Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 45 — John 6:28-30

Homily 45 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240145.htm>.

Contents · 9 chapters
  1. John 6:28-30
  2. John 6:31
  3. John 6:32
  4. John 6:33
  5. John 6:34
  6. John 6:35-36
  7. John 6:37
  8. John 6:38
  9. John 6:40

John 6:28-30

There is nothing worse, nothing more shameful, than gluttony; it makes the mind dull, and the soul fleshly; it blinds people and prevents them from seeing clearly. Notice, for example, how this is the case with the Jews; because they were focused on gluttony, completely occupied with worldly things, and without any spiritual thoughts, even though Christ tries to lead them forward with countless statements, both sharp and at the same time patient, they still do not rise up but continue groveling down below. Consider this: He said to them, You seek Me, not because you saw the miracles, but because you ate the bread and were filled; He confronted them with this rebuke, He showed them what food they ought to seek, saying, Labor not for the meat that perishes; He set before them the reward, saying, but that which endures unto everlasting life; then He provided a solution to what might have been an objection by declaring that He was sent from the Father.

1. There is nothing worse, nothing more shameful, than gluttony; it makes the mind gross, and the soul carnal; it blinds, and permits not to see clearly. Observe, for instance, how this is the case with the Jews; for because they were intent upon gluttony, entirely occupied with worldly things, and without any spiritual thoughts, though Christ leads them on by ten thousand sayings, sharp and at the same time forbearing, even thus they arise not, but continue groveling below. For consider; He said to them, You seek Me, not because ye saw the miracles, but because ye did eat of the bread, and were filled; He touched them by the reproof, He showed them what food they ought to seek, saying, Labor not for the meat that perishes; He set before them the prize, saying, but that which endures unto everlasting life; then provided a remedy for what might have been an objection, by declaring that He was sent from the Father.

What then did they do? As though they had heard nothing, they said, "What shall we do, that we might work the works of God?" They said this not so they might learn and do these works (as what follows shows), but to get Him to supply them with food again, wanting to persuade Him to satisfy them. What then does Christ say? "This is the work of God, that you believe in Him whom He has sent." At this they asked, "What sign do you show, that we may see and believe?"

What then did they? As though they had heard nothing, they said, What shall we do, that we might work the works of God? This they said, not that they might learn and do them, (as the sequel shows,) but to induce Him again to supply them with food, and desiring to persuade Him to satisfy them. What then says Christ? This is the work of God, that you believe in Him whom He has sent. On this they asked, What sign do you show, that we may see and believe?

John 6:31

Nothing is more senseless, nothing more unreasonable, than these men! While the miracle was still in their hands, they spoke as if none had been done, saying, What sign do you show? And after speaking this way, they don't even allow Him the right to choose the sign, but think they can force Him to display only the same kind that was performed in their fathers' time. This is why they say, Our fathers ate manna in the wilderness—thinking by this to provoke Him to work a miracle that would supply them with physical food. Otherwise, why did they mention none of the other miracles of old, though many occurred in those times, both in Egypt and at the sea and in the wilderness, but only the manna? Was it not because they greatly desired that one due to the tyranny of their stomachs? You who, when you saw His miracle, called Him a Prophet and tried to make Him a king—how is it that now, as if none had been performed, you have become ungrateful and ill-disposed, and ask for a sign, speaking words fit for parasites or hungry dogs? Does the manna now seem wonderful to you? Your soul is not now parched up.

Nothing more senseless, nothing more unreasonable, than these men! While the miracle was yet in their hands, as though none had been done, they spoke after this manner, What sign do you show? and having thus spoken, they do not even allow Him the right of choosing the sign, but think to force Him to exhibit none other than such a one as was wrought in the days of their fathers; wherefore they say, Our fathers did eat manna in the wilderness, thinking by this to provoke Him to work such a miracle as might supply them with carnal nourishment. Else why did they mention none other of the miracles of old, though many took place in those times, both in Egypt and at the sea and in the wilderness, but only that of the manna? Was it not because they greatly desired that one by reason of the tyranny of their bellies? You who when you saw His miracle called him a Prophet, and attempted to make Him a king, how is that now, as though none had been wrought, you have become thankless and ill-minded, and ask for a sign, uttering words fit for parasites, or hungry dogs? Does the manna now seem wonderful to you? Your soul is not now parched up.

Notice their hypocrisy. They didn't say "Moses did this sign—what do you do?" because they thought it would annoy Him. Instead, for a while they addressed Him with great respect because they expected food. So they didn't say "God did this—what do you do?" to avoid seeming to make Him equal with God. Nor did they bring up Moses, to avoid seeming to lower Him. Instead, they put it in neutral terms: "Our fathers ate manna in the wilderness." He could have replied, "I have now worked greater wonders than Moses did, requiring no staff, having no need of prayer, but doing everything of Myself; and if you recall the manna, see, I have given you bread." But this was not the right time for such words. The one thing He earnestly desired was to bring them to spiritual food. And observe His infinite wisdom and His manner of answering.

Mark too their hypocrisy. They said not, Moses did this sign, what doest thou? thinking it would annoy Him; but for a while they address Him with great reverence, through expectation of food. So they neither said, God did this, what doest thou? that they might not seem to make Him equal with God; nor did they bring forward Moses, that they might not seem to lower Him, but put the matter in an intermediate form, Our fathers did eat manna in the wilderness. He indeed might have replied, I, but now, have wrought greater wonders than did Moses, requiring no rod, having no need of prayer, but doing all of Myself; and, if you call to remembrance the manna, see, I have given you bread. But this was not the season for such speeches; and the one thing He earnestly desired was, to bring them to spiritual food. And observe His infinite wisdom and His manner of answering.

John 6:32

Why did He not say, "It was not Moses that gave it to you, but I"? Why does He put God in the place of Moses and Himself instead of manna? Because the weakness of His hearers was great, as is seen from what follows. For not even when He had spoken this way did He secure their attention, although He said at first, "You seek Me, not because you saw the miracle, but because you ate of the loaves and were filled" (John 6:26). Now because they sought these physical things, He wanted to correct them by His succeeding words, yet not even so did they stop. When He promised the Samaritan woman that He would give her the water, He made no mention of the Father. What does He say? "If you knew who it is that says to you, 'Give Me to drink,' you would have asked of Him, and He would have given you living water" (John 4:10); and again, "The water which I shall give." He does not refer her to the Father. But here He makes mention of the Father, so that you may understand how great was the faith of the Samaritan woman, and how great was the weakness of the Jews.

Why said He not, It was not Moses that gave it to you, but I; but puts God in the place of Moses, and Himself instead of manna? Because the infirmity of His hearers was great. As is seen from what follows. For not even when He had spoken thus did He secure their attention, although He said at first, You seek Me, not because ye saw the miracle, but because ye did eat of the loaves, and were filled. John 6:26 Now because they sought these (carnal) things, He would have corrected them by His succeeding words, yet not even so did they desist. When He promised the Samaritan woman that He would give her the water, He made no mention of the Father. What says He? If you knew who it is that says unto you, Give Me to drink, you would have asked of Him, and He would have given unto you living water John 4:10; and again, The water which I shall give. He referrs her not to The Father. But here He makes mention of The Father, that you may understand how great was the faith of the Samaritan woman, and how great the infirmity of the Jews.

Was the manna not from heaven? How then is it said to be from heaven? In the same way that Scripture speaks of birds of heaven and again says, "The Lord thundered from heaven." He calls that other bread the true bread, not because the miracle of the manna was false, but because it was a type and not the actual reality. In mentioning Moses, He does not compare Himself to him, because the Jews did not yet prefer Him to Moses, whom they still held in higher regard. So after saying "Moses gave not," He does not add "but I give." Instead He says that the Father, not Moses, gives. When they heard this, they replied, "Give us this bread to eat," because they still thought it was something material. They still expected to satisfy their appetites, and so they eagerly ran to Him. What does Christ do? Leading them on little by little, He says,

Was then the manna not from heaven? How then is it said to be from heaven? In the same manner as Scripture speaks of fowls of heaven Psalm 8:8; and again, The Lord thundered from heaven. Psalm 18:13 And He calls that other the true bread, not because the miracle of the manna was false, but because it was a type, and not the very truth. But in mentioning Moses, He does not compare Himself to him, for the Jews did not as yet prefer Him to Moses, of whom they still had a higher opinion. So that after saying, Moses gave not, He adds not that I give, but says that The Father, and not Moses, gives. They, when they heard this, replied, Give us this bread to eat; for they yet thought that it was something material, they yet expected to gratify their appetites, and so hastily ran to Him. What does Christ? Leading them on little by little, He says,

John 6:33

He says this not for the Jews alone, but for the whole world. And He offers not merely food, but life—a different and transformed life. He calls it life because they were all dead in sins. Yet they still remained bent downward, saying,

Not, says He, to Jews alone, but to all the world, not mere food, but life, another and an altered life. He calls it life, because they all were dead in sins. Yet they still kept downward bent, saying,

John 6:34

Then He rebuked them because they ran to Him when they supposed the food was material, but not when they learned that it was a spiritual kind, and said,

Then He, to rebuke them, because while they supposed that the food was material they ran to Him, but not when they learned that it was a spiritual kind, said,

John 6:35-36

Thus John also declares in advance, saying, "He speaks what He knows, and testifies what He has seen, and no one receives His testimony" (John 3:32); and again Christ Himself says, "We speak what We know, and testify what We have seen" (John 3:11), yet you do not believe. He does this to anticipate them, and to show them that the matter does not disturb Him, that He does not seek honor, that He is not ignorant of the secrets of their minds, nor of present things, nor of future things.

2. Thus also John cries, saying beforehand, He speaks that He knows, and testifies that He has seen, and no man receives His testimony John 3:32; and again Christ Himself, We speak that We do know, and testify that We have seen John 3:11, and you believe not. This He does to prevent them, and to show them that the matter does not trouble Him, that He desires not honor, that He is not ignorant of the secrets of their minds, nor of things present, nor of things to come.

I am the bread of life. Now He proceeds to reveal mysteries to them. First He speaks of His Godhead, saying, I am the bread of life. This is not spoken about His Body (concerning that He says later, And the bread which I shall give is My flesh), but here it refers to His Godhead. For that, through God the Word, is Bread, just as this bread also, through the Spirit descending on it, is made Heavenly Bread. Here He does not use witnesses as in His earlier speech, for He had the miracle of the loaves to witness to Him, and the Jews themselves for a time pretended to believe Him; in the earlier case they opposed and accused Him. This is why here He declares Himself openly. But they, since they expected to enjoy a physical feast, were not disturbed until they gave up their hope. Yet Christ was not silent on that account, but spoke many words of reproof. For they, who while they were eating called Him a Prophet, were here offended and called Him the carpenter's son; not so while they ate the loaves, then they said, He is The Prophet, and wanted to make Him a king. Now they seemed to be upset at His claim that He came down from heaven, but in truth it was not this that caused their anger, but the thought that they would not enjoy a physical meal. Had they been truly upset, they should have asked and inquired how He was the bread of life, how He had come down from heaven; but now they do not do this, but murmur. And that it was not this which offended them is clear from another circumstance. When He said, My Father gives you the bread, they did not cry out, Ask Him to give it; but what? Give us that bread; yet He did not say, I give, but, My Father gives; nevertheless, they, from desire for the food, thought Him worthy to be trusted to supply it. Now how could they, who considered Him worthy of their trust for giving, be afterward offended when they also heard that the Father gives? What is the reason? It is that when they heard they were not going to eat, they again disbelieved, and put forward as a cover for their disbelief that it was a difficult saying. Therefore He says, You have seen Me, and believe not; referring partly to His miracles, partly to the testimony from the Scriptures; For they, He says, are they which testify of Me; and, I have come in My Father's Name, and you receive Me not; and, How can you believe which receive honor of men?

I am the bread of life. Now He proceeds to commit unto them mysteries. And first He discourses of His Godhead, saying, I am the bread of life. For this is not spoken of His Body, (concerning that He says towards the end, And the bread which I shall give is My flesh,) but at present it referrs to His Godhead. For That, through God the Word, is Bread, as this bread also, through the Spirit descending on it, is made Heavenly Bread. Here He uses not witnesses, as in His former address, for He had the miracle of the loaves to witness to Him, and the Jews themselves for a while pretending to believe Him; in the former case they opposed and accused Him. This is the reason why here He declares Himself. But they, since they expected to enjoy a carnal feast, were not disturbed until they gave up their hope. Yet not for that was Christ silent, but uttered many words of reproof. For they, who while they were eating called Him a Prophet, were here offended, and called Him the carpenter's son; not so while they ate the loaves, then they said, He is The Prophet, and desired to make Him a king. Now they seemed to be indignant at His asserting that He came down from heaven, but in truth it was not this that caused their indignation, but the thought that they should not enjoy a material table. Had they been really indignant, they ought to have asked and enquired how He was the bread of life, how He had come down from heaven; but now they do not this, but murmur. And that it was not this which offended them is plain from another circumstance. When He said, My Father gives you the bread, they exclaimed not, Beseech Him that He give; but what? Give us that bread; yet He said not, I give, but, My Father gives; nevertheless, they, from desire of the food, thought Him worthy to be trusted to for its supply. Now how should they, who deemed Him worthy of their trust for giving, be afterward offended when they also heard that the Father gives? What is the reason? It is that when they heard that they were not to eat, they again disbelieved, and put forth by way of a cloak for their disbelief, that it was a high saying. Wherefore He says, You have seen Me, and believe not John 5:39; alluding partly to His miracles, partly to the testimony from the Scriptures; For they, He says, are they which testify of Me c. v. 43, 44; and, I have come in My Father's Name, and you receive Me not; and, How can you believe which receive honor of men?

John 6:37

Notice how He does everything for the sake of those who are saved. That's why He added this—so He wouldn't appear to be speaking carelessly and saying these things for no reason. But what does He mean when He says, "All that the Father gives Me shall come unto Me," and "I will raise it up in the last day"? Why does He speak of the general resurrection, in which even the ungodly share, as if it were the special gift of those who believe in Him? Because He is not speaking simply of resurrection, but of a particular kind of resurrection. After first saying, "I will not cast him out" and "I shall lose nothing of it," He then speaks of the resurrection. In the resurrection, some are cast out ("Take him, and cast him into outer darkness"), and some are destroyed ("Rather fear Him who is able to destroy both soul and body in hell"). And the statement "I give eternal life" makes this clear, for those who have done evil will go forth to the resurrection of damnation, and those who have done good to the resurrection of life. This resurrection to good things is what He means here. But what does He mean by saying, "All that the Father gives Me, shall come to Me"? He is addressing their unbelief, showing that whoever does not believe in Him transgresses the will of the Father. He says this not openly, but in a veiled way, and He does this everywhere, wanting to show that unbelievers are at odds with the Father, not with Him alone. For if this is His will, and if He came for this purpose—to save humanity—then those who do not believe transgress His will. So when He says the Father guides someone, nothing prevents that person from coming to Me. And in another place, "No man can come unto Me, except the Father draw him." And Paul says that He delivers them up to the Father: "When He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God, even the Father." Now just as the Father gives without depriving Himself, so the Son delivers up without excluding Himself. He is said to deliver us up because through Him we have access to the Father.

Observe how He does all things for the sake of them that are saved; therefore He added this, that He might not seem to be trifling and speaking these things to no purpose. But what is it that He says, All that the Father gives Me shall come unto Me John 6:37, and I will raise it up in the last day? John 6:40 Wherefore speaks He of the common resurrection, in which even the ungodly have a part, as though it were the peculiar gift of those who believe in Him? Because He speaks not simply of resurrection, but of a particular kind of resurrection. For having first said, I will not cast him out, I shall lose nothing of it, He then speaks of the resurrection. Since in the resurrection some are cast out, ( Take him, and cast him into outer darkness, Matthew 22:13) and some are destroyed. ( Rather fear Him who is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.) Matthew 10:28 And the expression, I give eternal life John 10:28, declares this; for they that have done evil shall go forth to the resurrection of damnation, and they that have done good to the resurrection of life. John 5:29 This then, the resurrection to good things, is that which He here designed. But what means He by saying, All that the Father gives Me, shall come to Me? He touches their unbelief, showing that whosoever believes not on Him transgresses the will of the Father. And thus He says it not nakedly, but in a covert manner, and this He does everywhere, wishing to show that unbelievers are at variance with the Father, not with Him alone. For if this is His will, and if for this He came, that He might save man, those who believe not transgress His will. When therefore, He says, the Father guides any man, there is nothing that hinders him from coming unto Me; and in another place, No man can come unto Me, except the Father draw him. John 6:44 And Paul says, that He delivers them up unto the Father; When He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God, even the Father. 1 Corinthians 15:24 Now as the Father when He gives does so without first depriving Himself, so the Son when He delivers up does so without excluding Himself. He is said to deliver us up, because through Him we have access (to the Father).

And the phrase "by whom" is also applied to the Father, as when the Apostle says, "By whom you were called unto the fellowship of His Son" (1 Corinthians 1:9), and "By the will of the Father." And again, "Blessed are you, Simon Barjona, for flesh and blood has not revealed it unto you" (Matthew 16:17). What He is suggesting here is something like this: that faith in Me is no ordinary thing, but needs an impulse from above. And He establishes this throughout His discourse, showing that this faith requires a noble sort of soul, and one drawn on by God.

3. And the by whom is also applied to the Father, as when the Apostle says, By whom you were called unto the fellowship of His Son 1 Corinthians 1:9: and, By the will of the Father. And again; Blessed are you, Simon Barjona, for flesh and blood has not revealed it unto you. Matthew 16:17 What He here intimates is something of this kind, that faith in Me is no ordinary thing, but needs an impulse from above; and this He establishes throughout His discourse, showing that this faith requires a noble sort of soul, and one drawn on by God.

But perhaps someone will say, "If everyone the Father gives, and whoever He draws, comes to You, and if no one can come to You unless it is given to him from above, then those to whom the Father does not give are free from any blame or accusation." These are just empty words and excuses. For our own deliberate choice is also required, because whether we are willing to be taught is a matter of choice, and whether we are willing to believe is also a matter of choice. And in this passage, by "which the Father gives Me," He is saying nothing other than that believing in Me is no ordinary thing, nor something that comes from human reasoning, but requires a revelation from above and a well-ordered soul to receive that revelation. And "He who comes to Me shall be saved" means that he will be greatly cared for. For it is on account of these people, He says, that I came and took upon Me the flesh and entered into the form of a servant. Then He adds;

But perhaps some one will say, If all that the Father gives, and whomsoever He shall draw, comes unto You, if none can come unto You except it be given him from above, then those to whom the Father gives not are free from any blame or charges. These are mere words and pretenses. For we require our own deliberate choice also, because whether we will be taught is a matter of choice, and also whether we will believe. And in this place, by the which the Father gives Me, He declares nothing else than that the believing on Me is no ordinary thing, nor one that comes of human reasonings, but needs a revelation from above, and a well-ordered soul to receive that revelation. And the, He that comes to Me shall be saved, means that he shall be greatly cared for. For on account of these, He says, I came, and took upon Me the flesh, and entered into the form of a servant. Then He adds;

John 6:38

What are You saying? Are Your will and His will two different things? To prevent anyone from suspecting this, He explains it through what comes next, saying:

What sayest Thou? Why, is Your will one, and His another? That none may suspect this, He explains it by what follows, saying;

John 6:40

Isn't this your will then? And how can you say, "I have come to send fire upon the earth, and what do I desire to see if it is already kindled?" For if you also desire this, it is very clear that your will and the Father's will are one. In another place he also says, "For as the Father raises up the dead and gives them life, even so the Son gives life to whom he will." But what is the will of the Father? Is it not that not even one of them should perish? You want this too. So the will of one does not differ from the will of the other. In another place he is seen establishing even more firmly his equality with the Father, saying, "I and my Father will come and will make our home with him." What he is saying is this: I came not to do anything other than what the Father wills. I have no will of my own different from the Father's, for all that is the Father's is mine, and all that is mine is the Father's. If now the things of the Father and the Son are held in common, he says with good reason, "Not that I might do my own will." But here he does not speak in this way; instead he saves this for the end. For, as I have said, he conceals and veils for a while these lofty matters and wants to prove that had he even said, "This is my will," they would have despised him. He therefore says that he cooperates with that will, wanting in this way to startle them more—as though he had said, "What do you think? Do you anger me by your disbelief? No, you provoke my Father." For this is the will of him who sent me, that of all which he has given me I should lose nothing. Here he shows that he does not need their service, that he came not for his own advantage but for their salvation, and not to get honor from them. This indeed he declared in a former address, saying, "I receive not honor from men," and again, "These things I say that you may be saved," since he everywhere labors to persuade them that he came for their salvation. And he says that he obtains honor for the Father so that he may not be suspected by them. And that it is for this reason he speaks this way, he has more clearly revealed by what follows. For he says, "He who seeks his own will seeks his own glory, but he who seeks his glory who sent him is true, and there is no unrighteousness in him." And this is the will of the Father, that everyone who sees the Son and believes in him may have everlasting life.

Is not then this Your will? And how sayest Thou, I have come to send fire upon the earth, and what have I desired to see, if that be already kindled? Luke 12:49 For if Thou also desirest this, it is very clear that Your will and the Father's is one. In another place also He says, For as the Father raises up the dead and quickens them, even so the Son quickens whom He will. John 5:21 But what is the will of the Father? Is it not, that not so much as one of them should perish? This Thou willest also. Matthew 18:14 So that the will of the One differs not from the will of the Other. So in another place He is seen establishing yet more firmly His equality with the Father, saying, I and My Father 'will come, and will make Our abode with him.' John 14:23 What He says then is this; I came not to do anything other than that which the Father wills, I have no will of My own different from that of the Father, for all that is the Father's is Mine, and all that is Mine is the Father's. If now the things of the Father and the Son are in common, He says with reason, Not that I might do My own will. But here He speaks not so, but reserves this for the end. For, as I have said, He conceals and veils for a while high matters, and desires to prove that had He even said, This is My will, they would have despised Him. He therefore says, that I co-operate with that Will, desiring thus to startle them more; as though He had said, What do you think? Do ye anger Me by your disbelief? Nay, you provoke My Father. For this is the will of Him that sent Me, that of all which He has given Me I should lose nothing. John 6:39 Here He shows that He needs not their service, that He came not for His own advantage, but for their salvation; and not to get honor from them. Which indeed He declared in a former address, saying, I receive not honor from men John 5:41; and again, These things I say that you may be saved. John 5:34 Since He everywhere labors to persuade them that He came for their salvation. And He says, that He obtains honor to the Father, in order that He may not be suspected by them. And that it is for this reason He thus speaks, He has more clearly revealed by what follows. For He says, He that seeks his own will seeks his own glory; but He that seeks His glory that sent Him is true, and there is no unrighteousness in Him. John 7:18 And this is the will of the Father, that every one which sees the Son, and believes in Him, may have everlasting life. John 6:40

And I will raise him up at the last day. Why does He keep returning to the Resurrection? It is so that people may not judge God's providence by present circumstances alone. If they do not see results here, they should not become discouraged on that account, but should wait for what is to come. And they should not despise Him just because their sins are not punished in the present, but should look forward to another life.

And I will raise him up at the last day. Why does He continually dwell upon the Resurrection? Is it that men may not judge of God's providence by present things alone; that if they enjoy not results here, they become not on that account desponding, but wait for the things that are to come, and that they may not, because their sins are not punished for the present, despise Him, but look for another life.

Now those men gained nothing, but let us take pains to benefit by having the Resurrection continually sounded in our ears. If we desire to be greedy, or to steal, or to do any wrong thing, let us immediately bring that Day into our thoughts. Let us picture the judgment seat in our minds, for such reflections will restrain the evil impulse more powerfully than any bridle. Let us continually say to others and to ourselves: There is a resurrection, and a fearful tribunal awaits us. If we see any man arrogant and puffed up with the good things of this world, let us make the same remark to him and show him that all those things remain here. If we observe another person grieving and impatient, let us say the same to him and point out to him that his sorrows shall have an end. If we see one careless and dissipated, let us say the same remedy over him and show that for his carelessness he must give account. This saying is able more than any other remedy to heal our souls. For there is a Resurrection, and that Resurrection is at our doors, not far off, nor at a distance. For yet a little while, and He that shall come will come, and will not tarry. And again, We must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ—that is, both bad and good, the one to be shamed in sight of all, the other in sight of all to be made more glorious. For as those who judge here punish the wicked and honor the good publicly, so too will it be there, that the one sort may have the greater shame, and the other more conspicuous glory. Let us picture these things to ourselves every day. If we are always thinking on them, no concern for present things will be able to sting us. For the things which are seen are temporary, but the things which are not seen are eternal. Continually let us say to ourselves and to others: There is a Resurrection, and a Judgment, and a scrutiny of our actions. And let as many as think there is such a thing as fate repeat this, and they shall immediately be delivered from the rottenness of their disease. For if there is a Resurrection and a Judgment, there is no fate, though they bring ten thousand arguments and choke themselves to prove it. But I am ashamed to be teaching Christians concerning the Resurrection, for he who needs to learn that there is a Resurrection, and who has not firmly persuaded himself that the affairs of this world do not go on by fate and without design and as chance will have them, can be no Christian. Therefore, I exhort and beseech you that we cleanse ourselves from all wickedness and do all in our power to obtain pardon and excuse in that Day.

Now those men gained nothing, but let us take pains to gain by having the Resurrection continually sounded in our ears; and if we desire to be grasping, or to steal, or to do any wrong thing, let us straightway take into our thoughts that Day, let us picture to ourselves the Judgment-seat, for such reflections will check the evil impulse more strongly than any bit. Let us continually say to others, and to ourselves, There is a resurrection, and a fearful tribunal awaits us. If we see any man insolent and puffed up with the good things of his world, let us make the same remark to him, and show him that all those things abide here: and if we observe another grieving and impatient, let us say the same to him, and point out to him that his sorrows shall have an end; if we see one careless and dissipated, let us say the same charm over him, and show that for his carelessness he must render account. This saying is able more than any other remedy to heal our souls. For there is a Resurrection, and that Resurrection is at our doors, not afar off, nor at a distance. For yet a little while, and He that shall come will come, and will not tarry. Hebrews 10:37 And again, We must all appear before the judgment-seat of Christ 2 Corinthians 5:10; that is, both bad and good, the one to be shamed in sight of all, the other in sight of all to be made more glorious. For as they who judge here punish the wicked and honor the good publicly, so too will it be there, that the one sort may have the greater shame, and the other more conspicuous glory. Let us picture these things to ourselves every day. If we are ever revolving them, no care for present things will be able to sting us. For the things which are seen are temporal, but the things which are not seen are eternal. 2 Corinthians 4:18 Continually let us say to ourselves and to others, There is a Resurrection, and a Judgment, and a scrutiny of our actions; and let as many as deem that there is such a thing as fate repeat this, and they shall straightway be delivered from the rottenness of their malady; for if there is a Resurrection, and a Judgment, there is no fate, though they bring ten thousand arguments, and choke themselves to prove it. But I am ashamed to be teaching Christians concerning the Resurrection: for he that needs to learn that there is a Resurrection, and who has not firmly persuaded himself that the affairs of this world go not on by fate, and without design, and as chance will have them, can be no Christian. Wherefore, I exhort and beseech you, that we cleanse ourselves from all wickedness, and do all in our power to obtain pardon and excuse in that Day.

Perhaps someone will say, "When will the end come? When will the Resurrection happen? Look how much time has passed, and nothing like this has happened yet." But it will happen, be assured. The people before the flood spoke in this same way and mocked Noah, but the flood came and swept away all those unbelievers while preserving him who believed. The people of Lot's time did not expect that stroke from God, until those lightnings and thunderbolts came down and destroyed them all completely. In neither of these cases—not for those men nor for those who lived in Noah's time—was there any warning of what was about to happen. Rather, when they were all living luxuriously and drinking and drunk with wine, then these unbearable calamities came upon them. The Resurrection will be the same way: it will come without any warning, but while we are in the midst of good times. This is why Paul says, "For when they shall say, Peace and safety; then sudden destruction comes upon them, as travail upon a woman with child; and they shall not escape." God has arranged this so that we may always be striving and not feel secure even in times of safety. What are you saying? Do you not expect that there will be a Resurrection and a Judgment? The demons confess these things, and yet you are shameless? "Have You come," they say, "to torment us before the time?" Now those who say there will be torment are aware of the Judgment, the reckoning, and the vengeance. Let us not, in addition to daring to do evil deeds, also anger God by disbelieving the word of the Resurrection. For just as Christ has been our beginning in other things, so also has He been in this; this is why He is called the first-born from the dead. Now if there were no Resurrection, how could He be the first-born, when no one of the dead was to follow Him? If there were no Resurrection, how would God's justice be preserved, when so many evil people prosper and so many good people are afflicted and die in their affliction? Where will each of these receive what they deserve, if there is no Resurrection? No one who has lived rightly disbelieves the Resurrection, but every day they pray and repeat that holy sentence, "Your Kingdom come." Who then are those who disbelieve the Resurrection? Those who have unholy ways and an unclean life, as the Prophet says, "His ways are always polluted. Your judgments are far above out of his sight." For a person cannot possibly live a pure life without believing in the Resurrection, since those who are conscious of no wrongdoing both speak of, wish for, and believe in it, so that they may receive their reward. Let us not then anger Him, but hear Him when He says, "Fear Him which is able to destroy both body and soul in hell," so that by that fear we may become better, and being delivered from that destruction, may be deemed worthy of the Kingdom of Heaven. May we all attain to this, through the grace and loving-kindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom and with whom to the Father and the Holy Ghost be glory, now and ever and to the endless ages of eternity. Amen.

Perhaps some one will say, When will be the consummation? When will be the Resurrection? See how long a time has gone by, and nothing of the kind has come to pass? Yet it shall be, be sure. For those before the flood spoke after this manner, and mocked at Noah, but the flood came and swept away all those unbelievers, but preserved him who believed. And the men of Lot's time expected not that stroke from God, until those lightnings and thunderbolts came down and destroyed them all utterly. Neither in the case of these men, nor of those who lived in the time of Noah, was there any preamble to what was about to happen, but when they were all living daintily, and drinking, and mad with wine, then came these intolerable calamities upon them. So also shall the Resurrection be; not with any preamble, but while we are in the midst of good times. Wherefore Paul says, For when they shall say, Peace and safety; then sudden destruction comes upon them, as travail upon a woman with child; and they shall not escape. 1 Thessalonians 5:3 God has so ordered this, that we may be always struggling, and be not confident even in time of safety. What do you say? Do you not expect that there will be a Resurrection and a Judgment? The devils confess these, and are you shameless? Have You come, they say, to torment us before the time? Matthew 8:29; now they who say that there will be torment; are aware of the Judgment, and the reckoning, and the vengeance. Let us not then besides daring evil deeds, anger God by disbelieving the word of the Resurrection. For as in other things Christ has been our beginning, so also has He in this; wherefore He is called the first-born from the dead. Colossians 1:18 Now if there were no Resurrection, how could He be the first-born, when no one of the dead was to follow Him? If there were no Resurrection, how would the justice of God be preserved, when so many evil men prosper, and so many good men are afflicted and die in their affliction? Where shall each of these obtain his deserts, if so be that there is no Resurrection? No one of those who have lived aright disbelieves the Resurrection, but every day they pray and repeat that holy sentence, Your Kingdom come. Who then are they that disbelieve the Resurrection? They who have unholy ways and an unclean life: as the Prophet says, His ways are always polluted. Your judgments are far above out of his sight. Psalm 10:5 For a man cannot possibly live a pure life without believing in the Resurrection; since they who are conscious of no iniquity both speak of, and wish for, and believe in it, that they may receive their recompense. Let us not then anger Him, but hear Him when He says, Fear Him which is able to destroy both body and soul in hell Matthew 10:28; that by that fear we may become better, and being delivered from that perdition, may be deemed worthy of the Kingdom of Heaven. Which may we all attain to, through the grace and loving-kindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom and with whom to the Father and the Holy Ghost be glory, now and ever and to the endless ages of eternity. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 44 — John 6:26-27

Homily 44 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240144.htm>.

John 6:26-27

Jesus answered them and said, "Truly, truly, I tell you, you seek Me not because you saw the miracles but because you ate the loaves and were filled. Do not work for the food that perishes, but for the food that endures to everlasting life."

Jesus answered them, and said, Verily, verily, I say unto you, You seek Me, not because ye saw the miracles but because ye did eat of the loaves and were filled. Labor not for the meat which perishes, but for that meat which endures unto everlasting life.

The mild and gentle approach is not always useful; there are times when a teacher needs sharper language. If the student is dull and slow to understand, then to pierce through that dullness, we must stir him with a goad. This is what the Son of God has done in this instance and in many others. When the crowds came and found Jesus and were flattering Him, saying, "Master, when did You get here?" He showed that He does not desire honor from men but looks to one thing only—their salvation. He answers them sharply, wishing to correct them not only in this way but also by revealing and exposing their thoughts. For what does He say? "Verily, verily, I say unto you" (speaking positively and with confirmation), "You seek Me, not because ye saw miracles, but because ye did eat of the loaves and were filled." He scolds and reproves them with these words, yet does not do so abruptly or violently, but very gently. He does not say, "You gluttons and belly-slaves, I have performed so many wonders, and you have never either followed Me or marveled at My works," but mildly and gently says something like this: "You seek Me, not because ye saw miracles, but because ye did eat of the loaves and were filled"—speaking not only of the past but also of the present miracle. It was not, He says, the miracle of the loaves that astonished you, but the being filled. That He did not say this about them by mere conjecture they immediately showed, for they came a second time on this account, expecting to enjoy the same food as before. Therefore they said, "Our fathers did eat manna in the wilderness." Again they pull Him toward the subject of physical food, which was the chief accusation and charge against them. But He does not stop at rebukes; He adds instruction also, saying, "Labor not for the meat which perishes, but for that meat which endures unto everlasting life."

1. The mild and gentle is not always useful, but there are times when the teacher needs sharper language. For if the disciple be dull and gross, then, in order to touch his dullness to the quick, we must rouse him with a goad. And this the Son of God has done in the present as well as in many other cases. For when the crowds had come and found Jesus, and were flattering Him, and saying, Master, when did You get here? to show that He desires not honor from men, but looks to one thing only, their salvation, He answers them sharply, wishing to correct them not in this way only, but also by revealing and exposing their thoughts. For what says He? Verily, verily, I say unto you, (speaking positively and with a confirmation,) You seek Me, not because ye saw miracles, but because ye did eat of the loaves and were filled. He chides and reproves them by these words, yet does not so abruptly or violently, but very sparingly. For He says not, O you gluttons and belly-slaves, I have wrought so many wonders, and you never have either followed Me, or marveled at My doings; but mildly and gently somewhat in this manner; You seek Me, not because ye saw miracles, but because ye did eat of the loaves and were filled; speaking not only of the past, but also of the present miracle. It was not, He says, the miracle of the loaves that astonished you, but the being filled. And that He said not this of them by conjecture they straightway showed, for on this account they came the second time, as being about to enjoy the same (food) as before. Wherefore they said, Our fathers did eat manna in the wilderness. Again they draw Him to (the subject of) carnal food, which was the chief accusation and charge against them. But He stops not at rebukes, but adds instruction also, saying, Labor not for the meat which perishes, but for that meat which endures unto everlasting life.

Which the Son of Man gives to you; for God the Father has sealed Him.

Which the Son of Man gives unto you; for Him has God the Father sealed.

What He is saying is like this: Don't worry about this earthly food, but about that spiritual food. But since some people who want to live doing nothing have misused this statement, as if Christ wanted to completely eliminate work, it's important to address them. They are slandering, so to speak, all of Christianity and causing it to be mocked for promoting idleness. First, though, we must mention what Paul said. What does he say? Remember the Lord, how He said, It is more blessed to give than to receive. Acts 20:35 Now how can someone give if he has nothing? How then does Jesus say to Martha, You are careful and troubled about many things, but one thing is needful, and Mary has chosen that good part? Luke 10:41-42; and again, Take no thought for the morrow. Matthew 6:34 It is now necessary to answer all these questions, not only so we may stop people from being idle, but also so the oracles of God don't appear to contradict themselves.

What He says, is of this kind: Make no account of this earthly, but of that spiritual food. But since some of those who desire to live in doing nothing have abused this speech, as though Christ would entirely abolish working, it is seasonable to say somewhat to them. For they slander, so to speak, all Christianity, and cause it to be ridiculed on the score of idleness. First however, we must mention that saying of Paul. What says he? Remember the Lord, how He said, It is more blessed to give than to receive. Acts 20:35 Now how can it be possible for him to give who has not? How then says Jesus to Martha, You are careful and troubled about many things, but one thing is needful, and Mary has chosen that good part? Luke 10:41-42; and again, Take no thought for the morrow. Matthew 6:34 For it is necessary now to resolve all these questions, not only that we may check men if they would be idle, but also that the oracles of God may not appear to bring in what is contradictory.

In another place, Paul says, "But we urge you, brothers, to increase more and more, to be quiet, and to do your own business, so that you may walk honestly toward those who are outside" (1 Thessalonians 4:10-12). And again, "Let the one who stole steal no more, but rather let him work, laboring with his own hands, so that he may have something to give to the one who needs" (Ephesians 4:28). Here the Apostle commands not just to work, but to work so vigorously and hard as to have something from it to give to others. And in another place he says again, "These hands have provided for my necessities and for those who were with me" (Acts 20:34). And writing to the Corinthians he said, "What then is my reward? That when I preach the Gospel, I may make the Gospel of Christ without charge" (1 Corinthians 9:18). And when he was in that city, he stayed with Aquila and Priscilla and worked, for by their trade they were tentmakers (Acts 18:3).

Now Paul in another place says, But we beseech you, brethren, that you increase more and more, that you study to be quiet, and to do your own business; that you may walk honestly toward them that are without 1 Thessalonians 4:10-12; and again; Let him that stole, steal no more; but rather let him labor, working with his own hands, that he may have to give to him that needs. Ephesians 4:28 Here the Apostle bids not simply work, but to work so vigorously and laboriously, as to have thereby somewhat to give to others. And in another place the same says again; These hands have ministered to my necessities, and to them that were with me. Acts 20:34 And writing to the Corinthians he said, What is my reward then? Verily, that when I preach the Gospel, I may make the Gospel of Christ without charge. 1 Corinthians 9:18 And when he was in that city, he abode with Aquila and Priscilla, and wrought, for by their occupation they were tentmakers. Acts 18:3

These passages show an even stronger opposition when taken literally, so we must now provide an explanation. What should we say? That taking no thought does not mean not working, but rather not being bound to the things of this life—that is, taking no care for tomorrow's comfort, but considering such concerns unnecessary. A person may do no work and yet store up treasure for tomorrow, while another may work yet be anxious about nothing. Anxiousness and work are not the same thing. A person does not work because he trusts in his work, but so that he may share with those in need. And what was said to Martha does not refer to tasks and working, but to this: that we must know the right time and not spend on bodily matters the time meant for listening. Christ did not speak those words to urge her toward laziness, but to fix her attention on listening. I came, He says, to teach you necessary things, but you are worried about a meal. Do you want to receive Me and provide Me with an expensive table? Provide a different kind of hospitality by giving Me your full attention and by imitating your sister's eagerness for instruction. He did not say this to forbid her hospitality—far from it! How could He?—but to show that she should not be busy with other matters during the time for listening. When He says, "Labor not for the meat that perishes," He is not suggesting that we should be idle (in fact, this most especially is meat that perishes, since idleness tends to teach every kind of wickedness), but that we should work and share. This is food that never perishes. But if anyone is lazy and gluttonous and cares only for luxury, that person works for the meat that perishes. Likewise, if someone through his labor feeds Christ, gives Him drink, and clothes Him, who would be so senseless and insane as to say that such a person labors for the meat that perishes, when this has the promise of the kingdom to come and those good things? This food endures forever. But at that time, since the crowds paid no attention to what really mattered and did not seek to learn who was doing these things and by what power, but wanted only one thing—to fill their stomachs without working—Christ rightly called such food "meat that perishes." I fed your bodies, He says, so that afterward you might seek that other food which endures, which nourishes the soul. But you run after what is earthly again. Therefore you do not understand that I am leading you not to this imperfect food, but to that which gives not temporary but eternal life, which nourishes not the body but the soul. Then, after He had spoken such great things about Himself and said that He would give this food, in order that His words might not create a stumbling block, He attributes the provision to the Father to make His statement believable. After saying, "Which the Son of Man shall give you," He adds, "Him has God the Father sealed"—that is, has sent Him for this purpose, so that He might bring this food to you. This statement also allows another interpretation. In another place Christ says, "He that hears My words has set to his seal that God is true"—that is, has shown forth undeniably. The expression here seems to hint at this as well, for "the Father has sealed" means nothing else than "has declared, has revealed by His testimony." He declared Himself as well, but since He was speaking to Jews, He brought forward the testimony of the Father.

These passages show a yet more decided opposition as to the letter; we must therefore now bring forward the solution. What then must be our reply? That to take no thought, does not mean not to work, but not to be nailed to the things of this life; that is, to take no care for tomorrow's ease, but to deem that superfluous. For a man may do no work, and (yet) lay up treasure for the morrow; and a man may work, yet be careful for nothing; for carefulness and work are not the same thing; it is not as trusting to his work that a man works, but, that he may impart to him that needs. And that too which was said to Martha refers not to works and working, but to this, that it is our duty to know the right season, and not to spend on carnal things the time proper for listening. Thus Christ spoke not the words as urging her to idleness, but to rivet her to listening. I came, says He, to teach you needful things, but you are anxious about a meal. Do you desire to receive Me, and to provide for Me a costly table? Provide another sort of entertainment, by giving me a ready hearing, and by imitating your sister's longing for instruction. He said not this to forbid her hospitality, (away with the thought! How could that be?) but to show that she ought not in the season for listening be busy about other matters. For to say, Labor not for the meat that perishes, is not the expression of one implying that we ought to be idle; (in fact, this most especially is meat that perishes, for idleness is wont to teach all wickedness;) but that we ought to work, and to impart. This is meat that never perishes; but if any be idle and gluttonous, and cares for luxury, that man works for the meat that perishes. So too, if a man by his labor should feed Christ, and give Him drink, and clothe Him, who so senseless and mad as to say that such an one labors for the meat that perishes, when there is for this the promise of the kingdom that is to come, and of those good things? This meat endures forever. But at that time, since the multitudes made no account of filth, nor sought to learn who it was that did these things, and by what power, but desired one thing only, to fill their bellies without working; Christ with good reason called such food, meat that perishes. I fed, He says, your bodies, that after this ye might seek that other food which endures, which nourishes the soul; but you again run after that which is earthy. Therefore ye do not understand that I lead you not to this imperfect food, but to that which gives not temporal but eternal life, which nourishes not the body but the soul. Then when He had uttered such great words concerning Himself, and had said that He would give this food, in order that what was spoken might not stand in their way, to make His saying credible He attributes the supply to the Father. For after saying, Which the Son of Man shall give you; He adds, Him has God the Father sealed, that is, has sent Him for this purpose, that He might bring the food to you. The saying also admits of another interpretation; for in another place Christ says, He that hears My words, has set to his seal that God is true John 3:33, that is, has showed forth undeniably. Which indeed the expression seems to me to hint at even in this place, for the Father has sealed, is nothing else than has declared, has revealed by His testimony. He in fact declared Himself too, but since He was speaking to Jews, He brought forward the testimony of the Father.

Let us learn, beloved, to ask God for the things we ought to ask of Him. Those other things—the ones belonging to this life—cannot really harm us, however they turn out. If we are rich, we will enjoy our luxury only here. If we fall into poverty, we will suffer nothing terrible. Neither the splendors nor the pains of this present life have much power to cause deep sadness or pleasure; they are insignificant and pass away very quickly. This is why they are rightly called a way, because they pass on and by their very nature do not last long. But the things to come last forever, both those of punishment and those of the Kingdom. So let us be very diligent concerning these things, to avoid the first and choose the last. For what advantage is there in this world's luxury? Today it exists, tomorrow it does not. Today a bright flower, tomorrow scattered dust. Today a burning fire, tomorrow smoldering ashes. But spiritual things are not like this. They remain shining and blooming forever, and become brighter every day. That wealth never perishes, never departs, never ceases, never brings with it worry or envy or blame. It does not destroy the body or corrupt the soul. It is without ill will and does not heap up malice—all of which accompany the other kind of wealth. That honor does not lift people into foolishness or make them arrogant. It never ceases or grows dim. Again, the rest and delight of heaven endures continually, always unchanging and immortal. One cannot find its end or limit. Let us desire this life, for if we do, we will make no account of present things. We will despise and mock at them all. Even if someone invited us into royal palaces, we would not choose to enter while we have this hope—yet nothing earthly seems closer to happiness than such an invitation. But to those possessed by love of heaven, even this seems small and mean and unworthy of consideration. Nothing that comes to an end is greatly to be desired. Whatever ceases, existing today but not tomorrow, even if very great, seems very small and contemptible. So let us not cling to fleeting things that slip away and depart, but to those that are enduring and immovable. May we all attain these through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom and with whom, to the Father and the Holy Spirit, be glory, now and ever and world without end. Amen.

2. Learn we then, beloved, to ask of God the things which it is meet for us to ask of Him. For those other things, those, I mean, which belong to this life, whichever way they may fall out, can do us no injury; for if we be rich, it is here only that we shall enjoy our luxury; and if we fall into poverty, we shall suffer nothing terrible. For neither the splendors nor the pains of the present life have much power in respect either of despondency or pleasure, they are contemptible, and slip away very swiftly. Wherefore they are called a way, with reason, because they pass away, and by their very nature do not long endure, but the things which are to come endure eternally, both those of punishment and those of the Kingdom. Let us then in regard of these things use much diligence to avoid the first and to choose the last. For what is the advantage of this world's luxury? Today it is, and tomorrow it is not; today a bright flower, tomorrow scattered dust; today a burning fire, tomorrow smouldering ashes. But spiritual things are not so, they ever remain shining and blooming, and becoming brighter every day. That wealth never perishes, never departs, never ceases, never brings with it care or envy or blame, destroys not the body, corrupts not the soul, is without ill will, heaps not up malice; all which things attend on the other kind of wealth. That honor lifts not men into folly, does not make them puffed up, never ceases nor is dimmed. Again, the rest and delight of heaven endures continually, ever being immovable and immortal, one cannot find its end or limit. This life then let us desire, for if we do so we shall make no account of present things, but shall despise and mock at them all, and though one should bid us enter into kingly halls, we shall not while we have this hope choose to do so; yet nothing (earthly) seems more near to happiness than such a permission; but to those who are possessed by love of heaven, even this seems little and mean, and worthy of no account. Nothing which comes to an end is to be much desired; whatever ceases, and today is and tomorrow is not, even though it be very great, yet seems to be very little and contemptible. Then let us not cling to fleeting things which slip away and depart, but to those which are enduring and immovable. To which may we all attain, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom and with whom, to the Father and the Holy Ghost, be glory, now and ever and world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 43 — John 6:16-18

Homily 43 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240143.htm>.

Contents · 7 chapters
  1. John 6:16-18
  2. John 6:19
  3. John 6:20
  4. John 6:21
  5. John 6:22
  6. John 6:24
  7. John 6:25

John 6:16-18

Christ provides for the good of his disciples not only when He is physically present, but also when far away; for having abundant means and skill, He accomplishes one and the same end through opposite actions. Notice, for example, what He has done here. He leaves His disciples and goes up into a mountain; and they, when evening had come, went down to the sea. They waited for Him until evening, expecting that He would come to them; but when evening had come, they could no longer bear not to seek their Master; so great a love possessed them. They did not say, It is now evening, and night has overtaken us, where shall we go? The place is dangerous, the time unsafe; but, driven by their longing, they entered into the boat. For the Evangelist has not mentioned the time without reason, but to show the warmth of their love.

1. Christ provides for the good of his disciples not only when He is present in the body, but also when far away; for having abundance of means and of skill, He effects one and the same end by contrary actions. Observe, for instance, what He has done here. He leaves His disciples, and goes up into a mountain; and they, when even had come, went down unto the sea. They waited for Him until evening, expecting that He would come unto them; but when even had come, they could no longer endure not to seek their Master; so great a love possessed them. They said not, It is now evening, and night has overtaken us, whither shall we depart? The place is dangerous, the time unsafe; but, goaded by their longing, they entered into the ship. For it is not without a cause that the Evangelist has declared the time also, but by it to show the warmth of their love.

Why then does Christ let them go and not show Himself? And again, why does He show Himself walking alone on the sea? By the first action He teaches them how great an evil it is to be forsaken by Him, and makes their longing greater. By the second action, again, He shows forth His power. For just as in His teaching they did not hear everything in common with the crowd, so in the case of the miracles they did not see them all with the mass of people, since it was necessary that those who were about to receive the responsibility of governing the world should have something more than the rest. And what kind of miracles, someone asks, did they see by themselves? The Transfiguration on the mountain, this one on the sea, and those after the Resurrection, which are many and important. And from these I conclude that there were others also. They came to Capernaum without any certain information, but expecting to find Him there or even in mid-journey. This the Evangelist implies by saying that it was now dark and Jesus had not yet come to them.

Wherefore then does Christ let them go, and not show Himself? And again, wherefore does He show Himself walking alone upon the sea? By the first He teaches them how great (an evil) it is to be forsaken by Him, and makes their longing greater; by the second, again, He shows forth His power. For as in His teaching they heard not all in common with the multitude, so in the case of the miracles they saw them not all with the mass of people, since it was needful that they who were about to receive in charge the presidency of the world, should have somewhat more than the rest. And what sort of miracles, says some one, saw they by themselves? The Transfiguration on the mount; this on the sea, and those after the Resurrection, which are many and important. And from these I conjecture that there were others also. They came to Capernaum without any certain information, but expecting to find Him there, or even in mid passage; this the Evangelist implies by saying that it was now dark, and Jesus was not yet come to them.

And the sea rose up because of a strong wind that was blowing. What did they do? They were troubled, for there were many different causes that forced them to be so. They were afraid because of the time, since it was dark; because of the storm, since the sea had risen; and because of the place, since they were not near land; but,

And the sea arose by reason of a great wind that blew. What did they? They were troubled, for there were many and various causes which forced them to be so. They were afraid by reason of the time for it was dark, of the storm for the sea had risen, of the place for they were not near land; but,

John 6:19

And finally, because the event was so unusual, for,

And, lastly, by reason of the strangeness of the thing, for,

They see Him walking on the sea. And when they were greatly troubled,

They see Him walking upon the sea. And when they were greatly troubled,

John 6:20

Why then does He appear? To show that it was He who would make the storm cease. For this is what the Evangelist has shown by saying,

Wherefore then appears He? To show that it was He who would make the storm cease. For this the Evangelist has shown, saying,

John 6:21

He not only gave them a safe journey, but also one with favorable winds.

He not only gave them a safe passage, but also one with a fair wind.

To the crowd He did not show Himself walking on the sea, because the miracle was too great for their weakness. In fact, even the disciples did not see Him doing this for long, but He appeared and immediately withdrew. Now this seems to me to be a different miracle from the one found in Matthew 14, and that it is different is clear from many reasons. For He often performs the same miracles in order to cause those who see them not merely to consider them very remarkable, but also to receive them with great faith.

To the multitude He shows not Himself walking upon the sea, for the miracle was too great to suit their infirmity. Indeed, even by the disciples He was not seen long doing this, but He appeared, and at once retired. Now this seems to me to be a different miracle from that found in Matthew xiv.; and that it is different is clear from many reasons. For He works often the same miracles, in order to cause the beholders not merely to count them very strange, but also to receive them with great faith.

It is I, be not afraid. As He spoke these words, He drove fear from their hearts. But at another time it was not like this; that is why Peter said, Lord, if it is You, command me to come to You. Matthew 14:28 Why is it that at that time they did not immediately accept this, but now they were convinced? It was because then the storm continued to batter the boat, but now at His voice the calm had arrived. Or if the reason is not this, it is the other one I mentioned before: that by repeatedly working the same miracles, He made the second one readily accepted through the first. But why did He not go up into the ship? Because He wanted to make the marvel greater, to reveal His Godhead to them more openly, and to show them that when He gave thanks before, He did not do so because He needed help, but out of condescension to them. He allowed the storm to arise so that they might always seek Him; He stilled the storm so that He might make His power known to them; He did not go up into the ship so that He might make the marvel greater.

It is I, be not afraid. As He spoke the word, He cast out fear from their souls. But at another time not so; wherefore Peter said, Lord, if it be Thou, bid me to come unto You. Matthew 14:28 Whence then was it that at that time they did not straightway admit this, but now were persuaded? It was because then the storm continued to toss the bark, but now at His voice the calm had come. Or if the reason be not this, it is that other which I have before mentioned, that oftentimes working the same miracles, He made the second to be readily received by means of the first. But wherefore went He not up into the ship? Because He would make the marvel greater, would more openly reveal to them His Godhead, and would show them, that when He before gave thanks, He did not so as needing aid, but in condescension to them. He allowed the storm to arise, that they might ever seek Him; He stilled the storm, that He might make known to them His power; He went not up into the ship, that He might make the marvel greater.

John 6:22

And why is John so precise? Why didn't he simply say that the crowds crossed over the next day and left? He wants to teach us something else—that Jesus allowed the crowds, if not openly then at least in a hidden way, to suspect what had happened. For it says, "They saw that there was no other boat there except one, and that Jesus did not get into it with His disciples."

And why is John so exact? Why said he not that the multitudes having passed over on the next day departed? He desires to teach us something else, namely, that Jesus allowed the multitudes if not openly, at least in a secret manner, to suspect what had taken place. For, They saw, says he, that there was none other boat there but one, and that Jesus went not into it with His disciples.

John 6:24

What else could they think except that He had gotten there by walking across the sea? For it wasn't possible to say that He had crossed in another ship. There was only one ship, the Evangelist says, and His disciples got into it. Yet when they came to Him after such a great wonder, they didn't ask Him how He crossed over, how He arrived there, or try to understand such a great sign. But what do they say?

What else then could they suspect, save that He had arrived there crossing the sea on foot? For it was not possible to say that He had passed over in another ship. For there was one, says the Evangelist, into which His disciples entered. Still when they came to Him after so great a wonder, they asked Him not how He crossed over, how He arrived there, nor sought to understand so great a sign. But what say they?

John 6:25

Unless someone claims that the word "when" is being used by them in the sense of "how." But it is also worth noticing here the fickleness of their impulses. For those who said, "This is that Prophet," those who were eager to take Him and make Him a king, now when they have found Him take no such action, but having cast out their astonishment, they no longer admire Him for His former deeds. They sought Him, desiring again to enjoy a table like the first.

2. Unless any one affirm that the when is here used by them in the sense of how. But it is worth while also to notice here the fickleness of their impulses For they who said, This is that Prophet; they who were anxious to take Him and make Him a king, now when they have found Him take no such counsel, but having cast out their astonishment, they no longer admire Him for His former deeds. They sought Him, desiring again to enjoy a table like the first.

The Jews under Moses' leadership crossed the Red Sea, but that situation is very different from this one. Moses did everything through prayer and as a servant, but Christ acted with absolute power. In that case, when the south wind blew, the water gave way so they could cross over on dry land, but here the miracle was greater. For the sea, while keeping its own physis, carried its Lord on its surface, confirming the Scripture that says, "Who walks upon the sea as upon a pavement."

The Jews under the guidance of Moses passed over the Red Sea, but that case is widely different from this. He did all with prayer and as a servant, but Christ with absolute power. There when the south wind blew, the water yielded so as to make them pass over on dry land, but here the miracle was greater. Exodus 14:21 For the sea retaining its proper nature so bare its Lord upon its surface, thus testifying to the Scripture which says, Who walks upon the sea as upon a pavement. Job 9:8

And with good reason, when He was about to enter stubborn and disobedient Capernaum, He performed the miracle of the loaves, wanting to soften its disobedience not only through what happened inside the city but also through the miracles that were done outside it. For wasn't it enough to soften even a stone that such crowds should come with great eagerness to that city? Yet they had no such response, but instead desired food for the body again, for which Jesus also rebukes them.

And with reason, when He was about to enter into stubborn and disobedient Capernaum, did He work the miracle of the loaves, as desiring not only by what took place within, but also by the miracles which were wrought without the city, to soften its disobedience. For was it not enough to soften even any stone, that such multitudes should come with great eagerness to that city? Yet they had no such feeling, but again desired food for the body; for which also they are reproached by Jesus.

My dear friends, since we know these things, let us give thanks to God for physical things, but much more for spiritual things. For this is His will, and it is on account of the spiritual things that He gives the physical ones, using them to lead in those who are less mature and to instruct them in advance, because they are still fixated on the world. But when such people receive these worldly things and find their satisfaction in them, then they are reproached and rebuked. In the case of the paralytic, Christ wanted first to give what was spiritual, but those who were present could not bear it. For when He said, "Your sins are forgiven you," they cried out, "This man blasphemes." Let us not, I beg you, be like this, but let us value spiritual things more highly. Why? Because when spiritual things are present with us, no harm comes from the absence of physical things; but when they are not present, what hope or comfort will remain for us? Therefore we should always call upon God for these spiritual things and beg Him for them. And Christ has also taught us to pray for such things. For if we examine that Prayer, we will find that there is nothing carnal in it, but everything spiritual, and even the small part that seems to relate to the senses becomes spiritual by the manner in which it is expressed. For to tell us to ask for no more than our successive, that is, our daily bread, would show a spiritual mind that is truly wise. And consider what comes before that: "Hallowed be Your Name, Your kingdom come, Your will be done as in heaven so on earth." Then, after mentioning that temporal need, He quickly leaves it and brings us back to the spiritual teaching, saying, "Forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors." Nowhere has He included in the Prayer riches or glory or power, but only things that contribute to the benefit of the soul—nothing earthly, but all things heavenly. If then we are commanded to refrain from the things of this present life, how could we help being wretched and miserable if we ask from God those things which, even when we have them, He tells us to cast away in order to free us from anxiety about them, and for which He tells us to take no trouble? This is using vain repetition, and this is why we accomplish nothing by our prayers. How then, someone asks, do the wicked grow rich, how do the unjust and impure, plunderers and greedy people? Not by God's giving—far from it!—but by plundering and taking more than their due. And how does God allow them? As He allowed that rich man, reserving him for greater punishment. Hear what Abraham says to him: "Son, you in your lifetime received your good things, and likewise Lazarus evil things, but now he is comforted, and you are tormented." Therefore, so that we also do not come to hear that voice by living softly and idly and gathering together many sins for ourselves, let us choose the true riches and right wisdom, so that we may obtain the promised good things. May we all arrive at them through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom and with whom, to the Father and the Holy Spirit, be glory, now and ever and world without end. Amen.

Let us then, beloved, knowing these things, give thanks to God for things of sense, but much more for things spiritual; for such is His will, and it is on account of the latter that He gives the former, leading in, as it were, by these the more imperfect sort, and giving them previous teaching, because they are yet gaping upon the world. But when such persons having received these worldly things, rest in them, then are they upbraided and rebuked. For in the case of him that had the palsy, Christ wished first to give that which was spiritual, but they that were present endured it not; for when He said, Your sins be forgiven you, they exclaimed, This man blasphemes. Matthew 9:2 Let us not, I entreat you, be so affected, but let us make more account of those (spiritual) things. Wherefore? Because when spiritual things are present with us, no harm arises from the absence of fleshly things; but when they are not, what hope, what comfort, shall then remain to us? Wherefore it is for these we ought always to call upon God, and entreat Him for them. And for such has Christ also taught us to pray; for if we unfold that Prayer, we shall find that there is nothing carnal in it, but all spiritual, and that even the small portion which seems to relate to sense, becomes by the manner spiritual. For to bid us ask no more than our successive, that is, our daily, bread, would mark a mind spiritual and truly wise. And consider what goes before that, Hallowed be Your Name, Your kingdom come, Your will be done as in heaven so on earth; then, after naming that temporal (need), He quickly leaves it, and brings us again to the spiritual doctrine, saying, Forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors. Nowhere has He put in the Prayer riches or glory or dominion, but all things contributing to the benefit of the soul; nothing earthly, but all things heavenly. If then we are bidden to refrain from the things of this present life, how could we help being wretched and miserable, asking from God those things which even having He bids us cast away, to free us from care about them, and for which He bids us take no pains. This is the using vain repetition; and this is why we effect nothing by our prayers. How then, says some one, do the wicked grow rich, how the unjust and impure, plunderers and covetous? Not by God's giving; (away with the thought!) but by plundering, and taking more than their due. And how does God allow them? As He allowed that rich man, reserving him for greater punishment. Luke 16:25 Hear what ( Abraham) says to him; Son, thou in your lifetime received your good things, and likewise Lazarus evil things, but now he is comforted, and you are tormented. Therefore that we also come not to hear that voice, by living softly and idly, and gathering together for ourselves many sins, let us choose the true riches and right wisdom, that we may obtain the promised good things; to which may we all arrive, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom and with whom, to the Father and the Holy Ghost, be glory, now and ever and world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 42 — John 6:1-4

Homily 42 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240142.htm>.

Contents · 5 chapters
  1. John 6:1-4
  2. John 6:4
  3. John 6:5
  4. John 6:5
  5. John 6:7

John 6:1-4

Dear friends, let us not fight with violent people, but learn that when doing so brings no harm to our virtue, we should give way to their evil plans; for in this way all their aggression is stopped. Just as arrows, when they strike a firm, hard, and resisting surface, bounce back with great force on those who throw them, but when the force of the throw has nothing to oppose it, it soon becomes weaker and stops, so it is with insolent people; when we fight with them they become fiercer, but when we yield and give ground, we easily calm all their madness. Therefore the Lord, when He knew that the Pharisees had heard that Jesus made and baptized more disciples than John, went into Galilee, to extinguish their envy, and to soften by His withdrawal the anger which was likely to be produced by these reports. And when He departed for the second time into Galilee, He does not come to the same places as before; for He did not go to Cana, but to the other side of the sea, and great crowds followed Him, watching the miracles which He did. What miracles? Why does he not mention them specifically? Because this Evangelist most of all desired to use the greater part of his book on the discourses and sermons of Christ. Notice, for instance, how for a whole year, or rather how even now at the feast of the Passover, he has given us no more information on the subject of miracles, than merely that He healed the paralytic and the nobleman's son. Because he was not eager to list them all, (that would have been impossible,) but out of many and great ones to record a few.

1. Beloved, let us not contend with violent men, but learn when the doing so brings no hurt to our virtue to give place to their evil counsels; for so all their hardihood is checked. As darts when they fall upon a firm, hard, and resisting substance, rebound with great violence on those who throw them, but when the violence of the cast has nothing to oppose it, it soon becomes weaker and ceases, so is it with insolent men; when we contend with them they become the fiercer, but when we yield and give ground, we easily abate all their madness. Wherefore the Lord when He knew that the Pharisees had heard that Jesus made and baptized more disciples than John, went into Galilee, to quench their envy, and to soften by His retirement the wrath which was likely to be engendered by these reports. And when He departed for the second time into Galilee, He comes not to the same places as before; for He went not to Cana, but to the other side of the sea, and great multitudes followed Him, beholding the miracles which He did. What miracles? Why does he not mention them specifically? Because this Evangelist most of all was desirous of employing the greater part of his book on the discourses and sermons [of Christ]. Observe, for instance, how for a whole year, or rather how even now at the feast of the Passover, he has given us no more information on the head of miracles, than merely that He healed the paralytic and the nobleman's son. Because he was not anxious to enumerate them all, (that would have been impossible,) but of many and great to record a few.

Verse 2. A great multitude followed Him beholding the miracles that He did. What is described here does not indicate a very wise state of mind, because even though they had received such teaching, they were still more attracted by the miracles, which was a sign of a cruder condition. For miracles, it says, are not for believers, but for unbelievers. The people described by Matthew did not act this way, but how? They were all astonished at His teaching, he says, because He taught as one having authority. Matthew 7:28-29

Ver. 2. A great multitude followed Him beholding the miracles that He did. What is here told marks not a very wise state of mind; for when they had enjoyed such teaching, they still were more attracted by the miracles, which was a sign of the grosser state. For miracles, It says, are not for believers, but for unbelievers. The people described by Matthew acted not thus, but how? They all, he says were astonished at His doctrine, because He taught as one having authority. Matthew 7:28-29

And why does He go to the mountain now and sit there with His disciples? It's because of the miracle that was about to happen. The fact that only the disciples went up with Him was a charge against the crowd that didn't follow Him. But He didn't go up the mountain only for this reason; He went also to teach us always to take breaks from the noise and confusion of everyday life. For solitude is appropriate for the pursuit of wisdom. And He often goes up alone into a mountain and spends the night there praying, to teach us that the person who wants to draw nearest to God must be free from all disturbance and must seek times and places that are free from confusion.

And why does He occupy the mountain now, and sit there with His disciples? Because of the miracle which was about to take place. And that the disciples alone went up with Him, was a charge against the multitude which followed Him not. Yet not for this only did He go up into the mountain, but to teach us ever to rest at intervals from the tumults and confusion of common life. For solitude is a thing meet for the study of wisdom. And often does He go up alone into a mountain, and spend the night there, and pray, to teach us that the man who will come most near to God must be free from all disturbance, and must seek times and places clear of confusion.

John 6:4

How then, someone asks, does He not go up to the feast, but when everyone is hurrying to Jerusalem, He Himself goes into Galilee, and not alone but takes His disciples with Him, and travels from there to Capernaum? Because from this point on He was quietly setting aside the Law, using the wickedness of the Jews as His occasion.

How then, says some one, does He not go up unto the feast, but, when all are pressing to Jerusalem, goes Himself into Galilee, and not Himself alone, but takes His disciples with Him, and proceeds thence to Capernaum? Because henceforth He was quietly annulling the Law, taking occasion from the wickedness of. the Jews.

John 6:5

This shows that He never sat idly with the disciples, but was perhaps carefully talking with them and making them pay attention and turn toward Him—something that especially demonstrates His tender care and the humility and condescension of His manner toward them. For they sat with Him, perhaps looking at one another; then, having lifted up His eyes, He saw the crowds coming to Him. Now the other Evangelists say that the disciples came and asked and begged Him not to send them away hungry, while St. John says that the question was put to Philip by Christ. Both accounts seem to me to be truly reported, but not to have happened at the same time, with the former account being earlier than the other, so that the two are entirely different.

This shows that He sat not at any time idly with the disciples, but perhaps carefully conversing with them, and making them attend and turn towards Him, a thing which peculiarly marks His tender care, and the humility and condescension of His demeanor towards them. For they sat with Him, perhaps looking at one another; then having lifted up His eyes, He beheld the multitudes coming unto Him. Now the other Evangelists say, that the disciples came and asked and besought Him that He would not send them away fasting, while St. John says, that the question was put to Philip by Christ. Both occurrences seem to me to be truly reported, but not to have taken place at the same time, the former account being prior to the other, so that the two are entirely different.

Why then does He ask Philip? He knew which of His disciples needed the most instruction, for this is the one who later said, "Show us the Father, and it is enough for us" (John 14:8). For this reason Jesus was preparing him in advance. If the miracle had simply been performed, it would not have seemed so amazing, but now He first makes him acknowledge the existing need, so that knowing the situation he might understand more precisely the greatness of the miracle that was about to happen. Therefore He says…

Wherefore then does He ask Philip? He knew which of His disciples needed most instruction; for this is he who afterwards said, Show us the Father, and it suffices us John 14:8, and on this account Jesus was beforehand bringing him into a proper state. For had the miracle simply been done, the marvel would not have seemed so great, but now He beforehand constrains him to confess the existing want, that knowing the state of matters he might be the more exactly acquainted with the magnitude of the miracle about to take place. Wherefore He says…

John 6:5

So in the Old Testament He spoke to Moses, for He did not perform the sign until He had asked him, "What is that in your hand?" Because things that happen unexpectedly and all at once tend to make us forget what came before, He first drew him into acknowledging the present situation, so that when the astonishment came upon him, he would not be able to push away the memory of what he had acknowledged, and thus he would learn by comparison the greatness of the miracle, which in fact happens in this case; for Philip, being asked, replied,

So in the Old [Testament] He spoke to Moses, for He wrought not the sign until He had asked him, What is that in your hand? Because things coming to pass unexpectedly and all at once, are wont to throw us into forgetfulness of things previous, therefore He first involved him in a confession of present circumstances, that when the astonishment should have come upon him, he might be unable afterwards to drive away the remembrance of what he had confessed, and thus might learn by comparison the greatness of the miracle, which in fact takes place in this instance; for Philip being asked, replied,

John 6:7

What does it mean "to prove him"? Did He not know what Philip would say? We cannot claim that. Then what does this expression mean? We can find the answer from the Old Testament. There too it says, "And it came to pass after these things that God did tempt Abraham, and said to him, Take your beloved son whom you love" (Genesis 22:1-2). Yet even in that passage it does not appear that when He says this, He waited to see how the trial would turn out—whether Abraham would obey or not. How could He wait, since He knows all things before they happen? Rather, the words in both cases are spoken in the manner of human beings. For just as when the Psalmist says that He searches the hearts of men, he does not mean a search done in ignorance but one of exact knowledge, so also when the Evangelist says that He proved Philip, he means only that He knew exactly. And perhaps we might say something else: that just as He once made Abraham more approved, so also He did the same with this man, bringing him through this question to an exact knowledge of the miracle. Therefore the Evangelist, so that you may not stop at the weak nature of the expression and form an improper opinion of what was said, adds, "He Himself knew what He would do."

2. What means, to prove him? Did not He know what would be said by him? We cannot assert that. What then is the meaning of the expression? We may discover it from the Old [Testament]. For there too it is said, And it came to pass after these things that God did tempt Abraham, and said to him, Take your beloved son whom you love Genesis 22:1-2; yet it does not appear in that place either, that when He says this He waited to see the end of the trial, whether Abraham would obey or not, (how could He, who knows all things before they come into existence? but the words in both cases are spoken after the manner of men. For as when (the Psalmist) says that He searches the hearts of men, he means not a search of ignorance but of exact knowledge, just so when the Evangelist says that He proved (Philip), he means only that He knew exactly. And perhaps one might say another thing, that as He once made Abraham more approved, so also did He this man, bringing him by this question to an exact knowledge of the miracle. The Evangelist therefore, that you may not stop at the feebleness of the expression, and so form an improper opinion of what was said, adds, He Himself knew what He would do.

Moreover, we must notice that whenever there is any mistaken assumption, the writer immediately corrects it very carefully. So in this passage, to prevent the hearers from forming such an assumption, he adds the correction, saying, "For He Himself knew what He would do." Similarly in that other passage, when he says that the Jews persecuted Him because He not only had broken the Sabbath but also said that God was His Father, making Himself equal with God—had there not been Christ's own assertion confirmed by His works, the writer would have added this correction there as well. For if even in words that Christ speaks, the Evangelist is careful that no one should have mistaken assumptions, much more in cases where others were speaking about Him would he have watched closely, had he perceived that an improper opinion prevailed concerning Him. But he did not do so, for he knew that this was His meaning and firm decree. Therefore, after saying "making Himself equal with God," he did not use any such correction; for what was spoken of was not a mistaken notion of theirs, but His own assertion confirmed by His works. So Philip, having been questioned,

Moreover we must observe this, that when there is any wrong suspicion, the writer straightway very carefully corrects it. As then in this place that the hearers might not form any such suspicion, he adds the corrective, saying, For He Himself knew what He would do: so also in that other place, when He says, that the Jews persecuted Him, because He not only had broken the Sabbath, but said also that God was His Father, making Himself equal with God, had there not been the assertion of Christ Himself confirmed by His works, he would there also have subjoined this correction. For if even in words which Christ speaks the Evangelist is careful that none should have suspicions, much more in cases where others were speaking of Him would he have looked closely, had he perceived that an improper opinion prevailed concerning Him. But he did not so, for he knew that this was His meaning, and immovable decree. Therefore after saying, making Himself equal with God, he used not any such correction; for the matter spoken of was not an erroneous fancy of theirs, but His own assertion ratified by His works. Philip then having been questioned,

Verse 8-9: Andrew, Simon's brother, said, "There is a boy here who has five barley loaves and two small fish, but what good are these among so many people?"

Ver. 8, 9. Andrew, Simon's brother, said, There is a lad here, which has five barley loaves, and two small fishes: but what are they among so many?

Andrew has a higher understanding than Philip, but he still had not grasped everything. Yet I do not think he spoke without purpose, but rather because he had heard of the miracles of the Prophets, and how Elisha performed a sign with the loaves (2 Kings 4:43). For this reason he rose to a certain level, but could not reach the very top.

Andrew is higher minded than Philip, yet had not he attained to everything. Yet I do not think that he spoke without an object, but as having heard of the miracles of the Prophets, and how Elisha wrought a sign with the loaves 2 Kings 4:43; on this account he mounted to a certain height, but could not attain to the very top.

Let us learn, then, we who indulge in luxury, what kind of food those great and admirable men ate. Let us observe and imitate both the quality and quantity of their frugal meals.

Let us learn then, we who give ourselves to luxury, what was the fare of those great and admirable men; and in quality and quantity let us behold and imitate the thriftiness of their table.

What follows also shows great weakness. For after saying, "has five barley loaves," he adds, "but what are they among so many?" He assumed that the Worker of the miracle would make less from less, and more from more. But this was not the case, since it was equally easy for Him to cause bread to spring forth from more or from less, because He needed no underlying material. But so that the creation might not seem alien to His Wisdom, as later slanderers and those infected with the disease of Marcion said, He used the creation itself as a foundation for His miracles.

What follows also expresses great weakness. For after saying, has five barley loaves, he adds, but what are they among so many? He supposed that the Worker of the miracle would make less out of less, and more out of more. But this was not the case, for it was alike easy to Him to cause bread to spring forth from more and from less, since He needed no subject-matter. But in order that the creation might not seem foreign to His Wisdom, as afterwards slanderers and those affected with the disease of Marcion said, He used the creation itself as a groundwork for His marvels.

When both the disciples had admitted they were at a loss, then He performed the miracle. They benefited more this way, having first acknowledged how difficult the matter was, so that when it happened, they would understand the power of God. And because a miracle was about to be performed—one that had also been done by the Prophets, though not to an equal degree—and because He would do it after first giving thanks, He made sure they would not fall into any suspicion that He was weak. Notice how by the very way He worked, He completely elevated their understanding of it and showed them the difference between Himself and others. For when the loaves had not yet appeared—so that you may learn that things that do not exist are to Him as though they did exist (as Paul says, who calls the things that are not as though they were, Romans 4:17)—He commanded them, as though the table were already prepared and ready, to sit down immediately, thus stirring up the minds of His disciples. And because they had benefited from the questioning, they immediately obeyed and were not confused, nor did they say, "How is this? Why do You tell us to sit down when there is nothing before us?" These same men, who at first disbelieved so much as to say, "Where shall we buy bread?" now believed, even before they saw the miracle, enough to readily make the crowds sit down.

When both the disciples had owned themselves at a loss, then He wrought the miracle; for thus they profited the more, having first confessed the difficulty of the matter, that when it should come to pass, they might understand the power of God. And because a miracle was about to be wrought, which had also been performed by the Prophets, although not in an equal degree, and because He would do it after first giving thanks, lest they should fall into any suspicion of weakness on His part, observe how by the very manner of His working He entirely raises their thoughts of it and shows them the difference (between Himself and others). For when the loaves had not yet appeared, that you may learn, that things that are not are to Him as though they were, (as Paul says, who calls the things that be not as though they were Romans 4:17) He commanded them as though the table were prepared and ready, straightway to sit down, rousing by this the minds of His disciples. And because they had profited by the questioning, they immediately obeyed, and were not confounded, nor said, How is this, why dost Thou bid us sit down, when there is nothing before us? The same men, who at first disbelieved so much as to say, Whence shall we buy bread? began so far to believe even before they saw the miracle, that they readily made the multitudes to sit down.

But why didn't He pray when He was about to heal the paralytic, or when He was raising the dead, or calming the sea, yet He does so here over the loaves? It was to show that when we begin our meals, we ought to give thanks to God. Furthermore, He does this especially in a lesser matter so that you may learn He doesn't do it from any necessity. For if that were the case, He would have done so much more in greater things. But since He performed those greater works by His own authority, it is clear that when He acted this way in the case of the lesser matter, it was through condescension. Besides, a great crowd was present, and it was necessary that they be persuaded He had come according to the will of God. Therefore, when He performs miracles without witnesses present, He shows nothing of this kind. But when He performs them in the presence of many, in order to persuade them that He is no enemy of God and no adversary of the One who has begotten Him, He removes their suspicion by giving thanks.

3. But why when He was about to restore the paralytic did He not pray, nor when He was raising the dead, or bridling the sea, while He does so here over the loaves? It was to show that when we begin our meals, we ought to give thanks unto God. Moreover, He does it especially in a lesser matter, that you may learn that He does it not as having any need; for were this the case, much more would He have done so in greater things; but when He did them by His own authority, it is clear that it was through condescension that He acted as He did in the case of the lesser. Besides, a great multitude was present, and it was necessary that they should be persuaded that He had come according to the will of God. Wherefore, when He does miracles in the absence of witnesses, He exhibits nothing of the kind; but when He does them in the presence of many, in order to persuade them that He is no enemy of God, no adversary of Him who has begotten Him, He removes the suspicion by thanksgiving.

And He gave to those who were sitting down, and they were satisfied.

And He gave to them that were set down, and they were filled.

Do you see how great the gap is between the servants and the Master? Since they received grace in limited measure, they performed their miracles accordingly, but God, who works with unlimited power, did everything most abundantly.

Do you see how great is the interval between the servants and the Master? They having grace by measure, wrought their miracles accordingly, but God, who acts with free power, did all most abundantly.

Verse 12. And He said to His disciples, "Gather up the fragments that remain," and they gathered them together and filled twelve baskets.

Ver. 12. And He said unto His disciples, Gather up the fragments which remain; — and they gathered them together, and filled twelve baskets.

This was not a pointless display, but was done so that the event would not be considered a mere illusion. For this reason He creates from matter that already exists. But why did He not give the bread to the crowds to carry, but only to His disciples? Because He was especially eager to instruct those who were to be the teachers of the world. The crowd would not yet gain much benefit from the miracles—in fact, they immediately forgot this one and asked for another—while these disciples would gain no small profit. And what took place was also no small condemnation of Judas, who carried a basket. That these things were done for their instruction is clear from what is said later, when He reminded them, saying, "Do you not yet understand—how many baskets you took up?" And for the same reason the baskets of fragments were equal in number to the disciples. Later, when they were more fully instructed, they did not take up so many, but only seven baskets. And I marvel not only at the quantity of loaves created, but beyond the quantity, at the exactness of the surplus—that He caused the extra amount to be neither more nor less than precisely what He willed, foreseeing how much they would consume. This demonstrates unspeakable power. The fragments then confirmed the matter, showing both these points: that what had taken place was no illusion, and that these fragments came from the loaves by which the people had been fed. As for the fishes, at this time they were produced from fish that already existed, but at a later time, after the Resurrection, they were not made from existing matter. Why? So that you may understand that even now He used matter not from necessity, nor because He needed any base to work from, but to silence the heretics.

This was not a superfluous show, but in order that the matter might not be deemed a mere illusion; and for this reason He creates from matter already subsisting. But why gave He not the bread to the multitudes to bear, but (only) to His disciples? Because He was most desirous to instruct these who were to be the teachers of the world. The multitude would not as yet reap any great fruit from the miracles, (at least they straightway forgot this one and asked for another,) while these would gain no common profit. And what took place was moreover no ordinary condemnation of Judas, who bore a basket. And that these things were done for their instruction is plain from what is said afterwards, when He reminded them, saying, Do ye not yet understand — how many baskets ye took up? Matthew 16:9 And for the same reason it was that the baskets of fragments were equal in number to the disciples; afterwards, when they were instructed, they took not up so many, but only seven baskets. Matthew 15:37 And I marvel not only at the quantity of loaves created, but besides the quantity, at the exactness of the surplus, that He caused the superabundance to be neither more nor less than just so much as He willed, foreseeing how much they would consume; a thing which marked unspeakable power. The fragments then confirmed the matter, showing both these points; that what had taken place was no illusion, and that these were from the loaves by which the people had been fed. As to the fishes, they at this time were produced from those already subsisting, but at a later period, after the Resurrection, they were not made from subsisting matter. Wherefore? That you may understand that even now He employed matter, not from necessity, nor as needing any base (to work upon), but to stop the mouths of heretics.

The multitudes said that this is truly the Prophet.

And the multitudes said, that this is of a truth The Prophet.

What excessive gluttony! He had done countless things more admirable than this, but nowhere did they make this confession except when they had been filled. Yet from this it is clear that they expected some remarkable prophet, for those others had said to John, "Are you that Prophet?" while these say, "This is that Prophet."

Oh, excess of gluttony! He had done ten thousand things more admirable than this, but nowhere did they make this confession, save when they had been filled. Yet hence it is evident that they expected some remarkable prophet; for those others had said (to John), Are you that Prophet? while these say, This is that Prophet.

When Jesus realized that they were about to come and take Him by force to make Him a king, He withdrew again to the mountain.

Ver. 15. When Jesus therefore perceived that they would come and take Him by force to make Him a king, He departed again into a mountain.

Wonderful! How great is the tyranny of gluttony, how great the fickleness of human minds! No longer do they defend the Law, no longer do they care about the violation of the Sabbath, no longer are they zealous for God. All such concerns are cast aside when their bellies have been filled. He was a prophet in their eyes, and they were about to choose Him as king. But Christ flees. Why? To teach us to despise worldly honors, and to show us that He needed nothing on earth. For He who chose all things humble—both mother and house and city and upbringing and clothing—would not afterwards be made illustrious by earthly things. The things He had from heaven were glorious and great: angels, a star, His Father proclaiming loudly, the Spirit testifying, and Prophets announcing Him from long ago. Those on earth were all humble, so that His power might appear all the more. He also came to teach us to despise the things of the world, and not to be amazed or astonished by the splendors of this life, but to laugh them all to scorn and to desire those which are to come. For whoever admires things here will not admire those in the heavens. This is also why He says to Pilate, My Kingdom is not of this world (John 18:36), so that He might not afterwards appear to have employed mere human fear or dominion for the purpose of persuasion. Why then does the Prophet say, Behold, your King comes to you, meek, and sitting upon an ass (Zechariah 9:9)? He spoke of that Kingdom which is in the heavens, but not of this one on earth. And for this reason Christ says, I receive not honor from men (John 5:41).

Wonderful! How great is the tyranny of gluttony, how great the fickleness of men's minds! No longer do they vindicate the Law, no longer do they care for the violation of the Sabbath, no longer are they zealous for God; all such considerations are thrown aside, when their bellies have been filled; He was a prophet in their eyes, and they were about to choose Him for a king. But Christ flees. Wherefore? To teach us to despise worldly dignities, and to show us that He needed nothing on earth. For He who chose all things mean, both mother and house and city and nurture and attire would not afterwards be made illustrious by things on earth. The things which (He had) from heaven were glorious and great, angels, a star, His Father loudly speaking, the Spirit testifying, and Prophets proclaiming Him from afar; those on earth were all mean, that thus His power might the more appear. He came also to teach us to despise the things of the world, and not be amazed or astonished by the splendors of this life, but to laugh them all to scorn, and to desire those which are to come. For he who admires things which are here, will not admire those in the heavens. Wherefore also He says to Pilate, My Kingdom is not of this world John 18:36, that He may not afterwards appear to have employed mere human terror or dominion for the purpose of persuasion. Why then says the Prophet, Behold, your King comes unto you, meek, and sitting upon an ass? Zechariah 9:9 He spoke of that Kingdom which is in the heavens, but not of this on earth; and on this account Christ says, I receive not honor from men. John 5:41

Let us learn, beloved, to despise worldly honor and not to desire it, for we have been honored with the greatest of all honors—compared to which worldly honor is truly an insult, ridicule, and mockery. Just as the riches of this world compared to the riches of heaven are poverty, and just as this life apart from eternal life is death (for "let the dead bury their dead" Matthew 8:28), so this honor compared to heavenly honor is shame and ridicule. Let us not pursue it then. If those who give it are worth less than a shadow or a dream, the honor itself is worth even less. "The glory of man is as the flower of the grass" 1 Peter 1:24—and what is more worthless than the flower of the grass? Even if this glory were everlasting, how could it profit the soul? Not at all. In fact, it greatly injures us by making us slaves—slaves in worse condition than those bought with money, slaves who obey not just one master but two, three, or ten thousand, all giving different commands. How much better to be a free person than a slave, to be free from slavery to men and subject only to the dominion of God? In short, if you desire glory, desire it—but let it be immortal glory, for that is displayed on a more glorious stage and brings greater profit. People here demand that you spend money to please them, but Christ, on the contrary, gives you a hundredfold for what you give Him and adds eternal life besides. Which is better then: to be admired on earth or in heaven? By man or by God? To your loss or to your gain? To wear a crown for a single day or for endless ages? Give to the one who needs, but do not give to a dancer, lest you lose your money and destroy his soul. For you are the cause of his coming to perdition through untimely generosity. If those on the stage knew that their work would be unprofitable, they would have ceased practicing it long ago. But when they see you applauding, crowding after them, spending and wasting your wealth on them, even if they have no desire to continue their profession, they are kept to it by the desire for gain. If they knew that no one would praise what they do, they would soon stop their labors because of their unprofitableness. But when they see that many admire their actions, the praise of others becomes a bait to them. Let us then stop this unprofitable spending. Let us learn upon whom and when we ought to spend. Let us not, I beg you, provoke God in both ways—gathering from where we ought not and scattering where we ought not. What anger does your conduct not deserve when you pass by the poor and give to a prostitute? Would not paying the wages of sin and bestowing honor where it would be right to punish be a charge against you, even if you paid from your just earnings? But when you feed your uncleanness by robbing orphans and wronging widows, consider how great a fire is prepared for those who dare such things. Hear what Paul says: "Who not only do these things, but also have pleasure in them that do them" Romans 1:32.

Learn we then, beloved, to despise and not to desire the honor which is from men; for we have been honored with the greatest of honors, compared with which that other is verily insult, ridicule, and mockery. And as the riches of this world compared with the riches of that are poverty, as this life apart from that is deadness, (for let the dead bury their dead Matthew 8:28) so this honor compared with that is shame and ridicule. Let us then not pursue it. If they who confer it are of less account than a shadow or a dream, the honor itself much more so. The glory of man is as the flower of the grass 1 Peter 1:24; and what is meaner than the flower of the grass? Were this glory everlasting, in what could it profit the soul? In nothing. Nay, it very greatly injures us by making us slaves, slaves in worse condition than those bought with money, slaves who obey not one master only, but two, three, ten thousand, all giving different commands. How much better is it to be a free man than a slave, to be free from the slavery of men, and subject only to the dominion of God? In a word, if you will desire glory, desire it, but let it be the glory immortal, for that is exhibited on a more glorious stage, and brings greater profit. For the men here bid you be at charges to please them, but Christ, on the contrary, gives you an hundredfold for what you give Him, and adds moreover eternal life. Which of the two then is better, to be admired on earth, or in heaven? By man, or by God? To your loss, or to your gain? To wear a crown for a single day, or for endless ages? Give to him that needs, but give not to a dancer, lest you lose your money and destroy his soul. For you are the cause of his (coming to) perdition through unseasonable munificence. Since did those on the stage know that their employment would be unprofitable, they would have long ago ceased to practice it; but when they behold you applauding, crowding after them, spending and wasting your substance upon them, even if they have no desire to follow (their profession), they are kept to it by the desire of gain. If they knew that no one would praise what they do, they would soon desist from their labors, by reason of their unprofitableness; but when they see that the action is admired by many, the praise of others becomes a bait to them. Let us then desist from this unprofitable expense, let us learn upon whom and when we ought to spend. Let us not, I implore you, provoke God in both ways, gathering whence we ought not, and scattering where we ought not; for what anger does not your conduct deserve, when you pass by the poor and givest to a harlot? Would not the paying the hire of sin and the bestowing honor where it were meet to punish have been a charge against you, even had you paid out of your just earnings? But when you feed your uncleanness by stripping orphans and wronging widows, consider how great a fire is prepared for those who dare such things. Hear what Paul says, Who not only do these things, but also have pleasure in them that do them. Romans 1:32

Perhaps we have spoken sharply to you, but if we do not speak sharply, there are real punishments waiting for those who sin without repenting. What good does it do to please people with words when they will be punished in reality? Do you take pleasure in watching a dancer, do you praise and admire him? Then you are worse than he is. His poverty gives him an excuse, though not a reasonable one, but you are stripped even of this defense. If I ask him why he has left other trades and come to this cursed and impure one, he will reply that he can gain great profits with little effort. But if I ask you why you admire someone who spends his time in impurity and lives to the harm of many, you cannot run to the same excuse, but must bow down your face and be ashamed and blush. Now if when called by us to give account you would have nothing to reply, when that terrible and inflexible Judgment comes where we must render account of thoughts and deeds and everything, how shall we stand? With what eyes shall we look at our Judge? What shall we say? What defense shall we make? What excuse, reasonable or unreasonable, shall we put forward? Shall we plead the expense? The gratification? The destruction of others whom we ruin through his art? We can have nothing to say, but must be punished with a punishment that has no end and knows no limit. That this may not happen to us, let us from now on guard all points, so that having departed with good hope, we may obtain the everlasting blessings; to which may we all attain through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom and with whom to the Father and the Holy Ghost be glory, now and ever and world without end. Amen.

Perhaps we have touched you sharply, yet if we touch you not, there are actual punishments awaiting those who sin without amendment. What then avails it to gratify by words those who shall be punished by realities? Do you take pleasure at a dancer, do you praise and admire him? Then are you worse than he; his poverty affords him an excuse though not a reasonable one, but you are stripped even of this defense. If I ask him, Why have you left other arts and come to this accursed and impure one? he will reply, because I can with little labor gain great profits. But if I ask you why you admire one who spends his time in impurity, and lives to the mischief of many, you can not run to the same excuse, but must bow down your face and be ashamed and blush. Now if when called by us to give account, you would have nothing to reply, class="greek">couldest reply nothing. " }}–> when that terrible and inexorable Judgment comes where we shall render account of thoughts and deeds and everything, how shall we stand? With what eyes shall we behold our Judge? What shall we say? What defense shall we make? What excuse reasonable or unreasonable shall we put forward? Shall we allege the expense? The gratification? The perdition of others whom by means of his art we ruin? We can have nothing to say, but must be punished with a punishment having no end, knowing no limit. That this come not to pass, let us henceforth guard all points, that having departed with a good hope, we may obtain the everlasting blessings; to which may we all attain through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom and with whom to the Father and the Holy Ghost be glory, now and ever and world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 41 — John 5:39-40

Homily 41 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240141.htm>.

Contents · 6 chapters
  1. John 5:39-40
  2. John 5:41
  3. John 5:42
  4. John 5:43
  5. John 5:44
  6. John 5:45-47

John 5:39-40

Search the Scriptures, for you think that in them you have eternal life, and these are the very Scriptures that testify about Me. Yet you are not willing to come to Me so that you may have eternal life.

Search the Scriptures; for in them ye think you have eternal life; and they are they which testify of Me. And ye will not come to Me that you might have [ eternal] life.

Beloved, let us place great value on spiritual matters, and not think it is enough for our salvation to pursue them casually. If in the affairs of this life a person cannot gain much profit by handling them carelessly and haphazardly, this will be even more true in spiritual matters, since these require still greater attention. This is why Christ, when He directed the Jews to the Scriptures, did not send them to a mere reading, but to a careful and thoughtful search. He did not say "Read the Scriptures," but "Search the Scriptures." Since the sayings concerning Him required great attention—for they had been concealed from the beginning for the benefit of the people of that time—He now commands them to dig down carefully so they might be able to discover what lay deep below. These sayings were not on the surface, nor were they laid out in plain view, but lay like some treasure hidden very deep. Now whoever searches for hidden things, unless he seeks them with care and effort, will never find what he is looking for. For this reason He said, "Search the Scriptures, because in them you think you have eternal life." He did not say "You have," but "you think," showing that they gained from them nothing great or elevated, expecting as they did to be saved by the mere reading, without the addition of faith. What He says is therefore something like this: Do you not admire the Scriptures? Do you not think they are the sources of all life? By these I confirm My claims now, for they are the ones which testify of Me, yet you will not come to Me that you may have eternal life. It was with good reason that He said "you think," because they would not obey, but merely took pride in the bare reading. Then, lest because of His very earnest care He should incur among them the suspicion of vainglory, and because He desired to be believed by them, should be thought to be seeking His own glory—for He reminded them of the words of John, and of the witness of God, and of His own works, and said everything He could to draw them to Him, and promised them life—since, I say, it was likely that many would suspect He spoke these things from a desire for glory, hear what He says:

1. Beloved, let us make great account of spiritual things, and not think that it is sufficient for us to salvation to pursue them anyhow. For if in things of this life a man can gain no great profit if he conduct them in an indifferent and chance way, much more will this be the case in spiritual things, since these require yet greater attention. Wherefore Christ when He referred the Jews to the Scriptures, sent them not to a mere reading, but a careful and considerate search; for He said not, Read the Scriptures, but, Search the Scriptures. Since the sayings relating to Him required great attention, (for they had been concealed from the beginning for the advantage of the men of that time,) He bids them now dig down with care that they might be able to discover what lay in the depth below. These sayings were not on the surface, nor were they cast forth to open view, but lay like some treasure hidden very deep. Now he that searches for hidden things, except he seek them with care and toil, will never find the object of his search. For which cause He said, Search the Scriptures, because in them ye think you have eternal life. He said not, You have, but ye think, showing that they gained from them nothing great or high, expecting as they did to be saved by the mere reading, without the addition of faith. What He says therefore is of this kind: Do ye not admire the Scriptures, do ye not think that they are the causes of all life? By these I confirm My claims now, for they are they which testify of Me, yet ye will not come to Me that you may have eternal life. It was thus with good reason that He said, ye think, because they would not obey, but merely prided themselves on the bare reading. Then lest owing to His very tender care He should incur among them the suspicion of vainglory, and because He desired to be believed by them, should be deemed to be seeking His own; (for He reminded them of the words of John, and of the witness of God, and of His own works, and said all He could to draw them to Him, and promised them life;) since, I say, it was likely that many would suspect that He spoke these things from a desire of glory, hear what He says:

John 5:41

That is, I do not need it. My nature, He says, is not of such a kind as to need the honor that comes from men, for if the sun can receive no addition from the light of a candle, I am much further from needing the honor that comes from men. Why then, someone asks, do you say these things if you do not need it? So that you may be saved. He stated this clearly above, and He implied the same thing here as well, by saying, that you might have life. Moreover, He gives another reason:

That is, I need it not: My nature, He says, is not of such a kind as to need the honor which is from men, for if the sun can receive no addition from the light of a candle, much farther am I from needing the honor which is from men. Why then, asks some one, do you say these things, if you need it not? That ye may be saved. This He positively asserted above, and the same He implied here also, by saying, that you might have life. Moreover, He puts another reason:

John 5:42

When they persecuted Him under the pretense of loving God because He made Himself equal with God, and He knew they would not believe Him, He anticipated someone might ask: Why do you say these things? He answers: I say them to convict you of this—that you do not persecute Me for love of God, since He testifies to Me both through works and through the Scriptures. Just as before, when you considered Me an enemy of God, you drove Me away, so now, since I have declared these things, you should have rushed to Me if you truly loved God. But you do not love Him. This is why I have spoken these words—to show that you are possessed with excessive pride, that you are boasting emptily and covering over your own envy. And He proves this not only by these things, but also by what would come to pass.

For when under pretense of loving God they persecuted Him because He made Himself equal with God, and He knew that they would not believe Him, lest any one should ask, why do you speak these words? I speak them, He says, to convict you of this, that it is not for the love of God that you persecute Me, if it be so that He testifies to Me both by works and by the Scriptures. For as before this when you deemed Me an enemy of God ye drove Me away, so now, since I have declared these things, you ought to have hastened to Me, if you had really loved. God. But ye love Him not. And therefore have I spoken these words, to show that you are possessed with excessive pride, that you are vainly boasting and shading over your own enviousness. And the same He proves not by these things only, but by those that should come to pass.

John 5:43

Do you see that He everywhere declares that He has been sent, that judgment has been committed to Him by the Father, that He can do nothing of Himself, in order to cut off every excuse for their unfairness? But who is it that He says here will come in his own name? He is referring here to Antichrist, and He provides an irrefutable proof of their unfairness. For if, as people who love God, you persecute Me, this should happen even more in the case of Antichrist. For he will not say that he is sent by the Father, nor that he comes according to His will, but in everything the opposite, seizing like a tyrant what does not belong to him, and claiming that he himself is the very God over all, as Paul says, "Exalting himself above all that is called God, or that is worshipped, showing himself that he is God" (2 Thessalonians 2:4). This is what it means to "come in his own name." I do not do this, but have come in the Name of My Father. That they did not receive One who said that He was sent by God was sufficient proof that they did not love God; but now from the opposite of this fact, from their being about to receive Antichrist, He shows their shamelessness. For when they did not receive One who claims that He was sent by God, and are about to worship one who does not know Him, and who says that he is God over all, it is clear that their persecution came from malice and from hating God. For this reason He gives two reasons for His words; first the kinder one, that you may be saved, and that you may have life; and when they would have mocked at Him, He gives the other which was more striking, showing that even if His hearers should not believe, still God was always accustomed to do His own works. Now Paul, speaking about Antichrist, said prophetically that God will send them strong delusion—so that they all might be judged who did not believe the truth, but had pleasure in unrighteousness (2 Thessalonians 2:11-12). Christ did not say, "He shall come," but "if he come," out of tenderness for His hearers, and because all their obstinacy was not yet complete. He was silent about the reason for his coming; but Paul, for those who can understand, has specifically alluded to it. For it is he who takes away all excuse from them.

2. Do you see that He everywhere declares that He has been sent, that judgment has been committed to Him by the Father, that He can do nothing of Himself, in order that He may cut off all excuse for their unfairness? But who is it that He here says shall come in his own name? He alludes here to Antichrist, and puts an incontrovertible proof of their unfairness. For if as loving God ye persecute Me, much more ought this to have taken place in the case of Antichrist. For he will neither say that he is sent by the Father, nor that he comes according to his will, but in everything contrariwise, seizing like a tyrant what belongs not to him, and asserting that he is the very God over all, as Paul says, 'Exalting himself above all that is called God, or that is worshipped, showing himself that he is God.' 2 Thessalonians 2:4 This is to 'come in his own name.' I do not so, but have come in the Name of My Father. That they received not One who said that He was sent of God, was a sufficient proof that they loved not God; but now from the contrary of this fact, from their being about to receive Antichrist, He shows their shamelessness. For when they received not One who asserts that He was sent by God, and are about to worship one who knows Him not, and who says that he is God over all, it is clear that their persecution proceeded from malice and from hating God. On this account He puts two reasons for His words; and first the kinder one, That ye may be saved; and, That ye may have life: and when they would have mocked at Him, He puts the other which was more striking, showing that even although His hearers should not believe, yet that God was wont always to do His own works. Now Paul speaking concerning Antichrist said prophetically, that God shall send them strong delusion — that they all might be judged who believed not the truth, but had pleasure in unrighteousness. 2 Thessalonians 2:11-12 Christ said not, He shall come; but, if He come, from tenderness for His hearers; and because all their obstinacy was not yet complete. He was silent as to the reason of His coming; but Paul, for those who can understand, has particularly alluded to it. For it is he who takes away all excuse from them.

Christ then also identifies the cause of their unbelief, saying…

Christ then puts also the cause of their unbelief, saying…

John 5:44

Therefore again He shows that they did not look to the things of God, but that under this pretense they wanted to satisfy their own personal desires, and were so far from doing this for His glory that they preferred honor from human beings to that which comes from Him. How then were they likely to have such hostility toward Him for a kind of honor which they so despised that they preferred to it the honor which comes from human beings?

Hence again He shows that they looked not to the things of God, but that under this pretense they desired to gratify private feeling, and were so far from doing this on account of His glory, that they preferred honor from men to that which comes from Him. How then were they likely to entertain such hostility towards Him for a kind of honor which they so despised, as to prefer to it the honor which comes from men?

After telling them that they did not have the love of God, and proving it both by what was happening in His own case and by what would happen in the case of Antichrist, and demonstrating that they had no excuse left, He next brings Moses forward as their accuser, going on to say,

Having told them that they had not the love of God, and having proved it by what was doing in His case, and by what should be in the case of Antichrist, and having demonstrated that they were deprived of all excuse, He next brings Moses to be their accuser, going on to say,

John 5:45-47

What He says is of this kind: It is Moses who has been insulted more than I by your conduct towards Me, for you have disbelieved him rather than Me. See how in every way He has removed from them all excuse. You said that you loved God when you persecuted Me; I have shown that you did so from hatred of Him. You say that I break the Sabbath and abolish the Law; I have freed Myself from this accusation as well. You claim that you believe in Moses by what you dare to do against Me; I on the contrary show that this is actually to disbelieve in Moses, for I am so far from opposing the Law that the one who will accuse you is none other than the man who gave you the Law. Just as He said of the Scriptures, in which you think you have eternal life, so also He says of Moses, in whom you trust—everywhere defeating them by their own weapons.

What He says is of this kind: It is Moses who has been insulted more than I by your conduct towards Me, for you have disbelieved him rather than Me. See how in every way He has cast them out from all excuse. You said that you loved God when you persecuted Me; I have shown that you did so from hatred of Him: ye say that I break the Sabbath and annul the Law; I have rid Me of this slander also: ye maintain that you believe in Moses by what ye dare to do against Me; I on the contrary show that this is most to disbelieve in Moses; for so far am I from opposing the Law, that he who shall accuse you is none other than the man who gave you the Law. As then He said of the Scriptures, in which ye think you have eternal life, so of Moses also He says, in whom you trust; everywhere conquering them by their own weapons.

And where, someone asks, is it clear that Moses will accuse us, and that you are not a boaster? What do you have to do with Moses? You have broken the Sabbath which he ordained that we should keep; how then should he accuse us? And how does it appear that we shall believe in another who comes in his own name? You make all these assertions without evidence. Now in truth all these points are proved above. For (Christ would reply) since it is acknowledged that I came from God, both by the works, by the voice of John, and by the testimony of the Father, it is evident that Moses will accuse the Jews. For what does he say? If a man comes doing miracles and leading you to God, and truly foretelling things to come, you must listen to him with complete readiness. Now Christ had done all this. He worked miracles in very truth, He drew all men to God, and He caused fulfillment to follow His predictions.

And whence, says some one, is it clear that Moses will accuse us, and that you are not a boaster? What have you to do with Moses? You have broken the Sabbath which he ordained that we should keep; how then should he accuse us? And how does it appear that we shall believe in another who comes in his own name? All these assertions you make without evidence. Now in truth all these points are proved above. For (Christ would reply) since it is acknowledged that I came from God, both by the works, by the voice of John, and by the testimony of the Father, it is evident that Moses will accuse the Jews. For what says he? If a man come doing miracles and leading you to God, and truly foretelling things future, you must hearken unto him with all readiness. Now Christ had done all this. He wrought miracles in very truth, He drew all men to God, and (so that He) caused accomplishment to follow His predictions.

But how does it appear that they will believe another? From their hatred of Christ, since those who turn away from Him who comes according to God's will will, it is quite clear, receive the enemy of God. And do not be surprised if He now puts forward Moses, although He said, I receive not witness from man, for He refers them not to Moses but to the Scriptures of God. However, since the Scriptures frightened them less, He brings His discourse around to the very person of Moses, setting their Lawgiver against them as their accuser, thus making the terror more powerful. And He refutes each of their claims. Notice: they said that they persecuted Him through love for God, but He shows that they did so through hating God. They said that they held fast to Moses, but He shows that they acted this way because they did not believe Moses. For if they had been zealous for the law, they ought to have received Him who fulfilled it. If they loved God they ought to have believed the One who drew them to Him. If they believed Moses they ought to have honored the One of whom Moses prophesied. But, Christ says, if Moses is disbelieved before My coming, it is not at all unlikely that I, who am announced by him, should be driven away by you. So just as He had shown from their conduct toward Himself that those who admired John actually despised him, so now He shows that those who thought they believed Moses did not believe him, and He turns back on their own heads everything that they thought to put forward in their own defense. Far from drawing you away from the Law, He says, I call your Lawgiver himself to be your accuser.

But whence does it appear that they will believe another? From their hating Christ, since they who turn aside from Him who comes according to the will of God will, it is quite plain, receive the enemy of God. And marvel not if He now puts forward Moses, although He said, I receive not witness from man, for He referrs them not to Moses, but to the Scriptures of God. However, since the Scriptures terrified them less, He brings round His discourse to the very person (of Moses), setting over against them their Lawgiver as their accuser, thus rendering the terror more impressive; and each of their assertions He refutes. Observe: they said that they persecuted Him through love for God, He shows that they did so through hating God; they said that they held fast to Moses, He shows that they acted thus because they believed not Moses. For had they been zealous for the law, they ought to have received Him who fulfilled it; if they loved God they ought to have believed One who drew them to Him, if they believed Moses they ought to have done homage to One of whom Moses prophesied. But (says Christ) if Moses is disbelieved before My coming, it is nothing unlikely that I, who am heralded by him, should be driven away by you. As then He had shown from their conduct towards Himself that they who admired John (really) despised him, so now He shows that they who thought that they believed Moses, believed him not, and turns back on their own head all that they thought to put forward in their own behalf. So far, He says, am I from drawing you away from the Law, that I call your Lawgiver himself to be your accuser.

That the Scriptures testified of Him He declared, but He did not specify where they testify. He wanted to inspire greater awe in them, to prompt them to search, and to force them into the position of having to ask questions. For if He had told them readily without their asking, they would have rejected the testimony. But now, if they paid any attention to His words, they would first need to ask and learn from Him what that testimony was. For this reason He relies more heavily on assertions and warnings, not only on proofs, so that He might win them over through fear of what He says. But even so they remained silent. That is what wickedness is like: whatever a person says or does to it, it is not stirred to action, but remains holding onto its own venom.

That the Scriptures testified of Him He declared, but where they testify He added not; desiring to inspire them with greater awe, and to prompt them to search, and to reduce them to the necessity of questioning. For had He told them readily and without their questioning, they would have rejected the testimony; but now, if they gave any heed to His words, they needed first of all to ask, and learn from Him what that testimony was. On this account He deals the more largely in assertions and threats, not in proofs only, that even so He may bring them over by fear of what He says; but they even so were silent. Such a thing is wickedness; whatsoever a man say or do it is not stirred to move, but remains keeping its peculiar venom.

We must drive out all wickedness from our souls and never again devise any deceit. For as one says, "To the perverse God sends crooked paths" (Proverbs 21:8, Septuagint), and "The holy spirit of discipline will flee deceit, and remove from thoughts that are without understanding" (Wisdom 1:5). Nothing makes people as foolish as wickedness does. When a person is treacherous, unfair, or ungrateful—these are different forms of wickedness—when without having been wronged he grieves another, when he weaves deceits, how can he not display an example of extreme foolishness? Again, nothing makes people as wise as virtue does. It makes them thankful and fair-minded, merciful, mild, gentle, and candid. It is usually the mother of all other blessings. And what is more understanding than someone so disposed? For virtue is the very spring and root of prudence, just as all wickedness has its beginning in foolishness. The insolent person and the angry person become prey to their respective passions from lack of wisdom. On this account the prophet said, "There is no soundness in my flesh: my wounds stink and are corrupt because of my foolishness" (Psalm 38:3-4), showing that all sin has its beginning in foolishness. And so the virtuous person who has the fear of God is more understanding than anyone. This is why a wise man has said, "The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom" (Proverbs 1:7). If then to fear God is to have wisdom, and the wicked person does not have that fear, he is deprived of what is truly wisdom—and deprived of what is truly wisdom, he is more foolish than anyone. Yet many admire the wicked as being able to do injustice and harm, not knowing that they ought to consider them the most wretched of all people, who, thinking to injure others, thrust the sword against themselves—an act of extreme foolishness, that a person should strike himself and not even know that he does so, but should think that he is injuring another while he is killing himself. Therefore Paul, knowing that we slay ourselves when we strike others, says, "Why do ye not rather take wrong? Why do ye not rather suffer yourselves to be defrauded?" (1 Corinthians 6:7). For not suffering wrong consists in doing none, just as not being ill-used consists in not using others ill—though this assertion may seem a riddle to the many, and to those who will not learn true wisdom. Knowing this, let us not call wretched or lament for those who suffer injury or insult, but for those who inflict these things. These are the ones who have been most injured, who have made God to be at war with them, and have opened the mouths of ten thousand accusers, who are getting an evil reputation in the present life and drawing down on themselves severe punishment in the life to come. While those who have been wronged by them and have nobly borne it all have God favorable to them, and everyone to sympathize with, praise, and welcome them. People such as these in the present life shall enjoy an exceeding good report, as affording the strongest example of true wisdom, and in the life to come shall share the good things everlasting. May we all attain to these through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father and the Holy Ghost be glory, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.

Wherefore we must cast out all wickedness from our souls, and never more contrive any deceit; for, says one, To the perverse God sends crooked paths Proverbs 21:8, Septuagint; and, The holy spirit of discipline will flee deceit, and remove from thoughts that are without understanding. Wisdom 1:5 For nothing makes men so foolish as wickedness; since when a man is treacherous, unfair, ungrateful, (these are different forms of wickedness,) when without having been wronged he grieves another, when he weaves deceits, how shall he not exhibit an example of excessive folly? Again, nothing makes men so wise as virtue; it renders them thankful and fair-minded, merciful, mild, gentle, and candid; it is wont to be the mother of all other blessings. And what is more understanding than one so disposed? For virtue is the very spring and root of prudence, just as all wickedness has its beginning in folly. For, the insolent man and the angry become the prey of their respective passions from lack of wisdom; on which account the prophet said, There is no soundness in my flesh: my wounds stink and are corrupt because of my foolishness Psalm 38:3-4: showing that all sin has its beginning in folly: and so the virtuous man who has the fear of God is more understanding than any; wherefore a wise man has said, The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom. Proverbs 1:7 If then to fear God is to have wisdom, and the wicked man has not that fear, he is deprived of that which is wisdom indeed — and deprived of that which is wisdom indeed, he is more foolish than any. And yet many admire the wicked as being able to do injustice and harm, not knowing that they ought to deem them wretched above all men, who thinking to injure others thrust the sword against themselves — an act of extremest folly, that a man should strike himself and not even know that he does so, but should think that he is injuring another while he is killing himself. Wherefore Paul, knowing that we slay ourselves when we smite others, says, Why do ye not rather take wrong? Why do ye not rather suffer yourselves to be defrauded? 1 Corinthians 6:7 For the not suffering wrong consists in doing none, as also the not being ill-used in not using others ill; though this assertion may seem a riddle to the many, and to those who will not learn true wisdom. Knowing this, let us not call wretched or lament for those who suffer injury or insult, but for such who inflict these things; these are they who have been most injured, who have made God to be at war with them, and have opened the mouths of ten thousand accusers, who are getting an evil reputation in the present life, and drawing down on themselves severe punishment in the life to come. While those who have been wronged by them, and have nobly borne it all, have God favorable to them, and all to condone with, and praise, and entertain them. Such as these in the present life, shall enjoy an exceeding good report, as affording the strongest example of true wisdom, and in the life to come shall share the good things everlasting; to which may we all attain through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father and the Holy Ghost be glory, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 40 — John 5:31-32

Homily 40 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240140.htm>.

Contents · 8 chapters
  1. John 5:31-32
  2. John 5:33
  3. John 5:34
  4. John 5:35
  5. John 5:36
  6. John 5:37
  7. John 5:38
  8. John 5:39

John 5:31-32

If someone who is unskilled in the craft tries to work a mine, he will get no gold. Instead, he will mix everything together randomly and aimlessly, and his labor will be useless and harmful. In the same way, those who do not understand the method of Holy Scripture or search out its distinctive features and principles, but read through all its parts carelessly and in the same manner, will mix the gold with dirt and never discover the treasure hidden within it. I am saying this now because the passage before us contains much gold, though it is not clearly visible but covered over with much obscurity. Therefore, by digging and refining, we must arrive at the correct meaning. For who would not immediately be troubled upon hearing Christ say, "If I testify of Myself, My witness is not true," especially since He often appears to have testified of Himself? For example, when speaking with the Samaritan woman He said, "I Am that speak unto you," and likewise to the blind man, "It is He that talks with you," and when rebuking the Jews, "You say, you blaspheme, because I said I am the Son of God." And in many other places He does this. If now all these statements are false, what hope of salvation shall we have? And where shall we find truth when Truth Itself declares, "My witness is not true"? Nor does this appear to be the only contradiction; there is another no less serious than this. He says later on, "Though I bear witness of Myself, yet My witness is true." Which one, tell me, am I to accept, and which should I consider a falsehood? If we take them out of context simply as they are said, without carefully considering the person to whom they are spoken, the reason for which they are said, or any other similar circumstances, they will both be falsehoods. For if His witness is not true, then this statement is not true either—not merely the second, but the first also. What then is the meaning? We need great watchfulness, or rather the grace of God, so that we do not stop at the mere words. For this is how the heretics go astray, because they do not investigate the speaker's purpose or the disposition of the hearers. If we do not add these and other points besides, such as times and places and the opinions of the listeners, many absurd consequences will follow.

1. If any one unpracticed in the art undertake to work a mine, he will get no gold, but confounding all aimlessly and together, will undergo a labor unprofitable and pernicious: so also they who understand not the method of Holy Scripture, nor search out its peculiarities and laws, but go over all its points carelessly and in one manner, will mix the gold with earth, and never discover the treasure which is laid up in it. I say this now because the passage before us contains much gold, not indeed manifest to view, but covered over with much obscurity, and therefore by digging and purifying we must arrive at the legitimate sense. For who would not at once be troubled at hearing Christ say, If I testify of Myself, My witness is not true; inasmuch as He often appears to have testified of Himself? For instance, conversing with the Samaritan woman He said, I Am that speak unto you: and in like manner to the blind man, It is He that talks with you John 9:37; and rebuking the Jews, You say, you blaspheme, because I said I am the Son of God. John 10:36 And in many other places besides He does this. If now all these assertions be false, what hope of salvation shall we have? And where shall we find truth when Truth Itself declares, My witness is not true? Nor does this appear to be the only contradiction; there is another not less than this. He says farther on, Though I bear witness of Myself, yet My witness is true John 8:14; which then, tell me, am I to receive, and which deem a falsehood? If we take them out thus [from the context] simply as they are said, without carefully considering the person to whom nor the cause for which they are said, nor any other like circumstances, they will both be falsehoods. For if His witness be not true, then this assertion is not true either, not merely the second, but the first also. What then is the meaning? We need great watchfulness, or rather the grace of God, that we rest not in the mere words; for thus the heretics err, because they enquire not into the object of the speaker nor the disposition of the hearers. If we add not these and other points besides, as times and places and the opinions of the listeners, many absurd consequences will follow.

What then is the meaning? The Jews were about to object to Him, "If you bear witness concerning yourself, your witness is not true" (John 8:13), so He spoke these words in anticipation. It was as though He had said: You will surely say to me, "We do not believe you, for no one who witnesses about himself is readily considered trustworthy among men." So the phrase "is not true" must not be read absolutely, but with reference to their suspicions, as though He had said: "to you it is not true." He uttered these words not looking to His own dignity, but to their secret thoughts. When He says, "My witness is not true," He rebukes their opinion of Him and the objection they were about to make against Him. But when He says, "Though I bear witness of Myself, My witness is true" (John 8:14), He declares the very nature of the thing itself—namely, that as God they ought to consider Him trustworthy even when speaking of Himself. He had spoken of the resurrection of the dead, and of the judgment, and that the one who believes in Him is not judged but comes into life, and that He shall sit to require an account from all men, and that He has the same authority and power with the Father. Since He was about to prove these things again in another way, He necessarily put their objection first. "I told you," He says, "that 'as the Father raises the dead and gives them life, so the Son gives life to whom He will.' I told you that 'the Father judges no man, but has committed all judgment to the Son.' I told you that men must 'honor the Son as they honor the Father.' I told you that 'whoever does not honor the Son does not honor the Father.' I told you that 'whoever hears My words and believes them shall not see death, but has passed from death to life' (John 5:24, not exactly quoted), that My voice shall raise the dead—some now, some hereafter—that I shall demand an account from all men of their transgressions, that I shall judge righteously, and reward those who have walked uprightly." Now since all these were assertions, since the things asserted were important, and since no clear proof of them had yet been given to the Jews but only one rather indistinct proof, He puts their objection first when He is about to proceed to establish His assertions. He speaks somewhat in this way, if not in these very words: "Perhaps you will say, 'You assert all this, but you are not a credible witness, since you testify about yourself.'" First, then, He checks their argumentative spirit by stating what they would say, and shows that He knew the secrets of their hearts, giving this first proof of His power. After stating the objection, He supplies other proofs that are clear and indisputable, producing three witnesses to what He said: the works He performed, the witness of the Father, and the preaching of John. He puts first the less important witness of John. For after saying, "There is another who bears witness of Me, and I know that his witness is true," He adds,

What then is the meaning? The Jews were about to object to Him, If you bear witness concerning yourself, your witness is not true John 8:13: therefore He spoke these words in anticipation; as though He had said, You will surely say to Me, we believe you not; for no one that witnesses of himself is readily held trustworthy among men. So that the is not true must not be read absolutely, but with reference to their suspicions, as though He had said, to you it is not true; and so He uttered the words not looking to His own dignity, but to their secret thoughts. When He says, My witness is not true, He rebukes their opinion of Him, and the objection about to be urged by them against Him; but when He says, Though I bear witness of Myself, My witness is true John 8:14, He declares the very nature of the thing itself, namely, that as God they ought to deem Him trustworthy even when speaking of Himself. For since He had spoken of the resurrection of the dead, and of the judgment, and that he that believes in Him is not judged, but comes unto life, and that He shall sit to require account of all men, and that He has the same Authority and Power with the Father; and since He was about again otherwise to prove these things, He necessarily put their objection first. I told you, He says, that 'as the Father raises the dead and quickens them, so the Son quickens whom He will'; I told you that 'the Father judges no man, but has committed all judgment unto the Son'; I told you that men must ' honor the Son as they honor the Father'; I told you that 'he that honors not the Son honors not the Father'; I told you that 'he that hears My words and believes them shall not see death, but has passed from death unto life' John 5:24; not exactly quoted; that My voice shall raise the dead, some now, some hereafter; that I shall demand account from all men of their transgressions, that I shall judge righteously, and recompense those who have walked uprightly. Now since all these were assertions, since the things asserted were important, and since no clear proof of them had as yet been afforded to the Jews but one rather indistinct, He puts their objection first when He is about to proceed to establish His assertions, speaking somewhat in this way if not in these very words: Perhaps you will say, you assert all this, but you are not a credible witness, since you testify of yourself. First then checking their disputatious spirit by setting forth what they would say, and showing that He knew the secrets of their hearts, and giving this first proof of His power, after stating the objection He supplies other proofs clear and indisputable, producing three witnesses to what He said, namely, the works wrought by Him, the witness of the Father, and the preaching of John. And He puts first the less important witness of John. For after saying, There is another that bears witness of Me, and I know that his witness is true, He adds,

John 5:33

Yet if Your witness is not true, how can You say, "I know that the testimony of John is true, and that he has borne witness to the truth"? And do you see, O man, how clear it is from this that the statement "My witness is not true" was directed at their hidden thoughts?

Yet if Your witness be not true, how sayest Thou, I know that the testimony of John is true, and that he has borne witness to the truth? And do you see (O man) how clear it hence is, that the expression, My witness is not true, was addressed to their secret thoughts?

What then, someone asks, if John bore witness partially? To prevent the Jews from making this claim, see how He removes this suspicion. He did not say, "John testified of Me," but rather, "You first sent to John," and you would not have sent if you had not considered him trustworthy. What's more, they had sent not to ask him about Christ, but about himself, and the man they considered trustworthy in matters concerning himself they would much more consider trustworthy in matters concerning another. For it is, so to speak, the nature of us all not to give as much credit to those who speak of themselves as to those who speak of others. Yet they considered him so trustworthy that he did not need any other testimony even concerning himself. For those who were sent did not say, "What do you say concerning Christ?" but "Who are you? What do you say of yourself?" Such great admiration they felt for the man. Now Christ alluded to all this by saying, "You sent unto John." And for this reason the Evangelist has not merely related that they sent, but is exact about the persons sent—that they were Priests and Pharisees, not common or lowly persons, nor such as might be corrupted or deceived, but men able to understand exactly what he said.

2. What then, says some one, if John bore witness partially. That the Jews might not assert this, see how He removes this suspicion. For He said not, John testified of Me, but, You first sent to John, and you would not have sent had ye not deemed him trustworthy. Nay, what is more, they had sent not to ask him about Christ, but about himself, and the man whom they deemed trustworthy in what related to himself they would much more deem so in what related to another. For it is, so to speak, the nature of us all not to give so much credit to those who speak of themselves as to those who speak of others; yet him they deemed so trustworthy as not to require even concerning himself any other testimony. For they who were sent said not, What do you say concerning Christ? but, Who are you? What do you say of yourself? So great admiration felt they for the man. Now to all this Christ made allusion by saying, You sent unto John. And on this account the Evangelist has not merely related that they sent, but is exact as to the persons sent that they were Priests and of the Pharisees, not common or abject persons, nor such as might be corrupted or cheated, but men able to understand exactly what he said.

John 5:34

Why then have You brought forward John's testimony? His testimony was not human testimony, for he says, "He that sent me to baptize with water, He said to me." So John's testimony was God's testimony, since he said what he did after learning it from Him. But so that no one should ask, "How is it clear that he learned from God?" and get stuck on this point, He thoroughly silences them by continuing to address their thoughts. For it was not likely that many would know these things; up to this point they had listened to John as to someone who spoke on his own authority, and therefore Christ says, "I receive not testimony from man." And so the Jews might not ask, "And if You were not going to receive human testimony and use it to strengthen Yourself, why have You brought forward this man's testimony?" see how He resolves this contradiction by what He adds. For after saying, "I receive not testimony from man," He has added,

Why then have You brought forward that of John? His testimony was not the testimony of man, for, says he, He that sent me to baptize with water, He said to me. John 1:33 So that John's testimony was the testimony of God; for having learned from Him he said what he did. But that none should ask, Whence is it clear that he learned from God? and stop at this, He abundantly silences them by still addressing Himself to their thoughts. For neither was it likely that many would know these things; they had hitherto given heed unto John as to one who spoke of himself, and therefore Christ says, I receive not testimony from man. And that the Jews might not ask, And if You were not about to receive the testimony of man, and by it to strengthen Yourself, why have You brought forward this man's testimony? see how He corrects this contradiction by what He adds. For after saying, I receive not testimony from man, He has added,

But I say these things so that you may be saved.

But these things I say, that you may be saved.

What He is saying is something like this: As God, I did not need the testimony of John, which is merely human testimony. Yet because you paid more attention to him, considered him more trustworthy than anyone else, and ran to him as to a prophet—for the whole city poured out to the Jordan—and you have not believed in Me even when I perform miracles, therefore I am reminding you of his testimony.

What He says is of this kind; I, being God, needed not the witness of John which is man's witness, yet because ye gave more heed to him, believe him more trustworthy than any, ran to him as to a prophet, (for all the city was poured forth to Jordan,) and have not believed on Me, even when working miracles, therefore I remind you of that witness of his.

John 5:35

To prevent them from replying, "What if he did speak and we did not receive him," He shows that they did receive John's sayings, since they sent not ordinary men but priests and Pharisees and were willing to rejoice. They admired the man so much and at the same time had nothing to say against his words. But the phrase "for a season" is the expression of one pointing out their fickleness and the fact that they soon turned away from him.

That they may not reply, What if he did speak and we received him not, He shows that they did receive John's sayings: since they sent not common men, but priests and Pharisees and were willing to rejoice; so much did they admire the man, and at the same time had nothing to say against his words. But the for a season, is the expression of one noting their levity, and the fact that they soon started away from him.

John 5:36

For if you had been willing to accept faith according to the natural consequence of the facts, I would have won you over by My works more than he did by his words. But since you will not, I bring you to John, not because I need his testimony, but because I do everything so that you may be saved. For I have greater witness than that of John, namely, that from My works; yet I do not merely consider how I may be made acceptable to you by credible evidence, but how by evidence of persons known to and admired by you. Then glancing at them and saying that they rejoiced for a season in his light, He declared that their zeal was only temporary and uncertain.

For had ye been willing to admit faith according to the (natural) consequence of the facts, I would have brought you over by My works more than he by his words. But since you will not, I bring you to John, not as needing his testimony, but because I do all 'that you may be saved.' For I have greater witness than that of John, namely, that from My works; yet I do not merely consider how I may be made acceptable to you by credible evidence, but how by that (of persons) known to and admired by you. Then glancing at them and saying that they rejoiced for a season in his (John's) light, He declared that their zeal was but temporary and uncertain.

He called John a torch, meaning that John did not have light from himself, but by the grace of the Spirit. However, the circumstance that would show the absolute distinction between Himself and John—namely, that He was the Sun of righteousness—He did not yet state openly. Instead, by merely hinting at this so far, He touched them sharply by showing that the same disposition that led them to despise John also prevented them from believing in Christ. For they admired even the man they claimed to admire only for a season, though if they had not acted this way, he would soon have led them by the hand to Jesus. Having then proved them completely unworthy of forgiveness, He went on to say, I have greater witness than that of John. What is that? It is the witness from His works.

He called John a torch, signifying that he had not light of himself, but by the grace of the Spirit; but the circumstance which caused the absolute distinction between Himself and John, namely, that He was the Sun of righteousness, this He put not yet; but merely hinting as yet at this He touched them sharply, by showing that from the same disposition which led them to despise John, neither could they believe in Christ. Since it was but for a season that they admired even the man whom they did admire, and who, had they not acted thus, would soon have led them by the hand to Jesus. Having then proved them altogether unworthy of forgiveness, He went on to say, I have greater witness than that of John. What is that? It is that from His works.

For the works, He says, which the Father has given Me to finish, the same works that I do bear witness of Me that the Father sent Me.

For the works, He says, which the Father has given Me to finish, the same works that I do bear witness of Me that the Father sent Me.

By this He reminded them of the paralytic who was healed, and of many other things. The words perhaps one of them might have claimed were mere boasting, spoken because of John's friendship toward Him (though indeed it was not in their power to say even this about John, a man who perfectly practiced wisdom and was admired by them for this reason), but the works could not admit this suspicion even among the most unreasonable of them; therefore He added this second testimony, saying, The works which the Father has given Me to finish, the same works that I do bear witness of Me that the Father sent Me.

By this He reminded them of the paralytic restored, and of many other things. The words perhaps one of them might have asserted were mere boast, and said by reason of John's friendship towards Him, (though indeed it was not in their power to say even this of John, a man equal to the exact practice of wisdom, and on this account admired by them,) but the works could not even among the maddest of them admit this suspicion; therefore He added this second testimony, saying, The works which the Father has given Me to finish, the same works that I do bear witness of Me that the Father sent Me.

In this passage, He also addresses the accusation about breaking the Sabbath. Since those people were arguing, "How can he be from God, seeing that he keeps not the Sabbath?" (John 9:16), He says, "Which My Father has given unto Me." Yet in reality, He acted with absolute authority, but in order to show most clearly that He does nothing contrary to the Father, He has used this expression that emphasizes His subordination. Why didn't He say, "The works which the Father has given Me testify that I am equal to the Father"? For both of these truths could be learned from the works: that He did nothing contrary to the Father, and that He was equal to the One who begot Him—a point He establishes elsewhere when He says, "If you believe not Me, believe the works: that you may know and believe that I am in the Father and the Father in Me" (John 10:38). In both ways, then, the works bore witness to Him: that He was equal to the Father, and that He did nothing contrary to Him. Why then did He not say this directly, instead of leaving out the greater point and putting forward the lesser one? Because establishing this lesser point was His first objective. For although it was far less significant to have people believe that He came from God than to have them believe that God was equal with Him (since coming from God was something the Prophets also claimed, but equality never was), He still works hard on the lesser point, knowing that once this was admitted, the other would be easily received afterward. So He makes no mention of the more important part of the testimony and presents its lesser function, so that through this they may also receive the other. Having accomplished this, He adds,

3. In this place He also meets the accusation respecting the violation of the Sabbath. For since those persons argued, How can he be from God, seeing that he keeps not the Sabbath? John 9:16, therefore He says, Which My Father has given unto Me. Yet in truth, He acted with absolute power, but in order most abundantly to show that He does nothing contrary to the Father, therefore He has put the expression of much inferiority. Since why did He not say, The works which the Father has given Me testify that I am equal to the Father? For both of these truths were to be earned from the works, that He did nothing contrary, and that He was equal to Him who begot Him; a point which He is establishing elsewhere, where He says, If you believe not Me, believe the works: that you may know and believe that I am in the Father and the Father in Me. John 10:38 In both respects, therefore, the works bore witness to Him, that He was equal to the Father, and that He did nothing contrary to Him. Why then said He not so, instead of leaving out the greater and putting forward this? Because to establish this was His first object. For although it was a far less thing to have it believed that He came from God, than to have it believed that God was equal with Him, (for that belonged to the Prophets also, but this never,) still He takes much pains as to the lesser point, as knowing that, this admitted, the other would afterwards be easily received. So that making no mention of the more important portion of the testimony, He puts its lesser office, that by this they may receive the other also. Having effected this, He adds,

John 5:37

Where did He bear witness of Him? In Jordan: This is My beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased; hear Him. But even this needed proof. John's testimony was clear, because they themselves had sent messengers to him and could not deny it. The testimony from miracles was likewise clear, because they had seen them performed, had heard from the man who was healed, and had believed—which is also where they got their accusation. Therefore, it remained to provide proof of the Father's testimony. Next, in order to accomplish this, He added,

Where did He bear witness of Him? In Jordan: This is My beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased Matthew 3:16; hear Him. Yet even this needed proof. The testimony of John then was clear, for they themselves had sent to him, and could not deny it. The testimony from miracles was in like manner clear, for they had seen them wrought, and had heard from him who was healed, and had believed; whence also they drew their accusation. It therefore remained to give proof to the testimony of the Father. Next in order to effect this, He added,

You have never heard His voice at any time:

You have neither heard His voice at any time:

How then does Moses say, "The Lord spoke, and Moses answered" (Exodus 19:19)? And how does David say, "He had heard a tongue which he knew not" (Psalm 81:5)? And how does Moses say again, "Is there any such people which has heard the voice of God?" (Deuteronomy 4:33)?

How then says Moses, The Lord spoke, and Moses answered? Exodus 19:19; and David, He had heard a tongue which he knew not Psalm 81:5; and Moses again, Is there any such people which has 'heard the voice of God?'? Deuteronomy 4:33

Nor seen His shape.

Nor seen His shape.

Yet Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel are said to have seen Him, and many others. What then does Christ mean by what He says now? He is guiding them step by step toward a philosophical understanding, showing that God has neither voice nor shape, but is higher than such forms or sounds. For just as when He says, "You have not heard His voice," He does not mean that God does utter a voice but one that cannot be heard, so when He says, "Nor seen His shape," He does not mean that God has a shape that is simply invisible, but rather that neither of these things belongs to God. And so that they could not say, "You are a boaster; God spoke only to Moses"—which they did in fact say: "We know that God spoke with Moses, but as for this fellow, we know not where He is from" (John 9:29)—He spoke as He did for this reason: to show that there is neither voice nor shape with God. But why, He says, should I mention these things? Not only have you "neither heard His voice nor seen His shape," but you cannot even claim what you boast about most and what you are most fully convinced of, namely, that you have received and keep His commandments. Therefore He adds,

Yet Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel, are said to have seen Him, and many others. What then is that which Christ says now? He guides them by degrees to a philosophical doctrine, showing that with God is neither voice nor shape, but that He is higher than such forms or sounds like these. For as when He says, You have not heard His voice, He does not mean that God does indeed utter a voice, but one which cannot be heard; so when He says, Nor seen His shape, He does not mean that God has a shape though one invisible, but that neither of these things belongs to God. And in order that they might not say, You are a boaster, God spoke to Moses only; (this at least they did say, We know that God spoke with Moses: as for this fellow, we know not whence He is John 9:29) on this account He spoke as He did, to show that there is neither voice nor shape with God. But why, He says, name I these things? Not only have ye 'neither heard His voice nor seen His shape,' but it is not even in your power to assert that of which you most boast and of which you are all most fully assured, namely, that you have received and keep His commandments. Wherefore He adds,

John 5:38

That is, the ordinances, the commandments, the Law, and the Prophets. For even if God ordained these things, they are still not with you, since you do not believe in Me. Because if the Scriptures everywhere say that it is necessary to pay attention to Me, and yet you do not believe, it is quite clear that His word is removed from you. Therefore He adds again,

That is, the ordinances, the commandments, the Law, and the Prophets. For even if God ordained these, still they are not with you, since you believe not on Me. Because, if the Scriptures everywhere say that it is necessary to give heed to Me, and yet ye believe not, it is quite clear that His word is removed from you. Wherefore again He adds,

For you do not believe in Him whom He has sent.

For whom He has sent, Him ye believe not.

Then, so they cannot argue, "How could He have testified to you if we have not heard His voice?" He says,

Then that they may not argue, How, if we have not heard His voice, has He testified unto you? He says,

John 5:39

Since the Father gave His testimony through these. He indeed gave it at the Jordan and on the mount, but Christ does not bring forward those voices, perhaps because doing so would have led to disbelief. For they did not hear one of them, the one on the mount, and though they heard the other, they paid no attention to it. For this reason He directs them to the Scriptures, showing that the Father's testimony comes from them, having first removed the old grounds on which they used to boast—either that they had seen God or that they had heard His voice. For since they would likely disbelieve His voice and imagine for themselves what took place on Sinai, after first correcting their mistaken ideas on these points and showing that what had been done was a condescension, He then directs them to the testimony of the Scriptures.

Since by these the Father gave His testimony. He gave it indeed by Jordan also and in the mount, but Christ brings not forward those voices; perhaps by doing so He would have been disbelieved; for one of them, that in the mount, they did not hear, and the other they heard indeed, but heeded not. For this reason He referrs them to the Scriptures, showing that from them comes the Father's testimony, having first removed the old grounds on which they used to boast, either as having seen God or as having heard His voice. For as it was likely that they would disbelieve His voice, and picture to themselves what took place on Sinai, after first correcting their suspicions on these points, and showing that what had been done was a condescension, He then referrs them to the testimony of the Scriptures.

Let us also arm and fortify ourselves from these Scriptures when we fight against heretics. For all Scripture is given by inspiration of God and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness, that the man of God may be perfect, thoroughly furnished unto every good work. He must have all these qualities, not just some of them, for a person who lacks any of them is not perfect. For tell me, what good is it if someone prays continually but does not give generously? Or if he gives generously but is covetous or violent? Or if he is not covetous or violent but gives to show off before others and gain their praise? Or if he gives alms carefully and according to God's will, yet becomes proud of this very thing and arrogant? Or if he is humble and constant in fasting but covetous, greedy for gain, and bound to earthly things, introducing into his soul the mother of all evil? For the love of money is the root of all evils. Let us then shudder at this action, let us flee this sin. This has made the world a waste, this has brought all things into confusion, this seduces us away from the most blessed service of Christ. It is not possible, He says, to serve God and mammon. For mammon gives commands that contradict those of Christ. One says, Give to those in need; the other says, Plunder the goods of the needy. Christ says, Forgive those who wrong you; the other says, Prepare snares against those who do you no wrong. Christ says, Be merciful and kind; mammon says, Be savage and cruel, and count the tears of the poor as nothing—so that he may make the Judge stern toward us on that day. For then all our actions will come before our eyes, along with those who have been injured and stripped by us, shutting us out from all excuse. For if Lazarus, who received no wrong from the rich man but only did not enjoy any of his good things, stood forth at that time as a bitter accuser and allowed him to obtain no pardon, what excuse, tell me, will those have who not only give no alms from their own substance but seize what belongs to others and overthrow orphans' houses? If those who have not fed Christ when He hungered have drawn such fire upon their heads, what consolation will those enjoy who plunder what does not belong to them at all, who weave countless lawsuits, who unjustly grasp the property of everyone? Let us then cast out this desire, and we will cast it out if we think of those before us who acted wrongfully, who were covetous and are now gone. Do not others now enjoy their wealth and labors while they lie in punishment, vengeance, and intolerable suffering? And how can this be anything but extreme foolishness—to weary and trouble ourselves so that during our lives we strain ourselves with labor, and when we depart from here undergo intolerable punishments and vengeances, when we might have enjoyed ourselves here (for nothing produces pleasure as much as the consciousness of giving alms), and when departing to that place might have been delivered from all our suffering and obtained countless blessings? For just as wickedness tends to punish those who pursue it even before they reach the pit, so also virtue, even before the gift of the Kingdom, provides delights for those who practice it here, making them live in company with good hopes and continual pleasure. Therefore, that we may obtain this both here and in the life to come, let us hold fast to good works, so we will gain the future crown. May we all reach it through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom and with whom, to the Father and the Holy Spirit, be glory, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.

4. And from these too let us also, when we war against heretics, arm and fortify ourselves. For all Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness, that the man of God may be perfect, thoroughly furnished unto every good work 2 Timothy 3:16-17; not that he may have some and not others, for such a man is not perfect. For tell me what profit is it, if a man pray continually, but give not liberal alms? Or if he give liberal alms, but be covetous or violent? Or if he be not covetous nor violent, but (is liberal) to make a show before men, and to gain the praise of the beholders? Or if he give alms with exactness and according to God's pleasure, yet be lifted up by this very thing, and be highminded? Or if he be humble and constant in fasting, but covetous, greedy of gain, and nailed to earth, and one who introduces into his soul the mother of mischief? For the love of money is the root of all evils. Let us then shudder at the action, let us flee the sin; this has made the world a waste, this has brought all things into confusion, this seduces us from the most blessed service of Christ. It is not possible, He says, to serve God and mammon. For mammon gives commands contradictory to those of Christ. The one says, Give to them that need; the other, Plunder the goods of the needy. Christ says, Forgive them that wrong you; the other, Prepare snares against those who do you no wrong. Christ says, Be merciful and kind; mammon says, Be savage and cruel, and count the tears of the poor as nothing; to the intent that he may render the Judge stern to us in that day. For then all our actions shall come before our eyes, and those who have been injured and stripped by us, shutting us out from all excuse. Since if Lazarus, who received no wrong from Dives, but only did not enjoy any of his good things, stood forth at that time as a bitter accuser and allowed him not to obtain any pardon, what excuse, tell me, shall they have, who, besides giving no alms of their own substance, seize that of others, and overthrow orphans' houses? If they who have not fed Christ when He hungered have drawn such fire upon their heads, what consolation shall they enjoy who plunder what belongs not to them at all, who weave ten thousand law-suits, who unjustly grasp the property of all men? Let us then cast out this desire; and we shall cast it out if we think of those before us who did wrongfully, who were covetous and are gone. Do not others enjoy their wealth and labors while they lie in punishment, and vengeance, and intolerable woes? And how can this be anything but extreme folly, to weary and vex ourselves, that living we may strain ourselves with labor, and on our departure hence undergo intolerable punishments and vengeances, when we might have enjoyed ourselves here, (for nothing so much causes pleasure as the consciousness of almsgiving,) and departing to that place might have been delivered from all our woes, and obtained ten thousand blessings? For as wickedness is wont to punish those who go after it, even before (they arrive at) the pit, so also virtue, even before the (gift of) the Kingdom, provides delights for those who here practice it, making them to live in company with good hopes and continual pleasure. Therefore that we may obtain this, both here and in the life to come, let us hold fast to good works, so shall we gain the future crown; to which may we all reach through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom and with whom, to the Father and the Holy Ghost, be glory, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 39 — John 5:23-24

Homily 39 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240139.htm>.

Contents · 8 chapters
  1. John 5:23-24
  2. John 5:24
  3. John 5:25
  4. John 5:26
  5. John 5:27
  6. John 5:28
  7. John 5:28-29
  8. John 5:30

John 5:23-24

Beloved, we need great diligence in all things, because we will give an account and undergo a strict inquiry both of our words and works. Our concerns do not stop with what exists now, but a certain other condition of life will receive us after this, and we will be brought before a fearful tribunal. For we must appear before the Judgment-seat of Christ, so that every person may receive the things done in his body, according to what he has done, whether it be good or bad. 2 Corinthians 5:10 Let us always keep in mind this tribunal, so that we may be enabled at all times to continue in virtue; for just as the person who has cast out from his soul that day rushes like a horse that has burst his bridle toward precipices (for his ways are always defiled Psalm 10:5), and then, giving the reason, the Psalmist has added, He puts Your judgments far away out of his sight, so the person who always retains this fear will walk soberly. Remember, says one, your last things, and you shall never do amiss. Sirach 7:40 For He who now has remitted our sins will then sit in judgment; He who has died for our sake will then appear again to judge all mankind. Unto them that look for Him, says the Apostle, shall He appear the second time without sin unto salvation. Hebrews 9:28 Therefore in this place also He says, My Father judges no man, but has committed all judgment unto the Son; that all men should honor the Son; even as they honor the Father.

1. Beloved, we need great diligence in all things, for we shall render account of and undergo a strict enquiry both of words and works. Our interests stop not with what now is, but a certain other condition of life shall receive us after this, and we shall be brought before a fearful tribunal. For we must appear before the Judgment-seat of Christ, that every one may receive the things done in his body, according to that he has done, whether it be good or bad. 2 Corinthians 5:10 Let us ever bear in mind this tribunal, that we may thus be enabled at all times to continue in virtue; for as he who has cast out from his soul that day, rushes like a horse that has burst his bridle to precipices, (for his ways are always defiled Psalm 10:5) and then assigning the reason the Psalmist has added, He puts Your judgments far away out of his sight;) so he that always retains this fear will walk soberly. Remember, says one, your last things, and you shall never do amiss. Sirach 7:40 For He who now has remitted our sins, will then sin in judgment; He who has died for our sake will then appear again to judge all mankind. Unto them that look for Him, says the Apostle, shall He appear the second time without sin unto salvation. Hebrews 9:28 Wherefore in this place also He says, My Father judges no man, but has committed all judgment unto the Son; that all men should honor the Son; even as they honor the Father.

Shall we then, someone says, also call Him Father? Far from it. He uses the word Son so that we may honor Him while He remains a Son, just as we honor the Father. But whoever calls Him Father does not honor the Son as the Father, but has confused everything. Moreover, since people are drawn more effectively by being punished than by being benefited, He has spoken in this terrifying way so that even fear may draw them to honor Him. And when He says all, His meaning is this: that He has power to punish and to honor, and does either as He wills. The expression has given is used so that you may not suppose Him not to have been Begotten, and thus think that there are two Fathers. For all that the Father is, this the Son is also—Begotten and remaining a Son. And so that you may learn that has given is the same as has begotten, hear this very thing declared by another passage. As, says Christ, the Father has life in Himself, so has He given to the Son to have life in Himself. John 5:26 What then? Did He first beget and then give Him life? For whoever gives, gives to something which already exists. Was He then begotten without life? Not even the devils could imagine this, for it is both very foolish and impious. As then has given life means has begotten Him who is Life, so has given judgment means has begotten Him who shall be Judge.

Shall we then, says some one, also call Him Father? Away with the thought. He uses the word Son that we may honor Him still remaining a Son, as we honor the Father; but he who calls Him Father does not honor the Son as the Father, but has confounded the whole. Moreover as men are not so much brought to by being benefited as by being punished, on this account He has spoken thus terribly, that even fear may draw them to honor Him. And when He says all, His meaning is this, that He has power to punish and to honor, and does either as He will. The expression has given, is used that you may not suppose Him not to have been Begotten, and so think that there are two Fathers. For all that the Father is, this the Son is also, Begotten, and remaining a Son. And that you may learn that has given is the same as has begotten, hear this very thing declared by another place. As, says Christ, the Father has life in Himself, so has He given to the Son to have life in Himself. John 5:26 What then? Did he first beget and then give Him life? For he who gives, gives to something which is. Was He then begotten without life? Not even the devils could imagine this, for it is very foolish as well as impious. As then has given life is has begotten Him who is Life, so, has given judgment is has begotten Him who shall be Judge.

That you may not, when you hear that He has the Father as His cause, imagine any difference of ousia or inferiority of honor, He comes to judge you, by this proving His Equality. For He who has authority to punish and to honor whom He will has the same Power as the Father. Since, if this is not the case, if having been begotten He afterwards received the honor, how did He come to be afterwards honored in this way? By what mode of advancement did He reach so far as to receive and be appointed to this dignity? Are you not ashamed to apply these carnal and mean imaginations so impudently to that Pure Nature which admits of no addition?

That you may not when you hear that He has the Father for His cause imagine any difference of essence or inferiority of honor, He comes to judge you, by this proving His Equality. For He who has authority to punish and to honor whom He will, has the same Power with the Father. Since, if this be not the case, if having been begotten He afterwards received the honor, how came it that He was afterwards [thus] honored, by what mode of advancement reached He so far as to receive and be appointed to this dignity? Are ye not ashamed thus impudently to apply to that Pure Nature which admits of no addition these carnal and mean imaginations?

Why then, someone asks, does Christ speak this way? So that His words may be easily received, and to prepare the way for elevated teachings. Therefore He mixes these statements with those, and those with these. And observe how He does it—it is useful to see this from the beginning. He said, "My Father works, and I work" (John 5:17), declaring by this their equality and equal honor. But they sought to kill Him. What does He do then? He lowers His manner of speaking, yet keeps the same meaning when He says, "The Son can do nothing of Himself." Then again He raises His discourse to high matters, saying, "Whatever things the Father does, these also the Son does likewise." Then He returns to what is lower: "For the Father loves the Son, and shows Him all things that Himself does; and He will show Him greater things than these." Then He rises higher: "For as the Father raises up the dead and quickens them, even so the Son quickens whom He will." After this He joins the high and the low together: "For neither does the Father judge anyone, but has given all judgment to the Son." Then He rises again: "That all men should honor the Son, even as they honor the Father." Do you see how He varies the discourse, weaving it from both high and low words and expressions, so that it might be acceptable to the people of that time, and so that those who would come later might receive no harm, gaining from the higher part a right understanding of the rest? For if this is not the case—if these sayings were not spoken through condescension—why were the high expressions added? Because someone who is entitled to utter great words concerning himself has, when he says anything lowly and humble, this reasonable excuse: that he does it for some wise purpose. But if someone who ought to speak humbly of himself says anything great, for what reason does he utter words that surpass his nature? This serves no purpose at all, but is an act of extreme impiety.

Why then, says some one, does Christ so speak? That His words may be readily received, and to clear the way for sublime sayings; therefore He mixes these with those, and those with these. And observe how (He does it); for it is good to see this from the beginning. He said, My Father works, and I work John 5:17, etc.: declaring by this their Equality and Equal honor. But they sought to kill Him. What does He then? He lowers His form of speech indeed, and puts the same meaning when He says, The Son can do nothing of Himself. Then again He raises His discourse to high matters, saying, Whatever things the Father does, these also does the Son likewise. Then He returns to what is lower, For the Father loves the Son, and shows Him all things that Himself does; and He will show Him greater things than these. Then He rises higher, For as the Father raises up the dead and quickens them, even so the Son quickens whom He will. After this again He joins the high and the low together, For neither does the Father judge any one, but has given all judgment to the Son; then rises again, That all men should honor the Son, even as they honor the Father. Do you see how He varies the discourse, weaving it both of high and low words and expressions, in order that it might be acceptable to the men of that time, and that those who should come after might receive no injury, gaining from the higher part a right opinion of the rest? For if this be not the case, if these sayings were not uttered through condescension, wherefore were the high expressions added? Because one who is entitled to utter great words concerning himself, has, when he says anything mean and low, this reasonable excuse, that he does it for some prudential purpose; but if one who ought to speak meanly of himself says anything great, on what account does he utter words which surpass his nature? This is not for any purpose at all, but an act of extreme impiety.

We can therefore give a reason for the humble expressions—a reason that is sufficient and fitting for God: His condescension, His teaching us to be moderate, and the salvation He accomplishes for us in this way. To make this clear, He Himself said in another place, "These things I say that you might be saved." For when He set aside His own testimony and turned to John's testimony (something unworthy of His greatness), He explains the reason for such humble language, saying, "These things I say that you might be saved." And you who claim that He does not have the same authority and power as the One who begot Him—what can you say when you hear Him speak words that declare His authority, power, and glory equal to the Father's? Therefore, if He is much inferior as you claim, why does He demand the same honor? And He doesn't stop there, but continues to say,

2. We are therefore able to assign a reason for the lowly expressions, a reason sufficient, and becoming to God, namely, His condescension, His teaching us to be moderate, and the salvation which is thus wrought for us. To declare which He said Himself in another place, These things I say that you might be saved. For when He left His own witness, and betook Himself to that of John, (a thing unworthy of His greatness,) He puts the reason of such lowliness of language, and says, These things I say that you might be saved. And ye who assert that He has not the same authority and power with Him who begot Him, what can you say when you hear Him utter words by which He declares His Authority and Power and Glory equal in respect of the Father? Wherefore, if He be as you assert very inferior, does He claim the same honor? Nor does He stop even here, but goes on to say,

He that honors not the Son honors not the Father which has sent Him. Do you see how the honor of the Son is connected with that of the Father? What about that? someone says. We see the same thing in the case of the Apostles: "He," Christ says, "who receives you receives Me." But in that passage He speaks this way because He makes the concerns of His servants His own. Here, however, it is because the ousia and the Glory is One with that of the Father. Therefore it is not said of the Apostles that they may honor, but rightly He says, He that honors not the Son honors not the Father. For where there are two kings, if one is insulted the other is insulted also, and especially when the one who is insulted is a son. He is insulted even when one of his soldiers is mistreated—not in the same way as in this case, but as it were in the person of another, while here it is as it were in his own person. This is why He said beforehand, That they should honor the Son even as they honor the Father, so that when He should say, He that honors not the Son honors not the Father, you might understand that the honor is the same. For He does not merely say, he that honors not the Son, but he that honors Him not in the way I have said honors not the Father.

He that honors not the Son honors not the Father which has sent Him. Do you see how the honor of the Son is connected with that of the Father? What of that? says one. We see the same in the case of the Apostles; 'He,' says Christ, 'who receives you receives Me.' Matthew 10:40 But in that place He speaks so, because He makes the concerns of His servants His own; here, because the Essence and the Glory is One (with that of the Father). Therefore it is not said of the Apostles that they may honor, but rightly He says, He that honors not the Son honors not the Father. For where there are two kings, if one is insulted the other is insulted also, and especially when he that is insulted is a son. He is insulted even when one of his soldiers is maltreated; not in the same way as in this case, but as it were in the person of another, while here it is as it were in his own. Wherefore He beforehand said, That they should honor the Son even as they honor the Father, in order that when He should say, He that honors not the Son honors not the Father, you might understand that the honor is the same. For He says not merely, he that honors not the Son, but he that honors Him not so as I have said honors not the Father.

And how, someone asks, can the one who sends and the one who is sent be of the same ousia? Again, you are dragging the argument down to earthly matters, and you don't realize that all this has been said for no other purpose than so we might know Him to be the Cause, and not fall into the error of Sabellius, and so that the weakness of the Jews might be healed in this way, so that He might not be considered an enemy of God. For they said, "This man is not of God," "This man has not come from God." Now to remove this suspicion, lowly sayings contributed more than lofty ones, and therefore He constantly and everywhere said that He had been sent—not so you would suppose that expression lessens His greatness in any way, but in order to silence them. And for this reason also He continually appeals to the Father, while also inserting mention of His own high origin. For if He had spoken everything in proportion to His dignity, the Jews would not have accepted His words, since because of just a few such expressions they persecuted and often stoned Him. And if He had looked only to them and used nothing but lowly expressions, many in later times might have been harmed. Therefore He mixes and blends His teaching, both stopping the mouths of the Jews with these lowly sayings, as I said, and also driving away any mean notion of what He had said from sensible people by expressions suited to His dignity, and proving that such a notion did not apply to Him at all in any way.

And how, says one, can he that sends and he that is sent be of the same essence? Again, you bring down the argument to carnal things, and perceivest not that all this has been said for no other purpose, but that we might know Him to be The Cause, and not fall into the error of Sabellius, and that in this manner the infirmity of the Jews might be healed, so that He might not be deemed an enemy of God; for they said, This man is not of God John 9:16, This man has not come from God. Now to remove this suspicion, high sayings did not contribute so much as the lowly, and therefore continually and everywhere He said that He had been sent; not that you might suppose that expression to be any lessening of His greatness, but in order to stop their mouths. And for this cause also He constantly betakes Himself to the Father, interposing moreover mention of His own high Parentage. For had He said all in proportion to His dignity, the Jews would not have received His words, since because of a few such expressions, they persecuted and oftentimes stoned Him; and if looking wholly to them He had used none but low expressions, many in after times might have been harmed. Wherefore He mingles and blends His teaching, both by these lowly sayings stopping, as I said, the mouths of the Jews, and also by expressions suited to His dignity banishing from men of sense any mean notion of what He had said, and proving that such a notion did not in any wise apply to Him at all.

The expression "having been sent" indicates a change of location—but God is present everywhere. Why then does He say that He was sent? He speaks in human terms, declaring His complete unity of will with the Father. Indeed, He shapes the words that follow with the intention of accomplishing this very thing.

The expression having been sent denotes change of place — but God is everywhere present. Wherefore then says He that He was sent? He speaks in an earthly way, declaring His unanimity with the Father. At least He shapes His succeeding words with a desire to effect this.

John 5:24

Do you see how He keeps repeating the same point to heal their suspicion? Both here and in what follows, He uses fear and promises of good things to remove their jealousy toward Him, and then He lowers Himself greatly in His words. He did not say "he who hears My words and believes in Me," because they would certainly have considered that pride and an unnecessary show of words. If after a very long time and countless miracles they still suspected this when He spoke this way, they would have done so even more at that earlier time. That is why later they said to Him, "Abraham is dead, and the prophets are dead, so how can You say, 'If a man keeps My saying, he shall never taste death?'" (John 8:52). So to keep them from becoming furious here as well, notice what He says: "He who hears My word and believes in Him who sent Me has everlasting life." This had no small effect in making His message acceptable, when they learned that those who hear Him also believe in the Father. After they readily accepted this, they would more easily accept the rest. So speaking in a humble manner actually contributed and paved the way for higher things. For after saying "has everlasting life," He adds,

Do you see how continually He puts the same thing to cure that feeling of suspicion, both in this place and in what follows by fear and by promises of blessings removing their jealousy of Him, and then again condescending greatly in words? For He said not, he that hears My words, and believes in Me, since they would have certainly deemed that to be pride, and a superfluous pomp of words; because, if after a very long time, and ten thousand miracles, they suspected this when He spoke after this manner, much more would they have done so then. It was on this account that at that later period they said to Him, Abraham is dead, and the prophets are dead, how sayest Thou, If a man keep My saying, he shall never taste of death? John 8:52 In order therefore that they may not here also become furious, see what He says, He that hears My word, and believes in Him that sent Me, has everlasting life. This had no small effect in making His discourse acceptable, when they learned that those who hear Him believe in the Father also; for after having received this with readiness, they would more easily receive the rest. So that the very speaking in a humble manner contributed and led the way to higher things; for after saying, has everlasting life, He adds,

And comes not into judgment, but is passed from death unto life.

And comes not into judgment, but is passed from death unto life.

Christ makes His message appealing through two things: first, because it is the Father who is the object of faith, and second, because the believer receives many blessings. And the phrase "comes not into judgment" means is not punished, for He is not speaking here of physical death, but of eternal death, just as He also speaks of the other life which is deathless.

By these two things He makes His discourse acceptable; first, because it is the Father who is believed on, and then, because the believer enjoys many blessings. And the comes not into judgment means, is not punished, for He speaks not of death here, but of death eternal, as also of the other life which is deathless.

John 5:25

Having said these words, He also speaks of the proof by deeds. For when He had said, "As the Father raises up the dead and gives them life, even so the Son gives life to whom He will," so that the thing might not seem to be mere boasting and pride, He offers proof by works, saying, "The hour comes." Then, so that you may not think that the time is long, He adds, "and now is, when the dead shall hear the voice of the Son of God, and they that have heard shall live." Do you see here His absolute and unutterable authority? For as it shall be in the Resurrection, even so, He says, it shall be now. Then too when we hear His voice commanding us we are raised; for, says the Apostle, at the command of God the dead shall arise. And from where, perhaps someone will ask, is it clear that the words are not mere boasting? From what He has added, "and now is"; because had His promises referred only to some future time, His discourse would have been suspected by them, but now He supplies them with a proof: "While I," He says, "am present among you, this thing shall come to pass"; and He would not, had He not possessed the power, have promised for that time, lest through the promise He should incur the greater ridicule. Then too He adds an argument demonstrating His assertions, saying,

Having said the words, He speaks also of the proof by deeds. For when He had said, As the Father raises up the dead and quickens them, even so the Son quickens whom He will, that the thing may not seem to be mere boasting and pride, He affords proof by works, saying, The hour comes; then, that you may not deem that the time is long, He adds, and now is, when the dead shall hear the voice of the Son of God, and they that have heard shall live. Do you see here His absolute and unutterable authority? For as it shall be in the Resurrection, even so, He says, it shall be now. Then too when we hear His voice commanding us we are raised; for, says the Apostle, at the command of God the dead shall arise. And whence, perhaps some one will ask, is it clear that the words are not mere boast? From what He has added, and now is; because had His promises referred only to some future time, His discourse would have been suspected by them, but now He supplies them with a proof: While I, says He, am tarrying among you, this thing shall come to pass; and He would not, had He not possessed the power, have promised for that time, lest through the promise He should incur the greater ridicule. Then too He adds an argument demonstrative of His assertions, saying,

John 5:26

Do you see that this declares a perfect likeness except in one point, which is that One is a Father and the Other a Son? For the expression "has given" merely introduces this distinction, but declares that all the rest is equal and exactly alike. From this it is clear that the Son does all things with as much authority and power as the Father, and that He is not empowered from some other source, for He has life in the same way as the Father has. And for this reason, what comes next is immediately added, so that from this we may understand the other also. What is this then? It is,

3. Do you see that this declares a perfect likeness save in one point, which is the One being a Father, and the Other a Son? For the expression has given, merely introduces this distinction, but declares that all the rest is equal and exactly alike. Whence it is clear that the Son does all things with as much authority and power as the Father, and that He is not empowered from some other source, for He has life so as the Father has. And on this account, what comes after is straightway added, that from this we may understand the other also. What is this then? It is,

John 5:27

Why does He continually focus on resurrection and judgment? For He says, "As the Father raises up the dead and quickens them, even so the Son quickens whom He will," and again, "the Father judges no man, but has committed all judgment to the Son," and again, "As the Father has life in Himself so has He given to the Son to have life in Himself," and again, "They that have heard the Voice of the Son of God shall live," and here again, "has given to Him authority to execute judgment." Why does He keep returning to these things? I mean, to judgment, and life, and resurrection? It is because these topics are able more than any others to draw in even the stubborn listener. For the person who is convinced that he will both rise again and give an account to Christ for his sins, even if he has seen no other sign, yet having accepted this, will surely run to Him to appease his Judge.

And wherefore does He continually dwell upon resurrection and judgment? For He says, As the Father raises up the dead and quickens them, even so the Son quickens whom He will: and again, the Father judges no man, but has committed all judgment to the Son: and again, As the Father has life in Himself so has He given to the Son to have life in Himself; and again, They that have heard [the Voice of the Son of God] shall live; and here again, Hath given to Him authority to execute judgment. Wherefore does He dwell on these things continually? I mean, on judgment, and life, and resurrection? It is because these subjects are able most of any to attract even the obstinate hearer. For the man who is persuaded that he shall both rise again and shall give account to Christ of his transgressions, even though he have seen no other sign, yet having admitted this, will surely run to Him to propitiate his Judge.

John 5:28

Paul of Samosata interprets it differently, but how? "He has given Him authority to execute judgment because He is the Son of Man." Now when the passage is read this way, it makes no sense, for He did not receive judgment authority because He was man (otherwise, what would prevent all men from being judges?), but because He is the Son of that Ineffable Essence, He is therefore Judge. So we must read it this way: "That He is the Son of Man, do not marvel at this." For when what He said seemed inconsistent to the hearers, and they considered Him nothing more than a mere man, while His words were greater than what suited man or even angel and were appropriate to God alone, to resolve this objection He adds,

Paul of Samosata renders it not so; but how? Hath given Him authority to execute judgment, 'because' He is the Son of Man. Now the passage thus read is inconsequent, for He did not receive judgment because He was man, (since then what hindered all men from being judges,) but because He is the Son of that Ineffable Essence, therefore is He Judge. So we must read, That He is the Son of Man, marvel not at this. For when what He said seemed to the hearers inconsistent, and they deemed Him nothing more than mere man, while His words were greater than suited man, yea, or even angel, and were proper to God only, to solve this objection He adds,

John 5:28-29

Why did He not say, "Do not marvel that He is the Son of Man, for He is also the Son of God," but instead mentioned the resurrection? He actually did address this earlier by saying "shall hear the voice of the Son of God." And if He is silent about it here, do not be surprised, for after mentioning a work that belongs properly to God, He then allows His hearers to infer from it that He was God and the Son of God. If He had continually asserted this Himself, it would have offended them at that time, but when proved through the demonstration of miracles, it made His teaching less burdensome. Similarly, those who construct logical arguments, after laying down their premises and fairly proving the point in question, often do not draw the conclusion themselves. Instead, to make their hearers more receptive and their victory more obvious, they cause the opponent himself to give the verdict, so that the bystanders will more readily agree with them when their opponents decide in their favor. Therefore, when He mentioned the resurrection of Lazarus, He did not speak of the Judgment (for Lazarus did not rise for this purpose), but when He spoke in general terms He also added that those who have done good shall go forth unto the resurrection of life, and those who have done evil unto the resurrection of judgment. John likewise led his hearers forward by speaking of the Judgment: "he that believes not on the Son shall not see life, but the wrath of God abides on him" (John 3:36). Jesus Himself also led Nicodemus forward in the same way: He said to him, "He that believes in the Son is not judged, but he that believes not is judged already" (John 3:18). Here too He mentions the judgment seat and the punishment that shall follow upon evil deeds. Because He had said earlier, "He that hears My words and believes in Him that sent Me is not judged," lest anyone should think that this alone is sufficient for salvation, He adds also the outcome of a person's life, declaring that those who have done good shall come forth unto the resurrection of life, and those who have done evil unto the resurrection of judgment. Since He had said that all the world should give account to Him, and that all at His voice should rise again—something new and strange and even now disbelieved by many who seem to have believed, not to mention by the Jews at that time—hear how He proceeds to prove it, again accommodating Himself to the weakness of His hearers.

And wherefore said He not, Marvel not that He is the Son of Man, for He is also the Son of God, but rather mentioned the resurrection? He did indeed put this above, by saying, shall hear the Voice of the Son of God. And if here He is silent on the matter, wonder not; for after mentioning a work which was proper to God, He then permits His hearers to collect from it that He was God, and the Son of God. For had this been continually asserted by Himself, it would at that time have offended them, but when proved by the argument of miracles, it rendered His doctrine less burdensome. So they who put together syllogisms, when having laid down their premises they have fairly proved the point in question, frequently do not draw the conclusion themselves, but to render their hearers more fairly disposed, and to make their victory more evident, cause the opponent himself to give the verdict, so that the by-standers may the rather agree with them when their opponents decide in their favor. When therefore He mentioned the resurrection of Lazarus, He spoke not of the Judgment (for it was not for this that Lazarus arose); but when He spoke generally He also added, that they that have done good shall go forth unto the resurrection of life, and they that have done evil unto the resurrection of judgment. Thus also John led on his hearers by speaking of the Judgment, and that he that believes not on the Son, shall not see life, but the wrath of God abides on him John 3:36: so too Himself led on Nicodemus: He that believes in the Son, He said to him, is not judged, but he that believes not is judged already John 3:18; and so here He mentions the Judgment-seat and the punishment which shall follow upon evil deeds. For because He had said above, He that hears My words and believes in Him that sent Me, is not judged, lest any one should imagine that this alone is sufficient for salvation, He adds also the result of man's life, declaring that they which have done good shall come forth unto the resurrection of life, and they that have done evil unto the resurrection of judgment. Since then He had said that all the world should render account to Him, and that all at His Voice should rise again, a thing new and strange and even now disbelieved by many who seem to have believed, not to say by the Jews at that time, hear how He goes to prove it, again condescending to the infirmity of His hearers.

John 5:30

Although He had just recently given a significant proof of the Resurrection by restoring the paralytic—which is why He did not speak about the Resurrection until after He had done something that fell only a little short of resurrection—and although He hinted at the Judgment after He had restored the body by saying, "Behold, you are made whole, sin no more, lest a worse thing come unto you," He still proclaimed beforehand both the resurrection of Lazarus and the resurrection of the world. After He had spoken of these two resurrections—that of Lazarus, which would happen almost immediately, and that of the inhabited world, which would occur long afterward—He confirms the first by means of the paralytic and by the nearness of the time, saying, "The hour comes and now is," and He confirms the other by the raising of Lazarus, using what had already happened to demonstrate before their eyes what had not yet occurred. We can observe Him doing this everywhere, putting forth two or three predictions and always confirming the future by the past.

Although He had but lately given no trifling proof of the Resurrection by bracing the paralytic; on which account also He had not spoken of the Resurrection before He had done what fell little short of resurrection. And the Judgment He hinted at after He had braced the body, by saying, Behold, you are made whole, sin no more, lest a worse thing come unto you; yet still He proclaimed beforehand the resurrection of Lazarus and of the world. And when He had spoken of these two, that of Lazarus which should come to pass almost immediately, and that of the inhabited world which should be long after, He confirms the first by the paralytic and by the nearness of the time, saying, The hour comes and now is; the other by the raising of Lazarus, by what had already come to pass bringing before their sight what had not yet done so. And this we may observe Him do everywhere, putting (forth) two or three predictions, and always confirming the future by the past.

Yet after saying and doing so much, since they were still very weak, He is not content but calms their argumentative temper with other words, saying, "I can of Myself do nothing; as I hear I judge, and My judgment is just, because I seek not My own will, but the will of Him which sent Me." Since He appeared to make some statements that seemed strange and different from those of the Prophets—for they said that it is God who judges all the earth, that is, the human race, and David proclaimed this truth loudly everywhere: "He shall judge the people in righteousness" and "God is a righteous Judge, strong and patient" (Psalm 96:10 and Psalm 7:11, Septuagint), as did all the Prophets and Moses; but Christ said, "The Father judges no man, but has committed all judgment to the Son," an expression that was enough to confuse a Jew who heard it and make him in turn suspect Christ of being an enemy of God—He here greatly condescends in His speech, as far as their weakness requires, in order to pull up this harmful opinion by the roots, and says, "I can of Myself do nothing." That is, you will see or hear nothing from Me that is strange, unlike, or contrary to what the Father desires. And having earlier declared that He was the Son of Man, and because they supposed Him to be a man at that time, He puts His expressions here accordingly. Just as when He said above, "We speak that we have heard, and testify that we have seen," and when John said, "What He has seen He testifies, and no man receives His testimony" (John 3:32)—both expressions refer to exact knowledge, not merely to hearing and seeing—so in this place when He speaks of hearing, He declares nothing else than that it is impossible for Him to desire anything except what the Father desires. Still He did not say this plainly, for they would not have readily accepted it if He had stated it that way. And how does He say it? In a manner very condescending and appropriate to a mere man: "As I hear I judge." Again He uses these words here not with reference to instruction—for He did not say "as I am taught," but "as I hear"—nor as though He needed to listen, for not only did He not need to be taught, but He did not even need to listen. Rather, it was to declare the unanimity and identity of His and the Father's decision, as though He had said, "I judge in the same way as if it were the Father Himself who judged." Then He adds, "and I know that My judgment is just, because I seek not My own will, but the will of Him that sent Me." What are You saying? Do You have a will different from that of the Father? Yet in another place He says, "As I and Thou are One" (speaking of will and unanimity), "grant to these also that they may be one in Us" (John 17:21, not verbally quoted)—that is, in faith concerning Us. Do you see that the words which seem most humble are those which conceal a high meaning? For what He implies is of this kind: not that the will of the Father is one and His own is another, but that, as one will in one mind, so is My own will and My Father's.

4. Yet after saying and doing so much, since they still were very weak He is not content, but by other expressions calms their disputatious temper, saying, I can of Myself do nothing; as I hear I judge, and My judgment is just, because I seek not My own will, but the will of Him which sent Me. For since He appeared to make some assertions strange and varying from those of the Prophets, (for they said that it is God who judges all the earth, that is, the human race; and this truth David everywhere loudly proclaimed, He shall judge the people in righteousness, and, God is a righteous Judge, strong and patient Psalm 96:10, and Psalm 7:11, Septuagint; as did all the Prophets and Moses; but Christ said, The Father judges no man, but has committed all judgment to the Son: an expression which was sufficient to perplex a Jew who heard it, and to make him in turn suspect Christ of being an enemy of God,) He here greatly condescends in His speech, and as far as their infirmity requires, in order to pluck up by the roots this pernicious opinion, and says, I can of Myself do nothing; that is, nothing strange, or unlike, or what the Father desires not will you see done or hear said by Me. And having before declared that He was the Son of Man, and because they supposed Him to be a man at that time, so also He puts [His expressions] here. As then when He said above, We speak that we have heard, and testify that we have seen; and when John said, What He has seen He testifies, and no man receives His testimony John 3:32; both expressions are used respecting exact knowledge, not concerning hearing and seeing merely; so in this place when He speaks of hearing, He declares nothing else than that it is impossible for Him to desire anything, save what the Father desires. Still He said not so plainly, (for they would not as yet have at once received it on hearing it thus asserted;) and how? In a manner very condescending and befitting a mere man, As I hear I judge. Again He uses these words in this place, not with reference to instruction, (for He said not, as I am taught, but as I hear;) nor as though He needed to listen, (for not only did He not require to be taught, but He needed not even to listen;) but it was to declare the Unanimity and Identity of [His and the Father's] decision, as though He had said, So I judge, as if it were the Father Himself that judged. Then He adds, and I know that My judgment is just, because I seek not My own will, but the will of Him that sent Me. What sayest Thou? Have You a will different from that of the Father? Yet in another place He says, As I and Thou are One, (speaking of will and unanimity,) grant to these also that they may be one in Us John 17:21; not verbally quoted; that is, in faith concerning Us. Do you see that the words which seem most humble are those which conceal a high meaning? For what He implies is of this kind: not that the will of the Father is one, and His own another; but that, as one will in one mind, so is My own will and My Father's.

And do not be surprised that He has claimed such a close union. Paul used the same illustration when speaking about the Spirit: "What man knows the things of a man, except the spirit of man which is in him? Even so the things of God knows no man, but the Spirit of God." So Christ's meaning is simply this: I do not have a will that is different and separate from the Father's. If He wants something, then I do too; if I want it, then He does too. Therefore, just as no one could object to the Father judging, no one may object to Me either, because the verdict of each comes from the same Mind. And if He speaks these words more like a man, do not be surprised, since they still considered Him to be merely a man. In passages like these, we must not only examine the meaning of the words, but also take into account what the hearers suspected, and understand what is said as being directed at that suspicion. Otherwise many difficulties will arise. Consider this: He says, "I seek not My own will." According to this, then, His will is different from the Father's, is imperfect—in fact, not merely imperfect, but even unprofitable. For if it is saving and agrees with the Father's, why would You not seek it? Mortal people might reasonably say this because they have many desires contrary to what the Father wants, but why would You say this when You are in all things like the Father? Not even a perfected man who has been crucified would speak this way. For if Paul so united himself with God's will that he could say, "I live, yet no longer I, but Christ lives in me," how does the Lord of all say, "I seek not My own will, but the will of Him that sent Me," as if that will were different? What then does He mean? He frames His message as if He were a mere man and adapts His language to His hearers' suspicions. After giving proof of His claims through what He said earlier—speaking partly as God, partly as a mere man—He again tries to establish the same point as a man, and says, "My judgment is just." And how is this demonstrated? Because "I seek not My own will, but the will of Him that sent Me." Just as with human beings, someone free from selfish ambition cannot justly be accused of making an unfair decision, neither can you now accuse Me. Someone who wants to establish his own interests might be suspected by many of corrupting justice for that purpose. But someone who does not look to his own interests—what reason could he have for not deciding justly? Now apply this reasoning to My case. If I had said I was not sent by the Father, if I had not given Him credit for the glory of what was done, some of you might perhaps have suspected that I was seeking honor for Myself and speaking falsely. But if I attribute and refer what is done to another, why and how could you have reason to suspect My words? Do you see how He strengthened His argument and showed that His judgment was just by using reasoning that any ordinary person might use in defending himself? Do you see how what I have often said is clearly visible? What is that? It is this: the extreme humility of these expressions especially persuades sensible people not to accept the words superficially and then fall into low opinions, but rather to work hard to reach the height of their meaning. This humility also easily lifts up those who were once groveling on the ground.

And marvel not that He has asserted so close a conjunction; for with reference to the Spirit also Paul has used this illustration: What man knows the things of a man, save the spirit of man which is in him? Even so the things of God knows no man, but the Spirit of God. Thus Christ's meaning is no other than this: I have not a will different and apart from that of the Father, but if He desires anything, then I also; if I, then He also. As therefore none could object to the Father judging, so neither may any to Me, for the sentence of Each is given from the same Mind. And if He utters these words rather as a man, marvel not, seeing that they still deemed Him to be mere man. Therefore in passages like these it is necessary not merely to enquire into the meaning of the words, but also to take into account the suspicion of the hearers, and listen to what is said as being addressed to that suspicion. Otherwise many difficulties will follow. Consider for instance, He says, I seek not My own will: according to this then His will is different (from that of the Father), is imperfect, nay, not merely imperfect, but even unprofitable. For if it be saving, if it agree with that of the Father, why do You not seek it? Mortals might with reason say so because they have many wills contrary to what seems good to the Father, but Thou, wherefore sayest Thou this, who art in all things like the Father? For this none would say is the language even of a man made perfect and crucified. For if Paul so blended himself with the will of God as to say, I live, yet no longer I, but Christ lives in me Galatians 2:20, how says the Lord of all, I seek not My own will, but the will of Him that sent Me, as though that will were different? What then is His meaning? He applies His discourse as if the case were that of a mere man, and suits His language to the suspicion of His hearers. For when He had, by what had gone before, given proof of His sayings, speaking partly as God, partly as a mere man, He again as a man endeavors to establish the same, and says, My judgment is just. And whence is this seen? Because I seek not My own will, but the will of Him that sent Me. For as in the case of men, he that is free from selfishness cannot be justly charged with having given an unfair decision, so neither will you now be able to accuse Me. He that desires to establish his own, may perhaps by many be suspected of corrupting justice with this intent; but he that looks not to his own, what reason can he have for not deciding justly? Apply now this reasoning to My case. Had I said that I was not sent by the Father, had I not referred to Him the glory of what was done, some of you might perhaps have suspected that desiring to gain honor for Myself, I said the thing that is not; but if I impute and refer what is done to another, wherefore and whence can you have cause to suspect My words? Do you see how He confirmed His discourse, and asserted that His judgment was just by an argument which any common man might have used in defending himself? Do you see how what I have often said is clearly visible? What is that? It is that the exceeding humility of the expressions most persuades men of sense not to receive the words off hand and then fall down [into low thoughts], but rather to take pains that they reach to the height of their meaning; this humility too with much ease then raises up those who were once groveling on the ground.

With all this in mind, I urge you not to pass carelessly by Christ's words, but to examine them all closely, always considering the reason for what has been said. Let us not assume that ignorance and simplicity will be enough to excuse us, for He has commanded us to be not merely harmless, but wise. Matthew 10:16 Let us therefore practice wisdom together with simplicity, both in doctrines and in the right actions of our lives. Let us judge ourselves here, so that we will not be condemned with the world hereafter. Let us act toward our fellow-servants as we want our Master to act toward us, for we say, Forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors. Matthew 6:12 I know that the wounded soul does not endure meekly, but if we consider that by doing so we benefit not the one who has wronged us but ourselves, we will quickly release the venom of our anger. For the one who did not forgive the hundred denarii to the one who had wronged him did not harm his fellow-servant but himself, by making himself liable again for the ten thousand talents he had previously been forgiven. Matthew 18:30-34 When we do not forgive others, we do not forgive ourselves. So let us not merely say to God, do not remember our offenses, but let each of us also say to ourselves, let us not remember the offenses of our fellow-servants done against us. For you first pass judgment on your own sins, and God judges afterward. You propose the law concerning remission and punishment, you declare your decision on these matters, and therefore whether God will or will not remember rests with you. For this reason Paul commands us to forgive, if anyone has a complaint against anyone Colossians 3:13, and not simply to forgive, but so that not even any remnants are left behind. Since Christ not only did not make our transgressions public, but did not even remind us the transgressors of them, nor say, in such and such things you have offended, but remitted and blotted out the handwriting, not counting our offenses, as Paul has also declared. Colossians 2:14 Let us also do this. Let us wipe away all trespasses against us from our minds, and if anything good has been done to us by the one who has wronged us, let us remember only that. But if anything grievous and hard to bear has occurred, let us cast it out and blot it out, so that not even a trace of it remains. And if nothing good has been done to us by that person, our reward and higher credit will be all the greater if we forgive. Others wipe away their sins by vigils, by sleeping on the ground, by ten thousand hardships, but you may cause all your trespasses to disappear by an easier way, namely by not remembering wrongs. Why then do you thrust the sword against yourself, as mad and frantic people do, and banish yourself from the life to come, when you ought to use every means to attain it? For if this present life is so desirable, what can one say of that other life from which pain and grief and mourning have fled away? There one need not fear death, nor imagine any end to those good things. Blessed, three times blessed, yes, and this many times over, are those who enjoy that blessed rest, while miserable, three times miserable, yes, ten thousand times miserable, are those who have cast themselves out from that blessedness. And what, someone says, makes us enjoy that life? Hear the Judge Himself conversing with a certain young man on this matter. When the young man said, What shall I do to inherit eternal life? Matthew 19:16 Christ, after repeating the other commandments to him, ended with the love of neighbor. Perhaps like that rich man some of my hearers will say that we also have kept these, for we have neither robbed, nor killed, nor committed adultery. Yet surely you will not be able to say that you have loved your neighbor as you ought to have loved him. For if a man has envied or spoken evil of another, if he has not helped him when injured, or not shared his possessions with him, then neither has he loved him. Now Christ has commanded not only this, but something more. What then is this? Sell, He says, what you have, and give to the poor, and come, follow Me Matthew 19:21—calling the imitation of Him in our actions following Him. What do we learn from this? First, that the one who does not have all these things cannot attain the highest places in that rest. For after the young man had said, All these things I have done, Christ, as though some great thing were lacking for his perfect approval, replied, If you will be perfect, sell what you have, and give to the poor, and come, follow Me. First then we may learn this; secondly, that Christ rebuked the man for his vain boast, for one who lived in such abundance and did not care about others living in poverty—how could he love his neighbor? So he did not speak truly even in this matter. But let us do both of these things. Let us be eager to empty out our possessions and to purchase heaven. For if men have often spent all their possessions for worldly honor, an honor that was to remain here below, and even here not to remain with us long (for many even long before their deaths have been stripped of their power, and others because of it have often lost their lives, and yet, although aware of this, they spend everything for its sake)—if now they do so much for this kind of honor, what could be more wretched than we if for the sake of that honor which abides and cannot be taken from us we will not give up even a little, nor supply to others those things which in a short time while yet here we will leave behind? What madness it must be, when it is in our power voluntarily to give to others and so to take with us those things of which we will even against our will be deprived, to refuse to do so! Yet if a man were being led to death, and it were proposed to him to give up all his goods and so go free, we would think a favor was being done for him. And shall we, who are being led on the way to the pit, shall we, when it is allowed us to give up half and be free, prefer to be punished and uselessly to retain what is not ours, even to the point of losing what is ours? What excuse will we have, what claim for pardon, who, when so easy a road has been cut for us to life, rush down precipices and travel along an unprofitable path, depriving ourselves of all things both here and hereafter, when we might enjoy both in security? If then we did not do so before, let us at least stop now. And coming to our senses, let us rightly dispose of present things, so that we may easily receive those which are to come, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father and the Holy Ghost be glory, forever and ever. Amen.

Now bearing all this in mind, let us not, I exhort you, carelessly pass by Christ's words, but enquire closely into them all, everywhere considering the reason of what has been said; and let us not deem that ignorance and simplicity will be sufficient to excuse us, for He has bidden us not merely to be harmless, but wise. Matthew 10:16 Let us therefore practice wisdom with simplicity, both as to doctrines and the right actions of our lives; let us judge ourselves here, that we be not condemned with the world hereafter; let us act towards our fellow-servants as we desire our Master to act towards us: for (we say), Forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors. Matthew 6:12 I know that the smitten soul endures not meekly, but if we consider that by so doing we do a kindness not to him who has grieved us but to ourselves, we shall soon let go the venom of our wrath; for he who forgave not the hundred pence to him who had transgressed against him, wronged not his fellow-servant but himself, by rendering himself liable for the ten thousand talents of which he had before received forgiveness. Matthew 18:30-34 When therefore we forgive not others, we forgive not ourselves. And so let us not merely say to God, remember not our offenses; but let each also say to himself, let us not remember the offenses of our fellow-servants done against us. For you first give judgment on your own sins, and God judges after; you propose the law concerning remission and punishment, you declare your decision on these matters, and therefore whether God shall or shall not remember, rests with you. For which cause Paul bids us forgive, if any One has cause of complaint against any Colossians 3:13, and not simply forgive, but so that not even any remnants be left behind. Since Christ not only did not publish our transgressions, but did not put us the transgressors in mind of them, nor say, in such and such things have you offended, but remitted and blotted out the handwriting, not reckoning our offenses, as Paul has also declared. Colossians 2:14 Let us too do this; let us wipe away all [trespasses against us] from our minds; and if any good thing has been done to us by him that has grieved us, let us only reckon that; but if anything grievous and hard to bear, let us cast it forth and blot it out, so that not even a vestige of it remain. And if no good has been done us by him, so much the greater recompense and higher credit will be ours if we forgive. Others by watching, by making the earth their bed, by ten thousand hardships, wipe away their sins, but thou by an easier way, I mean by not remembering wrongs, may cause all your trespasses to disappear. Why then do you thrust the sword against yourself, as do mad and frantic men, and banishest yourself from the life which is to come, when you ought to use every means to attain unto it? For if this present life be so desirable, what can one say of that other from which pain, and grief, and mourning, have fled away? There it needs not to fear death, nor imagine any end to those good things. Blessed, thrice blessed, yea, and this many times over, are they who enjoy that blessed rest, while they are miserable, thrice miserable, yea, ten thousand times miserable, who have cast themselves forth from that blessedness. And what, says some one, is it that makes us to enjoy that life? Hear the Judge Himself conversing with a certain young man on this matter. When the young man said, What shall I do to inherit eternal life? Matthew 19:16 Christ, after repeating to him the other commandments, ended with the love of his neighbor. Perhaps like that rich man some of my hearers will say, that we also have kept these, for we neither have robbed, nor killed, nor committed adultery; yet assuredly you will not be able to say this, that you have loved your neighbor as you ought to have loved him. For if a man has envied or spoken evil of another, if he has not helped him when injured, or not imparted to him of his substance, then neither has he loved him. Now Christ has commanded not only this, but something besides. What then is this? Sell, he says, that you have, and give to the poor; and come, follow Me Matthew 19:21: terming the imitating Him in our actions following Him. What learn we hence? First, that he who has not all these things cannot attain unto the chief places in that rest. For after the young man had said, All these things have I done, Christ, as though some great thing were wanting to his being perfectly approved, replied, If you will be perfect, sell that you have, and give to the poor: and come, follow Me. First then we may learn this; secondly, that Christ rebuked the man for his vain boast; for one who lived in such superfluity, and regarded not others living in poverty, how could he love his neighbor? So that neither in this matter did he speak truly. But let us do both the one and the other of these things; let us be eager to empty out our substance, and to purchase heaven. Since if for worldly honor men have often expended their whole possessions, an honor which was to stay here below, and even here not to stay by us long, (for many even much before their deaths have been stripped of their supremacy, and others because of it have often lost their lives, and yet, although aware of this, they expend all for its sake;) if now they do so much for this kind of honor, what can be more wretched than we if for the sake of that honor which abides and which cannot be taken from us we will not give up even a little, nor supply to others those things which in a short time while yet here we shall leave? What madness must it be, when it is in our power voluntarily to give to others, and so to take with us those things of which we shall even against our will be deprived, to refuse to do so? Yet if a man were being led to death, and it were proposed to him to give up all his goods and so go free, we should think a favor was conferred upon him; and shall we, who are being led on the way to the pit, shall we, when it is allowed us to give up half and be free, prefer to be punished, and uselessly to retain what is not ours even to the losing what is so? What excuse shall we have, what claim for pardon, who, when so easy a road has been cut for us unto life, rush down precipices, and travel along an unprofitable path, depriving ourselves of all things both here and hereafter, when we might enjoy both in security? If then we did not so before, let us at least stop now; and coming to ourselves, let us rightly dispose of things present, that we may easily receive those which are to come, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father and the Holy Ghost be glory, for ever and ever. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 38 — John 5:14

Homily 38 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240138.htm>.

Contents · 8 chapters
  1. John 5:14
  2. John 5:15
  3. John 5:16
  4. John 5:17
  5. John 5:18
  6. John 5:19
  7. John 5:20
  8. John 5:21

John 5:14

Sin is a fearful thing, truly fearful, and it ruins the soul. Sometimes through its excess the damage has overflowed and attacked people's bodies as well. Since for the most part we feel no pain when the soul is diseased, but if the body receives even a little injury we make every effort to free it from its sickness because we are aware of the sickness, God often punishes the body for the sins of the soul. In this way, through the punishment of the inferior part, the better part may also receive some healing. This is how Paul dealt with the adulterer among the Corinthians, checking the disease of the soul by the destruction of the flesh. Having applied the knife to the body, he thus suppressed the evil, like an excellent physician using external burning for dropsy or spleen when these conditions refuse to respond to internal medicines. Christ also did this in the case of the paralytic, as He showed when He said, "Behold, you are made whole; sin no more, lest a worse thing come unto you."

1. A fearful thing is sin, fearful, and the ruin of the soul, and the mischief oftentimes through its excess has overflowed and attacked men's bodies also. For since for the most part when the soul is diseased we feel no pain, but if the body receive though but a little hurt, we use every exertion to free it from its infirmity, because we are sensible of the infirmity, therefore God oftentimes punishes the body for the transgressions of the soul, so that by means of the scourging of the inferior part, the better part also may receive some healing. Thus too among the Corinthians Paul restored the adulterer, checking the disease of the soul by the destruction of the flesh, and having applied the knife to the body, so repressed the evil 1 Corinthians 5:5; like some excellent physician employing external cautery for dropsy or spleen, when they refuse to yield to internal remedies. This also Christ did in the case of the paralytic; as He showed when He said, Behold, you are made whole; sin no more, lest a worse thing come unto you.

What do we learn from this? First, that his disease came from his sins; second, that the accounts of hellfire should be believed; third, that the punishment is long—indeed endless. Where now are those who say, "I murdered in one hour, I committed adultery in a brief moment, and yet I am punished eternally"? Look at this man: he had not sinned for as many years as he suffered, for he spent an entire lifetime in the length of his punishment. Sins are not judged by time but by the nature of the transgressions. Beyond this, we can see another thing: even if we have suffered severely for former sins, if we later fall into the same ones, we will suffer much more severely. And rightly so, for someone who is not made better even by punishment is afterward led on as insensible and a despiser to still heavier punishment. The fault itself should be enough to restrain and make more sober the man who has once slipped, but when not even the addition of punishment accomplishes this, he naturally requires more bitter torments. Now if even in this world, when we fall into the same sins after punishment, we are disciplined yet more severely than before, ought we not—when we have sinned but not been punished at all—to be exceedingly afraid and to tremble, knowing we are about to endure something irreparable? But why, someone asks, are not all punished in this way? For we see many wicked people healthy in body, vigorous, and enjoying great prosperity. But let us not be confident; let us mourn for them most of all in this case, since their having suffered nothing here moves them toward a severer vengeance hereafter. As Paul declares when he says, "But now that we are judged, we are chastened of the Lord, that we should not be condemned with the world" (1 Corinthians 11:32). For the punishments here are for warning; those there are for vengeance.

Now what do we learn from this? First, that his disease had been produced by his sins; secondly, that the accounts of hell fire are to be believed; thirdly, that the punishment is long, nay endless. Where now are those who say, I murdered in an hour, I committed adultery in a little moment of time, and am I eternally punished? For behold this man had not sinned for so many years as he suffered, for he had spent a whole lifetime in the length of his punishment; and sins are not judged by time, but by the nature of the transgressions. Besides this, we may see another thing, that though we have suffered severely for former sins, if we afterwards fall into the same, we shall suffer much more severely. And with good reason; for he who is not made better even by punishment, is afterwards led as insensible and a despiser to still heavier chastisement. The fault should of itself be sufficient to check and to render more sober the man who once has slipped, but when not even the addition of punishment effects this, he naturally requires more bitter torments. Now if even in this world when after punishment we fall into the same sins, we are chastised yet more severely then before, ought we not when after sinning we have not been punished at all, to be then very exceedingly afraid and to tremble, as being about to endure something irreparable? And wherefore, says some one, are not all thus punished? For we see many bad men well in body, vigorous, and enjoying great prosperity. But let us not be confident, let us mourn for them in this case most of all, since their having suffered nothing here, helps them on to a severer vengeance hereafter. As Paul declares when he says, But now that we are judged, we are chastened of the Lord, that we should not be condemned with the world 1 Corinthians 11:32; for the punishments here are for warning, there for vengeance.

What then, someone asks, do all diseases come from sin? Not all, but most of them do; and some come from different kinds of loose living, since gluttony, intemperance, and laziness produce such sufferings. But the one rule we must observe is to bear every affliction thankfully, for they are sent because of our sins, as in the book of Kings we see one attacked by gout; they are also sent to make us approved, as the Lord says to Job, Do you think that I have spoken to you, except that you might appear righteous?

What then, says one, do all diseases proceed from sin? Not all, but most of them; and some proceed from different kinds of loose living, since gluttony, intemperance, and sloth, produce such like sufferings. But the one rule we have to observe, is to bear every stroke thankfully; for they are sent because of our sins, as in the Kings we see one attacked by gout 1 Kings 15:23; they are sent also to make us approved, as the Lord says to Job, Do you think that I have spoken to you, save that you might appear righteous? Job 60:8, Septuagint

But why is it that in the case of these paralytics Christ brings up their sins? For He says also to the paralytic in Matthew who lay on a bed, "Son, be of good cheer, your sins are forgiven you" (Matthew 9:2), and to this man, "Behold, you are made whole; sin no more." I know that some slander this paralytic, claiming that he was an accuser of Christ, and that therefore this statement was addressed to him. But what shall we say about the other paralytic in Matthew, who heard nearly the same words? For Christ says to him also, "Your sins be forgiven you." From this it is clear that this man was not addressed for the reason they claim. And we can see this more clearly from what follows. For the Evangelist says, "Afterward Jesus finds him in the Temple," which is evidence of his great piety. For he did not go off into the marketplaces and public areas, nor did he give himself over to luxury and ease, but remained in the Temple, even though he was about to face such a violent attack and be harassed by everyone there. Yet none of these things persuaded him to leave the Temple. Moreover, when Christ found him, even after he had spoken with the Jews, He implied nothing of that sort. For if He had wanted to accuse him of this, He would have said to him, "Are you attempting the same sins as before? Have you not been made better by your cure?" Yet He said nothing of the kind, but simply secured him for the future.

But why is it that in the case of these paralytics Christ brings forward their sins? For He says also to him in Matthew who lay on a bed, Son, be of good cheer, your sins are forgiven you Matthew 9:2: and to this man, Behold, you are made whole; sin no more. I know that some slander this paralytic, asserting that he was an accuser of Christ, and that therefore this speech was addressed to him; what then shall we say of the other in Matthew, who heard nearly the same words? For Christ says to him also, Your sins be forgiven you. Whence it is clear, that neither was this man thus addressed on the account which they allege. And this we may see more clearly from what follows; for, says the Evangelist, Afterward Jesus finds him in the Temple, which is an indication of his great piety; for he departed not into the market places and walks, nor gave himself up to luxury and ease, but remained in the Temple, although about to sustain so violent an attack and to be harassed by all there. Yet none of these things persuaded him to depart from the Temple. Moreover Christ having found him, even after he had conversed with the Jews, implied nothing of the kind. For had He desired to charge him with this, He would have said to him, Are you again attempting the same sins as before, are you not made better by your cure? Yet He said nothing of the kind, but merely secures him for the future.

Why then, when He had healed those who were lame and crippled, did He not mention this in any case? I think the diseases of these paralytics arose from sinful acts, while those of the others came from natural weakness. Or if this is not the case, then through these men and the words spoken to them, He has spoken to the rest as well. Since this disease is more serious than any other, through the greater He corrects the lesser also. And just as when He had healed a certain other person He commanded him to give glory to God, directing this exhortation not to him alone but through him to all, so He addresses to these men, and through these to all the rest of mankind, that exhortation and advice which was given to them by word of mouth. Beyond this we may also say that Jesus perceived great endurance in his soul, and addressed the exhortation to him as to one who was able to receive His command, keeping him in health both through the benefit received and through the fear of future evils.

2. Why then, when He had cured the halt and maimed, did He not in any instance make mention of the like? Methinks that the diseases of these (the paralytic) arose from acts of sin, those of the others from natural infirmity. Or if this be not so, then by means of these men, and by the words spoken to them, He has spoken to the rest also. For since this disease is more grievous than any other, by the greater He corrects also the less. And as when He had healed a certain other He charged him to give glory to God, addressing this exhortation not to him only but through him to all, so He addresses to these, and by these to all the rest of mankind, that exhortation and advice which was given to them by word of mouth. Besides this we may also say, that Jesus perceived great endurance in his soul, and addressed the exhortation to him as to one who was able to receive His command, keeping him to health both by the benefit, and by the fear of future ills.

Notice the absence of boasting. He did not say, "Look, I have made you whole," but rather, "You are made whole; sin no more." And again, not "lest I punish you," but "lest a worse thing come to you"—putting both statements in an impersonal way and showing that the cure came more from grace than from what the man deserved. For He did not tell him that he was delivered after suffering the full punishment he deserved, but that he was made whole through lovingkindness. If that were not the case, He would have said, "Look, you have suffered enough punishment for your sins, so be steadfast from now on." But He did not speak that way. Instead, how did He speak? "You are made whole; sin no more." Let us continually repeat these words to ourselves, and if after being disciplined we have been delivered, let each of us say to himself, "You are made whole; sin no more." But if we do not suffer punishment even while continuing in the same behavior, let us use as our reminder those words of the Apostle: "The goodness of God leads us to repentance, but according to our hardness and impenitent heart, we treasure up for ourselves wrath."

And observe the absence of boasting. He said not, Behold, I have made you whole, but, You are made whole; sin no more. And again, not, lest I punish you, but, lest a worse thing come unto you; putting both expressions not personally, and showing that the cure was rather of grace than of merit. For He declared not to him that he was delivered after suffering the deserved amount of punishment, but that through lovingkindness he was made whole. Had this not been the case, He would have said, Behold, you have suffered a sufficient punishment for your sins, be steadfast for the future. But now He spoke not so, but how? Behold, you are made whole; sin no more. Let us continually repeat these words to ourselves, and if after having been chastised we have been delivered, let each say to himself, Behold, you are made whole; sin no more. But if we suffer not punishment though continuing in the same courses, let us use for our charm that word of the Apostle, The goodness of God leads [us] to repentance, but after [our] hardness and impenitent heart, [we] treasure up unto [ourselves] wrath. Romans 2:4-5

And not only by strengthening the sick man's body, but also in another way, did He give him strong proof of His divinity. By saying "Sin no more," He showed that He knew all the sins that the man had committed in the past. Through this, He would gain the man's trust regarding the future.

And not only by strengthening the sick man's body, but also in another way, did He afford him a strong proof of His Divinity; for by saying, Sin no more, He showed that He knew all the transgressions that had formerly been committed by him; and by this He would gain his belief as to the future.

John 5:15

Again observe him continuing in the same right feeling. He does not say, "This is the one who said, Take up your bed," but when they continually brought forward this apparent charge, he continually puts forward the defense, again declaring his Healer and seeking to attract and attach others to Him. For he was not so unfeeling as to betray his Benefactor after such a benefit and command, and to speak as he did with evil intention. Had he been a wild beast, had he been something unlike a man and made of stone, the benefit and the fear would have been enough to restrain him, since, having the threat lodged within him, he would have dreaded lest he should suffer something worse, having already received the greatest proof of his Physician's power. Besides, had he wished to slander Him, he would have said nothing about his own cure, but would have mentioned and urged against Him the breaking of the Sabbath. But this is not the case, surely it is not. The words are words of great boldness and frankness. He proclaims his Benefactor no less than the blind man did. For what did he say? "He made clay and anointed my eyes." And so this man of whom we now speak says, "It is Jesus who made me whole."

Again observe him continuing in the same right feeling. He says not, This is he who said, Take up your bed, but when they continually advanced this seeming charge, he continually puts forward the defense, again declaring his Healer, and seeking to attract and attach others to Him. For he was not so unfeeling as after such a benefit and charge to betray his Benefactor, and to speak as he did with an evil intention. Had he been a wild beast, had he been something unlike a man and of stone, the benefit and the fear would have been enough to restrain him, since, having the threat lodged within, he would have dreaded lest he should suffer a worse thing, having already received the greatest pledges of the power of his Physician. Besides, had he wished to slander Him, he would have said nothing about his own cure, but would have mentioned and urged against Him the breach of the Sabbath. But this is not the case, surely it is not; the words are words of great boldness and candor; he pro claims his Benefactor no less than the blind man did. For what said he? He made clay, and anointed my eyes John 9:6; and so this man of whom we now speak, It is Jesus who made me whole.

John 5:16

What then does Christ say?

What then says Christ?

John 5:17

When there was a need to make an excuse for the Disciples, He brought forward David their fellow-servant, saying, Have you not read what David did when he was hungry? Matthew 12:2 But when an excuse was to be made for Himself, He appealed to the Father, showing in two ways His Equality: by calling God His Father in a special way, and by doing the same things which He did. And why did He not mention what took place at Jericho? Because He wished to raise them up from earthly thinking so that they might no longer regard Him as a man, but as God, and as one who has the right to make laws. For if He had not been The Very Son and of the same ousia, the defense would have been worse than the charge. For if a viceroy who had changed a royal law should, when accused of doing so, excuse himself in this manner and say, Yes, for the king also has annulled laws, he would not be able to escape, but would thus increase the weight of the charge. But in this case, since the dignity is equal, the defense is made perfect on most secure grounds. From the charges, He says, from which you absolve God, absolve Me also. And therefore He said first, My Father, so that He might persuade them even against their will to allow the same to Him, through reverence of His clearly asserted Sonship.

When there was need to make excuse for the Disciples, He brought forward David their fellow-servant, saying, Have ye not read what David did when he was an hungered? Matthew 12:2 But when excuse was to be made for Himself, He betook Himself to the Father, showing in two ways His Equality, by calling God His Father peculiarly, and by doing the same things which He did. And wherefore did He not mention what took place at Jericho? Because He wished to raise them up from earth that they might no longer attend to Him as to a man, but as to God, and as to one who ought to legislate: since had He not been The Very Son and of the same Essence, the defense would have been worse than the charge. For if a viceroy who had altered a royal law should, when charged with so doing, excuse himself in this manner, and say, Yea, for the king also has annulled laws, he would not be able to escape, but would thus increase the weight of the charge. But in this instance, since the dignity is equal, the defense is made perfect on most secure grounds. From the charges, says He, from which you absolve God, absolve Me also. And therefore He said first, My Father, that He might persuade them even against their will to allow to Him the same, through reverence of His clearly asserted Sonship.

If anyone asks, "How does the Father 'work' when He ceased on the seventh day from all His works?" let him learn the manner in which He works. What then is the manner of His working? He cares for and holds together all that has been made. Therefore, when you see the sun rising and the moon running in her path, the lakes and fountains and rivers and rains, the course of nature in seeds and in our own bodies and those of non-rational beings, and all the rest by which this universe is held together, then learn about the ceaseless working of the Father. For He makes His sun to rise upon the evil and the good, and sends rain on the just and on the unjust. And again, "If God so clothe the grass of the field, which today is, and tomorrow is cast into the fire," and speaking of the birds He said, "Your Heavenly Father feeds them."

If any one say, And how does the Father 'work,' who ceased on the seventh day from all His works? let him learn the manner in which He works. What then is the manner of His working? He cares for, He holds together all that has been made. Therefore when you behold the sun rising and the moon running in her path, the lakes, and fountains, and rivers, and rains, the course of nature in the seeds and in our own bodies and those of irrational beings, and all the rest by means of which this universe is made up, then learn the ceaseless working of the Father. For He makes His sun to rise upon the evil and the good, and sends rain on the just and on the unjust. Matthew 5:45 And again; If God so clothe the grass of the field, which today is, and tomorrow is cast into the fire Matthew 6:30; and speaking of the birds He said, Your Heavenly Father feeds them.

In that place, then, He did everything on the Sabbath day by words only and added nothing more, but refuted their charges by what was done in the Temple and from their own practice. But here, where He commanded a work to be done—the taking up of a bed, something of no great importance regarding the miracle itself, though by it He showed one point, a clear violation of the Sabbath—He takes His teaching to something greater. He wants to awe them more by referring to the dignity of the Father and to lift them up to higher thought. Therefore, when His teaching concerns the Sabbath, He does not defend Himself only as man or only as God, but sometimes in one way, sometimes in the other, because He wanted to persuade them both of the condescension of the Dispensation and the dignity of His Godhead. Therefore He now defends Himself as God, since if He had always spoken with them merely as a man, they would have remained in the same low condition. So to prevent this, He brings forward the Father. Yet creation itself works on the Sabbath—for the sun runs, rivers flow, fountains bubble, women give birth—but so that you may learn that He is not part of creation, He did not say, "Yes, I work, for creation works," but rather, "Yes, I work, for My Father works."

3. In that place then He did all on the Sabbath day by words only, and added nothing more, but refuted their charges by what was done in the Temple and from their own practice. But here where He commanded a work to be done, the taking up a bed, (a thing of no great importance as regarded the miracle, though by it He showed one point, a manifest violation of the Sabbath,) He leads up His discourse to something greater, desiring the more to awe them by reference to the dignity of the Father, and to lead them up to higher thought. Therefore when His discourse is concerning the Sabbath, He makes not His defense as man only, or as God only, but sometimes in one way, sometimes in the other; because He desired to persuade them both of the condescension of the Dispensation, and the Dignity of His Godhead. Therefore He now defends Himself as God, since had He always conversed with them merely as a man, they would have continued in the same low condition. Wherefore that this may not be, He brings forward the Father. Yet the creation itself works on the Sabbath, (for the sun runs, rivers flow, fountains bubble, women bear,) but that you may learn that He is not of creation, He said not, Yea, I work, for creation works, but, Yea, I work, for My Father works.

John 5:18

And he asserted this not merely by words, but by deeds, for he declared it not in speech alone, but even more often by actions. Why? Because they might object to his words and charge him with arrogance, but when they saw the truth of his actions proved by results and his power proclaimed by works, they could say nothing against him after that.

And this he asserted not by words merely, but by deeds, for not in speech alone, but also yet oftener by actions He declared it. Why so? Because they might object to His words and charge Him with arrogance, but when they saw the truth of His actions proved by results, and His power proclaimed by works, after that they could say nothing against Him.

But those who refuse to accept these words with the right understanding claim that Christ did not make Himself equal to God, but that the Jews only suspected this. Come then, let us review what has been said from the beginning. Tell me, did the Jews persecute Him or not? It is clear to everyone that they did. Did they persecute Him for this reason or for something else? Again, it is agreed that it was for this. Did He then break the Sabbath or not? No one can deny that He did. Did He call God His Father or not? This too is true. Then the rest also follows by the same logic. For just as calling God His Father, breaking the Sabbath, and being persecuted by the Jews for the former and especially for the latter reason were not false impressions but actual facts, so making Himself equal to God was a declaration with the same meaning.

But they who will not receive these words in a right mind assert, that Christ made not Himself equal to God, but that the Jews suspected this. Come then let us go over what has been said from the beginning. Tell me, did the Jews persecute Him, or did they not? It is clear to every one that they did. Did they persecute Him for this or for something else? It is again allowed that it was for this. Did He then break the Sabbath, or did He not? Against the fact that He did, no one can have anything to say. Did He call God His Father, or did He not call Him so? This too is true. Then the rest also follows by the same consequence; for as to call God His Father, to break the Sabbath, and to be persecuted by the Jews for the former and more especially for the latter reason, belonged not to a false imagination, but to actual fact, so to make Himself equal to God was a declaration of the same meaning.

And this becomes even clearer from what He said before, for "My Father works, and I work" is the statement of Someone declaring Himself equal to God. For in these words He has indicated no difference. He did not say, "He works, and I serve," but "As He works, so I work," and has declared absolute equality. But if He had not wished to establish this, and the Jews had assumed it without reason, He would not have allowed their minds to be deceived, but would have corrected this. Besides, the Evangelist would not have remained silent on the subject, but would have plainly said that the Jews assumed this, but that Jesus did not make Himself equal to God. As in another place he does exactly this, when he notices that something was said one way and understood another way, as "Destroy this Temple," said Christ, "and in three days I will raise It up" (John 2:19), speaking of His Flesh. But the Jews, not understanding this and supposing that the words were spoken about the Jewish Temple, said, "Forty-six years was this temple in building, and will You rear it up in three days?" Since He said one thing and they imagined another (for He spoke of His Flesh, and they thought that the words were spoken about their Temple), the Evangelist, observing this, or rather correcting their imagination, goes on to say, "But He spoke of the Temple of His Body." So here also, if Christ had not made Himself equal with God, had not wished to establish this, and yet the Jews had imagined that He did, the writer would here also have corrected their assumption and would have said, "The Jews thought that He made Himself equal to God, but indeed He spoke not of equality." And this is done not only in this place, nor only by this Evangelist, but again elsewhere another Evangelist is seen to do the same. For when Christ warned His disciples, saying, "Beware of the leaven of the Pharisees and Sadducees" (Matthew 16:6), and they reasoned among themselves, saying, "It is because we have taken no bread," and He spoke of one thing, calling their doctrine leaven, but the disciples imagined another, supposing that the words were said about bread, it is not now the Evangelist who corrects them, but Christ Himself, speaking thus, "How is it that you do not understand that I spoke not to you concerning bread?" But here there is nothing of the kind.

And this one may see more clearly from what He had before said, for My Father works, and I work, is the expression of One declaring Himself equal to God. For in these words He has marked no difference. He said not, He works, and I minister, but, As He works, so work I; and has declared absolute Equality. But if He had not wished to establish this, and the Jews had supposed so without reason, He would not have allowed their minds to be deceived, but would have corrected this. Besides, the Evangelist would not have been silent on the subject, but would have plainly said that the Jews supposed so, but that Jesus did not make Himself equal to God. As in another place he does this very thing, when he perceives that something was said in one way, and understood in another; as, Destroy this Temple, said Christ, and in three days I will raise It up John 2:19; speaking of His Flesh. But the Jews, not understanding this, and supposing that the words were spoken of the Jewish Temple, said, Forty and six years was this temple in building, and will You rear it up in three days? Since then He said one thing, and they imagined another, (for He spoke of His Flesh, and they thought that the words were spoken of their Temple,) the Evangelist remarking on this, or rather correcting their imagination, goes on to say, But He spoke of the Temple of His Body. So that here also, if Christ had not made Himself equal with God, had not wished to establish this, and yet the Jews had imagined that He did, the writer would here also have corrected their supposition, and would have said, The Jews thought that He made Himself equal to God, but indeed He spoke not of equality. And this is done not in this place only, nor by this Evangelist only, but again elsewhere another Evangelist is seen to do the same. For when Christ warned His disciples, saying, Beware of the leaven of the Pharisees and Sadducees Matthew 16:6, and they reasoned among themselves, saying, It is because we have taken no bread, and He spoke of one thing, calling their doctrine leaven, but the disciples imagined another, supposing that the words were said of bread; it is not now the Evangelist who sets them right, but Christ Himself, speaking thus, How is it that you do not understand, that I spoke not to you concerning bread? But here there is nothing of the kind.

But someone says that Christ added the following words to remove this very thought:

But, says some one, to remove this very thought Christ has added,

John 5:19

Listen! He does the opposite. He says this not to take away but to confirm His equality. But pay close attention, for this is no ordinary question. The expression "of Himself" is found in many places of Scripture, with reference both to Christ and to the Holy Spirit, and we must learn the meaning of the expression so that we may not fall into the greatest errors. For if one takes it separately by itself in the way it is obvious to take it, consider what a great absurdity will follow. He did not say that He could do some things of Himself and that others He could not, but universally,

Man! He does the contrary. He says this not to take away, but to confirm, His Equality. But attend carefully, for this is no common question. The expression of Himself is found in many places of Scripture, with reference both to Christ and to the Holy Ghost, and we must learn the force of the expression, that we may not fall into the greatest errors; for if one take it separately by itself in the way in which it is obvious to take it, consider how great an absurdity will follow. He said not that He could do some things of Himself and that others He could not, but universally,

I ask my opponent, then: Can the Son do nothing of Himself? Tell me. If he replies that He can do nothing, we will say that He has done of Himself the very greatest of all good things. As Paul cries aloud, saying, "Who being in the form of God, thought it not robbery to be equal with God, but made Himself of no reputation, and took upon Him the form of a servant." And again, Christ Himself says in another place, "I have power to lay down My life, and I have power to take it again," and "No man takes it from Me, but I lay it down of Myself." Do you see that He has power over life and death, and that He accomplished of Himself so mighty a work of salvation? And why do I speak concerning Christ, when even we, than whom nothing can be lower, do many things of ourselves? Of ourselves we choose vice, of ourselves we pursue virtue, and if we do not act of ourselves and do not have this power, we will neither suffer hell if we do wrong, nor enjoy the Kingdom if we do right.

4. The Son can do nothing of Himself. I ask then my opponent, Can the Son do nothing of Himself, tell me? If he reply, that He can do nothing, we will say, that He has done of Himself the very greatest of all goods. As Paul cries aloud, saying, Who being in the form of God, thought it not robbery to be equal with God, but made Himself of no reputation, and took upon Him the form of a servant. Philippians 2:6-7 And again, Christ Himself in another place says, I have power to lay down My life, and I have power to take it again: and, No man takes it from Me, but I lay it down of Myself. John 10:18 Do you see that He has power over life and death, and that He wrought of Himself so mighty a Dispensation? And why speak I concerning Christ, when even we, than whom nothing can be meaner, do many things of ourselves? Of ourselves we choose vice, of ourselves we go after virtue, and if we do it not of ourselves, and not having power, we shall neither suffer hell if we do wrong, nor enjoy the Kingdom if we do right.

What then does "can do nothing of Himself" mean? It means that He can do nothing in opposition to the Father, nothing alien from Him, nothing strange to Him—which is especially the assertion of one declaring an equality and complete agreement.

What then means, Can do nothing of Himself? That He can do nothing in opposition to the Father, nothing alien from, nothing strange to Him, which is especially the assertion of One declaring an Equality and entire agreement.

But why didn't He say that He does nothing contrary, instead of saying He cannot do? It was so that from this He might again show the unchangeable and exact nature of the Equality, for this expression does not attribute weakness to Him, but actually shows His great power. In another place Paul says of the Father, "That by two immutable things in which it was impossible for God to lie" (Hebrews 6:18), and again, "If we deny Him—He abides faithful, for He cannot deny Himself" (2 Timothy 2:12-13). And truly this expression "impossible" does not declare weakness, but power—unspeakable power. For what He is saying is something like this: that His essence (ousia) does not admit such things as these. For just as when we also say it is impossible for God to do wrong, we do not attribute any weakness to Him but confess in Him an inexpressible power, so also when He says, "I can of My own Self do nothing" (John 5:30), His meaning is that it is impossible—nature does not admit—that I should do anything contrary to the Father. And so that you may learn that this is really what is being said, let us go over what follows and see whether Christ agrees with what we say or with what you say. You claim that this expression eliminates His Power and His proper Authority, and shows His might to be weak. But I say that this proves His Equality, His unchanging Likeness to the Father, and the fact that all is done as it were by one Will and Power and Might. Let us then ask Christ Himself and see by what He says next whether He interprets these words according to your understanding or according to ours. What then does He say?

But wherefore said He not, that He does nothing contrary, instead of, He cannot do? It was that from this again He might show the invariableness and exactness of the Equality, for the expression imputes not weakness to Him, but even shows His great power; since in another place Paul says of the Father, That by two immutable things in which it was impossible for God to lie Hebrews 6:18: and again, If we deny Him — He abides faithful, for He cannot deny Himself. 2 Timothy 2:12-13 And in truth this expression, impossible, is not declaratory of weakness, but power, power unspeakable. For what He says is of this kind, that that Essence admits not such things as these. For just as when we also say, it is impossible for God to do wrong, we do not impute to Him any weakness, but confess in Him an unutterable power; so when He also says, I can of My own Self do nothing John 5:30, His meaning is, that it is impossible, nature admits not, that I should do anything contrary to the Father. And that you may learn that this is really what is said, let us, going over what follows, see whether Christ agrees with what is said by us, or among you. You say, that the expression does away with His Power and His proper Authority, and shows His might to be but weak; but I say, that this proves His Equality, His unvarying Likeness, (to the Father,) and the fact that all is done as it were by one Will and Power and Might. Let us then enquire of Christ Himself, and see by what He next says whether He interprets these words according to your supposition or according to ours. What then says He?

For whatever things the Father does, these also the Son does likewise.

For whatever things the Father does these also does the Son likewise.

Do you see how He has completely destroyed your argument and confirmed what we have been saying? If Christ does nothing on His own, then the Father also does nothing on His own, since Christ does all things in the same way as the Father. If this is not the case, another absurd conclusion follows. He did not say that He does whatever things He saw the Father do, but rather that unless He sees the Father doing something, He does not do it—extending His words to all time. According to your view, He would be constantly learning the same things over and over. Do you see how elevated this concept is, and how the very humility of the expression forces even the most shameless and unwilling people to avoid low thoughts that are unworthy of His dignity? For who could be so wretched and miserable as to claim that the Son learns day by day what He must do? And how could that statement be true—"You are the same, and Your years shall not fail" (Psalm 102:27)—or that other one, "All things were made by Him, and without Him was not anything made" (John 1:3), if the Father does certain things and the Son watches and imitates Him? Do you see that both from what was stated above and from what was said afterward, proof is given of His independent power? And if He introduces some expressions in a lowly manner, do not be surprised, for since they persecuted Him when they heard His exalted sayings and considered Him an enemy of God, He lowers His expression somewhat and then leads His discourse back up to the more sublime doctrines, alternating between higher and lower teaching so that it might be easily accepted even by those poorly disposed. Notice that after saying "My Father works, and I work," and after declaring Himself equal with God, He adds, "The Son can do nothing of Himself, but what He sees the Father do." Then again in a higher tone, "Whatever things the Father does, these also does the Son likewise." Then in a lower tone,

Do you see how He has taken away your assertion by the root, and confirmed what is said by us? Since, if Christ does nothing of Himself, neither will the Father do anything of Himself, if so be that Christ does all things in like manner to Him. If this be not the case, another strange conclusion will follow. For He said not, that whatsoever things He saw the Father do, He did, but, except He see the Father doing anything, He does it not; extending His words to all time; now He will, according to you, be continually learning the same things. Do you see how exalted is the idea, and that the very humility of the expression compels even the most shameless and unwilling to avoid groveling thoughts, and such as are unsuited to His dignity? For who so wretched and miserable as to assert, that the Son learns day by day what He must do? And how can that be true, You are the same, and Your years shall not fail? Psalm 102:27, or that other, All things were made by Him, and without Him was not anything made John 1:3; if the Father does certain things, and the Son sees and imitates Him? Do you see that from what was asserted above, and from what was said afterwards, proof is given of His independent Power? And if He brings forward some expressions in lowly manner, marvel not, for since they persecuted Him when they had heard His exalted sayings, and deemed Him to be an enemy of God, sinking a little in expression alone, He again leads His discourse up to the sublimer doctrines, then in turn to the lower, varying His teaching that it might be easy of acceptance even to the indisposed. Observe, after saying, My Father works, and I work; and after declaring Himself equal with God, He adds, The Son can do nothing of Himself, but what He sees the Father do. Then again in a higher strain, Whatever things the Father does, these also does the Son likewise. Then in a lower,

John 5:20

Do you see how great the humility of this is? And with good reason. What I said before, what I will not stop saying, I will now repeat: whenever He says anything lowly or humble, He states it in an exaggerated way, so that the very poorness of the expression itself may persuade even those who are resistant to understand these ideas with reverence. Because if this is not the case, see how absurd the claim becomes when we test it using the words themselves. When He says, "And shall show Him greater works than these," He will appear not to have learned many things yet—something that cannot even be said of the Apostles. For they, once they received the grace of the Spirit, immediately both knew and were able to do everything they needed to know and have the power to do. But Christ will appear not to have learned many things yet that He needed to know. And what could be more absurd than that?

Do you see how great is the humility of this? And with reason; for what I said before, what I shall not cease to say, I will now repeat, that when He utters anything low or humbly, He puts it in excess, that the very poverty of the expression may persuade even the indisposed to receive the notions with pious understanding. Since, if it be not so, see how absurd a thing is asserted, making the trial from the words themselves. For when He says, And shall show Him greater works than these, He will be found not to have yet learned many things, which cannot be said even of the Apostles; for they when they had once received the grace of the Spirit, in a moment both knew and were able to do all things which it was needful that they should know and have power to do, while Christ will be found to have not yet learned many things which He needed to know. And what can be more absurd than this?

What then does He mean? Because He had strengthened the paralytic and was about to raise the dead, He spoke this way, practically saying, "Do you marvel that I have strengthened the paralyzed? You will see greater things than these." But He did not speak in exactly this way. Instead, He proceeded in a somewhat humbler manner in order to calm their madness. And so that you may learn that "shall show" is not used in an absolute sense, listen again to what follows.

What then is His meaning? It was because He had strengthened the paralytic, and was about to raise the dead, that He thus spoke, all but saying, Wonder ye that I have strengthened the paralyzed? You shall see greater things than these. But He spoke not thus, but proceeded somehow in a humbler strain, in order that He might soothe their madness. And that you may learn that shall show is not used absolutely, listen again to what follows.

John 5:21

Yet "can do nothing of Himself" is opposed to "whom He will," since if He quickens whom He will, He can do something of Himself (for to will implies power), but if He can do nothing of Himself, then He cannot quicken whom He will. For the expression "as the Father raises up" shows unvarying resemblance in power, and "whom He will" shows equality of authority. Do you see, therefore, that "cannot do anything of Himself" is the expression of one not taking away His own authority, but declaring the unvarying resemblance of His power and will to those of the Father? In this sense also understand the words "shall show to Him," for in another place He says, "I will raise him up at the last Day" (John 6:40). And again, to show that He does it not by receiving an inward power from above, He says, "I am the Resurrection and the Life" (John 11:25). Then that you may not assert that He raises what dead He will and quickens them, but that He does not do other things in such manner, He anticipates and prevents every objection of the kind by saying, "Whatever things He does, these also does the Son likewise," thus declaring that He does all things which the Father does, and as the Father does them—whether you speak of the raising of the dead, or the fashioning of bodies, or the remission of sins, or any other matter whatever, He works in like manner to Him who begot Him.

Yet can do nothing of Himself is opposed to whom He will: since if He quickens whom He will, He can do something of Himself, (for to will implies power,) but if He can do nothing of Himself, then He can not quicken whom He will. For the expression, as the Father raises up, shows unvarying resemblance in Power, and whom He will, Equality of Authority. Do you see therefore that cannot do anything of Himself is the expression of One not taking away His (own) authority, but declaring the unvarying resemblance of His Power and Will (to those of the Father)? In this sense also understand the words, shall show to Him; for in another place He says, I will raise him up at the last Day. John 6:40 And again, to show that He does it not by receiving an inward power from above, He says, I am the Resurrection and the Life. John 11:25 Then that you may not assert that He raises what dead He will and quickens them, but that He does not other things in such manner, He anticipates and prevents every objection of the kind by saying, Whatever things He does, these also does the Son likewise, thus declaring that He does all things which the Father does, and as the Father does them; whether you speak of the raising of the dead, or the fashioning of bodies, or the remission of sins, or any other matter whatever, He works in like manner to Him who begot Him.

But people who are careless about their salvation pay no attention to any of these things—so great an evil is the love of status and position. This has been the mother of heresies, and has strengthened the impiety of the heathen. For God wanted His invisible things to be understood through the creation of this world, but they left these aside and refused to come by this way of teaching. Instead, they carved out another path for themselves, and so were cast out from the truth. And the Jews did not believe because they received honor from one another and did not seek the honor that comes from God. But let us, beloved, avoid this disease with all our strength and determination, for even if we have ten thousand good qualities, this plague of vainglory is enough to destroy them all. If therefore we desire praise, let us seek the praise that is from God, for the praise of men—whatever kind it may be—perishes as soon as it appears. Or if it does not perish, it brings us no profit and often proceeds from a corrupt judgment. And what is there to admire in the honor that comes from men? Young dancers enjoy it, as do immoral women and greedy, rapacious men. But the person who is approved by God is approved not with these, but with those holy men—the Prophets and Apostles who have shown forth an angelic life. If we feel any desire to lead crowds around with us or to be looked at by them, let us consider the matter by itself, and we shall find that it is utterly worthless. In short, if you are fond of crowds, draw to yourself the host of angels and become terrible to the devils. Then you will care nothing for mortal things, but will tread all that is splendid underfoot as mire and clay. And you will clearly see that nothing so fits a soul for shame as the passion for glory, for it cannot—it cannot be—that the man who desires this should live the crucified life, just as on the other hand it is not possible that the man who has trampled this underfoot should not trample down most other passions. For whoever masters this will get the better of envy and covetousness and all the grievous diseases. And how, someone says, shall we get the better of it? If we look to the other glory which is from heaven, and from which this earthly kind strives to cast us out. For that heavenly glory both makes us honored here and passes with us into the life which is to come, and delivers us from all fleshly slavery which we now most miserably serve, giving ourselves up entirely to earth and the things of earth. For if you go into the forum, if you enter a house, into the streets, into the soldiers' quarters, into inns, taverns, ships, islands, palaces, courts of justice, council chambers, you will everywhere find anxiety for things present and belonging to this life, and each person laboring for these things—whether gone or coming, traveling or staying at home, voyaging, tilling lands, in the fields, in the cities—in a word, all. What hope then of salvation do we have, when inhabiting God's earth we care nothing for the things of God? When commanded to be aliens from earthly things, we are aliens from heaven and citizens of earth. What can be worse than this insensibility, when hearing each day of the Judgment and of the Kingdom, we imitate the men in the days of Noah and those of Sodom, waiting to learn all by actual experience? Yet for this purpose were all those things written: that if anyone does not believe what is to come, he may from what has already happened get certain proof of what shall be. Therefore considering these things—both the past and the future—let us at least take breath a little from this hard slavery, and make some account of our souls also, that we may obtain both present and future blessings, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom, with the Father and the Holy Ghost, be glory, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.

5. But men careless of their salvation give heed to none of these things; so great an evil is it to be in love with precedence. This has been the mother of heresies, this has confirmed the impiety of the heathen. For God desired that His invisible things should be understood by the creation of this world Romans 1:20, but they having left these and refused to come by this mode of teaching, cut out for themselves another way, and so were cast out from the true. And the Jews believed not because they received honor from one another, and sought not the honor which is from God. But let us, beloved, avoid this disease exceedingly and with all earnestness; for though we have ten thousand good qualities, this plague of vainglory is sufficient to bring them all to nought. John 5:44 If therefore we desire praise, let us seek the praise which is from God, for the praise of men of whatever kind it be, as soon as it has appeared has perished, or if it perish not, brings to us no profit, and often proceeds from a corrupt judgment. And what is there to be admired in the honor which is from men? Which young dancers enjoy, and abandoned women, and covetous and rapacious men? But he who is approved of God, is approved not with these, but with those holy men the Prophets and Apostles, who have shown forth an angelic life. If we feel any desire to lead multitudes about with us or be looked at by them, let us consider the matter apart by itself, and we shall find that it is utterly worthless. In fine, if you are fond of crowds, draw to yourself the host of angels, and become terrible to the devils, then shall you care nothing for mortal things, but shall tread all that is splendid underfoot as mire and clay; and shall clearly see that nothing so fits a soul for shame as the passion for glory; for it cannot, it cannot be, that the man who desires this should live the crucified life, as on the other hand it is not possible that the man who has trodden this underfoot should not tread down most other passions; for he who masters this will get the better of envy and covetousness, and all the grievous maladies. And how, says some one, shall we get the better of it? If we look to the other glory which is from heaven, and from which this kind strives to cast us out. For that heavenly glory both makes us honored here, and passes with us into the life which is to come, and delivers us from all fleshly slavery which we now most miserably serve, giving up ourselves entirely to earth and the things of earth. For if you go into the forum, if you enter into a house, into the streets, into the soldiers' quarters, into inns, taverns, ships, islands, palaces, courts of justice, council chambers, you shall everywhere find anxiety for things present and belonging to this life, and each man laboring for these things, whether gone or coming, traveling or staying at home, voyaging, tilling lands, in the fields, in the cities, in a word, all. What hope then of salvation have we, when inhabiting God's earth we care not for the things of God, when bidden to be aliens from earthly things we are aliens from heaven and citizens of earth? What can be worse than this insensibility, when hearing each day of the Judgment and of the Kingdom, we imitate the men in the days of Noah, and those of Sodom, waiting to learn all by actual experience? Yet for this purpose were all those things written, that if any one believe not that which is to come, he may, from what has already been, get certain proof of what shall be. Considering therefore these things, both the past and the future, let us at least take breath a little from this hard slavery, and make some account of our souls also, that we may obtain both present and future blessings; through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom, with the Father and the Holy Ghost, be glory, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 37 — John 5:6-7

Homily 37 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240137.htm>.

Contents · 4 chapters
  1. John 5:6-7
  2. John 5:8
  3. John 5:10-11
  4. John 5:12-13

John 5:6-7

Great is the benefit of the divine Scriptures, and the help that comes from them is all-sufficient. Paul declared this when he said, "Whatever things were written in former times were written for our instruction, upon whom the ends of the ages have come, that through patience and comfort of the Scriptures we might have hope." Romans 15:4, 1 Corinthians 10:11 For the divine oracles are a treasury of every kind of medicine, so that whether one needs to quench pride, to put desire to sleep, to trample underfoot the love of money, to despise pain, to inspire confidence, or to gain patience, from them one can find abundant resources. For what person struggling with long poverty or bound to a severe disease will not, when he reads the passage before us, receive much comfort? This man had been paralyzed for thirty-eight years and saw each year others delivered while he himself remained bound by his disease, yet even so he did not fall back and despair, though truly not only despondency over the past but also hopelessness for the future was enough to overwhelm him. Listen now to what he says and learn the greatness of his sufferings. For when Christ said, "Do you want to be made well?" he replied, "Yes, Lord, but I have no one, when the water is troubled, to put me into the pool." What can be more pitiable than these words? What more sad than these circumstances? Do you see a heart crushed by long sickness? Do you see all violence subdued? He uttered no blasphemous word, nor such as we hear many use in adversity; he did not curse his day, he was not angry at the question, nor did he say, "Have You come to mock and make fun of us, that You ask whether I want to be made well?" but replied gently and with great meekness, "Yes, Lord"—yet he did not know who it was that asked him, nor that He would heal him, but still he mildly relates all the circumstances and asks nothing further, as though he were speaking to a physician and desired merely to tell the story of his sufferings. Perhaps he hoped that Christ might be useful to him enough to put him into the water, and desired to draw Him in by these words. What then does Jesus say?

1. Great is the profit of the divine Scriptures, and all-sufficient is the aid which comes from them. And Paul declared this when he said, Whatsoever things were written aforetime, were written aforetime for our admonition upon whom the ends of the world have come, that we through patience and comfort of the Scriptures might have hope. Romans 15:4, 1 Corinthians 10:11 For the divine oracles are a treasury of all manner of medicines, so that whether it be needful to quench pride, to lull desire to sleep, to tread under foot the love of money, to despise pain, to inspire confidence, to gain patience, from them one may find abundant resource. For what man of those who struggle with long poverty or who are nailed to a grievous disease, will not, when he reads the passage before us, receive much comfort? Since this man who had been paralytic for thirty and eight years, and who saw each year others delivered, and himself bound by his disease, not even so fell back and despaired, though in truth not merely despondency for the past, but also hopelessness for the future, was sufficient to over-strain him. Hear now what he says, and learn the greatness of his sufferings. For when Christ had said, Will you be made whole? Yea, Lord, he says, but I have no man, when the water is troubled, to put me into the pool. What can be more pitiable than these words? What more sad than these circumstances? Do you see a heart crushed through long sickness? Do you see all violence subdued? He uttered no blasphemous word, nor such as we hear the many use in reverses, he cursed not his day, he was not angry at the question, nor did he say, Have You come to make a mock and a jest of us, that Thou asks whether I desire to be made whole? but replied gently, and with great mildness, Yea, Lord; yet he knew not who it was that asked him, nor that He would heal him, but still he mildly relates all the circumstances and asks nothing further, as though he were speaking to a physician, and desired merely to tell the story of his sufferings. Perhaps he hoped that Christ might be so far useful to him as to put him into the water, and desired to attract Him by these words. What then says Jesus?

John 5:8

Now some people suppose that this is the same man in Matthew who was lying on a bed; but he is not, as is clear in many ways. First, from his lack of people to help him. That man had many to care for him and carry him, but this man had no one at all; that is why he said, I have no man. Second, from the manner of answering; the other said nothing, but this man describes his whole situation. Third, from the season and the time; this man was healed at a feast and on the Sabbath, while that other man was healed on a different day. The places were also different; one was cured in a house, the other by the pool. The manner of the cure was also different; there Christ said, Your sins are forgiven you, but here He strengthened the body first and then cared for the soul. In that case there was remission of sins (for He says, Your sins are forgiven you), but in this case there is warning and threats to strengthen the man for the future: Sin no more, lest a worse thing come to you. The accusations of the Jews are also different; here they object to Jesus for working on the Sabbath, but there they charge Him with blasphemy.

Now some suppose that this is the man in Matthew who was lying on a bed Matthew 9:2; but it is not so, as is clear in many ways. First, from his wanting persons to stand forward for him. That man had many to care for and to carry him, this man not a single one; wherefore he said, I have no man. Secondly, from the manner of answering; the other uttered no word, but this man relates his whole case. Thirdly, from the season and the time; this man was healed at a feast, and on the Sabbath, that other on a different day. The places too were different; one was cured in a house, the other by the pool. The manner also of the cure was altered; there Christ said, Your sins be forgiven you, but here He braced the body first, and then cared for the soul. In that case there was remission of sins, (for He says, Your sins be forgiven you,) but in this, warning and threats to strengthen the man for the future; Sin no more, lest a worse thing come unto you. John 5:14 The charges also of the Jews are different; here they object to Jesus, His working on the Sabbath, there they charge Him with blasphemy.

Consider now, I pray you, the great wisdom of God. He did not raise up the man at once, but first made him familiar through questioning, preparing the way for the coming faith. Nor does He only raise him up, but commands him to take up his bed, so as to confirm the miracle that had been performed, and so that no one might suppose what was done to be an illusion or a piece of acting. For he would not, unless his limbs had been firmly and completely restored, have been able to carry his bed. And Christ often does this, effectively silencing those who would like to be insolent. So in the case of the loaves, so that no one might claim that the men had merely been satisfied and that what was done was an illusion, He caused there to be many leftover pieces of the loaves. So to the leper who was cleansed He said, Go, show yourself to the priest, at once providing the most certain proof of the cleansing and stopping the shameless mouths of those who claimed that He was making laws in opposition to God. This also He did in the same way in the case of the wine; for He did not merely show it to them, but also caused it to be brought to the master of the feast, so that one who knew nothing of what had been done might, by his testimony, bear witness to Him without suspicion. This is why the Evangelist says that the master of the feast did not know where it came from, thus showing the impartiality of his testimony. And in another place, when He raised the dead, He said, Give him something to eat, supplying this proof of a real resurrection, and by these means persuading even the foolish that He was no deceiver, no dealer in illusions, but that He had come for the salvation of the common nature of mankind.

Consider now, I pray you, the exceeding wisdom of God. He raised not up the man at once, but first makes him familiar by questioning, making way for the coming faith; nor does He only raise, but bids him take up his bed, so as to confirm the miracle that had been wrought, and that none might suppose what was done to be illusion or a piece of acting. For he would not, unless his limbs had been firmly and thoroughly compacted, have been able to carry his bed. And this Christ often does, effectually silencing those who would fain be insolent. So in the case of the loaves, that no one might assert that the men had been merely satisfied, and that what was done was an illusion, He caused that there should be many relics of the loaves. So to the leper that was cleansed He said, Go, show yourself to the priest Matthew 8:4; at once providing most certain proof of the cleansing, and stopping the shameless mouths of those who asserted that He was legislating in opposition to God. This also He did in like manner in the case of the wine; for He did not merely show it to them, but also caused it to be borne to the governor of the feast, in order that one who knew nothing of what had been done, by his confession might bear to Him unsuspected testimony; wherefore the Evangelist says, that the ruler of the feast knew not whence it was, thus showing the impartiality of his testimony. And in another place, when He raised the dead, He said, Give ye him to eat; supplying this proof of a real resurrection, and by these means persuading even the foolish that He was no deceiver, no dealer in illusions, but that He had come for the salvation of the common nature of mankind.

But why didn't Jesus require faith from this man, as He did with others, saying, "Do you believe that I am able to do this?" It was because the man did not yet clearly know who He was. Jesus is only seen doing this after working miracles, not before. For people who had already witnessed His power at work on others, it made sense to say this to them. But for those who had not yet learned who He was—those who would come to know through signs—faith is required after the miracles. That is why Matthew does not show Christ saying this at the beginning of His miracles, but only later, after He had healed many, to the two blind men.

2. But why did not Jesus require faith of this man, as He did in the case of others, saying, Believest thou that I am able to do this? It was because the man did not yet clearly know who He was; and it is not before, but after the working of miracles that He is seen so doing. For persons who had beheld His power exerted on others would reasonably have this said to them, while of those who had not yet learned who He was, but who were to know afterwards by means of signs, it is after the miracles that faith is required. And therefore Matthew does not introduce Christ as having said this at the beginning of His miracles, but when He had healed many, to the two blind men only.

Observe, however, the paralytic's faith in this way. When he heard "Take up your bed and walk," he did not mock or say, "What can this mean? An Angel comes down and stirs the water and heals only one person, and do You, a man, by a simple command and word hope to be able to do greater things than Angels? This is mere vanity, boasting, mockery." But he neither said nor imagined anything like this. Instead, he heard and immediately got up, and becoming well, he did not disobey the One who gave the command. For he was immediately made well, picked up his bed, and walked. What followed was even far more admirable. That he believed at first, when no one was troubling him, was not so remarkable. But afterward, when the Jews were full of madness and pressed upon him from all sides, accusing and besieging him and saying, "It is not lawful for you to take up your bed," he paid no attention to their madness. Instead, he most boldly proclaimed his Benefactor in the midst of the assembly and silenced their shameless tongues. This, I say, was an act of great courage. For when the Jews rose up against him and said to him in a reproachful and insolent manner ("It is not lawful…"):

Observe however in this way the faith of the paralytic. When he had heard, Take up your bed and walk, he did not mock, nor say, What can this mean? An Angel comes down and troubles the water, and heals only one, and do You, a man, by a bare command and word hope to be able to do greater things than Angels? This is mere vanity, boasting, mockery. But he neither said nor imagined anything like this, but at once he heard and arose, and becoming whole, was not disobedient to Him that gave the command; for immediately he was made whole, and took up his bed, and walked. What followed was even far more admirable. That he believed at first, when no one troubled him, was not so marvelous, but that afterwards, when the Jews were full of madness and pressed upon him on all sides, accusing and besieging him and saying, It is not lawful for you to take up your bed, that then he gave no heed to their madness, but most boldly in the midst of the assembly proclaimed his Benefactor and silenced their shameless tongues, this, I say, was an act of great courage. For when the Jews arose against him, and said in a reproachful and insolent manner to him ("It is not lawful…"):

John 5:10-11

Hear what he says ("He that made me whole…"), almost saying, You are foolish and insane to tell me not to accept as my Teacher the one who has freed me from a long and severe illness, and not to obey whatever He may command. If he had chosen to act unfairly, he might have spoken differently, such as: I am not doing this of my own will, but at another's command; if this is blameworthy, blame the one who gave the order, and I will put down the bed. And he could have hidden the healing, for he knew well that they were upset not so much about the breaking of the Sabbath as about the curing of his sickness. Yet he neither hid this nor said that, nor asked for pardon, but with a loud voice confessed and proclaimed the benefit. This is what the paralytic did; but consider how unfairly they acted. For they did not say, Who is it that has made you whole? On this point they were silent, but kept bringing forward the apparent transgression.

Hear what he says ("He that made me whole…"), all but saying, You are silly and mad who bid me not to take Him for my Teacher who has delivered me from a long and grievous malady, and not to obey whatever He may command. Had he chosen to act in an unfair manner, he might have spoke differently, as thus, I do not this of my own will, but at the bidding of another; if this be a matter of blame, blame him who gave the order, and I will set down the bed. And he might have concealed the cure, for he well knew that they were vexed not so much at the breaking of the Sabbath, as at the curing of his infirmity. Yet he neither concealed this, nor said that, nor asked for pardon, but with loud voice confessed and proclaimed the benefit. Thus did the paralytic; but consider how unfairly they acted. For they said not, Who is it that has made you whole? on this point they were silent, but kept on bringing forward the seeming transgression.

John 5:12-13

And why did Jesus hide Himself? First, so that while He was absent, the man's testimony might be above suspicion, for the one who now felt himself healed was a credible witness to the benefit he received. And second, so that He might not make the fury of the Jews burn even hotter, for the very sight of someone they envy usually ignites no small spark in malicious people. For this reason He withdrew, leaving the deed by itself to speak for itself among them, so that He might not say anything in person about Himself, but rather those who had been healed would speak, along with the accusers themselves. Even the accusers for a time bear witness to the miracle, for they did not say, "Why have you commanded these things to be done on the Sabbath day?" but rather, "Why do you do these things on the Sabbath day?"—being upset not at the transgression but envious of the paralytic's healing. Yet in terms of human labor, what the paralytic did was actually more of a work, for the other was a saying and a word. Here then He commands another person to break the Sabbath, but elsewhere He does the same thing Himself, mixing clay and anointing a man's eyes in John 9. Yet He does these things not by transgressing but by going beyond the Law. We shall speak more about this later. For He does not, when accused by the Jews concerning the Sabbath, always defend Himself in the same way, and we must carefully observe this.

And why did Jesus conceal Himself? First, that while He was absent, the testimony of the man might be unsuspected, for he who now felt himself whole was a credible witness of the benefit. And in the next place, that He might not cause the fury of the Jews to be yet more inflamed, for the very sight of one whom they envy is wont to kindle not a small spark in malicious persons. On this account He retired, and left the deed by itself to plead its cause among them, that He might not say anything in person respecting Himself, but that they might do so who had been healed, and with them also the accusers. Even these last for a while testify to the miracle, for they said not, Wherefore have you commanded these things to be done on the Sabbath day? but, Wherefore doest thou these things on the Sabbath day? not being displeased at the transgression, but envious at the restoration of the paralytic. Yet in respect of human labor, what the paralytic did was rather a work, for the other was a saying and a word. Here then He commands another to break the Sabbath, but elsewhere He does the same Himself, mixing clay and anointing a man's eyes John 9; yet He does these things not transgressing, but going beyond the Law. And on this we shall hereafter speak. For He does not, when accused by the Jews respecting the Sabbath, always defend Himself in the same terms, and this we must carefully observe.

But let us consider for a while how great an evil envy is, and how it disables the eyes of the soul, endangering the salvation of the person possessed by it. For just as madmen often thrust their swords against their own bodies, so also malicious people, looking only to one thing—the injury of the person they envy—care nothing for their own salvation. People like these are worse than wild beasts. Wild beasts arm themselves against us when they lack food or when we have first provoked them, but these people, even when they have received kindness, have often repaid their benefactors as though they had been wronged by them. They are worse than wild beasts, like the devils, or perhaps worse than even those. For the devils have unceasing hostility against us, but do not plot against those of their own nature (and so by this Jesus silenced the Jews when they said that He cast out devils by Beelzebub), but these people respect neither their common nature nor spare their own selves. For before they trouble those whom they envy, they trouble their own souls, filling them with all manner of disturbance and despondency, fruitlessly and in vain. For why do you grieve, O man, at the prosperity of your neighbor? We ought to grieve at the troubles we suffer, not because we see others in good standing. Therefore this sin is stripped of all excuse. The fornicator may allege his lust, the thief his poverty, the murderer his passion—weak excuses and unreasonable, yet still they have these to allege. But what reason, tell me, will you name? None other at all, but that of intense wickedness. If we are commanded to love our enemies, what punishment shall we suffer if we hate our very friends? And if he who loves those that love him will be in no better a state than the heathen, what excuse, what defense shall he have who injures those that have done him no wrong? Hear Paul, what he says: "Though I give my body to be burned, and have not charity, it profits me nothing" (1 Corinthians 13:3). Now it is clear to everyone that where envy and malice are, there charity is not. This feeling is worse than fornication and adultery, for these go no farther than the one who does them, but the tyranny of envy has overturned entire Churches and has destroyed the whole world. Envy is the mother of murder. Through this Cain slew Abel his brother; through this Esau would have slain Jacob, and his brothers Joseph; through this the devil slew all mankind. You indeed do not kill now, but you do many things worse than murder: desiring that your brother may act shamefully, laying snares for him on all sides, paralyzing his efforts toward virtue, grieving that he pleases the Master of the world. Yet you war not with your brother, but with Him whom he serves; Him you insult when you prefer your glory to His. And what is in truth worst of all is that this sin seems to be an unimportant one, while in fact it is more grievous than any other. For though you show mercy and keep watch and fast, you are more accursed than anyone if you envy your brother, as is clear from this circumstance also. A man of the Corinthians was once guilty of adultery, yet he was charged with his sin and soon restored to righteousness. Cain envied Abel, but he was not healed, and although God Himself continually tended the wound, he became more pained and wave-tossed, and was hurried on to murder. Thus this passion is worse than that other, and does not easily permit itself to be cured unless we give heed. Let us then by all means tear it up by the roots, considering this: that just as we offend God when we waste away with envy at other people's blessings, so when we rejoice with them we are well pleasing to Him and render ourselves partakers of the good things laid up for the righteous. Therefore Paul exhorts us to "Rejoice with them that do rejoice, and weep with them that weep" (Romans 12:15), that on either hand we may reap great profit.

3. But let us consider awhile how great an evil is envy, how it disables the eyes of the soul to the endangering his salvation who is possessed by it. For as madmen often thrust their swords against their own bodies, so also malicious persons looking only to one thing, the injury of him they envy, care not for their own salvation. Men like these are worse than wild beasts; they when wanting food, or having first been provoked by us, arm themselves against us; but these men when they have received kindness, have often repaid their benefactors as though they had wronged them. Worse than wild beasts are they, like the devils, or perhaps worse than even those; for they against us indeed have unceasing hostility, but do not plot against those of their own nature, (and so by this Jesus silenced the Jews when they said that He cast out devils by Beelzebub,) but these men neither respect their common nature, nor spare their own selves. For before they vex those whom they envy they vex their own souls, filling them with all manner of trouble and despondency, fruitlessly and in vain. For wherefore do you grieve, O man, at the prosperity of your neighbor? We ought to grieve at the ills we suffer, not because we see others in good repute. Wherefore this sin is stripped of all excuse. The fornicator may allege his lust, the thief his poverty, the man-slayer his passion, frigid excuses and unreasonable, still they have these to allege. But what reason, tell me, will you name? None other at all, but that of intense wickedness. If we are commanded to love our enemies, what punishment shall we suffer if we hate our very friends? And if he who loves those that love him will be in no better a state than the heathen, what excuse, what palliation shall he have who injures those that have done him no wrong? Hear Paul, what he says, Though I give my body to be burned, and have not charity, it profits me nothing 1 Corinthians 13:3; now it is clear to every one that where envy and malice are, there charity is not. This feeling is worse than fornication and adultery, for these go no farther than him who does them, but the tyranny of envy has overturned entire Churches, and has destroyed the whole world. Envy is the mother of murder. Through this Cain slew Abel his brother; through this Esau (would have slain) Jacob, and his brethren Joseph, through this the devil all mankind. Thou indeed now killest not, but thou dost many things worse than murder, desiring that your brother may act unseemly, laying snares for him on all sides, paralyzing his labors on the side of virtue, grieving that he pleases the Master of the world. Yet you war not with your brother, but with Him whom he serves, Him you insult when you prefer your glory to His. And what is in truth worst of all, is that this sin seems to be an unimportant one, while in fact it is more grievous than any other; for though you show mercy and watchest and fastest, you are more accursed than any if you envy your brother. As is clear from this circumstance also. A man of the Corinthians was once guilty of adultery, yet he was charged with his sin and soon restored to righteousness; Cain envied Abel; but he was not healed, and although God Himself continually charmed the wound, he became more pained and wave-tossed, and was hurried on to murder. Thus this passion is worse than that other, and does not easily permit itself to be cured except we give heed. Let us then by all means tear it up by the roots, considering this, that as we offend God when we waste with envy at other men's blessings, so when we rejoice with them we are well pleasing to Him, and render ourselves partakers of the good things laid up for the righteous. Therefore Paul exhorts us to Rejoice with them that do rejoice, and weep with them that weep Romans 12:15, that on either hand we may reap great profit.

Since we share in someone else's reward simply by rejoicing with them in their work—even when we ourselves have done nothing—let us put away all envy and cultivate love in our hearts. By praising those fellow believers who please God, we will receive both present and future blessings through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, through whom and with whom, to the Father and the Holy Spirit, be glory now and forever, world without end. Amen.

Considering then that even when we labor not, by rejoicing with him that labors, we become sharers of his crown, let us cast aside all envy, and implant charity in our souls, that by applauding those of our brethren who are well pleasing unto God, we may obtain both present and future good things, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom and with whom, to the Father and the Holy Ghost, be glory, now and ever, world without end. Amen.


Homilies on the Gospel of John — Homily 36 — John 4:54-5:1

Homily 36 of 88 on the Gospel of John.

Source: Translated by Charles Marriott. From Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series , Vol. 14. Edited by Philip Schaff. ( Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889. ) Revised and edited for New Advent by Kevin Knight. <https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/240136.htm>.

John 4:54-5:1

Just as an expert in gold mines would not tolerate overlooking even the smallest vein because it produces great wealth, so in the holy Scriptures it is impossible without loss to pass by a single jot or tittle—we must examine everything carefully. For all of Scripture is spoken by the Holy Spirit, and nothing useless is written in it.

1. As in gold mines one skillful in what relates to them would not endure to overlook even the smallest vein as producing much wealth, so in the holy Scriptures it is impossible without loss to pass by one jot or one tittle, we must search into all. For they all are uttered by the Holy Spirit, and nothing useless is written in them.

Consider, for instance, what the Evangelist says in this place: "This is again the second miracle that Jesus did, when He had come out of Judæa into Galilee." He has not added the word "second" without reason, but to elevate the praise of the Samaritans even more, by showing that even when a second miracle had been performed, those who witnessed it had not yet reached the same level as those who had not seen a single one.

Consider, for instance, what the Evangelist in this place says, This is again the second miracle that Jesus did, when He had come out of Judæa into Galilee. Even the word second he has added not without cause, but to exalt yet more the praise of the Samaritans, by showing that even when a second miracle had been wrought, they who beheld it had not yet reached as high as those who had not seen one.

After this there was a feast of the Jews. What feast? I think it was Pentecost. And Jesus went up to Jerusalem. He regularly attended the city during the feasts, partly so that he might appear to celebrate with them, and partly so that he might draw the crowd that was free from deception. During these days especially, the more simple-minded people gathered together more than at other times.

After this there was a feast of the Jews. What feast? Methinks that of Pentecost. And Jesus went up to Jerusalem. Continually at the feasts He frequents the City, partly that He might appear to feast with them, partly that He might attract the multitude that was free from guile; for during these days especially, the more simply disposed ran together more than at other times.

John 5:2-3

What kind of healing is this? What mystery does it point to for us? These things are not written carelessly or without purpose, but they show in outline things to come through a figure and type, so that what was going to be extremely strange would not harm the power of faith among many people by coming unexpectedly. What then do they show in outline? A Baptism was about to be given, possessing great power and the greatest gifts, a Baptism purging all sins and making people alive instead of dead. These things are foreshadowed as in a picture by the pool and by many other circumstances. First, water is given that cleanses the stains of our bodies and those defilements which are not real but only seem to be, such as those from touching the dead, those from leprosy, and other similar causes. Under the old covenant one can see many things done by water for this reason. However, let us now proceed to the matter at hand.

What manner of cure is this? What mystery does it signify to us? For these things are not written carelessly, or without a purpose, but as by a figure and type they show in outline things to come, in order that what was exceedingly strange might not by coming unexpectedly harm among the many the power of faith. What then is it that they show in outline? A Baptism was about to be given, possessing much power, and the greatest of gifts, a Baptism purging all sins, and making men alive instead of dead. These things then are foreshown as in a picture by the pool, and by many other circumstances. And first is given a water which purges the stains of our bodies, and those defilements which are not, but seem to be, as those from touching the dead, those from leprosy, and other similar causes; under the old covenant one may see many things done by water on this account. However, let us now proceed to the matter in hand.

As I said before, God first causes defilements of our bodies to be washed away, and then infirmities of various kinds, by means of water. Because God, wanting to bring us closer to faith in baptism, no longer heals only defilements, but diseases as well. For those symbols that came closer in time to the reality—whether concerning Baptism, the Passion, or other things—were clearer than the more ancient ones. Just as the guards nearest to a prince are more splendid than those farther away, so it was with these symbols. An Angel came down and stirred the water, giving it healing power, so that the Jews might learn that the Lord of Angels could do much more to heal the diseases of the soul. Yet just as here it was not simply the nature of the water itself that healed (for then this would have happened all the time), but water combined with the work of the Angel, so in our case it is not merely the water that works, but when it has received the grace of the Spirit, then it washes away all our sins. Around this pool lay a great crowd of sick people—blind, lame, withered—waiting for the stirring of the water. But back then, sickness was an obstacle to anyone who wanted to be healed; now everyone has the ability to approach, for now it is not an Angel who stirs the water, but the Lord of Angels who does everything. The sick man cannot now say, "I have no one to help me." He cannot say, "While I am coming, another steps down before me." Even if the whole world should come, the grace is not used up, the power is not exhausted, but remains just as great as it was before. Just as the sun's rays give light every day yet are not used up, and their light is not diminished by giving such an abundant supply, so—and much more—the power of the Spirit is in no way lessened by the number of those who receive it. And this miracle was done so that people, learning that it is possible for water to heal the diseases of the body and being trained in this for a long time, might more easily believe that it can also heal the diseases of the soul.

First then, as I before said, He causes defilements of our bodies, and afterwards infirmities of different kinds, to be done away by water. Because God, desiring to bring us nearer to faith in baptism, no longer heals defilements only, but diseases also. For those figures which came nearer [in time] to the reality, both as regarded Baptism, and the Passion, and the rest, were plainer than the more ancient; and as the guards near the person of the prince are more splendid than those before, so was it with the types. And an Angel came down and troubled the water, and endued it with a healing power, that the Jews might learn that much more could the Lord of Angels heal the diseases of the soul. Yet as here it was not simply the nature of the water that healed, (for then this would have always taken place,) but water joined to the operation of the Angel; so in our case, it is not merely the water that works, but when it has received the grace of the Spirit, then it puts away all our sins. Around this pool lay a great multitude of impotent folk, of blind, halt, withered, waiting for the moving of the water; but then infirmity was a hindrance to him who desired to be healed, now each has power to approach, for now it is not an Angel that troubles, it is the Lord of Angels who works all. The sick man cannot now say, I have no man; he cannot say, While I am coming another steps down before me; though the whole world should come, the grace is not spent, the power is not exhausted, but remains equally great as it was before. Just as the sun's beams give light every day, yet are not exhausted, nor is their light made less by giving so abundant a supply; so, and much more, the power of the Spirit is in no way lessened by the numbers of those who enjoy it. And this miracle was done in order that men, learning that it is possible by water to heal the diseases of the body, and being exercised in this for a long time, might more easily believe that it can also heal the diseases of the soul.

But why did Jesus leave the rest and come to one man who had been sick for thirty-eight years? And why did He ask him, "Will you be made whole?" Not because He needed to learn—that was unnecessary—but so that He might show the man's perseverance, and so that we might know it was for this reason that He left the others and came to him. What then does the man say? "Yes, Lord," he says, "but I have no man when the water is troubled to put me into the pool, but while I am coming another steps down before me."

But why did Jesus, leaving the rest, come to one who was of thirty-eight years standing? And why did He ask him, Will you be made whole? Not that He might learn, that was needless; but that He might show the man's perseverance, and that we might know that it was on this account that He left the others and came to him. What then says he? Yea Lord, he says, but I have no man when the water is troubled to put me into the pool, but while I am coming another steps down before me.

Jesus asked "Will you be made whole?" so that we might learn these circumstances. He did not say "Will you that I heal you?" because the man had not yet formed any exalted ideas about Him. Instead, He said "Will you be made whole?" The paralytic's perseverance was astonishing. He had been sick for thirty-eight years, and each year, hoping to be freed from his disease, he continued to stay there and did not withdraw. If he had not been very persevering, wouldn't the future, if not the past, have been enough to make him leave the place? Consider, I ask you, how watchful the other sick people there would likely have been, since the time when the water was troubled was uncertain. The lame and halt could indeed observe it, but how did the blind see? Perhaps they learned it from the noise that arose.

It was that we might learn these circumstances that Jesus asked, Will you be made whole? and said not, Will you that I heal you? (for as yet the man had formed no exalted notions concerning Him,) but Will you be made whole? Astonishing was the perseverance of the paralytic, he was of thirty and eight years standing, and each year hoping to be freed from his disease, he continued in attendance, and withdrew not. Had he not been very persevering, would not the future, if not the past, have been sufficient to lead him from the spot? Consider, I pray you, how watchful it was likely that the other sick men there would be since the time when the water was troubled was uncertain. The lame and halt indeed might observe it, but how did the blind see? Perhaps they learned it from the clamor which arose.

We should be ashamed, beloved, we should be ashamed and groan over our extreme laziness. That man had been waiting for thirty-eight years without getting what he wanted, and he did not give up. He had failed not through any carelessness of his own, but because he was pushed aside and treated violently by others, and even so he did not lose heart. Yet we, if we have continued for ten days praying for something and have not received it, are afterwards too lazy to pray with the same eagerness. We wait on other people for so long a time, fighting and enduring hardships and performing slavish duties, and often in the end failing to get what we expected. But when it comes to our Master, from whom we are certain to receive a reward greater than our labors (for as the Apostle says, Hope does not put us to shame, Romans 5:5), we cannot endure to wait on Him with proper diligence. What punishment does this deserve! Even if we could receive nothing from Him, should we not consider the very act of conversing with Him continually to be the source of countless blessings? But continual prayer is hard work. And what aspect of virtue is not hard work? Indeed, someone says, this very point is very troubling—that pleasure is attached to vice, and labor to virtue. And many people, I think, raise this question. So what can be the reason? God gave us at the beginning a life free from worry and exempt from labor. We did not use the gift rightly, but were corrupted by doing nothing, and were driven out of Paradise. For this reason He made our life from then on one of toil, explaining His reasons for this to mankind, and saying as it were: I allowed you at the beginning to lead a life of enjoyment, but you were made worse by freedom, so I decreed that from now on labor and sweat would be laid upon you. And when even this labor did not restrain us, He then gave us a law containing many commandments, imposing it on us like bits and bridles placed on an unruly horse to restrain his wild movements, just as horse trainers do. This is why life is hard—because not laboring tends to be our ruin. For our nature cannot bear to be doing nothing, but easily turns aside to wickedness. Let us suppose that the temperate man, and the one who rightly performs the other virtues, has no need of labor, but does everything in his sleep—still, how would we have used our leisure? Would it not have been for pride and boasting? But why, someone says, has great pleasure been attached to vice, and great labor and toil to virtue? Well, what credit would you have, and for what would you receive a reward, if the matter were not difficult? Even now I can show you many who by nature hate relations with women, and avoid conversation with them as impure. Shall we then call these people chaste? Shall we crown these people, tell me, and proclaim them victors? By no means. Chastity is self-restraint and the mastering of pleasures that fight against us, just as in war the trophies are most honorable when the contest is violent, not when no one raises a hand against us. Many are by their very nature without passion—shall we call these people good-tempered? Not at all. And so the Lord after naming three types of eunuchs, leaves two of them without crowns, and admits only one into the kingdom of heaven (Matthew 19:12). But what need was there, someone says, for wickedness? I ask this too. What then made wickedness to exist? Nothing but our willful negligence. But, someone says, there ought to be only good people. Well, what is proper to the good person? Is it to watch and be alert, or to sleep and snore? And why, someone says, did it not seem good that a person should act rightly without laboring? You speak words that suit cattle or gluttons, or those who make their belly their god. To prove that these are foolish words, answer me this: Suppose there were a king and a general, and while the king was asleep or drunk, the general endured hardship and set up a trophy—whose would you consider the victory to be? Who would enjoy the pleasure of what was done? Do you see that the soul is especially attached to those things for which she has labored? And therefore God has joined labors to virtue, wishing to make us attached to her. For this reason we admire virtue, even if we do not act rightly ourselves, while we condemn vice even though it is very pleasant. And if you say, Why do we not admire those who are good by nature more than those who are so by choice? we reply, Because it is right to prefer the one who labors to the one who does not labor. For why do we labor? It is because you could not endure moderation when you did not have to labor. Moreover, if one examines carefully, laziness in other ways also tends to ruin us and cause us much trouble. If you wish, let us shut a man up, only feeding and indulging him, not allowing him to walk or taking him out to work, but let him enjoy table and bed and be in luxury continually—what could be more miserable than such a life? But, someone says, to work is one thing, to labor is another. Yes, but it was in man's power then to work without labor. And is this, he says, possible? Yes, it is possible; God even desired it, but you could not endure it. Therefore He placed you to work in the garden, assigning employment, but joining with it no labor. For if man had labored at the beginning, God would not afterwards have imposed labor as punishment. For it is possible to work and not be weary, as the angels do. To prove that they work, hear what David says: You who excel in strength, you who do His word (Psalm 103:20, Septuagint). Lack of strength causes much labor now, but then it was not so. For the one who has entered into His rest has ceased, as someone says, from his works, as God from His (Hebrews 4:10)—not meaning idleness here, but the ceasing from labor. For God works even now, as Christ says, My Father works until now, and I work (John 5:17). Therefore I urge you that, setting aside all carelessness, you be eager for virtue. For the pleasure of wickedness is short, but the pain is lasting; of virtue, on the contrary, the joy does not grow old, the labor is only for a season. Virtue even before the crowns are distributed encourages her worker and feeds him with hopes; vice even before the time of punishment torments the one who works for her, wringing and terrifying his conscience, and making it prone to imagine all evils. Are not these things worse than any labors, than any toils? And even if these things were not so, if there were pleasure, what could be more worthless than that pleasure? For as soon as it appears it flies away, withering and escaping before it has been grasped, whether you speak of the pleasure of beauty, or of luxury, or of wealth, for they do not cease to decay daily. But when there is besides punishment and vengeance for this pleasure, what can be more miserable than those who pursue it? Knowing this, then, let us endure all things for virtue, so we shall enjoy true pleasure, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father and the Holy Spirit be glory, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.

2. Let us be ashamed then, beloved, let us be ashamed, and groan over our excessive sloth. Thirty and eight years had that man been waiting without obtaining what he desired, and withdrew not. And he had failed not through any carelessness of his own, but through being oppressed and suffering violence from others, and not even thus did he grow dull; while we if we have persisted for ten days to pray for anything and have not obtained it, are too slothful afterwards to employ the same zeal. And on men we wait for so long a time, warring and enduring hardships and performing servile ministrations, and often at last failing in our expectation, but on our Master, from whom we are sure to obtain a recompense greater than our labors, (for, says the Apostle, Hope makes not ashamed Romans 5:5) on Him we endure not to wait with becoming diligence. What chastisement does this deserve! For even though we could receive nothing from Him, ought we not to deem the very conversing with Him continually the cause of ten thousand blessings? But continual prayer is a laborious thing. And what that belongs to virtue is not laborious? In truth, says some one, this very point is full of great difficulty, that pleasure is annexed to vice, and labor to virtue. And many, I think, make this a question. What then can be the reason? God gave us at the beginning a life free from care and exempt from labor. We used not the gift aright, but were perverted by doing nothing, and were banished from Paradise. On which account He made our life for the future one of toil, assigning as it were His reasons for this to mankind, and saying, I allowed you at the beginning to lead a life of enjoyment, but you were rendered worse by liberty, wherefore I commanded that henceforth labor and sweat be laid upon you. And when even this labor did not restrain us, He next gave us a law containing many commandments, imposing it on us like bits and curbs placed upon an unruly horse to restrain his prancings, just as horse breakers do. This is why life is laborious, because not to labor is wont to be our ruin. For our nature cannot bear to be doing nothing, but easily turns aside to wickedness. Let us suppose that the man who is temperate, and he who rightly performs the other virtues, has no need of labor, but that they do all things in their sleep, still how should we have employed our ease? Would it not have been for pride and boastfulness? But wherefore, says some one, has great pleasure been attached to vice, great labor and toil to virtue? Why, what thanks would you have had, and for what would you have received a reward, if the matter had not been one of difficulty? Even now I can show you many who naturally hate intercourse with women, and avoid conversation with them as impure; shall we then call these chaste, shall we crown these, tell me, and proclaim them victors? By no means. Chastity is self-restraint, and the mastering pleasures which fight, just as in war the trophies are most honorable when the contest is violent, not when no one raises a hand against us. Many are by their very nature passionless; shall we call these good tempered? Not at all. And so the Lord after naming three manners of the eunuch state, leaves two of them uncrowned, and admits one into the kingdom of heaven. Matthew 19:12 But what need, says one, was there of wickedness? I say this too. What is it then which made wickedness to be? What but our willful negligence? But, says one, there ought to be only good men. Well, what is proper to the good man? Is it to watch and be sober, or to sleep and snore? And why, says one, seemed class="greek">thoughtest thou. " }}–> it not good that a man should act rightly without laboring? You speak words which become the cattle or gluttons, or who make their belly their god. For to prove that these are the words of folly, answer me this. Suppose there were a king and a general, and while the king was asleep or drunk, the general should endure hardship and erect a trophy, whose would you count the victory to be? Who would enjoy the pleasure of what was done? Do you see that the soul is more especially disposed towards those things for which she has labored? And therefore God has joined labors to virtue, wishing to make us attached to her. For this cause we admire virtue, even although we act not rightly ourselves, while we condemn vice even though it be very pleasant. And if you say, Why do we not admire those who are good by nature more than those who are so by choice? we reply, Because it is just to prefer him that labors to him that labors not. For why is it that we labor? It is because thou did not bear with moderation the not laboring. Nay more, if one enquire exactly, in other ways also sloth is wont to undo us, and to cause us much trouble. Let us, if you will, shut a man up, only feeding and pampering him, not allowing him to walk nor conducting him forth to work, but let him enjoy table and bed, and be in luxury continually; what could be more wretched than such a life? But, says one, to work is one thing, to labor is another. Yea, but it was in man's power then to work without labor. And is this, says he, possible? Yea, it is possible; God even desired it, but you endured it not. Therefore He placed you to work in the garden, marking out employment, but joining with it no labor. For had man labored at the beginning, God would not afterwards have put labor by way of punishment. For it is possible to work and not to be wearied, as do the angels. To prove that they work, hear what David says; You that excel in strength, you that do His word. Psalm 103:20, Septuagint Want of strength causes much labor now, but then it was not so. For he that has entered into His rest, has ceased, says one, from his works, as God from His Hebrews 4:10: not meaning here idleness, but the ceasing from labor. For God works even now, as Christ says, My Father works hitherto, and I work. John 5:17 Wherefore I exhort you that, laying aside all carelessness, you be zealous for virtue. For the pleasure of wickedness is short, but the pain lasting; of virtue, on the contrary, the joy grows not old, the labor is but for a season. Virtue even before the crowns are distributed animates her workman, and feeds him with hopes; vice even before the time of vengeance punishes him who works for her, wringing and terrifying his conscience, and making it apt to imagine all ( evils). Are not these things worse than any labors, than any toils? And if these things were not so, if there were pleasure, what could be more worthless than that pleasure? For as soon as it appears it flies away, withering and escaping before it has been grasped, whether you speak of the pleasure of beauty, or that of luxury, or that of wealth, for they cease not daily to decay. But when there is besides (for this pleasure) punishment and vengeance, what can be more miserable than those who go after it? Knowing then this, let us endure all for virtue, so shall we enjoy true pleasure, through the grace and lovingkindness of our Lord Jesus Christ, with whom to the Father and the Holy Ghost be glory, now and ever, and world without end. Amen.