilled in rhetoric do exactly the same thing with sophists, because they too have their theaters, their audiences, applause, noise, and intense scrutiny of everything that is said.

Again; those who are skilled in rhetoric do just the same with respect to the sophists, for they too have their theaters, and their audience, and clappings of hands, and noise, and closest criticism of what is said.

And if people sit with such serious attention when it comes to rhetoricians, musicians, and athletes—in one case to watch, in the other both to watch and to listen—how much zeal and earnestness should you reasonably show when it is not a musician or debater who now steps forward to demonstrate his skill, but when a man is speaking from heaven and utters a voice clearer than thunder? For he has spread the sound throughout the whole earth and has occupied and filled it, not by the loudness of his cry, but by moving his tongue with the grace of God.

And if in the case of rhetoricians, musicians, and athletes, people sit in the one case to look on, in the other to see at once and to listen with such earnest attention; what zeal, what earnestness ought you in reason to display, when it is no musician or debater who now comes forward to a trial of skill, but when a man is speaking from heaven, and utters a voice plainer than thunder? For he has pervaded the whole earth with the sound; and occupied and filled it, not by the loudness of the cry, but by moving his tongue with the grace of God.

And what is wonderful, this sound, great as it is, is neither harsh nor unpleasant, but sweeter and more delightful than all musical harmony, and with greater power to soothe. Besides all this, it is most holy and most awesome, full of such great mysteries and bringing with it such great goods that if people would receive and keep them carefully and with ready minds, they could no longer be mere human beings or remain bound to the earth. Instead, they would rise above all the things of this life, and having adapted themselves to the condition of angels, would live on earth just as if it were heaven.

And what is wonderful, this sound, great as it is, is neither a harsh nor an unpleasant one, but sweeter and more delightful than all harmony of music, and with more skill to soothe; and besides all this, most holy, and most awful, and full of mysteries so great, and bringing with it goods so great, that if men were exactly and with ready mind to receive and keep them, they could no longer be mere men nor remain upon the earth, but would take their stand above all the things of this life, and having adapted themselves to the condition of angels, would dwell on earth just as if it were heaven.

For the son of thunder, the beloved of Christ, the pillar of the Churches throughout the world, who holds the keys of heaven, who drank the cup of Christ and was baptized with His baptism, who lay upon his Master's bosom with much confidence—this man comes forward to us now. He does not come as an actor in a play, not hiding his head with a mask (for he has a different kind of message to speak), nor mounting a platform, nor striking the stage with his foot, nor dressed in golden clothing. Instead, he enters wearing a robe of inconceivable beauty. For he will appear before us having put on Christ, having his beautiful feet shod with the preparation of the Gospel of peace, wearing a belt not around his waist but around his loins—not made of scarlet leather or gilded on the outside, but woven and composed of truth itself. Now he will appear before us, not acting a part (for with him there is nothing counterfeit, nor fiction, nor fable), but with uncovered head he proclaims to us the truth uncovered. He does not make the audience believe him to be other than he is through his bearing, his appearance, or his voice. He needs no musical instruments for delivering his message—no harp, lyre, or anything like them—for he accomplishes everything with his tongue, uttering a voice that is sweeter and more profitable than that of any harpist or any music. All heaven is his stage; his theater is the inhabited world; his audience is all the angels and as many people as are already angels or desire to become so—for only these can hear that harmony rightly and demonstrate it through their works. All the rest are like little children who hear but do not understand what they hear, being preoccupied with sweets and childish toys. So too these others, being caught up in pleasure and luxury and living only for wealth and power and sensuality, sometimes hear what is said, it is true, but show forth nothing great or noble in their actions because they have permanently fastened themselves to the clay of brickmaking. Beside this Apostle stand the powers from above, marveling at the beauty of his soul, his understanding, and the flowering of that virtue by which he drew Christ Himself to him and obtained the grace of the Spirit. For he has prepared his soul like a well-crafted and jeweled lyre with golden strings, and yielded it to the Spirit for the utterance of something great and sublime.

2. For the son of thunder, the beloved of Christ, the pillar of the Churches throughout the world, who holds the keys of heaven, who drank the cup of Christ, and was baptized with His baptism, who lay upon his Master's bosom with much confidence, this man comes forward to us now; not as an actor of a play, not hiding his head with a mask, (for he has another sort of words to speak,) nor mounting a platform, nor striking the stage with his foot, nor dressed out with apparel of gold, but he enters wearing a robe of inconceivable beauty. For he will appear before us having put on Christ Romans 13:14; Galatians 3:27, having his beautiful feet shod with the preparation of the Gospel of peace Ephesians 6:15; wearing a girdle not about his waist, but about his loins, not made of scarlet leather nor daubed outside with gold, but woven and composed of truth itself. Now will he appear before us, not acting a part, (for with him there is nothing counterfeit, nor fiction, nor fable,) but with unmasked head he proclaims to us the truth unmasked; not making the audience believe him other than he is by carriage, by look, by voice, needing for the delivery of his message no instruments of music, as harp, lyre, or any other the like, for he effects all with his tongue, uttering a voice which is sweeter and more profitable than that of any harper or any music. All heaven is his stage; his theater, the habitable world; his audience, all angels; and of men as many as are angels already, or desire to become so, for none but these can hear that harmony aright, and show it forth by their works; all the rest, like little children who hear, but what they hear understand not, from their anxiety about sweetmeats and childish playthings; so they too, being in mirth and luxury, and living only for wealth and power and sensuality, hear sometimes what is said, it is true, but show forth nothing great or noble in their actions through fastening themselves for good to the clay of the brickmaking. By this Apostle stand the powers from above, marveling at the beauty of his soul, and his understanding, and the bloom of that virtue by which he drew unto him Christ Himself, and obtained the grace of the Spirit. For he has made ready his soul, as some well-fashioned and jeweled lyre with strings of gold, and yielded it for the utterance of something great and sublime to the Spirit.

Since it is no longer the fisherman, the son of Zebedee, but the one who knows the deep things of God—I mean the Holy Spirit—who plays this instrument, let us listen accordingly. For he will say nothing to us as a mere man, but whatever he says, he will say from the depths of the Spirit, from those hidden things which even the Angels did not know before they happened, since they too have learned along with us and through us, by the voice of John, the things we now know. Another Apostle has declared this, saying, "To the intent that unto the principalities and powers might be known by the Church the manifold wisdom of God." If then principalities and powers and Cherubim and Seraphim learned these things through the Church, it is very clear that they were exceedingly eager to hear this teaching. And in this we have been greatly honored, that the Angels learned things they did not know before along with us—I will not now speak of their learning through us as well. Let us then show much silence and orderly conduct, not only today or on the day when we are listeners, but throughout our entire life, since it is always good to hear Him. For if we long to know what is happening in the palace—what, for instance, the king has said, what he has done, what plans he is making concerning his subjects, though in truth these things usually have little to do with us—how much more desirable is it to hear what God has said, especially when everything concerns us. And all this, this man will tell us exactly, since he is a friend of the King Himself, or rather, since he has Him speaking within himself, and from Him hears all things which He hears from the Father. "I have called you friends," He says, "for all things that I have heard of My Father, I have made known unto you."

3. Seeing then it is no longer the fisherman the son of Zebedee, but He who knows the deep things of God 1 Corinthians 2:10, the Holy Spirit I mean, that strikes this lyre, let us hearken accordingly. For he will say nothing to us as a man, but what he says, he will say from the depths of the Spirit, from those secret things which before they came to pass the very Angels knew not; since they too have learned by the voice of John with us, and by us, the things which we know. And this has another Apostle declared, saying, To the intent that unto the principalities and powers might be known by the Church the manifold wisdom of God. Ephesians 3:10 If then principalities, and powers, and Cherubim, and Seraphim, learned these things by the Church, it is very clear that they were exceedingly earnest in listening to this teaching; and even in this we have been not a little honored, that the Angels learned things which before they knew not with us; I do not at present speak of their learning by us also. Let us then show much silence and orderly behavior; not today only, nor during the day on which we are hearers, but during all our life, since it is at all times good to hear Him. For if we long to know what is going on in the palace, what, for instance, the king has said, what he has done, what counsel he is taking concerning his subjects, though in truth these things are for the most part nothing to us; much more is it desirable to hear what God has said, especially when all concerns us. And all this will this man tell us exactly, as being a friend of the King Himself, or rather, as having Him speaking within himself, and from Him hearing all things which He hears from the Father. I have called you friends, He says, for all things that I have heard of My Father, I have made known unto you. John 15:15

If we saw someone suddenly descend from the heights of heaven, promising to describe exactly all things there, we would all rush together to hear. Let us have the same attitude now. This Man speaks to us from that place; He is not of this world, as Christ Himself declares, "You are not of the world" (John 15:19), and He has the Comforter speaking within him—the Omnipresent One who knows the things of God as exactly as the soul of a person knows what belongs to itself, the Spirit of holiness, the righteous Spirit, the guiding Spirit, which leads people by the hand to heaven, which gives them other eyes, fitting them to see things to come as though present, and giving them even in the flesh to look into heavenly things. Let us yield ourselves to Him during all our life in much tranquility. Let no one dull, no one sleepy, no one sordid, enter here and stay; rather, let us remove ourselves to heaven, for there He speaks these things to those who are citizens there. And if we remain on earth, we shall gain nothing great from that place. For the words of John are nothing to those who do not desire to be freed from this pig-like life, just as the things of this world are nothing to him. Thunder amazes our souls, having sound without meaning; but this man's voice does not trouble any of the faithful—rather, it releases them from trouble and confusion. It amazes only the demons and those who are their slaves. Therefore, so that we may know how it amazes them, let us preserve deep silence, both outward and inward, but especially the latter. For what advantage is it if the mouth is quiet, but the soul is disturbed and full of turmoil? I am looking for the calm that is of the mind, of the soul, since it is the hearing of the soul which I require. Let no desire of riches trouble us, no lust of glory, no tyranny of anger, nor the crowd of other passions besides these. For it is not possible for the ear, unless it is cleansed, to perceive as it should the sublimity of the things spoken, nor rightly to understand the awesome and unutterable nature of these mysteries, and all other virtue which is in these divine oracles. If a man cannot learn well a melody on pipe or harp unless he strains his attention in every way, how shall one who sits as a listener to mystical sounds be able to hear with a careless soul?

4. As then we should all run together if we saw one from above bend down on a sudden from the height of heaven, promising to describe exactly all things there, even so let us be disposed now. It is from thence that this Man speaks to us; He is not of this world, as Christ Himself declares, You are not of the world John 15:19, and He has speaking within him the Comforter, the Omnipresent, who knows the things of God as exactly as the soul of man knows what belongs to herself, the Spirit of holiness, the righteous Spirit, the guiding Spirit, which leads men by the hand to heaven, which gives them other eyes, fitting them to see things to come as though present, and giving them even in the flesh to look into things heavenly. To Him then let us yield ourselves during all our life in much tranquillity. Let none dull, none sleepy, none sordid, enter here and tarry; but let us remove ourselves to heaven, for there He speaks these things to those who are citizens there. And if we tarry on earth, we shall gain nothing great from thence. For the words of John are nothing to those who do not desire to be freed from this swinish life, just as the things of this world to him are nothing. The thunder amazes our souls, having sound without significance; but this man's voice troubles none of the faithful, yea, rather releases them from trouble and confusion; it amazes the devils only, and those who are their slaves. Therefore that we may know how it amazes them, let us preserve deep silence, both external and mental, but especially the latter; for what advantage is it that the mouth be hushed, if the soul is disturbed and full of tossing? I look for that calm which is of the mind, of the soul, since it is the hearing of the soul which I require. Let then no desire of riches trouble us, no lust of glory, no tyranny of anger, nor the crowd of other passions besides these; for it is not possible for the ear, except it be cleansed, to perceive as it ought the sublimity of the things spoken; nor rightly to understand the awful and unutterable nature of these mysteries, and all other virtue which is in these divine oracles. If a man cannot learn well a melody on pipe or harp, unless he in every way strain his attention; how shall one, who sits as a listener to sounds mystical, be able to hear with a careless soul?

Christ Himself warned us about this when He said, "Give not that which is holy unto the dogs, neither cast your pearls before swine" (Matthew 7:6). He called these words pearls, though in reality they are far more precious, because we have no substance more valuable than this. For the same reason, He often compares their sweetness to honey—not because that fully measures their sweetness, but because among us there is nothing sweeter. Now, to show that they far exceed the nature of precious stones and the sweetness of any honey, listen to the prophet speaking about them and declaring this superiority: "More to be desired are they than gold and much precious stone; sweeter are they also than honey and the honeycomb" (Psalm 19:10). But this is true only for those who are spiritually healthy; that's why he added, "For your servant keeps them." And again in another place, when calling them sweet, he added "to my throat." He says, "How sweet are your words unto my throat" (Psalm 119:103). And again he emphasizes their superiority, saying, "Above honey and the honeycomb to my mouth." He was in very sound spiritual health. Let us not approach these words while we are spiritually sick, but rather, once we have healed our soul, then receive the food that is offered to us.

5. Wherefore Christ Himself exhorted, saying, Give not that which is holy unto the dogs, neither cast your pearls before swine. Matthew 7:6 He called these words pearls, though in truth they be much more precious than they, because we have no substance more precious than that. For this reason too He is wont often to compare their sweetness to honey, not that so much only is the measure of their sweetness, but because among us there is nothing sweeter. Now, to show that they very exceedingly surpass the nature of precious stones, and the sweetness of any honey, hear the prophet speaking concerning them, and declaring this superiority; More to be desired are they, he says than gold and much precious stone; sweeter are they also than honey and the honeycomb. Psalm 19:10 But to those (only) who are in health; wherefore he has added, For your servant keeps them. And again in another place calling them sweet he has added, to my throat. For he says, How sweet are your words unto my throat. Psalm 119:103 And again he insists on the superiority, saying, Above honey and the honeycomb to my mouth. For he was in very sound health. And let not us either come near to these while we are sick, but when we have healed our soul, so receive the food that is offered us.

This is why, after such a long introduction, I have not yet tried to explain these expressions of Saint John. I want everyone to put aside all kinds of weakness, and to enter here pure and free from anger, worry, and the anxieties of this life, and from all other passions—just as if they were entering heaven itself. For it is impossible for anyone to gain anything great from this unless he has first cleansed his soul in this way. Let no one say that the time until the coming communion is short, because it is possible to change the whole course of one's life not only in five days, but in a single moment. Tell me, what is worse than a robber and murderer? Is this not the most extreme kind of wickedness? Yet such a person reached the very summit of excellence at once and entered Paradise itself, needing not days or even half a day, but just one brief moment. So a person can change suddenly and become gold instead of clay. Since what belongs to virtue and vice is not determined by nature, the change is easy, not bound by any necessity. If you are willing and obedient, He says, you shall eat the good of the land. Do you see that only the will is needed? I mean will—not the ordinary wishing of the crowd—but earnest will. For I know that everyone wishes to fly up to heaven right now, but it is necessary to demonstrate the wish through actions. The merchant also wishes to get rich, but he does not allow his wish to stop at just thinking about it. No, he fits out a ship, gathers sailors, hires a pilot, supplies the vessel with all other provisions, borrows money, crosses the sea, travels to a foreign land, endures many dangers, and all the rest that those who sail the sea know well. We too must show our will in this way, for we also sail a voyage—not from land to land, but from earth to heaven. Let us therefore order our reason so that it is fit to steer our upward course, and our sailors so that they obey it, and let our vessel be sturdy so that it is not swamped by the troubles and discouragements of this life or lifted up by the blasts of vainglory, but is a secure and steady vessel. If we order our ship this way, and our pilot and crew likewise, we shall sail with a favorable wind, and we shall draw down to ourselves the Son of God, the true Pilot, who will not let our ship be overwhelmed. Even if ten thousand winds blow, He will rebuke the winds and the sea, and instead of raging waves, make a great calm.

It is for this reason that, after so long a preface, I have not yet attempted to fathom these expressions (of St. John), in order that every one having laid aside all manner of infirmity, as though he were entering into heaven itself, so may enter here pure, and freed from wrath and carefulness and anxiety of this life, of all other passions. For it is not otherwise possible for a man to gain from hence anything great, except he have first so cleansed anew his soul. And let no one say that the time to the coming communion is short, for it is possible, not only in five days, but in one moment, to change the whole course of life. Tell me what is worse than a robber and a murderer, is not this the extremest kind of wickedness? Yet such an one arrived straight at the summit of excellence, and passed into Paradise itself, not needing days, nor half a day, but one little moment. So that a man may change suddenly, and become gold instead of clay. For since what belongs to virtue and to vice is not by nature, the change is easy, as being independent of any necessity. If you be willing and obedient, He says, you shall eat the good of the land. Isaiah 1:19 Do you see that there needs the will only? will — not the common wishing of the multitude — but earnest will. For I know that all are wishing to fly up to heaven even now; but it is necessary to show forth the wish by works. The merchant too wishes to get rich; but he does not allow his wish to stop with the thought of it; no, he fits out a ship, and gets together sailors, and engages a pilot, and furnishes the vessel with all other stores, and borrows money, and crosses the sea, and goes away into a strange land, and endures many dangers, and all the rest which they know who sail the sea. So too must we show our will; for we also sail a voyage, not from land to land, but from earth to heaven. Let us then so order our reason, that it be serviceable to steer our upward course, and our sailors that they be obedient to it, and let our vessel be stout, that it be not swamped amidst the reverses and despondencies of this life, nor be lifted up by the blasts of vainglory, but be a fast and easy vessel. If so we order our ship, and so our pilot and our crew, we shall sail with a fair wind, and we shall draw down to ourselves the Son of God, the true Pilot, who will not leave our bark to be engulfed, but, though ten thousand winds may blow, will rebuke the winds and the sea, and instead of raging waves, make a great calm.

Having therefore prepared yourselves, come to our next assembly—if indeed you have any desire at all to hear something to your advantage—and store up what is said in your souls. But let none of you be the wayside, none the stony ground, none full of thorns. Let us make ourselves fallow ground. For then we preachers will sow the seed with gladness when we see the soil is clean. But if it is stony or rough, forgive us if we prefer not to labor in vain. For if we stop sowing and start cutting up thorns instead, it would surely be utter foolishness to cast seed into unworked ground.

6. Having therefore ordered yourselves, so come to our next assembly, if at least it be at all an object of desire to you to hear somewhat to your advantage, and lay up what is said in your souls. But let not one of you be the wayside, none the stony ground, none the full of thorns. Matthew 13:4-7 Let us make ourselves fallow lands. For so shall we (the preachers) put in the seed with gladness, when we see the land clean, but if stony or rough, pardon us if we like not to labor in vain. For if we shall leave off sowing and begin to cut up thorns, surely to cast seed into ground unwrought were extreme folly.

It is not appropriate for someone who has the benefit of hearing such teaching to also share in the table of demons. For what fellowship has righteousness with unrighteousness? You stand listening to John and learning spiritual truths through him, yet afterward you go to listen to prostitutes speaking vile things and acting even more vilely, and to effeminate performers striking one another? How will you be able to be properly cleansed if you wallow in such filth? Why should I list in detail all the indecency that takes place there? Everything there is laughter, everything is shame, everything is disgrace, insults and mockery, complete abandonment, complete destruction. Listen, I warn and command you all. Let none of those who enjoy the blessings of this table destroy his own soul through those destructive spectacles. Everything said and done there is a display of Satan. But you who have been initiated know what kind of covenants you made with us, or rather with Christ when He brought you into His mysteries, what you said to Him, what agreement you made with Him concerning Satan's display—how you renounced this along with Satan and his angels, and promised that you would not even cast a glance in that direction. There is therefore serious cause for fear, lest by becoming careless about such promises, one should make himself unworthy of these mysteries.

It is not meet that he who has the advantage of such hearing be partaker of the table of devils. For what fellowship has righteousness with unrighteousness? 2 Corinthians 6:14 You stand listening to John, and learning the things of the Spirit by him; and do you after this depart to listen to harlots speaking vile things, and acting viler, and to effeminates cuffing one another? How will you be able to be fairly cleansed, if you wallow in such mire? Why need I reckon in detail all the indecency that is there? All there is laughter, all is shame, all disgrace, revilings and mockings, all abandonment, all destruction. See, I forewarn and charge you all. Let none of those who enjoy the blessings of this table destroy his own soul by those pernicious spectacles. All that is said and done there is a pageant of Satan. But you who have been initiated know what manner of covenants you made with us, or rather you made with Christ when He guided you into His mysteries, what you spoke to Him, what speech you had with Him concerning Satan's pageant; how with Satan and his angels you renounced this also, and promised that you would not so much as cast a glance that way. There is then no slight ground for fear, lest, by becoming careless of such promises, one should render himself unworthy of these mysteries.

Do you not see how in royal palaces it is not those who have committed offenses, but those who have been honored and distinguished, who are called to share in special favor and are counted among the king's friends? A messenger has come to us from heaven, sent by God Himself, to speak with us about certain necessary matters, and you abandon hearing His will and the message He sends to you, and instead sit listening to actors. What thunderings, what lightning bolts from heaven does this behavior not deserve! For just as it is not proper to partake of the table of devils, neither is it proper to listen to devils, nor to be present with filthy clothing at that glorious Table, loaded with so many good things, which God Himself has prepared. Such is its power that it can raise us immediately to heaven, if only we approach it with a sober mind. For it is not possible that a person who is continually under the influence of God's words can remain in this present lowly condition, but he must soon take flight and fly away to the realm that is above, and land upon the infinite treasures of good things. May we all attain to this, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, through whom and with whom be glory to the Father and the All-holy Spirit, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.

7. Do you see not how in king's palaces it is not those who have offended, but those who have been honorably distinguished, that are called to share special favor, and are numbered among the king's friends. A messenger has come to us from heaven, sent by God Himself, to speak with us on certain necessary matters, and you leave hearing His will, and the message He sends to you, and sit listening to stage-players. What thunderings, what bolts from heaven, does not this conduct deserve! For as it is not meet to partake of the table of devils, so neither is it of the listening to devils; nor to be present with filthy raiment at that glorious Table, loaded with so many good things, which God Himself has provided. Such is its power, that it can raise us at once to heaven, if only we approach it with a sober mind. For it is not possible that he who is continually under the influence of the words of God, can remain in this present low condition, but he needs must presently take wing, and fly away to the land which is above, and light on the infinite treasures of good things; which may it be that we all attain to, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, through whom and with whom be glory to the Father and the All- holy Spirit, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Epistle to the Romans — Homily 32 — Romans 16:17-18

Homily 32 of 32 on St. Paul’s Epistle to the Romans.

Source: Translated by J. Walker, J. Sheppard and H. Browne, and revised by George B. Stevens. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 11. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/210232.htm>.

Opening

Romans 16:17-18

I urge you, brothers and sisters, to watch out for those who create divisions and put obstacles in your way that go against the teaching you have learned. Keep away from them. For such people are not serving our Lord Christ, but their own appetites. By smooth talk and flattery they deceive the minds of naive people.

Romans XVI. 17, 18

I urge you, brothers and sisters, to watch out for those who cause divisions and put obstacles in your way that go against the teaching you have learned, and stay away from them. For such people are not serving our Lord Jesus Christ, but their own appetites, and through smooth talk and flattery they deceive the minds of naive people.

Now I beseech you, brethren, mark them which cause divisions and offenses contrary to the doctrine which you have learned, and avoid them. For they that are such serve not our Lord Jesus Christ, but their own belly; and by good words and fair speeches deceive the hearts of the simple.

Paul gives another exhortation, followed by prayer. After telling them to mark those who cause divisions and not to listen to them, he continues, "And the God of peace shall bruise Satan under your feet shortly," and "The grace of our Lord be with you." Notice how gently he exhorts them. He does not act like someone giving advice, but like a servant, and with much respect. He calls them brethren and pleads with them. He says, "I beseech you, brethren." Then he also puts them on guard by showing how deceitful those who abuse them really are. As if they were not easy to recognize at once, he says "I beseech you to mark"—that is, to be extremely careful about them, to get to know them, and to search them out thoroughly. Mark whom? Those who cause divisions and offenses contrary to the doctrine which you have learned. If anything destroys the Church, it is being divided. This is the devil's weapon; this turns everything upside-down. As long as the body is joined as one, he has no power to get in, but offense comes from division. And where does division come from? From opinions contrary to the teaching of the Apostles. And where do such opinions come from? From people being slaves to the belly and other passions. He says, "Such serve not the Lord, but their own belly." So there would be no offense and no division unless someone thought up an opinion contrary to the doctrine of the Apostles. Paul points this out here by saying "contrary to the doctrine." He does not say "which we have taught," but "which you have learned," thus appealing to them directly and showing that they were persuaded of it, had heard it, and received it. What should we do to those who make trouble in this way? He does not say to hold a meeting and come to blows, but to avoid them. If they did this out of ignorance or error, we should correct them. But if they sin willfully, pull away from them. Elsewhere he says the same thing. He says, "Withdraw from every brother that walks disorderly," and when speaking to Timothy about the coppersmith, he gives similar advice: "Of whom also beware." Then, to mock those who dare to do such things, he mentions the reason for their devising this division. He says, "For they that are such serve not our Lord Christ, but their own belly." He said the same thing when writing to the Philippians: "Whose god is their belly." But here he seems to me to be referring to those among the Jews, whom he always particularly criticizes as gluttonous. When writing to Titus, he said of them, "Evil beasts, slow bellies." Christ also blames them on this point, saying, "You devour widows' houses." The Prophets accuse them of the same things. Scripture says, "My beloved has waxen fat and gross, and has kicked." Moses also urged them, saying, "When you have eaten and drunken and are full, remember the Lord your God." In the Gospels, those who say to Christ, "What sign do you show unto us?" pass over everything else and remember only the manna. So they appear everywhere to be controlled by this appetite. How can you not be ashamed at having slaves of the belly for your teachers when you are a brother of Christ? Now this is the root of the error, but the method of attack is a different disorder—flattery. He says it is by fair speeches that they deceive the hearts of the simple. Their attention is focused only on words, but their meaning is not the same, for it is full of fraud. He does not say that they deceive you, but rather the hearts of the simple. Even with this he was not satisfied, but to make this statement less offensive, he says,

Again an exhortation, and prayer after the exhortation. For after telling them to mark them which cause divisions, and not to listen to them, he proceeds, And the God of peace shall bruise Satan under your feet shortly: and, The grace of our Lord be with you. And notice how gently too he exhorts them: doing it not in the character of a counsellor, but that of a servant, and with much respect. For he calls them brethren, and supplicates them likewise. For, I beseech you, brethren, (he says). Then he also puts them on the defensive by showing the deceitfulness of those who abused them. For as though they were not at once to be discerned, he says, I beseech you to mark, that is, to be exceedingly particular about, and to get acquainted with, and to search out thoroughly — whom, pray? Why, those that cause divisions and offenses, contrary to the doctrine which you have learned. For this is, if anything the subversion of the Church, the being in divisions. This is the devil's weapon, this turns all things upside-down. For so long as the body is joined into one, he has no power to get an entrance, but it is from division that the offense comes. And whence is division? From opinions contrary to the teaching of the Apostles. And whence come opinions of this sort? From men's being slaves to the belly, and the other passions. For such, he says, serve not the Lord, but their own belly. And so there would be no offense, there would be no division, unless some opinion were thought of contrary to the doctrine of the Apostles. And this he here points out by saying, contrary to the doctrine. And he does not say which we have taught, but which you have learned, so anticipating them, and showing that they were persuaded of and had heard them and received them. And what are we to do to those who make mischief in this way? He does not say have a meeting and come to blows, but avoid them. For if it was from ignorance or error that they did this, one ought to set them right. But if they sin willingly, spring away from them. And in another place too he says this. For he says, Withdraw from every brother that walks disorderly 2 Thessalonians 3:6: and in speaking to Timothy about the coppersmith, he gives him the like advice, and says, Of whom also beware. 2 Timothy 4:15 Then also to lash ( κωμῳδὥν) those who dare to do such things, he mentions also the reason of their devising this division. For they that are such, he says, serve not our Lord Christ, but their own belly. And this he said too when he wrote to the Philippians, Whose god is their belly. Philippians 3:19 But here he appears to me to intimate those of the Jews, whom he ever uses particularly to find fault with as gluttonous. For in writing to Titus too, he said of them, Evil beasts, slow bellies. Titus 1:12, see 5:10 And Christ also blames them on this head: You devour widows' houses Matthew 23:14, He says. And the Prophets accuse them of things of the kind. For, My beloved, He says, has waxen fat and gross, and has kicked Deuteronomy 32:15. Wherefore also Moses exhorted them, and said, When you have eaten and drunken and are full, remember the Lord your God. (ib. 6:11, 12.) And in the Gospels, they who say to Christ, What sign do you show unto us? John 6:30 pass over everything else, and remember the manna. So do they everywhere appear to be possessed with this affection. How then do you come not to be ashamed at having slaves of the belly for your teachers, when you are a brother of Christ? Now the ground of the error is this, but the mode of attack is again a different disorder, viz. flattery. For it is by fair speeches, he says, that they deceive the hearts of the simple. For their attention reaches only to words; but their meaning is not such, for it is full of fraud. And he does not say that they deceive you, but the hearts of the simple. And even with this he was not satisfied, but with a view to making this statement less grating, he says,

Your obedience has become known to everyone.

Ver. 19. For your obedience has come abroad unto all men.

He does this not to allow them to become shameless, but to win them over in advance with praise and with the multitude of witnesses, so as to capture their attention. For I am not the only witness—the whole world is too. And he does not say "for your understanding," but "your obedience"—that is, their compliance, which was evidence of much meekness in them. "I am glad therefore on your behalf." And this too is no small praise. Then, after the praise, comes admonition. For lest, after freeing them from any accusations against them, he should make them more careless, thinking they are not being watched, he gives them another hint in his words,

This he does, not to leave them free to be shameless, but to win them beforehand with encomiums, and the number of his witnesses, to arrest their attention. For neither is it I alone that am the witness, but the whole world. And he does not say for your understanding, but, your obedience: that is, their compliance, which was evidence of much meekness in them. I am glad therefore on your behalf. And this is no small encomium too. Then, after the praise, admonition. For lest, after liberating them from any charges against them, he should make them the more listless, as not being observed; he gives them another hint in the words,

I want you to be wise when it comes to what is good, and innocent concerning evil.

I would have you wise unto that which is good, and simple concerning evil.

You see then how he attacks them again, and without them suspecting it. For this seems to hint that some of them were likely to be led astray.

You see then how he attacks them again, and that without their suspecting it. For this looks like intimating that some of them were apt to be led astray.

And the God of peace will crush Satan under your feet soon.

Ver. 20. And the God of peace shall bruise Satan under your feet shortly.

For since he had spoken of those who caused divisions and offenses among them, he also mentioned the God of peace, so that they might feel hopeful about being freed from these evils. For the one who rejoices in peace will put an end to what destroys it. And he does not say "will subject," but "will bruise," which is a stronger expression. And not only those people, but also the one who was their leader in this, Satan. And not merely "will bruise," but "under your feet," so that they themselves may obtain the victory and become honorable through the triumph. And the time itself is made a ground for comfort, for he adds "shortly." And this was both prayer and prophecy at once. "The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ be with you."

For since he had spoken of those who caused divisions and offenses among them, he has mentioned the God of peace also, that they might feel hopeful about the riddance of these evils. For he that rejoices in this (i.e., peace) will put an end to that which makes havoc of it. And he does not say, will subject, but will bruise Genesis 3:19, which is a stronger expression. And not those people only, but also him who was the general over them herein, Satan. And not will bruise merely, but under your feet, so that they may obtain the victory themselves, and become noble by the trophy. And the time again is made a ground of comfort. For he adds, shortly. And this was prayer and prophecy as well at once. The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ be with you.

That greatest weapon; that impregnable wall; that tower unshaken! For he reminds them of the grace, so that he may give them greater eagerness. Because if you have been freed from far more serious evils, and freed by grace alone, you will much more certainly be freed from the lesser ones, now that you have become friends and also contribute your own part. You see how he does not offer prayer without works, nor works without prayer. For after acknowledging their obedience, he then prays, showing that we need both—our own part as well as God's part—if we are to be properly saved. For it was not only before, but even now, though we may be important and highly regarded, we still need grace from Him.

That greatest weapon; that impregnable wall; that tower unshaken! For he reminds them of the grace, that he may give them the more alacrity. Because if you have been freed from the ills more grievous by far, and freed by grace only, much more will you be freed from the lesser, now you have become friends too, and contribute your own share likewise. You see how he neither puts prayer without works, nor works without prayer. For after giving them credit for their obedience, than he prays; to show that we need both, our own part as well as God's part, if we are to be duly saved. For it was not before only, but now too, even though we be great and in high esteem, we need grace from Him.

Timothy, my fellow worker, greets you.

Ver. 21. Timotheus my work-fellow salutes you.

Notice the customary praises once again. And Lucius, and Jason, and Sosipater my kinsmen.

Observe the customary encomiums again. And Lucius, and Jason, and Sosipater my kinsmen.

This Jason is also mentioned by Luke, who shows us his courage when he says that they dragged him to the city rulers, crying out, and so on (Acts 17:5). It is likely that the others were also noteworthy men. For Paul does not simply mention relatives unless they were also like him in godliness.

This Jason Luke also mentions, and sets before us his manliness also, when he says, that they drew him to the rulers of the city, crying, etc. Acts 17:5 And it is likely that the others too were men of note. For he does not mention relations barely, unless they were also like him in religiousness.

Verse 22. I, Tertius, who wrote this letter, greet you.

Ver. 22. I Tertius, who wrote this Epistle, salute you.

This too is no small praise, to be Paul's secretary. Yet he does not say this to praise himself, but so that he might secure warm affection for himself from them because of this service.

This too is no small encomium, to be Paul's amanuensis. Still it is not to pass encomiums on himself that he says this, but that he might attach a warm love to him on their part, for this ministration.

Verse 23. Gaius, my host (xenos) and host of the whole Church, greets you.

Ver. 23. Gaius mine host ( ξένος), and of the whole Church, salutes you.

See what a crown Paul has created for Gaius by testifying to such great hospitality in him, and by bringing the entire Church into this man's house! For by the word ξένος used here, he means a host, not a guest. But when you hear that he was Paul's host, do not admire him only for his generosity, but also for his disciplined life. For unless he were worthy of Paul's excellence, Paul would never have stayed there, since Paul, who took pains to go beyond many of Christ's commands, would never have violated that law which tells us to be very careful about who receives us and about lodging with worthy persons. Erastus, the chamberlain of the city, salutes you, and Quartus a brother. There is a purpose in his adding "the chamberlain of the city," for just as he wrote to the Philippians, "Those of Caesar's household salute you," so that he might show that the Gospel had taken hold among important people, so here too he mentions the title with the same goal in view, and to show that for the person who pays attention, neither riches are a hindrance, nor the cares of government, nor anything else of that kind.

See what a crown he has framed for him by bearing witness to such great hospitality in him, and brought in the entire Church into this man's house! For by the word ξένον, used here, he means a host, not a. But when you hear that he was Paul's host, do not admire him for his munificence only, but also for his strictness of life. For except he were worthy of Paul's excellency, he would never have lodged there, since he, who took pains to go beyond many of Christ's commands, would never have trespassed against that law, which bids us be very particular about who receive us, and about lodging with worthy persons. Matthew 10:11 Erastus, the chamberlain of the city, salutes you, and Quartus a brother. There is a purpose in his adding the chamberlain of the city, for as he wrote to the Philippians, They of Cæsar's household salute you Philippians 4:22, that he might show that the Gospel had taken a hold upon great folk, so here too he mentions the title with a view to the same object, and to show that, to the man who gives heed, neither riches are a hindrance, nor the cares of government, nor anything else of the kind.

The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ be with you all. Amen.

Ver. 24. The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ be with you all. Amen.

See what we ought to begin and end with everywhere! For he laid the foundation of the Epistle with this, and he puts the roof on with this, at once praying for the mother of all good things for them and calling the whole of his loving-kindness to their mind. For this is the best proof of a generous teacher: to benefit his learners not by word only, but also by prayer. For this reason someone said, "But let us give ourselves continually to prayers and to the ministry of the word" (Acts 6:4).

See what we ought to begin and to end with everywhere! For in this he laid the foundation of the Epistle, and in this he puts on the roof, at once praying for the mother of all good things for them, and calling the whole of his loving-kindness to their mind. For this is the best proof of a generous teacher, to benefit his learners not by word only, but likewise by prayer, for which cause also one said, But let us give ourselves continually to prayers, and to the ministry of the word. Acts 6:4

Who then is there to pray over us, since Paul has departed? Those who are imitators of Paul. We need only to make ourselves worthy of such intercession, so that we may not merely hear Paul's voice here, but also, when we have departed, be counted worthy to see the wrestler of Christ. Or rather, if we hear him here, we shall certainly see him hereafter—if not standing near him, yet we shall certainly see him, gleaming near the throne of the King. Where the Cherubim sing the glory, where the Seraphim are flying, there we shall see Paul with Peter, as a chief and leader of the choir of the saints, and we shall enjoy his generous love. For if when he was here he loved people so much that when he had the choice of departing and being with Christ, he chose to be here, how much more will he there display a warmer affection. I love Rome even for this, although indeed one has other grounds for praising it, both for its greatness and its antiquity and its beauty and its populousness and for its power and its wealth and for its successes in war. But I let all this pass and esteem it blessed on this account, that both in his lifetime he wrote to them and loved them so and talked with them while he was with us, and brought his life to a close there. Therefore the city is more notable on this ground than upon all others together. And like a body great and strong, it has as two gleaming eyes the bodies of these saints. Not so bright is the heaven when the sun sends forth his rays as is the city of Rome, sending out these two lights into all parts of the world. From there Paul will be caught up, from there Peter. Just think and shudder at the thought of what a sight Rome will see when Paul arises suddenly from that deposit, together with Peter, and is lifted up to meet the Lord. What a rose will Rome send up to Christ! What two crowns will the city have about it! What golden chains will she be girded with! What fountains possess! Therefore I admire the city, not for the much gold, not for the columns, not for the other display there, but for these pillars of the Church. Would that it were now given me to throw myself around the body of Paul and be riveted to the tomb, and to see the dust of that body that filled up that which was lacking after Christ, that bore the marks, that sowed the Gospel everywhere—yes, the dust of that body through which he ran to and fro everywhere! The dust of that body through which Christ spoke and the Light shone forth more brilliant than any lightning, and the voice started out more awful than any thunder to the devils! Through which he uttered that blessed voice, saying, I could wish that myself were accursed for my brethren, through which he spoke before kings and was not ashamed! Through which we come to know Paul, through which also Paul's Master! Not so awful to us is the thunder as was that voice to the demons! For if they shuddered at his clothes, much more did they at his voice. This led them away captive, this cleansed out the world, this put a stop to diseases, cast out vice, lifted the truth on high, had Christ riding upon it, and everywhere went about with Him; and what the Cherubim were, this was Paul's voice, for as He was seated upon those Powers, so was He upon Paul's tongue. For it had become worthy of receiving Christ by speaking those things only which were acceptable to Christ and flying as the Seraphim to unspeakable height! For what is more lofty than that voice which says, For I am persuaded that neither Angels, nor Principalities, nor Powers, nor things present, nor things to come, nor height, nor depth, nor any other creature, shall be able to separate us from the love of God, which is in Christ Jesus? What wings does this discourse not seem to you to have? What eyes? It was owing to this that he said, for we are not ignorant of his devices. Owing to this the devils fled not only at hearing him speak but even at seeing his garments. This is the mouth, the dust of which I would gladly see, through which Christ spoke the great and secret things, and greater than in His own person—for as He worked, so He also spoke greater things by the disciples—through which the Spirit gave those wondrous oracles to the world! For what good thing did not that mouth accomplish? Devils it drove out, sins it loosed, tyrants it muzzled, philosophers' mouths it stopped, the world it brought over to God, savages it persuaded to learn wisdom, all the whole order of the earth it altered. Things in Heaven too it arranged as it pleased, binding whom it would and loosing in the other world according to the power given to it. Nor is it that mouth only, but the heart too I would gladly see the dust of, which a man would not do wrong to call the heart of the world and a fountain of countless blessings and a beginning and element of our life. For the spirit of life was furnished out of it all and was distributed through the members of Christ, not as being sent forth by arteries but by a free choice of good deeds. This heart was so large as to take in entire cities and peoples and nations. For my heart, he says, is enlarged. Yet even a heart thus large, this very charity that enlarged it many a time straitened and oppressed. For he says, Out of much affliction and anguish of heart I wrote to you. I would be desirous to see that heart even after its dissolution, which burned at each one that was lost, which travailed a second time with the children that had proved abortions, which saw God—for the pure in heart, He says, shall see God—which became a sacrifice—for a sacrifice to God is a contrite heart—which was loftier than the heavens, which was wider than the world, which was brighter than the sun's beam, which was warmer than fire, which was stronger than adamant, which sent forth rivers—for rivers, it says, of living water shall flow out of his belly—wherein was a fountain springing up and watering not the face of the earth but the souls of men, whence not rivers only but even fountains of tears issued day and night, which lived the new life, not this one of ours—for I live, he says, yet not I, but Christ lives in me, so Paul's heart was His heart, and a tablet of the Holy Spirit and a book of grace—which trembled for the sins of others—for I fear, he says, lest by any means I have bestowed labor upon you in vain; lest as the serpent beguiled Eve; lest when I come I should find you not such as I would—which both feared for itself and was confident too—for I fear, he says, lest by any means after having preached to others I myself should be a castaway, And, I am persuaded that neither angels nor powers shall be able to separate us—which was counted worthy to love Christ as no other man loved Him; which despised death and hell, yet was broken down by brothers' tears—for he says, what do you mean to weep and to break my heart?—which was most enduring and yet could not bear to be absent from the Thessalonians by the space of an hour! I would gladly see the dust of hands that were in a chain, through the imposition of which the Spirit was furnished, through which the divine writings were written—for behold how large a letter I have written to you with my own hand, and again, The salutation of me Paul with my own hand—of those hands at the sight of which the serpent fell off into the fire. I would gladly see the dust of those eyes which were blinded gloriously, which recovered their sight again for the salvation of the world, which even in the body were counted worthy to see Christ, which saw earthly things yet saw them not, which saw the things which are not seen, which saw not sleep, which were watchful at midnight, which were not affected as eyes are. I would also see the dust of those feet which ran through the world and were not weary, which were bound in the stocks when the prison shook, which went through parts habitable or uninhabited, which walked on so many journeys. And why need I speak of single parts? I would gladly see the tomb where the armor of righteousness is laid up, the armor of light, the limbs which now live but which in life were made dead, and in all of which Christ lived, which were crucified to the world, which were Christ's members, which were clad in Christ, were a temple of the Spirit, a holy building, bound in the Spirit, riveted to the fear of God, which had the marks of Christ. This body is a wall to that city, which is safer than all towers and than thousands of battlements. And with it is that of Peter. For he honored him while alive. For he went up to see Peter, and therefore even when departed grace deigned to give him the same dwelling place with him. I would gladly see the spiritual lion. For as a lion breathing forth fire upon the herds of foxes, so he rushed upon the clan of demons and philosophers, and like the burst of

Who is there then to pray over us, since Paul has departed? These who are the imitators of Paul. Only let us yield ourselves worthy of such intercession ( συνηγορίας), that it may not be that we hear Paul's voice here only, but that hereafter, when we are departed, we may be counted worthy to see the wrestler of Christ. Or rather, if we hear him here, we shall certainly see him hereafter, if not as standing near him, yet see him we certainly shall, glistening near the Throne of the king. Where the Cherubim sing the glory, where the Seraphim are flying, there shall we see Paul, with Peter, and as a chief and leader of the choir of the Saints, and shall enjoy his generous love. For if when here he loved men so, that when he had the choice of departing and being with Christ, he chose to be here, much more will he there display a warmer affection. I love Rome even for this, although indeed one has other grounds for praising it, both for its greatness, and its antiquity, and its beauty, and its populousness, and for its power, and its wealth, and for its successes in war. But I let all this pass, and esteem it blessed on this account, that both in his lifetime he wrote to them, and loved them so, and talked with them whiles he was with us, and brought his life to a close there. Wherefore the city is more notable upon this ground, than upon all others together. And as a body great and strong, it has as two glistening eyes the bodies of these Saints. Not so bright is the heaven, when the sun sends forth his rays, as is the city of Rome, sending out these two lights into all parts of the world. From thence will Paul be caught up, from thence Peter. Just bethink you, and shudder ( φρίξατε) at the thought of what a sight Rome will see, when Paul arises suddenly from that deposit, together with Peter, and is lifted up to meet the Lord. 1 Thessalonians 4:17 What a rose will Rome send up to Christ! Isaiah 35:1 what two crowns will the city have about it! What golden chains will she be girded with! What fountains possess! Therefore I admire the city, not for the much gold, not for the columns, not for the other display there, but for these pillars of the Church. 1 Corinthians 15:38 Would that it were now given me to throw myself round ( περιχυθἥναι) the body of Paul, and be riveted to the tomb, and to see the dust of that body that filled up that which was lacking after Christ Colossians 1:24, that bore the marks ( στίγματα,) Galatians 6:17 that sowed the Gospel everywhere yea, the dust of that body through which he ran to and fro everywhere! The dust of that body through which Christ spoke, and the Light shone forth more brilliant than any lightning, and the voice started out, more awful than any thunder to the devils! Through which he uttered that blessed voice, saying, I could wish that myself were accursed, for my brethren Romans 9:3, through which he spoke before kings, and was not ashamed! Psalm 119:46 through which we come to know Paul through which also Paul's Master! Not so awful to us is the thunder, as was that voice to the demons! For if they shuddered at his clothes Acts 19:12, much more did they at his voice. This led them away captive, this cleansed out the world, this put a stop to diseases, cast out vice, lifted the truth on high, had Christ riding upon it, and everywhere went about with Him; and what the Cherubim were, this was Paul's voice, for as He was seated upon those Powers, so was He upon Paul's tongue. For it had become worthy of receiving Christ, by speaking those things only which were acceptable to Christ, and flying as the Seraphim to height unspeakable! For what more lofty than that voice which says, For I am persuaded that neither Angels, nor Principalities, nor Powers, nor things present, nor things to come, nor height, nor depth, nor any other creature, shall be able to separate us from the love of God, which is in Christ Jesus? Romans 8:38-39 What pinions does not this discourse seem to you to have? What eyes? Ezekiel 10:12 It was owing to this that he said, for we are not ignorant of his devices. 2 Corinthians 2:11 Owing to this did the devils flee not only at hearing him speak, but even at seeing his garments. This is the mouth, the dust whereof I would fain see, through which Christ spoke the great and secret things, and greater than in His own person, (for as He wrought, so He also spoke greater things by the disciples,) through which the Spirit gave those wondrous oracles to the world! For what good thing did not that mouth effect? Devils it drove out, sins it loosed, tyrants it muzzled, philosophers' mouths it stopped, the world it brought over to God, savages it persuaded to learn wisdom, all the whole order of the earth it altered. Things in Heaven too it disposed what way it listed 1 Corinthians 5:3-4, binding whom it would, and loosing in the other world, according unto the power given unto it. 2 Corinthians 13:10 Nor is it that mouth only, but the heart too would fain see the dust of, which a man would not do wrong to call the heart of the world, and a fountain of countless blessings, and a beginning, and element of our life. For the spirit of life was furnished out of it all, and was distributed through the members of Christ, not as being sent forth by arteries, but by a free choice of good deeds. This heart was so large, as to take in entire cities, and peoples, and nations. For my heart he says, is enlarged. 2 Corinthians 6:11 Yet even a heart thus large, did this very charity that enlarged it many a time straiten and oppress. For he says, Out of much affliction ( θλίψεως) and anguish ( συνοχἥς) of heart I wrote to you. 2 Corinthians 2:4 I were desirous to see that heart even after its dissolution, which burned at each one that was lost, which travailed a second time with the children that had proved abortions Galatians 4:19, which saw God, ( for the pure in heart, He says, shall see God,) Matthew 5:8 which became a Sacrifice, ( for a sacrifice to God is a contrite heart,) Psalm 51:17 which was loftier than the heavens, which was wider than the world, which was brighter than the sun's beam, which was warmer than fire, which was stronger than adamant, which sent forth rivers, ( for rivers, it says, of living water shall flow out of his belly,) John 7:38 wherein was a fountain springing up, and watering, not the face of the earth, but the souls of men, whence not rivers only, but even fountains of tears, issued day and night, which lived the new life, not this of ours, (for I live, he says, yet not I, but Christ lives in me, Galatians 2:20 so Paul's heart was His heart, and a tablet of the Holy Spirit, and a book of grace); which trembled for the sins of others, (for I fear, he says, lest by any means I have bestowed labor upon you in vain; Galatians 4:11 lest as the serpent beguiled Eve; 2 Corinthians 11:3 lest when I come I should find you not such as I would;) 2 Corinthians 12:20 which both feared for itself, and was confiding too, (for I fear, he says, lest by any means after having preached to others I myself should be a castaway, 1 Corinthians 9:27 And, I am persuaded that neither angels nor powers shall be able to separate us;) alluding to Romans 9:3 which was counted worthy to love Christ as no other man loved Him: which despised death and hell, yet was broken down by brothers' tears, (for he says, what mean ye to weep and to break mine heart?) Acts 21:13 which was most enduring, and yet could not bear to be absent from the Thessalonians by the space of an hour! 1 Thessalonians 2:17; 3:10 Fain would I see the dust of hands that were in a chain, through the imposition of which the Spirit was furnished, through which the divine writings were written, (for behold how large a letter I have written unto you with my own hand: and again, The salutation of me Paul with my own hand,) 1 Corinthians 16:21 of those hands at the sight of which the serpent fell off into the fire. Acts 28:5 Fain would I see the dust of those eyes which were blinded gloriously, which recovered their sight again for the salvation of the world; which even in the body were counted worthy to see Christ, which saw earthly things, yet saw them not, which saw the things which are not seen, which saw not sleep, which were watchful at midnight, which were not effected as eyes are. I would also see the dust of those feet, which ran through the world and were not weary; which were bound in the stocks when the prison shook, which went through parts habitable or uninhabited, which walked on so many journeys. And why need I speak of single parts? Fain would I see the tomb, where the armor of righteousness is laid up, the armor of light, the limbs which now live, but which in life were made dead; and in all whereof Christ lived, which were crucified to the world, which were Christ's members, which were clad in Christ, were a temple of the Spirit, an holy building, bound in the Spirit, Acts 20:22 riveted to the fear of God, which had the marks of Christ. This body is a wall to that City, which is safer than all towers, and than thousands of battlements. And with it is that of Peter. For he honored him while alive. For he went up to see Peter, Galatians 1:18 and therefore even when departed grace deigned to give him the same abode with him. Fain would I see the spiritual Lion. For as a lion breathing (Gr. sending,) Canticles 2:15 forth fire ( πὕρ ἀφιεὶς) upon the herds of foxes, so rushed he upon the clan of demons and philosophers, and as the burst of some thunderbolt, was borne down into the host of the devil. Luke 13:32 For he did not even come to set the battle in array against him, since he feared so and trembled at him, as that if he saw his shadow, and heard his voice, he fled even at a distance. And so did he deliver over to him the fornicator, though at a distance, and again snatched him out of his hands 1 Corinthians 5:5; 2 Corinthians 2:7-11; and so others also, that they might be taught not to blaspheme. 1 Timothy 1:20 And consider how he sent forth his own liegemen against him, rousing them, suppling them. And at one time he says to the Ephesians, We wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities and powers. Ephesians 6:12 Then too he puts our prize in heavenly places. For we struggle not for things of the earth, he says, but for Heaven, and the things in the Heavens. And to others, he says, Do you not know that we shall judge Angels? How much more the things of this life? 1 Corinthians 6:3 Let us then, laying all this to heart, stand nobly; for Paul was a man, partaking of the same nature with us, and having everything else in common with us. But because he showed such great love toward Christ, he went up above the Heavens, and stood with the Angels. And so if we too would rouse ourselves up some little, and kindle in ourselves that fire, we shall be able to emulate that holy man. For were this impossible, he would never have cried aloud, and said, Be imitators of me, as I am of Christ. 1 Corinthians 11:1 Let us not then admire him only, or be struck with him only, but imitate him, that we too may, when we depart hence, be counted worthy to see him, and to share the glory unutterable, which God grant that we may all attain to by the grace and love toward man of our Lord Jesus Christ, through Whom, and with Whom, be glory to the Father, with the Holy Ghost, now and evermore. Amen.


Homilies on the Epistle to the Romans — Homily 31 — Romans 16:5

Homily 31 of 32 on St. Paul’s Epistle to the Romans.

Source: Translated by J. Walker, J. Sheppard and H. Browne, and revised by George B. Stevens. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 11. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/210231.htm>.

Opening

Romans 16:5

Rom. XVI. 5

Greet my beloved Epenetus, who is the firstfruits of Achaia for Christ.

Salute my well-beloved Epenetus, who is the first-fruits of Achaia unto Christ.

I believe that many people, even those who seem to be extremely good, rush past this section of the Epistle as if it were unnecessary and carried little weight. I think the same thing happens to them with the genealogy in the Gospel. Because it is a list of names, they assume they cannot gain much benefit from it. Yet gold refiners are careful even about tiny fragments, while these people pass over such large pieces of gold. To prevent this from happening to them, what I have already said should be enough to shake them from their laziness. We have already shown from previous discussions that the benefit even from this section is not insignificant, when we lifted up your soul through those addresses. So today we will try to mine in this same place again. It is possible to find a great treasure even from bare names. If, for example, you were shown why Abraham was so called, why Sarah, why Israel, why Samuel, you would discover from this many real subjects worth investigating. You can gather the same advantage from times and places as well. The good person becomes rich even from these things, but the lazy person does not gain anything even from the most obvious matters. The very name of Adam teaches us considerable wisdom, as do the names of his son, his wife, and most of the others. Names serve to remind us of many circumstances. They reveal at once God's blessings and women's thankfulness, for when they conceived by God's gift, it was the women who gave these names to the children. But why are we now reflecting on names when so many important meanings are being neglected, and many people do not even know the names of the sacred books themselves? Still, we ought not to withdraw from paying attention to matters like this. For "you ought," He says, "to have put My money to the exchangers." Therefore, even if no one listens, let us do our part and demonstrate that there is nothing superfluous, nothing added randomly in the Scriptures. If these names served no purpose, they would not have been added to the Epistle, nor would Paul have written what he wrote. But some people are so small-minded, empty, and unworthy of Heaven that they think not only names but whole books of the Bible are useless—like Leviticus, Joshua, and others. In this way many simple-minded people have been led to reject the Old Testament, and advancing further along this evil path, they have likewise cut away many parts of the New Testament as well. But we do not pay much attention to these people, who are intoxicated and living for the flesh. However, if anyone loves wisdom and enjoys spiritual instruction, let him be told that even the things that seem unimportant in Scripture are not placed there randomly or without purpose, and that even the old laws have much to teach us. For it says, "All these things are types and are written for our instruction." This is why Paul also says to Timothy, "Give heed to reading, to exhortation," urging him to read the old books, even though Timothy had such great spiritual power that he could drive out demons and raise the dead. Now let us continue with the subject at hand. "Salute my well-beloved Epenetus." It is worth learning from this how Paul distributes different praises to each person. This praise is no small thing but is actually very great, and proof of great excellence in Epenetus—that Paul should consider him beloved, Paul who never loved out of favoritism but only by sound judgment. Then comes another commendation: "Who is the first-fruits of Achaia." What he means is either that Epenetus leaped forward before anyone else and became a believer (which would be no small praise), or that he displayed more godly behavior than anyone else. That is why, after saying "who is the first-fruits of Achaia," Paul does not stop there but, to prevent you from thinking this is worldly glory, adds "unto Christ." Now if in civil matters the person who is first seems great and honorable, how much more so in these matters. Since they were likely of humble origin, Paul speaks of the true noble birth and preeminence, giving Epenetus his honors from this. Paul says he is the first-fruits not only of Corinth but of the whole nation, as if he had become a door and entrance for the rest. The reward for such a person is not small, for he will receive much recompense from the achievements of others as well, since he contributed much toward them by being first.

I think that many even of those who have the appearance of being extremely good men, hasten over this part of the Epistle as superfluous, and having no great weight in it. And I think that the same befalls them in regard to the genealogy that is in the Gospel. For because it is a catalogue of names, they think they cannot get any great good from it. Yet the gold founders' people are careful even about the little fragments; while these pass over even such great cakes of gold. That this then may not befall them, what I have already said were enough to lead them off from their listlessness. For that the gain even from this is no contemptible one, we have shown even from what was said on a former occasion, when we lifted up your soul by means of these addresses. We will endeavor then today also to mine in this same place. For it is possible even from bare names to find a great treasure. If, for instance, you were shown why Abraham was so called, why Sarah, why Israel, why Samuel, you would find even from this a great many real subjects of research. And from times too, and from places, you may gather the same advantage. For the good man waxes rich even from these; but he that is slothful, does not gain even from the most evident things. Thus the very name of Adam teaches us no small wisdom, and that of his son, and of his wife, and most of the others. For names serve to remind us of several circumstances. They show at once God's benefits and women's thankfulness. For when they conceived by the gift of God, it was they who gave these names to the children. But why are we now philosophizing about names, while meanings so important are neglected, and many do not so much as know the very names of the sacred books? Still even then we ought not to recede from an attention to things of this sort. For you ought, He says, to have put My money to the exchangers. Matthew 25:27 And therefore though there be nobody that listens to it, let us do our part, and show that there is nothing superfluous, nothing added at random in the Scriptures. For if these names had no use, they would not then have been added to the Epistle, nor would Paul have written what he has written. But there are some even so low-minded, and empty, and unworthy of Heaven, as not to think that names only, but whole books of the Bible are of no use, as Leviticus, Joshua, and more besides. And in this way many of the simple ones have been for rejecting the Old Testament, and advancing on in the way, that results from this evil habit of mind, have likewise pruned away many parts of the New Testament also. But of these men, as intoxicated and living to the flesh, we do not make much account. But if any be a lover of wisdom, and a friend to spiritual entertainments, let him be told that even the things which seem to be unimportant in Scripture, are not placed there at random and to no purpose, and that even the old laws have much to profit us. For it says, All these things are types (A.V. ensamples) and are written for our instruction. 1 Corinthians 10:11 Wherefore to Timothy too he says, Give heed to reading, to exhortation 1 Timothy 4:13, so urging him to the reading of the old books, though he was a man with so great a spirit in him, as to be able to drive out devils, and to raise the dead. Let us now keep on with the subject in hand. Salute my well-beloved Epenetus. It is worth learning from this how he distributes to each the different praises. For this praise is no slight one, but even very great, and a proof of great excellence in him, that Paul should hold him beloved, Paul who had no idea of loving by favor, and not by cool judgment. Then another encomium comes, Who is the first-fruits of Achaia. For what he means is, either that he leaped forward before any one else, and became a believer (and this were no slight praise), or that he displayed more religious behavior than any other. And on this account after saying, who is the first-fruits of Achaia, he does not hold his peace, but to prevent your suspecting it to be a glory of the world's, he added, unto Christ. Now if in civil matters, he that is first seems to be great and honorable, much more so in these. As then it was likely that they were of low extraction, he speaks of the true noble birth and preëminency, and gives him his honors from this. And he says, that he is the first-fruits, not of Corinth only, but of the whole nation, as having become as it were a door, and an entrance to the rest. And to such, the reward is no small one. For such an one will reap much recompense also from the achievements of others, in that he too contributed much toward them by beginning.

Verse 6. Greet Mary, who worked very hard for us.

Ver. 6. Greet Mary, who bestowed much labor on us.

How is this? A woman is honored and proclaimed victorious again! Again we men are put to shame. Or rather, we are not just put to shame, but even have an honor conferred upon us. For it is an honor that there are such women among us, but we are put to shame because we men are left so far behind by them. But if we understand where their adornment comes from, we too can quickly catch up to them. Where then does their adornment come from? Let both men and women listen. It does not come from bracelets or necklaces, nor from their eunuchs, maidservants, and gold-embroidered dresses, but from their labors on behalf of the truth. For he says she bestowed much labor on us—that is, not only on herself or her own advancement (for many women today do this by fasting and sleeping on the floor), but also on others, thus running the same race that Apostles and Evangelists ran. In what sense then does he say, "I do not permit a woman to teach"? He means to prevent her from coming forward publicly and from the seat on the bema, not from the word of teaching. For if this were the case, how could he have said to the woman who had an unbelieving husband, "How do you know, O woman, if you will save your husband?" Or how could he allow her to instruct children, when he says, "but she will be saved through childbearing if they continue in faith, love, and holiness, with self-control"? How did Priscilla come to instruct even Apollos? It was not then to cut off private conversation for edification that he said this, but rather what is given before all in the public assembly, which it is the teacher's duty to give; or again, in case the husband is a believer and thoroughly equipped, able also to instruct her. When she is the wiser, then he does not forbid her from teaching and improving him. And he does not say "who taught much," but "who bestowed much labor," because along with teaching she performed other ministries besides—those involving dangers, money, and travels. For the women of those days were more spirited than lions, sharing with the Apostles their labors for the Gospel's sake. In this way they traveled with them and also performed all other ministries. And even in Christ's day, women followed Him who ministered to Him from their resources and waited upon the Teacher.

How is this? A woman again is honored and proclaimed victorious! Again are we men put to shame. Or rather, we are not put to shame only, but have even an honor conferred upon us. For an honor we have, in that there are such women among us, but we are put to shame, in that we men are left so far behind by them. But if we come to know whence it comes, that they are so adorned, we too shall speedily overtake them. Whence then is their adorning? Let both men and women listen. It is not from bracelets, or from necklaces, nor from their eunuchs either, and their maid-servants, and gold-broidered dresses, but from their toils in behalf of the truth. For he says, who bestowed much labor on us, that is, not on herself only, nor upon her own advancement, (see p. 520) (for this many women of the present day do, by fasting, and sleeping on the floor), but upon others also, so carrying on the race Apostles and Evangelists ran. In what sense then does he say, I suffer not a woman to teach? 1 Timothy 2:12 He means to hinder her from publicly coming forward 1 Corinthians 14:35, and from the seat on the bema, not from the word of teaching. Since if this were the case, how would he have said to the woman that had an unbelieving husband, How do you know, O woman, if you shall save your husband? 1 Corinthians 7:16 Or how came he to allow her to admonish children, when he says, but she shall be saved by child-bearing if they continue in faith, and charity, and holiness, with sobriety? 1 Timothy 2:15 How came Priscilla to instruct even Apollos? It was not then to cut in sunder private conversing for advantage that he said this, but that before all, and which it was the teacher's duty to give in the public assembly; or again, in case the husband be believing and thoroughly furnished, able also to instruct her. When she is the wiser, then he does not forbid her teaching and improving him. And he does not say, who taught much, but who bestowed much labor, because along with teaching ( τοὓ λόγου) she performs other ministries besides, those in the way of dangers, in the way of money, in the way of travels. For the women of those days were more spirited than lions, sharing with the Apostles their labors for the Gospel's sake. In this way they went travelling with them, and also performed all other ministries. And even in Christ's day there followed Him women, which ministered unto Him of their substance Luke 8:3, and waited upon the Teacher.

Greet Andronicus and Junia, my kinsmen.

Ver. 7. Salute Andronicus and Junia my kinsmen.

This also appears to be a statement of praise. What comes next is even more praiseworthy. And what kind of praise is this? "And my fellow-prisoners." This is the highest honor, a noble declaration. When was Paul a prisoner, that he could call them his fellow-prisoners? In fact, he had not been imprisoned, but he had suffered things worse than prisoners endure—being separated not only from his country and family, but also wrestling with hunger and constant threat of death, along with thousands of other hardships. A prisoner's only misfortune is being separated from relatives and often being enslaved rather than free. But in Paul's case, one could point to trials as numerous as snowflakes, which this blessed person endured by being carried about from place to place, whipped, chained, stoned, shipwrecked, with countless people plotting against him. Captives usually have no further enemy after being led away and actually receive considerable care from their captors. But this man was continually surrounded by enemies and saw spears on every side, along with sharpened swords, battle lines, and conflicts. Since these people likely shared many dangers with him, he calls them fellow-captives, just as in another passage he mentions "Aristarchus my fellow-prisoner." Then comes another praise besides this: "Who are of note among the Apostles." Indeed, to be apostles at all is a great thing. But to be especially distinguished even among the apostles—just consider what a magnificent praise this is! They were distinguished because of their works and their accomplishments. Oh, how great is the philosophia of this woman, that she should even be considered worthy of the title of apostle! But he does not stop even here; he adds yet another praise, saying, "Who were also in Christ before me."

This also looks like an encomium. And what follows is much more so. And what sort is this of? And my fellow-prisoners. For this is the greatest honor, the noble proclamation. And where was Paul a prisoner, that he should call them my fellow-prisoners? A prisoner indeed he had not been, but he had suffered things worse than prisoners, in being not an alien only to his country and his family, but in wrestling with famine and continual death, and thousands of other things. For of a prisoner the only misfortune is this, that he is separated from his relations, and often has to be a slave instead of being free. But in this case one may mention temptations thick as snow-flakes, which this blessed person underwent by being carried and taken about, scourged, fettered, stoned, shipwrecked, with countless people plotting against him. And captives indeed have no further foe after they are led away, but they even experience great care from those who have taken them. But this man was continually in the midst of enemies, and saw spears on every side, and sharpened swords, and arrays, and battles. Since then it was likely that these shared many dangers with him, he calls them fellow-captives. As in another passage also, Aristarchus my fellow-prisoner. Colossians 4:10 Then another praise besides. Who are of note among the Apostles. And indeed to be apostles at all is a great thing. But to be even among these of note, just consider what a great encomium this is! But they were of note owing to their works, to their achievements. Oh! How great is the devotion ( φιλοσοφία) of this woman, that she should be even counted worthy of the appellation of apostle! But even here he does not stop, but adds another encomium besides, and says, Who were also in Christ before me.

This too is high praise: that they came forward and arrived before others. But notice the holy soul, how free it is from vanity. For after achieving glory of this kind and degree, he places others ahead of himself and does not hide from us the fact that he came after them, nor is he ashamed to admit this. And why should you be surprised that he is not ashamed of this, when he does not even hesitate to display his former life before people, calling himself a blasphemer and a persecutor? 1 Timothy 1:13 Since he could not place them ahead of others on this basis, he considered himself, who had come in after others, and from this he found a way to give them praise by saying, Who were in Christ before me.

For this too is a very great praise, that they sprang forth and came before others. But let me draw your attention to the holy soul, how untainted it is by vanity. For after glory such as his in kind and degree, he sets others before himself, and does not hide from us the fact of his having come after them, nor is ashamed of confessing this. And why are you surprised at his not being ashamed of this, when he shuns not even to parade before men his former life, calling himself a blasphemer, and a persecutor? 1 Timothy 1:13 Since then he was not able to set them before others on this score, he looked out himself, who had come in after others, and from this he did find means of bestowing a praise upon them by saying, Who were in Christ before me.

Verse 8. Greet Amplias my beloved.

Ver. 8. Greet Amplias my beloved.

Here again he praises this person through his love. For Paul's love was directed toward God and brought countless blessings with it. For if being loved by a king is a great thing, what a great praise it must be to be beloved by Paul! For if Amplias had not acquired great virtue, he would not have attracted Paul's love. Since Paul is accustomed (οἶδε) not only to withhold his love from those who live in vice and transgressions, but even to anathematize them. As when he says, "If any man love not the Lord Jesus, let him be accursed" (1 Corinthians 16:22); and, "If any man preach any other gospel unto you than that you have received, let him be accursed" (Galatians 1:8).

Here again he passes encomiums upon his person by his love. For the love of Paul was for God, carrying countless blessings with it. For if being loved by the king is a great thing, what a great encomium must it be to be beloved by Paul? For if he had not acquired great virtue, he would not have attracted his love? Since as for those who live in vice and transgressions he is accustomed ( οἶδε) not only to abstain from loving them, but even to anathematize them. As when he says, If any man love not the Lord Jesus, let him be accursed 1 Corinthians 16:22; and, If any man preach any other gospel unto you than that you have received, let him be accursed. Galatians 1:8

Verse 9. Greet Urbanus, my fellow worker in the Lord.

Ver. 9. Salute Urbane, my helper in the Lord.

This is a higher praise than the previous one, for it actually includes that earlier praise as well. And Stachys, my beloved. This again is an honor of the same type.

This is a greater encomium than the other. For this even comprehends that. And Stachys, my beloved. This again is an honor of the same kind.

Verse 10. Greet Apelles, approved in Christ.

Ver. 10. Salute Apelles, approved in Christ.

There is no praise like this—being blameless and giving no opportunity for accusation in the things of God. For when he says "approved in Christ," he includes the whole catalog of virtues. And why does he nowhere say "my Lord so-and-so" or "my Master this person"? It is because these commendations were greater than those. For those are merely titles of rank (τιμἥς), but these are titles of virtue. And he paid them this same honor not randomly, or as if he were addressing people of lesser virtue with the same language as those of high and great character. For insofar as he is addressing them—and that too, one along with another in the same letter—he honors them all alike. But by stating the praises particular to each person, he sets before us the virtue peculiar to each. In this way he neither gives rise to envy by honoring one and dishonoring another, nor creates in them laziness and confusion by giving them all the same dignity when they did not deserve the same. See now how he again comes to the admirable women. For after saying, "Salute them which are of Aristobulus' household,"

There is no praise like this, being unblamable, and giving no handle in the things of God. For when he says, approved in Christ, he includes the whole list of virtues. And on what ground does he nowhere say my Lord such an one, my Master this? It is because these encomiums were greater than those. For those are mere titles of rank ( τιμἥς), but these are of virtue. And this same honor he paid them not at random, or as addressing several of inferior virtue with the high and great characters. For so far as he is addressing, and that too one along with another, and in the same letter, he honors them all alike. But by stating the praises particularly to each, he sets before us the virtue peculiar to each; so as neither to give birth to envy by honoring one and dishonoring another, nor to work in them listlessness and confusion, by giving them all the same dignity, though they did not deserve the same. See now how he again comes to the admirable women. For after saying, Salute them which are of Aristobulus' household,

Verse 11. Greet Herodion my kinsman; greet those who belong to the household of Narcissus.

Ver. 11. Salute Herodion my kinsman; greet them which be of the household of Narcissus;

It is likely that these people were not as distinguished as those mentioned earlier. For this reason, Paul does not even name them all individually. After giving them the praise that suited them—namely, that they were faithful (and this is the meaning of the phrase)—

Who, it is likely, were not so worthy as the afore-mentioned, on which account also he does not mention them all by name even, and after giving them the encomium which was suited to them, that of being faithful, (and this the meaning of,)

Which are in the Lord.

Which are in the Lord.

He returns again to the women and says,

He again reverts to the women, and says,

Verse 12. Greet Tryphena and Tryphosa, who work hard in the Lord.

Ver. 12. Salute Tryphena and Tryphosa, who labor in the Lord.

Regarding the earlier woman, he says she gave you her labor, but of these two he says they are still laboring. And this is no small praise, that they should be constantly at work, and not only work but labor as well. But he calls Persis beloved too, to show that she is greater than these.

And in regard to the former woman, he says that she bestowed labor upon you, but of these that they are still laboring. And this is no small encomium, that they should be in work throughout, and should not only work, but labor even. But Persis he calls beloved too, to show that she is greater than these.

For he says, "Salute my beloved Persis."

For he says, Salute my beloved Persis.

And he likewise testifies to her great labors, saying, "who labored much in the Lord."

And of her great laborings he likewise bears testimony, and says, which labored much in the Lord.

He knows exactly how to recognize each person according to their merits. By doing this, he makes these individuals more enthusiastic by not denying them any of what they are due, even commending the smallest superiority. At the same time, he makes the others more virtuous and spurs them on to the same zeal through his praises of these people.

So well does he know how to name each after his deserts, so making these more eager by not depriving them of any of their dues, but commending even the slightest preëminence, and making the others more virtuous, and inciting them to the same zeal, by his encomiums upon these.

Verse 12. Greet Rufus, chosen in the Lord, and his mother and mine.

Ver. 12. Salute Rufus, chosen in the Lord, and his mother and mine.

Here again the good things are without any drawback, since both the son and the mother are of such character, and the house is full of blessing, and the root agrees with the fruit. For Paul would not have simply said "his mother and mine" unless he had been testifying to the woman's great virtue.

Here again the good things are without any drawback, since the son and the mother are each of such a character, and the house is full of blessing, and the root agrees with the fruit; for he would not have simply said, his mother and mine, unless he had been bearing testimony to the woman for great virtue.

Verse 14. Greet Asyncritus, Phlegon, Hermas, Patrobas, Hermes, and the brothers who are with them.

Ver. 14. Salute Asyncritus, Phlegon, Hermas, Patrobas, Hermes, and the brethren which are with them.

Here don't focus on how he begins addressing them without any praise, but on how he did not consider them—though they appear to be far inferior to everyone else—unworthy of being addressed by him. Or rather, even this is no small praise, that he actually calls them brethren, just as he also calls those mentioned after them saints. For he says,

Here do not be looking to how he starts them without any encomium, but how he did not reckon them, though far inferior, as it seems, to all, unworthy of being addressed by him. Or rather even this is no slight praise that he even calls them brethren, as also those that are after them he calls saints. For he says,

Verse 15. Greet Philologus and Julius, Nereus and his sister, and Olympas, and all the saints who are with them.

Ver. 15. Salute Philologus, and Julius, and Nereus and his sister, and Olympas, and all the saints which are with them;

This was the highest honor and an indescribable height of dignity. Then, to prevent any jealousy from arising because he addressed one person in one way and another in a different way—naming some individually while mentioning others without distinction, praising some with many points and others with fewer—he once again brings them together in the equality of love and in the holy kiss, saying,

Which was the greatest dignity, and unspeakable height of honor. Then to prevent any jealousy rising from his addressing one in one way and another in another, and some by name and some with no distinction, and some with more points of praise, and some with fewer, he again mingles them in the equality of charity, and in the holy kiss, saying,

Greet one another with a holy kiss.

Ver. 16. Salute one another with an holy kiss.

To remove from them, through this greeting, all arguing that troubled them and all reasons for petty pride—so that neither the great might look down on the small, nor the small resent the greater—and so that arrogance and envy might be driven away even more, since this kiss calmed and made everyone equal. And so he not only tells them to greet one another in this way, but also sends them greetings from the Churches in the same manner. For he says, not this or that individual person greets you, but all of you together,

To cast out of them, by this salutation, all arguing that confused them, and all grounds for little pride; that neither the great might despise the little, nor the little grudge at the greater, but that haughtiness and envy might be more driven away, when this kiss soothed down and levelled every one. And therefore he not only bids them salute in this way, but sends in like manner to them the greeting from the Churches. For there salute you, he says, not this or that person individually, but all of you in common,

The churches of Christ.

The Churches of Christ.

You see that we gain no small benefits from these teachings, and what treasures we would have rushed past if we had not examined this part of the Epistle carefully, as far as we were able. So if there is anyone wise and spiritual, he will dive even deeper and find even more pearls. But since some have often asked why Paul addressed so many people in this Epistle, which he has not done in any other Epistle, we might say that it is because he had never yet seen the Romans that he does this. Yet someone may say, "Well, he had not seen the Colossians either, and yet he did not do anything like this." But these Romans were more distinguished than others, and had come there from other cities, to a safer and more royal city. Since they were living in a foreign land and needed much support for security, and some of them were his acquaintances, and some too had rendered him many important services, he rightly commends them by letter. For Paul's fame was then not small, but so great that even his sending them letters gave those who had the honor of receiving an Epistle from him much protection. For people not only respected him, but were even afraid of him. Had this not been so, he would not have said, "who has been a helper of many, and of myself also" (Romans 16:2). And again, "I could wish that I myself were accursed" (Romans 9:3). And to Philemon he wrote and said, "as Paul the aged, and a prisoner of Jesus Christ" (Philemon 9). And to the Galatians, "Behold, I Paul say to you" (Galatians 5:2). And, "You received me as Jesus Christ" (Galatians 4:14). And writing to the Corinthians he said, "Now some are puffed up, as though I would not come to you" (1 Corinthians 4:18). And again, "These things I have figuratively applied to myself and to Apollos, that you might learn in us not to think of men above what is written" (1 Corinthians 4:6). Now from all these passages it is clear that everyone had a high opinion of him. Wishing then that they should feel at ease and be honored, he addressed each of them, setting forth their praise in the best way he could. For one he calls beloved, another kinsman, another both, another fellow-prisoner, another fellow-worker, another approved, another elect. And of the women, one he addresses by her office, for he does not call her servant of the Church in an undefined way (because if this were so he would have given Tryphena and Persis this title too), but this one as having the office of deaconess, and another as helper and assistant, another as mother, another for the labors she underwent, and some he addresses by the household they belonged to, some by the name of brothers, some by the title of saints. And some he honors by the mere fact of addressing them, and some by addressing them by name, and some by calling them first-fruits, and some by their precedence in time, but more than all, Priscilla and Aquila. For even if all were believers, still all were not alike, but were different in their merits. Therefore to lead them all to greater zeal, he keeps no one's commendations concealed. For when those who labor more do not receive the greater reward also, many become more careless. On this ground even in the kingdom, the honors are not equal, nor among the disciples were all alike, but the three were preeminent above the rest. And among these three again there was a great difference. For this is a very exact method observed by God even to the last. Hence, "one star differs from another star in glory" (1 Corinthians 15:41), it says. And yet all were Apostles and all are to sit on twelve thrones, and all left their possessions, and all accompanied Him; still it was the three He took. And again, to these very three, He said it was possible that some might even be superior. "For to sit," He says, "on My right hand and on My left, is not Mine to give, except to those for whom it is prepared" (Mark 10:40). And He sets Peter before them, when He says, "Do you love Me more than these?" (John 21:15). And John too was loved even above the rest. For there shall be a strict examination of all, and if you are but a little better than your neighbor, if it is even an atom or anything ever so little, God will not overlook even this. And this even from ancient times one might see made clear. For even Lot was a righteous man, yet not so much as Abraham; and Hezekiah again, yet not so much as David; and all the prophets, yet not so much as John.

You see that they are no small gains that we earn from these addresses, and what treasures we should have passed hastily over, unless in this part of the Epistle also we had examined it with accuracy, such, I mean, as was in our power. So if there be found any man of wisdom and spiritual, he will dive even deeper, and find a greater number of pearls. But since some have often made it a question wherefore it was that in this Epistle he addressed so many, which thing he has not done in any other Epistle, we might say that it is owing to his never having seen the Romans yet, that he does this. And yet one may say, Well, he had not seen the Colossians either, and yet he did not do anything of the kind. But these were more honorable than others, and had come there from other cities, as to a safer and more royal city. Since then they were living in a foreign country, and they needed much provision for security, and some of them were of his acquaintance, but some too were there who had rendered him many important services, he with reason commends them by letters; for the glory of Paul was then not little, but so great, that even from his sending them letters, those who had the happiness to have an Epistle to them, gained much protection. For men not only reverenced him, but were even afraid of him. Had this not been so, he would not have said, who had been a succorer of many, and of myself also. Romans 16:2 And again, I could wish that myself were accursed. Romans 9:3 And to Philemon he wrote and said, as Paul the aged, and a prisoner of Jesus Christ. Philippians 9 And to the Galatians, Behold, I Paul say unto you. Galatians 5:2 And, You received me even as Jesus Christ. Galatians 4:14 And writing to the Corinthians he said, Now some are puffed up, as though I would not come unto you. 1 Corinthians 4:18 And again, These things I have in a figure transferred to myself and to Apollos, that you might learn in us not to think of men above that which is written. 1 Corinthians 4:6 Now from all these passages it is clear that all had a great opinion of him. Wishing then that they should feel on easy terms, and be in honor, he addressed each of them, setting forth their praise to the best advantage he might. For one he calls beloved, another kinsman, another both, another fellow-prisoner, another fellow-worker, another approved, another elect. And of the women one he addresses by her title, for he does not call her servant of the Church in an undefined way (because if this were so he would have given Tryphena and Persis this name too), but this one as having the office of deaconess, and another as helper and assistant, another as mother, another from the labors she underwent, and some he addresses from the house they belonged to, some by the name of Brethren, some by the appellation of Saints. And some he honors by the mere fact of addressing them, and some by addressing them by name, and some by calling them first-fruits, and some by their precedence in time, but more than all, Priscilla and Aquila. ( τοὺς περὶ Πρ. κ. ̓Α.) For even if all were believers, still all were not alike, but were different in their merits. Wherefore to lead them all to greater emulation, he keeps no man's encomiums concealed. For when they who labor more, do not receive the greater reward also, many become more listless. On this ground even in the kingdom, the honors are not equal, nor among the disciples were all alike, but the three were preëminent above the rest. And among these three again there was a great difference. For this is a very exact method observed by God even to the last. Hence, one star differs from another star in glory, 1 Corinthians 15:41, it says. And yet all were Apostles and all are to sit on twelve thrones, and all left their goods, and all companied with Him; still it was the three He took. And again, to these very three, He said it was possible ( ἐ γχωρεῖν) that some might even be superior. For to sit, He says, on My right hand and on My left, is not mine to give, save to those for whom it is prepared. Mark 10:40 And He sets Peter before them, when He says, Lovest thou Me more than these? John 21:15 And John too was loved even above the rest. For there shall be a strict examination of all, and if you be but little better than your neighbor, if it be even an atom, or anything ever so little, God will not overlook even this. And this even from of old one might see coming out. For even Lot was a righteous man, yet not so, as was Abraham; and Hezekiah again, yet not so as was David: and all the prophets, yet not so as was John.

Given the care with which these matters are presented, where then are those who refuse to accept that there is a hell? For if all the righteous will not enjoy the same destiny, if they surpass one another even slightly (for one star, it says, differs from another star in glory), how could sinners share the same fate as the righteous? Even a human being would not create such confusion, much less God! But if you wish, I will show you that even in the case of sinners, judging from observable facts, there is this distinction and precise judgment. Consider this: Adam sinned and Eve sinned, and both transgressed, yet they were not equally guilty. Therefore neither were they equally punished. The difference was so great that Paul said, "Adam was not deceived, but the woman being deceived fell into transgression." Yet the deception was one and the same. Still, God's thorough examination revealed a difference so great that Paul made this statement. Again, Cain was punished, but Lamech, who committed murder after him, did not suffer nearly so severe a punishment. Yet both acts were murder, and Lamech's was worse because even the example before him had not made him better. But since Lamech did not kill his brother after receiving a warning, did not need an accuser, and did not shrink from answering when God questioned him, but even without any accuser pleaded against himself and condemned himself more severely, he obtained pardon. But Cain, having done the opposite, was punished. See with what precision God examines the facts. For this reason He punished those in the flood one way and those in Sodom another, and the Israelites again—both those in Babylon and those in Antiochus' time—in different ways, thus showing that He keeps a strict account of our actions. Some were slaves for seventy years and others for four hundred, but others ate their children and underwent countless other more grievous calamities, and even in this way were not freed, neither they nor those who were burned alive in Sodom. For it shall be more tolerable, He says, for the land of Sodom and Gomorrah than for that city. For if He has no care for us, either when we sin or when we do right, perhaps there would be some reason in saying that there is no punishment. But since He is so extremely concerned about our not sinning and uses so many means to keep us on the right path, it is very clear that He punishes the wicked and also crowns those who do right. But let me ask you to consider the inconsistency of most people. For they complain against God because in His great patience He overlooks so many who are impious, impure, or violent, without punishing them now. Again, if He threatens to punish them in the next world, they are fierce and insistent in their accusations. Yet if this is troubling to them, they ought to accept and admire the former. But what folly! What an unreasonable and senseless attitude! What a sin-loving soul that longs after vice! For it is from this that all these opinions originate. And so if those who say these things would resolve to pursue virtue, they will immediately find themselves satisfied concerning hell also and will not doubt. And where, it is asked, and in what place is this hell? For some storytellers say that it is in the valley of Jehoshaphat, thus taking what was said about a certain past war and applying it to hell. But Scripture does not say this. But in what place, I ask, will it be? Somewhere, I think at least, entirely outside the bounds of this world. For just as prisons and mines are at a great distance from royal residences, so hell will be somewhere outside this world. Let us not seek to know where it is, but how we may escape it. Nor should we disbelieve in things to come simply because God does not punish everyone here. For He is merciful and patient—that is why He threatens and does not immediately cast us into it. For I desire not, He says, the death of a sinner. But if there is no death of a sinner, the words are meaningless. And I know indeed that there is nothing less pleasant to you than these words. But to me nothing is more pleasant. And I wish it were possible at our dinner, our supper, our baths, and everywhere to be talking about hell. For we would not then feel the pain of the evils in this world, nor the pleasure of its good things. For what would you tell me is an evil? Poverty? Disease? Captivity? Physical disability? Why, all these things are trivial compared to the punishment there, even if you speak of those who are tormented with hunger all their lives, or those who are disabled from their earliest days and beg—even this is luxury compared to those other evils. Let us then continually occupy ourselves with talking about these things. For to remember hell prevents our falling into hell. Do you not hear Saint Paul saying, "Who shall suffer everlasting punishment from the face of the Lord"? Do you not hear what Nero's character was, whom Paul even calls the Mystery of Antichrist? For "the mystery of iniquity," he says, "already works." What then? Is Nero to suffer nothing? Is Antichrist to suffer nothing? Or the Devil nothing? Then he will always be Antichrist, and so will the Devil. For they will not cease from evil unless they are punished. Yes, you say, but that there is a hell everyone sees. But only the unbelievers will fall into it. What is the reason, I ask? It is because the believers acknowledge their Master. And what does this matter? When their life is impure, they will on this ground be punished more severely than the unbelievers. For "as many as have sinned without law shall also perish without law, but as many as have sinned in the law shall be judged by the law." And "The servant who knew his master's will and did it not shall be beaten with many stripes." But if there is no such thing as giving an account of one's life, and all this is said carelessly, then neither will the Devil have vengeance taken upon him. For he too knows God, and far more than men do, and all the demons know Him and tremble and acknowledge that He is their Judge. If then there is no giving an account of our life, nor of evil deeds, then they too will completely escape. These things are not so, surely they are not! Do not deceive yourselves, beloved. For if there is no hell, how will the Apostles judge the twelve tribes of Israel? How does Paul say, "Do you not know that we shall judge angels? How much more things of this life"? How did Christ say, "The men of Nineveh shall arise and condemn this generation," and "It shall be more tolerable for the land of Sodom in the day of judgment"? Why then make light of things that are no laughing matter? Why deceive yourself and cheat your reason? Why fight against God's love for humanity? For it was through this that He prepared it and threatened, that we might not be cast into it, having become better through this fear. And thus whoever does away with speaking on these subjects does nothing else than thrust us into it and drive us there by this deception. Do not weaken the hands of those who labor for virtue, nor increase the laziness of those who sleep. For if the many are persuaded that there is no hell, when will they leave off vice? Or when will justice be seen? I do not speak of the distinction between sinners and righteous people, but between sinners and sinners. For why is it that one is punished here and another is not punished, though he commits the same sins or even far worse? For if there is no hell, you will have nothing to say in defense of this to those who raise it as an objection. Therefore my advice is that we abandon this foolishness and silence those who argue against these matters. For there will be an exact examination of the smallest things, both in the way of sins and in the way of good deeds, and we shall be punished for lustful looks, for idle words, for mere insulting words, for drunkenness we shall give an account, just as even for a cup of cold water we shall receive a reward, and for a sigh only. For it says, "Set a mark upon the foreheads of the men who sigh and cry." How then do you dare to say that He who will examine our actions with such great precision threatened hell with empty words and lightly? Do not, I beg you, do not with these false hopes destroy yourself and those who believe you! For if you disbelieve our words, inquire of Jews and Gentiles and all heretics. And all of them as with one voice will answer that there shall be a judgment and a retribution. And are human beings not enough? Ask the devils themselves, and you will hear them cry, "Why have you come here to torment us before the time?" And putting all this together, persuade your soul not to be careless, lest by experience you come to know there is a hell, but from this you may be sobered and so be able to escape those tortures and attain to the good

Where then are they who with all this great exactness in view, yet will not allow that there is a hell? For if all the righteous are not to enjoy the same lot, if they exceed others even a little ( for one star, it says, differs from another star in glory,) 1 Corinthians 15:41, how are sinners to be in the same lot with the righteous? Such a confusion as this even man would not make, much less God! But if you will, I will show you that even in the case of sinners, arguing from existing facts, there is this distinction, and exact just judgment. Now consider; Adam sinned, and Eve sinned, and both transgressed, yet they were not equally sinful. And therefore neither were they equally punished. For the difference was so great that Paul said, Adam was not deceived but the woman being deceived was in the transgression. And yet the deceit was one. But still God's searching examination pointed out a difference so great, as that Paul should make this assertion. Again, Cain was punished, but Lamech, who committed a murder after him, did not suffer near so great a punishment. And yet this was a murder, and that was a murder, and that so much the worse, because even by the example he had not become the better. But since the one neither killed his brother after exhortation, nor needed an accuser, nor shrunk from answering when God questioned him, but even without any accuser both pleaded again himself, and condemned himself more severely, he obtained pardon. But the other as having done the opposite was punished. See with what exactness God sifts the facts. For this reason He punished those in the flood in one way, and those in Sodom in another; and the Israelites again, both those in Babylon, and those in Antiochus' time, in different ways: so showing that He keeps a strict account of our doings. And these were slaves for seventy years, and those for four hundred, but others again ate their children, and underwent countless other more grievous calamities, and even in this way were not freed, either they or those that were burnt alive in Sodom. For it shall be more tolerable, He says, for the land of Sodom and Gomorrha, than for that city. Matthew 10:15 For if He has no care for us, either when we sin or when we do aright, perhaps there will be some reason in saying that there is no punishment. But since He is so exceedingly urgent about our not sinning, and adopts so many means to keep us in the right, it is very plain that He punishes the wicked, and also crowns those that do right. But let me beg you to consider the unfairness of the generality. For they find fault with God because He so often long-suffering, overlooks so many that are impious, impure, or violent, without now suffering punishment. Again, if He threaten to punish them in the other world, they are vehement and pressing in their accusations. And yet if this be painful, they ought to accept and admire the other. But alas the folly! The unreasonable and asinine spirit! Alas the sin-loving soul, that gazes after vice! For it is from this that all these opinions have their birth. And so if they who utter these things should be minded to lay hold upon virtue, they will presently find themselves satisfied concerning hell also, and will not doubt. And where (it is said) and in what place is this hell? For some fablers say that it is in the valley of Josaphat, thus drawing that which was said about a certain by-gone war, to apply to hell. But the Scripture does not say this. But in what place, pray, will it be? Somewhere as I think at least quite out of the pale of this world. For as the prisons and mines are at a great distance from royal residences, so will hell be somewhere out of this world. Seek we not then to know where it is, but how we may escape it. Neither yet because God does not punish all here, therefore disbelieve things to come. For merciful and long-suffering He is: that is why he threatens, and does not cast us into it immediately. For I desire not, He says, the death of a sinner. Ezekiel 18:32 But if there is no death of a sinner, the words are but idle. And I know indeed that there is nothing less pleasant to you than these words. But to me nothing is pleasanter. And would it were possible at our dinner, and our supper, and our baths, and everywhere, to be discoursing about hell. For we should not then feel the pain at the evils in this world, nor the pleasure of its good things. For what would you tell me was an evil? poverty? Disease? captivity? Maiming of the body? Why all these things are sport compared to the punishment there, even should you speak of those who are tormented with famine all their life long; or those who are maimed from their earliest days, and beg, even this is luxury compared to those other evils. Let us then continually employ ourselves with talking about these things. For to remember hell prevents our falling into hell. Do you not hear St. Paul saying, Who shall suffer everlasting punishment from the face of the Lord? 2 Thessalonians 1:9 Do you not hear what Nero's character was, whom Paul even calls the Mystery of Antichrist? For the mystery of iniquity, he says, already works. 2 Thessalonians 2:7 What then? Is Nero to suffer nothing? Is Antichrist to suffer nothing? Or the Devil nothing? Then he will always be Antichrist, and so the Devil. For from mischief they will not leave off, unless they be punished. Yea, you say, but that there is a hell everybody sees. But the unbelievers only are to fall into it. What is the reason, pray? It is because the believers acknowledge their Master. And what is this to the purpose? When their life is impure, they will on this ground be punished more severely than the unbelievers. For as many as have sinned without law shall also perish without law: but as many as have sinned in the law shall be judged by the law. Romans 2:12 And, The servant that knew his master's will, and did it not, shall be beaten with many stripes. Luke 12:47 But if there is no such thing as giving an account of one's life, and all this is said in a loose way then neither will the Devil have vengeance taken upon him. For he too knows God, and far more than men too, and all the demons know Him, and tremble, and own He is their Judge. If then there is no giving an account of our life, nor of evil deeds, then will they also clean escape. These things are not so, surely they are not! Deceive not yourselves, beloved. For if there is no hell, how are the Apostles to judge the twelve tribes of Israel? How comes Paul to say, Do you not know that we shall judge Angels? How much more things of this life? 1 Corinthians 6:3 How came Christ to say, The men of Nineveh shall arise and condemn this generation Matthew 12:41; and, It shall be more tolerable for the land of Sodom in the day of judgment? Matthew 11:24 Why then make merry with things that are no subjects for merriment? Why deceive yourself and put cheats upon your reason ( παραλογίζῃ, om. τὴν ψυχήνσου)? Why fight with the love of God toward man? For it was through this that He prepared it, and threatened, that we might not be cast into it, as having by this fear become better. And thus he that does away with speaking on these subjects does nothing else than thrust us into it, and drive us there by this deceit. Slacken not the hands of them then that labor for virtue, nor make the listlessness of them that sleep greater. For if the many be persuaded that there is no hell, when will they leave off vice? Or when will right be seen? I do not say between sinners and righteous men, but between sinners and sinners? For why is it that one is punished here, and another not punished, though he does the same sins, or even far worse? For if there be no hell, you will having nothing to say in defense of this to those who make it an objection. Wherefore my advice is, that we leave off this trifling, and stop the mouths of those that are gainsayers upon these subjects. For there will be an exact searching into the smallest things, both in the way of sins and in the way of good deeds, and we shall be punished for unchaste looks, and for idle words, and for mere reproachful words, and for drunkenness we shall render an account, as even for a cup of cold water we shall receive a reward, and a sigh only. Ecclesiastes 12:14 For it says, Set a mark upon the foreheads of the men that sigh and that cry. Ezekiel 9:4 How then do you dare to say that He, who with so great exactness will search into our doings, threatened hell in bare words, and lightly? Do not, I beseech you, do not with these vain hopes destroy yourself and those that are persuaded by you! For if you disbelieve our words, make enquiry of Jews and Gentiles, and all heretics. And all of them as with one mouth will answer that a judgment there shall be, and a retribution. And are men not enough? Ask the devils themselves, and you will hear them cry, Why have you come there to torment us before the time. Matthew 8:29 And putting all this together persuade your soul not to trifle idly, lest by experience thou come to know there is a hell, but from this you may be sobered, and so able to escape those tortures, and attain to the good things to come; whereof may we all partake by the grace and love towards man, etc.