Letters — Letter 207 — To the Clergy of Neocaesarea

A defense of antiphonal psalm-singing against critics who called it an innovation — a key primary source for 4th-century worship practice.

Source: Translated by Blomfield Jackson. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series , Vol. 8. Edited by Philip Schaff and Henry Wace. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1895. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/3202207.htm>.

Opening

ST. BASIL OF CAESAREA

ST. BASIL OF CAESAREA

To the clergy of Neocaesarea.

To the clergy of Neocæsarea.

You all agree in hating me. Every single one of you has followed the leader of this war against me. I was therefore inclined to say nothing to anyone. I decided that I would write no friendly letter, that I would begin no communication, but would keep my grief in silence to myself. Yet it is wrong to remain silent in the face of slander—not so that by contradicting it we might defend ourselves, but so that we may not allow a lie to spread further and harm its victims. I have therefore thought it necessary to bring this matter before all of you and to write you a letter, although when I recently wrote to all the presbyters together, you did not honor me with a reply. Do not, my brothers, indulge the pride of those who are filling your minds with destructive opinions. Do not consent to stand by idly when, as you well know, God's people are being ruined by godless teaching. No one except Sabellius the Libyan and Marcellus the Galatian has dared to teach and write what the leaders of your people are trying to present among you as their own private discovery. They make a great fuss about it, but they are completely unable to give their sophistries and fallacies even any appearance of truth. In their speeches against me they shrink from no evil, and stubbornly refuse to meet with me. Why? Is it not because they are afraid of being exposed for their own wicked opinions? Yes; and in their attacks upon me they have become so shameless as to invent certain false visions to discredit me while they falsely accuse my teaching of being destructive. Let them take upon their own heads all the visions of the autumn months; they can pin no blasphemy on me, for in every church there are many to testify to the truth.

You all concur in hating me. To a man you have followed the leader of the war against me. I was therefore minded to say not a word to any one. I determined that I would write no friendly letter; that I would start no communication, but keep my sorrow in silence to myself. Yet it is wrong to keep silence in the face of calumny; not that by contradiction we may vindicate ourselves, but that we may not allow a lie to travel further and its victims to be harmed. I have therefore thought it necessary to put this matter also before you all, and to write a letter to you, although, when I recently wrote to all the presbyterate in common, you did not do me the honour to send me a reply. Do not, my brethren, gratify the vanity of those who are filling your minds with pernicious opinions. Do not consent to look lightly on, when, to your knowledge, God's people are being subverted by impious teaching. None but Sabellius the Libyan and Marcellus the Galatian have dared to teach and write what the leaders of your people are attempting to bring forward among you as their own private discovery. They are making a great talk about it, but they are perfectly powerless to give their sophisms and fallacies even any color of truth. In their harangues against me they shrink from no wickedness, and persistently refuse to meet me. Why? Is it not because they are afraid of being convicted for their own wicked opinions? Yes; and in their attacks upon me they have become so lost to all sense of shame as to invent certain dreams to my discredit while they falsely accuse my teaching of being pernicious. Let them take upon their own heads all the visions of the autumn months; they can fix no blasphemy on me, for in every Church there are many to testify to the truth.

When they are asked why they wage this fierce and relentless war, they point to psalms and a kind of music that differs from the custom established among you, along with similar excuses they should be ashamed of. We are also accused because we support men in practicing true religion—men who have renounced the world and all those cares of this life which the Lord compares to thorns that prevent the word from bearing fruit. Such men carry in their bodies the death of Jesus; they have taken up their own cross and are followers of God. I would gladly give my life if these truly were my faults, and if I had people with me who acknowledged me as their teacher and had chosen this ascetic life. I hear that virtue of this kind can now be found in Egypt, and there are perhaps some men in Palestine whose conduct follows the Gospel's teachings. I am also told that some perfect and blessed men can be found in Mesopotamia. We, compared to the perfect, are children. But if women also have chosen to live according to the Gospel, preferring virginity to marriage, subduing the lust of the flesh, and living in the mourning that is called blessed, they are blessed in their commitment wherever they may be found. However, we have few examples of this to show, for among us people are still at a basic level and are being gradually led toward piety. If any accusations of disorder are brought against the conduct of our women, I do not undertake to defend them. But one thing I will say: these bold hearts and these unrestrained mouths are fearlessly saying what Satan, the father of lies, has until now been unable to say. I want you to know that we rejoice to have gatherings of both men and women whose citizenship is in heaven and who have crucified the flesh with its passions and desires; they give no thought to food and clothing, but remain undisturbed beside their Lord, continuing night and day in prayer. Their lips do not speak of human affairs: they sing hymns to God continually, working with their own hands so they may have something to give to those in need.

2. When they are asked the reason for this furious and truceless war, they allege psalms and a kind of music varying from the custom which has obtained among you, and similar pretexts of which they ought to be ashamed. We are, moreover, accused because we maintain men in the practice of true religion who have renounced the world and all those cares of this life, which the Lord likens to thorns that do not allow the word to bring forth fruit. Men of this kind carry about in the body the deadness of Jesus; they have taken up their own cross, and are followers of God. I would gladly give my life if these really were my faults, and if I had men with me owning me as teacher who had chosen this ascetic life. I hear that virtue of this kind is to be found now in Egypt, and there are, perhaps, some men in Palestine whose conversation follows the precepts of the Gospel. I am told too that some perfect and blessed men are to be found in Mesopotamia. We, in comparison with the perfect, are children. But if women also have chosen to live the Gospel life, preferring virginity to wedlock, leading captive the lust of the flesh, and living in the mourning which is called blessed, they are blessed in their profession wherever they are to be found. We, however, have few instances of this to show, for with us people are still in an elementary stage and are being gradually brought. to piety. If any charges of disorder are brought against the life of our women I do not undertake to defend them. One thing, however, I do say and that is, that these bold hearts, these unbridled mouths are ever fearlessly uttering what Satan, the father of lies, has hitherto been unable to say. I wish you to know that we rejoice to have assemblies of both men and women, whose conversation is in heaven and who have crucified the flesh with the affections and lusts thereof; they take no thought for food and raiment, but remain undisturbed beside their Lord, continuing night and day in prayer. Their lips speak not of the deeds of men: they sing hymns to God continually, working with their own hands that they may have to distribute to them that need.

Now regarding the charge about singing psalms, which my accusers use especially to frighten simple people, my response is this. The customs we follow agree with those of all the Churches of God. Among us, the people go at night to the house of prayer and, in distress, affliction, and continual tears, make confession to God. At last they rise from their prayers and begin to sing psalms. Then, divided into two groups, they sing antiphonally with one another, thus both reinforcing their study of the Gospels and at the same time cultivating in themselves an attentive disposition and a heart free from distraction. Afterward they again commit the opening of the melody to one person, and the rest take it up. And so, after passing the night in various psalm-singing, with prayers at intervals, as day begins to dawn all together, as with one voice and one heart, raise the psalm of confession to the Lord, each person forming his own expressions of penitence. If you reject me for these reasons, you will reject the Egyptians; you will reject both Libyans, Thebans, Palestinians, Arabians, Phoenicians, Syrians, the dwellers by the Euphrates—in a word, all those among whom vigils, prayers, and communal psalm-singing have been held in honor.

3. Now as to the charge relating to the singing of psalms, whereby my calumniators specially scare the simpler folk, my reply is this. The customs which now obtain are agreeable to those of all the Churches of God. Among us the people go at night to the house of prayer, and, in distress, affliction, and continual tears, making confession to God, at last rise from their prayers and begin to sing psalms. And now, divided into two parts, they sing antiphonally with one another, thus at once confirming their study of the Gospels, and at the same time producing for themselves a heedful temper and a heart free from distraction. Afterwards they again commit the prelude of the strain to one, and the rest take it up; and so after passing the night in various psalmody, praying at intervals as the day begins to dawn, all together, as with one voice and one heart, raise the psalm of confession to the Lord, each forming for himself his own expressions of penitence. If it is for these reasons that you renounce me, you will renounce the Egyptians; you will renounce both Libyans, Thebans, Palestinians, Arabians, Phœnicians, Syrians, the dwellers by the Euphrates; in a word all those among whom vigils, prayers, and common psalmody have been held in honour.

But it is claimed that these practices were not observed during the time of the great Gregory. My response is that even the Litanies you now use were not used in his time. I do not say this to criticize you, for my prayer would be that every one of you should live in tears and continual repentance. We, for our part, are always offering supplication for our sins, but we appeal to our God not as you do, in the words of mere humans, but in the oracles of the Spirit. And what evidence do you have that this custom was not followed in the time of the great Gregory? You have kept none of his customs up to the present time. Gregory did not cover his head at prayer. How could he? He was a true disciple of the Apostle who says, Every man praying or prophesying, having his head covered, dishonors his head. And a man indeed ought not to cover his head since he is the image of God. Oaths were shunned by Gregory, that pure soul, worthy of the fellowship of the Holy Spirit, content with yes and no, in accordance with the commandment of the Lord who said, I say to you swear not at all. Gregory could not bear to call his brother a fool, for he stood in awe of the threat of the Lord. Passion, wrath, and bitterness never came out of his mouth. Insults he hated, because they do not lead to the kingdom of heaven. Envy and arrogance had been shut out of that innocent soul. He would never have stood at the altar before being reconciled to his brother. A lie, or any word designed to slander anyone, he detested, as one who knew that lies come from the devil, and that the Lord will destroy all who utter a lie. If you have none of these things, and are clear of all, then you are truly disciples of the disciple of the Lord; if not, beware lest, in your disputes about the mode of singing psalms, you are straining at the gnat and setting aside the greatest of the commandments.

4. But, it is alleged, these practices were not observed in the time of the great Gregory. My rejoinder is that even the Litanies which you now use were not used in his time. I do not say this to find fault with you; for my prayer would be that every one of you should live in tears and continual penitence. We, for our part, are always offering supplication for our sins, but we propitiate our God not as you do, in the words of mere man, but in the oracles of the Spirit. And what evidence have you that this custom was not followed in the time of the great Gregory? You have kept none of his customs up to the present time. Gregory did not cover his head at prayer. How could he? He was a true disciple of the Apostle who says, Every man praying or prophesying, having his head covered, dishonours his head. 1 Corinthians 11:4 And a man indeed ought not to cover his head forasmuch as he is the image of God. 1 Corinthians 11:7 Oaths were shunned by Gregory, that pure soul, worthy of the fellowship of the Holy Ghost, content with yea and nay, in accordance with the commandment of the Lord Who said, I say unto you swear not at all. Matthew 5:34 Gregory could not bear to call his brother a fool, for he stood in awe of the threat of the Lord. Passion, wrath, and bitterness never proceeded out of his mouth. Railing he hated, because it leads not to the kingdom of heaven. Envy and arrogance had been shut out of that guiltless soul. He would never have stood at the altar before being reconciled to his brother. A lie, or any word designed to slander any one, he abominated, as one who knew that lies come from the devil, and that the Lord will destroy all that utter a lie. If you have none of these things, and are clear of all, then are you verily disciples of the disciple of the Lord; if not, beware lest, in your disputes about the mode of singing psalms, you are straining at the gnat and setting at naught the greatest of the commandments.

I have been forced to use these expressions because of the pressing need to defend myself, so that you may learn to remove the beam from your own eyes before you try to take out the specks from other people's eyes. Even so, I am granting everything, although nothing escapes God's examination. Just let the important matters take priority, and do not allow innovations in the faith to gain a hearing. Do not disregard the hypostases. Do not deny the name of Christ. Do not misinterpret Gregory's words. If you do these things, as long as I am alive and able to speak, I cannot remain silent when I see souls being destroyed in this way.

I have been driven to use these expressions by the urgency of my defense, that you may be taught to cast the beam out of your own eyes before you try to remove other men's motes. Nevertheless, I am conceding all, although there is nothing that is not searched into before God. Only let great matters prevail, and do not allow innovations in the faith to make themselves heard. Do not disregard the hypostases. Do not deny the name of Christ. Do not put a wrong meaning on the words of Gregory. If you do so, as long as I breathe and have the power of utterance, I cannot keep silence, when I see souls being thus destroyed.


Letters — Letter 217 — To Amphilochius, Canonical Letter III

The third Canonical Letter to Amphilochius, completing the set that became foundational to Eastern canon law.

Source: Translated by Blomfield Jackson. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series , Vol. 8. Edited by Philip Schaff and Henry Wace. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1895. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/3202217.htm>.

Opening

ST. BASIL OF CAESAREA

ST. BASIL OF CAESAREA

To Amphilochius, the Canons.

To Amphilochius, the Canons.

On my return from a long journey (for I had been in Pontus on church business and to visit my relatives), with my body weak and sick and my spirits quite broken, I took your reverence's letter in hand. As soon as I received these tokens of that voice which is the sweetest of all voices to me, and of that hand I love so well, I forgot all my troubles. And if receiving your letter cheered me up so much, you should be able to guess how much I value your actual presence. May the Holy One grant me this, whenever it is convenient for you and you send me an invitation. And if you were to come to the house at Euphemias, it would indeed be pleasant for me to meet you there, escaping from my troubles here and hurrying to your genuine affection. I may also possibly be compelled for other reasons to go as far as Nazianzus because of the sudden departure of the very God-beloved bishop Gregory. How or why this has happened, I have no information so far. The man about whom I had spoken to your excellency, and whom you expected to be ready by this time, has, you must know, fallen ill with a lingering disease, and is moreover now suffering from an eye problem arising from his old complaint and from the illness that has now struck him, and he is completely unfit to do any work. I have no one else with me. Consequently it is better, although the matter was left to me by them, for someone to be put forward by them. And indeed one cannot help but think that their words were used merely as a necessary formality, and that what they really wished was what they originally requested, that the person selected for leadership should be one of themselves. If there is anyone among the recently baptized, whether Macedonius approves or not, let him be appointed. You will instruct him in his duties, the Lord, who in all things works together with you, granting you His grace for this work also.

On my return from a long journey (for I have been into Pontus on ecclesiastical business, and to visit my relations) with my body weak and ill, and my spirits considerably broken, I took your reverence's letter into my hand. No sooner did I receive the tokens of that voice which to me is of all voices the sweetest, and of that hand that I love so well, than I forgot all my troubles. And if I was made so much more cheerful by the receipt of your letter, you ought to be able to conjecture at what value I price your actual presence. May this be granted me by the Holy One, whenever it may be convenient to you and you yourself send me an invitation. And if you were to come to the house at Euphemias it would indeed be pleasant for me to meet you, escaping from my vexations here, and hastening to your unfeigned affection. Possibly also for other reasons I may be compelled to go as far as Nazianzus by the sudden departure of the very God-beloved bishop Gregory. How or why this has come to pass, so far I have no information. The man about whom I had spoken to your excellency, and whom you expected to be ready by this time, has, you must know, fallen ill of a lingering disease, and is moreover now suffering from an affection of the eyes, arising from his old complaint and from the illness which has now befallen him, and he is quite unfit to do any work. I have no one else with me. It is consequently better, although the matter was left by them to me, for some one to be put forward by them. And indeed one cannot but think that the expressions were used merely as a necessary form, and that what they really wished was what they originally requested, that the person selected for the leadership should be one of themselves. If there is any one of the lately baptized, whether Macedonius approve or not, let him be appointed. You will instruct him in his duties, the Lord, Who in all things cooperates with you, granting you His grace for this work also.

As for the clergy, the Canons have commanded without making any distinction that one penalty is assigned for those who have fallen away—removal from ministry, whether they are ordained or remain in the ministry that is given without the laying on of hands.

LI. As to the clergy, the Canons have enjoined without making any distinction that one penalty is assigned for the lapsed — ejection from the ministry, whether they be in orders or remain in the ministry which is conferred without imposition of hands.

LII. The woman who has given birth to a child and abandoned it in the road, if she was able to save it and neglected it, or thought by this means to hide her sin, or was moved by some brutal and inhuman motive, is to be judged as in a case of murder. If, on the other hand, she was unable to provide for it and the child dies from exposure and lack of the necessities of life, the mother is to be pardoned.

LII. The woman who has given birth to a child and abandoned it in the road, if she was able to save it and neglected it, or thought by this means to hide her sin, or was moved by some brutal and inhuman motive, is to be judged as in a case of murder. If, on the other hand, she was unable to provide for it. and the child perish from exposure and want of the necessities of life, the mother is to be pardoned.

LIII. The widowed slave is not guilty of a serious sin if she enters a second marriage on the grounds of rape. She is not subject to accusation on this basis. It is the actual purpose rather than the stated reason that must be considered, but it is clear that she is subject to the penalty for digamy.

LIII. The widowed slave is not guilty of a serious fall if she adopts a second marriage under color of rape. She is not on this ground open to accusation. It is rather the object than the pretext which must be taken into account, but it is clear that she is exposed to the punishment of digamy.

LIV. I know that I have already written to your reverence as fully as I can about the distinctions to be observed in cases of involuntary homicide, and I have nothing more to say on this point. It is up to your judgment to increase or reduce the severity of the punishment according to what each individual case requires.

LIV. I know that I have already written to your reverence, so far as I can, on the distinctions to be observed in cases of involuntary homicide, and on this point I can say no more. It rests with your intelligence to increase or lessen the severity of the punishment as each individual case may require.

LV. Those who attack robbers, if they are laypeople, are prohibited from communion. If they are clergy, they are removed from their orders. For it is said, "All they that take the sword shall perish with the sword." Matthew 26:52

LV. Assailants of robbers, if they are outside, are prohibited from the communion of the good thing. If they are clerics they are degraded from their orders. For, it is said, All they that take the sword shall perish with the sword. Matthew 26:52

LVI. The intentional homicide who has afterwards repented will be excommunicated from the sacrament for twenty years. The twenty years will be assigned to him as follows: for four years he should weep, standing outside the door of the house of prayer, asking the faithful as they enter to offer prayer on his behalf and confessing his own sin. After four years he will be admitted among the hearers, and for five years will go out with them. For seven years he will go out with the kneelers, praying. For four years he will only stand with the faithful and will not take part in the oblation. When this period is completed, he will be admitted to participation in the sacrament.

LVI. The intentional homicide, who has afterwards repented, will be excommunicated from the sacrament for twenty years. The twenty years will be appointed for him as follows: for four he ought to weep, standing outside the door of the house of prayer, beseeching the faithful as they enter in to offer prayer in his behalf, and confessing his own sin. After four years he will be admitted among the hearers, and during five years will go out with them. During seven years he will go out with the kneelers, praying. During four years he will only stand with the faithful, and will not take part in the oblation. On the completion of this period he will be admitted to participation of the sacrament.

A person who commits unintentional homicide will be excluded from the sacrament for ten years. The ten years will be arranged as follows: for two years he will weep, for three years he will remain among the hearers, for four years he will be a kneeler, and for one year he will only stand. Then he will be admitted to the holy rites.

LVII. The unintentional homicide will be excluded for ten years from the sacrament. The ten years will be arranged as follows: For two years he will weep, for three years he will continue among the hearers; for four he will be a kneeler; and for one he will only stand. Then he will be admitted to the holy rites.

LVIII. The adulterer will be excluded from the sacrament for fifteen years. For four years he will weep, for five years he will be a hearer, for four years he will be a kneeler, and for two years he will stand without receiving communion.

LVIII. The adulterer will be excluded from the sacrament for fifteen years. During four he will be a weeper, and during five a hearer, during four a kneeler, and for two a stander without communion.

LIX. The fornicator will not be admitted to participate in the sacrament for seven years: two years as a weeper, two as a hearer, two as a kneeler, and one as a stander. In the eighth year he will be received into communion.

LIX. The fornicator will not be admitted to participation in the sacrament for seven years; weeping two, hearing two, kneeling two, and standing one: in the eighth he will be received into communion.

LX. A woman who has taken a vow of virginity and then broken her promise must complete the same period of penance required for adultery while remaining continent. The same rule applies to men who have professed a celibate life and then fall into sin.

LX. The woman who has professed virginity and broken her promise will complete the time appointed in the case of adultery in her continence. The same rule will be observed in the case of men who have professed a solitary life and who lapse.

LXI. The thief, if he has repented on his own and accused himself, shall only be prohibited from partaking of the sacrament for one year; if he is convicted, for two years. The period shall be divided between kneeling and standing. Then let him be considered worthy of communion.

LXI. The thief, if he have repented of his own accord and charged himself, shall only be prohibited from partaking of the sacrament for a year; if he be convicted, for two years. The period shall be divided between kneeling and standing. Then let him be held worthy of communion.

LXII. He who is guilty of unseemliness with males will be under discipline for the same time as adulterers.

LXII. He who is guilty of unseemliness with males will be under discipline for the same time as adulterers.

LXIII. He who confesses his iniquity in the case of beasts shall observe the same time in penance.

LXIII. He who confesses his iniquity in the case of brutes shall observe the same time in penance.

LXIV. Perjurers shall be excommunicated for ten years: two years weeping, three years hearing, four years kneeling, and one year standing only; then they shall be considered worthy of communion.

LXIV. Perjurers shall be excommunicated for ten years; weeping for two, hearing for three, kneeling for four, and standing only during one year; then they shall be held worthy of communion.

LXV. Anyone who confesses to practicing magic or sorcery must do penance for the same length of time as someone guilty of murder, and must be treated in the same way as someone who convicts himself of this sin.

LXV. He who confesses magic or sorcery shall do penance for the time of murder, and shall be treated in the same manner as he who convicts himself of this sin.

LXVI. The tomb breaker shall be excommunicated for ten years: weeping for two years, hearing for three years, kneeling for four years, standing for one year, and then he shall be admitted.

LXVI. The tomb breaker shall be excommunicated for ten years, weeping for two, hearing for three, kneeling for four, standing for one, then he shall be admitted.

LXVII. Incest with a sister shall require penance for the same length of time as murder.

LXVII. Incest with a sister shall incur penance for the same time as murder.

LXVIII. If relatives within the prohibited degrees of marriage are discovered to have engaged in sinful acts together, they shall receive the same punishment as for adultery.

LXVIII. The union of kindred within the prohibited degrees of marriage, if detected as having taken place in acts of sin, shall receive the punishment of adultery.

LXIX. The Reader who has intercourse with his betrothed before marriage shall be allowed to read after a year's suspension, while remaining without advancement. If he has had secret intercourse without betrothal, he shall be deposed from his ministry. The same applies to the minister.

LXIX. The Reader who has intercourse with his betrothed before marriage, shall be allowed to read after a year's suspension, remaining without advancement. If he has had secret intercourse without betrothal, he shall be deposed from his ministry. So too the minister.

LXX. The deacon who has been defiled in lips and has confessed to committing this sin shall be removed from his ministry. However, he shall be allowed to receive the sacrament together with the deacons. The same applies in the case of a priest. If anyone is found guilty of a more serious sin, whatever his rank may be, he shall be deposed.

LXX. The deacon who has been polluted in lips, and has confessed his commission of this sin, shall be removed from his ministry. But he shall be permitted to partake of the sacrament together with the deacons. The same holds good in the case of a priest. If any one be detected in a more serious sin, whatever be his degree, he shall be deposed.

LXXI. Whoever knows about someone committing any of the sins mentioned above and is found guilty of not confessing this knowledge shall be under punishment for the same length of time as the person who actually committed the sin.

LXXI. Whoever is aware of the commission of any one of the aforementioned sins, and is convicted without having confessed, shall be under punishment for the same space of time as the actual perpetrator.

LXXII. Anyone who has consulted soothsayers or any such persons shall be under discipline for the same length of time as a homicide.

LXXII. He who has entrusted himself to soothsayers, or any such persons, shall be under discipline for the same time as the homicide.

LXXIII. A person who has denied Christ and sinned against the mystery of salvation ought to weep for his entire life and is required to remain in penitence, being deemed worthy of the sacrament at the hour of death through faith in the mercy of God.

LXXIII. He who has denied Christ, and sinned against the mystery of salvation, ought to weep all his life long, and is bound to remain in penitence, being deemed worthy of the sacrament in the hour of death, through faith in the mercy of God.

LXXIV. If, however, each person who has committed the former sins becomes good through penitence, the one to whom God's loving-kindness has entrusted the power of loosing and binding will not deserve condemnation if he becomes less severe when he sees the exceptional greatness of the sinner's penitence, so that he shortens the period of punishment, for the history in the Scriptures teaches us that all who practice penitence with greater zeal quickly receive God's loving-kindness.

LXXIV. If, however, each man who has committed the former sins is made good, through penitence, he to whom is committed by the loving-kindness of God the power of loosing and binding will not be deserving of condemnation, if he become less severe, as he beholds the exceeding greatness of the penitence of the sinner, so as to lessen the period of punishment, for the history in the Scriptures informs us that all who exercise penitence with greater zeal quickly receive the loving-kindness of God.

LXXV. The man who has been polluted with his own sister, whether on his father's or mother's side, must not be allowed to enter the house of prayer until he has given up his sinful and unlawful conduct. After he has come to understand that terrible sin, let him weep for three years standing at the door of the house of prayer, asking the people as they enter to pray that each and all will mercifully offer earnest prayers to the Lord on his behalf. After this, let him be received for another three years to hearing alone, and while hearing the Scriptures and the instruction, let him be expelled and not admitted to prayer. Afterwards, if he has asked with tears and has fallen before the Lord with a contrite heart and great humility, let kneeling be granted to him during another three years. Thus, when he has worthily shown the fruits of repentance, let him be received in the tenth year to the prayer of the faithful without oblation, and after standing with the faithful in prayer for two years, then and not until then, let him be considered worthy of the communion of the good thing.

LXXV. The man who has been polluted with his own sister, either on the father's or the mother's side, must not be allowed to enter the house of prayer, until he has given up his iniquitous and unlawful conduct. And, after he has come to a sense of that fearful sin, let him weep for three years standing at the door of the house of prayer, and entreating the people as they go in to prayer that each and all will mercifully offer on his behalf their prayers with earnestness to the Lord. After this let him be received for another period of three years to hearing alone, and while hearing the Scriptures and the instruction, let him be expelled and not be admitted to prayer. Afterwards, if he has asked it with tears and has fallen before the Lord with contrition of heart and great humiliation, let kneeling be accorded to him during other three years. Thus, when he shall have worthily shown the fruits of repentance, let him be received in the tenth year to the prayer of the faithful without oblation; and after standing with the faithful in prayer for two years, then, and not till then, let him be held worthy of the communion of the good thing.

LXXVI. The same rule applies to those who take their own daughters-in-law.

LXXVI. The same rule applies to those who take their own daughters in law.

LXXVII. Anyone who abandons his lawfully married wife is subject by the Lord's judgment to the penalty of adultery. However, our Fathers have established as a canon that such sinners should weep for one year, be hearers for two years, spend three years kneeling, stand with the faithful in the seventh year, and then be considered worthy of the oblation, provided they have repented with tears.

LXXVII. He who abandons the wife, lawfully united to him, is subject by the sentence of the Lord to the penalty of adultery. But it has been laid down as a canon by our Fathers that such sinners should weep for a year, be hearers for two years, in kneeling for three years, stand with the faithful in the seventh; and thus be deemed worthy of the oblation, if they have repented with tears.

LXXVIII. The same rule should apply to those who marry two sisters, even if they marry them at different times.

LXXVIII. Let the same rule hold good in the case of those who marry two sisters, although at different times.

Men who lust after their stepmothers are subject to the same canon as those who lust after their sisters.

LXXIX. Men who rage after their stepmothers are subject to the same canon as those who rage after their sisters.

LXXX. The Fathers are silent on polygamy, since it is brutish and completely inhuman. This sin seems to me worse than fornication. Therefore, it is reasonable that those who commit this sin should be subject to the canons: one year of weeping, three years of kneeling, and then reception.

LXXX. On polygamy the Fathers are silent, as being brutish and altogether inhuman. The sin seems to me worse than fornication. It is therefore reasonable that such sinners should be subject to the canons; namely a year's weeping, three years kneeling and then reception.

LXXXI. During the barbarian invasion, many men have sworn pagan oaths, eaten things unlawfully offered to them in magic temples, and thus have broken their faith in God. Let rules be established for these men in accordance with the canons set down by our Fathers. Those who have endured severe tortures and have been forced into denial because they could not bear the suffering may be excluded for three years, be hearers for two years, be kneelers for three years, and then be received into communion. Those who have abandoned their faith in God by touching the tables of demons and swearing pagan oaths without suffering great violence should be excluded for three years and be hearers for two years. After they have prayed for three years as kneelers and have stood for another three years with the faithful in prayer, then let them be received into the communion of the good thing.

LXXXI. During the invasion of the barbarians many men have sworn heathen oaths, tasted things unlawfully offered them in magic temples and so have broken their faith in God. Let regulations be made in the case of these men in accordance with the canons laid down by our Fathers. Those who have endured grievous tortures and have been forced to denial, through inability to sustain the anguish, may be excluded for three years, hearers for two, kneelers for three, and so be received into communion. Those who have abandoned their faith in God, laying hands on the tables of the demons and swearing heathen oaths, without under going great violence, should be excluded for three years, hearers for two. When they have prayed for three years as kneelers, and have stood other three with the faithful in supplication, then let them be received into the communion of the good thing.

LXXXII. Regarding those who have broken oaths, if they violated their oaths under violent compulsion, they are subject to lighter penalties and may therefore be received back after six years. If they break their faith without compulsion, let them be weepers for two years, hearers for three, pray as kneelers for five, then for two years be received into the communion of prayer without the oblation, and so at last, after demonstrating proper repentance, they shall be restored to the communion of the body of Christ.

LXXXII. As to perjurers, if they have broken their oaths under violent compulsion, they are under lighter penalties and may therefore be received after six years. If they break their faith without compulsion, let them be weepers for two years, hearers for three, pray as kneelers for five, during two be received into the communion of prayer, without oblation, and so at last, after giving proof of due repentance, they shall be restored to the communion of the body of Christ.

Those who consult fortune-tellers and those who follow pagan customs, or who bring people into their homes to discover remedies and perform purification rituals, should fall under the canon of six years. After spending one year as weepers, one year as hearers, three years kneeling, and one year standing with the faithful, they may then be received.

LXXXIII. Consulters of soothsayers and they who follow heathen customs, or bring persons into their houses to discover remedies and to effect purification, should fall under the canon of six years. After weeping a year, hearing a year, kneeling for three years and standing with the faithful for a year so let them be received.

LXXXIV. I write all this to test the fruits of repentance. I do not determine these matters strictly by time, but I pay attention to how people actually repent. If people are in a condition where they find it difficult to give up their own ways and prefer to serve the pleasures of the flesh rather than to serve the Lord, and they refuse to accept the life of the Gospel, there is no common ground between them and me. Living among a disobedient and contradictory people, I have been taught to hear the words "Save your own soul." So let us not agree to perish together with such sinners. Let us fear the fearful judgment. Let us keep before our eyes the terrible day of the Lord's retribution. Let us not agree to perish in other people's sins, for if the terrors of the Lord have not taught us, if such great disasters have not brought us to recognize that it is because of our wickedness that the Lord has abandoned us and handed us over to the barbarians, that the people have been led captive before our enemies and given over to being scattered, because those who bear Christ's name have dared to do such things—if they have not known or understood that it is for these reasons that God's wrath has come upon us, what common ground for discussion do I have with them?

LXXXIV. I write all this with a view to testing the fruits of repentance. I do not decide such matters absolutely by time, but I give heed to the manner of penance. If men are in a state in which they find it hard to be weaned from their own ways and choose rather to serve the pleasures of the flesh than to serve the Lord, and refuse to accept the Gospel life, there is no common ground between me and them. In the midst of a disobedient and gainsaying people I have been taught to hear the words Save your own soul. Do not then let us consent to perish together with such sinners. Let us fear the awful judgment. Let us keep before our eyes the terrible day of the retribution of the Lord. Let us not consent to perish in other men's sins, for if the terrors of the Lord have not taught us, if so great calamities have not brought us to feel that it is because of our iniquity that the Lord has abandoned us, and given us into the hands of barbarians, that the people have been led captive before our foes and given over to dispersion, because the bearers of Christ's name have dared such deeds; if they have not known nor understood that it is for these reasons that the wrath of God has come upon us, what common ground of argument have I with them?

We ought to bear witness to them day and night, both publicly and privately. Let us not consent to be led away with them into their wickedness. Above all, let us pray that we may benefit them and rescue them from the trap of the evil one. If we cannot do this, let us at least do our utmost to save our own souls from eternal damnation.

But we ought to testify to them day and night, alike in public and in private. Let us not consent to be drawn away with them in their wickedness. Let us above all pray that we may do them good, and rescue them from the snare of the evil one. If we cannot do this, let us at all events do our best to save our own souls from everlasting damnation.


Letters — Letter 223 — To Eustathius of Sebaste

Basil’s extended autobiographical self-defense: his conversion from rhetoric to the ascetic life, and the breakdown of his relationship with Eustathius.

Source: Translated by Blomfield Jackson. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series , Vol. 8. Edited by Philip Schaff and Henry Wace. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1895. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/3202223.htm>.

Opening

ST. BASIL OF CAESAREA

ST. BASIL OF CAESAREA

Against Eustathius of Sebasteia.

Against Eustathius of Sebasteia.

There is a time to keep silence and a time to speak, as Ecclesiastes 3:7 says. Enough time has been given to silence, and now the time has come to open my mouth to make the truth known about matters that are, until now, unknown. The noble Job endured his sufferings in silence for a long time and always showed his courage by holding up under the most unbearable pain. But when he had struggled long enough in silence and had kept his anguish buried deep in his heart, he finally opened his mouth and spoke those well-known words. In my case, this is now the third year of my silence, and my boast has become like the Psalmist's: I was like a man who does not hear and in whose mouth are no arguments. So I shut up deep in my heart the pain I suffered because of the false accusations made against me, for slander humbles a man, and slander makes a poor man lose his balance. If, then, the harm of slander is so great that it can bring down even the perfect man from his height—for this is what Scripture means by "man"—and by "poor man" is meant someone who lacks the great doctrines, as the prophet also understands when he says, These are poor, therefore they shall not hear…I will go to the great men, he means by "poor" those who are lacking in understanding. Here, too, he clearly means those who are not yet equipped in the inner man and have not even reached the full measure of their maturity. These are the ones who, according to the proverb, are said to be made dizzy and tossed about. Nevertheless, I thought I should bear my troubles in silence, waiting to see what would come of them. I did not even think that what was said against me came from ill will; I thought it was the result of ignorance of the truth. But now I see that hostility grows with time, and that my accusers are not sorry for what they said at the beginning and do not take any trouble to make up for the past. Instead, they keep going and band together to achieve their original goal, which was to make my life miserable and to find ways to ruin my reputation among the brethren. Therefore, I no longer see safety in silence. I have remembered the words of Isaiah: I have kept silent for a long time, shall I always be quiet and hold myself back? I have been patient like a woman in labor. God grant that I may both receive the reward of silence and gain some strength to refute my opponents, and that by refuting them, I may dry up the bitter stream of lies that has poured out against me. Then I might say, My soul has passed over the torrent; and, If it had not been the Lord who was on our side when men rose up against us…then they would have swallowed us up alive, the water would have drowned us.

1. There is a time to keep silence and a time to speak, Ecclesiastes 3:7 is the saying of the Preacher. Time enough has been given to silence, and now the time has come to open my mouth for the publication of the truth concerning matters that are, up to now, unknown. The illustrious Job bore his calamities for a long time in silence, and ever showed his courage by holding out under the most intolerable sufferings, but when he had struggled long enough in silence, and had persisted in covering his anguish in the bottom of his heart, at last he opened his mouth and uttered his well-known words. In my own case this is now the third year of my silence, and my boast has become like that of the Psalmist, I was as a man that hears not and in whose mouth are no reproofs. Thus I shut up in the bottom of my heart the pangs which I suffered on account of the calumnies directed against me, for calumny humbles a man, and calumny makes a poor man giddy. If, therefore, the mischief of calumny is so great as to cast down even the perfect man from his height, for this is what Scripture indicates by the word man, and by the poor man is meant he who lacks the great doctrines, as is the view also of the prophet when he says, These are poor, therefore they shall not hear;…I will get me unto the great men, he means by poor those who are lacking in understanding; and here, too, he plainly means those who are not yet furnished in the inner man, and have not even come to the full measure of their age; it is these who are said by the proverb to be made giddy and tossed about. Nevertheless I thought that I ought to bear my troubles in silence, waiting for some indication to come out of them. I did not even think that what was said against me proceeded from ill will; I thought it was the result of ignorance of the truth. But now I see that hostility increases with time, and that my slanderers are not sorry for what they said at the beginning, and do not take any trouble to make amends for the past, but go on and on and rally themselves together to attain their original object. This was to make my life miserable and to devise means for sullying my reputation among the brethren. I, therefore, no longer see safety in silence. I have bethought me of the words of Isaiah: I have long time holden my peace, shall I always be still and refrain myself? I have been patient like a travailing woman. God grant that I may both receive the reward of silence, and gain some strength to confute my opponents, and that thus, by confuting them, I may dry up the bitter torrent of falsehood that has gushed out against me. So might I say, My soul has passed over the torrent; and, If it had not been the Lord who was on our side when men rose up against us,…then they had swallowed us up quick, the water had drowned us.

I had spent much time in vanity and wasted nearly all my youth in the vain labor I endured to acquire the wisdom that God made foolish. Then one day, like a man awakened from deep sleep, I turned my eyes to the marvelous light of the truth of the Gospel, and I recognized the uselessness of the wisdom of the princes of this world, which is coming to nothing. I wept many tears over my miserable life, and I prayed that guidance might be granted to me to lead me into the doctrines of true religion. First, I was determined to make some correction of my ways, which had long been corrupted by my association with wicked men. Then I read the Gospel, and I saw there that a great means of reaching perfection was selling one's possessions, sharing them with the poor, giving up all concern for this life, and refusing to allow the soul to be turned by any attachment to earthly things. And I prayed that I might find one of the brothers who had chosen this way of life, so that with him I might cross life's short and troubled strait. And I found many in Alexandria, and many in the rest of Egypt, and others in Palestine, and in Coele Syria, and in Mesopotamia. I admired their self-control in living and their endurance in hardship. I was amazed at their persistence in prayer and at their triumph over sleep. Subdued by no bodily necessity, always keeping their soul's purpose high and free, in hunger, in thirst, in cold, in nakedness, they never yielded to the body. They were never willing to waste attention on it. Always, as though living in flesh that was not theirs, they showed in actual fact what it means to sojourn for a while in this life and what it means to have one's citizenship and home in heaven. All this stirred my admiration. I called these men's lives blessed, in that they showed in deed that they bear about in their body the dying of Jesus. And I prayed that I too, as far as was possible for me, might imitate them.

2. Much time had I spent in vanity, and had wasted nearly all my youth in the vain labour which I underwent in acquiring the wisdom made foolish by God. Then once upon a time, like a man roused from deep sleep, I turned my eyes to the marvellous light of the truth of the Gospel, and I perceived the uselessness of the wisdom of the princes of this world, that come to naught. 1 Corinthians 2:6 I wept many tears over my miserable life and I prayed that guidance might be vouchsafed me to admit me to the doctrines of true religion. First of all was I minded to make some mending of my ways, long perverted as they were by my intimacy with wicked men. Then I read the Gospel, and I saw there that a great means of reaching perfection was the selling of one's goods, the sharing them with the poor, the giving up of all care for this life, and the refusal to allow the soul to be turned by any sympathy to things of earth. And I prayed that I might find some one of the brethren who had chosen this way of life, that with him I might cross life's short and troubled strait. And many did I find in Alexandria, and many in the rest of Egypt, and others in Palestine, and in Cœle Syria, and in Mesopotamia. I admired their continence in living, and their endurance in toil; I was amazed at their persistency in prayer, and at their triumphing over sleep; subdued by no natural necessity, ever keeping their souls' purpose high and free, in hunger, in thirst, in cold, in nakedness, 2 Corinthians 11:27 they never yielded to the body; they were never willing to waste attention on it; always, as though living in a flesh that was not theirs, they showed in very deed what it is to sojourn for a while in this life, and what to have one's citizenship and home in heaven. All this moved my admiration. I called these men's lives blessed, in that they did in deed show that they bear about in their body the dying of Jesus. 2 Corinthians 4:10 And I prayed that I, too, as far as in me lay, might imitate them.

When I saw certain men in my own country trying to imitate their way of life, I felt I had found help for my own salvation, and I took what I could see as proof of what I could not see. Since the hidden thoughts in each person's heart are unknown, I took simple clothing as a sufficient sign of humility of spirit. The rough cloak, the belt, and the shoes made of untanned leather were enough to convince me. Though many people tried to pull me away from their company, I would not let them, because I saw that they chose a life of hardship over a life of pleasure. Because of the remarkable quality of their lives, I became an enthusiastic supporter of them. So I would not listen to any criticism of their doctrines, even though many claimed that their ideas about God were mistaken and that they had become followers of the leader of the current heresy and were secretly spreading his teaching. But since I had never heard these things with my own ears, I concluded that those who reported them were slanderers. Then I was called to lead the Church. I will say nothing about the watchers and spies who were given to me under the pretense of help and loving fellowship, so that I do not harm my own case by telling an unbelievable story, or give believers a reason to hate their brothers and sisters if I am believed. This nearly happened to me, if I had not been prevented by God's mercy. For almost everyone became an object of suspicion to me, and wounded in heart as I was by treacherous attacks, I seemed to find nothing in anyone that I could trust. But even so, we still maintained a kind of friendship between us. We held discussions on doctrinal matters from time to time, and apparently we seemed to agree and stay united. But they began to discover that I was making the same statements about my faith in God that they had always heard from me. For if other things about me may cause regret, I dare make at least this one boast in the Lord: that I have never for one moment held mistaken ideas about God or entertained heretical opinions that I later had to change. The teaching about God that I received as a boy from my blessed mother and my grandmother Macrina, I have always held with growing conviction. When I reached mature reasoning, I did not shift my views from one position to another, but carried out the principles passed down to me by my parents. Just as a seed when it grows is first tiny and then gets bigger but always keeps its identity, not changed in nature though gradually perfected in growth, so I consider the same doctrine to have grown in my case through gradually advancing stages. What I believe now has not replaced what I believed at the beginning. Let them search their own consciences. Let these men who have now made me the subject of common gossip on the charge of false doctrine, and filled everyone's ears with the defamatory letters they have written against me, so that I am forced to defend myself this way, ask themselves if they have ever heard anything from me that differs from what I now say, and let them remember the judgment seat of Christ.

3. So when I beheld certain men in my own country striving to copy their ways, I felt that I had found a help to my own salvation, and I took the things seen for proof of things unseen. And since the secrets in the hearts of each of us are unknown, I held lowliness of dress to be a sufficient indication of lowliness of spirit; and there was enough to convince me in the coarse cloak, the girdle, and the shoes of untanned hide. And though many were for withdrawing me from their society, I would not allow it, because I saw that they put a life of endurance before a life of pleasure; and, because of the extraordinary excellence of their lives, I became an eager supporter of them. And so it came about that I would not hear of any fault being found with their doctrines, although many maintained that their conceptions about God were erroneous, and that they had become disciples of the champion of the present heresy, and were secretly propagating his teaching. But, as I had never at any time heard these things with my own ears, I concluded that those who reported them were calumniators. Then I was called to preside over the Church. Of the watchmen and spies, who were given me under the pretence of assistance and loving communion, I say nothing, lest I seem to injure my own cause by telling an incredible tale, or give believers an occasion for hating their fellows, if I am believed. This had almost been my own case, had I not been prevented by the mercy of God. For almost every one became an object of suspicion to me, and smitten at heart as I was by wounds treacherously inflicted, I seemed to find nothing in any man that I could trust. But so far there was, nevertheless, a kind of intimacy kept up between us. Once and again we held discussions on doctrinal points. and apparently we seemed to agree and keep together. But they began to find out that I made the same statements concerning my faith in God which they had always heard from me. For, if other things in me may move a sigh, this one boast at least I dare make in the Lord, that never for one moment have I held erroneous conceptions about God, or entertained heterodox opinions, which I have learned later to change. The teaching about God which I had received as a boy from my blessed mother and my grandmother Macrina, I have ever held with increased conviction. On my coming to ripe years of reason I did not shift my opinions from one to another, but carried out the principles delivered to me by my parents. Just as the seed when it grows is first tiny and then gets bigger but always preserves its identity, not changed in kind though gradually perfected in growth, so I reckon the same doctrine to have grown in my case through gradually advancing stages. What I hold now has not replaced what I held at the beginning. Let them search their own consciences. Let these men who have now made me the common talk on the charge of false doctrine, and deafened all men's ears with the defamatory letters which they have written against me, so that I am compelled thus to defend myself, ask themselves if they have ever heard anything from me, differing from what I now say, and let them remember the judgment seat of Christ.

I am accused of blasphemy against God. Yet it is impossible for anyone to convict me based on any written work about the faith that they bring forward against me, nor can I be charged based on statements I have made verbally, without being written down, in God's churches. Not a single witness has been found to say that he ever heard anything from me, when speaking privately, that contradicts true religion. So if I am not an unorthodox writer, if no fault can be found with my preaching, if I do not lead astray those who talk with me in my own home, on what basis am I being judged? But here is a new invention! The charge goes like this: someone in Syria has written something inconsistent with true religion, and twenty years ago or more you wrote him a letter—so you are an accomplice of this man, and what is alleged against him is alleged against you. O truth-loving sir, I reply, you who have been taught that lies are the offspring of the devil: what has proved to you that I wrote that letter? You never sent anyone; you never asked; you were never informed by me, who could have told you the truth. But even if the letter was mine, how do you know that the document now in your hands is from the same date as my letter? Who told you it is twenty years old? How do you know it is a composition by the man to whom my letter was sent? And even if he was the author, and I wrote to him, and my letter and his composition are from the same date, what proof is there that I accepted it in my judgment and that I hold those views?

4. I am charged with blasphemy against God. Yet it is impossible for me to be convicted on the ground of any treatise concerning the Faith, which they urge against me, nor can I be charged on the ground of the utterances which I have from time to time delivered by word of mouth, without their being committed to writing, in the churches of God. Not a single witness has been found to say that he has ever heard from me, when speaking in private, anything contrary to true religion. If then I am not an unorthodox writer, if no fault can be found with my preaching, if I do not lead astray those who converse with me in my own home, on what ground am I being judged? But there is a new invention! Somebody, runs the charge, in Syria has written something inconsistent with true religion; and twenty years or more ago you wrote him a letter: so you are an accomplice of the fellow, and what is urged against him is urged against you. O truth-loving sir, I reply, you who have been taught that lies are the offspring of the devil; what has proved to you that I wrote that letter? You never sent; you never asked; you were never informed by me, who might have told you the truth. But if the letter was mine, how do you know that the document that has come into your hands now is of the same date as my letter? Who told you that it is twenty years old? How do you know that it is a composition of the man to whom my letter was sent? And if he was the composer, and I wrote to him, and my letter and his composition belong to the same date, what proof is there that I accepted it in my judgment, and that I hold those views?

Ask yourself. How often did you visit me at my monastery on the Iris River when my deeply beloved brother Gregory was with me, living the same way of life? Did you ever hear anything like this? Was there any sign of such a thing, whether small or great? How many days did we spend in the village across the way at my mother's home, living as friend with friend and talking together night and day? Did you ever find me holding any such opinion? And when we traveled together to visit the blessed Silvanus, did we not discuss these matters along the way? And at Eusinoe, when you were preparing to leave with other bishops for Lampsacus, was our conversation not about the faith? Were your stenographers not at my side the whole time while I was dictating my objections to the heresy? Were your most faithful disciples not there as well? When I was visiting the brothers and spending the night with them in their prayers, constantly speaking and hearing about the things of God without argument, was the evidence I gave of my beliefs not exact and clear? How is it, then, that you now consider this weak and flimsy suspicion more important than the experience of such a long period of time?

5. Ask yourself. How often did you visit me in my monastery on the Iris, when my very God-beloved brother Gregory was with me, following the same course of life as myself? Did you ever hear anything of the kind? Was there any appearance of such a thing, small or great? How many days did we spend in the opposite village, at my mother's, living as friend with friend, and discoursing together night and day? Did you ever find me holding any opinion of the kind? And when we went together to visit the blessed Silvanus, did we not talk of these things on the way? And at Eusinoe, when you were about to set out with other bishops for Lampsacus, was not our discourse about the faith? Were not your shorthand writers at my side the whole time while I was dictating my objections to the heresy? Were not your most faithful disciples there too? When I was visiting the brotherhood, and passing the night with them in their prayers, continually speaking and hearing of the things pertaining to God without dispute, was not the evidence which I gave of my sentiments exact and definite? How came you then to reckon this rotten and slender suspicion as of more importance than the experience of such a length of time?

What evidence of my state of mind should you have trusted more than your own? Has there been the slightest inconsistency in my statements about the faith at Chalcedon, repeatedly at Heraclea, and earlier in the suburb of Caesarea? Don't they all agree with each other? The only exception is the increase in strength I mentioned before, which comes from growth and should not be seen as a change from worse to better, but rather as a completing of what was lacking through the addition of knowledge. How can you forget that the father will not bear the guilt of the son, nor the son bear the guilt of the father, but each will die for his own sin? I have neither father nor son whom you have slandered; I have had neither teacher nor student. But if the sins of parents must be charged against their children, it would be far more just for the sins of Arius to be charged against his disciples, and for whoever fathered the heretic Aetius to have the charges against the son applied to the father. If, on the other hand, it is unjust for anyone to be accused because of them, it is far more unjust that I should be held responsible because of men with whom I have nothing to do, even if they were complete sinners in every way and had written something worthy of condemnation. I must be forgiven if I don't believe everything that is said against them, since my own experience shows me how very easy it is for accusers to fall into slander.

What evidence of my frame of mind ought you to have preferred to your own? Has there been the slightest want of harmony in my utterances about the faith at Chalcedon, again and again at Heraclea, and at an earlier period in the suburb of Cæsarea? Are they not all mutually consistent? I only except the increase in force of which I spoke just now, resulting from advance, and which is not to be regarded as a change from worse to better, but rather as a filling up of what was wanting in the addition of knowledge. How can you fail to bear in mind that the father shall not bear the iniquity of the son, nor the son bear the iniquity of the father, but each shall die in his own sin? I have neither father nor son slandered by you; I have had neither teacher nor disciple. But if the sins of the parents must be made charges against their children, it is far fairer for the sins of Arius to be charged against his disciples; and, whoever begot the heretic Aetius, for the charges against the son to be applied to the father. If on the other hand it is unjust for any one to be accused for their sakes, it is far more unjust that I should be held responsible for the sake of men with whom I have nothing to do, even if they were in every respect sinners, and something worthy of condemnation has been written by them. I must be pardoned if I do not believe all that is urged against them. since my own experience shows me how very easy it is for accusers to slip into slander.

Even if they did come forward to accuse me because they had been deceived and thought I was connected with those who wrote the words of Sabellius that they are circulating, their conduct was inexcusable. They immediately attacked and wounded me, though I had done them no wrong, before they had obtained clear proof. I do not want to speak of myself as being bound to them in the closest friendship, or of them as clearly not being led by the Holy Spirit because they are nurturing false suspicions. Anyone who is about to cut himself off from a brother's friendship must give the matter deep thought, spend many sleepless nights, and seek the truth from God with many tears. Even the rulers of this world, when they are about to sentence some criminal to death, pull back the veil, call in experts to examine the case, spend considerable time weighing the severity of the law against humanity's common weakness, and with many sighs and laments over the harsh necessity, announce publicly that they are obeying the law out of necessity, not passing sentence to satisfy their own desires. How much greater care and diligence, how much more deliberation, should be exercised by someone who is about to break off a long-established friendship with a brother! In this case there is only a single letter, and even its authenticity is doubtful. It would be completely impossible to verify it by the signature, since they do not possess the original but only a copy. They are relying on one single document, and an old one at that. It is now twenty years since anything was written to that person. As for my opinions and conduct during the time since then, I can produce no better witnesses than the very men who are attacking and accusing me.

6. Even if they did come forward to accuse me, because they had been deceived, and thought that I was associated with the writers of those words of Sabellius which they are carrying about, they were guilty of unpardonable conduct in straightway attacking and wounding me, when I had done them no wrong, before they had obtained plain proof. I do not like to speak of myself as bound to them in the closest intimacy; or of them as being evidently not led by the Holy Spirit, because of their cherishing false suspicions. Much anxious thought must be taken, and many sleepless nights must be passed, and with many tears must the truth be sought from God, by him who is on the point of cutting himself off from a brother's friendship. Even the rulers of this world, when they are on the point of sentencing some evil doer to death, draw the veil aside, and call in experts for the examination of the case, and consume considerable time in weighing the severity of the law against the common fault of humanity, and with many a sigh and many a lament for the stern necessity of the case, proclaim before all the people that they are obeying the law from necessity, and not passing sentence to gratify their own wishes. How much greater care and diligence, how much more counsel, ought to be taken by one who is on the point of breaking off from long established friendship with a brother! In this case there is only a single letter and that of doubtful genuineness. It would be quite impossible to argue that it is known by the signature, for they possess not the original, but only a copy. They depend on one single document and that an old one. It is now twenty years since anything has been written to that person. Of my opinions and conduct in the intervening time I can adduce no better witnesses than the very men who attack and accuse me.

But the real reason for the separation is not this letter. There is another cause of the alienation. I am ashamed to mention it, and I would have remained silent about it forever if recent events had not forced me to reveal all their thinking for the sake of the good of the majority of the people. Good men have thought that being in communion with me was an obstacle to their regaining their authority. Some have been influenced by the signing of a certain creed that I proposed to them—not because I distrusted their beliefs, I admit, but because I wanted to remove the suspicions that most of the brothers who agree with me had about them. So, to prevent anything arising from that confession that might hinder their acceptance by the present authorities, they have renounced communion with me. This letter was devised as an afterthought to provide a pretext for the separation. A very clear proof of what I am saying is that after they denounced me and composed whatever complaints against me suited them, they sent their letters out in all directions before communicating with me. Their letter was already in the hands of others who had received it in the course of its transmission and who were about to send it on seven days before it reached my hands. The plan was that it would be passed from one person to another and so would be quickly distributed throughout the whole region. This was reported to me at the time by those who were giving me accurate information about all their activities. But I decided to keep silent until the Revealer of all secrets should expose their actions through plain and undeniable proof.

7. But the real reason of separation is not this letter. There is another cause of alienation. I am ashamed to mention it; and I would have been for ever silent about it had not recent events compelled me to publish all their mind for the sake of the good of the mass of the people. Good men have thought that communion with me was a bar to the recovery of their authority. Some have been influenced by the signature of a certain creed which I proposed to them, not that I distrusted their sentiments, I confess, but because I wished to do away with the suspicions which the more part of the brethren who agree with me entertained of them. Accordingly, to avoid anything arising from that confession to prevent their being accepted by the present authorities, they have renounced communion with me. This letter was devised by an after-thought as a pretext for the separation. A very plain proof of what I say is, that after they had denounced me, and composed such complaints against me as suited them, they sent round their letters in all directions before communicating with me. Their letter was in the possession of others who had received it in the course of transmission and who were on the point of sending it on seven days before it had reached my hands. The idea was that it would be handed from one to another and so would be quickly distributed over the whole country. This was reported to me at the time by those who were giving me clear information of all their proceedings. But I determined to hold my tongue until the Revealer of all secrets should publish their doings by plain and incontrovertible demonstration.


Letters — Letter 224 — To Eustathius of Sebaste

Continuing Basil’s self-defense and account of the controversy with Eustathius.

Source: Translated by Blomfield Jackson. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series , Vol. 8. Edited by Philip Schaff and Henry Wace. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1895. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/3202224.htm>.

Opening

ST. BASIL OF CAESAREA

ST. BASIL OF CAESAREA

To the presbyter Genethlius.

To the presbyter Genethlius.

I have received your reverence's letter and I am delighted at the title which you have aptly applied to the writing they have composed, calling it a writing of divorcement. I cannot imagine what defense the writers will be able to make before the tribunal of Christ, where no excuse will be of any use. After accusing me, violently attacking me, and spreading stories not according to the truth but according to what they wished to be true, they have put on a great show of humility and have accused me of arrogance for refusing to receive their envoys. They have written what is all—or nearly all, for I do not wish to exaggerate—lies, trying to persuade men rather than God, and to please men rather than God, with Whom nothing is more precious than truth. Furthermore, they have inserted heretical expressions into the letter written against me, and have concealed the author of the impiety, so that most of the more unsophisticated people might be deceived by the slander fabricated against me and suppose that the inserted portion is mine. For my clever slanderers say nothing about the name of the author of these vile doctrines, and it is left for simple people to suspect that these inventions, if not their actual written expression, are due to me. Now that you know all this, I urge you not to be disturbed yourselves, and to calm the agitation of those who are upset. I say this even though I know it will not be easy for my defense to be accepted, because I have already been undermined by the vile slanders uttered against me by influential persons.

1. I have received your reverence's letter and I am delighted at the title which you have felicitously applied to the writing which they have composed in calling it a writing of divorcement. Matthew 19:7 What defense the writers will be able to make before the tribunal of Christ, where no excuse will avail, I am quite unable to conceive. After accusing me, violently running me down, and telling tales in accordance not with the truth but with what they wished to be true, they have assumed a great show of humility, and have accused me of haughtiness for refusing to receive their envoys. They have written, as they have, what is all — or nearly all — for I do not wish to exaggerate — lies, in the endeavour to persuade men rather than God, and to please men rather than God, with Whom nothing is more precious than truth. Moreover into the letter written against me they have introduced heretical expressions, and have concealed the author of the impiety, in order that most of the more unsophisticated might be deceived by the calumny got up against me, and suppose the portion introduced to be mine. For nothing is said by my ingenious slanderers as to the name of the author of these vile doctrines, and it is left for the simple to suspect that these inventions, if not their expression in writing, is due to me. Now that you know all this, I exhort you not to be perturbed yourselves, and to calm the excitement of those who are agitated. I say this although I know that it will not be easy for my defense to be received, because I have been anticipated by the vile calumnies uttered against me by persons of influence.

Now regarding the claim that the writings circulating under my name are not mine at all, their anger toward me so clouds their judgment that they cannot see what is truly beneficial. Nevertheless, if you were to question them directly, I believe they would not reach such a level of stubborn perversity as to dare to speak the lie with their own lips and claim that the document in question is mine. And if it is not mine, why am I being judged for other people's writings? But they will insist that I am in communion with Apollinarius and harbor perverse doctrines of this kind in my heart. Let them be asked for proof. If they are able to examine a person's heart, let them say so, and you should accept as true everything they say about everything. If, on the other hand, they are trying to prove my communion on clear and visible grounds, let them produce either a canonical letter written by me to him or by him to me. Let them show that I have had dealings with his clergy or have ever received any of them into communion of prayer. If they bring forward the letter written some twenty-five years ago, written by a layman to a layman—and not even as I wrote it, but altered (God knows by whom)—then recognize their unfairness. No bishop is accused if, while he was a layman, he wrote something somewhat carelessly on an unimportant matter—not anything concerning the faith, but a mere word of friendly greeting. Very likely even my opponents are known to have written to Jews and to pagans without incurring any blame. Up to now no one has ever been judged for conduct such as that for which I am being condemned by these strainers-out of gnats. God, who knows human hearts, knows that I never wrote these things nor approved them, but that I anathematize all who hold the vile opinion of the confusion of the hypostases, on which point the most impious heresy of Sabellius has been revived. And all the brothers who have personally known my insignificant self know this equally well. Let those very men who now vehemently accuse me search their own consciences, and they will admit that from my boyhood I have been far removed from any doctrine of this kind.

2. Now as to the point that the writings going the round as mine are not mine at all, the angry feeling felt against me so confuses their reason that they cannot see what is profitable. Nevertheless, if the question were put to them by yourselves, I do think that they would not reach such a pitch of obstinate perversity as to dare to utter the lie with their own lips, and allege the document in question to be mine. And if it is not mine, why am I being judged for other men's writings? But they will urge that I am in communion with Apollinarius, and cherish in my heart perverse doctrines of this kind. Let them be asked for proof. If they are able to search into a man's heart, let them say so; and do you admit the truth of all that they say about everything. If on the other hand, they are trying to prove my being in communion on plain and open grounds, let them produce either a canonical letter written by me to him, or by him to me. Let them show that I have held intercourse with his clergy, or have ever received any one of them into the communion of prayer. If they adduce the letter written now five and twenty years ago, written by layman to layman, and not even this as I wrote it, but altered (God knows by whom), then recognise their unfairness. No bishop is accused if, while he was a layman, he wrote something somewhat incautiously on an indifferent matter; not anything concerning the Faith, but a mere word of friendly greeting. Possibly even my opponents are known to have written to Jews and to Pagans, without incurring any blame. Hitherto no one has ever been judged for any such conduct as that on which I am being condemned by these strainers-out of gnats. God, who knows men's hearts, knows that I never wrote these things, nor sanctioned them, but that I anathematize all who hold the vile opinion of the confusion of the hypostases, on which point the most impious heresy of Sabellius has been revived. And all the brethren who have been personally acquainted with my insignificant self know it equally well. Let those very men who now vehemently accuse me, search their own consciences, and they will own that from my boyhood I have been far removed from any doctrine of the kind.

If anyone asks what my opinion is, he will learn it from the actual short document, which has their own handwritten signature attached to it. They want to destroy this, and they are eager to hide their own change of position by slandering me. They do not want to admit that they have regretted signing the tract I gave them, while they accuse me of impiety based on the assumption that no one realizes their break from me is only a pretext, when in reality they have departed from that faith which they have repeatedly acknowledged in writing, before many witnesses, and have most recently received and signed when I delivered it to them. Anyone can read the signatures and learn the truth from the document itself. Their intention will be clear if, after reading the subscription they gave me, anyone reads the creed they gave Gelasius and observes what a vast difference there is between the two confessions. It would be better for men who so easily shift their own position not to examine other men's specks but to cast out the beam in their own eye. I am making a more complete defense on every point in another letter, which will satisfy readers who want fuller assurance. Now that you have received this letter, put away all discouragement and strengthen the love toward me which makes me eagerly long for union with you. Truly it is a great sorrow to me, and a pain in my heart that cannot be relieved, if the slanders spoken against me succeed in cooling your love and alienating us from one another. Farewell.

3. If any one enquires what my opinion is, he will learn it from the actual little document, to which is appended their own autograph signature. This they wish to destroy, and they are anxious to conceal their own change of position in slandering me. For they do not like to own that they have repented of their subscription to the tract I gave them; while they charge me with impiety from the idea that no one perceives that their disruption from me is only a pretext, while in reality they have departed from that faith which they have over and over again owned in writing, before many witnesses, and have lastly received and subscribed when delivered to them by me. It is open to any one to read the signatures and to learn the truth from the document itself. Their intention will be obvious, if, after reading the subscription which they gave me, any one reads the creed which they gave Gelasius, and observes what a vast difference there is between the two confessions. It would be better for men who so easily shift their own position, not to examine other men's motes but to cast out the beam in their own eye. I am making a more complete defense on every point in another letter; this will satisfy readers who want fuller assurance. Do you, now that you have received this letter, put away all despondency, and confirm the love to me, which makes me eagerly long for union with you. Verily it is a great sorrow to me, and a pain in my heart that cannot be assuaged, if the slanders uttered against me so far prevail as to chill your love and to alienate us from one another. Farewell.


Letters — Letter 225 — To Eustathius of Sebaste

The conclusion of Basil’s autobiographical self-defense regarding Eustathius.

Source: Translated by Blomfield Jackson. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series , Vol. 8. Edited by Philip Schaff and Henry Wace. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1895. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/3202225.htm>.

Opening

ST. BASIL OF CAESAREA

ST. BASIL OF CAESAREA

To Demosthenes, as from the synod of bishops.

To Demosthenes, as from the synod of bishops.

I am always very thankful to God and to the emperor, under whose rule we live, when I see the government of my country placed in the hands of someone who is not only a Christian but also upright in life and a careful guardian of the laws by which our life in this world is ordered. I have had special reason to offer this gratitude to God and to our God-beloved emperor on the occasion of your coming among us. I have been aware that some enemies of peace have been trying to stir your august tribunal against me, and I have been waiting to be summoned by your excellency so that you might learn the truth from me—if indeed your high wisdom considers the examination of ecclesiastical matters to be within your jurisdiction. The tribunal passed over me, but your excellency, moved by the accusations of Philochares, ordered my brother and fellow minister Gregory to be brought before your judgment seat. He obeyed your summons—how could he do otherwise? But he was attacked by pain in the side, and at the same time, because of a chill, was attacked by his old kidney complaint. He has therefore been compelled, forcibly detained by your soldiers as he was, to be taken to some quiet place where he could have his illnesses treated and get some relief from his unbearable agony. Under these circumstances we have joined together to approach your lordship with the request that you will not be angry at the postponement of the trial. The public interests have not in any way suffered through our delay, nor have those of the Church been injured. If there is any question about the wasteful spending of money, the treasurers of the Church funds are there, ready to give an account to anyone who wishes and to demonstrate the injustice of the charges brought by men who have avoided a careful hearing of the case before you. For they can easily make the truth clear to anyone who seeks it from the actual writings of the blessed bishop himself. If there is any other point of canonical order that requires investigation, and your excellency agrees to hear and judge it, it will be necessary for all of us to be present, because if there has been a failure in any point of canonical order, the responsibility lies with the consecrators and not with him who is forcibly compelled to undertake the ministry. We therefore ask you to reserve the hearing of the case for us in our own country, and not to compel us to travel beyond its borders, nor force us to meet with bishops with whom we have not yet reached agreement on ecclesiastical questions. I also beg you to be merciful to my own old age and poor health. You will learn by actual investigation, if it pleases God, that no canonical rule, whether small or great, was omitted in the appointment of the bishop. I pray that under your administration unity and peace may be brought about with my brethren; but as long as this does not exist it is difficult for us even to meet, because many of our simpler brethren suffer from our mutual disputes.

I am always very thankful to God and to the emperor, under whose rule we live, when I see the government of my country put into the hands of one who is not only a Christian, but is moreover correct in life and a careful guardian of the laws according to which our life in this world is ordered. I have had special reason for offering this gratitude to God and to our God-beloved emperor on the occasion of your coming among us. I have been aware that some of the enemies of peace have been about to stir your august tribunal against me, and have been waiting to be summoned by your excellency that you might learn the truth from me; if indeed your high wisdom condescends to consider the examination of ecclesiastical matters to be within your province. The tribunal overlooked me, but your excellency, moved by the reproaches of Philochares, ordered my brother and fellow-minister Gregory to be haled before your judgment seat. He obeyed your summons; how could he do otherwise? But he was attacked by pain in the side, and at the same time, in consequence of a chill, was attacked by his old kidney complaint. He has therefore been compelled, forcibly detained by your soldiers as he was, to be conveyed to some quiet spot, where he could have his maladies attended to, and get some comfort in his intolerable agony. Under these circumstances we have combined to approach your lordship with the entreaty that you will feel no anger at the postponement of the trial. The public interests have not in any way suffered through our delay, nor have those of the Church been injured. If there is any question of the wasteful expenditure of money, the treasurers of the Church funds are there, ready to give an account to any one who likes, and to exhibit the injustice of the charges advanced by men who have braved the careful hearing of the case before you. For they can have no difficulty in making the truth clear to any one who seeks it from the actual writings of the blessed bishop himself. If there is any other point of canonical order which requires investigation, and your excellency deigns to undertake to hear and to judge it, it will be necessary for us all to be present, because, if there has been a failure in any point of canonical order, the responsibility lies with the consecrators and not with him who is forcibly compelled to undertake the ministry. We therefore petition you to reserve the hearing of the case for us in our own country, and not to compel us to travel beyond its borders, nor force us to a meeting with bishops with whom we have not yet come to agreement on ecclesiastical questions. I beg you also to be merciful to my own old age and ill health. You will learn by actual investigation, if it please God, that no canonical rule be it small or great was omitted in the appointment of the bishop. I pray that under your administration unity and peace may be brought about with my brethren; but so long as this does not exist it is difficult for us even to meet, because many of our simpler brethren suffer from our mutual disputes.


Letters — Letter 243 — To the Bishops of Italy and Gaul

A later, more urgent appeal in the same unity campaign as Letter 92.

Source: Translated by Blomfield Jackson. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series , Vol. 8. Edited by Philip Schaff and Henry Wace. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1895. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/3202243.htm>.

Opening

ST. BASIL OF CAESAREA

ST. BASIL OF CAESAREA

To the bishops of Italy and Gaul concerning the state and disorder of the Churches.

To the bishops of Italy and Gaul concerning the condition and confusion of the Churches.

To his brothers truly beloved by God and very dear, and fellow ministers of like mind, the bishops of Gaul and Italy, Basil, bishop of Caesarea in Cappadocia. Our Lord Jesus Christ, who has graciously called the universal Church of God His body, and has made us individually members one of another, has also granted to all of us to live in close association with one another, as suits the unity of the members. Therefore, although we live far away from one another, yet regarding our close connection, we are very near. Since, then, the head cannot say to the feet, I have no need of you, you will not, I am sure, bear to reject us; you will, on the contrary, sympathize with us in the troubles to which, because of our sins, we have been handed over, in the same measure as we rejoice together with you in your glory in the peace which the Lord has given you. Previously we have also on another occasion called upon your love to send us help and sympathy; but our punishment was not complete, and you were not permitted to rise up to help us. One chief goal of our desire is that through you the state of confusion in which we find ourselves should be made known to the emperor of your part of the world. If this is difficult, we beg you to send envoys to visit and comfort us in our affliction, so that you may have the evidence of eyewitnesses of those sufferings of the East which cannot be told by word of mouth, because language is inadequate to give a clear account of our condition.

1. To his brethren truly God-beloved and very dear, and fellow ministers of like mind, the bishops of Gaul and Italy, Basil, bishop of Cæsarea in Cappadocia. Our Lord Jesus Christ, Who has deigned to style the universal Church of God His body, and has made us individually members one of another, has moreover granted to all of us to live in intimate association with one another, as befits the agreement of the members. Wherefore, although we dwell far away from one another, yet, as regards our close conjunction, we are very near. Since, then, the head cannot say to the feet, I have no need of you, 1 Corinthians 12:21 you will not, I am sure, endure to reject us; you will, on the contrary, sympathize with us in the troubles to which, for our sins, we have been given over, in proportion as we rejoice together with you in your glorying in the peace which the Lord has bestowed on you. Ere now we have also at another time invoked your charity to send us succour and sympathy; but our punishment was not full, and you were not suffered to rise up to succour us. One chief object of our desire is that through you the state of confusion in which we are situated should be made known to the emperor of your part of the world. If this is difficult, we beseech you to send envoys to visit and comfort us in our affliction, that you may have the evidence of eyewitnesses of those sufferings of the East which cannot be told by word of mouth, because language is inadequate to give a clear report of our condition.

Persecution has come upon us, most honourable brothers, and persecution in its most severe form. Shepherds are being persecuted so that their flocks may be scattered. The worst part is that those who are suffering cannot accept their hardships as proof of their witness, nor can the people honour these fighters as part of the army of martyrs, because the name of Christians is being used by the persecutors themselves. The one charge that now guarantees harsh punishment is carefully keeping the traditions of the Fathers. Because of this, the faithful are exiled from their homes and sent to live in distant regions. The unjust judges show no respect for grey hair, for genuine godliness, or for a life lived from youth to old age according to the Gospel. No criminal is condemned without evidence, but bishops have been convicted on false accusations alone and sentenced to punishments based on charges completely unsupported by proof. Some have not even known who accused them, nor been brought before any court, nor even been falsely accused at all. They have been seized violently late at night, exiled to distant places, and through the hardships of these remote wastelands, handed over to death. The rest is well known, though I do not mention it—the flight of priests, the flight of deacons, the plundering of all the clergy. Either the image must be worshipped, or we are handed over to the cruel burning of whips. The laity groan; tears fall without stopping in public and in private; everyone laments their sorrows together. No one's heart is so hard that they can lose a father and bear the loss calmly. There is a sound of mourning in the city—a sound in the fields, on the roads, in the deserts. One voice is heard from all who speak sad and pitiful words. Joy and spiritual gladness are taken away. Our feasts are turned into mourning. Our houses of prayer are shut. The altars of spiritual worship lie idle. Christians no longer gather together; teachers no longer lead. The teachings of salvation are no longer taught. We have no more solemn assemblies, no more evening hymns, no more of that blessed joy of souls that arises in the souls of all who believe in the Lord during communions and the sharing of spiritual gifts. We may well say, neither is there at this time prince, or prophet, or reader, or offering, or incense, or place to sacrifice before you, and to find mercy.

2. Persecution has come upon us, right honourable brethren, and persecution in the severest form. Shepherds are persecuted that their flocks may be scattered. And the worst of all is that those who are being treated ill cannot accept their sufferings in proof of their testimony, nor can the people reverence the athletes as in the army of martyrs, because the name of Christians is applied to the persecutors. The one charge which is now sure to secure severe punishment is the careful keeping of the traditions of the Fathers. For this the pious are exiled from their homes, and are sent away to dwell in distant regions. No reverence is shown by the judges of iniquity to the hoary head, to practical piety, to the life lived from boyhood to old age according to the Gospel. No malefactor is doomed without proof, but bishops have been convicted on calumny alone, and are consigned to penalties on charges wholly unsupported by evidence. Some have not even known who has accused them, nor been brought before any tribunal, nor even been falsely accused at all. They have been apprehended with violence late at night, have been exiled to distant places, and, through the hardships of these remote wastes, have been given over to death. The rest is notorious, though I make no mention of it — the flight of priests; the flight of deacons; the foraying of all the clergy. Either the image must be worshipped, or we are delivered to the wicked flame of whips. The laity groan; tears are falling without ceasing in public and in private; all are mutually lamenting their woes. No one's heart is so hard as to lose a father, and bear the bereavement meekly. There is a sound of them that mourn in the city — a sound in the fields, in the roads, in the deserts. But one voice is heard from all that utter sad and piteous words. Joy and spiritual gladness are taken away. Our feasts are turned into mourning. Amos 8:10 Our houses of prayer are shut. The altars of the spiritual service are lying idle. Christians no longer assemble together; teachers no longer preside. The doctrines of salvation are no longer taught. We have no more solemn assemblies, no more evening hymns, no more of that blessed joy of souls which arises in the souls of all that believe in the Lord at communions, and the imparting of spiritual boons. We may well say, Neither is there at this time prince, or prophet, or reader, or offering, or incense, or place to sacrifice before you, and to find mercy.

We are writing to those who already know these things, for there is no region of the world that is unaware of our troubles. Do not think we are using these words to inform you or to remind you who we are. We know you could no more forget us than a mother could forget the children she has borne. But all who are crushed under any heavy burden of suffering find some natural relief for their pain in expressing their distress aloud, and that is why we are doing what we do. We lighten the weight of our grief by telling you about our many misfortunes and by expressing the hope that you may perhaps be more moved to pray for us and may persuade the Lord to be reconciled to us. If these troubles affected only ourselves, we might have decided to remain silent and to rejoice in our sufferings for Christ's sake, since the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with the glory which shall be revealed in us. But right now we are alarmed that the harm growing day by day, like a flame spreading through burning wood, may consume what is nearby and then catch distant areas too. The plague of heresy is spreading, and there is reason to fear that after it has devoured our churches, it may creep on even as far as the sound part of your region. Perhaps it is because lawlessness has increased among us that we have been first handed over to be devoured by the cruel teeth of the enemies of God. But the gospel of the kingdom began in our regions and then went out into all the world. So perhaps—and this is most probable—the common enemy of our souls is working to bring it about that the seeds of apostasy, originating in the same place, should be spread throughout the world. For the darkness of ungodliness seeks to overtake the very hearts upon which the light of the knowledge of Christ has shone.

3. We are writing to those who know these things, for there is not a region of the world which is ignorant of our calamities. Do not suppose that we are using these words as though to give information, or to recall ourselves to your recollection. We know that you could no more forget us than a mother forget the sons of her womb. Isaiah 49:15 But all who are crushed by any weight of agony find some natural alleviation for their pain in uttering groans of distress, and it is for this that we are doing as we do. We get rid of the load of our grief in telling you of our manifold misfortunes, and in expressing the hope that you may haply be the more moved to pray for us, and may prevail on the Lord to be reconciled to us. And if these afflictions had been confined to ourselves, we might even have determined to keep silence, and to rejoice in our sufferings for Christ's sake, since the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with the glory which shall be revealed in us. Romans 8:18 But at the present time we are alarmed, lest the mischief growing day by day, like a flame spreading through some burning wood, when it has consumed what is close at hand, may catch distant objects too. The plague of heresy is spreading, and there is ground of apprehension lest, when it has devoured our Churches, it may afterwards creep on even so far as to the sound portion of your district. Peradventure it is because with us iniquity has abounded that we have been first delivered to be devoured by the cruel teeth of the enemies of God. But the gospel of the kingdom began in our regions, and then went forth over all the world. So, perhaps — and this is most probable — the common enemy of our souls, is striving to bring it about that the seeds of apostasy, originating in the same quarter, should be distributed throughout the world. For the darkness of impiety plots to come upon the very hearts whereon the light of the knowledge of Christ has shone.

Consider then, as true disciples of the Lord, that our sufferings are yours. We are not being attacked for the sake of riches, or glory, or any temporal advantages. We stand in the arena to fight for our common heritage, for the treasure of the sound faith that we received from our Fathers. Grieve with us, all of you who love the brethren, at the silencing of our men of true religion, and at the bold and blasphemous words of all who speak unrighteousness against God. The pillars and foundation of the truth have been scattered. We, whose insignificance has allowed us to be overlooked, are now deprived of our right to speak freely. Join the struggle for the people's sake. Do not think only of yourselves as securely anchored in a safe harbor, where the grace of God shelters you from the tempest of wicked winds. Reach out a helping hand to the churches that are being battered by the storm, so that if they are abandoned, they will not suffer complete shipwreck of the faith. Mourn with us that the Only-begotten is being blasphemed and there is no one to contradict it. The Holy Spirit is being despised, and he who is able to refute the error has been sent into exile. Polytheism has prevailed. Our opponents acknowledge a great God and a small God. Son is no longer a name of nature, but is regarded as some kind of honorary title. The Holy Spirit is not viewed as completing the Holy Trinity, nor as participating in the divine and blessed nature, but as somehow one of the created beings, attached to Father and Son merely at random and as occasion may require. Oh that my head were waters, and my eyes a fountain of tears, and I will weep many days for the people who are being driven to destruction by these vile doctrines. The ears of the simple are being led astray and have now grown accustomed to heretical impiety. The children of the Church are being raised in the doctrines of wickedness. What are they to do? Our opponents control the baptisms; they attend the dying on their way; they visit the sick; they comfort the sorrowful; they help the distressed; they give aid of various kinds; they administer the mysteries. All these things, as long as they are performed by our opponents, serve as bonds tying the people to their views. The result will be that in a little while, even if some freedom is granted to us, there is little hope that those who have been long under the influence of error will be brought back to recognition of the truth.

4. Reckon then, as true disciples of the Lord, that our sufferings are yours. We are not being attacked for the sake of riches, or glory, or any temporal advantages. We stand in the arena to fight for our common heritage, for the treasure of the sound faith, derived from our Fathers. Grieve with us, all you who love the brethren, at the shutting of the mouths of our men of true religion, and at the opening of the bold and blasphemous lips of all that utter unrighteousness against God. The pillars and foundation of the truth are scattered abroad. We, whose insignificance has allowed of our being overlooked, are deprived of our right of free speech. Join the struggle, for the people's sake. Do not think only of your being yourselves moored in a safe haven, where the grace of God gives you shelter from the tempest of the winds of wickedness. Reach out a helping hand to the Churches that are being buffeted by the storm, lest, if they be abandoned, they suffer complete shipwreck of the faith. Lament for us, in that the Only-begotten is being blasphemed, and there is none to offer contradiction. The Holy Ghost is being set at nought and he who is able to confute the error has been sent into exile. Polytheism has prevailed. Our opponents own a great God and a small God. Son is no longer a name of nature, but is looked upon as a title of some kind of honour. The Holy Ghost is regarded not as complemental of the Holy Trinity, nor as participating in the divine and blessed Nature, but as in some sort one of the number of created beings, and attached to Father and Son, at mere haphazard and as occasion may require. Oh that my head were waters, and my eyes a fountain of tears, Jeremiah 9:1 and I will weep many days for the people who are being driven to destruction by these vile doctrines. The ears of the simple are being led astray, and have now got used to heretical impiety. The nurslings of the Church are being brought up in the doctrines of iniquity. What are they to do? Our opponents have the command of baptisms; they speed the dying on their way; they visit the sick; they console the sorrowful; they aid the distressed; they give succour of various kinds; they communicate the mysteries. All these things, as long as the performance of them is in their hands, are so many ties to bind the people to their views. The result will be that in a little time, even if some liberty be conceded to us, there is small hope that they who have been long under the influence of error will be recalled to recognition of the truth.

Under these circumstances, it would have been good for many of us to travel to you and individually report our own situation. You can take as proof of how desperate our circumstances are the fact that we are not even free to travel. If anyone leaves his church even for a very short time, he will leave his people at the mercy of those who are plotting to destroy them. By God's mercy, instead of many messengers, we have sent one: our very reverend and beloved brother, the presbyter Dorotheus. He is fully able to explain in person whatever has been left out of our letter, because he has carefully followed everything that has happened and is zealous for the right faith. Welcome him in peace, and quickly send him back to us with good news of your readiness to help the brotherhood.

5. Under these circumstances it would have been well for many of us to have travelled to your reverences, and to have individually reported each his own position. You may now take as a proof of the sore straits in which we are placed the fact that we are not even free to travel abroad. For if any one leaves his Church, even for a very brief space, he will leave his people at the mercy of those who are plotting their ruin. By God's mercy instead of many we have sent one, our very reverend and beloved brother the presbyter Dorotheus. He is fully able to supply by his personal report whatever has been omitted in our letter, for he has carefully followed all that has occurred, and is jealous of the right faith. Receive him in peace, and speedily send him back to us, bringing us good news of your readiness to succour the brotherhood.


Letters to Olympias — Letters to Olympias

Five of Chrysostom’s seventeen surviving letters to the deaconess Olympias, written from exile, on patient endurance of suffering and trust in God’s providence.

The deaconess Olympias to whom seventeen of Chrysostom's extant letters are addressed was the most eminent of his female friends. She belonged to a Pagan family of high rank, and was born about 368. Her father Seleucus who was a count of the Empire died when she was a young girl and she was brought up under the guardianship of an uncle Procopius, who has a devout Christian and a friend of Gregory of Nazianzus. Gregory took great interest in her, speaking of her in his letters as "his own Olympias" and delighting to be addressed by her as "father." Her governess Theodosia, sister of St. Amphilochius of Iconium, was a woman whom Gregory exhorted her to imitate as the very pattern of Christian goodness. The orphan girl had great personal beauty, and was the heiress of a large fortune. Naturally therefore she had many suitors, and in 384 at the age of sixteen she was wedded to Nebridius, a young man of high rank and irreproachable character. The marriage however does not seem to have been a happy one, and perhaps in this fact as well as in the death of her husband about two years after their union, Olympias saw a divine intimation that she should not entangle herself again in the worldly cares and anxieties incident to married life. The Emperor Theodosius wished to unite her to a young Spaniard, Elpidius, a kinsman of his own, and irritated by her refusal, ordered her property to be confiscated until she should have attained her thirtieth year, unless she consented to the proposed union. Olympias however remained inflexible and in a letter of dignified sarcasm thanked the Emperor for relieving her from a heavy burden. "He could not have conferred a greater blessing upon her unless he had ordered her wealth to be bestowed upon the Churches and the poor." Theodosius perceiving the uselessness, if not regretting the injustice, of his harsh decree, cancelled it, and left her in the undisturbed enjoyment of her property. Henceforward her time and wealth were devoted to the service of religion. She ministered to the necessities of the sick and poor, and supported the work of the Church in Greece, Asia Minor and Syria with such lavish donations, not only of her money but of her land, that even Chrysostom, who might be called the great preacher of almsgiving, warned her against indiscriminate liberality, reminding her that as her wealth was a trust committed to her by God she ought to be discreet in the management of it. This salutary advice gained him the ill-will of many avaricious bishops and clergy who had profited, or hoped to profit, by her gifts. She in her turn requited the Archbishop for his spiritual care by many little feminine attentions to his bodily wants, especially by seeing that he was supplied with wholesome food, and did not overstrain his feeble constitution by a too rigid abstinence. She herself however practised the most austere asceticism, renouncing the luxury of the bath, wearing none but old coarse clothing, and subjecting herself to severe restrictions in respect of food and sleep. After the expulsion of Chrysostom from Constantinople 404, through the intrigues of his enemies, Olympias suffered much from the persecution to which all his followers were subjected. She was accused of having been concerned in causing the fire which broke out immediately after his departure, and destroyed the Cathedral Church and the Senate House. Her intrepid demeanour before the præfect who tried in vain to frighten her into a confession of guilt, or induce her to edge Arsacius who had been intruded into the See by an arbitrary exercise of imperial power, excited general admiration; and the tidings of her fortitude were a great consolation to the exiled archbishop in the midst of much bodily suffering, and mental distress. It is not quite certain whether she was driven from Constantinople or voluntarily retired from it; nor have we any definite information concerning the remainder of her life.

Source: Translated by W.R.W. Stephens. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 9. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/1916.htm>.

Contents · 5 chapters
  1. To My Lady
  2. To Olympias
  3. To Olympias
  4. To Olympias
  5. To Olympias

To My Lady

The most reverend and divinely favored deaconess Olympias, I John, Bishop, send greeting in the Lord.

The most reverend and divinely favored deaconess Olympias, I John, Bishop, send greeting in the Lord.

Come now, let me heal the wound of your despondency and scatter the thoughts that gather this cloud of worry around you. For what is it that upsets your mind, and why are you sorrowful and dejected? Is it because of the fierce dark storm that has overtaken the Church, wrapping everything in darkness like a moonless night, growing worse every day, laboring to bring about disastrous shipwrecks, and increasing the ruin of the world? I know all this as well as you do; no one will deny it, and if you wish I will create an image of the things now taking place so as to present the tragedy even more clearly to you. We see a sea stirred up from its very deepest parts, some sailors floating dead on the waves, others swallowed up by them, the planks of the ships breaking apart, the sails torn to shreds, the masts broken, the oars knocked out of the sailors' hands, the pilots sitting on the deck, clasping their knees with their hands instead of holding the rudder, bewailing the hopelessness of their situation with sharp cries and bitter laments, neither sky nor sea clearly visible, but everything one deep and impenetrable darkness, so that no one can see his neighbor, while the roaring of the waves is mighty, and sea monsters attack the crews on every side.

1. Come now let me relieve the wound of your despondency, and disperse the thoughts which gather this cloud of care around you. For what is it which upsets your mind, and why are you sorrowful and dejected? Is it because of the fierce black storm which has overtaken the Church, enveloping all things in darkness as of a night without a moon, and is growing to a head every day, travailing to bring forth disastrous shipwrecks, and increasing the ruin of the world? I know all this as well as you; none shall gainsay it, and if you like I will form an image of the things now taking place so as to present the tragedy yet more distinctly to you. We behold a sea upheaved from the very lowest depths, some sailors floating dead upon the waves, others engulfed by them, the planks of the ships breaking up, the sails torn to tatters, the masts sprung, the oars dashed out of the sailors' hands, the pilots seated on the deck, clasping their knees with their hands instead of grasping the rudder, bewailing the hopelessness of their situation with sharp cries and bitter lamentations, neither sky nor sea clearly visible, but all one deep and impenetrable darkness, so that no one can see his neighbour, while mighty is the roaring of the billows, and monsters of the sea attack the crews on every side.

But how much further should I pursue what cannot be grasped? Whatever image of our present troubles I might seek, words shrink back defeated from the attempt. Nevertheless, even when I look at these disasters, I do not abandon hope for better things, considering who the pilot is in all this—not someone who overcomes the storm through skill, but who calms the raging waters with his rod. But if he does not accomplish this at the outset and quickly, that is his custom—he does not put down these terrible evils at the beginning, but when they have increased and reached their extreme point, and most people have fallen into despair, then he works miraculously and beyond all expectation, thus displaying his own power and training the patience of those who endure these disasters. Therefore do not be discouraged. For there is only one thing, Olympias, that is truly terrible, only one real trial, and that is sin; and I have never stopped constantly repeating this point. But all other things—plots, hostilities, deceptions, slanders, insults, accusations, seizure of property, exile, the sharp sword of the enemy, danger at sea, warfare by the whole world, or anything else you can name—these are mere empty stories. For whatever the nature of these things may be, they are temporary and passing, and they affect a mortal body without doing any harm to the watchful soul. Therefore the blessed Paul, wishing to prove how insignificant both the pleasures and sorrows of this life are, declared the whole truth in one sentence when he said, "For the things which are seen are temporal." 2 Corinthians 4:18 Why then do you fear temporary things that pass away like a flowing river? For such is the nature of present things, whether they are pleasant or painful. And another prophet compared all human prosperity not to grass, but to something even more fragile, describing the whole of it as the flower of grass. For he did not single out any one part of it, such as wealth alone, or luxury alone, or power, or honor; but having gathered all the things that are considered splendid among people under the one term "glory," he said, "all the glory of man is as the flower of grass." Isaiah 40:6

But how much further shall I pursue the unattainable? For whatever image of our present evils I may seek speech shrinks baffled from the attempt. Nevertheless even when I look at these calamities I do not abandon the hope of better things, considering as I do who the pilot is in all this — not one who gets the better of the storm by his art, but calms the raging waters by his rod. But if He does not effect this at the outset and speedily, such is His custom — He does not at the beginning put down these terrible evils, but when they have increased, and come to extremities, and most persons are reduced to despair, then He works wondrously, and beyond all expectation, thus manifesting his own power, and training the patience of those who undergo these calamities. Do not therefore be cast down. For there is only one thing, Olympias, which is really terrible, only one real trial, and that is sin; and I have never ceased continually harping upon this theme; but as for all other things, plots, enmities, frauds, calumnies, insults, accusations, confiscation, exile, the keen sword of the enemy, the peril of the deep, warfare of the whole world, or anything else you like to name, they are but idle tales. For whatever the nature of these things may be they are transitory and perishable, and operate in a mortal body without doing any injury to the vigilant soul. Therefore the blessed Paul, desiring to prove the insignificance both of the pleasures and sorrows relating to this life, declared the whole truth in one sentence when he said — For the things which are seen are temporal. 2 Corinthians 4:18 Why then do you fear temporal things which pass away like the stream of a river. For such is the nature of present things whether they be pleasant or painful. And another prophet compared all human prosperity not to grass, but to another material even more flimsy, describing the whole of it as the flower of grass. For he did not single out any one part of it, as wealth alone, or luxury alone, or power, or honour; but having comprised all the things which are esteemed splendid among men under the one designation of glory he said all the glory of man is as the flower of grass. Isaiah 40:6

You will say, nevertheless, that adversity is terrible and hard to bear. But look at it again in comparison with another image, and then learn to despise it. For the insults, abuses, reproaches, and mockery inflicted by enemies, along with their plots, are compared to a worn-out garment and moth-eaten wool when God says "Fear not the reproach of men, neither be afraid of their revilings, for they shall wax old as does a garment, and like moth-eaten wool so shall they be consumed." Therefore let none of these things that are happening trouble you. Stop calling on this person or that for help, and stop running after shadows (for that is what human alliances are). Instead, persistently call upon Jesus, whom you serve, merely to bow his head, and in a moment all these evils will be dissolved. But if you have already called upon him and they have not yet been dissolved, this is the manner of God's dealing (for I will return to my former argument): He does not put down evils at the outset, but when they have reached their peak, when scarcely any form of the enemy's malice remains ungratified, then He suddenly converts everything to a state of peace and brings them to an unexpected resolution. For He is not only able to turn to good as many things as we expect and hope, but many more—infinitely more. This is why Paul says "now to Him who is able to do exceeding abundantly above all that we ask or think." Could He not, for example, have prevented the three children at the outset from falling into trial? But He did not choose to do this, thereby allowing them to suffer great pain. Therefore He allowed them to be delivered into the hands of barbarians, and the furnace to be heated to an immeasurable degree, and the king's wrath to blaze even more fiercely than the furnace, and their hands and feet to be bound with great severity, and them to be cast into the fire. And then, when all who watched despaired of their rescue, suddenly and beyond all hope, the wonder-working power of God, the supreme craftsman, was displayed and shone forth with exceeding splendor. For the fire was bound and the bondsmen were released, and the furnace became a temple of prayer, a place of fountains and dew, of higher dignity than a royal court, and the very hairs of their head prevailed over that all-devouring element which conquers even iron and stone and masters every kind of substance. And a solemn song of universal praise was instituted there by these holy men, inviting every kind of created thing to join in the wondrous melody. And they uttered hymns of thanksgiving to God for having been bound and also burnt (as far as the malice of their enemies had power), for having been exiles from their country, captives deprived of their liberty, wandering outcasts from city and home, sojourners in a strange and barbarous land—for all this was the outpouring of a grateful heart. And when the malicious devices of their enemies were perfected (for what further could they attempt after their death?) and the labors of the heroes were completed, and the garland of victory was woven, and their rewards were prepared and nothing more was wanting for their renown, then at last their calamities were brought to an end. And he who caused the furnace to be kindled and delivered them over to that great punishment became himself the panegyrist of those holy heroes and the herald of God's marvelous deed. Everywhere throughout the world he issued letters full of reverent praise, recording what had taken place and becoming the faithful herald of the miracles wrought by the wonder-working God. For since he had been an enemy and adversary, what he wrote was above suspicion even in the opinion of enemies.

2. Nevertheless, you will say, adversity is a terrible thing and grievous to be borne. Yet look at it again compared with another image and then also learn to despise it. For the railings, and insults, and reproaches, and gibes inflicted by enemies, and their plots are compared to a worn-out garment, and moth-eaten wool when God says Fear ye not the reproach of men, neither be ye afraid of their revilings, for they shall wax old as does a garment, and like moth-eaten wool so shall they be consumed. Isaiah 50:7-8 Therefore let none of these things which are happening trouble you, but ceasing to invoke the aid of this or that person, and to run after shadows (for such are human alliances), do thou persistently call upon Jesus, whom you serve, merely to bow his head; and in a moment of time all these evils will be dissolved. But if you have already called upon Him, and yet they have not been dissolved, such is the manner of God's dealing (for I will resume my former argument); He does not put down evils at the outset, but when they have grown to a head, when scarcely any form of the enemy's malice remains ungratified, then He suddenly converts all things to a state of tranquillity and conducts them to an unexpected settlement. For He is not only able to turn as many things as we expect and hope, to good, but many more, yea infinitely more. Wherefore also Paul says now to Him who is able to do exceeding abundantly above all that we ask or think. Ephesians 3:20 Could He not, for example, have prevented the three children at the outset from falling into trial? But He did not choose to do this, thereby conferring great pain upon them. Therefore He suffered them to be delivered into the hands of barbarians, and the furnace to be heated to an immeasurable height and the wrath of the king to blaze even more fiercely than the furnace, and hands and feet to be bound with great severity and they themselves to be cast into the fire; and then, when all they who beheld despaired of their rescue, suddenly, and beyond all hope, the wonder-working power of God, the supreme artificer, was displayed, and shone forth with exceeding splendour. For the fire was bound, and the bondmen were released; and the furnace became a temple of prayer, a place of fountains and dew, of higher dignity than a royal court, and the very hairs of their head prevailed over that all devouring element which gets the better even of iron and stone, and masters every kind of substance. And a solemn song of universal praise was instituted there by these holy men inviting every kind of created thing to join in the wondrous melody; and they uttered hymns of thanksgiving to God for that they had been bound, and also burnt, as far at least as the malice of their enemies had power; that they had been exiles from their country, captives deprived of their liberty, wandering outcasts from city and home, sojourners in a strange and barbarous land; for all this was the outpouring of a grateful heart. And when the malicious devices of their enemies were perfected (for what further could they attempt after their death?) and the labours of the heroes were completed, and the garland of victory was woven, and their rewards were prepared and nothing more was wanting for their renown; then at last their calamities were brought to an end, and he who caused the furnace to be kindled, and delivered them over to that great punishment, became himself the panegyrist of those holy heroes, and the herald of God's marvellous deed, and everywhere throughout the world issued letters full of reverent praise, recording what had taken place, and becoming the faithful herald of the miracles wrought by the wonder-working God. For inasmuch as he had been an enemy and adversary what he wrote was above suspicion even in the opinion of enemies.

Do you see the abundance of resources that belong to God? His wisdom, His extraordinary power, His loving-kindness and care? So don't be dismayed or troubled, but continue to give thanks to God for everything, praising and calling on Him, pleading and praying. Even if countless disturbances and troubles come upon you, even if storms are stirred up right before your eyes, don't let any of these things upset you. For our Master is not defeated by difficulty, even if everything is reduced to complete ruin. He is able to raise those who have fallen, to convert those who are in error, to set straight those who have been trapped, to release those who have been burdened with countless sins and make them righteous, to bring the dead to life, to restore brightness to decayed things and freshness to those that have grown old. For if He makes things that don't exist come into being, and gives existence to things that are nowhere evident at all, how much more will He set right things that already exist. But you will say there are many who perish, many who are caught in traps. Many such things have indeed often happened, yet afterward they have all received their proper correction, except for a few who have remained in an incurable condition even after their circumstances changed. Why are you troubled and distressed because one person is cast out and another is put in his place? Christ was crucified and the release of Barabbas the robber was demanded, and the depraved crowd clamored for the preservation of the murderer rather than of the Savior and benefactor. How many do you think stumbled at these things then? How many were destroyed? But I must take my argument even further back. Didn't the one who was crucified become a wanderer and fugitive immediately after his birth? Wasn't He removed from the very cradle with the whole household to a foreign land, taking that long journey into a barbarian region? And this removal gave occasion to torrents of blood, cruel murder and slaughter, and all the young children were cut to pieces just as if they had been soldiers arrayed in battle, and infants torn from the breast were handed over to death, and even when the milk was still in their throats, the sword was driven through their necks. What could be more distressing than this tragedy? And these things were done by the one who sought to destroy Jesus, yet the long-suffering God endured this tragic cruelty that caused so much bloodshed, and held back from preventing it although He had the power, displaying His long-suffering for some inscrutably wise purpose. And when Jesus had returned from the foreign land and was grown up, war was rekindled against Him on every side. First of all, the disciples of John were envious of Him and tried to slander Him, although John himself behaved reverently toward Him, and they said, "He who was with you beyond Jordan, look, the same one baptizes and all men come to Him." For these were the words of men who were already irritated, agitated by ill will, and consumed by that passion. For the same reason, one of the disciples who said these things disputed with a certain Jew and raised a contentious argument about purifying, comparing one kind of baptism with another, the baptism of John with that of the disciples of Christ. For there arose, it is said, a questioning on the part of John's disciples with a certain Jew about purifying. And when He began to work miracles, how many slanderers He had! Some called Him a Samaritan and demoniac, saying, "You are a Samaritan and have a devil"; others a deceiver, saying, "This man is not of God but deceives the multitude"; others a sorcerer, saying, "He casts out devils through Beelzebub the prince of the devils," and they continually said these things against Him and called Him an enemy of God, and a glutton, and a greedy man, and a drunkard, and a friend of the wicked and depraved. For He said, "The Son of man came eating and drinking and they say, 'Look, a gluttonous man and a wine-bibber, a friend of tax collectors and sinners.'" And when He was conversing with the prostitute they called Him a false prophet, for one said, "Had He been a prophet, He would have known who this woman is who speaks to Him." In fact, every day they sharpened their teeth against Him. And not only did the Jews oppose Him in this way, but even those who were thought to be His brothers were not sincerely attached to Him; even from His own family, opposition was kindled against Him. See at least how they also themselves were perverted, from the evangelist adding the remark, "For neither did His brothers believe in Him."

3. Do you see the abundance of resource belonging to God? His wisdom, His extraordinary power, His loving-kindness and care? Be not therefore dismayed or troubled but continue to give thanks to God for all things, praising, and invoking Him; beseeching and supplicating; even if countless tumults and troubles come upon you, even if tempests are stirred up before your eyes let none of these things disturb you. For our Master is not baffled by the difficulty, even if all things are reduced to the extremity of ruin. For it is possible for Him to raise those who have fallen, to convert those who are in error, to set straight those who have been ensnared, to release those who have been laden with countless sins, and make them righteous, to quicken those who are dead, to restore lustre to decayed things, and freshness to those which have waxen old. For if He makes things which are not, come into being, and bestows existence on things which are nowhere by any means manifest, how much more will He rectify things which already exist. But you will say there are many who perish, many who are caught by snares. Many such things have indeed often taken place, yet afterwards have all received their appropriate correction, save some few who have remained in an incurable condition, even after the change in their circumstances. Why are you troubled and distracted because such a person is cast out and such another is put into his place? Christ was crucified and the release of Barabbas the robber was demanded, and the depraved populace clamoured for the preservation of the murderer rather than of the Saviour and benefactor. How many think you then stumbled at these things? How many were destroyed? But I must carry my argument yet further back. Did not He who was crucified become immediately after his birth a wanderer and a fugitive? Was He not from the very cradle removed with the whole household into a strange land, taking that long journey into a barbarous region? And this removal gave occasion to torrents of blood, and cruel murder and slaughter, and all the children of tender age were cut to pieces just as if they had been soldiers arrayed in battle, and infants torn from the breast were handed over to death, and even when the milk was in their throats, the sword was driven through their necks. What could be more distressing than this tragedy? And these things were done by him who sought to destroy Jesus, yet the long-suffering God endured this tragical cruelty, which caused so much bloodshed, and forbore to prevent it although He had the power, displaying his long-suffering for some inscrutably wise purpose. And when Jesus had returned from the foreign land and was grown up, war was rekindled against him on every side. First of all the disciples of John were envious of Him and tried to slander Him, although John himself behaved reverently to Him, and they said He who was with you beyond Jordan, behold the same baptizes and all men come to Him. John 3:26 For these were the words of men who were already irritated, and agitated by ill-will, and consumed by that passion. For the same reason also one of the disciples who said these things disputed with a certain Jew and raised a contentious argument about purifying, comparing one kind of baptism with another, the baptism of John with that of the disciples of Christ. For there arose it is said, a questioning on the part of John's disciples with a certain Jew about purifying. And when He began to work miracles how many calumniators He had! Some called Him a Samaritan and demoniac saying You are a Samaritan and hast a Devil John 8:48 others a deceiver, saying This man is not of God but deceives the multitude John 7:12 others a sorcerer saying He casts out devils through Beelzebub the prince of the Devils Matthew 9:34 and they continually said these things against Him and called Him an adversary of God, and a gluttonous, and greedy man, and a drunkard, and a friend of the wicked and depraved. For He said, the Son of man came eating and drinking and they say behold a gluttonous man and a wine-bibber, a friend of publicans and sinners. Luke 7:34 And when he was conversing with the harlot they called Him a false prophet; For had He been a prophet, one said, He would have known who this woman is which speaks unto Him; Luke 7:39 in fact every day they sharpened their teeth against Him. And not only did the Jews thus oppose Him, but even those who were reputed to be his brethren were not sincerely attached to Him, but even out of his own family opposition was kindled against Him. See at least how they also themselves were perverted, from the evangelist adding the remark for neither did His brethren believe in Him. John 7:5

But since you mention many who were offended and went astray, consider how many of the disciples were offended at the time of the crucifixion. One betrayed Him, the others fled, one denied Him, and when all had abandoned Him He was led away bound without anyone accompanying Him. How many do you think were offended at that time—people who had recently seen Him working His miracles, raising the dead, cleansing lepers, casting out demons, multiplying loaves, and doing every other kind of wonderful deed—when they saw Him led away and bound, surrounded by common soldiers, followed by Jewish priests making a tumult and uproar, alone in the midst, hemmed in by all His enemies, with the traitor standing nearby and exulting in his deed? And what do you think was the effect when He was being scourged? A vast crowd was probably present, because it was a major festival that brought everyone together, and this drama of wickedness was performed in the capital city in the very middle of the day. How many who were present then do you think were offended when they saw Him bound, scourged, streaming with blood, examined before the governor's tribunal, with not one of His disciples standing by? What was the effect again when He was subjected to those many kinds of mockery, one after another, when they crowned Him with thorns, then dressed Him in a gorgeous robe, then put a reed in His hand, then fell down and worshipped Him, setting in motion every kind of mockery and derision? How many do you think were offended, how many bewildered, how many perplexed when they struck Him on the cheek and said, "Prophesy to us, Christ, who is it that struck you?" and when they led Him here and there and spent the whole day in mockery and abuse and ridicule and derision in the midst of the Jewish assembly? And when the servant of the High Priest struck Him; and when the soldiers divided His garments among themselves; and when He was led up to the cross with the marks of the scourge on His back and was fastened to the wood, how many do you think were offended? For not even then were those savage beasts softened, but they became more furious than before, and the tragedy became more intense, and the mockery increased. For some said, "Ah! You who destroy the temple and in three days build it up"; and others said, "He saved others, Himself He cannot save."

4. But since you call to mind many who were offended and went astray, how many of the disciples do you suppose were offended at the time of the crucifixion? One betrayed Him, the others took to flight, one denied Him, and when all had abandoned Him He was led away bound without companions. How many then think you who had lately seen Him working His miracles, raising the dead, cleansing lepers, casting out devils, multiplying loaves, and doing all other kinds of wonderful deeds, were offended at that season, when they beheld Him led away and bound, surrounded by common soldiers, and followed by Jewish priests making a tumult and uproar; alone in the midst hemmed in by all his enemies, and the traitor standing by and exulting in his deed? And what was the effect think you when He was being scourged? And probably a vast multitude was present. For it was an illustrious festival which brought all together, and this drama of iniquity was enacted in the capital city, and in the very middle of the day. How many think you who were present then were offended when they saw Him bound, scourged, streaming with blood, examined before the governor's tribunal, and not one of His disciples standing by? What was the effect again when He was subjected to those manifold kinds of mockery, successively repeated, when they crowned Him with thorns, then arrayed Him in a gorgeous robe, then put a reed in His hand, then fell down and worshipped Him, setting in motion every species of ribaldry and derision? How many think you were offended, how many bewildered, how many perplexed when they smote Him on the cheek and said prophesy unto us you Christ, who is He that smote you? Matthew 26:28 and when they led Him hither and there, and spent the whole day in scoffs and abuse, and ribaldry and derision in the midst of the Jewish assembly? And when the servant of the High-Priest dealt Him a blow; and when the soldiers parted His garments among them and when He was led up to the cross, having the marks of the scourge upon His back, and was fastened to the wood, how many think you were offended? For not even then were those savage beasts softened, but became more furious than before, and the tragedy became more intense, and the ribaldry increased. For some said Ah! Thou that destroyest the temple, and in three days buildest it up; Matthew 27:40 and some, He saved others, Himself He cannot save. Matthew 27:42

And others said, "If you are the Son of God, come down from the cross and we will believe you." (Matthew 27:40)

And others said If you are the Son of God come down from the cross and we will believe you. Matthew 27:40

Again, when they insulted Him by offering Him gall and vinegar on the sponge, how many do you think were offended? Or when the robbers reviled Him? Or when, as I have already said, they made that dreadful and monstrous assertion that the robber and housebreaker, the man burdened with the crime of murder, deserved to be released rather than Jesus, and having received permission from the judge to make their choice, preferred Barabbas, desiring not only to crucify Christ but also to involve Him in disgrace? For they thought that by these means they could create the belief that He was worse than the robber, and such a great transgressor that neither on grounds of mercy nor of the privilege of the Festival was it possible to save Him. For they did everything with a view to slandering His reputation, which was also the reason why they crucified the two robbers with Him. Nevertheless the truth was not obscured but shone forth all the more clearly. And they accused Him of seizing kingly power, saying, "Everyone who makes himself a king is not a friend of Caesar," bringing this charge of usurpation against one who had nowhere to lay his head. Moreover they brought a false accusation of blasphemy against Him. For the High Priest tore his clothes, saying, "He has spoken blasphemy; what further need have we of witnesses?" And what was the nature of his death? Was it not a violent one? Was it not the death of capital offenders? Of detestable criminals? Was it not of the vilest kind? Was it not the death of those who have committed the worst offenses and are not worthy to draw even their last breath upon the earth? And then as to the manner of his burial, was it not accomplished as a matter of favor? For a certain one came and begged for his body. Thus not even he who buried Him belonged to his own friends, to those whom He had benefited, to his disciples, to those who had enjoyed such open and beneficial association with Him, for all had taken flight, all had hurried away from Him. And that base suspicion which his enemies contrived in consequence of the resurrection when they said, "His disciples came and stole Him," how many do you think were offended, how many for a time were upset by that? For the story prevailed at that time, although it was a fabrication and was bought for money; nevertheless it held its ground among some people, after the seals of the tomb were broken, after the clear appearance of the truth. For the multitude did not know the prediction of the resurrection—and no wonder—since even his disciples did not understand it; for we read, "They did not know that He must rise again from the dead." How many therefore do you think were offended in those days? And yet the long-suffering God patiently endured, ordering all things according to His own inscrutable wisdom.

Again when they insulted Him by offering Him gall and vinegar on the sponge how many think you were offended? Or when the robbers reviled Him? Or when as I have already said, they made that dreadful and monstrous assertion that the robber and housebreaker, the man laden with the crime of murder deserved to be released rather than Jesus, and having received permission from the judge to make their choice preferred Barabbas, desiring not only to crucify Christ, but also to involve Him in infamy? For they thought that by these means they should be able to manufacture the belief that He was worse than the robber, and such a great transgressor that neither on the plea of mercy, nor of the privilege of the Festival was it possible to save Him. For they did everything with a view to slander His fame; which also was the reason why they crucified the two robbers with Him. Nevertheless the truth was not obscured, but shone forth all the more clearly. And they accused Him of usurping kingly power saying Every one who makes himself a king is not a friend of Cæsar bringing this charge of usurpation against one who had not where to lay his head. Moreover they brought a calumnious accusation of blasphemy against Him. For the High Priest rent his clothes saying He has spoken blasphemy; what further need have we of witnesses? Matthew 26:65 And what was the nature of his death? Was it not a violent one? Was it not the death of capital offenders? Of execrable criminals? Was it not of the vilest kind? Was it not the death of those who have perpetrated the worst offenses, and are not worthy to draw even their last breath upon the earth? And then as to the manner of his burial, was it not accomplished as a matter of favour? For a certain one came and begged for his body. Thus not even he who buried Him belonged to his own friends, to those whom He had benefited, to his disciples, to those who had enjoyed such free and salutary intercourse with Him, for all had taken to flight, all had hurried away from Him. And that base suspicion which his enemies contrived in consequence of the resurrection when they said His disciples came and stole Him Matthew 28:13 how many think you were offended, how many for a time upset by that? For the story prevailed at that time, although it was a fabrication, and was bought for money; nevertheless it held its ground among some people, after the seals (of the sepulchre were broken) after the manifest appearance of the truth. For the multitude did not know the prediction of the resurrection (and no wonder), inasmuch as even his disciples did not understand it; for we read they did not know that He must rise again from the dead. John 20:9 How many therefore think you were offended in those days? And yet the long-suffering God patiently endured, ordering all things according to His own inscrutable wisdom.

Then again after those days, the disciples continued to live in hiding and secrecy. They were fugitives, full of fear and trembling, constantly moving from place to place. Even when they began to appear after fifty days and to perform miracles, they did not enjoy complete security. But even after those events, there were countless stumbling-blocks to offend the weaker brethren: when they were beaten, when the Church was oppressed, when they themselves were driven away, and their enemies had the upper hand in many places and stirred up riots. For when they had gained much confidence through the miracles they performed, then the death of Stephen once again caused a severe persecution that scattered them all and threw the Church into confusion. The disciples were again frightened, fugitive, and distressed. And yet the Church continued to grow. It flourished through the signs that were performed and became famous because of the manner of its beginning. One disciple, for example, was let down through a window and so escaped the hands of the ruler. Others were brought out of prison by an angel and so released from their chains. Others were received into the houses of common people and craftsmen when they were driven out by those in authority. They were treated kindly in every way by female sellers of purple cloth, by tentmakers, and by tanners living on the outskirts of cities and by the seashore. Often they did not dare to appear in the middle of towns, and if they did venture there themselves, their hosts did not. And so, amidst alternating trials and periods of relief from trial, the fabric of the Church was built. Those who once stumbled were later set upright, those who wandered away were brought back, and the ruined places were built up more firmly than before. For this reason, when Paul prayed that the preaching of the word might proceed along a smooth path, God, who is rich in wisdom and resourcefulness, did not yield to his disciple. Even when invoked many times, he would not consent, but said, "My grace is sufficient for you, for my strength is made perfect in weakness." If you will now count up the good things along with the painful ones, you will see that many events have occurred which, if not actual signs and wonders, still resemble signs and are undeniable proofs of God's great providence and help. But so that you do not simply hear everything from me without any effort, I leave this as your task: that you may carefully count up everything and compare it with the misfortunes. By occupying yourself with this good work, you may turn your mind away from despair, for you will gain much comfort from this task.

5. Then again after those days the disciples continued to live in hiding and secrecy, being fugitives full of fear and trembling, continually shifting from place to place, and even when they began to appear after fifty days, and to work miracles, they did not enjoy perfect security; but even after those events there were innumerable stumbling-blocks to offend the weaker brethren, when they were scourged, when the Church was distressed, when they themselves were driven away, and their enemies had the upper hand in many places, and raised tumults. For when they had acquired much confidence by means of the miracles which they wrought, then the death of Stephen again caused a severe persecution, and dispersed them all, and involved the Church in confusion; and the disciples were again alarmed, fugitive, and distressed. And yet the Church continually grew, when it flourished by means of the signs which were wrought and became illustrious from the manner of its introduction. One disciple for example was let down through a window, and so escaped the hands of the ruler; others were brought out of prison by an angel and so released from their fetters; others were received into the houses of common people and artisans when they were driven out by those in authority; they were courteously treated in every way, by female sellers of purple, by tentmakers, and tanners dwelling in the outskirts of the cities, and by the sea shore. Frequently moreover they did not dare to appear in the middle of the towns; and if they did venture there themselves their entertainers did not. And thus amidst alternate trials, and respites from trial, the fabric of the Church was wrought, and they who once stumbled were afterwards set upright, and they who wandered away were brought back, and the ruined places were built up more firmly than before. For this cause when Paul prayed that the preaching of the word might proceed by a smooth course only, God rich in wisdom and resource did not yield to His disciple; nay even when many times invoked he would not consent but said my grace is sufficient for you, for my strength is made perfect in weakness. 2 Corinthians 12:9 If then even now you will reckon up the good things with the painful, you will see that many events have occurred which if not positive signs and wonders do yet resemble signs, and are unspeakable proofs of the great providence and succour of God. But that you may not hear everything from me without any trouble, I leave this as your task, that you may reckon up everything accurately and compare them with the misfortunes, and by occupying yourself with this good employment may divert your mind from despondency; for you will derive much consolation from this work.

Please give my warm greetings to everyone in your blessed household. May you remain in good health and cheerful spirits, most reverend and divinely favored lady.

Pray say many kind words from me to all your blessed household. May you continue in good health and good spirits, most reverend and divinely favoured lady.

If you want me to write long letters, let me know, and please do not mislead me by saying that you have thrown off all despondency and are enjoying a time of rest. For letters are the right kind of remedy to produce great cheerfulness in you, and you will continually receive letters from me. And when you write to me again, do not say "I have much comfort from your letters," for I already know this myself, but tell me that you have as much comfort as I wish you to have, that you are not overwhelmed with sorrow, that you do not spend your time weeping, but in serenity and cheerfulness.

If you wish me to write long letters inform me of this, and pray do not deceive me by saying that you have thrown off all despondency, and are enjoying a season of rest. For letters are a remedy of the proper kind to produce great cheerfulness in you, and you will continually see letters from me. And when you write to me again do not say I have much comfort from your letters, for this I know of myself, but tell me that you have as much as I wish you to have, that you are not confounded with sorrow, that you do not pass your time in weeping, but in serenity and cheerfulness.

To Olympias

Do not worry about me or torment yourself with anxiety because of the harsh winter, my weak digestion, and the raids by the Isaurians. The winter here is just what winter normally is in Armenia—nothing more needs to be said about it—and it does not harm me too much. I have planned ahead and made many arrangements to prevent problems that might come from these conditions: I keep a fire burning constantly, set up screens around the room where I live, use many blankets, and always stay indoors. This confinement bothers me, except for the benefit it brings; as long as I stay inside I am not badly troubled by the cold, but if I am forced to go outside even a little and encounter the outdoor air, I suffer considerable harm. Therefore I beg you, dear lady, and earnestly ask this great favor of you: pay close attention to restoring your physical health. Depression causes illness, and when the body is worn out and weakened and remains neglected, lacking the help of doctors, a healthy climate, and an adequate supply of life's necessities, consider how much additional suffering this creates. So I beg you, dear lady, to use various skilled doctors and to take medicines that can correct these problems. A few days ago when I was suffering from nausea because of the weather, I used among other treatments the medicine that my most prudent lady Syncletion sent me, and I found that using it for only three days cured my ailment. I urge you therefore to use this remedy yourself and to arrange for more of it to be sent to me. When I felt unwell again, I used it again and completely cured my problem; it reduces deep internal inflammation, draws moisture to the skin, produces moderate warmth, gives considerable strength, and stimulates appetite—and I experienced all these effects within a few days. So let my most honored lord Count Theophilus be encouraged to arrange to send more of this to me. Do not be distressed that I am spending the winter here, for I am in much better and healthier condition than I was last year; if you would also take proper care of yourself, you would be in far better shape. Now if you say that your ailments have been caused by depression, why do you keep asking for letters from me, since you have gained no benefit from them toward cheerfulness but have fallen so deeply under depression's tyranny that you even want to leave this world? Do you not know how great a reward awaits someone who endures even sickness with a grateful spirit? Have I not often spoken to you about this, both in person and through letters? But since the demands on your time, perhaps, or the particular nature of your illness and the rapid changes in your condition do not allow you to keep clearly and constantly in mind what I have said, listen once more while I try to heal the wounds of your depression by repeating the same remedy: for to write the same things, it is said, to me indeed is not grievous, and for you it is safe.

Do not be anxious on my behalf, nor rack yourself with solicitude, on account of the severity of the winter, and the weakness of my digestion, and the incursions of the Isaurians. For the winter is only what it is wont to be in Armenia; nothing more need be said about it; and it does not very seriously injure me. For in anticipation of these things I have devised many plans for averting the mischief which might arise from them; keeping up a constant fire, setting screens about the chamber in which I live, using a large number of rugs, and staying always indoors. This indeed is irksome to me, if it were not for the benefit to be derived; for as long as I remain indoors I am not severely distressed by the cold; but if I am compelled to go out a little, and come in contact with the outer air, I suffer no small damage. Wherefore I beseech you dear lady, and entreat you as a very great favour to pay great attention to the restoration of your bodily health. For dejection causes sickness; and when the body is exhausted and enfeebled, and remains in a neglected condition, deprived of the assistance of physicians, and of a wholesome climate, and an abundant supply of the necessaries of life, consider how great an aggravation of distress is occasioned thereby. Wherefore I beseech you, dear lady, to employ various and skilled physicians, and to take medicines which avail to correct these conditions. For a few days ago when I suffered from a tendency to vomiting, owing to the state of the atmosphere, I had recourse among other remedies to the drug which was sent me by my most discreet mistress Syncletion, and I found that no more than three days' application of it cured my infirmity. I beseech you therefore to make use of this remedy also yourself and to arrange that some more of it may be sent to me. For having again felt somewhat upset, I again had recourse to it, and completely cured my disorder; for it allays the deep internal inflammation, draws out moisture on the skin, causes a moderate degree of warmth, infuses no little vigor, and excites an appetite for food; and all these effects I experienced in the course of a few days. Let then my most honoured lord the Count Theophilus be exhorted to take means to send some of this to me again. And do not be distressed at my wintering here, for I am in a much more comfortable and sounder state of health than I was last year; so that if you also would take the requisite care of yourself, you would be in a far more satisfactory condition. Now if you say that your ailments have been produced by despondency how is it that you again ask for letters from me, seeing that you have not derived any benefit from them in the direction of cheerfulness, but have sunk so deeply under the tyranny of despondency as even to desire to depart out of this world. Are you ignorant how great a reward even of sickness awaits one who has a thankful spirit? Have I not often, both in person, and through letters, discoursed to you concerning this theme? But since the pressure of business perhaps, or the peculiar nature of your sickness, and the quick succession of changes in your condition do not permit you to retain what I have said constantly and clearly in your mind, listen once more while I try to heal the wounds of your despondency by repeating the same incantations: for to write the same things, it is said, to me indeed is not grievous, and for you it is safe. Philippians 3:1

What is it then that I say and write? Nothing, Olympias, brings so much credit to anyone as patient endurance in suffering. For this is truly the queen of virtues and the perfection of crowns. And just as it surpasses all other forms of righteousness, so this particular kind of it is more glorious than the rest. Perhaps what I have said seems unclear; I will therefore try to make it clearer. What then am I claiming? Not the loss of possessions, even if one were stripped of everything, not the loss of honors, nor exile from one's country and transportation to a distant land, nor the strain of labor and toil, nor imprisonment and bondage, nor insults and abuse and mockery (though you should not think that courageously enduring such things is a minor kind of fortitude, as Jeremiah, that great and eminent prophet, proves—for he was greatly distressed by this kind of trial). Yet not even this, nor the loss of children, even if they were torn from us all at once, nor the constant attacks of enemies, nor anything else of that nature—no, not even the head and crown of things considered painful, namely death, terrible and loathsome though it is—is as oppressive as physical illness. And this is proved by the greatest hero of endurance, who, when he was surrounded by bodily sickness, thought death would be a release from the calamities that were weighing him down. When he underwent all the other sufferings, he was not deeply affected by them, although he received blow after blow, and finally a deadly one. For it was no small matter, but rather evidence of the most malicious cruelty on the part of his enemy—dealing with someone who was no novice in suffering, nor entering the contest for the first time, but already exhausted from repeated attacks—to inflict upon him that deadly blow: the destruction of his children. It was inflicted so cruelly that all of them, both sons and daughters, were destroyed at the same moment in their youth and by a violent death. Their death was so sudden that it included their burial as well. For their father neither saw them laid on a bed, nor kissed their hands, nor heard their last words, nor touched their hands and knees, nor did he close their mouths or shut their eyes when they were about to die—acts which do much to console parents being separated from their children. Neither did he follow some of them to burial and find others at home when he returned to console him for those who had departed. Instead, he heard that while they were reclining on their couches at a banquet—a banquet full of love, not excess, a table of brotherly kindness—they were all overwhelmed. Blood and wine, the cups and the ceiling, the table and the dust and the limbs of his children were all mixed together. Nevertheless, when he heard these things, and others before them which were also distressing—for they too had perished in a distressing way: flocks and whole herds had been destroyed, the latter consumed by fire sent down from heaven (so said the evil messenger of this tragedy), and the former all seized together by various enemies and cut to pieces along with the shepherds themselves—nevertheless, I say, when he saw this great storm stirred up in a brief moment of time affecting his lands, his house, his cattle, and his children, when he saw wave following wave and long lines of rocks, when the darkness was profound and the surging waves unbearable, even then he was not tortured by despair, and scarcely seemed to feel what had happened, except as he was a man and a father. But when he was handed over to sickness and sores, then he longed for death, then he lamented and mourned himself, so that you may understand how this kind of suffering is more severe than all others, and this form of patience the highest of all. Nor is the Devil himself unaware of this fact. For when, after setting in motion all these trials, he saw that the hero remained untroubled and undismayed, he rushed to this as the greatest contest of all, saying that all the other calamities were bearable—loss of children or property or anything else (for this is what is meant by the expression "skin for skin")—but the deadly blow was when pain was inflicted on a man's body. And therefore, when he was defeated after this contest, he no longer had a word to say, although on previous occasions he had made the most vigorous and shameless resistance. In this instance, however, he found that he could not devise any further shameless scheme, but hid his face and retreated.

2. What is it then which I say and write? Nothing, Olympias, redounds so much to the credit of any one as patient endurance in suffering. For this is indeed the queen of virtues, and the perfection of crowns; and as it excels all other forms of righteousness, so this particular species of it is more glorious than the rest. Perhaps what I have said seems obscure; I will therefore try to make it clearer. What then is it that I affirm? Not the spoliation of goods, even if one were to be stripped bare of all one's possessions, not the loss of honours, nor expulsion from one's country, and transportation to a distant land, nor the strain of labour and toil, nor imprisonment, and bondage, nor reproaches, and abuse, and scoffings (not indeed that you are to think the courageous endurance of such things a slight kind of fortitude, as Jeremiah that great and eminent prophet proves who was not a little distressed by this kind of trial); Jeremiah xv yet not even this, nor the loss of children, even should they be torn from us in one fell swoop, nor the perpetual assaults of enemies, nor anything else of that nature, no, nor even the head and crown of things accounted painful, namely death, terrible and loathsome though it be, is so oppressive as infirmity of body. And this is proved by the greatest hero of endurance, who, when he was encompassed by bodily sickness, thought death would be a release from the calamities which were depressing him; and when he underwent all the other sufferings, was not sensible of them, although he received blow after blow, and at last a deadly one. For it was no slight matter, but rather an evidence of the most malignant cruelty on the part of his enemy in dealing with one who was no novice in suffering, nor entering the lists for the first time, but already exhausted with the frequent repetition of assaults, to inflict upon him that deadly blow, the destruction of his children, so cruelly inflicted moreover that all of either sex were destroyed at the same moment in early youth and by a violent end, and so instantaneous was their death that it involved their burial also. For their father neither saw them laid upon abed, nor kissed their hands, nor heard their last words, nor touched their hands and knees, nor did he shut their mouths, or close their eyes when they were about to die, acts which tend not a little to console parents who are being parted from their children; neither did he follow some of them to burial, and find others on his return home to console him for those who had departed; but he heard that as they were reclining on their couches at a banquet, a banquet full of love, not of excess, a table of brotherly kindness, they were all overwhelmed; and blood, and wine, the cups and the ceiling, the table, and the dust, and the limbs of his children, were all mingled together. Nevertheless when he heard these things, and others before these which were also distressing; for they too had perished in a distressing way; flocks and whole herds had been destroyed, the latter having been consumed by fire sent down from heaven, (so said the evil messenger of this tragedy,) and the former having been all seized together by various enemies, and cut to pieces as well as the shepherds themselves; nevertheless I say when he saw this great storm stirred up in a brief moment of time affecting his lands, his house, his cattle, and his children, when he saw billow following billow, and long lines of rocks, and the darkness was profound, and the surging waves unbearable, even then he was not tortured by despondency, and scarcely seemed to feel the things which had happened, save so far as he was a man and a father. But when he was delivered over to sickness and sores, then did he also long for death, then did he also bewail himself and lament, so that you may understand how this kind of suffering is more severe than all others, and this form of patience the highest of all. Nor is the Devil himself unaware of this fact; for when after having set in motion all these trials he perceived that the hero remained untroubled and undismayed he rushed to this as the greatest contest of all, saying that all the other calamities were bearable, as loss of child, or property, or anything else (for this is what is meant by the expression skin for skin Job 2:4) but the deadly blow was when pain was inflicted on a man's body. And therefore when he had been worsted after this contest, he had no longer a word to utter, although on former occasions he had made the most strenuous and shameless resistance. In this instance however he found that he could not invent any further shameless device, but hid his face and retreated.

Don't think, however, that you can justify your desire for death by pointing to Job's desire for it when he couldn't bear his sufferings. Consider the time when he desired it and the circumstances he faced—the law had not been given, the prophets had not appeared, grace had not been poured out as it was later, and he didn't have the benefit of any other kind of philosophy. As proof that more is required of us than of those who lived then, and that harder tasks are assigned to us, listen to Christ when He says: "Unless your righteousness exceeds the righteousness of the Scribes and Pharisees you shall in no case enter into the kingdom of Heaven." So don't think that praying for death now is free from blame, but listen to the voice of Saint Paul when he says: "To depart and to be with Christ is far better, but to abide in the flesh is more necessary for your sake." The more the strain of affliction increases, the more the garlands of victory multiply; the more the gold is heated, the more it becomes purified; the longer the merchant voyages on the sea, the larger the freight he collects. Don't think, then, that the labor now assigned to you is a slight one, but rather that it is higher than all you have undergone—I mean the labor that consists in bodily infirmity. In the case of Lazarus (and although I may have often said this to you, it doesn't prevent me from saying it now), this bodily infirmity contributed to his salvation. He departed to the bosom of the man who had a dwelling he shared with all who passed by, who continually shifted his home on account of God's command, and who sacrificed his own son, his only begotten, who had been given to him in extreme old age. Although Lazarus had done none of these things, he still obtained this blessing because he cheerfully endured poverty, infirmity, and friendlessness. This is such a great good for those who bear anything bravely that it releases anyone who may have committed the greatest sins from the heaviest burden of them. If someone is an upright and just person, it becomes an additional ground for the greatest confidence. It is a bright wreath of victory for the just, shining far above the brightness of the sun, and it is the greatest means of purification for those who have sinned. For this reason Paul delivers the man who committed incest to destruction of the flesh, purifying him by this means. As proof that what was done did purify him even from so great a stain, hear his words: "that his spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord." And when he was accusing others of another very awful sin—partaking unworthily of the holy table and those secret mysteries—and had said that such a person "will be guilty of the body and blood of the Lord," observe how he says that they too are purified from that grievous stain: "therefore are many weak and sickly among you." And then, by way of proving that they will not be confined to this condition of punishment but that some profit will be derived from it—namely release from the penalties the sin deserves—he added: "for if we would judge ourselves, we should not be judged. But now when we are judged, we are chastened of the Lord, that we should not be condemned with the world." Moreover, it is clear from the case of Job that those who have lived very righteously derive much benefit from such chastisement, for he was more illustrious after it than before. The case of Timothy also shows this. Although he was such a good man, entrusted with such an important ministry, and traveled around the world with Paul, he spent not just two or three days, or ten or twenty, or a hundred, but many days in succession in ill health, his body being very seriously weakened. Paul shows this where he said: "Use a little wine for your stomach's sake, and your frequent infirmities." And he who raised the dead did not cure this man's infirmity but left him in the furnace of his sickness so that he might from it gain a very great abundance of confidence. The lessons Paul himself had received from his Master, and the training he had received from Him, he passed on to his disciple. Although Paul was not subjected to bodily infirmity, he was buffeted by trials no less severe, which inflicted much physical pain. "For there was given unto me," he says, "a thorn in the flesh, a messenger of Satan to buffet me"—meaning by this the blows, the bonds, the chains, the imprisonments, the being dragged about and maltreated and tortured by the scourges of public executioners. Therefore, being unable to bear the pain these things caused to the body, "for this I besought the Lord thrice" (thrice here meaning many times) "that I might be delivered from this thorn." And then when he did not obtain his petition, having learned the benefit of the trial, he held his peace and rejoiced at the things that happened to him.

3. Think not however that it is an excuse to justify you in desiring death, that Job desired it, not being able to bear his sufferings. For consider the time when he desired it, and the disposition of his circumstances — the law was not given, the prophets had not appeared, grace had not been shed forth as it was afterwards, nor had he the advantage of any other kind of philosophy. For as a proof that more is demanded from us than from those who lived then, and that harder tasks are assigned to us, listen to Christ, when He says Unless your righteousness exceeds the righteousness of the Scribes and Pharisees you shall in no case enter into the kingdom of Heaven. Matthew 5:20 Do not think therefore that to pray for death now is exempt from blame, but hearken to the voice of St. Paul when he says To depart and to be with Christ is far better, but to abide in the flesh is more necessary for your sake. Philippians 1:23-24 For in proportion as the strain of the affliction is increased are the garlands of victory multiplied; in proportion as the gold is heated does it become purified, the longer the merchant makes his voyage on the sea, the larger is the freight which he collects. Do not then think that the labour now allotted to you is a slight one, but rather that it is higher than all which you have undergone, I mean that which consists in infirmity of body. For in the case of Lazarus Luke xvi (and although I may have often said this to you, it nowise hinders me from saying it now) this bodily infirmity availed for his salvation; and he departed to the bosom of the man who possessed a dwelling which he shared with all who passed by, and was continually shifting his home on account of God's command, and sacrificed his own son, his only begotten, who had been given him in extreme old age; although Lazarus had done none of these things yet he obtained this blessing inasmuch as he cheerfully endured poverty, and infirmity, and friendlessness. For this is so great a good to those who bear anything bravely that it releases any one who may have committed the greatest sins from the heaviest burden of them; or if any one is an upright and just man it becomes an additional ground of the greatest confidence. For it is a bright wreath of victory for the just, shining far above the brightness of the sun, and it is the greatest means of purification for those who have sinned. On this account Paul delivers the man who had made the incestuous marriage to destruction of the flesh, purifying him by this means. For as a proof that what was done did purify even from so great a stain hear his words that his spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord. 1 Corinthians 5:5 And when he was accusing others of another very awful sin, that of partaking unworthily of the holy table and those secret mysteries, and had said that such a person will be guilty of the body and blood of the Lord, 1 Corinthians 11:27 observe how he says that they also are purified from that grievous stain — therefore are many weak and sickly among you. 1 Corinthians 11:30 And then by way of proving that they will not be confined to this condition of punishment, but that some profit will be derived from it, namely release from the penalties to which the sin is liable, he added: for if we would judge ourselves, we should not be judged. But now when we are judged, we are chastened of the Lord, that we should not be condemned with the world. 1 Corinthians 11:31-32 Moreover that they who have lived very righteously derive much benefit from such chastisement is plain from the case of Job, who was more illustrious after it than before, and from the case of Timothy, who although he was such a good man, and entrusted with such an important ministry, and made the circuit of the world with Paul passed not two or three days, nor ten or twenty, or a hundred, but many in succession in ill health, his body being very seriously enfeebled. Paul shows this where he said Use a little wine for your stomach's sake, and your frequent infirmities. 1 Timothy 5:23 And he who raised the dead did not cure this man's infirmity, but left him in the furnace of his sickness so that he might therefrom contract a very great abundance of confidence. For the lessons which Paul himself had enjoyed from his Master, and the training which he had received from Him, he imparted to his disciple. For although he was not subjected to bodily infirmity, yet he was buffeted by trials not less severe, which inflicted much physical pain. For there was given unto me he says a thorn in the flesh, a messenger of Satan to buffet me meaning by this the blows, the bonds, the chains, the imprisonments, the being dragged about, and maltreated, and tortured by the scourges of public executioners. Wherefore also being unable to bear the pain occasioned to the body by these things for this I besought the Lord thrice (thrice here meaning many times) that I might be delivered from this thorn. And then when he did not obtain his petition, having learned the benefit of the trial, he held his peace, and rejoiced at the things which happened unto him.

Even if you stay at home and are confined to your bed, do not think your life is useless. You endure more severe pain than those who are dragged about, mistreated, and tortured by executioners, since in your extreme weakness you have a permanent executioner living with you.

Therefore even if you remain at home, and are set fast in bed, do not consider your life an idle one; for you undergo more severe pains than those who are dragged, and maltreated, and tortured by executioners, inasmuch as in this excessive infirmity of yours you have a perpetual executioner residing with you.

Do not desire death now, and do not neglect the means of healing, for this would not be safe. For this reason Paul also urges Timothy to take the greatest care of himself. Enough has now been said about illness. But if it is separation from me that causes your despondency, expect release from this. I have not said this simply to encourage you, but I am sure it really will happen. For if it were not destined to happen, I believe I would have departed from this world long ago, considering the trials that have been inflicted on me. To pass over everything that happened in Constantinople, after my departure from there you can understand what sufferings I endured on that long and cruel journey, most of which were enough to cause death—what I endured after arriving here, after being removed from Cucusus, and after staying in Arabissus. Yet I have survived all these things, and now I am in sound health and great security, so that all Armenians are amazed that with such a feeble and weak body as mine I can endure such an unbearable amount of cold, or that I can breathe at all, when those who are used to the winter are suffering from it terribly. Nevertheless I have remained unharmed up to this day, having escaped the hands of robbers who have repeatedly attacked us, and yet in daily need of life's necessities and deprived of the use of a bath. Although I have been constantly without this luxury since living here, I am now so used to the habit that I do not even long for the comfort it provides, but am in better health than before. Neither the harsh climate, nor the desolation of the region, nor the scarcity of food, nor the lack of attendants, nor the inexperience of physicians, nor the lack of a bath, nor constant confinement in one room as in a prison and the inability to move about which I always continually needed, nor constant contact with fire and smoke, nor fear of robbers, nor a constant state of siege, nor anything else of this kind has overcome me. On the contrary, I am in better health than I was elsewhere, although I received great care and attention there. Taking all these things into consideration, therefore, shake off the despondency that now weighs you down, and do not impose excessive and cruel punishments on yourself. I sent you the treatise I recently wrote, that no one can harm the man who does not injure himself, and the letter I now send you contends for the same position. I beg you therefore to read it constantly, and if your health permits, recite it aloud. For if you are willing, it may prove an effective remedy for you. But if you are stubborn with me and do not try to heal yourself, and will not rouse yourself from these dismal swamps of despondency despite the unlimited amount of advice and encouragement you receive, I shall not on my part readily agree to send you frequent and long letters if you are not going to derive any benefit in the way of cheerfulness from them. How then shall I know this? Not by your merely saying so, but by practical proof, since you recently stated that it was nothing but despondency that caused this sickness of yours. Since you have made this confession yourself, I shall not believe you have gotten rid of your despondency unless you have gotten rid of your bodily illness. For if it is the former that causes your disorder, as you say in your letter, it is obvious that when that has been dispersed the other will be removed at the same time, and when the root has been pulled up, the branches perish with it—and if the branches continue flowering and flourishing and producing an unnatural amount of fruit, I cannot believe you have been set free from the root of your distress. Therefore do not show me words but deeds, and if you get well, you will see letters sent to you again that exceed the length of former communications. Consider it no small consolation that I am alive and in good health, and that in the midst of such circumstances I have been freed from sickness and weakness, which, as I know, is a great annoyance and vexation to my enemies. It follows therefore that you should consider this the greatest encouragement and the crown of your consolation. Do not call your household desolate, which now has a higher place assigned to it in Heaven because of the sufferings it endures. I was deeply distressed on account of Pelagius the monk. Consider therefore what great rewards those deserve who bravely hold their ground, when men who spend their time in such a habit of discipline and endurance are found capable of degradation.

4. Do not then now desire death, nor neglect the means of cure; for indeed this would not be safe. On this account Paul also exhorts Timothy to take the greatest care of himself. As regards infirmity then enough has now been said. But if it is separation from me which causes your despondency expect release from this. And I have not said this now merely to encourage you, but I am sure that it really will be the case. For if it were not destined to happen, I should long ago, so at least I think, have departed from this world, considering the trials which have been inflicted on me. For to pass over all that occurred in Constantinople, after my departure thence, you may understand what sufferings I endured on that long and cruel journey, most of which were sufficient to produce death; what I endured after my arrival here, after my removal from Cucusus, and after my sojourn in Arabissus. Yet I have survived all these things, and now I am in sound health, and great security, so that all Armenians are astonished that with such a feeble and flimsy frame as mine I can support such an intolerable amount of cold, or that I can breathe at all, when those who are habituated to the winter are suffering from it in no common degree. Nevertheless I have remained uninjured up to the present day, having escaped the hands of robbers who have repeatedly attacked us, and yet in daily want of the necessaries of life, and deprived of the use of a bath; and although since my sojourn here I have been constantly without this luxury I am now so established in the habit that I do not even long for the comfort to be derived from it, but am in sounder health than before. And neither the inclemency of the climate, nor the desolation of the region, nor the scarcity of provisions, nor the lack of attendants, nor the unskillfulness of physicians, nor the deprivation of the bath, nor perpetual confinement in one chamber as in a prison, and the impossibility of moving about which I always used continually to need, nor perpetual contact with fire and smoke, nor fear of robbers, nor a constant state of siege, nor anything else of this kind has got the better of me; on the contrary I am in a sounder condition of health than I was elsewhere, although I then received great care and attention. Taking all these things then into consideration pray shake off the despondency which now oppresses you, and do not exact inordinate and cruel penances from yourself. I sent you the treatise which I have lately written, that no one can harm the man who does not injure himself, and the letter which I now send your honour contends for the same position. I beg you therefore to go over it constantly, and if your health permits you, recite it aloud. For if you will, it may prove an effectual remedy for you. But if you are contentious with me, and do not try to cure yourself, and will not rouse yourself from these dismal swamps of despondency in spite of the unlimited amount of advice and exhortation which you enjoy I shall not on my part readily consent to send you frequent and long letters, if you are not to derive any benefit in the way of cheerfulness from them. How then shall I know this? Not by your merely saying so, but by a practical proof, inasmuch as you lately affirmed that it was nothing but despondency which caused this sickness of yours. Since then you have yourself made this confession I shall not believe that you have got rid of your despondency unless you have got rid of your bodily infirmity. For if it is the former which causes your disorder, as you say in your letter, it is obvious that when that has been dispersed the other will be removed at the same time, and when the root has been plucked up, the branches perish with it — and if the branches continue flowering and flourishing, and producing an unnatural amount of fruit I cannot believe that you have been set free from the root of your distress. Therefore do not show me words but facts, and, if you get well, you will see letters sent to you again exceeding the limits of former communications. Deem it then no small consolation that I am alive, and in good health, and that in the midst of such circumstances I have been set free from sickness and infirmity, which, as I know, is a great annoyance and vexation to my enemies. It follows therefore that you should deem this the greatest encouragement, and the crown of your consolation. Do not call your household desolate, which has now a higher place assigned to it in Heaven by reason of the sufferings which it endures. I was grievously distressed on account of Pelagius the monk. Consider therefore what great rewards they deserve who bravely hold their ground, when men who pass their time in such a habit of discipline and endurance are found susceptible of degradation.

To Olympias

Having risen from the very gates of death, I am writing this letter to the discreet lady. I am very glad that your servants have reached me just as I am finally anchoring in harbor. If they had met me when I was still being tossed on the open sea and experiencing the cruel waves of bodily sickness, it would not have been easy for me to deceive your cautious spirit by sending good news instead of sorrowful news. The winter, which became unusually severe, brought on a storm of internal disorder that was even more distressing, and during the last two months I have been no better than a dead man—actually worse. I had just enough life to be aware of the horrors surrounding me, and day and dawn and noon were all one night to me as I spent all my time closely confined to my bed. Despite endless efforts, I could not shake off the harmful effects of the cold. Even though I kept a fire burning and endured a very unpleasant amount of smoke, and remained shut up in one room, covered with plenty of blankets, and not daring to set a foot outside the threshold, I underwent extreme suffering. Constant vomiting came on top of headache, loss of appetite, and continual sleeplessness. This is how I restlessly passed through my long dark sea of troubles. But so as not to distress your mind by dwelling on my miseries, I am now relieved from all of them. As soon as spring came and the temperature changed a little, all my troubles spontaneously vanished. Nevertheless, I still require great care regarding my diet, so I put only a light load on my stomach so that it can digest easily. But it has caused me no little concern to learn that my discreet mistress was brought to the verge of death. Nevertheless, because of my great affection and anxiety and concern for your welfare, I was relieved from this worry even before your letters arrived, since many people had come from there who brought me news of your restoration to health.

Having risen from the very gates of death I address this letter to the discreet lady; and I am very glad that your servants have met me just as I am anchoring at last in harbour. For had they met me when I was still tossing on the open sea, and experiencing the cruel waves of bodily sickness, it would not have been easy for me to deceive your cautious spirit, by sending good tidings instead of sorrowful. For the winter, which has become more than commonly severe, brought on a storm of internal disorder even more distressing, and during the last two months I have been no better than one dead, nay worse. For I had just enough life to be sensible of the horrors which encircled me, and day and dawn and noon were all one night to me as I spent all my time closely confined to my bed, and in spite of endless contrivances I could not shake off the pernicious effects of the cold; but although I kept a fire burning, and endured a most unpleasant amount of smoke, and remained cooped up in one chamber, covered with any quantity of wraps, and not daring to set a foot outside the threshold I underwent extreme sufferings, perpetual vomiting supervening on headache, loss of appetite, and constant sleeplessness. Thus restlessly did I pass through my long dark sea of troubles. But not to distress your mind by dwelling upon my miseries, from all of them I am now relieved. For as soon as spring approached, and a little change in the temperature took place, all my troubles spontaneously vanished. Nevertheless I still require great care as regards diet; therefore I put only a light load on my stomach, so that it may be able to digest it easily. But it has occasioned me no little concern to learn that my discreet mistress was brought to the verge of death. Nevertheless in consideration of my great affection, and anxiety, and solicitude for your welfare I was relieved from this care, even before the arrival of your letters, many persons having come from thence who brought me tidings of your restoration to health.

Now I am exceedingly glad and delighted to hear not only that you have been released from your illness, but above all that you bear whatever happens to you so bravely, calling it all nothing but an idle tale. What is even more remarkable is that you have applied this description even to your physical illness, which shows a strong spirit rich in the fruit of courage. For not only to bear misfortunes bravely but to be actually insensitive to them, to overlook them, and with so little effort to wear the victor's crown of patience—neither laboring nor toiling, neither feeling distress nor causing it to others, but as if leaping and dancing for joy the whole time—this is truly proof of the most complete philosophy. Therefore I rejoice and leap for joy. I am excited with delight, I am insensitive to my present loneliness and the other troubles that surround me, being cheered and brightened and not a little proud on account of your greatness of soul and the repeated victories you have won. This is not only for your own sake but also for the sake of that large and populous city where you are like a tower, a safe harbor, and a defensive wall, speaking in the eloquent voice of example and through your sufferings instructing people of both sexes to strip readily for these contests and descend into the arena with full courage and cheerfully bear the hardships that such contests involve. What is wonderful is that without thrusting yourself into the public square or occupying the city's public centers, but sitting all the while in a small house and confined room, you serve and prepare the combatants for the contest. And while the sea is raging around you and the waves are rising to their height, and cliffs and reefs and rocky ledges and fierce monsters appear on every side, and everything is shrouded in the deepest darkness, you set the sails of patience and float on with great calm, as if it were broad daylight with calm weather and a favorable breeze carrying you forward. So far from being overwhelmed by this terrible storm, you are not even sprinkled by the spray—and quite naturally so, such is the power of virtue as a rudder. Now merchants and pilots and sailors and travelers, when they see clouds gathering or fierce winds rushing down upon them or the breakers foaming violently, keep their vessels moored inside the harbor. And if they happen to be storm-tossed in the open sea, they do their best and devise every means to bring their ship to some anchorage or island or shore. But you, although countless winds and fierce waves burst upon you all at once, and the sea is churned up from its very depths by the severity of the storm, and some people are submerged, others floating dead upon the water, others drifting naked on planks—you plunge into the middle of this ocean of calamities and call all these things an idle tale, sailing on with a favorable breeze in the midst of the tempest. And naturally so, for pilots, even if they are infinitely wise in that skill, nevertheless do not have ability sufficient to withstand every kind of storm. Consequently they often shrink from doing battle with the waves. But the skill you possess is superior to every kind of storm—the power of a philosophical soul—which is stronger than ten thousand armies, mightier than weapons, and more secure than towers and fortifications. For the weapons and fortifications and towers that soldiers have are useful only for the security of the body, and not always or in every way. There are times when all these resources fail and leave those who flee to them for refuge without protection. But your powers do not repel the weapons of barbarians or the schemes of hostile people or any assaults and stratagems of that kind. Rather, they have trampled underfoot the constraining forces of nature, overthrown their tyranny, and leveled their fortress. And while constantly contending with demons, you have won countless victories yet have not received a single wound. You stand unharmed in the midst of a storm of arrows and turn the spears that are hurled at you back upon those who throw them. Such is the wisdom of your skill: by the sufferings you undergo you take revenge on those who inflict them; by the plots directed against you, you cause pain to your enemies, finding in their malice the best foundation for the materials of fame. And knowing these things well yourself and having gained understanding through experience, you naturally call them all an idle tale. For how could you not call them by that name, when you possess a mortal body yet despise death as if you were hurrying to leave a foreign country and return to your own land? You suffer chronically from the most severe illness, yet you are more cheerful than those who are thriving and healthy. You are not depressed by insults nor elated by honors and glory, the latter being a cause of infinite harm to many who, after a distinguished career in the priesthood and after reaching extreme old age and most venerable gray hairs, have fallen into disgrace on this account and become a common spectacle of mockery for those who wish to make fun. But you, on the contrary, though you are a woman clothed with a fragile body and subject to these severe attacks, have not only avoided falling into such a condition yourself but have prevented many others from doing so. They indeed, before they had advanced far in the contest, even at the very beginning and starting point, have been overthrown, whereas you, after having gone countless times around the far turning post, have won a prize in every race, after playing your part in countless kinds of wrestling and combat. And quite naturally so, for the wrestlings of virtue do not depend on age or bodily strength but only on the spirit and the disposition. Thus women have been crowned victors while men have been upset; likewise boys have been proclaimed conquerors while old men have been put to shame. It is always fitting to admire those who pursue virtue, but especially when some are found to cling to it at a time when many are abandoning it. Therefore, my dear lady, you deserve the highest admiration, since after so many men, women, and elderly people who seemed to enjoy the greatest reputation have been put to flight, all lying prostrate before the eyes of the world—and this not after a severe attack or any alarming gathering of the enemy's forces, but overthrown before the encounter and defeated before the battle—you, on the contrary, after so many battles and such a large gathering of the enemy are so far from being weakened or dismayed by the number of your adversities that you are all the more vigorous, and the increase of the contest gives you an increase of strength. For the memory of what has already been achieved becomes the source of cheerfulness and joy and greater zeal. Therefore I rejoice and leap for joy, for I will not stop repeating this and carrying everywhere with me the material of my joy. So although my separation from you distresses you, yet you have this very great consolation arising from your successful achievements. For I too, though banished to such a great distance, gain no small cheerfulness from this cause—I mean your courage.

And now I am exceedingly glad and delighted to hear, not only that you have been released from your infirmity, but above all that you bear the things which befall you so bravely, calling them all but an idle tale; and, which is indeed a greater matter, that you have applied this name even to your bodily infirmity, which is an evidence of a robust spirit, rich in the fruit of courage. For not only to bear misfortunes bravely but to be actually insensible to them, to overlook them, and with such little exertion to wreathe your brows with the garland prize of patience, neither labouring, nor toiling, neither feeling distress nor causing it to others, but as it were leaping and dancing for joy all the while, this is indeed a proof of the most finished philosophy. Therefore I rejoice, and leap for joy; I am in a flutter of delight, I am insensible to my present loneliness, and the other troubles which surround me, being cheered, and brightened, and not a little proud on account of your greatness of soul, and the repeated victories which you have won, and this, not only for your own sake, but also for the sake of that large and populous city, where you are like a tower, a haven, and a wall of defense, speaking in the eloquent voice of example, and through your sufferings instructing either sex to strip readily for these contests, and descend into the lists with all courage, and cheerfully bear the toils which such contests involve. And the wonder is that without thrusting yourself into the forum, or occupying the public centres of the city, but sitting all the while in a small house and confined chamber you serve and anoint the combatants for the contest, and while the sea is thus raging round you, and the billows are rising to a crest, and crags and reefs, and rocky ledges and fierce monsters appear on every side, and everything is shrouded in the most profound darkness you, setting the sails of patience, float on with great serenity, as if it was noonday, and calm weather, and a favourable breeze wafting you on, and so far from being overwhelmed by this grievous tempest are not even sprinkled by the spray; and very naturally so; such is the force of virtue as a rudder. Now merchants and pilots, and sailors and voyagers when they see clouds gathering up, or fierce winds rushing down upon them, or the breakers seething with an abundance of foam keep their vessels moored inside harbour; and if they chance to be tempest-tossed in the open sea they do their best, and devise every means to bring their ship to some anchorage, or island or shore. But you, although such innumerable winds, and fierce waves burst upon you together, and the sea is heaved up from its very depths owing to the severity of the storm, and some are submerged, others floating dead upon the water, others drifting naked upon planks, you plunging into the mid ocean of calamities call all these things an idle tale, sailing on with a favourable breeze in the midst of the tempest; and naturally so; for pilots, even if they are infinitely wise in that science, nevertheless have not skill sufficient to withstand every kind of storm; consequently they often shrink from doing battle with the waves. But the science which you have is superior to every kind of storm — the power of a philosophic soul — which is stronger than ten thousand armies, more powerful than arms, and more secure than towers and bulwarks. For the arms, and bulwarks, and towers which soldiers have, are serviceable for the security of the body only, and this not always, nor in every way; but there are times when all these resources are baffled, and leave those who fly to them for refuge destitute of protection. But your powers do not repel the weapons of barbarians, nor the devices of hostile men, nor any assaults and stratagems of that kind, but they have trampled under foot the constraining forces of nature, put down their tyranny and levelled their citadel. And while ceaselessly contending with demons, you have won countless victories, yet have not received a single blow, but stand unwounded in the midst of a storm of darts and turn the spears which are hurled at you back upon those who discharge them. Such is the wisdom of your art; by the sufferings which you undergo you take vengeance on those who inflict them; by the plots of which you are the subject you put your enemies to pain, possessing in their malice the best foundation for the materials of fame. And you, knowing these things well yourself, and having gained perception by experience, naturally call them all an idle tale. For how, pray, should you not call them by that name, possessing as you do a mortal body, and yet despising death as if you were hastening to quit a foreign country, and return to your own land; a chronic sufferer from the most severe infirmity, and yet more cheerfully disposed than the thriving and robust, not depressed by insults, nor elated by honours and glory, the latter being a cause of infinite mischief to many who after an illustrious career in the priesthood, and after reaching extreme old age, and the most venerable hoar hairs, have fallen into disgrace on this account, and become a common spectacle of derision for those who wish to make merry. But you on the contrary, woman as you are, clothed with a fragile body, and subject to these severe attacks, have not only avoided falling into such a condition yourself, but have prevented many others from so doing. They indeed before they had advanced far in the contest, even at the very outset and starting point, have been overthrown; whereas you, after having gone countless times round the farther turning post, have won a prize in every course, after playing your part in manifold kinds of wrestling and combats. And very naturally so; for the wrestlings of virtue do not depend upon age, or bodily strength, but only on the spirit and the disposition. Thus women have been crowned victors, while men have been upset; so also boys have been proclaimed conquerors, while aged men have been put to shame. It is indeed always fitting to admire those who pursue virtue, but especially when some are found to cling to it at a time when many are deserting it. Therefore, my sweet lady, you deserve superlative admiration, inasmuch as after so many men, women, and aged persons who seemed to enjoy the greatest reputation have been turned to flight, all lying prostrate before the eyes of the world, and this not after a severe onslaught, nor any alarming muster of the enemy's force, but overthrown before the encounter and worsted before the struggle, you on the contrary after so many battles and such large muster of the enemy are so far from being unstrung, or dismayed by the number of your adversities, that you are all the more vigorous, and the increase of the contest gives you an increase of strength. For the recollection of what has been already achieved becomes the ground of cheerfulness, and joy, and greater zeal. Therefore I rejoice, and leap for joy; for I will not cease repeating this, and taking about with me everywhere the material of my joy; so that although my separation from you distresses you, yet you have this very great consolation arising from your successful exploits; for I also who am banished to so great a distance gain no small cheerfulness from this cause — I mean your courage.

To Olympias

Why do you lament? Why do you torment yourself and inflict on yourself a punishment that your enemies could not inflict on you, having surrendered your soul to the tyranny of depression? The letters you sent me through Patricius have revealed to me the wounds inflicted on your mind. This is why I am very sorrowful and deeply distressed that when you should be making every effort and applying yourself to drive depression from your soul, you go about collecting distressing thoughts, even inventing things (as you say) that do not exist, and tearing yourself apart for no reason and to your very great harm. Why are you grieved because you could not remove me from Cucusus? Yet in fact, as far as you were concerned, you did remove me, having made every effort and endeavor for this purpose. Even if it has not actually happened, you should not be upset on that account. Perhaps it seemed good to God that I should run the longer double course so that the victory garland might be made more glorious. Why then are you upset about these things, which spread my fame abroad, when you should be leaping and dancing for joy and binding wreaths on your head because I have been considered worthy of such a great honor, which far exceeds what I deserve? Is it the desolation of this place that grieves you? Yet what can be more pleasant than my stay here? I have quietness and tranquility, plenty of leisure, and good physical health. Although the town has neither market-place nor market, that means nothing to me, for all things are poured out abundantly upon me as from a flowing spring. I find my lord the Bishop here and my lord Dioscorus constantly occupied with providing for my refreshment. The good Patricius will tell you that as far as my stay here is concerned, I pass my time cheerfully and gladly, surrounded by attention. But if you lament the events that occurred in Caesarea, here again your conduct is unworthy of you. For there also bright victory garlands were woven for me, since everyone was proclaiming and publishing my praises and expressing wonder and astonishment at the mistreatment I suffered followed by expulsion. Meanwhile, however, do not let anyone know these things, although they are the subject of much gossip. My lord Pœanius has disclosed to me that the presbyters of Pharetrius himself have arrived on the spot, who declare that they were in communion with me and had no communication or association or partnership with my adversaries. Therefore, to avoid upsetting them, do not let anyone know these things. Certainly the things that happened to me were very grievous, and if I had suffered no other distress, the events that happened there would have been enough to procure countless rewards for me—so extreme was the danger I encountered. Now I ask you to keep these matters secret, and so I will give you a brief account of them, not to grieve you but rather to make you glad. For herein lies the material of my gain, herein lies my wealth, herein the means of getting rid of my sins—that my journey is continually surrounded by trials of this kind and that they are inflicted on me by persons from whom they were quite unexpected. When I was about to enter the region of Cappadocia, having escaped from that man of Galatia who nearly threatened me with death, many people met me on the way saying the lord Pharetrius is waiting for you, going about in all directions for fear of missing the pleasure of meeting you, making every possible effort to see you and embrace you and show you all kinds of affectionate regard; and he has set the monasteries of men and women in motion for this purpose. Now when I heard these things, I did not expect that any of them would actually happen, but formed an impression in my own mind precisely the opposite—but I said nothing about this to anyone who brought me this message.

Why do you lament? Why do you belabour yourself, and demand of yourself a punishment which your enemies were not able to demand from you, having thus abandoned your soul to the tyranny of dejection? For the letters which you sent to me by the hands of Patricius have discovered to me the wounds which have been inflicted on your mind. Wherefore also I am very sorrowful and much distressed that when you ought to be using every exertion and making it your business to expel dejection from your soul, you go about collecting distressing thoughts, even inventing things (so you say) which do not exist, and tearing yourself to pieces for no purpose, and to your very great injury. For why are you grieved because you could not remove me from Cucusus? Yet indeed, as far as you were concerned, you did remove me, having made every exertion and endeavour for this purpose. And even if it has not been actually accomplished you ought not to be vexed on that account. For perhaps it seemed good to God that I should be set to run the longer double course, in order that the garland of victory might be rendered more glorious. Why then are you vexed on account of these things, in consequence of which my fame is spread abroad, when you ought to leap and dance for joy and bind wreaths upon your brow, because I have been deemed worthy of so great an honour which far exceeds my merits? Is it the desolation of this place which grieves you? Yet what can be pleasanter than my sojourn here? I have quietness, and tranquillity, plenty of leisure and good bodily health. For although the town has neither market-place nor market that is nothing to me. For all things are poured abundantly upon me as out of a flowing spring. I find my lord the Bishop here and my lord Dioscorus are constantly employed in providing for my refreshment. And the good Patricius will tell you that as far as my sojourn here is concerned I pass my time cheerfully and gladly, surrounded by attention. But if you lament the events which occurred in Cæsarea, here again your conduct is unworthy of yourself. For there also bright garlands of victory were woven for me, inasmuch as all were proclaiming and publishing my praises, and expressing wonder and astonishment at the ill-treatment to which I had been subjected followed by expulsion. Meanwhile however do not let any one know these things, although they are the theme of much gossip. For my lord Pœanius has disclosed to me that the presbyters of Pharetrius himself have arrived on the spot, who declare that they were in communion with me and had no communication or intercourse or partnership with my adversaries. Therefore to avoid upsetting them do not let any one know these things. For certainly the things which befell me were very grievous: and if I had not suffered any other distress the events which happened there would have sufficed to procure innumerable rewards for me: so extreme was the danger which I encountered. Now I beseech you to keep these matters secret, and so I will give you a short account of them, not in order to grieve you but rather to make you glad. For herein consists the material of my gain, herein consists my wealth, herein the means of getting rid of my sins — that my journey is continually encompassed by trials of this kind, and that they are inflicted upon me by persons from whom they were quite unexpected. For when I was about to enter the region of Cappadocia, having escaped from that man of Galatia, who nearly threatened me with death, many persons met me on the way saying the lord Pharetrius is awaiting you, and going about in all directions for fear of missing the pleasure of meeting you, and making every possible endeavour to see you, and embrace you, and show you all manner of affectionate regard; and he has set the monasteries of men and women in motion for this purpose. Now when I heard these things I did not expect that any of them would really take place, but formed an impression in my own mind precisely the reverse: but of this I said nothing to any of those who brought me this message.

Now when I arrived late one evening at Caesarea, exhausted and worn out, suffering from a burning fever at its peak and feeling faint and miserable to the extreme, I came upon an inn located just at the edge of the city. I made every effort to find some doctors and reduce this fiery fever, for my tertian fever was now at its worst. On top of this there was the exhaustion from traveling, the hard work, the stress, the complete lack of servants, the difficulty getting food and supplies, the absence of a doctor, the weakening effects of hard labor, and the heat and lack of sleep. So I was nearly a dead man when I entered the city. Then the entire clergy came to visit me, along with the people, monks, nuns, and doctors, and I received great care as everyone provided me with every kind of service and help. Yet even with all this, weighed down by the drowsiness that comes from feverish heat, I was in an extremely distressed state. Eventually, little by little, the illness began to end and decrease. Pharetrius, however, was nowhere to be seen, but waited for me to leave—I don't know what he had in mind. When I saw that my illness had gotten slightly better, I began making plans for my journey so I could reach Cucusus and get a little rest after the disasters of the trip. While I was in this situation, it was suddenly announced that the Isaurians in countless numbers were raiding the region of Caesarea, had burned a large village, and were extremely hostile. The tribune, hearing this, took his soldiers and went out. For they were afraid the enemy might also attack the city, and everyone was terrified and in agonized alarm since their very homeland was in danger, so that even old men took up the defense of the walls. While things were in this state, suddenly toward dawn a mob of monks (for that's what I must call them, showing their madness by the word) rushed to the house where we were staying, threatening to set it on fire and treat us with extreme violence unless we left. Neither the fear of the Isaurians, nor my own illness which was afflicting me so badly, nor anything else made them more reasonable, but they pressed on, driven by such fierce rage that even the proconsular soldiers were terrified. For they kept threatening them with beatings and boasted that they had shamefully beaten many of the proconsular soldiers. The soldiers, hearing these things, took refuge with me and pleaded and begged me, saying even if we must fall into the hands of the Isaurians, deliver us from these wild beasts. When the governor heard this he hurried down to the house intending to help me. But the monks paid no attention to his appeals, and in fact he was powerless. Seeing the great difficulty the situation was in and not daring to advise me either to go out to certain death or on the other hand to stay inside because of these men's excessive fury, he sent word to Pharetrius begging him to allow a few days' delay because of my illness and the approaching danger. But even then nothing was accomplished, and the next day the monks arrived even fiercer than before, and none of the presbyters dared to stand by me and help me, but covered with shame and embarrassment (for they said these things were being done on Pharetrius's orders) they hid themselves and stayed hidden, not answering even when I called them. Why make a long story? Although such great terrors were threatening, and death was nearly certain, and the fever was overwhelming me (for I had not yet gotten relief from the problems it was causing), I threw myself into the litter at high noon and was carried out from there, with all the people shrieking and howling and calling down curses on the one who did these things, while everyone wailed and mourned. But when I got outside the city, some of the clergy also gradually came out and accompanied me, mourning as they went. And having heard some people say Where are you taking him away to obvious death? one of those who was deeply devoted to me said to me Leave, I beg you; fall into the hands of the Isaurians, as long as you get away from us. For wherever you may fall, you will fall into a safe place, if only you escape our hands. Having heard and seen these things, the good Seleucia, the generous wife of my lord Rufinus (she was a most attentive friend to me), urged and begged me to stay at her house in the suburbs which was about five miles from the city, and she sent some men to escort me, and so I left for there.

2. Now when I arrived late one evening at Cæsarea, in an exhausted and worn-out condition, being in the very height of a burning fever, faint and suffering to the last degree, I lighted upon an inn situated just at the outskirts of the city, and took great pains to find some physicians and allay this fiery fever; for it was now the height of my tertian malady. And in addition to this there was the fatigue of the journey, the toil, the strain, the total absence of attendants, the difficulty of getting supplies, the want of a physician, the wasting effects of toil, and heat and sleeplessness; thus I was well near a dead man when I entered the city. Then indeed I was visited by the whole body of the clergy, and the people, monks, nuns, physicians, and I had the benefit of great attention, as all paid me every kind of ministration and assistance. Yet even thus, being oppressed by the lethargy arising from the feverish heat I was in an extremely distressed condition. At length by degrees the malady was coming to an end and abating. Pharetrius however nowhere appeared; but waited for my departure, I know not with what purpose in view. When then I saw that my disorder had slightly abated I began to form plans for my journey so as to reach Cucusus, and enjoy a little repose after the calamities of the way. And while I was thus situated it was suddenly announced that the Isaurians in countless multitudes were overrunning the district of Cæsarea, and had burnt a large village, and were most violently disposed. The tribune, having heard this, took the soldiers which he had and went out. For they were afraid lest the enemy should make an assault also upon the city, and all were in terror, and in an agony of alarm the very soil of their country being in jeopardy, so that even the old men undertook the defense of the walls. While affairs were in this condition suddenly towards dawn a rabble of monks (for so I must call them, indicating their frenzy by the expression) rushed up to the house where we were, threatening to set fire to it, and to treat us with the utmost violence unless we turned out of it. And neither the fear of the Isaurians, nor my own infirmity which was so grievously afflicting me, nor anything else made them more reasonable, but they pressed on, animated by such fierce rage that even the proconsular soldiers were terrified. For they kept threatening them with blows and boasted that they had shamefully beaten many of the proconsular soldiers. The soldiers having heard these things, sought refuge with me, and entreated and beseeched me, saying even if we are to fall into the hands of the Isaurians deliver us from these wild beasts. When the governor heard this he hastened down to the house intending to succour me. But the monks would not pay any heed to his exhortations, and in fact he was powerless. Perceiving the great strait in which affairs were placed and not daring to advise me either to go out to certain death, or on the other hand to stay indoors, owing to the excessive fury of these men, he sent to Pharetrius beseeching him to grant a few days respite on account of my infirmity and the impending danger. But even then nothing was effected, and on the morrow the monks arrived even fiercer than before, and none of the presbyters dared to stand by me and help me, but covered with shame and blushes (for they said that these things were done by the instructions of Pharetrius) they concealed themselves and lay hid, not responding even when I called them. What need to make a long story? Although such great terrors were imminent, and death well near a certainty, and the fever was oppressing me (for I had not yet got relief from the troubles arising from that cause) I flung myself at high noon into the litter, and was carried out thence, all the people shrieking and howling, and imprecating curses on the perpetrator of these deeds, while every one wailed and lamented. But when I got outside the city, some of the clergy also gradually came out and escorted me, mourning as they went. And having heard some persons say Where are you leading him away to manifest death? one of those who was warmly attached to me said to me Depart I entreat you; fall into the hands of the Isaurians, provided you get clear away from us. For wherever you may fall, you will fall into a place of security, if only you escape our hands. Having heard and seen these things the good Seleucia, the generous wife of my lord Ruffinus (a most attentive friend she was to me), exhorted and entreated me to lodge at her suburban house which was about five miles from the city and she sent some men to escort me, and so I departed there.

But not even there was this plot against me to come to an end. For as soon as Pharetrius knew what she had done, he published, as she said, many threats against her. But when she received me into her suburban villa I knew nothing of these things. When she came out to meet me she concealed these things from me, but disclosed them to her steward who was there, and ordered him to provide me with every possible means of rest. If any of the monks should make an assault, wishing to insult or harm me, he was to gather the laborers from her other farms and thus assemble a force against them. Moreover, she begged me to take refuge in her house, which had a fortress and was impregnable, so that I might escape the hands of the bishop and monks. This however I could not be persuaded to do, but remained in the villa, knowing nothing of the plans that were devised after these things. For even then they were not content to stop their fury against me, but Pharetrius harassed the lady, as she says, severely threatening her, pressuring and forcing her to expel me even from the suburbs. So at midnight, while I knew nothing of these things, the lady, being unable to endure his harassment, announced without my knowledge that the barbarians were at hand, for she was ashamed to mention the compulsion she had undergone. So in the middle of the night Evethius the presbyter came to me, and having woken me from sleep, exclaimed in a loud voice: Get up, I beg you, the barbarians are upon us, they are close at hand. Imagine my condition on hearing this! Then, when I said to him what must we do? We cannot take refuge in the city lest we suffer worse things than what the Isaurians are going to do to us. He compelled me to go out. It was midnight, a dark, murky night without a moon—a circumstance which filled up the measure of our confusion—we had no companion, no helper, for all had deserted us. Nevertheless, under the pressure of fear and in the expectation of immediate death, I got up, suffering as I was, having ordered torches to be lit. These however the presbyter ordered to be put out, for fear as he said lest the barbarians should be attracted by the light and attack us; so the torches were extinguished. Then the mule which carried my litter fell on its knees, the road being rough, steep, and stony, and I who was inside was thrown down and narrowly escaped destruction, after which I dismounted and was dragged along on foot, being held fast by Evethius the presbyter (for he also had gotten down from his mule), and so I plodded on, led, or rather hauled by the hand, for to walk was impossible through such difficult country and among steep mountains in the middle of the night. Imagine what my sufferings must have been, surrounded as I was by such calamities and oppressed by the fever, ignorant of the plans that had been made, but in terror of the barbarians and trembling with the expectation of falling into their hands. Do you not think that these sufferings alone, even if nothing else besides had befallen me, would be enough to blot out many of my sins and provide ample material for obtaining praise with God? Now the reason for all this, at least as I suppose, was that as soon as I arrived in Caesarea, those who were in official positions, the learned men who were ex-vicars and ex-governors, the ex-tribunes and indeed the whole people visited me every day, paid me great attention, and treated me as the apple of their eye. I suppose these things irritated Pharetrius and that the envy which drove me from Constantinople did not refrain from pursuing me even here. This at least is what I suppose, for I do not positively declare it but only suspect it to be the fact.

3. But not even there was this plot against me to come to an end. For as soon as Pharetrius knew what she had done, he published, as she said, many threats against her. But when she received me into her suburban villa I knew nothing of these things; for when she came out to meet me she concealed these things from me, but disclosed them to her steward who was there, and ordered him to afford me every possible means of repose, and if any of the monks should make an assault, wishing to insult or maltreat me, he was to collect the labourers from her other farms, and thus marshal a force against them. Moreover she besought me to take refuge in her house, which had a fortress and was impregnable, that I might escape the hands of the bishop and monks. This however I could not be induced to do, but remained in the villa, knowing nothing of the plans which were devised after these things. For even then they were not content to desist from their fury against me but Pharetrius beset the lady as she says, strictly threatening her, constraining and forcing her to expel me even from the suburbs, so that at midnight, I knowing nothing of these things, the lady being unable to endure his annoyance, announced, without my knowledge, that the barbarians were at hand, for she was ashamed to mention the compulsion which she had undergone. So in the middle of the night Evethius the presbyter came to me, and having roused me from sleep, exclaimed with a loud voice Get up, I pray you, the barbarians are upon us, they are close at hand. Imagine my condition on hearing this! Then, when I said to him what must we do? We cannot take refuge in the city lest we suffer worse things than what the Isaurians are going to do to us, he compelled me to go out. It was midnight, a dark, murky night without a moon — a circumstance which filled up the measure of our perplexity — we had no companion, no assistant, for all had deserted us. Nevertheless under the pressure of fear and in the expectation of immediate death, I got up, suffering as I was, having ordered torches to be lit. These however the presbyter ordered to be put out, for fear as he said lest the barbarians should be attracted by the light and attack us; so the torches were extinguished. Then the mule which carried my litter fell on its knees, the road being rugged, and steep and stony, and I who was inside was thrown down and narrowly escaped destruction, after which I dismounted, and was dragged along on foot, being held fast by Evethius the presbyter (for he also had alighted from his mule), and so I plodded on, led, or rather hauled by the hand, for to walk was impossible through such a difficult country, and among steep mountains in the middle of the night. Imagine what my sufferings must have been, encompassed as I was by such calamities, and oppressed by the fever, ignorant of the plans which had been made, but in terror of the barbarians and trembling. with the expectation of falling into their hands. Do you not think that these sufferings alone, even if nothing else besides had befallen me, would avail to blot out many of my sins, and afford ample material for obtaining praise with God? Now the reason of all this, at least as I suppose, was, that as soon as I arrived in Cæsarea, those who were in official positions, the learned men who were ex-vicars, and ex-governors, the ex-tribunes and indeed the whole people visited me every day, paid me great attention, and treated me as the apple of their eye; I suppose these things irritated Pharetrius and that the envy which drove me from Constantinople did not refrain from pursuing me even here. This at least is what I suppose, for I do not positively declare it but only suspect it to be the fact.

What can one say about the other events that happened along the way—the fears and the dangers? As I remember them day by day and constantly keep them in mind, I am filled with pleasure. I leap for joy like someone who has a great treasure stored up for him, for that is my situation and how I feel about them. Therefore I also beg you to rejoice at these things, to be glad and leap for joy, and to glorify God who has counted me worthy to suffer such things. And I ask you to keep these matters to yourself and not to reveal them to anyone, although for the most part the proconsular soldiers can fill the whole city with the story, since they themselves have undergone extreme danger.

And what is one to say about the other events which happened on the way, the fears and the perils? As I recall them day by day, and continually bear them in mind, I am elated with pleasure, I leap for joy as one who has a great treasure laid up in store for him; for such is my position and feeling about them. Wherefore also I beseech your Honour to rejoice at these things, to be glad, and leap for joy, and to glorify God who has counted me worthy to suffer such things. And I beseech you to keep these matters to yourself, and not to divulge them to any one, although for the most part the proconsular soldiers can fill all the city (with the story) as they themselves have undergone extreme danger.

Nevertheless, don't let anyone learn this from you, but instead silence those who talk about it. If you are worried that the effects of my mistreatment might linger, know for certain that I have completely freed myself from them, and that I am in better physical health than when I was living in Caesarea. And why do you fear the cold? A suitable house has been prepared for me, and my lord Dioscorus does and arranges everything to prevent me from feeling the slightest cold. And if I may judge from the beginning of my experience, the climate now seems to me eastern in character, no less than that of Antioch. The warmth is so great, the temperature so pleasant. But you have grieved me much by saying, "Perhaps you are annoyed with me for having neglected you," yet I sent a letter many days ago to your Honour begging you not to move me from this place. Now I realize that you need a strong defense and much hard work and effort to make a satisfactory apology for this statement. But perhaps you have made a partial apology by saying, "I am constantly thinking about how to increase my affliction." But I in turn consider it the greatest accusation that you should say I take pride in increasing my sorrow by dwelling on it, for when you ought to make every possible effort to dispel your affliction, you do the devil's will by increasing your despondency and sorrow. Are you not aware how great an evil despondency is?

4. Nevertheless do not let any one know this from your prudence, but rather put down those who talk about it. But if you are distressed lest the consequences of my ill-treatment should remain, know for certain that I have shaken myself entirely free from them, and that I am in better bodily health than when I was sojourning in Cæsarea. And why do you dread the cold? For a suitable dwelling has been prepared for me, and my lord Dioscorus does and arranges everything so as to prevent my having the least sensation of cold. And if I may form a conjecture from the outset of my experience, the climate now seems to me oriental in character, no less than that of Antioch. So great is the warmth, so pleasant is the temperature. But you have grieved me much by saying, perhaps you are annoyed with me as having neglected you, yet I dispatched a letter many days ago to your honour begging you not to move me from this place. Now I have had occasion to consider that you need a strong defense and much toil and labour to be able to make a satisfactory apology for this expression. But perhaps you have made a partial apology, by saying I am generally occupied in thinking how to increase my affliction. But I in my turn reckon it as the greatest accusation that you should say I take a pride in increasing my sorrow by thinking over it: for when you ought to make every possible effort to dispel your affliction you do the devil's will, by increasing your despondency and sorrow. Are you not aware how great an evil despondency is?

Regarding the Isaurians, stop worrying about them from now on. They have returned to their own country, and the governor has done everything necessary in this regard. I am much safer here than I was in Caesarea. From now on, I have no one to fear as much as the bishops, with a few exceptions. So don't be afraid about the Isaurians—they have withdrawn, and once winter arrives they will be confined to their own homes, though they may possibly come out again after Whitsuntide. And what do you mean by saying you haven't received letters from me? I have already sent you three long letters: one with the proconsular soldiers, one with Antonius, and the third with my servant Anatolius. Two of them were a healing medicine capable of reviving anyone who was despairing or stumbling, and leading them into a healthy state of peace. When you receive these letters, read through them constantly and carefully, and you will recognize their power and experience their healing effect and benefit, and you will tell me that you have gained much from them. I also have a third letter ready, similar to these, which I don't want to send right now because I was extremely upset when you said I pile up sorrowful thoughts and even invent things that don't exist—a statement unworthy of you that makes me ashamed. But read those letters I have sent, and you will no longer say such things, even if you are completely determined to be depressed. I, at least, have not stopped and will not stop saying that sin is the only thing that is truly distressing, and that all other things are just dust and smoke. For what is really painful about living in a prison and wearing a chain? Or about being mistreated when it brings so much gain? Or why should exile be painful, or the confiscation of property? These are just words, empty of any real terror—words devoid of sorrow. If you speak of death, you are only mentioning what is the debt of nature, something that must be experienced in any case even if no one hastens it. And if you speak of exile, you mention only a change of country and the sight of many cities. Or if you speak of confiscation of goods, you mention only freedom and release from worry.

As to the Isaurians, dismiss your fears in future concerning them: for they have returned into their own country: and the governor has done everything necessary in this respect; and I am in far greater security here than when I was in Cæsarea. For in future I have no one to fear so much as the bishops, with a few exceptions. On account of the Isaurians then fear nothing: for they have retreated, and when winter has set in they are confined to their own homes, although they may possibly come out after Whitsuntide. And what do you mean by saying that you have not the benefit of letters from me? I have already sent you three long letters, one by the proconsular soldiers, one by Antonius, and the third by Anatolius my servant; two of them were a salutary medicine capable of reviving any one who was desponding or stumbling, and conducting him into a healthy state of serenity. When you have received these letters then go over them constantly and thoroughly, and you will perceive their force and enjoy experience of their healing power, and benefit, and will inform me that you have derived much advantage therefrom. I have also a third letter ready, similar to these, which I do not choose to send at the present time having been exceedingly vexed at your saying I accumulate sorrowful thoughts, even inventing things which do not exist, an utterance unworthy of yourself, which makes me hide my head for shame. But read those letters which I have sent, and you will no longer say these things, even if you are infinitely bent on being despondent. I at least have not ceased, and will not cease saying that sin is the only thing which is really distressing; and that all other things are but dust and smoke. For what is there grievous in inhabiting a prison and wearing a chain? Or in being ill-treated when it is the occasion of so much gain? Or why should exile be grievous or confiscation of goods? These are mere words, destitute of any terrible reality, words void of sorrow. For if you speak of death you only mention that which is the debt of nature: a thing which must in any case be undergone even if no one hastens it: and if you speak of exile you mention that which only involves a change of country and the sight of many cities: or if you speak of confiscation of goods you mention what is only freedom and emancipation from care.

Do not stop paying attention to Bishop Maruthas, as far as it concerns you, so as to lift him up out of the pit. For I have special need of him because of the affairs in Persia. Find out from him, if you can, what has been accomplished there through his efforts, and why he has come home, and let me know whether you have delivered the two letters I sent to him. If he is willing to write to me, I will write back to him. But if he is not willing, let him at least tell you whether anything more has taken place there, and whether he is likely to accomplish anything by going there again. This is why I was eager to have a meeting with him. Nevertheless, let everything that depends on you be done, and take care to fulfill your own part, even if everyone else is rushing headlong to ruin. For this is how your reward will be perfected. By all means, therefore, make friends with him as much as possible. I beg you not to neglect what I am about to say, but to pay careful attention to it. The Marsian and Gothic monks where Bishop Serapion has constantly been hiding have informed me that Moduarius the deacon has come bringing word that Unilas, that excellent bishop whom I recently ordained and sent into Gothia, has died after achieving many great exploits. The deacon brought a letter from the king of the Goths requesting that a bishop be sent to them. Since I see no other way of dealing with the threatened catastrophe except delay and postponement (as it is impossible for them to sail into the Bosporus or into those parts at the present time), take measures to put them off for a time because of the winter season. Do not by any means neglect this, for it is a matter of the greatest importance. For there are two things that would especially distress me if they were to happen, which God forbid: one is that a bishop should be appointed by these men who have done such great wickedness and who have no right to appoint, and the other is that anyone should be appointed without proper consideration. For you know yourself that they are not eager to create some worthy man bishop, and if this should happen, which heaven forbid, you know what will follow. Use all diligence therefore to prevent either of these things from happening. But if it were possible for Moduarius to quietly and secretly hurry out to me, it would be of the greatest advantage. But if this is not possible, let what is practicable under the circumstances be done. For what takes place in the case of money, and actually occurred in the case of the widow in the gospel, also holds true in the case of practical affairs. For just as that poor woman, when she had cast two mites into the treasury, surpassed all those who had cast in more because she used up her whole substance, so too those who devote themselves to the work at hand with all their might complete it fully, as far as they are concerned, even if nothing results from it, and they have their reward perfected.

5. Do not cease to pay attention to Maruthas the Bishop, as far as it concerns you, so as to lift him up out of the pit. For I have special need of him on account of the affairs in Persia. And ascertain from him, if you can, what has been accomplished there through his agency, and for what purpose he has come home, and let me know whether you have delivered the two epistles which I sent to him: and if he is willing to write to me, I will write again to him: but if he should not be willing let him at least signify to your prudence whether anything more has taken place there, and whether he is likely to accomplish anything by going there again. For on this account I was anxious to have an interview with him. Nevertheless let all things which depend on you be done, and take care to fulfill your own part, even if all men are rushing headlong to ruin. For your reward will thus be perfected. By all means therefore make friends with him as far as it is possible. I beseech you not to neglect what I am about to say, but to pay diligent heed to it. The Marsian and Gothic monks where the Bishop Serapion has constantly been concealed have informed me that Moduarius the deacon has come bringing word that Unilas, that excellent bishop whom I lately ordained and sent into Gothia, has been laid to rest, after achieving many great exploits: and the deacon was the bearer of a letter from the king of the Goths begging that a bishop might be sent to them. Since then I see no other means of meeting the threatened catastrophe with a view to its correction save delay and postponement (as it is impossible for them to sail into the Bosporus or into those parts at the present time), take measures to put them off for a time on account of the winter season: and do not by any means neglect this: for it is a matter of the greatest importance. For there are two things which would specially distress me if they were to happen, which God forbid: one is that a bishop should be appointed by these men who have wrought such great wickedness, and who have no right to appoint, and the other is that any one should be made without consideration. For you know yourself that they are not anxious to create some worthy man bishop, and if this should take place, which heaven forbid, you are aware what will follow. Use all diligence therefore to prevent either of these things happening: but if it were possible for Moduarius quietly and secretly to hasten out to me it would be of the greatest advantage. But if this is not possible let what is practicable under the circumstances be done. For that which takes place in the case of money, and actually occurred in the case of the widow in the gospel, also holds good in the case of practical affairs. For as that poor woman when she had cast two mites into the treasury surpassed all those who had cast in more, because she used up her whole substance: even so they who devote themselves to the work in hand with all their might discharge it completely, so far as they are concerned, even if nothing results from it, and they have their reward perfected.

I am very grateful to Bishop Hilarius, because he wrote to me asking permission to leave for his own country, to arrange matters there, and then to return. Since his presence is very valuable (for he is a devout, inflexible, and zealous man), I have encouraged him to go and to come back quickly. Make sure, then, that the letter is delivered to him promptly and safely, and not set aside, because he earnestly and eagerly requested letters from me, and his presence is a great benefit. So by all means take care of the letters. And if Helladius the presbyter is not available, see that they are delivered to my friends by the hand of some sensible man who has good judgment.

I am very grateful to Hilarius the bishop: for he wrote to me asking to be allowed to depart to his own country, and to set things in order there, and then to come back again. As his presence therefore is of great service (for he is a devout, inflexible, and zealous man) I have urged him to depart and to return speedily. Take care then that the letter is quickly and safely delivered to him and not cast on one side: for he eagerly and earnestly begged for letters from me, and his presence is a great benefit. By all means therefore have a care of the letters; and if Helladius the presbyter be not on the spot see that they are delivered to my friends by the hands of some discreet man who has a head on his shoulders.

To Olympias

Nothing strange or unnatural has happened to your Piety, but only what is quite natural and reasonable: that through a constant succession of trials the sinews of your soul should become more strengthened, your zeal and energy for the struggle increased, and you should gain much joy from this. For this is the nature of affliction—when it takes hold of a brave and noble soul, this is what it normally produces. And just as fire, when applied to a piece of gold, makes it better proven, so also affliction, when it comes to golden characters, makes them purer and more proven. This is why Paul also said affliction works patience, and patience probation. For these reasons I too rejoice and leap for joy, and draw the greatest consolation in my solitude from considering your fortitude. Because of this, even though countless wolves surround you and many crowds of evildoers press in, I fear nothing. I pray both that present temptations may be suppressed and that others may not occur, thus fulfilling the Lord's command who tells us to pray that we may not enter into temptation. But if it should be permitted to happen again, I have good confidence concerning your golden soul, which gains from this the greatest riches for itself. For how will those who dare everything to their own destruction be able to terrify you? Will it be by loss of goods? But I know well that you count these as dust and cheaper than dirt. Or will it be by expulsion from country and home? But you know how to live in great and crowded cities as if they were uninhabited, spending all your time in quietness and rest, and trampling worldly ambitions under foot. Or do they threaten death? This also you have constantly practiced in advance, and if they should drag you to slaughter, they will be dragging a body that is already dead. What need is there to say more? No one will be able to do anything of this kind to you without finding that you have already abundantly made yourself undergo it. For by always walking the narrow and strait path, you have trained yourself in all these things. Therefore, having practiced this most beautiful art during your training, you now shine forth all the more gloriously in the contest itself, not only being in no way disturbed by what is happening, but rather uplifted, leaping and dancing for joy. For the contests you anticipated in your training you now undertake with great ease, even though in a woman's body, feebler than a cobweb, trampling under foot with mocking scorn the fury of strong men gnashing their teeth at you, being ready to suffer even worse things than they prepare for you. Happy and three times happy are you because of the crowns of victory to be won, but even more because of the contest itself. For such is the nature of these struggles: even before the prizes are given, even in the midst of strife, they have their recompense and reward—the pleasure you are now enjoying, the cheerfulness, the courage, the endurance, the patience, the strength that is proof against capture and conquest and rises superior to all things, the perfect training that makes you insensible to any terror from anyone, the power of standing on a rock in the midst of mighty waves of tribulation and sailing calmly with a favorable breeze when the sea is raging around you. These are the prizes of affliction even in this world before the kingdom of heaven is won. For I know very well that even at this present time, being lifted up with joy, you do not consider yourself clothed with a body, but if an opportunity should call you to do so, you would strip it off more readily than others do the clothing they wear. Rejoice therefore and be glad both for yourself and for those who have died a blessed death, not in a bed or in a house, but in prison, chains, and torment, and bewail only those who do these things, and grieve for them. But since you also wish to be informed about my bodily health, let me tell you that I have been relieved for now from the illness that was lately weighing me down and am now in a more comfortable condition. The only fear is that winter, on its return, might again wreak havoc on my feeble digestion, and as far as the Isaurians are concerned we now enjoy great security.

Nothing strange or unnatural has befallen your Piety, but only what is quite natural and consonant to reason, that by a constant succession of trials the sinews of your soul should become more braced, and your zeal and energy for the struggle increased, and that you should therefrom derive much joy. For such is the nature of affliction — when it lays hold of a brave and noble soul, this is what it is wont to effect. And as the fire makes the piece of gold, when it is applied to it, of better proof: so also affliction when it visits golden characters renders them purer and more proven. Wherefore also Paul said affliction works patience, and patience probation. Romans 5:3-4 For these reasons I also rejoice and leap for joy, and derive the greatest consolation of this my solitude from a consideration of your fortitude. On this account, even though innumerable wolves encompass you, and many crowds of wicked doers, I fear nothing; but I pray both that existing temptations may be suppressed, and that others may not occur, thus fulfilling the Lord's precept who bids us pray that we may not enter into temptation; but if it should be permitted to happen again I have good confidence concerning your golden soul, which acquires therefrom the greatest riches for itself. For by what means will they be able to terrify you, who dare everything to their own destruction? Will it be by loss of goods? But I know well that these are counted by you as dust and cheaper than dirt. Or shall it be by expulsion from country and home. But you know how to dwell in great and populous cities as if they were uninhabited, spending the whole of your time in quietness and rest, and treading worldly ambitions under foot. Or do they threaten death? This also you have constantly practiced by anticipation, and if they should drag you to slaughter, they will be dragging a body which is already dead. What need to speak more at length? No one will be able to do anything to you of this kind which he will not find you have already abundantly made yourself undergo. For by always walking in the narrow and strait path, you have trained yourself in all these things. Wherefore having practised this most beautiful art in the course of your training, you now shine forth the more gloriously in the contest itself, not only being in no wise disturbed by the things which are happening, but rather elated, and leaping and dancing for joy. For the contests which you have anticipated in your training you now undertake with much ease, although it be in a woman's body, feebler than a cobweb, treading under foot with derisive scorn the fury of lusty men gnashing their teeth upon you; being ready to suffer even worse things than they prepare for you. Happy and thrice happy are you by reason of the crowns of victory to be won, but even more by reason of the contest itself. For such is the nature of these struggles, even before the prizes are given even in the midst of strife they have their recompense and reward — the pleasure which you are now enjoying, the cheerfulness, the courage, the endurance, the patience, the power which is proof against capture and conquest and rises superior to all things; the perfect training which renders you insensible to any terror at the hands of any one, the power of standing on a rock in the midst of mighty billows of tribulation, and sailing in a calm with a favourable breeze when the sea is raging around you. These are the prizes of affliction even in this world before the kingdom of heaven is won. For I know very well that, even at this present time, being elated with joy, thou dost not consider yourself clothed with a body, but if an opportunity should summon you to do it, you would divest yourself of it more readily than others do of the raiment which they wear. Rejoice therefore and be glad both for yourself, and for those who have died a blessed death, not in a bed, nor in a house, but in prison, and chains, and torment; and bewail those only who do these things, and grieve for them. But since you also wish to be informed concerning my bodily health, let me tell you that I have been relieved for the present from the infirmity which was lately oppressing me, and am now in a more comfortable condition: the only fear is lest the winter on its return should again make havoc of my feeble digestion; and as far as the Isaurians are concerned we now enjoy great security.


Letters — Division I — Letters on the Apollinarian Controversy

Letters to Nectarius and to Cledonius against Apollinarius: Christ is one Person, perfect God and perfect man, with a human mind and soul.

Letters to Nectarius and to Cledonius against Apollinarius: Christ is one Person, perfect God and perfect man, with a human mind and soul.

5 letters — each opens on its own page.

No letter matches that.



To Ablabius: On “Not Three Gods”

Why Father, Son and Holy Spirit are one God and not three, though they are three hypostases sharing one ousia.

Source: Translated by H.A. Wilson. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series , Vol. 5. Edited by Philip Schaff and Henry Wace. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1893. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/2905.htm>.

Opening

To Ablabius.

To Ablabius.

You who are strengthened with all might in the inner man ought by rights to carry on the struggle against the enemies of the truth and not shrink from the task, so that we fathers may be gladdened by the noble efforts of our sons—for this is what the law of nature prompts. But since you turn your ranks around and send against us the attacks of those weapons hurled by the opponents of truth, and demand that their hot burning coals and their arrows sharpened by knowledge falsely so called should be quenched with the shield of faith by us old men, we accept your command and make ourselves an example of obedience. We do this so that you may give us the just reward by obeying similar commands yourself, Ablabius, noble soldier of Christ, if we should ever summon you to such a contest.

You that are strong with all might in the inner man ought by rights to carry on the struggle against the enemies of the truth, and not to shrink from the task, that we fathers may be gladdened by the noble toil of our sons; for this is the prompting of the law of nature: but as you turn your ranks, and send against us the assaults of those darts which are hurled by the opponents of the truth, and demand that their hot burning coals and their shafts sharpened by knowledge falsely so called should be quenched with the shield of faith by us old men, we accept your command, and make ourselves an example of obedience, in order that you may yourself give us the just requital on like commands, Ablabius, noble soldier of Christ, if we should ever summon you to such a contest.

The question you're asking us is no small matter, and it will cause serious harm if we don't address it properly. The way the question is framed initially forces us to accept one of two wrong views: either to say there are three Gods, which is forbidden, or to deny the Godhead of the Son and the Holy Spirit, which is both impious and absurd.

In truth, the question you propound to us is no small one, nor such that but small harm will follow if it meets with insufficient treatment. For by the force of the question, we are at first sight compelled to accept one or other of two erroneous opinions, and either to say there are three Gods, which is unlawful, or not to acknowledge the Godhead of the Son and the Holy Spirit, which is impious and absurd.

The argument you're presenting goes something like this: Peter, James, and John, sharing one human nature, are called three men, and there's nothing strange about using the plural form of a name derived from nature to describe those who are united in nature when there's more than one of them. So if everyday usage allows this, and no one objects to calling two people two or more than two people three, why is it that when we make statements about the mysteries of the Faith—though we confess three Persons and acknowledge no difference in nature between them—we somehow contradict our own confession when we say the Godhead of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit is one, yet forbid people from saying there are three Gods? This question is, as I said, very difficult to handle. Yet if we can find anything that offers support to our uncertain minds, so they no longer waver and stumble in this terrible dilemma, that would be good. On the other hand, even if our reasoning proves inadequate for the problem, we must hold forever, firm and unshaken, the tradition we received by succession from the fathers, and we must seek from the Lord the reason that defends our faith. And if this is discovered by anyone endowed with grace, we must give thanks to the one who gave the grace. But if not, we will nonetheless hold our faith unchangeably on those points that have been settled.

The argument which you state is something like this:– Peter, James, and John, being in one human nature, are called three men: and there is no absurdity in describing those who are united in nature, if they are more than one, by the plural number of the name derived from their nature. If, then, in the above case, custom admits this, and no one forbids us to speak of those who are two as two, or those who are more than two as three, how is it that in the case of our statements of the mysteries of the Faith, though confessing the Three Persons, and acknowledging no difference of nature between them, we are in some sense at variance with our confession, when we say that the Godhead of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost is one, and yet forbid men to say there are three Gods? The question is, as I said, very difficult to deal with: yet, if we should be able to find anything that may give support to the uncertainty of our mind, so that it may no longer totter and waver in this monstrous dilemma, it would be well: on the other hand, even if our reasoning be found unequal to the problem, we must keep for ever, firm and unmoved, the tradition which we received by succession from the fathers, and seek from the Lord the reason which is the advocate of our faith: and if this be found by any of those endowed with grace, we must give thanks to Him who bestowed the grace; but if not, we shall none the less, on those points which have been determined, hold our faith unchangeably.

What, then, is the reason that when we count one by one those who are presented to us in one nature, we ordinarily name them in the plural and speak of so many men, instead of calling them all one, while in the case of the Divine nature our doctrinal definition rejects the plurality of Gods, at the same time enumerating the Persons and yet not admitting the plural signification? Perhaps someone might seem to hit the mark if he were to say (speaking plainly to straightforward people) that the definition refused to reckon Gods in any number to avoid any resemblance to the polytheism of the pagans, lest, if we too were to enumerate the Deity not in the singular but in the plural, as they are accustomed to do, there might be supposed to be some shared doctrine as well. This answer, I say, if made to people of a more simple spirit, might seem to carry some weight, but in the case of the others who demand that one of the alternatives they propose should be established (either that we should not acknowledge the Godhead in Three Persons, or that, if we do, we should speak of those who share in the same Godhead as three), this answer does not furnish any solution to the difficulty. And therefore we must make our reply at greater length, tracing out the truth as best we can, for the question is no ordinary one.

What, then, is the reason that when we count one by one those who are exhibited to us in one nature, we ordinarily name them in the plural and speak of so many men, instead of calling them all one: while in the case of the Divine nature our doctrinal definition rejects the plurality of Gods, at once enumerating the Persons, and at the same time not admitting the plural signification? Perhaps one might seem to touch the point if he were to say (speaking offhand to straightforward people), that the definition refused to reckon Gods in any number to avoid any resemblance to the polytheism of the heathen, lest, if we too were to enumerate the Deity, not in the singular, but in the plural, as they are accustomed to do, there might be supposed to be also some community of doctrine. This answer, I say, if made to people of a more guileless spirit, might seem to be of some weight: but in the case of the others who require that one of the alternatives they propose should be established (either that we should not acknowledge the Godhead in Three Persons, or that, if we do, we should speak of those who share in the same Godhead as three), this answer is not such as to furnish any solution of the difficulty. And hence we must needs make our reply at greater length, tracing out the truth as best we may; for the question is no ordinary one.

We say, then, to begin with, that the practice of calling those who are not divided in nature by the very name of their common nature in the plural, and saying they are many men, is a customary misuse of language, and that it would be much the same thing to say they are many human natures. We can see the truth of this from the following example. When we address someone, we do not call him by the name of his nature, so that no confusion results from the shared name, as would happen if everyone who hears it thought that he himself was the person being addressed, because the call is made not by the proper name but by the common name of their nature. Instead, we separate him from the crowd by using the name that belongs to him as his own—that is, the name which identifies the particular subject. Thus there are many who have shared in the nature—many disciples, say, or apostles, or martyrs—but the man in them all is one. As we have said, the term man does not belong to the nature of the individual as such, but to what is common. Luke is a man, or Stephen is a man, but it does not follow that if anyone is a man he is therefore Luke or Stephen. Rather, the idea of the persons admits the separation that is made by the distinctive attributes considered in each one individually, and when they are combined they are presented to us by means of number. Yet their nature is one, unified in itself, and an absolutely indivisible unit, not capable of increase by addition or of decrease by subtraction, but in its essence being and continually remaining one, inseparable even though it appears in plurality, continuous, complete, and not divided among the individuals who participate in it. And just as we speak of a people, or a mob, or an army, or an assembly in the singular in every case, while each of these is understood as being plural in number, so according to the more accurate expression, man would be said to be one, even though those who are shown to us in the same nature make up a plurality. Thus it would be much better to correct our mistaken habit, so as no longer to extend the name of the nature to a plurality, than by our slavery to habit to transfer to our statements concerning God the error that exists in the above case. But since correcting the habit is impractical (for how could you persuade anyone not to speak of those who are shown in the same nature as many men?—indeed, in every case habit is hard to change), we are not so wrong in not going against the prevailing habit in the case of the lower nature, since no harm results from the mistaken use of the name. But in the case of the statement concerning the Divine nature, the loose use of terms is no longer so free from danger, for what is of small account in these subjects is no longer a small matter. Therefore we must confess one God, according to the testimony of Scripture, "Hear, O Israel, the Lord your God is one Lord," even though the name of Godhead extends through the Holy Trinity. I say this according to the account we have given in the case of human nature, in which we have learned that it is improper to extend the name of the nature by the mark of plurality. We must, however, examine the name of Godhead more carefully, in order to obtain, by means of the meaning involved in the word, some help toward clearing up the question before us.

We say, then, to begin with, that the practice of calling those who are not divided in nature by the very name of their common nature in the plural, and saying they are many men, is a customary abuse of language, and that it would be much the same thing to say they are many human natures. And the truth of this we may see from the following instance. When we address any one, we do not call him by the name of his nature, in order that no confusion may result from the community of the name, as would happen if every one of those who hear it were to think that he himself was the person addressed, because the call is made not by the proper appellation but by the common name of their nature: but we separate him from the multitude by using that name which belongs to him as his own — that, I mean, which signifies the particular subject. Thus there are many who have shared in the nature — many disciples, say, or apostles, or martyrs — but the man in them all is one; since, as has been said, the term man does not belong to the nature of the individual as such, but to that which is common. For Luke is a man, or Stephen is a man; but it does not follow that if any one is a man he is therefore Luke or Stephen: but the idea of the persons admits of that separation which is made by the peculiar attributes considered in each severally, and when they are combined is presented to us by means of number; yet their nature is one, at union in itself, and an absolutely indivisible unit, not capable of increase by addition or of diminution by subtraction, but in its essence being and continually remaining one, inseparable even though it appear in plurality, continuous, complete, and not divided with the individuals who participate in it. And as we speak of a people, or a mob, or an army, or an assembly in the singular in every case, while each of these is conceived as being in plurality, so according to the more accurate expression, man would be said to be one, even though those who are exhibited to us in the same nature make up a plurality. Thus it would be much better to correct our erroneous habit, so as no longer to extend to a plurality the name of the nature, than by our bondage to habit to transfer to our statements concerning God the error which exists in the above case. But since the correction of the habit is impracticable (for how could you persuade any one not to speak of those who are exhibited in the same nature as many men? — indeed, in every case habit is a thing hard to change), we are not so far wrong in not going contrary to the prevailing habit in the case of the lower nature, since no harm results from the mistaken use of the name: but in the case of the statement concerning the Divine nature the various use of terms is no longer so free from danger: for that which is of small account is in these subjects no longer a small matter. Therefore we must confess one God, according to the testimony of Scripture, Hear, O Israel, the Lord your God is one Lord, even though the name of Godhead extends through the Holy Trinity. This I say according to the account we have given in the case of human nature, in which we have learned that it is improper to extend the name of the nature by the mark of plurality. We must, however, more carefully examine the name of Godhead, in order to obtain, by means of the significance involved in the word, some help towards clearing up the question before us.

Most people think that the word Godhead is used in a special way with respect to nature. Just as heaven, the sun, or any other part of the universe is identified by proper names that signify the subjects, they say that in the case of the Supreme and Divine nature, the word Godhead is appropriately fitted to what it represents to us, like a kind of special name. We, on the other hand, following the guidance of Scripture, have learned that this nature is unnameable and unspeakable. We say that every term either invented by human custom or handed down to us by the Scriptures does explain our conceptions of the Divine nature, but does not contain the meaning of that nature itself. This can be shown without much difficulty. All other terms used for creation can be found, even without analyzing their origin, to be applied to subjects accidentally, because we are content to identify things in any way by the word applied to them so as to avoid confusion in our knowledge of the things signified. But all the terms employed to lead us to knowledge of God have each comprehended in them their own meaning, and you cannot find any word among the terms especially applied to God that is without a distinct sense. Therefore it is clear that by any of the terms we use, the Divine nature itself is not signified, but some aspect of what surrounds it is made known. For we say, for example, that the Deity is incorruptible, or powerful, or whatever else we customarily say of Him. But in each of these terms we find a particular sense, appropriate to be understood or affirmed of the Divine nature, yet not expressing what that nature is in its essence. For the subject, whatever it may be, is incorruptible. But our conception of incorruptibility is this: that what exists is not dissolved into decay. So when we say that He is incorruptible, we declare what His nature does not suffer, but we do not express what it is that does not suffer corruption. Similarly, if we say that He is the Giver of life, though we show by that name what He gives, we do not by that word declare what it is that gives it. By the same reasoning we find that everything else that results from the meaning involved in names expressing the Divine attributes either forbids us to conceive what we ought not to conceive of the Divine nature, or teaches us what we ought to conceive of it, but does not include an explanation of the nature itself. Since, then, we perceive the varied operations of the power above us, we fashion our names from the several operations that are known to us. And since we recognize as one of these that operation of surveying and inspection, or as one might call it, beholding, by which He surveys all things and overlooks them all, discerning our thoughts and even entering by His power of contemplation into those things that are not visible, we suppose that Godhead, or θεότης, is so called from θέα, or beholding, and that He who is our θεατής or beholder, by customary use and by the instruction of the Scriptures, is called θεός, or God. Now if anyone admits that to behold and to discern are the same thing, and that the God who superintends all things both is and is called the superintender of the universe, let him consider this operation and judge whether it belongs to one of the Persons we believe in the Holy Trinity, or whether the power extends throughout the three Persons. For if our interpretation of the term Godhead, or θεότης, is a true one, and the things that are seen are said to be beheld, or θεατά, and that which beholds them is called θεός, or God, no one of the Persons in the Trinity could reasonably be excluded from such a name on the ground of the sense involved in the word. For Scripture attributes the act of seeing equally to Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. David says, See, O God our defender, and from this we learn that sight is a proper operation of the idea of God, insofar as God is conceived, since he says, See, O God. But Jesus also sees the thoughts of those who condemn Him and questions why by His own power He pardons the sins of men. For it says, Jesus, seeing their thoughts. And of the Holy Spirit also, Peter says to Ananias, Why has Satan filled your heart, to lie to the Holy Ghost? This shows that the Holy Spirit was a true witness, aware of what Ananias had dared to do in secret, and by whom the manifestation of the secret was made to Peter. For Ananias became a thief of his own goods, secretly, as he thought, from all people, and concealing his sin. But the Holy Spirit at the same moment was in Peter and detected his intent, dragged down as it was to avarice, and gave to Peter from Himself the power of seeing the secret, while it is clear that He could not have done this had He not been able to behold hidden things.

Most men think that the word Godhead is used in a peculiar degree in respect of nature: and just as the heaven, or the sun, or any other of the constituent parts of the universe are denoted by proper names which are significant of the subjects, so they say that in the case of the Supreme and Divine nature, the word Godhead is fitly adapted to that which it represents to us, as a kind of special name. We, on the other hand, following the suggestions of Scripture, have learned that that nature is unnameable and unspeakable, and we say that every term either invented by the custom of men, or handed down to us by the Scriptures, is indeed explanatory of our conceptions of the Divine Nature, but does not include the signification of that nature itself. And it may be shown without much difficulty that this is the case. For all other terms which are used of the creation may be found, even without analysis of their origin, to be applied to the subjects accidentally, because we are content to denote the things in any way by the word applied to them so as to avoid confusion in our knowledge of the things signified. But all the terms that are employed to lead us to the knowledge of God have comprehended in them each its own meaning, and you cannot find any word among the terms especially applied to God which is without a distinct sense. Hence it is clear that by any of the terms we use the Divine nature itself is not signified, but some one of its surroundings is made known. For we say, it may be, that the Deity is incorruptible, or powerful, or whatever else we are accustomed to say of Him. But in each of these terms we find a peculiar sense, fit to be understood or asserted of the Divine nature, yet not expressing that which that nature is in its essence. For the subject, whatever it may be, is incorruptible: but our conception of incorruptibility is this — that that which is, is not resolved into decay: so, when we say that He is incorruptible, we declare what His nature does not suffer, but we do not express what that is which does not suffer corruption. Thus, again, if we say that He is the Giver of life, though we show by that appellation what He gives, we do not by that word declare what that is which gives it. And by the same reasoning we find that all else which results from the significance involved in the names expressing the Divine attributes either forbids us to conceive what we ought not to conceive of the Divine nature, or teaches us that which we ought to conceive of it, but does not include an explanation of the nature itself. Since, then, as we perceive the varied operations of the power above us, we fashion our appellations from the several operations that are known to us, and as we recognize as one of these that operation of surveying and inspection, or, as one might call it, beholding, whereby He surveys all things and overlooks them all, discerning our thoughts, and even entering by His power of contemplation into those things which are not visible, we suppose that Godhead, or θεότης, is so called from θέα, or beholding, and that He who is our θεατής or beholder, by customary use and by the instruction of the Scriptures, is called θεός, or God. Now if any one admits that to behold and to discern are the same thing, and that the God Who superintends all things, both is and is called the superintender of the universe, let him consider this operation, and judge whether it belongs to one of the Persons whom we believe in the Holy Trinity, or whether the power extends throughout the Three Persons. For if our interpretation of the term Godhead, or θεότης, is a true one, and the things which are seen are said to be beheld, or θεατά, and that which beholds them is called θεός, or God, no one of the Persons in the Trinity could reasonably be excluded from such an appellation on the ground of the sense involved in the word. For Scripture attributes the act of seeing equally to Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. David says, See, O God our defender: and from this we learn that sight is a proper operation of the idea of God, so far as God is conceived, since he says, See, O God. But Jesus also sees the thoughts of those who condemn Him, and questions why by His own power He pardons the sins of men? For it says, Jesus, seeing their thoughts. And of the Holy Spirit also, Peter says to Ananias, Why has Satan filled your heart, to lie to the Holy Ghost? Acts 5:3 showing that the Holy Spirit was a true witness, aware of what Ananias had dared to do in secret, and by Whom the manifestation of the secret was made to Peter. For Ananias became a thief of his own goods, secretly, as he thought, from all men, and concealing his sin: but the Holy Spirit at the same moment was in Peter, and detected his intent, dragged down as it was to avarice, and gave to Peter from Himself the power of seeing the secret, while it is clear that He could not have done this had He not been able to behold hidden things.

But someone will say that the proof of our argument does not yet address the question. For even if it were granted that the name of Godhead is a common name of the nature, it would not be established that we should not speak of Gods. Rather, by these arguments we are actually compelled to speak of Gods, because we find in human custom that not only those who share in the same nature, but even any who may be of the same occupation, are not spoken of in the singular when they are many. We speak of many orators, or surveyors, or farmers, or shoemakers, and so in all other cases. If Godhead were indeed a name of nature, it would be more proper, according to the argument laid down, to include the Three Persons in the singular number and to speak of One God, because of the inseparability and indivisibility of the nature. But since it has been established by what has been said that the term Godhead signifies operation and not nature, the argument from what has been advanced seems to turn to the opposite conclusion—that we ought all the more to call those three Gods who are contemplated in the same operation, just as one would speak of three philosophers or orators, or any other name derived from an occupation when those who take part in the same occupation are more than one.

But some one will say that the proof of our argument does not yet regard the question. For even if it were granted that the name of Godhead is a common name of the nature, it would not be established that we should not speak of Gods: but by these arguments, on the contrary, we are compelled to speak of Gods: for we find in the custom of mankind that not only those who are partakers in the same nature, but even any who may be of the same business, are not, when they are many, spoken of in the singular; as we speak of many orators, or surveyors, or farmers, or shoemakers, and so in all other cases. If, indeed, Godhead were an appellation of nature, it would be more proper, according to the argument laid down, to include the Three Persons in the singular number, and to speak of One God, by reason of the inseparability and indivisibility of the nature: but since it has been established by what has been said, that the term Godhead is significant of operation, and not of nature, the argument from what has been advanced seems to turn to the contrary conclusion, that we ought therefore all the more to call those three Gods who are contemplated in the same operation, as they say that one would speak of three philosophers or orators, or any other name derived from a business when those who take part in the same business are more than one.

I have put considerable effort into presenting this view by bringing forward the reasoning of our opponents, so that our conclusion may be more firmly established, being strengthened by these more detailed objections. Let us now return to our argument.

I have taken some pains, in setting forth this view, to bring forward the reasoning on behalf of the adversaries, that our decision may be the more firmly fixed, being strengthened by the more elaborate contradictions. Let us now resume our argument.

As we have already shown to some extent by our statement that the word "Godhead" does not signify nature but operation, one might reasonably suggest a reason why, in the case of human beings, those who share the same pursuits are counted and spoken of in the plural, while the Deity is spoken of in the singular as one God and one Godhead, even though the three hypostases are not separated from the meaning expressed by the term "Godhead." One might suggest, I say, the fact that human beings, even if several are engaged in the same form of action, work separately, each by himself, at the task he has undertaken, having no participation in his individual action with others who are engaged in the same occupation. For instance, take the case of several rhetoricians: their pursuit, being one, has the same name in numerous cases, but each of those who follow it works by himself—this one pleading on his own account, and that one on his own account. Thus, since among humans the action of each in the same pursuits is distinguished, they are properly called many, since each of them is separated from the others within his own sphere, according to the special character of his operation. But in the case of the divine physis, we do not similarly learn that the Father does anything by himself in which the Son does not work together, or again that the Son has any special operation apart from the Holy Spirit. Rather, every operation that extends from God to the creation, and is named according to our various conceptions of it, has its origin from the Father, proceeds through the Son, and is perfected in the Holy Spirit. For this reason the name derived from the operation is not divided according to the number of those who fulfill it, because the action of each concerning anything is not separate and distinct, but whatever comes to pass—whether in reference to the acts of his providence for us or to the government and constitution of the universe—comes to pass by the action of the three, yet what does come to pass is not three things. We may understand the meaning of this from one single example. From him, I say, who is the chief source of gifts, all things that have shared in this grace have obtained their life. When we inquire, then, where this good gift came to us from, we find by the guidance of the Scriptures that it was from the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Yet although we set forth three hypostases and three names, we do not consider that we have had bestowed upon us three lives, one from each hypostasis separately. Rather, the same life is worked in us by the Father, prepared by the Son, and depends on the will of the Holy Spirit. Since then the Holy Trinity fulfills every operation in a manner similar to what I have spoken of, not by separate action according to the number of the hypostases, but so that there is one motion and disposition of the good will that is communicated from the Father through the Son to the Spirit (for just as we do not call those whose operation gives one life three givers of life, neither do we call those who are contemplated in one goodness three good beings, nor speak of them in the plural by any of their other attributes), so neither can we call those who exercise this divine and superintending power and operation toward ourselves and all creation, jointly and inseparably, by their mutual action, three Gods. For just as when we learn concerning the God of the universe, from the words of Scripture, that he judges all the earth, we say that he is the judge of all things through the Son; and again, when we hear that the Father judges no one, we do not think that the Scripture contradicts itself (for he who judges all the earth does this by his Son to whom he has committed all judgment; and everything that is done by the Only-begotten has its reference to the Father, so that he himself is at once the judge of all things and judges no one, by reason of his having, as we said, committed all judgment to the Son, while all the judgment of the Son conforms to the will of the Father; and one could not properly say either that they are two judges, or that one of them is excluded from the authority and power implied in judgment)—so also in the case of the word "Godhead," Christ is the power of God and the wisdom of God, and that very power of superintendence and oversight that we call Godhead, the Father exercises through the Only-begotten, while the Son perfects every power by the Holy Spirit, judging, as Isaiah says, by the Spirit of judgment and the Spirit of burning, and acting by him also, according to the saying in the Gospel that was spoken to the Jews. For he says, "If I by the Spirit of God cast out demons," where he includes every form of doing good in a partial description, by reason of the unity of action, for the name derived from operation cannot be divided among many where the result of their mutual operation is one.

As we have to a certain extent shown by our statement that the word Godhead is not significant of nature but of operation, perhaps one might reasonably allege as a cause why, in the case of men, those who share with one another in the same pursuits are enumerated and spoken of in the plural, while on the other hand the Deity is spoken of in the singular as one God and one Godhead, even though the Three Persons are not separated from the significance expressed by the term Godhead, — one might allege, I say, the fact that men, even if several are engaged in the same form of action, work separately each by himself at the task he has undertaken, having no participation in his individual action with others who are engaged in the same occupation. For instance, supposing the case of several rhetoricians, their pursuit, being one, has the same name in the numerous cases: but each of those who follow it works by himself, this one pleading on his own account, and that on his own account. Thus, since among men the action of each in the same pursuits is discriminated, they are properly called many, since each of them is separated from the others within his own environment, according to the special character of his operation. But in the case of the Divine nature we do not similarly learn that the Father does anything by Himself in which the Son does not work conjointly, or again that the Son has any special operation apart from the Holy Spirit; but every operation which extends from God to the Creation, and is named according to our variable conceptions of it, has its origin from the Father, and proceeds through the Son, and is perfected in the Holy Spirit. For this reason the name derived from the operation is not divided with regard to the number of those who fulfil it, because the action of each concerning anything is not separate and peculiar, but whatever comes to pass, in reference either to the acts of His providence for us, or to the government and constitution of the universe, comes to pass by the action of the Three, yet what does come to pass is not three things. We may understand the meaning of this from one single instance. From Him, I say, Who is the chief source of gifts, all things which have shared in this grace have obtained their life. When we inquire, then, whence this good gift came to us, we find by the guidance of the Scriptures that it was from the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Yet although we set forth Three Persons and three names, we do not consider that we have had bestowed upon us three lives, one from each Person separately; but the same life is wrought in us by the Father, and prepared by the Son, and depends on the will of the Holy Spirit. Since then the Holy Trinity fulfils every operation in a manner similar to that of which I have spoken, not by separate action according to the number of the Persons, but so that there is one motion and disposition of the good will which is communicated from the Father through the Son to the Spirit (for as we do not call those whose operation gives one life three Givers of life, neither do we call those who are contemplated in one goodness three Good beings, nor speak of them in the plural by any of their other attributes); so neither can we call those who exercise this Divine and superintending power and operation towards ourselves and all creation, conjointly and inseparably, by their mutual action, three Gods. For as when we learn concerning the God of the universe, from the words of Scripture, that He judges all the earth Romans 3:6, we say that He is the Judge of all things through the Son: and again, when we hear that the Father judges no man, we do not think that the Scripture is at variance with itself –(for He Who judges all the earth does this by His Son to Whom He has committed all judgment; and everything which is done by the Only-begotten has its reference to the Father, so that He Himself is at once the Judge of all things and judges no man, by reason of His having, as we said, committed all judgment to the Son, while all the judgment of the Son is conformable to the will of the Father; and one could not properly say either that They are two judges, or that one of Them is excluded from the authority and power implied in judgment);– so also in the case of the word Godhead, Christ is the power of God and the wisdom of God, and that very power of superintendence and beholding which we call Godhead, the Father exercises through the Only-begotten, while the Son perfects every power by the Holy Spirit, judging, as Isaiah says, by the Spirit of judgment and the Spirit of burning Isaiah 4:4, and acting by Him also, according to the saying in the Gospel which was spoken to the Jews. For He says, If I by the Spirit of God cast out devils Matthew 12:28; where He includes every form of doing good in a partial description, by reason of the unity of action: for the name derived from operation cannot be divided among many where the result of their mutual operation is one.

Since the character of the superintending and observing power is one in Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, as we said in our previous argument—flowing from the Father as from a spring, brought into operation by the Son, and perfecting its grace through the power of the Spirit—and since no operation is separated with respect to the Persons, being fulfilled by each one individually apart from those joined with Him in our contemplation, but all providence, care, and oversight of everything, both in the sensible creation and in things of supramundane nature, and that power which preserves what exists, corrects what is wrong, and instructs what is rightly ordered, is one and not three (being directed by the Holy Trinity yet not divided by a threefold separation according to the number of the Persons contemplated in the Faith, so that each act, considered by itself, would be the work of the Father alone, or peculiarly of the Son, or separately of the Holy Spirit), but rather—as the Apostle says, "the one and the selfsame Spirit divides His good gifts to every man severally"—the movement of good proceeding from the Spirit is not without a beginning. We find that the power we conceive as preceding this movement, which is the Only-begotten God, is the maker of all things; without Him nothing that exists attains the beginning of its being. And again, this same source of good issues from the will of the Father.

Since, then, the character of the superintending and beholding power is one, in Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, as has been said in our previous argument, issuing from the Father as from a spring, brought into operation by the Son, and perfecting its grace by the power of the Spirit; and since no operation is separated in respect of the Persons, being fulfilled by each individually apart from that which is joined with Him in our contemplation, but all providence, care, and superintendence of all, alike of things in the sensible creation and of those of supramundane nature, and that power which preserves the things which are, and corrects those which are amiss, and instructs those which are ordered aright, is one, and not three, being, indeed, directed by the Holy Trinity, yet not severed by a threefold division according to the number of the Persons contemplated in the Faith, so that each of the acts, contemplated by itself, should be the work of the Father alone, or of the Son peculiarly, or of the Holy Spirit separately, but while, as the Apostle says, the one and the selfsame Spirit divides His good gifts to every man severally 1 Corinthians 12:11, the motion of good proceeding from the Spirit is not without beginning — we find that the power which we conceive as preceding this motion, which is the Only-begotten God, is the maker of all things; without Him no existent thing attains to the beginning of its being: and, again, this same source of good issues from the will of the Father.

If, then, every good thing and every good name, depending on that power and purpose which is without beginning, is brought to completion in the power of the Spirit through the Only-begotten God, without any mark of time or distinction (since there is no delay, whether actual or conceived, in the movement of the Divine will from the Father, through the Son, to the Spirit), and if Godhead is also one of the good names and concepts, it would not be right to divide the name into a plurality, since the unity that exists in the action prevents us from counting them as plural. And just as the Savior of all people, especially of those who believe, is spoken of by the Apostle as one, and no one argues from this phrase either that the Son does not save those who believe, or that salvation is given to those who receive it without the involvement of the Spirit—but rather that God who is over all is the Savior of all, while the Son accomplishes salvation through the grace of the Spirit, and yet they are not on this account called three Saviors in Scripture (even though salvation is confessed to come from the Holy Trinity)—so likewise they are not called three Gods, according to the meaning assigned to the term Godhead, even though the aforesaid title belongs to the Holy Trinity.

If, then, every good thing and every good name, depending on that power and purpose which is without beginning, is brought to perfection in the power of the Spirit through the Only-begotten God, without mark of time or distinction (since there is no delay, existent or conceived, in the motion of the Divine will from the Father, through the Son, to the Spirit): and if Godhead also is one of the good names and concepts, it would not be proper to divide the name into a plurality, since the unity existing in the action prevents plural enumeration. And as the Saviour of all men, specially of them that believe 1 Timothy 4:10, is spoken of by the Apostle as one, and no one from this phrase argues either that the Son does not save them who believe, or that salvation is given to those who receive it without the intervention of the Spirit; but God who is over all, is the Saviour of all, while the Son works salvation by means of the grace of the Spirit, and yet they are not on this account called in Scripture three Saviours (although salvation is confessed to proceed from the Holy Trinity): so neither are they called three Gods, according to the signification assigned to the term Godhead, even though the aforesaid appellation attaches to the Holy Trinity.

It doesn't seem to me absolutely necessary, for the sake of proving our present argument, to argue against those who oppose us by saying that we shouldn't think of Godhead as an operation. We believe the Divine nature is unlimited and incomprehensible, so we don't claim to comprehend it. Instead, we declare that the nature must be understood as infinite in every respect. What is absolutely infinite is not limited in one way while remaining unlimited in another—infinity is completely free from any limitation. So whatever is without limit is surely not even limited by a name. To maintain consistency in our understanding of the infinity of the Divine nature, we say that the Deity is above every name, and Godhead is a name. The same thing cannot both be a name and be considered above every name at the same time.

It does not seem to me absolutely necessary, with a view to the present proof of our argument, to contend against those who oppose us with the assertion that we are not to conceive Godhead as an operation. For we, believing the Divine nature to be unlimited and incomprehensible, conceive no comprehension of it, but declare that the nature is to be conceived in all respects as infinite: and that which is absolutely infinite is not limited in one respect while it is left unlimited in another, but infinity is free from limitation altogether. That therefore which is without limit is surely not limited even by name. In order then to mark the constancy of our conception of infinity in the case of the Divine nature, we say that the Deity is above every name: and Godhead is a name. Now it cannot be that the same thing should at once be a name and be accounted as above every name.

But if our opponents prefer to say that the term refers not to operation but to nature, we will return to our original argument: that common usage wrongly applies the name of a nature to indicate a multitude. According to true reasoning, no nature undergoes diminution or increase when it is observed in a larger or smaller number. Only those things that are observed with individual boundaries can be counted by addition. This boundary is marked by bodily appearance, size, place, difference in shape and color, and whatever is observed apart from these conditions is free from the boundary formed by such categories. What is not bounded in this way cannot be counted, and what cannot be counted cannot be observed as a multitude. For instance, we say that gold, even when cut into many shapes, is one, and we speak of it that way. But we speak of many coins or many staters without finding any multiplication of the nature of gold through the number of staters. For this reason, when gold is observed in greater quantity, whether in plate or in coin, we speak of it as much gold, but we do not speak of many golds because of the amount of material—except when someone says there are many gold pieces (Darics, for instance, or staters), in which case the number applies not to the material but to the pieces of money. Indeed, properly speaking, we should not call them gold but golden.

But if it pleases our adversaries to say that the significance of the term is not operation, but nature, we shall fall back upon our original argument, that custom applies the name of a nature to denote multitude erroneously: since according to true reasoning neither diminution nor increase attaches to any nature, when it is contemplated in a larger or smaller number. For it is only those things which are contemplated in their individual circumscription which are enumerated by way of addition. Now this circumscription is noted by bodily appearance, and size, and place, and difference figure and color, and that which is contemplated apart from these conditions is free from the circumscription which is formed by such categories. That which is not thus circumscribed is not enumerated, and that which is not enumerated cannot be contemplated in multitude. For we say that gold, even though it be cut into many figures, is one, and is so spoken of, but we speak of many coins or many staters, without finding any multiplication of the nature of gold by the number of staters; and for this reason we speak of gold, when it is contemplated in greater bulk, either in plate or in coin, as much, but we do not speak of it as many golds on account of the multitude of the material — except when one says there are many gold pieces (Darics, for instance, or staters), in which case it is not the material, but the pieces of money to which the significance of number applies: indeed, properly, we should not call them gold but golden.

As the gold coins are many but the gold itself is one, so too those who are shown to us individually in the nature of man—such as Peter, James, and John—are many, yet the man in them is one. And although Scripture uses the word according to its plural meaning when it says "men swear by the greater" and "sons of men" and in other similar phrases, we must recognize that in following the customary form of speech, it does not establish a rule about the proper way to use words. Nor does it say these things to instruct us about language, but rather uses the word according to prevailing custom with only this goal: that the word may benefit those who receive it. It takes no careful concern about its manner of speech on points where no harm can result from the phrasing in terms of how it is understood.

As, then, the golden staters are many, but the gold is one, so too those who are exhibited to us severally in the nature of man, as Peter, James, and John, are many, yet the man in them is one. And although Scripture extends the word according to the plural significance, where it says men swear by the greater Hebrews 6:16, and sons of men, and in other phrases of the like sort, we must recognize that in using the custom of the prevailing form of speech, it does not lay down a law as to the propriety of using the words in one way or another, nor does it say these things by way of giving us instruction about phrases, but uses the word according to the prevailing custom, with a view only to this, that the word may be profitable to those who receive it, taking no minute care in its manner of speech about points where no harm can result from the phrases in respect of the way they are understood.

It would take too long to catalog in detail all the Scriptures where expressions are inexactly formulated, in order to prove what I have stated. However, when there is a risk of harming any part of the truth, we no longer find in Scripture any careless or indifferent use of words. For this reason, Scripture allows the naming of men in the plural, because no one is led astray by such a manner of speech to imagine multiple humanities, or to suppose that many human natures are indicated by the fact that the name expressing that nature is used in the plural. But the word God Scripture uses carefully in the singular form only, guarding against introducing the idea of different natures in the Divine essence through the plural signification of Gods. This is why it says, the Lord our God is one Lord, and also proclaims the Only-begotten God by the name of Godhead, without dividing the Unity into a dual signification so as to call the Father and the Son two Gods, although each is proclaimed by the holy writers as God. The Father is God; the Son is God; and yet by the same proclamation God is One, because no difference either of nature or of operation is contemplated in the Godhead. For if, according to the idea of those who have been led astray, the nature of the Holy Trinity were diverse, the number would consequently be extended to a plurality of Gods, being divided according to the diversity of essence in the subjects. But since the Divine, single, and unchanging nature, in order to be one, rejects all diversity in essence, it does not admit in its own case the signification of multitude. Just as it is called one nature, so it is called in the singular by all its other names: God, Good, Holy, Savior, Just, Judge, and every other Divine name conceivable. Whether one says that the names refer to nature or to operation, we shall not dispute the point.

Indeed, it would be a lengthy task to set out in detail from the Scriptures those constructions which are inexactly expressed, in order to prove the statement I have made; where, however, there is a risk of injury to any part of the truth, we no longer find in Scriptural phrases any indiscriminate or indifferent use of words. For this reason Scripture admits the naming of men in the plural, because no one is by such a figure of speech led astray in his conceptions to imagine a multitude of humanities, or supposes that many human natures are indicated by the fact that the name expressive of that nature is used in the plural. But the word God it employs studiously in the singular form only, guarding against introducing the idea of different natures in the Divine essence by the plural signification of Gods. This is the cause why it says, the Lord our God is one Lord Deuteronomy 6:4, and also proclaims the Only-begotten God by the name of Godhead, without dividing the Unity into a dual signification, so as to call the Father and the Son two Gods, although each is proclaimed by the holy writers as God. The Father is God: the Son is God: and yet by the same proclamation God is One, because no difference either of nature or of operation is contemplated in the Godhead. For if (according to the idea of those who have been led astray) the nature of the Holy Trinity were diverse, the number would by consequence be extended to a plurality of Gods, being divided according to the diversity of essence in the subjects. But since the Divine, single, and unchanging nature, that it may be one, rejects all diversity in essence, it does not admit in its own case the signification of multitude; but as it is called one nature, so it is called in the singular by all its other names, God, Good, Holy, Saviour, Just, Judge, and every other Divine name conceivable: whether one says that the names refer to nature or to operation, we shall not dispute the point.

If anyone objects to our argument on the grounds that by not admitting a difference of nature it leads to a mixture and confusion of the Persons, we will give this answer to such a charge: while we confess that the character of the nature remains constant, we do not deny the difference in respect of cause and that which is caused. By this difference alone we understand that one Person is distinguished from another—by our belief that one is the Cause, and another is from the Cause. And within that which is from the Cause we recognize another distinction. For one comes directly from the first Cause, and another comes through that which is directly from the first Cause. In this way the attribute of being Only-begotten remains without question in the Son, and the Son's position in between, while it preserves His attribute of being Only-begotten, does not exclude the Spirit from His relation by way of physis to the Father.

If, however, any one cavils at our argument, on the ground that by not admitting the difference of nature it leads to a mixture and confusion of the Persons, we shall make to such a charge this answer — that while we confess the invariable character of the nature, we do not deny the difference in respect of cause, and that which is caused, by which alone we apprehend that one Person is distinguished from another — by our belief, that is, that one is the Cause, and another is of the Cause; and again in that which is of the Cause we recognize another distinction. For one is directly from the first Cause, and another by that which is directly from the first Cause; so that the attribute of being Only-begotten abides without doubt in the Son, and the interposition of the Son, while it guards His attribute of being Only-begotten, does not shut out the Spirit from His relation by way of nature to the Father.

When we speak of "cause" and "that which is caused," these words do not refer to nature (since no one would define cause and nature in the same way). Rather, we are pointing out a difference in the manner of existence. When we say that one is caused and the other is without cause, we are not dividing the nature by using the word "cause." We are simply indicating that the Son does not exist without being begotten, while the Father does not exist by being begotten. We must first believe that something exists, and then examine the manner in which what we believe in exists. The question of whether something exists is one thing; the question of how it exists is another. To say that something exists without being begotten describes the mode of its existence, but this phrase does not tell us what the thing actually is. If someone asked a farmer about a tree—whether it was planted or grew on its own—and the farmer answered either that it was not planted or that it was planted, would that answer reveal the nature of the tree? Certainly not. He would be explaining how it exists while leaving the question of what it is unclear and unexplained. Likewise, when we learn that He is unbegotten, we are taught the mode in which He exists and how we should conceive of His existence, but we do not learn from that phrase what He is. Therefore, when we recognize this kind of distinction within the Holy Trinity—believing that one Person (prosopon) is the Cause and another is from the Cause—we can no longer be accused of confusing the definition of the Persons by appealing to their shared nature.

But in speaking of cause, and of the cause, we do not by these words denote nature (for no one would give the same definition of cause and of nature), but we indicate the difference in manner of existence. For when we say that one is caused, and that the other is without cause, we do not divide the nature by the word cause, but only indicate the fact that the Son does not exist without generation, nor the Father by generation: but we must needs in the first place believe that something exists, and then scrutinize the manner of existence of the object of our belief: thus the question of existence is one, and that of the mode of existence is another. To say that anything exists without generation sets forth the mode of its existence, but what exists is not indicated by this phrase. If one were to ask a husbandman about a tree, whether it were planted or had grown of itself, and he were to answer either that the tree had not been planted or that it was the result of planting, would he by that answer declare the nature of the tree? Surely not; but while saying how it exists he would leave the question of its nature obscure and unexplained. So, in the other case, when we learn that He is unbegotten, we are taught in what mode He exists, and how it is fit that we should conceive Him as existing, but what He is we do not hear in that phrase. When, therefore, we acknowledge such a distinction in the case of the Holy Trinity, as to believe that one Person is the Cause, and another is of the Cause, we can no longer be accused of confounding the definition of the Persons by the community of nature.

Since the idea of cause differentiates the Persons of the Holy Trinity by declaring that one exists without a cause and another is of the cause, and since the Divine nature is understood by every concept as unchangeable and undivided, we properly declare that the Godhead is one and that God is one, and we use singular terms for all other names that express Divine attributes.

Thus, since on the one hand the idea of cause differentiates the Persons of the Holy Trinity, declaring that one exists without a Cause, and another is of the Cause; and since on the one hand the Divine nature is apprehended by every conception as unchangeable and undivided, for these reasons we properly declare the Godhead to be one, and God to be one, and employ in the singular all other names which express Divine attributes.