Letter 37
Of the same, from the letter to Charisius the monk, which begins with "It did not escape our smallness."
OF THE SAME FROM THE LETTER TO CHARISIUS THE MONK, THE BEGINNING OF WHICH IS, «It did not escape our smallness».
Which orthodox believer would agree that the Council of Chalcedon should be suppressed along with all the other holy councils, so that from the silence people might conclude it has equal honor? Surely those who reject it would raise arguments against those who accept it. One side would say, "It is suppressed because it is impious," while the other side would say, "It has been suppressed just like the other councils." And once again there would be arguments and conflicts.
Who among the orthodox would agree that the synod at Chalcedon should be suppressed in conjunction with all the religious synods, so that from the silence it might be inferred that it too enjoys equal honour? Assuredly those who turn away their faces from it would raise arguments against those who hold to it, and the one would say, «It is suppressed as impious», while the others would say. «It has met with the same suppression as the other synods», and again there would be contentions and disturbances.
And again, before these things, he says:
And again before these things he says.
For us to say that the synod must be suppressed and that we should formulate an orthodox confession, but not reject the blasphemies along with the persons themselves and their words, is neither lawful nor helpful for peace. Even if we were willing to close our eyes to this, no one among the congregations of the orthodox, especially after so much disturbance, would agree to such a false union, since the apostle plainly says, "If anyone preaches to you something different from what you have received, let him be anathema." What has thrown the churches into confusion down to the present day is this: the fact that those who hold power waver between the two sides and always wish to please both.
For for us to say that the synod must be suppressed, and formulate an orthodox confession, but not reject the blasphemies with the persons themselves and the words, is neither lawful nor conducive to peace. But, even if we be willing to shut our eyes, no one among the congregations of the orthodox, especially after so much agitation, would agree to such a spurious union, since the apostle plainly says, «If anyone preacheth to you outside what ye have received, let him be anathema». What has thrown the churches into confusion down to the present day is this, the fact that those who are in power halt between the two sides, and wish always to please both sides.
