Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 88 — John 21:15

Homily 88 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240188.htm>.

Contents · 9 chapters
  1. John 21:15
  2. John 21:17
  3. John 21:18
  4. John 21:19
  5. John 21:20-21
  6. John 21:22
  7. John 21:23
  8. John 21:24
  9. John 21:25

John 21:15

There are indeed many other things that can give us boldness toward God and show us to be bright and approved, but what most of all brings goodwill from on high is tender care for our neighbor. This is therefore what Christ requires of Peter. For when their eating was finished, Jesus says to Simon Peter, "Simon, son of Jonas, do you love Me more than these?" He says to Him, "Yes, Lord, You know that I love You."

1. There are indeed many other things which are able to give us boldness towards God, and to show us bright and approved, but that which most of all brings good will from on high, is tender care for our neighbor. Which therefore Christ requires of Peter. For when their eating was ended, Jesus says to Simon Peter, Simon, son of Jonas, do you love Me more than these? He says unto Him, Yea, Lord, You know that I love You.

He says to him, Feed My sheep.

He says unto him, Feed My sheep.

And why does He speak with Peter about these matters, passing by the others? He was the chosen one of the Apostles, the mouth of the disciples, the leader of the band; for this reason Paul also went up at one time to inquire of him rather than the others. And at the same time, to show him that he must now be confident, since the denial was done away with, Jesus puts into his hands the chief authority among the brethren. He does not bring up the denial or reproach him with what had happened, but says, "If you love Me, preside over your brethren, and the fervent love which you always showed and in which you rejoiced, demonstrate now; and the life which you said you would lay down for Me, now give for My sheep."

And why, having passed by the others, does He speak with Peter on these matters? He was the chosen one of the Apostles, the mouth of the disciples, the leader of the band; on this account also Paul went up upon a time to enquire of him rather than the others. And at the same time to show him that he must now be of good cheer, since the denial was done away, Jesus puts into his hands the chief authority among the brethren; and He brings not forward the denial, nor reproaches him with what had taken place, but says, If you love Me, preside over your brethren, and the warm love which you ever manifested, and in which you rejoiced, show thou now; and the life which you said you would lay down for Me, now give for My sheep.

When Peter was asked once and then again, he called upon Him who knows the secrets of the heart to witness. "He said to him again the second time, Simon, son of Jonas, do you love Me? He said to Him, Yes, Lord, You know that I love You. He said to him, Feed my sheep." And then Peter was asked even a third time. "He said to him the third time, Simon, son of Jonas, do you love Me? Peter was grieved because He said to him the third time, Do you love Me; and he said to Him, Lord, You know all things; You know that I love You. Jesus said to him, Feed my sheep." Peter was troubled, fearing a repetition of what had happened before, for back then, having been strong in his assertion, he was afterwards proven wrong, and therefore he turns again to Him. For the saying,

When then having been asked once and again, he called Him to witness who knows the secrets of the heart, " He saith to him again the second time, Simon, son of Jonas, do you love Me? He saith unto Him, Yea, Lord, Thou know that I love Thee. He saith unto him, Feed my sheep. " and then was asked even a third time, " He saith unto him the third time, Simon, son of Jonas, do you love Me? Peter was grieved because He said to him the third time, Do you love Me; and he said to Him, Lord, Thou know all things; Thou know that I love Thee. Jesus saith unto him, Feed my sheep. " N.T. }}–> he was troubled, fearing a repetition of what had happened before, (for then, having been strong in assertion, he was afterwards convicted,) and therefore he again betakes himself to Him. For the saying,

John 21:17

You know all things means things present and things to come. Do you see how he had become better and more disciplined, no longer self-willed or contradicting? For this is why he was troubled, lest perhaps I think that I love, yet do not love, just as before when I thought and declared much, yet I was proven wrong in the end. But Jesus asks him the third time, and the third time gives him the same command, to show how highly He values the care of His own sheep, and that this especially is a sign of love toward Him. And having spoken to him concerning love toward Himself, He foretells to him the martyrdom which he would undergo, showing that He did not say to him what He said out of distrust, but out of great trust in him; wishing besides to point out a proof of love toward Him, and to instruct us in what manner especially we ought to love Him. Therefore He says…

You know all things, means, things present, and things to come. Do you see how he had become better and more sober, being no more self-willed, or contradicting? For on this account he was troubled, lest perchance I think that I love, and love not, as before when I thought and affirmed much, yet I was convicted at last. But Jesus asks him the third time, and the third time gives him the same injunction, to show at what a price He sets the care of His own sheep, and that this especially is a sign of love towards Him. And having spoken to him concerning the love towards Himself, He foretells to him the martyrdom which he should undergo, showing that He said not to Him what he said as distrusting, but as greatly trusting him; wishing besides to point out a proof of love towards Him, and to instruct us in what manner especially we ought to love Him. Wherefore He says…

John 21:18

And yet he did will this and desired it, which is why Christ revealed it to him. Since Peter had continually said, "I will lay down my life for You" (John 13:37), and "Though I should die with You, yet will I not deny You" (Matthew 26:35), Christ has given him back his desire. What then is the meaning of "whither you will not"? He is speaking of natural feeling and the necessity of the flesh, and that the soul is unwillingly torn away from the body. So even though the will is firm, still even then nature would be found at fault. For no one lays aside the body without feeling, since God, as I said before, has suitably ordained this so that violent deaths might not be many. For if, as things are, the devil has been able to accomplish this and has led countless people to precipices and pits, had the soul not felt such a desire for the body, many would have rushed to this under any common discouragement. The phrase "whither you will not" is then the expression of one signifying natural feeling.

And yet this he did will, and desired; on which account also He has revealed it to him. For since Peter had continually said, I will lay down my life for You John 13:37, and, Though I should die with You, yet will I not deny You Matthew 26:35: He has given him back his desire. What then is the, Whither you will not? He speaks of natural feeling, and the necessity of the flesh, and that the soul is unwillingly torn away from the body. So that even though the will were firm, yet still even then nature would be found in fault. For no one lays aside the body without feeling, God, as I said before, having suitably ordained this, that violent deaths might not be many. For if, as things are, the devil has been able to effect this, and has led ten thousand to precipices and pits; had not the soul felt such a desire for the body, the many would have rushed to this under any common discouragement. The, whither you will not, is then the expression of one signifying natural feeling.

But how, after having said "When you were young," does He again say "When you are old"? This would suggest that Peter was not then young (and indeed he was not, nor was he old, but middle-aged). So why did Jesus remind him of his former life? He was showing that this is the physis of what belongs to Him. In the things of this life, a young man is useful and an old man useless, but in Mine, He says, it is not so. Rather, when old age has come, then excellence is brighter, then manliness is more illustrious, being hindered by nothing in the time of life. He said this not to terrify Peter, but to rouse him, for He knew his love and that he had long yearned for this blessing. At the same time He declares the kind of death. For since Peter always desired to be in the dangers which were for His sake, "Be of good cheer," He says, "I will so satisfy your desire that what you did not suffer when young, you will suffer when you are old." Then the Evangelist, to rouse the hearer, has added,

But how after having said, When you were young, does He again say, When you are old? For this is the expression of one declaring that he was not then young; (nor was he; nor yet old, but a man of middle age.) Wherefore then did He recall to his memory his former life? Signifying, that this is the nature of what belongs to Him. In things of this life the young man is useful, the old useless; but in Mine, He says, not so; but when old age has come on, then is excellence brighter, then is manliness more illustrious, being nothing hindered by the time of life. This He said not to terrify, but to rouse Him; for He knew his love, and that he long had yearned for this blessing. At the same time He declares the kind of death. For since Peter ever desired to be in the dangers which were for His sake, Be of good cheer, He says, I will so satisfy your desire, that, what you suffered not when young, you must suffer when you are old. Then the Evangelist, to rouse the hearer, has added,

John 21:19

He did not say "should die," but rather "should glorify God," so that you may learn that to suffer for Christ is glory and honor to the one who suffers.

He said not, Should die, but, Should glorify God, that you may learn, that to suffer for Christ, is glory and honor to the sufferer.

And after He had said this, He says, Follow Me.

And when He had spoken this, He says, Follow Me.

Here again He refers to his tender care and to his being very closely connected to Himself. And if anyone should ask, How then did James receive the chair at Jerusalem? I would give this answer, that He appointed Peter teacher, not of the chair, but of the world.

Here again He alludes to his tender carefulness, and to his being very closely attached to Himself. And if any should say, How then did James receive the chair at Jerusalem? I would make this reply, that He appointed Peter teacher, not of the chair, but of the world.

John 21:20-21

Wherefore has he reminded us of that reclining? Not without cause or in a chance way, but to show us what boldness Peter had after the denial. For he who then did not dare to question Jesus, but entrusted the task to another, was now entrusted with the chief authority over the brethren. And not only does he not entrust to another what relates to himself, but he himself now puts a question to his Master concerning another. John is silent, but Peter speaks. He also shows here the love which he had toward him; for Peter greatly loved John, as is clear from what followed, and their close union is shown throughout the whole Gospel and in the Acts. When Christ had foretold great things to him and committed the world to him and spoke beforehand of his martyrdom and testified that his love was greater than that of the others, Peter desired to have John also share with him, and said, And what shall this man do? Shall he not come the same way with us? And just as at that other time, not being able to ask himself, he put John forward, so now desiring to make him a return, and supposing that John would want to ask about the matters pertaining to himself but did not have courage, he himself undertook the questioning. What then does Christ say?

2. Wherefore has he reminded us of that reclining? Not without cause or in a chance way, but to show us what boldness Peter had after the denial. For he who then did not dare to question Jesus, but committed the office to another, was even entrusted with the chief authority over the brethren, and not only does not commit to another what relates to himself, but himself now puts a question to his Master concerning another. John is silent, but Peter speaks. He shows also here the love which he bare towards him; for Peter greatly loved John, as is clear from what followed, and their close union is shown through the whole Gospel, and in the Acts. When therefore Christ had foretold great things to him, and committed the world to him, and spoke beforehand of his martyrdom, and testified that his love was greater than that of the others, desiring to have John also to share with him, he said, And what shall this man do? Shall he not come the same way with us? And as at that other time not being able himself to ask, he puts John forward, so now desiring to make him a return, and supposing that he would desire to ask about the matters pertaining to himself, but had not courage, he himself undertook the questioning. What then says Christ?

John 21:22

Since Peter spoke from strong affection and wished not to be torn away from Christ, Christ showed that however much Peter might love, he could not surpass His love, saying, "If I will that he tarry—what is that to you?" By these words He teaches us not to be impatient or curious beyond what seems good to Him. For because Peter was always eager and rushing forward to make such inquiries, Christ said this to restrain his eagerness and to teach him not to inquire further.

Since he spoke from strong affection, and wishing not to be torn away from him, Christ, to show that however much he might love, he could not go beyond His love, says, If I will that he tarry — what is that to you? By these words teaching us not to be impatient, nor curious beyond what seems good to Him. For because Peter was ever hot, and springing forward to enquiries such as this, to cut short his warmth, and to teach him not to enquire farther, He says this.

John 21:23

Don't imagine for a moment, He says, that I manage your affairs according to a single pattern. And He did this to draw them away from their untimely concern for one another; for since they were about to receive responsibility for the world, they could no longer remain closely bound together—this would certainly have been a great loss to the world. Therefore He says to him: You have been entrusted with a work, focus on it, complete it, labor and struggle. What if I want him to remain here? Pay attention to and take care of your own responsibilities. And notice, I ask you, the Evangelist's lack of pride here as well; for after mentioning the disciples' opinion, he corrects it, as though they had not understood what Jesus meant. Jesus did not say, he tells us, that "he shall not die," but rather, "If I will that he tarry."

Do not thou on any account suppose, He says, that I order your matters after a single rule. And this He did to withdraw them from their unseasonable sympathy for each other; for since they were about to receive the charge of the world, it was necessary that they should no longer be closely associated together; for assuredly this would have been a great loss to the world. Wherefore He says unto him, You have had a work entrusted to you, look to it, accomplish it, labor and struggle. What if I will that he tarry here? Look thou to and care for your own matters. And observe, I pray you, here also the absence of pride in the Evangelist; for having mentioned the opinion of the disciples, he corrects it, as though they had not comprehended what Jesus meant. Jesus said not, he tells us, that 'he shall not die, but, If I will that he tarry.'

John 21:24

Why is it that when none of the others do this, he alone uses these words, and for the second time at that, bearing witness to himself? For this seems offensive to the hearers. What then is the reason? He is said to have been the last to come to writing, with Christ having moved and stirred him to the work. For this reason he continually puts forward his love, hinting at the cause that compelled him to write. Therefore he continually mentions it, to make his account trustworthy and to show that he came to this work moved by that cause. And he says, I know that the things he says are true. And if many do not believe, they are permitted to believe from this. From what? From what is said next.

Why is it, that then, when none of the others do so, he alone uses these words, and that for the second time, witnessing to himself? For it seems to be offensive to the hearers. What then is the cause? He is said to have been the last who came to writing, Christ having moved and roused him to the work; and on this account he continually sets forth his love, alluding to the cause by which he was impelled to write. Therefore also he continually makes mention of it, to make his record trustworthy, and to show, that, moved from thence, he came to this work. And I know, he says, that the things are true which he says. And if the many believe not, it is permitted them to believe from this. From what? From that which is said next.

John 21:25

It is clear from this that I could not have been writing to gain favor. I recorded how the miracles were so numerous, yet I have not even mentioned as many as the other Gospel writers have. Instead, I omitted most of them and focused on bringing forward the plots of the Jews, the stonings, the hatred, the insults, the verbal abuse, and I showed how they called Him a demoniac and a deceiver. I certainly could not have been acting to gain favor. Anyone trying to court favor would do the opposite—reject what is shameful and set forth what is glorious. Since he wrote what he did from complete certainty, he does not hesitate to offer his own testimony, challenging people individually to investigate and examine the facts closely. For it is our custom, when we think we are speaking the absolute truth, never to refuse our testimony; and if we do this, how much more would he who wrote by the Spirit do so. What the other Apostles declared when they preached, he also says: We are witnesses of the things spoken, and the Spirit which He has given to them that obey Him. Besides, he was present at all times and did not abandon Him even when He was being crucified, and had His mother entrusted to him. All these things are signs of his love for Him and of his exact knowledge of all things. And if he has said that so many miracles took place, do not be amazed, but considering the ineffable power of the One who performed them, receive what is spoken with faith. For it was as easy for Him to do whatever He willed as it is for us to speak—or rather much easier, for it was enough that He should will it only, and everything followed.

Whence it is clear that I could not have written to court favor; for I who, when the miracles were so many, have not even related so many as the others have, but omitting most of them, have brought forward the plots of the Jews, the stonings, the hatred, the insults, the revilings, and have shown how they called Him a demoniac and a deceiver, certainly could not have acted to gain favor. For it behooved one who courted favor to do the contrary, to reject the reproachful, to set forth the glorious. Since then he wrote what he did from full assurance, he does not decline to produce his own testimony, challenging men separately to enquire into and scrutinize the circumstances. For it is a custom with us, when we think that we are speaking exactly true, never to refuse our testimony; and if we do this, much more would he who wrote by the Spirit. What then the other Apostles when they preached declared, he also says; We are witnesses of the things spoken, and the Spirit which He has given to them that obey Him. Acts 5:32 And besides, he was present at all, and did not desert Him even when being crucified, and had His mother entrusted to him; all which things are signs of his love for Him, and of his knowing all things exactly. And if he has said that so many miracles had taken place, marvel thou not, but, considering the ineffable power of the Doer, receive with faith what is spoken. For it was as easy for Him to do whatever He would, as it is for us to speak, or rather much easier; for it sufficed that He should will only, and all followed.

Let us pay careful attention to these words, and let us not stop unfolding and searching through them, for it is through constant study that we gain some benefit. In this way we will be able to cleanse our life and cut away the thorns, for sin and worldly anxiety are like thorns—fruitless and painful. Just as a thorn pricks whoever holds it no matter which way it is grasped, so the things of this life cause pain to anyone who embraces and cherishes them, no matter how they are handled. Spiritual things are not like this. They resemble a pearl that delights the eyes no matter which way you turn it. For example, a man has performed an act of mercy. He is not only sustained by hopes for the future, but is also encouraged by present blessings, being everywhere full of confidence and doing everything with great boldness. Someone has conquered an evil desire. Even before obtaining the Kingdom, he has already received the reward here, being praised and approved, before everyone else, by his own conscience. Every good work is of this nature, just as conscience also punishes wicked deeds here, even before hell. For if, after sinning, you think about the future, you become afraid and tremble, though no one punishes you. If you think about the present, you have many enemies and live in suspicion, and you cannot look in the face even those who have not wronged you. For we do not gain as much pleasure from evil deeds as we do misery when conscience cries out against us, people outside condemn us, God is angered, hell labors to receive us, and our thoughts are not at rest. Sin is a heavy, heavy, and burdensome thing, harder to bear than any lead. Anyone who has any sense of it will not be able to look up even a little, no matter how insensitive he may be. For instance, Ahab, though very wicked, when he felt this, walked bent over, crushed and afflicted. For this reason he clothed himself in sackcloth and shed streams of tears. If we do this and grieve as he did, we shall put away our sins as Zacchaeus did, and we too shall obtain some pardon. For just as with tumors and festering ulcers, if one does not first stop the discharge that flows over and inflames the wound, however many remedies he applies, while the source of the evil is not stopped, he labors in vain—so too if we do not stop our hand from covetousness and check that evil influx of wealth, even if we give alms, we accomplish nothing. For whatever alms healed, covetousness coming afterward overwhelms and destroys, making it harder to heal than before. Let us therefore stop stealing and then give alms. But if we throw ourselves over cliffs, how shall we be able to recover ourselves? For if one party (that is, almsgiving) were pulling at a falling man from above, while another was forcibly dragging him from below, the only result of such a struggle would be that the man would be torn apart. So that we may not suffer this, nor have almsgiving depart and leave us while covetousness weighs us down from below, let us lighten ourselves and spread our wings, so that having been perfected by the removal of evil things and the practice of good, we may obtain the eternal goods, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father and the Holy Spirit be glory, dominion, and honor, now and ever and world without end. Amen.

3. Let us then give exact heed to the words, and let us not cease to unfold and search them through, for it is from continual application that we get some advantage. So shall we be able to cleanse our life, so to cut up the thorns; for such a thing is sin and worldly care, fruitless and painful. And as the thorn whatever way it is held pricks the holder, so the things of this life, on whatever side they be laid hold of, give pain to him who hugs and cherishes them. Not such are spiritual things; they resemble a pearl, whichever way thou turn it, it delights the eyes. As thus. A man has done a deed of mercy; he not only is fed with hopes of the future, but also is cheered by the good things here, being everywhere full of confidence, and doing all with much boldness. He has got the better of an evil desire; even before obtaining the Kingdom, he has already received the fruit here, being praised and approved, before all others, by his own conscience. And every good work is of this nature; just as conscience also punishes wicked deeds here, even before the pit. For if, after sinning, you consider the future, you become afraid and tremble, though no man punish you; if the present, you have many enemies, and livest in suspicion, and cannot henceforth even look in the face those who have wronged you, or rather, those who have not wronged you. deservest punishment. }}–> For we do not in the case of those evil deeds reap so much pleasure, as we do despondency, when conscience cries out against us, men, without, condemn us, God is angered, the pit travailing to receive us, our thoughts not at rest. A heavy, a heavy and a burdensome thing is sin, harder to bear than any lead. He at least who has any sense of it will not be able to look up ever so little, though he be very dull. Thus, for instance, Ahab, though very impious, when he felt this, walked bending downwards, crushed and afflicted. On this account he clothed himself in sackcloth, and shed fountains of tears. 1 Kings 21:27 If we do this, and grieve as he did, we shall put off our faults as did Zacchæus, and we too shall obtain some pardon. Luke 19:9 For as in the case of tumors, and fistulous ulcers, if one stay not first the discharge which runs over and inflames the wound, how many soever remedies he applies, while the source of the evil is not stopped, he does all in vain; so too if we stay not our hand from covetousness, and check not that evil afflux of wealth, although we give alms, we do all to no purpose. For that which was healed by it, covetousness coming after is wont to overwhelm and spoil, and to make harder to heal than before. Let us then cease from rapine, and so do alms. But if we betake ourselves to precipices, how shall we be able to recover ourselves? for if one party (that is, alms-doing) were to pull at a falling man from above, while another was forcibly dragging him from below, the only result of such a struggle would be, that the man would be torn asunder. That we may not suffer this, nor, while covetousness weighs us down from below, alms-doing depart and leave us, let us lighten ourselves, and spread our wings, that having been perfected by the riddance of evil things, and the practice of good, we may obtain the goods everlasting, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father and the Holy Ghost be glory, dominion, and honor, now and ever and world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 87 — John 20:24-25

Homily 87 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240187.htm>.

Contents · 10 chapters
  1. John 20:24-25
  2. John 20:26
  3. John 20:29
  4. John 20:30
  5. John 20:31
  6. John 21:1
  7. John 21:2
  8. John 21:5
  9. John 21:12
  10. John 21:14

John 20:24-25

As believing carelessly and randomly comes from being too easily persuaded, so being excessively curious and intrusive shows a very dull understanding. For this reason Thomas is held at fault. He did not believe the Apostles when they said, "We have seen the Lord"—not so much because he mistrusted them, but because he thought the thing was impossible, that is, the resurrection from the dead. He does not say "I do not believe you," but rather "Unless I put my hand—I do not believe." But how was it that when all were gathered together, he alone was absent? Probably after the recent scattering that had taken place, he had not yet returned. But when you see the unbelief of the disciple, consider the loving kindness of the Lord—how for the sake of a single soul He showed Himself with His wounds and comes to save even one person, though he was duller than the rest. For this reason Thomas demanded proof through the dullest of the senses and would not even trust his eyes. He did not say "Unless I see," but "Unless I handle," lest what he saw might somehow be an apparition. Yet the disciples who told him these things were at that time worthy of belief, and so was He who promised. Still, since Thomas desired more, Christ did not deprive him even of this.

1. As to believe carelessly and in a random way, comes of an over-easy temper; so to be beyond measure curious and meddlesome, marks a most gross understanding. On this account Thomas is held to blame. For he believed not the Apostles when they said, We have seen the Lord; not so much mistrusting them, as deeming the thing to be impossible, that is to say, the resurrection from the dead. Since he says not, I do not believe you, but, Except I put my hand — I do not believe. But how was it, that when all were collected together, he alone was absent? Probably after the dispersion which had lately taken place, he had not returned even then. But do thou, when you see the unbelief of the disciple, consider the lovingkindness of the Lord, how for the sake of a single soul He showed Himself with His wounds, and comes in order to save even the one, though he was grosser than the rest; on which account indeed he sought proof from the grossest of the senses, and would not even trust his eyes. For he said not, Except I see, but, Except I handle, he says, lest what he saw might somehow be an apparition. Yet the disciples who told him these things, were at the time worthy of credit, and so was He that promised; yet, since he desired more, Christ did not deprive him even of this.

And why does He not appear to him immediately, but only after eight days? John 20:26 So that, being continually instructed by the disciples in the meantime and hearing the same thing, he might be stirred up to more eager desire and become more ready to believe in the future. But how did he know that His side had been opened? From having heard it from the disciples. How then did he believe partly but not believe partly? Because this thing was very strange and wonderful. But observe, I ask you, the truthfulness of the disciples, how they hide no faults, either their own or those of others, but record them with great honesty.

And why does He not appear to him straightway, instead of after eight days? John 20:26 In order that being in the mean time continually instructed by the disciples, and hearing the same thing, he might be inflamed to more eager desire, and be more ready to believe for the future. But whence knew he that His side had been opened? From having heard it from the disciples. How then did he believe partly, and partly not believe? Because this thing was very strange and wonderful. But observe, I pray you, the truthfulness of the disciples, how they hide no faults, either their own or others', but record them with great veracity.

Jesus appears to them again and doesn't wait for Thomas to ask him or say anything. Before Thomas could speak, Jesus took the initiative and fulfilled his desire. This showed that even when Thomas spoke those words to the disciples, Jesus was actually present. Jesus used the same words Thomas had used, and in a way that conveyed both a sharp rebuke and instruction for the future. For after saying,

Jesus again presents himself to them, and waits not to be requested by Thomas, nor to hear any such thing, but before he had spoken, Himself prevented him, and fulfilled his desire; showing that even when he spoke those words to the disciples, He was present. For He used the same words, and in a manner conveying a sharp rebuke, and instruction for the future. For having said,

John 20:26

And do not be faithless, but believing.

And be not faithless, but believing.

Do you see that his doubt came from unbelief? But this was before he had received the Spirit. After that, it was no longer the case; from then on, they were made perfect.

Do you see that his doubt proceeded from unbelief? But it was before he had received the Spirit; after that, it was no longer so, but, for the future, they were perfected.

And Jesus rebuked him not only in this way, but also by what follows; for when Thomas, being fully satisfied, breathed again and cried aloud,

And not in this way only did Jesus rebuke him, but also by what follows; for when he, being fully satisfied, breathed again, and cried aloud,

John 20:29

For this is the nature of faith: to receive things that are not seen, since "Faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen" (Hebrews 11:1). And here He declares blessed not only the disciples but also those who would believe after them. Yet someone might say, "The disciples saw and believed." Yes, but they did not seek any such thing. Rather, from the evidence of the burial cloths, they immediately accepted the word concerning the Resurrection, and before they saw the body, they demonstrated complete faith. Therefore, when anyone today says, "I wish I had lived in those times and had seen Christ working miracles," let them consider that "Blessed are they who have not seen, and yet have believed."

For this is of faith, to receive things not seen; since, Faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen. Hebrews 11:1 And here He pronounces blessed not the disciples only, but those also who after them should believe. Yet, says some one, the disciples saw and believed. Yes, but they sought nothing of the kind, but from the proof of the napkins, they straightway received the word concerning the Resurrection, and before they saw the body, exhibited all faith. When therefore any one in the present day say, I would that I had lived in those times, and had seen Christ working miracles, let them reflect, that, Blessed are they who have not seen, and yet have believed.

It is worth asking how an incorruptible body could show the marks of the nails and could be touched by a mortal hand. But do not be troubled by this—what happened was a matter of condescension. For that which was so refined and light that it could enter when the doors were shut was free from all physical density. But this marvel was shown so that the Resurrection might be believed and so that people might know that it was the Crucified One Himself who had risen, and that someone else had not risen in His place. For this reason He rose bearing the signs of the Cross, and for this reason He ate. Indeed, the Apostles everywhere used this as proof of the Resurrection, saying, "We, who ate and drank with Him." So just as when we see Him walking on the waves before the Crucifixion, we do not say that His body is of a different nature but rather of our own, so too after the Resurrection, when we see Him with the marks of the nails, we should not therefore say that He is corruptible. For He displayed these appearances for the sake of the disciple.

It is worth enquiring, how an incorruptible body showed the prints of the nails, and was tangible by a mortal hand. But be not thou disturbed; what took place was a matter of condescension. For that which was so subtle and light as to enter in when the doors were shut, was free from all density; but this marvel was shown, that the Resurrection might be believed, and that men might know that it was the Crucified One Himself, and that another rose not in His stead. On this account He arose bearing the signs of the Cross, and on this account He eats. At least the Apostles everywhere made this a sign of the Resurrection, saying, We, who ate and drank with Him. Acts 10:41 As therefore when we see Him walking on the waves before the Crucifixion, we do not say, that that body is of a different nature, but of our own; so after the Resurrection, when we see Him with the prints of the nails, we will no more say, that he is therefore corruptible. For He exhibited these appearances on account of the disciple.

John 20:30

Since this Evangelist has mentioned fewer miracles than the others, he tells us that the others have not mentioned all of them either, but only as many as were sufficient to draw the hearers to belief. For, it says, "If they should be written every one, I suppose that even the world itself could not contain the books." (John 21:25) From this it is clear that what they have mentioned, they wrote not for display, but only for the sake of what was useful. For how could they who omitted the greater part write these others for display? But why did they not go through them all? Chiefly because of their number; besides, they also considered that he who did not believe those they had mentioned would not give heed to a greater number, while he who received these would have no need of another in order to believe. And here too he seems to me to be speaking for the time of the miracles after the Resurrection. Therefore He says,

2. Since this Evangelist has mentioned fewer than the others, he tells us that neither have all the others mentioned them all, but as many as were sufficient to draw the hearers to belief. For, If, it says, they should be written every one, I suppose that even the world itself could not contain the books. John 21:25 Whence it is clear, that What they have mentioned they wrote not for display, but only for the sake of what was useful. For how could they who omitted the greater part, write these others for display? But why went they not through them all? Chiefly on account of their number; besides, they also considered, that he who believed not those they had mentioned, would not give heed to a greater number; while he who received these, would have no need of another in order to believe. And here too he seems to me to be for the time speaking of the miracles after the Resurrection. Wherefore He says,

In the presence of His disciples.

In the presence of His disciples.

Just as many signs needed to be done before the Resurrection so that people might believe He was the Son of God, so also many were needed after the Resurrection so that they might accept that He had risen. There is another reason he added "in the presence of His disciples"—because after the Resurrection He spoke with them alone. This is why He said, "The world sees Me no more" (John 14:19). Then, so that you may understand that what was done was done only for the sake of the disciples, he added,

For as before the Resurrection it was necessary that many should be done, in order that they might believe that He was the Son of God, so was it also after the Resurrection, in order that they might admit that He had arisen. For another reason also he has added, In the presence of His disciples, because He conversed with them alone after the Resurrection; wherefore also He said, The world sees Me no more. John 14:19 Then, in order that you may understand that what was done was done only for the sake of the disciples, he added,

John 20:31

Speaking generally to all humanity and showing that He bestows a very great favor not on the One who is believed in, but on ourselves. In His Name, that is, through Him, for He is the Life.

Speaking generally to mankind, and showing that not on Him who is believed on, but on ourselves, he bestows a very great favor. In His Name, that is, through Him; for He is the Life.

John 21:1

Do you see that He no longer stays with them continually, nor as He did before? He appeared, for example, in the evening and then departed. Then after eight days He appeared once more and departed again. Then after these things He appeared by the sea, and again with great fear among them. But what does "showed" mean? From this it is clear that He was not seen unless He chose to reveal Himself, because His body was now incorruptible and of unmixed purity. But why has the writer mentioned the specific place? To show that He had now removed most of their fear, so that they now ventured out from their dwelling and went everywhere. For they were no longer shut up at home, but had gone into Galilee, avoiding the danger from the Jews. Simon, therefore, goes fishing. For since He was not with them continually, nor had the Spirit yet been given, nor had they at that time yet been entrusted with anything, having nothing to do, they returned to their trade.

Do you see that He remains not with them continually, nor as before? He appeared, for instance, in the evening, and flew away; then after eight days again once, and again flew away; then after these things by the sea, and again with great terror. But what is the, showed? From this it is clear that He was not seen unless He condescended, because His body was henceforth incorruptible, and of unmixed purity. But wherefore has the writer mentioned the place? To show that he had now taken away the greater part of their fear, so that they now ventured forth from their dwelling, and went about everywhere. For they were no longer shut up at home, but had gone into Galilee, avoiding the danger from the Jews. Simon, therefore, comes to fish. For since neither was He with them continually, nor was the Spirit yet given, nor they at that time yet entrusted with anything, having nothing to do, they went after their trade.

John 21:2

Since they had nothing to do, they went fishing, and they did this at night because they were very afraid. Luke also mentions this, but that is not the same occasion—it is a different one. The other disciples followed because they were now bound to one another, and at the same time they wanted to see the fishing and to use their free time well. As they were laboring and tired, Jesus appeared before them but did not immediately reveal Himself, so that they would enter into conversation with Him. He therefore says to them,

Having then nothing to do, they went to their fishing, and this same they did by night, because they were greatly afraid. This Luke also mentions; but this is not the same occasion, but a different one. And the other disciples followed, because they were henceforth bound to one another, and at the same time desired to see the fishing, and to bestow their leisure well. As they then were laboring and wearied, Jesus presents Himself before them, and does not at once reveal Himself, so that they enter into converse with Him. He therefore says to them,

John 21:5

For a time He speaks in a rather human way, as if He were about to buy something from them. But when they indicated that they had nothing, He told them to cast their nets to the right; and when they cast them they caught a large number of fish. But when they recognized Him, the disciples Peter and John again displayed the distinctive traits of their individual characters. The one was more passionate, the other more elevated; the one more eager, the other more perceptive. For this reason John first recognized Jesus, Peter first came to Him. For the signs that had occurred were not ordinary. What were they? First, that so many fish were caught; then, that the net did not break; then, that before they came ashore, the coals had already been there, and fish laid upon them, and bread. For He no longer made things out of matter that already existed, as, through a certain dispensation, He did before the Crucifixion. When Peter recognized Him, he threw down everything, both fish and nets, and put on his outer garment. Do you see his reverence and love? Yet they were only two hundred cubits away; but even so Peter could not wait to go to Him in the boat, but reached the shore by swimming. What then does Jesus do?

For a time He speaks rather after a human manner, as if about to buy somewhat of them. But when they made signs that they had none, He bade them cast their nets to the right; and on casting they obtained a haul. But when they recognized Him, the disciples Peter and John again exhibited the peculiarities of their several tempers. The one was more fervent, the other more lofty; the one more keen, the other more clear-sighted. On this account John first recognized Jesus, Peter first came to Him. For no ordinary signs were they which had taken place. What were they? First, that so many fish were caught; then, that the net did not break; then, that before they landed, the coals had been found, and fish laid thereon, and bread. For He no longer made things out of matter already subsisting, as, through a certain dispensation, He did before the Crucifixion. When therefore Peter knew Him, he threw down all, both fish and nets, and girded himself. Do you see his respect and love? Yet they were only two hundred cubits off; but not even so could Peter wait to go to Him in the boat, but reached the shore by swimming. What then does Jesus?

John 21:12

They no longer had the same boldness or confidence, nor did they approach Him with words anymore, but instead sat down in silence with great fear and reverence, paying close attention to Him.

For they no longer had the same boldness, nor were they so confident, nor did they now approach Him with speech, but with silence and great fear and reverence, sat down giving heed to Him.

For they knew that it was the Lord.

For they knew that it was the Lord.

And so they did not ask Him, "Who are You?" But seeing that His appearance was changed and filled with great awesomeness, they were greatly amazed and wanted to ask something about it. However, fear and their knowledge that He was not someone else but the same Person restrained their inquiry, and they simply ate what He created for them with a greater display of power than before. For here He no longer looks up to heaven or performs those human actions, showing that even those things He had done were done by way of condescension. And to show that He did not remain with them continually or in the same manner as before, it says that,

And therefore they did not ask Him, Who are You? But seeing that His form was altered, and full of much awfulness, they were greatly amazed, and desired to ask somewhat concerning it; but fear, and their knowledge that He was not some other, but the Same, checked the enquiry, and they only ate what He created for them with a greater exertion of power than before. For here He no more looks to heaven, nor performs those human acts, showing that those also which He did were done by way of condescension. And to show that He remained not with them continually, nor in like manner as before, It says that,

John 21:14

He tells them to bring some of the fish to show that what they saw was no mere appearance. Here the text does not say that He ate with them, but Luke says in another place that He did, for He was eating together with them. Acts 1:4 But how this happened, it is not for us to explain, for these things took place in an extraordinary manner, not because His nature now required food, but as an act of condescension to prove the Resurrection.

And He bids them to bring of the fish, to show that what they saw was no appearance. But here indeed it says not that He ate with them, but Luke, in another place, says that He did; for He was eating together with them. Acts 1:4 But the, how, it is not ours to say; for these things came to pass in too strange a manner, not as though His nature now needed food, but from an act of condescension, in proof of the Resurrection.

Perhaps when you heard these things, you felt excited and considered those blessed who were with Him then, and those who will be with Him on the day of the general Resurrection. Let us make every effort to see that wonderful Face. If hearing about it now makes us burn with such desire, and we long to have lived in those days when He walked on earth, to have heard His voice, seen His face, approached Him, touched Him, and served Him, think how great a thing it will be to see Him no longer in a mortal body nor doing human things, but surrounded by a bodyguard of angels, while we ourselves exist in a form of unmixed purity, beholding Him and enjoying the rest of that bliss that goes beyond all words. Therefore, I beg you, let us use every means not to miss such glory. Nothing is difficult if we are willing, nothing burdensome if we pay attention. If we endure, we shall also reign with Him. What does "if we endure" mean? It means if we bear tribulations, if we bear persecutions, if we walk on the narrow way. The narrow way is laborious by its physis, but our will makes it light through the hope of things to come. For our present light affliction works for us a far more exceeding and eternal weight of glory, while we look not at the things which are seen, but at those which are not seen. Let us transfer our eyes to heaven and continually imagine those things and behold them. If we always spend our time with them, we will not be moved to desire the pleasures of this world, nor will we find it hard to bear its sorrows. We will laugh at these and similar things, and nothing will be able to enslave us or lift us up, if only we direct our longing there and look to that love. And why do I say we will not grieve at present troubles? We will from then on not even appear to see them. Such is the power of strong desire. For instance, those who are not currently with us but are absent and loved—we picture them every day. Love's sovereignty is mighty; it alienates the soul from all other things and chains it to the desired object. If we love Christ this way, all things here will seem to be a shadow, an image, a dream. We too will say, "Who shall separate us from the love of Christ? Shall tribulation or distress?" He did not say money, wealth, or beauty (these are very mean and contemptible), but he listed the things that seem to be grievous: famines, persecutions, deaths. He despised even these as being nothing, but we, for the sake of money, separate ourselves from our life and cut ourselves off from the light. Paul prefers neither death nor life, nor things present nor things to come, nor any other creature to his love for Christ, but we, if we see a little bit of gold, are inflamed and trample on His laws. If these things are intolerable when spoken of, they are much more so when done. The terrible thing is this: we shudder to hear, but we do not shudder to do. We swear readily and perjure ourselves, we plunder and charge interest, we care nothing for self-control, we stop being exact in prayer, we transgress most of the commandments, and for the sake of money we disregard our own members. Whoever loves wealth will commit countless wrongs against his neighbor and against himself as well. He will easily become angry with his neighbor, revile him, call him a fool, swear and perjure himself, and does not even preserve the standards of the old law. Whoever loves gold will not love his neighbor, yet we, for the Kingdom's sake, are commanded to love even our enemies. Now if by fulfilling the old commandments we will not be able to enter the Kingdom of heaven unless our righteousness exceeds and goes beyond them, what excuse will we have when we transgress even these? Whoever loves money will not only fail to love his enemies, but will even treat his friends as enemies.

3. Perhaps when you heard these things, you glowed, and called those happy who were then with Him, and those who shall be with Him at the day of the general Resurrection. Let us then use every exertion that we may see that admirable Face. For if when now we hear we so burn, and desire to have been in those days which He spent upon earth, and to have heard His Voice, and seen His face, and to have approached, and touched, and ministered unto Him; consider how great a thing it is to see Him no longer in a mortal body, nor doing human actions, but with a body guard of Angels, being ourselves also in a form of unmixed purity, and beholding Him, and enjoying the rest of that bliss which passes all language. Wherefore, I entreat, let us use every means, so as not to miss such glory. For nothing is difficult if we be willing, nothing burdensome if we give heed. If we endure, we shall also reign with Him. 2 Timothy 2:12 What then is, If we endure? If we bear tribulations, if persecutions, if we walk in the strait way. For the strait way is by its nature laborious, but by our will it is rendered light, from the hope of things to come. For our present light affliction works for us a far more exceeding and eternal weight of glory; while we look not at the things which are seen, but at those which are not seen. 2 Corinthians 4:17-18 Let us then transfer our eyes to heaven, and continually imagine those things, and behold them. For if we always spend our time with them, we shall not be moved to desire the pleasures of this world, nor find it hard to bear its sorrows; but we shall laugh at these and the like, and nothing will be able to enslave or lift us up, if only we direct our longing there, and look to that love. And why say I that we shall not grieve at present troubles? We shall henceforth not even appear to see them. Such a thing is strong desire. Those, for instance, who are not at present with us, but being absent are loved, we image every day. For mighty is the sovereignty of love, it alienates the soul from all things else, and chains to the desired object. If thus we love Christ, all things here will seem to be a shadow, an image, a dream. We too shall say, Who shall separate us from the love of Christ? Shall tribulation, or distress? Romans 8:35 He said not, money, or wealth, or beauty, (these are very mean and contemptible,) but he has put the things which seem to be grievous, famines, persecutions, deaths. He then spat on these even, as being nought; but we for the sake of money separate ourselves from our life, and cut ourselves off from the light. And Paul indeed prefers neither death, nor life, nor things present, nor things to come, nor any other creature, to the love which is towards Him; but we, if we see a little portion of gold, are fired, and trample on His laws. And if these things are intolerable when spoken of, much more are they so when done. For the terrible thing is this, that we shudder to hear, but do not shudder to do: we swear readily, and perjure ourselves, and plunder, and exact usury, care nothing for sobriety, desist from exactness in prayer, transgress most of the commandments, and for the sake of money make no account of our own members. For he that loves wealth will work ten thousand mischiefs to his neighbor, and to himself as well. He will easily be angry with him, and revile him, and call him fool, and swear and perjure himself, and does not even preserve the measures of the old law. For he that loves gold will not love his neighbor; yet we, for the Kingdom's sake, are bidden to love even our enemies. Now if by fulfilling the old commandments, we shall not be able to enter the Kingdom of heaven, unless our righteousness exceed and go beyond them, when we transgress even these, what excuse shall we obtain? He that loves money, not only will not love his enemies, but will even treat his friends as enemies.

But why speak only of friends? Those who love money have often ignored even the bonds of family. Such a person does not recognize kinship, does not remember companionship, does not respect age, has no friend, and will be hostile toward everyone, but above all toward himself. He destroys not only his soul but torments himself with countless cares, labors, and sorrows. For he will endure foreign journeys, hostilities, dangers, conspiracies, and anything at all, just so he may keep in his house the root of all evil and count up much gold. What then can be more terrible than this disease? It brings none of the luxury or pleasure for which people often sin, and it brings no honor or glory. For the lover of money suspects that tens of thousands are against him, and indeed many truly do accuse, envy, slander, and plot against him. Those he has wronged hate him for the injuries they have suffered; those who have not yet suffered, fearing that they might, and sympathizing with those who have, show the same hostility; while the greater and more powerful, provoked and indignant on behalf of the weaker, and at the same time envying him, are also his enemies and haters. And why speak only of men? For when one has made God himself his enemy, what hope will there be for him? What consolation? What comfort? The person who loves riches will never be able to use them; he will be their slave and guardian, not their master. For being always anxious to increase them, he will never be willing to spend them; instead he will deprive himself and live in worse poverty than any poor man, since his desire never stops anywhere. Yet riches were made not to be kept but to be used; but if we are going to bury them for others, what can be more miserable than we who run about trying to gather the possessions of all people, only to shut them away and cut them off from common use? But there is another disease not less than this. Some men bury their money in the earth, others in their bellies, in pleasure and drunkenness, adding to injustice the punishment of self-indulgence. Some minister with their wealth to parasites and flatterers, others to dice and prostitutes, others to different expenses of the same kind, cutting out for themselves countless roads that lead to hell, while leaving the right and sanctioned road which leads to heaven. And yet that road has not only greater gain but greater pleasure than the things we have mentioned. For the man who gives to prostitutes is ridiculous and shameful, and will have many quarrels and brief pleasure; or rather, not even brief, because no matter what he gives to the women who are his mistresses, they will not thank him for it, for "The house of a stranger is a cask with holes." Besides, that sort of person is impudent, and Solomon has compared their love to the grave; and they stop only when they see their lover stripped of everything. Or rather, such a woman does not stop even then, but dresses herself up all the more, and tramples on him when he is down, and provokes much laughter against him, and causes him so much harm that it cannot even be described in words. Not such is the pleasure of those who are saved; for there no one has a rival, but all rejoice and are glad, both those who receive blessings and those who look on. No anger, no despondency, no shame, no disgrace besieges the soul of such a person, but great is the gladness of his conscience and great his hope of things to come; bright his glory and great his distinction; and more than all is the favor and safety which comes from God, with not one precipice or suspicion, but a waveless harbor and calm. Considering therefore all these things, and comparing pleasure with pleasure, let us choose the better, that we may obtain the good things to come, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory and dominion for ever and ever. Amen.

4. But why speak I of friends? The lovers of money have often ignored nature itself. Such a one knows not kindred, remembers not companionship, reverences not age, has no friend, but will be ill-disposed towards all, and above all others to himself, not only by destroying his soul, but by racking himself with ten thousand cares, and toils, and sorrows. For he will endure foreign travels, hatreds, dangers, plots, anything whatever, only that he may have in his house the root of all evil, and may count much gold. What then can be more grievous than this disease? It is void of any luxury or pleasure, for the sake of which men often sin, it is void of honor or glory. For the lover of money suspects that he has tens of thousands, and really has many, who accuse, and envy, and slander, and plot against him. Those whom he has wronged hate him as having been ill-used; those who have not yet suffered, fearing least they may suffer, and sympathizing with those who have, manifest the same hostility; while the greater and more powerful, being stung and indignant on account of the humbler sort, and at the same time also envying him, are his enemies and haters. And why speak I of men? For when one has God also made his enemy, what hope shall there then be for him? What consolation? What comfort? He that loves riches will never be able to use them; he will be their slave and keeper, not their master. For, being ever anxious to make them more, he will never be willing to spend them; but he will cut short himself, and be in poorer state than any poor man, as nowhere stopping in his desire. Yet riches are made not that we should keep, but that we should use them; but if we are going to bury them for others, what can be more miserable than we, who run about desiring to get together the possessions of all men, that we may shut them up within, and cut them off from common use? But there is another malady not less than this. Some men bury their money in the earth, others in their bellies, and in pleasure and drunkenness; together with injustice adding to themselves the punishment of wantonness. Some minister with their substance to parasites and flatterers, others to dice and harlots, others to different expenses of the same kind, cutting out for themselves ten thousand roads that lead to hell, but leaving the right and sanctioned road which leads to heaven. And yet it has not greater gain only, but greater pleasure than the things we have mentioned. For he who gives to harlots is ridiculous and shameful, and will have many quarrels, and brief pleasure; or rather, not even brief, because, give what he will to the women his mistresses, they will not thank him for it; for, The house of a stranger is a cask with holes. Proverbs 23:27, Septuagint Besides, that sort of persons is impudent, and Solomon has compared their love to the grave; and then only do they stop, when they see their lover stripped of all. Or rather, such a woman does not stop even then, but tricks herself out the more, and tramples on him when he is down, and excites much laughter against him, and works him so much mischief, as it is not possible even to describe by words. Not such is the pleasure of the saved; for neither has any there a rival, but all rejoice and are glad, both they that receive blessings, and they that look on. No anger, no despondency, no shame, no disgrace, besiege the soul of such a one, but great is the gladness of his conscience, and great his hope of things to come; bright his glory, and great his distinction; and more than all is the favor and safety which is from God, and not one precipice, nor suspicion, but a waveless harbor, and calm. Considering therefore all these things, and comparing pleasure with pleasure, let us choose the better, that we may obtain the good things to come, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory and dominion for ever and ever. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 86 — John 20:10-11

Homily 86 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240186.htm>.

Contents · 10 chapters
  1. John 20:10-11
  2. John 20:13
  3. John 20:14
  4. John 20:15
  5. John 20:17
  6. John 20:18
  7. John 20:19
  8. John 20:20
  9. John 20:21
  10. John 20:22-23

John 20:10-11

The female sex is somehow full of feeling and more inclined to pity. I say this so you won't wonder how Mary could weep bitterly at the tomb while Peter was not affected that way at all. For it says, The disciples went away to their own home, but she stood there shedding tears. Because her nature was weak, and she did not yet know accurately the account of the Resurrection; whereas they, having seen the linen clothes and believed, departed to their own homes in astonishment. And why didn't they go straight to Galilee, as they had been commanded before the Passion? Perhaps they were waiting for the others, and besides they were still at the height of their amazement. So they went their way, but she stood at the place, for, as I have said, even the sight of the tomb greatly comforted her. You can see her stooping down and wanting to see the place where the body lay, trying to ease her grief even more. And for this great zeal she received no small reward. For what the disciples did not see, this woman saw first: Angels sitting, one at the feet and the other at the head, in white; even their clothing was full of much radiance and joy. Since the woman's mind was not sufficiently elevated to accept the Resurrection from the proof of the burial cloths, something more takes place, she sees something more: Angels sitting in shining garments, so as to raise her for a while from her passionate sorrow and to comfort her. But they said nothing to her about the Resurrection, yet she is gently led forward in this doctrine. She saw bright and unusual faces; she saw shining garments, she heard a sympathizing voice. For what does the Angel say?

1. Full of feeling somehow is the female sex, and more inclined to pity. I say this, lest you should wonder how it could be that Mary wept bitterly at the tomb, while Peter was in no way so affected. For, The disciples, it says, went away unto their own home; but she stood shedding tears. Because hers was a feeble nature, and she as yet knew not accurately the account of the Resurrection; whereas they having seen the linen clothes and believed, departed to their own homes in astonishment. And wherefore went they not straightway to Galilee, as had been commanded them before the Passion? They waited for the others, perhaps, and besides they were yet at the height of their amazement. These then went their way: but she stood at the place, for, as I have said, even the sight of the tomb tended greatly to comfort her. At any rate, you see her, the more to ease her grief, stooping down, and desiring to behold the place where the body lay. And therefore she received no small reward for this her great zeal. For what the disciples saw not, this saw the woman first, Angels sitting, the one at the feet, the other at the head, in white; even the dress was full of much radiance and joy. Since the mind of the woman was not sufficiently elevated to accept the Resurrection from the proof of the napkins, something more takes place, she beholds something more; Angels sitting in shining garments, so as to raise her thus awhile from her passionate sorrow, and to comfort her. But they said nothing to her concerning the Resurrection, yet is she gently led forward in this doctrine. She saw countenances bright and unusual; she saw shining garments, she heard a sympathizing voice. For what says (the Angel)?

John 20:13

By all these circumstances, as if a door was being opened for her, she was led little by little to the knowledge of the Resurrection. And the way they were sitting invited her to question them, since they showed that they knew what had happened; for this reason they did not sit together, but apart from one another. Because she was not likely to dare question them right away, they brought her into conversation both by questioning her and by the way they were sitting. What then does she say? She speaks very warmly and affectionately;

By all these circumstances, as though a door was being opened for her, she was led little by little to the knowledge of the Resurrection. And the manner of their sitting invited her to question them, for they showed that they knew what had taken place; on which account they did not sit together either, but apart from one another. For because it was not likely that she would dare at once to question them, both by questioning her, and by the manner of their sitting, they bring her to converse. What then says she? She speaks very warmly and affectionately;

They have taken away my Lord, and I don't know where they have placed Him.

They have taken away my Lord, and I know not where they have laid Him.

What are you saying? Do you still not know anything about the Resurrection, but instead keep imagining that He has been laid somewhere? Do you see how she had not yet grasped the elevated teaching?

What do you say? Do you not know yet anything concerning the Resurrection, but do you still form fancies about His being laid? Do you see how she had not yet received the sublime doctrine?

John 20:14

And what kind of explanation is it that after she had spoken to them and not yet heard anything from them, she turned around? I think that while she was speaking, Christ suddenly appeared behind her and struck the Angels with awe. When they saw their Ruler, they immediately showed by their posture, their expression, and their movements that they saw the Lord. This caught the woman's attention and caused her to turn around. He appeared to them in this way, but not so to the woman, so as not to frighten her at first sight. Instead, he appeared in a humbler and more ordinary form, as is clear from her assumption that he was the gardener. It was fitting to lead someone with such a lowly mindset to higher matters not all at once, but gently. Therefore, he in turn asks her,

And by what kind of consequence is it, that she having spoken to them, and not having yet heard anything from them, turned back? Methinks that while she was speaking, Christ suddenly appearing behind her, struck the Angels with awe; and that they having beheld their Ruler, showed immediately by their bearing, their look, their movements, that they saw the Lord; and this drew the woman's attention, and caused her to turn herself backwards. To them then He appeared on this wise, but not so to the woman, in order not at the first sight to terrify her, but in a meaner and ordinary form, as is clear from her supposing that He was the gardener. It was meet to lead one of so lowly a mind to high matters, not all at once, but gently. He therefore in turn asks her,

John 20:15

This showed that He knew what she wanted to ask and prompted her to respond. And the woman, understanding this, does not mention the name of Jesus again, but as though the person questioning her already knew the subject of her inquiry, she replies,

This showed that He knew what she wished to ask, and led her to make answer. And the woman, understanding this, does not again mention the name of Jesus, but as though her questioner knew the subject of her enquiry replies,

Sir, if you have carried him away, tell me where you have put him, and I will take him away.

Sir, if you have borne him hence, tell me where you have laid him, and I will take him away.

Again she speaks of laying down, taking away, and carrying, as though she were talking about a corpse. But what she means is this: if you have taken him away because you were afraid of the Jews, tell me, and I will take him. The woman's kindness and loving devotion are great, but she still has no lofty understanding. This is why He now reveals the truth to her not through appearance, but through His voice. For just as He was sometimes recognized by the Jews and at other times went unnoticed though present, so too in speaking, He made Himself known when He chose to—just as when He said to the Jews, "Whom do you seek?" they recognized neither His face nor His voice until He chose to reveal Himself. The same thing happened here. And He spoke only her name, reproaching and rebuking her for having such thoughts about One who was alive. But how was it that,

Again she speaks of laying down, and taking away, and carrying, as though speaking of a corpse. But her meaning is this; If you have borne him hence for fear of the Jews, tell me, and I will take him. Great is the kindness and loving affection of the woman, but as yet there is nothing lofty with her. Wherefore He now sets the matter before her, not by appearance, but by Voice. For as He was at one time known to the Jews, and at another time unperceived though present; so too in speaking, He, when He chose, then made Himself known; as also when He said to the Jews, Whom do you seek? they knew neither the Countenance nor the Voice until He chose. And this was the case here. And He named her name only, reproaching and blaming her that she entertained such fancies concerning One who lived. But how was it that,

John 20:17

Some people claim that she was asking for spiritual grace, because she had heard Him say to the disciples, "If I go to the Father, I will ask Him, and He shall give you another Comforter" (chapter 14, verses 3 and 16). But how could she have heard this when she wasn't present with the disciples? Besides, such an idea is completely foreign to the meaning here. And how could she be asking for this when He had not yet gone to the Father? What then is the meaning? I think that she wanted to continue conversing with Him just as before, and that in her joy she perceived nothing elevated about Him, even though He had become far more excellent in the Flesh. Therefore, to lead her away from this notion, and so that she might speak to Him with much reverence (for He no longer appears as familiar with the disciples as before), He lifts up her thoughts, so that she would pay more reverent attention to Him. To have said, "Do not approach Me as you did before, for things are not in the same state, nor shall I be with you in the same way from now on," would have been harsh and arrogant-sounding; but the saying,

2. Some assert, that she asked for spiritual grace, because she had heard Him when with the disciples say, If I go to the Father, 'I will ask Him, and He shall give you another Comforter.' c. xiv. 3, 16 But how could she who was not present with the disciples have heard this? Besides, such an imagination is far from the meaning here. And how should she ask, when He had not yet gone to the Father? What then is the sense? Methinks that she wished still to converse with Him as before, and that in her joy she perceived nothing great in Him, although He had become far more excellent in the Flesh. To lead her therefore from this idea, and that she might speak to Him with much awe, (for neither with the disciples does He henceforth appear so familiar as before,) He raises her thoughts, that she should give more reverent heed to Him. To have said, Approach Me not as you did before, for matters are not in the same state, nor shall I henceforth be with you in the same way, would have been harsh and high-sounding; but the saying,

I am not yet ascended to the Father, though not painful to hear, was a statement declaring the same thing. For by saying, I am not yet ascended, He shows that He is hastening and pressing toward there, and that it was not appropriate for one about to depart there, and no longer to converse with men, to be regarded with the same feelings as before. And what follows shows that this is the case.

I am not yet ascended to the Father, though not painful to hear, was the saying of One declaring the same thing. For by saying, I am not yet ascended, He shows that He hastes and presses there; and that it was not meet that One about to depart there, and no longer to converse with men, should be looked on with the same feelings as before. And the sequel shows that this is the case.

Go and tell the brethren that I am going to My Father and your Father, to My God and your God.

Go and say unto the brethren, that I go unto My Father, and your Father, unto My God and your God.

Yet He was not about to do this immediately, but after forty days. Why then does He say this? Because He wants to lift up their thoughts and convince them that He is departing into the heavens. But the words "to My Father and your Father, to My God and your God" belong to the Dispensation, since the ascending also belongs to His Flesh. For He speaks these words to someone who did not have elevated understanding. Is the Father His in one way and ours in another? He certainly is. For if He is God of the righteous in a different manner than He is God of other people, how much more so in the case of the Son and us. For since He had said "Say to the brethren," so that they would not imagine any equality from this, He showed the difference. He was about to sit on His Father's throne, but they were to stand beside it. So even though in His hypostasis according to the Flesh He became our Brother, yet in honor He differed greatly from us—it cannot even be expressed how much.

Yet He was not about to do so immediately, but after forty days. How then says He this? With a desire to raise their minds, and to persuade them that He departs into the heavens. But the, To My Father and your Father, to My God, and your God, belongs to the Dispensation, since the ascending also belongs to His Flesh. For He speaks these words to one who had no high thoughts. Is then the Father His in one way, and ours in another? Assuredly then He is. For if He is God of the righteous in a manner different from that in which He is God of other men, much more in the case of the Son and us. For because He had said, Say to the brethren, in order that they might not imagine any equality from this, He showed the difference. He was about to sit on His Father's throne, but they to stand by. So that albeit in His Subsistence according to the Flesh He became our Brother, yet in Honor He greatly differed from us, it cannot even be told how much.

John 20:18

So great a good is perseverance and endurance. But why did they no longer grieve when He was about to depart, nor speak as they had before? At that earlier time they were affected in such a way because they thought He was going to die; but now that He had risen again, what reason did they have to grieve? Moreover, Mary reported His appearance and His words, which were enough to comfort them. Since it was likely that the disciples, on hearing these things, would either not believe the woman or, if they did believe, would grieve that He had not considered them worthy of the vision—even though He promised to meet them in Galilee—He did not let a single day pass, so that they might not become unsettled by dwelling on this. Instead, He brought them to a state of longing through their knowledge that He was risen and through what they heard from the woman. When they were thirsting to see Him and were greatly afraid (which thing itself especially made their yearning greater), He then presented Himself before them when it was evening, and that in a very marvelous way. And why did He appear in the evening? Because it was probable that they would then especially be very fearful. But the marvel was why they did not suppose Him to be an apparition, for He entered when the doors were shut, and suddenly. The chief cause was that the woman beforehand had produced great faith in them; besides, He showed His countenance to them clear and mild. He came not by day, so that all might be gathered together. For great was the amazement, for He did not knock at the door but all at once stood in the midst and showed His side and His hands. At the same time also by His voice He calmed their troubled thought, by saying,

So great a good is perseverance and endurance. But how was it that they did not any more grieve when He was about to depart, nor speak as they had done before? At that time they were affected in such a way, as supposing that He was about to die; but now that He was risen again, what reason had they to grieve? Moreover, Mary reported His appearance and His words, which were enough to comfort them. Since then it was likely that the disciples on hearing these things would either not believe the woman, or, believing, would grieve that He had not deemed them worthy of the vision, though He promised to meet them in Galilee; in order that they might not by dwelling on this be unsettled, He let not a single day pass, but having brought them to a state of longing, by their knowledge that He was risen, and by what they heard from the woman, when they were thirsting to see Him, and were greatly afraid, (which thing itself especially made their yearning greater,) He then, when it was evening, presented Himself before them, and that very marvelously. And why did He appear in the evening? Because it was probable that they would then especially be very fearful. But the marvel was, why they did not suppose Him to be an apparition; for He entered, when the doors were shut, and suddenly. The chief cause was, that the woman beforehand had wrought great faith in them; besides, He showed His countenance to them clear and mild. He came not by day, in order that all might be collected together. For great was the amazement; for neither did He knock at the door but all at once stood in the midst, and showed His side and His hands. At the same time also by His Voice He smoothed their tossing thought, by saying,

John 20:19

That is, be not troubled. At the same time, He reminded them of the words He spoke to them before the crucifixion: "My peace I leave unto you" (John 14:27), and again, "In me you have peace, but in the world you shall have tribulation" (John 16:33).

That is, Be not troubled; at the same time reminding them of the word which He spoke to them before the Crucifixion, My peace I leave unto you John 14:27; and again, In me you have peace, but in the world you shall have tribulation. John 16:33

John 20:20

Do you see how His words led to actions? Before the crucifixion He said, "I will see you again, and your heart shall rejoice, and your joy no man takes from you" (John 16:22). Now He accomplished this in deed. All these things led them to a most exact faith. Since they had an unending war with the Jews, He continually repeated "Peace be unto you," giving them consolation to balance the war. This was the first word He spoke to them after the Resurrection (which is why Paul continually says "Grace be unto you and peace"). To the women He announced joy, because that sex was in sorrow and had received this as the first curse. Therefore He gave announcements suited to each: to men, peace because of their war; to women, joy because of their sorrow. After removing all painful things, He told them of the successes of the Cross—and these were the peace. Since all hindrances have been removed, He says, and I have made My victory glorious, and all has been achieved (then He says afterwards),

Do you see the words issuing in deeds? For what He said before the Crucifixion, that I will see you again, and your heart shall rejoice, and your joy no man takes from you John 16:22, this He now accomplished in deed; but all these things led them to a most exact faith. For since they had a truceless war with the Jews, He continually repeated the, Peace be unto you, giving them, to counterbalance the war, the consolation. And so this was the first word that He spoke to them after the Resurrection, (wherefore also Paul continually says, Grace be unto you and peace,) and to women He gives good tidings of joy, because that sex was in sorrow, and had received this as the first curse. Therefore He gives good tidings suitable respectively, to men, peace, because of their war; joy to women, because of their sorrow. Then having put away all painful things, He tells of the successes of the Cross, and these were the peace. Since then all hindrances have been removed, He says, and I have made My victory glorious, and all has been achieved, (then He says afterwards,)

John 20:21

You have no difficulty because of what has already happened and because of the dignity of Me who sends you. Here He lifts up their souls and shows them their great reason for confidence, since they were about to undertake His work. And no longer is an appeal made to the Father, but with authority He gives them the power. For,

You have no difficulty, owing to what has already come to pass, and to the dignity of Me who send you. Here He lifts up their souls, and shows them their great cause of confidence, if so be that they were about to undertake His work. And no longer is an appeal made to the Father, but with authority He gives to them the power. For,

John 20:22-23

Just as a king who sends out governors gives them power to imprison people and to release them, so too when Christ sends these men out, he gives them the same kind of power. But how does he say, "If I do not go away, he will not come," and yet gives them the Spirit? Some say that he did not actually give them the Spirit, but made them ready to receive it by breathing on them. For if Daniel was afraid when he saw an angel, what would these men not have suffered when they received that indescribable gift, unless he had first prepared them? That is why he did not say, "You have received the Holy Spirit," but "Receive the Holy Spirit." Yet someone would not be wrong to say that they did in fact receive some spiritual power and grace at that moment—not the power to raise the dead or work miracles, but the power to forgive sins. For the gifts of the Spirit are of different kinds, which is why he added, "Whosesoever sins you remit, they are remitted to them," showing what kind of power he was giving. But in the other case, after forty days, they received the power to work miracles. That is why he says, "You shall receive power after the Holy Spirit has come upon you, and you shall be my witnesses both in Jerusalem and in all Judea." And they became witnesses through miracles, for the grace of the Spirit is beyond words and the gift takes many forms. But this happens so that you may learn that the gift and the power of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit is one. For things that seem to belong uniquely to the Father are also seen to belong to the Son and to the Holy Spirit. How then, someone asks, does no one come to the Son except the Father draw him? Well, this very thing is shown to belong to the Son as well. "I," he says, "am the way; no one comes to the Father but by me." And notice that it belongs to the Spirit also, for "No one can call Jesus Christ Lord except by the Holy Spirit." Again, we see that the apostles were given to the church at one time by the Father, at another by the Son, at another by the Holy Spirit, and that the diversities of gifts belong to the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit.

As a king sending forth governors, gives power to cast into prison and to deliver from it, so in sending these forth, Christ invests them with the same power. But how says He, If I go not away, He will not come John 16:7, and yet gives them the Spirit? Some say that He gave not the Spirit, but rendered them fit to receive It, by breathing on them. For if Daniel when he saw an Angel was afraid, what would not they have suffered when they received that unspeakable Gift, unless He had first made them learners? Wherefore He said not, You have received the Holy Ghost, but, Receive the Holy Ghost. Yet one will not be wrong in asserting that they then also received some spiritual power and grace; not so as to raise the dead, or to work miracles, but so as to remit sins. For the gifts of the Spirit are of different kinds; wherefore He added, Whosesoever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them, showing what kind of power He was giving. But in the other case, after forty days, they received the power of working miracles. Wherefore He says, You shall receive power, after that the Holy Ghost has come upon you, and you shall be My witnesses both in Jerusalem, and in all Judæa. Acts 1:8 And witnesses they became by means of miracles, for unspeakable is the grace of the Spirit and multiform the gift. But this comes to pass, that you may learn that the gift and the power of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost, is One. For things which appear to be peculiar to the Father, these are seen also to belong to the Son, and to the Holy Ghost. How then, says some one, does none come to the Son, 'except the Father draw him'? John 6:44 Why, this very thing is shown to belong to the Son also. I, He says, am the Way: no man comes unto the Father but by Me. John 14:6 And observe that it belongs to the Spirit also; for No man can call Jesus Christ Lord, but by the Holy Ghost. 1 Corinthians 12:3 Again, we see that the Apostles were given to the Church at one time by the Father, at another by the Son, at another by the Holy Ghost, and that the diversities of gifts 1 Corinthians 12:4 belong to the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost.

Let us do everything we can to have the Holy Spirit with us, and let us treat with great honor those into whose hands its operation has been entrusted. For the dignity of the priests is great. "Whosesoever sins you remit, they are remitted unto them," it says. This is why Paul says, "Obey them that have the rule over you, and submit yourselves." And hold them in very high honor. For you care only about your own affairs, and if you order them well, you give no account for others. But the priest, even if he rightly orders his own life, if he does not have an anxious care for yours—yes, and that of all those around him—will depart with the wicked into hell. And often, even when not betrayed by his own conduct, he perishes by yours, if he has not rightly performed all his part. Knowing therefore the greatness of the danger, give them a large share of your goodwill. Paul also implied this when he said, "For they watch for your souls," and not simply so, but "as they that shall give account." They ought therefore to receive great attention from you. But if you join with the rest in trampling upon them, then neither shall your affairs be in good condition. For while the steersman continues in good courage, the crew also will be safe. But if he is tired out by their reviling him and showing ill-will against him, he cannot watch equally well or retain his skill, and without intending it, he throws them into countless troubles. And so too the priest, if he enjoys honor from you, will be able to order your affairs well. But if you throw him into despondency, you weaken his hands and render both him and yourselves an easy prey to the waves, even if he is very courageous. Consider what Christ says concerning the Jews: "The Scribes and the Pharisees sit on Moses' seat; all therefore whatsoever they bid you to do, do." Now we do not say the priests sit on Moses' seat, but on that of Christ, for they have successively received His doctrine. Therefore Paul also says, "We are ambassadors for Christ, as though God did beseech you by us." Do you not see that in the case of Gentile rulers, all bow to them, and often even persons superior in family, in life, in intelligence, to those who judge them? Yet still, because of him who has given them authority, they consider none of these things, but respect the decision of their governor, whoever he is that receives rule over them. Is there then such fear when man appoints, but when God appoints do we despise him who is appointed, and abuse him, and besmirch him with countless reproaches, and though forbidden to judge our brethren, do we sharpen our tongue against our priests? And how can this deserve excuse, when we see not the beam in our own eye, but are bitterly over-curious about the mote in another's? Do you not know that by so judging you make your own judgment the harder? And I say this not as approving of those who exercise their priesthood unworthily, but as greatly pitying and weeping for them. Yet I do not on this account allow that it is right that they should be judged by those over whom they are set. And although their life may be much spoken against, you, if you take heed to yourself, will not be harmed at all in respect of the things committed to them by God. For if He caused a voice to be uttered by a donkey, and bestowed spiritual blessings by a diviner, working by the foolish mouth and impure tongue of Balaam, on behalf of the offending Jews, much more for the sake of you the right-minded will He, though the priests be exceedingly vile, work all the things that are His, and will send the Holy Spirit. For neither does the pure draw down that Spirit by his own purity, but it is grace that works all. For "all is for your sake, whether it be Paul, or Apollos, or Cephas." For the things that are placed in the hands of the priest, it is with God alone to give, and however far human wisdom may reach, it will appear inferior to that grace. And I say this not in order that we may order our own life carelessly, but that when some of those set over you are careless livers, you the ruled may not often heap up evil for yourselves. But why speak of priests? Neither Angel nor Archangel can do anything with regard to what is given from God, but the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit dispenses all, while the priest lends his tongue and affords his hand. For neither would it be just that through the wickedness of another, those who come in faith to the symbols of their salvation should be harmed. Knowing all these things, let us fear God and hold His priests in honor, paying them all reverence, so that both for our own good deeds and the attention shown to them, we may receive a great return from God, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father and the Holy Spirit be glory, dominion, and honor, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.

4. Let us then do all we can to have the Holy Spirit with ourselves, and let us treat with much honor those into whose hands its operation has been committed. For great is the dignity of the priests. Whosesoever sins, it says, ye remit, they are remitted unto them; wherefore also Paul says, Obey them that have the rule over you, and submit yourselves. Hebrews 13:17 And hold them very exceedingly in honor; for thou indeed carest about your own affairs, and if you order them well, you give no account for others, but the priest even if he rightly order his own life, if he have not an anxious care for yours, yea and that of all those around him, will depart with the wicked into hell; and often when not betrayed by his own conduct, he perishes by yours, if he have not rightly performed all his part. Knowing therefore the greatness of the danger, give them a large share of your goodwill; which Paul also implied when he said, For they watch for your souls, and not simply so, but, as they that shall give account. Hebrews 13:17 They ought therefore to receive great attention from you; but if you join with the rest in trampling upon them, then neither shall your affairs be in a good condition. For while the steersman continues in good courage, the crew also will be in safety; but if he be tired out by their reviling him and showing ill-will against him, he cannot watch equally well, or retain his skill, and without intending it, throws them into ten thousand mischiefs. And so too the priest, if he enjoy honor from you, will be able well to order your affairs; but if you throw them into despondency, you weaken their hands, and render them, as well as yourselves, an easy prey to the waves, although they be very courageous. Consider what Christ says concerning the Jews. The Scribes and the Pharisees sit on Moses' seat; all therefore whatsoever they bid you to do, do ye. Matthew 23:2-3 Now we have not to say, the priests sit on Moses' seat, but on that of Christ; for they have successively received His doctrine. Wherefore also Paul says, We are ambassadors for Christ, as though God did beseech you by us. 2 Corinthians 5:20 See ye not that in the case of Gentile rulers, all bow to them, and oftentimes even persons superior in family, in life, in intelligence, to those who judge them? Yet still because of him who has given them, they consider none of these things, but respect the decision of their governor, whosoever he be that receives the rule over them. Is there then such fear when man appoints, but when God appoints do we despise him who is appointed, and abuse him, and besmirch him with ten thousand reproaches, and though forbidden to judge our brethren, do we sharpen our tongue against our priests? And how can this deserve excuse, when we see not the beam in our own eye, but are bitterly over-curious about the mote in another's? Do you not know that by so judging you make your own judgment the harder? And this I say not as approving of those who exercise their priesthood unworthily, but as greatly pitying and weeping for them; yet do I not on this account allow that it is right that they should be judged by those over whom they are set. And although their life be very much spoken against, you, if you take heed to yourself, will not be harmed at all in respect of the things committed to them by God. For if He caused a voice to be uttered by an ass, and bestowed spiritual blessings by a diviner, working by the foolish mouth and impure tongue of Balaam, in behalf of the offending Jews, much more for the sake of you the right-minded will He, though the priests be exceedingly vile, work all the things that are His, and will send the Holy Ghost. For neither does the pure draw down that Spirit by his own purity, but it is grace that works all. For all, it says, is for your sake, whether it be Paul, or Apollos, or Cephas. 1 Corinthians 3:22-23 For the things which are placed in the hands of the priest it is with God alone to give; and however far human wisdom may reach, it will appear inferior to that grace. And this I say, not in order that we may order our own life carelessly, but that when some of those set over you are careless livers, you the ruled may not often heap up evil for yourselves. But why speak I of priests? Neither Angel nor Archangel can do anything with regard to what is given from God; but the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost, dispenses all, while the priest lends his tongue and affords his hand. For neither would it be just that through the wickedness of another, those who come in faith to the symbols of their salvation should be harmed. Knowing all these things, let us fear God, and hold His priests in honor, paying them all reverence; that both for our own good deeds, and the attention shown to them, we may receive a great return from God, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father and the Holy Ghost be glory, dominion, and honor, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 85 — John 19:16-18

Homily 85 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240185.htm>.

Contents · 13 chapters
  1. John 19:16-18
  2. John 19:19
  3. John 19:24
  4. John 19:26-7
  5. John 19:28
  6. John 19:28
  7. John 19:30
  8. John 19:31
  9. John 19:35
  10. John 19:36
  11. John 19:38
  12. John 20:1
  13. John 20:2

John 19:16-18

Successes have terrible power to bring down or lead astray those who do not pay attention. Thus the Jews, who at first enjoyed the influence of God, sought the law of royalty from the Gentiles, and in the wilderness after the manna remembered the onions. In the same way here, refusing the Kingdom of Christ, they invited Caesar's kingdom to themselves. Therefore God set a king over them, according to their own choice. When Pilate heard these things, he handed Him over to be crucified. This was completely without reason. For when he should have investigated whether Christ had aimed at sovereign power, he pronounced the sentence through fear alone. Yet to prevent this from happening to him, Christ had said beforehand, My kingdom is not of this world; but Pilate, having given himself completely to present things, would not exercise much wisdom. And yet his wife's dream should have been enough to terrify him; but he was not made better by any of these things, nor did he look to heaven, but handed Him over. And now they laid the cross upon Him as if He were a criminal. For they even hated the wood and could not bear even to touch it. This was also the case in the type; for Isaac carried the wood. But then the matter stopped at the will of his father, for it was the type; while here it proceeded to action, for it was the reality.

1. Successes have terrible power to cast down or draw aside those who take not heed. Thus the Jews, who at first enjoyed the influence of God, sought the law of royalty from the Gentiles, and in the wilderness after the manna remembered the onions. In the same way here, refusing the Kingdom of Christ, they invited to themselves that of Cæsar. Wherefore God set a king over them, according to their own decision. When then Pilate heard these things, he delivered Him to be crucified. Utterly without reason. For when he ought to have enquired whether Christ had aimed at sovereign power, he pronounced the sentence through fear alone. Yet that this might not befall him, Christ said beforehand, My kingdom is not of this world; but he having given himself wholly up to present things, would practice no great amount of wisdom. And yet his wife's dream should have been sufficient to terrify him; but by none of these things was he made better, nor did he look to heaven, but delivered Him up. And now they laid the cross upon Him as a malefactor. For even the wood they abominated, and endured not even to touch it. This was also the case in the type; for Isaac bare the wood. But then the matter stopped at the will of his father, for it was the type; while here it proceeded to action, for it was the reality.

And He came to the place of a skull. Some say that Adam died there and lies there, and that Jesus set up the trophy in this same place where death had reigned. For He went out carrying the Cross as a trophy over the tyranny of death, and as conquerors do, He bore upon His shoulders the symbol of victory. What does it matter if the Jews did these things with a different intention? They crucified Him with thieves as well, in this also unintentionally fulfilling prophecy. For what they did as an insult contributed to the truth, so that you may learn how great is its power, since the Prophet had foretold long ago that He was numbered with the transgressors. The devil therefore wanted to throw a veil over what was done, but was unable. For the three were crucified, but Jesus alone was glorious, so that you may learn that His power accomplished everything. Yet the miracles took place when all three had been nailed to the cross, but no one attributed anything that was done to either of the other two, but to Jesus only. So completely was the devil's plot made worthless, and everything returned upon his own head. For even one of these two was saved. He therefore did not insult the glory of the Cross, but contributed to it considerably. For it was no less a matter than shaking the rocks to change a thief upon the cross and to bring him into Paradise.

And He came to the place of a skull. Some say that Adam died there, and there lies; and that Jesus in this place where death had reigned, there also set up the trophy. For He went forth bearing the Cross as a trophy over the tyranny of death: and as conquerors do, so He bare upon His shoulders the symbol of victory. What matter if the Jews did these things with a different intent. They crucified Him too with thieves, in this also unintentionally fulfilling prophecy; for what they did for insult contributed to the truth, that you may learn how great is its power, since the Prophet had foretold of old, that He was numbered with the transgressors. Isaiah 53:12 The devil therefore wished to cast a veil over what was done, but was unable; for the three were crucified, but Jesus alone was glorious, that you may learn, that His power effected all. Yet the miracles took place when the three had been nailed to the cross; but no one attributed anything of what was done to either of those others, but to Jesus only; so entirely was the plot of the devil rendered vain, and all returned upon his own head. For even of these two, one was saved. He therefore did not insult the glory of the Cross, but contributed to it not a little. For it was not a less matter than shaking the rocks, to change a thief upon the cross, and to bring him unto Paradise.

John 19:19

At the same time, Pilate was both punishing the Jews and defending Christ. Since the Jews had handed Him over as worthless and tried to confirm this judgment by making Him share the punishment of the robbers, Pilate acted to prevent anyone in the future from bringing false charges against Him or accusing Him of being worthless and wicked. To silence both the Jews and anyone else who might want to accuse Him, and to show that they had risen up against their own King, Pilate placed those letters on the cross like a trophy. These letters speak with a clear voice, displaying His victory and proclaiming His Kingdom, though not in its fullness. He made this known not in just one language, but in three. Since there would likely be a mixed crowd among the Jews because of the Feast, Pilate publicly recorded the madness of the Jews in all these languages so that no one would be ignorant of this defense. The Jews remained hostile toward Him even when He was crucified. Yet what harm did this do to them? Nothing. For if He was mortal and weak and about to die completely, why did they fear the inscription declaring that He is the King of the Jews? And what do they ask? They say, "Write that 'he said.'" For as it stands now, it is a statement and a general declaration, but if "he said" were added, the charge would appear to come from His own rashness and arrogance. Still, Pilate was not swayed but held to his original decision. And something important was arranged even through this circumstance—indeed, the whole matter. For since the wood of the cross was buried and no one took care to preserve it (because fear was pressing and the believers were hurrying to other urgent matters), and since it was going to be sought in later times when the three crosses would likely lie together, the Lord's cross needed to be identifiable. It was made known to all, first by its position in the middle, and then by the title, since the crosses of the thieves had no titles.

At the same time requiting the Jews, and making a defense for Christ. For since they had given Him up as worthless, and attempted to confirm this sentence by making Him share the punishment of the robbers, in order that for the future it might be in no man's power to prefer evil charges against him, or to accuse him as a worthless and wicked person, to close moreover their mouths and the mouths of all who might desire to accuse Him, and to show that they had risen up against their own King, Pilate thus placed, as on a trophy, those letters, which utter a clear voice, and show forth His Victory, and proclaim His Kingdom, though not in its completeness. And this he made manifest not in a single tongue, but in three languages; for since it was likely that there would be a mixed multitude among the Jews on account of the Feast, in order that none might be ignorant of the defense, he publicly recorded the madness of the Jews, in all the languages. For they bore malice against Him even when crucified. Yet what did this harm you? Nothing. For if He was a mortal and weak, and was about to become extinct, why did you fear the letters asserting that He is the King of the Jews? And what do they ask? Say that 'he said.' For now it is an assertion, and a general sentence, but if 'he said' be added, the charge is shown to be one arising from his own rashness and arrogance. Still Pilate was not turned aside, but stood to his first decision. And it is no little thing that is dispensed even from this circumstance, but the whole matter. For since the wood of the cross was buried, because no one was careful to take it up, inasmuch as fear was pressing, and the believers were hurrying to other urgent matters; and since it was in after times to be sought for, and it was likely that the three crosses would lie together, in order that the Lord's might not be unknown, it was made manifest to all, first by its lying in the middle, and then by the title. For those of the thieves had no titles.

The soldiers divided the garments, but not the coat. See how the prophecies were fulfilled in every instance through their wicked acts; for this too had been predicted long ago. Yet there were three men crucified, but the prophetic details were fulfilled in Him alone. For why did they not do this in the case of the others, but only in His case? Consider also, I ask you, the exactness of the prophecy. For the Prophet says not only that they divided, but that they did not divide. So they divided the rest, but the coat they did not divide; instead they settled the matter by casting lots. And the phrase "woven from the top" is not included without purpose. Some say it declares a figurative truth: that the Crucified was not simply man, but also had the Divinity from above. Others say the Evangelist is describing the actual form of the coat. For since in Palestine they join together two strips of cloth when they weave their garments, John, to show that the coat was of this kind, says "woven from the top." And it seems to me he says this alluding to the humble quality of the garments, and that in this as in all other things, He followed a simple manner of life.

2. The soldiers parted the garments, but not the coat. See the prophecies in every instance fulfilled by their wickednesses; for this also had been predicted of old; yet there were three crucified, but the matters of the prophecies were fulfilled in Him. For why did they not this in the case of the others, but in His case only? Consider too, I pray you, the exactness of the prophecy. For the Prophet says not only, that they parted, but that they did not part. The rest therefore they divided, the coat they divided not, but committed the matter to a decision by lot. And the, Woven from the top John 19:23 is not put without a purpose; but some say that a figurative assertion is declared by it, that the Crucified was not simply man, but had also the Divinity from above. Others say that the Evangelist describes the very form of the coat. For since in Palestine they put together two strips of cloth and so weave their garments, John, to show that the coat was of this kind, says, Woven from the top; and to me he seems to say this, alluding to the poorness of the garments, and that as in all other things, so in dress also, He followed a simple fashion.

John 19:24

But He on the Cross commits His mother to the disciple, teaching us even to our last breath to show every care for our parents. When she troubled Him at an inappropriate time, He said, "Woman, what have I to do with you?" And, "Who is My mother?" But here He shows much loving affection and commits her to the disciple whom He loved. Again John conceals himself out of modesty; for had he desired to boast, he would have also mentioned the reason why he was loved, since it was probably some great and wonderful one. But why does He speak to John about nothing else, nor comfort him when he is despairing? Because it was no time for comforting with words; besides, it was no small thing for him to be honored with such an honor and to receive the reward of steadfastness. But consider, I ask you, how even on the cross He did everything without being troubled, speaking with the disciple about His mother, fulfilling prophecies, offering good hopes to the thief. Yet before He was crucified He appears sweating, agonized, afraid. What then can this mean? Nothing difficult, nothing unclear. There the weakness of nature had been shown, here the excess of Power was being shown. Besides, by these two things He teaches us that even if we are troubled before terrible things, we should not on that account shrink from terrible things, but when we have entered the struggle to consider all things possible and easy. Let us then not tremble at death. Our soul by nature has the love of life, but it lies with us either to loosen the bonds of nature and make this desire weak, or else to tighten them and make the desire more tyrannical. For just as we have the desire for sexual intercourse, but when we practice true wisdom we make the desire weak, so also it happens in the case of life; and just as God has attached bodily desire to the generation of children to maintain a succession among us, without however forbidding us from traveling the higher road of continence, so also He has implanted in us the love of life, forbidding us from destroying ourselves, but not preventing our despising the present life. And knowing this, we ought to observe proper measure, and neither go to death on our own at any time, even if countless terrible things afflict us, nor when dragged to it for the sake of what is pleasing to God to shrink back from it and fear it, but boldly to prepare for it, preferring the future to the present life.

But He on the Cross, commits His mother to the disciple, teaching us even to our last breath to show every care for our parents. When indeed she unseasonably troubled Him, He said, Woman, what have I to do with you? John 2:4 And, Who is My mother? Matthew 12:48 But here He shows much loving affection, and commits her to the disciple whom He loved. Again John conceals himself, in modesty; for had he desired to boast, he would have also put in the cause for which he was loved, since probably it was some great and wonderful one. But wherefore does He converse on nothing else with John, nor comfort him when desponding? Because it was no time for comforting by words; besides, it was no little thing for him to be honored with such honor, and to receive the reward of steadfastness. But do thou consider, I pray, how even on the cross He did everything without being troubled, speaking with the disciple concerning His mother, fulfilling prophecies, holding forth good hopes to the thief. Yet before He was crucified He appears sweating, agonized, fearing. What then can this mean? Nothing difficult, nothing doubtful. There indeed the weakness of nature had been shown, here was being shown the excess of Power. Besides, by these two things He teaches us, even if before things terrible we be troubled, not on that account to shrink from things terrible, but when we have embarked in the contest to deem all things possible and easy. Let us then not tremble at death. Our soul has by nature the love of life, but it lies with us either to loose the bands of nature, and make this desire weak; or else to tighten them, and make the desire more tyrannous. For as we have the desire of sexual intercourse, but when we practice true wisdom we render the desire weak, so also it falls out in the case of life; and as God has annexed carnal desire to the generation of children, to maintain a succession among us, without however forbidding us from traveling the higher road of continence; so also He has implanted in us the love of life, forbidding us from destroying ourselves, but not hindering our despising the present life. And it behooves us, knowing this, to observe due measure, and neither to go at any time to death of our own accord, even though ten thousand terrible things possess us; nor yet when dragged to it, for the sake of what is pleasing to God, to shrink back from and fear it, but boldly to strip for it, preferring the future to the present life.

But the women stood by the Cross, and the weaker sex then appeared the more courageous. So completely from that point onward were all things transformed.

But the women stood by the Cross, and the weaker sex then appeared the manlier John 19:25; so entirely henceforth were all things transformed.

John 19:26-7

And He, having committed His mother to John, said, "Behold your Son." O the honor! What honor He bestowed on the disciple! When He Himself was about to depart, He entrusted her to the disciple to care for. Since it was natural that, being His mother, she would grieve and need protection, He reasonably gave her to the beloved disciple. To him He says, "Behold your mother." He said this to bind them together in love, and the disciple, understanding this, took her to his own home. But why did He make no mention of any other woman, even though another stood there? To teach us to show extraordinary respect to our mothers. For just as when parents oppose us on spiritual matters we must not even acknowledge them, so when they do not hinder us, we ought to show them all proper respect and prefer them above others, because they gave birth to us, because they raised us, because they endured countless hardships for us. And by these words He silences the shamelessness of Marcion; for if He were not born according to the flesh and did not have a mother, why would He take such care for her alone?

3. And He, having committed His mother to John, said, Behold your Son. John 19:26 O the honor! With what honor did He honor the disciple! When He Himself was now departing, He committed her to the disciple to take care of. For since it was likely that, being His mother, she would grieve, and require protection, He with reason entrusted her to the beloved. To him He says, Behold your mother. John 19:27 This He said, knitting them together in charity; which the disciple understanding, took her to his own home. But why made He no mention of any other woman, although another stood there? To teach us to pay more than ordinary respect to our mothers. For as when parents oppose us on spiritual matters, we must not even own them, so when they do not hinder us, we ought to pay them all becoming respect, and to prefer them before others, because they begot us, because they bred us up, because they bare for us ten thousand terrible things. And by these words He silences the shamelessness of Marcion; for if He were not born according to the flesh, nor had a mother, wherefore takes He such forethought for her alone?

John 19:28

That is, nothing was lacking in the Dispensation. For He was eager to show everywhere that this Death was of a new kind, since the whole thing lay in the power of the Person dying, and death did not come upon the Body before He willed it; and He willed it after He had fulfilled all things. Therefore He also said, I have power to lay down My life, and I have power to take it again. John 10:18 Knowing therefore that all things were fulfilled, He says,

That is, that nothing was wanting to the Dispensation. For He was everywhere desirous to show, that this Death was of a new kind, if indeed the whole lay in the power of the Person dying, and death came not on the Body before He willed it; and He willed it after He had fulfilled all things. Therefore also He said, I have power to lay down My life; and I have power to take it again. John 10:18 Knowing therefore that all things were fulfilled, He says,

John 19:28

Here again a prophecy is being fulfilled. But consider, I ask you, the cursed character of those standing by. Even when we have countless enemies and have suffered unbearable things at their hands, we still relent when we see them perishing. But they did not even then make peace with Him, nor were they softened by what they witnessed. Instead, they became more brutal and increased their mockery. They brought Him vinegar on a sponge, the way people bring it to condemned criminals, and gave it to Him to drink. This is why the hyssop is mentioned.

Here again fulfilling a prophecy. But consider, I pray, the accursed nature of the bystanders. Though we have ten thousand enemies, and have suffered intolerable things at their hands, yet when we see them perishing, we relent; but they did not even so make peace with Him, nor were tamed by what they saw, but rather became more savage, and increased their irony; and having brought to Him vinegar on a sponge, as men bring it to the condemned, thus they gave Him to drink; since it is on this account that the hyssop is added.

John 19:30

Do you see how He does everything calmly and with power? What follows shows this. For when everything had been completed,

Do you see how He does all things calmly, and with power? And what follows shows this. For when all had been completed,

He bowed His head (which had not been nailed) and gave up His spirit.

He bowed His head, (this had not been nailed,) and gave up the ghost.

That is, He died. Yet normally, dying does not happen after bowing the head; but here, on the contrary, it does. For He did not bow His head after He had died, as happens with us, but when He had bent His head, then He died. By all these things the Evangelist has shown that He was Lord of all.

That is, died. Yet to expire does not come after the bowing the head; but here, on the contrary, it does. For He did not, when He had expired, bow His head, as happens with us, but when He had bent His head, then He expired. By all which things the Evangelist has shown, that He was Lord of all.

The Jews, however, who swallowed the camel and strained at the gnat, having committed such a terrible deed, were very strict about observing the day.

But the Jews, on the other hand, who swallowed the camel and strained at the gnat, having wrought so atrocious a deed, are very precise concerning the day.

John 19:31

Do you see how powerful truth is? Through the very things they are zealous about, prophecy is fulfilled, because by means of those things, this clear prediction—unrelated to them—receives its fulfillment. When the soldiers came, they broke the legs of the others but not those of Christ. Yet to please the Jews, they pierced His side with a spear and insulted the dead body. What an abominable and cursed intention! Yet, beloved, do not be dismayed or discouraged, because the things these men did from a wicked will actually served the truth. Since there was a prophecy saying, "They shall look on Him whom they pierced" (verse 37; Zechariah 12:10). And not only this, but the deed they dared to commit then became a proof of the faith for those who would later disbelieve, such as Thomas and those like him. Through this an ineffable mystery was also accomplished. For water and blood came forth. These fountains did not come forth without purpose or by chance, but because through these two together the Church exists. Those who are initiated know this, being regenerated by water and nourished by the Blood and the Flesh. From this the Mysteries take their beginning, so that when you approach that awesome cup, you may approach as one drinking from the very side.

Do you see how strong a thing is truth? By means of the very things which are the objects of their zeal, prophecy is fulfilled, for by occasion of those things, this plain prediction, unconnected with them, receives its accomplishment. For the soldiers when they came, broke the legs of the others, but not those of Christ. Yet these to gratify the Jews pierced His side with a spear, and now insulted the dead body. O abominable and accursed purpose! Yet, beloved, be not thou confounded, be not thou desponding; for the things which these men did from a wicked will, fought on the side of the truth. Since there was a prophecy, saying, (from this circumstance, They shall look on Him whom they pierced. Ver. 37; Zechariah 12:10 And not this only, but the deed then dared was a demonstration of the faith, to those who should afterwards disbelieve; as to Thomas, and those like him. With this too an ineffable mystery was accomplished. For there came forth water and blood. Not without a purpose, or by chance, did those founts come forth, but because by means of these two together the Church consists. And the initiated know it, being by water indeed regenerate, and nourished by the Blood and the Flesh. Hence the Mysteries take their beginning; that when you approach to that awful cup, you may so approach, as drinking from the very side.

John 19:35

That is, I did not hear this from others, but I was there myself and saw it, and this testimony is true, as you would expect. For he is describing an insult that was done, not something great and miraculous that might make you doubt his account. Rather, he is closing the mouths of heretics, loudly announcing in advance the Mysteries that were to come, and seeing the treasure stored up in them, so he is very precise about what happened. And that prophecy was also fulfilled,

That is, I heard it not from others, but was myself present and saw it, and the testimony is true. As may be supposed. For he relates an insult done; he relates not anything great and admirable, that you should suspect his narrative; but securing the mouths of heretics, and loudly proclaiming beforehand the Mysteries that should be, and beholding the treasure laid up in them, he is very exact concerning what took place. And that prophecy also is fulfilled,

John 19:36

Even if this statement referred to the Jewish Passover lamb, the type still came before for the sake of the reality, and in Him the prophecy was more fully accomplished. For this reason the Evangelist brought forward the Prophet. Since he would have seemed unreliable if he kept presenting himself as the only witness, he brings Moses to support him, and says that this did not happen without purpose, but was written long ago. This is the meaning of the words, "A bone of Him shall not be broken." Again he confirms the Prophet's words by his own witness. "I have told you these things," he says, "so that you might learn that the connection between the type and the reality is great." Do you see how much effort he puts into making people believe what seemed to be a matter of reproach and shame? For the soldier's insulting even the dead body was far worse than the crucifixion itself. But still, he says, I have told even these things, and told them very earnestly, "so that you might believe." Let no one then be unbelieving or harm our cause through shame. For the things that appear most shameful are the very venerable records of our blessings.

For even if this was said with reference to the lamb of the Jews, still it was for the sake of the reality that the type preceded, and in Him the prophecy was more fully accomplished. On this account the Evangelist brought forward the Prophet. For since by continually producing himself as witness he would have seemed unworthy of credit, he brings Moses to help him, and says, that neither did this come to pass without a purpose, but was written before of old. And this is the meaning of the words, A bone of Him shall not be broken. Again he confirms the Prophet's words by his own witness. These things, says he, I have told you, that you might learn that great is the connection of the type with the reality. Do you see what pains he takes to make that believed which seemed to be matter of reproach, and bringing shame? For that the soldier should insult even the dead body, was far worse than being crucified. But still, even these things, he says, I have told, and told with much earnestness, 'that you might believe.' John 19:35 Let none then be unbelieving, nor through shame injure our cause. For the things which appear to be most shameful, are the very venerable records of our good things.

John 19:38

Not one of the twelve, but perhaps one of the seventy. For now believing that the anger of the Jews was satisfied by the Cross, they approached without fear and took charge of His funeral. Joseph therefore came and asked the favor from Pilate, which he granted—why should he not? Nicodemus also helps him and provides a costly burial. For they were still inclined to think of Him as a mere man. And they brought those spices whose special quality is to preserve the body for a long time and not allow it to decay quickly, which was the act of men who imagined nothing great concerning Him; but in any case, they showed very loving affection. But how did none of the twelve come, neither John, nor Peter, nor any other of the more distinguished disciples? Nor does the writer hide this point. If anyone says that it was from fear of the Jews, these men also were affected by the same fear; for Joseph too was, it says, a secret disciple for fear of the Jews. And no one can say that Joseph acted this way because he greatly despised them, but though himself afraid, still he came. But John who was present and had seen Him die did nothing of the kind. It seems to me that Joseph was a man of high rank, as is clear from the funeral, and known to Pilate, which is also why he obtained the favor; and then he buried Him, not as a criminal, but magnificently, in the Jewish fashion, as some great and admirable person.

Not one of the twelve, but perhaps one of the seventy. For now deeming that the anger of the Jews was quenched by the Cross, they approached without fear, and took charge of His funeral. Joseph therefore came and asked the favor from Pilate, which he granted; why should he not? Nicodemus also assists him, and furnishes a costly burial. For they were still disposed to think of Him as a mere man. And they brought those spices whose special nature is to preserve the body for a long time, and not to allow it quickly to yield to corruption, which was an act of men imagining nothing great respecting Him; but anyhow, they exhibited very loving affection. But how did no one of the twelve come, neither John, nor Peter, nor any other of the more distinguished disciples? Nor does the writer conceal this point. If any one say that it was from fear of the Jews, these men also were occupied by the same fear; for Joseph too was, it says, A secret ( disciple) for fear of the Jews. And not one can say that Joseph acted thus because he greatly despised them, but though himself afraid, still he came. But John who was present, and had seen Him expire, did nothing of the kind. It seems to me that Joseph was a man of high rank, (as is clear from the funeral,) and known to Pilate, on which account also he obtained the favor; and then he buried Him, not as a criminal, but magnificently, after the Jewish fashion, as some great and admirable one.

And because they were pressed for time (since the death took place at the ninth hour, and it is likely that between going to Pilate and taking down the body, evening would come upon them when it was not lawful to work), they laid Him in the tomb that was nearby. And it is providentially arranged that He should be placed in a new tomb, where no one had been placed before, so that His Resurrection might not be thought to be that of someone else who lay there with Him; and so that the disciples might be able to come easily and witness what took place, because the place was near; and that not only they should be witnesses of His burial, but His enemies also, for the placing of seals on the tomb and the soldiers sitting by to guard it were the actions of people testifying to the burial. For Christ earnestly desired that this should be acknowledged, no less than the Resurrection. Therefore the disciples are also very earnest about this—showing that He died. For the Resurrection would be confirmed by all the time that followed, but the Death, if it had been partly concealed at that time or not made very clear, was likely to undermine the account of the Resurrection. Nor was it only for these reasons that He was laid nearby, but also so that the story about the stealing might be proved false.

4. And because they were straitened by the time, (since the Death took place at the ninth hour, and it is probable, that what with going to Pilate and what with taking down the body, evening would come upon them when it was not lawful to work,) they laid Him in the tomb that was near. And it is providentially ordered, that He should be placed in a new tomb, wherein no one had been placed before, that His Resurrection might not be deemed to be that of some other who lay there with Him; and that the disciples might be able easily to come and be spectators of what came to pass, because the place was near; and that not they alone should be witnesses of His burial, but His enemies also, for the placing seals on the tomb, and the sitting by of the soldiers to watch it, were the actions of men testifying to the burial. For Christ earnestly desired that this should be confessed, no less than the Resurrection. Wherefore also the disciples are very earnest about this, the showing that He died. For the Resurrection all succeeding time would confirm, but the Death, if at that time it had been partially concealed, or not made very manifest, was likely to harm the account of the Resurrection. Nor was it for these reasons only that He was laid near, but also that the story about the stealing might be proved false.

John 20:1

For He arose while both the stone and the seals still lay over Him; but because it was necessary that others should be fully convinced, the tomb was opened after the Resurrection, and in this way what had happened was confirmed. This, then, was what prompted Mary's action. For being completely filled with loving devotion toward her Master, when the Sabbath had ended, she could not bear to remain at rest, but came very early in the morning, wanting to find some comfort from the place itself. But when she saw the place and noticed that the stone had been taken away, she neither went inside nor bent down to look, but ran to the disciples, driven by the intensity of her desire; for this was what she earnestly longed for—she wanted to find out as quickly as possible what had happened to the body. This was the reason for her running, and her words make it clear.

For He arose while both stone and seals lay over Him; but because it was necessary that others should be fully satisfied, the tomb was opened after the Resurrection, and thus what had come to pass was confirmed. This then was what moved Mary. For being entirely full of loving affection towards her Master, when the Sabbath was past, she could not bear to rest, but came very early in the morning, desiring to find some consolation from the place. But when she saw the place, and the stone taken away, she neither entered in nor stooped down, but ran to the disciples, in the greatness of her longing; for this was what she earnestly desired, she wished very speedily to learn what had become of the body. This was the meaning of her running, and her words declare it.

John 20:2

Do you see how she did not yet understand anything clearly about the Resurrection, but thought the body had simply been moved, and reported everything plainly to the disciples? The Evangelist did not deny the woman this honor, nor did he consider it shameful that they should have first learned these things from her who had spent the night watching. In this way, the truth-loving nature of his character shines through everywhere. When she came and told them these things, they heard and rushed eagerly to the tomb, and saw the linen cloths lying there, which was a sign of the Resurrection. For if people had removed the body, they would not have stripped it first before doing so; nor if anyone had stolen it, would they have bothered to remove the head cloth, roll it up, and place it separately by itself. How would they have done it? They would have taken the body as it was. For this reason John tells us beforehand that it was buried with much myrrh, which glues linen to the body as firmly as lead, so that when you hear that the cloths lay separately, you may not tolerate those who say He was stolen. A thief would not have been so foolish as to waste so much effort on something unnecessary. Why would he unwrap the cloths? And how could he have escaped detection if he had? He would likely have spent much time doing so and been discovered through the delay and lingering. But why do the cloths lie apart, while the head cloth was wrapped up by itself? So that you may learn that this was not the action of people in confusion or haste—placing some things in one spot, some in another, and wrapping them together. From this they believed in the Resurrection. For this reason Christ appeared to them afterward, when they were already convinced by what they had seen. Notice here again the absence of boastfulness in the Evangelist, how he testifies to the thoroughness of Peter's search. For he himself, having arrived before Peter and having seen the linen cloths, did not investigate further but withdrew; but that eager one went farther in, examined everything carefully, and saw something more, and then the other was also called to see. For entering after Peter, he saw the grave-clothes lying there, and separate. Now to separate them and place one thing by itself and another, after rolling it up, by itself, was the action of someone doing things carefully, not haphazardly as if disturbed.

Do you see how she knew not as yet anything clearly concerning the Resurrection, but thought there had been a removal of the body, and tells all simply to the disciples? And the Evangelist has not deprived the woman of such a praise, nor thought it shame that they should have learned these things first from her who had passed the night in watching. Thus everywhere does the truth-loving nature of his disposition shine forth. When then she came and said these things, they hearing them, draw near with great eagerness to the sepulcher, and see the linen clothes lying, which was a sign of the Resurrection. For neither, if any persons had removed the body, would they before doing so have stripped it; nor if any had stolen it, would they have taken the trouble to remove the napkin, and roll it up, and lay it in a place by itself; but how? They would have taken the body as it was. On this account John tells us by anticipation that it was buried with much myrrh, which glues linen to the body not less firmly than lead; in order that when you hear that the napkins lay apart, you may not endure those who say that He was stolen. For a thief would not have been so foolish as to spend so much trouble on a superfluous matter. For why should he undo the clothes? And how could he have escaped detection if he had done so? Since he would probably have spent much time in so doing, and be found out by delaying and loitering. But why do the clothes lie apart, while the napkin was wrapped together by itself? That you may learn that it was not the action of men in confusion or haste, the placing some in one place, some in another, and the wrapping them together. From this they believed in the Resurrection. On this account Christ afterwards appeared to them, when they were convinced by what they had seen. Observe too here again the absence of boastfulness in the Evangelist, how he witnesses to the exactness of Peter's search. For he himself having gotten before Peter, and having seen the linen clothes, enquired not farther, but withdrew; but that fervent one passing farther in, looked at everything carefully, and saw somewhat more, and then the other too was summoned to the sight. For he entering after Peter, saw the grave-clothes lying, and separate. Now to separate, and to place one thing by itself, and another, after rolling it up, by itself, was the act of some one doing things carefully, and not in a chance way, as if disturbed.

But when you hear that your Lord rose naked, stop your madness about funerals. What is the point of that excessive and useless expense, which brings great loss to the mourners and no benefit to the departed—or if we must say it brings anything, it rather brings harm? The costliness of burial has often caused tombs to be broken into, and has caused someone who was buried with great care to be thrown out naked and unburied. What terrible vainglory! How great a tyranny it displays even in grief! What great foolishness! Many people, to prevent this from happening, cut up those fine clothes and fill them with many spices so that they will be doubly useless to those who would violate the dead, and then place them in the earth. Aren't these the actions of madmen? Of people out of their minds? To show off their extravagance and then destroy it? Yes, someone says, it is so that these things may remain safely with the dead that we use all these methods. Well then, if robbers don't take them, won't moths take them, and worms? Or if moths and worms don't take them, won't time and the dampness of decay destroy them? But let's suppose that neither tomb-breakers, nor moths, nor worms, nor time, nor anything else destroys what lies in the tomb, and that the body itself remains untouched until the Resurrection, and these things are preserved new and fresh and fine—what advantage is there from this to the departed, when the body is raised naked while these things remain here and profit us nothing for those accounts that must be given? Why then, someone says, was it done in the case of Christ? First of all, don't compare these things with human matters, since the prostitute even poured ointment on His holy feet. But if we must speak about these things, we say they were done when those doing them did not know the word of the Resurrection. Therefore it says, as was the manner of the Jews. For those who honored Christ were not the twelve, but those who did not honor Him greatly. The twelve honored Him not in this way, but by death and slaughter and dangers for His sake. That other was indeed honor, but far inferior to this of which I have spoken. Besides, as I began by saying, we are now speaking about men, but at that time these things were done in relation to the Lord. And so you may learn that Christ paid no attention to these things, He said, You saw Me hungry and you fed Me; thirsty and you gave Me drink; naked and you clothed Me—but nowhere did He say, dead and you buried Me. And I say this not to take away the custom of burial—far from it—but to cut short its extravagance and inappropriate vanity. But, someone says, feeling and grief and sympathy for the departed lead to this practice. The practice does not come from sympathy for the departed, but from vainglory. For if you want to sympathize with the dead, I will show you another way of mourning and will teach you to put on him garments that shall rise again with him and make him glorious. For these garments are not consumed by worms, nor wasted by time, nor stolen by tomb-breakers. What sort are these? The clothing of almsgiving—for this is a robe that shall rise again with him, because the seal of almsgiving is with him. Those who then hear, Hungering you fed Me, shine with these garments. These make people distinguished, these make them glorious, these place them in safety. But those used now are only something for moths to consume and a table for worms. And I say this not forbidding funeral observance, but telling you to do it with moderation, so as to cover the body and not commit it naked to the earth. For if when living He commands us to have no more than enough to cover us, much more when dead, since the dead body does not need garments as much as when it is living and breathing. When alive, because of the cold and for decency's sake, we need the covering of garments, but when dead we need burial clothes for none of these reasons, but only so the body may not lie naked. And better than burial clothes we have the earth, the fairest of coverings and more suited for the nature of bodies like ours. If then, where there are so many needs, we must not search for anything superfluous, much more where there is no such necessity is the display inappropriate.

5. But do thou, when you hear that your Lord arose naked, cease from your madness about funerals; for what is the meaning of that superfluous and unprofitable expense, which brings much loss to the mourners, and no gain to the departed, or (if we must say that it brings anything) rather harm? For the costliness of burial has often caused the breaking open of tombs, and has caused him to be cast out naked and unburied, who had been buried with much care. But alas for vainglory! How great the tyranny which it exhibits even in sorrow! How great the folly! Many, that this may not happen, having cut in pieces those fine clothes, and filled them with many spices, so that they may be doubly useless to those who would insult the dead, then commit them to the earth. Are not these the acts of madmen? Of men beside themselves? To make a show of their ambition, and then to destroy it? Yea, says some one, it is in order that they may lie safely with the dead that we use all these contrivances. Well then, if the robbers do not get them, will not the moths get them, and the worms? Or if the moths and worms get them not, will not time and the moisture of putrefaction destroy them? But let us suppose that neither tomb-breakers, nor moths, nor worms, nor time, nor anything else, destroy what lies in the tomb, but that the body itself remains untouched until the Resurrection, and these things are preserved new and fresh and fine; what advantage is there from this to the departed, when the body is raised naked, while these remain here, and profit us nothing for those accounts which must be given? Wherefore then, says some one, was it done in the case of Christ? First of all, do not compare these with human matters, since the harlot poured even ointment upon His holy feet. But if we must speak on these things, we say, that they were done when the doers knew not the word of the Resurrection; therefore it says, As was the manner of the Jews. For they who honored Christ were not of the twelve, but were those who did not honor Him greatly. The twelve honored Him not in this way, but by death and massacre and dangers for His sake. That other indeed was honor, but far inferior to this of which I have spoken. Besides, as I began by saying, we are now speaking of men, but at that time these things were done with relation to the Lord. And that you may learn that Christ made no account of these things, He said, You saw Me an hungered, and you fed Me; thirsty, and you gave Me drink; naked, and you clothed Me Matthew 25:35; but nowhere did He say, dead, and you buried Me. And this I say not as taking away the custom of burial, (that be far from me,) but as cutting short its extravagance and unseasonable vanity. But, says some one, feeling and grief and sympathy for the departed persuade to this practice. The practice does not proceed from sympathy for the departed, but from vainglory. Since if you desire to sympathize with the dead, I will show you another way of mourning, and will teach you to put on him garments which shall rise again with him, and make him glorious. For these garments are not consumed by worms, nor wasted by time, nor stolen by tomb-breakers. Of what sort then are these? The clothing of alms-doing; for this is a robe that shall rise again with him, because the seal of alms-doing is with him. With these garments shine they who then hear, Hungering ye fed Me. These make men distinguished, these make them glorious, these place them in safety; but those used now are only something for moths to consume, and a table for worms. And this I say, not forbidding to use funeral observance, but bidding you to do it with moderation, so as to cover the body, and not commit it naked to the earth. For if living He bids us have no more than enough to cover us, much more when dead; since the dead body has not so much need of garments as when it is living and breathing. For when alive, on account of the cold, and for decency's sake, we need the covering of garments, but when dead we require grave-clothes for none of these reasons, but that the body may not lie naked; and better than grave-clothes we have the earth, fairest of coverings, and more suited for the nature of such bodies as ours. If then where there are so many needs we must not search for anything superfluous, much more where there is no such necessity, is the ostentation unseasonable.

But someone will say the onlookers will laugh. Certainly, if there is any laughter, we need not care much about someone who is so extremely foolish. But in fact there are many who rather admire and accept our true wisdom. For these are not the things that deserve laughter, but those things we do at present—weeping and wailing and burying ourselves with the departed—these things deserve ridicule and punishment. But to show true wisdom, both in these matters and in the modest clothing we use, prepares crowns and praises for us, and everyone will applaud us and admire the power of Christ and will say: Amazing! How great is the power of the Crucified One! He has persuaded those who are perishing and wasting away that death is not death. Therefore they do not act as perishing people, but as people who send the dead ahead of them to a distant and better dwelling place. He has persuaded them that this corruptible and earthly body will put on a garment more glorious than silk or cloth of gold, the garment of immortality. Therefore they are not very anxious about their burial, but consider a virtuous life to be an admirable burial shroud. They will say these things if they see us showing true wisdom. But if they see us bent down with grief, acting like women, placing crowds of female mourners around us, they will laugh and mock and find fault in countless ways, tearing apart our foolish expense and our vain labor. We hear everyone finding fault with these things, and very reasonably. For what excuse can we have when we adorn a body that is consumed by corruption and worms, yet neglect Christ when he is thirsting, going about naked, and is a stranger? Let us cease from this vain trouble. Let us perform the funeral rites of the departed in a way that is good both for us and them, to the glory of God. Let us do much almsgiving for their sake; let us send with them the best provision for the journey. For if the memory of admirable people, though dead, has protected the living—for it says, I will defend this city for my own sake and for my servant David's sake—how much more will almsgiving accomplish this? For this has even raised the dead, as when the widows stood around showing what things Dorcas had made while she was with them. When someone is about to die, therefore, let the friend of that dying person prepare the funeral rites and persuade the departing one to leave something to the needy. With these garments let him send him to the grave, leaving Christ as his heir. For if those who name kings among their heirs leave a safe portion to their relatives, consider how much good someone will draw down upon himself and all his family when he leaves Christ as heir along with his children. These are the right kind of funerals; these benefit both those who remain and those who depart. If we are buried in this way, we will be glorious at the time of the resurrection. But if, caring for the body, we neglect the soul, we will suffer many terrible things and incur much ridicule. For it is no ordinary disgrace to depart without being clothed with virtue, nor is the body, even if cast out without a tomb, as disgraced as a soul appearing bare of virtue on that day. Let us put this on; let us wrap this around us. It is best to do so during our whole lifetime. But if we have been negligent in this life, let us at least be sober at our end and charge our relatives to help us when we depart by almsgiving, so that being helped by each other in this way, we may attain to much confidence through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father and the Holy Spirit be glory, dominion, and honor, now and ever and world without end. Amen.

6. But the lookers-on will laugh, says some one. Most certainly if there be any laughter, we need not care much for one so exceedingly foolish; but at present there are many who rather admire and accept our true wisdom. For these are not the things which deserve laughter, but those which we do at present, weeping, and wailing, and burying ourselves with the departed; these things deserve ridicule and punishment. But to show true wisdom, both in these respects and in the modesty of the attire used, prepares crowns and praises for us, and all will applaud us, and will admire the power of Christ, and will say, Amazing! How great is the power of the Crucified One! He has persuaded those who are perishing and wasting, that death is not death; they therefore do not act as perishing men, but as men who send the dead before them to a distant and better dwelling-place. He has persuaded them that this corruptible and earthy body shall put on a garment more glorious than silk or cloth of gold, the garment of immortality; therefore they are not very anxious about their burial, but deem a virtuous life to be an admirable winding-sheet. These things they will say, if they see us showing true wisdom; but if they behold us bent down with grief, playing the woman, placing around troops of female mourners, they will laugh, and mock, and find fault in ten thousand ways, pulling to pieces our foolish expense, our vain labor. With these things we hear all finding fault; and very reasonably. For what excuse can we have, when we adorn a body, which is consumed by corruption and worms, and neglect Christ when thirsting, going about naked, and a stranger? Cease we then from this vain trouble. Let us perform the obsequies of the departed, as is good both for us and them, to the glory of God: let us do much alms for their sake, let us send with them the best provision for the way. For if the memory of admirable men, though dead, has protected the living, (for, I will defend, it says, this city for Mine Own sake, and for My servant David's sake 2 Kings 19:34) much more will alms-doing effect this; for this has raised even the dead, as when the widows stood round showing what things Dorcas had made, while she was with them. Acts 9:39 When therefore one is about to die, let the friend of that dying person prepare the obsequies, and persuade the departing one to leave somewhat to the needy. With these garments let him send him to the grave, leaving Christ his heir. For if they who write kings among their heirs, leave a safe portion to their relations, when one leaves Christ heir with his children, consider how great good he will draw down upon himself and all his. These are the right sort of funerals, these profit both those who remain and those who depart. If we be so buried, we shall be glorious at the Resurrection-time. But if caring for the body we neglect the soul, we then shall suffer many terrible things, and incur much ridicule. For neither is it a common unseemliness to depart without being clothed with virtue, nor is the body, though cast out without a tomb, so disgraced, as a soul appearing bare of virtue in that day. This let us put on, this let us wrap around us; it is best to do so during all our lifetime; but if we have in this life been negligent, let us at least in our end be sober, and charge our relations to help us when we depart by alms-doing; that being thus assisted by each other, we may attain to much confidence, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father and the Holy Ghost be glory, dominion, and honor, now and ever and world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 84 — John 18:37

Homily 84 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240184.htm>.

Contents · 10 chapters
  1. John 18:37
  2. John 18:38
  3. John 18:39-40
  4. John 19:4-5
  5. John 19:6
  6. John 19:7
  7. John 19:10
  8. John 19:11
  9. John 19:12
  10. John 19:14-15

John 18:37

Longsuffering is a wonderful thing; it settles the soul as if in a calm harbor, protecting it from turmoil and evil spirits. Christ has taught us this everywhere, but especially now, when He is being judged, dragged around, and led from place to place. When He was brought to Annas, He answered with great gentleness, and to the servant who struck Him, He said something that could have completely crushed his arrogance. From there He went to Caiaphas, then to Pilate, and spent the entire night going through these events. Throughout it all, He displayed His own gentleness. When they said He was a criminal and could not prove it, He remained silent. But when He was questioned about the Kingdom, then He spoke to Pilate, teaching him and leading him toward higher matters. But why did Pilate question Him privately rather than in their presence, going into the judgment hall instead? He suspected something great about Him and wanted to learn everything accurately without being disturbed by the Jews. Then when Pilate said, "What have you done?" Jesus gave no answer on this point. But concerning what Pilate most wanted to hear about—namely, His Kingdom—He answered, saying, "My Kingdom is not of this world." That is, "I am indeed a King, but not the kind you suspect; rather, far more glorious." By these words and those that follow, He shows that He has done nothing wrong. For when someone says, "To this end was I born, and for this cause came I into the world, that I should bear witness unto the truth," he shows that he has done no wrong. Then when He says, "Every one that is of the truth hears My voice," He draws Pilate in by these means and persuades him to become a listener to His words. For if anyone is true and desires these things, He says, that person will certainly hear Me. And in fact, He so captivated him with these brief words that Pilate said,

1. A marvelous thing is longsuffering; it places the soul as in a quiet harbor, fleeing it from tossings and evil spirits. And this everywhere Christ has taught us, but especially now, when He is judged, and dragged, and led about. For when He was brought to Annas, He answered with great gentleness, and, to the servant who smote Him, said what had power to bring down all his insolence; thence having gone to Caiaphas, then to Pilate, and having spent the whole night in these scenes, He all through exhibits His own mildness; and when they said that He was a malefactor, and were not able to prove it, He stood silent; but when He was questioned concerning the Kingdom, then He spoke to Pilate, instructing him, and leading him in to higher matters. But why was it that Pilate made the enquiry not in their presence, but apart, having gone into the judgment hall? He suspected something great respecting Him, and wished, without being troubled by the Jews, to learn all accurately. Then when he said, What have you done? on this point Jesus made no answer; but concerning that of which Pilate most desired to hear, namely, His Kingdom, He answered, saying, My Kingdom is not of this world. That is, I am indeed a King, yet not such an one as you suspect, but far more glorious, declaring by these words and those which follow, that no evil had been done by Him. For one who says, To this end was I born, and for this cause came I into the world, that I should bear witness unto the truth, shows, that no evil has been done by Him. Then when He says, Every one that is of the truth hears My voice, He draws him on by these means, and persuades him to become a listener to the words. For if, says He, any one is true, and desires these things, he will certainly hear Me. And, in fact, He so took him by these short words, that he said,

John 18:38

But for now he focused on what was urgent, because he knew that this question required time, and he wanted to rescue Him from the violence of the Jews. So he went out, and what did he say?

But for the present he applies himself to what was pressing, for he knew that this question needed time, and desired to rescue Him from the violence of the Jews. Wherefore he went out, and what said he?

I find no fault in him.

I find no fault in him.

Consider how wisely he acted. He did not say, "Since he has sinned and deserves death, forgive him because of the Feast." Instead, he first declared Him completely innocent of all charges, and then asked them something additional: even if they were not willing to release Him as innocent, they should at least pardon Him as guilty because of the season. That is why he added,

Consider how prudently he acted. He said not, Since he has sinned, and is deserving of death, forgive him on account of the Feast; but having first acquitted Him of all guilt, he asks them over and above, if they were not minded to dismiss Him as innocent, yet as guilty to forgive Him on account of the time. Wherefore he added,

John 18:39-40

O cursed decision! They demand people who are like themselves in character, and they release the guilty. But they tell Pilate to punish the innocent one. For this was their long-standing custom. But observe throughout all this the loving kindness of the Lord in these circumstances. Pilate had Him scourged (John 19:1), perhaps wanting to wear down and calm the fury of the Jews. When he had not been able to free Him by his earlier attempts, he was eager to stop the evil at this point. So he had Him scourged and allowed what was done—the robe and crown put on Him—so as to lessen their anger. That is why he led Him out to them wearing the crown (John 19:5), so that when they saw the insult done to Him, they might calm down a little from their rage and pour out their venom. And how would the soldiers have done this if it had not been their ruler's command? To please the Jews. Since it was not by his command that they first went in at night, but to please the Jews, they dared anything for money. But He, when so many such things were done, still stood silent, just as He had done during the questioning, and answered nothing. And you should not merely hear these things, but keep them constantly in your mind. When you see the King of the world and of all the angels mocked by the soldiers in both words and actions, and bearing it all silently, imitate Him yourself through your deeds. For when Pilate had called Him the King of the Jews, and they then put on Him the garments of mockery, Pilate led Him out and said,

O accursed decision! They demand those like mannered with themselves, and let the guilty go; but bid him punish the innocent. For this was their longstanding custom. But do thou all through observe the lovingkindness of the Lord in these circumstances. Pilate scourged Him John 19:1 perhaps desiring to exhaust and to soothe the fury of the Jews. For when he had not been able to deliver Him by his former measures, being anxious to stay the evil at this point, he scourged Him, and permitted to be done what was done, the robe and crown to be put on Him, so as to relax their anger. Wherefore also he led Him forth to them crowned John 19:5, that, seeing the insult which had been done to Him, they might recover a little from their passion, and vomit their venom. And how would the soldiers have done this, had it not been the command of their ruler? To gratify the Jews. Since it was not by his command that they at first went in by night, but to please the Jews; they dared anything for money. But He, when so many and such things were done, yet stood silent, as He had done during the enquiry, and answered nothing. And do thou not merely hear these things, but keep them continually in your mind, and when you behold the King of the world and of all Angels, mocked of the soldiers, by words and by actions, and bearing all silently, do thou imitate Him by deeds yourself. For when Pilate had called Him the King of the Jews, and they now put about Him the apparel of mockery, then Pilate having led Him out, said,

John 19:4-5

But even this did not quench their rage; instead, they cried out,

But not even so was their rage quenched, but they cried out,

John 19:6

Then Pilate, seeing that everything was being done in vain, said,

Then Pilate, seeing that all was done in vain, said,

Take him yourselves and crucify him.

Take ye him, and crucify him.

It is clear from this that he had allowed what had happened earlier because of their madness.

Whence it is clear that he had permitted what had been done before, because of their madness.

For I, he says, find no fault in him.

For I, he says, find no fault in him.

See how many times the judge defends Him, continually clearing Him of the charges. But none of this shamed the dogs from their purpose. For the statement "Take Him and crucify Him" comes from one clearing himself of guilt and pushing them toward an action they were not permitted to do. They had brought Him so that the execution would happen by the governor's decision. But the opposite occurred—He was acquitted rather than condemned by the governor's decision. Then, because they were ashamed,

2. See in how many ways the judge makes His defense, continually acquitting Him of the charges; but none of these things shamed the dogs from their purpose. For the, Take ye him and crucify him, is the expression of one clearing himself of the guilt, and thrusting them forward to an action not permitted to them. They therefore had brought Him, in order that the thing might be done by the decision of the governor; but the contrary fell out, that He was rather acquitted than condemned by the governor's decision. Then, because they were ashamed,

John 19:7

How then, when the judge said, "Take ye him, and judge him according to your law," did ye reply, "It is not lawful for us to put any man to death," while here ye fly to the law? And consider the charge, "He made himself the Son of God." Tell me, is this a ground of accusation, that He who performed the deeds of the Son of God should call Himself the Son of God? What then does Christ do? While they held this dialogue with one another, He held His peace, fulfilling that saying of the Prophet, that He opens not his mouth: in His humiliation His judgment was taken away.

How then when the judge said, 'Take ye him, and judge him according to your law,' did ye reply, 'It is not lawful for us to put any man to death,' while here ye fly to the law? And consider the charge, 'He made himself the Son of God.' Tell me, is this a ground of accusation, that He who performed the deeds of the Son of God should call Himself the Son of God? What then does Christ? While they held this dialogue one with the other, He held His peace, fulfilling that saying of the Prophet, that He opens not his mouth: in His humiliation His judgment was taken away. Isaiah 53:7-8, Septuagint

Then Pilate is alarmed when he hears from them that He made Himself the Son of God, and he fears that the claim might actually be true and that he might seem to be transgressing. But these men who had learned this truth from both His deeds and words did not tremble with fear. Instead, they are putting Him to death for the very reasons they should have worshipped Him. Because of this, Pilate no longer asks Him, "What have you done?" but, shaken by fear, he begins the inquiry again, saying, "Are you the Christ?" But He did not answer. For Pilate had heard, "To this end was I born, and for this I came," and "My Kingdom is not of this world." When he should have opposed His enemies and freed Him, he did not do so but instead supported the fury of the Jews. Then, being silenced in every way, they turned their accusation into a political charge, saying, "He who makes himself a king speaks against Caesar." Pilate should therefore have carefully investigated whether He had actually aimed at sovereignty and attempted to expel Caesar from the kingdom. But he does not conduct an exact inquiry, and therefore Christ answered him nothing, because He knew that Pilate was asking all these questions pointlessly. Besides, since His works bore witness to Him, He would not prevail by words or compose any defense, showing that He came voluntarily to this condition. When He was silent, Pilate says,

Then Pilate is alarmed when he hears from them, that He made Himself the Son of God, and dreads lest the assertion may possibly be true, and he should seem to transgress; but these men who had learned this, both by His deeds and words, did not shudder, but are putting Him to death for the very reasons for which they ought to have worshipped Him. On this account he no more asks Him, What have you done? but, shaken by fear, he begins the enquiry again, saying, Are you the Christ? But He answered not. For he who had heard, To this end was I born, and for this came I, and, My Kingdom is not of this world, he, when he ought to have opposed His enemies and delivered Him, did not so, but seconded the fury of the Jews. Then they being in every way silenced, make their cry issue in a political charge, saying, He that makes himself a king, speaks against Cæsar. John 19:12 Pilate ought therefore to have accurately enquired, whether He had aimed at sovereignty, and set His hand to expel Cæsar from the kingdom. But he makes not an exact enquiry, and therefore Christ answered him nothing, because He knew that he asked all the questions idly. Besides, since His works bore witness to Him, He would not prevail by word, nor compose any defense, showing that He came voluntarily to this condition. When He was silent, Pilate says,

John 19:10

Do you see how he condemned himself beforehand? For if the whole matter rests with you, why don't you let Him go when you have found no fault in Him? When Pilate had spoken this sentence against himself, then He says,

Do you see how he condemned himself beforehand; for, if the whole rests with you, why dost not thou let Him go, when you have found no fault in Him? When then Pilate had uttered the sentence against himself, then He says,

John 19:11

Showing that he was also guilty of sin. Then, to deflate his pride and arrogance, He says,

Showing that he also was guilty of sin. Then, to pull down his pride and arrogance, He says,

You would have no power unless it were given to you.

You would have no power except it were given you.

Showing that this did not happen merely in the ordinary course of events, but that it was accomplished mystically. Then, lest you should think when you hear "Except it were given you" that Pilate was completely free from blame, He therefore said, "Therefore he that delivered Me unto you has the greater sin." Yet if it was given, neither Pilate nor they could be held accountable. You make an empty objection, for "given" here means what is "allowed"—as if He had said, "He has permitted these things to happen, but that does not clear you of wickedness." He awed Pilate with these words and offered a clear defense. For this reason Pilate tried to release Him, but they cried out again, saying,

Showing that this did not come to pass merely in the common order of events, but that it was accomplished mystically. Then lest, when you hear, Except it were given you, you should deem that Pilate was exempt from all blame, on this account therefore He said, Therefore he that delivered Me unto you has the greater sin. And yet if it was given, neither he nor they were liable to any charge. Thou objectest idly; for the 'given' in this place means what is 'allowed'; as though He had said, 'He has permitted these things to be, yet not for that are you clear of the wickedness.' He awed Pilate by the words, and proffered a clear defense. On which account that person sought to release Him; but they again cried out, saying,

John 19:12

When they gained nothing by bringing accusations based on their own law, they wickedly turned to external laws, saying,

For when they profited nothing by bringing charges drawn from their own law, they wickedly betook themselves to external laws, saying,

Everyone who makes himself a king speaks against Caesar.

Every one that makes himself a king speaks against Cæsar.

And where has this Man appeared as a tyrant? How can you prove it? By the purple robe? By the crown? By the clothing? By the soldiers? Did He not always walk unattended, except by His twelve disciples, following in every way a humble way of life, in food, clothing, and housing? But what shamelessness and ill-timed cowardice! For Pilate, thinking that he would now face some danger if he ignored these words, comes forward as though to investigate the matter (for sitting down indicated this), but without making any investigation, he handed Him over to them, intending to shame them. For to prove that he did it for this purpose, hear what he says.

And where has this Man appeared as a tyrant? Whence can you prove it? By the purple robe? By the diadem? By the dress? By the soldiers? Did not He ever walk unattended, save by His twelve disciples, following in every point a humble mode of living, both as to food, and clothing, and habitation? But O what shamelessness and ill-time cowardice! For Pilate, deeming that he should now incur some danger were he to overlook these words, comes forth as though to enquire into the matter, (for the sitting down showed this,) but without making any enquiry, he gave Him up to them, thinking to shame them. For to prove that he did it for this purpose, hear what he says.

John 19:14-15

By their own choice they brought punishment upon themselves. This is why God gave them up—because they were the first to cast themselves out from His providence and care. Since they rejected His rule with one voice, He allowed them to fall by their own decisions. Even so, what had been said should have been enough to calm their anger, but they were afraid that if He were released, He would draw the crowds to Himself again, and they did everything possible to prevent this. For love of power is a terrible thing, terrible and able to destroy the soul. It was because of this that they had never listened to Him. And yet Pilate, after only a few words, wanted to release Him, but they pressed on, saying, Crucify him. And why did they try so hard to kill Him in this way? It was a shameful death. They were afraid that there might be some memory of Him afterward, so they wanted to bring Him to this cursed punishment, not realizing that truth is lifted up by obstacles. To prove they had this fear, listen to what they say: We have heard that that deceiver said, After three days I will rise again. For this reason they stirred up all this trouble, turning everything upside down, so they could ruin things for the future. And the unruly people, corrupted by their rulers, kept shouting, Crucify him!

Of their own will they subjected themselves to punishment; therefore also God gave them up, because they were the first to cast themselves out from His providence and superintendence; and since with one voice they rejected His sovereignty, He allowed them to fall by their own suffrages. Still what had been said should have been sufficient to calm their passion, but they feared, lest, being let go, He should again draw the multitudes, and they did all they could to prevent this. For a dreadful thing is love of rule, dreadful and able to destroy the soul; it was on account of this that they had never heard Him. And yet Pilate, in consequence of a few words, desired to let Him go, but they pressed on, saying, Crucify him. And why did they strive to kill Him in this manner? It was a shameful death. Fearing therefore lest there should afterwards be any remembrance of Him, they desired to bring Him to the accursed punishment, not knowing that truth is exalted by hindrances. To prove that they had this suspicion, listen to what they say; We have heard that that deceiver said, After three days I will rise again Matthew 27:63; on this account they made all this stir, turning things upside down, that they might ruin matters in after time. And the ill-ordered people, corrupted by their rulers, cried out continually, Crucify him!

We should not just read about these things, but keep them in our minds: the crown of thorns, the robe, the reed, the blows, the striking on the cheek, the spitting, the mockery. If we continually meditate on these things, they are enough to remove all anger. When we are mocked or suffer injustice, let us still say, "The servant is not greater than his Lord," and let us remember the words the Jews spoke in their madness, saying, "You are a Samaritan and have a demon," and "He casts out demons by Beelzebub." He endured all these things so that we might follow in His footsteps and bear those mockings that disturb us more than any other kind of insult. Yet He not only bore these things, but also used every means to save and deliver from the appointed punishment those who did them. He sent the Apostles for their salvation too—you hear them saying, "We know that through ignorance you did it"—and by these means drew them to repentance. Let us imitate this, for nothing makes God as favorable toward us as loving our enemies and doing good to those who mistreat us. When someone insults you, do not look at him, but at the devil who moves him, and direct all your anger against the devil, but pity the man who is moved by him. If lying comes from the devil, being angry without cause comes from him even more. When you see someone mocking another, understand that it is the devil who moves him, for mockings do not belong to Christians. For he who has been commanded to mourn and has heard "Woe to you who laugh," yet who insults, jokes, and becomes excited, deserves not reproach from us but sorrow, since Christ also was troubled when He thought of Judas. Let us practice all these things in our actions, for if we do not act rightly in these matters, we have come into the world for no purpose and in vain. Or rather, we have come to our own harm, for faith is not sufficient to bring people to the Kingdom; in fact, it even has power in this way to condemn most severely those who live badly. For "he who knew his Lord's will and did not do it shall be beaten with many stripes," and again, "If I had not come and spoken to them, they would not have sin." What excuse then shall we have, who have been placed within the palace, deemed worthy to stoop down and enter the sanctuary, and have been made partakers of the releasing Mysteries, yet who are worse than the pagans who have shared in none of these things? For if they have shown so much true wisdom for the sake of vainglory, we should pursue all virtue much more, because it is pleasing to God. But at present we do not even despise wealth, while they have often been careless of their own lives, have given up their children in wars to their madness about demons, and have despised nature for the sake of their demons, but we do not even despise money for the sake of Christ, nor anger on account of God's will. Instead we are inflamed and in no better condition than those who have a fever. Just as those possessed by that illness are all burning, so we, choked as if by fire, cannot stop at any point of desire, increasing both anger and greed. For this reason I am ashamed and astonished when I see among the pagans people despising riches, but everyone among ourselves mad. For even if we could find some who despise riches, we would find that they have been captured by other vices, by passion or envy. It is a hard thing to discover true wisdom without a flaw. But the reason is that we are not earnest to get our remedies from the Scriptures, nor do we apply ourselves to those Scriptures with compunction, sorrow, and groaning, but carelessly, if at any time we happen to be at leisure. Therefore when a great rush of worldly matters comes, it overwhelms everything, and if there has been any profit, it destroys it. For if a man has a wound and after putting on a bandage does not tie it tight but allows it to fall off and exposes his sore to moisture, dust, heat, and countless other things able to irritate it, he will get no benefit—not because the remedies are ineffective, but because of his own carelessness. This also tends to happen to us when we pay little attention to the divine oracles but give ourselves up wholly and constantly to the things of this life; for in this way all the seed is choked and everything is made unfruitful. So that this may not happen, let us look carefully for a little while, let us look up to heaven, let us look down at the tombs and coffins of the dead. For the same end awaits us, and the same necessity of departure will often come upon us before the evening. Let us prepare for this journey; many supplies are needed for the journey, for the heat there is great, the drought great, and the solitude great. From now on there is no resting at an inn, there is no buying anything when one has not taken everything from here. Listen at least to what the virgins say: "Go to those who sell," but when they went they found no one. Listen to what Abraham says: "A gulf between us and you." Listen to what Ezekiel says concerning that day, that Noah, Job, and Daniel will in no way deliver their sons. But may it never happen that we hear these words; instead, having taken from here sufficient provision for our way to eternal life, may we behold our Lord Jesus Christ with boldness, with whom to the Father and the Holy Spirit be glory, dominion, honor, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.

3. But let us not merely read of these things, but bear them in our mind; the crown of thorns, the robe, the reed, the blows, the smiting on the cheek, the spittings, the irony. These things, if continually meditated on, are sufficient to take down all anger; and if we be mocked at, if we suffer injustice, let us still say, The servant is not greater than his Lord John 13:16; and let us bring forward the words of the Jews, which they uttered in their madness, saying, You are a Samaritan, and hast a devil John 8:48; and, He casts out devils by Beelzebub. Luke 11:15 For on this account He bare all these things, in order that we might walk in His footsteps, and endure those mockings which disturb more than any other kind of reproach. Yet nevertheless He not only bare these things, but even used every means to save and deliver from the appointed punishment those who did them. For He sent the Apostles also for their salvation, at least you hear them saying, that, We know that through ignorance you did it Acts 3:17; and by these means drawing them to repentance. This let us also imitate; for nothing so much makes God propitious as the loving enemies, and doing good to those who despitefully use us. When a man insults you, look not to him, but to the devil who moves him, and against him empty all your wrath, but pity the man who is moved by him. For if lying is from the devil, to be angry without a cause is much more so. When you see one turning another into ridicule, consider that it is the devil who moves him, for mockings belong not to Christians. For he who has been bidden to mourn, and has heard, Woe, you that laugh Luke 6:25, and who after this insults, and jests, and is excited, demands not reproach from us, but sorrow, since Christ also was troubled when He thought on Judas. All these things therefore let us practice in our actions, for if we act not rightly in these, we have come to no purpose and in vain into the world. Or rather we have come to our harm, for faith is not sufficient to bring men to the Kingdom, nay, it even has power in this way most to condemn those who exhibit an ill life; for He which knew his Lord's will, and did it not, shall be beaten with many stripes Luke 12:47; and again, If I had not come and spoken unto them, they had not had sin. John 15:22 What excuse then shall we have, who have been set within the palace, and deemed worthy to stoop down and enter into the sanctuary, and have been made partakers of the releasing Mysteries, and who yet are worse than the Greeks, who have shared in none of these things? For if they for the sake of vainglory have shown so much true wisdom, much more ought we to go after all virtue, because it is pleasing to God. But at present we do not even despise wealth; while they have often been careless of their life, and in wars have given up their children to their madness about devils, and have despised nature for the sake of their devils, but we do not even despise money for the sake of Christ, nor anger on account of God's will, but are inflamed, and in no better state than the fevered. And just as they, when possessed by their malady, are all burning, so we, suffocated as by some fire, can stop at no point of desire, increasing both anger and avarice. On this account I am ashamed and astonished, when I behold among the Greeks men despising riches, but all mad among ourselves. For even if we could find some despising riches, we should find that they have been made captive by other vices, by passion or envy; and a hard thing it is to discover true wisdom without a blemish. But the reason is, that we are not earnest to get our remedies from the Scriptures, nor do we apply ourselves to those Scriptures with compunction, and sorrow, and groaning, but carelessly, if at any time we chance to be at leisure. Therefore when a great rush of worldly matters comes, it overwhelms all; and if there has been any profit, destroys it. For if a man have a wound, and after putting on a plaster, do not tie it tight, but allow it to fall off, and expose his sore to wet, and dust, and heat, and ten thousand other things able to irritate it, he will get no good; yet not by reason of the inefficacy of the remedies, but by reason of his own carelessness. And this also is wont to happen to us, when we attend but little to the divine oracles, but give ourselves up wholly and incessantly to things of this life; for thus all the seed is choked, and all is made unfruitful. That this may not be the case, let us look carefully a little, let us look up to heaven, let us bend down to the tombs and coffins of the departed. For the same end awaits us, and the same necessity of departure will often come upon us before the evening. Prepare we then for this expedition; there is need of many supplies for the journey, for great is the heat there, and great the drought, and great the solitude. Henceforth there is no reposing at an inn, there is no buying anything, when one has not taken all from hence. Hear at least what the virgins say, Go to them that sell Matthew 25:9; but they who went found not. Hear what Abraham says, A gulf between us and you. Luke 16:26 Hear what Ezekiel says concerning that day, that Noah, and Job, and Daniel shall in nowise deliver their sons. Ezekiel 14:14 But may it never come to pass that we hear these words, but that having taken hence sufficient provision for our way to eternal life, we may behold with boldness our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father and the Holy Ghost be glory, dominion, honor, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 83 — John 18:1

Homily 83 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240183.htm>.

Contents · 26 chapters
  1. John 18:1
  2. John 18:2
  3. John 18:3
  4. John 18:4
  5. John 18:5
  6. John 18:8
  7. John 18:9
  8. John 18:11
  9. John 18:12-13
  10. John 18:14
  11. John 18:15
  12. John 18:17
  13. John 18:19
  14. John 18:20
  15. John 18:21
  16. John 18:22
  17. John 18:23
  18. John 18:25
  19. John 18:26
  20. John 18:29
  21. John 18:30
  22. John 18:31-32
  23. John 18:33-34
  24. John 18:35
  25. John 18:36
  26. John 18:37

John 18:1

Death is a terrible thing and full of terror, but not for those who have learned the true wisdom that comes from above. A person who knows nothing certain about what lies ahead, but thinks death is simply the complete dissolution and end of life, understandably shudders and is afraid, as if he were passing into non-existence. But we who, by the grace of God, have learned the hidden and secret things of His wisdom, and believe this event to be a departure to another place, should have no reason to tremble. Instead, we should rejoice and be glad that we are leaving this perishable life and going to one that is far better and brighter, and that has no end. Christ teaches this through His actions by going to His Passion not by constraint and necessity, but willingly. The text says that after Jesus spoke these things, He departed beyond the brook Cedron, where there was a garden, and He entered it with His disciples.

1. An awful thing is death, and very full of terror, but not to those who have learned the true wisdom which is above. For he that knows nothing certain concerning things to come, but deems it to be a certain dissolution and end of life, with reason shudders and is afraid, as though he were passing into non- existence. But we who, by the grace of God, have learned the hidden and secret things of His wisdom, and deem the action to be a departure to another place, should have no reason to tremble, but rather to rejoice and be glad, that leaving this perishable life we go to one far better and brighter, and which has no end. Which Christ teaching by His actions, goes to His Passion, not by constraint and necessity, but willingly. These things, it says, Jesus spoke, and departed 'beyond the brook Cedron, where was a garden, into the which He entered, and His disciples.'

John 18:2

He travels at midnight, crosses a river, and hurries to reach a place known to the traitor, reducing the effort for those who plotted against Him and freeing them from all trouble. He shows the disciples that He came willingly to this action—something that was most capable of comforting them—and places Himself in the garden as if in a prison.

He journeys at midnight, and crosses a river, and hastes to come to a place known to the traitor, lessening the labor to those who plotted against Him, and freeing them from all trouble; and shows to the disciples that He came willingly to the action, (a thing which was most of all sufficient to comfort them,) and places Himself in the garden as in a prison.

These things Jesus spoke to them. What are you saying? Surely He was speaking with the Father, surely He was praying. Why then do you not say that, having ceased from the prayer, He came there? Because it was not prayer, but a speech made for the sake of the disciples. And the disciples entered the garden. He had freed them from fear so completely that they no longer resisted but entered with Him into the garden. But how did Judas come there, or how had he learned where to go when he came? It is clear from this that Jesus usually spent the night outdoors. For if He had been in the habit of spending it at home, Judas would not have come to the desert but to the house, expecting to find Him asleep there. And in case you hear of a garden and think that Jesus hid Himself, it adds that Judas knew the place, and not just that, but that He often went there with His disciples. For many times He was with them in private, conversing about necessary matters and things that others were not permitted to hear. And He did this especially in mountains and gardens, seeking a place free from disturbance so that their attention would not be pulled away from listening.

These things spoke Jesus unto them. What do you say? Surely He was speaking with the Father, surely He was praying. Why then do you not say that, 'having ceased from the prayer,' He came there? Because it was not prayer, but a speech made on account of the disciples. And the disciples entered into the garden. He had so freed them from fear that they no longer resisted, but entered with Him into the garden. But how came Judas there, or whence had he gained his information when he came? It is evident from this circumstance, that Jesus generally passed the night out of doors. For had He been in the habit of spending it at home, Judas would not have come to the desert, but to the house, expecting there to find Him asleep. And lest, hearing of a garden, you should think that Jesus hid Himself, it adds, that Judas knew the place; and not simply so, but that He often resorted there with His disciples. For ofttimes He was with them apart, conversing on necessary matters, and such as it was not permitted to others to hear. And He did this especially in mountains and gardens, seeking a place free from disturbance, that their attention might not be distracted from listening.

John 18:3

These men had often tried to seize Him on other occasions but had been unable to do so. From this it is clear that at this time He surrendered Himself voluntarily. And how did they persuade the band? They were soldiers who had made it their practice to do anything for money.

And these men had often at other times sent to seize Him, but had not been able; whence it is plain, that at this time He voluntarily surrendered Himself. And how did they persuade the band? They were soldiers, who had made it their practice to do anything for money.

John 18:4

That is, He did not wait to learn this from their arrival, but spoke and acted with full composure, since He knew all these things. But why did they come with weapons when they were about to seize Him? They feared His followers, and for this reason they came upon Him late at night. And He went out and said to them, Whom do you seek?

That is, He did not wait to learn this from their coming, but spoke and acted without confusion, as knowing all these things. But why come they with weapons, when about to seize Him? They feared His followers, and for this reason they came upon Him late at night. And He went forth, and said to them, Whom do you seek?

John 18:5

Do you see His invincible power, how He disabled their eyes even though He was standing right among them? The Evangelist has shown that darkness was not the reason they failed to recognize Him, because he mentions they had torches as well. And even if there had been no torches, they should have at least recognized Him by His voice. Or if they didn't recognize it, how could Judas fail to know Him, since he had been with Him so constantly? For Judas too was standing with them, and he recognized Him no better than they did, but fell backward along with them. And Jesus did this to show that not only could they not arrest Him, but they could not even see Him when He was right among them, unless He allowed it.

Do you see His invincible power, how being in the midst of them He disabled their eyes? For that the darkness was not the cause of their not knowing Him, the Evangelist has shown, by saying, that they had torches also. And even had there been no torches, they ought at least to have known Him by His voice; or if they did not know it, how could Judas be ignorant, who had been so continually with Him? For he too stood with them, and knew Him no more than they, but with them fell backward. And Jesus did this to show, that not only they could not seize Him, but could not even see Him when in the midst, unless He gave permission.

John 18:8

See the restraint of the Evangelist, how he does not gloat over the traitor, but relates what happened, only wanting to prove one thing: that everything took place with His own consent. Then, so that no one could say that He Himself caused this by placing Himself into their hands and revealing Himself to them, after He had shown them everything that should have been enough to drive them away, when they persisted in their wickedness and had no excuse, He put Himself in their hands, saying,

See the forbearance of the Evangelist, how he does not insult over the traitor, but relates what took place, only desiring to prove one thing, that the whole took place with His own consent. Then, lest any one should say that He Himself brought them to this, by having placed Himself into their hands, and revealed Himself to them; after having shown to them all things which should have been sufficient to repulse them, when they persevered in their wickedness, and had no excuse, He put Himself in their hands, saying,

If therefore you seek Me, let these go their way.

If therefore ye seek Me, let these go their way.

He showed His loving kindness toward them right up to the final hour. If you want Me, He says, leave these men alone, for I am giving Myself up to you.

Manifesting until the last hour His lovingkindness towards them. If, He says, ye want Me, have nothing to do with these, for, behold, I give Myself up.

John 18:9

By loss He does not mean death here, but eternal loss; though the Evangelist in this case includes death as well. And one might wonder why they did not seize the disciples along with Him and kill them, especially when Peter had provoked them by what he did to the servant. Who then held them back? None other than that Power which threw them backward. And so the Evangelist, to show that this did not happen because of their own intention, but by the power and decision of the One whom they had seized, has added, That the saying might be fulfilled which He spoke, that not one, etc. John 17:12

By loss He does not here mean that which is of death, but that which is eternal; though the Evangelist in the present case includes the former also. And one might wonder why they did not seize them with Him, and cut them to pieces, especially when Peter had exasperated them by what he did to the servant. Who then restrained them? No other than that Power which cast them backward. And so the Evangelist, to show that it did not come to pass through their intention, but by the power and decree of Him whom they had seized, has added, That the saying might be fulfilled which He spoke, that not one, etc. John 17:12

Peter, therefore, taking courage from what Jesus said and from what had already happened, arms himself against the attackers. "But how," someone asks, "does the one who was told not to have a bag or two tunics possess a sword?" I think he had prepared it long before, fearing this very thing that came to pass. And if you say, "How does the one who was forbidden even to strike with his hand become a killer?" He had certainly been commanded not to defend himself, but here he was not defending himself but his Master. Besides, they were not yet perfect or complete. But if you want to see Peter equipped with heavenly wisdom, you will afterward see him wounded and bearing it meekly, suffering countless terrible things without being moved to anger. But Jesus here also performs a miracle, both showing that we ought to do good to those who do evil to us and revealing His own power. He therefore restored the servant's ear and said to Peter that all who take the sword will perish by the sword. And just as He did in the case of the basin, when He calmed Peter's intensity with a warning, so also here. The Evangelist adds the servant's name because what was done was very important—not only because He healed him, but because He healed someone who had come against Him and who shortly after would strike Him, and because He stopped the conflict that would likely have been started against the disciples because of this incident. For this reason the Evangelist has given the name, so that people of that time might search and carefully investigate whether these things had really happened. And he mentions the right ear not without purpose, but I think wanting to show the Apostle's impetuosity—that he almost aimed at the head itself. Yet Jesus not only restrains him with a warning but also calms him with other words, saying,

2. Peter, therefore, taking courage from His voice, and from what had already happened, arms himself against the assailants, And how, says some one, does he who was bidden not to have a scrip, not to have two coats, possess a sword? Methinks he had prepared it long before, as fearing this very thing which came to pass. But if you say, How does he, who was forbidden even to strike a blow with the hand, become a manslayer? He certainly had been commanded not to defend himself, but here he did not defend himself, but his Master. And besides, they were not as yet perfect or complete. But if you desire to see Peter endued with heavenly wisdom, you shall after this behold him wounded, and bearing it meekly, suffering ten thousand dreadful things, and not moved to anger. But Jesus here also works a miracle, both showing that we ought to do good to those who do evil to us, and revealing His own power. He therefore restored the servant's ear, and said to Peter, that All they that take the sword shall perish by the sword Matthew 26:52; and as He did in the case of the basin, when He relaxed his vehemence by a threat, so also here. The Evangelist adds the name of the servant, because the thing done was very great, not only because He healed him, but because He healed one who had come against Him, and who shortly after would buffet Him, and because He stayed the war which was like to have been kindled from this circumstance against the disciples. For this cause the Evangelist has put the name, so that the men of that time might search and enquire diligently whether these things had really come to pass. And not without a cause does he mention the right ear, but as I think desiring to show the impetuosity of the Apostle, that he almost aimed at the head itself. Yet Jesus not only restrains him by a threat, but also calms him by other words, saying,

John 18:11

Showing that what happened did not result from their power but from His consent, and declaring that He was not someone who opposed God but was obedient to the Father even to the point of death.

Showing, that what was done proceeded not from their power, but from His consent, and declaring that He was not one opposed to God but obedient to the Father even unto death.

John 18:12-13

Why did they take Him to Annas? In their delight they were making a display of what had been accomplished, as if they had set up a trophy.

Why to Annas? In their pleasure they made a show of what had been done, as though forsooth they had set up a trophy.

And he was father-in-law to Caiaphas.

And he was father-in-law to Caiaphas.

John 18:14

Why does the Evangelist remind us again of his prophecy? To show that these things happened for our salvation. And such is the overwhelming power of truth that even enemies proclaimed these things in advance. For in case the listener, hearing about bonds, should be confused, he reminds him of that prophecy—that the death of Jesus was the salvation of the world.

Why does the Evangelist again remind us of his prophecy? To show that these things were done for our salvation. And such is the exceeding force of truth, that even enemies proclaimed these things beforehand. For lest the listener, hearing of bonds, should be confounded, he reminds him of that prophecy, that the death of Jesus was the salvation of the world.

John 18:15

Who is that other disciple? It is the writer himself. And why does he not name himself? When he lay on the bosom of Jesus, he reasonably concealed his name; but now why does he do this? For the same reason, because here too he mentions a great good deed—that when everyone else had run away, he followed. Therefore he conceals himself and puts Peter before him. He had to mention himself so that you would understand that he narrates more exactly than the rest what took place in the hall, since he was actually inside. But observe how he diminishes his own praise; for, in case anyone should ask, "How, when all had retreated, did this man enter in farther than Simon?" he says that he was known to the high priest. So that no one should wonder that he followed, or praise him for his courage. But the wonder was Peter's case—that being in such fear, he came even as far as the hall when the others had retreated. His coming there was caused by love, his not entering inside by distress and fear. For the Evangelist has recorded these things to clear a way for excusing his denial; with regard to himself, he does not present it as any great matter that he was known to the high priest, but since he had said that he alone went in with Jesus, in case you should suppose that the action came from any exalted feelings, he also gives the reason. And that Peter would have also entered if he had been permitted, he shows by what follows; for when he went out and asked the woman who kept the door to bring in Peter, he immediately came in. But why did he not bring him in himself? He clung to Christ and followed Him; for this reason he asked the woman to bring him in. What then does the woman say?

Who is that other disciple? It is the writer himself. And wherefore does he not name himself? When he lay on the bosom of Jesus, he with reason concealed his name; but now why does he this? For the same reason, for here too he mentions a great good deed, that when all had started away, he followed. Therefore he conceals himself, and puts Peter before him. He was obliged to mention himself, that you might understand that he narrates more exactly than the rest what took place in the hall, as having been himself within. But observe how he detracts from his own praise; for, lest any one should ask, How, when all had retreated, did this man enter in farther than Simon? he says, that he was known to the high priest. So that no one should wonder that he followed, or cry him up for his manliness. But the wonder was that matter of Peter, that being in such fear, he came even as far as the hall, when the others had retreated. His coming there was caused by love, his not entering within by distress and fear. For the Evangelist has recorded these things, to clear a way for excusing his denial; with regard to himself, he does not set it down as any great matter that he was known to the high priest, but since he had said that he alone with Jesus went in, lest you should suppose that the action proceeded from any exalted feelings, he puts also the cause. And that Peter would have also entered had he been permitted, he shows by the sequel; for when he went out, and bade the damsel who kept the door bring in Peter, he straightway came in. But why did he not bring him in himself? He clung to Christ, and followed Him; on this account he bade the woman bring him in. What then says the woman?

John 18:17

What do you say, Peter? Didn't you just declare, "If I need to lay down my life for You, I will do it"? What has happened then, that you cannot even endure being questioned by a doorkeeper? Is it a soldier who questions you? Is it one of those who arrested Him? No, it is a lowly and insignificant doorkeeper, and the questioning is not even harsh. She does not say, "Are you a disciple of that deceiver and corrupter?" but rather "of that man," which sounds more like someone showing pity and sympathy. But Peter could not bear even these words. The phrase "Are you not also" is used because John was inside. The woman spoke so gently. But Peter noticed none of this and did not take it to heart, not the first time, nor the second, nor the third, but only when the rooster crowed; nor did even this bring him to his senses until Jesus gave him that piercing look. And he stood warming himself with the servants of the high priest, while Christ was kept bound inside. We say this not to accuse Peter, but to show the truth of what Christ had said.

What do you say, Peter? Did you not declare but now, If need be that I lay down my life for You, I will lay it down? What has happened then, that you can not even endure the questioning of a doorkeeper? Is it a soldier who questions you? Is it one of those who seized Him? No, it is a mean and abject doorkeeper, nor is the questioning of a rough kind. She says not, Are you a disciple of that cheat and corrupter, but, of that man, which was the expression rather of one pitying and relenting. But Peter could not bear any of these words. The, Are you not also, is said on this account, that John was within. So mildly did the woman speak. But he perceived none of this, nor took it into his mind, neither the first time, nor the second, nor the third, but when the cock crew; nor did this even bring him to his senses, till Jesus gave him the bitter look. And he stood warming himself with the servants of the high priest, but Christ was kept bound within. This we say not as accusing Peter, but showing the truth of what had been said by Christ.

John 18:19

O the wickedness! Though he had continually heard Him speaking in the temple and teaching openly, he now desires to be informed. Since they had no charge to bring, they inquired about His disciples—perhaps where they were, and why He had gathered them, and with what purpose, and under what conditions. He said this because he wanted to prove Him to be a seditious person and an innovator, since no one paid attention to Him except them alone, as if His group were some kind of workshop for evil. What then does Christ say? To overthrow this, He says,

3. O the wickedness! Though he had continually heard Him speaking in the temple and teaching openly, he now desires to be informed. For since they had no charge to bring, they enquired concerning His disciples, perhaps where they were, and why He had collected them, and with what intention, and on what terms. And this he said, as desiring to prove Him to be a seditious person and an innovator, since no one gave heed to Him, except them alone, as though His were some factory of wickedness. What then says Christ? To overthrow this, He says,

John 18:20

What then, did He say nothing in secret? He did, but not from fear as they thought, or to make conspiracies. Rather, He spoke in secret whenever His sayings were too elevated for the hearing of the many.

What then, said He nothing in secret? He did, but not, as they thought, from fear, and to make conspiracies, but if at any time His sayings were too high for the hearing of the many.

John 18:21

These are not the words of someone speaking arrogantly, but of someone who trusts in the truth of what He had said. So what He said at the beginning, "If I bear witness of Myself, My witness is not true" (John 5:31), He now implies again, wanting to make His testimony abundantly credible. For when Annas mentioned the disciples, what does He say? "Do you ask Me concerning Mine? Ask My enemies, ask those who have plotted against Me, who have bound Me; let them speak." This is unquestionable proof of truth, when someone calls his enemies to be witnesses to what he says. What then does the high priest do? When it would have been right to conduct the inquiry this way, that person did not do so.

These are not the words of one speaking arrogantly, but of one confiding in the truth of what He had said. What therefore He said at the beginning, If I bear witness of Myself, My witness is not true John 5:31, this He now implies, desiring to render His testimony abundantly credible. For when Annas mentioned the disciples, what says He? Do you ask Me concerning Mine? Ask Mine enemies, ask those who have plotted against Me, who have bound Me; let them speak. This is an unquestionable proof of truth, when one calls his enemies to be witnesses to what he says. What then does the high priest? When it would have been right thus to have made the enquiry, that person did not so.

John 18:22

What could be more daring than this? Shudder, O heaven, be amazed, O earth, at the patience of the Lord and the foolishness of the servants! Yet what was it that He said? He did not say, "Why do you ask Me," as if refusing to speak, but wishing to take away every excuse for foolish behavior; and being struck for this, though He was able to shake, destroy, or sweep away all things, He does not do any of these, but speaks words able to soften any brutality.

What could be more audacious than this? Shudder, O heaven, be astounded, O earth, at the long-suffering of the Lord, and the senselessness of the servants! Yet what was it that He said? He said not, Why do you ask Me, as if refusing to speak, but wishing to remove every pretext for senseless behavior; and being upon this buffeted, though He was able to shake, to annihilate, or to remove all things, He does not any one of these, but speaks words able to relax any brutality.

John 18:23

That is, if you can find fault with My words, then point it out; but if you cannot, why do you strike Me? Do you see that the judgment-hall is full of chaos, disorder, emotion, and confusion? The high priest asked questions deceitfully and treacherously, but Christ answered in a straightforward way, and as was appropriate. What then should have happened next? Either to refute what He said or to accept it. But this does not happen. Instead, a servant strikes Him. This was so far from being a proper court of justice—the proceedings were those of a conspiracy and an act of tyranny. Then, without having made any further discovery even after this, they send Him bound to Caiaphas.

That is, If you can lay hold on My words, declare it; but if you can not, why do you strike Me? Do you see that the judgment-hall is full of tumult, and trouble, and passion, and confusion? The high priest asked deceitfully and treacherously, Christ answered in a straightforward manner, and as was meet. What then was next to be done? Either to refute, or to accept what He said. This however is not done, but a servant buffets Him. So far was this from being a court of justice, and the proceedings those of a conspiracy, and a deed of tyranny. Then not having even so made any farther discovery, they send Him bound to Caiaphas.

John 18:25

How remarkable—what a strange dullness possessed that hot-tempered and impulsive man when Jesus was being led away! After all that had happened, he does not stir but still warms himself, so that you may learn how great is the weakness of our nature when God abandons us. And when questioned, he denies again.

Wonderful, by what a lethargy that hot and furious one was possessed, when Jesus was being led away! After such things as had taken place, he does not move, but still warms himself, that you may learn how great is the weakness of our nature if God abandons. And, being questioned, he denies again.

John 18:26

But neither did the garden bring him to remember what had taken place, nor the great affection which Jesus had shown there by those words. Instead, he drove all these things from his mind because of the pressure of anxiety. But why have the Evangelists unanimously written about him? Not to accuse the disciple, but to teach us how great an evil it is not to entrust everything to God, but to rely on oneself. But you should marvel at the tender care of his Master, who, though a prisoner and bound, showed great concern for his disciple, lifting Peter up when he had fallen by looking at him, and plunging him into a sea of tears.

But neither did the garden bring him to remember what had taken place, nor the great affection which Jesus there had shown by those words, but all these from pressure of anxiety he banished from his mind. But why have the Evangelists with one accord written concerning him? Not as accusing the disciple, but as desiring to teach us, how great an evil it is not to commit all to God, but to trust to one's self. But do thou admire the tender care of his Master, who, though a prisoner and bound, took great forethought for His disciple, raising Peter up, when he was down, by His look, and launching him into a sea of tears.

They lead Him therefore from Caiaphas to Pilate.

They lead Him therefore from Caiaphas to Pilate.

This was done so that the number of His judges might show, even against their will, how thoroughly tested His truth was. And it was early. Before the rooster crowed He was brought to Caiaphas, and early in the morning to Pilate. From this the Evangelist shows that after being questioned by Caiaphas for an entire half of the night, He was found guilty of nothing. That is why Caiaphas sent Him on to Pilate. But leaving these things for the other Gospel writers to relate, John speaks of what comes next. And notice the ridiculous behavior of the Jews. Those who had seized an innocent man and taken up arms do not enter the judgment hall, so they will not be polluted. And tell me, what kind of pollution was it to set foot in a judgment hall where wrongdoers receive justice? Those who paid tithes of mint and anise did not think they were polluted when they were intent on killing unjustly, but thought they polluted themselves by simply walking into a court of justice. And why did they not kill Him themselves instead of bringing Him to Pilate? First, most of their rule and authority had been taken away when their affairs were placed under Roman power. Besides, they feared that they might later be accused and punished by Him. But what does it mean when it says "that they might eat the Passover"? For He had done this on the first day of unleavened bread. Either he calls the whole feast the Passover, or means that they were then keeping the Passover, while He gave it to His followers one day earlier, reserving His own Sacrifice for the Preparation-day, when the Passover was also celebrated in ancient times. But though they had taken up arms, which was unlawful, and were shedding blood, they are scrupulous about the place and bring Pilate out to them.

This was done, in order that the number of His judges might show, even against their will, how fully tested was His truth. And it was early. Before cock crow He was brought to Caiaphas, early in the morning to Pilate; whence the Evangelist shows, that being questioned by Caiaphas during an entire half of the night, He was in nothing proved guilty; wherefore Caiaphas sent Him on to Pilate. But leaving these things for the others to relate, John speaks of what follows next. And observe the ridiculous conduct of the Jews. They who had seized the innocent, and taken up arms, do not enter into the hall of judgment, lest they should be polluted. And tell me, what kind of pollution was it to set foot in a judgment-hall, where wrong-doers suffer justice? They who paid tithes of mint and anise, did not think they were polluted when bent on killing unjustly, but thought that they polluted themselves by even treading in a court of justice. And why did they not kill Him, instead of bringing Him to Pilate? In the first place, the greater part of their rule and authority had been cut away, when their affairs were placed under the power of the Romans; and besides, they feared lest they should afterwards be accused and punished by Him. But what is, 'That they might eat the Passover?' For He had done this on the first day of unleavened bread. Either he calls the whole feast the Passover, or means, that they were then keeping the Passover, while He delivered it to His followers one day sooner, reserving His own Sacrifice for the Preparation-day, when also of old the Passover was celebrated. But they, though they had taken up arms, which was unlawful, and were shedding blood, are scrupulous about the place, and bring forth Pilate to them.

John 18:29

Do you see that he was free from love of power and from ill will? For when he saw Jesus bound and led by so many people, he did not think they had clear proof of their accusation, but questioned them, considering it strange that they should take the judgment upon themselves and then hand over the punishment to him without any judgment. What then do they say?

4. Do you see that he was free from fondness for rule and from malice? For seeing Jesus bound, and led by so many persons, he did not think that they had unquestionable proof of their accusation, but questions them, thinking it a strange thing that they should take for themselves the judgment, and then commit the punishment without any judgment to him. What then say they?

John 18:30

O madness! Why do you not mention His evil deeds instead of concealing them? Why do you not prove the evil? Do you see that they everywhere avoid a direct accusation, and that they can say nothing? Annas questioned Him about His doctrine, and having heard Him, sent Him to Caiaphas; and Caiaphas having in his turn questioned Him, and discovered nothing, sent Him to Pilate. Pilate says, What accusation do you bring against this man? Nor here do they have anything to say, but again they employ certain conjectures. At which Pilate, being perplexed, says,

O madness! For why do ye not mention His evil deeds, instead of concealing them? Why do ye not prove the evil? Do you see that they everywhere avoid a direct accusation, and that they can say nothing? That Annas questioned Him about His doctrine, and having heard Him, sent Him to Caiaphas; and he having in his turn questioned Him, and discovered, nothing, sent Him to Pilate. Pilate says, What accusation bring ye against this man? Nor here have they anything to say, but again employ certain conjectures. At which Pilate being perplexed says,

John 18:31-32

And how did the statement, 'It is not lawful for us to put any man to death,' reveal this? Either the Evangelist means that He was going to be killed not only by the Jews but also by the Gentiles, or that it was not lawful for them to crucify. But if they say, It is not lawful for us to put any man to death, they say it with reference to that particular time. For they did kill people, and they killed them in a different way, as Stephen shows by being stoned. But they wanted to crucify Him so they could make a public display of the manner of His death. Pilate, wanting to be free from trouble, does not dismiss Him after a long trial, but,

And how did the expression, 'It is not lawful for us to put any man to death,' declare this? Either the Evangelist means that He was about to be slain not by the Jews only, but by the Gentiles also, or that it was not lawful for them to crucify. But if they say, It is not lawful for us to put any man to death, they say it with reference to that season. For that they did slay men, and that they slew them in a different way, Stephen shows, being stoned. But they desired to crucify Him, that they might make a display of the manner of His death. Pilate, wishing to be freed from trouble, does not dismiss Him for a long trial, but,

John 18:33-34

Why did Christ ask this? Because He wanted to expose the evil intentions of the Jews. Pilate had heard this statement from many people, and since the accusers had nothing to say, he wanted to bring forward what was constantly being reported so the inquiry would not drag on. But when he said to them, "Judge him according to your law," wanting to show that His offense was not a Jewish one, they replied, "It is not lawful for us." He has not sinned against our law, but the charge is a general one. Pilate then, having understood this, says, as someone likely to be put in danger himself, "Are you the King of the Jews?" Then Jesus, not out of ignorance, but wanting the Jews to be accused even by Pilate himself, asked him, saying, "Did others tell you this? Are you saying this on your own or did others tell you about Me?" On this point then declaring himself, Pilate replied,

Wherefore did Christ ask this? Because He desired to expose the evil intentions of the Jews. Pilate had heard this saying from many, and, since the accusers had nothing to say, in order that the enquiry might not be a long one, he desires to bring forward that which was continually reported. But when he said to them, Judge him according to your law, wishing to show that His offense was not a Jewish one, they replied, It is not lawful for us. He has not sinned against our law, but the indictment is general. Pilate then, having perceived this, says, as being (himself) likely to be endangered, Are you the King of the Jews? Then Jesus, not from ignorance, but from a desire that the Jews should be accused even by him, asked him, saying, Did others tell it you? Sayest thou this thing of thyself or did others tell it thee of Me? " N.T. }}–> On this point then declaring himself, Pilate replied,

John 18:35

Here, Jesus wants to clear himself of the charge. Then, because Pilate had asked, "Are you the King?" Jesus rebukes him and answers, "You heard this from the Jews. Why don't you investigate carefully? They said I am a criminal; ask them what evil I have done. But you don't do this—you're simply bringing charges against me." Jesus answered him, "Do you say this on your own, or did others tell you?" Pilate cannot immediately say that he had heard it, but simply goes along with the people, saying, "They have delivered you to me. Therefore I must ask you what you have done." What then does Christ say?

Here desiring to clear himself of the matter. Then because he had said, Are you the King? Jesus reproving him answers, This you have heard from the Jews. Why do you not make accurate enquiry? They have said that I am a malefactor; ask them what evil I have done. But this you do not, but art simply framing charges against Me. Jesus answered him, Do you say this thing of yourself, or from others? Pilate then cannot at once say that he had heard it, but simply goes along with the people, saying, They have delivered you unto me. I must needs therefore ask you what you have done. What then says Christ?

John 18:36

He guides Pilate upward, who was not a very wicked man according to their standards, and desires to show that He is not merely a man, but God and the Son of God. And what does He say?

He leads upwards Pilate who was not a very wicked man, nor after their fashion, and desires to show that He is not a mere man, but God and the Son of God. And what says He?

If My Kingdom were of this world, then My servants would fight so that I would not be handed over to the Jews.

If My Kingdom were of this world, then would My servants fight, that I should not be delivered to the Jews.

He removes what Pilate had been afraid of for a time—the suspicion that He was seizing kingly power. Is His kingdom not of this world as well? Of course it is. How then does He say it "is not"? Not because He does not rule here, but because He has His empire from above, and because it is not human but far greater and more splendid than this one. If it is greater, then how was He captured by the other kingdom? By consenting and giving Himself up. But He does not reveal this at the moment. Instead, what does He say? If I had been of this world, "My servants would fight, that I should not be delivered." Here He shows the weakness of kingship among us—that its strength lies in servants—but the kingdom from above is sufficient for itself, needing nothing. From this statement the heretics take the opportunity to say that He is different from the Creator. What then, when it says He came to His own? What when He Himself says, "They are not of this world, as I am not of this world"? In the same way He says that His kingdom is not from here, not removing the world from His providence and care, but showing, as I said, that His power was not human or perishable. What then did Pilate say?

He undoes that which Pilate for a while had feared, namely, the suspicion of seizing kingly power, Is then His kingdom not of this world also? Certainly it is. How then says He it 'is not'? Not because He does not rule here, but because He has his empire from above, and because it is not human, but far greater than this and more splendid. If then it be greater, how was He made captive by the other? By consenting, and giving Himself up. But He does not at present reveal this, but what says He? If I had been of this world, 'My servants would fight, that I should not be delivered.' Here He shows the weakness of kingship among us, that its strength lies in servants; but that which is above is sufficient for itself, needing nothing. From this the heretics taking occasion say, that He is different from the Creator. What then, when it says, He came to His own? John 1:11 What, when Himself says, They are not of this world, as I am not of this world? John 17:14 So also He says that His kingdom is not from hence, not depriving the world of His providence and superintendence, but showing, as I said, that His power was not human or perishable. What then said Pilate?

John 18:37

If He was born a king, then all His other attributes also come by Generation, and He has nothing that He received as an addition. So when you hear that "As the Father has life in Himself, so has He given to the Son also to have life" (John 5:26), understand this to refer to nothing other than His generation, and the same applies to everything else.

If then He was born a king, all His other attributes are by Generation, and He has nothing which He received in addition. So that when you hear that, As the Father has life in Himself, so has He given to the Son also to have life John 5:26, deem of nothing else but His generation, and so of the rest.

And for this reason I came, so that I should bear witness to the truth.

And for this cause came I, that I should bear witness unto the truth.

That is, that I should speak this very thing, teach it, and persuade all people.

That is, that I should speak this very thing, and teach it, and persuade all men.

But you, O man, when you hear these things and see your Lord bound and led about, consider present circumstances to be nothing. How can it not be strange if Christ endured such things for your sake, yet you often cannot bear even words? He is spit upon, yet you adorn yourself with clothes and rings, and if you do not receive good reputation from everyone, you think life unbearable? He is insulted, endures mockings and contemptuous blows on the cheek; yet you wish to be honored everywhere, and you do not bear the reproach of Christ? Do you not hear Paul saying, "Be imitators of me, even as I also am of Christ"? Therefore, when anyone mocks you, remember your Lord, that in mockery they bowed the knee before Him, and harassed Him both by words and deeds, and treated Him with much contempt; but He not only did not defend Himself, but even repaid them with the opposite—with mildness and gentleness. Let us now imitate Him; in this way we shall be able to be delivered from all insult. For it is not the insulter who makes insults effective and biting, but the person who is small of soul and pained by them. If you are not pained, you have not been insulted; for the suffering from injuries depends not on those who inflict them, but on those who receive them. Why should you grieve at all? If a man has insulted you unjustly, in this case surely you ought not to grieve at all, but to pity him; if justly, all the more you ought to remain quiet. For if someone addresses you, a poor man, as though you were rich, the praise in his words means nothing to you, but his praise is rather mockery; and likewise if someone insulting you says things that are untrue, the reproach means nothing to you either. But if conscience takes hold of what has been said, do not grieve at the words, but make correction in deeds. This I say regarding what truly are insults. For if someone reproaches you with poverty or low birth, laugh at him. These things are a reproach not to the hearer, but to the speaker, as one who does not know true wisdom. But, someone says, when these things are said in the presence of many who are ignorant of the truth, the wound becomes unbearable. No, it is most bearable, when you have an audience present as witnesses praising and applauding you, scoffing at and mocking him. For not the one who defends himself, but the one who says nothing, is applauded by sensible people. And if none of those present is a sensible person, then laugh at him most of all, and delight yourself in the audience of heaven. For there all will praise and applaud and welcome you. For one angel is as valuable as the whole world. But why do I speak of angels, when the Lord Himself proclaims you? Let us train ourselves with these thoughts. For it is no loss to be silent when insulted, but it is a loss, on the contrary, to defend oneself when insulted. Since if it were wrong to bear silently what is said, Christ would never have told us, "If one strikes you on the right cheek, turn to him the other also." If then our enemy says what is not true, let us on this account even pity him, because he draws down upon himself the punishment and vengeance of the accusers, being unworthy even to read the Scriptures. For to the sinner God says, "Why do you declare My statutes, and take My covenant in your mouth? You sat and spoke against your brother." And if he speaks the truth, he also is to be pitied; since even the Pharisee spoke the truth; yet he did no harm to the one who heard him, but rather good, while he deprived himself of countless blessings, suffering shipwreck through this accusation. So that either way it is he who suffers injury, not you; but you, if you are sober-minded, will have double gain: both propitiating God by your silence, and becoming yet more prudent, gaining an opportunity from what has been said to correct what has been done, and despising mortal glory. For this is the source of our pain, that many rely upon the opinion of men. If we are minded to be truly wise in this way, we shall know well that human things are nothing. Let us then learn, and having counted up our faults, let us accomplish their correction in time, and let us resolve to correct one fault this month, another next month, and a third in the following month. And so ascending as if by steps, let us reach heaven by a Jacob's ladder. For the ladder seems to me to signify through that vision, in a mysterious way, the gradual ascent by means of virtue, by which it is possible for us to ascend from earth to heaven, not using material steps, but improvement and correction of character. Let us then take hold of this means of departure and ascent, so that having attained heaven, we may also enjoy all the blessings there, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ; to whom be glory forever and ever. Amen.

5. But do thou, O man, when you hear these things, and see your Lord bound and led about, deem present things to be nought. For how can it be otherwise than strange, if Christ bore such things for your sake, and you often cannot endure even words? He is spit upon, and do you deck yourself with garments and rings, and, if you gain not good report from all, think life unbearable? He is insulted, bears mockings, and scornful blows upon the cheek; and do you wish everywhere to be honored, and do you not bear the reproaching of Christ? Do you not hear Paul saying, Be imitators of me, even as I also am of Christ? 1 Corinthians 11:1 When therefore any one makes a jest of you, remember your Lord, that in mockery they bowed the knee before Him, and worried Him both by words and deeds, and treated Him with much irony; but He not only did not defend Himself, but even repaid them with the contraries, with mildness and gentleness. Him now let us emulate; so shall we be enabled even to be delivered from all insult. For it is not the insulter that gives effect to acts of insult, and makes them biting, but he who is little of soul, and is pained by them. If you are not pained, you have not been insulted; for the suffering from injuries depends not on those who inflict, but on those who undergo them. Why do you grieve at all? If a man has insulted you unjustly, in this case surely you ought not to grieve at all, but to pity him; if justly, much more ought thou to keep quiet. For should any one address you, a poor man, as though thou were rich, the praise contained in his words is nothing to you, but his encomium is rather mockery; and so if one insulting you utter things that are untrue, the reproach is nothing to you either. But if conscience takes hold of what has been said, be not grieved at the words, but make correction in deeds. This I say with regard to what really are insults. For if one reproach you with poverty or low birth, laugh at him. These things are a reproach not to the hearer, but to the speaker, as not knowing true wisdom. But, says some one, when these things are said in the presence of many who are ignorant of the truth, the wound becomes unbearable. Nay, it is most bearable, when you have an audience present of witnesses praising and applauding you, scoffing at and making a jest of him. For not he that defends himself, but he that says nothing, is applauded by sensible persons. And if none of those present be a sensible person, then laugh at him most of all, and delight yourself in the audience of heaven. For there all will praise and applaud and welcome you. For one Angel is as good as all the world. But why speak I of Angels, when the Lord Himself proclaims you? Let us exercise ourselves with these reasonings. For it is no loss to be silent when insulted, but it is, on the contrary, to defend one's self when insulted. Since were it a fault silently to bear what is said, Christ would never have told us, If one smite you on the right cheek, turn to him the other also. Matthew 5:39 If then our enemy say what is not true, let us on this account even pity him, because he draws down upon him the punishment and vengeance of the accusers, being unworthy even to read the Scriptures. For to the sinner God says, Why do you declare My statutes, and takest My covenant in your mouth? Thou sat and spoke against your brother. Psalm 50:16-20, Septuagint And if he speak the truth, so also he is to be pitied; since even the Pharisee spoke the truth; yet he did no harm to him who heard him, but rather good, while he deprived himself of ten thousand blessings, enduring shipwreck by this accusation. So that either way it is he that suffers injury, not thou; but thou, if you are sober, will have double gain; both the propitiating God by your silence, and the becoming yet more discreet, the gaining an opportunity from what has been said to correct what has been done, and the despising mortal glory. For this is the source of our pain, that many gape upon the opinion of men. If we are minded to be thus truly wise, we shall know well that human things are nothing. Let us learn then, and having reckoned up our faults, let us accomplish their correction in time, and let us determine to correct one this month, another next month, and a third in that which follows. And so mounting as it were by steps, let us get to heaven by a Jacob's ladder. For the ladder seems to me to signify in a riddle by that vision the gradual ascent by means of virtue, by which it is possible for us to ascend from earth to heaven, not using material steps, but improvement and correction of manners. Let us then lay hold on this means of departure and ascent, that having obtained heaven, we may also enjoy all the blessings there, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ; to whom be glory for ever and ever. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 82 — John 17:14

Homily 82 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240182.htm>.

Contents · 13 chapters
  1. John 17:14
  2. John 17:15
  3. John 17:16
  4. John 17:17
  5. John 17:17
  6. John 17:19
  7. John 17:20
  8. John 17:21
  9. John 17:22
  10. John 17:23
  11. John 17:24
  12. John 17:25
  13. John 17:26

John 17:14

When we become virtuous and are persecuted by the wicked, or when we desire virtue and are mocked by them, let us not be distracted or angry. For this is the natural course of things, and everywhere virtue tends to generate hatred from wicked men. For they envy those who desire to live properly, and they think they are preparing an excuse for themselves if they can destroy the reputation of others, so they hate them for having pursuits opposite to their own and use every means to shame their way of life. But let us not grieve, for this is a mark of virtue. Therefore Christ also says, "If you were of the world, the world would love its own" (John 15:19). And in another place again, "Woe to you when all men speak well of you" (Luke 6:26). Therefore He also says here, "I have given them Your word, and the world has hated them." Again He tells the reason why they were worthy to receive much care from the Father: "For Your sake," He says, "they have been hated, and for Your word's sake," so that they would be entitled to all providential care.

1. When having become virtuous we are persecuted by the wicked, or when being desirous of virtue we are mocked at by them, let us not be distracted or angry. For this is the natural course of things, and everywhere virtue is wont to engender hatred from wicked men. For envying those who desire to live properly, and thinking to prepare an excuse for themselves if they can overthrow the credit of others, they hate them as having pursuits opposite to their own, and use every means to shame their way of life. But let not us grieve, for this is a mark of virtue. Wherefore Christ also says, If you were of the world, the world would love its own. John 15:19 And in another place again, Woe unto you when all men shall speak well of you. Luke 6:26 Wherefore also He says here, I have given them Your word, and the world has hated them. Again He tells the reason for which they were worthy to obtain much care from the Father; For Your sake, He says, they have been hated, and for Your word's sake; so that they would be entitled to all providential care.

John 17:15

Again He simplifies His language; again He makes it clearer. This is the action of someone showing, by making precise requests for them, nothing other than that He has very tender care for them. Yet He Himself had told them that the Father would do all things whatever they should ask. How then does He pray for them here? As I said, for no other purpose than to show His love.

Again He simplifies His language; again He renders it more clear; which is the act of one showing, by making entreaty for them with exactness, nothing else but this, that He has a very tender care for them. Yet He Himself had told them, that the Father would do all things whatsoever they should ask. How then does He here pray for them? As I said, for no other purpose than to show His love.

John 17:16

How then does He say in another place, "Which You gave Me out of the world; Yours they were"? There He speaks of their physis; here of wicked actions. And He puts together a long praise of them: first, that they were not of the world; then, that the Father Himself had given them; and that they had kept His word; and that on this account they were hated. And if He says, "As I am not of the world," do not be troubled, for the "as" here does not express exact sameness. For just as when the "as" is used in the case of Him and the Father, a great Equality is signified because of the Relationship in physis, so when it is used of us and Him, the gap is great because of the great and infinite gap between the respective natures. For if He did no sin, nor was guile found in His mouth, how could the Apostles be reckoned equal to Him? What is it then that He says, "They are not of the world"? They look to another world, they have nothing in common with earth, but have become citizens of heaven. And by these words He shows His love, when He commends them to the Father and commits them to Him who begot Him. When He says, "Keep them," He does not speak merely of delivering them from dangers, but also with regard to their continuance in the faith. Therefore He adds,

How then says He in another place, Which You gave Me out of the world; Yours they were? John 17:6 There He speaks of their nature; here of wicked actions. And He puts together a long encomium of them; first, that they were not of the world; then, that the Father Himself had given them; and that they had kept His word; and that on this account they were hated. And if He says, As I am not of the world, be not troubled; for the as is not here expressive of unvarying exactness. For as, when in the case of Him and the Father the as is used, a great Equality is signified, because of the Relationship in Nature; so when it is used of us and Him, the interval is great, because of the great and infinite interval between the respective natures. For if He did no sin, neither was guile found in His mouth 1 Peter 2:22, how could the Apostles be reckoned equal to Him? What is it then that He says, They are not of the world? They look to another world, they have nothing common with earth, but have become citizens of heaven. And by these words He shows His love, when He commends them to the Father, and commits them to Him who begot Him. When He says, Keep them, He does not speak merely of delivering them from dangers, but also with regard to their continuance in the faith. Wherefore He adds,

John 17:17

Your word is truth.

Your word is truth.

That is, there is no falsehood in it, and everything said in it must necessarily come to pass. Also, it signifies nothing merely symbolic or physical. Paul says the same thing about the Church: that Christ has sanctified it by the Word. For the Word of God also has the power to cleanse. Moreover, "sanctify them" seems to me to mean something else, namely this: set them apart for the Word and for preaching. This becomes clear from what follows, for He says,

That is, there is no falsehood in it, and all that is said in it must needs come to pass; and again, it signifies nothing typical or bodily. As also Paul says concerning the Church, that He has sanctified it by the Word. For the Word of God is wont also to cleanse. Ephesians 5:26 Moreover, the, sanctify them, seems to me to signify something else, such as this, Set them apart for the Word and for preaching. And this is made plain from what follows. For, He says,

John 17:17

As Paul also says, Having put in us the word of reconciliation. 2 Corinthians 5:19 For the same purpose for which Christ came, for the same purpose did these take possession of the world. In this passage again the word "as" is not used to signify a resemblance between Himself and the Apostles; for how was it possible for men to be sent in any other way? But it was His custom to speak of the future as if it had already come to pass.

As Paul also says, Having put in us the word of reconciliation. 2 Corinthians 5:19 For the same end for which Christ came, for the same did these take possession of the world. In this place again the as is not put to signify resemblance in the case of Himself and the Apostles; for how was it possible for men to be sent otherwise? But it was His custom to speak of the future as having come to pass.

John 17:19

What does "I sanctify Myself" mean? It means I offer You a sacrifice. Now all sacrifices are called holy, and those things are especially called holy that are set apart for God. In the past, sanctification happened symbolically through the sheep, but now it happens not symbolically but through the truth itself. That is why He says, "That they may be sanctified in Your truth." For I both dedicate them to You and make them an offering. He says this either because their Head was being made such an offering, or because they too were being sacrificed. For it says, "Present your bodies a living sacrifice, holy" (Romans 12:1), and "We were counted as sheep for the slaughter" (Psalm 43:22). And He makes them a sacrifice and offering without death. That He was referring to His own sacrifice when He said "I sanctify" is clear from what follows.

What is, I sanctify Myself? I offer to You a sacrifice. Now all sacrifices are called holy, and those are specially called holy things, which are laid up for God. For whereas of old in type the sanctification was by the sheep, but now it is not in type, but by the truth itself, He therefore says, That they may be sanctified in Your truth. For I both dedicate them to You, and make them an offering; this He says, either because their Head was being made so, or because they also were sacrificed; for, Present, it says, your bodies a living sacrifice, holy Romans 12:1; and, We were counted as sheep for the slaughter. Psalm 43:22 And He makes them; without death, a sacrifice and offering; for that He alluded to His own sacrifice, when He said, I sanctify, is clear from what follows.

John 17:20

For since He was dying for them and said, "For their sakes I sanctify Myself," lest anyone should think that He did this for the Apostles only, He added, "Neither pray I for these only, but for them also who believe in Me through their word." By this again He revived their souls, showing that the disciples would be many. For because He made common what they possessed peculiarly, He comforts them by showing that they were being made the cause of the salvation of others.

2. For since He was dying for them, and said, that For their sakes I sanctify Myself, lest any one should think that He did this for the Apostles only, He added, Neither pray I for these only, but for them also who believe in Me through their word. By this again He revived their souls, showing that the disciples should be many. For because He made common what they possessed peculiarly, He comforts them by showing that they were being made the cause of the salvation of others.

After speaking about their salvation and their being sanctified by faith and the Sacrifice, He then speaks about concord, and finally concludes His discourse with this theme, having both begun and ended with it. For at the beginning He says, "A new commandment I give unto you" (John 13:34); and here,

After having thus spoken concerning their salvation, and their being sanctified by faith and the Sacrifice, He afterwards speaks of concord, and finally closes his discourse with this, having begun with it and ended in it. For at the beginning He says, A new commandment I give unto you John 13:34; and here,

John 17:21

Here again the "as" does not indicate exact similarity in their case, since it was not possible for them to that degree, but only as far as was possible for men. It is just as when He says "Be merciful, as your Father." Luke 6:36

Here again the as does not denote exact similarity in their case, (for it was not possible for them in so great a degree,) but only as far as was possible for men. Just as when He says Be merciful, as your Father. Luke 6:36

But what does "In Us" mean? It means in the faith that is directed toward Us. Because nothing offends everyone so much as divisions, He makes provision for them to be one. But someone asks, did He actually accomplish this? He certainly did accomplish it. For all who believe through the Apostles are one, even though some among them were torn away. Nor was this unknown to Him—He even foretold it and showed that it came from people's laziness.

But what is, In Us? In the faith which is on Us. Because nothing so offends all men as divisions, He provides that they should be one. What then, says some one, did He effect this? Certainly He effected it. For all who believe through the Apostles are one, though some from among them were torn away. Nor did this escape His knowledge, He even foretold it, and showed that it proceeded from men's slack-mindedness.

That the world may believe that You have sent Me.

That the world may believe that You have sent Me.

As He said at the beginning, "By this all people will know that you are My disciples, if you love one another." And how will they believe because of this? Because, He says, "You are a God of peace." So if they show the same character as those from whom they have learned, their listeners will recognize the teacher through the disciples. But if they quarrel, people will deny that they are disciples of a God of peace, and will refuse to accept that I, not being peaceable, have been sent from You. Do you see how, right to the end, He demonstrates His unanimity with the Father?

As He said in the beginning, By this shall all men know that you are My disciples, if you love one another. And how should they hence believe? Because, He says, You are a God of peace. If therefore they observe the same as those of whom they have learned, their hearers shall know the teacher by the disciples, but if they quarrel, men shall deny that they are the disciples of a God of peace, and will not allow that I, not being peaceable, have been sent from You. Do you see how, unto the end, He proves His unanimity with the Father?

John 17:22

That through miracles, through doctrines, and that they should be of one soul; for this is glory, that they should be one, and this is even greater than miracles. Just as people admire God because there is no strife or discord in That Nature, and this is His greatest glory, so too, He says, let these become glorious for the same reason. But how, someone asks, does He ask the Father to give this to them when He says that He Himself gives it? Whether His teaching concerns miracles, unanimity, or peace, He is clearly seen to have given these things to them Himself; from this it is clear that the request is made for their comfort.

That by miracles, that by doctrines, and, that they should be of one soul; for this is glory, that they should be one, and greater even than miracles. As men admire God because there is no strife or discord in That Nature, and this is His greatest glory, so too let these, He says, from this cause become glorious. And how, says some one, does He ask the Father to give this to them, when He says that He Himself gives it? Whether His discourse be concerning miracles, or unanimity, or peace, He is seen Himself to have given these things to them; whence it is clear that the petition is made for the sake of their comfort.

John 17:23

How did He give the glory? By being in them and having the Father with Him, so as to unite them together. But in another place He does not speak this way. He does not say that the Father comes through Him, but that He and the Father come and make their dwelling with him. In that passage He removes the suspicion of Sabellius, while here He removes that of Arius.

How gave He the glory? By being in them, and having the Father with Him, so as to weld them together. But in another place He speaks not so; He says not that the Father comes by Him, but, that He and the Father come, and take up their abode with him, there removing the suspicion of Sabellius, here that of Arius.

That they may be made perfect in one, and that the world may know that You have sent Me. John 14:23

The purpose of their unity is twofold: that they may be made perfect in one, and that the world may know that the Father sent the Son. He shows that this unity will be a clear proof of His mission from the Father, for it will demonstrate that the same power which the Father possesses has been given to the Son.

That they may be made perfect in one, and that the world may know that You have sent Me. John 14:23

He speaks these last words right after the previous ones to show that peace has more power to draw people to faith than a miracle does. Just as conflict naturally divides people, unity naturally binds them together.

He says these latter words immediately after the other, to show that peace has more power to attract men than a miracle; for as it is the nature of strife to separate, so it is that of agreement to weld together.

And I have loved them as You have loved Me.

And I have loved them as You have loved Me.

Here again the "as" means as far as it is possible for a man to be loved; and the sure proof of His love is His giving Himself for them. After having told them that they will be safe, that they will not be overthrown, that they will be holy, that many will believe through them, that they will enjoy great glory, that not He alone loved them, but the Father also, He next tells them about what will come after their time here on earth, concerning the prizes and crowns stored up for them.

Here again the as means, as far as it is possible for a man to be loved; and the sure proof of His love is His giving Himself for them. After having told them that they shall be in safety, that they shall not be overturned, that they shall be holy, that many shall believe through them, that they shall enjoy great glory, that not He alone loved them, but the Father also; He next tells them of what shall be after their sojourning here, concerning the prizes and crowns laid up for them.

John 17:24

Then do You gain something by prayer, and do You not yet possess that which they continually asked about, saying, 'Where are You going?' What are You saying? How then did You say to them, 'You shall sit upon twelve thrones'? How did You promise other things even more and greater? Do you see that He says everything by way of condescension? For how could He have said, You shall follow afterwards? But He speaks this way to bring about a fuller conviction and demonstration of His love.

Then dost Thou gain by prayer, and dost Thou not yet possess that concerning which they enquired continually, saying, 'Where are You going?' What sayest Thou? How then did You say to them, 'You shall sit upon twelve thrones'? Matthew 19:28 How did You promise other things more and greater? Do you see that He says all in the way of condescension? Since how would He have said, You shall follow afterwards? John 13:36 But He speaks thus with a view to a fuller conviction and demonstration of His love.

That they may behold My glory which You have given Me.

That they may behold My glory which You have given Me.

This again is a sign that He shares the same mind with the Father, even more clearly than the earlier signs, for He says, "Before the foundation of the world," yet it also contains a certain condescension, for He says, "You have given Me." Now if this is not the case, I would like to ask those who oppose this a question. The one who gives, gives to someone who already exists; did the Father then, after first begetting the Son, afterward give Him glory, having previously left Him without glory? And how could this make sense? Do you see that "He gave" means "He begot"?

This again is a sign of His being of one mind with the Father, of a higher character than those former, for He says, Before the foundation of the world, yet has it also a certain condescension; for, You have given Me, He says. Now if this be not the case, I would gladly ask the gainsayers a question. He that gives, gives to one subsisting; did the Father then, having first begotten the Son, afterwards give Him glory, having before allowed Him to be without glory? And how could this be reasonable? Seest that the He gave, is, He begot?

But why did He not say, "That they may share My glory," instead of, "That they may behold My glory"? Here He implies that all that rest consists in looking upon the Son of God. This is certainly what causes them to be glorified, as Paul says, "With open face mirroring the glory of the Lord" (2 Corinthians 3:18). For just as those who look upon sunbeams and enjoy a very clear atmosphere draw their enjoyment from their sight, so too, and to a much greater degree, this will cause us pleasure. At the same time He also shows that what they would behold was not the body then seen, but some awesome Substance.

3. But why said He not, That they may share My glory, instead of, That they may be hold My glory? Here He implies, that all that rest is, the looking on the Son of God. This certainly it is which causes them to be glorified; as Paul says, With open face mirroring the glory of the Lord. 2 Corinthians 3:18 For as they who look on the sunbeams, and enjoy a very clear atmosphere, draw their enjoyment from their sight, so then also, and in much greater degree, this will cause us pleasure. At the same time also He shows, that what they should behold was not the body then seen, but some awful Substance.

John 17:25

What does this mean? How does it connect? He shows here that no one knows God except those who have come to know the Son. What He says is something like this: I wanted everyone to be this way, yet they have not known You, even though they had no reason to complain against You. For this is what "O righteous Father" means. And here He seems to me to speak these words as if troubled that they would not know One so just and good. For since the Jews had claimed that they knew God, but that He did not know Him, He aims at this, saying, "For You loved Me before the foundation of the world," putting together a defense against the accusations of the Jews. For how could He who had received glory, who was loved before the foundation of the world, who wanted to have them as witnesses of that glory—how could He be opposed to the Father? So what the Jews say is not true, that they know You and that I do not know You; on the contrary, I know You, and they have not known You.

What means this? What connection has it? He here shows that no man knows God, save those only who have come to know the Son. And what He says is of this kind: I wished all to be so, yet they have not known You, although they had no complaint against You. For this is the meaning of, O righteous Father. And here He seems to me to speak these words, as vexed that they would not know One so just and good. For since the Jews had said that they knew God, but that He knew Him not, at this He aims, saying, For You loved Me before the foundation of the world; thus putting together a defense against the accusations of the Jews. For how could He who had received glory, who was loved before the foundation of the world, who desired to have them as witnesses of that glory, how could He be opposed to the Father? This then is not true which the Jews say, that they know You, and that I know You not; on the contrary, I know You, and they have not known You.

And these have known that You have sent Me.

And these have known that You have sent Me.

Do you see that He is referring to those who said He was not from God, and everything is ultimately summed up to address this argument?

Do you see that He alludes to those, who said that He was not from God, and all is finally summed up to meet this argument?

John 17:26

You say that perfect knowledge comes from the Spirit. But the things of the Spirit are Mine.

Yet you say that perfect knowledge is from the Spirit. But the things of the Spirit are Mine.

That the love with which You have loved Me may remain in them, and I in them.

That the love wherewith You have loved Me may remain in them, and I in them.

For if they learn who You are, then they will know that I am not separated from You, but one of the greatly loved, a true Son, and closely united with You. Those who are rightly convinced of this will maintain both faith in Me and perfect love; and while they love as they should, I remain in them. Do you see how He has reached a fitting conclusion, ending the discourse with love, the mother of all good things?

For if they learn who You are, then they shall know that I am not separated from You, but one of the greatly beloved, and a true Son, and closely knit to You. And those who are rightly persuaded of this, will keep both the faith which is on Me and perfect love; and while they love as they ought, I remain in them. Do you see how He has arrived at a good end, finishing off the discourse with love, the mother of all blessings?

Let us believe and love God, so that it may not be said of us, "They profess that they know God, but in their works they deny Him," and again, "He has denied the faith, and is worse than an infidel." For when an unbeliever helps his household servants, relatives, and strangers, while you do not even help those who are related to you by family, what excuse will you have when God is blasphemed and insulted because of you? Consider what opportunities for doing good God has given us. Have mercy on one person, He says, as a relative, on another as a friend, on another as a neighbor, on another as a fellow citizen, on another as a human being. And if none of these things move you, but you break through all bonds, hear from Paul that you are worse than an unbeliever. For he, having heard nothing of almsgiving or of heavenly things, has surpassed you in love for humanity. But you who are commanded to love even your enemies treat your friends as enemies, and care more about your money than about their bodies. Yet the money will suffer no harm by being spent, but your brother if neglected will perish. What madness, then, to be careful about money and careless about one's relatives? Where has this craving for riches burst in upon us? Where does this inhumanity and cruelty come from? For if anyone could, as though seated on the highest seat of a theater, look down upon the whole world—or rather, if you will, let us for now consider just a single city—if a man seated in an elevated spot could take in at a glance all the actions of the people there, consider what folly he would condemn, what tears he would weep, what laughter he would laugh, what hatred he would hate. For we commit such actions as deserve both laughter and the charge of folly and tears and hatred. One man keeps dogs to catch wild animals, himself sinking into brutality. Another keeps oxen and donkeys to transport stones, but neglects men wasting away with hunger, and spends unlimited gold to make statues of stone, but neglects real men who are becoming like stones through their miserable condition. Another, laboriously collecting golden quarries, puts them on his walls, but when he sees the naked bellies of the poor, he is not moved. Some contrive garments over their very garments, while their brother does not even have anything to cover his naked body. Again, one has swallowed up another in the law courts. Another has spent his money on women and parasites, another on stage-players and theatrical bands, another on splendid buildings and purchases of fields and houses. Again, one man is counting interest, another interest upon interest. Another is assembling gangs full of many deaths, and does not enjoy rest even at night, lying awake for others' harm. Then when day comes, they run, one to his unjust gain, another to his wasteful spending, others to public robbery. And great is the earnestness about things superfluous and forbidden, but no account is taken of necessary things. And those who decide questions of law have indeed the name of jurymen, but are really thieves and murderers. And if one should examine lawsuits and wills, he would find there again ten thousand mischiefs, frauds, robberies, and plots, and all their time is spent on these things. But there is no care for spiritual things, and they all trouble the Church for the sake of merely seeing. But this is not what is required. We need works and a pure mind. But if you spend all day grasping after riches, and then come in and say a few words, you have not only not appeased God, but have angered Him even more. Would you conciliate your Lord? Exhibit works, make yourself acquainted with the mass of woes, look upon the naked, the hungry, the wronged. He has laid out for you ten thousand ways of showing love for humanity. Let us not deceive ourselves by living aimlessly and to no purpose, nor presume because we are now in health. But bearing in mind that often when we have fallen into sickness and have reached the extreme of weakness, we have been paralyzed with fear and the expectation of things to come, let us expect to fall again into the same state, let us feel again the same fear, and let us become better men. For what is done now deserves infinite condemnation. For those in the courts of justice are like lions and dogs; those in the public places like foxes; and those who lead a life of leisure, even they do not use their leisure as they ought, spending all their time on theaters and the mischiefs arising from them. And there is no one to reprove what is being done, but there are many who envy and are vexed that they are not in the same condition, so that these in turn are punished, though not actually doing wicked things. For they not only do these things, but also have pleasure in those who do them. Because what belongs to their will is equally corrupt, from which it is plain that the intention also will be punished. I say these things each day, and I will not cease to say them. For if any listen, it is gain; but if none pay attention, you shall then hear these things when it will do you no good, and you shall blame yourselves, and we shall be free from fault. But may it never come to pass that we should only have this excuse, but that you may be our boast before the judgment-seat of Christ, that together we may enjoy the blessings, through the grace and loving-kindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father and the Holy Spirit be glory, forever and ever. Amen.

4. Let us then believe and love God, that it may not be said of us, They profess that they know God, but in their works they deny Him. Titus 1:16 And again, He has denied the faith, and is worse than an infidel. 1 Timothy 5:8 For when he helps his domestics and kinsmen and strangers, while thou dost not even succor those who are related to you by family, what will henceforth be your excuse, when God is blasphemed and insulted by reason of you? Consider what opportunities of doing good God has given to us. Have mercy on one, He says, as a kinsman, on another as a friend, on another as a neighbor, on another as a citizen, on another as a man. And if none of these things hold you, but you break through all bonds, hear from Paul, that you are worse than an infidel; for he having heard nothing of almsgiving, or of heavenly things, has overshot you in love for man; but thou who art bidden to love your very enemies, lookest upon your friends as enemies, and art more careful of your money than of their bodies. Yet the money by being spent will sustain no injury, but your brother if neglected will perish. What madness then to be careful of money, and careless about one's kindred? Whence has this craving for riches burst in upon us? Whence this inhumanity and cruelty? For if any one could, as though seated on the highest bench of a theater, look down upon all the world — or rather, if you will, let us for the present take in hand a single city — if then a man seated on an elevated spot could take in at a glance all the doings of the men there, consider what folly he would condemn, what tears he would weep, what laughter he would laugh, with what hatred he would hate; for we commit such actions as deserve both laughter, and the charge of folly, and tears, and hatred. One man keeps dogs to catch brute animals, himself sinking into brutality; another keeps oxen and asses to transport stones, but neglects men wasting with hunger; and spends gold without limit to make men of stone, but neglects real men, who are becoming like stones through their evil state. Another, collecting with great pains golden quarries, puts them about his walls, but when he beholds the naked bellies of the poor, is not moved. Some again contrive garments over their very garments, while their brother has not even wherewithal to cover his naked body. Again, one has swallowed up another in the law-courts; another has spent his money on women and parasites, another on stage-players and theatrical bands, another on splendid edifices, on purchases of fields and houses. Again, one man is counting interest, another interest of interest; another is putting together bands full of many deaths, and does not enjoy rest even at night, lying awake for others' harm. Then, when it is day, they run, one to his unjust gain, another to his wanton expense, others to public robbery. And great is the earnestness about things superfluous and forbidden, but of things necessary no account is taken; and they who decide questions of law have indeed the name of jurymen, but are really thieves and murderers. And if one should enquire into law suits and wills, he would find there again ten thousand mischiefs, frauds, robberies, plots, and about these things is all time spent; but for spiritual things there is no care, and they all inconvenience the Church, for the sake of seeing only. But this is not what is required; we need works, and a pure mind. But if you spend all the day in grasping after riches, and then coming in sayest a few words, you have not only not propitiated God, but hast even angered Him more. Would you conciliate your Lord, exhibit works, make yourself acquainted with the mass of woes, look upon the naked, the hungry, the wronged; He has cut out for you ten thousand ways of showing love for men. Let us not then deceive ourselves by living aimlessly and to no purpose, nor presume, because we now are in health; but bearing in mind, that often when we have fallen into sickness, and have reached the extreme of debility, we have been dead with fear and the looking for things to come, let us expect to fall again into the same state, let us get again the same fear, and let us become better men; since what is done now deserves infinite condemnation. For those in the courts of justice are like lions and dogs; those in the public places like foxes; and those who lead a life of leisure, even they do not use their leisure as they ought, spending all their time on theaters and the mischiefs arising from them. And there is no one to reprove what is being done; but there are many who envy, and are vexed that they are not in the like condition, so that these in their turn are punished, though not actually doing wicked things. For they not only do these things, but also have pleasure in them that do them. Because what belongs to their will is alike corrupt; whence it is plain, that the intention also will be punished. These things I say each day, and I will not cease to say them. For if any listen, it is gain; but if none give heed, you shall then hear these things, when it will avail you nothing, and you shall blame yourselves, and we shall be flee from fault. But may it never come to pass that we should only have this excuse, but that you may be our boast before the judgment-seat of Christ, that together we may enjoy the blessings, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father and the Holy Ghost be glory, for ever and ever. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 81 — John 17:6

Homily 81 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240181.htm>.

Contents · 7 chapters
  1. John 17:6
  2. John 17:7
  3. John 17:9
  4. John 17:10
  5. John 17:11
  6. John 17:12
  7. John 17:13

John 17:6

'Messenger' of great counsel (Isaiah 9:6, Septuagint), the Son of God is called, both because of the other things He taught and especially because He announced the Father to people, just as He now says, "I have manifested Your Name unto the men." For after saying, "I have finished Your work," He next explains it in detail, telling what kind of work. Now the Name was indeed well known. For Isaiah said, "You shall swear by the true God" (Isaiah 65:16). But what I have often told you I tell you now: though it was known, it was known only to Jews, and not even to all of them. But now He speaks concerning the Gentiles. Nor does He simply declare this, but also that they knew Him as the Father. For it is not the same thing to learn that He is Creator and to learn that He has a Son. But He manifested His Name both through words and through actions.

1. 'Messenger' of great counsel Isaiah 9:6, Septuagint, the Son of God is called, because of the other things which He taught, and principally because He announced the Father to men, as also now He says, I have manifested Your Name unto the men. For after having said, I have finished Your work, He next explains it in detail, telling what sort of work. Now the Name indeed was well known. For Esaias said, You shall swear by the true God. Isaiah 65:16. But what I have often told you I tell you now, that though it was known, yet it was so only to Jews, and not to all of these: but now He speaks concerning the Gentiles. Nor does He declare this merely, but also that they knew Him as the Father. For it is not the same thing to learn that He is Creator, and that He has a Son. But He manifested His Name both by words and actions.

Whom You gave Me out of the world. Just as He says earlier, "No man comes unto Me except it be given him" (John 6:65), and "Except My Father draw him" (John 6:64), so here too He says "Whom you gave Me." In John 14:6 He calls Himself the Way. From this it is clear that He establishes two things through what is said here: that He is not opposed to the Father, and that it is the Father's will to entrust them to the Son.

Whom You gave Me out of the world. As He says above, No man comes unto Me except it be given him John 6:65; and, Except My Father draw him John 6:64; so here too, Whom you gave Me. John 14:6 Now He calls Himself the Way; whence it is clear that He establishes two things by what is said here, that He is not opposed to the Father, and that it is the Father's will to entrust them to the Son.

Yours they were, and You gave them Me. Here He wants to teach that He is greatly loved by the Father. For it is clear that He did not need to receive them, since He made them and continually cares for them. How then did He receive them? As I said before, this shows His unanimity with the Father. Now if someone chooses to examine this matter in a human way and according to how the words are spoken, they will no longer belong to the Father. For if when the Father had them, the Son did not have them, then it is clear that when He gave them to the Son, He withdrew from His dominion over them. And again, there is an even more unseemly conclusion: they will be found to have been imperfect while they were still with the Father, but to have become perfect when they came to the Son. But it is absurd even to speak this way. What then does He declare by this? That it has seemed good to the Father also that they should believe in the Son.

Yours they were, and You gave them Me. Here He desires to teach that He is greatly loved by the Father. For that He needed not to receive them, is clear from this, He made them, He cares for them continually. How then did He receive them? This, as I said before, shows His unanimity with the Father. Now if a man choose to enquire into the matter in a human manner, and as the words are spoken, they will no longer belong to the Father. For if when the Father had them, the Son had them not, it is evident that when He gave them to the Son, He withdrew from His dominion over them. And again, there is a yet more unseemly conclusion; for they will be found to have been imperfect while they yet were with the Father, but to have become perfect when they came to the Son. But it is mockery even to speak thus. What then does He declare by this? That it has seemed good to the Father also that they should believe in the Son.

And they have kept Your word.

And they have kept Your word.

John 17:7

How did they keep Your word? By believing in Me and paying no attention to the Jews. For the one who believes in Him, it says, has set to his seal that God is true. John 3:33 Some read, Now I know that all things whatsoever You have given Me are of You. But this would make no sense, for how could the Son be ignorant of the things of the Father? No, the words are spoken about the disciples. From the time, He says, that I told them these things, they have learned that all that You have given Me is from You; nothing is alien, nothing peculiar to Me apart from You. (For whatever is peculiar makes most things alien. They therefore have known that all things, whatever I teach, are Your doctrines and teachings.) And how have they learned it? From My words, for that is how I have taught them. And I have taught them not only this, but also that I came out from You. For this He was eager to prove throughout all the Gospel.

How did they keep Your word? By believing in Me, and giving no heed to the Jews. For he that believes in Him, it says, 'has set to his seal that God is true.' John 3:33 Some read, Now I know that all things whatsoever You have given Me are of You. But this would have no reason; for how would the Son be ignorant of the things of the Father? No the words are spoken of the disciples. From the time, He says, that I told them these things, they have learned that all that You have given Me is from You; nothing is alien, nothing peculiar to Me, with You. (For whatever is peculiar, puts most things in the condition of being alien. They therefore have known that all things, whatsoever I teach, are Your doctrines and teachings. And whence have they learned it? From My words; for so have I taught them. And not only this have I taught them, but also that I came out from You. For this He was anxious to prove through all the Gospel.

John 17:9

What are You saying? Do You teach the Father, as if He were ignorant? Do You speak to Him as if He were someone who does not know? What does this distinction mean? Do you see that the prayer exists for nothing else except that they may understand the love which He has toward them? For He who not only gives what He has of His own, but also calls on Another to do the same, shows greater love. What then does "I pray for them" mean? Not for all the world, He says, but for those whom You have given Me. He repeatedly uses "have given" so that they might learn that this is pleasing to the Father. Then, because He had repeatedly said "they are Yours" and "You gave them to Me," in order to remove any wrong suspicion and prevent anyone from thinking that His authority was recent and that He had only now received them, what does He say?

What sayest Thou? Do You teach the Father, as though He were ignorant? Do You speak to Him as to a man who knows not? What then means this distinction? Do you see that the prayer is for nothing else than that they may understand the love which He has towards them? For He who not only gives what He has of His own, but also calls on Another to do the same, shows greater love. What then is, I pray for them? Not for all the world, He says, but for them whom You have given Me. He continually puts the hast given, that they might learn that this seems good to the Father. Then, because He had said continually, they are Yours, and, You gave them unto Me, to remove any evil suspicion, and lest any one should think that His authority was recent, and that He had but now received them, what says He?

John 17:10

Do you see the equality of honor? In case you might think, after hearing "You have given them to Me," that they were separated from the Father's authority, or previously from the Son's authority, He removed both problems by speaking as He did. It was as if He said: Do not think, when you hear "You have given them to Me," that they are separated from the Father, because what is Mine is His; nor when you hear "Yours they were," think that they were strangers to Me, because what is His is Mine. So the phrase "You have given" is said only as a condescension, because what the Father has is the Son's, and what the Son has is the Father's. But this cannot even be said of a human son; rather, it is because They exist in a greater equality of honor. For it is clear to everyone that what belongs to the lesser also belongs to the greater, but not the reverse; yet here He reverses these terms, and this reversal demonstrates equality. And in another place, making this clear, He said, "All things that the Father has are Mine," speaking of knowledge. And the expressions "have given Me" and similar ones are meant to show that He did not come as a stranger and draw them to Himself, but received them as His own. Then He gives the reason and the proof, saying, "And I am glorified in them"—meaning either that I have authority over them, or that they will glorify Me by believing in You and Me, and will glorify Us equally. But if He is not glorified equally in them, then what is the Father's is no longer His, because no one is glorified in those over whom he has no authority. Yet how is He glorified equally? All die for Him just as they do for the Father; they preach Him as they preach the Father; and just as they say all things are done in His Name, so also in the Name of the Son.

Do you see the equality of honor? For lest on hearing, You have given them Me, you should deem that they were alienated from the authority of the Father, or before this from that of the Son, He removed both difficulties by speaking as He did. It was as though He said, Do not when you hear that 'You have given them to Me,' deem that they are alienated from the Father, for what is Mine is His; nor when you hear, 'Yours they were,' think that they were aliens from Me, for what is His is Mine. So that the, You have given, is said only for condescension; for what the Father has is the Son's, and what the Son has is the Father's. But this cannot even be said of a son after the manner of man, but because They are upon a greater Equality of honor. For that what belongs to the less, belongs to the greater also, is clear to every one, but the reverse not so; but here He converts these terms, and the conversion declares Equality. And in another place, declaring this, He said, All things that the Father has are Mine, speaking of knowledge. And the hast given Me, and the like expressions, are to show that He did not come as an alien and draw them to Him, but received them as His own. Then He puts the cause and the proof, saying, And I am glorified in them, that is, either that I have power over them, or, that they shall glorify Me, believing in You and Me, and shall glorify Us alike. But if He is not glorified equally in them, what is the Father's is no longer His. For no one is glorified in those over whom he has no authority. Yet how is He glorified equally? All die for Him equally as for the Father; they preach Him as they do the Father; and as they say that all things are done in His Name, so also in the Name of the Son.

John 17:11

That is, although I no longer appear in the flesh, yet through these I am glorified. But why does He keep saying that I am not in the world, and that because I am leaving them I entrust them to You, and that when I was in the world I kept them? If someone takes these words at face value, many absurdities will result. How could it make sense to say that He is no longer in the world and that when He leaves He entrusts them to another? These are the words of a mere man leaving them forever. Do you see how He mostly speaks like a man, in a way suited to their mental state, because they thought they had greater security from His physical presence? This is why He says, "While I was with them, I kept them." Yet He tells them, "I come to you," and "I am with you till the end." How then does He say these words as if He is about to be separated from them? He addresses Himself, as I said before, to their thoughts, so that they may find some relief when they hear Him speaking this way and handing them over to the Father's care. Since after hearing many exhortations from Him they were not convinced, He then speaks with the Father, showing His love for them. It is as though He had said, "Since You call Me to Yourself, place these in safety, for I come to You." What are You saying? Are You not able to keep them? Yes, I am able. Why then do You speak this way? So that they may have My joy fulfilled—that is, so they may not be put to shame as being imperfect. By these words He showed that He had spoken all these things this way to give them rest and joy. The statement appears contradictory: "Now I am no longer in the world, and these are in the world." This was what they were suspecting. So for a time He accommodates Himself to them, because if He had said "I keep them," they would not have believed as readily. Therefore He says, "Holy Father, keep them through Your own Name"—that is, by Your help.

That is, Although I appear no longer in the flesh, yet by these am I glorified. But why does He say continuously, that, I am not in the world; and that, because I leave them I commit them to You; and that, when I was in the world I kept them? For if one should take these words in their simple sense, many absurdities will follow. For how could it be reasonable to say, that He is no longer in the world, and that when He departs He commits them to another? Since these are the words of a mere man parting from them forever. Do you see how He speaks for the most part like a man, and in a way adapted to their state of mind, because they thought that they had a greater degree of safety from His presence? Wherefore He says, While I was with them, I kept them. John 14:28 Yet He tells them, I come to you; and, I am with you till the end. Matthew 28:20 How then says He these words, as if about to be parted from them? He addresses Himself, as I said before, to their thoughts, that they may take breath a little when they hear Him speaking thus, and delivering them over to the care of the Father. For since, after hearing many exhortations from Him, they were not persuaded, He then holds converse with the Father, manifesting His affection for them. As though He had said, Since You call Me to Yourself, place these in safety; for I come to You. What sayest Thou? Are You not able to keep them? Yea, I am able. Wherefore then do You speak thus? That they may have My joy fulfilled John 17:13; that is, may not be confounded, as being imperfect. And by these words He showed that He had spoken all these things so, to give them rest and joy. For the saying appears to be contradictory. Now I am no longer in the world, and these are in the world. This was what they were suspecting. For a while therefore He condescends to them, because had He said, I keep them, they would not have so well believed; wherefore He says, Holy Father, keep them through Your own Name; that is, by your help.

John 17:12

Again He speaks as a human being and as a Prophet, since nowhere does He appear to have done anything by the Name of God.

Again He speaks as a man and as a Prophet, since nowhere does He appear to have done anything by the Name of God.

Those whom You gave Me I have kept, and none of them has been lost, except the son of perdition, so that the Scripture might be fulfilled.

Those that You gave Me I have kept, and none of them is lost, but the son of perdition, that the Scripture might be fulfilled.

And in another place He says, "Of all that You gave Me, I will surely lose nothing." Yet not only was Judas lost, but also many afterward. How then does He say, "I will in no way lose"? For My part, I will not lose anyone. So in another place, declaring the matter more clearly, He said, "I will in no way cast out." Not through any fault of Mine, not because I either instigate their departure or abandon them; but if they withdraw on their own, I do not compel them by force.

And in another place He says, Of all that You gave Me, I will surely lose nothing. John 6:39 Yet not only was he lost, but also many afterwards; how then says He, I will in nowise lose? For My part, I will not lose. So in another place, declaring the matter was more clearly, He said, I will in nowise cast out. John 6:37 Not through fault of Mine, not because I either instigate or abandon them; but if they start away of themselves, I draw them not by necessity.

John 17:13

Do you see that the discourse is structured in a more human way? So if anyone wants to use these words to diminish the Son, he will diminish the Father as well. Notice, as proof of this, how from the beginning He speaks partly as if informing and explaining to Him, and partly as if commanding. Informing, as when He says, I pray not for the world; commanding, as, I have kept them until now, and none of them is lost; and, do You therefore now keep them, He says. And again, Yours they were, and You have given them unto Me and While I was in the world I kept them. But the explanation for all of this is that the words were addressed to their weakness.

Do you see that the discourse is composed rather in a human manner? So that should any wish from these words to lower the Son, he will lower the Father also. Observe, in proof of this, how from the beginning He speaks partly as though informing and explaining to Him, partly as enjoining. Informing, as when He says, I pray not for the world; enjoining, as, I have kept them until now, and none of them is lost; and, do Thou therefore now keep them, He says. And again, Yours they were, and You have given them unto Me and While I was in the world I kept them. But the solution of all is, that the words were addressed to their infirmity.

But after saying that none of them was lost except the son of perdition, He added, "that the Scripture might be fulfilled." Of what Scripture does He speak? That which foretells many things concerning Him. Not that He perished for the purpose of fulfilling Scripture. But we have already spoken at length on this point: this is the distinctive manner of Scripture, which presents things that happen in accordance with it as though they were caused by it. And it is necessary to examine carefully all aspects—both the manner of the speaker, his argument, and the laws of Scripture—if indeed we intend not to draw wrong conclusions. For "Brethren, be not children in your minds."

But after having said that none of them was lost but the son of perdition, He added, that the Scripture might be fulfilled. Of what Scripture does He speak? That which foretells many things concerning Him. Not that He perished on that account, in order that the Scripture might be fulfilled. But we have before spoken at length on this point, that this is the peculiar manner of Scripture, which puts things which fall out in accordance with it, as though they were caused by it. And it is needful to enquire exactly into all, both the manner of the speaker, his argument, and the laws of Scripture, if at least we are minded not to draw wrong conclusions. For, Brethren, be not children in your minds. 1 Corinthians 14:20

It is necessary to think carefully about this, not only for understanding the Scriptures, but also for being earnest in one's way of life. Young children do not desire great things, but usually admire things that are worthless. They are pleased when they see chariots, horses, a muleteer, and wheels all made of clay. But if they see a king sitting on a chariot with a pair of white mules and great splendor, they do not even turn their heads. They dress up dolls made of the same material as brides, but actual brides who are real and beautiful they do not even notice. This is their experience in many other matters as well. Many people today suffer from this same condition. When they hear about heavenly things, they do not even pay attention to them, but they are as eager for all things made of clay as children are, and they foolishly admire wealth that is earthly and honor the glory and luxury of the present life. Yet these things are just as much toys as those children's playthings, while the other things are the causes of life, glory, and rest. Just as children who are deprived of their toys cry and do not even know how to desire real things, so also are many of those who seem to be adults. That is why it says, "Be not children in your minds" (1 Corinthians 14:20). Do you desire riches? Tell me, do you not desire the wealth that lasts, but only childish toys? If you saw someone admiring a lead coin and stooping to pick it up, you would consider his poverty to be extreme. So do you, who collect things more worthless than this, count yourself among the rich? How can this make sense? We should call that person rich who despises all present things. For no one will choose to laugh at these trivial things—silver, gold, and other showy objects—unless he has a desire for greater things. Just as a person would not despise a lead coin unless he possessed gold coins, so you, when you see someone running past all worldly things, should understand that he does so for no other reason than because he looks to a greater world. A farmer despises a few grains of wheat when he expects a larger harvest. If we despise things we have when our hope is uncertain, how much more should we do so when our expectation is sure? Therefore I pray and beg you not to bring loss on yourselves, nor to hold onto mud and rob yourselves of the treasures that are above, bringing your vessel to port loaded with straw and chaff. Let each person say what he will about us, let him be angry at our constant warnings, let him call us silly, tedious, or tiresome—still we will not stop exhorting you on these matters continually and repeatedly reminding you of what the Prophet said: "Break off your sins by almsgiving, and your iniquities by showing mercy to the poor" (Daniel 4:27), and bind them on your neck. Do not act this way today and stop tomorrow. Even the body needs daily food, and so does the soul—in fact, the soul needs it even more. If it does not receive food, it becomes weaker and more worthless. Let us not neglect it when it is perishing and choking. Each day it receives many wounds by being lustful, angry, lazy, insulting, vengeful, and envious. It is therefore necessary to prepare remedies for it, and no small remedy is that of almsgiving, which can be applied to every wound. For it says, "Give alms of such things as you have, and behold all things are clean unto you" (Luke 11:41). Give alms, not what comes from greed, for what comes from greed does not last, even if you give to those in need. True almsgiving is that which is free from all injustice; this makes all things clean. This is something better even than fasting or lying on the ground. Those practices may be more painful and difficult, but almsgiving is more profitable. It enlightens the soul and makes it sleek, beautiful, and vigorous. Just as olive oil strengthens athletes, this oil restores the combatants of piety. Let us anoint our hands so that we may lift them up well against our adversary. The person who practices showing mercy to those in need will soon stop being greedy. The one who continues giving to the poor will soon stop being angry and will never be proud. Just as a physician who continually treats wounded people is easily sobered by seeing human nature in the calamities of others, so we, if we take up the work of helping the poor, will easily become truly wise. We will not admire riches or consider present things to be of great importance, but will despise them all. Rising up to heaven, we will easily obtain the eternal blessings through the grace and loving-kindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom, with the Father and the Holy Spirit, be glory forever and ever. Amen.

3. This it is necessary to consider well, not only for the understanding the Scriptures, but also for earnestness in one's way of life. For so little children do not desire great things, but are wont to admire those which are worth nothing; they are pleased at seeing chariots, and horses, and the muleteer, and wheels, all made out of earthenware; but if they see a king sitting upon a chariot, and a pair of white mules, and great magnificence, they do not even turn their heads. And they deck out as brides dolls made of the same material, but the actual brides, real and beautiful, they do not even notice; and this is their case in many other matters. Now this many men also undergo at this time; for when they hear of heavenly things, they do not even give heed to them, but toward all the things of clay they are as eager as children, and stupidly admire the wealth which is of earth, and honor the glory and luxury of the present life. Yet these are just as much toys as those; but the other are the causes of life, and glory, and repose. But as children deprived of their playthings cry, and do not know how even to desire the realities, so also are many of those who seem to be men. Wherefore it says, Be not children in your minds. 1 Corinthians 14:20 Desirest thou riches, tell me, and do you not desire the wealth that lasts, but childish toys? If you should see a man admiring a leaden coin, and stooping to pick it up, you would pronounce his penury to be extreme; and do you, who collectest more worthless things than this, number yourself among the rich? How can this consist with reason? We will call him rich who despises all present things. For no one, no one will choose to laugh at these little things, silver and gold, and other things of show, unless he have the desire of greater things; just as the man would not despise the leaden coin, unless he possessed coins of gold. Do thou, therefore, when you see a man running by all worldly things, deem that he does so from no other motive than because he looks to a greater world. So the husbandman despises a few grains of wheat, when he expects a larger harvest. But if, when the hope is uncertain, we despise things which are, much more ought we to do so in a case where the expectation is sure. Wherefore I pray and beseech you not to bring loss on yourselves, nor, keeping hold of mire, rob yourselves of the treasures which are above, bringing your vessel to port laden with straw and chaff. Let each say what he will concerning us, let him be angry at our continual admonitions, let him call us silly, tedious, tiresome, still we will not desist from exhorting you on these matters continually, and from continually repeating to you that of the Prophet, 'Break off your sins by almsgiving, and your iniquities by showing mercy to the poor' Daniel 4:27, and bind them upon your neck. Do not act in this way today, and desist tomorrow. For even this body has need of daily food; and so too has the soul, or rather that much more; and if it give not, it becomes weaker and more vile. Let us then not neglect it when it is perishing, choking. Many wounds it receives each day, by being lustful, angry, slothful, reviling, revengeful, envious. It is therefore necessary to prepare also remedies for it, and no small remedy is that of almsgiving, which can be placed on every wound. For, Give alms, it says, of such things as you have, and behold all things are clean unto you. Luke 11:41 Alms, not covetousness, for that which proceeds from covetousness endures not, though thou give to those who need. For almsgiving is that which is free from all injustice, this makes all things clean. This is a thing better even than fasting, or lying on the ground; they may be more painful and laborious, but this more profitable. It enlightens the soul, makes it sleek, beautiful, and vigorous. Not so does the fruit of the olive hold up the athletes, as this oil recovers the combatants of piety. Let us then anoint our hands, that we may lift them up well against our adversary. He that practices showing mercy to him that needs, will soon cease from covetousness, he who continues in giving to the poor, will soon cease from anger, and will never even be high-minded. For as the physician continually tending wounded persons is easily sobered, beholding human nature in the calamities of others; so we, if we enter upon the work of aiding the poor, shall easily become truly wise, and shall not admire riches, nor deem present things any great matter, but despise them all, and soaring aloft to heaven, shall easily obtain the eternal blessings, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ; to whom, with the Father and the Holy Ghost, be glory for ever and ever. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 80 — John 17:1

Homily 80 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240180.htm>.

Contents · 5 chapters
  1. John 17:1
  2. John 17:2
  3. John 17:3
  4. John 17:4
  5. John 17:5

John 17:1

He that has done and taught, it says, the same shall be called great in the Kingdom of heaven. And with good reason, for showing true wisdom in words is easy, but the proof that comes through works is the part of someone noble and great. This is why Christ, when speaking about enduring evil, puts Himself forward, telling us to take Him as our example. For this reason too, after this teaching, He turns to prayer, teaching us in our trials to leave everything aside and run to God. Because He had said, "In the world you shall have tribulation," and had shaken their souls, He lifts them up again through prayer. They still paid attention to Him as to a man, and He acts this way for their sake, just as He did in the case of Lazarus, and there tells the reason: "Because of the people that stand by I said it, that they might believe that You have sent Me." Yes, someone says, this happened with good reason in the case of the Jews, but why in the case of the disciples? With good reason in the case of the disciples also. For those who, after all that had been said and done, said, "Now we know that You know," most of all needed to be strengthened. Besides, the Evangelist does not even call the action prayer, but what does he say? He lifted up His eyes to heaven—and says instead that it was a conversation with the Father. And if elsewhere he speaks of prayer, and at one time shows Him kneeling on His knees, at another time lifting His eyes to heaven, do not be troubled, for by these means we are taught the earnestness that should be in our petitions—that standing we should look up, not with the eyes of the flesh only, but of the mind, and that we should bend our knees, crushing our own hearts. For Christ came not merely to reveal Himself, but also to teach ineffable virtue. But the teacher must teach not by words only, but also by actions. Let us hear then what He says in this place.

1. He that has done and taught, it says, the same shall be called great in the Kingdom of heaven. And with much reason; for to show true wisdom in words, is easy, but the proof which is by works is the part of some noble and great one. Wherefore also Christ, speaking of the endurance of evil, puts Himself forth, bidding us take example from Him. On this account too, after this admonition, He betakes Himself to prayer, teaching us in our temptations to leave all things, and flee to God. For because He had said, In the world you shall have tribulation, and had shaken their souls, by the prayer He raises them again. As yet they gave heed unto Him as to a man; and for their sake He acts thus, just as He did in the case of Lazarus, and there tells the reason; Because of the people that stand by I said it, that they might believe that You have sent Me. John 11:42 Yea, says some one, this took place with good cause in the case of the Jews; but wherefore in that of the disciples? With good cause in the case of the disciples also. For they who, after all that had been said and done, said, Now we know that You know John 16:30, most of all needed to be established. Besides, the Evangelist does not even call the action prayer; but what says he? He lifted up His eyes to heaven, and says rather that it was a discoursing with the Father. And if elsewhere he speaks of prayer, and at one time shows Him kneeling on His knees, at another lifting His eyes to heaven, be not thou troubled; for by these means we are taught the earnestness which should be in our petitions, that standing we should look up, not with the eyes of the flesh only, but of the mind, and that we should bend our knees, bruising our own hearts. For Christ came not merely to manifest Himself, but also about to teach virtue ineffable. But it behooves the teacher to teach, not by words only, but also by actions. Let us hear then what He says in this place.

Father, the hour has come; glorify Your Son, that Your Son also may glorify You.

Father, the hour has come; glorify Your Son, that Your Son also may glorify You.

Again He shows us that He does not come to the Cross unwillingly. For how could He be unwilling when He prayed for this to happen and called it glory—not only for Himself as the Crucified One, but also for the Father? Since this was the case, both the Son and the Father were glorified. Before the Crucifixion, not even the Jews knew Him; as it says, "Israel has not known Me" (Isaiah 1:3). But after the Crucifixion, all the world ran to Him. Then He also speaks of the manner of the glory and how He will glorify Him.

Again He shows us, that not unwilling He comes to the Cross. For how could He be unwilling, who prayed that this might come to pass, and called the action glory, not only for Himself the Crucified, but also for the Father? Since this was the case, for not the Son only, but the Father also was glorified. For before the Crucifixion, not even the Jews knew Him; Israel, it says, has not known Me Isaiah 1:3; but after the Crucifixion, all the world ran to Him. Then He speaks also of the manner of the glory, and how He will glorify Him.

John 17:2

For always doing good is glory to God. But what does "As You have given Him power over all flesh" mean? He now shows that what belongs to the preaching is not limited to the Jews alone, but extends to all the world, and He establishes beforehand the first invitations to the Gentiles. And since He had said, "Go not into the way of the Gentiles" (Matthew 10:5), and after this time is about to say, "Go, and make disciples of all nations" (Matthew 28:19), He shows that the Father also wills this. For this greatly offended the Jews, and the disciples too. Indeed, even after this they did not easily accept bringing the Gentiles in, until they received the teaching of the Spirit, because this created no small stumbling block for the Jews. Therefore, when Peter came to Jerusalem after such a manifestation of the Spirit, he could scarcely escape the charges brought against him, even by relating the vision of the sheet. But what does "You have given Him power over all flesh" mean? I will ask the heretics: When did He receive this power? Was it before He formed them, or after? He Himself says that it was after He had been crucified and had risen again. At least then He said, "All power is given unto Me" (Matthew 28:18), and "Go and make disciples of all nations." What then, did He not have authority over His own works? Did He make them, and yet not have authority over them after making them? Yet He is seen doing everything in times of old, punishing some as sinners (for it says, "Surely I will not hide from My servant Abraham that which I am about to do," Genesis 18:17, Septuagint) and honoring others as righteous. Did He then have the power at that time, and now had He lost it, and did He receive it again? What devil could claim this? But if His power was the same both then and now (for He says, "As the Father raises up the dead and quickens them, even so the Son quickens whom He will," John 5:21), what is the meaning of these words? He was about to send them to the Gentiles. Therefore, so that they might not think this was an innovation, because He had said, "I am not sent, save unto the lost sheep of the house of Israel" (Matthew 15:24), He shows that this also seems good to the Father. And if He says this with great humility of language, it is not surprising. For in this way He instructed both those at that time and those who came afterwards. And as I have said before, He always, by the excess of humble language, firmly persuaded them that the words were those of condescension.

For to be always doing good, is glory to God. But what is, As You have given Him power over all flesh? He now shows, that what belongs to the preaching is not confined to the Jews alone, but is extended to all the world, and lays down beforehand the first invitations to the Gentiles. And since He had said, Go not into the way of the Gentiles Matthew 10:5, and after this time is about to say, Go, and make disciples of all nations Matthew 28:19, He shows that the Father also wills this. For this greatly offended the Jews, and the disciples too; nor indeed after this did they easily endure to lay hold on the Gentiles, until they received the teaching of the Spirit; because hence arose no small stumblingblock for the Jews. Therefore, when Peter after such a manifestation of the Spirit came to Jerusalem, he could scarcely, by relating the vision of the sheet, escape the charges brought against him. But what is, You have given Him power over all flesh? I will ask the heretics, When did He receive this power? Was it before He formed them, or after? He himself says, that it was after that He had been crucified, and had risen again; at least then He said, All power is given unto Me Matthew 28:18, and, Go and make disciples of all nations. What then, had He not authority over His own works? Did He make them, and had He not authority over them after having made them? Yet He is seen doing all in times of old, punishing some as sinners, (for, Surely I will not hide, it says, from My servant Abraham, that which I am about to do Genesis 18:17, Septuagint) and honoring others as righteous. Had He then the power at that time, and now had He lost it, and did He again receive it? What devil could assert this? But if His power was the same both then and now, (for, says He, as the Father raises up the dead and quickens them, even so the Son quickens whom He will John 5:21) what is the meaning of the words? He was about to send them to the Gentiles; in order therefore that they might not think that this was an innovation, because He had said, I am not sent, save unto the lost sheep of the house of Israel Matthew 15:24, He shows that this seems good to the Father also. And if He says this with great meanness of circumstance, it is not wonderful. For so He edified both those at that time, and those who came afterwards; and as I have before said, He always by the excess of meanness firmly persuaded them that the words were those of condescension.

But what does "of all flesh" mean? Certainly not all believed. Yet, as far as He was concerned, all believed; and if people paid no attention to His words, the fault was not in the teacher, but in those who did not receive them.

2. But what is, Of all flesh? For certainly not all believed. Yet, for His part, all believed; and if men gave no heed to His words, the fault was not in the teacher, but in those who received them not.

That He should give eternal life to as many as You have given Him.

That He should give eternal life to as many as You have given Him.

If He also speaks here in a more human manner, do not be surprised. He does so both for the reasons I have already given, and to avoid saying anything great about Himself, since this was a stumbling block to His hearers because they did not yet imagine anything great concerning Him. John, for instance, when he speaks in his own person, does not do this, but raises his language to greater sublimity, saying, "All things were made by Him, and without Him was not anything made," and that He was Life, and that He was Light, and that He came to His own. John does not say that He would not have had power unless He had received it, but rather that He gave to others also power to become sons of God. And Paul likewise calls Him equal with God. But He Himself speaks in a more human way, saying, "That He should give eternal life to as many as You have given Him."

If here also He speaks in a more human manner, wonder not. For He does so both on account of the reasons I have given, and to avoid the saying anything great concerning Himself; since this was a stumblingblock to the hearers because as yet they imagined nothing great concerning Him. John, for example, when He speaks in his own person, does not so, but leads up his language to greater sublimity, saying, All things were made by Him, and without Him was not anything made c. i. 3, 4, 9, 11; and that He was Life; and that He was Light; and that He came to His own: he says not, that He would not have had power, had He not received it, but that He gave to others also power to become sons of God. And Paul in like manner calls Him equal with God. But He Himself asks in a more human way, saying thus, That He should give eternal life to as many as You have given Him. Philippians 2:6

John 17:3

The only true God, He says, to distinguish Him from those which are not gods, because He was about to send them to the Gentiles. But if they will not accept this, and because of this word alone they reject the Son from being true God, then as they continue with this reasoning they end up rejecting Him from being God at all. For He also says, "You do not seek the glory that comes from the only God" (John 5:44). So then, is the Son not God? But if the Son is God, and the Son of the Father who is called the Only God, it is clear that He also is true, and the Son of Him who is called the Only true God. Why, when Paul says, "Or I only and Barnabas" (1 Corinthians 9:6), does he exclude Barnabas? Not at all, because the word "only" is used to distinguish from others. And if He is not true God, how is He Truth? For Truth far surpasses what is true. What should we call someone who is not a true man, tell me? Should we not say he is not a man at all? So if the Son is not true God, how is He God? And how does He make us gods and sons if He is not true? But we have spoken more fully on these matters in another place, so let us turn to what follows.

The only true God, He says, by way of distinction from those which are not gods; for He was about to send them to the Gentiles. But if they will not allow this, but on account of this word only reject the Son from being true God, in this way as they proceed they reject Him from being God at all. For He also says, You seek not the glory which is from the only God. John 5:44 Well then; shall not the Son be God? But if the Son be God, and the Son of the Father who is called the Only God, it is clear that He also is true, and the Son of Him who is called the Only true God. Why, when Paul says, Or I only and Barnabas 1 Corinthians 9:6, does he exclude Barnabas? Not at all; for the only is put by way of distinction from others. And, if He be not true God, how is He Truth? For truth far surpasses what is true. What shall we call the not being a true man, tell me? Shall we not call it the not being a man at all? So if the Son is not true God, how is He God? And how makes He us gods and sons, if He is not true? But on these matters we have spoken more particularly in another place; wherefore let us apply ourselves to what follows.

John 17:4

I have finished the work which You gave Me to do.

I have finished the work which You gave Me that I should do it.

And yet the action was still only beginning, or rather had not yet begun. How then could He say, "I have finished"? Either He means that I have done all My part; or He is speaking of the future as if it had already happened; or, what one might say most of all, that everything was already accomplished because the root of blessings had been laid, whose fruits would certainly and necessarily follow, and because of His being present at and assisting in those things that would take place afterward. For this reason He says again in a condescending way, "which You gave Me." For if He had actually waited to hear and learn, this would have fallen far short of His glory. For that He came to this of His own will is clear from many passages. As when Paul says that He so loved us as to give Himself for us (Ephesians 5:2); and "He emptied Himself and took upon Him the form of a servant" (Philippians 2:7); and "As the Father has loved Me, so have I loved you" (John 15:9).

And yet the action was still but beginning, or rather was not yet beginning. How then said He, I have finished? Either He means, that I have done all My part; or He speaks of the future, as having already come to pass; or, which one may say most of all, that all was already effected, because the root of blessings had been laid, which fruits would certainly and necessarily follow, and from His being present at and assisting in those things which should take place after these. On this account He says again in a condescending way, Which You gave Me. For had He indeed waited to hear and learn, this would have fallen far short of His glory. For that He came to this of His own will, is clear from many passages. As when Paul says, that He so loved us, as to give Himself for us Ephesians 5:2; and, He emptied Himself, and took upon Him the form of a servant Philippians 2:7; and, As the Father has loved Me, so have I loved you. John 15:9

John 17:5

Where is that glory? For even if it made sense that He was not honored among men because of the flesh that covered Him, why does He seek to be glorified with the Father? What then does He say here? This statement refers to the Dispensation, since His fleshly nature had not yet been glorified, not having yet received incorruption or shared the kingly throne. Therefore He did not say on earth, but with You.

Where is that glory? For allowing that He was with reason unhonored among men, because of the covering which was put around Him; how seeks He class="greek">seekest Thou. " }}–> to be glorified with the Father? What then says He here? The saying refers to the Dispensation; since His fleshly nature had not yet been glorified, not having as yet enjoyed incorruption, nor shared the kingly throne. Therefore He said not on earth, but with You.

We will also enjoy this glory according to our measure, if we live soberly. This is why Paul says, "If so be that we suffer with Him, that we may also be glorified together" (Romans 8:17). Those who plot against themselves through laziness and sleep deserve countless tears when such glory is set before them. Even if there were no hell, they would be more miserable than anyone, because when it is in their power to reign and be glorified with the Son of God, they deprive themselves of such great blessings. Even if it were necessary to be cut in pieces, to die ten thousand deaths, to give up every day ten thousand lives and as many bodies, ought we not to submit to such things for such glory? But now we do not even despise money, which later we will leave behind whether we want to or not. We do not despise money, which brings us countless troubles, which stays here, which is not our own. For we are only stewards of what is not our own, even if we receive it from our fathers. But when there is also hell, and the worm that does not die, and the fire that is not quenched, and the gnashing of teeth, how, tell me, will we bear these things? How long will we refuse to see clearly, and spend everything on daily fights, arguments, and useless talk, feeding and cultivating the earth, fattening the body and neglecting the soul, making no account of necessary things but much fuss about things that are superfluous and unprofitable? And we build splendid tombs and buy expensive houses and drag around herds of all kinds of servants, and appoint different stewards, installing managers of lands, houses, and money, and managers of those managers—but as for our desolate soul, we care nothing about it. What will be the end of this? Don't we fill only one belly? Don't we clothe only one body? What is all this great bustle of business? Why and for what reason do we cut up and tear to pieces the one soul we have been assigned, attending to the service of such things, contriving for ourselves a grievous slavery? For whoever needs many things is the slave of many things, even if he seems to be their master. The lord is actually the slave of his own servants, and brings on himself another and heavier form of slavery. In another way too he is their slave, not daring to enter the marketplace, the bath, or the field without them. But they frequently go about in all directions without him. The one who seems to be master dares not go out from home if his slaves are not present, and if he sticks his head out of his house while unattended, he thinks he is being laughed at. Perhaps some laugh at us when we say this, yet for this very reason they deserve countless tears. To show that this is slavery, I would gladly ask you: would you want to need someone to put food to your mouth and apply the cup to your lips? Would you not consider such a situation worthy of tears? What if you continually required people to support you so you could walk—would you not think yourself pitiable and in this respect more wretched than anyone? So then you ought to feel the same way now. For it makes no difference whether one is enslaved in this way by irrational things or by men.

3. This glory we also shall enjoy according to our measure, if we be sober. Wherefore Paul says, If so be that we suffer with Him, that we may also be glorified together. Romans 8:17 Ten thousand tears then do they merit, who through sluggishness and sleep plot against themselves when such glory is set before them; and, were there no hell, they would be more wretched than any, who, when it is in their power to reign and to be glorified with the Son of God, deprive themselves of so great blessings. Since if it were necessary to be cut in pieces, if to die ten thousand deaths, if to give up every day ten thousand lives and as many bodies, ought we not to submit to such things for such glory? But now we do not even despise money, which hereafter, though unwilling, we shall leave: we do not despise money, which brings about us ten thousand mischiefs, which remains here, which is not our own. For we are but stewards of that which is not our own, although we receive it from our fathers. But when there is hell besides, and the worm that dies not, and the fire that is not quenched, and the gnashing of teeth, how, tell me, shall we bear these things? How long will we refuse to see clearly, and spend our all on daily fightings, and contentions, and unprofitable talk, feeding, cultivating earth, fattening the body and neglecting the soul, making no account of necessary things, but much care about things superfluous and unprofitable? And we build splendid tombs, and buy costly houses, and draw about with us herds of all kinds of servants, and devise different stewards, appointing managers of lands, of houses, of money, and managers of those managers; but as to our desolate soul, we care nothing for that. And what will be the limit to this? Is it not one belly that we fill, is it not one body that we clothe? What is this great bustle of business? Why and wherefore do we cut up and tear to pieces the one soul, which we have had assigned to us, in attending to the service of such things, contriving for ourselves a grievous slavery? For he who needs many things is the slave of many things, although he seem to be their master. Since the lord is the slave even of his domestics, and brings in another and a heavier mode of service; and in another way also he is their slave, not daring without them to enter the agora, nor the bath, nor the field, but they frequently go about in all directions without him. He who seems to be master, dares not, if his slaves be not present, to go forth from home, and if while unattended he do but put his head out of his house, he thinks that he is laughed at. Perhaps some laugh at us when we say this, yet on this very account they would be deserving of ten thousand tears. For to show that this is slavery, I would gladly ask you, would you wish to need some one to put the morsel to your mouth, and to apply the cup to your lips? Would you not deem such a service worthy of tears? What if you required continually supporters to enable you to walk, would you not think yourself pitiable, and in this respect more wretched than any? So then you ought to be disposed now. For it matters nothing whether one is so treated by irrational things, or by men.

Why, tell me, don't the Angels differ from us in this respect: that they don't need as many things as we do? Therefore, the less we need, the more we are advancing toward them; the more we need, the more we sink down to this perishable life. And so you may learn that these things are true, ask those who have grown old which life they consider happiest—when they were helplessly mastered by their needs, or now when they are masters of these things? We have mentioned these people because those who are intoxicated with youth don't even recognize the excess of their slavery. For what about those who have a fever—do they call themselves happy when, being very thirsty, they drink much and need even more, or when, having recovered their health, they are free from the desire? Do you see that in every case needing much is pitiable, far removed from true wisdom, and an intensification of slavery and desire? Why then do we voluntarily increase our own wretchedness? For tell me, if it were possible to live unharmed without a roof or walls, wouldn't you prefer this? Why then do you increase the signs of your weakness? Don't we call Adam happy for this very reason, that he needed nothing—no house, no clothes? Yes, someone says, but now we need them. Why then do we make our need greater? If many people cut back on many things that are actually needed (I mean servants, houses, and money), what excuse can we have if we exceed what is needed? The more you surround yourself with, the more enslaved you become; for by whatever proportion you require more, by that proportion you have encroached upon your freedom. For absolute freedom is to need nothing at all; the next level is to need little; and this the Angels and their imitators especially possess. But for people to achieve this while remaining in a mortal body—consider how great a praise this deserves. This is also what Paul said when writing to the Corinthians: "But I spare you," and "lest such should have trouble in the flesh." Riches are called usable things so that we may use them rightly, not keep and bury them; for this is not to possess them, but to be possessed by them. For if we are going to make this our aim—how to multiply them, rather than how to employ them rightly—the order is reversed, and they possess us, not we them. Let us then free ourselves from this grievous bondage and at last become free. Why do we devise ten thousand different chains for ourselves? Isn't the bond of nature enough for you, and the necessity of life, and the crowd of ten thousand affairs, without you also twisting other nets for yourself and putting them around your feet? And when will you lay hold on heaven and be able to stand on that height? For it is a great thing, a great thing, that even having cut through all these cords, you should be able to lay hold on the city which is above. There are so many other hindrances; so that we may conquer all of them, let us keep to the middle way, and having put away superfluities, let us keep to what is necessary. Thus we shall lay hold on eternal life, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory forever and ever. Amen.

Why, tell me, do not the Angels differ from us in this respect, that they do not want so many things as we do? Therefore the less we need, the more we are on our way to them; the more we need, the more we sink down to this perishable life. And that you may learn that these things are so, ask those who have grown old which life they deem happiest, that when they were helplessly mastered, or now when they are masters of these things? We have mentioned these persons, because those who are intoxicated with youth, do not even know the excess of their slavery. For what of those in fever, do they call themselves happy when, thirsting much, they drink much and need more, or when, having recovered their health, they are free from the desire? Do you see that in every instance the needing much is pitiable, and far apart from true wisdom, and an aggravation of slavery and desire? Why then do we voluntarily increase to ourselves wretchedness? For, tell me, if it were possible to live uninjured without roof or walls, would you not prefer this; wherefore then do you increase the signs of your weakness? Do we not for this call Adam happy, that he needed nothing, no house, no clothes? Yes, says some one, but now we are in need of them. Why then do we make our need greater? If many persons curtail many of the things actually needed, (servants, I mean, and houses, and money,) what excuse can we have if we overstep the need? The more you put about you, the more slavish do you become; for by whatever proportion you require more, in that proportion you have trenched upon your freedom. For absolute freedom is, to want nothing at all; the next is, to want little; and this the Angels and their imitators especially possess. But for men to succeed in this while tarrying in a mortal body, think how great praise this has. This also Paul said, when writing to the Corinthians, But I spare you, and, lest such should have trouble in the flesh. 1 Corinthians 7:28 Riches are called usables, that we may use them rightly, and not keep and bury them; for this is not to possess them, but to be possessed by them. Since if we are going to make this our aim how to multiply them, not that we may employ them rightly, the order is reversed, and they possess us, not we them. Let us then free ourselves from this grievous bondage, and at last become free. Why do we devise ten thousand different chains for ourselves? Is not the bond of nature enough for you, and the necessity of life, and the crowd of ten thousand affairs, but do you twine also other nets for yourself, and put them about your feet? And when will you lay hold on heaven, and be able to stand on that height? For a great thing, a great thing is it, that even having cut asunder all these cords, you should be able to lay hold on the city which is above. So many other hindrances are there; all which that we may conquer, let us keep to the mean estate [and having put away superfluities, let us keep to what is necessary.] Thus shall we lay hold on eternal life, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory for ever and ever. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 79 — John 16:16-17

Homily 79 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240179.htm>.

Contents · 11 chapters
  1. John 16:16-17
  2. John 16:20
  3. John 16:21
  4. John 16:22-23
  5. John 16:24
  6. John 16:25
  7. John 16:26
  8. John 16:27-28
  9. John 16:30
  10. John 16:32
  11. John 16:33

John 16:16-17

Nothing is as effective at crushing the soul when it is troubled and gripped by deep despondency as continually dwelling on words that cause pain. Why then did Christ, after saying "I am going" and "From now on I will not speak with you," keep returning to the same subject, saying "A little while, and you will not see Me, because I am going to Him who sent Me"? When He had restored them through His words about the Spirit, He again undermines their courage. Why does He do this? He is testing their feelings and making them more tested and approved, and He is training them through hearing painful things to bear separation from Him with courage. For those who had practiced this when it was spoken in words were likely to bear it easily in actual events later on. And if one looks closely, this very thing is a consolation—the statement that "I am going to the Father." For it is the expression of One who declares that He will not perish, but that His end is a kind of relocation. He also adds another consolation. For He does not merely say "A little while, and you will not see Me," but also "A little while, and you will see Me," showing that He will both come to them again, and that their separation would be only for a short time, while His presence with them would be continuous. However, they did not understand this. From this one may reasonably wonder how, after having often heard these things, they are confused, as though they had heard nothing. How then is it that they did not understand? It was either because of grief, as I suppose, for that drove what was said from their understanding, or because of the obscurity of the words. For He seemed to them to be setting forth two contraries, which were not contrary. "If," one of them says, "we will see You, where are You going? And if You are going, how will we see You?" Therefore they say, "We cannot tell what He is saying." That He was about to depart, they knew; but they did not know that He would soon come to them. For this reason He rebukes them, because they did not understand His statement. For, desiring to instill in them the teaching concerning His death, what does He say?

1. Nothing is wont so to cast down the soul that is anguished and possessed by deep despondency, as when words which cause pain are continually dwelt upon. Why then did Christ, after saying, I go, and, Hereafter I will not speak with you, continually dwell on the same subject, saying, A little while, and you shall not see Me, because I go to Him that sent Me? When He had recovered them by His words concerning the Spirit, He again casts down their courage. Wherefore does He this? He tests their feelings, and renders them more proved, and well accustoms them by hearing sad things, manfully to bear separation from Him; for they who had practiced this when spoken of in words, were likely in actions also, easily to bear it afterwards. And if one enquire closely, this very thing is a consolation, the saying that, I go to the Father. For it is the expression of One, who declares that He shall not perish, but that His end is a kind of translation. He adds too another consolation; for He says not merely, A little while, and you shall not see Me, but also, A little while, and you shall see Me; showing that He will both come to them again, and that their separation would be but for a little while, and His presence with them continual. This, however, they did not understand. Whence one may with reason wonder how, after having often heard these things, they doubt, as though they had heard nothing. How then is it that they did not understand? It was either through grief, as I suppose, for that drove what was said from their understanding; or through the obscurity of the words. Because He seemed to them to set forth two contraries, which were not contrary. If, says one of them, we shall see You, where are You going? And if You go, how shall we see You? Therefore they say, We cannot tell what He says. That He was about to depart, they knew; but they knew not that He would shortly come to them. On which account He rebukes them, because they did not understand His saying. For, desiring to instill in them the doctrine concerning His death, what says He?

John 16:20

Because they did not want His death, they quickly came to believe that He would not die, and then when they heard that He would die, they were confused and did not know what "a little while" meant. So He says, "You will mourn and lament."

Because by reason of their not desiring His death, they quickly ran into the belief that He would not die, and then when they heard that He would die, cast about, not knowing what that little meant, He says, You shall mourn and lament.

But your sorrow will be turned into joy. Then, having shown that joy comes after grief, that grief gives birth to joy, and that grief is short while the pleasure is endless, He moves to a common example. And what does He say?

But your sorrow shall be turned into joy. Then having shown that after grief comes joy, and that grief genders joy, and that grief is short, but the pleasure endless, He passes to a common example; and what says He?

John 16:21

And He has used a comparison that the Prophets also use continually, likening distress to the severe pains of childbirth. But what He says is like this: Labor pains will seize you, but the pain of childbirth is the cause of joy. He is both confirming His words about the Resurrection and showing that departing from this life is like passing from the womb into the light of day. It is as if He had said, Do not be surprised that I bring you to your benefit through such sorrow, since even a mother, to become a mother, passes through pain in the same way. Here He also implies something mystical: that He has broken the labor pains of death and caused a new man to be born from them. And He did not say only that the pain will pass away, but that she does not even remember it, so great is the joy that follows. So it will also be with the Saints. And yet the woman does not rejoice because a human being has come into the world, but because a son has been born to her. If it were otherwise, nothing would prevent a barren woman from rejoicing over another woman who gives birth. Why then did He speak this way? Because He introduced this example only for this purpose: to show that sorrow is for a time, but joy is lasting; to show that death is a passage into life; and to show the great benefit of their sufferings. He did not say a child has been born, but a man. For in my view He here alludes to His own Resurrection, and that He would be born not into that death which brought the labor pain, but into the Kingdom. Therefore He did not say a child has been born to her, but a man has been born into the world.

And He has used a comparison which the Prophets also use continually, likening despondencies to the exceeding pains of childbirth. But what He says is of this kind: Travail pains shall lay hold on you, but the pang of childbirth is the cause of joy; both confirming His words relative to the Resurrection, and showing that the departing hence is like passing from the womb into the light of day. As though He had said, Marvel not that I bring you to your advantage through such sorrow, since even a mother to become a mother, passes in like manner through pain. Here also He implies something mystical, that He has loosened the travail pangs of death, and caused a new man to be born of them. And He said not, that the pain shall pass away only, but, she does not even remember it, so great is the joy which succeeds; so also shall it be with the Saints. And yet the woman does not rejoice because a man has come into the world, but because a son has been born to her; since, had this been the case, nothing would have hindered the barren from rejoicing over another who bears. Why then spoke He thus? Because He introduced this example for this purpose only, to show that sorrow is for a season, but joy lasting: and to show that (death) is a translation unto life; and to show the great profit of their pangs. He said not, a child has been born, but, A man. For to my mind He here alludes to His own Resurrection, and that He should be born not unto that death which bare the birth-pang, but unto the Kingdom. Therefore He said not, a child has been born unto her, but, A man has been born into the world.

John 16:22-23

Again, He proves nothing else by these words except that He is from God. For then, from that time forward, you will know all things. But what does "You shall not ask Me" mean? You will need no intercessor, but it will be sufficient for you to call on My Name, and in this way obtain all things.

Again He proves nothing else by these words, but that He is from God. For then you shall for the time to come know all things. But what is, You shall not ask Me? You shall need no intercessor, but it is sufficient that you call on My Name, and so gain all things.

Truly, truly, I say to you, whatever you ask My Father in My Name.

Verily, verily, I say unto you, Whatsoever you shall ask My Father in My Name.

He demonstrates the power of His Name, since even without being seen or called upon, but only named, He makes us approved by the Father. But where has this taken place? Where they say, "Lord, look at their threats, and grant to Your servants that they may speak Your word with boldness" (Acts 4:29-31), and work miracles in Your Name. And the place where they were was shaken.

He shows the power of His Name, if at least being neither seen nor called upon, but only named, He even makes us approved by the Father. But where has this taken place? Where they say, Lord, behold their threatenings, and grant unto Your servants that with boldness they may speak Your word Acts 4:29-31, and work miracles in Your Name. And the place was shaken where they were.

John 16:24

Therefore He shows it is good that He should leave, since up to this point they had asked for nothing, but afterward they would receive everything they asked for. For do not think that because I will no longer be with you, you are abandoned; My Name will give you greater boldness. Since the words He had spoken had been obscure, He says,

2. Hence He shows it to be good that He should depart, if hitherto they had asked nothing, and if then they should receive all things whatsoever they should ask. For do not suppose, because I shall no longer be with you, that you are deserted; My Name shall give you greater boldness. Since then the words which He had used had been veiled, He says,

John 16:25

There will be a time when you will know all things clearly. He is speaking of the time of the Resurrection. Then,

There shall be a time when you shall know all things clearly. He speaks of the time of the Resurrection. Then,

I will tell you plainly about the Father.

I shall tell you plainly of the Father.

For He was with them and talked with them forty days, being assembled with them and speaking of the things concerning the kingdom of God (Acts 1:3-4)—because now you are afraid and not paying attention to my words; but then when you see me risen again and talk with me, you will be able to learn everything plainly, for the Father himself will love you when your faith in me has been made firm.

(For He was with them, and talked with them forty days, being assembled with them, and speaking of the things concerning the kingdom of God Acts 1:3-4)– because now being in fear, you give no heed to My words; but then when you see Me risen again, and converse with Me, you will be able to learn all things plainly, for the Father Himself will love you, when your faith in Me has been made firm.

John 16:26

Your love for Me is sufficient to serve as your advocate.

Your love for Me suffices to be your advocate.

John 16:27-28

For since His teaching about the Resurrection, and along with this, the hearing that I came out from God and I am going there, gave them no small comfort, He continually addresses these things. He gave a pledge, first, that they were right in believing in Him; second, that they would be safe. When He said, "A little while, and you shall not see Me; and again a little while, and you shall see Me" (John 16:17), they reasonably did not understand Him. But now it is no longer so. What then does "You shall not ask Me" mean? You shall not say, "Show us the Father," and, "Where are You going?" for you shall know all knowledge, and the Father shall be favorably disposed toward you just as I am. It was this especially which made them breathe again, the learning that they would be the Father's friends, which is why they say,

For since His discourse concerning the Resurrection, and together with this, the hearing that I came out from God, and there I go, gave them no common comfort, He continually handles these things. He gave a pledge, in the first place, that they were right in believing on Him; in the second, that they should be in safety. When therefore He said, A little while, and you shall not see Me; and again a little while, and you shall see Me John 16:17, they with reason did not understand Him. But now it is no longer so. What then is, You shall not ask Me? You shall not say, 'Show us the Father,' and, 'Where are You going?' for you shall know all knowledge, and the Father shall be disposed towards you even as I am. It was this especially which made them breathe again, the learning that they should be the Father's friends wherefore they say,

John 16:30

Do you see that He responded to what was secretly dwelling in their minds?

Do you see that He made answer to what was secretly harboring in their minds?

And you do not need anyone to ask you questions.

And needest not that any man should ask You.

That is, before hearing, You know the things that made us stumble, and You have given us rest, since You have said, 'The Father loves you, because you have loved Me.' After so many and so great matters, they say, "Now we know." Do you see how imperfect their state still was? Then, when they say "Now we know" as though conferring a favor upon Him, He replies: You still require many other things to come to perfection; nothing has yet been achieved by you. You will soon betray Me to My enemies, and such fear will seize you that you will not even be able to stay together with one another, yet I will suffer nothing dreadful from this. Do you see again how condescending His speech is? And indeed He makes this a charge against them, that they continually needed condescension. For when they say, "Look, now You speak plainly, and speak no parable" (John 16:29), and therefore we believe You, He shows them that now, when they believe, they do not yet truly believe, and He does not accept their words. He says this, referring them to another time. But the,

That is, Before hearing, You know the things which made us stumble, and You have given us rest, since You have said, 'The Father loves you, because you have loved Me.' After so many and so great matters, they say, Now we know. Do you see in what an imperfect state they were? Then, when, as though conferring a favor upon Him, they say, Now we know, He replies, You still require many other things to come to perfection; nothing is as yet achieved by you. You shall presently betray Me to My enemies, and such fear shall seize you, that you shall not even be able to retire one with another, yet from this I shall suffer nothing dreadful. Do you see again how con descending His speech is? And indeed He makes this a charge against them, that they continually needed condescension. For when they say, Lo, now You speak plainly, and speakest no parable John 16:29, and therefore we believe You, He shows them that now, when they believe, they do not yet believe, neither does He accept their words. This He says, referring them to another season. But the,

John 16:32

He has again attributed this to them, for they wanted to learn this everywhere. Then, to show that He did not give them perfect knowledge by saying this, but so that their reason might not rebel (for it was likely that they might form some human ideas and think that they would not receive any assistance from Him), He says,

He has again put on their account; for this they everywhere wished to learn. Then, to show that He did not give them perfect knowledge by saying this, but in order that their reason might not rebel, (for it was probable that they might form some human ideas, and think that they should not enjoy any assistance from Him,) He says,

John 16:33

That is, you should not push Me out of your thoughts, but receive Me. So let no one twist these words into a doctrine; they are spoken for our comfort and love. For even when you suffer the things I have mentioned, your troubles will not end there. As long as you are in the world you will have sorrow, not only now when I am betrayed, but also afterward. But lift up your minds, for you will suffer nothing terrible. When the master has conquered his enemies, the disciples must not lose heart. And how, tell me, have You 'conquered the world'? I have already told you that I have cast down its ruler, but you will know this later, when all things yield and give way to you.

That is, that you should not cast Me from your thoughts, but receive Me. Let no one, then, drag these words into a doctrine; they are spoken for our comfort and love. For not even when we suffer such things as I have mentioned shall your troubles stop there, but as long as you are in the world you shall have sorrow, not only now when I am betrayed, but also afterwards. But rouse your minds, for you shall suffer nothing terrible. When the master has gotten the better of his enemies, the disciples must not despond. And how, tell me, have You 'conquered the world'? I have told you already, that I have cast down its ruler, but you shall know hereafter, when all things yield and give place to you.

But we are also allowed to conquer by looking to the Author of our faith and walking on the road He opened for us. So death will not gain mastery over us either. "What then, shall we not die?" someone asks. Well, this very fact makes it clear that death will not master us. A champion is truly glorious not when he has avoided fighting his opponent, but when he has fought and is not held down by him. We are therefore not mortal because of our struggle with death, but immortal because of our victory. We would have been mortal if we had remained with death forever. Just as I would not call the longest-living animals immortal simply because they avoid death for a long time, I would not call someone who rises after death mortal just because death dissolved him. For tell me, if a man blushes briefly, would we say he was always red? Of course not, because the action is not a permanent state. If someone turns pale, would we call him jaundiced? No, because the condition is only temporary. And so you would not call someone mortal who has been in death's hands for only a short time. In this way we might even speak of those who sleep, for they are in a sense dead and inactive. But does death corrupt our bodies? What of it? It does not leave them in corruption, but makes them better. Let us then conquer the world, let us run toward immortality, let us follow our King, let us also set up a trophy, let us despise the world's pleasures. We need no effort to do this—let us transfer our souls to heaven, and the whole world is conquered. If you do not desire it, it is conquered; if you mock it, it is defeated. We are strangers and sojourners, so let us not grieve over any of its painful things. For if you had come from a famous country and from distinguished ancestors and gone to some distant land where you were unknown to anyone, having with you neither servants nor wealth, and someone insulted you, you would not grieve as if you had suffered these things at home. For knowing clearly that you were in a strange and foreign land would convince you to bear everything easily and to despise hunger, thirst, and any suffering whatever. Consider this now as well, that you are a stranger and sojourner, and let nothing disturb you in this foreign land. For you have a City whose Artificer and Creator is God, and the sojourn itself is only for a short time. Let whoever wishes strike, insult, revile—we are in a strange land and live as temporary residents. The dreadful thing would be to suffer this way in our own country, before our fellow citizens—that is the greatest disgrace and loss. For if a man is where no one knows him, he endures everything easily, because insult becomes more bitter when those who offer it know what they are doing. For instance, if a man insults the governor, knowing he is governor, then the insult is bitter; but if he insults him thinking he is a private citizen, he cannot even touch the one who receives the insult. Let us reason the same way. For our revilers do not know what we are—that we are citizens of heaven, registered in the country above, fellow-choristers of the Cherubim. So let us not grieve or consider their insult to be an insult. If they had known, they would not have insulted us. Do they think we are poor and insignificant? Let us not count this as an insult either. For tell me, if a traveler had arrived ahead of his servants and was sitting for a short time in the inn waiting for them, and then the innkeeper or some other travelers behaved rudely toward him and reviled him, would he not laugh at their ignorance? Would their mistake not actually give him pleasure? Would he not feel satisfaction as if someone else, not he himself, were being insulted? Let us behave the same way. We too sit in an inn, waiting for our friends who travel the same road. When we are all gathered together, then they will know whom they insulted. Then these men will hang their heads; then they will say, "This is he whom we fools had in derision" (Wisdom 5:3).

3. But it is permitted to us also to conquer, looking to the Author of our faith, and walking on that road which He cut for us. So neither shall death get the mastery of us. What then, shall we not die? says some one. Why, from this very thing it is clear that he shall not gain the mastery over us. The champion truly will then be glorious, not when he has not closed with his opponent, but when having closed he is not holden by him. We therefore are not mortal, because of our struggle with death, but immortal, because of our victory; then should we have been mortal, had we remained with him always. As then I should not call the longest-lived animals immortal, although they long remain free from death, so neither him who shall rise after death mortal, because he is dissolved by death. For, tell me, if a man blush a little, should we say that he was continually ruddy? Not so, for the action is not a habit. If one become pale, should we call him jaundiced? No, for the affection is but temporary. And so you would not call him mortal, who has been for but a short time in the hands of death. Since in this way we may speak of those who sleep, for they are dead, so to say, and without action. But does death corrupt our bodies? What of that? It is not that they may remain in corruption, but that they be made better. Let us then conquer the world, let us run to immortality, let us follow our King, let us too set up a trophy, let us despise the world's pleasures. We need no toil to do so; let us transfer our souls to heaven, and all the world is conquered. If you desire it not, it is conquered; if you deride it, it is worsted. Strangers are we and sojourners, let us then not grieve at any of its painful things. For if, being sprung from a renowned country, and from illustrious ancestors, you had gone into some distant land, being known to no one, having with you neither servants nor wealth, and then some one had insulted you, you would not grieve as though you had suffered these things at home. For the knowing clearly that you were in a strange and foreign land, would persuade you to bear all easily, and to despise hunger, and thirst, and any suffering whatever. Consider this also now, that you are a stranger and a sojourner, and let nothing disturb you in this foreign land; for you have a City whose Artificer and Creator is God, and the sojourning itself is but for a short and little time. Let whoever will strike, insult, revile; we are in a strange land, and live but meanly; the dreadful thing would be, to suffer so in our own country, before our fellow citizens, then is the greatest unseemliness and loss. For if a man be where he had none that knows him, he endures all easily, because insult becomes more grievous from the intention of those who offer it. For instance, if a man insult the governor, knowing that he is governor, then the insult is bitter; but if he insult, supposing him to be a private man, he cannot even touch him who undergoes the insult. So let us reason also. For neither do our revilers know what we are, as, that we are citizens of heaven, registered for the country which is above, fellow-choristers of the Cherubim. Let us not then grieve nor deem their insult to be insult; had they known, they would not have insulted us. Do they deem us poor and mean? Neither let us count this an insult. For tell me, if a traveler having got before his servants, were sitting a little space in the inn waiting for them, and then the innkeeper, or some travelers, should behave rudely to him, and revile him, would he not laugh at the other's ignorance? Would not their mistake rather give him pleasure? Would he not feel a satisfaction as though not he but some one else were insulted? Let us too behave thus. We too sit in an inn, waiting for our friends who travel the same road; when we are all collected, then they shall know whom they insult. These men then shall hang their heads; then they shall say, This is he whom we fools had in derision. Wisdom 5:3

Let us comfort ourselves with these two truths: first, that we are not truly insulted, since they do not know who we are, and second, that if we want satisfaction, they will later give us a most bitter one. But God forbid that anyone should have such a cruel and inhuman soul. What if we are insulted by our own relatives? This is what seems burdensome. No, this is actually the lighter thing. Why? Because we do not bear insults from those we love in the same way as we bear them from strangers. For instance, when consoling those who have been wronged, we often say, "It is a brother who has wronged you, bear it nobly; it is a father; it is an uncle." But if the name of father and brother moves you to patience, how much more if I name a relationship more intimate than these? For we are not only brothers to one another, but also members, and one body. Now if the name of brother moves you, how much more that of member. Have you not heard that pagan proverb which says that we should keep friends despite their faults? Have you not heard Paul say, "Bear one another's burdens"? Do you not see lovers? For I am forced, since I cannot draw an example from you, to bring my argument to that illustration. Paul also does this, saying, "Furthermore we have had fathers in our flesh who corrected us, and we gave them reverence." Or rather, what he says to the Romans is more fitting: "As you have yielded your members servants to uncleanness and to iniquity unto iniquity, even so now yield your members servants to righteousness." For this reason let us confidently use this illustration. Now do you not observe lovers, what miseries they suffer when inflamed with desire for prostitutes—cuffed, beaten, and laughed at, enduring a prostitute who turns away from and insults them in countless ways? Yet if they see just once anything sweet or gentle, all is well with them, all former things are forgotten, everything proceeds smoothly, whether it be poverty, sickness, or anything else. For they consider their own life miserable or blessed according to how the woman they love treats them. They know nothing of worldly honor or disgrace, but even if someone insults them, they bear everything easily because of the great pleasure and delight they receive from her. And though she reviles them, though she spits in their face, they think, when enduring this, that they are being showered with roses. And what wonder if such are their feelings toward her person? For they think her very house more splendid than any, though it be made of mud, though it be falling down. But why speak of walls? When they even see the places she frequents in the evening, they are excited. Allow me now to speak the following using the Apostle's words. As he says, "As you have yielded your members servants to uncleanness, so yield your members servants unto righteousness," so in the same manner now I say: as we have loved these women, let us love one another, and we shall not think that we suffer anything terrible. And why do I say, one another? Let us love God in this way. Do you recoil when you hear that I require as much love in the case of God as we have shown toward a prostitute? But I recoil that we do not show even this much. And, if you will, let us continue the argument, though what is said is very painful. The woman who is loved promises her lovers nothing good, but dishonor, shame, and insolence. For this is what devotion to a prostitute makes a man: ridiculous, shameful, dishonored. But God promises us heaven and the good things that are in heaven. He has made us sons and brothers of the Only-begotten, and has given you countless things while living, and when you die, resurrection, and promises that He will give us such good things as it is not even possible to imagine, and makes us honored and revered. Again, that woman compels her lovers to spend all their wealth for the pit and for destruction; but God commands us to sow in heaven, and gives us a hundredfold and eternal life. Again, she uses her lover like a slave, giving commands more harshly than any tyrant; but God says, "I no longer call you servants, but friends."

4. With these two things then let us comfort ourselves, that we are not insulted, for they know not who we are, and that, if we wish to obtain satisfaction, they shall hereafter give us a most bitter one. But God forbid that any should have a soul so cruel and inhuman. What then if we be insulted by our kinsmen? For this is the burdensome thing. Nay, this is the light thing. Why, pray? Because we do not bear those whom we love when they insult us, in the same way as we bear those whom we do not know. For instance, in consoling those who have been injured, we often say, It is a brother who has injured you, bear it nobly; it is a father; it is an uncle. But if the name of father and brother puts you to shame, much more if I name to you a relationship more intimate than these; for we are not only brethren one to another, but also members, and one body. Now if the name of brother shame you, much more that of member. Have you not heard that Gentile proverb, which says, that it behooves to keep friends with their defects? Have you not heard Paul say, Bear ye one another's burdens? Do you see not lovers? For I am compelled, since I cannot draw an instance from you, to bring my discourse to that ground of argument. This also Paul does, thus saying, Furthermore we have had fathers in our flesh, which corrected us, and we gave them reverence. Hebrews 12:9 Or rather, that is more apt which he says to the Romans, As you have yielded your members servants to uncleanness and to iniquity unto iniquity, even so now yield your members servants to righteousness. For this reason let us confidently keep hold of the illustration. Now do you not observe lovers, what miseries these suffer when inflamed with desire for harlots, cuffed, beaten, and laughed at, enduring a harlot, who turns away from and insults them in ten thousand ways; yet if they see but once anything sweet or gentle, all is well to do with them, all former things are gone, all goes on with a fair wind, be it poverty, be it sickness, be it anything else besides these. For they count their own life as miserable or blessed, according as they may have her whom they love disposed towards them. They know nothing of mortal honor or disgrace, but even if one insult, they bear all easily through the great pleasure and delight which they receive from her; and though she revile, though she spit in their face, they think, when they are enduring this, that they are being pelted with roses. And what wonder, if such are their feelings as to her person? For her very house they think to be more splendid than any, though it be but of mud, though it be falling down. But why speak I of walls? When they even see the places which they frequent in the evening, they are excited. Allow me now for what follows to speak the word of the Apostle. As he says, As you have yielded your members servants to uncleanness, so yield your members servants unto righteousness; so in like manner now I say, as we have loved these women, let us love one another, and we shall not think that we suffer anything terrible. And why say I, one another? Let us so love God. Do ye shudder, when you hear that I require as much love in the case of God, as we have shown towards a harlot? But I shudder that we do not show even thus much. And, if you will, let us go on with the argument, though what is said be very painful. The woman beloved promises her lovers nothing good, but dishonor, shame, and insolence. For this is what the waiting upon a harlot makes a man, ridiculous, shameful, dishonored. But God promises us heaven, and the good things which are in heaven; He has made us sons, and brethren of the Only-begotten, and has given you ten thousand things while living, and when you die, resurrection, and promises that He will give us such good things as it is not possible even to imagine, and makes us honored and revered. Again, that woman compels her lovers to spend all their substance for the pit and for destruction; but God bids us sow the heaven, and gives us an hundred-fold, and eternal life. Again, she uses her lover like a slave, giving commands more hardly than any tyrant; but God says, I no longer call you servants, but friends. John 15:15

Have you seen how extreme both the evils here and the blessings there are? What follows from this? For the sake of this woman, many men stay awake and readily obey whatever she commands. They give up house, father, mother, friends, money, and patronage, leaving everything that belongs to them in want and desolation. But for the sake of God—or rather for our own sake—we often refuse to spend even a third of our possessions. Instead, we look at the hungry and overlook them, we run past the naked and do not even speak a word to them. Yet lovers, if they see even a little servant girl belonging to their mistress, even if she is a barbarian, will stand in the middle of the marketplace and talk with her as if they were proud and glad to do so, pouring out an endless stream of words. For her sake they count their entire life as nothing and consider rulers and power as nothing—all who have experienced this disease know this—and they thank her more when she commands them than others do when they serve. Is there not good reason for hell to exist? Are there not good reasons for countless punishments? Let us then become sober and devote to the service of God as much, or half, or even a third of what others give to the prostitute. Perhaps you shudder again at this—I do too. But I want you to shudder not just at the words but at the actions themselves. As it is, our hearts are set in order here, but we go out and throw it all away. What then do we gain? For there, if spending money is required, no one complains of poverty but even borrows money to give, even when beaten. But here, if we merely mention almsgiving, people bring up children, wife, house, patronage, and ten thousand excuses. But someone says the pleasure is great there. This is exactly what I lament and mourn. What if I show that the pleasure here is greater? For there, shame, insult, and expense cut away no small part of the pleasure, and after these come quarreling and enmity. But here there is nothing of that kind. What is there, tell me, equal to this pleasure: to sit expecting heaven and the kingdom there, the glory of the saints, and the endless life? But someone says these things are only expected, while the others are experienced. What kind of experience? Do you want me to tell you about pleasures that are also experienced here? Consider what freedom you enjoy and how you fear and tremble before no one when you live with virtue—neither enemy, plotter, informer, rival in reputation or love, envious person, poverty, sickness, nor any other human thing. But there, even if ten thousand things go according to your wishes and riches flow in like a fountain, the war with rivals, the plots, and the ambushes will make the life of someone who wallows with those women more miserable than anyone else's. For when that abominable woman is haughty and insolent, you must even kindle a quarrel to flatter her. This is more grievous than ten thousand deaths, more intolerable than any punishment. But here there is nothing of the kind. For it says the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, and peace. Here there is no quarreling, no inappropriate financial expense, no disgrace combined with expense. And if you give just a penny, a loaf of bread, or a cup of cold water, He will be greatly obliged to you, and He does nothing to cause you pain or grief, but does everything to make you glorious and free you from all shame. What defense then will we have? What pardon will we gain if we abandon these things and give ourselves over to the opposite, voluntarily casting ourselves into the furnace burning with fire? Therefore I urge those who are sick with this disease to recover themselves and return to health, and not allow themselves to fall into despair. Since that son was also in a far more grievous state than this, yet when he returned to his father's house, he came back to his former honor and appeared more glorious than the one who had always been pleasing. Let us also imitate him, and by returning to our Father, even if it is late, let us depart from that captivity and transfer ourselves to freedom, so that we may enjoy the kingdom of heaven, through the grace and loving-kindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom with the Father and the Holy Spirit be glory, forever and ever. Amen.

5. Have ye seen the excess both of the evils here and the blessings there? What then comes next? For this woman's sake, many lie awake, and whatever she commands, readily obey; give up house, and father, and mother, and friends, and money, and patronage, and leave all that belongs to them in want and desolation; but for the sake of God, or rather for the sake of ourselves, we often do not choose to expend even the third portion of our substance, but we look on the hungry, we overlook him, and run past the naked, and do not even bestow a word upon him. But the lovers, if they see but a little servant girl of their mistress, and her a barbarian, they stand in the middle of the market-place, and talk with her, as if they were proud and glad to do so, unrolling an interminable round of words; and for her sake they count all their living as nothing, deem rulers and rule nothing, (they know it, all who have had experience of the malady,) and thank her more when she commands, than others when they serve. Is there not with good reason a hell? Are there not with good reason ten thousand punishments? Let us then become sober, let us apply to the service of God as much, or half, or even the third part of what others supply to the harlot. Perhaps again ye shudder; for so do I myself. But I would not that you should shudder at words only, but at the actions; as it is, here indeed our hearts are made orderly, but we go forth and cast all away. What then is the gain? For there, if it be required to spend money, no one laments his poverty, but even borrows it to give, perchance, when smitten. But here, if we do but mention almsgiving, they pretend to us children, and wife, and house, and patronage, and ten thousand excuses. But, says some one, the pleasure is great there. This it is that I lament and mourn. What if I show that the pleasure here is greater? For there shame, and insult, and expense, cut away no little of the pleasure, and after these the quarreling and enmity; but here there is nothing of the kind. What is there, tell me, equal to this pleasure, to sit expecting heaven and the kingdom there, and the glory of the saints, and the life that is endless? But these things, says some one, are in expectation, the others in experience. What kind of experience? Will you that I tell you the pleasures which are here also by experience? Consider what freedom you enjoy, and how you fear and tremble at no man when you live in company with virtue, neither enemy, nor plotter, nor informer, nor rival in credit or in love, nor envious person, nor poverty, nor sickness, nor any other human thing. But there, although ten thousand things be according to your mind, though riches flow in as from a fountain, yet the war with rivals, and the plots, and ambuscades, will make more miserable than any the life of him who wallows with those women. For when that abominable one is haughty, and insolent, you needs must kindle quarrel to flatter her. This therefore is more grievous than ten thousand deaths, more intolerable than any punishment. But here there is nothing of the kind. For the fruit, it says, of the Spirit is love, joy, peace. Galatians 5:22 Here is no quarreling, nor unseasonable pecuniary expense, nor disgrace and expense too; and if you give but a farthing, or a loaf, or a cup of cold water, He will be much beholden to you, and He does nothing to pain or grieve you, but all so as to make you glorious, and free you from all shame. What defense therefore shall we have, what pardon shall we gain, if, leaving these things, we give ourselves up to the contrary, and voluntarily cast ourselves into the furnace that burns with fire? Wherefore I exhort those who are sick of this malady, to recover themselves, and return to health, and not allow themselves to fall into despair. Since that son also was in a far more grievous state than this, yet when he returned to his father's house, he came to his former honor, and appeared more glorious than him who had ever been well-pleasing. Let us also imitate him, and returning to our Father, even though it be late, let us depart from that captivity, and transfer ourselves to freedom, that we may enjoy the Kingdom of heaven, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom with the Father and the Holy Ghost be glory, for ever and ever. Amen.